̸͊
̹͉͇̾̽̾̓̾ͅ

͈͇
̻͇͇͇͌́͊͋͐͆͠͠
̺͉͇͈̾́
 4&3#*4$)&
","%&.*&
%&3
8*44&/4$)"'5&/
6/%
,¾/45&
*/45*565
'¾3
#"-,"/0-0(*&
40/%&3"64("#&/


70-,4.64&6.
#&-(3"%

.*5
3&*4&'¾)3&3/

%63$)

4¾%045&6301"
3FEBLUFVS
%KPSEKF
4
,PTUJǀ

*N
"VGUSBH
EFS
7FSMÅHFS

%VØBO
#BUBLPWJǀ
%JSFLUPS
EFT
*OTUJUVUT
GÛS
#BMLBOPMPHJF
5BUKBOB
$WFUJǀBOJO
%JSFLUPS
EFT
7PMLTNVTFVNT

#&-(3"%

 ̸͉͈͊͊̓
̸̸̸̓̽̾́͠ͅ
̸̸͆͌̓
́
͇͌̾͋͆͊͋́ͅ
̸̸̹͇͇̈́̓͆̈́͑̓́
́͆͊͋́͋͌͋
̸͈͇̹͊̾͆
̸̸́̀̽͢


̸͉͇͆̽͆́
͌̀̾͠ͅ
̸̹͇̻͉̾̽

̸͊
̹͉͇̾̽̾̓̾ͅ

͈͇
̻͇͇͇͌́͊͋͐͆͠͠

̺͉͇͈̾́
͌ͻͰͯ͸ͳ͵
͚͇͉͚̾
͊
͇̓͊͋́ͣ

̀ͪ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂Ͱ

ͯͻ
̽;΃ͪ͸
͋
̹ͪͽͪ͵͹ͬͳΕ
ͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ͹ͻ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵͹ͭ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽͪ
̸͊͆͌
ͯͻ
͋ͪͽΒͪ͸ͪ
͏ͬΒͰͽͳΕͪ͸ͳ͸
ͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ͹ͻ
͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͭ
ͷ;ͲͰΒͪ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;

̸̹͇̻͉̾̽

 ̸͊
̹͉͇̾̽̾̓̾ͅ
͈͇
̻͇͇͇͌́͊͋͐͆͠͠
̺͉͇͈̾́
͌ͻͰͯ͸ͳ͵
͚͹ͻΌͰ
͊
̓͹ͼͽͳΕ

́Ͳͯͪͬͪ΂ͳ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
̸͊͆͌
̓͸ͰͲͅͳ΀ͪͳͶ͹ͬͪ


̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
CBMLJOTU!TBOVBDZV
͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ
ͷ;ͲͰΒ
͋ͻͭ
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͪ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
XXXOBSPEOJNV[FKPSHZV

͌ͻͰΌͳͬͪ΂͵ͳ
͹ͯͫ͹ͻ
ͪ͵ͪͯͰͷͳ͵
͆ͳ͵͹Ͷͪ
͋ͪͼͳΕ

ͯͻ
̽;΃ͪ͸
͋
̹ͪͽͪ͵͹ͬͳΕ

ͯͻ
͚͹ͻΌͰ
͊
̓͹ͼͽͳΕ
ͯͻ
͋ͪͽΒͪ͸ͪ
͏ͬΒͰͽͳΕͪ͸ͳ͸
ͯͻ
̽ͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ

ͯͻ
ͪͅͻ͵͹
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ
ͯͻ
̺Ͱͻ͵ͪ
͠͹ͬͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ
͍͹Ͷ͵Ͱͻ
ͪͅͻͬͳ΁

ͷͻ
͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
͈
͉ͳͼͽͳΕ
ͷͻ
͐Ͱͯ͹ͷͳͻ
̸͸ͽͳΕ

͉Ͱ΁Ͱ͸ͲͰ͸ͽͳ
ͪ͵ͪͯͰͷͳ͵
͆ͳ͵͹Ͷͪ
͋ͪͼͳΕ
ͺͻ͹Ϳ
ͯͻ
̀͹ͻͪ͸
̿ͳͶͰͽͳΕ

͈ͻͰͬ͹ͯ
ͻͰͲͳͷͰͪ
͸ͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ
ΒͰͲͳ͵
͇ͶͳͬͰͻͪ
̽;ͻͫͪͫͪ

̈́Ͱ͵ͽ;ͻͪ
ͳ
͵͹ͻͰ͵ͽ;ͻͪ
͋ͪͽΒͪ͸ͪ
̓͹ͻͳΕͪ͸ͪ΁

̈́ͳ͵͹ͬ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͭͻͪͿͳ΂͵ͪ
͹ͺͻͰͷͪ
̓ͻͪ͸ͳͼͶͪͬ
̺ͻͪ͸ͳΕ

͋ͳͻͪͱ


͑ͽͪͷͺͪ
͐ͳͭ͹Βͪ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ

*4#/

*4#/
9

̓Δͳͭͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓ;ΒͰ
;Ͳ
Ϳͳ͸ͪ͸ͼͳΒͼ͵;
ͺ͹ͯͻ΃͵;
ͅͳ͸ͳͼͽͪͻͼͽͬͪ
͸ͪ;͵Ͱ

ͳ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽͰ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ͸Ͱ
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸Ͱ
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͪ
;
͹͵ͬͳͻ;
ͻͪͯͪ

͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ΒͰ͵ͽ;
ͫͻ

ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ͹ͷ

t̾ͬͻ͹ͺͪ
ͳ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
;
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸͹
ͯ͹ͫͪ
;ͲͪΒͪͷ͸ͪ
ͬͳΌͰΔͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͱͳͷͪΔͪi
 ͊
ͪ
ͯ
ͻ
ͱ
ͪ
Β

͌ͬ͹ͯ͸ͪ
ͻͰ΂







































































͚͹ͻΌͰ
͊
̓͹ͼͽͳΕ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͵ͪ͹
͹ͭͶͰͯͪͶ͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;













%KPSEKF
4
,PTUJǀ
3FJTFGÛISFS
BMT
4QJFHFMCJMEFS
QPMJUJTDIFS
7FSÅOEFSVOHFO

BVG
EFN
#BMLBO












































͋ͪͽΒͪ͸ͪ
͏ͬΒͰͽͳΕͪ͸ͳ͸
̸ͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽͳ

;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ


































5BUKBOB
$WKFUJǀBOJO
"SDIÅPMPHJF
VOE
3FJTFGÛISFS
BSDIÅPMPHJTDIF
-PLBMJUÅUFO

JO
4FSCJFO
,VMUVSUPVSJTNVT
VOE
3FJTFGÛISFS





































ͪͅͻ͵͹
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
;
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ

ͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ

ͬͰ͵ͪ








.BSLP
1PQPWJǀ
#FMHSBE
JO
EFVUTDIFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO
&OEF
EFT

VOE
"OGBOH
EFT

+BISIVOEFSUT










































͐Ͱͯ͹ͷͳͻ
̸͸ͽͳΕ
͇ͯ
͋ͳͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͯ͹
ͪͶͫͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͫͰͼͺ;Εͪ








































ƀFEPNJS
"OUJǀ
"VT
5JSBOB
CJT
JOT
BMCBOJTDIF
XFHMPTF
(FMÅOEF
IJO


























̺ͪͶͰ͸ͽͳ͸ͪ
̿ͳͬ͵͹ͬͳΕ
͊Ͷͳ͵ͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͷͰΔͪ͸ͪ
;
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼͳͷͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
























































7BMFOUJOB
ÂJWLPWJǀ
#JMEFS
FJOFS
4UBEU
EVSDI
EBT
&SECFCFO
TUÅOEJH
WFSÅOEFSU

,PUPS
JO
3FJTFGÛISFSO











































͠͹ͬͪ͸͵ͪ
͚͹ͻΌͰͬͳΕ͠͹ͬͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ
͌
ͼͰ͸΁ͳ
͇Ͷͳͷͺͪ










































+PWBOLB
%KPSEKFWJǀ+PWBOPWJǀ
*N
4DIBUUFO
EFT
0MZNQVT





































̹͹Βͪ͸ͪ
ͅͳΓ͵͹ͬͳἘͪͽͳΕ
͈ͰΒͼͪͱͳ
ͫͰͲ
ͼͰͶͪ
ͷͪͻͭͳ͸ͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͻ;ͻͪͶ͸͹ͭ
;
99
ͬͰ͵;

͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ;
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ΀
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ





















































#PKBOB
.JMKLPWJǀ,BUJǀ
-BOETDIBGUFO
PIOF
%ÕSGFS
.BSHJOBMJTJFSVOH
EFT
SVSBMFO

&MFNFOUFT
JN

+BISIVOEFSU
EBSHFTUFMMU
BN
#FJTQJFM

FJOJHFS
EFVUTDIFS
3FJTFGÛISFS





































̽ͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ
͊ͻͺͼ͵͹
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
;
ͻͪ͸ͳͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ





%BOJDB
1PQPWJǀ
4FSCJTDIFT
NJUUFMBMUFSMJDIFT
&SCF
JO
GSÛIFO
EFVUTDIFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO






͉ͳͿͪͽ
̓;ͶͰ͸͹ͬͳΕ
́͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
͈͹ͯ;͸ͪͬΓͪ



















3JGBU
,VMFOPWJǀ
%BT
JOEVTUSJFMMF
&SCF
EFT
TFSCJTDIFO
5FJMT
EFS
%POBVHFHFOE




















̺Ͱͻ͵ͪ
͠͹ͬͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͰ
͵ͪͻͽͰ





































7FSLB
+PWBOPWJǀ
3FJTFGÛISFS
VOE
EBSJO
WPSLPNNFOEF
-BOELBSUFO


















͇ͶͳͬͰͻͪ
̽;ͻͫͪͫͪ
͇ͯͻͰͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͹
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
;
͸Ͱ͵ͳͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
























0MJWFSB
%VSCBCB
%FS
TFSCJTDIFO
4QSBDIF
HFXJENFUF
,BQJUFM
JO
FJOJHFO
EFVUTDIFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO
















































͇ͽ͹
̈́;ͽ΀ͪͻ
m
͋ͪΔͪ
͈Ͱͽͻ͹ͬͳΕ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
;
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸ͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ

͵ͻͰͳͻͪΔͰ
ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͽͰͽͪ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͵͹͸ͼͽͻ;͵΁ͳΒ;
ͺͰͻͳͿͰͻͳΒͰ






















0UP
-VUIBS
m
5BOKB
1FUSPWJǀ
%FS
#BMLBO
JO
XFTUMJDIFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO

*EFOUJUÅUTHFTUBMUVOH
EVSDI
,POTUSVLUJPO
EFS
1FSJQIFSJF


























͠ͰͶͳ΁ͪ
͆͹ͬͪ͵͹ͬͳΕ̈́͹ͺ;΃ͳ͸ͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
;
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ











































+FMJDB
/PWBLPWJǀ-PQVØJOB
+VHPTMBXJFO
JO
OJFEFSMÅOEJTDIFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO
BVT
EFO
FS
+BISFO
EFT

+BISIVOEFSUT




































͊Ͷ͹ͫ͹ͯͪ͸
͊
͈ͪΒ͹ͬͳΕ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
;
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ




































4MPCPEBO
4
1BKPWJǀ
4FSCJFO
JO
TQBOJTDIFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO

































͉ͪͯͷͳͶͪ
̀͹ͽ͹ͬͳΕ

̸͸ͽͳ΂͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ
t͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ
m
ͲͰͷΓͪ
͵͹͸ͽͻͪͼͽͪ
ͳ
ͻͪͼ͵͹΃͸Ͱ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰi








































































3BENJMB
;PUPWJǀ
"OUJLFT
&SCF
WPO
,MFJOBTJFO
t%JF
5ÛSLFJ
m
FJO
-BOE
EFS
,POUSBTUF

VOE
EFS
ÛQQJHFO
4DIÕOIFJUi














































͆Ͱ͸ͪͯ
ͪͅ͵;ΓͰͬͳΕ
͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͯ͹
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ












/FOBE
.BLVMKFWJǀ
3FJTFO
VOE
,VMUVS
FJO
3FJTFGÛISFS
WPO
#FMHSBE
OBDI
8JFO
BVT
EFN
+BIS

































































͆ͳ͵͹Ͷͪ
͈ͪ͸͹ͬ
͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
;
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ

;
ͯͻ;ͭ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ

ͬͰ͵ͪ


































/JLPMB
1BOPW
3FJTFGÛISFS
JO
EFS
3FQVCMJL
.BLFEPOJFO


JO
EFS
[XFJUFO
)ÅMGUF
EFT

+BISIVOEFSUT



















































͋ͪͽΒͪ͸ͪ
̹͹͵ͪ͸
͈͹Ͱͽͳ͵ͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͅͳͶ͹΃ͪ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
͹ͯ
ͅͰͯͳͽͰͻͪ͸ͪ

ͯ͹
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͳ΀
͹ͫͻ͹͸ͪ͵ͪ
͑;ͷͪͯͳΒͰ







































5BUKBOB
#PLBO
1PFUJL
EFS
3FJTFGÛISFS
WPO
.JMPØ
$SOKBOTLJ
WPN
.JUUFMNFFS
CJT
[V
EFO
MFU[UFO
)ÛHFMO
»VNBEJKBT













































͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
̽ͳͷͳΕ
t̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻu
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͯ͸;
͹ͼ͹ͫ;
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͭ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͳΒͰ
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ













































-KVCPESBH
%JNJǀ
&JO
3FJTFGÛISFS
GÛS
FJOF
1FSTPO
FJO
#FJUSBH
[VS
(FTDIJDIUF
EFS
%JQMPNBUJF
EFT
TP[JBMJTUJTDIFO
+VHPTMBXJFOT





























͇ͭΔͰ͸
̹ͪ͵ͳΕ
̺͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
;
ͷͰ͸ͪΘͷͰ͸ͽ;
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹΁ͳ͹͸͹ͭ
ͷͳ͵ͼͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ










































0HOKFO
#BLJǀ
3FJTFGÛISFS
JN
.BOBHFNFOU
FJOFS
1SPNPUJPOTNJTDIVOH
EFT
#BMLBO
BMT
FJOFT
FJOIFJUMJDIFO
3FJTF[JFMT
GÛS
5PVSJTUFO















ͪͅ΃ͪ
̺;͵ͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ
͊ͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
͸ͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ;
























.BØB
7VLBOPWJǀ
.PEFSOF
3FJTFGÛISFS
JN
*OUFSOFU








































ͪͅΒͪ
͋͹ͯ͹ͻ͹ͬͳΕ
́͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ

ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ



























































.BKB
5PEPSPWJǀ
*OUFSOFUQSÅTFOUBUJPOFO
UPVSJTUJTDIFS
"OHFCPUF
FMFDUSPOJTDIF
3FJTFGÛISFS



























͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
͈
͉ͳͼͽͳΕ
͈͹;Ͳͯͪ͸͹ͼͽ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
t̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀i
͹
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ


























-KVCPESBH
1
3JTUJǀ
;VWFSMÅTTJHLFJU
EFS
%BUFO
t8IJUBLFST
"MNBOBDIi
ÛCFS
+VHPTMBXJFO










̸;ͽ͹ͻͳ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͪ













































"VUPSFO
EFS
#FJUSÅHF




















































̸̺͇͌̽͆
͉̾͐

̺ͳ΃Ͱ
͹ͯ
ͼͽ͹
ͳ
ͺͰͯͰͼͰͽ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
;͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͰ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͺ͹ͯͱͪ
͸ͻ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸Ͱ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͰ
͸ͪͲͳͬͪ
ͺ͹
ͳͷͰ͸;
΂͹ͬͰ͵ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͳ
͸ͪΒͲͪ
ͼͶ;ͱ͸ͳΒͳ
Ͳͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͳ
͸ͪͼͽͪ͸ͪ͵
ͳ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ

ͳ

ͬͰ͵ͪ

͉Ͱ΂
ΒͰ
͸ͪͻͪͬ͸͹
͹
̓ͪͻͶ;
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹Β
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂͵͹Β
͵;Εͳ
;
̈́ͪΒͺ΁ͳ
ͭ;
;
͵͹Β͹Β
ͼ;
͸ͪͼͽͪͶͳ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
ͽ;ͻͳ
ͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͳͶͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͈ͳ͹͸ͳͻͼ͵ͳ
ͺ͹ͯ;΀ͬͪͽ
̓ͪͻͶͪ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͬͻͶ͹
ͫͻͲ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪ͹
ͳͲ;
ͲͰͽ͸͹
ͺ͹ͺ;Ͷͪͻͪ͸
͵͹ͯ
͸ͪΒ΃ͳͻͰ
΂ͳͽͪͶͪ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ;ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͪ
ΒͰ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
͹ͼͷͳ
ͼͶͳ͹
΂ͳͽͪͬ;
ͼͰͻͳΒ;
ͼͶͳ΂͸ͳ΀
͵Δͳͭͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;Εͳ
;
ͼͬͪ͵͹Β
͹ͯ
Δͳ΀

͸Ͱ͵;
͸͹ͬ;
ͲͰͷΓ;
ͳͶͳ
͸͹ͬͳ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸

͌
ͯͻ;ͭ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
ΒͰ
ͼͬͰ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͻͪ
ͼͽͪ͹
ͺͪ
ͼ;
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂ͳ
΃ͳͻ͹ͷ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͺ͹΂ͰͶͳ
ͼ
ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͪΔͰͷ

ͳ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͰͷ
͹ͬͪ͵ͬͳ΀
͵Δͳͱͳ΁ͪ
͊ͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳͷ͹
ͼͪͷ͹
̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ

ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
)BSUMFCFO
(SJFCFO
#MVF
(VJEF
#FSMJU[
5IF
3PVHI
(VJEF

ͳͽͯ
́ͲͯͪͬͪΔͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
;

ͬͰ͵;
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪͬͪ
Ͱ͵ͼͺͪ͸ͲͳΒ;

ͺͪ
ͽͳͻͪͱͳ
ͺͻͰͶͪͲͰ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͼͽ͹ͽͳ͸ͪ
΀ͳΓͪͯͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻͪ͵ͪ

̺͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͼͪͷ͹
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸Ͱ

ͳͲͬ͹ͻͰ
ͼͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͳͼͽ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ;
Β;
ͼͶͳ͵;
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͪͷͰͻͪͬͪΒ;
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ

 ͑ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͳ
Ͳͪ
͸ͪΒ΃ͳͻ;
΂ͳͽͪͶͪ΂͵;
ͺ;ͫͶͳ͵;
͹͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͼͽ͹ͭͪ
ΒͰ
ͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͱͪ͸ͻ͹ͬͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸Ͱ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͰ
͸ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ

͹ͫͶͳ͵;ΒͰ
ͼͶͳ͵ͪ
t͹
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͷi

͋Ͱ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓ;Β;
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
̀ͫ͹ͻ͸ͳ͵;
ͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
͸ͪͺͳͼͪ͸ͳ

ͼ;
͸ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;
ͻͰͿͰͻͪͽͪ
ͺ͹ͯ͸Ͱͽͳ΀
͸ͪ
ͷͰΌ;͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͷ
͸ͪ;΂͸͹ͷ
ͼ͵;ͺ;

͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
͹ͯͻͱͪ͸
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
͹ͯ

ͯ͹

͹͵ͽ͹ͫͻͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪ
ͼͶ͹ͬ͹ͷ
t͊ͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͷ
ͺ͹
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳi
͇ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ
΁ͳΓ
͊͵;ͺͪ
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͭͪ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ

Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͳͷ
͸ͪ
ͻͪͲ͸ͳͷ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ΒͰͲͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ


ͳ
;

ͬͰ͵;
ͳͶͳ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸ͳͷ
;
ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻ͹͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͷͰͯͳΒͳͷͪ
ͳͼͺͳͽͪ
͵ͪ
͵͹
ͳ
͸ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ΒͰ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸
;
Δͳͷͪ
͋͹
ͼ;
ͯͰͶͪ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ

ͼͰ
͹ͭͶͰͯͪΒ;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
;
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
ͻͪͼͺͻͪͬΓͪ

͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
ͳ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
͹
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͳͷͪ
ͼͪ͹
ͫͻͪΕͪΒ;
͸ͪͼͰΓͳͷͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ΒͰͲͳ΁ͳͷͪ

ͳ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͳ
ͳͽͯ

͇ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪͽ͹ͻͳ
ͼ͵;ͺͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
Ͳͪ΀ͬͪΓ;Β;
̻Ͱ͹Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷ
ͼ͵͹ͷ
Ϳͪ͵;ͶͽͰͽ;
ͅͰͭͪͽͻͰ͸ͯ
;͸ͳͬͰͻͲͳͽͰͽͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰΔͰ͸ͳ΀
͸ͪ;͵ͪ

͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͷ
ͷ;ͲͰΒ;
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
̻ͰͽͰ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ;
(PFUIF*OTUJUVU

*OUFS
/BUJPOFT

;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͅͳ͸ͳͼͽͪͻͼͽͬ;
͸ͪ;͵Ͱ
ͳ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳ
ͽͰ
΂͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬͰ
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸Ͱ
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
͹ͯͻͱͪͬͪΔͰ

ͷͰΌ;͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͭ
͸ͪ;΂͸͹ͭ
ͼ͵;ͺͪ
t͊ͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͷ
ͺ͹
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹
ͺͳi

͚
͊
̓
͚͹ͻΌͰ
͊
͇̓͊͋́ͣ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
̸͊͆͌
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

̹͉̾̽̾̓̾́
̸͇̓
̸͇̻͇̈́̾̽̈́

͈͇͎̈́́͋́͐̓́

̸͈͉͇̾͆ͅ
̸͆
̸̸̹̈́̓͆͌

͋͹͵͹ͷ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͯͰͬͰͽ͸ͪͰͼͽ͹ͭ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
;
ͯͬͪͯͰͼͰͽ͹ͷ
ͬͰ͵;

;
͵ͪͽͪͶ͹Ͳͳͷͪ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂͵ͳ΀
͵;Εͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ΒͰͲͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
Ͷͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͭͻ΃ͽ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͺ͹
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
͈;ͽ͸ͳ͵;
ͳ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁;

ͫͳͶͰ
ͼ;
͸ͪ
ͻͪͼͺ͹ͶͪͭͪΔ;
ͻͪͲ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͻ;΂͸Ͱ
͵ΔͳͭͰ
Ͳͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹
ΌͰ
͵ͪͱͳͺ;ͽͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͬ͹ΌͰ
ͺ;ͽͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͬ͹
ͯͳ΂ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͼͬͰ
;
ͳͼͽ͹ͷ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
͹ͬͪΒ
ͺ͹Βͪͷ
ͺͻͰͬ͹ΌͰ͸

͸ͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ΒͰͲͳ͵
͌
͵Δͳͱͪͻͪͷͪ
ͼ;
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͵;ͺͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
̓ͪͻͶͪ

̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
Ͱͯͳ΁ͳΒͪ
)BOECVDI
GÛS
3FJTFOEF
WPO
,BSM
#BFEFLFS

̹ͳͫͶͳ
͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽͪ
Ͱͯͳ΁ͳΒͪ
.FZFST
3FJTFCÛDIFS

ͫͰ΂͵͹ͭ
͵Δͳͱͪ
ͻͪ
̸ͯ͹ͶͿͪ
͎ͪͻͽͶͰͫͰ͸Ͱ
)BSUMFCFOT
*MMVTUSJSUFS
'ÛISFS

ͫͰͻͶͳ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ

ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂ͪ
͋Ͱ͹ͫͪͶͯͪ
̻ͻͳͫͰ͸ͪ
(SJFCFO3FJTFGÛISFS

͈ͻͬ͹ͭ
ͯ;͸ͪͬͼ͵͹ͭ



͈͹Βͪͷ
ΒͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽ͹
ͺͻͰͬ͹ΌͰ͸
͸ͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ΒͰͲͳ͵
͌ͺ͹ͻͰͯͳ
͉Ͱ΂͸ͳ͵

ͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹ͭͪ
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸͹ͭ
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ

͆͹ͬͳ
͊ͪͯ̀ͪͭͻͰͫ
ͪͅͽͳ΁ͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͪ
m

ͪͅͽͳ΁ͪ
΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͪ


͉
͠͹ͬͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ
̈́
̸ͽͪ͸ͪ΁͵͹ͬͳΕ
͊ͳͼͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵ͳ
ͻͰ΂͸ͳ͵

ͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ
͆͹ͬͳ
͊ͪͯ
ͪͅͽͳ΁ͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͪ


#
(SVKJǀ
+
;JEBS

3FǁOJL
/FNBǁLPTSQTLPISWBUTLJ
J
TSQTLPISWBUTLPOFNBǁLJ
TB
LSBULPN
HSBNBUJLPN

OFNBǁLPH
KF[JLB
8ÕSUFSCVDI
%FVUTDITFSCPDSPBUJTDI
4FSCPDSPBUJTDIEFVUTDI
NJU
LVS[
FS
EFVUTDIFS
(SBNNBUJL
ƀFUSOBFTUP
J[EBOKF
$FUJOKF
0CPE

+
ƄVLBOPWJǀ
.

+PWBOPWJǀ
/
,PTUJǀ
#JSBǁ
#
1FUSPOJKFWJǀ
#
1PQPWJǀ
#
ÂJWPKJOPWJǀ
/FNBǁLPTSQTLJ

J
TSQTLPOFNBǁLJ
SFǁOJL
%FVUTDITFSCJTDIFT
VOE
TFSCJTDIEFVUTDIFT
8ÕSUFSCVDI
#FP
HSBE
#FPHSBETLJ
J[EBWBǁLPHSBêǁLJ
[BWPE

 ͚͹ͻΌͰ
͊
̓͹ͼͽͳΕ

ͺͪͻ͹ͫͻ͹ͯͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͪ
%JF
%POBV
WPO
1BTTBV
CJT
[VN
4DIXBS[FO
.F
FSF

Ͳͪͽͳͷ
͈͹ͶͳͭͶ͹ͽͪ
1PMZHMPUU

̽ͳ
ͅ͹͸ͪ
%V
.POU

ͪͅͻ͵ͪ
͈͹Ͷͪ

.BSDP
1PMP

ͳͽͯ
͋;
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
ͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ͼ͵͹ͻ͹
Ͳͪͫ͹ͻͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
ͳͲ
ͯͪΔͪ
̈́Ͱͪ
̺ͰͻͶͪ
-
8PFSM

̓ͪͻͶͪ
͈
̻ͳͽͰͻͪ
,BSM
1
(FVUFS

̸ͯ͹ͶͿͪ

͎ͰͶͯͰͻͪ
"EPMQG
)ÕMEFS

͍ͻͪ͸΁ͪ
̀ͳͫͰͻͪ
'SBO[
4JFCFS

ͳͽͯ
͊ͬͳ
͹͸ͳ

ͼͺͪͯͪΒ;
;
͹͸;
ͭͻ;ͺ;
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂ͪ
ͳ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͸ͪ
ͺͻͬ͹ͷ
ͷͰͼͽ;
ͺ;ͽ
͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͪ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͳ
΃ͳͻ͹Β
΂ͳͽͪͶͪ΂͵͹Β
ͺ;ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
ͺ͹͵;΃ͪͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͯ͹΂ͪͻͪ
Β;
ͻͰ΂Β;
ͳ
ͼͶͳ͵͹ͷ
͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͼͽͬͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
͈ͻ͹;΂ͪͬͪΒ;Εͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪͽ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͺ͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;

ͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;
ͭͻͪΌͰ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ;
͸ͪ
ͻͪͼͺ͹ͶͪͭͪΔ;
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͽͳ
͹

ͽͻͳ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͻͪͲͬͳͽ͵ͪ
͈ͻͬͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͯ͹ͬͰͲ;ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͻͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ
΂Ͱ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͽͻͪΒͰ
ͯ͹
͵ͻͪΒͪ
͈ͻͬ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͽΒ
͹ͯ

ͯ͹


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͌
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
͹ͯͼͰ͵
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͼͰ
ͼͬͻͼͽͪͽͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͳ
͹ͯ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹
͵ͻͪΒͪ
̽ͻ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
͋ͻͰΕͳ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ
ͼ;
͸ͪΒͲͪͯ

ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͰ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
͢ͳ΀
ͼ;
͹ͫͰͶͰͱͳͶͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
͸ͪͭͶͳ

ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͰ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͫͻ͹Β͸ͪ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ

ͻͪͲ͸ͳ΀
ͼͰͻͳΒͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ



(SJFCFOT
3FJTFGÛISFS

$BNJMMP
.PSHBO
%BMNBUJFO
#PTOJFO
)FS[FHPXJ
OB
.POUFOFHSP
VOE
EJF
+POJTDIFO
*OTFMO
#FSMJO
(PMETDINJEU

(SJFCFOT
3FJ
TFGÛISFS

"CCB[JB
EJF
ÕTUFSSFJDIJTDIF
3JWJFSB
VOE
,PSGV
1SBLUJTDIFS
3FJTFGÛISFS


"VëBHF #FSMJO (PMETDINJEU  )BSUMFCFOT *MMVTUSJSUFS 'ÛISFS  *MMVTUSJSUFS

'ÛISFS
EVSDI
%BMNBUJFO
"CCB[JB-VTTJOQJDDPMP

-ÅOHT
EFS
,ÛTUF
WPO
"MCBOJFO
CJT
,P
SGV
VOE
OBDI
EFO
JPOJTDIFO
*OTFMO

HÅO[MJDI
VNHFBSCFJUFUF
VOE
WFSNFISUF
"VëBHF
8JFO
1FTU
-FJQ[JH
"
)BSUMFCFOT
7FSMBH

(FVUFST
'ÛISFS
"CCB[JB
'JVNF
1PMB

VOE
-VTTJOQJDDPMP

OFVCF
"VëBHF %BSNTUBEU
-FJQ[JH
4UÅEUFCJMEFSm7FSMBH
,BSM
1

(FVUFS

8PFSMT
3FJTFIBOECÛDIFS
'ÛISFS
EVSDI
,POTUBOUJOPQFM
VOE
6NHFCVOH

-FJQ[JH
8PFSMT
3FJTFCÛDIFSWMH




̺ͪͱ͸ͳΒͪ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͪ
͹
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
*
#BDLFT
8FHXFJTFS
JO
EJF

'SFNEF
3FJTFGÛISFS
3FJTFSBUHFCFS
3FJTF[FJUTDISJѫFO
#FSHJTDI
(MBECBDI
ѮPNBT
.PSVT"LBE

#FOTCFSHFS
1SPUPLPMMF


*
,JFGFS
3FJTFQVCMJ[JTUJL
VOE
&OU
1SJWJMFHJTJFSVOH
EFT
3FJTFOT
JN

+BISIVOEFSU
BVGHF[FJHU
BN
#FJTQJFM
#BFEFLFS
4BM[
CVSH

4BM[CVSH
6OJW
(FJTUFTXJTT
'BL
%JTT


͚
͊
̓͹ͼͽͳΕ
̺ͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͼ͵͹

͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
͌
͆ͳ΃
ͳ
̺ͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͪ
**
͆ͳ΃

ͼͽͻ

%K
4
,PTUJǀ

#BFEFLFS
VOE
.FZFS
m
&JO
#JME
EFS
#BMLBOIBMCJOTFM
GÛS
3JTFOEF
#BMDBOJDB
999*7


̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

4

#
-BVUFSCBDI
#BFEFLFS
VOE
BOEFSF
3FJFTFGÛISFS
&JOF

1SPCMFNTLJ[[F
*O
;FJUTDISJѫ GÛS
7PMLTLVOEF



4

#
-BVUFSCBDI

i7PO
EFO
&JOXPIOFSOu
"MMUBHTEBSTUFMMVOHFO
JN
4QJFHFM
EFT
3FJTFGÛISFST
*O
;FJUTDISJѫ
GÛS
7PMLTLVOEF



4

-
/FVOMJOHFS
3FJTFGÛISFS
JN
8BOEFM
EFS
;FJU

8JFO

8JFOFS
4UBEU
VOE
-BOEFTCJCMJPUIFL
8FDITFMBVTTUFMMVOH
EFS
8JFOFS

4UBEU
VOE
-BOEFTCJCMJPUIFL


)
1PQQ
%BT
#JME
EFS
.JUUFMNFFSMÅOEFS
JO
EFS

3FJTFGÛISFS-JUFSBUVS
&JOF
7PSUSBHTSFJIF
JN
4PNNFSTFNFTUFS

1BTTBV
1BTTBWJB
6OJW7FSM

1BTTBVFS
.JUUFMNFFSTUVEJFO


)
1PQQ
3FJTFGÛISFS-JUFSBUVS
VOE

HFPHSBQIJTDIF
-BOEFTLVOEF
*O
(FPHSBQIJTDIF
3VOETDIBV
+H

.ÅS[

#E

4


8
)BVFOTUFJO
8FHXFJTFS
EVSDI
.FZFST
3FJTFCÛDIFS



#JCMJPHSB
 ̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͵ͪ͹
͹ͭͶͰͯͪͶ͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸; 

͈ͻͬͳ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ
m

͈;ͽ͸ͳ͵
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;

ͳ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͪͷͰͻͪͬͪ͹
ͯͪ
͹ͫͳ
ΌͰ
΁ͰͶ͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹
ͺ͹Ͷ;͹ͼͽͻͬ͹
ͷ͹ͻͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͼͪ
ͼ͹ͫ͹ͷ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹͸ͰͼͰ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ
͵͹
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ΒͰͻ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸ͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸ͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
;
ΒͰͯ͸͹Β

͵ΔͳͲͳ
͢Ͱͷ;
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͪ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫ͸ͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
͹ͬ͹ͭͪ
ͱͪ͸ͻͪ
͹
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
̸;ͼͽͻ͹
͌ͭͪͻͼ͵͹Β
ͳ
͋;ͻͼ͵͹Β
͆ͪͷͰͻ͸ͳ͵
ΒͰ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͷ͹ͻͪ͹
ͯͪ
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͺͻ͹
΂ͳͽͪ
ΒͰͯ͸͹
͹ͯ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
͹ͯ
͹ͬͳ΀
͵Δͳͱͳ΁ͪ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͫͳ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͽͰ͵
͸Ͱ
͹ͺ΃ͽ;
ͼͶͳ͵;
͹
Β;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹ͭ
͵͹͸ͽͳ͸Ͱ͸ͽͪ
͇
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹Ͷ;͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
ΒͰ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ
΁ͳΒͰ
΁ͻͺͰ͹
ͳͲ
͵Δͳͭͪ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸ͪ
̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵ͪ
ͪ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͳ

ͳͲ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͷ͹ͻͰͷ
͹ͯ
͋ͻͼͽͪ
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹
Β;ͱ͸ͳ΀

͹ͫͪͶͪ
͈ͰͶ͹ͺ͹͸ͰͲͪ

́Ͳͫ͹ͻ
͵Δͳͭͪ
͹
̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵͹Β
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪΒͬͰΕͳ
ΒͰͻ
ͼ;
͹͸Ͱ
͸ͪΒ
΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
ͳͲ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸;
ͳ
ͺͻͰ΃ͽͪͷͺͪͬͪ͸Ͱ
͌
Δͳͷͪ
ͼ;
͹ͺͳͼͳͬͪ͸ͳ

ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ
ͺͻͪͬ΁ͳ
͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
͸ͪ
͵͹ͺ͸;
ͳ
ͻͰ͵ͪͷͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͳ
ͺ͹
ͷ͹ͻ;
̺͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͹

̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵͹Β
ͫͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͯͰΓͰ͸ͳ
;
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
΁ͰͶͳ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͬͰͲͪ͸ͳ΀
ͲͪΒͰͯ
͸ͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͰͷ
ͪͶͳ
ͼ;
͹ͬͰ
΁ͰͶͳ͸Ͱ
ͳͼͽ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
ͫͳͶͰ
ͳ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳ

Ͳͪ
ͼͰͫͰ
͌Ͳ
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
ͯ͹ͺ;͸Ͱ
͹ͺͰͽ
ͽͰ
΁ͰͶͳ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰ΃ͽͪͷͺͪͬͪ͸Ͱ
;
͹ͫͶͳ͵;

͸Ͱ͵ͳ΀
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
͵ͪ͹
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
͹͸ͳ΀
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
΂ͳͽͪͶͪ΁
ͳ͸
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͼͪ͸
͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔ;
ͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͷ͹ͻͰͷ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺͻͳ͹ͫͪΓ;

͊ͬͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͳ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂ͳ
͹ͬ͹ͭͪ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ
̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿ
ͼ͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
͎ͪͻͽͶͰͫͰ͸
̻ͻͳͫͰ͸
ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͼͽͪͶ͸͹
ͻͪͯͳͶͳ
ͪ
ͻͰͯͪ͵ͽ͹ͻͳ

ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͪ
ͼ;
ͬͻͶ͹
ͼͽͻ;΂͸͹
ͺͻͰ͸͹ͼͳͶͳ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͰ
ͳͲ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
;
ͯͻ;
ͭͳ
͌
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
ͺ͹
̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵͹Β
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳ͹ͫͪΓͰ
ͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸
ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͷ͹ͻͪ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
̹͹ͼ͸Ͱ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
͏ͻ͸Ͱ

̻͹ͻͰ
͌
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͳ
ͯͰ͹
ͼͰͬͰͻ͸ͳ΀

ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
ͻͰ΂
ΒͰ
͸ͪͻͪͬ͸͹
͹
͹ͫͪͬͰͲ͸͹ͷ
͹ͺͳͼ;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
̽;
͸ͪͬ͹ͷ
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹
͏ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͷ͹ͻͪ

͋ͪ͵͹
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͯͬͪͯͰͼͰͽ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭ͹
ͳͲͯͪΔͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
ͳͲ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͹
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽ͹Β
ͯͻͱͪͬͳ
ͳͷͪ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͪͬͪ͸
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ
¸TUFSSFJDI6O
QIJF
NJU
"CCPMEVOHFO
5BCFMMFO
3FHJTUFS
VOE
FJOFS
&JOGÛISVOH
WPO
"MFY
8
)JOSJDITFO

4UBEUPMEFOEPSG
)JOSJDITFO

"
)JOSJDITFO
#BFEFLFST
3FJTFIBOECÛDIFS


WPMMTU
7FS[
EU
FOHM
V
GSBO[
"VTH
NJU
DISPOPM
¾CFSTJDIUTUBG
)PM[NJOEFO

)JOSJDITFO

"
)JOSJDITFO
#BFEFLFST
3FJTFIBOECÛDIFS

#JCMJPHSBQIJF


7FS[FJDIOJT

7FSMBHTHFTDIJDIUF
NJU
"CCJMEVOHFO
VOE
[VTÅU[MJDIFO

¾CFSTJDIUFO

"Vë #FWFSO )JOSJDITFO  ) 4BSLPXTLJ %BT
#JCMJPHSBQIJTDIF
*O
TUJUVU
7FSMBHTHFTDIJDIUF
VOE
#JCMJPHSBQIJF

.BOOIFJN
8JFO
;ÛSJDI

 ͚͹ͻΌͰ
͊
̓͹ͼͽͳΕ

HBSO
ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͰΓͰ͸͹
ΒͰ
;
ͽͻͳ
ͬͰΕͰ
΁ͰͶͳ͸Ͱ
ͪ

̸;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͫ

̀Ͱ
ͷΓͰ
;ͭͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
͵ͻ;͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͬ

̹͹ͼ͸ͪ
͈͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
;
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂͵͹Β
͵;Εͳ
̓ͪͻͶͪ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͷͰΔͪ
Β;
;
ͯͬͪ
ͷͪ΀ͪ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͺ͹
̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵͹Β
̻͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

͸ͪ

͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ͸͹Β
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͯͬͪͯͰͼͰͽ
ͳ
ͼͰͯͷ͹ͭ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸
ΒͰ
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͳ

ͽͰ͵ͼͽ
¸TUFSSFJDI6OHBSO
OFCTU
#PTOJFO
VOE
)FSDFHPWJOB
$FUJOKF
#FM
HSBE
#VLBSFTU
̸Ͷͳ
ͬͰΕ
;
͸ͪͻͰͯ͸͹ͷ
ͯͬͪͯͰͼͰͽ
ͳ
͹ͼͷ͹ͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
ͳͲ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹͸͹ͬ͹
ͺͻ͹ͷͰΔͰ͸
ͳͲ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͳͷͰ
̹͹
ͼ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͹ͯ΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸͹
¸TUFSSFJDI6OHBSO
OFCTU
$FUJOKF

#FMHSBE
#VLBSFTU
́ͼͽͳ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ
Ͳͪͺͪͱͪ
ͼͰ
ͳ
;
͸ͪͻͰͯ͸͹ͷ

ͳͲͯͪΔ;

͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸͹ͷ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

̓ͪͯͪ
ͼͰ
;ͺ͹ͻͰͯͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͳ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͪ
ͽͻͳ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
ͼͪ
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ
͸ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͳ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂͵ͪ
ͯͪ
;
ͼͽͬͪͻͳ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ΀
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵ͪ

͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
͌
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯͰΓͪ͵
ΒͰ
͸͹ͼͳ͹
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ

̹͹ͼ͸ͪ
̻͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽ͹ͭ
͹ͯͰΓ͵ͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰΔͰ͸
;
̹͹ͼ͸ͪ

ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͪ
ͪ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸;
ͯͪ͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽͪ͵
͈ͻͬ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ

͸ͪͲͳͬ
̹͹ͼ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͰͼͽͪΒͰ
ͼͪ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ͸͹ͭ
Ͷͳͼͽͪ
ͯ͹͵
ͼͰ
;
ͼͪ
ͯͻͱͪΒ;
͹͸
ͺ͹ΒͪͬΓ;ΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͻͪͬ͸͹ͺͻͪͬ͸ͳ
ͯͰ͹
ͅ͹͸ͪͻ΀ͳΒͰ
ͼͪ
͋ͳͻ͹Ͷ͹ͷ

̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
̹Ͱ΂͹ͷ
ͳͽͯ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
͏ͰͽͳΔͰ
ͳ
̹;͵;ͻͰ΃ͽ
ͫͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͳ
ͻͪ͸ͳΒͰ
͹ͺͳͼͳͬͪ͸ͳ
͵ͪ͹

ͷͰͼͽͪ
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͪͬ΁ͳͷͪ
͇ͯ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͹͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͳͼͽͪ͵
͸;ͽͳ
ͳ
;
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
*9
6OHBSO
,SPBUJFO
VOE
4MBXPOJFO
#FM
HSBE
ͳ
9
4JFCFOCÛSHFO
#VLBSFTU
͌
ͼͰͻͳΒͳ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽͪ
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ͹ͷ

.FZFST
3FJTFCÛDIFS
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͺ͹
̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵͹Β
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ

͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
ͯͻ;ͭͪ΂ͳΒͪ
͌
͹ͬͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
͸ͪͳͷͰ
Ͳͪͺͪͱͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͰͽ
ͬͰΕͳ΀

΁ͰͶͳ͸ͪ
ͪ
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
Δͳ΀
ͽͻͰΕͪ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬΓͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
̹͹ͼ͸ͪ

ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͪ
͌
ͼͬͳ΀
ͺͰͽ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ΀
΁ͰͶͳ͸ͪ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ͵;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ

ͼ;
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸ͳ
͸ͪΒͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ
ͺͻͪͬ΁ͳ
ͺ͹
̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵͹Β
ͪͶͳ
ͺ͹
΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͳͷͪ

ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹
͹ͯ
̽ͻͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
Β;ͱ͸͹
͹ͯ
͊ͪͬͰ
ͳ
̽;͸ͪͬͪ
͆ͪΒͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͳ
ͻͪͲͶ͹ͭ
ΒͰ

ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
ͬͰΕ
ͯ͹
ͽͪͯͪ
͹ͫΒͪ



0FTUFSSFJDI6OHBSO
)BOECVDI
GÛS
3FJTFOEF
WPO
,BSM
#BFEFLFS

"VëBHF
-FJQ[JH
7FSMBH
WPO
,BSM
#BFEFLFS

¸TUFSSFJDI6OHBSO
OFCTU
#PTOJFO
VOE
)FS
DFHPWJOB
$FUJOKF
#FMHSBE
#VLBSFTU
)BOECVDI
GÛS
3FJTFOEF
WPO
,BSM
#BFEFLFS


"VGMBHF
-FJQ[JH
7FSMBH
WPO
,BSM
#BFEFLFS

¸TUFSSFJDI6OHBSO
OFCTU
$FUJOKF

#FMHSBE
#VLBSFTU
)BOECVDI
GÛS
3FJTFOEF
WPO
,BSM
#BFEFLFS

"VGMBHF
-FJQ[JH

7FSMBH
WPO
,BSM
#BFEFLFS

 ̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͵ͪ͹
͹ͭͶͰͯͪͶ͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸; 

ͬͳ͹
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͺ͹
͋;ͻͼ͵͹Β
;
͵͹ΒͰͷ
ΒͰ
ΒͰͯ͸͹
͹ͯ
ͬͪͱ͸ͳ΀

ͷͰͼͽͪ
Ͳͪ;Ͳͳͷͪ͹
ͳ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
͊ͬͰ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͯ͹
ͼͪͯͪ
ͲͪͺͪͱͰ͸Ͱ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
ͯͬͪ
͸ͪΒͺ͹
Ͳ͸ͪͽͳΒͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͪ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂ͪ
̓ͪͻͶͪ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͳ
̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳ
ͽ;ͽͪ
͹ͭͶͰͯͪͶ͹
ͼ;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳͷͪ
̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵Ͱ

ͳ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
͈ͻͬͪ
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͪ
ͯͬͪͯͰͼͰͽ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ΒͰ

ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
͸Ͱͼ;ͭͶͪͼͳ΁ͪ
ͳ
͏ͪͻͳ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͽͰ
ΒͰ
ͼͶͳ͵ͪ
͵͹
Β͹ͷ
ΒͰ
̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵ͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ

͹ͯͻͪͲ
ͽͻͰ͸;ͽ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͼͳͽ;ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
;
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
͈ͻͳ͹ͫͪΓͰ
ͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͷ͹ͻͪ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
͏ͻ͸ͪ
̻͹ͻͪ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳ
ΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
͵͹Β;
ͲͪͺΓ;ͼ͵;ΒͰ
͠͹͸ͼ͵͹
ͷ͹ͻͰ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸͹
ͼͪ

ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳͷ
͹ͼͽͻͬͳͷͪ
̓ͻͿ͹ͷ
ͳ
̓ͰͿͪͶ͹͸ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͫͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ

ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵;
͹ͺͰͽ
;
ͲͪͼͰͫ͸͹Β
͵Δͳͱͳ΁ͳ
͌
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ;
ͻͰ΂
ΒͰ
͹
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͷͪ
Ͳͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶ͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͳͷ
;
ΒͰͯ͸͹Β
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪ
ͽͳΒͳ΀
ͫͰ΂͵ͳ΀
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂͵ͳ΀
͵;Εͪ
̸ͯ͹ͶͿͪ
͎ͪͻͽͶͰͫͰ͸ͪ
͇ͯ
̹ͰͻͶͳ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ



.FZFST
3FJTFCÛDIFS
0FTUFSSFJDI
VOE
EBT
BOHSFO[FOEF
6OHBSO

VNHFBS
CFJUFUF
"VGMBHF
-FJQ[JH
8JFO
#JCMJPHSBQIJTDIFT
*OTUJUVU

0FTUFSSFJDI6OHBSO

#PTOJFO
VOE
)FS[FHPXJOB

"VGMBHF
-FJQ[JH
#JCMJPHSBQIJTDIFT
*OTUJUVU

.FZ
FST
3FJTFCÛDIFS
0FTUFSSFJDI6OHBSO
#PTOJFO
VOE
)FS[FHPXJOB

WFSNFISUF
"VGMB
HF
-FJQ[JH
8JFO
#JCMJPHSBQIJTDIFT
*OTUJUVU

 ͚͹ͻΌͰ
͊
̓͹ͼͽͳΕ

͵͹͸ͭͻͰͼͪ
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹
͈ͻͬ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ

ͻͪͽͪ
͹ͬͯͰ
ͼ;
ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͪ͸Ͱ
͵Δͳ
ͱͳ΁Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
͸͹ͼͳͶͰ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ

͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ
"
)BSUMFCFOT
JMMVTUSJSUFS

'ÛISFS
ͼ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ͸ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯ͸ͪ
ͼͶ͹ͬ͹ͷ
)BOECVDI
GÛS
5PVSJTUFO

VOE
(FTDIÅGUTm3FJTFOEF
ͭͯͰ
ͼ;

ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͺ͹
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳͷ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͳ
ͷͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪͷͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͺ͹͵ͻͪΒͳ͸ͪͷͪ

͹ͫͰͶͰͱͪͬͪ͸ͳ
ͫͻ͹ΒͰͬͳͷͪ
͋ͪ͵͹

ͫͻ͹Β

͸͹ͼͰ
ͼͬͪ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹
ΌͰ
ͺ͹
͋ͻͼͽ;
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹Β
͹͵͹Ͷͳ͸ͳ

͠Ͱͯͪ͸ͪͰͼͽ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
͹ͯ

ͯ͹


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳͶ;ͼͽͻ͹ͬͪ͸͹ͭ
ͬ͹
ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͺ͹
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͳ
ͳͷͪΒ;
ͫͻ͹Β


ͯ͹͵
ͼ;
ͽͻͳ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ

ͺ͹
̹͹ͼ͸ͳ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
͹ͫͰͶͰ
ͱͰ͸ͪ
ͫͻ͹ΒͰͷ

͎ͪͻͽͶͰͫͰ͸͹ͬͰ
͵Δͳͱͳ΁Ͱ
ͼ;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸ͳ
;ͱͳ
ͳͶͳ

΃ͳͻͳ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸
͈ͪͱΔͪ
ͻͰͯͪ͵ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͳ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
;ͼͷͰͻͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
ͺͻ
ͬ͹ͷ
ͷͰͼͽ;
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳ͹ͫͪΓͰ
ͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͷ͹ͻͪ
͹ͯ
͋ͻͼͽͪ
ͯ͹
͠͹͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
͹ͼͽͻ
ͬͪ
ͪ
;
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͰ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹
͈ͳͻͰΒͪ
͇

ͲͪͶͰΌ;
ͼͰ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͺͳͼͪͶ͹
ͳ
ͻͪͼͺͻͪͬΓͪͶ͹
ͼͪͷ͹
ΒͰ
;͵ͻͪͽ͵͹
;͵ͪͲͪ
͸͹
͸ͪ
͸ͪΒͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͪͬ΁Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͅͰͽ͵͹ͬͳΕ
m
͊ͪͻͪΒͰͬ͹
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ

m
͏ͰͽͳΔͰ
ͳͽͯ
́ͼͽͪ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
ͺͻͳͼ;ͽ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
;
ͽͻͳ
ͺ͹ͷͰ
͸;ͽͪ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
͹
̹͹ͼ͸ͳ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
͊ͬͪ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͪͷ͹

͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸;
͹ͺͳͼ;
ͺ;ͽͰͬͪ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͳ΀
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͪ
͊ͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
;
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
̓ͪͻͶͪ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͳ
̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿ
ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽͪ
;ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͷͰ
ͼͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;ΒͰ
͹ͯ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ΀
͵Δͳͱͳ΁ͪ
ͫͰ΂
͵͹ͭ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂ͪ
̸ͯ͹ͶͿͪ
͎ͪͻͽͶͰͫͰ͸ͪ



)BSUMFCFOAT
*MMVTUSJSUFS
'ÛISFS

*MMVTUSJSUFS
'ÛISFS
EVSDI
5SJFTU
VOE
6NHF
CVOHFO
OFCTU
"VTGMÛHFO
OBDI
"RVJMFKB
(ÕS[
1PMB
'JVNF
"CCB[JB
VOE
7FOFEJH
EVSDI

*TUSJFO
JN
2VBSOFSP
BVG
EFS
1POUFCCB#BIO
OBDI
EFN
8ÕSUIFSTFF
,MBHFOGVSU
VOE

0CFS,SBJO

HÅO[MJDI
VNHFBSCFJUF
"VGMBHF
8JFO
1FTU
-FJQ[JH
"
)BSUMFCFOT
7FS
MBH

)BSUMFCFOAT
*MMVTUSJSUFS
'ÛISFS

*MMVTUSJFSUFS
'ÛISFS
EVSDI
%BMNBUJFO
MÅOHT

EFS
,ÛTUF
WPO
"MCBOJFO
CJT
,PSGV
VOE
OBDI
EFO
*POJTDIFO
*OTFMO

"VGMBHF
8JFO
1FTU

-FJQ[JH
"
)BSUMFCFOT
7FSMBH

)BSUMFCFOAT
*MMVTUSJFSUFS
'ÛISFS

$
"
/FVGFME
.ÛODIFO

+VMJVT
1PKNBO
*MMVTUSJFSUFS
'ÛISFS
EVSDI
#PTOJFO
VOE
EJF
)FSDFHPXJOB


WPMMLPNNFO
OFV
CFBSCFJUFUF
"VGMBHF
8JFO
-FJQ[JH
"
)BSUMFCFOT
7FSMBH

 ̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͵ͪ͹
͹ͭͶͰͯͪͶ͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸; 

̓ͪͻͶ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ
ͳ
̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͫͪͻͰͷ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ

;
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
ͼͪͷ
Β;ͭ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹Ͷ;͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
̸;ͼͽͻ͹
͌ͭͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
΂ͬͻͼͽ͹
ͯͻͱͪͶͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪ
̺͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͺ͹

̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
ͳ
̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵͹Β
ͼͪͷ͹
ͺ͹ͽͬͻΌ;Β;
͹ͬ;
ͽͰͲ;
͈;ͽ͸ͳ͵
ΒͰ
ͯͰ
ͽͪΓ͸͹
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͼͪ͸
͹
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͪͬ΁ͳͷͪ
ͳͶͳ
͸ͪͼͰΓͳͷͪ
͸ͪ
Δͳͷͪ

ͪͶͳ
ͼͽͻ͹ͭ͹
;
͹͵ͬͳͻͳͷͪ
ͽͪͯͪ΃Δͳ΀
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳ΀

ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
̀ͪ
ͬͰͲ;
ͼͪ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳͷ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳͷͪ
;ͬͰ͵
ΒͰ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ͵
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ

;ͺ;Εͳͬͪ͸
͸ͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂Ͱ
ͳͲ
ͼͶͳ΂͸ͳ΀
ͼͰͻͳΒͪ
̈́ͪΒͺ΁ͳ΃͵ͳ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂ͳ

̓ͪͻͶ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ
ͳ
̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
ͼ;
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
Β;ͱ͸͹
͹ͯ

͊ͪͬͰ
ͳ
̽;͸ͪͬͪ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁;
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂ͳͬͪͶͳ
ͼͬ͹Βͪ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
͹
͋;ͻͼ͵͹Β
ͳ

ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
Ͳͪ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰ
ͼͪ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ

ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹
ͳ
Β;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹
͹ͯ
͋ͻͼͽͪ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳͽͳ

ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͺ͹
͊ͰͬͰͻ͸͹Β
͊ͻͰͯΔ͹Β
ͳͶͳ
͠;ͱ͸͹Β
́ͽͪͶͳΒͳ
͊ͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͪ
ͺ͹ͷͰ
͸;ͽͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
̓ͪͻͶͪ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͳ
̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽͪ
ͺ͹
Ͳͪ
ͺͪͯ͸͹ͷ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵͹ͬͪͶͪ
͹ͯ
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͰ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ

ͺ͹
͹ͼͽͪͶͳͷ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪͷͪ
ͽ͹ͭͪ
ͯ͹ͫͪ
͌
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
͎ͪͻͽͶͰͫͰ͸ͪ
ͳͲ
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
͹ͬ͹
ͼͽͻͳ͵ͽ͸͹
ͺ͹
΃ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹
ͼͰ
ͭ;ͫͳ
͎ͪͻͽͶͰͫͰ͸͹ͬͳ
ͳͶ;
ͼͽͻ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͹ͭͶͰͯͪͶ͹
ͼ;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͪͷͫͳ΁ͳΒͪ
̹Ͱ΂͵͹ͭ
ͯͬ͹ͻͪ

΁ͰͶͪ
ͳͼͽ͹΂͸ͪ
͹ͫͪͶͪ
ͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͷ͹ͻͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
ͼͰ
;
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͸͹Β
ͼͿͰͻͳ

̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
͊ͽ͹ͭͪ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͹ͺͳͼͳ
ͺͶ͹ͬͳͯͫͰ
ͺ͹Ͷͪ͵͹
ͺͻ͹ͯ;ͱͪͬͪͶͳ

 ͚͹ͻΌͰ
͊
̓͹ͼͽͳΕ

͹ͯ
̓ͻͿͪ
ͳ
̓ͰͿͪͶ͹͸ͳΒͰ
;
ͺͻͬͳͷ
ͳͲ
ͯͪΔͳͷͪ
ͯ͹
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ

ͳ
͈ͳͻͰΒͪ
;
ΒͰͯͪ͸ͪͰͼͽ͹ͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
ͳͲ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

͌
ͯͻ;ͭ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ

ͳ
ͺͻ
ͬͳͷ
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͪͷͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
ΒͰͯ
͸͹Β
ͲͰͷΓͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͺ͹
ͼͬͰΕͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸ͪ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
̹ͳͶͪ
ΒͰ

ͽ͹
͸ͪͻͪͬ͸͹
̻ͻ΂͵ͪ
;
ΔͰ͸ͳͷ
ͽͪͯͪ
΃Δͳͷ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
́Ͳͯͪͬͪ΂͵ͪ
͵;Εͪ

̓ͪͻͶͪ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
͹ͫΒͪͬͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͰͽ
ͳͲ
ͯͪΔͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
Ͳͪ
̻ͻ΂͵;





ͳ


͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͬ͹
ͯͳ΂
ͺ͹
̸ͽͳ͸ͳ


̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
;

Ͱͯͳ΁ͳΒͳ
.FZFST
3FJTFCÛDIFS
ͺ͹΂Ͱ͹

ΒͰ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͫͪͬͳ
̻ͻ΂͵͹ͷ
ͪͶͳ

ͺͻͬ͹
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
;
͵͹ΒͰͷ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͸ͪ΃ͶͰ
ͳ
͊ͳͻͳΒͪ
͈ͪͶͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ
ͳ
͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ



ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
;
ͯͬͪ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ͹ͷ
5ÛSLFJ
VOE
(SJFDIFOMBOE

6OUFSF
%POBVMÅOEFS
VOE
,MFJOBTJFO



ͳ
͸ͪ
͵ͻͪΒ;
;
Β͹΃
ͽͻͳ

ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼ;
ͳͷͪͶͪ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ
,MFJOBTJFO
VOE
(SJFDIFOMBOE
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹

(SJFDIFOMBOE
VOE
,MFJOBTJFO





͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
;
͹ͬ;
ͲͰͷΓ;
͸ͳΒͰ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
tͳͲ;ͲͰͽͪ͸
ͼͻͰΕͪ͸
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ
;

ͱͳͬ͹ͽ;i
͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
ͲͪͫͰͶͰͱͰ͸͹
;
;ͬ͹ͯ;
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
͹ͯ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹
ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͬͰΕ
ΒͰ
ͼͬͰ
ͬͰΕͳ
ͫͻ͹Β
͹͸ͳ΀
͵͹Βͳ
ͱͰͶͰ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ
tͯ͹ͷ͹ͬͳ͸;
ͼͬͳ΀

ͶͰͺ͹ͽͪ
͵Ͷͪͼͳ΂͸;
ͲͰͷΓ;
͎ͰͶͪͯͰi
́
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͼͬͳ΀
ͻͪͲͪͻͪΔͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼ;
΂ͳ
͸ͳͶͳ
tͬͻͰͷͰ
ͳ
Γ;ͯͼ͵ͳ
͸Ͱͷͪͻi
ͭͻ΂͵͹
ͽͶ͹
ͺͻ;ͱͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳͷͪ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽ;
ͳ



(SJFDIFOMBOE
)BOECVDI
GÛS
3FJTFOEF
WPO
,BSM
#BFEFLFS

"VGMBHF
-FJQ[JH

7FSMBH
WPO
,BSM
#BFEFLFS

"UIFO
)BOECVDI
GÛS
3FJTFOEF
WPO
,BSM
#BFEFLFS


"VGMBHF
-FJQ[JH
7FSMBH
WPO
,BSM
#BFEFLFS



.FZFST
3FJTFCÛDIFS
4ZSJFO
1BMÅTUJOB
(SJFDIFOMBOE
VOE
5ÛSLFJ

"VGMBHF

-FJQ[JH
#JCMJPHSBQIJTDIFT
*OTUJUVU

5ÛSLFJ
VOE
(SJFDIFOMBOE
6OUFSF
%POBVMÅO
EFS
VOE
,MFJOBTJFO

"VGMBHF
-FJQ[JH
#JCMJPHSBQIJTDIFT
*OTUJUVU

5ÛSLFJ
VOE

(SJFDIFOMBOE
6OUFSF
%POBVMÅOEFS
VOE
,MFJOBTJFO

"VGMBHF
-FJQ[JH
8JFO
#JCMJP
HSBQIJTDIFT
*OTUJUVU

6OUFSF
%POBVMÅOEFS
VOE
5ÛSLFJ

"VGMBHF
-FJQ[JH
8JFO

#JCMJPHSBQIJTDIFT
*OTUJUVU

5ÛSLFJ
3VNÅOJFO
4FSCJFO
#VMHBSJFO

"VGMBHF

-FJQ[JH
8JFO
#JCMJPHSBQIJTDIFT
*OTUJUVU

5ÛSLFJ
3VNÅOJFO
4FSCJFO
#VMHBSJFO


"VGMBHF
-FJQ[JH
8JFO
#JCMJPHSBQIJTDIFT
*OTUJUVU

5ÛSLFJ
3VNÅOJFO
4FSCJFO

#VMHBSJFO

"VGMBHF
-FJQ[JH
8JFO
#JCMJPHSBQIJTDIFT
*OTUJUVU

#BMLBOTUBBUFO

VOE
,POTUBOUJOPQFM
"OBUPMJTDIF
VOE
#BHEBECBIO


"VGMBHF
-FJQ[JH
8JFO
#JCMJP
HSBQIJTDIFT
*OTUJUVU

 ̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͵ͪ͹
͹ͭͶͰͯͪͶ͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸; 

ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͫͻ͹Β͸ͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ͲͪͼͽͪΒͰ
ͯͪ΀
͋;
ͼ;
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͳ
ͯ;ͫ͹͵͹
ͺͶͪͬ͹

ͷ͹ͻͰ
Ͳͯͻͪͬ
ͬͪͲͯ;΀
ͳ
ͺͻͪͬͪ
΀ͪͻͷ͹͸ͳΒͪ
ͫ͹Βͪ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͪ
ͺ͹Γͪ
ͭͻͪΌͰͬͳ
͸ͪ
ͳ
ͬͰͭͰͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͇ͬͰ
ͻͰ΂ͳ
ͳͲ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽ͹ͭ
;ͬ͹ͯͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͺ͹
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ
͸Ͱ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲ;Β;
ͼͪ
͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
Γ;ͫͪͬͳ
ͳ
ͺͪͱΔͰ
ͼ;
ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͪ͸Ͱ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
ͺ͹

͹ͬ͹Β
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹Β
ͲͰͷΓͳ
̸Ͷͳ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ
͸ͳ
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ;
͸ͳΒͰ
͹ͯͼͽ;
ͺͳ͹
͹ͯ
;͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͰ͸Ͱ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͰ
͵ΔͳͭͰ
ͼͬͰ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪ͸͹
ͳ
͹ͺͳ
ͼͪ͸͹
Ͳͪ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒ;
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
;
ΔͰ͸ͳͷ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂
͵ͳͷ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͪ
ͽ͹
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͳ
ͯ͹
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͋ͰͼͪͶͳΒͰ
ΒͰͻ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ

ͯͪ͸ͪ΃ΔͰ
͊ͰͬͰͻ͸Ͱ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͰ
;
͹͵ͬͳͻͳͷͪ
͇ͼͷͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ

΁ͪͻͼͽͬͪ

̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͺ͹
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
ͫͳͶͳ
ͼ;
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͯͰΓͰ͸ͳ
;

΂Ͱͽͳͻͳ
ͬͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
΁ͰͶͳ͸Ͱ
̸ͽͳ͸ͪ
ͼͪ
͹͵͹Ͷͳ͸͹ͷ
ͺͻͬͪ
ͼͰͬͰͻ͸ͳ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳ

ͼͪ
͹ͺͳͼͳͷͪ
͋Ͱͻͷ͹ͺͳͶͪ
̺͹Ͷ͹ͼͪ
ͳ
̈́ͪͻͳͼͰ
ͯͻ;ͭͪ
͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
̾;ͫͰΒͪ
̓ͳ
͵ͶͪͯͰ
ͳ
͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
͠͹͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͷ͹ͻͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͰ
ͼͰ
;
ͽͻͰΕ͹Β
΁ͰͶͳ͸ͳ
ͪ
;
΂Ͱͽͬͻͽ͹Β

͵͹͸ͪ΂͸͹
͈ͰͶ͹ͺ͹͸ͰͲ
͈ͻͳͺͻͰͷͪΒ;Εͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂Ͱ
ͺ͹
͋;ͻͼ͵͹Β
ͳ
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͳ
ͳ
ͻͰͯͪ͵ͽ͹
ͻͳ
̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽͪ
͹ͯͼͽ;ͺͳͶͳ
ͼ;
͹ͯ
ͼͬ͹Βͳ΀
;͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͰ͸ͳ΀

͵͹͸΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͪ
̻ͻ΂͵ͪ
ΒͰ
;
Δͳ΀͹ͬͳͷ
͵Δͳͱͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
͸Ͱ
;
ͺ͹
Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬͰΕ
;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
͹͵ͬͳͻͳͷͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹
ͽͶ͹

̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͬͰͲͪ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͼ
͹ͫͪͶ͹ͷ
ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ
͋ͻ͹Βͪ
͈Ͱͻͭͪͷ͹͸
͎ͪͶͳ͵ͪͻ
͸ͪͼ
̾ͿͰͼ
ͅͳͶͰͽ
̽ͳͯͳͷͪ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͯͰ͹
ͼ;
ͭͻ΂͵͹ͭ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ

ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
ͳ
͸͹ͬͰ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͸ͳͼ;
;
ͼͽͪΔ;
ͯͪ

ͻͪͲͯͬ͹ΒͰ
ͳ
ͳͲͫͻͳ΃;
ͽ;
ͬͰͲ;
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
ͯͬͪ
͵͹͸ͽͳ͸Ͱ͸ͽͪ
͏Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹΂͸ͳ
ͯͰ͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹Ͷ;͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
͹ͺͳͼͳͬͪ͸ͳ

ͼ;
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
͵ͪ͹
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪ
͆ͳΒͰͯ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ

͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͬ͹Β
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
ͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͷͰΌ;͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹
ͺͻͳͲ͸ͪ
ͽͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
͉;ͷ;͸ͳΒͪ
͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ
̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͯ͹ͫͳͶͪ
ͲͪͼͰͫ͸;

͵Δͳͭ;
͇
Δͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͳͼͪ͸͹
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸͹
ͼ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳͷ
ͪͶͳ
ΒͰ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶ͸͹
ͷͰͼͽ͹

ͳͺͪ͵
Ͳͪ;ͲͳͷͪͶͪ
͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ

͊ͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͬͪ͵ͬͪ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͲͪͬͳͼͳͶͪ
;
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸͹Β

ͷͰͻͳ
ͳ
͹ͯ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͼͰΕͳͬͪͶͳ

ͽͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͊ͬͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ
ͺͻͪͬ΁ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͷͪ
́ͼͽͪͷͫ;Ͷ;
ͽͪ͵͹
ͯͪ

ͼ;
ͼͬͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼ;
ͺͻ;ͭͰ
ͺͻ͹ͶͪͲͳͶͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ͸Ͱ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ

ͳ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͵Δͳͱͳ΁ͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
;
͸ͪΒ͵ͻͪΕͳͷ
΁ͻͽͪͷͪ

͇ͺͳͼͳͷͪ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿ
ͼ͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
ͳͲ
̈́ͪΒͺ΁ͳͭͪ
ͺ͹΂Ͱ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͫͪͬͳ
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͹ͯ
ͯͬͰ

ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͪ
ͺͻͰ
̓ͪͻͶͪ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
͋ͪ΂͸ͳΒͰ
Β͹΃

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͻͰͯͪ͵΁ͳΒͪ

͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂ͪ
ͺ͹͵ͻͰ͸;Ͷͪ
ΒͰ
͸͹ͬ;
ͼͰͻͳΒ;
ͺ͹ͯ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΂͵ͳͷ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ͹ͷ

 ͚͹ͻΌͰ
͊
̓͹ͼͽͳΕ

͇ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽ
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
;
Δ͹Β
;
ͺͻͬ͹ͷ
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͷ
ͳͲ

ͳ
ͽͻͰΕͰͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔ;

ͳͲ

͸ͪ΃ͶͰ
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸Ͱ
͊ͳͻͳΒͪ
͈ͪͶͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ
̻ͻ΂͵ͪ
͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͯ;͸ͪͬ
ͼ͵Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͳ
ͪͅͶͪ
̸ͲͳΒͪ
͇ͯ
΂Ͱͽͬͻͽ͹ͭ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
ͻͰͯͪ͵ͽ͹ͻͳ
ΕͰ
͵͹͸ͪ΂
͸͹
;
ΒͰͯ͸;
͵Δͳͱͳ΁;
ͳͲͯͬ͹Βͳͽͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͪ

͹ͯ
ͺͰͽ͹ͭ
ͯ͹
ͼͰͯͷ͹ͭ
͹͸Ͱ
ΕͰ
ͳͷͪͽͳ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ
5ÛSLFJ
3VNÅOJFO
4FSCJFO

#VMHBSJFO
͆Ͱͺ;͸ͪ
ͽͻͳ
ͷͰͼͰ΁ͪ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͳͲͫͳΒͪΔͰ
͈ͻͬ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ

͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
Ͳͪͺͳͼͪ͸͹
;
ͺͻͰͯͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ;
̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
Β͹΃

ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
ͷͰΔͪ
ͳͷͰ
͌
͹ͼͷ͹ͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
ͼͪͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͺͻ͹΂ͳͽͪͽͳ
#BMLBO
TUBBUFO
VOE
,POTUBOUJOPQFM
"OBUPMJTDIF
VOE
#BHEBECBIO

͠͹΃
͹ͯ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͫΒͪͬͳ͹
ͺͻͬ͹
ͳͲͯͪΔͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
Ͳͪ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͺ͹
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
̓ͪͻͶ;
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;
ͼ;
͹ͼͽͪͶͰ
ͺ͹
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ

ͯͪ͸ͪ΃ΔͰ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
͉;ͷ;͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
͋;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
͋Ͱ͵
;
ͺͻͬ͹Β
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͳ

ͯͬͪͯͰͼͰͽ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
;
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂͵͹Β
͵;Εͳ
̓ͪͻͶ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ
;
̈́ͪΒͺ΁ͳͭ;
ͺͻͳ
ͺͻͰͷΓͰ͸ͪ
ͼ;
ͳ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͪ
ͯͬͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
͵͹͸ͪ΂͸͹

Ͳͪ͹͵ͻ;ͱͰ͸ͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸ͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͪ

͈ͻͬ͹
ͳͲͯͪΔͰ
ͳͲ

͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ͹ͷ
,POTUBOUJOP
QFM
VOE
EBT
XFTUMJDIF
,MFJOBTJFO
ͯ͹͵
ͯͻ;ͭ͹
ͺͻ͹΃ͳͻͰ͸͹
ͺ͹ͯͼͰΕͪ
͸ͪ

͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽͪ
ͳ
ͭͶͪͼͳ
,POTUBOUJOPQFM

#BMLBOTUBBUFO
,MFJOBTJFO
"SDIJQFM
$ZQSFO
́
͵͹ͯ
̓ͪͻͶͪ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͪ͵΁Ͱ͸ͪͽ
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
͋;ͻͼ͵͹Β
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
̓͹͸ͼͽͪ͸
ͽͳ͸͹ͺ͹Γ;
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ
͇ͺͳͼͳ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͻ͹Ͷͪ
ͲͳͶ͹
ͼ;
΂ͪ͵
͵ͻͪΕͳ
ͳ
ͼͪͱͰͽͳΒͳ
͸Ͱͭ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
ͲͪͺͪͱͰ͸͹
;
ͳͲͯͪΔ;

̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽͪ
ͅͰΔͪΒ;Εͳ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬͰ
ͼͬ͹Βͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͳ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ

ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͺ͹Βͷ͹ͬͰ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͳ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ
ͳ
͸ͪΒ΃ͳͻ͹Β
΂ͳͽͪͶͪ΂
͵͹Β
ͺ;ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͯ;͸ͪͬͼ͵Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
ͺ͹͵;΃ͪ
ͬͪΒ;Εͳ
ͳ
͸ͪ
͹ͬͪΒ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͯͪ
ͳ΀
ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͰ
͵ͻͪΒΔͰͷ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ͵;
̸Ͷͳ

ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
ͯ;ͭ͹
ͼͰ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͷͰΔͪͶͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
͸ͪ
Δ͹Β
ΒͰ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ
ͬͰ͸ͳͼͪ͸͹
ͼͪͷ͹
;
͵ͻͪΒΔ͹Β
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͳ
̓ΔͳͭͰ
ͼ;
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͽͰ
ͬͻͼͽͰ

ͺ͹ͯͰΓͰ͸Ͱ
;
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
΁ͰͶͳ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ͼͰ
ͳͲͯͬͪΒͪΒ;
ͯͬͰ

͈ͻͬͪ
ͼͪͯͻͱͳ
͹ͺͳͼ
ͳ
ͼͪͬͰͽ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͺ͹
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
͉;ͷ;͸ͳΒͳ
ͳ

̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵͹Β
͸ͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͪͬ΁ͳͷͪ

ͪ

͵͹ͺ͸Ͱ͸ͳͷ
ͬ͹Ͳ͹ͷ
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
͆ͳ΃ͪ
Ͳͪ
͊͹ͿͳΒ;
ͳ

́ͼͽͪͷͫ;Ͷ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
͹ͯ
͆ͳ΃ͪ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
͊͵͹ͺΓͪ
Ͳͪ
͊͹Ͷ;͸
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͹ͯ
ͯͪ͸ͪ
΃ΔͰͭ
ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͭ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ
Ͳͪ
͈ͻͳ΃ͽͳ͸;
ͳ
̓͹ͼ͹ͬͼ͵;
ͅͳͽͻ͹
ͬͳ΁;



)BOECVDI
GÛS
3FJTFOEF
WPO
,BSM
#BFEFLFS
,POTUBOUJOPQFM
VOE
EBT
XFTUMJDIF

,MFJOBTJFO
-FJQ[JH
7FSMBH
WPO
,BSM
#BFEFLFS

)BOECVDI
GÛS
3FJTFOEF
WPO
,BSM

#BFEFLFS
,POTUBOUJOPQFM
#BMLBOTUBBUFO
,MFJOBTJFO
"SDIJQFM
$ZQFSO

"VGMBHF
/F
CFOU
#BFEFLFST
,POTUBOUJOPQFM
VOE
,MFJOBTJFO
-FJQ[JH
7FSMBH
WPO
,BSM
#BFEFLFS


 ̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͵ͪ͹
͹ͭͶͰͯͪͶ͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸; 

ͫ

ͬ͹ͯͰ͸ͳͷ
͹ͯ
̹;ͯͳͷͺͰ΃ͽͰ
ͫͻ͹ͯ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
͋;ͻ͸͊Ͱ
ͬͰͻͳ͸ͪ
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹
ͯͰͶͽͰ
̽;͸ͪͬͪ
ͳ
͏ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͷ͹ͻͪ

̽ͻ;ͭͳ
ͬͰΕͳ
ͯͰ͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸
́ͼͽͪͷͫ;Ͷ;
ͪͅͶ͹Β

̸ͲͳΒͳ
ͳ
ͼͰͬͰͻ͸ͳͷ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳͷͪ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͽͪͯͪ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͳ

;
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
͋;ͻͼ͵͹ͭ
΁ͪͻͼͽͬͪ

͇͸͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼͳͭ;ͻ͸͹
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͳͼͽͪΕͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΂͵;
΁ͻͽ;
ͳ
;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹
Όͪͷͪ
̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽͪ
ͳ
̓ͪͻͶͪ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ΒͰ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͯͪ

ΒͰ
͹
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
Ͱͽ͸ͳ΂͵͹Β
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͳ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂
͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͺͳͼͪ͸͹
;
ͺ͹ͭͶͪͬΓͳͷͪ
͹
͋;ͻͼ͵͹Β
͸Ͱͭ͹
;

͹͸ͳͷ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
͹ͬͳ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͳ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪͬͪΒ;

́ͼͽͳ
ΒͰ
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ
ͳ
ͼͪ
ΒͰͲͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͳ
;
ΒͰͯ͸ͳͷ

ͳ
;
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰΕ;Β;
͹ͫͻͳͼͳ
ͼͽͪͻ͹ͭ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸ͪ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͳͬͪ
Δͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
͹͸͹ͭͪ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͪ͵͹Ͳͬͪ͸ͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͪ
͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ

ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͳͷͪͶͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͫͪͶͪͷͪ
̽;͸ͪͬͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͰͬͰͻ;
ͳ
͌͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ;

͊ͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͼͰ
;ͽͳͼͪ͵
͵ͪ͹
ͯͪ
̹ͰͻͶͳ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
͵͹͸ͭͻͰͼͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͳ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͯͪ

͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͸ͳͼ;
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͶͰ
ͷͰΌ;͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹
ͺͻͳͲ͸ͪͽͰ

͋Ͱ͵
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
Ͳͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ΀
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂ͪ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ
͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͷͰͽ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͱͰΓͪ
ͻͰͯͪ͵ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͳ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͯͪ
Ͳͪͺͳ΃;
͸ͪΒ͸͹ͬͳΒͰ
ͺ͹Ͷͳ
ͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
;
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
͸ͪͼͽͪͶͰ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀

ͻͪͽ͹ͬͪ
͉Ͱͯͪ͵ͽ͹ͻͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ΕͰ
ͽ͹
͹ͫΒͪͼ͸ͳͽͳ
;
΀ͻ͹͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳͷ
ͺͻͳͶ͹
Ͳͳͷͪ
͹
͸ͪΒͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͳͷ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳͷͪ
͹ͯ
ͪ͸ͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͯ͹
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ
͸ͳ΀
ͯͪ͸ͪ
͋͹
ͼ;
ͼͪͱͰͽͳ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͳ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͪͬ͸͹
͸ͪͫͻͪΒͪΒ;

ͼͬͳ
ͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͳ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳ
ͪͶͳ
ͼͰ
͹͸ͳͷͪ
ͳͲ
͸͹ͬͳΒͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕ;ΒͰ

ͬͰΕͪ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
ͺ͹ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪͷͪ
͸ͪͼͽͪͶͳͷ
;
ͺͻͬͰ
ͯͬͰ
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͰ


ͬͰ͵ͪ
́
;
͹ͺͳͼ;
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͻͪͽ͹ͬͪ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͳ΀
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯͳ΁ͪ
ͺ͹ͽͪ͸͵͹

ͼ;
͸ͪͫͻ͹Βͪ͸ͳ
ͼͬͳ
ͬͰΕͳ
ͼ;͵͹ͫͳ
ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͰ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͳͺͪΒͪΔͰ
̓͹ͼ͹
ͬͪ
ͳ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸ͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͸ͪ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳ
Βͳ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
ͳͽͯ

̸Ͷͳ
͹΂ͳͭͶͰͯ͸͹
ͯͪ
ͻͰͯͪ͵ͽ͹ͻͳ
͸ͳͼ;
ͳͷͪͶͳ
ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ

ͯͪ
ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͰ
͸͹ͬ͹
ͳͶͳ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷ
ͺͻͰͻͪΌͰ͸͹
ͳͲͯͪΔͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͌
͹ͺͳͼ;

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
͊͹Ͷ;͸;
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͬͰ͸ͳͼͪ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
͸ͪ
͸Ͱ
͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͷͰͼͽͪ
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;Ͷ͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͵͹ͯ
͉ͳͼͽ͹ͬ΁ͪ
͸Ͱ
͵ͪͯͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͳ
͋;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͪ
ΒͰ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ͵
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ

ͷ͹ͻͪ͹
ͬͻͶ͹
ͺͪͱΓͳͬ͹
ͯͪ
΂ͳͽͪ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͰ
͸Ͱ
ͫͳ
Ͷͳ
ͼͽͰ͵ͪ͹
ͺͻͪͬ;
ͼͶͳ͵;

͹
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
͵͹Βͳͷ
ΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪ͹

͌
͹ͺͳͼͳͷͪ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹Ͷ;͹ͼͽͻ
ͬͪ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
͸ͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
ͯ͹ͷͳ͸ͳͻͪ
͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ
͵ͪ͵͹

͸ͪ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ͸ͳͷ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͳ
;
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͵Δͳͱͳ΁ͪ
͌
ͳͲͯͪ
Δͳͷͪ
̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽͪ
͵ͻ;ͺ͸ͳͷ
ͼͶ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͯ΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸͹

 ͚͹ͻΌͰ
͊
̓͹ͼͽͳΕ

͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ
ͪ
ͳͼͺ͹ͯ
ͽ͹ͭͪ
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
ͼͳͽ͸ͳΒͳͷ
ͳ
ͳͷͰ͸ͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
͉;ͷ;͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ

̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
͌
ͺͻͬ͹ͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
̓ͪͻͶͪ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
΂ͳͽͪΒ;
ͼͰ

ͼͪͷ͹
ͳͷͰ͸ͪ
̓͹͸ͼͽͪ͸ͽͳ͸͹ͺ͹Γͪ
ͳ
ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ
ͪ
͹
͹ͼͽͪͶͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ

ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ
͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
͌
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͬͻͰ
ͷͰ͸͹
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭ͹
;
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ;
ͺ͹͸͹ͬ͹
ͺͻͬ͹
ͷͰͼͽ͹
Ͳͪ;Ͳͳͷͪ
̓͹͸ͼͽͪ͸ͽͳ͸͹
ͺ͹Γ
ͺͪ
ͽͰ͵
͹͸ͯͪ
͹ͼͽͪͶͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͯ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ͹Βͷ͹ͷ
#BM
LBOTUBBUFO
͊ͬͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͵͹ͺ͸͹ͷ
ͳ
ͬ͹ͯ͹ͷ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͼ;
͹ͺͳͼͳͬͪ͸ͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ

͵ͻͪΒΔͳ
΁ͳΓ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
;ͬͰ͵
ͫͳ͹
́ͼͽͪͷͫ;Ͷ
͵ͪ
ΔͰͷ;
ͼ;
ͼͬͳ
ͼͽͻͰͷͳͶͳ

m
ͳ
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͳ
ͺͪͻ͹ͫͻ͹ͯ
͈͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
ͫͰͶͰͱͰ͸Ͱ
ͪͶͳ
͸Ͱ

;
͹͸͹Β
ͷͰͻͳ
;
͵͹Β͹Β
ͳ
ͲͪͼͶ;ͱ;Β;

̸͵͹
ͼͰ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
Ͳͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͳͻͪ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ
΁ͰͶͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͳ
ͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
;
ͯͻ;ͭ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ

ͳ
ͺͻͬͳͷ
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͪͷͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ

ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹
͈ͻͬ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͳͷͰͽͳͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͽͻͳ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͯ͹
ͫͳͶͰ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶ͸;
;Ͷ͹ͭ;
̻ͻ΂͵ͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͪͷ͹ͷ
Β;ͭ;
ͺ͹Ͷ;͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ
͸ͪ

ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
ͳ
̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵ͪ
͸ͪ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹Β
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ

͌
ͽ͹ͷ
ͽͻ͹;ͭͶ;
͹ͼͶͳ͵ͪͬͪͶͪ
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͽͻͰ͸;ͽ͸ͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͼͳͽ;ͪ΁ͳΒͪ

͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͷ͹Ε
ͯͬͰΒ;
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ΀
΁ͪͻͰͬͳ͸ͪ
͵͹ΒͰ

͸ͳ͵ͪ͵͹
͸ͳͼ;
΀ͽͰͶͰ
ͯͪ
ͳͲͭ;ͫͰ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
;ͽͳ΁ͪΒͰ
͸ͪ
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;

̽ͻ;ͭͳ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ


͈ͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹Β
͵ͪͻͽͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
͈ͻ
ͬ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͻͪͼͺͪͯ
̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͰ
͸͹ͬͰ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ

͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
ͼ;͵͹ͫͳ
;
ͪͅͶ͹Β
̸ͲͳΒͳ
ͳ
ͼͰ͹ͫͪ
ͭͻ΂͵͹ͭ
ͱͳͬΓͪ
ͳͲ
͋;ͻͼ͵Ͱ

ͺͪ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͪ
͵ͻͳͲͪ
ͳ
;ͼͺ͹͸
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
͸͹ͬͰ
ͼͳͶͰ
;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
Ϳͪ͵ͽ͹
ͻͳ
ͼ;
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
;
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͷͰ
;ͽͳ΁ͪͶͳ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͪΔͰ
ͳ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪΔͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹
Όͪ
͆Ͱ͵Ͱ
͹ͯ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂͵ͳ΀
͵;Εͪ
ͼ;
ͻͰͯ;͵͹ͬͪͶͰ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͭͻͪͷͰ
̓ͪͻͶ
̹Ͱ
ͯͰ͵Ͱͻ
ͳͶͳ
̸ͯ͹ͶͿ
͎ͪͻͽͶͰͫͰ͸
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͼ;
͹ͺͰͽ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸͹ͷ

ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹
͹ͫ;ͼͽͪͬͳͶͰ
ͼͬ͹Β;
ͺͻ͹ͯ;͵΁ͳΒ;
ͳͲ
ͺ͹Ͷͳ
ͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͻͪͲͶ͹ͭͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
ͳͲ
̈́ͪΒͺ΁ͳͭͪ
͌

͸Ͱͼͳͭ;ͻ͸ͳͷ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪͷͪ
ͳ
͸Ͱͷͳͻ͸ͳͷ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳͷͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͻͰΌͰ

ͼͻͰͽͪͶͳ
ͺ͹
ͷ͹ͻͳͷͪ
ͺͻ;ͭͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͷ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
͆ͪΒͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
͹ͯ
͵ͻͪΒͪ
͈ͻͬ͹ͭ

ͯ͹
͵ͻͪΒͪ
̽ͻ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͫͳͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸͹
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͳ
́Ͳͯͪ
ͬͪ΂͵Ͱ
͵;ΕͰ
͍ͳͫͪ
̸ͯͻͳͪ
ͳͲ
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
̻ͻͳͫͰ͸
ͳͲ
̹ͰͻͶͳ͸ͪ
ͳ
͍́̈́
ͳͲ
̽ͻͰ



)BOECVDI
GÛS
3FJTFOEF
WPO
,BSM
#BFEFLFS
%BMNBUJFO
VOE
EJF
"ESJB
8FTUMJ
DIFT
4ÛETMBXJFO
#PTOJFO
#VEBQFTU
*TUSJFO
"MCBOJFO
,PSGV
-FJQ[JH
7FSMBH
WPO
,BSM

#BFEFLFS

.FZFST
3FJTFCÛDIFS
"ESJB
%BMNBUJFO
,SPBUJTDIF
,ÛTUF
#PTOJFO
*UB
MJFOJTDIF
"ESJBLÛTUF
"MCBOJFO
,PSGV
-FJQ[JH
#JCMJPHSBQIJTDIFT
*OTUJUVU

 ̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͵ͪ͹
͹ͭͶͰͯͪͶ͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸; 

ͲͯͰ͸ͪ
ͺͪͱΔ;
;ͼͷͰͻͪͬͪΒ;
ͫͪ΃
͸ͪ
͹ͬͪΒ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ

t͊;͸΁Ͱ
ͺͶͪͬ͹
΂ͳͼͽ͹
ͷ͹ͻͰ
ͷͳͻͳͼ
ͅͰͯͳͽͰͻͪ͸ͪ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽ͹
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰi
͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
ͫͳͶ͹
Ͳͪͺͳͼͪ͸͹
;
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
͹ͯ
̻ͻͳͫͰ͸͹
ͬͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ͼ;
ͻͪͲͶ͹Ͳͳ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ΒͰ
ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹

ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂͵ͳ΀
͵;Εͪ
ͳͲ
ͻͪͲ͸ͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
̸;ͼͽͻͳΒͰ
ͳ
͆Ͱͷͪ΂͵Ͱ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪͶ͹

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
ͺ͹
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͳ
͌
Δͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸͹
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸͹
ͷͪ΀͹ͷ

ͼͪͷ͹
ͺͻͳ͹ͫͪΓͰ
ͯ͹͵
ΒͰ
ͲͪͶͰΌͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
;
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͷ
ͺͶͪ͸;
ͽͰ͵
ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ

͹ͫΒͪͼ͸Ͱ
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
ͷͰΌ;ͼ͹ͫ͸Ͱ
ͬͰͲͰ
͌
̻ͻͳͫͰ͸͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳͲͯͬͪΒͪΒ;
ͼͰ
΁Ͱ
Ͷͳ͸Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
͊ͰͬͰͻ͸ͪ
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͊ͻͰͯΔͪ
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͇ͼͽͻͬͪ

͊ͰͬͰͻ͸Ͱ
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͇ͼͽͻͬͪ
͊ͻͰͯΔͰ
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͠;ͱ͸ͪ
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
;

͹͵ͬͳͻ;
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
̽;ͫͻ͹ͬ͸ͳ͵
ͳ
͏ͪͬͽͪͽ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͹͵͹Ͷ͸ͪ
͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
ͪ
ͲͪͼͰͫ͸;

΁ͰͶͳ͸;
΂ͳ͸ͳ͹
ΒͰ
͹ͺͳͼ
̹͹͵Ͱ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵Ͱ



'
4DINBM
'ÛISFS
EVSDI
%BMNBUJFO

"VGMBHF
8JFO
"ESJB7FSMBH



.
4DIOFJEFS
%VSDI
%BMNBUJFO
CJT
[V
EFO
4DIXBS[FO
#FSHFO
-BOE
.FFS
VOE
*OTFM
GBISUFO
4UVUUHBSU
)ÅEFDLF

8PFSMT
3FJTFIBOECÛDIFS
*MMVTUSJFSUFS
'VFISFS
EVSDI

%BMNBUJFO
VOE
EBT
,SPBUJTDIF
,VFTUFOMBOE
.JU
LMFJOFN
4QSBDIGVFISFS
-FJQ[JH
8PFSMAT

3FJTFCVFDIFS
7FSMBH

3VEPMG
4JFCFS
'ÛISFS
EVSDI
%BMNBUJFO
VOE
EBT
,SPBUJTDIF

,ÛTUFOMBOE
OFCTU
5PVSFO
EVSDI
.POUFOFHSP
#PTOJFO
VOE
)FS[FHPXJOB
VOE
LMFJOFN

4QSBDIGÛISFS
%SFTEFO
*-'7FSMBH

(SJFCFO
3FJTFGÛISFS

(FPSH
,BSP
"UIFO

VOE
6NHFCVOH
#FSMJO
(SJFCFO7FSMBH

 ͚͹ͻΌͰ
͊
̓͹ͼͽͳΕ

́ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
;
ͼͬͳͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ

̻ͻͳͫͰ͸͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͺ͹
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͳ

;
ͺͻͰͯͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ;
ͼͽͪΒͪͶͪ
ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸ͳ΁ͪ

t6OTFSF
3FJTFGÛISFS
TJOE
WÕMMJH
VO
QBSUFJJTDIi
ͳͺͪ͵
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͻͪ
ͳͼͽͪΕͳ

ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ
ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͭͪ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͪ
ͭͻͪΌͰ

ͺ͹Ͷͪ͵͹
ͷͰΔͪ
͆ͪͼͶ͹ͬ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͳͲ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹

ͯͻ;ͭ͹
ͳͲͯͪΔͰ
ͭͶͪͼͳ͹
ΒͰ
(SJFCFOT

3FJTFGÛISFS

#BOE

%BMNBUJFO

VOE
EJF
LSPBUJTDIF
"ESJB
ͯ͹͵
ͼͰ
͸ͪ

͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ͸͹ͷ
Ͷͳͼͽ;
ͺͰͽ͹ͭ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
͸ͪ
ͶͪͲͳ
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͳ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ
(SJFCFOT
3FJ
TFGÛISFS

#BOE

%BMNBUJFO
VOE

EJF
XJDIUJHTUFO
5FJMF
WPO
4MPXFOJFO

,SPBUJFO
.POUFOFHSP
#PTOJFO
VOE

EFS
)FS[FHPXJOB
NJU
"OHBCFO
GÛS

"VUPNPCJMTUFO
̸Ͷͳ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵Ͱ
;
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
͸ͳͼ;
͸ͳͼ;
ͼͪͷ͹
;
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ;

͌
ͺͰͽ͹ͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
;
΃Ͱͼͽ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͰͷ
ͺͻͰͯ

̽ͻ;ͭͳ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͳ
ͻͪͽ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͻͰͯͪ͵ͽ͹ͻͳ
̻ͻͳͫͰ͸͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
Ͳͪ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͲͪͯͻͱͪͬͪΒ;
ͺ͹ͯͰͶ;
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͽͻͳ
ͬͰΕͰ
ͻͰͭͳΒͰ
͊ͰͬͰͻ͸;

͊ͻͰͯΔ;
ͳ
͠;ͱ͸;
ͪͶͳ
͹ͬ͹Β
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔ͹Β
ͼͪͯͪ
ͯ͹ͯͪΒ;
ͳ
̹͹͵;
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵;

ͼͪ
ͼͬͳͷ
͸ͪͼͰΓͳͷͪ
;
ͲͪͶͳͬ;
ͪ
;
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸;
΁ͰͶͳ͸;
ͳͲͯͬͪΒͪΒ;
͏ͻ͸;
̻͹ͻ;

ͳ
̹͹ͼ͸;
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸;
΂ͪ͵
ͯ͹
̹ͪΔͪ
̈́;͵Ͱ
̹ͰͲ
͹ͫͲͳͻͪ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ

ͼͽͪͬ
ͳͲ͸Ͱͽ
;
ͺͻͰͯͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ;
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
t͸ͰͺͪͻͽͳΒͼ͵ͳi
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂
ͼͬͰͼ͸͹

ͳͶͳ
͸Ͱ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ͯͪ
͹ͺͼͽͪ͸Ͱ
ͫͰͲ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯͳ΁ͪ
;
͸͹ͬ͹͸ͪͼͽͪͶͳͷ
ͯͻ;
΃ͽͬͰ͸ͳͷ
͹͵͹Ͷ͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
͆͹ͬͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͼͳͶͪ
ͷͶͰͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͬͰ
ͺͻ͹ͽͳͬ
͸ͳ͵Ͱ
̺ͰΕͪ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
ͫͳΕͰ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸ͪ
ͳ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͳ
͸͹
ͬ͹͸ͪͼͽͪͶ͹Β
ͯͻͱͪͬͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
͈ͻͬ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
ͪͶͳ
ΕͰ



(SJFCFO
3FJTFGÛISFS

"MCFSU
(PMETDINJEU
<7PSS>
%BMNBUJFO
VOE
EJF

LSPBUJTDIF
"ESJB

"VGMMBHF
#FSMJO
(SJFCFO7FSMBH

(SJFCFO
3FJTFGÛISFS


%BMNBUJFO
VOE
EJF
XJDIUJHTUFO
5FJMF
WPO
4MPXFOJFO
,SPBUJFO
.POUFOFHSP
#PTOJFO
VOE

EFS
)FS[FHPXJOB
NJU
"OHBCFO
GÛS
"VUPNPCJMTUFO

"VGMBHF
#FSMJO
(SJFCFO
7FSMBH

"MCFSU
(PMETDINJEU

(SJFCFO
3FJTFGÛISFS

%BMNBUJFO
VOE
EJF
XJDIUJHTUFO

5FJMF
WPO
4MPXFOJFO
,SPBUJFO
.POUFOFHSP
#PTOJFO
VOE
EFS
)FS[FHPXJOB
NJU
"OHBCFO

GÛS
"VUPNPCJMTUFO

"VGMBHF
#FSMJO
(SJFCFO

(SJFCFO
3FJTFGÛISFS

%BMNB
UJFO
+VHPTMBXJTDIF
"ESJBLÛTUF
NJU
*OTFMO
VOE
)JOUFSMBOE
NJU
"OHBCFO
GÛS
"VUPGBISFS


"VGMBHF
#FSMJO
(SJFCFO

 ̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͵ͪ͹
͹ͭͶͰͯͪͶ͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸; 

Ͳͪͽ͹
͹ͼͽͪͶͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͪ
͉;ͷ;͸ͳΒͪ
͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ

ͫͳͽͳ
;
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͷ
ͺͶͪ͸;
ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͳͲ;ͲͷͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
͇
Δ͹Β
ΒͰ
;
ͼͽͬͪͻͳ

͹ͯ
ͼͬͳ΀
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸͹
͸ͪΒͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͪ͵͹
ͽ;
ͻͪ΂;
͸ͪͷ͹
ͳ
ͻͪͲ͸ͪ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͳͷͪ
ͺ͹
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͳ
͈ͪͱΔ;

͹ͬͯͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ͺͻͳͬͶͪ΂ͳ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
͹
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
ͳͲͷͰ
Ό;
ͯͬͪ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͪ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͪ
͎ͰͻͫͰͻͽͪ
͋ͪ;ͫͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸
;
ͯͬͪ

ͳͲͯͪΔͪ

ͳ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;
͏ͳͻͳ΀;
̓ͪ͹
ͳ
͹ͼͽͪͶͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
ͳ
͹ͬͯͰ
ͼͰ
ͳͲͯͬͪΒͪ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͲͪͼͰͫ͸ͳ΀

΁ͰͶͳ͸ͪ
̸Ͷͳ
ͯ͹͵
ͼ;
;
͹ͼͽͪͶͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
͹͸Ͱ
͹ͫͶͳ͵͹ͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͺ;ͽ
͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͪͬ΁ͳͷͪ
ͯͻ;ͷͼ͵͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͰ͸͹ͭ
ͳͶͳ
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒͪ
͎Ͱͻ
ͫͰͻͽ
͋ͪ;ͫ
͸ͪ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͪͬ͸͹
͸ͪͫͻͪΒͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͪ
ͷͰͼͽͪ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
͊Ͷͪͬ͹͸ͳΒͰ
̺͹Βͬ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳͶͳ
͊ͻͰͷͪ
̹ͪ͸ͪͽͪ
ͳ

̹ͪ΂͵Ͱ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
Β;ͱ͸͹
͹ͯ
͊ͪͬͰ
ͳ
̽;͸ͪͬͪ
̹͹ͼ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͻͳͷ͹ͻΒͪ
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽͳͻͰ
͹ͯ
̹ͳ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͯ͹

̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͳ
͸ͪΒͲͪͯ
͏ͻ͸Ͱ
̻͹ͻͰ
;
΂ͳΒͳͷ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͸ͪ΃Ͷͪ
ͳ
ͷͰͼͽͪ

͈ͰΕ
ͳ
͚ͪ͵͹ͬͳ΁ͪ
͈͹ͯͰͶͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
͎ͰͻͫͰͻͽͪ
͋ͪ;ͫͪ
ͺ͹ͺͻͳͷͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͰ
ͺ͹Ͷͳ
ͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͰͶͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͸ͪ
ͫͪ͸͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͪͶͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͼͰ
ͳͲͯͬͪΒͪ
͹ͯ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳ΀
͹

͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͯ͹
ͼͪͯͪ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͻͰ΂ͳ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͯͬͰ
ͬͪͱ͸Ͱ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
̽͹͵
ͼ;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
ͯ͹
͵ͻͪΒͪ
͈ͻͬ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
;
ͬͰΕͳ͸ͳ
ͼͶ;΂ͪ
ΒͰͬͪ
;Ͳ
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͵Ͱ
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͪͶͳ
ͻͰͯͪ͵ͽ͹ͻͳ
͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ΒͰ

΂Ͱͼͽ͹
ͲͪͬͳͼͳͶ͹
΃ͽͪ
ΕͰ
ͼͰ
ͼͬͰ
͸ͪΕͳ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
͎ͰͻͫͰͻͽ
͋ͪ;ͫ
ΒͰ
;ͬͰ͹

ΒͰͯ͸;
͸͹ͬͳ͸;
͵͹Βͪ
ΕͰ
ͼͰ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
;
͵Δͳͱͳ΁ͪͷͪ
͹ͬ͹ͭͪ
ͱͪ͸ͻͪ
;ͼͽͪͶͳ
ͽͳ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͷͰΔͳͬͪͽͳ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
̽ͻ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
͋ͪ;ͫ
ΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͼͪͻͪͯ
͸ͳ͵Ͱ
͸ͪͳͷͰ
͹ͯͪͫͻͪ͹
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͫͻ͹Β͸Ͱ
ͳͼͽͪ͵͸;ͽͰ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪ͹΁Ͱ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ

ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
͋ͪ͵͹
ΕͰ
ͼͰ
;
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ
΂;
͵ͪ͹
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͭͪ
͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
ͳ
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
Β;ͱ͸͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀

͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
͸ͪΕͳ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻͷͪ͸
̺Ͱ͸ͯͰͶ
͹
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͳͷͪ
ͳ
͸͹΃Δͪͷͪ

ͺͳ΃Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͿͰͼ͹ͻ
̽
͠
̽Ͱͻ͹͵͹
ͪ
͹
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸ͳͷ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳ
ͻͳͷͪ
̸ͶͰ͵ͼͪ͸ͯͪͻ
̽Ͱͻ͹͵͹

̽ͻ;ͭͪ
ͬͪͱ͸ͪ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵ͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͪΔͰ
ͷͰͼͽͪ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼ;

ͱͳͬͰͶͳ
͆Ͱͷ΁ͳ
ͳͶͳ
ͽͪ΂͸ͳΒͰ
ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸͹
ͺ͹ͯ;͸ͪͬͼ͵ͳ
͆Ͱͷ΁ͳ
͌
ͼͬͳͷ

ͯ͹
ͼͪͯͪ
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯͪ͸ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
Ͳͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
͸ͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
͹ͯ


ͺͪ
ͯ͹
ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͺͳͼͪ͸͹
͹



)
5BVC
'ÛISFS
EVSDI
EBT
,ÕOJHSFJDI
EFS
4FSCFO
,SPBUFO
VOE
4MPXFOFO
+V
HPTMBXJFO

;ÛSJDI
7PMLTXJSUTDIBGUMJDIFS
7FSMBH

*MMVTUSJFSUFS
'ÛISFS
EVSDI
+VHPT
MBXJFO
,ÕOJHSFJDI
EFS
4FSCFO
,SPBUFO
VOE
4MPXFOFO


WFSCFTTFSUF
VOE
FSXFJUFSUF

"VGMBHF
;ÛSJDI
7PMLTXJSUTDIBGUMJDIFS
7FSMBH
"
(

 ͚͹ͻΌͰ
͊
̓͹ͼͽͳΕ

ͺ͹ͯ;͸ͪͬͼ͵ͳͷ
͆Ͱͷ΁ͳͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
͵͹ͯ
͎ͰͻͫͰͻͽͪ
͋ͪ;ͫͪ
͌
͹ͺͳͼͳͷͪ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ

̺͹Βͬ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͭ
ͫͳͻͪ͸ͪ
ͼ;
͹͸ͪ
ͷͰͼͽͪ
;
͵͹Βͪ
ͼ;
ͯ͹ͼͰΓͰ͸ͳ

ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͯͪΓͰ
ͱͳͬͰͶͳ
ͺ͹ͯ;͸ͪͬͼ͵ͳ
͆Ͱͷ΁ͳ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔ;
̸ͺͪͽͳ͸
̺ͻ
ͫͪͼ
̹ͪ΂͵ͪ
͈ͪͶͪ͸͵ͪ
̺ͻ΃ͪ΁
͈ͪ͸΂Ͱͬ͹
ͳͽͯ

͈Ͱͻͳ͹ͯ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
ͯͬͪ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͪ
ͻͪͽͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͸ͪ͵Ͷ͹ΔͰ͸͹

ͻͪͲͬͳΒͪΔ;
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͳͷͪ
ͻͪͯͳ
ͼͽͳ΁ͪΔͪ
͸͹ͬͳ΀
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΔͪ
͹

͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
ͳͶͳ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͪͬ͸͹ͭ
͹ͯͷ͹ͻͪ
̺ͰΕ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͪ
Ͱ͵͹
͸͹ͷͼ͵ͪ
͵ͻͳͲͪ
ͪ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͻͪΌͪΔͰ
͸͹ͬͳ΀
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͷ͹Ε͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͼ
ͬͰͶͳ
͵ͳͷ
ͪͷͫͳ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
;͸͹ͼͳͶͳ
ͼ;
͸ͰͳͲͬͰͼ͸͹ͼͽ
;
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸ͳ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ
ͺͪ

ΒͰ
ͼͽ͹ͭͪ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͷͪΔͰ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͱͰΓͰ
Ͳͪ
͹ͽͳͼ͵ͳͬͪΔͰ
;
͸͹ͬͰ
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͰ

͹ͫͪͼΒͪ͸Ͱ
ͼ;͸΁Ͱͷ
ͳͶͳ
ͽͻͪͭͪΔͰ
Ͳͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰͷ
ͼͪ

ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂Ͱͷ
;
ͻ;΁ͳ
̹ͰͲ
͹ͫͲͳͻͪ
͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ
ͺ͹
Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂ͳ
͹ͬͰ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͰ
ͽͻ;ͯͳͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹͵;΃ͪΒ;
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͯͻͱͰ
ͺ͹
ͯͪΓͰ
͹ͯ
͸ͪͯ͹ͶͪͲͰΕͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͽͳͼ΁ͳͷͪ
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼͷ͹

ͬͳͯͰͶͳ
͸ͳͼ;
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͼ;ͺͻ͹ͽͼͽͪͬͰ

̸Ͷͳ
ͬͳ΀͹ͻ
͹ͼͬͪΒͪ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹΀͹ͯͪ
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
;Ͳͻ͹͵ͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ


ͯ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸͹Β
ͼ΁Ͱ͸ͳ
͹ͺͰͽ
ͺ͹Βͪͬͳ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͼͺͰ΁ͳ
Ϳͳ΂ͪ͸
ͺ͹ͯͱͪ͸ͻ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
̹ͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͽ͹
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͬ͹Β͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͅͰΌ;
͹ͬͪ
͵ͬͳͷ
͵Δͳͱͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͼͰ
ͳͼͽͳ΂;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͰ

͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
#FMHSBE
m
EJF
8FJ“F
4UBEU
&JO
LMFJOFS
4PMEB
UFOGÛISFS
͇ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸
͹ͯ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵Ͱ
͵͹ͷͪ͸ͯͰ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
ͼͪ
ͯͰͽͪΓ
͸ͳͷ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͷ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͹͸
ΒͰ
ͬ͹Β͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͳ
͹Ϳͳ΁ͳͻͳͷͪ
ͺͻ;ͱͪ͹
͸ͪΒͬͪͱ͸ͳ
ΒͰ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
ͭͻͪͯ;
͹
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹Β
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͰͶͳ΂ͪ͸ͪ
͵ͪͯ

ͭ͹ͯ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͺ͹ͯ
ͪ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͷ
ͬͶͪ΃Ε;
ͺͪ
ͼ;
ͽͪ͵͹
ͳͲͫͰͭͪͬͪ͸ͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ

ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͳͼ;
;͵ͶͪͺͪͶͳ
;
ͬͰΕ
Ͳͪͷͳ΃ΓͰ͸;
ͼ΀Ͱͷ;
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
ΒͰ

;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
t̀ͰͷΓͪ
ͼͰΓͪ͵ͪi
ͪ
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪͶ͹
ͳ
΃ͽ͹

ΕͰ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪͽͳ
t̹ͰͶ͹ͷ
ͭͻͪͯ;i
ͯ͹͸͹ͼͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͳͶͳ
ΕͰ
ͯ͹͸Ͱͽͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
͆Ͱͷ
΁ͳ

͋ͻͰΕͳ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ


͇ͫ͸͹ͬͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͬͰΕͳ΀
ͻͪͲͪͻͪΔͪ
;
ΔͰ͸͹Β

ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
̽ͻ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͺͪ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͼͽͪͫͳͶͳͲ͹ͬͪΔͰ

Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪ
͸ͪ
͵͹͸ͽͳ͸Ͱ͸ͽ;
ͯ͹ͺͻͳ͸ͰͶͳ
ͼ;
͸͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β;

ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
ͪ
ͼ
Δͳͷ
ͳ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
͹͸͹ͭ
΃ͽ͹
ͭͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͪͽͳͶ͹
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ͸ͪ
ͳ͸Ϳͻͪ
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͪ
ͪͬͳ͹
ͺͻͰͬ͹Ͳ
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͸͹ͬͳ
ͺ;ͽͰͬͳ
ͳͲͭͻͪͯΔͪ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ
͸ͳ΀
ͷ͹ͽͰͶͪ
ͳ
΀͹ͽͰͶͪ
ͺ͹ͯͳͲͪΔͰ
;ͼͶ;ͭͪ
͸ͪ
ͬͳ΃ͳ
͸ͳͬ͹
͵͹Βͳ
͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪ
ͻͪ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͼͽͪ͸ͯͪͻͯ;
͸͹ͬͳ΀
t͸͹ͷͪͯͪi
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼ;
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
͸ͪͲͳͬͪ͸ͳ

ͱͳͽͰΓͳ
͵͹͸ͽͳ͸Ͱ͸ͽͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͷͪ΀͹ͷ
;
ͶͰͽΔͳͷ
ͷͰͼͰ΁ͳͷͪ
΀ͻͶͳͶͳ
͸ͪ

ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
tͼ;͸΁ͪ
ͳ
ͺͶͪͬ͹ͭ
ͷ͹ͻͪi
 ̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͵ͪ͹
͹ͭͶͰͯͪͶ͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸; 

͈ͰͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͭͪ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͹ͬͪΒ
͸͹ͬͳ
;ͲͶͰͽ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
ͺ͹
΂ͰͶͳ
ͼ;
ͯͪ
ͺͻͪͽͰ
ͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂ͳ
ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͪΔͰͷ
͵Δͳͭͪ
͹

ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͳͷͪ
͵;ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͪ
ͻͰ͵ͪ
t͸͹ͷͪͯͪi
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ

͵ͻͰͽͪͶͪ
͊ͶͰͯͰΕͰ
΂Ͱͽͳͻͳ
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹
ͯͰͬͰͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹
΃Ͷ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͯͰͿͳ͸ͳͼͪ͸Ͱ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
͸ͪͷͰͽͪͶͰ
ͼ;
ͯ͹͸Ͱ͵ͶͰ
ͳ
͵͹͸
΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒ;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
ͺͪ
ͼͰ
͹͸ͳ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͺ͹ͯͰͶͳͽͳ
;
ͯͬͰ
ͬͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͭͻ;ͺͰ

͌
ͺͻͬ;
ͼͺͪͯͪΒ;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͳ
ͳ
ͻͰ
ͯͪ͵ͽ͹ͻͳ
ͼͽͻͳ͵ͽ͸͹
ͯͻͱͪͶͳ
;ͽͬͻΌͰ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
;
͠;ͭ͹ͳ
ͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
ͺͪ
ͼ;
ͽͪ͵͹
ͳ
͹ͺͳͼͳͬͪͶͳ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
ͳͶͳ
ͷͪΔͰ

ͻͰͭͳΒͰ
;
ΔͰ͸ͳͷ
͹͵ͬͳͻͳͷͪ
͉ͪͲ͸Ͱ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂͵Ͱ
͵;ΕͰ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪͶͰ
ͼ;
͸ͪ

ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ͹ͷ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
ͲͰͷΓ;
;
ΔͰ͸ͳͷ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͭͻͪ
͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸
́ͼͽͻͰ
ͳ
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹͸Ͱ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
;

ͼͽͬͪͻ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͬͶͪ΂ͳͶͳ
͸ͪΒͬͰΕͳ
ͫͻ͹Β
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͶͪ΁ͪ

͆ͪ
ͳͼͽͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
̻ͻ΂͵ͪ
͵ͪ͹
΁ͰͶͳ͸ͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͻͰͭͳ
͹͸ͪͶ͸͹
͌
ͽͰ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸Ͱ
ͼͺͪͯͪΒ;
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͪ
͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
͊ͪ͸ͽ͹ͻͳ
͸ͳ
̓ͻͳͽ
ͳͶͳ
͹ͺͰͽ
ͭͻ;ͺͰ
͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
̓ͳ͵ͶͪͯͰ
͋;
ͼ;
͸ͪͻͪͬ͸͹
ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ

ͺ͹
͸ͪΒͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳΒͳͷ
ͭͻ΂͵ͳͷ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
̸ͽͳ͸ͪ
ͳ
͊͹Ͷ;͸

̀ͰͷΓͪ
͸ͪ
ͯͬͪ
͵͹͸ͽͳ͸Ͱ͸ͽͪ
͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ
ͺͻͬ͹ͫͳͽ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ

͵ͪ͹
΁ͰͶͳ͸ͪ
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͯͬͪͯͰͼͰͽ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͻͪ
ͼͽ͹ͷ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ
Ͳͪ
ΔͰ͸Ͱ
͹ͫͪͶͰ
ͳ
͹͸ͪ
ͺ͹΂ͰͶͪ
͹ͺͳͼͳͬͪͽͳ
ͺ͹
ͻͰͭͳ




/BHFMT
3FJTFGÛISFS
(FOG
/BHFM

+VHPTMBXJFO

(SJFDIFOMBOE


#VMHBSJFO

3VNÅOJFO

(SJFCFO3FJTFGÛISFS
.ÛODIFO
,BSM
ѮJFNJH ,(

#VMHBSJFO

3VNÅOJFO

5ÛSLFJ

1PMZHMPUU
,MFJOF
#JCMJPUIFL
3FJTF
GÛISFS
.ÛODIFO
1PMZHMPUU7FSMBH

3VNÅOJFO

(SJFDIFOMBOE

"VGMBHF


3IPEPT

"VGMBHF

#VMHBSJFO

"VGMBHF

*TUBOCVM

"VGMBHF

,SFUB


"VGMBHF

5ÛSLFJ

"VGMBHF

4DISPFEFS
3FJTFGÛISFS
#VMHBSJFO
#POO

7MH
,
4DISPEFS

.BSDP
1PMP
.BJST
(FPHSBQIJTDIFS
7FSMBH
#SPTDIVS

5ÛSLFJ

*TUBOCVM

5ÛSLJTDIF
.JUUFMNFFSLÛTUF

#BFEFLFS
"MMJBO[
3FJTFGÛISFS
4UVUU
HBSU
#BFEFLFST
"VUPGÛISFS7FSMBH

(SJFDIFOMBOE
'FSJFO
4UÅEUF
-BOETDIBGUFO
%FS

HSP“F
JMMVTUSJFSUF
3FJTFGÛISFS

"VGMBHF

5ÛSLJTDIF
,ÛTUFO

"UIFO


#BFEFLFST
"VUPSFJTFGÛISFS
4UVUUHBSU

#VMHBSJFO
NJU
;VGBISUT3PVUF
WPO
+VHPTMBXJFO

VOE
"OTDIMVTT4USFDLF
OBDI
*TUBOCVM

+VHPTMBXJFO
VOE
(SJFDIFOMBOE
NJU
FVSPQÅ
JTDIFS
5ÛSLFJ

%V.POU
,ÕMO
%V.POU
#VDIWFSMBH

"
(PSZT
*TUBOCVM

'

3
4DIFDL
5ÛSLJTDIF
8FTULÛTUF

)
&
-BU[LF
5ÛSLJTDIF
4ÛELÛTUF

,
#ÕUJH

$IBMLJEJLJ
VOE
5FTTFBMPOJLJ

/
"EBNT
4BOUPSJOJ

,
#ÕUJH
,PT
/JTTZSPT

,BMZNOPT
1BUNPT
-FSPT
-JQTJ
"TUZQBMFB

#
4DIBSGFOCFSHFS
.
4UFJOIPGG
,ZL
MBEFO

"
4DIOFJEFS
,SFUB

,
#ÕUJH
4BNPT

,
#ÕUJH
,PSGV
-FGLBT

,FGBMMPOJB
*UIBLJ
;BLJOUIPT
NJU
"UMBT

%V.POU
,VOTU3FJTFGÛISFS
,ÕMO
%V
.POU
#VDIWFSMBH

,
8
#MPIN
4UÅEUF
VOE
4UÅUUFO
EFS
5ÛSLFJ

'
3PUIFS
+VHPTMB
XJFO

)BNCVSH
&EJUJPO
.BSJUJN
/BVUJTDIFS
3FJTFGÛISFS
)BNCVSH

8
)PPQ

"
)PSO
5ÛSLJTDIF
4ÛELÛTUF
VOE
;ZQFSO

"
)PSO
8
)PPQ
,SFV[FO
[XJTDIFO

5ÛSLJTDIFS
,ÛTUF
VOE
0TUHSJFDIJTDIFO
*OTFMO

 ͚͹ͻΌͰ
͊
̓͹ͼͽͳΕ

Βͪͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͪͅͶ͹ͪͲͳΒͼ͵ͪ
͹ͫͪͶͪ
͹ͫͪͶͪ
͊ͻͰͯ͹ͲͰͷ͸͹ͭ
ͷ͹ͻͪ
ͳͶͳ

ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳͷͪ
́ͼͽͪͷͫ;Ͷ
ͪͅͻͷͪͻͳͼ
̹͹ͯͻ;ͷ
ͳͽͯ
͇ͬͪΒ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪ
΁ͰͶͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͳͶͳ
ΔͰ͸ͳ΀
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪ
;

ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
Ͳͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͺͻͳͷͰΔ;ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ͺͪ
ΒͰ
;
͸Ͱ͵͹Β
͹ͯ
ͫͳͫͶͳ
͹ͽͰ͵ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
ΒͰͯ͸͹Β
ͲͰͷΓͳ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸͹
ͼͬͰ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͵Δͳͭͪ
͆ͪΒͫ͹Γͳ

ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
Ͳͪ
ͳͲ͸Ͱͽ;
ͽͰͲ;
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ͼ;
̻ͻ΂͵ͪ
ͳ
͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ
͈ͻͬͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ

ͺͰͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸ͪ
;
ΒͰͯ͸͹Β
͵ΔͳͲͳ
ͪ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
͵͹͸ͽͳ͸Ͱ͸
ͽͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
ͲͪͼͰͫ͸Ͱ
΁ͰͶͳ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͪ
͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
;
͠͹͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͷ͹ͻ;
ͳ
̓ͻͳͽ

͈͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂͵Ͱ
͵;ΕͰ
̽ͳ
ͅ͹͸
͈͹ͶͳͭͶ͹ͽ
ͳ
ͪͅͻ͵͹

͈͹Ͷ͹
ͳͲͯͪΒ;
ͲͪͼͰͫ͸Ͱ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
ͺ͹
̸ͽͳ͸ͳ
͊͹Ͷ;͸;
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷ;͹ͼͽͻͬ;
͎ͪͶ
͵ͳͯͳ͵ͳ
͹ͼͽͻͬͳͷͪ
͉͹ͯ͹ͼ
͊ͪͷ͹ͼ
̓ͻͳͽ
͊ͪ͸ͽ͹ͻͳ͸ͳ
ͭͻ;ͺͳ
͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
;

͠͹͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͷ͹ͻ;
ͳ
̓ͳ͵Ͷͪͯͪͷͪ
͌
ͯͻ;ͭ;
ͭͻ;ͺ;
ͼͺͪͯͪΒ;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͬͰͲͳͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ

ͳ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͼ;
͹ͬͯͰ
ͫͳͶͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
͸ͪ
ͺͪͺͳͻ;
ͳ
͸ͳͼ;

ͫͳͶͰ
ͺͻͰͺͻͰ͵ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻͰͶͪͱͰΔͰ
ͳͲ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
;
ͯͻ;ͭ;
͐ͳͽͪͬ;
ͼͰͻͳΒ;

͹ͬͪ͵ͬͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
ͺ͹΂ͰͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓ;ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
̽ͻ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ

ͺ͹͸͹ͬ͹
ͪ͵ͽͳͬͳͻͪ͸ͪ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂͵ͪ
͵;Εͪ
̓ͪͻͶͪ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
̓ΔͳͭͰ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͰ

͵͹͸΁ͳͺͳͻͪ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
ͫͪͲͳ
͵͹͸΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͳ΂͸ͳ΀
͵ͻ;ͭ͹ͬͪ
;
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻ;
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪ
ͲͳͶͰ
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
ͳͶͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
ͳ
̻ͻ΂͵ͪ

͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͺ;ͽ͸͹ͷ
ͳ
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͷͻͰͱ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͬͰͲͪ͸Ͱ
ͼ
͹͵͹Ͷ
͸ͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
͌
ͳͼͽ͹Β
Ͱͯͳ΁ͳΒͳ
ͲͪͺͪͱͪΒ;
ͼͰ
ͳ
͵ΔͳͭͰ
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ͹ͷ

͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ
ͼͪ
ͻ;ͽͪͷͪ
ͯ͹
͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͪ
ͳͶͳ
̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͪ
ͳͽͯ

 ̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͵ͪ͹
͹ͭͶͰͯͪͶ͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸; 

͉ͪͼͺͪͯ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͰ
͸͹ͬͳ΀
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;

;ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͷͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͹ͯͻͪͲͳͶͳ
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͪΔͰ
ͳ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪΔͰ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ΀

ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͋Ͱ͵
;
ͯͻ;ͭ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͰ
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͭͪ
ͬͰ͵ͪ

͸ͪ
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽ;
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ΒͪͬͳͶͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͺ͹
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
͸ͪͼͽͪ
Ͷͳͷ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͻͪͼͺͪͯͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
͉Ͱ΂
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͬ͹ͷ
ͷͰͼͽ;
͹
ͺ;ͽ͹
ͬ͹Όͳ
ͺ͹
́ͼͽͻͳ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
͹ͼͽͻͬͳͷͪ
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͲͪͼͰͫ͸ͳͷ
͵Δͳͭͪͷͪ
͹

͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͳ
ͳ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹Β
́ͲͯͪͬͪΔͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͺ͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͽͻ;ͼ͸͹ͷ

ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Β;
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ΃ΔͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
;ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͷͰ
Ͳͪ͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
Ͳͪ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪΔͰͷ

͵Δͳͱͳ΁ͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͭ
ͱͪ͸ͻͪ
͹
͹ͼͽͪͶͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͳͷͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂
͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ

 ͚͹ͻΌͰ
͊
̓͹ͼͽͳΕ

̓ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
;
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔ͹Β
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͳ
ͯͬͪͯͰͼͰͽ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͸͹ͬͳ
ͰͶͰ͵
ͽͻ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͷͰͯͳΒ
ͺ͹΂Ͱ͹
ͯͪ
Ͳͪ;Ͳͳͷͪ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͷͰͼͽ͹
;
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͷ͸͹
ͭ͹ͫͻ͹Β͸Ͱ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂͵Ͱ
͵;ΕͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͯ͹
ͽͪͯͪ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪͶͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ
͸Ͱ
ͷͰͯͳΒͰ
ͺ͹΂ͰͶͰ
ͼ;
ͯͪ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͰ
͹ͬ͹
͸͹ͬ͹
ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬ͹
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪ

͉Ͱ΂
ΒͰ
͸ͪͻͪͬ͸͹
͹
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ;
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͰͲͪͯͻͱͳͬ͹
΃ͳͻͳ͹
ͅ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ

ͼͽͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶͳͲ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͼͷͪΔͰ͸ͳ
ͽͻ͹΃͵͹ͬͳ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪΔͪ

ͼͪͷ͹
ͼ;
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
͹ͯ
ͺͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͸͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͷͰͯͳΒͪ
͇ͬ;
΃ͪ͸ͼ;
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ͼ;
ͺ͹
͵;΃ͪͶͰ
ͯͪ
ͳͼ͵͹ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͬͰΕ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͰ
͵;ΕͰ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭͰ
͸͹ͬͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
͸ͪ

͹ͬͪΒ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͽͻͪͱͳͶͰ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͷͰͼͽ͹
;
ͼͬͰͽ;
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ

̓͹͸΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͪ
͹ͬͪ͵ͬͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͸Ͱ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
͹ͯ
͹͸ͳ΀
͸ͪ
ͼͽͪͶͳ΀
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͪ
͋;
ͼ;
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͼͪͫͻͪ͸Ͱ
͸ͪΒͬͪͱ͸ͳ
 ̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͵ͪ͹
͹ͭͶͰͯͪͶ͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸; 

ΒͰ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
ΒͰͯ͸͹Β
ͲͰͷΓͳ
ͳ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͺ͹
Δ͹Β

ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΁͹ͷ
ͪͬͳ͹͸͹ͷ
ͫͻ͹ͯ͹ͷ
ͳͶͳ
ͯͻ;ͷͼ͵ͳͷ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒͰͷ
̻ͻͪΌͪ

͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͳͻͪ͸ͪ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ͵;
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͰ
;ͺ͹ͻͰͯͳͽͳ
ͼͪ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͳͷ

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
ͺͻͬͰ
ͭͻ;ͺͰ
͸ͪͼͽͪͶͳͷ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
̽ͻ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
́

͹ͬͯͰ
ΒͰ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵ͪ
ͼͽͻͳ͵ͽ͸͹ͭ
ͺͻͳͯͻͱͪͬͪΔͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
͹ͯ͸͹
ͼ͸͹
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ

̸Ͷͳ
΂ͪ͵
ͳ
͵͹ͯ
͹ͬͪ͵ͬͳ΀
ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͷͰͯͳΒͪ
͵͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ΒͰ
ͷ͹
ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
ͺͶͪͼͳͻͪΔͪ
͸ͪΒ͸͹ͬͳΒͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͼ͵͹ͻ͹
ͫͰͲͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂͸ͪ

ͯ͹ͶͪͲͳ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͯ͹
ͭͻͰ΃ͪ͵ͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͯ͹ͭ͹ͯͳͶ͹
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
͹͵ͽ͹ͫͻͪ
ͷͰ
ͼͰ΁ͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳͷ
ͼͪΒͽ͹ͬͳͷͪ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
ͺͻͳͼ;ͽ͸ͪ
ͳͷͰ
͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
́Ͷͳ
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
ͻͰͯͪ͵΁ͳΒͪ
ͳͲͫͰͭͶͪ

ͼͬͪ͵;
Ͳͪͫ;͸;
ͳ
ͼ͵ͳ͸;Ͷͪ
͹ͯͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ͸͹ͼͽ
ͼͪ
ͼͰͫͰ
ͺͻͳͷͰͽ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͳ͸
Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͳ
͏ͻ͸͹Β
̻͹ͻͳ
ͺͻͰ;ͲͳͷͪΒ;
ͼͪ
Ͳͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸͹ͭ
ͼͪΒͽͪ

ͅͳ͸ͳͼͽͪͻͼͽͬͪ
ͳ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͪ
͆ͪ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳͷ
ͼͪΒͽ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͹ͺͰͽ

ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
ͼ;
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͪͬ͸͹
ͳͲ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ
ͼͪ
ͺ͹ͺͳͼͪ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
͹
͵͹
Βͳͷͪ
Ͳͪͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
ͱͰͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͳ΃Ͱ
͆ͪ
ͼͪΒͽ;
͵͹Βͳ

ͼͰ
Ͳ͹ͬͰ
4DIXBS[BVGXFJTT
ͲͪͺͪͱͰ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͺͻͳͶ͹Ͳͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
͹
̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵͹Β
̻ͻ΂
͵͹Β
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹Β
͉;ͷ;͸ͳΒͳ
ͳ
͋;ͻͼ͵͹Β
͊ͬͰ
͹ͼͽͪͶͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ

̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
͸ͳͼ;
͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͰ


́Ͳͯͪͬͪ΂ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
͸ͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
ͳͷͪͶͪ
ͼ;
͹ͯ

̹ͰͻͶͳ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
͵͹͸ͭͻͰͼͪ
ͺͪ
ͯ͹
ͺͻͬͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͳͼͽ;
΁ͳΓ͸;
ͺ;
ͫͶͳ͵;
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͱͰͶͰͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺ;
ͪͶͳ
ͳ

΂ͳͽͪ͹΁Ͱ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͽ͹
ͫͳͶͪ
͸ͪͷͰͻͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͼ;
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͪͬ͸͹
΀ͽͰͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ

ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͳ΃;
͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹Ͷ;͹ͼͽͻͬ;
͠Ͱͯ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΀
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵ͪ
ͼͬͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽ͹ͭ

ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͽͪͶ͸͹
ͺͻͪΕͰΔͰ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
;
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β

̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
͈͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹ͭ͹ͯͳͶͰ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪ
Δͪ
ͯͬͪ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
ͼ;
ͻͰͭͳͼͽͻ͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
;
ͺͻͬ͹ͷ
͸ͪͻͰͯ͸͹ͷ
͌
ͺͻͬ͹ͷ
͹ͬͯͰ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽ͹ͷ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸ͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͪ
ΒͰ
;
ͫͰ
ͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͺ͹ͯͰΓͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
ͯͬͰ
ͬͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͸Ͱ
ͼͿͰͻͰ
ΒͰͯ͸;
͵͹Βͪ

ΒͰ
͹ͫ;΀ͬͪͽͪͶͪ
ͪ;ͼͽͻ͹;ͭͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͰ
͏ͻ͸Ͱ
̻͹ͻͰ
̸Ͷ
ͫͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭ;
;
͹͵ͬͳͻ;
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶ
͸͹ͭ
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹ͭ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ




IUUQXXXUSBWFMOPWBEF
IUUQXXXTDIXBS[BVGXFJTTEF
IUUQXXXBCFOUFVFSSFJTFOEF
 ͚͹ͻΌͰ
͊
̓͹ͼͽͳΕ

́ͯͰΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳΓͰ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂ͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͳ
ͻͰͯͪ͵ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
ͫͳͶͰ
ͼ;

ͪ;ͼͽͻ͹΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͳͲͪͷ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻ͵͹΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͳͲͪͷ
͇
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͳ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹
Ͷ;͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
͹
Ͱͽ͸ͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͳͶͳ
͵͹͸ͿͰͼͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͷ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬ;
͹
͵Ͷͳͷͳ
ͳͽͯ

ͺͳͼͪ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͯͪ
ͼ;
;ͬͰ͵
̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵ͪ
ͳͶͳ
͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ
ͫͳͶͰ
;
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻ;

ͺͪͱΔͰ
ͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͊ͬͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ
ͺͻͪͬ΁ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͳͲ
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
͵ͪ

̓͹͸ͼͽͪ͸ͽͳ͸͹ͺ͹Γ;
ͳ
͹ͫͻ͸;ͽ͹
ͫͰͲ
͹ͫͲͳͻͪ
ͯͪ
Ͷͳ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹
Δͳ΀
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͳ
Ͷ͹
͵͹ͺ͸͹ͷ
ͳͶͳ
ͬ͹ͯͰ͸ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽͰͬͳͷͪ
͌
ͼͬͳͷ
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯͪ͸ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ

͹ͯͼͶͳ͵ͪͬͪͶͪ
ͼͰ
ͽͻͰ͸;ͽ͸ͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͼͳͽ;ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
ͪͶͳ
ͳ

ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͷ͹Ε
ͯͬͰΒ;
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ΀
΁ͪͻͰͬͳ͸ͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
͸ͳ͵ͪ͵͹
͸ͳͼ;
΀ͽͰͶͰ

ͯͪ
ͳͲͭ;ͫͰ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
;ͽͳ΁ͪΒͰ
͸ͪ
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
͈Ͱͻͳ͹ͯ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
ͯͬͪ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͪ
ͻͪͽͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͸ͪ͵Ͷ͹ΔͰ͸͹

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͳͷͪ
ͻͪͯͳ
ͼͽͳ΁ͪΔͪ
͸͹ͬͳ΀
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΔͪ
͹
͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ

ͳͶͳ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͪͬ͸͹ͭ
͹ͯͷ͹ͻͪ
͈͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͪ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͪ
͵ͻͳͲͪ
ͪ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͻͪ
ΌͪΔͰ
͸͹ͬͳ΀
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͷ͹Ε͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͼ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͷ
ͪͷͫͳ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
;͸͹ͼͳͶͳ

ͼ;
͸ͰͳͲͬͰͼ͸͹ͼͽ
;
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸ͳ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ
̹ͰͲ
͹ͫͲͳͻͪ
͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͺ͹
Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂ͳ
͹ͬͰ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͰ
ͽͻ;ͯͳͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͯͻͱͰ
ͺ͹ͯͪΓͰ
͹ͯ
͸ͪ
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͰΕͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͽͳͼ΁ͳͷͪ
͸ͳͼ;
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ;ͺͻ;
̸
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ

͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵ͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
͹ͼͽͪͶͪ
ͺͻͳͼ;ͽ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͬͳͯΓͳͬͪ
͸ͪ

ͺͻͬͳ
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯ
͸͹ͬͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͪ
͵ͪͻͽͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
͹ͭͶͰͯͪͶͪ
ͼͰ

;
ͼͬͳͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
͌
ͯͻ;ͭ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͹ͯ
΂ͰͽͻͯͰͼͰͽ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͷͳͻͪ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
ͺͪ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͳ
ͻͪͼͺͪͯͪ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͪ

͹ͫͶͳ͵͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͭͻͪΌͰ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
;
ͬͰΕͳ͸ͳ
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒͰͬͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͺͻ͹
ͷͰ͸ͳͶͪ
́Ͷͳ
ͼ;
ͺ͹΃ͽ͹ͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͳͶͳ
͹

͸Ͱ͵ͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
͸ͪ
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽ;
;͹ͺ΃ͽͰ
͸Ͱͷͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͼͪ
ͺͻͰͺ͹
Ͳ͸ͪͽΓͳͬͳͷ
ͫ͹Βͪͷͪ
͵͹ͻͳ΁ͪ
́Ͳͯͪͬͪ΂ͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͺ͹ͷ͸͹
ͺͻͪͽͰ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ

ͺͻͳͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
;
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
 ̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͵ͪ͹
͹ͭͶͰͯͪͶ͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸; 

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

%KPSEKF
4
,PTUJǀ
3FJTFGÛISFS
BMT
4QJFHFMCJMEFS
QPMJUJTDIFS
7FSÅOEFSVOHFO

BVG
EFN
#BMLBO

%JF
7FSMBHF
EJF
3FJTFGÛISFS
JO
EFS
EFVUTDIFO
4QSBDIF
IFSBVTHBCFO

IBUUFO
OBDI
EFN
#FSMJOFS
,POHSFTT
CJT
[V
EFO
FSTUFO
+BISFO
EFT

+BISIVOEFSUT

FJO
VOE
EBTTFMCF
1VCMJLVN
3FJTFOEF
EJF
4ÛEPTUFVSPQB
CFTVDIFO
XPMMUFO

BCFS
BVDI
-FTFS
EJF
LFJOF
3FJTF
WPSIBUUFO
TPOEFSO
OVS
*OGPSNBUJPOFO
ÛCFS

EJF
#BMLBOIBMCJOTFM
CSBVDIUFO

&JOFT
EFS
XJDIUJHTUFO
.FSLNBMF
BMMFS
BVT
EFS
HFOBOOUFO
;FJU
TUB
NNFOEFO
3FJTFGÛISFS
JTU
EBT
#FEÛSGOJT
OBDI
HFOBVFN
7FSGPMHFO
QPMJUJTDIFS

7FSÅOEFSVOHFO
JO
4ÛEPTUFVSPQB
%JF
[XJTDIFO
[XFJ
"VTHBCFO
JO
FJOFN
-BOE

PEFS
JO
EFS
HBO[FO
3FHJPO
TUBUUHFGVOEFOFO
QPMJUJTDIFO
7FSÅOEFSVOHFO
XFSEFO

TDIPO
JO
EFS
OÅDITUFO
"VTHBCF
WFS[FJDIOFU

*N
FSTUFO
IJFS
FSXÅIOUFO
;FJUSBVN
XVSEF
4ÛEPTUFVSPQB
JO
3FJTF
GÛISFSO
JO
[XFJ
HSP“F
*OUFSFTTFOHFCJFUF
FJOHFUFJMU
m
EBT
FSTUF
EBT
5FJMF
EFS

¸TUFSSFJDIJTDI6OHBSJTDIFO
.POBSDIJF
XJF
BVDI
WPO
.POUFOFHSP
"MCBOJFO

VOE
(SJFDIFOMBOE
VOE
EBT
[XFJUF
EBT
EJF
-ÅOEFS
EFT
;FOUSBM
VOE
0TUCBMLBO

VNGBTTUF

%JF
-FJUNPUJWF
EFS
"VUPSFO
3FEBLUFVSF
VOE
)FSBVTHFCFS
EFS
3FJTFGÛISFS

XBSFO
"VTUSP
VOE
5VSLP[FOUSJTNVT
%JF
SÅVNMJDIFO
#FTPOEFSIFJUFO
EFS

#BMLBOIBMCJOTFM
EJF
FUIOJTDIF
VOE
LPOGFTTJPOFMMF
;VTBNNFOTFU[VOH
EBT

,MJNB
VTX
XVSEFO
JNNFS
WPN
4UBOEQVOLU
EFS
¸TUFSSFJDIJTDI6OHBSJTDIFO

.POBSDIJF
PEFS
EFS
5ÛSLFJ
BVT
CFUSBDIUFU
"MMF
8FHF
GÛISUFO
OBDI
PEFS

BVT
8JFO
PEFS
,POTUBOUJOPQFM
PC
ÛCFS
-BOEFT
PEFS
8BTTFSXFHF
*O
BMMFO

BOBMZTJFSUFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO
XJSE
TPXPIM
EJF
NPNFOUBOF
QPMJUJTDIF
4JUVBUJPO
BVG

EFN
#BMLBO
EBSHFMFHU
BMT
BVDI
EJF
QPMJUJTDIF
,SBGU
EFS
CFJEFO
(SP“NÅDIUF

EJF
JISFN
&JOGMVTT
BVG
EFN
FSXÅIOUFO
(FCJFU
LFJOFTGBMMT
FOUTBHFO
XPMMUFO

%FS
;FJUSBVN
[XJTDIFO
EFO
CFJEFO
8FMULSJFHFO
XBS
XFEFS
GÛS
#JMEVOHT

OPDI
GÛS
&SIPMVOHTSFJTFO
CFTPOEFST
HÛOTUJH
#FLBOOUMJDI
CSBDIUF
EJF
HSP“F

8FMUXJSUTDIBGUTLSJTF
BO
EJF
VONJUUFMCBS
EBT
&OUTUFIFO
OFVFS
QPMJUJTDIFS

.ÅDIUF
NJU
HSP“FO
"OGPSEFSVOHFO
BOLOÛQGUF
6OHFXJTTIFJU
JOT
"MMUBHTMFCFO

5SPU[
BMMFS
#FNÛIVOHFO
BOHFLÛOEJHUFO
7FSÅOEFSVOHFO
GFSO[VCMFJCFO

LPOOUFO
EJF
7FSMBHF
EJF
GÛS
EJF
-JUFSBUVSHBUUVOH
EFS
3FJTFGÛISFS
CFLBOOU

XBSFO
EBVFSOEFN
%SVDL
OJDIU
TUBOEIBMUFO
&JO
.FSLNBM
CMJFC
FSIBMUFO
VOE

BVG
EFO
FSTUFO
#MJDL
FSLFOOCBS
m
EJF
OFVF
QPMJUJTDIF
-BOELBSUF
+VHPTMBXJFOT

XVSEF
JO
BMMFO
"VTHBCFO
EBSHFTUFMMU

 ͚͹ͻΌͰ
͊
̓͹ͼͽͳΕ

*O
EFS
[XFJUFO
)ÅMGUF
EFT

+BISIVOEFSUT
EI
OBDI
NFIS
BMT
WJFS[JH

+BISFO
'SJFEFO
BVG
EFN
#BMLBO
VOE
EFN
BOTDIMJF“FOEFO
,SJFH
VOE
;FSGBMM

FJOFT
4UBBUFT
XVSEF
BO
EFS
,PO[FQUJPO
EFS
(FTUBMUVOH
WPO
3FJTFGÛISFSO
OJDIUT

8FTFOUMJDIFT
WFSÅOEFSU
&OUXFEFS
XFSEFO
IFVU[VUBHF
TUBBUMJDIF
PEFS
SFHJPOBMF

(SFO[FO
SFTQFLUJFSU
PEFS
XFSEFO
CFTUJNNUF
-ÅOEFS
BVG
EFN
.BSLU
EVSDI

LFJOF
CFLBOOUFO
3FJTFGÛISFS
WFSUSFUFO
%JF
7FSMBHF
WFSGPMHFO
OVO
QPMJUJTDIF

6NTUÅOEF
VOE
7FSÅOEFSVOHFO
JO
4ÛEPTUFVSPQB
TFIS
TPSHGÅMUJH

͋ͪͽΒͪ͸ͪ
͏̸̺̾͋́ͣ͆́͆͠
͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ
ͷ;ͲͰΒ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

̸̸͉͎͇͇̻̾̈́́͠



















́
̹͉̾̽̾̓̾́
ћ
̸͉͎͇͇̾̈́͑̓́

̸͇̈́̓̈́́͋̾͋́
͌
͉̹͊́́͠

͉̓͌̈́͋͌͆́
̸͉͋͌́̀ͅ

́
̹͉̾̽̾̓̾́

͋;ͻͳͲͪͷ
ΒͰ
ͽͻͪΒ͸ͪ
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶ͸ͪ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͪ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͪ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ
΁ͪ
͊ͬͰ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͼͬͰ
ͼͽ;ͯͳ͹Ͳ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
͹ͯ
ͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹
΃Ͷ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͹
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷ;
͵ͪ͹
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸͹ͷ
ͳͶͳ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ

͹ͯ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΀
͹ͫͶͳ͵ͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
͹
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹ͷ
ͽͳͺ;
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
;Ͳͳͷͪ

;
͹ͫͲͳͻ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
͊ͬͰ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ
΁ͳͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͳ
ͼ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸ͳͷ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͷ
͹͸ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͻͪ͸ͭͳͻͪΒ;
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸;
ͫͪ΃ͽͳ͸;
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸;
ͫͪ΃ͽͳ͸;
ͳͶͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ

͵ͪ͹
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͻͪͲͶ͹ͭͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
΂ͳΒͳ
ΒͰ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ
ͷͰΌ;
ͯͻ;
ͭͳͷ
΁ͳΓͰͬͳͷͪ
͹ͽ͵ͻͳͬͪΔͰ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽͪ

͈͹ͬͰΓͪ
*$0.04B
J[

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸͹

ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͱͳͬͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͭͶͪͬ͸Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂
͵Ͱ
ͪͽͻͪ͵΁ͳΒͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
ͺ͹ͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪΒ;Εͳ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͳͻ͹͵ͳ

ͺ͹Βͪͷ
͵͹Βͳ
;͵Γ;΂;ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͪ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͪ
͹͵ͻ;ͱͰΔͪ
͵͹Βͳ
͹ͫ;΀ͬͪͽͪ

ͺͰΒͼͪͱͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͪ
ͷͰͼͽͪ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽͰ
ͫͳ͹Ͷ͹΃͵Ͱ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
Ͳͫͳͻ
͵Ͱ
ͺͻ͹΃ͶͰ
ͳ
ͼͪͯͪ΃ΔͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͪ͵ͼͰ
Ͳ͸ͪΔͰ
ͳ
ͱͳͬͪ
ͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬͪ

͆ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͫͰͶͰͱͳ
ͯ;ͭ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Βͪ
΂ͳ͸ͰΕͳ
ͼ;΃ͽͳ͸;



*$0.04
$IBSUFS
PG
$VMUVSBM
5PVSJTN

XXXJDPNPT
PSHUPVSJTBN@
DIBSUFS
IUMN



*$0.04
*OUFSOBUJPOBM
$VMUVSBM
5PVSJTN
DIBSUFS
.BOBHJOH
UPVSJTN
QMBDFT
PG

IFSJUBHF
TJHOJêDBODF  XXXJDPNPT
PSHUPVSJTBN@DIBSUFS
IUMN

 ͋ͪͽΒͪ͸ͪ
͏ͬΒͰͽͳΕͪ͸ͳ͸

ͻͪͲ͸͹Ͷͳ͵ͳ΀
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͪ;ͽ͹΀ͽ͹͸ͳ΀
ͳ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶ͸ͳ΀

ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͽͰͽͪ
ͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͭͻͪͶ͸ͳ
ΒͰ
ͯͰ͹
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸͹ͭ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ


͊ͽ͹ͭͪ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͪ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͪ
ͫͪ΃ͽͳ͸ͪ
ͷ͹ͻͪ
ͯͪ
ͫ;ͯͰ

ͿͳͲͳ΂͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͶͰ͵ͽ;ͪͶ͸͹
ͳͳͶͳ
Ͱͷ͹ͽͳͬ͸͹
ͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺͪ΂͸P
ͭͰ͸ͰͻͪͶ͸͹Β

ͺ;ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
͉ͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ
͸ͳͬ͹ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ

m
;͸ͳͬͰͻͲͪͶ͸ͪ
ͬͻͰͯ
͸͹ͼͽ
ͳͶͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ
ͳͶͳ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶ͸ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ
͵ͪ͹

ͳ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͯͪ
ͫ;ͯ;
ͺͻͳͺͳͼͪ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ
ͻͰΌͰ͸͹ͷ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻ;
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
ͷ͹ͻͪΒ;
ͯͪ
͸ͪ
ͻͰͶͰͬͪ͸ͽͪ͸
ͳ
ͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺͪ΂ͪ͸

͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͫ;ͯ;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͯ͹ͷͪΕͳ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͳͷͪ
ͼͪ

͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪΒ;Εͳͷ
ͼͽͳͷ;Ͷͪͽͳͬ͸ͳͷ
ͳ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳͷ
Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͷͪ
͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬͪ
Δͪ
ͳ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͈͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͺͻ͹ͭͻͪͷͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹΁ͳΒͰ
ͽͻͰ
ͫͪ
ͯͪ
͹ͫ͹ͭͪΕ;Β;
ͻͪͲͬͳΒͪΒ;
ͳ
͹΂;ͬͪΒ;
ͼͬ͹Βͼͽͬͪ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ

ͫͪ΃ͽͳ͸Ͱ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͵ͪ͹
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͷͰͯͳΒͪ
m
ͯ;ͭ͹
͹ͼͳͷ
Ͷͳ΂͸ͳ΀
ͳͼ͵;ͼͽͪͬͪ

ͳ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ
ͷͰͯͳΒ
m
͵͹Βͳ
ͺͻͰ͸͹ͼͰ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸;
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒ;
Ͱͯ;͵;Β;
ͳ
;ͼͷͰ
ͻͪͬͪΒ;
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
ͫͳ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͺͪͱΓͳͬ͹
ͺͻͰͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒ;
͵ͪ͵͹
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͰ

ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͳ
͸ͳͬ͹Ͱ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ

̓ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔ;
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽͳ
;
͊ͻͫͳ
Βͳ
ͳ
ͯͪ
Ͷͳ
͹͸ͳ
Ͳͪͳͼͽͪ
͹ͷ͹ͭ;ΕͪͬͪΒ;
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
͹ͼͽͬͪͻͳ

͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹Ͳͳͽͳͬ͸ͪ
ͼͳͶͪ
Ͳͪ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽ;
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹΁ͳΒ;
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͭ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ
͸͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲ;Β;
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͳ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻͳ

́ͲͪͫͻͪͶͳ
ͼͷ͹
ͽͻͳ
ͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸͹
͸ͪΒͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳΒͪ
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͪ
Ͷ͹͵ͪ
ͶͳͽͰͽͪ
;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͳͲ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ΀
Ͱͺ͹΀ͪ
m
̈́ͰͺͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ
̺ͳͻ
̻ͪͷͲͳͭͻͪͯ
ͳ

͏ͪͻͳ΂ͳ͸
̻ͻͪͯ

̈́ͰͺͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ
̺ͳͻ
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
ͼͰ͸Ͳͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹
͹ͽ͵ͻͳΕͰ
ͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸͹
ͺͻͬͳ

ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽ
͵͹ͯ
͸ͪͼ
΂ͳΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͷͰͯͳΒͼ͵ͳ

ͯ͹ͼͶͰͯ͸͹
ͺͻͪΕͰ͸͹
ͳ
΂ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͪ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸
ͺ͹ͯ;
΀ͬͪͽ
̽ͻ;ͭͪ
ͯͬͪ
ͼͰ
ͯ;ͭ͹
ͼͳͼͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵ͳ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱ;Β;
ͪͯͰ͵ͬͪͽ͸͹
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͯ
ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ
;
ͼͽͻ;΂͸͹Β
ͳ
͸ͪ;΂͸͹ͺ͹ͺ;Ͷͪͻ͸͹Β
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͳ
ͳ
͹ͷ͹ͭ;Εͪͬͪ
Β;
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͼͶ͹ΒͰͬͳͽ͹
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹
ͳ
ͪͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͰ

̓͹ͻͳ΃ΕͰ͸ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͼ;
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒͪ͸
ͳͲͫ͹ͻ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ΒͰ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹
ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂
ΒͰ
ͪͭͰ͸΁ͳΒͪ
͈;ͽ͸ͳ͵ 
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷΓͰ͸
ͳ

͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸
;
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂͵͹Β
͵;Εͳ
̓ͪͻͶͪ
̹ͰͯͰ͵ͰͻB
ͳͲ

͹
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ 



*CJE
1SJODJQMF



*CJE
1SJODJQMF



-K
%
5SBKLPWJǀ
4SCJKB
5VSJTUJǁLJ
WPEJǁ
1SFEV[FǀF
[B
TBPCSBǀBK
QVUOJLB
J

UVSJTUB
V
4SCJKJ
1VUOJL
#FPHSBE

EBMKF
4SCJKB




#BFEFLFST
"MMJBO[
3FJTFGÛSFS
+VHPTMBXJFO
#BFEFLFS
4UVUUHBSU
m
'SFJCVSH


EBMKF
+VHPTMBXJFO


̸ͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ 
 ͋ͪͽΒͪ͸ͪ
͏ͬΒͰͽͳΕͪ͸ͳ͸

ͽͻͰΕͳ
ΒͰ
Ͱ͸΁ͳ͵Ͷ͹ͺͰͯͳΒͼ͵͹ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͹
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
ͳͲ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ 
ͪ
΂Ͱͽͬͻͽͳ
ΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͹
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͳ
͏ͻ͸͹Β
̻͹ͻͳ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

ͺͻͳͬͪͽ͸Ͱ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂͵Ͱ
͵;ΕͰ
ͳͲ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͽͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͶ͸͹
Ͱ͸΁ͳ͵Ͷ͹ͺͰͯͳΒ
ͼ͵͹ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Pͭ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͪ



͊Ͷ;΂ͪΒ

̈́ͰͺͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ
̺ͳͻ

́ͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
̈́ͰͺͰ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
̺ͳͻͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͼ;
ͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹

΃Ͷ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͽͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͳͲ

ͼͪͷ͹
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰ
ͳ
ͬͰͶͳ΂ͪ͸ͼͽͬͰ
͸͹ͼͽ
͚Ͱͻͯͪͺͼ͵Ͱ
͵Ͷͳͼ;ͻͰ
̾͸΁ͳ͵Ͷ͹ͺͰͯͳΒͼ͵͹
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͳͲ


ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
t1SBJTUPSJKTLP
OBTFMKF
VEBMKFOP
PLP
 
LN
PE
VØǀB
#P
MKFUJOTLF
SFLF
V
%VOBW
1PTFCBO
[OBǁBK
BSIFPMPØLPH
PULSJǀB
-FQFOTLJ

7JS
TBESßBO
KF
V
ǁJOKFOJDJ
EB
TV
JTQPE
TUBSJKJI
OFPMJUTLJI
OBTFMKB
T
NB
UFSJKBMPN
EPCSP
QP[OBUF
TUBSǁFWBǁLF
HSVQF
PULSJWFOJ
EPTBE
OFQP[OBUJ

TQPNFOJDJ
QSBJTUPSJKTLF
LVMUVSF
J
VNFUOPTUJ
QMBOTLJ
J[HSBDžFOP
OBTFMKF
T

JNQP[BOUOJN
PTUBDJNB
BSIJUFLUVSF
J
NPOVNFOUBMOJN
TLVMQUVSBNB
PE

LBNFOB
'PSNB
LBNFOJI
PCMVUBLB
ǁWSTUB
J
KBTOB
KBKBTUPH
PCMJLB
JNBMB

KF
NBHJKTLV
NPǀ
[B
TUBOPWOJLBVNFUOJLB
-FQFOTLPH
7JSB
0OB
TF
OJKF

TNFMB
OBSVØBWBUJ
V
MJLPWOPK
PCSBEJ
0OP
ØUP
OBKWJØF
J[OFOBDžVKF
V
PWPK

WFMJLPK
VNFUOPTUJ
KF
OKFOB
NPǀ
EB
TB
NBMP
UFIOJǁLJI
QPTUVQBLB
JTLBßF

OBKWFǀJ
VNFUOJǁLJ
EPNFUi
͊ͪͷ͹
ͯͰͼͰͽͪ͵
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ;Β;Εͳ

͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒ;
ͳ
͏ͻ͸;
̻͹ͻ;
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͳ
ͼͰ
;
t%POKJ
.JMBOPWBD
ǁVWFOP
UV
SJTUJǁLP
NFTUP
OB
%VOBWVi 
ͪͶͳ
ͼͰ
͹
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽ;
̈́ͰͺͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ
̺ͳͻ
ͭ͹



#MBHP
OB
QVUFWJNB
+VHPTMBWJKF
&ODJLMPQFEJKTLP
UVSJTUJǁLJ
WPEJǁ
VS
/

5PNBØFWJǀ

+VHPTMBWJKBQVCMJL
#FPHSBE

EBMKF
+VHPTMBWJKB




̓ͻ͹Ͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒ;
ͳ
͏ͻ͸;
̻͹ͻ;
ͺͻͳͻ
͊
͉ͳͼͽͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ

̸͊́
̸̓͊̾͆
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

m
̈́͹Ͳ͸ͳ΁ͪ

ͯͪΓͰ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
ͳ
͏ͻ͸ͪ
̻͹ͻͪ




̈́ͰͺͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ
̺ͳͻ
ΒͰ
ͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸͹
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪΒͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳΒͳ
ͺͻͪͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳ
ͽͰͽ
;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
͆ͪͶͪͲͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͯ;͸ͪͬͼ͵͹Β
͹ͫͪͶͳ
;
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
͸Ͱͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺͪ΂͸͹Β
͚Ͱͻ
ͯͪͺͼ͵͹Β
͵Ͷͳͼ;ͻͳ
́ͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ͸
ΒͰ
΃ͰͲͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
;
ͼ͵Ͷ͹ͺ;
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ΀

Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽ͸ͳ΀
ͳͼ͵͹ͺͪͬͪΔͪ
ͺ͹ͬͰͲͪ͸ͳ΀
ͼͪ
ͳͲͭͻͪͯΔ͹ͷ
΀ͳͯͻ͹ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
͚Ͱͻͯͪͺ
͆ͳ͵͹

͸ͳΒͰ
͹΂Ͱ͵ͳͬͪ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͳͼͺ͹ͯ
ͷͪͶ͹ͭ
͸Ͱ͹Ͷͳͽͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
ͺͻ͹͸ͪΌ;
ͼͰͯͪͷ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ΀
ͼ;͵
΁Ͱͼͳͬ͸͸͹
ͳͲͭͻͪΌͰ͸ͳ΀
ͪ͸ͭͶ͹ͷͰͻͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͼͪ
ͺͪͱΓͳͬ͹
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽͳͷ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳͷͪ͵;Εͪ
ͷͪ
ͭͻ͹ͫ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
;͵ͪͲ;Β;
͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͭͻͰͫ͸Ͱ
ͻͳͽ;ͪͶͰ
͹ͫͳΓͰ
ͺ͹͵ͻͰͽ͸ͳ΀
͵͹
΃ͽͪ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
͵ͪͷͰ͸ͳ΀
͸ͪͶͪͲͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͷ͹͸;ͷͰ͸ͽͪͶ͸Ͱ
͵ͪͷͰ͸Ͱ
ͼ͵;Ͷͺͽ;ͻͰ
̽ͪΓͪ
ͼ;
ͳͼͽͻͪ
ͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲͪͶͪ
ͯͪ
̈́ͰͺͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ
̺ͳͻ
ͷ͹ͻͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͽͻͰͽͳͻͪ
͵ͪ͹
΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸Ͱ
ͳ

ͯ;ͭ͹ͽͻͪΒ͸Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
m
#$
m
#$
ͺͻͰͷͪ
$
ͯͪͽ;ͷͳͷͪ

ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ

͸ͪΒͼͶ͹ͱͰ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͳ
͸ͪΒͳ͸ͽͻͳͭͪ͸ͽ͸ͳΒͳ΀
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ΀
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
̺ͳͯͳ
̽
͊ͻͰΒ͹ͬͳΕ
͡

̹ͪͫ͹ͬͳΕ
͌ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽ
̈́ͰͺͰ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
̺ͳͻͪ
͈ͻ͹ͼͬͰͽͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

ͼͪ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻ͹ͷ


4SCJKB

m


+VHPTMBWJKB

m


͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
ͳ
͏ͻ͸ͪ
̻͹ͻͪ


 ̸ͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ 

ͬ͹ͻͳ
͵ͪͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͪͅΒͯͪ͸ͺͰ͵
tͰͺ͹͸ͳͷ͸ͳ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽ
ͳͷͪ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ

ͼͶ͹ͱͰ͸;
ͼͽͻͪͽͳͭͻͪͿͳΒ;
̓ͻ͹Ͳ
;ͬͳͯ
;
͹ͼͽͪͽ͵Ͱ
͵;Εͪ
;͵;ͺͪ͸
ͫͻ͹Β
͵;
Εͪ
;
ͼͬͳͷ
΀͹ͻͳͲ͹͸ͽͳͷͪ
ΒͰ

ͳ
ͼͬͰ
ͼ;
΃ͪͽ͹ͻͪͼͽͰ
ͼͪ
͹ͭΔͳ΃ͽͰͷ
;
ͼͻͰ
ͯͳ΃ͽ;

ͼͬͰͽͳͶͳ΃ͽͪ
ͼ͵;Ͷͺͽ;ͻͪ
͹ͯ
Θͳ͸͹ͬͼ͵ͳ΀
͹ͫͶ;ͽͪ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͭͻͪͬ;ͻͪ

͸ͪ
͵ͪͷͰ͸;
͵͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͻ͹ͱͳ͸ͳ
ͺͳͼͷͪ
͵ͻͪΒΔͰ
΃ͳͿͻ͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
͸ͪͷͪ
ͼͽͻͪ
͸ͪ
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃ΔͰͷ
΂͹ͬͰ͵;
ͺͻ;ͱͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
ͯͪ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪ
ͽͬ͹ͻ΁ͪ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͱͳͬͰͶͪ
;
ͻͪͼ͵͹ͻͪ͵;
ͼͪ
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹ͷ
͌
ͽ͹
ͯͪͬ͸͹

ͯ͹ͫͪ
7**
ͷͳͶͰ͸ͳΒ;ͷ
ͺ
͸
Ͱ
Ͱͺ͹΀ͪ
ͷͰͲ͹Ͷͳͽͪ
ͼͻͰͯΔͰ
͵ͪͷͰ͸͹
ͯ͹ͫͪ

;

͹ͼͽͪͶͳͷ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳͷͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͱͳͬͰͶ͹
ͼͰ
ͺ͹
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
Ͳͪ͵Ͷ͹͸ͳͷͪ
ͳ
;

ͼ͵ͻ͹ͷ͸ͳͷ
͵͹Ͷͳͫͪͷͪ
ͪ
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͼͬͰͯͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹͸Ͱ͵;
ͭͻͪͬ;ͻ;

;ͻͪΌͰ͸;
͸ͪ
͵͹ͼͽͳ
ͳͶͳ
ͻ͹ͭ;
̓;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
̈́ͰͺͰ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
̺ͳͻͪ
ͼͽͬ͹ͻͳͶͪ
ΒͰ

ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͼͶ͹ͱͰ͸Ͱ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸Ͱ
ͳ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵Ͱ
;ͼͶ͹ͬͰ
Ͳͪ
͸ͪͼͽͪ͸ͪ͵
ΒͰͯ
͸Ͱ
͵͹ͷͺͶͰ͵ͼ͸Ͱ
ͻͰͶͳͭͳΒͰ
͇ͼͶ;΃͵;Β;Εͳ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ
ͺͪͱΓͳͬͳ
ͼͶ;΃ͪͶͪ΁

ͺͻ͹ͿͰͼ͹ͻ
͊ͻͰΒ͹ͬͳΕ

͹ͽ͵ͻͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͽͪΒ͸;
Ϳ͹ͻͷ;Ͷ;
͵͹Βͪ
ͶͰͱͳ
;
͹ͼ͸͹ͬͳ

ͬͰͻ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͇ͫͶ;ͽͪ͵
m
ͺͻͰͳͼ͵͹͸ͼ͵͹
ΒͪΒͰ
m
ͻͳͫ͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͫͳΕͰ
m
ͼͬͳ
ͷ;
΃͵ͪͻ΁ͳ
ͳ
ͱͰ͸Ͱ
͌Ͳ
ͺ͹ͷ͹Ε
͹ͬͰ
Ϳ͹ͻͷ;ͶͰ
͸ͳ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁;
̈́ͰͺͰ͸
ͼ͵͹ͭ
̺ͳͻͪ
͸ͰΕͰ
ͫͳͽͳ
ͽͰ΃͵͹
ͯͪ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ
͵Ͱi
͆Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͵ͻͪͽ͵͹
͹ͫͪͬͰ΃ͽͪͬͪ
t̽͹Δͳ
ͅͳͶͪ͸͹ͬͪ΁
͸ͪͶͪ
Ͳͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
͵ͻͪΒ;
ͺͻͬ͹ͭ
<ΌͰͻͯͪͺͼ͵͹ͭ>
ͽͰͼ͸ͪ΁ͪ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͳͲͭͻͪͯΔͰ
<ͫͻͪ͸Ͱ>

͸ͪΌͰ͸ͳ
ͼ;
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͼͽͪͻ͹ͭ
ͻͳͫͪͻͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͰͶͪ
̈́ͰͺͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ
̺ͳͻ



͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
ͳ
͏ͻ͸ͪ
̻͹ͻͪ

m
 ͋ͪͽΒͪ͸ͪ
͏ͬΒͰͽͳΕͪ͸ͳ͸

͇ͽ͵ͻͳΕͰ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹
ͳ
͹ͯ
͹ͭͻ͹ͷ͸͹ͭ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ
ͺ͹΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͳͼ͵͹
ͺͪͬͪΔͪ
͹ͷ͹ͭ;ΕͳͶͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ;΂͸͹
ͺ͹ͺ;͸Ͱ
ͺͻͪͲ͸ͳ͸Ͱ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
ͼͻͰͯΔͰͭ

ͳ
ͷͶͪΌͰͭ
͵ͪͷͰ͸͹ͭ
ͯ͹ͫͪ
;
̓ͪͻͺͪͽͼ͵͹ͷ
ͫͪͼͰ͸;
͠Ͱͯͪ͸
ͯͰ͹
͸ͪͶͪͲͪ
ͳͲ

͹ͼ͸͹ͬͪ
͹͵͹

͵;Εͪ
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫ͸ͳ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳ
ͳ
͹΂;ͬͪ͸Ͱ
͵ͪͷͰ͸Ͱ
ͼ͵;Ͷͺͽ;ͻͰ

ͯ͹΃ͶͰ
ͼ;
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
;
͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ
ͷ;ͲͰΒ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
ͯͰ͹
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͰ
ͬͳͯͰͽͳ
;

ͷ;ͲͰΒ;
͸ͪ
͹ͽͬ͹ͻͰ͸͹ͷ
;
ͫͶͳͲͳ͸ͳ
̽͹ΔͰͭ
ͅͳͶͪ͸͹ͬ΁ͪi

͊Ͷ;΂ͪΒ

̻ͪͷͲͳͭͻͪͯ

͇
̻ͪͷͲͳͭͻͪͯ;
ͼͰ

ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͸ͪ
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
t,PE
TFMB

(BN[JHSBEB
QPTUPKF
PTUBDJ
TUBSPH
(BN[JHSBETLPH
HSBEB
LPKJ
KF
EBOBT

QPUQVOP
V
SVØFWJOBNB
5P
KF
SJNTLB
UWSDžBWB
LPKB
KF
TMVßJMB
J
V
LBTOJ
KF
WSFNF
(SBE
MFßJ
OB
QPMKBOJ
QPSFE
$SOPH
5JNPLB
UF
TF
QP
UPNF
V

TWPKPK
LPOTUSVLDJKJ
SB[MJLVKF
PE
PTUBMJI
HSBEPWB
V
OBØPK
[FNMKJ
LPKJ
TV

VWFL
QPEJ[BOJ
OB
V[WJØFOKJNB
1SBWPVHBPOPH
KF
PCMJLB
J
JNBP
KF

LV
MBi
͋ͻͳ
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͰ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
t1SJCMJßOP

LN
KVHP[BQBEOP
PE
;BKFǁBSB

LPE
;WF[EBOB
OB
EFTOPK
PCBMJ
$SOPH
5JNPLB
OBMB[F
TF
PTUBDJ
KFEOPH

PE
OBKESBHPDFOJKJI
BOUJǁLJI
BSIFPMPØLJI
OBMB[JØUB
1SFUQPTUBWMKB
TF
EB

KF
HSBE
QPEJHBP
SJNTLJ
DBS
(BMFSJKF
TWPKPK
NBKDJ
3PNVMJ
J
EB
KF
QP
OKPK

HSBE
OB[WBO
3PNVMJBOB
4NBUSB
TF
EB
KF
QSWPCJUOP
VUWSDžFOKF
T
LSBKB

***
WFLB
PCOPWJP
,POTUBOUJO
7FMJLJ
V
QSWPK
ǁFUWSUJOJ
*7
WFLB
6OVUBS

VUWSDžFOKB
EPTBE
TV
PULSJWFOJ
WFMJLB
J
SBTLPØOB
QBMBUB
TB
BUSJKVNPN
V

TFWFSP[BQBEOPK
ǁFUWSUJ
EWB
QBHBOTLB
ISBNB
USJ
ISJØǀBOTLF
DSLWF
OFLP
MJLP
WFMFMFQOJI
TUBNCFOJI
PEBKB
J
NOPHPCSPKOB
OFWFØUP
HSBDžFOB
LBTOJKB

[EBOKB
1PTFCOV
VNFUOJǁLV
WSFEOPTU
JNBKV
PULSJWFOJ
QPEOJ
NP[BJDJ
V

LPNQMFLTV
NPOVNFOUBMOF
QBMBUF
.OPØUWP
NBMJI
PTNPVHBPOJI
LSV
ßOJI
J
LWBESBUOJI
QPMKB
JTQVOKFOJI
SB[OPWSTOJN
PSOBNFOUJNB
ǁJKF
TV

GPSNF
J
CPKF
SBWOF
OBKCPMKJN
EPTBE
QP[OBUJN
PTUWBSFOKJNB
TB
QPEOJN



+VHPTMBXJFO




͌ͽͬͻΌͰ͸ͪ
΁ͪͻͼ͵ͪ
ͺͪͶͪͽͪ
ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͿͳ͵͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
'FMJY
3PNVMJBOB
m
ͽͰͼͽͪ
ͷͰ͸ͽͪͶ͸ͪ
ͭͻͪͯΔͪ
ͳͷͺͰͻͪͽ͹ͻͪ
̻ͪͶͰͻͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͷͰͼͽ͹
ͷͪ;Ͳ͹ͶͰΒ
ͳ
͵͹͸ͼͰ͵ͻͪͽͳͬ͸ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ
͸ͳ͵
͸ͪ
ͪͭͅ;ͻͳ

ͭͯͰ
ΒͰ
ͼͪ΀ͻͪΔͰ͸
ͳ
ͯͳͬͳ͸ͳͲͳͻͪ͸
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽͪ
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ
***
ͬͰ͵ͪ
̺ͰΕ
;

ͯͻ;ͭ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
*7
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ΔͰ͸ͪ
ͺͻͬ͹ͫͳͽ͸ͪ
͸ͪͷͰ͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͼͽͪΒͰ
ͽͰ
ΒͰ
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹
΀;͸ͼ͵͹ͭ

ͻ;΃ͰΔͪ
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸͹ͷ
7
ͬͰ͵ͪ
;ͽͬͻΌͰ͸͹
͸ͪͼͰΓͰ
͸ͪͶͳ͵
͸ͪ
ͬ͹Β͸ͳ
Ͷ͹ͭ͹ͻ
͌
7*
ͬͰ͵;
͹͸ͪ

ΒͰ
ΒͰͯ͸͹
͹ͯ
ͷͪΔͳ΀
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
͹ͫ͸͹ͬͳ͹
͠;ͼͽͳ͸ͳΒͪ͸
̺ͳͯͳ
̽
͊ͻͰΒ͹ͬͳΕ
͚
ͪ͠͸
͵͹ͬͳΕ
̸
̈́ͪͶ͹ͬͳΕ
̻ͪͷͲͳͭͻͪͯ
m
͵ͪͼ͸͹ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵ͳ
΁ͪͻͼ͵ͳ
ͯͬ͹ͻͪ΁
̸͊͆͌
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ


̽
͊ͻͰΒ͹ͬͳΕ
;ͻ

͉ͳͷͼ͵ͳ
΁ͪͻͼ͵ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
ͳ
ͺͪͶͪͽͰ
̸͊͆͌
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ


ͼͪ
ͼͽͪͻͳΒ͹ͷ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻ͹ͷ
%
4SFKPWJǀ
ƀ
7BTJǀ
*NQFSJBM
.BVTPMFB
BOE
$POTFDSBUJPO

.FNPSJBMT
JO
'FMJY
3PNVMJBOB
4"/6
#FPHSBE

%
4SFKPWJǀ
%JWB
3PNVMB
%JWVT

(BMFSJVT
;
ѮF "HF PG 5FUSBSDIT %
4SFKPWJǀ
VS

4"/6
#FPHSBE

m


4SCJKB



̸ͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ 
 ͋ͪͽΒͪ͸ͪ
͏ͬΒͰͽͳΕͪ͸ͳ͸

NP[BJDJNB
LBTOPBOUJǁLPH
EPCB
V
&WSPQJ
TBNP
KPØ
WJØF
QPUWSDžVKF
EB
KF

PWB
QBMBUB
CJMB
DBSTLB
SF[JEFODJKBi
͊ͻͰͯͳ͸͹ͷ
ͳ΀
̻ͪͷͲͳͭͻͪͯ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪ
ΒͰ
tͻͰͲͳͯͰ͸΁ͳΒͪ
ͻͳͷͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳͷͺͰͻͪͽ͹ͻͪ
̻ͪΒͪ
̻ͪͶͰͻͳΒͪ
̺ͪͶͰͻͳΒͪ
ͪͅ͵ͼͳ
ͷͳͶͳΒͪ͸ͪ
m

ͷͰͼͽ͹
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͳͷͪ
ͳͷͺͰ
ͻͪͽ͹ͻ
͸ͪͲͬͪ͹
ͺ͹
ͼͬ͹Β͹Β
ͷͪΒ΁ͳ
͉͹ͷ;Ͷͳ
ͳ
;
͵͹ͷͰ
ΒͰ
ͻ͹ΌͰ͸
ͳ
ͼͪ΀ͻͪΔͰ͸

̸ͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͪ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲͪͶͪ
ͼ;
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
̻ͪͷͲͳͭͻͪͯ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͪͭͶͰ
ͯͪͬͪͽͳ
;
΃Ͱͼͽ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͺͻͰͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹
͸ͪͼͰΓͰ
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸ͪ
***
͵ͻͪΒ

**
ͳ
ͺͻͬͪ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͪ
*
ͷͳͶͰ͸ͳΒ;ͷͪ
ͺ
͸
Ͱ

͵ͪ͹
ͻͳͷͼ͵͹
ͺ͹Γͼ͵͹
ͳͷͪΔͰ

m
WJMMB
SVTUJDB
***
ͬͰ͵

͵ͪ͹
΁ͪͻͼ͵ͳ
ͯͬ͹ͻͪ΁
͉͹ͷ;ͶͳΒͪ͸ͪ
͵ͻͪΒ
***
m
ͺ͹
΂Ͱͽͪ͵
*7
ͬͰ͵ͪ

͵ͪ͹
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ͸͹
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹
ͳ
ͲͫͰͭ
;
ͼ;ͽ͹͸;
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͪ

ͯͻ;ͭͪ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͪ
*7
ͳ
ͺͻͬͪ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͪ
7
ͬͰ͵ͪ

͵ͪ͹
ͻͪ͸͹ͬͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͼ͵͹

͸ͪͼͰΓͰ
͹ͯ
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸Ͱ
7
ͯ͹
ͺͻͬͳ΀
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͪ
7**
ͬͰ͵ͪ

͵ͪ͹
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ
͸ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
9*
ͬͰ͵

ͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͼ͵Ͷ͹͸ͳ΃ͽͪ
;
9*7
ͳ
97
ͬͰ͵;
;

ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵ͳ΀
͹ͼͬͪΒͪΔͪi
̽ͰͽͪΓ͸ͳΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
ͿͪͲͪ
΁ͪͻͼ͵Ͱ

ͻͰͲͳͯͰ͸΁ͳΒͰ
ͭͯͰ
ͼͰ
t̻ͪͷͲͳͭͻͪͯ
ͼͬͻͼͽͪͬͪ
;
ͻͰͯ
͸ͪΒͻͰͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪͽͳͬ͸ͳ
Βͳ΀
ͻͳͷͼ͵ͳ΀
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͻͪ͸͹ͬͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;i
̻ͪͷ
Ͳͳͭͻͪͯ
ͼͰ
͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
;
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;

͊Ͷ;΂ͪΒ

͏ͪͻͳ΂ͳ͸
̻ͻͪͯ

tƀJUBWB
EPMJOB
SFLF
+BCMBOJDF
KF
V
BOUJǁLP
EPCB
J
LBTOJKF
CJMB
HVTUP

OBTFMKFOB
J
TBEB
KF
QVOB
BSIFPMPØLJI
PTUBUBLB
6
CMJ[JOJ
TFMB
1SFLPQǁFMJDF

J
»UVMDB
WSØFOB
TV
V
OFLPMJLP
NBIPWB
PULPQBWBOKB
SVØFWJOB
SBOPWJ[BOUJK
TLPH
HSBEB
$BSJǁJOB
[B
LPKJ
TF
ESßJ
EB
KF
TMBWOB
+VTUJOJKBOB
1SJNB
6
KV
ßOPN
EFMV
PWPH
HSBEB

HPEJOF
PULSJWFOB
KF
CB[JMJLB
EVHBǁLB

B

ØJSPLB

NFUBSB
/B
KFEOPN
PE
LBQJUFMB
PULSJWFO
KF
VSF[BO
NPOPHSBN



+VHPTMBWJKB

m


͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
ͳ
͏ͻ͸ͪ
̻͹ͻͪ

m


͌ͽͬͻΌͰ͸͹
ͬͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͼ͵͹
͸ͪͼͰΓͰ
m
VSCT
m
ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͿͳ͵͹ͬͪ͸͹
͵ͪ͹
*VTUJOJBOB

1SJNB
ͭͻͪͯ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽ
ͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
7*
ͬͰ͵ͪ
;
ͫͶͳͲͳ͸ͳ
ͷͰͼͽͪ
ͻ͹ΌͰΔͪ
΁ͪͻͪ
͠;ͼͽͳ͸ͳ
Βͪ͸ͪ
͌
ͺͻͬ͹Β
ͿͪͲͳ
ͳͲͭͻͪͯΔͰ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽ
ΒͰ
̸͵ͻ͹ͺ͹Γ
ͳ
̻͹ͻΔͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͼͪ
ͫͰͯͰͷͳͷͪ
ͯͻ;
ͭ;
ͿͪͲ;
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸ͪ
7*
ͬͰ͵ͪ

͹ͫͰͶͰͱͪͬͪ
ͺͻ͹ͫͳΒͪΔͰ
;Ͷͳ΁ͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͳͲͪΔͰ
ͫͰͯͰͷͪ
̽͹ΔͰͭ

ͭͻͪͯͪ
;
ͽͻͰΕ͹Β
ͿͪͲͳ
ͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
7*
ͬͰ͵ͪ

ͳͲͬͻ΃Ͱ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
ͫͻ͹Β͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͭͻͪͯΔͰ
ͳ
ͪͯͪͺ
ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͰΕͳ΀
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽͪ
ͳ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪͬͪΔͰ
ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
͏ͪͻͳ΂ͳ͸
̻ͻͪͯ
ΒͰ

ͼͽͻͪͯͪ͹
;
ͺ͹ͱͪͻ;
;
ͪͬͪͻ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
͸ͪͺͪͯ;

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̹ͳ͹
ΒͰ
Ͱͺͳͼ͵͹ͺͼ͵͹

ͼͰͯͳ΃ͽͰ
́Ͷͳͻͳ͵ͪ
̺ͳͯͳ
̺
̓͹͸ͯͳΕ
̺
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ
͏ͪͻͳ΂ͳ͸
̻ͻͪͯ
m
;ͽͬͻΌͰ͸͹
͸ͪ
ͼͰΓͰ
;
ͬͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͼ͵͹ͷ
́Ͷͳͻͳ͵;
̸͊͆͌
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

ͼͪ
ͼͽͪͻͳΒ͹ͷ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻ͹ͷ


/
%VWBM
7
1PQPWJǀ
VS

$BSJǁJO
(SBE
*
$PMMFDUJPO
EF
M&DPMF
'SBODBJTF
EF
3PNF

 &DPMF
'SBODBJTF
EF
3PNF
3PNF
m
#FMHSBEF

#
#BWBOU
7
,POEJǀ
+
.
4QJFTFS

VS

$BSJǁJO
(SBE
**
$PMMFDUJPO
EF
M&DPMF
'SBODBJTF
EF
3PNF

&DPMF
'SBODBJTF
EF

3PNF
3PNF
m
#FMHSBEF


 ̸ͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ 

WJ[BOUJKTLPH
DBSB
+VTUJOJKBOB
6
SVØFWJOBNB
DSLWF
PULSJWFOB
TV

HP
EJOF
J
PHOKJØUB
TB
PTUBDJNB
TMPWFOTLF
LVMUVSF
OB
PTOPWV
ǁFHB
TF
NPßF

TMVUJUJ
P
CPSCBNB
4MPWFOB
[B
PWBK
HSBE
J
P
OKJIPWPN
ßJWPUV
OB
OKFHPWJN

SVØFWJOBNBi
t*[
WSFNFOB
+VTUJOJKBOB
V
+VHPTMBWJKJ
QP[OBUB
TV
EWB
TQP
NFOJLB
CB[JMJLB
V
1PSFǁV
OB
+BESBOTLPK
PCBMJ
T
WSFEOJN
NP[BJDJNB


J
$BSJǁJO
(SBE
%B
MJ
KF
SFǁ
P
J[
MJUFSBUVSF
QP[OBUPN
*VTUJOJBOB
1SJNB

SF[JEFODJKBMOPN
HSBEV
$BSB
OJKF
KPØ
TJHVSOP
.POPHSBN
+VTUJOJKBOB
OB

KFEOPN
PE
LBQJUFMB
OF
EBKF
[B
UP
OJLBLBW
EPLB[
;JEPWJ
TB
LVMBNB
PLSV
ßVKV
OBTFMKF
EP
TBEB
TV
PULSJWFOF
EWF
HSBETLF
LBQJKF
VOVUBS
LPKJI
KF


ßJWFMP
PLP


MKVEJ
JTUSBßJWBOKB
PULSJWBKV
[BKFEOJDV
OB
WSIVODV

SBEJPOJDF
QSPEBWOJDF
DSLWF
VQSBWOF
PCKFLUF
DJTUFSOF
UFSNF
J
ESVHF

HSBDžFWJOF

4SFEJØUF
HSBEB
ǁJOJ
LSVßOJ
USH
PEBLMF
QPMB[F
ǁFUJSJ
VMJDF
+FE
OB
WPEJ
EP
USPCSPEOF

N
EVHF
FQJTLPQBMOF
CB[JMJLF
PE
LPKF
TV
QPE
OJ
NP[BJDJ
TBMF
J
LSTUJPOJDB
PǁVWBOJ
J[
WSFNFOB
PQTBEF
%SVHB
VMJDB

WPEJ
EP
CB[JMJLF
TB
LSJQUPN
*[WBO
[JEPWB
KF
OBTFMKF
KPØ
KFEOB
DSLWB
J

ǁJUBW
TJTUFN
VUWSDžFOJI
TUSBßBSB
*TQPE
SFLF
$BSJǁJOF
PULSJWFOB
KF
J
CSB
OB
4MPWFOJ
TV
HSBE
SB[SVØJMJ
V
7**
WFLV
%PTBEBØOKB
JTLPQBWBOKB
EP
[WPMKBWBKV
EB
TF
QSFUQPTUBWJ
EB
$BSJǁJO
(SBE
LSJKF
KPØ
NOPHF
UBKOFi

͠;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ
Ͱ͸΁ͳ͵Ͷ͹ͺͰͯͳΒͼ͵͹ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲͳͻͪ
t6

BUBSV
TFMB
»UVMBD

LN
PE
-FCBOB
LPE
-FTLPWDB
OBMB[F
TF
PTUBDJ
$BSJ



4SCJKB




+VHPTMBXJFO


 ͋ͪͽΒͪ͸ͪ
͏ͬΒͰͽͳΕͪ͸ͳ͸

ǁJOPH
HSBEB
KFEOPH
PE
OBKWFǀJI
J
OBK[OBǁBKOJKJI
HSBEPWB
OB
OBØFN
UMV

%PTBE
TV
PULSJWFOJ
WFMJLJ
EFMPWJ
BLSPQPMKB
HPSOKFH
TSFEOKFH

J
EPOKFH

KVßOPH

HSBEB
TWBLJ
PQBTBO
TOBßOJN
CFEFNPN
4WF
VMJDF
HSBEB
QPQMP
ǁBOF
TV
UFØLJN
LBNFOJN
QSBWPVHBPOJN
QMPǁBNB
6
PCJMKV
SB[OPWS
TOJI
HSBDžFWJOB
TB
NBTJWOJN
TUVCPWJNB
ǁJKJ
TV
LBQJUFMJ
CJMJ
CPHBUP
VLSB
ØFOJ
EFLPSBUJWOJN
ëPSBMOJN NPUJWJNB UJQJǁOJN
[B
+VTUJOJKBOPWP
EPCB

J[EBWBKBKV
TF
FQJTLPQTLB
CB[JMJLB
TB
LSTUJPOJDPN
J
FQJTLPQTLB
QBMBUB
OB

BLSPQPMKV
LSVßOJ
USH
TB
USHPWJNB
J
ESVHJN
QSPGBOJN
[HSBEBNB
CB[JMJLB

TB
LSJQUPN
NBMB
CB[JMJLB
J
LSTUPPCSB[OB
DSLWB
V
TSFEOKFN
HSBEV
CB[JMJ
LB
TB
USBOTFQUPN
EWB
LVQBUJMB
J
[HSBEB
TB
EWF
BQTJEF
V
EPOKFN
HSBEV

LBP
J
USJLPOIPTOB
HSPCMKBOTLB
DSLWB
WBO
CFEFNB
TB
KVßOF
TUSBOF
/B

ßBMPTU
PE
WFǀFH
EFMB
PWJI
HSBDžFWJOB
TBǁVWBOJ
TV
TBNP
QSFLSBTOJ
QPEOJ

NP[BJDJ
4WJ
QPEOJ
NP[BJDJ
EBOBT
TV
QPLSJWFOJ
QFTLPN
/BKWFǀJ
EFP
OB
MB[B
J[
$BSJǁJOPH
(SBEB
KF
V
/BSPEOPN
NV[FKV
V
#FPHSBEV
B
KFEBO
EFP

KF
J[MPßFO
V
-FTLPWBǁLPN
NV[FKVi
͈;ͽ;Β;Εͳ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒ;
ͳ
͏ͻ͸;

̻͹ͻ;
ͳ΀
t͠;ͼͽͳ͸ͳΒͪ͸ͪ
͈ͻͳͷͪ
ͼͺͪͯͪ
;
ͬͻ΀;͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵Ͱ
Ͷ͹
͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽͰ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
̺Ͷͪͯͳͷͳͻ
͉
͈Ͱͽ͵͹ͬͳΕ

ͪͬͭ;ͼͽͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

Ͳͪͺ͹΂Ͱ͹
ΒͰ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
Ͱ͵ͼ͵Ͷ;ͲͳͬͳͽͰͽ͈ͪ͹ͯ
͹͵ͻͳΓͰͷ
͊ͻͺ
ͼ͵Ͱ
ͪ͵ͪͯͰͷͳΒͰ
͸ͪ;͵ͪ
ͳ
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͶͳ
ͼ;
͚
̹͹΃͵͹ͬͳΕ
̸

̽Ͱͻ͹͵͹
͊
͉ͪͯ͹Β΂ͳΕ
͚
ͪͅ͸͹̀ͳͼͳ͠;ͼͽͳ͸ͳΒͪ͸ͪ
͈ͻͳͷͪ
͵͹Β;
ΒͰ
΁ͪͻ

͠;ͼͽͳ͸ͳΒͪ͸
ͺ͹ͯͳͭͪ͹
͵ͪ͹
ͼͬ͹Β
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽͪ͸
ͯͪͻ
ͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͷ
͉ͪͯͪ͸;
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂ͳ͹

ΒͰ
ͳͶͳͻͼ͵;
̽ͪͻͯͪ͸ͳΒ;
ͳ
ͷͰͯͳͽͰͻͪ͸ͼ͵;
̽ͪ͵ͳΒ;
ͯͬͰ
ͺͻ͹ͬͳ͸΁ͳΒͰ
ͼͪ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪͷͪ
̽ͪͻͯͪ͸ͪ΁ͪ
ͳ
͋ͻͪ΂ͪ͸ͪi

͊
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͵͹ͷ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͪ
ͪͯͰ͵ͬͪͽͪ͸
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸

ͼͪ
Βͪͼ͸͹
ͳͲͭͻͪΌͰ͸ͳͷ
͵ͻͳͽͰͻͳΒ;ͷͳͷͪ
ͯ͹
͵͹ΒͰͭ
͸ͳͬ͹ͪ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ

ͼͰ
͹ͫͻͪΕͪ
ͺ;ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
ͳ
͵͹
ͼ;
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͺͶͪͼͳͻͪ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ
΁ͳΒͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
Ͳͪͯ͹ͬ͹ΓͪͬͪΒ;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͼ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸ͳͷ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͷ
Ͳͪ
ͫͪ΃ͽͳ͸;

ͳ
ͻͪͲ͸͹ͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͯ͹ͷͪΕͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͳ
Ͱ͸΁ͳ͵Ͷ͹ͺͰ
ͯͳΒͼ͵͹ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͷͳ͸ͳͷͪͶ͸͹
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͶ;ͱͰ

ͺͻ͹ͷ͹΁ͳΒͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ΀
Ͷ͹͵ͪ
ͶͳͽͰͽͪ
͊ͬͰͼͽ
͹
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͹͸ͳ
ͼͪ΂;ͬͪΒ;
Β͹΃
ΒͰ
ͷͪΔͰ
ͺͻͳͼ;ͽ͸ͪ


̓ͪ͵͹
ͼͷ͹
ͬͳͯͰͶͳ
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫΓͰ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
m
͹ͫͳͷ
ͳ
ͬͰͻ͹ͯ͹ͼͽ͹Β
͸͹ͼͽ
m
ͲͪͬͳͼͰ
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
͹ͯ
Ͳ͸ͪΔͪ
͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͳ
ͪͿͳ͸ͳͽͰͽͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͪ

ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͭͶͪͬΓͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸ͳ΀
͹ͯͻͰͯ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͪ
;ͻͰΌͳͬͪ΂͵ͳ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺͽ

ͳ
ͼͽͻ͹ͭ͹ͼͽ
;
΀ͳΒͰͻͪͻ΀ͳΒͳ
ͯ͹ͼͽ;ͺ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͼͬͰ
ͷͪΔͰ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͼ;ͽ͸ͪ



+VHPTMBWJKB

m


͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
ͳ
͏ͻ͸ͪ
̻͹ͻͪ

m
 ̸ͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ 

͵͹ͯ
͸͹ͬͳΒͳ΀
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
́ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͼͽͻ;΂͸Ͱ
ͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͵͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸͹
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽ;Β;
͸ͪͶͪͲͰ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
;
ͼ;ͷͳͻͪΔ;
ͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͪͽͪ

ͳ
;͹ͫͶͳ΂ͪͬͪΔ;
ͳ
ͺͻͳͻͰΌͳͬͪΔ;
Ͳͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͳ
ͯ͹
ͺ͹ͭͻͰ΃͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸
ͽͰͻͺͻͰͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͺ͹ͭͻͰ΃͸ͳ΀
ͪ͵΁Ͱ͸ͪͽͪ
ͳ
ͪͷͪͽͰͻͼ͵͹ͭ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͻͰͲ;Ͷ
ͽͪͽͪ
ͳ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͸ͪ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶ͸͹ͷ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͷ
ͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͷ

͸ͳͬ͹;
͌
ͳͷ
͹ͯͻͰͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵Ͱ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳ
ͽͰͽͰ
ͳͷͪΒ;
ͳ
Ͱͷ͹ͽͳͬ͸;
͹ͫ͹ΒͰ͸͹ͼͽ
;
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͬͪΔ;
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ
ͳ
͵ͪͽ͵ͪͯͪ

ͺͻͰ͸ͪͭͶͪ΃Ͱ͸
ͺͪͽͻͳ͹ͽͳͲͪͷ


͌͵ͻͪͽ͵͹
͸ͪ΃ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͹
͸ͪͷͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
͹
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳͷ

Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽͳͷͪ
ͯͪΒ;
͸Ͱͽͪ΂͸;
ͼͶͳ͵;
ͳͶͳ
;
͸ͪΒͷͪΔ;
ͻ;͵;
ͺͻͰͽͰͻͪ͸;

ͼͶͳ͵;
͇͸ͳ
͸Ͱ
͸;ͯͰ
͹͸͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
͸ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ΀
ͷͰͻͳ
Ͷͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
͹΂Ͱ͵;ΒͰ
͹ͯ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
͹ͬͪ͵ͬ͹ͭ
ͷͰͯͳΒͪ
͵ͻͪͽ͵;
Ͳͪ

ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͰ
͸ͳͬ͹Ͱ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͪͯͰ͵ͬͪͽ͸;
m
͹ͺͽͳͷͪͶ͸;
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒ;

͵͹Βͪ
͸Ͱ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͹
ͬͰͶͳ΂ͪ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
ͬͰΕ
͸;ͯͳ
ͰͶͰͷͰ͸ͽͪͻ
͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
͹
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽͳͷͪ
ͳ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͻͰͪͶ͸Ͱ

ͻͪͲͶ͹ͭͰ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽ;

ͽΒ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͰΔͰ
ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ
͆Ͱ
ͫͳ
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
ͪ
ͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͽͪ͵ͬͳ΀
ͺͻͳͷͰͻͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ

ͺ͹ΒͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͪͬΓ;ΒͰ
͵͹ͷͺͶͰ͵ͼ͸͹ͼͽ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽͪ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͫͪͲͳ΂͸ͳ
ͷͪͻ͵Ͱͽͳ͸
΃͵ͳ
ͺͻͳ͸΁ͳͺ
ͺ͹ͽͻͪͱΔͰͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
ͅ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
m
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͳ

ͳͶͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
͹΂Ͱ͵;Β;
t[OBǁBKOP
JTLVTUWPi
tJTQVOKFOKFi
ͪͶͳ
ͳ

ͼͽͰͻͰ͹ͽͳͺͰ
ͳ
ͿͪͷͳͶͳΒͪͻͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸;
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽ
͌͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͺ͹ͼͷͪͽͻͪͷ͹

ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
͵ͪ͹
͵͹͸Ͳ;ͷͰ͸ͽͰ
ͳͶͳ
͵ͶͳΒͰ͸ͽͰ
ͽͪͯͪ
Ͳͪͳͼͽͪ
ͳͷͪͷ͹

͵ͳ΂
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽͰ
Ͳͪ
͵ͳ΂
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͷͳͼͽͳ΂͸;
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽ
ͷͳͼͽͰͻͳΒͰ
΀Ͱ
ͻ͹ΒͰ
ͻ͹ͷͪ͸ͽͳ΂͸Ͱ
ͺͰΒͼͪͱͰ
ͽΒ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵;
ͰͭͲ͹ͽͳ͵;
͋ͻͰͫͪ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͳͽͳ

΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͳ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͰ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
;
Ͷͳ΂͸͹ͷ
ͳ
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶ͸͹ͷ
͵͹͸ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;

͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳ͵ͪͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ
͸Ͱ
ͳ
Ͳͪͫͪͬ͸Ͱ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͷ͹ͱͰͷ͹
ͯͪ
ͳͲͫͰͭ͸Ͱͷ͹
ͯͪ
ͫ;ͯͰͷ͹
ͳͶͳ
ͰͶͳͽͳͼͽͳ΂
͸ͳ
͸;ͯͰΕͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ΁ͳ͸ͪ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͯͪ

ͻͪͲ;ͷͰ
ͳͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͫ;ͯͰͷ͹
ͺ͹ͬͻ΃͸ͳ
ͳ
͸Ͱ͹ͻͳͭͳ͸ͪͶ͸ͳ
ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͰͷ
ͼͪͷ͹

ΒͰͯ͸͹ͯͳͷͰ͸Ͳͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͪͽͻͪ͵΁ͳΒͪ
ͪͽͻͪ͵΁ͳΒͪ
Ͳͪ
͸ͳͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͽͻͪͼͽͳ

͊
͹ͫͲͳͻ͹ͷ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
ͺ͹ͼͷͪͽͻͪ
ͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹Ͳͳͽͳͬ
͸ͪ
ͼͳͶͪͼ͸ͪͭͪ
Ͳͪ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽ;
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͫͪ΃ͽͳ͸Ͱ 
ͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ

;ͽͳ΁ͪΒ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
ͽͪ͵ͪͬ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͺͻ͹ͭͻͰͼͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͻͪͽͰͭͳΒͰ
͸;ͱ͸Ͱ
;
ͼͬͻ΀;

ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͰ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬͰ
Ͳͪ
ͪͯͰ͵ͬͪͽ͸͹
͵͹ͻͳ΃ΕͰΔͰ
ͺ͹Ͳͳͽͳͬ͸ͳ΀
ͰͿͰ͵ͪͽͪ
ͳ



-
(JU[
'FOPNFOPMPHJKB
LJǁB
#JCMJPUFLB
99
WFL
CS

#*(;
#FPHSBE


m


.
4IBOLT
$
5JMMFZ
3F$POTUSVDUJOH
"SDIBFPMPHZ
3PVUMFEHF
-POEPO


/FX
:PVSL

OE
FEJUJPO




1SFBNCVMB
1PWFMKF
P
NFDžVOBSPEOPN
UVSJ[NV
*$0.04

 ͋ͪͽΒͪ͸ͪ
͏ͬΒͰͽͳΕͪ͸ͳ͸

;ͫͶͪͱͪͬͪΔͰ
͸Ͱͭͪͽͳͬ͸ͳ΀ 
ΒͰͻ
ΒͰ
ͼ;ͯͫͳ͸ͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
ͳͼͽͰ

ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͰ
ͭͯͰͭ͹ͯ
ΒͰ
Ͷͳ΁Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
ͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ
ͼͷͪͽͻͪͷ͹

ͯͪ
͸ͪͺͻͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͷͳ΃ΓͰ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͻͪͽͰͭͳΒͰ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͯͪ
͹ͫ;΀ͬͪͽͪΒ;
ͳ
͵ͻͰͳ
ͻͪΔͰ
ͪͯͰ͵ͬͪͽ͸ͳ΀
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ΕͰ
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽͳ
ͫͳ
ͽͳ
ͺ͹͸͹ͬ͹
͹ͽ͵ͻͳͬͰ͸ͳ



1SFBNCVMB
1PWFMKF
P
LVMUVSOPN
UVSJ[NV
*$0.04

 ̸ͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ 

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

5BUKBOB
$WKFUJǀBOJO
"SDIÅPMPHJF
VOE
3FJTFGÛISFS

BSDIÅPMPHJTDIF
-PLBMJUÅUFO
JO
4FSCJFO
,VMUVSUPVSJTNVT
VOE
3FJTFGÛISFS

3FJTFGÛISFS
BMT
FJOFT
m
NBODINBM
BVDI
EBT
FJO[JHF
m
EFS
.FEJFO
EJF

HSVOEMFHFOEF
*OGPSNBUJPOFO
WFSNJUUFMO
CJMEFO
VOE
MFJUFO
NÛTTUFO
OJDIU
OVS

#FEÛSGOJTTF
EFS
3FJTFOEFO
TPOEFSO
BVDI
LVMUVSFMMF
8FSUF
VOE
EJF
#FEFVUVOH

EFT
&SCFT
FSLFOOFO

8JF
BSDIÅPMPHJTDIF
-PLBMJUÅUFO
JO
4FSCJFO
JO
3FJTFGÛISFSO
BOT
-JDIU

HFCSBDIU
XFSEFO
VOE
JOXJFXFJU
EJFTF
EFO
,VMUVSUPVSJTNVT
BMT
FJOFO
QPTJUJWFO

"TQFLU
CF[ÛHMJDI
EFS
#FXBISVOH
VOE
EFS
'ÕSEFSVOH
EFT
/BUVS
VOE

,VMUVSFSCFT
WPSBOUSFJCFO
LÕOOFO
[FJHFO
NFISFSF
#FJTQJFMF
BVT
WFSTDIJFEFOFO

&QPDIFO
m
-FQFOTLJ
7JS
(BN[JHSBE
$BSJǁJO
HSBE

%JF
3FJTFGÛISFS
EJF
[XFDLT
EFS
WPSMJFHFOEFO
6OUFSTVDIVOH
CFOVU[U

XVSEFO
XVSEFO
EVSDI
;VGBMM
BVTHFTVDIU
m
EFS
FSTUF
FJO
WPO
EFS
3FJTFBHFOUVS

1VUOJL
IFSBVTHFHFCFOFS
3FJTFGÛISFS
TUBNNU
BVT
EFN
+BIS

EFS

[XFJUF
XVSEF

WPN
7FSMBH
,BSM
#BFEFLFS
WFSÕGGFOUMJDIU
EFS
ESJUUF
JTU

FJO
FO[ZLMPQÅEJTDIFS
3FJTFGÛISFS
EVSDI
+VHPTMBXJFO
BVT

EFS
WJFSUF

EJFTNBM
FJO
3FJTFGÛISFS
ÛCFS
4FSCJFO
VOE
.POUFOFHSP
BVT

FOUTUBOE
JO

FJOFN
1SJWBUWFSMBH
JO
4FSCJFO
EFS
CFBCTJDIUJHU
EBNBMT
BO
FO[ZLMPQÅEJTDI
UPVSJTUJTDIFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO
[V
BSCFJUFO

%JF
JO
EJFTFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO
BOHFGÛISUFO
*OGPSNBUJPOFO
XJF
BVDI
EFSFO

6NGBOH
VOE
;VWFSMÅTTJHLFJU
IÅOHFO
JO
FSTUFS
-JOJF
NJU
4BDILFOOUOJTTFO

#JMEVOHTTUBOE
VOE
;VOFJHVOH
EFT
KFXFJMJHFO
"VUPST
FJOFT
CFTUJNNUFO
,BQJUFMT

PEFS
FJOFS
UIFNBUJTDIFO
&JOIFJU
[VTBNNFO
*O
OFVFSFO
"VTHBCFO
LPNNFO

SFEBLUJPOFMMF
,PO[FQUF
VOE
8FSUTDIÅU[VOHFO
EFS
[VS
7FSGÛHVOH
HFTUFMMUFO

"OHBCFO
JNNFS
XFOJHFS
[VN
7PSTDIFJO
0CXPIM
'BDIQVCMJLBUJPOFO
EJF

&SHFCOJTTF
XJTTFOTDIBGUMJDIFS
'PSTDIVOHFO
EFUBJMMJFSU
VOE
FYBLU
EBSMFHFO

SFMBUJW
PGU
WFSXFOEFU
XFSEFO
LPNNU
CFJN
;VTBNNFOGÛHFO
WPO
3FTVMUBUFO

JO
3FJTFGÛISFSO
OJDIU
TFMUFO
[V
'FIMFJOTDIÅU[VOHFO
VOE
JOUFSQSFUBUJPOFO

[V
MBJFOIBGUFO
#FXFSUVOHFO
BVG
MPLBMFN
SFHJPOBMFN
VOE
JOUFSOBUJPOBMFN

/JWFBV
*O
EFO
FS
+BISFO
XFJTFO
BSDIÅPMPHJTDIFO
-PLBMJUÅUFO
HFXJENFUF

,BQJUFM
FNPUJPOBM
HFGÅSCUF
,POOPUBUJPOFO
NJUVOUFS
BVDI
ÛCFSCFUPOUFO

1BUSJPUJTNVT
BVG

*O
"OCFUSBDIU
BSDIÅPMPHJTDIFS
-PLBMJUÅUFO
CJFUFO
VOTFSF
FJHFOFO

3FJTFGÛISFS
FJO
XFOO
BVDI
OJDIU
GBMTDIFT
EBOO
XFOJHTUFOT
ÛCFSUSJFCFOFT
#JME

EBS
4JF
CJFUFO
OJDIUT
WPO
*OGPSNBUJPOFO
BO
EJF
IFVU[VUBHF
IJOTJDIUMJDI
BLUVFMMFS

.B“TUÅCF
VOE
#FEÛSGOJTTF
WPO
5PVSJTUFO
WPO
FJOFN
TPMDIFO
.FEJVN
FSXBSUFU

 ͋ͪͽΒͪ͸ͪ
͏ͬΒͰͽͳΕͪ͸ͳ͸

XFSEFO
LVS[F
VOUFSTDIJFEMJDIFO
#FOVU[FSLSFJTFO
BOHFQBTTUF
*OGPSNBUJPOFO

EI
PQUJNBMF
*OGPSNBUJPOFO
EJF
OJDIU
OVS
FJOF
FS[ÅIMFOTXFSUF
(FTDIJDIUF

UIFNBUJTJFSFO
TPOEFSO
OPUXFOEJHFT
(SVOEXJTTFO
ÛCFS
KFXFJMJHF
-PLBMJUÅUFO

TBDIMJDI
VOE
PCKFLUJW
MJFGFSO
VOE
SFBMJTUJTDIF
(SÛOEF
[V
FJOFN
#FTVDI

IFSWPSIFCFO
&T
HJCU
WJFMF
UBEFMOTXFSUF
7FSTVDIF
,PNQMFYJUÅU
FJOFS
-PLBMJUÅU

[V
TJNQMJGJ[JFSFO
VN
EFN
1SJO[JQ
WPO
"OHFCPU
VOE
/BDIGSBHF
[V
HFOÛHFO

8FOO
#FTVDIFS
OVS
BMT
,POTVNFOUFO
PEFS
,VOEFO
CFUSBDIUFU
XFSEFO
FOUTUFIU

OPUXFOEJHFSXFJTF
FJOF
HFTDIJDIUMJDIF
&YPUJL
JO
EFS
OVS
,JUTDI-PLBMJUÅUFO

GÛS
,JUTDI5PVSJTUFO
FJOF
NZTUJTDIF
7FSHBOHFOIFJU
)FMEFO
SPNBOUJTDIF

-BOETDIBGUFO
VTX
FJOF
XJDIUJHF
3PMMF
TQJFMFO
*O
QFSTÕOMJDIFN
VOE
TP[JBMFN

;VTBNNFOIBOH
TPMMUFO
5BUTBDIFO
VOE

(FTDIJDIUTHFHFOTUÅOEF
BOHFCPUFO

XFSEFO
EJF
OJDIU
OVS
JOGPSNBUJW
VOE
LPNNVOJLBUJW
TJOE
TPOEFSO
BVDI

JOUFSFTTBOU
VOE
BOSFHFOE
%BEVSDI
MJFGF
NBO
OJDIU
NFIS
EJF
(FGBIS
FMJUÅS

[V
WFSGBISFO
JOEFN
OVS
*OGPSNBUJPOFO
QSÅTFOUJFSU
XFSEFO
EJF
GÛS
XFOJHF

WFSTUÅOEMJDI
TJOE
PEFS
BCFS
/BDIESVDL
BVG
FJOEJNFOTJPOBMFO
3FJ[
[V
MFHFO

VOE
EBEVSDI
PCFSGMÅDIMJDI
VOE
CBOBM
[V
CMFJCFO
ͪͅͻ͵͹
͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
̸ͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

̸̹͇̻͉̾̽
͌
̸͆̾͐̓́ͅͅ

̸̸͈͇̺͇͚͌͋ͅ
̸͉̓̾͠ͅ


́
͈͇͇͐̾͋̓ͅ


̸̺̾̓

̿ͰΓͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͼͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒ͹ͷ
͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹ͭ
ͬͰͻ͸ͳ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͪ
ͽͳͶͪ΁
΂͹ͬͰ͵ͪ
Β͹΃
͹ͯ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͻͪΌͪΔͪ
ͺͻͬͳ΀
΁ͳͬͳͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͊ͬͪ͵ͪ

ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͹
͹͸͹ͷͰ
΃ͽ͹
ͺͻͰͯͼͽ͹Βͳ
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ;
;
͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹
ͺͻͰͯ
ͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͯͻͪͭ͹΁Ͱ͸;
ͺ͹ͷ͹Ε
͈ͻͬͳ
ͺ͹͵;΃ͪΒͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;
ͽ͹ͷ
ͼͷͳͼͶ;

ͺ͹ͷ͹ͭ͸Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪͽͳͱͰΓ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
͵͹ͻͰ͸ͳͷͪ
ͼͰͱ;
ͯ;ͫ͹͵͹
;
ͯͪͬ͸ͪ

ͻͪͲͯ͹ͫΓͪ
ͪ͸ͽͳ͵Ͱ
͇ͫͳͷ͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸ͪ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͪ
ΒͰ

͹ͷͳΓͰ͸͹
΃ͽͳͬ͹
͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
;
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
ͬͰΕ
ͳ
ͭͰ͸Ͱͻͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͫͶͳͼ͵ͳͷ

͸ͪ΃Ͱͷ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸;
̹ͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
ͼ͸ͪͱͪ͸
ͺ͹ͯͼͽͳ΁ͪΒ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͽͳͼ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ
͵;ΕͰ
ͳ

͵ͻͰ͸Ͱ
ͯͪΓͰ
͹ͯ
Ͳͪͬͳ΂ͪΒͪ
͇ͬͪ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬͪ
ͽͰͷͪ
Ͳͪ͹͵;ͺΓͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͪͱΔ;

ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳ΀
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂ͪ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͽͪͻͳΒͳ΀
ͽͪ͵͹
ͳ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ΀
ͽͰ
ͼͰ
ͼͽ͹ͭͪ

;
ͽͪ
ͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪΔͪ
͸ͰΕͰͷ͹
;ͺ;΃ͽͪͽͳ
͊ͶͰͯͰΕͳ
ͽͰͷ;
͹ͬ͹ͭͪ
ͼ͵;ͺͪ
͸ͪ΃;

ͺͪͱΔ;
;ͼͷͰͻͳΕͰͷ͹
͵ͪ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
͹
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ

͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
͸ͪͷͰͻ͸ͳͷ
ͯͪ

ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁;
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ

́Ͳ
ͻͪͲͯ͹ͫΓͪ
͹ͯ
͵ͻͪΒͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺͪ
ͯ͹
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵ͪ
͈ͻͬ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ

ͻͪͽͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͺͻͳͻ;΂͸ͳ͵ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂
͵ͳ΀
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂ͪ
ͳ
ͽ͹
m
7FSMBH
WPO
,BSM
#BFEFLFS
ͳͲ
̈́ͪΒͺ΁ͳͭͪ
ͳ
#JCMJPHSBQ
IJTDIFT
*OTUJUVUB
ͳͲ
̈́ͪΒͺ΁ͳͭͪ
ͳ
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
̀ͪ
͹ͬ;
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵;
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳͶͳ
ͼͷ͹

̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬͪ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
m
)BOECVDI
GVS
SFJTFOEF
ͳͲ

ͳ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ 


)BOECVDI
GVS
3FJTFOEF
,POTUBOUJOPQFM
VOE
EBT
8FTUMJDIF
,MFJOBTJFO
FE
,BSM

#BFEFLFS
-FJQ[JH

m
)BOECVJDI
GVS
3FJTFOEF
,POTUBOUJOPQFM
#BMLBOTUBB
UFO
,MFJOBTJFO
"SDIJQFM
$ZQFSO
FE
,BSM
#BFEFLFS
-FJQ[JH

m
 ͪͅͻ͵͹
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ

ͳ
.FZFST
3FJTFCÛDIFS
ͳͲ



ͳ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͈͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
͹ͬͰ
ͯͬͰ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͰ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂͵Ͱ
͵;ΕͰ
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͼͰ

ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;Β;
ͼͪͷ͹
ͺ͹
͹ͫͳͷ;
̀ͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;
͹ͯ
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬͳ΀
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼ;

͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
͹ͺ΃ͳͻ͸ͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͳΒͪ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
͵͹ͯ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂͵Ͱ
͵;ΕͰ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ

ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͼ;
Ͳ͸ͪͽ͸͹
ͼͪͱͰͽͳΒͰ
ͪͶͳ
;
͸Ͱ͵ͳͷ
ͯͰͽͪΓͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹;Ͳͯͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
͵ͪͯͪ
ͼ;
;
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
΂Ͱͷ;
ΕͰ
ͯͪΓͰ

ͫͳͽͳ
ͻͰ΂ͳ

͈ͻͳͻ;΂͸ͳ΁ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͺͻͰͯͷͰͽ

͸ͪ΃Ͱͭ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͼͶͰͯͰ
;͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͰ͸
ͽ͹͵
ͳͲͶͪͭͪΔͪ
͆ͪ
ͺͻͳͶͪͲ;
̹Ͱ
͹ͭͻͪͯ;
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
ΒͰ
ͳͷͪ͹
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵;
ͯͪ
ͺͻ͹΂ͳͽͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ
͵Ͱ
͹
ͭͻͪͯ;
;
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͽͳͱͰ
͆ͪ
ͺͻͬ͹ͷ
ͷͰͼͽ;
ͼͰ
ͼͪ͹ͺ΃ͽͪͬͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
ͭͶͪͬ
͸ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
͸ͪ

ΔͰͭ͹ͬ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒ

͸ͪ
ͼͺ͹Β;
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ΀
ͻͰ͵ͪ
΃ͽ͹
ͷ;
ΒͰ
ͯ;ͭ͹
ͯͪͬͪͶ͹
ͺ͹ͼͰͫͪ͸
ͼͽͻͪͽͰ΃͵ͳ

Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ
͵ͪ͹
t͵Γ;΂ͪ
͋;ͻͼ͵Ͱi
͊ͶͰͯͳ
ͳ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
tͯ͹
͸Ͱ
ͯͪͬ͸͹i
ͳͷͪ͹
͹ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͪͶ͸;
;ͻͫͪ͸;
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻ;
ͪͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͫͻͲ͹
ͺͻͰ͹ͫͻͪ
ͱͪͬͪ
;
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
̓ͪ͹
ͼͽͪͻͳΒͳ
ͯͰ͹
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͼͪ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵ͳͷ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰͷ

ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͼͰ
̽͹ͻΕ͹Ͷ
ͭͯͰ
ΒͰ
ͳ
͵ͬͪͻͽ
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪͬͪΒ;
t΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͠ͰͬͻͰΒͳi

͈͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͰ
ͼͰͿͪͻͯͼ͵Ͱ
ͷͪ΀ͪͶͰ
ͼͪ
ͼͳ͸ͪͭ͹ͭ͹ͷ
;
͹͵ͬͳͻ;
ͽ;ͻͼ͵͹ͭ
΃Ͱ΀Ͱͻͪ

ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹Βͪͬ;
ͯ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͽͻͪΒͪΔͪ
΂ͳΒͳ
͵͹ͻͰ͸ͳ
ͼͰͱ;
ͯ͹

ͼͽ͹
ͶͰΕͪ


͌
ͳͼͽ͹ͷ
;ͬ͹ͯ͸͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͫͻ͹Β
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͼͪ
͸ͪͲ͸ͪ
͵͹ͷ
͵͹͸ͿͰͼͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
;
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
ͳͲ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͼͪ͹ͺ΃ͽͪͬͪ
ͯͪ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͳͷͪ

ͱͳͽͰΓͪ
͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ΒͰ
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹

ͺͻͰ͵͹

ͫͳͶ͹
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬ͸Ͱ
ͬͰͻͰ
͹͵͹

͵ͪͽ͹Ͷͳ͵ͪ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹


ͺͻ͹ͽͰͼͽͪ͸ͪͽͪ

͠ͰͬͻͰΒͪ
ͳ
ͼͪͷ͹

ͷ;ͼͶͳͷͪ͸ͪ
̓ͻ͹Ͳ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͳΒͪ
ͳͲ
ͯͪΔͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
;ͻͰͯ͸͹
ͼͰ
ͺͻͪͽͳ
ͻͪͼͽ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
͋ͪ͵͹

ͼͰ
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΒͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁ͳ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͫͳͶ͹

͹͵͹

ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
́ͼͽͳ
ͫͻ͹Β
ͺ͹͸ͪͬΓͪ
ͳ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ͹
ͳͲͯͪΔͰ
ͳͲ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͪͶͳ
ͫͰͲ
͸ͪͬ͹ΌͰ͸ͪ
͵͹͸ͿͰͼͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͰ
͆Ͱ΃ͽ͹

͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
ͬͰΕ

ͭͻͪͯ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͪͅΒͰͻ;
ͳͷͪ͹
͹͵͹

ͱͳͽͰΓͪ
ͪ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

͌
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ;
͸ͪ
͵͹͸ͿͰͼͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸;
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻ;
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ

ͺͻͬͰ
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͰ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
;͹΂Γͳͬ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ

ͫͻ͹Β
͠ͰͬͻͰΒͪ
ͻͪͼͽͰ
͸ͪ

ͯ͹͵

ͫͻ͹Β
ͷ;ͼͶͳͷͪ͸ͪ
ͼͽͪͭ͸ͳͻͪ
͸ͪ
͹͵͹


̽ͪΓͰ
ͼͶͰͯͳ
΂ͳͽͪͬ
͸ͳͲ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵͹
Βͳ
ͺͻͬͳ
ͺ;ͽ
ͼͽͳͱͰ
;
͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ
ͭͻͪͯ
̹;ͯ;Εͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ͹
͸ͪ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͳ



.FZFST
3FJTFCVDIFS
5VSLFJ
3VNBOJFO
4FSCJFO
#VMHBSJFO
'VOGUF
"VGMBHF

-FJQ[JH
VOE
8JFO

m
́ͼͽ͹
4FDITUF
"VGMBHF

m
́ͼͽ͹
4FCFOUF

"VGMBHF

m
.FZFST
3FJFTCVDIFS
#BMLBOTUBBUFO
VOE
,POTUBOUJOPQFM
"DIUF

"VGMBHF

m
 ̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
;
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ

ͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ

ͬͰ͵ͪ 

͸ͪ
;ͶͪͲ;
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
ͼͶͰͯͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͪͼ͹΃͵ͪ
͵͹͸ͽͻ͹Ͷͪ
͇͸ͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͫͪͬΓͪͶͪ

͸ͪ
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΂͵͹Β
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͳͶͳ
;
ͺͻͳͼͽͪ͸ͳ΃ͽ;
͈͹ͼͰͯ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͺͪͼ͹΃ͪ

ͫͳͶ͹
ΒͰ
͹ͫͪͬͰͲ͸͹
ͪͶͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͬͳͲͰ
ͼͰ
͸ͳͭͯͰ
͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔ;
͈͹Ͷͳ΁ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ

;ͺͳͼͳͬͪͶͪ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
͹
ͼͽͻͪ͸΁;
ͪͶͳ
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͯ;ͻͪ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͫͻͲͪ
ͳ

 ͪͅͻ͵͹
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ

ͽͻͪΒͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͪ͹ͺ΃ͽͪͬͪ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
͹͵͹

ͷͳ

͸;ͽͪ
ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
ͼ͵ͻͰͽͪͶͪ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;ΕͰ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰ
ͷͰ
͌͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ΒͰ

͸Ͱ͵͹
͸ͪͷͰͻͪͬͪ͹
ͯͪ
͸ͪͺ;ͼͽͳ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
ͫͻ͹ͯ͹ͷ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ

ͺ͹ͶͪͲͳ͹
;

΂ͪͼ͹ͬͪ
;Β;ͽͻ͹
ͺͪͼ͹΃͵Ͱ
Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͶ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͷ͹ͻͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
͹ͫͪͬͳ

ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸͹
ͺ͹ͺ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰ
͵ͻͪΒͪ
ͻͪͯ͸͹ͭ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂͸Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳ΁ͳΒ
ͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
;
ͺͻͳͼͽͪ͸ͳ΃ͽ;
͌
ͬͰͲͳ
ͼͪ
͹ͬͳͷ
Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͶ͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
;
ͭ͹ͽ͹
ͬ͹
ͼͬͳͷ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͳͻͪ͸ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͼͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;

;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͼͬͳ
͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͳΒͳ
Γ;ͯͳ
ͼͶ;ͱͰ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵͹ͷ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ

΂ͳ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΁ͳ
;
ͺͻͳͼͽͪ͸ͳ΃ͽ;

͈ͻͳͼͽͳͭͶ͹ͷ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵;
ͼͰ
ͼͪͬͰͽ;ΒͰ
ͯͪ
͸͹ͬͪ΁
ͷͰΔͪ
;
ͷͰΔͪ΂͸ͳ
΁ͪͷͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͺͻͳͼͽͪ͸ͳ΃ͽ;
ͳͶͳ
;
ͫͪ͸͵ͪͷͪ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͬ͹Γ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͬͳͲͳΒͰ
ͳ
;ͬͰ͵
;Ͳ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͰ͸;
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͪ;ͼͽͻ͹;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͳ
͸͹ͬͪ΁
͸Ͱͻͪ
ͯ͹
ͺͻͳͷͪ
ͳͲͬͪ͸
͸͹ͬ΂ͪ͸ͳ΀
Ͳͪͬ͹ͯͪ
̀ͪ
͸͹ͬ΂ͪ͸Ͱ
ͽͻͪ͸ͼͪ͵΁ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;
΂ͳͬͪ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͪ
͵ͻͰͯͳͽ͸ͪ
ͫͪ͸͵ͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͷͪͶͪ
ͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ͸;
ͺ͹ͼͶ͹ͬ͸;

ͼͪͻͪͯΔ;
ͼͪ
͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪΒ;Εͳͷ
ͫͪ͸͵ͪͷͪ
;
̹ͰͻͶͳ͸;
ͳ
̈́ͪΒͺ΁ͳͭ;
͌Ͳ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻ
ͷͪ΁ͳΒ;
͹
ͷ͹͸Ͱͽͪͻ͸͹ͷ
ͼͳͼͽͰͷ;
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͳ
͸͹ͬ΂ͪ͸ͳͷ
ͪͺ͹Ͱ
͸ͳͷͪ
;
͹ͺͽͳ΁ͪΒ;
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͼͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͯͳ͸ͪͻ
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ͵
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵͹ͷ
Ϳͻͪ͸͵;

ͪ
ͳͼͽͪ͵͸;ͽ
ΒͰ
ͳ
͵;ͻͼ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹Β
ͳ
ͪ;ͼͽͻ͹;ͭͪͻͼ͵͹Β
ͷ͹͸Ͱͽͳ
͋ͪ͵͹

ͼͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ

͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ΀
ͷͪͻͪ͵ͪ
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͪͶ͹
m
ͯͳ͸ͪͻͪ
ͪ


ͼͬͰͭͪ

ͯͳ͸ͪͻͪ
΃ͽ͹
ΕͰ
͹ͼͽͪͽͳ
͸Ͱͺͻ͹ͷͰΔͰ͸͹
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵ͪ

͈ͻͬ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
̓;ͻͼ
ͪ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
͵ͻ;͸Ͱ
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ
͵͹͸ͼͽͪ͸
ͽͪ͸
̻͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ


͵ͻ;͸Ͱ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͷͰΔͪͶͰ
Ͳͪ
 
ͯ͹
 
ͯͳ͸ͪͻͪ
ͪ
ͳͼͽͳ

͹ͯ͸͹ͼ
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͳ


̀ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͸ͪ͵͹͸
ͲͪͯͻͱͪͬͪΔͪ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
ͱͰͶͰͶͳ
ͯͪ

͸ͪͼͽͪͬͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͬ͹Ͳ͹ͷ
ͼͪͷ͹
;
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬͳͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪͽ
ͳ

ͻͰͯ
ͬ͹ͱΔͰ
ͼͪ
͹Ͳ͸ͪ΂Ͱ͸͹ͷ
΁Ͱ͸͹ͷ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹ͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͯ͹
ͱͰ
ΓͰ͸Ͱ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΒͰͷ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹
͆ͳ΃ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪͶ͹
 
ͯ͹


ͼͪͽͳ
ͯ͹
͊͹ͿͳΒͰ
͹͵͹

ͪ
ͯ͹
͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͪ


ͼͪͽͳ
͈;ͽ͸ͪ
͵ͪͻͽͪ
*

͵ͶͪͼͰ
ͯ͹
͆ͳ΃ͪ
͵͹΃ͽͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͺͻͬͰ
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͰ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
 
ͯͳ͸

**
͵ͶͪͼͰ
 
ͪ
***
͵ͶͪͼͰ

ͯͳ͸ͪͻͪ
͌
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ;
͸ͪ
΁Ͱ͸Ͱ
ͳͲ

͵͹ΒͰ

ͼ;
ͫͳͶͰ
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
;͹΂ͪͬͪ
ͼͰ
Ͷͳ͸Ͱͪͻ͸͹
ͺ͹ΒͰͬͽͳΔͰΔͰ
͹ͯ
ͺ͹
ͯͬͪ
ͯͳ
͸ͪͻͪ
́ͷͪΒ;Εͳ
;
ͬͳͯ;
ͯͪ
ͼ;
͹ͬͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͫͳ
ͳ΀
͸ͪ
ͲͬͪͶͳ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵͹ͷ
ͺͻͰͬͪͼ΀͹ͯ͸͹
ͫͳͶͳ
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸ͳ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ

ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͳ΃Ͷͳ
͵ͪ
Β;ͭ;
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹͵;
͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔ;
ͼͰ
͹ͯͻͰͯͳ΃ͽͪ

͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
͈Ͱ΃ͽͪ
ͳ
̹Ͱ΂
ͳͶͳ
͈ͪͻͳͲ
m
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͸ͪ
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
t͇ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽ
Ͱ͵ͼ
ͺͻͰͼͪi
͋Ͱ
΁ͰͶ͹ͬͳͽͰ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ

͸ͪͶͪͲͳͷ͹
;

͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪΒ;Εͳͷ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
ͳͲ
ͳͼͽ͹ͭ
ͻͪͲͯ͹ͫΓͪ

́͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
ͻͰͯ;
ͬ͹ͱΔͰ
ͺͪͻ͹ͫͻ͹ͯͪ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ
͸ͳͼ;
ͫͳͶͰ

͹ͯ
ͺͻͳͷͪͻ͸͹ͭ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ
͆ͪͶͪͲͳͷ͹
ͳ΀
ͼͪͷ͹
;
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬͳͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
ͳͲ

 ̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
;
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ

ͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ

ͬͰ͵ͪ 


ͳ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͽ͹
͹͸Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
͸ͪ
͏ͪͻͼ͵͹͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵͹

̽;͸ͪͬͼ͵͹
ͺͪͻ͹ͫͻ͹ͯͪͻͼ͵͹
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬ͹
t̽͹ͫͻͳͷ
ͫͻ͹ͯ͹ͬͳͷͪi
͹ͬͰ
͵͹ͷ
ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͷ͹ͭͶ͹
ͼͰ
ͽͻͳ
ͺ;ͽͪ
͸ͰͯͰΓ͸͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪͽͳ
ͺͻͰ
ͷͪ
͇ͻ΃ͪͬ;
ͳ
͋;ͻ͸
͊ͰͬͰͻͳ͸;
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
̹;ͯͳͷͺͰ΃ͽͳ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
͈ͪ͸΂Ͱͬ;
ͳ

͑ͪͺ΁;
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸͹
ͪ
ͯ͹
̀Ͱͷ;͸ͪ
ͯͬͪ
ͺ;ͽͪ
;
ͽ͹͵;
ͯͪ͸ͪ
ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
͸ͪ

͸Ͱ͵ͳͷ
͹ͯ
͹ͬͳ΀
ͻͰͶͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪͶͪ
ͼ;
ͳ
ͺͶ͹ͬͳͶͪ
͊ͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
̹ͻ͹ͯͪͻ
ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͪ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹Ͷͪ
ͼͪͽͪ
ͷ͹ͭͶ͹
ͺͻͰΕͳ
;
̀Ͱͷ;͸
ͳͶͳ

ͼͬͪ͵͹ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪͽͳ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͪ
ͯ͹
͉ͪͯ;ΒͰͬ΁ͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
͵ͪ

ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹Β
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͳ

͊ͬͪ͵͹ͷ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵;
;
ͼͽͻͪ͸͹ͷ
ͭͻͪͯ;
ͺ͹΃ͽͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
;ͼͶ;ͭͰ
ͼ;
;͹ͫͳ
΂ͪΒͰ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͪ
͌
ͽ͹ͷ
ͼͷͳͼͶ;
ͫͳͶͳ
ͼ;
;ͺ;ΕͰ͸ͳ
͸ͪ
̻Ͷͪͬ͸;
ͺ͹΃ͽ;
ͼͪ

ͽͰͶͰͭͻͪͿ͹ͷ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
;
ͼͪͯͪ
ͺ͹ͻ;΃Ͱ͸͹ͷ
̓͹Ͷͪͻ΂Ͱͬ͹ͷ
ͲͯͪΔ;

͵͹ͯ
͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͳ΃ͽͪ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
͹͸;
;
Ͳͭͻͪͯͳ
̿ͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ

ͳ
ͺ͹΃ͽ;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ͊ͪͬͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
͵ͻͪΒ
͈ͻͳͼͽͪ͸ͳ΃ͽͪ
;
̓ͪͻͪ
Ό͹ͻΌͰͬ͹Β
;Ͷͳ΁ͳ
͌Ͳ
͹ͬ͹
;ͺ;ͽͼͽͬ͹
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
ͼ;
ͺͻ͹΂ͳͽͪͽͳ
ͳ
͵͹Ͷͳ͵Ͱ
ͼ;

΁Ͱ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹΃ͽͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͽͰͶͰͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ΀
;ͼͶ;ͭͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΒͰͷ͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;
ͯ͹ͷͪ
ΕͰͷ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ;
ͼͶͪΔͰ
ͺͳͼͷͪ
͵͹΃ͽͪͶ͹

ͺͪͻͪ
ͪ
ͯ͹ͺͳͼ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͳͶͳ
ͻͪͲ
ͭͶͰͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ

ͺͪͻͪ
͏Ͱ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ
ͳ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͼͽͬ͹
ͼ;
;
ͺͻ͹ͼͰ͵;
ͫͳͶͰ
ͯͬ͹ͼͽͻ;͵͹

ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͊ͶͪΔͰ
ͽͰͶͰͭͻͪͷͪ
Ͳͪ
͆Ͱͷͪ΂͵;
͹ͯ
ͷͳ͸ͳͷ;ͷ

ͻͰ΂ͳ
ΒͰ
͵͹΃ͽͪͶ͹

 
ͯͳ͸
Ͳͪ
̸;ͼͽͻͳΒ;
 
Ͳͪ
ͪͅΌͪͻͼ͵;
 
ͯͳ͸
ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂ΒͰ
͊ͻͫͳ
ΒͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͪ
ͯͳ͸ͪͻͪ
̺ͪΓͪ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͯͼͰͽͳͽͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͪͻͳͿͪ
Ͳͪ
͏ͻ͸;
̻͹ͻ;

;
ͽ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͳͲ͸͹ͼͳͶͪ
΁ͰͶͳ΀
 
ͯͳ͸ͪͻͪ
͇ͬͰ
΁Ͱ͸Ͱ
͸ͪͻͪͬ͸͹
͸ͳͼ;
ͼͰ

ͷͰΔͪͶͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͹ͯ
ͯͬͰ
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹
͈ͻͬ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ

͌
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬͳͷ
ͳ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ͹
ͼͰ
ͳ
͸ͳͲ

ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ΀

ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͼͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ͭ͹
ͬ͹ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͸ͪͷͰͻͪͬͪͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͳͲͬͰͼ͸͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͺͻ͹ͬͰͯ;
;

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
͋;
ͼ;
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
΀͹ͽͰͶͳͷͪ
͵ͪͿͪ͸ͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͺͳͬ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ


͵Δͳͱͪͻͪͷͪ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
;ͼͶ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͻͰͬ͹Ͳͪ
ͳ

΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
ͬͪͱ͸͹
ͪͯͻͰͼͪͷͪ
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͪͬͪ

͆Ͱͷͪ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ
̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͼ
ͳͷͰ͸ͳͷͪ
ͺ͹ͼͶͪ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͪ͵ͻͰͯͳͽ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ΀
͸ͪ

ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͷ
ͯͬ͹ͻ;
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͵͹͸Ͳ;Ͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͽͪͯͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͳ
͸ͪ
ͼͶ;ͱͫͳ
;

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;

͈͹ͶͪͲͰΕͳ
ͼͪ
̿ͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͳͶͳ
͈ͻͳͼͽͪ͸ͳ΃ͽͪ
͵ͪ
΁Ͱ͸
ͽͻ;
Ͳͪ
ͬ͹ͱΔ;
ͺ͹
ͭͻͪͯ;
͹͸ͯͪ΃Δͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳͷͪ
ͫͳͶͳ
ͼ;
͸ͪ
ͻͪͼͺ͹Ͷͪͭͪ
Δ;
ͿͳΒͪ͵Ͱͻ
ͳ
ͽͻͪͷͬͪΒͳ
̀ͪ
ͳͷ;Ε͸ͳΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͿͳΒͪ͵Ͱͻ
ͼͳͭ;ͻ͸͹
ͫͳ͹
;ͯ͹ͫ͸ͳ
Βͳ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͶͳ΂͸͹
ͼ͵;ͺ
̺͹ͱΔͪ
ͯ͹
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
͋ͰͻͪͲͳΒͪ
ͳͶͳ



́Ͷ;ͼͽͻ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͬ͹Όͪ
ͺ͹
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁ͳ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͳ
͹͵͹Ͷͳ͸ͳ

ͳͲͻͪͯͳ͹
͊ͻͰͽ
͇ͫͻͪͯ͹ͬͳΕ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ


 ͪͅͻ͵͹
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ

̓ͻͪΓͰͬ͹ͭ
ͽͻͭͪ
ͼͪͯͪ
͊ͽ;ͯͰ͸ͽͼ͵ͳ
ͽͻͭ

͵͹΃ͽͪͶͪ
ΒͰ

ͪ
͸͹Ε;
΁ͰͶͪ


ͯͳ͸ͪͻͪ
́ͲͶͰͽ
ͯ͹
͋͹ͺ΂ͳͯͰͻͪ
ͳ
͸ͪͲͪͯ
ͼͪ
ͲͪͯͻͱͪͬͪΔͰͷ
͹ͯ
ͯͬͪ
ͼͪͽͪ

͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΒͰͷ͹
ͳͲ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
͵͹΃ͽͪ͹
ΒͰ

ͯͳ͸ͪͻͪ
ͪ
ͯ͹
ͷͪ͸ͪ
ͼͽͳͻͪ
͉ͪ͵͹ͬͳ΁Ͱ
΁ͰͶͳ΀

ͯͳ͸ͪͻͪ
̺͹ͱΔͪ
ͽͻͪͷͬͪΒͰͷ
ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͽ͸͹

ΒͰͬͽͳ͸ͳΒͪ
͌
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬͳͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
ͳͲ

