You are on page 1of 52

12

1
Earlier Lecture
• We studied the effect of the heat exchanger
effectiveness ε on the performance of a Linde –
Hampson system.

Q act
• Mathematically, ε =
Q m ax

• In a Linde – Hampson cycle, the heat exchanger


effectiveness ε is h1 ' − h g or h3 ' − h 2
ε = ε =
h1 − h g h3 − h 2

2
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Earlier Lecture
• The liquid yield y for a Linde – Hampson system
is given by

( h1 − h2 ) − (1 − ε ) ( h 1 − hg )
y =
(h 1 − h f ) − (1 − ε ) ( h 1 − hg )
• The effectiveness should be more than 85% in
order to have a liquid yield in the Linde –
Hampson cycle.

3
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Outline of the Lecture
Topic : Gas Liquefaction and Refrigeration
Systems (contd)

• Precooled Linde – Hampson system


• Liquid yield
• Work requirement
• Maximum liquid yield

• Comparison between the Simple and Precooled


Linde – Hampson systems

4
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Introduction
• We have seen earlier that, as the compression
temperature decreases, the yield y increases for
a Linde – Hampson system.

• The method of cooling the gas after the


compression or before the entrance to the heat
exchanger is called as precooling.

5
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Introduction
• The Linde – Hampson cycle with a precooling
arrangement is called as Precooled Linde –
Hampson cycle.

• Here after, we refer these two cycles as Simple


Linde – Hampson system and Precooled Linde –
Hampson system respectively.

6
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
• The Simple Linde – Hampson
mɺ r system is as shown in the
figure.
Wc 2

• A 3 fluid heat exchanger is


mɺ f QR
mɺ used to thermally couple the
precooling and the Linde –
W c1 Hampson systems.

( mɺ − mɺ ) f • Hence, the temperature is


lowered after compression or
g
f before the entry to the heat
mɺ f exchanger.
7
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
• The features of the
mɺ r precooling system are as
follows.
Wc 2

• It is a closed cycle
refrigerator with the cold
heat exchanger thermally
LHS coupled to the simple Linde –
Hampson system.

• In other words, the cooling


object for this refrigerator is
the Linde – Hampson cycle.
8
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
• The heat exchanger of
mɺ r precooling system is cooled
by water and J – T device is
Wc 2 used to attain lower
temperature.

• The process of compression


LHS is assumed to be adiabatic.
Hence, QR = 0.

• R134a, NH3, CO2 are the


common refrigerants in the
precooling systems.
9
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
• The salient features of a
mɺ r Precooled Linde – Hampson
system are as follows.
Wc 2

• The system consists of a


mɺ f QR
mɺ compressor, heat exchangers
(2 and 3 – fluid) and a J – T
W c1 expansion device.

( mɺ − mɺ ) f • Compression process is
isothermal (adiabatic in
g
f precooling system) while the J
mɺ f – T expansion is isenthalpic.
10
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
• All the processes are assumed
mɺ r to be ideal in nature and there
are no pressure drops in the
Wc 2 system.

mɺ f QR
mɺ • The heat exchangers are
assumed to be 100% effective
W c1 and the processes are isobaric
in nature.
( mɺ − mɺ ) f

g
f
mɺ f
11
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
• The gas to be liquefied by
mɺ r the liquefaction system is
called as Primary Fluid.
Wc 2

• Whereas, the refrigerant in


mɺ f QR
mɺ the precooling system is
called as Secondary Fluid.
W c1

( mɺ − mɺ ) f

g
f
mɺ f
12
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
a b 2 1
mɺ r c
3 Precooling 6
Wc 2 Temp.
mɺ f QR d
mɺ 2 3
1
W c1
6
h=const
( mɺ − mɺ )
f 4 4

g 5 f g
f 5
mɺ f s
13
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
• The precooling limit of
2 1
the precooling cycle is
3 Ref. BP 6 governed by the boiling
Td
point of refrigerant at its
suction pressure.

