Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PRACTICE
Practice tip
Sphygmomanometer
calibration
Why, how and how often?
Martin J Turner
BACKGROUND
BSc(Eng), MSc(Eng), PhD, is
Hypertension is the most commonly managed problem in general practice. Systematic errors in blood pressure
Senior Research Asssociate,
Departments of Anaesthetics measurements caused by inadequate sphygmomanometer calibration are a common cause of over- and under-
and School of Public Health identification of hypertension.
Screening and Test Evaluation
Programme, University of OBJECTIVE
Sydney, New South Wales. This article reviews sphygmomanometer error and makes recommendations regarding in service maintenance and
mjturner@usyd.edu.au calibration of sphygmomanometers.
Catherine Speechly DISCUSSION
BMedSc, MBBS, FRACGP, is Most sphygmomanometer surveys report high rates of inadequate calibration and other faults, particularly in aneroid
Research Officer, Projects, sphygmomanometers. Automatic electronic sphygmomanometers produce systematic errors in some patients. All
Research and Development
Unit, The Royal Australian sphygmomanometers should be checked and calibrated by an accredited laboratory at least annually. Aneroid
College of General sphygmomanometers should be calibrated every 6 months. Only properly validated automatic sphygmomanometers
Practitioners, New South should be used. Practices should perform regular in house checks of sphygmomanometers. Good sphygmomanometer
Wales. maintenance and traceable sphygmomanometer calibration will contribute to reducing the burden of cardiovascular
Noel Bignell disease and the number of patients overtreated for hypertension in Australia.
PhD(Physics), is Manager,
Mass Quantities and Acoustics,
National Measurement
Institute, New South Wales. Hypertension is the most commonly managed problem errors is to use the correct measurement technique and
in general practice, accounting for 8.6% of encounters well maintained and calibrated instruments.
and 7.9% of prescriptions.1 However, just under half the
cases in Australia are untreated.1 Frequent consequences
Hypertension detection and systematic errors
of hypertension are stroke and cardiovascular disease, The detection of hypertension is extremely sensitive to
which caused 38% of all deaths in Australia in 2002.2 systematic errors in BP measurements. Figure 1 shows
Hypertension in its early stages can be diagnosed only that a consistent 5 mmHg error can more than double
by measurement of blood pressure (BP). or halve the number of patients diagnosed with diastolic
hypertension. Further analysis of data from the same survey3
All measurements are contaminated by errors that may be allows the effects of any systematic error on the detection
divided into two types: of diastolic and systolic hypertension to be estimated.4
• random errors are different on every occasion and can A consistent 5 mmHg error in systolic pressure can
be reduced by averaging a number of measurements result in systolic hypertension being underdiagnosed by
(random variation caused by biological variability is 30% or overdiagnosed by 43%.4 The current Australian
usually indistinguishable from random measurement Sphygmomanometer Standard allows systematic errors up
error and is also reduced by averaging), and to approximately ±4 mmHg in new sphygmomanometers.5
• systematic errors, which have approximately the
Sphygmomanometers
same value on every occasion and are not reduced
by averaging. Mercury and aneroid sphygmomanometers
Inadequate sphygmomanometer maintenance and Studies of calibration errors of mercury and aneroid
calibration is a common cause of systematic error sphygmomanometers in Australia6–8 have been limited
in BP measurements. Systematic errors are difficult to and lacking in quality, but do suggest that all is not well.
detect and correct. The only way to reduce systematic Several studies indicate that substantial proportions of
834 Reprinted from Australian Family Physician Vol. 36, No. 10, October 2007
Sphygmomanometer calibration – why, how and how often? CLINICAL PRACTICE
sphygmomanometers in general practices with every patient before readings are used to several consultations and the potential costs of
and hospitals exhibit clinically significant diagnose or manage hypertension.21 the additional visits and the adverse effects of
(>3 mmHg) systematic pressure errors and incorrect treatment of a number of patients have
Nonautomatic electronic sphygmomanometers
other faults. 9–12 Some guidelines implicitly to be weighed up against the cost of calibration.
