Professional Documents
Culture Documents
(10920684 - Neurosurgical Focus) Combined Endovascular and Microsurgical Management of Giant and Complex Unruptured Aneurysms
(10920684 - Neurosurgical Focus) Combined Endovascular and Microsurgical Management of Giant and Complex Unruptured Aneurysms
Division of Neurological Surgery, Barrow Neurological Institute, St. Joseph’s Hospital and Medical
Center, Phoenix, Arizona
Object. The purpose of this study was to assess the efficacy and describe the technical features of combined endo-
vascular and microsurgical treatments for complex and giant unruptured intracranial aneurysms.
Methods. A prospectively maintained database was reviewed to identify all patients with unruptured intracranial an-
eurysms who were treated with combined techniques. Twenty-one lesions were treated in as many patients: six lesions
involved the posterior cerebral artery (PCA); seven the cavernous portion of the internal carotid artery (ICA); two the
basilar apex; two the basilar trunk; and one each the anterior communicating artery, anterior cerebral artery, petrous
ICA, and cervical ICA. Aneurysms were treated with combined extracranial–intracranial bypass procedures and par-
ent-vessel occlusion, flow redirection, or arterial transposition.
Aneurysm occlusion was achieved in 20 patients. In the remaining patient the aneurysm recurred, requiring stent-
assisted repeated coil placement. Three patients suffered permanent neurological deficits related to treatment, and three
died, two of whom had basilar trunk aneurysms.
Conclusions. Certain complex aneurysms may be treated optimally by combining endovascular and surgical proce-
dures. A low incidence of complications follows treatment of anterior circulation aneurysms. Treatment of complex
posterior circulation aneurysms is associated with a higher incidence of complications, although this likely reflects the
more complex nature of these lesions. The risks of this combined treatment strategy are likely lower than the risks asso-
ciated with the natural history of this subset of aneurysms.
Combined microsurgical and endovascular strategies importantly, the combined management plan should im-
have been used for more than a decade to treat complex prove on the natural history of the untreated lesion. In this
intracranial aneurysms.2,15,19 Ongoing advances in endo- report we present our series of patients who were treated
vascular techniques have increased the safety and efficacy with a combined approach. Our goal was to identify the
of this modality of treatment, making it more attractive, types of complex aneurysms for which such an approach
especially for patients. As the field of endovascular neu- is indicated.
rosurgery evolves, interest in combined neurovascular
teams has been renewed.1,6–10,13,14,17,18 Such teams select the
optimal management strategy for aneurysms on a case-by- CLINICAL MATERIAL AND METHODS
case basis. The records of 21 patients who underwent combination
A subset of intracranial aneurysms requires combined therapy for unruptured aneurysms between January 1997
microsurgical and endovascular management. Ideally, a and March 2003 were reviewed to determine aneurysm
combined treatment strategy offers better results and leads location, type of endovascular and surgical intervention,
to fewer complications than either treatment alone. Most follow-up results of treatment, and associated complica-
tions. Only patients for whom a combined endovascular
and surgical intervention was planned at the start of treat-
ment were included in the study. Patients undergoing clip
Abbreviations used in this paper: ACA = anterior cerebral ar-
tery; ACoA = anterior communicating artery; BA = basilar artery;
placement for the recurrence of an aneurysm previously
EDH = epidural hematoma; GDC = Guglielmi detachable coil; treated with coil occlusion or coil occlusion for the recur-
ICA = internal carotid artery; MCA = middle cerebral artery; OA = rence of an aneurysm previously treated with clip place-
occipital artery; PCA = posterior cerebral artery; PICA = posterior ment were excluded. All patients were followed for the
inferior cerebellar artery; SCA = superior cerebellar artery; STA = development of treatment-related sequelae by using a pro-
superficial temporal artery; VA = vertebral artery. spectively maintained database.
