Professional Documents
Culture Documents
An Occupation-Based Community Program at the Youth Resource Center in Salt Lake City
University of Utah
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 2
The purpose of this needs analysis and literature review is to determine how skilled
occupational therapy (OT) services can be applied to improve outcomes for the underserved
population at the Youth Resource Center (YRC). The YRC is an emergency shelter for
vulnerable youth ages 15-22. This needs assessment included data provided by the Sorensen
Legacy Foundation in their 2018 Impact Report (Sparrow, 2018) which discusses outcomes of
the YRC, through staff interviews, and semi-structured and informal interviews with the clients
as well as informal observation at the site. The evidence provided in this report illustrates the
Description of Setting
Community Information
The YRC is located on the outskirts of downtown Salt Lake City (SLC), Utah. SLC is
Utah’s capital city, and the most heavily populated city in the state. According to the United
States Census Bureau (U.S. Census Bureau, 2017) SLC had a population of approximately
200,544 as of July 1, 2017 with youth under the age of 18 making up 21.2% of the population
(U.S. Census Bureau, 2017). The population of the city is predominately Caucasian with 72%
percent of people noted to be white, followed by 21.6% of Hispanic or Latino decent (U.S.
activities including snow skiing, its wide variety of restaurants, and its rich cultural and
educational opportunities and museums. SLC is home to Temple Square which is famous for
beautiful gardens in the summer and Christmas light displays in the winter. Temple Square is
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 3
owned by the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS) and provides a hub for LDS
church members world-wide. Salt Lake County’s predominant religion is the LDS church with
approximately 51.2% of people in the county claiming membership (Canhan, 2014). The LDS
church and its history are central to the culture of the area with many people in the city claiming
ancestry to the Mormon Pioneers that settled the area in 1847 (Tullis, 2014).
The YRC is under the umbrella of Volunteers of America (VOA, Utah.) The VOA
mission statement is “We have always been and will always be here to help. Our mission is to
reach and uplift all people, touching their body, mind, and ultimately their soul” (VOA, Utah).
The YRC does not have their own official mission statement, however, Carlos Garcia, their
Program Manager stated in an interview that his personal mission for the facility is to “provide
consistency and structure using peer modeling in order to help the youth get on their feet in three
to six months” (C. Garcia, personal communication, September 17, 2018). The YRC is intended
to be an emergency shelter, however many end up staying at the facility for years. Carlos is
working to improve turn-around times to help clients obtain permanent housing as soon as
possible. Clients at the YRC are given opportunities to receive vouchers for rapid rehousing, but
in order to qualify, they must meet certain criteria. Overall, the culture of the agency is a desire
to help the clients gain the skills and resources they need in order to become independent.
Services Provided
setting. They have a total of 30 beds for clients to stay the night, they provide three meals a day,
and clients especially interested in receiving housing vouchers are able to enroll in a self-reliance
program (SRP). The YRC offers free legal advice from a lawyer who is paid through a grant and
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 4
employs three licensed clinical social workers to directly work with the clients. Additionally, the
YRC has a relationship with many community organizations such as the Cornerstone Counseling
Center, The 4th Street Clinic, the University of Utah School of Dentistry, and Odyssey House.
For services they are unable to provide in-house, the YRC can put their clients in touch with
someone from a relevant organization. Clients who are on an SRP are required to attend daily
group activities. Group sessions may include topics such as learning coping skills, safe sex
practices, communication skills, vocational rehab, lesbian gay bisexual transgender queer
intersex asexual (LGBTQIA) discussion groups, job readiness, resume writing, and creative
writing to just name some of the possibilities. Additionally, the YRC provides showers and a
place to do laundry as well as clothing items as needed. They can also arrange transportation for
the youth to go to job interviews or other important appointments (C. Garcia, personal
Staff Disciplines
Most of the staff members in leadership roles are clinical social workers. This includes
both the Director of Youth Services and the Program Manager. Additionally, the YRC employs
three social workers in clinical roles to work directly with the youth. One works full time, and
the other two are part time. Youth Advocates who work on the floor typically have a bachelor’s
degree in a field of their choice, but this is not required. If a person appears to be a good fit for
the position and population, a degree is not necessary. A position as a youth advocate provides
valuable experience for people pursuing a degree in a social work or related areas. Much of the
work accomplished at the YRC is done through background-checked volunteers. For example,
all meals are donated, prepared, and served by volunteers. Volunteers also run many of the
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 5
group activities as well as collect and sort donations. Volunteers come from a wide variety of
professional backgrounds.
Funding Sources
According to the Director of Youth Services, Cydnie LaCour, approximately 80% of donations
are from private funds (C. LaCour, personal communication, September 10, 2018). LaCour
notes that the rest of the funding for the YRC is from a variety of donors including the United
States Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), state and federal funding
sources, an Emergency Services Grant, and Intermountain Healthcare (IHC) provides funding to
pay for a full-time social worker as part of the 20% of funding that is not from private donors.
The VOA was founded in 1896 by Maud and Ballington Booth with the Utah extension
being opened in 1907 (VOA, Utah). Initial services included a hotel for the needy and
medication distribution (VOA, Utah). By the 1920’s, the VOA was also providing an
employment agency, thrift store, and an emergency shelter (VOA, Utah). Unfortunately, due to
the Great Depression, the Utah branch was forced to close in 1929 (VOA, Utah). The Utah
branch of VOA was re-opened in 1986 with a detox center (VOA, Utah). VOA services in Utah
have since expanded to include homeless shelters, substance abuse cessation programs, mental
health services, and services to protect against domestic violence (VOA, Utah).