assume that mercury sphygmomanometers The anticipated demise of the mercur y There may also be medicolegal consequences
never require calibration. 13 While aneroid sphygmomanometer has prompted the of not calibrating sphygmomanometers at
sphygmomanometers fare worse than mercury development of electronic pressure indicators appropriate intervals.22 The calibration interval
instruments, many studies have found significant that can be used with manual auscultation also depends on the robustness of the
errors in mercury sphygmomanometers.9,10,12 of the Korotkov sounds. These ‘hybrid’ instrument and the conditions under which it
Rouse and Marshall 14 found that nearly 100 sphygmomanometers are available with is used. If an instrument proves to be stable
of 1462 sphygmomanometers were in such segmented displays that mimic the linear after several calibration cycles it is possible to
poor condition that their tester suggested and circular scales of mercury and aneroid increase the calibration interval with caution
they be withdrawn from ser vice, and manometers. Some versions, which have buttons and due consideration of the risks of erroneous
Knight et al 10 found that none of the 472 that the operator presses at the systolic and measurements. Conversely, if large calibration
sphygmomanometers they tested complied diastolic pressure points, should reduce some errors are found, the interval should be reduced
fully with the British Sphygmomanometer operator dependent errors such as terminal digit or the instrument replaced.
S t a n d a r d c u r r e n t i n 2 0 01. A n e r o i d preference.21
Recommended test and calibration
sphygmomanometers provided as promotional
Maintenance and calibration of methods
gifts by pharmaceutical companies have been
sphygmomanometers
shown to be less accurate than others12 and Formal calibration of the pressure indicator
should be avoided. All sphygmomanometers sold in Australia • T h e p r e s s u r e i n d i c a t o r s o f a l l
are required to comply with the Australian sphygmomanometers should be calibrated
Automatic oscillometric sphygmomanometers
Standard AS EN 1060 2002 Noninvasive by a laboratory accredited by the National
Most automatic oscillometric Sphygmomanometers Parts 1, 2 and 35 at the Association of Testing Authorities (NATA) to
sphygmomanometers measure cuff pressure time of sale. Although these standards are calibrate pressure gauges or transducers
electronically and use proprietary algorithms primarily intended for assessing and licensing over the range 0–40 kPa (0–300 mmHg).
to estimate systolic and diastolic pressures new instruments, they do contain limited NATA publishes searchable lists of calibration
by analysing the pulsations in cuff pressure as performance and quality clauses against laboratories on its website (www.nata.com.
the cuff deflates or inflates. Systematic errors which sphygmomanometers in service can be au). Use the keyword 'pressure' to search
can be caused by both lack of calibration of assessed and calibrated. the measurement science and technology
the electronic pressure sensing system and field of testing for a laboratory. The least
How often should sphygmomanometers be
by the algorithm that estimates diastolic and uncertainty of measurement included in the
checked and calibrated?
systolic pressures. Because the algorithms are scope of each laboratory is the best accuracy
confidential and differ between instruments, There are three criteria to consider when selecting that laboratory can offer. Look for a least
protocols have been developed to validate a calibration interval: uncertainty of measurement of 0.05 kPa
oscillometric sphygmomanometers against • the probability that the sphygmomanometer (0.4 mmHg) or less.
manual auscultatory measurements. 15,16 The will go out of calibration to a clinically • The laborator y should be requested
dabl Educational Trust (www.dableducational. significant extent between calibrations to calibrate the indicator from zero
com) assesses each validation report and makes • the consequences of discovering that to the maximum pressure on the
recommendations according to the results and a sphygmomanometer has a clinically sphygmomanometer scale at pressure
quality of the validations.16 Sphygmomanometers significant calibration error increments not greater than 6 kPa
can pass validation tests despite producing • the cost of calibration. (50 mmHg).
clinically significant errors that can be If a clinician is notified by a medical testing • Calibration intervals should not be greater
greater than 15 mmHg in some individuals.17 laboratory of systematic errors in cholesterol test than those indicated in Table 1.
Oscillometric sphygmomanometers perform results, he/she would advise patients to have the
Performance and condition
poorly in pregnant women, 18 diabetics 19 and measurement repeated. Similarly, if a clinically
in patients with stiff arteries,20 but the causes significant BP error is discovered, the clinician The general condition of sphygmomanometers
of systematic errors are not well understood. is ethically bound to recall all patients whose and compliance with the other in service
For these reasons the American Heart BP was measured since the previous calibration clauses of the current sphygmomanometer
Association recommends that each oscillometric when the sphygmomanometer was known standard should be checked annually by an
sphygmomanometer should be validated for use to be accurate. A BP determination involves experienced technician. Formal records of the
Reprinted from Australian Family Physician Vol. 36, No. 10, October 2007 835
CLINICAL PRACTICE Sphygmomanometer calibration – why, how and how often?
