Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Objective: To investigate the functional and sexual outcome of sigmoid vaginoplasty in patients with Mayer-Rokitansky-Kuster-Hauser (MRKH) syndrome.
Design: Prospective study.
Setting: University hospital.
Patient(s): Fifty-nine consecutive patients with MRKH syndrome.
Intervention(s): Forty-eight patients underwent sigmoid vaginoplasty, and 11 were treated using the Frank method of dilatation.
Main Outcome Measure(s): Functional results and sexuality were evaluated with the use of two standardized questionnaires: the Female Sexual
Function Index (FSFI) and the revised Female Sexual Distress Scale (FSDS-R). Questions were added to analyze depression, body image perception,
and desire of motherhood.
Result(s): Out of the 68% of patients who answered the questionnaire, 73% had regular sexual intercourse. The mean total FSFI score was
28 3.1 in the operated group and 30 5.3 in the group treated with the Frank method. Their mean FSDS-R scores were 21 12.1 and 18 13.8, respectively.
Conclusion(s): Sigmoid vaginoplasty is an effective technique providing a nearly normal sexual function to patients with vaginal aplasia. Despite this,
psychologic distress related to sexuality persists in most patients, demonstrating the need for a multidisciplinary support. (Fertil SterilÒ 2012;97:691–6.
Ó2012 by American Society for Reproductive Medicine.)
Key Words: Sigmoid vaginoplasty, MRKH, Rokitansky syndrome, sexuality, vaginal agenesis
T
he Mayer-Rokitansky-Kuster- associated with skeletal or urinary tract Several techniques of vaginal recon-
Hauser syndrome (MRKH) repre- anomalies (type II) in 10% and 40% of struction, surgical and nonsurgical, have
sents the primary cause of cases, respectively (1–3). been described: The Frank procedure (6),
vaginal aplasia, with an incidence of 1 Infertility and the lack of normal the McIndoe operation (7), the Vecchietti
in 4,500 female births (1). sexuality are the factors that seem to technique (8), and Bloch-Davydov vagi-
Mullerian duct agenesis results in have the greatest impact on the quality noplasty (9) are currently the most popu-
the congenital absence of uterus and of life. The confirmation of the diag- lar. According to the recommendations
vagina associated with a normal karyo- nosis has a profound psychologic im- of the American College of Obstetrics
type (46,XX) and functional ovaries. pact on body image and self-esteem, and Gynecology (10), the nonsurgical
The etiology of the MRKH syndrome and as a result one-third of patients Frank method must be favored wherever
remains unclear, and the diagnosis is suffer from depression (4). Gestational possible. However, owing to the lack of
usually established during adolescence, surrogacy is a possible option for prospective randomized trials, no con-
the first clinical sign being primary women diagnosed with MRKH syn- sensus has yet been established on the
amenorrhea associated with otherwise drome, the risk of recurrence of the best surgical treatment.
normal puberty development. The syn- MRKH syndrome in the offspring be- The technique presented in the
drome can be isolated (type I), and it is ing estimated at 1%–2% (5). present article is based on the use of
bowel graft to create a neovagina and
was first described by Baldwin in 1904
Received August 12, 2011; revised November 25, 2011; accepted December 12, 2011; published online (11). Historically, this method was not
January 14, 2012.
C.C. has nothing to disclose. M.C.-M. has nothing to disclose. A.L. has nothing to disclose. D.R. has used as a first-line treatment, owing to
nothing to disclose. its associated morbidity. However, the
Reprint requests: Daniel Raudrant, M.D., Service de Gynecologie Obste
trique, Centre Hospitalier Lyon
Sud, Chemin du Grand Revoyet, 69495 Pierre Be nite, France (E-mail: daniel.raudrant@chu-lyon.fr). progress in antibiotic prophylaxis and
in colorectal anastomosis has recently
Fertility and Sterility® Vol. 97, No. 3, March 2012 0015-0282/$36.00 permitted the use of sigmoid graft as
Copyright ©2012 American Society for Reproductive Medicine, Published by Elsevier Inc.
doi:10.1016/j.fertnstert.2011.12.015 first-line surgical therapy.
