Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Original Article
Cross-sectional Study
Hye-Mi Jo, MPH1, Eun Hye Lee, MD, PhD2, Kyungran Ko, MD, PhD3, Bong Joo Kang, MD,
PhD4, Joo Hee Cha, MD, PhD5, Ann Yi, MD, PhD6, Hae Kyoung Jung, MD7, Jae Kwan Jun,
MD, PhD1 and on behalf of the Alliance for Breast Cancer Screening in Korea (ABCS-K)
le
1
National Cancer Control Institute, National Cancer Center, Goyang, 2Department of Radiology,
ic
Soon Chun Hyang University Bucheon Hospital, Soon Chun Hyang University College of
Medicine, Bucheon, 3Center for Breast Cancer, National Cancer Center Hospital, National
t
Ar
Cancer Center, Goyang, 4Department of Radiology, College of Medicine, The Catholic
National Cancer Control Institute, National Cancer Center, 323 Ilsan-ro, Ilsandong-gu,
This article has been accepted for publication and undergone full peer review but has not
been through the copyediting, typesetting, pagination and proofreading process which may
lead to differences between this version and the Version of Record. Please cite this article as
an ‘Accepted Article’, doi:10.4143/crt.2018.297
1
Korean Cancer Association
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
CANCER RESEARCH AND TREATMENT (CRT)
Abstract
Purpose
Women with dense breast are known to be at high risk for breast cancer, but their prevalence and
number of Korean women are unknown. The current study was to investigate the distribution of
le
Materials and Methods
For obtaining a nationwide representative sample, 6,481 mammograms were collected from 86
ic
screening units participated in the National Cancer Screening Program for breast cancer. Based
t
on the American College of Radiology Breast Imaging Reporting and Data System
Ar
classification, breast density was evaluated by six breast radiologists, qualitatively. We applied
these breast density distributions to age-specific counts of the Korean women population
ed
derived to mid-year 2017 to estimate the number of Korean women with dense breasts.
Results
pt
Overall, 54.4% (95% confidence interval [CI], 52.9% to 55.8%) of women 40 to 69 years of
age had heterogeneously or extremely dense breasts, and this proportion was inversely
ce
associated with age. Based on the age distribution of Korean women, we estimated that
6,083,000 women (95% CI, 5,919,600 to 6,245,600) age 40-69 years in Korean have dense
Ac
breasts. Women aged 40-49 years (n=3,450,000) accounted for 56.7% of this group.
Conclusion
More than half of Korean women aged 40 and over have dense breasts. To prevent breast
2
Korean Cancer Association
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
CANCER RESEARCH AND TREATMENT (CRT)
Introduction
quantitatively, is well-known as a risk factor for breast cancer in Western women [1,2].
Recent studies have reported that it might be a risk factor in Asian women [3,4].
It is used as a surrogate marker of breast cancer prevention [5] and makes a model for
le
predicting a risk of breast cancer in individuals more accurate [6]. Moreover, in women with
ic
dense breast, the MBD makes it difficult to detect breast cancer, which decreases the accuracy
t
Ar
Age is most likely associated with the MBD, which is decreased by age. In addition,
anthropometric, parity, and hormonal factors known as the risk factor of breast cancer are also
associated with the MBD [9]. Although many epidemiological studies including immigration
ed
studies reported that there are ethnic and geographic differences in the MBD [10-14], most of
them have a problem of small sample size and representativeness of populations. In Asian
pt
women, the proportions of women with dense breast may be higher than those of western
women.
ce
Many Korean women are known to have small breast volume and a higher proportion of
dense breasts [15,16]. However, to date, there is no study on the distribution of breast density
Ac
using a large-scale and representative sample of asymptomatic Korean women. The objective
of this study, therefore, is to examine the distribution of MBD by age in women undergoing
screening mammography and estimate the prevalence of Korean women with dense breasts.
