A

P
P
E
N
D
I
X
 Appendix 1

Pre-Test Result of Experimental Class

No Students Reseacher Co- T-Score X1 X12

Reseacher
1 Ana Afriana 75 73 146 73 5329
2 Desi Susanti 72 70 142 71 5041
3 Erin Ardwiyansi 43 41 84 42 1764
4 Firlia Susanti 48 46 95 47,5 2256,25
5 Heni Dwi Lestari 50 44 94 47 2209
6 Indah Riati 85 80 165 82,5 6806,25
7 Istiana Deni Putri 62 63 125 62,5 3906,25
8 Kanti Rahayu 44 42 86 43 1849
9 Mela Astri 64 62 126 63 3969
10 Neni Vebriana 50 52 102 51 2601
11 Nofrida Fitriani 66 64 130 65 4225
12 Piko Harmeki 56 56 112 56 3136
13 Ramlan Hidayat 39 34 73 36,5 1332,25
14 Revita Septiana M 71 71 142 71 5041
15 Rini Karlina 56 51 107 53,5 2862,25
16 Tria Fiska Novia 83 81 165 82 6724
17 Violita Ayu Andini 52 48 100 50 2500
18 Wulansari Rahmawati 62 63 125 62,5 3906,25
19 Yodita Dwi Mentari 74 72 146 73 5329
20 Yozy Ardian Putra 40 40 73 40 1600
SUM 1172,5 72386,5
MEAN 58,625
 Appendix 3

Post-Test of Experimental Group

No Students Reseacher Co- T-Score X1 X12

Reseacher
1 Ana Afriana 54 50 104 52 2704
2 Desi Susanti 67 63 130 65 4225,25
3 Erin Ardwiyansi 55 50 105 52,5 2756,25
4 Firlia Susanti 60 58 118 59 3481
5 Heni Dwi Lestari 68 66 134 67 4489
6 Indah Riati 91 89 180 90 8100
7 Istiana Deni Putri 68 64 132 66 4356
8 Kanti Rahayu 51 46 97 48,5 2352,25
9 Mela Astri 76 71 147 73,5 5402,25
10 Neni Vebriana 68 64 132 66 4356
11 Nofrida Fitriani 76 71 147 73,5 5402,25
12 Piko Harmeki 63 61 124 62 3488
13 Ramlan Hidayat 54 47 101 50,5 2550,25
14 Revita Septiana M 79 75 154 77 5929
15 Rini Karlina 55 50 105 52,5 2756,25
16 Tria Fiska Novia 84 79 163 81,5 6642,25
17 Violita Ayu Andini 68 64 132 66 4356
18 Wulansari Rahmawati 85 81 166 83 6889
19 Yodita Dwi Mentari 79 75 154 77 5929
20 Yozy Ardian Putra 68 64 132 66 4356
SUM 1328,5 90520
MEAN 66,425
 Appendix 2

Pre-Test of Control Class

No Students Reseacher Co- T-Score X2 X22

Reseacher
1 Ayu Lestari 50 49 99 49,5 2450,25
2 Dona Demasari 53 54 107 53,5 2862,25
3 Geby Wulandari 55 56 111 55,5 3080,25
4 Gita Agustina 63 61 124 62 3844
5 Hartati 60 59 119 59,5 3540,25
6 Ika Ratnawati 63 61 124 62 3844
7 Lelmi Yuda Insi 56 61 117 58,5 3422,25
8 Millyan Fitriani 44 46 90 45 2025
9 Mira Astuti 50 52 102 51 2601
10 Nepi Kasari 40 39 79 39,5 1560,25
11 Noprianti 41 43 84 42 1764
12 Puspita Arini 39 34 73 36,5 1332,25
13 Ririn Putri Ananda 63 61 124 62 3844
14 Seli Andriani 70 71 141 70,5 4970,25
15 Septi Suci Lestari 55 57 112 56 3136
16 Sinta Purnama Sari 56 61 117 58,5 3422,25
17 Wiwik Lestari 50 49 99 49,5 2450,25
18 Wulandari 49 50 99 49,5 2450,25
19 Yeka Oktavianti 44 48 92 46 2116
20 Yuliasana 63 61 124 62 3844
SUM 1068,5 58558,75
MEAN 53,425
 Appendix 4

Post-Test of Control Class

No Students Reseacher Co- T-Score X2 X22

Reseacher
1 Ayu Lestari 67 64 131 65,5 4290,25
2 Dona Demasari 60 58 118 59 3481
3 Geby Wulandari 66 64 130 65 4225
4 Gita Agustina 68 66 134 67 4489
5 Hartati 59 54 113 56,5 3192,25
6 Ika Ratnawati 71 70 141 70,5 4970,25
7 Lelmi Yuda Insi 58 53 111 55,5 3080,25
8 Millyan Fitriani 46 43 89 44,5 1980,25
9 Mira Astuti 60 58 118 59 3481
10 Nepi Kasari 66 64 130 65 4225
11 Noprianti 47 43 90 45 2025
12 Puspita Arini 40 38 78 39 1521
13 Ririn Putri Ananda 71 70 141 70,5 4970,25
14 Seli Andriani 79 75 154 77 5929
15 Septi Suci Lestari 76 71 147 73,5 5402,25
16 Sinta Purnama Sari 58 53 111 55,5 3080,25
17 Wiwik Lestari 53 49 102 51 2601
18 Wulandari 60 58 118 59 3481
19 Yeka Oktavianti 46 43 89 44,5 1980,25
20 Yuliasana 68 73 141 70,5 4970,25
SUM 1193 73374,5
MEAN 59,65
 Appendix 5