The aim of the present study was to evaluate the func- Patients were encouraged to become sexually active. In the
tional outcome and the influence on sexuality provided by absence of sexual intercourse, they were instructed to practice
this technique. Therefore, two standardized questionnaires dilatation with Hegar dilators (no. 26 or 27) every 2–3 days.
were used: the Female Sexual Function Index (FSFI) (12) A postoperative clinical follow-up was proposed at 6
and the revised Female Sexual Distress Scale (FSDS-R) (13, months after surgery and then yearly.
14). Questions were added to assess body image perception, Functional results were assessed with the use of a question-
desire of motherhood, and signs of depression. We also naire designed in collaboration with a sexologist consultant
reported the anatomic results and complications of patients (M.C.-M.). The questionnaire mailed to each patient consisted
who underwent sigmoid colpoplasty. of 44 questions. It included Rosen’s FSFI (12): 19 items analyz-
ing six separate domains of the functional aspect of female
sexuality: desire, arousability, orgasm, lubrication, comfort,
MATERIALS AND METHODS and quality of sexual life. The total FSFI score was obtained
Patients by adding up the six domain scores and could be 36 at most.
Between August 1992 and July 2010, 59 patients with MRKH Patients having a total score of %26.55 were defined as having
syndrome were referred to the H^otel Dieu and Lyon Sud Uni- sexual dysfunction (16). The subsequent 13 questions were
versity Hospitals. Eleven were treated by the Frank method, those of the FSDS-R (13, 14) assessing psychologic distress in
and 48 underwent sigmoid vaginoplasty, all of which were women with hypoactive sexual desire disorder. A score of
performed by the same surgeon (D.R.). Only patients who >11 out of 52 suggested sexual distress.
had been operated >6 months before the time of study were We included 12 additional questions concerning details
included. In two cases, the sigmoid colpoplasty was not the of sexual intercourse, vaginal discharge, pelvic pain, self-
first procedure used to create a neovagina: One woman had esteem, depression, and gestational surrogacy.
already undergone an unsuccessful split-thickness skin graft,
and another had already been operated on twice (McIndoe
Statistical Analysis
procedure followed by a Vecchietti operation).
The mean age at the time of surgery was 19 years; 22% of Statistical analysis was performed using SAS software (SAS In-
the patients had renal malformations; 9 patients showed skel- stitute). Mann-Whitney test was used to compare questionnaire
etal abnormalities; 69% of patients had an isolated MRKH scores between the two groups. Parameters from the additional
syndrome. questions were analyzed using c2 test and Fisher exact test.
RESULTS
Surgical Procedure
Complications
Fifty-nine patients, who had previously been proposed the di-
A major complication was encountered in two patients, who
latation method, were referred to our center for surgical treat-
developed pelvic hematomas due to bleeding in the perineal
ment. The nonsurgical Frank method was once again
cleavage, requiring surgical reexploration and hemostasis.
systematically suggested. All patients were informed of the sur-
Rectal injury occurred in two patients. The wounds were
gical and nonsurgical alternatives of neocolpopoeisis and of
immediately detected and sutured without any further
the potential benefits and risks of each technique. In 11 pa-
complication.
tients, Hegar dilatations were chosen; 48 of the 59 patients un-
One patient developed a left tubal abscess 2 years after
derwent sigmoid colpoplasty. All of these patients opted for
surgery. It was drained by laparoscopy and the left tube was
surgery to engage in sexual activity as soon as possible.
removed, allowing a rapid recovery.
The surgical procedure applied was described by Commu-
In two patients, prolapse of the neovagina occurred. In
nal et al. in an earlier report (15). A standard abdominal Pfan-
each case, the promontory stitch was still in the correct posi-
nenstiel incision was used in 47 cases, and a laparoscopic
tion and the prolapse was due to an oversized graft. This was
approach was used in one case.
managed by the vaginal resection of the prolapsed tissue.
At the stage of the perineal dissection, a U-shaped inci-
sion was made in the vaginal dimple to protect the urethra
and to provide a flap large enough to allow for a colovestibu- Anatomic Results
lar anastomosis. Anatomic results were satisfactory in 83% of patients. Eight
To prevent a prolapse of the sigmoid transplant, the neo- (17%) had a stenosis of the colovestibular anastomosis, of
vagina was fixed to the sacral promontory with two polyester which five required dilatation under general anesthesia.
stitches.