TABLE 1
Clinical summary of 21 patients with aneurysms who underwent a combined approach*
Case Age (yrs), Indication Location Complicating Neurological FU
No. Sex for Op of Lesion Factors Complications Sequelae (mos)
TABLE 2
Location of lesion, treatment, and outcome in 21 patients with complex aneurysms
Outcome
extracranial–intracranial revascularization and endovas- (14.3%) had good outcomes, and three (14.3%) died
cular parent-vessel occlusion. Six patients harbored an- (Table 2). One patient (Case 13) died of an underlying pul-
eurysms of the PCA (one giant, four dissecting, one fu- monary malignancy. Another (Case 6) presented with ex-
siform; four of the P1–P2 junction; one of the P2 segment; tensor posturing after intraoperative rupture of his giant
and one of the P3/P4 junction), five of whom underwent basilar trunk aneurysm. He suffered a postoperative EDH
an OA–PCA anastomosis followed by endovascular coil and died of brainstem compression caused by the aneu-
placement and occlusion of the aneurysm and PCA. The rysm. The third patient who died (Case 8) had experienced
other patient underwent an OA onlay. The patient with a a brainstem stroke 6 years earlier. His giant basilar trunk
dissecting aneurysm at the P3–P4 junction of the PCA un- aneurysm was treated with an STA–SCA bypass, followed
derwent an OA onlay, followed by endovascular balloon by coil occlusion of the right VA distal to the PICA. Three
occlusion of the parent vessel. A patient with a giant basi- months later, BA thrombosis developed on the morning
lar apex aneurysm was treated with coil embolization fol- that he was scheduled to undergo endovascular occlusion
lowed by an STA–SCA bypass. of the contralateral VA, and he died.
The mean follow-up duration for the 18 surviving pa-
Flow Redirection tients was 20 months (range 1–48 months). Eleven pa-
Four patients underwent flow redirection procedures. A tients were symptom and disease free at follow-up review.
patient with a giant basilar tip aneurysm underwent clip Four patients’ symptoms were unchanged from presenta-
placement on P1 away from the aneurysm to redirect flow. tion, including three who presented with mass effect and
She later underwent endovascular stent placement in the one who continued to suffer headaches. Three patients
BA and contralateral PCA and stent-assisted coil place- suffered mild strokes that resulted in a homonymous
ment in the basilar trunk aneurysm. A patient with a large hemianopia after occlusion of their bypass graft.
right A2 aneurysm underwent a pericallosal artery micro-
surgical bypass followed by endovascular parent-vessel Aneurysm Obliteration
occlusion of the right A1 to redirect flow through the an- Immediate postoperative angiography confirmed oblit-
eurysm. Two patients underwent STA–SCA anastomosis eration of the lesion in 20 patients and demonstrated resid-
followed by endovascular occlusion of the VAs to reverse ual aneurysm in the other one. Angiographic follow-up
flow through the BA. studies were obtained in 14 of the 18 surviving patients
Additional Combined Techniques and demonstrated complete occlusion or stable residual
aneurysm in 13 and a 1-cm enlarging residual lesion in
A patient with the giant ACoA aneurysm underwent an one. The latter patient underwent stent-assisted coil place-
A3–A3 bypass followed by clip occlusion of the aneurysm. ment in the residual aneurysm.
One day later, this patient underwent endovascular coil
placement in the inflow into the giant ACA. Another pa- Postoperative Complications
tient with a high cervical ICA aneurysm was found to
have a tortuous cervical carotid artery. To render the artery Procedure-related complications occurred in eight cas-
amenable to stent placement, the ICA was transposed sur- es. One patient had an occlusion of an OA–PCA bypass
gically, thus straightening the portion of the artery that graft and a homonymous hemianopia developed; no treat-
harbored the aneurysm. The aneurysm was then treated ment was given, and the deficit was permanent. Five pa-
with stent placement and coil occlusion. tients suffered EDHs, all of which occurred after heparin-
ization and endovascular treatment (Cases 1, 4, 6, 8, and
RESULTS 19). Among these, one patient (Case 6) presented in a
coma and died shortly after evacuation of the EDH. An-
Clinical Outcomes
other patient (Case 8) died 3 months later of a brainstem
Fifteen patients (71.4%) had excellent outcomes, three stroke.
