Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Background: Fluorescein and indocyanine green (ICG) performed in 45 minutes. It was possible to study dif-
angiography are both useful in the diagnosis and treat- ferences in fluorescein patterns by comparing identi-
ment of many retinal diseases. In some cases, both tests cally timed frames and to find cases in which ICG or fluo-
must be performed for diagnosis and treatment; how- rescein was optimal in visualizing retinal and subretinal
ever, performing both is time-consuming and may re- structures. Confocal optical sections in the depth (z) di-
quire multiple injections. mension allowed viewing in different planes. It was pos-
sible to overlay ICG and fluorescein images or compare
Methods: We designed a compact digital confocal scan- them side-by-side using a linked cursor. Digital trans-
ning laser ophthalmoscope to perform true simulta- mission of the images was also performed.
neous fluorescein and ICG angiography. We report our
experience using the instrument to perform 169 angio- Conclusions: Simultaneous ICG and fluorescein angi-
grams in 117 patients. ography can be performed rapidly, safely, and conve-
niently. The availability of simultaneous angiography will
Results: There were no unexpected adverse effects from allow critical determination of the relative advantages and
mixing the dyes and administering them in 1 injection. disadvantages of both types of angiography.
An entire examination, including fundus photography,
fluorescein angiography, and ICG angiography, could be Arch Ophthalmol. 1998;116:455-463
F
LUORESCEIN angiography is a phy. This has made ICG angiography a
useful tool for the diagnosis useful clinical diagnostic tool, particu-
of many retinal diseases. It larly for imaging of subretinal neovascu-
provides diagnostic as well as lar membranes in cases where such mem-
treatment information by al- branes can not be adequately imaged with
lowing visualization of the retinal and cho- fluorescein angiography.4-8
roidal vasculature. Angiography allows
identification of leakage of the small fluo- For editorial comment
rescein molecule in pathological states.
More recently, indocyanine green (ICG) see page 521
angiography has been developed. This
molecule is larger (molecular weight, 775 Another approach to fluorescence an-
d vs 332 d for fluorescein) and more pro- giography (using either fluorescein or ICG)
tein-bound in plasma than is fluorescein is the scanning laser ophthalmoscope.9 This
and fluoresces in the infrared spectrum. instrument has come into common clini-
Initially, ICG angiography was per- cal practice because of its commercializa-
formed with infrared photographic film. tion in recent years.10 Advantages of the
However, the poor sensitivity of film scanning laser ophthalmoscope include the
coupled with the relatively weak fluores- ability to use an excitation light that scans
cence properties of the dye caused this the retina, allowing more intense excita-
method to be abandoned.1-3 The strong tion (thus providing a stronger emission sig-
binding of ICG dye to plasma proteins re- nal) while still using safe levels of illumi-
sults in slow leakage as compared with nation. This is possible because the
From the Department of fluorescein and reduces the amount of ex- scanning beam illuminates each area point
Ophthalmology, Shiley Eye travascular fluorescence available for im- of the retina for only 0.1 to 0.7 microsec-
Center, University of aging. Digital video cameras have been onds. Scanning laser ophthalmoscope an-
California, San Diego. used to capture images for ICG angiogra- giography gives temporal information that
is richer than still (“digital”) imaging systems because true mark”) injection of ICG dye.5 This instrument was the
video allows imaging at rates of 20 to 30 frames per sec- first completely digital instrument to allow scanning la-
ond. This allows more detail to be seen in the transit phases ser video angiography. Image capture and processing is
and may give better information about patterns of leak- done digitally so that no information is lost at any stage
ing vessels. Furthermore, the illuminating beam is mono- of processing, image manipulation, or transmission.