ͳ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ

ͼͰ
ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻͳ΂͸ͳ
ͽͻͪͷͬͪΒ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
͹͸ͪΒ
ͼͪ
͵͹Δͼ͵͹ͷ
ͬ;΂͹ͷ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
;ͫͻͲ͹

͸ͪ͵͹͸
ͽ͹ͭ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͳͲͪ΃ͪ͹
ͳͲ
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͰ
͏Ͱ͸ͪ
ͬ͹ͱΔͰ
ͽͻͪͷͬͪΒͰͷ
ͺ͹

΁Ͱ͸ͽͻ;
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͵͹΃ͽͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;

ͳ

ͺͪͻͪ
̽͹
;ͯͪΓͰ͸͹ͭ
͋͹ͺ΂ͳͯͰͻͪ

ͬ͹ͱΔͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͻͪΒͪͶͪ
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
ͷͪΔͰ
͹ͯ
ͺ͹Ͷͪ
ͼͪͽͪ
ͪ
΁Ͱ͸ͪ
ͽͻͪͷͬͪΒͼ͵Ͱ
͵ͪͻͽͰ

;
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
ͺͻͪͬ΁;
ͳͲ͸͹ͼͳͶͪ
ΒͰ

ͺͪͻͪ

ͅͰΌ;
ͫͰ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳͷ
΀͹ͽͰͶͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͫͳͶ͹
͹͵͹



;
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬͳͷ
ͳ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬͳͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;
ΒͰ
͹ͯͼͰͯͪΔͰ
;
ͼͪͷ͹
΂Ͱͽͳͻͳ
ͯ͹
΃Ͱͼͽ
ͳ
ͽ͹
ͳͼ͵Γ;΂ͳͬ͹
͹͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͬͰ
͵ͪ
ͽͰͭ͹ͻͳΒͰ
͆ͪ
΂ͰͶ;
ͶͳͼͽͰ
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
΀͹ͽͰͶ
t̻ͻͪ͸ͯi

͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ͹
͸ͪ
ͷͰͼͽ;
ͼͪͯͪ΃ΔͰ
ͲͭͻͪͯͰ
͍ͳͶ͹Ͳ͹Ϳͼ͵͹ͭ
Ϳͪ͵;ͶͽͰͽͪ
;

͐ͳ͵ͪ
͡;ͫͳ͸͹Β
;Ͷͳ΁ͳ

́ͷͪ͹
ΒͰ

ͶͰͺ͹
;ͻͰΌͰ͸ͳ΀
ͼ͹ͫͪ
ͼͪ
΁Ͱ͸ͪͷͪ

͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͼ
͵ͻͰͽͪͶͰ
͹ͯ

ͯ͹

ͯͳ͸ͪͻͪ
͈ͻͰͺ͹ͻ;͵ͪ
ͷ;
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͳ
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ

ͽ;
ͷ͹ͭͶ͹
ͺ͹ͺͳͽͳ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͭ
ͳ
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹
ͺͶͲͰ͸ͼ͵͹
ͺͳͬ͹
͊;ͯͰΕͳ
ͺ͹

΁Ͱ͸ͪͷͪ
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
͸ͪΒͫ͹Γͳ
͹͸͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ
ͫͰ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳ
΀͹ͽͰͶ
͈ͻͳͷͪͽ

ͷ;
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰ;Ͳͳͷͪ
͸͹ͬ͹ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽͳ
΀͹ͽͰͶ
tͅ͹ͼ͵ͬͪi
͸ͪ

͋ͰͻͪͲͳΒͪͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͳͷͪ͹

ͼ͹ͫͪ
ͼ
ͻͪͼͺ͹͸͹ͷ
΁Ͱ͸ͪ
͹ͯ

ͺͪ

΂ͪ͵
ͯ͹

ͯͳ͸ͪͻͪ 
͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͺ͹
ͼͬͰͷ;
ͼ;ͯͰΕͳ
ͺͶͪΕͪͶ͹
Ͳͪ
ͪͺͪͻͽ
ͷͪ͸
̺ͪΓͪ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
΀͹ͽͰͶ;
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͯ;ͭ͹
ͬͪͱͳ͹
Ͳͪ

͸ͪΒͶ;͵ͼ;Ͳ͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͰ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵͹
ͲͯͪΔͰ
ͽͰ
ͬͻͼͽͰ
͹ͫͳ΂͸͹
͹ͯͼͰͯͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͼͽͻͪ
͸ͳ
Ͳͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹Β
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͅͰΌ;
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹

ͼ͵ͻ͹ͷ͸ͳΒͳͷ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ͹
ͼͰ
΀͹ͽͰͶ
t͈ͪͻͳͲi
͸ͪ
͋ͰͻͪͲͳΒͪͷͪ 
͸ͪ
ͷͰͼͽ;
ͯͪ͸ͪ
΃ΔͰͭ
̹ͰͲͳͼͽͪ͸ͪ
΂ͳΒͳ
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͫͪͻ
ͻͰͼͽ͹ͻͪ͸
ͫͳ͹
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂Ͱ͸



́ͼͽ͹



̹
̈́ͪͲͪͻͰͬͳΕ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ͸ͪͯͶͰ΃ͽͬͪ
͵͹ͻͺ͹ͻͪ΁ͳΒͰ
;ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬͰ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͺͻͳ
ͬͪͽ͸Ͱ
Βͪͬ͸ͳ
ͼͶ;ͱͫͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
Βͪͬ͸ͳ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ
;Ͷͳ΁Ͱ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

m


͈ͻͬ͹ͫͳͽ͸ͳ
΀͹ͽͰͶ
t̻ͻͪ͸ͯi
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ͹
;
Ͳͭͻͪͯͳ
t͊ͽͪͻ͹ͭ
ͲͯͪΔͪi
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;
ͽ͹Β

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
ͺ;ͽͪ
͊ͪͫ͹ͻ͸Ͱ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ
̻͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

̽
ͅͳͶͳ΂ͰͬͳΕ
ͼͳ͸
Ͳͪ
͵;ͺ΁ͪ
΀͹ͽͰͶͪ
;
t͊ͽͪͻ͹ͷ
ͲͯͪΔ;i
ͭͻͪͯͳ
͸͹ͬͳ
΀͹ͽͰͶ
t̻ͻͪ͸ͯi
;
͐ͳ͵ͪ
͡;ͫͳ͸͹Β

͸ͪ

ͷͰͼͽ;
ͼͽͪͻͳΒͰͭ
΀͹ͽͰͶͪ
t͈ͻͰͼͽ͹Ͷ͹͸ͪͼͶͰͯ͸ͳ͵i
̺ͳͯͳ
%
ƄVSJǀ;BNPMP
)PUFMJ
J
LBGB
OF

WFLB
V
#FPHSBEV
#FPHSBE

m


́Ͷ;ͼͽͻ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͬ͹Όͪ
ͺ͹
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;



͎͹ͽͰͶ
t͈ͪͻͳͲi
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽ
ΒͰ
͹͵͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ


ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͬͪͱͳ͹
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ
ͫ͹Γͳ
ͫͰ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳ
΀͹ͽͰͶ
́ͷͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͺͪͻ͸͹
ͭͻͰΒͪΔͰ
ͰͶͰͭͪ͸ͽ͸͹
͸ͪͷͰ
΃ͽͰ͸Ͱ
ͼ͹ͫͰ
ͳ
ͻͰͼͽ͹ͻͪ͸
ͼͪ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳΒͪͶͳͽͰͽͳͷͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵Ͱ
͵;΀ͳΔͰ
͈͹ͻ;
΃Ͱ͸
ΒͰ
͸Ͱͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸͹
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
̽ͻ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͬͳͯͳ
%
ƄVSJǀ;BNPMP
m
 ̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
;
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ

ͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ

ͬͰ͵ͪ 

͆ͪ
ͼͽͪͻͳΒ͹Β
Ͷͳͼͽͳ
΀͹ͽͰͶͪ
;
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
ͶͪͲͳͷ͹
͎͹ͽͰͶ
t͆ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶi
͸ͪ
;ͭͶ;
ͼͪͯͪ΃ΔͰ
͈ͪͻͳͼ͵Ͱ
;Ͷ
ͳ
̺ͰͶͳ͵ͳ΀

ͼͽͰͺͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͳͷͪ͹

ͼ͹ͫ;
ͺ͹
΁Ͱ͸ͳ
͹ͯ
 
ͯ͹

ͯͳ͸ͪͻͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ

΀͹ͽͰͶ
t͈ͻͰͼͽ͹Ͷ͹͸ͪͼͶͰͯ͸ͳ͵i
ͺ͹ͻ;΃Ͱ͸
ͺͻͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͇ͫͪ
ͼ;
ͽͪ
ͯͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂Ͱ͸ͪ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ

;ͷͰͻͰ͸ͳ΀
΁Ͱ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹ͭ
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͪΒͪ
ͪͶͳ

ͼͰ
;
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͳΒͳͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔ;
ͅͰΌ;
ͫ͹ΓͰ

΀͹ͽͰͶͰ
ͼͺͪͯͪͶͳ
ͼ;
t͊ͻͺͼ͵ͪ
͵ͻ;͸ͪi
;
̓͸ͰͲ
ͅͳ΀ͪͳͶ͹ͬ͹Β
;Ͷͳ΁ͳ
ͼͪͯͪ

̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͽͰ͵ͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ

ͼͪ

ͼ͹ͫͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͳͲ͸ͪΒͷΓͳͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹

΁Ͱ͸ͪͷͪ
͹ͯ

ͯ͹

ͯͳ͸ͪͻͪ
ͳ
t́ͷͺͰͻͳΒͪͶi
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ
;
̺ͪͼͳ͸͹Β
;Ͷͳ΁ͳ
ͯ͹

̓ͪͺͰͽͪ͸
ͅͳ΃ͳ͸͹ͭ
ͲͯͪΔͪ
͇ͬͪΒ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ
ͫͰ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳ
΀͹ͽͰͶ
ͳͷͪ͹
ΒͰ


ͼ͹ͫͪ
Ͳͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͺͶͪΕͪͶͪ
;ͷͰͻͰ͸ͪ
ͼ;ͷͪ
͹ͯ
 
ͯ͹

ͯͳ͸ͪͻͪ
͌
ͳͼͽ;

͵ͪͽͰͭ͹ͻͳΒ;
ͼͺͪͯͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ
΀͹ͽͰͶ
t͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳ
͵ͻͪΓi
͸ͪ
;ͭͶ;
͌Ͳ;͸

ͅͳͻ͵͹ͬͰ
ͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃ΔͰ
͈ͪͻͳͼ͵Ͱ
;Ͷͳ΁Ͱ
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸
͹ͽͷͰ͸͹Β
ͺ;ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
͌

̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͳ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͳ
͸͹ͬ͹ͺ͹ͯͳͭ
͸;ͽͳ
΀͹ͽͰͶ
t̹ͻͳͼͽ͹Ͷi
;
̓ͪͻͪΌ͹ͻΌͰͬ͹Β
;Ͷͳ΁ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͻͪͼͺ͹Ͷͪͭͪ͹
ͼͪ


ͼ͹ͫͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
Ͳͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;
͹ͯ
΀͹ͽͰͶͪ
tͅ͹ͼ͵ͬͰi
ͳͷͪͶͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͽ͸͹
;ͷͰͻͰ
͸ͳΒͰ
΁Ͱ͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͼͰ΂͸͹
m
ͯͳ͸ͪͻͪ
Ͳͪ
͸͹Ε


̀ͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;Ͳ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;͵;
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͪΒͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵ͪ
͹
΁Ͱ
͸ͪͷͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͹ͫͪͬͰ΃ͽͪͬͪΒ;
ͳ
͹
ͬͻͼͽͪͷͪ
ͺͳͬͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
;
ͺ͹
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳͷ
΀͹ͽͰͶͳͷͪ
ͼͶ;ͱͰ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͯͪ
;
t̻ͻͪ͸ͯi

΀͹ͽͰͶ;
ͼͶ;ͱͰ
ͽ͹΂Ͱ͸͹
ͺͶͲͰ͸ͼ͵͹
ͺͳͬ͹
ͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;
ͼ;ͼͰͯ͸͹ͷ
t́ͷͺͰͻͳ
ΒͪͶim;
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͯ͹ͫͳͽͳ
͹ͬ͹
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹
ͺͳͬ͹
;
ͿͶͪ΃ͪͷͪ
́͸ͪ΂Ͱ
;
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ
͸͹Β
ͻ;ͫͻͳ΁ͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͰ
ͯ͹ͫͻͰ
ͺͳͬ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
#JFSIBMMFO

ͳ
ͽ͹
t̓ͪͼͳ͸ͪi
ͯ͹

΀͹ͽͰͶͪ
t͈ͪͻͳͲi
͸ͪ
͋ͰͻͪͲͳΒͪͷͪ
ͼͪ
ͽͻͳ
ͬͻͼͽͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ΀
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ΀

ͺͳͬͪ
t͉;ͼ͵ͳ
΁ͪͻi
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ
ͺ͹
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹ͷ
ͺͶͲͰ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͳ
ͷͳ͸΀Ͱ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺͳ
ͬ;
ͳ
͸ͪͻͪͬ͸͹
΂;ͬͰ͸ͳ
t̓͹Ͷͪͻͪ΁i
͵͹ͯ
͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͳ΃ͽͪ
͵͹Βͳ



͎͹ͽͰͶ
t͆ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶi
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽ
ΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͬͪͱͳ͹
ΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
΀͹ͽͰͶ
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͭ

ͻͰͯͪ
͊ͬ͹Β͹Β
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸͹Β
͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳ
ͼͶ;ͱͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͯ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͊ͪ΂;ͬͪ͸
ΒͰ
ͯ͹
͸ͪ΃ͳ΀
ͯͪ
͸ͪ
ͬͳͯͳ
%
ƄVSJǀ;BNPMP
m


͎͹ͽͰͶ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ͹
;
͐ͳ͵ͪ
͡;ͫͳ͸͹Β
;Ͷͳ΁ͳ

ͪͶͳ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͭͻͰ΃͸͹
͹Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪͬͪ͸

ͳ
͸ͪ
ͪͯͻͰͼͳ
̓͸ͰͲ
ͅͳ΀ͪͳͶ͹ͬͪ

ͬͳͯͳ
%
ƄVSJǀ;BNPMP
m


͎͹ͽͰͶ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͼͬ͹Β͹Β
ͺͻͬ͹ͫͳͽ͸͹Β
͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳ
ͼͶ;ͱͳ͹
ΒͰ

ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͬͳͯͳ
%
ƄVSJǀ;BNPMP
m


͎͹ͽͰͶ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽ
͹͵͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͪ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸͹
ΒͰ
͹ͫ͸͹ͬΓͰ͸

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

̀ͭͻͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͻ;΃Ͱ͸ͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͬͳͯͳ
%
ƄVSJǀ;BNPMP
m



͎͹ͽͰͶ
t͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳ
͵ͻͪΓi
ͳͲͭͻͪΌͰ͸
ΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͪͶͳ
ΒͰ
;
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͸ͪͬͻͪͽͪ

͹ͫ͸ͪͬΓͪ͸
ͳ
ͯ͹ͭͻͪΌͳͬͪ͸
͈͹ͻ;΃Ͱ͸
ΒͰ
;
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͷ
ͫ͹ͷͫͪͻͯ͹ͬͪΔ;
ͪͺͻͳͶͪ

ͭ͹
ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͬͳͯͳ
%
ƄVSJǀ
;BNPMP
m


̀ͭͻͪͯͪ
t̓͹Ͷͪͻ΁ͪi
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
Ͳͪͯ;ͱͫͳ͸Ͱ
́ͶͳΒͰ
ͅͳͶ͹ͼͪͬΓͰͬͳΕͪ
̓͹Ͷͪͻ΁ͪ

͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃ΔͰͭ
ͺͪͻ͵ͪ
͸ͪ
;ͭͶ;
͍ͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵Ͱ
;Ͷ
ͳ
͋ͻͭͪ
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ
͵Ͱ
̹ͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽͪ

ͪ
ͺ͹ͻ;΃Ͱ͸ͪ
ΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͬͳͯͳ
%
ƄVSJǀ;BNPMP

m
 ͪͅͻ͵͹
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ

ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͭ
ͻͰ͵Ͷͪͷͳͻͪ
ͳ
͵ͪ͹
t5IFBUFS$BGFi
ͼͪ
ͷ;Ͳͳ͵͹ͷ
͌
̹Ͱ
ͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͳ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͼͰ
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͯͪ
͹ͬͪΒ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶ
ͳͷͪ
ͳ

ͶͰͽΔ;
ͫͪ΃ͽ;
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͽ;
ͼͶ;ͱͰ
ͯ͹ͫͻͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͪ
ͬͳ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
͹͸ͪ
ͳͲ

͸Ͱͭ͹ͽͳ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
͵ͻͪΒͪ
̓ͪ͹
ͷͰͼͽͪ
Ͳͪ
ͻͪͲ͹͸͹ͯ;
ͼͪ
ͷ;Ͳͳ͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ
͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͷͳΔ;
ͼͰ
ͳ
͵ͪͿͪ͸Ͱ
΀͹ͽͰͶͪ
t̹;ͶͰͬͪͻi
ͳ
t͊ͶͪͬͳΒͪi
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
t$B
GF
/FX
:PSLi
ͼ
͹ͯͶͳ΂͸ͳͷ
ͺͳͬ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͷ;Ͳͳ͵͹ͷ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ͹

;
͹͵ͬͳͻ;
t̓͹Ͷͪͻ΁ͪi



͡;ͫͳͽͰΓͳͷͪ
ͯ͹ͫͻͰ
΀ͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͳͲ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂
͵ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
ͫͳͶ͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͻͪͼͺ͹ͶͪͭͪΔ;
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͼ͹Ͷͳͯ͸ͳ΀
͵ͪͿͪ͸ͪ
͆ͪ

ͺͻͬ͹ͷ
ͷͰͼͽ;
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͻͰͼͽ͹ͻͪ͸
t͎ͪΒͯ;͵
̺ͰΓ͵͹i
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪ
Ͳͳ͹
͸ͪ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵;
̓͸ͰͲ
ͅͳ΀ͪͳͶ͹ͬͰ
;Ͷͳ΁Ͱ
͇ͬͯͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ
͸͹
ͳͼͽͪ͵͸;ͽ͹
ͼͶ;ͱͳͶͪ
ΒͰͶͪ
ͪ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
͵;΀ͳΔͰ
ͪ
ͽ;
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͪ͹
ͳ

͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ
͵Ͷ;ͫ
ͯ͹͵
ͼ;
ͼͰ
;
ͻͰͼͽ͹ͻͪ͸;
΀͹ͽͰͶͪ
t͊ͻͺͼ͵ͪ
͵ͻ;͸ͪi
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ

ͯ͹ͫͳͽͳ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͭ
ͳ
ͷͪΌͪͻͼ͵ͳ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳΒͪͶͳͽͰͽͳ
ͪ
ͯ͹ͫͪͻ
ͻͰͼͽ͹ͻͪ͸

ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ
ͳ
;
t͉;ͼ͵͹ͷ
΁ͪͻ;i
͌
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
ͳͲ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;Β;
ͼͰ
;
ͻͰͼͽ͹ͻͪ͸;
t̓͹Ͷͪͻͪ΁i
ͼͺͰ΁ͳΒͪͶͳͽͰͽͳ
ͼͻͺ
ͼ͵Ͱ
͵;΀ͳΔͰ
ΕͰͬͪͺ΂ͳΕͳ
ͻͪͱΔͳΕͳ
Ε;ͶͫͪͼͽͳΒͪ
ͼͪͻͷͪ
Ό;ͬͰ΂
ͻͪͲ͸Ͱ

ͺͳͽͰ
ͳ
ͼͶ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͪ
ͬͳ͸ͪ
̀ͪ
ͽͪ
ͼͽͻͪ͸΁ͳͷͪ
ͺ͹
ͳͷͰ͸;
͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͪ

ΒͰͶͪ
ͯͪͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͯ͹ͯͪͽ͸͹
͹ͫͪͬͰ΃ͽͰΔͰ
͹ͯ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͬͻͼͽͰ
͸ͪͷͳͻ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͼ;
ΒͰͶͪ

ͼͺͻͪͬΓͪ͸ͪ

͌
ͼͬͳͷ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ

͸ͪ
ͳͼͽͪ͵
͸;ͽ͹ͷ
ͷͰͼͽ;
ͼ;
ͳ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ

ͺ;΃ͪ΂Ͱ
͆ͪ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵;
ΒͰ

ͳͼͽͪ͵͸;ͽ͹
;ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͰΔͰ
ͯͪ
;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳ
ͯ;ͬͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͷ͹͸͹
ͺ͹Ͷ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͪ
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵ͪ
Ϳͪͫͻͳ͵ͪ
ͺͻͰͻͪΌͳͬͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͷͪΕͳ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵ͳ

ͯ;ͬͪ͸
͏Ͱ͸ͪ
͵;ͽͳΒͰ

͵͹ͷ

ͫ͹Γͳ΀
΁ͳͭͪͻͰͽͪ
͵ͻͰͽͪͶͪ
ͼͰ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;

ͳ

 
ͯͳ͸
͏ͳͭͪͻͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͺͻ͹ͯͪͬͪ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ

ͺͪͻͪ
ͺ͹
͵͹ͷͪͯ;
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ

ͼ;
ͫͳͶͰ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯΔͰ
ͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
;
ͫ͹Γͳͷ
΀͹ͽͰͶͳͷͪ
t̻ͻͪ͸ͯi

ͳ
t͈ͪͻͳͲi
ͷ͹ͭͶͰ

͸ͪͫͪͬͳͽͳ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͰ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͷͪͻ͵Ͱ
t#SJUBOJDBi
ͳͶͳ

t$SFNF
EF
$VCBi

̀ͪ
ͼͽͻͪ͸΁Ͱ
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͳͼ;
ͫͳͶͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
΀Ͱͯ͹͸ͳͼͽͳ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂Ͱ͸Ͱ
ͼ;

͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
͹ͯ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳΒͳ΀
͵Δͳͱͪͻͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͳ
ͽ͹
͹͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ

͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ͳͷͪͽͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ
͋͹
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͰ
ͻͪͯΔͰ
͊ͬͰͽͳͼͶͪ
ͬͪ
͏ͬͳΒͪ͸͹ͬͳΕͪ
ͳ
̻Ͱ΁Ͱ
̓͹͸ͪ
͹ͫͰ
;
̓͸ͰͲ
ͅͳ΀ͪͳͶ͹ͬ͹Β
;Ͷͳ΁ͳ
͹ͼ͸͹



͎͹ͽͰͶ
t̹;ͶͰͬͪͻi
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
;ͭͶ;
;Ͷͳ΁ͪ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
̹ͻͪΕͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͬͳΕͪ

ͪ
;
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬ;
ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͯͬ͹ͻͪ͸ͪ
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃ΔͰͭ
ͫͳ͹ͼ͵͹ͺͪ
t̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸i
ͬͳͯͳ
%
ƄV
SJǀ;BNPMP
m


%
ƄVSJǀ;BNPMP
OE
m
 ̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
;
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ

ͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ

ͬͰ͵ͪ 

ͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͳͼͽͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
;
ͺ͹ͽ͹Δͳͷ
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͫͳͶͰ
΁ͰΔͰ͸Ͱ

ͳ
͵ͪ͹
;ͼͺͰ΃͸Ͱ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂͵Ͱ
͵;ΕͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͪ
t̽ͬ͹ͻͼ͵ͪ
͵Δͳͱͪͻͪ

ͅͳͽͰ
͊ͽͪΒͳΕͪi

͌
͹͵ͬͳͻ;
ͫͶ͹͵ͪ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
ΒͰ

;
ͼͬͳͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
ͳͷͪ͹
͹Ͳ͸ͪ΂Ͱ͸Ͱ
ͪͯͻͰͼͰ
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͼ͵͹͵͹͸
Ͳ;Ͷͪͻ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͪͬͪ
m
͆Ͱͷͪ΂͵Ͱ
΂ͳΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͼͶͪ͸ͼͽͬ͹
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
Ͷ͹
;
̓ͻ;͸ͼ͵͹Β
;Ͷ

;ͭͪ͹
ͼͪ
͌Ͷͳ΁͹ͷ
͵ͻͪΓͪ
ͅͳͶ;ͽͳ͸ͪ

͵͹͸Ͳ;Ͷͪͽ
͸ͪ

̓ͻͪΓͰͬ͹ͷ
ͽͻͭ;

ͳ
̸;ͼͽͻ͹;ͭͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͪ
ͺ͹ͼͶͪ͸ͼͽͬ͹ͷ
;
͊ͽ;ͯͰ͸ͳ΂͵͹Β



͇
ͫͰ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳͷ
͵Δͳͱͪͻͪͷͪ
ͬ
͡
̽;ͻ͵͹ͬͳΕͪ͠͵΃ͳΕ
̓ΔͳͱͪͻͰ
;
FE
̺

͐;ͫͻͳͶ͹ͬͳΕ

́ͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ


 ͪͅͻ͵͹
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ


ͼͪͯͪ
͌Ͷͳ΁ͪ
͊ͬ
ͪͅͻ͵͹ͬͳΕͪ

ͳ
͵͹͸Ͳ;Ͷͪͽ͹ͷ
;
ͼͪͯͪ΃Δ͹Β
͈ͪͻͳͼ͵͹Β

;Ͷͳ΁ͳ
ͯ͹
ͲͭͻͪͯͰ
̈́ͳ͵͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͪ͵ͪͯͷͳΒͰ
͋;
ͼ;
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͫͰ͹ͭͻͪͯ
ͼ͵ͳ
΀ͻͪͷ͹ͬͳ
Ͳͪ
ͬͰͻ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͼͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
͆ͪ
ͺͻͬ͹ͷ

ͷͰͼͽ;
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
͆Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͪ
Ͱͬͪ͸ͭͰͶͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
΁ͻ͵ͬͪ
ͼͪ
΃͵͹
Ͷ͹ͷ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
;
͌Ͷͳ΁ͳ
̺;͵ͪ
̓ͪͻͪΘͳΕͪ
ͪ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͳ
͵ͪ
ͽ͹Ͷͳ΂͵ͪ
͵ͪͺͰͶͪ
;Ͳ
ͪ;ͼͽͻ͹;ͭͪͻͼ͵͹
ͺ͹ͼͶͪ͸ͼͽͬ͹
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯͳͶͪ
ͯͪ
͸ͪ΃Δ͹Β
΁ͻ͵ͬͳ
t̓ͻͳͼͽͪ
̓ͻͪΓͪi
;
̓ͻ;͸ͼ͵͹Β
;Ͷͳ΁ͳ

́͸ͯͳ͵ͪͽͳͬͪ͸
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵
ͳ
΃ͽͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
;
ͺͻͬ͹Β
ͯͰ
΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͳ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
ͯͪ
͵;ͺͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͼ;ͬͰ͸ͳͻ
͌
ͼͬͳͷ
ͪ͸ͪ
ͶͳͲͳͻͪ͸ͳͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
ͽͪ
ͬͻͼͽͪ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
ͼͬ͹ͯͳ

ͼͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
͸ͪ
tͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ΕͳͶͳͷͰi
ͺ͹
ͼͬͰͷ;
ͼ;ͯͰΕͳ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͰ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯͰ

ͺͳͻ͹ͽͼ͵ͳ΀
ͻͪͯͳ͹͸ͳ΁ͪ
͇͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
͸ͪͫͪͬͳͽͳ
;
ͺͻ͹ͯͪͬ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ

ͯ;ͱ
̓͸ͰͲ
ͅͳ΀ͪͳͶ͹ͬͰ
;Ͷͳ΁Ͱ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͺͳΒͪ΁ͳ
ͭͯͰ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͰ
ͳͲͶ͹ͱͰ͸Ͱ

ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͻ;͵͹ͽͬ͹ͻͳ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬͰ
ͼͽͻͪ͸΁ͳͷͪ
́ͲͭͶͰͯͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ

ͳ
͹͸ͯͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͼͪͯͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͪ
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁ͪ
;
ͽ͹ͷ
ͼͷͳͼͶ;
͸;ͯͳͶͪ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ

ͼ͵ͻ͹ͷͪ͸
ͳͲͫ͹ͻ

͈;ͽ͸ͳ͵
͵͹Βͳ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͼͷͰͼͽͳ͹
;
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂Ͱ͸ͳ΀
΀͹ͽͰͶͪ

ͳ
͹ͯͶ;΂ͳ͹
ͯͪ
;
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁ͳ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͬͰͯͰ
͵͹Βͳ
ͯͪ͸
ͷ͹
ͭͪ͹
ΒͰ
;͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͭͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪͶ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;͵ͻͪͽ͵͹
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪ
ͼ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳ
Β͹ͷ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͳ
ͼͪͲ͸ͪ
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
͹
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΂͵͹ͷ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌ;
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳ
Βͳͷ
Βͪͬ͸ͳͷ
ͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ


̀ͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹
ΒͰ
ͬͳͯͰͽͳ
͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
͸ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;
͵͹Βͳ΀
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͪ

ͺͻͰ
ͲͰ͸ͽ͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
ͯ;ͭͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
͌
ͼͬͪ
΂Ͱͽͳͻͳ
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬͪ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ

ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
ͼ;
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͳͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͽ͹
ͼͪ
ͭͻͰ΃͵ͪͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
͹ͯ͸͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹
ͻͪͲͯ͹ͫΓͰ
͈ͻͳ΂ͪ
Ͳͪͺ͹΂ͳΔͰ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͯͪ

ͼͰ
͸ͪ
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͷͰͼͽ;
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ͹
ͻͳͷͼ͵ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
͊ͳ͸ͭͳͯ;͸;ͷ
ͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ

ͽ;
ͫͳͶͪ
ͼͽͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͳͻͪ͸ͪ
*7
ͶͰͭͳΒͪ
'MBWJB

̽ͪΓͰ
ͼͰ
͵ͪͱͰ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͽͳͷ

ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂ΒͰͷ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
ͬͶͪͯͪͶͳ
̺ͳͲͪ͸ͽͳ͸΁ͳ
ͳ
ͪͅΌͪͻͳ
ͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͺͻ
ͬͳ
ͺ;ͽ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
ͯ͹΃ͪ͹
ͺ͹ͯ
ͼͻͺͼ͵;
ͬͶͪͼͽ

;
ͯ͹ͫͪ
΁ͪͻͪ
͊ͽͰ
Ϳͪ͸ͪ
̽;΃ͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͺ͹͸͹ͬ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̀ͪͽͳͷ
ͼͶͰͯͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵

ͯͪ
ͭͪ
ΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͯͪ͹
ͪͅΌͪͻͳͷͪ
ͯͰͼͺ͹ͽ
͚;ͻΌͰ
̹ͻͪ͸͵͹ͬͳΕ

͆ͳΒͰ
ͼͺ͹ͻ͸͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ͹
ͺ͹ͯ
ͬͶͪ΃Ε;
͵ͻͪΓͪ

͊ͽͰͿͪ͸ͪ
̽;΃ͪ͸ͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͼͰ
͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸ͳ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͬͶͪ
ͯͪͬͳ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ

ͯ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ
ͯͪΓ;
ͼ;ͯͫͳ͸;
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͫͳ͹

͹ͯ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹ͭ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ
͊
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯ
ͼͻͺͼ͵;
ͬͶͪͼͽ

ͺ͹͸͹ͬ͹
ͯ͹΃ͪ͹
ͽͰ͵

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͪ
͸Ͱ
ͯͬͰ
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͰ
ͻͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͪͽ

ͪͅΌͪͻͳͷͪ

ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
ͼͷͻͽͳ
ͯͰͼͺ͹ͽͪ
͊ͽͰͿͪ͸ͪ
̈́ͪͲͪͻͰͬͳΕͪ
͌
ͽͻͪ
ͭͪΔ;
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͻͰ͵Ͷ͹ͷ
͹ͬͳ΀
ͭͻͰ΃ͪ͵ͪ
ͷ͹ͭͶ͹
ͼͰ
;͹΂ͳͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
͹͸Ͱ
͸ͪͼͽͪͶͰ

͸Ͱͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͰ;ͲͳͷͪΔͰͷ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͳͲ
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬ͹ͭ
̈́Ͱ͵ͼͳ͵͹͸ͪ
ͭͯͰ

 ̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
;
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ

ͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ

ͬͰ͵ͪ 

ΒͰ
ͼͽͪͻͳΒͪ
ͺ͹ͬͰͼͽ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͹ͫͻͪΌͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;
ͽͪͯͪ
ͬͰΕ

ͲͪͼͽͪͻͰͶͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͰ
͌
͸ͪͼͽͪͬ͵;
͵͹͸΁ͳͲ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳ΂Ͱ
͹

ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
ͼ;
Ͳ͸ͪͽ͸͹
ͺ͹;Ͳͯͪ͸ͳΒͳ
͆Ͱ΃ͽ͹
͹ͺ΃ͳͻ͸ͳΒͰ
ͼ;

͹ͫͻͪΌͰ͸ͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͻͪͲͯ͹ͫΓͪ
͵ͪͯͪ
ͼͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
ͺ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ͹
ͺ͹ͯ

ͪ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͷ
ͬͶͪ΃Ε;
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
Ͷ͹ͭͳ΂͸͹
ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͳͷͪ
;
ͬͳͯ;
͵͹Β͹Β
ΒͰ

΂ͳͽͪͶͪ΂͵͹Β
ͺ;ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
ͽ͹
ͫͳͶ͹
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸͹
͌
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬͳͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ

ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
͵ͻͪͽ͵͹
ͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
;ͽͰͷͰΓͰ
͸ͳΒͳ
ͫ;ͯ;Εͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͵͹ͻͳ΃ΕͰ͸ͪ
͸͹ͬͳΒͪ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͪ
m
͹ͯ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ
͸ͪ
ͽͪͯͪ
͸ͪΒ͸͹ͬͳΒͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
͍ͰͶͳ͵ͼͪ
̓ͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
%BT
,ÕOJHSFJDI
4FSCJFO
VOE

EBT
4FSCFOWPML

ͳ


ͳ
̓͹͸ͼͽͪ͸ͽͳ͸ͪ
͠ͳͻͰ΂Ͱ͵ͪ
(FTDIJDIUF
EFS

4FSCFO



͇ͺͳͼͳ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΂͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰ
Όͪ
͵͹ͻͰ͵ͽ͸͹
ͼ;
ͺͻ͹ͫͻͪ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͽͪ΂͸͹
ͳͲͶ͹ͱͰ͸ͳ
͸ͪ
͸ͳͬ͹;
Ͳ͸ͪΔͪ
͹͸͹ͭͪ

ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
͌͹΂Γͳͬ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬͳ΀
ͽͪ͵͹
ͳ

̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬͳ΀
;ͻͰͯ͸͹
͸͹ͬͰͶͳͻͪΒ;
ͳ
ͯ͹ͺ;Δ;Β;
ͼͽͪͽͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻ
ͷͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
͹
͸͹ͬͳͷ
ͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͺͻͰͯͶ͹ͱͰ͸ͪ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͷͪͻ΃ͻ;ͽͪ
ΒͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͪ
͈;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͼͪ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬͳͷ
ͬ͹
ͯͳ΂Ͱͷ
ͻͪͲͭͶͰͯͪΔͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͼ;
Ͳͪͺ͹΂ͳΔͪͶͳ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
ͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ

;͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͰ͸͹
ͺ͹ͶͪͲͰΕͳ
͹ͯ
̓ͪͶͰͷͰͭͯͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
͋ͬͻΌͪͬͰ
ͯ͹͵
ΒͰ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͷͪ
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬͳ΀
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
ͺͻͰͯͶ͹ͱͰ͸ͪ
΃ͰͽΔͪ
;
ͼ;ͺͻ͹ͽ͸͹ͷ
ͺͻͪͬ΁;
m
͹ͯ

ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͵ͪ
̓ͪͶͰͷͰͭͯͪ͸;


͇ͯͶ;΂ͳͶͳ
ͼͷ͹
ͼͰ
ͯͪ
͵ͻͰ͸Ͱͷ͹
ͽͻͪͭ͹ͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͼͪ

ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬͳͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔͰͷ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͳͲͪ΃Ͷ͹
ͼͪͷ͹
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͷͰͼͰ΁ͳ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͳͲ
ͫͳΒͪΔͰ
͸ͰͼͻͰΕ͸͹ͭ
͈ͻͬ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
́ͯ;Εͳ
͹ͯ
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͼͽͪ
͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͸ͪͳͶͪͲͳͶ͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͲͭͻͪͯͰ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳ΀
͸ͪͯͶͰ΃ͽͪͬͪ
m
ͷͳ͸ͳͼͽͪͻͼͽͪ
ͬͪ
ͬ͹Βͼ͵Ͱ 
Ϳͳ͸ͪ͸ͼͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͭͻͪΌͰͬͳ͸ͪ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸͹ͭ
ͼͪͬͰͽͪ
ͳ

ͬ͹Β͸Ͱ
ͪ͵ͪͯͰͷͳΒͰ
͈͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͼͽͪͻͪ
͸Ͱ;ͭͶͰͯ͸ͪ
Ͳͭͻͪͯͪ
͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ



.FZFST
,POWFSTBUJPOT-FYJLPO
;XFJUFS
#BOE
-FJQ[JH
VOE
8JFO

m



̀ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͅͳ͸ͳͼͽͪͻͼͽͬͪ
ͬ͹Β͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ

;ͭͶ;
;Ͷͳ΁ͪ
͆ͰͷͪΔͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
̓͸ͰͲͪ
ͅͳͶ͹΃ͪ
͈͹ͻ;΃Ͱ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
;
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͷ
ͫ͹ͷͫͪͻͯ͹ͬͪΔ;

ͪͺͻͳͶͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ


ͅͳ͸ͳͼͽͪͻͼͽͬ͹
Ϳͳ͸ͪ͸ͼͳΒͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶ͹
ͼͰ
;
ͲͯͪΔ;
ͭͻͪΌͰ͸͹ͷ
Ͳͪ
ͯͬ͹ͻ
͵͸ͰͲͪ

ͅͳͶ͹΃ͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͈͹ͻ;΃Ͱ͸͹
;
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͷ
ͫ͹ͷͫͪͻͯ͹ͬͪΔ;

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ



̀ͭͻͪͯͪ
͸ͪ
;ͭͶ;
;Ͷͳ΁ͪ
̓͸ͰͲͪ
ͅͳͶ͹΃ͪ
ͳ
ͪͅͼͪͻͳ͵͹ͬͰ


̀ͭͻͪͯͪ
͸ͪ
;ͭͶ;
;Ͷͳ΁ͪ
̓͸ͰͲͪ
ͅͳͶ͹΃ͪ
ͳ
̻Ͱͺͻͪͽ͹ͬͰ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽͪ
͹͵͹


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͪ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͺ;ͽͪ
ͯ͹ͭͻͪΌͳͬͪ͸ͪ


̀ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͼͽͪͻͰ
̺͹Β͸Ͱ
ͪ͵ͪͯͰͷͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽͪ
͹͵͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
ͼͰ

͸ͪ
;ͭͶ;
;Ͷͳ΁ͪ
͆ͰͷͪΔͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
̓͸ͰͲͪ
ͅͳͶ͹΃ͪ
͈͹ͻ;΃Ͱ͸ͪ
;
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͷ
ͫ͹ͷͫͪͻͯ͹ͬͪΔ;


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
 ͪͅͻ͵͹
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ

ͼ͵;ͺ΃ͽͳ͸Ͱ
;Ͳ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;
ͽ͹͵;
ͭͻͪΌͰΔͰ
͸͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͼ͵;ͺ΃ͽͳ͸
ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͲͯͪΔͪ
tͺͻͰ͵͹
ͺ;ͽͪ
ͯͬ͹ͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͫͪ΃ͽͰi
̽ͪΓͰ
͸ͳͲ
̓͸ͰͲ
ͅͳͶ͹΃Ͱͬ;

;Ͷͳ΁;
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵;
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͼ͵ͻͰ͸;ͽͪ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
͸ͪ
̾ͽ͸͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ͷ;ͲͰΒ
ͼͪ

ͳͲͶ͹ͱͫ͹ͷ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
ͻ;͵͹ͽͬ͹ͻͳ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
Ͱ͵ͼͺ͹Ͳͳ΁ͳΒ;
ͅ;ͲͰΒͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ

ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͼͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ΁ͳͷͪ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͿͶ͹ͻͰ
ͳ
Ϳͪ;͸Ͱ
͈͹ͽͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͶ͸ͳͷ
ͺ͹
ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͭͶͪ΃Ͱ͸͹
ͯͪ
ͷ;ͲͰΒͼ͵ͳ
ͼͶ;ͱͫͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͰ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ

̺ͻͪΕͪΒ;Εͳ
ͼͰ
;Ͳ
͌Ͷͳ΁;
͵͸ͰͲͪ
ͅͳͶ͹΃ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͶͪ΁
ΒͰ
ͼͽͳͲͪ͹
ͯ͹
ͭͶͪͬ͸Ͱ

ͪͻͽͰͻͳΒͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
m
͌Ͷͳ΁Ͱ
͵ͻͪΓͪ
ͅͳͶͪ͸ͪ
͋;
ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ͯͪ

ͬͳͯͳ
͵͹ͷͺͶͰ͵ͼ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯͬ͹ͻͪ
m
ͽͪ͵͹Ͳͬͪ͸ͳ
͊ͽͪͻͳ
ͯͬ͹ͻ
ͭͻͪΌͰ͸

m
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͆͹ͬͳ
ͯͬ͹ͻ 
΂ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͲͭͻͪͯΔͪ
Ͳͪͺ͹΂Ͱͽͪ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
ͷͰͼͽ;
ͼͽͪͻͰ
ͲͭͻͪͯͰ
ͅͳ͸ͳͼͽͪͻͼͽͬͪ
ͳ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΀
ͯͰͶͪ
̀ͪ
͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪͶͪ
ͳ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ

ͯͬ͹ͻͼ͵͹
ͲͯͪΔͰ
ͳ
ͻͪͲͭͶͰͯͪ
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͪ
ͯͬ͹ͻͪ͸ͪ
ͼͪ
͹͵͹Ͷ͸ͳͷ
ͼͪͶ͹͸ͳͷͪ

͈ͻͰͷͪ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
ͳͲ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
͹ͯ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ 

ͽͪ͵ͬͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͪ
ͼͰ

ͷ͹ͭͶͪ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪͽͳ
;Ͳ
ͼͪͭͶͪͼ͸͹ͼͽ
ͷͪͻ΃ͪͶͪ
̽ͬ͹ͻͪ
̓ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͻͰ΂
͹

͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵͹Β
ͻͰͲͳͯͰ͸΁ͳΒͳ
;
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͪ͸ͳͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
Ͳͪ
ͫͰͶͰͱͰ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͽ;
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
ͳ
Ͳͭͻͪͯͪ
ͽͪͯͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͺ͹ͻ;΃Ͱ͸͹ͭ
ͼͽͪͻ͹ͭ

t̓͹͸ͪ͵ͪi 
ͭͯͰ
ͼ;

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͹Ϳͳ΁ͳͻͳ
;ͫͳͶͳ
͵ͻͪΓͪ
̸ͶͰ͵ͼͪ͸ͯͻͪ
ͳ

͵ͻͪΓͳ΁;
̽ͻͪͭ;
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͼͪ΀ͻͪΔͰ͸ͳ
;
ͷͪͶ͹Β
΁ͻ͵ͬͳ
͊ͬ
ͪͅͻ͵ͪ

͸ͪ
ͼͽͪͻ͹ͷ
͋ͪ΃ͷͪΒͯͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͭͻ͹ͫΓ;
͌
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
͹ͯ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
;͹΂Ͱ͸͹
ΒͰ

΂ͪ͵
ͯͪ
ͭͻ͹ͫ͸͹
ͷͰͼͽ͹
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͪͻͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
͹ͫͰͶͰͱͰ͸͹
͸ͳ
͸ͪͯͭͻ͹ͫ
͸ͳͷ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵͹ͷ
́͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͪ
͹ͬͪΒ
͵ͻͬͪͬͳ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒ
ͯ;ͭ͹
ΒͰ
ͫͳ
Ͷ͹
ͱͳͬ͹
;
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹Β
Βͪͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
͸ͪ΃Ͷ͹
ͼͬ͹Β
͹ͯͻͪͲ
ͳ
;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹
Όͪͷͪ
͹
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͻͰ΂



͊ͽͪͻͪ
Ͳͭͻͪͯͪ
͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͼ͵;ͺ΃ͽͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
;ͭͶ;
;Ͷͳ΁ͪ
̓͸ͰͲͪ
ͅͳ
Ͷ͹΃ͪ
ͳ
̓ͻͪΓͳ΁Ͱ
͆ͪͽͪͶͳΒͰ


ͅ;ͲͰΒ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ͹
͸ͪ
;ͭͶ;
̹ͳͻ΂ͪ͸ͳ͸͹ͬͰ
;Ͷͳ΁Ͱ
;
Ͳͭͻͪͯͳ
̀ͪͯ;ͱͫͳ͸Ͱ
͊ͽͰͬ΂Ͱ

ͅͳ΀ͪΒͶ͹ͬͳΕͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͻ;΃Ͱ͸ͪ
;
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪͷͪ
ͺͻͰͯ
̽ͻ;ͭͳ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͳ
ͻͪͽ


͊ͪͯͪ
͊͵;ͺ΃ͽͳ͸ͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ


͊ͪͯͪ
͈ͻͰͯͼͰͯ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ͹
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ


̹
̈́ͪͲͪͻͰͬͳΕ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ


̀ͭͻͪͯͪ
̓͹͸ͪ͵ͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͊ͽͪͻ͹ͭ
ͳ
͆͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͯͬ͹ͻͪ
ͭͻͪΌͰ͸ͪ

͹͵͹

͹ͽ͵;ͺΓͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
Ͳͪ
ͯͬ͹ͻ
͵͸ͰͲͪ
̸ͶͰ͵ͼͪ͸ͯͻͪ
̓ͪͻͪ
Ό͹ͻΌͰͬͳΕͪ
͈͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͽ;
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
ͻͰͲͳͯͰ͸΁ͳΒͪ
͇ͫͻͰ͸͹ͬͳΕͪ
m
͵͸ͰͲͪ
ͅͳ΀ͪͳͶͪ
ͳ

͵ͻͪΓͰͬͪ
ͅͳͶͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
̸ͶͰ͵ͼͪ͸ͯͻͪ
͈͹ͼͶͰ
ͪͽͰ͸ͽͪͽͪ
ͺ͹
͸ͪͻͰΌͰΔ;
͵ͻͪΓͪ
͈Ͱͽͻͪ
̓͹͸ͪ͵

ΒͰ
ͼͻ;΃Ͱ͸

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ



͆ͪͯͭͻ͹ͫ͸ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺͪͻ;
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽ
ΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;
ͬͻͰͷͰ

ͪ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
͹͵;ͺͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
͊ͽͻͪͯͪ͹
ΒͰ
;
ͺ͹ͱͪͻ;
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
;͸ͳ΃ͽͳ͹
ͼͽͪͻ;
΁ͻ͵ͬ;

ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ͫ͹ͷͫͪͻͯ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͪͺͻͳͶͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͈͹ͼͷͻͽ͸ͳ
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳ
̓ͻͪ
Γͪ
ͳ
̓ͻͪΓͳ΁Ͱ
ͺͻͰ͸Ͱͽͳ
ͼ;
͵ͻͳͺͽ;
͸͹ͬͰ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ
͊ͬ
ͪͅͻ͵ͪ
 ̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
;
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ

ͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ

ͬͰ͵ͪ 

̽ͪΓͰ
;
΃ͰͽΔͳ
ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͫͰ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵͹ͷ
;Ͷͳ΁͹ͷ
͵ͪ
͋ͰͻͪͲͳΒͪͷͪ

ͳ
̓͸ͰͲ
ͅͳ΀ͪͳͶ͹ͬ͹Β
ͭͯͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͰ
ͻͰͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͬͪͽ͸Ͱ

ͲͭͻͪͯͰ
ͳ
ͽͻͭ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪͽͳͱͰΓ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
ͼ͵ͻͰΕͰ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
͸ͪ
ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ͸͹

ͭͻͪΌͰ͸ͪ
ͲͯͪΔͪ
ͅͳ͸ͳͼͽͪͻͼͽͬͪ
ͺͻͪͬͯͰ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͬͰͽͰ
͇ͬ͹
ͯͻ;ͭ͹
ΒͰ

ͼͬ͹Β͹ͷ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽ͹ͷ
Ϳͪͼͪͯ͹ͷ
ͷ͹ͯͰͶ͹ͬͪ͸͹ͷ
;
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͷ
ͼͽͳͶ;
ͫͰͲ

ͼ;ͷΔͰ
ͺͻͳͬͶͪ΂ͳͶ͹
ͺͪͱΔ;
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
́
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
΂ͳͽͪͬ͹
ͼͽ͹
ͶͰΕͰ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹ͭ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͌
ͼͽͪͻͳ
Βͳͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
͸ͪ
͋ͰͻͪͲͳΒͪͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
̓͸ͰͲ
ͅͳͶ͹
΃Ͱͬͪ
΂Ͱͼͷͪ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽͪ

͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
;
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪͷͪ
ͺͻͰͯ
͈ͻͬͳ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͳ

ͻͪͽ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͬ͹ͷ
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ΃ΔͰͷ
ͷͰͼͽ;

͌
ͯͪΓͰͷ
ͻͪͲͭͶͰͯͪΔ;
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͶͪ΁
ͼͰ
;ͺ;Ε;ΒͰ
͵ͪ
ͽͻͭ;
͸ͪ

͵͹ΒͰͷ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
͊ͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵
̓͸ͰͲ;
ͅͳ΀ͪͳͶ;
ͳ
ͲͯͪΔͰ
͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹Ͳ͹
ͻͳ΃ͽͪ
͋;
ΒͰ
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ

ͳ
;
ͺͻͬͳͷ
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͪͷͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͳ
̻Ͷͪͬ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹΃ͽͪ
;
ͼͽͪͻ͹Β
̓͹Ͷͪͻ΂Ͱͬ͹Β
Ͳͪͯ;ͱͫͳ͸ͳ
͌
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͳΒͳͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ

ͪͅΒͰͻͪ
ͳ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͼͰ
ͳ
Ͳͭͻͪͯͪ
͌ͺͻͪͬͰ
Ϳ͹͸ͯ͹ͬͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹

̽ͻͱͪͬ͸Ͱ
΀ͳͺ͹ͽͰ͵ͪͻ͸Ͱ
ͫͪ͸͵Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
͸͹ͬ͹ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽ͹
ͲͯͪΔͰ
̓ͪ͹
Ͳͪ͸ͳ
ͷΓͳͬ
ͯͰͽͪΓ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͼͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ;
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ
ͼͽͪΒͪͶͪ
͊ͽͪͷͫ͹Ͷ
͵ͪͺͳΒͪ
Ͳͪ
͵͹
Β;
ͼͰ
ͯͪΒͰ
͸Ͱͽͪ΂ͪ͸
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽͪ
͹ͯ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
Ϳ͹͸
̈́ͪ;ͯ͹͸ͪ
;

ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͪ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
͹͵;ͺͪ΁ͳΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͇ͬ͹
ͲͯͪΔͰ
͹͵͹
͵͹ΒͰͭ
ͼ;

ͬ͹ΌͰ͸Ͱ
ͫ͹ͻͫͰ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
͹ͼͶ͹ͫͪΌͪΔͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

m
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
m
ͺ͹ͻ;΃Ͱ͸͹
ΒͰ
͹ͯͷͪ΀
͸ͪ͵͹͸
͵͹͸ͪ΂͸͹ͭ

ͽ;ͻͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͬͶͪ΂ͰΔͪ
ͳͲ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵Ͱ
ͬͪͻ͹΃ͳ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ


͌
ͯͪΓ͹Β
΃ͰͽΔͳ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͷ
Ͳ͸ͪͽͳͱͰΓ͸ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
ͼͽͳͲͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͯ͹
̓ͻͪ
ΓͰͬ͹ͭ
ͽͻͭͪ
͠Ͱͯͪ͸
ͯͰ͹
ͽ͹ͭ
ͼͻͰͯͳ΃ΔͰͭ
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
ͽͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͰΕ

ͫͳ͹
ͺͪͻ͵͹ͬͼ͵ͳ
;ͻͰΌͰ͸
ͼͪ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵͹ͷ
͠͹ͼͳͿ;
͈ͪ͸΂ͳΕ; 
͸ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ

ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͼ͵ͻͰΕͰ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
ͯ͹͵
ΒͰ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
ͯͰ͹
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
Ͳͪ;ͲͳͷͪͶͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͪ



̀ͭͻͪͯͪ
͸ͪ
͋ͰͻͪͲͳΒͪͷͪ

͹΂;ͬͪ͸ͪ
;
ͳͲͬ͹ͻ͸͹ͷ
͹ͫͶͳ͵;



͊ͪͯͪ
ͲͯͪΔͰ
̺;͵͹ͬͰ
Ͳͪͯ;ͱͫͳ͸Ͱ
;
͌Ͷ
͵ͻͪΓͪ
ͅͳͶͪ͸ͪ



͐Ͱͼͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͻͰ͵͹͸ͼͽͻ;͵΁ͳΒͰ
͋ͰͻͪͲͳΒͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͼͰΓͰ͸ͪ
;

͋͹ͺ΂ͳͯͰͻ
͆ͪ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͼͽͪͻ͹
ͷͰͼͽ͹
ͬͻͪΕͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ


͊ͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵
͵͸ͰͲ;
ͅͳ΀ͪͳͶ;
ͻͪͯ
ͿͳͻͰ͸ͽͳ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͬͪΒͪͻͪ
̾
͈ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͹ͽ͵ͻͳ
ͬͰ͸

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ


̀ͭͻͪͯͪ
͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͳ΃ͽͪ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͺͻ͹ΒͰ͵ͽ;

ͪͻ΀
̸
̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵͹ͭ


͊ͽͪͻͪ
̓͹Ͷͪͻ΂Ͱͬͪ
Ͳͪͯ;ͱͫͳ͸ͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
;ͭͶ;
͍ͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵Ͱ
;Ͷͳ΁Ͱ
ͳ
͋ͻ
ͭͪ
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
͈͹ͻ;΃Ͱ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
;
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͷ
ͫ͹ͷͫͪͻͯ͹ͬͪΔ;
ͪͺͻͳͶͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ



͌ͺͻͪͬͪ
Ϳ͹͸ͯ͹ͬͪ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͯ͹ͭͻͪΌͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
ͯͬͪ
ͼͬͰͽ
ͼ͵ͪ
ͻͪͽͪ
͊ͪͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͽ;
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ
ͷ;ͲͰΒ


̺ͪͻ͹΃͵ͪ
͊ͽͪͷͫ͹Ͷ
͵ͪͺͳΒͪ
;
ͼͬ͹Β͹Β
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔ͹Β
ͿͪͲͳ
͸ͪͼͽͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
;
ͻͪͲͯ͹ͫΓ;

m
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
ͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͪͽ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵ͳ΀
Ϳ͹ͻͽͳͿͳ͵ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͳ΀
ͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ


͊ͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵
͠
͈ͪ͸΂ͳΕ;
ͯͰͶ͹
ͬͪΒͪͻͪ
͚
͠͹ͬͪ͸͹ͬͳΕͪ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽ
ΒͰ

ͭ͹
ͯͳ͸Ͱ
 ͪͅͻ͵͹
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ

ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͪ
ͺͳΒͪ΁ͪ
͋ͻͭ͹ͷ
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͷͳ͸ͳͻͪͶ͹
ͷ͹͸;ͷͰ͸ͽͪͶ͸͹
̓ͪͺͰͽͪ͸
ͅͳ
΃ͳ͸͹
ͲͯͪΔͰ
m
ͼͰͯͳ΃ͽͰ
͌͸ͳͬͰͻͲͳͽͰͽͪ
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ΃ΔͰ
̺ͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
΃͵͹ͶͰ
ͼͪ

ͽͻͳ
Ϳͪ͵;ͶͽͰͽͪ
m
͈ͻͪͬ͸ͳͷ
͋Ͱ΀͸ͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͳ
͍ͳͶ͹Ͳ͹Ϳͼ͵ͳͷ
΃ͽ͹
ͺ;ͽ͹
ͬ͹ΌͰ
͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͺ;΃ͽͪΒ;
ͯͪ
ͳͼͽͪ͵͸;
͌
ͳͼͽ͹ͷ
ͲͯͪΔ;
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
ͼͰ
ͽͪͯͪ
ͳ

͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͪ
ͫͳͫͶͳ͹ͽͰ͵ͪ
͈ͪͱΔͰ
ΒͰ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹
͸ͪͭͶͪ΃Ͱ͸͹
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͪ

͹ͫͳͷ
ͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
ΔͰ͸ͳ΀
Ϳ͹͸ͯ͹ͬͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΒͰͷ͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͬͪ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;
΁ͳΒͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͰͯ͹ͬͪͶͪ
Ϳ͹͸ͯ
͹ͯ

͵Δͳͭͪ
ͷͰΌ;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼ;

ͼͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸ͪ
ͯͻͪͭ͹΁Ͱ͸͹ͼͽ
΂;ͬͪͶͳ
ͼͽͪͻ͹ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͻ;͵͹ͺͳͼͳ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ

ͼͶͳ΂͸ͳ
ͼͺͳͼͳ
͌
ͷͰͼͰ΁ͳͷͪ
ͺͻͰͯ
͈ͻͬͳ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͳ
ͻͪͽ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͪ
ͫͳ
ͫͶͳ͹ͽͰ͵ͪ
ΒͰ
ͻͪͼͺ͹ͶͪͭͪͶͪ
Ϳ͹͸ͯ͹ͷ
͹ͯ

͵Δͳͭͪ
͌
͸Ͱͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸͹Β

ͫͶͳͲͳ͸ͳ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
ͼͰ
ͳ
Ͳͭͻͪͯͪ
͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͭ
ͷ;ͲͰΒͪ
ͼͪ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͳͷ
Ͳͫͳͻ͵ͪ
ͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;Β;
Ͳͪ
ͻͪͲͭͶͰͯͪΔͰ
̓ͪ͹
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͳ
Ͱ͵ͼͺ͹͸ͪͽ

;
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͼͰ
ͫͻ͹͸Ͳͪ͸ͪ
ͭͶͪͬͪ

΁ͪͻͪ
̓͹͸ͼͽͪ͸ͽͳ͸ͪ
͹ͽ͵ͻͳͬͰ͸ͪ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͻͪ͸ͳΒͰ
;
͆ͳ΃;
͈͹
ͷͳΔͰ
ͼͰ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͵;ͼͽ͹ͼ
ͷ;ͲͰΒͪ
ͽͪͯͪ
ͫͳ͹
ͺͻ͹Ϳ
ͅͳͶ͹ΒͰ
̺ͪͼͳΕ

ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ
͸ͪ;΂͸ͳ͵
ͳ
;ͽͰͷͰΓͳͽͰΓ
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͰ
;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͅ;ͲͰΒ
ͼͰ
Ͳͪ

ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁Ͱ
͹ͽͬͪͻͪ͹
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͭ
ͯͪ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
m
ͳ
͹ͯ
m
΂ͪͼ͹ͬͪ
ͺ͹ͺ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͪ

;ͶͪͲ
ͼͰ
͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͪͺͶͪΕͳͬͪ͹
̽ͪΓͰ
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ;
͵ͪ
͋ͬͻΌͪͬͳ
ͺͻ͹ͶͪͲͳͶ͹
ͼͰ

ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͲͭͻͪͯͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͺ΃ͽͳ͸Ͱ

͈ͻͰ
;Ͷͪͼ͵ͪ
;
͋ͬͻΌͪͬ;
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁;
ͼͰ
ͼ;ͭͰͻͳͼͪͶ͹
ͼ͵ͻͰͽͪΔͰ
ͺ͹
ͺͻͰ΂͸͹ͷ
;Ͷͳ΁͹ͷ
ͻͪͯͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ
͵ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶͳ
m
ͫͰ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵͹Β
͊ͪͫ͹ͻ͸͹Β
΁ͻ
͵ͬͳ
̓ͪ͹
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽ
͹ͬ͹ͭ

΀ͻͪͷͪ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸͹ͭ
ͪͻ΀ͪ͸ΌͰͶ;
ͅͳ΀ͪͳͶ;

͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ΒͰͯͳ͸͹
ͭͻ͹ͫ͹ͬͳ
͵͸ͰͱͰͬͪ
ͅͳͶ͹΃ͪ
ͳ
ͅͳ΀ͪͳͶͪ
͊ͪͷ͹
;

̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁;
ͼͰ
;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
ͳ
͸ͪ
Ͳͳͯ
͸͹
ͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͼͽͬ͹
ͯͰͶ͹
̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͪ
̸ͬͻͪͷ͹ͬͳΕͪ

͊ͪͷͪ
͋ͬͻΌͪͬͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
;
ͽ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
ͫͳͶͪ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳ
ͬ͹Β͸ͳ

͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽ
ͪ
ͯͰͶ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳ
Ͳͪͽͬ͹ͻ
ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͺͪ͵
͹ͽͬ͹ͻͰ͸ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ
͹΁Ͱ
͆͹΃ͰΔͰ
Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͪͺͪͻͪͽͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͲͪͫͻͪΔͰ͸͹
ͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͪͬͰͽ͹ͬͪ͸͹
ͯͪ
;
ͺ͹ͼͰͽ;
͋ͬͻΌͪͬͳ
ͳͯ;
;
ͺͻͪͽΔͳ
͸Ͱ͵͹ͭ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶ͸͹ͭ

ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
̀ͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;
͹ͯ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬͳͭ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
ͭͯͰ
ͼͰ
ͼͽͪͻͪ
͋ͬͻΌͪ
ͬͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
;ͲͭͻͰͯ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
;
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
ΔͰ͸ͳͷ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹
ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸ͪ
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
ͬͰΕͪ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
͌ͶͪͲͳͶ͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
͊ͽͪͷͫ͹Ͷ

͵ͪͺͳΒ;
͸ͪͯ
͵͹Β͹ͷ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
ͺͶ͹΂ͪ
ͼ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵ͳͷ
͸ͪͽͺͳͼ͹ͷ
ͺͻͰ͵ͻͳͬͰ
͸ͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͭͻͫ͹ͷ
͌
̻͹ͻΔͰͷ
ͭͻͪͯ;
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͳ
ͼ;
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ

̺͹Β͸ͳ
ͷ;ͲͰΒ
ͺͻͰͯ
͵͹Βͳͷ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͳ
ͽ͹ͺ͹ͬͳ
͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͳͲ


ͬͰ͵ͪ 
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͯͪ
;ͱͳͬͪΒ;
;
ͳͲͬͪ͸ͻͰͯ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯ;
͸ͪ
;΃ΕͰ
͊ͪͬͰ
;



̺͹Β͸ͳ
ͷ;ͲͰΒ
;
̻͹ͻΔͰͷ
ͭͻͪͯ;
͹ͽͬ͹ͻͰ͸
ΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;
ΒͰͯ͸͹Β
ͷͪΔ͹Β
͵ͻ;
ͱ͸͹Β
Ͳͭͻͪͯͳ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃ΔͰͭ
͉ͳͷͼ͵͹ͭ
ͫ;͸ͪͻͪ
͈͹ͻ;΃Ͱ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
͵͹ͷ
ͫ͹ͷͫͪͻͯ͹ͬͪΔͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͯ͹͵
ͼ;
Ͱ͵ͼͺ͹͸ͪͽͳ
͸ͪΒͬͰΕͳͷ
ͯͰͶ͹ͷ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͻͪͽ͸͹ͭ

ͷͰͽͰͱͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͻͪͯͪͶͳ
ͳͶͳ
͹ͺΓͪ΂͵ͪ͸ͳ
 ̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
;
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ

ͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ

ͬͰ͵ͪ 

̽;͸ͪͬ
ͳ
ͬ͹Βͬ͹Όͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͻͪͬ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͇ͯ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳ΀
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ

ͼͰ
̺ͰͶͳ͵ͳ
ͫ;͸ͪͻ 
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
͹ͫͳΕͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
;
ͺͻͪͽΔͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͳ

͋;ͻͫͰ
ͭͯͰ
ΒͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͽͪͯͪ
ͺ͹ͭͻͰ΃͸͹
ͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͶ͹
ͫͳ͹
ͼͪ΀ͻͪΔͰ͸
̓ͪͻͪ

ͅ;ͼͽͪͿͪ
ͺͪ΃ͪ
ͺͻͰͯͬ͹ͯ͸ͳ͵
ͽ;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͬ͹Βͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
͸Ͱ;ͼͺͰͶͰ
͹ͺͼͪ
ͯͰ
̹Ͱ΂ͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̓ͪ͹
ͭͶͪͬ͸Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
̽͹ΔͰͭ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͺ͹ͷͳ
Δ;
ͼͰ
͵;Ͷͪ
͆Ͱͫ͹Β΃ͪ
;Ͳ
͸ͪͲ͸ͪ͵;
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͪ
͹ͯ
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ΃ΔͰͭ

ͷ͸͹΃ͽͬͪ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸ͳ΀
ͫͰ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳ΀
͵;Ͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ

̓ͪͺͳΒͪ
ͺͻͳ͸΁ͪ

̾;ͭͰ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼ;
ΒͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͳ
ͽͪͯͪ
͸ͪͲͳͬͪͶͳ
̺ͻͰͯͳ
͸ͪͭͶͪͼͳͽͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ

;
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬͳͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
͹
͹ͬ͹ͷ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͷ
ͲͯͪΔ;
ͳͲ͸Ͱͽ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷ

ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲͪ͸
ͳ
ͽͪ΂ͪ͸
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵
m
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͹͸͹
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽ͹
ͺ͹
͸ͪͻͰΌͰΔ;
ͺͻͳ͸
΁ͪ
̾;ͭͰ͸ͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
͵ͪͺͳΒͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
͸͹ͼͳͶͪ
ͳͷͰ
΁ͪͻͪ

̓ͪͻͶͪ

7*
͇ͯ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͬͻͰͯ͸ͳ΀
ͺͪͱΔͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
;͵ͪͲͪ͸͹
͸ͪ

΁ͻ͵ͬ;
͉;ͱͳ΁;
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͻͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͫͪͻ;ͽ͸ͳ
ͷͪͭͪ΁ͳ͸
ͳ
ͼͽͪͻ;
̀ͳ͸ͯͪ͸

͵ͪͺͳΒ;
ͼͪ
ͯͬͰ
ͺ͹Ͷ;͵ͻ;ͱ͸Ͱ
͵;ͶͰ
͈͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
͋ͬͻΌͪͬͳ
;
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳͷ
͸Ͱ
ͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
ͳͲͶ͹ͱͰ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͼͪͱͰͽ͹
ͪͶͳ
ͼͰ
ͳͷͪ
;ͽͳͼͪ͵
ͯͪ
ͳͷ
ΒͰ

͵ͪ͹
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͶ͹ͱͪ͵
ͺ͹ͼͶ;ͱͳ͹
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
͹ͺ΃ͳͻ͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹
ͳͲͯͪΔͰ

̺͹Όͪ
ͺ͹
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

̀ͪͬͻ΃ͪͬͪΒ;Εͳ
ͻͪͲͭͶͰͯͪΔͰ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ͯͪ

ͼͰ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͱͽͪ
ͺ͹
̓ͪͶͰͷͰͭͯͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺͪͻ͵;
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
͹Ͳ͸ͪ΂Ͱ͸
͵ͪ͹
tͭͶͪͬ͸͹

ͫͰ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵͹
΃ͰͽͪͶͳ΃ͽͰi
ͭͯͰ
ΒͰ
;
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸Ͱ
ͯͪ͸Ͱ
ͼͬͳͻͪ͹
ͬ͹Β͸ͳ
͹ͻ͵Ͱ
ͼͽͪͻ
͌
ͪͷͫͳΒͰ͸ͽ;
ͺͪͻ͵ͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͫͳͼͽͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽͳ΀
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ΀

tͺͳͼͪ΁ͪ
ͳ
;΂ͰΔͪ͵ͪi
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͷ͹͸;ͷͰ͸ͽͪͶ͸ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵
̺͹ͱͯ;
̓ͪͻͪΌ͹ͻ
Ό;
̀͸ͪͽͳͱͰΓ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͼ;
ͳͷͪͶͳ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵;
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͳͲ
ͺͪͻ͵
ͼͺ;ͼͽͰ
ͯ͹
̽͹ͻ
Ε͹Ͷͪ
͵ͬͪͻͽͪ
ͼͪ
ͺͻͰ͹ͼͽͪͶͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵ͳͷ
ͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
ͭͯͰ
ͼ;
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͬͳͯͰ

ͻ;΃Ͱͬͳ͸Ͱ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͫͪͻ͹͵͸Ͱ
ͺͪͶͪͽͰ
ͳͲ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͪ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
͹͵;ͺͪ΁ͳΒͰ

m

͵͹Β;
ͼ;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͳ
͸ͪͲͳͬͪͶͳ
tͯͬ͹ͻ͹ͷ
ͺͻͳ͸΁ͪ
̾;ͭͰ͸ͪi

͆Ͱ΃ͽ͹
ͯͪΓͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
ͼͰ
ͳ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͪ
ͺͻͰ͹ͼͽͪͶͪ
ͫͰ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͪ
̹ͪΒͻͪ͵Ͷͳ
Θͪ
ͷͳΒͪ
Ͳͪ
͵͹Β;
ͼͰ
;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
t͸Ͱͯͪͬ͸͹
͹ͫ͸͹ͬΓͰ͸ͪi



ͅ
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ
t̺ͰͶͳ͵ͳ
ͫ;͸ͪͻ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵Ͱ
ͽͬͻΌͪͬͰi
̻͹ͯͳ΃Δͪ͵
ͭͻͪͯͪ
̹Ͱ͹
ͭͻͪͯͪ
99*7

m


ͅ
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ
t͋;ͻͫͰ
;
̻͹ͻΔͰͷ
ͭͻͪͯ;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵Ͱ
ͽͬͻΌͪͬͰi
̻͹ͯͳ΃Δͪ͵
ͭͻͪ
ͯͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
9997***

m


ͅ
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͪ
ͽͬͻΌͪͬͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ




͊ͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵
̓ͪͻͪΌ͹ͻΌ;
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ͹
͸ͪ
ͷͰͼͽ;
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃ΔͰͭ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
̀ͪ
΀ͬͪͶ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͍ͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵͹Β
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
͹ͽ͵ͻͳͬͰ͸

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͪ
ͼͻ;΃Ͱ͸
͹ͯ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͪ;ͼͽͻͳΒ
ͼ͵ͳ΀
͹͵;ͺͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͳ΀
ͬͶͪͼͽͳ
;
ͺͻ͹ͶͰΕͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ


͇ͫ͸͹ͬͪ
ΘͪͷͳΒͰ
ͳͲͬͰͯͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹
͸ͪͻͰΌͰΔ;
͵ͻͪΓͪ
̸ͶͰ͵ͼͪ͸ͯͻͪ

͇ͫͻͰ͸͹ͬͳΕͪ
ͬͳͯͳ
%
ƄVSJǀ;BNPMP
#FPHSBE
LBP
PSJKFOUBMOB
WBSPØ
QPE
5VSDJNB

m
#FPHSBE

m
 ͪͅͻ͵͹
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ

͆ͪ͵͹͸
΃ͰͽΔͰ
ͺ͹
ͭͻͪͯ;
Ͳͪ
΃ͽͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
ͯ͹ͬ͹Γͪ͸
ͼͪͷ͹
ΒͰͯͪ͸

ͯͪ͸
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ͯͪ
͹ͯͰ
ͳ
ͯ͹
͋͹ͺ΂ͳͯͰͻͪ
͹ͷͳΓͰ͸͹ͭ
ͳͲͶͰ
ͽͳ΃ͽͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͪ
̀ͪ
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫ͸͹
ͷͪΔͰ
͹ͯ
ͺ͹Ͷͪ
ͼͪͽͪ
ͬ͹ͱΔͰ

ͽͻͪͷͬͪΒͰͷ
͋;
ͼͰ
͹͵͹
t͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵͹ͭ
ͶͰͽΔͳ͵͹ͬ΁ͪi
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
̓͹͸ͪ͵ͪ
͵͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ
ͅͳͶ͹΃ͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ͹
ͶͰͺ͹
;ͻͰΌͰ͸
ͺͪͻ͵
͆Ͱ΃ͽ͹
ͯͪΓͰ
΃ͰͽΔ͹ͷ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ

̓͹΃;ͽΔͪ͵
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͳͶ͹
ͼͰ
ͯ͹
ͷͰͼͽͪ
͸ͪ
͵͹ΒͰͷ
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
;ͫͳΒͰ͸
͵͸ͰͲ
ͅͳ΀ͪ
ͳͶ͹
͌
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
ͳͲͶͰͽͳ
ͺ͹
͹͵͹Ͷͳ͸ͳ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ

͸ͳͼ;
ͫͳͶͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂ͳͬͪ͸ͳ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͳ
ͼ;
;
ͽ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͻͪͯ͹

͹ͯͶͪͲͳͶͳ
ͯ͹
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͪ
͉ͪ͵͹ͬͳ΁Ͱ
ͳͶͳ
ͯ͹
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
;ͯͪΓͰ͸ͳΒͰ
̸ͬͪͶͰ

͸ͪ
΂ͳΒͰͷ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͬͻ΀;
ͽͪͯͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͰ
ͻͪͲͬͪͶͳ͸Ͱ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹ͭ
ͭͻͪͯͪ

̿ͻ͸͹ͬͪ

͆ͪ
͵ͻͪΒ;
Ͳͪͬͻ΃ͪͬͪΒ;Εͳ
͹ͬͪΒ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ
͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
͸ͪͷ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͲͪͷͳͼͶͳ
ͷ͹
͵ͪ͵ͪͬ
;ͽͳͼͪ͵
͸ͪ
ͼͽͻͪ͸͹ͭ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͪ
ͺͻͰ
ͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁ͪ
͆ͪ͵͹͸
΂ͳͽͪͬ͹ͭ
ͼͽ͹ͶͰΕͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͯͪΓͰ
͹ͼͽͪ͹
ͼͪͷ͹
ͺͻ͹
ͶͪͲ͸ͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͈͹ͻͰͯ
͋ͬͻΌͪͬͰ
ͳ
̓ͪͶͰͷͰͭͯͪ͸ͪ
͵͹Βͳ

ͼͪͯͪ
ͯͰͶ;Β;
;ͻͰΌͰ͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͬͶͪ΂͸ͳΒͰ
ͷͪͶ͹
ΒͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͫͳ

ͺͻͳͬ;͵ͶͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸;
ͺͪͱΔ;
ͼͽͻͪ͸͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
͉Ͱͽ͵ͳ
ͼ;
ͷ;ͲͰΒͳ
͹ͽͬ͹
ͻͰ͸ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁Ͱ
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ΃Δͳ
ͯͬ͹ͻ͹ͬͳ
ͳ
ͻͰͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪͽͳͬͪ͸ͪ
Βͪͬ͸ͪ

ͲͯͪΔͪ
͸ͳͼ;
ͯ͹ͼͽ;ͺ͸ͪ
ͪ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ
ͼ;ͬͰ͸ͳͻͪ
΂ͳ͸ͳ
͸ͪͷ
ͼͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
΂ͪ͵
ͳ

ͷͪΔͪ
͸Ͱͭ͹
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ
̸͵ͽ;ͰͶ͸;
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹ͼͽ

ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͻ;΃Ͱͬͳ͸Ͱ

Βͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͲͯͪΔͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͻͪͯͪͶͳ΀
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͰͭ
ͫ͹ͷͫͪͻͯ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͽͳͱͰΓ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͰ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺͻͳͬͶͪ΂ͳ
Ͷ͹
ͷͰͼͽ͹
ͭͯͰ
ΒͰ
ͳͲͬͻ΃Ͱ͸͹
͵ͻͪΓͰ;ͫͳͼͽͬ͹

͆Ͱͼ;ͷΔͳͬͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͭͻͰͼ͹ͷ

͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
͹ͼͽͬͪͻͰ͸
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹ͽͰ͵Ͷͳ΀
ͼͽ͹ͽͳ͸;
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
͸ͳΒͰ

ͺ͹ͼͽͪ͹
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬͳΒͳ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳͷͪ
ͪ
ͯͪ
Ͷͳ
ΕͰ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͳ
͹ͼͽͪͽͳ

ͼ;ͯͳΕͰ
͹͸ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͽͰͷ͹ͷ
ͫ;ͯ;
ͫͪͬͳͶͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ
͸ͪͻͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͼͽ͹
ͶͰΕͪ
 ̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
;
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ

ͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ

ͬͰ͵ͪ 

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

.BSLP
1PQPWJǀ
#FMHSBE
JO
EFVUTDIFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO
&OEF
EFT


VOE
"OGBOH
EFT

+BISIVOEFSUT

%JF
3FJTFGÛISFS
EFOFO
JN
WPSMJFHFOEFO
"SUJLFM
CFTPOEFSF
"VGNFS

LTBNLFJU
HFXJENFU
XJSE
GPMHFO
FJOFN
ÛCMJDIFO
&S[ÅIMNVTUFS
7PS
#FMHSBE

CJFUFU
TJDI
FJOFN
EFVUTDIFO
3FJTFOEFO
EJF
(FMFHFOIFJU
BO
HSVOEMFHFOEF

"OHBCFO
ÛCFS
EJF
4UBEU
[V
MFTFO
JO
EFS
FS
HFSBEF
BOLPNNU
"O
FSTUFS
4UFMMF

FSGÅISU
FS
EBTT
FT
EJF
)BVQUTUBEU
EFT
,ÕOJHSFJDIT
4FSCJFO
JTU
FT
XJSE
XFJUFSIJO

BVG
EJF
HÛOTUJHF
HFPHSBGJTDIF
-BHF
#FMHSBET
BN
;VTBNNFOGMVTT
[XFJFS
HSP“FS

'MÛTTF
WFSXJFTFO
XBT
EFS
4UBEU
FJOF
CFTPOEFSF
TUSBUFHJTDIF
#FEFVUVOH
BMT

EFN
t4DIMÛTTFM
[VS
5ÛSLFJi
WFSMFJIU
"VT
FJOFS
XFJUFSFO
#FNFSLVOH
FSGÅISU

NBO
EBTT
#FMHSBE
tCJT
WPS
LVS[FNi
FJOF
PSJFOUBMJTDIF
TUÅEUFCBVMJDIF
4USVLUVS

BVGHFXJFTFO
IBCF
OVO
BCFS
SBTDI
JO
FJOF
FVSPQÅJTDIF
4UBEU
VNHFXBOEFMU

XFSEF
"MT
FJO
BMUFT
NJU
UÛSLJTDIFO
¾CFSCMFJCTFMO
WFSTFIFOFT
4UBEUWJFSUFM

XVSEF
%PSǀPM
IFSBVTHFIPCFO
XP
TJDI
VB
FJO
WPO
TQBOJTDIFO
+VEFO
CFTJFEFMUFS

4UBEUUFJM
CFGBOE
%JF
5BUTBDIF
EBTT
JOOFSIBMC
FJOFT
BCHFTDIMPTTFOFO
UÛSLJTDIFO

8PIOWJFSUFMT
BVDI
4FQIBSEJN
MFCUFO
EJF
JISF
(PUUFTEJFOTUF
JO
FJOFS
4ZOBHPHF

WFSSJDIUFUFO
TUFMMUF
FJOF
HFTDIJDIUMJDIF
&STDIFJOVOH
EBS
EFSFO
8VS[FMO
TJDI

CJT
JOT

+BISIVOEFSU
[VSÛDLWFSGPMHFO
MJF“FO

%JF
4DIJMEFSVOHFO
EFS
4FIFOTXÛSEJHLFJUFO
EFS
4UBEU
VOE
EFSFO
%FO
LNÅMFS
TJOE
TPSHGÅMUJH
BVTHFTVDIU
VOE
EFN
EBNBMJHFO
,FOOUOJTTUBOE

FOUTQSFDIFOE
BVDI
SFMBUJW
[FJUHFNœ
EBSHFTUFMMU
&T
JTU
OJDIU
[V
ÛCFSTFIFO

EBTT
EJF
"VTHBCFO
EFS
3FJTFGÛISFS
WPO
.FZFS
VOE
#BFEFLFS
JO
SFHFMNœJHFO

"CTUÅOEFO
NJU
FSOFVFSUFO
*OGPSNBUJPOFO
WFSWPMMTUÅOEJHU
JOEFN
VB

"OHBCFO

[V
OFVFO
#BVUFO
BLUVBMJTJFSU
XFSEFO
%JF
FNQGPIMFOFO
3FJTFUPVSFO
TJOE

KFEPDI
VOUFSTDIJFEMJDI
%JF
3FJTFOEFO
NJU
EFN
3FJTFGÛISFS
WPO
#BFEFLFS

CFHJOOFO
JISF
4UBEUCFTJDIUJHVOH
XJF
FT
BVDI
IFVU[VUBHF
ÛCMJDI
JTU
WPO
EFS

#VSH
BVG
EFN
,BMFNFHEBO
%FO
-FTFSO
EFS
3FJTFGÛISFS
WPO
.FZFS
XJSE
FJO

4QB[JFSHBOH
JO
FOUHFHFOHFTFU[UFS
3JDIUVOH
FNQGPIMFO
m
WPN
)BVQUCBIOIPG

[VN
,BMFNFHEBO
IJO

4DIMJF“MJDI
CMFJCU
EJF
'SBHF
PGGFO
XBT
GÛS
FJOFO
&JOESVDL
EJF
NPEFSOF

TFSCJTDIF
)BVQUTUBEU
BVG
BVTMÅOEJTDIF
3FJTFOEF
NBDIU



"VDI
IVOEFSU
+BISF
TQÅUFS
CMFJCU
#FMHSBE
OVS
FJO
WPSÛCFSHFIFOEFT

3FJTF[JFM
7PO
EFS
#VSH
VOE
EFN
,BMFNFHEBO
BCHFTFIFO
EJF
IFVU[VUBHF

PSEFOUMJDIFS
VOE
BUUSBLUJWFS
XJSLFO
HJCU
FT
XFOJHF
4FIFOTXÛSEJHLFJUFO

EFOFO
BVTMÅOEJTDIF
3FJTFOEF
CFTPOEFSF
"VGNFSLTBNLFJU
TDIFOLFO
XÛSEFO

&T
HJCU
XFOJHF
.VTFFO
EJF
CFTVDIU
XFSEFO
EÛSGFO
FIFNBMJHF
4DIMÕTTFS
VOE

 ͪͅͻ͵͹
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ

SFQSÅTFOUBUJWF
ÕGGFOUMJDIF
#BVUFO
TJOE
OJDIU
BMMHFNFJO
[VHÅOHMJDI
VOE
EBT

"OHFCPU
BO
4PVWFOJST
JTU
OBDI
VOTFSFN
&SBDIUFO
CFTDIFJEFOFS
EFOO
KF
"LUVFMMF

4FIFOTXÛSEJHLFJUFO
TUFMMFO
EJF
¾CFSSFTUF
BMUFS
JN
MFU[UFO
#PNCBSEFNFOU


[FSTUÕSUFS
ÕGGFOUMJDIFS
(FCÅVEF
EBS
FCFOTP
XJF
FT
WPS
FUXB
FJOFN
+BISIVOEFSU

WJFMF
/FVHJFSJHF
[VN
0SU
IJO[PH
XP
EBT
"UUFOUBU
BVG
EBT
LÕOJHMJDIF
&IFQBBS

WFSÛCU
XVSEF
5SPU[
VOCFTUSFJUCBS
HFXBMUJHFN
'PSUTDISJUU
EFS
JN
MFU[UFO
+BISIVOEFSU

HFNBDIU
XVSEF
XVSEF
#FMHSBE
GÛS
BVTMÅOEJTDIF
5PVSJTUFO
LFJO
CJTTDIFO

BUUSBLUJWFS
0C
FT
BVDI
XFJUFSIJO
TP
CMFJCU
LÕOOUFO
OVS
VOTFSF
/BDIGPMHFS

FSNJUUFMO
XFOO
TJF
TJDI
EFNTFMCFO
5IFNB
"OGBOH
EFT
OÅDITUFO
+BISIVOEFSUT

XJENFO
XÛSEFO

͐Ͱͯ͹ͷͳͻ
̸͆͋́ͣ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
̸͊͆͌

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

͇̽
̸͉͋́͆̾
͇̽

̸̸̹͎̈́͆͊̓́
̸̹͈̾͊͌ͣ

̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
;
͸͹ͬͰͷͫͻ;

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̓͸Ͱ
ͱͰͬͳ͸ͪ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
΃Ͱͼͽͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͪ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
͹ͼ͸͹
ͬͪ͸ͪ
;
͸͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͬͰ͵;
͇ͬ;
ͲͰͷΓ;
ΒͰ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
͹ͯͻͰͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
;
#SJUBOJDJ
Β͹΃

͵ͻͪΒͰͷ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
͹ͺͳͼͪ͹
ͺ͹ͼͰͱ;Εͳ
Ͳͪ
͵Ͷͪͼͳ΂͸ͳͷ
ͯͰͶ͹ͷ
ͼͰͯͪͷ͸ͪͰͼͽ͹
ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹ͭ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳ΂ͪͻͪ
̾ͯͬͪͻͪͯͪ
̻ͳͫ͹͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
͹ͫͶͪͼͽ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
t͸ͪͶͪͲͳ

͸ͪ
ͯ͹ͷͪ͵;
́ͽͪͶͳΒͰ
ͪͶͳ
ΒͰ
͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͫͳͶ͹
͵͹Βͪ
ͪͿͻͳ΂͵ͪ
ͲͰͷΓͪi

͆ͪͼͽͪͶͪ
;
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
͸ͳͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͫͪͶͰ
ͳ
͹ͼͶ͹ΔͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
ͬͳͼ͹͵Ͱ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ

͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͳ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
͵ΔͳͭͰ
͹
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳ
Βͳ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸Ͱ
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ
ͼͰͯͪͷͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͽͬͻͯͳͶͳ

ͯͪ
ͫͳ
ͺ͹ͻͪͬ͸ͪ͸Ͱ
;΂ͳ͸ͳͶͰ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒ;
ͺͻ͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳΒ͹ͷ
͹ͯ
͍ͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵Ͱ

͹ͬͪ
ͲͰͷΓͪ
ΒͰ
ͬ͹Γ͹ͷ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ΀
ͼͳͶͪ
ͳ
ͼ͸ͪͭ͹ͷ
ͼ;ͼͰͯͪ
͹ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂Ͱ͸ͪ
͸ͪ

͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͪ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͹ͯͬͪΒͪ
͹ͯ
͹ͼͽͪͽ͵ͪ
ͺ͹Ͷ;͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
̽ͪ

ͼͰ
͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
ͺ͹ͯ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽ͹ͷ
̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
́ͽͪͶͳΒͰ
ͷͪͶͰ͸ͪ

ͲͰͷΓͪ
΂ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͬͶͪͯͪ
;
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵;
͵͹͸ͽͻ͹ͶͳͼͪͶͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͯͬͪ

ͺͻͳ͹ͫͪͶ͸ͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͫͳ
;
͸ͪΒͫ͹ΓͰͷ
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ;
ͯͬ͹ͼͽͻ;͵͹
;ͷͪΔͰ͸ͪ

Ͷͳ΃Ͱ͸ͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
ͷ͹ͻͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͫͪͶͰ
ͳ
ͳͲͶͪͼ͵ͪ
͸ͪ
͇΀ͻͳͯͼ͵͹
ͳ
͊͵ͪͯͪͻͼ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͲͰͻ͹
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͪ
ͼͰ
ͳͺͪ͵
͹ͯͻͱͪͶͪ
;
͸ͰͲ͸ͪͽ͸͹
ͳͲͷͰΔͰ͸ͳͷ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ

;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ;
͸ͪ
͹͸Ͱ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸Ͱ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̸Ͷͳ
ͽͰ͵
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
Ͳͪͬͻ΃ͳ͹

͈ͻͬͳ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͳ
ͻͪͽ
Ͳͪͺ͹΂ͰͶͰ
ͼ;
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͫͰͲͬͶͪ΃Εͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͹͵͹͸΂ͪ
ͶͰ
;΂ͬͻ΃ΕͳͬͪΔͰͷ
̸΀ͷͰͯͫͰͭͪ
̀͹ͭ;ͪ
͸ͪ
ͬͶͪͼͽͳ
ͅ͹Ε͸ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͰͯ͸ͳ͵

ͼͰ

;Ͳ
ͺ͹ͷ͹Ε
́ͽͪͶͳΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͭͶͪͼͳ͹
Ͳͪ
͵ͻͪΓͪ
NCSFU

̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͰ

 ͐Ͱͯ͹ͷͳͻ
̸͸ͽͳΕ

͉ͪͲͯ͹ͫΓͰ
ͷͳͻͪ
Ͳͪͬͻ΃ͳͶ͹
ͼͰ
ͬͰΕ
;
ͪͺͻͳͶ;

͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͪ

Ͳͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͼͰͯͪͷ
ͯͪ͸ͪ
͹͵;ͺͳͻͪ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͳͽͪͶͳΒͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͬ͹Βͼ͵Ͱ
͈͹ͼͶͰ

ͻͪͽͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;
ͲͰͷΓͳ
ΒͰ
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͲͪͷ
͉Ͱͱͳͷ
̾͸
ͬͰͻͪ
͎͹ΘͰ
m

ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰͯ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͉ͪͷͳͲͪ
̸ͶͳΒͰ
m


͹ͼͽͪ͹
ΒͰ
;ͺͪͷΕͰ͸
ͺ͹
ͳͲ͹Ͷͪ΁ͳΒͳ
ͳ
ͻͰͺͻͰͼͳΒͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͷͰͽ͸;͹

ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ;
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͋͹͵͹ͷ
ͼ͵͹ͻ͹
ͺ͹Ͷͪ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ΀

ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͪͬͪΔͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
͊͹ͬΒͰͽͼ͵͹ͷ
͊ͪͬͰͲ;
ͳͶͳ
̓ͳ͸ͳ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳ
Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
Ͳͪͽͬ͹ͻͰ͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
͹͵͹Ͷ͸͹ͷ
ͼͬͰͽ;
;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͯͳ
ͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͷ
ͳ
ͼͪͫ͹ͻͪΕͪΒ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯ;
́Ͳ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͼ;

;
ͳ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͼͽͬ͹
͹ͯͶͪͲͳͶͳ
ͻͰͽ͵ͳ
ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͳ
ͪ
;
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒ;
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͳͶ͹

Β͹΃
ͷͪΔͰ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͶͪ΁ͪ
̻͹ͯͳ͸ͪͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼ
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͪΔͪ
ͬͳͲͰ

Ͳͪ
ͭͻͪΌͪ͸Ͱ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
Ͳͪ΀ͽͰͬͪ͹
͵͹ͷͺͶͳ͵͹ͬͪ͸;
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͯ;ͻ;
͵͹Β͹Β
ΒͰ

ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯͳͶ͹
ͺ͹ͯ͸͹΃ͰΔͰ
Ϳ͹ͻͷ;Ͷͪͻͪ
ͼͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͼͽ͹ͽͳ͸ͪ
͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪ
͸ͪ

ͺͳͽͪΔͪ
͵ͪ͵ͬ͹
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͻͰ΁ͳͷ͹
t̻ͯͰ
ͼͽͰ
ͫͳͶͳ
m
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ i
͌

ͲͰͷΓͳ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͪ͹
ͺͻͳͬͪͽ͸ͳ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ
ͪ
ͯ͹
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵ͪ
͹ͼͪͷͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
;
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͳ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͪ͵͹
ͫͳ
͸Ͱ͵͹
ͳ
ͺ͹
ͼͰͽͳ͹
͹ͬ;
ͲͰͷΓ;
ͺͻͳͬͪͽ͸͹
ͷ͹ͻͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͼͪ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͬͰ
ͽͪ͵ͼͳ
;
ͲͰ
ͷΓͳ
;
͵͹Β;
ΒͰ
ͯ͹΃ͪ͹
͸ͳΒͰ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
͸ͪΕͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͪͶͳ
ΒͰ
Ͳͪͽ͹
ͳͷͪ͹
͸ͰͺͻͰ
͵ͳͯ͸;
ͳ
͸Ͱͼ͵ͻͳͬͰ͸;
ͺͻͪͽΔ;
͎͹ͽͰͶ
;
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ

ͼͻͰͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͯͬͪͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
;
͋ͳͻͪ͸ͳ

͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͰ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸͹
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͹

͹ͯ

͵ͪͯͪ
ͭͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ
͵ͻͪΓ
͈Ͱͽͪͻ
͸ͪͲͬͪ͹
΃ͽͪͶ͹ͷ
ͳ
͵ͻͪΒͪ
͹ͼͪͷ
ͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀

ͬͰ͵ͪ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͼͽͳ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪͶͪ
͸͹ͬͪ
΀͹ͽͰͶͼ͵ͪ
Ͳͭͻͪͯͪ
ͪͶͳ

ΒͰ
ͳ
͹͸ͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͺ͹ͯͶ͹ͱ͸ͪ
ͻͰͼͽͻͳ͵΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͼͽͻ;ΒͰ
ͪ
;
͵;ͺͪͽͳͶͳͷͪ
͸ͳΒͰ

ͫͳͶ͹
ͽ͹ͺͶͰ
ͬ͹ͯͰ
͈ͻͳͶͳ͵Ͱ
;
ͲͰͷΓͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͳͶͰ
ͽͰ͵
ͯͰͬͰͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ




́ͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ;
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ΔͰ͸Ͱ
ͼͶͳ͵Ͱ
͵ͪ͵ͬͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
;
ͽ;ͻͳ
ͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;ΕͰ
ΒͰ
ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
ͺ͹ͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳ
;
͹͵ͬͳͻͳͷͪ
͵ͻͪΕͳͷ

͹ͯ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͼͽ͹ͶͰΕͪ
͋͹͵͹ͷ
ͽ͹ͭ
ͻͪͲͯ͹ͫΓͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
͸ͳΒͰ
ͯ;ͱͰ
͹ͯ

ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
Γ;ͯͼ͵͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͹͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
͵ͻͪͽ͵͹
ͫͳͶͪ
͹ͯͻͰͯͳ΃ͽͰ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹
ͬͪ͸ͳ΀
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͪ͵ͪ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
;
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͯͰͼͰͽ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͯ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͽͻͪΒͪΔͪ
ͯͬͪ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͪ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͺ͹ͯ
͹͵;ͺͪ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ΀
ͼͳͶͪ

ͪ
͹ͯ

ͯ͹


ͯ͹

ͳ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ

ͲͰͷΓͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
;

ͼͽͪΔ;
ͫͰͲͬͶͪ΃Εͪ
͐ͰͽͻͯͰͼͰͽ
ͳ
΃Ͱͼͽ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͽͻͪΒͪΔͪ
ͻͪͶͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶͳ
ͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͯͳ͵ͽͪͽ;ͻͰ
ͳ
͸ͪͻͰͯ͸ͳ΀
΃Ͱͼͽ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
͹ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂Ͱ͸Ͱ
ͯͰͷ͹͵ͻͪͽͳΒͰ

̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
;
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳͶͳ
ͯͰͶͳͷͳ΂͸͹
Ͳͪͽͬ͹ͻͰ͸ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ
͹΁Ͱ
ͳͲ
ͳ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͼͽͬͪ
̽ͪ͵ͶͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͯͰͬͰͯͰͼͰͽ
ͳ
ͯͬͰ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͪ
Δͪ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
΃ͰͲͯͰͼͰͽ
΃Ͱͼͽ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
;
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹ͼͽͳ
Ͳͪͽͬ͹ͻͰ͸ͪ



͌
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͺͻͰͶͪͼ͵ͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͬ͹Βͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͰ
͇ͯ
ͪͶͫͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͫͰͼͺ;Εͪ
ͯ͹
͋ͳͻͪ͸Ͱ 
 ͐Ͱͯ͹ͷͳͻ
̸͸ͽͳΕ

Ͳͪ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ
ͳͲ
ͳ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͼͽͬͪ
ͯ͹͵
ΒͰ
ͯͪΓͳ΀

΃Ͱͼͽ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͽͰ͵
ͯͰͶͳͷͳ΂͸͹
͹ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ΌͰ͸ͪ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ

ͳͲ͹Ͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͅ͹ͱͰ
ͼͰ
ͻͰΕͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
Ͳͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͽͻͳ͸ͪͰͼͽ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͯ;
ͭ͹ͭ
ͻͪͲͯ͹ͫΓͪ
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ
ͯͬͪͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͳ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͬͰ
͵ͪ
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͶͪͲ;
ͳͲ

;

ͬͰ͵
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
Ͳͪͳͼͽͪ
͹ͽͬ͹ͻͰ͸ͪ
Ͳͪ

ͼͽͻͪ͸΁Ͱ
ͪ
ͽͳͷͰ
ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
͇ͯ

ͯ͹
͸ͪ΃ͳ΀
ͯͪ͸ͪ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ

͸ͪͺͻͰͽ͵ͪ
;
ͼͽͪ͸ͯͪͻͯ;
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ;
ͳ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͳͷ
ͽͰ΀͸͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͪ
ͷͪ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͶͪ
;
ͬͰͶͳ͵͹Β
ͷͰͻͳ
ͼͶͳ΂͸ͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳͷ
ͼͻͰͯ͹ͲͰͷ͸ͳͷ

ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
΂ͳΒͪ
ͻͰͶͪͽͳͬ͸ͪ
͸ͰͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ͸͹ͼͽ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͺͻͰ͵ͪ
ͬͰΕ

ͺ͹ͯͼͽͳ΁ͪΒ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷ;

̀͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸͹
Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͽͳͬ͸͹
ͻͪͲͯ͹ͫΓͰ
ͬͰͲͪ͸͹
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ
͵ͻͪͽ͵͹ͽͻͪΒ͸;
ͼͽͪ
ͫͳͶ͸͹ͼͽ
͵͹Β;
ΒͰ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͳ
ͺͻ;ͱͳͶͪ
̀͹ͭ;͹ͬͪ
ͷ͹͸ͪͻ΀ͳΒͪ
̹ͳͶͰ
ͼ;
ͽ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
ͬͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ͸Ͱ
͵ͻͳͲͰ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;

ͯ͹ͼͰͭͶͪ
ͼͬ͹Β
ͬͻ΀;͸ͪ΁

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͬͰΕͪ͸
ͫͻ͹Β
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
;
ͼͰͬͰͻ͹ͳ
ͼͽ͹΂͸͹ͷ
͊ͻͰͯ͹ͲͰͷΓ;
̹;ͯ;Εͳ
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͼͬͪ͵͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͯ͹
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͰ

;
ͽ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͷ͹ͭͶ͹
ͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳ
ͺͻͰͯ;ͭͳͷ
ͳ
͹ͫͳͶͪͲ͸ͳͷ
Ͷ͹ͭͳ΂͸ͪ
ͽ;ͻͳ
ͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͻ;ͽͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
;
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒ;
ͺͻͰ͵͹
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
͹ͯ
Βͪͯͻͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
Ͷ;͵ͪ

͈;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
͹ͯ
͋ͻͼͽͪ
͸ͪ
Β;ͭ
Βͪͯͻͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ

͹ͫͪͶ͹ͷ
ͺ͹΃Ͷͳ
͸͹ͼͰΕͳ
ͼͪ
ͼ͹ͫ͹ͷ
́Ͷ;ͼͽͻ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
Ͳͪ
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒ;

ͳͲͯͪͽ
;
̹Ͱ΂;
ͳ
̈́ͪΒͺ΁ͳͭ;

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͫͳͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͽͰ΃͵͹
ͯͪ
ͻͪͲͶ;΂Ͱ
ͪͶ
ͫͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͫͪͶͰ
͇ͼͷͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
΁ͪͻͼͽͬͪ
͹ͯ
Ͷ;͵ͪ
͸ͰͲͪͬͳͼ͸Ͱ
̓͸ͰͱͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
͏ͻ
͸Ͱ
̻͹ͻͰ
͈͹ͼͶͰ
̹ͪͻͪ
"OUJWBSJ

ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
ΒͰ
ͯͪ͹
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
͹ͺͳͼ
͊͵ͪͯͻͪ

4DVUBSJ

ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯͪ
͸ͪͬͰ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
;
ͭͻͪͯ;
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ

΀͹ͽͰͶ
t̾ͬͻ͹ͺͪi
ͳ
͹͸ͯͪ
ͺͻͰ΃ͪ͹
͸ͪ
΁ͻ͸͹ͭ͹ͻͼ͵ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
͌Ͷ΁ͳΔ
%VMDJH
OP

͋Ͱ͵
;Ͳ
͵ͻͪͽͪ͵
͹ͯͰΓͪ͵
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸
Ͷ;΁ͳ
͊ͬ
͠͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
ͅͰͯ͹ͬͼ͵͹ͭ
4

(JPWBOOJ
EJ
.FEVB

ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
ͼͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
͊͵Ͱ͸ͯͰͻͫͰͭͪ
ͳ
ͽ͹
͵ͪ͹
ͪͶͫͪ͸
ͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͭ
Β;͸ͪ͵ͪ
́Ͳ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;Εͳ
͡Ͱ΃
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
ΒͰ
ͼ͵͹ͻ͹
ͺ͹Ͷ͹
ͬͳ͸;
ͼͺͳͼͪ
ͬͰͲͪ͸͹ͭ
Ͳͪ
ͪͶͫͪ͸ͼ͵;
͹ͫͪͶ;
ͺ͹ͼͬͰͽͳ͹
͸ͪΒͬͰΕ͹Β
Ͷ;΁ͳ
m
̽ͻͪ
΂;
͇͸
ͼͰ
ͫͪͬͳ͹
ͳͲͭͶͰͯ͹ͷ
Ͷ;͵Ͱ
ͳ
΁ͳͽͪͯͰͶͰ
;
ͭͻͪͯ;
Ͷͳ͸ͭͬͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ

ͺ͹ͻͰ͵Ͷ;
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͳͷͰ͸ͪ
ͳ
͸ͪͻͪͬ͸͹
ͫ͹ͭͪͽ͹ͷ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ͹ͷ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͭͻͪͯͪ

͹ͯ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
ͯ͹ͫͪ
ͭ͹ͽͼ͵Ͱ
͵ͻͪΓͳ΁Ͱ
̸ͷͪͶͪͼͬͳ͸ͽͰ
ͬͳ
Ͳͪ͸ͽͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
͸͹ͻͷͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͪ͸ͱ;Βͼ͵Ͱ
;ͺͻͪͬͰ
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹
͹ͼͷͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
͹ͼͬͪΒͪ
Δͪ
͆ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
͹
΀͹ͽͰͶ;
ͳͶͳ
͸Ͱ͵͹Β
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹Β
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹ͼͽͳ
͊ͬͰ

ͯ͹
̺ͪͶ͹͸Ͱ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͷͳ΃ΓͰΔ;
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͷ͹ͭͶͪ
ͯͪ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷͪΒ;

ͼͪͷ͹
;΃Εͪ
ͻͰ͵ͪ
͑͵;ͷͫͳ
4LVNCJ

͊ͰͷͰ͸ͳ
4FNFOJ

ͳ
̺͹Β;΃Ͱ
7P
KVTTB

͇ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ͼͪͷ͹
ͺͻͬͪ
ͲͪͬͻͰΌ;ΒͰ
ͺͪͱΔ;
ͳ
ͽ͹
Ͳͪͽ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͻͪͲͯͬͪΒͪ



*MMVTUSJFSUFS
'ÛISFS
EVSDI
%BMNBUJFO
"CCB[JB

-VTTJO

-ÅOHT
EFS
,ÛTUF
WPO

"MCBOJFO
CJT
,PSGV
VOE
/BDI
EFO
*POJTDIFO
*OTFMO
8JFO
VOE
-FJQ[JH
"
)BSUMFCFOT

WFSMBH




̓͹Βͳ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽ
;
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͳͲ


 ͇ͯ
ͪͶͫͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͫͰͼͺ;Εͪ
ͯ͹
͋ͳͻͪ͸Ͱ 

̸Ͷͫͪ͸΁Ͱ̻ͰͭͰ
͹ͯ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͪ΁ͪ͋͹ͼ͵ͪ
͆ͪ
ͺ;ͽ;
Ͳͪ
̓ͻͿ
Β͹΃
ͯͬͰ
Ͷ;͵Ͱ
ͳ΃
΂Ͱ͵ͳͬͪͶͰ
ͼ;
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
̺ͪͶ͹͸ͪ
"WMPOB

͹
͵͹Β͹Β
ΒͰ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͷ͹ͭ;ΕͰ

ͯͪͽͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ΒͰ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͳ

;Ͷ͹ͭͪ
ͭͻ΂͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
̸ͺ͹Ͷ͹͸ͳΒͰ
;
̓͹ͻͳ͸ͽͼ͵͹ͷ
ͻͪͽ;
͈ͰͶ͹ͺ͹͸Ͱͼ͵͹ͷ

ͻͪͽ;

ͳ
͊ͪ͸ͽͪ
̓ͪͻͪ͸ͽͪ
͹
͵͹Β͹Β
ΒͰ
͸ͪͺͳͼͪ͸͹
ͽͰ͵
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͺͻͳͭ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀

ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸ͳ΁ͪ

͠Ͱͯͪ͸
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸
ΒͰ
;
̽ͻͰͲͯͰ͸;
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̸;ͽ͹ͻ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰͽͳ͹
ΒͰ
΂ͳͽͪͬ͹
ͺ͹ͭͶͪͬΓͰ
̸Ͷ
ͫͪ͸ͳΒͳ
͇ͬ͹ͭ
ͺ;ͽͪ
ͻͰ΂
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
͹
ͯͻͱͪͬͳ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͷͪͶͪ
ͳ
ͼͬ͹Β
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ

ͭͻͪͯ
ͳ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
͈;ͽ͸ͳ͵;
ΒͰ
΂ͪ͵
ͺ͹͸;ΌͰ͸
ͳ
ͻͰ΂͸ͳ͵
͹ͯ

ͯͬͪͯͰͼͰͽ
ͳͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͳ
ͼͽ͹ͽͳ͸ͪ͵
ͻͰ΂ͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
͹ͯ
Δͳ΀
ͳͲͬͰͯͰ͸Ͱ
;
͹ͺͼͰ
ͭ;
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͬͰͽ͸͹ͷ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͷ
ͷͰͼͽ;
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͱͰ͸ͳ
͸͹ͬ͹ͭͻ΂͵ͳ

ͻͰ΂͸ͳ͵
͈͹ͻͰͯ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͬͰͲͪ͸ͳ΀
Ͳͪ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒ;
ͫͳΓ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͳΔ
ͼ͵ͳ
ͼͬͰͽ
ͳ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ͹
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͹ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵;

ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻ;
ͪͶͫͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
͵ͪ͵ͬͪ
ΒͰ
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
ͺͻ͹ͭͶͪ΃Ͱ
Δͪ
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
́ͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͯͪͽͪ
ΒͰ
;
͹ͺ΃ͽͳͷ

΁ͻͽͪͷͪ
ͳ
͸ͪ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
͸ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
͹ͫͳ΂͸͹
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
;
Ͱ͸΁ͳ͵Ͷ͹ͺͰ
ͯͳΒͪͷͪ
͋Ͱ͹ͻͳΒͪ
͹
ͳͶͳͻͼ͵͹ͽͻͪ΂͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͻͰ͵Ͷ;
ͳͲ͸ͰͼͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͰͲ
ͫͳͶ͹

͵ͪ͵ͬͰ
Ͳͪͯͻ΃͵Ͱ
ͯ͹͵
ΒͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͪ
ͳͶͳͻͼ͵ͳ΀
ͯͻͱͪͬͳ΁ͪ
ͳ
͉ͳͷͪ

ͯͪͽ
͵ͪ͹
ͯͰ͹
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͫͪ΃ͽͳ͸Ͱ
͈ͻͰͭͶͰͯ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ

͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸
ΒͰ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͼͷͰΔͳͬͪΔͰ
͹ͼͬͪΒͪ΂ͪ
̻͹ͽͪ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͪ

̹;ͭͪͻͪ
͆͹ͻͷͪ͸ͪ
̸͸ͱ;Βͪ΁ͪ
͊ͻͫͪ
͊͵Ͱ͸ͯͰͻͫͰͭ
ͿͰ;ͯͪͶͪ΁
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ

ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
97
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪͷͪ
;ͼͺͰ΃͸͹
ͼ;ͺͻ͹ͽͼͽͪͬΓͪ͹
͇ͼͷͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
΁ͪͻ
ͼͽͬ;
͸ͪͲͬͪ͸
ΒͰ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳͷ
Β;͸ͪ͵͹ͷ
͈͹ͼͶͰ
͹ͺͳͼͪ
ͺͻ͹ͺͪͼͽͳ
ΔͰͭ͹
ͬ͹ͭ
;ͼͽͪ͸͵ͪ

;ͼͶͰͯͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͳ
͸ͪͻͪͬ͸͹

ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͪ
ͰͺͳͲ͹ͯͪ
ͼͪ
̸Ͷͳͺͪ΃͹ͷ
͹ͯ
ͪ͠Δͳ͸Ͱ
̸;ͽ͹ͻ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͻͰ
ͭͶͰͯͪ
͹΂ͳͭͶͰͯ͸͹
͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪ͹
ͻͪͲͯ͹ͫΓͰ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ͹ͯͪ

͸ͳͽͳ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͪΔͰ
͈ͻͳͲͻͰ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͶͳͭͰ
̻͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͰͲͪͬͳͼ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸Ͱ
ͼ;

΀ͻ͹͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
͹ͯ
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪ
͸͹ͬͰ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪ
ͬͰ
͆ͪͷͰͼ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
͈ͻͬ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͺͻ͹ͭͶͪ΃ͰΔͪ
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ
͵Ͱ
ͳ
͸ͪͺ͹ͼͶͰͽ͵;
ͷ͹͸ͪͻ΀ͳΒͰ

̽ͻ;ͭͳ
ͯͰ͹
ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͈ͻͬͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ
ͯͰ͹
͹ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ

ͺ;ͽ
ͯ;ͱ
ͪͶͫͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͫͪͶͰ
ͺ͹͸͹ͬ͹
͹ͯ
ͼͰͬͰͻͪ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
Β;ͭ;
͇ͬ͹ͭ
ͺ;ͽͪ

ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
ͼ;
ͼͬͳ
ͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͳ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
;͵Γ;΂;Β;Εͳ
ͳ
͡Ͱ΃
́ͺͪ͵
ͼͪͷ͹

;
ͬͰͲͳ
ͼͪ
̽ͻͪ΂Ͱͷ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
ͼͰ
;ͺ;΃ͽͪ
;
͹ͺͳͼ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͳ
͵ͪ͹
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽ



%S
3VEPMG
4JFCFS
'ÛISFS
EVSDI
(SJFDIFOMBOE
VOE
"MCBOJFO
OFCTU
FJOFN
LMFJ
OFO
4QSBDIGÛISFS
%FVUDI"MCBOJTDI
BOE
%FVUTDI/FVHSFJDIJTDI
%SFTEFO






́ͼͽ͹



͠Ͱͯͳ͸ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
ͬͶͪͯͪͻ
ͳͲ
Ͷ͹ͲͰ
͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
͊ͽͰͿͪ͸
̽;΃ͪ͸
 ͐Ͱͯ͹ͷͳͻ
̸͸ͽͳΕ

ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͫͪͲͪͻͪ
ͳ
΁ͳͽͪͯͰͶͰ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵
͸ͳͲ͹ͲͰͷͼ͵͹ͷ
͹Ϳͳ΁ͳ
ͻ;
͋͹ͷͼ͹͸;
͋Ͱ͵
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͺͪͱΔͳ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁ͪ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂Ͱ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
;

;͸;ͽͻͪ΃Δ͹ͼͽͳ
͈ͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
͋ͳͻͪ͸ͪ
ͼͪ
ͼͬ͹Βͪ
΂Ͱͽͳͻͳ
΀͹
ͽͰͶͪ
́͸ͽͰͻ͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ
̓͹͸ͽͳ͸Ͱ͸ͽͪͶ
͉͹ͷͪ
ͳ
̻ͻͪ͸ͯ

͈͹ͻͰͯ
Βͪͬ͸ͳ΀

Ͳͭͻͪͯͪ
ͺͪͻͶͪͷͰ͸ͽͪ
ͳ
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͪͶͪͽͰ
ͳ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸͹ͭ
ͷ;ͲͰΒͪ
ͼͪ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂
͵ͳͷ
ͼ͵;Ͷͺͽ;ͻͪͷͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁;
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂Ͱ͸͹
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͫͻ͹Β
͸Ͱ
ͳͼͶͪͷͼ͵Ͱ
ͫ͹ͭ͹ͷ͹ΓͰ
ͷ͹΃ͰΒͰ

͋ͳͻͪ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͰΕ
;
ͽ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͳͷͪͶͪ

ͪͰͻ͹ͯͻ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻͪ͸;
͊ͶͰͯͰΕͰ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂Ͱ͸Ͱ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶͰ
ͼ;

͊͵ͪͯͪͻ
̾Ͷͫͪͼͪ͸
̹Ͱͻͪͽ
͉͹ͭ͹ͱͳ͸ͪ
3PHP[IJOB

ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͳ
ͳͲ
ͬ͹ͻͳ΃ͽͰ
ͻͰ͵Ͱ
͑͵;ͷͫͰ
̀ͪͽͳͷ
ͽ;
ͼ;
̈́;΃Δͪ
̹Ͱͻͪͽ
ͳ
̺ͪͶ͹͸ͪ
ͳ
Δͳ
΀͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͽͳ΂;
ͳͲ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͼͻͰͯΔͰͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ

͋Ͱ͵
͸ͪ
͵ͻͪΒ;
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸ͳ
ͼ;
Β;ͭ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͼͪ
ͼͻͰͯͳ΃ͽͰͷ
;
͚ͳͻ͹͵ͪͼͽͻͳ
ͳ

ͼͰͬͰͻ
ͼͪ
͊͵ͪͯͻ͹ͷ
͆ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͳͲͻͳ΂ͳͽ͹
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽ
ͪͶͳ

ΒͰ
ͳͲͬͰͼ͸͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͻͪͯͳͶ͹
͹
͸ͰͻͰͯ͹ͬ͸͹ͷ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͫ;ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͳͶͳ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͷ͹ͫͳͶ
ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ;
̈́Ͱͽ͹ͬͪͶͳ΃ͽͪ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͯͪ
͸ͳͼ;
͸ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͪ
͹ͼͳͷ

;ͲͭͻͰͯ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͻͰ΂
͹
͹ͫͪͶͳ
͇΀ͻͳͯͼ͵͹ͭ
ΒͰͲͰͻͪ
ͳ
͈͹ͭͻͪͯͰ΁;
͸ͪΒͬͰΕͰͷ

ͭͻͪͯ;
͸ͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹Β
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹Β
͹ͫͪͶͳ

͆ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬͪͷͪ
̺͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͪͺͳͼͪ͸
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͬ͹
ͯͳ΂
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͳ
;
͈ͻͳͻ;΂͸ͳ͵;
͹
͊ͻͰͯΔ͹Β
ͳ
́ͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ

͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸͹ͷ
͸ͪ
Ͱ͸ͭͶͰͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
;
͏ͳͻͳ΀;
Ͳͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸;

͊ͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͪ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͰΕ
͵Ͷͪͼͳ΂͸ͪ
͹ͺ΃ͽͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
ͫ͹
ͭͪͽͼͽͬͳͷͪ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͳ
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͼ;
ͳͼͽ͹ͬͰͽ͸ͳ
́ͺͪ͵
͹ͬ͹ͷ

ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
΀ͻ͹͸͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
͸ͪͺͳͼͪ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸͹

;
ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;
ͼͪ
Ͳͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸ͳͷ
ͬͳΌͰΔͰͷ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
ͪͶͫͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
͹ͯ

ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
ͬͶͪͯͰ
́ͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͺ͹΂ͳΔͰ
ͼ
͵ͻͪΓͰͷ
̸ͻ
ͭ͹͸͹ͷ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ
͸
Ͱ
ͬͶͪͯͪ͹
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸ͳͷ
͹ͫͪͶͪͷͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ

͊ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
͈ͻͳͲͻͰ͸ͼ͵ͪ
Ͷͳͭͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸ͳΒͪ
΀ͻ͹͸͹
Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͪ
͹ͯ
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪ
͸ͰͲͪͬͳͼ͸͹ͼͽͳ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͈͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ;
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹Β
Ͱͽ͸ͳ΂͵͹Β
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͳ
͸ͪ
ͬͰͯͰ͸ͳ
ͼ;
;
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹ͼͽͳ
;
ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;
ͼͪ
Ͳͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸͹ͷ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͼͽͪͽͳͼͽͳ
͵͹ͷ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
͵͹Β͹Β
͹ͼͳͷ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͪ΁ͪ
;
ͲͰͷΓͳ
ͱͳͬͰ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
̺Ͷͪ΀ͪ
ͳ

̻ͻ͵ͪ
΂ͳΒͳ
ΒͰ
ͫͻ͹Β
ͯͪͽ
ͺ͹ͭͻͰ΃͸͹
ͺ͹΃ͽ͹
;
Ͳͫͳͻ;
ͼͪ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸΁ͳͷͪ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ

ͺͻ͹΁Ͱ͸ͪͽ
ͳͲ͸͹ͼͳ
 

̸;ͽ͹ͻ
ΒͰ
Ͳͪͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪ͸
ͳ
Ͳͪ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͺͻ͹
ͺ;ͼͽͳ͹
ͯͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳ
Ͳͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͯͬͪ



́ͼͽ͹



5BZMPS
4%1
)BOECPPL
PG
$FOUSBM
BOE
&BTU
&VSPQF

"
)BOECPPL

BOE
(VJEF
UP
"MCBOJB
"VTUSJB
#VMHBSJB
$[FDIPTMPWBLJB
(SFFDF
)VOHBSZ
-JFDIUFO
TUFJO
1PMBOE
3VNBOJB
5VSLFZ
:VHPTMBWJB
BOE
UP
UIFJS
SFTPVSDFT
ѮF $FOUSBM &VSP
QFBO
5JNFT
1VCMJTIJOH
$P
-UE
;VSJDI

QQ

 ͇ͯ
ͪͶͫͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͫͰͼͺ;Εͪ
ͯ͹
͋ͳͻͪ͸Ͱ 

ͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
;ͬ͹Ͳ
ͺ͹ͻͪͼͽͪ͹
Ͳͪ

ͪ
ͪͶͫͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͳͲͬ͹Ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ

͹ͯ
͹ͼͪͷ
ͺ;ͽͪ
́ͺͪ͵
;ͬ͹Ͳ
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͯͪΓͰ
ͫͳ͹
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͽͻ͹ͼͽͻ;͵͹
ͬͰΕͳ
͹ͯ

ͳͲͬ͹Ͳͪ

̸;ͽ͹ͻ
ΒͰ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒ;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳ͹
͵ͪ͹
ͲͰͷΓ;
͵͹Βͪ
ͫͳ
ͷ͹ͭͶͪ
ͫͳͽͳ

ͳͲͬͪ͸ͻͰͯ͸͹
ͷͰͼͽ͹
Ͳͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
͉ͪͲͶ͹ͭͰ
Ͳͪ
ͽͪ͵ͬ;
͹΁Ͱ͸;
͹͸
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
ͺͻͰ

ͼͬͰͭͪ
;
ͬͰͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͫͻ͹Β;
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬͳ΀
ͳ
ͼͽͪͻͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͳ
ͼͰͶͪ
ͺͻͰͯͳͬ
͸͹ͷ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
͵ͻͪΒ͹Ͷͳ͵;
ͳ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰ
ͼͰ
tͱͳͬ͹ͽ;
ͳͼͺ;ΔͰ͸͹ͷ
ͪͬͪ͸
ͽ;ͻͪͷͪ
ͷͳͽͼ͵͹ͭ
́ͼͽ͹͵ͪi
̓ͪ͹
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬͪ
͹ͯͻͰͯͳ΃ͽͪ
͹͸
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ

̓͹ͻ΂;
ͅ͹ͼ͵͹ͺ͹ͶͰ
͈ͻͰͼͺͪ͸ͼ͵͹
ΒͰͲͰͻ͹
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
;
̾ͺͳͻ;

ͷͰΌ;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͳ
̾ͻͼͰ͵
ͽͬͻΌͪͬͰ
̺ͳΒ;΃;
7JKPTB

ͳ
̓ͰͶͼͳͻ;
,FMDZSB


ͳ
ͻͪͲ͹ͻͰ͸ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
͋ͰͺͰͶͰ͸ͳ
;
͵͹ͷ
ΒͰ

̸Ͷͳͺͪ΃ͪ
ͼͻͰ͹
̹ͪΒͻ͹͸ͪ

͆ͪͻͪͬ͸͹
͸ͪ
ͼͳͻ͹ͷͪ΃͸ͳΒͰͷ
ͼͰͬͰͻ;
ͷ͹ͭͶ͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪΕͳ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͰͭͲ͹ͽͳ͵Ͱ

ͅͳͻͯͳͽͳ
ͼͪ
ͼͬ͹Β͹ͷ
ͽͰ͵
͸Ͱͯͪͬ͸͹
;ͭͪ΃Ͱ͸͹ͷ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ

ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
͵ͪͺͰͽͪ͸͹ͷ
ͳ
t̹ͳͼ͵;ͺ͹ͷ
͹ͯ
͇ͻ͹΃ͪi
΂ͳΒͰ
ͱͰ͸Ͱ
͹ͺͶͪ͵;Β;
͊͵Ͱ͸
ͯͰͻͫͰͭͪ
ͫͳͼ͵;ͺ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͽ΂ͳΔͰ͸
ͼͪͷ͹ͷͰ
ͺͪͺͳ
ͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͪ
΁ͻ͵ͬͳ΁ͪ
ͳͷͪ

ͼͽͪͽ;ͼ
͵ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶͰ
΂ͳ͸ͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͱͳͬͳ
͹ͼͽͪͽͪ͵
ͺ͹Ͳ͸͹ͭ
ͼͻͰͯΔͰͭ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
͈͹ͼͶͰ
ͅͳͻͯͳͽͪ
΂ͳ͸ͳͶ͹
ͼͰ
ͬͻͰͯ͸ͳͷ
͹ͫͳΕͳ
̓ͻ͹Β;
͊ͬ
͠͹ͬͪ͸ͪ

ͅͰͯ͹ͬͼ͵͹ͭ
̹Ͱͻͪͽ
͊ͪ͸ͽͪ
̓ͪͻͪ͸ͽ;
͊ͪͻͪ͸ͯ;

ͳ
̹;ͽͻͳ͸͹
͊ͪ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ
͵͹ͷ
͊ͬ
͠͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
ͅͰͯ͹ͬͼ͵͹ͭ
ͭͯͰ
ΒͰ
ͽͬͻΌͪͬ;
͹ͫ͸͹ͬͳ͹
ͼ;Ͷͽͪ͸
͊ͰͶͳͷ
*

ͼͬͪ
͹ͼͽͪͶͪ
ͷͰͼͽͪ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͪ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ΀

͹ͼͽͪͽͪ͵ͪ
̸;ͽ͹ͻ
ΒͰ
΂ͪ͵
ͫͰͲ
ͳ
ͷͪͶ͹
ͼ;ͷΔͰ
͸ͪͬͰ͹
ͳ
͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
̹;ͽͻͳ͸͹

#VUISPUVN

͹ͼ͸͹ͬͪ͹
ͅͰ͸ͰͶͪΒ
ͼͳ͸
ͽͻ͹Βͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
͵ͻͪΓͪ
͈ͻͳΒͪͷͪ
͆ͪͺ͹
ͼͶͰͽ͵;
ͳͲ͸ͰͼͰ͸ͳ
ͼ;
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
ͬͰΕͳͷ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͋ͳͻͪ͸ͳ

̓͹ͻͳ΁ͳ
͊͵ͪͯͻ;
̾Ͷͫͪͼͪ͸;
̸ͻͭͳͻ͹͵ͪͼͽͻ;
͚ͳͻ͹͵ͪͼͽͻ;

̹Ͱͻͪͽ;
̺ͪ
Ͷ͹͸ͳ
ͳ
̽ͻͪ΂;
ͷͰΌ;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
͹͸ͪΒ
͹
ͺ͹ͻͰ͵Ͷ;
ͳͷͰ͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ

͸ͪͲͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹
͋Ͱ΀Ͱͻͪ͸;

ͳ
Ͱͽ͸ͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬ;
͊͵ͪͯͻͪ
̹;ͯ;Εͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ
΁ͳ
͹ͫͪͬͰ΃ͽͰ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͳ
͹
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ͯͪ
;
͋ͳͻͪ͸ͳ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͯͪ
͵;ͺͰ
΂Ͱͽͳͻͳ
ͯ͸Ͱͬ
͸Ͱ
͸͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͸ͰͯͰΓ͸ͳ͵
ͳͼͽͳ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
ͪͶͫͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͅͰΌ;
΃Ͱͼ͸ͪͰͼͽ

ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΀
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͪͬͪ
;
͋ͳͻͪ͸ͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͼ;
ͯͬͪ
ͫͳ
Ͷͪ
͸ͰͰͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͽ͹
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ͹
̸͊̽
ͳ
ͪ͠ͺͪ͸ͪ
͆ͪͷͰͻ͸ͳ΁ͳ

ͼ;
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͼͳͭ;ͻͪΒ;
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͫ͹ͻͪͬ͵ͪ
;
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͳ
ͪͶͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
;

ͳͽͪͶͳΒͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
͵͹ͷͺͪ͸ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͯ͹͵
ͼ;
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ
͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵;

͵ͪ͸΁ͰͶͪͻͳΒ;
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͪͶͳ
͸ͪ
̸ͬͰ͸ͳΒͳ
̓ͶͰͫͰͻ
;
͈ͪͻͳͲ;
͌
ͳͲͯͪΔͰ
͈ͻͳͻ;΂͸ͳ͵ͪ
Ͳͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸;
͋ͰΒͶ͹ͻ
͸ͳΒͰ
;͸Ͱ͹
͸͹ͬͰ

ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
ΒͰ
ͽ͹ͷ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͼͬͰͭͪ
ͯͰͬͰͽ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΀
ͯͳ
ͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͪͬͪ
ͯ͹͵
ΒͰ
;
ͬͰͲͳ
ͼͪ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ͹ͷ
ͲͰͷΓͰ

ͺͻͳͷͰͽͳ͹
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼ;
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͪ
;ͶͪͭͪΔͪ
͸Ͱ͹ͺ΀͹ͯ͸ͪ
;͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ
ͱͰΓͪ



́ͼͽ͹



́ͼͽ͹



́ͼͽ͹

 ͐Ͱͯ͹ͷͳͻ
̸͸ͽͳΕ

Ͳͪ
ΔͰ͸ͳͷ
͸ͪͺͻͰͽ͵͹ͷ
̽ͪ
ͼͰ
ͲͰͷΓͪ
;
ͷͰΌ;ͬͻͰͷͰ͸;
ͻͪͲͬͳͶͪ
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂ͳ
Ͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͪͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪͶͪ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪ
;

̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͳ
͹͵;ͺΓͰ͸ͪ
;
̸̓͋ͅ
,MVCJ
UVSJTUJL
BVUPNPCJMJTUJL
NCSFUPS


m
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͳ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͷ͹ͫͳͶͼ͵ͳ
͵Ͷ;ͫ
͇ͬ͹ͭͪ
ͺ;ͽͪ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;

͹
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͳ
ͺͻͳͯ͹ͯͪͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
͹ͼͪͷ
΁ͻ͸͹ͫͰͶͳ΀
Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ
́ͲͯͪΔͰ

ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ΒͰ
ͼ
ͷͪΔͳͷ
ͳͲͷͰ͸ͪͷͪ
ͺͻͰ΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸͹
ͽͻͳ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͵ͪ
ͼ͸ͳΒͰ




͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳͶͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸Ͱ

̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͰ
;
ͻͪͲͯ͹ͫΓ;
ͳͲͷͰΌ;

ͳ

ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ΒͰͯ͸;
ͲͰͷΓ;

͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͰ͵
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
ͯͪ
ͫ;ͯͰ
͹ͽ͵ͻͳͬͰ͸ͪ
Ͳͪ
΃ͳͻ;
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵;
Βͪͬ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ

ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁Ͱ
̀ͰͷΓͪ
ͷͳͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳͼͽ͹͵ͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ͸͹
ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͼ͵ͻͪΒ
͸;ͽͪ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ΒͰ
ͺͻͬͳ΀
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͪ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
ͺ͹
ͼͰΕͳͬͪͶͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ;
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
ͼͰͬͰͻ͸ͳ΀
Βͪͯͻͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
Ͷ;͵ͪ
̺Ͱ͸Ͱ΁ͳΒͰ

ͳ
͋ͻͼͽͪ

ͳ
̈́Ͱͬͪ͸ͽͪ
͋Ͱ͵
͹ͯ
ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͪ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸Ͱ
ͪͶͫͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
ͳ

;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬͰ
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͬͰΕͪ͹
ͳ
ͯ͹ͫͳ͹
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ
͸Ͱ
͹ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͬ͹
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ͹
;
ͳ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͼͽͬ;
ͪ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͳ

͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
;
ͲͰͷΓͳ
̀ͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
͸Ͱͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͰΕͰͭ
ͻͰ΂
͸͹ͭ
ͳ
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
;
ͺͻͳͻ;΂͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͼ
͵ͻͪΒͪ
ͽͻͳ
ͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
;͹ͺ΃ͽͰ
͸Ͱ
ͼͺ͹ͷͳΔ;
ͪͬͳ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ
ͷͰΌ;

ͪͶͫͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ
Β͹΃
͹ͯ
͵ͻͪΒͪ
ͯͬͪͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ


ͬͰ͵ͪ
͈͹ͻͰͯ
ͪͬͳ͹͸ͪ
ͼͺ͹ͷͳΔ;
ͼͰ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͫ;ͼͳ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͷ͹ͫͳͶͳ
ͳ
΂ͪ͵
ͷ͹ͽ͹
ͻͳ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼ;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ
ͫͳͶͳ
ͺͻͰͬ͹ͱͰ͸ͳ
́
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͽ͹ͭͪ
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͽ;ͻͳ
Ͳͪͷ
;ͫͻͲͪ͸͹
ͻͪͲͬͳΒͪ͹
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪ
ͳͽͪͶͳΒͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
͹͵;ͺͪ΁ͳΒͰ

ͼͪͷ͹
;ͺ͹ͻͰΌͰΔͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ΀
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
͋ͰΒͶ͹ͻ͹ͬͳ΀
ͺͻͳͻ;΂͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͺ͹͵ͪ
Ͳ;ΒͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͰͺͰ͸͹
ͭ;ͫͳͶͪ
͸ͰͲͪͬͳͼ͸͹ͼͽ
͈͹ͼͶͰ
̽ͻ;ͭ͹ͭ

ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͼͽͪͶͪ
ͯͪ
ͫ;ͯͰ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͪ
ͷͰͽͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ

ͳ
ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͳͲͷͰ͸ͳͶ͹
ͽͰ͵

͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹
ͺͻͬͳ
ͺ;ͽ
;
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷ;
ͺͻͰͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ

Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ͸
ͼͰͭͷͰ͸ͽ
ͫ;ͯ;ΕͰͭ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Βͪ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͰ



5BZMPS
4%1
)BOECPPL
PG
$FOUSBM
BOE
&BTU
&VSPQF

"
)BOECPPL
BOE

(VJEF
UP
"MCBOJB
"VTUSJB
#VMHBSJB
$[FDIPTMPWBLJB
(SFFDF
)VOHBSZ
-JFDIUFOTUFJO
1P
MBOE
3VNBOJB
5VSLFZ
:VHPTMBWJB
BOE
UP
UIFJS
SFTPVSDFT
ѮF $FOUSBM &VSPQFBO 5JNFT
1VCMJTIJOH
$P
-UE
;VSJDI

TUS



͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
͵ͪͻͽͪ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͳͲ

ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
ͲͰͷΓ;
ͼ
ΔͰ͸ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽͰͬͳͷͪ

ͪͰͻ͹ͯͻ͹ͷͳͷͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳͷ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͳ
΂Ͱͽͻ͸ͪͰͼͽ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳ
Βͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
 ͇ͯ
ͪͶͫͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͫͰͼͺ;Εͪ
ͯ͹
͋ͳͻͪ͸Ͱ 

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

ƀFEPNJS
"OUJǀ
"VT
5JSBOB
CJT
JOT
BMCBOJTDIF
XFHMPTF
(FMÅOEF
IJO

%JF
(FTDIJDIUF
"MCBOJFOT
XJF
BVDI
EBT
#JME
"MCBOJFOT
JO
3FJTFGÛISFSO

MÅTTU
TJDI
JO
FJOFN
3BINFO
CFUSBDIUFO
EFS
LÛS[FS
BMT
FJO
+BISIVOEFSU
JTU
*O

EJFTFS
;FJUTQBOOF
EJF
JNNFS
OPDI
OJDIU
XFTFOUMJDI
MÅOHFS
BMT
EJF
-FCFOT[FJU

FJOFT
.FOTDIFO
JTU
XBS
"MCBOJFO
LVS[GSJTUJH
FJO
3FJTF[JFM
GÛS
EFO
PSHBOJTJFSUFO

'SFNEFOWFSLFIS


%JF
3FJTFGÛISFS
EJF
EBT
(FCJFU
EFT
NPEFSOFO
BMCBOJTDIFO
4UBBUFT

[XJTDIFO

VOE

WPSTUFMMFO
[FJHFO
FJO
-BOE
EBT
WPO
EFS
FVSPQÅJTDIFO

¸GGFOUMJDILFJU
VOE
BVTMÅOEJTDIFO
#FTVDIFSO
FSTU
FOUEFDLU
XFSEFO
TPMMUF


%JFTFT
NZUIJTDIF
.PSHFOMBOE
MBH
BCTFJUT
BMMFS
3FJTFXFHF
XFTIBMC
FT

JO
EFO
FSTUFO
+BIS[FIOUFO
EFT
PSHBOJTJFSUFO
5PVSJTNVT
OVS
WPO
3FJTFOEFO

CFTVDIU
XVSEF
EJF
BVT
EFO
BESJBUJTDIFO
/PSEIÅGFO
XJF
7FOFEJH
VOE
5SJFTU
JO

EJF
-FWBOUF
[V
8BTTFS

GVISFO


/BDI
EFS
(SÛOEVOH
EFT
BMCBOTJDIFO
3FJDIFT
VOE
EBNJU
FJOFT
NPEFSOFO

BMCBOJTDIFO
4UBBUFT
HFXBOO
EFS
5PVSJTNVT
JNNFS
NFIS
BO
#FEFVUVOH
VOE

XVSEF
[VHMFJDI
BVDI
JOTUJUVUJPOBMJTJFSU
[VFSTU
EVSDI
EJF
FSTUF
7FSUSFUVOH
JN

"VTMBOE
EBOBDI
BCFS
BVDI
EVSDI
FJOF
UPVSJTUJTDIF
0SHBOJTBUJPO
[VMBOEF
&T
TFJ

IJFS
CFUPOU
EBTT
OFCFO
EFN
JOFYJTUFOUFO
8BTTFS
m
VOE
EFN
&JTFOCBIOWFSLFIS

EFS
JO
EFN
EFS
3FJTFGÛISFSO
JO
EFO
TQÅUFO
%SFJ“JHFSO
LBVN
OPDI
FSXÅIOU

XVSEF
BVDI
EFS
-VGUWFSLFIS
[XJTDIFO
EFO
BMCBOJTDIFO
4UÅEUFO
FJOF
XJDIUJHF

3PMMF
TQJFMUF
EFS
OÅNMJDI
TDIPO
&OEF
EFS
FS
+BISF
EFT

+BISIVOEFSUT

FJOHFGÛISU
XVSEF
/FCFO
'MVH[FVHFO
XVSEFO
BMT
5SBOTQPSUNJUUFM
GÛS
5PVSJTUFO

0NOJCVTTF
"VUPT
VOE
TPHBS
.PUPSSÅEFS
BOHFHFCFO

0CXPIM
EFS
5PVSJTNVT
CJT
[VS
JUBMJFOJTDIFO
0LLVQBUJPO
JN
TDIOFMMFO

8BDITUVN
CFHSJGGFO
JTU
MÅTTU
FJO
7FSHMFJDI
NFISFSFS
"VTHBCFO
EFS
)BOECÛDIFS

WPO
5BZMPS
5BZMPS
4%1
)BOECPPL
PG
$FOUSBM
BOE
&BTU
&VSPQF
"
)BOECPPL

BOE
(VJEF
UP
"MCBOJB
"VTUSJB
#VMHBSJB
$[FDIPTMPWBLJB
(SFFDF
)VOHBSZ

-JFDIUFOTUFJO
1PMBOE
3VNBOJB
5VSLFZ
:VHPTMBWJB
BOE
UP
UIFJS
SFTPVSDFT
ѮF

$FOUSBM
&VSPQFBO
5JNFT
1VCMJTIJOH
$P
-UE
;VSJDI

EFVUMJDI
[FJHFO
EBTT

EBCFJ
EJF
6OBCIÅOHJHLFJU
"MCBOJFOT
4DISJUU
GÛS
4DISJUU
WFSMPSFO
HJOH

/BDI
EFN
[XFJUFO
8FMULSJFH
XBS
"MCBOJFO
GÛS
5PVSJTUFO
LFJO
XJDIUJHFT

3FJTF[JFM
NFIS
;V
FJOFS
8JFEFSCFMFCVOH
EFT
5PVSJTNVT
LBN
FSTU
OBDI
EFN

+BIS

BMT
FS
[VN
FSTUFO
.BM
BMT
CFEFVUFOEFT
4FHNFOU
EFS
LÛOGUJHFO

&OUXJDLMVOH
"MCBOJFOT
FSLBOOU
XVSEF

̺ͪͶͰ͸ͽͳ͸ͪ
̺͇̺̿́̓́ͣ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
̸͊͆͌

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

̸͊̈́́̓
̸̸̻͉̽
̸̸̾͆͢ͅ

͌
̸͇͉̀̾͋̾͊́͡ͅͅ
ћ
͇͇͉̓͋
͌
̸̺͇̽́͐́ͅ

̸̀
͈͌͋͆́̓̾

͋͹͵͹ͷ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
ͷͰΔͪΒ;
ͳͲͭͶͰͯ
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
ͺͻ͹ͺͪͯͪΔͰͷ


ͻͪͽ͸ͳͷ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
ͻͪͲͪͻͪΔͳͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͷ
ͳͲͭͻͪͯ
Δ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͺͻͪΕͰΔͰͷ
ͼͽͳͶͼ͵ͳ΀
ͽ͹͵͹ͬͪ
͌
ͺ͹͵;΃ͪΒͳͷͪ
ͻͰ͵͹͸ͼͽͻ;͵΁ͳΒͰ

ͺͻͬ͹ͫͳͽ͸͹ͭ
ͼͽͪΔͪ
ͳ
;ͽͬͻΌͳͬͪΔͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
͹ͫ͸͹ͬͰ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;
ͻͰ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ΀
ͳ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͺͳͼͪ͸ͪ
ͭͻͪ
Όͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻ
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΔͪ
ͳ
͹ͷ͹ͭ;Εͪͬͪ
ͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪΔͰ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
;

΃ͳͻͳͷ
͹͵ͬͳͻͳͷͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸ͳ΀
ͽ͹͵͹ͬͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
;
͵͹ΒͰͷ

ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
ͯͰ΃ͪͬͪͶͰ
͌
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔ;
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͸Ͱ͵͹ͭ

ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͯͪ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
͸ͳͲ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻ
ͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͹
ͼͽͪΔ;
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΂͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
;
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸͹ͷ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸;
͇ͬ͹ͷ

ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͳ
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΔͪ
ͫͳΕͰ
ͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪ͸ͳ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰ
ͻ;
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͳ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͪ
ͼͪ

͵͹Βͳͷ
ͼͰ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͼ;ͼͻͰͽͪ͹
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
m
;΂ͰͼͽͪͶͳͷ
ͻͪͲ͹ͻ͸ͳͷ

ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼͳͷͪ
͠Ͱͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
΁ͳΓͰͬͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ΒͰͼͽͰ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪ
ͬͪΔͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͪ
ͼͪ
ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶ͸ͳͷ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯ͹ͷ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͌ͺͻͪ
ͬ͹
͹ͬͪ
ͯͳͷͰ͸ͲͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͯͻͪͭ͹΁Ͱ͸ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂ͪ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ

̽ͬͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͺͳͼͪ͸
ͺͻͰ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
;ͫͻͲ͹
͸ͪ͵͹͸
̽ͻ;ͭ͹ͭ

ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͺͻ;ͱͪΒ;
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
ͳͲͭͶͰͯ;
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͺͻͰ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͰͭ

ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͺͻͰ
͹ͫͳͷ͸ͳ΀
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
͵͹Βͪ

ͼ;
ͯ͹͸ͰͶͪ
͸͹ͬͰ
ͳ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
ͳͲ͸Ͱ͸ͪΌ;Β;ΕͰ
ͻͰͲ;ͶͽͪͽͰ
͈ͻͰͷͯͪ
;
ͼͬ͹ͷ
ͻͪͯ;

͹ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͳͼͪ͸ͳ
͵ͪ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽ͹ͬͪΔ;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͪͻ΀ͳͬͼ͵Ͱ
ͭͻͪΌͰ

 ̺ͪͶͰ͸ͽͳ͸ͪ
̿ͳͬ͵͹ͬͳΕ

̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͳ
̹͹͵Ͱ
ͯ͹͸
́ͬ͹
͊ͽΒͰͺ΂ͰͬͳΕ
ͳ
ͯ͹͸
͆ͳ͵͹
̈́;͵͹ͬͳΕ
͹ͺͻ͹ͫͪ
Ͷͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͳ
;
ͺͳͼͪΔ;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
̽͹͸
́ͬ͹
͊ͽΒͰͺ΂ͰͬͳΕ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͺͳͼͪ͹
̺͹Όͪ

ͺ͹
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ;

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͪ
ͯ͹͸
͆ͳ͵͹
̈́;͵͹ͬͳΕ
̹͹͵ͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵ͪ
̓;Ͷ
ͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳͼ͵ͳ
ͬ͹Ό

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̓͹ͷͺͪͻͪ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
;

͹ͬͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͼͪͯͪ΃ΔͰͭ
ͼͽͪΔͪ
;͹΂ͪͬͪΒ;
ͼͰ
ͫͻ͹Β͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
ͪͶͳ

ͳ
͵͹͸ͼͽͪ͸ͽͰ
͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ΒͰ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳΒͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ

͌
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͵ͪͯͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͵ͪ͹
ͯͰͿͳ͸ͳͼͪ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͱͪ͸ͻ
͸ͳ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͪ͹
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬ͸Ͱ
ͰͶͰͷͰ͸ͽͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰͷ͹
͸ͪΕͳ
;
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
͵Δͳ
ͱͰͬ͸ͳͷ
ͯͰͶͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼ;
͵ͪ͹
΁ͳΓ
ͳͷͪͶͪ
ͪͿͳͻͷͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͭͻͪͯͪ
Ͳͪͳ͸ͽͰͻͰ
ͼ͹ͬͪ͸͹Β
ͺ;ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
̀ͪ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͰ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
;
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ

ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸͹ͭ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸ͳ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͳ
ΒͰͼ;
ͯͬͪ
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ
͸ͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
͸ͪͼͽͪͶͪ
;

ͳ

ͬͰ͵;
m
ͻͰ͸Ͱͼͪ͸ͼ͸ͪ
ͺ͹Ͱͷͪ
͇ͺͳͼ
ͲͪͶͳͬͪ
ͳ

ͭͻͪͯͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͺͳͼͪ͸ͪ
ͺͻͰ

ͭ

͵͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͰͼ͸ͳ͵ͪ
́ͬͪ͸ͪ
̹͹͸Ͱ

̹͹Ͷͳ΁Ͱ 
ͳ
ͫͪͻ͹͵͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹
͋ͳͷ͹ͽͰΒͪ
͏ͳͲͳͶͰ
̀Ͷͪͽ͸ͳ
ͬ͹
͹͵͹

ͭ


̺ͪͱ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͳͼͽͪΕͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͯͰͶͪ
͸ͪͼͽͪͶͪ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳͶͳ
ͭͻͪͯ

ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͪ
ͬͶͪͼͽͰͶͪ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹ͷ
͵ͻ;ͭ;
;΂Ͱ͸ͳ΀
Γ;ͯͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
͹͸͹ͷ
;

̺Ͱ͸Ͱ΁ͳΒͳ
̀ͫ͹ͭ
ͽͪ͵ͬͰ
͸ͪͷͰ͸Ͱ
͹ͬͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
ͳͷͪΒ;
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺͽ
ͫͶͳͲͪ͵
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ
͸ͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
̀ͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΂͵ͪ
ͳͷ
ΒͰ
ͳͯͰΒͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪ

ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͰ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ
ͬͳΒͪ
͸ͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳͷ
;Ͷͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͽͻͭ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͏ͳͲͳͶͳ͸Ͱ
ͻͰ΂ͳ
ͳͲ
ͺͻͬͰ
ͺ͹
Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
Ͷͪ͵͹
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͭͶͰ
ͲͪͷͰ͸ͳͽͳ
͸Ͱ͵͹ͷ
ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸ͳ΁͹ͷ
ͳͲ

ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
t͌
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ;
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͰ
ͻ;΃Ͱͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ΀
ͯͳͬ͸ͳ΀

͹΃ͽͰΕͰ͸ͳ΀
ͲͯͪΔͪ
ͳ
ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳ΀
΁ͻ͵ͪͬͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͻͪͲ͸ͳ
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼͳ
ͼͻ;
΃ͳͶͳ
ͳͶͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͺͻ͹ͺͪͶͰ
͹ͯ
ͯ;ͭ͹ͽͻͪΒ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͫ;ͯ;Εͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͬ͹
ͽͶͰ

ͺ͹ͯͶ͹ͱ͸͹
ͳ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͷi

̓ΔͳͱͰͬ͸ͳ
͹ͺ;ͼ
̹͹͸Ͱ
ͳ
͏ͳͲͳͶͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸;
ͽͻͪͯͳ
΁ͳΒ;
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͽͰ
ͼͰ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
ͯͬ͹Βͳ΁Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪ͹΁ͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
ͭͻͪͯͪ

ͯ͹͸
́ͬͪ
͊ͽΒͰͺ΂ͰͬͳΕͪ
ͳ
ͯ͹͸
͆ͳ͵ͪ
̈́;͵͹ͬͳΕͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;
;͹΂ͳͽͳ
͹ͯΒͰ΁ͳ

ͻͰ΂͸ͳ͵
ͳ
ͪͽͷ͹ͼͿͰͻͪ
ͼͽͪͻͳΒͳ΀
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ
͸͹ͭ
͹͵ͻ;ͱͰΔͪ



̹͹͸ͳ͸ͪ
ͺͰͼͷͪ
%FTDSJQUJP
TJOVT
FU
VSCJT
BDSJWFO
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
Ϳͳ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
̺ͰͻͭͳͶͳΒͰͬ͹ͷ
;Ͳ͹ͻ;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͺͻ͹ͱͳͷͪΔͰ
ͻͰͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͳ
͸ͪͯͻͰͪͶ͸͹ͭ

;
͹ͺͳͼ;
̹͹͵Ͱ
ͳ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
͈Ͱͼͷ;
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰͽͳ͹
ͼͬ͹ͷ
;Βͪ͵;
́ͶͳΒͳ
̀ͪͭ;ͻ͹ͬͳΕ;
͵͹Βͳ

ΒͰ
ͳ
ͼͪͷ
ͫͳ͹
ͺͰͼ͸ͳ͵
ͬ
͚
̹ͳͲͪ͸ͽͳ
͡
͈ͪͼ͵ͬͪͶͳΕ
́
̹
̹͹Ͷͳ΁ͪ
̓ΔͳͱͰͬ͸͹ͼͽ

͏ͻ͸Ͱ
̻͹ͻͰ
̻͹ͻͰ
͹ͯ
9**
ͯ͹
9*9
ͬͳΒͰ͵ͪ
ͺͻͳͻͰͯͳ͹
͊
̓ͪͶͰͲͳΕ
͏ͰͽͳΔͰ

m

m



"͸ͪͶͳͼͽͳ
͎ͻ͹͸ͳ΂ͪͻͳ
̹ͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͳ
̓ΔͳͱͰͬ͸͹ͼͽ
͏ͻ͸Ͱ
̻͹ͻͰ
͹ͯ
9**
ͯ͹
9*9

ͬͳΒͰ͵ͪ
ͺͻͳͻͰͯͳ͹
ͅ
ͅͳͶ͹΃ͰͬͳΕ
͏ͰͽͳΔͰ


 ͊Ͷͳ͵ͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͷͰΔͪ͸ͪ
;
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼͳͷͪ 

͈͹ͻͰͯ
͹ͬͳ΀
͸ͪͫͻ͹Βͪ͸ͳ΀
ͯͰͶͪ
ͫͳΕͰ
ͻͰ΂ͳ
ͳ
͹
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹
ͺͳͼͳͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͫ͹ͻͪͬͰΕͳ
;
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ;
;

ͬͰ͵;
ͺͳͼͪͶͳ
́ͽͪͶͳΒͪ͸ͳ

ͅ;΁ͳ͹
͋͹ͷͪͲͳ͸ͳ
̹͹ͽͪ͸ͳ΂͵ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͺ͹
͵͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵͹ͷ
͹͵ͻ;ͭ;
ͳͲͯ

͸ͪ
͸Ͱͷ

ͭ

̹ͪͻͽ͹Ͷ͹ͷͰ͹
̹ΒͪͲ͹ͶͰͽ͹
͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͼͪ͵ͼ͹͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
͵ͻͪ
Γͪ
͍ͻͳͯͻͳ΀ͪ
̸;ͭ;ͼͽͪ
;
͏ͻ͸;
̻͹ͻ;

ͭ

ͳ
̸͸ͽ͹͸ͳ͹
̹ͪͶͯͪ΂ͳ
̹͹
͵ͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵ͪ
ͳ
͏ͻ͸͹ͭ͹ͻ΁ͳ
͌ͽͳͼ΁ͳ
ͼͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͳ
ͲͪͫͳΓͰ΃͵Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ

ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͶ;ͱͰ
Ͳͪ
;ͬ͹ͯ
;
ͿͶ͹ͻ;
͏ͻ͸Ͱ
̻͹ͻͰ
ͳͲ

ͭ

ͺͻͰ͸͹ͼͰ

ͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬͪ
ͳ
ͯͪΒ;
ͲͪͺͪͱͪΔͪ
ͳ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
ͼ;͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͳ

ͫ;ͯ;Εͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͪͷͰͻͪͬͪΒ;
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ
͹ͬͪΒ
͵ͻͪΒ

̓͹͸΁Ͱͺͽ
ͻͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
Ͳͪͷͳ΃ΓͰ͸
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͳͲͯͬ͹ΒͰ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͰ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ
͸Ͱ
ͽͰͷͰ
;
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
ͪ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͯͰͿͳ͸ͳ
ͼͪ͸Ͱ
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͳͻͪΒ;
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸ͳ
͸ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͳ
ͺ͹ͼͷͪͽͻͪͶͳ
ͳ

ͫͰͶͰͱͳͶͳ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸Ͱ
ͿͰ͸͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
͆Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵ͳ
ͳͲͯͬ͹ΒͰ͸ͳ΀
΁Ͱ
Ͷͳ͸ͪ
ͼͰ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
͹ͫͪͬͰͲ͸͹
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
;
ͯͰͶͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͪ
Ͳͪ
ͽͰͷ;
ͳͷͪΒ;
͹ͺͳͼ

̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͳ
̹͹͵Ͱ
͇ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͯͰͶͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͯͻͱͰ
ͼͬͳ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͳ

͹ͬͳ΀
ͯͰͶͪ
ΒͰͼͽͰ
ͺ͹ͯͰͶͪ
͸ͪ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ;
͵͹Βͪ
ͭͪ
͹͵ͻ;ͱ;ΒͰ
͇ͬ͹ͷ

ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
ΕͰ
ͫͳͽͳ
;ͼͷͰͻͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͼͪͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͪ

ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸͹
͹͵ͻ;ͱͰΔͰ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ

ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
;
;ͱͰͷ
ͼͷͳͼͶ;
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;

ͫͳͶͰ
ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶ͸Ͱ
;
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
 ̺ͪͶͰ͸ͽͳ͸ͪ
̿ͳͬ͵͹ͬͳΕ

̀ͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;
͹ͯ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
ͷͰΔͪ͹
ͺͻͳ
ͻ͹ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
͹ͼͽͪͶͪ
͸Ͱͺͻ͹ͷͰΔͰ͸ͪ
͉Ͱ΂͸ͳ͵
͵͹Βͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͳ
ͪ;ͽ͹
ͻͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͰ
Ͳͪ
ͯͰͼ͵ͻͳͺ΁ͳΒ;
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒͪ
̀ͪͶͳͬͪ

ͳ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͺ;͸͹
ͷͰΔͪ͹
͹ͯ
͈͹ͻͿͳͻ͹ͭͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͬ͹ͭ
Ͳͪͺͳͼͪ
ͳͲ


ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͯ͹
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸͹ͭ
ͯ͹ͫͪ
͐Ͱͼͽ͹
΁ͳͽͳͻͪ͸
͹ͺͳͼ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
̓͹͸ͼͽͪ͸ͽͳ͸ͪ

͈͹ͻͿͳͻ͹ͭͰ͸ͳͽͪ
;
%F
BENJOJTUSBOEP
JNQFSJP
ͭͶͪͼͳ
t̻ͻͪͯ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ
Ͳ͸ͪ
΂ͳ
͸ͪ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
͉͹ͷͰΒͪ
ͼ;ͱͰ͸͹
ͳ
ͼͽͳͼ͸;ͽ͹
Ͳͪͽ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͷ͹ͻͰ
;ͶͪͲͳ
͵ͪ͹

;ͼ͵ͳ
ΒͰͲͳ͵
ͯ͹

ͳ

ͷͳΓͪ
ͳ
͸ͪ
͵ͻͪΒ;
ͷ͹ͻͪ
ΒͰ
ͭͻͪͯ
͌͹͵͹Ͷ͹
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͭͻͪ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͬͳͼ͹͵ͪ
ͫͻͯͪ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͼ;͸΁Ͱ
ͬͳͯͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͶͰͽͳ
;
ͺ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͪ
Ͳͳͷͳ

͸ͳ͵ͪͯͪi
̽͹ͱͳͬΓͪΒͳ
ͯ;ͭͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ͲͪͶͳͬͪ
ͼͽͰ΃ΔͰ͸͹ͭ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͹͵͹ͷͳͽͳ΀

ͫͻͯͪ
ͪ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͺ͹ͯ
ͫͻͰͭ͹ͷ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͪ

;ͽͬͻͯͪ
;ͲͯͳͱͰ
͸ͪͯ
Δͳͷ
ͺͻͰͻͪͼͶͳ
ͼ;
;
͹ͺ΃ͽͪ
ͷͰͼͽͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
ͼ;ͼͻͰΕ;

ͳ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
͹
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ΕͰ
ͫͳͽͳ
ͻͰ΂ͳ

̺͹Όͪ
ͺ͹
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ;
ͯ͹͸
́ͬͪ
͊ͽΒͰͺ΂ͰͬͳΕͪ
ͺ͹
͸ͪ;΂͸͹Β
ͬͪͶͳͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ

ͳ
͹ͫͳΓ;
͵͹ͻͳ΃ΕͰ͸Ͱ
ͪͻ΀ͳͬͼ͵Ͱ
ͭͻͪΌͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
͸ͰͲͪ͹ͫͳͶͪͲ͸;
Ͷͳ
ͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻ;
Ͳͪ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂Ͱ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
͌ͷͰ΃͸͹ͼͽ

ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͯͪ
ͺͻͳͶͪͭ͹ͯͳ
͸ͪ;΂͸ͳ
ͷͰͽ͹ͯ
Ͳͪ΀ͽͰͬͳͷͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͹ͭͶͰͯͪ
ͼͰ
;

ͼͺ͹ͼ͹ͫ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͳ
ͼͶ͹ͱͰ͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͰ
ͳͲ
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ

ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͼͬͳͷͪ
͹͸ͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͱͰͶͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒ;
ͼͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ͹ͷ

͆ͪ;΂͸ͳ΂͵ͳ
ͼͰ͸ͲͳͫͳͶͳͽͰͽ
ͳ
ͳͲͻͪͱͰ͸ͳ
͹ͼͰΕͪΒ
Ͳͪ
ͷͰͻ;
;ͼͶ͹ͬͳͶͳ
ͼ;

͵͹ͯ
ͯ͹͸
́ͬͪ
͊ͽΒͰͺ΂ͰͬͳΕͪ
ͬͻͶ͹
ͼ;Ͳͯͻͱͪ͸
ͻͰ΂͸ͳ͵
͵͹Βͳͷ
ͼͰ
͹ͺͳͼ;Β;

ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͰ
̸;ͽ͹ͻ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵;
͹ͫͻͪΕͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵;
͵͹Βͳ
;
ͽ͹
ͬͻͰ
ͷͰ
;
̀ͪͶͳͬ
;ͺͶ͹ͬΓͪͬͪ
ͺͪͻ͹ͫͻ͹ͯ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
͵ͪ͵͹
ΕͰ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͪ
̹͹͵Ͱ

̓͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵Ͱ
t͵ͪ͹
͸Ͱ͵͹ͷ
΂ͪͻ͹ͫ͸͹ͷ
ͼͳͶ͹ͷ
͹ͱͳͬΒͰͽͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ;
ͼ;ͷ͹ͻ͸;

ͯ;΃;i

͈͹
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͳ
ͳ
ͼͽͳͶ;
ͺͳͼͪΔͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽ
͹ͯ
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸͹ͭ
ͬ͹
ͯͳ΂
ͯ͹͸
͆ͳ͵ͪ
̈́;͵͹ͬͳΕͪ
͹ͯͼͶͳ͵ͪͬͪ
͸ͪͷͰͻ;
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͯͪ
͸ͪͺͳ΃Ͱ
ͺͻͳ
ͻ;΂͸ͳ͵
͵͹Βͳ
ͫͳ
ͫͶͳͱͰ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪ͹
ͯ͹ͷͪΕͰ
ͳ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͼͪ
̀ͪͶͳ
ͬ͹ͷ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳͷ
ͻͰͽ͵͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
͊ͽ͹ͭͪ
;
ͺͻͬ͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;

ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
ͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪ
͹ͺ΃ͽͪ
ͺͳͽͪΔͪ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒ;
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ͹
͵Ͷͳͷ;

ͿͶ͹ͻ;
ͳ
Ϳͪ;͸;
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ;

ͪ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͼͳͼͽͰͷͪͽͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸Ͱ

ͺ͹
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͈ͻͳͼͽͻͪͼ͸͹ͼͽ
Ͳͪ
ͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ
͵ͻͪΒ
;͹΂ͪͬͪ
ͼͰ
;
͹ͺͳͼͳͷͪ

ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
;
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͳͷ
ͰͺͳͽͰͽͳͷͪ
t̹͹͵͹͵͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵ͳ

̀ͪͶͳͬ
ͼͪ
̈́͹ͬΕͰ͸͹ͷ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
΂;ͯͰͼ͸͹
ͯΒͰͶ͹
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͰ
͵͹ΒͰͷ;
ΒͰ
ͽͰ
΃͵͹
͸ͪΕͳ
ͻͪͬ͸ͪ
;
ͼͬͳΒͰͽ;i
͈ͻͰͷͪ
ͯ͹͸
͆
̈́;͵͹ͬͳΕ;
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͳ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͳ



̺ͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͳ
Ͳͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ;
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͽ
**

ͺͻͳͻͰͯͳ͹
̹

͍ͰͻΒͪ͸΂ͳΕ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ




*
4UKFQǁFWJǀ
7PDžB
QP
,PUPSV
;
"SIJWTLB
JTUSBßJWBOKB
#PLF
,PUPSTLF
1FSBTU



 ͊Ͷͳ͵ͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͷͰΔͪ͸ͪ
;
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼͳͷͪ 

ͽͰͽͳ
;
͹΁ͰΔͳͬͪΔ;
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͪ
͹΁Ͱ͸ͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
̹͹͵ͪ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ

͸ͪΒͶͰͺ΃ͳ΀
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͪ
;
ͼͬͰͽ;
ͳ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͻ͹ͷͪ͸ͽͳ΂͸ͳΒͳ΀
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͪ
;
͠;
ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
͊ͶͰͯͰ
͹ͺͳͼͳ
ͫͳΓͪ
͹ͫͪͶͰ
΂ͪͻ͹ͫ͸Ͱ
ͷͰͼͰ΂ͳ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳ
͵͹Β͹Β
ͼͰ

t;
ͷ͹ͻ;
͹ͭͶͰͯͪΒ;
͵;ΕͰ
ͺͪͶͪ΂Ͱ
ͳ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ
ͼͪ
Ͳͬ͹͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͺͪ
ͽͳ
ͼͰ
΂ͳ͸ͳ

ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͽ͹
ͽͪΒͪ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸ͳ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬͳ
ͼͳͻͰ͸ͪi
͉Ͱ΂͸ͳ͵
ͼͶͳ΂ͪ͸
ͻͰ͸Ͱͼͪ͸ͼ͸͹ͷ

ͳ
ͫͪͻ͹͵͸͹ͷ
͵ͪ͵ͪͬ
ͼ;
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳͶͳ
́ͬͪ͸
̹͹͸ͪ
ͳ
͋ͳͷ͹ͽͰΒ
͏ͳͲͳͶͪ
͵ͪ
ͯͪ
̹͹͵;
ͳ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ
;ͺ͹ͻͰΌ;Β;
ͼͪ
ͷͳͽ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳͷ
ͫͳΕͳͷͪ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͳͶͳ

ͼͶͪͬ͸ͳͷ
ͳͽͪͶͳΒͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͺͰͼ͸ͳ͵
́ͬͪ͸
̹͹͸ͪ
ͱͰͶͳ
ͯͪ
t͹ͽͰ΂Ͱͼͽͬͪ
ͷ͹ͭ
͹ͺͳ΃Ͱͷ
ͯ͹ͷi

ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
t͸Ͱͫ͹ͯ͹ͽͳ΂͸Ͱ
ͭ͹ͻͰi
;΃Εͪ
ͲͪͶͳͬ
tͼͽΒͰ͸͹ͬͳͽͰ
΃͵ͻͳΓͰi
ͼͽͰ
ΔͰ
͈ͰͬͪΔͰ
͹
̹͹͵ͳ
Ͳͪͺ͹΂ͳΔͰ
ͻͰ΂ͳͷͪ
t͌
ͲͪͼͰͶ͵;
ͯ;ͭ͹ͷ
ΒͰ
ͲͪͶͳͬi

͇ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
ͺͰͼ͸ͳ͵
ͳ
΁ͬͰͽ͸Ͱ
ͯ͹Ͷͳ͸Ͱ
ͯͻͬͰΕͰ
ͺͶ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͬͻͽ͹ͬͰ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͳ
ͱ;
ͳͲͬͪ͸
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳ΀
ͫͰͯͰͷͪ
̺Ͱ͵
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
͋ͳͷ͹ͽͰΒ
͏ͳͲͳͶͪ
͹ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ

͸Ͱ͹ͫͳ΂ͪ͸
͹ͫͶͳ͵
̹͹͵Ͱ
ͻͰ΂ͳͷͪ
t̀ͪͶͳͬ
ͼͰ
ͺͻ;ͱͪ
;
͹ͫͶͳ͵;
ͲͷͳΒͰi

͇΁ͰΔ;ΒͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͪ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
͵ͻͪΒͪ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸͹
ͻͪͲ͸͹ͬͻͼ͸ͪ
t́ͲͭͶͰ
ͯͪͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
͹͸͹
΃ͽ͹
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͪ
ͳͷͪ
ͺ͹ͯͳΒͰΓͰ͸͹
ͳ
ͻͪͼ;ͽ͹
͸ͪ
ͻͪͲ͸ͳͷ

ͷΒͰͼͽͳͷͪ
ͺ͹
ͼͬͳΒͰͽ;
͹ͬͯΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͼͪͱͰͽ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͼΒͪΒ͸͹
ͼͪ͵;ͺΓͰ
͸͹
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸Ͱ
ͫͻͰͱ;Γ΁ͳ
ͯ͹Ͷͳ͸Ͱ
ͶͳͬͪͯͰ
ͺ͹Γͪ
ͺͪ΃Δͪ΁ͳ
ͻͳΒͰ͵Ͱ
ͳͲ
ͬ͹ͻͳ
ͺ͹ͽ͹΁ͳ
ͬͳ͸͹ͭͻͪͯͳ
ͷͪͼͶͳΔͪ΁ͳ
ͷ͹ͻͪ
ͻͳͫͰ
ͺͽͳ΁Ͱ
ͯͳͬΓͪ΂



͆
̈́;͵͹ͬͳΕ
̹͹͵ͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵ͪ
̓;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳͼ͵ͳ
ͬ͹Ό
͏ͰͽͳΔͰ


m


͚
̹ͳͲͪ͸ͽͳ
͡
͈ͪͼ͵ͬͪͶͳΕ
́
̹
̹͹Ͷͳ΁ͪ
m
 ̺ͪͶͰ͸ͽͳ͸ͪ
̿ͳͬ͵͹ͬͳΕ

ͳ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͳΔͰ
ͼͬͳ΀
ͬͻͼͽͪ
;Ͳ
ͼͬͰ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͼͽͬͪͻͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͰ
ͳ

;ͱͳͬͪΔͪ
Γ;ͯͳ
͹ͫͳ΂͸͹
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͪ΂͸͹
ͷ͹ͭ;
͸ͪΕͳ
;
ͻͪͲ͸ͳͷ
ͺ͹͵ͻͪ
Βͳ͸ͪͷͪi
̓ͪͯͪ
͏ͳͲͳͶͪ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͹
;ͽͬͻΌͰΔ;
ͳ
ͫͻͯ;
͊ͬͰͽͳ
́ͬͪ͸
͹͸

ͼͪͼͬͳͷ
;
ͯ;΀;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰΕ;ΒͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͽͬͻΌͪͬͪ
͸ͪ
ͷͰΔͰ͸ͪ
Ͳͪ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽ;
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
͹ͷ͹ͭ;Εͪͬͪ
ͶͰͺ
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯ

́ͲͻͪͲ
͵͹Βͳ
͸Ͱͯͬ͹ͼͷͳͼͶͰ͸͹
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͹
͸ͪͷͰͻͳ
͏ͳͲͳͶͰ
ͯͪ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁ͳͷͪ

ͺͻͰͯ͹΂ͳ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
;ͱͳͬͪΔͪ
;
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ͹͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
ͶͰ
ͺ͹ͽͪͷͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ

́Ͳ;ͲͰͽͪ͸
͹ͺͳͼ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͰ
̹͹͵͹͵͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵͹ͭ
ͲͪͶͳͬͪ
ͯͪΒͰ
ͫ͹ͽͪ͸ͳ΂ͪͻ

ͅ;΁ͳ͹
͋͹ͷͪͲͳ͸ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
;
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ;
ͫ͹ͻͪͬͳ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹
ͼͶ;ͱͫͰ
͸͹Β
ͯ;ͱ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͳΔ;Εͳ
͵ͪ͵͹
Β͹΃
͸ͳ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͫ͹ͽͪ͸ͳ΂ͪͻ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͽͳ
ͭͪ͹
ͯ͹
͹ͬͰ
t͸ͪΒ;ͯͪΓͰ͸ͳΒͰ
ͽͪ΂͵Ͱ
ͪ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰi
͈ͻͰͷͯͪ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ

ͺͻͰͽͰͱ͸͹
͹
ͿͶ͹ͻͳ
͵͹Β;
;ͺ͹ͻͰΌ;ΒͰ
ͼͪ
ͯͪͶͷͪͽͳ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹͸ͪͶͪͲͳ

ͺͻͳΒͪͽ͸ͪ
ͳͲ͸Ͱ͸ͪΌͰΔͪ
Ͳͪͯͻͱͪͬͪ
ͼͰ
;
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͸ͪͬͻͪͽͪ
ͳ
͸ͪ
͹ͺͳͼ
ͲͪͶͳͬͪ

ͳ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
t̓ͪͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͶ͹ͬͳ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͲͪͶͳͬ
̹͹͵Ͱ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳͷ
͵ͻͳ
ͬͳ͸ͪͷͪ
;ͬͳΒͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͹΃ͽͻ͹
͹ͼΒͰ͸΂Ͱ͸ͳ΀
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͪ
͵͹ͯ
ͼͬͪ͵Ͱ
ͼΓͰͯͰΕͰ

͵ͻͳͬͳ͸Ͱ
͹ͽͬͪͻͪ
ͼͰ
͸͹ͬͳ
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯ
ͳ
ͷͳΒͰΔͪ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
ͺͰΒͲͪͱͪ
͈ͻ͹ͯͳͻ;
Εͳ
ͯ;ͫΓͰ
;
Ͷͪͬͳͻͳ͸ͽ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͪ
ͼͬͰ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͼͰ
͹ͼΒͰΕͪ
ͼͽͰͭ͸;ͽ͹ͼͽ
ͯͪ
ͫͳ

ͫͳ͹
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹
ͼͽΒͰ΃ΔͰ͸
͵͹ͯ
ͺͻͳͼͽͪΒͪΔͪ
;
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ;
͵͹Βͳ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
ͼͽͬͪͻ
͸͹ͼͽ
ͽͰ͵
͵ͪͯͪ
ͷ;
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹
ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͳ΃
̻ͻͪͯͳΕ
ͶͰͱͳ
ͼͪ͵ͻͳͬͰ͸
;

ͯ;ͫͳ͸ͳ
ͲͪͶͳͬͪ
;
ͺ͹ͯ͸͹ͱΒ;
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵Ͱ
ͽͬͻΌͪͬͰ
͵͹Βͪ
ͽ;
ͼͽ͹Βͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ

͹ͯͬ͹ΒͳͶͪ
͹ͯ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸Ͱ
͊ͰͯͶ͹
̈́͹ͬΕͰ͸
m
ͺͻͳͷ
ͺͻͰͬ

ͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͪ͵͹
͸ͪ
Ͳͬͪ͸ͪ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͼͬ͹ͭ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͪ
͹ͽͬ͹ͻͰ͸͹ͭ
ͷ͹ͻͪ
ͺ͹ͽͼΒͰΕͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͰͯͶ͹

͊ͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͼͰ
;ͽͳͼͪ͵
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͪ
ͼͽͻ͹ͺ͹΃ͽͪͬͪ
;
ͯ;ͫͳ͸;
ͪ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸Ͱ

ͼͽͳΒͰ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ͹ͼͽͪΒ;
ͯͪ
ͺͻͳΒͰͽͰΕͳ
ͬͳͼͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͯͪ
ΕͰ
ͳ
͹͸Ͱ
;ͼ͵͹ͻ͹
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽͳ

ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͽ͵ͳͯͪΒ;i

͌ͫͻͲ͹
͸ͪ͵͹͸
͋͹ͷͪͲͳ͸ͳΒͰͬ͹ͭ
͹ͺͳͼͪ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
;ͽͳͼ͵Ͱ
͹
̹͹͵ͳ
͹ͫΒͪ
ͬͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
̹ͪͻͽ͹Ͷ͹ͷͰ͹
̹ΒͪͲ͹ͶͰͽ͹
͈͹ͼͰͽͳ͹
ΒͰ
͹ͬͪΒ
͵ͻͪΒ
;
ͺͻͪͽΔͳ
ͼͪ͵
ͼ͹͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
͵ͻͪΓͪ
͍ͻͳͯͻͳ΀ͪ
̸;ͭ;ͼͽͪ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
͸ͪ;͵ͪ

͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
;
ͺͻ͹ͶͰΕͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪ͹
ͺ͹
́ͼͽͻͳ
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͳ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ

͏ͻ͸͹Β
̻͹ͻͳ
ͳ
̹͹͵ͳ
ͻͪͯͳ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͪ
ͫͳΓͪ͵ͪ
ͽͳ΀
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͪ
̓ͻͪΓ
ͺ;
ͽ;ΒͰ
͸͹ͬͳͷ
ͰͶͰͭͪ͸ͽ͸ͳͷ
ͺͪͻ͹ͫͻ͹ͯ͹ͷ
̓͹͸ͽͰ
ͅͳͽͻ͹ͬͼ͵ͳ
ͺͪͻ͹ͫͻ͹ͯ

ͪ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
̈́͹Βͯͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͺ͹ͶͪͲͳ
ͳͲ
͋ͻͼͽͪ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ
;
ͽ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͳ
͵ͪ͹

ͫͻͲͳ
̈́͹Βͯ͹ͬ
ͺͪͻ͹ͫͻ͹ͯ

;
ͺͻͪͽΔͳ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͼͬͳͽͰ
͌Ͷͪͼ͵͹ͷ
;
ͲͪͶͳͬ
̹ΒͪͲ͹



"͸ͪͶͳͼͽͳ
͎ͻ͹͸ͳ΂ͪͻͳ
̹ͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͳ



́ͼͽ͹



.VDJP
5PNB[JOJ
#PUBOJǁLB
QVUPWBOKB
QP
LPUPSTLPN
PLSVHV
JO
$SOB
(PSB

WSBUB
#BMLBOB
1VUPQJTJ
J
[BQJTJ
FWSPQTLJI
CPUBOJǁBSB
FE
7
1VMFWJǀ
%
7JODFL
$FUJOKF



 ͊Ͷͳ͵ͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͷͰΔͪ͸ͪ
;
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼͳͷͪ 

ͶͰͽ͹
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͲͪͶͳͬ
ͬͻͶ͹
ͯ;ͭͪ΂ͪ͵
ͬͳΒ;ͭͪͬ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
΃ͳͻ͹͵
ͺ͹ͺ;ͽ

ͬͰͶͳ͵͹ͭ
ΒͰͲͰͻͪ
͵͹ΒͰͭ
Ͳͪͽͬͪͻͪ
Ͷͪ͸ͪ΁
ͬͳͼ͹͵ͳ΀
͵ͻͰ΂Δͪ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͪ

͇ͫͪͶ;
͹͵ͻ;ͱ;Β;
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹
͹ͫͻͪΌͰ͸ͪ
ͺ͹Γͪ
ͳ
ͫ;Β͸͹
ͻͪͼͽͳΔͰ
͆ͪΒͬͳ΃Ͱ

ͳͷͪ
ͬͳ͸͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͳ
ͷͪͼͶͳΔͪ͵ͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͷ;ͻͬͳ
Ͷ͹ͬ͹ͻͪ
ͼͷ͹͵ͪͬͪ
͵Ͱͯͻͪ

ͳ
͸ͪͻͪ͸Θͳ
t͐ͰͷͺͻͰͼͳ
ͶͳΒͰͺͳ΀
ͺͳͻͪͷͳͯͪͶ͸ͳ΀
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͻͰΌͪ
Β;
ͯͪΒ;
͹ͬͳͷ
ͺͶ͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
ͽͰͻͪͼͪͷ
Β͹΃
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͰͶͰͭͪ͸΁ͳΒͰi
̓ͪͱͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ

ͼ͵͹ͻ͹
ͼͬͪ͵ͳ΀
ͺͰͯͰͼͰͽ
͵͹ͻͪ͵ͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͫͪͶͳ
ͼ;ͼͻͰΕ;
ͶͰͺͰ
ͬͳͶͰ
tͳͶͳ
ͺͻ͹
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͼͪ
΁ͻ͵ͬͪͷͪ
͵ͪͺͰͶͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͪ
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͻͰͿͶͰ͵ͽ͹ͬͪͶ͹

͵ͪ͹
;
͹ͭͶͰͯͪͶ;
;
͹ͫͶͳͱΔ͹Β
ͬ͹ͯͳ
ͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
;
΁ͳΒͰͶ͹ͷ
ͲͪͶͳͬ;
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹

;ͷͳͻͰ͸ͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͽͰ͵
ͼͪͷ͹
͸ͪͷͻͰ΃͵ͪ͸ͪ
͋͹
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͳ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͽ͹ͭͪ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ
Ͷͳͬ
ͼͪ
ͼͬͳ΀
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͪ
Ͳͪͽͬ͹ͻͰ͸
͸ͰͺͻͰ͵ͳͯ͸ͳͷ
Ͷͪ͸΁Ͱͷ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͪ
ͳ
΃ͽ͹

ͼͰ
ͬΒͰͽͪͻ
͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͳͶ͹ͬͳͽ͹
ͻͪͲͬͳͽͳi

͇ͼ͹ͫͰ͸͹ͼͽ
̹͹͵Ͱ
ΒͰͼͽͰ
ΔͰ͸ͪ
͵Ͷͳͷͪ
͵͹Β;
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳ΃Ͱ
͹ͫͳΓͰ
͵ͳ
΃͸ͳ΀
ͯͪ͸ͪ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
΁ͰͶͰ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̀ͪ
͵Ͷͳͷ;
ͯ͹͸
͆ͳ͵͹
̈́;͵͹ͬͳΕ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ

ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͆͹ͬͳ
Ͳͳͷͳ
͸ͪΒͽ͹ͺͶͳΒͳ
;
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
ͼͻͰͯΔͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ΃Δͪ
ΒͰ
‚$
ͪ
;
Βͪ͸;ͪͻ;
‚$

͌ͽͳ΁ͪΒ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵Ͱ
ΒͰ



#BSUPMPNFP
#KB[PMFUP
t1VUPWBOKF
TBLTPOTLPH
LSBMKB
'SJESJIB
"VHVTUB
V

$SOV
(PSV

Hi
;
$SOB
(PSB
WSBUB
#BMLBOB
m
 ̺ͪͶͰ͸ͽͳ͸ͪ
̿ͳͬ͵͹ͬͳΕ

ͬͳͯΓͳͬ
΂ͪ͵
ͳ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͻͰ΂
͹
ͿͶ͹ͻͳ
ͳ
Ϳͪ;͸ͳ
m
ͯͪ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͪ
ͬͶͪͼͽ
;Ͷͪ
ͱͰ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ
͸ͪͺ͹ͻ
;
ͺ͹΃;ͷΓͪͬͪΔ;
ͫ͹͵ͰΓͼ͵ͳ΀
ͭ͹ͶͰͽͳ
̽ͰͽͪΓ͸͹
ͺ͹
ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
ͿͶ͹ͻ;
ͳ
Ϳͪ;͸;
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
͸ͪ
͵ͻͪΒ;
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;͹
ͳ
ͯͪ
;
Ͳͳͯͳ͸ͪͷͪ
4BO

(JPWBOOJKB
ͱͳͬͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸ͪ
ͬͻͼͽͪ
ͺ;ͱͪ
DMBVTJMJB
DBUIBSFOTJT
̀ͪ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͰ

ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂;ΒͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͫͶͪͭͰ
͵ͶͳͷͰ
;
̹͹͵ͳ
ͷ͹ͭ;ΕͰ
ͺͻ͹ͯ;ͱͰ
ΔͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͼͰͲ͹͸Ͱ

͌ͽͳͼ΁ͳ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ΁ͪ
ͼ;
ͫͶͳͱͳ
ͻͰͪͶ͸͹ͼͽͳ
̓ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͫͳ

ͼͰ
ͳ
͹΂Ͱ͵ͳͬͪͶ͹
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸Ͱ
͵Ͷͳͷͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͯͶͳ͵Ͱ
͵ͻͪΒͪ
ͳͲ͸͹ͼͳ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͫ͹
ͽͪ͸ͳ΂ͪͻ
ͅ;΁ͳ͹
͋͹ͷͪͲͳ͸ͳ
t͌
ΓͰͽΔͰͷ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
;
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ;
ͼ;͸΁Ͱ
ͼͰ

ͺ͹ΒͪͬΓ;ΒͰ
͹͵͹

΂ͪͼ͹ͬͪ
;Β;ͽͻ͹
͸ͪ͵͹͸
΃ͽ͹
ͳͲͫͳΒͰ
ͳͲͪ
̈́͹ͬΕͰ͸ͪ
͈͹
ͼͶͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͲͪͶͪͲͳ
ͬͰΕ
͹͵͹

΂ͪͼ͹ͬͪ
ͳͲͪ
ͫͻͯͪ
̺ͻͷͪ΁
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
Ͳͪͺͪ
ͯ;
͹ͯ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͌
ͽ͹͵;
ͯͪ͸ͪ
ͬͶͪͯͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͪ
ͼͺͪͻͳ͸ͪ
͸Ͱ͹΂Ͱ͵ͳͬͪ͸ͪ
Ͳͪ
͹ͬ;

ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵;
΃ͳͻͳ͸;
͸͹
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
;ͼͶ͹ͬΓͰ͸͹
Ͳͪͽͬ͹ͻͰ͸͹΃Ε;
ͲͪͶͳͬͪ
ͼͽͳ
ΒͰ͸ͪͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
͹ͯͫͳΒͪΒ;
ͼ;͸΂ͰͬͰ
Ͳͻͪ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͼͺͻͰ΂ͪͬͪΒ;
ͺͻ͹ͬΒͰͽͻͪͬͪΔͰ
͌

ͳͲͬΒͰͼ͸͹
ͯ͹ͫͪ
ͯͪ͸ͪ
ͽͰͻͷ͹ͷͰͽͪͻ
ͼͰ
ͺͰΔͰ
ͳ
ͯ͹
ͽͰͷͺͰͻͪͽ;ͻͪ
ͬͳ΃ͳ΀
͹ͯ

͹͸ͳ΀
;
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͳ
ͭͯΒͰ
ͼ;
ΓͰͽΔͰ
ͬͻ;Εͳ͸Ͱ
;ͫͶͪͱͪͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͻͼ͵ͳͷ
ͬΒͰ
ͽͻ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
ͼΒͰͬͰͻ͹Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸ͳͷi
̀ͪͺͪͱͪ
ͳ
ͫͻ͹Β͸Ͱ
ͺͪͯͪͬͳ͸Ͱ

ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͶͰͽΔͳ΀
ͷͰͼͰ΁ͳ
ͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
Ͳͳͷͳ
ͺͻͰͽͬͪͻͪΒ;
;
͸ͰͺͻͰ͵ͳͯ͸Ͱ
ͺΓ;
ͼ͵͹ͬͰ
t͐ͰͼͽͰ
ͺͪͯͪͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͳͲ
͹ͫͶͪ͵ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͼ͵;ͺΓͪΒ;
͹͵͹
͹ͫͶͳͱΔͳ΀
ͬͳ
ͼ͹͵ͳ΀
ͬͻ΀͹ͬͪ
ͳͲ͸ͪͯ
̀ͪͶͳͬͪ
ͯͪΒ;
ͬͰͭͰͽͪ΁ͳΒͳ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
͵ͻͪΒͪ
ͼͬΒͰͱͳ͸;
ͪ

͵͹Βͪ
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹
ͳͲ͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
͵͹ͯ
ͿͶ͹ͻͰ
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͰi
͋͹ͷͪͲͳ͸ͳ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂;ΒͰ

t
͌
ͽ͹͵;
ͯͪ͸ͪ
ͬͶͪͯͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͪ
ͼͺͪͻͳ͸ͪ
͸Ͱ͹΂Ͱ͵ͳͬͪ͸ͪ
Ͳͪ
͹ͬ;
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿ
ͼ͵;
΃ͳͻͳ͸;
͸͹
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
;ͼͶ͹ͬΓͰ͸͹
Ͳͪͽͬ͹ͻͰ͸͹΃Ε;
ͲͪͶͳͬͪ
ͼͽͳΒͰ͸ͪͷͪ
͵͹
ΒͰ
͹ͯͫͳΒͪΒ;
ͼ;͸΂ͰͬͰ
Ͳͻͪ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͼͺͻͰ΂ͪͬͪΒ;
ͺͻ͹ͬΒͰͽͻͪͬͪΔͰi

͌
͹ͫͳΓ;
Ϳͪ͸ͽͪͼͽͳ΂͸ͳ΀
ͳ
ͷͳͽ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ΀
͹ͺͳͼͪ
͵͹Βͪ
΂ͳ͸Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪͽͪ͸

ͯͰ͹
#PWF
EPSP
ͳͲͯͬͪΒͪΒ;
ͼͰ
͏ͳͲͳͶͳ͸ͪ
͸Ͱͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸ͪ
ͲͪͺͪͱͪΔͪ
ͺͻͳͻ͹
ͯͰ
ͳ
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵͹ͭ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
͆ͪ
ͽͪ͵ͪͬ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
ͳ
͹
͵Ͷͳͷͪͽͼ͵ͳͷ
;ͼͶ͹
ͬͳͷͪ
͹
Ͳͳͷͼ͵ͳͷ
ͬͰͽͻ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ΒͰ
ͭͻͪͯ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳΕͰ͸
ͫͻͯͳͷͪ
͹

ͽ͹ͷͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
Ͳͳͷͳ
ͷ͹ͻͰ
ͲͪͶͰͯͳ
ΒͰͻ
ͼͰ
ͷͰ΃ͪ
ͼͪ
ͼͶͪͽ͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͪͷͪ
͐ͰͼͽͰ

ͼ;
͵ͳ΃Ͱ
;Ͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͺͶͪͬͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
͸ͳ͵ͪ͵͹
ͯͪ
ͺͻͰͼͽͪ͸;
tͺͪ
ͼͰ

ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
΂ͳ͸ͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͽͳͭͪ͹
͸͹ͬͳ
͹ͺ΃ͽͳ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͺi
̀ͫ͹ͭ
ͬͰͶͳ͵Ͱ

ͬͶͪͱ͸͹ͼͽͳ
;
̀ͪͶͳͬ;
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
΁ͰͶͰ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͼͰ
ͬͳͯͰͽͳ
ͷͪͭͶͰ
͆ͪ͵͹͸
;ͬͳͯͪ
;
ͻͰ΂͸ͳ͵
͵͹Βͳͷ
ͼ;
ͯ͹ͷͪΕͳ
ͳ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͷͪͽͻͪ΂ͳ

͹ͺͳͼͳͬͪͶͳ
͸Ͱ͹ͫͳ΂͸;
ͳ
ͺ͹ͷͪͶ͹
ͼ;ͻ͹ͬ;
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ;
̹͹͵Ͱ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͼͬͻ
͸;ͽͳ
ͳ
͸ͪ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
;
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳ



͆
̈́;͵͹ͬͳΕ
̹͹͵ͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵ͪ



.VDJP
5PNB[JOJ
#PUBOJǁLB
QVUPWBOKB



"͸ͪͶͳͼͽͳ
͎ͻ͹͸ͳ΂ͪͻͳ
̹ͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͳ
m
 ͊Ͷͳ͵ͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͷͰΔͪ͸ͪ
;
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼͳͷͪ 

ͽͳͷ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳͷͪ
͉Ͱ͵͹͸ͼͽͻ;ͳͼͪΔͰ
ͼͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
;
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸͹ͷ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸;

Ͳͪ΀ͽͰͬͪ
ͬͳ΃ͰͼͶ͹Β͸;
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲ;
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͪ
͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ΒͰ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
͆Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ
͵͹
͹ͬͪ͵ͬͳ΀
ͽͰͷͪ
;ͶͪͲͳ
;
ͼͪͼͽͪͬ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹
ͻͳ
͹
ͳͲͭͶͰͯ;
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳͷͪ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽͳͷ
ͭͻͪΌͰͬͳ͸ͪͷͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ

ͪͶͳ
ͳ
͹
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ;
ͽͻͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͻͽͼ͵ͳͷ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳͷ
ͯͰ΃ͪͬͪΔͳͷͪ

́ͲͭͶͰͯ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͫͶͳ͵͹ͬͪ͹
ͯͰͶͳͷͳ΂͸͹
ͼͬͰͼ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪͷͪ
ͺͻͪ
ΕͰΔͰͷ
ͼͽͳͶͼ͵ͳ΀
ͽ͹͵͹ͬͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
͹͸ͳͷ
͸ͪͷͰͽ͸;ͽͳͷ
͸Ͱ͵͹͸ͽͻ͹Ͷͳͼͪ͸ͳͷ

ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
͸͹ͼͰ
ͼͪ
ͼ͹ͫ͹ͷ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
͵ͪͽͪͼͽͻ͹ͿͰ
m
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼͳ

ͳ
ͺ͹ͱͪͻͳ
̓ͪ͹
ͳͲͻͪͲ
ͽͪ͵ͬ͹ͭ
ͽ͹͵ͪ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
;
ͭͻͪͯ;
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
͸Ͱ͹
ͫͳ΂͸ͪ
ͼͳͷͫͳ͹Ͳͪ
ͼͽͳͶ͹ͬͪ
ͳ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳΒͪ
͵͹ͻͳ΃ΕͰΔͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳ΀

ͼͺ͹ͶͳΒͪ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ͹͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͼ͵;Ͷͺͽ;ͻͰ
ͳ
ͭͻͪΌͰͬͳ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
͵ͪͷͰ͸ͪ
ͼͪ
ͻͪͲͻ;
΃Ͱ͸ͳ΀
ͲͯͪΔͪ
͈͹ͼͶͰͯΔͳ
ͻͪͲ͹ͻ͸ͳ
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;ͼͶ͹ͬͳ͹

ΒͰ
͹ͫͳͷ͸ͪ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼ;
ͳͲ͸ͰͶͪ
͸ͪ
ͬͳͯͰͶ͹
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͫͻ͹Β
ͯ͹
ͽͪͯͪ

͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹ͭ
Ͳͳͯ͸͹ͭ
ͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͼͽͬͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵͹

ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ͹͸
ͼ͵Ͱ
΁ͰͶͳ͸Ͱ
̽ͬͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͊ͽΒͰͺ΂ͰͬͳΕͪ
ͳ
̈́;͵͹ͬͳΕͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
͸ͪͷ

ͼͶͳ͵;
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͺͻͰ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͰ
͹ͫ͸͹ͬͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͺͻͰ
ͳ
͸ͪ͵͹͸
̽ͻ;ͭ͹ͭ

ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ

̽͹͸
́ͬ͹
͊ͽΒͰͺ΂ͰͬͳΕ
ͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹
ͯͰͶͳ͹
ͺ͹
ͺ͹ͯ͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬͳͷͪ
̻Ͷͪͬ͸ͪ
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͪ
ͬͻͪͽͪ
͋ͻͭ
͹ͫͪͶͰ
͵ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶͪ

͊ͬ
͋ͻͳͺ;͸ͪ
͉ͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻ
͵ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶͰ
̹͹͵ͰΓͼ͵ͪ
ͷ͹ͻ͸ͪͻͳ΁ͪ
ͼͪͻ͵͹Ϳͪͭ

̸͸ͯͻͳΒͰ
͊ͪͻͪ΁Ͱ͸ͳͼͪ
̻;ͻͯͳΕ
΁ͻ͵ͬͪ
͊ͬ
͠͹ͼͳͺͪ
͊ͬ
̸͸ͪ
̓͹ͶͰΌͪͽͪ

ͺ;ͽ
͸ͪ
ͽͬͻΌͪͬ;
͊ͬ
́ͬͪ͸ͪ
͏ͻ͸͹ͭ͹ͻͼ͵ͳ
ͺͪͲͪͻ
΁ͻ͵ͬͪ
͊ͬ
͆ͳ͵͹ͶͰ
͊ͬ

̈́;͵ͪ
ͅ;ͲͰΒ
΁ͻ͵ͬͪ
͊ͬ
̓ͶͪͻͰ
͈͹ͭͶͪͬͪͻͼͽͬ͹
ͼͻͰͼ͵͹
Ͳͭͻͪͯͪ
̽ͻͱͪͬ͸Ͱ

ͺ͹Ͷͳ΁ͳΒͰ
͵ͪͽ͹Ͷͳ΂͵͹
ͯͰ΂ΒͰ
ͼΒͰͷͰ͸ͳ΃ͽͰ
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵͹
ͽͻͭ͹ͬͳ΃ͽͰ
͸ͪ
͹ͫͪ
Ͷͳ
͇ͯͪͫͳͻ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͺͻͪͬΓͰ͸
ͯͪ
ͼͶͳ͵ͪ
͹
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͫ;ͯͰ

ͼͪͱͰͽͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͽͳͬ͸ͪ
͈ͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸͹
ͳͲͶͪͱͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ
ͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
͹ͺͳͼͪ
;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
;͹΂ͪͬͪ
͸ͪΒͬͪ
ͱ͸ͳΒͰ
ͯͰͽͪΓͰ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ
ͳ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
ͼͪͯͻͱͰ
͹ͫͳΓͰ
Ͷͪͽͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀

͸ͪͽͺͳͼͪ
ͳ
ͳͲͬ͹ͯͪ
ͳͲ
ͪͻ΀ͳͬͼ͵Ͱ
ͭͻͪΌͰ
ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
͹ͬͰ
͹ͼ͹ͫͳ͸Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͺͻͪ
ͽͰ
΁ͰͶ͹͵;ͺ͸͹
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹
͸ͪ;΂͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͼ;
;ͼͷͰͻͰ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ

ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵͹ͭͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ
͵ͻͳͬ;ͯͪͬͳͷ
;Ͷͳ΁ͪͷͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;Εͳ

ͷ;
ͼͪ΂;ͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͯͰͶͳΕͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
̓ͪ͵͹
ͽ͹
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ
ͳͶ;ͼͽͻ;ΒͰ
ͯͰ͹

ͳͲ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
t̓ͪͯ
ΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
͹ͼͽͪͬͳ͹
ͶͪΌ;
ͳ
;ͺ;ͽͳ͹
ͼͰ
͹ͫͪͶ͹ͷ
͹ͼͽͪ
ͬΓͪΒ;Εͳ
͸ͪ
ͶͳΒͰͬ͹Β
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ
ͫͳͬ΃Ͱ
ͫͻ͹ͯ͹ͭͻͪͯͳͶͳ΃ͽͰ
ͳ
͹ͺΕͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ

ͺͰͻͳͬ͹Β
ͼ
ͬͻͶ͹
;ͯ͹ͫ͸͹ͷ
͵ͪͬͪ͸͹ͷ
̽͹Βͷͳ
͵͹Βͪ
ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͳͷͪ
ͼͶ;ͱͳ
Ͳͪ

͹ͯͷ͹ͻ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͭ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͲͪͫͪͬͰ
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͳ
ͯ͹
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳ΀
ͬͻͪͽͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼ;
Ͳͳͯͪ͸ͪ

ͭ͹ͯ

Ͳͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͺͻ͹ͬͳͯ;ͻͪ
̹Ͱͻ͸ͪͻͯͪ
͉Ͱ͸ͳͰͻ
͸ͪ
͵͹ΒͰͭ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ

ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͸ͪ
ͼͶ͹ͬͪ
#
3i
̓͹ͯ
͊ͽΒͰͺ΂ͰͬͳΕͪ
ͼ;
͹ͺͳͼ
ͯͪͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͳ
ͼͽͳͶͼ͵͹



*
4UKFQǁFWJǀ
7PDžB
QP
,PUPSV

 ̺ͪͶͰ͸ͽͳ͸ͪ
̿ͳͬ͵͹ͬͳΕ

͹ͯͻͰΌͳͬͪΔͰ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͸ͪͼͽͪͶͳ
ͺͻͰ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͰͭ
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼͪ
ͽͰ
ͼͰ
;

ͷ͸͹ͭͳͷ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;Β;
͹ͯ
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃ΔͰͭ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ
ͳͲͷͰΔͰ͸͹ͭ

͸͹ͬͳΒͳͷ
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΔͰͷ
̻͹ͬ͹ͻͰΕͳ
͹
͵ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶͳ
͊ͬͰͽ͹ͭ
͋ͻͳͺ;͸ͪ
͊ͽΒͰͺ΂Ͱ
ͬͳΕ
ͳͲ͸͹ͼͳ
ͫͻ͹Β͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
;
ͼͪͱͰͽ͹Β
ͳ
Βͪͼ͸͹Β
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳ
͵͹Βͳ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͰ

ͳ
Ͳͪͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪ͸ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͳͷͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͳ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂ͳͷͪ
ͼͽͪͻͳ͸ͪ

̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
̀ͪͯͻͱͪͬͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͻͰ͵͹͸ͼͽͻ;͵΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
̓ͪͽͰ
ͯͻͪͶͪ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬͰͶͪ
͸ͪ͵͹͸
ͯͬͪ
ͻͪͲ͹ͻ͸ͪ
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼͪ
;
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ


ͳ
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
́ͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
͸ͪΒͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͳͲͬͻ΃Ͱ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
̓ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶͳ

͸ͪ͵͹͸
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;͵Ͷ͹ΔͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
͵;ͺ͹Ͷͪ
ͯ͹͵
ͼ;


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͼͻ;΃Ͱ͸ͳ
Ͳͬ͹͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹΂ͰΓͰ
ͽͰ
ͼ;
;
͹ͫ͸͹ͬͳ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
;ͼͶͰͯͳ
Ͷͪ
ͳͲͭͻͪΌͰ͸ͳ
̽ͪ͸ͪ΃Δͳ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯ
̓ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶͰ
ΒͰ
ͻͰ͵͹͸ͼͽͻ;͵΁ͳΒͪ
͸ͪ͵͹͸

ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͰͭ
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͹ͯͻͪͱͪͬͪ
͸͹ͬͳΒͪ
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΔͪ
͸ͪ
ͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͻͰ΂
͹
;͸;ͽͻͪ΃Δ͹ͼͽͳ
ͫ;ͯ;Εͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͽͻͫ;΃Βͳͷͪ

Ͷ;͵͹ͬͪ
͹ͽ͵ͻͳͬͰ͸ͳ
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳ
ͿͻͰͼ͵͹
ͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͼͽͬͪ
ͳͲ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͪ
ͼͪ
ͿͻͰͼͪ
͵ͪ
;
ͭͶͪͬ͸͹Β
͹Ͷͽͪͻͼ͵͹Β
ͪͺͼͳͯͳ
͹ͯ
ͻͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ΀
ͼ͵ͳ͸;ͽ
ΒͰ
ͷͪͶͽͰͻ

͵͹Βͳ
ͳ΀
ΒͰ
ͯ;ͭ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͼ͵ͻͳͬͪ͹


͆ͪ
ͼͶͳ΂ͪ͸
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
͵ͪ͹
́ͬͪ͸
̹͹͸ͪ
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸͹ͷ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
͊ͽΒͰͺ΂Ͱ
ͬͳΕ
͹Ͷͪ͵΃ͪͬͪ
ͼ͸ͪͶͪͱͰΔͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
;
ͭͻͪͯ;
͆ͪͫͻͪΒͪ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͳ

΁ͻ͵ͬͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͰ
;
;Ͷͳ΁ͳ
ͳͲ͸ͪͯ
̓ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶͰ
͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹

Ͳͪͯͻͱͪͬͪ
͸ͪ
΁ͻ͵ͬͳ
͊ͬͰͽ͹ͭ
͈ͪͬͶͪ
ͪ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͯ͹
̓͹ͶͰΌͪͽͰ

t̓ͻͰ͸Ͱ
Ͷͳ
ͺͪ͵
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
ͼΒͰͬͰͻ͸ͳͷ
ͼͷΒͰͻ͹ͷ
ͳͲ
;Ͷͳ΁Ͱ
Ͳͪ
΁ͻ͵ͬ͹ͷ
͊ͬ

͋ͻͳͺ;͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹΃ͪͬ΃ͳ
ͺ͹͵ͻͪΒ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͽͪͷ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͯ͹Εͳ
ΕͰ
ͯ͹
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ

ͼͬ
͠͹ͼͳͺͪ
ͼͪͭͻͪΌͰ͸Ͱ
ͭ͹ͯ

;Ͳ
΁ͻ͵ͬ;
͊ͬ
̓ͻͳͱͪi
̓ͪ͵͹
;Ͷͳ΁;

͵͹Βͪ
͹ͯ
̓ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ
͵ͪ
̻;ͻͯͳΕ;
ͳ
ͯͪΓͰ
͵ͪ
̓͹ͶͰΌͪͽͳ
́ͬͪ͸
̹͹͸ͪ
;

ͺͰͼͷͳ
ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͪͬͪ
͹͸ͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͳͼ;
ͬͳͯͰͶͳ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ
t̽ͬͳΒͰ
ͼ;
΁ͰͼͽͰ

͹ͯ
ͽͻͭͪ
ͺͪ
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
͵ͪ
̻;ͻͯ;
ͬ͹ͯͳi
ͪ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͯͪΓͰ
t͊͵ͻͰ͸ͳ
͹
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ
΂Ͱ
ͺ;ͽ
ͳ
ͺͻͪͭ
ͪͺ͹ͼͽ͹Ͷ
ΕͰ
ͽͳ
͈ͪͬͶͰ
;
΁ͻ͵ͬͳ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͯͪͼͽͻͰ
ͼͬ͹Β͹Β
ͺͻͬͳ

͵ͪ͸ͯͪ
͹ͯ
ͼͬͳΒͰ΀
̹Ͱ͸Ͱͯͳ͵ͽ
͹ͯ
͆;ͻͼͳΒͰ
ͼͶͳΒͰͯͳ
ͪ
ͯ͹
ΔͰͭ
ͺͻͬͳ
͵ͻͳͱ

͸͹ͬ͹ͭͪ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͪ
ͼͬͰͽ͹ͼͽ
͹ͽͬͪͻͪ
ͱͰ͸ͼ͵͹ͭͪ
ͽ;i

͌
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
ͯ͹͸
͆ͳ͵ͪ
̈́;͵͹ͬͳΕͪ
ͼͬͪ͵ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͳ
͸ͪͼͰΓͰ
;
̹͹͵ͳ
ͺ͹
ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͼ;
͹ͫͻͪΌͰ͸ͳ
ͼͪ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬͳ΃ͽͪ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
̓ͪͯͪ

ͺͳ΃Ͱ
͹
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ;
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͸ͪͫͻͪΒͪ
ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽͰ
̓͹
ͽ͹ͻͪ͸Ͱ
͈͹ͼͶͰͻͪͽ͸ͳ
ͯ;΀
Βͪͼ͸͹
ͼͰ
;͹΂ͪͬͪ
͵ͪͯͪ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͹
͵͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵͹ͷ

ͫͳͼ͵;ͺ;
͍ͻͪ͸;
͌ΕͰͶͳ͸ͳΒ;m͋ͳ΁ͳ
tͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳͷ
ͳ
΀;ͷͪ͸ͳ



́ͼͽ͹



͚
̹ͳͲͪ͸ͽͳ
͡
͈ͪͼ͵ͬͪͶͳΕ
́
̹
̹͹Ͷͳ΁ͪ

 ͊Ͷͳ͵ͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͷͰΔͪ͸ͪ
;
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼͳͷͪ 

ͽͪͻ͸ͳͷ
ͻͪͯ͹ͷ
͹ͼ͹ͫͳͽ͹

ͲͪͶͪͭͪΔͰͷ
Ͳͪ
ͫͻͪͽͼͽͬ͹
ͳ

ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬ͹
ͳ
ͬΒͰͻͼ͵;
ͽͻͺͰ
Γͳͬ͹ͼͽ
ͬͰͲͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͳͷͰ

Ͳͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ
͸ͪ
ͬΒͰ΂ͳͽͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͸ͪi
͈͹ͷͳΔ;Εͳ

ͺͻͰͺͶͳ
ͽͪΔͰ
;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͼͽͳͶ͹ͬͪ

͸ͪ
ͼͪ΂;ͬͪ͸ͳͷ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͷͪ
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
t̸
ͯͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͽͻͪ
ͯͪ͹
͹ͯ
ͺ͹ͱͪͻͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͼͪ

ͫͳ͹
ͫͳ
ͻͳΒͰͯͪ͵
ͺͻͳͷΒͰͻ

ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬΒͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹ͭ
ͭͻͪͯͪi

̈́;͵͹ͬͳΕ
;
ͬͻͶ͹
͵ͻͪͽ͵ͳͷ

΁ͻͽͪͷͪ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ

ͯͰͼͳͶͰ
͸ͪ͵͹͸
ͯͬͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͪ

ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼͪ
;

ͳ

ͬͰ
͵;
͸Ͱ
ͲͪͯͻͱͪͬͪΒ;Εͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ

ͯͰͽͪΓͳͷͪ
͆Ͱ
Ͳͪͫ͹ͻͪͬΓͪ

͸ͪ
ͱͳͬ;
ͼͶͳ͵;
͵͹Β;
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
ͻͰ΂ͳ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͯͪ
ͳͲͪͲ͹ͬ;
͵͹ͯ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁ͪ
ͽͰ
ͳͼ
ͽͳ΂Ͱ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͺͻ͹΂ͰΓͰ
̓ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶͰ
tͼͪ
ͲͪͶͰΌͰͷ
ͯͳͬΓͰ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͰ
͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪ

͸ͪ
ͭͶͰͯͪ͹΁ͪ
͸ͰͲͪͫ͹ͻͪͬͪ͸
;ͽͳͼͪ͵i
͇ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
͸ͪΒͬͰΕͰ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͪ

Ͳͪ
̻͹ͼͺ;
͹ͯ
ͲͯͻͪͬΓͪ
;
ͫͻͯ;
͊ͬͰͽͳ
́ͬͪ͸
͵ͪͱͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
tͼͻͰͯͳ΃͸ͪ
ͰͼͽͰͽ
ͼ͵ͪ
ͽͪ΂͵ͪ
;ͽͬͻΌͰ͸͹ͭͪ
ͫͻͳΒͰͭͪ
͹ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
ͺ;΁ͪ
ͬͪ͸ͻͰͯͪ͸
ͬͳͯͳ͵
͸ͪ
ͽͻ͹
;ͭͶͪͼͽͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͳ
ͫͪͲͰ͸i
͈ͻͰͷͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳͷ
ͻͰ΂ͳͷͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ
ͳͷͪ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷ

ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸͹
;ͽͬͻΌͰΔͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͪ
t͸ͪΒͬͰΕͪ
ͪͽͻͪ͵΁ͳΒͪi

̓ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ͹
ͺͻͰ
͹ͫͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͪ
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼͪ
;

ͳ


ͬͰ͵;
ͺͻͰͯ͹΂ͪͬͪΒ;
́ͬͪ͸
̹͹͸ͪ
̹͹Ͷͳ΁ͪ
΃ͰͽͪΒ;Εͳ
;Ͷͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͺͻͰ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͪ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͳ
͋ͳͷ͹ͽͰΒ
͏ͳͲͳͶͪ
΂ͳΒͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂Ͱ
͹
ͺͻ͹
ͷͰ͸ͪͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
;ͼͶͰͯͳͶͰ
͸ͪ͵͹͸
͹ͬͰ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͪͶͳ
ͺͻͰ
ͬͰͶͳ͵͹ͭ
ͲͰͷΓ͹
ͽͻͰͼͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

̹͹͸ͪ
͸ͪͫͻͪΒͪ
;
ͼͬ͹ͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔ;
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͷ͸͹ͭͰ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;

ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͳ
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼͳ
;͸ͳ΃ͽͳͶͳ
ͽͰ
ΒͰ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
΂Ͱ
ͼͽ͹
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ
ͽͻͪͭ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬͳ
ͷͰͼͽ͹
ͭͯͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͹͸Ͱ
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͰ



͆
̈́;͵͹ͬͳΕ
̹͹͵ͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵ͪ
m


́ͼͽ͹



́ͼͽ͹



 ̺ͪͶͰ͸ͽͳ͸ͪ
̿ͳͬ͵͹ͬͳΕ

̓ͪͯͪ
͹ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
ͼͪͷ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͳ
ͬͪͱ͸Ͱ
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸Ͱ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ

ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͰ
͹
;ͼͽͻ͹Βͼͽͬ;
ͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸;
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
ͳ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͪ
͊ͽ͹
ͭͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͬͪ
ͺͰͼͷͪ
ͬͪͱͪ͸
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸ͳ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻ
Ͳͪ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͳ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
̹͹Ͷͳ΁ͪ
ͬͻͶ͹
ͼͶͳ͵͹ͬͳͽ͹
ͺͻͰͯ
ͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͯͰͬ͹Β͵Ͱ
;
ͻͪͼͺͻͪͬͳ
͵͹Βͪ
ΕͰ
ͺͻͬͪ
ͯͪ
Ͳͪ΀ͬͪͽͳ
ͬ͹ͯ;
ͳͲ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͪ

͸ͪ
͈;΂;
ͳͶͳ
ͺ͹ͬ͹ͻ͵;
ͫͰͻͪ΂ͪ
ͺͶ͹ͯ͹ͬͪ
͌
ͭͻͪͯ
ͼͰ
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸͹
ͯ͹ͬ͹ͲͰ

ͬͳ͸͹
ͳ
ͱͳͽͪͻͳ΁Ͱ
ͯ͹͵
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͬͳͼ͹͵͹ͷ
ͺͪͶͪͽ͹ͷ
ͼͪͼͽͪΒ;
ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳ
Γ;
ͯͳ
ͯͪ
ͷͰͻͰ
͸ͪ
ͼ;ͯͼ͵͹Β
ͬͪͭͳ
͸Ͱ͵͹
Ͳ͹ͬͰ
ͪͯͬ͹͵ͪͽͪ
͸Ͱ͵͹
ͭͶͪͼ͸͹
ͺͻ͹ͽͳ
ͬ;ͻͰ΂ͳ
͋ͪͯͪ
ͼ;
;
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ;
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪͶͰ
ͫͻ͹Β͸Ͱ
ͻͪͯΔͰ
ͼ
ͻ͹ͫ͹ͷ
ͳͲ
ͯͪͶͰ
͵ͳ΀
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͪ
͇ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͽͻͭ;
ͼͪͼͽͪΒ;
ͯͪ
;ͭ͹ͬͪͻͪΒ;
ͽͻͭ͹ͬͪ΂͵Ͱ

ͺ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͯͰͶͳ
ͺͻͪͬͯͪ
͊ͶͰͯͳ
ͯͰͽͪΓͪ͸
͹ͺͳͼ
ͼͪͷ͹ͭ
ͭͻͪͯͪ

Ͳͳͯͳ͸ͪ
ͺͪͶͪͽͪ
ͳ
΁ͻ͵ͪͬͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
;͸;ͽͻͪ΃Δ͹ͼͽͳ
̓ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶͰ
͊
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͷͯͪ
͸ͪͼͽͪ͹
͵ͪ͹
ͺͻ͹ͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͰ
ͺ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΁Ͱ

̹͹Ͷͳ΁ͪ
#PWF
EPSP
ΒͰͼͽͰ
ͳ
͸Ͱ͵ͪ
ͬͻͼͽͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ
͈͹ͼͷͪ
ͽͻͪ͸ͳ
ͼͪ
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃ΔͰͭ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬͳ΃ͽͪ
͏ͳͲͳͶͳ͸ͳ
ͳͲͻͪͲͳ
ͳ
ͻͰ΂͸ͳ͵
ͺ͹ͬͻͰ
ͷͰ͸͹
ͺ͹ͼͽͪΒ;
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
t͌͸;ͽͪͻ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͰ
ͼͰ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ

ͶͳΒͰͺͰ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰi
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
;ͼͶͰͯͳͶ͹
;͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͰ͸͹
ͺͻͰͽͰͻͳͬͪΔͰ
͵ͪ
͵͹
ͼͰ
ͻͰͬ͸͹ͼͽ
;
͹ͫͪͬΓͪΔ;
ͼͶ;ͱͫͳ
;
Δͳͷͪ
͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
͸ͪΕͳ
;
΁ͰͶ͹Β
̽ͪͶ
ͷͪ΁ͳΒͳ
͌
ͯ;΀;
ͼͷͰΔͳͬͪΔͪ
ͻͰͪͶͳͼͽͳ΂͸ͳ΀
͹ͺͳͼͪ
ͳ
Ϳͪ͸ͽͪͲͳΒͰ
΃ͽ͹

ΒͰ
͹ͯͶͳ͵ͪ
΁ͰͶ͹͵;ͺ͸͹ͭ
#PWF
EPSP
͏ͳͲͳͶͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͳ
̓ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶ;
ͽͰ

͵ͪͱͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼ;
ΔͰ͸ͳ
Ͳͬ͹͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͬͳ΃ͳ
͹ͯ
͹͸ͳ΀
͸ͪ
΁ͻ͵ͬͳ
4BO
'SBODFTDP

EFMMB
7JHOB
;
̺Ͱ͸Ͱ΁ͳΒͳ
̻͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͹
ͼͬͰ΂ͪ͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͶͪͬͰ
ͼͬͰͽ͹ͭ
͋ͻͳ
ͺ;͸ͪ
ͳ
ͼͬͰͽ͹ͭ
ͪͅͻ͵ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͹
ͼͪΒͷ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͹ͯͻͱͪͬͪͶͳ
ͺͻͰͯ

̓ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶ͹ͷ
͆Ͱ͵ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
ͼ;
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸͹
ͬͪͱ͸ͳ
ͼͪ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬͳ΃ͽͪ
͸ͪ;΂
͸Ͱ
͵ͻͳͽͳ͵Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
;
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ;
͵ͪͯͪ
͏ͳͲͳͶͪ
ͺͳ΃Ͱ
͹
΁ͻ͵ͬͳ
͊ͬͰͽͰ
ͪͅͻͳΒͰ

̓͹ͶͰΌͪͽͰ
ͻͰ͵ͪͬ΃ͳ
͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
ͺͻͬͪ
ͼͪͭͻͪΌͰ͸ͪ
΁ͻ͵ͬͪ
;
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ;
ͳ
͵ͪ͹

ͺ͹ͽͬͻͯ;
ͯ͹͸͹ͼͳ
ͽͲͬ
̸͸ͯͻͰͪ΁ͳΒͰͬ;
ͺ͹ͬͰΓ;
͹
ͳͲͭͻͪͯΔͳ
͹ͬͰ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ

ͽͰ
ͼͷͪͽͻͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
ͫͳ͹
ͺͻͬͳ
ͫͰ͸Ͱͯͳ͵ͽͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ
̺ͰͶͳ͵;
ͺͪ
ͱΔ;
͏ͳͲͳͶͪ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕ;ΒͰ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ;
ͺͶͰͷͼͽͬͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
̹͹Ͷͳ΁ͪ
ͽͰ
ͺͳ΃Ͱ

͹
Δͳ΀͹ͬͳͷ
ͺͪͶͪͽͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͬͳͶͪͷͪ
̀ͪͺͪͱͪ
͵ͪ͵͹
;
ͭͻͪͯ;
ͳͷͪ
ͶͰͺͳ΀
͵;Εͪ

ͳ
ͺͪͶͪͽͪ
͹ͯ
ͫͰͶ͹ͭ
͵ͪͷͰ͸ͪ
΂ͳΒͳ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͯ͹ͬͳ
;
ͼ͹ͫͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͯͬ͹ͻͳ΃ͽͳͷͪ

ͺ͹͵ͻͳͬͪΒ;
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹
;ͭͶͪ΂ͪ͸ͳͷ
ͫͰͶͳͷ
ͳ
΁ͻͬͰ͸ͳͷ
͵ͪͷͰ͸ͳͷ
ͺͶ͹΂ͪͷͪ

͈Ͱͻ΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
Ͳͪͬͳͼͳ
͹ͯ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀

ͷ͹ͯͰͶͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͺͻͳ΀ͬͪΕͰ͸ͳ
;
ͯͪͽ͹ͷ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
͹ͯ

ͺ͹ͻͰ͵Ͷͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͳ
ͼͬͻ΀Ͱ
ͫͰͶͰͱͰΔͪ
;ͽͳͼͪ͵ͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͺ;
ͽ͹ͺͳͼͳͷͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ͸ͪ
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
΂ͳͽͪΒ;
΀ͬͪͶ͹ͼͺͰͬͳ
͹
ͭͻͪͯ;
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳͷ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͹
͹ͯͰΕͳ
ͳ
ͺ͹͸ͪ΃ͪΔ;
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ



"͸ͪͶͳͼͽͳ
͎ͻ͹͸ͳ΂ͪͻͳ
̹ͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͳ


́ͼͽ͹
m
 ͊Ͷͳ͵ͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͷͰΔͪ͸ͪ
;
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼͳͷͪ 

͸ͳ͵ͪ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͳͷ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ͸ͳͷ

͸ͪͬͳ͵ͪͷͪ
͹
ͳͲͭͶͰͯ;
ͳ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽ
ͼͽͬ;
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͰ
͵͹Βͪ
͹͵ͻ;ͱ;
ΒͰ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ
͊ͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ

ͼͽͻͪ͸΁ͳ
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
́ͽͪͶͳΒͪ
͸ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͪͬͻͪΕͪΒ;
ͺ͹
͸Ͱ͵͹ͷ

ͺ͹ͼͶ;
;
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͼ;
͵ͻͳ
ͽͳ΂͸ͳΒͳ
͌ͽͳ΁ͪΒ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
;
͵͹ΒͰͷ

ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͸ͪͼͽͪΒ;
͸ͪΒΒͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͰ

;͹΂ͪͬͪ
;
͹ͯͪͫͳͻ;
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ
ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͪ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹
͵ͶͪΔͪ
ͬͰΕͪ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͺͻͰ
ͷͪ
΁ͰͶ͹͵;ͺ͸͹ͷ
ͯ;΀;
;
͵͹ΒͰͷ

ΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͺͳͼͪ͸
̽͹͸
͆ͳ͵͹

̈́;͵͹ͬͳΕ

ͭ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ

ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͯͰ΃ͪ
ͬͪΔͪ
͸ͪΒͬͰΕͳ
ͯͰ͹
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕ;ΒͰ

͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹͹ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯͳͶͪ΂͵͹Β
ͫ͹ͻͫͳ
̓ͪͯͪ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͹
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ;
ͺͻͰ
ͷͪ
ͺ͹ͺͳͼ;
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;
̹͹͵ͳ
ͱͳͬͳ

ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;

ͺ͹
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹Β
ͺͻͳͺͪͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͏ͻ͸͹ͭ͹ͻ΁ͳ
͊ͻͫͳ
ͳ
͎ͻͬͪͽͳ
ͪ
ͺ͹
ͬͰͻ
ͼ͵͹Β

ͼ;
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬ͸ͳ
ͪ

͵ͪͽ͹Ͷͳ΁ͳ
̺ͻͰͷͰ
;
͵͹ΒͰͷ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͺͳͼͪ͸

͹ͯͻͪͱͪͬͪ
ͼͰ
;
͵͹͸ͼͽͪͽͪ΁ͳΒͳ
ͯͪ
tΒͰͯ͸ͳ
ͼ
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷͪ
ͱͳͬͰ
;
ͺͻͳͷΒͰͻ͸͹ͷ

ͫͻͪͽͼͽͬ;
ͳ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬ;i

͆Ͱ΃ͽ͹
ͻͪ͸ͳΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̾Ͷͳ͹
ͅͳΓ͹ͻͳ͸ͳ
ͳͲͯͪΒͰ
;
́ͽͪͶͳ
Βͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͏ͻ͸;
̻͹ͻ;
́Ͳͯͪͽ
ΒͰ
;
͹͵ͬͳͻ;
Ͱͯͳ΁ͳΒͰ
1BFTJ
EBUUVBMJUÆ

$PMMBOB
EJ
NPOPHSBGJF
HFPHSBGJDIF
;
͹͵ͬͳͻ;
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸͹
΃Ͱ
ͼ͸ͪͰͼͽ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͰ
͹ͯ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹ͭ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ
Ͳͪ
ͽͪͯͪ΃Δ;
́ͽͪͶͳ
Β;
͊ͳͻͳΒͪ
̾ͭͳͺͪͽ
͋;͸ͳͼ
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
̓͹ͻͲͳ͵ͪ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͪ
͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ

̓Ͱ͸ͳΒͪ
͌͵ͻͪΒͳ͸ͪ
͊;ͯͪ͸
ͪ͠ͺͪ͸

ͅͳΓ͹ͻͳ͸ͳ
ͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪ
͏ͻ͸;
̻͹ͻ;

ͼͪ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬͳ΃ͽͪ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
ͳ
͸ͪͲͳͬͪ
ͅ͹͸ͽͰ͸Ͱͭͻ͹
ͬͪͱ͸ͳ΀

ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͯͰ΃ͪͬͪΔͪ
ͿͳͲͳ΂͵ͳ΀
͹ͼ͹ͫͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ͹
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵;
ͼͳͽ;ͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͻͰͭͳΒͰ
ͳ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
́ͼͽͳ
΂Ͱ
͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͬͰ͵͹ͬͪ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͼͰͽͳ
ͫͶͪͭ͹ͻ͹ͯͪ͸
΁ͳͬͳͶͳ
Ͳͪ΁ͳΒͼ͵ͳ
;ͽͳ΁ͪΒ
́ͽͪͶͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
̺Ͱ͸Ͱ΁ͳΒͰ
ͼͪ
͵͹Β͹ͷ
ΒͰ
͏ͻ͸ͪ
̻͹ͻͪ

ͳͷͪͶͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
͈͹΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ
;

ͽ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͫͳ͹
ͪ͸Ͱ͵ͽͳͻͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
́ͽͪͶͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͼͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
;ͲͭͻͰͯ

ͅͳͭͶͳ͹ͻͳ͸ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
͸ͪ
͵͹͸
ͅ;ͼ͹Ͷͳ͸ͳΒͪ
ͽͰ
ͼͰ
;
ͽ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͏ͻ͸ͪ
̻͹ͻͪ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂ͳ
ͼͪ
MB
QSPWJODJB

 ̺ͪͶͰ͸ͽͳ͸ͪ
̿ͳͬ͵͹ͬͳΕ

JUBMJBOB
EJ
$BUUBSP
͆ͪΒͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͭͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ;Β;
ͺ;ͽͰͬͳ
͵͹Βͪ
ͷͰͼͽͪ
ͼͺͪΒͪΒ;

͵͹Ͷͳ͵Ͱ
ͼ;
ͯ;ͱͳ͸Ͱ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͪ
;ͯͪΓͰ͸͹ͼͽ
͹ͯ
ͬͰΕͳ΀
ͷͰͼͽͪ
m
ͽͪ͵͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ

ͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
;ͽͳͼͪ͵
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
Ͳͪ
͹͵;ͺͪ΁ͳΒ;
͋ͪ͵͹

ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͺ;ͽ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ
m
͌Ͷ΁ͳΔ
;
ͯ;ͱͳ͸ͳ
͹ͯ

͵ͷ
͹ͯ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ
͸͹ͭ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ
Ͳͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
ΒͰͻ
ͳͯͰ
ͯ;ͱ
ͻͳͬͳΒͰͻͰ
͋ͪ͵͹ΌͰ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ
m
͏Ͱ
ͽͳΔͰ

͵ͷ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͸ͪͺͻͪͬͳͶͳ
̸;ͼͽͳΒͪ͸΁ͳ
m
͊ͪ
ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳͷ

ͼͰͻͺͰ͸ͽͳ͸ͪͷͪ
ͯ;ͱ
ͫͻͯͪ
ͬͳͼ͹͵͹ͭ

ͷ
̓ͪͱͰ
ͯͪ
͸ͪ͵͹͸
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͯ͹Ͷͪ
Ͳͳ
ͯ;ͱ
͹ͫͪͶͰ
̹;ͯͬͪ
ͼͪ

ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
VOB
DJUUBEJOB
EJ
UJQP

WFOF[JBOP

̓ͪ͵͹
ͼ;
͸Ͱ͵ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳ
ͺͻͰͻͪͼͶͳ
ͬͻͶ͹
ͫͻͲ͹
͹ͯ
Δͳ
΀͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͯͰ΃ͪͬͪΔͪ
;
ͶͰͭͰ͸ͯ;
͸ͪΒͫ͹ΓͰ
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂ͳ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
͹ͯͫͻͪ͸Ͱ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ

͹ͯ
͸ͪͺͪͯͪ
͎ͪΒͻ;ͯͳ͸ͪ
̹ͪͻͫͪͻ͹ͼͰ
;
ͺͻͬ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
͈ͻͳͷͰͻ

ΒͰ
ͬͻͶ͹
ͼͶͳ͵͹ͬͳͽ
ΒͰͻ
ͼͰ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹
ͫͰͶͰͱͰΔͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͺͻͪͽͳͽͳ
͹ͯ
ͱͳͬ͹ͭ

ͼͰΕͪΔͪ
́ͬͪ͸ͪ
̹͹͸Ͱ
̹͹Ͷͳ΁Ͱ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
͏ͳͲͳͶͰ
ͯ͹
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͳͲ


ͬͰ͵ͪ
͇ͯͫͻͪ͸ͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹ͭ͹ͯͳͶͪ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͼͰͬͰͻ͸ͳͷ
ͬͻͪͽͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͫͰͯͰͷͳͷͪ

ͺ͹ͼͽͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͯͰ͹
ͶͰͭͰ͸ͯͰ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͺͻͳ΂ͪͬͪ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
ͳͲͭͻͪͯ
ΔͰ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
͵͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵Ͱ
;ͽͬͻͯͰ

́Ͳ;ͲͰͽ͸͹
ͬͰ΃ͽ͹
;
ͼͪͱͰͽ͹Β
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳ
ͯ͹͸
́ͬ͹
͊ͽΒͰͺ΂ͰͬͳΕ
ͯ͹͸͹
ͼͳ
͸ͪΒͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
ͳͲ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸Ͱ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ

;ͬͻͼͽͳͬ΃ͳ
ͷͰΌ;
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͰ
ͯ͹ͯ;΃Ͱ
;
ΒͰͯ͸͹Β
ͻͰ
΂Ͱ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͳ
͸ͪͺͪͯ
͎ͪΒͻ;ͯͳ͸ͪ
̹ͪͻͫͪͻ͹ͼͰ

ͭ
tΒͪ͵ͳͷ
ͫͻ͹ͯ͹ͬΓͰͷi

̽͹͸
͆
̈́;͵͹ͬͳΕ
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͼͰͬͰͻ͸ͪ
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͪ
ͬͻͪͽͪ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵
͹ͯͫͻͪ
͸Ͱ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͺͻ͹ͽͳͬ
ͿͶ͹ͽͰ
͎ͪΒͻ;ͯͳ͸͹ͬͰ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͺͶ͹ͬͳͶͪ
ͯ͹
Δͳ΀

͊ͬͰͯ͹΂ͪ͸ͼͽͬ͹
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͺͳͼ΁ͳ

ͳ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͳͼͽͳ΁ͪͶͳ
ͳ
͹ͺͰ
ͬͪͶͳ
;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
ͳͲ
ͺͻͬͰ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪ
Βͪ͸
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒ
ͬͻͰͯͪ͸
ͼͰΕͪΔͪ
̓ͪ͵͹
ͼ;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͊ͽΒͰͺ΂ͰͬͳΕͪ
ͳ
̈́;͵͹ͬͳΕͪ
͹ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͳͼͪ͸ͳ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
ͳ
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ

;
;ͱͰͷ
ͼͷͳͼͶ;
ͼ;
ͬͻͶ͹
͹ͼ͵;ͯ͸Ͱ
͆Ͱͯ͹ͼͽͪͽͪ͵
͹ͬͪ͵ͬͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ

ͼͬͰͯ͹΂ͳ
ͳ
͹
ͻͰͪͶ͸͹Β
ͼͳͽ;ͪ΁ͳΒͳ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪͶͪ
;
ͽ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪͬͪ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͪ΂ͳΒͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
͹ͯ
ͯͪ͸ͪ
΃ΔͰͭ
͇ͫ͸͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹΂ͰͶ͹
ͼͰ
ͼͪ

͹ͲͫͳΓ͸ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͪͶͳ

ͳ
ͼͬͳ΀
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
ͬͳͯ͹ͬͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
͌
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͺͳͼͪΔͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ

͊ͽΒͰͺ΂ͰͬͳΕͪ
ͳ
̈́;͵͹ͬͳΕͪ
ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
;
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͪ
ͳͽͪͶͳΒͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀

ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ΁ͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͳ
;ͭ͹ͼͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͪ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͳͲ


&MJP
.JHMJPSJOJ
*M
.POUFOFHSP
1BFTJ
EBUUVBMJUÆ

3PNB



*
4UKFQǁFWJǀ
7PDžB
QP
,PUPSV



͆
̈́;͵͹ͬͳΕ
̹͹͵ͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵B

 ͊Ͷͳ͵ͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͷͰΔͪ͸ͪ
;
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼͳͷͪ 

ͭͶͰͯͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͽ͸͹
ͯͻ;ͭͪ΂ͳΒͰ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͯ͹͸
́ͬ͹
͊ͽΒͰͺ΂ͰͬͳΕ
ͯͪΒͰ
ͼͺͳͼͪ͵

;ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͯͪ
ͫ;ͯ;
͹ͯ
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂͸Ͱ
ͬͪͱ͸͹ͼͽͳ
Ͳͪ
ͻͪͲ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͰ
ͽͳ͹΁Ͱ
΃͵͹ͶͰ
ͺ͹ͷ͹ͻͼ͵ͪ
ͪ͵ͪͯͰͷͳΒͪ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͪ
ͫͪ͸͵Ͱ
ͳ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ
͸͹
ͬͪͱ͸͹
Ͳͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
m
ͺͪͻ͹ͫͻ͹ͯͼ͵͹
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬ͹
̹͹͵ͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ;ΒͰ

ͺͶ͹ͬͳͯͫͰ
ͲͪͶͳͬ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͪͭͰ͸΁ͳΒͰ
tͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͶ͹ͬͳͯͫͰi

t̽;ͫͻ͹ͬͪ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͶ͹ͬͳͯͫͰi
ͳ
ͳͽͪͶͳΒͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ
t1VHMJBi
͌
͹͵ͬͳͻ;
ͶͰͭͰ͸ͯͰ

ͷͪͺͰ
͸ͪͫͻͪΒͪ
ͳ
΂Ͱͽͳͻͳ
΀͹ͽͰͶͪ
̸͵ͽ;ͰͶ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͵͹ΒͰ

͊ͽΒͰͺ΂ͰͬͳΕ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
m
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͯ͹ͫͳ͹
ͳͲ
̻ͻͫΓͪ
ͺͳΒ;Ε;
ͬ͹ͯ;


ͭ
ͪ
ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻͳ΂͸;
ͻͪͼͬͰͽ;

ͭ
̺͹ͯͳ΂
ͯ͹͸
́ͬͪ
͊ͽΒͰͺ΂ͰͬͳΕͪ
ͼͪͯͻͱͳ

ͼͬͰ
΃ͽ͹
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͯ͹ͫͪͻ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͯͪ
ͳͷͪ
ͽͰ
ͼͽ͹ͭͪ
͸ͪ
͵ͻͪΒ;
΂ͳͽͪͷ͹
t͆ͪ

ͻͪͼͽͪ͸͵;
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΂Ͱ
ͱͰͶͰΕͳ
ͽͳ
ͼͻͰͽͪ͸
ͺ͹ͬͻͪͽͪ͵
;
ͽͬ͹Β;
͹ͽͪΘͫͳ͸;

ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;ΒͰͷ
ͽͳ
ͯͪ
;ͺ;ͽͳ΃
ͽͬ͹ΒͰ
ͺͻͳΒͪͽͰΓͰ
ͳ
ͯͪ
͹͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͼΒͰͽͰ
͹ͬͪΒ

͵ͻͪΒ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͪ
ͪ
ͳ
Γ;ͯͼ͵ͪ
ͻ;͵ͪ
m
ͫͪͻͰͷ
;
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
m
ͽͪ͵͹

ͫ͹ͭͪͽ͹
͹ͫͯͪͻͳͶͪi
͆ͳ͵͹
̈́;͵͹ͬͳΕ
Β͹΃
ͷͪΔͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͹
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂͸ͳͷ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͷͪ
ͽͰ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒͰ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁Ͱ
ͼͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹΃Ε;
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͳͲͶͰͽͪ
ͳͲ
̓͹
ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͫ;ͼͳͷͪ
ͷ͹ͽ͹ͻ͸ͳͷ
ͶͪΌͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͺͪͻ͹ͫͻ͹ͯͳͷͪ
ͺ͹
͹͵͹Ͷͳ͸ͳ