The mean operating time was 183 36 minutes.
Functional Results
The mean age of patients at the time of investigation was 24
Assessment of Anatomic and Functional Results years, and the mean time after surgery was 6 years (range 10
Anatomic results were assessed by a first clinical examination months–17.8 years).
under general anaesthesia 1 month after surgery. Wound Forty patients (68%) answered the questionnaire: 35 (73%)
healing and vaginal patency were evaluated using Hegar of the 48 who had received surgery and 5 (45%) of the 11 who
dilators (nos. 28–32). had been treated by the Frank method. Six (10%) were lost to
18.40 15.4
21.35 12.2
not answer. One of them replied that the subject was too
FSDS-R
.72
intimate to be discussed in a mailed questionnaire.
Table 1 shows FSFI and FSDS-R scores. Table 2 presents
answers to the additional questions concerning intercourse
30.25 6.2
frequency, vaginal discharge, pelvic pain, self-esteem,
28.00 3.1
Total score
5.40 1.2
5.35 0.6
The mean FSDS-R score was 21. Only 15% had a score
<11, indicating the absence of anxiety related to sexuality.
.57
.61
5.10 1.0
4.74 0.7
discharge discomfort.
Frank method group. In the group treated by the Frank pro-
cedure, one patient had never had sexual intercourse; 75% of
the remaining patients had regular sexual activity. The mean
4.65 1.3
4.36 0.9
Desire
time before the first sexual relation after the first dilatation
.64
Note: FSDS-R ¼ revised Female Sexual Distress Scale; FSFI ¼ Female Sexual Function Index.
The mean total FSFI score was 30, and each domain score
40 (68%)
5 (45%)
35 (73%)
Psychological Results
Within the two groups, 28% of the patients showed signs of
Frank method
TABLE 1
TABLE 2
Answers to additional questions concerning intercourse frequency, vaginal discharge, pelvic pain, self-esteem, depression, and surrogacy.
Question Sigmoid vaginoplasty Frank method All patients P value
Mean time before first intercourse after 7 5 .54
treatment (mo)
Vaginal intercourse frequency
Occasionally 8 (27%) 1 (25%)
1–2/wk 12 (40%) 0
2–3/wk 7 (23%) 2 (50%)
Daily 3 (10%) 1 (25%)
Vaginal discharge discomfort 23 (68%) 0 .01
Abdominal pain 22 (65%) 1 (20%) .69
Dyspareunia 24 (80%) 2 (50%) .22
Thinking of adoption 27 (79%) 3 (60%) 30 (77%) 1.00
Thinking of surrogacy 27 (79%) 5 (100%) 32 (82%) .57
Depression signs
Feel depressed or desperate? 10 (29%) 1 (20%) 11 (28%) 1.00
Decreased interest or pleasure in
everyday life?
Femininity feeling 24 (70%) 3 (60%) .59
Changes in body image since treatment 15 (44%) 3 (60%) .65
Body image perception
Positive 17 (50%) 2 (40%)
Neither positive nor negative 13 (38%) 3 (60%)
Negative 4 (12%) 0
Carrard. Sexuality after sigmoid vaginoplasty. Fertil Steril 2012.
feminine’’ versus 60% of the patients treated by the Frank (4% of patients in our series), which is also described in other
method (P¼ .59). Approximately one-half of the women esti- techniques (5, 17), is now rare because a promontory fixation
mated that their treatment had ‘‘almost or entirely’’ changed is systematically performed.
their body image (44% of the operated, 60% of the nonoper- Even if vaginal discharge is sometimes perceived as un-
ated; P¼ .65) and that they perceived this change as ‘‘positive’’ comfortable, sigmoid colploplasty is the only technique pro-
(50% of the operated, 40% of the nonoperated). viding natural lubrication of the neovagina (2).