The Comparison of Pre-Test Result in Experimental and Control Class

No Experimental Class Control Class

(X1) X1 2 X2 X2 2
1 73 5329 49,5 2450,25
2 71 5041 53,5 2862,25
3 42 1764 55,5 3080,25
4 47,5 2256,25 62 3844
5 47 2209 59,5 3540,25
6 82,5 6806,25 62 3844
7 62,5 3906,25 58,5 3422,25
8 43 1849 45 2025
9 63 3969 51 2601
10 51 2601 39,5 1560,25
11 65 4225 42 1764
12 56 3136 36,5 1332,25
13 36,5 1332,25 62 3844
14 71 5041 70,5 4970,25
15 53,5 2862,25 56 3136
16 82 6724 58,5 3422,25
17 50 2500 49,5 2450,25
18 62,5 3906,25 49,5 2450,25
19 73 5329 46 2116
20 40 1600 62 3844
N= ∑X1= 1062,5 (∑X1)2= 1128906,3 ∑X2= 1068,5 ∑X2 2= 1141692,3
20 X = 53,125 X = 53,425
(∑X)2= 60289,25 (∑X2)2= 58558,75
Sources: SPPS 16/17
 Appendix 6

The Comparison of Post-Test Result in Experimental and Control Class

No Experimental Class Control Class

(X1) X1 2 X2 X2 2

1 52 2704 65,5 4290,25

2 65 4225,25 59 3481
3 52,5 2756,25 65 4225
4 59 3481 67 4489
5 67 4489 56,5 3192,25
6 90 8100 70,5 4970,25
7 66 4356 55,5 3080,25
8 48,5 2352,25 44,5 1980,25
9 73,5 5402,25 59 3481
10 66 4356 65 4225
11 73,5 5402,25 45 2025
12 62 3488 39 1521
13 50,5 2550,25 70,5 4970,25
14 77 5929 77 5929
15 52,5 2756,25 73,5 5402,25
16 81,5 6642,25 55,5 3080,25
17 66 4356 51 2601
18 83 6889 59 3481
19 77 5929 44,5 1980,25
20 66 4356 70,5 4970,25
N= ∑X1= 1328,5 (∑X1)2= 1764912,3 ∑X2= 1193 ∑X2 2= 1423259
20 X = 66,425 X =59,65
(∑X)2= 90520 (∑X2)2= 73374,5
Sources: SPPS 16/17
 Appendix 7

The Result of Pre Test

𝑋̅1 −𝑋̅2
t=
(∑ 𝑋1 )2 2 −(∑ 𝑋2 )
2
∑ 𝑋2 − +∑ 𝑋
√ 1 𝑁1 2 𝑁2 1
( + )
1
𝑁1+𝑁 −2 𝑁1 𝑁2
2

58,625−53,425
t=
(1172,5)2 (1068,5)2
√72386,5− 20
+58558,75−
20 1 1
( + )
20+20−2 20 20

5,2
t= 1374756,3 1141692,3
√72386,5− +58558,75−
20 20 2
( )
38 20

5,2
t = √(72386,5−68737,815)+(58558,75−50400,8)
(0,1)
38

5,2
t= 3648,685+1474,15
√ (0,1)
38

5,2
t= 5122,835
√ (0,1)
38

5,2
t=
√134,811 (0,1)

5,2
t=
√13,481

5,2
t = 3,67 t = 1,41

t-count = 1,41 ( t-table = 1,685. So, t-count < t-table ( 1,41< 1,685 ))
 Appendix 8

The Result of Post Test

𝑋̅1 −𝑋̅2
t=
(∑ 𝑋1 )2 2 −(∑ 𝑋2 )
2
∑ 𝑋2 − +∑ 𝑋
√ 1 𝑁1 2 𝑁2 1
( + )
1
𝑁1+𝑁 −2 𝑁1 𝑁2
2

66,425−59,65
t=
(1328,5)2 (1193)2
√90520− 20
+73374,5−
20 ( 1 + 1 )
20+20−2 20 20

6,775
t= 1764912,3 1423249
√90520− +73374,5− 20
20 2
( )
38 20

6,775
t = √(90520−88245,615)+(73374,5−7116,45)
(0,1)
38

6,775
t= 2274,385+2212,05
√ (0,1)
38

6,775
t= 4486,435
√ (0,1)
38

6,775
t=
√118,064(0,1)

6,775
t=
√11,806

6,775
t = 3,435 t = 1,972

t-count = 1,972 ( t-table = 1,685. So, t-count > t-table ( 1,972 > 1,685 ))
DOCUMENTATION OF EXPERIMENTAL GROUP
DOCUMENTATION OF CONRTOL GROUP