• Boiling point of the


common refrigerants at
1 bar are
h=const
4 Fluid Boiling Pt.
CO2 216.6 K
f g
5 NH3 240 K
R134a 247 K
s
14
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
a
• Consider a control volume
b
mɺ r for this system as shown in
c
the figure.
Wc 2

• It encloses the 3 fluid heat


mɺ f QR d
mɺ 2 3
exchanger, J – T device and
1 the liquid container.
W c1
6
• The 1st Law is applied to
( mɺ − mɺ )
f 4 analyse the system. The
changes in the velocities
g 5
f and datum levels are
mɺ f assumed to be negligible.
15
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
a
• The quantities entering and
b
mɺ r leaving the control volume
c
are as follows.
Wc 2
IN OUT
mr @ d mr @ a
mɺ f QR d
mɺ 2 3
m@2 m – mf @ 1
1 mf @ f
W c1
6 • Applying the 1st law, we
have
( mɺ − mɺ )
f 4
mɺ r hd ,r + mh
ɺ 2
= mɺ r ha ,r + ( mɺ − mɺ f ) h1 + mɺ f h f
g 5
f
mɺ f
16
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
a b mɺ r hd ,r + mh
ɺ 2
= mɺ r ha ,r + ( mɺ − mɺ f ) h1 + mɺ f h f
mɺ r c

Wc 2
• Rearranging the terms, we
mɺ f QR have
d
mɺ 2 3
1 mɺ f  h1 − h2  mɺ r  ha ,r − hd ,r 
=  +  
W c1
6
mɺ  h1 − h f  mɺ  h1 − h f 
( mɺ − mɺ )
f 4 mɺ r
• Denoting the ratio =r
g 5 mɺ
f
mɺ f
17
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
a
• We have,
b
mɺ r c mɺ f h1 − h2  ha , r − hd ,r 
y= = +r 
Wc 2 mɺ h1 − h f  h −h
 1 f 
mɺ f QR d • The first term in the above
mɺ 2 3 expression is the yield for a
1
simple Linde – Hampson
W c1
6
system.

( mɺ − mɺ )
f 4
• The second term is the
g 5 additional yield occurring
f due to the precooling of
mɺ f
the Simple system.
18
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
a b mɺ f h1 − h2  ha , r − hd ,r 
mɺ r y= = +r 
c mɺ h1 − h f  h −h
 1 f 
Wc 2
• This increment in the yield
mɺ f QR is dependent on the
d
mɺ 2 3
1
• The change in enthalpy
W c1
6 values from (hd  ha)
of the refrigerant.
( mɺ − mɺ )
f 4

g 5 • Refrigerant flow rate


f
(mr).
mɺ f
19
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
a
• Since, the 3 – fluid heat
b
mɺ r exchanger is assumed to
c
be 100% effective, the
Wc 2 following conditions hold
true.
mɺ f QR d • The minimum value of T3
mɺ 2 3
1 would be equal to Td, which
W c1 is the boiling point of the
6 refrigerant.
( mɺ − mɺ ) • The maximum value of T6
f 4
would be equal to Td, which
g 5 is the boiling point of the
f
refrigerant.
mɺ f
20
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
a
• At this condition, the
b
mɺ r system produces the
c
maximum yield for a given
Wc 2 refrigerant.

mɺ f QR d
mɺ 2 3
• Mathematically,
1 • y = ymax for T3 = T6 = Td
W c1
6
• Consider a control volume
( mɺ − mɺ )
f 4 enclosing the heat
g
exchanger, J – T device
5
f and the liquid container as
mɺ f shown in the figure.
21
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
a
• The quantities entering and
b
mɺ r leaving the control volume
c
are as follows.
Wc 2
IN OUT
m@3 mf @ f
mɺ f QR d
mɺ 2 3
m – mf @ 6
1
W c1
6 • Applying the 1st law, we
have
( mɺ − mɺ )
f 4

g 5 ɺ 3 = mɺ f h f + ( mɺ − mɺ f ) h6
mh
f
mɺ f
22
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
a
• Rearranging the terms, we
b
mɺ r have
c

Wc 2 mɺ f ( h6 − h f ) = mɺ ( h6 − h3 )

mɺ f QR d
mɺ 2 mɺ f h6 − h3
3
ymax = =
1 mɺ h6 − h f
W c1
6 • The quantities h3 and h6 are
evaluated at the boiling
( mɺ − mɺ )
f 4
point of the refrigerant (Td).
g 5
f
mɺ f
23
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
a
• Consider a control volume
b
mɺ r for the compressor in the
c
liquefaction cycle as shown
Wc 2 in the figure.