̓ͪ͵͹
ͼ;
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪͶͰ
͵ͪͿͪ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͭ͹ͼͽͳ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
;
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ;
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ


ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂Ͱ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸ͳ
͹ͺͳͼͳ
̸͸ͽ͹͸ͳΒͪ
̹ͪͶͯͪ΂ͳΒͪ
tͅ͸͹ͭͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ

ͳͶͳ
ͺͳͼ΁ͳ
ͳͲ͸͹ͼͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ;
ͱͳͬͳ
Ͷ͹΃Ͱ
ͳͲ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͻͪͲͶ͹ͭͪ

͋ͪͷ͹
ͳͷͪ
ͷͪͶ͹
ͭ͹ͼͽͳ͹͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͳ
Ͷ͹͵ͪ͸ͯͳi
̀ͪͽͳͷ
;
ͯ;΀;
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ΃Δͳ΀

ͺͻ͹ͺͳͼͪ
͵ͪ͵ͬͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪͶͳ
͹ͯ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ
;΃ͪ͹
;
ͼͪ
ͼͽͪͬ
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
̺Ͱ͸Ͱ΁ͳΒͰ

ͬͰ͵;
̹ͪͶͯͪ΂ͳ
ͯ͹ͯͪΒͰ
t͌͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͷ
Ͳͪ
͸ͪ
ͻ͹ͯ
ΒͰ
ͫ͹ΓͰ
͹ͬͪ͵͹
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
Ͳͪ
͏ͻ͸;
̻͹ͻ;
ΒͰͻ
ͫͳ
ͼͪ
ͬͳ͸͹ͷ
ͳ
ͺͳΕͳͷͪ

ͫͳͶ͹
ͼͽͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͼ;͵͹ͫͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͬͻͰͯͪi
͇ͺͳͼ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸͹ͭ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
;
͵ͪͿͪ͸ͳ
t́ͲͷͰΌ;
ͫ;Β͸ͳ΀
ͫͳΓͪ͵ͪ

ͳ
ͺͰΔͪ΂ͳ΁ͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͻͪΒ;
ͫͪ΃ͽ;
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͯͳͬͪ͸
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͺ͹͵ͻͳͬͪΒ;

ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
Ͳͳͯ͹ͬͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ
͸Ͱ͵ͪ
ͬͻͼͽͪ
͵ͪͿͪ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͺͳͬ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͭͯΒͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ

ͼ͵ͻ͹ͷ͸͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ΒͰͯͰ
ͳ
ͺͳΒͰ
͌ͬͰ΂Ͱ
ͼͰ
ͽ;
͹͵;ͺͳ
΁ͳ͹
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸ͳ
ͼͶ͹Β

ͪ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͬ͹Β͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͼͪ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͳͷ
͹Ϳͳ΁ͳͻͳͷͪ
ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͳ
ͳ
͹͸͹
ͷͪͶ͹

ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸͹ͭ
͵ͻͰͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰͭ
ͳͷͪ
ͭͻͪͯ
͑Ͱͽͪ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͻͼ͵͹ͷ
ͻͳͬ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͷͪ
ͽͻͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͪ
͸ͪ͵Ͷͪͺͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͶͰ΃Ͱ
ͼͬͳͻͪ
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͼͬͪ͵ͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͻͪͲͭͪ
Γ;ΒͰ
ͯ;΃ͪ
͌
͹ͬ͹Β
ͺͻͪͼͽͪͻ͹Β
Ͷ;΁ͳ
ͼͬͳ
ͼ;
ͫͻͪΕͪ
ͳ
Βͪ
ͼͪͷ
ͼͰ
ͽ;
ͯͳͬ͸͹

͹ͼΒͰΕͪ͹i
͈͹ͭͶͰͯͪΒͷ͹
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͳ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͼ͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͳ
Ͳͪ



*
4UKFQǁFWJǀ
7PDžB
QP
,PUPSV



́ͼͽ͹



͆
̈́;͵͹ͬͳΕ
̹͹͵ͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵B



"OUPOJP
#BMEBǁJ
t#PLB
,PUPSTLB
J
$SOPHPSDJ
6UJTDJ
TB
QVUPWBOKB
J
[BCJMKFØLF

LPKF
USFCB
EB
QPTMVßF
[B
VWPE
V
GMPSV
$SOF
(PSFi
;
$SOB
(PSB
WSBUB
#BMLBOB

 ̺ͪͶͰ͸ͽͳ͸ͪ
̿ͳͬ͵͹ͬͳΕ

ͺͻͰ͸͹Εͳ΃Ͱ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̓ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
̹ͪͶͯͪ΂ͳ
ͺ͹
ͼͬ͹ͷ
ͯ͹Ͷͪͼ͵;
;
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ

͹ͯͶ;΂ͳ͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͯͷ͹ͻͳ
ΒͰͻ
ͼͰ
ͼͺ;΃ͽͪͶͪ
͸͹Ε
ͼͪͲ͸ͪ͹
ΒͰ
tͯͪ

;
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ;
͸Ͱͷͪ
ͼ͹ͫͪ
͵ͪ͹
͵͹ͯ
͸ͪͼi
ͬͰΕ
ΒͰ
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
ͯͪ
͸ͪΌͰ
ͺͻͳͬͪͽ͸ͳ

ͼͷͰ΃ͽͪΒ
̓ͪ͵͹
ͼ;
;
ͽ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪͶͰ
ͭ͹ͼͽͳ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͳͲͬͪ͸
Ͳͳͯͳ͸ͪ
̓͹
ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰͯ͹΂ͳ
ͯͰͽͪΓͪ͸
͹ͺͳͼ
;ͱͪͼ͸;ͽ͹ͭ
̹ͪͶͯͪ΂ͳΒͪ
͵͹Βͳ

ͼͰ
ͼͺͻͰͷͪ͹
ͯͪ
ͳͲ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
͵ͻͰ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ
Ͳͪ
̹;ͯͬ;
́Ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͭ
͵ͪͲͳ
ͬͪΔͪ
͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͰ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂ͳͽͳ
͹
͵͹ͷ
ͷͰͼͽ;
ͼͰ
ͽͪ΂͸͹
ͻͪͯͳ
͹ͼͳͷ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ

͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
;
͸Ͱͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸͹Β
ͫͶͳͲͳ͸ͳ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸͹
͸ͰͭͯͰ
͵ͻͪΒ
̻;ͻͯͳ
Εͪ
tͷͪͶͳ
ͽͻͭ
ͳͲͬͪ͸
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͭͯΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
͸Ͱ͵ͪ
ͬͻͼͽͪ
ͭ͹ͼͽͳ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͪ

΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
Ͳͪͺͻͪͬ͹
ͫͳ͹
ͼͪͷ͹
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͵;ΕͰͻͪ͵i
͈ͻͰͷͪ
̹ͪͶͯͪ΂ͳΒ;
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ

t͹ͯͬͻͪͽ͸ͪ
ͭ͹ͼͽͳ͹͸ͳ΁ͪi
ͪ
;
ΒͰͯ͸͹Β
ͼ͹ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͼͺͪͬͪͶ͹
tͺ͹
͹ͼͷ͹ͻ͹
͸ͪ

ͼͷͻͯΓͳͷ
͵ͻͰͬͰͽͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͳ
ͻͪͼͺ͹ͻͰΌͰ͸ͳ
͸ͪ
ͼͽͻͪ΃ͪ͸
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸

͇ͼ͹ͫͰ
ͼͪ
ͯ͸ͪ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸͹ͭ
ͼͶ͹Βͪ
ͫͶͪͱͰ͸͹
ͼ;
ͼͺͪͬͪͶͰ
;
ͽ͹ͷ
Ό;ͫͻͳ΃ͽ;

́ͼ͵ͻͰ͸͹
ͯͪ
͵ͪͱͰͷ
ͯͪ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳ΀
ͼͽΒͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͫ;ͬͪ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
ͱͳͬ͹
ͽͳΔͪ
ͺ͹΀ͶͰͺ͸ͳ΀
͸ͪ
Γ;ͯͼ͵;
͵ͻͬ
͸ͳΒͰͼͪͷ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ͯͪ
ͼ͵Ͷ͹ͺͳͷ
͹΂ͳ
͸ͳ

͸ͪ
ͷͳ͸;ͽ
̓ͪ͵ͬͪ
ͫΒͰͯͪi
͌Β;ͽͻ;
ΒͰ
͹ͯ
Γ;ͫͪͲ͸͹ͭ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ͸ͳ͸ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ

;ͷͳͬͪ͹
ͪ
͸ͪ
͵͹ΒͰͭ
ΒͰ
̹ͪͶͯͪ΂ͳ
͸ͪͳ΃ͪ͹
͸ͪ
ͷ͹ͻͼ͵͹Β
ͻͳͬͳ
ͼͪͲ͸ͪ͹
ͯͪ
͸ͪ

͸ͪΒ͵ͻͪΕͰͷ
ͺ;ͽ;
Ͳͪ
̹;ͯͬ;
ͯ͹
͵͹ΒͰ
ͳͷͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͹ͯ

͵ͳͶ͹ͷͰͽͪͻͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ

͸ͳ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͭ͹ͼͽͳ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
̺ͻͶ͹
ͼͶͳ͵͹ͬͳͽ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵
ͳͲ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͺͻ;
ͱͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
Ͳͪ
ͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪΔͪ
ͬͳ΃ͰͼͶ͹Β͸ͳ΀
ͰͶͰͷͰ͸ͪͽͪ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͪ
ͼͬͪ
͵͹ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸͹ͭ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂ͳ
ͳ
͹
;ͽͳͼ͵;
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
;

ͬͰ͵;

ͺͻͰ͸͹΃Ͱ͸
Ͳͪͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪ͸ͳͷͪ
Ͳͪ
͹ͬ͹
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂ΒͰ

͈ͻͰͭͶͰͯ͹ͷ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͽͰͷͪ
ͳͲ
ͳͲͪͫͻͪ͸ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
Δͳ
΀͹ͬͳͷ
ͺ͹ͻͰΌͰΔͰͷ
ͼͪ
ͯͰͶͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͪ
͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒ;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͯͱͪ͸ͻ;
ͪͶͳ

;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸͹Β
ͭͻ;ͺͳ
Γ;ͯͳ
ͷ͹ͭͶͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ

;͹΂ͳͽͳ
ͼͶͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͬͰ͵͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͺͻ͹ͬͶͪ΂Ͱ
;
ͬͳͯ;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͽͻͪ
ͯͳ΁ͳΒͰ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͼͽͪͻ͹ͭ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͊ͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͯͰ΃ͪ
ͬͪͶͰ
͹ͯ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
͵ͪͽͪͼͽͻ͹Ϳͪ
ͻͪͽ͸ͳ΀
ͻͪͲͪͻͪΔͪ
ͯ͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͳ

ͳͯͰ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ΀
ͷͰΔͪͶͰ
ͼ;
ͳͲͭͶͰͯ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͻͰ΂͸ͳ͵
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;

ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͳ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ

 ͊Ͷͳ͵ͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͷͰΔͪ͸ͪ
;
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼͳͷͪ 

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

7BMFOUJOB
ÂJWLPWJǀ
#JMEFS
FJOFS
4UBEU
EVSDI
&SECFCFO
TUÅOEJH
WFSÅOEFSU

,PUPS
JO
3FJTFGÛISFSO

*N
7FSTVDI
EJF
VSTQSÛOHMJDIF
'PSN
WPO
,VMUVSEFOLNÅMFSO
[V

SFLPOTUSVJFSFO
VOE
EFO
;FJUSBVN
JISFS
&SOFVFSVOH
GFTU[VMFHFO
LÕOOUF

OJDIU
OVS
OBDI
4DISJGURVFMMFO
BSDIÅPMPHJTDIFO
VOE
BSDIJUFLUPOJTDIFO

'PSTDIVOHTFSHFCOJTTFO
TPOEFSO
BVDI
OBDI
3FJTFGÛISFSO
HFHSJGGFO
XFSEFO

EJF
JISFSTFJUT
FCFOTP
WJFMF
OÛU[MJDIF
*OGPSNBUJPOFO
CJFUFO
3FJTFGÛISFS
XFSEFO

BVDI
JN
WPSMJFHFOEFO
"SUJLFM
ÛCFS
EJF
(FTDIJDIUF
EFS
4UBEU
,PUPS
[V
3BUF

HF[PHFO
IJOTJDIUMJDI
FJOFT
TQF[JGJTDIFO
1SPCMFNT
NJU
EFN
TJDI
EJF
4UBEU
JO

EFS
7FSHBOHFOIFJU
IÅVGJH
BCNÛIFO
NVTTUF
m
FT
IBOEFMU
TJDI
VN
[BIMSFJDIF

WFSIFFSFOEF
&SECFCFO
%BSVN
XFSEFO
[XFJ
3FJTFGÛISFS
BVTHFXÅIMU
VOE

BOBMZTJFSU
3FJTFGÛISFS
EVSDI
,PUPS
WPO
*WP
4UKFQǁFWJǀ
BVT

VOE
#PLB

,PUPSTLB
&JO
LVMUVSHFTDIJDIUMJDIFS
3FJTFGÛISFS
WPO
/JLP
-VLPWJǀ
BVT

/BDI

FJOFS
HSÛOEMJDIFO
6OUFSTVDIVOH
EFS
XJDIUJHTUFO
5IFNFO
JO
EFO
BOHFHFCFOFO

3FJTFGÛISFS
VOE
FJOFN
EBSBVG
GPMHFOEFO
7FSHMFJDI
NJU
BOEFSFO
4DISJGUXFSLFO

EJF
PCXPIM
OJDIU
[V
EFNTFMCFO
6OUFSHFOSF
HFIÕSFOE
XJFEFSVN
,PUPS
BMT

)BVQUUIFNB
IBCFO
FSXÅIOU
TFJFO
IJFS
FJO
3FOBJTTBODF(FEJDIU
WPO
*WBO

#POP
#PMJDB
%FTDSJQUJP
TJOVT
FU
VSCJT
BDSJWFO
VOE
FJO
CBSPDLFT
8FSL
WPO

5JNPUFK
$J[JMB
m
#PWF
EAPSP

LÕOOFO
CFTUJNNUF
¨IOMJDILFJUFO
GFTUHFTUFMMU

XFSEFO
EJF
KBISIVOEFSUMBOH
BMT
LVMUVSFMMFT
.VTUFS
EJFTFS
BMUFSUÛNMJDIFO

4UBEU
JNNFS
XJFEFS
WPSLPNNFO
"OEFSFSTFJUT
WFSÅOEFSUFO
WJFMF
&SFJHOJTTF

m
&SECFCFO
,SJFHT[FSTUÕSVOHFO
QPMJUJTDIF
VOE
JEFPMPHJTDIF
/FVJHLFJUFO

m
EBT
&STDIFJOVOHTCJME
EFS
4UBEU
VOE
EJF
&S[ÅIMXFJTF
EFS
"VUPSFO
EJF
,PUPS

GSFNEFO
3FJTFOEFO
WPSTUFMMFO
XPMMUFO
6OTFS
"VHFONFSL
SJDIUFUF
TJDI
EBCFJ

BVG
FJOJHF
ÛCMJDIF
&MFNFOUF
FJOFT
KFEFO
3FJTFGÛISFST
EJF
4UBEU
TFMCFS
VOE

JISF
6NHFCVOH
,VMUVSEFOLNÅMFS
EJF
(FTDIJDIUF
WPO
,PUPS
VOE
UPVSJTUJTDIF

*OGPSNBUJPOFO
JN
FOHFSFO
4JOOF
EJF
JO
WFSHBOHFOFO
;FJUFO
BLUVFMM
XBSFO

%BT
¨V“FSF
EFS
4UBEU
ÅOEFSUF
TJDI
VOUFS
EBVFSOEFN
&JOGMVTT
CFXVTTU

EVSDIHFGÛISUFS
6NHFTUBMUVOHFO
VOE
OFV
FOUTUBOEFOFS
4UJMTUSÕNVOHFO

BCFS
BVDI
KFOFS
VOLPOUSPMMJFSUFO
EVSDI
/BUVSLBUBTUSPQIFO
WFSVSTBDIUFO

6NXÅM[VOHFO
"MT
"VTESVDL
BMM
EJFTFS
7FSXBOEMVOHFO
CFTUFIU
JO
EFS
4UBEU

IFVU[VUBHF
FJOF
VOHFXÕIOMJDIF
4ZNCJPTF
VOUFSTDIJFEMJDIFS
4UJMSJDIUVOHFO

VOE
5SBEJUJPOFO
/BDI
EFN
MFU[UFO
WFSXÛTUFOEFO
&SECFCFO
JN
+BIS


XVSEFO
[BIMSFJDIF
6OUFSTVDIVOHFO
EVSDIHFGÛISU
CFJ
EFOFO
WJFMF
8FSLF
EFS

CJTIFS
VOCFLBOOU
HFCMJFCFOFO
8BOENBMFSFJ
BCFS
BVDI
BOEFSF
LÛOTUMFSJTDI
BSDIJUFLUPOJTDIF
&S[FVHOJTTF
BOT
5BHFTMJDIU
LBNFO


͠͹ͬͪ͸͵ͪ

̸͚͇͉͚̺͇̺͇̺̾́ͣ͆́ͣ͠
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
̸͊͆͌

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

͌
͊̾͆͏́
̸͇͈̈́́ͅ

͇ͯ
ͼͬͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
̻ͻ΂͵ͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
͸ͪΒͬͳ΃Ͱ

ͺͻͳͼ;ͽ͸ͪ
;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸͹Β
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͳ
ΒͰͻ
ΒͰ
ͼͪ΂;ͬͪ͸͹
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͹ͯ


ͺͻ͹ͼ͵ͳ͸ͳͽͪͻͳ͹͸ͪ
ͳͽͳ͸ͰͻͪͻͳΒͪ
ͪ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸͹
͹͵͹

ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ

͌
ͼͬͳͷ
ͽͳͷ
ͯͰͶͳͷͪ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͬ
͹ͯ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ
ͼͪ
ͺͻͰͫ͹ͭͪͽͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ

ͯ͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂͸ͳ΀
ͼͪͬͰͽͪ
ͳ
;ͺ;ͽͼͽͪͬͪ
;ͬͰ͵
ͼ;
ͼͪͯͻ
ͱͪ͸ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͳͶͳ
Ͱͽ͸͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼͳ
͵͹Βͳ
͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͽͻͪͭ
͹

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͳ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
Ͱͺ͹΀Ͱ
͈;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͳ
ͼ;
͵ͪ͹
Ͳͪͫͪͬ͸ͪ
ͳ
͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬ͸ͪ
ͶͰ͵ͽͳͻͪ

ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͫ;ͯͳͶͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
Ͳͪ
tͺͰͻͳͿͰͻͳ
Β;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰi
͸Ͱͭ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͻͪͯ͹Ͳ͸ͪͶͰ
ͯ;΀͹ͬͰ
ͺ͹͵ͻͰͽͪͶͳ
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ
͋Ͱ͵
ͼ;

ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼͳ
͹
tͼͶͪͬ͸͹Β
ͪ͸ͽͳ΁ͳi
ͳͲ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸Ͱ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͷͰͷ͹ͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪ
ͽ;ͻͰ
ͬͳ͵ͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯ͹ͫͪ
ͺ͹ͫ;ͯͳͶͳ
ͱͳͬΓͰ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
Ͳͪ
t͸Ͱͬͪͻͬͪͻͼ͵ͳ
ͯͰ͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪi
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼ;
ͼͰ
;
ͺ͹΀͹
ͯ;
;
ͲͰͷΓ;
tͼͶͪͬ͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳi
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͪͷͪ
͸ͪ;΂͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͬ͹Β͸ͳͷ

ͼͽͻ;΂Δͪ΁ͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͷͳͼͳ͹͸ͪͻͳͷͪ
ͺͻͳͯͻ;ͱͳͶͳ
ͳ
ͻ͹ͷͪ͸ͽͳ΂͸ͳ
ͿͳͶ΀ͰͶͰ
͸ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͸ͪͷͰͻ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͳ
ͪͬͪ͸ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ
ͳͲ
ͬͳ΃ͳ΀
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͼͻͰ
ͯͳ͸ͪ
͊ͬͳ
͹͸ͳ
ͼͬͰͼͻͯ͸͹
ͼ;
;΂Ͱͼͽͬ͹ͬͪͶͳ
;
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͻͪΔ;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͰ

͹
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
͵ͪ͹
t͵͹ͶͰͬ΁ͳ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰi
ͳ
tͿ;͸͵΁ͳ͹͸ͳͼͪͶͳ
͵ͪ͹

ͺ͹ͽͺ͹ͻͪ
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͯ͸;
ͬͻͼͽ;
ͼ;ͻ͹ͭͪͽͼ͵͹ͭ
͵͹Ͷ͹͸ͳΒͪͶͳͲͷͪ
͵͹Βͳͷ
ΒͰ
̻ͻ΂͵ͪ

;ͬͰͯͰ͸ͪ
;
ͳ͸ͽͰͶͰ͵ͽ;ͪͶ͸;
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸;
ͼ΁Ͱ͸;
̀ͪͺͪͯͪi
ͅͰͽͪͿ͹ͻͳ΂͵͹



Ȅʒʐʠʌʊʂ




'MFNJOH


 ͠͹ͬͪ͸͵ͪ
͚͹ͻΌͰͬͳΕ͠͹ͬͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ

ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͪͬͪΔͰ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
̀ͪͺͪͯ;
ͽͰ͵Ͷ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͳͼͽ͹ͬͰΕͳͬͪΔͰͷ
̸ͽͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ

ͫͶͳͼͽͪͬ͹ͭ
ͷͰͻͷͰͻͪ
ͪ͸ͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͼͪ
ͼͬͰ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹ͷ
̻ͻ΂͵͹ͷ
͌ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰͷ
ͼͪ

ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸͹ͷ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻ͹ͷ
͹
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
͹ͽ͵ͻͳͬͪ
ͼͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
ͺͻͳ΀ͬͪͽͪΔͪ

͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
tͰͭͲ͹ͽͳ΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰi
ͯͻ;ͭͪ΂ͳΒͰͭ
͹ͯ
ͬͪͻͬͪͻͼ͵͹ͭ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ

ͺ͹ͯ͸ͰͫΓͪ
ͪ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͳ
ͳͲ͸ͪͶͪͱͰΔͰ
ͺ͹
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹ͷ
ͼ΀ͬͪͽͪΔ;
͹

tͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΔ;i
ͳ
ͼ͹ͺͼͽͬͰ͸ͳ΀
͵͹ͻͰ͸ͪ
;
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵͹Β
ͭͻ΂͵͹Β
ͫͪ΃ͽͳ͸ͳ
̻ͻ΂
͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
΁ͳΓ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
Ͳͪͻͪͯ
ͺ͹͵Ͷ͹ΔͰΔͪ

͵͹ͻͰ͸ͳͷͪ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͬͰΕ
ͳ
;
ͺ͹ͽͻͪͲͳ
Ͳͪ
ͼ͹ͺͼͽͬͰ͸ͳͷ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ
͸ͳͷ
ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͽͰͽ͹ͷ
͊ͬͰ
ͯ͹
ͺͰͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
̻ͻ΂͵ͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰΕͳ
ͬͪ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͼͳͷͫ͹Ͷ
ͪ͸ͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͪ
ͽͰ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
ͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪ͸ͪ

;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
ͽͪͯͪ
ͬͰΕ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳͷ
͹ͼͶ͹͸΁ͳͷͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
̾͵ͼͺͪ͸ͲͳΒ;

ͷͪͼ͹ͬ͸͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
;
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
ͺ͹΂Ͱͬ
͹ͯ
΃ͰͲͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺͻͪ
ͽͳ
ͳ
΂ͳͽͪͬͪ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͯ͹ͷͪΕͳ΀
ͳ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΀

ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂ͪ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳΒͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ

ΔͰ͸͹ͭ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͽͰͽͪ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͳͯͰ͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒ;
tͼͶͪͬ͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳi

ͳ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺͰΒͼͪͱͪ
ͳͯͰͪͶͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ΀
͹ͯ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
͌
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹
ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
ͭͻ΂͵ͳ΀
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂ͪ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͪͬ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳ΀ͬͪΕͰ͸
ͷ͹ͯͰͶ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸Ͱ

ͺͻ͹ͯ;͵΁ͳΒͰ
ͪ
ͯͪ
ͺͻͳͽ͹ͷ
͸ͳΒͰ
͹ͫͻͪΕͰ͸ͪ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
͸ͪ
ͬͰͻ͹ͯ͹ͼͽ͹Β͸͹ͼͽ

ͽ;ͷͪ΂ͰΔͪ
ͭͻ΂͵Ͱ
ͪ͸ͽͳ͵Ͱ
͸ͪ
tͳ͸ͽͰͶͰ͵ͽ;ͪͶ͸;
͵͹Ͷ͹͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒ;i
ͭͻ΂͵Ͱ
ͫͪ
΃ͽͳ͸Ͱ
ͳͶͳ
͸ͪ
ͿͻͪͭͷͰ͸ͽͪͻ͸͹ͼͽ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͪ
͹
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β

͊ͬͰ͹ͫ;΀ͬͪͽ͸ͳΒͪ
ͼͶͳ͵ͪ
͹
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
ͳͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
͹͸ͪ
ͼ΀ͰͷͪͽͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͪ

ͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͼͰ
;
͹ͺ΃ͽͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
ͭͯͰ
ͼͰ
̸ͽͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
̸ͽͳ͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;Β;
͵ͪ͹

͹ͪͲͪ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
ͪ
͋ͰͼͪͶͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͅͰͽͰ͹ͻͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͻͳͲ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͬͳͲͪ͸
ͽͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
̀ͪ;ͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͰͷ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
͸ͪ
ͬͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺͰ
ͻͳ͹ͯ;
ͼͪͷ͹
ΒͰ
ͯ͹͸Ͱ͵ͶͰ
ͼͪͭͶͰͯͪ͸ͪ
ͬͰͻͽͳ͵ͪͶͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Βͪ
͹ͬͰ

ͲͰͷΓͰ
͆ͪΒͪͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳΒͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͼͳͷͫ͹Ͷͳ
ͬͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͫͪ΃ͽͳ
͸Ͱ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͳ
ͅͰͽͰ͹ͻͪ
͊ͬͰͽͳ
͆ͳ͵͹Ͷͪ
͉;ͼͪ͸
̺ͪͻͶͪͪͷ
ͅͰͽͪͷ͹ͻ
Ϳ͹Ͳͳͼ
͊ͬͰͽͪ
͋ͻ͹Βͳ΁ͪ
͊ͬͰͽͳ
͊ͽͰͿͪ͸
͵͹Βͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͯͪ
ͶͰͫͯͰ
;
ͬͪͲͯ;΀;

ͫͶͳͱͰ
͸Ͱͫ;
͸Ͱͭ͹
ͲͰͷΓͳ
ͲͪͯͳͬΓ;Β;
ͺ͹ͬͻ΀
ͼͬͰͭͪ
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒͰͷ

ͼͺ͹Γ͸ͳͷ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯ͹ͷ
ͷͪͯͪ
͸ͳ΃ͽͪ
ͷͪΔͰ
Ͳͳͯ͸ͳͷ
ͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͼͽͬ͹ͷ
ͫ͹ͭͪ
ͽͳͷ
ͫͳͫͶͳ͹ͽͰ͵ͪͷͪ
ͻͰͽ͵ͳͷ
ͻ;͵͹ͺͳͼͳͷͪ
ͳ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ͸ͳͷ
ͯͻͪͭ͹΁Ͱ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͷͪ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
ͼ;
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ
͸Ͱͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸͹
͋ͪ͵͹

ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳ΀
΃Ͱͼͽ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͪ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽ͹

ͳͶͳ
ͻͰ͸͹ͬͳͻͪ͸͹
;

ͬͰ͵;
̽ͻ;ͭͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸ͳΒͳ
ͳ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͯͪ

ͼ;
̺ͰͶͳ͵ͳ
ͅͰͽͰ͹ͻͳ
ͳͶͳ
ͅͰͽͪͷ͹ͻͿ͹Ͳͳͼ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽͳ
;

ͬͰ͵;
ͪ
ͯͪ

ΒͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ

ͳ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽ͹
Β͹΃

ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͪ
͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ΒͰ

ͳ
;

ͼͪͯͪ΃ΔͰ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
;
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͳ
͆ͪ
ͼͪΒͽ;
̽ͻͱͪͬ͸Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳ



(SFFDF

 ͌
ͼͰ͸΁ͳ
͇Ͷͳͷͺͪ 

Ͳͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹Ͳͳͬ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳͷͪ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ
ͅͰͽͰ͹ͻͰ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ
͊ͬͰͽͰ

͋ͻ͹Βͳ΁Ͱ
͸ͪ
͇Ͷͳͷͺ;
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ
͊ͬͰͽͰ
̹ͪͻͫͪͻͰ
͸ͪ
͹ͼͽͻͬ;
͊͵͹ͺͰͶ͹ͼ
ͳ

ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ
͊ͬͰͽͰ
̹͹ͭ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΁Ͱ
͸ͪ
ͼͽͰ͸ͪͷͪ
̓͹ͻ͹͸
;ͺ;ΕͰ͸
ΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹Ͳͳͬ

Ͳͪͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪ͸ͳͷͪ
Ͳͪ
ͬͰͻͼ͵ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
̺ͰͶͰͶͰͺ͸ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͬͳͲͪ͸
ͽͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͰ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͰ
ͻͳͲ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͺͻ;ͱͪΒ;
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͹ͯ

͸ͪͲ͸ͪ΂Ͱ͸͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
͈ͻͰ;ͲͳͷͪΔͰ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͽͰͻͷͳ͸ͪ
ͬͰͻͫͪͶ͸͹
ͺͻͰ;ͼͷͰ
ͻͪͬͪΔͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
͸ͪ
ͬͰͻͼ͵ͳ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ΒͰ
ͳͲͶͳ΃͸ͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪ͵
ͺͻ͹
΁Ͱͼ;
ͭͶ͹ͫͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
͵͹ͷͰͻ΁ͳΒͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͸Ͱͭ͹
͹ͼͺ͹ͻͪͬͪΔͰ
ͅͰͽͰ͹ͻͪ

͵ͪ͹
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ

͇ͼͽͪͶͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
͋ͰͼͪͶͳΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͼͪΒͽ;
̽ͻͱͪͬ
͸Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͯ͹͸͹ͼͰ
͸͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
;
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β;
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
;
̻ͻ΂
͵͹Β
ͺ͹ͷͰͻͪΒ;Εͳ
ͽͰͱͳ΃ͽͰ
ͼͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
͸ͪ
ͻͰ͵ͻͰͪͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͰ
͊

ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
͹ͬͪ͵ͬͳͷ
ͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺ͹ͷ
ͻͪͲͫͳΒͪ
ͼͰ
ͼͽͰͻͰ͹ͽͳͺ͸ͳ
ͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺ

̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
ͳ
͸ͪͭ͹ͬͰ΃ͽͪͬͪΒ;
͸͹ͬͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
͊
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͼ;΃ͽͳ͸
ͼ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹ͼͽ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͰͼͽͪͶͪ
;
ͺ͹ͬͶͪΌͳͬͪΔ;
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹ͷ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ
ͳͶͳ
;
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼ;
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͭͶ͹ͫͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
͹ͼͰ
 ͠͹ͬͪ͸͵ͪ
͚͹ͻΌͰͬͳΕ͠͹ͬͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ

Εͪ
;
ͺ͹ͲͳͬͪΔ;
͸ͪ
ͬͰͻͼ͵ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
͋ͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵ͳ

Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽͳ
͋ͰͼͪͶͳΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
ͷ;ͲͰΒͳ
͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
;
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ
΁ͪͷͪ
ͺͻͰͿͰ͵ͽ;ͻͪ
͸Ͱͭ͹
ͳ
;
ͷͪΔͳͷ
ͷͰͼͽͳͷͪ
ͳͲ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ΒͰͻ
ͬͰ
ͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸͹
͸ͳͼ;
ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͳͷͺͻͰͼͳͬ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͱͰͶͰ
ͼ͸ͪͱ͸ͳΒͳ

ͼ;ͼͻͰͽ
ͼͪ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͹ͷ
;
΃ͽ͹
͵ͻͪΕͰͷ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸;
ͳͶͳ
ͼͰ
ͱͰͶͳ

ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͪ
͋ͰͼͪͶͳΒͰ
ͺ͹
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͼͽͪ͸ͯͪͻͯͳͷͪ

͋ͰͼͪͶͳΒͪ
͹ͫͶͪͼͽ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͇Ͷͳͷͺͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͰͬͰͻ;
̾ͭͰΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͷ͹ͻͪ
ͳ

ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸Ͱ
͇ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͳͼͽ͹͵;
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸Ͱ
͇ͽͻͳͼ
͸ͪ
Β;ͭ;
ͳ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͬͰ
͸ͪ΁ͪ
͈ͳ͸ͯͪ
͸ͪ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ;
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;ΒͰ
ͼͰ
͵ͪ͹
Ͱ͵͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻ
͵ͻ;͸ͪ

ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͪ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
ͼͪ
ͻͰ͵ͪͷͪ
ΒͰͲͰͻͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͻͪͲ͸͹ͬͻͼ͸ͳͷ
ͫͳΓ
͸ͳͷ
ͳ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͳΔͼ͵ͳͷ
ͼͬͰͽ͹ͷ
̀ͯͻͪͬͪ
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͪ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͼͽͬͪ

͋ͰͼͪͶͳΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
΀Ͷͪͯ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͽ͹ͺͶͳ
ͷͳ͸ͰͻͪͶ͸ͳ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͳ
͊ͷ͹͵͹ͬͪ

;
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Β;
̓ͪͻͯͳ΁Ͱ
ͼͬͰͼͻͯ͸͹
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;Β;
͵ͪ͹
͹ͫͶͳ͵
ͲͯͻͪͬͼͽͬͰ
͸͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
͡;ͫͳͽͰΓͳͷͪ
ͼͺ͹ͻͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
͋ͰͼͪͶͳΒͪ
͹ͷ͹ͭ;Εͪͬͪ

ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͸ͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͰ
ͬͳͯ͹ͬͰ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼͺ͹ͻͽ͹ͬͪ

ͼ͵ͳΒͪΔͰ
ͼͪ͸͵ͪΔͰ
ͳͶͳ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͪͻͰΔͰ
͇Ͷͳͷͺ
ͯ͹ͷ
ͫ͹ͭ͹ͬͪ
ͷͰͼͽ͹
͹ͯͪ
͵ͶͰ
ΒͰ
̀Ͱͬͼ
ͼͶͪ͹
ͬͰͽͻ͹ͬͰ
ͷ;ΔͰ
ͳͶͳ
ͼ͸Ͱͭ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͰ΂͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͪ
ͳͲ

ͫͰͶ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
͸ͪͷͰͻͰ͸͹ͭ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͼͻͰͽ͸Ͱ
ͼͪ
ͪ͸ͽͳ͵͹ͷ
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
;

ͼͰ͸΁ͳ
ͪͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
΀ͻͪͷ͹ͬͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸ͳ
̀Ͱͬͼ;
ͳͶͳ
͹ͶͳͷͺͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ

ͫ͹ͭ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͫ͹ͭͳΔͪͷͪ
;
ͷͳͻ͸ͳΒͳͷ
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͳͷͪ
̸ͽͳ͵Ͱ
̽ͰͶ;
͇Ͷͳͷͺͪ

ͭͯͰ
ͺ͹
͎͹ͷͰͻ;
tͬͰͽͻ͹ͬͳ
͸Ͱ
ͯ;ͬͪΒ;
ͼ͸Ͱͭ
͸Ͱ
ͺͪͯͪt
ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͪͬͪΒ;
ͼͰ

ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͹͸ͳ
ͬͳ΂͸ͳ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͪͻͰΔ;

͠͹΃
;

ͬͰ͵;
ͼͬͰͽͳ
̽ͳ͹͸ͳͼͳΒͰ
ͺͻͬͳ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂
͇Ͷͳͷͺͪ
ͺ͹ͺͰ͹

ͼͰ
ͯ͹
ͬͻ΀ͪ
͈ͻ͹ͻ͹͵ͪ
́ͶͳΒͰ
͸ͪ

ͷͰͽͻͪ
ͭͯͰ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭͪ͹
΁ͻ͵ͬ;
͹ͬ͹ͷ

ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ;
̾͸ͭͶͰͲ
̽ͪͬͳͯ
͌ͻ͵ͪͻͽ
%BWJE
6SRVIBSU

ͯ͹ͼͰͭͪ͹
ΒͰ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͯ͹

ͷͰͽͪͻͪ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹͸ͪ΃ͪ͹
͹ͼͽͪͽ͵Ͱ
΀ͻͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͼͽ;ͫ͹ͬͪ
͆Ͱͷͪ΂
͵ͳ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿ
̾͵Ͱ͸ͫͻͰ΀Ͱͻ
&DLFOCSFDIFS

ͳͲͻͪͯͳ͹
ΒͰ

ͺͻͬ;
ͷͪͺ;

͇Ͷͳͷͺͪ
ͷͪͯͪ
͸Ͱͺ͹ͽͺ;͸;
ΒͰͻ
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ
͸ͪΒͬͳ΃ͳ
ͬͻ΀
;ͲͰͽ
͈ͻ͹ͻ͹͵
́Ͷͳ
Βͪ
ͷͰͼͽ͹
ͯ͹
͵͹ͭͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂
ͯ͹ͼͺͰ͹
͆ͪΒͬͳ΃ͳ
ͬͻ΀
͹ͼͬ͹ΒͰ͸
ΒͰ
ͽͰ͵


̽͹
ΔͰͭͪ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
;ͼͺͰͶͳ
͑ͬͪΒ΁ͪͻ΁ͳ
͍ͻͰͯͰͻͰͳ͵
̹͹ͳͼ͹͸ͪͼ
'SFEF
SJD
#PJTTPOOBT

ͳ
̽ͪ͸ͳΒͰͶ
̹ͪ;ͯ
̹͹ͬͳ
%BOJFM
#BVE
#PWZ

ͼͪ
̻ͻ͵͹ͷ

͎ͻͳͼͽ͹ͼ͹ͷ
̓ͪ͵ͪͶ͹ͼ͹ͷ
͌
͸͹ͬͳΒͰ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͇Ͷͳͺͷ
ͺ͹Ͳͳͬͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͯͪ

;ͱͳͬͪΒ;
;
ͫͰͶͳͷ
ͼͺ͹ͻͽ͹ͬͳͷͪ

̸͵͹
ͼͰ
;ͺ͹ͻͰͯͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸ͳ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
͇Ͷͳͷͺ
ͼͺ͹ͷͳ
ΔͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͺͻͰͺͻͰ͵ͪ
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ;
ͳͶͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͬͪͱ͸ͪ
ͼͽͻͪͽͰ΃͵ͪ
ͽͪ΂͵ͪ
ͼͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱ
ͻͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͭͪ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;Β;
͵ͪ͹
ͼ͸Ͱͱ͸;
΂ͪͻ͹ͶͳΒ;
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹͸Ͱ͵ͶͰ

ͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͽͳ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰΔͰ͸
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͯͻͰͬ͸͹Β
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭ͹Β

ͺ͹
ͬͳͼͳ͸ͳ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
͆͹ͬͳΒͪ
ͼ΀ͬͪͽͪΔͪ
͇Ͷͳͷͺͪ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰΔͰ͸ͪ
ͼ;
ͳ

ͼͪͷͳͷ
ͽͳͷ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͪ
͹ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͼͽͳͭͶͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͬ;
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸;
͵ͪ͹
ͳ

 ͌
ͼͰ͸΁ͳ
͇Ͷͳͷͺͪ 

ͺ͹Ͳͳͬ͹ͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͯͷ͹ͻ
́ͺͪ͵
͹ͼͽͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͷͳͽ
͹
͇Ͷͳͷͺ;
͵ͪ͹
ͺͻͰ
ͫͳͬͪͶͳ΃ͽ;
ͫͰͼͷͻͽ͸ͳ΀
ͫ͹ͭ͹ͬͪ
͆͹ͬ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͳ
͸͹ͬͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳ
͵͹ΒͰ

͇Ͷͳͷͺ
͸;ͯͳ
;΂ͳ͸ͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͯͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͪΔͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼ;
͹ͼͽͪΒͪͶͪ
;
ͯ͹ͷͰ͸;
ͶͰ
ͺͰ
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͼͪ
ͷͪͶ͹
ͬͳͲ;ͰͶ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͹ͱͳͬͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͫ;ͯͰ

ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
ͳ
Ͳͪ
͹͸͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪͶͰ͵͹
͹ͯ
ͫͶͳͼͽͪͬ͹ͭ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂
͵͹ͭ
ͷͰͻͷͰͻͪ
͊ͬ͹ΒͰͬͻͼͽͪ͸
͹ͽͺ͹ͻ
͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬͪΔ;
ͼͽͰͻͰ͹ͽͳͺͪ
ͺͻ;ͱͪ
ͼͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͷͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͪ΂͸Ͱ
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼ;
ͼͪͭͶͰͯͪ͸Ͱ
ͼͬͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ

Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽͳͷͪ
͈ͻͳͷͰͽ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
;͵͹
Ͷͳ͵͹
ͯ͹ΌͰ
ͯ͹
ͳͲ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
;
͵͹ͻͳͼͽ
ͬͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒ
ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳͶͳ
͹ͫͻ͸;ͽ͹
͸ͪͼͽͪΒͰ
͹ͷͰͽͪΔͰ
͸ͰͺͻͰͼͽͪ͸͹ͭ
ͯͳΒͪͶ͹ͭͪ
͎ͰͶͰ͸ͪ

͉͹ͷͳ͹ͼͳ͸ͪ
ͳ
̻ͻ͵ͪ
ͺͻͰ͵ͳͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͬͰͻͽͳ͵ͪͶͪ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Βͪ
ͭͻ΂͵͹ͭ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ
͸͹ͭ
ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͽͰͽͪ
ͯ͹
΂Ͱͭͪ
ΒͰ
̻ͻ΁ͳͷͪ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͼͽͪͶ͹
ͪ
͸ͪ
΃ͽͪ
ͱͰͶͰ
ͯͪ

;͵ͪͱ;
ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵;
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼ;
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͼ͵͹ͻ͹

Ͳͪ
ͼͬͪ͵ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͶͰ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽ͹
ͳͶ;ͼͽͻ͹ͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂Ͱ
͸ͪͭͶͪ΃ͪͬͪΒ;Εͳ

͵͹͸ͽͳ͸;ͳͽͰͽ
͇ͬͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͹ͫͳ΂͸͹
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ΀
͹ͯͻͰͯ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͹

ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒ;
͵Ͷͳͷͳ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬ;
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
ͼͪͯͻͱͰ
ͳ
͹͸͹
΃ͽ͹
ͫͳ
ͺ;ͽ
͸ͳ͵
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
ͯͪ
ͬͳͯͳ
͸ͪΒͺͻͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳ
ͬͰ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͰ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͹͸͹
΃ͽ͹
ͫͳ
͸ͪͷͰͻ͸ͳ͵

ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
ͯͪ
Ͳ͸ͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ;
ͽͻͰ͸;ͽ͸;
;ͺͻͪͬ;

ͺͻ͹ͫͪΔͰ
͵;Ͷͳ͸ͪͻͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼͺͰ΁ͳΒͪͶͳͽͰͽͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͬͳ͸ͪ
ͽ͹ͭ
͵ͻͪΒͪ
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹
ͺ͹
ͼͰͫ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͫͳ
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
͵ͪ͹
ͬͳͯ
ͼ;ͬͰ͸ͳͻͪ
ͺ͹͸Ͱͽͳ
ͳͲ
ͽ͹ͭ

ͷͰͼͽͪ
͋ͪ͵ͪͬ
ΒͰ
ͻͰ΁ͳͷ͹
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ
ͼͪ
ͬͪͻ͹΃ͳ΁͹ͷ
̾Ͷͪͼ͹͸ͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
ͶͪͲͳ
΂ͪ͵
͸ͳ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
3PVHI
(VJEF
-POFM;
1MBOFU
#MVF

RVJEF
#BFEFLFS
͇͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͰ͵
;ͼͺ;ͽ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸ͪ
ͳ
;
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;

Ͳͪ
̻ͻ΂͵;
ͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒ;
ͳͲ

͇͸͹
΃ͽ͹
͹ͫ͹ͭͪΕ;ΒͰ
΂ͳͽͪͬ;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪ
ͬ;
͹
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͷͰͼͽ;
ΒͰͼͽͰ
ͽ͹
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͭͪ
;
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
ͺ͹΀͹ͯͳͶͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ
ͺ;
ͽ͹ͺͳͼ΁ͳ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
̾ͬͶͳΒͪ
͐ͰͶͰͫͳΒͪ

̈́Ͱ͹͸
͎ͳΒͰΒ
-FPO
)FVZFZ



͈͹ͻͿͳͻͳΒͰ
͌ͼͺͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ

̈́ͰΒ͵
-FBL

̹ͻͪ;͸
#SPXO

̀͹ͽ͹ͼ

ͅ͹Ͷ͹ͼ͹ͼ


̾Ͷͪͼ͹͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ͸ͪ΂Ͱ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͪ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͺ͹ͽͳ΂;
͹ͯ
ͪ͸ͽͳ͵Ͱ

ͯ͹
͸͹ͬͳΒͳ΀
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
͈͹
ΒͰͯ͸ͳͷ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂ͳͷͪ
͹͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͬ͹
ͳͷͰ
ͯ͹
ͫͳͶͪ
Β͹΃
ͺͻͰ
͸ͰͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸ͳ΀

ͷͳͶͳ͹͸ͪ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͪ
ͺ͹
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷͪ
ͺͻͰ


ͷͳͶͳ͹͸ͪ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
͆ͪͲͳͬ
͈ͰͻͰͬͳͪ
ͯ͹ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹
ͺͻͬͳͷ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ
΁ͳͷͪ
͈ͰͻͰͬͪ͸ͳͷͪ
͎͹ͷͰͻ
ΒͰ
ͼͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͫͰͶͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
͇Ͷ͹ͼ͹͸;
͋;ͻ
΁ͳ
͵ͪ͹
̸Ͷ͹ͼ͹͸;



#BFEFLFST


 ͠͹ͬͪ͸͵ͪ
͚͹ͻΌͰͬͳΕ͠͹ͬͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ

̸͸ͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
;
Δ͹Β
ͼͻͰΕ;
ͼͰ
ͽF͵
;
ͽͻͪͭ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͵ͪ͵ͬͰ
ͼ;

ͻ;΃Ͱͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
΂ͳΒͳ
͹΃ͽͰΕͰ͸ͳ
Ͳͳͯ͹ͬͳ
ͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
͹͵ͻ;ͱ;Β;

ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ
̹͹ͭ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΁Ͱ
͇Ͷͳͷͺͳ͹ͽͳͼͰ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͬͰΕͳ΀
ͽͰͼͪͶͼ͵ͳ΀

ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͪ
ͼͪͭͻͪΌͰ͸͹ͭ
ͺͻͳ
͵ͻͪΒ;

ͬͰ͵ͪ
͈͹ͯͳͭͪ͹
ͭͪ
ΒͰ
̸͸ͯͻ͹͸ͳ͵

**
͈ͪͶͰ͹Ͷ͹ͭ
΂ͳΒͳ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͻͽͻͰͽ
ͺͻͰͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͼͰͬͰͻ͸͹ͷ
Ͳͳͯ;
͈ͻͬ͹ͫͳͽ
͸͹
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸
͈ͻͰ͹ͫͻͪͱͰΔ;
ͷ;ͯͻ͹ͼͽͳ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͲͬͪ͸
ͪͅ͸ͪ
ͼͽͳͻ
̹͹ͭ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ͸ͳ΀
ͷ;͵ͪ
ͳ
͸ͪΒͲͪͯ
ͺ͹
ͷͪͶ͹Β
ͳ͵͹͸ͳ
̹͹ͭ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΁Ͱ
͵͹
Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ;
̹͹ͭ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΁ͪ
͇Ͷͳͷͺͳ͹ͽͳͼͪ
ͪͅ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ

ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
ͼ͸ͪͱͪ͸
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻ
ͼ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͷ
ͫͻ͹ΒͰͷ
ͷ͹͸ͪ΀ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹

;

ͬͰ͵;
́Ͳ
ͽ͹ͭ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
ͼͪ΂;ͬͪ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͪ
ͫͳͫͶͳ͹ͽͰ͵ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͯͰ͹

ͻͳͲ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͌
͸Ͱͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸͹Β
ͫͶͳͲͳ͸ͳ
̾Ͷͪͼ͹͸Ͱ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
ͼͰ
Β͹΃

ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͪ

ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽͳ΀
;
ͬͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͼ͵͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͠͹΃
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵
̺ͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͰ
͵͹
Βͳ
ͳ
;
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃ΔͰ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͼͶ;ͱͳ
ͼͬͻͼͳ
ΒͰͼͽͰ
ͷ͹ͼͽ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͺͪΒͪ
ͯͬͪ
ͯͰͶͪ

ͭͻͪͯͪ
͆ͪͲͳͬͳ
;Ͷͳ΁ͪ
;
̾Ͷͪͼ͹͸ͳ
͹ͯͪΒ;
ͱͳͬ͹
ͼͰΕͪΔͰ
͸ͪ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵͹
ͬͻͰ
ͷͰ
ͳ
ͷͪ͵ͪͻ
ͫͰͲ
ͺ͹ͬͻ΃͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͰ
ͼ΀ͬͪͽͳͽͳ

ͪͽͷ͹ͼͿͰͻͪ
ͷͰͼͽͪ
;
͵͹ͷͰ

ͼͰ
ͼͪͼͽͪΒ;
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵͹
ͬͳͲͪ͸
ͽͳΒͼ͵͹
ͽ;ͻͼ͵͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͳ
ͼͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹ͼͽ
́ͷͰ͸ͪ
͵ͶͰͿͽͪ

͆ͳ͵͹΁ͪͻ͹ͼͪ
̓ͪͻͪͽͪͼ͹ͼͪ
ͳ

͠͹ͻͭ͹ͼͪ
͇Ͷͳͷͺͳ͹ͼͪ
ͺ͹͵ͻͰ
ͽͪ΂ͪ
ͫ͹ͻͫͰ
ͺͻ͹ͽͳͬ
͋;ͻͪ͵ͪ

ͺ͹ͯͼͰΕͪΒ;
͸ͪ
͹ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ΌͰΔͰ

͹ͯ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͬͶͪͼͽͳ
͌
͹ͫͶͳ
ͱΔͰͷ
ͼͰͶ;
̈́ͳͬͪͯͳ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ

ͼͰ
ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸
͵;Εͪ
͇Ͷͳͷͺͳ
͹ͼͪ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͷͪΔͳ΀
ͷ;ͲͰΒͪ

͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
ͼͻͰΕ;
;
ͼͰͶͳ
ͷͪ
͹͵͹
̾Ͷͪͼ͹͸Ͱ
͌Ͷͳ΁Ͱ
;

΁Ͱ͸ͽͻ;
͸͹ͼͰ
ͳͷͰ͸ͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ
͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
̸͸ͽͳͷͳͼͪ

̻ͪͲͳͼͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
;
̹Ͱ΂;
ͺ͹
͵ͻͰ͸;͹
΂ͪͼ͹ͺͳͼ
t̾ͻͷͳ͹ͼ

̈́͹ͭ͹ͼi
ͿͳͶ͹Ͳ͹Ϳͪ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹
ͿͰͼ͹ͻͪ
͈ͰͲͪͻ͹ͼͪ
̽ͳͷͳ



Ȓʋʐʠʃʂʒʂ


 ͌
ͼͰ͸΁ͳ
͇Ͷͳͷͺͪ 

ͽͻͳͪͯͳͼͪ
ͺͻ͹ͿͰͼ͹ͻͪ
ͳ
ͺͰͼ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͈ͰͻͰͬ͹ͼͪ
͎ͻͳͼͽ͹Ϳ͹ͻ͹ͼͪ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
͹ͯ

ͼͶͰͯͫͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͫͶͳͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͪͻͪͯ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͉ͳͭͰ
͍ͰͻͰ͹ͼͪ
̽͹ͱͳͬΓͪΒ;
ͪͽͷ͹ͼ
ͿͰͻͰ
͹ͬͰ
ͬͪͻ͹΃ͳ΁Ͱ
ͯ͹ͺͻͳ͸͹ͼͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
ͺ͹ͻͰ͵Ͷ;
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ

ͽ͹ͺ͹͸ͳͷͳͷͪ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽͳͷͪ
̽ͳͷͰ͸ͲͳΒͪ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͹ͽ͵ͻͳͬͪ
ͼͰ
;

ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
͹
;ͺͻͪͬͳ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷͪΔͳͷͪ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͫͻ͹Β;
ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸ͳ΀

͸͹ͬͳ͸ͪ

͌
͸͹ͬͳΒͰ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͼͬͰ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͺ;Ͷͪͻ͸ͳΒͪ
ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻ͹͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ

͵͹Βͪ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
͹Ϳͳ΁ͳΒͰͶ͸͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
ͼͪͯͻͱͳ
ͳ
͵͹ͷͰ͸ͽͪͻͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͶͪ΁ͪ
͹ͼ͹
ͫͰ͸;
ͺͻ͹ͬͰͻ;
͹͸͹ͭͪ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸͹
̓͹ͯ
͹ͬͪ͵ͬ͹ͭ
ͬͳͯͪ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪ
Δͪ
ͼͪ
̻ͻ΂͵͹ͷ
ͲͪͺͪͱͪΒ;
ͼͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
ͼͪΒͽ͹ͬͪ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
ͭͻ΂͵ͳ΀

ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͪ
;
ͳͼͽ͹Β
ͷͰͻͳ
͵ͪ͹
;
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
͉ͪͲͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͼ;
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ

ͬͳͯΓͳͬͰ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
ͭͻ΂͵ͳ΀
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͼͪΒͽ͹ͬͪ
ͳ
͹͸ͳ΀
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
ͷͰ
ͼ͸ͳ΀
̺͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
΁ͰͶ;
̻ͻ΂͵;
ͺ͹
;ͼͽͪΓͰ͸͹ͷ
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒ;
Ϳͪͬ͹ͻͳͲ;Β;
ͪ͸
ͽͳ΂͵;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ;
ͳ
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͰ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
͹͸ͪ
͵͹͸΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͳͼͪ͸ͪ
͇ͫͶͪͼ͸ͳ
ͬ͹
ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͺ͹
͏Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶ͸͹Β
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
͋ͻͪ͵ͳΒͳ
͋ͰͼͪͶͳΒͳ
ͳͶͳ
͹ͼͽͻͬͳͷͪ
ͯͪͶͰ͵͹

ͼ;
͵͹͸͵ͻͰͽ͸ͳΒͳ
ͳ
;ͺ͹ͻ͸ͳΒͳ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
͹ͺ΃ͽͰͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀

ͷͰͽͪ
;͵ͪͱ;
ͳ
͸ͪ
͹͸Ͱ
͸Ͱͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͪͺ͹ͼͽͻ͹Ϳͳͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͹ͫͳΓͰͷ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ
͵ͪ
͸ͪͼͽ͹ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͺͻͳͬ;͵;
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁Ͱ
͠͹΃
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸ͳΒͳ
ͼ;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͺ͹
ͺ͹ΒͰ
ͯͳ͸ͪ΂͸ͳͷ
ͷͰͼͽͳͷͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸ͳ
͸ͰͺͻͳͺͻͰͷΓͰ͸ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ

͸ͪͷͰͻ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
CBDLQBDLFSͳͷͪ
͸ͪ
ͯ;ͭͰ
ͳͶͳ
͵ͻͪͽ͵Ͱ
ͼͽͪͲͰ
͵͹Βͳ
ͫͰͲ
ͺ͹
Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
ͷͰͼͽͪ
͸Ͱ
ͫͳ
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒ;
ͯ;΀
ͽͰ
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸Ͱ
΂ͪ͵

ͳ
;͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͫͳ
ͽ͹
ͱͪͻ͵͹
ͱͰͶͰͶͳ

͌
ͳͲ͸ͪͶͪͱͰΔ;
͸͹ͬͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹
ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͪͶͽͰͻ͸ͪͽͳͬ͸;
΀Ͱͯ͹͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵;
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒ;

̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ
;ͺ;Ε;ΒͰ
ͺ͹Ͳͳͬ
Ͳͪ
͹ͫͳͶͪͲͪ͵
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
ͬͳ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͳͶͳ
ͭͪͼͽͻ͹͸͹ͷ
ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽͰͬͳͷͪ
͈ͻͪͽͰΕͳ
ͺ͹ͫ;ͯͰ
ͯ͹Ͷͪͼ͵ͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͻͪ
ͼͰ
͸͹
ͬͪ
ͼͳͷͫ͹Ͷͳ΂͸ͪ
ͪ;ͽͰ͸ͽͳ΂͸͹ͼͽ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
͹ͫͪͼΒͪ͸ͪ
͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
;
͵ͻͳͼͽͪͶ͸͹

ͫͳͼͽͻ͹ͷ
ͷ͹ͻ;
m
Γ;ͫͳͽͰΓͳͷͪ
ͼ;͸΁ͪ
ͿͰͽͪ
ͺͻͰͶͳͬͰ͸ͪ
ͷͪͼͶͳ͸͹ͬͳͷ

;ΓͰͷ

tͱͯͰͻ͹Δͪͷͪi
ͻͰ΁ͳ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͫ;Ͳ;͵ͳ
m
ͱͰΓ͸ͳͷͪ
ͲͪͫͪͬͰ
ͳͶͳ
̀͹ͻ
ͫͪͪͬͪ͸ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳͷͪ

ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͼͬͰ
͸͹ͬ͹ͼͽͬ͹ͻͰ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͰͻͰ͹ͽͳͺ͸Ͱ
ͼͶͳ͵Ͱ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͯ;͵
ͽͳ
ͷͪͻ͵Ͱͽͳ͸΃͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͯ;΀ͬͪͽͪ
͹ͼͽͪΒ;
;
ͼͰ͸΁ͳ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͼͳͷ
ͫ͹Ͷͪ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͫͪ΃ͽͳ͸Ͱ
̸͵ͻ͹ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͼͳͼͪ
ͳ
ͷͰͻͷͰͻͪ
͹ͶͳͷͺͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͫ͹
ͭ͹ͬͪ
͆͹ͬͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪͷͰΕ;
ͼͬ͹Βͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͷͰͻͳͶͪ
ͺͻͰͯ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ

ͼͰ
͹ͺͰͽ
Ͳͪ͸Ͱͷͪͻ;ΒͰ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͫͳͽ͸͹
͹ͯͻͰΌͰΔͰ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͳ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
͵ͪ͹

΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
ͼͪ
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
ͻͪͲ͸͹ͬͻͼ͸ͳͷ
͹ͫͶͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͳ
͸ͰͲͪ͹ͫͳͶͪͲ͸͹ͷ

ͬͰͻͽͳ͵ͪͶ͹ͷ
͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͵ͪ͹
͵͹ͺ΂ͪ
ͳͷͪͭͳ͸ͪͻ͸Ͱ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ



Ȋʛʌʆʓʈ
TB

5PVS
(VJEF


 ͠͹ͬͪ͸͵ͪ
͚͹ͻΌͰͬͳΕ͠͹ͬͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ

΁ͳΒͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
ͳ
ΔͰ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͸ͪͼͽ͹ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͬͶͪΌ;Β;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳͷͪ

ͺ͹ͯͼͽͪ͵͸;ͽͳ
͵͹ͷͰͻ΁ͳΒͪͶ͸ͳͷ
ͰͿͰ͵ͽ͹ͷ
ͺͻͰͽͬͪͻͪΒ;Εͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵Ͱ

ͪ͸ͽͳ͵Ͱ
;
ͼͰͭͷͰ͸ͽͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͷͪͻ΃ͻ;ͽͰ
ͬͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͼ͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
;

ͬͰͻͼ͵ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
̈́͹͵ͪ͵͸ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͯ͹ͷͪΕͳ΀
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͪ
͸ͳͼ;
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯ

ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͰ
ͼͳͷͫ͹Ͷͳ΂͸Ͱ
ͪ;ͽͰ͸ͽͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
͌
Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΔ;

ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
;
ͼͰ͸΁ͳ
΁ͰͶ͹ͬͳͽͳΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪΒ;
͹ͼ͹ͫͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳ
ΒͰ
͹ͫΒͰͯͳΔ;Β;
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͽͳ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
ͼͪ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳͷ
͋ͪ͵ͬͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͪ

ͭͻ΂͵͹ͭ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
͸ͪ
tͺͻͪͬͳi
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ
ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͽͰͽ
;
ͼͬ͹Β
ΔͰͭ͹
ͬ͹Β
ͯͳ͸ͪͷͳ΁ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;
͹ͯ
ͳͷͪͭͳ͸ͪͻ͸͹ͭ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͽͰͽͪ

ͳͲͻͪͱͰ͸͹ͭ
ͼͳͷͫ͹Ͷͳͷͪ

̸̸͉͉̈́́͋̾͋͌

Ȅʒʐʠʌʊʂ

m
Ȑʆʒʊʈʄʈʔʊʋʚ
ʉʛ•ʂʔʂ
Ȕʑʐʅʐ•ʜ
ʋʂʊ
Ȑʒʐʓʆʄʄʝʓʆʊʥ
Ȅʒʐʠʌʊʂ

ȋʐʕʋʝʂ
ͰE

Ȋʛʎʔʒʐ
ȍʆʐʆʌʌʈʎʊʋʢʎ
ʆʒʆʕʎʢʎ
ȁʉʈʎʚ

(SFFDF

m
(SFFDF
5IFTTBMZ
.FUFPSB
)FMMFOJD
/BUJPOBM
5PVSJTN
0SHBOJ
TBUJPO
"UIFOT
'MFNJOH

m
,BUISZO
&
'MFNJOH
0SJFOUBMJTN
UIF
#BMLBOT
BOE
#BMLBOT

BOE
#BMLBO
)JTUPSJPHSBQIZ
"NFSJDBO
)JTUPSJDBM
3FWJFX

Ȋʛʌʆʓʈ
TB

m
Ȉʆʓʓʂʌʝʂ
ȁʌʛʏʂʎʅʒʐʥ
Ȋʛʌʆʓʈʥ
ͰE

Ȑʐʌʊʔʊʓʔʊʋʟʥ
ʐʒʄʂʎʊʓ•ʟʥ

ȅʌʂʓʓʟʎʂʥ
ȅʌʚʓʓʐʎʂ
5PVS
(VJEF

m
5PVS
(VJEF
GPS
UIF
"SFB
PG
&MBTTPOB
)FMMB
&MBTTPOB

Ȓʋʐʠʃʂʒʂ

m
ȅʕʚʄʄʆʌʐʥ
ȁ
Ȓʋʐʠʃʂʒʂ
ȏʌʕ•ʑʊʢʔʊʓʓʂ
ȁʋʂʅʈ•ʝʂ
ȁʉʈʎʢʎ

ȁʉʈʎʚ
 ͌
ͼͰ͸΁ͳ
͇Ͷͳͷͺͪ 

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

+PWBOLB
%KPSEKFWJǀ+PWBOPWJǀ
*N
4DIBUUFO
EFT
0MZNQVT

(MÅO[FOEFS
.BSNPS
VOE
EBT
BOUJLF
"UIFO
[V
;FJUFO
WJLUPSJBOJTDIFS

3FJTFCFSJDIUFSTUBUUFS
BMT
4JOOCJME
(SJFDIFOMBOET
VOE
EFT
HFTBNUFO
HSJFDIJTDIFO

/BUJPOBMXFTFOT
BL[FQUJFSU
TJOE
BVDI
JO
EFS
3FJTFMJUFSBUVS
BMT
FYJTUFO[JFMMFT

.PEFMM
BOFSLBOOU
TP
EBTT
NPEFSOF
3FJTFGÛISFS
EVSDI
EBT
HBO[F
(SJFDIFOMBOE

OBDI
FJOHFGMFJTDIUFS
(FXPIOIFJU
FCFOGBMMT
EJF
BOUJLF
,VMUVS
VOE
EJF
3FHJPOFO

GBWPSJTJFSFO
JO
EFOFO
EBT
BOUJLF
&SCF
LPO[FOUSJFSU
JTU

3FHJPOBMF
3FJTFGÛISFS
EVSDI
;FOUSBMHSJFDIFOMBOE
5SBLJFO
5FTTBMJFO

PEFS
HSJFDIJTDIF
*OTFMO
TJOE
WJFM
LPOLSFUFS
VOE
WFSTVDIFO
NFJTUFOT
OFCFO

BMMHFNFJO
CFLBOOUFO
3FJTF[JFMFO
BVDI
BVG
XFOJH
CFBDIUFUF
IJO[VXFJTFO
WPS

BMMFN
EBEVSDI
EBTT
TJF
*OGPSNBUJPOFO
JO
)ÛMMF
VOE
'ÛMMF
MJFGFSO
VN
#FTVDIFS

IJO[VMPDLFO
/PDI
QSÅ[JTFS
TJOE
0SUTSFJTFGÛISFS
EJF
BVG
LVS[
&OUTDIMPTTFOF


3FJTFOEF
BC[JFMFO
BVG
#BDLQBDLFS
PC
,VS[
PEFS
-BOHTUSFDLMFS
EJF
PIOF

(SVOELFOOUOJTTF
ÛCFS
EJF
(FTDIJDIUF
EFT
KFXFJMJHFO
0SUFT
EFTTFO
UZQJTDIFO

(FJTU
OJDIU
FSLFOOFO
LÕOOUFO
BVDI
XFOO
TJF
FT
TFIOMJDI
IFSCFJXÛOTDIUFO

%VSDI
EJF
&OUXJDLMVOH
EFT
5PVSJTNVT
BOHFTQPSOU
WFSTVDIFO
HSJFDI
JTDIF
3FJTFBHFOUVSFO
OJDIU
OVS
BVG
EBT
BOUJLF
VOE
CZ[BOUJOJTDIF
&SCF

TPOEFSO
BVDI
BVG
'PMLMPS
(BTUSPOPNJF
VOE
/BUVSTDIÅU[F
(SJFDIFOMBOET
[V

WFSXFJTFO
5PVSJTUFO
XFSEFO
[V
FJOFN
#FTVDI
JN
BMUFSOBUJWFO
IFEPOJTUJTDIFO

(SJFDIFOMBOE
FJOHFMBEFO
EBT
OFVF
4ZNCPMF
BOCJFUFU
TPOOFOIFMMF
4USÅOEF

'FUB,ÅTF
JO
4BM[MBLF
PEFS
JN
0MJWFOÕM
3FUTJOB
#VTVLJ

5SPU[EFN
CMFJCFO
BMM
EJFTF
OFV
FOUTUBOEFOFO
TUFSFPUZQFO
#JMEFS

(SJFDIFOMBOET
BMT
1SPEVLUF
HVU
EVSDIEBDIUFS
8FSCFLBNQBHOFO
JN
4DIBUUFO

EFT
BMUFO
(SJFDIFOMBOET
BMT
USBEJUJPOFMMFO
4ZNCPMT
EFT
"MUFSUVNT
JN
4DIBUUFO

EFS
"LSPQPMJT
VOE
.BSNPSQMBTUJLFO
EFS
(ÕUUFS
WPN
0MZNQVT

/FVF
;FJUFO
GÛISFO
JN
5PVSJTNVT
OFVF
.B“TUÅCF
IFSCFJ
WPS
EFOFO

BVDI
FJOF
TP
XJDIUJHF
#FTUJNNVOH
FJOFT
-BOEFT
[VSÛDLXFJDIFO
NVTT
XJF
EJF

,VMUVS
NJU
JISFS
NBOOJHGBMUJHFO
&STDIFJOVOHTGPSNFO
VOE
VOVNHÅOHMJDIFO

TUVGFOBSUJHFO
&OUXJDLMVOH

6OUFS
EFN
%SVDL
LPNNFS[JFMMFS
&GGFLUF
WFSTVDIFO
3FJTFMFJUFS
IFVU[V
UBHF
JO
JISFS
'VOLUJPO
BMT
7FSNJUUMFS
[XJTDIFO
JNBHJOÅSFO
UPVSJTUJTDIFO

%FTUJOBUJPOFO
VOE
EFSFO
1SÅTFOUBUJPOFO
JO
"OTQSÛDIF
VOE
'PSEFSVOHFO
JISFS

SFJTFMVTUJHFO
,VOEFO
FJO[VXJMMJHFO
JOEFN
TJF
BOUJLF
%FOLNÅMFS
JO
"CTDIOJUUF

JISFS
3FJTFSPVUFO
EBT
CZ[BOUJOJTDIF
&SCF
EBHFHFO
JO
EFO
3FMJHJPOTUPVSJTNVT

WFSXBOEFMO


 ͠͹ͬͪ͸͵ͪ
͚͹ͻΌͰͬͳΕ͠͹ͬͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ

7PO
MPLBMFO
7FSMBHFO
IFSBVTHFHFCFOF
VOE
WPO
FJOIFJNJTDIFO
"VUPSFO

WFSGBTTUF
3FJTFGÛISFS
TJOE
LFJO
1SPEVLU
EFS
*OEVTUSJF
EJF
TZNCPMJTDIF

"VUIFOUJ[JUÅU
IFSTUFMMU
*O
JISFO
1SÅTFOUBUJPOFO
EFS
JN
4DIBUUFO
HFCMJFCFOFO

4UÅEUF
XFSEFO
&JHFOUÛNMJDILFJUFO
EFS
KFXFJMJHFO
3FJTF[JFMF
[VTBNNFOIÅOHFOE

ÛCFSCMJDLU
3FMJLUF
EFS
7FSHBOHFOIFJU
NJU
BLUVFMMFO
LPOTFRVFOU
WFSLOÛQGU


4PMDIF
HFUSFVFO
"CCJMEFS
EFS
HSJFDIJTDIFO
4UÅEUF
XFJTFO
BVG
EJF
tFDIUFi

/BUJPOBMJEFOUJUÅU
JO
EFSFO
EZOBNJTDIFS
&JHFOBSU
IJO
EJF
FJOF
JNBHJOÅSF
WPO

4ZNCPMFO
HFUSBHFOF
/BUJPOBMJEFOUJUÅU
LPOUSBQVOLUJFSU

̹͹Βͪ͸ͪ
̸͇̺́̓́ͣ̓͋́ͣ͡ͅ
́ͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

̸͈̾̀̿́͠
̹̾̀
̸͊̾̈́
ћ
̸̸̸͉̻́͆̈́́̀ͅ͏̸́͠

̸͉͉͇̻͌̈́͆
͌
99
̺̾̓͌












̸͆
͈͉͉́̾͌ͅ
̸͎͆̾͐̓́ͅ

̸̹͉̾̽̾̓̾

̸͸ͪͶͳͲ͹ͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
͸ͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ΀
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ

99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒ;
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͼ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂ΒͰͷ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͳ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹ͭ

̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
͹΂ͳͭͶͰͯ͸͹
ͯͪ
;
Δͳͷͪ
;͹ͺ΃ͽͰ
͸Ͱͷͪ
ͼͰͶͪ
͵ͪ͹
΁ͳΓͰͬͪ

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͪ
ͯͪ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
;͹ͺ΃ͽͰ
͸Ͱͷͪ
͸ͳ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
ͫͰͲ
͹ͫͲͳͻͪ

΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
;
ͺͻͬ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
;
ͷ͸͹ͭͳͷ
ͺͻͰ
ͯͰͶͳͷͪ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͷͪͶ͹
ͳͲͷͰΔͰ͸
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ

ͳͲͭͶͰͯ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ͸ͪ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͼͰͶͪ
͋͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͫͳͶ͹
͹΂ͳͭͶͰͯ
͸͹
;
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺͻͰͽͰͱ͸͹
ͼͽ͹΂ͪͻͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼ;
;
͹ͯ
͸͹ͼ;
͸ͪ
9*9
ͬͰ͵
ͺͻͰͽͻͺͰͶͪ
͸ͪΒͷͪΔͰ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
;
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͳΒͳ
ͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸;

ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
͊Ͱ͹ͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͽ͸͹
ͼ;
ͼͰ

ͻͪͲͶͳ͵͹ͬͪͶͰ
͹ͯ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͳ΀
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͺͪ
ͼ;
ͷ͹ͭͶͰ
ͯͪ
ͫ;
ͯ;
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ
΁ͳΓ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
́
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͽ͹ͭͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹
ͬͪΔͰ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
Ͳͪ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͼͬͰͶ͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͰ

Ͳͪ
ͺͰΒͲͪͱ͸Ͱ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰ
ͺͻͰͽͰͱ͸͹
Ͳͪ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͪ
̾͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
ͳ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
͹͸
ͯ͹͸͹ͼͳ

;ͽͳ
΂;
͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸;
ͼͬͰͼͽͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͰ΂͸͹ͭ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͸Ͱ͵͹ͭ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͪ
͌ͺͻͪ
ͬ͹
ͽͪ͵ͬͳͷ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͯͻ;΃ͽͪͬͪ
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸ͳ

ͼ;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
;
ͯͻ;ͭ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
Ͳͪ

;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰ
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹Βͪͬͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͼͰ΂ͪ͸
΂͹ͬͰ͵
͸Ͱ
ͫͳ
ͼͷͰ͹
ͯͪ
ͺͻ͹
ͺ;ͼͽͳ
;͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͷ;
ΒͰ
ͼͽͪͶ͹
ͯ͹
ͼ͹ͺͼͽͬͰ͸Ͱ
͹ͺ΃ͽͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͌
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷ
ͼ͵ͳ
ͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ͸ͳͷ
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸ͪͷͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
ͼͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
9*9
ͳ

 ̹͹Βͪ͸ͪ
ͅͳΓ͵͹ͬͳἘͪͽͳΕ

99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺͻͪͲ͸Ͱ
ΒͰͻ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ͹
͹ͯͶͪͲͳ
;
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͪ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
͋ͪ͵ͬͳ

ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸ͳ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼͳ
ͺ͹ͼͽͰͺͰ͸͹
ͼ;
;ͽͳ΁ͪͶͳ
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͭ;ͫΓͰΔͰ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹
ͬͪΔͪ
Ͳͪ
ͻ;ͻͪͶ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
͸ͪΒͺͻͰ
͵͹ͯ
ͬͳ΃ͳ΀
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸ͳ΀
ͼͶ͹ΒͰͬͪ
ͪ

ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͳ
͵͹ͯ
ͬͰΕͳ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͸Ͱ͵͹ͭ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͪ
͉;ͻͪͶ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ

ͺͻͳͬͶͪ΂Ͱ
͹ͽͪͯͪ
ͺͪͱΔ;
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
͵ͪ͹
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
ͼ
ͶͰͺͳͷ
ͺͰΒͲͪͱͳͷͪ

ͳͶͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͷͰͼͽͪ
ͭͯͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͹ͯͳͭͻͪͶͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳ
ͳͶͳ

ͭͯͰ
ͼ;
͹ͽ͵ͻͳͬͰ͸ͪ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͪ
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ΃ͽͪ
͊ͰͶ͹
͵ͪ͹
ͪͻ΀ͳ
ͽͰ͵ͽ͹͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͺͰΒͲͪͱ͸ͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸ͪ
΁ͰͶͳ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵͹
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ͹

ͳ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
ͳ
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͪ
ͺͻͰͼͽͪΒ;
ͯͪ
ͺͻͳͬͶͪ΂Ͱ

ͺͪͱΔ;

͆ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ;
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
͸;ͯͰ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲͪͽͳ

ͯͪ
ΒͰ
99
ͬͰ͵
ͯ͹ͬͰ͹
ͯ͹
ͷͪͻͭͳ͸ͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͻ;ͻͪͶ͸͹ͭ
;
ͼͬͰͼͽͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͰ΂
͸͹ͭ
ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͳ͸ͪ
͋͹
ͺ͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
;͹΂Γͳͬ͹
ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
;ͺ͹ͻͰͯͰ
ͼͪͯͻ
ͱͪΒͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ
ͳͲ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͼͪ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳͷͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͳͲ
99
΂ͪ͵
ͳ
;͵͹
Ͷͳ͵͹
ͼͰ
;Ͳͷ;
;
͹ͫͲͳͻ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
͹ͫͰΒ;
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͻ͸ͳ΀
ͬͻͼͽͪ
́ͪ͵͹

ͼ;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͳ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
;ͼͷͰͻͰ͸ͳ
͸ͪ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰ
΂ͳͽͪͶͪ΁ͪ
ͼ
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͳͷͪ

͵͹ΒͰ
͸ͰͷͪΒ;
͸ͪͷͰͻ;
ͯͪ
ͼͪͷͳ
͹ͫͳΌ;
ͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸ͳ
͹͸ͳͷͪ
͵͹
Βͳ
;ͺͻͪͬ͹
͸ͪͷͰͻͪͬͪΒ;
ͯͪ
ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳ
ΒͰͯ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
͸Ͱ
ͫͳ

ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͯͻͪͼͽͳ΂͸͹
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;Β;
͵ͪͯͪ
ͼ;
;
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹ͼͽͳ

ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ΀
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͪ
́ͺͪ͵
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͼ;
͹΂ͳͭͶͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͫͪͻ
͵ͪ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
;
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
ͼͰͶͪ
ͳ
ͻ;ͻͪͶ͸ͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
͸ͳͷͪͶ͹
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ͸Ͱ

́͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͪ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸͹Β
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͳ
ͫͳ
Ͷ͹
ΒͰ
ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹
͹΂ͳͭͶͰͯ͸͹
ͳ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͺ͹ͯͻ͹ͫ͸͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁ͳͷͪ
;͵ͪͲͳͬͪ͸͹

͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
͸ͪ
ͼͰͶͪ
͵ͪ͹
͸ͰͲͪ͹ͫͳͶͪͲ͸Ͱ
ͰͽͪͺͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͳ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͳ΀

͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͳ
͸ͪ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ;
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ͸;
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒ;
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͰ
ͳ
͸͹΃Δ;
ͺͪ
ͳ
͸ͪ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
Δͳ΀͹
ͬͰ
ͳͼ΀ͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͳͶͳ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰΌͳͬͪΔͪ
ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
͸ͪ
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸͹ͭ
ͱͳͬ͹
ͽͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
͹ͼͽͪΒ;
͸ͪ
ͷͪͻͭͳ͸ͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ

ͬͰΕ
ͳ
͸Ͱ͵ͳ΀
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂ͪ
ͽͲͬ
ͰͭͲ͹ͽͳ΂͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͪ
̺Ͱ͹ͷͪ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
ΒͰ

͸ͪͭͶͪ΃ͪͬͪ͸͹
͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸͹ͼͽ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͺͪ
ͳ
͊ͻͫͳ
ΒͰ
;ͺͻͪͬ͹
ͼͰͶ͹
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯ
ͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
;
ͽ͹Β
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸ͳ
͊ͽ͹ͭͪ

ͼ;
ͫͳͶͰ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷ
;͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͰ͸Ͱ
ͳͲΒͪͬͰ
ͺ͹ͺ;ͽ
͹͸Ͱ
̈́ͪͼͶͪ
͎;ΔͪͯͳΒͪ
ͯͪ
ͽͰ͵

ͺ͹
ͳͲͶͪͼ͵;
ͳͲ
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
tͺ͹΂ͳΔ;
͹͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸Ͱ
͹ͯͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͪ
<>

͵͹ΒͰ
͵͸ͰͱͰͬͳ͸;
΂ͳ͸Ͱ
͹ͼ͹ͫͳͽ͹ͷi
͊͵ͻͰͽͪ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁ͪ
͸ͪ

ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰ
ͺͰΒͲͪͱͪ
ͪ
͹ͯ;΃ͰͬΓͰΔͰ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͪͷͪ
ͺ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
ͼͰ

ͺͻͰͽͬͪͻͪͶ͹
;
ͼͰ͸ͽͳͷͰ͸ͽͪͶ͸Ͱ
͹ͺͳͼͰ
ͺͻͰͺ;͸Ͱ
Ͱͷ͹΁ͳΒͪ
͈͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͼ;



̹͹ͱͳͯͪͻ
̓͹ͬͪ΂Ͱ͵
͈;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ
͹
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͭͻ͹Ϳͪ
̈́ͪͼͶͪ
͎;ΔͪͯͳΒͪ
̀ͫ͹ͻ͸ͳ͵

ͪͅͽͳ΁Ͱ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
Ͳͪ
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
ΒͰͲͳ͵
͵Δ

ͼͬ

͆͹ͬͳ
͊ͪͯ


 ͈ͰΒͲͪͱͳ
ͫͰͲ
ͼͰͶͪ 

ͳͼͽͳ΁ͪ͸ͳ
͵͹͸ͽͻͪͼͽͳ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͸Ͱͯͳͻ͸;ͽͳ΀
΃;ͷͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͪ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽͳ
ͬͳͼͪ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
ͺͻͳ
΂Ͱͷ;
͸ͳͼ;
ͫͳͶͳ
Ͳͪ͸ͰͷͪͻͰ͸ͳ
ͬͰΕ
͸ͪͭͶͪ΃Ͱ͸ͳ

ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
ͲͪͼͰΒͪ͸ͳͷ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪͷͪ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹ͷ
͵ͬͪͶͳͽͰͽ;
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͽ͹

ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͻͰͯ͹ͬ͸͹
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ
;
ͳͽͳ͸ͰͻͰͻͳͷͪ
̸ͷͳ
̹;Ͱͪ
"NJ
#PVF

͹
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺ
ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͋;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
͢ͳ΀͹ͬ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
΂ͳ͸ͳͶͰ
ͼ;
ͽͪͯͪ
ͳ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸͹

ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ͵͹ͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸Ͱ
ͬͻͼͽͰ
ͺ͹Γ͹ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͲͰͷΓͳ΃ͽͪ
ͭͯͰ

ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
͸ͪͭͶͪ΃ͪͬͪ͸͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͫͪ΃ͽͪͷͪ
Ͳ͹ͬ;
ͳ
ͬ͹ΕΔͪ
΁ͳ
Ͳͪͺ;΃ͽͰ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͼͶͳ΂͸ͳ
͹͸ͳͷͪ
;
̸ͲͳΒͳ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͬͻͽΔͪ΁ͳ
;ͻͰΌͰ͸ͳ
;

ͺͻͪͬͳͶ͸ͳͷ
ͶͰΒͪͷͪ
ͷͪͯͪ
ͲͪͼͰΒͪ͸ͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
͸ͪΒ͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳΒͳͷ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪͷͪ

ͳ
Ό;Ͷͳͼͽͪ͸ͳ
΁ͬͰͽ͸Ͱ
ͫͪ΃ͽͰ
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͫͰͲ
ͶͰΒͪ
͐ͪ͵
ͼ;
͸ͪͫͻͪΒͪ͸Ͱ

ͳ
ͬͻͼͽͰ
΁ͬͰΕͪ
ͳ
ͬ͹Εͪ
;
ͽͳͷ
ͫͪ΃ͽͪͷͪ
́͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͪ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͯ
ͻ;΂Βͪ
ͳͼ͵ͪͲͪ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͪͷͪ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸ͪ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰΌͳͬͪΔͪ
ͼͰ͹
ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
͌͵ͪͲͳͬͪ͸͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭͰ
ͯͰͽͪΓͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹

͹͸Ͱ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͹ͯ;ͯͪͻͪͶͳ
͹ͯ
ͼͽͪ͸ͯͪͻͯͪ
;
̀ͪͺͪͯ͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
͹ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
ΒͰ
͸ͪ

̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͳ͹
͸ͪΒͬͰΕͳ
ͫͻ͹Β
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͼͺͻͰͷ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ΀
ͯͪ

ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͫͰͶͰ΃͵Ͱ
ͳ
͹ͫΒͪͬͳ
͌ͺ͹ͻͰΌͳͬͪ͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸

͹ͻͰͲͳͬͪΔͪ
ͬͳ͸͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
;
͸Ͱ͵͹Β
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵͹Β
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͳ
;
͈ͻ;ͼ͵͹Β

͈͹ͯͻ͹ͫ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͳͼ΀ͻͪ͸ͪ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
ͺͻͳ
΂Ͱͷ;

΂ͳͽͪͶͪ΁
͸ͳΒͰ
;ͺ;Εͳͬͪ͸
ͼͪͷ͹
;
͵ͬͪͶͳͽͰͽ
ͳ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸Ͱ
͸ͪͷͳͻ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͽͰ
ͳͼ
΀ͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͬͰΕ
ͳ
;
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͰ
΀ͻͪ͸Ͱ
͇ͬͳ
ͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻͳ

ͺ͹͵ͪͲ;Β;
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͪ͹
ͳͲͻͪͱͰ͸
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ
ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
΂ͳͽͪͶͪ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ;
ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͯͪ
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΒ;
ͷ͸͹ͭͰ
ͯͰͽͪΓͰ
͹
ͼͰͶͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵͹ͷ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸;
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ

;
ͷͪͶ͹
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳͷ
ͳ
ͼ͵͹ͻ͹
ͰͭͲ͹ͽͳ΂͸ͳͷ
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳͷͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹
ͺͰ
͆ͳ
ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱ͸͹
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͪ
ͼͰͶ͹
͸ͳΒͰ
ͳͼ͵ͪͲͪ͸͹
;
ͫͰͯͰ
͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͼ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵ͪ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͬͰΕ
͸ͳ
ͳͲ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͳͼͽ͹ͭ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
͌ͬͪͱͪͬͪΒ;Εͳ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁;
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ
ͫͳ͹
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸
ͯͻ;ͭͪ΂ͳΒ͹Β

ͺ;ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
͸Ͱͭ͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ΁
ͼͪͷ͹ͼͽͪͶ͸͹
ͳ
ͺ͹

ͼ͹ͺͼͽͬͰ͸͹ͷ
ͳͲͫ͹ͻ;
ͽͻͪͱͳ͹
΁ͳΓ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͵ͶͪͼͳͿͳ͵͹ͬͪ͹
ͳ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪ
Ͳͳͬͪ͹
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͹
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸͹Β
ͲͰͷΓͳ
ͪ
ͺͳͼͪ΁
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
͸ͪͼͽ͹Βͪ͹
ͯͪ

;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͼ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ͯͪ
͹΂Ͱ͵;ΒͰ
ͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳͷͪ



8JMMJBN
%FOUPO
4FSCJFO
VOE
EJF
4FSCFO
/BDI
BOEFSFO
2VFMMFO
VOE
FJHFOFO

&SGBISVOHFO
GSFJ
CFBSCFJUFU
%BWJE
WPO
$ÕMMO
#FSMJO




"NJ
#PVÊ
3FDVFJM
EzJUJOFSBJSFT
EBOT
MB
5VSRVJF
Ez&VSPQF
%FUBJMT

HFPHSBQIJRVFT
UPQPHSBQIJRVFT
FU
TUBUJTUJRVFT
TVS
DFU
&NQJSF
7JFOOF




"NJ
#PVF
-B
5VSRVJF
Ez&VSPQF
U
***
1BSJT




̺ͳͶ΀ͰͶͷ
͉ͳ΀ͽͰͻ
͈ͻͳͶͳ͵Ͱ
;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͺ͹ͯ
͵͸ͰͲ͹ͷ
ͅͳͶ͹΃Ͱͷ
ͯ͹
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ

ͪͫͯͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ
͸ͪΒ͸͹ͬͳΒͳ΀
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͪ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵ͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ

͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
ͳ
ͽ͹ͺ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͪ
ͼ͵ͳ΁ͪ
̓͸ͰͱͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
̓ͻͪͭ;ΒͰͬͪ΁



 ̹͹Βͪ͸ͪ
ͅͳΓ͵͹ͬͳἘͪͽͳΕ

͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
ͯͪ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪ
͵ͻͰΕ;Εͳ
ͼͰ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͪͬ΁ͳͷͪ

͹ͯͼ;ͼͽͬ͹
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ
Ͳͪ
ͼͰͶ͹
͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͳͺͳͼͪͽͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͽͳͷ
ͻͪͲ
Ͷͳ͵ͪͷͪ

ͅ͹ͭͶ͹
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͽͺ͹ͼͽͪͬͳͽͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͯͼ;ͼͽͬ͹
;ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͸ͪ
Ͳͪ͸ͳ
ͷΓͳͬ͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͼͰͶͪ
;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
;ͼͶ͹ͬΓͰ͸͹
͸Ͱͯ͹ͼͽͪͽ
͵͹ͷ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ͸ͳ΀
ͬͰͲͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͫͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͯ͹ͬͰͶͰ
ͯ͹
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͪ

̓ͻͪΒͰͷ
9*9
ͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͼ;

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪͶͳ
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΁͹ͷ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
;
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
ͳͷͪͶͪ
͸ͰͻͪͲͬͳ
ΒͰ͸;
ͷͻͰͱ;
ͺͻ;ͭͪ
ͺͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͯ͹ͼͽ;ͺ͸͹ͼͽ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ΀
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͽͰ΃͵ͪ
ͳ

ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͪͽͳ΂͸ͪ
͋͹
ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͭͶ͹
ͯͪ
;ͽͳ΂Ͱ
͸ͪ
͹ͯͼ;ͼͽͬ͹
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ

;
;ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ΒͰͻ
ͼ;
ͼͰͶͪ
ͳͷͪͶͪ
ͼ;ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͷͪͶ͹
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹
ͼͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪͶͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͯ;ͲͳͷͪͶͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͰ
ͬ͹Ͳ͸ͳͷ
ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͳͷͪ
ͻͪͯͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹ͭ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͪ
ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͯͪ
͸ͳΒͰ

ͻͰ΂
͹
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͰͺͻͰ͵ͪͷͪ
͹ͫͳͶͪͼ͵;
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͳ΀
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
ͬͰΕ
ͯͪ

ΒͰ
;
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
ͼ;΃ͽͳ͸ͼ͵͹
͹ͯͼ;ͼͽͬ͹
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲ;Β;
ͺͻͳͷͰͻͳ

ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͯͶͪͱͰ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹ͭ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ

ͻͪͯͳ
͹ͫͳͶͪͼ͵ͪ
͸ͪΒͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳΒͳ΀
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͪ
͇ͯͼ;ͼͽͬ͹
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰ
ͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ
Ͳͪ
ͻ;ͻͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ΒͰ
;͹΂Γͳͬ͹
;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
ͳͲ

ͼͻͰͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͳͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͽͪͯͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸͹
ͺͻͰͬ͹Ͳ͸͹

ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬ͹
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͼͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪ͹
ͳ
͹ͼͽͪ͹
ͪ;ͽ͹ͷ͹ͫͳͶ
́
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ

ͺͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
͹͸
ͺͻ;ͱͪ͹
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͯ͹Ͷͪͼ͵ͪ
;
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ

ͻͰͽ͵͹
ͼ;
͵ͪͯͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͺ͹͵ͶͪΔͪͶͳ
ͺͪͱΔ;
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͫͳ
ͺ;ͽ
͸ͳ͵Ͱ
͸ͪͬͰͶͳ
͸ͪ
͹ͫͳͶͪͲͪ͵
͸Ͱ͵ͳ΀
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͳ΀
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
ͼͪ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸ͳͷ

ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ;ͻͰ
ͳͶͳ
ͪͷͫͳΒͰ͸ͽͪͶ͸ͳͷ
΁ͰͶͳ͸ͪͷͪ
͵ͪ͵ͬͰ
ͼͰ

ͽͰ΃͵͹
͸ͪͶͪͲͰ
;
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳͷͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
͢ͳ΀͹ͬ͹
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͪ

ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸ͪ
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͼͰ
͹ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂ͪͬͪͶ͹
͸ͪ
ͺͻͰ
ͲͰ͸ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͳͶͳ
ͯͬͰ
Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
Γ;ͯͳ
;
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹Β
͸͹΃Δͳ
ͳͶͳ

Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵Ͱ
͵;ΕͰ
́ͪ͵͹
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͭͶͪ
ͼͽͪͬͳͽͳ
ͺͻͳͷͰͯͫͪ
ͯͪ

ͼ;
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
ͼͰͶͪ
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
͹ͼͽͪͶͪ
ͳͲͬͪ͸
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͪͬͪ΁ͪ

ͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͪ
ͷͻͰͱͪ
;
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͻͰͶͪͽͳͬ͸͹
͸ͰͻͪͲ
ͬͳΒͰ͸ͪ
ͪ
͵ͬͪͶͳͽͰͽ
ͺ;ͽͰͬͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͬ͹ͯͳͶͳ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
;ͯͪ
ΓͰ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͪͬͪ΁ͪ
͹ͼͰͽ͸͹
Ͷ͹΃ͳΒͳ
͸Ͱͭ͹
;
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ

ͪ;ͽ͹ͷ͹ͫͳͶ
͵ͪ͹
ͺͻͰͬ͹Ͳ͸͹
ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬ͹
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͼ
Ͷͪ͵͹Ε͹ͷ
ͼͪͬͶͪͯͪͽͳ
ͽͰ

ͺͻͰͺͻͰ͵Ͱ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪͶ͹
ͳͲͻͪͱͰ͸͹
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͪ
Ͳͪ
ͬͻͼͽͰ



#BFEFLFST
"MMJBO[
3FJTFGVISFS
+VHPTMBXJFO
#BFEFLFS
4UVUUHBSU'SFJCVSH
T

B

&SOTU
/FVNBZS
8FSOFS
1êTUFS +VHPTMBXJFO
#VDIDMVC
&Y
MJCSJT
;ÛSJDI



 ͈ͰΒͲͪͱͳ
ͫͰͲ
ͼͰͶͪ 

ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
͸;ͯͳͶͪ
ͻ;ͻͪͶ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
͌
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͭ
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ

΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͺͰΒͲͪͱ͸Ͱ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
;
Βͪ
ͯͻͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
͈ͻͳͷ͹ͻΒ;
ͻͰͯ͹ͬ͸͹
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͰ
ͷͰͼͽͪ
;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
ͳͪ͵͹

ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹
ͳͲͭͻͪͯΔͰ
ͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͷͪͭͳͼͽͻͪͶͰ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵Ͱ
;
ͽ͹Β

͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
͸ͳͼ;
ͫͳͶͰ
ͫ͹ΓͰ
͸Ͱͭ͹
;
ͯ;ͫͳ͸ͳ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹Ͷ;͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸͹ͷ
;
9*9
ͬͰ͵;
͹ͽͬͪͻͪͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷ
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͪ
Βͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
͸ͪΕͳ
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
;
΀ͪ͸͹ͬͳͷͪ
;Ͳ
ͬͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰͽ͸Ͱ
ͼͪ
͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
;
ͺͻͬ͹ͷ
ͻͰͯ;
;Ͳ
͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳ
ͯͻ;ͷ
͊ͽ͹ͭͪ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ

ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ΁ͳ
͹ͯͷͪͻͪͶͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͭ͹ͼͽͳ
;
;ͼͪͷΓͰ͸ͳͷ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͳ
ͷͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͼͰͶͳͷͪ
ͳ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͹
Δͳͷͪ
;͸͹ͼͳͶͳ
ͼ;
;
͹ͫͪͬͰͲ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͫͰͶͰ
΃͵Ͱ
͋͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͻͪͲͶ͹ͭͪ
΃ͽ͹
͹
ͽͪ͵ͬͳͷ
ͷͰͼͽͳͷͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͳ
ͯ͹
͸͹ͼͰ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬͪ
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂ͰΔͪ
ͳͼͽͳ͸ͪ
͸Ͱ
;ͬͰ͵
ͳ
ͺ͹;Ͳͯͪ͸ͪ
͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ

;
99
ͬͰ͵;
ͺ͹ͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪͶͪ
ͼ;
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͪΒ
;
΀͹ͽͰͶͳͷͪ
͸ͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ

;ͬͰ͵
ͼ͵ͻͰΕ;
ͺͪͱΔ; 
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ
ͷͰͼͽͳͷͪ
;ͯͪΓͰ͸ͳͷ
͹ͯ
ͺ;ͽ͸͹ͭ

ͺͻͪͬ΁ͪ
ͬͻͰͯ͸ͳͷ
͹ͫͳͶͪͼ͵ͪ
ͳ
͸ͪ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸ͳ΀
ͳͲͶͰͽͪ

ͺ͹͸Ͱ͵ͪͯ
ͳ
ͬͳ΃Ͱͯ͸Ͱͬ͸ͳ΀
͈͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͸ͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ

;ͺ;Εͳͬͪ͹
ͼͰ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͳΒͳ
ͯͰ͹
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͼͻͰͯΔͰ
͵ͶͪͼͰ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͬͳ΃ͳ΀

͵Ͷͪͼͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͳͷͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͳ
͸͹ͬ΁ͪ
ͳ
͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪ
Δͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼ;
ͺͻͳͶͳ΂͸͹
ͯ;ͭ͹
ͽͻͪΒͪͶͪ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͻͰͶͪͽͳͬ͸͹
ͼͺ͹
ͻ͹ͭ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒͪ
͋ͪ͵ͬ͹Β
͵ͶͳΒͰ͸ͽͰͶͳ
͹ͫͻͪΕͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͺͪ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ

ͷ͹ͭͶ͹
ͺͻͰͽͺ͹ͼͽͪͬͳͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
͸Ͱ͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪΒ;ΕͰ
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͪΒ͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ

ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
ͯͪ
;ͭ͹ͼͽͰ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͷͰ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
͸ͪͬͳ͵ͶͰ
͸ͪ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸

ͼͽͪ͸ͯͪͻͯ
͹ͯͬͻͪΕͪͶͰ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͪ΂Ͱ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
͹ͯ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹ͭ
;ͺ;ΕͳͬͪΔͪ
͵ͪ

ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͳͷ
͸ͪͼͰΓͳͷͪ
͋͹ͷͰ
ͺͻ͹ͽͳͬͻͰ΂ͳ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ
9*9
ͳ

ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
΁ͳΓ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹Ͷ;͹
ͼͽͻͬͪ
ͫͳ͹
ͪͲͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͯͰ͹
͋;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͭͯͰ
ͼ;
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͫͳͶͰ
Β͹΃
͸Ͱͺ͹ͬ͹Γ͸ͳΒͰ

͸Ͱͭ͹
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
ͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ͽͲͬ
ͰͭͲ͹ͽͳ΂͸Ͱ
ͽͪ΂͵Ͱ
ͽ͹ͭ
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹



́ͲͻͪͲͳͽ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
;ͺ;ΕͳͬͪΔͪ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
-FT
(VJEFT

#MVFT
:VHPTMBWJF
-JCSBJSF
)BDIFUUF
1BSJT

́ͪ͵͹
ͯ͹͸͹ͼͳ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͼͪͱͰͽͰ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ

͹͸
ͻͰͯ͹ͬ͸͹
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͪͬ΁ͳͷͪ
ͼ͵ͻͰΕͰ
ͺͪͱΔ;
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ͵;
͸ͪ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸Ͱ
ͬͳͼ͹ͬͰ

ͳͶͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͺͰΒͲͪͱ͸Ͱ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͪ
ͼ
͸ͪͬ͹ΌͰΔͰͷ
͸ͪͯͷ͹ͻͼ͵ͳ΀
ͬͳͼͳ͸ͪ

ͪͶͳ
͸Ͱ
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͼͰͶͪ
;
ͽͳͷ
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳͷͪ


#BFEFLFST
"VUPSFJTFGÛISFS
+VHPTMBXJFO
VOE
(SJFDIFOMBOE
NJU
FVSPQÅJTDIFS

5ÛSLFJ
4UVUUHBSU
T
B
<>



;PSBO
,POTUBOUJOPWJǀ
%FVUTDIF
3FJTFCFTDISFJCVOHFO
ÛCFS
4FSCJFO
VOE

.POUFOFHSP
.ÛODIFO




+
"
$VEEPO
+VHPTMBWXJFO
&JO
'VISFS
%FVUTDI
WPO
ѮPNBT .VOTUFS OBDI
EFS
0SJHJOBMBVTHBCF
EJFTFT
#VDIFT
uѮF $PNQBOJPO (VJEF UP +VHPTMBWJBu
JN
7FSMBH

$PMMJOT
-POEPO
1SFTUFM7FSMBH
.VODIFO
T
B


ͳ
ͯͻ
͌
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
-FT

(VJEFT
#MVFT
:VHPTMBWJF
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
;Ͳ
ͼͬͪ͵͹
ͷͰͼͽ͹
;
͵͹ͷͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͳ

ͳͷͰ
΀͹ͽͰͶͪ
 ̹͹Βͪ͸ͪ
ͅͳΓ͵͹ͬͳἘͪͽͳΕ

͹͸Ͱ
ͬͰͲͪ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Βͪ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͺͻͳͬͶͪ΂ͳͶͰ

ͺͪͱΔ;
͐ͪ͵
ͼͰ
;
͸Ͱ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
ͼ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵ͪ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͼͪ
ͬͰͽ;ΒͰ
;ͲͳͷͪΔͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͬ͹ͯͳͶͪ΁ͪ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
Ͷͪ͵΃Ͱ
ͼͪͬͶͪͯͪͶͰ

ͺͻͰͺͻͰ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͼͪͷ͹ͼͽͪͶ͸͹
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪͶ͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͯ͹
͸ͪΒͲͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬͳ
Βͳ΀
΁ͳΓͰͬͪ
͸ͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
;ͺ;ΕͳͬͪͶͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͫͰͲ
͹ͫͲͳͻͪ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͵ͬͪ
ͶͳͽͰͽ
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͪΒͪ
͸ͪ
ͽͪͷ͹΃Δͳͷ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
Ͳ͸ͪͽ͸͹
͹ͯ;ͯͪͻͪ͹
͹ͯ

;͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͰ͸͹ͭ
͈͹ͯͳͲͪΔͰͷ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͳͬ͹ͪ
ͬͰΕͳ͸Ͱ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯ͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹
ͺͰ
;
ͯͻ;ͭ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͰͷ
ͼͬͰ
ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͷͪͽͰͻͳ
ΒͪͶ͸͹
ͼͬͰ
ͫ͹ΓͰ
ͼͳͽ;ͳͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͼͻͰͯΔͰ
͵ͶͪͼͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͺ͹
ͼͽͪΒ;
ͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺͪ΂͸ͪ
ͳ
;͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͰ͸ͪ
ͷͰΌ;
ΔͰ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͢ͳ΀͹
ͬͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪͶͪ
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͪΒ
;
΀͹ͽͰͶͳͷͪ
͊ͷͰ΃ͽͪΒ
͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
͸ͳͼ;
ͼͰ
;
ͷͰΌ;ͬͻͰͷͰ͸;
ͺ͹ͺͻͪͬͳͶͰ

ͪͶͳ
ͼ;
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸͹
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ͸Ͱ
ͬͰͲͰ
ͺ͹ͫ͹Γ΃ͪ͸Ͱ
΂ͳͷͰ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹
ͬͰΕͪ͹
ͳ
ͻͪͯͳΒ;ͼ
͵ͻͰͽͪΔͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
͋͹
ΒͰ
͹ͽͬ͹ͻͳͶ͹
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
Ͳͪ
ͫͻͲ͹
ͳ

ΒͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͪͬ͸͹
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͪ
ͫͪͻ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸ͳ΀

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͳͲ
ͬͰΕͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳ΀
΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͽͪ
͹͵͹Ͷ͸͹ͼͽ
͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͪͬͰͶͪ

ͺͳͼ΁Ͱ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͯͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
;͵ͪͱ;
͸ͪ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
͇͸ͪ
ͼ;
ͳ

ͯͪΓͰ
͹ͼͽͪͶͪ
͸ͪ
ͷͪͻͭͳ͸ͳ
ͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͼ;
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹
͵ͻͪΒͪ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͵ͪ͹
΁ͳ
ΓͰͬͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
Ϳ͹͵;ͼͳͻͪͶͳ
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵Ͱ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͰ
͇ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͳͼͪ͸͹ͼͽ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͪ΂ͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
͸ͪ
;ͻͫͪ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ

ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͳͶ;ͼͽͻ͹ͬͪͽͳ
͸ͪͭͶͪ΃Ͱ͸ͳͷ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͰͷ
Ͳͪ
ͼͺͰ
΁ͳͿͳ΂͸Ͱ
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸Ͱ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼ;
͹΂;ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͻ;ͻͪͶ͸ͳ
ͰͶͰͷͰ͸ͽͳ

Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Βͪ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ΂͸ͳ
;ͺͻͪͬ͹
Ͳͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
͉;ͻͪͶ͸͹
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ

ͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͪ΂Ͱ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͫͳͶ͹
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹
ͼͪͷ͹
ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͬͰͲͪ͸͹
Ͳͪ
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͪ

͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
ͳ
ͼͽ͹ͭͪ
͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͺ;΃ͽͪΒ;
ͯͪ
;ͺ;ͽͰ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
͸ͪ
ͽͰ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸͹
ͼͽͳ
΂ͪ͵
ͳ
ͼͽͪ͸ͯͪͻͯͳͲ;Β;
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸Ͱ
ͽͰͻͷͳ͸Ͱ
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
Βͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
͹ͫͰͶͰͱͳͶͳ

ͼͬ͹Βͼͽͬͪ
ͽͪ͵ͬͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳ΀
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
͉Ͱ΂
ΒͰ
͹
(BSUFOTUÅEUF
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳͷͪ

ͬͻͽ͹ͬͪ
͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ΒͰ
͸ͪΒͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳΒͳ
ͳ
;ͬͰ͵
͸ͪͭͶͪ΃Ͱ͸͹
Ͳͪͼͽ;ͺΓͰ͸
̹ͳͽ͹Γ

ͅ͹͸ͪͼͽͳͻ

̻͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͯͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
;
͵͹ͷͰ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͳͼͽͪ͵͸;
ͽͪ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͪ
͹ͬͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
;
ͯ͹Ͷͳ͸ͳ
̺ͪͻͯͪͻͪ
t͵;Εͪ
ͼͪ
ͬͰͻͪ͸ͯͪͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ

ͼͰ
;Ͳͯͳͱ;
͸ͪ
͹ͫͻ͹͸΁ͳͷͪ
́͸ͽͰ͸Ͳͳͬ͸͹
ͺ͹ͬͻͽͪͻͼͽͬ͹
ͳͲͻͪͱͰ͸ͪ
ͫͻͳ
ͭͪ
͹͵͹
ͼͳͼͽͰͷͪ
Ͳͪ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯΔͪͬͪΔͰi
̽ͪ
ͷͪͻͭͳ͸ͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͼͰͶͪ
;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
ͯͳ΁ͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
Ͷ͹΃ͳ΀
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ͸ͳ΀
ͬͰͲͪ
ͳ
͸Ͱ͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪΒ;Εͳ΀
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͪΒ͸ͳ΀



,BSM
#BFEFLFS
,POTUBOUJOPQFM
#BMLBOTUBBUFO
,MFJOBTJFO
"SDIJQFM
$ZQFSO

)BOECVDI
GVS
3FJTFOEF
-FJQ[JH
7FSMBH
WPO
,BSM
#BFEFLFS

9**


#BFEFLFST
"VUPSFJTFGÛISFS
+VHPTMBXJFO
VOE
(SJFDIFOMBOE
NJU
FVSPQBJTDIFS

5ÛSLFJ


 ͈ͰΒͲͪͱͳ
ͫͰͲ
ͼͰͶͪ 

ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂Ͱ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͷͪͶͳ΀
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ΀
͹ͫͶͪ
ͼͽͳ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼ;
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
Ͳͪ͹ͫͳΌͰ͸ͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳͷͪ
ͺͻ;ͱͪΒ;

ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͪ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
͌
Δͳͷͪ
ͼ;
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
͸ͪͭͶͪ΃Ͱ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ

ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰ
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
͵͹ͽͶͳ͸ͪ
ͳ
͸ͳͲͳ͸ͪ
ͯ͹͵

ͼͰ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͪ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔ;
ͼͪͷ͹
͵ͪ͹
ͻͪͼ͵ͻͼ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͺ;ͽͰͬͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͷͰͼͽͪ
;

΂ͳΒ͹Β
ͼͰ
ͫͶͳͲͳ͸ͳ
͹ͯͳͭͻͪͶͪ
͸Ͱ͵ͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͪ
ͫͳͽ͵ͪ
ͳͶͳ
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹͸ͪΌͰ͸͹

Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸͹
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵͹
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ΃ͽͰ
͋ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ

ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
͋͹ͺͶͳ΁Ͱ
;
͵͹Β͹Β
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͯͬͪ
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͪ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
m
͈ͻ͹͵;
ͺΓͰ
ͳ
̓;ͻ΃;ͷͶͳΒͪ
m
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸͹
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸͹
Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹
ͳ
͵;Ͷ
ͽ;ͻ͸͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͯ͹͵
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽ͹
ͼͬͰͭͪ
ΒͰͯ͸͹
ͼͰͶ͹
m
͈Ͷ͹΂͸ͳ͵
;
͵͹ͷͰ

ͼͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͬ͹Βͼ͵ͪ
͵͸ͰͲͪ
̈́ͪͲͪͻͪ
ͼ;͵͹ͫͳͶͪ
ͼ
͋;ͻ΁ͳͷͪ
ͳ
;
΂ͳΒ͹Β
ΒͰ

ͫͶͳͲͳ͸ͳ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ΃ͽͰ
ͬͳ͸΂ͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͊Ͱ͹ͼ͵ͪ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
;
͹ͬͪ͵ͬͳͷ

ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔ;
ͼͰ
Β͹΃
ΒͰͯͳ͸͹
;
͵͹͸ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
ͷͳ͸ͰͻͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͫͪΔͪ
ͳ

ͶͰ͵͹ͬͳͽͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͪ
Ͳͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͬͰͲ;ΒͰ
ͳ
͸Ͱ͵͹
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹
ͺͻͰͯͪΔͰ
͋Ͱ΃͵͹
ͫͳ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͺ͹ͬͰͲͪͽͳ
͹ͯͼ;ͼͽͬ͹
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ

99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͼ
;ͫͻͲͪ͸͹ͷ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ

ͳ
;ͻͫͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ΀ͬͪͽͳͶͪ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂ΒͰ
;
ͯͻ;ͭ͹Β
ͺ͹
Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͋ͳ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼͳ
͸ͳͼ;
;͸ͳ΃ͽͳͶͳ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͼͰ͹
ͼ͵Ͱ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ;ͻͰ
ͳ
ͺͰΒͲͪͱͪ
;
͸ͪΒͬͰΕͰͷ
ͯͰͶ;
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͆ͪͺͻ͹ͽͳͬ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ
΁ͳͷͪ
;ͻͫͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ΀
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸ͪ
ͷ͹ͭͶͪ
ͼ;
͹΂;ͬͪ͸ͪ
ͻ;ͻͪͶ͸ͪ
͹ͫͰͶͰͱΒͪ

ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ΀
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͪ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͽͳ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ
΁ͳΓ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
́
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͽ͹ͭͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͼͰͶ͹
ͳ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ

;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
͸Ͱ
͹ͫͪͲͳͻ;
͸ͳ
͵ͪͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
͸ͪͭͶͪ΃ͪͬͪΒ;
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͲͰͷΓͪ
ͳͶͳ

͹ͫͶͪͼͽ
͸ͪ
͵͹Β;
ͼ͵ͻͰΕ;
ͺͪͱΔ;
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵;
ͺ͹Γ͹ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ͸ͪ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͯͪ
;

Δ͹Β
ͺͻͰ͹ͬͶͪͯͪͬͪ
ͼͽ͹΂ͪͻͼͽͬ͹
ͳͶͳ
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͻͪͯΔͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
͸Ͱ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
ͳͼ
ͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͼͽ͹΂͸ͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
ͺͻͰͯͰ͹
ͼ
ͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ͸ͳͷ
ͼͽ͹΂ͪͻͼͽͬ͹ͷ
ͶͰͺͳͷ

΃;ͷͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͳͷ
ͺͪ΃Δͪ΁ͳͷͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͼͰ
͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
͸ͳ
ΒͰͯ͸͹
ͼͰͶ͹

́Ͳͬ͹ͻͳ΃ͽͰ
͹ͬͪ͵ͬͳ΀
ͷͪͻͭͳ͸ͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͰ
͹΂ͳͭͶͰͯ
͸Ͱ
ͬͰΕ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
΁ͳΓ͸ͪ
ͭͻ;ͺͪ
͵͹Β͹Β
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͹ͫͻͪΕͪͶͳ

ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͳ
͹΂Ͱ͵ͳͬͪΔͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͰ
ͽͰ
΁ͳΓ͸Ͱ
ͭͻ;ͺͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰͷ

ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
ͯͪ
ͫ;ͯ;
Ͳͪͯ͹ͬ͹ΓͰ͸Ͱ
̓ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸͹
ͽͪͯͪ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͽ;ͻͳ
ͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
;ͺ;ΕͳͬͪͶͳ
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͬͳ΃ͳ΀
͵Ͷͪͼͪ
ͳ

ͭ͹ͻΔͰ
ͼͻͰͯΔͰ
͵ͶͪͼͰ
͋ͪ
ͭͻ;ͺͪ
ͳͷͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͿͳͶͳͼͪ͸ͪ
͹΂Ͱ͵ͳͬͪΔͪ
͹ͯ

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͳͲͭͻͪΌͰ͸ͪ
͵Ͷͪͼͳ΂͸ͳͷ
΃͵͹Ͷ͹ͬͪΔͰͷ
ͳ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͼͽ;ͯͳΒ



̓ͻ͹Ͳ
͋͹ͺͶͳ΁;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͼͪͬͰͲ
͋͹ͺͶͳ΁Ͱ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

ͫ
ͭ



̓ͻ͹Ͳ
͋͹ͺͶͳ΁;



#BFEFLFST
"VUPSFJTFGÛISFS
+VHPTMBXJFO
VOE
(SJFDIFOMBOE
NJU
FVSPQÅJTDIFS

5ÛSLFJ

 ̹͹Βͪ͸ͪ
ͅͳΓ͵͹ͬͳἘͪͽͳΕ

ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͼ;
͵ͪ͹
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂͸ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͻͱͪͶͳ
ͽͪ

͹΂Ͱ͵ͳͬͪΔͪ
͢ͳͷͪ
ͼ;
ͺͻͳͶͪͭ͹ΌͰ͸ͳ
ͳ
΁ͳΓͰͬͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
m
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͳ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
Ͳͫͳͻ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͯͰͶͪ

͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͼ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͼ͵;Ͷͺͽ͹ͻͼ͵ͪ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͳ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ͹͸ͼ͵ͪ
͋;
ͺ;ͫͶͳ͵;

͸ͳΒͰ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷͪ͹
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ
͹ͫͳ΂͸ͳ΀
Γ;ͯͳ
ͼͪͷͳͷ
ͽͳͷ
͸ͳ
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸ͪ
;
͵͹Β͹Β

ͼ;
ͱͳͬͰͶͳ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͯͻͱͪͶͳ
ͽ;
ͽͰ͸ͯͰ͸΁ͳΒ;
;
ͺͻ͹
ͷͰ͸ͳ
ͼͬͰͼͽͳ
ͬͰΕ
ͼ;
ͼͶͳ΂͸;
ͼͬͰͼͽ
͸ͪͼͽͪͬͳͶͳ
ͯͪ
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͻͪΒ;
ͳ
͵ͪͯͪ

ͼͰ
ͼ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳͷ
ͻͪͲͬ͹ΒͰͷ
ͳ
ͫͶͪͭ͹ͼͽͪΔͰͷ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯ͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ

ͺͻ͹΃ͳͻͳ͹
͵ͻ;ͭ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͳ΀
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
͵ͪͯͪ
ͼ;
ͳ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳ
ͺͻͳ
ͺͪͯ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͼͻͰͯΔͰ
͵ͶͪͼͰ
ͷͪͼ͹ͬ͸͹
͵ͻͰ͸;Ͷͳ
͸ͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ

͋ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͻͪ͸ͪ
ͼͬͰͼͽ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
΁ͳΓͰͬͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
;ͻͫͪ͸Ͱ
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸Ͱ
;

͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼ;
ͼͪ΂;ͬͪ͸ͳ
͸ͪΒͬͻͰͯ͸ͳΒͳ
ͽͻͪͭ͹ͬͳ
΁ͳͬͳͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͳͲ
ͬͪ͸
Δͳ΀
ͬͻͰͯ͸ͳ
΁ͳΓͰͬͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͳ
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ

Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽͳ
ͳ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ͹͸ͼ͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
͊ͽ͹ͭͪ
ͼͰ
ͭ;ͫͳ
;ͻͪͬ͸͹ͽͰͱͰ
͸͹ͼͽ
;ͻͫͪ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
ͻ;ͻͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ΂͸ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͰ

ͳͲ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͵ͪͯͪ
ͼ;
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͪ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷͪͶͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹

ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸͹
Ͳͪ
͹ͬ͹
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͼͽ͹ͭͪ
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͷ͸͹ͭͪ
ͼͪ΂;ͬͪͶͪ

͹ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͰ
ͳ
͹ͫͰͶͰͱΒͪ
ͪ
ͼͰͶͪ
ͺͻͳͬͶͪ΂ͳͶͪ
ͺͪͱΔ;
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
ͳ
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͪ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸͹ͷ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬͪΔͪ

ͳͼ΀ͻͪ͸͹ͷ
ͳ
͹ͯͰͬͪΔͰͷ
;ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͷͰ
͹ͯ;ͯͪͻͪͶ͹
͹ͯ
;͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͰ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪ
ͬͪ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͹
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ;
́
;
99
ͬͰ͵;
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸

ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
;
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ
͸ͰͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ͸ͳͷ

ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͽ͸͹
ͼͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵͹ͬͪ͹
͹ͯ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸ͪ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
;
Ͳͪͺͪͯ
͸͹Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͼͰ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͪ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ

ͳͺͪ͵
ͼͬͰͶ͹
͸ͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͪ
ͺͰΒͲͪͱ͸Ͱ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰ
ΒͰͻ
ΒͰ
;
ͷͰΌ;ͬͻͰͷͰ
͸;
ͺͻ͹ͷͰΔͰ͸ͪ
ͼͬͰͼͽ
͹
ͽ͹ͷͰ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͼͽͳ΁ͪΔͰ
͹ͺ
΃ͽͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͋Ͱ͵
;
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔ͹Β
΂Ͱͽͬͻͽͳ͸ͳ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
;
̀ͪͺͪͯ͸͹Β

̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
͸ͪͻͪͼͽͪ͹
ͺ͹͵ͻͰͽ
Ͳͪ
͹ͽͬͪͻͪΔͰ
ͷ;ͲͰΒͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͽͬ͹ͻͰ͸͹ͷ
΂ͳΒͳ
ΒͰ

Ͳͪͯͪͽͪ͵
ͫͳ͹
ͯͪ
͹΂;ͬͪ
ͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶ͸Ͱ
͹ͼͽͪͽ͵Ͱ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸ͪ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
ͳ

ͼͰͶ͹
͵ͪ͹
ͪͷͫͳΒͰ͸ͽͪͶ͸;
΁ͰͶͳ͸;
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
;
ͷͰΌ;ͬͻͰͷͰ͸;
ͼͽͰ͵Ͷ͹
ͼͽͪͽ;ͼ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͰͺͰ͸͹
ͼͰ
ͫ;ͯͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
Ͳͪ

ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͪ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
͇͸͹
ΒͰ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
ͫͳͶ͹
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
͹ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂Ͱ͸͹
ͳ
ͺͻͰͽͰͱ͸͹

;ͼͷͰͻͰ͸͹
͸ͪ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵Ͱ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ
ͳ
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͳ΀

ͼͻͰͯͳ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͵ͬͰ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͳ
͵ͻͪΒͺ;ͽͪ΃ͳ
ͳͶͳ
ͺͻ͹Ϳͪ͸ͳ
ͺͻͳͲ͹ͻͳ

΀ͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͺͳΕͪ
͸ͪ
ͭͻ͹ͫΓͳͷͪ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͼͬͰͽ͵͹ͬͪΔͪ
Ͳͪͯ;΃͸ͳ΁ͪ
;
ͳͼ
ͽ͹΂͸͹Β
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ

͇ͬͪ͵ͪͬ
ͼͽͪͽ;ͼ
ͼͰͶͪ
;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͸ͪͼͽͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͳͿͰͻͰ͸
΁ͳͻͪΔͰͷ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
͇͸͹
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͺ͹ͬͰͲͪ͸͹
ͼ
͸ͰͼͽͪΒͪΔͰͷ



+
"
$VEEPO
+VHPTMBWXJFO
&JO
'VISFS



+
"
$VEEPO
+VHPTMBWXJFO
&JO
'VISFS

 ͈ͰΒͲͪͱͳ
ͫͰͲ
ͼͰͶͪ 

ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ
Ͳͪ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵Ͱ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ΒͰͻ
;
Δͳͷͪ
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
͸ͳͼ;
ͫͳͶͳ

ͼͪ΂;ͬͪ͸ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͹ͫͰͶͰͱͪͬͪͶͳ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͯͪ͵
ͳͶͳ
ͬͻ΀;͸ͪ΁
;
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β;
΁ͳͬͳͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͬͰΕ
ͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶ͸ͳ
ͽͻͪ
ͭ͹ͬͳ
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸͹ͭ
;ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͷͰ
ͳ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸͹ͭ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
͵͹Βͳ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵

͸ͳͼ;
ͼͷͪͽͻͪ͸ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳͷ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͊ͽ͹ͭͪ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸Ͱ

͹ͼͽͪΒ;
ͳͲͬͪ͸
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
͋Ͱ͵
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͯͳͼͽͪ͸
΁ͪ
;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ;
͸ͪ
ͪ;ͽͰ͸ͽͳ΂͸;
ͻ;ͻͪͶ͸;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ;
ͫͳͶͪ
ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͪ

ͯͪ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯͳ
ͽͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͼͽͰ͵͸;
ͼͽͪͽ;ͼ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͺ͹͸͹
ͬ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹΂Ͱ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͫ;ͯͳ
ͳͼͽͳ͸ͪ
m
ͯ͹ͼͽͪ
ͼͽͳͯΓͳͬ͹
ͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ
Ͳͪ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͪ

ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
 ̹͹Βͪ͸ͪ
ͅͳΓ͵͹ͬͳἘͪͽͳΕ

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

#PKBOB
.JMKLPWJǀ,BUJǀ
-BOETDIBGUFO
PIOF
%ÕSGFS
.BSHJOBMJTJFSVOH
EFT
SVSBMFO
&MFNFOUFT








JN

+BISIVOEFSU
EBSHFTUFMMU
BN
#FJTQJFM
FJOJHFS
EFVUTDIFS
3FJTFGÛISFS

*N
6OUFSTDIJFE
[VS
3FJTFMJUFSBUVS
EJF
%ÕSGFSO
VOE
MÅOEMJDIFS
6NHF

CVOH
TDIMFDIUIJO
WJFM
"VGNFSLTBNLFJU
TDIFOLUF
VOE
TUÅEUJTDIF
VOE
SVSBMF

&MFNFOUF
BVG
EFN
(FCJFU
EFT
8FTUCBMLBO
FJOTDIMJF“MJDI
4FSCJFO
RVBOUJUBUJW

HMFJDINœJH
CFIBOEFMUF
XBSFO
MÅOEMJDIF
(FHFOEFO
JO
3FJTFGÛISFSO
BMT
FJOFN

CFTPOEFSFO
(FOSF
EFS
3FJTFMJUFSBUVS
JN
7FSMBVG
EFT

+BISIVOEFSUT
WÕMMJH

NBSHJOBMJTJFSU
%JFTFN
.BOHFM
BN
*OUFSFTTF
MBHFO
&SXBSUVOHFO
QPUFOUJFMMFS

#FOVU[FS
XJF
BVDI
WFSÅOEFSUFT
(FTFMMTDIBGUTCFXVTTUTFJO
[VHSVOEF
%BT
XBSFO

OÅNMJDI
EJF
;FJUFO
SBTDIFS
*OEVTUSJBMJTJFSVOH
XP
JNNFS
NFIS
"OTÅTTJHF
JISF

%ÕSGFS
WFSMJF“FO
XBT
[VN
7FSMVTU
EFT
*OUFSFTTFT
BN
-ÅOEMJDIFO
GÛISUF
%JF

;JFMHSVQQF
BO
EJF
TJDI
EJF
3FJTFGÛISFS
XFOEFO
XPMMUFO
CJMEFUFO
"OHFIÕSJHF

IÕIFSFS
(FTFMMTDIBGUTTDIJDIUFO
VOE
PCFSFS
.JUUFMTDIJDIU
TFJU
EFS
.JUUF
EFT


+BISIVOEFSUT
BVDI
EFS
TÅNUMJDIFO
.JUUFMTDIJDIU
%JFTF
;JFMHSVQQF
IBUUF
QSP
GJMJFSUF
&SXBSUVOHFO
IJOTJDIUMJDI
VOUFSOPNNFOFS
3FJTFO
EJF
TJF
JISFS
LMBT
TJTDIFO
"VTCJMEVOH
VOE
JISFO
[VS
5SBEJUJPO
HFXPSEFOFO
4UVEJFOSFJTFO
EBO
LFO
LPOOUF
"MT
QSBLUJTDIF
)FMGFS
VOUFSTUÛU[UFO
3FJTFGÛISFS
EJFTF
&SXBSUVOHFO

EFOFO
EBOO
BVDI
3FJTF[JFMF
BOHFQBTTU
XVSEFO
m
CFLBOOUF
LVMUVSHFTDIJDIUMJDIF

;FOUSFO
4UÅEUF
XJF
BVDI
.BM
#JMEIBVFS
VOE
"SDIJUFLUVSXFSLF
%JFTFT
1V
CMJLVN
JOUFSFTTJFSUF
TJDI
XFEFS
GÛS
EBT
BMMUÅHMJDIF
-FCFO
FJOGBDIFS
.FOTDIFO

OPDI
GÛS
EJF
6NHFCVOH
JO
EFS
EJFTF
XPIOUFO
%JF
3FJTFGÛISFS
VOUFSTUÛU[UFO

EJFTF
5FOEFO[
JN
WFSÅOEFSUFO
#FXVTTUTFJO
VOE
CFXBISUFO
TJF
BVDI
[V
;FJ
UFO
XP
EBOL
XJSUTDIBGUMJDIFS
&OUXJDLMVOH
VOE
FSIÕIUFN
-FCFOTTUBOEBSE
EFS

XFTUFVSPQÅJTDIFO
-ÅOEFS
EFS
#FOVU[FSLSFJT
GÛS
EJF
3FJTFGÛISFS
JNNFS
CSFJUFS

XVSEF
4P
XVSEF
EFTTFO
#FXVTTUTFJO
HFGPSNU
OBDI
EFN
BMT
TFIFOTXFSUF
3FJ
TF[JFMF
BVTTDIMJF“MJDI
HFTDIJDIUMJDIF
VOE
BSDIÅPMPHJTDIF
-PLBMJUÅUFO
XJF
BVDI

BSDIJUFLUPOJTDIFT
&SCF
CF[FJDIOFU
XVSEFO
#FJ
UJFGFSHSÛOEJHFS
%JGGFSFO[JF
SVOH
EFT
,VMUVSUPVSJTNVT
XVSEFO
EJFTF
*OIBMUF
[VN
&SXFSC
EFS
"MMHFNFJO
CJMEVOH
JNNFS
XJDIUJHFS
%B
JO
MÅOEMJDIFO
(FNFJOTDIBGUFO
NFJTUFOT
LFJOF

LVMUVSHFTDIJDIUMJDIFO
%FOLNÅMFS
BVGCFXBISU
XVSEFO
EJF
'PSUTDISJUUF
PEFS

)ÕIFQVOLUF
JO
EFS
&OUXJDLMVOH
FJOFS
,VMUVS
XJEFSTQJFHFMUFO
TPOEFSO
MFEJH
MJDI
NBUFSJFMMF
4QVSFO
EFT
"MMUBHTMFCFOT
WFSTDIXBOE
EBT
*OUFSFTTF
BO
MÅOEMJ
DIFO
(FCJFUFO
PEFS
WFSXBOEFMUF
TJDI
JOT
*OUFSFTTF
BO
TDIÕOFO
-BOETDIBGUFO

 ͈ͰΒͲͪͱͳ
ͫͰͲ
ͼͰͶͪ 

&STU
BMT
EFS
DISPOPMPHJTDIF
"CTUBOE
HSP“
HFOVH
XBS
LPOOUFO
1SPEVLUF
EJFTFS

BVUIFOUJTDIFO
SVSBMFO
,VMUVS
[V
,VMUVSEFOLNÅMFSO
CFGÕSEFSU
XFSEFO
"MT
JO

8FTUFVSPQB
EJF
#FXFHVOH
BO
#FEFVUVOH
HFXBOO
EJF
TJDI
GÛS
'SFJMJDIUNVTFFO

FJOTFU[UF
EFSFO
"VGHBCF
XBS
NBUFSJFMMF
3FTUF
EFS
MÅOEMJDIFO
-FCFOTXFJTF
XJF

BVDI
%ÕSGFS
BMT
-FCFOTNJMJFV
[V
QGMFHFO
FSXBDIUF
JN
'SFNEFOWFSLFIS
XJF
EFSVN
EBT
*OUFSFTTF
BO
MÅOEMJDIFS
6NHFCVOH
&T
XBS
USPU[EFN
ÛCFSXJFHFOE

BVG
%PSGLJSDIFO
VOE
FJOJHF
#FTPOEFSIFJUFO
EFS
MÅOEMJDIFO
-FCFOTXFJTF
FUXB

(SBCTUFJOF
BN
4USB“FOSBOE
CFTDISÅOLU
̽ͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
̸͊͆͌
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

͉͈͇͊͊̓

͉͇̺͇̺͇͊̾̽̾̓͆͢

̸͚͆͊̈́̾̾
͌
̸͉͆́ͅ

̸͆̾͐̓́ͅͅ

̸̸͈͇̺͇͚͌͋ͅ

̾ͬͻ͹ͺΓͪ͸ͳ͸
ͼͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ


ͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵ͪ

ͼͽ͹ͶͰΕͪ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͰ
ͳͶͳ
Ͳ͸ͪͽͳͱͰΓͰ
͸ͪ΃ͪ͹
;
ͼͳ
ͽ;ͪ΁ͳΒͳ
ͯͪ
ͺͻͰͯ;ͲͷͰ
ͽͰͭ͹ͫ͸͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
;
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͰ
ͳͷͪ͹

ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͻͪͼͺ͹ͶͪͭͪΔ;
ͺͻ͹ͬͰͻͰ͸Ͱ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
ͅͰΌ;
Δͳͷͪ
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ;
ͻͰ
ͺ;ͽͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͼ;
ͼ
ͻͪͲͶ͹ͭ͹ͷ
;ͱͳͬͪͶͳ
#BFEFLFS
ͳ
.FZFS
ͳͲ
̈́ͪΒͺ΁ͳͭͪ
͌Ͳ

͸ͳͲ
͸Ͱ͹ͺ΀͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
͹ͫͪͬͰ΃ͽͰΔͪ
ͳ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ΀
ͼ;ͭͰͼͽͳΒͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͽͳ΁ͪ
Ͷͳ
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂͸Ͱ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͹ͬͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͸;ͯͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͳ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸Ͱ

ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΂͵͹ͷ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌ;
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ΀
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪ

͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
;͵Γ;΂;Β;Εͳ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
̓ͪ͵͹

ͼ;
ͽ͹
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂ͳ
ͬͰΕ
ͳͼͽͪ͵Ͷͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͪ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹

͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͳͬͪ͸ͳ
ͼ;
;
͹ͬͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
;
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͼͶ͹ΒͰͬͪ
͵ͪ͹

ͻͪͲͯ͹ͫΓͰ
ͪ͸ͽͳ͵Ͱ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͼͻͰͯΔͳ
ͬͰ͵
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ
͹ͼͷͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͬͶͪͯͪͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ

ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸͹
ͯ͹ͫͪ
ͽ͹
ΒͰͼͽ

ͼͽ͹ͶͰΕͰ
͇ͬ͹ͷ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͺͻͰͯͷͰͽ
͸ͪ΃Ͱ

ͺͪͱΔͰ
ͫͳΕͰ
ͻͰ΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
;
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;
ͽͳͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ

͈ͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪΔͪ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͬͳ΃Ͱͼͽͻ;͵͹
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹ͭ
ͺͳͽͪ
Δͪ
ͬͪͱ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͳͷͪͽͳ
͸ͪ
;ͷ;
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;

ͬͰ͵;
͸ͪ
΃ͳͻ͹͵͹ͷ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹ͷ



̺
͚
͊
̓͹ͼͽͳΕ
̺ͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͼ͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
͆ͳ΃
ͳ
̺ͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͪ
**

͆ͳ΃

m
%KPSEKF
4
,PTUJǀ
#BFEFLFS
VOE
.FZFS
m
&JO
#JME
EFS
#BMLBOIBM
CJOTFM
GÛS
3JTFOEF
#BMDBOJDB
999*7

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

m

 ̽ͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ

ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͪ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸;
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
Ͷ͹
ͬͪͱͪ͸
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
;͵;ͺ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͰ͹͵;ͺͪ΁ͳΒͪ

Γ;ͯͳ
̹ͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯͳ΁ͪ
ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͽ͹͵͹ͬͪ
m
ͫ͹ͻͫͰ

ͺ͹͵͹ͻͰ͸ͳ΀
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
Ͳͪ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹
͹ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ΌͰΔͰ
΂ͳΒͳ
ΒͰ
ͳͼ΀͹ͯ
ͫͳͶ͹

ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͰ
͸͹ͬͳ΀
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
̓ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͸ͪ
΃ͶͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
;
ͼͪͷ͹ͷ
ͼͻͰͯͳ΃ͽ;
ͽͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͫ;ͶͰ͸ͽ͸ͳ΀
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΔͪ
͌
ͼͬͰͼͽͳ

ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͼͻͰͯΔͳ
ͬͰ͵
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪͬͪ͸
͵ͪ͹
ͲͶͪͽ͸͹
ͯ͹ͫͪ
΀ͻͳ΃Εͪ͸
ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͵ͪͯͪ
ͼ;
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
ͶͰͭͳͽͳͷͳ
ͽͰͽ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ΀
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ΀
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
̓ΔͳͱͰͬ͸ͪ
ͳ
;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͺ͹
ͺ;Ͷͪͻ͸ͪ
ͷͪ΃ͽͪ
ͼͽ͹ͭͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
Ͳͪ͹͵;ͺΓͰ͸ͪ
ͷͳͽͼ͵ͳͷ
Ͷͳ͵͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͳͼͽ͹
ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͽͪͭ͹͸ͳͼͽͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳͷͪ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ

̺ͪͱͪ͸
ͳͲͬ͹ͻ
͸ͪͯͪ΀͸;Εͪ
ͫͳͶͳ
ͼ;
͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͳ
ͳ
Ͱͺͼ͵ͳ
Β;͸ͪ΁ͳ

ͬͰΕ
ͳ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸ͳ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͳ
ͯͻͰͬ͸Ͱ
ͻ;΃Ͱͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵Ͱ
ͻͰ
Ͷͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ
̀ͪ
͸ͪ΃
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷ
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
ΒͰ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸͹
ͯͪ
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͳ
ͯ͹
͹ͽ͵ͻͳΕͪ

ͬͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
΂ͳͷͰ
ΒͰ
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸
͹ͺ΃ͽͳ
͹͵ͬͳͻ
Ͳͪ
ͫ͹ΓͰ

ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪΔͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹ͭ
ͼͽͬͪͻͪͶͪ΃ͽͬͪ

͇ͫͪͬͰ΃ͽͰΔͪ
͹
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹Β
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹Β
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂
͵͹ͷ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌ;
;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͯ͹΂Ͱ͸ͳ
͸ͪ
ͯͬͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͪ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸ͪ

͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͹ͺͳͼͰ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ΀
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
m
΁ͻ͵ͪͬͪ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͪ
ͽͬͻΌͪͬͪ
m
ͳ

;Ͳ
ͺ͹ͷ͹Ε
ͷͪͶͳ΀
;ͬ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
ͻͪͼͺͻͪͬͪ
ͳͶͳ
͵ͻͪͽ͵ͳ΀
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
͹ͼͬͻͽͪ

;ͷͰͽ͸;ͽͳ΀
;
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ
͌Ͳ
͹ͺ΃ͽ;
ͫͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒ;
͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ

ͺ͹Ͷ;͹ͼͽͻͬ;
͵͹ͻͳ΃ΕͰ͸ͪ
ͼ;
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸ͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸ͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹Β
ͳͼͽ͹
ͻͳΒͳ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵͹Β
ͫͪ΃ͽͳ͸ͳ
͈ͪͯͪ
;
͹΂ͳ
ͯͪ
;
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͱͰ͸͹ͷ

ͼͺͳͼ͵;
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͰ
ͺͻͰ͹ͬͶͪΌ;Β;
͵ΔͳͭͰ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸Ͱ
͸͹ͬͳΒ͹Β
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹Β
ͺ͹
ͬͰͼͽͳ
ͯ͹͵
ͼͰ
Ͳͪ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰ
ͼͪ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹΃Ε;
ͳ
ͼͺ͹
ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂ͳͬͪͶͪ
ͷ͹͸͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ
͹
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
͍ͰͶͳ͵ͼͪ
̓ͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ

͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
;
̈́ͪΒͺ΁ͳͭ;

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͌
ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;
ͼ
ͺͻͪ͵ͼ͹ͷ
;ͼͽͪΓͰ͸͹ͷ

;
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂͵ͳͷ
͵;Εͪͷͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͪ
ͳͲͶͪ
ͭͪΔͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
Ͳͪͼ͸ͳͬͪͶͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
͹ͺͳͼ;
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͪͬͪ΁ͪ
͋Ͱͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒ;

ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
ͺ͹͵ͻͳͬͪͶͰ
ͼ;
ͯͬͰ
ͻ;ͽͰ
ͪ
ͺͻͰͬ͹Ͳ͸͹
ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬ͹
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ

ͬ͹Ͳ
͈ͻͬͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯͬͳΌͪͶͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
͹ͯ
̹;ͯͳͷͺͰ΃ͽͰ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ

͊͹ͿͳΒͰ
͍ͳͶͳͺ͹ͺ͹Γͪ
ͳ
̸ͯͻͳΒͪ͸͹ͺ͹Γͪ
ͯ͹
̓͹͸ͼͽͪ͸ͽͳ͸͹ͺ͹Γͪ
̽ͻ;
ͭͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͶͪͲͳͶͪ
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͳ΃Ͷͪ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
͆ͳ΃ͪ
̺ͻͪΔͪ
ͳ
͊͵͹ͺΓͪ
ͳ



͆
ͪͅ͵;ΓͰͬͳΕ
͊ͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͽͰͷͰ
;
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͷ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ͸͹ͷ
ͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͼͽͬ;

9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͈ͻͳͶ͹ͭ
ͻͰ΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
;
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͷ
ͼͶͳ
͵ͪͻͼͽͬ;
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͈͹ͼͽͬͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͼ͵ͪ
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
*
͌ͻͰͯ͸ͳ͵
̽
̽ͪͬͳͯ͹ͬ

̀ͫ͹ͻ͸ͳ͵
̀̈́͌
m
͆͹ͬͳ
͊ͪͯ

m
ͼͪ
͹ͯͪͫͻͪ͸͹ͷ
͹ͺ΃ͽ͹ͷ
ͫͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪ
ͿͳΒ͹ͷ



'
,BOJU[
4FSCJFO
-FJQ[JH

 ͊ͻͺͼ͵͹
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
;
ͻͪ͸ͳͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ 

Ͳͪͬͻ΃ͪͬͪͶͪ
ͼͰ
;
͊͹Ͷ;͸;
͈͹΂Ͱͬ
͹ͯ

͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͵ͪͯͪ

ͼ;
ͺ͹΂ͰͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͳͲͶͪͲͰ
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬͳ
ͳ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
Ͳͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸;

̾ͬͻ͹ͺ;
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͳ
ͼ;
;
͸ͪ΂ͰͶ;
ͺͻͰ΃ͽͪͷͺͪͬͪ͸ͳ
ͳͲ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
;

ͯͻ;ͭ͹
ͪ
ͳͲͷͰ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
ͬͻ΃Ͱ͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
͹͸ͯͪ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
;΂ͳ͸ͳͽͳ
͵ͪ͵ͬ;

ͯ͹ͺ;͸;
ͳͶͳ
ͳͼͺͻͪͬͳͽͳ
ͭͻͰ΃͵;
ͅͰΌ;
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
ͳͺͪ͵
;͹΂ͪͬͪ
ͳ

ͯͻ;ͭͪ
ͬͻͼͽͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͽ͸ͪ
ͽͰ͵
;
͸ͳΒͪ͸ͼͪͷͪ
ͳͶͳ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸ͳͷ
͸ͪ
ͭͶͪͼ΁ͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͽ;ͷͪ΂ͳͽͳ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰΔͰ͸ͳͷ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸ͳͷ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳ
ͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ
́ͷͪΒ;Εͳ
ͼͬͰ
ͽ͹
;
ͬͳͯ;
͸ͪ΃ͪ
ͳͼͺͳͽͳͬͪΔͪ
͸ͳͼͷ͹

Ͳͪͼ͸͹ͬͪͶͳ
͸ͪ
΁ͰͶ͹͵;ͺ͸͹ͷ
ͬͰΕ
ͼͷͳ΃ΓͰ͸͹
͹ͯͪͫͻͪ͸͹ͷ
;Ͳ͹ͻ͵;
͎ͻ͹
͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
ͺͻͬͳ
;
͸ͳͲ;
ΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
ͼͪ
ͼͪͷ͹ͭ
͵ͻͪΒͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ



ͼͶͰͯͳ
ͳͲͯͪΔͰ
ͳͲ
ͻͪͲͯ͹ͫΓͪ
̸͸Ͱ͵ͼͳ͹͸Ͱ
͵ͻͳͲͰ


ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͪ
ͯͬͪ

;
͸ͳͲ;
ͳͲ
 
͸Ͱͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸͹
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯͰ
ͳͲͫͳΒͪΔ;
͈ͻͬ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪ
ͽͪ
͊ͬͳ
ͳͼͺͳͽͳͬͪ͸ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹ͭ

ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽͪ
ͳͲ
̈́ͪΒͺ΁ͳͭͪ
ͳ
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
ͪͅΒͰͻ

ͼͺͰ΁ͳΒͪͶͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸͹ͭ
͸ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;

;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸͹ͭ
ͯ͹ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂ΒͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͼͪ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ
͵͹ͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
ͳͲ

͵ͪͯͪ
ͼͰ
͵͹͸͵;ͻͰ͸ͽͼ͵ͪ
͵;Εͪ
̓ͪͻͶͪ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ

ͺ͹͸͹ͬ͹
͹͵ͻͰ͸;Ͷͪ
͹ͬ͹Β
ͻͰͭͳΒͳ
͈͹ͭͶͰͯͪΒͷ͹
ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
΃ͽͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
͹ͯ
ͼͻͺ
ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ͺͻͰ
ͼͽ͹ͽͳ͸ͪ͵
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͯͪ
ͬͳͯͳ

ͺͻ͹ͼͰ΂ͪ͸
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
̓ͻͰ͸;ΕͰͷ͹
ͺͻͬͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͪͬ΁Ͱͷ
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͸Ͱ

ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͌
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁ͳ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͻͪͯ͹Ͳ͸ͪͶͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹

ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;͵ͻͪͽ͵͹
͸ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;
;ͬ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳͲ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪ

ͼͪ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹΃Ε;
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͇΂;ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͷͰΌ;
ͽͳͷ
͸ͳͼ;
ͷ;
ͽͪͯͪ
ͫͳͶͳ
ͯ͹ͼͽ;ͺ͸ͳ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ
ͼͽͪͻ͹Β

ͽͬͻΌͪͬͳ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
ͼ͵ͻͰͽͪͶͪ
ΒͰͯͳ͸͹
͸ͪ
͵;Ͷ;
͆Ͱͫ͹Β΃;
͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔ;
͹ͯ

͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ
ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳ΀
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸ͳ΀
Ϳ͹ͻͽͳͿͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͆ͪͺ;΃ͽͪΒ;Εͳ
̹Ͱ
͹ͭͻͪͯ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵;
ͼͰ
͹ͫͪͬͰͲ͸͹
;͵ͪͲͳͬͪͶ͹
͸ͪ
̸ͬͪͶ;
͵ͪ͹
;Ͳͬͳ΃ͰΔͰ
͵͹ΒͰ

ΒͰ
ͯ;ͭ͹
͹ͼͽͪΒͪͶ͹
;
ͬͳͯ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹Γ;
ͼͪ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬͳͷ
ͻ;΃Ͱͬͳ͸ͪͷͪ
ͽͬͻΌͪ



.FZFST
3FJTFCÛDIFS
5ÛSLFJ
3VNÅOJFO
4FCJFO
#VMHBSJFO

"VGMBHF
-FJQ[JH

VOE
8JFO



.FZFST
3FJTFCÛDIFS
5ÛSLFJ
3VNÅOJFO
#VMHBSJFO

"VGMBHF
-FJQ[JH
VOE

8JFO



#BMLBOTUBBUFO
VOE
,POTUBOUJOPQFM
"OBUPMJTDIF
VOE
#BHEBCBIO


"VGMBHF

-FJQ[JH
VOE
8JFO

,POTUBOUJOPQFM
#BMLBOTUBBUFO
,MFJOBTJFO
"SDIJQFM
$ZQFSO

)BOECVDI
GÛS
3FJTFOEF
WPO
,BSM
#BFEFLFS

"VG
/FCFOU#BFEFLFST
,POTUBOUJOPQFM

VOE
,MFJOBTJFO
-FJQ[JH




͚
͊
̓͹ͼͽͳΕ
̺ͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͼ͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
m


̺
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
̀ͫ͹ͻ͸ͳ͵;
ͻͪͯ
ͅ
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
;
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ

͵ͻͪΒͰͷ

ͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵ͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
͹
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸ͳͷ
ͫͰ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳͷ
Ϳ͹ͻͽͳͿͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ

ͳ
͵;Ͷͳ
͆Ͱͫ͹Β΃ͳ
ͅ
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͪ
ͽͬͻΌͪͬͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ


ͳ
ͯͪΓͰ

 ̽ͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ

ͬͰ
̺͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͳͲ

ͼͽͻ


ͳ

ͼͽͻ


͸Ͱ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͰ
ͫͶͳͱͰ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ
͵Ͱ
͹
͹ͬ͹Β
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹Β
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹Β
;ͽͬͻͯͳ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹Β
͵ͪ͹
̿ͻ͸͹ͬ
ͪͶͳ

ͼͰ
Ͳͪͽ͹
;
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͳ
ͳͲ

͵ͪͱͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
ͽ;ͻͼ͵ͪ

Ϳ͹ͻͽͳͿͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳͲ

ͺ͹
ͳͷͰ͸;
)ͪXBMF
ͼͽͻ



͊ͶͰͯͳͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͑;ͷͪͯͳΒ;
m
ͼͻ΁Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͽ͹
Βͳ
;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;
̺͹Ͳ
ΒͰ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹ͶͪͲͳ͹
ͫͶͳͲ;
̸ͻͪ͸ΌͰͶ͹ͬ΁ͪ

Ͳͪ;ͼͽͪͬΓͪ͹
ͼͰ
;
͈ͪͶͪ͸΁ͳ
ͳ
ͪͭ͠͹ͯͳ͸ͳ
ͪͶͳ
ΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͯͻͱͪ͹

;ͺ;ͽͼͽͬͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͽͰ͵
;
͹͵͹Ͷͳ͸ͳ
ͣ;ͺͻͳΒͰ
ͳͷͪ͹
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵;
ͯͪ
ͬͳͯͳ
͸Ͱ
͵ͳ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
ͳͲ

ͼͽͻ



;ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͪͬͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͽ;
͸ͪ
ͽͻͳ
ͼͪͽͪ
΀͹ͯͪ
;
ͼ͵ͻͳͬͰ͸͹ͷ
΃;ͷ͹ͬͳͽ͹ͷ
͵Ͷͪ͸
΁;
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽͳ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ
͉ͪͬͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭͪ͹
͵͸ͰͲ
̈́ͪ
Ͳͪͻ
Β;͸ͪ͵
̓͹ͼ͹ͬͼ͵͹ͭ
ͫ͹Βͪ
̓͸ͰͱͰͬͪ
ͺ͹ͭͳͫͳΒͪ
;
ͫ͹ͻͫͳ
ͺͻ͹ͽͳͬ
͋;ͻͪ͵ͪ


ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
͸ͰͲͪ͹ͫͳͶͪͲ͸͹
͹ͺ΃ͽͰ
ͷͰͼͽ͹
ͳ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒ

͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͹΂ͳͭͶͰͯ͸͹
ͼ͸ͪͱ͸͹
;ͻͰͲͪ͹
;
ͼͬͰͼͽ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺΓͪ͸ͪ
̺͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͳͲ


ͼͽͻ


ͳ

ͼͽͻ


Β͹΃
ͼ;
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͽͳͬ͸ͳΒͳ
̓ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
͹
͉ͪ
ͬͪ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͻͰ΂
ͺͪͱΔͪ
ͼͰ
ͼ͵ͻͰΕͰ
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͿͻͰͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͻͽͻͰͽ
͵͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ
̈́ͪͲͪͻͪ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
ͼ;ͺͻ;ͱ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͈ͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
͹ͫͳͶͪͲͪ͵

ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͪ
ͪͅ͸ͪͼͳΒͰ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
͹ͯ
͉ͪͬͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
;ͯͪΓͰ͸
ͽͻͳ
ͳ
ͺ͹
ͼͪͽͳ
΀͹ͯͪ

͆ͪͻ͹΂ͳ͹
ͼ͸ͪͱͪ͸
;ͽͳͼͪ͵
͸ͪ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͼ;
͹ͼͽͪͬͳͶͳ
ͫͰͯͰͷͳ
tͼͪ

ͯͬͪ͸ͪͰͼͽ
͵ͬͪͯͻͪͽ͸ͳ΀
͵;Ͷͪi
ͳ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ;ͻͪ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ
tͼͪ
΃Ͱͼͽ
ͷͰͽͪͶ͹ͷ

ͺ͹͵ͻͳͬͰ͸ͳ΀
͵;ͺ͹Ͷͪi

̓ͻͰΕ;Εͳ
ͼͰ
ͯͪΓͰ
ͱͳͬ͹ͺͳͼ͸͹ͷ
ͯ͹Ͷͳ͸͹ͷ
ͅ͹ͻͪͬͰ
ͬ͹Ͳ
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹Ͷͪ
Ͳͳ͹
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͊ͽͪͶͪΕ
΂ͳΒͪ
ͼ;
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͪ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽ
ͫͳͶͰ
ͻ;΃Ͱͬͳ͸Ͱ
tͼͽͪ
ͻ͹ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
Ͳͪͷ͵ͪi
̓ͪͱͰ
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͽ͹
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͭͪ
͋;ͻ΁ͳ
ͻͪͲ͹ͻͳͶͳ
Β͹΃
;


ͬͰ͵;
ͪ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳ
ͭ͹ͼͺ͹ͯͪͻͳ
͹ͺͰͬͪ͸ͳ
;
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
Ͱͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺͰͼͷͪ
ͷͪ
ͪͅΒͰͻ

ͼͽͻ


ͼͽͻ


ͼͽͻ


͆ͰͯͪͶͰ͵͹
͹ͯ

͊ͽͪͶͪΕͪ
ͷ͹ͭͶ͹
ͼͰ
ͼͽͳΕͳ
ͯ͹
̓ͻ;΃Ͱͬ΁ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
ͼͳͼͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵ͳ

͸Ͱͽͪ΂͸͹
͹Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪͬͪΒ;
͵ͪ͹
ͻͰͲͳͯͰ͸΁ͳΒ;
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͰͭ
ͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ
ͼͽͪͻͰ
ͼͻͺ
ͼ͵Ͱ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
ͺ͹͸͹ͬ͹
ͺ͹ͯͼͰΕͪΒ;Εͳ
͸ͪ
̓͹ͼ͹ͬͼ͵;
ͫͳͽ͵;
͇ͯ
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ΃ΔͰ

ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͪͶͪͽͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
ͼ
͵ͻͪΒͪ

ͳ
ͺͻͬͳ΀
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͫͳ͹

ΒͰ
;
ͺͻͳͶͳ΁ͳ
ͯͪ
ͬͳͯͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
͹ͼͽͪͽ͵Ͱ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
͵;ͶͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͻ;΃Ͱ͸Ͱ
Ͳͳͯ͹ͬͰ

͇͸
ͼͰ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ͯͳͬͳͽͳ
ͺͻͳͯͬ͹ͻ͸͹Β
΁ͻ͵ͬͳ
m
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹Β
͵ͪ͹

̈́ͪͲͪͻͳ΁ͪ
m
͹ͯͶͳ΂͸͹
͹΂;ͬͪ͸͹Β
ͳͪ͵͹
ͫͰͲ
ͱͳͬ͹ͺͳͼͪ
̺ͻͰͯͳ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ

ͯͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
ͳͲ

͵ͪͱͰ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͿͻͰͼ͵Ͱ
;͸ͳ΃ͽͰ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪͽ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;

͋;ͻ΁ͳ
΁ͻ͵ͬ;
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳͶͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͫͪͻ;ͽ͸ͳ
ͷͪͭͪ΁ͳ͸
ͼͽͻ


͌
͹ͼͽͪͶͳͷ



̀ͪ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ;ͻ;
͉ͪͬͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͳ
͉ͰͼͪͬͰ
̺
͉ͳͼͽͳΕ
ͅ͹ͻͪͬͼ͵ͪ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ;ͻͪ

̓ͻ;΃Ͱͬͪ΁

ͬ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
̹
͋͹ͯͳΕ
ͪͅ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ
͉Ͱͼͪͬͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ




̽
ͅͳ͸ͳΕ
͇
̺;͵ͪͯͳ͸
͊
͚͹ͻΌͰͬͳΕ
͊ͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
͊ͽͪͶͪΕ
͉ͪ
΃͵ͪ
ͫͪ΃ͽͳ͸ͪ

̓ͻͪΓͰͬ͹

m
 ͊ͻͺͼ͵͹
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
;
ͻͪ͸ͳͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ 

ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͳ͸ͪ΂Ͱ
ͯ͹ͼͶ͹ͬ͸͹
ͺ͹͸ͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͳͲͬ͹ͻ͸ͳ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ
͹ͬͪΒ
ͺ͹ͯͪ

ͽͪ͵
ͼͰ
ͳͲ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪ

ͼͽͻ


ͼͽͻ


̓ͪ͹
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͳ
͹ͯΒͰ͵

ͼͽͪͻͳ΀
ͼͶͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯͬ͹ͭͶͪͬ͹ͭ

͹ͻͶͪ
͸ͪ
Β;ͱ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͻͽͪͶ;
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ

̀ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
̓ͻ;΃Ͱͬͪ΁
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ͹
ͬͪͱ͸;
ͽͪ΂͵;

ͼͽ͹ͭͪ
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
͹ͯͪͽͶͰ
ͺ͹ͶͪͲͳͶ͹
͸ͪ
ͳͲͶͰͽ
;
Β;ͱ͸Ͱ
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͰ
;
ͽͻͪΒͪΔ;
͹ͯ

΂Ͱͽͳͻͳ
ͯ͹
΃Ͱͼͽ
ͯͪ͸ͪ
͇ͫͳͶͪͲͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͳ
ͳ
ͼͽͪͻͳ͸Ͱ
;
ͯ͹Ͷͳ͸ͳ

ͅ͹ͻͪͬͰ
́ͫͻͪ
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͺͪͯͳ͸ͪͷͪ
̓͹ͺͪ͹͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͪ
ͳͲͶͰͽ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂ͳͬͪ͹

͵ͪ͹
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͶͰͺ΃ͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͪ
͸ͪ
΂ͳͽͪͬ͹ͷ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹Ͷ;͹ͼͽͻͬ;

͇͸
ΒͰ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺΓͪ͸ͳ͸;
ͯ͹ͳͼͽͪ
͸;ͯͳ͹
ͻͰͯͪ͵
;ͭ͹ΌͪΒ
m
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵;

ͯͪ
ͬͳͯͳ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸Ͱ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ;ͻͰ
ͳ
ͼͶͳ͵ͪͻ
ͼͽͬͪ
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͳ΀
ͳͼͽ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
ͯ͹ͱͳͬͳ
;
͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪΒ;ΕͰͷ
ͪ;ͽͰ͸ͽͳ΂͸͹ͷ

ͪͷͫͳΒͰ͸ͽ;
͈;ͽ͹ͬͪͶ͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
͵͹Δͳͷͪ
;Ͳ
͹ͫͪͬͰͲ͸;
ͺͻͪͽΔ;
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶ͸͹ͭ

ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪ͹΁ͪ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪ
ͪ
͸͹ΕͳͬͪͶ͹
;
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͳͷͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͯ͹ͷͪ
Εͳ͸ͼͽͬͳͷͪ
͈;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͵ͻͰͽͪͶͳ
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͳͷͪ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸Ͱ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰ
ͺͻͳ

΂Ͱͷ;
ͼ;
͸ͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺΓͪ͸Ͱ
͸ͪΒΒ΂ͳ
;ͽͳͼͪ͵
͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͳ
ͯͻͪͷͪͽͳ΂͸ͳ
ͪͷͫͳ
ΒͰ͸ͽͳ
m
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͬͳͼ͹ͬͳ
ͳ
͵Ͷͪ͸΁ͳ
͵Ͷͳͼ;ͻͰ
ͳ
͵ͪΔ͹͸ͳ
ͱͳͬ͹ͺͳͼ͸ͳ

ͬͳͯͳ͵͹ͬ΁ͳ
͌͵;ͺ͸͹ͷ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪΒ;
ͳͲͬ͹ͻ͸͹ͭ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸ͪ
ͱͳͬΓͰΔͪ
ͯ͹ͺͻͳ
͸͹ͼͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͯ͹ͷͪΕͪ
΀ͻͪ͸ͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;Β;
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͵͹ͯ
ͺͪͼͽͳ
ͻͪ
͸ͪ
̓͹ͺͪ͹͸ͳ͵;
͹ͫͪͬͰͲ͸͹
ͺͻ͹ͫͪΒ;
ͷͶͰ͵͹
ͼͳͻ
ͳ
ΒͪΒͪ
͋Ͱ͵ͼͽ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ

ͼ
͵ͻͪΒͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͷͪͽͻͪ͸
ͼͪ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬͳ΃ͽͪ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ΂͸͹

ΒͰ
ͳ͸ͽ͹͸ͳͻͪ͸
͌
ΔͰͷ;
͵ͪ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒ;
͹ͯΒͰ΁ͳ
ͻ͹ͷͪ͸ͽͳ΂ͪͻͼ͵͹ͭ

͸ͪͯͪ΀͸;Εͪ
ͳ
Ϳͪͼ΁ͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͰͶͰͷͰ͸ͽͪͻ͸ͳͷ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
΁ͳͬͳͶͳͲͪ΁ͳ
Β͹ͷ
͸Ͱͳͼ͵ͬͪͻͰ͸ͳ΀
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸ͪ
ͪ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
͹ͼ͹ͫͰ͸
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂͵ͳ
ͯ;΀
ͳ

ͼͺͻͰͷ͸͹ͼͽ
͸ͪ
ͪͬͪ͸ͽ;ͻ;
͌
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͳΒͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
ͼͪͯͻͱͳ͸ͪ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ

͸ͰΕͰ
ͼͰ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͷͰΔͪͽͳ
ͪͶͳ
ΕͰ
ͽ͹͸
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͽͳ
ͷͪΔͰ
͸ͪͯͪ΀͸;ͽ
ͪ
ͳͲͶͪͭͪ
ΔͰ
ͼ;ͬΓͰ
ͳ
͵͹͸΁ͳͲ͸ͳΒͰ

̓ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
͹
ͼͽͪͻͳ͸ͪͷͪ
ͻͰ΂
͹ͬͪ
ͽ;ͻͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹
ͼͬ͹ͷ
ͳͽͳ͸ͰͻͰ
ͻ;
ͫͳͽ͸͹
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵͹ͬͪͶͪ
͹ͯ
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃Δͳ΀
͇ͯ
̓ͻ;΃Ͱͬ΁ͪ
ͺ;ͽ
ΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ͹
͵ͪ

͋ͻͼͽͰ͸ͳ͵;
;
΂ͳΒ͹Β
ͼͰ
͹͵͹Ͷͳ͸ͳ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯͪͽͳ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ
͡;ͫ͹ͼͽͳ
Δͪ
Ͳͪͯ;ͱͫͳ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͭͻ͹ͫ͸͹
ͷͰͼͽ͹
t΁ͪͻͳ΁Ͱ
ͅͳͶͳ΁Ͱ
ͱͰ͸Ͱ
΁ͪͻͪ
̈́ͪͲͪͻͪi

͵ͪ͵͹
ͽ͹
;͵ͻͪͽ͵͹
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͬͰͽͪ͸
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
͵ͪͲ;Β;
ͼͬͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
ͪͅΒͰͻ


ͼͽͻ


ͼͽͻ


ͼͽͻ


͇ͯͪͽͶͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ;

͸ͪ͵͹͸
͹ͽͺͻͳͶͳ͵Ͱ
΂Ͱͽͳͻͳ
ͼͪͽͳ
Βͪ΀ͪΔͪ
ͼͽͳͲͪͶ͹
ͼͰ
;
̿ͳ΂;
͊ͪ
ͯͪ͸ͪ



͇
͵͹ͷͺͶͰ͵ͼ;
ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͻͰͲͳͯͰ͸΁ͳΒͰ
;
̓ͻ;΃Ͱͬ΁;
ͅ
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ
͌ͽͬͻΌͰ
Δͪ
ͷ͹ͻͪͬͼ͵Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
͊ͬͰͽͳ
͵͸ͰͲ
̈́ͪͲͪͻ
͊ͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͹
΃Ͱͼͽ͹Β
ͼͽ͹ͭ͹ͯͳ΃Δͳ΁ͳ
̓͹
ͼ͹ͬͼ͵͹ͭ
ͫ͹Βͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

m


͊
͚;ͻͳΕ
͡;ͫ͹ͼͽͳΔͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

 ̽ͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ

΃ΔͰͭ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬͳ΃ͽͪ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͸;ͯͳͶͳ
͹
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳ
ͻ;
͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
͹ͼ͵;ͯ͸ͳ
ͬͰΕ
ͯ͹ͫͻͳͷ
ͯͰͶ͹ͷ
ͳ
͸Ͱͽͪ΂͸ͳ
́ͼͺͻͪͬ͸͹

ͼͰ
͸ͪͭͶͪ΃ͪͬͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
̿ͳ΂ͪ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽͳ
͵ͻ;͸ͳͯͫͰ͸ͳ
΀ͻͪͷ
͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ

ͪͶͳ
ͼͰ
͵ͪ͹
ΔͰ͸
͵ͽͳͽ͹ͻ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͼͬͰͽͳ
͊ͪͬͪ
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͯ͹ͼͶ͹ͬ
͸͹
ͺ͹͸ͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͶͰͭͰ͸ͯ;
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼ;
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
͵ͻ;͸ͳͼͪΔͪ
Ͳͪ
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͭ
͹ͯ

΃Ͱͼͽ
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͪ
ͺͻ͹ͫͳΒͪ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸ͪ
ͬͻͪͽͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͫͳ
ͺ͹
͹ͫͪͬΓͰ͸͹Β
΁ͰͻͰ
ͷ͹͸ͳΒͳ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͺ͹͸͹ͬ͹
ͲͪͲͳͯͪ͸ͪ
͌
ͼͬͳͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
ͼͻͰΕͰ
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵

ͯͪ
ͱͳ΂͵ͪ
΁ͻ͵ͬͪ
͹ͫ͸͹ͬΓͰ͸ͪ
;
͸͹ͬͳΒͰ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͷͰ΃ͪͬͳ͸;

ͻ͹ͷͪ͸ͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͳ
ͬͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͭͻͪͯͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ
ͪ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
ͳͲ

ͯ͹ͯͪΒͰ

ͼͰ
Β͹΃
ͳ
͹ͺͪͼ͵ͪ
͹
ͺͻͰͬͶͪͼͽͳ
ͻ͹ͷͪ͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
͵͹ͷͺ͹͸Ͱ͸ͽͰ
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͽ;ͷͪ΂ͳ

ͬͰΕͳ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬ͹ͷ
ͭͻͪͯͳͽͰΓͪ
ͳͲ
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͪͅΒͰͻ

ͼͽͻ



ͼͽͻ


ͼͽͻ


͈ͻͬ͹ͫͳͽ͸ͳ
ͱͳͬ͹ͺͳͼ
ͽͰ͵
ͯͰͶͳͷͳ΂͸͹

ͬͳͯΓͳͬ
ͺͻͳͺͳͼͪ͸
ΒͰ
ͳͽͪͶͳΒͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͷͪΒͼͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
ͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹
ͬ͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͳͲ

ͼͽͻ


ͺ͹ͼͶ;ͱͳ͹
ͼͰ
͸Ͱͺ͹;Ͳͯͪ͸ͳͷ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻ͹ͷ
͵ͪ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͫͻͪΒͪ
ͼͪ΂;ͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͱͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͿͻͰͼ͵Ͱ
͐ͰͽͻͯͰͼͰͽ͹ͻͳ΁;
ͷ;΂Ͱ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͼͬ

͊ͪͬ;
ͼͬ
͋Ͱ͹ͯ͹ͼͳΒ;
ͳ
͊ͽͰͿͪ͸ͪ
͆ͰͷͪΔ;

͌
̿ͳ΂ͳ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͼͺͪͬͪͶ͹
ͪ
ͻͪ͸͹
;Β;ͽͻ͹
͵ͻͰͽͪͶ͹
ͯͪΓͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ

̓ͻͪΓͰͬ;
ͪ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͯ͹Ͷͳ͸͹ͷ
́ͫͻͪ
͈ͰΒͲͪͱ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͬͪ͹
ͼͬͰ
ͱͳͬ͹ͺͳ
ͼ͸ͳΒͳ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪ͹
ͫͳ
ͬͰͶͳ΂ͪ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸
͵ͪͯͪ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹ΒͪͬͳͶͰ

ͻ;΃Ͱͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͽͬͻΌͪͬͰ
ͪͭͅͶͳ΂
͹͵ͻ;ͱͰ͸Ͱ
ͫͻͯͳͷͪ
ͪͅΒͰͻ

ͼͽͻ



ͼͽͻ


ͼͽͻ


̓ͻ͹Ͳ
ͼͬͰ
͵ͻ΃ͰͬͳͽͳΒͳ
ͺͻͰͯͰ͹
Βͪ΀ͪͶ͹
ͫͳ

ͼͰ
Β͹΃
͹͵͹
΂Ͱͽͳͻͳ
ͼͪͽͪ
ͪ
͹͸ͯͪ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͪΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
͹ͽͬ͹ͻͳͶͪ
ͯ͹Ͷͳ͸ͪ
͹ͫͻͪ
ͼͶͪ
ͲͰͶͰ͸͹ͷ
Ͷͳͬͪͯ͹ͷ
ͳ
;͹͵ͬͳͻͰ͸ͪ
΃;ͷ͹ͷ
ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ
ΔͰ
;͵ͪͲͪͶ͹
ͫͰͶ͹

ͷͰͻͷͰͻ͸͹
ͲͯͪΔͰ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͪ
͊ͽ;ͯͰ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͌
ͺ͹ͯ;΀ͬͪͽ;
͸ͪ΃Ͱͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ

ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
͸ͪΒͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͪ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͬͻ΀;͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪΒ

͋͹
ͼͰ
ͯͪ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂ͳͽͳ
ͬͰΕ
ͳ
͸ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
m
͸Ͱ;ͺ͹ͻͰͯͳͬ͹
ͬͰΕͰͭ

;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ;
͸ͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
m
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰͽͳͶͰ
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͷͪ
͸ͪͼͽͳͻ;
̺ͰΕ
;
;ͬ͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͳͲ

ͼͽͻ

m

ͯͪΒͰ
ͯ͹
Ͳ͸ͪΔͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁;
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
͸ͪΒͬͰΕͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͪ
ͼͬͰͽͳ
Δͪ
Ͳͪͯ;ͱͫͳ͸ͪ
͊ͽͰͿͪ͸ͪ
͆ͰͷͪΔͰ
͹ͼ͸ͳͬͪ΂ͪ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͬͶͪͯͪͻ
ͼ͵Ͱ
ͯͳ͸ͪͼͽͳΒͰ
͆Ͱ
ͳͲ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹
ͽͰͶ͹
͸ͪ͵͹͸

΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
͹ͫΒͪͬͳͶ͹
;
͎ͳͶͪ͸ͯͪͻ;
;
͊ͽ;ͯͰ͸ͳ΁;
ͺͻͰ͸Ͱ͹
ͼͬ
͊ͪͬͪ
ͳͲͷͳ
ͻͳͬ΃ͳ
͸ͪ
ͽͪΒ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͼͬ͹Β;
ͲͪͬͪΌͰ͸;
ͫͻͪΕ;
͆ͪΒͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͺͪͱΔͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ

ΒͰ
ͻͪͲ;ͷΓͳͬ͹
ͺ͹ͼͬͰͽͳ͹
̹͹ͭ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ͸͹Β
΁ͻ͵ͬͳ
͈͹ͯͻ͹ͫ͸͹
ͼͰ
͹ͺͳͼ;
Β;
ΔͰ͸Ͱ
ͷͰͻͷͰͻ͸Ͱ
ͿͪͼͪͯͰ
ͳ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽ
ͼ͵;Ͷͺͽ;ͻͪͶ͸ͳ
;͵ͻͪͼ
͈͹ͯͬͶͪ΂Ͱ
ͼͰ



ͅ
͐ͪ͸ͪ͵mͅͰͯͳΕ
̹
͋͹ͯͳΕ
ͪͅ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ
̿ͳ΂ͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

ͪͅ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ

̿ͳ΂ͪ
̀ͫ͹ͻ͸ͳ͵
ͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
͈ͻͳͻͰͯͳ͹
̻
͊;ͫ͹ͽͳΕ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬ͹



͇
ͽͬͻΌͪͬͳ
ͪͭͅͶͳ΂
͊
͚͹ͻΌͰͬͳΕ
ͪͭͅͶͳ΂
͉ͪ΃͵ͪ
ͫͪ΃ͽͳ͸ͪ

̓ͻͪΓͰͬ͹


m
 ͊ͻͺͼ͵͹
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
;
ͻͪ͸ͳͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ 

ͬͳͼ͹͵Ͱ
ͭͻͪͯͳͽͰΓͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
΀ͻͪͷͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͳͺͻͪͽͪ

͵ͻͪΓͪ
͉ͪͯ͹ͼͶͪͬͪ
͹΁ͰΔ;ΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͫͰͲͬͻͰͯ͸͹
ͲͯͪΔͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
Ͳͪ͵ͶͪΔͪ
ͷ͹͸;
ͷͰ͸ͽͪͶ͸ͳ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͻͽͪͶ
͌
;͸;ͽͻͪ΃Δ͹ͼͽͳ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ
m
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͪ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ
͵͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͪ
ͺͻͳͺͻͪͽͰ
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͺͻͰ͵ͻͳͬͰ͸ͪ
ͱͳ
ͬ͹ͺͳͼ͹ͷ
ͳͲ
ͺͻͬͰ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

ͼͽ͹ͶͰΕͪ
m
ͺͪͱΔͪ
ͼͰ
ͼ͵ͻͰΕͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
͸ͪ

ͻͪͼ͵͹΃ͪ͸
͵ͳͬ͹ͽ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
;ͷͰͼͽ͹
͊ͽͰͿͪ͸;
͈ͻͬ͹ͬͰ͸΂ͪ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͭͻͰ΃͸͹

ͺͻͳͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
ͼͬ
͊ͳͷͰ͹͸;
͊ͪͼͬͳͷ
;͵ͻͪͽ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͳ
ͼͽ;ͯͰ͸ͳ΂͵ͪ

̓ͻͪΓͰͬͪ
΁ͻ͵ͬͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͼͰ
Ͳͪͽ͹
;
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͷ
ͺͻͰͬ͹ͯ;
ͯ͹͸͹ͼͳ
͵ͽͳͽ͹ͻͼ͵ͳ

͸ͪͽͺͳͼ
͵ͻͪΓͪ
ͅͳͶ;ͽͳ͸ͪ
ͼͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͽͳͽ;Ͷ͹ͷ
t͵ͻͪΓ
ͼͬͳ΀
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ΀

ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͷ͹ͻͼ͵ͳ΀i
͌͹΂ͪͬͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
͹ͺͳͼͪ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ

ͽͰ͵ͼͽ
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͳͲ

;
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͳͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
ͯ͹ͺ;Δ;ΒͰ
͸͹
ͬͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͷͰΔͪ
;
ͳͲͬͰͼ͸ͳͷ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ

ͼͽͻ

m

ͼͽͻ


͇ͼͳͷ
͹
΁ͻ͵ͬͳ
ͽ;
ͼͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
ͳ
͹
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͼ͵͹ͷ

͵͹ͷͺͶͰ͵ͼ;
̺ͳͼ͹͵͹
͹ͫͲͳΌͰ
ͽͪ΂͸͹
ͼͰ
͹΁ͰΔ;ΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
͹ͼ͹ͫͰ͸͹
ͼͽͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͪ
ͪ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔ;
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͯͬ͹ͼͺͻͪͽ͸ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ
͵͹
͸ͪ΁ͳ
ͼͪ
Β;ͱ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸ͳ
ͺͻͰͫͳͬͪΔ;
ͷ͹͸ͪ΀ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͶͪ΁ͪ
ͳ

΀͹ͯ͹΂ͪͼ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͌
Ͳ͸ͪ͵
Ͳͪ΀ͬͪͶ͸͹ͼͽͳ
Ͳͪ
;͵ͪͲͪ͸͹
ͭ͹ͼͽ͹ͺͻͳͷͼͽͬ͹
;
ͷͪ͸ͪ
ͼͽͳͻ;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;ΒͰ
ͯͪͬͪΔͰ
͸͹ͬ΂ͪ͸͹ͭ
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͭͪ
͈;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
ͳͲ


ͯ͹͸͹ͼͰ
ͯ͹ͯͪͽ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
͹
Ͱ͸ͽͰͻͳΒͰͻ;
̹͹ͭ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ͸͹ͭ
΀ͻͪͷͪ

ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬ
ͼ͵ͻͰΕͰ
ͺͪͱΔ;
͸ͪ
ͶͰͺ;
͵ͻͼͽͳ͹͸ͳ΁;
ͪ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͳ
ͿͻͰͼ͵Ͱ
͵͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
tͬͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͼ͵͹ͷ
ͼͽͳͶ;

ͬͰ͵ͪi
͆Ͱ
Ͳͪ͹ͫͳͶͪͲͳ
͸ͳ
ͱͳͬ͹
ͺͳͼ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͰ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ
ͳͼͽͳ΂;Εͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
ͬͳͼ͹͵Ͱ
;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ

ͼͽͻ


̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ͹
ͳͲͯͪΔͰ
ͳͲ
ͳͼͽͰ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
Β͹΃
ͺ͹ͯͻ͹ͫ͸ͳΒͰ

͹
ͿͻͰͼ͵ͪͷͪ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͰ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ
m
ͽ;
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͳͷͰ͸΁Ͱ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͰ
ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳ
ͺ͹ͻ
ͽͻͰͽͳ
ͳ
͵͹ͷͺ͹Ͳͳ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳͲ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
͎ͻͳͼͽͪ
ͳ
̹͹ͭ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΁Ͱ
;Ͳ
ͺͻͳͷͰͯͫ;

ͯͪ
ͳͷ
ͪ͸ͪͶ͹ͭͳΒͰ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͽͻͪͱͳͽͳ
;
ͷ͹Ͳͪͳ΁ͳͷͪ
΁ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͼ͵Ͱ
̓ͪ΀ͻͳΒͰ

ΘͪͷͳΒͰ
ͼͽͻ


͊ͪͷ͹
;
ΒͰͯ͸͹Β
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ΂͸͹Β
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͬ͹
ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͳͲ

͹ͼ͵;ͯ͸ͳΒͳ
ͼ;
͹ͯ
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
̓ͽͳͽ͹ͻͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͽͺͳͼ
ͳͲ

̓ͻͪΓͰͬͰ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ
ͽ;
ͼͰ
;͹ͺ΃ͽͰ
͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
͇ͼͽͪΒͰ
͸ͪͷ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹ͷͳ
΃Γͪͷ͹
͹͵͹
ͻͪͲͶ͹ͭͪ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͳͲ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪ
ͅ͹ͱͰ
ͫͳͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ

͸͹ͬͳ΀
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
ͽͪΒ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵
;΂ͳ͸ͳ͹
͸ͰͲͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬͳͷ
ͪ
ͷ͹ͱͯͪ
;
ͺͻͳ
Ͷͳ͵ͪͷͪ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͳͲͫͳΒͪΔͰ
ͻͪͽͪ
͆Ͱͷ΁ͳ
͸ͳͼ;
ͱͰͶͰͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͯͼͰΕͪΒ;

͸ͪ
Ͷͳ΂͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
ͽͳͽ;Ͷ;
͵ͻͪΓͪ
ͅͳͶ;ͽͳ͸ͪ
m
ͼͳͷͫ͹Ͷͪ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
Ͱ͵ͼͺͪ͸Ͳͳͬ͸Ͱ

ͳ
ͺ͹ͫͰͯ͹͸͹ͼ͸Ͱ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵Ͱ
̓ͪ͵͹
ͫͳͶ͹
͹ͯͰΓͪ͵
͹
͊ͽ;ͯͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
;



͌
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
͸͹ͬͳΒͳ
͵ͳͬ͹ͽ
͹͵͹ͬͪ͸
ͼͻͰͫͻ͹ͷ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ;
ͯͪͻ͹ͬͪ
Ͷͪ
͵ΔͰͭͳΔͪ
͈Ͱͻͼͳͯͪ
̓ͪͻͪΌ͹ͻΌͰͬͳΌ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ


͇
͊ͽ;ͯͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͬ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͪ
ͷ͹͸͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
ͅ
̓ͪ΃ͪ͸ͳ͸
ͅ
͐ͪ͸ͪ͵
ͅͰͯͳΕ
͠
ͪͅ͵ͼͳͷ͹ͬͳΕ
̹
͋͹ͯͳΕ
ͅ
͑ͪ͵͹ͽͪ
ͪͅ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ
͊ͽ;ͯͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ


̻
̹ͪͫͳΕ
̺
̓͹ͻͪΕ
͊
ͣͳͻ͵͹ͬͳΕ
͊ͽ;ͯͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

 ̽ͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
ͼͰ
Ͳͪͬͻ΃ͪͬͪ
ͽ;ͷͪ΂ͰΔͰͷ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͻͳͭͪ
Ͳͪ
ͼͺͪͼ
ͯ;΃Ͱ
ͫͳͶͪ

ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ
ͷ͹ͽͳͬ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
͵͹ΒͰͭ
ͼ;
͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͳ
ͺ͹ͯͳͲͪͶͳ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͼͽ͹ͭͪ

͹͸Ͱ
͸ͪͲͳͬͪΒ;
tͲͪͯ;ͱͫͳ͸ͪͷͪi
͌
ͼͬͳͷ
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬͳͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
ͺ͹͸ͪͬΓͪ

ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͯͪΔͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͪͽ
ͽͪ͵ͬͰ
͸ͰͷͪΔͳΕ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͫ͹ͱ͸͹ͼͽͳ
;
͹͵͹
Ͷͳ͸ͳ
͊ͽ;ͯͰ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽ͹
ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳͺͰͽ
΁ͻ͵ͪͬͪ
ͳ
͵ͪͺͰͶͪ
͠Ͱͯ͸ͪ
ͷͰ
Ό;
Δͳͷͪ
͈ͪͬͶͳ΁ͪ
͸ͪ
̻͹ͻΔͰͷ
́ͫͻ;
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͫ;ͯ;Εͳ
ͬͻͶ͹
ͶͰ
ͺͪ
ͳ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͷ͹ͭ;Εͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͪͅΒͰͻ


ͼͽͻ


ͼͽͻ


ͼͽͻ



͆ͪΒͪͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳΒͳ
ͯͰ͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
;
͹͵ͬͳͻ;
ͺͻͬͰ
ͻ;ͽͰ
ͽͳͷͰ
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹

͹͵͹͸΂ͪ͸
͌
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹Β
ͺ͹͸;ͯͳ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͯͶͪͱͰ

ͼͰ
ͯ͹ͯ;΃Ͱ
Β͹΃
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͼͺ͹ͻͰͯ͸ͳ
ͺͻͪͬͪ΁
ͺͻͰͷͪ
͐ͪ΂͵;
͈͹ͱͰͭͳ
ͳ
͌ͱͳ
΁;
͆ͪ
ͽ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͽͰͲ;
ͼ͵ͻͰΕͰ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸ͪ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
͸ͪ
͇ͬ΂ͪͻͼ͵͹͵ͪͫͶͪͻͼ͵;

͵Ͷͳͼ;ͻ;
ͳ
ΔͰ͸Ͱ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͰ
ͼͽͻ


͆ͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ
ͺͻͪͬͪ΁
ͬͻͪΕͪͶ͹
ͼͰ
ͺ͹͸͹ͬ͹
͵͹ͯ
͊ͽͪͶͪΕͪ
ͳ

ͳ΃Ͷ͹
ͯͪΓͰ
͵ͪ
Β;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹͵;
ͳ
ͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵͹Β
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
̸ͶͰ͵ͼͳ͸΁ͪ

͆ͳ΃ͪ
͊ͳΕͰͬͪ
̹ͰͶͰ
͈ͪͶͪ͸͵Ͱ
ͳ
͈ͳͻ͹ͽͪ
̓ͪ͹
ͯ͹ͯͪͽ͸ͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
ͳͲ

͆ͳ΃ͪ
ͼͰ
͸;ͯͳ͹
ͳͲͶͰͽ
Ͳͪ
̓ΔͪͱͰͬͪ΁
ͳ
̀ͪΒͰ΂ͪͻ
;͵Γ;΂;Β;Εͳ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͪͻ
ͼ͵ͳ
ͺ͹΀͹ͯ
͸ͪ
͊;ͬ;
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸;
ͪͅΒͰͻ

ͼͽͻ
m

ͼͽͻ
m


ͼͽͻ
m

̾ͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
Ͳͪͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪ͸
Ͳͪ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ
͸Ͱ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͪ
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
ͺ;ͽͪ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
͹΂Ͱ͵ͳͬͪͽͳ
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽͰ
Ͳͪ
͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹ͼͽͳ
͇ͯ
ͼͽͪͻͳ͸ͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͼ;
ͷ;
ͼ͵ͻͰͽͪͶͳ
ͺͪͱΔ;
͸ͪ
͸ͳ΃͵;

ͳ
ͺͳͻ͹ͽͼ͵;
ͽͬͻΌͪͬ;
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͻ;΃Ͱͬͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
tͲͪͷ͵͹ͬͪ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳ
ͻͪ
ͳ
͵ͪͺͰͶͪi
;
͊ͳΕͰͬͪ΂͵͹Β
͵Ͷͳͼ;ͻͳ
́ͺͪ͵
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
ͻͪͯ͹Ͳ͸ͪͶ͹ͭ
ͯ;΀ͪ

ͳ
͹΃ͽͻ͹ͭ
ͲͪͺͪͱͪΔͪ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ΒͰ
;
͹ͬͳͷ
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͳͷͪ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͶͪͲ;
ͳͲ

;


ͼͽ͹ͶͰΕͰ
ͯͪ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬͳ
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
͹ͯ
͹͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ΒͪͬͰ
͵͹Β;
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳ΂ͪͻͳ
͹Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪ
ͬͪΒ;
͵ͪ͹
tͺͻ͹ͯ;ͱͰ͸ͳ
ͼͻͰͯΔͳ
ͬͰ͵i
͋ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
;
͹͵͹Ͷͳ͸ͳ
̸ͶͰ͵ͼͳ͸΁ͪ
ͷ͹
ͭͪ͹
ͯͪ
ͬͳͯͳ
ͼͰͶͪ
ͼͪ
͵;ΕͰͻ΁ͳͷͪ
͸ͪͺͻͪͬΓͰ͸ͳͷ
͹ͯ
ͶͰͺͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹͵ͻͳͬͰ͸ͳ΀

ͼͶͪͷ͹ͷ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͫͰͲ
ͺͻ͹Ͳ͹ͻͪ
ͷͰΌ;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯ͸͹
͵ͻͰͽͪͶͰ

͵ͻͪͽ͵͹ͯͶͪ͵Ͱ
͹ͬ΁Ͱ
ͳ
΂Ͱ͵ͳΔͪͼͽͰ
ͼͬͳΔͰ
͌
ͽͪ͵ͬͳͷ
͵;Εͪͷͪ
͹ͫΒͪ΃Δͪͬͪ

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
͸Ͱ
ͱͳͬͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͼͳͻ͹ͽͳΔͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͳ
ͳͷ;Ε͸ͳ
Γ;ͯͳ
̺Ͱ͹ͷͪ
ͰͭͲ͹
ͽͳ΂͸ͪ
ͷ͹ͻͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺΓͪ͸ͳ͸;
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪͽͳ
͸ͳ΃͵ͪ
΂ͪͻ΃ͳΒͪ
ͼͪ

ͫ;΂͸ͳͷ
ͼͬͰͽ͹ͷ
;
΃ͪͻͰ͸ͳͷ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
͸͹΃Δͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͯ;Εͪ͸ͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;

͸;ͯͳͶͳ
΁ͻͬͰ͸Ͱ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ΕͳͶͳͷͰ
;ͫͻ;ͼͰ
ͬͰͲͰ͸Ͱ
ͲͶͪͽ͸ͳͷ
͸ͳͽͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͻ;΂
͸͹
ͽ͵ͪ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͭͪ΂Ͱ
ͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͰ
͹ͯ
ͿͳͶͳͭͻͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽ͹
;͵ͻͪ΃Ͱ͸͹
͹ͻ;ͱ
ΒͰ
̓ͪ͹
͹ͯΒͰ͵
͸Ͱ͵ͳ΀
ͪͻ΀ͪͳ΂͸ͳ΀
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͪ
ͳ
ͯͻͰͬ͸ͳ΀
;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
ͯͪͬ͸͹

ͺͻ͹΃Ͷͳ΀
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͼͳͭ;ͻ͸͹
ͷ;
ͼͰ
΂ͳ͸ͳ͹
ͺͻͳͲ͹ͻ
ͼͪ΀ͻͪ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
͸ͳ΃͵͹ͷ

ͭͻ͹ͫΓ;
͸ͪ
ͭͻ͹ͫ͹ͬͰ
;͵͹ͺͪ͸Ͱ
ͫͰͲ
ͻͰͯͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͻͰͽ͵ͪ
ͱͰ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͶͪͭͪͶͰ

΀ͻͪ͸;
ͺͪͶͳͶͰ
ͼͬͰΕͰ
ͪ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͺ͹΂ͳΔͪͶͰ
ͯͪ
͸ͪͻͳ΂;
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹͵͹Β͸ͳ͵͹ͷ

̹ͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͽ;
ͳ
ͼͬͰ΃ͽͰ͸ͳ͵
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͽͪͷΒͪ͸͹ͷ
͵ͪͯͳ͹
ͭͻ͹ͫ
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͪΒ;Εͳ
Ͳͪ

 ͊ͻͺͼ͵͹
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
;
ͻͪ͸ͳͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ 

;Ͳͬͻͪͽ
΀ͻͪ͸;
ͳ
ͼͳͽͪ͸
͸͹ͬͪ΁
ͪ
;
ͺ͹ͭͻͰͫ͸͹ͷ
ͻͳͽ;ͪͶ;
;΂Ͱͼͽͬ͹ͬͪͶͳ
ͼ;

ͳ
͏ͳͭͪ͸ͳ
;ͯͪͻͪΒ;Εͳ
;
ͫ;ͫΔͰͬͰ
̽ͻ;ͭͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ
ͺͻͪͬͪ΁
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
͆ͳ΃ͪ
ͳ
͊͵͹ͺΓͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ͹
ͯ͹

͊͹Ͷ;͸ͪ
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ
Γ;ͫͳͽͰΓͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸ͳ΀
ͼͽͪͻͳ͸ͪ
ͯͪͶͰ
͵͹
ͷͪΔͰ
ͪͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͬͪ͸
͆Ͱ
Ͳͪͽ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
m
͸ͪͺͻ͹ͽͳͬ

ͬͰΕ
ͼͽ͹ͭͪ
΃ͽ͹
;ͼͶͰͯ
ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪ
͹͸ͳ
͸ͳͼ;
ͫͳͶͳ
ͯ͹ͼͽ;ͺ͸ͳ

͇ͯͪͫͻͪ͸ͳ
;Ͳ͹ͻͪ͵
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ;
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͻͰ΂ͳͽ
ΒͰͻ
ͺ͹
ͻͰͯ
͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂ͳ
͹
ͼͽͪΔ;
;
Β;ͱ͸ͳͷ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺ͹͵ͻͪΒͳ͸ͪͷͪ
ͺͻͰ
ͳ

ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͻͪͽ͹ͬͪ

͇ͯ
͆ͳ΃ͪ
ͬ͹Ͳ
ΒͰ
ͳ΃ͪ͹
͵ͪ
Β;ͭ;
ͺͻͰ͵͹
̈́Ͱͼ͵͹ͬ΁ͪ
ͳ
̺ͻͪΔͪ
ͯ͹
͉ͳ
ͼͽ͹ͬ΁ͪ
ͭͯͰ
ͼͰ
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹

͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͽ;ͻͼ͵ͪ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͆ͪ
ͽ͹ͷ

ͺ͹ͽͰͲ;
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͪ
ͼͽͪͻͳ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
͵͹Β;
ͼͰ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
;ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͪͬͪ
ͫͳͶͰ
ͼ;
ͻ;΃Ͱͬͳ
͸Ͱ
̓;ͻͬͳ͸ͭͻͪͯͪ
͇ͬ͹
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹
;ͽͬͻΌͰΔͰ
ͳͲ
ͯ͹ͫͪ
͵͸ͰͲͪ
̈́ͪͲͪͻͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹
Όͪ
ͳͲ

ͺͻͳͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
͸Ͱ͵͹Β
ͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵͹Β
ͺͻͳ͸΁ͰͲͳ
ͺ͹ͬ͹ͯͰΕͳ
ͼͰ
͹΂ͳ
ͭͶͰͯ͸͹
Ͳͪ
ͶͰͭͰ͸ͯ͹ͷ
Ͷͳ΃Ͱ͸͹ͷ
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͭ
;ͽͰͷͰΓͰΔͪ
ͯ͹͵
ͼͰ
;
ͷͶͪΌͳͷ

ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
ͽͬͻΌͪͬͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
;͵ͻͪͽ͵͹
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͪͅΒͰͻ

ͼͽͻ



ͼͽͻ


ͼͽͻ


͊ͶͰͯͰΕͪ
ͯͰ͹͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰ͵͹

̹;Βͪ͸͹ͬ΁ͪ
ͳ
͈ͻͰ΃Ͱͬͪ
ͯ͹
̓;ͷͪ͸͹ͬͪ
͋ͪ
ͬͪͻ͹΃ͳ΁ͪ
ͯͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͬ͹ͯͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹
ͻ;
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͳͲ

ͼͽͻ


Ͳͪ
͵ͻͪΕͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
͹ͼͬͻͽ
͹

ͺͶͰͷͰ͸;
̓;ͷͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯͳ΁ͪͷͪ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹ͯ͹ͻͪ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
́ͲͶͪ
ͱ;
ͼͰ
;
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳͷ
΁ͻͽͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵Ͱ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Β;
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
̺ͪͻͯͪͻͪ
ͳ

͊ͽͻ;ͷͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
͸ͪ͵͹͸
ͼͷͻͽͳ
΁ͪͻͪ
͊ͽͰͿͪ͸ͪ
̽;΃ͪ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
ͼͻͰͯͳ΃ͽͰ

ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸Ͱ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
͵͸ͰͱͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
́ͷͰ͸;Β;
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͰΕͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ
΁ͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͬͶͪͼͽͰͶͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͳΕ
ͪͅͻ͵͹
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺΓͪ͸ͳͷͪ

ͫͳ͹
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ
Ͳͪ΀ͬͪΓ;Β;Εͳ
ͺͻͰͬ͹ͯͳͷͪ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
Ͱͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͰͲͳΒͰ
͌
ͽ͹ͷ

͵͹͸ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽ
t΂;ͬͰ͸ͳ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻi
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
;
̿ͰͭͶͳͭ͹ͬ;

͸ͪ
ͯͰͼͰͽ
͵ͳͶ͹ͷͰͽͪͻͪ
ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹
͹ͯ
̓;ͷͪ͸͹ͬͪ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ͺͻͰͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪ
ͽͳ
͵ͪ͹
΁ͻ͵ͬ;
ͼͬ
͚͹ͻΌͪ
;
͊ͽͪͻ͹ͷ
͆ͪͭ͹ͻͳ΂ͳ͸;
͈͹Ͳ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
;

ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹
ͼ;
ͳͲ͹ͼͽͪͬͳͶͰ
͹ͬͪ
ͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪΔͪ
͹΁ͰΔ;Β;Εͳ
ͳ΀
ͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸͹

͵ͪ͹
͸Ͱͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬͪ

͊ͶͰͯͰΕͪ
ͳ
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͫͳͶ͹
ΒͰ
͊͵͹ͺΓͰ
͊ͽͪ
ͻͳΒͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͸ͪͭͶͪ΃ͪͬͪΒ;
ͶͰͺ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͳ
ͼͶͳ͵͹ͬͳͽ͹ͼͽ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͭ

ͽͻͭ͹ͬͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
ͪ
͹ͯ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͼ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͵͹ͷ
ͬͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͪ͵ͬͪ
ͯ;͵ͽͪ
;͵ͪͲ;Β;
ͳͼ͵Γ;΂ͳͬ͹
͸ͪ
͹ͼͷͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
m
̓;ͻ΃;ͷͶͳ
΀ͪ͸

͵ͪͷͰ͸ͳ
ͷ͹ͼͽ
ͅͰ΀ͷͰͯͪ
**
ͳ
tͶͰͺ;
ͽ;ͻͼ͵;
ΘͪͷͳΒ;i
;
ͫͶͳͲͳ͸ͳ
;ͺͻͪͬ͸Ͱ



̸
̽Ͱͻ͹͵͹
͊ͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
͏ͻ͸͹Β
̻͹ͻͳ
ͳ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

m


̹
͋͹ͯͳΕ
͊ͽͪͻ͹
͆ͪͭ͹ͻͳ΂ͳ͸͹
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

 ̽ͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ

ͲͭͻͪͯͰ
̓͹͸ͪ͵ͪ
͇
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͼͽͪͻͳ͸ͪͷͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ
͸ͳ͵ͪ͵ͬ͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
͌ͷͰ
ͼͽ͹
ͽ͹ͭͪ
ͯͪΒͰ
ͼͰ
͵ͻͪͽͪ͵
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͲͫͳͬͪΔͪ
ͳͲ
ͻͪͲͯ͹ͫΓͪ

ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͬͶͪͼͽͳ
;
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
͸ͪͭͶͪ΃ͪͬͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂
͵ͳ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ͸ͳ
;ͲͶͰͽ
͊͵͹ͺΓͪ
Ͳͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
΁ͪͻͪ
̽;΃ͪ͸ͪ
ͪͅΒͰͻ


ͼͽͻ
m

ͼͽͻ


͌
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
͹

͊͵͹ͺΓ;
m
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹
Ͳͪͬͻ΃Ͱͽ͵;
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͻͪͽ͹ͬͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͶ͹
ͬͪͱ͸͹

ͼͻͺͼ͵͹
ͪͯͷͳ͸ͳͼͽͻͪͽͳͬ͸͹
ͳ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ͸͹
ͼͻͰͯͳ΃ͽͰ
m
ͺͻ;ͱͪΒ;
ͫͳͽ͸͹
ͳͲ
ͷͰΔͰ͸;
ͼͶͳ͵;
͆ͪ
ͺͻͬ͹ͷ
ͷͰͼͽ;
ͽ;ͻͼ͵͹
ͳͷͰ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
¾TLÛC
ͲͪͷͰΔͰ͸͹

ΒͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ
ͳ
ͼͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͬͪͻ͹΃ͳͷͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ΌͰ͸͹Β
ͽͰ
ͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
͈ͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
ͬͶͪͼͽͳ
ͬͳͯ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
;
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
͹Ϳͳ΁ͳΒͰͶ
͸ͳͷ
ͼͿͰͻͪͷͪ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
͇͸ͪ
ͼͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
͸Ͱ
͹ͼͰΕͪ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͻͰ΂

͹
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹ͷ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͷ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌ;
m
ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͳͲ;ͲͷͰ
͹͵͹Ͷ͸͹ͼͽ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ

ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͫ͹Γͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳ΀
΀͹ͽͰͶͪ
ͺ͹͸Ͱ͹
͸ͪͲͳͬ
t͏ͪͻ
̽;΃ͪ͸i
͈ͻͳͶͳ
͵Ͱ
ͼͰ
͹΂ͳͭͶͰͯ͸͹
Β͹΃
͸ͳͼ;
ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͼͽͪͫͳͶͳͲ͹ͬͪͶͰ
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͽͪ
ͻͳ͸Ͱ
ͫͳͶͰ
ͳͲ͸͹ͬͪ
͹ͽ͵ͻͳͬͰ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͶͰ
ͯ͹ͼͽ;ͺ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͳͷͪ
ͪͅ
Ͷͳ
͸ͪͺͻͰͯͪ͵
ͳͺͪ͵
͹ͭͶͰͯͪ
ͼͰ
;
ͽ͹ͷͰ
΃ͽ͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;Β;
͹ͫͳͶͪͲͪ͵
ͪͅͻ͵͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͪ
΂ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͰͬͰͶͳ͵ͪ
;ͯͪΓͰ
͸͹ͼͽ
͹ͯ
͊͵͹ͺΓͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͳͷͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͭͪͻͪ͸ͽ
ͫͰͲͫͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬ

ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͵ͪͱͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭͪ͹
΁ͪͻ
̽;΃ͪ͸
ͼͽͻ


ͪ
ͳͼͽ;

ͭͻͰ΃͵;
ͺ͹͸ͪͬΓͪ
ͳ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
͵͹Βͳ
ͳͼͽ͹Β
Ͱͺ͹΀ͳ
ͺͻͳͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
ͳ
ͼ͵͹ͺͼ͵ͳ

̓;ͻ΃;ͷͶͳ΀ͪ͸
ͼͽͻ



́Ͳ
͊͵͹ͺΓͪ
ͬ͹Ͳ͹ͷ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͭͶ͹
͸ͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͳ
Ͳͪ
͊͹Ͷ;͸
ͺͻͰ͵͹
̺ͰͶͰ
ͼͪ
͈ͻͳͶͰͺͪ
ͳ
̽Ͱͷͳͻ
͵ͪͺͳΒͰ
͇ͫͪͬͰ΃ͽͰΔͪ
͵͹Βͪ
;
ͻͪͼͺ͹͸;
͹ͯ
ͼͪͷ͹

ͯͬͰ
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͰ
ͯ͹͸͹ͼͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
͹
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
ͳ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬ;
ͼͽͪ
͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ
ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͼ;
Ͳ͸ͳͷΓͳͬͪ
ͳ
ͻͰ΂ͳͽͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹

ͲͪͬͻͰΌ;Β;
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸;
ͼͽ;ͯͳΒ;
̀ͪ
͸ͪ΃;
ͽͰͷ;
͸ͪ
ͱͪͶ͹ͼͽ
ͻͪͼͺ͹ͶͪͱͰͷ͹

͸Ͱ;ͺ͹ͻͰͯͳͬ͹
͹ͼ͵;ͯ͸ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͭͻͪΌ͹ͷ
͉Ͱ΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ
͸͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
ͼͬ͹ͯͳͶͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂͸͹
ͼͪͷ͹
͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͯͪΔͪ
͹
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͳΕ;

ͪͅͻ͵;
;
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ;
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
ͱͳͬͪ
͵ͪ͵ͬͪ
ͼ;
ͲͪͫͰͶͰͱͰ͸ͪ
;
͹͵͹Ͷͳ͸ͳ

͈ͻͳͶͰͺͪ
ͳ
̽Ͱͷͳͻ
͵ͪͺͳΒͰ
ͪͅΒͰͻ

ͼͽͻ


ͼͽͻ



ͼͽͻ



͇ͯ
͊͵͹ͺΓͪ
ΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ͹
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
ͼͺ͹ͻͰͯ͸ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ
ͺͻͪͬͪ΁
ͺͻͰͷͪ

ͅͳͽͻ͹ͬͳ΁ͳ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
̓ͪ΂ͪ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͌ͻ͹΃Ͱͬ΁ͪ
ͳ
͈ͻͳ΃ͽͳ͸Ͱ
͈;ͽ͸ͳ͵
͵͹Βͳ

ͫͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ΃ͪ͹
͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Β;
̓͹ͼ͹ͬͪ
ͪ
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
ͅͰͽ͹΀ͳΒͰ
ͷ͹ͻͪ͹
ΒͰ

ͯͪ͸ͪ΃Δͳͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵͹ͷ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͰΕͳ
ͯͪ
ͻͪ΂;͸ͪ
ͼ
ͽͰ΃͵͹ͷ
ͫͰͲͫͰͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹ͷ
ͼͳ
ͽ;ͪ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
̓ͻͰͽͪΔͰ
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒ͹ͷ
ͫͳͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
͹ͺͪͼ͸͹
ͳ
ͼͽ͹ͭͪ



̺
̓͹ͻͪΕ
͊ͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͷ͹͸;ͷͰ͸ͽͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ;ͻͰ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
;
͈͹
ͬͪͻͯͪͻΒ;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

m
 ͊ͻͺͼ͵͹
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
;
ͻͪ͸ͳͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ 

͹ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂Ͱ͸͹
m
͵ͪ͵͹
ͺͻͰ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͻͪͽ͹ͬͪ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͳ
͸ͪ͵͹͸
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪ
ͬΓͪΔͪ
ͬͶͪͼͽͳ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
͊ͽ͹ͭͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͭͻͪͷ
͵͹Βͳ
ͺͻͰͯͶͪͱ;

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
ͫͳ͹
ͼͬͰͯͰ͸
͸ͪ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͼͳͭ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͯ͹
͵͹Βͳ΀
ͼͰ

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪͶ͹
ͬ͹Ͳ͹ͷ
ͯ͹͵
ͼͰ
;
;͸;ͽͻͪ΃Δ͹ͼͽ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͲͪͶͪͲͳͶ͹

̓͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͭͻͪͷ
ͫͳ͹
ͼ;ͱͰ͸
ͳ
ͻͰͼͽͻͳ͵ͽͳͬͪ͸
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂ͳ
ͳ
ͽ͹
΃ͽ͹

ͼ;
ͬͪ͸
ͯ͹ͷͪ΃ͪΒͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͪ
ͫͳͶͰ
ͳ
͸ͪΒͬͻͰͯ͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ

ͼͬͰͽͳΔͰ
m
͈ͰΕ͵ͪ
ͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻ΃ͳΒͪ
ͳ
̽Ͱ΂ͪ͸ͳ
͆ͪΒͬͰΕͪ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽ
Ͳͪ

ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͫͳ
ͼͽͳͭͪ͹
ͯ͹
͈ͻͳ΃ͽͳ͸Ͱ
ͫͳͶ͹
ΒͰ
̓͹ͼ͹ͬ͹
ͺ͹ΓͰ
̓ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ

ͬͰΕ
ͳͼͽͪ͵͸;ͽ͹
΂;ͬͰ͸ͪ
ͫͳͽ͵ͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
΀ͻͳ΃Εͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
͹ͼͷͪ͸ͶͳΒͪ
ͳͷͪͶͪ

ΒͰ
ͳ
;
ͼͬͰͼͽͳ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
ͼͬ͹Β;
ͽͻͪͭͳ΂͸;
ͪ;ͻ;
ͳ
ͺͪͻͪͯͳͭͷͪͽͼ͵ͳ

ͼͷͳͼͪ͹
ͺͪ
ΒͰ
͸Ͱͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸ͳ
ͯ͹ͯͳͻ
ͼͪ
ͷͰͼͽ͹ͷ
ΔͰ͸͹ͭ
ͲͫͳͬͪΔͪ
ͷ͹ͻͪ͹

Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁;
ͺ͹ͯͼͽͳ΁ͪͽͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭͪ
ͻͪͲͷͳ΃ΓͪΔͪ
ͳ
͹ͼͰΕͪΔͪ

͋͹
ͼͰ
ͬͳͯͳ
ͳͲ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
͵͹Βͳ
͹ͺ΃ͳͻ͸͹
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͰ
͹

̓͹ͼ͹ͬͼ͵͹ͷ
ͫ͹Β;
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
ͺ͹ͯͻ͹ͫ͸͹
ͳ
ͼͶͳ͵͹ͬͳͽ͹
͹ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
ͭͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂

ͳͲ

ͼͽͻ
m

͊ͶͰͯͰΕͪ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
͵͹͸΁ͳͲ͸ͳΒͪ


ͼͽͻ


ͼͽͻ


ͯ͹͵
ͷ;
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
ͳͲ

ͭ
ͺ͹
ͼͬͰΕ;ΒͰ
ͽͰ͵
ΒͰͯ͸;
ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸ͳ΁;
̀ͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΂͵ͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͯͶͳ͵ͪ
ͼͬͳ΀
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ΀

ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
΃ͽ͹
͹
̓͹ͼ͹ͬͼ͵͹ͷ
ͫ͹Β;
ͺͳ΃;
͸ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;
ͲͪͫͶ;ͯͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
͹
ͽ͹ͷ

ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒ;
ͬͶͪͯͪͶͰ
;
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹Β
ͻ͹ͷͪ͸ͽͳ΂ͪͻͼ͵͹Β
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳ͹ͭͻͪ
ͿͳΒͳ
BͶͳ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͼͪ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬͳ΃ͽͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͼͽͻͪͽͰ΃͵ͳ΀
΁ͳΓͰͬͪ

̸;ͼͽͻ͹;ͭͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͷ͹͸ͪͻ΀ͳΒͰ
͆Ͱͽͪ΂͸Ͱ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͺͻͰͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͸ͳͼ;
ͼͰ
ͽͳ΁ͪͶͰ

ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͳͼ΀͹ͯͪ
ͫͳͽ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ΔͰ͸ͳ΀
;͵;ͺ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯͳ΁ͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͽ͹͵ͪ
ͳ
;΂Ͱ
ͼ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͼͪͷ͹ͭ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͪ
͇͸
ΒͰ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͺͻͰͽͳͻͪ͸
͵ͪ͹
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͪ
ͫͳͽ͵ͪ
;
͵͹
Β͹Β
ͼͰ
͇ͼͷͪ͸ͼ͵͹Β
ͳͷͺͰͻͳΒͳ
ͼ;ͺͻ͹ͽͼͽͪͬͳ͹
ͼͪͬͰͲ
Β;ͱ͸͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀

͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
͸ͪ
΂ͰͶ;
ͼͪ
͊ͻͫͳͷͪ
͆ͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹Β
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ
͵͹Β;
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͯͬ͹ͯͳͶͳ

͵͸ͰͲ
̈́ͪͲͪͻ
ͳ
̺;͵
̹ͻͪ͸͵͹ͬͳΕ
ͫ͹ͻͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͵ͪͱ;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
Β͹΃
ͳ
̹͹
ͼͪ͸΁ͳ
ͺ͹ͯ
͵͹ͷͪ͸ͯ͹ͷ
͵ͻͪΓͪ
͊ͽͰͿͪ͸ͪ
͋ͬͻͽ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͬ͹Βͬ͹ͯͰ
̺Ͷͪͽ͵ͪ
͎ͻͪ
͸ͳΕͪ
͎ͻͬͪͽͳ
͸ͪ
΂ͰͶ;
ͼͪ
ͫͪ͸͹ͷ
́ͬͪ͸͹ͷ
͎͹ͻͬͪͽ͹ͷ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵Ͱ

ͳ
ͬͶͪ΃͵Ͱ
ͽͻ;ͺͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸΁ͳ
͋Ͱ
ͲͪͫͶ;ͯͰ
;ͺ͹ͻ͸͹
ͼͰ

ͺ͹͸ͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͳͲ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
;
ͯͻ;ͭ͹
ͳͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
Β͹΃
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
͹ͬͪΒ

ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷ
;
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹Β
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͳ
ͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪ͸
͸ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬͪͷͪ
͵ͻͳͽͳ΂
͵Ͱ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
͸ͪ;͵Ͱ
͆ͪ
΂ͳͽͪͬ͹ͷ
ͺ;ͽ͸͹ͷ
ͺͻͪͬ΁;
͹ͯ
͊͵͹ͺΓͪ
ͯ͹
ͅͳͽͻ͹ͬͳ΁Ͱ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ
΂ͳͷͪ
ͳͲͯͪͽͳͷ
ͺͻͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͼͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͼͻͰͯ
Δ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸ͳ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͪͷ
ͺ͹
ͼͰͫͳ
ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹

ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͋ͪ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͪ
ͼͽͪͻͳ͸ͪ
͵͹Β;
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͳ
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͬͳͯͰ
ͳ
ͽ͹



̹͹Β
͸ͪ
̓͹ͼ͹ͬ;
m
ͼͽͪͻͳΒͪ
ͳ
͸͹ͬͳΒͪ
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΔͪ
͉Ͱͯͪ͵ͽ͹ͻ
͉
ͅͳ΀ͪΓ΂ͳΕ
̹Ͱ͹
ͭͻͪͯ

 ̽ͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ

ͳͲ
ͯͪΓͳ͸Ͱ
ͫͳͶͰ
ͼ;
ͻ;΃Ͱͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͽͬͻΌͪͬͰ
̀ͬͰ΂ͪ͸
͸ͪ
ͫͻͯ;
;
ͫͶͳͲͳ͸ͳ

ͅͳͽͻ͹ͬͳ΁Ͱ
́Ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
ͼ;
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;͵ͻͪͽ͵͹
͹ͫͪͬͰͼͽͰ
͹
ͯͻͪͷͪ
ͽͳ΂͸ͳͷ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳͷͪ
ͬͰͲͪ͸ͳͷ
Ͳͪ
Ͳͪͽ͹΂ͰΔͰ
͵ͻͪΓͪ
͊ͽͰͿͪ͸ͪ
̽Ͱ΂ͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ

͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͹ͯͳͭͻͪͶͳ
;
͹ͬ͹Β
;ͽͬͻͯͳ
ͪͅΒͰͻ

ͼͽͻ


ͼͽͻ



͆ͪ͵͹͸

ͺͻͳͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͰͺͰ͸͹
ͷͰΔͪΒ;
͸ͪ
ͫ͹ΓͰ
́ͺͪ͵
͸ͪ

ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽ͹ͷ
ͺ;ͽ͸͹ͷ
ͺͻͪͬ΁;
ͳ
ͯͪΓͰ
ͼ;
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸͹
ͻͰͽ͵ͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͼͻͰͯ
Δ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͶͪ΁
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯͪ
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬ

ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͳͲ

ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͯ͹ͯ;΃Ͱ
͈ͻͳͲͻͰ͸
͵ͪ͹
ͱͳͬ͹ͺͳͼͪ͸
ͭͻͪͯͳΕ
;

ͺ͹ͯ͸͹ͱΒ;
͑ͪͻ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸Ͱ
ͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸Ͱ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ
ͳ
ͼͽͪ
ͻͳ͸Ͱ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
ͫͳͶͰ
͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͰ
ͳ
͸Ͱͯ͹ͼͽ;ͺ͸Ͱ
ͫ;ͯ;Εͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͳͶͳ
Ͳͪͺ;
ͼͽͰͶͰ
ͳͶͳ
ͺͻͰ͹ͫͻͪΕͰ͸Ͱ
;
ΘͪͷͳΒͰ
͇
͈ͻͳͲͻͰ͸;
͸ͪ
ͼͶͳ΂ͪ͸
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͭ͹
ͬ͹ͻͳ
ͳ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͸ͪͭͶͪ΃ͪͬͪΒ;Εͳ
ͺͻͳͽ͹ͷ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͭͻͪͯ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
;

ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Β;
͵͹ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ΒͰͯ͸͹
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͯͳͬΓͳΒͳ΀
ͳ
͸ͪΒͷͪΔͰ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ΀

;
΂ͳͽͪͬ͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
͇ͬͪΒ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͽͬͻΌͪͬ;
̀ͬͰ΂ͪ͸

͵ͪ͹
ͷͰͼͽ͹
ͭͯͰ
ΒͰ
;ͼͷͻΕͰ͸
͊ͽͰͿͪ͸
̽Ͱ΂ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;
ͳͲ

ͺͻͳ
ͺͪͯͪ
ͳ
ͲͪͼͶ;ͭͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻͬͳ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͪ
̻ͻͪ΂ͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
̀ͫ͹ͭ
ͫͶͳͲͳ͸Ͱ

͈ͻͳ΃ͽͳ͸Ͱ
͹͸ͪ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͭͶͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͽͳ
ͪ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂Ͱ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵

ͲͶͪͽ͸͹ͭ
ͯ͹ͫͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼͽͬͪ
̺͹ͯͳ΂
ΒͰ
ͽͪ΂͸͹
͹ͺͻͰͯͰͶͳ͹
΁ͻ͵ͬ;

;
ͺͻͬ;
΂Ͱͽͬͻͽͳ͸;

ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͳͼͽͳ΂;Εͳ
͵ͻͼͽ͹͹ͫͻͪͲ͸ͳ
͹ͫͶͳ͵
ΔͰ͸Ͱ
ͪͻ
΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ͹͸ͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬͰ
ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸͹
ͿͻͰͼ͵͹
ͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͼͽͬ͹
ͼͽͻ


͇ͬͳͷ

ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
ͳͼ΁ͻͺΓͰ͸
ͼͺͳͼͪ͵
ͼͽͪͻͳ͸ͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
͸ͪ͵͹͸
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͻͪͽ͹ͬͪ

ͪ
;
͹ͼͬͳͽ
͈ͻͬ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ͬͳͯͰͽͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͲͪͯͰͼͳ͹

͸ͪ
̓͹ͼ͹ͬ;

̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͳͲ

͸ͪ΂ͳ͸ͳ͹
ΒͰ
Β͹΃
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͳͼ͵͹ͻͪ͵
͇͸

;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͳ
;
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
ͼͺ͹ͻͰͯ͸͹ͷ
ͺͻͪͬ΁;
͵͹Βͳ

ͬ͹ͯͳ
͹ͯ
ͅͳͽͻ͹ͬͳ΁Ͱ
͵ͪ
͆͹ͬ͹ͷ
͈ͪͲͪͻ;
ͳ
͊ΒͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͳ
ͯͪΓͰ
;
͹ͫͶͪͼͽ

͈͹ͶͳͷΓͪ
m
;
͈ͻͳΒͰͺ͹ΓͰ
͌ͬͪ΁
ͳ
͈ͻͳͫ͹Β
ͳ
ͳͲ
͈ͻͳΒͰͺ͹Γͪ
;
͈ΓͰͬΓͪ

ͼͽͻ
m

́ͺͪ͵
ͺ͹ͽͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͶ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͶͪ΁
͹ͬͳ΀
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͪ
ͷ͹ͻͪ͹
ΒͰ

ͫͳͽͳ
ͺͻͳͶͳ΂͸͹
͹ͫͰͼ΀ͻͪͫͻͰ͸
͸ͪ͵͹͸
΃ͽ͹
ͫͳ
ͺͻ͹΂ͳͽͪ͹
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹
ΌͰ
͌Ͳ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͻ;ͽͳ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
͹͸
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͻΌͪͬͰ
ͺ;ͽͰ
ͬͰ
ͳ
ͫͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͬͪͻ͹΃ͳ΁Ͱ
ͪ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͪͬͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͼ͹ͺ
ͼͽͬͰ͸Ͱ
ͼͳͭ;ͻ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͹ͫͪͬͰͲ͸͹
ͺ͹ͼͪͬͰͽ;ΒͰ
ͼͪ
͸ͪͯͶͰͱ͸ͳͷ
͵͹͸Ͳ;Ͷ͹ͷ

ͺͻͰ
͸Ͱͭ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
͸Ͱ͵;ͯͪ
͹ͽͳͼ͸Ͱ
͈ͻ͹ͼͰ΂ͪ͸
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͶͪ΁
ͫͳ͹

ΒͰ
;ͼ͵ͻͪΕͰ͸
Ͳͪ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;
͹͵ͬͳͻ;
͹ͬͰ
ͽ;ͻͰ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ͯͪ
ͬͳͯͳ



̸
̸
̻ͳΓͿͰͻͯͳ͸ͭ
͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͺ͹
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
̹͹ͼ͸ͳ
ͳ
͊ͽͪͻ͹Β
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ

͊ͪͻͪΒͰͬ͹

m
́
̀ͯͻͪͬ͵͹ͬͳΕ
͊ͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
̹Ͱ͹
ͭͻͪͯ

m


͊
ͣ;ͻ΂ͳΕ
̹
͋͹ͯͳΕ
̻ͻͪ΂ͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ;ͻͪ
͊Ͷͳ͵ͪͻ
ͼͽͬ͹

͈ͻͳ΃ͽͳ͸ͪ
m
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

 ͊ͻͺͼ͵͹
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
;
ͻͪ͸ͳͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ 

ͻͰ΁ͳͷ͹
΁ͻ͵ͬ;
͊ͬ
͈Ͱͽͻͪ
͚;ͻΌͰͬͰ
͊ͽ;ͺ͹ͬͰ
ͳ
͊͹ͺ͹Εͪ͸Ͱ
͵͹ͯ
͆͹ͬ͹ͭ

͈ͪͲͪͻͪ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ
ͅͳͶͰ΃Ͱͬ;
;
ͫͶͳͲͳ͸ͳ
͈ͻͳΒͰͺ͹Γͪ
ͳͶͳ
͊ͬ
͋ͻ͹Βͳ
΁;
ͺΓͰͬͪΓͼ͵;

͇ͬͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͫͪ΃ͽͳ͸Ͱ

m
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͬͰΕ
ͺ͹΂ͰͶͳ
ͯͪ
͹ͽ͵ͻͳͬͪΒ;
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ
ͼͽͻ;΂Δͪ΁ͳ
m
ͺ͹ͼͽͪΕͰ

ͺͻͪͬͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͽͰ͵
;
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͳΒͰ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͳ
;
ͼͪͼͬͳͷ
ͯͻ;
ͭͪ΂ͳΒͳͷ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
͹͵͹Ͷ͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ

 ̽ͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͳΕ

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

%BOJDB
1PQPWJǀ
4FSCJTDIFT
NJUUFMBMUFSMJDIFT
&SCF
JO
GSÛIFO
EFVUTDIFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO

*O
EFS
WPSMJFHFOEFO
"SCFJU
XJSE
EJF
3F[FQUJPO
EFT
TFSCJTDIFO

NJUUFMBMUFSMJDIFO
&SCFT
JO
EFVUTDIFO
3FJTFSGÛISFSO
WPN
&OEF
EFT


+BISIVOEFSUT
VOE
BVT
EFO
CFJEFO
FSTUFO
+BIS[FIOUFO
EFT

+BISIVOEFSUT

EBSHFMFHU
VOE
BOBMZTJFSU
%FS
6OUFSTVDIVOH
MJFHFO
1VCMJLBUJPOFO
[XFJFS

BOHFTFIFOFS
7FSMBHF
[VHSVOEF
m
KFOFT
WPO
,BSM
#BFEFLFS
XJF
BVDI
EFT

#JCMJPHSBQIJTDIFO
*OTUJUVUT
BVT
-FJQ[JH
*N
.JUUFMQVOLU
VOTFSFT
*OUFSFTTFT

TUFIFO
EBCFJ
ESFJ
BCTJDIUMJDI
BVTHFXÅIMUF
#FJTQJFMF
EJF
VB
GÛS
EBNBMJHF

HFTFMMTDIBGUMJDIF
VOE
QPMJUJTDIF
6NTUÅOEF
NB“HFCMJDI
TJOE
%FS
DISPOPMPHJTDI

FSTUF
JO
EJFTFS
3FJIFOGPMHF
JTU
EFS
3FJTFGÛISFS
BVT

EFS
OÅDITUF
TUBNNU

BVT
EFS
;FJU
EFS
"OTDIMVTTLSJTF


%JF
CFJEFO
MFU[UFO
EJF
3FJTFGÛISFS

WPO
.FZFS
VOE
#BFEFLFS
FOUTUBOEFO

JN
+BIS
XP
EFS
&STUF
8FMULSJFH

BVTCSBDI
%JF
"VTGÛISVOHTTUSVLUVS
EJFTFS
3FJTFGÛISFS
SVIU
BVG
EFO

#FTDISFJCVOHFO
WPO
3FJTFSPVUFO
%BT
(FCJFU
EFS
TFSCJTDIFO
-ÅOEFS
XVSEF

WPO
[XFJ
3PVUFO
EVSDIRVFSU
EJF
FSTUF
GÛISUF
WPO
#VEBQFTU
ÛCFS
#FMHSBE
VOE

4PGJB
OBDI
,POTUBOUJOPQFM
EJF
[XFJUF
BVT
#FMHSBE
ÛCFS
/JØ
7SBOKF
VOE
4LPQKF

CJT
OBDI
5IFTTBMPOJLJ

*N
3BINFO
EFS
FSTUFO
3FJTFSPVUF
LPOOUF
FJO
FVSPQÅJTDIFS
3FJTFOEFS

FJOF
HBO[F
3FJIF
TFIFOTXFSUFS
VOE
JOUFSFTTBOUFS
%FOLNÅMFS
EFT
TFSCJTDIFO

NJUUFMBMUFSMJDIFO
&SCFT
CFTJDIUJHFO
"VG
EFS
3FJTF
EVSDI
»VNBEJKB
LPOOUF
FS

EJF
(FMFHFOIFJU
XBISOFINFO
EJF
,MÕTUFS
3BWBOJDB
VOE
.BOBTJKB
[V
CFTVDIFO

OPDI
XFJUFS
TÛEMJDI
CJT
OBDI
,SVØFWBD
EVSDI[VESJOHFO
[VN
BMUCFSÛINUFO

0SU
XP
EFS
'ÛSTU
-B[BS
IFSSTDIUF
7PO
,SVØFWBD
BVT
LPOOUF
NBO
XFJUFS

FJOF
NFISUÅHJHF
3VOESFJTF
EVSDI
EJF
(FHFOE
JN
.PSBWB
VOE
JN
*CBS5BM

VOUFSOFINFO
[VN
7FSXFJMFO
MVEFO
EPSU
BVDI
EJF
"CIÅOHF
WPO
,PQBPOJL
FJO

%JFTF
3FJTFSPVUF
EJF
3FJTFMFJUFS
BMT
FJOF
EFS
TDIÕOTUFO
FNQGBIMFO
TUFMMUF
GÛS

EJF
5PVSJTUFO
FJO
NBOOJHGBMUJHFT
&SMFCOJT
EBS
4JF
LPOOUFO
OÅNMJDI
HMFJDI[FJUJH

EJF
VOCFSÛISUF
VOE
NBMFSJTDIF
/BUVSMBOETDIBGU
HFOJF“FO
VOE
FJOJHF
FJONBMJHF

%FOLNÅMFS
EFS
NJUUFMBMUFSMJDIFO
"SDIJUFLUVS
VOE
8BOENBMFSFJ
LFOOFO
MFSOFO

m
-KVCPTUJOKB
ÂJǁB
EJF
#VSH
.BHMJǁ
VOE
BMT
)ÕIFQVOLU
EBT
,MPTUFS
4UVEFOJDB

%JF
JO
EFO
WPSIBOEFOFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO
ÛCFS
EJFTF
%FOLNÅMFS
BOHFCPUFOFO

*OGPSNBUJPOFO
TJOE
HSVOETÅU[MJDI
LPSSFLU
VOE
EFN
EBNBMJHFO
8JTTFOTTUBOE

FOUTQSFDIFOE
PCXPIM
EBSJO
NJUVOUFS
&DIPT
BLUVFMMFS
&SFJHOJTTF
[VN
7PSTDIFJO

LPNNFO

%JF
[XFJUF
3FJTFSPVUF
XBS
GÛS
-JFCIBCFS
EFT
"MUFSUÛNMJDIFO
XFOJHFS

BUUSBLUJW
XFJM
EBT
WPSIBOEFOF
BOUJLF
&SCF
XFEFS
WPS
OPDI
VONJUUFMCBS
OBDI
EFN

 ͊ͻͺͼ͵͹
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
;
ͻͪ͸ͳͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ 

[XFJUFO
8FMULSJFH
[VHÅOHMJDI
XBS
#FJTQJFMTXFJTF
FNQGBIMFO
EJF
3FJTFGÛISFS

JO
EFOFO
4LPQKF
BMT
3FJTF[JFM
EBSHFTUFMMU
XVSEF
OVS
EJF
#FTJDIUJHVOH
EFT
OBIF

MJFHFOEFO
,MPTUFST
EFT
)FJMJHFO
.BSLP
VOE
EJFT
FSTU
OBDI

%JF
HSՓUF

6OTJDIFSIFJU
IFSSTDIUF
BVG
EFN
,PTPXP
VOE
.FUPDIJFO
XP
OJDIU
FJONBM
EJF

CFSÛINUFTUFO
%FOLNÅMFS
FUXB
EJF
1BUSJBSDIJF
WPO
1Fǀ
EBT
,MPTUFS
%FǁBOJ

PEFS
EJF
,JSDIFO
JO
1SJ[SFO
[VHÅOHMJDI
XBSFO
&STU
OBDI

XJSE
JO
EFO

3FJTFGÛISFS
FJO
#FTVDI
JN
,MPTUFS
(SBǁBOJDB
FNQGPIMFO
XBT
EBOL
EFS
/ÅIF

WPO
1SJØUJOB
TJDIFS
HFOVH
XBS
&T
JTU
JOUFSFTTBOU
[V
FSXÅIOFO
EBTT
JO
BMMFO

"VTHBCFO
EFS
BOBMZTJFSUFO
3FJTFGÛISFS
ÛCFS
EJF
4DIMBDIU
BVG
EFN
"NTFMGFME

CFSJDIUFU
XVSEF
EJF
JN
#FXVTTUTFJO
EFS
3FJTFOEFO
BVT
EFN
8FTUFO
FJOFO

CFTPOEFSFO
1MBU[
FJOOBIN
%JFTFT
&SFJHOJT
XVSEF
KFEPDI
GÅMTDIMJDIFSXFJTF

m
JO
¾CFSFJOTUJNNVOH
NJU
XFJU
WFSCSFJUFUFN
*SSHMBVCFO
EFS
SPNBOUJTDIFO

(FTDIJDIUTTDISFJCVOH
BCFS
BVDI
NJU
FJOJHFO
TUSBUFHJTDIFO
;JFMFO
EFS

¸TUFSSFJDIJTDI6OHBSJTDIFO
.POBSDIJF
m
BMT
FJO
,BNQG
EFT
TÛETMBXJTDIFO

#ÛOEOJTTFT
HFHFO
EBT
PTNBOJTDIF
*NQFSJVN
JOUFSQSFUJFSU

*N
(SVOEF
HFOPNNFO
XVSEF
EBT
NJUUFMBMUFSMJDIF
&SCF
BVG
EFN
(FCJFU

EFS
TFSCJTDIFO
-ÅOEFS
OBDI
EFO
#BMLBO,SJFHFO
JO
HSՓFSFN
6NGBOH
GÛS

3FJTFOEF
BVT
EFN
8FTUFO
[VHÅOHMJDI
%JF
%FOLNÅMFS
EFS
TFSCJTDIFO
,VMUVS

XVSEFO
FSTU
WJFM
TQÅUFS
[VN
FDIUFO
UPVSJTUJTDIFO
3FJTF[JFM
VOE
[XBS
VOUFS

WÕMMJH
WFSÅOEFSUFO
HFTDIJDIUMJDIFO
6NTUÅOEFO
͉ͳͿͪͽ
͇̺̓͌̈́̾͆́ͣ

ͅ;ͲͰΒ
͸ͪ;͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͽͰ΀͸ͳ͵Ͱ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

͉͇́͆̽͌͊͋́͊̓͠

̸͚͆͊̈́̾̾
͉͈͇̻͊͊̓

̸̽̾̈́
̸̸͈͇̺̽͌͆͡

́͸ͽͰ͸Ͳͳͬ͸͹
ͼͳͼͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵͹
ͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͯͳͼ΁ͳͺͶͳ͸ͪͻ͸͹
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ
ΔͰ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
;
͸ͪ΃͹Β
ͲͰͷΓͳ
ͽͻͪΒͰ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
;͸ͪ
Ͳͪͯ
ͼͪ
ͻͰ͵͹ͭ͸͹ͼ΁ͳͻͪΔͰͷ
ͽͰͻͰ͸ͪ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͷͪͽͰ
ͻͳΒͪͶ͸ͳ΀
͹ͼͽͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͼͽͪͻͳ΀
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͽͰ΀͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼͪ
͵ͪ͹

ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹ͭ
΃ͳͻͰͭ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
͵͹͸ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ
͈͹Ͳͳͽͳͬͪ͸
ͺ͹ͷͪ͵
ͼͰ
ͯͰͼͳ͹

Ͳͪ΀ͬͪΓ;Β;Εͳ
ͻͰͪͶ͸͹Β
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͳ͵;ͺͰ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ

ͽͰ΀͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
;
͸ͪ΃͹Β
ͲͰͷΓͳ
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͼͺͻ͹ͬͰͯͰ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͪ
ͬͪͶ͹ͻͳ
Ͳͪ΁ͳΒͪ
̓͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͬͰΕ
ͼͽͬ͹ͻͰ͸Ͱ
ͫͪͲͰ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͼ;
ͳ
;ͻͫͪ͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ

Ͳͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͳ
Ͳͪͬ͹ͯͳ
Ͳͪ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽ;
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
Ͳͪ
͵͹͸͵ͻͰͽ
͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͰ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͸ͺͻ
ͫͳͶͪ
͹͸ͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ
ͻͰ͵͹ͭ͸͹ͼ΁ͳͻͪ
ΔͰͷ
;
͹͵ͬͳͻ;
̓͹ͻͳͯ͹ͻ

Ͳͪ
̺Ͷͪͯ;
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͳ
͸ͪ
͵ͻͪΒ;
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͰ

ͷͰΌ;͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͼͪͻͪͯΔͰ
m
͉Ͱͭͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͭͻͪͷͳ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͳ

ͳ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͭ
͹͵ͻ;ͱͰΔͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
4"*5$)0304


͆͹ͬͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͳ
ͳ
͉ͪͯ͸ͪ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͈͹ͯ;͸ͪͬͼ͵ͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ

"3(&
%POBVMBOEFS


"3(&
%POBVMBOEFS

,VMUVSTUSBTTF
%POBV

ͼͰ͵΁ͳΒͪ
Ͳͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒ;

"3(&
%POBVMBOEFS
͉ͪͯ͸ͪ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͈͹ͯ;͸ͪͬͼ͵ͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
ͼͪ

;ͺͻͪͬ͸ͳͷ
ͽͰͶ͹ͷ
͵͹ΒͰ
΂ͳ͸ͳ
̓͹͸ͿͰͻͰ͸΁ͳΒͪ
΃ͰͿ͹ͬͪ
ͬͶͪͯͪ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
ͺ͹ͽ
ͺͳͼ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͼͺ͹ͻͪͲ;ͷͪ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͽͳ΂Ͱ
̽;͸ͪͬ
ͳ
ͽ͹
̹ͪͬͪͻ
 ͉ͳͿͪͽ
̓;ͶͰ͸͹ͬͳΕ

ͼ͵Ͱ
̽͹ΔͰ
̸;ͼͽͻͳΒͰ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͪ΂͵Ͱ
ͪͅΌͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
̹;ͭͪͻ

ͼ͵Ͱ
͉;ͷ;͸ͳΒͰ
ͅ͹ͶͯͪͬͳΒͰ
ͳ
͌͵ͻͪΒͳ͸Ͱ
͢;
΂ͳ͸Ͱ

ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪ
;
;͵;ͺ͸͹


ͺͻͳͫͻͰͱ͸ͳ΀
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹
ͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺ
ͼ͵͹
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂ΒͰ
ͳ
Ͳͪ
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͹͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͪ
Ͳͪ
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
ΒͰ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
͸Ͱ͵ͪ