Regarding motherhood, 77% wished to or had already ap- Another advantage of this procedure is the possibility of
plied for adoption; 82% (32/39) would consider surrogacy. It coitus shortly after surgery. Whereas techniques of passive di-
needs to be added that among the 11 patients presenting signs latation require an average delay of 11.8 1.6 months (18)
of depression, four had good FSFI and/or FSDS-R scores, before the first sexual intercourse, sigmoid vaginoplasty al-
which suggests a psychologic distress linked to a cause inde- lows sexual activity after 1 month. It can also be supposed
pendent of their sexuality. One patient emphasized that her that surgery is often chosen because it is psychologically
depression had ‘‘nothing to do with her sexuality,’’ and six complicated for these young patients to go through repeated
others specified that it was due to the unfulfilled desire for self-dilatations sometimes experienced as embarrassing or
motherhood. shameful (19).
Furthermore, as the laparoscopic approach increasingly
replaces laparotomy, postoperative inconveniences should
DISCUSSION gradually become negligible, provided the surgeons have ex-
In the past 20 years, numerous studies have evaluated the an- tensive experience in both gynecologic and digestive laparo-
atomic results of the various techniques of creating a neova- scopic surgery (20–22).
gina in patients with MRKH syndrome. However, the In the first 16 patients of this study, analyzed by Commu-
functional outcome was usually simply assessed according nal et al. (15), functional results of sigmoid colpopoeisis were
to the presence or absence of sexual relations, and few studies good and similar to those of ‘‘normal’’ women, with the ex-
provided a more thorough and profound analysis. ception of the comfort criterion. The present report, based
The aim of creating a neovagina is to enable satisfactory on a larger series, confirms these findings with slight differ-
sexual activity and thus to achieve a physical and psychologic ences: The mean total FSFI score was 28 3.1 among oper-
equilibrium. In this study we used two standardized question- ated patients, i.e., slightly lower than in the previous
naires (FSFI and FSDS-R) to describe the sexual results of pa- investigation. The mean FSDS-R was 21 12.1 indicating
tients with MRKH syndrome who had a sigmoid neovagina. psychologic distress related to sexuality.
We included additional questions to evaluate psychological Several factors may explain these results. First, one may
distress, infertility and body image problems. question the relevance of comparing patients with the normal
Anatomic results of sigmoid colpoplasty are good. population. Rather, pre- and postoperative results should be
Shrinkage of the graft remains the primary complication evaluated, which would provide a more precise indication
(17%). It is, however, easy to repair. A prolapse of the neovagina of the effect of the surgery.
24. Labus LD, Djordjevic ML, Stanojevic DS, Bizic MR, Stojanovic BZ, Cavic TM. 27. Giannesi A, Marchiole P, Benchaib M, Chevret-Measson M, Mathevet P,
Rectosigmoid vaginoplasty in patients with vaginal agenesis: sexual and psy- Dargent D. Sexuality after laparoscopic Davydov in patients affected by con-
chosocial outcomes. Sex Health 2011;8:427–30. genital complete vaginal agenesis associated with uterine agenesis or hypo-
25. Laggari V, Diareme S, Christogiorgos S, Deligeoroglou E, Christopoulos P, plasia. Hum Reprod 2005;20:2954–7.
Tsiantis J, et al. Anxiety and depression in adolescents with polycystic ovary 28. Fedele L, Bianchi S, Frontino G, Fontana E, Restelli E, Bruni V. The laparoscopic
syndrome and Mayer-Rokitansky-Ku €ster-Hauser syndrome. J Psychosom Vecchietti’s modified technique in Rokitansky syndrome: anatomic, functional,
Obstet Gynaecol 2009;30:83–8. and sexual long-term results. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2008;198:377.e1–6.
26. Heller-Boersma JG, Schmidt UH, Edmonds DK. Psychological distress in 29. Fotopoulou C, Sehouli J, Gehrmann N, Schoenborn I, Lichtenegger W. Func-
women with uterovaginal agenesis (Mayer-Rokitansky-Kuster-Hauser Syn- tional and anatomic results of amnion vaginoplasty in young women with
drome, MRKH). Psychosomatics 2009;50:277–81. Mayer-Rokitansky-Ku €ster-Hauser syndrome. Fertil Steril 2010;94:317–23.