mɺ f QR d
mɺ 2 3
• The quantities entering and
1 leaving this control volume
W c1 are as given below.
6
IN OUT
( mɺ − mɺ )
f 4 m@1 m@2
-Wc1 -QR
g 5
f
mɺ f
24
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
a
• Using 1st Law for the
b
mɺ r following table, we get
c
IN OUT
Wc 2
m@1 m@2
-Wc1 -QR
mɺ f QR d
mɺ 2 3 Ein = Eout
1
W c1
6 ɺ 1 − Wc1 = mh
mh ɺ 2 − QR

( mɺ − mɺ ) • Rearranging the terms, we


f 4
have
f
g 5 QR − Wc1 = mɺ ( h2 − h1 )
mɺ f
25
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
a b QR − Wc1 = mɺ ( h2 − h1 )
mɺ r c • The heat of compression QR
can be obtained by using 2nd
Wc 2
Law for an isothermal
mɺ f QR
compression. It is given by,
d

1
2 3
ɺ 1 ( s2 − s1 )
QR = mT
W c1
6 • Combining the above
equations, we have
( mɺ − mɺ )
f 4

g
ɺ 1 ( s1 − s2 ) − mɺ ( h1 − h2 )
−Wc1 = mT
5
f
mɺ f
26
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
a
• Similarly, a control volume
b
mɺ r is taken enclosing the
c
refrigerating compressor.
Wc 2

mɺ f
• The quantities entering and
QR d
mɺ 2 3
leaving this control volume
1 are as given below.
W c1
6 IN OUT
mr @ a mr @ b
( mɺ − mɺ )
f 4 -Wc2 0
g 5 • The heat of compression is
f zero because the process is
mɺ f
adiabatic.
27
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
a
• Using 1st Law for the
b
mɺ r following table, we get
c
IN OUT
Wc 2
mr @ a mr @ b
-Wc2 0
mɺ f QR d
mɺ 2 3 Ein = Eout
1
W c1
6 mɺ r ha ,r − Wc 2 = mɺ r hb ,r

( mɺ − mɺ ) • Rearranging the terms, we


f 4
have
f
g 5 −Wc 2 = mɺ r ( hb ,r − ha ,r )
mɺ f
28
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
a
• The total work requirement
b
mɺ r for this system is
c
Wc = Wc1 + Wc 2
Wc 2

mɺ f QR • Substituting the following


d
mɺ 2 3 values, we have
1
W c1
ɺ 1 ( s1 − s2 ) − mɺ ( h1 − h2 )
−Wc1 = mT
6
−Wc 2 = mɺ r ( hb ,r − ha ,r )
( mɺ − mɺ )
f 4
ɺ 1 ( s1 − s2 ) − mɺ ( h1 − h2 )
−Wc = mT
g 5
f
+ mɺ r ( hb , r − ha ,r )
mɺ f
29
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
a b ɺ 1 ( s1 − s2 ) − mɺ ( h1 − h2 )
−Wc = mT
+ mɺ r ( hb , r − ha ,r )
mɺ r c

Wc 2
• The work required for a unit
mass of primary gas
mɺ f QR d
mɺ 2 3
compressed is given as
1
Wc
W c1 − = T1 ( s1 − s2 ) − ( h1 − h2 )
6 mɺ
mɺ r
( mɺ − mɺ )
f 4
+

( hb ,r − ha ,r )

g 5
f
mɺ f
30
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
mɺ r
a b • Denoting the ratio =r
mɺ r c mɺ
Wc
= T1 ( s1 − s2 ) − ( h1 − h2 )
Wc 2


mɺ f QR mɺ r
mɺ 2
d
3 +

( hb ,r − ha ,r )
1
W c1
6 Wc
− = T1 ( s1 − s2 ) − ( h1 − h2 )
( mɺ − mɺ )
f 4

+ r ( hb ,r − ha ,r )
g 5
f
mɺ f
31
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Precooled L – H Cycle
a b Wc
mɺ r c − = T1 ( s1 − s2 ) − ( h1 − h2 )

Wc 2 + r ( hb ,r − ha ,r )

mɺ f QR d
• The first and second terms
mɺ 2 3 are the work requirement in
1
a Simple Linde – Hampson
W c1
6
system.