Using the recent studies conducted with a representative sample [17,18], we sought to
3
Korean Cancer Association
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
CANCER RESEARCH AND TREATMENT (CRT)
The Korean Mammographic Density (KoMAD) study was designed to estimate the
prevalence of dense breast representatively and to determine the association between breast
density and breast cancer risk in Korean women. It was conducted from January 2012 to
December 2014. The design and study enrolment have been fully described in detail
previously [4, 19]. Briefly, the eligible population of this study consisted of women aged 40
le
years and over who participated in the National Cancer Screening Program (NCSP) in 2009.
ic
To prevent over-representation of specific regions, the participants were randomly selected
t
Ar
years in each region. To ensure accessibility of mammograms, screening units were restricted
to a total amount of mammograms annually. Imaging data were collected from a total of 86
screening units representing their respective district regions. The mammographic images were
ed
obtained from the screening units in the form of original analog film copy or Digital Imaging
and Communication in Medicine (DICOM) file. Among the selected women, 962 women
pt
(12.9%) whose were not stored craniocaudal (CC) and mediolateral oblique (MLO) images of
both breasts, or whose was not re-readable film status, were excluded. Finally, mammograms
ce
The MBD was measured qualitatively according to the American College of Radiology
Ac
(ACR) Breast Imaging Reporting and Data System (BI-RADS) classification (4th edition) of
breast density [20]. Six radiologists who are active members of the Korean Society of Breast
Imaging and breast specialists in general hospitals participated in this study. To reduce
variability in evaluating MBD, six breast radiologists were trained in the ACR BI-RADS
classification of breast density. Prior to read mammography images in this study, the inter-
radiologist agreement of ACR BI-RADS classification was evaluated. Based on pilot test,
4
Korean Cancer Association
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
CANCER RESEARCH AND TREATMENT (CRT)
radiologists showed substantial agreement for measurement of MBD: the weighted kappa
value for inter-radiologist agreement was 0.83 (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.80 to 0.86)
[21]. They were paired into three groups to read MBD. If two radiologists’ read were not
consistent, they discussed to reach an agreement. Each BI-RADS density grade was classified
as follows [20]: almost entirely fat (0%-25% glandular); scattered fibroglandular densities
le
(76%-100% glandular). Density classifications were grouped almost entirely fat and scattered
ic
breasts”.
t
We used the distribution of MBD by age groups for estimating prevalence of breast density
Ar
and its 95% CI in Korean women. For estimating counts of women with a dense breast by age
group, we obtained data from the 2017 Korean Census. By multiplying the weighted
ed
each age group. All other statistical analyses were conducted using SAS Statistical Software,
pt
1. Ethical statement
With permission from the Ministry of Health and Welfare, informed consent for this study
Ac
was not required, which was approved by the Institutional Review Board (IRB) of the
5
Korean Cancer Association
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
CANCER RESEARCH AND TREATMENT (CRT)
Results
Table 1 shows the characteristics of the study participants and their breast densities. About
11.1% of the participants reported having used hormones. This study included 1,212 (18.7%)
women in the ‘almost entirely fat,’ 1,862 (28.7%) women in the ‘scattered fibroglandular
densities,’ 2,212 (34.1%) women in the ‘heterogeneously dense,’ and 1,195 (18.4%) women in
le
Fig. 1 shows the distribution of breast density measured by four BI-RADS categories for
ic
women aged 40 years and older in this study. The highest proportions by each age group were
as follows: extremely dense (44.2%) for aged 40-44 years, heterogeneously dense (43.7%) for
t
Ar
aged 45-54 years, scattered fibroglandular tissue (40.5%) for aged 55-64 years, and almost
entirely fat (53.2%) for aged 65 years and older. The proportions of dense breasts declined
with increasing age. Similar trends were observed when stratified by health insurance status
ed
(S1 Fig.). It sharply decreased in Korean women aged 55-59 years. Women with dense breasts
in their 40s showed more than 70%, but they fell to less than 10% from the age of 65. Overall,
pt
45.6% (95% CI, 44.2% to 47.0%) in the Korean women aged 40 years and older, which was
extremely dense breasts (Table 2). For women aged 40 to 69 years, 54.4% (95% CI, 52.9 to
55.8) and 6,083,000 women (95% CI, 5,919,600 to 6,245,600) were estimated, respectively.
Ac
Our results were compared with prior studies conducted in United States and China is
presented in Fig. 2. Similar to our results, the prevalence of MBD in United States and
Chinese women decreased with increasing age. Until the age of 60, the prevalence of MBD of
Korean women was higher than that of U.S. women. At age 60, U.S. women with dense
breasts began to outstrip Korean women with dense breasts. Within comparable age groups,
6
Korean Cancer Association
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
CANCER RESEARCH AND TREATMENT (CRT)
Discussion
We quantitatively estimated Korean women with dense breasts, which might be one of
major risk factors for breast cancer. Among all Korean women aged 40 years and over, who
are the target population of the NCSP for breast cancer, we estimated that the proportion of
le
which most guidelines for breast cancer screening recommend, the proportion was increased
ic
to 54.4% (6,083,000 women).
t
Ar
mammographic density according age group between women in Korean and United States.
