You are on page 1of 4

No.

55 April 2008

GENI Z A H F R AGM EN T S
The Newsletter of Cambridge University’s Taylor-Schechter Genizah Research Unit at Cambridge University Library

Friedberg £1m for online archive


Some thirteen years ago – the FGP’s Jerusalem
several generations in digi- offices on a monthly basis
tal terms – Dr Douglas De over the next three years.
Lacy, then Research Assis- The end result will be an
tant in the T-S Genizah archive exceeding 312,000
Unit, wrote that “recent high-quality, life-size im-
developments in informa- ages, depicting every leaf,
tion technology, particu- every fragment and every
larly the World-Wide Web, scrap from Cambridge’s T-
mean that the potential is S Collection, as well as
unlimited. My dream is of those items from the
a Web page containing full Library’s Oriental and
catalogues and bibliogra- Additional Collections that
phies, texts and images of are also thought to have
all the [Genizah] docu- emerged from the Ben
ments. Imagine the possi- Ezra Synagogue.
bilities!” (Genizah Fragments Once the FGP has mount-
30, 1995). ed Cambridge’s images
Others have shared this online, together with those
vision, and in recent years Genizah fragments being digitised at the University Library of the other digitised col-
the Friedberg Genizah lections, it will be possible
Project (FGP) has led the manuscripts themselves Cambridge University for the researcher to call up
way towards the achieve- and placing all of the Library – through its digi- a picture of any fragment;
ment of this ambitious goal. images online. tisation project (30,000 to compare it to similar
The world of Genizah A substantial number of images) funded by the Arts fragments in other collec-
research has already been the world’s Genizah manu- and Humanities Research tions; and, by these means,
revolutionised by the Pro- scripts have now been pho- Council – and the FGP, eventually to complete the
ject, founded and financed tographed by the FGP and mean that this ambitious dreamed-of task of piecing
by the Canadian business- are being made available project is now a realistic together the myriad manu-
man, Albert D. Friedberg, through its web portal one. scripts that have, until now,
with many programmes of (http://www.genizah.org/). The Genizah Unit is been scattered in libraries,
cataloguing, description But, until now, the mass therefore pleased to universities and collections
and publication in various digitisation of Cambridge’s announce that the Project around the globe.
Genizah collections around almost 200,000 manuscript will be providing funding The world of Genizah
the world under its belt. fragments was seen as an of over £1 million to digi- research will never be the
Most recently, however, impossible dream, with tise the remaining manu- same again, and we shall
Rabbi Reuven Rubelow, one early estimate suggest- scripts in the T-S Genizah all owe a great debt of grat-
who manages the FGP for ing that the task would Collection. itude to Albert D. Fried-
Mr Friedberg, and Profes- take 27 years! This intensive work will berg and the FGP for this
sor Yaacov Choueka, the Recent advances in digi- be carried out by the stunning achievement.
Project’s head of comput- tal imaging technology, Library’s Imaging Services BEN OUTHWAITE
erisation, have set their coupled with the valuable Department, and the Head of Genizah
sights on digitising the experience gained by both images will be delivered to Research Unit

Gifts to T-S Unit


The T-S Research Unit Victoria J. Elenowitz; £500
gratefully acknowledges the from Cyril and Betty Stein;
continued valuable sup- £500 from Mark Goldberg;
port of the Friedberg £300 from the Manifold
Genizah Project, which will Trust; £250 from the Sidney
amount to more than $20,000 through Danny to further liturgical research and Elizabeth Corob
£50,000 this academic year. Gershon from the estate of in the Genizah. Charitable Trust; £200
Major funding has also his aunt, Miriam Wieder, We are also grateful for a from the F. & D. Worms
been received from the in memory of the renown- generous benefaction of Charitable Trust; $250 from
Arts and Humanities ed scholar Professor £1,000, arranged by Philip J. C. Weber; £100 from Jack
Research Council towards Naphtali Wieder, of Jews’ Maurice from the estate of Lunzer; and smaller or
the ongoing projects of College and Bar-Ilan Muriel Turk. anonymous gifts.
description and digitisa- University. In keeping with Other substantial assis- The continued support of
tion. Professor Wieder’s inter- tance in recent months our many friends is much
The Unit has received ests, the sum will be used includes $2,000 from appreciated.