ͬͻͼͽͪ
ͺͻͰͬ͹ͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
;
̾͌
͇ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͪ
͸ͪ΂ͰͶͪ
͉ͪͯ͸Ͱ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ΒͰͼ;
΃ͳͻͰ
ΔͰ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͯͳͷͰ͸ͲͳΒͰ
͹΂;ͬͪΔͰ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͫͪ΃ͽͳ͸Ͱ
͵ͪ͹

ͳ
ͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪΔͰ
ͬͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͼͶͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ΀
͵͹ͻͰ͸ͪ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵Ͱ

΁ͳͬͳͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͇ͼͳͷ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͼͶͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͰ
ͲͰ
ͷΓͰ
ͺ͹ͬͰͲ;ΒͰ
ͽ͹͵
ͻͰ͵Ͱ
̽;͸ͪͬ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
;Ͳ
ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͿͶͰ͵ͼͳͫͳͶ͸͹ͼͽͳ

ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͺ͹ͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳ
ͳ
͵ͪ͹
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸ͪ
Ͳ͹͸ͪ
;
͸ͪΒ΃ͳͻͰͷ
ͼͷͳͼͶ;

̽ͪ͵ͶͰ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
͹
͵͹Β͹Β
ΒͰ
͹ͬͯͰ
ͻͰ΂
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
͹ͯ

͵ͷ
;Ͳ
ͶͰͬ;
ͳ

ͯͰͼ͸;
͹ͫͪͶ;
̽;͸ͪͬͪ
΁ͰͶͳͷ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳͷ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ


͆ͪͯͶͰͱ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͉ͪͯ͸Ͱ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͼ;
Ϳͳ͸ͪ͸ͼͳͻͪΔͰ
͵͹͸ͽͻ͹Ͷͪ
ͼͪ
ͯͻͱͪΒͪ
ͳ
ͻͰͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ΒͰ͵ͪͽͪ
͇ͼͳͷ
ͽ͹ͭͪ
̾͌
Ϳͳ͸ͪ͸ͼͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͻ
ͱͪͬͪ
͉ͪͯ͸;
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΁;
ͺͻ͹ͭͻͪͷͳͷͪ
1)"3&
ͳ
5"$*4
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͺͻ͹
ͭͻͪͷͰ
*OUFSSFHOVN
**
ͳ
***
̀ͪ΀ͬͪΓ;Β;Εͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
ͺͻͳͼͽͳͭͶͳͷ
͹ͯ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
;΂Ͱͼ͸ͳ΁ͪ

΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸͹
ΒͰ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͳͲͻͪΌͰ͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͸ͪ


ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ;
́ͪ͵͹
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
Β͹΃
͸ͳΒͰ
;
ͼͬ͹Β͹Β
͵͹͸ͪ΂͸͹Β

ͳͶͳ
ͳͯͰͪͶ͸͹Β
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳ
͹͸ͪ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͼͪͯͻͱͳ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸Ͱ
ͯͳͭͳͽͪͶͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͭͰ
 ́͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
͈͹ͯ;͸ͪͬΓͪ 

͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵Ͱ
͵ͪͻͽͰ
͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪΒ;Εͳ΀
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪ
ͼͪ
ͪͯͰ͵ͬͪͽ͸ͳͷ
ͶͰͭͰ͸ͯͪͷͪ

̽ͪΓͰ
͹ͬͪ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͷ͹ͭ;ΕͳͶͪ
ͼͬͪ͵͹Β
ͲͰͷΓͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳ

ͺ͹͸ͪ͹ͼ͹ͫ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵
ͯ͹ͷͪΕͳ͸ͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ
ͳ
Ͱ͸ͭͶͰͼ͵ͳ

ͳ
Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪ
ͿͳΒͪͷͪ
̓͹͸͵ͻͰͽ͸͹
ͺͻͰͽͻͪͭ͹ͷ
ͷ͹ͱͰͽͰ
ͺͻ͹͸ͪΕͳ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸

ͳͶͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
͵͹͸ͼ;Ͷͽ;Β;Εͳ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵;
ͯͳͭͳͽͪͶ͸;
͵ͪͻͽ;
ͳ
ͶͰͭͰ͸ͯ;
͸ͪ

Δ͹Β
ͳ
ͼͪͲ͸ͪͽͳ
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͹
͸ͺͻ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹ͼͽͳͷͪ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳͷ
ͷͪ͸ͳͿͰͼͽͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳͷ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽͳͷͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͳ͸
ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͷ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌ;
͉ͪͯ͸ͪ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͳͷͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͼͰ͵΁ͳΒͪ
ͪ
;
͹͵ͬͳͻ;
ͼͰ͵΁ͳΒͰ
͆ͪ;͵ͪ

ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
ͼͪͯͻͱͰ
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ΒͰ͵ͽͳ
̽;͸ͪͬ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
,VM
UVSTUSBTTF
%POBV

ͳ
̽;͸ͪͬ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͪ
ͷͪͭͳͼͽͻͪͶͪ
͇ͼͽͪͶͰ
ͼͰ͵΁ͳΒͰ

ͼ;

͈ͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ͸͹
ͺͶͪ͸ͳͻͪΔͰ
ͳ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽͪ
͹͵͹Ͷͳ͸Ͱ
ͼͪ
ͺͻ͹ΒͰ͵ͽͳͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹

ͼ;
̀ͪ΃ͽͳͽͪ
ͬ͹ͯͪ
ͳ
͆ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ
ͺͪͻ͵͹ͬͳ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͼͰ͵΁ͳΒͪ
͊ͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ

ͳ
ͻ;ͯͪͻͼͽͬ͹
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
̽ͻͱͰΕͳ
ͼͰ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΀
͸ͪ΂ͰͶͪ
͉ͪͯ͸Ͱ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
;
͸ͪ΃Ͱͷ
ͯͰͶ;
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͯ͹
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ΒͰ
;
ͿͪͲͪͷͪ
*OUFSSFHOVN
**
ͳ
***
ͳ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͽͻͳ
ͺ͹ͽͺͻ͹
ΒͰ͵ͽͪ
ͳͲͻͪΌͰ͸ͪ
̓;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͪ
ͷͪͺͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
͈͹ͯ;͸ͪͬΓͪ
̓͹͸͵ͻͰͽ
͸͹
ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͪ
ͳ
ͳͲͻͪͯͪ
͵ͪͻͪͽͪ
ͬͪͶ͹ͻͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳ
͹ͫͻͪͯͪ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͳ
ͷͪ͸ͳͿͰͼͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͳ
;
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͷ
͵͹ͻͪ͵;
Δͳ΀͹ͬͪ
ͺͻͰ
ͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͌
ͼͪͻͪͯΔͳ
͎;ͰͫͰͻͪ
ͳͲ
ͅͳ͸΀Ͱ͸ͪ
ͳ
̻Ͱ͹͵ͪͻͽͰ
ͯͳͭͳͽͪͶͳͲ͹
ͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
ͼͬͰ
͵ͪͻͽͰ
͸ͪ΃Ͱͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
͈͹ͯ;͸ͪͬΓͪ
ͳ
ͲͪͼͰͫ͸͹
ͼͬͳ΀
ͬͰΕͳ΀
ͭͻͪ
ͯ͹ͬͪ
͹ͫͻͪΌͰ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
ͳ
Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
Ͳͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͹ͯ

͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽͪ
ͳ

ͷͪ͸ͳͿͰͼͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ΂͵ͳ
Ͳͪͬ͹ͯ
Ͳͪ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽ;
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͳ
ͅ;ͲͰΒ
͸ͪ;͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͽͰ΀͸ͳ͵Ͱ

͆Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
;
͹͵ͬͳͻ;
͉ͪͯ
͸Ͱ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͸ͪͼͽͪͶͳ
ͼ;
͵ͪ͹
ͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͪͽ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͫͪͲͪ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ

͵͹͸͵ͻͰͽ͸͹
ͻͰ΁Ͱ͸ͽ͸ͳ΀
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
͸ͪ΃Ͱͭ

ͯͰͶͪ
͈͹ͯ;͸ͪͬΓͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳ
ͼͽͻ;΂͸͹Β
ͳ
΃ͳͻ͹Β
Βͪͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹
ͻ;
͹ͯ

͵ͷ
ͶͰͬ͹
ͳ
ͯͰͼ͸͹
͹ͯ
̽;͸ͪͬͪ
;
;͵;ͺ͸͹Β
ͯ;ͱͳ͸ͳ
͹ͯ

͵ͷ

͠Ͱͯ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
;ΒͰͯ͸͹
ͳ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹ͼͽͳ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͪͻͰͪͶͪ

ͺͻ͹ͳͼͽͰ͵Ͷͪ
ͳͲ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽ͹ͭ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͪͶ͸͹ͭ
͵͹͸ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ

ΒͰ
ͳ
͹΂ͳͭͶͰͯ͸ͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽ͹ͼͽ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
;
ͽͳͺ;
ͳ
͹ͫͳͷ;

ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͰ

ͯͪ͸ͪ΃ΔͰ
ͼͰͬͰͻ͸Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ΃ΔͰ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳ
ΒͰ
ͳ
Β;ͱ͸͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
͈ͪ͸͹͸ͼ͵Ͱ
͸ͳͲͳΒͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͯͰͶͪ
̺͹Βͬ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ
΃ΔͰͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
̸;ͼͽͻ͹;ͭͪͻͼ͵͹ͭ
΁ͪͻͼͽͬͪ
́͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪ
̺͹Βͬ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

ͺ͹΂ͰͶͪ
ΒͰ
Β͹΃
;
97***
ͬͰ͵;
ͼ
͹ͼͶ͹͸΁Ͱͷ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͰ΀ͻͪͷͫͰ͸;
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒ;

ͳͻͳͭͪ΁ͳ͹͸Ͱ
ͼͳͼͽͰͷͰ
ͳ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ͸;
ͷͻͰͱ;
͌
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ΒͰ
ͽͪΒ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼ

ͺ͹͵ͻͰ͸;ͽ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
;
ͯͻ;ͭ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͪ
ΔͰ͸;
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ;

ͽ͹ͭͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
͹ͼͳͷ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ͸Ͱ
ͷͻͰͱͰ
ͺͻͰ΀ͻͪͷͫͰ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽͳͶ͸Ͱ

 ͉ͳͿͪͽ
̓;ͶͰ͸͹ͬͳΕ

ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͰ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳ΃;
ͳ
ͬͰΕͪ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͻ͹ΒͰΔͪ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲ

ͬ͹ͯΔͪ
ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻͳ΂͸Ͱ
Ͱ͸ͰͻͭͳΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽͳͶ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͬ͹Β͸ͪ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͪ
͌

ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳͷ
΁ͻͽͪͷͪ
ͼͳͽ;ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
ͽͪ͵ͬͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

́Ͳͬ͹ͻͳ

͆Ͱ͵Ͱ
͹ͯ
ͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͫͪͬͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ͹ͷ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
ͯͳ
ͻͰ͵ͽ͸͹
ͼͰ
ͳͶͳ
ͳ͸ͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ͸͹
ͫͪͬͰ
͹ͬͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷ͹ͷ
́ͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͭͻͪΌͰ

͹
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͷ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌ;
ͺ͹͸Ͱ͵ͪͯ
ͳͷͪ
;
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶ͸ͳͷ

Ϳͪͫͻͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͪͻ΀ͳ
ͬͪͷͪ
ͳͶͳ
;
ͪͻ΀ͳͬͳͷͪ
ͬͰΕͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͭͯͰ
ͼͰ
΂;ͬͪ
ͼ͹Ͷͳͯͪ͸
ͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶ

͆ͪ
ͱͪͶ͹ͼͽ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
m
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ͸͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
͹ͬͪΒ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
͸ͳ
͸ͪ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
͹ͬ͹
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂
͸͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
͊ͻͰΕ͹ͷ
;
ͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͳ΀
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͪ
ͳ͸ͽ
͸ͰͲͳͬ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͹

ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͷ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌ;
̾͸ͭͶͰͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͶͳ
͉;ͻͪ
͸ͺͻ
͵͹Βͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;

ͫ͹ͭͪͽ͹
ͳͶ;ͼͽͻ͹ͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂Ͱ
Ͳͪ
͹ͫͳͶͪͲͪ͵
ͼͽͪͻͳ΀
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͪ
ͯͪͽͰ
ͻͰ
ͭͳΒͰ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;ͭͰͻͳ΃;
ͻ;ͽͰ
͹ͫͳͶͪͼ͵ͪ
ͼͽͪͻͳ΀
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒ΀ͼ͵ͳ΀
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽͪ

ͽͰ
ͼͰ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͳ
Ͳ͹ͬ;
͉;ͽͰ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͇ͼͳͷ
ͽ͹ͭͪ
͹͸ͳ
͸ͪͷ
ͯͰ
ͽͪΓ͸͹
ͺͻ;ͱͪΒ;
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΔͪ
ͳ
͹
͹ͼͽͪͶͳͷ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͻͰͭͳΒͰ
͹
͵͹Β͹Β

ΒͰ
ͻͰ΂
͉ͪͲͬ͹ΒͰͷ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͺ;ͶͪͻͳͲͪ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽͪ
;ͫͻͲͪ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
͹Ͷͪ͵΃ͪ
͸͹
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͼͪΔͰ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸͹
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͪ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀

΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͸ͪͼͽͪͶͳ
ͻͰ΁ͳ͵Ͷͪͱ͹ͷ
ͼͽͪͻͳ΀
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
Ͳ͹͸ͪ

͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͸ͺͻ
Ͳ͹͸ͪ
*SPO
#SJEHF
(PSHF
;
̺ͰͶͳ͵͹Β
̹ͻͳͽͪ͸ͳΒͳ
ͳͶͳ
΃ͳ
ͻͰ
ͭͶͰͯͪ͸͹
ͬͰΕ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
"3(&
%POBVMBOEFS
͊΀͹ͯ͸͹
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͰ

ͻͰΕͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͸ͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͼͪΒͽ;
"3(&
%POBVMBEFS
;ΒͰͯ͸͹

ͳ
ͺͻͬͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
͸ͪ΃Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ

́ͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪͽ
ͳ
ͽͰͻͰ͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ

̽͹
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ͼ;
ͻͰ͵͹ͭ͸͹ͼ΁ͳͻͪΔͰͷ
͹ͫ;΀ͬͪΕͰ͸ͳ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͼͬͳ
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳ

ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽ͹Β
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
͌ͺ͹ͻͰΌͳͬͪΔͰͷ

ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͪ
ͳ
ͼͽͪΔͪ
͸ͪ
ͽͰͻͰ͸;
;ͽͬͻͯͳ͹
ͼͪͷ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͰΕͳ͸ͪ
Ͳ͸ͪ
΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͬ͹ͷ
ͷͰͼͽ;
̽Ͱ͹
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͰ͸ͳ΀

Ͷ͹͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͼͽͪͻͳ΀
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͼͽͻ͹ΒͰΔͪ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͯͪ

ͼ;
͸Ͱ͵ͪ
͹ͯ
Δͳ΀
;͸ͳ΃ͽͰ͸ͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
;ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͷͰ
ͳͲͷͰ͸ͳͶͪ
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳΒ;

ͳ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯ
͇ͬͪ
͹ͺͪͼ͵ͪ
ͺͻͬͰ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸͹
ͼͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳ
͸ͪ
ͷͪΔͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͻ͹ΒͰΔͪ

ͳ
͸ͪ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͰ
;
Ͳ͹͸ͪͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
;
͸͹ͬͳΒͰ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͺͻͰͽͻͺͰͶͰ
͹ͲͫͳΓ͸Ͱ

ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͬͰΕͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ΀
Ͳͪ΀ͬͪͽͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ

͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ΃ΔͰ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
Ͳ͹͸Ͱ
;
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͷ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͷ͸͹
 ́͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
͈͹ͯ;͸ͪͬΓͪ 

΃ͽͬ͹
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽͪ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
΂ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͷͰ͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰΔͰ͸ͪ
;

ͯ͹ͫͻ͹ͷ
ΒͰ
ͼͽͪΔ;
ͺͻͬͰ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸͹
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͼ͹Ͷͳͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͭͻͪͯΔͰ
ͳ
ͫͻͳͭͰ
͸͹
ͬ͹ͭ
ͬͶͪͼ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͌
΃ͳͻͰͷ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻ;
ͬͰΕͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͳͷͪ
ͳ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;

ͯ͹͸Ͱͯͪͬ͸͹
ͫͳͶͳ
;
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳΒͳ
ͳ
;
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹ͷ
ͼ;
ͼͽͪΔ;
̀ͪ΀ͬͪΓ;Εͳ
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹Β

Ͷ͹͵ͪ΁ͳΒͳ
ͳ
ͼ͹Ͷͳͯ͸͹Β
ͭͻͪͯΔͳ
͹͸ͳ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͫͳͽͳ
ͺ͹ͭ͹ͯ͸ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻͰ͸ͪͷͰ͸;

͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
͸ͺͻ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳ
ͺͪͷ;΂͸ͳ
͵͹ͷͫͳ͸ͪͽ
ͼͽͪͻͪ
̓Ͷͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͳ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳ
ͬ;͸ͪͻͼ͵ͳ
͵͹ͷͫͳ͸ͪͽ
͵͹ͯ
͈ͪ͸΂Ͱͬͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ͷ͹ͼͽͪ
͊͹͵͹
ͺͰ͵ͪ
ͻͪ
ͼͽͪͻͪ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͪ
Ͳ͹͸ͪ
͸ͪ
̈́ͳͷͪ͸;
ͳ
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ
͵͹ͺͶͰ͵ͼ
͸ͪ

͆͹ͬ͹ͷ
͸ͪͼͰΓ;
;
͆͹ͬ͹ͷ
͊ͪͯ;
ͳͽͯ
̓ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͻͰ΂
͹
ͭͻ;ͺͳ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽͪ
͵͹Βͳ

ͼ;
;
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳΒͳ
͵ͪ͵ͬͳ
ͼ;
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͷͪ΃ͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͷͶͳ͸͹ͬͳ
ͳͶͳ
ͳͻͰ
ͬͰͻͲͳͫͳͶ͸Ͱ
΁ͻͺ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
Ͳͪ
ͬ͹ͯ;
ͼͽͪͻͳ
͹͵͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

͹΂;ͬͪ͸ͪ

;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫ͸ͪ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽ
ΒͰͼͽͰ
͹͸͹
΃ͽ͹
ͳͷ
ͭͪͻͪ͸ͽ;ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹
ͼͽͪΔͰ
ͺ͹͸Ͱ
͵ͪͯ
ͳ
ͳͲͬͪ͸ͻͰͯ͸͹
͇ͬ͹Β
ͭͻ;ͺͳ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒ;
ͳ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳ

Ͳͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ;
͸ͪ;͵Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
Ͳͭͻͪͯͪ
ͺͻͬͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
͇ͺͼͰͻͬͪͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ

ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͇ͺͼͰͻͬͪͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
͸ͪ
̀ͬͰͲͯͪͻͳ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
͈͹ͼͰͫ͸;
ͭͻ;ͺ;
΂ͳ͸Ͱ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͬͪ͸
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳΒͰ
͸ͳͼ;

ͻͰͬͳͽͪͶͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͪ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹
ͼͽͪΔͰ
ͼͰ
͵ͻͰΕͰ
͹ͯ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹ͭ
ͯ͹
ͯͰ
ͬͪͼͽͳͻͪ͸͹ͭ
͹ͫͳ΂͸͹
ͼ;
͸ͪͺ;΃ͽͰ͸ͳ
ͳ
͹
Δͳͷͪ
͸ͳ͵͹
͸Ͱ
ͬ͹ͯͳ
ͻͪ΂;͸ͪ

͇͸ͳ
ͺ͹͸Ͱ͵ͪͯ
΂ͳ͸Ͱ
ͯͰ͹
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ΃ΔͰͳ΀
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
Ͳ͹͸ͪ

ͯͰͶ;Β;

Βͪͯ͸͹
ͳ
Ͳͪͺ;΃ͽͰ͸͹
ͪͬͰͽͳΔͼ͵ͳ
ͼ;
ͺͻͪͲ͸ͳ
ͳͶͳ
ͼ;
͵ͪͽ͵ͪͯ
͸ͪͼͰΓͰ͸ͳ

ͫͰͼ͵;Ε͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ

̓ͻͪΒͰͷ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
Ͳͪ΀ͬͪΓ;Εͳ
ͼͬ͹ͷ
͹ͺͻͰͯͰΓͰΔ;
Ͳͪ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻͪ͸

ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
ͳ
ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻͳͿͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͳͪ͵͹
ͷͪͶͪ
ͳ
ͼͳͻ͹ͷͪ΃͸ͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͺͪ͵

Ͳͪ͵͹ͻͪ΂ͳͶͪ
;
ͽͪͯͪ
͸ͪΒͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳΒͰ
΁ͳͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͽ͹͵͹ͬͰ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
;

͵͹ͻͪ͵
ͼ
͸ͪΒͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ͸ͳΒͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͳ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
;ͬͰͶͳ

ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻͳ΂͸;
Ͱ͸ͰͻͭͳΒ;
͈ͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯΔͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͷͰ͸ͪ
ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻͳ΂͸Ͱ
Ͱ͸ͰͻͭͳΒͰ

ΒͰ
Ͳͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒ;
ͽ͹ͭͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͳͶͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ
ͳͼ͵͹ͻͪ͵
ͳ
͹ͷ͹ͭ;ΕͳͶͪ
ΒͰ

͸ͰͼͷͰͽͪ͸
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
̾ͶͰ͵ͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
ͭͻͪΌͰ͸Ͱ
͸ͪͷͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ
Ͳͪ

ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͰ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͰ
ͺͻͳ
΂Ͱͷ;
ΒͰ
͵͹ͻͳ΃ΕͰ͸ͪ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͪ
͹ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͻͰ͸͹
ͷͳͻͪ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹Όͪ΂ͪ
4JFNFOT
4DIVDLFSU
ͳ
"&(

ͳ
ͺͻͳͷͰΔͳͬͪ͸ͪ

͸ͪΒ͸͹ͬͳΒͪ
ͽͰ΀͸ͳ΂͵ͪ
ͻͰ΃ͰΔͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻͪ
ͻͪͯͳ
͋ͰͼͶͳ͸
ͺ͹Ͷͳ
ͿͪͲ͸ͳ
ͽͻͪ͸ͼͿ͹ͻͷͪͽ͹ͻ
́ͲͭͻͪΌͰ͸
ΒͰ
ͼͳͼͽͰͷ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯΔͰ
ͳ
ͯͳͼͽͻͳͫ;
΁ͳΒͰ
ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻͳ΂͸Ͱ
Ͱ͸ͰͻͭͳΒͰ
;
΂ͳΒͰͷ
ΒͰ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬ;
ͫͳͶ͹
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
΀ͳͯͻ͹ͰͶͰ͵
ͽͻͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ΀
ͽͰͻͷ͹ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻͪ͸ͪ
̀ͫ͹ͭ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹
΁Ͱͼͪ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯΔͰ
ͼͬͰ
ͽͰͻͷ͹ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
Ͷ͹΁ͳͻͪ͸Ͱ
;
͸Ͱͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸͹Β

ͫͶͳͲͳ͸ͳ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ΀
ͻͰ͵ͪ
ͽͻͪ͸ͼͺ͹ͻͽ
;ͭΓͪ
ͳ
΃Γͪ͵Ͱ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻ
ͽͰ΀͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ

ͬ͹ͯͰ
Ͳͪ
΀ͶͪΌͰΔͰ
ͷͪ΃ͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼ͵Ͷ͹ͺ͹ͬͪ

͋͹
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹
ͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͽͳ

͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͭͯͰ
ͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͰ
ͽͻͳ
͹ͯ
΂Ͱͽͳͻͳ
ͼͽͪͻͰ
ͽͰͻͷ͹
 ͉ͳͿͪͽ
̓;ͶͰ͸͹ͬͳΕ

ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻͳ΂͸Ͱ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
͵ͪͶ͹ͻͳ΂͸Ͱ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͽ͹
ͽͪͯͪ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͶ͹

ͼͬͰ
ͳͲͭͻͪΌͰ͸Ͱ
;
Ͳ͹͸ͳ
̽͹ͻΕ͹Ͷͪ
ͳ
̀Ͱͷ;͸;
;
͸Ͱͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸͹Β
ͫͶͳͲͳ͸ͳ
̽;
͸ͪͬͪ
ͽͻͳ
͸ͪ
̽͹ͻΕ͹Ͷ;
ͺͻͬͪ
ͬͰΕͪ
ͽͰͻͷ͹ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻͪ͸ͪ
;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ

ͼͻ;΃Ͱ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͯͬͰ
Β͹΃
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͰΕͰ
m
͸ͪ
;ͭͶ;
;Ͷͳ΁ͪ
̽͹ͫͻͪ΂ͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͊͵Ͱ͸ͯͰͻ
ͫͰͭ͹ͬͰ
ͳ
͊͸ͪͭͪ
ͳ
ͼͬͰͽͶ͹ͼͽ
;
̽͹ͻΕ͹Ͷͼ͵͹Β
ͷͪͻͳ͸ͳ
ͽͰ
͋Ͱͻͷ͹ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻͪ
͸ͪ
ͯͯ
Ͳͪ
ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻͳ΂͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͯ;ͲͰΕͪ
͸ͪ
̀Ͱͷ;͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
͵ͰΒ;

͆ͪͱͪͶ͹ͼͽ
͹΂;
ͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
ͼͪͷ͹
ͲͭͻͪͯͰ
ͺ͹͸ͰͭͯͰ
ͼ
ͺ͹ͷ͹Ε͸ͳͷ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳͷͪ
ͪͶͳ
͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͼͽͪͻͰ

ͺͪͻ͸Ͱ
ͷͪ΃ͳ͸Ͱ
ͭͰ͸Ͱͻͪͽ͹ͻͳ
ͳ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳ
΀ͳͯͻ͹ͷͰ΀ͪ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ
ͼ͵Ͷ͹ͺ͹ͬͳ

͌
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃Δ͹Β
̺͹Βͬ͹ͯͳ͸ͳ
͸ͪ
ͯ͸;
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ΃ΔͰͭ
͈ͪ͸͹͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͷ͹ͻͪ

͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
̽;͸ͪͬ͹ͷ
͹ͽͰ͵Ͷ͹
;
͏ͻ͸͹
ͷ͹ͻͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
9*9
ͬͰ
͵ͪ
Ͳͪͺ͹΂ͳΔͰ
ͭͻͪͯΔͪ
ͼͳͼͽͰͷͪ
͵ͪ͸ͪͶͪ
;ͼͽͪͬͪ
ͳ
΁ͻͺ͸ͳ΀
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ

͋ͪΒ
ͼͶ͹ͱͰ͸ͳ
ͼͳͼͽͰͷ
ΒͰ
;ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͷͰ
ͳ
͵͹͸ͪ΂͸͹
ͻͰ΃ͳ͹
΂͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬͪ

ͬͳ΃ͰͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸ͪ
͸ͪͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͪ
ͯͪ
;͵ͻ͹ͽͳ
ͬ͹ͯͰ͸;
ͼͽͳ΀ͳΒ;
ͳ
;΂ͳ͸ͳ
ΒͰ
ͼͰͫͳ

;ͼͶ;ͱ͸͹ͷ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶ;΃͸͹ͷ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
Β͹΃
ͼ;
͉ͳͷΓͪ͸ͳ
;
***
ͬͰ͵;
ͳͲ
ͬ͹ͯͳͶͳ
ͻͪͯ͹ͬͰ
͸ͪ
ͳͼ;΃ͳͬͪΔ;
ͷ͹΂ͬͪͻͪ
;
͊ͻͰͷ;

͇
ͼͽͪͶ͸͹Β
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͳ

ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͬ͹ͯ͹ͽ͹͵͹ͬͳ
;ͻͰͯͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͰ
ͳ
ͺͻͬͳ
͸ͪͷͪ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ
Ͳͪ͵͹͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͪ͵ͽͳ

;ͻͰͯͫͰ
;ͭͪͻͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͪͫ͹ͻͪ
ͼ
͵ͻͪΒͪ
97*
ͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵ͪ
97**
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͹
΂ͳ΃ΕͰΔ;

ͻͰ΂͸ͳ΀
͵͹ͻͳͽͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͳͲͪΔ;
͸ͪͼͳͺͪ
͋͹͵͹ͷ
97***
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺͻͰͯ;ͲͳͷͪΒ;

 ́͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
͈͹ͯ;͸ͪͬΓͪ 

ͼͰ
͹ͫͳͷ͸ͳ
ͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͻͰ΃ͳͶͳ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͳ
tͼ;ͬͳ΃͸ͳ΀i
ͬ͹ͯͪ

͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͻͰͭ;Ͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͻͰ͵ͪ
͋ͳͼͰ
͋ͪͷͳ΃ͪ
ͳ
̹ͰͭͰΒͪ
͊ͻͰͯͳ͸͹ͷ
9*9

ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͼͰ
;ͬͳͯͰͶ͹
ͯͪ
ΕͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
ͫ͹ͻͫͪ
ͺͻ͹ͽͳͬ
ͬ͹ͯͰ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͳ
΀ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͺͶͪͬͪ
͹ͯ
ͼͺ͹Γ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
;͸;ͽͻͪ΃Δͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͪ
ͼͽͬ͹ͻͳͽͳ
;ͼͶ͹ͬͰ
ͯͪ

ͼͰ
͹͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹
ͳ
͵͹͸ͪ΂͸͹
ͼͽͪͬͰ
ͺ͹ͯ
͵͹͸ͽͻ͹Ͷ;
͊ͬͳ
ͯ͹ͽͪͯ
ͭͻͪΌͰ͸ͳ

͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳ
ͫͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͺͪͻ΁ͳΒͪͶ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͻͰͶͪͽͳͬ͸͹
ͰͿͳ͵ͪͼ͸ͳ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ

͹ͼ͸ͳͬͪΒ;
ͺͻͬͰ
ͬ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪͯͻ;ͭͰ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͏Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶ͸͹
;ͯͻ;ͱͰΔͰ
Ͳͪ

ͻͰͭ;Ͷͪ΁ͳΒ;
͈͹ͽͳͼΒͪ
ͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ΀
ΒͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
;
̹ͪ͸ͪͽ;
ͬͰΕ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͯͰ
ͼͰͽ
͇ͼ͸ͳͬͪΒ;
ͳ΀
͸Ͱͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸͹
Ͳͪͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͬͶͪͼ͸ͳ΁ͳ
;ͭͻ͹ͱͰ͸͹ͭ

ͲͰͷΓͳ΃ͽͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͯͲ͹ͻ͹ͷ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
͉Ͱ΂
ΒͰ
ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
͹
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Β;
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͽͳ΂Ͱ
̽;͸ͪͬ
ͯͻ;ͭͪ
ͺ͹

ͬͰͶͳ΂ͳ͸ͳ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͪ
ͻͰ͵ͪ
;͵;ͺ͸Ͱ
ͯ;ͱͳ͸Ͱ

͵ͷ
̽;ͱͳ͸ͪ
ͽ͹͵ͪ
̽;
͸ͪͬͪ
;
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Β;
ͳͲ͸͹ͼͳ
΂ͳͽͪͬͳ΀

͵ͷ
͇
ͷ͹Εͳ
ͽͰ
ͻͰ͵Ͱ

ͼͬͰͯ͹΂ͳ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵
ͯͪ
ΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͼͰ΂͸ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͽͳ΁ͪΒ
̽;͸ͪͬͪ
͵͹ͯ

͈ͪ͸΂Ͱͬͪ
ͫͳ͹

NT
ͯ͹͵
ΒͰ
;

ΒͰͯ͸͹Β
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͬͶͪͱ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͳͲ͸͹ͼͳ͹

NT
ͪͯͪͅ
;
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͭ;
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͽͳͺͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
͸;ͱ͸͹
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͽͳ

͹
;͸ͳͬͰͻͲͪͶ͸͹ͷ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ;
̽;͸ͪͬͪ
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͼͰͽͳͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ΔͰͷ;

͸ͪͶͪͲͰ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
ͯͪ
ͳͷͪ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸;
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ͸;
ͬͪ
ͱ͸͹ͼͽ
m
̓͹ͻͳͯ͹ͻ

ͯͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ
Ͳͪ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ͸ͪ

ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͪ
;ͯͻ;ͱͳͬͪΔͪ
m
"3(&
%POBV
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸
ͫ͹ͭͪͽ
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳ
ͷͪ
ͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶ͸Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰͱ;
ͯ;ͫ͹͵͹
;
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽ
m
̈́ͰͺͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ

ͬͳͻ
̺ͳ͸΂ͪ
ͻͳͷͼ͵ͳ
ͶͳͷͰͼ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪ
ͼͶͰΌͪ
m
ͳͻͰͬͰͻͲͳͫͳͶ͸ͳ
ͼͳͼͽͰͷͳ
Ͳͪ
ͬ͹ͯ;
͊ͬͳͶͪͻͪ
ͳ
͍ͪͫͻͳ͵ͪ
ͼͽͪ͵Ͷͪ

;
͈ͪ͸΂Ͱͬ;
͈ͳͬͪͻͪ
;
̸ͺͪͽͳ͸;
̺͹ͯ͹ͬ͹ͯ
ͳ
͵͹ͷͺͶͰ͵ͼ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽͳͶ͸ͳ΀
Ϳͪ
ͫͻͳ͵ͪ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;

 ͉ͳͿͪͽ
̓;ͶͰ͸͹ͬͳΕ

̺ͻͪͽͳͷ͹
ͼͰ
ͼͽͪͻͳͷ
΁ͻͺ͸ͳͷ
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͳ
͹͸͹ͷͰ
΃ͽ͹
ͳ΀
΂ͳ͸ͳ

ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸ͳͷ
́ͼ͵;ͼͽͬ͹
;
ͫ͹ͻͫͳ
ͼͪ
ͬ͹ͯͰ͸͹ͷ
ͼͽͳ΀ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲͪͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͳͺͳ
͸ͳͼ;
ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸ͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹ͼͽͳ
Ͳͪ;ͼͽͪͬͰ
̓ͻͪΒͰͷ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ

͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
͹ͫͪͶͪͷͪ
̽;͸ͪͬͪ
ͳ
͊ͪͬͰ
ͼͪͭͻͪΌͰ͸ͪ
ͬͰΕͳ͸ͪ
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃Δͳ΀
͸ͪͼͳ
ͺͪ
ͼͪ
΂;ͬͪͻ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͷͪͭͪ΁ͳ͸ͳͷͪ
ͳ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳͷ
Ͳͭͻͪͯͪͷͪ
͸ͪ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳ
ΕͰ͸͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
ͺ͹ͯͳͱ;
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͺͻͬͰ
ͳͻͰͬͰͻͲͳͫͳͶ͸Ͱ
΁ͻͺ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ

͢ͳ΀͹ͬͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͷͰ͸ͪ
ͯͪ
ͼ;ͬͳ΃͸;
ͬ͹ͯ;
ͳͲͫͪ΁Ͱ
ͳͲ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳΕͰ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ

;
͸ͪΒͫͶͳͱͳ
ͻͰ΁ͳͺͳΒͰ͸ͽ
ͻͰ͵;
ͳͶͳ
ΒͰͲͰͻ͹
́Ͳ
ͬͳͲ;ͻͰ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽͰ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
ͽͰ
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͼͪ
ͼͬͳͷ

ͺ͹ͷ͹Ε͸ͳͷ
͵ͪͺͪ΁ͳͽͰͽͳͷͪ
͵ͪ͸ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͻͪͲ͸ͳ
΀ͳͯͻ͹ͯͳ͸ͪͷͳ΂͵ͳ
ͼͳͼͽͰ
ͷͳ

͸ͳͼ;
͸ͳ΃ͽͪ
ͷͪΔͰ
ͬͪͱ͸Ͱ
ͳ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬͰ
͹ͯ
ͬͰΕ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ΀
ͼͽͪͻͳ΀

ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻͪ͸ͪ
͊Ͷͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͼ;
͹΂ͳͽͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͬͳ
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶͪ͸

ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ͸ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ
ͼ͹Ͷͳͯ͸ͪ
ͭͻͪͯΔͪ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͰΕͳ͸ͪ

͹΂;ͬͪ͸ͪ
;
ͳͲͬ͹ͻ͸͹ͷ
͹ͫͶͳ͵;
ͳ
ͻͪͯ͸͹ͷ
ͼͽͪΔ;
ͽͰ
ͯͪ
ͯ͹ͫͪͻ
ͯͰ͹
͹ͫΒͰ
͵ͪͽͪ
;Ͳ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸;
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ;ͻ;
͵ͻͪͼͳ
ͳ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͶͰͺ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯ
͢ͳ΀͹
ͬ͹
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹
ͼͽͪΔͰ
ͳ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸͹ͼͽ
;ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͷͰ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͺͻͳͺͳͼͪͽͳ

ͫͻͳͱΓͳͬ͹ͷ
͹ͯͻͱͪͬͪΔ;
ͳ
ͺͰͻͷͪ͸Ͱ͸ͽ͸͹Β
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳΒͳ
͆Ͱ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͯͪ
͸Ͱ

ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱͷ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
;Ͳͫ;ΌͰΔͰ
͵ͪͯ
ͭ͹ͯ
ͼͰ
͸ͪΌͰͷ
;
͸Ͱ͵͹ͷ
͹ͯ
ͽͳ΀
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽͪ

ͼͪ
ͼͽͪͻͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͫͳ͸ͪͷͪ
ͬͰ͸ͽͳͶͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͭͰ͸Ͱͻͪͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
ͼ
ͷ͸͹΃ͽͬ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͷ
͸͹
ͳͲͻͪΌͰ͸ͳ΀
ͷͰͼͳ͸ͭͪ͸ͳ΀
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͪ
ͳͶͳ
͹Ͳ͸ͪ͵ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹Όͪ΂ͪ
͐ͪ͵
ͼ;

ͳ
͸Ͱ͵ͳ
ͰͶͰͷͰ͸ͽͳ
͹ͯ
ͼͰ͵;͸ͯͪͻ͸͹ͭ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ
ͺͻ͹Ͳ͹ͻͼ͵ͪ
͹͵͸ͪ
ͼͽͰͺͰ͸ͳ
΁Ͱ
ͳͶͳ
͵Ͷ;ͺͰ
ͳͲͻͪΌͰ͸ͳ
͵ͬͪͶͳͽͰͽ͸͹
ͳ
ͼͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͷ
ͺͪͱΔ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͼͷͳͼͶ͹ͷ

Ͳͪ
ͰͼͽͰͽͼ͵͹
͋͹
͸ͪ΃Ͱ
͸Ͱͺͻ͹΁ͰΔͳͬ͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
Β͹΃
ͼͽͻͺΓͳͬ͹
΂Ͱ͵ͪ
ͯͪ

΃ͳͻͪ
Βͪͬ͸͹ͼͽ
͹ͽ͵ͻͳΒͰ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ;
ͶͰͺ͹ͽ;
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͼͽ͹ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ͽ͸;
ͪ;ͽͰ͸ͽͳ΂
͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
ͺ͹;Ͳͯͪ͸
ͻͪͯ

 ́͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
͈͹ͯ;͸ͪͬΓͪ 

̽ͪ͵ͶͰ
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
ͽͻͪͼͪ
tͻ;ͽͰ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰi
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͯͪ
͹ͫ
;΀ͬͪͽͳ
͹ͬͰ
ͼͽ͹ͽͳ͸ͪ͵
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͼͽͪͻͰ
΁ͻͺ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͳ
ͽ͹
͸ͪ
ͶͰͬ͹Β

͹ͫͪͶͳ
̽;͸ͪͬͪ
m
;
͈Ͷͪͬ͸͹Β
ͳ
̽;ͫ͹ͬ΁;
͸ͪ
ͶͰͬ͹Β
͹ͫͪͶͳ
͊ͪͬͰ
m
;
̹͹ΓͰͬ
΁ͳͷͪ
ͳ
͊;ͻ΂ͳ͸;
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͹͵͹
͏ͪͻͼ͵͹ͭ
ΒͰͲͰͻͪ
;
ͫͶͳͲͳ͸ͳ
̾΂͵Ͱ
͆Ͱ͹ͼͺ͹ͻ
͸͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽ
ͽͳ΀
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹
͹΂;ͬͪ͸ͳ΀
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͪ
ͳ

ͯͪ
;
ͼ͵Ͷ͹ͺ;
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃ΔͰ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;

ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸;
ͻͰͽ͵͹ͼͽ
΂ͪ͵
ͳ
;
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͳͷ
͹͵ͬͳͻͳͷͪ
͈ͻͰͻͪͯͪ
ͱͳͽͪͻͳ΁ͪ
΂ͳ͸ͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͷͪΔͳ
ͳ
ͲͪͼͰͫͪ͸
ͯͰ͹
;
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼ;

ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯΔͰ
΀ͻͪ͸Ͱ
̺ͰΕ
ͳ
ͼ;ͷͪͻͪ͸
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪͽͪ
ͺͻͰͻͪͯͰ
ͱͳ
ͽͪͻͳ΁ͪ
͹ͽ͵ͻͳͬͪ
΂͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬͰ
͸ͪͺ͹ͻͰ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͬͰΕͪ
͵͹Ͷͳ΂ͳ͸;
ͳ
͵ͬͪͶͳͽͰͽ

ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯΔͰ
̓͹ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͼͰ
ͼͬͪ
ͯͰͶ͹ͽͬ͹ͻ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͻͪͼͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͳͬͪ
ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͪ

ͺͻͳͷͳͽͳͬ͸ͳ
ͻ;΂͸ͳ
ͷͶͳ͸͹ͬͳ
ͬͰͽͻͰΔͪ΂Ͱ
ͬ͹ͯͰ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ
͸ͳ΀
ͷͪ΃ͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͷͶͳ͸͹ͬͪ
́ͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͷͪͽͻͪ͸͹
ͫͰͲ
͹ͫͲͳͻͪ
͸ͪ

΂Ͱͼͽ͹
ͭͰ͸ͳΒͪͶ͸ͪ
ͳ͸ͱͰΔͰͻͼ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͭͻͪͯͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͪ
ͻͰ΃ͰΔͪ
͹ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂ͪͬͪΒ;
Εͳ
Ϳͪ͵ͽ͹ͻ
;ͬͰ͵
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
ͽͳͺ
ͳ
ͰͿͳ͵ͪͼ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͪ
ͺ͹ͭ͹͸ͪ
;
ͺ͹ͼͽͻ͹ΒͰ
Δͳͷͪ
ͪͅ͸Ͱ
Γ;ͯͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͳͶͳ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͳΔͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͭ͹͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͼ͸ͪͭͰ
;
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵͹

ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͼ;
ͻͰ΃ͪͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͳͼ͵͹ͻͳ΃ΕͪͬͪΔͰͷ
ͼ͸ͪͭͰ
ͬͰͽͻͪ
ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͰ
́
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ

ͼ;
͸ͪͳͷͰ
͹΂;ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶ͸ͳ
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳ
ͬͰͽͻͰΔͪ΂ͪ
ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͸ͪ

͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;
͵͹Βͳ΀
ͼ;
ͻͰ͵͹͸ͼͽͻ;ͳͼͪ͸ͳ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼ
ͻͪͯͪ
΂ͪ͵
ͳ
͹͸ͳ

͵͹ͷͺͶͳ͵͹ͬͪ͸ͳΒͳ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
͉ͳͷͼ͵ͳ
ͷͶͳ͸
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
̸ͻͶͪ

ͳͲ
*7
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͹ͼͪͷ
ͷͶͳ͸͹ͬͪ
ͼ
ͳͼͽ͹
ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͺͪͻͳ
ͬ͹ͯͰ͸ͳ΂͸ͳ΀
ͽ͹΂͵͹ͬͪ


ͅͶͳ͸͹ͬͳ
͸ͪ
ͬͰͽͪͻ
ͳ
ͬ͹ͯ;
ͫͳͽ͸͹
ͼ;
;ͽͳ΁ͪͶͳ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽͪ͵
ͷͰ΀ͪ͸ͳͲͪ
΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͳͷͪΒ;
ͬͳ΃ͰͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸;
ͺͻͳͷͰ͸;
ͅͰͻͰ͸͹
ͷͰͻͳͶͳͷͪ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ΀

ͺ͹ͼͽͻ͹ΒͰΔͪ
ͼ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
ͷ͹Εͳͷͪ
ͼͽͪͻͳ
ͼͳͼͽͰͷͳ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹
ͭ;
ͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳ
͸ͰͰͿͳ͵ͪͼ͸ͳͷ
ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
͹ͼͳͷ
ͰͬͳͯͰ͸ͽ͸ͳ΀
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵ͪ
͸ͪ

;ͷ;
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͳͷͪͽͳ
ͳ
ͽ͹
ͯͪ
ͯ͹ͼ͵͹ͻͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͷ͹ͭ;ΕͰ
ͺͻͳͷͰ͸ͳͽͳ
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ

͹ͯ
ͳͲͬͪ͸ͻͰͯ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹͸ͪͶͪͲͪ͵ͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͻͰ΁ͳͷ͹
͎Ͱͻ͹͸͹ͬͪ
ͷͪͶͪ

ͺͪͻ͸ͪ
ͷͪ΃ͳ͸ͪ
ͳͲ
*
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͋Ͱ͵
͸Ͱͯͪͬ͸͹
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ
97***
ͼͽ͹ͶͰΕͪ
͹ͺ
΃ͽͳ
;ͼͺ͹͸
ͺ͹ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ;
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
͸ͪ;͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͽͰ΀͸ͳ͵Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͺͻͳͷͰ͸ͪ
͵ͬͪͶͳ
ͽͰͽ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͪ
Ͱ͸ͰͻͭͳΒͰ
͹ͫͰͲͫͰΌ;Β;
ͳ
ͫͻͲ
ͽͰ΀͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
;ͼͺ͹͸
ͼͳͷ
ͫ͹Ͷͳ΂͸͹
͸ͪͲͬͪ͸
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͷ
ͻͰͬ͹Ͷ;΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
͈ͻͰ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͬͰ͵͹ͬͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰΔͰ͸
ͺͻͳ͸΁ͳͺ
ͷͶͰͬͰΔͪ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͰΒͪ
ͬͪΔͪ
ͱͳͽͪͻͳ΁ͪ
ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ΒͰ
;ͼͺͰ΃ͪ͸
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳ
ͫͰͲ
͹ͫ
Ͳͳͻͪ
͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯ͸ͳ
͵ͪͺͪ΁ͳͽͰͽ
ͷͶͳ͸ͪ
͈ͻ͹΁Ͱͼ
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͪΔͪ
Ϳͳ͸ͪͶ͸͹ͭ

ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯͪ
ͫͻͪ΃͸ͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͭͻͳͲͪ
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯ
ͳ
ͼͪͯ
͹ͯͬͳΒͪ
ͼͰ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͼͶͳ΂͸Ͱ

ͿͪͲͰ
ͷͶͰͬͰΔͪ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͯͳͲͪΔͪ
ͼͳͻ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
ͬͳ΃;
Ͱͽͪͱ;
ͳ
͵͹͸ͪ΂
͸͹
ͺͻ͹ͼͰΒͪͬͪΔͪ
ͳ
ͽ͹
ͽͪ͵͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͼͳͻ͹ͬͳ͸ͪ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͼͳͽͪ
ͼͺ;΃ͽͪ
ͼ
͸ͪΒ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͸ͪ
͸ͪΒ͸ͳͱ;
͵͹ͽ;
͆ͪͻͪͬ͸͹
ͻͰ΂
ΒͰ
͹
ͬͳ΃ͰͰͽͪͱ͸ͳͷ
ͷͪ΃ͳ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ

ͷͶͳ͸͹ͬͳͷͪ
̀ͪ
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳ͹͸ͳͼͪΔͰ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
tͯ;ͭ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͭi
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼͪ

 ͉ͳͿͪͽ
̓;ͶͰ͸͹ͬͳΕ

ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯΔͰ
ͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ͼͰ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳ
tͷͪ΃ͳ͸ͰͻͳΒͪi
΂ͳΒͳ
ΒͰ

ͺͻͳ͸΁ͳͺ
ͻͪͯͪ
ͼͽͪͻ
ͼͽ͹ͽͳ͸ͪ͵
ͳͶͳ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͪ
͵ͪͽ͵ͪͯ
ͼ;
;ͺͻͪͬ͹

ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͼͽͪͻͰ
΂ͪ͵
ͳ
ͼͪͷͰ
ͷͪ΃ͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͬͪΓ͸Ͱ
ͼͽ͹Ͷͳ΁Ͱ
ͼͳͽͪ

ͳ
ͰͶͰͬͪͽ͹ͻͳ
͆ͪ
͸ͪ΃ͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
ͫͳͽ͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͯͰ΃ͪͬͪͶͰ

ͽͪ͵͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͷͰΔͪͶͳ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͳ
ͺ͹ͭ͹͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ;
;
ͺͻͬ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ

99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͋͹͵͹ͷ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͷͪ΃ͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͷͶͳ͸͹ͬͳ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͽͰͱ͸͹
͵͹ͻͳ
ͼͽͳͶͳ
ͼ͸ͪͭ;
ͬ͹ͯͰ͸͹ͭ
ͽ͹͵ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͭ͹͸
ͽ;ͻͫͳ͸Ͱ
ͯ͹͵
ͼ;
;
ͷͪΔ͹Β
ͷͰͻͳ

;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫΓͪͬͪͶͳ
ͼͽͪͫͳͶ͸;
ͳͶͳ
ͺ͹͵ͻͰͽ͸;
ͺͪͻ͸;
ͷͪ΃ͳ͸;
͈͹͸Ͱ͵ͪͯ
ͼ;

ͼͰ
ͽͪ
ͯͬͪ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͪ
ͻ͹ͽͪ΁ͳ͹͸͹ͭ
͵ͻͰͽͪΔͪ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳͶͪ
͵͹ͷͫͳ͸͹ͬͪ͸͹
̺ͰΕ

ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͼ͸ͪͭͪ
ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻͳ΂͸Ͱ
Ͱ͸ͰͻͭͳΒͰ
ͼͰ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳ
Ͳͪ

ͺ͹͵ͻͰͽͪΔͰ
ͯͳ͸ͪͷ͹
ͷͪ΃ͳ͸ͪ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻ͹ͷ͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
͋ͪͯͪ
ͭͻͪΌͰ͸ͳ

ͷͶͳ͸͹ͬͳ
ͼ;
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͬͰΕͳ͸ͪ
Ϳͪͫͻͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͭ͹͸ͪ
ͳͷͪͶͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͳͲ
ͬ͹ͻ
ͻ͹ͽͪ΁ͳ͹͸͹ͭ
͵ͻͰͽͪΔͪ
͹ͫͳ΂͸͹
͸ͪ
͸ͪΒ͸ͳͱ͹Β
Ͱͽͪͱͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͼͳͼͽͰ
ͷ͹ͷ
͹ͼ͹ͬͳ͸ͪ
ͼ
ͽ͹΂͵͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͺͻͰ͸͹ͼͳͶ͹
ͺ͹
ͼͺͻͪͽ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͯ͹

ͼͬͪ͵Ͱ
ͷͪ΃ͳ͸Ͱ
ͳͶͳ
ͰͶͰͬͪͽ͹ͻͪ

̻ͻ;ͺͳ
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳ΀
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽͪ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰ
Όͪ
͸ͪ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃ΔͰ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒ;
ͳ
͹ͬͪ͵ͬͳ
ͷͶͳ͸͹ͬͳ
͵͹
Βͳ
ͼ;
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
ͳ
ͯ͹
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
͸ͰͺͻͰ͵ͳͯ͸͹
;
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳΒͳ
͇ͫͳ΂͸͹
ͼ;
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹

͹΂;ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͳ
͹
Δͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ
ͼͽͪͶ͸ͪ
ͫͻͳͭͪ
ͯ͹͵
ͼ;
ͽͰ΀͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱ
ͼͳ
;
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳͷ
΁ͻͽͪͷͪ
ͼͪ΂;ͬͪ͸ͳ
͆Ͱ͵ͳ
ͼ;
;
ͷͪΔ͹Β
ͷͰͻͳ
͹ͫ͸ͪͬΓͪ͸ͳ

͵ͪͽ͵ͪͯ
ͳ
ͻͰ͸͹ͬͳͻͪ͸ͳ
ͷͪͯͪ
ͻͰͽ͵͹
͆ͪΒͼͽͪͻͳΒͳ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳ
ͳͲ
ͽͰ
ͭͻ;ͺͰ
ͼ;

Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͪ
ͺ͹ͭ͹͸ͪ
;ͬͰ͵
;
͸Ͱͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸͹Β
ͫͶͳͲͳ͸ͳ
ͬ͹ͯ͹ͽ͹͵͹ͬͪ
͢ͳ΀͹
ͬͪ
ͫͻ͹Β͸͹ͼͽ
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶͪ͸ͪ
ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶ͸͹ͼͽ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
ͪͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͬͪ͸
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼ

 ́͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
͈͹ͯ;͸ͪͬΓͪ 

ͻͪͯͪ
͵ͪͽ͵ͪͯ
ͳ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸ͪ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵;ͻͪ
΂ͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ΀
͸ͰͲͪ͹ͫͳͶͪͲ͸ͳͷͪ
͸Ͱ

ͼͪͷ͹
Ͳͪ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂Ͱ
ͬͰΕ
ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
̹;ͯ;Εͳ
ͯͪ
ͳ΀
ͳͷͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹

ͺ͹ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ;
;
̺͹Βͬ͹ͯͳ͸ͳ
΂ͪ͵
ͳ
ͺ͹ͬͻ΃ͪ͸
͹ͫͳͶͪͲͪ͵
ͳͲͳͼ͵;ΒͰ
ͬͳ΃Ͱͯ͸Ͱͬ
͸;
tͻ;ͽ;
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰi
͢ͳ΀͹ͬ͹
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͪ΂͸͹
ͺ͹ͫͻͪΒͪΔͰ

Ͳͪ΀ͽͰͬͪ
ͺ͹ͯ;ͱͳ
ͼͺͳͼͪ͵
ͽͪ͵͹
ͯͪ
Ε;
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
ͷͶͳ͸͹ͬͰ

͹͸Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͬͰΕͰͭ
͵ͪͺͪ΁ͳͽͰͽͪ
̺ͰͶͳ͵ͳ
ͺͪͻ͸ͳ
ͷͶͳ͸
;
̓ͳ͵ͳ͸ͯͳ

̈́Ͱ͸ͭͪ;Ͱͻ
;
͊ͽͻͪͱͳ
͍ͪͶ͵Ͱ͸ͫ;ͻͭͰͻ
ͳ
ͪͅͻͳΕ
;
͹͵͹Ͷͳ͸ͳ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ

ͷͶͳ͸͹ͬͳ
;
͊Ͱ͸ͽͳ
ͳ
͇ͫͻͰ͸͹ͬ΁;

͋͹͵͹ͷ
9*7
97
ͳ
97*
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͹ͼ͸ͳͬͪΒ;
ͼͰ
ͺͻͬͰ
ͬͰΕͰ
ͺͳͬͪͻͰ
͸͹

ͽͰ΀͸͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͪ
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͯͪΓͰ
͹ͼͶͪΔͪ
͸ͪ
ͰͷͺͳͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͷͰͽ͹ͯͰ
ͫͰͲ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΀

ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͪ
ͫͳ͹΀ͰͷͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼͪ
͇ͺ΃ͽͳ
ͳ
ͽͰ΀͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
;ͼͺ͹͸
;

̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
97***
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͹ͯͻͪͱͪͬͪ
ͼͰ
ͳ
;
΀ͷͰΓͪͻͼͽͬ;
ͳ
ͺͳͬͪͻͼͽͬ;

͇ͼ͸ͳͬͪΒ;
ͼͰ
ͺͻͬͰ
ͬͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͳͬͪͻͰ
ͼͪ
ͼͽͪ͸ͯͪͻͯͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯ
Δ͹ͷ
͋ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻͪ
ͻͪͯͳ
ͪͅͻͳΒͪ
͋ͰͻͰͲͳΒͪ
ͳͲͯͪͶͪ
ͺͪͽͰ͸ͽ
͵͹Βͳͷ

ͼͰ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳͷ
͵ͪ͸΁ͰͶͪͻͳΒͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͷͪͭͳͼͽͻͪͽͳͷͪ
͸ͪͶͪͱͰ
ͯͪ
ͺͰ΂ͪͽͰ
ͫͪͶͰ

΀ͷͰΓͪ
ͳ
ͳͲͯͪΒ;
ͼͰͻͽͳͿͳ͵ͪͽ
͹
ͺ͹ͻͰ͵Ͷ;
͵ͪ͵͹
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͼͺͻͰ΂ͳͶͰ
ͷͪͶͬͰͻ
Ͳͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͼ
ͷͪΔͰ
͵ͬͪͶͳͽͰͽ͸ͳͷ
΀ͷͰΓ͹ͷ
͋͹
ΒͰ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͵ͪͯͪ
;
̺͹Βͬ͹ͯͳ͸ͳ

ͺ͹΂ͳΔͰ
ͭͪΒͰΔͰ
΀ͷͰΓͪ
ͳ
͵ͪͯͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͼ͸ͳͬͪΒ;
ͺͻͬͰ
ͬͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͳͬͪͻͰ
;
ͬͰ
Εͳͷ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͳ
;
͸Ͱͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸͹Β
ͫͶͳͲͳ͸ͳ
ͻͰ΂͸ͳ΀
ͽ͹͵͹ͬͪ
͈ͻͬ;
ͽͪ͵ͬ;

ͺͳͬͪͻ;
͵ͪͺͪ΁ͳͽͰͽͪ

΀Ͱ͵ͽ͹Ͷͳͽͪͻͪ
ͺͳͬͪ
͹ͼ͸ͳͬͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;

͈ͪ͸΂Ͱͬ;
̸ͫͻͪ΀ͪͷ
̓Ͱͺͳ΃
͋;
ͺͳͬͪͻ;
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
;ΒͰͯ͸͹
ͳ
͸ͪ΃
͸ͪΒͼͽͪͻͳΒͳ

ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
͵;ͺͳͶͪ
ΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͽͰͷͰΓ͸͹

ͻͰ͸͹ͬͳͻͪͶͪ
ͺ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΁ͪ
̺ͪΒͿͰͻͽ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͯͪ
ΔͰ͸
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃Δͳ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯ
;ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͷͰ
ͺ͹ͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͳͲ
ͯ͹ͫͪ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
;
Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͰͯ;
͌
̺ͻ΃΁;
ͼͰ


 ͉ͳͿͪͽ
̓;ͶͰ͸͹ͬͳΕ

͹ͼ͸ͳͬͪ
̺ͻ΃ͪ΂͵ͪ
ͺͳͬͪͻͪ
͊ͽ͹ͽͳ͸ͪ͵
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ

͵;ͺͳ͹
Β;
ΒͰ

͠͹ͬͪ͸
͏͹Ϳͷͪ͸
̻͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

ͺͳͬͪͻͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ͹ͽͪͶ͸͹
ͻͰ͸͹ͬͳͻͪ͸ͪ
ͪ


ΒͰ
͹ͺͻͰͷΓͰ͸ͪ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͳͷ
ͺͪͻ͸ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͭ͹͸͹ͷ
ͳ
͸͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͽͰ΀͸͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒ͹ͷ

͈ͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯΔ;
ͺͳͬͪ
;
̀ͻͰΔͪ͸ͳ͸;
ͽͪͯͪ΃ΔͰͷ
̺ͰͶͳ͵͹ͷ
̹Ͱ΂͵ͰͻͰ
͵;
ͺ͹΂Ͱ͹
ΒͰ

̀ͰͫͪͼͽͳΒͪ͸
̓ͻͪΒ΁ͪΒͲͰ͸
͈ͳͬͪͻ;
ΒͰ

͵;ͺͳͶͪ
ͺ͹
ͻ͹ͯͳ΁ͪ
̽;͸ΌͰͻͼ͵ͳ
͵͹Βͪ
Β;
ΒͰ

ͳ
ͽͰͷͰΓ͸͹
͹ͫ͸͹ͬͳͶͪ
ͯ͹ͼͰͭͪͬ΃ͳ

͵ͪͺͪ΁ͳͽͰͽ
͹ͯ

΀Ͱ͵ͽ͹Ͷͳͽͪͻͪ

͈ͳͬͪͻͪ
;
̸ͺͪͽͳ͸;
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳΒͪ
͵ͪ͹
̸ͷͪ͸͹ͬͪ
ͺͳͬͪͻͪ
ͼͪͭͻͪΌͰ͸ͪ

ΒͰ

ͪ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͺ;ͽͪ
ͻͰ͵͹͸ͼͽͻ;ͳͼͪ͸ͪ
͇΂;ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͺͻͬ͹ͫͳͽ
͸ͳ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰ;ͻͰΌͰ͸ͳ
;
Ͱ͵ͼ͵Ͷ;Ͳͳͬͪ͸
͵ͪ͸΁ͰͶͪͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻ͹
ͼͽ͹ͻ
͌
9*9
ͬͰ͵;
ͼͰ
͹ͼ͸ͳͬͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͼͶͳ΂͸ͳ΀
ͺͳͬͪͻͪ
̹Ͱ΂ͰΒͼ͵;
͵͹Β;


͹ͼ͸ͳͬͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ
͵͹Ͷ͹͸ͳͼͽͪ
͉ͪΒ΀
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
ΒͰ
͵;ͺͳ͹
ͬͰͶͰͺ͹ͼͰͯ
͸ͳ͵
ͳͲ
ͽ͹ͭ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
̻ͳ͸ͯͰͻ
́ͭ͸ͪ΁
̽ͪ͸ͪ΃Δͳ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯ
ͼͽͪͻͳ΀
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽͪ

ͺͳͬͪͻͰ
ͯͪͽͳͻͪ
ͳͲ
m
͈ͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯΔͪ
ͺͳͬͪ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
ͳͷͪ
ͯ;ͭ;
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳΒ;
Β͹΃
ͼͰ
;
97

ͬͰ͵;
ͷͪͼ͹ͬ͸͹
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯͳͶ͹
;
ͯ͹ͷͪΕͳ͸ͼͽͬͳͷͪ
ͭ͹ͼͽͳ͹͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͳ
͸ͪ

ͯͬ͹ͻ;
ͯͰͼͺ͹ͽͪ
͊ͽͰͿͪ͸ͪ
̈́ͪͲͪͻͰͬͳΕͪ

͌
ͯ͹ͫͪ
ͪ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
͹͵;ͺͪ΁ͳ
ΒͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
m
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯΔͪ
ͺͳͬͪ
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͪ
Ϳͪͫͻͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͻͪͲͷͰ
ͻͰ
͆ͪ
̽͹ͻΕ͹Ͷ;
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪͶͰ
ͯͬͰ
ͷͪΔͰ
ͺͳͬͪͻͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͳͲͭͻͪͯͳͶͳ

ͪ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻͰͯ;Ͳͳͷͪ΂ͳ
͈͹
ͺͻͰͶͪͼ͵;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
;
ͽ;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͻ;͵Ͱ
ͺͳ
ͬͪͻͳ
ͺͻͰͫͪ΁;Β;
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯΔ;
;
ͼ;ͼͰͯ͸͹
͈ͪ͸΂Ͱͬ͹
ͳ
̀Ͱͷ;͸
͈ͻͬͰ
ͺͳͬͪ
ͻͰ
;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͹ͼ͸ͳͬͪΒ;
ͼͰ
;
ͬͰΕͳͷ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳͷͪ
̓͸ͰͲ
ͅͳͶ͹΃

͇ͫͻͰ͸͹ͬͳΕ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
͸ͪ
;ͭͶ;
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
̻Ͱͺͻͪͽ͹ͬͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

ͭͻͪͯͳ
ͬͰͶͳ͵;
ͺͳͬͪͻ;
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ;
͵ͪ͹
̓͸ͰͱͰͬͪ
ͺͳͬͪͻͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ΕͰ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ

 ́͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
͈͹ͯ;͸ͪͬΓͪ 

͹ͯͳͭͻͪͽͳ
ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸;
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵;
;Ͷ͹ͭ;
͸͹
Ͳͭͻͪͯͪ
͸ͪͱͪ

Ͷ͹ͼͽ
͸ͳΒͰ
͹΂;ͬͪ͸ͪ
͌
ͳͼͽ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͹ͼ͸ͳͬͪ
ͳ
ͷͪͶͪ
͚͹ͻΌͰͬͳΕͰͬͪ
ͺͳͬͪ
ͻͪ
͸ͪ
ͷͰͼͽ;
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃ΔͰ
͊͵ͪͯͪͻͶͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͳͬͪͻͰ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
̹ͪΒͶ͹͸ͳ
ΒͰͬͪ
ͺͳͬͪͻͪ
͚͹ͻΌͰ
̺ͪΒͿͰͻͽ

;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
ͺͻͪͬͳ
ͺͳͬͪͻ;
ͼ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ

ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸͹ͷ
ͽͰ΀͸͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒ͹ͷ
ͪ
̈́ͪͲͪͻ
̽;͸ΌͰͻͼ͵ͳ

͹ͼ͸ͳͬͪ
ͺͳͬͪͻ;
;

͐ͰͶͪͻͰͬ;
͆ͪ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃ΔͰ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͪͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹Β
ͭͻ;ͺͳ
͸ͪΒͼͽͪͻͳ
Βͳ΀
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͹΂;ͬͪͶͳ
ͪ;ͽͰ͸ͽͳ΂ͪ͸
ͳͲͭͶͰͯ
ͳͲ

ͻͪ͸ͳ΀
ͿͪͲͪ
ͭͻͪͯΔͰ
ͪͶͳ
͸ͪͱͪͶ͹ͼͽ
ͷͪͶ͹
΃ͽͪ
͹ͯ
ͼͽͪͻͰ
ͽͰ΀͸͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͰ

ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒ;
ͳ
ͺͳͬͪͻͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͯͪ͸ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ͼͶ;ͱͰ
ͼͬ͹Β͹Β
ͺͻͬ͹ͫͳͽ͸͹Β
ͼͬͻͼͳ

͠Ͱͯ͸ͪ
͹ͯ

ͻ;ͽͪ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸ͪ
ͼͽͪͻͳͷ
ͺͳͬͪͻͪͷͪ

ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͳ
ͳ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͫͪͶͪͷͪ
ͻͰ͵ͪ

̽;͸ͪͬͪ
͋ͪͷͳ΃ͪ
ͳͶͳ
͊ͪͬͰ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͰ
͹ͼ͹ͫͰ͸Ͱ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ

͈ͻͪͬ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͽͰ΀͸ͳ΂͵ͪ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽͪ

͌
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ;
͸ͪ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ
ͳ
ͫͻ͹Β͸͹ͼͽ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪ
ͼͶͰΌͪ
ͷͪͶ͹
Δͳ΀
;ͱͳͬͪ
͸Ͱ͵ͳ
͹ͯ
ͬͳͯ͹ͬͪ
ͺͻͪͬ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽͰ
̀ͪ΃ͽͳͽͪ

͹ͼͽͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͼͽͪͻͳ΀
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼͪ
JO
TJUV
ͭͶ͹ͫͪͶ
 ͉ͳͿͪͽ
̓;ͶͰ͸͹ͬͳΕ

͸͹
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͺ͹ͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳ
ͳͲ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
;ͭͶ͹ͬͪ
ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
͹ͬͪΒ
ͪͼͺͰ͵ͽ
ΒͰ
ͳ͸
ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽͪ͸
Ͳͪ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͽͳͺͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
;
͵͹͸ͪ΂͸͹ͷ
͹ͫͶͳ͵;

ͽΒ
ͯͪ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͷ͹ͻͪΒ;
ͯͪ
ͺͻͳͬ;͵;
ͺͪͱΔ;
ͳ
ͯͪ
Ͳͪͯ͹ͬ͹ΓͰ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰ
ͫͰ
ͺͻ͹ͼͰ΂͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͪ
Ͳͪ΀ͽͰͬͰ
;
ͻͪͼͺ͹͸;
͹ͯ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹ͭ
͹ͺ΃ͽͰͭ

͵͹͸ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ
ͳ
ͪͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͬͪ͸͹ͭ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ
ͯ͹
ͪͯͰ͵ͬͪͽ͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͸ͪ

Ͷͳ΁;
ͷͰͼͽͪ

͉;ͽͰ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͸ͪ΃Ͱͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
͈;ͯ;͸ͪͬΓͪ

́ͯͰΒͰ
Ͳͪ
ͽͻͪͼͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;Εͳ΀
ͻ;ͽͪ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͸ͪ΃Ͱͭ
ͯͰ
Ͷͪ
͈;ͯ;͸ͪͬΓͪ
ͺͻ͹ͳͼͽͰ͵ͶͰ
ͼ;
ͳͲ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹͸Ͱ͵ͪͯ
ͳ
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹

ͯ;ͱͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼ;
ͺͻ͹ͽͰ͵Ͷͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͯ;ͲͰͽͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͰ

ͻͰ͵͹ͭ͸͹ͼ΁ͳͻͪΔͪ
ͽͰͻͰ͸ͪ
̽ͪ͵ͶͰ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
Ͳͭ͹ͯͪ͸
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
͹ͫͳͶͪͼ͵ͪ
͹ͼͽͪ
ͽͪ͵ͪ
ͼͽͪͻͳ΀
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͪ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͪͻͰͪͶͪ
ΒͰͼ;
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸ͪ
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹
ͳͼͺͶͪ
͸ͳͻͪ͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
̓ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͬͰΕͳ͸ͪ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
;
ͬͰΕͳͷ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
ͷͪ
ͽͪ͵ͬͰ
ͻ;ͽͰ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͫͳͽͳ
ͳ
ͺͻͳΒͪͽͪ͸
ͳͲͶͰͽ

͆ͪͱͪͶ͹ͼͽ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
͹ͬͪ͵ͬͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͼͻͰ΃ΕͰͷ͹
ͼͰ
ͼͪ
ͺͻͰͽͰͱ͸͹

Ͷ͹΃ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽͰͬͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹
ͽͪ͵͹
Ͷ͹΃ͳͷ
͹Ͳ͸ͪ͵ͪͷͪ
͸ͪ
Δͳͷͪ
͆Ͱ
ͽͻͰͫͪ

ͳͷͪͽͳ
ͳͶ;ͲͳΒͰ
͸ͳͽͳ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ
͸͹
͵ͪ͹
ͽͪ͵ͪͬ
͹ͫͰͶͰͱͰ͸
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸ͳͷ
ͷͪͻ͵Ͱͻ͹ͷ
̽ͪ͵ͶͰ
͸Ͱ͹ͺ΀͹ͯͪ͸

ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͫͪͻ
ͺͶͪ͸
ͺ;ͽͪ
ͳ
͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪΒ;ΕͰ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵Ͱ
͵ͪͻͽͰ
͵ͪ͵ͬͳ΀
ͼͻͰΕ͹ͷ

ͳͷͪ
ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͳ
͸ͪͻͪͬ͸͹
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹
ͻͪͼͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͰΔͰ
̀ͫ͹ͭ
ͯ͹ͷͳ͸ͪͽ͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹
Ͷ͹ͱͪΒͪ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
ͳͳͶͳ
͆͹ͬͳ
͊ͪͯ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͫͳͽͳ
ͺ͹ͶͪͲ͸Ͱ
ͽͪ΂͵Ͱ

͹ͬͳ΀
ͷͳ͸ͳ
ͻ;ͽͪ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͉;ͽͪ

ͺ͹ͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪ
͹ͫͳͶͪͲͪ͵
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͳ΀
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽͪ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;

m
͍ͪͫͻͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͪͺͳͻͪ
ͅͳͶͪ͸ͪ
̺ͪͺͰ
ͅͶͳ͸
ͺͻͬ͹ͭ
ͪ͵΁ͳ͹͸ͪͻͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯͻ;
΃ͽͬͪ
͎ͪ͵Ͱ͹ͬͰ
͑ͰΕͰͻͪ͸Ͱ
̓͹ͬ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͸͹ͬ΁ͪ
͋Ͱͻͷ͹ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
͊͸ͪͭͪ
ͳ

ͼͬͰͽͶ͹ͼͽ
;
͊͵Ͱ͸ͯͰͻͫͰͭ͹ͬ͹Β
;Ͷͳ΁ͳ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽͳͶ͸ͳ
͵͹ͷͫͳ͸ͪͽ

̺;͸ͪͻͼ͵ͳ
͵͹ͷͫͳ͸ͪͽ
ͼͽͪͻͰ
̓Ͷͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͏ͳͭͶͪ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
̈́Ͱ΃Ε;
ͼͽͪͻͰ
̓ͪͺͰ
ͽͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͪ
ͼͽͪͻͳͷ
ͪͭͪͅ΁ͳ͸͹ͷ
ͪ
;
̀Ͱͷ;͸;
m

̓ͪͺͰͽͪ͸ͳΒͰ
̓Ͷͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͳ

ͼͽͪͻͰ
͏ͳͭͶͪ͸Ͱ
͉;ͽ͹ͷ

ͫͳ
ͼͰ
͹ͫͳ΃ͪ͹
ͯͰ͹
Β;ͱ͸͹ͭ
̹ͪ͸ͪͽͪ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͼͽͪͻͳ΀

Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͬͳ΃ͰͰͽͪͱ͸ͳ΀
ͷͶͳ͸͹ͬͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͼͰ
ͬͳͯͰͽͳ
;
͊ͽͪͻ΂Ͱ
ͬ;
ͳ

͇ͷ͹Γͳ΁ͳ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͼͽͪͻͳ
ͷ͹ͼͽ
;
͈Ͷ͹΂ͳ΁ͳ
͍ͪͫͻͳ͵ͪ
ͼͽͪ͵Ͷͪ
;

̓͹ͬͳ͸;
͏ͻͺ͸ͪ
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
;
̽;ͫ͹ͬ΁;
Ϳͪͫͻͳ͵ͪ
ͼͬͳͶͰ
;
̹ͰͶ͹Β
͏ͻ͵ͬͳ

ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
;
ͪ͠ͼͰ͸͹ͬ;
ͳ
̺ͻ΃΁;
ͼͽͪͻͪ
ͬͳ͸ͪͻͳΒͪ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
;

̺ͻ΃΁;
ͷͶͳ͸͹ͬͳ
;
͌Γͷͳ
̸Ͷͳͫ;͸ͪͻ;
ͳ
̺Ͷͪͯͳͷͳͻ͹ͬ΁;
͉;ͽͪ

ͼͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳ
͸ͪ
͊ͻͰͷ
ͭͯͰ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
͹ͫͳΕͳ
ͼͽͪͻͳ
ͷͶͳ͸
;
͊;ͻ
΂ͳ͸;
΁ͻͺ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
;
͊;ͻ΂ͳ͸;
ͳ
̹͹ΓͰͬ΁ͳͷͪ

ͺͳͬͪͻͪ
;
͊ͻͰͷͼ͵͹Β

 ́͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
͈͹ͯ;͸ͪͬΓͪ 

ͅͳͽͻ͹ͬͳ΁ͳ
̀͹ͻ͵ͪ
;
͑ͪͺ΁;
ͪ
;
͇ͫͻͰ͸͹ͬ΁;
ͷͶͳ͸
ͳ
͵͹ͷͺͶͰ͵ͼ
ͯͻͬ͸Ͱ

ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͰ
͊ͳͷ͹ͬͳΕ
͋ͻͪͼ͹ͷ
ͻ;ͽͰ

ͫͳ
ͼͰ
͹ͽͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪͶ͹
ͯ͹
͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͪ
ͭͯͰ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
͹ͫͳ
Εͳ
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ΃Δͳ
ͷͰͽͪͶ;ͻ΃͵ͳ
ͭͳͭͪ͸ͽ
4"35*%
͆ͪ
ͺ;ͽ;
ͯ͹
͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͰ
ͼͰ
ͯͬͪ
ͳͲͬͪ͸ͻͰͯ͸ͪ
ͼͽͪͻͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
Ͱͽͪͱ͸ͪ
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͪ
ͷͶͳ͸ͪ
;
̻ͻ͹΁͵͹Β
ͳ
̹ͰͶ͹ͷ
͈͹ͽ͹͵;
 ͉ͳͿͪͽ
̓;ͶͰ͸͹ͬͳΕ

͉;ͽͪ

ͼͪͯͻͱͳ
͹ͫͳͶͪͲͪ͵
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽͪ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͽͰͲ;
͈ͪ͸΂Ͱͬ͹
m
͆͹ͬͳ

͊ͪͯ
ͳ
ͽ͹
ͼͽͪͻͪ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͪ
Ͳ͹͸ͪ
;
͈ͪ͸΂Ͱͬ;
ͼͪ
̺ͪΒͿͰͻͽ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺͳ
ͬͪͻ͹ͷ
̿ͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁͹ͷ
͋ͪͷͳ΃
͏ͻͬͰ͸ͳͷ
ͷͪͭͪ΁ͳ͸͹ͷ
ͬ͹ͯ͹
ͽ͹ͻΔͰͷ
ͼͬͳͶͪͻ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͼͬͰͽͳ͹͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͸ͪ
;΃Ε;
͋ͪͷͳ΃ͪ
;
̽;͸ͪͬ
͆ͪ

ͺ;ͽ;
͵ͪ
͆͹ͬ͹ͷ
͊ͪͯ;
͹ͫͳͶͪͲͪ͵
΁ͻͺ͸ͳ΀
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͸ͪ
͏ͪͻͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͰͻ;

Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯ͹ͽ͹ͻΔͪ
ͳ
ͷͶͳ͸͹ͬͪ
;
̾΂͵͹Β
ͺͳͬͪͻÄ
ͳ
̀ͻͰΔͪ͸ͳ͸;
;
̹Ͱ΂ͰΒ;

͸Ͱ͵ͪ΃ΔͰ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
Ͳ͹͸Ͱ
ͼͪ
͐Ͱ΃͵ͳͷ
ͷͪͭͪ΁ͳ͸͹ͷ
ͼͽͪͻͰ
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΂
͵Ͱ
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͇͵ͻͰͽ͸ͳ΁Ͱ

ͳ
͈͹΃ͽͰ
;
͆͹ͬ͹ͷ
͊ͪͯ;
ͳ
͸ͪ
͵ͻͪΒ;
ͺͻͰͶͰͺͰ

΁ͻͺ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
̿ͪͫΓͪ
͉;ͽͪ

ͼͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳ
͸ͪ
̹ͪ΂͵;
ͭͯͰ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͬͳͯͰͽͳ
ͼͽͪͻͪ
ͺͳͬͪͻͪ

̽;͸ΌͰͻͼ͵͹ͭ
;
͐ͰͶͪͻͰͬ;
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͪ
΁ͻͺ͸ͪ
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
;
͈Ͷͪͬ͸͹Β

̸ͷͪ͸͹ͬͪ
ͺͳͬͪͻͪ
;
̸ͺͪͽͳ͸;
ͷͶͳ͸
ͼͪ
ͺͻͰͬ͹ͯ͸ͳ΁͹ͷ
Ͳͪ
ͬ͹ͯ;
;
͹͵͹Ͷͳ
͸ͳ
͊͹ͷͫ͹ͻͪ
ͷͶͳ͸͹ͬͳ
ͳ
΃ͰΕͰͻͪ͸ͪ
;
͏ͻͬͰ͸͵ͳ
 ́͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
͈͹ͯ;͸ͪͬΓͪ 

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

3JGBU
,VMFOPWJǀ
%BT
JOEVTUSJFMMF
&SCF
EFT
TFSCJTDIFO
5FJMT
EFS
%POBVHFHFOE

%BOL
JOUFOTJWFO
TZTUFNBUJTDIFO
VOE
JOUFSEJTQ[JQMJOÅSFO
'PSTDIVOHFO

JN
#FSFJDI
EFT
JOEVTUSJFMMFO
&SCFT
HFQBBSU
NJU
3FLPHOPTUJ[JFSVOH
WPO

(FMÅOEFO
NJU
4DIVU[NB“OBINFO
[VS
*OTUBOEIBMUVOH
NBUFSJFMMFS
3FTUF
EFS

BMUFO
*OEVTUSJFO
FOUTUBOEFO
%BUFOCBOLFO
EJF
OJDIU
OVS
WPO
EFO
*OTUJUVUJPOFO

EJF
TJF
QSPEV[JFSUFO
EBT
.VTFVN
EFS
8JTTFOTDIBGU
VOE
5FDIOJL
VOE
EJF

4FSCJTDIF
"LBEFNJF
EFS
8JTTFOTDIBGUFO
VOE
,ÛOTUF

TPOEFSO
BVDI
WPO

XFJUFSFO
*OTUBO[FO
CFOVU[U
XFSEFO
FUXB
WPO
TUÅEUFCBVMJDIFO
¨NUFSO
VOE
WPO

¨NUFSO
[VN
4DIVU[
EFS
,VMUVSEFOLNÅMFS
VOE
[XBS
[V
TFIS
LPOLSFUFO
;XFDLFO

m
EBSVOUFS
TFJFO
WPS
BMMFN
EBT
1SPKFLU
EFS
&SXFJUFSVOH
EFT
"VUPCBIOOFU[FT

t,PSSJEPS
i

JOUFSOBUJPOBMF
;VTBNNFOBSCFJU
SFHJPOBMF
1SPKFLUF
[VS

&SIBMUVOH
VOE
1GMFHF
EFT
,VMUVSFSCFT
VOE
EFS
6NHFCVOH
JO
4ÛEPTUFVSPQB

4"*5$)0304
m
OFVF
,VMUVS[FOUSFO
VOE
"SCFJUTHFNFJOTDIBGU
EFS

%POBVMÅOEFS
"3(&
%POBVMÅOEFS

[V
FSXÅIOFO
%JFTF
"SCFJUTHFNFJOTDIBGU

JTU
FJO
7FSCVOE
EFS
WPO
EFS
%POBV
EVSDIGMPTTFOFO
-ÅOEFS
EFS
BVT


3FHJPOFO
BVT

-ÅOEFSO
CFTUFIU
VOE
FJO
FUXB

LN
CSFJUFT
5FSSJUPSJVN

BN
MJOLFO
VOE
SFDIUFO
%POBVVGFS
BN
HFTBNUFO
'MVTTMBVG
FOUMBOH
VNGBTTU

;V
EFO
(SVOEQSJO[JQJFO
EFS
"SCFJUTHFNFJOTDIBGU
[ÅIMFO
&SXFJUFSVOH

EFS
FVSPQÅJTDIFO
%JNFOTJPOFO
EFS
;VTBNNFOBSCFJU
*OTUBOEIBMUVOH

EFT
HFNFJOTBNFO
FVSPQÅJTDIFO
,VMUVSTDIBU[FT
7FSHMFJDIF
BVGGBMMFOEFS

¨IOMJDILFJUFO
VOE
HFNFJOTBNFS
8VS[FMO
EFS
FVSPQÅJTDIFO
,VMUVS FO

%BOL

WJFMFS
WPO
EFO
EBSBO
UFJMOFINFOEFO
-ÅOEFSO
[VHFTDIJDLUFS
"OHBCFO
XVSEFO

FJOJHF
1VCMJLBUJPOFO
WFSÕGGFOUMJDIU
VOE
FJOF
*OUFSOFUQSÅTFOUBUJPO
FJOHFSJDIUFU

XP
EJHJUBMJTJFSUF
HFPHSBGJTDIF
,BSUFO
CFTUJNNUFS
3FHJPOFO
NJU
FOUTQSFDIFOEFO

#JMEMFHFOEFO
BOHFCPUFO
XFSEFO
%VSDI
*OUFSOFUSFDIFSDIFO
VOE
EBOL

FJOTDIMÅHJHFO
,BSUFO
JO
FMFLUSPOJTDIFS
'PSN
LBOO
NBO
JOUFSFTTBOUF
3FHJPOFO

PEFS
4UÅEUF
GJOEFO
VOE
FJOJHFT
ÛCFS
UPVSJTUJTDIF
4FIFOTXÛSEJHLFJUFO
LVMUVSFMMF

&SFJHOJTTF
BSDIÅPMPHJTDIF
-PLBMJUÅUFO
PEFS
JOEVTUSJFMMF
&SSVOHFOTDIBGUFO

FSGBISFO

-FJEFS
TUFMMFO
HFESVDLUF
3FJTFGÛISFS
GÛS
EJFTF
3FHJPO
LFJO
JOEVTUSJFMMFT

&SCF
EBS
*O
EFO
FOUXJDLFMUFO
-ÅOEFSO
&VSPQBT
XVSEFO
JO
EFO
MFU[UFO

+BIS[FIOUFO
TQF[JGJTDIF
3FJTGÛISFS
ÛCFS
JOEVTUSJFMMFT
&SCF
WPO
&OHMBOE

PEFS
EFT
3VISHFCJFUT
WFSÕGGFOUMJDIU
EJF
SFJDI
JMMVTUSJFSUF
"OMFJUVOHFO
[VS

#FTJDIUJHVOH
BMUFS
*OEVTUSJFBOMBHFO
EFS
HFOBOOUFO
(FCJFUFO
BVGXFJTFO
VOE

3FJTFSPVUFO
BMUFS
*OEVTUSJFBOMBHFO
FNQGFIMFO
EJF
BMT
3PVUFO
JOEVTUSJFMMFS

,VMUVS
CF[FJDIOFU
XFSEFO
.JU
EFS
&OUXJDLMVOH
VOE
1PQVMBSJTJFSVOH
EFT

 ͉ͳͿͪͽ
̓;ͶͰ͸͹ͬͳΕ

*OUFSOFU
XVSEF
EJF
*OGPSNBUJPOTÛCFSNJUUMVOH
FSMFJDIUFSU
VOE
CFTDIMFVOJHU

XBT
BVDI
EBT
"OHFCPU
BO
UPVSJTUJTDIFO
;FOUSFO
EJF
BVT
BMUFO
*OEVTUSJFBOMBHFO

FOUTUBOEFO
SFJDIIBMUJHFS
NBDIUF
&JO
HVUFT
#FJTQJFM
EBGÛS
XÅSF
EBT
(FCJFU
*SPO

#SJEHF
(PSHF
JO
(SP“CSJUBOOJFO
%JF
1SÅTFOUBUJPO
BVG
EFS
*OUFSOFUTFJUF
"3(&

%POBVMÅOEFS
LBOO
HMFJDI[FJUJH
BMT
FSTUFS
3FJTFGÛISFS
EFT
JOEVTUSJFMMFO
&SCFT

FJOFS
3FHJPO
JO
4FSCJFO
CF[FJDIOFU
XFSEFO

.ÕHMJDIF
3FJTFSPVUFO
BVG
EFN
8FH
[VS
&OUEFDLVOH
EFS
8JSUTDIBѫTLVMUVS
VOTFSFS
%POBVSFHJPO
GPMHFO
4QVSFO
FJOUÅHJHFS
HVU
HFQMBOUFS
VOE
EVSDIEBDIUFS

3FJTFO
EJF
JO
MFU[UFS
;FJU
[XFDLT
3FLPHOJTUJ[JFSVOH
EFT
(FCJFUT
VOUFSOPNNFO

XVSEFO
%BT
TUFMMU
FJOF
BOHFOFINF
VOE
HÛOTUJHF
.ÕHMJDILFJU
[VS
#FTJDIUJHVOH

EFS
3FTUF
BMUFS
*OEVTUSJFBOMBHFO
JO
EFS
3FHJPO
EBS
%B
EJF
NFJTUFO
0CKFLUF

JO
HSՓFSFO
4UÅEUFO
MJFHFO
MBTTFO
TJDI
EJFTF
3FJTFUPVSFO
MFJDIU
JO
BOHFOFINF

"VTëÛHFO
WFSXBOEFMO
-FJEFS
XFSEFO
EJFTF
3FJTFO
JOGPMHF
TDIMFDIUFS

-BOETUSB“FO
VOE
XFOJH
CFOVU[CBSFS
8FHXFJTFS
FSIFCMJDI
FSTDIXFSU
&T
JTU

BVDI
OJDIU
[V
WFSIFJNMJDIFO
EBTT
LFJOFT
EJFTFS
TFIFOTXFSUFO
*OEVTUSJFPCKFLUF

EVSDI
TQF[JêTDIF .BSLFS HFLFOO[FJDIOFU JTU XBT HVUF -BOELBSUFO VOE
3FJTFQMÅOF
VOFOUCFISMJDI
NBDIU
EJF
HMÛDLMJDIFSXFJTF
SFJDIMJDI
WPSIBOEFO

TJOE
*ISFS
EPNJOBOUFO
-BHF
[VGPMHF
LÕOOFO
HSՓFSF
4UÅEUF
XJF
#FMHSBE
PEFS

/PWJ
4BE
"VTHBOHTQVOLUF
EJFTFS
.JOJUPVSFO
[VS
#FTJDIUJHVOH
EFS
JOEVTUSJFMMFO

,VMUVS
TFJO

%JF
TFDIT
FNQGPIMFOFO
5PVSFO
GÛISFO
[V
BMUFO
0CKFLUFO
EJF
JO
FJOFN

;FJULPOUJOVVN
WPO
FUXB

+BISFO
BMT
.ÛIMFO
PEFS
8BTTFSLBOÅMFO
EJFOUFO
EJF

¾CFSëVTT BO 8BTTFSNFOHFO JO OBIF MJFHFOEF 'MÛTTF
PEFS
4FFO
BCëJF“FO
MBTTFO

PEFS
BCFS
BMT
.JOJXFSLTUÅUUFO
JO
EFOFO
OBDI
BMUFO
5FDIOPMPHJFO
(MBT
PEFS

#BDLTUFJO
IFSHFTUFMMU
XJSE
/FCFO
EJFTFO
JO
FVSPQÅJTDIFO
;VTBNNFOIÅOHFO

FJONBMJHFO
0CKFLUFO
HJCU
FT
BVDI
TPMDIF
EJF
OJDIU
NFIS
JO
#FUSJFC
TJOE
EJF

BCFS
EVSDI
JISF
.POVNFOUBMJUÅU
VOE
4DIÕOIFJU
FJOFO
CFEFVUTBNFO
5FJM
EFS

(FTDIJDIUF
VOTFSFT
-BOEFT
WFSBOTDIBVMJDIFO

̺Ͱͻ͵ͪ
̸͇̺͇̺͆́ͣ͠
̻Ͱ͹Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ
Ϳͪ͵;ͶͽͰͽ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

̹͉̾̽̾̓̾́

́
͎͇̺́̾͢
̸͉̓͋̾

͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͫͰͲ
ͷͪͺͪ
ͳ
͹Ͳ͸ͪ΂Ͱ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͪͬͪ΁ͪ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͯͬͳΒͪΒ;
͸ͪ
ͼ;ͷͳ΁Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͼͰΕͪΒ;
͸ͪ
ͫͻ͹ͯ
ͫͰͲ
͵͹ͷͺͪͼͪ
̓ͻ͹Ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ;
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͳ
ͳ

ͷͪͺͰ
ͼ;
͸ͪͼͽͪΒͪͶͳ
ͺͻͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
;ͬ͹ͯͰΕͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ

͸ͪͷͰͻ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
;
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
͹ͫͰͶͰͱͰ͸
ͼ͹ͺͼͽͬͰ͸ͳͷ
΁ͳΓͰͷ

͆ͪͼͽͪ͸ͪ͵
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͼͰͱͰ
ͯͪͶͰ͵͹
;
ͬͰ͵͹ͬͰ
͵ͪͯͪ
ͼ;
͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ
Γ;
ͯͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪͶͳ
ͺͻͰ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
͵;ͻͳ͹ͲͳͽͰͽͪ
͸Ͱͭ͹
ͳͲ
ͺͻͰ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͰ
͈;ͽ͹ͺͳ
ͼ͸ͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
ͼ;
;
͸ͰͲ͸ͪͽ͸ͳͷ
ͿͻͪͭͷͰ͸ͽͳͷͪ
ͳͷͪͶͪ
͹ͫͰͶͰͱ
Βͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͊ͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸ͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
ͺͪ͵
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
ͻͰͶͳͭͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͷͳͼͶͪ

;ͺ;Ε;Β;
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽͰͬͰ
ͳ
ͷͰͼͽͪ
΀͹ͯ͹΂ͪ΃Εͪ

͌
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͻͰ͸Ͱͼͪ͸ͼͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
;
́ͽͪͶͳΒ;
ͺ͹ͼͽͪΒ;
ͺ͹ͺ;Ͷͪͻ͸ͪ
;

ͺͻͳͬͳͶͰͭ͹ͬͪ͸ͳͷ
͵Ͷͪͼͪͷͪ
͊ͰͬͰͻ͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͳ
̺ͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
̹ͻͳͽͪ͸ͳΒͰ
͢ͳ
΀͹ͬͳ
ͺͳͼͪ͸ͳ
ͳͲͬͰ΃ͽͪΒͳ
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͱͰ͸ͳ
Ϳ͹͸ͯ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
Ϳͳ͸ͪ͸ͼͳͻͪ
Ͷͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͼͪͯͻͱͰ
ͰͶͰͷͰ͸ͽͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͆Ͱ͵ͳ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͳ
Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ
tͳͽͳ͸Ͱ
ͻͰͻͪi
͸Ͱ͵ͳ
ͷͪͺͪ
ͺ;ͽͰͬͪ
ͳ
ͼͬͰ
΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͳ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
͌ͬ͹ΌͰΔͰ
͸͹ͬͳΒͳ΀
ͬͳͯ͹ͬͪ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸Ͱ
ͽͰ΀͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͯ͹ͺͻͳ͸ͰͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹
΃ͳͻͳͬͪΔ;
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽͪ
ͳ
ͼͷͪΔͰΔ;
΁Ͱ͸Ͱ
͵Δͳͭͪ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͯ;͵΁ͳΒͰ
ͳͶ;ͼͽͻͪ
΁ͳΒͪ
;͵Γ;΂;Β;Εͳ
ͭͻͪͬͳͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͰ
ͺͻͰͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽΓͳͬͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͫͪ͵ͪͻ͸ͪ

΂ͰͶͳ΂͸ͪ
ͳ
͵ͪͷͰ͸ͪ
Ͷͳͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ
̽;ͭ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͽͰ΀͸͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͪ
ͳͲͻͪͯͰ
͵ͪͻͪͽͪ
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ͹ͼͽͪΒͪͶͪ
Ͳͪ
͵ͬͪ
ͶͳͽͰͽ͸ͳͷ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͳͶ;ͼͽͻͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
;
͵Δͳͭͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ

ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
͢ͳ΀͹ͬ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
ͳ
ͻͪͲͷͰͻͪ
ͼ;
͹ͼ͵;ͯͰͬͪͶͳ
;
ͷ͸͹ͭͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯͪ
 ̺Ͱͻ͵ͪ
͠͹ͬͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ

΁ͳͷͪ
͋ͪ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͪͬ͸͹ͼͽ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹ͺ;ΔͪͬͪͶͪ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸ͳͷ
͹ͺͳͼͳͷͪ
ͺ;ͽͰͬͪ
ͳ

ͺͻͳͶͳ΂͸͹
ͭͻ;ͫͳͷ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
͸ͰͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ͸ͳͷ
΁ͻͽͰͱͳͷͪ

̀͸ͪͽ͸͹
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ͸ͳΒͳ
ͽͳͺ͹ͬͳ
ͷͪͺͪ
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔ;
ͼͰ

ͺ͹ΒͪͬΓ;Β;
;
ͯͰͬͰͽ͸ͪͰͼͽ͹ͷ
ͬͰ͵;
ͪͅͺͰ
ͺ;ͽͰͬͪ
ͺͻͪͽͰ
ͭͶͪͬ͸Ͱ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ

ͺͻͪͬ΁Ͱ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͱͰ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
͵ͪ͹
ͺͪ͸ͰͶͳ
ͳͶͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͳ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳ
͈͹ΒͪͬΓͳͬͪ
ΔͰ
ͷͪͺͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͳ
ͲͪͺͪͱͰ͸
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͲͪͫͰ
ͶͰͱͰ͸
;
͍ͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵͹Β
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
̺ͰͶͳ͵͹Β
̹ͻͳͽͪ͸ͳΒͳ
̀Ͱ͸ͳͽ
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͼͽͳͭ͸;ͽ

;
ͯͰͶ;
ͫͻͳͽͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ;ͽ͹
ͺͳͼ΁ͪ
ͦ͹͸ͪ
͇ͭͳͶͫͪΒͪ

+PIO
0HJMCZ

ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͲͳ
ͬ͹ͷ
t#SJUBOOJF
%FQJDUBi

;
ͯͰͬͰͽ͸ͪͰͼͽ͹ͷ
ͬͰ͵;

̺ͻͰͷͰ͸͹ͷ
ΒͰ
ͽͰ΀
͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵͹
͸ͪͺͻͰͯ͹ͬͪΔͰ

;ͽͳ΁ͪͶ͹
͸ͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭͰ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ
͸͹ͼͽͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͺͰ΃;Β;

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͽͻͪ͸ͼͺ͹ͻͽ

΃ͽͪͷͺͪΔͰ
͵Δͳͭͪ
͸͹ͬͰ

͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͪͬ΁Ͱ

͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪΒͪͶ͹

ͯ͹ͼͽ;ͺ͸ͳΒͰ
͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͺ͹
ͬͶͪ΃ΕͰ͸ͳͷͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͳ
ͼͬͰ

ͬͰΕͰͷ
ͫͻ͹Β;
Γ;ͯͳ
ͼͬͳ΀

͵Ͷͪͼͪ
͌Ͷͪͼ͵͹ͷ
;
ͯͰͬͰͽ
͸ͪͰͼͽͳ
ͬͰ͵
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ

ͼͰ
͹ͯͶͪͲͳͶ͹
͵͹Δͳͷͪ
ͳ

͵͹΂ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͼͺ͹ͻ͹
ͳ
͸Ͱ

;ͬͰ͵
ͼͳͭ;ͻ͸͹


͉Ͱͽ͵ͪ
ͳ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
͸Ͱͼͳͭ;ͻ͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ

̓ͻͿ


)BOECVDI
GÛS
5PVSJTUFO

͇ͯ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͯ͹
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪͶ͹
ͼͰ
ͼͪ
΂Ͱͼͽͳͷ
ͻͳͲͳ͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹

ͲͯͻͪͬΓͰ
͌
́ͽͪͶͳΒͳ
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪͶͪ
͹ͺͪͼ͸͹ͼͽ
͹ͯ
ͷͪͶͪͻͳΒͰ
ͳ

ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
ͰͺͳͯͰͷͳΒͪ
ͫͰͲ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽͰ
ͲͯͻͪͬΓͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ
͵ͪ
͋ͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͳ
ͳ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͷͰΌ;
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
ͼ;
͹ͽͰͱͪ
ͬͪͶͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͆ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͺͪͼ͹΃ͪ
ͬͳͲͪ
;
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃ΔͰͷ
ͼͷͳͼͶ;

ͳ
ͺ͹ͽ
ͺ;͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͯ͹͵;ͷͰ͸ͪͽͪ
Ͳͪ
ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͿͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͬͰΕ
ͼ;
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ


͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
͹Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪͬͪ͸ͳ
͵ͪ͹
͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ
ͼ;ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳ
ͳͲͶ͹ͱͰ͸ͳ
ͺΓͪ΂͵ͪͷͪ

ͳ
ͷ;΂ͰΔ;
 ̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͰ
͵ͪͻͽͰ 

͈ͻ͹ͽͰͼͽͪ͸ͽͳ
ͼ;
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
ͺͻͳ͵ͻͳͬͪͶͳ
ͼͬ͹Βͪ
͹ͫͰͶͰͱΒͪ
͹ͯͶͪͲͰΕͳ

;
͵ͪͽ͹Ͷͳ΂͵ͪ
ͷͰͼͽͪ
ͯ͹͵
ͼ;
ͳͼͽͳ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͳ
ͳͼ͵ͻͼͪͬͪͶͳ
;
͹ͫͻ͸;ͽ͹ͷ

ͺͻͪͬ΁;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
;
ͺͻ͹ͽͰͼͽͪ͸ͽͼ͵ͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
ͯ͹Ͷͪͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͯͻ;
ͭͰ
ͬͰͻ͹ͳͼͺ͹ͬͰͼͽͳ
͌
ͯͻ;ͭ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
ͯͰͬͰͽ͸ͪͰͼͽ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ
ͼ;
Ͷͳͷͳͽͳ

Ͳͪ
͸ͪΒͫ͹ͭͪͽͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͬͶͪ΃ΕͰ͸Ͱ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͼͬͳ΀
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸ͳ΀
ͼͶ͹ΒͰͬͪ
Ͳͪ

Δͳ΀͹ͬ
͹ͯͶͪͲͪ͵
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͻͪͯͳ
;ͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͬ͹ͯͪ
͆ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
ͼ;

ͳͷ
ͯ͹ͯͰΓͳͬͪ͸ͳ
ͺͻͪͽͳ͹΁ͳ
ͳ
ͽ;ͷͪ΂ͳ
΁ͪͻͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͺͳͼͪ
ͳ
ΒͰͲͳ΂͵͹ͭ

ͼͺ͹ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪΔͪ
͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͼ;
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͫͳͬͪͶͪ
ͫͰͲͫͰͯ͸ͳΒͪ
ͺͻͳ
ͷͪͷΓ;Β;Εͳ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ
ͫͻ͹Β
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͳ΀
ͺ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΁ͪ

͉ͪͲͬ͹Β
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͯͰͬͰͽ͸Ͱͼͽ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͳͷͪ
ͬͳͯ͸;
;Ͷ͹ͭ;
;

ͼͬͰ
ͷͪͼ͹ͬ͸ͳΒͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͳͷͪ

͵ͪ͹
ͳ

ͺ͹ͬͰͲͳͬͪΔ;
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͳ
ͬͰΕͳ΀

͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
ͦ͹ͻΘ
̹ͻͰͯ΃͹
(FPSHF
#SBETIBX
m

ΒͰ
͹ͫΒͪͬͳ͹
ͺͻ
ͬͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΁͹ͷ
ͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͼͪ΂ͳ͸ͳ͹
ͷͪͺ;

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ

͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͺͪͻ͹ͫͻ͹ͯ͹ͷ
͹ͯ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͼͺͰ΃ͳͶͪ
͸͹ͬ;

Ͱͻ;
ͼͬͰ
ͷͪͼ͹ͬ͸ͳΒͰͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
͈ͪͻ͹ͫͻ͹ͯ
ͼ;
ͼͬͰ
΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳͶͳ
ͪͷͰ
ͻͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͺ;ͽ;Β;Εͳ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
̸ͽͶͪ͸ͽͳ͵ͪ
;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺ;
͹ͯͻͰͯͳ΃ͽͰ

͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͪͶ͹
͹ͫͰͶͰͱΒͰ
ͼͬͰͽͳͶͳ΃ͽͪ
ͺͻͰ
͸Ͱͭ͹
ͪͬͪ͸ͽ;ͻͰ
͆ͪ
͵ͻͪΒ;


ͯͰͬͰͽ͸ͪͰͼͽ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͼ;
ͼͬͰ
ͷͪͼ͹ͬ͸ͳΒͳ
ͦ͹͸
ͪͅ
ͻͳ
+PIO
.VSSBZ
m

ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ
Ͷ͹͸ͯ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂
;Ͷ͹ͱͳ͹
ΒͰ

Ͳ͸ͪͽͪ͸
ͯͰ͹
ͼͬ͹ͭ
ͫ;ΘͰͽͪ
;
͵͹͸΁ͳͺͳͻͪΔͰ
ͳ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͰ
͸͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳ
ͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͯ͹
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
;
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͳ
̻͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

͹ͫΒͪͬͳ͹

ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͻ;΂͸ͳ͵
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
͵͹Βͳ
ͳͯ;
;
͎͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͳΒ;
̹ͰͶͭͳΒ;
͈ͻ;ͼ͵;
ͳ

͊ͰͬͰͻ͸;
͆Ͱͷͪ΂͵;

̓ͪͻͶ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ
,BSM
#BFEFLFS
m

ͺͻͬͳ
ͺ;ͽ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ
ͼͰ
ͻͳΒ;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽΓͳͬͳ΀
͵ͪ͹
tͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳi

͈ͻͬͪ
͵Δͳͭͪ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͳͷͪ
ͯ͹Ͷͳ͸͹ͷ
͉ͪΒ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ
͎͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͳΒͰ
ͯ͹

͑ͬͪΒ΁ͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

ͅ͸͹ͭͳ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͳ
ͼ;
Ͳͪͺ͹΂ͰͶͳ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͺ͹ͺ;ͽ
ͅ
̾ͫͰ
Ͷͪ
.
&CFM

̾ͯͷ͹͸ͯͪ
̹͹Βͼͪ
&ENPOE
#PZT

ͪͅͻͳΒͪ͸Ͱ
͑ͽͪͻ͵Ͱ
.B
SJKBOF
4UBSLF

ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͺͳͼͪ΁ͪ
͸ͪ
͊ͽͪͻ͹ͷ
͵͹͸ͽͳ͸Ͱ͸ͽ;
͌
Δͳ΀͹ͬͳͷ

ͯͰͶͳͷͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͷͪͺͪ
ͳ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͪ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ

͌
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳ΂ͪͻͪ
̸Ͷ͹ΒͲͪ
̺ͳͶ΀ͰͶͷͪ
͑ͻͪΒͫͰͻͪ

"MPJT
8JMIFMN
4DISFJCFS
m

ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͲͳͬ͹ͷ
t͈;ͽ͹ͬͪ
Δͪ
ͯ͹Ͷͳ͸͹ͷ
͉ͪΒ͸Ͱi
ͺͻͬͳ
ͺ;ͽ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ΒͪͬΓ;Β;
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͳ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͯͰͼͰͽ

ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͪ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͺͻͬͳ
ͺ;ͽ
ͼͰ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓ;Β;
;
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
ͳͲ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

̓ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
ͺ͹ͺ;ͽ
ͷͪͺͪ
ͳ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͪ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͼͬ͹Β
ͬͻ΀;͸ͪ΁

ͯ͹ͼͽͳͱ;
;
͵Δͳͭͪͷͪ
̓ͪͻͶͪ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
͋͹
ΒͰ
ͯ;ͭ͹
ͫͳͶͪ
ͯ͹ͷͳ͸ͪ͸ͽ͸ͪ
ͼͰ
 ̺Ͱͻ͵ͪ
͠͹ͬͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ

ͻͳΒͪ
ͷͰΌ;͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪ͸ͳ
͹ͯ
ͺͻͬͰ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

ͯͰͬͰͽ͸ͪͰͼͽ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͯ͹
̽ͻ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
̺͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͼ;
͹ͫ;΀ͬͪͽͪͶͳ

Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
̹Ͷͳͼ͵ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹͵
ͳ
̸͸ͭͶ͹̸ͷͰͻͳ͵;
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͳ
ͬͳ
΃ͰΒͰͲͳ΂͸͹
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
͸ͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͷ
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͳ
Ͱ͸ͭͶͰͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;

̀ͫ͹ͭ
ͪͱ;ͻ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͼ;
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ͸͹
ͻͰͬͳͯͳͻͪ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͯ͹ͺ;Δͪͬͪ͸ͳ

ͺͻͪͽͰΕͳ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
;
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͯͳ͸ͪͷͳ΂͸͹ͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͪͷͫͳΒͰ͸ͽ;

̓ͬͪͶͳͽͪͽͳͬ͸ͪ
͹ͼ͹ͫͳ͸ͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͼ;
ͷ͸͹ͭͰ
͸ͪ΁ͻͽͪ͸Ͱ
ͳ
;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂
͵ͳ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸Ͱ
ͷͪͺͰ
ͳ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͳ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
ͳ
ͼͬͰ
ͪͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳΒͳ΀

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͈͹
͵ͬͪͶͳͽͰͽ;
΃ͽͪͷͺͰ
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ΀

ͺͻͳͶ͹ͭͪ
ͳͲͯͬͪΒͪͶͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͿͳͻͷͰ
̺ͪͭ͸Ͱͻ
ͳ
̽ͰͫͰͶͼ
8BHOFS

%FCFMT


͊ͬͪ͵͹
ͳͲͯͪΔͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹ΌͰ
ͳͷͪͶ͹
ΒͰ
͹ͯ
ͺͰͽ͸ͪͰͼͽ
ͯ͹
ͺͰͯͰͼͰͽͪ͵
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͪ

̺ͻͰͷͰ͸͹ͷ
ΒͰ
;ͼͪͬͻ΃ͪͬͪ͸ͪ
ͽͰ΀͸ͳ͵ͪ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪΔͪ
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ
ͯͰͬͰͽ͸ͪͰ
ͼͽ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
Ͳͪͼͽ;ͺΓͰ͸ͪ
͵͹Ͷ͹ͻ͸ͪ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ
ͷͪͺͪ
ͳ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͪ

̺ͰͶͳ΂ͳ͸ͪ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͪ
ͬͪͻͳͻͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͯ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ

Y

΁ͷ


ͳͶͳ
΂ͪ͵
ͷͪΔͰ
ͯ͹
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ΀
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
;͸͹΃Ͱ͸ͳ
͵ͪ͹

ͺ͹ͼͰͫͪ͸
;ͷͰͽͪ͵
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͊ͬͪ͵ͳ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͷͪΔͳ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ

ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬͳ

Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽͳ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪΒͪͶͳ
ͼ;

͹ͫͪͬͰͲͪ͸
ͯͰ͹
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͌
ͯͰͶ;
̓ͪͻͶͪ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱ
ͻͪ
t͈ͻͳͻ;΂͸ͳ͵
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ
͵Ͱi
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸͹ͷ

ͭ͹ͯͳ
͸Ͱ
;
̈́ͪΒͺ΁ͳͭ;
ͲͪͫͰͶͰͱͰ͸ͳ

ͼ;
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸ͳͷ

ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ΀
ͭͰ͹
ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ΀
ͻͰͭͳΒͪ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͳ

ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳ
̺͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͼ;
ͺͻͳ
͵ͪͲͳͬͪͶͳ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒ;
͊ͰͬͰ
ͻ͹Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸Ͱ
͆Ͱͷͪ΂͵Ͱ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

ͷͪͺͰ
ͳ

ͺͶͪ
͸͹ͬͪ

͊ͰͬͰͻ͸Ͱ
͆Ͱͷͪ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ

̽ͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ

͵ͪͻͪͽͪ
ͳ

ͺͶͪ
͸͹ͬͪ

̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵Ͱ


͵ͪͻͪͽͪ
ͳ

ͺͶͪ͸ͪ

̈́͹͸ͯ͹
͸ͪ

͵ͪͻͽͰ
ͳ

ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͪ


́ͽͪͶͳΒͰ
͈ͪͻͳͲͪ
͉;ͼͳΒͰ

͑ͬͰͯͼ͵Ͱ
͆͹ͻͬͰ΃͵Ͱ
ͳͽͯ
͈ͻͳͻ;΂͸ͳ͵
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ

̻Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵Ͱ
ͷͪͺͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͯͰͶ͹
̓ͪͻͶͪ
̹ͰͯͰ͵ͪͻͪ
ͳͲ


͋Ͱͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵Ͱ

ͼͪͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ
ͯͰ͹
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
͸ͪΒ 
͵ͪͻͪͽͪ
ͳ

ͺͶͪ͸ͪ

 ̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͰ
͵ͪͻͽͰ 

΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
ͼ;
ͼͪͯͻͱͪͬͪͶͰ
ͻͪͲͷͰͻ;
ͳ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
͹ͼ͵;ͯ͸;
ͶͰͭͰ͸ͯ;
͸ͪ
͵͹Β͹Β
ͼ;

͸ͪͲ͸ͪ΂Ͱ͸ͳ
ͺ;ͽͰͬͳ
ͳ
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͻ;ͭͰ
͊ͪͯͻͱͪΒ
ͷͪͺͪ
ͼͰ
ͷͰΔͪ͹
͵ͻ͹Ͳ

ͬͻͰͷͰ
͆ͪ
ͺͻͬͳͷ
ͷͪͺͪͷͪ
ͼ;
ͺ͹
ͺͻͪͬͳͶ;
ͲͪͫͰͶͰͱͰ͸Ͱ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
͸ͰͺͻͰ΁ͳ
Ͳ͸Ͱ
ͪͯͷͳ͸ͳͼͽͻͪͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͳ
ͳͲͪͫͻͪ͸ͳ
ͽ͹ͺ͹͸ͳͷͳ
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ

ͫͳͶ͹
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸ͳΒͳ΀
͸ͪͲͳͬͪ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
ͻͰ͵ͪ
ͪ͸ͽͻ͹ͺ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ΀
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽͪ

̓ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͪ
ͺͻ͹ΒͰ͵΁ͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͷͻͰͱͪ
ͷͰͻͳͯͳΒͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͺͪͻͪͶͰͶͪ
ͼ;

ͺ͹ͬͰΕͪͶͰ
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫΓͳͬ͹ͼͽ
ͷͪͺͪ
;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
͋Ͱ͵
͸ͪ

͸͹ͬͳΒͳͷ
͵ͪͻͽͪͷͪ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ΒͪͬΓ;ΒͰ
ͯͬ͹ͯͳͷͰ͸Ͳͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͰ
ͻͰ
ΓͰͿͪ
΂ͳͷͰ
ͼͰ
ͼͽͳ΂;
ͬͪͱ͸ͪ
Ͳ͸ͪΔͪ
͹
ͬͳͼͳ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
͹ͫͶͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͈ͻͰͯͼͽͪ
ͬΓͪΔͰ
ͽͰͻͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͽͰͱͪ͵
Ͳͪͯͪͽͪ͵
Ͳͪ
ͷͰͻͰΔͰ
̓ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ΒͰ

;ͼͪͬͻ΃ͪͬͪ͸
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͬͰ͵͹ͬͪ
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
ͽͰ͵
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ
ͯͰͬͰͽ͸ͪͰͼͽ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͯ͹ͼͽͳ
ͭͪ͹
Ͳ͸ͪͽ͸;
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸;
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫΓͳͬ͹ͼͽ
̓͹͸ͬͰ͸΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΁ͳ
͸ͪ
͵ͪͻͽͪͷͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͳͼ;
ͷͰΔͪͶͳ
ͪͶͳ
ͺͻͪͬ
΁ͳ
ͻͰ΂͸ͳ΀
ͽ͹͵͹ͬͪ
ͳͷͰ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
ͺͪ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒ
ͺ;ͽͰ
ͬͪ
ͷ͹ͼͽ͹ͬͪ
͵ͪ͸ͪͶͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͳ
ͪͯͷͳ͸ͳͼͽͻͪͽͳͬ͸ͳ΀
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͳ

ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
ͪ͸ͽͻ͹ͺ͹ͭͰ͸ͳ΀
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽͪ
ͼ;
͸ͪ
ͼͬͪ͵͹Β
͵ͪͻͽͳ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ
͆ͳͬ͹

;͹ͺ΃ͽͪͬͪΔͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͳͲͫ͹ͻ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
ΒͰ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
Ͳͪͬͳͼͳ͹
͹ͯ
ͼ;ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳͬ
͸Ͱ
͹΁Ͱ͸Ͱ
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͪ
͈͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͪͶ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͯͰͶͪ
;ͼͶ͹ͬͳͶͪ

ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫ;
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͳͬͪΔͪ
Ͷͳ͸ͳΒͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
͈ͻͬͪ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͳͬͪΔͪ

ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͺ͹΂ͳΔ;
;
΃Ͱͼ͸ͪͰͼͽ͹ͷ
ͬͰ͵;
͸ͪ
͵ͪͻͽͪͷͪ
͇ͻͽͰͶͳ
ΒͰͬ͹ͭ
ͪͽͶͪͼͪ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

͇ͯ
ͽͪͯͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸Ͱ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͼͬͰ
΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ

ͺ͹ͼͽͪΒ;
͹ͫͪͬͰͲͪ͸
ͰͶͰͷͰ͸ͽ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ΀
͵ͪͻͪͽͪ

͇ͼͳͷ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͹ͫͪͬͰͲͪ͸
ͰͶͰͷͰ͸ͽ
͵ͪͻͽͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪΒ;
ͭͻͪ
͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͷͪΔͳ΀
ͪͯͷͳ͸ͳͼͽͻͪͽͳͬ͸͹ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͪͶ͸ͳ΀
΁ͰͶͳ͸ͪ
͊
͹ͫͲͳͻ͹ͷ

ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͷͪΔͳ΀
ͪͯͷͳ͸ͳͼͽͻͪͽͳͬ͸ͳ΀
΁ͰͶͳ͸ͪ
ͫͳͶͰ
ͺ͹ͯͶ͹ͱ͸Ͱ

΂Ͱͼͽͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪͷͪ
ͺ͹ͺ;ͽ
ͺͻ͹ͽͰ͵ͽ͹ͻͪͽͪ
ͯͰͷͳͶͳͽͪͻͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ΀
Ͳ͹͸ͪ

ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸Ͱ
;ͺͻͪͬͰ
͹͸Ͱ
ͼ;
ͼͬͰ
ͷͪΔͰ
ͫͳͶͰ
͹ͫͪͬͰͲͪ͸
ͰͶͰͷͰ͸ͽ

ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
͵ͪͻͽͰ
͆ͪͼ;ͺͻ͹ͽ
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳ
͸ͪ
ͷͪͺͪͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͳͷͪΒ;
ͽ;
ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͶͳ
ͯ͹͵;ͷͰ͸ͽ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͫͳ͹
ͫͰͶͰ
ͱͰ͸
͸͹ͬͳͷ
ͷͰͽ͹ͯͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͫͳ͹
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͹ͯ
΃ͽ;ͻ͹ͭ
ͬͳͲ;ͰͶ͸͹ͭ
ͳͼ͵ͪͲͪ

͌
ͺͻͬͳͷ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͬͰΕͪ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹͵ͶͪΔͪ
ͺͻͰ΁ͳ
Ͳ͸ͳΒͰͷ
͹ͯͪͫͳͻ;
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͬͰΕͪΔ;
ͭͰ͹ͷͰͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͽͪ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ

͊ͪͼͬͳͷ
ΒͰ
ͳͲͬͰͼ͸͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ
͹ͬͪ͵ͬͳ΀
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͳͶ͹
ͭͪ
;
͹ͫͳΓ;
ͽ͹ͺ͹͸ͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͹ͽ͵ͻͳͬͪͶͳ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͰ
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͰ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹
ͬͪ
͹ͫͰͶͰͱΒͪ
ͅ͸͹ͭ͹
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸ͳΒͳ
ͳ
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸ͳΒͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳ
ͼͰ
ͼ;ͼͻͰΕ;
;

ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ

 ̺Ͱͻ͵ͪ
͠͹ͬͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ

̺͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
)BOECVDI
GÛS
3FJTFOEF
WPO
,
#BFEFLFS


͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ
;
ͯͻ;ͭ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
ͯͰͬͰͽ͸ͪͰͼͽ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ

͵ͪͻͽͰ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͳ
ͳ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ

ͻͰͯ ͫͻ͹Β
ͫͻ͹Β
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
ͫͻ ͵ͪͻͪͽͪ ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͪ ͹ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͪ

 ͆Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͪ



 ͆Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͪ̽ͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ 


 ͆Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͪ



 ̹ͰͻͶͳ͸ 


 ̽͹Ͷͳ͸ͪ
͉ͪΒ͸Ͱ 


̹ͪΒͰͻ͸
͋ͳͻ͹Ͷ

 


̀ͪͶ΁ͫ;ͻͭ
̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵ͪ


 

̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
̹͹ͼ͸ͪ
 ̹ͰͶͭͳΒͪ
͎͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͳΒͪ 


 ̻ͻ΂͵ͪ 


̺ͰͶͳ͵ͪ
̹ͻͳͽͪ͸ͳΒͪ
́ͻ
 


ͼ͵ͪ

 ̈́͹͸ͯ͹͸ 


́ͽͪͶͳΒͪ
̈́ͳͬ͹ͻ͸͹



 ͍ͳͻͰ͸΁ͪ
͉ͪͬͰ͸ͪ



͆ͳ΁ͪ
̸Βͪ΂ͳ͹
̓͹ͻͲͳ͵ͪ

͊ͻͰͯΔͪ
́ͽͪͶͳΒͪ

 



ͳ
͉ͳͷ
͠;ͱ͸ͪ
́ͽͪͶͳΒͪ



 ͊ͳ΁ͳͶͳΒͪ
͊ͪͻͯͳ͸ͳΒͪ



ͪͅͶͽͪ
͋;͸ͳͼ
̓ͻͿ
 ͈ͪͶͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ
ͳ
͊ͳͻͳΒͪ 


 ͈ͪͻͳͲ 


 ͑ͬͪΒ΁ͪͻͼ͵ͪ 



͆Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ
̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ
ͺ͹
ͷ͹͸;ͷͰ͸ͽͪͶ͸ͳͷ

ͯͰͶͳͷͪ
Ͱ͸΁ͳ͵Ͷ͹ͺͰͯͳΒͪͷͪ
ͻͰ΂͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͪͽͶͪͼͳͷͪ
͹ͫΒͪͬͳ͹
ΒͰ
΃ͰͲͯͰ
ͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͯͰͬͰͽ͸ͪͰͼͽ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͰ
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂Ͱ
.FZFST

3FJTFCÛDIFS

͌
Δͳͷͪ
ͼ;
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸Ͱ
ͻͰͭͳΒͰ
͆Ͱͷͪ΂͵Ͱ
͑ͬͪΒ΁ͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
͍ͻͪ͸
 ̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͰ
͵ͪͻͽͰ 

΁;ͼ͵Ͱ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
́ͽͪͶͳΒͰ
̾ͭͳͺͽͪ
ͪͅΒͰͻ͹ͬͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͳ
͹ͺͻͰͷΓͰ

͸ͳ
͹ͯͶͳ΂͸ͳͷ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͼ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳͷ
ͯͰͽͪΓͳͷͪ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͳͷ

;
ͫ͹Βͳ
ͅ͸͹ͭͳ
͹ͯ
ͽͳ΀
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͪ
ͫͳͶͳ
ͼ;
;ͻͪΌͰ͸ͳ
ͲͪͼͶ;ͭ͹ͷ
ͿͳͻͷͰ
͉Ͱ
ͬͰ͸΃ͽͪΒ͸
3BWFOTUFJO

Ͳ͸ͪͽ͸͹
ͼ;ͺͰͻͳ͹ͻ͸ͳΒͰ
;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ;
͸ͪ
ͺͻͬͰ
̓ͪͻͶͪ

̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ

͊Ͱͷ
ͪͅΒͰͻͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ
ͻͳͬͪͶ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͫͰͻͶͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͳͲͯͪ
ͬͪ΂
͋Ͱ͹ͫͪͶͯ
̻ͻͳͫͰ͸
5IFPCBME
(SJFCFO

͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
͹ͫΒͪͬͳ͹

ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ

ͺͻͰͽͰͱ͸͹
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͰ
͋Ͱ
ͼͰͻͳΒͰ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵͹ͷ

ͳ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͷ
͹ͫͳͶ;Β;
͵ͬͪͶͳͽͰͽ͸ͳͷ
ͷͪͺͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ

̸;ͽ͹ͻ
̸ͶͫͰͻͽ
̻͹Ͷͯ΃ͷͳͽ
"MCFSU
(PMETNJUI

͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪ͹

ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂
;
ͼͪͻͪͯΔͳ
ͼͪ
̈́Ͱ͹ͺ͹Ͷͯ͹ͷ
̓ͻͪ΁͹ͷ
-FPQPME
,SBU[

͹ͫΒͪͬΓͳ
ͬͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂Ͱ
ͼͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳͷ
ͷͪͺͪͷͪ
͆ͪ
͵ͻͪΒ;
ͯͰͬͰͽ͸ͪͰͼͽ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͹ͫΒͪ
ͬΓͳͬͪ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
͊ͪ͸͵ͽ
͈ͰͽͰͻͼͫ;ͻͭͪ
̓͹͸ͼͽͪ͸ͽͳ͸͹ͺ͹Γͪ

ͳ
ΒͰͯ͸͹
ͳͲͯͪΔͰ
͢;Β͹ͻ͵ͪ
ͳ
͐ͳ͵ͪͭͪ
͈ͻͰ
͸ͪͼͽͪ͸͵ͪ
ͳ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽͰ
ͼͬ͹Βͳ΀

ͯͰͶͪ
ͳͽͪͶͳΒͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂ͳ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͲͪΒͷΓͳͬͪͶͳ
ͯ͹
ͽͪͯͪ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸Ͱ

ͬ͹ͯͳ΂Ͱ
ͼͪ
ͷͪͺͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
͆Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͼͪ
ͷͪͺͪ
ͷͪ
ͳ

ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͪ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
͸ͪͲͬͪ͸ͳ΀
t(VJEB
EFM
WJBHHJBUPSF
JO
*UBMJBi

͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ
ͼ;

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̈́;ͳΌͳ
͏;͵͹Ͷͳ
-VJHJ
;VDPMMJ

ΒͰ

ͭ͹
ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͹ͫΒͪͬͳ͹
ͺͻͬͳ
͵ͻ;ͱ͸ͳ
ͺͶͪ͸
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͅͳͶͪ͸ͪ

̽ͻ;ͭͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
͹ͯͶͳ΂͸͹
͹ͺͻͰͷΓͰ͸
ͯͰͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͪ;ͽ͹
ͻͪ

̿ͰͻͯͰ͸ͪͻͯͪ
̸ͻͽͪͻͳͪΒͪ
(FSEFOBSE
"SUBSJBT

ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͹ͫ
ΒͪͬΓͰ͸
͸ͪ
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
͆ͪ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͼ;
ͺͻͬͳ
ͺ;ͽ

ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ͸ͳΒͰ
;΁ͻͽͪ͸ͳ
ͼͬͳ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳ
͵;ΕͰ

͈͹ͼͷͪͽͻͪΒ;Εͳ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
m
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͼ;
ͫͰͲ
ͺͻͰͷ΁ͪ

;
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͼͽͬ;
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͭͪ
ͅ͹ͱͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͻͰͯͪ͸
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
ͻͪͯ

ͫͻͳͽͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼͽͬͪͻͪͶͪ΁ͪ
ͳ
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
ͺͻͰͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒͰ

ͺ͹
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͺͻͰͼͽͳͱ͸ͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽ͹
͹ͺͻͰͷΓͰ͸ͳͷ

ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳͷ
̹ͪͻͽ͹Ͷ͹ͷͰ͹ͬͳͷ
͵ͪͻͽͪͷͪ

̸͸ͪͶͳͲ͹ͷ
Ͳ͸ͪͽ͸͹ͭ
ͫͻ͹Βͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͳ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂͵ͪ
ͯͪ

ΒͰ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ
ͻͪͲ͸͹ͬͻͼͽͪ͸
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͹͸ͳ
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸͹
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰ
ͫΓͪͬͪͽͳ
̺ͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽ
͹ͬͪ͵ͬͳ΀
ͷͪͺͪ
ͳ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͪ
;
ͺͻͬ͹ͷ
ͻͰͯ;
ΒͰ
ͿͳͲͳ͹
͸͹ͷͼ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΒ͸ͪ
ͪ
ͷͪΔͰ
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͪ
͋͹
ΒͰ
ͻͪͲ;ͷΓͳͬ͹
ͼͪ
ͪͼͺͰ͵
ͽͪ
ͽͰ΃͵͹Εͪ
;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΔ;
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
ͳ
ͼͽͰͺͰ͸ͪ
ͽͰ΀͸ͳ΂͵͹ͽͰ΀͸͹Ͷ͹
΃͵ͳ΀
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
͊
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͷ
ͼͰ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂;ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͳ
͆Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͪ

΃͵͹Ͷͪ
ͼͪ
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͳͷ
ͯͰͶͳͷͪ
͹ͯͻͪͲ
ͬͳ΃Ͱͭ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͹Ͷ͹΃͵͹ͭ

͸ͳͬ͹ͪ
ͳ
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΔͪ
͈ͻͬͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂Ͱ
ͼ͸ͳͷͪΔͰ
ͳ
ͭͻͪͿͳ΂͵͹

ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ΀
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ΀
ͻͰͭͳΒͪ
͵ͪ͹
͸ͪΒͫ͹ΓͰ
ͼͬͰͯ͹
΂ͪ͸ͼͽͬ͹
͸ͪͳͶͪͲͳͷ͹
;
ͻͪͯ͹ͬͳͷͪ
̓ͪͻͶͪ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
̸Ͷ͹ΒͲͪ
̺ͳͶ΀ͰͶͷͪ

͑ͻͪΒͫͰͻͪ
ͪͅΒͰͻͪ
ͳͽͯ
 ̺Ͱͻ͵ͪ
͠͹ͬͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ

̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͼͬ͹Β;
;Ͷ͹ͭ;
͸ͪͶͪͲͰ
;
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹Β
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͳ
͢ͳ
΀͹ͬͪ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽ
ͼͰ
ͷͰͻͳ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͯ͹ͺͻͳ͸͹ͼ
ͳͲ;΂ͪͬͪΔ;
ͪ͸ͽͻ͹ͺ͹ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿ
ͼ͵͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Βͪ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
ͳ
ͻͰͭͳΒͪ
͆ͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳͷ
͵ͪͻͽͪͷͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͬͰͯͰ͸ͪ
ͶͰͭͰ͸ͯͪ
͵͹Βͪ
;ͺ;Ε;ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸Ͱ
ͫͰͶͰ΃͵Ͱ
;
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͳͲ

͵͹Βͳ΀
ͯ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒͰͷ͹
ͺͻͰΌͪ΃Δͪ
ͳ
͸͹ͬͪ
ͳͷͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
ͫͻ͹Β
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ

ͷͰΌ;ͼ͹ͫ͸;
;ͯͪΓͰ͸͹ͼͽ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
͆ͪ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͷ
͵ͪͻͽͪͷͪ
ͺͻͬͳ΀
ͫͰͯͰ
͵Ͱͻͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
͸ͪΒͬͻͰͯ͸ͳΒͪ
ͽ͹ͺ͹͸͹ͷͪͼͽͳ͵ͪ
͌Ͳ
Δͳ΀
ͼ;
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
ͯͰ
ͽͪΓ͸ͳ
͹ͺͳͼͳ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͳ
ͳͲͬͰ΃ͽͪΒͳ

̓ͻͪΒͰͷ
ͯͰͬͰͽ͸ͪͰͼͽ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
ͼ;
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪ͸ͳ
ͯͰͽͪΓ
͸ͳ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͳ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼ;
Βͪͼ͸͹
ͷͪͻ͵ͳͻͪ͸ͳ
ͬͪͱ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂
͵ͳ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳ
ͺ͹ͺ;ͽ
΀͹ͽͰͶͪ
ͺͪ͸ͼͳ͹͸ͪ
ͷ;ͲͰΒͪ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸ͳ΀
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ

͇ͺͪͽͳΒͪ

ͺͶͪ͸
ͭͻͪͯͪ

9*9
ͬͰ͵

̻Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͪ
Ͳ͸ͪΔͪ
ͳ
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͳ
͹
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ
͵͹ͷ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͫͳͶͳ
ͼ;
͹ͼ͵;ͯ͸ͳ
ͽͰ
ͼͰ
ͼͽ͹ͭͪ
ΒͪͬΓͪ
ͼͬͰ
΂Ͱ΃Εͪ
ͺ͹ͽͻͪͱΔͪ

Ͳͪ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸ͳͷ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͷ
͹ͫͪͬͰ΃ͽͰΔͳͷͪ
͹ͯ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͻͪͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͽͻ
ͭ͹ͬͪ΁ͪ
͵ͪͶ;ΌͰͻͪ
΀ͻ͹͸ͳ΂ͪͻͪ
͉ͪ͸ͳΒͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸ͪ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͪ
͹
͹ͬͳͷ

ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
ͽͳ΁ͪͶͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͺͳͼͪ
;ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹ΒͪͼͰͬͪ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
;Ͳ
ͭͶͪͬ͸Ͱ
͵͹ͺ
 ̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͰ
͵ͪͻͽͰ 

͸Ͱ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͰ͸Ͱ
ͺ;ͽͰͬͰ
͆ͪͭͶ͹
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹

ͺ͹ͯͼͽͪ͵͸;ͽ͹
ͬ͹Β͸ͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͻͪͲͶ͹Ͳͳͷͪ
͆ͪͼͽͪΒͪͶͰ
ͼ;
͸͹ͬͳΒͰ
͵ͪͻͽͰ
ͪͶͳ

͸Ͱ
;ͬͰ͵
ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͯ͹ͫͻͰ
ͳ
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫΓͳͬͰ
͌
ͼͽ;ͯͳΒͪͷͪ
͸ͪΒ;΂Ͱ͸ͳΒͳ΀

ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳ΂ͪͻͪ
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
ͼͰ
ͺͳͼͪͶ͹
͹
̽;͸ͪͬ;
͆ͪͺͻͰͯͪ͵
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹

ͼͺ͹ͻ
ΒͰͻ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
΀ͻ͹͸ͳ΂ͪͻͳ
ͬ͹Β͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͳ
ͻͪͯ͹Ͳ͸ͪͶͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͸ͪ
ͼͬ͹ͷ

ͺͻ͹ͶͪͲ;
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒ;
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷͪͶͳ
Ͳͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ;
͸Ͱͭ͹
Ͳͪ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒ;

ͳ
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒ;
͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͳͷ͹ͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͼ;
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͳͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͼͪ
ͬͰΕ͹ͷ

ͽͪ΂͸͹΃Ε;
ͪ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͳΒͳ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
͵ͪͻͪͽͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
ͼͺ͹ͻ͹
ΒͰ
͹ͯͷͳ
΁ͪ͹
͇ͯ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
̸;ͼͽͻͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͷͪͶͪ
͸ͪΒͫ͹Γ;
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵;
Ͳͪ

ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹
ͺͻ͹;΂ͪͬͪΔͰ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
͌
ͯͰͶ;
͆ͳ͵͹ͶͰ
͉ͪͯ͹Β΂ͳΕͪ
t̻Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹
Ͳ͸ͪΔͰ
͹
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ
͵͹ͷ

ͬͰ͵ͪi
ΒͰ
ͲͪͫͰͶͰͱͰ͸͹
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͼͬͳ
ͪ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
΂ͳ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ

ΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͺ͹ͬͰͻͰ͸͹
ͺͻ͹;΂ͪͬͪΔͰ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͳ
ͳͲͬͰ΃ͽͪ
ΒͰ
ͼ͵ͳ΁Ͱ
ͳ
͵ͪͻͽͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
ͭ͹ͷͳͶͪͶͰ
͵͹ͯ
ͪ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹Β
͸ͳ΀
ͬͶͪͼͽͳ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͭͶ͹
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͪ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͬͶͪͼͽͳ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͸͹ͷ
ͼͪͫͻͪͶͰ
͹ͭͻ͹ͷ͸;
΀ͻͺ;
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵Ͱ
ͭͻͪΌͰ
͹
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͷͰΌ;
͵͹Β͹ͷ
ΒͰ

ͫͳͶ͹
͸ͪΒͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͳͽͳ͸ͰͻͰͻͪ
ͼ
ͫͻͳͱΓͳͬͳͷ
͸͹ͽͪͷͪ
͹
͵ͬͪͶͳͽͰͽ;
ͺ;ͽͰͬͪ

͹
;ͯͪΓͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͷͰͼͽͪ
͹
ͷ͹ͼͽ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͳͽͯ
͊
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͷ
ͼͰ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂;ΒͰ
ͯͪ

ΒͰ
ͼͽͪͻͳΒͪ
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͽͰͱ͸͹
ͻͪͽ͸ͪ
ͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ
ͯͰ͹

͵ͪͻͪͽͪ
Ͳͪͷͳ΃ΓͰ͸
͵ͪ͹
͵ͪͻͽͰ
ͫ͹Βͳ΃ͽͪ
͏ͰͶ͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹
͈͹Ͷ;͹ͼͽͻͬ͹

ͫͳͶ͹
ΒͰ
Β͹΃
͸ͪ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵;
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͽͪ͵͹
͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹
ͯͪ
ͼ;
͸ͪ
ΔͰͷ;
ͫͳͶͳ

ͷ͹ͭ;Εͳ
ͺͻ͹͸ͪͶͪͼ΁ͳ
͵ͪ͹
;
͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳͷ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͼͬͰͽͪi

͆͹ͬͳ
ͺ͹ͯͼͽͳ΁ͪΒͳ
Ͳͪ
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͭͰ
͹
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ΒͪͬͳͶͳ

ͼ;
ͼͰ
;
ͺͻͬ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
͆ͪΒͺͻͰ
ͳͲ
ͻͪͽ͸ͳ΀
ͻͪͲͶ͹ͭͪ
͈ͻ͹ͽͳͬ
͸ͳ΁ͳ
͆ͪͺ͹ͶͰ͹͸ͪ
ͼ;
͵͹ͺͳͻͪͶͳ
ͬͰͶͳ͵͹ͭ
ͬ͹Βͼ͵͹ͬ͹Ό;
ͳ
;
ͽ͹ͷͰ
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;

͹ͯ
ΔͰͭͪ
;΂ͳͶͳ
͹
ͬͪͱ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͯ͹ͫͻͳ΀
͵ͪͻͪͽͪ
Ͳͪ
ͻͪͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
̸;ͼͽͻͳΒͪ
ΒͰ

ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
͵ͪͻͽͰ
ͳͲͻͪΌͳͬͪͶͪ
;
̹Ͱ΂;
ͭͯͰ
ΒͰ
͹ͯ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͪ͹
t5PQP
HSBQIJDTIMJUIPHSBQIJTIF
"OTUBMU
EFT
(FOFSBMRVBSUJFNFJTUFS4UBBCFTi

ͯ͹͵
ΒͰ
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ͻͪͯ
ͬ͹Β͸ͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬͶͪͼͽͳ
;
́ͽͪͶͳΒͳ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸

;
t*
3
*OTUJUVUP
HFPHSBGJDP
NJMJUBSFi

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̓ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͬͰΕ

ͳͼͽͪ͵ͪ͹
͆ͳ͵͹Ͷͪ
͉ͪͯ͹Β΂ͳΕ
͋͹ͺ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹Ͷͳͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
Ͳͪͬ͹ͯ
;
̹Ͱ΂;

ΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳͷͰ͸͹ͬͪ͸
͵ͪ͹
t,
,
NJMJUÅSHFPHSBGJTDIFT
*OTUJUVUi
ͳ

ͫͳ͹
ͯ;ͭ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ
Ͳͪͬ͹ͯ
Ͳͪ
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒ;
ͼͬͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
̹ͪͶ
͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹Ͷ;͹ͼͽͻͬͪ

͊ͽ;ͯͳΒͪ
t¾CFS
4FSCJFOi
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͪ
"ͯͪͷͪ
Ϳ͹͸
̺ͪΒ͸ͭͪͻͽͰ͸ͪ
"EBN

WPO
8FJOHBSUFO

ΒͰ
;ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸ͳͶͪ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵;
ͳ

͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵;
ͼͶͳ͵;

͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
;Ͳ
ͷ͹ͽͳͬ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳ͹
͸ͪ
ͪ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͬ͹Β͸͹ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ

ͪͼͺͳͻͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͸ͪ
Δ;
͆ͪ
͵ͪͻͽͪͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸ͪ
͹ͻ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸Ͱ

ͼͶͳ͵ͪ͸Ͱ
΁ͻͽͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͯ͹͵
ͼ;
ͬ͹ͯͰ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͸ͪ
͵ͪͻͽͪͷͪ
ͳ

 ̺Ͱͻ͵ͪ
͠͹ͬͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ

;
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
͈;ͽͰͬͳ
͸ͳͼ;
ͫͻͳͱΓͳͬ͹
͹ͫͻͪΌͰ͸ͳ
͌͸ͰͼͰ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͼͪͷ͹
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ

ͯͻ;ͷ͹ͬͳ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ͊͹ͿͳΒͪ
ͳ
͊ͪͻͪΒͰͬ͹͊͹Ͷ;͸
ͼ
ΒͰͯ͸ͳͷ
͹ͭͻͪ͸͵͹ͷ
͸ͪ

͊͵ͪͯͪͻ
͇΁Ͱ͸͹ͷ
̺ͪΒ͸ͭͪͻͽͰ͸͹ͬͳ΀
͵ͪͻͪͽͪ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͫͪͬͳͶͳ
̺;͵
ͳ
̓͹ͺͳ
ͽͪͻ
ͫͰͶͰͱͰΕͳ
ͳͲͬͰͼ͸Ͱ
ͳͼͺͻͪͬ͵Ͱ
̺ͪΒ͸ͭͪͻͽͰ͸͹ͬͰ
͵ͪͻͽͰ

̺ͪΒ͸ͭͪͻͽͰ͸͹ͬ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
͹ͺͳͼ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͼͪ
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͷ
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͯ;ͭ͹

ͺ͹ͯͼͽͳ΁ͪΒ
Ͳͪ
ͼͶͳ΂͸Ͱ
ͻͪͯ͹ͬͰ
;
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸͹Β
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͳ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͳ

ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ

̓ͻͪΒͰͷ
ͯͰͬͰͽ͸ͪͰͼͽ͹ͭ
ͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ
ͯͬͪͯͰͼͰͽ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ

ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸ͳ
͸ͪ
͵ͪͻͽͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͺ͹ͺͻͳͷͪΒ;

ͼͬͰ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͳΒͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
͇͸ͳ
ͼͰ
ͺͪͱΓͳͬ͹
͹ͯͪͫͳͻͪΒ;
ͳͷͪΒ;Εͳ
;
ͬͳͯ;

Δͳ΀͹ͬ;
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳΒ;
ͳ
Ͳͪ΀ͽͰͬͰ
ͼͬͰ
ͬͰΕͰͭ
ͫͻ͹Βͪ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ͵ͪ
̓ͪͻͽͰ
ͳ
ͺͶͪ
͸͹ͬͳ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͼͰͫͪ͸
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪ
ͻͰͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
ΒͰͲͳ͵͹ͷ
ͭͻͪ
Ϳͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͼͳͷͫ͹Ͷͪ
ͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽ͹ͼͽ
ͻͪͲͷͰͻͰ
ͯͪΒͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ

ͳͲͪͫͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
ͬͰͶͳ΂ͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͫͻ͹Βͪ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽͪ
͋ͪ͵ͬͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;

͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͭ
ͯ͹ͺͻͳ͸͹ͼͰ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β;
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ
ͭͻͪͿͳ΂͵Ͱ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͪ
ͼ͵;ͺ

ͼͳͷͫ͹Ͷͪ
ͳ
ͼͶͳ͵ͪ
ͯ͹ͺͻͳ͸͹ͼͳ
ͫͻͱͰͷ
΂ͳͽͪΔ;
ͳ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪΔ;
͹ͼ͹ͫͰ͸͹
ͼͽͳ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ
ͼͬͳ΀
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
͸ͪ
̀ͰͷΓͳ
̽ͬͪͯͰͼͰͽͳ
ͬͰ͵
ΒͰ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͺ͹ΒͪͬͰ
ͬͰͶͳ͵͹ͭ
ͫͻ͹Βͪ
͵Δͳͭͪ
ͫͻ͹΃;ͻͪ

΂ͪͼ͹ͺͳͼͪ
ͪͽͶͪͼͪ
ͳ
;͸ͪͺͻͰΌͰΔͪ
Ͳ͸ͪΔͪ
͹
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͻͰͭͳΒͪ
ͯͻ
ͱͪͬͪ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
͆ͪͭͶͪ΃ͪͬͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͼ͹ͫͰ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽ͹ͼͽ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀

͹ͯͶͳ͵ͪ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͰ

͈ͻͳͬͻͰͯ͸ͳ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͼͽͪ͵ͪ͹
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β

ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒͪ
ͽͻͪ͸ͼͺ͹ͻͽͪ
ͳ
ͷͪͼ͹ͬ͸͹ͭ
͵ͻͰͽͪΔͪ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
̓ͪͻͽͰ

ͺ;ͽͰͬͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪΒ;
ͺͻͳͷͪͻ͸ͳ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͸Ͱ͹ͺ΀͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ
΁ͳͷͪ
ͽͻͭ͹ͬ΁ͳͷͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ΁ͳͷͪ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂ͳͷͪ
͆ͪͼͶͪΔͪΒ;Εͳ
ͼͰ

͸ͪ
ͻͪ͸ͳΒͪ
Ͳ͸ͪΔͪ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪΒ;
ͼͰ
͵ͪͻͽͰ
ͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
ͳ
ͬͰΕͰ
ͷͪͽͰ
ͷͪͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͽͪ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ

̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͹
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
ͼͪͯͻͱͰ
ͷ͸͹ͭͰ
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵Ͱ

ͺͻͳͶ͹ͭͰ
͸ͪ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼ;
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸Ͱ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ

ͺͻͪͬ΁ͳ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
͋ͪ͵ͪͬ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͼͶ͹
ͬ͹ͷ
t+VHPTMBXJFOi
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂͵Ͱ
͵;ΕͰ
͈͹ͶͳͭͶ͹ͽ
ͳͲ
ͅͳ͸΀Ͱ͸ͪ
ͼͪ

ͺͶͪ
͸͹ͬͪ
ͳ
͵ͪͻͪͽͪ
͇͸
ͼͪͯͻͱͳ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
ͳ
͹ͺͳͼͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽͳ΀

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽͪ
ͷ;ͲͰΒͪ
΁ͻ͵ͪͬͪ
ͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;΁ͳΒͪ
;

ͷ͸͹ͭͳͷ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͺ͹ͺ;ͽ
̀ͪͯͻͪ
͉ͳΒͰ͵Ͱ
̽;ͫͻ͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
̹Ͱ͹
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͊͵͹ͺΓͪ
ͳͽͯ

͌
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ͹ͷ
t#BFEFLFS{T
"VUPSFJTGÛISFS
+VHPTMBXJ
FO
VOE
(SJFDIFOMBOE
NJU
&VSPQÅJTDIFSUÛSLFJi
͸ͪͶͪͲͰ
ͼͰ

͵ͪͻͽͰ
ͳ


ͺͶͪ͸ͪ
̻Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͪ

͵ͪͻͽͪ


ͼͪͯͻͱͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
͹
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͽͪ
ͯͪ΃ΔͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ΒͰͻ
ΒͰ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
ͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
͸ͪͲͳͬͰ
͸ͪ
 ̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͰ
͵ͪͻͽͰ 

ͼͰΓͪ
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͪ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͪ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΂͵;
ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸;
ͷͻͰͱ;
̓Δͳͭͪ

ͼͪͯͻͱͳ
ͯͪΓͳ͸͹ͷͰͻ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
͸ͪͲ͸ͪ΂Ͱ͸;
;ͯͪΓͰ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͹ͺͳͼͪ
͸ͳ΀
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
;
͵ͳͶ͹ͷͰͽͻͳͷͪ
͌
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
ΒͰ
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸͹
͸ͪͼͰΓͰ
͋͹ͺ͹Ͷͪ
ͪ

͸ͪ
ͯͪΓͳ͸͹ͷͰͻ;
͹Ͳ͸ͪ΂Ͱ͸͹
ͻͪͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͰ

͵ͷ

͹ͯ
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸͹ͭ
ͅͶͪͯͰ
͸͹ͬ΁ͪ
ͣͳͻͳͶͳ΂͸ͳ
͸ͪͲͳͬ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
͋͹ͺ͹Ͷͪ
͸ͪͯͷ͹ͻͼ͵ͪ
ͬͳͼͳ͸ͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͪ

ͻͰ͵ͪ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽͳ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒ
;ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΂͵ͪ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͺ͹ͯ
̓ͪͻͪΌ͹ͻΌͰͷ


͇ͺͶͰ͸ͪ΁
ͷͪ;Ͳ͹ͶͰΒ
͊ͬͰͽͳ
͚͹ͻΌͰ

ͷͰͻͷͰͻ͸ͳ
ͷ͹Ͳͪͳ͵
ͳ
ͺ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΂͸ͪ

ͭͻ͹ͫ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͯͳ͸ͪͼͽͳΒͰ
̓ͪͻͪΌ͹ͻΌͰͬͳΕ
ͳͽͯ
ͼ;
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͽͳͺͼ͵;
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒ;
͸͹ͬͳΒͰͭ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
͹
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ

͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸
;
͑ͽ;ͽͭͪͻͽ;

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

ͺͶͪ͸

ͼͪ

ͽ;ͻͳ
ͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽͪ
3
m


 ̺Ͱͻ͵ͪ
͠͹ͬͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ

͆ͪ
ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳͷ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ

ͼͬͰ
ΒͰ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
͹
͸͹ͬͳͷ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
;ͺ͹ͽͺ;Δ;Β;
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿ
ͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͋ͪ͵͹
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
͸ͪ
ͺͶͪ͸;
ͭͻͪͯͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ

;
ͻͪͲͷͰͻͳ

ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸ͳ
ͼ;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ

΀͹ͽͰͶͳ
ͳͽͯ
͌
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ͹ͷ
+VHPTMBXJFO
VOE
(SJFDIFOMBOE
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ

ͼͰ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͪ
ͼͰͻͳΒͪ
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͭͪ
͆ͪ
ͺͻͬ͹Β
͵ͪͻͽͳ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸

ΒͰ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
͈͹ͻͰͯ
ͭͻͪͿͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͼͳͷͫ͹Ͷͪ

͸;ͷͰͻͳ΂͵ͳ
ͼ;
͸ͪͲ͸ͪ΂Ͱ͸Ͱ
͵͹͹ͻͯͳ͸ͪͽͰ
ͫͻ͹Β
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͬͰͶͳ΂ͳ͸ͪ

ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ

͌
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽ͹ͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
ͷͰΌ;
ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳͷ
͵ͪͻͽͪͷͪ
ͼ;
͵ͪͻͽͪ

ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪ
ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸Ͱ
ͷͻͰͱͰ
ͼͪ
͸ͪͲ͸ͪ΂Ͱ͸ͳͷ
ͼͻͰͯͳ΃ͽͳͷͪ
ͼͽͪͻ͹ͭͻ΂͵Ͱ
͵;Ͷ
ͽ;ͻͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ

ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͪͬ΁ͳͷͪ
͵ͻͰͽͪΔͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͌
ͯͰͬͰͽ͸ͪͰͼͽ͹ͷ
ͬͰ͵;
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
ͼͰ
ͻͪͲͬͳΒͪ͹
;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
ͳ
ͷͰͯͳͽͰ
ͻͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
̓ΔͳͭͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͳ
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ͸͹

ͼ;
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ
́ͼͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͼͪ
ͽͰ΀͸ͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͻͰ΃ͰΔͳͷͪ
ͳ
͵ͬͪͶͳͽͰͽ͹ͷ
΃ͽͪͷ
ͺͰ
͇ͯ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ΀
΁ͻ͸͹ͫͰͶͳ΀
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͼͳͻ͹ͷͪ΃͸ͳΒͰͭ
ͼͪͻΘͪΒͪ
ͯ͹

͹ͯͶͳ΂͸ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͼͪ
ͬͳͼ͹͵͹͵͹Ͷ͹ͻ͸ͳͷ
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸ͳͷ

ͷͪͺͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
͆ͪΒͫ͹Γͳ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͳ
ͼ;
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͳͬͪͶͳ
ͯͰ
ͽͪΓ͸;
;͸;ͽͻͪ΃Δ;
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻ;
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
;͵Γ;΂;Β;Εͳ
ͺͪͱΓͳͬ͹
;͸ͰͽͰ

ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
ͺ͹
͹ͫ͹ͯͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͯͪΓ͹Β
ͺͰͻͳͿͰͻͳΒͳ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͈Ͷͪ͸͹ͬͳ

ͼ;
΁ͻͽͪ͸ͳ
ͺͪͱΓͳͬ͹
ͼͪ
ͷͪͽͰͷͪͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸ͳͷ
ͷͰͻͪͷͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹

ͻͪͲͷͰͻ͹ͷ

̸ͽͳ͸ͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻ

̸͵ͻ͹ͺ͹Γ
 ̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͰ
͵ͪͻͽͰ 

̽ͻ;ͭͪ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵ͪ
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͭͪ
;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ

ΒͰ
ͽͰ΀͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
ͳ
ͽͰ΀͸ͳ͵ͪ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪΔͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͯ͹ͼͽͳͱͰ
ͬͳͼ͹͵
͸ͳ
ͬ͹
͸ͪ
͵ͻͪΒ;
ͯͰͬͰͽ͸ͪͰͼͽ͹ͭ
ͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ
ͯͬͪͯͰͼͰͽ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͈͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ
ͯͬͪ
ͯͰͼͰͽ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪΔͰ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ΀
ͷͪͺͪ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ;
ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷ;
͹ͫͪͬΓͪͶͰ

ͼ;
΃ͽͪͷͺͪͻͳΒͰ
ͼͪ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ΁ͳ͸͹ͷ
Ͳͪͺ͹ͼͶͰ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͽͰͱ͸͹
ͱͰ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͻͪͯ
͸Ͱ
ͼ͸ͪͭͰ
͈ͻͳ΀ͬͪΕͰ͸͹
ΒͰ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪΔͰ
;
ͫ͹Βͳ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ΀
ͺ͹ͭ͹ͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ

ͷͰΌ;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
ͳͲͯͬͪΒͪ
Ͷͪ͵΃ͪ
΂ͳͽΓͳͬ͹ͼͽ
ͳ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͪͬ͸ͳΒͪ
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ
͸͹ͼͽ
͌
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵;
ͷͪͺͰ
ͼ;
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ͸͹
ͫͳͶͰ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͪͬ͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͪ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
;͹ͺ
΃ͽͰ͸ͳͷ
ͭͰ͸ͰͻͪͶͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
̹ͻͱͰ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͺͻͰͯ͹ͬͪͶͪ
ͽͰ΀͸ͳ͵ͪ

΃ͽͪͷͺͪΔͪ
͹ͯ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺͽ;ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͻͰ΃ͰΔͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͺ͹ͯͳͱ;
͵ͬͪͶͳͽͰͽ
ͷͪͺͪ

̽ͬͪͯͰͼͰͽͳ
ͬͰ͵
ͳ
͸͹ͬ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͯ͹͸͹ͼͰ
͸͹ͬͰ
ͺͻͪͬ΁Ͱ
;
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β;
͵ͪͻ
ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
͵ͻͰͳͻͪΔ;
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ΀
ͷͪͺͪ
ͳ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͪ
̓ͪͻͽ͹
ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͯͳͼ΁ͳͺͶͳ͸ͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
ͫͪͬͳ
ͳͲͻͪͯ͹ͷ
ͷͪͺͪ
ͳ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͪ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ

ͳͷͪ
ͽͪ͵ͬͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͪͷͪ
Ͳͪ
ͼͰͫͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͫͳͽͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ

͋Ͱͷͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻ͹͸ͼ͵Ͱ
͵ͪͻͽͰ
ͼͪ
͹ͫͳΓͰͷ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶ͸ͳͷ

ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͰͷ
;
ͻͰͪͶ͸͹ͷ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸;
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ;Β;
΁ͰͶ;
ͺͶͪ͸Ͱͽ;
̀ͰͷΓ;
ͳ
ͼͬͰ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͳ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽ
ͼͬͪ͵ͳ
͵ͬͪͯͻͪͽ͸ͳ
ͷͰͽͪͻ
ͲͰ
ͷΓͰ
΃ͽͪͭ͹ͯ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ΔͰͷ;
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶ͹

̸̸͉͉̈́́͋̾͋͌

)BOECVDI
GVS
5PVSJTUFO
'ÛISFS
%VSDI
%BMNBUJFO
-ÅOHT
EFS
,ÛTUF
WPO
"MCB
OJFO
CJT
,PSGV
8JFO
VOE
-FJQ[JH
"
)BSUMFCFOT
7FSMBH

͆
͉ͪͯ͹Β΂ͳΕ
̻Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹
Ͳ͸ͪΔͰ
͹
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
͈͹ͼͰͫ͸ͪ
ͳͲͯͪ
Δͪ
͊ͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͪ
ͼͬ

̽ͻͱͪͬ͸ͪ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪͻͳΒͪ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ
͸Ͱ
͊ͻͫͪ
͎ͻͬͪͽͪ
ͳ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͪ΁ͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

)BOECVDI
GÛS
3FJTFOEF
7PO
,BSM
#BFEFLFS
7FSMBH
7PO
,BSM
#BFEFLFS

-FJQ[JH


+VHPTMBXJFO
.ÛOJDI
1PMZHMPUU7FSMBH

#BFEFLFS{T
"MMJBO[
3FJTFGÛISFS
(SJFDIFOMBOE
.JU
HSP“FS
3FJTFLBSUF
7FSMBH

,BSM
#BFEFLFS


 ̺Ͱͻ͵ͪ
͠͹ͬͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

7FSLB
+PWBOPWJǀ
3FJTFGÛISFS
VOE
EBSJO
WPSLPNNFOEF
-BOELBSUFO

%JF
5FDIOJL
EFS
"VTBSCFJUVOH
WPO
-BOELBSUFO
CMJFC
MBOHF
;FJU
XFJU

IJOUFS
2VBMJUÅUTUFYUFO
VOE
JMMVTUSBUJPOFO
JO
#ÛDIFSO
VOE
3FJTFGÛISFSO
[VSÛDL

*IS
*OIBMU
VOE
6NGBOH
FOUCFISUFO
WJFMFS
*OGPSNBUJPOFO
%JFTF
4DIMJDIUIFJU

XVSEF
EVSDI
EFUBJMMJFSUF
8FHCFTDISFJCVOHFO
VOE
[JFNMJDI
HSPCF
OJDIU
TFMUFO

VOÛCFSTJDIUMJDIF
;FJDIOVOHFO
BVTHFHMJDIFO


*N

+BISIVOEFSU
UBVDIUFO
WJFM
JOUFSFTTBOUFSF
-BOELBSUFO
BVG
EJF

3FJTFOEFO
[VHVUF
LBNFO
%JFTF
WFSGPMHUFO
)BVQUXFHF
VOE
XVSEFO
BMT

;FJDIOVOHFO
PEFS
5FJMF
EBWPO
IJO[VHFGÛHU
7PSIBOEFOTFJO
WPO
-BOELBSUFO

GÛS
3FJTFOEF
VOE
7PSBOLPNNFO
EFT
1FSTPOFOWFSLFIST
XVSEFO
JO
'SBOLSFJDI

VOE
JO
(SP“CSJUBOOJFO
WFS[FJDIOFU

.JU
EFS
;FJU
CFFJOGMVTTUFO
UFDIOJTDIF
'PSUTDISJUUF
CFTUJNNUF
5ÅUJHLFJUFO

JNNFS
JOUFOTJWFS
JOTCFTPOEFSF
KFOF
EJF
BVG
3FJTFO
5PVSJTNVT
#ÛDIFSBVTHBCF

OFVF
LBSUPHSBGJTDIF
3JDIUVOHFO
GÕSEFSOE
FJOXJSLFO

*N

+BISIVOEFSU
XVSEFO
LPOWFOUJPOFMMF
;FJDIFO
BVG
-BOELBSUFO

OJDIU
WFSÅOEFSU
OVS
XBSFO
'MVTTCFUUFO
0SUTOBNFO
VOE
MBHFO
XJF
BVDI
EJF

-BHF
WPO
-BOETUB“FO
#SÛDLFO
QPMJUJTDIFO
VOE
BENJOJTUSBUJWFO
(SFO[FO
BVG

KFEFS
-BOELBSUF
VOUFSTDIJFEMJDI
7FSFJOGBDIVOHFO
VOE
*OIBMUTXBIM
IÅOHFO

TFIS
PGU
NJU
EFS
QFSTÕOMJDIFO
4UFMMVOHOBINF
EFT
,BSUPHSBQIFO
[VTBNNFO

1PMJUJTDIUFSSJUPSJBMF
"CHSFO[VOHFO
CFXJSLUFO
&JOGÛHFO
[XJTDIFOTUBBUMJDIFS

(SFO[MJOJFO

#ÛDIFS
3FJTFGÛISFS
VOE
LBSUPHSBGJTDIF
8FSLF
TJOE
HSVOETÅU[MJDI

JOIBMUMJDI
WFSTDIJFEFOBSUJH
%BT
HMFJDIF
HJMU
BVDI
GÛS
UFDIOJTDIF
-ÕTVOHFO

VOE
GÛS
EJF
%SVDLRVBMJUÅU
7PO
FJOGBDIFO
TDIXBS[XFJ“FO
JOIBMUTBSNFO

4FJUFO
HFMBOHUF
NBO
[V
LPMPSJFSUFO
'PUPT
FSTULMBTTJHFS
2VBMJUÅU
LBSUPHSBGJTDI

QSÅ[JTFO
-BOELBSUFO
VOE
4UBEUQMÅOFO

%JF
CFTUFO
4UBEUQMÅOF
[FJHUFO
FJOF
EFUBJMMJFSUF
*OOFOTUSVLUVS
EFS

KFXFJMJHFO
4UBEU
FJOTDIMJF“MJDI
TPSHGÅMUJH
FJOHFUSBHFOFS
*OIBMUTWFSÅOEFSVOHFO

BO
4UBEUSÅOEFO
VOE
JO
FUXBT
BCHFMFHFOFO
7PSPSUFO
%JFTF
1MÅOF
XVSEFO
HFOBV

HF[FJDIOFU
JO
NBUIFNBUJTDI
QSÅ[JTFO
.B“TUÅCFO

%JF
[XFJUF
XJDIUJHF
$IBSBLUFSJTUJL
LBSUPHSBGJTDIFS
#FJUSÅHF
JO
EJFTFO

3FJTFGÛISFSO
CF[JFIU
TJDI
BVG
7FSÅOEFSVOHFO
JN
#FSFJDI
EFS
%SVDLUFDIOJL

EJF
&OEF
EFT

VOE
"OGBOH
EFT

+BISIVOEFSUT
IPIF
2VBMJUÅU
FSSFJDIUF

"OGBOH
EFT

+BISIVOEFSUT
XVSEFO
HSP“F
-BOELBSUFO
JO
%SVDLFSFJFO

WPSCFSFJUFU
VOE
HFESVDLU
EJF
XFOJHF
NFJTUFOT
XFJCMJDIF
"SCFJUTLSÅGUF

FJOTUFMMUFO
%FS
'BSCESVDL
XVSEF
[VS
3FHFM
ÛCFSXJFHFOE
CFTTFSFS
-FTCBSLFJU

 ̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͰ
͵ͪͻͽͰ 

VOE
HSՓFSFS
¾CFSTJDIUMJDILFJU
IBMCFS
"OGÅOHMJDI
XBSFO
EJFTF
-BOELBSUFO

JOIBMUMJDI
WFSFJOGBDIU
NJU
[JFNMJDI
BMMHFNFJOFO
%BUFO
WFSTFIFO
%JF

%SVDLUFDIOJL
HJOH
LPO[FQUVFMMFO
-ÕTVOHFO
[VS
&SIÕIVOH
EFS
%SVDLRVBMJUÅU

WPSBO

%BT

+BISIVOEFSU
VOE
EBT
OFVF
;FJUBMUFS
CSJOHFO
EBOO
OFVF

3JDIUVOHFO
JO
EFS
,BSUPHSBGJF
C[X
JO
EFS
(FTUBMUVOH
NPEFSOFS
-BOELBSUFO

VOE
4UBEUQMÅOF
"MT
%JT[JQMJO
WFSNBH
TJF
IFVU[VUBHF
3FJTFGÛISFS
NJU
FJHFOFO

.BUFSJBMJFO
JOIBMUMJDI
[V
EFTJHOJFSFO

5IFNBUJTDIF
-BOELBSUFO
JO
FMFLUSPOJTDIFS
"VTGÛISVOH
NJU
WJFMFO

%BUFO
VOE
BLUVFMMFO
*OIBMUFO
JO
SFFMMFS
;FJU
WFSTFIFO
[FJHFO
EJF
HFTBNUF

&SELVHFM
NJU
BMMFO
3FJTF[JFMFO
EI
KFEFO
2VBESBUNFUFS
EFS
0CFSGMÅDIF
NJU

BMMFO
EBSBVG
CFGJOEMJDIFO
0CKFLUFO

͇ͶͳͬͰͻͪ
̸̸͉̹̹̽͌
͍ͳͶ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
Ϳͪ͵;ͶͽͰͽ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

͇͉̽̾̽͆́͏̾

͇
͉͈͇͊͊̓ͅ
̾̀́̓͌͠

͌
͆̾̓́ͅ
̸͆̾͐̓́ͅͅ

̸̹͉̾̽̾̓̾́ͅ

͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͺͰ͵ͽͳ
ͫͻ͹΃;ͻͰ
ͳ
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳ

͹͸ͪͶ͸͹
ͼͶͳ΂͸ͪ
͵͹ͷͺͳͶͪ΁ͳΒͼ͵ͪ
͹ͼͽͬͪͻͰΔͪ
ͼͺͪͯͪΒ;
;
ͽͪ͵͹Ͳͬͪ͸Ͱ
;ͺ͹
ͽͻͰͫ͸Ͱ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͬͻͼͽͰ
͸Ͱͷ
(FCSBVDITUFYUTPSUFO

Ͳͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
͉͹ͶͿ

ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͬ͹ͯͰΕͳ΀
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ΀
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
Ͷͳ͸ͭͬͳͼͽͪ
ͯͪΒͰ
ͯͰͿͳ͸ͳ΁ͳ
Β;
ͬͳͼ͹͵͹ͭ
ͼͽͰͺͰ͸ͪ
͹ͺ΃ͽ͹ͼͽͳ
͇ͺ΃ͽͰ
;ͲͰͬ
Ͳͪ
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫ͸Ͱ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͰ

ͬͪͱͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
͹͵ͻͰ͸;ͽͳ
͵ͪ
ͻͰ΃ͪͬͪΔ;
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͪ
ͳ
ͽ͹
ͽͪ͵ͬ͹ͭ

ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͪ
ͳͶͳ
͸Ͱ͵͹ͭ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ

͵͹ΒͰͷ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ΒͰͲͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺͳ
ͽͳ
3PMG



̀ͪ
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫ͸Ͱ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͬͻͼͽͰ
ͬͪͱͳ
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͰ

ͺͻͪͬͳͶ͹
ͪ

ͺͻͰͯͷͰͽ
͵͹Βͳͷ
ͼͰ
͹ͬͳ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͳ
ͫͪͬͰ
͸ͳΒͰ
Ϳͳ͵΁ͳ͹͸ͪ
Ͷͪ͸
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ
͵͹ͯ
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸ͳ΀
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͭͪ
ͺͻ͹ͯ;
΁Ͱ͸ͽ
ͺ͹ͲͪΒͷΓ;ΒͰ
ͳͲ
ͻͰͪͶ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͫ

;
Δͳͷͪ
ͯ͹ͷͳ͸ͳͻͪ
͸ͪΒͷͪΔͰ
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ

͵͹ͷ;͸ͳ͵ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪ
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳΒͪ
ͺͻͰͷͯͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͫͳͽͳ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͶͳͿ;͸͵΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ
͸ͳ

͸ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;
΂Ͱͭͪ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͻͪͲͬͻͼͽͪͽͳ
;
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͰ
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ

͵ͪͽͰͭ͹ͻͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͺ;ͽ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͽͳͬ͸ͳ΀
ͪͺͰͶͪͽͳͬ͸ͳ΀
͹ͫͶͳͭͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͳ΀

͵͹͸ͽͪ͵ͽ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
ͯͰ͵Ͷͪͻͪͽͳͬ͸ͳ΀
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͪ
#SJOLFS


G

͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹

;
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͰ
ͷͪ͵ͻ͹ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͽͳͺ͹ͬͰ
m
ͯͰͼ͵ͻͳͺͽͳͬ



͉͹ͶͿ
ΒͰ
;
ͼͬ͹ͷ
͸ͪΒͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳΒͰͷ
ͻͪͯ;
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸͹ͷ
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫ͸ͳ΀

ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͬͻͼͽͪ
͸ͪͬͰ͹
͹͵͹

ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ΀
͸ͪͲͳͬͪ
Ͳͪ
͹ͬͰ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͰ
ͷͰͽ͹ͯ͹Ͷ͹
΃͵ͳ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͼͶ;ͱͳͬ΃ͳ
ͺͻͰͬͪͼ΀͹ͯ͸͹
ͽͪ͵ͼ͹͸͹ͷͳΒ͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ΂͵ͳ΀
΂ͳ͸͹ͬͪ
͊ͰͻͶͪ
ͳ
͇ͼͽͳ
͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
̹ͻͳ͸͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ͹ͷ
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͷ
ͽͳͺ͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒ͹ͷ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͪ



͈ͻͰͬ͹ͯͳ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͳ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳ΀
΁ͳͽͪͽͪ
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
m
͇
̽

 ͇ͶͳͬͰͻͪ
̽;ͻͫͪͫͪ

͸Ͱ
͸ͪͻͪͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
Ͱ͵ͼͺ͹Ͳͳͽ͹ͻ͸Ͱ
ͪͻͭ;ͷͰ͸ͽͪͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;͵ͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
8FS

MJDI


͌
ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;
ͼͪ
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺͽ;ͪͶ͸͹
ͺͻͳͷͪͻ͸ͳͷ
΁ͳΓͰͷ
m
ͺͻ;ͱͪ
ΔͰͷ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͺ͹ͽͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͶ͸ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͹
͸ͪΒͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳΒͳͷ

ͯͪͽ͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹

͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͰ
ͳͶͳ
͸Ͱͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹ͯͰͶͳͷͳ΂
͸͹

ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸Ͱ
m
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͳͶͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
;
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͪͶ
͸͹Ͷͳ͸ͭͬͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯ;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͪ;ͽ͹͸͹ͷ͸;
ͳ
͵͹΀ͰͻͰ͸ͽ͸;

ͬͰͶͳ΂ͳ͸;
͵͹Βͪ
ͺ͹
ͺͻͪͬͳͶ;
͹ͫ;΀ͬͪͽͪ
ͬͰΕͳ
ͫͻ͹Β
ͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵ͳ΀
΁ͰͶͳ͸ͪ

ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸ͳ΀
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳͷ
ͪͼͺͰ͵ͽͳͷͪ
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͻͰͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳ
Βͳ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͳ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΁ͳ
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͸ͪ;΁ͳ
͌
ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;

ͼͪ
͹ͬͪ͵ͬ͹ͷ
ͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵͹ͷ
ͻͪͲ͸͹ͻ͹ͯ͸͹΃Ε;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
;
ͯͬ͹
ͼͽͻ;͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯ;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͯͳͼ΁ͳͺͶͳ͸ͪͻ͸ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯ
͵ͪ͹

͵͹͸ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ
͸ͪͼͽͪ͹
ͳͲ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ΀
ͰͺͳͼͽͰͷ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ΀
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͪ
͹͸
ͳͼͽ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;Εͳ
ͺͻͰͯͷͰͽ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͳ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷͪΔͪ

ͬͰͶͳ͵͹ͭ
ͫͻ͹Βͪ
͸ͪ;͵ͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
Ͱͽ͸͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͰ
ͳ
Ͱͽ͸͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ

ͪ͸ͽͻ͹ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͰ
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͰ
ͼ͹΁ͳ͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͰ
ͿͳͶ͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͰ
ͳͽͯ

̓ͪ͹
ͺͻͰͯͷͰͽ
ͺͻ͹;΂ͪͬͪΔͪ
Ͷͳ͸ͭͬͳͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͰͬͪͼ΀͹ͯ͸͹
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͪͶ
͸Ͱ
Ͷͳ͸ͭͬͳͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
ͯͳͼ΁ͳͺͶͳ͸Ͱ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
ͫͪͬͳ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͷ
͵ͪ͹
͸ͪΒͷͪΔ͹ͷ

Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͰΔͼ͵͹ͷ
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͪͶ͸͹ͷ
ͳͶͳ
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͷ
΁ͰͶͳ͸͹ͷ
ͽ;ͻͳ
ͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
;
͸ͪ΃͹Β
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
;
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹ͼͽͳ
Ͳͪ͸Ͱͷͪ
ͻͰ͸;
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͪͶ͸;
ͬͻͼͽ;
͊
͹ͫͲͳͻ͹ͷ
͸ͪ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ;
ͻͰͶͪͽͳͬ͸͹
͹ͼ͵;ͯ͸;

ͺͻ͹ͯ;͵΁ͳΒ;
͸ͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
͹ͬͪ
ΒͰ
͹͵͹Ͷ͸͹ͼͽ
Ͳͪͺͻͪͬ͹
ͳ
͹΂Ͱ͵ͳͬͪ
͸ͪ
̽ͪ
ΒͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
͸ͪ;΂͸͹
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͰ
Ͷͳ͸ͭͬͳͼͽͪ
Ͳͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂Ͱ
ͳ
͸ͪ

͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͷ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Β;
͸Ͱͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͳͲͻͪͱͰ͸͹
W
8JFSMBDIFS



G

΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ΒͰ
͵͹Βͪ
;ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
΂;ͯͳ
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ

ͳ
ͳ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳͷ
ͭͰͻͷͪ͸ͳͼͽͳͷͪ
͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
;
ͯͳΒͪ΀ͻ͹͸͹Β
ͬͰΕ
ͳ
;
ͼͳ͸΀ͻ͹
͸͹Β
ͺͰͻͼͺͰ͵ͽͳͬͳ
͸;ͯͳ
͹ͫͳΓͰ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͪ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ΒͰ
;

ͬͻͰͷͰ
͸ͰͼͶ;ΕͰ͸Ͱ
Ͱ͵ͼͺͪ͸ͲͳΒͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
ͳ
ͯ͹ͼͪͯ
͸ͰͲͪͫͰͶͰͱͰ͸͹ͭ
ͼͽͰͺͰ
͸ͪ
ͷ͹ͫͳͶ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽͰ
ͺͻͰͺͶͪͬΓͰ͸͹
ͼͺͰ΁ͳΒͪͶͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͳͷ

ͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͽͳͱ;
ͳ
;
͸ͪΒ;ͯͪΓͰ͸ͳ
ΒͰ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͰ
ͼͬͰͽͪ



̾ͭͲͰͷͺͶͪͻ͸͹
ΕͰͷ͹
͹ͬͯͰ
͸ͪͬͰͼͽͳ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ΀
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂͵ͳ΀
͵;
Εͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͫͪͬͰ
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͬͻͼͽ͹ͷ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͰ
,MFUU
7FSMBH
4UVUUHBSU
͵͹Βͪ
;
ͼͬ͹Β͹Β
ͺ͹͸;ͯͳ

ͳͷͪ
΂ͳͽͪͬ;
ͼͰͻͳΒ;
ͼͺͰ΁ͳΒͪͶͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ
ͫͻ͹Β
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ΒͰͲͳ
͵ͪ
ͯͰͿͳ͸ͳͼͪ͸ͳ΀
͵ͪ͹
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͻͰ΂͸ͳ͵
ͳ
ΒͰͲͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
3FJTFXÕSUFSCVDI
VOE

4QSBDIGÛISFS
NJU
JOUFSLVMUVSFMMFO
5JQQT

͇͸ͳ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
͸ͪ
̾͸ͭͶͰͼ͵;
ͳ
̸͊̽
͍ͻͪ͸΁;
ͼ͵;
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒ;
́ͽͪͶͳΒ;
͉;ͼͳΒ;
͆Ͱͷͪ΂͵;
̓ͳ͸;
̽ͪ͸ͼ͵;
̻ͻ΂͵;
ͪ͠ͺͪ͸
͎͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͳΒ;

͈͹Γͼ͵;
͈͹ͻͽ;ͭͪͶͳΒ;
͐Ͱ΃͵;
͋;ͻͼ͵;
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵;
̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵;
͆͹ͻͬͰ΃͵;
ͳ
ͪͅΌͪͻ
ͼ͵;
͈͹ͻͰͯ
͹ͬ͹ͭͪ
ͳͼͽͳ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂
͸;ͯͳ
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͲͳ͵Ͱ
ͯͪͽͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
ͻͰ΂͸ͳ͵Ͱ
͸ͪΒͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͳ΀

ͻͰ΂ͳ
ͳ
ͳͲͻͪͲͪ
ͼͪ
Ϳ͹͸Ͱͽͼ͵ͳͷ
ͳͲͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͲͳͬ͹ͷ
-BTU
.JOVUF
4QSBDIGÛISFS

 ͇ͯͻͰͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͹
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
;
͸Ͱ͵ͳͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ 

͌
ͺ͹͵;΃ͪΒ;
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͼ͵ͻͰ͸Ͱ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
͸ͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵ͰͻͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͷ͹
ͭ;Εͳ
ͺͻͰͯͷͰͽ
Ͷͳ͸ͭͬͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;͵ͪͱͰ
͸ͪ

ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͼͽͪ͸ͯͪͻͯ͸ͳ΀
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͪ
ͫ͹ΓͰ
͹ͺͻͰͷΓͰ͸ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͻͪͯ;

͸;ͯͳͷ͹
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ
͹ͯͻͰͯ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͹
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͷͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹ͷͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻ
ͬͪͽͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
;
͸Ͱ͵ͳͷ
ͳͼ΁ͻͺ͸ͳΒͳͷ
ͳͶͳ
ͺ͹ͺ;Ͷͪͻ͸ͳΒͳͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ

ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͫͪͬͰ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
͸ͪ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͹ͬͳͷ
ΒͰͲͳ
͵͹ͷ
͌
ͱͰΓͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͳ
ͽ͹ͷ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͱ;
ͳ
ͰͬͰ͸ͽ;ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
Ϳ͹͵;ͼͪ

ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͺͳͼͪ΁ͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͲͳ͵
͵͹Βͳ
͹ͺͳͼ;Β;
Ͳͪ
ͺͻͰͯͷͰͽ
ͻͪ
ͯͪ
;ͲͰͽͳ
ͼ;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵ͪ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͳ
͹͸ͳ
ͳͲ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͳ΀
ͯͰ΁Ͱ
͸ͳΒͪ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
̽ͪ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͳ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͪ΂͸ͳ΀
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
;΂ͳ͸ͳͶͳ
ͫͪ
ͻͰͷ
ͯͰͶͳͷͳ΂͸͹
;ͺ͹ͻͰͯͳͬͳͷ
;
ͻͪͯ;
ΕͰ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽͪ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰͽͳ
ͽͳ
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͳͷ
ͪͼͺͰ͵ͽͳͷͪ
͸ͪͲͳͬ;
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ;
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͬͪͻͳΒͰͽͰͽͳͷͪ

ͪͶͿͪͫͰͽͼ͵ͳͷ
ͳ

ͯͳΒͪͶͰ͵ͪͽͼ͵ͳͷ

͹ͺͳͼͪ͸ͳͷ
ΒͰͲͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͪͷͪ

ͳ
ͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵ͳͷ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
͹ͫ;΀ͬͪΕͰ͸ͳͷ
ͭͶ͹ͼͪͻ͹ͷ

͈ͻͰͭͶͰͯ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͸ͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
ͼͪ
͹ͯͻͰͯ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸ͳͷ

ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͷ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹ͷͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;

ͅͰͼͽ͹
̻͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

̸;ͽ͹ͻ ͆ͪͲͳͬ ́Ͳͯͪͬͪ΂
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
*MMVTUSJFSUFS

"
)BSUMFCFOT

"
)BSUMFCFO 'ÛISFS
EVSDI
#Fǁ-BKQDJH 

7FSMBH
%BMNBUJFO
*MMVTUSJFSUFS

7PMLTXJSUTDIB
)
5BVC 'ÛISFS
EVSDI
$JSJI


GUMJDIFS
7FSMBH
+VHPTMBXJFO

1PMZHMPUU
+VHPTMBXJFO 1PMZHMPUU
7FSMBH .JOIFO 

3FJTFGÛISFS
+VHPTMBXJFO
VOE

#BFEFLFST
#BFEFLFST

(SJFDIFOMBOE

"VUP "VUPGÛISFS »UVUHBSU 

NJU
FVSPQÅJTDIFS

SFJTFGÛISFS 7FSMBH
5ÛSLFJ
#BFEFLFST
"MMJ »UVUHBSU
+VHPTMBXJFO #BFEFLFS


BO[
3FJTFGÛISFS 'SBKCVSH



͌
ͺ͹ͯ͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ;
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹͸Ͱ͵ͶͰ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ͵;Β;
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͪͶ͸Ͱ
͹ͫͶͪ
ͼͽͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ;Β;
ͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹ͫ;΀ͬͪͽͪΒ;
ͬͰΕͳ
ͯͰ͹
ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
Βͪͯͻͪ͸
ͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͫͪͶͰ
ͳ
͠͹͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͻͳͷ͹ͻΒͪ
m
͹ͯ
͇ͺͪͽͳΒͰ
ͳ
̈́͹΃ͳΔͪ
ͯ;ͱ
ͪͶͫͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͫͪͶͰ
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹

̓ͻͿͪ
ͳ
͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
;
Β͹͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͷ͹ͻ;
*MMVTUSJFSUFS
'ÛISFS
EVDI
%BMNBUJFO
OFCTU
"CCB[JB

VOE
-VTTJO

MÅOHTU
EFS
,ÛTUF
WPO
"MCBOJFO
CJT
,PSGV
VOE
OBDI
EFO
JPOJTDIFO
*OTFMO




͇ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸
;
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͳ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰΔͰ͸͹
ͳͷͰ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
͸ͪ
͵͹Β;
ͼͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳ

͹ͬͪΒ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
;
ͺ͹ͯ͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ;
ͺ͹ͯͼͰΕͪ
͸ͪ
ΔͰ͸
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸ͳ
͸ͪͲͳͬ
,ÕOJHSFJDI
EFS
4FSCFO

,S͹BUFO
VOE
4MPXFOFO

 ͇ͶͳͬͰͻͪ
̽;ͻͫͪͫͪ

͎ͪͻͽͶͰͫͰ͸͹ͬ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;
͹ͯͰΓ͵;
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͲͳͬ͹ͷ

t4QSBDIMJDIF
#FIFMGFi
ͯ͹͸͹ͼͳ
ͼͰͷͪͼͳ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
΂Ͱͽͬ͹ͻ͹ΒͰͲͳ΂͸ͳ
ͭͶ͹
ͼͪͻ
;ͻͰΌͰ͸
ͺ͹
ͪͶͿͪͫͰͽͼ͵͹ͷ
ͻͰͯ͹ͼͶͰͯ;
ͼ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵͹ͷ
͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹
ͶͪͲ͸ͳͷ
͵͹Βͳ
͹ͫ;΀ͬͪͽͪ
ͳͽͪͶͳΒͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ 
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͳ
4FSCPLSP
BUJTDI

ͳ
ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͪ΂͵ͳ
ͯͰ͹
ͅͰΌ;
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͳͷ
ͶͰ͵ͼͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ΒͰͯͳ
͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͺͻͰ͹ͬͶͪΌ;Β;
͹͸Ͱ
ΒͰ͵ͪͬͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ
ͳΒͰ͵ͪͬͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳͲͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͪ
̿ͳͬͳ͹

ͱͰΓͰͲ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͼͬͳΒͰΕͪ

͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
ͻͰΌͰ
ͼͰ
ΒͪͬΓͪ
ͳ
ͪͶͽͰͻ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ͵ͪͬͼ͵͹
Ͱ͵ͪͬͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳͲͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͪ
ͫΒͰͶͫͰ͹
ͷΓͰ͵͹ͷͶͰ͵͹

;
ͳͲͬͰͼ͸ͳͷ
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒͰͬͳͷͪ

ͯ͹ͶͪͲͳ
ͯ͹
΀ͳͺͰͻͭͰ͸ͰͻͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
͸ͪͬ͹ΌͰΔͪ
ͺ͹ͭͻͰ΃͸͹ͭ
ͻͰͿͶͰ͵ͼͪ

ͼͽͪͻ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͭͶͪͼͪ
Βͪͽ
[EJKFMB
WJKFUBS

͑ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͳͲͫ͹ͻͪ
ͶͰ͵ͼͳ
͵Ͱ
ͽͳ΂Ͱ
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͭͶ͹ͼͪͻ;
ͲͪͺͪͱͪΒ;
ͼͰ
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͰ
ͬͪͻͳΒͪ͸ͽͰ
͸ͪͬ͹ΌͰΔͪ

ͪ

ͼͪͷ͹
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͪ
ͬͪͻͳΒͪ͸ͽͪ
͹ͼͽͻͬ͹
;Ͷͳ΁ͪ
΀ͶͰͫ

ͫ

ͼͪͷ͹
΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͪ

ͬͪͻͳΒͪ͸ͽͪ
ͱͶͳ΁ͪ
ͼ͹Ͷ
͹΁ͪͽ
͵ͪͬͪ

΁

͹ͫͰ
ͶͰ͵ͼͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͬͪͻͳΒͪ͸ͽͰ
΂ͪ͵
΃ͳͻͰ
΀Ͷͪ΂Ͱ

ͯ

͹ͫͰ
ͳͲͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ͸Ͱ
ͬͪͻͳΒͪ͸ͽͰ
ͯΒͰͬ͹Β͵ͪͯͰͬ͹Β͵ͪ
ͶͳΒͰ
ͬ͹ͶͰͬ͹
ͬͻͳΒͰͷͰͬͻͰͷͰ

͈͹ͻͰͯ
ͼͽͪ͸ͯͪͻͯ͸ͳ΀
ͶͰ͵ͼͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ΁ͪ
;

ͭͶ͹ͼͪͻ;
ͼͰ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͳ
͸Ͱͼͽͪ͸ͯͪͻͯ͸ͪ
ͶͰ͵ͼͳ͵ͪ
ͳͽͪͶͳΒͪ͸ͳͲͷͳ
͵ͪͻ;΁Ͱ


ͽ;ͻ΁ͳͲͷͳ
Βͪͺ;͸ΘͰ

͹ͭͻͽͪ΂

Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͲͷͳ
ͷͪͼͪ͵

ͷͪͲͭͪ
͸͹ͱͳ΁Ͱ


ͷͪ͵ͪͲͰ


͈͹ͻͰͯ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸ͳ΀
͹ͼ͹ͫͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͹ͬͪΒ
ͭͶ͹ͼͪͻ
ΒͰ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂ͪ͸
ͺ͹

ͻͰͯ;͵΁ͳΒͳ
ͶͰ͵ͼͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂͸͹
ͳͼ͵Γ;΂ͳͬ͹
͸ͪ
ͳͷͰ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͬͻͼͽͰ
ͻͰ΂ͳ

m
ͳͷͰ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
;͵Γ;΂;Β;Εͳ
ͳ
ͭͶͪͭ͹Ͷͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͷͰ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͼͺͪͬͪΔͰ

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ

ͺͻͳͯͰͬͰ
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͭͰ
ͫͻ͹ΒͰͬͰ
m
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͺ͹
͵͹͸ͼͰ͵ͬͰ͸ͽ
͸͹ͷ
ͳͲ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΔ;
ͭͶͪͭ͹Ͷͪ
͋Ͱͷͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
Ͳͪͼͽ;ͺΓͰ͸Ͱ
;
ͭͶ͹ͼͪͻ;

͹ͫ;΀ͬͪͽͪΒ;
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͰ
ͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͰ
Ͳͪ
ͯ͹ͷͪΕͳ͸ͼͽͬ͹
͵ͻͰͬͰͽ
ͬͳΓ;΃͵ͪ


ͭͻͪΌͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;΁ͳΒͰ
΁ͻ͵ͬͪ
͵ͻ΂ͷͪ

ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ΒͪͬͰ
͵ͳ΃ͪ
ͫͻ
ͯ͹
΃;ͷͪ

ͯͰͶ͹ͬͰ
ͽͰͶͪ
͹͵͹
;ͼͽͪ

ͱͳͬ͹ͽͳΔͰ
͵͹Δ

΀ͻͪ͸;
ͽͰͶͰͽͳ
͸ͪ

Ͳͪ͸ͳͷͪΔͪ
ͼͶ;΃͵ͳΔͪ


̓͹͸ͪ΂͸͹
;
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹ͷ
ͭͶ͹ͼͪͻ;
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͼͰ
͵͹͸ͼͽͪͽ͹ͬͪͽͳ
ͳ
ͳͲͬͰ
ͼ͸Ͱ
ͳͲͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͺͳͼ͸Ͱ
ͳͶͳ
ͷ͹ͻͿ͹Ͷ͹΃͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͭͻͰ΃͵Ͱ
΂ͳΒͳ
ͼͰ

;Ͳͻ͹͵
ͺͻͰͽͰͱ͸͹
ͷ͹ͱͰ
Ͷ͹΁ͳͻͪͽͳ
;
͸ͰͳͲͬͻ΃Ͱ͸ͳͷ
ͭͶͪͼ͹ͬ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ
͸ͪͷͪ
ͳͶͳ
͸Ͱͺ͹΃ͽ͹ͬͪΔ;
ͷ͹ͻͿ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ΀
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽͪ͵ͪ
ͽͰͱ͵͹
ͺͰͽͯͰ
ͼͰͽ
͹ͺͪ͸͵Ͱ



͌
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒͰͬͳͷͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͪ
ͯͳΒͪͶͰ͵ͪͽͼ͵͹ͭ
͹ͯͼͽ;ͺͪΔͪ
;
ͭͶ͹ͼͪͻ;
ͼͰ
͹ͼͳͷ
͸Ͱ;
ͽͻͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͪ͸ͯͪͻͯ͸Ͱ
ͶͰ͵ͼͰͷͰ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͳ
ͽͻ΃Εͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͬͰ͸Ͱ΁ͳΒͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͬͪͻͳΒͪ͸ͽͪ



́͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ͸͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
;
͹ͯͰΓ͵;
͹
ͭͻ΂͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
ͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵Ͱ

͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
͹͸͹ͷͪͼͳ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
΀ͳΒͰͻͪͻ΀ͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸Ͱ



͌
ͳͲͬͰͼ͸ͳͷ
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒͰͬͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͰ΃͵͹
ͳͶͳ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
͸Ͱͷ͹ͭ;ΕͰ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂ͳͽͳ
ͯͪ
Ͷͳ

ͼͰ
͵͹͸ͼͽͪͽ͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
ͭͻͰ΃͵ͪ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͬͰͼͽͳ
͸ͪ
͸Ͱͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸;
ΒͰͲͳ΂͵;
͵͹ͷͺͰͽͰ͸΁ͳΒ;
ͳͶͳ
ΒͰ

ͺͻ͹;Ͳͻ͹͵͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
͹ͫͳ΂͸͹ͷ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪͻͼ͵͹ͷ
ͭͻͰ΃͵͹ͷ

 ͇ͯͻͰͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͹
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
;
͸Ͱ͵ͳͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ 

͇ͼͳͷ
͹ͬͯͰ
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸͹ͭ
ͭͶ͹ͼͪͻͪ
͹ͬͪΒ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ
͸Ͱ
ͯ͹͸͹ͼͳ
͸ͳ͵ͪ͵ͬͰ

ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
͸ͪͲͬͪ͸͹ͷ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͳͷ

͋ͪ;ͫ͹ͬ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸;ͯͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
͹ͺ΃ͳͻ͸ͳΒͰ

ͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͭͶͪͬΓͰ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸͹
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
ͺ͹ͯ

͸ͪͲͳͬ͹ͷ
,MFJOFS

4QSBDIGÛISFS
ͪͅͶͳ
ΒͰͲͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂

͵͹ΒͰ
͹ͫ;΀ͬͪͽͪ
΂ͳͽͪͬͳ΀
ͺͰͽ
ͼͽͻͪ
͸ͪ

ͼͽͻ

͠ͰͲͳ͵
ͼͰ
͹ͬͯͰ
͸ͪͲͳͬͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͳͶͳ
΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͳ
tͭͻͪ͸ͪ

ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ
ͺ͹
Ͳͬ;͵;
ͺ͹ͯͼͰΕͪ
͸ͪ
ͳͽͪͶͳΒͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͼͳ΁

͈͹
ͻͪͼ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽͻͪΔͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͹͸
͹ͫ;΀ͬͪͽͪ
͸ͪΒͬͰΕͳ
ͯͰ͹
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͹ͼͳͷ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͰ

ͭͯͰ
ͼͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
tͯͳΒͪͶͰ͵ͽ
ͳͼͽͰ
ΒͰͲͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͭͻ;ͺͰi

̸;ͽ͹ͻ
͵͹͸ͼͽͪͽ;ΒͰ
ͺ͹
ͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͰ
ͯͬͪΒ;
ͺͳͼͪͷͪ
Ͷͪͽͳ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
;
ͺͻͳͷ͹ͻΒ;
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͳ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹Β

ͻͰͿ͹ͻͷͳͼͪ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͪͻ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ΕͳͻͳͶͳ΁Ͱ
͵͹Β;
ͷͳͷ͹
ͼͽͪ͸ͯͪͻͯͪ

ͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸͹
;
ͱͰΓͳ
ͯͪ
ͯͪͽ͹ͷ
ͭͻͪͿͳΒ͹ͷ
ͺͻͰͯ͹΂ͳ
ͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͳͲͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͪ

͸ͪͲͳͬͪ
$ZSJMJDB

;
ͼͰͬͰͻ͸͹Β
ͳ
Β;ͱ͸͹Β
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
̺͹Βͬ͹ͯͳ͸ͳ
͏ͻ͸͹Β
̻͹
ͻͳ
͉ͪͬ͸͹ͺͻͪͬ͸͹
͵͹ͻͳ΃ΕͰΔͰ
͹ͫͪ
ͺͳͼͷͪ
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ͵;ΒͰ
ͼͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ

͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
;
̹͹ͼ͸ͳ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
͊Ͷͪͬ͹͸ͳΒͳ
͊ͻͰͷ;
͈͹
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͷͳ
΃ΓͰΔ;
ΕͳͻͳͶͳ΁ͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͳͯͰͪͶ͸͹
ͺͳͼͷ͹
ͺ͹΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
;
Δ͹Β
ΒͰͯͪ͸

ͭͶͪͼ
ͳͲͻͪͱͰ͸
ΒͰͯ͸ͳͷ
ͼͶ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺͻͳ͸΁ͳͺ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ

ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͷ
ͯͰͶ͹ͷ
Ͳͪ΀ͬͪͽͳ͹
ͳ
Ͷͪͽͳ͸ͳ΁;

͌
͹ͬ͹ͷ
͹ͯͰΓ͵;
ͼͰ
ͯͪΓͰ
͵͹͸
ͼͽͪͽ;ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͰ
Ͱ͵ͪͬͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳΒͰ͵ͪͬͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ
ͳ͵ͪͬͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯͳΒͪͶͰ͵ͽͪ
ͽͰ
ͫ͹ͻ
ͫͰ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻͰͬͶͪͼͽ
;
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
ͺͻͬͪ
ͯͬͪ

̸;ͽ͹ͻ
ΒͰ
ͳͲͻͳ΂ͳͽ
;
ͼͽͪͬ;
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ
͸Ͱͼ͵ͻͳͬͰ͸ͪ
ͽͰ͸ͯͰ͸΁ͳΒͪ
ͺ͹ͽͳ
ͼ͵ͳͬͪΔͪ
tͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͶͰͺͰ
ͳ
ͷͳͶ͹Ͳͬ;΂͸Ͱ
ͪͶͳ
͵͹ͷͺͶͳ͵͹ͬͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͳΒͰ͵ͪͬͳ΁Ͱi

;
͵͹ͻͳͼͽ
tͶͪ͵΃Ͱ
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͪͬ͸ͳΒͰ
Ͱ͵ͪͬͳ΁Ͱi
͑ͽ͹
ͼͰ

ͪͻͰͪͶͪ
ͻͪͼͺͻ͹ͼͽͪΔͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͽͳ΂Ͱ
͹ͬͯͰ
ͼͰ
͵͹͸ͼͽͪͽ;ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͳΒͰ͵ͪͬͳ΁ͪ

;
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸͹Β
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͳ
;
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹Β
ͺͻͰͷͯͪ
ͳ
͹ͬͯͰ
;Ͳ
͹ͭͻͪͯ;
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;

ͼͪͷ͹ͷ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ;
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳ
Ͱ͵ͪͬͳ΁ͪ

͵ͪ͹
ͳ
;
͏ͻ͸͹Β
̻͹ͻͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ

ͳ
Β;ͱ͸͹Β
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
͹Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪͬͪΒ;
͵ͪ͹
͵͹ͶͰͬ͵Ͱ
ͳΒͰ͵ͪͬͳ΁Ͱ
ͷͪΔͰ

ΒͰ
ͳͼ͵Γ;΂ͳͬͪ
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͪ
;
̹͹ͼ͸ͳ
͊Ͷͪͬ͹͸ͳΒͳ
ͳ
ͼͰͬͰͻ͸͹Β
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͳ

̓ͪ͵͹
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
ͯͪΓͰ
ͼͪ͹ͺ΃ͽͪͬͪ
;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͳ
̺͹Βͬ͹ͯͳ͸ͳ
;
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸͹Β
;ͺ͹
ͽͻͰͫͳ
ͺͻͰ͹ͬͶͪΌ;ΒͰ
Ͱ͵ͪͬͳ΁ͪ
ͳͪ͵͹
͸ͰͭͯͰ
ͳͷͪ
ͳ
͸ͪΒ΂ͳͼͽͳΒͰ
ͳΒͰ͵ͪͬͳ΁Ͱ


̀ͪ
ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͪ΂͵ͳ
ΒͰͲͳ͵
͹ͬͯͰ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͻͪͲͬͳ͹
ͳͲ
Ͱ͵ͪͬͳ΁Ͱ
ͽͰ
ͯͪ
ͭͪ

͵ͪ͹
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸ͳ
ΒͰͲͳ͵
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͷͳͶͳ͹͸
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ

͌
͸ͪͼͽͪͬ͵;
͹ͬͰ
ͻͪͼͺͻͪͬͰ
"CIBOEMVOH

͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͼͪͷ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
͸ͪͲͳ
ͬͪ
ͫͰͲ
ͺͻͰͽͰ͸ͲͳΒͪ
ͯͪ
ͲͪͶͪͲͳ
;
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
͵ͪ͵͹
͵ͪͱͰ
ͳͲͻͪͲͳͽ͹



̽ͪͽͳ
͵͹͸ͽͰ͵ͼͽ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͱͰ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳͲͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͪ
;ͼͶ͹
ͬΓͰ͸Ͱ
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫ͹ͷ
ͯͳΒͪ͵ͻͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
Ͳ͸ͪ͵͹ͬͪ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ǀ
͹Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪͬͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͳͻ͹͵͹
ͪ
ǁ
͵ͪ͹

͹΃ͽͻ͹
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹
UTDI
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ͵͹
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
Eß
͸ͪͲͳͬͪ
΃ͳͻ͹͵ͳͷ
ͪ
Dž
͹΃ͽͻͳͷ
ETDI



͇ͬͯͰ
͸Ͱͯ͹ͼͽͪΒ;
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
ͪͶͽͰͻ͸ͪͽͳͬ͸͹Β
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͳ
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͪ

 ͇ͶͳͬͰͻͪ
̽;ͻͫͪͫͪ

͵͹ͷͺͶͳ͵͹ͬͪ͸͹ͭ
ͭͻͪͷͪͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͼͳͼͽͰͷͪ 
͋ͪ;ͫ
͸;ͯͳ
͵ͻͪͽͪ͵
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ

͸Ͱ͵ͳ΀
ͷ͹ͻͿ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ΀
͵ͪͽͰͭ͹ͻͳΒͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͻ͹ͯ
ͳͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͺͻͳͯͰͬ
ͼ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͲͪͷͰ͸ͳ΂͵ͪ
ͯͰ͵Ͷͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͷ͸͹ͱͳ͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͯͰͬͪ
͹ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
Ͷͳ΂͸ͳ΀
Ͳͪ
ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
ͻͰͯ͸ͳ΀
ͫͻ͹ΒͰͬͪ
̽ͰͿͳ͸ͳ΃;Εͳ
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
͹ͯ
Δͳ΀
͹͸

͸Ͱͯͬ͹ͼͷͳͼͶͰ͸͹
ͺͻͳͷͰΔ;ΒͰ
͵͹͸ͽͻͪͼͽͳͬ͸ͳ
ͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͭ

͵͹͸ͼͽͪͽ;Β;Εͳ
͸Ͱͯ͹ͼͽͪͽͪ͵
΂Ͷͪ͸ͪ
͵ͪͽͰͭ͹ͻͳΒͰ
͵͹Β;
ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ΒͰͲͳ΁ͳ

Ͳͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;
͹ͯ
ͭͰͻͷͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
͸ͳ
͸Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒ;

̽ͪͽͪ
͹ͫΒͪ΃ΔͰΔͪ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ

ͼ;
΃ͽ;ͻͪ
ͫ;ͯ;Εͳ
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹
ͳͲ͹Ͷ͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
͹ͼͽͪͽ͵ͪ
ͼͳͼͽͰͷͪ
͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͭ;

ͺ͹ͼͶ;ͱͳͽͳ
͸ͳ
Ͳͪ
͵ͪ͵ͬ;
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂͸;
ͺͻͳͷͰ͸;


̀ͪ
ͭͻͪͷͪͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ͹ͷ
ͼͶͰͯͳ
ͼͺͳͼͪ͵
͹ͯ
ͼͰͯͪͷ
ͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵ͳ΀

΁ͰͶͳ͸ͪ
;
͹͵ͬͳͻ;
͵͹Βͳ΀
ͼ;
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸Ͱ
ͿͻͪͲͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͫͳ
ͺ͹
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ͹ͬ͹ͷ
͹΂Ͱ
͵ͳͬͪΔ;
ͷ͹ͭͶͰ
ͫͳͽͳ
͹ͯ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
;
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸;
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳ
Β;
͉Ͱ΂
ΒͰ
͹
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳͷͪ
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͲͳͬ͹ͷ
͆ͪ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͌
ͺ͹΃ͽͳ
͆ͪ
͵;ͺͪ
Δ;
ͳ
͵͹ͯ
ͿͻͳͲͰͻͪ
̓;ͺ͹ͬͳ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͺͻͪͬ͵ͪ
͉ͪ΂;͸ͪΔͰ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
͎͹ͽͰͶ

ͻͰͼͽ͹ͻͪ͸
͇ͺ΃ͽͳ
ͳͲͻͪͲͳ


ͅͰΌ;
͹ͬͳͷ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬͳͷ
͵͹͸ͼͽͻ;͵΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͼ;
ͳ
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
Βͪ
ͬΓͪΒ;
ͳͲͬͰͼ͸Ͱ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͶͳ͸ͭͬͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͭͻͰ΃͵Ͱ
m
͹͸Ͱ
͸ͪͺͻͪͬΓͰΔͰ
ͺ͹ͯ
;ͽͳ
΁ͪΒͰͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ
ͻͰΌͰ
ͳ
͹͸Ͱ
ͳ͸ͽͻͪͶͳ͸ͭͬͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͰ
͵͹ͯ

͵͹Βͳ΀
ͯ͹
ͭͻͰ΃͵Ͱ
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͳ
;ͼͶͰͯ
͸Ͱͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸Ͱ
͵͹ͷͺͰͽͰ͸΁ͳΒͰ
;
΁ͳΓ͸͹ͷ

ΒͰͲͳ͵;

m
͑ͽͪ
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͰͽͰ
ͺ͹ͭͻͰ΃͸ͪ
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͭͶͪͭ͹Ͷͼ͵͹ͭ
ͪͼͺͰ͵ͽͪ 

ͺ͹ͭͻͰ΃͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͯͳ͵ͪͽͼ͵ͪ
͵͹Ͷ͹͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪ

m
͑ͽͪ
ͼͽͪΒͰ
͵͹΃ͽͪ

ΒͰͯ͸͹
ͺͳͼͷ͹
͵ͪͻͽͪ

Ͳͪ
ͳ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͼͽͬ͹

ͺ͹ͭͻͰ΃͸ͪ
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͪ
;ͺͳͽ͸͹ͭ
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͭͪ
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͫͻ͹Βͪ
͵ͪ͹
͵͹ͷͺͰ͸
Ͳͪ΁ͳΒͰ
Ͳͪ
͸Ͱͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͰΕͳ
΂Ͷͪ͸


m
ͅ͹ͭ;
͹ͯͪͬͯͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͽͳ
ͼͪ
̹
ͳͲ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͰ
;ͺͳͽ͸Ͱ
ͺͪͻͽͳ͵;
ͶͰ
Ͷͳ


m
͈ͻͰͺ͹ͻ;ΕͰ͸͹
͸Ͱͻͪͼͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵Ͱ
;
ͳͲͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ;
ͯͬͪ
ͺͪͶͪ
ͽͪͶ͸ͪ
ͭͶͪͼͪ




̸;ͽ͹ͻ
Ͳͪ;Ͳͬͻͪͽ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͺͻͳͻ;΂͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͻͰͿͰͻͰ͸ͽ͸ͳ΀
ͭͻͪͷͪͽͳ
͵ͪ
͈Ͱͽͻ͹ͬͳΕ
ͣ͹ͻ͹ͬͳΕ
̻͹ͺ΂ͰͬͳΕ
/FVGFME
.FUPVMB
ͺͻ͹Ϳ
ͅ
͉Ͱ΃Ͱͽͪͻ



̀ͪ
ΒͰͲͳ͵Ͱ
ͼͰ
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͻͪͯ;
;ͷͰͼͽ͹
͸ͪͲͳͬͪ
ͷͪͽͰͻΔͳ
ͳ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͰ
͹Ͳ͸ͪ͵Ͱ

ͺ͹ͶͪͲ͸ͳ
"VTHBOHTTQSBDIF

ͳ
΁ͳΓ͸ͳ
ΒͰͲͳ͵
;JFMTQSBDIF




͌ͷͰͼͽ͹
͸Ͱͼͬͻ΃Ͱ͸͹ͭ
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫΓͰ͸
ΒͰ
ͼͬͻ΃Ͱ͸ͳ
ͭͶͪͭ͹Ͷͼ͵ͳ
ͬͳͯ



͌
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͰΔ;
͑ͽͪ
ͱͰͶͳͽͰ
ͯͪ
͸ͪͻ;΂ͳͽͰ
ͽΒ
ͺ͹ͯ
;ͽͳ΁ͪΒͰͷ
ͼͰͷͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͪ͵ͽ;
ͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ͭͶͪͭ͹Ͷͪ
OFINFO


͌
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ;
ͯͪ͵ͪ͵͹
͸Ͱ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͳͼ͵Γ;΂ͳͽͳ
͸ͳ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
ͫͪ͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
΃ͽͪͷ
ͺͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͭͻͰ΃͵Ͱ

 ͇ͯͻͰͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͹
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
;
͸Ͱ͵ͳͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ 

m
̓͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ΕͰ
ͽͻͪΒͪͽͳ
ͯ͹͵
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͰͷ
ͬͰͲ;
ͳͲ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͰ
͸Ͱͭͪ΁ͳ
͹͸Ͱ
ͺͪͻͽͳ͵;ͶͰ
͸Ͱ

m
ͅ͹Ͷͳͷ
ͺͶͪͽͳͽͳ
ͅ͹Ͷͳͷ
͹ͫͻͳΒͪͽͳ
͇΃ͳ΃ͪͽͳ
͸Ͱͼͽͪ͸
ͯͪͻͯ͸ͪ
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͳ͸Ϳͳ͸ͳͽͳͬͪ
;
ͳͷͺͰͻͪͽͳͬ͸͹Β
ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸ͳ΁ͳ


͇ͬͪ
Ͷͳͼͽͪ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬͳ΀
ͿͻͪͲͪ
͸ͪͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͼͰ
͵ͻͪͽ͵ͳͷ
ͭͶ͹ͼͪͻ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͯ

͸ͪͲͳͬ͹ͷ
,MFJOFT
8ÕSUFSCVDI
͇͸
͹ͫ;΀ͬͪͽͪ
ͺͻͰ͵͹

ͶͰ͵ͼͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ΒͰͯͳ
͸ͳ΁ͪ
͸ͪͬͰͯ͸ͳ΀
ͪͶͿͪͫͰͽͼ͵ͳͷ
ͻͰͯ͹ͼͶͰͯ͹ͷ
ͼͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵͹ͷ
͵ͪ͹

ͺ͹ͶͪͲ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͳ
΂Ͱͷ;
ͼͰ
ͷͰΌ;
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͳͼ͵Γ;΂ͳͬ͹
Ͱ͵ͪͬͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺͻͰͬ͹ͯ
͸ͳͷ
Ͱ͵ͬͳͬͪͶͰ͸ͽͳͷͪ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͰ
ͳ
ͶͰ͵ͼͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͯ;ͫͶͰͽ͸Ͱ
Ϳ͹ͻͷͰ
΀ͶͰͫ͵ͻ;΀

ͼͺͻͪͽ͵ͪͽ
΁Ͱͼͽͪ
;Ͷͳ΁ͪ
ͶͰ͵ͪͻͶͰ΂͸ͳ͵ 


Β;΀ͪ΂͹ͻͫͪͼ;ͺͪ
΀Ͷͪ΂Ͱ
΂ͪ͵΃ͳͻͰ
͹ͽ͹͵͹ͼͽͻͬ͹
ͯ;΀ͪ͸ͯ;ͬͪ͸
ͬ͹ͲͬͶͪ͵
͠Ͱͯ͸ͪ͵͹
ͼ;
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ

΂Ͱͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒͰͬͳ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͪ
ͪͶͳ
͸Ͱ
ͳ
΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͪ

ͬͪͻͳΒͪ͸ͽͪ
ͻͰ΂ͳ
ͺͻͪͲ͸ͳ͵
͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͫͶͪͭͯͪ͸

ͺͰ΃͵ͳͻ
͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͻ;΂͸ͳ͵

͵ͪ΃ͳ
͵ͪ
͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͱͶͳ΁ͪ

ͳͽͯ
ͅͰΌ;
ͶͰ͵ͼͰͷͪͷͪ
Ͳͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͺͻͰͽͺ͹ͼͽͪͬͳͽͳ

ͯͪ
;
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
͸Ͱ
ͫͳ
;΃ͶͰ
;
ͶͰ͵ͼͳ΂͵ͳ
ͷͳ͸ͳͷ;ͷ
͸ͪΒͬͳ΃Ͱ
ΒͰ

͹͸ͳ΀
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
͸ͪ
͸ͪͲͳͬͰ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷͪΔͪ
%JFOFS
m
TMVHB

%JFOTUNBOO

m
OPTBǁ

ͱͳͬ͹ͽͳΔͪ
&TFM
m
NBHBSBD
3JOE

HPWFEP

ͺͻͰͬͪͲͳΌͰ͸ͳ΀

͹ͫͶͳ͵ͪ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͳ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
"CPSU
m
OVßOJL
,MPTFUU

m
[BIPE
(BTUIPG

HPTUJPOJDB

ͺͻͰͬ͹Ͳ͸ͳ΀
ͼͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͪ
%SPTDILF

ͳ
ͼͶ

͈͹ͶͳͭͶ͹ͽ͹ͬ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
;
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
͵ͻͪͽ͵͹Β

ΒͰͯ͸͹ͼͽ;ͫͪ΂͸͹Β
ͻ;ͫͻͳ΁ͳ
4QSBDIF
VOE
4DISJGU
ͯͪ
;
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͰ

ͽͻͳ
ͼͶ;ͱͫͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͳ
ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͪ΂͵ͳ
ͳ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ
͵͹
Βͪ
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͽ͹
͵ͪ͵͹
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͳͶͪͲͳ
ͳͲ
͹ͬͰ
͸ͰͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸Ͱ
Ϳ͹ͻͷ;Ͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
m
ͼͬͳ

Ͷͳͼͽ͹ͷ

ͺͳ΃;
ͺ͹ͷ͹Ε;
ͯͬͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͪ
ͺͳͼͷͪ
m
Ͷͪͽͳ͸ͳ΂͸͹ͭ
ͳ
Εͳͻͳ
Ͷͳ΂͸͹ͭ
ͣͳͻͳͶͳ΂͸͹
ͺͳͼͷ͹
ͼͰ
ͺͻͳ
ͽ͹ͷ
ͯ͹ͬ͹ͯͳ
;
ͬͰͲ;
ͼͪ
͹͸ͳͷ
͵͹ΒͰ

ͼͰ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳ
;
͊͹ͬΒͰͽͼ͵͹ͷ
͊ͪͬͰͲ;
ͳ
;
̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵͹Β
͇ͬͯͰ
ͼͰ
͸Ͱ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͰ

͸ͳ͵ͪ͵ͬͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
ͬͰͲͪ͸ͳ
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͲͳ͵
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳ͹͸ͳͼͪΔͰ



͌
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
;ͬͰͯͰ͸Ͱ
ͬͰͲ͸ͳ͵͹ͷ
CJT
͸ͰͷͪΒ;
͸Ͱ
ͭͪ΁ͳΒ;
8JF
MBOHF
EBVFSU
FT
CJT
JDI
7FSCJOEVOH
CFLPNNF

̓͹ͻͰͼͺ͹͸ͯͰ͸ͽ͸ͳ
ͬͰͲ͸ͳ͵

;
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
ͯ͹͵
;ͬ͹ͯͳ
͸Ͱͭͳͻͪ͸;
Ͳͪͬͳͼ͸;
ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸ͳ΁;
̓͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ΕͰ
ͽͻͪΒͪͽͳ
ͯ͹͵

͸Ͱ
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͰͷ
ͬͰͲ;



͇ͬͪ
͸ͰͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸͹ͼͽ
ͼͰ
ͳͼͺͻͪͬΓͪ
ͬͰΕ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͻͰͯ͹ͬͪ
͸ͳͱͰ
;
ͺͪͼ;ͼ;
ͭͯͰ

ͼͰ
ͯͰͿͳ͸ͳ΃Ͱ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͪͶ͸ͪ
Ͳͪͼͽ;ͺΓͰ͸͹ͼͽ
͹ͬͳ΀
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͳ
ͼͰ
͵͹ͻͳ
ͼͽͳ
;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹Β
̹͹ͼ͸ͳ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ
ΕͳͻͳͶͳ΁ͪ
LZSJMMJTDIF

4DISJGU

;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫΓͪͬͪ
ͼͰ
;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͳ
͏ͻ͸͹Β
̻͹ͻͳ
ͪ
Ͷͪͽͳ͸ͳ΁ͪ
;
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹Β
ͳ
̹͹ͼ͸ͳ

ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ

 ͇ͶͳͬͰͻͪ
̽;ͻͫͪͫͪ

̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͷ͹ͫͳͶͼ͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͼͪͯͻͱͳ

͸ͪΒͺͻͰ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
͵ͻͪͽ͵ͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
Ͳͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͯ;ͱͳ͸Ͱ
ͼͬͰͭͪ

ͽͻͳ
ͺͪͼ;ͼͪ
͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ͼͰ
;ͬ͹ͯ͸ͳ
Ͳͪͺͻͪͬ͹
͸ͳ
͸Ͱ
ͫͪͬͳ
͹ͼ͹ͫͰ͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ

ͯ͹ͷͪΕͰͭͯ͹ͷͪΕͳ΀
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͻͪͼͺͻ͹ͼͽͻͪΔͰ͸͹΃Ε;
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ

ͷͰΌ;
ͯ͹ͷͪΕͳͷ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ͹ͷ
m
͹ͬͯͰ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͳ

ͳ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹Β
ͯ͹ͼͽͪ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ
ͳ
ͽ͹
ͺͻͰͬͪͼ΀͹ͯ͸͹
ͷͰΌ;
͹ͫͻͪͲ͹
ͬͪ͸ͳΒͳͷ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽ͹ͷ
ͳͶͳ
ͷͰΌ;
ͼͽͪͻͳΒͳͷ
ͼͬͰͽ͹ͷ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͳ
;

͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͼͻͰͼͽͳ
Γ;ͯͳ
ͼͪ
Ͳ͸ͪΔͰͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͭ
͌
͸ͪͼͽͪͬ͵;
ͼͰ

ͯͪΓͰ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͰ
ͼͶ;ͱͫͰ͸ͳ
ΒͰͲͳ΁ͳ
͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ΒͰ
͸ͪΒͲͪͼͽ;ͺΓͰ͸ͳΒͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹
΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͳ

ͷͳͶͳ͹͸ͪ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ͸ͳ͵ͪ

ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͪ΂͵ͳ
 
ͷͳͶͳ͹͸


ͳ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ
 
ͷͳͶͳ͹͸

͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ΒͰͲͳ΁ͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͷͪΔͳ͸ͪ
ͪͶ
ͫͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ

ͷͳͶͳ͹͸

ͷͪΌͪͻͼ͵ͳ


ͽ;ͻͼ͵ͳ


͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ


͌
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͰͷ
ͺͪͼ;ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͽͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͶ͸ͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳͷͪ
͹ͫΒͪ΃Δͪ
ͬͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͰ
ͯͬͪΒ;
ͺͳͼͪͷͪ
ͺͻͳ
΂Ͱͷ;
ͼͰ
Ͳͪ
ΕͳͻͳͶͳ΂͸͹
͵͹͸ͼͽͪͽ;ΒͰ
ͯͪ

;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪ
ͻ;ͼ͵͹ͷ
ΕͳͻͳͶͳ΂͸͹ͷ
ͺͳͼͷ;


͌
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂͸͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͭͶͪͬΓͪ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ͵;
ͼͰ
͸;ͯͳ
΂Ͱͽͬ͹
ͻ͹ΒͰͲͳ΂͸ͳ
ͭͶ͹ͼͪͻ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͳ
ͭͻ΂͵ͳ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵ͳ

͵͹Βͳ

ͼͪͯͻͱͳ
ͬͪͱ͸Ͱ
ͻͰ΂ͳ
ͳ
ͿͻͪͲͰ
8JDIUJHF
8ÕSUFS
VOE
3FEFXFOEVOHFO


ͼͬͻͼͽͪ͸Ͱ
;
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵ͳ΀
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
ͳͷͰ͸ͪ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
ͳ
Ͱͽ͸͹͸ͳͷͳ

Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͫ͹ͻͪͬͪ͵
;
΀͹ͽͰͶ;
͹ͯͶͪͲͪ͵
;
ͻͰͼͽ͹ͻͪ͸
ΒͰͶ͹
ͳ
ͺͳΕͰ

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
͵͹Ͷͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͻͰͲͰͻͬ͸ͳ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳ
ͼ
͹ͫͲͳͻ͹ͷ
ͯͪ
΁ͳΓ͸;
ͭͻ;ͺ;

͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
;ͺͻͪͬ͹
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ

ͪ;ͽ͹ͷ͹ͫͳͶ͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹ͶͪͲͰ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒ;
ͳ
͹ͼͽͪͶͰ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͰ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
ͻͪ
Ͳ;ͷΓͳͬ͹
ΒͰ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͹ͬͪΒ
ͯͰ͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
ͳ
͸ͪΒ͹ͺ΃ͳͻ͸ͳΒͳ

͊ͺͰ΁ͳ
Ϳͳ΂͸͹ͼͽ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͭͶ͹ͼͪͻͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͵͹ͯ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ΀
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͼͶ͹ͱ͸ͳ΀
ͻͰ΂ͳ
͹ͫͰͶͰͱͰ͸
ͪ͵΁Ͱ͸ͽ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͼͶ͹ͭ

̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͷ͹ͫͳͶͼ͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳͷͪ
ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳ
΂ͪ͸
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͽͳͬ͸ͳ
ͯͰ͹
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͼͪ
͸ͪͭͶͪͼ͵͹ͷ

͸ͪ
ΒͰͲͳ΂͵͹Β
ͻͪͲ͸͹Ͷͳ͵͹ͼͽͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
͇ͼͳͷ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹ͭ
͵ͪ͹

ͼͶ;ͱͫͰ͸͹ͭ
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ
;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹Β
̹͹ͼ͸ͳ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
ͳ
͏ͻ
͸͹Β
̻͹ͻͳ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͰ
ͼͰ
ͳ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳ
ΒͰͲͳ΁ͳ
ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͪ΂͵ͳ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ
ΒͰͲͳ
΁ͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͷͪΔͳͷͪ
ͪͶͫͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͷͪΌͪͻͼ͵ͳ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵ͳ
ͼͶ͹ͬͪ΂͵ͳ

ͻ;ͷ;͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͳ
́
͹ͬͯͰ
ͼͰ
;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͰ
ͯͬͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͪ

ͺͳͼͷͪ
ͺͻͳ
΂Ͱͷ;
ͼͰ
Ͳͪ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ͸Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪ͵Ͱ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
t͈;ͽ͹͵ͪͲͳ



ͯ͹ͯͪͽ͸͹
͸ͪͺͳͼͪ͸ͳ
ͳ
Ͷͪͽͳ͸ͳ΁͹ͷi
͇ͬͪΒ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ
ͫͪͫͳͶ͹͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͻͪ
Ͳ͸͹ͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
Ͳͪͬͻ΃ͪͬͪ
ͼͰ
ͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵ͳͷ
ͭͶ͹ͼͪͻ͹ͷ
͵͹Βͳ
͹ͫ;΀ͬͪͽͪ
ͭͰ͹
ͭͻͪͿͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹Βͷ͹ͬͰ
ͬͪͱ͸Ͱ
ͳͲͻͪͲͰ
ͶͰ͵ͼͳ͵;
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳ
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪ
Δ;
͸ͪ
ͺ͹΃ͽͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
Ͳͪ
ͬ͹Ͳͪ΂ͪ
͹ͬͪΒ
ͯͰ͹
ΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
;
ͺͻͰͽ
΀͹ͯ͸͹ͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
͸ͪΒ͹ͺͼͰͱ͸ͳΒͳ


 ͇ͯͻͰͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͹
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
;
͸Ͱ͵ͳͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ 

͇ͯͻͰͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͹
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
͵ͪ͵ͬͰ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ΒͪͬΓ;Β;
;
͹ͬͯͰ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸ͳͷ
ͫͰ
ͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
͵ͪ͵͹
͹͸ͳͷͪ
ͳͲͯͪͽͳͷ
ͺͻͰ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͼͽ͹ͽͳ͸;
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͽͪ͵͹

ͳ
͹͸ͳͷ
͸͹ͬͳΒͳͷ
ͳͷͪΒ;
͸ͪΒ͹ͺ΃ͽͳΒͳ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͽͳͬ͸ͳ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ
ͳ
͸ͪ

͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
͸ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͵͹͸΁ͳͺͳͻͪ͸Ͱ
͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͺ͹ͼͶ;ͱͳͽͳ
Ͳͪ
͹ͼͽͬͪͻͰΔͰ

ͳͼͽͳ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͫ͹ͻͪͬ͵ͪ
;
͸ͪ΃ͳͷ
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͳͷͪ
͢ͳ΀͹
ͬͪ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͽͳͬ͸ͪ
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳΒͪ
ͳͼ΁ͻͺΓ;ΒͰ
ͼͰ
;
͸ͪͬ͹ΌͰΔ;
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͪ
ΒͰ
Ͳͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬͪͻͳΒͰͽͰͽͪ
ͺͻͳ
΂Ͱͷ;
ͼͬͳ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͳͻͪ͸ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͳͼͽ͹΂͸;
ͳ

Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸;
ͬͪͻͳΒͪ͸ͽ;
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͷͪͽͻͪΒ;
ͼͪͷ͹
͵ͪ͹
ͯͬͰ
ͺ͹Βͪͬ͸Ͱ
Ϳ͹ͻͷͰ

ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͳͼͽ͹ͭ
ΒͰͲͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͼͳͼͽͰͷͪ

ͳ
ͯͬͪ
ͺͳͼͷͪ
͈͹ͻͰͯ
ͽ͹ͭͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͳ
ͫͰͯͰ
͵Ͱͻͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͫͳ΂͸͹
͹ͯͶ;΂;Β;
ͯͪ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ͵;
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
ͳ
͹ͷͪΔͳ
ͭͶ͹ͼͪͻ
΂ͳΒͳ

ͼͰ
͹ͫͳͷ
ͳ
΃ͳͻͳ͸ͪ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͪ
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
͸ͳͼ;
ͫͳͽ͸͹
ͳͲͷͰ͸ͳͶͳ

͊ͺ͹ͻͪͯͳ΂͸͹
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͫͰͲ
ͺͻͰͽͰ͸ͲͳΒͪ
Ͳͪ
Ͷͳ͸ͭͬͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸͹΃Ε;

ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ
ΒͰͲͳ΂͵ͳ
ͰͶͰͷͰ͸ͽͳ
ͪ
ͺͻͰͬͪͼ΀͹ͯ͸͹
ͭͶͪͼ͹ͬͳ
ͼͶ͹ͬͪ
ͳ
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ

͹ͯ
ͺͻͳͷͪͻ͸ͳ΀
ͷ͹ͻͿ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ΀
͵ͪͽͰͭ͹ͻͳΒͪ
͹ͫΒͪ΃ΔͪͬͪΒ;
ͺ;ͽͰͷ
ͺ͹ͻͰ
ΌͰΔͪ
ͼͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵͹ͷ
͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹ͶͪͲ͸ͳͷ
͋ͰͷͪͽͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀

ͻͪͲͶͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͼͶͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
;
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͳͻͪ͸ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ

Ͳͪ
΁ͳΓ
ͽͰ
͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͳ
ͷ͹ͭͶͪ
ͫͳͽͳ
ͻͰͪͶͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
̺Ͱ͹ͷͪ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹
ͫͳ

ͫͳͶ͹
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
͵͹͸ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͳͻͪͽͳ
͸͹ͬͳΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂Ͱ
͵͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ͫͳ

ͼͰ
;
ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;
ͼ
ͺͻͰ͹ͬͶͪΌ;Β;Εͳͷ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼ͹ͷ
;
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹ͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͷ

ͯͻ;΃ͽͬ;
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͳͷ
ͷͪͻ͵Ͱͽͳ͸΃͵ͳͷ
΁ͳΓͰͬͳͷͪ
ͷ͹ͭͶ͹
͹΂Ͱ
͵ͳͬͪͽͳ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͺͻͪͭͷͪͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ

#*#-*0(3"'*+"

#SJOLFS
,

m
-JOHVJTUJTDIF
5FYUBOBMZTF
&JOF
&JOGÛISVOH
JO
(SVOECFHSJG
GF
VOE
.FUIPEFO
#FSMJO

̓͹ͼͽͳΕ
͚
͊

m
̺ͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͼ͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
͌
͆ͳ΃
ͳ
̺ͳͲͪ͸
ͽͳΒͪ
͆ͳ΃


1MFJOFT
+

m
4QSBDIFOLFOOUOJT
JN
.BTTFO
5PVSJTNVT
m
FJOF
OJDIU
XBISHF
OPNNFOF
"VGHBCF
EFS
4QSBDIXJTTFOTDIBGUFO
%BT
#FJTQJFM
EFS
BSBCJTDIFO
.JU
UFMNFFS"OSBJOFSTUBBUFO
6
1PQQ
)
)STH

%BT
#JME
EFS
.JUUFMNFFSMÅOEFS

JO
EFS
3FJTFGÛISFS-JUFSBUVS
1BTTBV


3PMG
&

m
%JF
'VOLUJPOFO
EFS
(FCSBVDITUFYUTPSUFO
#FSMJO/FX
:PSL

8FSMJDI
&

m
5ZQPMPHJF
EFS
5FYUF
&OUXVSG
FJOFT
UFYUMJOHVJTUJTDIFO
.PEFMMT

[VS
(SVOEMFHVOH
FJOFS
5FYUHSBNNBUJL
)FJEFMCFSH

8JFSMBDIFS
"

m
;VN
"VGCBV
FJOFS
3FJTFGÛISFSGPSTDIVOH
JOUFSLVMUVSFM
MFS
(FSNBOJTUJL
6
+BISCVDI
%FVUTDI
BMT
'SFNETQSBDIF

5ÛCJOHFO

 ͇ͶͳͬͰͻͪ
̽;ͻͫͪͫͪ

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

0MJWFSB
%VSCBCB
%FS
TFSCJTDIFO
4QSBDIF
HFXJENFUF
,BQJUFM

JO
FJOJHFO
EFVUTDIFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO

*O
EFS
WPSMJFHFOEFO
"SCFJU
XFSEFO
FJOJHF
EFS
JN
EFVUTDITQSBDIJHFO

(FCJFU
"OGBOH
VOE
&OEF
EFT

+BISIVOEFSUT
FSTDIJFOFOFO
3FJTFGÛISFS

EBSHFMFHU
XPCFJ
CFTPOEFSF
"VGNFSLTBNLFJU
,BQJUFMO
VOE
"CTDIOJUUFO

HFXJENFU
XJSE
EJF
EJF
TFSCJTDIF
TFSCPLSPBUJTDIF
TFSCPLSPBUJTDIF
4QSBDIF

UIFNBUJTJFSFO
%JFTF
VNGBTTFO
JE3
BMMHFNFJOF
"OHBCFO
[V
EFO
CFLBOOUFO

EJBMFLUBMFO
7BSJFUÅUFO
VOE
VOUFSTDIJFEMJDIFO
4DISJGUFO
XJF
BVDI
LVS[F

8PSUMJTUFO
NJU
GSFRVFOUFS
VOE
GÛS
3FJTFOEF
OÛU[MJDIFS
-FYJL

%JF
IJFS
BOHFTQSPDIFOFO
,BQJUFM
EJF
[VN
5IFNB
EJF
4QSBDIF
EFT

3FJTFMBOEFT
IBCFO
XFJTFO
TPXPIM

JO
ÅMUFSFO
WPS
FUXB

+BISFO
WFSÕGGFOUMJ
DIUFO
BMT
BVDI
JO
OFVFSFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO
FJOFO
BMMHFNFJOFO
JOGPSNBUJWFO

$IBSBLUFS
BVG
*ISFS
LPO[FQUJPOFMMFO
(FTUBMUVOH
VOE
JOIBMUMJDIFO
"VT
BSCFJUVOH
HFNœ
WFSNÕHFO
TJF
[V
LFJOFS
XBISIBGUFO
VOE
OJDIU
WPSHFU
ÅVTDIUFO
,PNNVOJLBUJPO
JN
;JFMMBOE
GÛISFO
%FS
*OGPSNBUJPOTXFSU
EJFTFS

QTFVEPMJOHVJTUJTDIFO
VOE
m
LPNNVOJLBUJWFO
"VTMFHVOHFO
FSTDIÕQGU
TJDI

JO
FJOUÕOJHFO
"VG[ÅIMVOHFO
EFS
4QSBDIWBSJFUÅUFO
XPCFJ
BMMF
EFS
"OBMZTF

VOUFS[PHFOFO
3FJTGÛISFS
EJF
ÕTUMJDIF
VOE
XFTUMJDIF
7BSJFUÅU
BVTTDIMJF“MJDI
BMT

[XFJ
&STDIFJOVOHTGPSNFO
FJOFT
VOE
EFTTFMCFO
4QSBDITZTUFNT
CFUSBDIUFO

VOE

EFS
CFJEFO
4DISJGUFO
"V“FSEFN
WFSGÛHFO
EJFTF
3FJTFGÛISFS
ÛCFS
FJO
NFJTUFOT

XFOJH
HFIBMUWPMMFT
(MPTTBS
EFTTFO
6NGBOH
KBIS[FIOUFMBOH
VOWFSÅOEFSMJDI

CMFJCU
.JUVOUFS
XFSEFO
NBODIF
4QSBDIFMFNFOUF
m
WPSXJFHFOE
-BVUF

#VDITUBCFO LPNCJOBUJPOFO

VOE
FJOJHF
HSVOEMFHFOEF
NPSQIPMPHJTDIF

,BUFHPSJFO
m
EVSDI
4QSBDIWFSHMFJDIF
NJU
EFN
%FVUTDIFO
BMT
"VTHBOHTTQSBDIF

FSMÅVUFSU
PIOF
EBTT
EBCFJ
FJO
"OTQSVDI
BVG
7PMMTUÅOEJHLFJU
VOE
MJOHVJTUJTDIF

(FOBVJHLFJU
FSIPCFO
XJSE
%JF
5IFNBUJTJFSVOH
WPO
,VMUVSVOUFSTDIJFEFO
VOE

ÅIOMJDILFJUFO
XJSE
EBCFJ
XFEFS
FSTUSFCU
OPDI
SFBMJTJFSU
&T
XÅSF
JO
EJFTFN

;VTBNNFOIBOH
TFIS
JOUFSFTTBOU
OFVFSF
3FJTFGÛISFS
[V
BOBMZTJFSFO
&T
MJFHU

OÅNMJDI
BVG
EFS
)BOE
EBTT
EJFTF
EFN
BLUVFMMFO
HFTFMMTDIBGUMJDIFO
%JTLVST

VOE
BOHFTBHUFO
.BSLUXFSUFO
GPMHFOE
JO
FSTUFS
-JOJF
QSBHNBUJTDIF
VOE

JOUFSLVMUVSFMMF
*OIBMUF
BVGXFJTFO

͇ͽ͹
̸͎͉̈́͌͋

͆ͪ;΂͸͹ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂͵ͳ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻ

̸͊̀͌

͡;ͫΓͪ͸ͪ
͋ͪΔͪ
͈͉͇̺̾͋́ͣ

̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
̸͊͆͌

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

̸̸̹̈́̓͆
͌
̸̸͈̀̽͆́ͅ

͉͋͌́͊͋́͐̓́ͅ
̸̺͇̽́͐́ͅ
ћ
̸͉͉̓̾́̾͢
̸́̽̾͆͋́͋̾͋

͉͇̓̀
͇͉̓͆͊͋͌̓͏́͌͠

͈͉͍͉̾́̾́̾͠

̾ͬͻ͹ͺͪ
͈͹ͯͰͶͰ
ͳ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ

͇ͬͪΒ
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͭ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͺ͹͵;΃ͪΒ
͹΁ͻͽͪͬͪΔͪ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼͪ
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪ
ͬΓͪΔͪ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹ͭ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪ
ͳ
Β;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
ͺͰͻͳͿͰͻͳΒͰ

ͳ
;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
͸ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͲͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͷͰ΀ͪ͸ͳͲͷͰ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͰ
;
͹ͼ͸͹
ͬͳ
͹ͬͳ΀
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼͪ
͌
ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔ;
ͼͳͷͫ͹Ͷͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹
ͬͶͪ΂ͰΔ;
Ͳͪͷͳ΃ΓͰ͸Ͱ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͼͪ
΂ͳΒͰ
ͼͰ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ΃Ͷͪ
t͹ͺͪͼ͸ͪ

Ͳ͹͸ͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰi
t͇ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽi
tͲͰͷΓͪ
΀ͳΓͪͯ;
ͳ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
͸͹Εͳi
t͵͹ͷͺͶͰ͵ͼ͸ͪ

ͪͺͼ;ͻͯ͸͹ͼͽ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪi
ͪ
ͼͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
΀ͻͳ΃Εͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ
΁ͳͬͳͶͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͪ

ͳ
ͯͰͷ͹͵ͻͪͽͼ͵ͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͪ
ͬͪͱ͸;
;Ͷ͹ͭ;
͹ͯͳͭͻͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸ͪ

ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͪ
͵͹Β;
ͼ;
ͼͽͬͪͻͪͶͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͼͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯͪ
͵͹͸ͼͽͻ;ͳ΃;Εͳ

Β;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸ͳ
ͯͰ͹
t͊ͽͪͻ͹ͭ
͵͹͸ͽͳ͸Ͱ͸ͽͪi
͵ͪ͹
ͯͻ;ͭͪ΂ͳΒ;
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸;

ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵;
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸;
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸;
΁ͰͶͳ͸;
͋ͪ
΁ͰͶͳ͸ͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ

9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͹ͽ͵ͻͳͬͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
͵͹͸ͼͽͻ;ͳͼͪ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ

ͬ͹Β͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͽͻͭ͹ͬͪ΁ͪ
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͪ
͸ͪ;΂͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͺͳͼͪ΁ͪ
ͳ
ͪͬͪ͸ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ


ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ΁ͻͽͪ͸ͪ
ͬͰΕ
;
97
ͬͰ͵;
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
͹ͽ͹ͷͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
͹ͼͬͪΒͪΔͪ

̓͹͸ͼͽͪ͸ͽͳ͸͹ͺ͹Γͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
"OFOFBT
4JWMJVT
1JDDPMPNJOJ

͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺͪͺͪ
͈ͳΒͰ
**

ͻͪͲͬͳ͹
͸͹ͬ;
ͭͰ͹ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵;
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒ;

Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹ͭ
΀ͻͳ΃Εͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
͏Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶ͸ͳ
ͯͰ͹
ͽͰ
͸͹ͬͰ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͼͬͰ
ͼͰ

ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵͹ͬͪ͹
͹ͯ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳ΀
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͪ
͵͹͸ͽͳ͸Ͱ͸ͽͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
͹ͯ
Β;ͭ͹ͳ
 ͇ͽ͹
̈́;ͽ΀ͪͻ
m
͋ͪΔͪ
͈Ͱͽͻ͹ͬͳΕ

ͼͽ͹΂͸ͳ΀
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼ;
;ͺͻͪͬΓͪͶͳ
tͬͪͻͬͪͻͼ͵ͳ
͋;ͻ΁ͳi
͈ͻͰ
ͺͰͽ
͸ͪͰͼͽ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͪ΂ͳΒͳ
̺ͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
t
UIF

VOSFWFBMFE
DFOUFS
PG
DJWJMJ[FE
&VSPQFBO
XPSME
GPS
TFWFSBM
DFOUVSJFT
BGUFS

UIF
GBMM
PG
3PNF
BOE

UIF
8FTU
XBT
TZOPOJNPVT
XJUI
CBSCBSJUZ
BOE
DSV
EFOFTTi
4WFUMBOB
#PZN
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
t&VSPQF
XBT
BMXBZT
PCTFTTFE
XJUI
JUT

CPSEFST
JOUFSOBM
BOE
FYUFSOBM
'JSTU
UIF
EJTUJODUJPOT
XFSF
EFUFSNJOFE
CZ

DMJNBUF
OPU
CZ
QFPQMF
'SPN
BOUJRVJUZ
UP
UIF
3FOBJTTBODF
UIF
EJWJTJPO

CFUXFFO
/PSUI
BOE
4PVUI
OPU
&BTU
BOE
8FTU
XBT
UIF
DFOUSBM
POF
*O

GBDU
UIF
TPVUI
PG
&VSPQF
BOE
UIF
.FEJUFSSBOFBO
CBTJO
XFSF
TFFO
BT
B

DSBEMF
PG
DJWJMJ[BUJPO
XIJMF
OPSUI
PG
(BVM
m
'SBODT
(PUIT
BOE
"OHMP4B
YPOT
m
XBT
DPOTJEFSFE
UIF
MBOE
PG
CBSCBSJBOT
%VSJOH
UIF
&OMJHIUNFOU

UIF
EJWJTJPO
PG
&VSPQF
JOUP
&BTU
BOE
8FTU
CFDBNF
NPSF
QSPNJOFOUi

.BSJB
5PEPSPWB
͹
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͺͰͻ΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͰ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳͼͽ͹͵ͪ
ͳ
Β;
ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹͵ͪ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͰ
t0OMZ
BGUFS
UIF
GBMM
PG
$POTUBOUJOPQMF

BOE

FDMJQTF
PG
UIF
0SUIPEPY
DIVSDI
CVU
FTQFDJBMMZ
XJUI
UIF
VOJRVF
FDPOPNJD

UBLFPGG
PG
8FTUFSO
&VSPQF
XBT
&BTU
BOE
4PVUFBTU

JOUFSOBMJ[FE
BMTP
CZ

UIF
0SUIPEPY
XPSME
BT
UIF
MFTT
QSJWJMFEHFE
PG
UIF
PQQPTJUJPO
QBJSi

́ͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͰͶͰ
;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
ͼ;
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ;
ͪ

͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͪ
ͯͬͪ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬͰͶͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͰ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵Ͱ

ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͽͰͽͰ
͆ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͺ͹ͯͰͶ͹ͷ
͉ͳͷͼ͵͹ͭ
΁ͪͻͼͽͬͪ
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ

ΒͰ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ΕͰ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͽͳ
Ͷͳ͸ͳΒͪ
ͻͪͲͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂ͰΔͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
Ͳͪ
ͺͪͯ͸͹ͭ
͵ͪͽ͹Ͷͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͽͰͼͽͪ͸ͽͼ͵͹ͭ

ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹ͭ
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬ͸͹ͭ


΀ͻͳ΃Εͪ͸ͼͽͬͪ
͇ͽ͹ͷͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ
͹ͼͬͪΒͪΔͪ
͹ͯͻͰͯͳͶͪ
ͼ;
ͳͼͶͪͷͼ͵Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ

Ͳ͹͸Ͱ
;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
͇ͬͰ
͵͹͸ͿͰͼͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͰͶͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͰ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ΀

Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳͷͺͰͻͳΒͪ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͻͪͽ͹ͬͳ
ͳ
ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͰ
͸͹ͬͳ΀

ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶ͸ͳ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
;ͼͶ͹ͬͳ
m

ͼͬͰ
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
;
ͬͰͶͳ͵͹Β
ͷͰͻͳ
ͯ͹ͺͻͳ͸ͰͶ͹
;͹ͫͶͳ΂ͪͬͪΔ;
ͳ
ͺͻͰ͹ͫͶͳ͵͹ͬͪΔ;

Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͽͰͽͪ


͌
97***
ͳ
9*9
ͬͰ͵;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͪ
ͳ
ͼͬͰͽ
ͼ;
ͳͲ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸Ͱ
ͺͰͻͼͺͰ͵ͽͳͬͰ

ͫͳͶͳ
ͺ͹ͯͰΓͰ͸ͳ
͸ͪ
΀ͻͳ΃Εͪ͸ͼ͵;
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸;

΁ͳͬͳͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͳ
ͼͬͰͽ
ͳͲ
ͬͪ͸
ͽͰ
΁ͳͬͳͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͈͹ͼͶͰ
tͺͻ͹ͶͰΕͪ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶ͸͹Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ΀
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪi


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

m
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͰ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
;΂ͳ͸ͳͶ͹
ͯͰͶ͹ͷ
΁ͳͬͳͶͳͲ͹
ͬͪ͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ͳ
ͯͪΓͰ
΂ͳ͸ͳͶͳ
ͺͰͻͳͿͰͻͳΒ;
m
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;

Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸Ͱ
΁ͳͬͳͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͯͰͼͺ͹ͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͬͪͻͬͪͻͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬ͸͹ͭ
ͷ;
ͼͶͳͷͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
͹ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͼ;ͻ͹ͬ͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͳͶ͸͹ͭ

Β;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͶͪ

ΒͰ
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
ͿͶͰ͵ͼͳͫͳͶ͸ͳΒͪ
͋ͪ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͯͪͶͰ͵͹
΂ͬͻ΃Εͪ
;
97**



4
#PZN
5IF
'VUVSF
PG
/PTUBMHJB
/FX
:PSL




.
5PEPSPWB
*NBHJOJOH
UIF
#BMLBOT
/FX
:PSL
m
0YGPSE


 ̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
;
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸ͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ 

ͬͰ͵;
͸ͪ͵͹͸
ͽ;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͺͼͪͯͰ
̹Ͱ΂ͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̺͹Β͸ͳ
ͼͽͻͪͽͰͲͳ
ͯͬ͹ͻ

ͼ͵ͳ
΂ͳ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͳ
ͪͻͳͼͽ͹͵ͻͪͽͼ͵ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͸ͳͼ;
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
ͼͶ͹ͱͳͽͳ

͹͵͹
ͽ͹ͭͪ
͵͹Β;
͹ͯ
΂Ͱͽͳͻͳ
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͪ͸Ͱ
ͻͰ͵Ͱ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳ

ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁͹ͷ
m
͊ͪͬ;
̽;͸ͪͬ
̓;ͺ;
ͳͶͳ
̓ͻ͵;
ͳͶͳ
ͼͬͰ
Δͳ΀
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸͹
͌

ͬͰΕͳ͸ͳ
͹ͺͳͼͪ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
t͇ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͪi
ͳ
΀ͻͳ΃Εͪ͸ͼͽͬͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ

ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
ͯ;ͱ
̺͹Β͸Ͱ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
΂ͳͷ
ͼ;
͋;ͻ΁ͳ

ͺ͹ͽͳͼ͸;ͽͳ
ͳͲ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶ͸ͳ΀
;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͳ΀
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͼͰͬͰͻ͸ͳ΀
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͪ
ͯͪ
͸ͪ΃ΔͰ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
͋͹͵͹ͷ
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͳ΀

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
̺͹Β͸Ͱ

͵ͻͪΒͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
́ͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
͊Ͷͪͬ͹͸ͳΒͰ
͹ͫͳ΂͸͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͰͬͰͻ͸͹Β
͹ͫͪͶͳ

͊ͪͬͰ
́Ͳͪ
ͽͰ
Ͷͳ͸ͳΒͰ
ͱͳͬͰͶͪ
ͼ;
tͼͽͬ͹ͻͰΔͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒ;
͇ͽ͹ͷͪ͸
ͼ͵͹ͷ
΁ͪͻͼͽͬ;i
Ͳͪͻ͹ͫΓͰ͸ͪ
ͬͰ΂ͳͽ͹ͷ
ͳͭͻ͹ͷ
͸ͪͼͳΓͪ
ͳ
͹ͼͬͰͽͰ
̓͹
ͭ͹ͯ

ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͶͪͲͳ͹
͹ͬ;
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁;
ͫͰͲ
͹ͫͲͳͻͪ
͸ͪ
ͽ͹
ͯͪ
Ͷͳ
ͼ;
ͷ͹ͽͳͬͳ
Ͳͪ
ΔͰ͸

ͺͻͰͶͪͲͪ͵
ͫͳͶͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͺͪͭͪ͸ͯͪ
͸ͪ;΂͸ͪ
ͯͰͼ͵ͻͳͺ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͻ͹
ͷͪ͸ͽͳ΂ͪͻͼ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͽͻͪͭͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺͶͰͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͷ
ͪ;ͽͰ͸ͽͳ΂͸͹΃Ε;
͹ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
ΒͰ
͵ͪ͹

Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸;
Ͷͳ͸ͳΒ;
̓͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ΒͰ
͹ͬͪ͵ͬͪ
ͺͰͻ΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͪ
Β;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹͵ͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ

;ͽͳ΁ͪͶͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵;
ͳ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸Ͱ
͹ͫͻͪͼ΁Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͰͶͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͶ͹

ΒͰ
Βͪͼ͸͹
ͽͰ͵
;
ͯͻͪͷͪͽͳ΂͸͹Β
Ͳͪͬͻ΃͸ͳ΁ͳ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
̈́ͳ͸ͳΒͪ
ͳͼ͵Γ;΂ͰΔͪ

Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͻͪ͸ͪ
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶ͸ͪ
͸Ͱͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸͹

ͺͻͰ
ͳ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͰͭ
tͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽ͹ͭ͹ͯͳ΃ΔͰͭ
ͻͪͽͪi


ͳ

ͺ͹
ͻͪͼͺͪͯ;
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶͳͲͷͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

͈͹ͯͰͶͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
͸ͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯ
ͳ
́ͼͽ͹͵
͵͹͸ͪ΂͸͹
ΒͰ
;ͽͬͻΌͰ͸ͪ
ͭͬ͹ͲͯͰ
͸͹ͷ
ͲͪͬͰͼ͹ͷ
m
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹
ͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬ͹
́ͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͳͷͪͶ͹
ΒͰ

Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯͳ΁;
ͯͪ
ΔͰ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
̀ͪͺͪͯ͸ͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͪ
͸Ͱ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪͬͪ

ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
̾ͬͻ͹ͺΓͪ͸Ͱ
tͳͼͽͰ
ͬͻͼͽͰi
ͳͶͳ
͵ͪ͹
̾ͬͻ͹ͺΓͪ͸Ͱ
;͹ͺ΃ͽͰ
̓ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼͷ͹
ͬͰΕ
ͳͼͽͪ͵Ͷͳ
tͳͲͬ͹ͻͳi
ͳ
tͪͻͭ;ͷͰ͸ͽͳi
Ͳͪ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸;

ͺ͹ͯͰͶ;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͺ͹ͽͳ΂;
ͳͲ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸Ͱ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͰ
97***
ͳ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ

͌
ͽ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸ͪ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͹
ͬͪΔͪ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͹
͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳͷ
ͳ
ͯͪͶͰ͵ͳͷ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͵͹͸ͽͳ͸Ͱ͸ͽͪ

ͳ
ͬͰΕ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
;΂ͰΔͪ
͹
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
ͷͪ
͇͸͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
͹
Δͳͷͪ
Ͳ͸ͪͶ͹
ͳͶͳ
ͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͶ͹
ͺ͹ͽͳ΁ͪͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͳͲ
͹ͺͳͼͪ

ͽͻͭ͹ͬͪ΁ͪ
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͪ
ͳ
͸ͪ;΂͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͫ͹ͻͪͬͳͶͳ
;
ͽͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ

ͳͶͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͺͻ͹ͶͪͲͳͶͳ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
Δͳ΀

̓ͻͪΒͰͷ
9*9
ͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͵ͪͯͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
;
͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͰ

͵ͻͪΒͰͬͰ
ͺͻͰͼͽͪΒ;
ͯͪ
ͫ;ͯ;
ͺͻͳͬͳͶͰͭͳΒͪ
ͬͳ΃ͳ΀
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸ͳ΀
͵Ͷͪͼͪ
Βͪ
ͬΓͪ
ͼͰ
Β͹΃
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͱͪ͸ͻ
͵͹Βͳ
Ͳͪ
΁ͳΓ
ͳͷͪ
ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͪͬͪΔͰ
ͯͪͶͰ͵ͳ΀
ͳ

͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ΀
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͪ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
͸ͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
Ͱ͵ͼͺͶͳ΁ͳͽ͸ͳΒͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
͸Ͱͭ͹

ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸ͪ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͪ
ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͇͸ͳ
ͼ;
;
99
ͬͰ͵;

ͼ͵͹ͻ͹
;
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺͻͰ;ͲͰͶͳ
;Ͷ͹ͭ;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͶͳ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ

ͳͲͬ͹ͻ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͹
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪͷͪ
͌
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺͻͳͶ͹
 ͇ͽ͹
̈́;ͽ΀ͪͻ
m
͋ͪΔͪ
͈Ͱͽͻ͹ͬͳΕ

ͭ;
ͺ͹͵;΃ͪͬͪͷ͹
ͯͪ
ͺ͹͵ͪͱͰͷ͹
͵ͪ͵ͬͪ
ΒͰ
;Ͷ͹ͭͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
;

Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͻͪΔ;
ͳ
͹ͯͻͱͪͬͪΔ;
ͼͽͰͻͰ͹ͽͳͺͪ
͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
ͳ
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΔ;

Ͳͪͷͳ΃ΓͰ͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸ͳ΀
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͵ͻͰͳͻͪΔͰ
ͺͰͻͳͿͰ
ͻͳΒͪ
ͳ
͵ͪ͵ͪͬ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳ
ͽ͹ͷͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͱͪ͸ͻͪ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͳͷͪ
͵ͪ͹

ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸ͳ͵;
;
͵ͻͰͳͻͪΔ;
ͳ
;΂ͬͻ΃ΕͳͬͪΔ;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
͹ͫͻͪ
Ͳͪ΁ͪ
ͼͽͰͻͰ͹ͽͳͺͪ
ͳ
ͷͳͽ͹ͬͪ

͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͹ͯͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͱͪ͸ͻͪ
ͳ
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͻͪΔͰ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼͪ

́ͲͷͰΌ;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹

Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳ΀
ͼͶͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹
ͽͪ͵͹
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳ΀
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵ͪ
͇ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͪ
ͼͶͳ΂
͸͹ͼͽ
ΒͰ
;
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ͯͪ
ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͯ͹͸͹ͼͰ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ
΁ͳΒͰ
͹
ͯͻ;ͭ͹Β
ͳ
͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹Β
ͲͰͷΓͳ
ͳͶͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͳ
͇ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵ͪ

ΒͰ
;
͹ͼ͹ͫͳ͸ͪͷͪ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼͪ
ͳ
͵͹͸ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
;
͵͹ͷͰ
ͼͰ
ͽͪΒ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼ
͵͹͸ͼͽͳ
ͽ;ͳ΃Ͱ
ͯ͹͵
;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͳͷͪ
ͪͯͻͰͼͪͽ
͸Ͱͷͪ
ͬͪͱ͸;
;Ͷ͹ͭ;
;
͹ͫͶͳ͵͹ͬͪΔ;

ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼͪ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
;
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹ͼͽͳ
;ͼͷͰͻͰ͸
͸ͪ
ͪͯͻͰͼͪ
ͽͪ
ͳ
;
ͬͰͶͳ͵͹Β
ͷͰͻͳ
ͯͳͻͰ͵ͽͳͬͪ͸
̽͹͵
;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͳͷͪ
͵Γ;΂͸ͪ
;Ͷ͹ͭͪ

ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ΁;
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼ
;
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹ͼͽͳ
͹ͫͶͳ͵͹
ͬͪ͸
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͻͰ΁ͳͺͳΒͰ͸ͽ;
m
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ
̽ͳͼ͵;ͻͼ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͹ͯͶͳ͵;ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͬͳ
ͼ͹͵ͳͷ
ͼͽͰͺͰ͸͹ͷ
ͻͰͿͰͻͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͶ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͵͹͸͵ͻͰͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
Ϳͪ͵ͽ;ͪͶ͸͹ͼͽͳ

ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ͸Ͱ
Ͷ͹΁ͳͻͪ͸͹ͼͽͳ
m
;ͺ;Ε;ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͬͻͶ͹
͵͹͸͵ͻͰͽ͸Ͱ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͰ
ͳ

Ͷ͹͵ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͯ͹͵
;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͳͷͪ
ͽͪ͵ͬͪ
ͻͰͿͰͻͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͶ͸͹ͼͽ
͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͻͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹
Βͪͽͳ
́ͪ͵͹
ͼ;
ͼͰ
;
97***
ͳ
9*9
ͬͰ͵;
ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͳ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
͹ͯͶͳ͵͹ͬͪͶͳ

Ϳͪ͵ͽ;ͪͶ͸͹΃Ε;
Ͳͪ
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͻͪΔͰ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͳ
ͼͽͰͻͰ͹ͽͳͺ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͪ

;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
ͫͳͶͰ
ͼ;
ͯͪͶͰ͵͹
ͺ͹ͭ͹ͯ͸ͳΒͰ
͹͸Ͱ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸Ͱ
Ϳ͹ͻͷͰ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ

ͼͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ΁ͳ
͸ͳͼ;
;ͼͻͰͯͼͻͰΌͳͬͪͶͳ
͸ͪ
Ϳͪ͵ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒ;
ͳ
ͼͺ͹Γͪ΃Δ;

ͻͰͪͶ͸͹ͼͽ
͸Ͱͭ͹
͸ͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͰͿͶͰ͵ͼͳͬ͸;
ͷͰ΃ͪͬͳ͸;
Ϳͪ͵ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
ͳ
Ϳͳ͵
΁ͳΒͰ
́
͸ͪ
͵ͻͪΒ;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͳ
ͼ;
ͺͳͼͪ͸ͳ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸Ͱ
ͻͪ΂;͸ͪ
͸ͪ
ͽ͹
ͯͪ
ΕͰ

ͼͰ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ
΂ͳͽͪͶͪ΁
͸ͪΕͳ
͸ͪ
ͷͰͼͽ;
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
͹ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
ͯ͹͵
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ

;ͼͶ͹ͬ
Ͳͪ
ͪͯͰ͵ͬͪͽ͸͹
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳ͹͸ͳͼͪΔͰ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͹͸ͪΒ
͵͹
ͳ΀
΂ͳ
ͽͪ
ͽ͹
΂ͳ͸ͳ
ͪ

;
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼ;
͹ͯͶ;΂ͳͬͪΔͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;ͺ;ͽͳ
;
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸;
ͲͰͷΓ;

ͳͶͳ
͹ͫͶͪͼͽ
ͳͶͳ
ͫ

;
ͽͻͰ͸;ͽ͵;
͵ͪͯ
ͼͰ
ͽͪͷ͹
ͬͰΕ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ


͉ͪͲͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂ͪͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹ͭ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪ
͹ͯ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
ͳͼͽ͹΂
͸Ͱ
ͳ
Β;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͰͻͳͿͰͻͳΒͰ
͸ͪͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͺ;͸ͳͷ
ͳ͸ͽͰ͸
ͲͳͽͰͽ͹ͷ
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
ͯͰͬͰͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͸Ͱͼͽͪ͸͵͹ͷ
ͭͬ͹ͲͯͰ͸Ͱ

ͲͪͬͰͼͰ
͵͹Ͷͪͺͼ͹ͷ
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶͳͲͷͪ
ͳ
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
ͼͪ
ͽͻͪͭͳ΂͸ͳͷ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳͷͪ

;
ͫͳͬ΃͹Β
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
͹ͬͳͷ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼͳͷͪ
ͬͰΕ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸ͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͪ
ͺͪ



́ͼͺ
.
#BLJǀ)BZEFO
J
3
)BZEFO
0SJFOUBMJTU
7BSJBUJPOT
PO
UIF
5IFNF

A#BMLBOT
4ZNCPMJD
(FPHSBQIZ
JO
SFDFOU
:VHPTMBW
$VMUVSBM
1PMJUJDT
4MBWJD
3FWJFX




 ̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
;
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸ͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ 

ͱΔͪ
ͪ͸ͽͻ͹ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͭͪ
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳ΂ͪͻͪ
̽ͳͼ͵;ͻͲͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͷͰ΀ͪ͸ͳͲͷͰ
͹ͬͰ
͵;Ͷ
ͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͯͳͿͰͻͰ͸΁ͳΒͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͷ͹
ͳ
;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
͌
ͽͰ͵
ͼͽ;
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͶͰͯͳ

ͫͪͬͳΕͰͷ͹
ͼͰ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳͷ
͹ͯͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼͪ
ͺ͹ͷ͹Ε;
͵͹
ΒͰͭ
ͼͰ
;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͻͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͪ
͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
͵ͪ͹

Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹Β
ͺͰͻͳͿͰͻͳΒͳ
ͺ͹ͻͰ͵Ͷ͹ͷ
ͽ͹ͭ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳͷ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β͸ͳͷ

ͺ;ͽͰͷ
ͳ
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
͹ͬͪΒ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼ
ͳͷͪ
;
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͻͪΔ;
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹Ͱ
ͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͽͰͽͪ

͈ͼͰ;ͯ͹ͪ͸ͽͻ͹ͺ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼ
;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ

͌
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͪ
ͺͰͻ΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ΀
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
;
ͬͰͶͳ͵͹Β

ͷͰͻͳ
ͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͪͽ
ͺͻ͹ͽ͹ͻ͹ͷͪ͸ͽͳ΂ͪͻͼ͵͹ͭ
͵͹͸ͲͰͻͬͪͽͳͬͳͲͷͪ
Ͳͪͼ͸͹ͬͪ͸͹ͭ

͸ͪ
΀ͰͻͯͰͻ͹ͬͼ͵ͳͷ
ͳͯͰΒͪͷͪ
͹
ͪ;ͽͰ͸ͽͳ΂͸͹ͷ
ͯ;΀;
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
͋ͪ
ͺͰͻ
΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸ͳΒͰ
ͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͪͽ

ͳͼ͵ͻͳͬΓͪͬͪΔͪ
͎ͰͻͯͰͻ͹ͬͳ΀
ͳͯͰΒͪ

ͷͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
͹͸
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
͹ͺͳͼ͹ͷ
ͬͻͶͳ͸ͪ
ͳ

͸Ͱ͹ͯͼͽͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ΀
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ

΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬͳ͹
͹ͼ͸͹ͬͰ
Ͳͪ
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͰ

ͼͽͰͻͰ͹ͽͳͺ͸͹ͭ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
tͯ͹ͷͳ͸ͪ͸ͽ͸ͳ΀
̻Ͱͻͷͪ͸ͪi
ͳ
tͺ͹͵͹ͻ͸ͳ΀

͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͪi
͢Ͱͭ͹ͬͪ
ͳͯͰΒͪ
͹
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͵͹ͶͰ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͭ
ͯ;΀ͪ
͵͹Βͳ

ͼͰ
ͷͪ͸ͳͿͰͼͽ;ΒͰ
;
͵͹ͶͰ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͪ͵ͼͪͷͪ
ͯ͹ͬͰͶͪ
ΒͰ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
ͯ͹
ͻͪͲ
ͬ͹Βͪ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺͽͪ
͹
tͼ;ͺͰͻͳ͹ͻ͸ͳͷi
ͳ
tͳ͸ͿͰͻͳ͹ͻ͸ͳͷi
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͳͷͪ
͌Ͳ
ͺ͹
ͯͻ΃͵;
͵͹͸ͲͰͻͬͪͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͪ͸ͽͳͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
΀ͪͫͲͫ;ͻ΃͵Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵Ͱ

;
ͺͻͬ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
.FUUFSOJDI

ͻͰͳ͸ͽͰͻͺͻͰͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
΀ͰͻͯͰ
ͻ͹ͬͼ͵ͳ΀
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺͪͽͪ
͆ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
7PML

ͳ
̓;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
,VMUVS

ͻͰͲ;ͶͽͳͻͪͶͪ
ΒͰ

ͻͰͳ͸ͬͰ͸΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͬͻͶͳ͸ͪ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͳ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸͹ͭ


m
.
#BLJǀ)BZEFO
/FTUJOH
0SJFOUBMJTN
5IF
$BTF
PG
'PSNFS
:VHPTMBWJB

4MBWJD
3FWJFX


%
#KFMJǀ
5IF
#BMLBOT
*NBHJOFSZ
BOE
UIF
1BSBEPY
PG
&VSPQFBO

#PSEFST
&VSP[JOF

IUUQXXXFVSP[JOFDPNBSUJDMFmmCKFMJDFOIUNM

.
5PEPSPWB
5IF
#BMLBOT
'SPN
%JTD͹WFSZ
UP
*OWFOUJPO
4MBWJD

3FWJFX



m
.
5PEPSPWB
FE

/BUJPOBM
*EFOUJUJFT
BOE
/BUJPOBM
.FNPSJFT
JO
UIF
#BMLBOT

-POEPO



͎ͰͻͯͰͻ
ΒͰ
̻Ͱͻͷͪ͸Ͱ
͹ͺͳͼͳͬͪ͹
͵ͪ͹
tͱͳͬͳ
Ͳͳͯ
͹
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͯͳͬΓͪ
Ϳ;ͻͳΒͪ
͎;͸ͪ

ͪͅΌͪͻͪ
ͅ͹͸ͭ͹Ͷͪ
ͳ
͋;ͻͪ͵ͪ
ͻͪͲͫͳΒͪ
;
͵͹ͷͪͯͳΕͰu
͏Ͱ͸ͳ͹
ΒͰ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ;
ͬͳͼͳ͸;
ͳ

ͽͰͶͰͼ͸;
ͼ͸ͪͭ;
Δͳ΀͹ͬ;
͵ͻͬ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ;
ͺͻͰͯ;Ͳͳͷͪ΂͵;
;ͼͽͻͪΒ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
͹ͯͶ;΂͸͹ͼͽ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ

΀Ͱͻ͹Βͼ͵ͳ
͹ͼͰΕͪΒ
ͯ;ͱ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͯͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͯͪ
ͷͪͻ΃ͳͻͪΒ;
Ͳͪ
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
ͬ͹Όͪͷͪ
͵;ͯͪ

ͭ͹ͯ
ͳ΀
͹͸ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͰ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͼͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͷͳ΃ΓͰΔ;
;ͬͰ͵
ͫͳͶͳ

͸ͪ
;ͯͪͻ;
̻Ͱͻͷͪ͸ͪ
ͺ͹΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͬ͹ͶͰͶͳ
ͷͳͻ
ͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸͹
ͼ;
ͳͲͭ;ͫͳͶͳ
ͼͬ͹Β;
tͯͪͬ͸ͪ΃Δ;

ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯ;u
ΒͰͻ
͸ͳͼ;
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸͹ͼͰ
ͼͪ
ͭͰͻͷͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͪͭͻͰͼͳΒ͹ͷ
͎ͰͻͯͰͻ
ΒͰ
ͼͪ

ͯͳͬΓͰΔͰͷ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ͹
͹
Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹Β
ͭ͹ͼͽ͹Γ;ͫͳͬ͹ͼͽͳ
ͬͳͯͰ͹
ͳ΀
ΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͺͻͰͯͪ͸Ͱ
ͼͬ͹Β͹Β

ͭͻ;ͫ͹Β
͸ͰͲͪͬͳͼ͸͹ͼͽͳ
Ͷ͹ΒͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͼͷͪͽͻͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
͹͸ͳ
ͺ͹΃ͽ;Β;
Ͳͪ͵͹͸
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͺͻͰͲͳͻ;

͵ͻͪΌ;
ͳ
ͺΓͪ΂͵;
-
+PIOTPO
$FOUSBM
&VSPQF
&OFNJFT
/FJHICPST
'SJFOET
/FX
:PSL

m
0YGPSE



 ͇ͽ͹
̈́;ͽ΀ͪͻ
m
͋ͪΔͪ
͈Ͱͽͻ͹ͬͳΕ

ͺ͹ͻͰͽ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͯͰͿͳ͸ͳͼͪΔͰͷ
tͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀i
ͳ
t͸Ͱͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀i
͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ

́ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
͎ͰͻͯͰͻ
ͫͳ͹
ͬͻͶ͹
ͻͰͲͰͻͬͳͼͪ͸
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͳͯͰΒͳ
͸ͪͺͻͰͽ͵ͪ
ΒͰͻ
ͼ;

ͺ͹ͷ͹Ε;
ΔͰ
ͺͻͪͬΓͰ͸Ͱ
͸Ͱͭͪͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ΒͰ

ͼͬͪ͵ͳ
ͳͷͪ͹
ͪ;ͽͰ͸ͽͳ΂͸;
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ;
ͳ
ͯ;΀
͹͸
͸ͳ͵ͪͯͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͽͬͻͯͳ͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰͯ
͸ͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͳͶͳ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͯͪ
ͫ;ͯͰ
͹΁ͰΔͳͬͪ͸ͪ
ͷͰͻͳͶͳͷͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
͵;Ͷ
ͽ;ͻͰ
͆ͪͺͻ͹ͽͳͬ
ͻͪͲͷͰͽͪΔͰ
ͼͬ͹Β͹ͷ
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͷ
ͳͶͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͹ͷ
͎ͰͻͯͰͻ
ΒͰ

ͼͷͪͽͻͪ͹
͸ͪΒͭͶ;ͺΓͳͷ
͹ͫͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͫͪ΀ͪͽ͹ͼͽͳ
͇ͬͪ͵ͬͪ
Ͷͳ͸ͳΒͪ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪ
ͬͪΔͪ
ͳ
͹ͫΒͪ΃ΔͪͬͪΔͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
͵;Ͷͷͳ͸ͳͻͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
;
͸ͪ΁ͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹Β

ͽͰͻͷͳ͸͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͳ
;
͵͹Β͹Β
Ϳͳͭ;ͻͳͻͪΒ;
)FSSFOWPML
ͳ
4LMBWFOWÕMLFS
ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ
΂ͪΒ͸͹
ΒͰ
;ͽͳ΁ͪͶͪ
͸ͪ
tͭͰ͸͹΁ͳͯ͸Ͱ
ͳͯͰ͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͰi
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ

̽͹͵
;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͳͷͪ
ͳͲ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͷ͹ͱͰͷ͹
͸ͪΕͳ
͹ͯͫͶͰͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͬͳ΀

ͺͻ͹ͽ͹ͻ͹ͷͪ͸ͽͳ΂ͪͻͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳͯͰΒͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂Ͱ
͹ͯͶͳ͵;ΒͰ
ͯͻ;ͭͪ
ͬͻ
ͼͽͪ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͳ΀
ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͪͬͪ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸ͳͷ
ͷͰͯͳΒͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͳͲͬͰ΃ͽͪ
ͬͪΒ;
͹
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳͷͪ
;
ͺ͹ͼͽ͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͺͼͰ;ͯ͹ͪ͸ͽͻ͹
ͺ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼ
;
͵͹ͷͰ
ͼͰ
ͼ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͯͳͼͽͪ͸΁ͪ

͵͹Βͪ
ͫͳ
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
ͯͪ
͹ͫͰͲͫͰͯͳ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
͸Ͱ;ͽͻͪͶ͸͹ͼͽ
͸ͪͻͪ΁ͳΒͰ

ͼ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
;ͺͻͪͬ͹
ͽͪ
ͯͳͼͽͪ͸΁ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯͳ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼ
;
͵͹ͷͰ
ͼ;
Γ;
ͯͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͯͷͰͽ
͸ͪͻͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹
ͯͻ;ͭͪ΂ͳΒͳ

͸Ͱ͹ͫͳ΂͸ͳ
͵ͪ͹
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳ
ͺ͹ͼͷͪͽͻͪΔͪ

̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
͵ͪ͹
ͻͳͲ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͪ
ͳ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͵͹ͯ

ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͳͲͪͲͳͬͪ
ͻ͹ͷͪ͸ͽͳ΂ͪͻͼ͵͹
͹ͯ;΃ͰͬΓͰΔͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͯͪ

ͼͰ
ͺͻͰ͸ͰͼͰ
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͌
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
Ͳͪ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒ;
-POFMZ
QMBOFUB

ͼͽ͹Βͳ
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͳ
͹ͺͳͼ
i5IF
UJNFIFXO
JOGMVFODF
PG
SFHJPOBM
DVMUVSFT

BOE
PG
0SUIPEPY
$ISJTUJBOJUZ
XJUI
*TMBN
IBT
QSPEVDFE
JO
.BDFEPOJB

B
VOJRVF
DVMUVSF
BOE
B
EJTUJODU
QFPQMF
UIBU
EFTFSWFT
NPSF
UIBO
B
QBT
TJOH
HMBODF
PO
UIF
XBZ
UP
TPNFXIFSF
FMTF
.BDFEPOJB
JT
NFEJFWBM
NP
OBTUFSJFT
UJNFXPSO
5VSLJTI
CB[BBST
0SUIPEPY
DIVSDIFT
BOE
TQBDFBHF

TIPQQJOH
DFOUSFT
*U
JT
BMTP
UIF
ESPOF
PG
UIF
MPDBM
CBHQJQFT
5VSLJTITUZMF



́ͼͺ
#
*TJBI
7JDP
BOE
)FSEFS
5XP
4UVEJFT
JO
UIF
)JTUPSZ
PG
*EFBT
/FX
:PSL


-
+PIOTPO
$FOUSBM
&VSPQF


͌
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸ͳͷ
ͷͰͯͳΒͳͷͪ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳ
͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
ͫͳͬ΃Ͱ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ

ͯͰͬͰͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ͸ͳ
ͳͲ
ͺͰͻͼͺͰ͵ͽͳͬͰ
ͺͼͰ;ͯ͹ͪ͸ͽͻ͹ͺ͹Ͷ͹΃͵͹ͭ

ͺ͹ͼͷͪͽͻͪ΂ͪ
͵ͪ͹
tTBWBHF
TQFDUBDMF
BMMJFO
UP
PVS
DJWJMJ[FE
TZTUFN
BOE
WBMVFTu
4

ÂJßFL
$BVHIU
JO
"OPUIFST
%SFBN
JO
#PTOJB
8IZ
#PTOJB 
8SJUJOHT
PO
UIF
#BMLBO

8BS
3
"MJ
-
-JGTDIVMU[
;ͻ

4UPOZ
$SFFL
1BNQIMFUFFST


JTQ
"
#PSDJMB

5SBWFM
(VJEFT
UP
i&BTUFSO
&VSPQFu
1PTU$PNNVOJTN
4JUFT
BOE
"NFSJDBO
5SBWFMFST
ͻͪͯ

ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸
͸ͪ
7
$POHSFTT
PG
UIF
"NFSJDBT
6OJWFSTJEBE
EF
MBT
"NFSJDBT
1VCFCMB

.FYJDP
m
PLUPCBS


 ̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
;
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸ͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ 

HSJMMFE
NJODFNFBU
BOE
#BMLBO
CVSFL
DIFFTF
PS
NFBU
QJF

5IF
DPVOUSZ

JT
VOCFMJFWBCMZ
HSFFO
BOE
CSFBUIUBLJOHMZ
HPSHFPVT
JUT
QFPQMF
BSF
IPTQJ
UBCMF
BOE
XFMDPNJOH
PG
WJTJUPSTi

́ͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪ
ͳ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͽ͹Βͳ

̀ͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂Ͱ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ΂͸͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͰ
ͻͰͪͶ
͸͹ͼͽͳ
;
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪ
ͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
;Ͳͫ;ͯΓͳͬͰ
ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͸ͪ
͵͹Β͹Β
Ͳͪͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͷͪͽͻͪ΂
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
ͼͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯͪ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͭͶͰͯͪͽͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ;
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
;ͺͻͪͬ͹
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪ
ͫͪ΃

͵ͪ͹
͸ͪ
ͽͰͶͰͬͳͲͳΒͼ͵͹ͷ
Ͱ͵ͻͪ͸;
;
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
͹ͯ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
Ͳͪ
͉;ͷ;͸ͳΒ;
ͳͲ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵;
ͼͰ
ͼ͵ͻͰΕͰ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
ͯͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͬ͹ͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔ;
ͷ͹ͱͰ

ͺ͹ͼͽͪͽͳ
ͼͬͰͯ͹͵
ͼͺͰ͵ͽͪ͵;Ͷͪͻ͸͹ͭ
ͻͪͼͺͪͯͪΔͪ
tUIF
IJTUPSJDBM
TQFDUBDMF

PG
B
DSVNCMJOH
SFHJNF
ZJFMEJOH
JO
QMBDFT
UP
TQSPVUT
PG
MJCFSBUFE
JOJUJBUJ
WF
BOE
BDUJWJUZi
͊Ͷͳ΂͸͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
;
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
tBT
UIF
PME
TPDJFUZ

EJTJOUFHSBUFT
UIF
SFHJPO
PGGFST
UIF
QPMJUJDBM
TJHIUTFJOH
PQQPSUVOJUZ
PG
B

MJGFUJNF
UP
UIF
USBWFMFS
XIP
XBOUT
NPSF
UIBO
HSBOE
QIPUP
PQQPSUVOJUJFT

BOE
4PDJBMJTU
TPVWFOJSTi
t'PS
UIF
USBWFMFS
XJUI
UIF
MBUFTU
NBQ
JO
IBOE

UIJT
SFHJPO
PGGFST
B
SBSF
PQQPSUVOJUZ
UP
HMJNQTF
IJTUPSZ
TUSVHHMJOH
XJUI

UIF
GVUVSF
UIF
DPMMJTJPO
PG
DPNNBOE
BOE
NBSLFU
FDPOPNJFT
BOE
PG
DP
VSTF
&BTU
DPOGSPOUJOH
8FTUi
͌
ͳͲͬͰͼ͸͹ͷ
ͼͷͳͼͶ;
͵͹͸ͽͻͪͯͳ͵ͽ͹ͻ͸ͪ
;ͺͻͪͬ͹
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸͹Β
ͯͳ͸ͪͷͳ΂
͸͹Β
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͪ
͹
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β

̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸;
;
͵͹ͷͰ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͼͽ͹Βͳ
ͽͰ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͼͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯͪ

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͳ
͸Ͱ͵;
ͬͻͼͽ;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ

ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͽΒ
;
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽ
ͭͯͰ
ͭͪ
΂Ͱ͵ͪΒ;
͸Ͱͽͪ͵͸;ͽͪ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͪ
ͳ
͸ͪͼͰΓͰ͸ͪ

ͷͰͼͽͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼ;
tCMFTTFEMZ
CFIJOE
UIF
UJNFTi
t$SVNCMJOH
GBDBEFT
EJMBQJ
EBUFE
QBMBDFT
BOE
USFBDIFSPVT
DPCCMFE
TUSFFUT
CPUI
TIPDL
BOE
FODIBOU

UIF
WJTJUPS
VTFE
UP
B
XPSME
XIFSF
XIBU
SFNBJOT
PG
IJTUPSZ
IBT
CFFO
TQVS
DFE
VQ
G͹S
UVSJTU
FZFTi
"
#PSDJMB
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͯͪ
t&BTUFSO
&VSPQF
BQQFBST




-POFMZ
1MBOFU
.BDFEPOJB
IUUQXXXMPOFMZQMBOFUDPNEFTUJOBUJPOTFVSPQF
NBDFEPOJB


"
5BOFS
FU
BM
'SPNNFST
#VEHFU
5SBWFM
(VJEF
&BTUFSO
&VSPQF
PO

B
%BZ

/FX
:PSL


ͪͅͽͰͻͳΒͪͶ
ͳͲ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
'SPNNFST
3BQPQPSU
ͳ

'PEPST
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
"
#PSDJMB
5SBWFM
(VJEFT
UP
i&BTUFSO
&VSPQFu


3
3BQPQPSU
(SFBU
$JUJFT
PG
&BTUFSO
&VSPQF
4BOUB
'F

YJJ


́ͼͽ͹
Y


́ͼͽ͹



.
#BLFS
5IF
$[FDI
3FQVCMJD
'PEPST
&BTUFSO
BOE
$FOUSBM
&VSPQF
+
+FOOJGFS

1BVMM
;ͻ

/FX
:PSL


 ͇ͽ͹
̈́;ͽ΀ͪͻ
m
͋ͪΔͪ
͈Ͱͽͻ͹ͬͳΕ

BT
B
UFSSJUPSZ
UIBU
IBT
TPNFIPX
CFFO
GSP[FO
JO
UIF
QBTU
QSFDJTFMZ
CFDBV
TF
PG
UIF
ZFBST
PG
$PNNVOJTN
UIBU
LFQU
JU
JTPMBUFE
GSPN
UIF
8FTU
ѮJT
&BTUFSO
&VSPQF
PGGFST
UIF
SFBEFSUPVSJTU
UIF
PQQPSUVOJUZ
PG
UJNFUSBWFM

JOUP
B
EFFQFS
BOE
EFFQFS
QBTU
UIF
PQQPSUVOJUZ
PG
TMJQQJOH
JOUP
B
EJGGF
SFOU
NPSF
DPNGPSUJOH
XPSMEi
͈ͻͰͷͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͪͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͯͪΒ;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͯͪ

ͼͰ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ
;
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
ͳ
́ͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
͹ͯͬͳΒͪ
;
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
͸Ͱ
ͭ͹
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͫͻͲͳ͸ͪ
͵͹Β͹ͷ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͺͻ͹ͶͪͲͳ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;ΒͰ
͹ͯ
͹͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯ;
͹ͯ
ͼ;ͼͽͬ͹
͵ͪͺͳͽͪͶͳͲͷͪ
ͯ͹͸ͰͶ͹
ΒͰ
tB
XSBQQFE
TFOTF
PG
UJNF
UIF
JOUFOTJUZ

PG
GSJFOETIJQT
UIF
BCTFODF
PG
DPOTUBOU
TFOTPSZ
BTTBVMUT
UISPVHI
BEWFSUJ
TNFOUTi

͡;ͯͳ
ͼͪ
ͻͰͺ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͫ͹ͶͰͼͽ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶͳͲͷͪ
t͵Ͷͳ͸ͳ΂͵ͳi

ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼ
͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;

͋͹͵͹ͷ
97**
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺΓͪ͸ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪͶͳ
͸ͪ

̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
ͫͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͳͷͺͻͰͼͳ͹͸ͳͻͪ͸ͳ
tͰͿͳ͵ͪͼ͸͹΃Ε;
͹ͽ͹ͷͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͫͳͻ͹
͵ͻͪͽͳΒͰ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͬ͹Β͸ͳ΀
ͼ͸ͪͭͪ
ͳͷͺͰͻͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͻͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹΃Ε;

͹ͽ͹ͷͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͪi
ͪͶͳ
ͼ;
;
ͳͼͽ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯ
Γ;ͯͳ
ͼͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ

͹ͺͳͼͳͬͪͶͳ
͵ͪ͹
͸ͪ͵ͪͲͪ͸
ͳ
ͯͳͬΓͳ

̾ͬͻ͹΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͳ΂͸ͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͺͻͰͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ

̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
ͺ;͸ͪ
tͪ͸ͽͳͽ;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͺͪͭͪ͸ͯͰi
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͻͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬ;
͹

ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͇ͽ͹ͷͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͷͺͰͻͳΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
͵ͻͬ͹ͱͰͯ͸ͳͷ
ͳ
͸ͰΓ;ͯͼ͵ͳͷ

ͯͳͬΓͪ΁ͳͷͪ
ͻͪͽ͹ͫ͹ͻ͸ͳͷ
ͳ

͸Ͱ΁ͳͬͳͶͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͳͷ
ͳ
ͪͭͻͰͼͳͬ͸ͳͷ
Γ;ͯͳ
ͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͬͰ͵͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͱͳͬͰͶͳ
ͺ͹ͯ
;ͽͳ΁ͪΒͰͷ
t͸Ͱ͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
͋;ͻͪ͵ͪ

m
ΒͰͶͳ
͵͹Δͼ͵͹
ͷͰͼ͹
ͳ

ͺͻͰͲͳͻͪͶͳ
͸ͪ;͵;i 
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͶͳ
ͳͼͽͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ

Δͳ΀͹ͬͳ
;ͭΔͰͽͪ΂ͳ

̽ͰͬͰͽ͸ͪͰͼͽͳ
ͬͰ͵
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳ΃Ͱ
;ͼͶ͹ͱΔͪͬͪΔͰ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼͪ
͹
tͯͻ;
ͭͪ΂ͳΒ͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳi
;͹ͫͶͳ΂ͪͬͪΔͰͷ
ͳͯͰΒͪ
͹
tͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͳi
tͬͰͼͽͰͻ
͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͳi
ͳ
tͰͬͻ͹ͺͰͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͳi
ͽͰ
ͯͻ;ͭͪ΂ͳΒͰ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
͉ͪͲͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;

Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹ͭ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͰͻͳͿͰͻͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪΒ;
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͸Ͱ
ͭ͹
͹΂ͳͭͶͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͷͪͯͪ
ͼ;
ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͪ
Ͳͪ
ͳͼͽͳ΁ͪΔͰ
ͽͳ΀
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͶͪ



"
#PSDJMB
5SBWFM
(VJEFT
UP
i&BTUFSO
&VSPQFu


3
3BQPQPSU
(SFBU
$JUJFT
PG
&BTUFSO
&VSPQF
Y


͋Ͱͻͷͳ͸
i͵Ͷͳ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼu
;ͬ͹ͯͳ
"
#PSDJMB
5SBWFM
(VJEFT
UP
i&BTUFSO

&VSPQFu


5
.BTUOBL
&WSPQB
.FE
FWPMVDJKP
JO
FWUBOB[JKP
-KVCMKBOB


ͳͼͺ

ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
&
.FVUIFO
%FS
'BMM
WPO
,POTUBOUJOPQFM
VOE
EFS
MBUFJOJTDIF
8FTUFO
%FS
'SJFEF

VOUFS
3FMJHJPOFO
OBDI
/JDPMBT
WPO
,VFT
3
)BVCTU
;ͻ

.BJO[

 ̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
;
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸ͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ 

ͼ͹Ϳͳͼͽͳ΁ͳͻͪ͸ͳΒͪ
́ͼͽͳ΂;
ͼͰ
ͻͰͶͳͭͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷ͸Ͱ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵Ͱ 
ͽͰͶͰͼ͸Ͱ

͹ͼ͹ͫͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
ͼ;ͻ͹ͬ͹ͼͽ
Γ;ͯͳ
ͼͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
͊;ͻ͹ͬ͹ͼͽ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ
͸͹
ͳͼͽͳ΁ͪͶͪ
͵ͪ͹
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵ͪ
Γ;ͯͳ
;
ͺ͹ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂͸ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͳͷͪ

m
ͽͳͺͳ΂͸ͪ
Ͳͪ
͵ͻͪΒͳ΃͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͳ
͏ͻ͸͹ͭ͹ͻ΁Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͰ
ͺ͹
ͽ͹ͷͰ
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
͵;
ͭͶͪΒ;
Γ;ͯͼ͵ͳͷ
Ͷ͹ͫͪΔͪͷͪ
͆Ͱ͸͹ͻͷͪͶ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͰ
ͬͻͼͽͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼ͸ͪ
͵͹͸ͼͽͪ͸ͽͪ
;

ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸͹Β
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͳ
ͳ
ͻͪͲ͸ͳͷ
ͬͻͼͽͪͷͪ
ͰͼͰΒͳͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
;

9*9
ͬͰ͵;
ΒͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͼͰ
ͳ
;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
;
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͳͷ
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳ
Βͪͷͪ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͭͯͰ
ͼͻͰΕͰͷ͹
͸ͪͻͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
t͸Ͱ͸͹ͻͷͪͶ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͲͷͪi

ͽͻͪ;ͷͪͽͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͼͳͻ͹ͷͪ΃ͽͬ;
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͼ;ͺͻ͹ͽͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺ
ͼ͵͹Β
ͯͰͷ͹͵ͻͪͽͳΒͳ
͸͹ͻͷͪͶ͸͹ͷ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ;
ͺͻ͹ͭͻͰͼ;
ͳ
ͯͰͿͳ͸ͳͼͪ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹
ͻͰͽ͵;
̓ͪ͵͹
ͼͽ͹Βͳ
;
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
͹ͯ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
tOBUJPOBMJTN
BOE

CVMMFUT
UISFBUFO
UP
UFBS
BQBSU
UIF
NPSF
CBDLXBSE
#BMLBOJ[FE
DPVOUSJFT

NPSF
USBHJDBMMZ
:VHPTMBWJBi
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸
͵ͪ͹
͹ͫͶͪͼͽ
ͽͻͪ;ͷͪ
ͽͳ΂͸͹ͭ
;
͵͹Β͹Β
͸ͳΒͰ
ͯ͹΃Ͷ͹
ͯ͹
ͻͪͯͳ͵ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
ͳ
;
͵͹Β͹Β
ͼͰ
ͼͪ

͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͯͳ͵ͽͪͽ;ͻͪ
ͺͻͰ΃Ͷ͹
͸ͪ
͸Ͱ͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͯͳ͵ͽͪͽ;ͻͰ

ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͪ
Ͱͬ͹Ͷ;΁ͳΒͪ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͪͽͳ΂͸ͪ
m
͹͸Ͱ

ͼ;
ͳ
ͯͪΓͰ
ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͸ͪͼͳͶ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͬͻͪͽͪ
ͭͯͰ
tFUIOJD
GFVET
BSF
QSP
EVDJOH
TQBTNT
PG
WJPMFODFi
̾ͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ
͵͹͸ͿͶͳ͵ͽͳ
tͫ͹ͶͰͼͽ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪi

ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ
ͼ;
͵ͪ͹
ͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯͳ΁ͪ
Ͳͪ͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͼͽͳ
;
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ

͹ͯ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͼͰ
ͯͪ
;
ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β

̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
tFWFSZXIFSF
FOFSHZ
PG
SFDPOTUSVDUJPO
JT
WJTJCMFi
ͪͶͳ
tTPNF
PG

UIF
DPVOUSJFT
DPOUJOVF
UP
MBH
CFIJOEi
͋ͪ͵͹
;
͉;ͷ;͸ͳΒͳ
ͳ
̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵͹Β

Ͳͫ͹ͭ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͰ
Ͳͪ͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͼͽͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͶͪ΁
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͬͳͯͰͽͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶͳͲͪͷ
ͳ

Ͱͽ͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
͵͹͸ͿͶͳ͵ͽͰ
ͪͶͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
ͳ
tͺͻͰͯͰͶͰ
͸Ͱͳͼ͵ͬͪͻͰ͸Ͱ
͵ͪͺͳ
ͽͪͶͳͲͷ͹ͷi



t̿Ͱ͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͪu
͸ͳΒͰ
͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͪ
ͻͪͬ͸͹ͯ;΃͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂͸͹
͸ͳ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ

ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ΁ͪ
͌
Δͳ΀͹ͬͳͷ
͹ͺͳͼͳͷͪ
ͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͯͪͶͷͪͽͳ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͱͰ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ͸Ͱ

ͼ;
͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͶͰͺͰ
ͳ
ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ͸͹
ͭͻͪΌͰ͸Ͱ
͢ͳ΀͹ͬͳ
ͷ;΃͵ͳ
ͺͪͻͽ͸Ͱͻͳ
ͼ;
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ

ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͳͬͪ͸ͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͼͶͳ΂͸ͳ
ͯͳͬΓͳͷ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͳΔͪͷͪ
ͼͪ
ͷͪͶͳͷ
͹΂ͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͳͼͽͪ͵͸;ͽͳͷ

΂ͰͶ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͫͰͲ
ͳͷͪͶ͹
ͺͶͰͷͰ͸ͳͽͰ
ͭͻͪΌͰ



̺ͳ΃Ͱ
͹
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ͬ
͵͹ͯ
#
+F[FSOJL
%FßFMB
LKFS
KF
WTF
OBSPCF
-KVCMKBOB


m
ͳͼͺ
ͳ
͹ͺͳͼͰ
ͼ;ͻ͹ͬ͹ͼͽͳ
͌ͼ͵͹͵ͪ
;
ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͪ΂͵͹Β
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹Β
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ

͵͹ΒͰ
ͯͪΒͰ
.
)MBEOJL
4MPWBOJ
W
TMPWFOTLJ
[HPEPWJOTLJ
QPWFTUJ
IUUQXXXJKTTJMJU
TMPWBOJIUNM



8
&DIJLTPO
5IF
/FX
&BTUFSO
&VSPQF
JO
'PEPST

&BTUFSO
&VSPQF
$I

#JMMZ
;ͻ

/FX
:PSL





8
&DIJLTPO
*OUSPEVDUJPO
JO
'PEPST

&BTUFSO
&VSPQF
$I
#JMMZ
;ͻ


/FX
:PSL

YYJJJ


8
&DIJLTPO
*OUSPEVDUJPO
JO
'PEPST
&BTUFSO
&VSPQF
$I
#JMMZ
;ͻ

/FX

:PSL

YYJW
 ͇ͽ͹
̈́;ͽ΀ͪͻ
m
͋ͪΔͪ
͈Ͱͽͻ͹ͬͳΕ

ͅͰͽͪͿ͹ͻͪ
ͷ͹ͼͽͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
͵ͪ͹
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͷͰͼͽ͹
ͼ;ͼͻͰͽͪ
ͼͬͰͽ͹
ͬͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
t͸ͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͪ
ͺ;ͽͪi

͇ͺ΃ͽͰ
ͷͰͼͽ͹
;
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͳͬͪΔ;
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
;
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͳ΀
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹

ͬͰ͵͹ͬͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͷͰͽͪͿ͹ͻͪ
tͷ͹ͼͽͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
΁ͳͬͳͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪi
ͷͰΌ;
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
͵͹Βͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͳ
;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
͸ͳͽͳ
͸ͪ
͇ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽ;
ͪ
ͳͼͽ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͯͰ͹
ͳ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͳ
͇ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͪ
͌
͵ͪͼ͸͹ͷ
97***
ͬͰ͵;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳ
ͼ΁ͳ
ͼͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯͪ
ͺͳ΃;
ͼͪ
ͺ;͸͹
ͼͳͷͺͪͽͳΒͰ
͹
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳͷͪ

͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
tͳͲͷͰΌ;
̸ͲͳΒͰ
ͳ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
ͼͽͪͽͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ

ͺͻ͹ͭͻͰͼͪ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͫ;ͯ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳi
͵͹Βͳ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͯͪ
ͯ͹ͺͻͳ͸Ͱͼ;
ͳͼ
ͺͻͪͬΓͪΔ;
;ͬͻͰͱͰ͸ͳ΀
ͼͽͰͻͰ͹ͽͳͺͪ
͹
͇ͼͷͪ͸ͶͳΒͪͷͪ
͇ͬͪ
ͼͳͷͺͪͽͳΒͪ

͵ͪ͹
;͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͯͰͬͰͽ͸ͪͰͼͽ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹
ͻ͹ͷͪ͸ͽͳ΂ͪͻͼ͵͹
͹ͺͳͼͳͬͪΔͰ
͊ͻ
ͫͪ
͵ͪ͹
tͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯ͹Γ;ͫͳͬͳ΀i
̹;ͭͪͻͪ
͵ͪ͹
tͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ͸ͳ΀i
͋;ͻͪ͵ͪ
͵ͪ͹

t΀;ͷͪ͸ͳ΀i
ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
;
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳΒͳ
ͯͳͿͰͻͰ͸΁ͳΒͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
͵͹͸ͼͽͻ;͵΁ͳΒͰ
ͺͰ
ͻͳͿͰͻͳΒͰ
;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ;
͸ͪ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻ
͸ͳ΃ͽͪ
ͷͪΔͰ
͹ͯ
͹ͺͳͼͪ
ͼ;ͻ͹
ͬ͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͯͳͬΓͪ΃ͽͬͪ
ͽͳ΀
ͳͼͽͳ΀
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
́
;
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
ͺ͹
ͺͻͪͬͳͶ;
͸ͪͳͶͪͲͳ
ͷ͹
͸ͪ
ͽͰͷͪͽͳͲͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͽͪ΂͵Ͱ
ͼ;
ͼͻͰͽͪ
ͼͬͰͽ͹ͬͪ
ͽͪΒ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒ
ΒͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
ͻͪͲͶ͹ͭ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽ;

͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸;
ΒͰͻ
ͳͲ
ΔͰͭͪ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͳͶͪͲͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͪ
ͻͪͲ͸͹Ͷͳ͵͹ͼͽ
ͳ
ͫ͹
ͭͪͽͼͽͬ͹
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
;Ͳͻ͹͵
͵ͻͬͪͬͳ΀
Ͱͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͳ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳ΀
ͼ;͵͹ͫͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
;

ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
-POFMZ
1MBOFUB
Ͳͪ
̹͹ͼ͸;
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸;
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͯͪ
t#PTOJB

BOE
)FSDFHPWJOB
PS
#PTOJB
)FS[FHPWJOB
BT
TPNF
QSFGFS
JU

JT
B
DSPTTSP
BET
DPVOUSZ
4BOEXJDIFE
CFUXFFO
$SPBUJB
BOE
4FSCJB
JUT
CFFO
B
[POF

PG
DPOUFOUJPO
TJODF
0DDJEFOU
BOE
0SJFOU
êSTU CFHBO BSNXSFTUMJOH GPS
JU
*UT
CFFO
UISPVHI
$ISJTUJBO
.VTMJN
BOE
0SUIPEPY
IBOET
GPS
B
XIJ
MF
JUT
QFPQMF
TFFNFE
UP
FOKPZ
UIFJS
NVMUJDVMUVSBM
NJMJFVi
͌
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;

ͳͼͽ͹ͭ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂ͪ
Ͳͪ
̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵;
ͷ͹ͱͰͷ͹
ͺͻ͹΂ͳͽͪͽͳ
ͯͪ
t#VMHBSJB
TJUT
BU

UIF
DSPTTSPBET
PG
&VSPQF
BOE
"TJB
SJHIU
JO
UIF
CFMMZ
PG
UIF
#BMLBOTi 
ͪ

;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
Ͳͪ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒ;
ͯͪ
tѮF #BMLBOT IBWF BMXBZT CFFO B TUSBUFHJD
DSPTTSPBET
BOE
.BDFEPOJB
IBT
PGUFO
XPSO
JUT
TIBSF
PG
USPVCMFT
GPS
JUT

UFSSJUPSJBM
QSPXFTTi


͆ͪ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼ
͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
͵ͪ͹
ͷͰͼͽ;
ͼ;ͼͻͰͽͪ
́ͼͽ͹͵ͪ
ͳ
̀ͪͺͪͯͪ

͸ͪͯ͹ͬͰͲ;ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͯͳͼ͵ͻ;ͼ
͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
͵ͪ͹
tͯͰͶ;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
͵͹Βͳ
ͽ͹
͸ͳΒͰi
͌



-POFMZ
1MBOFU
#PTOJB
BOE
)FSDFHPWJOB IUUQXXXMPOFMZQMBOFUDPN
EFTUJOBUJPOTFVSPQFCPTOJB@IFSDFHPWJOB


-POFMZ
1MBOFU
#VMHBSJB
IUUQXXXMPOFMZQMBOFUDPNEFTUJOBUJPOTFVSPQF
CVMHBSJB



-POFMZ
1MBOFU
.BDFEPOJB
 ̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
;
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸ͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ 

ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
͹ͯ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
ΒͰ
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸
͵ͪ͹
tB
SFHJPO
UIBU

MJFT
CFZPOE
PVS
FWFSZEBZ
MJGF
UPVDIJOH
JU
JO
NBOZ
QPJOUT
B
SFHJPO
UIBU

XBT
PODF
BO
JOUFHSBM
QBSU
PG
UIF
&VSPQF
XF
LOPX
QBSU
PG
JUT
DVMUVSF
UIP
VHIU
BSU
BOE
XBZ
PG
MJGF
BOE
ZFU
OFWFS
DPNQMFUFMZ
TP
B
SFHJPO
UIBU
GPS

DFOUVSJFT
MBZ
IBMGXBZ
CFUXFFO
UIF
0DDJEFOU
BOE
0SJFOU
TIBSJOH
JO
UIF

GBTDJOBUJPOT
PG
CPUI
XIJMF
QSFTFSWJOH
JUT
PXO
EFFQMZ
JOHSBJOFE
DIBSBD
UFSi


́Ͳ
ͷͰͽͪͿ͹ͻͪ
ͻͪͼ͵ͻ΃Εͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͷ͹ͼͽͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͰ
͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;

͵ͪ͹
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸;
t͸ͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͪ
ͺ;ͽͪi
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͳͶͪͲͳ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͪ
͹
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ΂͸͹
ͼͽͳ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳ΀
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͹͸ͳ
ͼ;
͹ͯ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸ͳ΀
ͺ;
ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ΁ͪ
ͬͳΌͰ͸ͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹Ͷ;ͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ͸ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷ;΁ͳͬͳͶͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷ;͹ͻͳ
ΒͰ͸ͽͪͶ͸ͳ
͸Ͱ͵͹ͷͺͶͰͽ͸ͳ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂ΒͰ
͸ͰͻͪͲ;ͷΓͳͬ͹
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ
͹΁Ͱ
ͼͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
͹΃ͽͻ͹
ͼ;ͺͻ͹ͽͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͳͯͰΒͳ
tͰͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͰͯͪi

;
͵͹Β͹Β
ΒͰ
Ͱͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͪ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯ͸͹ͼͽ
ͬͻͶ͹
;ͼ͵͹
ͺ͹ͬͰͲͪ͸ͪ
ͼ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳͷ

ΒͰͲͳ͵͹ͷ
ͳ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒ͹ͷ
͌͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͫͶͳͱͰ
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯͪͷ͹
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼ
΂ͳΒͳ
ͼ;

ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ΁ͳ
͸͹ͬͳ͸ͪͻͳ
΂ͳ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͳ
͸ͪ;΂͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͼͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯͪ
͵͹
Βͳ
ͼ;
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ
9*9
ͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͹ͽ͵ͻͳͬͪͶͳ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵;
ͷͰ΃ͪ
ͬͳ͸;
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
ͻͰͶͳͭͳΒͪ
ͳ
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ
ͬͳͯͰΕͰͷ͹
ͯͪ
͹͸ͳ
͹ͬ;
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͼͽͻ;͵͹ͼͽ

ͬͳͯͰ
͵ͪ͹
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
;
ͳͼͽ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
Ͳͫ;Δ;Β;ΕͰ
ͳ
͸ͰͺͻͳΒͪͽ͸͹
;Ͳ͸Ͱͷͳͻ;Β;
ΕͰ
*SWJOF
ͳ
(BM
ͯͪΒ;
͸ͳͲ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻͪ
Ͳͪ
ͽͪ͵ͪͬ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿ

̓ͪͻͶ
Ϳ͹͸
̾ͼͽͻͪΒ΀
,BSM
WPO
¸TUSFJDI

͸ͪͺͳͼͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ

ͼͶͰͯͰΕͰ
ͻͰͯ͹ͬͰ
͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
t*OTUFBE
PG
SBDJBMMZ
QVSF
5VSLT
BOE
"MCBOJ
BOT
XF
GJOE
QFPQMF
XIP
BSF
SBDJBMMZ
NJYFE
BOE
XIPTF
NVMUJMJOHVBMJTN

NJTMFBET
VT
BCPVU
UIFJS
PSJHJOT
TP
UIBU
UIFZ
DBO
CF
DPVOUFE
TPNFUJNFT

BT
(SFFLT
TPNFUJNFT
BT
#VMHBSJBOT
TPNFUJNFT
BT
8BMMBDIJBOTi
̽ͻ;
ͭͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ΁
ͳͲ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
-VDZ
(BSOFUU
͹ͬͪ͵͹
͹ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸
ͼ͵;
t͵͹͸Ϳ;ͲͳΒ;i
;
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ
tB
(SFFL
TQFBLJOH
DPNNVOJUZ
NBZ

QSPWF
UP
CF
8BMMBDIJBO
"MCBOJBO
PS
FWFO
#VMHBSJBO
BOE
UIF
JOIBCJUBOUT

PG
B
4MBWTQFBLJOH
WJMMBHF
NBZ
DMBJN
UP
CF
PG
(SFFL
PSJHJO
"MM
UIFTF
WB
SJPVT
FUIOJDBM
FMFNFOUT
BSF
JO
NBOZ
DPVOUSZ
EJTUSJDUT
PG
.BDFEPOJB
BT

XFMM
BT
JO
UIF
UPXOT
TP
IFMQMFTTMZ
GVTFE
BOE
JOUFSNJOHMFEi
&ISFOQSFJT



$I
#JMMZ
'PEPST

&BTUFSO
&VSPQF
/FX
:PSL

W


+
5
*SWJOF
ͳ
4
(BM
-BOHVBHF
*EFPMPHZ
BOE
-JOHVJTUJD
%JGGFSFOUJBUJPO
3FHJNFT

PG
-BOHVBHF
*EFPMPHJFT
1PMJUJDT
BOE
*EFOUJUJFT
1
7
,SPTLSJUZ
;ͻ

4BOUB
'F


m


,
WPO
¸TUSFJDI
%JF
#FWÕMLFSVOH
WPO
.BLFEPOJFO
(FPHSBQIJTDIF
;FJUTDISJGU

9*




-
(BSOFUU
5VSLJTI
-JGF
JO
5PXO
BOE
$PVOUSZ
/FX
:PSL

m
.

5PEPSPWB
*NBHJOJOH
UIF
#BMLBOT


͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
͸Ͱ͵ͳ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ
;
97***

ͬͰ͵;
ͷͰ΃ͪͶͳ
Ͱͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͪ
ͳ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶ͸ͪ
ͳͷͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪͲͳͬͰ
Ͳͪ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͿͰͼͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ

 ͇ͽ͹
̈́;ͽ΀ͪͻ
m
͋ͪΔͪ
͈Ͱͽͻ͹ͬͳΕ

͹ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
tUIF
-FWBOUJOF
UZQF
JO
UIF
BSFBT
CFUXFFO
UIF
#BMLBOT
BOE
.F
EJUFSSBOFBOi
͵ͪ͹
tQTZDIPMPHJDBMMZ
BOE
TPDJBMMZ
USVMZ
B
AXBWFSJOH
GPSN

B
DPNQPTJUF
PG
&BTUFSOFS
BOE
8FTUFSOFS
NVMUJMJOHVBM
TVQFSGJDJBM
BOE

VOSFMJBCMFi
͋͹ͯ͹ͻ͹ͬͪ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͻͰ΂ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ΁ͪ
ͼͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯͪ
͵͹ͷͰ
ͼͰ

͸ͳͼ;
ͯ͹ͺͪͶͳ
ͻͰͶͳͭͳ͹Ͳ͸ͳ
͹ͫͻͰͯͳ
͵ͪͽ͹Ͷͳ͵ͪ
ͯ;ͱ
ͯͪͶͷͪͽͳ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͫͪͶͰ

ͳ
ͷ͹ͶͳͽͬͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
͹͸ͳ
ͳͲͭ͹ͬͪͻͪΒ;
͸ͪ
ͼͬ͹ͷ
tͺ͹Ͷ;Ͷͪͽͳ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹Ͷ;ͼͶ͹
ͬͰ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;i
͇ͬͪ
ͷͰ΃ͪ͸ͪ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ΂͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͪ
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ
;
ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;

ΒͰ
ͼͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͪͷͪ
͹
tͺ͹Ͷ;ͽͪ͸ͼ͵͹Βi
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͳ
Γ;ͯͳ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
͵͹Βͳ

ͼͰ
;ͬͰ͵
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͰ
;
ͷͰΌ;ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;

ͳ
Ͳͪͽ͹
ͼ;
͸ͰͺͻͰͯͬͳͯΓͳͬͳ
ͳ
͸Ͱͺ͹
;Ͳͯͪ͸ͳ

̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
͵ͪ͹
͹ͭͶͰͯͪͶ͹
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ

͌
ͯ͹ͼͪͯͪ΃ΔͰͷ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
ͺ͹͵;΃ͪͶͳ
ͼͷ͹
ͯͪ
;͵ͪͱͰͷ͹
͸ͪ
͵͹͸ͽͳ͸;ͳ
ͽͰͽ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͪ
͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
ͳ
Β;ͭ͹
ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
͹ͯ

97*
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͸ͪ͹ͬͪͷ͹
͸;ͯͳͶͪ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸ͪ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͪ
ͳ
ͼͶͳ͵Ͱ

͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
͸;ͯͰ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
́
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳ
ͼ͸;
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻ;
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂Ͱ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳ΃Ͱ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
;

Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳΒͳ
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪ
ͳ
ͻͰͭͰ͸ͰͻͳͼͪΔͪ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
t̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰi

ͳ
t̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪi
͋͹͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͳ΀
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒ;
ͳ
ͺ͹
ͽͪΒ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪΒͰ

͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
ͳͯͰ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͯͰ͹
͹ͺ΃ͽͳΒͰͭ
͸ͪͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳ
;

͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͼͶͰͯͳͶͳ
ͻͪͼͺͪͯ;
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͼͳ
ͼͽͰͷͪ
͹Ͳ͸ͪ΂Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹
ͼͽͻͪ͸͹
΁ͳͬͳͶͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸͹Β
͸ͪͺͻͰͯ͸͹Β

ͳ
ͯͰͷ͹͵ͻͪͽͼ͵͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
ͳ
͸Ͱͺͻͳ΀ͬͪͽΓͳͬ͹
Ͳͪ
Δ;
ͳ
ͼͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ

ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹
ͳͲͬ͹ͻ͸͹
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹
ͳ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ΌͰ͸͹
Γ;ͯͳͷͪ
ͳͲ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͻͰͭͳ͹
͸ͪ
͈ͻͳ
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ͼͰ
͵ͪͯ
ͼͰ
ͳͷͪ
;
ͬͳͯ;
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳΒͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ

ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸͹
͸ͪͷͰΕͰ
ͺͳͽͪΔͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͳ
#PSDJMB
t5IF
RVFTUJPO
JT
JG

&BTUFSO
&VSPQFBO
TJUFT
BQQFBS
BT
TJUFT
PG
BCKFDUJPO
IPX
EP
UIFZ
CFDPNF

EFTJSBCMF
USBWFM
EFTUJOBUJPOT i
͇
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͳ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ

ͭͻ;ͺͰ
ͳ
͸ͪͯͳͷ͵Ͱ
͇͸ͳ
ͫͳ
ͼͬͻͼͽͪͬͪͶͳ
;
ͳͼͽͳ
ͭͻ;ͺ;
)VTBSFO
ͼͺͰ΁ͳΒͪͶ͸Ͱ
̸;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ

ͳ
ͪͅΌͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͬ͹Β͸Ͱ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ΁Ͱ

)FZEVLLFO
΀ͪΒͯ;͵Ͱ
;ͼͽͪ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͽͳͬ
͋;ͻͪ͵ͪ


5PMQBUDIFO
͸ͰͼͺͻͰͽΔͪ͵͹ͬͳΕͰ

*OTVSHFOUFO
;ͼͽͪ͸ͳ͵Ͱ

4DMBWPOJFSO
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸Ͱ


1BOEVSFO
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͶͳ
ͪͶͫͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳ΁ͪΒ΁Ͱ

7BSBTEJOFS
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
̺ͪͻͪͱͯͳ͸ͪ

ͭͻͪͯͪ
;
ͼͰͬͰͻ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹Β

-ZDBOFSO


$SPBUFO
͎ͻͬͪͽͰ

.PSMBLFO

ͅ͹ͻͶͪ͵Ͱ

3BJU[FO
͊ͻͫͰ

8BMBDIFO
̺Ͷͪ΀Ͱ

%BMNBUJFOFS
̽ͪͶͷͪͽͳ͸΁Ͱ

6TLPLFO

;ͼ͵͹͵Ͱ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
̺͹Β͸Ͱ
̓ͻͪΒͳ͸Ͱ

ͳͼͺ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
(BCSJFMMB
4DIVCFSU
#FSMJO
VOE

4VFEPTUFVSPQB
#FSMJO
VOE
0TUFVSPQB
,MBVT
.FZFS
;ͻ



m


.
&ISFOQSFJT
5IF
4PVM
PG
UIF
&BTU
&YQFSJFODFT
BOE
3FGMFDUJPOT
/FX
:PSL





.
5PEPSPWB
*NBHJOJOH
UIF
#BMLBOT



"
#PSDJMB
5SBWFM
(VJEFT
UP
i&BTUFSO
&VSPQFu
 ̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
;
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸ͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ 

ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͳ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
ͼͽͪͻ͹ͭ
͵͹͸ͽͳ͸Ͱ͸ͽͪ
͸ͪͺͳͼͪ͸͹
ΒͰ

ͬͰΕ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͽ͹ͭͪ
̀ͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
ΒͰ
tͯͻ;ͭͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͪi
ͰͭͲ͹ͽͳ΂͸ͪ
ͯͻ;
ͭͪ΂ͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͯͪͶͰ͵ͪ
ͺͻͳͬͶͪ΂͸ͪ
;ͺͻͪͬ͹
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
;ͯͪΓͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
4WFUMBOB

#PZN
ͺͳ΃Ͱ
ͯͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯ
ͻͪͯ͹
ͺ͹ͼͰΕ;ΒͰ
͹ͬ;
ͯͻ;ͭ;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺ;
ͪͶͳ
ͷ;
͹͸ͪ

͸ͳ͵ͪͯͪ
͸Ͱ
;ͲͬͻͪΕͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽ;
ͼͳͭ;ͻ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͪ
ͯͳͼͽͪ͸΁ͪ
ΒͰ

͹͸͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
;
͹ͼ͸͹ͬͳ
͹ͬͰ
ͺͻͳͬͶͪ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
m
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͬͰΕͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε
͸͹ͼͽ
ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͪͬͪΔͪ
ͬͰΕͳ
ΒͰ
;
̀ͪͺͪͯ͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
ͼͽͻͪ΀
͹ͯ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͳ
Ͳͪ΁ͳΒͰ
̀ͪͺͪͯ͸ͳ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺΓͪ͸ͳ͸
tBMTP
MPWFE
IJT
JNBHF
PG
IJNTFMG
BT
B

DPVSBHFPVT
USBWFMFS
BOE
B
TISFXE
CBSHBJO
IVOUFS
PO
UIF
PUIFS
TJEFi

͋ͪ
ͼͶͳ͵ͪ
΀ͻͪͫͻ͹ͭ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂ͪ
ͼͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯͪ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͰ
͸ͪΕͳ
ͳ

;
ͼ͵͹ͻ͹
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͷ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹ͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸͹ͷ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ
͸͹ͷ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁;
̸
͹ͯ;΃ͰͬΓͰΔͰ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͰͭͲ͹ͽͳ͵͹ͷ
΀Ͱͯ͹͸ͳͲͷ͹ͷ

͹ͺ;΃ͽͰ͸͹΃Ε;
ͶͰͱͰͻ͸ͳͷ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͹ͷ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸;
ͳ
ͻͪͯ;
ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͪ
͸͹΃Ε;
Ͳͪͫͪͬͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͫͳͲͪͻ͸͹΃Ε;
ͺ͹ͼͽͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͻͰͪͶ͸͹ͼͽͳ

͸Ͱ͵ͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͻͼͽͪ
͹ͭͶͰͯͪͶͪ
;
͵͹ͷͰ
Β͹΃
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͰ
ͯ͹
ͳͲͻͪͱͪΒͪ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹
ͼͽͳ
tͰͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵Ͱ
΁ͳͬͳͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰi
́
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͹
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β

ͳ
́ͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͽͪ͵ͬ͹
͹ͭͶͰͯͪͶ͹
͇͸ͳ
΃ͽͪͬͳ΃Ͱ

ͷ͹ͭ;
ͫͳͽͳ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͺ͹ͭ͹ͯͪ͸
tͷͰͯͳΒ
Ͳͪ
͹ͭͶͰͯͪΔͰi
ͯͪ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͪ
Ϳ;͸͵
΁ͳΒͪ
m
͹ͺͳͼͳͬͪΔͰ
ͻͰͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͪ
ͳ
Γ;ͯͳ
ͺ͹͸Ͱ͵ͪͯ
ͺͻͰͼͽͪΒͰ

ͯͪ
ͫ;ͯͰ
ͻͰͶͰͬͪ͸ͽ͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͽͬͪͻͪ
;
ͳͷͪͭͳ͸ͪͻ͸͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ

;
ͳͷͪͭͳ͸ͪͻ͸;
ͲͰͷΓ;
ͼͬͰ
;
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳΒͳ
ͺ͹ͽͻͬΌͳͬͪΔͪ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹ͭ
ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳ
ͽͰͽͪ
ͳ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͳͼͽͳ΁ͪΔͰ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ;
͸ͪ

ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͽͰͽ
ͳ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
́ͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
͠Ͱͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
;ͺͰ΂ͪ
ͽΓͳͬͳ΀
ͺͻͳͷͰͻͪ
ͽͪ͵ͬ͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
΂ͳΒͳ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁ͳ
͸ͳ͵ͪͯͪ

͸ͰΕͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͽͳ
ͲͰͷΓ;
͵͹Β;
͹͸
͹ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
ΒͰͻ
͹͸ͪ
͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ

͵Δͳͭͪ
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ͹ͷ
.PMWBOJB
"
-BOE
VOUPVDIFE
CZ
NPEFSO
EFOUJTUSZ

ͺͻͬ͹
ͳͲͯͪΔͰ


͇ͬͪΒ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͫͰͲ
͹ͫͲͳͻͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͯͼ;ͼͽͬ͹
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂
͸Ͱ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺ͹΃ͽ͹
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͵͹Β;
͹ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
;͹ͺ΃ͽͰ
͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ

ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪͬͪ
͹ͭͻ͹ͷ͸;
ͺ͹ͺ;Ͷͪͻ͸͹ͼͽ
;
̀ͪͺͪͯ͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
̸ͷͰͻͳ΁ͳ
ͳ

̸;ͼͽͻͪͶͳΒͳ
ͅ͹Ͷͬͪ͸ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͷͪͭͳ͸ͪͻ͸ͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͰ͸ͪ
͸ͰͭͯͰ
͸ͪ

̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
;
΂ͳΒ͹Β
ΕͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͳ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͳΒͳ
ͳ
ͼͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ
΂ͳͽͪͶͪ΁
m
ͳͷͪͭͳ͸ͪͻ͸ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
ͺͻͰͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ

͹ͼ͹ͫͳ͸Ͱ
ͼͬͳ΀
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
́ͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹
ͺͰ
͊ͳͻ͹ͷͪ΃ͽͬ͹
͵͹ͻ;ͺ΁ͳΒͪ
Ͱ͵͹Ͷ͹΃͵Ͱ
͵ͪͽͪͼͽͻ͹ͿͰ
͹ͺͪͼ͸͹ͼͽ
͹ͯ
ͷͳ
͸ͪ
ͳ
͸;͵ͶͰͪͻ͸͹ͭ
ͲͪͭͪΌͰΔͪ
ͼͳͬͪ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͳΒͪ
͵ͻͳͷͳ͸ͪͶ
ͺͻΓͪͬ΃ͽͳ͸ͪ



4
#PZN
5IF
'VUVSF
PG
/PTUBMHJB




́ͼͽ͹



4
$JMBVSP
5
(MFJTOFS
3
4JUDI
.PMWBOJB
"
-BOE
6OUPVDIFE
CZ
.PEFSO

%FOUJTUSZ
-POEPO

 ͇ͽ͹
̈́;ͽ΀ͪͻ
m
͋ͪΔͪ
͈Ͱͽͻ͹ͬͳΕ

ͻ;΃Ͱͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͫͳͲͪͻ͸ͳ
ͯͰͽͪΓͳ
ͳͲ
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸͹ͭ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
ͅ͹Ͷͬͪ͸ͪ΁ͪ

ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͺ͹
ͼͬͰͷ;
ͼ;ͯͰΕͳ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻ
ͫͰͼ͵ͻͪΒ͸Ͱ
ͲͪͫͪͬͰ
Ͳͪ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁Ͱ

͸ͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯ;
Ͳͪͽ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͪͺͼͽͻͪ͵΁ͳΒͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳͼͽ͹͵ͪ
;
͹ͫͶͳ
͵;
ͅ͹Ͷͬͪ͸ͳΒͰ
͹ͷ͹ͭ;Εͪͬͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͼͬͰ
͹͸͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
t͹ͫͳ΂͸͹i
t͸͹ͻͷͪͶ͸͹i

ͳ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΂͵͹
Ͳͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
͵ͪ͹
ͺͰͻͳͿͰͻͳΒ;
ͳ
̀ͪͺͪͯ͸;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺ;
͵ͪ͹
΁Ͱ͸
ͽͪͻ
Ͳͪ͸Ͱͷͪͻͳ
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;
͵͹ͻͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͸ͪΌͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͰͼͰ͸΁ͳΒͪ

͹͸͹ͭ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͻ;ͭͪ΂ͳΒͰ
ͳ
Ͳͪͽ͹
Ͳͪͫͪͬ͸͹
ͳ
ͺͻͳͬͶͪ΂͸͹
͋ͳͷ
ͺͻͰ
΃ͽ͹

ͳͷͪͭͳ͸ͪͻ͸͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
;
͹ͬ;
ͳͷͪͭͳ͸ͪͻ͸;
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵;
ͲͰͷΓ;
͸Ͱ
ͯ͹͸͹
ͼͳ
Ͳͪ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁ͪͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͸ͳ͵ͪ͵ͬ;
͹ͺͪͼ͸͹ͼͽ
͵͹Β;
ͫͳ
ͻͰͪͶ͸͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ

ͺ͹ͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪͶ͹
͈Ͱͻ΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͪ
͹ͬͰ
͵ΔͳͭͰ
΂ͳ͸ͳ
͸ͪͷ
ͼͰ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬͳΒ͹ͷ

͹ͯ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͼͳΒͰ
͹
͸ͪͷͰͻͪͷͪ
ΔͰ͸ͳ΀
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͪ
m
ͪ
͹͸Ͱ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͭͶͰ
ͽ;ͷͪ΂ͳͽͳ

;
ͻͪͼͺ͹͸;
͹ͯ
ͬͰ΃ͽ͹ͭ
ͺͪͻ͹ͯͳͻͪΔͪ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼͪ
͵͹Βͳ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳ΃Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹
ΒͰΕͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶ
͹
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͯ͹

ͽ͹ͭͪ
ͯͪ
͵Δͳͭͪ

tSFJOGPSDFT
TUFSFPUZQFT
PG
&VSPQFT
NPSF
EFQSJWFE
TUBUFTi
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͽ͹Βͳ
;

ͻͰ΁Ͱ͸ͲͳΒͳ
##$B
͹ͯ

ͪͺͻͳͶͪ



͇ͭͻ͹ͷ͸ͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽ͹ͼͽ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
t̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰi
ͳ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
͵͹Β͹Β
ͼͰ

ͬͰΕ
ͬͰ͵͹ͬͳͷͪ
͵͹͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͳ΃Ͱ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸ͳ
ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͽͰͽ
ͳ
͸ͪ
͵͹Β͹Β
ͼͰ
Ͳͪͼ͸ͳͬͪ

ͺ͹ͯͰͶͪ
͸ͪ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻ
ͳ
ͺͰͻͳͿͰͻͳΒ;
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͪͽͳ΂͸ͳ
Βͪ
͸Ͱͭ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͬͰΕͳ͸ͪ
͹͸ͳ΀
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͪ
Δ͹Β
ͳ͸ͼͳͼͽͳͻͪΒ;
ͱͰͶͰ
ͯͪ
ͬͰͻ;Β;
̽͹
ͭͪΌͪΒͳ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͳ΀
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͼͰ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
͸ͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳ
ͽͳͷ
ͷͰͼͽͳͷͪ
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
.BSJB
5PEPSPWB
ͽ;ͷͪ΂ͳͽͳ
͵ͪ͹
tͬͰͼͽͰͻ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳ
Βͪi
ͳ
tͰͬͻ͹ͺͰͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪi
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
tUIF
#BMLBOT
XFSF
CFDPNJOH
&VSPQFBO

CZ
TIFEEJOH
UIF
MBTU
SFTJEVF
PG
BO
JNQFSJBM
MFHBDZ
XJEFMZ
DPOTJEFSFE
BT

BOPNBMZ
BO
UIF
UJNF
BOE
CZ
BTTVNJOH
BOE
FNVMBUJOH
IPNPHFOFPVT

&VSPQFBO
OBUJPOTUBUF
BT
UIF
OPSNBUJWF
GPSN
PG
TPDJBM
PSHBOJ[BUJPO
*U

NBZ
XFMM
CF
UIBU
XIBU
XF
BSF
XJUOFTTJOH
UPEBZ
XSPOHMZ
BUUSJCVUFE
UP
TP
NF
#BMLBO
FTTFODF
JT
UIF
VMUJNBUF
&VSPQFJ[BUJPO
PG
UIF
#BMLBOT
*G
UIF

#BMLBOT
BSF
BT
*
UIJOL
UIFZ
BSF
UBOUBNPVOU
UP
UIFJS
0UUPNBO
MFHBDZ

UIJT
JT
BO
BEWBODFE
TUBHF
PG
UIF
FOE
PG
UIF
#BMLBOTi
́
4WFUMBOB
#PZN

ͺͳ΃Ͱ
ͯͪ
t8FTUFSOFST
UPP
DBNF
UP
FNCSBDF
&VSPQF
BGUFS
EFWBTUBUJOH
NB
TBDSFT
BOE
XBST
PG
SFMJHJPVT
BOE
QPMJUJDBM
JOUPMFSBODF
"U
MFBTU
POF
GPVSUI

PG
UIF
OPX
QSPVEMZ
EFNPDSBUJD
NFNCFST
PG
UIF
&VSPQFBO
6OJPO
XFSF

GBTDJTU
PS
SJHIUXJOH
EJDUBUPSTIJQT
BT
SFDFOUMZ
BT
UIF
UXFOUJFUI
DFOUVSZ

5IVT
8FTU
&VSPQFBOT
DBO
GJOE
QMFOUZ
PG
i&BTU
&VSPQFBOi
FYQFSJFODFT
JO



.PMWBOJB
4QPPG
.PDLT
5SBWFM
#PPLT
##$
/FXT
8PSME
FEJUJPO

BQSJM


IUUQOFXTCCDDPVLIJFVSPQFTUN


.
5PEPSPWB
*NBHJOJOH
UIF
#BMLBOT

ͳͼͺ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
%
(PGGNBO
5IF

0UUPNBO
&NQJSF
BOE
&BSMZ
.PEFSO
&VSPQF
$BNCSJEHF

 ̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
;
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸ͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ 

UIFJS
PXO
SFDͰOU
QBTU
UIBU
NJHIU
IFMQ
UIFN
SFBMJ[F
UIBU
UIF
TJNJMBSJUJFT

CFUXFFO
&BTU
BOE
8FTU
DPVME
CF
NPSF
VODBOOZ
UIBO
UIF
EJGGFSFODFTi

̸̸͉͉̈́́͋̾͋͌
́
̺͇͉́̀́

#BLFS

‡
.BSL
#BLFS
5IF
$[FDI
3FQVCMJD
'PEPST
&BTUFSO
BOE
$FOUSBM

&VSPQF
+FOOJGFS
+
1BVMM
VS

/FX
:PSL
'PEPST
#BLJǀ)BZEFO)BZEFO

‡
.JMJDB
#BLJǀ)BZEFO
J
3PCFSU
)BZEFO
0SJ
FOUBMJTU
7BSJBUJPOT
PO
UIF
5IFNF
A#BMLBOT
4ZNCPMJD
(FPHSBQIZ
JO
SFDFOU

:VHPTMBW
$VMUVSBM

1PMJUJDT
4MBWJD
3FWJFX



m
#BLJǀ)BZEFO

‡
.JMJDB
#BLJǀ)BZEFO
/FTUJOH
0SJFOUBMJTN
5IF
$BTF
PG

'PSNFS
:VHPTMBWJB
4MBWJD
3FWJFX

#JMMZ

‡
$ISJTUPQIFS
#JMMZ
'PEPST

&BTUFSO
&VSPQF
/FX
:PSL
'P
EPST
#KFMJǀ

‡
%VØBO
#KFMJǀ
5IF
#BMLBOT
*NBHJOFSZ
BOE
UIF
1BSBEPY
PG
&VSP
QFBO
#PSEFST

&VSP[JOF

IUUQXXXFVSP[JOFDPNBSUJDMF
mmCKFMJDFOIUNM
#PSDJMB

‡
"OEBMVOB
#PSDJMB
5SBWFM
(VJEFT
UP
i&BTUFSO
&VSPQFi
1PTU
$PNNVOJTN

4JUFT
BOE
"NFSJDBO
5SBWFMFST
SBE
QSFETUBWMKFO
OB
7
$POHSFTT

PG
UIF
"NFSJDBT

6OJWFSTJEBE
EF
MBT
"NFSJDBT
1VCFCMB
.FYJDP
m
PL
UPCBS

#PZN

‡
4WFUMBOB
#PZN
5IF
'VUVSF
PG
/PTUBMHJB
/FX
:PSL
#BTJD
#P
PLT
$JMBVSP
FU
BMM

‡
4BOUP
$JMBVSP
5PN
(MFJTOFS
3PC
4JUDI
.PMWBOJB
"

-BOE
6OUPVDIFE
CZ
.PEFSO
%FOUJTUSZ
+FUMBH
5SBWFM
(VJEF
-POEPO
"UMBO
UJD
#PPLT
&DIJLTPO

‡
8JMMJBN
&DIJLTPO
5IF
/FX
&BTUFSO
&VSPQF
JO
'PEPST


&BTUFSO
&VSPQF
$ISJTUPQIFS
#JMMZ
VS

/FX
:PSL
'PEPST
m
&DIJLTPO

‡
8JMMJBN
&DIJLTPO
*OUSPEVDUJPO
JO
'PEPST

&BTUFSO

&VSPQF
$ISJTUPQIFS
#JMMZ
VS

/FX
:PSL
'PEPST
99**m9997**
&DIJLTPO

‡
8JMMJBN
&DIJLTPO
*OUSPEVDUJPO
JO
'PEPST
&BTUFSO
&VSP
QF
$ISJTUPQIFS

#JMMZ
VS

/FX
:PSL
'PEPST
99*7m999*7
&ISFOQSFJT

‡
.
&ISFOQSFJT
5IF
4PVM
PG
UIF
&BTU
&YQFSJFODFT
BOE
3F
GMFDUJPOT
/FX
:PSL



4
#PZN
5IF
'VUVSF
PG
/PTUBMHJB

 ͇ͽ͹
̈́;ͽ΀ͪͻ
m
͋ͪΔͪ
͈Ͱͽͻ͹ͬͳΕ

(BSOFUU

‡
-VDZ
(BSOFUU
5VSLJTI
-JGF
JO
5PXO
BOE
$PVOUSZ
/FX
:PSL

(PGGNBO

‡
%
(PGGNBO
5IF
0UUPNBO
&NQJSF
BOE
&BSMZ
.PEFSO
&VSP
QF
$BNCSJEHF
$BNCSJEHF
6OJWFSTJUZ
1SFTT
)MBEOJL
‡
.JSBO
)MBEOJL
4MPWBOJ
W
TMPWFOTLJ
[HPEPWJOTLJ
QPWFTUJ

IUUQXXXJKTTJMJUTMPWBOJ
IUNM

*SWJOF
J
(BM

+VEJUI
5
*SWJOF
BOE
4VTBO
(BM
-BOHVBHF
*EFPMPHZ
BOE
-JO
HVJTUJD
%JGGFSFOUJBUJPO
3FHJNFT
PG
-BOHVBHF
*EFPMPHJFT
1PMJUJDT
BOE
*EFO
UJUJFT
1
7
,SPTLSJUZ
;ͻ

4BOUB
'F
4DIPPM
PG
"NFSJDBO
3FTFBSDI
1SFTT

m
*TJBI

‡
#FSMJO
*TJBI
7JDP
BOE
)FSEFS
5XP
4UVEJFT
JO
UIF
)JTUPSZ
PG
*EFBT

/FX
:PSL
7JLJOH
1SFTT
+F[FSOJL

‡
#PßJEBS
+F[FSOJL
%FßFMB
LKFS
KF
WTF
OBSPCF
-KVCMKBOB
;OBO
TUWFOP
JO

QVCMJDJTUJǁOP
TSFEJØǁF
+PIOTPO

‡
-POOJF
+PIOTPO
$FOUSBM
&VSPQF
&OFNJFT
/FJHICPST
'SJ
FOET
/FX
:PSL

m
0YGPSE
0YGPSE
6OJWFSTJUZ
1SFTT
-POFMZ
1MBOFU
#VHBSTLB
‡
IUUQXXXMPOFMZQMBOFUDPNEFTUJOBUJPOTFVSP
QFCVMHBSJB
-POFMZ
1MBOFU
#PTOB
J
)FSDFHPWJOB
‡

IUUQXXXMPOFMZQMBOFUDPNEFTUJOBUJPOTFVSPQF

CPTOJB@IFSDFHPWJOB
-POFMZ
1MBOFU
.BLFEPOJKB
‡
IUUQXXXMPOFMZQMBOFUDPNEFTUJOBUJPOT
FVSPQFNBDFEPOJB
.BTUOBL

‡
5PNBß
.BTUOBL
&WSPQB
.FE
FWPMVDJKP
JO
FWUBOB[JKP
-KVCMKB
OB
4UVEJB

IVNBOJUBUJT
.FVUIFO

‡
&SJDI
.FVUIFO
%FS
'BMM
WPO
,POTUBOUJOPQFM
VOE
EFS
MBUF
JOJTDIF
8FTUFO

%FS
'SJFEF
VOUFS
3FMJHJPOFO
OBDI
/JDPMBT
WPO
,VFT
3

)BVCTU
VS

.BJO[
3BQPQPSU

‡
3PHFS
3BQPQPSU
(SFBU
$JUJFT
PG
&BTUFSO
&VSPQF
4BOUB
'F

+PIO
.VJS
4DIVCFSU

‡
(BCSJFMMB
4DIVCFSU
i#FSMJO
VOE
4VFEPTUFVSPQBi
*O
,MBVT

.FZFS
VS


#FSMJO
VOE
0TUFVSPQB
$PMMPRVJVN
7FSMBH
m
5BOOFS
FU
BM

‡
"EBN
5BOFS
*BO
8BUTPO
;BDIBSZ
4DISBH
"OESFX
,B
QMBO
'SPNNFST
#VEHFU
5SBWFM
(VJEF
&BTUFSO
&VSPQF
PO

B
%BZ
/FX

:PSL

.BDNJMMBO
5PEPSPWB

‡
.BSJB
5PEPSPWB
5IF
#BMLBOT
'SPN
%JTDPJWFSZ
UP
*OWFO
UJPO
4MBWJD
3FWJFX


m
5PEPSPWB

‡
.BSJB
5PEPSPWB
*NBHJOJOH
UIF
#BMLBOT
/FX
:PSL
m
0Y
GPSE
0YGPSE
6OJWFSTJUZ
1SFTT
 ̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
;
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸ͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ 

5PEPSPWB

‡
.BSJB
5PEPSPWB
.
5PEPSPWB
FE
/BUJPOBM
*EFOUJUJFT
BOE

/BUJPOBM
.FNPSJFT
JO
UIF
#BMLBOT
-POEPO
7PO
¸TUSFJDI

‡
,BSM
WPO
¸TUSFJDI
%JF
#FWÕMLFSVOH
WPO
.BLFEPOJFO

(FPHSBQIJTDIF
;FJUTDISJGU
9*
m
ÂJßFL

‡
4MBWPK
ÂJßFL
$BVHIU
JO
"OPUIFST
%SFBN
JO
#PTOJB
*O
8IZ

#PTOJB 

8SJUJOHT
PO
UIF
#BMLBO
8BS
3BCJB
"MJ
-BXSFODF
-JGTDIVMU[
VS


4UPOZ
$SFFL
1BNQIMFUFFST
 ͇ͽ͹
̈́;ͽ΀ͪͻ
m
͋ͪΔͪ
͈Ͱͽͻ͹ͬͳΕ

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

0UP
-VUIBS
m
5BOKB
1FUSPWJǀ

%FS
#BMLBO
JO
XFTUMJDIFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO
*EFOUJUÅUTHFTUBMUVOH
EVSDI
,POTUSVLUJPO
EFS
1FSJQIFSJF

%JF
WPSMJFHFOEF
"SCFJU
CFTDIÅGUJHU
TJDI
NJU
1SP[FTTFO
EFS
(SFO[CJMEVOH

[XFJFS
(SP“HFCJFUF
m
WPO
8FTUFVSPQB
BMT
;FOUSVN
VOE
0TUFVSPQB
BMT

FVSPQÅJTDIFS
1FSJQIFSJF
XPCFJ
CFTPOEFSF
"VGNFSLTBNLFJU
EJTLVSTJWFO

'PSNFO
HFXJENFU
XJSE
EVSDI
EJF
JO
EFO
MFU[UFO
+BISIVOEFSUFO
EJFTF
5FJMVOH

&VSPQBT
SF
LPOTUJUVJFSU
XJSE

t2VFMMFOu
VOE
t"SHVNFOUFu
[V
FJOFS
NPEFSOFO
"VѫHMJFEFSVOH
&VSPQBT
FOUTUBNNFO
EFS
3FJTFMJUFSBUVS
BVT
EFN

VOE

+BISIVOEFSU

*N

+BISIVOEFSU
OBINFO
EJF
3FJTFGÛISFS
GBTU
BVTOBINTMPT
EJF
3PMMF
EFT

3FJTFCFSJDIUFT
BO
VOE

XVSEFO
[VS
)BVQURVFMMF
WPO
*OGPSNBUJPOFO
ÛCFS

BOEFSF
-ÅOEFS
VOE
,VMUVSFO

*N
WPSMJFHFOEFO
"SUJLFM
WFSTVDIFO
EJF
"VUPSFO
[V
[FJHFO
XFMDIF
3PMMF

EJF
3FJTFGÛISFS
CFJN
&OUTUFIFO
VOE
#FTUFIFOCMFJCFO
EFS
4UFSFPUZQFO
ÛCFS
EFO

#BMLBO
TQJFMFO
XJF
BVDI
CFJ
EFS
,POTUSVLUJPO
BVTHFEBDIUFS
JNQSPWJTJFSUFS

JOUFSOFS
FVSPQÅJTDIFS
(SFO[FO
EVSDI
(FTUBMUVOH
WPO
1FSJQIFSJFO
%JF
[XFJUF

'SBHF
CFTDIÅGUJHU
TJDI
NJU
EFO
#F[JFIVOHFO
[XJTDIFO
EJFTFN
(FOSF
VOE

3FJTFGÛISFSO
BMT
EFTTFO
7PSHÅOHFSO
JO
FJOFS
MBOHFO
(FTDIJDIUF
CFTUJNNUFS

LVMUVSFMMFS
.VTUFS
4UFSFPUZQFO
VOE
.ZUIFO
%JF
"OBMZTF
HSVOEMFHFOEFS

%JTLVSTNVTUFS
WFSXFJTU
BVG
EJF
,POJUVJUÅUTMJOJFO
[XJTDIFO
HÅOHJHFO

7PSTUFMMVOHFO
ÛCFS
EFO
#BMLBO
VOE
4ÛE
PTUFVSPQB
EJF
TFJU
EFN


+BISIVOEFSU
JO
EFS
XFTUMJDIFO
3FJTFMJUFSBUVS
HFQGMFHU
XFSEFO
VOE

EFN
"CCJME

EJFTFS
3FHJPO
JO
NPEFSOFO
3FJTGÛISFSO

*O
EFO
MFU[UFO
BOEFSUIBMC
+BIS[FIOUFO
XJSE
EJFTFS
%JTLVST
JO
OPDI

HSՓFSFN
.B“F
JEFPMPHJTDI
HFGÅSCU
XBT
FJOFS
BMMHFNFJOFSFO
5FOEFO[

FOUTQSJDIU
OBDI
EFS
EJF
&SFJHOJTTF
JO
4ÛEPTUFVSPQB
TFJU
EFN
6OUFSHBOH
EFT

,PNVOJTNVT
LPOTFRVFOU
BMT
FJO
1IÅOPNFO
CF[FJDIOFU
XFSEFO
EBT
FJOFSTFJUT

EFN
[JWJMJTJFSUFO
GPSUHFTDISJUUFOFO
VOE
EFNPLSBUJTDI
HFTJOOUFO
&VSPQB
WÕMMJH

GSFNE
VOE
JOBL[FQUBCFM
EFO
#BMLBOWÕMLFSO
BOEFSFSTFJUT
KFEPDI
GBTU
BOHFCPSFO

JTU

%BT
#JME
EFT
NVUJHFO
GPSTDIFOEFO
3FJTFOEFO
BVT
EFN
8FTUFO
MÅTTU

TJDI
JO
QSBLUJTDI
KFEFN
NPEFSOFO
EFN
XFTUMJDIFO
-FTFS
BOHFQBTTUFO

3FJTFGÛISFS
WPSGJOEFO
%JF
#FHFJTUFSVOH
ÛCFS
CBMLBOUZQJTDIF
1IÅOPNFOF
XJF

&YPUJL
)FEPOJTNVT
(FMBTTFOIFJU

MPDLFSF
"VGGBTTVOH
WPO
;FJU
VOE
1GMJDIU

.ۓJHBOH
XJF
BVDI
#J[BSSFSJFO
EFS
QPTUTP[JBMJTUJTDIFO
3FBMJUÅU
TUFMMFO
FJOF

"SU
4QJFHFM
EBS
JO
EFN
8FSUF
EFS
tFVSPQÅJTDIFO
,VMUVSi
OPUXFOEJHFSXFJTF

OPDI
JOUFOTJWFS
[VN
7PSTDIFJO
LPNNFO
"VDI
EJF
BLUVFMMTUFO
3FJTFGÛISFS

ÛCFS
4ÛEPTU
VOE
0TUFVSPQB
TUFMMFO
FJO
TPMDIFT
4QJFHFMCJME
EBS
͠ͰͶͳ΁ͪ

̸͇̺͇̺͆̓́ͣњ̸͇͈̈́͌͑́͆
͍ͳͶ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
Ϳͪ͵;ͶͽͰͽ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

̸̸̻͇̺͌͊̈́́͠͠

͌
̸͎͇̈́͆̽͊̓́ͅ

̸̹͉̾̽̾̓̾́ͅ

͉͎͋́̽̾͊̾͋́
̸̻͇̽́͆


̸̺̾̓

̸͵͹
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽ;
ͼ΀ͬͪͽͳͷ͹
͵ͪ͹
tͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͻͪͯͳ
͹ͯͷ͹ͻͪ
ͳ
ͻͪͲ͹͸͹

ͯͰi
͹͸ͯͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;
ͺͻ͹͸ͪΌͰ͸Ͱ
ͭͻͪΌͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰͷ͹
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂ͳͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͸ͪ

ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͽͪ͵ͬͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͺ͹΂ͰͶͳ
ΒͪͬΓͪͽͳ
ͬͰ͹
ͷͪ
ͻͪ͸͹
͈ͻͬͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ
͸ͪ
͸ͳͲ͹ͲͰͷͼ͵͹ͷ
;
͵͹ͷͰ
ͼͰ
͹ͺͳͼ;Β;
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ

ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;Β;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͼ

͵ͻͪΒͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
̸;ͽ͹ͻ
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
ͺͻͪͽͳͶͪ΁
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͿͶͪͷͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͶͰͷͳΕͪ

͠͹ͼͪ
ͬͪ͸
͎ͳͼͽͰͶͰͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
΀͹ͯ͹΂ͪͼ͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
͸ͪͷͰͻͰ
;ͷͰ͹
;ͼͺ;ͽ
ͯͪ

͵͹ͷͫͳ͸;ΒͰ
ͼͪ
͹ͯͷ͹ͻ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͻͪͲ͹͸͹ͯ͹ͷ

̽;ͭͳ
͸ͳͲ
ͬͰ͵͹ͬͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͳ
ͼ;
ͼͶ;ͱͳͶͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͼͬ͹ΒͰͬͻͼ͸ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱ
ͻͳ
Ͳͪ
͹͸Ͱ
͎͹Ͷͪ͸Όͪ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͍Ͷͪͷͪ͸΁Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͽͳͱͰΓͪ
ͬ;͵Ͷͪ
͸ͪ
ͯͪͶͰ͵ͪ

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͌
͸Ͱͯ͹ͼͽͪͽ͵;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸Ͱ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͰ
ͼ͹ͺͼͽͬͰ͸ͳ΀
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͪ

ͻͪͯ͹
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͲͪͶ͹
ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻͰͬ͹ͯͳͷͪ
ͼͪ
Ͱ͸ͭͶͰͼ͵͹ͭ
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂
͵͹ͭ
͊ͬͰ
ͯ͹
͵ͻͪΒͪ
ͯͰͬͰͽ͸ͪͰͼͽ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ

ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
;
͸ͳͲ͹ͲͰͷͼ͵ͳͷ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͳͷͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͽͻͪ͸Ͳͳͽ
͸Ͱ
ͯͰ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͵ͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͺͻͰͬͪͼ΀͹ͯ͸͹
͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯ;

͈ͻͬͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ
;
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹ͷ
ͼͷͳͼͶ;
ͽͰ
ͻͰ΂ͳ
ΒͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͼͰ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ
͵͹ͷ
ͯͬͪͯͰͼͰͽ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
Ͳͪ΀ͬͪΓ;Β;Εͳ
͸ͪͭͶ͹ͷ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β;
ͺͻͰͬ͹Ͳ͸ͳ΀
ͼͻͰͯͼͽͪ



3FǁOJL
TSQTLPISWBUTLPH
LOKJßFWOPH
KF[JLB
/PWJ
4BE



;B
QSFHMFE
QVUPQJTOF
MJUFSBUVSF
P
TSQTLJN
LSBKFWJNB
EP
QPǁFULB

WFLB
WJEJ

/PWBLPWJǀ-PQVØJOB

 ͠ͰͶͳ΁ͪ
͆͹ͬͪ͵͹ͬͳΕ̈́͹ͺ;΃ͳ͸ͪ

ͬͪ
ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͳ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͷ͹ͫͳͶͼ͵͹ͷ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ;
͈͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ
΀͹
Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵ͳ
ͺͳͼͪ΁
ͪͅͻͼͰͶ;ͼ
̾ͷͪ͸ͽͼ
͹ͫΒͪͬͳ͹
ΒͰ

ͯͰͽͪΓͪ͸
͹ͺͳͼ
ͼͬ͹ͭ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͺ͹
̹͹ͼ͸ͳ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
͇ͼͳͷ
ͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪΔͪ

ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵͹ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͼͳͽ;ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
̾ͷͪ͸ͽͼ
ΒͰ

ͬͻͶ͹
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸͹
͹ͺͳͼͪ͹
ͼͬͰ
͹͸͹
΃ͽ͹
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͺͻͳͬ;Εͳ
Ͳͪͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪ͸͹ͭ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽ;
ͳ
΃ͽ͹
ͷ;
ͷ͹ͱͰ
͹Ͷͪ͵΃ͪͽͳ
ͫ͹ͻͪͬͪ͵
;
͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹Β
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸ͳ

ͺ͹΂Ͱͬ
͹ͯ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
ͬͻͼͽͰ
ͳ
΁Ͱ͸ͪ
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͪΒͪ
ͺͪ
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹
ͼ;
ͬͰ͸ͳͻͪ
͢Ͱͭ͹ͬͪ
Ϳͪͼ΁ͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͹ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͪͶ͸͹ͷ
ͰͭͲ͹ͽͳ͵͹ͷ
ͲͪͻͪͲͳΕͰ
ͳ

ͬͰΕͳ͸;
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
Ͳͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;ͼͻͰͽ
ͼͪ
͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳͷ
͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
͸ͪΒͳ
ͲͪͲ͹ͬ͸ͳΒͳ
ͷ͹ͷͰ͸ͪͽ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹ͷ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺ͹ͷ
́ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪΒͺͻͰ
ͷ;ͼͶͳͷͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
ͽͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͺͶͰ͸ͳ
ͼͬ͹Β͹ͷ
ͰͭͲ͹
ͽͳ΂͸͹΃Ε;
ͺͻͳͷͪͷΓͳͬ͹ͼͽ
͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͼͰͯ;ΒͰ
ͳ
΁ͻ͸͹ͭ͹ͻͼ͵ͪ
͵ͪ͹

΃ͽ͹
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͶͪͲͳ
ͳͲ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ
̺ͪ͸
ͯͰͻ
ͅͰΒͪ
ͭ͹ͼͺ͹Όͳ΁Ͱ
̈́;΀ͽ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ͸ͳ
Βͪ
ͬͪ͸
ͯͰͻ
ͪͅ͸ͯͰͻͰͪ

̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͻͪͽ͹ͬͳ
ͳ
͈ͻͬͳ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͳ
ͻͪͽ
Ͳͪ;ͼͽͪͬͳͶͳ
ͼ;
͹ͬ͹
ͺͻ͹
ͫ;ΌͰ͸͹
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻͰͯͬ͹ͻΒͰ
͇ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͪ
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ
ͽͻͳ
ͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͺ͹͸͹ͬ͹
͹ͯͬͪͱͳͶͳ
͸ͪ
Β;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹͵
͋ͪͷ͹
ͳ΀
ΒͰ

ͼͪͯͪ
΂Ͱ͵ͪͶͪ
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
͸͹ͬͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͪ
ͽͬ͹ͻͰͬͳ͸ͪ
m
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
m
΂ͳΒͳ
ΕͰ

ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͪͯ;ͽ
ͪ
;ΒͰͯ͸͹
ͳ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͷͪ͸ͪ
m
;ͺͻͪ
ͬ͹
ͫͳͽͳ
ΔͰ͸ͪ
ͻͪͲ͸͹Ͷͳ͵͹ͼͽ
̀ͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;
͹ͯ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸͹ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀

ͼͽ;ͯͳΒͪ
ͳͲ
ͯͬͪͯͰͼͰͽͰ
ͳ
ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͰ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
$PSEFNBOT

4DIBNFM
IPVU


͵͹ΒͰ
͸͹ͬ͹͸ͪͼͽͪͶͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
ͳͼͺ;Δͪͬͪ
ͼ͵Ͱͺͼ͹ͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸Ͱ

ͻͰͺ͹ͻͽͪͱͰ
ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
͹ͯͳ΃;
ͳͼ͵ͻͰ͸ͳͷ
͹ͯ;΃ͰͬΓͰΔͰͷ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͪ

͋ͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
͸ͳͲ͹ͲͰͷͼ͵ͪ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͪ
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸ͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ
ͷͪ
ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪͽͳͱͰΓ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͱͪ͸ͻ͹ͬͼ͵ͳ
΂ͳͼͽͪ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
;
ͼͷͳͼͶ;

ͽͪ͵ͼͪͽͳͬ͸͹ͭ
͸ͪͬ͹ΌͰΔͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ
͌
ͬͰΕͳ͸ͳ

ͼͶ;΂ͪΒͰͬͪ
ͼͰ
ͻͪͯͳ
͹
ͷͰ΃ͪͬͳ͸ͳ
ͱͪ͸ͻ͹ͬͪ
ͼ
ͽͳͷ
΃ͽ͹
ͼͬͰ
ͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͰ

͹ͯͳ΃;
;
ͬͰͶͳ͵͹Β
ͷͰͻͳ
ͼ;ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͷ
͸͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͅ͹ͭ;ΕͰ
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
͎͹Ͷͪ͸
Όͪ͸ͳ
ͫ;ͯ;Εͳ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹ͶͳͭͶ͹ͽͰ
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳͽͳ
ͳ
Ͱ͸ͭͶͰͼ͵;

ͳ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͼ͵;
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻ;
͌ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͽͳͬ͸ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹
ͺͳͼ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃Ε;
Ϳ͹ͻͷ;

̽͸Ͱͬ͸ͳ΁ͳ

ͪͅͻͳ͸;ͼ
ͬͪ͸
ͯͰͻ
̈́;ͫͰ
.BSJOVT
WBO
EFS
-VCCF

ͲͶ͹ͼͻͰΕ͸ͳ

͹͵ͻͳͬΓͰ͸ͳ͵
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͱͪͻ
;
͉ͪΒ΀ͼͽͪͭ;
ͼͰͺͽͰͷͫͻͪ

ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯ
;ͽͳ΁ͪΒͰͷ



*CJE
TUSBOF
G
J
G


*CJE
TUSBOF
G
J
G


$SOB
(PSB
$*%
1PEHPSJDB

V
QSFWPEV
+
/
-

 ͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
;
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ 

͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͺͪͭͪ͸ͯͰ
͵ͻͰ͸;͹
ͺͰ΃ͳ΁Ͱ
Ͳͪ
̓ͳ͸;
ͷͳͼͶͰΕͳ
ͯͪ
ΕͰ

ͺͻͰ͵͹
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͳ
͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͪ
Ͳͪ
ͯͬͪͽͻͳ
ͷͰͼͰ΁ͪ
ͼͽͳΕͳ
ͯ͹
ͼͬ͹ͭ
͹ͯͻͰ
ͯͳ΃ͽͪ
̀ͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒ;
ΒͰ
ͬͰͻ͹ͬͪ͹
ͯͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͬͰΕͪ
͹ͯ
͊ͰͬͰͻ͸͹ͭ
̹ͻͪͫͪ͸ͽͪ

ͳ
ͯͪ
ΕͰ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰΕͳ
Ͳͪ
΂Ͱͽͳͻͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪ
͊ͪ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒ͹ͷ
͵ͪͻͽͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͷͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ
ͺͪ
ΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ͹
ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸ͳ͵
͵ͪ͵͹
ͫͳ
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͬͳͷͪ

͸ͪ
ͽͪΒ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͼͽͬ͹ͻͳ͹
ͼͶͳ͵;
͹
ͼͬͰͽ;
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͷ
͸ͪͺͪΕͰ͸͹ͷ
ͻͪͯ͸͹ͷ

ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ;
́ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͼͪͷ
ͫͳ͹
ͺ͹Ͷ;ͺͳͼͷͰ͸
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ
ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸ͳ͵
ͳͺͪ͵

ͯͪΒͰ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ
;ͬͳͯ
;
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
ͼ
͵͹Βͳͷ
ΒͰ
͹͸

͸ͪΒͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͳ͹
;
ͯ͹ͯͳͻ
ͺ;ͽ;Β;Εͳ
ͺͰ΃ͳ΁Ͱ
ͻͪͯͰΕͳ
ͺ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
͵ͪ͹

͸ͪͺ͹Ͷͳ΂ͪͻ
ͳ
ͼͺͪͬͪΒ;Εͳ
ͺ͹
΃ͽͪͶͪͷͪ
t̓ͪ͵͹
ͷͳ
ͼͰ
΂ͳ͸ͳ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬͪ͸
ͪͶͳ
ΒͰ
ͬͰͼͰ͹

͊ͬ;ͯͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͰͶ;
ͼͰ
ͳͲ
͵;Εͪ
͹ͻͰ
ͺͰͼͷͰ
̸
ͽ͹
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
;
͹ͬͳͷ
ͭͪͯ
͸ͳͷ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳͷͪ
͠Ͱͻ
͸ͳ
͹ͬͯͰ
ͽͰͱͪ͵;
͸Ͱ
ͳͯͰ
͸ͪΒͫ͹ΓͰ
ͳ
͹ͺͼͽͪΒͰ
ͼͪͷ͹

Ͳͪ΀ͬͪΓ;Β;Εͳ
ͽ͹ͷͰ
΃ͽ͹
͸Ͱͷͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͳͲͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
ͳ
΃ͽ͹
ͼͬͰ
ͺͻͪͬͳ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹
ͳͲͬ͹ͯͳ
ͼͪͷi
4DIPVUFO


t
͹ͯͪͽͶͰ
ͳͯͰͷ
Ͳͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͲͰͷΓͪ
;
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ

ͳ
Β͹΃
ͳͷͪ
͵ͻͪΓͪ
΂ͳΒͪ
ͼͰ
ͭͶͪͬͪ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͬͳͯͰͽͳ
͸ͪ
ͺͪͻͪͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
;
͎͹Ͷͪ͸
ͯͳΒͳ
̺ͳͶ΀ͰͶͷͳ͸ͪi


t͇ͬͯͰ
ͼͪͷ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͼͻͰ͹
ͺͻͪͬͰ
΁ͳͭͪ͸Ͱ
̹ͪ΃
ΒͰ
ͽͳͺͳ΂͸͹
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼ;

ͽͳ
Γ;ͯͳ
͹ͫ;΂Ͱ͸ͳ
̺Ͱͻ;ΒͰͷ
ͯͪ
͹͸ͳ
Ͳͪͺͻͪͬ͹
͸͹ͼͰ
ͺ͹΁Ͱͺͪ͸Ͱ
ͼͪ͵͹Ͱ
ͳ

ͺͪ͸ͽͪͶ͹͸Ͱ
Ͳͪͽ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͽͪ͵͹
ͬ͹ͶͰ
ͳ
ͯͻ;͵΂ͳΒͰ
ͳ
͸Ͱ
ͱͰͶͰi


̓ΔͳͱͰͬ͸͹ͼͽ

͠Ͱͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͺͻͬͳ΀
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͺ͹
ͺͻͬ͹Β
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
ͫͳ͹

ΒͰ
̓͹ͻ͸ͰͶͳͼ
͠͹΀ͪ͸Ͱͼ
̿͹ͻͱ
͊ͺ;Ͷͼͽͻͪ
$PSOFMJT
+PIBOOFT
(FPSHF
4QP
FMTUSB
m

ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳΒͳ
ͺ͹
ͼͬ͹ͷ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͻ͸͹ͷ
ͺͼͰ;ͯ͹͸ͳͷ;
"

%FO
%PMBSE
"
%FO
%PPMBBSE

͇ͬͪΒ
΂;ͬͰ͸ͳ
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵ͳ
ͻ͹ͷͪ͸͹ͺͳ
ͼͪ΁
ͺ;ͼͽ͹Ͷ͹ͬ͸͹ͭ
ͳ
͸Ͱͷͳͻ͸͹ͭ
ͯ;΀ͪ
͹ͽ͵ͻͳ͹
ΒͰ
΂ͪͻͳ
ͯͪΓͳ͸Ͱ
Β͹΃
͵ͪ͹

ͯͰ΂ͪ͵
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹
͠;ͱ͸;
̸Ϳͻͳ͵;
ͭͯͰ
ͷ;
ΒͰ
͹ͽͪ΁
ΒͰͯ͸͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͫͳ͹

ͺͻ͹ͽͰͼͽͪ͸ͽͼ͵ͳ
ͷͳͼͳ͹͸ͪͻ
͈ͻͰͷͪ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺͰΒͲͪͱͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͼͰͽͳ͹

Γ;ͫͪͬ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͬͳ
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯ
ͳ
͹ͽͪͯ
ΒͰ
͸ͪΒͻͪͯͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰΕͳͬͪ͹
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵Ͱ
̸Ͷ
ͺͰ
͑ͪͷ͹͸ͳ

ͳ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
͆ͪ
ͽͳͷ
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
ͬͳ΃ͰͷͰͼͰ΂͸ͳͷ
ͺͰ΃ͪ΂ͰΔͳͷͪ

ͺ͹
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͳ
ͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
m
ͺͻͬ͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯ;ͲͰ͹

m
ͼͪ͵;ͺΓͪ͹
ΒͰ

;ͽͳͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
͹ͺͼͰͻͬͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳͲ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ͼ;
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͪͼͽͪͶͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭͪ
͸ͰͲͪͫ͹ͻͪͬ
͸ͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵Ͱ
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
̻͹ͼͽͳ͹͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͼ
ͺ͹ͽ͵͹ͬͳ
΁͹ͷ
%F
IFSCFSH
NFU
IFU
IPFGJK[FS


͇ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽ
Ͱ͵ͼͺͻͰͼ
0SJÌOU&Y
QSFTT


͊ͬͪͯͫͪ
ͼͰͯͷ͹ͻͳ΁Ͱ
΁ͳͭͪ͸ͪ
%F
CSVJMPGU
EFS
[FWFO
[JHFVOFST

 ͠ͰͶͳ΁ͪ
͆͹ͬͪ͵͹ͬͳΕ̈́͹ͺ;΃ͳ͸ͪ



ͳ
̀ͰͷΓͪ
ͳͲͪ
̹͹ͱͳΒͳ΀
ͶͰΌͪ
)FU
MBOE
BDIUFS
(PET
SVH



͢Ͱͭ͹ͬ
ͺͻͬͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒ;
͸ͪͼͽͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͯ;΃Ͱ

ͽͰ͵

ͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
ͻͰͺ͹ͻͽͪͱͰ
ͳ
ͻ͹ͷͪ͸ͳ
ͫͳͶͳ
ͽͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͺ͹
ͫ;ͯͳͶͳ
ͺͪͱΔ;
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵Ͱ
Βͪͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
Ͳͪ
Β;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹͵
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
Ͳͪ
ͽͪ
ͷ͹΃Δͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΔͪ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸;

͹ͼ͹ͫͰ͸͹ͼͽ

͌
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͬΒ;;
ͼͪ
͎ͪ͸ͼ͹ͷ
ͬͪ͸
ͯͰ
̺ͪͻͼͰ͸ͫ;ͻ΀͹ͷ
)BOT
WBO
EF
8B
BSTFOCVSH

ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ͹ͷ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ

ͫͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
̽Ͱ͸
̽͹Ͷͪͻͯ
ΒͰ
ͳͲ͸Ͱ͹
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ

ͬͪͱͪ͸
΂ͳ͸ͳͶͪ΁
Ͳͪ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪΔͰ
ͺͻͳͬͶͪ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
Ͳͪ
͎͹Ͷͪ͸
Όͪ͸Ͱ
t̺Ͱ͹ͷͪ
ͼͪͷ
Ͳͪͬ͹ͶͰ͹
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒ;
ͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸͹
Ͳͪͽ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
ͫͳ
Ͷͪ
ͺͻͬͪ
ͲͰͷΓͪ
;
͵͹Β͹Β
ͼͪͷ
m
ͼͪ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬͳ΃ͽͪ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵Ͱ
΁ͳͬͳ
ͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
m
ͯ͹΃ͪ͹
;
ͯ͹ͯͳͻ
ͼͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͼͽͪͻͳΒͳͷ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳͷ
͹ͫͻͪͼ΁Ͱͷ

͋ͪΒ
ͼͽͪͻͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ
͹ͫͻͪͲͪ΁
ΒͰ
͸Ͱͼͽͪ͹
;ͼͶͰͯ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͻͪͽ͸͹ͭ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Βͪ
ͳ

Βͪ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
ͱͪͶͳͷ
Ͳͪ
Δͳͷ
ͷͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͪΒ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
͸ͰͳͲͫͰͱͪ͸i



͋;
Ϳͪͼ΁ͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͯ;ͫΓͳͷ
ͼͶ͹ΒͰͬͳͷͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͺͼͳ΀͹
Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ΀
͹ͫͻͪͲͪ΁ͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͯͪ΀ΔͳͬͪͶͪ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
͵͹ͶͰͭͰ
ͺ͹

ͺͰͻ;
̽Ͱ͸
̽͹Ͷͪͻͯ
ΒͰ
͸ͪΒ;ͺͰ΂ͪͽΓͳͬͳΒͰ
ͳͶ;ͼͽͻ͹ͬͪ͹
ͼ͹ͺͼͽͬͰ͸ͳͷ
ͳͼ͵;
ͼͽͬ͹ͷ
t̸Ͷͳ
ͫͳ͹
ͼͪͷ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͼͻͰΕͪ͸
ͽͪͷ͹
̓ͪͯ
ͼͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͼͰͽͳͷ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼ;

;ͬͰ΂Ͱ
;
ͫͳͶ͹
͵͹ͷ
ͭͻͪͯ;
ͳͶͳ
ͷͪΔͰͷ
ͷͰͼͽ;
ͺ͹
͵ͪͿͪ͸ͪͷͪ
͸ͪͼͽ;ͺͪͶͰ

ͺͰͬͪ΂ͳ΁Ͱ
͌ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͼͪͷ
ͼͰ
;͸ͪͺͻͰͯ
ͻͪͼͺͳͽͳͬͪ͹
͹
΂ͪͼ;
Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹ͭ
͸ͪ
ͼͽ;ͺͪ
́
͹͸ͯͪ
ͫͳ΀
ͼͰ
͸ͰͭͯͰ
͹͵͹
ͯͰͬͰͽ
ͼͪͽͳ
;ͬͰ΂Ͱ
;ͺ;ͽͳ͹
ͽͪͷ͹
͆ͪ
ͻ;΂ͳ͹
ͫͳ΀
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͶ͹
ͪ
͹͸ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;ͫͻͲ͹
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͳ͹
͹ͻ͵Ͱͼͽͪͻ

͌ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͼͰ
ͼͬͳͻͪͶ͹
͸ͪ
΂Ͱͽͳͻͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;ͷͰ͸ͽͪ
͵ͼͳͶ͹Ϳ͹͸;
΀ͪͻͷ͹͸ͳ
΁ͳ
ͺͻͬ͹Β
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭ͹Β
ͬͳ͹Ͷͳ͸ͳ
͐Ͱͼͽ͹
ͳͷ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͳͯͻ;ͱͳͬͪ͹
ͳ
ͬͳ͹Ͷ͹͸΂Ͱ
Ͷ͹
ͪ
͸ͳ͵ͪ͵͹
͸Ͱ
ͼͷͰͷ͹
ͯͪ
Ͳͪͫ͹ͻͪͬͳͷ͹
͸ͳ
ͺͰͬͪ΂ͳ΁;
ͼͪ
ͯͪͳͻͪͷͪ
͌ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͼ;
ͽ͹
ͫͳͶͳ
΁ͳͭͪ͸ͳ
͏ͻͺͶͳ
ͼ;
ͳͲ
͸ͰͳͲͷͰͻ͸͹ͭ
ͫͶͪͭͪ

Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
ͺͰͼͪͷͪ
̀ͪ
΃ͪ΂ͳ΁;
ͼͳͽ͸ͳ͸Ͱ
ͼͬͳͻͪͶͳ
ͼ;

ͺͰͼͷͰ
ͺ͹
ͺ͹ͻ;Θͫͳ͸ͳ
͆͹ͬͪ΁
ͼͰ
ͯͪͬͪ͹
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
ͫͳ͹
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒ
;

ͪ;ͼͽͻ͹;ͭͪͻͼ͵͹Β
ͷ͹͸ͪͻ΀ͳΒͳ
͋Ͱ
ͺͰͬͪ΂ͳ΁Ͱ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͰ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷ
͸ͰͲͪͬͳͼ͸Ͱ
ͯͰͬ͹Β͵Ͱ
͆Ͱ͵Ͱ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͰ

ͬͻͶ͹
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͰ
ͪ
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͺ͹
ͲͪͽͬͪͻͪΔ;
͵ͪͿͪ͸Ͱ
͹ͯͪͬͪͶͰ
;ͷͰͻͰ͸͹Β

ͺͻ͹ͼͽͳͽ;΁ͳΒͳ
ͼͪ
ͷ;΃ͽͰͻͳΒ͹ͷ
ͺ͹
ͼͬ͹ͷ
ͳͲͫ͹ͻ;
̹ͳͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͽ;
ͺͻͰͶͰͺͳ΀

ͱͰ͸ͪ
ͼΒͪΒ͸ͳ΀
͏ͳͭͪ͸͵ͳ
̹ͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
͵͹Β;
͸ͳͼͳ
ͼͷͰ͹
ͯͪ
ͺͳͺ͸Ͱ΃
̀ͬͪ



1SFWPE
PWPH
EFMB
PCKBWMKFO
KF
V
#FPHSBEV
.JOFSWB




t+VHPTMBWJKB
LBMFJEPTLPQTLB
EFTUJOBDJKBt
+PFHPTMBWJÌ
LBMFJEPTDPQJTDI

SFJTMBOE

4MFEJMB
TV
KPØ
EWB
J[EBOKB

J



;B
EOFWOJ
MJTU
)BOEFMTCMBE
 ͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
;
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ 

Ͷͪ
ͼͰ
͊ͽͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
;ͯͪͽͪ
Ͳͪ
ͬ͹Ό;
͹ͻ͵Ͱͼͽͻͪ
͈;ͽ͹ͬͪ͹
ͼͪͷ
Ͳͪ
͊ͽͪ͸͹ͷ

͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͯ͹
͊͵͹ͺΓͪ
͹ͼͪͷ
ͼͽ͹ͽͳ͸ͪ
͵ͳͶ͹ͷͰͽͪͻͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͯͪ
ͫͳ΀
ΒͰ

΂;͹
͵ͪ͵͹
ͺͰͬͪ
̹ͳ͹
ͼͪͷ
ͲͪΓ;ͫΓͰ͸
;
Δ;
͸ͪ
͸Ͱ͵ͳ
ͬͻͶ͹
΂;ͯͪ͸
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸

͆Ͱ
ͯͪ
ͫͳ΀
ͼͺͪͬͪ͹
ͼ
Δ͹ͷ
ͬͰΕ
Ͳͪͽ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͷͳ
ΒͰ
ͺͻ;ͱͪͶͪ
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
΃ͽ͹
͠;
ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͳ
͸ͪͲͳͬͪΒ;
ͼͰͬͯͪ΀͹ͷ
͋͹
ΒͰ
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸ͪ
ͬͻͼͽͪ
ͯͪͷͪͻͪ

͵͹Βͳ
ͽͰ
;΂Ͱ
ͯͪ
ͷ͹ͻͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͪͽͳ
͸Ͱ͵ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
ͼͬͰͽ
͹ͼͽͬͪͻͰΔͰ
͹͸͹ͭ
΃ͽ͹

ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͲͰͷΓͳ
͸Ͱͯ͹ͼͽͳͱ͸͹
͠Ͱͯͪ͸
ͼͬͰͽ
ͭͯͰ
ΒͰ
ͳ
Γ;ͫͪͬ
ͽͻͪΒ͸ͪ
ͭͯͰ
ͼͳ
ͬͰ΂
͸͹
ͷͶͪͯi
Ϳ

͆Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
̽Ͱ͸
̽͹Ͷͪͻͯ͹ͬͪ
Γ;ͫͪͬ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
͊ͽͪ͸ͳ

ͳ
ͼͰͬͯͪ΀;
ͻͰͲ;ͶͽͳͻͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
͊ͬͪͯͫ͹ͷ
ͼͰͯͷ͹ͻͳ΁Ͱ
͏ͳͭͪ͸ͪ
͇ͼͳͷ
ͺͰ΃ͪ΂ͰΔͪ
ͫͳ΁ͳ͵ͶͳͲͪͷ
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ
͎͹Ͷͪ͸Όͪ͸Ͱ
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ

Ͷͪ͵͹
ͯ͹ͼͽ;ͺ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
Ͳͪͽ͹
͹ͷͳΓͰ͸ͳ΀
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
̺Ͱͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸͹
ΒͰ

ͳ
ͽ͹
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͻͪͲͶ͹ͭͪ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͼͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ͺͻͰͬͰͯͰ͸ͪ
͵Δͳͭͪ
̾ͭ͹͸ͪ

͑ͶͪΒ͸ͳ΁ͪ
&HPO
4DIMFJOJU[

̽ͬͪͯͰͼͰͽ
͸ͰͯͰΓͪ
ͪͬͪ͸ͽ;ͻͰ
̹ͳ΁ͳ͵Ͷ͹ͷ

͵ͪ
ͼ;͸΂ͪ͸͹ͷ
Β;ͭ;
́ͪ͵͹
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸ͪ
ͷͶͪͯͳͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
Ͳͪͫͪͬ͸ͪ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͪ

͹ͬ͹
ͯͰͶ͹
ͼͪͯͻͱͳ
ͼͬͰ
ͰͶͰͷͰ͸ͽͰ
ͻ͹ͷͪ͸ͽͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸͹ͭ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
͇͸͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪ

ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͷͰͼͽͪ
ͳ
Ͱ͵ͼͺͶͳ΁ͳͽ͸͹
͹ͼͬͻΕͰ
͸ͪ
ͽͪΒ
ͱͪ͸ͻ
 ͠ͰͶͳ΁ͪ
͆͹ͬͪ͵͹ͬͳΕ̈́͹ͺ;΃ͳ͸ͪ

͈ͻͰͯͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͺͳͼͪ͹
ͭͻͪͯ͹͸ͪ΂ͰͶ͸ͳ͵
͊ͪͻͪΒͰͬͪ
̸ͼͳͷ
̹Ͱͭ
ͅ;ͽͰ
ͬͰͶͳΕ
͵͹ͷͰ
ΒͰ
ͯͰͶ͹
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸͹
t͌ͬͰ͵
ͷͰ
ΒͰ
ͻͪͯ͹ͬͪͶ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͷͰΌ;
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͳͷͪ
͸ͪ΃Ͱͭ
ͭͻͪͯͪ

ͼͬͪ͵ͳ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
ͼͬͰ
ͬͰΕͳ
ͫͻ͹Β
ͷͶͪͯͳ΀
Γ;ͯͳ
ͳͲ
ͼͬͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ

̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ΒͰͻ
ͷͳ΃ΓͰΔͪ
ͼͪͷ
ͯͪ
ΕͰ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒ;Εͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͰ
͹ͷͶͪͯͳ͸ͪ

;͸Ͱͽͳ
͸͹ͬͳ
ͯ;΀
;
ͷͰΌ;͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
ͯ;΀
ͳͼ͵ͻͰ͸Ͱ
ͽͰͱΔͰ
Ͳͪ
ͷͰΌ;
ͼ͹ͫ͸ͳͷ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪΔͰͷ
ͳ
ͳͼ͵ͻͰ͸͹ͷ
ͼͪͻͪͯΔ͹ͷ
̀ͪͽ͹
ͼͪ
ͻͪͯ͹΃Ε;
ͺ͹ͲͯͻͪͬΓͪͷ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͰ
͹ͬͰ
͵ΔͳͭͰ
ͳ
;ͬͰ
ΌͰ͸
ͼͪͷ
ͯͪ
ΕͰ
;
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͵ͪͯͪ
ͷͶͪͯͳ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
ͫ;ͯͰ
ͯ͹ͼͽͳͭͪ͹
ͲͻͰͶ͹
ͷ;ͱͰͬ
͸͹
ͯ͹ͫͪ
ͯ͹ͫͻͪ
ͬ͹Γͪ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
͹Βͪ΂ͪͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͬͰ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͼ͸ͪͭͰ
ͺ͹
ͼͬͰͽͰ
ͷͳͻ͹Γ;ͫͳͬ͹ͷ
ͻͪͯ;i

́ͪ͵͹
ͯ͹͸Ͱ͵ͶͰ
;ͺ;ΕͰ͸
;
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ;
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
͵͹Βͳ
͹ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
ͷͶͪ
Όͪ͸ͳ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͽͰͻͪ͸͹
ͽͪ΂ͪ͸
;
ͺ͹Βͷ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳ
͋ͪ͵͹

Ͳͪ
ΔͰͭͪ
͏ͻ͸ͪ
̻͹ͻͪ
ͳͷͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫͪ͸
ͼͽͪͽ;ͼ
;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ;
͸ͪ
͹ͼͽͪͶͰ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͰ

͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͬͪΓͯͪ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͻ͹ͷͪ͸ͽͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
͸ͪͲͳͬͪ
ͅ͹͸ͽͰ͸Ͱͭͻ͹
ͪ
͡;
ͫΓͪ͸ͪ
ͳͼͺͪͯͪ
ͼͶ͹ͬͪ΂͵ͪ
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁ͪ
͆ͪͻͪͬ͸͹
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͪ
͸ͪͷͰ͸ͪ
͹ͬͰ

͵ΔͳͭͰ
ΒͰ
6OUFSIBMUVOH
ͪͶͳ
;ͺͻͪͬ͹
Ͳͪͽ͹
͹͸ͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
͹ͯͶͳ΂͸;

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵;
ͻͰ͵Ͷͪͷ;

̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ

͍;͸͵΁ͳΒ;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͼ;
ͬͻ΃ͳͶͰ
ͳ
ͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
Β;
ͷͰ΃ͪͬͳ͸;
ͳͼͺ͹ͬͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͲͰ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͻ͸ͳ΀
;ͲͶͰͽͪ
ͭͰ͹ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͳ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ΀
ͼͽ;ͯͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͷͰͼͽ͹
ͼ;ͼͻͰͽͪ
ͻͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͼͽͳ
΁ͳͬͳͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ

̀ͪͺͪͯͪ
ͳ
ͷͳͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
́ͼͽ͹͵ͪ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͼͽͳ΁ͪΒ͸͹
͸ͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭͰ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ

͌
ͺ͹ͽͻͪͲͳ
Ͳͪ
ͽ͹ͷ
ͬͻͼͽ͹ͷ
ͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬͪ
͵ͪ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Β;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ
͸ͳ΀
͹ͫͻͪͲͪ΁ͪ
͵ͪ͵ͬͳͷ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪͬͪ͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
;ͺ;ͽͳ͹
ͼͰ
ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͭͳͷ͸ͪͲͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͿͰͼ͹ͻ
̺ͳ΀Ͱͻ
̺ͪͶ͵
8JFHFS
7BML

͆ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹
ͬ;
ͼͬ͹ͭ
Ͷͳ΂͸͹ͭ
ͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͼͪ
ͷͰͻ͹ͯͪͬ͸ͳͷ
ͯ͹ͷͪ
Εͳͷ
ͳ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳͷ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͳͷͪ
͹͸
ΒͰ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳ͹
ͺͻͬͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂

͵͹Βͳ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͱͪ͸ͻ͹ͬͼ͵͹
͹ͺͻͰͯͰΓͰΔͰ
͸͹ͼͳ
;
ͼͪͷ͹ͷ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ;
m
3FJTHJET

WPPS
IFU
CVJUFOMBOE
m
+PFHPTMBWJÌ
m
ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ

;
ͼͬ͹Β͹Β
ͼͰͻͳΒͳ
͹ͫΒͪ
ͬͳ͹
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵ͳ
ͪ;ͽ͹mͷ͹ͽ͹
ͼͪͬͰͲ
̸͆8̹
͌
ͼͬ͹ͷ
ͺͻͰͯͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ;
ͽͪͯͪ΃Δͳ
ͺ͹΂ͪͼ͸ͳ
ͭͰ͸ͰͻͪͶ͸ͳ
͵͹͸Ͳ;Ͷ
̓ͻͪ
ΓͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
̓͹ͻ͸ͰͶͳͼ
̽ͳͻ͵
ͅͰͻͰ͸ͼ
ͳͼͽͪ͵ͪ͹
ΒͰ
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ



͇
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͷ
͹΁;
ͪͅΒ͸ͪͻͯ;
ͅͰͻͰ͸ͼ;
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͺ͹΂ͪͼ͸͹ͷ
͵͹͸Ͳ;Ͷ;
ͬͳͯͳ

͆͹ͬͪ͵͹ͬͳΕ̈́͹ͺ;΃ͳ͸ͪ


 ͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
;
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ 

͸Ͱ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ͹ͬͰ
͹ͼ͹ͫͳ͸Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
͵ͻͪͼͰ
ͳ
ͼͬͰ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͳͼ΁Ͱ
ͫͰ
ͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͽ͹ͭ
ͻͪͲͯ͹ͫΓͪ
ͪ
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸ͪ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͼͪ͸͹ͼͽ
͸ͪ΂ͳͽͪ͸͹ͼͽ

ͳ
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹͸ͪͷͰͻ͸͹ͼͽ
͊ͬ͹Β
ͺ͹ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ
͹ͬͪΒ
ͼͬͰͼͽͻͪ͸͹
ͪ͸ͭͪͱ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ͵
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
Ͳͪ΀ͬͪΓ;Β;Εͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳͷ
͵͹͸ͽͪ͵ͽͳͷͪ
ͼͪ
ͺͻͳ͸΁͹ͷ

͈ͪͬͶ͹ͷ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͼͽͬͪ
͸ͪ΃Ͷͪ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
;
ͬͶͪͼ͸ͳ
΃ͽͬ;
͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͭ
ͷ;ͲͰΒͪ

Ͳͪͬͻ΃ͪͬͪ
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͳͷ
ͻͰ΂ͳͷͪ

t͆Ͱ͵ͪ
͹ͬͪ
͵Δͳͱͳ΁ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͶ;ͱͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂͸ͳ
ͺͻͳͻ;΂͸ͳ͵
͸ͪ

ͺ;ͽ;
Ͳͪ
ͲͰͷΓ;
͵͹Βͪ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͱͯͪ
ͷ͹ͭͶͪ
͸ͪͲͬͪͽͳ
͸ͪΒͶͰͺ΃͹ͷ
ͳ
͸ͪΒͳ͸ͽͰ
ͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ͸ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͷ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
͸Ͱ͵ͪ
͸ͪͳΌͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳΒͰͷ
͵ͪ͵ͪͬ
ͲͪͼͶ;ͱ;ΒͰ

ͳ
͸Ͱ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͺͰ΃ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
;
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳi


͋͹͸
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
̺ͪͶ͵
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬͳ͹
ͬͰΕ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͬ͹Β
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ
͹ͯ
;͵;ͺ͸͹



;ͺͻͪͬ͹
ͺ͹ͽͬͻΌ;ΒͰ
ͅͰͻͰ͸ͼ͹ͬͰ
ͻͰ΂ͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
ͷ͹ͱͯͪ
͸ͪΒ
ͶͰͺ΃ͪ
ͲͰͷΓͪ
;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
;ͺͻͪͬ͹
Ͳͪͽ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͪ
;
ͷͪͶ͹ͷ
t͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͲͰͷΓͪ
ͫͰͲ
ͺͻͰͷ΁ͪ
͌
ͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ

ͷ͹ͻ;
ͺͶ;ͽͪΒ;
͸ͳͲ͹ͬͳ
͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
ͺ͹ͺ;ͽ
͹͵ͳΕͰ͸ͳ΀
ͫͪͻ͵ͳ
ͯ͹͵
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
͵͹ͺ
͸;
;ͼͻͰͯ
ͽͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͼͽͳΔͪ
ͼͷͰΔ;Β;
ͲͪͶͳͬͳ
͸ͪͶͳ͵
͸ͪ
΃ͬͪΒ΁ͪͻͼ͵ͪ

ΒͰͲͰͻͪ
ͳ
͸͹ͻͬͰ΃͵Ͱ
ͿΒ͹ͻͯ͹ͬͰ
̸
͵ͪ͵͹
ͽͰ͵
͹ͺ΂ͳΔͪͬͪΒ;
ͳͲͶͰͽͳ
ͯ;ͱ
̽;
͸ͪͬͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͷͰΌ;
ͭ͹ͻͯͰ
͏ͻ͸͹ͭ͹ͻ΁Ͱ
ͺͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ
ͯͪͶͷͪͽͳ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
͵ͪͽͰͯͻͪ
Ͷͪͷͪ
Β;ͱ͸͹ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
͊ͺͶͳͽ

̽;ͫͻ͹ͬ͸ͳ͵
ͅ͹ͼͽͪͻ
ͳͶͳ
͊ͪͻͪΒͰͬ͹
ͭͯͰ
ͼͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
;
͸Ͱͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸͹ͷ
ͯ͹
ͯͳͻ;
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒͰ
ͼͪ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͺͻͪͬͳ΀
ͷ;ͼͶͳͷͪ͸ͪ
͐ͳͷ
ΒͰ
ͷ;ΒͰͲͳ͸
ͼ
ͬͳͽ
͵͹ͭ
ͷͳ͸ͪͻͰͽͪ
͹ͽͺͰͬͪ͹
͸ͪ
ͼͬͰ
΂Ͱͽͳͻͳ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
̸Ͷͪ΀
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ

ͫ͹ͭ
ͪ
ͅ;΀ͪͷͰͯ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ
ͺͻ͹ͻ͹͵
͵ͪ
ΘͪͷͳΒͳ
ͺ͹΀ͻͶͰ
ͷ;΃͵ͪͻ΁ͳ
͹͵ͳΕͰ͸ͳ

ͿͰͼ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͫͪ͸ͳͷͪ
̸
Ͳͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͻͪͷͪͲͪ͸ͪ
ͷ;ͼͶͳͷͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪ

;
ͼͬͳͷ
ͼͰ
ΘͪͷͳΒͪͷͪ
;ͬͰ΂Ͱ
ͺͪͶͰ
ͼͬͰΕͰ
ͯ͹͵
Ͷͪͷͺͳ͹͸ͳ
ͳ
΃ͪͻͰ͸Ͱ
ͼͬͰ
ͽͳΓ͵Ͱ
͹ͫͪͼͳͺͪΒ;
ͫͪ΃ͽͰ
ͳ
ͬͻͽ͹ͬͰ
ͼͬͰͽͶ͹΃Ε;
͸ͪͶͳ͵
͸ͪ
ͫͰ͸ͭͪͶͼ͵Ͱ
ͬͪ
ͽͻͰ
ͪ
ͷͳ͸ͪͻͰͽͳ
ͺ͹ͺ;ͽ
ͺͶͪͷͰ͸ͳ΀
ͼͽͻͰͶͪ
ͼͽͻͰͷͰ
;ͬͳͼ
ͳͲ
ͷͻͪ͵ͪ
ͲͰͷΓͰ

ͳ
͹ͫͶͳͱΔͰ
ͬ͹ͯͰ
̸͵͹
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ͯ͹ͯͪͷ͹
ͭ͹ͼͽ͹Γ;ͫͳͬ͹ͼͽ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͪ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪ
ͬͪΔͰ
Ͱ͸ͭͶͰͼ͵͹ͭ
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳͶͳ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ͺͪ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
͸͹΃ΔͰ
͵͹ΒͰ

ͼͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;Β;
͹ͯ
ͼͰͶͪ
ͯ͹
ͼͰͶͪ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͻͪͲ͸͹Ͷͳ͵͹ͼͽ
ͺͰΒͲͪͱͪ
͹͸ͯͪ
ΒͰ

ͻͪͲ;ͷΓͳͬ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͬͪ͵ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
;ͫͻͲ͹
͹ͽ͵ͻͳΒͰ
͸Ͱ͵͹
ͷͰͼͽ͹
͵͹ΒͰ
͹ͯͪΒͰ

;ͽͳͼͪ͵
ͯͪ
ͷ;
͸ͪ
ͲͰͷΓͳ
͸Ͱͷͪ
ͺͻͰͷ΁ͪ
ͺͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͽ͹ͭͪ
ͷ͹ͻͪ
ͫͳͽͳ
͵;ͽͪ͵

ͻͪΒͪi



͈͹
ͼͬ͹Β͹Β
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͳ
̺ͪͶ͵͹ͬ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
ͳͷͪ
͹ͯͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͺ;ͽ͹
ͺͳͼ͸Ͱ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͰ
͹ͫ͹ͭͪΕͰ͸Ͱ
ͰͶͰͷͰ͸ͽͳͷͪ
ͭͰ͹ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͽ;ͯͳΒͰ
͌
ͼͰͯͪͷ͸ͪͰͼͽ
ͺ͹ͭͶͪͬΓͪ
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͳ
͵͹
Βͳ
ͺ͹
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͼ΀ͬͪͽͪΔ;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͪ

ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
͸ͪΒͺͻͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
͊͵͹ͺΓͰ
͡;ͫΓͪ͸ͪ

̽;ͫͻ͹ͬ͸ͳ͵
ͅ͹ͼͽͪͻ
͊ͪͻͪΒͰͬ͹
ͳ
͡;ͫΓͪ͸ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͼͶ;ͱͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹
ͶͪͲͳ΃ͽͪ
Ͳͪ
ͳͲͶͰͽͰ
;
ͫͶͳͱ;
ͳ
ͯͪΓ;
͹͵͹Ͷͳ͸;
 ͠ͰͶͳ΁ͪ
͆͹ͬͪ͵͹ͬͳΕ̈́͹ͺ;΃ͳ͸ͪ

͑ͽ͹
ͼͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
;
ͯͬͪ
ͼͽ;ͺ΁ͪ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͭͶͪͬ͸Ͱ
͵;Ͷ
ͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
̓ͪͶͰͷͰͭͯͪ͸
ͅ;ͲͰΒ
ͺͻͳ͸΁ͪ
͈ͪ
ͬͶͪ

ͼ
͸Ͱ͹ͺ΀͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
͹ͫΒͪ΃ΔͰΔͳͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͬͳΌͰΔͰ
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͬͪ
͵͹ͯ͸Ͱͬͳ΁Ͱ
t̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͼ
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͷ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͺ͹͸͹ͼ͸ͳ
͸ͪ
̓ͪͶͰͷͰͭͯͪ͸
ΒͰͻ

ͽͰ͵
͸ͪ͵͹͸
ͯ;ͱͰͭ
͹͵ͶͰͬͪΔͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
͹ͺͰͽ
;ͼͷͰͻͪͬͪ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
͵͹ͻͪ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͰ
ͷͪ
ͭͻͪͯ;
ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
͵ͪͯ
ͼͰ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
͸ͪΌͰ
;
ͺͻͳΒͪͽ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰͽ͸ͳͷ
ͽͻ
ͭ͹ͬͪ΂͵ͳͷ
;Ͷͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͭͯͰ
ͼͰ
ͼ;ͼͻͰΕ;
ͳͼͽ͹͵
ͳ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͼͬͰ
ͻͪͼͰ
ͼͻͰͯ
ΔͰ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
͹ͺͰͽ
Ͷͪ͵͹
Ͳͪͫ͹ͻͪͬͳ
͸ͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
̓ͪ͵ͬͳ΀
ͼͰ
ͼͬͰ
tͽͳͺ͹ͬͪi
΃ͰΕͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ͹ͷ
̽ͪ
ΒͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
ͯ;ͭ͹

ͫͳ͹
ͺ͹ͯ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵ͳͷ
;ͽͳ΁ͪΒͰͷ
ͬͳͯͳ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹
ͿͰͼ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
͸͹ͼͰ
ͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ

͸Ͱͷ;ͼͶͳͷͪ͸ͳ
̸Ͷͬͪ
m
ͼͶͪͽ͵ͳ΃
͹ͯ
ͫͻͪ΃͸ͪ
ͷͰͯͪ
ͷͶͰ͵ͪ
ΒͪΒͪ
ͳ
ͷͶͰͬͰ
͸ͳ΀
ͫͪͯͰͷͪ
m
ͳͲͶ͹ͱͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
;
͵͹ͽ;ͻͳͷͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͺ;ͽ
ͷͶͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͽ͹΂
͵͹ͬͪ
͋ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͶͪͼͽͳ΁ͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͼͶͪͽ͵ͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
Ͳͪͺͻͪͬ͹
ͼͪͷ͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰͼͽͳ
;Ͳ

΁ͻ͸;
͵ͪͿ;
ͳͶͳ
ͫ͹Ͳ;
m
Ͷͳͷ;͸ͪͯ;
ͼͺͻͪͬΓͰ͸;
͹ͯ
͵;͵;ͻ;Ͳͪi



̓ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͽ͹
ͳ
ͺͻͳͶͳ΂ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
ͼͰ
ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
͹ͼͬͻΕͰ
ͳ
͸ͪ

ͭ;ͻͷͪ͸Ͷ;͵
͊ͺ͹ͷͳΔ;Εͳ
ͻͪͲ͸͹Ͷͳ͵͹ͼͽ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
͹͸
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͻ͹΃ͽͳΓ
ͳ

Ͷ;͵
͵ͪ͹
͸ͰͳͲ͹ͼͽͪͬ͸;
tͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵;
ͬͪ͸ͳͶ;i


̓͹ͯ
͹ͫͳ΂͸͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
ͭͪ
Ϳͪͼ΁ͳ͸ͳͻͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹
ͺ͹͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͯͻͱͪΔͰ
ͳ

ͶͰͺ͹ͽͪ
͸͹΃Δͳ
t͊ͰΓͪ΁ͳ
ͳ
ͼͰΓͪ͸͵Ͱ
;
ͶͰͺͳͷ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
͸͹΃Δͪͷͪ
m
;
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͯ͸Ͱͬ
͸͹Β
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ
ͭͻͪͯ;
m
΀͹ͯͪΒ;
;Ͷͳ΁ͪͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͺͶͰͷͳΕͳ
ͳ
ͺͶͰͷ͵ͳΔͰ
ͷͰͼͪͻ

ͺ͹ͯ
ͬͰͻͯͳͷ
͸Ͱͫ͹ͷ
͹͵ͻͰΕͰ
ͺͻͪͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͻͪͱΔ;
ͼͳͻ͹ͽͳΔͼ͵ͳ
͹ͫ;΂Ͱ͸ͳ

Γ;ͯͳ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͰ
;ͼͶ;ͭͰ
΂ͳͼͽͪ΂ͪ
΁ͳͺͰͶͪ
΁ͳͭͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͷ;Ͳͳ͵ͪ
ͯ͹ͺͳͻͰ
ͳͲ

ͼͬͳ΀
͵ͪͿͪ͸ͪ
͇ͺ΀ͻͬͪ͸
ͼͬͳͷ
͹ͬͳͷ
;ͽͳͼ΁ͳͷͪ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͪ΁
;
͸Ͱ͵ͳͷ
΂Ͱͽͬͻ
ͽͳͷͪ
ͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
;ͽͳͼͪ͵
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
;
͸Ͱ͵͹ͷ
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͷ
͵ͻͪΒ;
ͼͬͰͽͪ
͈͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͳ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͳ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
ͼͪ
ͺͪͶͪͽͪͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
;

Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
ͼͪ
ͯͰͼͰͽͪ͵
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬ͸ͳ΀
΁ͻ͵ͪͬͪ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
ΘͪͷͳΒ͹ͷ

ͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳͷ
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͫ͹ͭ͹ͷ͹Γͪͷͪ
ͳͷͪ
ͼ͵;Ͷͺͽ;ͻͪ
ͳ
ͷ;ͲͰΒͪi


͋ͪΒ
ͼ;ͯͪͻ
ͼͬͰͽ͹ͬͪ
ͽ͹
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂͸͹
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂ΒͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ

ͬͰΕ
ͳͼͽͪ͵͸;ͽ͹
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻ
Ϳͪͼ΁ͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͪ
Ϳͪͼ΁ͳ͸ͪ
΁ͳΒͪ
ͻͪͼͽͰ
ͼͪ
ͳͲͻͪͲͳͽ͹΃Ε;
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵ͪ
́Ͳ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
̺ͪͶ͵
͸ͪΒͺͻͰ
ͺ;ͽ;ΒͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
̽;͸ͪͬͪ
ͯ͹
͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͪ

̻͹Ͷ;ͺ΁ͪ
ͳ
̓Ͷͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
͹ͽͳͼ͸;͹
;
t͠;ͱ͸;
͊ͻͫͳΒ;i
͋͹
ΒͰ



͈ͻͳ͸΁
͈ͪͬͶͰ
ΒͰ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͭ
Ͳͪ΀ͬͪΓ;Β;Εͳ
ͪ͸ͭͪͱͷͪ͸;
ͭͰ͸ͰͻͪͶ͸͹ͭ

͵͹͸Ͳ;Ͷͪ
ͅͰͻͰ͸ͼͪ
Ͳͪ
ͅ;ͲͰΒ
͸ͪͫͪͬͳ͹
΂ͰͽͻͯͰͼͰͽͪ͵
ͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͪ
ͳͲ
jͲͰͷΓͰ
͉Ͱͷͫͻͪ͸ͽͪv

͵ͪ͵͹
̺ͪͶ͵
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ


̽ͪΓͰ
;
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
̺ͪͶ͵
͸;ͯͳ
ͳ
΁Ͱ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵
ͽͳ΀
;ͼͶ;ͭͪ
͐ͳ΃ͰΔͰ
΁ͳͺͰͶͪ

ͳͲ͸͹ͼͳͶ͹
ΒͰ

ͯͳ͸ͪͻͪ
ͽΒ

ͺͻ͹ͼͰ΂͸Ͱ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵Ͱ
͸ͪͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
 ͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
;
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ 

͸ͪͳͷͰ
͸ͪͲͳͬ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͯͰ͹
ͪ;ͽ͹
ͻͪ
ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͰ

Ͳͪ
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃Δ;
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒ;
̺ͪͶ͵

ͰͶͰͭͪ͸ͽ͸͹
ͼ;ͭͰͻͳ΃Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵;

ͺ͹Ͳͪͯͳ͸;
͸ͪͲͳͬͪ
͸Ͱ
;ͺ;΃ͽͪΒ;Εͳ

ͼͰ
;
ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸͹ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͬ͹ͯͰ
t͠;ͱ͸;
͊ͻͫͳΒ;
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
͸ͪͲͳ
ͬͪΒ;
ͺ͹ΒͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸͹
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳ
Β͹ͷ
ͪͶͳ
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔ;
ͺ͹
͹ͬͳͷ

Β;ͱ͸ͳͷ
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͳͷͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ

ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂Γͳͬ
ΒͰ
͹ͺͻͰͲ
;
͵͹ͻͳ
΃ΕͰΔ;
ͻͪ͸ͳΒͳ΀
͸ͪͲͳͬͪ
ΒͰͻ
͹͸ͳ

͵͹ͯ
Β;ͱ͸ͳ΀
͊ͻͫͪ
ͫ;ͯͰ
;ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ

͸ͪ
ͽͰ΃͵ͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͪ
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ
ͺͻ͹
ͫ;ͯͰ
ͳ
͹΂Ͱ͵ͳͬͪΔͪ
͉ͳͷΓͪ͸ͳ

̻ͻ΁ͳ
̹;ͭͪͻͳ
̺ͳͲͪ͸ͽͳ͸΁ͳ
͊ͻ
ͫͳ
ͳ
͋;ͻ΁ͳ
ͼͬͳ
ͼ;
͹͸ͳ
;ͽͳͼ͸;
Ͷͳ
ͼͬ͹Β
ͺͰ΂ͪͽ
͸ͪ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ͹

͵͹ͭͪ
ͫ͹ͭ͹ͷ͹ΓͰ
ͺ͹ͯͼͰΕͪΒ;
͸ͪ
ͽ͹

ͯͪ
͸ͳ΂ͳΒͪ
ͬͶͪͼͽ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͬͰ΂͸ͪ
ͳ
ͯͪ

͵ͶͰͽͬͪ
ͽͰ΃͵͹
ͺ͹ͫͰΌͰ͸͹ͷA
ͺͻͰͯ
ͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͼ;ͻ͹ͬ;
ͳͼͽͳ͸;i


̺ͪͶ͵
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ;
̹ͳͽ͹Γͪ
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ΃Δͳ
ͪͅ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ

ͳ
ͺͻ͹
ͷͰ͸ΓͳͬͰ
ͼ;ͯͫͳ͸Ͱ
ͫ͹ͭ͹ͷ͹Γͪ
ͳͶ;ͼͽͻ;ΒͰ
ͽ;
ͼͬ͹Β;
͵͹͸ͼͽͪͽͪ΁ͳΒ;
̓ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΕͰ
ͼͰ
ͳͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬͳͽͳ
ͳ
ͳͲ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹
͸ͳΒͪ
ͽΒ
ͽͪͯͪ΃Δͪ
͠;ͱ͸ͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͪͬ͹
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹

͹ͽ͵ͻ͹ͬͰΔͰ
͈͹ͻͰͯ
̹͹ͼ͸Ͱ
͹͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹
ͷͰͻͳͶͳͷͪ
ͽͪͯͪ΃Δͳ΀
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵ͳ΀

ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͯ͹ͬͪͶͪ
ͼͬͰ
͹ͼ͹ͫͳ͸Ͱ
ͪ;ͽͰ͸ͽͳ΂͸͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
΀ͳͽͪ

͵ͪ͵͹
ͺ͹
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͪ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͳ
ͺ͹
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
ͼͶͳ͵͹ͬͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ

ͳ
ͭ͹ͼͽ͹Γ;ͫͳͬ͹ͼͽͳ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
̺ͪͶ͵
ΒͰ
;ͺͻ͵͹ͼ
ͼ͹ͺͼͽͬͰ͸͹ͷ
Ͱ͸ͽ;
ͲͳΒͪͲͷ;
ͳͺͪ͵
ͼͬͰͼͽͪ͸
ͻͪͲͷͪͱͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͰ΂͸͹ͭ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹ͭ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͳ
͹
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ
ͻͪ΂;͸ͪ
t̀ͯ;΃͸͹
ͼͰ
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
ͪͶͳ
ͳͪ͵͹
ͷ͹ͻͪͷ͹
ͯͪ
ͺ͹΀ͬͪ
Ͷͳͷ͹
Β;ͱ͸;
͊ͻͫͳΒ;
͵ͪ͹
ͲͰͷΓ;
;
͵͹Β͹Β
Ϳ͹Ͷ͵Ͷ͹ͻͳͼͽͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳ΂ͪͻͳ
ͳ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ
ͳͷͪΒ;
΃ͽͪ
ͯͪ
͸ͪ;΂Ͱ
ͳ
΂Ͱͭͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ;ͱͳͬͪΒ;
ͳͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ

ͼͳͻ͹ͷͪ΃͸͹
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ͹
͹ͯ
ͼͻ΁ͪ
ͽͻ;ͯͳ
ͯͪ
ͫ;ͯͰ
͸ͪ
;ͼͶ;Ͳͳ
ͽ;ͻͳ
ͼͽͳͷͪ
͹͸ͪΒ
͵͹
͹΂Ͱ͵;ΒͰ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸ͳ
͵͹ͷͿ͹ͻ
ͫ͹ΓͰ
ΕͰ
ͼͰ
ͼ͸ͪΕͳ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͭͯͰ

ͯͻ;ͭͯͰ
;
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳi


̀ͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ;
͹ͽͰͶͪ
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
͹ͺͼͰͻͬͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͵͹Βͪ
;
ͯͪ
͸ͪ΃ΔͰ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
;
͎͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͳΒͳ
͸Ͱ
ͫͳ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;Εͪ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ

͸Ͱ͵͹ͻͰ͵ͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
 ͠ͰͶͳ΁ͪ
͆͹ͬͪ͵͹ͬͳΕ̈́͹ͺ;΃ͳ͸ͪ

t̽͹͵
Β;ͱ͸͹ͼͻͺͼ͵͹
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ͹
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͺ͹ͬ͹Γͪ͸

;ͽͳͼͪ͵
͸ͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰ
ͼͪ
΁ͳͭͪ͸ͳͷͪ
ͳͼ;ͬͳ΃Ͱ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
ͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͳ
ͻͪ
ͻͪͲ͹΂ͪͻͪΔͳͷͪi



͈͹ͯ
tͻͪͲ͹΂ͪͻͪΔͰͷi
̺ͪͶ͵
ͺ͹ͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪ
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹
ͯͻ;͵΂ͳΒͰ
ͬͻͰͯ
͸͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͻͪͯͪ
;
ͻ͹ͷͼ͵͹Β
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͆ͪͬͳ͵ͪ͹
͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͽͰͼͽͪ͸ͽͼ͵;
ͻͪͯ͸;

Ͱͽͳ͵;
͹͸
͸ͳΒͰ
;
ͼͽͪΔ;
ͯͪ
ͼ΀ͬͪͽͳ
ͯͻ;͵΂ͳΒ;
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ͸;
ͿͳͶ͹Ͳ͹ͿͳΒ;
͋͹

ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
͸Ͱͭ͹ͯ͹ͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
͸Ͱͺ͹ΒͷΓͳͬ͹ͼͽͳ
ͻ͹ͷͼ͵͹ͭ
ͷͰ͸ͽͪͶͳͽͰͽͪ
ͳͶ;
ͼͽͻ;ΒͰ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
ͪ͸Ͱ͵ͯ͹ͽ͹ͷ
t͎͹ΕͰ΃
Ͷͳ
ͯͪ
ͻͪͯͳ΃
Ͳͪ
ͷͰ͸Ͱ i
;ͺͳͽͪ
͸Ͱ͵͹
ͭͻͷͪΓͪ
͹ͯ
΂͹ͬͰ͵ͪ

͵͹Βͳ
ͷ;
ͼͪ
͹ͼͷͰ΀͹ͷ
;Ͳͬͻͪͽͳ
̽ͪ
ΒͰ
̹͹ͭ
ͱͰͶͰ͹
ͯͪ
Βͪ
ͻͪͯͳͷ
ͼͽͬ͹ͻͳ͹

ͫͳ
ͷͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͬ͹Ͷͪ
ͪ
͸Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
΁ͳͭͪ͸ͳ͸ͪi



͌
͸Ͱ΂ͪͼͽͪ͸
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͲͪͻͪΌͳͬͪΔͪ
̺ͪͶ͵
͹ͼͳͷ
ͭͪͽͪΔͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͬ͹ͯͪΘͳ
ͼͪΔͪ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼΒͪ΂ͰΔͰ
ͳ
Ͷͪͱ͸͹
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͰ
t͆ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼΒͪ͵Ͱ
ͼͰ
ͳ͸ͪ΂Ͱ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
͸ͪͳΕͳ
ͼͬ;ͯͪ
ͺ͹
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͳ
ͪͶͳ

ͳ
͸ͪ
͸ͪͷͰͽΓͳͬͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂Ͱ
͈ͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͳͲͬͰͼͽͪ͸
͹ͺͻͰͲ
ͺͻͳ

ͳͲͫ͹ͻ;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ΒͰͻ
ͽͪ
ͭ͹ͼͺ͹ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͯͶͳ΂͸͹
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰ
;
;ͷͰΕͰ
ͼ͵ͶͪͺͪΔͪ

ͺ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͪ
͹
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
͸ͰͷͪΒ;
ͫͶͪͭ͹ͭ
ͺ͹Βͷͪ
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
͸ͪ
͸ͪΒΓ;ͫͪͲ͸ͳΒͳ

͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͺͪͺͻͰ͸͹
͸ͪͺͶͪͽͳͶͳ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
;ͼͶ;ͭͰ
̽ͪ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͳͲͫͰͭͶͪ
ͽͪ͵ͬͪ
ͻͪͲ͹
΂ͪͻͰΔͪ
ͫ͹ΓͰ
ΒͰ
͹ͫͻͪͽͳͽͳ
ͼͰ
͈;ͽ͸ͳ͵;
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͼͬ;ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͬͰͲͪ͸
ͼͪ
;΂Ͱ
͸ͳͷ
Γ;ͯͳͷͪi


̽ͪ
ΒͰ
̺ͪͶ͵
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ
ͼͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ͹ͷ
͵ͻͪΒͪ
͵͹Βͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ;ΒͰ
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂ͳ

΂ͳΔͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͯͪ
͊͵͹ͺΓͰ
͸ͪΒͪͬΓ;ΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁;
ͼͽͪͻͰ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸Ͱ

͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
͌ͺͻ͵͹ͼ
ͽͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͬͰͻͰ͸ͳͷ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ;
ͼͰ

ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
ͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪͶ͸͹ͭ
;Ͷͪͼ͵ͪ
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹Ͷ͹͸ͪͼͶͰͯ͸ͳ͵ͪ
̸ͶͰ͵
ͼͪ͸ͯͻͪ
ͳ
͵ͻͪΓͪ
͈Ͱͽͻͪ
;
͊͵͹ͺΓͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͺ͹ͽ͵ͻͪͯͪ
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ

ͭͻͰ΃͵ͪ
;
ͺͻͰͬ͹ͯ;
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͭͰͼͶͪ
t͊ͪͷ͹
ͼͶ͹ͭͪ
͊ͻͫͳ͸ͪ
ͼͺͪ΃ͪͬͪi
͇͸

ͭͪ
͸ͰͪͯͰ͵ͬͪͽ͸͹
ͺͻͰͬ͹ͯͳ
͵ͪ͹
t4FSWJTDI
IFJM
MJHU
JO
EF
FFVXJHIFJEi
ͽΒ

t͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͼͺͪͼ
ΒͰ
;
ͬͰ΂͸͹ͼͽͳi



̺ͪͶ͵͹ͬͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
͵͹ͷͰ͸ͽͪͻͳ
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
͹͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͪͽͳ

͵ͪ͹
VOEFSTUBUFNFOU
̽ͪΒͰ
ͳ΀
ͼͪͷ͹
͹ͬͶͪ΃
ͫͰͲ
͹ͫΒͪ΃ΔͰΔͪ
ͳ
ͯ;ͫΓͰ
ͪ͸ͪ
ͶͳͲͰ
͋ͪ͵͹
͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔ;
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
̽Ͱͫͪͻ
͵ͪͱͰ
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͰ
t̽Ͱͫͪͻ
̻ͻͪͯ
ͼͪ
ͳͲͻͪͱͰ͸͹
͹ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͪͶ͸ͳͷ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ͹ͷ
̺Ͱ͵͹ͬͳ
ͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͽͻͺͰ͹
͹ͯ
̸ͻ͸ͪ;ͽͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͼ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͺ͹ͺ;ͽ

ͶͰ΃ͳ͸ͪͻͪ
ͼͽ;΃ͽͳͶͳ
ͳͲ
ͪͶͫͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͫͳ
ͼͬͰ
͹ͯ
ͳ͵ͪ͵ͬͰ

ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͹ͯͬͶͪ΂ͳͶͳ
;
ͼͬ͹Βͪ
ͼ͵ͻ͹ͬͳ΃ͽͪi


̸;ͽ͹ͻ
ͺͻͳ
ͽ͹ͷ
͸Ͱ
ͯͪΒͰ
͸ͳ͵ͪ͵ͬ͹ͭ
͹ͫΒͪ΃ΔͰΔͪ
;Ͳ
ͺ͹Βͪͷ
t̸ͻ͸ͪ;
ͽͳi
͵͹Βͳ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͰ΂͸͹ͭ
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵͹ͭ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁ͪ
͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
͸ͰͯͰͿͳ͸ͳͼͪ͸
́Ͳ

͸Ͱ͵ͳ΀
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
͹ͺͪͼ͵ͳ
ͼͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
Βͪͼ͸͹
ͬͳͯͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
̺ͪͶ͵
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͳͼͽ͹
ͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͳ͵;ͺͳ͹
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
͇ͫͳͶͪͲͰΕͳ
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬ͸Ͱ
ͷͪ͸ͪ
 ͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
;
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ 

ͼͽͳͻͰ
͸ͪ
͇΀ͻͳͯ;
ͳ
͵ͻͪΒ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ
͆͹ͬ͹ͭ
͹͸
ͼͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͳͲͭͻͪΌͰ͸ͳ

Ͳͪ΀ͬͪΓ;Β;Εͳ
ͯ͹͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ΀
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͪ
́ͼͽ͹
ͽͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ
ͼͪ

ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͷ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ͹ͷ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ
͆͹ͬ͹ͭ
̓ͪͯ
ͼ;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
;
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
̺ͪͶ͵
ͳͲ
͸͹ͼͳ
ΒͰͯ͸;
͹ͺͪͼ͵;
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΂͵ͪ
ͳ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ΁ͳͷͪ
ΔͰͭ͹
ͬ͹ͭ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͪ
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͸Ͱͭͪͽͳͬ͸ͪ
͹΁Ͱ͸ͪ
ͅͰ΃ͽͻ͹ͬͳΕͰͬͰ
ͼ͵;Ͷͽͺ;ͻͰ
̻ͻͭ;
ͻͪ
͆ͳ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
;
ͺͻͰͯͬ͹ͻΒ;
̽ͳ͹͵ͶͰ΁ͳΒͪ͸͹ͬͰ
ͺͪͶͪͽͰ
͊ͬ͹Β
ͼ;ͯ
͹͸
ͺ͹ͽ͵ͻͰ
ͺΓ;ΒͰ
͵͹ͷͰ͸ͽͪͻ͹ͷ
̹Ͱͻ͸ͪͻͯͪ
͑͹ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯ͸͹
ͳͲΒͪͬͳ͹
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͰ
t͊͵;Ͷͺͽ;ͻͪ
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͫͻͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͪ͵͹
΀͹ΕͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͼͽͪͬͰ
͹ͬͯͰ
͹͸ͯͪ
ͽͻͰ
ͫͪ
ͯͪ
;͵Ͷ͹͸Ͱ
ͺͪͶͪͽ;i


́͸ͪ΂Ͱ
ͳ
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪͬͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͺͻͰͯͬ͹ͻΒͰ
͸Ͱ͵͹ͭ

ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
΂ͳΒͰ
ͬͰͼ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
;
ͬͳͯ;
΃ͪͻͰ͸͹Ͷͳ͵͹
͹ͫ;΂Ͱ͸͹ͭ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
ͬͳ
Όͪ
͸ͪ
ͽͻͭ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͊ͳΔͪ
͊ͺͶͳͽͪ
̽;ͫͻ͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ

͈͹ͼͰͫ͸;
ͺͪͱΔ;
̺ͪͶ͵
;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
͹ͼ͹ͫͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͏ͻ͸Ͱ
̻͹ͻͰ
́
ΔͰͷ;

͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳͷ
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͺͪͯͪ
;
͹΂ͳ
ͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻ΀ͪͶ͸͹
;ͼͽͻ͹Β
ͼͽͬ͹
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͪ
ͺ͹ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ;
͵ͪͯ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒ
ͱͰ͸Ͱ
;
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
ͳ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ
ͺͻͰ
ͷͪ
͹ͻ;ͱΒ;
t̹͹ͻͫͪ
ͼͪ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͹ͷ
͵͹Βͪ
͸ͳ͵ͪͯ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͳͲͯͪ΃͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͻͪͽ͹
ͫ͹ͻ͸ͳ
ͼ;ͼͰͯͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͭ
ͼ;͹΂ͪͬͪͶͳ
ͼͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹΃Ε;
ͺͻͰͬͻͰͷͰ͸Ͱ

ͼͷͻͽͳ
͸ͳͼ;
ͼͪͷ͹
ͺͻ͹ͯ;ͫͳͶͳ
ͻͰͶͳͭͳ͹Ͳ͸͹
͹ͼͰΕͪΔͰ
͸Ͱͭ͹
ͳ
Γ;ͫͪͬ
ͺͻͰ
ͷͪ
͹ͻ;ͱΒ;
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
;ͼͪΌ;ΒͰ
ͬͰΕ
͵͹ͯ
ͯͰ΁Ͱ
̽͹͵ͭ͹ͯ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͯ͹Ͳͬ͹ΓͰ͸͹

͸͹ͼͳͽͳ
͹ͻ;ͱΒͰ
͹ͯͻͪͼͶͳ
ͼ;
ͼͬͪ
ͼͶͪͬΓͪ
Ͳͪͺ͹΂ͳΔͪͶͳ
ͳ
Ͳͪͬͻ΃ͪͬͪͶͳ

ͫͰͼ͹ͷ;΂͸͹ͷ
ͺͪΓͫ͹ͷ
ͯ͹͵
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ
ͯͰ΁;
͹ͷͳΓͰ͸ͪ
ͳͭͻͪ
ͫͳͶ͹
͸ͳ΃ͪΔͰΔͰ
;

ͺͰͬ΁ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͬͰͲͪ͸
Ͳͪ
ͯͪͼ͵;
ͺͶ;ͽͪ͹
ͺ͹
ͽͪͶͪͼͳͷͪi
Ϳ

͠͹΃
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
tͼ΁Ͱ͸Ͱi
ͳͲ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸͹ͭ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ

͵ͪ͹
ͽͳͺͳ΂ͪ͸
ͳͲͻͪͲ
΁ͻ͸͹ͭ͹ͻͼ͵Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
tͅ;΃͵ͪͻ΁ͳ
͹ͭͻ͸;ͽͳ
;
ͻͳͽͰ
΃ͰͽͪΒ;
;͸ͪ͹͵͹Ͷ͹
ͼͪ
͵ͪͺͳ΁ͪͷͪ
͸ͪ

ͭͶͪͬͳ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ͼͰ
͸Ͱ
ͫͳ
ͷ͹ͻͪͶͳ
ͼͽͳͯͰͽͳ
͸ͳ
;
͸ͪΒ͹ͽͷͰ͸ͳΒͳͷ
ͼͪͶ͹͸ͳͷͪ

̺ͳͯͰͶͳ
ͼͷ͹
ͺͻ͹ͼΒͪ͵ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͻ;΂ͳ͹
ͯͪ
ͷ;
ͼͰ
ͯ͹͸ͰͼͰ
͵ͪͿͪ
ͯ͹͵
ͺ;΃Ͱ
Εͳ
;ͫͳΒͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͪͶͳ
͹΂ͳͭͶͰͯ͸͹
ͳͲ
ͽͪ͵ͽͳ΂͸ͳ΀
ͻͪͲͶ͹ͭͪ
͸͹ͼͳ
͹ͯͰΕ;
ͼͪ

Ͳͪ͵ͻͺͪͷͪ
ͻͪͲ͸͹ͻͪͲ͸ͳ΀
ͫ͹Βͪ
͸ͰͯͪͶͰ͵͹
ͷ;
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯ
ͼ;͸΁͹ͫͻͪ͸͹ͷ
ͼͰͯͰͶͪ

͵͹ͶͰͭͳ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͈͹͸͹ͼͳͽͳ
ͷ͹ͷ΁ͳ
ͳͲ
΁ͻ͸͹ͭ͹ͻͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͪ
΃Ͱͺ;ͻͰ
ͼͰ
;
ͫ͹ͭͪ
ͽͳͷ
͸͹΃Δͪͷͪ
ͯ͹͵
Δͳ΀͹ͬͰ
ͱͰ͸Ͱ
ͫͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ
ͺ͹͵;΃ͪͬͪΒ;
ͯͪ
ͺͻ͹
ͯͪΒ;
ͯͻͬͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼ;
Β͹΃
;
ͻͪ͸͹
Β;ͽͻ͹
ͼ͸ͰͶͰ
ͯ͹ͶͰ
͆Ͱ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͺͻͰ͸ͪͭͶ͹

ͼ;ͯͳͽͳ
ͼͳͻ͹ͷͪ΃͸ͳ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ
͏ͻ͸Ͱ
̻͹ͻͰ
ΒͰ
ͬͰ͵͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͷ͹ͻͪ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͫ͹ͻͳ

͸ͪ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ
ͳ
ͼͷͻͽ
Ͳͪ
ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯ;
͵͹Β;
ͼ;
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͳ
ͼͽͰ͵Ͷͳ
ͫͰͲ
ͺ͹
ͷ;
͵Ͱ
ͳͶͳ
ͬͰΕ
͹ͯͪͬ͸͹
ͳ
ͽͪ
ͼͽͪͶ͸ͪ
ͫ͹ͻͫͪ
ͼͽͬ͹ͻͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
Ͳͪ

͸ͪͼ
ͽͰ΃͵͹
ͼ΀ͬͪͽΓͳͬͳi


 ͠ͰͶͳ΁ͪ
͆͹ͬͪ͵͹ͬͳΕ̈́͹ͺ;΃ͳ͸ͪ

͈ͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰ
ͼ;
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
͹͸͹
΃ͽ͹
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
ͼͷͪͽͻͪ
ͬͻ΀;͸

ͼ͵ͳͷ
͸Ͱ͸ͪͯͷͪ΃͸ͳͷ
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹ͷ
͏ͻ͸Ͱ
̻͹ͻͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
͸Ͱͷͪ
ͺͻͰͷ΁ͪ
;
΂ͳͽͪͬ͹Β

̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
͋;
ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
ͷͳͼͶͳ
͸ͪ
̹͹͵;
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵;
ͳ
ͯͰ͹͸ͳ΁;
ͺ;ͽͪ
͹ͯ

̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͯ͹
͏ͰͽͳΔͪ
t͆Ͱͷͪ
͸ͳ΃ͽͪ
ͶͰͺ΃Ͱ
͹ͯ
̽;ͫͻ͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
̈́͹͵ͻ;ͷͪ
Ͳ͸ͪΒ;
ͯͪ
ͳͲΒͪ
ͬͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ
̻ͻͰ΃Ͱ
ΒͰͻ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵ͳ
ͲͪͶͳͬ
ͺͻͰͬͪͲͳͶͪͲͳ
ͼͬͰ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰ
͵͹ΒͰ

͸ͪͷ
ΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͯ͹ͼͪͯ
ͺ͹ͯͪͻͳͶ͹wi


͈ͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ͸͹
ͭͶͰͯͪ͸͹
͸ͪΒͬͰΕ;
ͺͪͱΔ;
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ

ͺ͹͵ͶͪΔͪ
̹͹ͼ͸ͳ
͊ͬ͹ΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͪͺ͹΂ͳΔͰ
;
ͅ͹ͼͽͪͻ;
ͭͯͰ
͹ͯͷͪ΀
ͳͼ
ͺͻͪͬΓͪ
ͭͻͰ΃͵;
ͼͬ͹ͭ
ͼͶͪͬ͸͹ͭ
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸ͳ͵ͪ
̾ͷͪ͸ͽͼͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͼͽͪͻ
ͼ͵ͳ
ͷ͹ͼͽ
͸ͪͲͬͪ͹
ͻͳͷͼ͵ͳͷ
͇ͽ͵ͻͳͬͪ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁ͳͷͪ
ΒͰͯ͸;
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ

ͷͪͶ͹
Ͳ͸ͪ͸;
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽ
ͪ
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͼͽͪͻͼ͵͹
ͺͳͬ͹
͵͹ΒͰ
ͱͳͽͰΓͳ
΀ͶͪͯͰ

ͺ͹ͯ
ͷ͹ͼͽ͹ͷ
;
ͶͰͯͰ͸͹Β
͆ͰͻͰͽͬͳ

̓ͪ͹
ͬͻͶͳ͸;
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͪ΁ͪ
̺ͪͶ͵
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
͹ͼͳͷ
;
ͫ͹ͻͫͪͷͪ

ͺ͹ͯΒͰͯ͸ͪ͵;
ͻͰͬ͸͹ͼͽ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲͪͶͳ
ͳ
;
;΂ͰΔ;
͹ͯ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͯͪ

ͼͰ
;
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ;ͻͳ
ͼ;ͼͻͰΕ;
ͽ;ͻͼ͵ͳ
ͳͽͪͶͳΒͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͯͪͶͷͪͽͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͳ
ͪͻͪͺ
ͼ͵ͳ
;ͽͳ΁ͪΒͳ
́ͪ͵͹
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸;
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
΂ͳ͸Ͱ
͸Ͱͷ;
ͼͶͳͷͪ͸ͳ
͹͸
ͅ͹ͼͽͪͻ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪͬͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͷ;ͼͶͳͷͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͭͯͰ
ͷ;

ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯ
ͺͻͳͬͶͪ΂ͳ
ͬͻͰͬͪ
΂ͪͻ΃ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͷ;ͼͶͳͷͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͱͰ͸ͼ͵ͪ
͸͹΃Δͪ
͵͹Βͪ

ͼͰ
͵ͻͰΕͰ
͹ͯ
΂ͪͯ͹ͻͪ
ͯ͹
ͼͪͷ͹
͹ͬͶͪ΃
ͺͻͰ͵ͻͳͬͰ͸Ͱ
͵͹ͼͰ
́ͼͽͰ
ͼ΁Ͱ͸Ͱ
΂ͪͻ΃ͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
Ϳͪͼ΁ͳ͸ͳͻͪΒ;
ͭͪ
ͳ
;
͊ͪͻͪΒͰͬ;

̺Ͱ͹ͷͪ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸͹
͸ͪ
͸Ͱ͵ͳ΀
ͺͰͽ͸ͪͰͼͽͪ͵
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͪ
͹ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
ͷ;ͼͶͳͷͪ͸ͼ͵;

ͱͳͬ͹ͽ͸;
ͿͳͶ͹Ͳ͹ͿͳΒ;
;͵Γ;΂;Β;Εͳ
ͺ͹Βͷ͹ͬͰ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
ΕͰͳͿ
ͳ
ͪ΃ͳ͵

͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸͹
ͱͳͬΓͰΔͰ
͹ͯ
͵͹ͶͰͬ͵Ͱ
ͯ͹
ͭͻ͹ͫͪ
;͵Γ;΂;Β;Εͳ
ͳ
ͻͰ
΁Ͱͺͽ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻͳͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͰ
͵ͪͿͰ
͊
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
͸ͪ͵Ͷ͹͸͹ͼͽͳ
̺ͪͶ͵
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
;Γ;ͯ
͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
ͫͶͪͭ͹ͼͽ
;
ͷͰΌ;ͼ͹ͫ͸͹ͷ
͹ͺ΀͹ΌͰΔ;
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
;ͬͪͱͪͬͪΔͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
;͵ͪ
Ͳ;ΒͰ
ͱͰ͸ͪͷͪ
΂ͳΒͳ
ͼͽͪͽ;ͼ
͸Ͱ
ͼͷͪͽͻͪ
͸ͳͷͪͶ͹
ͺ͹ͽ΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳͷ
̓ͪ͹
ΒͰͯͳ͸;

ͷͪ͸;
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͳΔͪͷͪ
tͪͅͶͽͻͰͽͳͻͪΔͰ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͳΔͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ͸ͪ΂Ͱ
ͲͶ͹
͸ͪ
΂ͳͽͪͬ͹ͷ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ
͸;i


͈͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪΔͪ
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂͸͹
͸Ͱͷͪ
΂ͪ͵
͸ͳ
͵ͪͯ
ΒͰ
ͫͶͳ
ͼ͵ͪ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽ
;
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
͈ͻͰͶͪͲͰΕͳ
ͷ͹ͼͽ͹ͷ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
ͅͳΓͪ΁͵Ͱ
̺ͪͶ͵

ͼͪͷ͹
ͼͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͺ;΁ΔͰ
͸ͪ
͍ͻͪΔ;
͍Ͱͻͯͳ͸ͪ͸ͯͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹ͬ͹ͯ
͈ͻͬ͹ͷ
ͼͬͰͽ
ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͻͪͽ;
ͳ
ͺͻͰ͸͹ͼͳ
ͻͰ΂ͳ
ͳͼͺͳͼͪ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͺͶ͹΂ͳ
t)JFS
HBG
(B
CSJMMP
1SJODJQ
POT
MBOE
EF
WSJKIFJE
m
͇ͬͯͰ
ΒͰ
̻ͪͬͻͳͶ͹
͈ͻͳ͸΁ͳͺ
ͺ͹ͯͪ
ͻͳ͹
ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯ;
͸ͪ΃͹Β
ͲͰͷΓͳi



/PWBLPWJǀ-PQVØJOB

 ͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
;
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ 

͑ͽ͹
ͼͰ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͰ

ͽͳ΂Ͱ
͹ͯ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͪ
̺ͪͶ͵
ͺͻͰ

ͼͬͰͭͪ
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒ;
͈Ͷͳͽͬͳ΂͵ͪ

ΒͰͲͰͻͪ
ͳ
̹ͶͰͯͼ͵͹
ΒͰͲͰͻ͹
ͪ
ͼͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͹
Ͷ͹΃͵Ͱ
ͽͪ΂͵Ͱ
ͼ;ͼͻͰͽ
́ͼͽ͹͵ͪ
ͳ
̀ͪͺͪͯͪ

͹Ͷͳ΂Ͱ͸
;
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹Β
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵
ͽ;ͻͳ
ͳ
ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ;

ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
;
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳͷ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
͸͹
΃Δͪͷͪ
̺ͪͶ͵͹ͬ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͳͶ;ͼͽͻ͹ͬͪ͸
ΒͰ

ͼͪ
΂ͰͽͻͯͰͼͰͽͪ͵
΁ͻ͸͹ͫͰͶͳ΀
Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪ
ͿͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͯͬͰ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵Ͱ
͵ͪͻͽͰ
̓͹ͯ
Ϳ͹
ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ
ͼͰ
ΒͰͯ͸ͳͷ
ͯͰͶ͹ͷ
ͻͪͯͳ
͹

ͺͪ͸͹ͻͪͷͼ͵ͳͷ
ͼ͸ͳͷ΁ͳͷͪ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͰ
ͳ

ͭͻͪͯͼ͵Ͱ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ;ͻͰ
ͪ
ͯͰͶ͹ͷ
ͼ;
;
ͺͳ
ͽͪΔ;
ͺ͹ͻͽͻͰͽͳ
ͷ;΃͵ͪͻͪ΁ͪ
ͳ
ͱͰ͸ͪ
;

͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
͸͹΃Δͪͷͪ
̽ͪͽͰ
ͼ;
ͳ
ͯͬͰ
ͻͰͺͻ͹ͯ;͵΁ͳΒͰ
;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͯͰͶͪ

͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ΒͰͯ͸͹
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͿͻͰͼ͵;
ͳͲ
̺ͳͼ͹͵ͳ΀
̽Ͱ΂ͪ͸ͪ


̻͹ͯͳ͸;
ͯͪ͸ͪ
͸ͪ͵͹͸
̺ͪͶ͵͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͳͲ
΃ͽͪͷͺͰ
ͳͲͶͪͲͳ
ͯͰ
Ͷ͹
ͺͳͼͪ͸͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͰ
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵Ͱ
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͆ͪͼͶ͹ͬ

̈́;ͽͪΔͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸͹ͷ
;XFSGUPDIUFO
EPPS
EFO
#BMLBO


ͼ;ͭͰͻͳ΃Ͱ

͵Ͷͪͼͳ΂ͪ͸
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ
ͳ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹͸Ͱ͵ͶͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;ΒͰ
͹ͯ
̺ͪͶ͵͹
ͬ͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͳ
ͺ͹ͯΒͰͯ͸ͪ͵͹
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ
΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͺͰͯͰͼͰͽͪ͵
Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ
ͼͶͳ΂͸͹ͭ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͵͹ͯ
̺ͪͶ͵ͪ

̸;ͽ͹ͻ
ΒͰ
͊
̸
͉Ͱͳͽͼͷͪ
͸͹ͬͳ͸ͪͻ
;
ͼͶ;ͱͫͳ
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵Ͱ
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΁Ͱ

ͯ͹ͫͪͻ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪͶͪ΁
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
̽ͪͶͰ͵͹ͭ
ͳͼͽ͹͵ͪ
ͭͯͰ
ΒͰ

;
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
m
;
ͽͪͯͪ΃Δ͹Β
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵͹Β
͵͹Ͷ͹͸ͳΒͳ
́͸ͯ͹͸ͰͲͳΒͳ

/FEFSMBOET*OEJÌ

ͫͳ͹
ͭͻͪͯ͹͸ͪ΂ͰͶ͸ͳ͵
̹ͪ͸ͯ;͸ͭͪ
̓ͪ͹
ͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͪͽ
ͽ͹ͭ

ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͫ͹ͻͪͬ͵ͪ
ͳͲͪ΃Ͷͪ
ΒͰ

Β͹΃
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͪ
ͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͺ͹ͯ

͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ͹ͷ
̈́;ͽͪΔͪ
́͸ͯ͹͸ͰͲͳΒ͹ͷ
;XFSGUPDIUFO
EPPS
*OEJÌ


͑ͽ͹
ͼͰ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
ͽͳ΂Ͱ
͉Ͱͳͽͼͷͪ
ΒͰ
Β͹΃

͹ͫΒͪͬͳ͹
ΒͰͯ͸;
ͻͪ͸ͳ
Β;
ͬͰͻͲͳΒ;
ͼͬ͹ͭ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͲͳͬ͹ͷ
t͆ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;i
ͪ

ΒͰ
;
͎͹
Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵͹ͷ
ͷͰͼͰ΂͸ͳ͵;
)PMMBOETDI
.BBOECMBE

͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ
΂Ͷͪ͸ͪ͵

͹
̿ͪ͸ͳ
ͅͰͻ͵;ͼ
͸Ͱ͹ͫͳ΂͸͹Β
͎͹Ͷͪ͸Όͪ͸͵ͳ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
͸͹ͬ΂ͪ͸ͳͷ

ͺͻͳͶ͹Ͳͳͷͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
Ͷͳ΂͸ͳͷ
;΂Ͱ΃ΕͰͷ
ͺ͹ͽͺ͹ͷ͹ͭͶͪ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͪ΂͵ͳ
;ͼͽͪ
͸ͪ͵
ͪͅͽͰͻͳΒͪͶ
Ͳͪ
ͽͪΒ
ͼͬ͹Β
΂Ͷͪ͸ͪ͵
͉Ͱͳͽͼͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳ͵;ͺͳ͹
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͼͬ͹ͭ

ͫ͹ͻͪͬ͵ͪ
;
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
ͭͯͰ
ͼͰ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
ͼ;ͼͻͰ͹
ͼͪ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳͷ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳ



*CJE
TUS
G
 ͠ͰͶͳ΁ͪ
͆͹ͬͪ͵͹ͬͳΕ̈́͹ͺ;΃ͳ͸ͪ

΂ͪͻͰͷ
̺Ͷͪͯͳͷͳͻ͹ͷ
ͣ͹ͻ͹ͬͳΕͰͷ
́Ͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ΀
͹ͺͪͼ͵ͳ
ͳ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ

͵͹ΒͰ
ͯͪΒͰ
;
ͼͬ͹ͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ;
Βͪͼ͸͹
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͳ
ͯ͹
ͳͲͻͪͱͪΒͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͉Ͱͳͽͼͷͪ

ͫͳ͹
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ
ͼͪ
ͣ͹ͻ͹ͬͳΕͰͬͳͷ
ͯͰͶ͹ͷ
͇ͬͪΒ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͪ
;ΒͰͯ͸͹
ͳ
ͼͽ;ͯͳΒͪ
;
ͷͪͶ͹ͷ
ͼͪ
͹ͼͪͷ
ͺ͹
ͭͶͪͬΓͪ
͸ͪ

ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪͺ͹΂ͳΔͰ
ͻͰ΂͸͹ͷ
ͯͰ͹͸ͳ΁͹ͷ
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͯ͹

͈ͻͪ΀͹ͬͪ
͵͹Β;
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
͸ͪͲͳͬͪ
tͫ͹ͭ͹ͬͼ͵͹ͷi
͇ͯͪͽͶͰ
ͼͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͪ

͊͹ͿͳΒ;
͸ͪͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΁͹ͷ
͢;
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͪͶ;ͫͳ

ͫͻ͹ͯͪ
̸ͶͰ͵ͼͪ͸ͯͪͻ
;
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬ;
ͷͶͪͯͳ΀
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ΀
͹Ϳͳ΁ͳͻͪ
ͺͻͳͼͰͽͳ

ͼͬ͹ͭ
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸͹ͭ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
;Ͳ
Ͳͬ;͵Ͱ
ͺͰͼͪͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͭͪ
ͽͪͯͪ
͹ͺ΂ͳ͸ͳ
ͶͰ
t͠Ͱͯͪ͸
ͷͶͪΌͪ͸ͳ
ͼͳ͸
ͪͅͻͼͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ͼͰ͹

ΒͰ
Ͳͪ
͸ͪ΃
ͼͽ͹
ͳ
ͳͼͺͻͳ΂ͪ͹
͸ͪͷ
ͯͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳ
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͬͳ
ͪ
͵ͪͺͰͶͪ
ͺͰͬͪΒ;

ͺͰͼͷͰ
͹
ͫ͹ͻͫͳ
ͳ
Γ;ͫͪͬͳ
͈͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
ͼͰ
͹ͭͶͪ΃ͪͬͪ͹
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͷͶͪͯͳΕ

ͺͻͰͶͰͺ͹ͭ
ͭͶͪͼͪ
;Ͳ
ͺͻͪͽΔ;
ͭͳͽͪͻͰ
͈ͻͰͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒͰͷ͹
ͺͰͼͷ;
s̓͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͽͰ

ͬ͹Ͷͳͷ
͸Ͱ
ͬ͹Ͷͳ
ͽͰ
͸ͳ͵͹A
͵͹Β;
ͼͷ͹
ͺͻͬͳ
ͺ;ͽ
΂;Ͷͳ
ͺͻ͹΃ͶͰ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
ͳ
͌ͱͳ΁;
ͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ
;ͽͳͼͪ͵
͸ͪ
͸ͪͼ
͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͳ
̽ͪ
ͼ;
ͷͰ͸ͳ

͹΂ͳ
ͽͬ͹ΒͰ
͈͹ΌͰͷ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͶ͹
̽ͻ;ͭͪͻ
ͷͳ
ͼͰ
ͱͰ͸ͳ
͋Ͱ΃͵͹
ΒͰ
ͽͪΒ͸͹
Γ;
ͫͳͽͳ
ͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭͰ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
͊ͬͰ
ͼ;
ͽ͹
ͻ͹ͷͪ͸ͽͳ΂͸Ͱ
ͺͰͼͷͰ
ͽͳͺͳ΂͸͹
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ

͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͪ
͸ͪͼͽͪͶͰ
;
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳͷͪ
ͺ͹ͽͶͪ΂Ͱ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͫ;͸Ͱ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼͰ

͹ͭͶͰͯͪ
͵ͻͬͪͬͪ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
ͳ
ͱͰͼͽ͹͵ͪ
ͬ͹Γͪ
Ͳͪ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ͹ͷi



͋ͳͺͳ΂͸͹
Ͳͪ
͉Ͱͳͽͼͷ;
ΒͰ
ͷͰ΃ͪͬͳ͸ͪ
Ͷͳ΂͸͹ͭ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪΒͪ
ͳ
ͷ͸͹
΃ͽͬͪ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͼͽͻ;΂͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͇ͼͳͷ
΃ͶͪͭͰͻͳͷͪ
͹͸
ͼͰ
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ

ͺ͹ͭͶͪͬΓ;
ͫͪͬͳ
ͳ
ͼͽͪΔͰͷ
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͰ΂͸͹ͭ
ͫͻ͹ͯͪͻͼͽͬͪ
ͫͻ͹ΒͰͷ

ͳ
ͽ͹͸ͪͱ͹ͷ
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͶ͹ͬͳͶͪ
͸ͪ
̽;͸ͪͬ;
ͳ
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸ͳͷ
ͯͰͶͳͷͪ

ͳ͸ͼͺͳͻͳͼͪ͸ͳͷ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ͹ͷ
͵ͻͪΒͪ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͺͻ͹ͶͪͲͳ
͌ͭ͹ΌͪΒ
ͬ͹ͱΔͰ
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΁͹ͷ
͹ͯ
͈ͻͪ΀͹ͬͪ
ͯ͹
͆ͳ΃ͪ
ͺ͹ͯͼͰΕͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹
ͻͪ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵Ͱ
;
́͸ͯ͹͸ͰͲͳΒͳ
ͼ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵ͪ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͊Ͷͳ΂͸͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͼͪ
΀͹ͽͰͶ
ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͪΒͰͷ
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͪ
͸ͳͬ͹;
͹΂Ͱ͵ͳͬͪΔͪ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹ͭ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
͉Ͱͳͽͼͷͪ
͸ͪ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
΃ͪͻͷͪ͸ͽͪ͸
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͼͽͬͪΓͪ
ͼͬ͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͷͰͯͫͰ
͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͶͪͲͰΕͳ
ͺͻͳ
ͽ͹ͷ
͸ͳ͵ͪͯ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁;
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹͸ͪͷͰͻ͸͹
ͼͽͳ

̽ͪ
ͼ;
;
ͽ͹
ͯ͹ͫͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪͶͳ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͎͹Ͷͪ͸
ͯͳΒͰ
ͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂ͳ
͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬ͹
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵ͳ΀
ͻͰ΂͸ͳ΀



3FJUTNB



̸;ͽ͹ͻ
ͳͼͺͻͪͬ͸͹
ͯͪΒͰ
ͺͻͰͬ͹ͯͰ
͹ͬͳ΀
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬͪ
͸ͪ
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵ͳ


̀ͪ
̸ͯ;
̓ͪͶͰ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸͹
ͳ͸ͼͺͳͻͳͼͪͶͪ
ͯͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͳͼ΁ͪ
͎Ͱͻͷͪ͸ͪ

̹ͪ͸ͭͪ
ͯͪ
͸ͪͺͳ΃Ͱ
ͼͬ͹Β
ͻ͹ͷͪ͸
t̸ͺͪͽͻͳͯͳi
 ͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
;
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ 

ͫͻ͹ͯ͹ͬͪ
͸ͪ
̽;͸ͪͬ;
ͬͰΕ
ͳ
ͻͰ͵ͶͪͷͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
͉Ͱͳͽͼͷͪ
Ͳͪͽͳ΂Ͱ
;
͆ͳ΃;
͌

ͺͳͽͪΔ;
ͼ;
ͻͰ͵ͶͪͷͰ
Ͳͪ
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͳΒͪͶͳ΁Ͱ
ͷͪͻ͵Ͱ
̺ͳͻ
͠͹΃
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
͹ͷͳΓͰ͸ͳ΀
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ͹ͬͳ΀
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ΒͰ

͈ͻͬͳ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͳ
ͻͪͽ
͊͵͹ͻ͹
ͯͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ
ͷͰͼͽͪ
Ͳͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
͹͸
͸Ͱ
ͬͰͲ;ΒͰ
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ

Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸Ͱ
ͻͪͽ͸Ͱ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͰ
͈ͻͳ
ͽ͹ͷ
͹͸
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͳ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻ; 
΂Ͱͼͽ͹

ͳ
ͫͰͶͰͽͻͳͼͽͳ͵;
͵͹Βͪ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁;
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͫͳͽͳ
͹ͯ
ͺ͹ͷ͹Εͳ
Ͳͪ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸ͳΒͰ

ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͼͪΔͰ
̽ͻ;ͭ͹
ͬͻͶ͹
͹ͺ΃ͳͻ͸͹
ͺ͹ͭͶͪͬΓͰ
ͺͻͪͬͪ
ΒͰ
Ͱ͸΁ͳ͵Ͷ͹ͺͰͯͳΒͼ͵ͪ
ͼͽ;
ͯͳΒͪ
͹
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β;
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
̽ͪ
ΒͰ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ
ͳ
ͼͪ
ͯ͹ͷͪΕ͹ͷ

ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻ͹ͷ
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂ͳ
ͳ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ
ͼͪ
ͻͪͯ͹ͬͳͷͪ
̽ͳͷͳ
ͽͻͳΒͪ
͈Ͱͽͻ͹ͬͳΕͪ
͉ͪͯ͹ͼͶͪͬͪ
̽ͳͷ΂͹ͬͪ
ͳ
̽ͻͪͭ͹ͷͳͻͪ
̸ͻ͸ͪ;ͽ͹ͬͳΕͪ

͆ͪΒͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͭͪ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
Ͳͪ͹͵;ͺΓͪΒ;
ͷͪͶͬͰͻͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͬͰͲ;Β;
Ͳͪ
ͳͷͰ

ͫͪͻ͹͸ͪ
ͅ͹ͻͳ΁ͪ
Ϳ͹͸
͎ͳͻ΃ͪ

͈ͻͳͫͶͳͱͪͬͪΒ;Εͳ
ͼͰ
ͭͻ΂͵͹ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵͹Β
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͉Ͱͳͽͼͷͪ
͹ͬ͹

ͺ͹ͭͶͪͬΓͰ
Ͳͪͬͻ΃ͪͬͪ
ΒͰͯ͸ͳͷ
΁ͳͽͪͽ͹ͷ
̾ͯͳͽ
̽;ͻ΀ͪͷ
͵͹Βͳͷ
͸ͪΒͪͬΓ;ΒͰ

Β;ͱ͸͹ͼͻͺͼ͵;
ͽΒ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵;
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͪͽͳ͵;
ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͯͪΓͰ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ

ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶͪ͸
͵ͪͯͪ
ͼ;
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵Ͱ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
;
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
t'PML
JO
UIF
#BMLBOT
MJWF
JO
UIFJS
QBTU
UP
BO
FYUFOU
XIJDI
JT
IBSE

GPS
VT
JO
UIF
8FTU
UP
SFBMJ[Fi


͆ͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ͹ͬ͹
ͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪΔͰ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͪ
;
͸ͪΒΒ;ͱ͸ͳΒͰͷ
ͯͰͶ;
͠;ͭ͹
ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
;ͽͳ΁ͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ͻ͹ͷͪ͸
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͲͰͷΓͪ͵ͪ
̸
̽Ͱ͸
̽͹Ͷͪͻͯͪ

͇ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽ
Ͱ͵ͼͺͻͰͼ
;
͵͹ΒͰͷ
ͼͰ
͹ͬͪΒ
ͼ͹Ͷͳͯͪͻͳ΃Ͱ
ͼͪ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͼͽͪ
ͬ͹ͷ
͇ͽ;ͯ
͸Ͱ
΂;ͯͳ
ͯͪ
͉Ͱͳͽͼͷͪ
͸Ͱ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳ
͸ͪͲͳͬ
͠;ͱ͸ͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
͢Ͱ
ͭ͹ͬͪ
Ϳͪͼ΁ͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͼͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͺ͹
ͼͬͰͷ;
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͷ
ͷ͹ͱͰ

ͷͰͻͳͽͳ
ͼͪ
̺ͪͶ͵͹ͬ͹ͷ
͌
;ͬ͹ͯ͸͹ͷ
ͺͪͼ;ͼ;
͹͸
ͯͪΒͰ
͵ͻͪͽͪ͵
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ

ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ
ͳͲ
͵͹ΒͰͭ
ͼͰ
ͬͳͯͳ
͵͹͸ͼ;Ͷͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͣ͹ͻ͹ͬͳΕͰͬ͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
t͌ΕͳΕ;
ͯ;ͫΓͰ
;
͹ͬͰ
ͯͰͽͪΓͰ
ΒͰͻ
ͼͰ
ͳ͸ͪ΂Ͱ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͪ
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸͹ͼͽ

ͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͽͰͱΔͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
͹͸ͪ
͸Ͱͭ;ΒͰ
ͽͰ΃͵͹
ͯͪΒ;
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͽͳ<>
͆ͪ
ͭ͹
ͻͰͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽ͹Β
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹Β
͹͵;ͺͪ΁ͳΒͳ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ
͹ͯ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
΁ͪͻͪ

̽;΃ͪ͸ͪ
ͽͰͷͰΓͰ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͽͰ͸ͲͳΒͰ
͊ͻͫͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͬ;
ͲͰͷΓ;
͵͹Β;
ͼ;

̓;
ͷͪ͸͹ͬͼ͵͹ͷ
ͫͳͽ͵͹ͷ
;
ͺͻͬ͹ͷ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͻͪͽ;
ͺͻͰ͹ͽͰͶͳ
͹ͯ
͋;ͻͪ͵ͪi


Ϳ


͌
ͼͬ͹ͷ
ͯͪΓͰͷ
ͳͲͶͪͭͪΔ;
͉Ͱͳͽͼͷͪ
ͺ͹ͯΒͰͯ͸ͪ͵͹
͵ͻͳͽͳ͵;ΒͰ
ͫ;ͭͪͻ
ͼ͵Ͱ
ͪͼͺͳͻͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͳͶ;ͼͽͻͪ΁ͳΒ;
Βͪ͵Ͱ
ͬͰͲͰ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸Ͱ
ͽͻͪ
ͯͳ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵Ͱ
΁ͳͽͳͻͪ
ͼͽͻ͹Ϳ;
ͳͲ
ͺͰͼͷͰ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸Ͱ
ͬ͹Βͬ͹ͯͳ
͠͹ͬͪ
͸;
̽͹ͬͰͲͰ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ



͋ͪ͵͹
Ͳͪ
ͯͰͽͪΓͰ
;
ͬͰͲͳ
ͼͪ
ͼ;ΌͰΔͰͷ
̸ͺͳͼ;
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͯͰͶ͹
̾ͯͳͽ
̽;ͻ΀ͪͷ
ѮF
4FSBKFWP
$SJNF


 ͠ͰͶͳ΁ͪ
͆͹ͬͪ͵͹ͬͳΕ̈́͹ͺ;΃ͳ͸ͪ

t̓ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼͷ͹
͸ͪͺͳͼͪͶͳ
Ͳͪͼͪͯ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͽ͵ͪ
ͳͲͬ͹ΒͰͬͪ͸ͪ
̸Ͷͳ
͹͸͹ͬͻͰ
ͷͰ͸ͳ
ͯ;΀
͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͳ΃΂ͰͲ͸;ͽͳ
Ͳͪ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͪ
͇΂ͳͭͶͰͯ͸͹
ͯͪ

ΒͰ
ͺͪ΁ͳͿͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͷ;͵͹ͽͻͺ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͯͪ
ΕͰ
ͺͳͽͪΔͰ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͷͪΔͳ͸ͪ
;

͹ͬͳͷ
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͳͷͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
͸ͪ͸Ͱͽͳ
ͬͶͪͯͳ
Β͹΃
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͭͶͪͬ͹ͫ͹ΓͰ
ͳ
ͯͪ

ΕͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͽͳ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͪͭͳͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
͸Ͱͷͳͻͪi


͇ͯ
͹͸ͳ΀
ͼͳͽ͸ͳ΀
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹
ΒͰ
ͼͪ
Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ
͸ͺͻ
͵ͪ͵ͪͬ
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
ͫͳ͹ͼ͵͹ͺͼ͵ͳ
ͻͰͺͰͻͽ͹ͪͻ
;
̹ͳͽ͹Γ;

͵ͪͼͰ

ͼ;
ͺ;͸ͳͶͳ
ͅ͹ͻͳͼ
͑ͰͬͪͶͳΒͰ
ͳ
̓ͶͰͻ͵
̻ͰΒͫͶ
̸
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳ
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͳ
ͼ;
;ͺͻ
͵͹ͼ
;ͻͫͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸͹ͷ
ͪͷͫͳΒͰ͸ͽ;
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
ͫͳͶͳ
͹ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͪͶ͸ͳ

t͌ͺͻ͵͹ͼ
ͻͪ͸͹ͷ
Β;ͽͻ;
ͽͰͻͪͼͪ
ͭͯͰ
ͯ͹ͻ;΂͵;ΒͰͷ͹
ͺ;͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͪ

͵͹Βͳ
ͼͻ΂;
΁ͻ͸;
͵ͪͿ;
ͳ
ͬͳ΃ͳ΀
ͳ
͸ͳͱͳ΀
͹Ϳͳ΁ͳͻͪ
͊ͬͳ
͹͸ͳ
ͼ;
͹ͼͽͪ
ͬͳͶͳ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͱͰ͸Ͱ
͵͹ͯ
͵;ΕͰ
ΒͰͻ
ͳͷ
ͬͪΓͯͪ
ͺ͹
Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͷͳ΃ΓͰΔ;
͸ͳΒͰ

ͷͰͼͽ͹
;
͵ͪͿͪ͸ͳ
ͫͪͻͰͷ
͸Ͱ
;
Β;ͽͪͻΔͰ
ͼͪͽͰi


͇ͯ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͪͽͻͪ͵΁ͳΒͪ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ
͉Ͱͳͽͼͷͪ
͸ͪͬ͹
ͯͳ
͇΀ͻͳͯͼ͵͹
ΒͰͲͰͻ͹
ͳ
ͬ͹ͱΔ;
Εͳͻ͹ͷ
Ͳͬͪ͸ͳͷ
͈ͷͺ;ͻ΂Ͱ
͹ͯ
͇΀ͻͳͯͪ
ͯ͹

͊͵͹ͺΓͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͺͻͪͬ;
ͪͬͪ͸ͽ;ͻ;
̽ͪ
ͫͳ
ͳͶ;ͼͽͻ͹ͬͪ͹
;Ͳͫ;
ͯΓͳͬ͹ͼͽ
͹ͬͰ
ͽͻͪͼͰ
͹ͯ

ͼͪͽͳ
ͬ͹ͱΔͰ
Ͳͪ

͵ͷ

ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
΁ͳͽͳͻͪ
̾͸ͭͶͰ
Ͳͪ
̽ͰΒͬͳͯͪ
͍;ͽͷͰ͸ͪ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ
#BMLBO
)PMJEBZ



t5IFSF
JT
B
TUPSZ
PG
B
DPNNFSDJBM
USBWFMMFS
XIP
CPVHIU
B
TFDPOE
DMBTT
UJDLFU
BOE
DPNQMBJOFE
UP
UIF
DPOEVDUPS
XIFO
IF
GPVOE
IJNTFMG

QBDLFE
JO
XJUI
B
DSPXE
PG
QFBTBOUT
BOE
MJWF
HPBUT
)F
EJE
OPU
TFF
XIBU

BEWBUBHF
IF
HPU
GPS
IJT
FYUSB
PVUMBZ
)F
XBT
UPME
UIBU
UIJSEDMBTTUJDLFU
IPMEFST
XFSF
PCMJHFE
UP
HFU
PVU
BOE
IFMQ
XIFOFWFS
UIF
MPDPNPUJWF
SBO

PGG
UIF
SBJMT
CVU
TFDPOEDMBTT
QBTTFOHFST
XFSF
FOUJUMFE
UP
TJU
XIFSF
UIFZ

XFSFi


̺Ͱͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸͹
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͯ
;ͽͳ΁ͪΒͰͷ
͹ͬͰ
ͪ͸Ͱͭͯ͹ͽͰ
͉Ͱͳͽͼͷͪ
͹ͯͶ;΂ͳ͹
Ͳͪ

͸ͪͼͽͪͬͪ͵
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͫ;ͼ͹ͷ
ͯ͹
͊͵͹ͺΓͪ
͇
ͼͽͪΔ;
ͷ͹ͽ͹ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͼͪ͹
ͫͻͪΕͪΒͪ
;
ͽ͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂Ͱ
΂Ͱͼͽͳ
ͼ;ͯͪͻͳ
ͼͪ
ͼͽ͹͵͹ͷ
͵͹Βͪ

ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯ͸ͪ
΃Ͱͽͪ
͵͹Ͷ͹ͬ͹Ͳ͹ͷ
̻Ͷͪͬ͸ͪ
͹ͯͶͳ͵ͪ
΀͹ͽͰͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͪ͵
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸͹
Ͷ͹
΃ͪ
΀ͳͭͳΒͰ͸ͪ
;ͼͶͰͯ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͫ;ͬͰ
ͳ
͹ͼͽͪͶͪ
ͭͪͷͪͯ
ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯ͸͹
͵ͻͰΕ;
ͼ͹ͫͪ
ͷͪ
̈́ͪ͵͹͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
͵͹ͷͰ͸ͽͪͻͳͷͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
͹ͯͶ;΂;ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͷ;
ͽͪ͵ͬͳ
ͯͰͽͪΓͳ
͸Ͱ

ͷ͹ͭ;
ͺ͹͵ͬͪͻͳͽͳ
;ͱͳͬͪΔͰ
;
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͪͷͪ
͊ͽͳͭͪͬ΃ͳ
;
͊͵͹ͺΓͰ
͉Ͱͳͽͼͷͪ
ͼͰ
ͯͪΒͰ
;
͹ͫͳͶͪͲͪ͵
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
Ͳ͸ͪ
ͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
͹
΁ͻ͵ͬͳ
͊ͬͰͽ͹ͭ
ͼͺͪͼͪ
ͫͰͶͰͱͳ
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͰ

t͈͹ͼͰΕ;ΒͰͷ͹
͠ͰͬͻͰΒͼ͵;
΂Ͱͽͬͻͽ
ͳ͹
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͿͳͶͳͭͻͪ͸ΘͳΒ;
͵͹Βͳ

͸ͪͷ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͶͰͺͰ
ͻ;͵͹ͽͬ͹ͻͳ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
̓;ͻ΃;ͷͶͳ
΀ͪ͸
ͼͽͪͻͳ
͵ͪ
ͻͪͬͪ͸ͼͰͻͪΒ
ΘͪͷͳΒ;
ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͳͬ͸;
΁ͻ͵ͬ;
͊ͬͰͽ͹ͭ
ͼͺͪͼͪ
ͼͪ
ͬͰͶͳ΂ͪ͸ͼͽͬͰ
͸ͳͷ
ͼͽ͹ͭ͹ͯͳ΃Δͳͷ
ͳ͵͹͸͹ͼͽͪͼ͹ͷ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͳͲͻͰͲͫͪͻͳͶͳ
͍ͳͶͳͺ͹ͬͳΕ

ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳ
ͼͳ͸͹ͬͳ
͇ͬͪΒ
ͯ;ͫ͹ͻͰͲ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
͸ͪΒͶͰͺ΃Ͱ
΃ͽ͹
ͼͪͷ
ͳ͵ͪͯ

 ͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
;
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ 

ͬͳͯͰ͹
ͺ͹
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͳ
ͼͰ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷ
ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͳ͹
ͻͪͯ;
ͬͳͻ΁ͫ;ͻ΃͵͹ͭ
͋ͳͶͷͪ͸ͪ

͉ͳͷͰ͸΃͸ͪΒͯͰͻͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͻͰ΁ͳͷ͹
ͬͳͯͰͽͳ
;
͉͹ͽͰ͸ͫ;ͻͭ;
;
̹ͪͬͪͻ
ͼ͵͹Β
͋ͳͺͳ΂͸͹
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
;
͹ͬ͹Β
΁ͻ͵ͬͳ
Ϳͳͭ;ͻͰ
͊ͪͶ͹ͷͰ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀

ͯͪͽͰ
;
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
͸͹΃Δͪͷͪi


͆ͪͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;Εͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͺ͹
̓͹ͼ͹ͬ;
͉Ͱͳͽͼͷͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰΕ;ΒͰ
ͳ
̻ͻͪ΂ͪ
͸ͳ΁;
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
̻ͪͲͳͷͰͼͽͪ͸
ͳ
̀ͬͰ΂ͪ͸
ͯͪΒ;Εͳ
ͺͻͳ
ͽ͹ͷ
͸ͳͲ
ͺͻ͹ͬͰͻͰ͸ͳ΀

ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͌
͈ͻͳ΃ͽͳ͸ͳ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒͰ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹ͭ

ͽͻͭ͹ͬͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
͹΂ͳͭͶͰͯ͸͹
͸Ͱ
ͯͰͶͳ
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵͹
͹ͯ;΃ͰͬΓͰ
ΔͰ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒ͹ͷ
t͈͹
ΔͰͷ;
ͼ;
ͼͪ͸ͳͽͪͻͳΒͰ
ͽͪͷ͹
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͷͪΔ͵ͪͬͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ

΂ͳͼͽ͹ΕͰ
ͺ͹
΀͹ͽͰͶͳͷͪ
͑ͽ͹
ͷͳ
͸Ͱ
͹ͼͺ͹ͻͪͬͪͷ͹i


ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
Ͳͪ
ͬͰΕͳ͸;
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵ͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
ͽͪ
Ͳͪ͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͼͽ
ͳ
ͪ;ͽͰ͸
ͽͳ΂͸͹ͼͽ
m
͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
͹͸ͳ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪͬͪΒ;
m
͸Ͱ
;ͷͪΔ;Β;
΂ͪͻ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ

ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪΒͪ
̀ͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ
ΒͰ
͹ͺͳͼ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͯͪͬͪ΂ͳ΁Ͱ
;
͈ͰΕͳ
΂ͳΒͳ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯ
͹ͯ;
ͯͪͻͪ
͹ͯ
͹΂Ͱ͵ͳͬͪ͸Ͱ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͪͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͼ͵ͻ͹ͷ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͹
΂ͰͱΔͳ

Ͳͪ
ͲͪͺͪͯΔͪ΂͵ͳͷ
;Ͳ͹ͻͳͷͪ
t͠Ͱͯ͸ͪ
͸ͪͷ͹Ͷ͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
ͭ͹ͼͺ͹Όͳ΁ͪ
ͯͻͰ΂ͪͬ͹
΁ͻͬͰ͸ͳ΀
;ͼͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
͹΂;ͺͪ
͸ͳ΀
͹ͫͻͬͪ
;ͬͰͻͪͬͪ
͸ͪͼ
ͯͪ
;ͼͺ;ͽ
͸ͳ΃ͽͪ
͸ͰΕͰͷ͹
͸ͪΕͳ
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͶ͹
m
΃ͽ͹
ΕͰ

ͼͰ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲͪͽͳ
͵ͪ͹
͸Ͱͳͼͽͳ͸ͪ
m
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͯͪΒͰ
͸ͪͷ
Ͳͪ
;ͱͳ͸;
ͽͬͻͯ͹

͵;ͬͪ͸ͪ
ΒͪΒͪ
ͳ
ͲͰͷͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͼͪ
ͫ͹ͱͪ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸͹ͷ
͵͹ͫͪͼͳ΁͹ͷi


͊ͶͰͯͰΕͳ
ͯͰ͹
ͰͽͪͺͰ
ͺ͹͵ͻͳͬͪ
͏ͻ͸;
̻͹ͻ;
ͳ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ
͹΂Ͱ
͵ͳͬͪͽͳ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰ
͹ͬͰ
ͯͰ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͫͰͲ
ͻͰ΂ͳ

͌
̸͸ͯͻͳΒͰͬͳ΁ͳ
ͭͪ
ͺͪ͵
ͺͻͱͰ͸ͪ
ͻͳͫͪ
;
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶ͸͹Β
͵ͪͿͪ͸ͳ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͯͪ

͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳ
ͼ;ͺͰͻͶͪͽͳͬͰ
t͈ͻͳ΀ͬͪͽͪͷ͹
ͺ͹͸;ͯ;
͸ͪͻ;΂;ΒͰͷ͹
ͺͻͱͰ͸;
ͻͳͫ;
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͯ͹
ͫͻ͹
ͼͺͻͰͷΓͰ͸ͪ
ͯͪ
͸ͪͻ;΂;ΒͰͷ͹
Β͹΃
ΒͰͯ͸;
ͺ͹ͻ΁ͳΒ;
͆Ͱ
ͼͰΕͪͷ
ͼͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͪͷ

ͳ͵ͪͯ
ΒͰ͹
;͵;ͼ͸ͳΒ;
ͺͻͱͰ͸;
ͻͳͫ;i


̓ͪ͹
ͺͻͰͬ͹ͯͳͶͪ΁
ͳͷ
;
̸͸ͯͻͳΒͰͬͳ΁ͳ
ͼͶ;ͱͳ
ͷͰͼ͸ͳ
ͶͰ͵ͪͻ
t͍ͻͪ͸
΁;ͼ͵ͳ
Όͪ͵
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
͸ͪ͵͹͸
;ͫͳͼͽͬͪ
͵ͻͪΓͪ
̸ͶͰ͵ͼͪ͸ͯͻͪ
ͫͳ͹
ͺͻͳͷ͹ͻͪ͸

͹ͯ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͬͶͪͼͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸͹
ͼͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͳͷͪ

͸ͪͺ;ͼͽͳ
͍ͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵;i


̸;ͽ͹ͻ
;
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͰͷ
ͺͪͼ;ͼ;
Βͪͼ͸͹
ͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͯ͹
Ͳ͸ͪΔͪ
ͯͪ
͹ͼ;Ό;ΒͰ

ͽͪ͵ͪͬ
ͯͳͼ͵ͻͳͷͳ͸ͪͽ͹ͻͼ͵ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͽ;ͺͪ͵
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͷͪͽͻͪ
ͽͳͺͳ΂͸ͳͷ
Ͳͪ
͹͸ͯͪ
΃ΔͰ
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵Ͱ
ͬͶͪͼͽͳ
t͈ͻͳ΂ͪͷ͹
͹
ͼͽ͹ͽͳ͸;
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ΀
ͼͽͬͪͻͳ
͌
͹ͯͶͪͼ͵;
͸ͪͷ
ͯ͹͵
ͽ͹ͻ
Ͳͪ
;ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸;
ͺ͹͵ͶͪΔͪ
ͯͻͬͰ͸;
ͽͪͫͪ͵Ͱͻ;
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶ͸ͳ
ͼ;ͬͰ͸ͳͻ
͊
ΒͰͯ
͸Ͱ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ΒͰ
;ͻͰͲͪ͸
Ͷͳ͵
͇ͫͳͶͳΕͪ
;ͫͳ΁Ͱ
ͼ;Ͷͽͪ͸ͪ
ͅ;ͻͪͽͪ
*
ͼ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ

ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͻͽͻͰͽ
͈ͻͳ͸΁ͳͺͪ
;ͫͳ΁Ͱ
͸ͪͯͬ͹Βͬ͹ͯͰ
͍ͻͪ͸΁ͪ
͍Ͱͻͯͳ͸ͪ͸
 ͠ͰͶͳ΁ͪ
͆͹ͬͪ͵͹ͬͳΕ̈́͹ͺ;΃ͳ͸ͪ

ͯͪ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
ͱͰ͸Ͱ
́ͲͷͰΌ;
ͽͪ
ͯͬͪ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͪ
Β;͸ͪ͵ͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͰ
ͼͰ
;͵ͻ΃ͽͰ͸ͪ

͵ͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͻͰͬ͹ͶͬͰͻi


̸;ͽ͹ͻ͹ͬ
ͳͲͫ͹ͻ
ͻͰ΂ͳ
͹ͯͪΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͫͶͪͭ͹ͷ
ͳͻ͹͸ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͷͪͽͻͪ
ͼͬͰͽ

;
͵͹ΒͰͷ
ͼͰ
͹ͬͪ͵ͬͪ
ͬͻͼͽͪ
Β;͸ͪ΃ͽͬͪ
ͬͰͶͳ΂ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳͲͻͪͲ
ͳͼ͵ͻͰ͸͹ͭ
ͯ͹ͷ͹
Γ;ͫΓͪ

͈͹ͼͶͰͯΔͪ
ͯͰ͹͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
͉Ͱͳͽͼͷ;
͹ͯ
̽;ͫͻ͹ͬ͸ͳ
͵ͪ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
͊ͺͶͳͽͪ
ͯ͹
̀ͪͭͻͰͫͪ
̀ͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;
͹ͯ
̺ͪͶ͵ͪ
͹͸
̽;ͫͻ͹ͬ͸ͳ͵

ͼͷͪͽͻͪ
ͬͻ΀;͸΁Ͱͷ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪΒͪ
t͇ͯ
ͼͬͳ΀
ͷͰͼͽͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒͰͷ
m
ͪ
Δͳ΀
ͳͷͪ
ͺ͹ͯ͹ͼͽͪ
m
ͷͳͼͶͳͷ

ͯͪ
ΒͰ
̽;ͫͻ͹ͬ͸ͳ͵
͸ͪΒͯͳͬ͸ͳΒͰ
̈́Ͱͺ
ͺͻͳΒͪͽͪ͸
ͳ
ͷͳͻͪ͸
͌͸;ͽͪͻ
Ͳͳͯͳ
͸ͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͷ͹ͫͳͶͪ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͯͪ
ͷ͹ͱͰ΃
͸ͪ
ͷͳͻ;
ͯͪ
΃Ͱͽͪ΃
͆Ͱ
ͷͪ
͸ͪͺͪͯ͸͹ͭ
Ͷ;͵ͼ;Ͳͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ
ͭͪͶͪͷͰ
ͳͷͪ
ͯ͹ͫͻͰ
ͷ;Ͳͳ͵Ͱ
ͼͽͪͻ
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͯ͹
ͼͽ͹Βͪ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸
ͼͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͶͰͺͳͷ
ͳͲͶͰͽͳͷͪ
;
͹͵͹Ͷͳ͸;i



͌
̽;ͫͻ͹ͬ͸ͳ͵;
ΒͰ
͉Ͱͳͽͼͷͪ
;
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵͹ͷ
ͪͻ΀ͳͬ;
ͺ͹͵;΃ͪ͹
ͯͪ

ͺͻ͹͸ͪΌͰ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
ͼ;ͯͫͳ͸ͳ
̿ͪ͸Ͱ
ͅͰͻ͵;ͼ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
;
ͽ͹ͷ
ͭͻͪͯ;

ͼͻͰͽͪͶͪ
ͼͪ
͡;ͫͳͫͻͪͽͳΕͰͷ
ͺͻͰͯͬ͹ͯ͸ͳ͵͹ͷ
΀Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͪ΂͵ͳ΀
;ͼͽͪ͸ͳ͵ͪ

ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
;
ͪͻ΀ͳͬ;
ͽ͹
ͻͪͲͯ͹ͫΓͰ
Β͹΃
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͼͻͰΌͰ͸͹
ͳ
ͯ͹ͼͽ;ͺ͸͹

Βͪͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
ͯ͹
ͼͬ͹Βͳ΀
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͯ͹΃ͪ͹
Ͳͪ΀ͬͪΓ;Β;Εͳ
͵͹͸
ͽͪ͵ͽͳͷͪ
ͼͪ
̺Ͷͪͯͳͷͳͻ͹ͷ
ͣ͹ͻ͹ͬͳΕͰͷ
͇ͯ
ΔͰͭͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͪͲ͸ͪ͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
̿ͪ͸ͪ

ͅͰͻ͵;ͼ
͸ͪ͵͹͸
ͪ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
Ͳͪͻ͹ͫΓͰ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
ͯ͹΂Ͱ͵ͪ͸ͪ

;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪ
ͯ;
͵ͪ͹
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͪ
Β;͸ͪ͵ͳΔͪ
ͳͲ
ͷͳͶ͹΃ͽͰ
͸ͪͲͬͪ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
͚;ͻͰ
ͪ͠͵΃ͳΕͪ

ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͷ
͠͹ͬͪ͸͵͹ͷ
͇ͻͶͰͪ͸͵͹ͷ
͇ͯ
̽;ͫͻ͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͯ͹
͊ͺͶͳͽͪ
͉Ͱͳͽͼͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ΃ͪ͹
ͫͻ͹ͯ͹ͷ
t̓ͻͪΓ

̸ͶͰ͵ͼͪ͸ͯͪͻ
*i
̽;ͫͻ͹ͬͪ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͪͻ͹ͫͻ͹ͯͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͶ͹ͬͳͯͫͰ
͇ͺ΂ͳΔͰ͸
ͶͰͺ͹
ͽ͹ͷ
͹ͼͽͻͬÄ
ͳ
͹ͫͪͶͰ
͵ͻͪΒ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ͺͶ͹ͬͰ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
;ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͹ͼͰΕͪ

ͳͻͳͽͪ΁ͳΒ;
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬͪ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͭͻ;ͺͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
m
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳ΀
ͲͰͷΓͪ͵ͪ

̀ͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͳ
;
͸ͪ΃Ͱ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͎͹Ͷͪ͸Όͪ͸ͳͷͪ
;
ͳ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͼͽͬ;
͸ͪΒ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͼͷͰͽͪΒ;
ͼ͹ͺͼͽͬͰ͸ͳ
ͲͰͷΓͪ΁ͳ
Ͳͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͷͪͽͻͪΒ;
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͫ;΂͸ͳ
ͳ
͸Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ
t͠Ͱͯͳ͸;
ͯͳͼ͹͸ͪ͸ͽ͸͹ͼͽ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬ͹
ͭͻ;ͺͰ
͹ͯ
΂Ͱͽͬ͹
ͻ͹
͎͹Ͷͪ͸Όͪ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ͭ͹ͼͺ͹ͯͪ
;
͵͹΃;Γͪͷͪ
ͯ͹ͶͪͲF
͸ͪ
ͬͰ΂Ͱͻ;
ͪ
ΒͰͯ
͸ͪ
͹ͯ
ͯͪͷͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
;
ͼͽͪΔ;
ͯͪ
ͼͪ͵ͻͳΒͰ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͪͷͼͽͰͻͯͪͷͼ͵͹
ͺ͹ͻͰ͵Ͷ͹i




̓ͪͯ
ͱͰͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ͵ͻͰ͸Ͱ
ͺͪͱΔ;
͸ͪ
Ͳͪ͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͼͽ
;
ͽͰ΀͸ͳ΁ͳ
͉Ͱͳͽͼͷͪ

΂Ͱͼͽ͹
ͺ͹ͽͰͱͰ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͻͰΌͰΔͳͷͪ
ͼͪ
ͯͪͶͰ͵ͳͷ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪ͹

ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͼͬ͹ͭ
ͼͶ;ͱͫ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
;
̓͹ͻ΂;Ͷͳ
ͺͻͳͷͰΕ;ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͬ͹ΕͰ
ͯͳͱͰ

͸ͪ
ͺͪͶ;ͫ;
;
͵͹ͻͺͪͷͪ
͸ͪ
ͳͼͽͳ
ͺͻͳͷͳͽͳͬ͸ͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
ͬͳͯͰ͹

ͯͬͪͯͰͼͰͽ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͻͪ͸ͳΒͰ
;
̻ͬͳ͸ͰΒͼ͵͹ͷ
ͲͪͶͳͬ;
 ͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
;
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ 

̀ͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
;ͺͻ͵͹ͼ
ͳͲͬͻͼ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔ;
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
͈ͻͬ͹ͭ

ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
ͫ͹Βͳ΃ͽͪ
;
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ
ͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
͉Ͱͳͽͼͷͪ

ͼͶͪͫ͹
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒͰ
΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵;
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ;
̾ͬ͹
΃ͽͪ
ͼͪͷ
͵ͪͱͰ
͹
ͼͬ͹ͷ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪ
Δ;
΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
t͇
̀ͪͭͻͰͫ;
͸Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪͷ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͯ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͻͪ͸ͳΒͰ
Ͳͬͪ͹
̸ͭͻͪͷ

ͯ͹͵
ΒͰ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͪ
Β͹΃
ͫͳͶͪ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ
ͯͰ͹
̽;͸ͪͬͼ͵Ͱ
ͷ͹͸ͪͻ΀ͳΒͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ;

ͯ͹

ͬͶͪͯͪ͹
ͫͪ͸
͠ͰͶͪ΂ͳΕ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ

ͿͪͶͼͳͿͳ͵͹ͬͪ͸ͳͷ
ͯ͹͵;ͷͰ͸
ͽͳͷͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ͹
͹ͲͶ͹ͭͶͪ΃Ͱ͸ͳ
̀ͪͭͻͰͫͪ΂͵ͳ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼ
Ͳͪ
ͬͰͶͰͳͲͯͪΒ;
m
΃ͽ͹

ΒͰ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
΃ͽͰͽͳͶ͹
;ͭͶͰͯ;
̸;ͼͽͻ͹;ͭͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͷ͹͸ͪͻ΀ͳΒͰ
m
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ

;ΒͰͯͳΔͰΔͪ
ͼͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒ͹ͷ
͸ͪͼͽͪ͹
Βͪ͵
ͺ͹͵ͻͰͽ
Ͳͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹͸͹ͷͳΒ;
ͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͪΒ

ͺ͹͵ͻͰͽ
ͼͪͯͪ
ͺ͹ͯ
ͬ͹Όͼͽͬ͹ͷ
ͪͅ΂Ͱ͵ͪ
͆ͳΒͰ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͪͶͳ
ΒͰ
ͳͺͪ͵
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹i



͌ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒ;Εͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
͹
͵͹ΒͰͷ
Ͳ͸ͪ
ͽͰ͵
ͺ͹͸Ͱ͵ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ

ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵
͹͸
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂;ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
tͺͻͰͶͰͺ
ͼͪ
΃ͳͻ͹͵ͳͷ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪi

ͳ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͳͷ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳͷ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ͹ͷ
̹;ͯ;Εͳͷ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͳͷͪ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;
ΒͰ
ͅͰ΃ͽͻ͹ͬͳΕͰͬ
ͷ;ͲͰΒ
ͳ
̀ͪͭͻͰͫͪ΂͵;
ͿͳͶ΀ͪͻͷ͹͸ͳΒ;
ͭͯͰ
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͼͪͷ
ͺͻͳ
ͼ;ͼͽͬ͹ͬͪ͹
ͳͲͬ͹ΌͰΔ;
̻͹ͽ͹ͬ΂ͰͬͰ
ͼͳͷͿ͹͸ͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͰͷͰ
͇ͻͪ΂ͳ

͊;ͷͳͻͪΒ;Εͳ
ͼͬͰ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
;ͽͳͼ͵Ͱ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͪ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͳ
ͼͪ
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ
͸͹ͭ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͉Ͱͳͽͼͷͪ
͵ͪͱͰ
ͯͪ
͹ͼͰΕͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵͹
ͯͳͬΓͰΔͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͼͬͰͷ;

΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͬͰͲͪ͸͹
Ͳͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
̽ͪ
ͫͳ
ͫͶͳͱͰ
͹ͫΒͪͼ͸ͳ͹
ͽͪ
ͼͬ͹Βͪ
͹ͼͰΕͪΔͪ
͹͸

Β͹΃
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
΁ͳͽͳͻͪ
̾ͯͳͽ
̽ͪͻͰͷ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͯͬͪͯͰͼͰͽͪ͵
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͺͻͰ
ΔͰͭͪ

͹ͫΒͪͬͳͶͪ
͵Δͳͭ;
5IF
#VSEFO
PG
UIF
#BMLBOT
t5SBWFMMJOH
JO
UIF
/FBS
&BTU
IBT
CFFO
TBJE
CZ
NBOZ
UP
CF
EJGGJDVMU

EBOHFSPVT
BOE
XIJDI
JT
FWFO
NPSF
BMBSNJOH
UP
UIF
$PPLSFBSFE
UPVSJTU

VODPNGPSUBCMF
*U
NBZ
CF
TP
*
BN
OPU
DBQBCMF
PG
KVEHJOH
8IFO
*
BN
UIF
SF
UIF
POMZ
EJGGJDVMUZ
JT
UP
UFBS
NZTFMG
MPPTF
GSPN
JUT
FODIBOUNFOUT
BOE

SFUVSO
8FTUXBSET
"T
GPS
EBOHFST
BOE
EJTDPNGPSUT
UIFZ
BSF
BMM
GPSHPUUFO

JO
UIF
BMMBCTPSCJOH
JOUFSFTU
PG
JUT
QSPCMFNTi


͋ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͳ
ͼ;
;ͺͻͪͬ͹
͹͸͹
΃ͽ͹
Ϳͪͼ΁ͳ͸ͳͻͪ
͉Ͱͳͽͼͷ;
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͪ
ͬ͹ͯͰΕͳ
;͵ͻͪͽ͵͹
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵Ͱ
;
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸;
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂;ΒͰ

ͼͶͰͯͰΕͰ
t͋͹
ͼ;
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͼͳͽ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
͸Ͱ
ͫͳ
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
ͯͪ
Ͳͪͼͽͻͪ΃Ͱ
͸ͳΒͰͯ
͸͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽ;
͆ͪͺͻ͹ͽͳͬ
͠Ͱͻ
ͳͲ
Δͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͶͪͲͳ
ͯͪ
ͻ͹ͷͪ͸ͽͳ͵ͪ
ͼͻͰΕ͹ͷ

Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͪͺ;ͼͽͳͶͪ
ͼͬͰͽ
̸
ͺͻ͹͸ͪͶͪͱͰΔͰ
;Ͳͻ͹͵ͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͬͰͲͪ͸͹
ͼͽͳ
ͳ͸΁ͳͯͰ͸ͪͽͪ
ΒͰ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͱͰͼͽͳ͸Ͱ
͵͹Β͹ͷ
͵͹͸ͿͶͳ͵ͽͳ
ͼ͵ͻͰΕ;
ͺͪͱΔ;
Βͪͬ
͸͹ͼͽͳ
;ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ͸ͳΒͳi


́Ͳ
Ͳͪͬͻ΃͸ͳ΀
ͺͪͼ;ͼͪ
͵ΔͳͭͰ
Β͹΃
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
ͳͲͫͳΒͪ
͹ͯ;΃ͰͬΓͰΔͰ
͸Ͱ
ͺͪͽͬ͹ͻͰ͸͹΃Ε;
ͳ
ͪ;ͽͰ͸ͽͳ΂͸͹΃Ε;
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
͵͹ΒͰ
͉Ͱͳͽͼͷ;

ͺ͹ͬͰͲ;ΒͰ
ͼͪ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳͷ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
͋ͪΒ
͹ͼͰΕͪΒ
͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͯͪ

ͺ͹ͷ;ͽͳ
͸ͳ
ͼͳͻ͹ͷͪ΃ͽͬ͹
͸ͳ
ͷͪΔ͵ͪͬͪ
΀ͳͭͳΒͰ͸ͪ
 ͠ͰͶͳ΁ͪ
͆͹ͬͪ͵͹ͬͳΕ̈́͹ͺ;΃ͳ͸ͪ

͆ͪΒ͹ͫͳͷ͸ͳΒ;
ͼͽ;ͯͳΒ;
ͳ
;ΒͰͯ͸͹
͸ͪΒͶͳͽͰͻͪͻ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸͹
ͯͰ
Ͷ͹
͸ͪͺͳͼͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͻ
͍ͰͶͳ͵ͼ
͉;ͽͰ͸
'FMJY
3VUUFO
m

΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵ͳ

ͺͰͼ͸ͳ͵
ͳ
ͺͳͼͪ΁
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ͸
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ͸ͳ͵
;
͹͵ͬͳͻ;
ͺ͹͵ͻͰͽͪ
Ͳͪ

͵ͪͽ͹Ͷͳ΂͵;
Ͱͷͪ͸΁ͳͺͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͼ;ͺͻ;ͭ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͰ
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵Ͱ
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸ͳ΁Ͱ

ͪͅͻͳ
̓;͸Ͱ͸
.BSJF
$PFOFO

̀ͪ΀ͬͪΓ;Β;Εͳ
ͬͳ΃Ͱͭ͹ͯͳ΃ΔͰͷ
ͫ͹ͻͪͬ͵;

;
͉ͳͷ;
ͻͪͲͬͳ͹
ΒͰ
Γ;ͫͪͬ
Ͳͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
͵ͻͪΒ͹Ͷͳ͵Ͱ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
͸Ͱ͵͹
Ͷͳ͵͹
Ͳͫͳͻ͵ͳ
ͺ͹ͰͲͳΒͰ
ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͳ΃͸ͳ΀
͵͹ͷͪͯͪ
ͳ
͸͹ͬͰͶͪ
͹ͫΒͪͬͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ;
ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸Ͱ
ͼͽ;ͯͳΒͰ
͹
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͳ


̹ͻͳͱ;


͈͹Γͼ͵͹Β



͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ


ͳ
͋͹ͼ͵ͪ͸ͳ



͆ͪ

ͼͽͻͪ͸ͪ
;

ͺ͹ͭͶͪͬΓͪ
͉;ͽͰ͸
ΒͰ
ͺͻ;ͱͳ͹
ͺͻͪͬͰ
ͷͪͶͰ

ͪͻͪͫͰͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͲͰ
͢Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ
͹ͺͳͼͳ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͰ
ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͼ;
ͫͻͪ
ͬ;ͻ͹Ͳ͸ͳ
ͼͪ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͻ͸Ͱ
ͽͪ΂͵Ͱ
ͭͶͰͯͳ΃ͽͪ
ͯͪ
ͯͰͶ;Β;
ͺ͹ͺ;ͽ
ͼͪͬͻ΃Ͱ͸ͳ΀

ͿͳͶͷͼ͵ͳ΀
ͷͳ͸ͳΒͪͽ;ͻͪ
͇ͯ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
͸ͪΒͬͳ΃Ͱ
Ϳͪͼ΁ͳ͸ͳͻͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ͹ͬͪ
Ͱͻ;
ͯͳ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳ
;ͺ;ΕͰ͸͹ͼͽ
;
ͼͬͰ
ͬͳͯ͹ͬͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
̀ͪͯͳͬΓ;Β;ΕͰ
ΒͰ
ͼͪ
͵ͪ͵ͬ͹ͷ

ͼͽͻ;΂͸͹΃Ε;
ͱͪͻ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸͹΃Ε;
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ;
ͻͳ
Ͱͽ͸͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͳ
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͵͸ͳͱͰͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͼͬͳ΀
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ

́͸ͪ΂Ͱ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͰ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ΒͰ
ͬͰͲͪ͸͹
Ͳͪ
ͳͷͰ
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸
ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹΂ͪͼ͸͹ͭ
͵͹͸Ͳ;Ͷͪ
ͅͰͻͰ͸ͼͪ
͌ͬ͹ͯ͸͹
ͺ͹ͭͶͪͬΓͰ
͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͼ;ͭͰͻͳ΃Ͱ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹ͼͽ
ͼͪ
ͯͰ
Ͷ͹ͷ
̺Ͷͪͯͳͷͳͻͪ
ͣ͹ͻ͹ͬͳΕͪ
͆ͪͱͪͶ͹ͼͽ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͯͪͽͪ
ͫͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ
ͽͪ
͵͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼ
ͺ͹;Ͳͯͪ͸͹΃Ε;
ͻͰΕͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͼͬͰ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͰ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳ͹
̾ͬ͹
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
;ͬͳͯͪ
;
ͼ;΃ͽͳ͸;
ͻͪͲ
Ͷͳ͵ͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͪ΁ͪ
͎ͻͬͪͽͪ
ͳ
͊ͻͫͪ
t͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ͹ͯ
ͼͪͷ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͰ͹
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
͹ͼͬͰ΃Εͳͬͪ
Δͪ
ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͯ͹͵
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͊ͻͫͳ
m
ͪ;ͽ͹͸͹ͷ͸ͳ
͹ͯ

ͳ
͸ͰͲͪͬͳͼ͸ͳ
͹ͯ


m
ͫ͹ͻͳͶͳ
ͼͪͫΓ͹ͷ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸΁ͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͼͪ
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͳͷ
ͼ;ͼͰ
ͯͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͫͻͪΕ͹ͷ
ͫ͹ͻͳͶͳ
΃͵͹Ͷ͹ͷ
͆ͪͼͺͻͪͷ
͹ͺͳͺΓͳͬͰ
ͫ͹ͻͫͰ
͵͹Β;
ΒͰ

ͽͪͷ͹
ͺͻ͹ͽͳͬ
͋;ͻͪ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͬͰ͹
̓ͪͻͪΌ͹ͻΌͰ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸΁ͳ
ͼ;
ͼͬ͹Β;
ͺͻ͹ͽͳͬ

̸;ͼͽͻͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͬͰͶͳ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹Γ;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͌
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
TͰ
ͼ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹ͷ
ͻͪͲͬͳ
Ͷͪ
ͼͪͷ͹ͼͽͪͶ͸ͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
;
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͳ
ͳ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹Β
ͽͰͱΔͪ
Ͳͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸͹
ͽͬ͹ͻ͸͹΃Ε;
͋ͪͷ͹
ͼ;
ͼͰ
;ͲͭͪΒͪͶͳ
Β;͸ͪ΁ͳ
m
͹ͬͯͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͻͪΌͪͶͳ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͳ

Γ;ͯͳ
͋ͪͷ͹
ͼͰ
ͻͪͯͳͶ͹
͹
ͭͬ͹ͲͯͰ͸͹Β
ͼͳͶͳ
ͳ
ͷ͹Εͳ
m
͹ͬͯͰ
͹
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ
͸͹Β
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͳ
ͳ
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽͳi


́ͪ͵͹
͵ͪͽ͹Ͷͳ͵
͉;ͽͰ͸
ͼͪ
ͼͽͻͪ΀͹ͺ͹΃ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰͷ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͬͰͻͳ
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹
ͻͳΒͳ
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬΓͪ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͹
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͳͷͪ
tͪ͠
͸ͳͼͪͷ
ͼͷͰͼͽͪ
͹ͼͰͽͳ͹
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͰ
ͳ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ
͹ͬͰ
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬ͸Ͱ

ͲͰͷΓͰ
͹͸ͪ͵͹
͵ͪ͵ͬͰ
ͼ;
;
ͼͽͬͪͻ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͱͰͶͰ
ͯͪ
ͫ;ͯ;
ͬͳΌͰ͸Ͱ
͇ͬͳ

ͯͻͪͭ;Γͳ
ͳͲͭ;ͫΓͰ͸ͳ
;
͸Ͱͷͪͻ;
;
ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹ͷ
Ͳͪͫ͹ͻͪͬ;
m
ͺͻͪͬͪ
ͼ;
΂;ͯͪ

΂;ͯͰͼ͸ͪ
͹ͽ͵ͻ͹ͬͰΔͪ
ͯ;΃Ͱ
̀Ͷͪͽ͸ͳ
ͽͻͪͭ͹ͬͳ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͽͬ͹
 ͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
;
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ 

ͻͳͶ͹
;
΂ͳͼͽ;
ͼͪͭ;
͉ͰͶͳ͵ͽͳ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
Ͳͭͻ;΃ͪͶͪ
;
ͶͰͭͰ͸ͯ;

ͳ
ͼͪ͸
̀ͭ;ͱͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͳͼ͵ͻͲͪ͸Ͱ
ͺͶͰͷͳΕ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͬͰΓͰ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹͵͹ΓͰΔͪ
͵͹ΒͰ

ΒͰ
͹ͼ;ΌͰ͸͹
͸ͪ
ͺ͹͵͹ͻ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
ͻ͹ͺͼͽͬ͹
ͼͬ͹Β;
ͯͪͶͰ͵;
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽ
ͼͬ͹Β;

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ;
ͳ
ͼͬ͹Β;
ͬͰͻ;
ͺ͹ͳͼͽ͹ͬͰͽͳͶ͹
ͼͪ
͸Ͱ;ͽͰ΃͸͹ͷ
ͽ;ͭ͹ͷ
̽ͻͪͭ͹΁Ͱ
͸ͪ
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂ͪ͸ͼͽͬͪ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
΁ͳͬͳͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͻͪͼ΁ͬͪͶͰ
ͺ͹ͯ

ͼ;͸΁Ͱͷ
̺ͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͰ
m
ͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͷͪͻͳͶͪ
Ͳͪ
Δ;i


͌͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͳ͵ͪͯ
ͫ;ͯͰ
ΒͪͬͳͶͪ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͪ
Ͳͪ
͹ͯͪͬͪΔͰͷ
ͺͻͳͲ͸ͪΔͪ

ͲͰͷΓͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
͸Ͱͷͪ
͹͸ͯͪ
͉;ͽͰ͸͹ͬ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ͲͪͼͶ;ͱ;ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͫ;ͯͰ

ͺͻͰͬͰͯͰ͸
̸͵͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻͬͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͽͬ͹ͻͰͬͳ͸ͪ
ͳͲͪͲͳͬͪͶͪ

͵͹͸ͽͻ͹ͬͰͻͲ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͪͬ͹ͬͰ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͭ͸͹ͲͰ
͵ͪ͹
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺͻ͹
ͼͽ͹ͻ
ΒͰ
;
͎͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͳΒͳ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪͬͪ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
͹Ͷͳ΂ͰΔͰ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬͪ
ͼ;ͺͻ͹ͽ͸͹
ͼͽͳ
̽ͪ͵ͶͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͳͯͰͪͶ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
;
ͷͪͶ͹ͷ
́ͼ͵;ͼͽͬ͹
̾ͬͻ͹ͺ
ͼ͵Ͱ
͌͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͪͼ
;΂ͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͪ͵ͪͬ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͳͯͰͪͶ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
͹ͼͽͬͪͻΓͳͬ
ͳ

ͫͰͲ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸͹ͭ
͹͵ͬͳͻͪ
ͺ͹ͯ
;ͼͶ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͳ
ͫͳͬ΃Ͱ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͬͰͲͪ͸ͳ
ͯ͹ͫͻͳͷ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͻͪͼͽͰͻͰΕͰ͸ͳ
ͬͳͲ͸ͳ΀
ͻͰͱͳ
ͷͪ

̸̸̹̹͇̻͉͍́̈́́́͠

$PSEFNBOT
.

m
t%F
+PFHPTMBWFOi
6
7FSIBOEFMJOHFO
WBO
EF
"MHFNFF
OF
,BUIPMJFLF
7MBBNTDIF
)PPHFTDIPPMVJUCSFJEJOH
"OUXFSQFO

%PPMBBSE
"
%FO


m
%F
)FSCFSH
NFU
IFU
)PFGJK[FS
"NTUFSEBN
%PPMBBSE
"
%FO

m
0SJÌOU
&YQSFTT
"NTUFSEBN
%PPMBBSE
"
%FO


m
)FU
MBOE
BDIUFS
(PET
SVH
"NTUFSEBN
%PPMBBSE
"
%FO


m
7BLBOUJFMBOE
+PFHPTMBWJÌ
"NTUFSEBN
/PWBLPWJǀ-PQVØJOB
+


m
4SCJ
J
KVHPJTUPǁOB
&WSPQB
V
OJ[P[FNTLJN
J[WP
SJNB
EP

#FPHSBE
0PSUIVZT
$

"
%FO
%PPMBBSE

m
%JU
JT
+PFHPTMBWJÌ
"NTUFSEBN

3FJUTNB
4
"

m
;XFSGUPDIUFO
EPPS
EFO
#BMLBO
%FO
)BBH
3FJUTNB
4
"

m
+PFHPTMBWJÌ
FO
EF
PWFSJHF
#BMLBO
m
FFO
UPFSJTUJTDI
EPSB
EP
)BBHTDI
NBBOECMBE


3VUUFO
'FMJY

m
+PFHPTMBWJÌ
-BOETDIBQ
m
WPMLTMFWFO
"NTUFSEBN
4DIBNFMIPVU
(


m

%F
WPMLFSFO
WBO
&VSPQB
FO
EF
TUSJKE
EFS
OBUJPOBMJUFJ
UFO
"NTUFSEBN
8FSFMECJCMJPUIFFL
 ͠ͰͶͳ΁ͪ
͆͹ͬͪ͵͹ͬͳΕ̈́͹ͺ;΃ͳ͸ͪ

4DIPVUFO
.BSUJO


m
.BSJOVT
WBO
EFS
-VCCF
&FO
CJPHSBGJF
"NTUFSEBN

7BML
8JFHFS


m
3FJ[FO
JO
IFU
LPOJOLSJKL
+PFHPTMBWJÌ
%FO
)BBH
,PO

/FE
5PFSJTUFOCPOE
"/8#

8BBSTFOCVSH
)BOT
WBO
EF


m
"
%FO
%PPMBBSE
1PSUSFU
WBO
FFO
LVOTUF
OBBS
"NTUFSEBN
XXXUIFCIDPSH
XXXECOMPSH
 ͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
;
΀͹Ͷͪ͸ͯͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ 

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

+FMJDB
/PWBLPWJǀ-PQVØJOB
+VHPTMBXJFO
JO
OJFEFSMÅOEJTDIFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO

BVT
EFO
FS
+BISFO
EFT

+BISIVOEFSUT

8FOO
NBO
5PVSJTUFO
BMT
t&SIPMVOH
VOE
6OUFSIBMUVOH
TVDIFOEF

3FJTFOEFi
CF[FJDIOFU
MÅTTU
TJDI
BVGHSVOE
BVTGJOEJH
HFNBDIUFS
VOE
BOBMZTJFSUFS

2VFMMFO
TDIMJF“FO
EBTT
TPMDIF
JO
4ÛEPTUFVSPQB
WFSIÅMUOJTNœJH
GSÛI[FJUJH

FSTDIJFOFO
%FS
FSTUF
3FJTFGÛISFS
JO
EFS
OJFEFSMÅOEJTDIFO
4QSBDIF
JO
EFN

/BUVSTDIÕOIFJUFO
CFTDISJFCFO
VOE
LVMUVSFMMF
4FIFOTXÛSEJHLFJUFO
WPO

%BMNBUJFO
SÛINFOE
IFSWPSHFIPCFO
XVSEFO
TUBNNU
BVT
EFO
MFU[UFO
+BISFO

EFT

+BISIVOEFSUT
%FS
"VUPS
CFGBOE
TJDI
JO
#FHMFJUVOH
FJOFT
GMÅNJTDIFO

"EMJHFO
+PT
WBO
)JTUFMF
EFS
[V
EJFTFS
;FJU
QJMHFSUF
BCFS
BVDI
6OUFSIBMUVOH

VOE
&SIPMVOH
TVDIUF

+BISIVOEFSUFMBOH
MFJTUFUFO
3FJTFGÛISFS
/JFEFSMÅOEFSO
VOE
'MBNFO

HVUF
%JFOTUF
EJF
EVSDI
/FVHJFSEF
[V
MBOHFO
3FJTFUPVSFO
BOHFTQPSOU
XVSEFO

*O
&SNBOHFMVOH
EFS
WPO
FJHFOFO
"VUPSFO
WFSGBTTUFO
3FJTFMJUFSBUVS
XVSEF

IÅVGJH
VOE
HFSO
OBDI
¾CFSTFU[VHFO
BVT
EFN
&OHMJTDIFO
'SBO[ÕTJTDIFO
VOE

%FVUTDIFO
HFHSJGGFO
#JT
[VN
&OEF
EFT

+BISIVOEFSUT
TUFMMUF
4ÛEPTUFVSPQB

JO
OJFEFSMÅOEJTDIFO
2VFMMFO
KFEPDI
OVS
FJOF
5SBOTJUTUBUJPO
BVG
EFN
MBOHFO

8FH
[V
BOEFSFO
3FJTF[JFMFO
EBS
m
BN
IÅVGJHTUFO
OBDI
,POTUBOUJOPQFM

%JF
FSTUFO
5PVSJTUFO
JN
NPEFSOFO
4JOOF
EFT
8PSUFT
FSTDIJFOFO
EBOO

"OGBOH
EFT

+BISIVOEFSUT
EBOL
JOUFOTJWFS
&OUXJDLMVOH
WPO
7FSLFISTNJUUFMO

JO
FSTUFS
-JOJF
WPO
4DIJFOFO
VOE
"VUPWFSLFIS
&JO
CFLBOOUFS
OJFEFSMÅOEJTDIFS

4DISJGUTUFMMFS
.BSTFMVT
&NBOUT
WFSÕGGFOUMJDIUF
JN
+BIS

FJOF
EFUBJMMJFSUF

4DIJMEFSVOH
TFJOFS
UPVSJTUJTDIFO
3FJTFO
EVSDI
#PTOJFO
VOE
)FS[FHPXJOB


*OGPMHF
EFS
CFJEFO
#BMLBOLSJFHF
VOE
EFT
&STUFO
8FMULSJFHT
WFSMPTDI

EJFTFT
HFSBEF
FSXFDLUF
*OUFSFTTF
GÛS
EJF
OBIF
-FWBOUF
5PVSJTUFO
XBHUFO
TJDI

FSTU
"OGBOH
EFS
FS
+BISF
EFT

+BISIVOEFSUT
XJFEFS
HFO
4ÛEPTUFO
%PSU

FOUTUBOE
NJUUMFSXFJMF
FJO
OFVFT
4UBBUTHFCJMEF
+VHPTMBXJFO
EFTTFO
7JFMGÅMUJHLFJU

TFJOFO
7PSUFJM
JN
UPVSJTUJTDIFO
VOE
HMFJDI[FJUJH
TFJOFO
FOUTDIFJEFOEFO
/BDIUFJM

JN
QPMJUJTDIFO
4JOOF
EBSTUFMMUF
"MMFO
HFTFMMTDIBGUTQPMJUJTDIFO
4UVEJFO
BVT
EFO

FS
VOE
FS
+BISF
[VXJEFS
EJF
EFN
OFV
FOUTUBOEFOFO
4UBBU
NJU
4LFQTJT

FOUHFHFOTFIFO
RVJMMU
BVT
EFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO
VOHFIFNNUF
VOE
BVGSJDIUJHF

#FHFJTUFSVOH
JISFS
7FSGBTTFS
IFSBVT

0CXPIM
BMT
QPMJUJTDIFT
(FCJMEF
JO
OJFEFSMÅOEJTDIFO
2VFMMFO
XJEFS
TQSVDITWPMM
VOE
LPOUSPWFST
JOUFSQSFUJFSU
XVSEF
EBT
FSTUF
+VHPTMBXJFO
JO

LVMUVSFMMFS
VOE
UPVSJTUJTDIFS
)JOTJDIU
BMT
7FSLÕSQFSVOH
EFS
&JOIFJU
WPO

(FHFOTÅU[FO
EI
BMT
*OCFHSJGG
BMMFS
UPVSJTUJTDIFO
8FSUF
&VSPQBT
JN
,MFJOFO

CFUSBDIUFU
͊Ͷ͹ͫ͹ͯͪ͸
͊
̸͈͇̺́ͣ͠
̻Ͱ͹Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ
Ϳͪ͵;ͶͽͰͽ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

̸͉̹͊́͠
͌
̸͈͑͆͊̓́ͅ

̸̹͉̾̽̾̓̾́ͅ


̓ͻͪΕͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
͹ͼͬͻͽ
͈ͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͳͲͻͪͯͰ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͻͪͯͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͪ

ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͼͽ;ͺ͸͹ͼͽ
͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪΒ;Ε͹Β
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͳͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹Β
ͭͻͪΌͳ
ͳ
ͯ͹͵;
ͷͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͳͷ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͭͰ͸ͰͻͪͶ͸͹
ͺ͹ͼͷͪͽͻͪ͸͹
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
Ͷͳͷͳ
ͽͳͻͪ͸ͳ
ͳ
͹ͼ͵;ͯ͸ͳ
͋ͪ
͵͹͸ͼͽͪͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳ
͵ͪ͵͹
͸ͪ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͽͪ͵͹

ͳ
͸ͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͰ
͊΀͹ͯ͸͹
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͰ
ͻͰΕͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͰͷͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͪ

͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͪ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
ͳ
;
ͽ͹ͷ
͵͹͸ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
͊ͻͫͳΒ͹ͷ
Β͹΃

;ͬͰ͵
͸Ͱͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͳͲ;΂Ͱ͸ͪ
;͵Γ;΂;Β;Εͳ
ͳ
ͺͳͽͪΔͪ
ͬͰͲͪ͸ͪ
Ͳͪ
͸ͪͼͽͪ͸ͪ͵

΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸ͳ΀
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
&Y
TJMFOUJP
;
ͽ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯ;
͹ͫΒͪ΃Δͪͬͪͷ͹
͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯͳ΁;
ͼͺͰ΁ͳ
Ϳͳ΂͸ͳ΀
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
͹͵͹Ͷ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ

ͺͻ͹ͽͪͭ͹͸ͳͲͪͷ
͸ͪ
ͷͰΌ;͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹Β
ͼ΁Ͱ͸ͳ
ͫͳ͹
ͺͻͰ;ͼͷͰͻͰ͸
;
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͯͰͶ͹
ͬͰ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
ͳ
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
;
ͽͲͬ
t͆͹ͬͳ
ͼͬͰͽi
ͳͶͳ
͎ͳͼͺͪ͸ͼ͵;
̸ͷͰͻͳ͵;

͵͹Β;
ͼ;
͑ͺͪ͸΁ͳ
ͳͼͽͻͪΒ͸͹
͸ͪͲͳͬͪͶͳ
t̀ͪͺͪͯ͸Ͱ
́͸ͯͳΒͰi
͋ͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͽͻͰͫͪ



͋;
ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
ͷͳͼͶͳͷ͹
͸ͪ
ͲͪͺͳͼͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͰ
ͳͲͬͰ΃ͽͪΒͰ
ͳͶͳ
͹ͼͽͪͶ;
ͯ͹͵;
ͷͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒ;
͵͹Βͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͻͰ͵Ͷͪ
ͪ
͹ͼͬͰͽΓͪͬͪ
͸Ͱ͵ͳ
͹ͯ
ͪͼͺͰ͵ͪͽͪ
ͼͶ͹ͱͰ͸Ͱ

ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͻͰͪͶ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͪ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
Δ͹Β


*PBOOJT
,
)BTTJPUJT
&TQBÒB
Z
FM
4VSFTFUF
EF
&VSPQB
FO
MB
ÊQPDB
NPEFSOB
$VB
USP
TJHMPT
EF
EJMFNBT
EJQMPNÃUJDPT
;
&TQBÒB
Z
MB
DVMUVSB
IJTQÃOJDB
FO
FM
TVSFTUF

FVSPQFP

&E
%JSFDDJÓO
(FOFSBM
EF
3FMBDJPOFT
$VMUVSBMFT
Z
$JFOUÎêDBT
.JOJTUFSJP
EF
"TVOUPT
&YUF
SJPSFT
EF
&TQBÒB
"UFOBT

m
 ͊Ͷ͹ͫ͹ͯͪ͸
͊
͈ͪΒ͹ͬͳΕ

͸ͪͭͶͪͼͳͽͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͪ
͹ͼͳͷ
ͽͲͬ
t͆͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͪi
ͺ͹ͼͰͯ͹ͬͪͶͪ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ

͵͹͸ͼͽͪ͸ͽ͸Ͱ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ
΁ͳͬͳͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͳ͹ͻͳͽͰͽͰ
;

͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
ͼͰͬͰͻ͸Ͱ
̸Ϳͻͳ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͯͰͶͳͷͳ΂͸͹
;
ͪͲͳΒͼ͵͹ͺͪ΁ͳͿͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͻͰͭͳ
͹͸;
͌
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͭ
͹ͬ͹Β
ͽͬͻͯΔͳ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳͷ͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͼͪͷ
͵ͻͪΒ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
͵͹Ͷ͹
͸ͳΒͪͶͳͲͷͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
΂ͳ͸
ͻͰͯ;͵΁ͳΒͰ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ

͸ͪ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͰΕ;
ͺ͹͵ͪͲͪ͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͪͯͅͻͳͯ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳͲͭ;ͫͳͬ΃ͳ

ͼͬ͹Βͪ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͪ
ͽͻͳ
ͺͻͰ͵͹ͷ͹ͻͼ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͯͪ
m
͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ΒͰ
;ͺͻͪͬ͹
ΒͰͯͪ͸

͹ͯ
Δͳ΀
ͫͳ͹
;
̸ͲͳΒͳ
͍ͳͶͳͺͳ͸ͳ

ͯ͹͵
ͼ;
͹ͼͽͪͶͪ
ͯͬͪ
ͫͳͶͳ
;
̈́ͪͽͳ͸ͼ͵͹Β

̸ͷͰͻͳ΁ͳ
̓;ͫͪ
ͳ
͈͹ͻͽ͹ͻͳ͵͹

m
ΒͰͯͳ͸͹
ͼͪ΂;ͬͪ͹
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͰ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
͸Ͱ͵ͪ
ͯͪ΃ΔͰ
ͬͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͳͷͺͰͻͳΒͰ
;
Ͳ͹͸ͳ
ͪͭͅͻͰͫͪ
̓͹͸ͪ΂ͪ͸͹
͵ͪͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͻͪͯͳ
͹

ͼͻͺͼ͵͹΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳͷͪ
;
͸ͪΒ΃ͳͻͰͷ
ͼͷͳͼͶ;
ͽͰ
ͻͰ΂ͳ
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͳ
ͼͰ

ͯ͹
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂͵ͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͽͰ΃͵͹
;ͽͬͻͯͳͽͳ
͵͹͸ͽͳ͸;ͳͽͰͽ
;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳͷͪ

̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͼͪ
͸ͪ΃͹ͷ
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸͹ͷ
͵͹ΒͰͷ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪ
͊
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͰΕͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͭͻͪ
ΌͰ
ͺͻͳͷͰͽ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
͹
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͼͶ͹ͱͰ͸ͳͷ

ͳ
͵͹͸ͽͻͪͯͳ͵ͽ͹ͻ͸ͳͷ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳͷͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
͇ͽ͹ͷͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
΁ͪͻ
ͼͽͬͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
ͯͰͿͳ͸ͳͼͪͽͳ
tͼͽͪΔͰͷ
͸Ͱ͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪi
Ͳͫ͹ͭ

ͼͽͻͪ΀ͪ
ͪͯͅͻͳͯͪ
͹ͯ
ͰͬͰ͸ͽ;ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͻ΃͵Ͱ
͈͹ͻͽͰ
ͷͪͬͪͻͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͫ;ΔͰ
͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
;
ͼͰͬͰͻ͸͹Β
̸Ϳͻͳ΁ͳ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͳͷ
͸ͪͼͰ͹ͫͳ͸ͪͷͪ
;
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ

̈́Ͱͬͪ͸ͽͪ
͸ͪ
́ͫͰͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹Ͷ;͹ͼͽͻͬ;
͈ͻͳ
ͽ͹ͷͰ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͯͳ͸ͪ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͪ
ͼͳͶͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
;
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺͻͰ͵ͳ͸;Ͷͪ
͹ͯ͸͹
ͼͰ
ͼͪ
͈͹ͻͽ͹ͷ
;
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
͹ͯ
ͼ͵͹ͻ͹
ͽͻͳ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
97*m97***

͌͵ͻͪͽ͵͹

ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͻͰͪͶ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳ
ͳͲ
ͽ͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
͹ͽ͹ͷͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͷͺͰͻͳΒͰ
m
;

΂ͳΒͳ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬ
ΒͰ
;΃Ͷͪ
ͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
m
ͽͰ΃͵͹
ͼ;
ͺͻ͹ͯͳͻͪͶͳ
;
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͷͰ͸
ͽͪͶͳͽͰͽ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸͹ͭ
ͯ͹ͫͪ
ͳ
ͽ͹
ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
΃ͺͪ͸
ͼ͵ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳ΂ͪͻͳ
ͳ
΀ͻ͹͸ͳ΂ͪͻͳ
ͫͳͶͳ
;ͼͷͰͻͰ͸ͳ
͸ͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͰ
ͼͬͰͽͪ

̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
ΒͰ
ͺ͹
ͯͰͿͳ͸ͳ΁ͳΒͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ͹
ͬͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ

͸ͪ͵͹͸
͹ͼͬͪΒͪΔͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪ͹
ͯͰ͹
͹ͽ͹ͷͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͷͺͰͻͳΒͰ
ͪ
ͼͬͳ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳ
ͬͰͲͪ
͸ͳ
Ͳͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
ͼ;
;
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵͹Β
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͳ
͹ͫͻͪΌͳͬͪ͸ͳ
͸ͪ͵͹͸
Δͳ
΀͹ͬ͹ͭ
͹ͯͳͭͻͪͬͪΔͪ
;Ͳ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͰ͸;
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳͶͳ
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ

ͳͲͬ͹ͻͳ΀ͻ͹͸ͳ͵Ͱ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͹
Δͳͷͪ
ͳͲͬͰ΃ͽͪͬͪͶͳ
̀͸ͪ΂ͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͻͪͯͳ
͹

ͻͰͺͻ͹ͯ;͵΁ͳΒͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
ͽ͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
;
͸ͪΒͬͰΕ͹Β
ͷͰͻͳ
Ͳͪͼ͸͹ͬͪ͸͹Β

͸ͪ
ͳ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳͷ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͳͷͪ
͈͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ
ͯ͹ͼͽͪ
͹ͻͳͭͳ͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͪ
ͳͲ
ͽ͹ͭ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ

͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒ;
ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹ͭ
ͅͰͯͳͽͰͻͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ



͇
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳͷͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
;͵Γ;΂;Β;Εͳ
ͳ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸
ͼ͵Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸;
ͼͽ;ͯͳΒ;
͹ͫΒͪͬͳ͹
ΒͰ
*PBOOJT
,
)BTTJPUJT
&QBÒB
Z
FM
4VSFTUF

EF
&VSPQB
FO
MB
ÊQPDB
NPEFSOB
DVBUSP
TJHMPT
EF
EJMFNBT
EJQMPNÃUJDPT
PQ
DJU

 ͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
;
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ 

͸ͪ
ͺͳͽͪΔͪ
ͺͶ͹ͬͳͯͫͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͷ͹ͻͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽͰͬͪ
͋ͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͰ
ͳ
͹ͺͳͼͳ

͹ͻ;ͱͪ͸ͳ΀
ͼ;͵͹ͫͪ
;
ͬ͹ͯͪͷͪ
ͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
̾ͭͰΒͪ
͌
ͽͳͷ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳͷ

ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
Ͳͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸ͳ͵ͪ
͹ͺͳͼͳ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
ͼͪ
ͽͳ΀

ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
ͳͶͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͳ
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͪ
ͫͳͶͳ
ͼ;
͵ͻͪΒΔͰ
͹ͼ͵;ͯ͸ͳ

ͳ
;ͬͰ͵
;
ͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ͸͹Β
ͬͰͲͳ
ͼ
ͺͳͽͪΔͳͷͪ
ͳͲ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͬ͹Β͸Ͱ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ

͌͵ͻͪͽ͵͹
͸ͪ
́ͫͰͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹Ͷ;͹ͼͽͻͬ;
ͼͽͬͪͻͪ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͳͺͳͲͳͻͪ͸ͪ

ͺͻͰͯ͹Θͫͪ
͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
͵ͪ͹
ͼͽͻͪ͸͹ͷ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ

Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;ΒͰ
;
ͼͬͳͷ
ͬͳͯ͹ͬͳͷͪ
Γ;ͯͼ͵Ͱ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ

Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹Β
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͻͰͶͳͭͳ͹Ͳ͸͹Β

͌
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸ͳͷ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
ͳ
΁ͳͬͳͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
͹͵ͬͳͻͳͷͪ
Ͳ͸ͪͽ
͸͹
ΒͰ
͹ͽͰͱͪ͸͹
ͳͲ;΂ͪͬͪΔͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͪ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸͹ͷ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹

ΔͰ͸͹ͭ
ͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͼͽͰͺͰ͸ͪ
Ͳͪͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪ͸͹ͼͽͳ
Ͳͪ
͹ͬͪΒ
ͯͰ͹
͸ͪ΃Ͱͭ

͵͹͸ͽͳ͸Ͱ͸ͽͪ
ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
97*
97**
ͳ
97***
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͫͰͲ
͹ͫͲͳͻͪ
͸ͪ

͹ͺ΃ͽͰͺͻͳ΀ͬͪΕͰ͸;
͹΁Ͱ͸;
͹
͵ͻͪΒΔͰ
͹ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂Ͱ͸ͳͷ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳͷͪ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ

ͼͪ
t́ͼͽ͹΂͸ͳͷ
ͅͰͯͳͽͰͻͪ͸͹ͷi
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͼͰ
͵͹͸ͽͪ͵ͽͳ
ͼͪ
ͭͻ΂͵͹
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬ͸ͳͷ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳͷ
ͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ͹ͷ
͆ͪͳͷͰ

͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ΒͰ
;
ͼ͵Ͷ͹ͺ;
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͪ͸ͽͳ͹ͽ͹ͷͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͽͻͪͽͰͭͳΒͰ
ͳ͸ͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ͸͹

ͺͻ;ͱͪͶͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻ΃͵;
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
΀ͻͳ΃Εͪ͸ͼͽͬ;
͋ͪͯͪ΃Δͪ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ

ͭͰ͹ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͼͽͻͪͽͰͭͳΒͪ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͅͰͯͳͽͰͻͪ͸;
ͳ
;
ͽ͹ͷ
͵͹͸ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;

̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͬͪͼ΀͹ͯ͸͹
;ͼͶ͹ͬΓͰ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͷ͹ͻͼ͵ͳͷ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͳͷͪ

ͳ
ͪͯͅͻͳͯ
ΒͰ
ͼͪ
͵ͻͪΒΔͰͭ
Ͳͪͺͪͯͪ
tNBSF
OPTUSVNiB
;
ͼͬ͹Βͼͽͬ;
ͬͰͶͳ͵Ͱ

ͪͽͶͪ͸ͽͼ͵͹ͷͰͯͳͽͰͻͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͳͶͰ
ͳͼͺ͹Γͪͬͪ͹
͸ͪͭͶͪ΃Ͱ͸;
ͳ
ͬͳ΃ͰͼͶ͹Β͸;

ͽ;ͻ͵͹Ϳ͹ͫͳΒ;
͌
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹ͷ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͬͪͱ͸;
;Ͷ͹ͭ;
;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳͷͪ

͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͪ
͹ͬͳͷ
ͯͰͶ͹ͷ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
͹ͯͳͭͻͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ΔͰ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͯͳ
͸ͪ
Β;ͭ;

́ͽͪͶͳΒͰ
͉ͪͯͳ
ͼͰ
͹
͆ͪͺ;Γ;
ͅͰͼͳ͸ͳ
ͳ
͈ͪͶͰͻͷ;
Ͷ;͵ͪͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;

ͳͷͪͶͰ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ
ͭͰ͹ͼͽͻͪͽͰ΃͵ͳ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͳ
ͬ͹Β͸ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ

;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳͷͪ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹ͷ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺ͹ͷ
͌
ͼ;΃ͽͳ͸ͳ
͹ͬͳ

ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ;ͽͬͻΌͰΔͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ͷ͹ͼͽ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
́ͫͰͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ

ͺ͹Ͷ;͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
ͳ
Β;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹͵ͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͳ
ͼͬͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͱͰͶͰͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͳͲ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳ
ΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ;Β;
;
ͽͪΒ
ͯͰ͹
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͰ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳΒͪͶ͸ͳ
ͳͲͪͼͶͪ͸ͳ΁ͳ
΃ͺͳ
Β;͸ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ΁ͳ
ͳͲͫͰͭͶͳ΁Ͱ
ͽͻͭ͹ͬ΁ͳ
ͷ͹ͻ͸ͪͻͳ
ͷ͹͸ͪͼͳ
ͪͬͪ͸ͽ;ͻͳ
ͼͽͳ
ͳͽͯ

ͷ͹ͻͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ͯͪ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͰ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͰͯͰ
;
Β;ͱ͸͹Β
́ͽͪͶͳΒͳ

͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ;
Ͳͪ
͇ͽ͹ͷͪ͸ͼ͵;
ͳͷͺͰͻͳΒ;
͌ΒͰͯ͸͹
ͽͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͯͳ
͵͹ͻͳ΃ΕͰ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͳ

͵ͪ͹
ͬ͹Β͸Ͱ
ͫͪͲͰ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹Β͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͬͰ͸΁ͳΒͪ
;
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶ
͸͹ͷ
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹ͷ
ͅͰͯͳͽͰͻͪ͸;
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͸ͪ
Β;ͱ͸͹ͷ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;



͇
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͬͳΌͰΔ;
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
;
97*
ͳ
97**
ͬͰ͵;
͵͹͸ͼ;Ͷͽ͹ͬͪͽͳ
.JHVFM
"O
HFM
EF
#VOFT
*CBSSB
&M
.VOEP
#BMDÃOJDP
Z
TV
3FDFQDJÓO
FO
MB
$VMUVSB
FTQBÒPMB
EFM
4JHMP

97*
;
&TQBÒB
Z
MB
DVMUVSB
IJTQÃOJDB
FO
FM
TVSFTUF

FVSPQFP
PQ
DJU

 ͊Ͷ͹ͫ͹ͯͪ͸
͊
͈ͪΒ͹ͬͳΕ

͌
ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;
ͼ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸ͳͷ
ͭͰ͹ͼͽͻͪͽͰ΃͵ͳͷ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͳͷͪ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͰ

Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂ͳͽͳ
ͯͪ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͳͷͪͶͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͬͰ͸΁ͳ͹͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ

ͪͷͫͳ΁ͳΒͰ
;
ͽ͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
ͅͰͯͳͽͰͻͪ͸ͪ
͹ͼͳͷ
ͯͪ
ͼͺͻͰ΂ͳ
͹ͺͪͼ͸͹ͼͽ
͹ͯ
ͷ;
ͼͶͳͷͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
͸ͪΒͰͲͯͳ
͸ͪ
ͳͽͪͶͳΒͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͼͰͬͰͻ͸͹ͪͿͻͳ΂͵Ͱ
͹ͫͪͶͰ
͵ͪ͹

ͳ
ͯͪ
ͳͲ
ͯͳ͸ͪͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
͹ͫͪͬͰͲͪ
ͺ͹ͷ͹ͭ͸Ͱ
͎ͪͫͼͫ;ͻͭ͹ͬ΁ͳͷͪ
;
͹ͯͫͻͪ͸ͳ

ͺ͹ͼͰͯͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͰͬͰͻ;
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
;
ͪͅΌͪͻͼ͵͹Β
͌ͺͻͪͬ͹
ͳͲ
ͽ͹ͭ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ

ͳͷͪͷ͹
ͳ
ͺͻͬͪ
ͪ;ͽͰ͸ͽͳ΂͸ͪ
ͯ͹͵;ͷͰ͸ͽͪ
͹
ͫ͹ͻͪͬ͵;
͑ͺͪ͸ͪ΁ͪ
͸ͪ
͸ͪ΃ͳͷ

ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
͈ͻͬͳ
ͽͻͪͭ͹ͬͳ
;ͽͳ΁ͪΒͪ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
Εͳ
;
97***
ͬͰ͵;
͇
ͽ͹ͷ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒ;
͸ͪͷ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸
ͺͶ͹΂ͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽͪ
͸ͪ
;ͽͬͻΌͰΔ;
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͫ;ͯͳͷͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯͬ͹ͻ΁ͪ
͹ͯ

ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͽͪͯͪ΃ΔͰͭ
ͪͷͫͪͼͪͯ͹ͻͪ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
;
ͪͅΌͪͻͼ͵͹Β
͸ͪ
͵͹Β͹Β
ͺͳ΃Ͱ

t*O
.FNPSJBN

͇ͬ;ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;΃Ͷ͹

΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹Β͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;

;΂Ͱͼͽͬ͹ͬͪͶͳ
;
͹ͼͶ͹ͫͪΌͪΔ;
̹;ͯͳͷͪi
̺ͪͱ͸͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͼͰ

;
ͽ͹Β
͸ͪͷͰͻͳ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͬ͹Β͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͼ;͵͹ͫͳͶͳ
ͼͪ
͋;ͻ΁ͳͷͪ
͵͹ͯ
ͬ͹Βͬ͹Όͪ͸
ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͊Ͱ͸ͽͰ
͇ͯ
ͽͪͯͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
͹ͯ
ͪ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͽ;ͻͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
;

͵͹ͷͰ
ͼ;
;΂Ͱͼͽͬ͹ͬͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͬ͹Β͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͳͲ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺͪ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
͸ͪͻͰͯ͸ͪ
ͽͻͳ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
͸Ͱ
ͻͪͼͺ͹ͶͪͱͰͷ͹
ͯ͹͵;ͷͰ͸ͽͳͷͪ
͹
ͫͳͽ͸ͳΒͰͷ
;ͽͳ΁ͪΒ;
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͪ

ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͰ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
ͺͪ
ͼͰ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͽ͹ͭͪ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂ͳͽͳ
ͯͪ
͹͸
͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͳ

ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͪ͹
̓͹͸ͪ΂͸͹
ͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬ͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
;
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵͹Β
ͼͺ͹Γ͸͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΁ͳ
ͯ͹
͸Ͱ͵ͶͰ
Βͪ΂ͪ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͼ
͹ͫͲͳͻ͹ͷ
͸ͪ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁;
ͯͪ
ͼ;
͸ͰͲͪͬͳͼ͸Ͱ

ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
ͺ͹΂ͰͶͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹Ͳͳ΁ͳ͹͸ͳͻͪΒ;
;
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ
ͷͰΌ;͸ͪ
ͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ
͵͹͸ͽͰ͵ͼͽ
ͯͰͿͳ͸ͳ΃;Εͳ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ
͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳ͹ͻͳͽͰͽͰ
͆ͪͳͷͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͰ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳ
Ͳͪͺͳͼͳ
ͳ
ͳͲͬͰ΃ͽͪΒͳ

͹
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β;
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͼ͵ͳ΀
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
ͪͯͅͻͳͯͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͰ
ͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁ͪ
;
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸;
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
̸ͽͳ͸ͳ
͋ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

Ͳͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸͹
ͺͻͳͲ͸ͪͶͪ
̻ͻ΂͵;
ͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳͷͰ͸͹ͬͪ͸
ΒͰ
ͳ
ΔͰ͸
ͺͻͬͳ

͹ͽͺͻͪͬ͸ͳ͵
ͺ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͪ

;
ͽ͹Β
ͲͰͷΓͳ
͑ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
ͳ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
͸Ͱ͹ͺ΀͹ͯ͸͹

ΒͰ
;͵ͪͲͪͽͳ
͸ͪ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁;
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͪͬͪ

;
͋;ͻͼ͵͹Β
ͳ
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳͶͪ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳΒ;
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͼ͵;
ͺ͹
Ͷͳͽͳ͵;
;
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺͪͶͪ
͹ͽͬͪͻͪΔ;
͸͹ͬͳ΀
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽ



+PBRVÎO
1ÊSF[
(ÓNF[
&M
QBQFM
EF
&TQBÒB
FO
FM
QSPDFTP
EF
QB[
FO
MB
FY:VHPTMB
WJB
;
-PT
OVFWPT
&TUBEPT
EF
MB
BOUJHVB
:VHPTMBWJB
&ET
+PTÊ
(JSÓO
J
4MPCPEBO
1BKPWJǀ

6OJWFSTJEBE
EF
0WJFEP
0WJFEP




̺Ͱ͹ͷͪ
ͯ͹ͫͻ;
ͼͽ;ͯͳΒ;
͹
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͼ͵ͳͷ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳͷͪ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ

̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
͸ͪͺͳͼͪ͹
ΒͰ
.JHVFM
"OHFM
0DIPB
#SVO
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
;
&TQBÒB
Z
MB
$VMUV
SB
)JTQÃOJDB
FO
FM
4VSFTUF
EF
&VSPQB
&E%JSFDDJÓO
(FOFSBM
EF
3FMBDJPOFT
$VMUVSBMFT
Z

$JFOUÎêDBT.JOJTUFSJP EF "TVOUPT &YUFSJPSFT EF &TQBÒB
PQ
DJU
m
 ͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
;
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ 

ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͪͬͪ
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͻ;ͷ;͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻͳ͸΁

̓ͪͻ͹Ͷ
͎͹Ͱ͸΁͹ͶͰͻ͸
;ͺ;ͽͳ͹
Ͳͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸ͳ
Ͳͪ΀ͽͰͬ
ͪͯͅͻͳͯ;
ͯͪ
ͺͻͳͲ͸ͪ
ΔͰ
ͭ͹ͬ;
ͯͻͱͪͬ;
͌͵ͻͪͽ͵͹
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͲ͸ͪͶͪ
͉;ͷ;͸ͳΒ;

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ

͸ͪͯͪΓͰ
ΕͰ
ΔͰ͸
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ͵
;
̹;͵;ͻͰ΃ͽ;
;ΒͰͯ͸͹
ͫͳͽͳ

͸ͪͯͶͰͱͪ͸
ͳ
Ͳͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒ;
ͳ
̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵;
͈͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͪ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ

ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͻͪͽ͹ͬͪ
ͺͻ͹ͭͶͪͼͳͶͪ
͸Ͱ;ͽͻͪͶ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
ͽͰ͵

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;
̹Ͱ
͹ͭͻͪͯ
ͺ͹ͼͶͪͶͪ
ͼͬ͹ͭ
͹ͽͺͻͪͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
;ͫͻͲ͹
ͺͻͰͷͰ΃ͽͰ͸
;

͊͹ͿͳΒ;
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͻͪͽ͸ͳ΀
ͯͰΒͼͽͪͬͪ
̓͹͸ͪ΂͸͹
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸ͪ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ

ͪͬͭ;ͼͽͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
Ͳͬͪ
͸ͳ΂͸͹
ͺͻͳͲ͸ͪͶͪ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸;
͊ͻͫͪ
͎ͻͬͪͽͪ
ͳ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͪ΁ͪ
ͳ
;
ͺ͹ͽͺ;
͸͹ͼͽͳ
͸͹ͻͷͪͶͳͲ͹ͬͪͶͪ
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
ͼ
͸ͪ΃͹ͷ
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͷ
͌
ͳͼͽ͹
ͻͳΒͳ
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͼ͵ͳ΀
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
ͯͬͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͬͪͱ͸͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ

ͯͪ
ΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸ͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
ͺͻͳͲ͸ͪͶͪ
͸͹ͬ;
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵;

ͯͻͱͪͬ;
͸ͪ
΂ͰͶ;
ͼͪ
ͭͰ͸ͰͻͪͶͳͼͳͷ;ͼ͹ͷ
͍ͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵͹ͷ
͍ͻͪ͸͵͹ͷ
̹ͪΒͪͷ͹͸
ͽͰ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹
ͳͲͫͳΒͪΔ;
̽ͻ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͳ
ͻͪͼͺͪͯͪ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸Ͱ

͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͪ
͹ͯͶ;΂ͳͶͪ
ͯͪ
Ͳͪͽͬ͹ͻͳ
ͪͷͫͪͼͪͯ;
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
ͪͶͳ

ͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͽͬ͹ͻͳ
;
̀ͪͭͻͰͫ;
ͭͯͰ
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹͵Ͷͪͷ͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
͎͆̽
̻Ͱ͸ͰͻͪͶ͸͹
ͺ͹ͼͷͪͽͻͪ͸͹
ͯ͹
ͺͪͯͪ
̹ͰͻͶͳ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
Ͳͳͯͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳ
͑ͺͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͪ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͳ
͉;ͼͳΒ͹ͷ
ͫͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ

͸ͰͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ͸ͳ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ΀ͶͪͯͳͶͪ
ͳ
ͻͰͯ;͵͹ͬͪͶͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
ͼͪ
͹ͬͳͷ
ͯͰ
Ͷ͹ͷ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͫͰͯͰ
ͼ͹ͬΒͰͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͻͰͬ͹Ͷ;΁ͳΒͰ
;
͉;ͼͳΒͳ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

ͪͶͳ
ͳ
Ϳͻͪ͸͵ͳͲͷͪ
;
ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͻͪͽ;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
ͳͲͻͪͲͳͽͰ
ͪ͸
ͽͳ͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
͹ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
͹͸Ͱͷ͹ͭ;ΕͳͶͪ
ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͪͬͪΔͰ

͸͹ͬ͹;ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬΓͰ͸ͳͷ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͻͰͱͳͷͳͷͪ
;
ͽ͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ

͋Ͱ͵
;
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔ͹Β
ͿͪͲͳ
Ϳͻͪ͸͵ͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
ͯ͹΃Ͷ͹
ΒͰ
ͯ͹
ͼ͵ͻ͹ͷ
͸͹ͭ
ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͪͬͪΔͪ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͳ
;

ͽ͹ͷ
͵͹͸ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
ͼͪ
ͫͳͬ΃͹ͷ
͍͉͊͠
ͳ
ͳ͸ͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ͸͹
͊ͻͫͳΒ͹ͷ
͇ͬ;
΂ͳΔͰ
͸ͳ΁;
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͽ;ͷͪ΂ͳͽͳ
;
ͼ͵Ͷ͹ͺ;
͸ͪͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͪ
Ϳͻͪ͸͵ͳͲͷͪ
ͯͪ
͹ͫͰͲͫͰͯͳ

΃ͽ͹
΃ͳͻͰ
ͷͰΌ;͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹
ͺͻͳͲ͸ͪΔͰ
͆ͪͼ;ͺͻ͹ͽ
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ͼͺ͹Γ͸ͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵ͪ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
;
ͺ͹ͼͽ
Ϳͻͪ͸͵ͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
;
ͺ͹ͼͽ΀Ͷͪͯ͸͹ͻͪͽ͹ͬͼ͵͹ͷ
ͯ͹ͱͳ
ͬͰͶͪ
ΒͰ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸Ͱ
ͻͰͿ͹ͻͷͰ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͹ͷ͹ͭ;ΕͳͶ͹
ͺ͹ͼͽͰͺͰ͸͹
ͳ
ͰͿͳ͵ͪͼ͸͹

ͺͻͳͶͪͭ͹ΌͪͬͪΔͰ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ
ͪͯͅͻͳͯͪ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪͷͪ
;
ͼͬͰͽ;
;Ͳ
ͺͪͻͪͶͰͶ͸͹

ͯͰͿͳ͸ͳͼͪΔͰ
͸͹ͬͳ΀
ͼͺ͹Γ͸͹ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͳ͹ͻͳͽͰͽͪ
̀ͫ͹ͭ
ͽ͹ͭͪ
ͺ͹
ͻͰͯ
ͬͰΕ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͳ͹ͻͳͽͰͽͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͽ͹
̈́ͪͽͳ͸ͼ͵ͪ
̸ͷͰ
ͻͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͅͰͯͳͽͰͻͪ͸
ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͪͭͅͻͰͫͪ
;
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼ;
ͯͳͬͰͻͼͳͿͳ
͵ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͼͺ͹Γ͸͹ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͼͽͻͪͽͰͭͳΒͰ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͼͰ
;͹΂ͳͽͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΁ͳ

ΔͰ͸Ͱ
ͷ;͸ͯͳͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
;͵Γ;΂ͳͬͪΔͰ
͹ͬͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
;
ͻͰ΃ͪͬͪΔͰ

͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͪ
͸ͪ͵͹͸
ͯ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
ͷͰΌ;͸ͪͻ͹ͯ
 ͊Ͷ͹ͫ͹ͯͪ͸
͊
͈ͪΒ͹ͬͳΕ

͸Ͱ
ͳͲ͹Ͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͌
ͽ͹ͷ
͵͹͸ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
ͬͪͱ͸͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͯ͹΃Ͷ͹
ͳ

ͯ͹
ͯͪΓͰͭ
Βͪ΂ͪΔͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͫͳͬ΃ͳͷ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͳ΂
͵ͳͷ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪͷͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
͹ͫͻ͸;ͽ͹
̹ͳͬ΃Ͱ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͹ͽ͵ͻͳͶͰ

ͼ;
ΒͰͯ͸;
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹
͸͹ͬ;
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒ;
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ
ͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ͸;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ

ͼͽͪͫͳͶ͸;
ͳ
ͯͰͷ͹͵ͻͪͽͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸;
͌͵ͻͪͽ͵͹

΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬͪ
;
ͯ͹ͷͰ͸;
ͯͰͷ͹͵ͻͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͽͻͪ͸Ͳͳ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͯͰ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͸ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;
ͷ͹ͯͰͶͪ
ͼͳͼͽͰͷͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹͸͹ͷ͸ͳ΀
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
ͫͳ
Ͷͪ
ͼ;
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͪͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͪ
Ͳͪ
͸͹ͬͰ
ͬͶͪͼͽͳ
;
ͽͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ

́͸ͽͰ͸Ͳͳͬ͸͹ͷ
ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͪͬͪΔ;
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͯ͹
ͺͻͳ͸ͰͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
ΔͰ͸ͪ
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͳΒͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲͪͶͪ
ͬͳͼ͹͵ͳ
ͼͽͰ
ͺͰ͸
ͺͻ͹ͿͰͼͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͺͻͪͭͷͪͽͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
;
ͼͽͻͪͽͰͭͳΒͳ
΃ͽ͹
ͫ͹ΓͰͭ

;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͪ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͽͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͶͪ
ͫͳͬ΃ͳ΀
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͯͻͱͪ
ͬͪ
͑ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͽͳ΂Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰͷ͹
͵͹͸ͼͽͪͽ͹ͬͪͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͪ
͹ͲͫͳΓ
͸͹
ͳ
ͼͳͼͽͰͷͪͽͳ΂͸͹
ͺ͹ͼͬͰͽͳͶͪ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷ;
ͻͪͼͺͪͯͪ
ͫͳͬ΃Ͱ
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸
ͼ͵Ͱ
ͿͰͯͰͻͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
ͺͻͳͲ͸ͪͬͪΔͪ
͸ͰͲͪͬͳͼ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͼ;ͬͰͻͰ͸ͳͽͰͽͪ

͸͹ͬͳ΀
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͼͬͳͷ
͸Ͱͭͪͽͳͬ͸ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯͳ΁ͪͷͪ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼͪ

ͺ͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
;
΁ͰͶͳ͸ͳ
͈͹ͼͽͰͺͰ͸͹
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͭͻͰͼͳͬ͸͹
ͪ͸ͭͪͱ͹ͬͪΔͰ
̓ͻͪΓͰ
ͬͳ͸Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
΂Ͷͪ͸ͪ
̾̀̾͌
ͳ
̸͇͆͋
;
ͺͻ͹͸ͪͶͪͱͰΔ;
ͻͰ΃ͰΔͪ
Ͳͪ
͹ͬ;
͵ͻͳͲ;

;ͽͳ΂;
ͯͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͫͳͬ΃ͪ
͍͉͊͠
ͺͪ
ͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪ͸;
ΒͰͯͪ͸

͹ͯ
ͺͻͳ͹ͻͳͽͰͽͪ
ΔͰ͸Ͱ
ͼͺ͹Γ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
Βͪͬ͸͹ͭ
ͷΔͰΔͪ
͑ͺͪ
͸ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͷͪͶͪ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸;
;Ͷ͹ͭ;
;
ͺͻ͹͸ͪͶͪͱͰΔ;
ͷͳͻͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͬͳͷ

ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
ͳ
;΂Ͱͼͽͬ͹ͬͪͶͪ
;
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲͳͻͪΔ;
ͼͬͳ΀
ͷͳͻ͹ͬ͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸ͳ΁ͳΒͪ
ͽͳͬͪ
͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
ͫͳͬ΃Ͱ
͍͉͊͠
̀ͫ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
ͽ͹ͭͪ
ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯ͸͹
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ

Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂ͳͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵ͪ
͵ͻͳͲͪ
ͳ
ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͻͪͽ͹ͬͳ
;
ͽ͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;

̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͶͳ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͹
͸ͪ΃͹Β
ͲͰͷΓͳ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ

ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
;ͽͳ΁ͪͶ͹
͸ͪ
ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͰ
͸Ͱͭͪͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͯ͹ΘͫͰ
͹
Δ͹Β

͌͵ͻͪͽ͵͹
ͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬ͹
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͪ
͸ͪ΃ͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
Ͳ͸ͪͽ͸͹
ΒͰ

͹Βͪ΂ͪ͸͹
ͳ
ͯͳͬͰͻͼͳͿͳ͵͹ͬͪ͸͹
;
ͺͻͬ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
ͯͰͬͰͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹
ͺͻͬͳ
ͺ;ͽ
;
ͯ;ͭ͹Β
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
͹ͬͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸ͪ

͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͪ
;ͼͺͰͬͪ
ͯͪ
͹ͼͽͬͪͻͳ
ͳ
ͬ͹Β͸͹
ͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬ͹
;
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶ͸͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;

̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
;
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
̹͹ͼ͸ͳ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶ͹
ͼͰ
͹͵͹


΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹Β͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͪ
ͬ͹Β͸ͪ
ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͪ
;
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͳ

ͯ͹͵
ͼͰ

͸ͪ
̓͹ͼ͹ͬ;
ͽͻͰ͸;ͽ͸͹
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
͹͵͹

ͬ͹Β͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͳͲ
ͽͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ



͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
ͳ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͪ

͈͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ
͸ͪ΃ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳ΂ͪͻͳ
;ͼͺͰͶͳ
ͼ;
ͯͪ
ͺͻ͹͸ͪΌ;
ͳ
͹ͺͳ΃;

͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬͰ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
ͬͰͲͪ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
͵͹͸ͽͪ͵
ͽͰ
ͳ
ͽ͹
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
ͬͶͪͯͪͬͳ͸Ͱ
̓ͪͻͶͪ
7
$BSMP
7

͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ

 ͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
;
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ 

͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͪ
͸ͪͼͽ͹ΒͪͶͪ
ͯͪ
ͫ;ͯͰ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͪ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽ͸ͳ΁ͪͺͻͰͯͬ͹ͯ͸ͳ΁ͪ

΀ͻͳ΃Εͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
͆ͪͳͷͰ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͼ͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳͶͪ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
͸ͪͺͪͯͰ

͸ͪ
ͬͰ͸Ͱ΁ͳΒͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ
;ͽͬͻΌͰΔͪ
;
̽ͪͶͷͪ΁ͳΒͳ
ͳ
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
̓ͻͿ

ͯͪ
ͺͻͳͬ͹Ͷͳ

̺Ͱ͸Ͱ΁ͳΒ;
ͯͪ
ͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺͳ
͊ͬͰͽ͹Β
ͪͶͳΒͪ͸ͼͳ
ͳ
͹͸ͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͽͪΒ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͳ͸ͯͳ
ͻͰ͵ͽ͸͹
͹Βͪ΂ͪͶͪ
ͳ
ͼͬ͹Β
;ͽͳ΁ͪΒ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
͌
ͽ͹ͷ
͵͹͸ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
ͼͰ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ

ͯͪ
ΒͰ
̹͹ͱͳͯͪͻ
̺;͵͹ͬͳΕ
ͬͰ͸Ͱ΁ͳΒͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͺͶͰͷͳΕ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ
͵ͪ͹
%JPOJTJP

EF
MB
7FDIJB

ͺ͹ͼͰͯ͹ͬͪ͹
ͼͻͺͼ͵;
΃ͽͪͷͺͪͻͳΒ;
;
̺Ͱ͸Ͱ΁ͳΒͳ
ͫͳ͹
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽ
͸ͳ͵
ͭͻ΂͵Ͱ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
;
ͽ͹ͷ
ͭͻͪͯ;
ͺ͹ͯͻͱͪͬͪ͹
ͳͯͰΒ;
ͯͪ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͼ;ͬͰ
ͻͰ͸
ͫ;ͯͰ
ͬͻ΀͹ͬ͸ͳ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽ͸ͳ͵
΀ͻͳ΃Εͪ͸ͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
ͺ͹ͫ;͸ͳ

ͺͻ͹ͽͳͬ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͬͶͪͯͪͬͳ͸Ͱ
;Ͳ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵;
ͺ͹ͷ͹Ε
̽͹ͯͪͽ͸͹
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽͪ͸

ͷ͹ͷͰ͸ͪͽ
;
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͪͯͪ΃Δͳ

ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
͆͹ͬͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
΁ͻ͸͹ͭ͹ͻͼ͵ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ
͆͹ͬͳ

͹ͼ͸͹ͬͪ͸


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͫͳ͹
ͺ͹ͯ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͬͶͪ΃Ε;
͹ͯ

ͯ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͯ͹͵
ͼ;

͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
̽;ͫͻ͹ͬͪ΂͵Ͱ
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͳ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
͵ͻ;͸Ͱ
ͫͳͶͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹

ͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ͸ͳΒͳ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶ;ͱͳͶͳ
̽;ͫͻ͹ͬ͸ͳ͵;
ͯͪ
ͼͷͪΔͳ
ͺͻͳͽͳͼͪ͵
̺Ͱ͸Ͱ΁ͳΒͰ

ͳ
͹ͽ͹ͷͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
͈͹ͻͽͰ
ͪ
͑ͺͪ͸΁ͳͷͪ
ͯͪ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
̽;ͫͻ͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͹ͽ͵ͻͳΒ;
;͸;
ͽͻͪ΃Δ͹ͼͽ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
͌͵ͻͪͽ͵͹
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
9*9
ͳ
ͺͻͬͰ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ
͸Ͱ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͫͳͶͳ
ͼ;
͸ͪ
ͯ͹ͼͽͪ
͸ͳͼ͵͹ͷ
͸ͳͬ͹;
ͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸

͸ͳ͵ͪͯͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͺͻͳ͹ͻͳͽͰͽ
Ͳͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸Ͱ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͺ͹Γ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵Ͱ

ͳͶͳ
΃ͳͻͳ΀
͸ͪ;΂͸ͳ΀
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
͵ͻ;ͭ͹ͬͪ
͇ͬͪ
͵͹͸ͼͽͪͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͸ͪͷ

͹ͽ͵ͻͳͬͪ
;Ͳͻ͹͵
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
͵͹ΒͰͭ
͹ͬͪΒ
ͯͰ͹
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͳ
͸ͪ΃ͪ
ͲͰͷΓͪ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͳ
ͺͻͰͯͷͰͽ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ΁ͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͺͻͳͺͻͰ
ͷͪΔͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
΃ͽͪͷͺͪΔͪ
ͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵ͳ΀
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
;
ͽ͹Β
ͲͰͷΓͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͫͳ

΃ͳͻ͹Β
΂ͳͽͪͶͪ΂͵͹Β
ͺ;ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
ͳ
Γ;ͯͳͷͪ
ͱͰΓ͸ͳ΀
͸͹ͬͳ΀
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΔͪ
ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹
ͬͪΔͪ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͺͻ;ͱͳͶͳ
ͳ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
ͯͪ
͵͹ͷͺͶͰ
ͽͳͻͪΒ;
ͼͬ͹Βͪ
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΔͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬͳ
͹ͻͳͭͳ͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͪͺͰͻ
΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͰ
͸ͪ΃Ͱͭ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ΔͰ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ
͵ͪ
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳͽͯ
͈ͻͳ
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
͸ͪͭͶͪͼͳͽͳ
ͯͪ

ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͳ
ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͬͪͱ͸Ͱ
ͯ͹͵;ͷͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳ͹͸Ͱ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͰ

͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͯͪ
ͺͻ;ͱͪΒ;
ͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂͸Ͱ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ
΁ͳΒͰ
Ͳͪ
ͻͰͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒ;
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͳ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͽ͹ͭͪ
΃ͽ͹
;
ͫͰͯͰ
͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
͸ͪͳͶͪͲͳͷ͹
͸ͪ
͵͹ͷͺͪͻͪͽͳͬ͸;
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲ;
ͷͰ͸ͽͪͶͳͽͰ
ͽͪ
ͯͪͽ͹ͭ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ

̓͹ͷͺͪͻͪͽͳͬ͸ͳ
ͷͰͽ͹ͯ
ͼͰ
;͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͰ͸͹

͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳ͹
ͼ
΁ͳΓͰͷ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͯͪͽ͹ͭ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭͰ͹Ͱ
ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬͳ
ͺ͹ͻͰΌͰΔͪ
ͼͪ
ͼ͹ͺͼͽͬͰ͸ͳͷ


̀ͪ
͹ͺ΃ͳͻ͸ͳΒ;
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒ;
͹
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳͷͪ
ͽ͹ͭ
ͺͰͻͳ͹
ͯͪ
͵͹͸ͼ;Ͷͽ͹ͬͪͽͳ
͆ͳ͵͹Ͷͪ
͊ͪͷͪͻΘͳΕ
-B
&TQBÒB
Z
FM
4VSFTUF
&VSPQFP
;
&TQBÒB
Z
MB

DVMUVSB
IJTQÃOJDB
FO
FM
TVSFTUF

FVSPQFP
PQ
DJU
m
 ͊Ͷ͹ͫ͹ͯͪ͸
͊
͈ͪΒ͹ͬͳΕ

̓ͪͯͪ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͷ͹
͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͳͷͪ
ͳͲͬͰ΃ͽͪΒͳͷͪ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͷ
͵ͪͻ

ͽͪͷͪ
΁ͻͽͰͱͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͳͶ;ͼͽͻͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
ͷ͹ͻͪͷ͹
ͼͰ

ͺͻͳͼͰͽͳͽͳ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͯ;ͭͰ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳΒͰ
;
ͽ͹Β
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͽ͹
ͺ͹΂Ͱͬ΃ͳ
͹ͯ

͹ͽ͵ͻͳΕͪ
̸ͷͰͻͳ͵Ͱ
͈ͻͳ
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
͸ͪͭͶͪ΃ͪͬͪͷ͹
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ

΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͼ;ͯ͸͹
;ͽͳ΁ͪͶͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͯͻͰΌͳͬͪΔͰ

ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͷ͹ͻͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳ
͵͹͸ͽͳ͸Ͱ͸ͽͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽͰͬͪ
;
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
͵͹
Βͳ
ͼ;
͑ͺͪ͸΁ͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͬ΃ͳ
͹ͯ
͵ͻͪΒͪ
97
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͽͪ͵͹
;ͼͺͰ΃͸͹
͹ͽ͵ͻͳͬͪͶͳ
ͳ

͹ͼͬͪΒͪͶͳ
͆ͪΒͫ͹Γͳ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͽͰ
ͬͻͼͽͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
ͼͰ
;
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳΒͳ΀
ͪͻ΀ͳͬͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͬͰͽ;
΂;ͬͰ͸ͳ
t"SDIJWP
(FOFSBM
EF
*OEJBTi
ͼͪ

ͼͰͯͳ΃ͽͰͷ
;
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͭͻͪͯ;
͊ͰͬͳΓͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬͪ͸

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͈ͻͰͷͪ
ͺͻ͹ͿͰͼ͹ͻ;
͍ͻͪ͸ͼͳͼ͵;
̺Ͱͳͭͳ
'SBODJTDP
7FJHB

ͼͪ
̸;ͽ͹
͸͹ͷ͸͹ͭ
;͸ͳͬͰͻͲͳͽͰͽͪ
ͳͲ
̹ͪͻ΁ͰͶ͹͸Ͱ
;
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͳ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͪ
ͳ

ͻͪͲ͸͹ͬͻͼ͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸ͪ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͪ
΂ͳΒͳ
ͼ;
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͳ
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͼͽͻͪ͸
΁ͳ
ͼ
͹ͫͲͳͻ͹ͷ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͪ
ͲͰͷΓͪ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͬ΃ͳ
͹ͯ
97***
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͺͻͰͯͷͰͽ

͸ͪͭͶͪ΃Ͱ͸͹ͭ
ͳ
ͬͳ΃ͰͼͶ͹Β͸͹ͭ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ
΂;ͬͰ͸ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ΁ͪ
ͼͪ
ͼͰ
ͬͰͻͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
͢ͳ΀
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷͪͶͪ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽ
ΒͰͲͳ͵

ͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͼͽͬ͹
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸͹ͼͽ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
;
;͸;ͽͻͪ΃Δ͹ͼͽͳ
́ͫͰͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹
Ͷ;͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ;ͻͪ
ͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳ
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹
͹΂;ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ
͸ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͳ
;ͽͬͻΌͰΔͪ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
Ϳ͹Ͷ͵Ͷ͹ͻ
ͳ

ͭͪͼͽͻ͹͸͹ͷͳΒͪ

ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͬͳ͸΁ͳΒͪ
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
̸͸ͯͪͶ;ͲͳΒͰ
ͳ
ΔͰ͸ͳ

ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
͊ͰͬͳΓͪ
̓͹ͻͯ͹ͫͪ
ͪͅͶͪͭͪ
ͳ
̓ͪͯͳͲ

;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰ
ͳ
͹ͺͳͼͳͬͪ
ΔͰ
ͽͪͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͰΕͰ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͰ
ͳͽͯ

͈ͻ͹ͿͰͼ͹ͻ
̺Ͱͳͭͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͫΒͪͬͳ͹
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸;
͵͹ͷͺͪͻͪͽͳͬ͸;
ͼͽ;
ͯͳΒ;
͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͳͷͪ
ͺ͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͳ
́ͫͰͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹Ͷ;͹ͼͽͻͬ;
ͺ͹ͯ

͸ͪͲͳͬ͹ͷ
&O
MPT
DPOêOFT
͆ͪ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ

͌
ͽ͹ͷ
ͻͪͯ;
ͳͲ͸͹ͼͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͳͲ

Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬͳ΀
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
͹
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
͋;ͻͼ͵͹Β
ͳ
͊ͻ
ͫͳΒͳ
́Ͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͰͻͼͺͰ͵ͽͳͬͰ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬͪ
ΔͰͭ͹
ͬͪ
ͺ͹ͶͪͲ͸ͪ
΀ͳͺ͹ͽͰͲͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
Ͳͪͼ͸ͳͬͪ
͸ͪ
ͽͬͻͯΔͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ
͹ͯ
ͺ͹
Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ΀
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ΁ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͺͻ͹͵ͼͽͪͻͳͶͳ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͽ͹ͭ

ͯ͹ͫͪ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪͶͳ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸͹ͷ
͋;ͻͼ͵͹ͷ
̹Ͷͳͼ͵ͳͷ
́ͼͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͳ
͊Ͱ
ͬͰͻ͸͹ͷ
̸Ϳͻͳ͵͹ͷ
͈ͻͳ
ͽ͹ͷͰ
͸ͪͭͶͪ΃ͪͬͪ
ͼͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͬ΃ͳ
͹ͯ

ͭ͹
ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͪ
ͺ͹͸͹ͬ͹
͹ͽ͵ͻͳͶͪ
ͅͰͯͳͽͰͻͪ͸
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͯͬͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͸ͪͶͪ

Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵Ͱ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͼͪ
ͷ;ͼͶͳͷͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͼͬͰͽ͹ͷ
ͳ
΁ͳͬͳͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ

ͳ΃Ͷͪ
;ͺͻͪͬ͹
ͺͻͰ͵͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ
́ͫͰͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹Ͷ;͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
͈;ͽ͹ͺͳ
ͼ΁ͳ
ͼ;
ͺ͹΂ͰͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͳ΀
͹ͽ͵ͻͳͬͪΒ;
ͺ͹ͼͰΕ;Β;
ͳͼͽͻͪͱ;Β;
ͳ
ͯͪ
͹ͺͳͼ;Β;
Δͳ
΀͹ͬͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͳ
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͰ


'SBODJTDP
7FJHB
3PESÎHVF[
&O
MPT
$POêOFT $SÓOJDBT
EF
7JBKFT
QPS
MBT

1FOÎOTVMBT
#BMDÃOJDB
F
*CÊSJDB
EVSBOUF
FM
1FSÎPEP
3PNÃOUJDP
;
&TQBÒB
Z
MB
DVMUVSB

IJTQÃOJDB
FO
FM
TVSFTUF

FVSPQFP
PQ
DJU
m
 ͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
;
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ 

͑ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸͹Β
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͳ
ͳ
;͹ͺ
΃ͽͰ
;
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
΀ͻ͹͸ͳ͵ͪͷͪ
ͳ
Ͳͪͺͳͼͳͷͪ
ͳͲ
ͽ͹ͭ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͼͰ

;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͼͽͪͬ
ͬͰΕͳ͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺΓͪ͸ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͳͼͽ͹͵
ͳ
Β;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹͵
͸ͪ΃Ͱͭ

͵͹͸ͽͳ͸Ͱ͸ͽͪ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪͬͪͶͳ
͵ͪ͹
͸Ͱͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͳͲͯͳͿͰͻͰ͸΁ͳͻͪ͸;
͵;Ͷ
ͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵;
΁ͰͶͳ͸;
͵͹Βͪ
ͺ͹΂ͳΔͰ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
͋͹
͸Ͱͯͬ͹ͼͷͳͼͶͰ
͸͹
;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
͸ͪ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁;
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
m
;Ͳ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽͪ͵
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
m
ͫͳ͹
ͺ͹ͳ
ͼͽ͹ͬͰΕͰ͸
ͼͪ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵ͳͷ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͫͪ΃ͽͳ͸͹ͷ
͌
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ

ͽ͹ͭ
ͯ͹ͫͪ
Βͪ΂ͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͪ
΀ͰͶͰ͸ͼ͵;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ;
ͳ
;
ͽ͹ͷ
͵͹͸ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;

Ͳͪ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͰ
;
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ
97***
ͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
̻ͻ΂͵ͪ
ͺ͹
ͼͽͪΒͰ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͷͰͽ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ΀
ͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͻͪͲ͸͹Ͷͳ
͵͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹ͿͳͶͪ
;͵Γ;΂;Β;Εͳ
ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵ͰͻͰ
͌͵ͻͪͽ͵͹
̻ͻ΂͵ͪ
ͼͰ
ͳͲͯͬͪΒͪ
ͳͲ

ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸͹
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹ͭ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͹Ͷ͹΃͵͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
ͳ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪͬͪ
ͼͬ͹Β;

ͺ;͸;
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸;
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸;
Ͱͷͪ͸΁ͳͺͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͽͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻ
ͳ͸ͽͰ
ͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ΀
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͳ΀
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ΁ͪ
͑ͽ͹
ͼͰ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͿͰͼ͹ͻ
̺Ͱͳͭͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
͸ͪ
͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹΁ͰΔͳͬͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ
͵͹Βͳ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͰ
͸ͪ΃Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
;
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹Ͱ
ͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͳ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͳ͸ͽͰͶͰ͵ͽ;ͪͶ͸ͳͷ
͵ͻ;ͭ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͳͷͪ
΂;ͬͰ͸͹
ͯͰ
Ͷ͹
̸ͶͿ͹͸ͼͪ
ͯͰ
̈́ͪͷͪͻͽͳ͸ͪ
t4PVWFOJST
JNQSFTTJPOT
QFOTÊFT
FU
QBZTB



1FESP
#ÃEFOBT
EF
MB
1FÒB
ͳͲ
ͺͻͰͼͽͳͱ͸͹ͭ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
̺ͳͼ͹͵͹ͭ
ͼͪͬͰͽͪ
Ͳͪ
͸ͪ;΂
͸ͪ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͼͪ
ͼͰͯͳ΃ͽͰͷ
;
ͪͯͅͻͳͯ;
͹ͫΒͪͬͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͻͪͯ
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͲͳͬ͹ͷ
&M
1SPHSBNB

3FWPMVDJPOBSJP
EFM
1PFNB
5VSJPT
;
͵͹ͷͰ
;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
͸ͪ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁;
ͯͪ
ͼ;
Ͳͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;
͹ͯ

͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
;
ͽͲͬ
j͆͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͼͬͰͽ;v
͸ͪͺͻͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͳͯͰΒͰ
͍ͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵Ͱ
ͻͰͬ͹Ͷ;΁ͳΒͰ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
Ͷͪ͵
΃Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͯͳͻͪͶͰ
;
ͼͬͰͼͽ
ͽͪͷ͹΃Δͳ΀
ͳ͸ͽͰͶͰ͵ͽ;ͪͶͪ΁ͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͽͰ΂ͪ
ͺ͹͵ͻͰͽͪ
Ͳͪ
͸ͰͲͪͬͳ
ͼ͸͹ͼͽ
̈́ͪͽͳ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
̸ͷͰͻͳ͵Ͱ
͌
̈́ͪͽͳ͸ͼ͵͹Β
̸ͷͰͻͳ΁ͳ
ͺ͹ΒͪͬͳͶͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͼͽ;ͯͳΒͰ
͹
3JHBT

7FMFTUJOMJTV


͵ͪ͹
ͺͻͰͽͰ΂ͳ
ͭͻ΂͵Ͱ
͸ͰͲͪͬͳͼ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
t΀Ͱͻ͹Β;
ͳ
ͷ;΂Ͱ͸ͳ͵;u

΀ͳͼͺͪ͸͹ͪͷͰͻͳ΂͵Ͱ
͸ͰͲͪͬͳͼ͸͹ͼͽͳ
'SBODJTDV
EF
.JSBOEJ


̀ͪ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͰ

͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͻͪͯͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ͸͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͼͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
Ͳͪͽ͹΂Ͱ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ͹
ͳ
ͼͷͻͽ
͉ͳͭͪ
ͼͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹ͭ͹ͯͳͶ͹
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵͹Β
ͽͬͻΌͪͬͳ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͯ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵͹ͷ
ͬͶͪ΃Ε;

̀ͪ
͹ͺ΃ͳͻ͸ͳΒ;
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒ;
͵͹͸ͼ;Ͷͽ͹ͬͪͽͳ
XXXêMPMDTJDFTEFQBSUBNFOUPT
CJ[BOUJOPTSJHBTIUNM



ͅͰΌ;
͸ͪΒͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳΒͳͷ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͳ͸ͽͰͶͰ͵ͽ;ͪͶ΁ͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͺͳͼͪͶͳ
͹

̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
;
ͳͷͰ
ͺ͹ͯͻ΃͵Ͱ
ͫ͹ͻͫͳ
΀ͻͳ΃Εͪ͸ͼͽͬͪ
ͺͻ͹ͽͳͬ
ͳͼͶͪͷͪ
ͫͳͶͳ
ͼ;
̈́ͪͷͪͻͽͳ͸

͑ͪͽ͹ͫͻͳΒͪ͸
̺ͳ͵ͽ͹ͻ
́ͭ͹
ͳ
΂;ͬͰ͸ͳ
Ͷ͹ͻͯ
̹ͪΒͻ͹͸
͌
ͽ͹
ͯ͹ͫͪ
;
͍ͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵͹Β
ͼͰ
͹ͫ
ΒͪͬΓ;ΒͰ
΂ͳͽͪͬ
͸ͳͲ
ͯͰͶͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͳͲͻͪͱͪͬͪΒ;
ͼ͹Ͷͳͯͪͻ͸͹ͼͽ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳ͸ͽͰͶͰ͵ͽ;ͪͶͪ΁ͪ

ͼͪ
ͭͻ΂͵͹ͷ
ͫͻ͹ͫ͹ͷ
̀ͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;
͹ͯ
͍ͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵Ͱ
;
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͳ
ͼͰ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͷͪͶ͹
ͺͳͼͪͶ͹
͹

͹ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯͳͶͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ͹͵ͻͰͽͳͷͪ
;
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
͋͹
ͼͰ
͹ͫΒͪ
΃Δͪͬͪ
ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁͹ͷ
ͯͪ
;
ͽ͹Β
ͲͰͷΓͳ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͽͪ͵͹
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ΀
Ͷͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ

m
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
Ͳͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
ͫͳ͹
͉ͳͭͪͼ

͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͲͪͶͪͭͪͶͰ
Ͳͪ
ͳͯͰͪͶͰ
͍ͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵Ͱ

ͻͰͬ͹Ͷ;΁ͳΒͰ
͈͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͉ͳͭͪͼ
ͼͪ
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͻͰͬͰ͹
̽Ͱ͵Ͷͪͻͪ΁ͳΒ;
͹
ͺͻͪͬͳͷͪ

ͳ
͌ͼͽͪͬ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͌
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͳ
ΒͰ
ͽͰ͵
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
Ͳ͸ͪ
΂ͪΒ͸ͪ
ͼͽ;ͯͳΒͪ
͹
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͳͼͽͪ͵͸;ͽ͹ͷ
̻ͻ͵;
ͺͻͰͽͰ΂ͳ
ͭͻ΂͵Ͱ
͸ͰͲͪͬͳͼ͸͹ͼͽͳ
%PO
.BSDPT

.BOVFM
3ÎP
Z
$PSPOFM
-B
JOTVSSFDDJÓO
EF
MB
(SFDJB
&E
3BNPT
Z
$PNQBÒÎB
.BESJE






"MQIPOTF
EF
-BNBSUJOF


 ͊Ͷ͹ͫ͹ͯͪ͸
͊
͈ͪΒ͹ͬͳΕ

HFT
QFOEBOU
VO
WPZBHF
FO
0SJFOU
m

i
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸͹
;
̹ͰͶͳͭͳΒͳ

#SJTFM
&E
8BIMFO


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͈ͻͳ
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
;ͲͰͽͳ
;
͹ͫͲͳͻ
ͯͪ

ͼͰ
ͻͪͯͳ
͹
ͳͼͽͪ͵͸;ͽ͹ͷ
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͳ͸ͽͰͶͰ͵ͽ;ͪͶ΁;
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸ͳ͵;
ͳ

ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂ͪͻ;
ΒͰͻ
̈́ͪͷͪͻͽͳ͸
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
ͺ͹ͼͶͪ͸ͳ͵
;
͊͵;ͺ΃ͽͳ͸ͳ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͷͳ
͸ͳͼͽͪͻ
ͳ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͪ
͍ͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵Ͱ
͌
͹ͬ͹ͷ
̈́ͪͷͪͻͽͳ͸͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ;
ͳͷͪ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͪ
;
͵͹ͷͰ
͹͸
ͳͲ͸͹ͼͳ

ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͬͪͱ͸Ͱ
ͯͰͽͪΓͰͲͪͺͳͼͰ
͹
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͷ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ;
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳͷ

͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͳͷͪ
ͳ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵ͪͷͪ
́
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
;͹΂Ͱ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͸ͪͲ͸ͪ΂Ͱ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ͹ͼͽͪ
Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ;
͸ͪ
̻ͻ΂͵;
̈́ͪͷͪͻͽͳ͸
͹ͽ͵ͻͳͬͪ
΂ͳͽͪͬ;
ͼ͵ͪͶ;

ΔͰ͸ͳ΀
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ΀
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ
m
ͷͪͯͪ
;ͭͶͪͬ
͸͹ͷ
ͼͰΓͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͻͰ͵Ͷͪ
m
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳ΃Ͱ
ͼͰ
͹͸ͳͷ
ͫ͹ͻͫͰ͸ͳͷ
͹ͼ͹ͫͳ͸ͪ
ͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͼͬ͹ΒͼͽͬͰ͸Ͱ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͷ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͳͷͪ
͌Ͳ
ͽ͹
̈́ͪͷͪͻͽͳ͸
;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ

͸ͪ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻ͸;
ͻͰͶͳͭͳ͹Ͳ͸͹ͼͽ
͹ͺ΃ͽͰ
ͻͪͼͺͻ͹ͼͽͻͪΔͰ͸;
ͷͰΌ;
͊ͻͫͳͷͪ
ͭͯͰ

ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ
΀ͪͻͷ͹͸ͳΒͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
ͺ͹ͫ;ΔͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͼͰΓͪ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͼͬͰ΃ͽͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵͹Βͳ

ͼͰ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ
ͫ͹ͻͰ
ͳ
ͬͶͪͯͪΒ;
́͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ͸͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͰΕ

ͳ
ͼͪͷ
̈́ͪͷͪͻͽͳ͸
ͺ͹͵;΃ͪ͹
ͯͪ
ͺͻͰͯͬͳͯͳ
ͫ;ͯ;Εͳ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͪͶͳ

ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
͆ͪͳͷͰ
ͺͻ͹ͿͰͼ͹ͻ
̺Ͱͳͭͪ
͸ͪ
ͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
ͺ͹ͯͬͶͪ΂ͳ
̈́ͪͷͪͻͽͳ͸͹ͬ;
͹΁Ͱ͸;
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͯͪ
ΕͰ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ

ͺͻͰͯͬ͹ͯͳͽͳ
ΒͰͯ͸;
Β;ͱ͸͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵;
ͿͰͯͰͻͪ΁ͳΒ;
͵͹Βͪ
ΕͰ
͸ͪͼͽͪͽͳ
͸ͪ

ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ΃ΔͰͭ
͇ͽ͹ͷͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
΁ͪͻͼͽͬͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΕͰ
ͫͳͽͳ

ͺͻͳͼͳΓͰ
͸͹
ͯͪ
͸ͪͺ;ͼͽͳ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺ;
͌
͸͹ͬͳΒͰ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͳͷͪͽͳ
;
ͬͳͯ;
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
;
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ

ͳͲͬ͹ͻͳͷͪ
͹ͫͻͪΌͳͬͪ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͼͪͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ
ͯͰ͹
ͫͳͬ΃Ͱ
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͿͰͯͰ
ͻͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͼͪ
͵͹Β͹ͷ
ΒͰ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸ͪ
ͳͷͪͶͪ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
͸ͰͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
͋ͪ

͹΁Ͱ͸ͪ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͺͻͳ΀ͬͪͽͳͽͳ
ͳ
Ͳͪ
Ϳͻͪ͸͵ͳͼͽͳ΂͵;
Ͱͺ͹΀;
΃ͽ͹
͸ͪͼ
ΒͰͯ
͸͹ͼͽͪͬ͸͹
;ͺ;Ε;ΒͰ
͸ͪ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁;
ͯͪ
͸ͪ΃ͪ
ͲͰͷΓͪ
͸ͳ͵ͪͯͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
;

ͺͻͳ͹ͻͳͽͰͽ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹Γ;
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳ΂ͪͻͪ
΀ͻ͹͸ͳ΂ͪ
ͻͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ΁ͪ
͊
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸ͪ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͬ
΃ͳ
͹ͯ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͽͰͺͰ͸͹
ͺͻͰͻͪͼͶͪ
;
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͺͻͳͼ;ͽ͸ͳΒͳ΀

Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ΀
΂ͳ͸ͳͶͪ΁ͪ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͻͰͪͶ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͑ͺͪ
͸ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
;ͺͻͪͬ͹
;
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
ͻͪͼͺͪͯͪ
ͫͳͬ΃Ͱ
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͿͰͯͰͻͪ΁ͳΒͰ

ͳ͸ͽͰ͸Ͳͳͬ͸͹
ͺ͹΂ͰͶͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒͰ
ͼͪ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳͷ
Β;ͱ͸͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ

͸ͪͻ͹ͯͳͷͪͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͯ͹
ͽͪͯͪ
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͫͳͶͳ
͹ͫΒͰͯͳΔͰ͸ͳ

Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
͹͵ͬͳͻ͹ͷ
͈ͻͳ
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ͬͪͱ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͳͼͽͪΕͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ
͸ͪ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͪ
;͹΂ͳ
ͻͪͼͺͪͯͪ
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸Ͱ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬͳͶͪ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ

ͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
ͼͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͽ͹
͸ͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵͹ͷ



'SBODJTDP
7FJHB
3PESÎHVF[
&O
MPT
$POêOFT $SÓOJDBT
EF
7JBKFT
QPS
MBT

1FOÎOTVMBT
#BMDÃOJDB
F
*CÊSJDB
EVSBOUF
FM
1FSÎPEP
3PNÃOUJDP
PQ
DJU

 ͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
;
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ 

͸ͪ;΂͸͹ͷ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͷ
ͺͶͪ͸;
͊;ͬͰͻͰ͸
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
͎;ͪ͸
̓ͪͻͶ͹ͼ
*
ͯͰ

̹͹ͻͫ͹ͯ
;΂ͳ͸ͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͺͻͬ;
Ͳͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸;
ͺ͹ͼͰͽ;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

ͯ͹͵
ΒͰ
ͫͳͬ΃ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͰͯ͸ͳ͵
͈ͻͰͯͼͰͯ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
͍͉͊͠
̈́ͪͲͪͻ
ͅ͹Βͼ͹ͬ
;Ͳ
ͬͻͪͽ͸͹
Ͳͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸͹
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹
ͪͯͅͻͳͯ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͠͹΃
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
͵͹ͷͺ͹
͸Ͱ͸ͽͪ
;ͽͳ΁ͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵;
ͺͻͰͷͪ
͵ͻͳͲͳ
;
͍͉͊͠
ͪ
ͽ͹
ΒͰ

΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͯͪ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͪ
m
Ͳͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;
͹ͯ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ΀
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹Ͱͬͻ͹ͺ
ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͼͳͶͪ
m
͸ͳ͵ͪͯͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͳͷͪͶͪ
͸Ͱͭͪͽͳͬ͸͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹
͸ͪ
ͼͶͰΌͰ
ͼͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸͹ͷ
ͳͶͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ͹ͷ
ͫͳͬ΃Ͱ
͍͉͊͠
ͺͪ
ͼͪͷͳͷ
ͽͳͷ
͸ͳ
ͼͪ

͊ͻͫͳΒ͹ͷ
͋ͪ͵͹ΌͰ
Ͳͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;
͹ͯ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
m
͵ͪ͹

ͷ;Ͷͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
ͼͪ
ͼ͹ͺͼͽͬͰ͸ͳͷ
ͽͻͪͭͳ΂͸ͳͷ
ͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬ͹ͷ
ͳͲ

ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
͑ͺͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
m
ͺ͹͵ͪͲͪͶͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͼͺͻͰͷ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ

͹ͼͰΕͪΒͪ
ͯͪ
ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͿͳ͵;ΒͰ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͫͻ͹Β͸Ͱ
͹ͺͪͼ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
;
ͫͳͬ΃͹Β

͍͉͊͠
ͫͳͶͰ
ͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͪͽ
ͼͬͰ
͸ͪͭͶͪ΃Ͱ͸ͳΒͳ΀
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͳͿ;ͭͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͽͰ͸ͯͰ͸΁ͳ
Βͪ
͆ͪ
͵ͻͪΒ;
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͰ
ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯ͸͹
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂ͳͽͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;ͽͳ΁ͪΒ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸Ͱ

͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͽ͸͹
͹Βͪ΂ͪ͸
ͳ
ͳͲͬͪ͸
ͼͰͭͷͰ͸ͽͪ
ͫͰͲ
ͫͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
͹΂;ͬͪΔͪ
ͷͳͻͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
;
ͯ͹ͷͰ͸;
ͽͰ΀͸ͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͪͼͺͰ͵ͪͽͪ

ͼͺͻ͹ͬ͹ΌͰΔͪ
ͷͰΌ;͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
͹ͯͻͰͯͫͳ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
;
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯ;
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ

͸ͰͬͶͪͯͳ͸ͳ΀
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
͵ͪͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͹
΀;ͷͪ͸ͳͽͪͻ
͸͹Β
ͺ͹ͷ͹Εͳ
́ͼͽ͹
ͽͪ͵͹
;͹΂ͪͬͪ
ͼͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͪ
ͬͳͯ͸͹
ͳ͸ͽͰ͸Ͳͳͬͳ
ͻͪͶͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͯͳΒͪͶ͹ͭ
ͼͪ
ͼͬͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
͸ͪͼͽͪͶͳͷ
ͳͲ
ͫͳͬ΃Ͱ
͍͉͊͠

ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͳͲ
͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
͈ͪͻͪͶͰͶ͸͹
ͼ
ͳ͸ͽͰ͸ͲͳͬͳͻͪΔͰͷ
ͼͬͰ;͵;ͺ͸ͳ΀
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;

͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯ͸͹ͭ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͳ
ͳ
ͯ͹
ͻͪͼͽ;ΕͰͭ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰ
ͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ
΃ͳͻͳ΀
͵ͻ;ͭ͹ͬͪ
Ͳͪ
͹ͬͪΒ
ͯͰ͹
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;
ͻ;
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ;
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͻͰͲ;ͶͽͳͻͪͶ͹
;ͷ͸͹ͱͪͬͪΔͰͷ
ͻͪͲ͸ͳ΀
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͪ

͵͹Βͳ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
ͺ͹ͯͬͰͼͽͳ
ͺ͹ͯ
͵ͪͽͰͭ͹ͻͳΒ;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ
ͳͶͳ

΀ͻ͹͸ͳ͵ͪ
͉ͪͯͳ
ͼͰ
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
͹
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳͷ
ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻ͹͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔͳ
ͷͪͬͰͻͲͳΒͪͷͪ
͹
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
͸ͪͼͽͪͶͳͷ
͹ͯ
ͫͳͬ΃Ͱ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
;Ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰ
ͫͪ͸
ͪ͵΁Ͱ͸ͪͽ
͸ͪ
ͽͻͪͭͳ΂͸Ͱ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͰ
ͳͲ
ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
͇ͬͳ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͳ

ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
Ͳͪͳͼͽͪ
͸ͪΒ΃ͳͻͳ
ͯͳΒͪͺͪͲ͹͸
ͬͳΌͰΔͪ
ͳ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͰ
;Ͳͻ͹͵ͪ



͌͵;ͺ͸ͳ
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵͹΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬͰͶͳ
ͼ;
ͻͰͶͪͽͳͬ͸͹
ͫͻͲ
ͳ

ͼͬͰ͹ͫ;΀ͬͪͽͪ͸
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
͸ͪ͵͹͸
Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͶ͸͹ͭ
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪ
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͼ͵ͳ΀
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͪ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͈͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
Ͳͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸ͳ΀
ͳ
͵͹͸ͽͳ͸;ͳͻͪ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͳ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ΀

͵͹͸ͽͪ͵ͪͽͪ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
Ϳͻͪ͸͵ͳͲͷͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
͈͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͽͻͰͫͪ
͸ͪͭͶͪͼͳͽͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;
ͻͰͶͪͽͳͬ
͸͹
͵ͻͪͽ͵͹ͷ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
ͲͪͫͰͶͰͱͰ͸
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ͸
;ͼͺ͹͸
ͳ
ͯͳͬͰͻͼͳͿͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͼͬͳ΀
͹ͫͶͳ͵ͪ

ͼͪͻͪͯΔͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵Ͱ
͋ͪ͵ͪͬ
ͽͻͰ͸ͯ
;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳͷͪ
ͯͬͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
Ͳͪͯͻͱͪ͸
ΒͰ
ͳ

ͽ͹͵͹ͷ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͯ͹΃Ͷ͹
ͯ͹
ͼͽͪͭ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ

͌
ͯͻ;ͭ͹Β

ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
ͽͰ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͯ͹΃Ͷ͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͯ͹
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸͹ͭ
ͺͪͯͪ
;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳͷͪ
 ͊Ͷ͹ͫ͹ͯͪ͸
͊
͈ͪΒ͹ͬͳΕ

Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͽͻͪͭͰͯͳΒͰ
ͯͰͬͰͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͪ
ͯ͹ͼͽ;ͺ͸ͳ

ͼ;
͸ͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳͷ
ͬͰͫ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸ͳ΀
Ͷͳ
ͼͽ͹ͬͪ
;
͑ͺͪ͸ͳΒͳ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͽ͹
t&M
1BÎTi
t"#$i
ͳͶͳ
t&M
.VOEPi


ͻͪͲ͸ͳ΀
͸ͰͯͰΓ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ΀
͸ͪ;΂͸ͳ΀
΂ͪͼ͹ͺͳͼͪ
ͳ
ͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ΀
͸ͪ
;΂͸͹ͪ͵ͪͯͰͷͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;΁ͳΒͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͽ͹
t3FBM
*OTUJUVUP
&MDBOP

EF
&TUVEJPT
*OUFSOBDJPOBMFT
Z
&TUSBUÊHJDPTi
t*OTUJUVUP
6OJWFSTJUBSJP
EF

*OWFTUJHBDJÓO
0SUFHB
Z
(BTTFUi
ͳͶͳ
t6OJWFSTJEBE
EF
0WJFEP
m
'BDVMUBE

EF
(FPFHSBGÎB
F
)JTUPSJBi
ͳͽͯ
͈ͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
͵͹͸ͼ;Ͷͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͽ͹ͭ
ͻͪͲ͸͹Ͷͳ͵͹ͭ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳ͹͸͹ͭ
ͷͪ
ͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͪ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹Εͳ
ͯ͹
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂͵ͪ
ͯͪ
;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ;
͸ͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒ;
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵

ͺͻͰ͹ͬͶͪͯͪͬͪ
ΔͰ͸
͸Ͱͭͪͽͳͬͪ͸
ͳͷͳΘ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
͹͸ͪ
ͼͰ
ͼͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ
͸͹
ͳͶͳ
ͳ͸ͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ͸͹
͵ͪ͹
͸ͪΒͬͰΕͳ
͵ͻͳͬͪ΁
Ͳͪ
ͼͽͻͪͯͪΔͪ
;
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹Β
ͳ

ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
;
̹͹ͼ͸ͳ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
͇ͬͪ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ΒͰ

ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯͳ΁ͪ
Ͳͪͳͼͽͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳ΀
ͳͲͬͰ΃ͽͪΒͪ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
΀;ͷͪ͸ͳͽͪͻͪ
΁ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͸ͪ͵͹͸
ͼͬ͹ͭ
ͻͪͯͪ
;
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸ͳͷ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͫͳͬ΃Ͱ
͍͉͊͠
ͳ
̓͹
ͼ͹ͬͪ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪͶͳ
ͼͬ͹Βͪ
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΔͪ
ͳ
ͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬͪ
ͼͽͰ΂Ͱ͸ͪ
JO
TJUV
͌
ͺͻͪ͵ͼͳ

ͽ͹
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͳ
ͯͪ
;͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
͵͹͸ͼ;Ͷͽ;ΒͰͷ͹
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͬͰͫ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΁;
t1PSUBM
NVOEPTi
m
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͪ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
Ͳͪ

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͺ͹
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
ͳ
ͼͬͰͽ;
m
ͬͳͯͰΕͰͷ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ;
̹͹ͼ͸Ͱ
ͳ

͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͵ͪ͹
͹
tͲͪͫ͹ͻͪͬΓͰ͸͹Β
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹Β
Ͳͪ΂ͪͻͪ͸͹ͼͽͳi

&M
FODBOUP
PMWJEBEP
EF
MPT
#BMDBOFT

͵͹Β;
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͺ͹͸͹ͬ͹
͹ͽ͵ͻͳͽͳ

͈ͻͳ
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ͺͻ;ͱͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͳͲ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͹
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͳ

͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͳͷͪ
Ͱͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ

ͳ
ͷͰͼͽͳͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͽͳ
ͯ͹͵
ͼͰ
;
;ͬ͹ͯ͸͹ͷ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭͰ͹
ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͹
tͼͻͺͼ͵͹Β
ͪͭͻͰͼͳΒͳi
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
͹
ͼͽͻͪͯͪΔ;

ͳ
;͸ͳ΃ͽͰΔ;
ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͊ͪͻͪΒͰͬͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳ΀
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳ΀

ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͌
ͺ͹ͽͻͪͲͳ
Ͳͪ
͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪΒ;Εͳͷ
ͬͰͫ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
͹
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ΔͰ͸͹Β

ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͳ
͹ͫͳ΂ͪ
Βͳͷͪ
;
͊ͻͫͪ
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͳ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂͵ͪ
ͯͪ
͹͸Ͱ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͳ
͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͰ
͵ͪ͹



͆ͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳͷ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
;͸ͳͬͰͻͲͳͽͰͽͳͷͪ
ͳ
;
͸ͪ;΂͸͹ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͳ͸
ͼͽͳͽ;΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͽͰͷͰΓ͸͹
ͼ;
ͳͲ;΂ͪͬͪ͸ͳ
;Ͳͻ͹΁ͳ
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
͵ͻͳͲͰ
ͳ
ͻͪͼͺͪͯͪ
͇ͬ͹ͷ

ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
͸ͪͬͰ΃ΕͰͷ͹
͌͸ͳͬͰͻͲͳͽͰͽ
ͳͲ
͇ͬͳͰͯͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͪ;ͽ͹͸͹ͷ͸Ͱ
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ

̸ͼͽ;ͻͳΒͪͼ

͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
;
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
͸ͪͬͻͪͽͪ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪ͹
ͶͰͽΔͰ
͵;ͻͼͰͬͰ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͯͳͺͶ͹ͷ
΁Ͱ
͹
ͽ͹Β
ͽͰͷͳ
ͳ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳͲͯͪ͹
͵Δͳͭ;
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͲͳͬ͹ͷ
-PT
OVFWPT
&TUBEPT
EF
MB

BOUJHVB
:VHPTMBWJB
&E
+PTF
(JSPO
Z
4MPCPEBO
1BKPWJD

ͳͶͳ
ͻͪͯ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹ͭ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ

ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳ΂ͪͻͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪ͹΁ͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͳ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
'SBODJTDB
7FJHF
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
͹ͫΒͪͬͳ͹
ͯͬͰ

ͼͽ;ͯͳΒͰ
͹
ͽͳͷ
ͽͰͷͪͷͪ
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͲͳͬ͹ͷ
-B
5SBNQB
#BMDÃOJDB
&E
(SJKBMCP
.POEBEPSJ

4"
#BSDFMPOB

J
4MPCP
6OB
CJPHSBGÎB
OP
BVUPSJ[BEB
EF
.JMPTFWJDI
&E
%FCBUF

#BSDFMPOB

 ͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
;
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ 

ͯ͹ͫͻ͹
͹ͼͷͳ΃ΓͰ͸Ͱ
ͫͪͲͰ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΕͰ
ͺͻ;ͱͳͽͳ
ͷ;ͶͽͳͯͳͷͰ͸Ͳͳ͹
͸ͪͶ͸;
ͼͶͳ͵;
͹
͸ͪ΃͹Β
ͲͰͷΓͳ
ΔͰ͸͹Β
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͼͪͯͪ΃Δ͹ͼͽͳ
͇ͬͪ

΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ͸͹
;ͽͳ΂Ͱ
͸ͪ
ͼͷͪΔͰΔͰ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͑ͺͪ͸ͪ΁ͪ
Ͳͪ

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
;
͊ͻͫͳΒ;
ͳ
;ͺ;Ε;ΒͰ
͸ͪ
͸Ͱ͹ͺ΀͹ͯ͸͹ͼͽ
͹ͼͷͳ΃ΓͪͬͪΔͪ
΃ͽ͹

ͪͭͳͶ͸ͳΒͰ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͻͪͽͰͭͳΒͰ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒ;
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
;
͸ͪΒ΃ͳͻͳͷ

΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳͷ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
͵ͻ;ͭ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͌
ͽ͹ͷ
͵͹͸ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ͸͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͰ͵


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ΒͰͲͳ͵
ͺͻͰͬͰͯͰ͸͹
΂;ͬͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹
́ͻ͵ͳΔͰ
͉ͰͫͰ͵Ͱ

̺Ͱͼͽ
3FCCFDDF
8FTU
$FDJMZ
*TBCFM
'BJSGJ
m

ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

t͏ͻ͸͹
ΒͪͭΔͰ
ͼͳͬͳ
ͼ͹͵͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͺ͹
;͸;ͽͻͪ΃Δ͹ͼͽͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰi

$PSEFSP
OFHSP
IBMDÓO
HSJT
WJBKF
BM
JOUFSJPS
EF
:VHPTMBWJB
&E
#JCMJPUF
DB
(SBOEFT
7JBKFSPT
ͳͲ
̹ͪͻͽͼͰͶ͹͸Ͱ
ͳ
;
ͺͻͰͬ͹ͯ;
-VJTB
.VSSJMB
'PSUB


͇ͬ͹
ͬͰΕ
͵Ͷͪͼͳ΂͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸Ͱ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͰ
ͳͲͪͲͬͪͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͬͰͶͳ͵͹

ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͰ
;
͸ͪΒ΃ͳͻͳͷ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
͵ͻ;ͭ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͳ
͹
ΔͰͷ;
ΒͰ
͸ͪͺͳͼͪ
͸͹
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
΂Ͷͪ͸ͪ͵ͪ
͵ͻͳͽͳ͵ͪ
ͳͶͳ
͹ͼͬͻͽͪ
͇ͬ͹ͷ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
͸ͪͬͰ΃ΕͰͷ͹

ͼͪͷ͹
͹ͼͬͻͽ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹ͭ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
͸͹ͬͳ͸ͪͻͪ
)FSNBOOB
5FSUTDIB
m
͵͹Βͳ

ͼͶ͹ͬͳ
Ͳͪ
͸ͪΒͫ͹ΓͰͭ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪ͹΁ͪ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪ
;
ͫͳͬ΃͹Β
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
ͳ
͸ͪ

̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
m
ͳͲ
͸ͪΒ;ͭͶͰͯ͸ͳΒͰͭ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸͹ͭ
Ͷͳͼͽͪ
t&M
1BÎTi
͇͸
ΒͰ
;
ͺͻͰͼͽͳͱ͸͹ͷ
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸͹ͷ
ͯ͹ͯͪͽ͵;
ͽ͹ͭ
Ͷͳͼͽͪ
t#BCFMJBi

͹ͫΒͪͬͳ͹
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ͹ͷ
t͠Ͱͯ͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͯͳͬ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͻͪͼͽͻͭͪ͸ͪ
ͲͰͷΓͪi
6O

CFMMÎTJNP
QBÎT
EFTUSP[BEP

ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͯͰͽͪΓͪ͸
ͳ
Ͱͷ͹ͽͳͬͪ͸
͹ͼͬͻͽ
͸ͪ
͹ͬ͹
΂;
ͬͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹
ͳͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͺͳͼͪͽͰΓͳ΁Ͱ
ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ΁ͪ
͌
ͼͬ͹ͷ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
͋Ͱͻ΂
ͯ͹
ͼͶ͹ͬ΁Ͱ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
tͳͲ͸Ͱ͸ͪΌ;Β;Εͪ
ͼͳͷͺͪͽͳΒͪ
͵͹Β;
̺Ͱͼͽ͹ͬͪ
ͳͲͻͪͱͪͬͪ

ͺͻͰͷͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͳ
ΔͰ͸͹Β
ͫ͹ͻͫͳi
ͳ
ͽ͹
ͽ;ͷͪ΂ͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯͳ΁;
ͺ͹ͯͻ΃͵Ͱ

͵͹Β;
ͼ;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͺͻ;ͱͪͶͰ
͍ͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵ͪ
ͳ
̺ͰͶͳ͵ͪ
̹ͻͳͽͪ͸ͳΒͪ
͋Ͱͻ΂
m
͵͹Βͳ

ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͼͶ͹ͬͳ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹ͭ
ͪ͸ͽͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͼͽͻ͹ΒͰ͸͹ͭ
͸͹ͬͳ͸ͪͻͪ
m
ͺ͹͵;
΃ͪͬͪ
ͯͪ
ͳͼ͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳ
ͻͪͲͷͳ΃ΓͪΔͪ
̺Ͱͼͽ͹ͬͰ
͹
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ;
Βͪ΂ͪΔͪ
ͯͰͷ͹͵ͻͪ
ͽͳΒͰ
;
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͵ͪ͹
͸ͪΒͫ͹ΓͰͭ

ͬͳͯͪ
͹ͯͫͻͪ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ
͸ͪͻͪͼͽͪΒ;ΕͰͭ
͸ͪ΁ͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͬͪͻͬͪͻͼͽͬͪ
ͺ͹ͳͼͽ͹ͬͰΕ;
Β;Εͳ
ͳ΀
ͼͪ
t͸ͪͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͰͷ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͫ͹ͻͰ
ͺͻ͹ͽͳͬ
Ͱͽ͸͹͸ͪ΁ͳͲͷͪ
͊Ͷ͹
ͫ͹ͯͪ͸ͪ
ͅͳͶ͹΃ͰͬͳΕͪi

͆ͪ
͵ͻͪΒ;
ͷ͹ͱͰͷ͹
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂ͳͽͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
;
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
;
͵Ͷͪͼͳ΂͸͹Β
ͳͶͳ
ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻ͹͸ͼ͵͹Β

ͬͰͻͲͳΒͳ
ͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ΔͰ͸
;ͭͶͰͯ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
͸Ͱͭͪͽͳͬͪ͸
ͳ
ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ

͹ͺͽͰͻͰΕͰ͸
ΔͰ͸͹ͷ
;Ͷ͹ͭ͹ͷ
;
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳͷͪ
ͳͲ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
ͻͪͼͺͪͯͪ
ͫͳͬ΃Ͱ

͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
͆ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;
ͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͪͽͪ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
m
;ͲͳͷͪΒ;Εͳ
;
͹ͫͲͳͻ

ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸͹
ͬͰΕ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͰ
͹ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂Ͱ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺ͹
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
ͯ͹ͼͽ;ͺ͸͹ͼͽͳ



&M
1BÎT
m
#BCFMJB

Β;Ͷ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
 ͊Ͷ͹ͫ͹ͯͪ͸
͊
͈ͪΒ͹ͬͳΕ

͹ͻͳͭͳ͸ͪͶ͸ͳͷ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͳͷͪ
m
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂;ΒͰͷ͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͪ
ͫͳͬ΃ͪ

Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ
͵͹Βͪ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
͸ͳΒͰ
;ͼͺͰͶͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯͳ

ͻͪͽ͸͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
;
͹΂ͳͷͪ
͸ͪΒ΃ͳͻͰ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
Βͪͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͠Ͱͯ͸͹ͼͽͪͬ͸͹
ͻͰ
΂Ͱ͸͹
͹
Δ͹Β
͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹
͹ͼͷͳ΃ΓͰ͸Ͱ
ͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͫͳ
ͺͻͰ;
ͼͷͰͻͳͶͰ
ͺͪͱΔ;
͑ͺͪ͸ͪ΁ͪ
͸ͪ
ΔͰ͸;
ͫ͹ͭͪͽ;
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ;
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͰ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ;
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰ
ͳͶͳ
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͰ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͸Ͱ͹ͺ΀͹ͯ
͸ͳ
Ͳͪ
;ͼͺͰ΃͸;
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͫͳͶ͹
͵͹ΒͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
;
Ͱͻͳ
ͭͶ͹ͫͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ

͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͪ
;
͵͹ΒͰͷ
ͱͳͬͳͷ͹
ͪ
΂ͳΒͰ
Βͪͬ͸͹
ͷΔͰ
ΔͰ
;
͸ͪΒͬͰΕ͹Β
ͷͰͻͳ
͵ͻͰͳͻͪΒ;
;ͺͻͪͬ͹
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͳ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͷ͹Εͳ
 ͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
;
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ 

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

4MPCPEBO
1BKPWJǀ
4FSCJFO
JO
TQBOJTDIFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO

*O
OFVFSFO
;FJUFO
XVSEF
4FSCJFO
JO
VOUFSTDIJFEMJDIFO
TQBOJTDIFO

2VFMMFO
JNNFS
BMT
JOUFHSBMFS
5FJM
EFS
FIFNBMJHFO
KVHPTMBXJTDIFO
'ÕEFSBUJPO

CFUSBDIUFU
NJU
EFS
EBT
TQBOJTDIF
,ÕOJHSFJDI
LFJOF
CFTPOEFST
FOHFO

#F[JFIVOHFO
QGMFHUF
%JFTF
&JOTDIÅU[VOH
LÕOOUF
TJDI
BVDI
BVG
EBT
3FHJNF

WPO
'SBODP
CF[JFIFO
XBT
XJFEFSVN
BVG
EJF
5BUTBDIF
[VSÛDL[VGÛISFO
JTU
EBTT

VOTFS
-BOE
OJF
[V
1SJPSJUÅUFO
EFS
TQBOJTDIFO
(FTDIJDIUTXJTTFOTDIBGUMFS
VOE

TDISFJCFS
PEFS
EFS
3FJTFMJUFSBUVS
JOTHFTBNU
[ÅIMUF

"VG
EFS
4VDIF
OBDI
FOUTQSFDIFOEFO
8FCTFJUFO
ÛCFS
4FSCJFO
ÛCFS
TFJOF

(FTDIJDIUF
(FPHSBGJF
,VMUVS
(FTDIJDIUTEFOLNÅMFS
4JUUFO
VOE
#SÅVDIF

MÅTTU
TJDI
OVS
GFTUTUFMMFO
EBTT
FT
FJHFOUMJDI
LFJOF
WFSOÛOGUJH
EVSDIEBDIUFO

%BUFOCBOLFO
HJCU
EJF
FJO
NVMUJEJNFOTJPOBMFT
"CCJME
VOTFSFT
-BOEFT
TFJOFS

(FTDIJDIUF
VOE
(FHFOXBSU
CJFUFO
LÕOOUFO
%JFTF
5BUTBDIF
XJSLU
FOUTDIFJEFOE

BVG
NBOHFMIBGUFT
*OUFSFTTF
EFS
4QBOJFS
BO
3FJTFO
OBDI
4FSCJFO
FJO
VOE
MFHU

[VTUÅOEJHFO
*OTUBO[FO
OBIF
4USBUFHJFO
[V
BHJMFS
VOE
NPEFSOFS
7PSTUFMMVOH

4FSCJFOT
JO
EFO
CSFJUFTUFO
TQBOJTDIFO
LVMUVSFMMFO
VOE
UPVSJTUJTDIFO
,SFJTFO

IFSBVT[VBSCFJUFO

"VGHSVOE
EFS
PCFO
TLJ[[JFSUFO
4JUVBUJPO
MÅTTU
TJDI
TDIMJF“FO
EBTT

4FSCJFO
JO
TQBOJTDIFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO
TPXPIM
JN
LMBTTJTDIFO
BMT
BVDI
JN

FMFLUSPOJTDIFO
'PSNBU
JNNFS
OPDI
FJO
WFSOBDIMÅTTJHUFT
3FJTF[JFM
CMFJCU
VOE

EBTT
FT
JNNFS
OPDI
FJOFO
ÛCMFO
-FVNVOE
IBU
EFS
EVSDI
TFJOF
3PMMF
JO
EFO

&SFJHOJTTFO
VN
EFO
;FSGBMM
EFT
FIFNBMJHFO
+VHPTMBXJFOT
OVS
OPDI
WFSTUÅSLU

XJSE
0CXPIM
JOGPMHF
CFTDISÅOLUFS
;VHÅOHMJDILFJU
EFS
0SJHJOBMRVFMMFO
LFJO

"OTQSVDI
BVG
EJF
7PMMTUÅOEJHLFJU
EFS
WPSMJFHFOEFO
"OBMZTF
FSIPCFO
XFSEFO

EÛSGUF
LÕOOUF
NBO
EBSBVT
TDIMJF“FO
EBTT
4FSCJFO
EJF
FJO[JHF
FIFNBMJHF

KVHPTMBXJTDIF
5FJMSFQVCMJL
JTU
EFS
EJF
,SJFHTFSFJHOJTTF
WPO
EFS
TQBOJTDIFO

¸GGFOUMJDILFJU
JNNFS
OPDI
[VS
-BTU
HFMFHU
XFSEFO
&T
HJCU
OÅNMJDI
LFJOF

HVU
EVSDIEBDIUFO
1VCMJLBUJPOFO
EJF
EJF
"VGNFSLTBNLFJU
EFS
4QBOJFS
BVG

EJF
TFSCJTDIF
FSFJHOJTSFJDIF
(FTDIJDIUF
BVG
EBT
TFSCJTDIF
7PML
VOE
EFTTFO

BMUCFXBISUF
5SBEJUJPOFO
,VMUVS
/BUVSTDIÕOIFJUFO
PEFS
BOEFSF
*OIBMUF
MFOLFO

LÕOOUFO
XBT
JN
(MPCBMJTJFSVOHT[FJUBMUFS
JO
EFN
EJF
ÕGGFOUMJDIF
.FJOVOH

XFMUXFJU
BVT
NÅDIUJHFO
JOUFSOBUJPOBMFO
*OGPSNBUJPOT[FOUSFO
HFGPSNU
XJSE
[V

JOUFSOBUJPOBM
FSGPMHSFJDIFS
%BSCJFUVOH
FJOFT
-BOEFT
CFJUSBHFO
LÕOOUF


͉ͪͯͷͳͶͪ
͇͇̺̀͋́ͣ
̸ͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

̸͇͆͋́͐̓
̸͚͆͊̈́̾̾

̸̈́̾ͅ
̸̀́̾͠
ћ
t̸͉͋͌͊̓
̸̀̾͡ͅ

̸̸͇͉̓͆͋͊͋

́
̸͉͇͊̓͑͆̾
͈͇̈́̾͋̾i

̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͪͭͰ͸΁ͳΒͰ
t̸ͻͭ;ͼ
ͽ;ͻͼi
͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ
ͲͰͷΓͪ
͵͹͸
ͽͻͪͼͽͪ
ͳ
ͻͪͼ͵͹΃͸Ͱ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰ
ͺ͹ͯͰΓͰ͸
ΒͰ
;
ͽͻͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ͸ͪ
͹ͯͰΓ͵ͪ

͇ͼͳͷ
͵ͻͪͽ͵͹ͭ
;ͬ͹ͯͪ
;
͵͹ͷͰ
ͼ;
ͯͪͽͰ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ
͸͹Β
ͳ
ͭͰ͹ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹Β
ͼͶͳ΁ͳ
͋;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ
ͼͪͯͻͱͳ
Β͹΃
ͯͬͪ
ͺ͹ͭͶͪ
ͬΓͪ
t͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯ
͹ͯ
̓͹͸ͼͽͪ͸ͽͳ͸͹ͺ͹Γͪ
ͯ͹
́ͼͽͪ͸ͫ;Ͷͪ
ͭͻͪͯ
͸ͪ
ͯͬͪ

͵͹͸ͽͳ͸Ͱ͸ͽͪi 
ͳ
t̾ͭͰΒͼ͵͹
ͺͻͳͷ͹ͻΒͰ
ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ
m
ͪͬͰ͸ͳΒͪ
ͼͰΕͪΔͪi
͊

͹ͫͲͳͻ͹ͷ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
͸ͪ
͸ͪ΃Ͱͷ
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽ;
;ͬͰ͵
ͫͳͶͪ
͹ͼ͵;ͯ
͸ͪ
ͳ
;
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃ΔͰ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͳ
͸Ͱͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͰΕͪ
ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ
ͼͷ͹
ͳͼͺͻͬͪ

ͺͻͰͯ
͸Ͱͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
͵͹ͷͺͪͻͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͪ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷ
ͷͰΌ;ͼ͹ͫ͸͹ͭ

ͺ͹ͻͰΌͰΔͪ
ͼ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͪͽͪ
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ΀
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͪ͸
ͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͼͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͷͰ
;

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͽͳͬ͸͹ͷ
΃ͽͳͬ;
́ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
͸ͪ͹͵͹
͸Ͱͼͺ͹Βͳͬ͹
ͺ͹
ͲͬͪΕͰͷ͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ
ͰͶͰͷͰ͸ͪͽ
ͳͼͽͪͱͳͬͪ΂͵ͳ
ͯ;΀
ͱͰΓͪ͸
ͼͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰͬͻͼ͸͹ͭ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷͳͷ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳͷͪ


͇
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌ;
ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ
͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ΒͰ
͹͸͹
ͫ͹ͭͪͽ͹
ͷ͹ͱͰ

ͼͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͽͳ
ͺͻͰ͹ͺ΃ͳͻ͸͹
͇͸͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪͻͪͬ͸͹
;
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽ͹ͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;

ͯͪͽ͹
;
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳͷ
΁ͻͽͪͷͪ
ͼ
͸Ͱ͹ͺ΀͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͺͻͳͶͪͭ͹ΌͰ



%
ÂFMKLP
5VSTLB
[FNMKB
LPOUSBTUB
J
SBTLPØOF
MFQPUF
#FPHSBE




́ͼͽ͹
m


́ͼͽ͹
m
 ͉ͪͯͷͳͶͪ
̀͹ͽ͹ͬͳΕ

͸ͳͷ
͸ͪΒ΃ͳͻ͹Β
͵ͶͳΒͰ͸ͽͰͶͳ
ͱͰΓ͸͹Β
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͹ͯͷ͹ͻͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪ

ͬͪΔͪ
ͼͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
ͼͽͪͻͳ͸ͪͷͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
;
ͺͻͬ͹ͷ
͹ͯͰΓ͵;

ͯͪͽ
ͳͼͺͻͬͪ
͵ͻͪͽͪ͵
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͪ
͹ͯ

ͬͺ͸Ͱ
ͺͪ
͸ͪ

ͯͪΓͰ
ͪ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳͷͪ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀

ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
;
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃ΔͰͷ
́ͼͽͪ͸ͫ;Ͷ;
̽ͪͽͳ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
͎ͳͺ͹ͯͻ͹ͷ;

̾ͭͳͺͪͽͼ͵͹ͷ
͹ͫͰͶͳͼ͵;
̓͹͸ͼͽͪ͸ͽͳ͸͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͼͽ;ͫ;
̺ͪͶͰ͸ͼ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͪ͵ͬͪͯ;͵
ͽ;
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͷ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌ;
ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ
ͺ͹΀ͻͪΔͰ͸͹ͷ
;

̸ͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵͹ͷ
ͷ;ͲͰΒ;
́ͼͽͪ͸ͫ;Ͷͪ
͈;΃ͽͪΒ;Εͳ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂͵͹ͷ
ͯ;΀;

͸ͪ
ͬ͹Γ;
ͻͰΕͳ
ΕͰͷ͹
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
͎ͳͺ͹ͯͻ͹ͷ;
ͯͪͽͳ
Βͪͼ͸͹
ͳ
;
ͳͼͽ͹

ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ͸͹
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͎ͳͺ͹ͯͻ͹ͷ
ΒͰͯ
͸ͪ
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͳ
͸ͪΒͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͭͻͪΌͰͬͳ͸ͪ
ͼͽͪͻ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ

΂ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͭͻͪͯΔͪ
͹ͽͺ͹΂ͰͶͪ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ

ͬ
ͪ
ͯ͹ͬͻ΃Ͱ͸ͪ
;
ͬͻͰͷͰ
΁ͪͻͪ
̓͹͸
ͼͽͪ͸ͽͳ͸ͪ
̺ͰͶͳ͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͬͻ΃ͳ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ
͹͵͹

΀ͪ
ͳ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹΃Ε;
ͺͻͳͷͪ
Δͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͯͰͼͰͽͳ͸ͪ
΀ͳΓͪͯͪ
ͭͶͰͯͪͶͪ΁ͪ
̀ͪ
ͺ͹΀ͬͪͶ;
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;

t̸ͻͭ;ͼ
ͽ;ͻͼͪi
͎ͳͺ͹ͯͻ͹ͷ
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸
;
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͼͬͳͷ
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ͹͸
ͼ͵͹Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳͷ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳͷͪ
΃ͽ͹
ͯ͹΂ͪͻͪͬͪ
ͼͶͳ͵;
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ΃ΔͰͭ

ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ
͹ͬͰ
ͭͻͪΌͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͼͳͷ
ͯͰ͵͹ͻͪͽͳͬ͸͹ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ΀

ͰͶͰͷͰ͸ͪͽͪ
;Ͳ
΁ͪͻͼ͵;
Ͷ͹ͱ;
;
ͼͶ;ͱͫͳ
ͯͰ͵͹ͻͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳͷͪͶͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸Ͱ

ͼͽͪͽ;Ͱ
ͫ͹ͭ͹ͬͪ
ͳ
΁ͪͻͰͬͪ
̾ͭͳͺͪͽͼ͵ͳ
͹ͫͰͶͳͼ͵
̓͹͸ͼͽͪ͸ͽͳ͸͹ͬ
ͼͽ;ͫ
ͳ

̺ͪͶͰ͸ͼ͹ͬ
ͪ͵ͬͪͯ;͵ͽ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͼͪ
ͷͪΔͰ
ͯͰͽͪΓͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͯ͹
ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸͹
ͅ͹ͱͯͪ
ΒͰ
ΒͰͯͳ͸͹
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
͸ͪͭͶͪͼͳͽͳ
ͯͪ
Ͱͭͳͺͪͽͼ͵ͳ

͹ͫͰͶͳͼ͵
͵ͪ͹
ͼͺ͹Β
Ͱͭͳͺͽ͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͪ͸ͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
͸ͪΒͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ
͸ͳΒͳ
ͯͰ͹
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ΃ΔͰͭ
̓͹͸ͼͽͪ͸ͽͳ͸͹ͺ͹Γͪ
͌
ͫͰͯͰ
͵Ͱͻ;
ͼͰ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͰ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸;
ͳͲͻͪͯͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪ

͹ͫͰͶͳͼ͵ͪ
͇ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
ͼͰ
͵ͪͷͰ͸͹
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΓͰ
ͳͲ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
΁ͪͻͪ
͋Ͱ͹ͯ͹ͼͳΒͪ

ͼͪ
ͻͰΓͰͿ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͪͷͪ
ͺ͹ͯͳͲͪΔͪ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͈ͪ͸ͪ
ͼͪ
Ϳͻ;Ͷ͹ͷ

ͳ
΁ͪͻͪ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
ͺ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΁Ͱ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵;
;
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ

ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸
͹͵͹

ͭ
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
ͯͪ
ͯÄ
;ͽͳͼͪ͵
ͬͰͶͳ΂ͳ͸Ͱ
ͷ͹Εͳ
ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ
΂ͪΒͪ
́ͷͺͰͻͳΒͰ
͆ͪͼ;ͺͻ͹ͽ
ΔͰͷ;
ͼͽ͹Βͳ
̺ͪͶͰ͸ͼ͹ͬ
ͪ͵ͬͪͯ;͵ͽ
ͳͲͭͻͪΌͰ͸

ͽ͹͵͹ͷ

ͬ
;
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
ͬͶͪͯͪͬͳ͸Ͱ
̓͹͸ͼͽͪ͸ͽͳ͸ͪ
̺ͰͶͳ͵͹ͭ
ͳ

̺ͪͶͰ͸ͼͪ
̸͵ͬͪͯ;͵ͽ
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
ͯ;ͭ
͹͵͹


ͷ
ͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳ
ͼͪͯͪ΃Δͳ
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳ

ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
͹ͼͽͪͽ͵Ͱ
;ͻͫͪ͸͹ͭ
ͭͻͪΌͰͬͳ͸ͪͻͼͽͬͪ
͵ͪͼ͸Ͱ
ͪ͸ͽͳ͵Ͱ
͹
΂ͳΒ͹Β

ͽͰͷͰΓ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͸ͪΒͫ͹ΓͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͪ͵ͬͪ
ͯ;͵ͽ
;
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͼ;Ͷͽͪ͸ͪ
͊;ͶͰΒͷͪ͸ͪ
*
̺ͰͶͳ΂ͪ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸͹ͭ
ͫͳ͹
ͺ͹ͺͻͪͬΓͰ͸
ͳ

͵͹ͻͳ΃ΕͰ͸
Ͳͪ
ͼ͸ͪͫͯͰͬͪΔͰ
ͬ͹ͯ͹ͷ
ͺͪͶͪͽͰ
͋͹ͺ͵ͪͺͳ

͆ͪͱͪͶ͹ͼͽ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͺ͹΀ͻͪΔͰ͸͹
;
ͬͳͽͻͳ͸ͪͷͪ
̸ͻ΀Ͱ͹
Ͷ͹΃͵͹ͭ
ͷ;ͲͰΒͪ
;
́ͼͽͪ͸ͫ;Ͷ;
ͯͪͽ͹
ΒͰ
;
ͳͲͬͰͼ͸͹Β
ͷͰͻͳ
ͼ;ͷͪͻ͸͹
͆Ͱͯ͹
ͼͽͪΒ;
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
ͺ͹ͻͰ͵Ͷ;
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ΀
͸ͪͶͪͲͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
ͼͽͰͶͪ

ͼͪ
͵Ͷͳ͸ͪͼͽͳͷ
ͺͳͼͷ͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳ
͸;ͷͳͲͷͪͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͫͳͫͶͳ͹ͿͳͶͼ͵Ͱ
͵͹
 ̸͸ͽͳ΂͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ 

ͶͰ͵΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
͵͹ͶͰ͵΁ͳΒͰ
͸ͪ͵ͳͽͪ
ͅ͹ͱͯͪ

͸ͪΒͬͰΕ;
ͷͪ͸;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
͸Ͱͯ͹ͼͽͪͽͪ͵

ͫͪͻ
ͼ;ͷͪͻ͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͪΔͪ
ͽͲͬ
t͵ͻ;ͺ
͸Ͱ
ͫͻ͹͸ͲͰi
ͳͲ
ͅ;ͲͰΒͪ
;
́ͼͽͪ͸ͫ;Ͷ;

͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͼͽͪͽ;Ͱ
͊ͪͷͼ͹͸ͪ
͎Ͱͻͪ͵Ͷͪ

̾ͻ͹ͼͪ
ͳ
͈ͼͳ΀Ͱ
̀Ͱͬͼͪ
ͳ
΁ͪͻͪ
͎ͪͯͻͳΒͪ
͸ͪ
͆͹
Ͳͪ
ͼͬͪ͵;
ΒͰ
ͺ͹΀ͬͪͶ;
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͪΔͰ

͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼͪͻ͵͹Ϳͪͭͪ
ͳͲ
͊ͳͯ͹͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹

ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ΀

͹ͽ͵ͻͳΕͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
͇ͬͪΒ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵
ΒͰ
ͼͬͪ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
;ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸ͳͽͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵͹ͷ
ͯͪ

ͼ;
;
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
͹ͯ
ͺͻͬͰ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

ͯ͹

ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

ͬ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Β;
ͯͪ͸ͪ
΃ΔͰ
͋;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͲͻͪΌͳͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͼͰͻͳΒͰ
͹ͯ͸͹
ͼ͸͹
ͭͻ;ͺͰ
Ͷ;͵ͼ;Ͳ͸ͳ΀
ͼͪͻ͵͹Ϳͪͭͪ
͵͹Βͳ

ͼ;
ͳͲͬ͹ͱͰ͸ͳ
ͳ
;
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͰ
͏ͪͻͼͽͬͪ

ͺͪ
ͳ
;
ͼͪͷ
͉ͳͷ
͉ͪͯͳ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
Ͳͪ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ;

ͳͲͻͪͯ;
͸ͳͼ;
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸͹
;ͫͳ΁ͳͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͪͶͳ

ͼͰ
ͼͷͪͽͻͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
Δͳ΀
ͫͳͶͪ
;
Β;ͭ͹Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹Β
ͪͅͶ͹Β
̸ͲͳΒͳ
ͺ͹͵ͻͪ
Βͳ͸ͪ
͈ͪͷͿͳͶͳΒͪ
ͯ͹͵
ͼͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͷ͹ͭ;Εͪ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͳ
ͻͪͯͳ͹͸ͳ΁ͪ
͸ͪ

͹ͼͽͻͬ;
͈ͻ͹͵͹͸ͰͲ;
;
ͫͶͳͲͳ͸ͳ
́ͼͽͪ͸ͫ;Ͷͪ

̸͵͹
͸ͪͼͽͪͬͳͷ͹
ͯͪ
ͺ;ͽ;ΒͰͷ͹
ͯͪΓͰ
͋;ͻͼ͵͹ͷ
͸ͪΕͳ
ΕͰͷ͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪ

̾ͭͰΒͼ͵͹Β
͹ͫͪͶͳ
ͳͶͳ
̸ͬͰ͸ͳΒͳ
ͼͰΕͪΔͪ
͇ͬͪ͵͹
ͺ͹Ͱͽͳ΂ͪ͸
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ
ͼͶͰͯͰ
ΕͰͭ
͹ͯͰΓ͵ͪ
͹ͬ͹ͭͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
;
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹ͼͽͳ
͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽ͹ͷ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂
͵͹ͷ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌ;
ͰͭͰΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͻͳͷ͹ͻΒͪ
ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͱͽͳ΂͸͹ͷ
ͽͰ͵
ͼͽ;ͪͶ͸͹ͷ
Ͱ͵ͼ͵;ͻͼ;
ͺͻͰͯ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
;
;ͬ͹ͯ;
t̓ͻͪͽ͵ͪ

ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪi
͇ͬͳͷ
;ͬ͹ͯ͹ͷ
΂ͳͽͪͶͪ΁
ͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͰͶͰͷͰ͸ͽͪͻ͸ͳ
ͺͻͰ
ͭͶͰͯ
;
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ;
ͰͭͰΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͼͽͪͻͳΒͳ΀
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͯ͹

ͯͪ͸ͪ΃Δͳ΀
ͯͪ͸ͪ
͇ͬͪ͵ͪͬ
;ͬ͹ͯ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
͸ͪ
΃ͪͻͰ
͸͹Ͷͳ͵;
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵;
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽ
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃ΔͰ
͋;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͪ͵͹
ͯͪͽͳ
;
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳͷ

ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͺͻ;ͱͪΒ;
;ͬͳͯ
;
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͻͰͶͪ
΁ͳΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Β;
ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ
ͪͅͶ͹ͷ
̸ͲͳΒ͹ͷ
͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͬͶͪͯͪͶͳ

ͳͼͺͻͬͪ
͎Ͱͽͳͽͳ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
͎ͰͶͰ͸ͳ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
̻ͻ΁ͳ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
ͼͬ͹Βͳ΀
͵͹Ͷ͹
͸ͳΒͪ 
ͳ
͉ͳͷΓͪ͸ͳ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
ͺͻ͹ͬͳ͸΁ͳΒͪ
ͬͰΕ
ΒͰ
ͪͅͶͪ
̸ͲͳΒͪ
ͺͪͷͽͳͶͪ
ͳ



1
%FWBOCF[
(SBOEF[
#SPO[FT
EV
.VTFÊ
EF
4UBOCVM
1BSJT

m
m

1M
9997***m9-*7
7***m9**
97m9997**


/
$BNCJ
"OUJǁLJ
TBSLPGB[J
OB
JTUPǁOPK
PCBMJ
+BESBOB
4QMJU





+
.
$PPL
(SFFL
4FUUMFNFOU
JO
UIF
&BTUFSO
"FHFBO
BOE
"TJB
.JOPS
V
ѮF
$BNCSJHF
"ODJFOU
)JTUPSZ
$BNCSJHF

,VMUVSHFTDIJDIUF
EFT
"MUFO
7PSEFSBTJFO

#FSMJO

m
m

 ͉ͪͯͷͳͶͪ
̀͹ͽ͹ͬͳΕ

ͺͰͻͼͳΒͼ͵;
ͯ͹ͷͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒ;
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͺͻ͹Ͷͪͼ͵Ͱ
ͬ͹Βͼ͵Ͱ
̸ͶͰ͵ͼͪ͸ͯͻͪ
̺ͰͶͳ͵͹ͭ
͌

͹ͬ͹ͷ
͹ͯͰΓ͵;
ͺ͹ͷͳΔ;
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͷͰͼͽͳͷͪ
ͻ͹ΌͰΔͪ
ͳ
͸ͪΒ;΂Ͱ͸ͳΒͳ
Γ;ͯͳ

ͺͻ͹΀;ΒͪͶͳ΀
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
͋ͪͶͰͼ
̸͸ͪ͵ͼͳͷͪ͸ͯͪͻ
̸͸ͪ͵ͼͳͷͰ͸ͪ

ͳ
ͼͬ
ͪͺ͹ͼͽ͹Ͷ
͈ͪͬͶͰ
͇ͬ͹
;ͬ͹ͯ͸͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
ͯͪΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͳͲͬͰͼͽͪ͸
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ΒͰ
Ͳͭͻ͹ͬͳͽ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͷͪͶ͹
ͰͼͰΒͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺ
΃ͽ͹
͸ͳΒͰ
͹ͯ
ͷͪͶ͹ͭ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ

ΒͰͻ
;ͺͻͪͬ͹
͹ͬͪ͵ͪͬ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͳͲͶͪͭͪΔͪ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͯͪ
;
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁;
ͺͻ͹ͫ;ͯͳ
ͯͪΓͰ

ͳ
ͬͰΕͰ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͪ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ

ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ

͇ͬͪ͵ͪͬ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ
ͭͻ΂͵Ͱ
΀ͰͶͰ͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͻͳͷͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͻͪ͸͹΀ͻͳ΃Εͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
΁ͬͰͽͪͶͪ
ͺ͹
ͰͭͰΒͼ͵ͳͷ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ
ͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ

ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
;
;ͬ͹ͯ͸͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
͸ͪͭͶͪ΃ͪͬͪ
ͼͰ

ͯͪΓͰ
;
͹ͯͰΓ͵;
t̻ͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͶͰͽ͹ͬͪͶͳ΃ͽͪi
͈;ͽ͸ͳ͵
͸ͪͷͰͻ
͸ͳ͵
ͳ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂
;
ͼͽͪͶ͸͹Β
ͺ͹ͽͻͪͲͳ
Ͳͪ
ͯ;΀͹ͷ
ͼͽͪͻ͹ͭ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹΀;ΒͪͶ͹ͭ

ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΕͰ
;
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸;
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃ΔͰͷ
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳͷͪ
ͼͽͪͻͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ

͋ͻ͹ΒͰ
͈Ͱͻͭͪͷ͹͸ͪ
̾ͿͰͼͪ
̸Ϳͻ͹ͯͳͲͳΒͪͼͪ
͈ͻͳΒͰ͸Ͱ
ͅͳͶͰͽͪ
̽ͳͯͳͷͰ

͎ͳΒͰͻͪͺ͹Ͷͳͼͪ
͎ͪͶͳ͵ͪͻ͸ͪͼͪ
ͳ
̓͸ͳͯ͹ͼͪ

͇
͎͹ͷͰͻ͹ͬ͹Β
͋ͻ͹Βͳ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫ͸͹
ͺ;͸͹
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͽͳ
͇͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͰΕ

͸ͪ
͸ͪΒͶͰͺ΃ͳ
ͳ
͸ͪΒ;Ͳͫ;ͯΓͳͬͳΒͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
͹ͺͰͬͪ͸ͪ
;
́ͶͳΒͪͯͳ
ͪ
ΔͰ͸ͳ

Β;͸ͪ΁ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ
;
ͷͳͽ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳͷ
ͻͰ΂͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
̸ͻͭ;ͼ͹ͬ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ

ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͼͶͳ͵͹ͬͳͽ͹
ͷͳͽ͹Ͷ͹΃͵;
ͼͶͳ͵;
͋ͻ͹Βͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ

;ͺ͹ͽͺ;ΔͰ͸;
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
͹
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
͎ͳͼͪͻͶͳ͵ͪ
̀ͪ

ͺ͹΀ͬͪͶ;
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͳ͸ͪ΂Ͱ
ͻͰͽ͵͹
ͬͰͲ;Β;
Ͳͪ
ͼ;ͯ
ͫͳ͸;
ͽͲͬ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
͋ͻ͹ΒͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͷͰͼͽ;
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ΃ΔͰͭ
ͭͻͪͯͪ

ͳͲ
͎͹ͷͰͻ͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͳͲ͸ͳ͵Ͷ͹
΀ͰͶͰ͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹
ͳ
ͻͳͷͼ͵͹
͸ͪͼͰΓͰ
ͺ͹
ͼͶͰͯΔͳ
ͺ;ͽ
͹ͫ͸͹ͬΓͰ͸͹
Ͳͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
̸ͬͭ;ͼͽͪ
͵ͪ͹
*MJVN
/PWVN

͈͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͯͪͽͳ
;
̸ͻͭ;ͼ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;
;
ͬͰͲͳ
ͼͪ
͈Ͱͻͭͪͷ͹
͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲ;Β;
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͬͯͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪͶ͹
͸ͪͼͰΓͰ
ͪͻ΀ͪΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ
͵Ͷͪͼͳ΂͸͹ͭ
ͺͰ
ͻͳ͹ͯͪ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͼͺͻͬͪ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͺ͹ͯ
ͶͳͯͳΒͼ͵͹ͷ
ͪ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͺͰͻͼͳΒͼ͵͹ͷ
;ͺͻͪ
ͬ͹ͷ
ͳ
͸ͪͯͲ͹ͻ͹ͷ
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹

ͭ
ͺ
͸
Ͱ
ͳ
;ͺͻͪͬͰ
̸ͶͰ͵ͼͪ͸ͯͻͪ
̺ͰͶͳ͵͹ͭ

͈͹ͼͶͰ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
͊ͰͶͰ;͵ͳͯͪ
͈Ͱͻͭͪͷ͹͸
ΒͰ

ͭ
ͺ
͸
Ͱ
͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸
ͽͰͼͽͪ
ͷͰ͸ͽ͹ͷ
͉ͳͷ;
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
΂Ͱͭͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͭͶͪ΃Ͱ͸
Ͳͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͺͻ͹ͬͳ͸΁ͳΒͰ

̸ͲͳΒͰ
͈Ͱͻͭͪͷ͹͸
ΒͰ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸
͵ͪ͹
͸ͪΒͫͶͳͼͽͪͬͳΒͳ
;ͻͫͪ͸ͳ
ͳ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻ
ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ
;
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
΀ͰͶͰ͸ͳͲͷͪ
ͳ
ͻͳͷͼ͵Ͱ
Ͱͺ͹΀Ͱ

̽ͪΓͰ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͯͳ͸ͪͼͽͳΒͰ
̸ͽͪͶͳͯͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
΂;ͬͰ͸ͪ

ͺͰͻͭͪͷ͹͸ͼ͵ͪ
̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͽͰ͵ͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͪ
͹͵͹

ͼͬͳͽͪ͵ͪ
ͺͻͳ͵;ͺΓͰ
͸ͳ΀
ͳͲ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ΀
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͪ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͪ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ

ͬ
ͺ͸Ͱ



̺ͳͯͳ
͸ͺͻ
;
̸
͏Ͱͻͷͪ͸͹ͬͳἘ;Ͳͷͪ͸͹ͬͳΕm̽
͊ͻͰΒ͹ͬͳΕ
͉Ͱ΂͸ͳ͵
ͭͻ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ

ͻͳͷͼ͵Ͱ
ͷͳͽ͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ


 ̸͸ͽͳ΂͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ 

ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͪͶͰ͵ͼͪ͸ͯͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͳ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻ
ͼͽͪͻ͹ͭͪ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
̀ͪͽ͹
ͳ

͸ͳΒͰ
΂;ͯ͸͹
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͈Ͱͻͭͪͷ͹͸;
ͯͳͬͳͶͳ
ͳ
;
ΔͰͷ;
ͼͽͪͼͪͬͪͶͳ
͸ͪΒ;΂Ͱ͸ͳ
Βͳ
Γ;ͯͳ
͹͸͹ͭͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
̈́ͳͬͳΒͰ
ͳͶͳ
̻ͪͶͰ͸
΂;ͬͰ͸ͳ
ͿͳͲͳ
΂ͪͻ
ͼͽͪͻ͹ͭͪ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͶͰ͵ͪͻ
ͪͅͻ͵ͪ
̸;ͻͰͶͳΒͪ
͌
͈Ͱͻͭͪͷ͹͸;
ΒͰ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬͪ͸͹

ͳ
͸ͪΒͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳΒͰ
ͶͰ΂ͳͶͳ΃ͽͰ
;
͵͹ͷͰ
ΒͰ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͹ͼͽͪͶͳ΀
ͲͯͻͪͬͼͽͬͰ͸ͳ΀

ͽͻͰͽͷͪ͸ͪ
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ͵͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͽͰ΂ͪ
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃ΔͰ
ͺͼͳ΀͹ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͰ
m
͵͹͸ͼͽͪ
ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͳ
ͶͰ΂ͰΔͰ
ͺͼͳ΀͹ͿͳͲͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͲͯͻͪͬΓͪ
ͫ͹ͶͰͼ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳͷ

ͼ͸͹ͬͳͷͪ
͈͹ͻͰͯ
ͽ͹ͭͪ
͵͹ͻͳ΃ΕͰ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͷͰͯͳ΁ͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͽͻͰͽͷͪ͸ͳ
ͽ͹ͺͶͳ΀

͵;ͺ͵ͳ
ͷͪͼͪͱͪ
ͳ
ͳͼͺͳΒͪΔͪ
ͶͰ͵͹ͬͳͽͰ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͬ͹ͯͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͻͰͶͪ͵ͼͪ
΁ͳΒͪ
;
͹ͫͶͳͱΔ͹Β
ͫͳͫͶͳ͹ͽͰ΁ͳ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͳ΃ͽ;
͈͹ͻͰͯ
ͽ͹ͭͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
ͼͰ

ͯͪΓͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ
ͯͪ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒͰ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵͹
ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͳ΃ͽͰ
ͳ
̸͵ͻ͹ͺ͹Γ
͈͹Ͳ͹ͻͳ΃ͽͰ

ͼͰ
͹ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ΒͰͯ͸͹
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͫ͹Γͳ΀
͹͸͹ͭͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͼͬ͹ͭͪ
͵ͪͺͪ΁ͳ
ͽͰͽͪ
͹ͯ


ͼͰͯͳ΃ͽͪ
ͳ
ͼͽͻͷ͹ͭ
͸ͪͭͳͫͪ
ͽͰͻͰ͸ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͺͻͳ͸͹ͼͳ͹

ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸͹Β
ͪ͵;ͼͽͳ΁ͳ
̸͵ͻ͹ͺ͹Γ
ΒͰ
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸ͳΒͰ
͈͹ͷͳΔͰ

ͼͰ
͋ͻͪΒͪ͸Ͱ;ͷ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽ
;
ͼͶͪͬ;
ͻͳͷͼ͵ͳ΀
΁ͪͻͰͬͪ
͋ͻͪΒͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
͎ͪͯͻͳ
Βͪ͸ͪ
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳ
ͺͪͶͪͽͰ
̾;ͷͰ͸ͪ
**
ͳ
̸ͽͪͶͪ
*
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳ
΀ͻͪͷͪ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸͹ͭ

ͫ͹ͭͳΔͳ
̸ͽͳ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͽͰͷͰΓͳ
΂;ͬͰ͸͹ͭ
ͺͰͻͭͪͷ͹͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
͹Ͷͽͪͻͪ
͊ͷͪͽͻͪͷ͹

ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͼ͹Ͷͳͯ͸͹
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪ
ͬΓͰ͸ͳ
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
̸ͼ͵ͶͰͺͳ͹͸
ͼͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ͸ͳͷ
ͯͰͽͪΓͳͷͪ
͹
ͷͰͽ͹ͯͪ
ͷͪ
ͶͰ΂ͰΔͪ
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͷͰͯͳ΁ͳ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻ;
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͹ͫΒͪ΃ΔͰΔͰ

͸ͪͼͽͪ͸͵ͪ
ͳ
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͰ
ͺͰͻͭͪͷͰ͸ͽͪ
;
ͬͰͲͳ
ͼͪ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
͹
ͺͰͻͭͪ
ͷ͹͸ͼ͵͹Β
ͫͳͫͶͳ͹ͽͰ΁ͳ
͆͹
ͳͼͽ͹
ͽͪ͵͹
ͼͷͪͽͻͪͷ͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹

ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳͷ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽͳͷͪ
ͳ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳͷͪ
;ͺͻͪͬ͹
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ
͸͹ͭ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
;
ͳͲͬͰͼ͸͹Β
ͷͰͻͳ
;ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸ͳͽͳ
͋ͪ͵͹

͸ͺͻ
;
ͬͰͲͳ
ͼͪ
ͷͰͯͳ΁ͳ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻ͹ͷ
̸ͼ͵ͶͰͺͳ͹͸͹ͷ
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͪ

ͳͼͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͫͰͶͰͱͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͰ
ͿͪͲͰ
ͳͲͭͻͪͯΔͰ
ͳ
͹ͫ͸͹ͬͰ
͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀

ΒͰ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͪ
ͳͲͬͻ΃Ͱ͸ͪ
;
ͬͻͰͷͰ
΁ͪͻͪ
͎ͪͯͻͳΒͪ͸ͪ
͇
ͬͰͶͳ΂ͳ͸ͳ
͹ͬ͹
ͭͪ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͪ
ͷ͹ͱͯͪ
͸ͪΒͫ͹ΓͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͰͪͽͪͻ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽ
;Ͳ

ΔͰͭͪ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ͯͪ
ͺͻͳͷͳ
͹͵͹


ͭͶͰͯͪͶͪ΁ͪ
́ͼ͵͹ͺͪͬͪΔͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵Ͱ
ͪͻ
΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵Ͱ
΃͵͹ͶͰ
ͬͻ΃Ͱ͸ͪ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
͸ͪ
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
ͺ͹͵ͪͲͪͶͪ

ͼ;
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸Ͱͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸͹
;Ͳ
ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͳ΃ͽͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ͹
΀ͻͪͷ
ͫ͹ͭͪ
̽ͳ͹͸ͳͼͪ
́ͼ
͵͹ͺͪͬͪΔͪ
ͬͻ΃Ͱ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
̸͵ͻ͹ͺ͹Γ;
ͺͻ;ͱͳͶͪ
ͼ;
͸ͪ
;ͬͳͯ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
͹ͼͽͪͽͪ
͵ͪ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ͹͸ͼ͵͹ͯͰ͵͹ͻͪͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͺͶͪͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽ;
ͭͻͪΌͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
΂;ͬͰ͸͹ͭ

ͺͰͻͭͪͷ͹͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
͹Ͷͽͪͻͪ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸͹ͭ
̀Ͱͬͼ;
ͳ
̸ͽͰ͸ͳ
̸ͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ͹͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͶͰ



'ÛISFS
EVSDI
EJF
"VTTUFMMVOH
EFT
1FSHBNPONVTFVNT
"OUJLFTBNMVOH
**m***

#FSMJO




́ͼͽ͹



́ͼͽ͹
m
"CC


 ͉ͪͯͷͳͶͪ
̀͹ͽ͹ͬͳΕ

ͺ͹ͽͪ
͹ͬ͹ͭͪ
ͼͬͰͽͳͶͳ΃ͽͪ
ͼͪ
͵͹Ͷ͹͸ͪͯͪͷͪ
ͰͶͰͭͪ͸ͽ͸ͳ΀
ͯ͹ͻͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼͽ;ͫ͹ͬͪ

ͯ͹ͺ;ΔͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͪΒͪͻͼ͵͹ͷ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͻͰΓͰͿ͸͹ͭ
ͿͻͳͲͪ
͆ͪ
ΔͰͷ;
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ

̀Ͱͬͼͪ
ͳ
̸ͽͳ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ
̸ͺ͹Ͷ͹͸
̸ͻͽͰͷͳͯͪ
̈́Ͱͽͪ
͇͵Ͱͪ͸
̸ͷ
Ϳͳͽͻͳͽͪ
ͅ͹ΒͻͰ
ͫ͹ͭͳΔͰ
ͼ;ͯͫͳ͸Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͪ
ͫ͹ͱͪ͸ͼͽͬͪ
ͼͬͰͽͶ͹ͼͽͳ

ͳ
ͽͪͷͰ
ͪ
;
ͷͪ͸ͳͻ;
͸ͪΒͶͰͺ΃ͳ΀
ͺͻͳͷͰͻͪ
΀ͰͶͰ͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͼ͵;Ͷͺͽ;ͻͰ

͹͸͹ͭͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
͍ͻͳͲ
ͼͪ
;͸;ͽͻͪ΃ΔͰ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
͋ͰͶͰͿͪ
͎Ͱ
ͻͪ͵Ͷ͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͼͳ͸ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͺͻͳͺ͹ΒͰ͸
ͺͰͻͭͪͷ͹͸ͼ͵͹Β
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵͹Β
ͺ͹
ͻ͹ͯͳ΁ͳ
͇ͬ͹
ͼͰ
;
̸ͻͭ;ͼ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͼ;ͷͪͻ͸͹

͋ͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͼ;
;
ͺ͹ͽ;͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳͲ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸ͪ
ͼͬͰͽͳͶͳ΃ͽͪ
;
͈Ͱͻͭͪ
ͷ͹͸;
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸ͳ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳ
ͳ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳ
;ͻͫͪ͸͹ͭ
ͭͻͪΌͰͬͳ͸ͪͻͼͽͬͪ
ͳͲ

΀ͰͶͰ͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
̓ͪ͹
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
ͬͪͱ͸͹
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ

ͺͻ͹΃ͳͻͰΔͰ
Ͳͳͯ͹ͬͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
;
ͬͻͰͷͰ
̾;ͷͰ͸Ͱͼͪ
**
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
͹ͫ;΀ͬͪͽͳͶ͹

Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸Ͱ
ͽͪ΂͵Ͱ
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵͹ͭ
;ͻͫͪ͸ͳͲͷͪ
Ͳ͸ͪͽ͸͹
ͺͻ͹΃ͳͻͰ͸͹ͭ
;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ;

͸ͪ
Ͳͳͯ͹ͬͰ
΁ͳͽͪͯͰͶͰ
ͳͲ
͸ͪΒͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸ͳΒͰ
m
ͬ
ͺ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͼ͵Ͱ
Ͳͳͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳͲ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
͍ͳͶͰͽͰͻ͹ͼͪ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͺͻͬͰ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

ͬ
ͺ͸Ͱ

͋ͪ͵͹ΌͰ
;
΀ͰͶͰ͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
͸͹ͬͪ
ͽͻͱ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͵ͪ͹

ͳ
͎Ͱͻ͹͹͸
Ͳͭͻͪͯͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳͶͪ
ͳ
;
ͻͳͷͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
̺ͰͲͪ͸͹
Ͳͪ

͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͳ
ͻͳͷͼ͵ͳ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
͸ͪͬͰͼͽͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͫͳ͹

;ͬͰΕͪ͸
ͳ
;ͶͰͺ΃ͪ͸
ͳͲͭͻͪͯΔ͹ͷ
ͼͽͪͯͳ;ͷͪ
ͳ
ͪͷͿͳͽͰͪͽͻͪ
͌
ͬͻͰͷͰ
΁ͪͻͪ

͎ͪͯͻͳΒͪ͸ͪ
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽ
ͽͲͬ
͏ͻͬͰ͸ͳ
΀ͻͪͷ
΂ͳΒͳ
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳ
ͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ

ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
;Ͳͫ;ͯΓͳͬ
ͯ͹͵ͪͲ
ͫͻͲ͹ͭ
΃ͳͻͰΔͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
̓ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
΁ͪͻ
͎ͪ
ͯͻͳΒͪ͸
;
ͫ;͵ͬͪͶ͸͹ͷ
ͼͷͳͼͶ;
ͽͰ
ͻͰ΂ͳ
ͫͳ͹
͹ͫ;ͲͰͽ
̾ͭͳͺͽ͹ͷ
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
͹ͬͪΒ

΀ͻͪͷ
ͫͳ͹
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸
Ͱͭͳͺͪͽͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫ͹ͭ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͊Ͱͻͪͺͳͼ;
ͳ
́ͼͳͯͳ
͆ͪ

΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͯͳΒ;ͷ;
͹ͬ͹ͭ
΀ͻͪͷͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
ͼͽͪͽ;ͪ
ͫ͹ͭͪ

͊Ͱͻͪͺͳͼͪ
;
͵͹Β;
ͼ;
ͺ;ͽͰͷ
ͯ͹ΔͰͭ
ͼ͵ͻͳͬͰ͸͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹ͶͪͲͪ
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
;Εͳ
ͼͬͰ
΃ͽͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͳ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͺ͹ͼͽͳΕͳ
ͰͿͰ͵ͪͽ
tͫ͹ͭͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳi
͇ͯ
ͼͽͪͻͳΒͳ΀

ͼͬͰͽͳͶͳ΃ͽͪ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
ͼͬͰͽͳͶͳ΃ͽͰ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸͹
͎Ͱͻͳ

͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
;
ͬͻͰͷͰ

ͬ
ͺ͸Ͱ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽ͹
ͺͶͰ͸ͳͶ͹
ͺͪͱΔ;
ͬͰͻ͸ͳ
͵ͪ
ͳ
͹ͫͳ΂͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͼͷͪͽͻͪ΂ͪ
ͺͻͰͶͰͺ͹ͷ
ͰͶͰͭͪ͸΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͯ͹ͻͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼͽ;ͫ͹ͬͪ

̸͵͹
͸ͪͼͽͪͬͳͷ͹
ͯͪ
ͺ;ͽ;ΒͰͷ͹
ͯͪΓͰ
ͰͭͰΒͼ͵͹ͷ
͹ͫͪͶ͹ͷ
ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ

;Ͳ
ͺ͹ͷ͹Ε
̸ͻͭ;ͼ͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
͸ͪͳΕͳ
ΕͰͷ͹
͸ͪ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͶͰͺ΃ͳ΀

ͳ
͸ͪΒͫ͹ΓͰ
͹΂;ͬͪ͸ͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͼͽͪͻ͹ͭͪ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
m
̾ͿͰͼ
͇
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͳ
͹ͬ͹ͭ

ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͸ͪΒͫ͹ΓͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;
ΔͰͷ;
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ͹
̸ͻͽͰ
ͷͳͯͳ͸
΀ͻͪͷ
ΒͰͯ͸͹
͹ͯ
ͼͰͯͪͷ
΂;ͯͪ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ

ͭ
ͺ͸Ͱ

ͫͳ͹
ͲͪͺͪͶͳ͹
ͳͲͬͰͼ͸ͳ
͎Ͱͻ͹ͼͽͻͪͽ
ͪ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͭͪ
͹ͫ͸͹ͬͳ͹
̸ͶͰ͵ͼͪ͸ͯͪͻ



́ͼͽ͹
m
"CC


m
83BEU
(VJE
UP
1FSHBNPO
m
'ÛISFS
m

3FICFSÐ
*TUBOCVM



1M



́ͼͽ͹
m
 ̸͸ͽͳ΂͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ 

ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ
̺ͰΕ
ͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸͹
͸ͪͫͻͪΒͪΔͰ
Βͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͭͻͪΌͰͬͳ͸ͪ
;
ͫͰ
ͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;
ͯ͹ͺͻͳ͸͹ͼͳ
ͯͪ
Ͳͪͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂
ͼͽͰ͵͸Ͱ

;ͽͳͼͪ͵
͹
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͳ
ͳ
ͬͰͶͳ΂ͳ͸ͳ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼ;
͸ͪͫͻ͹Βͪ͸ͳ
͊Ͱͻͪ
ͺͳͼ͹ͬ
΀ͻͪͷ

ͬ
ͺ͸Ͱ

̽͹ͷͳ΁ͳΒͪ͸͹ͬ
ͳ
͎ͪͯͻͳΒͪ͸͹ͬ
΀ͻͪͷ
͇ͯͰ͹͸

ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͳ΃ͽͰ
͏ͰͶͲ;ͼ͹ͬͪ
ͫͳͫͶͳ͹ͽͰ͵ͪ
͊΀͹Ͷͪͼͽͳ͵ͳ͸ͪ
͵;ͺͪͽͳͶͪ
ͯ͹Δͪ

̸ͭ͹ͻͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͽͲͬ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͪ
̸ͭ͹ͻͪ
ͼͪ
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳͷͪ
ͳͲ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
̸ͬͭ;ͼͽͪ
ͳ

̓Ͷͪ;ͯͳΒͪ
ͳ
͵ͪͺͳΒͪ
ͪͭͅ͸ͰͲͳΒͪ
ͳͲ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
΁ͪͻͪ
̺ͰͼͺͪͲͳΒͪ͸ͪ
͈ͻͰͷͪ

΀ͻ͹͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵͹ͷ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͳ
;
ͳͼͽ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͳ

΀ͻͳ΃Εͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪ
͵;Εͪ
͈ͻͰͼͬͰͽͰ
̹͹ͭ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΁Ͱ
͎ͻͳ΃Εͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ

ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͼͪ
ͯ;΀͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹΀;ΒͪͶͰ
ͪ͸ͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪ
ͳ
ͫͪͲͳͶͳ͵ͪ
ͼͬ

ͪͺ͹ͼͽ͹Ͷͪ
͠͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽͪ
;

ͬͰ͵;
ͪ͠ͼ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͹͸ͯͪ΃Δͳ
̾ͿͰͼ

ͫͳ͹
ͭͻͪͯ
͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
΁ͪͻͰͬͪ
ͿͳͶ͹Ͳ͹Ϳͪ
ͺͰͼ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͼͰ͸ͪͽ͹ͻͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͳ
ͽͻ
ͭ͹ͬͪ΁ͪ
ͳ
ͪͺ͹ͼͽ͹Ͷͪ
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͳ
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͪ͵
ͪͺ͹ͼͽ͹Ͷͪ
͈ͪͬͶͪ
ͳ

ΒͰͯͬͪ
;ͭ;΃Ͱ͸;
ͫ;͸;
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͷͰΌ;ͼ͹ͫ͸͹ͭ
͹ͫͻͪ΂;͸ͪ
΀ͻͳ΃Εͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͫ͹ͱͪ΁ͪ
;
ͬͰͲͳ
ͼͪ
ͺ͹΃ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰͷ
̸ͻͽͰͷͳͯͰ
̾ͿͰͼ͵Ͱ
̽ͪΓͰ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͯͪ

ΒͰ
;
̾ͿͰͼ;
ͪͺ͹ͼͽ͹Ͷ
͈ͪͬͶͰ
͹ͯͻͱͪ͹
ͼͬ͹Β;
ͺ͹ͼͶͪ͸ͳ΁;
̾ͿͰ΃ͪ͸ͳͷͪ
͹
ͷͰ
Ό;ͼ͹ͫ͸͹Β
Γ;ͫͪͬͳ
ͳ
Γ;ͫͪͬͳ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
͎ͻͳͼͽ;
ͳ
΁ͻ͵ͬͳ
ͳ
;ͼͺͰ͹
ͯͪ
͹ͻͭͪ



͌ͺ͹ͻͰͯͳ
͆͹ͬͳ
ͲͪͬͰͽ
ͺͻͰͬ͹ͯ
̺
͊ͽͰͿͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ
̓ͪͻͪΘͳΕ

̽ͰͶͪ
ͪͺ͹ͼͽ͹Ͷͼ͵ͪ

ͭͶ


 ͉ͪͯͷͳͶͪ
̀͹ͽ͹ͬͳΕ

͸ͳͲ;ΒͰ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸;
΀ͻͳ΃Εͪ͸ͼ͵;
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΁;
ͽͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͬͯͰ
ͪͺ͹ͼͽ͹Ͷ
͠͹ͬͪ͸

͸ͪͺͳͼͪ͹
͠Ͱͬͪ͸ΌͰΓͰ
ͳ
ͫͻͳ͸;͹
ͼͰ
͹
ͪͅΒ΁ͳ
̹͹ͱΒ͹Β
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹
ΔͰ͸Ͱ
ͼͷͻͽͳ

̓;Εͪ
̹͹ͭ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΁Ͱ
;
͵͹Β͹Β
ΒͰ
͹͸ͪ
ͱͳͬͰͶͪ
ͳ
;ͷͻͶͪ
͹ͽͬ͹ͻͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰ
ͽͳ͹΁Ͱ
ͷͪ΀͹ͷ
΀͹ͯ͹΂ͪͼ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͫͪͲͳͶͳ͵ͪ
ͼͬ
͠͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͫͪͲͳͶͳ͵ͪ
ͼͬ

ͪͅͻͳΒͰ
͇ͬͪ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͪ
ͼͷͪͽͻͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͬ͹ͷ
΁ͻ͵ͬ͹ͷ
;
ͼͬͰͽ;
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸͹Β

ͪͅΒ΁ͳ
̹͹ͱΒ͹Β
͈͹ͻͰͯ
͹ͬͳ΀
΀ͻͳ΃Εͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼͬͰͽͳͶͳ΃ͽͪ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͼͰ
ͯͪ

;
̾ͿͰͼ;
ͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ͼͽ͹ΒͰ
͸ͰͲ͸ͪͽ͸ͳ
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳ
̸ͻͽͰͷͳͯͳ͸͹ͭ
΀ͻͪͷͪ
ͽͳͺͪ

ͯͳͺͽͰͻ͹ͼͪ
΀ͻͪͷͪ
ͼͪ
ͯͬͪ
ͻͰͯͪ
ͼͽ;ͫ͹ͬͪ
;͵ͻͪ΃Ͱ͸͹ͭ
ͼͽͪͽ;͹ͷ
ͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳͷ
ͼͽͪͽ;Ͱͽͪͷͪ
͹ͬͰ
ͫ͹ͭͳΔͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
΀ͻͳ΃Εͪ͸ͳ
;
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͸ͪͬͻͪͽͪ

ͺ͹͵;΃ͪͬͪͶͳ
ͳ
;
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
;ͼͺͰͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͳͼͺͻͰͽ;ͻͪΒ;
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͷͰ
͊
͹ͫͲͳͻ͹ͷ

ͯͪ
ΒͰ
̸ͻͽͰͷͳͯͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Β;
ͺ͹΃ͽ͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
͵ͪ͹
ͫ͹ͭͳ
Δͪ
Ͷ͹ͬͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͫ͹ͭͳΔͪ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͷͪΒ͵ͪ
ͼͬͰ͵͹Ͷͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͰ
ͳ

ͺͶ͹ͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͳ
΂;ͯ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
͹͵͹
ͺ͹΃ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ΔͰ͸͹ͭ
͵;Ͷͽͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ

ͫͳ͹
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸͹
Βͪ͵
ͳͲͫͳΒͪͶͳ
ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵ͳ
ͼ;͵͹ͫͳ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
΀ͻͳ΃Εͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͺͪͭͪ
͸ͪ
͠Ͱͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͽͪ͵ͬͳ΀
ͼ;͵͹ͫͪ
ͺͪͷͽͰ
ͳ
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳ
ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͳ΃ͽͪ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽ͹ͭ

;

ͬ
ͺ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͵͹͸ͪ΂͸͹
ͯ͹ͭͻͪΌͰ͸͹ͷ
ͳ
Ͳͪͬͻ΃Ͱ͸͹ͷ
;
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
͹ͯ
΁ͪͻͪ

̓Ͷͪ;ͯͳΒͪ
ͯ͹
͋ͻͪΒͪ͸ͪ
͈͹Ͳ͹ͻͳ΃ͽͰ
ΒͰ
ͫͻ͹ΒͪͶ͹
͹͵͹

ͻͰͯ͹ͬͪ
Ͳͪ
ͼͰͯͳ
΃ͽͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͶͪ΁ͪ
ͳ
ͫͳͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸͹
ͪ͵;ͼͽͳ΂͸͹
;ͼͶͰͯ
͸ͪͭͳͫͪ
ͽͰͻͰ͸ͪ

͌
ΔͰͷ;
ΒͰ
ͪͺ͹ͼͽ͹Ͷ
͈ͪͬͶͰ
ͯͻͱͪ͹
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͰ
ͺ͹ͼͶͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
̾ͿͰ΃ͪ͸ͳ
ͷͪ
͵ͪͯͪ
ͼ;
ͺͻͳͼͽͪͶͳ΁Ͱ
ͳ
ͺ͹΃ͽ͹ͬͪ͹΁ͳ
̸ͻͽͰͷͳͯͳ͸͹ͭ
͵;Ͷͽͪ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ

ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹͵;΃ͪͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͭͪ
;ͫͳΒ;
͆Ͱͼ;ͷΔͳͬ͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͽͰ͵ͪ
;

̾ͿͰͼ;
ͺͪͷͽͳͶͪ
ͺͻ͹Ͷͪͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͼͽͪͼͪͬͪΔͪ
ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳ΀
;΂Ͱ͸ͳ΀
Γ;ͯͳ
͹͸͹ͭͪ

ͯ͹ͫͪ
͈͹ͯͳͭͪ͹
Β;
ΒͰ
;
ͯͻ;ͭ͹Β
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͳ

ͬ
͸Ͱ
͵͹͸Ͳ;Ͷ
̸ͲͳΒͰ
̻
͠;Ͷͳ;ͼ

͏ͰͶͲ;ͼ
͈͹ͶͰͷͪͰ͸;ͼ
ͳͶͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ
ͼͳ͸
͠;Ͷͳ;ͼ
̸͵ͬͳͶͪ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͷ

ͲͪͬͰ΃ͽͪΔ;
͊ͷͪͽͻͪͷ͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
͸ͪͭͶͪͼͳͽͳ
ͯͪ
͹
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͳ
͹ͬ͹ͭͪ

ͲͯͪΔͪ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͰ
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͻͪͬͪ
ͺͳͶͪͼͽͪͻͪ
ͳ
͵͹ͻͳ͸ͽͼ͵ͳ΀
͵ͪͺͳͽͰ
Ͷͪ
ͼͪ
;͵ͻͪͼͳͷͪ
ͪΒͰͻ΃ͽͪͫͪ
ͬ͹Ͷ;ͽͪ
ͪ͵ͪ͸ͽ;ͼ͹ͬ͹ͭ
Ͷͳ΃Εͪ
ͳ
ͫͳΓ͸ͳ΀
ͳ

ͿͶ͹ͻͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͺͶͰͽͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳ
ͽͳͷͺͪ͸͹͸ͪ
ͼͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͹ͷ
ͅͰͯ;ͲͰ
ͳ

ͻ͹ͲͰͽͪͷͪ
͋ͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ΒͰ
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
͸ͪͶͪͲ
΂;ͬͰ͸͹ͭ
͏ͰͶͲ;ͼ͹ͬ͹ͭ

ͼͪͻ͵͹Ϳͪͭͪ
͇ͬͪΒ
ͼͪͻ͵͹Ϳͪͭ
͸ͪΌͰ͸
;͸;ͽͪͻ
ͼͻͰͯΔͰ
͸ͳ΃Ͱ
̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͽͰ͵Ͱ

ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͳͲͻͪΌͰ͸
͹ͯ
ͷͰͻͷͰͻͪ
ͼͪ
ͭͻ΂͵͹ͭ
͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
͈ͪͻ͹ͼͪ
̓;ͽͳΒͪ
ͼͪͻ͵͹
Ϳͪͭͪ
ΒͰ
;͵ͻͪ΃Ͱ͸ͪ
ͭͳͻͶͪ͸ͯͪͷͪ
͹ͯ
ͻ͹ͲͰͽͪ
΃ͳ΃ͪͻ͵ͳ
Ͷͳ΃Εͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͺͶͰ
ͽͰ͸ͳ΀
ͽͻͪ͵ͪ
ͼͪ
ͪͷ͹ͻͳͷͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
ͳ
ͻ͹ͲͰͽͪͷͪ
;͸;ͽͪͻ
ͺ͹Ͷ;͵ͻ;ͱ͸ͳ΀

ͺ͹Γͪ
͈͹͵Ͷ͹ͺͪ΁
ͼͪͻ͵͹Ϳͪͭͪ
ͳͷͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͻͰΓͰͿ͸Ͱ
;͵ͻͪͼͰ
;
ͬͳͯ;
ͬ͹Ͷ;ͽͪ
ͳ

ͭͶͪͬͪ
ͅͰͯ;ͲͰ
͌
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽͰ
͹ͼͽͪͽ͵Ͱ
ͼͺͪͯͪΒ;
ͳ
ͼ͵;Ͷͺͽ;ͻͰ
ͳͲ
̹ͳͫͶͳ



'PSTDIVOHFO
JO
&QIFTPT
#BOE
7
)Fѫ 
8JFO


"CC
 

5
*
**



́ͼͽ͹
m
"CC
m

"CC



́ͼͽ͹
m
"CC



 ̸͸ͽͳ΂͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ 

͹ͽͰ͵Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;
͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔ;
ͪ
Ͳͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͽͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͯͪ
ͼ;

ͫͳͶͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͫͳͫͶͳ͹ͽͰ͵ͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͳͲͭͻͪΌͰ͸ͪ
͌
ͽͪ͵ͬͰ

ͼͰ
;ͫͻͪΒͪΒ;
ͼͽͪͽ;Ͱ
ͽͲͬ
ͱͰ͸ͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
͊͹ͿͳΒͰ
̸ͻͰͽͰ
ͳ
̾ͺͳͼͽͰͷͰ 

͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͼͽͪͽ;Ͱͽͪ
ͅͰͶͺ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
ͼͪͯͪ
;
ͅ;ͲͰΒ;
;
̹Ͱ΂; 
ͳ
ͼͽͪͽ;ͪ
ͷ;΃͵ͪͻ
΁ͪ
;
ͺͪ͸΁ͳͻ;
ͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸͹
͵͹͸Ͳ;Ͷͪ
͏ͰͶͲ;ͼͪ
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͰ͸ͪ
;
̸͸ͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ

ͷ;ͲͰΒ;
;
́ͼͽͪ͸ͫ;Ͷ;
͋ͻͰͫͪ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
Β͹΃
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͼͺ͹
ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ;ͻͰ
ͳ
;ͻͫͪ͸ͳͲͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͳͼ;
͸ͪͫͻ͹Βͪ͸ͳ
;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;

ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒ;
ͽͲͬ
ͪͬͭ;ͼͽ͹ͬͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
;
͵͹ͷͰ
ΒͰ
̾ͿͰͼ
ͳ͸ͪ΂Ͱ

ͯ͹ͼͽͳͭͪ͹
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͳ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ͹͸ͼ͵͹;ͻͫͪ͸ͳ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
͌
ͽͪ͵ͬͰ
ͼͺ͹
ͷͰ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͼͺͪͯͪ
ͳ
΂;ͬͰ͸ͪ
͵ͪͺͳΒͪ
ͅͰͲ;ͼͪ
ͳ
ͅͳͽͻͳͯͪͽͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
Β;ͱ͸ͪ

͵ͪͺͳΒͪ
̸ͭ͹ͻͰ
ͅͰͲ;ͼ
ͳ
ͅͳͽͻͳͯͪͽ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͼͪ΂;ͬͪ͸͹ͷ
ͰͺͳͭͻͪͿ
ͼ͵͹ͷ
͸ͪͽͺͳͼ;
ͫͳͶͳ
΁ͪͻͼ͵ͳ
ͻ͹ͫ͹ͬͳ
m
͹ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ΌͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͺ͹ͻͰ͵Ͷ͹ͷ
͹ͻͳ
ΒͰ͸ͽͪͶ΁ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭͶͳ
ͼ;
͹ͬ;
͵ͪͺͳΒ;
͸ͪΒͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸ͳΒͰ

ͳͶͳ

ͭ
ͺ͸Ͱ

ͳ
;͵ͻͪͼͳͶͳ
ΒͰ
Β͹͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺͳͶͪͼͽͻͳͷͪ
͇ͯ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳ΀
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͽͻͰͫͪ

ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
ͅͰͷͳΒ;ͼ͹ͬ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵
͊Ͱ͵ͼͽͳͶͳΒͪ
͈͹ͶͳΒͪ
͵ͪ͹

ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵
̸ͬͭ;ͼͽͪ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͭ
;Βͪ͵ͪ
͌
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͊Ͱ͵ͼͽͳͶͳΒͪ
͈͹ͶͳΒͪ

ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͳͲͭͻͪΌͰ͸
ͳ
ͽͲͬ
ͪ͵ͬͪͯ;͵ͽ
͊
͈͹ͶͳΒͪ
;
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
͹ͯ
m
ͭ͸Ͱ

͌
ͳͼͽ͹ͷ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
ͫͳͶͰ
ͼ;
ͳͲͭͻͪΌͰ͸Ͱ
"RVB
5SPFTTJUJDB
ͳ
"RVB
*VMJB
ͺ͹
ͺͶ͹΂ͪ͸ͪ
;Ͷͳ΁ͪ
͵ͪ
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵͹Β
ͬͰΕ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͳ
ͳͲͬͰͯͰ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
ͺͻͳͬͪͽ͸ͳ

ͳ
Βͪͬ͸ͳ
ͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
͹
΂Ͱͷ;
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂Ͱ
ͼͪ΂;ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͰͺͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͽͺͳͼͳ
ͅͰΌ;

Δͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ͫͳͶͪ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͪ
ͳͲͭͻͪͯΔͪ
ͫͪͲͳͶͳ͵Ͱ
͸ͪ
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵͹Β

ͽͻͱ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͇ͬͪ
ͫͪͲͳͶͳ͵ͪ
ͼͰ
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳͷͪ
ͺͪͷͽͳ
ͺ͹
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͳ
ͼͽ;ͫ͹
ͬͪ
ͳ
͵ͪͺͳͽͰͶͪ
ͯ͹ͻͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ
͵͹ͻͳ͸ͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͽͳͶͪ
ͼͪ
ͪ͵ͪ͸ͽ;ͼ͹ͬͳͷ
Ͷͳ΃ΕͰͷ

ͳ
ͻ͹ͲͰͽͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͳͲͯͬͪΒͪ
ͺ͹
͸Ͱ͹ͫͳ΂͸ͳͷ
͵ͪͺͳͽͰͶͳͷͪ
ͼͪ
ͭͶͪͬͪͷͪ
ͫͳ͵ͪ

̈́Ͱͺ͹ͽͪ
͹ͼͽͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ͹͸ͼ͵͹ͯͰ͵͹ͻͪͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͺͶͪͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ

̾ͿͰͼͪ
ΒͰ
;ͺͻͪͬ͹
͹͸͹
ͺ͹
΂Ͱͷ;
ΒͰ
͹ͬͪΒ
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͼͪͯͪ
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ

Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽ
΂;ͬͰ͸
ͪ
΃ͽ͹
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
̓ͪ͹
ͯͪ
͸ͳ
͸ͪ

ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͷ
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵͹ͷ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽ;
͸ͳΒͰ
͵͹͸ͼͽͪͽ͹ͬͪ͸͹
ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹

͹ͫͳΓͰ
͹ͼͽͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ͹͸ͼ͵͹ͯͰ͵͹ͻͪͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͺͶͪͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͳͲͻͪΌͰ͸Ͱ
;

ͽͪ͵͹
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸ͳͷ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͪͬ͸ͳͷ
ͪ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͰͶͰͭͪ͸ͽ͸͹
ͶͰͺͳͷ
Ͷͳ͸ͳΒͪͷͪ

ͪͻ΀ͳͽͻͪͬͪ
ͺͳͶͪͼͽͪͻͪ
ͳ
͵ͪͺͳͽͰͶͪ
͢ͳ΀͹ͬͰ
ͰͶͰͭͪ͸ͽ͸Ͱ
Ͷͳ͸ͳΒͰ
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͪ



́ͼͽ͹
m
"CC


m
"CC




́ͼͽ͹

"CC



́ͼͽ͹

"CC




8
"M[JOHFS
"VHVTUFJTDIF
"SDIJUFLUVS
JO
&QIFTPT
8JFO

#BOE
97*m
97**
m
"CC
m



́ͼͽ͹
m
"CC
m
m
"CC

m
"CC





́ͼͽ͹
m
"CC



́ͼͽ͹
m
"CC
m

 ͉ͪͯͷͳͶͪ
̀͹ͽ͹ͬͳΕ

Β;
ͻͪͲͳͭͻͪ͸;
ͶͰͺ͹ͽ;
ͻͰΓͰͿ͸ͳ΀
;͵ͻͪͼͪ
ͳͲͬͰͯͰ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͪ΂͸͹
ͳͶͳ

;
ͺͻͰͺͶͰͽͳͷͪ
ͷ͹ͽͳͬͪ
ͻ͹ͲͰͽͪ
ͪΒͰͻ΃ͽͪͫͪ
ͪ͵ͪ͸ͽ;ͼ͹ͬ͹ͭ
Ͷͳ΃Εͪ
ͭͳͻ
Ͷͪ͸ͯͳ
ͳ
΃ͳ΃ͪͻ͵ͳ
̸͵͹
ͼͰ
;Ͳ
ͽ͹
ͲͪͷͳͼͶͰ
ͳ
ͻͰΓͰͿ͸ͳ
;͵ͻͪͼͳ
̸ͷ͹ͻͪ

ͭͶͪͬͪ
ͅͰͯ;ͲͰ
ͼͽͪͽ;ͪ
ͫ͹ͭ͹ͬͪ
ͳ
΁ͪͻͰͬͪ
ͻͪͲͷͰ΃ͽͰ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹
;Ͷͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͽͻ
ͭ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͺͻ͹΂ͰΓͳͷͪ
ͳ
;͸;ͽͻͪ΃Δ͹ͼͽͳ
Βͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͭͻͪΌͰͬͳ͸ͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͽͰ΃͵͹

ͲͪͷͳͼͶͳͽͳ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸;
ͶͰͺ͹ͽ;
ͪ͸ͽͳ͵Ͱ
͵͹Β;
ΒͰ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹͵;΃ͪ͹
ͯͪ

͹ͱͳͬͳ
ͳ
ͺͻͰ͵͹ͺͳͻͪ
Β͹΃
ΒͰͯͳ͸͹
ͼͬͰͽ
ͻͰ͸Ͱͼͪ͸ͼͰ
ͳ
ͫͪͻ͹͵ͪ

̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͷ
ͼͰ
ͯͪΓͰ
ͺ;ͽ;ΒͰ
ͳ
ͯ͹
̸Ϳͻ͹ͯͳͲͳΒͪͼͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
;
ͪ͸
ͽͳ΂͵͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͫͳ͹
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ
ͺ͹
͸Ͱͭ͹ͬͪΔ;
ͿͳͶ͹Ͳ͹ͿͳΒͰ
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͷͰ
ͯͳ΁ͳ͸Ͱ
͈͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͼͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ͻͰͶͪͽͳͬ͸͹
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹
͹΂;ͬͪ͸
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳ

ͼͽͪͯͳ͹͸
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͬͰΕͳ΀
͹͸ͯͪ΃ΔͰͭ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳ
΀ͻͪͷͪ

ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸͹ͭ
ͫ͹ͭͳΔͳ
Γ;ͫͪͬͳ
̸Ϳͻ͹ͯͳͽͳ
͇ͼͳͷ
ͽ͹ͭͪ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͼͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͪ͸
ͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͳͷͪ͹
ͳ
ͪͭ͹ͻ;
ͼͽͪͯͳ͹͸
ͳ
͵;ͺͪͽͳͶͪ
͆ͰͯͪͶͰ͵͹
͹ͯ
̸Ϳͻ͹ͯͳ
ͲͳΒͪͼͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
͈ͻͳΒͰ͸ͪ
ͭͻͪͯ
Ͳͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
Ͳ͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲ;
͵͹ͬͪ͸͹ͭ
͸͹ͬ΁ͪ

ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
΂Ͷͪ͸
͠͹͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͶͳͭͰ
͌
͸ͪΒͼͽͪͻͳΒͰ
ͭͻͪΌͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
͹ͬ͹ͭͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͵͹Βͳ

ΒͰ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͻͪͼͽͪ͹
;
΀ͰͶͰ͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹
ͳ
ͻͳͷͼ͵͹
͸ͪͼͰΓͰ
ͼͺͪͯͪ
ͼͬͰͽͳ
Ͷͳ΃ͽͰ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸͹
̽ͰͷͰͽͻͳ
ͳ
̓͹ͻͳ
ͪ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͳ
΀ͻͪͷ
ͫ͹ͭͳΔͰ
̸ͽͰ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ

΂ͳΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹ͬͻ΃ͰΔͰ
ͳͲͭͻͪͯΔͰ
ͺ͹ͫͻͳ͸;͹
̸ͶͰ͵ͼͪ͸ͯͪͻ
̺ͰͶͳ͵ͳ
͇ͬͯͰ
ͼ;

ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
͹ͽ͵ͻͳͬͰ͸ͳ
ͳ
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳ
̀Ͱͬͼ͹ͬ͹ͭ
΀ͻͪͷͪ
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵Ͱ
ͬͰΕ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͳ
ͺ͹
Ͳ͹ͻͳ΃ͽͪ
́ͲͷͰΌ;
̸Ϳͻ͹ͯͳͲͳΒͪͼͪ
ͳ
͈ͻͳΒͰ͸Ͱ
;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;
ͼͰ
;
͵ͻͪͽ͵ͳͷ

΁ͻͽͪͷͪ
ͯͪΒ;
ͳ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
͎ͳΒͰͻͪͺ͹Ͷͳͼ;
͈͹ͻͰͯ

͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
͹ͬ
ͯͰ
͹΂;ͬͪ͸ͳ
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳ
͵;ͺͪͽͳ
Ͷͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͳ΃ͽͪ
ͳͲ
ͻͳͷͼ͵͹ͭ

ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͷͪͻͽͳͻͳΒ;
ͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
;

ͬ
ͳͲͭͻͪΌͰ͸
͸ͪ

ͷͰͼͽ;
ͭͯͰ
ΒͰ

ͭ
ͺ͹ͭ;ͫΓͰ͸

ͼͬ
ͪͺ͹ͼͽ͹Ͷ
͍ͳͶͳͺ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ

ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͳ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸͹

ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽͪ͸
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵
m
ͯͪ

ͼ;
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͹͸͹ͭͪ
ͯ͹ͫͪ

ͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͶͳ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͷͰͼͽ;

͎ͳΒͰͻͪͺ͹Ͷͳͼͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
ΒͰͯͪ͸

͹ͯ
;ͶͪͲͪ
;
ͺ͹ͯͲͰͷ͸ͳ
͎ͪͯ

ͅͳͶͰͽ
ͳ
̽ͳͯͳͷͪ

Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽͳ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
͹͸͹ͭͪ

ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ
ͼ;

;
̸ͻͭ;ͼ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͳ
;

͸ͪΒ͵ͻͪΕͳͷ
΁ͻͽͪͷͪ
̀ͪ
ͅͳ
 ̸͸ͽͳ΂͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ 

ͶͰͽ
ͼͰ
͵ͪͱͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͬͰ
Εͳ͸ͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
͹͵͹


ͭ
ͺ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪ͹
ͯͰ͹

ͻͳͷͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͬͳ͸΁ͳΒͰ
̸Ͳͳ
ΒͰ
ͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͽͪ͵ͪͬ
;ͶͰͺ΃ͪ͸

ͷ͸͹ͭͳͷ
ͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹

ͼ;
ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͳ΃ͽͰ
͆ͳͷͿͰ;ͷ

͵;ͺͪͽͳͶͪ
ͳ
ͼͰͬͰͻ͸ͪ
͵ͪͺͳ
Βͪ
Β;ͱ͸Ͱ
̸ͭ͹ͻͰ
͆ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹
ͷͰ͸;ͽͪ
΂;ͬͰ͸ͪ
ͷͳͶͰͽͼ͵ͪ

ͯͰ͵͹ͻͪͽͳͬ͸ͪ
ͽͰͻͪ͵͹ͽͪ 

ͳ
ͼ͵;Ͷͺͽ;ͻͰ
ͪͻ΀ͪΒͼ͵͹ͭ

ͅͳͶͰͽͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
͸ͪ
ͶͪͲͰ
ͺ͹
ͷ͸͹ͭͳͷ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͳͷ

ͷ;ͲͰΒͳͷͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͹ͼͽͪ
Ͷͳ΀
ͫͰͻͶͳ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͅ;ͲͰΒ;

ͳ
ͺͪͻͳͼ͵͹ͷ
̈́;ͬͻ;
͇ͯ
΂;
ͬͰ͸Ͱ
ͼ͵;Ͷͺͽ;ͻͰ
ͪͻ΀ͪΒͼ͵͹ͭ

ͅͳͶͰͽͪ
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ
͵͹
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
ͼͽͪͽ;Ͱ
̸ͻͽͰ
ͷͳͯͰ
̸ͺ͹Ͷ͹͸ͪ
ͳ
ͭͻ;ͺ;
̽ͰͷͰͽͻͪ
ͳ
̓͹ͻͪ
͆Ͱ΃ͽ͹
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
;

ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰͽͳͽͳ
̽ͳͯͳͷͳ
͆ͪ
ͺͻͬ͹ͷ
ͷͰͼͽ;
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹

ΒͰ
͸ͪͭͶͪͼͳͽͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
̽ͳͯͳͷͪ
ͭͻͪͯͼͬͰͽͳͶͳ΃ͽͰ
ͺ͹
΂Ͱͷ;
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;ΒͰ

͹ͯ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳ΀
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ
͇ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
΀ͻͪͷ;

ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸͹ͷ
ͫ͹ͭ;
̸ͺ͹Ͷ͹͸;
̽ͳͯͳͷͪΒ;
ͯͪͽͳ
ͼ;
;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͳ
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸͹

͆ͪͬ͹ͯͰ
ͼͰ
ͿͪͲͰ
ͳͲͭͻͪͯΔͰ
ͻ;΃ͰΔͪ
ͳ
͹ͫ͸͹ͬͰ
΀ͻͪͷͪ
͹ͯ
ͪͻ΀ͪΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͰ
ͻͳ͹ͯͪ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
ͺͰͻͼͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ͸ͬͪͲͳΒͰ
ͺͪ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
΀ͰͶͰ͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͳ
͸ͪ
͵ͻͪΒ;

ͻͳͷͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
;
ͬͻͰͷͰ
΁ͪͻͰͬͪ
̸;ͻͰͶͳΒͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
̽ͳ͹͵ͶͰ΁ͳΒͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͬͰͽͳͶͳ΃ͽͰ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬͰͶ͹
ͺ͹͸͹ͬ͸ͳ
ͺͻ͹΁ͬͪͽ
͎ͻͪͷ
ΒͰ
;
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ͹͸
ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͼͷͳͼͶ;
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸
͵ͪ͹
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͳ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ;ͻͰ
Β͹͸ͼ͵͹ͭ

ͼͽͳͶͪ
ͪ
ͺ͹
ͯͳͷͰ͸ͲͳΒͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ͹͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͼͽͳͶ;
͵ͪ͹
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͬͰ
Εͳ΀
ͳ
͸ͪΒͰͶͰͭͪ͸ͽ͸ͳΒͳ΀
;
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͼͬͰͽ;
͆Ͱ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔ;
ͼͰ
΂;ͬͰ͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͼͽͪͬͪ
̻͹ͻͭ͹͸Ͱ
ͼͪ
ͿͻͳͲͪ
͹ͬ͹ͭͪ
΀ͻͪͷͪ
ͻͰΓͰͿ͸ͳ
ͯͰ͵͹ͻͪͽͳͬ͸ͳ
;͵ͻͪͼͳ

ͭͰ͹ͷͰͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
͹ͻ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͪͽͪ
ͳ
ͼͳͻͰ͸ͪ
͋ͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ΒͰ
ͳͲ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ

ͺ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͳͲ
ͪͻ΀ͪΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳ
ͼͪ΂;ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳ
͹Ͷͽͪͻͪ



ͅ
ͅ
̓͹ͫΆͶͳ͸ͪ
ͅͳͶͰͽ
ͅ͹ͼ͵ͬͪ

m


́ͼͽ͹

ͼͶ



ͼͶ



3
/BVNBOO
%JEZNB
'ÛISFS
*TUBOCVM

m
"CC
m

 ͉ͪͯͷͳͶͪ
̀͹ͽ͹ͬͳΕ

ͼ͵;Ͷͺͽ;ͻͪ
ͶͰͱͰΕͰͭ
Ͷͪͬͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͼ͵;Ͷͺͽ;ͻͪ
ͷ;΃͵ͪͻ΁ͪ
;
ͼͰͯͰΕͰͷ
ͺ͹
Ͷ͹ͱͪΒ;
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ
ͼͽͪΒͪͶͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͬͰͽ͹ͷ
ͯͻ;ͷ;
ͪ
ͼͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͰ͸ͪ
;

̹ͻͳͽͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͷ;ͲͰΒ;
;
̈́͹͸ͯ͹͸;
͋ͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͼͰ
͸Ͱ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;
ͫͶͳͲͳ
͸ͳ
̸ͺ͹Ͷ͹͸͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͳͶͳ΃ͽͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶ͹
Β͹΃
ΒͰͯ͸͹
ͷͪΔͰ
ͼͬͰͽͳͶͳ΃ͽͰ

΀ͻͪͷ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸
ͫ͹ͭͳΔͳ
̸ͻͽͰͷͳͯͳ

̽ͪΓͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
͋;ͻͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;
t̸ͻͭ;ͼ
ͽ;ͻͼͪi
ͬ͹ͯͳ

͸ͪͼ
ͯ͹
ͯͬͰ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͰ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͎ͪͶͳ͵ͪͻ͸ͪͼͪ
ͳ
̓͸ͳͯ͹ͼͪ
͎ͪͶͳ͵ͪͻ
͸ͪͼ
ͼͰ
͹ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
̓ͪͻͳΒͰ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ͹ͯ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͻ͹ͯ͸͹
ͷͰͼͽ͹

ͭͻͪͯ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͺͪͷͽͳ͹
ͬͶͪͯͪͬͳ͸;
͈ͰͻͼͳΒͪ͸ͪ΁ͪ
ͳ
͹ͼͽͪ͹
;ͺͪͷΕͰ͸
͵ͪ͵͹
;

ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͼͬͰͽ;
ͽͪ͵͹
ͳ
;
ͼͬͰͽ;
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃Δͳ΁Ͱ
ͺ͹
΂;ͬͰ͸͹ͷ
ͪͅ;Ͳ͹ͶͰΒ;

͇
ͪͅ;Ͳ͹ͶͰΒ;
ͼͰ
͵ͪͱͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͭͶͪ΃Ͱ͸
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͯ͸͹
͹ͯ
ͼͰͯͪͷ
΂;ͯͪ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂
͵͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͪ
ͳͲͭͻͪͯΔͪ
͹ͽͺ͹΂ͰͶͪ

ͭ
ͺ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͳ
΃Ͱ
ͺ;ͽͪ
ͫͳ͹
ͯͰͶͳͷͳ΂͸͹
ͻͪͲͪͻͪ͸
ͳ
͹ͫ͸ͪͬΓͪ͸
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹͵
͵͹͸ͪ΂͸͹
͸ͳΒͰ

ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
ͻͪͲͪͻͪΔͪ
;
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͽͻͰͼ;
ͭͻͪΌͰͬͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶ
ͻͪͲͬ;΂Ͱ͸
ͳ
;

͸ͪΒͬͰΕ͹Β
ͷͰͻͳ
ͳͼ͵͹ͻͳ΃ΕͰ͸
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ

ͬ
Ͳͪ
ͳͲͭͻͪͯΔ;
ͽͬͻΌͪͬͰ
ͼͬ
͈Ͱ
ͽͻͪ
̓͸ͳͯ͹ͼ
ͼͰ
͹ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
̓ͪͻͳΒͰ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
͹ͼͽͪ͹

;ͺͪͷΕͰ͸
;
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͼͬͰͽ;
͵ͪ͹
ͭͻͪͯ
;
͵͹ͷͰ
ΒͰ
ͬͶͪͯͪͶͪ
͹ͺ͹Β͸ͪ
ͷͰͶ͹
ͯͳΒͪ
Γ;ͫͪͬͳ
ͳ
ͬͳ͸ͪ
ͫ;ͯ;Εͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
ͺ͹ͯͳͭ͸;ͽ
;
ͼͶͪͬ;
̸Ϳͻ͹ͯͳͽͰ

ͫ͹ͭͳΔͰ
Γ;ͫͪͬͳ
ͳ
ͫͳ͹
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ
ͺ͹
ͳͲͬͻͼ͸͹ͷ
ͬͳ͸;
͆ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͼͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ

Β͹΃
;

ͬ
ͺ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
̓͸ͳͯ͹ͼ;
;Ͳ
̸ͺ͹Ͷ͹͸͹ͬ
΀ͻͪͷ
ͺ͹΂ͰͶͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͻͪͲͬͳΒͪ

ͳ
ͯ͹ͼͽͳͭͶͪ
ͼͬ͹Β
͸ͪΒͬͰΕͳ
ͺͻ͹΁ͬͪͽ
͸ͪΒͼͽͪͻͳΒͪ
ͭͻ΂͵ͪ
ͶͰ͵ͪͻͼ͵ͪ
΃͵͹Ͷͪ

ͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;

ͬ
ͺ͸Ͱ
ͫͳ͹
΂;ͬͰ͸
͵ͪ͹
;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻ

͹͸͹ͭͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
̽ͪ͸ͪͼ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ΒͰͯͳ͸͹
͹΂;ͬͪ͸ͳ
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳ
͵ͻ;ͱ͸͹ͭ

΀ͻͪͷͪ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸͹ͭ
ͫ͹ͭͳΔͳ
̸Ϳͻ͹ͯͳͽͳ
͌
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;
ͼͰ
͸Ͱ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ΒͰͯͪ͸

Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ͸
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͬͰͲͪ͸
Ͳͪ
͹ͬͪΒ
΀ͻͪͷ
͆ͪͳͷͰ
;
ΔͰͷ;
ΒͰ
ͼͽͪΒͪͶͪ

ͼͽͪͽ;ͪ
ͫ͹ͭͳΔͰ
̸Ϳͻ͹ͯͳͽͰ
ͽͲͬ
t̸Ϳͻ͹ͯͳͽͪ
ͼͪ
̓͸ͳͯ͹ͼͪi
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
;
ͪ͸
ͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͼͬͰͽ;
ͫͳͶͪ
͸ͪͯͪͶͰ͵͹
΂;ͬͰ͸ͪ
ͺ͹
ͼͬ͹Β͹Β
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͳ

͈͹ͷͳΔͪΔͰͷ
̓͸ͳͯ͹ͼͪ
Ͳͪͬͻ΃ͪͬͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͬ͹ΌͰΔͰ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
Ͷ͹͵ͪ
΁ͳΒͪ
;
͋;ͻͼ͵͹Β
;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;
t̸ͻͭ;ͼ
ͽ;ͻͼͪi
͆ͪͬͰͯͰ͸ͳ
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵ͳ
Ͷ͹͵ͪ
ͶͳͽͰͽͳ
ͼ;
͹ͫͻͪΌͰ͸ͳ
ͼ͹Ͷͳͯ͸͹
ͳ
;
͵ͻͪͽ͵ͳͷ
΁ͻͽͪͷͪ
ͯ͹ͼͽͪ
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸͹

ͼͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵͹ͭ
ͪͼͺͰ͵ͽͪ
̓ͻͪͽ͵ͳ
ͳ
ͺͻͰ΁ͳ
Ͳ͸ͳ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͬͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͪͻ
΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ΀
͹ͼͽͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͪΔͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ΀
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
͸ͪ;΂
͸ͳ΀
ͳ
;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ΀
΃͵͹Ͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
΁ͬͰͽͪͶͰ
;
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵͹
ͯ͹ͫͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͬͳͷ

ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪ
;ͽͳͼͪ͵
͹
͋;ͻͼ͵͹Β
;
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
͵ͪ͹
͹

ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
͸ͪ
͵͹Β͹Β
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͶͪͷͪͶͰ
ͪͻ΀ͪΒͼ͵ͪ
ͭͻ΂͵ͪ
΀ͰͶͰ͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ

ͳ
ͻͳͷͼ͵ͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
ͫ;ͻ͸ͳ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳ
ͺͰͻͼͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͭͻ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ



́ͼͽ͹

"CC


"CC

 ̸͸ͽͳ΂͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ 

ͻͳͷͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ
ͽͻͭ͹ͬͪ΂͵ͳ
ͳ
ͻͰͶͳͭͳ͹Ͳ͸͹ͿͳͶ͹Ͳ͹Ϳͼ͵ͳ

;ͽͳ΁ͪΒͳ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ΀
΃͵͹Ͷͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͪͬͪ΁ͪ
͊ͷͪͽͻͪͷ͹
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͬͰΕ

ͭ͹ͻͰ
ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͲͬͰͼ͸ͪ
ͷͪ͸ͪ
͹ͬ͹ͭͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
;
ͺͻ͹ͺ;΃ͽͪΔ;
ͯͪ

ͼͰ
͸ͪͫͻ͹ΒͰ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
Δͳ
΀͹ͬͳ
͹ͼͽͪ΁ͳ
ͪ
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
΃ͽ͹
͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͪͭͶͪ΃Ͱ͸͹
͹ͫͳΓͰ
ͳ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͪ
ͪͻ
΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ͹͸ͼ͵͹ͯͰ͵͹ͻͪͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͺͶͪͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
̸Ͷͳ
ͪ͵͹
͵ͪ͹
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹Ͳͳ
ͳͷͪͷ͹

͸ͪ
;ͷ;
ͯͬͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
͈ͪ;ͼͪ͸ͳΒͰͬ
͇ͺͳͼ
͎ͰͶͪͯͰ
ͳͶͳ
͈ͪ΂͹ͬ
"VT

%BMNBUJFO
VOE
TFJOFN
)JOUFSMBOE
ͷ͹ͱͰͷ͹
͵͹͸ͼͽͪͽ͹ͬͪͽͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͼͶͰͯͰ
ΕͰ
,͹
ͼͷ͹
ͷͳ
ͯͪ
͹
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ͼ;ͯͳͷ͹

 ͉ͪͯͷͳͶͪ
̀͹ͽ͹ͬͳΕ

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

3BENJMB
;PUPWJǀ
"OUJLFT
&SCF
WPO
,MFJOBTJFO
t%JF
5ÛSLFJ
m
FJO
-BOE
EFS
,POUSBTUF
VOE
SFJDIMJDIFO
4DIÕOIFJUi

%FS
3FJTFGÛISFS
t%JF
5ÛSLFJ
m
FJO
-BOE
EFS
,POUSBTUF
VOE
SFJDIMJDIFO

4DIÕOIFJUi
IFSBVTHFHFCFO
WPO
EFS
3FJTFBHFOUVS
t"SHVT
5PVSTi
CJFUFU
JO

HSP“FO
;ÛHFO
OPUXFOEJHF
"OHBCFO
[VN
BOUJLFO
&SCF
WPO
,MFJOBTJFO
BVG

EFN
(FCJFU
EFS
IFVUJHFO
5ÛSLFJ
EJF
JO
FSTUFS
-JOJF
EFN
CSFJUFO
SFJTFMVTUJHFO

1VCMJLVN
BOHFQBTTU
XFSEFO
EBT
TPXPIM
&SIPMVOH
BMT
BVDI
*OGPSNBUJPOFO

ÛCFS
LVMUVSHFTDIJDIUMJDIFT
"MUFSUVN
CSBVDIU

&JOF
LVS[F
¾CFSTJDIU
ÛCFS
EJF
XJDIUJHTUFO
(FTDIJDIUTFSFJHOJTTF
BVG
EFN

(FCJFU
EFT
IFVUJHFO
*TUBOCVM
VOE
BO
EFS
¨HÅJTDIFO
,ÛTUF
MJFGFSU
*OGPSNBUJPOFO

ÛCFS
EJF
BCXFDITMVOHTSFJDIF
7FSHBOHFOIFJU
EJFTFS
3FHJPO
JO
EFS
WFSTDIJFEFOF

,VMUVSFO
HFHFOFJOBOEFS
QSBMMUFO
BCFS
BVDI
NJUFJOBOEFS
JO
FOHFN
,POUBLU

TUBOEFO
m
EJF
QFSTJTDIF
BSDIBJTDIF
VOE
LMBTTJTDI
HSJFDIJTDIF
IFMMFOJTUJTDIF

VOE
SÕNJTDIF
/FCFO
EFO
TFIFOTXFSUFO
LVMUVSHFTDIJDIUMJDIFO
%FOLNÅMFSO
JO

*TUBOCVM
XFSEFO
BVDI
KFOF
JO
5SPJB
1FSHBNPO
&QIFTPT
"QISPEJTJBT
.JMFU

PEFS
.JMFUVT

%JEJNB
)JFSBQPMJT
1BNVLLBMF

)BMJLBSOBT
VOE
,OJEPT

WPSHFTUFMMU
'ÛS
NBODIF
%FOLNÅMFS
XFSEFO
FJOJHF
TFIS
JOUFSFTTBOUF
%FUBJMT

FSXÅIOU
FUXB
JN
'BMM
EFS
1GFSEFSFOOCBIO
JO
*TUBOCVM
XP
JO
LOBQQFO
8PSUFO

EBT
1GFSEFSFOOFO
JO
EFS
7FSHBOHFOIFJU
HFTDIJMEFSU
XJSE
%JF
"OHBCFO
[V

FJOJHFO
BOUJLFO
4UÅEUFO
BO
EFS
¨HÅJTDIFO
,ÛTUF
CJFUFO
FJO
#JME
BO
EBT
EJF

XJDIUJHTUFO
;FOUSFO
EFS
,VMUVS
,VOTU
8JTTFOTDIBGU
1IJMPTPQIJF
VOE
3FMJHJPO

JO
EFO
7PSEFSHSVOE
SÛDLU
4P
XJSE
[
#
&QIFTPT
BMT
FJOF
4UBEU
QSÅTFOUJFSU

EJF
JO
EFS
(FTDIJDIUF
EFT
$ISJTUFOUVNT
FJOF
XJDIUJHF
3PMMF
TQJFMUF
XP
EFS

"QPTUFM
1BVMVT
XFJMUF
XP
EJF
(PUUFTNVUUFS
VOE
EFS
"QPTUFM
+PIBOOFT
MFCUFO

VOE
WFSTUBSCFO
%JF
EBNBMJHF
,VMUVS
TQJFHFMU
TJDI
JO
EFO
#FTDISFJCVOHFO
EFT

CFSÛINUFO
5IFBUFS
JO
1FSHBNPO
VOE
&QIFTPT
VOE
EFS
#JCMJPUIFL
EFT
$FMTVT

JO
&QIFTPT
XJEFS
1FSHBNPO
XJSE
FCFOGBMMT
BMT
FJO
CFSÛINUFT
;FOUSVN
EFS

QSBLUJTDIFO
.FEJ[JO
WPSHFTUFMMU
XP
#FIBOEMVOHFO
BVGHSVOE
FJOFS
.JTDIVOH

BVT
1TZDIPBOBMZTF
VOE
5SBVNEFVUVOH
QSBLUJ[JFSU
XVSEFO
"N
HSÛOEMJDITUFO

XFSEFO
TFMCTUWFSTUÅOEMJDI
BSDIÅPMPHJTDIF
¾CFSSFTUF
EFS
TUÅEUFCBVMJDIFO

"SDIJUFLUVS
CFTDISJFCFO
JOTCFTPOEFSF
JO
EFO
,BQJUFMO
ÛCFS
1FSHBNPO
VOE

&QIFTPT
XJF
BVDI
BSDIÅPMPHJTDIF
"VTHSBCVOHFO
[BIMSFJDIFS
5FNQFM
VOE

XFJUFSFS
IFJMJHFS
VOE
QSPQIFUJTDIFS
0SUF
EBSHFMFHU
XFSEFO
m
FUXB
EJF
XFJUIJO

CFLBOOUF
3PUF
)BMMF
VSTQSÛOHMJDI
5FNQFM

VOE
EFS
1FSHBNPO"MUBS
EFS

%PNJUJBO5FNQFM
EFS
)BESJBOTUFNQFM
"SUFNJT5FNQFM
JO
&QIFTPT

EFS

5FNQFM
%FNFUFS
VOE
,PSB
EFS
5FNFQFM
EFS
(ÕUUJO
"UIFO
5FNQFM
EFS

 ̸͸ͽͳ΂͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͪͅͶͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ 

"QISPEJUF
JO
"QISPEJTJBT
VOE
EBT
QSPQIFUJTDIF
"QPMMPO)FJMJHUVN
JO
%JEJNB

NJU
TFJOFN
HFXBMUJHFO
5FNQFM

%FS
FOUTDIFJEFOEF
/BDIUFJM
EJFTFT
3FJTFGÛISFST
CFTUFIU
EBSJO
EBTT

NBODIF
&JO[FMIFJUFO
EJF
EJF
#FEFVUVOH
VOE
4DIÕOIFJU
EFT
BOUJLFO
&SCFT
WPO

,MFJOBTJFO
BN
EFVUMJDITUFO
[VN
7PSTDIFJO
LPNNFO
MBTTFO
ÛCFSIBVQU
OJDIU

FSXÅIOU
PEFS
OJDIU
EFVUMJDI
IFSWPSHFIPCFO
XFSEFO
"MT
#FJTQJFMF
LÕOOFO

EJF
4BSLPQIBHF
BOHFGÛISU
XFSEFO
EJF
WFSNVUMJDI
BVG
EFS
*OTFM
1SPLPOFT
JO

EFS
/ÅIF
WPO
*TUBOCVM
IFSHFTUFMMU
XVSEFO
EJF
TH
HSP“F
#SPO[FLVOTU
BVT
EFN

"SDIÅPMPHJTDIFO
.VTFVN
JO
*TUBOCVM
EJF
BSDIBJTDIF
1MBTUJL
BVT
.JMFU
EFS

CFSÛINUF
4BSLPQIBH
EFT
$FMTVT
FCFOTP
XJF
EJF
TÅNUMJDIF
BSDIJUFLUPOJTDI
EFLPSBUJWF
1MBTUJL
WPO
5FNQFMO
VOE
BOEFSFO
ÕGGFOUMJDIFO
#BVUFO
EJF
EVSDI

LMBSF
VOE
EFVUMJDI
-JOJFO
EFS
,BQJUFM
1JMBTUFS
"SDIJUSBWF
VOE
EVSDI
EFLPSBUJWF

7FSGMFDIUVOHFO
WPO
3PTFUUFO
"LBOUIVT
7PMVUFO
&JFSTUÅCFO
VOE
BOEFSFO

QGMBO[MJDIFO
VOE
HFPNFUSJTDIFO
0SOBNFOUFO
HFLFOO[FJDIOFU
TJOE

 ͉ͪͯͷͳͶͪ
̀͹ͽ͹ͬͳΕ
͆Ͱ͸ͪͯ
̸̺̓͌̾́ͣ͡ͅ
͍ͳͶ͹Ͳ͹Ϳͼ͵ͳ
Ϳͪ͵;ͶͽͰͽ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

̸͈͇̺͌͋̾͢
́
̸͉̓͌̈́͋͌

ћ
̺͇̽́͐
͇̽
̸̸̹͇̻͉̾̽

͇̽
̸̹̾͐
́̀

̻͇̽́͆̾

͠Ͱͯ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳ΀
ͽͰ͵͹ͬͳ͸ͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ΒͰͼͽͰ

ͼͬͰͼͽ
͹
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͳ
͵ͪ͹
Γ;ͯͼ͵͹Β
ͯͰͶͪͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
;͸ͳͬͰͻͲͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ

΂ͳΒͰ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͽͰͷͰΓͪ
͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͌ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪ
ͬͪΔͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͷ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺ
΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
;Ͳ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹
΂ͳͽͪΔͰ
ͳ
ͼͪͶ͹͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͯͳͼ͵;ͼͳΒͰ
͹
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
Βͪͬ
͸ͳͷ
ͺͳͽͪΔͳͷͪ
΂ͳ͸
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͵͹Βͳ
;
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹Β
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸ͳ
͹ͽͰͶ͹ͽͬ͹ͻ;ΒͰ

͵ͻͪΒͰͷ
97***
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ͸ͳ
ͺ;ͽ
̽͹ͼͳͽͰΒͪ
͇ͫͻͪͯ͹ͬͳΕͪ

̽͹ͼͳͽͰΒͰͬ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳ΀
;Ͳ͹ͻͪ 

ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͼͽ;ͯͰ͸ͪͽͪ
ͳ
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͽͬͻΌͰ͸ͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͫͻ͹Β͸͹ͷ
ͺ;
ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸͹ͷ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻ͹ͷ
ͼ͸ͪͱ͸͹
ͯ͹ͺͻͳ͸͹ͼͰ
͹ͫͶͳ͵͹ͬͪΔ;
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
͵;Ͷ
ͽ;ͻͰ

͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
;ͼͷͰͻͰ͸ͪ
͵ͪ
ͼͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺ͹ͯͻͪ
Ͳ;ͷͰͬͪΒ;
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰ
ͼͻͰͯͳ΃ͽͪ
ͼͽͪͻͳ΀
΁ͳͬͳͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͬͪͱ͸ͳ΀
ͪͻ΀Ͱ
͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ΀
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽͪ
͹ͫͳͶͪͼ͵Ͱ
ͷ;ͲͰΒͪ
ͳ
ͭͪͶͰͻͳΒͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ
΀ͻͪͷ͹ͬͳͷͪ



̺ͳͯͳ
+
)BCFSNBT
4USVLUVSXBOEFM
EFS
¸GGFOUMJDILFJU
4VISLBNQ
'SBOLGVSU

BN
.BJO




̽͹ͼͳͽͰΒ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ͹
;
9*9
ͬͰ͵;
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳ΀
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ΀
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹
͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
΀Ͱͻ͹Βͪ
ͅ
͋ͳͷ͹ͽͳΒͰͬͳΕ
͎Ͱͻ͹Β
ͺͰͻͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
ͽͳͺ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͪ
ͭͰ͸ͰͲͪ
Βͪͬ͸ͳ΀

͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
̺ͪͶͯͰ΁͹ͬͪ
ͼ͵;Ͷͺͽ;ͻͪ
̽͹ͼͳͽͰΒͪ
͇ͫͻͪͯ͹ͬͳΕͪ
͆ͪͼͶͰΌͰ

***
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ



͆
ͪͅ͵;ΓͰͬͳΕ
͌ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͪ
ͳͯͰΒͪ
;
9*9

ͬͰ͵;
͊ͳͼͽͰͷ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͬͳͲ;ͰͶ͸Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
;
ͼͶ;ͱͫͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͯ͹͵ͽ͹ͻͼ͵ͪ
ͯͳ
ͼͰͻͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ


 ͆Ͱ͸ͪͯ
ͪͅ͵;ΓͰͬͳΕ

;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͪ
;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬ͹ͬͪ
ΔͰ
ͽͰ͵;Εͳͷ
ͷ;Ͳͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͳ΃͸ͳͷ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳͷͪ
͋͹͵͹ͷ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͪ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
͵ͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳ
ͬͪ͸Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ΀

΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻͪ
͇͸ͪ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͪ
ͬͪͱͪ͸
ͼͰͭͷͰ͸ͽ
ͺͻͳͬͪͽ͸͹ͭ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ 
ͪ

;
Δͳ΀͹ͬ
͹ͫͪͬͰͲ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͺͻͪͽͰΕͳ
ͯͰ͹
ͼͺͪͯͪΒ;
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
̓͹ͻͳ
΃ΕͰΔͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
;ͽͳ΁ͪͶ͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
͹ͫͶͳ͵͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͺ;Ͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͋ͪ
͵͹
́ͺ͹Ͷͳͽ
͋Ͱ͸
΂ͪ͵
͹ͯͻͰΌ;ΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹ͼͰͫͪ͸
ͽͳͺ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
;
9*9
ͬͰ͵;

͹͸Ͱ
͵͹Βͳ
tΒͰͯ;
ͺͪͼͽͻͷ͵;
͸ͪ
ͷͰͼͽͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂Ͱ͸ͪ
;
͵ΔͳͲͳ

ͳ
ͻͪͼͺͻͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͼͪ
ͭ͹ͼͽͳ͹͸ͳ΂ͪͻͰͷ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
΁Ͱ͸ͪ
ͬͳ΃ͪ
͸Ͱͭ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͺͳ΃Ͱ

;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;i
͡;ͫͪ
͆Ͱ͸ͪͯ͹ͬͳΕ
;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸ͳͷ
ͫͰͶͰ΃͵ͪ
ͷͪ
ͳͲ
́ͽͪͶͳΒͰ
ͳͲ

ͺͻ;ͱͪ
ͼͶͳ͵;
͵͹ͻͳ΃ΕͰΔͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͇͸
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ

͹
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͯͪ
t͆ͳ͵͹
͸ͰΕͰ
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ

ͻͪͲͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ͹ͷ
ͳ
Ͳͪͺͳͽ͵ͳͬͪΔͰͷ
ͯͪ
ͯ͹ͼͪΌ;ΒͰ
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͷ
͊ͬͪ͵ͳ
ͳͷͪͷ͹
ͺ͹

ΒͰͯ͸;
͵Δͳͭ;
;
͵͹Β͹Β
ͼ;
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
́ͽͪͶͳΒͰ
ͽ͹
͸ͪͷ
ΒͰ
ͻͪͲͭ͹ͬ͹ͻi
͆ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
;
9*9
ͬͰ͵;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͪ
ͼ;

ͷͰͼͽͪ
;
́ͽͪͶͳΒͳ
ͳ
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
ͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͵ͻͰͽͪͶͳ
ͳ

ͺ͹
ͷͪͽͳ΂͸ͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͺ͹
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͬͪ͸Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
͋ͻͪ͸ͼͿ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
;ͽͳ΁ͪͶͳ
ͼ;
͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͬͰΕͪ
ΔͰ
ͫͻ͹Βͪ
͹ͯͻͰͯͳ΃ͽͪ
ͳ
ͳͼͽͳ΁ͪΔͰ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼ;
ͼͰ

͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͰ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͰ
Ͳͫͳͻ͵Ͱ
ͳ
͹ͯͬͳΒͪ͹
ͳ͸ͽͰ͸Ͳͳͬ͸ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂
͵ͳ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ
͠Ͱͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͽͪ͵ͬͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
̹Ͱ΂
̹Ͱ΂
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁ͪ
͎ͪͫͲͫ;ͻ΃͵Ͱ
ͳͷͺͰͻͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ͹
ΒͰ
ΒͰͯͪ͸

͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͳ΀
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ΀
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻͪ
͇ͬͪΒ

ͭͻͪͯ
ΒͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪͬͪ͹
ͫ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͰ
͵ͪ͹

;
ͻͰͬ͹Ͷ;΁ͳΒͳ

ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͼͬ͹Β;
ͽͻͪ͸ͼͿ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒ;
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͭͶͰͯͪͶͪ
;

ͼͬͳͷ
ͼͿͰͻͪͷͪ
Βͪͬ͸͹ͭ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
͹ͯ
;ͻͫͪ͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͻͰ΃ͰΔͪ
ͯ͹
ͼͬͪ͵͹
ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸Ͱ
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
̽Ͱ΃ͪͬͪΔͪ
;
̹Ͱ΂;
͵ͪ͹
ͳͼͽͪ͵͸;ͽ͹Β
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹Β

ͷͰͽͻ͹ͺ͹Ͷͳ
ͺͻͳͬͶͪ΂ͳͶͪ
ͼ;
ͺͪͱΔ;
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵Ͱ
Βͪͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͠Ͱͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
Ͳ͸ͪ
΂ͪΒ͸ͳ΀
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͪ
͹ͯͬͳ͹
ͼͰ

͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
;
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁ͳ
͎ͪͫͲͫ;ͻ΃͵Ͱ
ͳͷ
ͺͰͻͳΒͰ
͹ͯͻͱͪ͸ͪ
͊ͬͰͽͼ͵ͪ
ͳͲͶ͹ͱͫͪ
͇ͬͪΒ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒ
;ͼͷͰͻͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͺͪͱΔ;

ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
Βͪͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪΒͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸ͳΒͰ
;ͽͳ΁ͪͶ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͽͰ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;

ͳͲͯͪΔ;
ͭͶͪͬ͸Ͱ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
͵ΔͳͱͪͻͰ
͠
̽
̈́ͪͲͪͻͰͬͳΕͪ
ͺ͹Βͪͬͳ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒ
ͻͪ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ



͌ͺ͹ͻ
̸
̓͹ͻͫͰ͸
t͋ͪΒ͸ͪ
ͳ͸ͯͳͬͳͯ;Ͱi
;
́ͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
ͺͻͳͬͪͽ͸͹ͭ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
͵Δ


ͺͻͳͻͰͯͳͶͳ
͍
̸ͻͳΒͰͼ
m
̿
̽ͳͫͳ
;ͻͰͯͳͶͪ
ͅ
͈Ͱͻ͹
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ


͇

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͳͷͪ
ͬͳͯͳ
ͳ
͋
̀ͰͶͯͳ͸
́͸ͽͳͷ͸ͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
΂͹ͬͰ΂ͪ͸ͼͽͬͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ






͋
̀ͰͶͯͳ͸
͸ͪͬ
ͯͰͶ͹



͡
͈
͆Ͱ͸ͪͯ͹ͬͳΕ
͈ͳͼͷͪ
ͳͲ
́ͽͪͶͳΒͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ


͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͯ͹
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ 
 ͆Ͱ͸ͪͯ
ͪͅ͵;ΓͰͬͳΕ

ͳͶͳ
͸ͪΒͫ͹Γͳ
ͬ͹Ό
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͯ͹
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
ͳ
ͼͬ;ͯͪ
ͺ͹
̹Ͱ΂;
Ͳͪ
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͭͪ
ͪ

͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
Ͳͪ
͹͸Ͱ
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͳͼ;
ͬͰ΃ͽͳ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳͷ
ΒͰͲͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͳ
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͳͷͪ
͌
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͭͻͪͯ
̹Ͱ΂
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸͹
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ

ͼͻͺͼ͵͹Β
Βͪͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͇͸
ΒͰ
;Ͳ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
ͳ
͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ͹
Ͳͪ
͊ͻ
ͫͰ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹
ͪͯͷͳ͸ͳͼͽͻͪͽͳͬ͸͹
͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬ͸͹
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ
͸͹
ͳ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵͹
ͼͻͰͯͳ΃ͽͰ
̸ͯͷͳ͸ͳͼͽͻͪͽͳͬ͸͹ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͳ
ͽͻͭ͹
ͬͪ΂͵ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͫͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃Εͳ
΁ͳΓͰ
ͬͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
Ͳͪ
̹Ͱ΂
ͯ͹͵
ΒͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
ͼͺͪͯͪͶͪ
;
ͺͻ͹ͺͻͪͽ͸ͳ
ͯͰ͹

͹ͬͳ΀
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͪ
̹ͻ͹Β
͊ͻͫͪ
;
̹Ͱ΂;
ͳ
͎ͪͫͲͫ;ͻ΃͵͹Β
ͷ͹͸ͪͻ΀ͳΒͳ
;ͼͶ͹ͬͳ͹
ΒͰ

ͯͪ
ͼͰ

;
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁ͳ
΁ͪͻͼͽͬͪ
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͻͪ
ͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͪ
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬ͸ͪ

΁ͻ͵ͬͰ͸ͪ
͹ͺ΃ͽͳ͸ͪ
͊ͬͰͽͼ͵ͪ
ͳͲͶ͹ͱͫͪ

ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͬͰͶͪ
ͯ͹
ͳͼͽͳ΁ͪΔͪ
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
͵ͪ͹
͵;Ͷ
ͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͼͽͪ͵Ͷͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͫͻ͹Β͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
̺ͰͶͳ͵ͪ

ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͪ
ͷͪ͸ͳͿͰͼͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͹ͽͬ͹ͻͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ

*7
ͺ͹
ͼͽͪͻ͹ͷ
ͳͶͳ

7


ͺ͹
͸͹ͬ͹ͷ
͵ͪͶͰ͸ͯͪͻ;
ͪ
͹ͬͪ
ͯͰ΃ͪͬͪΔͪ
Ͳͪͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪͶͪ
ͼ;
ͳ
Βͪͬ͸͹ͼͽ

̓͸ͰͱͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
͇
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂Ͱ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳ
͸ͪͽͺͳͼͳ
;
͹͸͹ͬͻͰ
ͷͰ͸͹Β
΃ͽͪͷͺͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͯ͹͸͹ͼͰ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͫ͹ͻͪͬ͵ͪ

;
̹Ͱ΂; 
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͳͲͬͰ΃ͽͪΒͰ
͹
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͳͷͪ
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
ͳ
ͳͲͶ͹ͱͫͰ
́ͪ͵͹

̓͸ͰͱͰͬͳ͸ͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
;΂Ͱͼͽͬ͹ͬͪͶͪ
͸ͪ
͊ͬͰͽͼ͵͹Β
ͳͲͶ͹ͱͫͳ
̹Ͱ΂
ͼ;



̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͳͶͳ
͸ͪΒͫ͹Γͳ
ͬ͹Ό
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͯ͹
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
ͳ
ͼͬ;ͯͪ

ͺ͹
̹Ͱ΂;
Ͳͪ
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͭͪ
ͪ
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
Ͳͪ
͹͸Ͱ
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͳͼ;
ͬͰ΃ͽͳ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳͷ
ΒͰͲͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͳ
͹ͫͳ
΂ͪΒͳͷͪ
ͳͲͯͪͶͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͪ
͵Δͳͱͪͻͪ
͠
̽
̈́ͪͲͪͻͰͬͳΕͪ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ



ͼͽͻ
ͯͪΓͰ
̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ



̺ͳͯͳ
͊ͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͹
ͼͰͯͪͷͯͰͼͰͽͺͰͽ͹ͭ͹ͯͳ΃Δͳ΁ͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬ͸Ͱ
΁ͻ
͵ͬͰ͸͹΃͵͹Ͷͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͺ΃ͽͳ͸Ͱ
;
̹Ͱ΂;

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ


.
%
1FZGVTT
#BM
LBOPSUIPEPYF
,BVGMFVUF
JO
8JFO
¸TUFSSFJDIJTDIF
0TUIFGUF
)FGU

8JFO




̽
ͅͰͯͪ͵͹ͬͳΕ
͊ͻͫͳ
;
̹Ͱ΂;
͆͹ͬͳ
͊ͪͯ




͊ͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͹
ͼͰͯͪͷͯͰͼͰͽͺͰͽ͹ͭ͹ͯͳ΃Δͳ΁ͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬ͸Ͱ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ͸͹
΃͵͹Ͷͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͺ΃ͽͳ͸Ͱ
;
̹Ͱ΂;




͇
͊ͬͰͽͼ͵͹Β
ͳͲͶ͹ͱͫͳ

;
̹Ͱ΂;
)
'VY
+BQBO
BVG
EFS
8FMUBVTTUFMMVOH
JO

8JFO

"VTTU
,BU
8JFO

8FMUBVTTUFMMVOHFO
JN

+BISIVOEFSU
"VTTU
,BU

.ÛODIFO



+
1FNTFM
%JF
8JFOFS
8FMUBVTTUFMMVOH
WPO

V
5SBVN
VOE

8JSLMJDILFJU
m
8JFO

"VTTU
,BU
8JFO


+
1FNTFM
%JF
8JFOFS

8FMUBVTTUFMMVOH
WPO

8JFO,ÕMO

,
3PTDIJU[
8JFOFS
8FMUBVTTUFMMVOH


8JFO




͊ͬͰͽͼ͵;
ͳͲͶ͹ͱͫ;
;
̹Ͱ΂;
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳͷ
ͼͽͪͽͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ

͹ͫͳ΃Ͷ͹



ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͶͪ΁ͪ
8FMUBVTTUFMMVOHFO
JN

+BISIVOEFSU
99*9



̹͹ͻͪͬͪ͵
;
̹Ͱ΂;
;
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͊ͬͰͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͲͶ͹ͱͫͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ͹
ΒͰ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶ
͸ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͪ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͳͷͪ
͸;ͯͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͅͳͶͳ΁ͪ
͠͹ͬͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ
ͯͰͼͰͽ
ͼ͹ͫͪ
;

;Ͷͳ΁ͳ
)BUOFS
TBJH
/P

ͅͳͶͳ΁ͪ
͠͹ͬͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ
͊ͬͰͽͼ͵ͳ
ͳͲͶ͹ͭ
;
̹Ͱ΂;
͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
͸͹ͬͳ
͸Ͱ


̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

*7





t̸;ͼͽͻͳΒͪi
͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
͸͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

*7



͊ͬͰͽͼ͵ͪ
ͳͲͶ͹
ͱͫͪ
;
̹Ͱ΂;

͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
͸͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

7



 ͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͯ͹
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ 

ͺ͹΀͹ͯͳͶͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͳͲ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
͢ͳ΀͹ͬ
ͫͻ͹Β
͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ΀
ΒͰ
ͼͬͪ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͫͳͶ͹
͋͹
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͽͬͻΌ;ΒͰ
ͳ
;
ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸ͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͶͰ΃͵ͪͷͪ
ͅͳͶͪ͸ͪ
͚

ͅͳͶͳΕͰͬͳΕͪ
͇͸
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ

*9

ͯͪ
̀ͪ͵ͪ
͈Ͱͽ͵͹ͬͳΕ
tͼ;ͽͻͪ
ͳͯͰ

;
̹Ͱ΂
͸ͪ
ͳͲͶ͹ͱͫ;i

͊ͬͰͽͼ͵ͪ
ͳͲͶ͹ͱͫͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ͸
ͺ͹ͬ͹ͯ
Ͳͪ
ͷ͸͹
ͭ͹ͫͻ͹Β͸Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͼ;ͼͻͰͽͰ
;
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁ͳ
͎ͪͫͲͫ;ͻ΃͵Ͱ
ͳͷͺͰͻͳΒͰ

͋ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
̹Ͱ΂
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͳ
͈ͪͻͳͲ
ͺ͹΀͹ͯͳ͹
;
ͺͻͬ͹Β
ͺ͹
ͺ;͸͹ͶͰͽͼͽͬ;
ͳ
ͼͽ;
ͺͪΔ;
͸ͪ
tͬͶͪͯ;i
m
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹

7***

Ͳͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸͹Β
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ

ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
͵͸ͰͲ
ͅͳͶͪ͸
͇ͫͻͰ͸͹ͬͳΕ
͇͸
ΒͰ
ͺͪͻ͹ͫͻ͹ͯ͹ͷ
t͆Ͱͺ
ͽ;͸i 
ͯ͹ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪ͹
;
΁ͪͻͼ͵;
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁;

7***

̓͸ͰͲ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ

ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͰ͸
;
ͲͯͪΔ;
ͅͳ͸ͳͼͽͪͻͼͽͬͪ
Ϳͳ͸ͪ͸ͼͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͼͬ͹ͭ
ͫ͹
ͻͪͬ͵ͪ
ͳͷͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͼ;ͼͻͰͽͪ
ͼͪ
΁ͪͻͰͷ
͍ͻͪΔ͹ͷ
͠͹ͼͳͿ͹ͷ
Ͳͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸Ͱ

ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ
ͯͬ͹ͻ;
͑Ͱ͸ͫͻ;͸;
ͳ
͹ͺͰͻͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͯͬͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ
͊ͬͰͽͼ͵͹Β
ͳͲͶ͹
ͱͫͳ

ͳ

7***
́ͲͶ͹ͱͫ;
ͳ
̹Ͱ΂
ͺ͹΀͹ͯͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
΁ͻ͸͹ͭ͹ͻͼ͵ͳ
͵͸ͰͲ

͆ͳ͵͹Ͷͪ
͵͹ͭͪ
ͼ;

7

ͼͬͰ΂ͪ͸͹
ͯ͹΂Ͱ͵ͪͶͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱ

΁ͻ͵ͬͰ͸Ͱ
͹ͺ΃ͽͳ͸Ͱ

͆Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͯͪ͸ͪ
ͺ͹
͹ͽͬͪͻͪΔ;
͊ͬͰͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͲͶ͹ͱͫͰ

*7

ͺ͹

ͼͽͪͻ͹ͷ
͵ͪͶͰ͸ͯͪͻ;
;
t͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ
͸͹ͬͳ͸ͪͷͪi
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸
ΒͰ
ͳ
͹ͭͶͪͼ
͵͹Βͳͷ

ͼͰ
ͻͰ͵Ͷͪͷͳͻͪ͹
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͯ͹
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
ͺ͹
΁Ͱ͸ͳ
͹ͯ
t
ͭͻ
͐ͪͻ

́Ͷͳ

͸͹ͬi
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪΌͰ
;
ͼͬͳͷ
͵Δͳͱͪͻͪͷͪ
;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͳ

;
ͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͳͷ
͵Δͳͱͪͻͪͷͪ
;
̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵͹Β

̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͳͶͳ
͸ͪΒͫ͹Γͳ
ͬ͹Ό
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͯ͹

̹Ͱ΂ͪ
ͳ
ͼͬ;ͯͪ
ͺ͹
̹Ͱ΂;
Ͳͪ
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͭͪ
ͪ
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
Ͳͪ
͹͸Ͱ
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͳͼ;
ͬͰ΃ͽͳ

ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳͷ
ΒͰͲͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͳ
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͳͷͪ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ΒͰ
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͻͪ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ΀

ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͸ͪͼͽͪͶͳ΀
;
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
͈ͳͼͪ΁
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹
Ͳ͸ͪͽ
ͪͶͳ
ΒͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͺͪͯͪ͹
;
͵ͻ;ͭ
͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͳΒͳ΀
Γ;ͯͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͼͬ͹ͭ

ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
͇͸
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
;
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
;ͼͺͰ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
;
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹ͼͽͳ



͌
ͅͳͶͳΕͰͬͳΕͰͬ͹ͷ
ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸ͳ͵;
ͼͰ
͸Ͱ
ͬͳͯͳ
͹ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
ΒͰ
̀ͪ͵ͪ
͈Ͱͽ͵͹ͬͳΕ
ͪͶͳ
͹͸ͪ

͸ͪΒͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͳͲ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
̽͸Ͱͬ͸ͳ͵
ͅͳͶͪ͸ͪ
͚
ͅͳͶͳΕͰͬͳΕͪ
̸ͻ΀ͳͬ

̸͊͆͌

͵Δ
7*




͆ͰͲͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸ͳ
ͯͰ͹
͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
͸͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

7***





͆ͰͲͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸ͳ
ͯͰ͹
͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
͸͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

7***





͆ͰͲͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸ͳ
ͯͰ͹
͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
͸͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

7***



͆ͰͲͬͪ
͸ͳ΂͸ͳ
ͯͰ͹
͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
͸͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

7***



͆ͰͲͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸ͳ
ͯͰ͹
͊ͻͺ
ͼ͵Ͱ
͸͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

7***



͆ͰͲͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸ͳ
ͯͰ͹
͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
͸͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ


̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

7***





͆ͰͲͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸ͳ
ͯͰ͹
͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
͸͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

7***



͆ͰͲͬͪ
͸ͳ΂͸ͳ
ͯͰ͹
͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
͸͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

7***





͊ͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͹
ͼͰͯͪͷͯͰͼͰͽͺͰͽ͹ͭ͹ͯͳ΃Δͳ΁ͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬ͸Ͱ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ͸͹
΃͵͹Ͷͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͺ΃ͽͳ͸Ͱ
;
̹Ͱ΂;




̓ΔͳͱͰͬ͸ͳ
͹ͭͶͪͼͳ
͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
͸͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

*7



 ͆Ͱ͸ͪͯ
ͪͅ͵;ΓͰͬͳΕ

ͺͻͳͶͪͭ͹ͯͳ
ͱͰΓͰ͸͹Β
ͺ;ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
͈ͻͬͳ
ͯͰ͹
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͯͪͽ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰ
ͷͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͳͷͰ͸͹Β
͵ΔͳͲͳ
̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͠͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
͊;ͫ͹ͽͳΕͪ
ͳͲ


͋ͪ͵͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹Β
ͺ;ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
͸;ͯͳ͹
͸ͪͳͲͭͶͰͯ
ͺͻͰͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽΓͳͬͳ

ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
ͳ
Βͪͼ͸͹
;͵ͪͲͳͬͪ͹
͸ͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ;
͸ͪͷͰ͸;
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͪ
΂ͳͽͪͶͪ΁ͪ

ͼͪ
΀ͪͫͲͫ;ͻ΃͵͹ͷ
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁͹ͷ
͌ͺͻ͵͹ͼ
ͳͼͽ͹ͷ
͸ͪͲͳͬ;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͼͰ
ͺ͹

͵͹͸΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͳ
ͳ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;ΒͰ
͹ͯ
͊;ͫ͹ͽͳΕͰͬͰ
͵Δͳ
ͭͰ
͊;ͫ͹ͽͳΕͰͬͪ
͵Δͳͭͪ
ͺͻͳͻͰΌͰ͸ͪ
ͺ͹
΂Ͱͽͬͻͽ͹ͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
ͯͰͶͪ
̸ͯ͹ͶͿͪ

͑ͷͳͯͶͪ
8JFO
EJF
,BJTFSTUBEU 
͸ͪͼͽͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
;tͱͪͻ͵͹Β
ͱͰΓͳ
ͯͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;

ͳ
͹͸͹
͸ͪ΃ͳ
Γ;ͯͳ
͵͹Βͳ
;
̹Ͱ΂;
ͫͳͶͳ
͸ͳͼ;
ͳͶͳ
΃ͽ͹
͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͳͶͳ
΃ͽ͹

͸ͳͼ;
ͯ͹ͫͳͶͳ
ͬ͹ΓͰ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ
͸Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪͯ;
ͬͳͯͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͯ;
ͫͪͻͰͷ

;
ͷͪͶ͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
ͳ
ͼͶͪͫ͹Β
ͼͶͳ΁ͳ
΃ͽͪ
ͼ;
ͼͬͰ
;ͻͪͯͳͶͳ
͸ͪ
΂;ͯ͹
Γ;ͯͼ͵͹ͭͪ

;ͷͪ
ͳ
ͯ;΀ͪ
΃ͽ͹
͹͸ͳ
͸ͳͼ;
;
ͼͽͪΔ;
͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͷͳͼͶͳͽͳ
͸ͳ
ͼͰͫͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪ
ͬͳͽͳ
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͳͼ;
ͳͷͪͶͳ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͽ͹
ͼͬͰ
ͬͳͯͰͽͳ
ͳͶͳ
΂ͳͽͪͽͳi
̀ͪͽ͹

͵Δͳͭͪ
ͳͲ

ͯ͹͸͹ͼͳ
͹ͺͳͼ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͼͪ
ͼͬͳͷ
͸ͪΒͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͳͷ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹
ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͯ͹͵
ΒͰ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
ͽͪ͵ͪͬ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ͯͪ
͸ͪΌͰ

ͯͰͶͳͷͳ΂͸͹
ͷͰͼͽͪ
ͳͼ͵Γ;΂ͳͬ͹
;
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͭͶͪͬΓ;
;
͵͹ͷͰ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͯͻ͹ͫ
͸ͳΒͰ
͹ͺͳͼ;Β;
͸ͪΒͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͰ
͹ͼ͹ͫͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͋;
ΒͰ
͊;ͫ͹ͽͳΕͰͬ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹

ͯͪ
ͫ;ͯͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͯͰͶͳͷͳ΂͸͹
͵͹ͻͳ΃ΕͰ͸
ΒͰͻ
ͼ;
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳ
ͳͲ
ͻͰͬ͹Ͷ;΁ͳΒͰ


;ͼͶ͹ͬͳͶͳ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
ͭͻͪͯͪ
̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ

Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
͸ͳ
ͯͰͶ͹
͵͹ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹
ͺͻͰͬ͹ͯͳ
͸Ͱ͵ͳ

͹ͯ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ 
ΒͰͻ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸ͳ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ
ͺͻ;ͱͪ
ͬͰͶͳ
͵ͳ
ͫͻ͹Β
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸ͳ΀
͊ͻͫͳͷͪ
̸;ͽ͹ͻ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰ͸ͳ͹

ΒͰ
ͳ
͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪΒ;Εͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͺͳͼͪΔͪ
͵͹Βͳ
;
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹ͼͽͳ
͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪ
ͺͻͪ
ͬͳͶͳͷͪ
͹ͺͳͼͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͯ͹͸͹ͼͳ
;
͉Ͱͽ͹ͻͳ΁ͳ
͚͹ͻΌͰ
ͪͅͶͰͽͳΕ

͋ͪ͵͹
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͼͬ͹ͷ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ;
͵͹ͷͫͳ͸;ΒͰ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͪ

ͽ͹ͺ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͪ
Ͱͽ͸͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͪ
͹ͺͳͼͳͬͪΔͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
tͪͻ΀Ͱ͹
Ͷ͹ͭͳͼ͵ͪ
͵͹Ί
͹ͺͳͼ;Ή
ͺͪͷͰͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬͪ
ͳͽͯi



̹Ͱ΂΅
ͳ
͸¢ͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͹ͺͳͼͪ͹
*͹ͪ͸͸΅
͊;ͫͫ͹ͽͳΕ΅
ͳͲͯͪ͹
̓ͪͻͶ·

̻ͪʹͫͰͶ΅



́ͼͽ͹
ͫͰͲ
͹Ͳ͸ͪ͵Ͱ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ


̿ͳͬ͹ͽ
ͯͻͪ
͠͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
͊;ͫ͹ͽͳΕͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͫͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ

̽ͻ;ͭͳ
ͯͰ͹
͈ͻ͹ͶͰΕͰ
͆͹
ͬͳ
͊ͪͯ




̺͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͫ;ͯ;
͵͹ͻͳ΃ΕͰ͸ͳ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͺͻͳͻͰΌͳͬͪΔͪ
ͯͰͶͪ

̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͼ;
%FVUTDIMBOE
VOE
EFS
¸TUFSSFJDIJTDIF
,BJTFSTUBBU

)BOECVDI
GÛS
3FJTFOEF
WPO
,
#BFEFLFS
$PCMFO[

)
+
.FZFS
8JFO
'ÛISFS

EVSDI
EJF
,BJTFSTUBEU
VOE
BVG
EFO
CFTVDIUFOTUFO
3PVUFO
EVSDI
0FTUFSSFPJDI
m6OHBSO

VOUFS
CFTPOE
#FSÛDLTJDIU
EFS
8FMU"VTTUFMMVOH

,
#BFEFDLFS
4ÛE%FVUTDIMBOE

VOE
0FTUFSSFJDI
)BOECVDI
GÛS
3FJTFOEF
-FJQ[JH

,
#BFEFDLFS
0FTUFSSFJDI
VOE

6OHBSO
)BOECVDI
GÛS
3FJTFOEF
-FJQ[JH

'ÛISFS
EVSDI
EJF
,BJTFSTUBEU
)JMECVSH
IBVTFO



͚
ͪͅͶͰͽͳΕ·
͉ͳͽ͹ͻͳ͵ͪ
ͯͰ͹
ͯͻ;ͭJʹ
΂ͪͼͽ͸ͪ
ͻͳͽ͹ͻͳ͵ͪ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;




 ͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͯ͹
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ 

̺͹ͯͳ΂
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͰΓͰ͸
;
΂Ͱͽͻ͸ͪͰͼͽ
ͺ͹ͭͶͪͬΓͪ
̓ͻͪͽ͵Ͱ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ

͉ͪͲ͸Ͱ
ͽͪ͵ͼͰ
͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
̽;͸ͪͬ͹ͷ
͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͭͬ͹ͲͯͰ͸ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽͰͷ
́Ͳ

̹Ͱ΂ͪ
;
͈Ͱ΃ͽ;
͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͯ͹
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
̻͹ͼͽͳ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
;
̹Ͱ΂;
͈ͻͬ͹
΀͹ͯͪΔͰ

͵ͻ͹Ͳ
̹Ͱ΂
͑ͽͪ
ͼͰ
;
͵͹Βͳ
ͯͪ͸
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͬͳͯͳͽͳ
͆ͪΒͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹
ͼͽͳ
͇ͫ΃ͳͻ͸ͳΒͰ
͹
͹ͬͳͷ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
͋Ͱͪͽͻͳ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͲͪͫͪͬͰ

͇͵͹Ͷͳ͸ͪ
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
͑Ͱ͸ͫͻ;͸

ͳ
́ͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
͆ͪͲͳͬͳ
ͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
ͺ͹ͭͶͪ
ͬΓͪ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲ;Β;
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
;ͺ;
΃ͽͪΒ;
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
͵ͪ͹
΂ͳ͸
;ͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͳ
͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬͪΔͪ
;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͳ
̀ͪͽ͹

ΒͰ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͪ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪͶͪ
ͳͼͽͳ΁ͪΔͰ
ͳ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰ
΂ͳͽͪ
͹΁ͪ
ͼͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳͷ
ͰͶͰͷͰ͸ͽͳͷͪ
͸;ͱ͸ͳͷ
Ͳͪ
ͳͼͺ;ΔͪͬͪΔͰ
;ͼͺͰ΃͸͹ͭ
΁ͳ
Γͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͳ
Ͳͪͼ͸͹ͬͪ͸
͸ͪ
ͽ;ͷͪ΂ͰΔ;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ

ͷ͹ͯͰͶͪ
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸Ͱ
;
͵͹Β;
ͼͰ
ͺ;ͽ;ΒͰ
;͵ͪͲͳͬͪΔ;
͸ͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ
ͼ͵Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
͵ͻͪΒ
ͺ;ͽͪ
ͳ
͹ͫΒͪ΃ΔͪͬͪΔ;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͽ͹ͺ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ

ͭͻͪͯͪ
̹Ͱ΂ͪ

*
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
m
̹Ͱ΂
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ
ͷ͹ͯͰͶͳ
;
͹ͭͶͰͯͪͶ;

͠Ͱͯ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
ͫͳͽ͸ͳ΀
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ΒͰͼ;
͸Ͱ͹ͺ
΀͹ͯ͸ͪ
;ͺ;ͽͼͽͬͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͌
Δͳ΀
ͼ;
;ͭͻͪΌͰ͸Ͱ
͸;ͱ͸Ͱ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳ
ΒͰ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ΒͰ͵΁ͳΒͪ
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸Ͱ
;
͵͹Β;
ͼͰ
ͺ;ͽ;ΒͰ
̓ͻ͹Ͳ
͸ͪͬ͹ΌͰΔͰ
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͪ

ͺͻͪͬͳͶͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͷ͹Εͳ
Ͳͪ
ͼ͸ͪͶͪͱͰΔͰ
;
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸ͳͷ
ͼͳͽ;ͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
͹ͭͶͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹
ͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪΔͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
;
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͺ;
ͽ;ΒͰ
͈͹ͭͶͰͯ
͸ͪ
ͱͰΓͰ͸͹
͹ͯͻͰͯͳ΃ͽͰ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸
ΒͰ
ͬͳͲ;ͻ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͪ

ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͸Ͱͭ͹
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳͷ
ͼͽͪΔͰͷ
͈;ͽ͸ͳ͵
ͺͻͰͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒͰ
ͷ͹ͯͰͶ
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸Ͱ

ͳ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͼ͹ͺͼͽͬͰ͸ͳͷ
ͼ΀ͬͪͽͪΔͳͷͪ
͹ͯͻͰΌ;ΒͰ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͺ͹͸ͪ΃ͪΔͰ
͈;ͽ͸ͳ΂
͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͯ͹͸͹΃ͰΔͰ
͸ͪΒͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͵͹ͯͳͿͳ͵;ΒͰ

ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯ
ͳ
;ͼͷͰͻͪͬͪ
͵ͻͰͽͪΔͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹͸ͪ΃ͪΔͰ
͵ͪ
ͳ
;
ͷͰͼͽ;

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͈;ͽ
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͯ͹
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
ͳ
;ͺ;ͽͼͽͬͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͭͪ
ͺͻͪͽͰ
͸Ͱ
͸͹ͼͰ
͹ͯͶͳ
͵Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͷ͹ͯͰͶͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹
͹ͯ;ͯͪͻͪΒ;
͹ͯ
ͽͪͯͪ
ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶ
͸͹ͭ
ͼͽͰͻͰ͹ͽͳͺ͸͹ͭ
ͳ
͹ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͪͶͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯͪ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
́͸Ϳ͹ͻ
ͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͼ;
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͽͰ΀͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
͸Ͱͭ͹
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͹Ͷ͹΃͵Ͱ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͰ
͌
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
ͼͰ

͵ͪ͹
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͯ͹
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͰ
ͺͻͰͬ͹Ͳͳ

ͫͻ͹ͯ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΁͹ͷ
͇ͺͳͼͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷ
͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪΒ;
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻ
ͷͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪ͸ͳͷ
;
t͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ
͸͹ͬͳ͸ͪͷͪi
͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͫͻ͹ͯ͹ͷ



͇
ͺͻ͹ΒͰ͵΁ͳΒͳ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
ͬͳͯͰͽͳ
.
5PEPSPWB
*NBHJOBSOJ
#BMLBO
#FPHSBE




̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ

 ͆Ͱ͸ͪͯ
ͪͅ͵;ΓͰͬͳΕ

ͫͳ
Ͳͪͺ͹΂ͳΔͪͶ͹
ͺͻͰͬ͹Ͳ͹ͷ
ͳͲ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
;

΂ͪͼ͹ͬͪ
;Β;ͽͻ͹
ͯ͹
̀Ͱͷ;͸ͪ

͹ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͳ΃Ͷ͹
ͯ͹
͈Ͱ΃ͽͰ
ͳ
ͯͪΓͰ
ͯ͹
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
͈;ͽ͸ͳ͵
͵͹Βͳ

ͫͳ
ͼͰ
͹ͯͶ;΂ͳ͹
ͯͪ
͵ͻͰ͸Ͱ
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΁͹ͷ
ͷ͹ͻͪ͹
ͫͳ
ͺͪͻ͹ͫͻ͹ͯ͹ͷ
tͯͻͱͪͬ
͸Ͱ
ͱͰΓͰͲ͸ͳ΁Ͱi
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͬͰͲͰ
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͪ
̽;ͫͻͪͬͳ΁Ͱ

ͳͶͳ
̺ͰͶͳ͵͹ͭ

̻ͻͪͯͳ΃ͽͪ
ͯ͹
̹ͪͲΒͪ΃ͪ
ͭͯͰ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
;͵ͻ΁ͪ͹
;
ͬ͹Ͳ
͠Ͱͯͪ͸

͹ͯ
ͼͽͻͪ΀͹ͬͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͪͽͳ͹
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͳͲ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
͵ͻͳͷͳ͸ͪͶ
;

ͬͰͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͭͻͪͯ;
ͺ͹ͺ;ͽ
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
͌
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͯͻͪͼ;ͯͰ
͹
͵ͻͳͷͳ͸ͪͶ;

ͯͰͷͪ͸ͽ;Β;
ͳ
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͼͰ
ͯͪ
t͹
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͷ
ͬͪͻ͹΃ͳͷͪ
͹ͫͳ΂͸͹
ͼͰ
ͺͻͳ΂ͪ
͹

͵ͻͪΌͪͷͪ
ͳ
͹
ͬͰ΃ͽͳͷ
Ͷ͹ͺ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͸Ͱͭ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
;
ͼͪͷ͹Β
ͼͽͬͪͻͳ

͆ͪΒͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͺͪͲͳͽͳ
͸ͪ
ͼͪͽ
ͳ
͸ͪ
͸͹ͬ΁Ͱ
;
ΘͰͺ;
͵ͪͯ
ͼͰ
͸ͰͭͯͰ
;
ͭ͹ͷͳ
Ͷͳ
ͭ;ͻͪͽͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
͵ͪͯ
͵;ͺ;ΒͰͽͰ
ͫͳͶͰͽͰ
͵ͪͯ
ͳͲͶͪͲͳͽͰ
ͳͲ
ͽͰͪͽ͹ͻͪ

ͳͽͯ
̸͵͹
ͺ͹͸ͰͼͰͽͰ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͸͹ͬͪ΁ͪ
;ͲͷͳͽͰ
ͷͪͶͳ
͵͹ͱ͸ͳ
ΕͰͷͰͻ
ͳͷͪ
ͳ΀

͵͹ͯ
ͻ;͵ͪͬͳ΂ͪͻͪ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
Ͳͪ

ͭͻ͹΃ͪ

ͽ;
ͼ;
ͬͪͷ
͸͹ͬ΁ͳ
͸ͪΒͼͳͭ;ͻ͸ͳ
Βͳ
͌
ΘͰͺ;
ͲͪͯͻͱͳͽͰ
͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͬͪͷ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
Ͳͪ
ͯͬͪ
ͽͻͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪi

̀͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ͸
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
;
;ͺ;ͽͼͽͬͳͷͪ
͹
ͼ͸ͪͶͪͱͰΔ;
;
̹Ͱ΂;
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸

ΒͰ
ͳͼ΀ͻͪ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͪΒ;
̓ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
͸Ͱ

Ͳ͸ͪΒ;
ΒͰͲͳ͵
ͺͻͰͬ͹ͯͰ
ͼͰ
ͳ
͹ͫΒͪ΃ΔͪͬͪΒ;
͸ͪͲͳͬͳ
ΒͰͶͪ
t͠ͰͶͪ
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪΒͬͳ
΃Ͱ
;
ͫͰ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺͳͬ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
CJSIBMF

ͼͺ͹ͷͳΔ;
ΒͰͼ;
͹ͬͪ
̹ͪΒ΃Ͷͼ;ͺͰ
ͽ͹

ΒͰ
ͶͰͺͪ
ͭ;ͼͽͪ
ͻͳͫΓͪ
΂͹ͻͫͪ

ͷͳ͸Ͱͼͽͻͪ
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͫͻͪ
ͽͪͶͳΒͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͼ;ͺͪ

ͳͷͪ
;
Δ͹Β
ͺͳͻͳ͸΂ͪ
͵͹ͷͪͯͳΕͪ
ͷͰͼͪ
ͳ
ͻͪͲ͸Ͱ
ͲͰͶͰ͸ͳ

̹;ΒΓ͹͸
͑͸ͳ΁
Ͷͪ
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͽͪ͸͵ͳ
ͺͻͱͰ͸
͵͹ͷͪͯͳΕ
ͷͰͼͪ

ͻ͹ͼͽͫͰͿ
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͭ͹ͬͰΌͳ͸ͪ
;
ͺ͹
Ͷͪ
ͺͰ΂Ͱ͸ͪ
ͳͲ͸;ͽͻͪ
ΒͰ
͵ͻͬͪͬͪ
͵ͪͯ
͸͹ͱͰͷ
ͼͰ΂ͰͽͰ
ͽͬͻͯͪ
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͶ͹
ͪ
ͺͻͳ

ͽ͹ͷ
ͬͻͶ͹
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹
ͻͪ͸ͳ
ͳ
͵͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪͬͳ͵͸Ͱ
ͬͻͶ͹
ͷ;
ΒͰ
ͼͶͪͽ͵͹

΃͹ͺͿͫͻͪ
ͽͰ͸
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͼͬͳΔͼ͵͹
ͼ;ͬ͹
ͷͰͼ͹


ͭ;Ͷͪ΃
ͳͷͪ
ͯͬͰ
ͼ͹ͻͽͰ
͵ͪͯ
͵ͪͱͰͽͰ

;͸ͭͪͻͼ͵ͳ
ͭ;Ͷͪ΃
͹͸ͯͪ
ͯ͹͸ͰͼͰ
ͬͪͷ
ͷͪͶ͹
ͲͪͺͪͺͻͰ͸
ͭ;Ͷͪ΃
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͳ΃ͽͪ

ͯͻ;ͭ͹
͸ͳΒͰ
͸Ͱͭ͹
ͺͪͺͻͳ͵ͪ΃


ͽͰͼͽͪ
ͷͰͶ΃ͺͪΒͲ͸

ͼ;
;
̹Ͱ΂;
ͯ͹ͫͻͳ
ͳ

ΒͰͬͽͳ͸ͳ
͇ͫͳ΂͸͹
͹͸ͳ
΃ͽ͹
;
ΒͰͶ͹ͬ͸ͳ͵;
ͼͽ͹ΒͰ
Ͳͪͺͳͼͪ͸ͳ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͬ͹ͷ
ͳͶͳ

ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͷ
ͷͰͼͽ;
Ϳͻͳ΃͵ͳ
ͼ;
͇͸ͳ
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͳͷ
ͳͷͰ͸ͪ
ͺͰ΂ͪͽͪ͸ͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͼ;

͵͹Ͷͪ΂ͳi

͌
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸Ͱ
ͭ͹ͼͽͳ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͳ
΀͹ͽͰͶͳ
;
̹Ͱ΂;

ͪ
͵ͪ͹
͸ͪΒͼ͵;ͺΓͳ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͼͰ
̻ͻͪ͸ͯ
΀͹ͽͰͶ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͺͻͬͳ΀
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ΀
ͳ

Ͷ;͵ͼ;Ͳ͸ͳ΀
΀͹ͽͰͶͪ 
̾ͻ΁͎Ͱͻ΁͹ͭ
̓ͪͻͶ
͎͹ͽͰͶ
ͅ;͸΂
̽ͳͬΓͳ
΂͹ͬͰ͵



͈ͻͬ͹
΁
͵ͻ
͹ͬͶ
ͯ;͸ͪͬͼ͵͹

ͺͪͻ͹ͫͻ͹ͯ͸͹
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬ͹
͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
͸͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

̹Ͱ͹
ͭͻͪͯ

***





͉Ͱͯ
ͺͶ͹ͬͳͯͫͰ
͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
͸͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

***





̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ



́ͼͽ͹



+
1FNTFM
%JF
8JFOFS
8FMUBVTTUFMMVOH
WPO

;
5SBVN
VOE
8JSLMJDILFJU

m
8JFO


 ͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͯ͹
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ 

t JMEFS
NBO
i
ͳ
ͯͻ
́ͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͼͰ
ͯͪ
͊ͻͫͳ
͸ͪΒͬͳ΃Ͱ
͹ͯͼͰͯͪΒ;
;
΀͹ͽͰͶͳ
ͷͪ
͆ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ
̹ͰͶͳ
͵;ͻΒͪ͵
t BKTFS
WPMG
i
ͳ
̈́͹͸ͯ͹͸
͌ͭ͹ͼͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ

͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸ͳ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ;Β;

ͼͰ
ͳ
;
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͺͻͳͻ;΂͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁Ͱ
΁ͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͋ͪ
͵͹
ͼ;
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͹ͯͼͰͯͪͶͳ
;
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳͷͪ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂ͳͬͪ͸ͳͷ
ͳ
Ͳͪ

Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͭ͹ͼͽͰ
ͭͻͪͯͪ

͌
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸͹ͷ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ;
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ

ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸͹
ͷͰͼͽ͹
Ͳͪ;ͲͳͷͪͶͰ
ͼ;
͵ͪͿͪ͸Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͯ
ͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͰ
Βͪͬ͸ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
ͭͯͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
Γ;ͯͳ
ͼ;ͼͻͰͽͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͻͪͲͷͰΔͳͬͪͶͰ

ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͷͳ΃ΓͰΔͪ
͹
ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶ͸ͳͷ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳͷͪ
͈ͻͬͪ
ͫͰ΂͵ͪ
͵ͪ
Ϳͪ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ
ͳͼͺͳΒͪΔͪ
͵ͪͿͰ
ͼͽͳͭͪ͹
ΒͰ
͹ͯ
͋;ͻͪ͵ͪ 
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͹ͬͪΒ

͸ͪͺͳͽͪ͵
ͻͰͯ͹ͬ͸͹
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳͶͳ
͆ͪͬͳ͵;
͵͹ͻͳ΃ΕͰΔͪ
͵ͪͿͰ
;ͼͬ͹ΒͳͶͳ
ͼ;

ͳ
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬ͸ͳ
΀ͻͳ΃Εͪ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͯ
͋;ͻ΁ͳͷͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͽͻ
ͭ͹ͬ΁ͳͷͪ
;
̹Ͱ΂;
͵ͪͿͪ͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
;
͵͹ͷͰ
ͼ;
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
ͯͪ

;ͺͻͪͱΔͪͬͪΒ;
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͼͬ͹Βͳ΀
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸ͳ΀
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͪ
͌
̹Ͱ΂;
͊ͻͫͳ

ͼ;
ͺ͹΀͹ͯͳͶͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵;
ͳ
ͭͻ΂͵;
͵ͪͿͪ͸;
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪͶͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε
͸͹ͼͽ
΂ͳͽͪΔͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ΀
͸͹ͬͳ͸ͪ
͆ͰͯͪͶͰ͵͹
͹ͯ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
͵ͪͿͪ͸Ͱ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ

ͼͰ
ͺͳͬ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂Ͱ͸ͪ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
t͋ͻͳ
ͭͪͬͻͪ͸ͪi
%SFJ
3BCFO

΂ͳΒͳ

ΒͰ
ͬͶͪͼ͸ͳ͵
̽ͳͬͳ΃͹ͬͼ͵ͳ
ͪ
ͭͯͰ
ͼͰ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
΂;ΒͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ

́ͼͽͳ
ͬͶͪͼ͸ͳ͵
ͳͷͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͺͳͬ͸ͳ΁;
t͑ͬͪΒ΁Ͱͻ΀ͪ;Ͳi
;
͈ͻͪͽͰͻ;
͸ͰͯͪͶͰ
͵͹
͹ͯ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͲͶ͹ͱͫͰ
̓ͪ͹
͸ͪΒ͵ͬͪͶͳͽͰͽ͸ͳΒͳ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
͸ͪΒͼ͵;ͺΓͳ
ͻͰͼͽ͹
ͻͪ͸
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸
ΒͰ
t;BIFSi

͎͹ͽͰͶͳ
ͳ
͵ͪͿͪ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂Ͱ͸ͳ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
͸ͪͶͪͲͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
;
΁Ͱ͸
ͽͻ;
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
;
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
͹͵͹
͍ͶͪΒ΃ͷͪͻ͵ͽͪ
'MFJTDINBSLU

ͭͯͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪ
ͲͳͶͰ
ͳ
ͭͻ΂͵ͪ
΁ͻ͵ͬͪ
ͳ
ͼͳ͸ͪͭ͹ͭͪ
͈;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͼͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
ͺ͹ͯ

͹ͼͷͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͬͶͪ΃Ε;
ͫͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͻͰͯ͹ͬ͸ͳ
ͭ͹ͼͽͳ
ͫͰ΂͵ͳ΀

͵ͪͿͪ͸ͪ
͇͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯ͹ͷ
m
͹ͯͰΕ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͺ͹͸ͪ΃ͪΔͰͷ
ͯͪͬͪͶͳ



̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ




͈;͸Ͱ
ͪͯͻͰͼͰ
͹ͬͳ΀
ͭ͹ͼͽͳ͹͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͳ
΀͹ͽͰͶͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͰ
ͼͰ
;
%FVUTDIMBOE
VOE
EFS

¸TUFSSFJDIJTDIF
,BJTFSTUBBU
)BOECVDI
GÛS
3FJTFOEF
WPO
,
#BFEFLFS
$PCMFO[





̺ͳͯͳ
3
8JU[NBOO
%BT
8JFOFS
,BGGFIBVT
BMT
0SU
TUÅEUJTDIFS
(FTFMMJHLFJU

VOE
,VMUVS

;
%BT
8JFOFS
,BGGFIB;T
7PO
EFO
"OGÅOHFO
CJT
[;S
;XJTDIFO
LSJFHT[FJU
";TTU
,BU
8JFO




͇
ͺͻͬͳͷ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
Βͪͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
;͵Γ;΂;Β;Εͳ
͵ͪͿͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
+
)B
CFSNBT
͸ͪͬ
ͯͰͶ͹



,
5FQMZ
%JF
"OGÅOHF
EFT
8JFOFS
,BGGFFIBVTFT
-FHFOEFO
VOE
'BLUFO
;
%BT

8JFOFS
,BGGFIBVT
7PO
EFO
"OGÅOHFO
CJT
[VS
;XJTDIFOLSJFHT[FJU



͉Ͱͼͽ͹ͻͪ͸
j%SFJ
3BCFOv
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ͹
ͼͰ
;
;Ͷͳ΁ͳ
3BCFOHBTTF
̀ͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ

ͼͰ
͹ͬͪ
;Ͷͳ΁ͪ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
Ͳ͹ͬͰ
3BCFO
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;
Δ͹Β
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
̓ͪͿͰ
3BBC


̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ

 ͆Ͱ͸ͪͯ
ͪͅ͵;ΓͰͬͳΕ

ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸ͳ
ͺͰ΂ͪͽ
͵ͪͿͪ͸ͪͷͪ
΁ͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
;ͽͳ΁ͪͶ͹
ͯͪ

͹͸ͳ
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
͹Ͳ͸ͪ΂Ͱ͸ͳ
͵ͪ͹
̻ͻ΁ͳ
ͳ
͋;ͻ΁ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪ͸;
ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͷͰͽ
ͺͻͳ
͵ͪͲͳͬͪΔͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼ;
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͭ͹ͼͽͳ
΁ͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ

͹ͯͼͰͯͪͶͳ

ͳ
͵ͻͰͽͪͶͳ
ͼͰ
;
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͭͯͰ
ͼ;
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͽͻͭ͹ͬ΁ͳ
ͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ

ͼͽ;ͯͰ͸ͽͳ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹
ͬͰΕ
ͫͳͶͳ
ͺͻͳͼ;ͽ͸ͳ
̓ͪ͹
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͯ͹ͷͳ͸ͪ͸ͽ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͪ
ΒͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͼͰ
΁Ͱ͸Ͱ
ͳ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ
΂;
ͼͰ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͷͪΔͳ΀
͸͹ͬ΂ͪ͸ͳ΀
ͯͪͬͪΔͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
͸ͪͭͶͪ
΃ͪͬͪ
ͯͪ
tͪ͵͹
ͼͽͰ
ͯ͹΃Ͷͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͯͪ
ͬͳͯͳͽͰ
̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ͪ͵͹
ͱͰͶͳͽͰ
͹
ͷͪͶ͹

ͽͻ͹΃͵ͪ
ͺͻ͹Εͳ
͸Ͱͷ͹ΒͽͰ
͸ͳ΃ͽͪ
͵;ͺ͹ͬͪͽͳ
ͅ͸͹ͭͰ
ͼͽͬͪͻͳ
͵;ͺͳΕͰͽͰ

ΒͰͬͽͳ͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͫ͹ΓͰ
͵͹ͯ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
͵;ΕͰi
͇ͬͪ
;ͺ;ͽͼͽͬͪ
ͼͪ
΁Ͱ͸ͪͷͪ
;ͼͶ͹ͬΓͰ
͸ͪ
ͼ;
͸Ͱ
ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͷͪΔͳͷ
ͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶ͸ͳͷ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹ͷ

΃ͽͰͯΓͳͬ͹΃Ε;
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͽͻͭ͹ͬͪ΁ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
΂ͳ͸ͳͶͳ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ

ͼͶ͹Β
ͳͲ
͵͹ͭ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͽͳ΁ͪͶͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
Ͳͪ
̹Ͱ΂

͊ͪͯͻͱͪΒ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͳ
;ͺ;ͽͼͽͬͪ
ͯͪͽͪ
;
ΔͰͷ;
ͺ͹͵ͪͲ;Β;
ͯͪ
͹ͺ΃ͽͰ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͹Ͷ͹΃͵Ͱ
͹ͼ͹ͫͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͳ
̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
͸ͳͼ;
ͫͳͶͰ

ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͳͲ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
͇͸Ͱ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͰ
ͯͰ͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͭ
ͼͳͼͽͰ
ͷͪ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͻͪͲͬͳΒͪ͹
ͳ
;
ͷͶͪͯ͹Β
̓͸ͰͱͰͬͳ͸ͳ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͯͪ
ͳͲͯͪ
ͬͪΔͰ
ͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͺ͹
͵ͪͲ;Β;
ͳ
ͺ͹ͽͬͻΌ;Β;
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͰͳͲͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͳ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵;
Ͱͷͪ͸΁ͳͺͪ΁ͳΒ;
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ

;
9*9
ͬͰ͵;

**
̓;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ;

͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͺ͹͵ͻͰ͸;ͽ͹
ͳͲ
ͱͰΓͰ
Ͳͪ
Ͷͳ΂͸ͳͷ
;ͼͪͬͻ΃ͪͬͪΔͰͷ
ͺ͹ͯ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺͻͰͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒ;
ͳ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
͵ͻͰͽͪΔͪ
͵ͪ

ͱͰΓͰ͸͹Β
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͳ
͌
Ͳͪͬͳͼ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͹ͯ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͯ;ͱͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ

ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͷ͹ͭ;
;ͺͻͪͬ͹
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͫ;ͯ;
͹ͯͪͫͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹
ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͬͪͱ͸ͳͷ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ

ͫͻ͹ͯ͹ͷ
ͳͶͳ
ͬ͹Ͳ͹ͷ
͸ͳΒͰ

͸;ͯͳͶ͹
͹ͼͳͷ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͸͹Β
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͲͪͯͻͱͪͬͪΔͪ
;
ͷͰ
ͼͽͳͷͪ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͻ͹ͶͪͲͳͶ͹
ͪͶͳ
ͼ;
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽͰ
ͽͪ΂͵Ͱ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳ
ͼͽͳ΂͸Ͱ
ͺ͹
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳͷ
ͳͶͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
͹ͼ͹ͫͰ͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͫͳ
ͶͰ
͸ͪͭͶͪ΃Ͱ͸Ͱ
͋Ͱ͵ͼͽ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͸;ͯͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹

ͯͪ
;Ͳ
ͺ͹ͷ͹Ε
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
ͷͰͷ͹ͻͳ΃Ͱ
͇ͯͪͫͳͻ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽͳ΀
ͷͰͼͽͪ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͳ΀
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵ͪ
Ͳͪͬͳ
ͼͳ͹
ΒͰ
͹ͯ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͰ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͊ͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸͹ͼͽ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ;ͽ͹



͈͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
΁ͻͽͰͱͪ
ͳ
ͼͶͳ͵ͪ
ͼͪ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͳͷͪ
j̻ͻ͵ͪv
ͳ
j͋;ͻͪ͵ͪv
;
ͫͰ΂
͵ͳͷ
͵ͪͿͪ͸ͪͷͪ
̺ͳͯͳ
%BT
8JFOFS
,BGGFIBVT
7PO
EFO
"OGÅOHFO
CJT
[VS
;XJTDIFOLSJ
FHT[FJU
LBU





̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ

 ͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͯ͹
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ 

ͬͪΔͪ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵;
ͺ͹ͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͼͽͳ΁ͪΔͰ
͹ͼ͹ͫͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ

͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
͸͹ͼͳͶͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
͹ͺ΃ͽͳ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ
͋ͳͷͰ
ͼͰ

ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪ͹
ͼͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͹ͷ
ͼͬ͹ͭ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
͸ͪͼͽͪΔͰ͸͹ͭ
;

͎ͪͫͲͫ;ͻ΃͵͹Β
ͷ͹͸ͪͻ΀ͳΒͳ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͹ͷ͹ͭ;ΕͪͬͪͶ͹
͵͹͸ͼͽͻ;ͳͼͪΔͰ
ͼͬͰͼͽͳ

͹
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸͹ͷ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͷ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͷ
ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͽͰͽ;

͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ

ͳ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͹ͯ
͸͹ͼͳͶͰ
͸ͪ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶ͸ͳ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͬͰͻͼ͵ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒ

ͳͼͽͳ΁ͪͶͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͻͰͯ͹ͷ
ͺͻͪͽͰΕͳ

ͽͻͪͼ;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͌
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
ͼͰ

͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
;
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͸͹Β
ͱͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ΂
͵͹Β
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁ͳ
̹ͪͲΒͪ΃
ͳͼͽ͹ͳ
ͷͰ͸ͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬ͸ͳ

ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ
͈;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ΒͰ

ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂ͳͬͪ͸͹
ͯͪ
ͭͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ

ΒͰͻ
ͼ;
ͳͷͪͶͳ
tͯ͹ͼͽͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ

ͯ͹͵
ͯ͹ΌͰ
ͱͰΓͰͲ͸ͳ΁ͪi
͇
̹Ͱ
Ͷ͹Β
͏ͻ͵ͬͳ
̺ͻ΃΁;
͋Ͱͷͳ΃ͬͪͻ;
ͳ
͊ͰͭͰͯͳ͸;
ͯ͹͸͹ͼͰ
ͼͰ
͹ͫͪͬͰ΃ͽͰΔͪ
͹

ͫͻ͹Β;
ͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹Β
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͳ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ
΁ͻ͵ͬͪͷͪ

Ͱͺͪͻ΀ͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
ͼͰͯͳ΃ͽͳͷͪ
ͳ
΃͵͹Ͷͪͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͳͷ
͸ͪΒͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͳͷ

ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
͹ͼ͹ͫͰ͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
Ͳͪ
͋Ͱͷͳ΃ͬͪͻ
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ

tΒͪ͵
ͭͻͪͯ
ͳ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͪ
ͬͪͻ͹΃
;
΁ͰͶ͹ͷ
ͽ͹ͷ
͵ͻͪΒ;
͌
ΔͰͷ;
ͱͳͬͰ
͹͵͹


΀ͳΓͪͯͰ
ͯ;΃ͪ
͆Ͱͷͪ΁ͪ
͊ͻͫͪ
̺Ͷͪ
ͳ
ͪͅΌͪͻͪ
́ͷͪ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
Ϳͪͫͻͳ͵ͪ

͵ͪ͹
Ͳͪ
΂͹Β;
Ͳͪ
ͽ͵ͪΔͰ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻͰͯͰΔͰ
ͼͬͳͶͰ
Ͳͪ
Ͷͳ͵ͰͻͰ
ͳ
ͻ͹Ͳ͹ͶͳΒͰ
ͳͽͯi

͇
͆͹ͬ͹ͷ
͊ͪͯ;
ͼͰ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
tͶͰͺͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͪ
ͼͻͫͼ͵ͪ
ͬͪͻ͹΃
̽;ͭͪ΂͵ͪ

Ε;ͺͻͳΒͪ
͸ͪ
ͶͪΌͪͷͪ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͪ
̺ͪͻͪͯͳ͸
ͳ
͆͹ͬͳ
͊ͪͯ
͋;
ΒͰ
ͼͽ͹Ͷͳ΁ͪ

ͬͶͪͯͳ͵Ͱ
ͫͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ͳͷͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͪ
ͭͳͷ͸ͪͲͳΒͪ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪͻͳΒͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ

͸͹ͬͳ͸ͪ
ͪͅͽͳ΁ͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͪ
͵͹͸Ͳͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
ͺͰͽ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͶͰͺͳ
΁ͻ͵ͬͳ
ͳ
ͽ

ͯ
́ͷͪ
͹͵͹


ͱͳͽͰΓͪi
͌
̹ͪΒͳ
͸ͪͼͰΓͰ͸͹ͷ
ͼͪ
͹͵͹


ͼͽͪ



͇
͵͹͸ͼͽͻ;ͳͼͪΔ;
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͼͬͰͼͽͳ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰͷ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹
͸ͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
ͬͳͯͳ
͆
ͪͅ͵;ΓͰͬͳΕ
͌ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͪ
ͳͯͰΒͪ
;
9*9
ͬͰ͵;




͇
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ;
̹ͪͲΒͪ΃;
ͅ
͠͹ͬͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ
ͪͅ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ
̹ͪͲΒͪ΃
̀ͫ͹ͻ͸ͳ͵
Ͳͪ
Ͷͳ
͵͹ͬ͸Ͱ
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͪͅͽͳ΁Ͱ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ

͆͹ͬͳ
͊ͪͯ



́ͼͽͳ
͊Ͷͳ͵ͪͻͼͽͬ͹

͋Ͱͷͳ΃ͬͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
Ͱͺͪͻ΀ͳΒͰ
͆͹ͬͳ
͊ͪͯ




̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ




́ͼͽ͹



́ͼͽ͹

 ͆Ͱ͸ͪͯ
ͪͅ͵;ΓͰͬͳΕ

͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
ͼͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͷͰͼͽ;
ͼͪ
ͷͪΌͪͻͼ͵ͳͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
ͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ

ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ͹ͷ
͌
ͭͻͪͯ;
ͳͷͪ
tͬͳ΃Ͱ
΁ͻ͵ͬͳ
ͳ
ΒͰͯ͸;
ͼͳ͸ͪͭ͹ͭ;
Ϳͻͪ͸
΁ͳ΃͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ
΃ͺͳͽͪΓ
ͷͪͭͪ΁ͳ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ
ͼ͹
͵ͪͼͪͻ͸Ͱ
ͭͳͷ͸ͪͲͳΒ;

̺ͻͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͶͰͺ
ͯͬ͹ͻ
͵͸ͰͲͪ
̻ͻͪͼͪͶ͵͹ͬͳΕͪ
͌
̹ͪΒͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ
ͼͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽͪ
ͽͻ
ͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͪ
ͼͪ
ͱͳͽ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͼͬͳΔͪͷͪi
͇
͊ͻͰͷͼ͵ͳͷ
̓ͪͻͶ͹ͬ΁ͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ

͵ͪ͹
ͷͰͼͽ;
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸͹ͷ
;
ͻͰͬ͹Ͷ;΁ͳΒͳ

ͼͪ
ͼͰͯͳ΃ͽͰͷ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͪͽͻͳ
Βͪͻ΀ͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͷ
ͫ͹ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͳΒ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͭͳͷ͸ͪͲͳΒ͹ͷ
ͳ
t͹͵͹

ͱͳͽͰΓͪ
ͭ͹
ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͼͪͷͳ΀
͊ͻͫͪi
̀ͪ
ͬͳ͸͹ͭͻͪͯͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͼͪ
ͫͻ͹ͯͪ
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ

ͯͪ
ͬͳͯͰ
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͼͰ
ͯͪ
tͯͪΒ;
ͬͻͶ͹
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹
ͬͳ͸͹i
͆ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͯͪ
t͌

͊Ͱ͸ͽ̸͸ͯͻͰΒͳ
͸ͰͯͪͶͰ͵͹
͹ͯ
͈Ͱ΃ͽͰ
;Ͳ
̽;͸ͪͬ
ͳͷͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͪ
͸ͪͼͰͶͫͳ͸ͪ

͌
͈Ͱ΃ͽͳ
ͳ
̹;ͯͳͷ;
ͳͷͪ
ͼͻͫͼ͵ͪ
΁ͻ͵ͬͪ
͌
̹;ͯͳͷ;
ͱͳͬͳ
ͼͪͯͪ
͹͵͹


ͪ
;
͈Ͱ΃ͽͳ
͹͵͹

͊ͻͫͪ
i

̹ͳͽͪ͸
ͯͰ͹
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
͵ͻͪΒ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͽͻͪͼͪ
ͯ͹͸͹ͼͳ͹
ΒͰ

͹ͺͳͼͰ
ͳ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͷͪΌͪͻͼ͵ͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͺͻ͹ͶͪͲͳ
Ͷ͹
͊ͪͯͻͱͪΒ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͹ͯͻͰΌͳͬͪ͸
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;
͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ

ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͯ͹ͼͽͳͭ͸;Εͪ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ

Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ
̀ͪ
̹;ͯͳͷ
ͼͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͽͪͻͳ
ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ


ͫͳ͹
΂;ͬͰ͸
ͺ͹
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
ͶͰ͵͹ͬͳͽͳͷ
ͽ͹ͺͶͳͷ
͵;ͺͪͽͳͶͳͷͪ
ͼͪ
ͷͳ͸Ͱ
ͻͪͶ͸ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͬͳ͸͹ͷ
͠Ͱͯ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͳ΀
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵ͪ

ͳ
t͸ͪΒͬͰΕͪ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽ
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
;
͈Ͱ΃ͽͳ
ͬͳͯͳͽͳ
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͪ

͸ͪ
Ͷͪ͸΁ͳͷͪ
Ε;ͺͻͳΒͪ
̽ͬͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͪ
ͼͽ;ͫͪ
͹Ͳͳͯͪ͸ͪ
ͼ;
;
ͼͻͰͯ
̽;͸ͪͬͪ
ͼͬͪ
͵ͳ
ΒͰ
ͬͳͼ͹͵

ͼͽ͹ͺͪ

̓͹Ͷͪ
ͼͪ
͸ͪΒͬͰΕͳͷ
ͽͰͻͰͽ͹ͷ
ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯ͸͹
ͽͻ΂Ͱ
ͺ͹

Δ͹Βi
́ͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ
ͅ͹΀ͪ΂ͪ
͈͹ͱ;͸ͪ
ͳ
̺ͳ΃Ͱͭͻͪͯͪ
;ͼͶ͹ͬͳͶͳ

ͼ;
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
ͯ͹͸Ͱͼ;
ͼ͵ͻͪΕͰ͸ͳ
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯͳ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͹ͬͯͰ

͹ͯͬͳΒͪͶͳ
͌
ͽ;ͷͪ΂ͰΔ;
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ
͹ͬͳ΀
ͷͰͼͽͪ
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸͹
ΒͰ

;͵ͪͲͳͬͪ͸͹
͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
ͭͯͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͹͸ͳ
͹ͯͳͭͻͪͶͳ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸Ͱ
͵ͪ
ͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
͹ͬͳ΀
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
;
͈͹ͱ;͸;
ͷͰͼͽ;
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ΃ΔͰͭ

͵ͻ;͸ͳͼͪΔͪ
;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͳ΀
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͪ
ͳͼͽͳ΁ͪͶ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͬͳͯͳ
t
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͷͪͶͳ
͸ͪ
ͼ;ͽ
ͫͻͰͱ΂ͳΕ
͹ͫͲͳͯͪ͸
ͳ
͹ͫͭͻͪΌͰ͸
͹͵͹Ͷ͹
͋͹
ͼͰ
Ͳ͹ͬͰ
͵ͻͪΓͰͬ
ͫͻͰͱ
΂ͳΕ
͆ͪ
ͽͪΒ
ͫͻͰͱ΂ͳΕ
͹ͫͳ΂͸͹
ͼ;
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͳ
;͸ͭͪͻͼ͵ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
͵ͻ;͸ͳͼͪ
Δͪ
;
ͼͬͰ΂ͪ͸͹ͷ
͹ͯͰͶ;
ͳ
ͺ͹ͯ
͵ͻ;͸͹ͷ
͸ͪ
͵͹Δ;
ͳͲͶͪͲͳͶͳ
ͺͻͰͯ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ
ͳ

ͷͪ΀͸;Ͷͳ
ͼ;
ͼͪͫΓ͹ͷ
ͼͬͰͽ͹ͭ
͊ͽͰͬͪ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͬͰ
΂Ͱͽͳͻͳ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
Ͳͪ



́ͼͽ͹



́ͼͽ͹



́ͼͽ͹



́ͼͽ͹



́ͼͽ͹



́ͼͽ͹



́ͼͽ͹


 ͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͯ͹
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ 

Ͳ͸ͪ͵
ͯͪ
ΕͰ
΁ͪͻͼͽͬ͹
ͫͻͪ͸ͳͽͳ
͸ͪ
ͼͬͰ
΂Ͱͽͳͻͳ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ ͊ͪͯͪΔͳ
΁ͪͻ
͵ͻ;
͸ͳͼͪ͹
ͼͰ
Ͳͪ
͵ͻͪΓͪ
;͸ͭͪͻͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪ
ͽͪΒ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
;
͈Ͱ΃ͽͳ
i

̀͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
͸ͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
;͵ͪͲͳͬͪͶ͹
ͽ͹
͵͹ͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
Ͳͪ
̹Ͱ΂
ͫͳͶͰ
ͼ;
;͹ͫͶͳ΂Ͱ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͷͪΌͪͻͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳ

͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ΀
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ΀

ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
͢ͳ΀͹ͬ
͹ͯͪͫͳͻ
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
;ͼͶ͹ͬΓͰ͸
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͫͳ͹
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸
͌ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;

̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͫͳͶ͹
ΒͰ
͹ͯ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸Ͱ
ͬͪͱ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͯ͹ͺͻͳ͸͹ͼͳͶ͹
͵͹͸
ͼͽͻ;͵΁ͳΒͳ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸͹ͭ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͽͰͽͪ
͌͵ͪͲͳͬͪΔͰ
͸ͪ
ͫ͹
ͭͪͽ;
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵;
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
͵͹Βͳͷ
ͼͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪͶ͹

ͫͳͶ͹
ΒͰ
Ͳͪͼ͸͹ͬͪ͸͹
͸ͪ
ͼͬͰ͹ͺ΃ͽͰͷ
͵;Ͷͽ;
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
;
9*9
ͬͰ͵;
ͯ͹͵
ͼ;

Ͳͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵;
ͽͻͭ͹ͬͪ΂͵;
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵;
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵;
ͰͶͳͽ;
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪͶͪ

;
̹Ͱ΂
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͫͳͶͰ
͹ͯ
ͬͰͶͳ͵͹ͭ

Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ

***
̹Ͱ΂
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
;
Ͷͪͬͳͻͳ͸ͽ;

͈ͻͰͷͪ
΀;ͷͪ͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
΁ͳΓ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
΀͹ͯ͹΂ͪ
ͼ͸ͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͳͶͳ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ͸͹ͭ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͺͻ͹͸ͪͶͪͲͪ͵
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪ
Ͷͪͬͳͻͳ͸ͽͪ

m
t΀ͻͪͷͪ
ͷ;ͯͻ͹ͼͽͳi
͋ͪ͵͹
ͳ
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͪ͵
͸ͪ
͹ͯͻͰͯͳ΃ͽͰ
t΀͹ͯ͹΂ͪͼ͸ͳ͵ͪi

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͸Ͱ
͹Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪͬͪ
͵ͻͪΒ
͸ͪͺ͹ͻͪ
ͳ
͹ͼͽͬͪͻͰΔͰ
΁ͳΓͪ
͈͹ͼͶͰ
ͽͰ΃͵͹ΕͰ

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͼͶͰͯͳ
ͺͻ͹͸ͪͶͪͱͰΔͰ
ͳ
͹ͫͳͶͪͲͪ͵
t΀ͻͪͷ͹ͬͪ
ͷ;ͯͻ͹ͼͽͳi
͹Ͷͳ
΂Ͱ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯ;
;
ͬͳͯ;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ
͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪΒ;Εͳ΀
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;΁ͳΒͪ
͋;
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸͹
ͷͰͼͽ͹
Ͳͪ;ͲͳͷͪΒ;

ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͇͸ͳ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
;
9*9
ͬͰ͵; 
t͵ͶͪͼͳͿͳ͵;Β;i
ͳ
t͹ͽ͵ͻͳͬͪΒ;i
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͵͹ΒͰ

ͷ͹ͻͪΒ;
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ
ͳ
͸;ͯͰ
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸ͪ
;ͺ;ͽͼͽͬͪ
͹
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͺ͹
ͼͰͽͪ
ͳ
;ͽͬͻΌͰ͸ͳ
ͻͰͯ͹ͼͶͰͯ
͹ͫͳͶͪͲͪ͵ͪ

͈͹ͼͰͽͪ
͸Ͱ͵͹ͷ
ͭͻͪͯ;
ͺ͹ͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪΔͰ
;ͻͫͪ͸Ͱ
΁ͰͶͳ͸Ͱ

͵ͪ͹
ͪͻͽͳͿͳ΁ͳͻͪ͸͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
ͼͪ
ͼ͹ͺͼͽͬͰ͸ͳͷ
ͼͳͷͫ͹Ͷͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͼͻͰͯͳ
΃ͽͰͷ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
͵ͪ͹
͹ͭͶͰͯͪͶ͹
ͷ͹Εͳ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͼͽͬͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ



́ͼͽ͹



̺ͳͯͳ
ͅ
͋ͳͷ͹ͽͳΒͰͬͳΕ
͎Ͱͻ͹Β
ͺͰͻͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
ͽͳͺ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͪ
ͭͰ͸ͰͲͪ
Βͪͬ͸ͳ΀

͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
̺ͪͶͯͰ΁͹ͬͪ
ͼ͵;Ͷͺͽ;ͻͪ
̽͹ͼͳͽͰΒͪ
͇ͫͻͪͯ͹ͬͳΕͪ



͊ͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻ;
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯͪ
͸ͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
͹Ͷͳ΂ͪͬͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪͽ
ͷͰ
ͽ͹ͯ͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͇
ΔͰ͸ͳͷ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͬͳͯͳ
)
-PDIFS
,VOTU
HFTDIJDIUF
BMT
IJTUPSJTDIF
5IFPSJF
EFS
,VOTU 8JMIFMN
'JOL
7FSMBH
.ÛODIFO




.
)FTTF

+
1FDIF
4UBEUQMBOVOH
[XJTDIFO
,VOTU
VOE
1PMJUJL
;
,VOTU
EJF

(FTDIJDIUF
JISFS
'VOLUJPOFO
)STH
7PO
8
#VTDI
VOE
1
4DINPPL
8FJOIFJN
VOE

#FSMJO


 ͆Ͱ͸ͪͯ
ͪͅ͵;ΓͰͬͳΕ

ͳ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ΀
ͯͰ΃ͪͬͪΔͪ
̀ͪͽ͹
ͼͰ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
Βͪͼ͸͹
͹ͯͻͰΌ;ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;
Εͳ
ͽ͹͵
͹ͫͳͶͪͲͪ͵ͪ
͌
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ

͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷ;
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸͹
ΒͰ
ΒͰͯ͸͹
ͺ͹ͭͶͪͬΓͰ
t͈ͻͬ͹
΀͹ͯͪΔͰ
ͺ͹
̹Ͱ
΂;i
͋;
ͼͰ
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͯͪ
t
ͷͪ
ͭͯͰ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͪ΁
;
̹Ͱ΂;
͹ͯͼͰ͹
ͺͻͬͳ
ͷ;
ΒͰ
΀͹ͯ

͸ͪ
͊ͽͰͬͪ͸͹ͬ
ͺͶͪ΁
ͭͯͰ
ΒͰ
ͼͻͰͯͳ΃ͽͰ
ͬͪͻ͹΃ͳ
͈ͻͬͪ
ͷ;
ΒͰ
ͱͰΓͪ
͸ͪͻ͹
΂ͳͽ͹
ͪ͵͹
Β͹΃
͸ͳͭͯͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
;
̹Ͱ΂;
ͯͪ
ͺͻͰͽͻ΂ͳ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳΒͳ΀

;Ͷͳ΁ͪ
ͺͻͰ
͸Ͱͭ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͺ͹΂͸Ͱ
ͬͪͻ͹΃͵Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯͪͽͳ
͋ͪ͵͹

ΕͰ
ͷ͹Εͳ
ͳͷͪͽͳ
͸Ͱ͵ͳ
͹ͺ΃ͽͳ
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ
΁ͰͶͰ
ͬͪͻ͹΃ͳi
͈;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͳͲ

͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
͹ͯͶͪͼ͵ͪ
;
ͼͻ΁Ͱ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͹ͫͳͶͪͼ͵ͪ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͼ͵Ͱ
͵ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶͰ
m
4UFQIBOTEPNB
͵ͻͰ͸;
ͺͻͰͷͪ
̻ͻͪͫͰ͸;
͵ͪ
;Ͷͳ΁ͳ
͉ͳ͸ͭ
΃ͽͻͪͼͰ͋͹ͷ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͳ
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
ͷ͹ͻͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ͯͪ
ͺͻ͹Ό;
͵ͻ͹Ͳ

ͯͬ͹ͻ
ͭͯͰ
ͼ;
ͷ͹ͭͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͬͳͯͰ
tͬͰͶͳ΂ͪ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸ͳ
ͫ;ͻͭͽ͹ͻ
ͺͰͽ
͵ͪͺͳΒͪ
͸ͪ

ͼͬ͹ͯ͹ͬͰ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͼͻͰͯΔͳ
ͼͬ͹ͯ
ͺͻ͹ͶͪͲͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
΁ͪͻ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͪ
ͿͪͷͳͶͳΒͪ

ͼ

ͯͰͼ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
΃ͽͪͽ;ͪ
Ͱͻ΁΀Ͱͻ΁͹ͭͪ
̓ͪͻͶͪ
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͽ;͵ͪ͹
ͼ
͆ͪͺ͹ͶͰ͹͸͹ͷ

*
ͪ
ͼ
ͶͰͬͰ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
΃ͽͪͽ;ͪ
ͺͻͳ͸΁ͪ
̾ͬΌͰ͸ͳΒͪ
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͽ;͵ͪ͹
ͼ
͋;ͻ΁ͳͷͪ

ͳ
͹ͼͬ͹Βͳ͹
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
͹ͫͰ
ͼ;
΃ͽͪͽ;Ͱ
͸ͪ
͵͹Δ;i
͇ͫͳͶͪͲͪ͵
;Ͷͳ΁Ͱ
͉ͳ͸ͭ
΃ͽͻͪͼͰ
͵͹Βͪ
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͻͪ
;ͻͫͪ͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺͻͼͽͰ͸
͹͵͹
ͼͽͪͻͳΒͰͭ
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵͹ͭ

ΒͰͲͭͻͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪ͹
ΒͰ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰ
ͼͪ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳͷ
ͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
̹Ͱ΂ͪ

͉ͳ͸ͭ΃ͽͻͪͼͰ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͪ
ͳͯͰ͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ;ͻͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͳ
ͼ;
͹ͯ
ͻͪͲ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
ͽ͹͵͹ͬͪ
͎ͪͫͲͫ;ͻ΃͵Ͱ
ͺͻͰ
ͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͈ͳͼͪ΁
ͳ
ͺͻͳͻͰΌͳͬͪ΂
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ

ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ
ͳ
ͼͪ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͳͲͭͻͪͯΔͰ
͸ͪ
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ

͸ͪͭͶͪ΃ͪͬͪ
tͭͯͰ
ͼͰ
ͬͳͯͰ
΃ͳͻ͹͵ͳ
ͺͻͪͲ͸ͳ
ͺͶͪ΁Ͱͬͳ
Ͳͳͯͪ
ΕͰ
ͼͰ
;͸ͳͬͰͻ
ͲͳͽͰͽ
ͺͪͶͪͽͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼ;ΌͰ
Ͳͪ
ͭͰ͸ͰͻͪͶ͵͹ͷͪ͸ͯ;
͈ͪͻͶͪͷͰ͸ͽ
ͬͪͻ͹
΃͵;
͵;Ε;
ͳ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ
ͅ;ͲͰΒi

͉ͪͲͭͶͰͯͪΔͰ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳ΀
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͼͶͰ
ͯͰΕ;
ͿͪͲ;
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ
͋;
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸͹
ͷͰͼͽ͹
Ͳͪ;Ͳͳͷͪ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͪ
ͳͲͶ͹ͱͫͪ
̀ͪͽ͹

ͼͰ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
͹ͫͻͪΕͪ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁ͳͷͪ
t̽͹͵
ͼͽͰ
ͭ͹ͯ
;
̹Ͱ΂;
ͼͬͪ͵ͳ
ͯͪ͸
͸ͪΒͬͳ
΃Ͱ
ΕͰͽͰ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͬͰͼͽͳ
ͭͶͰͯͪΒ;Εͳ
ͳͲͶ͹ͱͫ;
͈͹Ͷͪ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸Ͱͫͳ
ͫͳ
Ͷ͹
ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͯͪ
΂͹ͬͰ͵
ͺ͹ͬͻ΃͸͹
ͼͬͰ
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯͪ
ͅ͸͹ͭͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ

͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
ͶͰͺͰ
ͬͰ΃ͽͳ͸Ͱ
ͫͳ
ΕͰ
;
ͳͲͶ͹ͭ;
Ͳͪͼͽ;ͺΓͰ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͼͽͻͪ͸΁ͳ
ΕͰ

Ͳͪͯ͹ͬ͹Γͳͽͳ
ͼͰ
ͼͪ
ͭͶͰͯͪΔͰͷ
ͳͲͶ͹ͭͪi



̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ



́ͼͽ͹



͇
ͫͰ΂͵͹Β
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵͹Β
͵ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶͳ
4U
4UFQIBO

+BISF
4VNCPM
VOE
.JUUF
JO

8JFO

"VTTU
,BU
8JFO




̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ



͇
͉ͳ͸ͭ΃ͽͻͪͼͰ
ͬͳͯͳ
̓
̾
͑͹ͻͼ͵Ͱ
'JOEFTJÊDMF
;
̹Ͱ΂;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ





̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ



́ͼͽ͹

 ͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͯ͹
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ 

͌
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͼ΀ͬͪͽͪΔͳͷͪ
ͺ͹ͻͰͽ͵ͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹
ͼͽͳ
ͳͼͽͳ΂;
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͰ
ͷ;ͲͰΒͼ͵Ͱ
Ͳͫͳͻ͵Ͱ
Βͪͬ͸ͪ
ͲͯͪΔͪ
ͳ
Βͪͬ͸ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ
͸ͳ΁ͳ
̽͹͸͹ͼͰ
ͼͰ
;ͺ;ͽͼͽͬͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ

Βͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
ͺͻͳͬͪͽ͸ͳ΀
Ͳͫͳͻ͵ͳ
ͳ
ͳͼͽͳ΂;
ͼͰ
͸ͪΒͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͰ
΁ͰͶͳ͸Ͱ
͆ͪͭͶͪ
΃Ͱ͸Ͱ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
΂ͳΒͳ
ͯ͹ͫͪͻ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͺͻ;ͱͪ
͹ͯͪͫͳͻ
ͼͶͳ͵ͪ
ͽͪͯͪ
ͳͲ
Ͷ͹ͱͰ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͷͪ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
΃͵͹Ͷͪ 
;
̻͹ͻΔͰͷ
̹ͰͶ
ͬͰͯͰͻ;
ͺ͹͵ͪͲ;Β;
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪΔͰ
;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
;͵;ͼ
ͺ;ͫͶͳ
͵Ͱ

͊Ͷͳ͵Ͱ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸Ͱ

͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯ;ͯͪͻͪΒ;
ͼͰ
;
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͼ

͹͸ͳͷͪ
ͳͲ
͊;ͫ͹ͽͳΕͰͬ͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
ͳͲ

͋͹
Βͪͼ͸͹
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͹
ͰͬͳͯͰ͸ͽ͸ͳͷ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪͷͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
͹
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ

ͯ͹
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͳͼͽͳ΂;
ͯͰͶͪ
ͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͪ
ͺ͹ͺ;ͽ
͉Ͱͷͫͻͪ͸ͽͪ
̺ͪ͸
̽ͪΒ͵ͪ

̓͹ͻͰΌͪ
͋ͳ΁ͳΒͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
͉;ͫͰ͸ͼͪ
͈͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪͭͶͪ΃ͪͬͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;
ͽͻͰΕ͹Β

ͼͪͶͳ
̻͹ͻΔͰͭ
̹ͰͶͬͰͯͰͻͪ
t͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
͸ͪΒͼ͵;ͺ͹΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͪ
ͼͶͳ͵ͪ
ͪ
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͼͶͳ
͵ͪ
̹͹ͭ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΁Ͱ
͹ͯ
͉ͪͿͪΒͰͶͪ
͸ͪΒͬͰΕͰͭ
ͷ͹ͶͰͻͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͬͰͽ;i
́ͼͽͳ΁ͪΔͰ

͉ͪͿͪͰͶͪ
͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͼ΀ͬͪͽͪΔͳͷͪ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
͹͸
ͺ͹
ͼͷͪͽͻͪ͸
͵ͪ͹
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͬͰΕͳ΀
ͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͪ
;
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
;ͼͶ͹ͬͳͶ͹

ΔͰͭ͹ͬ;
ͬͰͶͳ͵;
ͺ͹ͺ;Ͷͪͻ͸͹ͼͽ
;
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͪ
ͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳͷ

͵ͻ;ͭ͹ͬͳͷͪ

͈ͻ͹ͭͻͪͷ
͹ͫͳͶͪͼ͵ͪ
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹͸;ΌͰ͸

ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͳͷͪ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶ͸͹ͼͽ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪ
ͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
͌
ΔͰͷ;
ͼͰ
;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
͸ͪ
ͼͽͪͻͳΒͰ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͳ
͸ͪ

ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͯ͹ͼͽͳͭ͸;Εͪ
͈;ͽ͸ͳ͵
͵͹Βͳ
ͫͳ
ͼͶͰͯͳ͹
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ

ͼͰ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪ
ͼ
΁ͰͶ͹͵;ͺ͸͹ͷ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹͸;ͯ͹ͷ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͰ
͹ͫ
Βͪ΃ΔͰΔͪ
͹
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͯͰͶͪ
ͳͯͰ͹Ͷ͹΃͵͹ͷ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͰΔ;
ͳ

Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳΒͳ
Βͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͲͯͪΔͪ
ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͹
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸͹Β
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵͹Β

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͳ
̹Ͱ΂ͪ



̓͹͸΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒ;
ͳͲͶ͹ͱͫͰ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬ͵Ͱ
;
̹ͰͶͬͰͯͰͻ;
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪ͹
ΒͰ

ͺͻͰ
ͷͪ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳͷ
΃͵͹Ͷͪͷͪ
$ISJTUJBO
WPO
.FDIFM
)
-PDIFS
OBW
EFMP




͇ͺͳͼͳ
ͼͪͶͪ
;
̻͹ͻΔͰͷ
̹ͰͶͬͰͯͰͻ;

ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸ͳ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪΒ;
͵Δͳͭͪ
ͷͪ
('
8BBHFO
%JF
WPSOFINTUFO
,VOTUEFOLNÅMFS
JO
8JFO
FSTUFS
5IFJM
8JFO


('
8BBHFO
%JF
WPSOFINTUFO
,VOTUEFOLNÅMFS
JO
8JFO
[XFJUIFS
5IFJM
8JFO




̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ



́ͼͽ͹



͉ͪͿͪͰͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ͹
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͬͰΕͳ΀
;Ͳ͹ͻͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ͸͹ͭ

ͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͼͽͬͪ
;
9*9
ͬͰ͵;
;
ͪ͵ͪͯͰͷͼ͵ͳͷ
Ͷͳ͵͹ͬ͸ͳͷ
͵ͻ;ͭ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͌ͺ͹ͻ
.
1
%SJTLFM

3FQSFTFOUJOH
#FMJFG
3FMJHJPO
"SU
BOE
4PDJFUZ
JO
/JOFUFFOUI
$FOU;SZ
'SBODF
6OJWFSTJUZ

1BSL
5IF
1FOOTZMWBOJB
4UBUF
6OJWFSTJUZ
 



͡;ͫͪ
͆Ͱ͸ͪͯ͹ͬͳΕ
ͫͰͶͰͱͳ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
͈Ͱͽͪͻ
**
͈Ͱͽͻ͹ͬͳΕ
͢Ͱͭ͹΃
ͯͳͬͳ͹
͉ͪͿͪ
ͰͶ͹ͬ͹Β
ͼͶͳ΁ͳ
j͈ͻͰ͹ͫͻͪͱͰΔͰ
͎ͻͳͼͽ͹ͬ͹v
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ
̺ͪͽͳ͵ͪ͸;
͡
͈
͆Ͱ͸ͪ
ͯ͹ͬͳΕ
͸ͪͬ
ͯͰͶ͹


 ͆Ͱ͸ͪͯ
ͪͅ͵;ΓͰͬͳΕ

͊ͪͯͻͱͪΒ͸Ͱ
͹ͼ͹ͫͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͯͰͶͪ
̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
͸ͪ
ͷͰΔͰ͸͹ͭ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔ;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲ;Β;
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ
ͳ

͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
̺͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;

ͫͳͽͪ͸
ͼͰͭͷͰ͸ͽ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͸Ͱ͹ͺ΀͹ͯ͸ͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͽ͹ͻͫͳ
ͳ

ͷ͹ͭ;Εͳ
΂ͬͻͼͽ͹
͵͹ͯͳͿͳ͵͹ͬͪ͸ͳ
͵Γ;΂
Ͳͪ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪΔͰ
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸Ͱ
;
͵͹Β;

ͼͰ
͹ͯͶͪͲͳ
͇͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͽͳͼ͵;Β;
Ͷͳ΂͸Ͱ
Ͱͷ͹΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͳͼͽͳ΂;
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ

ͺͻͰͷͪ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͻͰͽ͵;
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
Ͳͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ

ͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͶ͹
ͯͪ
ͳͷͪ
;͸ͳͬͰͻͲͪͶ͸͹
ͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͰΔͰ
͉ͪͲͶ͹Ͳͳ
ͳͲ
ͯͪͬͪΔͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͫͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͳͼͽͳ΁ͪΔͰ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶ
͸ͳ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳ
ͺ͹ͺ;ͽ
͊ͬͰͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͲͶ͹ͱͫͰ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͺͻͳͬͶͪ΂ͳͶͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ

͋ͪ͵͹
͹͸ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
͹ͯͪͫͻͪ
͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͬͳͲ;ͻͳ
ͳ
͵ͻͳͽͰͻͳΒ;ͷͳͷͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͺ;Ͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͇ͯͶ;΂;Β;
Εͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
;
ͽ;ͷͪ΂ͰΔ;
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ΀
΁ͰͶͳ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͺ;ͽ
͵ͪͽͪͶ͹ͭͪ

Ͳͫͳͻ͵Ͱ
ͷ;ͲͰΒͪ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
ͷ͹Ε
ͺͳͼͪ͸Ͱ
ͻͰ΂ͳ
;
Βͪͬ͸͹Β
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͺͻͰͽͪ΁ͳΒͳ

ͬͳͲ;ͰͶ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶ͸Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͇ͯͪͫͳͻ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹

ͪͯͪͺͽͳͻͪ͸͹
ͽ;ͷͪ΂ͰΔͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͺ;ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
ͿͶͰ͵ͼͳͫͳͶ͸͹ͼͽ
t΂ͳ
ͽͪΔͪi
ͳ
͹ͯͼ;ͼͽͬ͹
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸Ͱ
ͻͰ΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ

͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸Ͱ

́ͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳ
ͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ΒͰ
;
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹Β
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸ͳ
ͯͪ
ͳͷͪ
ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸;
Ͱͯ;͵ͪͽͳͬ͸;

;Ͷ͹ͭ;
͈;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͬ
͹ͯ

ͯͰͶͪ
̾ͻ͸ͼͽͪ
͍ͰͻͼͽͰͻͪ
)BOECVDI
GÛS
3FJTFOEF
JO
*UBMJFO
ͳͲ

ΒͰͯͪ͸

͹ͯ
ͬͪͱ͸ͳ΀
ͬͳͯ͹ͬͪ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͳͬͪΔͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ

̓͹ͻͳ΃ΕͰ͸ͳ
ͼ;
͵ͪ͹
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͳ
͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͳ
Ͳͪ

ͺͻ͹;΂ͪͬͪΔͪ
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸ͳ΀
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸ͪ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͯ͹
̹Ͱ΂ͪ

ͳ
ͺ͹
΁ͪͻͼ͵͹Β
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͯ͹͸͹ͼͳ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ
ͫͻ͹Β
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ

͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
͸ͪ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸;
;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵;
ͺͻͪ͵ͼ;
͋ͳͷͰ
ΒͰ
ͼͻͺ
ͼ͵ͪ
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸ͪ
ͯ͹ͫͳͶͪ
ͳ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶ͸ͳ
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ
;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͻͪ͵ͼͰ
;

̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵͹Β

͇ͺͪͱͪΔͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͪ
ͳͲ͸Ͱͽͳ΀
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;

̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲ;Β;
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶ͸Ͱ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵Ͱ
͸͹ͻ
ͷͰ
ͫͳͶͰ
;ͼͬ͹ΒͰ͸Ͱ
ͳ
;
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹Β
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸ͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
͹͸Ͱ
͹ͫΒͰͯͳΔͪͬͪͶͰ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͹ͷ
͊ͻͫͪ
;
̸;ͼͽͻ͹͌ͭͪͻͼ͵͹Β
ͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͰ
͋ͳͷͰ
ͼ;

;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
ͼͺ͹ΒͰ͸Ͱ
;͸ͳͬͰͻͲͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ
ͷͰ͸ͳͽͪ
;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
͎ͪͫͲͫ;ͻ΃͵ͪ
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͷͰͼͽͪ
ͷͪΌͪͻͼ͵Ͱ

ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͯ͹
̹Ͱ΂ͪ

ͺ͹ͽͬͻΌͳͬͪ͹

ΒͰ
ͺͻͳ͸΁ͳͺͰ
ͺ͹ͬͰͲͪ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
;͵ͪͲͳ



)
-PDIFS
͸ͪͬ
ͯͰͶ͹



 ͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͯ͹
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ 

ͬͪ͹
͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼ
ͽͻͪ͸ͼͿ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͳ
ͯ͹
ͺͻͳ͸͹ͼͳ͹
͵͹͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͳͼͪΔ;
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸͹ͭ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹ͭ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͳͯͰ͸
ͽͳͽͰͽͪ
̹Ͱ΂
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
͎ͪͫͲͫ;ͻ΃͵;
ͳͷ
ͺͰͻͳΒ;
͵ͪ͹
ͯͻ;ͭͪ΂ͳΒͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
ͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͸Ͱ
ͬͳͯͳ

͵ͪ͹
ͼͽͻͪ͸΁ͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͪ΂ͳΒͰ
ͬͰΕ
ͳͼͽ͹ͬͰͽ͸Ͱ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ

 ͆Ͱ͸ͪͯ
ͪͅ͵;ΓͰͬͳΕ

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

/FOBE
.BLVMKFWJǀ
3FJTFO
VOE
,VMUVS

FJO
3FJTFGÛISFS
WPO
#FMHSBE
OBDI
8JFO
BVT
EFN
+BIS


8JFO
EJF
)BVQUTUBEU
EFS
)BCTCVSHFS
.POBSDIJF
TUFMMUF
XÅISFOE
EFT


+BISIVOEFSUT
FJOFT
EFS
CFEFVUFOETUFO
FVSPQÅJTDIFO
LVMUVSQPMJUJTDIFO
;FOUSFO

EBS
%JFTF
4UBEU
EVSDIMFCUF
JO
EJFTFN
;FJUSBVN
TUÛSNJTDIF
QPMJUJTDIF
&SFJHOJTTF

XJF
[
#
EJF
3FWPMVUJPO
BVT

BCFS
BVDI
EJF
FJHFOF
5SBOTGPSNBUJPO
EJF
TJDI

JO
BMMFO
#FSFJDIFO
EFT
ÕGGFOUMJDIFO
-FCFOT
XJEFSTQJFHFMUF
WPO
TUÅEUFCBVMJDIFO

-ÕTVOHFO
CJT
[VS
"MMUBHTLVMUVS
IJO
%JF
"VGNFSLTBNLFJU
EFS
FVSPQÅJTDIFO

¸GGFOUMJDILFJU
XVSEF
EBVFSOE
BVG
&SFJHOJTTF
JO
8JFO
BMT
FJOFS
XJDIUJHFO

FVSPQÅJTDIFO
.FUSPQPMF
HFMFOLU

&JOFT
TPMDIFS
FSXÅIOFOTXFSUFO
&SFJHOJTTF

TUFMMUF
BVDI
EJF
JN
+BISF

JO
8JFO
TUBUUHFGVOEFOF
8FMUBVTTUFMMVOH

EBS
%JFTF
XVSEF
BVDI
WPO
EFS
TFSCJTDIFO
¸GGFOUMJDILFJU
WFSGPMHU
XBT

IÕDITUXBISTDIFJOMJDI
BVDI
EJF
)FSBVTHBCF
FJOFT
EFS
ÅMUFTUFO
TFSCJTDIFO

3FJTFGÛISFS
FOUTDIFJEFOE
CFFJOGMVTTUF
JN
XJDIUJHTUFO
TFSCJTDIFO
7FSMBH
WPO

+
%
-B[BSFWJǀ
8JFO
VOE
EFTTFO
4FIFOTXÛSEJHLFJUFO
PEFS
EFS
CFTUF
3FJTFGÛISFS

WPO
#FMHSBE
OBDI
8JFO
VOE
LSFV[
VOE
RVFS
EVSDI
8JFO
GÛS
KFEFSNBOO
VOE

JOTCFTPOEFSF
GÛS
KFOF
EJF
EFS
'SFNETQSBDIFO
VOE
CSÅVDIF
OJDIU
LVOEJH
TJOE

%JF
JOIBMUMJDIFO
.FSLNBMF
EFT
3FJTFGÛISFST
VOUFS
EFN
5JUFM
8JFO
VOE

EFTTFO
4FIFOTXÛSEJHLFJUFO
EFS
JO
FSTUFS
-JOJF
BVG
LVMUVSFMMF
4FIFOTXÛSEJHLFJUFO

BC[JFMU
[FJHFO
EFVUMJDI
EJF
#FEFVUVOH
VOE
EBT
#JMEVOHTQPUFOUJBM
EFS
3FJTFGÛISFS

4JF
TUFMMFO
FJO
XJDIUJHFT
4FHNFOU
KFEFS
3FJTF
EBS
FJOFO
VOFOUCFISMJDIFO

(FHFOTUBOE
JO
KFEFS
3FJTFUBTDIF
FJOFO
NÕHMJDIFO
TUSFOH
LPEJGJ[JFSUFO

4DIMÛTTFM
[VN
7FSTUFIFO
EFS
;JFMLVMUVS
*O
EJFTFO
XFSEFO
QFSTÕOMJDIF

(FGÛIMF
[VSÛDLHFESÅOHU
VOE
EJF
OBDI
CFTUJNNUFO
JN

+BISIVOEFSU
GÛS

VOJWFSTFMM
VOE
OBUJPOBM
CFEFVUFOE
HFIBMUFOFO
8FSUNB“TUÅCFO
BVTHFXÅIMUFO

4FIFOTXÛSEJHFJUFO
JO
EFO
7PSEFSHSVOE
HFSÛDLU
%JF
3FJTFGÛISFS
XVSEFO
EBNBMT

WFSÕGGFOUMJDIU
VN
EJF
8JDIUJHLFJU
EFS
(SP“TUÅEUF
[V
VOUFSTUSFJDIFO
BCFS
BVDI

BVG
BLUVFMMF
*OUFSFTTF
FSXFDLFOEF

&SFJHOJTTF
BVGNFSLTBN
[V
NBDIFO
XJF
[
#


EJF
8FMUBVTTUFMMVOH
JO
8JFO
*OIBMUMJDI
HFTUBMUFU
OBDI
,SJUFSJFO
VOE
"OTJDIUFO

WPO
3FJTFOEFO
TUFMMFO
TJF
FJOFO
CFEFVUFOEFO
5FJM
EFS
,VMUVSHFTDIJDIUF
EBS

%JF
FOUTDIFJEFOEF
#FEFVUVOH
EFS
3FJTFGÛISFS
GÛS
*OUFSQSFUBUJPOFO
CFTUJNNUFS

LVMUVSFMMFS
5FJMCFSFJDIF
FUXB
.VTFVNTLBUBMPHF
[FJHU
EFVUMJDI
EJF
5BVHMJDILFJU

FJOFT
4DISJGUXFSLFT
[VS
ÕGGFOUMJDIFO
%FVUVOH
WJTVFMMFS
VOE
NBUFSJFMMFS
,VMUVS

%JF
"VTXBIM
BO
4FIFOTXÛSEJHLFJUFO
VOE
EFSFO
EFN
1VCMJLVN
BOHFQBTTUFO

*OUFSQSFUBUJPOFO
XFJTU
BVG
'MFYJCJMJUÅU
EFS
-FTBSUFO
VOE
"VTCMFJCFO
BO

FJOIFJUMJDIFS
3F[FQUJPO
LVMUVSFMMFS
4FIFOTXÛSEJHLFJUFO
FJOFS
(FHFOE
IJO

 ͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͹ͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͯ͹
̹Ͱ΂ͪ
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ 

%BOL
TFJOFN
LVOTUHFTDIJDIUMJDIFO
(FIBMU
LPOOUF
EFS
3FJTFGÛISFS
8JFO
VOE

EFTTFO
4FIFOTXÛSEJHLFJUFO
JO
4FSCJFO
FJOF
XJDIUJHF
#JMEVOHTSPMMF
TQJFMFO

%JF
JO
EJFTFN
3FJTFGÛISFS
WPSHFOPNNFOFO
*OUFSQSFUBUJPOFO
LVMUVSFMMFS

8FSUF
VOE
#SÅVDIF
[FJHFO
EBTT
EJF
EBNBMJHFO
FVSPQÅJTDIFO
/PSNFO
BVDI

JO
4FSCJFO
BVGHFOPNNFO
XVSEFO
%BOL
LVMUVSFMMFO
&SSVOHFOTDIBGUFO
EFS
JO

¸TUFSSFJDI6OHBSO
BOTÅTTJHFO
4FSCFO
FOUIJFMUFO
EJFTF
FVSPQÅJTDIFO
/PSNFO

BVDI
XJDIUJHF
/BUJPOBMJOIBMUF
VOE
XFSUF
%BEVSDI
XVSEFO
JO
EJFTFN

3FJTFGÛISFS
VOJWFSTFMM
VOE
OBUJPOBM
CFEFVUFOEF
,VOTUXFSLF
EJF
)BVQUTUBEU

EFS
)BCTCVSHFS
.POBSDIJF
XJDIUJHF
0SUF
EFS
VOHBSJTDIFO
(FTDIJDIUF
VOE

EJF
TFSCJTDIF
,VMUVS
[VTBNNFOHFCSBDIU
%FS
TFSCJTDIF
3FJTFGÛISFS
OBDI
8JFO

BVT

CFTUÅUJHUF
1SJO[JQJFO
EFS
7FSGMPDIUFOIFJU
WPO
3FJTFO
#JMEVOH
VOE

,VMUVS
XJFT
BVG
5SBOTGPSNJFSVOHTQSP[FTTF
JO
4ÛEPTUFVSPQB
IJO
VOE
USVH
[VS

,POTUJUVJFSVOH
FJOFS
FJOIFJUMJDIFO
FVSPQÅJTDIFO
,VMUVSJEFOUJUÅU
CFJ

͆ͳ͵͹Ͷͪ
̸͈͇̺͆
͈ͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͷͪͽͰͷͪͽͳ΂͵ͳ
Ϳͪ͵;ͶͽͰͽ

́͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
Ͳͪ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒ;
͊͵͹ͺΒͰ

͉͋͌́͊͋́͐̓́
̺͇̽́͐́

͌
͉͈̹̾͌̈́́͏́

̸͇̓̾̽͆́́͠ͅ
͌
͉̻͇̽͌͠

͈͇͇̺̈́́͆́
99
̸̺̾̓

͈ͻͬͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
;
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱ

Ͷͳ
ͼ;
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ΒͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͽͪ΂͸͹
;
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͷͳ͸;Ͷ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ

͈͹΃ͽ͹
͹ͬͪ͵ͬͳ
ͼͽͻ;΂͸ͳ
ͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
ͯ͹ͼͪͯ
͵͹ͯ
͸ͪͼ
;
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ
͸ͳͼ;

ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͽͻͰͽͳͻͪ͸ͳ
ͷͳͼͶͳͷ
͸ͪ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ;
΀ͻ͹͸͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒ;
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͪ
ͳ

ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
͹ͬͯͰ
ͼͪͷ
͹ͯͪͫͻͪ͹
ͷͰͽ͹ͯ͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒ;
ͻͪͯͪ
;
͵͹Β͹Β
Ε;
ͳͲͬͻ΃ͳͽͳ

ͼͳͼͽͰͷͪͽͳͲͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͳ
ͽ͹
ͻ;͵͹ͬ͹ͯͰΕͳ
ͼͰ
΀ͻ͹͸͹Ͷ͹
ͭͳΒ͹ͷ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹ͭ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͪ
͋͹
͸Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
͸ͪΒͼͽͪͻͳΒͰ
͹ͬͪ͵ͬͰ

͵ΔͳͭͰ
ͳ
͸ͪΒͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͰ
́ͺͪ͵
ͺ͹ͼͷͪͽͻͪΒ;Εͳ
ͼͪ
ͯͳͼ
ͽͪ͸΁Ͱ
ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͼͬͪ͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͵͹Βͳ
ΕͰ
ͫͳͽͳ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͳͻͪ͸
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ

ͻͪͯ;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͻͰͷͰ͵
ͯͰͶ͹
ͼͪͷ
Ͳͪ
ͼͰͫͰ
ͳ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰ
ͼͰ
Ͳͪ
ͽͪͯͪ΃Δ;

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵;
͵ͶͳΒͰ͸ͽͰͶ;

͌
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͳͻͪ͸͹ͷ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
ͪ
͹ͬͯͰ
ΕͰͷ͹
ͺͻͳͯ͹ͯͪͽͳ
ͳ
ͺͻͬͰ
ͽͻͳ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
;
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͹ͯ
ͺͰ
ͯͰͼͰͽͪ͵
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͇ͬͯͰ
ͼͰ
ͻͪ΂;͸ͪΒ;
͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
͹͸ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ

͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
͸ͪ
͸ͪ΃;
ͲͰͷΓ;
͵ͪ͹
΁ͰͶͳ͸;
ͬͰΕ
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂Ͱ
͵͹Βͳ
ͽͻͰͽͳͻͪΒ;

ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ

͊͵͹ͺΒͰ
͇΀ͻͳͯ
͊ͽͻ;ͭͪ
̽͹Βͻͪ͸
̓ͻ;΃Ͱͬ͹
ͪͬͅͻ͹ͬ͹
͊ͽͻ;ͷͳ΁ͪ
ͳ
ͯͻ

͇͸͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͪΒͬͰΕͳ
ͫͻ͹Β
ΒͰ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸
ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͼͬͳͷ
ͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͳͷ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳͷ
ΒͰͲͳ΁ͳͷͪ
Ͱ͸ͭͶͰͼ͵͹ͷ
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;
ͼ͵͹ͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͷ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹ͷ
ͻ;ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͳͽͯ
 ͆ͳ͵͹Ͷͪ
͈ͪ͸͹ͬ

͌
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͻͪͯ;
ͲͪͯͻͱͪΕ;
ͼͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
͸ͪ
͸Ͱ͵ͳͷ
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͽ;
ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸ͳͷ
;
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ

ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͪͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ
ΒͰ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
͹ͯ
ͺͻͬͳ΀

ͪ͵͹
͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͺͻͬ͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
Ͳͪ
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ͵;
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒ;
̺͹ͯͳ΂
ΒͰ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͳ
ͼ;
́ͬͪ͸
͋͹΂͵ͪ
ͳ
̸ͶͰ͵ͼͪ͸ͯͪͻ
ͅͳ͸΂Ͱͬ
́Ͳͯͪ
ͬͪ΂
ΒͰ
͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͼͪͬͰͲ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ
ͪ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͺͳͼͪ͸
͸ͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹
΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
Ͷͪͽͳ͸ͳ΂͸ͳͷ
ͺͳͼͷ͹ͷ
;͵;ͺ͸ͳ
ͫͻ͹Β
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͳͲ͸͹
ͼͳ

͌
͵ΔͳͲͳ
ͼ;

Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ͼ;
ͼͪͷ͹
ͽͻͳ
ͳͲͻͪΌͰ͸Ͱ

;
͵͹Ͷ͹ͻ
ͽͰ΀͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͳ
ͽ͹
ͺͪ͸͹ͻͪͷͪ
͇΀ͻͳͯͼ͵͹ͭ
͠ͰͲͰͻͪ
ͳ
͸ͪͼͰΓͰ
̓ͪ͸Ͱ͹

͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͪ
͸͹΃Δͪ
͊͵͹ͺͼ͵Ͱ
͹͵͹Ͷͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͿͻͰͼ͵ͪ
Ͳͬͪ͸ͪ
t͋͹ͷͳ͸͹
͸ͰͬͰͻ
ͼͽͬ͹i
͵͹Βͪ
ͺ͹ͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͳͲ
9*7
ͬͰ͵ͪ

͌
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ;
͸ͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͺͻͰͯͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͪ
ͳ
;ͬ͹ͯ͸͹ͭ
ͯͰ
Ͷͪ
͹ͬͪΒ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͰΓͰ͸
͸ͪ
ͯͬͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
ͳ
ͽ͹
͹ͺ΃ͽͳ
ͳ
ͺͻͪ͵
ͽͳ΂͸ͳ
͌
ͺͻͬ͹ͷ
ͼ;
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͳ
͹ͯͰΓ΁ͳ
΀ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ
ͫ͹ͻͫͪ

ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͪ
ͼͪ
̺ͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒ͹ͷ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͪ
;
ͼͪͼͽͪͬ;
ͫ;ͭͪͻ
ͼ͵Ͱ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
ͼͪͷ͹ͼͽͪͶ͸ͪ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
;ͼͽͪ͸΁ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͽͳͬ
ͬͳͲͪ͸
ͽͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͬͶͪͼͽͳ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͭ͹ͼͺ͹ͯͪͻͳ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͈ͻ͹ͼͰ͵ͪ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͪ
;

ͼͪͼͽͪͬ;
͸ͰͷͪΔͳΕ͵Ͱ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͪ
ͺ͹ͯ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵ͳͷ
ͻ͹ͺ
ͼͽͬ͹ͷ
ͺ͹΂Ͱ΁ͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͻͰͬ͹Ͷ;΁ͳ͹͸ͪͻ͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹͵ͻͰͽͪ
́Ͷͳ͸ͯͰ͸
ͼ͵ͳ
;ͼͽͪ͸ͪ͵
ͻͪͼͺͪͻ΂ͪͬͪΔͰ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͻͪͽ͹ͬͪ
ͳ

͈ͻͬ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͪ
;
͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹͹ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯͳͶͪ΂͵͹Β
ͫ͹ͻͫͳ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹΀ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͪ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ;ͻͪ
ͱͳ
ͬ͹ͺͳͼ
ͺͳͼͷͰ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
Ϳ͹Ͷ͵Ͷ͹ͻ

ͻͪͲͬͳͽͪ͵
͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͪͅ͵Ͱ
ͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸͹
;ͼͽͻ͹Βͼͽͬ͹
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒ
͵Ͷͳͷͪ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͪ

ͻ;ͯ͸͹
ͫͶͪͭ͹
ͺ͹Γ͹ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͪ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸ͳ
ͼͽͪ͸ͯͪͻͯ
ͶͰ͵͹ͬͳͽͰ
ͫͪΔͰ
ͳ

ͼͺ͹ͻͽ͹ͬͳ

͌
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͷ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂͸͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
ͯͪͽ
ΒͰ
΀ͻ͹͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ

ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳ΀
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
ͳ
͸Ͱ͵ͳ΀
ͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳ
Βͪ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰ
ͼͰ
ͼͪ
ͼͬͳͷ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͳͷ
ͫͳͽ͸ͳΒͳͷ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵ͪͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ

ͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͻ;ͽͰ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͯͻͱͪͬ;
͆ͪ
͵ͻͪΒ;
ΒͰ
ͯ͹͸Ͱͽ
ͳ
ͻͰͭͳͼͽͪͻ

ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳ
͸ͪͻͪͬ͸͹
Β͹΃
ͳ
ͽͪͯͪ
͸ͰͳͲͫͰͱ͸Ͱ
ͻͰ͵ͶͪͷͰ

ͽͪ΂͸͹
ͺͰͽ
͸ͪͰͼͽ
ͼͺ͹͸Ͳ͹ͻͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
Ϳͳ͸ͪ͸ͼͳͻͪͶͳ
ͳͲͶͪͲͪ͵
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ

.BDFEPOJF:PVHPTMBWJF
ΒͰ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͰͭ
ͺ͹
ͼͽͪͻ͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͬͪ
ͱ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͇ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸
ΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
͋;
ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͼͪͬͰͲͪ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ
͋Ͱ͵ͼͽ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͺͳͼͪ͸
͸ͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹ͷ

ͳ
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
;
ͺͪͻͪͶͰͶ͸͹Β
ͯͬ͹ͻͰͯ͸͹Β
͵͹ͷͫͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͳ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ

ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͺͻͬͳ΀
ͪ͵͹
͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͺͻͬͳ
͹ͬͪ͵ͪͬ
ͺ͹͵;΃ͪΒ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂
͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
Ͳͪ
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ͵;
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒ;
͹ͫΒͪͬͳ
ͯͬ͹ΒͰͲͳ΂͸͹
͌͵;ͺͪ͸
ͫͻ͹Β

ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͪͷ͹

ͯ͹͵
ΒͰ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ
͹ͫ͹ͭͪΕͰ͸
ͼͪ

΁ͻ͸͹ͫͰͶͰ
Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪ
ͿͳΒͰ
͸ͪ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼ;
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸ͪ
͸ͪΒ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ΂͸ͳΒͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͷͰ
 ͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
;
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ 

ͼͽͪ
ͳ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽͳ
;
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
͇΀ͻͳͯͼ͵͹
͈ͻͰͼͺͪ͸ͼ͵͹

ͳ
̽͹Βͻͪ͸ͼ͵͹
͠ͰͲͰͻ͹
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
͊͵͹ͺΒͰ
͇΀ͻͳͯ
͊ͽͻ;ͭͪ
ͳ
̓ͻ;΃Ͱ
ͬ͹
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
͵ͪͷͺ͹ͬͪ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹΀ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼͺ͹
ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͪͅ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ
͊ͬ
̸͸ͯͻͰΒͪ
9*7
ͿͻͰͼ͵ͪ
̹͹ͭ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΁Ͱ
ͳͲ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ

͊ͬ
͊͹ͿͳΒͪ
̽ͪ;ͽͺͪ΃ͳ͸
ͪͷͪͷ
;
͊͵͹ͺΒ;
͊ͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵
ͺͪͶͳͷ
ͫ͹ͻ΁ͳͷͪ

ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
;
ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͭͻͪͯ;
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ

͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͿͻͪͭͷͰ͸ͪͽͪ
ͳͲ
ͷͪ͵Ͱ
ͯ͹͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
Ϳ͹Ͷ͵Ͷ͹ͻͪ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͪ
ͳ
ͷͪ͸ͳͿͰͼͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͼ͵ͳ΁ͪ

ͳ
͵ͪͻͪͽͪ
ͳ
ͯͻ
͋ͳͻͪͱ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ΒͰ

ͺͻͳͷͰͻͪ͵ͪ
͌
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ;
͸ͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
;
;ͬ͹ͯ͸͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
ͼ;
ͯͪͽͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ

͹
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͷ
ͳ
ͼ͹΁ͳ͹Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳͷ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰ
ͻͳͼͽͳ͵ͪͷͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͼͶͰͯͳ
͵ͻͪͽͪ͵
͹ͺͳͼ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ΂͸ͳ΀
ͭͻͪ
ͯ͹ͬͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͬͰΕ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
ͼͶͰͯͳ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ
ͳ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͪͶ͸ͳ

ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ
ͽͻͳΒ;
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
ͽͰ͵ͽ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ΒͰͲͰͻͪ
ͼͪ
ͼͬͳͷ

Δͳ΀͹ͬͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͪͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
͌
ͺͻ͹ͯ;
ͱͰͽ͵;
ͼ;
ͫͪΔͰ
ͳ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͪͻͼ͵ͳ
ͯ͹ͷ͹ͬͳ
ͪ
Ͳͪ
͵ͻͪΒ
ͼ;
ͯͪͽͳ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽͳ
ͷͰΌ;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸͹
ͷͰͼͽ͹
Ͳͪ;Ͳͳͷͪ
ͭͻͪͯ

̓ͻ;΃Ͱͬ͹
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͪ
͹͵͹Ͷͳ͸ͪ

͇΀ͻͳͯ
KF
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͳ
ͺ͹
΀ͻ͹͸͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͳ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪΔͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͪ
ͳͲͪ
΃ͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͳͼͽͰ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸ͳ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹

͇ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸
ΒͰ
͸ͪ

Ͱ͸ͭͶͰͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
ͪ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
́Ͳͯͪͬͪ΂͵ͳ
Ͳͪͬ͹ͯ
t͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪi

ͼͪ
ͼͰͯͳ΃ͽͰͷ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
͍͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
ΒͰ
;ͻͪͯͳ͹
͋͹΃͹
̽ͪͫͪ΁
͇ͬͪΒ

ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͳͷͪ

ͼͽͻͪ͸ͪ
ͪ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ
ͼ;
͸ͪͺͳͼͪͶͳ
ͅͳ͹ͯͻͪͭ
͈ͪͬͶ͹ͬͳΕ
ͳ
͏ͬͰ
ͽͪ͸
̻ͻ͹Ͳͯͪ͸͹ͬ
͎ͻ͹͸͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͪ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸͹ͭ
ͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ΂͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹

ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͼͬͰ
͹ͼͽͪͶͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͷ͹͸͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͼͶͳ΂͸ͳ΀
͇΀ͻͳͯ;

͇ͬͯͰ
ͼ;
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸Ͱ
ͼͬͰ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵Ͱ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
͇΀ͻͳ
ͯͪ
ͳ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪΒͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͰ
͇΀ͻͳͯͼ͵͹ͭ
ΒͰͲͰͻͪ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͼͬͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹΀ͳ
ͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͪ
ͯ͹ͫͻͪ
ͺͻͳ
΂Ͱͷ;
ΒͰ
͸ͪͭͶͪ΃Ͱ͸͹
ͯͪ
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͯͻͰͬ͸͹ͷ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸
ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͭͻͪͯ;
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ
ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹
΁ͻ͵ͪͬͪ
ͳ
ͼͬͰͽͳ΀
΁ͻ͵͹ͬ͸ͳ΀
ͷͰͼͽͪ
͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹

ͳͷͪ
ͯͪ͸ͪ
;
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͳ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹

͆Ͱ
Ͳͪ͹ͼͽͪΒ;
ͷͪΔͰ
͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ

ͷͪ͸ͳͿͰͼͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͳͷͪΒ;
ͫ͹ͭͪͽ
Ͱͽ͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵͹΀ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ

͵ͪ͵͹
ͳ
ͪͷͫͳΒͰ͸ͽͪͶ͸ͳ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ
ͼͽͪͻ͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
̀ͪͽͳͷ
ΒͰ
ͯͪͽ
ͯͰͽͪ
Γͪ͸
͹ͺͳͼ
͵͹ͷͺͶͰͽ͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳͻͪͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
ͪ
;
ͽ͹ͷ
ͺͻͪͬ΁;

͸ͪΒͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͷͰͼͽͪ
Ͳͪ;ͲͳͷͪΒ;
΀͹ͽͰͶͼ͵͹;ͭ͹ͼͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳ

͊͵͹ͺΒͰ
͇ͬͪΒ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ΒͰ
ͺͻͬͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͹
ͽ;
ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳͷͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͭ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ
ͪ
ͳͲͯͪͽ
ΒͰ
ͯͪͶͰ͵Ͱ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̸;ͽ͹ͻ
ΒͰ
͠͹ͻͯͪ͸
͈ͪͬͶ͹ͬͼ͵ͳ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂
t͆͹ͬͪ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳ
Βͪi
ͳ
ͪͭͰ͸΁ͳΒͪ
Ͳͪ
Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͯ͹͵;ͷͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒ;

t̀ͪͭͻͰͫi
͍͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
ͼ;

;ͻͪΌͰ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
͸ͪΒͰͷͳ͸Ͱ͸ͽ͸ͳΒͳ΀
Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
̓
̹ͳͶ
 ͆ͳ͵͹Ͷͪ
͈ͪ͸͹ͬ

ͫͳͶ͹ͬͼ͵ͳ
̹
̽ͻ͸͵͹ͬ
̸
ͅͳ͸΂Ͱͬ
̓
̻Ͱ͹ͻͭͳͰͬͼ͵ͳ
ͳ
͚
ͪ͠͵ͳͷ͹ͬͳΕ

́ͲͯͪΔͰ
ͳͷͪ

ͼͽͻͪ͸ͪ

Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ
;
΁ͻ͸͹ͫͰͶ͹Β
ͽͰ΀͸ͳ΁ͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ

ͺͶͪ͸
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͼͪ
ͫͻ͹ΒͰͬͳͷͪ
ͳ
͹Ͳ͸ͪ͵ͪͷͪ
ͼͬͳ΀
;Ͷͳ΁ͪ
͋Ͱ͵ͼͽ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͺͳͼͪ͸
͸ͪ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
ͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
ΒͰ

ͺ͹ͻͰΌͪ͸
ͺ͹
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͳͷ
ͺ͹ͭͶͪͬΓͳͷͪ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒ
͊͵͹ͺΒͪ
ͬͰ
ͲͰ
;
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
ͻͰΓͰͿ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͵Ͷͳͷͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͻͰ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ΒͰͲͰ
ͻͪ
ͯͬͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͫͪͶͳ
ͻͰ͵Ͱ
̺ͪͻͯͪͻͪ
΀ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ

ͭ͹ͯͳ
͸ͪ
ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯ͸͹ͭ
͊͵͹ͺΒͪ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
΃ͰͽΔͪ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͳ

ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳ

͇΀ͻͳͯ
ΒͰ
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͹ͯ
͹͸ͳ΀
ͼͽͪͻͳΒͳ΀
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͳͲͪ΃ͪ͹

ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
Ͱͯͳ΁ͳΒͰ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸Ͱ
;

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͳ
́Ͳͯͪͽ
ΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ

ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
ͪ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
t͋;ͻͳ
ͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪi
ͳͲ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
̸;ͽ͹ͻͳ
ͼ;
͉
̓;Ͳͷͪ͸͹ͬͼ͵ͳ
ͳ
̽
͑ͪͻͳΕ

̓Δͳͭͪ
ͳͷͪ

ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͳ

Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ
;
΁ͻ͸͹ͫͰͶ͹Β
ͽͰ΀͸ͳ΁ͳ
͵ͪ͹

ͳ
ͺͶͪ͸
ͭͻͪͯͪ
̺͹ͯͳ΂
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸
ͭ͹ͯͳ΃Δͳ΁ͳ
ͼͷͻͽͳ
ͬͰͶͳ͵͹ͭ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸
ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
̓ͶͳͷͰ͸ͽͪ
͇΀ͻͳͯͼ͵͹ͭ

͢Ͱͭ͹ͬ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
ΒͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͻͰͶͪͽͳͬ͸͹
ͼͽͪ͸ͯͪͻͯ͸ͳ
Ͳͪͽ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͷͪ
Ͷ͹
͸Ͱ;͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͰ͸ͳΒͳ
͹ͯ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳ΀
ͪ
ͻͰͯ͹ͼͶͰͯ
ΒͰ
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͳ
ͻͰ΂ͳ
͹
ͭͻͪͯ;

͸ͪ
ΒͰͲͰͻ;
ͯͻͰͬ͸ͳ
͇΀ͻͳͯ
͸ͪ
ΒͰͲͰͻ;
͇΀ͻͳͯͼ͵͹
ΒͰͲͰͻ͹
ͭͻͪͯ
ͬͰ͵͹ͬͪ

ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͵ͻͪͽ͵Ͱ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͪ
;
͵͹Β͹Β
ΒͰ
΁ͳ
ͽͳͻͪ͸͹

͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬͪ


͊͵͹ͺΒͰ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͺ͹
ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͻͰΕͳ
ͼͽͪͻ͹
ͼͽͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ
ͪ
ͳ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͼͽͪͻͳΒͳ΀
;
ͪͅ͵Ͱ
ͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ
͇ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸
ΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͪ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂ͳ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͳ
͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ

ͼͪͬͰͲ
͊͵͹ͺΒͪ
ͳ
t͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪi
ͳͲ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ

͇ͬͪΒ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ΒͰ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ΂ͪ͸
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͭ
ͳ
ͺ͹
ͽ͹ͷͰ

΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͹͸

ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͺͻͬͳ΀
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸
͸ͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹

͸ͪ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹ͷ
Ͱ͸ͭͶͰͼ͵͹ͷ
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͳ
͸Ͱ
ͷͪ΂͵͹ͷ
̸;ͽ͹ͻ
͵ΔͳͭͰ
ΒͰ
̸ͶͰ͵ͼͪ͸ͯͪͻ
ͅͳ͸΂Ͱͬ
͆ͪ

ͼͽͻͪ͸ͪ
͹ͯ΃ͽͪͷ
ͺͪ͸
ΒͰ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ
ͳͷͪ

΁ͻ͸͹ͫͰͶͰ
Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ

;
͵͹Ͷ͹ͻ;
ͳ
͵ͪͻͽ;

ͺͶͪ͸ͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͊͵͹ͺΒͪ
͊ͪͯͻͱͪΒ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ
͹ͬͪ͵͹
͹ͺ΃ͽͳ
ͯͰ͹
͹

͊͵͹ͺΒ;
͹ͫͳͶͪͲͪ͵
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͹ͫͳͶͪͲͪ͵
͹͵͹Ͷͳ͸Ͱ
͵ͻͪͽͪ͵
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͪͅ͵Ͱ
ͯ͹͸ͳΒ;
ͳ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
͊͵͹ͺΒ;

͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͺ͹
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ
͸ͪ
ͻ;ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͳ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸
ͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸
ΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̺͹ͯͳ΂
ΒͰ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
͹ͯ΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸
ͳ

͸ͪ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳͷ
ΒͰͲͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͳ
Ͱ͸ͭͶͰͼ͵ͳ
Ϳͻͪ͸
΁;ͼ͵ͳ
ͳ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳ
͆ͪ

ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸Ͱ
ͼ;

ͳͶ;ͼͽͻͪ΁ͳΒͰ

͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ͼ;
ͼͪͷ͹
ͯͬͰ
ͳͲͻͪΌͰ͸Ͱ
;
΁ͻ͸͹ͫͰͶ͹Β
ͽͰ΀͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͼͪ
ͷͪͺͪͷͪ
͹ͯ
 ͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
;
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ 

ͻͰΌͰ͸ͳ΀
ͳͽͳ͸ͰͻͰͻͪ
͆ͪ
Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪͷͪ
ͼ;
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸Ͱ
;
ͫ;͵ͬͪͶ͸͹ͷ

ͼͷͳͼͶ;
ͻͰ΂ͳ
ͼͬͳ
͸ͪΒ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ΂͸ͳΒͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳ
ͪͅ
͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ

́Ͳͯͪͬͪ΂ͳ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͳ
͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͼͪͬͰͲ

ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
͈͆́
t͠Ͱͱi
ͳͲ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
̸;ͽ͹ͻͳ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ
ͼ;
̓
̹ͪͶͪͫͪ
͸͹ͬ
̺
̹;ͱͪͻ͹ͬͼ͵ͪ
̀
̽ͰͶͳ͸ͳ͵͹ͬͪ
͋
̓Ͱ΁͵ͪͻ͹ͬͼ͵ͳ
̸
̓ͻͼͽͰͬͪ
́

ͅͳ͵;Ͷ΂ͳΕ
ͅ
͈ͪ͸͹ͬ
̹
͈Ͱ͵Ͱͬͼ͵ͳ
̸
͈Ͱͽͻ;΃Ͱͬͪ
͠
͈͹ͺ͹ͬͼ͵ͳ
̻

͋͹ͯ͹ͻ͹ͬͼ͵ͳ
ͳ
̓
͋͹ͷ͹ͬͼ͵ͳ

͊ͪͯͻͱͪΒ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͰΓͰ͸
;
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͪ
;
ͺͻͬ͹ͷ
ͼ;
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ
͸͹ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͯͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰ
ͳ
ͷ͹ͽͳͬͳ
͉͊
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳ
Βͪ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͬͰ͵͹ͬͰ
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵Ͱ
ͳͼ͵͹ͺͳ͸Ͱ
;
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵͹

ͿͻͰͼ͵͹ͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͼͽͬ͹
ͼͽͪͻͪ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ;ͻͪ
;
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͪ

;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽ
;
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ
ΒͰͲͳ͵
ͺͳͼͷͰ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ
͸͹ͼͽ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸͹ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹
;ͻͰΌͰΔͰ
͉͊
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
͉͊
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹
͸ͳΒͪ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
͸ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͫͻ͹Β͵ͳ
͌
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
ΒͰ
͹ͫͻͪΌͰ͸ͳ

ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ
͊͵͹ͺΒͰ
ͪ
;
ͽͻͰΕͰͷ
ͼ;
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸ͳ
ͳͽͳ͸Ͱͻͪ
ͻͳ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒ;
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͹ͫͻͪΌͰ͸ͳ
͸ͪ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽͪ͸
ͳ
ͼͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
͵͹Βͳ
ͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͳͲͻͪΌ;Β;

ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͈͹ͻͰͯ
ͷͪͻ΃ͻ;ͽͪ
;
ͼͬͪ͵͹Β
͹ͯ
Δͳ΀

ͯͪͽͳ
ͼ;
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳͷ
ͼͰ
͹͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͽͰͱͰ
ͳ
͹
ͼͬͳͷ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹΀ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͷ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵ͪ
ͷͪ
ͳ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͬͳͯͰ
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ;
͈͹ͻͰͯ
ͼͬͪ͵Ͱ
ͻ;ͽͰ
ͳͼ΁ͻ
ͽͪ͸
ΒͰ
ͳ
ΔͰ͸
͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪΒ;Εͳ
ͭͻͪͿͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
;ͯͪΓͰ͸͹ͼͽ
ͼͬͳ΀

ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸ͳ΀
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ

͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
Ͳͪ
̽͹Βͻͪ͸
ΒͰ
͹ͯ΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ

ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͺͻͬͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
Ͳͪ
͹ͬͪΒ
ͺͻͰͯͳͬ͸ͳ
΀ͳͯͻ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ

ΒͰͲͰͻͼ͵ͳ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽ
;
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͭ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͳ
ΒͰ
ͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͪͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽͪ
;
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
́Ͳ
ͯͪͬͪ΂ͳ
ͼ;
͈́̓
t́Ͳͬ͹ͻͼ͵ͳi
ͳ
tͅͶͪͲi
ͳͲ
̹͹ͭͯͪ͸΁ͳ
ͪ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ

ΒͰ
ͅͳͽ͹
͋ͰͷͰ͸;ͭ͹ͬ̿ͰͶͰͲ͸ͳ
͈͹ͻͰͯ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ
͸ͪ

ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;

ͯ͹ͷͳ͸ͳͻͪ

͵͹Ͷ͹ͻ
Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ

ͅͰͽ͹ͯ͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͪ
͹ͺͳͼͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͽͪ͸ͯͪͻͯ͸ͪ
͈͹ͻͰͯ
;ͬ͹ͯͪ
;
ͺͻͬ͹ͷ

ͯͰͶ;
ͼ;
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸Ͱ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹͵Ͷͳͷͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͳ
͹ͼͽͪͶͪ

ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͪ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͼͽͬͪ
̽͹Βͻͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
̽͹Βͻͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ΒͰͲͰͻͪ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹
ͱͪΒ
͵Ͷͳͷͪͽͼ͵ͳ
;ͼͶ͹ͬͳ
̽͹Βͻͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
̽͹Βͻͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ΒͰͲͰͻͪ
ͬ͹ͯͪ
ͳ
ΔͰ͸ͪ

ͶͰ͵͹ͬͳͽͪ
ͼͬ͹Βͼͽͬͪ
ͺͽͳ΁Ͱ
ͳ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͳΔͰ
ͻͪͼͽͳͽͰͶ͸ͳ
ͼͬͰͽ;͵ͻͪͼ
ͳ
ͫ͹
ͭͪͽͼͽͬ͹
̽͹Βͻͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
̽͹Βͻͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ΒͰͲͰͻͪ

̽͹Βͻͪ͸ͼ͵͹
ΒͰͲͰͻ͹
͸ͪΒͫ͹ͭͪͽͳΒͰ

ͻͳͫ͹ͷ
ͳ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͼ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͬͰͲͪ͸͹ͼͽ
̽͹Βͻͪ͸ͪ
͌
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
ͭ͹ͬ͹
ͻͳ
ͼͰ
͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
̽͹Βͻͪ͸ͪ
̽͹Βͻͪ͸
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͪ
ͳͷͰ͸ͪ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
΀ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ

 ͆ͳ͵͹Ͷͪ
͈ͪ͸͹ͬ

ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ͹
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͪ
Ͱͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͪ
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͪ
ͯ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̽͹Βͻͪ͸

͵ͪ͹
Ͳͪ͸ͪͽͼ͵ͳ
ͽͻͭ͹ͬͪ΂͵ͳ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ͸ͳ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻ
ͯ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ͸ͪͽ
ͼͽͬ͹
ͽͻͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͪ
ͯ͹Βͻͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͺͳΒͪ΁ͪ
ͳ
̽͹Βͻͪ͸
͵ͪ͹
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͺͻ͹ͼͬͰͽ͸ͳ

ͳ
΁ͻ͵͹ͬ͸ͳ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳ
;΂Ͱ͸ͳ
Γ;ͯͳ
͌
ͽͻͰΕͰͷ
ͯͰͶ;
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸

̽͹Βͻͪ͸
ͯ͹Βͻͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͵ͻͪΒ
;
͸ͪ΃Ͱ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͯ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͇ͬ
ͯͰ
ͼ;
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹;ͭ͹ͼͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ
͵ͪͺͪ΁ͳͽͰͽͳ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;

ͪ;ͽ͹͵ͪͷͺ͹ͬͳ
tͅͰͻͯͪΒͪi
ͳ
t̸΂ͳ͵͹ͽi
;ͭ͹ͼͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳ
͈́̓ͪ

t́Ͳͬ͹ͻͼ͵͹ͭi
ͳͲ
̹͹ͭͯͪ͸΁ͳ
͵͹ͷͫͳ͸ͪͽ
ͳͲ
͹ͫͶͳͱΔͰͭ
ͷͪͶ͹ͭ
ͭͻͪͯͳΕͪ
͵͹
Βͳ
ΒͰ
;
ͽ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰΌͳͬͪ͹
ͼ͵͹ͻ͹
ͼͬͳͷ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳͷͪ
͸ͪ
͠ͰͲͰͻ;
͵ͪ͹

ͳ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳ
͌
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͰͷ
΂Ͱͽͬͻͽ͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
ͯͪͽͳ
ͼ;

ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸͹ͷ
ͺͻͰͯ;ͲͰΕ;
ͳ
ͭͻͪͯͳΕ;
̹͹ͭͯͪ͸΁ͳ
ͪ
͸ͪ
͵ͻͪΒ;
͹ͯ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂ͪ͵
͸ͪ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͳ΀
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ

̓ͻ;΃Ͱͬ͹
ΒͰ
ΘͰͺ͸ͪ
ͷ͹͸͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ
͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͳͷͰ͸͹ͷ
ͭͻͪͯ;
͵͹Βͳ

ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͽ͹ͭͪ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ
͵ͪ͹
͸ͪΒͻͰͬ͹Ͷ;΁ͳ͹͸ͪͻ͸ͳΒͳ
;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͳ
ΒͰͯ͸;
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͪͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳΒͳ΀
Ͳͳͷͼ͵͹ͼͺ͹ͻͽͼ͵ͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀

ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
;
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ
͇ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
Β;Ͷͪ
ͷͰͼͰ΁ͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;

΂ͪͼͽ
ͭ͹ͯͳ΃Δͳ΁Ͱ
́Ͷͳ͸ͯͰ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
;ͼͽͪ͸͵ͪ
ͳ
̓ͻ;΃Ͱͬͼ͵Ͱ
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
͌ͻͰΌͳͬͪ΂͵ͳ
͹ͯͫ͹ͻ
ͼ;
ͼͪ΂ͳΔͪͬͪͶͳ
͎ͻͳͼͽ͹
̸͸ͯ͹͸͹͈ͬ͹Γͪ͸
ͼ͵ͳ
̸͸ͽ͹͸ͳͰ
͆ͳ͵͹Ͷ͹ͬͼ͵ͳ
̓ͻͼͽ͹
̸
͋͹ͺ;Ͳ͹ͬͼ͵ͳ
ͳ
̽ͻͪͭͳ
͋͹ͲͳΒͪ

́Ͳͯͪͬͪ΂
ΒͰ
͎ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͷ;ͲͰΒ
̓ͻ;΃Ͱͬͪ
Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
ΒͰ
;ͻͪͯͳ͹
̹

̽ͻ͸͵͹ͬ
ͅ͹͸͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
͌͵;ͺͪ͸
ͫͻ͹Β
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͳͲ͸͹ͼͳ

ͪ
ͫͻ͹Β
Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ

͹ͯ

͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͼͪͷ͹
΂Ͱͽͳͻͳ
;
΁ͻ͸͹ͫͰͶ͹Β
ͽͰ΀͸ͳ΁ͳ
͊ͪͯͻͱͪΒ
ΒͰ
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͳ
ͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͪ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͪ
͹ͫͰͶͰͱΒͪ
΀ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ
ͼ͵ͳ
ͻͪͲͬͳͽͪ͵
́Ͷͳ͸ͯͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ
;ͼͽͪ͸ͪ͵
ͳ
̓ͻ;΃Ͱͬͼ͵ͪ
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ
͇̹͆

ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͳͲͭͻͪͯΔͪ
ͼͪ͵ͻͪͶ͸ͪ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ;ͻͪ
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͪ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵
ͽ;ͻͪ
ͷ;ͲͰΒͳ
ͭͪͶͰͻͳΒͰ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸
m
͹ͫͰͶͰͱΒͪ
́Ͷͳ͸ͯͰ͸ͪ
ͳ

͇̹͆ͪ
ͭͪͶͰͻͳΒͪ
͆ͳ͵͹Ͷͪ
ͪͅͻͽͳ͸͹ͼ͵ͳ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ

͊͵͹ͺΒͰ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͪ
͹͵͹Ͷͳ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̸;ͽ͹ͻ

ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ
ΒͰ
͇ͶͳͬͰͻͪ
͚Ͱ͵ͳΕ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂
͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͼͪͬͰͲ
͊͵͹ͺΒͪ
̓Δͳͭͪ

ͳͷͪ
;͵;ͺ͸͹

ͼͽͻͪ͸ͪ
ͼͪ

ͼͶͳ͵ͪ
;
͵͹Ͷ͹ͻ;
ͼ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͷ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͊͵͹ͺΒͪ

͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͷͪͺ͹ͷ
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ
͋Ͱ͵ͼͽ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͺͳͼͪ͸
͸ͪ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸
ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹ͷ
Ͱ͸ͭͶͰͼ͵͹ͷ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͷ
ͳ
΃ͺͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;

͈͹ͻͰͯ
͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͭ
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
ͼ;
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͯ͹ͽͪͯ
͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ
ͪͻ
΀ͳͬͼ͵ͳ
ͼ͸ͳͷ΁ͳ
͹
ͫ͹ͭͪͽ͹Β
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳΒͳ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͳ
ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͭ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͪͅ͵Ͱ
ͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ

͊ͽͪͻͪ
ͼ͵͹ͺͼ͵ͪ
΂ͪͻ΃ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͵͹Βͳ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
͵ͪͱͰ
ͳ

ͼͪͷ͹
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹
ͳͷͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͹
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻ
ͷ͸͹
ͭͳ΀
ͲͫͳͬͪΔͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͹ͯͬͳΒͪͶͳ
;
ΔͰͷ;
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹Β
͹͵͹Ͷͳ͸ͳ
̸;ͽ͹ͻ

 ͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
;
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ 

ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ
ΒͰ
̓͹ͼͽͪ
̹ͪͶͪͫͪ͸͹ͬ
ͪ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂
ΒͰ
͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͼͪͬͰͲ
͊͵͹ͺΒͪ

͇ͬ͹
ΒͰ
ΘͰͺ͸ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͳͲͻͪΌͰ͸
ͺ͹
ͽͪͯͪ
ͪ
ͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
͸ͪΒͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳΒ͹Β
ͽͰ΀
͸͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͳ
ͳͷͪ

ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ

Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
;
͵͹Ͷ͹ͻ;
ͳ
΃Ͱͼͽ
΁ͻ͸͹ͫͰ
Ͷͳ΀
͇ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͳ
Ͱ͸ͭͶͰͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
͊ͪͯͻͱͪΒ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͳ
ͷͰͼͽ͹
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ͸ͪ
ͺ͹
ͬͰͲͪ͸͹ͼͽ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͼͽͪͻ͹
͊͵͹ͺΒͰ
΀ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ

ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ
͵ͪͯͪ
ͳ
͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͶͪ
͊ͽͪͻͪ
΂ͪͻ΃ͳΒͪ
͊͵͹ͺΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯ
ͬͶͪ΃Ε;

͹ͼͷͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
͋;ͻͪ͵ͪ


͵ͪ͹
ͳ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰ
ͼͽͪͻ͹ͭ
͊͵͹ͺΒͪ
ͳ

ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳ΀
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;΁ͳΒͪ
ͳͲ
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
͵;Ͷ
ͽ;ͻͰ
ͳ
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
;
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͽͻͳΒ;
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸ͳ΀
ͳͽͳ͸ͰͻͰͻͪ


ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͪ
ͲͰͷΓͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪΒͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳΒͳ
ͳ
͸ͪΒͫ͹ΓͰ

;ͻͪΌͰ͸
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
;͹ͺ΃ͽͰ
ͯ͹ͼͪͯͪ
ͳͲͪ΃ͪ͹
;
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ
΁ͳ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ
͇ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸
ΒͰ

ͪ
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͰ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
͊ͪΒͷ;
͵Δͳͭͪ

;
͊͵͹ͺΒ;
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͭͶͪ΃Ͱ͸
Ͳͪ
͸ͪΒͫ͹Γ;
͵Δͳͭ;
Ͳͪ
ͺͻ͹ͽͰ͵Ͷͳ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ͹ͯͳ΃Δͳ

ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ
̺͹ͯͳ΂
ͳͷͪ

ͼͽͻͪ͸ͪ

Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒ;
ͳ

͵ͪͻͪͽͪ
̸;ͽ͹ͻ

ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ
ΒͰ
͆ͳ͵͹Ͷͪ
͈ͪ͸͹ͬ
ͪ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂
̽́̽
t́͸ͪ
̓͹ͷͰͻ΁i
ͳͲ
͊͵͹ͺΒͪ

͇ͬͪΒ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ΒͰ
ͳ͸ͪ΂Ͱ
ͯͬ͹ΒͰͲͳ΂ͪ͸
͸ͪ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͳ
Ͱ͸ͭͶͰͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ
͵;
͇ͬ͹
ΒͰ
;ΒͰͯ͸͹
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͺͻͬͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͳͷͪ

͵͹ͷͰͻ΁ͳΒͪͶ͸ͳ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ
ͪ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ

ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ
͹ͬͯͰ
ͼ;
ͯͪͽͳ
ͻͰ͵Ͷͪͷ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
ͳ
͹
ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ
͸ͳͷ
ͳ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳͷ
ͺͻͰͯ;ͲͰΕͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
;΂Ͱͼͽͬ͹ͬͪͶͳ
;
Ϳͳ͸ͪ͸ͼͳͻͪΔ;

͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͷͰͭͪ
ͺͻ͹ΒͰ͵ͽͪ

͆ͪ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͯͪͽͰ
ͼ;
͸ͪΒ͹ͺ΃ͽͳΒͰ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸Ͱ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳ
ͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
Ͳͪ
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ͵;
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒ;
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͸Ͱ͵ͳ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
ͼͽͪ
͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ;
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹Β
ͬͪͶ;ͽͳ
ͪͲͫ;΁ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
;ͻͰΌͰ
Δ;
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͰͶͪͲͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͼͶ
̽ͪΓͰ
ͼͶͰͯͳ
͵͹ͷͺͶͰͽ͸ͪ
ͷ͹͸͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ

ͼͬͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͭͯͰ
ΒͰ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ
ͪ͵΁Ͱ͸ͽ
ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸
͸ͪ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵Ͱ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͸ͪ
͵͹ͷͺͶͰͽ͸;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵;
ͷͪͽͰͻͳ
ΒͪͶ͸;
ͫͪͲ;


̽;΃ͪ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͳͲͪ΃ͪ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͳ
ΒͰ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͽͳͺͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸
;
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
ͪͅ͵Ͱ
ͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ
́Ͳͯͪͬͪ΂
ΒͰ
̽ͳͻͰ͵΁ͳΒͪ
Ͳͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͳ
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͊͵͹ͺΒͪ

ͪ
ͳ͸ͳ΁ͳͻͪ͸
ΒͰ
ͱͰΓ͹ͷ
ͳ
΁ͳΓͰͷ
ͯͪ
ͫ;ͯͰ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ͸ͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ

ͺͻ͹ͺͪͭͪ͸ͯͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁Ͱ
͇ͶͳͷͺͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳͭͪͻͪ
;
̸ͽͳ͸ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͫͳ
ͽͻͰ
ͫͪͶ͹
ͯͪ
ͺͻ͹ͶͪͲͰ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͸ͪ΃;
ͲͰͷΓ;
̺͹ͯͳ΂
ΒͰ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸
ͯͬ͹ΒͰͲͳ΂͸͹
͸ͪ

ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͳ
Ͱ͸ͭͶͰͼ͵͹ͷ
͸ͪ

ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͼͪ

͵͹Ͷ͹ͻ
Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ

ͳ
ͯͰͬͰͽ
͵ͪͻͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ
͈ͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͼͽͬͪͻ͸͹
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸
ͽͳͺ

Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
̸;ͽ͹ͻͳ
ͼ;
͇ͶͳͬͰͻͪ
͚Ͱ͵ͳΕ
ͳ
̀͹ͻͪ͸

͋ͪ͸Ͱͬͼ͵ͳ

 ͆ͳ͵͹Ͷͪ
͈ͪ͸͹ͬ

͊ͪͯͻͱͳ͸ͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͰΓͰ͸ͪ
;
ͯͬͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
ͳ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ

͹ͬͪ͵͹
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒͽͰ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒ;
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸͹
;ͻͰΌͰΔͰ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͪͶ͸ͪ
͹ͻ
ͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ͹
ͳ
͵ͻͪͽͪ͵
΀ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹
͸ͳΒͰ
͌
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
͵ΔͳͭͰ
ͯͪͽ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ
ͼͬͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͺ͹
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳ
ΒͪͶ͸͹Β
ͺ͹ͯͰͶͳ
ͯ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪ΃ͪ
ͲͰͷΓͪ
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳ͹͸ͳͼͪͶͪ

ͼͪ

͹ͺ΃ͽͳ͸ͼ͵ͪ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪ

ͪ
ͳͼͽͳ
ͼ;
ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ
;
͵͹͸ͽͰ͵ͼͽ
ͷͰΌ;ͼ͹ͫ͸Ͱ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͬͰͲͪ͸͹ͼͽͳ
 ͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
;
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ 

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

/JLPMB
1BOPW
3FJTFGÛISFS
JO
EFS
3FQVCMJL
.BLFEPOJFO

JO
EFS
[XFJUFO
)ÅMGUF
EFT

+BISIVOEFSUT

3FJTFGÛISFS
TUFMMFO
CFLBOOUMJDI
FJOFO
TFIS
XJDIUJHFO
'BLUPS
[VS

&OUXJDLMVOH
EFT
5PVSJTNVT
EBS
VOE
[XBS
BVG
GBTU
BMMFO
&CFOFO
m
EFS
MPLBMFO

SFHJPOBMFO
VOE
JOUFSOBUJPOBMFO
4JF
OFINFO
FJOFO
CFEFVUFOEFO
1MBU[
JN

HFOBOOUFO
8JSUTDIBGUT[XFJH
FJO
E
I
PIOF
3FJTFGÛISFS
XÅSF
FT
VONÕHMJDI

BMMF
4DIÕOIFJUFO
VOE
*OIBMUF
[V
CFTDISFJCFO
EJF
FJO
3FJTF[JFM
BO[VCJFUFO

IÅUUF
%FTXFHFO
TQJFMU
EJFTF
-JUFSBUVSHBUUVOH
V
B
FJOF
XFTFOUMJDIF
3PMMF

JO
EFS
#FTDIBGGVOH
EFS
GÛS
EJF
5PVSJTUFO
VOFOUCFISMJDIFO
*OGPSNBUJPOFO

FJOFSTFJUT
VOE
EFS
FOUTQSFDIFOEFO
8FSCFNBUFSJBMJFO
BOEFSFSTFJUT
%BT
HJMU

BVDI
GÛS
3FJTFGÛISFS
GÛS
.BLFEPOJFO
EJF
SFMBUJW
TQÅU
FOUTUBOEFO
TJOE
EI

FSTU
"OGBOH
EFS
[XFJUFO
)ÅMGUF
EFT
MFU[UFO
+BISIVOEFSUT
*N
6OUFSTDIJFE

[V
EFO
NBLFEPOJTDIFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO
LPNNFO
EJF
FSTUFO
3FJTFGÛISFS
VOE

PSHBOJTJFSUFO
3FJTFUPVSFO
JO
WJFMFO
UPVSJTUJTDI
FOUXJDLFMUFO
-ÅOEFSO
FUXB

IVOEFSU
+BISF
WPSIFS
WPS
E
I
&OEF
EFS
FSTUFO
)ÅMGUF
EFT

+BISIVOEFSUT

%JF
FSTUFO
3FJTFGÛISFS
JO
EFS
3FQVCMJL
.BLFEPOJFO
FSTDIJFOFO
JO

EFS
FSTUFO
)ÅMGUF
EFT
WPSJHFO
+BISIVOEFSUT
*O
&SNBOHFMVOH
FOUTQSFDIFOEFS

XJTTFOTDIBGUMJDIFS
"SCFJUFO
[VN
5IFNB
3FJTFGÛISFS
WPS
BMMFN
TPMDIFS
EJF

TJDI
NJU
EFSFO
&OUTUFIVOHTHFTDIJDIUF
VOE
*OIBMUFO
CFTDIÅGUJHFO
XJSE
EJF

WPSMJFHFOEF
"OBMZTF
OBDI
FJOFS
"SCFJUNFUIPEPMPHJF
VOUFSOPNNFO
EJF
EJF

3FJTFGÛISFS
JO
DISPOPMPHJTDIFS
3FJIFOGPMHF
TZTUFNBUJTJFSFO
MÅTTU

%JFT
TPMM
LFJOFTGBMMT
CFEFVUFO
EJF
ÅMUFTUFO
XÅSFO
HMFJDI[FJUJH
EJF

CFEFVUFOETUFO
"VT
FJOFS
IVOEFSU
+BISF
MBOHFO
&OUGFSOVOH
KFEPDI
TDIFJOFO

BMMF
JN
WPSMJFHFOEFO
"SUJLFM
BOBMZTJFSUFO
3FJTFGÛISFS
FDIUF
EFN
(FTDINBDL

EBNBMJHFS
3FJTFOEFS
BOHFQBTTUF
.FJTUFSXFSLF
[V
TFJO

*O
EJFTFS
;FJU
FJOTDIMJF“MJDI
EFS
FSTUFO
ESFJ
+BISF
EFT

+BISIVOEFSUT

XVSEFO
JO
EFS
3FQVCMJL
.BLFEPOJFO
NFIS
BMT

3FJTFGÛISFS
WFSÕGGFOUMJDIU

%B[V
XFSEFO
OJDIU
OVS
TPMDIF
HF[ÅIMU
EJF
EBT
HBO[F
-BOE
.BLFEPOJFO
TDIJMEFSO

TPOEFSO
BVDI
KFOF
EJF
TJDI
BVG
CFTUJNNUF
XJDIUJHF
3FJTF[JFMF
LPO[FOUSJFSFO

FUXB
4LPQKF
0ISJE
4USVHB
%PKSBO
,SVØFWP
.BWSPWP
4USVNJDB
FUD
*O

EJFTFN
;VTBNNFOIBOH
TFJ
XJDIUJH
[V
CFUPOFO
EBTT
EJF
NFJTUFO
3FJTFGÛISFS

OJDIU
OVS
BVG
.BLFEPOJTDI
TPOEFSO
BVDI
JO
BMMFO
XJDIUJHFSFO
'SFNETQSBDIFO

FSTDIJFOFO
&OHMJTDI
'SBO[ÕTJTDI
%FVUTDI
4FSCP,SPBUJTDI
3VTTJTDI
VTX
͋ͪͽΒͪ͸ͪ
̸̹͇̓͆
̀ͪͬ͹ͯ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻ͹;΂ͪͬͪΔͰ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͻͪͲͬͳͽ͵ͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

̸͈͇̾͋́̓
̸̹͉̾̽̾̓̾


̸͇́̈́͑ͅ
͏̸͉͇̻͆͊̓͢

ћ
͇̽
̸̸͉̾̽́͋̾͆ͅ

͇̽
͈͇͎͊̈́̾̽́͢

̸̸͇̹͉͇͆̓
̸͑͌̽́̾͠ͅ

t͆ͪͻ͹ͯͳ
͵͹Βͳ
͸Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪΌͪ΀;
Ͳͪ
ͷ͹ͻͰ

͸ͳͽ
ͼ;
ͺͶ͹ͬͳͶͳ
Δͳͷ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪΒ;
΂Ͱ
ͼͽ͹
͵ͪ͹
ͼͽ͹͵ͪ
ͭͻͯ͸ͪ
ͪ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͳ
͵͹Βͳ

ͼ;
ͳͷͪͶͳ
ͷ͹ͻͪ
ͳ
͵ͻͼͽͪͻͳͶͳ
ΔͳͷͰ

΂Ͱͼͽ͹
ͼͰ
΂ͳ͸Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
ͼ͵;ͺ
ͯͳͬ͹ͬͪi
̺Ͱ΂͸ͳ
ͷ͹ͻͼ͵ͳ
͵ͻͪΒ͹Ͷͳ͵
͌
ͼͬ͹ͷ
ͺͻͬ͹ͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;
͆ͪ΃Ͱ
ͺͶͪͱͰ
͸ͪ
ͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸;
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͻͪͯͳ͹

Ͳͪ
Ͱͯͳ΁ͳΒ;
tͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͼͽͻͪͱͪi
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ΒͰ
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͳ͹
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͺͰ
ͼ͸ͳ΂͵͹
;ͷͰΕͰ
͊ͬ;
ͼͬ͹Β;
;ͼ΀ͳΕͰ͸͹ͼͽ
ͷ͹ͻͰͷ
ͳ
Γ;ͫͪͬ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪ
Δ;
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
;Ͳͫ;ͯΓͳͬͰ
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͰ
ͺͰͼ͸ͳ͵
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰ͸Ͱ͹
ͳ
ͯ͹΂ͪͻͪ͹
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
͸Ͱ
ͼͬͪ͵ͳͯͪ΃Δͳͷ
ͳ
͸Ͱͺ͹͸͹ͬΓͳͬͳͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵͹ͷ
͇
ͽ͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
ͳ
ͽ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͱͽͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͹ͼͽͪͶͳ΀

́ͼͳͯ͹ͻͪ
͊Ͱ͵;ͶͳΕ 
̺Ͷͪͯͳͷͳͻ
̹;Δͪ΁
ͳ
͡ͳΓͪ͸ͪ
͚;ͻΌͳΕ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͻͰͯͳͶͪ
ͺ͹͸͹ͬΓͰ͸͹
ͳͲͯͪΔͰ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
͹

̹͹͵ͳ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵͹Β




ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ

͆ͪ΃Ͱ
ͺͶͪͱͰ
͸ͪ
ͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ





͌
Ͱͯͳ΁ͳΒͳ
tͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͫͳͫͶͳ͹ͽͰ͵ͪi
̸Ͷͷͪ͸ͪ΀ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪͶ͹
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬ͹

ͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͼͽͻͪͱͪ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ΒͰ
͹ͫΒͪͬͳ͹
ͯͬͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
͆ͪ΃Ͱ
ͺͶͪͱͰ
͸ͪ
ͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸;


ͳ
̹͹͵ͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵ͪ





́ͼͳͯ͹ͻͪ
͊Ͱ͵;ͶͳΕ



7MBEJNJS
#VOKBD
%OFWOJL
P
$SOKBOTLPN
̹̻́̀
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ





ͅͳͶ͹΃
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
̹͹͵ͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵ͪ
͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͪ
ͫͳͫͶͳ͹ͽͰ͵ͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ



 ͋ͪͽΒͪ͸ͪ
̹͹͵ͪ͸

͈;ͽ
͵ͪ͹
ͺͻͬ͹ͻͪͲͻͰͯ͸ͪ
m
ͬͪ͸ͻͰͯ͸ͪ
Ͱͷ͹΁ͳΒͪ

ͅͳͶ͹΃
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͅͰͯͳͽͰͻͪ͸
Β͹΃
ͯͪͶͰ͵Ͱ
ͽͰ

ͺͻͰͯ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽͪ͵
̺ͰͶͳ͵͹ͭ
͉ͪͽͪ
;
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͳ
͵͹Β;
ΕͰ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͼͬ͹Βͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
͸͹ͼͽͪͶ
ͭͳ΂͸͹
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͪͽͳ
͵ͪ͹
͸ͪΒͼͻͰΕ͸ͳΒ;
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸;
ͼͬ͹ͭ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
͈ͻͰͺͶͪͬΓͰ͸

͹ͼͰΕͪΔͳͷͪ
͹ͺ΂ͳΔͰ͸
ͷ͹ͻͰͷ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͬͳ
ͺ;ͽ
;ͭͶͰͯͪ͹
;
͉ͳΒͰ΁ͳ
͏ͻ
Δͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͺͳ΃Ͱ
t͋ͪͷ͹
ͭͯͰ
ͳͷͪ
ͷ͹ͻͪ
ͳͷͪ
ͯͪΓͳ͸Ͱ
ͳͷͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪi

͆ͪΒͶͰͺ΃;
ͼͬ͹Β;
ͺͰͼͷ;
̈́ͪͷͰ͸ͽ
͸ͪͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ͹ͷ 
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ΒͰ

͸ͪͺͳͼͪ͹
ͲͪͭͶͰͯͪ͸
;
ͷ͹ͻͰ
͋͹
ͺͻͰͶͰͺ͹
ͺͶͪͬ͹
ͺͻ͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͼͽͬ͹
ͫͳͶ͹
ΒͰ

ͺͰͼ͸ͳ͵͹ͬͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͪ
ͳ͸ͼͺͳͻͪ΁ͳΒͪ
̓͹ͯͰ͸
̹ͳ΂
;
̹ͻͪΒͽ͹͸;
ͳͽͪͶͳΒͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ

͹ͫͪͶͪ
͹͵ͻ;ͱͰ͸ͪ
ͷ͹ͻͰͷ
͆͹ͻͬͰ΃͵ͪ
̽ͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ


͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ΒͰ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪ͹

ͳ
ͼͳͷͫ͹Ͷͳ΂͸͹
ͳ
ͯ͹ͼͶ͹ͬ͸͹
́

ͼΒͪΒ
ͳ
ͫͰͯ;
ͼͬͰͽͪ
͹ͺͳͼͳͬͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͼ
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ͵ͳͷ
ͱͪͻ͹ͷ
̀ͪͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
;
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
ͫͰ
ͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
;ͼͺͰ͹
ͯͪ
ͬͰ΃ͽ͹
ͼͺ͹Βͳ
͹͸;
tͻͪͬ͸;i
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͽͳͬ͸;
ͯͳͷͰ͸
ͲͳΒ;
ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ
ͼͪ
͹ͼ͹ͫͰ͸͹ͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹Ͱͽͳ͵͹ͷ
͵͹Βͪ
ͫ;ͯͳ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΂Ͱͬ;

ͷͪ΃ͽ;
͹ͱͳͬΓͪͬͪΒ;Εͳ
ͼ;ͭͰͼͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͼͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͰͯ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͻͪͯ͹Ͳ͸ͪͶ͹
΃Ε;
͍ͪͼ΁ͳ͸ͳͻͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁Ͱ
͸;ͯͰΕͳ
ͳͷ
͹ͬͪ͵ͬ͹ͷ
ͰͼͽͰͽͳͲͪ΁ͳ
Β͹ͷ
͹ͺͳͼͪ
ͳ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͼͪͼͬͳͷ
͹ͻͳͭͳ͸ͪͶ͸ͳ
Ͷͳ΂͸ͳ
ͪ͵΁Ͱ͸ͽ
͌
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹

ͺͻͪͬͳ
ͬͳͻͽ;͹Ͳ
ͯͪ
͹ͽͷͰ͸ͳͷ
͸ͳΒͪ͸ͼͪͷͪ
ͼͽͳͶͼ͵ͳ΀
Ϳͳ͸Ͱͼͪ
;Ͳͬͳͼͳ
ͼͬͰ

͹͸͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͹ͯͶ;΂ͳ͹
ͯͪ
͹ͺͳ΃Ͱ
ͯͪΒ;Εͳ
ͼͽͬͪͻͳͷͪ
Γ;ͯͳͷͪ
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͳͷͪ

m
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
΂ͪͻ͹ͫ͸;
ͺͻͳͬͶͪ΂͸͹ͼͽ
ͼͬ͹ͭ
;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͬͳΌͰΔͪ

̸
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͪ
΂ͳΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͻͰ͵Ͷ͹
ͫ͹ͱͪ͸ͼ͵͹
;ͬͰ͵
;ͼ΀ͳΕ;ΒͰ
ͳ
ͺͶͰ͸ͳ

͈͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
͵ͪͯ
ΒͰ
ͼͬͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͶ͹
ͼͪͷ͹
ͯͰ͹
ͷͰΌ;ͼ͹ͫ͸Ͱ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳ͵ͪ
΁ͳΒͰ
ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͳ
;
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ͸ͼͳͼͽͳͻͪ
͸ͪ
͹Ͳ͸ͪ΂Ͱ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͻ;΁ͳ

ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͳ
ͯ͹͵
ͼͰ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͪ
ͳ
ͰͼͽͰͽͼ͵͹
;
͹ͬͪ͵ͬ͹ͷ
ͬͳΌͰΔ;
ͼͽͬͪͻͳ

͹ͯͫͪ΁;Β;
͵ͪ͹
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
t͸Ͱͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͪ;ͽͰ͸ͽͳ΂͸͹i
tͪ͸ͪ΀ͻ͹͸͹i
tͽͻͪͯͳ
΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹i
m
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
͸Ͱͺͻͳ΀ͬͪͽΓͳͬ͹
Ͳͪ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͳ
;͵;ͼ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ΒͰ

ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
͹ͺͳͼͳͷͪ
͹ͯͫͻͪ͸ͳ͹
Ͱͻ͹ͼ
ͺͻͳͬͶͪ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͷͳͼͽͳ΂͸Ͱ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰ
ͺͻͰ
ͯͰͶͪ
ͷͳͼͽͳ΂͸Ͱ
ͽͪΒ͸Ͱ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͳ
ͳͲ͸ͪͯ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
ͷͳͼͽͳ΂͸Ͱ
;Ͳͬͳ΃Ͱ͸͹
ͼͽͳ
͹ͼͰΕͪΔͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ΁ͪ

͊ͬͰͽͼ͵͹
ͷ͹ͻͰ
͵͹ΒͰͷ
ͳ
ͷͳ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪͷ͹

;Ͳͫ;Ό;ΒͰ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ

́
ͽ͹
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͹ͫͰ
ͯͳͷͰ͸ͲͳΒͰ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͿͰ͸͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽ;
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͪ
ͪͶͳ

ͳͼͽ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
ͳ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͸ͪ΃
;ͼ;ͯ

͵͹Βͳ
͸ͪͷ
ͳ
ͯͪ͸ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
͸Ͱ
ͯͪ
ͯͪ
ͯͳ΃Ͱ
ͷ͹
ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯ͸͹
ͯͪ
ͱͳͬͳͷ͹
ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͼͻͰΕ͸͹
ͷͳͻ͸͹
΀ͪͻͷ͹
͸ͳ΂͸͹




ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹




ͅͳͶ͹΃
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
̈́ͪͷͰ͸ͽ
͸ͪͯ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ͹ͷ
̺Ͱͯ;ͽͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

 ͈͹Ͱͽͳ͵ͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ

ͅͳͶ͹΃ͪ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ 

̓͹ͯ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ΁ͪ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͬͪ
ͺͻ͹ͶͪͲ͸͹ͼͽ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
ͼͰ
;ͬͰ͵

͹ͼͰΕͪ
ͼ͸ͪͱ͸͹
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
ͼͪ
ͽͻͰ͸;΁ͳͷͪ
;ͱͳͬͪΔͪ
;
Ϳ͹ͻ
ͷͪͶ͸͹ͷ
͹ͺͳͼ;
ͬͳͯΓͳͬ͹ͭ
ͳ
͸ͰͬͳͯΓͳͬ͹ͭ

t͡;ͫͳ΂ͪͼͽ͹
ͷ͹ͻͰ
ͻ;ͷͰ͸ͪ
ͺ͹Ͷ;ͷͻͪ΂͸ͪ
;͸;ͽͻͪ΃Δ͹ͼͽ
΀ͻͪ
ͷͪ

Ͷͪ͵ͳ
ͺͶͪͬͳ
͹͵Ͱͪ͸
ͺ͹ͯ
ͼͳͬͳͷ
ͭ͹ͶͰͷͳͷ
ͬͻͶͰͽͳͷͪ
΃;ͷͪ
͵ͰͼͽͰ
͸͹ͬͪ
ͳ
ͼͽͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪͯ
ͺ;ͽͰͷ
͹ͭͻ͹ͷ͸Ͱ
ͼͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͭ͹ͶͰͷͳ΀
ͬͻ΀͹ͬͪ
͏ͻ͸ͪ
̻͹ͻͪ

ͯͰͷ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͬͻͶͰͽ͸ͪi

͊ͪͷ͹
ͳͲͯͬ͹Βͳͬ΃ͳ
͹ͬͰ
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ͸͹
ͳͲͪͫͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͯͰͬͰ
͹ͼͰΕͪͷ͹
ͯͻͪ
ͷͪͽͳ͵;
͸Ͱͱ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
Γ;ͫͪͬ
΃ͽ͹
͸ͪͷ
ͳ΀
ͺͰͼ͸ͳ͵
ͺͻͰ͸͹ͼͳ
͹ͺͳͼ;Β;Εͳ

ͺͻͳͲ͹ͻͰ
΀ͻͪͷ͹ͬͰ
ͳ
͸Ͱ;͵ͻ͹ͽͳͬ;
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ;
͵͹Βͪ
;
ͲͪͶͰΌ;
̹͹͵Ͱ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ
ͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͪ
͵;Ͷͳͼͪ
Ͳͪ
͸Ͱ͵;
ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵;
ͯͻͪͷ;
̽ͻͪͷ;
t
ͺͻͳ΂ͪ
͵ͻͬͪͬͳ΀
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
͸ͰͼͻͰͽ͸͹ͭ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
΂ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͼ;
͵ͻͬΓ;

͸Ͱ͵ͪͯ
͸ͪͽͪͺͪͶͳ
͋;ͻ΁ͳ
ͅͶͰ΂ͳΕͳ
ͳ
̸;ͼͽͻͳΒͪ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͻͪͼ͵͹΃͸Ͱ
ͼͬͳͶͰ

ͫ͹ͭͪͽͰ
ͫͻ͹ͯ͹ͬͰ
ͳ
ͼͻͰͫͻ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͲͶͪͽ͹ͷ
͹͵͹ͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͷͪ΂ͰͬͰi

̀ͪ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͰ
ͼͬ͹Βͳ΀
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͼͰ
ͽͻ;ͯͳ͹
ͯͪ
ͯ͹Ͳ͸ͪ
ͳ

͹͸͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷͪ
͹ͼͽͪͶ͹
ͼ͵ͻͳͬͰ͸͹
ͯͪ
ͳͲͪ
ͬͰͶ͹ͬͪ
ͽͪΒ͸ͳ
͹ͺͳ΃Ͱ
ͼͬͰ

ͼ͵ͻͳͬͰ͸Ͱ
ͬͰͲͰ
͹ͬͳ΀
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͪ
ͼͪ
͹͸ͳͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
;
ͼͬ͹ͷ
ͳͷͪͭͳ͸ͪͻ͸͹ͷ

ͼ;ͷͪͽͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔ;
ͼ͸ͪͱ͸͹
ͬͳͯͰ͹
ͳ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬͰ͹

̈́Ͱͺ͹ͽͪ
̹͹͵Ͱ
m
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
΃ͬͪΒ΁ͪͻͼ͵ͳ΀
ΒͰͲͰͻͪ

͸͹ͻͬͰ΃͵ͳ΀
ͿΒ͹ͻͯ͹ͬͪ
ͳ
̹͹ͼͿ͹ͻͪ

t͠Ͱͯͪ͸
͵ͻͪͼͪ͸
̓ͪͬ͵ͪͲ
͸ͪ
ͺͶͪͬ͹ͷ
ͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͷ͹ͻ;
ͬͪ͸ͻͰͯ͸ͪ

ͳ
͸ͰͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸ͪ
̹͹͵ͪ
ΒͰ

ͼͪ΂;ͬͪͶͪ
ͺͻͳ΂Ͱ
ͼͬ͹Βͳ΀
ͺͻͰͯͪ͵ͪ
͹
ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯͪ
ͷͪ
ͳ
ͻ͹ͫ͹ͬͪΔ;i
̹͹͵ͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵ͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
͹͸ͯͪ
;
Ͱͺ͹΀ͳ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͫͪ΃

ͳͼͽ͹
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͼͪͯͪ
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂ͳͶͪ
͹
ͺͻ͹ͶͪͲ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͸ͪ΃ͳ΀
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
ͳ
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͪ

͹
ͽ͹ͷͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͼͬͰͽ
;ͬͰ͵
ͳ
͸ͰͺͻͰ͵ͳͯ͸͹
ͷͰΔͪ
͈;ͽͰͬͳ
͸͹ͬ΁ͪ
ͳ
ͷ͹Εͳ

ͷͰΔͪΒ;
ͼͬ͹Β
ͺͻͪͬͪ΁
ͼ͵ͻͰΕ;
ͼͪ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
ͯͻ;ͭ;
ͼͽͻͪ͸;
͸ͪͭͻͪΌ;Β;Εͳ

ͼͪͷ͹
͹͸ͪΒ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ
;ͷͰ
ͯͪ
ͭͻͪͯͳ
ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͽͬͪͻͪ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸
͹
ͼͬ͹ͷ

ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪΔ;
;
ͯͪ͸ͳͷͪ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͼͶͪͬͰ
ͳ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͼͽͬͪ
͊ͪͷ͹
͹͸ͪΒ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ

͹ͼͽͪͬͳ
ͽͻͪͭͪ
͹
ͼͬ͹Β͹Β
ͯ;΃ͳ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͺͻͳ΂Ͱ
ͳ
͵ΔͳͭͰ

;ͬͰ͵
ͳͼͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵ͪ
ͳͲ
ͼͬ͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
;
ͫ;ͯ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͻͪΌͪ
͸͹ͬͳ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ

t̓;ΕͰ
͈ͻ΂ͪΔͪ
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯ
ͺ;͸Ͱ
ͻͪͼ͵͹΃͸͹ͭ
͸ͪͷͰ΃ͽͪΒͪ
ͳͲ
ͼͬͳ΀
ͯͰͶ͹
ͬͪ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
ͼͪͯͪ
ͼ;
ͺͻͪͲ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ΒͰͿͽͳ͸Ͱ
΂;ͯ͸͹ͬͪͽ͹
͹͵;ͺΓͰ͸Ͱ
ͯ;ͱ
͹ͫͪͶͰ

͹͵͹
ͬͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
ͭͻͪͯͳͶͪ
͹ͯ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵ͪ
͍ͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵Ͱ
͉Ͱͬ͹Ͷ;΁ͳ




ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹




ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹



ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹


 ͋ͪͽΒͪ͸ͪ
̹͹͵ͪ͸

ΒͰ
ͺͪ
ͼ͵͹ͻ͹
ͯ͹
ͻͪͽͪi 
ͳͶͳ
t͉ͳͼͪ͸
ͳͶͳͻͼ͵ͳ΀
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͪ
ͼͪͯ
ΒͰ
ͷͪͶͪ

ͳ
ͫͰͯ͸ͪ
ͬͪͻ͹΃ͳ΁ͪ
Ͳͳͷͳ
ͺͻͳΒͪͽ͸ͪ
ͳ
΃ͪͻͰ͸ͪ
ͶͰͽͳ
͆Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ
͸ͰͳͲͷͰͻ
͸͹
ͫ͹ͭͪͽ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷ
ΒͰ
͹ͼͳͻ͹ͷͪ΃ͳ͹
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪ͹
ͻ͹ͷͪ͸ͽͳ΂ͪ͸i


͌
͹ͺͳͼ;
͈Ͱͻͪͼͽͪ
͹ͺͰͽ
͹ͼͰΕͪ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͻͫͳͯ͸͹ͼͽ
͸ͪͺ;΃ͽͰ͸͹ͭ

ͪͬͰͽ͸͹ͭ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
t͈Ͱͻͪͼͽ
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪΒ΂;ͯ͸ͳΒͪ
ͬͪͻ͹΃
;
̹͹͵ͳ
ͪ
ͷ͹ͱͯͪ
ͳ

͸ͪ
΁ͰͶ͹ͷ
ͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸;
͈;ͼͽͪ
ͳ
ͷͻͽͬͪ
͹ͫͻͪͼͶͪ
ͽͻͪͬ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͫͻ΃Γͪ͸͹ͷ
͵ͪ͹

ͪͬͰͽ
ͫͰͶͳ
ͼͰ
͸͹Ε;
͵ͻͪΒ
ͷ͹ͻͪi
t͈Ͱͻͪͼͽ
ΒͰ
Ͳ͹ͻ͹ͷ
͵ͪ͹
ͷͻͽͪͬ
Ͷͪͫ;ͯ

̹Ͱ͹
ͺͻͰͫͶͰͯͰ͹
ͼͪ
ͷͪ΀͹ͬͳ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹
͵ͻ͹ͬ͹ͬͳͷͪ
̻ͻͫ
͈Ͱͻͪͼͽͪ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲ;Β;

ͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
;
͹ͺ΃ͽͳ͸ͼ͵͹Β
͵;Εͳ
͇͸
ΒͰ
͵ͻͼͽ
͸ͪ
͵͹ͷͰ
ͼ;
ͼ͵Ͷ͹ͺΓͰ͸Ͱ
ͯͬͰ
ͻ;
͵Ͱ
͆ͪ
ΔͰͷ;
ͼ;
ͯͬͪ͸ͪͰͼͽ
ͷͪͶͳ΀
ͭͻͫ͹ͬͪ
ͬͶͪͼͽͰͶͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΁ͪ
͹ͯ

͵͹Βͳ΀
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͸ͳ͵͹
͸Ͱ
ͱͳͬͳi
́ͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͪ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͷͳͽͼ͵ͪ
͸͹ͼͽͪͶͭͳΒͪ
;ͺ͹ͻ͸͹
ͺ͹ͯͼͰΕͪΔͰ
͸ͪ

͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ΃ΔͰ
Β;͸ͪ΃ͽͬ͹
ͳ
ͽͰͱΔ;
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͷͪͶ͹ͭ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪΌͰ
͸ͪ
΀Ͱ
ͻ͹Βͼ͵ͳͷ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
΀ͻ͹͸ͳ͵Ͱ

ͯ͹ͷͳ͸ͪ͸ͽ͸ͳ
ͼ;
;

͹ͺͳͼ;
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͭ
ͫ͹͵ͰΓ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ

tͅ͹ͻͰ
ͳͼͺ͹ͯ
͈Ͱͻͪͼͽͪ
ͳ
͉ͳͼ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
͵Ͷͪͼͳ΂͸͹
ͷ͹ͻͰ
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵Ͱ

ͱͰΓͰ
Ͳͪ
ͷ͹ͻͰͺͶ͹ͬͼͽͬ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹΃ͶͰ
ͼͶͪͬͰi
̸
͹ͺ΃ͽͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͯ͹ͷ͹ͬͳ

͹ͺ;ͼͽͰͶͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯͳΕͪ
̹͹͵Ͱ
΂;ͬͪΒ;
͵ͪ͹
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͷ͹ͻͼ͵Ͱ
Ͳͪͼͽͪ
ͬͰ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͭͻͫ͹ͬͰ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
͸Ͱͼͽͬͪͻ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͻͽͻͰͽͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽͳ΀
ͺ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΁ͪ
ͳ

ͷ͹ͻͰͺͶ͹ͬͪ΁ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͽͪͷ͹
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯ
ͻͪͽ͹ͬͪͶͳ
Ͳͪ
͉;ͼ͵;
́ͷͺͰͻͪͽ͹ͻͼ͵;

ͅ͹ͻ͸ͪͻͳ΁;
Ͳͪ
̺Ͱ͸Ͱ΁ͳΒ;
ͳ
ͷͶͰͽͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ͯ;ͱͯͪ
͋;
ͼ;
ͪͅͽͳΒͪ
̀ͷͪΒͰ
ͬͳΕ
ͪͅͻ͵͹
ͪͅͻͽͳ͸͹ͬͳΕ
ͭͻ͹Ϳ͹ͬͳ
̺͹Β͸͹ͬͳΕͳ
̺ͳ΁͵͹
̹;Β͹ͬͳΕ
͹͸ͪΒ

͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͫͻͪ͸ͳ͹
̾ͻ΁Ͱͭ͸͹ͬͳ
͹ͯ
͋;ͻͪ͵ͪ
ͫͪ΁ͪΒ;Εͳ
͵ͪͷͰ͸ͪ
ͼ
ͻͪͷͰ͸ͪ
Ͳͪ

ͬͻͰͷͰ
͹ͺͼͪͯͰ


͋ͪ͵͹ΌͰ
;
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͷ
ͭͻͪͯ;
̹͹͵Ͱ
ͺͻͳͼ;ͽ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
Βͪ͵ͪ
ͻͰͶͳͭͳ͹Ͳ͸ͪ

ͯͳͷͰ͸ͲͳΒͪ
t̓ͻͼ͸;
ͼͶͪͬ;
͸ͪΒ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ΂͸ͳΒͳ
͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒ
ͯ͹ͷͪΕͳ΀
͊ͻ
ͫͪ
ͼͶͪͬͰ
;
̹͹͵ͳ
ͫͰͲ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬ͸ͳ
ͳ
͵ͪͽ͹Ͷͳ΁ͳ
ͳ
͊ͻͫͳ
ͳ

͎ͻͬͪͽͳ
͹ͯ;ͬͰ͵i
͉ͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͳ
ͷ͹΃ͽͳ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͳ
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬ͸ͳ
ͳ

͵ͪͽ͹Ͷͳ΂͵ͳ
ͼͪ
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
ͽ͹ͻΔͰͬͳͷͪ
ͳ
Ͳͬ͹͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ

ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͼ;
͸Ͱͭ͹
;͵ͻͪͼ

;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
t͵ͻͼͽ
΃ͽ͹
ͭͪ
ΒͰ
ͯͻͱͪ͹
;
ͻ;΁ͳ
͵ͪͺ;΁ͳ͸
ͪͅͻ͵͹

̽Ͱͬͳͪ͸͹
͵ͪͯ
ΒͰ
ͫͶͪͭ͹ͼͳΓͪ͹
΀ͻͳ΃Εͪ͸ͼ͵;
ͬ͹Βͼ͵;
ͺ͹Γͼ͵͹ͭ
͵ͻͪΓͪ
ͪ͠͸ͪ

͊͹ͫΒͰͼ͵͹ͭi
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯͳͶͪ
̹Ͱ΂
͹ͯ
͋;ͻͪ͵ͪ
ͭ͹ͯ

ͺͪ
tͼͳͶͰ



ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹




ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹




ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹




ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹




ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹




ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹


 ͈͹Ͱͽͳ͵ͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ

ͅͳͶ͹΃ͪ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ 

ͼͳΒͪ
ͷ͹΃ͽͳΒ;
ͻͪͲ͸ͳ΀
ͼͬͰͽͪ΁ͪ
ͼͬͰ
;
ͼͻͰͫͻ͸ͳͷ
΃͵ͻͳΔͪͷͪi
͌
ͺͻ
ͬ;
͸ͰͯͰΓ;
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
ͼͬͰͽ͹ͭ
͋ͻͳͿ;͸ͪ
;
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ;
ͼͰ
ͳͲ͸͹ͼͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͪ
ͭͶͪͬͪ

͹͵͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
ͼͻͰͫͻ͹ͷ
ͳ
͸͹ͼͳ
ͼͰ
ͽͰ΃͵ͳͷ
ͫ͹ͶͰͼ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
̓ͻͼͽ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
͹ͽͰͽ

;
ͫͳ΁ͳ
ͼ
̹;ͭͪͻͳͷͪ
Ͳͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
΁ͪͻͪ
̽;΃ͪ͸ͪ
̹͹͵ͰΓͳ
ͼ;
ͯ͹ͫͳͶͳ
͵ͪ͹

ͺ͹͵Ͷ͹͸
Ͳͪ
΀ͻͪͫͻ͹ͼͽ
͌
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻ;
;
͈ͻ΂Δ;
΂;ͬͪ
ͼͰ
ͳ
΃͹Γͪ
͹ͯ
ͼͻͰ
ͫͻͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪͶͪ
͸ͪΒͻ͹ͷͪ͸ͽͳ΂͸ͳΒͰͷ
͹ͯ
ͼͬͳ΀
ͫͻͳͽͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀

Ͷ͹ͻͯ͹ͬͪ
ͦ͹ͻΘ;
̻͹ͻͯ͹͸;
̹ͪΒͻ͹͸;
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ
͆͹ͬͳ
̀ͰͶͰ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͪͅ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ
͊ͪͬͳ͸ͪ
͉ͳͼͪ͸
͈Ͱͻͪͼͽ
̽͹
ͫͻ͹ͽͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ
͏ͰͽͳΔͰ
̹;ͯͬͪ
ͳ
͊ͬͰͽͳ
͊ͽͰͿͪ͸
ͅ;͹
͈ͻ΂ͪΔ
͊ͽ͹Ͷͳͬ

̈́ͰͺͰͽͪ͸Ͱ
̓ͪͷͰ͸ͪͻͳ
͋ͳͬͪͽ
̓ͻͽ͹ͶͰ
͡;΃ͽͳ΁ͪ
ͳ
͈ͻͰͬͶͪ͵ͪ
m
ͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ

ͼ;
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
ͻ͹ͷͪ͸ͽͳ΂͸͹
ͳ
ͯͻͪͷͪͽͳ΂͸͹
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͸Ͱ
́

ͪ͸ͽͳ΂͵ͳ
͇Ͷͳͷͺ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͯ͸ͰͫΓͪ
tͬͰ΂ͪ͸
ͳ
ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯͪ͸i
̈́͹ͬΕͰ͸
t;
ͼͬ͹ͷ

ͷ;Δͪͷͪ
ͫͳΒͰ͸͹ͷ
ͬͻ΀;i
͹Ͷͳ΂ͪͬͪ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ͵
ͯͻͰͬ͸͹ͷ
ͺͪͭͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺͼͳ
΀͹Ͷ͹΃͵͹ͷ
ͪͻ΀Ͱͽͳͺ;
͵͹ͶͰ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹͸ͰͼͬͰͼ͸͹ͷ
ͭ͹ͻ΃ͽͪ΂͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
͏ͻ
͸Ͱ
̻͹ͻͰ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͼͬ͹ͭ
͸ͪΒͫ͹ΓͰͭ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬͳ͹
͸ͪ
͸ͪΒͬͳ΃;

ͷ͹ͭ;Ε;
ͬͳͼͳ͸;
ͺͻͪͬ͹
ͺ͹ͯ
͹ͫͶͪ͵Ͱ
΃ͽ͹
ͫͶͳͱͰ
̹͹ͭ;
͊ͬͳ
͹ͬͳ
͹ͺͳͼͳ

ͼ;
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸͹
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ
;
͵͹͸ͽͰ͵ͼͽ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͷ͹Ε͸Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͱͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͼͬͰͼ͸Ͱ

ͳ
ͼͬͳ΀
͸ͰͬͳͯΓͳͬͳ΀
͹ͯͪͬ͸͹
Ͳͪͫ͹ͻͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ΀
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ

͸Ͱ͵ͳͷ
΂;ͯ͹ͷ
ͺͻͰͱͳͬͰͶ͹
Β͹΃
ͺͻͰ͹ͼͽͪͶ͹
͸ͪ
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͫͻͳͼͪ͸͹ͷ
ͻͪͽ͸͹ͷ

ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
ͼͬͳ΀
͹͸ͳ΀
ͼ;ͯͫͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹͸͹ͬΓͰ͸ͳ΀
;ͯͪͻͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳ
ΒͰ

͆ͪ
ͺ͹ͬͻͪͽ͵;
ͳͲ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
Ͳͪͷͳ΃ΓͰ͸ͳ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͹ͫͳͶͪͲͳ
tͬͪ͸
ͻͰͯ͸ͳ
ͿΒ͹ͻͯ
̹͹͵Ͱ
ͳͭͻ;
͹ͭͻ͹ͷ͸ͳ΀
͵ͻ΃Ͱͬͪ
ͷͶͰͽͪ΂͵ͳ
ͽͳ΀ͳ΀
ͲͪͶͳͬͪ
ͳ

͹΃ͽͻͳ΀
΂ͳͼͽͳ΀
ͬͳͯͳ͵ͪ
͊͵͹ͻ͹
͸ͰͺͻͰ͵ͳͯ͸͹
ͼͰ
͸ͳͱ;
͵ͻͪΒ
ͺ;ͽͪ
ͫͰͶͰ

͵;ΕͰ
͸ͪͼͰΓͪ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ
΂ͳͼͽͪ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ
ͬͰͼͰͶͪ
ͶͰͽͳ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ
ͺ;͸ͪ
͵;ͺͪ΂ͪ
͵͹Βͳ

ͼ;
ͳͲ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͳͲ
͹ͫͶͳͱΔͳ΀
ͷͰͼͽͪ
ͯ͹΃Ͷͳ
ͽ;
ͺ͹ͯ
΀Ͷͪͯ͹ͬͳ͸;
΃;ͷͰ

͵ͰͼͽͰ͸͹ͬͪ
ͯͪ
ͶͰͽ;Β;
͆͹Ε;
ͽͳ΀ͪ
ͼͬͳͻ͵ͪ
ͷͪ͸ͯ͹Ͷͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͽͪͷͫ;ͻͳ΁Ͱ
ͺͰ
ͼͷͪ
ͼͷͰ΀
ͳͲ
΂;͸͹ͬͪ
΃ͽ͹
͵ͶͳͲͰ
ͺ͹
ͷͰͼͰ΂ͳ͸ͳ
ͯͪΒ;
ͽ͹ͷ
͵ͻͪΒ;
ͽ͹͸
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ

ͺͳͽ͹ͷͰ
ͼͰ͸ͽͳͷͰ͸ͽͪͶ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
Ϳͻͳͬ͹Ͷ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ͸ͪ΂Ͱ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷ
͸Ͱ͹ͫͳ΂ͪ͸

;
ͽ͹Β
ͲͰͷΓͳ
ͯͰͷ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
͵͹͸ͽͻͪͼͽͪ
ͳ
ͫ;ͻͪi
́
ͼͪͷ͹
͹ͬͪ
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͪ
ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͫͳ
ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸ͪ
ͯͪ
͸ͪͷ

Βͪͼ͸͹
ͯ͹΂ͪͻͪ
ͼͬ;
͹͸;
ͽͪΒͪ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸;
ͳ
;Ͳͫ;Ό;Β;Ε;
ͶͰͺ͹ͽ;
͵͹Β;
΂͹ͬͰ͵
ͷ͹
ͻͪ
ͯͪ
͹ͼͰͽͳ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͼͪͷ
͵ͻͰΕͰ
͹ͬͳͷ
ͷͳͼͽͳ΂͸ͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ

ͫͳͶ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
΂ͳͽͪ
͹
Δͳͷͪ



ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹




ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹


ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹

 ͋ͪͽΒͪ͸ͪ
̹͹͵ͪ͸

͋ͻͰͫͪͶ͹
ͫͳ
Ͳͪͽ͹
ͯͪ
ͫͪͻ
ͯͬͪ
ͺ;ͽͪ
ͫ;ͯͰͷ͹
Ͳͪ΀ͬͪͶ͸ͳ
̹͹ͭ;
͵ͪͯ

ΒͰ
;
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
̹͹͵ͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻͼ͵ͪ
Ͳͪͽ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰͷ͹
͸ͪͲͬͪͽͳ
͸ͪ΃͹ͷ
ͳ

Ͳͪͽ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͳͷͪͷ͹
ͺͰͼ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
͹
Δ͹Β
ͻͰ͵ͪ͹
ͼͬͰ

͸ͪ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͷͪͶ͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹
ͼͽ͹ͻ;
ΒͰͲͳ͵͹ͷ
ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹
͸Ͱͼͬͪ͵ͳͯͪ΃Δͳͷ
ͯͻ;ͭͪ΂ͳΒͳͷ
͹ͯ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
͸ͪͷ

ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹ͭ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
͹ͬͰ
ͫͰͯͰ͵ͰͻͰ
;Ͳ͸Ͱ͹
͸ͪͯ
ͺ;͵ͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻ
ͷͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
̽ͪ͸ͪͼ
͵ͪͯ
΂ͳͽͪͷ͹
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸Ͱ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂Ͱ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͏ͻ͸;
̻͹ͻ;
͵ͪ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ

͸Ͱ
ͻͪͯͳ
͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
͹
͹͸͹ͷͰ
΃ͽ͹
͸ͪͷ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳ͹
͏ͻΔͪ͸
ͼ͵ͳ
Β͹΃

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͆Ͱͯ͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
͹ͼͰΕͪΒ
ͼͳͶͰ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ
ͽͪΒ
͸Ͱ
͸Ͱͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͼ;
ͳͼͽͪ͵͸;ͽͰ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
͸ͪͷ

ΒͰ
ͳͯͰͪͶ͸ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼͪ΁
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͹ͺͳͼͪ͹
͌
͸ͪͯͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹Β
ͻͰͪͶ͸͹
ͼͽͳ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͳ
ͳ
ͼͪ͵ͻͪͶ͸ͪ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ͹͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͲͯͪΔͪ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
ͯ͹ͷͳ͸ͳ
ͻͪΒ;
͸ͪͯ
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ͸ͳͷ
΀ͪ͹ͼ͹ͷ
͸ͪͯͳͻ;ΕͰ
ͫͪ͸ͪͶ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͵͹Β;
ͼͪ
ͼ͹ͫ͹ͷ
ͯ͹
͸͹ͼͳ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ
΂͹ͬͰ͵
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͳ͵ͪ͵͹
͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͼͽͪΒͰ
;Ͳ
͹ͬͰ
ͯͻͪͷͪͽͳ΂͸Ͱ

ͭͰ͹ͺ͹Ͱͽͼ͵Ͱ
͵;ͶͳͼͰ
ͷͰͯͳͽͰͻͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
̹͹͵Ͱ
t
͋ͪΒ
͵ͻͪΒ
ͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
Β͹΃
ͳͷͪ
͸ͪ΃Ͱͭ
ͫ;ͻ͸͹
ͺͪͽͰͽͳ΂͸͹ͭ
ͽͻͪͭͳ΂
͸͹ͭ
͸ͪ
ͼͰͫͳ
͆Ͱ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
Ͳͪͫ͹ͻͪͬͳͽͳi
tͅ͹ͻͰ
ͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸ͼ͵͹
ͳ͸ͪ΂Ͱ
ͺ͹
̽ͪͶ
ͷͪ΁ͳΒͳ
ͷͪͶͰ͸͹
ͳ
ͽ͹ͺͶ͹
͹ͬͯͰ
ΒͰ
͹ͭͻ͹ͷ͸͹
ͳ
ͽͷ;ͻ͸͹
ͼͪ
͸Ͱ΂ͳͷ
ͭ͹ͻ͵ͳͷ

;
ͼͬ͹Β͹Β
Γ;ͫͳ΂ͪͼͽ͹Β
ͫͰͼ͵͹͸ͪ΂͸͹ͼͽͳi

́
͵͹
ΒͰ
͵ͪͯͪͻ
ͯͪ
ͺͳͼͪΔͰͷ
͵ͪͱͰ
͵ͪ͵ͪͬ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯ

ͳ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ

͈ͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸ͳ
͸͹ͬͳ͸ͪͻͼ͵ͳ
͵ͻͪͽ͵ͳ
͹ͺͳͼͳ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
͹

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒ;
͸ͪͼ
ͼͪ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒͰͷ
ͫͻ͹ΒͰͷ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ
͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ͸ͳͷ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͰͷ
͸ͪ΃Ͱ
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͌
ͯͰͶ;
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
Ͳ͹ͬͰ

͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
;
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸͹
;ͱ;ͻͫͪ͸͹ͷ
ͻͳͽͷ;
͵ͻͪͽ͵ͳ΀
ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸ͳ
΁ͪ
ͺͰͼ͸ͳ͵
͸ͪͼ
͸ͪ
ͼͬ͹Β
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͼ;ͭͰͼͽͳͬ͸͹
;ͬ͹ͯͳ
;
ͼͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͬͰͶͳ΂ͪ͸
ͼͽͬͰ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͺͻ;ͱͪΒ;
ͺ͹ͯΒͰͯ͸ͪ͵͹
ͼͪ
̸ͬͪͶͰ
ͳ
ͼͪ
͵ͪͶͰͷͰͭ
ͯͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͽͰͻͪͼͰ
t͊;͸΂Ͱͬͳ
ͲͪͶͪͼ΁ͳ
͸ͳͼ;
ͽ;
ͷͪΔͰ
ͬͰͶͳ΂ͪ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸ͳ
͸Ͱͭ͹

;
͉ͳͷ;i
t̀ͪͶͪͼ΁ͳ
ͼ;͸΁ͪ
ͽ;
ͼ;
ͶͰͺ΃ͳ
͸Ͱͭ͹
͸ͪ
ͅ͹͸ͽͰ
͈ͳ͸΂ͳΒ;
ͳͶͳ

͸ͪ
;Ͳͬͳ΃ͳ΁ͳ
ͅ͹͸ͷͪͻͽͻͪi
͇ͬͪΒ
ͼͶ;ͱͫͰ͸ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ΒͰ
ͺͳͼͪ͹
ͺͻͰͽͰͱ͸͹
;
Ͳͬͪ
͸ͳ΂͸͹ͷ
ͽ͹͸;

ͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸͹
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂ͪ
ͳͲͯͪ͹
ͭͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵͹ͷ



ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹ 


ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹



ͅͳͶ͹΃
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͪ
͵Δͳ̸ͭͪͶͿͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ



ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹



ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹

 ͈͹Ͱͽͳ͵ͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ

ͅͳͶ͹΃ͪ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ 

ΒͰͲͳ͵;
t̹ͳͻ͹
Ͳͪ
΃ͽͪͷͺ;i

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ


͇͸
͸Ͱ
͹ͫͳͶ;ΒͰ
;
ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹Β
ͷͰ
ͻͳ
ͺ͹Ͱͽͼ͵ͳͷ
Ͱ͵ͼ͵;ͻͼͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͱͯͪ
͹΂Ͱ͵ͳͬͪͶͳ
͹ͯ
͹ͬͪ͵ͬͰ
ͽͰ
ͷͰ
ͳ
͹ͬͪ͵ͬ͹ͭ
ͺͳͼ΁ͪ
̓ͻͳͽͳ͵;Β;Εͳ
͹ͫͪͲͻͳͬ͹
ͼͬ͹ͭ
ͯͪͬ͸͹ͭ
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸ͳ
͵ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͬͰ͵͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͺͻͰ
ΔͰͭͪ

ͺͳͼͪ͹
͹
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
̓͹͸ͼͽͪ͸ͽͳ͸ͪ
͍ͳ
Ͷ͹ͼ͹Ϳͪ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͷ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͺͻͰ͸͹ͼͳ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͭͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͪͷ
͸ͪͲͬͪ͹

tͽ͹͸

ͺͻͰͽͰͻͪ͸͹ͭ
ͬͰͶͳ΂ͪΔͪi
t̹Ͱ΃Ͱ
ͽ͹
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ΀
ͯͻͰͬ͸ͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ

ͳ
͸ͪ
͵ͻͪͼ͸͹ͷͰ
ͷͰͼͽ;
͵ͪ͹
ͷͪͶ͹
ͭͯͰ
;
ͬͪͼͰΓͰ͸ͳ
;Ͳ
ͽ͹
ͫͰ΃Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͪ

ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ
͵ͪ͹
͵ͻͳͶͪ
ͶͪΌͪ
;
΁ͪͻͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺͻͳͼͽͪ͸ͳ΃ͽ;
ͼͪ
ͽͪ͵ͬͳͷ
;ͽͬͻΌͰ
Δͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͼͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹΃Ε;
ͯ͹ͫͪͬΓͪΔͪ
ͻͪͲ͸͹ͬͻͼ͸Ͱ
΀ͻͪ͸Ͱi

͇ͬͪΒ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͫͰ΃Ͱ
ͬͪͳͼͽͳ͸;
ͼͰͯͷ͹ͬͻ΀

̽ͪ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͼͽ͹ͽͳ͸ͪ͵
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͻͰ͵Ͷ͹
ͼͬͰ
͹͸͹
͸Ͱ͹ͺ΀͹ͯ͸͹

͹
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
͹
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹Β
ͫ;ͻ͸͹Β
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
ͫͳͽ͵ͪͷͪ
ͭͻͪΌͰͬͳ͸ͪͷͪ


͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ΒͰ
͹ͺͳͼͰ
ͺ͹ͯͰͶͳ͹
͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͭͶͪͬΓͪ

̓Δͳͭͪ
ͺ͹΂ͳΔͰ
ͯ;ͭͪ΂͵ͳͷ
;ͬ͹ͯ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͯͰΓͰ͸ͳͷ
͸ͪ
͇ͺ΃ͽͳ
ͺ͹
ͭͶͰͯ
ͳ
͸ͪ
́ͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͺͰͽ
ͼͪͼͽ͹Βͳ
ͳͲ
΂Ͱͽͳͻͳ

͹ͯͰΓ͵ͪ
́ͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
;
ͯ͹ͫͪ
̓͸ͰͱͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ

̻ͻͪͯͪ
ͳͲ
΀ͳΓͪͯ;
ͳ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
͸͹Εͳ
ͳ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
;
ͼ;ͯͫ͹͸͹ͼ͸ͳͷ
ͯͪ͸ͳͷͪ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

̀ͪͽͳͷ
ͼͶͰͯͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
ͯͰ͹
͵ΔͳͭͰ
ͳͼͺ;ΔͰ͸
ͷͪΔͰ
ͺ͹Ͱͽͼ͵ͳͷ
ͪ
ͷ͸͹
ͭ͹
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͽͳͬ͸ͳͷ
;ͺ;ͽͼͽͬͳͷͪ
ͺ͹ͯ
͹ͺ΃ͽͳͷ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ͹ͷ
̹͹ͻͪ
ͬͪ͵
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ; 
ͳ
͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪΒ;Ε͹ͷ
ͼͰͻͳΒ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͯ͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬͪ
̓ͪ͵͹
ͼͽͳΕͳ

;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
̓Ͷͳͷͪ
͎͹ͽͰͶͳ
͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
͹ͫͪͬͰ΃ͽͰΔͪ
͈͹ͼͶͪ͸ͼͽͬͪ

ͳ
͵͹͸Ͳ;Ͷͪͽͳ
̓ͪͿͪ͸Ͱ
ͳ
̻;ͻͷͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ
Ͳͪͯ͹ͬ͹Γͼͽͬͪ
ͳͽͯ
͈͹͸Ͱ͵ͪ
ͳͼ͵ͻͳ
΁ͪ
ͼͽͳͶͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵͹ͭ
ͺͳͼ΁ͪ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͼͰ
͸Ͱ͵ͪ͵͹
ͺͻ͹ͬ;͵Ͷͪ
΂ͪ͵
ͳ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͹ͬͪΒ

tͼ;ͬͳi
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ
͵ͪ͹
ͻͰ΁ͳͷ͹
;
͹ͺͳͼ;
ͫͰ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳ΀
͵ͪͿͪ͸ͪ
t

ͭͯͰ
ͼͰ

ͼͻͰΕ;
ͺͻͳΒͪͽͰΓͳ
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
ͻͪͼͺͻͪͬΓͪͶͳ
͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΁ͳ
ͳͶͳ
ͻͪͲͭ͹ͬͪͻͪͶͳ
͹

ͺ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͇ͬͰ
͵ͪͿͪ͸Ͱ
ͳͷͪΒ;
ͼͽͪͶ͸;
͵ͶͳΒͰ͸ͽͰͶ;
͵͹Βͪ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪͷͪ
ͯ͹
ͶͪͲͳ
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸͹
ͳ
Ͳͪ;Ͳͳͷͪ
ͳͼͽͰ
ͼͽ͹Ͷ͹ͬͰi
͌
ͽͻͰΕͰͷ
ͯͰͶ;
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͫͳ͹
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ
͆ͪ
ͫͰ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳͷ
;Ͷͳ΁ͪ

ͷͪ
ͺͳͼͪ΁
͸ͪͷ
ͺͻͰͯͶͪͱͰ
ͯͪ
͹ͫͪͬͰͲ͸͹
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͷ͹
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
ͳͼ͵Γ;΂ͳ



ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹ 



ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹



ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹ 


ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹



ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹



ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹

 ͋ͪͽΒͪ͸ͪ
̹͹͵ͪ͸

ͬ͹
;
ͶͰͽ͹
ͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͼͰ͸ͳ
ΒͰͻ
tͼͰͺͽͰͷͫͪͻ
ͳ
͹͵ͽ͹ͫͪͻ
͸ͳͭͯͰ
͸ͳͼ;

ͽͪ͵͹
ͶͰͺͳi
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͹ͬͯͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
ͳ
͹
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͪ
΂ͳ
Βͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬͪ
ͬͰͯͻͳ͸ͪ
ͳ
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸ͪ
ͳͻ͹͸ͳΒͪ

̓ͪ͵͹

ΒͰ
ͯ͹
ͼͪͯͪ
ͺ͹ͯ͸Ͱ͹
ͳ
ͼ;ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͸Ͱͬ͹Γͪ
͹ͬ͹ͷ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ;
ͼͰ
ͼͬͰ
΂ͳ͸ͳ
͸Ͱ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͷͰ΃͸͹
͸ͳ΃ͽͪ
ͷ;
͸Ͱ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ
ͯ͹ͼͽ͹Β͸͹
ͯͳͬΓͰΔͪ
͇ͬ͹Β
͹΁Ͱ͸ͳ

͹ͯͷͪ΀
ͺͻͳͯͻ;ͱ;ΒͰ
Β͹΃
ΒͰͯ͸;
ͼͪ
Β͹΃
͹΂ͳͭͶͰͯ͸ͳΒͳͷ
ͽͻͪͭ͹ͷ
Ͷͳ΂͸͹ͭ

ͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬͪ
͈ͻ͹΂ͳͽͪΕͰͷ͹
ͽͪ͵͹
ͯͪ
΂;ͬͰ͸ͪ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪ
Όͪ͸͵ͳ
͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͳ͵ͪ͵ͪͬ
͸͹ͬ
;ͽͳͼͪ͵
͇ͯͰͬͪΔͰ
ͼͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
΃ͳ͵ͪ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ

ͺ͹΂ͰͶ͹
ΒͰ
Β͹΃
ͯͪͬ͸͹
͊ͽͻͪ͸΁ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͻͪͽ
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͰ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
͵͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ
͈ͪͬͶͪ
ͳ
ͺͰͼ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͻͳͷͰΕ;Β;
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͼͽͬ͹
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ

͸ͪ΃Ͱ
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
̈́;͵ͼ;Ͳ͸ͳ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͷ͹ͫͳͶͳ
ͻͪͼ͵͹΃
ͻͰͲͳͯͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͶ͸͹ͭ

̽ͰͯͳΔͪ
ͽ͹ͭ
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ΃ͽͪ
͸ͪΒͫ͹ͭͪͽͳΒͳ΀

ͺ͹΂ͰͶͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͯͷͪ΀
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
͈ͻͬ͹ͭ

ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
͊ͬͰ
ΒͰ
;
ͽ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͺ͹ͯͳͲͪ͸͹
͵ͪ͵͹
ͺͳͼͪ΁
͵ͪͱͰ
tͽͳͺͳ΂
͸͹
ͪͷͰͻͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͫͻͲͳ͸͹ͷi
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͹ͬͯͰ
;
ͳͷͰ
ͳ
;
͵͹ͻͳͼͽ
ͼͬ͹Βͳ΀
΂ͳͽͪͶͪ΁ͪ

ͺ;ͽ;ΒͰ

ͺ͹Ͷͪ͵͹
͵͹ͻͪ͵͹ͷ
ͻͪͯ͹Ͳ͸ͪͶ͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
;Ͷͳ΁ͪͷͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳͷ

ͫ;ͶͰͬͪͻͳͷͪ
ͺͶ͹΂͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͺ͹ͻͽͪͷͪ
ͼ͹͵ͪ΁ͳͷͪ
ͪ;Ͷͪͷͪ
ͬͻͽ͹ͬͳͷͪ

ͪͶͰΒͪͷͪ
ͽͰͻͪͼͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͺͪͻ͵͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͪͅͶ͹
ͺ͹
ͷͪͶ͹
΂ͳͽͪͶͪ΁
͵͹ͻͪ΁ͳͷͪ

͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸͹ͭ
̺ͰͻͭͳͶͳΒͪ

͹ͫͳΕͳ
ΕͰ
΂ͳͽͪͬ
ͭͻͪͯ
;Ͳ
ͯ;ͱ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͺͻͰ͵͹
͹ͯ
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵͹ͭ
̽ͬ͹ͻͪ
ͯ͹
΂;ͯͰͼ͸͹ͭ
̓ͪͶͰͷͰͭͯͪ͸ͪ
͈͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͼ;
;
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳΒͳ
Ͳͪͯͪͽ͹ͭ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ͸͹
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ
ͽͳͬ͸ͳ
͹ͺͳͼͳ
Βͪͬ͸ͳ΀
Ͳͭͻͪͯͪ
ͷ;ͲͰΒͪ
ͳ
ͫͳͫͶͳ͹ͽͰ͵ͪ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̓ͻ͹Ͳ
ͼͽͳͶ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
͸Ͱͼ͵ͻͳͬͰ͸͹
ͺͻ͹ͼͳΒͪͬͪ
ͽͰ΃͵͹
;͵ͻ͹ͽͳͬͳ

ͼ;ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳ
ͼͽͪͬ
ͺͳͼ΁ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
͹ͬͯͰ
͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͺ;΃ͽͪ
ͯͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͼ;

ͷ͸͹ͭͰ
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;΁ͳΒͪ
ͺ͹ͯͳͭͶͳ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ
ͻͪͯ

͹ͼͷͳͼͶͳͶͳ

ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹ͽͬ͹ͻͳ
͌
ͯͪΓͰͷ
͹ͺͳͼ;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͼ
ͺ͹ͯͼͰΕͪ
͸ͪ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵
ͽ͹͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͫͻͲ͹
ͻͪͼͽͰ
ͳ
ͭͻͪͯͳ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪΒ;Εͳ
ͺͻͪͬͪ

ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͪ
ͷͰͽͻ͹ͺ͹Ͷͪ
͌
͵ͻͪͽ͵͹ͷ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸;
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͳͶ͹
ͼͰ
ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹

ͽ͹ͭͪ

ͽͪ͵͹
ͯͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
ͭͯͰ
ΒͰ
͸Ͱ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͯͪͬ͸͹
ͫͳͶͪ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂͸ͪ
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͪ

͵ͪͺͳΒͪ
;ͶͪͲ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

ͬͰΕ
Ͳͪͯ;ͭ͹
Ͳͪ;Ͳͳͷͪ
ͽͳͺͳ΂͸͹
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ
ͼͺ͹
ͷͰ͸ͳ͵
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸
ͺͻͳ͸΁;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸͹ͷ
ͬͶͪͯͪ͹΁;

͵͸ͰͲ;
ͅͳ΀ͪͳͶ;
͇ͫͻͰ͸͹ͬͳΕ;

͋;
ͼ;
ͳ
͵ͻͪͽ͵Ͱ
ͪͶͳ
ͰͿͰ͵ͽ͸Ͱ
ͼ͹΁ͳ͹Ͷ͹΃͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͳͷͺͻͰ
ͼͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͺ;ͽ
͹͸Ͱ
͹
ͫͻͲ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͽͻͪΒ͸͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼ;
͸ͪͼͰΓͪͬͪΔͪ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͽͪ
͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
;
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁;
́Ͷͳ
ͻͰ΁ͳͷ͹
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
͵͹ͷͰ͸ͽͪͻ



ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹



ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹

 ͈͹Ͱͽͳ͵ͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ

ͅͳͶ͹΃ͪ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ 

ͺͳͼ΁ͪ
͹
ͽ͹ͷͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹
ͺ͹ͷͳͻΓͳͬͳ
ͳ
ͷͳͻ͹Γ;ͫͳͬͳ
̹Ͱ͹
ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͳ͸
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
Ͷͪ͵͹
ͼ͵Ͷͪͺͪ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪ͸ͼͽͬͪ
ͼͪ
ͼͽͻͪ͸΁ͳͷͪ

ͳ
ͼͬ͹Β͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͳ΂͸͹ͷ
Γ;ͫͪͲ͸͹΃Ε;
ͭͻͪͯͳ
ͺͻͳΒͪͽͰΓͼ͵;
ͪͽͷ͹ͼͿͰͻ;

ͳͼͽͳ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͭ͹ͼͽ͹ͺͻͳͷͼͽͬͪ

̓ͪͶͰͷͰͭͯͪ͸ͼ͵;
͋ͬͻΌͪͬ;
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͹ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
ͼ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰͷ
͵ͪ͹

ͳ͸ͼͺͳͻͪͽͳͬ͸͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹
ͺ͹ͯͼͰΕͪΔͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͻͪͽ͹ͬͰ
ͳ

͹ͼͬͪΒͪΔͪ
m
ͪͶͳ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸͹
;ͻͰΌͰ͸ͳ
ͺͪͻ͵
ͼͪ
ͶͰͺͳͷ
΃Ͱͽͪ
Ͷͳ΃ͽͳͷͪ
͆͹ͬ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ΒͰ
ͳͲͷͰ͸ͳͶ͹
ͿͳͲͳ͹͸͹ͷͳΒ;
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͺͻͰͫͪ΁ͳͬ
΃ͳ
ͼͬ͹Β
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ
ͼͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
ͼͪ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͭ

͸ͪ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸͹
͈ͻ͹΁Ͱͼ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͰͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
;ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͷͰ
ͺ͹ͽͺ͹ͷ͹ͭ͸;ͽ

ͰͶͳͽ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͫͰͶͰ
ͻ;ͼ͵Ͱ
Ͱͷͳͭͻͪ΁ͳΒͰ

ͳͲͷͰ͸ͳ͹
ΒͰ
͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹

Ͷͳ͵
ͬͰΕ
ͳ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ΃ΔͰ
t̓ͪͺͳΒͰ
ͻͪͽ͹ͬͪi

͌ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ
ͼͺ͹ͻͽ
ͳ
ͻͪͲ͹͸͹ͯͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸;

ͽͰͷ;
͸ͪ΃Ͱͭ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
̸Ͷͳ
ͽ͹
͸Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͳͼͪ΁
Ͷͳ΂͸͹
Ͳͪͯ͹ͬ͹
Γͪ͸
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹͸;ͯ͹ͷ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
͉ͰͶͪͽͳͬ͸͹
ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳ

͵͹͸΁Ͱͻͽͳ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͳ΃͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͰ
͹ͬͯͰ
͸ͳͼ;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ
ͼ
͸Ͱ͵ͳͷ

ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸ͳͷ
Ͱ͸ͽ;ͲͳΒͪͲͷ͹ͷ
ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
Ͳͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;
͹ͯ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͼͰͭͷͰ͸ͽͪ
͵;Ͷ
ͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸͹
͹ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
Ͷͳ͵͹ͬ͸ͳ

ͱͳͬ͹ͽ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͺͳ΃;Εͳ
ͼ
Γ;ͫͪͬΓ;
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰͷ
͹
ͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͳͷͪ

ͼͽͳͶ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͺͻͪͬ΁ͳͷͪ
͹
ͯ͹ͷͰͽ;
ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ;
͵͹Βͳ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
ͳͷͪΒ;
ΔͰ
ͭ͹ͬͳ
͸ͪΒͬͳΌͰ͸ͳΒͳ
;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ

́͸ͽͰͶͰ͵ͽ;ͪͶ͸ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͻͪͼͽͰ
͹ͯ
͵ͻͪΒͪ

ͬͰ͵ͪ
̀ͪͫͪͬͪ

ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͻͽ
ͼ;
͹ͷͳΓͰ͸Ͱ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͹͸ͯͪ΃ΔͰͭ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
;ͷ͹ͻ͸͹ͭ

͹ͯ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͼͽͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͽΔͳ
ͻͪͽ͹ͷ
͈͹ͽͻͰͫͪ
Ͳͪ
ͷͳͻ͹ͷ
ͳ
΂ͰͱΔͪ

Ͳͪ
;ͯ͹ͫ͸ͳͷ
ͳ
ͫͰͲͫͻͳͱ͸ͳͷ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ͹ͷ
͹ͯͻͰΌ;Β;
ͷͪ͸ͳͻͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͰ
͸͹
ͬ͹;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸Ͱ
͵ͶͪͼͰ
ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͪ
͊ͽͻͪ͸ͳ
;Ͳ͹ͻͳ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
΂ͳ͸Ͱ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ

͇ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͪͶ͸ͳ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
ͼͰ
;ͫͻͲͪ͸͹
ͬͰͼͽͰͻ͸ͳͲͳͻͪ
ͺ͹΂ͳΔͰ
ͼͬͰ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ

ͯͪ
Ͷͳ΂ͳ
͸ͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͰ
ͅ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
;
͹ͬ͹Β
ͼͳͭ;ͻ͸͹
͸ͪΒ;ͻͫͪ͸ͳΒ͹Β
ͽͪ΂͵ͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ

ͯ͹͸ͰͶͪ
͸͹ͬͰ
ͷͰͯͳΒͰ
͈͹΂ͳΔͰ
Ͱ͵ͼͺͪ͸ͲͳΒͪ
ͿͳͶͷͪ
ͺͻͰͯΔͪ΂Ͱ
ͫͳ͹ͼ͵͹ͺ
ͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͰ
ͼ
ͪͷͰͻͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͿͳͶͷ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͳ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵ͳͷ
͹ͺͰͻͰͽͪͷͪ
͈͹
΂ͳΔͰ
ͫ͹ͻͫͪ
Ͳͪ
͸ͪ΃Ͱ
ͿͳͶͷͼ͵͹
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽͰ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͪͷͰͻͳ΂
͵Ͱ
ͿͳͶͷͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͰ
͈͹΂Ͱ΁ͳ
ͺ͹ͺ;Ͷͪͻ͸Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͻͪͲͬͳΒͪΒ;
ͺ͹ͽͻͰ
ͫ;
Ͳͪ
Ͳͪͫͪͬ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳ
ͺ͹΂ͳΔ;
ͯͪ
͹ͼͬͪΒͪΒ;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ΒͰ
ͬ͹ͶͰ͹
ͼͺ͹ͻͽ
ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
Ϳ;ͯͫͪͶ
͵͹Βͳ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸͹
ͼ
ͽͰ
͸ͳͼ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͭ͹ͶͿ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪΒ;
͹ͷͳΓͰ͸ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͻͽ͹ͬͳ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͪ
͆ͪΒͬͪͱ͸ͳ
Βͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
͹ͬͳͷ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͼͬͳͷ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳͷ
ͼͺ͹ͻͽ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͰ
ͼͰ
;ͻͰͯ
͸͹
;
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;
;͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͷ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ΒͰ
͸Ͱ
ͷͪΔͰ
ͼͺ͹ͻͽͳͼͽͪ
͸Ͱͭ͹
΃ͽ͹

ΒͰ
ͺͰͼ͸ͳ͵
ͳ
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸ͳ͵

̸Ͷͳ
͹ͼͰΕͪΔͰ
ͷͰͻͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹΃ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͲͪͯͪͽͰ

 ͋ͪͽΒͪ͸ͪ
̹͹͵ͪ͸

Ϳ͹ͻͷͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
;ͽͳ΂;
͸ͪ
ͽ͹
ͯͪ
͹ͬͪΒ
ͼͬͰͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ
ͪͽͶͰͽͪ

͸ͳΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͽͻͰ͸;ͽ͵ͪ
͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͫͪ΁ͳ
ͷͰͻ;
͸ͪΒ͸;ͱ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͯ͹͵

ͺͳ΃Ͱ
͹
ͼͬ͹Β͹Β
͹ͷͳΓͰ͸͹Β
ͽͰͷͳ
͋;
ͼ;
͸ͪͻͪͬ͸͹
ͳ
ͼͬͪ
ͳͲͶͰͽͳ΃ͽͪ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
ͳ
͹͵͹Ͷͳ͸ͳ
͊ͬͪ
͵͹ͷ
͹ͯ
Δͳ΀
ͺͳͼͪ΁
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕ;ΒͰ
ͺ͹
ΒͰͯ͸;
ͼͽͻͪ͸;
͈ͻͰͯΔͪ΂Ͱ
͸ͰͳͲͫͰͱ͸ͳ

͋͹ͺ΂ͳͯͰͻ
ͳ
̓͹΃;ͽΔͪ͵
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
̀Ͱͷ;͸
͉ͪ͵͹ͬͳ΁ͪ
̸ͬͪͶͪ
͇ͺͶͰ͸ͪ΁

̸ͻͪ͸ΌͰͶ͹ͬͪ΁
͍ͻ;΃͵ͪ
̻͹ͻͪ
͈ͪ
͹͸ͯͪ
ͻͰ͵͹ͷ
;Ͳ
̽;͸ͪͬ
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹
͈ͪ͸
΂Ͱͬͪ
͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͪ
̽͹ΔͰͭ
ͅͳͶͪ͸͹ͬ΁ͪ
ͳ
͋Ͱ͵ͳΒͰ
͊ͬͳ
͹ͬͳ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ͹ͷ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸Ͱ

΁ͰͶͳ͸Ͱ
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͼͪ
ͺ͹Ͳͳ΁ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͭ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪ
ͬͪ͹΁ͪ
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
ͳͼ͵;ͼ͸͹ͭ
ͳ
ͬͰ΃ͽ͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͷͳ͸ͳΒͪͽ;ͻͰ

ͼͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ͸ͳ΀
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹
͹ͺͪͱͰ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
ͼͪͱͰͽ͹
ͳͼͺͳͼͪ͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸
Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͌
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹ͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
ͫͰ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵͹ͭ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
͵͹ΒͰ

ΒͰ
;ΒͰͯ͸͹
ͳ
ͺͻͬ͹
ͳͲͯͪΔͰ
͸ͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
͹ͻͳͭͳ͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
͵ΔͳͭͰ
ͳͲͪ
΃ͶͰ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;

ͪͶͳ
͸ͪ
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵͹ͷ

͵ͪ͹
ͪͺͰ͸ͯͳ͵ͼ
ͳͲͪ΃Ͷͪ
ͼ;
Β͹΃

ͯͬͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸ͪ
ͳͲͯͬ͹ΒͰ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͭͶͪͬΓͪ
͊ͬͳͽͪΔͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͳ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
;

ͼ͸Ͱͭ;
͌
͹ͬͳͷ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
Β͹΃
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͺ͹Βͪ΂ͪͬͪ
;ͽͳͼͪ͵
΂ͬͻͼͽͰ
ͬͰͲͰ

ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͳ
ͽͳͷͰ
ͺͻͬ͹ͫͳͽ͸ͳ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ
ͯ͹
ͫͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͺ͹Ͱͽͼ͵͹
Ϳͳ͸ͪͶͰ
͌
͹ͬͳͷ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͷ
͸ͪ

͸ͪΒ͹΂ͳͭͶͰͯ͸ͳΒͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͺ͹͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
ͳ
ͯ͹͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
͵ͪ͵ͪͬ
ΒͰ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪΒ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
ͯ͹΂ͪͻͪͬͪΒ;Εͳ
͸ͪͷ
ͬͰ΃ͽͳ͸͹ͷ
ͪ;ͽͰ͸ͽͳ΂͸͹ͭ
;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͼͬ;
ͳ

ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
͸Ͱͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ;
ͶͰͺ͹ͽ;
ͺͻͰͼͽ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
́
ͯͻͪͷͪͽͳ΂͸͹
ͳ
ͻ͹
ͷͪ͸ͽͳ΂͸͹

͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͪͷ͹
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͽ͹
;ͷͰ

̿ͪͻ
ΒͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
΃ͽ͹
ͬͰΕ
ͯͪͬ͸͹
ͭ͹ͻͳ

͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͷͰͼͽ;
ͺͳͽͪ
t͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
͸ͪͼ
ͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
;ͯͳ΃Ͱ
ͷ͹
ͶͰͺ͹ͽ;
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͷͰͼͽͪi
͇͸
͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͳͷͪͶ͹
ͻͪͬ͸͹ͯ;΃ͪ͸
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
͸Ͱͷͪͻͪ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͳ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
Ͳͪͫ͹ͻͪͬͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͬͰ
͹͸Ͱ
ͼ͵ͻͳͬͰ
͸Ͱ
͸ͰͼͽͪͶͰ
ͺ͹ͯͲͰͷ͸Ͱ
ͼͻ;΃Ͱ͸Ͱ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͰ
͸ͪ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͲͻͪͼͽͪ͹
͹͸ͪΒ

ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͳ
͹ͯ
ͼͬͳ΀
ͯ͹ͼͪͯͪ΃Δͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
͸ͪ
͌΃Ε;
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
ͯͬͰ

ͻͰ͵Ͱ
͋͹Ͷͳ͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͪͭͪ
ͻͰͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
ͱͳͬͰ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
ͪ
ͭͻͪͯ
͵ͪ͹

ͯͪ
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ
͸ͪͼ
;ͬͰ͵
͸͹ͬ
ͳ
͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ
;ͬͰ͵
ͼͪͷ͹
͹͸ͪΒ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ
͹ͯͼΒͪΒ

ͬͰ΂͸͹ͭ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
;ͬͰ͵
͸Ͱ͵ͪ͵͹
ͻͪͬ͸͹ͯ;΃ͪ͸
tͼͬͰ
΃ͽ͹
ͳͷͪ
;
ͺͻ͹Ͷͪ
Ͳ͸͹ͼͽ
ͻͪͼͳͺͪ i
͐ͳͽͪΒ;Εͳ
͹ͺͳͼ
Ͱͺ͹΀ͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
;
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
ͱͳͬͰ͹
̹Ͱ



͈ͻͬͳ
ͺ;ͽ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸͹
;
΂ͪͼ͹ͺͳͼ;
t̺ͻͰͷͰi

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ


͋ͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͳͲ
΂ͪͼ͹ͺͳͼͪ
t̺ͻͰͷͰi
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ


ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹



ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹

 ͈͹Ͱͽͳ͵ͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ

ͅͳͶ͹΃ͪ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ 

͹ͭͻͪͯ
ͼͬͰ
͸ͪͷ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹
ͳ
ͼͬͰ
ͼͷ͹
ͬͰΕ
ͬͳͯͰͶͳ
͠Ͱͻ
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ͺ͹͸Ͱ͵ͳ

ΔͰͭ͹ͬ
͵ͻͪΒ
ͼͪ΂;ͬͪ͹
ͪͽͷ͹ͼͿͰͻ;
ͳͲ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
̽Ͱͼͺ͹ͽͪ
ͪ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸͹
ͽ;ͻͼ͵͹

ͯ͹ͫͪ
͹ͼͽͪͶ͹
ΒͰ
;
ͷͳͻͳͼͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
tͺͻ͹ͶͪͲͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͼͬͰ
΃ͽ͹
ͺͻ͹ΌͰi
́ͼͽ͹

ͽͪ͵͹
ͳ
͹͸ͪΒ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
ͲͶͪͽ͸͹ͭ
ͯ͹ͫͪ
͵͸ͰͲͪ
ͅͳ΀ͪͳͶͪ
ͳ
͵ͻͪΓͪ
̸ͶͰ͵ͼͪ͸
ͯͻͪ
͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
ͺͻͳͼ;ͽͪ͸
;
ͼͽͪͻͳͷ
ͺͶ͹ͽ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͭ͹ͼͺ͹ͯͼ͵ͳͷ

͵;Εͪͷͪ
́Ͳ
ͯ͹ͼͶ͹ͬ͸͹
ͼͬͪ͵Ͱ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͬͳͯͳ
ͼͰ
ͯͳͻ͸;ͽ͹ͼͽ
ͽͻ;
ͯ͹ͷ
͸ͪ΃ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸ͳ͵ͪ
Ͳͪ͸ͪͽͶͳΒͪ
ͭͻͪͯͳͽͰΓͪ
ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
t͹Ϳͳ΁ͳͻ
ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΁ͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͼͽͬ͹ͻͳͶͰ
͹ͬ;
ͬͪͻ͹΃
͸ͪ
ͼͬ͹Β͹Β
ͼͳͻ͹ͽͳΔͳ

΂ͪͼͽͳ
ͳ
͵ͪͬͪΓͰͻͼͽͬ;i
͈Ͱͼ͸ͳ͵
ΒͰ
ͺ͹͸͹ͼͪ͸
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͼͰΓͪ͵Ͱ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
;

͹ͺͪ͸΁ͳͷͪ
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͳͶͳ
ͳ
ͼ
ͬͰͻ͹ͷ
ͳ
΂ͰͱΔ͹ͷ
ͷͪͻΓͳͬ͹
ͭͻͪͯͳͶͳ
ͼͬ͹Β

ͭͻͪͯ
͈͹͸͹ͼͪ͸
ΒͰ
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͽ;
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͯ;΃͸;
ͭ͹ͼͽ͹ͺͻͳͷͳͬ͹ͼͽ
͸ͪ
͹͸;
͸Ͱ
ͼͬͪ͵ͳͯͪ΃Δ;
ͽ͹ͺͶͳ͸;
͸ͪ
ͯ͹ͷͪΕͰ
ͬͪͼͺͳͽͪΔͰ
ͼͰΓͪ΂͵ͳ΀
ͼͳ͸͹ͬͪ
͵͹Βͳ

͸ͳͼ;
Ͳͪͫ͹ͻͪͬͳͶͳ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
ͳͪ͵͹
ͼ;
ͳ΃Ͷͳ
͸ͪ
΃͵͹Ͷ͹ͬͪΔͰ
;
̹Ͱ΂
͈ͪ
ͻͳͲ
̹ͰͻͶͳ͸
ͳ
͈ͻͪͭ
͋ͪ
ͫ;ͻ͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽ
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
tͬͪ͸ͻͰͯ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͷͰ͸ͪ

Ͷͳ͵͹ͬͪ
ͳ
ͼ΁Ͱ͸ͪ
͉͹ͷͪ͸
ΒͰ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
Β͹΃
͹ͯͪͬ͸͹
͹ͯ
͹͸ͯͪ
Β͹΃

͵ͪͯ
ͼ;
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ
͸ͪ΃ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
ͫͳͶͳ
ͺͪͶͪ͸͵Ͱi
͠Ͱͻ
t̿ͪͻ
ΒͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
΃ͽ͹
ͬͰΕ
ͯͪͬ͸͹
ͭ͹ͻͳi

t̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
ͳͷͪ
ͺͻͪͬ;
͹ͽͷͰ͸͹ͼͽ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͪ
͹ͯ
͸ͰͲͪͼͶ;ͱͰ͸ͳ΀

;ͬͻͰͯͪi
͈Ͱͼ͸ͳ͵
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
ͬͰΕ
ͼͬͰ
ͬͳͯͰ͹
ͳ
͸ͳ΂Ͱͭ
ͼͰ
͸Ͱ
ͫ͹Βͳ

ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹
ͫͳΕͰ
΂Ͱͯ͸͹
ͪ
ͽͰͶ͹
ͶͰͺ͹
ͳ
ͯͪ
͹͸ͪΒ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
͵͹Βͳ
ͽͰ͵
ͯ͹Ͷͪ
Ͳͳ
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͪͷ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͪͬͪ
ͳͲ
ͯͪͶͰ͵Ͱ
ͫ;ͯ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳͲ͸ͪͯ
ͻͰ͵ͪ
ͳͷͪ

ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
Ͳͪ
ͻͪͼͽ
͌
͹ͬͪ͵ͬ͹ͷ
ͭͻͪͯ;
ΒͰ
ͼͬͰ
ͺ;͸͹
ͽͻͪͭͳ΂͸Ͱ
ͪ
ͺ͹͸Ͱ͵ͪͯ
ͳ
ͼͻͰΕ͸Ͱ
͸Ͱ
ͳͲͬͰͼ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͊ͬͰ
΃ͽ͹
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͺͳ΃Ͱ
͹
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
;
ΔͰͷ;

ͭ;ͫͳͶͳ
͹
͸ͪΒͷͳͶͳΒͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͷ͹ͻͪͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
Ͳͪ;ͬͰ͵
ͻͪͼͽͪ͸;
m
ͼͬͰ
ΒͰ

ͽ͹
ͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ͳͼͽͳ͸ͳͽ͹

͌͸;ͽͻͪ΃Δͪ
ͼ͵ͻͳͬͰ͸ͪ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͼͽͬͪͻͳ
;Ͷͳ΁ͪ
;Ͳͬͳ΃ͳ
΁ͪ
ͳͯͰ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸͹
ͼͪ
ͼͺ͹Γͪ΃Δ͹ͷ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
t̺ͪͻ͹΃
ͼͪ
ͬͳͼ͹͵ͳͷ

ͺͻ͹ͿͳͶ͹ͷ
;ͼͺͻͪͬ͸͹ͭ
ͼͽͪͬͪ
ͼ
ͺ͹Βͪͬ͹ͷ
͸ͪ
ͫͻͯ;
Ͳͪ͵͹ͻͪ΂ͪΒͰͷ
͸ͪͯ
ͬ͹
ͯͪͷͪi
͇΂ͳͽͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͰͼ͸ͳ͵͹ͬͪ
͸ͰͼͽͻͺΓͳͬ͹ͼͽ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
΃ͽ͹
ͺͻͰ
͵͹
͸ͪ΂͸͹
ͳͲͭͻͪͯͳ
͇͸
ͭͪ
ͬͳͯͳ
;
ͫ;ͯ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
͸ͪͷ
ͼͬ͹Β;
ͬͳͲͳ
Β;
͸Ͱͼͬͪ͵ͳͯͪ΃Δ͹ͷ
ͺ͹Ͱͽͳ͵͹ͷ
͉Ͱ΂ͳͷͪ
ͭͻͪͯͳ
͸ͰͳͲͭͻͪΌͰ͸͹



ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹



ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹



ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹



ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹

 ͋ͪͽΒͪ͸ͪ
̹͹͵ͪ͸

͈͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͶͰͺ
ͯͰ͹
͹ͬͰ
ͪͺ͹ͽͰ͹ͲͰ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ΒͰ
͹ͺͳͼ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͺ͹ͯ

ͼ͸Ͱͭ͹ͷ
͉ͪͲͫ͹ͻͳͽͳ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ
͹ͫͶͳ΁ͳ
ͼͽͪͻͪ
;ͯ͹ͫ͸͹ͼͽ
ͺ͹ͬ;
΂Ͱ͸͹
ͭ͹ͼͺ͹ͯͼͽͬ͹
̓͹͸ͪ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
͈ͪͽͻͳΒͪͻ΃ͳΒͰ
͊͵ͪͯͪͻͶͳΒͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͺ͹ͯ

ͼ͸Ͱͭ͹ͷ
ͭ;ͫͳ
͹ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͪͶ͸ͳ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯ
ͳ
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͪ
͸ͪ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͳ
ͪ
͵;ͫͰͽͪ
̺͹
Ͳ͸ͰͼͰ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ
ͺ͹ͯ
ͼ͸Ͱͱ͸͹ͷ
ͫͰͶͳ͸͹ͷ
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͪΒ;
͹ͫͶͳ͵
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͼ͵Ͱ

ͼ͵ͻͳͬͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͼͬͰͽͳΔͰ
͋ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
͹͸
ͬͳͯͰ͹
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
͸Ͱͯͳͻ͸;ͽͰ
΂ͳͼͽ͹
ͽͰ
ͺ͹ͯ
ͷͰͽͪͿͳͲͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͫͰͶͳ͸͹ͷ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͶ;ͽΔͪ
ͬͰ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
͌
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
ͼͬͰ
ͻͪͼͽͰ
ͳ
ͷͰΔͪ
ͼͰ
tͬͰ΂͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͼͪͷ͹
ͬͳͯͳ΁ͳ
̓ͪͶͰ
ͷͰͭͯͪ͸ͪi
̀ͳͷͪ
ͼͽͳ΃ͪͬͪ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͪ
ͼ͸Ͱͭ
ͫ;ͯͳ
ͼͰΕͪΔͪ
͸ͪ
ͯͰͽͳΔͼͽͬ͹

͈͹ͭͶͰͯ͹ͷ
ͼ
̓ͪͶͰͷͰͭͯͪ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
ͬͰͽͪͻ
ͬͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͺͪͻ͹ͫͻ͹ͯ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͫ͹ͻͳ
ͼͪ

ͽͪͶͪͼͳͷͪ
͹ͫ;΀ͬͪͽͳ͹
ΒͰ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͼͬ;
ͼͰͽ;
΃ͽ͹
͸ͪͼ
;ͬͰ͵
ͺͻͰͺͶͪͬͳ

͵ͪͯ
͸ͪ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͺͪͯ͸Ͱ
͸Ͱͼͽͬͪͻ͸ͳ
ͫͰ͹ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳ
ͼ͸Ͱͭ
͵͹Βͳ
;΂ͳ͸ͳ
ͼͬͰ
͹͵͹

͸ͪͼ
ͺ͹ͷͪͶ͹
͸Ͱͼͽͬͪͻ͸ͳͷ



ͅ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ͯͰͶ͹

 ͈͹Ͱͽͳ͵ͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͪ

ͅͳͶ͹΃ͪ
͏ͻΔͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ 

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

5BUKBOB
#PLBO
1PFUJL
EFS
3FJTFGÛISFS
WPO
.JMPØ
$SOKBOTLJ
WPN
.JUUFMNFFS
CJT
[V
EFO
MFU[UFO
)ÛHFMO
»VNBEJKBT

*N
WPSMJFHFOEFO
"SUJLFM
XJSE
BVG
FJOJHF
XJDIUJHF
QPFUJTDIF
"TQFLUF
BVT

[XFJ
WPO
JOTHFTBNU
ESFJ
3FJTFGÛISFSO
IJOHFXJFTFO
EJF
WPO
.JMPØ
$SOKBOTLJ

TUBNNFO
&T
IBOEFMU
TJDI
WPO
#PLB
LPUPSTLB
VOE
#FPHSBE
EJF
OFVMJDI

XJFEFSIPMUF
"VTHBCFO
FSMFCUFO

1PFUJTDIF
4DIJMEFSVOHFO
EFS
CFUSFGGFOEFO
3FHJPOFO
VOE
EFSFO

SVINSFJDIFO
(FTDIJDIUF
TJOE
BVDI
GÛS
EFO
NPEFSOFO
-FTFS
JNNFS
OPDI

BLUVFMM
3FJTFGÛISFS
TJOE
BMT
FJO
CFTPOEFSFT
(FOSF
BVT
EFN
#FEÛSGOJT
IFSBVT

FOUTUBOEFO
3FJTFO
XPIMIBCFOEFS
#ÛSHFS
BVT
SFJDIFSFO
-ÅOEFSO
XJF
BVDI

NBODIFS
HVU
BVTHFCJMEFUFO
"MMFJOHÅOHFS
BVT
ÅSNFSFO
-ÅOEFSO
&VSPQBT
FJOFO

UJFGFSFO
4JOO
[V
WFSMFJIFO

.JMPØ
$SOKBOTLJ
XBS
CFLBOOUMJDI
OJDIU
OVS
FJO
CFEFVUFOEFS
4DISJGUTUFMMFS

EFS
WPS
EFN
;XFJUFO
8FMULSJFH
BVDI
JN
EJQMPNBUJTDIFO
%JFOTU
TUBOE
TPOEFSO

FCFO
BVDI
FJO
HSP“FS
3FJTFMJUFSBU
%FS
WPSMJFHFOEF
"SUJLFM
CFTDIÅGUJHU
TJDI

JO
FSTUFS
-JOJF
NJU
TFJOFN
MFJEFOTDIBGUMJDI
GFTTFMOEFO
4UJM
%BSJO
XJSE
BCFS

[VHMFJDI
BVDI
BVG
FJOFO
XFJUFSFO
"TQFLU
EJFTFS
-JUFSBUVSHBUUVOH
BVGNFSLTBN

HFNBDIU
m
BVG
EFSFO
4FSJPTJUÅU
%FS
.FISTDIJDIUJHLFJU
VOE
.FISEFVUJHLFJU
EFT

5FYUFT
MJFHFO
EJF
HVUF
"VTCJMEVOH
VOE
WJFMTFJUJHF
*OUFSFTTFO
EFT
4DISJGUTUFMMFST

[VHSVOEF
EJF
EFO
-FTFS
EJSFLU
JO
FJOF
JNBHJOÅSF
3FJTF
NJU
FJOFS
;FJUNBTDIJOF

RVFS
EVSDI
EJF
(FTDIJDIUF
EFS
(FHFOEFO
IJOFJOGÛISU
EJF
FS
CFTDISFJCU
.JU

TFJOFO
EJDIUFSJTDIFO
,PNNFOUBSFO
VOE
QIBOUBTJFWPMMFO
&JOGÅMMFO
EJF
TJDI
[

#
BVG
4[FOFO
EFT
4POOFOVOUFSHBOHT
VOE
XFJUFSF
ESBNBUJTDIF
%FUBJMT
CF[JFIFO

[FJHU
FS
JO
GBTU
GJMNGBSUFS
4QBOOVOH
EBT
.FFS
)ÅVTFS
.FOTDIFO
4JUUFO
VOE

#SÅVDIF

4FJO
5FYU
JTU
FJOF
EJDIUFSJTDIF
4DIÕQGVOH
TFJOF
3FJTFGÛISFS
WFSNÕHFO

FT
BVDI
IFVU[VUBHF
JOT
*NBHJOÅSF
(FTDIJDIUMJDIF
VOE
.ZTUJTDIF
EFS
(FHFOEFO

IJO[VMPDLFO
EJF
HMÛDLMJDIFSXFJTF
WPO
JIN
CFTDISJFCFO
XVSEFO
.BO
LBOO

EBSJO
4UPM[
&JHFOTJOO
BCFS
BVDI
FJOF
-FCFOTQIJMPTPQIJF
TQÛSFO
EJF
TJDI
BVG

%JDIUFST
7FSTÕIOVOH
NJU
TDIJDLTBMIBGUFN
-FCFOTMFJE
[VSÛDLGÛISFO
MÅTTU

#FMHSBE
BMT
MFCFOTMBOHF
-JFCMJOHTTUBEU
WPO
$SOKBOTLJ
VOE
EBT

"ESJBUJTDIF
.FFS
IBCFO
JO
EJFTFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO
FJOF
WÕMMJH
OFVF
'BSCF
FJOFO

OFVFO
(FTDINBDL
VOE
(FSVDI
FSIBMUFO
EJF
EFO
3FJTFOEFO
EVSDI
;FJU
VOE

3BVN
IFVUF
OPDI
HVU
EJFOFO
LÕOOFO
%JF
"UNPTQIÅSF
MÅOHTU
WFSHBOHFOFS

;FJUFO
TQJFHFMU
TJDI
EBSJO
EFVUMJDI
XJEFS
NBODIF
HFTDIJDIUMJDIFO
&SFJHOJTTF

PEFS
#SÅVDIF
XFSEFO
TP
CFUPOU
EBTT
TJDI
FJO
NPEFSOFS
-FTFS
WFSHFXJTTFSO

LBOO
XJF
ÅIOMJDI
FS
TFJOFO
7PSGBISFO
BVTTJFIU
XJF
[BVCFSIBGU
EJF
(FTDIJDIUF

JO
VOTFSFO
(FCJFUFO
[VS
8JFEFSIPMVOH
LPNNU


͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
̽́́ͣͅ
͍ͳͶ͹Ͳ͹Ϳͼ͵ͳ
Ϳͪ͵;ͶͽͰͽ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

t̹͉̾̽̾̓̾i

̸̀
̾̽͆͌͠
͇͇̹͊͌
ћ
͈͉͇̻́̈́
͇͉́͊͋́́͠

̸͈͇̽́̈́͋́̾͠ͅ

͇͊͏̸́̈́́͊͋́͐̓̾͠
̸̻͇̺͌͊̈́́̾͠͠

̹͹ͭͪͽ͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳͷͪ
t͸ͪͫͳΒͰ͸͹i
Ͱ͸ͰͻͭͳΒ͹ͷ
͹ͼͶ͹ͫ͹
ΌͰ͸͹ͷ
;
ͽͰ͵
Ͳͪͬͻ΃Ͱ͸͹ͷ
ͻͪͽ;
ͳͼͺ;ΔͰ͸͹
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼͳͷͪ
ͯ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͽͻͪΒͪΔͪ
ͼͪ