The YRC was originally taken over by VOA in 1999. The YRC was previously located
on State Street in downtown SLC but moved to the current location two years ago (A. Dover,
personal communication, September 27, 2018). The previous location was only open from 9:00
AM to 5:00 PM and was not an emergency shelter. By moving to a larger location, the YRC was
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 6
able to add 30 beds for overnight shelter. Due to the new center, the YRC has also been able to
spend the last two years expanding the services provided (D. Rodriguez, personal
Economic. Since the YRC is mostly funded by private donations, they do not experience
as many policy issues as organizations that are government-funded may, however they do have
to work within a limited budget and rely on grant money to fund some of their positions. Right
now, grant money pays a lawyer for 10 hours of services a week, and a grant from IHC pays for
their full-time social worker who is instrumental in running the SRP’s for those looking to obtain
housing vouchers. Without grant money, those two valuable services may not be fundable.
Political, Social, and Demographic Factors. One significant concern that was expressed
by multiple staff members was about the foster care system. According to LaCour, up to 70% of
the clients in the shelter at any given time have been touched by the foster care system (C.
LaCour, personal communication, September 10, 2018). Per Garcia, many of the youth at the
YRC have either aged out of foster care, ran away from an abusive foster family, or were kicked
out of the home by their foster family (C. Garcia, personal communication, September 17, 2018).
Garcia feels that the foster care system is failing teens by not providing them with quality
placements where they will be safe. Additionally, there are not many good programs to help
youth transition from the foster care system into mainstream society. Here in Utah, the YRC is
one of the few places those who age out of the system can go for help.
When asked about internal policy issues, Carlos Garcia was mostly frustrated with their
current policies for suspensions. Certain infractions such as substance use, fighting, or
inappropriate physical contact with a staff member may result in a suspension. This is
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 7
concerning to Garcia because the clients that are most likely to be suspended are often the clients
that need services the most (C. Garcia, personal communication, September 17, 2018).
Frequently, those that are suspended rely on the YRC to provide them safe housing and meals.
Clients with mental health diagnoses or a history of substance abuse receive suspensions due to
behaviors that may be attributed to their condition and are often the most vulnerable because
they may not have support outside of the YRC. Essentially being suspended for a long period of
time is going to cause them to lose progress that they have made (C. Garcia, personal
significant LDS population. Approximately 18% of the population at the YRC (Sparrow, 2018)
identify as LGBTQ. Some LDS parents are unwilling to accept that their child identifies as
homosexual. For this reason, some of the clients at the YRC are there because they were kicked
out of their homes due to their sexual identity (C. Garcia, personal communication, September
17, 2018).
The target population for the YRC are youth aged 15-22 that are homeless or in danger of
becoming homeless by HUD standards (Sparrow, 2018). The following data is from the intake
For the 2017-2018 Fiscal Year (FY) the YRC served 715 individuals
According to Andrea Dover, the most often seen medical diagnosis for clients at the YRC
include schizophrenia, trauma, suicidal ideation, substance use, and depression (A. Dover,
According to Garcia, he would like to see the program incorporate more physical activity
for the youth, and more educational opportunities to learn life skills (C. Garcia, personal
communication, September 17, 2018). Garcia would especially like to see a boxing group to
help mitigate some anger for the clients by having them particpate in a sport that allows them to
take out their frustrations in a gym rather than on other people. He is working to expand the
number of groups offered, and to widen the variety of topics. According to Andrea Dover the
clients need to learn more life skills, and she would like to find a way to incorporate this into
future program development (A. Dover, personal communication, September 24, 2018.) Overall,
the staff would like to find more effective ways to engage the clients in the activities and
programs provided in order to help the clients gain the skills and self-sufficiency needed to live
independently as well as put them in touch with the resources they may need to become as
Staff Perspective
Interviews were completed in order to learn the strengths and weaknesses of the programs
offered at the YRC from the perspective of the staff members that work directly with the youth.
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 9
Members of the YRC team were very welcoming and eager to share their perspectives and gave
great in-depth information regarding the programs offered and how they would like to see the
Cydnie LaCour is the Director of Youth Services at the YRC, and she feels that the self-
reliance program is a strong point in the services provided. This program serves a total of 15
clients at a time who are guaranteed a bed at night as long as they are complying with the
requirements of the SRP. As part of the SRP, clients work one-on-one with a youth advocate to
set and work on self-sufficiency goals and meet with a social worker weekly. Those who fully
participate in this program and take advantage of what it offers frequently obtain jobs and rapid
rehousing vouchers. LaCour also sees the relationship the YRC has with other organizations as a
positive. Through these relationships, the YRC can get their clients in touch with resources for
medical help, dental services, mental health facilities and substance abuse programs.
work with, and they have high turnover at the facility, especially in the youth advocate positions.