ON OTHER PAGES: Cradle to grave – 2; Ultimate dream – 3; Cairo celebrates – 4


2 Genizah Fragments

From cradle to grave


Within the framework of a joint tions of faith and theology, orous conservation standards, the
project between the JTS- responsa in the Genizah frag- support provided by the conser-
Schocken Institute for Jewish ments and other manuscripts vation department has consider-
Research in Jerusalem and the have had their say. ably improved my research.
Taylor-Schechter Genizah Re- Although we are enamoured with In the hands of Nagio Vince-
search Unit, I was invited to responsa literature’s potential for Dewerse, one of the Library’s
spend a six-month sabbatical at future research, the sober question conservation experts, ancient
Cambridge aimed at preparing a remains: how to provide superior fragments are renewed, faded
catalogue devoted exclusively to access to this material and to handwriting becomes legible, and
responsa literature in the describe its contents for a new gen- anaemic paper and parchment
Cambridge Hebrew manuscript eration of students and scholars. A restored to life. To touch a deli-
collections. fundamental obstacle for investi- cate and ancient manuscript from
Responsa (shutim, a Hebrew gating responsa has been our igno- the erstwhile Genizah is to make
abbreviation meaning “questions rance regarding which Genizah contact, physically and intellectu-
and answers”) span some 1,200 fragments contain responsa and ally, with the rich and diverse Mosseri V.199.2 after
years. The quantity of the materi- what their subject matter is. Jewish culture of the Middle Ages conservation
al is beyond our imagination: To solve this problem, the joint and beyond.
responsa filled communal and project will prepare a detailed, Although the study of responsa acceptable [in other words, Reuven
educational needs by providing descriptive catalogue devoted to offers fertile ground for Jewish retains his legal status to litigate the
answers from eminent rabbis and the numerous responsa in the law and historical research, some- debt with Levi].
Hebrew manuscript collections times a hand-copied responsum There is nothing unusual about
housed at Cambridge. In addition, can contribute unexpectedly to this case as it appears in the
for the first time in a catalogue of other disciplines. For example, Talmud and rabbinic literature in
this nature, it will provide tran- MS V.199.2 from the Mosseri col- various contexts (cf. Ketubot 92b,
scriptions of responsa that have yet lection, which at first glance Baba Qama 8b and Baba Mezia
to be published, with each entry resembles a standard responsum, 14a). What is unusual are the
supplemented by biographical and enables us to observe more about extraneous writings surrounding
bibliographical information. the copying methods of an anony- the text of this so-called “ques-
Thus far, I have examined frag- mous scribe than about an tion and answer.”
ments and manuscripts from the author’s response. We find three lines of short
Mosseri and Taylor-Schechter This fragment, probably from aphorisms, followed by partial
collections and from other select- Egypt and copied in a Sephardic words representing practice pen-
ed manuscripts in the libraries of (circa fifteenth-century) hand, strokes. Moreover, the scribe
Cambridge University and offers the contents of an abbrevi- wrote an unusual expression,
Westminster College. ated responsum: lamelech leshoni (perhaps a cor-
To date, more than five hundred A question where Reuven sold ruption of lamed leshoni, “study
and eighty responsa from the Shimon a field with a guarantee language,” or “study writing”).
tenth-eleventh to the nineteenth [the text reads be’achrayut, literal- The bottom line reads, tam ven-
centuries have been documented. ly “with responsibility,” a legal ishlam (“completed”), a conclud-