chromatic and the intensity of fluorescence may be higher Although ICG angiography may be advantageous in
because of the scanning laser ophthalmoscope beam and certain cases of subretinal neovascularization and in di-
the fact that point-by-point illumination is used.10 Stereo- agnosing other disorders,4,5,7 one of its drawbacks is the
scopic imaging is also possible using scanning laser oph- long period of time required for angiography (45 min-
thalmoscope techniques.11 utes) and the need to obtain a second angiogram after a
We recently described the use of a confocal scan- fluorescein angiogram is obtained. The process of ob-
ning laser ophthalmoscope to perform tomographic im- taining a fluorescein and ICG angiogram sequentially is
aging of macular diseases.12 By optically isolating the im- time consuming and requires 2 or 3 (if a landmark in-
age plane to a narrow plane in the depth (z) dimension, jection is used) injections for each patient for comple-
depth information and measurements could be ob- tion of the set of studies. Moreover, the angiograms are
tained. Subsequently, we adapted the scanning laser to- performed at different times, making it difficult to know
mograph to perform ICG angiography.13,14 The instru- if differences in fluorescence leakage patterns are due to
ment allowed better discrimination against out-of-focus differences in properties of the dyes or in the quality of
objects (tomography) and provided higher contrast than the photographs. This may be one reason why different
other systems. The simple optical path and optimized ex- investigators vary in their assessment of the additional
citation and emission detection systems improved the sen- incremental benefit of ICG over fluorescein angiogra-
sitivity of the instrument so that 70% of the photons ex- phy.4,10,14-16 To determine if high-quality simultaneous im-
iting the eye could be detected. This allowed excellent ages from fluorescein and ICG angiograms could be ob-
visualization of vessels in the late stages (45 minutes) of tained, we modified a small, digital, personal computer–
the ICG angiogram without the use of a second (“land- based confocal scanning laser ophthalmoscope to allow
C D
Figure 1. Confocal fluorescein–indocyanine green (ICG) angiogram showing hyperfluoresence and early leakage due to subretinal neovascular membrane at 56.03
seconds. The fluorescein angiogram shows early leakage (A) but the vascular membrane is not well defined. The ICG frame (B) shows a vascular plexus (top of
cursor). The cursors in A and B frames are at the same location on the fundus. Late frames on the fluorescein (C) and ICG (D) angiograms show leakage at 42
minutes 15 seconds. Note that the dark outlines of retinal vessels are clearly seen in the late ICG frame, allowing localization of retinal vascular landmarks without
a second (“landmark”) injection.
simultaneous imaging after a single intravenous injec- tions was performed without problems. A saline solu-
tion of both ICG and fluorescein. We do not advocate tion “flush” injection was not necessary to obtain good
performing simultaneous angiography on every patient; image quality. The time necessary for an entire study was
rather, our goal was to determine whether such angiog- 45 minutes and only 1 injection per patient was needed.
raphy could be performed and to evaluate the character- Red-free color images were also obtained using the green
istics of confocal simultaneous angiography. wavelength of the argon laser. Infared fundus photo-
graphs were obtained using the diode laser. It was not
RESULTS necessary to reinject ICG dye to image retinal vessels in
the late phase of the study. The retinal vessels were vis-
CLINICAL ADVANTAGES ible at the 40-minute time point owing to the sensitivity
of the detector, which allowed visualization of the back-
One hundred sixty-nine angiograms were performed with ground choroidal ICG dye fluorescence. This allowed im-
no serious adverse reactions. Preparation of the dye mix- aging of the retinal vessels as dark linear structures sil-
ture from the 2 commercially available sterile prepara- houetted by this background fluorescence13 (Figure 1).
Figure 2. Confocal fluorescein–indocyanine green (ICG) angiogram in an eye with a choroidal nevus, showing venous laminar phase at 11.42 seconds along the
inferotemporal branch retinal vein. The location of the beginning of the laminar flow is the same in both fluorescein (A) and ICG (B) angiograms and occurs at the
junction of the third small tributary vein from the optic nerve head in the photographs.
TIME COURSE OF APPEARANCE OF BOTH DYES It is interesting that in some cases, feeder vessels can be
seen in ICG and not in fluorescein angiogram frames
Analysis of patients in whom rapid sequences of early (Figure 4).
frames were performed showed that the transit of ICG We found that the ability to view multiple images
and fluorescein to the eye appeared to be simultaneous. or video-rate images provided more information than
This was best seen in the early laminar flow or arterial single frames. A pseudostereo image was possible by slowly
filling phases where arterial filling or localized venous moving the instrument in the horizontal meridian.11 The
laminar flow patterns could be seen. In these cases, the information density included horizontal resolution and
patterns of vascular filling over time appeared to be the a temporal component. During the study, frames were
same with both dyes (Figure 2). We found that it was selectively focused at different planes because of the con-
possible to artificially make either dye appear to fluo- focal nature of the detection system. The ability to pro-
resce earlier by changing the gain settings on the instru- cure images at rapid rates allowed us to select the most
ment. We did not perform absolute calibration of the emit- optimal frame for determining and guiding treatment.