Having consistent staff members is important because it gives the employees valuable
opportunities to build relationships with the clients. Additionally, the YRC is meant to be an
emergency shelter for short stays, however some of the clients have been there for over two
years. Finding a way to get clients to a point of self-reliance is a concern, especially when they
Carlos Garcia is the current Program Manager, and previously worked as a Youth
Advocate. He feels that the shelter is moving in the right direction regarding the services
provided but is concerned that clients are spending too much time there. Ideally, he would like
clients staying at the YRC for three to six months at the most. He also is concerned that the
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 10
clients there typically get very little exercise. He would like to see physical fitness incorporated
in the groups offered. He sees the benefit that exercise could have on mood and anger
management but has not yet been able to bring in group leaders to help with this. Right now,
groups run from 3:00-5:00 every day, and unless a client is on an SRP, they are not required to
attend. He would like to see more participation in groups. Additionally, right now, there are
only a total of 2-4 different groups offered during this time slot. He would like to have a greater
Andrea Dover is currently working as the night time social worker at the YRC. Prior to
receiving her Master of Clinical Social Work degree, she worked as a Youth Advocate. She has
been at the YRC since it opened at the new location two years ago and personally knows many
of the clients there. She notes that at the YRC, they can do low-level case management, but
overall, it’s not enough for many of the client’s there. For example, they cannot distribute
medications, but some of the clients are unable to effectively manage their medications on their
own. Some of the strengths she notes are that minors are guaranteed a bed in the shelter, and that
their intake process includes assessments to determine the extent of the services needed. In the
past, some of the clients at the shelter were not in need of services and were just there to hang
out with friends. Though this still occurs, it’s not as rampant as before. They use the Casey Life
Skills Assessment to better assess the client’s ability to communicate effectively, take care of
themselves and their environment, and their ability to manage their finances. They also use the
Client Perspective
interview that is used to determine, rate, and quantify performance problems from the client’s
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 11
perspective was administered to total of four clients, three males and one female. They ranged in
age from 21-22. Those who completed the COPM, consistently identified the following
occupational performance problems: Keeping jobs, finding and keeping housing, and having
more meaningful relationships with family and/or close friends. With the help of the YRC, the
youth interviewed who want to gain employment and have gone through with the application and
interview process have been able to obtain jobs but are having a hard time abiding by the rules of
their workplace and finding reliable transportation to get to the site. In one interview, client #1
stated that “my bike was stolen, so now it’s hard to get to work” (Client #1, personal
communication, September 19, 2018) client #2 noted that “I act impulsively and sometimes says
things my boss doesn’t want to hear” (Client #2, personal communication, August 31, 2018).
This led to him being fired from his most recent position. Of the four who completed the
COPM, only one was currently employed. All four stated that they want to qualify for housing,
but only one of them was actively participating in the programs necessary to do so. All four of
the clients who agreed to completing a COPM identified at least one disability. Two have
learning disabilities, one has schizophrenia, and one has hemophilia that has led to multiple
hospitalizations. Client #3 has a young son that he is rarely able to see (Client #3, personal
communication, August 31, 2018), and client #2 was recently released from jail after spending 6
months incarcerated for a parole violation (Client #2, personal communication, August 31,
2018). All four have stinted relationships with their biological families but had some degree of
contact. Reasons for homelessness included being kicked out, family living out of state, family
unable to support them financially, and one client’s mother is also homeless.
Those that completed the COPM were asked about what the YRC does well. All of them
feel like it is much better than living on the streets or living in other shelters. Three of the four
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 12
had nothing but great things to say. They love the staff, feel that their best interests are always
kept in mind, and that the YRC is doing its best to help them find jobs, permanent homes, and
get the medical attention they need. Client #1 complained about the drama of living there. He is
tired of the noise, fighting, and general “nosiness” of the other clients indicating that the sensory
needs of some clients are unmet (Client #1, personal communication, September 19, 2018).
Informal interviews, and observation have been completed on an on-going basis. From
these interviews and observations, the problems with employment and housing continued to be
top concerns for the clients served, however only a handful of those I spoke with are actively
doing anything to improve their current situation. A few of those I spoke with are actively
pursuing college degrees, however they expressed concerns about reliable transportation, and
being able to maintain balance between work, school, and a social life.
Impact Report, and client observations in a variety of situations was utilized to form an educated
opinion regarding the strengths and weaknesses of the current programs available at the YRC.
The staff at the YRC is continually looking at ways to improve their service delivery and are
open to implementing changes that will increase the success of their organization. They are very
Strengths. The YRC does an amazing job of creating a safe space for homeless youth
and taking care of their immediate human needs. They foster a culture of inclusion which is
apparent in the interactions of the clients with each other as well as in the interactions between
staff and clients. According to Garcia, they have had clients from all over the nation that have
heard about their program and traveled to Utah in order to find a safe space (C. Garcia, personal
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 13
communication, September 17, 2018). The YRC has fostered relationships with a variety of
other organizations in order to provide necessary services to their clientele. Though somewhat
limited in the services they can provide on-site, they have a wide network of resources to put
their clients in touch with. For the youth that choose to participate fully in a SRP, they have a
relatively quick turn around from homelessness to being housed. Additionally, those who want
jobs are able to find them with the help of the YRC which helps with resume writing,
applications, clothing for interviews, and provides bus tokens for transportation to interviews.
The lawyer on site is able to provide advice on a variety of legal concerns that are faced by this
population. These include emancipation, as wells as advice regarding legal concerns and
convictions. In some cases, he is able to remind the youth of important court dates and arrange
for transportation. The YRC ensures that basic human needs are met. They are able to provide
shelter, meals, clothing, access to hygiene items, and emotional support from trained adults.
Weaknesses and barriers. Most of the clients at the YRC are not progressing towards
self-sufficiency. They rely on the shelter to provide them with everything they need and become
comfortable with this arrangement, however it is not a permanent solution, and if they are unable
to become self-sufficient, they will eventually find themselves on the streets. When asked what
a typical day looks like, most of the clients noted that they “hang out” or “walk around” most of
the day. Their engagement in meaningful occupations is generally very limited. Many of these
youth have a limited knowledge of basic skills such as personal finance, housekeeping, cooking,
or making and keeping appointments. Some have never learned to use public transportation or
how to drive. Someone has always done these things for them, and they are in a state of stuck.