Only forty per cent from the clas- instrument protecting the purchaser ing formula popular among copy-
sical Genizah period (the tenth to against any liens on the property]. ists for completing a codex, but
the thirteenth centuries) has, A third party, Levi [Reuven’s cred- not appropriate – nor in the cor-
Mosseri V.199.2 before however, been transcribed and itor], seizes the field from Shimon. rect textual position – for the end
conservation published, and material from the The answer follows: the law is of an individual responsum. It is
thirteenth century onwards has that Reuven can argue the case with more than likely, therefore, that
judges (as well as lesser-known barely been touched. Levi. Levi cannot counter “as the we are looking not at an authored
personalities) to official questions Working with fragments from land is no longer yours, you are not “question and answer,” but at a
sent on behalf of Jewish commu- the Mosseri collection has been my legal opponent in this manner,” case-study illustrating the art of
nities and to private queries. an extraordinary experience. because Reuven’s response, “if [the responsum writing.
From the end of the nineteenth Although much of the material field is] seized from Shimon, it SHMUEL GLICK
century, scholars began to recog- has still to meet Cambridge’s rig- comes back to me,” is considered Head of JTS-Schocken Institute
nise that responsa literature was a
vital and novel resource for his-
torical research. While studying
fragments of such material, one
travels through a time-tunnel of
Jewish history uncovering the
rich and hidden facets of private
and public Jewish medieval life.
Discovering the secrets
During my second year of doc- dealt closely with Genizah which a letter was written. This
From the cradle to the grave, toral research, I started working sources for many years. and many other philological phe-
responsa vividly describe domes- as an assistant in the Taylor- These insights helped me enor- nomena that distinctly mark the
tic affairs reflecting human mer- Schechter Genizah Unit for one mously in my research into lan- letters from the different cen-
its, convictions and flaws. Certain day a week. I expected that the guage change within Judaeo- turies were collected and analysed
responsa contain vivid accounts additional workload, although in Arabic letter-writing. I observed, in my thesis.
of household intrigue, infidelity, many respects associated with my for example, a fascinating phe- And so there was a happy end-
solemn oaths, and sibling rivalry. research, would slow down the nomenon related to the verb “to ing for me. I finished writing my
As legal missives, the contents completion of my thesis. In the send.” thesis (A Linguistic Analysis of
reveal how rabbinic and secular event, the opposite proved true. The eleventh-century writers Judaeo-Arabic Letters from the
leaders maintained community Through steady contact with used the word nafada to denote Cairo Genizah) within the regular
stability and personal harmony the manuscripts and constant “sending,” while those in the fol- time-frame of three years – not
during times of daily stress. Our interaction with my colleagues, I lowing two centuries employed least thanks to the help I received
basic knowledge of private and developed a keener sense of the the term sayyara. From the fif- from my Genizah colleagues –
institutionalised education like- Genizah material than I would teenth century onwards, “to and I am happy to work now in
wise stems from responsa docu- otherwise have done, discovering send” was expressed by arsala. the T-S Unit as a Research
ments. From the prosaic issue of a many of the “secrets” and details The verb can thus act as a shib- Associate.
tutor’s salary to burning ques- accessible only to those who have boleth for assessing the period in ESTHER-MIRIAM WAGNER
Visit our Web pages at http://www.lib.cam.ac.uk/Taylor-Schechter
Genizah Fragments 3