( mɺ − mɺ )
f 4
• The third term is the
g 5 additional work required to
f precool the system.
mɺ f
32
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Tutorial – 1
• Determine the y, ymax, the work/unit mass
compressed, work/unit mass liquefied and FOM
for the Simple and Precooled Linde – Hampson
systems with Nitrogen as working fluid. The
R134A is the refrigerant for the precooling
system with ratio r as 0.08. The liquefaction
system is operated between 1.013 bar (1 atm)
and 101.3 bar (100 atm) at 300 K. The following
is the data for R134a. Comment on the results.
a b c
p (bar) 1.013 10.13 10.13
T (K) 300 373 300
h (J/g) 390 482 260
33
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Tutorial – 1
Given
Cycle : Simple and Precooled L – H System
Working Fluid : Nitrogen
Pressure : 1 atm  100 atm
Temperature : 300 K
Refrigerant : R134a, 1 atm  10 atm
Mass ratio(r) : 0.08
For above cycles, Calculate and comment
1 Liquid Yield y, ymax
2 Work/unit mass of gas compressed
3 Work/unit mass of gas liquefied
4 FOM

34
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Tutorial – 1
a b
1 2 f
mɺ r c
p (bar) 1.013 101.3 1.013
T (K) 300 300 77
Wc 2 h (J/g) 462 445 29
s (J/gK) 4.42 3.1 0.42
mɺ f QR d
mɺ 2 3 a b c
1 p (bar) 1.013 10.13 10.13
W c1 T (K) 300 373 300
6
h (J/g) 390 482 260
( mɺ − mɺ )
f 4 s (J/gK) R134a
g • hd = hc, since the
5
f expansion is isenthalpic.
mɺ f
35
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Tutorial – 1
• Ideal Work Requirement
1
Wɺi
− = T1 ( s1 − s f ) − ( h1 − h f )

T
1 2 f
p (bar) 1.013 101.3 1.013
T (K) 300 300 77 f g
h (J/g) 462 445 29 s
s (J/gK) 4.42 3.1 0.42
Wc
− = 300 ( 4.42 − 0.42 ) − ( 462 − 29 ) = 767 J / g

36
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Tutorial – 1
100 1
• Liquid yield T=const
2 1
300
 h1 − h2 
y = 
h −h
 1 f 
1 2 f 3 h=const
p (bar) 1.013 101.3 1.013
f g
T (K) 300 300 77 4
h (J/g) 462 445 29 s
s (J/gK) 4.42 3.1 0.42
 h1 − h2   462 − 445   17 
y =
h −h  =   =  433  = 0.04
 1 f   462 − 29   
37
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Tutorial – 1
100 1
• Work/unit mass of gas T=const
2 1
compressed 300

Wc
− = T1 ( s1 − s2 ) − ( h1 − h2 )

1 2 f 3 h=const
p (bar) 1.013 101.3 1.013
f g
T (K) 300 300 77 4
h (J/g) 462 445 29 s
s (J/gK) 4.42 3.1 0.42
Wc
− = 300 ( 4.42 − 3.1) − ( 462 − 445 ) = 379 J / g

38
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Tutorial – 1
100 1
• Work/unit mass of gas T=const
2 1
liquefied 300

Wc y = 0.04
− = 379
mɺ 3 h=const

f g
4
s
Wc Wc 379
− =− = = 9475 J / g
mɺ f ymɺ 0.04

39
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Tutorial – 1
100 1
• Figure of Merit (FOM) T=const
2 1
300

Wc Wi
− = 9475 − = 767
mɺ f mɺ f
3 h=const

f g
4
s
Wi
mɺ f 767
FOM = = = 0.081
Wc 9475
mɺ f
40
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Tutorial – 1
• The T – s diagram for a 100
2 1 1
Precooled Linde – 3
Prec. 6
Hampson system is as Temp
shown.