There result of the overall tendency with aging was similar to our results. However, the
proportion of women with dense breasts in Korean was higher than 80% until their late 40s,
ed
and then there was a sharp decrease in the proportion upper 50 years. By comparing the
characteristic change in breast, it is that Korean women in aged between 40 and 54 years were
pt
a much greater proportion of dense breasts than U.S. women, and that the transfer from dense
breasts to fatty breasts tends to change more rapidly than U.S. women. Our results in the
ce
proportion of breast density according age group are similar to prior studies in China and
Japan. The proportion of women with dense breasts in China and Japan was higher in under
Ac
50 years of age, and then breast density tends to decrease with increasing age. But, Setsuko et
al. [22] has limitation in making comparisons with our results because a quoted age standards
are different and absolute density was not evaluation in their study.
Since 2002, the NCSP for breast cancer has been conducted for all Korean women aged 40
years old and over, biennially. To date, the participation rate is about 52% and more than 3.3
million women are receiving screening mammography each year [23]. Higher recall rates of
7
Korean Cancer Association
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
CANCER RESEARCH AND TREATMENT (CRT)
NCSP, especially over 20% in aged 40s than those of other screening programs in Western
countries was reported [24]. Women with extremely dense breast were 7 times more likely to
recall than women with almost entirely fatty breast [25]. It might be due to risk of interval
cancer in women with dense breast and concerns about subsequent medical litigation.
finding due to the masking effect of dense tissue [7,8]. An interval cancer diagnosed in
le
woman with dense breasts has led to legislation in the United States that mandates disclosure
ic
density notification law was first enacted in Connecticut in 2009, it has been put into effect in
t
35 states and requires direct screen notification on mammographic results indicating the
Ar
presence of dense breasts [26]. It has been estimated that more than 25 million women with
dense breasts in the United States’ could be affected by the breast density notification laws
ed
[17]. On the other hand, in Korea, the NCSP started to record breast density information in
Some limitations of this study regarding interpreting result exist. First, we evaluated MBD
is widely used, its assessments depend on the ability and experience of radiologists and may
quantitative breast density analysis is needed with more objective and higher reproducibility,
but supplying digital radiographic system for mammography is essential. Second, we could
not consider the other factors that can influence breast density in this study, such as the body
mass index, reproductive and hormonal factors, or socioeconomic status. However, our study
minimized the effects of these external factors by applying a representative sampling strategy.
Third, there were discrepancies between the time when the survey was conducted and the
8
Korean Cancer Association
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
CANCER RESEARCH AND TREATMENT (CRT)
yearly population data used for estimation of the counts of women with dense breasts.
Although there is no evidence that the prevalence of MBD by age changes with the calendar
year, further studies are required to determine the changes in breast density over time through
repeated measurements.
Despite these limitations, our study is meaningful because this is nationwide survey for
estimating the distribution of MBD among Korean women and counting women with dense
le
breasts quantitatively. It could be utilized as principal evidence for developing the preventing
ic
Our results indicate the underlying prevalence of dense breasts among the Korean women
t
aged 40 years and older. More than half of the Korean women have dense breasts. In spite of
Ar
limited evidences [27], Korean women with dense breasts are recommended supplemental
screening such as breast ultrasonography. More than 19,000 breast cancers are newly
ed
diagnosed each year and it is expected that the number will continue to increase in near future
[28,29]. To prevent breast cancer effectively and efficiently, it is necessary to develop a new
pt
Conflicts of Interest
Acknowledgments
This research was supported by a grant of the Korea Health Technology R&D project
through the Korea Health Industry Development Institute (KHIDI), funded by the Ministry of
9
Korean Cancer Association
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
CANCER RESEARCH AND TREATMENT (CRT)
References
1. Boyd NF, Martin LJ, Yaffe MJ, Minkin S. Mammographic density and breast cancer risk:
2. Astley SM, Harkness EF, Sergeant JC, Warwick J, Stavrinos P, Warren R et al. A
le
3. Bae JM, Kim EH. Breast Density and Risk of Breast Cancer in Asian Women: A Meta-
ic
analysis of Observational Studies. J Prev Med Public Health. 2016;49:367-75.