The ultimate dream


A sabbatical in Cambridge is the original fragments, studying the
ultimate dream of every Genizah “suspect” pieces together, and
scholar. Having spent the past checking whether they join or if T-S AS 159.247, a
five years studying the Genizah the handwriting matches. Genizah manuscript
magical fragments (see my brief In this way, I am seeking to recently discovered
report in Genizah Fragments 49) improve my understanding of by Dr Bohak
and reading them from hazy their contents, especially in areas containing an
microfilm copies, I cherished the – such as alchemy or astrology – unidentified Indian
opportunity to work with the where my familiarity with the language
original documents. sources is insufficient to identify
With sabbatical funding from or classify a fragment accurately. known, in its Latin version, as ments exist. But a more careful
Tel Aviv University, and addi- To that end, I have sought the Ps.-Aristotle, On Stones. reading convinced me that it was
tional assistance – through the advice of experts on the medieval Once again, the identification of a Christian hagiographic work.
Genizah Research Unit – from Muslim scientific tradition and a fragment in its original Arabic After a quick search for all the
the John S. Cohen Foundation have learned much in the process. text (written, of course, in Saint Johns of early Christianity,
and the Friedberg Genizah On one occasion, I showed some Hebrew letters) made an impor- the fragment – soon be published
Project, I have been enabled to of the Judaeo-Arabic fragments tant contribution to the study of by Dr Friedrich Niessen and
bring my family to Cambridge for to Professor Charles Burnett, of medieval alchemy. And as this is myself – turned out to be the Life
an entire year, during which I the Warburg Institute, who iden- but one of many alchemical frag- of St. John of the Golden Gospel, a
plan to catalogue all the magical, tified a particular text (T-S Ar. ments in the Genizah, I have little work which enjoyed some popu-
astrological, divinatory and 29.51 and Ar. 30.91) as a copy of doubt that many similar discover- larity in Christian Egypt but
alchemical fragments in the Thabit ben Qurra’s On Talismans, ies are bound to follow. whose presence in the Cairo
Cambridge Genizah collections. of which two medieval Latin The greatest joy, however, Genizah, in a Judaeo-Arabic ver-
I have so far identified more translations are known but whose comes from unexpected frag- sion copied on parchment by an
than 200 new fragments, most of original Arabic text no longer ments, those about which even an experienced scribe, came as
them relatively small and exists. The Judaeo-Arabic version experienced Genizah scholar has something of a surprise.
insignificant, but some large and of this important text would be a never heard. Surveying the Genizah frag-
important enough to be worthy of most welcome addition to the On one of my first days at ments is a little like gold-mining,
further study. study of Thabit’s works and of Cambridge, I was staring at a since one knows what one is look-
I have also endeavoured to find the transmission of Muslim talis- well-preserved bifolium (T-S ing for, but is never sure what one
partnerships between separate manic lore. 10K9.2) containing the last three will find. And it is as addictive as
fragments which once formed a On another occasion, Bink pages of a book entitled Kitab gambling, since one spends fruit-
single page or single quire. This Hallum – who is writing a doctor- Yuhana. My first thought was less hours in the hope that the
task is difficult when working al thesis (under Burnett’s super- that this might be an Arabic ver- next attempt will produce a really
directly from microfilm, or vision) on the Arabic alchemical sion of the Book of Jannes and spectacular result.
microfilm-prints, but becomes texts known as Zosimus – identi- Jambres, a Judaeo-Greek compo- GIDEON BOHAK
much simpler when handling the fied T-S Ar. 43.267 as a text sition of which only tiny frag- Tel Aviv University

Variations in the Haggadah text


At this time of the year, most on God’s relationship with Israel also include instructions in tury land of Israel still included
Jewish families celebrate the first and his gift of the festival. Judaeo-Arabic to guide the one it, though in a different form, as
evening of Passover by recalling In a number of Genizah texts leading the seder (T-S H2.112). recorded in Genizah text T-S
the biblical story of their ances- (for example, T-S H2.124), it also Most intriguing of all is the mah H2.152: “On normal nights, we
tors’ exodus from Egypt at a contains a lengthy piece with nishtanah passage traditionally eat meat that is either roasted,
domestic service called the seder detailed and poetic remarks about recited by the youngest partici- stewed or boiled; but tonight we
(“order”), by way of a narrative the historical origins of the festive pant. From the early Middle used to eat, in the Temple, only
entitled the haggadah (“recital”). day, including the sentence “on Ages, this has consisted of four roast:  
 