Homonymous hemianopia developed in three patients During surgery, the neck of the aneurysm could not be
treated with OA–PCA revascularization (Cases 1, 4, and clipped satisfactorily because of the extensive thrombosis
19). In one (Case 1) the complication resolved complete- and calcification at its base. Therefore, the P1 segment of
ly, in one (Case 19) an occlusion of the graft developed the right PCA was clipped as it emerged from the base of
and this patient was found to have a left PCA infarct, and the aneurysm. The posterior communicating artery recon-
in one (Case 4) a mild permanent visual field deficit was stituted the distal right PCA (Fig. 2B). The second stage
found. In one patient (Case 18) a pseudoaneurysm devel- of treatment was stent placement. After the initial angio-
oped at the femoral artery after a cavernous ICA aneu- grams were obtained a 3 14–mm stent (Radius; Bos-
rysm was treated with coils. One patient (Case 2) required ton Scientific, Watertown, MA) was placed, extending
placement of a ventriculoperitoneal shunt after surgery to from the left PCA down to the BA proximal to the SCAs.
control increased intracranial pressure. Three weeks later, the residual aneurysm was embolized
with seven GDCs, which were placed without incident
(Fig. 2C and D). The patient later died of her underlying
ILLUSTRATIVE CASES malignancy.
Case 16
Case 19
This 65-year-old woman had a 3-month history of pro-
gressive proptosis, double vision, and intermittent head- This 65-year-old man had received a diagnosis of a
aches. Magnetic resonance imaging and magnetic reso- giant left PCA aneurysm 3 years earlier and had been told
nance angiography revealed a mesial right temporal mass, that the lesion was inoperable. He presented to us with
and four-vessel angiography demonstrated a giant cav- progressive decline, including dizziness, right hemipare-
ernous ICA aneurysm (Fig. 1A). sis, and intermittent diplopia. Angiography confirmed the
A right STA–MCA bypass was performed, and patency presence of the aneurysm (Fig. 3A), and an OA–distal
was documented using intraoperative angiography. Three PCA bypass followed by coil embolization of the distal P2
days later the patient tolerated temporary test occlusion of segment of the PCA was recommended.
the right ICA. Seven GDCs were inserted into the petrous Initially, the patient underwent a bioccipital craniotomy
and high cervical segments of the right ICA (Fig. 1B and and microsurgical anastomosis of the right OA to the dis-
C). Complete occlusion of the vessel was documented, tal PCA. Two days later angiography demonstrated paten-
and a right external carotid artery injection demonstrated cy of the bypass, and the patient underwent coil emboliza-
excellent filling of the distal MCA branches through the tion and occlusion of the aneurysm and parent artery (Fig.
bypass graft. At her 6-month follow-up examination, the 3B and C). Seven GDCs were deposited within the an-
patient reported resolution of her symptoms. Angiography eurysm. Subsequent angiography demonstrated filling of
confirmed obliteration of the aneurysm and patency of the the PCA through the bypass graft but no filling of the an-
bypass graft. eurysm from the VA injections.
The patient’s postoperative course was complicated
Case 13 by an occipital EDH, which caused right homonymous
hemianopia. The hematoma was evacuated and the pa-
This 51-year-old woman with a history of lung cancer tient’s left visual field cut resolved. At 1-year follow-up
presented with the sudden onset of slurred speech and examination, the patient had resumed all activities of daily
weakness of the right arm. Imaging studies revealed a cal- living.
cified basilar apex aneurysm extending into the third ven-
tricle (Fig. 2A) and an infarction of the left temporal lobe
and posterior aspect of the left subinsular cortex. A three- DISCUSSION
stage approach, including clip placement, endovascular Combined endovascular and surgical therapy has been
stent insertion, and embolization was recommended. practiced since 1987.19 Early applications of endovascular
Fig. 1. Case 16. Cerebral angiograms and artist’s rendering depicting the anterior circulation. Left: Preoperative lat-
eral view of the right ICA demonstrating a giant cavernous carotid artery aneurysm. Center: Lateral view obtained after
bypass and coil occlusion confirming obliteration of the aneurysm and occlusion of the ICA. Right: Illustration depict-
ing the combined technique.