Additionally, few of them participate in meaningful recreational activities and are not typically
pursing their interests. Lack of participation in meaningful occupations is due in part to many of
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 14
the youth being in survival mode, and just trying to get by, but for longer term clients, it appears
they are in the midst of a cycle where their needs are met, so they are doing little to change their
situation as they are comfortable in the moment. Some clients also were found to take the
services they are receiving for granted. For example, some of the youth throw away clothing
rather than washing it because they know they can get more for free.
Group activities have great potential to be highly beneficial, however often groups that
are educational are not well attended. The clients prefer activities that they see as fun, such as
browsing the internet in the computer lab and often avoid less enticing activities. Clients who
are required to attend group activities as part of a SRP are not obligated to participate. All that is
necessary to meet their requirements is that they show up. Often clients will sit and play on their
phones or sleep. Additionally, there are few groups that consistently teach skills to help client’s
become successful outside of the YRC. Additionally, the volunteers teaching these courses do
not always have the education and resources to help clients with special needs. OTs are in a
unique position to teach life skills while also being able to do in depth activity analysis to
determine what components of an activity are difficult for a client and help them build the skills
This literature review was completed in order to determine the most critical occupation-
based needs of the clients who are accessing the resources at the YRC. The American Journal of
Occupational Therapy (AJOT) and the University of Utah Spencer S. Eccles Health Sciences
Library were utilized to find relevant articles. Search terms used included: Occupational
therapy, mental health, foster care, learned helplessness, life skills, homelessness, youth,
homeless shelter, young adult. AJOT provided a total of six articles written within the last 10
years that met the established criteria, one of which was a pilot study to build evidence towards a
second article that was also utilized. The University of Utah Eccles Health Sciences Library
produced a total of seven articles that were written within the last ten years that lend support to
this literature review. Articles were deemed appropriate if they included one or more of the
search terms in a context that was also applicable to the services provided at the YRC or the
Peer-reviewed articles were utilized to better assess health-related concerns impacting the
occupational performance of a young homeless population. Gronski et al. (2013) proposed that
childhood toxic stress can put young adults at risk for mental and physical health problems
throughout their lifetime. These stressors include childhood traumas such as witnessing or being
a victim of abuse or crime. Many of the youth living at the YRC have experienced toxic stress in
the past and continue to experience it because being homeless is extremely traumatic. Living
with toxic stress is concerning during formative years where the brain is still developing
(Gronski, 2013). The overuse of the body’s stress response system can lead to increased
prevalence of adult diseases including depression, anxiety, mental illness, decreased cognition,
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 16
cardiovascular disease, diabetes, and hypertension to name a few. Exposure to toxic stress also
causes adolescents to become more likely to drink alcohol, use tobacco, use illicit drugs, and
participate in risky behaviors such as gambling as compared to youth that have not been exposed
to toxic stress (Shonkoff et al., 2012). Read, Roush, and Downing (2018) discuss the transition
from adolescence to early adulthood and the need for interventions for youth in this demographic
because they are at high risk for developing serious mental illnesses including psychosis and
suicidal ideation. Read et al. (2013) confirmed the need to address cognition, self-esteem, social-
functioning, and occupational function with this population in order to improve occupational
outcomes which are often poor for this demographic. Toglia and Berg, 2013, added that that
“executive cognitive impairments are a major contributor to the underlying learning, behavioral,
and psychosocial deficits observed in at-risk youth (Toglia and Berg, 2013, p.1).” Medalia,
Saperstein, Huang, Lee, and Ronan (2017), stated that cognitive impairments negatively impact
education and vocational results for homeless youth. Overall, youth who have experienced
significant toxic stress are more likely than peers who have not experienced toxic stress to
develop serious mental illness, have cognitive disabilities, and to abuse substances.
Additionally, they are at risk for dropping out of school, participating in gang activity, being
As previously discussed, toxic stress is a major risk factor for a variety of deficits and
diagnoses that cause barriers to occupational performance for young adults. Some of these
include the development of substance abuse disorders, mental health disorders, and diagnoses
that affect cognition along with a slew of other chronic medical conditions that all have the
potential to affect task performance. Another concern for this population is learned helplessness.
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 17
According to Gomez, Ryan, Norton, Jones, and Galán- Cisneros (2015), the child welfare system
may inhibit the development of self-efficacy. This pertains to children raised in foster care as
well as those relying on homeless services. The youth living in the American Southwest who
were interviewed by Gomez et al. (2015), expressed that they have not learned the life skills
necessary to thrive in the real world. Out of the 134 young adults interviewed, only two felt as
though they were well prepared for adulthood (Gomez et al., 2015). According to Courtney,
Lee, and Perez, (2011), who did research in the Midwestern United States, 28% of former foster
children interviewed felt prepared for adult life. Though this statistic is more promising than that
found by Gomez et al. (2015), it is still concerning as fewer than one-third of those surveyed are
confident in their ability to function successfully as an adult. Often youth in foster care receive
government aid checks or other direct services that they come to rely on and have limited
knowledge of how to take care of themselves once these resources are no longer available
(Gomez et al., 2015). Additionally, youth in foster care become accustomed to foster parents
and other case managers taking care of their needs, so they do not learn how to do for themselves
(Gomez et al., 2015). Paul-Ward and Lambdin-Pattavina, (2016) added that frequently, agencies
supporting young adults do not have a large enough staff to individually assess each client’s
needs, so the staff does everything for the youth rather than helping the youth learn to complete
important tasks for themselves. This contributes to the problem of learned helplessness as the
youth learn to rely on others to problem solve for them. According to one client interviewed by
Gomez et al. (2015), when an individual is in foster care, they depend on other people to do
things for them. Once they are in the real world, people get confused and lost.