ted light from each point on the fundus. We found that
it was easy to study the differences in fluorescence pat- CONFOCALITY
terns, lesion localization, and leakage patterns using ICG
and fluorescein with the simultaneously acquired im- The use of confocal optics had 2 effects. It allowed im-
ages (Figure 2). aging in a relatively narrow plane of focus and it also in-
creased the contrast considerably. This improved the qual-
CLINICAL UTILITY IN SUBRETINAL ity of the images.13 In addition, the ability to move the
NEOVASCULARIZATION AND OTHER DISEASES plane of focus in depth allowed the physician to discern
the optimal plane of focus for visualizing the pathologi-
The production of true simultaneous images negated the cal structures of interest. As previously described,13 the
possibility that one of the angiograms was of higher qual- higher contrast of this system allowed visualization of the
ity than the other and that this allowed better visualiza- retinal vasculature superimposed on the background ICG
tion of pathological states. The potential reasons that one fluorescence in 40-minute late frames of the ICG angio-
study might be of better quality include better centering grams (Figure 1). In addition, we were able to show the
of the camera image pathway in the pupil, less patient depth location of subretinal neovascular membranes by
movement, better focus, more correct exposure, less blink- scanning at different planes of focus (Figure 5).
ing, and other factors. Using the simultaneous angio-
gram, in some cases ICG showed a subretinal neovascu- REGISTRATION AND COMPARISON
lar membrane better than fluorescein and in other cases OF SIMULTANEOUS IMAGES
fluorescein showed it better than ICG (Figure 3). Only
a larger study can determine the relative sensitivity and We studied 2 methods for comparing the simultaneous
specificity of the 2 techniques. Our review of the images ICG and fluorescein images. Color-coding the images
suggests that both studies are needed in difficult cases. (fluorescein in green and ICG in red) allowed overlay of
C D
Figure 3. Confocal fluorescein–indocyanine green (ICG) angiogram showing an organizing pigment epithelial detachment with underlying subretinal neovascular
membrane seen better on fluorescein then ICG images. Hyperfluoresence and early leakage of dye are seen more impressively at 1 minute 5 seconds on the
fluorescein (A) than ICG (B) frames. Later frames of the fluorescein (C) and ICG (D) studies also show more leakage and dye pooling in the fluorescein study (6
minutes 47 seconds).
the 2 images (Figure 6). We also were able to study the IMAGE STORAGE, TRANSFER, AND RETRIEVAL
2 monochromatic gray-scaled images side by side, elec-
tronically linked with a cursor. The cursor location in The output of the instrument was digital. Thus each im-
the 2 images always corresponded to the identical loca- age entailed 256 3 256 bytes plus 8-bit gray-scale infor-
tion in the fundus. This allowed simultaneous viewing mation at each location. Each location of the fundus was
of a given point on the fundus in both ICG and fluores- imaged twice so that each image pair (ICG and fluores-
cein images (Figure 7). We found this less confusing cein) was approximately 130 kilobytes. The completely
and more precise than the dual-color method. This digital nature of the output allowed storage of all of the
method was possible only because each line of the an- acquired information electronically without any loss of
giogram was scanned both for ICG and fluorescein im- detail. The images could be stored using the software de-
ages in a quasi-simultaneous fashion and correspond- signed for the instrument or could be loaded into any com-
ing points could be determined. There was no image mercially available software on any platform, either PC
manipulation involved in performing this electronic link- or Macintosh. Several selected pairs of images could be
ing between the 2 images. easily transported on a single floppy disk to a second com-
Figure 4. A, Confocal fluorescein–indocyanine green (ICG) angiogram showing hyperfluoresence and early fluorescein leakage in the foveal area at 53.04 seconds.
B, Simultaneous ICG frame shows a feeder vessel perfusing a round subretinal neovascular membrane. C, 32 magnification of (B) shows details of feeder vessel
and subretinal neovascular membrane. In all 3 images the cursors are in precisely the same location because the images are digitally aligned pixel by pixel. The
cursors are linked and correspond to the same location for each simultaneous pair.
A B
C D
Figure 5. Frames from an indocyanine green (ICG) image series showing a subretinal neovascular membrane. The confocal series was taken at varying depths. A,
−6.0 diopters (D); B, −4.0 D; C, −2.5 D; and D, +2.0 D. The subretinal neovascular membrane is seen at the −2.25 D plane as are other choroidal details.
