Heavenly Bodies
Film Stars and Society
Second edition
Richard Dyer
JR foutesae
(86 Rash aap‘Unapters
Judy Garland and gay men
‘Hecoe tld sont pickling pa Mok wo sid oa cou ays tea
‘Se pe bons a got fa Gln
‘eed Wilkens peaking foe On
“Tee Ke he coum rck ars ei myst. The
‘Wand sga whch al hy sere bet onda pasty Semaning
(mee Mist Anca ad what ams hal. Mie Aree. The
init Vin andthe es th Pace MoveDen The ues a
‘nme obi ante New Lat ha Cobo andthe Tid Worl And
Somes fade tice fia reson fom a of them. Tao bad Jay
aed
rag Queen in Tne Gos By
In the June 1973 ese ofthe Birmingham Gay Liberation Font newsletter,
there wos an ete about fay Garland. Tt was cle ‘Bor i ‘rank’
id wan pated on pink paper Ictmade no reference to paynes whatsoever
‘Fhe tthor dl not el hat thre was any aoe to expan wy there should
{Ba strigforard fan's acount of Galan’ fe the publation of a
‘itant iy polteal group Nor the editorial collective, of wich Twas
‘Trmember (hough L nether wrote nor sugges the avi). We had &
‘olcy of minting anything anybody in OLE sutnitted provided that was
Pot salt reit or fase. The Gland pice was none of tess and We
tere nmersedin gay male clare a the author so that printing a pice
e Gordad seme hike the mos natural thing ithe world, When we
‘Saesbutl ic however umber of people, gy abd straght, ashes us what
Sneath be pews was doing in the sewsetex A fer wee objecting on
{he pound that Garland Seloged to the unibered days of say ext-
‘nce befoe GLE, but the rest wore mystified. Why vs Gatland ina 3
‘Dagatne’ And hen they lew the aosver~ because so many gay
(Gadccatt ae into her =the next question was a bemused win?” Tai
(Shaper isan atom to answer hat question,1 wey Garensanegay man
Ftc Mono can ben iin
“Et these tun ety Robeaon so ato appeal aoe
SEL tess uo ihr ger ietaton wn bom
TENYfve densest oro Gard ee equi
‘ee appears aun bus vatun apc of fr mage
lise dren cea within ae xy mentees chap
ince eal bow spss eps of Gans og could te 2
Percale ef sae ce
Mit an scrapes bth ater of Ge abe ered
toa ints pes bute pri fay beng
ses tiereiy len andy alesse hve en ke,
Se tn sy uray ty, ban ees be oe
sed aa nprtant fie ir donne ox Mees 175
saree tt ler Bt CiamaantSaiupnan 1a, We
‘BoE Mtg 19 Whie 1B) Honever ean a8 uy male cates
eearone anit uve seo oy Cand btn ances
sit ae ia bate Gra Garbo and Mtoe Ditch,
‘Teter etn import or bh eke dt eu
isu on bls been thar ages ad the at
Soak dr cules cated wih Resi aly Ronin rok, hay
Sfonbnge Geo Scand ohn (ae Rus 98 and Dyer 19
‘Thou is rable woul eon sports pin forthe 2)
tak ed of Gatto aed Dictih bey nul il od to be ie
apse om bie ag?
i ran male oy eats ses parnon by being whan
Govecd analy meopetany sed white Ti oe ote tel
(oo provi an ont en old tae be at as
frodia! inthe dong ar ny me hetos ew Yor, London,
SosFrmcico Amiens Sys ct) and oer nfo ee shown
bar) uations rey sot by mes Urb ite gy men
Stair cs Sine po nt cndoraon tes
Seca oy mace ale
“hc pod cnet contra cos fs 950. Kain tat estat
sul) Ca ated by MOMs ord thermore der hen
Bohccrtloned) sommes Thr even, bea const
{he unc «salen beak ih Garand’s uncompleted nd rary
oA eg mad obit ang Cs a hn epee
Sutiposifenng ovdetnen, aorta ans rari at
elt mc ft yang of Coa Ta pa eg css
SCersotequt cuter “tor Sowlopmet fhe come sprees
Sfpnsng oe London Pals SL; her veils Str
Soe han Cul oO Sng 1962 wl ar cing 8 A Ch
Tain 1902 od having a showy cameo indent Nerenberg 196k
ree fon fr Capitol records betwee 1955 an 1958, notably Miss
etc done, The Letter, Jy Love athe daub abu Jy
see mts Hai (x cording of her I961 concert that was the fist be
Fae sine non copie teeson shows incuding 0 aS
ARUEERI (re fond Stor uber 1935, The Jay Garand Stow 1963) 008
Fee rca for CBSin TOG are as neviens, radio show’ TV
rc appearances and much pes coverage, chiefly of he west
There cucideatempts, divorce hospitalisons, nd the Lk).
PE our 9s0 reading ws asda seaing of ber carer before 1950, ¢
ren back tothe ene fms earings and biogapy in the ek of
(Ete Slice ‘Th was faitated by the growth of television and, args
dae a roxy cinemas spealing it nstaigin renal, both making
es Sr Ru onstanyaalable for reviewing. In aston, mush of bt
gS carer deliberately evokes and rewocs ez early cae: Both 4
Poe porn and {Could Ge On Singing ae clearly based on Garlands ie
SRR oen a Trank’ nthe ferme sie knowing préis of he
IRB: Mont had fostered (et Jenings 1979. Equally her concer were
ra yee het hin carey, itroduaing ony nied amount of se
te Sn Mody of past ite were strodoced with verses such as “The
saat ny fein my soagn’ At Christopher Finch (1975: 186) puts
her once Were
‘a povel kind of Brosdvay musical, the words and esi by vations
ae tnd composes the book by Sody Garland, wih the formate
WEutence of the entre Hollywood press corps. To the audiens, the
‘ook was hud) Galan ie sory.
equa inportet, dosing hi period Garland spoke inerasingly about
Baa reas olay nat are i Meals in 1952}, thas provide
te peor oppotuutyofeading those ms and images hough set
owiedgeand'undesandigs.
Bete ote easy of ber enter work and its importance 3 8
setecce point ip be ltr fi, concerts records and press coverage, the
etre Besta caret een to tis chapter, bat is ead tava
Tee hele taken up by the gay mae sbeultare fer 1930. The ac of
(ose Sauce of Galant this subculture was avaye widely noted. Most
ee rr altuais mention ty and twas particalaty notable, for straight
Shaprra eapetly. at the concert: AD Orio (1975 132-4) quotes from
Serer mia Chzen News review of ber 1961 Hallyweod Bow! conc:
“Thy were all there, the guys and dlls and the sich ma siting
TELRES atch coosad througout the concert. After “Over he