4. Park B, Cho HM, Lee EH, Song S, Suh M, Choi KS, et al. Does breast density measured
t
Ar
through population-based screening independently increase breast cancer risk in Asian
5. Nyante SJ, Sherman ME, Pfeiffer RM, Berrington de Gonzalez A, Brinton LA, Aiello
ed
Bowles EJ, et al. Prognostic significance of mammographic density change after initiation
Using clinical factors and mammographic breast density to estimate breast cancer risk:
ce
development and validation of a new predictive model. Ann Intern Med. 2008;148:337-47.
7. Trentham-Dietz A, Kerlikowske K, Stout NK, Miglioretti DL, Schechter CB, Ergun MA, et
Ac
al. Tailoring Breast Cancer Screening Intervals by Breast Density and Risk for Women
Aged 50 Years or Older: Collaborative Modeling of Screening Outcomes. Ann Intern Med.
2016;165:700-12.
2015;33:1030-7.
10
Korean Cancer Association
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
CANCER RESEARCH AND TREATMENT (CRT)
9. Boyd NF, Rommens JM, Vogt K, Lee V, Hopper JL, Yaffe MJ, et al. Mammographic breast
and their determinants in women from Japan and Hawaii. Int J Cancer. 2002;102:29-33.
11. Maskarinec G, Pagano I, Chen Z, Nagata C, Gram IT. Ethnic and geographic differences
in mammographic density and their association with breast cancer incidence. Breast
le
Cancer Res. 2007;104:47-56.
12. Mariapun S, Li J, Yip CH, Taib NA, Teo SH. Ethnic and geographic differences in
ic
mammographic density and their association with breast cancer incidence. PLoS One.
t
2015;10:e0117568.
Ar
13. McCormack VA, Perry N, Vinnicombe SJ, Silva Idos S. Ethnic variations in
2008;168:412-21.
14. Habel LA, Capra AM, Oestreicher N, Greendale GA, Cauley JA, Bromberger J, et al.
pt
15. Kim SH, Kim MH, Oh KK. Analysis and comparison of breast density according to age
ce
2000;42:1009-14.
Ac
16. Youn I, Choi S, Kook SH, Choi YJ. Mammographic Breast Density Evaluation in Korean
2016;31:457-62.
17. Sprague BL, Gangnon RE, Burt V, Trentham-Dietz A, Hampton JM, Wellman RD, et al.
Prevalence of mammographically dense breasts in the United States. J Natl Cancer Inst.
2014;106:dju255.
11
Korean Cancer Association
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
CANCER RESEARCH AND TREATMENT (CRT)
18. Dai H, Yan Y, Wang P, Liu P, Cao Y, Xiong L, et al. Distribution of mammographic
density and its influential factors among Chinese women. Int J Epidemiol.
2014;43:1240-51.
19. Jun JK, Kim MJ, Choi KS, Suh M, Jung KW. Development of a sampling strategy and
le
20. American College of Radiology. Breast Imaging Reporting and Data System, 4th ed.
ic
21. Jo HM, Song S, Lee EH, Ko K, Kang BJ, Cha JH, et al. Interpretive volume and inter-
t
radiologist agreement on assessing breast density. J Korean Soc Breast Screening
2018;15:15-22.
Ar
22. Ishihara S, Taira N, Kawasaki K, Ishibe Y, Mizoo T, Nishiyama K, et al. Association
ed
between mammographic breast density and lifestyle in Japanese women. Acta Med
Okayama. 2013;67:145-51.
pt
23. Suh M, Song S, Cho HN, Park B, Jun JK, Choi E, et al. Trends in participation rates for
the National Cancer Screening Program in Korea, 2002-2012. Cancer Res Treat
ce
2017;49:798-806.
24. Lee EH, Kim KW, Kim YJ, Shin DR, Park YM, Lim HS, et al. Performance of screening
Ac
mammography: a report of the Alliance for Breast Cancer Screening in Korea. Korean J
Radiol 2016;17:489-96.
25. Kim YJ, Lee EH, Jun JK, Shin DR, Park YM, Kim HW, et al. Analysis of participant
factors that affect the diagnostic performance of screening mammography: a report of the
26. Are You Dense. Inc. [Internet]. U.S.: Are You Dense Advocary. [cited 2018 Apr 13].
12
Korean Cancer Association
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
CANCER RESEARCH AND TREATMENT (CRT)
27. Lee EH, Park B, Kim NS, Seo HJ, Ko KL, Min JW, et al. The Korean guideline for breast
28. Jung KW, Won YJ, Kong HJ, Lee ES; Community of Population-based Regional Cancer
le
29. Jung KW, Won YJ, Kong HJ, Lee ES. Prediction of cancer incidence and mortality in
t ic
Ar
ed
pt
ce
Ac
13
Korean Cancer Association
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
CANCER RESEARCH AND TREATMENT (CRT)
le
t ic
Fig. 1. Distribution of breast density categories of American College of Radiology (ACS)
Ar
Breast Imaging Reporting and Data System (BI-RADS) by age in Korean women.
ed
pt
ce
Ac
14
Korean Cancer Association
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
CANCER RESEARCH AND TREATMENT (CRT)
le
ic
Fig. 2. Comparison of prevalences of dense breasts between Korean women, Chinese women
t
[18], and U.S. women [17] by age.