The YRC provides many of the same services that youth receive while in foster care, so
an adult, such as social workers and youth advocates continue to take care of their needs for
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 18
them. One of the two youth interviewed by Gomez et al. (2015) who stated that they felt
prepared for adulthood, attributed this to good foster parents who helped them learn the skills
needed to be independent.
Overwhelmingly, those interviewed by both Gomez et al. (2015) and Courtney et al.,
(2011), stated that they needed to learn life skills in order to be successful. These include topics
such as vocational skills, skills to finish high school as well as college preparation information,
social competency, sexuality, financial literacy, health and wellness information, housing
services, learning to drive or use public transportation, and help navigating systems such as
healthcare.
It is clear that programs to develop life skills are important to young adults who are aging
out of foster care or are receiving homeless services; however, according to Paul-Ward (2009),
classes focusing on independent living skills were often scheduled inconsistently. Furthermore,
youth interviewed at one facility stated that they did not know when classes were available, or
they did not receive notification far enough in advance to attend. Those who would have liked to
attend were disappointed when they learned that they missed out on opportunities to participate
in life skills courses. Another problem noted, is that there is frequently no good way to insure
participation. In cases where mandatory participation was implemented, youth quickly learned
that there were no actual repercussions for not attending. Inconsistent scheduling, combined
with poor notification of upcoming classes, and no repercussions for absenteeism lead to
unsatisfactory attendance of life skills classes while leaving youth frustrated, and feeling
Working with homeless youth is an emerging and important practice area for OTs.
According to Lloyd, & Bassett (2012), OTs are able to complete occupation-based assessments
and help clients engage successfully in their life roles. By using a strengths-based approach, and
wellbeing can be improved (Lloyd & Bassett, 2012). Unique perspectives gained from using OT
models as part of service delivery make OTs a valuable resource when working with a homeless
population (Lloyd & Bassett, 2012). According to Paul-Ward and Lambdin-Pattavina (2016),
OT practitioners have the skills to intervene on both the community and individual levels while
Two specific intervention approaches were found in the literature to be beneficial to at-
risk young adults and adolescents. These intervention approaches include a cognitive
remediation approach researched by Weiner, Toglia, and Berg initially as a pilot study, then a
larger randomized controlled study was conducted by Toglia and Berg the following year
comparing at risk youth with typical peers (Weiner, Toglia, & Berg 2012; Toglia & Berg, 2013;
Medalia et al., 2017). Life skills training was addressed by a variety of authors as a beneficial
intervention for youth transitioning to adulthood (Buchert, 2014; Courtney et al., 2011; Keenan,
Weiner et al. (2012) and Toglia and Berg, (2013), used the Weekly Calendar Planning
executive function are better able to navigate the demands of adulthood (Weiner et al., 2012).
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 20
By observing the strategies a participant uses to complete the WCPA, a trained OT can
determine what aspects of executive function are problematic for the client. The OT can then
use this information to plan interventions which have the potential to increase performance in
broad areas (Toglia & Berg, 2013; Weiner, Toglia & Berg, 2012) “The WCPA analyzes how a
person manages and copes with a complex and cognitively challenging activity and involves
following and organizing a list of appointments or errands into a weekly schedule while keeping
track of rules, avoiding conflicts, monitoring passage of time, and inhibiting distractions.
Because performance on multiple-step activities such as the WCPA requires coordinating and
integrating various cognitive abilities, this assessment provides the opportunity to observe how
an individual manages a cognitively challenging task (Toglia, 2015).” Medalia et al. (2017, p.
with a variety of disorders. They found that after 13 sessions, the majority of participants
showed significant improvement in executive function, verbal memory, working memory, and
processing speed as well as improved mental health outcomes which generalized to improved
Life skills training is a very broad topic, but for the purposes of this literature review, it
refers to any skills that an at-risk youth would benefit from in order to transition to adulthood
successfully. Buchert (2014), defined them as skills that sustained economic growth and allowed
individuals to lead autonomous lives in the 21st century, and Keenan et al. (2013), also noted the
with challenges. Keenan et al. (2013) developed a life skills program that used the Canadian
priorities for intervention and quantify their ability to perform an occupation as well as their
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 21
satisfaction with their performance. The COPM is a powerful tool in that it involves the client
directly in the process of goal setting, and it provides an outcome measure to confirm that
intervention is effective. After administering the COPM, they provided life skills coaching to a
total of 22 male and 28 female participants with the average age of 18.1 years with a variety of
disabilities that may be seen in the population at the YRC. They worked with each individual to
set personal goals, and participants attended group sessions as well as one-on-one sessions where
their personal goals were the focus of intervention. Topics covered were determined by the goals
set by the participants and included nutrition, money management, community mobility,
recreation, personal development, organizational skills, independent living, career planning, and
relationships (Keenan et al., 2013). Outcomes from the COPM showed that life skills
interventions provided statistically significant improvement for participants, and it was noted that
some participants preferred group activities where some preferred one-on-one sessions, but both
action, it is possible to determine which clients would benefit from cognitive skills training to
improve executive function. Cognitive skills training as well as life skills training are highly
beneficial to improving outcomes for high risk youth. By using the WCPA in conjunction with
the COPM, goals can be set, and interventions tailored to the needs of the individual as well as
the group. OTs are well qualified to design programs to target the client factors, activity
Program Overview
Homeless youth are frequently unprepared for adult responsibilities. Those living in
shelters become accustomed to their needs being met by their case-workers and other adult
professionals. This leaves them unprepared to care for themselves when they no longer qualify
for services. At the YRC, clients age out of the provided programs on their 23rd birthday. This
life skills program will provide youth with the tools that are necessary to transition to adulthood
successfully. Services provided will include group activities as well as one-on-one sessions with
an occupational therapist. These services will support the YRC by adding additional structure to
their self-reliance program, and by providing the youth with opportunities to work one-on-one
Occupational Justice. Occupational justice was described by Stadnyk, Townsend, and Wilcock
(2010), as “meaningful and purposeful occupations (tasks and activities) that people want to do,
need to do, and can do considering their personal and situational circumstances’’ (p. 331).