40
A calibration certificate endorsed with the NATA
Accurate, 8% hypertensive logo should be obtained from the calibration
30
laboratory. If the pressure indicator of the
20 16 Under-reads by 5 mmHg, sphygmomanometer is not adjustable (eg. most
10 3% hypertensive
10
5
mercury and aneroid sphygmomanometers)
2 1
0 then the calibration certificate should include
< 80 80–84 85–89 90–94 95–99 >100 a table containing corrections that should be
Diastolic BP (mmHg) added to indicated values to obtain the correct
measurement, for both rising and falling pressures.
Figure 1. The distribution of diastolic BP in the Canadian population in 1986–19903 demonstrates how
systematic errors can affect the detection of hypertension. A clinician whose sphygmomanometer is accurate In a busy practice where it may not be practicable
would find that 8% of the population has DBP >90 mmHg. If the sphygmomanometer consistently over-reads to add corrections to every BP measurement,
by 5 mmHg then patients whose DBP is 85 mmHg would appear to have a DBP of 90 mmHg, so the clinician
would find that 18% of the population has DBP >90 mmHg. If the sphygmomanometer under-reads by 5 nonadjustable sphygmomanometers that have
mmHg then patients whose DBP is 95 mmHg would appear to have a DBP of 90 mmHg, so the clinician would
find that only 3% of the population has DBP >90 mmHg corrections larger than 3 mmHg should be repaired
or replaced.
outcomes of these assessments should be sphygmomanometer bulb If the instrument is adjustable (eg. some
kept. At the time of writing we are not aware of • with the valve open check that the reference electronic sphygmomanometers) then the
any facilities that offer these tests commercially manometer displays zero and record the laboratory can be requested to adjust the
in Australia, but they should become more pressure indicated by the sphygmomanometer instrument to minimise the errors over
readily available as demand increases. Aspects • increase the pressure to approximately a particular pressure range. In this case it is
that should be tested include: 200 mmHg and deflate slowly, stopping common to request both before and after
• air leakage when the reference manometer indicates calibration correction tables.
• rapid exhaust time approximately 100 mmHg Recent evidence suggests that systematic
• the condition of cuff, tubes, bulb and fittings • record and compare the pressures indicated errors of 3 mmHg probably result in clinically
• scale visibility on the reference manometer and on the significant over- and under-detection of
• contamination of the glass tube or mercury sphygmomanometer hypertension.4 Therefore, we recommend that
• cuff inflation and deflation control • open the valve so the pressure decreases where possible the error of the pressure indicator
• security of mercury containment. to zero over 2–3 seconds and check that the should be 1 mmHg or less. Good quality mercury
reference manometer displays zero pressure and electronic pressure indicators should be
In house checks of the pressure indicator
• record the pressure indicated by the capable of achieving this performance.
To detect clinically significant calibration errors sphygmomanometer
Oscillometric sphygmomanometers
between formal calibrations and minimise the Formal records should be kept of these checks
consequences of erroneous measurements, it (eg. in a notebook). The reference manometer Some validations of oscillometric
is useful to carry out regular in house checks of should be locked away when not used for internal sphygmomanometers are poorly performed
the pressure indicator.
Practices should maintain a reference Table 1. Recommended calibration and check intervals for mercury, aneroid and
manometer (preferably a good qualit y electronic sphygmomanometers
electronic instrument) that is not used for daily
Type of instrument Calibration Check
measurements but against which all in service
interval interval
sphygmomanometers are checked at two (months) (months)
pressures (eg. 0 and 100 mmHg) regularly in
Mercury sphygmomanometers that are permanently fixed 36 6
the practice: to an immovable object
• if the sphygmomanometer is electronic set it Portable mercury sphygmomanometers 12 6
to a mode in which pressure is continuously Aneroid sphygmomanometers used in a consulting room 6 1
displayed Aneroid sphygmomanometers carried around daily 6 0.5
• using Y-connectors and leak free tubing Electronic oscillometric sphygmomanometers 12 6
connect the reference manometer to the Electronic manual sphygmomanometers 12 6
sphygmomanometer pressure inlet and a
836 Reprinted from Australian Family Physician Vol. 36, No. 10, October 2007
Sphygmomanometer calibration – why, how and how often? CLINICAL PRACTICE
Reprinted from Australian Family Physician Vol. 36, No. 10, October 2007 837