Figure 6. A, Simultaneous fluorescein and indocyanine green (ICG) angiogram frames of a patient with angioid streaks displayed side by side. B, Color-coded
information from both frames in 1 image. Green indicates fluorescein fluorescence and red indicates ICG.
puter in a laser treatment room. We also were able to trans- nose and guide treatment. In general, we performed si-
port images via Internet connections (approximately 5 multaneous angiography in cases in which prior fluo-
seconds per image pair) to remote sites anywhere in the rescein angiography did not or was not expected to reveal
world. Video information was stored on portable hard sufficient information for treatment or diagnosis. A sa-
disk drives and a variety of other media at low cost. At line solution flush injection was not used as high-
our institution, we chose to use Ethernet cable to trans- quality images were obtained without it.
port image pairs at times of approximately 1 second per The ability to perform simultaneous angiography was
ICG/fluorescein pair from the angiography suite to the demonstrated by Bischoff et al,21 who described a pro-
laser suite. totype simultaneous ICG and fluorescein angiogram based
Red-free photographs were also obtained with the on a scanning laser ophthalmoscope. Their instrument
green 514.5-nm channel of the argon laser and infrared pho- differed from the instrument we describe. Their instru-
tographs were procured with the diode laser wavelength. ment acquired true simultaneous images of the fundus
These showed subretinal structures such as drusen more with 2 continuous laser light sources and 2 light detec-
clearly then color or red-free fundus photographs.19 tors. It was a prototype and required the presence of a
These photographic images were not simultaneous complicated computer setup, 2 video recorders, and 2
but were taken at the same magnification and were suit- monitors, filling half a room. The set-up of the instru-
able for performing overlays on angiographic images, as ment in our study switches laser light sources during the
are used in posttreatment assessment in eyes treated for acquisition of a single video line to capture quasi-
subretinal neovascularization.9,20 Infrared fundus pho- simultaneous images (time separation, 0.1 millisec-
tographs could also be performed with the instrument. onds). The light exposure is limited as sources are never
simultaneously active during the scan. In addition, the
COMMENT present instrument allows acquisition of red-free and in-
frared fundus photographs, as well as storing all images
Simultaneous confocal ICG and fluorescein angiogra- digitally so that any image can be recalled or trans-
phy using a confocal scanning laser ophthalmoscope has ported at any time or location without any loss of image
several advantages. Clinically, we noted no serious ad- quality. The use of a PC computer platform allows the
verse reactions in a series of 169 simultaneous ICG/ use of any software system and great flexibility in image
fluorescein injections. The time required to perform the storage and processing. It is important to realize that in-
entire study was considerably shorter than first perform- formation density not only includes horizontal resolu-
ing a fluorescein study, reviewing it, and subsequently tion but also a time component. By shifting planes of fo-
performing the ICG study. In addition, the confocal na- cus and angle of imaging, one can often see better details
ture of the instrument allowed for extremely high con- of the structure of interest and can also choose the indi-
trast in the later images, which allowed visualization of vidual frame that best shows the pathological feature of
retinal vessels at the late time points and obviated the need interest or the one that must be projected to guide laser
for a landmark injection of fluorescein. Thus, simulta- therapy. Other advantages of video imaging include the
neous angiography is beneficial both from the patient’s ability to see moving particles in the fluorescein images;
perspective as well as that of the ophthalmologist’s of- this may enhance the visualization of subretinal neovas-
fice staff; only 1 injection is needed and in 40 minutes cular membranes.22
fundus photography, ICG angiography, and fluorescein There has been some controversy regarding the is-
angiography can be completed and reviewed to diag- sue of transit times of the 2 fluorescent dyes.21,22 We found
D E F
G H
Figure 7. Confocal fluorescein–indocyanine green (ICG) angiogram of a patient with pseudoxanthoma elasticum and angioid streaks. The cursor marks identical
locations on the simultaneous fluorescein (A, C, E, and G) and ICG (B, D, F, and H) frames. All images are in the early phase of the angiogram at 2 minutes 14.82
seconds. A and B, The junction of a retinal artery and the disc margin, beneath which there is hyperfluorescence due to an angioid streak. This is not yet seen on
the ICG frame. C and D, A retinal artery, which is in an identical location on both the fluorescein and ICG frames as marked by the linked cursor. E and F, The
cursor moved again, this time to a circumferential area of hyperfluoresence seen on both the fluorescein and ICG frames corresponding to an angioid streak. In
operation, moving the cursor on one frame moves it on the other, allowing precise identification of corresponding areas on simultaneous ICG and fluorescein
frames. G and H, The late fluorescein images6 and ICG14; the angioid streaks are much more visible on the ICG image, as is the reticulated appearance of Bruch
membrane.
both dyes arrived simultaneously in the early phase of We found that it was easy to study the differences
our study. There is no reason for the dyes to arrive at dif- in fluorescence patterns and lesion localization using ICG
ferent time points.23,24 When the relative gains of our de- and fluorescein with the simultaneously acquired im-
tectors were equal, there was no evidence that one of the ages. We preferred the linked cursor software mode to
dyes transited faster than the other. critically and simultaneously compare locations of the