This has, from at least the earliest that day he brought his servants questions about the matzah .   
rabbinic times, been a popular out of the iron furnace and res- (unleavened bread), the sharp- The custom of eating roast lamb
ritual, and it is therefore hardly cued us” (       tasting vegetables, the two had apparently continued in some
surprising to find many relevant   
 ). The instances of dipping one item into communities in post-talmudic
texts from the Genizah. custom is noted but not forbidden another before eating it, and the times, but those responsible for
What may be surprising for by Sa‘adya Gaon in his prayer- custom of reclining at the table. this amendment had evidently
those thoroughly familiar with book (pages 141–2). The passage is recorded in the ceased the practice and consid-
the version as handed down in Equally interesting is the addi- Mishnah (Pesahim . 10.4) and dates ered the question illogical. They
printed haggadah editions, and as tion at the conclusion of the qid- from at least the first century. Its could not, however, bring them-
chanted at the table through the dush not only of the blessing earliest form probably referred to selves to eliminate it completely.
generations, is that there are some thanking God for our survival only three topics: the dipping, the Most of the Genizah versions
remarkable variations between until this festival ( ), but matzah and the roast meat, are noted by the Babylonian
what came to be standard from also of the one used on Hanukkah the last-mentioned referring to geonic authorities as customs
about the twelfth century and and Purim, which offers grati- the consumption of part of the (often followed in the Jewish
what circulated in and around tude for the miracles divinely paschal lamb just sacrificed in the homeland) that should be discon-
Egypt and the land of Israel in the performed for us (  Temple. Order and content then tinued. Their view prevailed in
period immediately beforehand, ), as in T-S H2.124, 152. gradually underwent change. practical liturgy, but the Genizah
as documented in Genizah texts. While the Exodus story is tradi- Obviously, at some stage, the texts have preserved the evidence.
The qiddush toasts the festival tionally recited in Hebrew, there inclusion of this question about STEFAN C. REIF
over a glass of wine and intro- are Genizah texts in which parts the roast lamb became dubious, Emeritus Professor of Medieval
duces the proceedings. Its simple of it appear in Aramaic (T-S because it was no longer relevant. Hebrew; Project Consultant,
and standard format concentrates H2.152). Many Genizah texts But some Jews in the tenth-cen- Cambridge University Library
Visit our Web pages at http://www.lib.cam.ac.uk/Taylor-Schechter
4 Genizah Fragments

Cairo goes back to future How you


Medieval Fustat’s Ben Ezra
Synagogue, the depository of
many of the Genizah manuscripts
a testimony to the major discover-
ies made through manuscripts
amassed over a period of one
can help
now housed at Cambridge thousand years, and analysed by IF YOU would like to re-
University Library, was one of the scholars over many decades. ceive Genizah Fragments
venues for internationally spon- “Through the scholarly study regularly, to inquire about
sored celebrations arranged over of these testimonies to early the Taylor-Schechter Geni-
several days last autumn by Cairo’s medieval Jewish life, it has zah Collection, or to learn
small but lively Jewish community. become possible to reconstruct how you may assist with
Representatives of several em- social, economic, religious and its preservation and study,
bassies, Government officials, civic cultural developments in the east- please write to Dr Ben
and Jewish leaders, scholars and ern Mediterranean. Active Outhwaite, Head of the
native Cairenes – many now resi- research projects at Cambridge Taylor-Schechter Genizah
dent in Israel, France, Britain and and elsewhere, some now sup- Research Unit, at Cam-
the United States – marked the ported by the Friedberg Genizah bridge University Library,
Sign at the entrance to the West Road, Cambridge
centenary of the city’s Adly Street Ben Ezra exhibition Project, are continuing to uncov-
Synagogue and the completion of er fascinating data and, if funds CB3 9DR, England.
its handsome restoration. is now one of the capital’s fore- can be raised, all the manuscripts THE LIBRARY may also be
Welcomed by Carmen Wein- most tourist attractions. On will soon be available online by reached by fax (01223)
stein, the community’s president, Carmen Weinstein’s initiative, a way of digitised images.” 333160 or by telephone
the guests were entertained by a permanent exhibition centre has Those manuscripts, Professor (01223) 333000. The inter-
choir from Thessaloniki, Greece, been opened in an annex, with the Reif added, included the Mosseri net access is at http://
who performed Jewish music, and co-operation of Professor Stefan Genizah Collection, some 7,000 www.lib.cam.ac.uk/Taylor-
by the Egyptian baritone, Gaber Reif, former director of the Taylor- fragments acquired by a well- Schechter. Inquiries by e-
El Beltagui, who sang an ode Schechter Unit at Cambridge, known Cairo family, which were mail should be addressed
to peace in French, English, and London architect Michael currently being conserved, to genizah@lib.cam.ac.uk.
Hebrew and Russian. The Mallinson. described, digitised and made
American Ambassador, Francis Representing – with his wife, available in Cambridge, a process ALL CONTRIBUTIONS to
Ricciardone, headed the panoply Shulie – the Unit, the University that had attracted major financial the Unit, whether for re-
of distinguished speakers. and the Library at the celebra- support. search or other activities,
One of the days was devoted to tions, Professor Reif addressed a Among the activities during the are made to the “Univer-
the Cairo Genizah, the contents large audience on the history of celebrations were visits to the sity of Cambridge,” which
of which were revealed in the the synagogue and its world- city’s synagogues, now mostly enjoys charitable status for
nineteenth century and brought renowned manuscripts. unused but still preserved intact tax and similar purposes.
to various centres of scholarship It was, he said, a superb idea to and carefully guarded. The events
in Europe and the United States link the treasures once again with were sponsored by the Cairo IN THE USA, “Cambridge
– some seventy per cent, through the Ben Ezra Synagogue, and Jewish community, Spain’s Casa in America” supports the
Solomon Schechter, to Cam- with Cairo, through a set of fac- Sefarad Israel, Association Nebi Taylor-Schechter Collec-
bridge. similes and explanatory panels, Daniel of France, and the Joint tion with its unfunded
The Ben Ezra Synagogue has and it was the organisers’ hope Distribution Committee in the grant number 7/78. Please
been magnificently restored and that the exhibition would serve as United States. contact the Director of the
Annual Appeal at 100
Avenue of the Americas,
New York, NY 10013-0271
(tel: 212-984-0960).