restricted due to a variety of circumstances. The type of occupational injustice most frequently
seen at the YRC is occupational depravation which occurs when people are unable to participate
in meaningful occupations due to factors they cannot control (Durocher, Gibson, & Rappolt,
2014). Being homeless limits opportunities for the youth at the YRC to explore areas of
occupational interest, because the clients there have limited resources available to them to pursue
meaningful occupations. Occupational marginalization also occurs at the YRC. This happens
when people have little choice in decision making or are held back from pursing meaningful
occupations by sociocultural factors including expectations for behavior (Stadnyk et al., 2010).
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 23
Often the social norms of the YRC that include substance abuse, and inappropriate behaviors do
not promote healthy or meaningful occupational engagement. This program will address
occupational injustice by providing the youth with opportunities to explore their occupational
needs through group activities and one-on-one occupational therapy sessions. The youth will be
provided with the resources and tools they need to break out of the cycle of occupational
Role of the OT. Direct occupational therapy services will be provided to clients at the YRC
through an initial evaluation, group activities, and weekly one-on-one therapy sessions. These
services will focus on occupation-based goals that the clients identify through the COPM. The
most frequently identified goals will be utilized as topics for group activities, and goals that are
rehabilitation will be integrated in both group settings, and with individuals. Indirect services
will also be provided by a youth advocate trained by the OT to assist with group activities.
OTs have a unique skill set making them the optimal professional to run a program of this
nature. They have a background that encompasses psychology, anatomy, cognition, and
sociology. OTs also have in-depth knowledge of activity analysis and motivational interviewing,
and are able to create treatment plans targeting a wide range of ability levels. In this setting, an
OT can help people with rehabilitative needs ranging from specific components of an activity to
Factors Influencing Service Delivery. Decisions regarding preferred service delivery were
influenced by multiple factors including demographics of the population served at the YRC and
policies already in place at the shelter. The cultural norms represented at the YRC, trauma
informed care, and potential for funding were all taken into consideration. Additionally,
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 24
economic implications such as the long-term financial burden that is possible when problems
specific to this population are not addressed were looked at. At-risk youth who do not gain the
skills necessary to succeed on their own are likely to remain homeless, participate in risky
behaviors, or adopt unhealthy habits as coping mechanisms (Shonkoff et al., 2012). This
program will act to prevent continued homelessness for clients at the YRC which will in turn
lessen the economic burden the homeless population has on the infrastructure of Salt Lake City
and the state of Utah. By reaching clients at this transitional time of their lives, future financial,
This program offers primary, secondary, and tertiary prevention for at risk youth.
interventions to those who do not score within the normal range of the WCPA, and tertiary
prevention is addressed through one-on-one sessions for those who demonstrate significant
cognitive impairments. By addressing life skills and cognition with this population, we are
reducing their risk for continued homelessness, reducing their risk of substance abuse, and
providing interventions that will transfer to future interactions and situations for improved
abilities which helps increase occupational performance in a variety of situations and settings.
guide program interventions. This model is used to show that occupational performance emerges
from the transaction between people, the environment, and their occupations. This model
pertains to anyone that is not satisfied with their occupational performance due to a lack of
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 25
congruence between themselves, their occupations, and their environment (Law et al., 1996).
Right now, the clients served are not satisfied with their ability to perform a variety of tasks
necessary to live independently. PEO will be used to improve performance through adapting the
teaching compenestory strategies. PEO provides a holistic approach that allows changes to be
The complementary models that will be utilized are the Dynamic Interactional Model,
Kawa model, and the Lifestyle Redesign program. The Dynamic Interactional Model (DIM)
addresses how internal and external variables influence cognition and contribute to the efficacy
of the client’s occupational performance. The goals of this model are to decrease activity
limitations and enhance participation in everyday activities. This model addresses how people
process, learn, and generalize new information. Information processing skills as well as self-
efficacy will be addressed, and cognitive strategies will be integrated in treatment (Toglia, 2011).