Fig. 2. Case 13. Cerebral angiograms and artist’s rendering depicting the posterior circulation. A: Anteroposterior
view demonstrating a large basilar apex aneurysm. B: Anteroposterior view of the aneurysm after microsurgical clip-
ping of the right P1 segment of the PCA. Subsequently, a stent was placed extending from the distal BA to the left P1 seg-
ment of the PCA. C: Angiogram obtained when the patient returned for further endovascular obliteration of the an-
eurysm with seven GDCs 3 weeks after placement of the stent. D: Illustration depicting the combined technique.
therapy as a surgical adjunct included embolization of apy was performed safely and aneurysms were obliterated
vascular lesions before resection.4,18,20 This approach made successfully in most cases. The use of such techniques
it possible to obliterate extensive portions of vascular mal- significantly alters the natural history of these lesions.5
formations and tumors and thus enhanced the feasibili- The combined endovascular and surgical treatment
ty of resection. Combined techniques have also been ap- paradigms typically fall within one of four categories, as
plied to the treatment of intracranial dural fistulas6,12,17 follows: 1) endovascular or surgical treatment after un-
and vascular occlusion.11,16,21 The classic application of successful prior surgical or endovascular treatment, re-
the combined technique is an extracranial–intracranial by- spectively; 2) endovascular treatment of the remote sec-
pass combined with endovascular parent-vessel occlusion. ond aneurysm; 3) endovascular proximal parent artery
First attempted in 1987, Serbinenko, et al.,19 described this control during surgery for clip occlusion/decompression;
technique in 1990 after treating nine patients with giant and 4) combined surgical and endovascular treatment for
ICA aneurysms for whom direct clip occlu- sion was complex intracranial aneurysms (for example, microsurgi-
deemed to be associated with an unjustifiably high risk. cal revascularization followed by endovascular parent-
Early combined treatment strategies also included en- artery occlusion and flow-redirection techniques).
dovascular retrograde suction decompression of paracli- Barnett, et al.,2 Lawton, et al.,13 and Hacein-Bey, et al.,7
noid aneurysms to facilitate dissection and direct clip oc- published large contemporary series of patients treated
clusion.3 The use of balloon occlusion of the ICA before with a combined modality. In this report, we reviewed on-
dissection of unruptured aneurysms allowed proximal ly the subset of patients who received the aforementioned
artery control for temporary occlusion without requiring fourth treatment paradigm. Specifically, endovascular and
neck dissection for proximal control of the ICA.15 surgical modalities were combined in the initial treatment
The overwhelmingly poor prognosis associated with plan. Broadly, these patients may be categorized in the fol-
untreated giant and complex aneurysms mandates aggres- lowing subgroups: 1) those with aneurysms involving the
sive treatment in which both microsurgical and endovas- petrous, cavernous, or paraclinoid ICA that are not ame-
cular techniques are used. In this series, combination ther- nable to direct surgical clip occlusion and that require
Fig. 3. Case 19. Cerebral angiograms and artist’s rendering depicting the posterior circulation. Left: Anteroposterior
view demonstrating a large right-sided P1/P2 junction aneurysm. Center: Anteroposterior view of the aneurysm after
OA–PCA bypass and coil embolization and occlusion of the lesion and parent artery. Right: Illustration depicting the
combined technique.
an STA–MCA bypass or a cervical carotid artery–MCA sive craniectomy and recovered from this procedure dur-
saphenous vein bypass graft followed by parent-vessel ing his prolonged hospitalization. He died 3 months later
occlusion; 2) those with aneurysms in the posterior circu- of a posterior fossa stroke caused by BA thrombosis suf-
lation that require an STA–SCA or OA–PCA bypass; and fered on the day he was scheduled to undergo the second
3) those with complex aneurysms that cannot be eliminat- stage of endovascular treatment. One patient with a basi-
ed from the circulation and that require flow-redirection lar apex aneurysm was treated with flow redirection en-
techniques. In our series, the most common aneurysms for tailing surgical clip occlusion of the right P1 segment of
which a combined technique was required were those in- the PCA, followed by stent placement in the distal BA and
volving the cavernous ICA and PCA. Of the latter, most left PCA, followed in turn by stent-assisted coil emboliza-
were dissecting aneurysms. tion of the aneurysm (Fig. 2D). This patient eventually
died of an underlying malignancy, although her postoper-
Treatment of ICA Aneurysms ative course was excellent.
The technique for combining endovascular and surgical Two patients underwent flow-reversal techniques for
approaches to treat ICA aneurysms (Fig. 1C) has been ACA aneurysms. One had an A2–A3 aneurysm and the
well described.1,2,8,10,13–15 We treated 12 patients by using an other had an ACoA aneurysm. Both patients underwent
STA–MCA bypass or cervical ICA–MCA saphenous vein A3–A3 bypass followed by endovascular occlusion of the
bypass graft, and all had excellent outcomes. aneurysm and feeding artery.