On merchants and medics “CAMBRIDGE in America”


is recognised by the IRS as
a charitable organisation,
and contributions for the
Two important volumes of Although Goitein gave tastes of considering that it builds in great benefit of the Genizah
Genizah research have recently the work to come among his many part on the work done during Research Unit are legally
been published by Brill of articles and books, most notably Lev’s sojourn in Cambridge just a deductible for USA income
Leiden. The anticipation for the in his Letters of Medieval Jewish few years ago. tax purposes. Contribu-
first, S. D. Goitein and Traders (Princeton, 1973), on his Another hefty volume, it exam- tions are similarly deduc-
Mordechai Akiva Friedman’s death in 1985 the India Book was ines the numerous medieval pre- tible in Canada even if
India Traders of the Middle Ages. unfinished. scriptions and lists of materia made directly to the Devel-
Documents from the Cairo Geniza. The heavy responsibility for medica found among the Genizah opment Office at the
The “India Book” (ISBN: 978 90 completing the work passed to manuscripts to describe the prac- University of Cambridge.
04 15472 8), has been building Friedman, his former student, tice, as distinct from the theory, of
since 1954, when Goitein an- who has produced a remarkably medieval medicine and the –
nounced his intention to examine clear and comprehensive work on often bizarre – substances pre- The T-S Unit thanks the
evidence found among the manu- this fascinating area of medieval scribed by medieval practitioners. Lauffer Family Charitable
scripts for the extensive medieval history, bringing us the fruits of An important work of medical Trust for helping to make
Jewish trade with India. Goitein’s many years of research history, it owes much to the fact possible the production of
The Genizah is, in fact, almost a together with his own important that the Genizah manuscripts this newsletter. The Trust
unique source for this area of insights. It is a volume to be cele- preserve so many examples of was founded in memory of
medieval trade. The evidence is brated. everyday medicine in use — David Lauffer, who took a
abundant in hundreds of letters The second work, Practical scribbled prescriptions, medical keen interest in Jewish his-
and other texts, documenting the Materia Medica of the Medieval asides in letters, physician’s notes tory, particularly Genizah
lives and work of figures such as Eastern Mediterranean According — without which any study studies. He is warmly re-
the Tunisian-born Jewish mer- to the Cairo Genizah, by Efraim would have to be based mainly on membered in the Unit, and
chant Abraham ben Yiju, who Lev and Zohar Amar (ISBN: 978 the idealised practice preserved in his family’s continued sup-
spent years on India’s Malabar 90 04 16120 7; ISSN: 1570-1484), the theoretical medical works of port is much appreciated.
coast. has appeared remarkably quickly, the medieval Arab world.

Edited by Rebecca Jefferson and printed by Cambridge University Press

You might also like