The Kawa model will be used because it will resonate with the population at the YRC where
many of the clients there are interested in Eastern culture, and non-traditional spirituality. This
model uses a metaphor where life is represented by a river, obstacles are represented as rocks in
the river, and driftwood represents personal attributes. The Kawa model provides a powerful
visual tool for the youth to use to assess their current barriers to occupational success, and what
attributes they possess to increase their achievements (Kawa, 2009). Finally, Lifestyle Redesign
will be utilized because it provides a framework for health promotion with an underlying
psychological well-being. Though originally utilized for a well-elderly program, it can also be
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 26
used with other populations to build healthy habits and routines (Mandel, Jackson, Zemke,
Goal 1. Clients will increase competency and satisfaction related to self-identified life skill tasks
point increase in satisfaction with at least two identified occupational problems on the
Goal 2. Clients will demonstrate overall improvement in executive function that will generalize
Objective 1. Within 12 weeks, 80% of clients will independently demonstrate the use of
at least one new additional strategy when completing the Weekly Calendar Planning
Objective 2. Within 12 weeks, 80% of clients will independently score within 10% of a
Life Skills Training with Cognitive Rehabilitation. This program will ideally become part of
the programming already available at the YRC and run continuously in 12-week cycles that end
with a graduation ceremony. Group activities will be provided for two hours, twice a week, and
hour-long one-on-one sessions will be scheduled with participants on a weekly basis. The health
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 27
and wellness of participants will be addressed in sessions about self-care, navigating the health
care system, and preventing substance abuse. For those who would like to finish high school or
attend college, sessions can be held to help clients know what is necessary to finish their
education, and individual sessions can be used to not only learn ways to access education, but to
address client factors and performance skills that may be preventing academic success. As
needed or requested, social skills will be addressed, as well as participation in local government
as a voter. Since the clients will help guide topics addressed through their personal goals, any
topic of interest can be explored with an emphasis on skills that will increase independence.
All clients will be eligible to participate if they are interested in the program. Those who are
on an SRP will required to take part as part as part of the plan. In situations where program
capacity is at its limit, those on the SRP will be given priority eligibility over those who are not
participating in an SRP.
Time requirements. The following is a sample schedule for the program. Group outings and
activities will take place between 3:00-5:00 PM, during the time the YRC sets apart for group
Monday: 2 hours for an outing relevant to Life Skills education (OTR and YA)
The YRC currently provides a total of 30 beds for clients at night, with many more youth
spending time there during the day to access the resources provided by the facility. Those on a
SRP are guaranteed a bed at night as incentive to participate fully. The other 15 beds are divvied
out through a daily lottery system. Those who do not get a bed are required to sleep somewhere
else. Those who do not get beds stay with friends, use what money they have to get a motel
room, or sleep at the downtown library which is where the younger homeless population prefers
to stay. Most youth avoid the adult homeless population that gathers around Pioneer Park, and
the Road Home. They avoid these areas in part to evade violence, and to stay away from drugs
Staff Involvement. Some staff members may be involved with the program by assisting with
group activities which will require extra training regarding occupation-based treatment. The
social workers on staff will advocate for this program to the clients who may choose to attend
based on their goals and interests and will require those on an SRP to attend. Anyone who is
interested in participating may do so and will be evaluated in order to establish personal goals.
These goals will then be used to guide group activities as well as individualized treatment plans.
Youth advocates who assist with group activities will be directly involved with the program for
approximately six hours per week. Social workers, and other employees will be educated on the
fundamentals of the program, which may take about an hour, and from there, minimal time will
be spent referring individuals. The occupational therapist will initially complete a COPM and
WCPA activity with clients. The most frequently identified occupational concerns will be
targeted in group activities, where other topics will be addressed in individual sessions.
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 29
Community resources will be utilized for outings. For example, banks, medical clinics,
restaurants, schools, and other facilities may be visited as part of a group outing. Professionals
from a variety of disciplines will also be asked to come teach the youth. A small budget will be
incorporated for group activities and to bring in guest speakers. Many professionals are willing
to provide pro-bono services to the YRC which will allow the budgeted funds to be utilized for
situations when a guest requires payment for time or travel. Currently, the YRC refers clients to
a variety of resources as part of their service model. This program will also strive to find
appropriate resources to provide the best outcomes for clients. It is difficult to determine exactly
which places and resources will be included in this program since the client goals will drive the
content.
Space Requirements. This program will require classroom space, office space, and a storage
area. The YRC already has multiple classrooms equipped with tables and chairs available for
use during group activities. They also have a large computer lab that can be reserved for use.
Preferably, the OT running this program would have a private office in order to meet with
client’s one-on-one and to store OT supplies separately from other supplies. At a minimum, the
OT would require access to a private room for treatment sessions and have an area in a locked
room set aside for storage. Space is not likely to become a concern for this program. The YRC
is located in as new, state of the art facility that was designed with growth in mind.
Budget. The net cost of this program is estimated to be $30,750. This includes supplies, a
budget for unexpected costs, salary for the OT, and hourly pay for a youth advocate. This
program will benefit from a part time OT on staff and includes an estimate to pay them for 15
hours a week to run this program. Youth advocates are already employed at the YRC, so it is
possible that this will not be an extra cost if they are able to provide one without hiring an
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 30
additional staff member. The YRC works as a non-profit entity with a robust community of
people that donate a wide variety of supplies that will be utilized for this program. See appendix
Funding. Grant money may be available to fund this program. An advanced search on the
Foundation Directory On-Line using the key words “homeless, youth, occupational therapy, and
Salt Lake City” revealed that the George S. and Dolores Dore Eccles Foundation has grant
money available for homeless services as well as for health care related programs. The United
States Department of Health and Human services also provides numerous grants for homeless
services as well as healthcare related needs. Finally, Funding Institutional has grant money
available for a very specific program that involves cognitive rehabilitation. This program would
Marketing for the program will be done internally because the program is only available to
youth who access the services at the YRC. Employees will help market the program by referring
clients to it when they see that it would be beneficial for their personal growth, or as a
supplement to the SRP. The youth typically respect the staff at the YRC, and take suggestions
from them seriously, especially those who are on an SRP since participating in that program can
lead to housing vouchers. Additionally, posters and announcements about the program and what
it offers the clients will be displayed within the facility. Overall, this program will be well
attended because it was written in response to direct feedback provided by the clients who are
Expected Outcomes. The literature strongly suggests that this program will have a significant
positive impact on performance of life skills as well as cognition. Participants will leave the
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 31
program better prepared for adult responsibilities and have the skills to generalize information to
novel tasks, and improved problem-solving skills. Outcomes will be measured through the
program goals and objectives. Efficacy of the program will be demonstrated by improved scores
on the COPM as well as WCPA and EFPT scores. In addition to the quantitative data that will
be determined through the goals and objectives, clients will be surveyed regarding their opinion
of the program and this feedback will be implemented to improve the quality of the program.