Ar
ed
pt
ce
Ac
15
Korean Cancer Association
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
CANCER RESEARCH AND TREATMENT (CRT)
le
1 699 (10.8)
≥2 5,471 (84.4)
Missing 25 (0.4)
Breast feeding (mo)
ic
Never 774 (11.9)
<12 2,128 (32.8)
≥12 3,578 (55.2)
t
Missing 1 (0.0)
Age at menopause (yr)
Premenopausal
<45
Ar 83 (1.3)
259 (4.0)
45-54 3,490 (53.9)
≥55 411 (6.3)
Missing 2,238 (34.5)
ed
16
Korean Cancer Association
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
CANCER RESEARCH AND TREATMENT (CRT)
Table 2. Estimated number of Korean women in each of the ACR BI-RADS breast density categories
Age ACR BI-RADS breast density categorya)
le
group Scattered Dense breastsb)
(yr) Almost entirely fat Heterogeneously dense Extremely dense
fibroglandular densities
ic
40-44 3.09 (1.94 to 4.92) 26.92 (23.16 to 31.17) 82.91 (77.18 to 88.75) 89.36 (83.47 to 95.31) 172.25 (167.82 to 176.21)
45-49 7.57 (5.49 to 10.40) 44.80 (39.62 to 50.47) 102.82 (96.12 to 109.59) 68.91 (62.82 to 75.34) 171.73 (165.79 to 177.24)
50-54 16.83 (14.16 to 19.95) 63.92 (59.18 to 68.84) 83.81 (78.77 to 88.96) 37.20 (33.31 to 41.42) 121.02 (115.87 to 126.04)
t
55-59 41.62 (35.18 to 48.92) 84.54 (76.17 to 93.21) 68.98 (61.01 to 77.48) 16.26 (11.97 to 21.92) 85.26 (76.76 to 94.01)
Ar
60-64 53.35 (47.77 to 59.26) 66.40 (60.46 to 72.51) 36.70 (31.88 to 42.02) 5.02 (3.25 to 7.72) 41.71 (36.62 to 47.25)
65-69 48.66 (42.68 to 54.87) 48.55 (42.60 to 54.72) 19.42 (15.28 to 24.40) 0.85 (0.27 to 2.67) 20.27 (16.05 to 25.32)
70-74 50.40 (45.69 to 55.06) 32.23 (27.95 to 36.82) 12.88 (10.03 to 16.41) 0.69 (0.22 to 2.16) 13.59 (10.64 to 17.17)
75-79 51.22 (46.17 to 56.09) 28.07 (23.63 to 32.93) 8.13 (5.63 to 11.60) 0.88 (0.19 to 3.82) 9.02 (6.31 to 12.72)
≥80 64.13 (54.45 to 73.04) 29.29 (21.67 to 38.37) 11.49 (6.27 to 20.18) N.A. 11.49 (6.27 to 20.18)
ed
40-69c),d) 170.91 (158.76 to 183.82) 335.55 (324.22 to 354.72) 389.95 (397.30 to 405.23) 212.51 (206.38 to 230.84) 608.30 (591.96 to 624.56)
ACR BI-RADS, American College of Radiology Breast Imaging Reporting and Data System; N.A., not available. a)Units: 10,000 women and 95%
confidence intervals, b)Heterogeneously dense or Extremly dense, c)The recommendations by National guidelines for breast cancer screening [ref.
pt
27], d)Estimates may be different from sum of each cells due to rounding, Estimated for data based on 2017 Korean Census counts.
ce
Ac
17
Korean Cancer Association
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
CANCER RESEARCH AND TREATMENT (CRT)
le
t ic
S1 Fig. Comparision of the prevalences of dense breasts according to the health insurance
Ar
status. NHIS, National Health Insurance Survice; MAP, Medical Aid Program.
ed
pt
ce
Ac
18
Korean Cancer Association
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.