3. Batjer HH, Samson DS: Retrograde suction decompression microsurgical and endovascular management of complex in-
of giant paraclinoidal aneurysms. Technical note. J Neurosurg tracranial aneurysms. Neurosurgery 52:263–275, 2003
73:305–306, 1990 14. Martin NA: The combination of endovascular and surgical tech-
4. Deruty R, Pelissou-Guyotat I, Amat D, Mottolese C, Bascou- niques for the treatment of intracranial aneurysms. Neurosurg
lergue Y, Turjman F, et al: Multidisciplinary treatment of ce- Clin N Am 9:897, 1998
rebral arteriovenous malformations. Neurol Res 17:169–177, 15. Mizoi K, Takahashi A, Yoshimoto T, et al: Combined endovas-
1995 cular and neurosurgical approach for paraclinoid internal ca-
5. Ferguson GG, Peerless SJ, Drake CG: Natural history of intra- rotid artery aneurysms. Neurosurgery 33:986–992, 1993
cranial aneurysms. N Engl J Med 305:99, 1981 16. Pappada G, Marina R, Fiori L, et al: Surgery and stenting as
6. Goto K, Sidipratomo P, Ogata N, et al: Combining endovascu- combined treatment of a symptomatic tandem stenosis of the
lar and neurosurgical treatments of high-risk dural arteriove- carotid artery. Acta Neurochir 141:1177–1181, 1999
nous fistulas in the lateral sinus and the confluence of the sinus- 17. Pierot L, Visot A, Boulin A, et al: Combined neurosurgical and
es. J Neurosurg 90:289–299, 1999 neuroradiological treatment of a complex superior sagittal sinus
7. Hacein-Bey L, Connolly ES Jr, Mayer SA, et al: Complex in- dural fistula: technical note. Neurosurgery 42:194–197, 1998
tracranial aneurysms: combined operative and endovascular 18. Rosenblatt S, Lewis AI, Tew JM: Combined interventional and
approaches. Neurosurgery 43:1304–1313, 1998 surgical treatment of arteriovenous malformations. Neuroim-
8. Hoh BL, Carter BS, Budzik RF, et al: Results after surgical and aging Clin N Am 8:469–482, 1998
endovascular treatment of paraclinoid aneurysms by a com- 19. Serbinenko FA, Filatov JM, Spallone A, et al: Management of
bined neurovascular team. Neurosurgery 48:78–90, 2001 giant intracranial ICA aneurysms with combined extracranial-
9. Hoh BL, Ogilvy CS, Butler WE, et al: Multimodality treatment intracranial anastomosis and endovascular occlusion. J Neuro-
of nongalenic arteriovenous malformations in pediatric pa- surg 73:57–63, 1990
tients. Neurosurgery 47:346–358, 2000 20. Shaffrey ME, Persing JA, Ferguson RD, et al: Vascular lesions
10. Hoh BL, Putman CM, Budzik RF, et al: Combined surgical and involving the cranial base: combined surgical and intervention-
endovascular techniques of flow alteration to treat fusiform and al radiologic approach. J Craniofac Surg 1:106–111, 1990
complex wide-necked intracranial aneurysms that are unsuit- 21. Terada T, Nakai E, Tsuura M, et al: Combined surgery and en-
able for clipping or coil embolization. J Neurosurg 95:24–35, dovascular stenting for basilar artery stenosis refractory to bal-
2001 loon angioplasty: technical case report. Acta Neurochir 143:
11. Konishi Y, Sato E, Shiokawa Y, et al: A combined surgical and 511–516, 2001
endovascular treatment for a case with five vertebro-basilar
aneurysms and bilateral internal carotid artery occlusions. Surg
Neurol 50:363–366, 1998 Manuscript received September 17, 2004.
12. Krisht AF, Burson T: Combined pretemporal and endovascular Accepted in final form October 5, 2004.
approach to the cavernous sinus for the treatment of carotid- Address reprint requests to: Felipe C. Albuquerque, M.D., Neu-
cavernous dural fistulae: technical case report. Neurosurgery roscience Publications; Barrow Neurological Institute, 350 West
44:415–418, 1999 Thomas Road, Phoenix, Arizona 85013. email: neuropub@
13. Lawton MT, Quinones-Hinojosa A, Sanai N, et al: Combined chw.edu.