What topics were not addressed that you feel should have been?
If you could change one thing about the program, what would it be?
This program has the potential to be highly beneficial to the youth at the YRC, and if
implemented it would provide additional structure to the programs already in place. Through
participation, not only will they be more prepared for stepping into adult roles, they will also be
Staff questions
Do you see any common client needs that are not being adequately met?
Do you see any ways that OT could enhance your current programs?
What do you find most challenging about your job?
Is there a lot of employee turnover?
How do you protect your own mental health while working with this population?
What is the purpose of your organization? (Mission statement, philosophy, etc.)
What group of individuals do you serve?
What are some of the characteristics of this group? Diagnoses, LOS, what other services
do they usually get
What are your funding sources?
What kinds of programming/services do you currently offer?
What are plans for different or additional services, etc. in the future?
Based upon your knowledge of your clients and how they function in your program or
after they leave, what gaps do you see in their functioning or skill levels?
Client questions
The COPM was administered to the client first, then the following questions were asked if not
Total= $30,750
Indirect Costs These expenses will be covered by the $0
YRC as in-kind donations. Items include
building maintenance, utilities
Income
Budget
Summary
Total costs
$30,750
Total income or
in-kind
contributions
Net cost of
program
$30,750
Total= $30,750
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 38
References
Buchert, L. (2014). Learning needs and life skills for youth: An introduction. International
Canham, M. (2014, December). Mormon populace picks up the pace in Utah. Salt Lake Tribune.
Courtney, M., Lee, J. & Perez, A. (2011). Receipt of help acquiring life skills and predictors of
help receipt among current and former foster youth. Children and Youth Services Review,
33(12), pp.2442-2451.
Durocher, E., Gibson, B. E., & Rappolt, S. (2014). Occupational Justice: A Conceptual
doi:10.1080/14427591.2013.775692
Gomez, R., Ryan, T., Norton, C., Jones, C. & Galán-Cisneros, P. (2015). Perceptions of learned
helplessness among emerging adults aging out of foster care. Child and Adolescent Social
Gronski, M.P., Boga, K.E., Kloeckner, J., Russell-Thomas, D., Taff, S. D., Walker, K.A. & Berg,
doi:10.5014/ajot.2013.008755
Iwama, M. K., Thomson, N. A., & MacDonald, R. M. (2009). The Kawa Model: The power of
Keenan, S., King, G., Curran, C., & McPherson, A. (2013). Effectiveness of experiential life
skills coaching for youth with a disability. Physical & Occupational Therapy In
Law, M., Baptiste, S., Carswell, A., McColl, M. A., Polatajko, H., & Pollock, N. (2014).
Law, M., Cooper, B., Strong, S., Stewart, D., Rigby, P., & Letts, L. (1996). The Person-
Lloyd, C. & Bassett, H. (2012). The role of occupational therapy in working with the homeless
Mandel, D. R., Jackson, J. M., Zemke, R., Nelson, L., Clark, F.A., (1999). Lifestyle Redesign:
Association.
Medalia, A., Saperstein, A., Huang, Y., Lee, S. & Ronan, E. (2017). Cognitive skills training
for homeless transition-age youth. The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 205 (11),
pp.859-866.
Paul-Ward, A. (2009). Social and occupational justice barriers in the transition from foster
88.
Paul-Ward, A., & Lambdin-Pattavina, C.A. (2016). New roles for occupational therapy to
promote independence among youth aging out of foster care. American Journal of
Read, H., Roush, S., & Downing, D. (2018). Early intervention in mental health for adolescents
and young adults: A systematic review. American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 72,
doi:10.5014/ajot.2018,033118
LIFE SKILLS TRAINING TO PROMOTE INDEPENDENCE 41
Shonkoff, J. P., Siegel, B. S., Garner, A. S., Dobbins, M. I., Earls, M. F.,
McGuinn, L., Wood, David L. (2012). The lifelong effects of early childhood adversity
Sparrow, C. (2018). Sorenson Legacy Foundation 2018 Impact Report Youth Resource Center
Christiansen & E. A. Townsend (Eds.), Introduction to occupation: The art and science of
living (2nd ed., pp. 329-358). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education
https://myaota.aota.org/shop_aota/prodview.aspx?TYPE=D&PID=271083346&SKU=90
0369
Toglia, Joan (2011). The dynamical interactional model of cognition in cognitive rehabilitation.
Toglia, J., & Berg, C. (2013). Performance-based measure of executive function: Comparison of
community and at-risk youth. American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 67, 515-523
doi:10.5014/ajot.2013.008482
Tullis, B. (2014, July). What was life like for the Mormon pioneers after entering the Salt Lake
U.S. Census Bureau (2017). Salt Lake City Population. Retrieved from
https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/saltlakecitycityutah
https://www.voaut.org
Weiner, N.W., Toglia, J., & Berg, C. (2012). Weekly Calendar Planning Activity (WCPA): A