Chapter 3
PERMEABLE ZONE LOGS
hefirststepin analyzing a set oflogs, asoutlined previouly, isto pick
‘ot the permeable zane, which may be sands or carbonates, and
‘iseard the impermeable shales. The logs wed for this purpose are
the Spontaneous Potential (SP) and the Gamma Ray (GR). They arealways
recorded in Track
“The two logs distinguish shales from nonshales by quite different mocha-
num, The SP isan electrical measurement and heGR isanuclear messure-
tment, Sometimes the logs are virtually identical; sometimes they are vasthy
diferent, Fortunately, when one s poor, the other is usually gv.
ig. 3-1 compares SP and GH logs in typical sft rock serd-and-shale
sequence, Both curves are good inthis case and clearly distinguish theshales|
‘on the right from the permeable sands on the let. In soft rock the SP
ienerally gives a more black-and-white distinction between the sheles nd
thesands than does the CR, The latter shows more variability in both shale
and sapd readings.
‘By contrast, in hard limestone formations the SP may be alazy, poorly
eveloped curve that hardly resolves permeable and impermeable zones.
‘The GR is superior under these conditions giving goed shale-carbonate
distinction and bed resolution
‘Both eurvesare used to indicattheshalecontent ofa permeablezone for
shay formation interpretation (chapter 1). The GR is more quastitative
than the SP in this rexpost. On the other hand the SP may be usedto give the
formation water resistivity required for saturation calculations,
SPONTANEOUS POTENTIAL (SP) LOG
‘The SP logiea recording ofthe difference in lectrica potential between
fied electrode at thesurace and a movable electrode inthe borehole. The
hole must be illed with conductive mud. NoSP can be measured in ol-base
mud, empty holes, or cased holes. The seal ofthe SP logis in millivolts.
‘There ino absolute zero; only changes in potential are recordedESSENTIALS OF MODERN OPEN-HOLE LOG INTERPRETATION
Measurement ofthe SP issimple, but understanding thelogisnotso easy.
‘he og isthe one curve among modern logs whose boundary response and
bed definition vary widely with formation and sud properties. The SP
‘curve s used to
* select permeable zones
* provide Rvalues .
* etimate the degree of shalines of reservoir rock
‘SOURCE OF SPONTANEOUS POTENTIAL
‘The potential sensed is a combination of four electrical potentials st in
‘motion when the dilhole penetrates the formations. These are shown in
Fig. 3-2 with polarities appropriate for the usual fresh-mud ease where
Tea
oo
Fig. 3-1 Comparison of ° and Gtiogs eo formations (om Applied
Opennote og interpretation, courtesy OW. Hich),
PERMEABLEZONE LOGS a
[qi Ryo They are, in order of importance
° an electrochemical potential, Es, existing across the impermeable
‘hale between its horizontal interface with a permeable one snd its
vertical interface with the borehole
+ an electrochemical potential, Ey, existing across the transition
between invaded and noninvaded zones in the permeable bed
+ an eleotokinetic potentil,E., existing across the mud eake
* fn electrokinetic potentil, Ey existing ucros a thia layer of shale
‘ext tothe borehole
o o
Shao base tre
ig, 3-2 Origin of spontaneous potential8 ESSENTIALS OF MODERN OFEN-HOLELOG INTERPRETATION
Electrochemical Potentiats'=?
‘The potontial Ey is « membrane potential asociaed with selective
passageof onsin the shale. Because of layered clay etructure end charges on
‘the layers, shales pass Na+ ions but retain Cl fons. When shale separates
Sodium chloride solution of different concentrations, the Na+ lors move
through the shale from the more-concentrated solution (normally the for.
‘ation water to the les-concentrated solution (normally the mud). This
constitutes a current flow. The magnitude of the potential causing thistlow
‘sa function ofthe ione activities of the two solutions; these in turn are
related to thelr resistivities, For sodium chloride solutions at 77°F, the
potential in mliols i
Eq = ~59.1 og a/R) en)
Ry and R, are equivalent resistivities closely related to actual valuesof
R,cand R. The negativesign means the potentials negative relative tothe
value observed in a thick shale far from a boundary.
‘The potential E, isa liguid junction or effusion potential that exists
scrosthe interface of solutions of different salinity. Cl~ lons have greater
mobility than do Na+ ions, so there i a net flow of negative charges
{tom the mor concentrated formation water tothe le concentated ned
trate,
This is equivalent toa curent low inthe oppaste direction The magni
tude of the corresponding potential, millivolts, for sodium chloride solu
lone at 77°F is
~ 1S log Rule) oy
‘This potential asthe same dependency as Fy but is only one-fifth as large,
Itisofsuch polarity ato add to Ey.
‘Combining the two, the total electrochemical potential is any
y= —K log (Raw/ Ba) 6)
, which is proportional to absolute temperature, i given by
K-61 +0197 oa
where T sin dagrees Fahrenheit,
‘Typically, 1s 70-100 my for fesh mud and saline formation waters.
PERMEABLE ZONE LOGS ”
Hectrotttration Potentials
‘The potential E, across the mud cake is ofa different nature, Its an
clectrofiltratin or steaming potential thts produced by aflow af ectro-
Iyte, themud filtrate, through porous medium, the mudeake.”Themagnl-
tude cannot be predicted with any accuracy. However, an approrimate
relation for is value in mv, hes been given as
By = 0.04» APR co)
where
[AP = pressure differential between borehole and formation, psi
FR, = mud cake resistivity, ohm-m
tee = mud eakethieknes, in
£" = APL water loss ofthe mad, 0/90 min
With AP = 200, Ra = 1s to = 0.5, and
conditions, Ea. 3.8 gives B= 8 mv.
“Typically E,qis afew milveltsand addsto forthe normal case of Fi,
> Ry, However its partially counterbalanced by a similar potential, Ey
Gf opposite polarity atthe shale-borehole boundary where the shale isl
Sete lk cae with very low water ns. Conseuety the net