• The state properties are


4 h=const
as tabulated below.
f g
1 2 f 5

p (bar) 1.013 101.3 1.013 s


T (K) 300 300 77
h (J/g) 462 445 29
s (J/gK) 4.42 3.1 0.42

41
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Tutorial – 1
• Liquid yield

mɺ f h1 − h2  ha , r − hd ,r 
y= = +r  r = 0 .0 8
mɺ h1 − h f  h −h
 1 f 
1 2 f a b c
p (bar) 1.013 101.3 1.013 1.013 10.13 10.13
T (K) 300 300 77 300 373 300
h (J/g) 462 445 29 390 482 260
s (J/gK) 4.42 3.1 0.42 R134a
( 462 − 445 ) ( 390 − 260 ) (17 ) (130 )
y = + 0.08 = + 0.08 = 0.063
( 462 − 29 ) ( 462 − 29 ) ( 433) ( 433)
42
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Tutorial – 1
• Work/unit mass of N2
compressed
Wc r = 0 .0 8
− = T1 ( s1 − s2 ) − ( h1 − h2 )

+ r ( hb ,r − ha ,r )
1 2 f a b c
p (bar) 1.013 101.3 1.013 1.013 10.13 10.13
T (K) 300 300 77 300 373 300
h (J/g) 462 445 29 390 482 260
s (J/gK) 4.42 3.1 0.42 R134a
Wc
− = 300 ( 4.42 − 3.1) − ( 462 − 445 ) + 0.08 ( 482 − 390 ) = 386.3 J / g

43
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Tutorial – 1
• Work/unit mass of N2 100
2 1 1
liquefied 3
Prec. 6
Temp

Wc y = 0.063
− = 386.3

4 h=const
f g
5

Wc Wc s
− =− 386.3
= = 6131.7 J / g
mɺ f ymɺ 0.063

44
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Tutorial – 1
• Figure of Merit (FOM) 100
2 1 1
3
Prec. 6
Temp

Wc Wi
− = 6131.7 − = 767
mɺ f mɺ f
4 h=const
f g
5
s
Wi
mɺ f 767
FOM = = = 0.1251
Wc 6131.7
mɺ f
45
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Tutorial – 1
• Maximum Liquid yield 100
2 1 1
y = ymax T3 = T6 = Td = 247 K 247 3 Ref BP 6

h6 − h3
ymax = r = 0 .0 8
h6 − h f
3 6 f 4 h=const
p (bar) 101.3 1.013 1.013 f g
5
T (K) 247 247 77
h (J/g) 380 408 29 s

( 408 − 380 )
=
( 28 )
= 0.074
ymax =
( 408 − 29 ) ( 379 )
46
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Tutorial – 1
Simple Precooled Max.
y 0.04 0.063 0.074

Wc 379 386.3 386.3




W 9475 6131.7 5220.2
− c
mɺ f
0.081 0.1251 0.147
FOM

• Tabulating the results, we have the above


comparison for Simple and Precooled Linde –
Hampson System.

47
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Assignment
1. Compare and comment on the following for both
Simple and Precooled Linde – Hampson systems
with Air as working fluid when the system is
operated between 1.013 bar (1 atm) and 202.6
bar (200 atm) at 300 K. The effectiveness of HX
is 100% and r=0.1.

• Ideal Work requirement


• Liquid yield
• Work/unit mass compressed
• Work/unit mass liquefied
• FOM
48
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Summary
• The method of cooling the gas after the
compression or before the entrance to the heat
exchanger is called as precooling.

• The Linde – Hampson cycle with a precooling


arrangement is called as Precooled Linde –
Hampson cycle.

• In a Precooled Linde – Hampson system, a closed


cycle refrigerator is thermally coupled to a simple
Linde – Hampson system through a 3 – fluid heat
exchanger.

49
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Summary
• Compression process is isothermal in Liquefaction
cycle but it is adiabatic in precooling system of a
Precooled Linde – Hampson system.

• The precooling limit of the precooling cycle is


governed by the boiling point of refrigerant at its
suction pressure.

• The yield for a Precooled Linde – Hampson


system is
mɺ f h1 − h2  ha , r − hd ,r  mɺ r
y= = +r  =r
h1 − h f 
mɺ  h1 − h f  mɺ
50
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Summary
mɺ f h6 − h3
ymax = =
mɺ h6 − h f
• The maximum liquid yield is given by the above
expression. The enthalpy values are evaluated at
the boiling point of the refrigerant.

• The work requirement for the unit mass of


primary fluid compressed is
Wc
− = T1 ( s1 − s2 ) − ( h1 − h2 ) + r ( hb ,r − ha ,r )

• From the tutorial, the yield of the precooled
system is more than that of a simple system.
51
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay
Thank You!

52
Prof. M D Atrey, Department of Mechanical Engineering, IIT Bombay

You might also like