ͳͼͺͻͰͺͶͰͽͪ͸ͳͷ
;Ͳͻ͹΁ͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
͹ͽͺ͹΂ͰͶ͹
ͯͪ

͹ͽ͵;΁ͪͬͪ
ͼͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸͹ͷ
ͫͳͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷ
͹ͼ͹ͫͰ͸͹
͊ͬͰͽ
ΒͰ
ͳͲͪ΃ͪ͹

ͳͲ
ͻͪͽͪ
͹ͺͽͰͻͰΕͰ͸
ͷ͸͹΃ͽͬ͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹ͱͳͬΓͰ͸͹ͭ
̺ͰͶͳ͵ͳ
Γ;ͯͼ͵ͳ
ͭ;ͫͳ
΁ͳ
ͲͶ͹΂ͳ͸ͳ
ͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶ͸ͪ
ͻͪͲͪͻͪΔͪ
ͻͰͬ͹Ͷ;΁ͳ͹͸ͪͻ͸Ͱ
ͼͷͰ͸Ͱ
ͬͶͪͼͽͳ

͹ͼͽͪͬͳͶͰ
ͼ;
ͼͬ͹Β
ͽͻͪͭ
;
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͳͷͪ
Γ;ͯͳ
ͳ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
͈͹ͯͰͶͪ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͫͰͯ
͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͫͰΌͰ͸Ͱ
͹ͼͰΕͪͶͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͷ
͵͹ͻͪ͵;
͉ͪͽ͸ͪ
͵͹ͪͶͳ΁ͳΒͪ
ͺ͹
ͫͰͯ͸ͳ͵ͪ
t͸ͪͭͻͳͱͰ͸ͪi
͸Ͱͺ͹ͬͰͻͰΔͰͷ
ͼ;͵͹ͫͳͷͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ
ͼ;ͷΔͳ΂Ͱ
Δͳͷͪ
ͺͻ͹ͽͳͬͻͰ΂͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸͹ͭ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Βͪ
ͺ͹΂ͰͶͪ
ͼͰ
ͻͪͼͺͪͯͪͽͳ

͈͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͰ
tͭͬ͹ͲͯͰ͸Ͱ
ͲͪͬͰͼͰi
ͼ;͵͹ͫͳ
͸ͪ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͻͪͽ͹ͬͳ
΃ͺͳΒ;
͸ͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵ͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͸ͳ΀
ͼͿͰͻͪ
ͫͶ͹͵͹ͬͼ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͯͰͶͪ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
͹ͫͻͪ΂;͸


ͳͲͷͰΌ;
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
ͽͻ͵ͪ
;
͸ͪ͹ͻ;ͱͪΔ;
ͻͪͼͺͪͯ
͵͹Ͷ͹͸ͳ
ΒͪͶ͸ͳ΀
΁ͪͻͼͽͪͬͪ
ͻͪΌͪΔͰ
tͽͻͰΕͰͭ
ͼͬͰͽͪi
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
ͼ;
͹ͯ
͹ͯͶͳ͵ͪ
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳ
Βͪ
͹ͫͰͶͰͱͰ͸ͳ΀
t΀Ͷͪͯ͸ͳͷ
ͻͪͽ͹ͷi
͆ͪ
;͸;ͽͻͪ΃ΔͰͷ
ͺͶͪ͸;
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹

ͬͻͰͷͰ
͹ͫ͸͹ͬͰ
ͳ
ͳͲͭͻͪͯΔͰ
ͻͪͲͬͶͪ΃ΕͳͬͪΔͪ
͵Ͷͪͼ͸͹ͭ
͸ͰͺͻͳΒͪͽͰΓͪ

ͺͻͬͳ΀
ͺͰͽ͹ͭ͹ͯͳ΃Δͳ΀
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͪ
ͻͪͯ͸ͳ΀
ͪ͵΁ͳΒͪ
ͺͻ;ͭͪ
ͭͻͪͯͳͶͳ΃ͽͪ

ͪͭͻͪͻ͸Ͱ
ͻͰͿ͹ͻͷͰ
ͳ
͵͹Ͷ͹͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͵͹ͶͰ͵ͽͳͬͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͼͰͶͪ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͭ

ͯͰͷ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͶ͹ͷͪ
;ͫͻͲͪ͸Ͱ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
;ͻͫͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ

ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
m
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
t͵͹͸ͽͻ͹Ͷͳͼͪ͸͹ͭ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪi
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
ͱͳ
ͬͰͶ͹
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
t΀Ͱͻ͹Βͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
Β͹΃
ͼͬͰͽͶͳΒͰ
ͫ;ͯ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳi
;Ͳ

 ͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
̽ͳͷͳΕ

ͼͽͪͶ͸͹
tͼͽͰͲͪΔͰ
͵ͪͳ΃ͪi
̺ͻͰͷͰ
;
͵͹ͷͰ
ΒͰ
ͷͪͼ͹ͬ͸͹
͵͹ͶͰ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹
ͺ;ͽ͹
ͬͪΔͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
͹ͯͶͪͲͪ͵
͸ͪ
ͷ͹ͻͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͬͰΕͳ͸ͪ
ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ

ͺ͹
ͺͻͬͳ
ͺ;ͽ
ͬͳͯͰͶͪ
ͼͷͪͽͻͪ͸͹
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
͹ͯ
ͽͰ͵͹ͬͳ͸ͪ
;ͼͺͰ΃͸͹
ͳͲͬ͹ΒͰ
ͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͻͰͬ͹Ͷ;΁ͳΒͰ
͌
ͺͻͬ͹Β
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͻͪͽ͸͹Β
ͯͰ΁Ͱ͸ͳΒͳ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪͶ͹
͈͹ͼͰͫ
͸͹
͸Ͱ
;
ͳ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͼͽͬ͹
ͳͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
ͺ͹
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵͹
ͬͪͶͪ
͹ͯ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
̀ͪͬͻ΃Ͱͽͪ͵
ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪ
ͽͪ
;
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
ͻͰ΃ͰΔͰ
t͋ͻ΃Εͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͳͽͪΔͪi
ͳ
ͺ͹ͷͳͻͰΔͰ
ͼͪ
͉͊͊͊͹ͷ

;΂ͳ͸ͳͶͳ
ͼ;
;
ͯͻ;ͭ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
ͳ΀
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ

ͯ͹͸Ͱ͵ͶͰ
tͺͻ͹ͺ;ͼͽΓͳͬͳΒͳͷi
Ͳͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͳ΀
ͺͻͰ͵͹ͻͪ΂ͳͬͪͶͳ

͈ͻͪͬ͹
͸ͪ
ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯ͸͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͺ͹͵ͪͲͪͽͰΓ
ͯ͹ͼͰͭ͸;ͽͳ΀

ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯͪ
ͳ
ͫͳͽ͸ͪ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͯ͸Ͱͬͳ΁Ͱ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸͹ͭ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
͋͹

ͺͻͪͬ͹
ΒͰ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͫͳͶ͹
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
͹ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂Ͱ͸͹
͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͺͻͳͬͳͶͰ
ͭͳΒͪ
ͻͰͽ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
ͺͻ͹ͬͰͻͰ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
ͺ͹;Ͳͯͪ͸ͳ΀

͋ͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
;
ͳ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͼͽͬ͹
ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
ͳ
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
ͺ;ͽ;Β;
ͬͳ
ͼ͹͵ͳ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͺͪͻͽͳΒͼ͵ͳ
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳ͹͸Ͱͻͳ
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͰ
ͼͽͻ;΂Δͪ΁ͳ

͵͹Βͳ
ͳͯ;
͸ͪ
;ͼͪͬͻ΃ͪͬͪΔͰ
ͳͶͳ
ͳ΀
ͼͶ;ͱͫͰ͸ͪ
ͯ;ͱ͸͹ͼͽ
ͬ͹ͯͳ
ͺͻͰ͵͹

ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͷͰΌͪ
ͼͺ͹ͻͽͳͼͽͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͻͰͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪͽͳͬ΁ͳ
ͪ
ͷͰΌ;
Δͳ
ͷͪ
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
Ϳ;ͯͫͪͶͰͻͳ

;ͷͰͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͳ
͸ͪ;΂͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͼͽͳͺͰ͸ͯͳͼͽͳ
̓͹
ͶͰ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͯͰ΁Ͱ
;
ͳ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͼͽͬ͹
ͺͻͰͼͽͪΒ;

̾͵ͼ͵;ͻͲͳΒͰ

ͺͻͪͬͯͪ͸Ͱ
tͬͳ΃ͳͷ
΁ͳΓͰͬͳͷͪi
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
ͼ;

͹ͫ;΀ͬͪͽͪͶͰ
ͳ
ͼͽ;ͯͰ͸ͽͰ
͌Ͳ


͹͸ͳ΀
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
;
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪͷͪ
m
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒ;
ͽͻͪΒ͸͹
͸ͪͺ;
ͼͽͳͶͳ
ͼ
tͶͰͭͪͶ͸ͳͷ
ͺͪͺͳͻͳͷͪi
ͼͪ
ͱͰΓ͹ͷ
tͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͼͺ͹ΒͰ
ͼͪ
ͺ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΁͹ͷi

ͳ
ͭ͹ͻ΂ͳ͸͹ͷ
͵͹Β;
Ͳͪ
ͼ͹ͫ͹ͷ
͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪ
͸ͰͺͻͳΒͪͽͪ͸
ͻͪͼͽͪ͸ͪ͵
ͼͪ
ͯ͹ͷ͹ͬͳ
͸͹ͷ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸Ͱ
ͼͶ;ͱͫͰ
ͻͰͭͳͼͽͻ͹ͬͪͶͰ
ͼ;
ͳ

͹͸ͳ΀
͵͹Βͳ
ͫͰͱͰ
ͺͻͰ
͵͹
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͹͵͹

ͷͰͼͰ΂͸͹

;
͸ͪͯͳ
ͯͪ
ͳ΀
͸ͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯ;
΂Ͱ͵ͪ
͸Ͱ͵ͳ

͸͹ͬͳ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ
͇ͯ
tͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪi
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ

ͼͪ
ͺͪͼ͹΃Ͱͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪͶͳ

ͳͲ
ͲͰͷΓͰ

ͼͰ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͬͻͪͽͳͶ͹
̹Ͱ͵ͼͽͬͪ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͹Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪͬͪ͸ͪ

ͼ;
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒ͸Ͱͭͪͽͳͬ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹Βͪͬͪ
ͳ
ͼͷͪͽͻͪ͸ͪ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͬͻͼ͸͹ͷ
ͳͲͯͪΒ͹ͷ
̽ͻ;ͭͰ
͵ͪͽͰͭ͹ͻͳΒͰ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
͸ͳͼ;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪͶͰ
ͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͺ;ͽ͹
ͬͪͶͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
;
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ
͆ͪͼ;ͺͻ͹ͽ
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ͱͰΓͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪ
ΔͰͷ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
͵͹ͯ
ͼͬͳ΀
͵ͪͽͰͭ͹ͻͳΒͪ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
̸͸͵ͰͽͰ
ͳͲ
ͯͻ;
ͭͰ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ΀
ͺ͹͵ͪͲ;Β;
ͯͪ

ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
ͱͰͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͺ;ͽ;ΒͰ
;

͉͊͊͊

͍ͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵;

́͸ͯͳΒ;

;
̹;ͻͷ;

́ͽͪͶͳΒ;


̸͊̽

̻ͻ΂͵;

͑ͬͪΒ΁ͪͻͼ͵;

;
̾ͭͳͺͪͽ
͊ͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;
ͺͳͽͪ
Δ;
ͫͳ͹
tͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺ͹Ͳͳͽͳͬͪ͸
ͳͲͫ͹ͻi
ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸͹ͷ

ͺͻ͹ͺͪͭͪ͸ͯ͹ͷ
ͳ

ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͳͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͳͷͪ͹
͠͹ͼͳͺ
̹ͻ͹Ͳ

͋ͳͽ͹
͌
ͳͼͽ͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͼͽͬͪͻ͸͹ͼͽ
ΒͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͶͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪΒͺ͹ͱͰΓ͸ͳΒͪ
ͫͳͶͪ

 t̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻi
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͯ͸;
͹ͼ͹ͫ; 

ͪͷͰͻͳ΂͵ͪ
ͬͳͲͪ

͋͹͵͹ͷ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ΀ͽͰͬͰ
Ͳͪ
ͪͷͰͻͳ΂͵;
ͬͳͲ;

ͽͻͪͱͳͶ͹
ΒͰ
͹͵͹

ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͪ
ͷͰͼͰ΂͸͹
ͪ
ͬͰΕ

;͹΂Γͳͬ
ΒͰ
ͻͪͼͽ
͹ͯ


ͺ;ͽͪ

ͬͳͲͪ
ͷͰͼͰ΂͸͹

͇͸ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪͶͳ
ͼͽͳ΁ͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ͺͻͪ
ͬ͹
ͯͪ
tͳͲ͸Ͱͼ;
ͳͲ
ͲͰͷΓͰi

ͪ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͬ
͹ͯ
ͿͰͫͻ;ͪͻͪ


ͯ͹Ͷͪͻͪ
͊
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼ͹ͷ
ͶͳͫͰͻͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͺͪͼ͹΃͵͹ͭ
ͻͰͱͳͷͪ
ͫͻ͹Β
͹͸ͳ΀
͵͹Βͳ

ͺ;ͽ;ΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͬͰΕͪ͸
t̻Ͷͪͯi
Ͳͪ
ͺͪͼ͹΃Ͱͷ
ͳ
͹ͯͶͪͼ͵͹ͷ
;
ͳ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͼͽͬ͹

ͺ͹͵ͻͰΕͰ
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ
;
ͳ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͼͽͬ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͹͵͹

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ


m


m

͇ͽͬͪͻͪΔͰ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͺ͹͵ͻͰΕͰ
ͻͪͼͺͻͪͬͰ

͹
tͻͪͼͳͺͪΔ;
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪi
ͳ
ͳ͸ͳ΁ͳͻͪ
Ͳͪ΀ͽͰͬͰ
Ͳͪ
΃ͽͰͯΔ͹ͷ
́ͺͪ͵

ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲ;Β;
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;
ͯͻ;ͭ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
ͳ΀
ͯͬͪ
ͺ;ͽͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ

͸͹ͬ΁ͪ
ͽͻ͹΃ͳͶ͹
͸ͪ
tͼͶ;ͱͫͰ͸ͪi
͸Ͱͭ͹
͸ͪ
tͺͻͳͬͪͽ͸ͪi
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͈ͻͬͳ

t΃;΃͵ͪͬ΁ͳi
tͺͰͻͶ͹͸
͵͹΃;ΓͰi
tͷ͹͸ͽͭ͹ͷͰͻͳ
ͷͪ͸ͽͳͶͳi
ͿͪͻͷͰͻ͵Ͱ

ͭͻͪͷ͹Ϳ͹͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͶ͹΂Ͱ
ͫͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͼͽͳͱ͸ͳ
ͼͳͷͫ͹Ͷͳ
͸͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͳ

Ͳ͸ͪ͵
ͺ͹ͼͰͯ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͺͪͼ͹΃ͪ

͉ͪͲͶ͹Ͳͳ
ͼͶͪͫ͹ͭ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͺͻ͹ͳͼͽͳ΁ͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ͳͲ
Ͳͪͽͬ͹ͻͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ

ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
;ͼͺ͹ͻͰ͸͹ͭ
͵;ͻͼͪ
ͶͳͫͰͻͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͺͪͼ͹΃ͪ
͸ͳͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͽͪ͸ͯͪͻ
ͯͪ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
ͳͯͰ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ΀
ͫͪͻͳΒͰͻͪ
ͼͽͻͪ΀ͪ
͹ͯ
ͳ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͼͽͬͪ
ͳ

ͼ;ͷΔͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͬͪ͵͹
ͺͻͰ͵͹ͻͪ΂ͰΔͰ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
t͸ͪ
́ͼͽ͹͵i
ͳͶͳ
t͸ͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯi

ͼ͹ͫ͹ͷ
͸͹ͼͳ
́ͼ͵;ͼͽͬ͹
ͼͪ
ͼͺ͹Γ͸ͳͷ
ͼͬͰͽ͹ͷ
ΒͰ
ͭͰ͸ͰͻͪͶ͸͹
ͫͳͶ͹
ͼ͵ͻ͹ͷ
͸͹
͇ͽ;ͯͪ
ͳ
;ͭͪͼͶͪ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͪ
Ͳͪ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪΔͰͷ
͵Δͳͭͪ
͵ͪ͵ͬͰ
ͼ;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ

Ͳͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
́ͺͪ͵
ͫͳͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͼ
Ͷͪ͵͹Ε͹ͷ
ͫͻ͹ͯͳͶͳ

ͺͻͰ͵͹
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͪͿͻͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͳ
ͪͲͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
̀ͪ
Δͳ΀
ͼ;

ͺͳͼͪ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸ͳ
tͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳi
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵;
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͳΒ;












̓͹
ΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
͹
͵͹ͷͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͷ͹
͢Ͱͭ͹ͬ͹
ͳͷͰ
ΒͰ
͠͹ͼͳͺ
̹ͻ͹Ͳ
͋ͳ
ͽ͹
͇͸
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͿͰͼͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ
ͻͰͬ͹Ͷ;΁ͳ͹͸ͪͻ
͆ͪͶͪͲͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
΂ͰͶ;
ͺͪͻͽͳΒͰ

Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͪ
͵͹Βͪ

ͫͻ͹Βͳ

ͪ
ͬͰΕ

ͺͻͰ
͵͹

΂Ͷͪ͸͹ͬͪ
͈ͪͻͽͳΒͰ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
;
ͻͪͽ͸ͳͷ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪͷͪ
͹ͯ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͷͪͶͰ

ͳ
͹ͯ
̓͹ͷͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͻͪͼͺ;΃ͽͰ͸Ͱ
ͼͰ͵΁ͳΒͰ

ͳͲͻͪͼͶͪ
;
ͯͳͬͪ
ͼͽͪͶͪ

;Ͳ
ͫ͹͵
͈͊̓ ͫ

ͺ͹ͼͽͪͶͪ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͳ΀
Ϳͪ͵ͽ͹ͻͪ
;
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺ
ͼ͵͹ͷ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹͵ͻͰͽ;
͸ͪΒͯ͹ͼͶͰͯ͸ͳΒͳ
ͪ͸ͽͳͳͷͺͰͻͳΒͪͶͳͼͽͳ΂
͵ͳ
Ͱ͵ͼͺ͹͸Ͱ͸ͽ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯ;
ͻͰͬ͹Ͷ;΁ͳ͹͸ͪͻ͸ͳ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻ
Ͳͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
m

ͷ͹Εͪ͸
ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͼ͹ͫͪ͸
ͯͪ
΃ͳͻͳ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͳͯͰΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͳ΀
͸ͪͷͰΕͰ
́ͼͽ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹

͠͹ͼͳͺ
̹ͻ͹Ͳ
͋ͳͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳ͵
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͽ͹Βͳ
͸ͪ
΂ͰͶ;
̺ͶͪͯͰ
͵͹Βͪ
ͺͻͰͷͪ

Ͳͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
;ͱͳͬͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻ΃͵;

ͳͲͫ͹ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͽͰͶͪ
͵͹ͷͪ͸ͯ;
ΒͰ
ͬ͹Βͼ͵͹ͷ
͹ͯ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹

ͬ͹Β͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͯͻͱͳ
ͳ
͵͹͸ͽͻ͹Ͷͳ΃Ͱ
ͼͬͰ
ͺ͹Ͷ;
ͭͰ
ͬͶͪͼͽͳ
͌
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
ΒͰ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂ͪͻ
͹ͬͰ͸΂ͪ͸
ͼͶͪͬ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͫͰͯ͸ͳ͵ͪ
;
ͻͪͽ;

ͺͻ͹ͽͳͬ
Ϳͪ΃ͳͲͷͪ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͼ;ͺͻ͹ͽͼͽͪͬͳ͹
͊ͽͪΓͳ͸;
ͳͲ͸;
 ͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
̽ͳͷͳΕ

ΌͰ͸ͳ
tͺͻͳΒͪͽͰΓi
̀ͪͺͪͯͪ
;
΂ͳΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͪͬͰ
͸ͪͷͰͻͰ
ͼ;ͷΔͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳ͵

΂ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
;
ͼͬ͹ΒͰͬͻͼ͸͹Β
ͳͲ͹Ͷͪ΁ͳΒͳ
ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ

ͳ
ͼ;͵͹ͫͪ

ͼͪ
́͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͳͷ
ͫͳͻ͹͹ͷ
ͺ͹͵;΃ͪͬͪ
ͯͪ
ͺͻ͹͸ͪΌͰ
ͪͶͽͰͻ͸ͪͽͳͬ;
ͯ͹
ͽͪͯͪ΃Δ͹Β
ͼͺ͹Γ͸͹ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹Β
͹ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͳ

͋ͻͪͭͪΔͰ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͪͶͽͰͻ͸ͪͽͳͬ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͼͽͰ΂Ͱ͸ͪ
ͬͰ΃ͽͳ͸ͪ
tͷͪ
͸ͰͬͻͳͼͪΔͪi
;
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΁ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͆ͪ

͸Ͱ͵ͪ
͹ͯ
Δͳ΀
͠͹ͼͳͺ
̹ͻ͹Ͳ
͋ͳͽ͹
ΒͰ
͵ͻͰͽͪ͹
ͼ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷΓͰ͸ͳͷ

tͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪi
͋ͳ
tͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳi
ͫͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͺͻͳͶͪͭ͹ΌͰ͸ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͷ
tͺ͹ͼͶ;i

ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂ͪͻͪ
ͳ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵͹͸͵ͻͰͽ͸͹Β
ͷͳͼͳΒͳ
͵͹Β;
ͬͻ΃ͳ
Ͳ͸ͪΔͳͷͪ

͵͹Βͪ
ͼ;
ͷ;
͸Ͱ͹ͺ΀͹ͯ͸ͪ
;
ͼ;ͼͻͰͽͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͻͪͲͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͷͪ
ͼͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ

ͺͪͻͽ͸Ͱͻͳͷͪ
ͺͳͽͪΔͳͷͪ
͸ͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͷ͹ͻͪ
ͳͷͪͽͳ
ͬͪΓͪ͸Ͱ
͹ͯͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͰ
ͬͳͲͳ
Βͪͷͪ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱ͸ͪͷͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͳͷͪ
ͼͽͪͬ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
͹ͯͻͰΌ;Β;
ͳ
ͯͰͿͳ͸ͳ΃;

ΒͰͯ͸;
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵;
͋͹͵͹ͷ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
͸ͪ
ͬͶͪͼͽͳ
ͳ
͹ͫͪͬΓͪ͹
͸ͪΒͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͯͻ
ͱͪͬ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͺͪͻͽͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͯ;ͱ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͠͹ͼͳͺ
̹ͻ͹Ͳ
͋ͳͽ͹
ΒͰ
;΂ͳ͸ͳ͹

ͯͻͱͪͬ
͸ͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹
ͺͻͰ͵͹

ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
ͼ;ͼͻͰ͹
ͼͰ
ͼͪ
͹͵͹

ͺͻͰͯ
ͼͰͯ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
ͳ
ͬͶͪͯͪ
̹ͻ͹Ͳ͹ͬͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
;
ͼͬ͹Βͼͽͬ;
ͺͻͬ͹ͭ
΂͹ͬͰ͵ͪ

Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͻͰͬ͹Ͷ;΁ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹΂ͰͶͪ
ͼ;
ͬͰΕ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͳ΀
ͻͪͽ͸ͳ΀

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
͈;ͽ
;
́ͽͪͶͳΒ;
ͳ
ͼ;ͼͻͰͽͳ
ͼͪ
ͭͰ͸ͰͻͪͶ͹ͷ
̺ͳͶͼ͹͸͹ͷ
ͳ
ͫͻͳͽͪ͸
ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺͻͰͷͳΒͰͻ͹ͷ
͐Ͱͻ΂ͳͶ͹ͷ
m

;ͽͻͶͳ
ͼ;
ͺ;ͽ
ͼͺ͹ͻͪͲ;ͷ;

͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ

Β;͸ͪ

͠͹ͼͳͺ
̹ͻ͹Ͳ
͋ͳͽ͹
ͼ͵Ͷ͹ͺͳ͹
͸ͪ
̺ͳͼ;
ͼͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͰͯ
͸ͳ͵͹ͷ
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵Ͱ
ͬͶͪͯͰ
́ͬͪ͸͹ͷ
͑;ͫͪ΃ͳΕͰͷ
͇ͯͶͪͲͪ͵
;
̓ͻͪΒ͹ͬ;
ͳ

ͅ͹ͼ͵ͬ;
m

ͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͳͻͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͹ͷ͹ͭ;Εͳ
Ͷͳ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ
͸ͪͼͽ;ͺ

͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹͹ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯͳͶͪ΂͵Ͱ
ͬ͹Βͼ͵Ͱ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͳ

͏ͻͬͰ͸Ͱ
ͪͻͷͳΒͰ
;
͹ͺͰͻͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
Ͳͪ
͵͹͸ͪ΂͸͹
͹ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ΌͰΔͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
͊ͻ
ͫͳΒͰ
ͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
;
͉͊͊͊
m
m


ͻͰͲ;ͶͽͳͻͪͶͪ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͽͺͳͼͳͬͪΔͰͷ
͌ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͪ
͹
ͺͻͳΒͪͽͰΓͼͽͬ;
;ͲͪΒͪͷ͸͹Β

ͺ͹ͷ͹Εͳ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͻͪͽ͸͹Β
ͼͪͻͪͯΔͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ͹
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;
ͼͺ͹Γ
͸͹ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
͹ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͍͉͆͠
;
ͺͻͬͳͷ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͻͪͽ͸ͳͷ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪͷͪ

ͳ
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΔ;
ͫͶͳͼ͵ͳ΀
ͷͰΌ;ͺͪͻͽͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳ
ͷͰΌ;ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳ΀
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͪ

͋ͳ΀
ͺͻͬͳ΀
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͻͪͽ͸ͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
͠͹ͼͳͺ
̹ͻ͹Ͳ
͋ͳͽ͹
ΒͰ
tͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪ͹i
ͳ
ͺ͹

̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
͆͹ͬͰͷͫͻͪ

ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹
ΒͰ
̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵;
ͳ
ͼͪ
̻Ͱ͹ͻͭͳ
̽ͳͷͳͽͻ͹
ͬͳͷ
ͬͰͻͳͿͳ͵͹ͬͪ͹
͸ͪ΁ͻͽ
͌ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͪ
͹
ͺͻͳΒͪͽͰΓͼͽͬ;
;ͲͪΒͪͷ͸͹Β
ͺ͹ͷ͹Εͳ

ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͻͪͽ͸͹Β
ͼͪͻͪͯΔͳ
̽Ͱ΁Ͱͷͫͻͪ

͋ͳͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪ͹
;
ͪͅΌͪͻͼ͵;

ͳ
͉;ͷ;͸ͳΒ;
̽͹
ͳͲͫͳΒͪΔͪ
ͼ;͵͹ͫͪ
ͼͪ
́͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͳͷ
ͫͳͻ͹͹ͷ
͵͹Βͳ

ΒͰ
͸ͪ
͸Ͱ͵͹
ͬͻͰͷͰ
͹ͯͶ͹ͱͳ͹
͋ͳͽ͹ͬͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͲͰͷΓͰ

t͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͯͰͷ͹͵ͻͪͽͳΒͰi
͈͹Γͼ͵;
ͳ
͐Ͱ΀͹ͼͶ͹ͬͪ΂͵;
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ

ΒͰ
͠͹ͼͳͺ
̹ͻ͹Ͳ
͋ͳͽ͹
ͺ͹͸͹ͬ͹
t͹ͫͳͶͪͲͳ͹i
ͽͰ͵
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸͹ͷ

͋ͪͯͪ
ͺ;
ͽ;ΒͰ
;
͋;ͻͼ͵;
m

ͳ
̻ͻ΂͵;
m

͋ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͯ͸͹
ͼͪ
͹͸ͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯ;ͲͰ͹
;
́͸ͯͳΒ;
ͳ
̹;ͻͷ;

 t̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻi
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͯ͸;
͹ͼ͹ͫ; 

m

;
͹ͼ͸͹ͬͳ
ͼ;
tͼͺ͹Γ͸͹ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͺͻͰͶ͹ͷͪi
͵͹
Βͳ
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ
ͯ;ͭͳ
͸ͳͲ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
͹ͯͻͰͯͳ͹
ͼͺ͹Γ͸͹ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵;
͹ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒ;

͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ












͈͹ͼͶͰ
ͼ;͵͹ͫͪ
ͼͪ
́͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͳͷ
ͫͳͻ͹͹ͷ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
ͼ;
ͽͻͰ
ͫͪͶͳ
t͸͹ͬͳ
ͺͻͳΒͪͽͰΓͳi
͈ͻͳͽͳͼͪ͵
͉͊͊͊ͪ
ͳ
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪ
Γͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
m
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͽͳ͹
ͯͪ
ͺͻͰͻͪͼͽͰ
;
͹ͽͬ͹ͻͰ͸ͳ

͹ͻ;ͱͪ͸ͳ
ͼ;͵͹ͫ
;΂ͳ͸ͳ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
Ͳͪ
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͰ
ͼͪͻͪͯΔͪ

ͼͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺͪΔͰ
ͺͻ͹ͭͻͪͷ;
ͬ͹Β͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͷ͹Εͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
͹͸
ͯͪͬͪ͹

ͺ͹ͼͽͪ͸Ͱ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͪ
ͪͶͽͰͻ͸ͪͽͳͬͪ
̽͹ͯͪͽ͸ͳ
ͷ͹ͽͳͬͳ
Ͳͪ
ͼͪͻͪͯΔ;
͵ͻͳͶͳ
ͼ;

ͼͰ
;
͵ͻͪΒΔͰ
͸ͰͲͪͬͳͯ͸͹Β
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵͹Β
ͳ
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶ͸͹Β
ͼͳͽ;ͪ΁ͳΒͳ
ͺͻ͹;Ͳͻ͹
͵͹ͬͪ͸͹Β
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵͹ͷ
ͫͶ͹͵ͪͯ͹ͷ
͸Ͱͻ͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪͷͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͷ
ͳͲͯͬͪ
ΒͪΔͳͷͪ
Ͳͪ
͸ͪ͹ͻ;ͱͪΔͰ
ͳ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͬ͹Βͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͺ΃ͽ͹Β
͸Ͱͷͪ΃ͽͳ͸ͳ

ͅ͹ͽͳͬͳ
̀ͪͺͪͯͪ
ͽͰͷͰΓͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱ͸ͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͽͻͪͽͰ΃͵ͪ
ͺ͹Ͳͳ΁ͳ
Βͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
t͹ͯ
ͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ͸͹ͭ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ
Ͳͪ
͹ͯͫͻͪ͸;
ͼͰͬͰͻ͸͹ͪͽͶͪ͸ͽͼ͵͹ͭ

ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪi
ͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͺͻͰͷ͸͹ͼͽ
ͽͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͯͪ
ͫͻͪ͸ͳ
ͼͰͫͰ
t͹ͯ
ͬͳͽͪͶ͸͹ͭ
Ͳ͸ͪ
΂ͪΒͪͲͪ
ͫͰͲͫͰͯ͸͹ͼͽ
̸͊̽i
ͅ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
ͺͻ͹ͯ͹ͻͪ
;
ͼͬͰͽ
ͳͲͪ
tͭͬ͹ͲͯͰ͸Ͱ

ͲͪͬͰͼͰi
ͳ
;ͬͰͻͰΔͰ
ͿͰͫͻ;ͪͻ


ͯͪ
ͫͳ
t;ͯͪͻi
͸ͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒ;
;ͭͻ͹
Ͳͳ͹
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͳ
ͷͳͻ
ͳ
ͳͲͪͲͬͪ͹
ͼ;͵͹ͫ
;
͵͹ͷͰ
̸͊̽
͸Ͱ
ͫͳ
ͷ͹ͭͶͰ
͹ͼͽͪͽͳ
ͺ͹

ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ
ͺͻͰͼ;ͯ͸͹
ͼ;
;ͽͳ΁ͪͶͳ
ͯͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͽ͹ͭͪ
΃ͽ͹
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳ͹

ͼͺͻͰͷͪ͸
ͯͪ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ
ͷͳ΃ΓͰΔͰ
͹
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͻͰͱͳͷ;
;
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪ
ͬͳΒͳ
ͺ͹ͯͻͱͳ
͋ͳͽͪ
;
΀ͻͪ͸ͳ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵͹Β
ͺ͹ͷ͹Εͳ
͸ͪ͹ͻ;ͱͪΔ;
͌
ͷ͹ͭ;
ΕͰͷ
͵͹͸Ϳͻ͹͸ͽͳͻͪΔ;
ͼͪ
tͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͶͪͭͰͻ͹ͷi
ͻͪ΂;͸ͪͶ͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪ


ͯͳͬͳͲͳΒͰ
ͳ
͹͵͹

ͬ͹Β͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͳͷͪͶͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
́
ͯ͹͵

ΒͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
Ͳͪ΀ͽͰͬͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
΃ͳͻ;
ͬ͹Β͸;
ͺ͹ͷ͹Ε
ͳ
ͭͪͻͪ͸΁ͳΒͰ
̀ͪͺͪͯͪ
ͯͪ

ΕͰ
;
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ;
ͪͭͻͰͼͳΒͰ
͉͊͊͊ͪ
ͺͻͳͽͰΕͳ
;
ͺ͹ͷ͹Ε
̸͊̽
ͼ;
ͳ͸ͼͳͼͽͳͻͪ
ͶͰ
͸ͪ
΃ͽ͹
ͽͰ΃ΔͰͷ
ͬͰͲͳͬͪΔ;
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
Ͳͪ
͹ͯͫͻͪͷͫͰ͸;
ͼͽͻͪͽͰͭͳΒ;

̸͇͆͋ͪ
ͳ
ΔͰ͸͹
;͵Γ;΂ͳͬͪΔͰ
;
͹ͺͰͻͪͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͰ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͪͽͶͪ͸ͽͼ͵Ͱ

ͬ͹Β͸Ͱ
ͭͻ;ͺͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͉ͪͲͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
ͬ͹ΌͰ͸ͳ
ͼͪ
ͭͰ͸ͰͻͪͶ͹ͷ
͋͹ͷͪͼ͹ͷ
͎Ͱ͸ͯͳΒͰͷ

͋ͻͳͺͪͻͽͳͽ͸͹Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵ͪ
͵͹͸ͿͰͻͰ͸΁ͳΒͪ
͸͹ͬͰͷͫͪͻ


ͺ͹͵ͪͲͪ
Ͷͳ
ͼ;
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͯͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯ
ͺͻ͹΁ͰΔ;ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͻͪͽ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͳͷͪͽͳ

ͼͪͷ͹
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶ͸Ͱ
͹͵ͬͳͻͰ
ͳ
ͯͪ
͹ͽ;ͯͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͺͻͰͷͪ͸
ͯͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͬͰ͸ͳ΃Ͱ
;

ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ;
͸ͪͺͪͯͪ
͸ͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒ;
̺ͰͲͳͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͪ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
ͳ
ͻͰ
ͭͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͪ
ͼͪͻͪͯΔͪ
ͼͪ
̻ͻ΂͵͹ͷ
ͳ
͋;ͻͼ͵͹ͷ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
͹ͯ

ͽ͹ͭ
ͽͻͰ͸;ͽ͵ͪ
Ͳͪ
͠͹ͼͳͺͪ
̹ͻ͹Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸͹
;͵Γ;΂ͳͬͪΔͰ
;
̸͇͆͋
ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪΔͰ
ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸Ͱ
ͯͳͼͽͪ͸΁Ͱ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͽ͹ͷ
ͬ͹Β͸͹ͷ
ͼͪͬͰͲ;
͆Ͱͼ;ͷΔͳͬ͹
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͷ͹ͽͳͬͳ
ͼͪͻͪͯΔͰ
ͫͳͶͳ
;ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͷͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ

́ͺͪ͵
ͫͳͶ͹
͵ͪ͵͹
ͫͳͶ͹
;
ͯͻ;ͭ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;

 ͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
̽ͳͷͳΕ

ΒͰ
Βͪͼ͸͹
Ϳ͹ͻͷ;Ͷͳͼͪ͸
ͼͽͪͬ
ͯͪ
;
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ;
͸ͪͺͪͯͪ
͉͊͊͊ͪ
͸ͪ
͸Ͱ͵;
tͲͪ
ͺͪͯ͸;i
ͲͰͷΓ;
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
͹ͼͽͪͽͳ
tͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹
ͺ͹
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳi

͊ͬͻͼͽͪͬͪΔͰ
t;Ͳ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺ;i
ͺͻͪͬͯͪ͸͹
ΒͰ
tͷ͹ͻͪͶ͸͹ͷ
͹ͫͪͬͰͲ͹ͷi
ͲͰͷΓͰ

͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͺͻͰͯͰͶͳͶͪ
Ͳͪ
ͷͳͻ
ͺͻ͹ͽͳͬ
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͭ
ͪͭͻͰͼͳͬ͸͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͷͰ΃ͪΔͪ

;
;͸;ͽͻͪ΃ΔͰ
ͺ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
ͳͲͭͻͪΌͳͬͪΔͰ
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹ͼ;ͼͰͯͼ͵ͳ΀

͹ͯ͸͹ͼͪ
ͷͳͻ͹Γ;ͫͳͬ;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵;
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵;
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸;
ͼͪͻͪͯΔ;
͸ͪ

ͫͪͲͳ
ͻͪͬ͸͹ͺͻͪͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪΔͪ
͈ͻͳ
ͽ͹ͷ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
͸ͪͭͶͪ
΃ͪͬͪ͸͹
ͯͪ
ͺͻͳ΀ͬͪͽͪΔͰ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͬ͹Β͸Ͱ
ͳ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͷ͹Εͳ
;
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ;

͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
͸Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͳ
ͺͻͳͼͽͪΒͪΔͰ
͸ͪ
ͽ;ΌͰ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
;ͼͶ͹ͬͰ
ͳ
͹ͭͻͪ
͸ͳ΂ͪͬͪΔͰ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵Ͱ
͸ͰͲͪͬͳͼ͸͹ͼͽͳ
́ͺͪ͵
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹
ͼͷͻ
ͽͳ
͠͹ͼͳͿͪ
̺ͳͼͪͻΒ͹͸͹ͬͳ΂ͪ
͊ͽͪΓͳ͸ͪ
͸Ͱ͵ͻͳͽͳ΂͸͹ͼͽ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯ;
ͳ

͹΃ͽͻͪ
͹ͼ;ͯͪ
tͼ͹ͬΒͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
΀ͰͭͰͷ͹͸ͳͲͷͪi
ͺ͹͵ͪͲͪͽͰΓ
ͼ;
ͯͪ
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸
ͼ͵ͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵ͪ
Ͱ͵ͬͳͯͳͼͽͪ͸΁Ͱ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͼ;΂ͰΓͰ͸ͳͷ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͪͷͪ
;
t΀Ͷͪͯ͸͹ͷ

ͻͪͽ;i
Β͹΃
͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪͶͪ
͊ͽͪΓͳ͸͹ͬͪ
ͼͷͻͽ
ͺ͹ͫ;ͯͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͯ;
ͳ
ͳͲ͸ͰͯͻͳͶͪ
ͼͽͻͪ΀
͹ͯ
ͺ͹ͷͳ
ͻͰΔͪ
͋ͪ
ͯͬͪ
͹ͼͰΕͪΔͪ
ͳͲͪͲͬͪͶͪ
ͼ;
tͯͻͪͷͪͽͳ΂͸;
͸ͪͺͰͽ͹ͼͽi
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͫ;
ͲͰͶͪ
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͰ

ͷͪͻͽͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̸Ͷͳ
͊ͽͪΓͳ͸͹ͬͪ

ͼͷͻͽ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͷ͹ͭͶͪ
ͯͪ
ͳͲͷͳͻͳ
ͯͬͰ
ͺ͹
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
΂Ͱͷ;
ͼ;ͺͻ͹ͽ͸Ͱ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺ΁ͳ
ΒͰ
͹
ͼͪͻͪͯΔͳ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺͪͻͽͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
͌

ͽͰͷͰΓ;
ͼͶ͹ͱͰ͸ͳ΀
ͯͳ͸ͪͷͳ΂͸ͳ΀
ͳ
ͳ͸΁ͳͯͰ͸ͽ͸ͳ΀
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͪ
ͼͽͪΒͪͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͺͳ
ͽͪΔͰ
ͯͪ
Ͷͳ
ΕͰ
ͼͪͻͪͯΔͪ
ͽͰΕͳ
;
͹͵ͬͳͻ;
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
tͶͪͭͰͻͪi
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪ

ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͳͯͰΒ͸͹ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͶͪͽͿ͹ͻͷͰ
ͳͶͳ
ͺͪ͵
ͼͪͷ͹ͼͽͪͶ͸͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͽ;ͺͪ

ͼ;ͬͰͻͰ͸ͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
ͳ
ͻͰͬ͹Ͷ;΁ͳ͹͸ͪͻ͸ͳ΀
ͼ͸ͪͭͪ
;
ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;
ͼͪ
ͬͶͪͼͽͳͽͳͷ

ͼͽͻͪͽͰ΃͵ͳͷ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱ͸ͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͳͷͪ
͍ͶͰ͵ͼͳͫͳͶ͸ͳΒ;
ͼͺ͹Γ͸;
ͺ͹
Ͷͳͽͳ͵;
͉͊͊͊ͪ
;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͻͰ΂͸ͳ͵;
ͯͰͿͳ͸ͳͼͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ͺ͹Βͷ͹ͬͳ
tͺ͹
ͺ;΃ͽͪΔͰ
͸ͪͺͰͽ͹ͼͽͳi
ͳ
tͷͳͻ͹Γ;ͫͳͬͪ
͵͹ͰͭͲͳͼͽͰ͸΁ͳΒͪ i
ͪ
;
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽ
ͼ͵͹Β
ͺͻͪ͵ͼͳ
ͬͰΕͪ
ͼͺ͹ͼ͹ͫ͸͹ͼͽ
Ͳͪ
ͳ͸ͳ΁ͳΒͪͽͳͬ;
ͺͻͰͭ͹ͬͪͻͪΔͰ
΃ͳͻͰΔͰ

ͷͰΌ;͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
͵͹͸ͽͪ͵ͪͽͪ
t͆͹ͬͳ
͵;ͻͼi
ͼͺ͹Γ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵Ͱ
;
ͼ;΃ͽͳ
͸ͳ
͸ͳΒͰ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͳ͹
ͺ͹ͺ;΃ͽͪΔͰ
ͳ
ͼͺͻͰͷ͸͹ͼͽ
͸ͪ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
;ͼͽ;ͺ͵Ͱ

ͬͰΕ
ͳͼͽͻͪΒͪͬͪΔͰ
͸ͪ
ͿͶͰ͵ͼͳͫͳͶ͸ͳΒͰͷ
ͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺ;
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͼ͹ͬΒͰͽͼ͵;

ͼͺ͹Γ͸;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵;
΂ͳ͸ͳ͹
ͷͪΔͰ
ͯͰͿͪ͸Ͳͳͬ͸͹ͷ
t̓ͻͳͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͻͰͬͳͲͳΒͪi

ͼͺ͹Γ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵Ͱ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪͶͪ
ͯͪ
;
ͳͷͰ
tͺ͹ͺ;΃ͽͪΔͪ
͸ͪͺͰͽ͹
ͼͽͳi
ͫ;ͯͰ
ͯ͹ͺ;΃ͽͰ͸ͪ
ͯͰͲͳ͸ͽͰͭͻͪ΁ͳΒͪ
tͶͪͭͰͻͪi
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͲͰ
ͷͪΓͪ
ͬͰΕ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͺͻ͹ͽͳͬ
ͻͪ΂;͸ͪͶͪ
ͼ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳͷ
ͯͪΓͳͷ
;΂ͬͻ΃ΕͳͬͪΔͰͷ

͉ͰͿ͹ͻͷͼ͵ͳ
ͯͰ͹
ͼ͹ͬΒͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻ;͵͹ͬ͹ͯͼͽͬͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
ͷͳ΃ΓͰΔͪ
ͯͪ
͹΂;ͬͪΔͰ

tͶͪͭͰͻͪi
ͳ
ͼ͹ͬΒͰͽͼ͵ͪ
ͯ͹ͷͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
;
ΔͰͷ;
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͫͳͽͳ
Ͷͪ͵΃Ͱ
͹ͼͽͬͪͻͰ
͸ͳ
;͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͺͳͽͪΔͰ
ͺ͹͸͹ͬ͸͹ͭ
ͺͻͳͬͶͪ΂ͰΔͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͫ;ͯͰ
tͺ͹Ͳͳ
ͽͳͬ͸͹
ͻͰ΃Ͱ͸͹i
͊;ͯͪͻͳ
͵͹͸ͲͰͻͬͪͽͳͬ͸ͳ΀
ͼͽͪΓͳ͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;
ͻͪ
ͳ
ͶͳͫͰͻͪͶ͸ͳΒͰͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͬ͹Όͼͽͬͪ
͉͊͊͊
͸ͪΒͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ͸ͳΒͰ
ͼ;

 t̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻi
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͯ͸;
͹ͼ͹ͫ; 

;ͽͳ΁ͪͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ

ͳ
ͺͻͬͳ΀
ͷͰͼͰ΁ͳ

͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
Ͳͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸ͳ΀

͵͹͸ͽͪ͵ͪͽͪ
ͼͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳͷ
ͳ
ͺͪͻͽͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
ͬͻ΀͹ͷ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
͠͹ͼͳͺͪ
̹ͻ͹Ͳͪ
͋ͳͽͪ
ΒͰ
͸Ͱͼ;ͷΔͳͬ͹
͹ͺͽͰͻͰΕͳͬͪͶͪ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͪ
ͼͪ
ͻͪͯΔͪ
ͼͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯ͹ͷ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͺ;͸ͪ
ͳͼ͵;΃ͰΔͪ
͸Ͱͺ͹ͬͰͻͰΔͪ
ͼ;ͷΔͳ

ͺͻͳͼͷ͹ͽͻͰ
ͺͻͰͳͼͺͳͽͳͬͪΔͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯ͸ͳ
ͼͪͬͰͲ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͼ;
ͭͪ
ͺͻͳͷ͹ͻͪͬͪͶͳ

ͯͪ
;
ͳ͸ͬͰͼͽͳ΁ͳ͹͸͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΁ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ
ͻͪ΂;͸ͪ
͹
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵͹Β
͹ͺͻͪͬͯͪ͸͹
ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͰͿͳ͵ͪͼ͸͹ͼͽͳ
;ͶͪͭͪΔͪ
ͪ
͸Ͱ
͹
Ͳͪͯ͹ͬ͹ΓͰΔ;
ͬ͹Β͸͹ͼͽͻͪͽͰ΃͵ͳ΀

ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͳ΀
΁ͳΓͰͬͪ
̀ͪ΀ͽͰͬͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͳͻͪ
ΔͰ
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͰ
͹ͯ
ͬ͹Β͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͽͰ΃͵Ͱ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͰ
͸ͪ
Ͷͪ͵;

͹ͯ;ͼͽͪΒͪΔͰ
͹ͯ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺͽͪ
tͼͪͷ͹ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͰi
ͺͻͰ͹ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒ;

͸ͪ
ͳͲͬ͹Ͳ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͽͻͱͳ΃͸ͳ
ͷ͹ͯͰͶ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯΔ;
ͺ͹ͽͻ͹΃͸ͳ΀
ͯ͹ͫͪͻͪ
ͳ

΀ͻͪ͸Ͱ
͋ͻͪͱͳͶͳ
ͼ;
;ͻͪͬ͸͹ͽͰͱͰΔͰ
ͺͶͪͽ͸͹ͭ
ͫͳͶͪ͸ͼͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
͹ͯ;
ͼͽͪΒͪΔͰ
͹ͯ
ͺͻͰͪͷͫͳ΁ͳ͹Ͳ͸͹ͭ
ͳ͸ͬͰͼͽͳ΁ͳ͹͸͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹ͭͻͪͷͪ
͸ͪͺ;΃ͽͪΔͰ

͵͹ͶͰ͵ͽͳͬͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͺͻͳ͸;ͯ͸͹ͭ
͹ͽ͵;ͺͪ
ͼͷͪΔͳͬͪΔͰ
;ͬ͹Ͳͪ
͹ͺͻͰͷͰ

͹ͫͪͬͰͲ͸͹ͼͽ
͵͹͸ͼ;Ͷͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͼͪ
ͬͶͪͯͪͷͪ
̸͊̽
ͳ
̺ͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
̹ͻͳͽͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͳ
Ͷͳ͵͹ͷ
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͭ
ͫ;ͯ;ΕͰͭ
Ͳͪͯ;ͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸ͪ
ͻͰͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͵ͻͰͯͳͽͪ

ͺ͹ͼͽͰͺͰ͸͹
ͳ͸ͽͰͭͻͳͼͪΔͰ
;
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽͰ
͋ͳͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
ͼͬͰͼͽͪ͸
ͯͪ

ΒͰ
ͼͺͻͰͷ͸͹ͼͽ
̀ͪͺͪͯͪ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͷ͹ͭ͸Ͱ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
;ͼͶ͹ͬΓͰ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͰͷ

ͪͷͰͻͳ΂͵͹ͼ͹ͬΒͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͬ͹Β͸͹ͭ
ͳ
ͳͯͰ͹Ͷ͹΃͵͹ͭ
ͻͳͬͪͶͼͽͬͪ
ͯ͹ͷͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ

͉͊͊͊ͪ
;
ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
ͼͽͻͪ΀͹ͷ
͹ͯ
ͼ͹ͬΒͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹ͯ͹ͻͪ
͸ͪ
̀ͪ
ͺͪͯ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫ͹ͷ
Ͳͪ
tͼ;ͱͪͬͪΔͰi
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;ΕͰͭ
ͼ͹ͬΒͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
;ͽͳ΁ͪΒͪ

;ͬͰͻͰΔͰͷ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͺͼͽͪ͸ͪ͵
ͳ
͸ͪͺͻͰͯ͹ͬͪΔͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͼͳͷͫ͹Ͷ
͸Ͱ;ͼͺͰ
΀ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪͬͪ
tͼ͹ͬΒͰͽͼ͵ͳ
ͳͷͺͰͻͳΒͪͶͳͲͪͷi
̀͸ͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪ
ͬͳΒͪ
Ͳͪ΀ͬͪΓ;Β;Εͳ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒ;
ͳ
ͬ͹Β͸͹Β
ͼ͸ͪͲͳ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͯͪ

͹ͯͳͭͻͪ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸;
;Ͷ͹ͭ;
;
͹Βͪ΂ͪͬͪΔ;
Β;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹ͭ
͵ͻͳͶͪ
̸͇͆͋
ͳ
ͻͰͪ
ͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͼͽͻͪͽͰͭͳΒͰ
tͺͰͻͳͿͰͻ͸Ͱ
͹ͯͫͻͪ͸Ͱi
ͪͶͳ
ͼͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
ͺͶͪ
΃ͳ͹
tͽͰͼ͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͬͰͲͳͬͪΔͪi
ͳ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͭ
;΂Ͱ΃Εͪ
;
͹ͺͰͻͪͽͳͬ͸ͳͷ
ͺͶͪ
͸͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͳ
͹ͯͫͻͪͷͫͰ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͪͷͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯͪ
͈ͻ͹΁Ͱ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͻͪͽͰ΃͵ͳ΀

ͼͽͻ;΂Δͪ͵ͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
tͷͻͽͬͪ
Ͳ͹͸ͪi
͹ͯ
ͼͽͻͪͽͰ΃͵͹ͭ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ
Ͳͪ

̀ͪͺͪͯ
͵͹Β;
ͽͻͰͫͪ
tͺ͹͵ͻͳͽͳi
ͼ͸ͪͭͪͷͪ
̸͇͆͋ͪ
΂ͳ͸ͳͶͰ
ͼ;
ͭͪ
͸Ͱͼͺ͹
͵͹Β͸ͳͷ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
͹ͷ͹ͭ;ΕͪͬͪͶͰ
ͯͪ
tͳͲͬͶͪ΂ͳi
͵͹͸͵ͻͰͽ͸;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵;
Ͱ͵͹
͸͹ͷͼ͵;
ͳ
ͬ͹Β͸;
ͺ͹ͷ͹Ε
̹ͻͳ͸;͹
ͭͪ
ΒͰ
͸Ͱͯͬ͹ͼͷͳͼͶͰ͸
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͼͽͪͬ

ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͻͰ΃ͰΔͰ
ͽͻ΃Εͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
͵ͻͳͲͰ
tͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹
ͳ
ͷ͹ͻͪͶ͸͹
ͺͳͽͪΔͰ
̀ͪͺͪ
ͯͪi
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷ
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͪΒͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ͸ͳΒͰ
ͲͪͯͳͻͰ
;
ͼͿͰͻ;
͹ͯͫͻͪͷͫͰ͸Ͱ
ͷ͹Εͳ

̀ͪͺͪͯͪ
ͪ
͹ͯͼ;ͼͽͬ͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͬ͹ΓͰ
ͯͪ
t͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳͷ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͪͷͪ

ͺͶͪΕͪ
ͺͪͻͽ͸Ͱͻͼͽͬ͹
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸ͳ΀
ͼͳͶͪi
͸ͪͭ͹͸ͳͶ͹
ͭͪ
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͭͻ΂Ͱͬͳͽ͹
ͽͻͪ
ͭͪ
Ͳͪ
tͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͳͲͶͪͲ͹ͷi
̾͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͬ͹Β͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͷ͹Ε
͵͹Β;
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͷͪ͹
ͳ

ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͽ͹ͭͪ
΃ͽ͹
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
;ͼͶ͹ͬΓͰ͸ͪ
t͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸ͳͷ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
͵͹͸
΁ͰͼͳΒͪͷͪi
ͺ͹ͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͶͳͫͰͻͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒ;
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͳΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸;

 ͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
̽ͳͷͳΕ

͵͹͸΁Ͱͺͽͪ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸͹ͭ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Βͪ
ͺͻͰ͹ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͰ

ͺͰ͸͹
ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͪͬͪΔͰ
ͳ
;͵Γ;΂ͳͬͪΔͰ
;
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸ͳ
ͬ͹Β͸ͳ
ͼͪͬͰͲ
͸;ͱ͸;

ͯͰͷ͹͵ͻͪͽͳͲͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͪ
ͼͷͪΔͳͬͪΔͰ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
;Ͷ͹ͭͰ
͊̓͠
͸Ͱͷͳ
͸͹ͬ͸͹
͸ͪͺ;΃ͽͪΔͰ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΀
͸ͪ΂ͰͶͪ
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶͳͲͷͪ
̸ͶͽͰͻ͸ͪͽͳͬͪ
ͼͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
m
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͪͲͳͻͪͶͪ
;
ͻͰͭͳ͹
͸ͪͶ͸͹Β
ͼͪͻͪͯΔͳ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͬͰͲͳͬͪΔ;

ͼͪ
̻ͻ΂͵͹ͷ
ͳ
͋;ͻͼ͵͹ͷ

͹ͯ

΂Ͷͪ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
̸͇͆͋
ͺͪ͵ͽͪ

͋͹
ΒͰ
;
ͬͳΌͰΔͳͷͪ
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹
ͬͰ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸͹ͺͪͻͽͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͬͻ΀ͪ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͳͶ͹
ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͳͽͳ
ͼͰ
̀ͪͺͪͯ;

Ͳͪͯͻͱͪͽͳ
ͼͬ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͼͳͼͽͰͷ
͹ͼͽͪͽͳ
ͬͰͻͪ͸
͹͸͹ͷͰ
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
Β;ͭ͹
ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͳ
͸ͪͲͳͬͪͶͳ
tͳͲͬ͹ͻ͸ͳ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͲͪͷi
͈ͻͰͶ͹ͷ͸ͳ
΁;
;
ͽͳͷ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳͷͪ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͳ
͸Ͱ;ͼͺͰͶͳ
ͺͻͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ

Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͬ͹Β͸͹ͭ
ͬͻ΀ͪ
ͼͪ
ͭͰ͸ͰͻͪͶ͹ͷ
͋͹ͷͪͼ͹ͷ
͎ͪ͸ͯͳΒͰͷ
m


ͳ
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΔͰ
ͯͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͺͻͰͷͪ͸
ͯͪ
;
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ;
ͼ͹ͬΒͰͽͼ͵Ͱ

ͳ͸ͽͰͻͬͰ͸΁ͳΒͰ
ͫͰͲͻͰͲͰͻͬ͸͹
ͳ
ͺ;͸ͳͷ
͵ͪͺͪ΁ͳͽͰͽ͹ͷ
ͫͻͪ͸ͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒ;

;͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺͳ
̸͇͆͋
ͺͪ͵ͽ;
̀ͪͽ͹
ͼ;
;ͷͰͼͽ͹
ͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ͸ͳ΀
ͬͰͲͪ

ͼͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯ͹ͷ
ͺͪͻͽ͸Ͱͻͳ
͸ͪ͵͹͸
ͽ͹ͭͪ
ͺ͹ͽͻͪͱͰ͸ͳ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
͆͹ͬͳ
ͬͳͯ

ͼͪͻͪͯΔͰ
ͼͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯ͹ͷ
ͳͼ͵ͪͲͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ͳ͸ͽͰ͸Ͳͳͬͳͻͪ͸ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͳ
ͬ͹Β͸ͳ

ͺͻͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
ͼͪ
̻ͻ΂͵͹ͷ
ͳ
͋;ͻͼ͵͹ͷ
͇ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͪ
͹ͺͪͼ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
ͼͽͻͪ΀
͹ͯ

ͼ͹ͬΒͰͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͬ͹Β͸Ͱ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͬͰ͸΁ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͳͼͳͶͳ͹
ΒͰ
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͺͪͻͽͳΒͼ͵ͳ

ͬͻ΀
͸ͪ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸;
ͼͪͻͪͯΔ;
ͼͪ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
ͼ;ͺͻ͹ͽ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
ͼ;ͺͻ͹ͽͼͽͪͬΓͰ
͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͼͳͼͽͰͷͪ
͌ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ
͹
ͺͻͳΒͪͽͰΓͼͽͬ;
ͳ
ͼͪͻͪͯΔͳ
͠;ͭ͹
ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ
͋;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͽͺͳͼͪ͸
ΒͰ

ͿͰͫͻ;ͪͻͪ

̓ͪ͵͹
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ


ͳ
ͺͻͬͳ΀
ͷͰͼͰ΁ͳ

ͅ͹ͼ͵ͬͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͳͼ͵ͪͲͳͬͪͶͪ
ͬ͹Γ;
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͷͳͻͰ
ΔͰͷ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
͋ͳͽ͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸ͳ͹
Β͹΃

ΒͰͯͪ͸
͵͹ͻͪ͵
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
;
ͺ͹ͬͰͲͳͬͪΔ;
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼͪͬͰͲ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͈͹͵;΃ͪΒ
ͯͪ

ͫ;ͯͰ

ͳͲͫͰͭ͸;ͽ
Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͶ͸ͳ
;ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ͸ͳ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ
ͼͪ
̸͇͆͋
ͺͪ͵ͽ͹ͷ
ͪͶͳ

ͳͼͽ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ
΂ͬͻ΃Εͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͳ
ͬ͹Β͸ͳ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳ
ͼͪ

ΔͰ͸ͳͷ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
΂Ͷͪ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͺ͹͵ͻͰ͸;Ͷͳ
ͼ;
͠͹ͼͳͺͪ
̹ͻ͹Ͳͪ
͋ͳͽͪ
͵ͪ

́ͼͽͪͷͫ;Ͷ;
ͳ
̸ͽͳ͸ͳ
͈ͻͳͺͻͰͷͪΒ;Εͳ
ͼͰ
Ͳͪ
ͽͪ
ͬͪͱ͸ͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹
ͬͪΔͪ
͠͹ͼͳͺ
̹ͻ͹Ͳ
͋ͳͽ͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͻͪͼͺ͹ͶͪͭͪΔ;
ͳͷͪ͹
ͼͬ͹ΒͰͬͻͼ͸Ͱ
tͬ͹ͯͳ΂Ͱi

͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵;
ͳ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͳΒ;
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ













͇
͵ͪ͵ͬͳͷ
ΒͰ
tͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪi
ͻͰ΂

͌
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
ΒͰ
tͼ͵;ͺi
ͺ͹ͬͰͻΓͳͬͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͺͻ͹ͬͰͻͰ͸ͳ΀

ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
͹ͺͼͰͻͬͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱ͸ͪ
ͳͯͰΒͪ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͼͽͪ
ͬ͹ͬͪ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂ͪ͵ͪ
ͺͻͳͫͻͪ͸ͳ΀
ͼͪ
΁ͳΓͰͷ
΃ͽ͹
;ͼͺͰ΃͸ͳΒͰ
ͻͰͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ

 t̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻi
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͯ͸;
͹ͼ͹ͫ; 

ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͯ;Ͳͳͷͪ
͊ͪͯͻͱͪΒͳ
ͽͳ΀
tͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪi
ͼ;

͹ͽ;ͯͪ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸͹
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸ͳ
͇͸ͳ
͸Ͱ
Ͳͪͯ͹ͬ͹ΓͪͬͪΒ;
ͻͪͯ͹Ͳ͸ͪͶ͹ͼͽ

ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͸ͪͷͰͻ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͹
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸ͳ
;
͵͹Β;
ͺ;ͽ;ΒͰ

t͊ͰͶͰ͵΁ͳΒͪi
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ

͵͹ΒͰ
ͯ͹͸͹ͼͰ
;΂ͳΔͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͪ
΁ͳΓͰͷ
ͼͽͳ΁ͪΔͪ
ͺ͹;Ͳͯͪ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
tͼͶͳ
͵Ͱ
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͭi
ͺ͹ͼͷͪͽͻͪ͸͹ͭ
ͺ;ͽͰͷ

m
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪΔͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
͸ͪ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳͷͪ
9*9
ͳ
99

ͬͰ͵ͪ

m
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͪ
͹ͺ΃ͽͰͭ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ͭͰ͹ͼͽͻͪͽͰ΃͵ͳ
ͳ
ͭͰ͹ͺ͹Ͷͳ
ͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒ
ͺ͹ͬͻ΃ͳ͸ͪ
͸ͪͼͰΓͰ͸͹ͼͽ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸Ͱ
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͰ
ͳ͸
ͼͽͳͽ;΁ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͼͳͼͽͰͷ

m
ͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪΔͪ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵͹ͭ
m
ͺͻͰͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ

;
ͻͪͬ͸ͳ
;͸;ͽͻͪ΃Δͳ΀
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͪ
ͳ

ͼͺ͹Γ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵Ͱ

m
ͯͰͿͳ͸ͳͼͪΔͪ
͹ͺͽͳͷͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸͹ͭ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ

ͬ͹Β͸͹ͭ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵͹ͭ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ

͵͹Βͳ
͹ͯͻͰΌ;ΒͰ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
͵;ͻͼ
͵͹
Βͳ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͻͰͪͶͳͲ͹ͬͪͽͳ
̽ͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͻͰ΂ͳͷͪ
;
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
ΒͰ
ͼͶ͹ͱͰ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͻͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂
͵ͪ
tͼͶͳ͵ͪ
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͭi
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͼͰͫͰ
ͼͪͷ͹ͭ
ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
ͼͬ͹Βͳ΀
ͬͳͽͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͼͺ͹Γ
͸͹ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ΀
΁ͳΓͰͬͪ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͽͰ͸
΁ͳΒͪͶͪ
ͳ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
͆ͪͷͰͻͪ
ͼ
͵͹Β͹ͷ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸ͳ
tͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳi
͸ͪͼͽͪΒ;
͵ͻͪΒΔͰ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͪͭͷͪ
ͽͳ΂͸ͪ
ͳ
͸Ͱͯͬ͹ͼͷͳͼͶͰ͸͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͪ
͈ͻͰͲͰ͸ͽ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰͶͰ͵
ͽ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͻͪ͸ͭͳͻͪ͸ͳ
ͺ͹
ͬͪͱ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͵͹Β;
͸ͪͷͰΕͰ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͪ

̽ͪͽ;ͷͳ
ͳ
Ͷͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͼͺ͹ͷͳΔ;
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂Ͱ
͹
ͺͻͰͶ͹ͷ͸ͳͷ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪ
Βͳͷͪ
ͪ
͹͸ͳ
͹ͺͰͽ
ͺ͹ͻͰΌͪ͸ͳ
;
͸ͳͲ;
;͵ͪͲ;Β;
͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹΁ͰͼͰ
͵͹Βͳ
ͳͷ
͹ͯͻͰ
Ό;Β;
ͼͷͳͼͪ͹
͌͹΂Ͱ͸ͳ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼͳ
ͳͷͪΒ;
ͼͬͰ
ͽͻͳ
ͽͰͷͺ͹ͻͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͯͳͷͰ͸ͲͳΒͰ

m
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽ
ͼͪͯͪ΃Δ͹ͼͽ
ͳ
ͫ;ͯ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͽͻͰ͸;ͽͪ͵
;
͵͹ͷͰ
Ͳͪͺ͹΂ͳ
ΔͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;Εͳ
ͺͳͽͪΔͪ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
ͽͻͪͭͪ
Ͳͪ
͹ͯͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
ͷͪ
͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂ͪͻͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͫ;ͯ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
́͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
tͼͪ͹ͺ΃ͽͪͬͪΒ;i
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸ͳ
tͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳi
ͻͪͲͶͳ
΂ͳͽͰ
ͼ;
ͺ͹
ͽͳͺ;
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ;
ͺ͹ͻͰ͵Ͷ;
͈͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͳͫͳͻͪΒ;
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ

ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳ
ͻͰͼ͹ͻͳ
ͳ
ͼͶ;ͱͫͰ
ͺͪͻͽͳΒͼ͵ͳ
Ϳ͹ͻ;ͷͳ
͸ͪ;΂͸ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽͳ
ͪ

͵͹͸ͪ΂͸͹
ͳ΀
;͹ͫͶͳ΂ͪͬͪ
;
΁ͰͶͳ͸;
Ͳͪ
ͼͰͫͰ
ͅͳ͸ͳͼͽͪͻͼͽͬ͹
ͳ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΀

ͺ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͪ
̓ͪ͹
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͳ
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΔͪ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͼͰ
Ͳͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸ͳ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͳ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻ
ͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
m
ͬͰͼͽͳ
ͽͰͶͰͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ΀
ͪͭͰ͸΁ͳΒͪ
ͼͽͪͽͳͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͫ;ΘͰͽͳ
ͺͻͳ΀͹ͯͪ

ͳ
ͻͪͼ΀͹ͯͪ
ͫͳͶͪ͸ͼͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
ͺͻͪͬ͸ͪ
ͪ͵ͽͪ
ͷͰΌ;͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ

;ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
͹͸ͪ
͵͹Βͪ
͸Ͱͭ;ΒͰ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͽͳ΂͵͹
͸͹ͬͳ͸ͪͻ
ͼͽͬ͹

́͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͼͪͫͳͻͪΒ;
ͳ
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͼ͵ͳͷ
͵ͪ͸ͪͶͳͷͪ
̺ͪͱ͸͹

ͷͰͼͽ͹
;
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͻͪΔ;
ͺ͹;Ͳͯͪ͸Ͱ
ͼͶͳ͵Ͱ
͹
ͲͰͷΓͳ
;
͵͹Β;
ͼͰ
ͺ;ͽ;Β;
ͳͷͪ

 ͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
̽ͳͷͳΕ

͸ͪ;͵ͪ
͸ͪ;΂͸ͪ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͪ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͳ͵ͪ
΁ͳΓ͸ͪ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͳ
ͻͰͲ;Ͷ

ͽͪͽͳ
ͯ͹
͵͹Βͳ΀
ͼͰ
ͺ;ͽͰͷ
Δͳ΀
ͯ͹΃Ͷ͹

͈͹ͼͰͫ͸;
ͽͰͱͳ͸;
ͳͷͪΒ;
ͺ͹ͬͰͻ
Γͳͬͳ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͳ
ͯ͹
͵͹Βͳ΀
ͼ;
ͯ͹΃ͶͰ
tͼͺͰ΁ͳΒͪͶͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸Ͱi
ͼͶ;ͱͫͰ
ͳ
ͬ͹Β͸Ͱ

ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͰ
͈͹͸Ͱ͵ͪͯ
ͼͰ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͻͪͼͺ͹ͶͪͱͰ
΁ͻ͵ͬͪ

͊ͪͫͻͪ͸ͳ
͸ͪ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
ͷͰͼͽ;
ͳ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
t͹ͫͻͪΌͰ͸ͳ i
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸ͳ
ͳͲͬ͹
ͻͳ
ͯ͹͸͹ͼͰ
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸;
΀ͻ͹͸͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒ;
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͪ
ͳͲ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͽͳ

ͻͰͯ͹ͼͶͰͯ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͽͰͲͪ
ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͿͳ͵͹ͬͪͽͳ
ͺ͹͵ͻͰͽͪ΂ͳ
ͳ͸ͳ΁ͳΒͪ
ͽͳͬͪ
ͬͳͯͰͽͳ
ͳͼ΀͹ͯͳ
ͼ;ͼͻͰͽͪ
ͳ
ͻͪͲͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͪ
;͹΂ͳͽͳ
ͺͻͰͶ͹ͷ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
;
ͷͰ
Ό;ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳͷ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳͷͪ
ͺͻͰͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ
ͼͽͪͬ͹ͬͳ
ͪ͵ͽͰͻͪ
;
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳͷͪ

ͳͲ͸;ΌͰ͸ͳ
͵͹ͷͺͻ͹ͷͳͼͳ
ͺͻͳͷͪͻ͸ͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͳ
;Ͳͻ͹΁ͳ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯͳ΁Ͱ

ͯ͹͸Ͱͽͳ΀
͹ͯͶ;͵ͪ
;ͼͶ͹ͬΓͰ͸͹ͼͽ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͽͰͲͪ
ͳͯͰ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͪ
;ͫͰΌͰ
Δͪ
ͬ͹Γͪ
ͳ
;ͬͰ͵
ͼͰͫͳ΂͸ͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
Ϳͻ͹͸ͽ͹ͬͳ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͳ

ͪ͵ͽͰͻͳ

͌ͬͳͯ
;
tͬ͹ͯͳ΂Ͱi
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͺͻͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ
Ͳͪ
͠͹ͼͳͺͪ
̹ͻ͹Ͳͪ
͋ͳͽͪ
Ϳͪͼ΁ͳ
͸ͳͻͪ
tͻͪͼͺ͹͸͹ͷ
ͳ
ͫͻ͹ΒͰͷ
ͽͰͷͪi
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͼͷͪͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͬͪͱ͸ͳͷ
͸ͰͲͪ͹ͫͳ
ͶͪͲ͸ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫ͸ͳͷ
Ͳͪ
;ͼͺͰ΃͸͹
ͬ͹ΌͰΔͰ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵Ͱ
͌Ͳ
͹͸Ͱ

͵ͻ;΁ͳΒͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͼ;΃ͽͳ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
tͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳi
ͼ;
ͺͻ͹ͭ͹ͬͪͻͪͶͳ
ͳ
͹
ͽͰͷͪͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ

͸ͪ
ͺͻͬͳ
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪΒ;
ͷͪͻͭͳ͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͪͶͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
͸ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͬͳ΁Ͱ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
tͷͪͶ͹ͭ
΂͹ͬͰ͵ͪi
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂Ͱ
͹
ͺͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͷͪ͸ͪͷͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳ
ͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͼͳͼͽͰͷͪ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸;
ͺͻͳͬͻͰΌͳͬͪΔͪ
t͵;ͻͼ;i

Ͳͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͲͪͶͪͭͪͽͳ
;΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳͷ
ͭͻͰ΃͵ͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͯͪ

͹͸Ͱ
ͫ;ͯ;
ͳͲͫͰͭ͸;ͽͰ
ͫ;ͯ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸ͳͷͪ
͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͼͰͭ͸;ͽͳ
͆ͳ
ΒͰ
;
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
ͼͪͷ͹
ͯ͹ͫͻͪ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͼͪ͸͹ͼͽ
͹
ͲͰͷΓͳ
;
͵͹Β;
ͼͰ
ͺ;ͽ;ΒͰ
ͬͰΕ

ͼ;΃ͽͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ
tͰͶͰͷͰ͸ͽͳ
Ͳͪ
ͭͻͪΌͰΔͰ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵Ͱi
ͼͪ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
͠͹ͼͳͺ
̹ͻ͹Ͳ

͋ͳͽ͹
͵ͻͰͽͪ͹
͸ͪ
ͼͬ͹Βͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ












͊
͵ͪ͵ͬ͹ͷ
tͼͶͳ͵͹ͷi
͋;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
͋ͳͽ͹
ͪͺͻͳͶͪ

ͳ
Β;͸ͪ


͵ͻͰΕͰ
͸ͪ
ͼͬ͹Βͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ

͠͹ͼͳͺ
̹ͻ͹Ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͬ͹Β͸Ͱ
ͼͪͬͰͲ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͽͻͪͱͳ
ͷͰΌ;
ͲͰͷΓͪ
ͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
;
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
΂Ͱͷ;
ͫͳͶͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͰ
͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ
ΒͰ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͽͻͳ
ͺ;ͽͪ

ͫͳͶͪ
ͬͰΕͪ

ͳͷͪ
ͺ͹ͬͻ΃ͳ͸;
͹ͯ

͵ͷ
͹ͯ
΂Ͱͭͪ

͵ͷ
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ
͵ͪ͸;

ͪ
̻ͻ΂͵ͪ
ͯͬͪ
ͺ;ͽͪ
ͷͪΔͪ

ͳͷͪ
ͺ͹ͬͻ΃ͳ͸;
͹ͯ

͵ͷ
͹ͯ
΂Ͱͭͪ


͵ͷ
͸ͪ
͹ͼͽͻͬͳͷͪ

͹ͯ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
͋ͳͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͻͪ΂;͸ͪ͹
͸ͪ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͳ΀

ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹

ͷͳͶͳ͹͸ͪ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͇ͯ
ͼͽͻͪͽͰ΃͵Ͱ
ͬͪͱ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
ͳ

ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͷͪͶͪ
ͼ͵͹ͻ͹
ͽͻͳ
ͺ;ͽͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͱͳͽͰΓͪ


͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ
͹͵͹

ͷͳͶͳ͹͸ͪ
ͪ
̻ͻ΂͵ͪ
 

ͳͷͪͶͪ
ͯͬͪ
ͺ;ͽͪ
ͷͪΔ;
͸ͪͼͰΓͰ
 t̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻi
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͯ͸;
͹ͼ͹ͫ; 

͸͹ͼͽ

;
͋;ͻͼ͵͹Β
ͱͳͬͳ

ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͸ͪ
͵ͷ
ͪ
;
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β



͇ͫͰ

ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
ΒͰ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͪͶͪ
΀͹ͷ͹ͭͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͬͰͻͼ͵ͪ
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͪ

ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
͌
͋;ͻͼ͵͹Β
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͳ
ͯ͹ͼͽ;ͺ
͸ͳ
͋ͳͽ;
ͱͳͬͰͶ͹

͋;ͻͪ͵ͪ
ͳ

ͷ;ͼͶͳͷͪ͸ͪ
ͯ͹͵
ΒͰ
;
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
ͫͳͶ͹

ͺͻͰ͵͹

̻ͻ͵ͪ
ͳ

ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬ͸ͳ΀
΀ͻͳ΃Εͪ͸ͪ
̽͹ͷͳ͸ͪ͸ͽ͸͹
ͪͭͻͪͻ
͸Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ

͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ
ͺͻͰ͵͹

ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
ͱͳͬͳ
͸ͪ
ͼͰͶ;
ͳ
͹ͯ
ͺ͹
Γ͹ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͰ

ͳ
̻ͻ΂͵ͪ
ͼ;
ͼͬ͹Β
͸ͪͺͻͰͯͪ͵
ͽͰͷͰΓͳͶͰ
͸ͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳͷ
Ͱ͵͹
͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳͷ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺͽͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͼͽͻͪͽͰͭͳΒͪͷͪ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Βͪ
́ͺͪ͵
;
͹ͫͪ
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒͪ

ͼͳͽ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͯ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͷͳ͸ͳͻͪ͹
;
ͺ͹Γ͹ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͳ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
;
ͼͽͪΔ;

ͯͪ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬͰͯͰ
ͬͳ΃ͪ͵
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͹ͷ͹ͭ;Εͳ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͪ

ͪ͸ͭͪͱ;ΒͰ

ͬͳ΃ͪ͵
ͻͪͯ͸Ͱ
ͼ͸ͪͭͰ
;
ͺͻ͹ͯ;͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͷ
ͻͪͯ;
ͳͼ΀ͻͪ͸ͳ
ͬͰͶͳ
͵;
ͺ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΁;
̹;ͯ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
ΒͰ
;͵ͳͯͪ͹
ͳ
͸ͳͲͪ͵
ͼͽͰͺͰ͸
ͺͻ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ

͋ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
;
͋;ͻͼ͵͹Β
ͫͳͶ͹
ͺͻͰ͵͹

͸ͰͺͳͼͷͰ͸͹ͭ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ


ͼͰͶͪ
ͫͰͲ
΃͵͹ͶͰ
ͳ
;΂ͳͽͰΓͪ
ͬͳͼ͹͵
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱ͸ͪͽ
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͫ͹ͶͰͼͽͳ
ͫ͹
ͶͰͼͽͳ
Ͷ͹΃Ͱ
ͳͼ΀ͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸ͪ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬͪΔͪ

ͬͳͼ͹͵
͸ͪͽͪͶͳͽͰͽ
ͳ
͹͵͹


ͼͷͻͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͸͹ͬ͹ͻ͹ΌͰ͸΂ͪͯͳ
͸Ͱͯ͹ͼͽͪͽͪ͵
ͶͰ͵ͪͻͪ
͹ͯ

ͶͰ͵ͪͻͪ


ΒͰ
ͱͳͬͰͶ͹
;
́ͼͽͪͷͫ;Ͷ;
ͳ
̸͸͵ͪͻͳ

͈͹
ͺ͹͵ͪͲͪͽͰΓͳͷͪ
͹
ͯͻ;
΃ͽͬͰ͸͹Β
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͳ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
;
ͺ͹ͯͻͰΌͰ
͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒ;
;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ;
͸ͪ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͼ;ͼͰͯͰ
͇
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͼͪͬͰͲ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
͠͹ͼͳͺ
̹ͻ͹Ͳ
͋ͳͽ͹
ͺ͹ͼͰΕͳͬͪ͹


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͼͳͼͽͰͷͳ
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ
;
ͽͳͷ
ͯͻ
ͱͪͬͪͷͪ
m
;ͼͽͪͬ͸ͪ
ͷ͹͸ͪͻ΀ͳΒͪ
;
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
ͳ
ͼͰ͵;Ͷͪͻ͸ͪ
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ
;
͋;ͻ
ͼ͵͹Β
t̺͹ͯͳ΂ͳi
ͼ;
͹ͽ;ͯͪ
ͯ͹͸͹ͼͳͶͳ
ͺ͹ͯͻ͹ͫ͸Ͱ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͰ
;ͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͪ͵ͪͽͪ

ͼͪ
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸͹
;ͽͬͻΌͰ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͪͬͳͷͪ
ͳ
͹ͫͪͬͰͲͪͷͪ
ͷ͹͸ͪͻ΀ͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͰͯ
͸ͳ͵ͪ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
ͼ͵;ͺ΃ͽͳ͸ͪ
ͼ;ͯ͹ͬͪ
͉ͪͲͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͼͺͻͰͷ͸͹ͼͽ
ͯͪ
͹͸Ͱ
ͫ;
ͯ;
ͺͻͰͬͪͲͳΌͰ͸Ͱ
;ͺͰ΂ͪͽΓͳͬ͹
ͼ;
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂ͳͶͰ
͹
Βͪ΂ͳ͸ͳ
ͷ͹ͽͳͬͪ
ͳ
ͼͽͻͪ΀;

͵ͪ͹
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸͹ͷ
ͭͰ͸Ͱͻͪͽ͹ͻ;
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼͪ
ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͪͬͪΔͪ
̀͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ͸
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪ͹
ΒͰ
;
tͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪi
ͽͰͷͪͷͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ

ͼͪͽ͵ͪ͸ͳͷ
͹ͯ
ͷͰΌ;ͼ͹ͫ͸ͳ΀
͵͹͸ͿͶͳ͵Bͽͪ
ͳ
ͼ;͵͹ͫͪ
͉ͪͽ͹ͬͳ
ͫ;͸Ͱ
;ͼͽͪ͸
΁ͳ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹
ͺͻͪΕͰΔͰ
;
͹ͺ΃ͽͰͷ
͵͹͸ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
9*9

ͳ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͯͪ
ͼ;ͯͫͳ͸;
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
;
͵͹͸ͽͳ
͸;ͳͽͰͽ;
͹ͯͻͰΌ;Β;
ͬͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͼͳͶͰ
;
ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;
ͼͪ
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
;ͬͰ͵
ͼͰͫͳ΂͸ͳͷ

ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͳͷͪ
͇ͯ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
;ͼͽͪ͸ͪ͵ͪ
ͼ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵ͪ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺͻͰ͵͹

̓ͻͳͷͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
m

ͳ

̺ͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
͵ͻͳͲͰ
m


ͯ͹
ͻͰ΃ͪͬͪΔͪ
tͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹ͭ
ͺͳͽͪΔͪi
;
ͻͪͽ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͼ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵ͪ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͳ

ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͳ΀
ͻͪͽ͹ͬͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͹ͫͰͶͰͱͳͶͳ
Ͱͺ͹΀;
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽ͹ͬͪ͸ͪ

ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
ͺͰͻͷͪ͸Ͱ͸ͽ͸ͳ΀
ͼ;͵͹ͫͪ

ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
ͳ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
t̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹
ͺͳͽͪΔͰi
ΒͰ

ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸͹
͵ͪ͹
tͼ͵;ͺ
ͳͼ͵Γ;΂ͳͬ͹ͼͽͳi
͵͹Βͪ
͹͸Ͱͷ͹ͭ;Εͪͬͪ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸
 ͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
̽ͳͷͳΕ

ͼ͵Ͱ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͰ
ͳ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͪͷͰ
;ͻͰͯͰ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
͈ͻ͹ͷͰ
͸ͪ
ͽͪ͵ͬ͹ͭ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸ͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹͸ͪ΃ͪΔͪ
͸ͪͷͰͽͪͶͪ
ͼͰ
͵ͪ͹
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ
ͳͲ
ͶͪͲ
ͳͲ
͵ͻ;ͭͪ
͸ͰͼͻͰΕͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
;͵ͳͯͪΒ;
ͫ;ͯ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
͇ͯ
Ͷͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ

ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽ
ΒͰ
ͯͪͬͪ͸ͪ
͹͸ͳͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
͹ͼͽͪͬͳͶͰ
;ͺͰ΂ͪͽΓͳͬ
ͽͻͪͭ

;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΁ͳ
͈͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ΒͰ
;͵ͪͲͪ͸͹
͸ͪ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵;
ͼͪͻͪͯΔͰ

̾ͶͰͿͽͰͻ͹ͼͪ
̺Ͱ͸ͳͲͰͶ͹ͼͪ
ͳ
͸ͪͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͪ
̓ͰͷͪͶͪ
̸ͽͪͽ;ͻ͵ͪ
ͯͪ
͹ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂ͳ

;ͺͶͳͽͪΔͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ΀
ͼͳͶͪ

ͳͲͬͰͯͰ
ͻͰͿ͹ͻͷͰ
ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ
ͼͪͷ͹ͼͽͪͶ͸;
ͺ͹Ͷͳ
ͽͳ͵;
͆Ͱͼ;ͷΔͳͬ͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪͶ͹
;ͫͰΌͰΔͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͰΕͪΔͰ
͸ͪ
ͽ;
ͳ
ͽͪ
͵ͬ;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵;
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
tͱͳͬ͹i
;
̸ͽͳ͸ͳ
ͳ
́ͼͽͪͷͫ;Ͷ;
ͯͪ
ͭͪ
;
ͫ;ͯ;
Εͳͷ
ͻͪͲͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͷͪ
ͺ͹͸͹ͬ͹
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͪͿͳͻͷͳͼͪͽͳ
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͽͰͷͰΓͳͷͪ
ͽͪ͵ͬͰ

ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳΒͰ
ͭͻͪͯͳͽͳ
ͫ;ͯ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
͌͹΂Γͳͬ͹
ΒͰ
ͳ͸ͼͳͼͽͳͻͪΔͰ

tͺͳͼͪ΁ͪi
ͳ
ͺͻͳͻͰΌͳͬͪ΂ͪ
tͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪi
͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͬͰͻͰ͸͹Β
Ϳͪ͵ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͳ
Ͱͭ
Ͳͪ͵ͽ͸͹ͷ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͷ
ͳͼ͵ͪͲ;
;Ͳͯͻͱͪ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͹ͯ
͵͹ͷͰ͸ͽͪͻͪ
͇΃ͽͻ͹
ΒͰ

͵ͻͳͽͳ͵͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹ͭͻͰ΃͸ͪ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͷͪ΃Ͱ͸ͪ
͹ͺ͹ͻͽ;͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͳ
ͫͰͼ
΁ͳΓ͸ͪ
͸ͰͻͰͪͶ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͭ;ͫͳͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵ͪ

͈̓
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
́ͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹
ΒͰ

͸ͪ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
tͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪi
;
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳΒͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
͊;΃ͽͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͻͪͲ
;ͷͰͬͪΔͰ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
ΒͰ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͪͬͪͶ͹
͸ͪ
ͺͰͻͷͪ͸Ͱ͸ͽ͸Ͱ
͸Ͱͼͺ͹ͻͪͲ;ͷͰ

ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
9*9
ͳ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͶ͹
͹
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͷ
ͼͳͶͪ
ͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͭͰ͸Ͱͻͪͽ͹ͻ;
ͽͻͪͭͰͯͳΒͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
͹ͫͰͶͰͱͳͶͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ;
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ

;͵ͪͲͳͬͪͶ͹
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻͰ
ͼͪͻͪͯΔͰ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
;
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ

ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͻͰͲ;ͶͽͪͽͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
͹͸ͪ
ͯ͹͸ͰͶͪ

͹ͺͻͪͬͯͪͬͪͶ͹
ͬͶͪͼͽͳͽͳ
ͺ͹
Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
͵;ͻͼ
ͪͿͳͻͷͳͼͪͶ͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵;
ͺͻͳΒͪͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ
ͳ
΂ͬͻ΃ΕͰͭ
ͻͰͭͳ
͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͬͰͲͳͬͪΔͪ
͵ͪ͹
ΒͰͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͪͶͽͰͻ͸ͪͽͳͬͰ
͵͹Βͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
͹ͫͰͲͫͰΌ;
ΒͰ
ͫ;ͯ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
͹ͫΒͪ΃ΔͪͬͪͶ͹
ͳ
ͼ;΃ͽͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͹ͺͻͪͬͯͪͬͪͶ͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ

ͺ͹ͽͰͲͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
͠͹ͼͳͺ
̹ͻ͹Ͳ
͋ͳͽ͹
ͺ͹ͬͶͪ΂ͳ͹
tͷͪ͸Ͱͬͻͳ΃;Εͳi
ͳͲͷͰΌ;

ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ΀
ͼͳͶͪ
́ͼͽ͹͵ͪ
ͳ
̀ͪͺͪͯͪ

͊
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹ͷ
ͺͪͱΔ͹ͷ
tͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳi
ͼ;
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂ͳͶͳ
͹
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳͷ

ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
;
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
͠͹ͼͳͺ
̹ͻ͹Ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪ͹
̸͸ͪͶͳͲͳͻͪ͸ͳ
ͼ;

ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͳ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͫ͸͹ͬͰ
ͪͭͻͪͻ͸͹ͭ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͬͰ͸΁ͳ͹͸ͳ
Ͳͪͷ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
;
ͼͿͰͻͳ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͰ
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͪ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯΔͰ
Ͳͪͯ;ͱͰ͸͹ͼͽ

ͫ;ΘͰͽͳ
ͳ
ͺͶͪͽ͸ͳ
ͫͳͶͪ͸ͼͳ
ͳ͸ͿͶͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͼͽͻͪͽͰͭͳΒͰ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Βͪ
ͳ
ͼͬͰ
͹ͼͽͪ
Ͷ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸͹
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂ͳͶ͹
͹
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͯͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͼͽͪͶ͸;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵;
͈͹ͯͻ͹ͫ͸͹
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͳ
ͺͻͪΕͰ͸ͳ
;ͼͶ͹ͬͳ
ͳ
ͬͳͼͳ͸ͪ
ͪͷͰ
ͻͳ΂͵Ͱ
΁ͳͬͳͶ͸Ͱ

 
ͷͳͶͳΒͪͻͯͰ
ͯ͹Ͷͪͻͪ

ͳ
ͬ͹Β͸Ͱ
ͷͳͶͳΒͪͻͯͪ
ͯ͹Ͷͪͻͪ


ͺ͹ͷ͹Εͳ
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
̹ͰͲ
ͳͯͰ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͯͻͪͼ;ͯͪ
ͷͰͻͰ͸
ΒͰ
;΂ͳ͸ͪ͵
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ

ͺ͹ͷ͹Εͳ
m
ΔͰ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͷͪ͸Ͱ
͌͹΂ͪͬͪ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͺͳͺΓͳͬ
ͻͰͲ;Ͷ
ͽͪͽ
ͽͰ
ͺ͹ͷ͹Εͳ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
̻ͻ΂͵ͪ
;
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹
͹ͺͻͰͷΓͰ͸ͪ
ͬ͹Βͼ͵ͪ
͹ͯ

͹͵͹

ͬ͹Β͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͳͲͭͻͪΌͰ͸Ͱ
Βͪͬ͸Ͱ
;ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬͰ
͹ͫ͸͹ͬΓͰ͸ͪ
ͷͻͰͱͪ

΃͵͹Ͷͼ͵ͳ΀
Ͳͭͻͪͯͪ
ͺ͹ͯͳͲͪΔͰ
ͺͻͳͬͪͽ͸͹ͭ
ͼͽͪͷͫͰ͸͹ͭ
Ϳ͹͸ͯͪ
ͳͲͭͻͪͯΔͪ

 t̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻi
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͯ͸;
͹ͼ͹ͫ; 

͸͹ͬͳ΀
ͺͻ;ͭͪ

͵ͷ

ͪͼͿͪͶͽ͸ͳ΀
ͺ;ͽͰͬͪ

͵ͷ

ͪͰͻ͹ͯͻ͹ͷͪ



ͽͰͶͰ͵͹ͷ;͸ͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͹͵͹

͵ͷ

ͺ͹ͯͳͲͪΔͰ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͰ
ͯ͹
͸ͳͬ͹ͪ
͵͹
Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ΃ͳͬͪ͹
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵;
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯΔ;
ͳͲ

Ͳͪ

ͳ
ͺͻͳ
͸͹ͼͰ
;
ͺ͹Γ͹ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͳ
Ͳͪ

͊
ͺ͹ͯΒͰͯ͸ͪ͵͹ͷ
ͺͪͱΔ͹ͷ
ͺͻͪΕͰ͸
ΒͰ
ͳ

Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
͋;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
͌͹΂ͪͬͪ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
tͪͅͻ΃ͪͶ͹ͬͳͷ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͷi

ͺ͹ͯͻͱͪ͸ͪ
ͺ͹Γ͹ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͪ
ͪͶͳ
ΒͰ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷ
Ͳͪͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
ͳ͸ͯ;
ͼͽͻͳΒͰ
͊͵ͻͰͽͪ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
͸ͪ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁;
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͪ
ͲͰͷΓͪ
;
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;

m
ͯ͹ͫͳͶͪ

ͷͳͶͳ͹͸ͪ
ͯ͹Ͷͪͻͪ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͷ͹Εͳ


ͷͳͶͳ͹͸ͪ
ͯ͹Ͷͪͻͪ
ͬ͹Β͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͷ͹Εͳ
ͳ

ͷͳͶͳ͹͸ͪ
ͯ͹Ͷͪͻͪ
͵ͻͰͯͳͽͪ

́Ͳ
ͽͳ΀
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂ͳͬͪ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͪ
͋;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
Ͳͪͬͳͼ͸ͪ
͹ͯ

̸͊̽
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͬͪ͵͹
;͵ͳͯͪΔͰ
ͪͷͰͻͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͷ͹Εͳ
͸;ͱ͸͹
ͺͻ͹ͬ͹΁ͳͻͪ
ͽͰ
΃͵Ͱ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͻͰͷͰΕͪΒͰ
͋;
Ͳͪͬͳͼ͸͹ͼͽ
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͯͪͽ͸͹
ͺ͹Βͪ΂ͪͬͪͶͪ
΂ͳ
ΔͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͬ
͹ͯ

͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ
ͷ͹ͻͪͶͪ
ͯͪ
͸ͪͺ;ͼͽͳ
Ͱͽͪͽͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ

ͷ͹ͯͰͶ
t͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͰi
ͼͪͷ͹ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͰ

ͳ
͹ͺͻͰͯͰͶͳ

ͼͰ
Ͳͪ
ͽͻͱͳ΃͸ͳ
ͷ͹ͯͰͶ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰΌͳͬͪΔͪ
ͺ͹
ͪͷͰͻͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͷ͹ͯͰͶ;
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ

ͯ͹ͯͪͽ͸͹
ͺ͹ͬͰΕͪͶ͹
ͽ;ͻͼ͵;
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵;
Ͳͪͬͳͼ͸͹ͼͽ
͌ͬͳͯ
;
tͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬ͹i

͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ
ͳ
̻ͻ΂͵ͪ
ͳͷͪͶͰ
ͼͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯ͹ͷ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͬ͹Β͸͹ͷ
ͳ
Ͱ͵͹
͸͹ͷͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͷ͹Εͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͶ;ͱͳ͹
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺͪͻͽͳΒͼ͵͹ͷ
ͬͻ΀;

tͯͪ
Ͳͪͬͳͻͳ
;
ͫ;ͯ;Ε͸͹ͼͽi
ͳ
Β͹΃
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͬͰͻ;ΒͰ
;
tͳͼͺͻͪͬ͸͹ͼͽi
ͼ͹ͺ
ͼͽͬͰ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͳͲͷͳ΁ͪΔͪ
ͳͲ
ͼͷͻͽ͹͸͹ͼ͸͹ͭ
ͲͪͭͻΓͪΒͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ΀
ͼͳͶͪ

ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͯͳ͵ͽͪͽ;
͌
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳΒͳ
ͬ͹ΌͰΔͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͫͳͶͰ
ͼ;
ͳ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͰ
;ͼͶ͹ͬͪ
ͱͳ
ͬ͹ͽͪ
ͳ
ͼͽͪ͸ͯͪͻͯͪ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
͈;ͽ;Β;Εͳ
;
͋;ͻͼ͵;
͠͹ͼͳͺ
̹ͻ͹Ͳ
ΒͰ

ͻͪͼͺ͹Ͷͪͭͪ͹
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;
ͽ͹Β
ͲͰͷΓͳ
͸ͰͲͪͺ͹ͼͶͰ͸͹ͼͽ
ͺ͹ͬͰΕͪͬͪ

̸͸ͪͶͳͲͪ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼͪ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹Γ͹ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͰ
ͳͲͪͲͬͪ͸͹ͭ
ͷͰ΀ͪ͸ͳ
Ͳͪ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯΔͰ
͸ͪͷͰͽͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫ;
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͭ͹ͯͳ΃ΔͰ
;
ͯͻ;ͭͰ

ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͼͰ͵ͽ͹ͻͰ
tͺͻͰͫͪ΁ͳi
͹͵͹

Γ;ͯͳ
͌Ͳ
͹͵͹
 
ͷͳͶͳ͹
͸ͪ
ͼͰΓͪ͵ͪ
ͫͰͲ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͳ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁;
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͽͬͪͻͪΔͰ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͻͪͯ͸͹ͭ
ͷͰͼͽͪ

͵͹΃ͽͪͶ͹
ͯͻͱͪͬ;
͹͵͹

ͯ͹Ͷͪͻͪ
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
΂ͳ͸ͳͶ͹
͹ͭͻ͹ͷ͸͹
͹ͺͽͰͻͰΕͰ
ΔͰ
Ͳͪ
͸ͰͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ͸;
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ;
͵͹Βͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
;
ͼͽͪΔ;
ͯͪ
ͪͺͼ͹ͻͫ;ΒͰ
ͬͳ
΃ͪ͵
ͻͪͯ͸Ͱ
ͼ͸ͪͭͰ
ͼͪ
ͼͰͶͪ

͆ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ
ͯ͹΀͹ͯͪ͵
;
͋;ͻͼ͵͹Β
ͺ͹ͬͰΕͪ͸

ΒͰ
;
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪͷͪ
m
Ͳͪ

ͳ
ͳͲ͸͹ͼͳ͹
ΒͰ

ͯ͹Ͷͪͻ
͌
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹
͸ͪͶ͸͹ͷ
ͯ͹΀͹ͽ͵;
ͺ͹Γ͹ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͪ
ΒͰ
;΂Ͱͼͽͬ͹ͬͪͶͪ
ͼͪ

ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͪ

ͼͪ

ͽͻͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͪ

;ͼͶ;ͱ͸Ͱ
ͯͰͶͪͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ

ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ

́ͪ͵͹

Ͱ͵ͼͽͰ͸Ͳͳͬ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͬͰͲͪ͸ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͷͪͶͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͯ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰͯͬͪ
͹ͫͰͲͫͰΌ;ΒͰ
ͰͭͲͳͼͽͰ͸
΁ͳΒ;
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
ͬͶͪͼ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͺ͹Γ͹ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͪ
ΒͰ
;΂Ͱͼͽͬ͹ͬͪͶͪ
;
;͵;ͺ͸͹ͷ

ͳͲͬ͹Ͳ;
ͼͪ
͹͵͹


̺ͳ΃Ͱ
͹ͯ

ͼͰ͹ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
ͱͳͬͰͶ͹
ΒͰ

ͷͳͷ͹
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ͸ͳ΀
ͽ͹͵͹ͬͪ
ͳ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽ;
ͺ͹ΒͪͬΓͳͬͪͶ͹
͸ͳ
͵ͪ͹

͵;ͺͪ΁
͸ͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͺͻ͹ͯͪͬͪ΁
͇ͯ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͽͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͶ͸͹
ͷ͹ͭͶͪ
͹ͫͻͪ
 ͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
̽ͳͷͳΕ

Όͳͬͪͽͳ
͹͵͹

;͵;ͺ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͬͻ΃ͳ͸Ͱ

͹͵͹

ΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͺ͹ͯ
ͻͪͲ͸ͳͷ
͵;Ͷ
ͽ;ͻͪͷͪ

ͺ͹ͯ
;ͭͪͻ͹ͷ
ͯ͹͵
ͼͰ
͹ͼͽͪͶ͹
͹͵͹


͸ͳΒͰ
͹ͫͻͪΌͳͬͪͶ͹

ͅ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯΔͰ
͵͹Β;
ΒͰ
;
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪͷͪ
m
ͼͳͷͫ͹
ͶͳͲ͹ͬͪͶ͹
ͬͳ΃Ͱͼͽͻ;͵͹
;ͬͰΕͪΔͰ
ͫͻ͹Βͪ
ͽͻͪ͵ͽ͹ͻͪ
ͼͪ

͸ͪ



;ͬ͹ΌͰΔͰ
ͭͬ͹ͲͯͰ͸͹ͭ
ͺͶ;ͭͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͼͳͷͫ͹Ͷͪ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹Γ͹ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͰ
;ͬͰ
ͲͰ͸͹

ͽͻͪ͵ͽ͹ͻͼ͵ͳ
ͺͶ;ͭ

ͺͻͳͷͰ͸ͪ
ͺ͹Γ͹ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ͸ͳ΀
ͷͪ΃ͳ͸ͪ

;
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯΔͳ 
͵͹ͼͪ΂ͳ΁ͪ

ͬͻ΃ͪͶͳ΁ͪ

͸ͪΒͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ͸ͳΒͰ
ΒͰ

;ͽͳ΁ͪͶ͹
͸ͪ
;ͯͬ͹ͼͽͻ;΂ͰΔͰ
ͺ͹Γ͹ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͳ΀͹ͯͪ
͌
;͵;ͺ͸͹ͷ

ͫͳͶͪ͸ͼ;
ͺ͹Γ͹ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯΔͰ
ͺ΃Ͱ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ΒͰ
;ͬͰΕͪ͸ͪ
Ͳͪ


͵;͵;ͻ;Ͳ
Ͳͪ

ͷͪͼͶͳ͸͹ͬ͹
;ΓͰ

ͺͪͷ;͵

͵ͻ͹ͷͺͳͻ


Β;ͱ͸͹
ͬ͹ΕͰ

̸͸ͪͶͳͲͪ
ͽͻͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͽ͹͵͹ͬͪ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲͳͬͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;

;͵;ͺ͸͹ͷ
ͳͲͬ͹Ͳ;
ͯ;ͬͪ͸
;΂Ͱͼͽͬ͹ͬͪ͹
ͼͪ

ͼ;ͬ͹
ͭͻ͹ͱΌͰ

ͷͪͼͶͳ
͸Ͱ

ͪͶ͵͹΀͹Ͷ͸ͪ
ͺͳΕͪ
 
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭ͹
͆ͪ
Ͷͳͼͽͪͷͪ
;ͬ͹Ͳͪ
ͺͻͰͯΔͪ΂ͳͶͰ

ͼ;
ͷͪ΃ͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͷͰͽͪͶͳ
ͼͪ
 
ͺ΃Ͱ͸ͳ΁ͪ

;ͭͪΓ
͸ͪͿͽͪ
ͳ
ͫͰ͸Ͳͳ͸


ͽͰ͵ͼͽͳͶ͸ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯͳ

̾͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ
ͯͰͿͳ΁ͳͽ
΂ͳ͸ͳ͹
ΒͰ


ͼͬͳ΀
ͺͻͳ΀͹ͯͪ
́Ͳͯͪ΁ͳ
Ͳͪ
͹ͯͫͻͪ͸;
;΂Ͱͼͽͬ͹ͬͪͶͳ
ͼ;
;
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͫ;ΘͰ
ͽ;
ͼͪ

͏ͰͶ͹͵;ͺ͸ͪ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͪ
͸;ͯͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͶͳ͵;
ͪͭͻͪͻ͸͹ͭ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͪ

͵͹ΒͰ
ͷ;͵͹ͽͻͺ͸͹
ͺ͹ͫͰΌ;ΒͰ
ͭͶͪͯ
;
͵͹ͷͰ
͸Ͱͷͪ
ͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ͸Ͱ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͰ

ͭͯͰ
ΒͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͳ
͸ͪͺͻͰͯͪ͵
͸ͰͻͪͲͯͬ͹Β͸͹
ͺ͹ͬͰͲͪ͸
ͼͪ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳͷ
ͯ͹͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ

ͳ
͵ͻͰͯͳͽͳͷͪ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͸Ͱͷͳ͸͹ͬ͸͹
;ͽͳ΁ͪͶ͹
͸ͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͼͽͪͬ͹ͬͰ
ͳ
͸Ͱ
ͼ͵ͻͳͬͰ͸;
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹ͼͽͻͪ͸;
Ͳͪͬͳͼ͸͹ͼͽ
͹ͯ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
͵ͻͰͯͳͽ͹ͻͪ
͌ͬͳͯ
;
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ͸ͳ
ͼͽͪ͸ͯͪͻͯ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ΒͰ
͸;
ͯͳ͹
ͺͻͰͭͻ΃ͽ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;
͵͹Βͳ΀
ΒͰ
͵ͻͰͳͻͪ͸ͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵ͪ

͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͽ͹Β
ͲͰͷΓͳ
͈͹ͶͪͲͰΕͳ
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ
͠͹ͼͳͺ
̹ͻ͹Ͳ
͋ͳͽ͹
ΒͰ

ͫͳ͹
͹ͫͪͬͰ΃ͽͰ͸
ͯͪ
ͳ͸ͿͶͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͸ͪΒͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ͸ͳΒͰ
;ͭͻ͹ͱͪͬͪ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ͸ͳ

ͼͽͪ͸ͯͪͻͯ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
͈ͶͪͽͰ
ͳ
͸ͪͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͫͳͶͰ
ͼ;
ͷͪΔͰ
͸Ͱͭ͹


΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸͹
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͶ͹
͹
ͺ͹ͭ;ͫ͸ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯͳ΁ͪͷͪ
̽ͻ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽ
ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͳ
ͭͻͪΌͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
͇ͺ΃ͽͪ
ͺ͹ͽͻ͹΃Δͪ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͳͼͺ͹ͯ

ͺͻͰͯͻͪͽ͸͹ͭ
͸ͳͬ͹ͪ
̻͹ͯͳ΃Δͪ
ͺ͹ͽͻ͹΃Δͪ
ͷͰͼͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ

ͷͪΔͪ
͸Ͱ
ͭ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͲ͸͹ͼͳͶͪ

͵ͭ
ͭ͹ͯͳ΃ΔͰ
ͺ͹
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵;
ͪ


ͳͲͷͰΌ;

ͳ

͵ͭ

͊ͽͪͷͫͰ͸ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
;ͷͪΔͰ͸
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ

ͯ͹͵
ΒͰ

ͳͲͭͻͪͯΔͪ
Ͳͪͯ͹ͬ͹ΓͪͬͪͶͪ
ͼͪͷ͹

ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
ͺͻͳͼͺͰͶ͹ͭ

;
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͰ
̸͸ͪͶͳͲͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͰ
͸ͪ
ͻͪͼͺ͹ͶͪͭͪΔ;
͋ͳͽ;
ͺ͹͵ͪͲͳͬͪͶͰ
ͼ;

ͯͪ
;
̸ͽͳ͸ͳ

ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ
͵;΀ͳΔ;
ͪ
΂ͪ͵

͵;ͺͪͽͳͶ͹
ͯͪ


ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬͪ
ͳͷͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͺ͹
ΒͰͯ͸;
ͼ͹ͫ;
ͯͪ
;

ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͹ͯ

͹ͼ͹ͫͪ

ͱͳͬͳ
;
ΒͰͯ͸͹Β
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
͊ͽͪͭ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ͸ͳ΀
;ͼͶ͹ͬͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
;Ͳ

͹ͼͽͪͶ͹
;Ͳͻ͹͵͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
͸ͳͼ͵ͳͷ
͸ͪͯ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͺͶͪͽͪ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒ
ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͯ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵ͻͰͽͪͶͪ
͹ͯ

ͯ͹

ͯ͹Ͷͪͻͪ
ͷͰͼͰ΂͸͹
ͯ͹͵
ͼ;
͵ͪͽͰͭ͹ͻͳ
ΒͰ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͰ
ͽͰͷͰΓ
ͻͰͱͳͷͪ
ͫͳͶͰ
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹

 t̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻi
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͯ͸;
͹ͼ͹ͫ; 

ͫ͹ΓͰ
ͺͶͪΕͰ͸Ͱ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳ
΂ͳ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͹͵͹

ͯ͹Ͷͪͻͪ
͸ͪ΂ͰͶ͸ͳ΁ͳ


ͺ͹ͻ;΂͸ͳ΁ͳ

ͷͪΒ͹ͻͳ


͌
;ͼͶ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͵ͪͯͪ
ͼ;
ͼͪͷ͹
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
΁Ͱ͸Ͱ
ͼ͵͹΂ͳͶͰ
Ͳͪ
͹͵͹

ͪ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ͸ͳ
ͽͻ͹΃͵͹ͬͳ
Ͳͪ

͸ͪ
ͬͰͯͰ͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͪΔͪ
ͼ;
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͶͪ
͹
ͬͰͶͳ͵͹Β
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵͹Β
͸Ͱͼͳͭ;ͻ͸͹ͼͽͳ

ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹Β
͸ͰͼͽͪͫͳͶ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͼͺ;ΔͪͬͪͶͪ
ͼͬͪ͵͹
ͯ͸Ͱͬͳ΁;
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
;
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
͊ͬͰ
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
ͻͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶͳͲ͹ͬͪͶ͹
tͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͪ

͹΂Ͱ͵ͳͬͪΔͪi
;͵ͪͲͳͬͪͶ͹
͸ͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;ΕͰ
͹ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͼͪͻͪͯΔͰ
ͼ;ͭͰͼͽͳͬ͸͹
ͭ͹ͬ͹
ͻͳͶ͹
͹
ͺͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͳ

tͫ͹ΓͰͷ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ;i
;
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶͳͲͷ;
͊ͪ
ͺ͹ͯΒͰͯ͸ͪ͵͹ͷ
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸͹΃Ε;
ͳ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͽͳ΂͸͹΃Ε;
tͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳi
ͭ͹
ͬ͹ͻͰ
͹
;͸;ͽͻͪ΃Δ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΁ͳ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ
͋;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
̓ͪ͹
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸Ͱ
͵ͪͻͪ͵
ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
;͸;ͽͻͪ΃ΔͰͭ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Βͪ
͹͸ͳ
ͼ͵ͻͰΕ;
ͺͪͱΔ;
͸ͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ
ͫͻ͹Β

ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
ͬͶͪͯͪ
͹ͯͼ;ͼͽͬ͹
͵͹͸ͽͳ͸;ͳͽͰͽͪ
͸ͰͼͽͪͫͳͶ͸͹ͼͽ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵;
ͳ

ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵;
Ͳͪͬͳͼ͸͹ͼͽ
͹ͯ
̀ͪͺͪͯͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
Ͳͪ
ͼͬͰ
ͺͳͽͪ
͌͹΂Ͱ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͳ͸
ͽͰ͸Ͳͳͬ͸͹ͼͽ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸ͳ΀
͵ͻͰͽͪΔͪ
ͺ͹ͯͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
͸Ͱ͹΂Ͱ͵ͳͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ

͵͹ͷͫͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͭͻ;ͺͳͼͪͬͪΔͪ
͏ͰͶ͹͵;ͺ͸;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵;
ͼͳͽ;ͪ΁ͳΒ;

ͺ͹ͯΒͰͯ͸ͪ͵͹
;
͋;ͻͼ͵͹Β
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
;
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͼͪͫͻͪ͸ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ

͹ͺͽͰͻͰΕ;Β;
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶ͸ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͳ
̀ͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͪͻͽͳΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹΁ͰΔͳ
ͬͪ͸͹
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͫͰͲ
Βͪ΂Ͱ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸Ͱ
;͵͹ͻͰΔͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͊͵ͻͰͽͪ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͪͱΔͪ

͸ͪ
;Ͷ͹ͭ;
ͬ͹Βͼ͵Ͱ
;
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬ;
͌
͸ͰͼͽͪͫͳͶ͸ͳͷ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ

͹͸ͪ
ͼͰ
͵ͪ͹
tͲͪ΃ͽͳͽ͸ͳ͵
͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ i
ͺ͹ΒͪͬΓͳͬͪͶͪ
;
ͳͲͻͪͲͳͽ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂
͵͹Β
;Ͷ͹Ͳͳ
͇
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸͹
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂ͳͶ͹
ͳ
ͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬ͹
ͺͰ͸Ͳͳ͹͸ͳ
ͼͪ͸ͳ΀
͹Ϳͳ΁ͳͻͪ
;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΁ͳ

͇ͯ
Δͳ΀
ͼ;
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ
ͼ;΃ͽͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͫͳͶͳ

ͼͻͰͯͳ΃ͽͪ
͹͵͹
͵͹Βͳ΀
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͹͵;ͺΓͪͶͰ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͪͻͽͳΒͰ
ͳ
͵͹ͪͶͳ΁ͳΒͰ

͌
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫͪ͸
;ͽͳ΁ͪΒ
ͪ
ͼͪͷͳͷ
ͽͳͷ
ͳ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸;
;Ͷ͹ͭ;
ͳͭͻͪͶͪ

ͷ͹͸ͪͻ΀ͳΒͪ

͉ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶͪ͸
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯ
͹ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ΌͰ͸
ͳͶ;ͲͳΒͪ
ͳ
Ͱͷ͹΁ͳΒͪ
͹ͫͰͶͰͱΒͰ
ΒͰ

ͳ
͹͸ͳ΀
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͪ
tͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪi
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸ͳ΀
͠͹ͼͳͺ;
̹ͻ͹Ͳ;
͋ͳͽ;
͵͹Βͳ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͰ

͹
ͼͺ͹Γ͸͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΁ͳ
͊ͽͻͪͽͰ΃͵ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒ
͋;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ
΁ͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͹͸Ͱ
͸ͪͶͪͲͰ
͸ͪ
tͫͻͳͽͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͳͷͺͰͻͳΒͪͶ͸͹ͷ
ͺ;ͽ;i
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ͹

ΒͰ
͋ͳͽ;
͹
ͼͺͻͰͷ͸͹ͼͽͳ
̀ͪͺͪͯͪ
ͯͪ
ͺͰͻͷͪ͸Ͱ͸ͽ͸͹
;΂ͬͻ΃Ε;ΒͰ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͺ͹
Ͳͳ΁ͳΒͰ
;
ͽͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
͌ͬͳͯ
;
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͽͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͶͰ
ͼͬͰͯ͹΂ͳ͹
ΒͰ
͹

ͱͳͬ͹ͽ͸͹Β
;ͺ;ΕͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͽͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
͸ͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͳ
ͷ͹Ε͸ͳ΀

Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
ͳ
̸͊̽
ͯͪ
Ͳͪͻͪͯ
͹ͫͰͲͫͰΌͰΔͪ
ͬͶͪͼͽͳͽͳ΀
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ

;
͊ͻͰͯ͹ͲͰͷΓ;
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͻͱͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺ͹ͯ;ͺͻ;
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͰΕͰ

ͻͰͱͳͷͰ
͌
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹΁ͰΔͳͬͪ͸͹
ͯͪ
ͫͰͲ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͷ͹Εͳ
̀ͪ
ͺͪͯͪ
͸Ͱ
ͫͳ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;Εͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͪ
͹ͫ͸͹ͬͪ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ
͸ͪͺͻͰͯͪ͵

ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶ͸ͳ
ͷͳͻ
͵͹Βͳ
;
Δͳͷͪ
ͬͶͪͯͪ
͌͹΂ͪͬͪ͸͹
ΒͰ

ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
;ͼͶ͹ͬͳ
tͲͪͬͳͼ͸͹ͼͽͳi
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͻͪͶͳ
͵͹ͯ
ͽͪͷ͹΃Δͳ΀
ͺ͹
Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͰͶͳͽͪ
ͼͬͰͼͽ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;ͬͰ͵
ͽͻͰͫͪ
͹ͼͶͪΔͪͽͳ
͸ͪ
ΒͰͯ͸;
ͬͰͶͳ͵;

 ͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
̽ͳͷͳΕ

ͼͳͶ;
͹ͽ;ͯͪ
ͼͺͻͰͷ͸͹ͼͽ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͳ΀ͬͪͽͰ
ͪͷͰͻͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͬ͹Β͸Ͱ
ͫͪͲͰ
;
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

͈͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͰ
ͼ;
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͶͰ
;
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͭ
ͽͰͲͰ
ͯͪ
͹ͫͰ

ͲͰͷΓͰ
͸ͪͼͽ͹ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͬ͹ͯͰ
tͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵;
ͻͪͬ͸͹ͽͰͱͰi
ͳ
ͪ͸;ͶͳͻͪΒ;
ͼͺ͹ͻ͹ͬͰ

͵͹ΒͰ
ͳͷͪΒ;
ͼͪ
ͼ;ͼͰͯͳͷͪ
͊ͬͰͼͽ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͳ
̻ͻ΂͵ͪ
ͳ
͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ
;
ͺͳͽͪΔͳͷͪ
͹ͯ
ͫͻͪ͸Ͱ
;ͺ;ΕͰ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵;
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸;
ͼͪͻͪͯΔ;
ͺͻ;ͱͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
΃ͪ͸ͼ;

ͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͷͰͽ͸Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
tͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ
ͼͪͬͰͲ͸ͳ͵i
͊;΃ͽͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ

ͺ;ͽ
;
̸͸͵ͪͻ;
ͳ
̸ͽͳ͸;
ͳͪ͵͹
ͳ͸ͳ΁ͳͻͪ͸
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫ͹ͷ
ͰͿͳ͵ͪͼ͸Ͱ
͹ͯͫͻͪ͸Ͱ

ͲͰͷΓͰ
͸ͳΒͰ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͳ͹
t;ͺͪͯͪΔͰ
;
Ͳͪͷ͵;i
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸ͳ΀
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͪ
ͷ͹Εͳ

ͬͰΕ
ͻͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶͪ͸
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺ͹ͽͰͲ
Ͳͪͼ͸͹ͬͪ͸
͸ͪ
ͽͰͷͰΓ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱ͸ͪ
ͷͪ
ͷͰΌ;͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͼͳͽ;ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
;ͼ͵ͶͪΌͰ͸
ͼ
΁ͳΓͰͬͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͬͳͲͳΒͪͷͪ
ͼ͹ͺ
ͼͽͬͰ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵Ͱ

͊
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹ͷ
ͺͪͱΔ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͷͪͽͻͪ͸ͳ
ͼ;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
̻ͻ΂͵ͪ
ͳ

͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ
ͳͷͪͶͰ
ͼͪ
̸͊̽
͈͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͼ͵ͻͰͽͪ͸ͪ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
͸ͪ
ͽͻ͹Βͪ͵;
;Ͷ͹ͭ;

̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
;
ͪͷͰͻͳ΂͵͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΁ͳ
;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
m
͵ͪ͹
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͪͷͰͻͳ΂͵ͳ΀

ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ
͸ͪ
̹Ͷͳͼ͵͹ͷ
ͳͼͽ͹͵;
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
͹ͯ
;ͺ͹ͻͳ΃ͽͪ
͹ͯͫͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͅͰͯͳͽͰ
ͻͪ͸ͪ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͪ
Ͳͪ
΃ͳͻͰΔͰ
;ͽͳ΁ͪΒͪ
͸ͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
͋ͳͷ
ͻͪͲͶ͹Ͳͳͷͪ

͹ͫΒͪ΃Δͪͬͪ͸ͪ
ͼ;
ͪͷͰͻͳ΂͵ͪ
;ͶͪͭͪΔͪ
;
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ͸;
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻ;
ͳ
ͬ͹Β͸Ͱ

ͳ͸ͼͽͪͶͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͊ͷͪͽͻͪ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
̻ͻ΂͵ͪ
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͪ
tͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ
ͫͪͲͰi
͸ͪ
Β;ͱ͸͹ͷ

ͫͶ͹͵;
ͼ͹ͬΒͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͫͶ͹͵ͪ
;
͊ͻͰͯ͹ͲͰͷΓ;
ͳ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
̹Ͷͳͼ͵͹ͷ
ͳͼͽ͹͵;
͌ͺ͹
ͻͰͯ͹
ͼͪ
ͽͳͷ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͪ
͵ͻͰͯͳͽͪ
;Ͷ͹ͱͰ͸ͳ΀
ͷͳͷ͹
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͼ;ͫͬͰ͸΁ͳ
Βͪ
;͵ͪͲͳͬͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
̻ͻ΂͵ͪ
;ͼͶͰͯ
͸ͰͻͰ͸ͽͪͫͳͶ͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯΔͰ
ͳ
ͷͪΔ͵ͪ

ͼͳͻ͹ͬͳ͸ͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͭ͹ͯ͸ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͳ͸ͬͰͼͽͳ΁ͳΒͰ
͌
tͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪi
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸ͳͷ

͋ͳͽ;
͸Ͱͯͬ͹ͼͷͳͼͶͰ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͳͼͽͳ΁ͪ͸͹
ͯͪ
ͪͷͰͻͳ΂͵ͪ
ͪͷͫͪͼͪͯͪ
ͬ͹Β͸ͪ
ͳ
Ͱ͵͹
͸͹ͷͼ͵ͪ
ͷͳͼͳΒͪ
;
̸ͽͳ͸ͳ
͸ͪΒͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ͸ͳΒͰ
ͻ;͵͹ͬ͹ͯͰ
ͭͻ΂͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵͹ͷ

ͳ
ͭͻ΂͵͹ͷ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ͹ͷ
ͭͻ;ͺͰ
ͪͷͰͻͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͼͽͻ;΂Δͪ͵ͪ
ͺͻͳͼ;ͽ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
;

ͼͬͳͷ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳͷ
ͻͰͼ͹ͻͳͷͪ

̽͹ͷͳ͸ͪ͸ͽ͸͹
ͪͷͰͻͳ΂͵͹
ͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬ͹
ͻͰͭͳ
ͼͽͻ͹ͬͪ͸͹
ΒͰ
;
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͪͺͪͻͪͽ;
ͬ͹Βͼ΁ͳ
ͼͬͳͷ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺͪͻͽͳ
Βͪͷͪ
ͷͰͯͳΒͳͷͪ
̸͸ͪͶͳͲ͹ͷ
ͯ͹ͼͽ;ͺ͸ͳ΀
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͺ͹ͽͬͻΌͰ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͼ;

ͼͬͰ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͭͻ΂͵Ͱ
ͬͶͪͯͰ
ͫͳͶͰ
;ͼ͵ͶͪΌͰ͸Ͱ
ͼͪ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͳͷͪ
̸͊̽
;

̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
͊ͻͰͯ͹ͲͰͷΓ;
̹Ͷͳͼ͵͹ͷ
ͳͼͽ͹͵;
͊͵ͻͰ͸;ͽͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͪͱΔͪ

͸ͪ
ͼͰͻͬͳͶ͸͹ͼͽ
ͭͻ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬͶͪͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͽͻ;ͯ
ͯͪ
ͫ;ͯ;
t΃ͽ͹
͸Ͱ͹ͺ΀͹ͯ͸ͳΒͳi
;

ͼͺͻ͹ͬ͹ΌͰΔ;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵Ͱ
̸͊̽
͇ͽ;ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹΁ͰΔͳͬͪ͸͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͬ
͹ͯ


;
͹ͯͫͻͪͷͫͰ͸͹ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͳͷͪ
̸͊̽
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸ͪ

t΃ͳͻͪ
;Ͷ͹ͭͪi
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͶ͹
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
ͳͷͪͶ͹
ͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ͸Ͱ

ͬͰͲͰ
ͼͪ
ͺ͹͵;΃ͪΒͳͷͪ
;ͬͶͪ΂ͰΔͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
;
̸͇͆͋
̀ͪͽ͹
ͼ;
tͬ͹ͯͳ
΂ͳi
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸ͳ
͋ͳͽ;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵;
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
͹΁ͰΔͳͬͪͶͳ
͵ͪ͹
͸Ͱͳͼ͵ͻͰ͸;
ͳ
ͼͪ
ͬͰͽ͹ͬͪͶͳ
͹ͺͻͰͲ͸͹ͼͽ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͷ
ͼͽͪͬ;
ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͶ͹ͭ;
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͽͳͱͰ
ͳͲ

̸ͽͳ͸Ͱ
͊Ͷͳ΂͸ͳ
ͻͪͲͶ͹Ͳͳ
͹ͯͻͰΌͳͬͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵;
̸͊̽
ͺͻͰͷͪ
͋;ͻ
ͼ͵͹Β
͌
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹΁ͰΔͳͬͪ͸͹
ͯͪ
ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͰ
ͯͰͿͪ͸Ͳͳͬ͸͹͹Ϳͪ͸Ͳͳͬ
 t̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻi
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͯ͸;
͹ͼ͹ͫ; 

͸Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͳͳ΁ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
͉͊͊͊;
͸ͪ
ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹ͷ
ͅͰͯͳͽͰͻͪ͸;
ͳ
̹Ͷͳͼ͵͹ͷ

ͳͼͽ͹͵;
͵͹͸ͼ͹Ͷͳͯ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͪͷͰͻͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͶͳͯͰͻͼͽͬͪ
;
ͽ͹Β
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
ͼͬͰͽͪ

ͻͳͬͪͶͳͽͰͽ
̸͊̽
ͳ
̺ͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
̹ͻͳͽͪ͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͼͽͻͪͽͰ΃͵ͳ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸͹
ͬͪͱ͸͹Β

ͺ͹Ͳͳ΁ͳΒͳ
΀Ͷͪͯ͸͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͼͺͻͰ΂ͪͬͪΔͰ
͉͊͊͊ͪ
ͯͪ
ͬͻ΃ͳ
ͺͰ͸Ͱͽͻͪ΁ͳΒ;

ͺͻͰ͵͹
Ͷͳ͸ͳΒͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͲͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂ͰΔͪ
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸͹ͭ
͸ͪ
ͪ͠Ͷͽͳ
ͳ

;
͈͹ͼͽͯͪͷ;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
͹ͯ
ͻͪͲͶ͹ͭͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͯ͹ͷͳ͸ͪ͸ͽ͸͹
͹ͯ
ͻͰΌͳͬͪͶͳ
ͪͷͰͻͳ΂͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ
Ͳͪ
͋;ͻͼ͵;
͋ͳͷͰ
ΒͰ
͹ͫΒͪ΃Δͪͬͪ͸ͪ
΂ͳΔͰ
͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͬ
͹ͯ

͋ͻ;ͷͪ͸͹ͬͪ
ͯ͹͵ͽͻͳ͸ͪ

ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹

ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
;͵Γ;΂ͳͬͪΔͪ
;
̸͇͆͋

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯ;
ͬ͹Β͸Ͱ
ͯ͹͵ͽͻͳ
͸Ͱ
͹ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͳͼͪ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
̸͊̽
͑ͪ͸ͼ;
Ͳͪ
ͬ͹ΌͰΔͰ
ͼͪͷ͹ͼͽͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ

ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵Ͱ
͠͹ͼͳͺ
̹ͻ͹Ͳ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪ͹
;
͸ͪͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͳͷͪ
͋;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͯͪ
ͻ;
͵͹ͬ͹ͯͰΕͳ
ͼͰ
ͬͶͪͼͽͳͽͳͷ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳͷ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͳͷͪ
͹΂;ͬͪ
ͼͬ͹Β;
ͼͪ
ͷ͹ͼͽͪͶ͸͹ͼͽ
t̺͹ͯͳ΂ͳi
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͳ
ͼͪ΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ
Ͳͪ
͋ͳͽ͹ͬͰ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͰ


͸Ͱͯͬ͹ͼͷͳͼͶͰ͸͹
ͼ;
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͶͳ
ͯͪ
;Ͳ
;ͼ͵;
ͼͪͻͪͯΔ;
ͼͪ
̸͊̽
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ
ͳ

͸ͪͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͰ
ͬͶͪͼͽͳ
;
̸͸͵ͪͻͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;Ͳ
ͷͪΔͰ
͵͹͸΁ͰͼͳΒͰ
ͳ
;ͼͽ;ͺ͵Ͱ
ͯ͹ͫͳ
ΒͰ
΃ͽ͹
ͬͰΕͪ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͬ͹Β͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͷ͹Ε
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͯ;ͭ͹ͻ͹΂͸ͳ
ͲͪΒͷ͹ͬͳ

͵͹Βͳ
͹ͷ͹ͭ;ΕͪͬͪΒ;
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͺͰͻͳͽͰͽ

͌ͺͻ͵͹ͼ
ͪͷͰͻͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺͻͳ
ͽͳͼ΁ͳͷͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͪͬͰͽͳͷͪ
ͪ͸ͭͪͱ͹ͬͪΔͰͷ
tͪͷͰͻͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͼͽͻ;΂Δͪ͵ͪ
͵͹͸ͽͻ͹
Ͷ͹ͷ
͸ͪͯ
Ϳͳ͸ͪ͸ͼͳΒͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͪͻͷͳΒ͹ͷ
͹ͫͶͳ͵͹ͬͪΔͰͷ
Βͪͬ͸͹ͭ
ͷͳ΃ΓͰΔͪ

ͺͻͳͯ͹ͫͳΒͪΔͰͷ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͪ
ͰͶͳͽͪ
;͹΂Γͳͬͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͫͻͳͭͪ
͹
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽͳ
ͪ;ͽͰ͸
ͽͳ΂͸ͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͼ͵ͳ΀
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ
͌
ͺ͹͵;΃ͪΒͳͷͪ
ͻͰ΃ͪͬͪΔͪ

ͼͺ͹ͻ͸ͳ΀
ͺͳͽͪΔͪ
ͳ
͸͹ͻͷͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͪ
ͼͪ
͉͊͊͊
;
͵͹͸ͽͻ͹Ͷͳ
tͻͪ
ͯͪ
ͪͷͰͻͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͼͽͻ;΂Δͪ͵ͪi
ͺ;ͽͰͷ
ͺ͹;Ͳͯͪ͸ͳ΀
ͯ͹ͷͪΕͳ΀
͵ͪͯͻ͹ͬͪ
ͳ
ͽͰ
ͱΔͳ
Ͳͪ
ͼͷͪΔͰΔͰͷ
ͪͷͰͻͳ΂͵͹ͭ
;ͽͳ΁ͪΒͪ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
ΒͰ
ͬͳͯͰ͹
Βͪͼ͸͹
͸ͪͼͽ͹
ΒͪΔͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͺ͹Γ͸ͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵ͪ
͋;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͫ;ͯͰ
ͬ͹ΌͰ͸ͪ
;
ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;
ͼ
ͬͶͪͼͽͳͽͳͷ

͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳͷ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͳͷͪ
͋͹
ΒͰ
ͼͷͪͽͻͪ͸͹
΃ͪ͸ͼ͹ͷ
Ͳͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰ͸Ͳͳͬ͸ͳΒ;

ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵;
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸;
ͼͪͻͪͯΔ;
͌
tͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪi
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸ͳͷ
͠͹ͼͳͺ;
̹ͻ͹Ͳ;
ͽͰͷͰΓ͸͹
ͼ;
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͳ
ͻͪ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͻͪͽ͸ͳ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͼͪ
͋;ͻͼ͵͹ͷ
ͳ
̻ͻ΂͵͹ͷ
͇ͯ
ͺ͹
ͶͪͲ͸ͳ΀
t͸Ͱͼͺ͹ͻͪͲ;ͷͪi
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
tͼ;ͱͪͬͪͶͳi
ͼͬͰ
ͬͳͯ͹ͬͰ

͵͹͸ͽͪ͵ͪͽͪ
t͸ͪ
͸ͪΒ͸;ͱ͸ͳΒ;
ͷͰͻ;i
ͳ
;ͽͳ΁ͪͶͳ
ͯͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳ
ͫ;ͯ;
ͳͼͺ͹ͯ

ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
t;͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͰ͸Ͱ
͵͹ͻͰ͵ͽ͸͹ͼͽͳi
ͺͻͰΌͰ͸
ΒͰ
ͯ;ͭ
ͺ;ͽ
ͯ͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ

ͼͪͻͪͯΔͰ
ͳ
ͬ͹Β͸͹ͭ
ͼͪͬͰͲ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
͈ͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
;
ͽ;ͻͼ͵͹Β
ͼͺ͹Γ͸͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ
΁ͳ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͼ;
ͯ͹΃ͶͰ
ͯ͹
ͳͲͻͪͱͪΒͪ
;

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͳ

͌
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹΁ͰΔͳͬͪ͸͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͹͸ͪ
ͳ͸ͳ΁ͳͻͪ͸ͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͳͷͪ
tͽ;ͻ
ͼ͵Ͱ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
͹ͯͫͻͪ͸Ͱi
ͳ
Ͳͪ΀ͽͰͬͳͷͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯͪ
ͯͪ
;
ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;
ͼ
ΔͰͭ͹
ͬͳͷ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͼͽͻͪͽͰ΃͵ͳͷ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵͹ͽ;ͻͼ͵͹

ͲͫͶͳͱͰΔͰ
ͫ;ͯͰ
Ͱͽͪͺͪ
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ;
ͺͻͳ͵Γ;΂ͰΔͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
̸ͽͶͪ͸ͽͼ͵͹ͷ

ͺͪ͵ͽ;
̻ͻͪΌͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͻͪͽ
;
̻ͻ΂͵͹Β
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸͹
;͵Γ;΂ͳͬͪΔͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ

 ͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
̽ͳͷͳΕ

;
ΔͰͭͪ
ͼͬͰͶͳ
ͼ;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
ͯͬͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͸ͪ
͸ͪΒͷͪΔ;
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε;
ͷͰͻ;
;
ͺͻͬͳͷ

ͺ͹ͼͶͰͻͪͽ͸ͳͷ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪͷͪ
͌ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΔ;
ͫͶͳͱͳ΀
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͪ
ͯͬͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͼ;

ͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺͳͶͰ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͬ
͹ͯ

͌
ͲͫͶͳͱͪͬͪΔ;
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͳ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
̀ͪͺͪͯ

ΒͰ
ͬͳͯͰ͹
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ͸
͵͹ͻͪ͵
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ;
t͵͹͸ͼ͹Ͷͳͯͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂
Βͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͺͻͰ͵;
Ͳͪ
ͰͬͰ͸ͽ;ͪͶ͸;
ͼ͹ͬΒͰͽͼ͵;
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͬͰ͸΁ͳΒ;i
͈ͳͽͪΔͰ
ͬ͹Β͸Ͱ

ͼͪͻͪͯΔͰ
ͽͻͳ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ

ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͺͻͬͳ
ͺ;ͽ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸͹
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ


͆ͪͼ;ͺͻ͹ͽ
͸ͪͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͳͷͪ
̸͸͵ͪͻͰ
ͳ
̸ͽͳ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪΔͰͷ

ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
͹ͯͫͻͪ͸Ͱ
͵͹Βͪ
ͫͳ
ͯ͹ͺͻͳ͸ͰͶͪ
͹ͺ΃ͽ͹Β
ͫͰͲͫͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
͸ͪͽͰ
ͻͪͶͪ
̸͇͆͋
ͯͪ
ͫͻͳ͸Ͱ
͹
͹ͯͫͻͪ͸ͳ
΁ͰͶ͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

ΒͰ
;
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵;
ͺͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽ
ͯͪͬͪ͹
ͺͻ͹΃ͳͻͳͬͪΔ;
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ͸ͳ΀
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͪ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸ͳ΀
ͬͰͲͪ
ͺͪ
ͽͰ͵
͹͸ͯͪ
ͬ͹Β͸ͳ΀
͵͹͸ͽͪ͵ͪͽͪ
͌
tͬ͹ͯͳ
΂ͳͷͪi
ͼ;
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸͹
ͻͰͭͳͼͽͻ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͼͬͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
͵͹͸ͽͪ͵ͽͳ
̽Ͱ͵Ͷͪ
ͻͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͽͻͳΒ;
ͬͶͪͯͪ
͹ͯ

Β;͸ͪ

̓͹͸ͿͰͻͰ͸΁ͳΒͪ
ͽͻͳΒ;
ͷͳ͸ͳͼͽͪͻͪ

;
̸ͽͳ͸ͳ
m
͌ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ
͹
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͻͪΔ;
͊ͽͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͼͰ͵ͻͰͽͪͻͳΒͪͽͪ

̸͸͵ͪͻͼ͵͹ͭ
;ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͪ
͹ͯ


ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ
ͯͰͶͰͭͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ͸ͳ͵ͪ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
ͻͪͯ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͬ͹Β͸ͳ΀
ͼͽͻ;΂Δͪ͵ͪ
΂Ͱͽͳͻͳ
ͬ͹Β͸ͪ
ͼͪͬͰͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ


͌͹΂ͪͬͪ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵ͪ
ͼͪͬͰͲ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
ͺ͹Ͳͳͽͳͬ͸͹ͭ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳ
Ͷͪ
;ͬͰ͵
ͳͼ͵ͻͰ͸ͪ
ͳ
;
ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;
ͼ
ͻͰͪͶ͸ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͪͷͪ
͇ͬͳͼ͸͹ͼͽ
͹
ͺ͹ͷ͹Ε

͵͹Β;
ͼ;
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͪͶͰ
͹ͯ
̀ͪͺͪͯͪ
;ͽͳ΁ͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵ͪ
͵͹Β;
ͬ͹ͯͰ
͸ͪΒ
ͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͽͰͱͳͻͪ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
ͳ
͸ͪ
;΃ͽͻͫ
ͪ;ͽͰ͸ͽͳ΂͸ͳ΀
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ
͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ
̸͊̽
͋͹
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΔͰ
ͼ;ͭͰͻͳͼͪͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͺͰͻͷͪ͸Ͱ͸ͽ͸ͳ
͹ͺͻͰͲ
ͳ

ͽͰͷͰΓ͸͹
ͺͻ͹ͷͳ΃ΓͪΔͰ
ͼͬͪ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͽͳͲͪͶͪ
ͳͲ

̸͸͵ͪͻͰ
ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͳͲ
̸ͽͳ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͽͳͼ΁ͳ
ͯͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
ͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺͳ
̸͆
͇͋;
ͺ͹͵;΃ͪΒͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͳͲͷͰ͸ͳ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ
̸͸͵ͪͻͼ͵͹ͭ
;ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͪ
͹ͻͳΒͰ͸
ͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͼͪͬͰͲ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͸ͪ
ͺͶͪ͸͹ͬͰ
̸͊̽

͈͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͼ͵ͻͰͽͪ͸ͪ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
͸ͪ

ͺ͹ͬͰΕͪΔͰ
;ͽͳ΁ͪΒͪ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
;
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸;
͵ͪ͹
ͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ͸;
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯͳ΁;
ΔͰ͸͹ͭ

;΂Ͱ΃Εͪ
;
͹͵ͬͳͻͳͷͪ
̸͸͵ͪͻͼ͵͹ͭ
;ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͪ
͈ͻͰͲͰ͸ͽ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͭ͹ͬ͹
ͻͳ
ͳͲ
Βͪ͸;ͪͻͪ

ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͳͻͪ͸Ͱ
͹ͯͻͰͯͫͰ
̸͸͵ͪͻͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͺ͹ͻͪͲ;ͷͪ


ͿͰͫͻ;ͪͻ


ͽͰͷͰΓ͸͹
ͺͻͰͽͻͰͼͰ͸ͳ

ͷ͹ͯͪͶͳͽͰͽͳ
ͬ͹Β͸Ͱ
ͼͪͻͪͯΔͰ
ͳ

͹ͼͽͬͪͻͰ͸ͳ
͵͹͸ͽͪ͵ͽͳ
͸ͪ
ͽ͹ͷ
ͺ͹Γ;
ͼ͵ͻͰ͸;ͽͪ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͫͪͬͰͲͰ
͵͹ΒͰ

͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ
ͳͷͪ
;
͹͵ͬͳͻͳͷͪ
͊ͰͬͰͻ͸͹ͭ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹ͭ
ͺͪ͵ͽͪ
͇͉͆̾̾ͅ
͇̽

ͼͪͭͶͰͯͪ͸ͳ
;΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͶ͹Ͳͳ
ͳ
ͳ͸ͳ΁ͳΒͪͽͳͬͰ

͵͹Βͳ
ͬ͹ͯͰ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;
΂ͰΔ;
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͪͬͰͲͪ
t̺͹ͯͳ΂ͳi
ͼ;
ͺ͹͸;ͯͳͶͳ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͭͻ΃ͽ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻ
ͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͹
ͼͪͻͪͯΔͳ
;
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͺͻ͹ͺͪͭͪ͸ͯͰ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸ͳ΀
ͬͰ
Ͳͪ
ͼͿͰͻͳ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͳΒͰ
t̺͹ͯͳ΂ͳi
ͼ;
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͶͳ
͹
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β;
ͽͻͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀

͹ͯ͸͹ͼͪ

ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͳ
ͽͻͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͻͪͲͷͰ͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͳͷͪ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵Ͱ

ͼͪͻͪͯΔͰ
͠Ͱͯ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
ͽͰͷͪ
ͫͳͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͺͳͽͪΔͰ
ͳͼͰΓͪͬͪΔͪ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
͸ͪ΁ͳ
͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͷͪΔͳ͸Ͱ
ͳͲ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͺ͹
͸Ͱ͵ͳͷ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱ͸ͪͷͪ
ͻͪͯͳͶ͹
ͼͰ
͹

ͺ͹ͽͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͶ͸͹ͷ
ͳͼͰΓͪͬͪΔ;
͹͵͹

͋;ͻͪ͵ͪ
͹ͯ

͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͳ΀
ΒͰ

 t̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻi
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͯ͸;
͹ͼ͹ͫ; 

ͫͳͶ͹
;
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ

͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷ
͹ͫͰ΃ͽͰΕͰΔͪ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸Ͱ

ͳͷ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵ͳ΀
ͯͻͱͪͬΓͪ͸ͪ
͇ͯ
͸ͰͻͰ΃Ͱ͸ͳ΀
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳͷͪ
ͼͪ

̻ͻ΂͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸;
ͽͰͱͳ͸;
ΒͰ
ͳͷͪͶ͹
ͺͳͽͪΔͰ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͷͪΔͳ͸Ͱ
;
͠Ͱ
ͭͰΒͼ͵͹Β
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷ
ͳͲͫͰͭͶͳ΁ͪ
͹͵͹

Γ;ͯͳ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ΒͰ


ͲͪͫͻͪΔͰ͸
ͺ͹ͬͻͪͽͪ͵
;
͹ͽͪΘͫͳ͸;

͸ͰͻͰ΃Ͱ͸ͳ
ͼͽͪͽ;ͼ
͎ͳͶͪ͸ͯͪͻͪ

ͳ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͯͪ
͹͸
Ͳͪͯͻͱͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ
͹ͫ͸͹ͬͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸
ͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
Ͳ͹͸Ͱ
;
͊͹Ͷ;͸;
ͳͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͺͳͽͪΔͪ
͆͹
ͳ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹
ΒͰΕͳ΀
ͽͰ΃͵͹Εͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
;
ͺͻͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͷͪ
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
ͺͻͰͬͪͲͳΕͳ
;
ͺͻ͹ͶͰΕͰ


ΒͰ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪͶ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͪͻͪͯΔͪ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
̻ͻ΂͵Ͱ
͋;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ

͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͳͷͪ
ͫ;ͯ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
̸͸ͪͶͳͲͪ
ΒͰ
;ͺ;ΕͳͬͪͶͪ
͸ͪ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂ͪ͵
ͯͪ
;Ͳ

͸Ͱͼ;ͷΔͳͬ;
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫ;
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͼͪͻͪͯΔ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͰ
ͳ
͵͹͸͵ͻͰͽ͸ͳ

Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͳ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͰ













͋ͰͷͰΓ͸ͪ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
͠͹ͼͳͺ
̹ͻ͹Ͳ
͋ͳͽ͹
ͷͪΒͪ
ͳ

Β;͸ͪ

;΂ͳ͸ͳ͹
̸͸͵ͪͻͳ
ͳ
̸ͽͳ͸ͳ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ΕͰ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲͪͽͳ
;
͵͹Β͹Β
ΒͰ

ͷͰͻͳ
ͺͻͳͫͻͪ͸͹
ͳ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽ͹ͬͪ͸͹
;
tͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪi

͸ͪ΃Ͷ͹
͹ͯͻͪͲͪ
;
ͺ͹Ͷͳ
ͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͻͪͲͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͷͪ
ͬ͹ΌͰ͸ͳͷ
ͽͳͷ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ
͌ͬͳͯ
;
ͽͰ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰͬͻͼ͸Ͱ

tͫͰͯͰ͵ͰͻͰi
ͺͻͪͬΓͰ͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͯ͸;
͹ͼ͹ͫ;
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͬͰΕ
ͻͰ΂ͳͽ͹
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ

͹
͹ͲͫͳΓ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂ͪͻͪ

͌ͽͰͷͰΓͰ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͳ
ͼͪͽ͵ͪ͸ͳ
͹ͯ
ͺͻ͹ͬͰͻͰ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͻͪͲ͸͹Ͷͳ͵ͳ΀

ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͼͽͪͬ͹ͬͪ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͽͳ΂͸ͳ
ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳ

tͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳi
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵;
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ;
ͳ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͳΒ;
ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;͵ͽͳͬͪ͸
ͼ;
ͺ;
ͽ͹͵ͪͲ
Ͳͪ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪΔͰ
ͺ͹Ͳͳ΁ͳΒͪ
tͷͪͶͳ΀i
ͷͰΌ;
tͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͷͪi
;
ͺͻͰͶ͹ͷ
͸ͳͷ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪͷͪ
͎Ͷͪͯ͸͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
 ͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
̽ͳͷͳΕ

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

-KVCPESBH
%JNJǀ
&JO
3FJTFGÛISFS
GÛS
FJOF
1FSTPO

FJO
#FJUSBH
[VS
(FTDIJDIUF
EFS
%JQMPNBUJF

EFT
TP[JBMJTUJTDIFO
+VHPTMBXJFOT

*O
EFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO
EJF
GÛS
+PTJQ
#SP[
JO
EFS
/BDILSJFHT[FJU
WFSGBTTU

XVSEFO
XVSEFO
#F[JFIVOHFO
[XJTDIFO
+VHPTMBXJFO
FJOFSTFJUT
VOE
EFS

5ÛSLFJ
VOE
(SJFDIFOMBOE
BOEFSFSTFJU
HSÛOEMJDI
BOBMZTJFSU
7PO
BOGÅOHMJDIFO

t.JTTWFSTUÅOEOJTTFOi
EJF
BMMF
,POUBLUF
QPMJUJTDI
BVG
FJO
.JOEFTUNB“
tCFTDI
SÅOLUFOi
XFTIBMC
EJFTF
#F[JFIVOHFO
VOUFS
EFS
4DIXFMMF
EFT
ÛCMJDI
,PSSFLUFO

HFIBMUFO
XVSEFO
CJT
[VS
QPMJUJTDIFO
;VTBNNFOBSCFJU
VOE
NJMJUÅSJTDIFO

"MMJBO[
NVTTUF
NBO
FJOFO
MBOHFO
8FH
HFIFO

*O
EJFTFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO
XVSEFO
BMMF
QPMJUJTDIFO
,POUBLUF
QSÅ[JT
BVGHF[ÅIMU

%FLMBSBUJPO
ESFJFS
3FHJFSVOHFO
WPN

+VOJ

,POGFSFO[
ESFJFS
.JOJTUFS

JO
"UIFO
WPN

CJT
[VN

+VMJ

7FSUSBH
[VS
#JMEVOH
EFT
TUÅOEJHFO

4FLSFUBSJBUT
EFT
7FSUSBHT
JO
"UIFO
WPN

/PWFNCFS


FCFOTPXPIM
XJF

#FTVDIF
XJSUTDIBGUMJDIFS
LVMUVSFMMFS
NJMJUÅSJTDIFS
%FMFHBUJPOFO
[#
WJFS

.JMJUÅSUBHVOHFO

&T
LBN
[VN
7PSTDIFJO
EBTT
EJF
1PMJUJL
EFS
7FSCÛOEFUFO
USPU[

BMMFS
QPTJUJWFO
"TQFLUF
OJDIU
JNNFS
FISMJDI
VOE
CFTUFIFOEFO
#FEÛSGOJTTFO

FOUTQSFDIFOU
GPSNVMJFSU
XVSEF



3FJTFGÛISFS
CPUFO
BVDI
WJFMGÅMUJHF
*OGPSNBUJPOFO
IJOTJDIUMJDI
EFS
;VT
BNNFOBSCFJU

JN
#FSFJDI
,VMUVS

(FTFMMTDIBGUT
VOE
8JSUTDIBGUTCF[JFIVOHFO

BO
VOE
UIFNBUJTJFSUFO
VOUFSTDIJFEMJDIF
'SBHFO
FUXB
&OUXJDLMVOH
EFS

)BOEFMTCF[JFIVOHFO
4USVLUVS
WPO
)BOEFMTBVTUBVTDI
1SPCMFNF
EFS
XJSU
TDIBGUMJDIFO
;VTBNNFOBSCFJU
&JOFT
EFS
5IFNFO
XBS
BVDI
EBT
1IÅOPNFO

EFS
"VTXBOEFSVOH
EFS
UÛSLJTDIFO
/BUJPOBMNJOEFSIFJU
BVT
+VHPTMBXJFO
OBDI

NBODIFO
&JOTDIÅU[VOHFO
IBOEFMUF
FT
TJDI
VN

QPUFOUJFMMF
"VTXBOEFSFS

WPO
JOTHFTBNU

JO
+VHPTMBXJFO
BOTÅTTJHFO
5ÛSLFO

VOE
EBT
1SPCMFN

EFS
&OUTDIÅEJHVOH
GÛS
FOUFJHOFUF
#FTJU[UÛNFS
EFS
UÛSLJTDIFO
#ÛSHFS
"VG

[XJTDIFOTUBBUMJDIFO
#F[JFIVOHFO
NJU
(SJFDIFOMBOE
MBTUFUFO
VOUFS
BMMFO

VOHFMÕTUFO
'SBHFO
JO
FSTUFS
-JOJF
EJF
-BHF
EFS
NBLFEPOJTDIFO
.JOEFSIFJU
JN

¨HÅZJTDIFO
.BLFEPOJFO
EBT
1SPCMFN
EFS
'MÛDIUMJOHF
FT
IBOEFMUF
TJDI
VN

FUXB

.FOTDIFO
EFOFO

EJF
3ÛDLLFIS
JO
EJF
)FJNBU
WFSXFJHFSU

XVSEF

EFS
VOHFMÕTUF
4UBUVT
WPN
$IJMBOEBS
EFTTFO
/BUJPOBMDIBSBLUFS
OPDI

[V
FSLÅNQGFO
XBS
EJF
8JFEFSBVGSJDIUVOH
EFS
GSFJFO
KVHPTMBXJTDIFO
;POF

JO
5IFTTBMPOJLJ
7FSNÕHFOTGSBHFO
%JFTFO
4DIXJFSJHLFJUFO
[VN
5SPU[
EJF

FT
JO
7FSIBOEMVOHFO
[V
ÛCFSXJOEFO
HBMU
TDIJFO
JN
'SÛIMJOH

EBTT

EJF
;VTBNNFOBSCFJU
ESFJFS
#BMLBOTUBBUFO
+VHPTMBXJFO
(SJFDIFOMBOE
EJF

5ÛSLFJ

[VLVOGUTUSÅDIUJH
JTU
"OBMZTFO
MJF“FO
EFO
4DIMVTT
[V
EBTT
FT
OFCFO

 t̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻi
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͯ͸;
͹ͼ͹ͫ; 

VOCFTUSFJUCBSFN
#FEBSG
BO
QPMJUJTDIFS
;VTBNNFOBSCFJU
BVDI
XFJUFSF
LPOLSFUF

8JSUTDIBGUTJOUFSFTTFO
VOE
,VMUVSCFEÛSGOJTTF
HÅCF

(SÛOEMJDIF
6OUFSTVDIVOHFO
EFS
#FTVDIF
EJF
+PTJQ
#SP[
5JUP
JN
.BJ

VOE
+VOJ

JO
"OLBSB
VOE
"UIFO
BCTUBUUFUF
XÛSEFO
TJDIFSMJDI
[FJHFO

JOXJFXFJU
TJDI
*OGPSNBUJPOFO
BVT
EFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO
JO
QPMJUJTDIFO
(FTQSÅDIFO

XJEFSTQJFHFMUFO
EJF
CFJ
TPMDIFO
(FMFHFOIFJUFO
HFGÛISU
XVSEFO
"VDI
FJOF

GMÛDIUJHF
&JOTJDIUOBINF
JO
EJFTF
GÛS
FJOF
1FSTPO
WFSGBTTUFO
3FJTFGÛISFS
[FVHU

BCFS
WPO
EFS
&SOTUIBGUJHLFJU
FJOFT
4UBBUFT
FJOFS
1PMJUJL
VOE
FJOFT
1PMJUJLFST
(VU

CFHSÛOEFU
SFJDI
HFTUBMUFU
BVG
ÛCFSQSÛGUFO
%BUFO
WJFMGÅMUJHFO
*OGPSNBUJPOFO

VOE
QPMJUJTDIFO
&JOTUFMMVOHFO
CFSVIFOE
BOBMZUJTDI
VOE
JOTUSVLUJW
TUFMMFO
EJFTF

3FJTFGÛISFS
JN
#FSFJDI
1PMJUJL
(FTDIJDIUF
VOE
8JSUTDIBGU
FJOFO
[VWFSMÅTTTJHFO

8FHXFJTFS
[VS
"VGLMÅSVOH
EFS
4UFMMVOH
WPO
tLMFJOFOi
VOE
tHSP“FOi
JO
EFO

FOUTDIFJEFOEFO
+BISFO
EFT
LBMUFO
,SJFHT
EFS


͇ͭΔͰ͸
̸̹̓́ͣ
͍ͪ͵;ͶͽͰͽ
Ͳͪ
;ͼͶ;ͱ͸ͳ
ͫͳͲ͸ͳͼ
͆͹ͬͳ
͊ͪͯ

̺͇̽́͐́
̸̀
͈͌͋͆́̓̾

͌
̸̾͆ͦ̾͆͋͌ͅͅ

͈͉͇͇ͅ͏͇͇̻́͆

̸́̓͊ͅ
̸̸̸̹̈́̓͆

̸͇̓
͉͋͌́͊͋́͐̓̾

̸̽̾͊͋́͆͏́̾͠


͈ͻ͹ͿͳͶͳͼͪΔͰ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ

͌
ͯͪ͸ͪ΃Δͳͷ
;ͼͶ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͯ͹ͷͳ͸ͳͻͪΔͪ
t;ͼͶ;ͱ͸Ͱ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͳΒͰi

;
΂ͳΒͳͷ
͹͵ͬͳͻͳͷͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
Ͳͪ;Ͳͳͷͪ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͰ
ͷͰͼͽ͹
ͺ͹
ͫͻ͹Β
͸ͳͷ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳͷ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
΃ͳͻͳͷ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸ͳͷ
͵͹͸͹ͽͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
;
ͼͳ
ͽ;ͪ΁ͳΒͳ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͳͲ͹΃ͽͻͰ͸Ͱ
͵͹͸͵;ͻͰ͸ͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͫ͹ͻͫͰ
Ͳͪͺ͹ͼͰͯ͸;ͽ͹ͼͽͳ

ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽͪ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯͳͷͪ
ͽΒ
;ͼͶ;ͭͪͷͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ
ͳͲͪͲ͹ͬ

ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
͵ͻͰͳͻͪΔͰ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͿͳͶͳͼͪΔͰ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͫͳ
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹

ͯͪ
ͫ;ͯͰ
͸͹ͬͳ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽ;
͇ͬ͹
ͬͪͱͳ
ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂ΒͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ

ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͳͷͪΒ;
;
ͬͳͯ;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯͳ

Ͳͪ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸ͪ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼ;
͸Ͱͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͪ

ͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͻͰͶͪͽͳͬ͸͹
ͷͪΔͰ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͪ
͸ͪ
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽ;
͌ͺͻͪͬ͹
ͽͪ͵ͬ͹
ΒͰͯ͸͹

ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂ΒͰ
ΒͰ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
͵͹Βͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯ

͸ͳΒͰ
ͯ͹
ͼͪͯͪ
͸ͳ
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͻͪ͸
ͪ
͸ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹ͬͳͼͪ͸
͵ͪ͹
tͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΂͵ͳi

ͽΒ
ͳ͸ͽͰͭͻͳͼͪ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͭͪ
ͼͪ΂ͳΔͪͬͪ
Β;
͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵;
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͽͳ
͵ͪ͹
tͷͪΔͰ
ͳͶͳ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ

Ͳͪ͹͵ͻ;ͱͰ͸;
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵;
΁ͰͶͳ͸;
͵͹Βͪ
ͻͪͼͺ͹ͶͪͱͰ
ͪͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳͷ



0ͭΔF͸
̹B͵ͳΕ
ͅBͻ͵Fͽͳ͸ͭ
ͷF͸BΘͷF͸ͽ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F
ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳKF

&͵P͸Pͷͼ͵ͳ
ͿB͵;ͶͽFͽ
̹FPͭͻBͯ

 ͇ͭΔͰ͸
̹ͪ͵ͳΕ

͵͹ͷ;͸ͳ͵ͪͽͳͬ͸ͳͷ
ͳ
ͻͰ΁Ͱͺͽͳͬ͸ͳͷ
Ϳͪ͵ͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
ͽΒ
ͼͬͳͷ
͹͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͳͻ͹
ͯ͸ͳͷ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸ͳͷ
ͪ͸ͽͻ͹ͺ͹ͭͰ͸ͳͷ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪ
ΕͪΒ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻͰͽͺ͹ͼͽͪͬ͵ͪͷͪ
Ͳͪ
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͪΒ
ͳͼ΀ͻͪ͸;
͹ͯͷ͹ͻ
ͻͰ͵ͻͰͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͳ

Ͳͪͫͪͬ;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
ͽΒ
ͳͲͭͻͪΌͰ͸ͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ
i
͆Ͱ
ͼͺ͹ͻͰΕͳ
ͺ͹ͼͽͳͭ͸;ͽͰ
ͻͰͲ;ͶͽͪͽͰ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
;
ͯ͹
ͼͪͯͪ΃ΔͰͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β;
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͳͷͪΒ;Εͳ
;
ͬͳͯ;
ΒͰͯ͸;

΃ͳͻ;
Ͷͳͼͽ;
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹͵ͪͲͪͽͰΓͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
͸ͺͻ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ

ͺͻ͹ͷͰͽ
͹ͼͽͬͪͻͰ͸ͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͽͻ͹΃Δͪ
ͳͲͭͻͪΌͰ͸͹ͼͽ
͵ͪͺͪ΁ͳͽͰͽͪ

Ͳͪ
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͪΒ
ͳ
ͳͼ΀ͻͪ͸;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
͸Ͱ͹ͺ΀͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
͵ͪͺͪ΁ͳͽͰͽͪ

ͳ͸Ϳͻͪ
ͳ
ͼ;ͺͻͪ
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͰ
ͷͳ΃ΓͰΔͪ
ͼͷ͹
ͯͪ
͹ͬ͹
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͪͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹

ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂ΒͰ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͳ͸ͽͰͭͻͳͼͪΔͰͷ
ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳ΀
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ

ͻͪͲͬ͹Β;
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͳͭ͸Ͱ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͈͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͳͷͪΒ;
;
ͬͳͯ;

ͳ
ͳͲͻͪͱͰ͸Ͱ
͵͹ͷͺͪͻͪͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
;
ͯ͹ͷͰ͸;
ͪͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ

͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
ͪ
͸ͪͯͪͼͬͰ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͭ
͹͵ͻ;ͱͰΔͪ
ͪ
͹͸ͯͪ
ͳ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͫ͹
ͭͪͽ͹ͭ
ͳ
;͸ͳ͵ͪͽ͸͹ͭ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳ΀

ͬͳͼ͹͵͹ͬͻͰͯ͸ͳ΀
ͪ͸ͽͻ͹ͺ͹ͭͰ͸ͳ΀
Ϳͪ͵ͽ͹ͻͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
͸ͺͻ
ͷͰͶ͹ͼ

͸͹΃ΔͰ
Ϳ͹Ͷ͵Ͷ͹ͻ
ͭͪͼͽͻ͹͸͹ͷͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
Ϳͪ͵ͽ͹ͻͳ
͊ͬͰ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸͹

ͯͪΒͰ
ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͰͶͰͷͰ͸ͽͪͽͪ
Ͳͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;Εͳ
ͫͻͱͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
͸ͪ
ͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
ͼͰͶͰ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳ΀
ͬͳͯ͹ͬͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
ͫͪͲͳͻͪ͸ͳ΀
͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳͷ

ͺͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
;ͺ͹ͻͳ΃ͽͰ
ͳͷͪΒ;
;
;͸ͳ͵ͪͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͻͰͽ͵͹ͼͽͳ

ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ΀
Ϳͪ͵ͽ͹ͻͪ
͈ͻ͹ͿͳͶͳͼͪΔͰ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͸ͰΕͰ

ͫͳͽͳ
;ͼͺͰ΃͸͹
;͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͼͰ
͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͷͰ͸Ͱ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ
ͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺͳ
ͽͻ
ͱͳ΃͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͪΔ;
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
͹͸ͳ
ͳͲ
ͯ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
ͷͰ͸ͪΘͷͰ͸ͽͪ
ͽΒ

ͺͶͪ͸ͳͻͪΔͪ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͳ
͵͹͸ͽͻ͹ͶͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ΀
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ

͌
ͽͳͷ
͹͵ͬͳͻͳͷͪ
ͷͪͻ͵Ͱͽͳ͸ͭ
͵ͪ͹
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸͹Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼ

ͿͳͶ͹Ͳ͹ͿͳΒͪ
ͳ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͪ
ͺ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͳͷͪΒ;
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͬͪͱ͸;
;Ͷ͹ͭ;

͇ͽ;ͯͪ
ͺ͹
͸ͪ΃Ͱͷ
ͷͳ΃ΓͰΔ;
ͺͻͳͷͰ͸ͪ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺͽ;ͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͷ͹ͯͰͶͪ
Ͳͪ

ͷͪͻ͵Ͱͽͳ͸ͭ
ͷͰ͸ͪΘͷͰ͸ͽ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͫͳͽͳ
ͻͰ
ͶͰͬͪ͸ͽͪ͸
͇ͬͪΒ
ͷ͹ͯͰͶ
͹ͫ;΀ͬͪͽͪ
ͬͰΕͳ
ͫͻ͹Β
ͰͶͰͷͰ͸ͪͽͪ

ͪ

ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲ;
Ͱ͵ͼͽͰͻ͸͹ͭ
͹͵ͻ;ͱͰΔͪ
ͫ

ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲ;
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸ͳ΀
ͻͰͼ;ͻͼͪ

ͬ

ͯͰͿͳ͸ͳͼͪΔͰ
ͷͳͼͳΒͰ
΁ͳΓͰͬͪ
ͳ
ͼͷͰͻ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͭ

Ϳ͹ͻͷ;ͶͳͼͪΔͰ
ͭͶ͹ͫͪͶ͸ͳ΀

ͷͪͻ͵Ͱͽͳ͸ͭ
ͼͽͻͪͽͰͭͳΒͪ
ͯ

ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
ͼͽͻͪͽͰͭͳΒͪ
Ͳͪ
ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;ͷͰ͸ͽͰ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͽΒ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯ
΁Ͱ͸Ͱ
͵ͪ͸ͪͶͰ

ͺͻ͹ͯͪΒͰ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹΁ͳΒ;


Ό

Ϳ͹ͻͷ;ͶͳͼͪΔͰ
͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪΒ;ΕͰ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸͹ͼͽͳ

͇͆͋
ͳ
̸͆͋

ͳ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͳ΀
ͼͳͼͽͰͷͪ
Ͱ

͵͹͸ͽͻ͹Ͷ;
ͳ

ͻͰͬͳͲͳΒ;
ͼͬͳ΀
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ



0ͭΔͰ͸
̹B͵ͳΕ
ͳͼͽP
 ̺͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
;
ͷͰ͸ͪΘͷͰ͸ͽ;
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹΁ͳ͹͸͹ͭ
ͷͳ͵ͼͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ 


͊ͪͯͻͱͪΒ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺͽ;ͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͷ͹ͯͰͶͪ
Ͳͪ
ͷͪͻ͵Ͱͽͳ͸ͭ
ͷͰ͸ͪΘͷͰ͸ͽ

̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ

͊ͳͽ;ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͺͻͬͳ
͵͹ͻͪ͵
;
ͷͰ͸ͪΘͷͰ͸ͽ;
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ

͵ͪ͹
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲ;
ͷͪ͵ͻ͹P͵ͻ;ͱͰΔͪ

ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽͪ
͵͹͸͵;ͻͰ͸΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸͹ͭ
͹͵ͻ;ͱͰΔͪ
͆͹ͻͷͪͶ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹Εͳ
͹ͯ

ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
ͽͻͰ͸ͯ͹ͬͪ
ͳ
ͽͰ͸ͯͰ͸΁ͳΒͪ
;
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵͹ͷ

ͼ͹΁ͳ͹͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͷ
ͽͰ΀͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͯͰͷ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹ͷ
ͳ

ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͷ
͹͵ͻ;ͱͰΔ;
ͅ͹ͻͪΒ;
ͼͰ
;ͬͪͱͪͬͪͽͳ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͳ
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΔͪ
͹

͸ͺͻ
Ϳ͹͸ͯ;
ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯ͸͹ͭ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
͵͹Βͳͷ
ͻͪͼͺ͹ͶͪͱͰ
ͺ͹ͽͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͶ͸ͪ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͽͻͪͱΔͪ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪͷͪ
;
͸ͳͬ͹;
ͯͳͼ͵ͻͰ΁ͳ͹͸͹ͭ
ͯ͹΀͹ͽ͵ͪ

ͻͪͼͽ;
ͺͻͳͷͰ͸Ͱ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳ͹͸Ͱ
ͽͰ΀͸͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪͷͪ
;
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͳ

ͺ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΁Ͱ
ͺ͹ͬͰΕͪΔ;
͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬ͸͹ͭ
͸ͳͬ͹ͪ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪͷͪ

;
͸ͪͬͳ͵ͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͿͰͻͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͳͷͪ
;
ͼͷͳͼͶ;

ͬͰΕͰͭ
ͫͻ͹Βͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͳ
ͷͪ͵ͼͳͷͪͶ͸͹ͭ

Ͳͪͯ͹ͬ͹ΓͪͬͪΔͪ
ͳͲͯͳͿͰͻͰ͸΁ͳͻͪ͸ͳ΀
Ͳͪ΀ͽͰͬͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͽͻͪͱΔͰ

ͽΒ
Ͳͪ΀ͽͰͬͳͷͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͽͻͪͱΔͰ
Ͳͪ
;΂Ͱͼͽͬ͹ͬͪΔͰ
;
ͼͺͰ΁ͳΒͪͶ͸ͳͷ

ͬͻͼͽͪͷͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
ͳ
ͼͶ
͋ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
ͷ͹ͻͪΒ;
ͫͳͽͳ
ͯ͹ͺ;ΔͰ͸ͳ
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΔͳͷͪ
͹
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪͷͪ
͸ͪ

ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽ;
ͽΒ
͹
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
ͬͰͶͳ΂ͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͼ͸ͪͭͰ
ͺ͹ͽͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͶ͸͹Β
ͳ

ͻͰͪͶ͸͹Β
ͽͻͪͱΔͳ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵͹Β
ͼ͸ͪͲͳ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ΀
ͼͰͭͷͰ͸ͪͽͪ
ͽͻͪͱΔͰ
ͪ

ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
͹
͵͹͸͵;ͻͰ͸΁ͳΒͳ
ͽΒ
͵͹
ͼ;
ͽͳ
͵͹͸͵;ͻͰ͸ͽͳ
͵ͪ͵ͬͪ

ΒͰ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͪ
ͺ͹Ͳͳ΁ͳΒͪ
͸ͪ
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽ;
;
͵͹Β͹Β
ͿͪͲͳ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ͸͹ͭ
΁ͳ͵Ͷ;ͼͪ
ͼͰ

͹͸ͳ
͸ͪͶͪͲͰ
ͳ
ͼͶ
͇ͬͰ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͯͪΒ;
ΒͰͯ͸;
΃ͳͻ;
Ͷͳͼͽ;
΃ͪ͸ͼͳ

ͳ
ͺͻͰͽΔͳ
ͭͯͰ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͬͰ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫ͸͹
ͷͪ͵ͼͳͷͪͶ͸͹
ͳͼ͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳͽͳ
ͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ

ͳͲͫͰΕͳ
͊ͶͰͯͳ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸ͳ΀
ͻͰͼ;ͻͼͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͫͳ
ͽͻͰͫͪͶ͹
ͯͪ
ͺ͹͵ͪͱͰ

ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱ
ͼͶͪͫͰ
ͳ
Βͪ͵Ͱ
ͽͪ΂͵Ͱ
;
ͼͬͳͷ
FͶFͷF͸ͽͳͷB
ͻFͶFͬB͸ͽ͸ͳͷ
ͲB

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͫͳͲ͸ͳͼ
ͼͽBΔF
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Pͭ
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯB
ͽK
BͽͻB͵
ͽͳͬ͸Pͼͽ
ͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺB΂͸Pͼͽ
ͳ
;ͼͶPͬͰ
ͲB
ͫPͻBͬB͵
͵BP
ͳ
ͼͽBΔF
PͼͽB
Ͷͳ΀
FͶFͷF͸BͽB
ͷBͻ͵Fͽͳ͸ͭ
ͷͳ͵ͼB
Pͯ͸Pͼ͸P
΁F͸B
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳKF
ͳ
͵B
͸BͶB
ͺͻPͯBKF

͌
͵PͻFͼͺPͯF͸΁ͳK;
ͼF
ͯPͬPͯF
ͳ͸ͽFͻ͸F
ͺͻFͯ͸Pͼͽͳ
ͼB

F͵ͼͽFͻ͸ͳͷ
΃B͸ͼBͷB
̽FͿͳ͸ͳͼBΔF
ͷͳͼͳKF
΁ͳΓFͬB
ͳ
ͼͷFͻ͸ͳ΁B
KF
͸BͻFͯ͸ͳ
͵PͻB͵

;
ͷF͸BΘͷF͸ͽ;
͋ͻFͫB
KBͼ͸P
ͯFͿͳ͸ͳͼBͽͳ
ͼͬͻ΀;
ͳͶͳ
;ͶPͭ;
̹BͶ͵B͸B

͵BP
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F
ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳKF
͊ͬB͵B͵P
ͯB
ͷͳͼͳKB
ͷPͻB
ͯB
PͯͻBͲͳ



"MBTUBJS
.
.PSSJTPO
)PTQJUBMJUZ
BOE
5SBWFM
.BSLFUJOH
%FMNBS
ѮPNTPO
-FBSOJOH
64"



%BWJE
8FBWFS
-BVSB
-BXUPO
5PVSJTN
.BOBHFNFO
+PIO
8JMFZ
BOE
4POT

"VTUSBMJB

 ͇ͭΔͰ͸
̹ͪ͵ͳΕ

ͱFΓ;
ͯB
PͬB
ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳKB
ͺPͼͽB͸F
ͺPͲ͸BͽB
͸B
ͷFΌ;͸BͻPͯ͸Pͷ
ͽ;

ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Pͷ
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽ;
0͸B
ͷPͱF
ͻBͲͶͳ΂ͳͽP
ͯB
ͼF
ͯFͿͳ͸ͳ΃F
BͶͳ

KF
ͫͳͽB͸
͵P͸ͼF͸Ͳ;ͼ
ͲFͷBΓB
͵PKF
΂ͳ͸F
PͬP
ͺPͯͻ;΂KF
́ͲB
ͽPͭB
ͼͶFͯͳ

ͿPͻͷ;ͶͳͼBΔF
΁ͳΓFͬB
͵PKͳ
ͼ;
͸BK΂F΃ΕF
ͳͲͻBͱF͸ͳ
;
͵ͬB͸ͽͳͽBͽͳͬ͸Pͷ

PͫͶͳ͵;
ͬFͲB͸P
ͲB
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺͻPͷFͽ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵;
ͺPͽͻP΃Δ;


B
ͲBͽͳͷ
ͼͶFͯF
ͼͷFͻ͸ͳ΁F
͵PKͳͷB
ͼF
ͽͳ
΁ͳΓFͬͳ
ͺPͼͽͳͱ;
"͵P
KF

͸BͭͶBͼB͵
;
ͷͳͼͳKͳ
͸B
ͷFΌ;͸BͻPͯ͸Pͷ
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽ;
͸BͭͶBͼB͵
;
΁ͳΓFͬͳͷB

ͷPͻBP
ͫͳ
ͯB
ͫ;ͯF
;
͵PͻFͼͺPͯF͸΁ͳKͳ
ͼ
ͺBͱΓͳͬPͷ
ͽK
tPͯͻͱͳͬPͷi

F͵ͼͺͶPBͽB΁ͳKPͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͻFͼ;ͻͼB
͌
ͼͷFͻ͸ͳ΁BͷB
ͷPͭ;
ͯB
ͯP
ͷͳ͸ͳͻBK;
͵B͵P
͵ͬB͸ͽͳͽBͽͳͬ͸ͳ
ͽB͵P
ͳ
͵ͬBͶͳͽBͽͳͬ͸ͳ
FͶFͷF͸ͽͳ

ͻBͲͬPKB

͍Pͻͷ;ͶͳͼBΔF
ͭͶPͫBͶ͸ͳ΀
ͷBͻ͵Fͽͳ͸ͭ
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳKB
ͼͶFͯͳ
ͺPͼͶF

ͯFͿͳ͸ͳͼBΔB
ͷͳͼͳKB
ͳ
΁ͳΓFͬB
0ͼ͸Pͬ͸P
KF
ͻBͲ;ͷFͽͳ
΂ͳΔF͸ͳ΁;
ͯB

ͭF͸FͻBͶ͸P
ͺPͼͽPKF
ͽͻͳ
ͭͶPͫBͶ͸F
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳKF 
ͳ
ͽP
ͽͲͬ
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳKB

͸FͯͳͿFͻF͸΁ͳͻB͸Pͭ
ͷBͻ͵Fͽͳ͸ͭB
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳKB
ͯͳͿFͻF͸΁ͳͻB͸Pͭ
ͷBͻ͵F
ͽͳ͸ͭB
ͳ
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳKB
ͿP͵;ͼB
͊ͽͻBͽFͭͳKB
ͿͻP͸ͽBͶ͸Pͭ
͸Bͼͽ;ͺB

̹BͶ͵B͸B
͵BP
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F
ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳKF
͸B
ͷFΌ;͸BͻPͯ͸P
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵P

ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽF
ͫͰͲ
;ͬBͱBͬBΔB
ͫͻPK͸ͳ΀
ͼͺF΁ͳͿͳ΂͸Pͼͽͳ
ͽPͭ
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽB
ͺP

΂ͳͽBͬPͷ
͸ͳͲ;
PͫFͶFͱKB
͸F
ͫͳ
ͼF
ͷPͭͶB
ͺͻͳ΀ͬBͽͳͽͳ
͵BP
ͺͻPͫͳͽB΂͸B

ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳKB
0ͬP
ͺͻPͳͲͳͶBͲͳ
ͳͲ
KFͯ͸PͼͽBͬ͸F
΂ͳΔF͸ͳ΁F
ͺPͼͽPKBΔB

ͫͻPK͸ͳ΀
ͽͻͱͳ΃͸ͳ΀
ͷFͽB
͵PKF
ͼF
ͻBͲͶͳ͵;K;
ͺP
΂ͳͽBͬPͷ
͸ͳͲ;
PͫF
ͶFͱKB
Ͷͳ΂͸ͳͷ
ͭFPͭͻBͿͼ͵ͳͷ
F͵P͸Pͷͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͳ΀FͬͳPͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͳ

ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͬBͻͳKBͫͳͶBͷB

0ͽ;ͯB
ͼ;ͭFͻͳ΃FͷP
ͯB
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵B
ͺPͶͳ
ͽͳ͵B
ͲB
ͳ͸ͽFͭͻͳͼB͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯ
̹BͶ͵B͸B
ͺͻͳͷF͸ͳ

ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳK;
ͯͳͿFͻF͸΁ͳͻB͸Pͭ
ͷBͻ͵Fͽͳ͸ͭB
ͳ
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳK;
ͿP͵;ͼB
͌
PͫB

ͼͶ;΂BKB
ͷBͽͻͳ΁B
ͺPͻͽͿPͶͳP
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯͽͻͱͳ΃ͽF
KF
ͳ͸ͯͳ͵Bͽͳͬ͸B

ͲB
ͿPͻͷͳͻBΔF
PͯͭPͬBͻBK;ΕFͭ
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯB
ͲB
PͯͭPͬBͻBK;ΕF
ͼFͭͷF͸ͽF

ͽͻBͱΔF
B
;
ͯͻ;ͭPͷ
ͼͶ;΂BK;
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳKPͷ
ͿP͵;ͼB
ͺͻB͵ͽͳ΂͸P
ͼF

ͳͲ
PͬF
ͷBͽͻͳ΁F
PͯBͫͳͻBK;
ͼBͷP
͸F͵ͳ
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯͳ
ͳ
ͼFͭͷF͸ͽͳ
͈P

͸B΃Fͷ
ͷͳ΃ΓFΔ;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵B
ͺPͶͳͽͳ͵B
̹BͶ͵B͸B
ͷPͱF
ͯB
ͺͻͳͷF͸ͳ

͸F͵PͶͳ͵P
Pͼ͸Pͬ͸ͳ΀
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳKB
ͳ
ͽP
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳK;
ͼFͭͷF͸ͽB΁ͳKF

ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽB
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳK;
ͯͳͿFͻF͸΁ͳͻBΔB
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯB
ͳ
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳK;

ͼͽͬBͻBΔB
ͳͷͳΘB
ͳ
ͺPͲͳ΁ͳP͸ͳͻBΔB
͌
ͺͻͬPͷ
ͼͶ;΂BK;
ͼF
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽF



0ͭΔF͸
̹B͵ͳΕ
ͅBͻ͵Fͽͳ͸ͭ
;
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷ;
&͵P͸Pͷͼ͵ͳ
ͿB͵;ͶͽFͽ
̹FPͭͻBͯ




0ͭΔF͸
̹B͵ͳΕ
͈ͻFͯͶPͭ
ͲB
ͼBͯͻͱBK
ͷBͻ͵Fͽͳ͸ͭ
ͷF͸BΘͷF͸ͽB
;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵PK

ͺPͶͳͽͳ΁ͳ
ͫBͶ͵B͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͲFͷBΓB
͆B;΂͸ͳ
ͼͳͷͺPͲͳK;ͷ
ͼB
ͷFΌ;͸BͻPͯ͸ͳͷ
;΂F΃ΕFͷ

̀͸B΂BK
ͷF͸BΘͷF͸ͽB
ͳ
ͷBͻ͵Fͽͳ͸ͭB
ͲB
F͵P͸Pͷͼ͵ͳ
ͻBͲͬPK
ͫBͶ͵B͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͲFͷBΓB

̀ͫPͻ͸ͳ͵
ͻBͯPͬB
&͵P͸Pͷͼ͵F
ͽFͷF
ͫͻ



&͵P͸Pͷͼ͵ͳ
ͿB͵;ͶͽFͽ
͆ͳ΃

 ̺͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
;
ͷͰ͸ͪΘͷͰ͸ͽ;
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹΁ͳ͹͸͹ͭ
ͷͳ͵ͼͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ 

tͶPͷͳi
͸B
ͷBΔF
ͳ
΀PͷPͭF͸ͳKF
ͭͻ;ͺF
ͺPͽͻP΃B΂B
ͳ
ͺͻFͷB
ΔͳͷB
;ͼ
ͷFͻBͬBK;
ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;ͷF͸ͽͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F
ͺPͶͳͽͳ͵F
ͽK
ͷBͻ͵Fͽͳ͸ͭ

ͷͳ͵ͼͪ
͌
ͯͻ;ͭPͷ
ͼͶ;΂BK;
ͼF
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯ
ͺͻͳͶBͭPΌBͬB

ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽ;
ͺPͼFͫ͸P
;
ͯPͷF͸;
ͽͲͬ
;ͬFΕB͸ͳ΀
FͶFͷF͸BͽB
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯB
B
;

ͽͻFΕFͷ
ͼͶ;΂BK;
ͼF
;Ͳ
;ͺPͽͻFͫ;
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳP͸Pͭ
ͷͳ͵ͼB
͸BͼͽPKͳ
ͳͲͭͻBͯͳͽͳ

PͯͭPͬBͻBK;Εͳ
ͳͷͳΘ
ͽK
ͺͻFͯͼͽBͬB
ͳ
ͺPͲͳ΁ͳKB
ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳKF
;
ͼͬFͼͽͳ

ͺPͽͻP΃B΂B

͉BͲͬPK
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳKB
ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;ͷF͸BͽB
ͷBͻ͵Fͽͳ͸ͭ
ͷͳ͵ͼB
͌
ͼͽBͻͽ;

ͽͻFͫB
͸BͺͻBͬͳͽͳ
ͯͳͼͽͳ͸͵΁ͳK;
ͳͲͷFΌ;
ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;ͷF͸BͽB
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F

ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;ͷF͸BͽB
ͺPͼͶPͬ͸F
ͺPͶͳͽͳ͵F
Pͯ͸Pͼ͸P
ͳͲͷFΌ;
ͷB͵ͻP
ͳ

ͷͳ͵ͻP
͸ͳͬPB
;ͺͻBͬΓBΔB
;
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷ;

͌
PͬPͷ
͵P͸ͽF͵ͼͽ;
ͯPͷͳ͸B͸ͽ͸P

ͼ;
;
ͿP͵;ͼ;
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯ
΁F͸B
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳKB
ͳ
͵B͸BͶͳ
ͺͻPͯBKF
BͶͳ
͸B

ͷB͵ͻP
͸ͳͬP;
ͽK
ͲB
ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳK;
;
΁FͶͳ͸ͳ

͉Bͯͳ
ͼF
;
ͼ;΃ͽͳ͸ͳ
P

ͺPͽͻFͫͳ
KBͼ͸Pͭ
ͯFͿͳ͸ͳͼBΔB
ͳ͸ͽFͭͻͳͼB͸Pͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Pͭ
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯB

ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯ͸ͳ
ͷͳ͵ͼ

͵BP
͸PͼFΕFͭ
ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;ͷF͸BͽB
ͷBͻ͵Fͽͳ͸ͭB
ͲBͽͳͷ

ͯFͿͳ͸ͳͼBΔ;
΁F͸Pͬ͸Pͭ
ͷͳ͵ͼB
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳP͸Pͭ
ͷͳ͵ͼB
͵BP
ͳ
ͷͳ͵ͼB
͵B͸BͶB

ͺͻPͯBKF
͋B͵PΌF
ͷB͵ͻP
͸ͳͬP
;ͺͻBͬΓBΔB
ͺPͯͻBͲ;ͷFͬB
ͳ
;ͼͷͰͻͪͬͪ

ͬͻͶP
ͬFͶͳ͵;
ͺBͱΔ;
͸B
͵PPͻͯͳ͸Bͽͳͬ͸;
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳK;
ͽK
͸ͪ
ͼͽͬBͻBΔF

PͺͽͳͷBͶ͸F
͵Pͷͫͳ͸B΁ͳKF
ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;ͷF͸BͽB
ͳ
ͺP
΀PͻͳͲP͸BͽBͶ͸PK

ͳ
ͺP
ͬFͻͽͳ͵BͶ͸PK
Pͼ͸Pͬͳ
͋P
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͻF΂ͳͷB
Ͳ͸B΂ͳ
ͯB
͸ͺͻ
ͺͻP
ͳͲͬPͯ
ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳKF
;
ͼFͫF
ͳ͸͵PͻͺPͻͳͻB
΂ͳͽBͬ
͸ͳͲ
ͺBͻ΁ͳKBͶ͸ͳ΀

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯB
ͷFΌ;
͵PKͳͷB
KF
ͺPͽͻFͫ͸B
Ͳ͸B΂BK͸B

͵PPͻͯͳ͸B΁ͳKB
͈Bͻ΁ͳKBͶ͸ͳ
ͳ͸ͽFͻFͼͳ
͸F
ͫͳ
ͼͷFͶͳ
ͯB
͸BͯͬͶBͯBK;
P͸F

ͳ͸ͽFͻFͼF
͵PKͳ
ͼF
ͯFͿͳ͸ͳ΃;
͵BP
ͼͽͻBͽF΃͵ͳ
͋P
ͬBͱͳ
ͳ
ͲB
ͼͬF
PͼͽBͶF

ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;ͷF͸ͽF
ͽͻͱͳ΃͸Pͭ
͸Bͼͽ;ͺB
͋B͵PΌF
ͺͻBͬΓFΔF
PͺͽͳͷBͶ͸F

͵Pͷͫͳ͸B΁ͳKF
ͷBͻ͵Fͽͳ͸ͭ
ͷͳ͵ͼB
͸B
ͷB͵ͻP
͸ͳͬP;
͸ͳKF
΂ͳ͸
ͬFΕ
ͺͻP΁Fͼ

;ͼBͭͶB΃BͬBΔB
ͻBͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ΀
FͶFͷF͸BͽB
ͺͻPͭͻBͷB
ͳ
ͺPͶͳͽͳ͵B
ͳ

͸BͶBͱFΔB
ͲBKFͯ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͯPͯͳͻ͸ͳ΀
ͽB΂B͵B
ͲB
ͭͻBΌFΔF
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳKF
͵Pͯ

ͼͬB͵Pͭ
Pͯ
Δͳ΀
͈PͽͻFͫ͸B
KF
PͺͽͳͷBͶ͸B
BͶP͵B΁ͳKB
ͻFͼ;ͻͼB
B
΁ͳΓ
ͫͳ

ͽͻFͫBͶP
ͺPͼͽͳͲBͽͳ
͵ͻPͲ
ͼͽͬBͻBΔF
͵P͸ͲͳͼͽF͸ͽ͸F
ͳ
͵PͷͺͶFͷF͸ͽBͻ͸F

͵Pͷͫͳ͸B΁ͳKF
͵PKB
ͯP͸Pͼͳ
ͱFΓF͸F
ͽK
ͼͳ͸FͻͭFͽͼ͵F
ͻFͲ;ͶͽBͽF
͍PͻͷͳͻBΔF
PͯͭPͬBͻBK;ΕF
PͻͭB͸ͳͲPͬB͸Pͼͽͳ
͆͋0
ͳ
͆͋"


ͳ
ͻBͲͬPK
ͳ͸ͿPͻͷB΁ͳP͸ͳ΀
ͼͳͼͽFͷB
͆B΂ͳ͸
ͳͷͺͶFͷF͸ͽͳͻBΔB

ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳKB
;
ͷ͸PͭPͷF
ͲBͬͳͼͳ
ͳ
Pͯ
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻF
͈PͶBͲͳͷP
Pͯ

΂ͳΔF͸ͳ΁F
ͯB
ͼ;
ͫͪͶ͵B͸ͼ͵F
ͲFͷΓF
ͳͲͭͻBͯͳͶF
ͼͳͼͽFͷ
ͯͻͱBͬ͸ͳ΀
ͳ

ͺBͻBͯͻͱBͬ͸ͳ΀
PͻͭB͸B
;
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷ;
Pͯ͸Pͼ͸P
ͯB
;
ͼͬB͵PK
Pͯ
Δͳ΀
ͺPͼͽPKͳ



1IJMJQ
,PUMFS
+PIO
#PXFO
+BNFT
.BLFOT
.BSLFUJOH
GPS
)PTQJUBMJUZ
BOE

5PVSJTN
1SFOUJDF
)BMM
64"

 ͇ͭΔͰ͸
̹ͪ͵ͳΕ

ͳͲͯͳͿFͻF͸΁ͳͻB͸
ͯͻͱBͬ͸ͳ
PͻͭB͸
͆͋"
m
͆B΁ͳP͸BͶ͸B
͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵B

"ͯͷͳ͸ͳͼͽͻB΁ͳKB

͵PKͳ
ͼF
ͫBͬͳ
;͸BͺͻFΌFΔFͷ
ͳ
ͻBͲͬPKFͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷB

ΔFͭPͬPͷ
ͶFͭͳͼͶBͽͳͬPͷ
ͯP͸P΃FΔFͷ
PͯͭPͬBͻBK;Εͳ΀
ͷFͻB
ͺPͶͳͽͳ͵F

ͻBͲͬPKB
ͷFΌ;͸BͻPͯ͸Pͷ
ͼBͻBͯΔPͷ
ͳ
ͼͶ
͵BP
ͳ
͸B
ͻBͲͶͳ΂ͳͽF
͸B΂ͳ͸F

ͿPͻͷͳͻB͸ͳ
ͺBͻBͯͻͱBͬ͸ͳ
PͻͭB͸ͳ
͆͋0
m
͆B΁ͳP͸BͶ͸B
͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵B

0ͻͭB͸ͳͲB΁ͳKB

͵PKPK
ͼF
͸BK΂F΃ΕF
ͺPͬFͻBͬBK;
ͺPͼͶPͬͳ
ͳͲ
ͯPͷF͸B

ͳ͸ͿPͻͷBͽͳͬ͸PͺͻPͷPͽͳͬ͸F
B͵ͽͳͬ͸Pͼͽͳ
ͅFΌ;ͽͳͷ
P͸P
΃ͽP
KF

΂ͳΔF͸ͳ΁B
KF
Pͯͼ;ͼͽͬP
ͲBKFͯ͸ͳ΂͵F
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F
ͺPͶͳͽͳ͵F
ͲB
̹BͶ͵B͸

͵BP
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵;
ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳK;
&͵P͸Pͷͼ͵P
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬF͸P
ͺPͶͳͽͳ΂͵P

ͳ
ͳ͸P
ͺͻPͿͳͶͳͼBΔF
̹BͶ͵B͸B
͸F
ͷPͻB
ͯB
Ͳ͸B΂ͳ
ͺPͻFͯ
PͼͽBͶPͭ
ͳ

B;ͽPͷBͽͼ͵P
ͼͽͬBͻBΔF
͸Bͯ͸B΁ͳP͸BͶ͸ͳ΀
ͽFͶB
ͲB
ͻBͲͬPK
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷB
ͲB
PͬP

ͺPͯͻ;΂KF
͋P
ͺͻF
ͺPͯͻBͲ;ͷFͬB
ͻBͲͬͳKBΔF
͵PPͻͯͳ͸Bͽͳͬ͸F
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳKF

;
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷ;
ͺPͼFͫ͸P
͵Pͯ
ͲBKFͯ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ΀
FͶFͷF͸BͽB
;
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳKBͷB

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Pͭ
ͻBͲͬPKB
ͳ
ͺPͼFͫ͸P
;
ΔF͸Pͷ
ͯFͶ;
͵PKͳ
ͼF
Pͯ͸Pͼͳ
͸B

ͺͻPͷP΁ͳP͸ͳ
ͷͳ͵ͼ
ͽK
ͺͻͳͷF͸;
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳKF
ͺͻPͿͳͶͳͼBΔB
ͳͷͳΘB

ͳ
ͺPͲͳ΁ͳP͸ͳͻBΔB
ͲB
̹BͶ͵B͸
;
΁FͶͳ͸ͳ
0ͽ;ͯB
͵ͻPͲ
ͳ͸ͽF͸Ͳͳͬ͸ͳK;

ͼBͻBͯΔ;
ͺPKFͯͳ͸B΂͸ͳ΀
͆͋0
ͳ
͆͋"
ͫBͶ͵B͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͲFͷBΓB
ͼF
ͷPͱF

ͳͲͯͬPKͳͽͳ
P͸P
΃ͽP
KF
ͼͽͻBͽF΃͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͽFͻFͼ
ͳ
ͯPͫͳͽͳ
ͼͳ͸FͻͭͳKB

FͿF͵BͽB
;
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷ;
͆BͺPͷͳΔFͷP
ͯB
ͼF
ͺ;ͽFͷ
ͺͻͳͷF͸F
ͼBͬͻFͷF͸F

ͳ͸ͿPͻͷB΁ͳP͸F
ͽF΀͸PͶPͭͳKF
ͺPͼFͫ͸P
ͳ
ͳ͸ͽFͻ͸FͽB
;PͫͶͳ΂BͬBΔF

̹BͶ͵B͸B
͵BP
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F
ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳKF
ͷPͱF
ͻFͶBͽͳͬ͸P
ͶB͵P

ͺPͼͽͳΕͳ
̓P͸ͽͻPͶB
ͳ
ͻFͬͳͲͳKB
ͼͬͳ΀
B͵ͽͳͬ͸Pͼͽͳ
0ͬB
B͵ͽͳͬ͸Pͼͽ
KF
;

ͷF͸BΘͷF͸ͽ;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F
ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳKF
΂FͼͽP
ͲB͸FͷBͻͳͬB͸B
̹ͳͽ͸P

KF
ͻBͲ;ͷFͽͳ
KF
͸F
͵BP
tQPTU
GFTUVNi
ͻFB͵΁ͳK;
ͬFΕ
͵BP
ͺFͻͷB͸F͸ͽ͸;

͵P͸ͽͻPͶ;
ͼͬͳ΀
ͷBͻ͵Fͽͳ͸΃͵ͳ΀
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
B͵ͽͳͬ͸Pͼͽͳ
̻ͻF΃͵F
KF

ͺPͽͻFͫ͸P
ͳͼͺͻBͬΓBͽͳ
;
΀Pͯ;
ͺB
΂B͵
ͳ
ͺͻFͯ;ͺͻFͯͳͽͳ
Δͳ΀Pͬ;
ͺPKBͬ;

tGFFE
GPSXBSEi
͵P͸ͽͻPͶB

͈PͽͻFͫ͸B
KF
ͼͽBͶ͸B
ͻFͬͳͲͳKB
P͵ͻ;ͱFΔB

ͳ
ͽP
ͷB͵ͻPP͵ͻ;ͱFΔB
F͵P͸Pͷͼ͵Pͭ
ͽF΀͸PͶP΃͵Pͭ
ͯFͷPͭͻBͿͼ͵Pͭ

ͺPͶͳͽͳ΂͵Pͭ
ͺͻBͬ͸Pͭ
ͺͻͳͻPͯ͸Pͭ
ͼP΁ͳP͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Pͭ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭPͭ

͵BP
ͳ

ͻFͬͳͲͳKB
ͿB͵ͽPͻB
ͷͳ͵ͻPP͵ͻ;ͱFΔB
ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;ͷF͸ͽͳ
ͷBͻ͵Fͽͳ͸ͭ
ͷͳ͵ͼB

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵P
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽF
ͽF͵;ΕB
ͽͻBͱΔB
͵P͸͵;ͻF͸ͽͳ
KBͬ͸Pͼͽ

ͲBͽͳͷ

ͻFͬͳͲͳKB
ͷBͻ͵Fͽͳ͸ͭ
ͷͳͼͳKF
ͳ
΁ͳΓFͬB
ͳ
ͻFͬͳͲͳKB
ͼͬͳ΀
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳKB

ͳ
ͺͻPͭͻBͷB
͵BP
ͳ
ͻFͬͳͲͳKB
;͵;ͺ͸F
PͻͭB͸ͳͲB΁ͳKF
ͳ
ͼͳͼͽFͷB
̓Γ;
΂͸B
ͺPͯͻ;΂KB
ͲB
;ͼͺF΃͸P
ͼͽͻBͽF΃͵P
;ͺͻBͬΓBΔF
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ

ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳKBͷB
ͫͳΕF
ͼͶFͯFΕB
ͼͬFͼ͸Pͼͽ
ͻFͲͳͯF͸BͽB
ͽK
ͯPͷͳ΁ͳͶ͸Pͭ



&SOJF
)FBUI
+FĒSFZ 8BMM .BSLFUJOH
5PVSJTN
%FTUJOBUJPOT
+PIO
8JMFZ
BOE

4POT
"VTUSBMJB

 ̺͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
;
ͷͰ͸ͪΘͷͰ͸ͽ;
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹΁ͳ͹͸͹ͭ
ͷͳ͵ͼͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ 

ͼͽB͸Pͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬB
P
͵PͻͳͼͽͳͷB
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷB
ͳ
Δͳ΀PͬP
͸FͺPͼͻFͯ͸P
;΂F΃ΕF

;
P΂;ͬBΔ;
ͳ
;͸BͺͻFΌFΔ;
ͺͻͳͻPͯ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
ͻFͼ;ͻͼB
ͲB
ͻBͲͬPK

ͽ;ͻͳͲͷB
͵BP
ͳ
;ͼͶPͬB
ͲB
ͫPͻBͬB͵

ͺͶB͸ͳͻBΔF
ͻBͲͬPKB
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷB
͵ͻPͲ

΀BͻͷP͸ͳK;
F͵ͼͽFͻ͸ͳ΀
΁ͳΓFͬB
ͳ
΁ͳΓFͬB
ͶP͵BͶ͸Pͭ
ͼͽB͸Pͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬB

͵B
ͫPΓFͷ
ͱͳͬPͽ͸Pͷ
ͼͽͳͶ;
ͳ
͵ͬBͶͳͽFͽ;
ͱͳͬPͽB
ͺͻͳ΀ͬBͽBΔF

Pͯ
ͼͽͻB͸F
ͻFͲͳͯF͸BͽB

P͸Pͭ
ͳͷͳΘB
͵PKͳ
ͼF
ͼͽͬBͻB
P
ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳKͳ

ͼ͵ͶBͯ͸F
ͳ
΀BͻͷP͸ͳ΂͸F
ͬFͲF
ͺͻͳͬBͽ͸Pͭ
ͯͻͱBͬ͸Pͭ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭPͭ
ͳ͸ͽFͻFͼB
͸B

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵PK
ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳKͳ
ͳ
ͻFͼͺF͵ͽPͬBΔF
ͽͻBͯͳ΁ͳKF
ͽK
Pͫͳ΂BKB
ͳ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻF
͵PKB
ͺͻFPͬͶBΌ;KF
͵Pͯ
ͶP͵BͶ͸Pͭ
ͼͽB͸Pͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬB
ͳ
ͼͶ
͊ͬB͵B͵P

ͽ;
ͬFPͷB
ͷ͸PͭP
ͷPͱF
ͯB
ͺPͷPͭ͸F
ͺͻͳͷF͸B
ͳ
ͻBͲͬPK
ͳ͸ͿPͻͷB΁ͳP͸F

ͽF΀͸PͶPͭͳKF
͊ͷBͽͻBͷP
ͯB
KFͯB͸
ͻBͲͻBΌF͸
ͳ͸ͿPͻͷB΁ͳP͸ͳ
ͼͳͼͽFͷ

ͳ
ͲB
ͺPͯͻ;΂KF
̹BͶ͵B͸B

ͷPͱF
ͯB
ͳͷB
ͼͶFͯFΕF
ͯFͶPͬF
͵PKͳ
;KFͯ͸P

PͶB͵΃BͬBK;
͵P͸ͽͻPͶ;

B

ͳ͸ͽFͻ͸P
ͳͲͬF΃ͽBͬBΔF
ͫ

ͷBͻ͵Fͽͳ͸ͭ

PͫKB΃ΔBͬBΔF
ͬ

ͳͼͽͻBͱͳͬBΔF
ͷBͻ͵Fͽͳ͸ͭB
ͳ
ͭ

B͸BͶͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ

ͷBͻ͵Fͽͳ͸ͭ


͊ͽͻBͽFͭͳKB
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳP͸Pͭ
ͷͳ͵ͼB
̹BͶ͵B͸B
͵BP
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F

ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳKF

͈ͻPͷP΁ͳP͸ͳ
ͷͳ͵ͼ
ͳͶͳ
KP΃
͸BͲͳͬB͸
ͳ
͵Pͷ;͸ͳ͵B΁ͳP͸ͳ
ͷͳ͵ͼ

ͺPͯͻBͲ;ͷFͬB
ͷBͼPͬ͸P
͵Pͷ;͸ͳ΁ͳͻBΔF
ͼB
ͺPͽͻP΃B΂ͳͷB
ͻBͯͳ
ͼͽͳ
ͷ;ͶͳͼBΔB
ͳ
;͸BͺͻFΌFΔB
ͺͶBͼͷB͸B
0ͬBK
ͺPKBͷ
Pͫ;΀ͬBͽB
ͬFΕͳ
ͫͻPK

ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;ͷF͸BͽB
ͽK
ͼͻFͯͼͽBͬB

͆BK΂F΃ΕF
ͼF
ͺPͯ
ͽͳͷ
ͺPͯͻBͲ;ͷFͬB

ͺͻPͺBͭB͸ͯB
;͸BͺͻFΌFΔF
ͺͻPͯBKF
Pͯ͸Pͼͳ
ͼB
KBͬ͸P΃Ε;
Ͷͳ΂͸B
ͺͻPͯBKB

͵BP
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;ͷF͸ͽͳ

͌Pͫͳ΂BKF͸P
KF
ͯB
ͼF
;ͺBͯB
;
ͭͻF΃͵;
ͽF
ͯB
ͼF
ͺͻPͺBͭB͸ͯB

ͺPͳͼͽPͬFΕ;KF
ͼB
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳKPͷ
ͅFΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳK;
ͽͻFͫB
ͽͻFͽͳͻBͽͳ

͵BP
ͯBͶF͵P
΃ͳͻͳ
ͺPKBͷ
͐ͳΔF͸ͳ΁B
KF
ͯB
KF
ͺͻPͺBͭB͸ͯB
ͼ͵PͻP
ͻFͯPͬ͸P

;
ͯPͷͳ͸B͸ͽ͸Pͷ
ͿP͵;ͼ;
ͳ
ͽP
͵BP
Pͺ΃ͽB
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵B
ͺͻPͺBͭB͸ͯB
B͵P

KF
ͻF΂
P
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵PK
ͺPͶͳͽͳ΁ͳ

ͳͶͳ
͵BP
͵PͷFͻ΁ͳKBͶ͸B
ͺͻPͺBͭB͸ͯB

B͵P
KF
ͻF΂
P
ͺPͼͶPͬ͸PK
ͺPͶͳͽͳ΁ͳ

͌
ͺͻͬPͷ
ͼͶ;΂BK;
͵ͻFͳͻB
ͼF

ͺPͲͳͽͳͬ͸B
ͺͻFͯͼͽBͬB
ͳ
ͳͲͭͻBΌ;KF
ͱFΓF͸ͳ
ͳͷͳΘ
ͲB
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵;

ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳK;
;
΁FͶͳ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͽP
͸B
ͳͲBͫͻB͸Pͷ
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽ;
̽ͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͻF΂ͳͷB

ͼͽͬBͻB
ͼF
ͼͬFͼͽ
P
ͺPͼͽPKBΔ;
ͳ
ͺͻFͯ͸PͼͽͳͷB
ͽB͵ͬF
ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳKF
B

;
ͯͻ;ͭPͷ
ͼͶ;΂BK;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵B
ͽͻBͱΔB
ͼF
ͺͻͳͬͶB΂ͳ
͸B
͵P͸͵ͻFͽ͸F



̈́F͵ͼͳ͵P͸
ͷBͻ͵Fͽͳ͸ͭB
͊BͬͻFͷF͸B
Bͯͷͳ͸ͳͼͽͻB΁ͳKB
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻBͯ



4UFQIFO
'
8JUU
-VJ[
.PVUJOIP
5PVSJTN
ͅBSLFUJOH
BOE
.BOBHFNFOU

)BOECPPL
1SFOUJDF
)BMM
6,

 ͇ͭΔͰ͸
̹ͪ͵ͳΕ

ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯF
ͳ
ͳ͸͵Ͷͳ͸ͳͻB
͸B
Δͳ΀Pͬ;
͵;ͺPͬͳ͸;
"Ͷͳ
ͺͻPͺBͭB͸ͯB
ͫͳ

ͽͻFͫBͶP
ͯB
tͳͯFi
ͺBͻBͶFͶ͸P
ͼ
;͸BͺͻFΌFΔFͷ
ͺͻPͯBKF
͵BP
ͽB͵ͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ

ͼͻFͯͼͽͬPͷ
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳP͸F
B͵ͽͳͬ͸Pͼͽͳ
ͭͯF
KF
ͿP͵;ͼ
ͳ
͸B
ͺPͽͻP΃B΂F

BͶͳ
ͳ
͸B
ͺͻPͯBK͸P
PͼPͫΓF
;
͵B͸BͶͳͷB
ͺͻPͯBKF
ͲBͺPͼͶF͸F
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭF

ͼFͭͷF͸ͽF
́ͼͽPͬͻFͷF͸P
ͳ
ͻBͲͬͳKBΔF
Pͯ͸PͼB
ͼB
KBͬ͸P΃Ε;
͵P͸ͽB͵ͽͳ

ͼB
ͷFͯͳKͳͷB
ͲBͳ͸ͽFͻFͼPͬB͸Pͷ
KBͬ͸P΃Ε;
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷB

ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ

ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;ͷF͸ͽͳ
ͫͳ
ͽͻFͫBͶP
ͯB
ͫ;ͯ;
BͯF͵ͬBͽ͸P
ͲBͼͽ;ͺΓF͸ͳ

+Bͼ͸P
ͼF
;P΂BͬB
ͯB
Pͼ͸Pͬ͸ͳ
ͲBͯBͽB͵
͵Pͷ;͸ͳ͵B΁ͳP͸Pͭ
ͷͳ͵ͼͪ

ͶFͱͳ
;
ͿPͻͷͳͻBΔ;
PͯͭPͬBͻBK;ΕFͭ
͸ͳͬPB
ͳ
͵ͬBͶͳͽFͽB
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F

ͽͻBͱΔF
ͲB
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯPͷ
͵PKͳ
ͼF
ͱFͶͳ
ͺͶBͼͳͻBͽͳ
͸B
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽF

̹BͶ͵B͸
͵BP
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵B
ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳKB

͵ͻPͲ
ͼͽͬBͻBΔF
ͼͬFͼ͸Pͼͽͳ

P
ͳ͸ͽFͭͻͳͼB͸Pͷ
ͺͻPͲͬPͯ;
B
P͸ͯB
ͳ
ͺPͷFͻBΔFͷ
͵ͻͳͬ;ΓF
ͽͻBͱΔF

;
͵Pͻͳͼͽ
ͼͬB͵Pͭ
Pͯ
ͺͻPͺBͭͳͻB͸ͳ΀
ͺBͻ΁ͳKBͶ͸ͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀

ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯB
ͼͷF΃ͽBK
ͳͼ΀ͻB͸B
ͲBͫBͬB
ͻBͲP͸PͯB
ͳ
ͼͶ

́ͷBK;Εͳ
ͺͻFͽ΀Pͯ͸P
;
ͬͳͯ;
ͷPͱFͷP
ͼ;ͭFͻͳͼBͽͳ
ͯB
ͼF
;
ͫ;ͯ;ΕPK

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵PK
ͺPͶͳͽͳ΁ͳ
̹BͶ͵B͸B
ͺPͼFͫ͸P
ͬFͲB͸P
ͲB
ͺͻPͷPͽͳͬ͸F

B͵ͽͳͬ͸Pͼͽͳ
ͯFͿͳ͸ͳ΃F
ͺͻP΁Fͼ
ͳͲͭͻBͯΔF
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳ͸F
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳKF
0͸

ͫͳ
Pͫ;΀ͬBͽͳP
͸F͵PͶͳ͵P
ͿBͲB
ͳ
ͽP
B

PͯBͫͳͻ
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽB
͸B
͵PKF
ͫͳ
ͫͳͶP

ͺPͱFΓ͸P
ͯB
ͼF
̹BͶ͵B͸
͵BP
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵B
ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳKB
ͺPͲͳ΁ͳP͸ͳͻB

ͫ

ͯFͿͳ͸ͳͼBΔF
Pͼ͸Pͬ͸ͳ΀
ͲBͯBͽB͵B
ͳ
͵P͸͵ͻFͽ͸ͳ΀
΁ͳΓFͬB

ͺͻPͷP΁ͳP͸F
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳKF
ͬ

;ͽͬͻΌͳͬBΔF
BͯF͵ͬBͽ͸F
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳ͸F

ͺPͻ;͵F
ͭ

ͯFͿͳ͸ͳͼBΔF
;ͺPͽͻFͫF
ͼͬB͵Pͭ
Pͯ
ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;ͷF͸BͽB
ͽK

ͼͻFͯͼͽBͬB
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳ͹͸F
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳKF
ͯ

BͶͳͷF͸ͽͳͻBΔF
PͯͭPͬBͻBK;ΕFͭ

ͳ
ͫͶBͭPͬͻFͷF͸Pͭ
ͫ;ΘFͽB
ͳ
Ό

;ͼͽB͸PͬΓBͬBΔF
͵P͸ͽͻPͶF
ͺͻPͷPͽͳͬ͸F

B͵ͽͳͬ͸Pͼͽͳ
͋ͻͱͳ΃ͽF
͸B
͵PKF
ͼF
͸Bͼͽ;ͺB
KF
ͺͻͬͳ
Pͯ
͵PͻB͵B
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳ͸F

ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳKF
͈PͽͻFͫ͸P
KF
ͳͷBͽͳ
΂ͳͽBͬ
͸ͳͲ
ͻFͶFͬB͸ͽ͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸ͿPͻͷB΁ͳKB

P
ͲͫͳͬBΔͳͷB
͸B
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽ;
BͶͳ
ͳ
P
ͺP͸B΃BΔ;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F
ͽͻBͱΔF

́ͼͽPͬͻFͷF͸P
ͺPͽͻFͫ͸P
KF
ͺP͸;ͯͳͽͳ
PͫͳΓF
ͳ͸ͿPͻͷB΁ͳKB
P
̹BͶ͵B͸;

ͭͯF
ͽP
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ
ͳͯ;
΃ͽB
ͷPͭ;
ͯB
ͻBͯF
͵B͵P
ͯB
ͺ;ͽ;K;
ͳ
ͼͶ


̈́Pͭͳ΂͸P
KF
ͺͻFͽͺPͼͽBͬͳͽͳ
ͯB
ͼF
ͻBͯͳ
P
FͬͻPͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͲFͷΓBͷB

͵BP
ͳͲͬPͻͳͷB
ͽͻBͱΔF
ͳ
ͻBͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳͷ
ͽͻͱͳ΃͸ͳͷ
ͷFͽBͷB
;
ͽͳͷ

P͵ͬͳͻͳͷB
̀BͯBͽB͵΁ͳΓ
KF
ͺPͽͻFͫ͸P
ͯPͬPͯͳͽͳ
;
͵PͻFͼͺPͯF͸΁ͳK;
ͼB

΂ͳΔF͸ͳ΁Pͷ
ͯB
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳKB
;ͬF͵
ͺPͶBͲͳ
Pͯ
Pͯ͸PͼB
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯͽͻͱͳ΃ͽF

ͽF
ͯB
ͼF
ͳ
͵Pͯ
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽB
ͳ
͵Pͯ
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯB
ͷPͱF
ͯͳͼBͭͻFͭͳͻBͽͳ
Δͳ΀Pͬ

Ͳ͸B΂BK
ͼB
ͼͽB͸Pͬͳ΃ͽB
ͼ͸BͭF
͸ͺͻ
KB͵
ͼͻFͯΔͳ
ͼͶBͫ

͌
͵P͸͵ͻFͽ͸Pͷ

ͼͶ;΂BK;
̹BͶ͵B͸B
ͺP
͸B΃Fͷ
ͷͳ΃ΓFΔ;
ͷPͭͶB
ͫͳ
ͼF
BͺͻP͵ͼͳͷͳͻBͽͳ

ͺPͼͽPKFΕB
ͼͳͽB΁ͳKB
ͺPͷF͸;ͽPͭ
Pͯ͸PͼB
͵BP
ͻFͶBͽͳͬ͸P
KB͵P

 ̺͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
;
ͷͰ͸ͪΘͷͰ͸ͽ;
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹΁ͳ͹͸͹ͭ
ͷͳ͵ͼͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ 

ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽFͼͻFͯΔͳ
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯ
͌
ͽB͵ͬPK
KFͯ͸PK
ͼͳͽ;B΁ͳKͳ
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳKB

ͫͳ
ͷPͻBͶB
ͫͳͽͳ
ͬFPͷB
BͭͻFͼͳͬ͸B
ͳ
Ͳ͸B΂BK͸B
ͺP
Pͫͳͷ;
΁F͸F
ͫͳ

ͫͳͶP
ͺPͽͻFͫ͸P
ͯͻͱBͽͳ
ͳͼͺPͯ
ͽͻͱͳ΃͸Pͭ
ͺͻPͼF͵B
;
ͺͻPͯBKͳ
ͫͳ
ͼF

͵PͻͳͼͽͳͶͳ
ͳ
ͯͳͻF͵ͽ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͳ͸ͯͳͻF͵ͽ͸ͳ
͵B͸BͶͳ
ͺͻPͯBKF
ͬFΕ
ͺͻFͷB

ͼFͭͷF͸ͽ;
ͽͻBͱΔF
ͳ
;
ͬFͲͳ
ͼB
͵P͸͵ͻFͽ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯPͷ

B
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯ

ͫͳ
ͼF
ͼ͸Bͱ͸P
ͯͳͿFͻF͸΁ͳͻBP
ͳ
ͳͼͽͳ΁BP
ͼͶPͭB͸
tͬͻFͯ͸Pͼͽ
ͲB
͸PͬB΁i

WBMVF
GPS
NPOFZ

͈Pͻ;͵B
ͫͳ
ͷPͻBͶB
ͯB
ͺͻPͳͲBΌF
͵BP
ͻFͲ;ͶͽB͸ͽB
Pͯ͸PͼB

ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯB
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽB
ͳ
͵P͸͵;ͻF͸΁ͳKF
̀͸B΂ͳ
ͺPͽͻFͫ͸F
ͼ;
F͵ͼͽFͻ͸F

ͳ͸ͿPͻͷB΁ͳKF
ͼB
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽB
m
΃ͽB
ͺPͽͻP΃B΂ͳ
ͱFͶF
͵B͵ͬͳ
ͼ;

ͺPͽFͲͳ
͵P͸͵;ͻF͸BͽB
;
ͯPͷF͸;
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳ͸Pͭ
ͷͳ͵ͼB
͵BP
ͳ
ͳ͸ͽFͻ͸F

ͳ͸ͿPͻͷB΁ͳKF
P
KB͵ͳͷ
ͳ
ͼͶBͫͳͷ
ͽB΂͵BͷB
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯB
͈ͻPͷPͽͳͬ͸B

ͺPͻ;͵B
͵PKB
PͯBͬͯF
ͽͻFͫB
ͯB
ͺͻPͳͲBΌF
ͷPͻB
ͳͷBͽͳ
ͬBͱ͸Pͼͽ
ͲB

ͺPͽͻP΃B΂F
ͷPͻB
ͷ;
;͵BͲBͽͳ
ͯB
ͺPͼͽPKF
͵PͷͺBͻBͽͳͬ͸F
ͺͻFͯ͸Pͼͽͳ

͵Pͯ
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯB
ͳ
PͼͽBͶͳ΀
ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;ͷF͸BͽB
ͺPͶͳͽͳ͵F

̽PͫͻP
ͫͳ
ͫͳͶP

ͯB
ͼF
ͳͷͳΘ
ͭͻBͯͳ
ͳ
͸B
;͸ͳ͵Bͽ͸ͳͷ
PͫFΕBΔͳͷB
641m6OJRVF
4FMMJOH

1SPQPTJUJPO

KFͻ
KF
ͳͲͭͻBͯΔB
ͳͷͳΘB
ͺPͯ
ͯFKͼͽͬPͷ
ͼͺͶFͽB
ͿB͵ͽPͻB

͵B͵P
͸B
ͼͽͻB͸ͳ
ͽͻBͱΔF
ͷPͽͳͬB΁ͳKB
ͺFͻ΁Fͺ΁ͳKB
ͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬP

ͺͼͳ΀PͶP΃͵F
ͳ
ͼP΁ͳPF͵P͸Pͷͼ͵F
͵BͻB͵ͽFͻͳͼͽͳ͵F
ͳ
ͯͻ

ͽB͵P
ͳ
͸B

ͼͽͻB͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F
ͺP͸;ͯF
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯ
ͷFͯͳKͳ
ͷBͻ͵Fͽͳ͸ͭ
ͳ
ͯͻ

͈ͻPͷP΁ͳP͸ͳ
ͷͳ͵ͼ
ͺPͯͻBͲ;ͷFͬB
;ͺPͽͻFͫ;
ͼͬͳ΀
ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;ͷF͸BͽB

BͶͳ
ͯPͲͳͻB͸P
ͬFΕ
ͺͻFͷB
΁ͳΓ;
ͳ
ͲBͯBͽ͵;
ͳ
PͫFͲͫFΌF͸ͳͷ
ͼͻFͯͼͽͬͳͷB

;
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳP͸Pͷ
ͫ;ΘFͽ;
͌
PͬPͷ
͵P͸ͽF͵ͼͽ;
Pͯ
;ͽͳ΁BKB
ΕͰ
ͫͳͽͳ
΂ͳͽBͬ

͸ͳͲ
ͿB͵ͽPͻB
͵BP
΃ͽP
ͼ;
͸ͺͻ
B

P͸ͳ
;
ͬFͲͳ
ͼB
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯPͷ
͵PKͳͷ

ͼF
ͻBͼͺPͶBͱF
͸ͺͻ
ͼBͷB
ΔFͭPͬB
ͺͻͳͻPͯB
ΔFͭPͬ
͵ͬBͶͳͽFͽ
ͿBͲB
;

ͱͳͬPͽ͸Pͷ
΁ͳ͵Ͷ;ͼ;
ͳ
ͼͶ

ͫ

ͽͻͱͳ΃͸ͳ
ͿB͵ͽPͻͳ
͸ͺͻ
ͳ͸ͽF͸ͲͳͽFͽ

͵P͸͵;ͻF͸΁ͳKF
͵POK;͸͵ͽ;ͻB
ͳ
ͼͶ

ͬ

ͿB͵ͽPͻͳ
͸B
ͼͽͻB͸ͳ
ͽͻBͱΔF

͸ͺͻ
CͻPK
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽB
Δͳ΀PͬB
͵P͸΁F͸ͽͻB΁ͳKB
ͺFͻͼͺF͵ͽͳͬB
ͳ
ͼͶ

ͭ


ͿB͵ͽPͻͳ
ͷBͻ͵Fͽͳ͸ͭB
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳKB
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;ͷF͸BͽB
ͺPͶͳͽͳ͵F

ͳ
ͼͶ

ͅFΌ;ͽͳͷ
͵B͵Bͬ
ͭPͯ
ͯB
KF
ͿP͵;ͼ
͸B
ͺPKFͯͳ͸B΂͸F
ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;ͷF͸ͽF

ͺͻPͷP΁ͳP͸Pͭ
ͷͳ͵ͼB
ͺͻPͺBͭB͸ͯB
;͸BͺͻFΌFΔF
ͺͻPͯBKF

ͫͳͽ͸P
KF

͸F
ͳͲͭ;ͫͳͽͳ
ͳͲ
ͬͳͯB
ͳ
ͬBͱ͸Pͼͽ
ͺP΃ͽPͬBΔB
PͯͻFΌF͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͳ͸΁ͳͺB

;
ͺͻPͺBͭB͸ͯ͸PK
ͽK
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳP͸PK

B͵ͽͳͬ͸Pͼͽͳ
΂ͳKF
;ͬBͱBͬBΔF

ͳ
ͺͻͳ΀ͬBͽBΔF
ͺͻFͯͼͽBͬΓB
ͬBͱB͸
FͶFͷF͸ͽ
ͲB
ͺPͲͳͽͳͬB͸
ͳͼ΀Pͯ

ͺͻPͷP΁ͳP͸F
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳKF
͆F͵ͳ
Pͯ
Δͳ΀
ͷPͭ;
ͼF
ͼ;ͫͶͳͷͳͻBͽͳ
;

ͼͶFͯFΕFͷ
B

ͺͻPͷP΁ͳKB
ͷPͻB
ͫͳͽͳ
͵PPͻͯͳ͸ͳͼB͸B
ͽK
΁ͳΓFͬͳ
Pͺ΃ͽF

ͳ
͵PͷFͻ΁ͳKBͶ͸F
ͺͻPͺBͭB͸ͯF
ͷPͻBK;
ͼF
ͯPͺ;ΔBͬBͽͳ
ͫ

ͺPͽͻFͫ͸P



0HJMWZ
PO
"EWFSUJTJOH
7JOUBHF
#PPLT
/FX
:PSL

 ͇ͭΔͰ͸
̹ͪ͵ͳΕ

KF
ͻBͲͬͳKBͽͳ
ͽB͵ͬF
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳP͸F
͵BͷͺBΔF
͵PKF
ΕF
ͯPͺͻͳ͸Pͼͳͽͳ
ͺP
ͬFΕB͸PK
ͺͻFͺPͲ͸BͽΓͳͬPͼͽͳ
ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳKF
BͶͳ
ͳ
ͬFΕFͷ
;P΂BͬBΔ;

Pͯ
ͼͽͻB͸F
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F
ͽͻBͱΔF
ͬ

ͷPͻB
ͼF
ͫͳͽͳ
B;ͽF͸ͽͳ΂B͸

ͳ
͵ͻFBͽͳͬB͸
;
ͺPͻ;͵BͷB
ͭ

ͺPͽͻFͫ͸P
KF
ͳͼͽͳ΁Bͽͳ
P͸P
΃ͽP
ͼ;

͵PͷͺBͻBͽͳͬ͸F
ͺͻFͯ͸Pͼͽͳ
ͯ

ͺPͽͻFͫ͸B
KF
ͼͽBͶ͸B
͵PͻFͼͺPͯF͸
΁ͳKB
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳKF
ͼB
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯPͷ
BͶͳ
ͳ
ͼB
PͼͽBͶͳͷ
ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;ͷF͸ͽͳͷB

͸Bͼͽ;ͺB
΁F͸B
͵B͸BͶͳ
ͺͻPͯBKF

̹;ΘFͽ
͵PKͳ
KF
ͺPͽͻFͫ͸P
PͫFͲͫFͯͳͽͳ
ͲB
ͺͻPͷPͽͳͬ͸F
B͵ͽͳͬ͸Pͼͽͳ

ͷPͱF
ͯB
ͼF
ͿPͻͷͳͻB
͸B
ͬͳ΃F
͸B΂ͳ͸B
͈ͻFͺPͻ;͵B
͊ͬFͽͼ͵F
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F

PͻͭB͸ͳͲB΁ͳKF
8͋0
m
8PSME
5PVSJTN
0SHBOJTBUJPO

KF
ͯB
ͼF
ͲB
ͽͲͬ

Pͺ΃ͽ;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵;
ͺͻPͺBͭB͸ͯ;
ͳͲͯͬBKB

Pͯ
PͼͽͬBͻF͸Pͭ
ͯFͬͳͲ͸Pͭ

ͺͻͳͶͳͬB
Pͯ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷB
ͅFΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͺP
͸B΃Fͷ
ͷͳ΃ΓFΔ;
ͷFͽPͯ
ͽͲͬ
΁ͳΓB

ͳ
ͲBͯBͽ͵B
ͫͳP
ͫͳ
ͺPͱFΓB͸
KFͻ
ͼF
ͻBͯͳ
P
ͺPͽͻFͫͳ
PͫFͲͫFΌͳͬBΔB
ͳ

ͬFΕͳ΀
Ϳͳ͸B͸ͼͳKͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼͻFͯͼͽBͬB
ͲB
ͺͻPͷPͽͳͬ͸F
B͵ͽͳͬ͸Pͼͽͳ
B
͵PKF
ͼ;

͸FPͺ΀Pͯ͸F
ͯB
ͫͳ
ͼF
PͯͭPͬPͻͳͶP
ͺPͼͽBͬΓF͸Pͷ
΁ͳΓ;
ͺͻFͺPͲ͸BͬBΔF

̹BͶ͵B͸B
͵BP
KFͯͳ͸ͼͽͬF͸F
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F
ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳKF
͸B
FͬͻPͺͼ͵Pͷ

ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽ;

̺FPͷB
KF
ͬBͱ͸P
ͯB
ͫ;ͯF
PͫFͲͫFΌF͸
͵P͸ͽͳ͸;ͳͽFͽ
ͺͻͳͶͳͬB

Ϳͳ͸B͸ͼͳKͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼͻFͯͼͽBͬB
͵B͵P
ͫͳ
ͺͻPͷPͽͳͬ͸F
B͵ͽͳͬ͸Pͼͽͳ
ͷPͭͶF
ͯB

ͼF
PͯͬͳKBK;
͸B
ͬͻFͷF
ͳ
͸B
ͺFͻͷB͸F͸ͽ͸PK
Pͼ͸Pͬͳ

̓P͸ͽͻPͶBͻFͬͳͲͳKB
ͼF
ͷ͹ͻͪ
ͺFͻͷB͸F͸ͽ͸P
ͼͺͻPͬPͯͳͽͳ
͍Pͻ
ͷF
ͷPͭ;
ͫͳͽͳ
ͻBͲͶͳ΂ͳͽF
B
͸BK΂F΃ΕF
ͼF
ͺͻͳͷFΔ;K;
B͸͵FͽF
ͳͶͳ
͵;
ͺP͸ͳ
ͺͻF͵P
͵PKͳ΀
ͼF
;ͽͬͻΌ;KF
;ͼͺF΃͸Pͼͽ
ͺͻPͿͳͶͳͼBΔB
ͳͷͳΘB
ͳ

ͼͽFͺF͸
ͺPͲͳ΁ͳP͸ͳͻBΔB
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯB
;
ͼͬFͼͽͳ
ͺPͽͻP΃B΂B
͈PͷF͸;ͽF

B͵ͽͳͬ͸Pͼͽͳ
ͷPͭ;
ͼF
ͳͲͬPͯͳͽͳ
͵B͵P
͸B
Fͷͳͽͳͬ͸Pͷ
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽ;
ͽB͵P
ͳ

͸B
ͻF΁Fͺͽͳͬ͸Pͷ
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽ;


̺Pͯͳ΂ͳ
ͲB
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵F
tͫFͯF͵Fͻͳi

;
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳP͸Pͷ
ͷͳ͵ͼ;

͌Pͫͳ΂BKF͸P
KF
ͯB
ͼF
ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;ͷF͸ͽͳ
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳP͸Pͭ
ͷͳ͵ͼB
ͺͻͳ

΂Fͷ;
ͼF
ͺPͼFͫ͸P
ͳͷB
;
ͬͳͯ;
ͺͻPͺBͭB͸ͯB
͵BP
͸BKͬBͱ͸ͳKͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͻ;
ͷF͸ͽ
ͻBͲͬͻͼͽBͬBK;
ͼB
ͼͽB͸Pͬͳ΃ͽB
ͺͻͳͷF͸F
ͻBͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ΀
ͼͻFͯͼͽBͬB

;
͸Bͼͽ;ͺ;
͸B
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵P
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽF
͋B͵P
ͼF
ͷPͭ;
ͳͼͽͪ͵͸;ͽͳ
B


ͭͻBͿͳ΂͵B
ͼͻFͯͼͽͬB
ͫ

PͭͶBͼ͸B
ͼͻFͯͼͽͬB
ͬ

ͺͻPKF͵΁ͳP͸B
ͼͻFͯͼͽͬB
ͳ

ͭ

ͺͻPͼͽPͻ͸P
ͺͶBͼͽͳ΂͸B
ͼͻFͯͼͽͬB

̻ͻBͿͳ΂͵B
ͼͻFͯͼͽͬB
ͼ;
͸BKͻBͼͺͻPͼͽͻBΔF͸ͳKB
ͼͻFͯͼͽͬB
ͽ;ͻͳ
ͼͽͳ΂͵F
ͺͻPͺBͭB͸ͯF
0͸B
ͼ;
ͽͲͬ
ͼBͷPͼͽBͶ͸B
ͼͻFͯͼͽͬB
ͽK
͸F
ͽͻBͱF
ͷF
ͯͳK;ͷ
͵BP
ͺͻF͸Pͼ͸ͳ͵B
ͺPͻ;͵F
ͳ
;
Pͼ͸Pͬͳ
ͺͻFͯͼͽBͬΓBK;
ͯͳͻF͵ͽB͸

͸B΂ͳ͸
͵Pͷ;͸ͳ΁ͳͻBΔB
ͼ
ͺPͽF͸΁ͳKBͶ͸Pͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Pͷ
ͽͻBͱΔPͷ

͋B͵PΌF
ͻBͯͳ
ͼF
P
ͬFPͷB
ͿͶF͵ͼͳͫͳͶ͸ͳͷ
ͼͻFͯͼͽͬͳͷB
͵Pͷ;͸ͳ΁ͳͻBΔB

 ̺͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
;
ͷͰ͸ͪΘͷͰ͸ͽ;
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹΁ͳ͹͸͹ͭ
ͷͳ͵ͼͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ 

ͼB
ͺPͽͻP΃B΂ͳͷB
͵B͵P
ͺP
Pͫͳͷ;
ͳ
ͬFͶͳ΂ͳ͸ͳ
ͽB͵P
ͳ
ͺP
Δͳ΀PͬPͷ

ͬͻFͷF͸;
ͷFͼͽ;
ͳ
ͼBͯͻͱBK;
͉Bͯͳ
ͼF
͸BK΂F΃ΕF
P
ͼͻFͯͼͽͬͳͷB
͵PKB
ͺͻ;
ͱBK;
PͫͳΓF
͵ͻFBͽͳͬ͸ͳ΀
ͷPͭ;Ε͸Pͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͽP
ͼB
ͼͽB͸Pͬͳ΃ͽB
ͺPͻ;͵F
ͽK

ͽFͷF
ͼͶͳ͵F
ͽF͵ͼͽB
ͳ
;
΁FͶͳ͸ͳ
ͺPͼͷBͽͻB͸P
ͯͳͲBK͸B
͋B͵PΌF
P͸B

ͺPͯͻBͲ;ͷFͬBK;
ͻFͶBͽͳͬ͸P
͸ͳͱF
Ϳͳ͵ͼ͸F
ͽͻP΃͵PͬF
BͶͳ
ͳͼͽP
ͽB͵P

ͺPͯͻBͲ;ͷFͬBK;
ͳ
ͬFPͷB
ͬͳͼP͵
͵ͬBͶͳͽFͽ
ͳͲͻBͯF
͆BK΂F΃ΕF
ͼF
;
PͬPͷ

͵P͸ͽF͵ͼͽ;
ͳͷBK;
;
ͬͳͯ;
ͼͻFͯͼͽͬB
͵BP
΃ͽP
ͼ;
ͺͶB͵Bͽͳ
ͺͻPͼͺF͵ͽͳ

ͿPͶͯFͻͳ
ͫͻP΃;ͻF
ͳ
ͻBͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
ͺͳͼB͸ͳ
ͷBͽFͻͳKBͶͳ
ͲB
ͳ͸ͿPͻ
ͷͳͼBΔF
ͺPͽF͸΁ͳKBͶ͸F
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F
ͽͻBͱΔF
0ͭͶBͼ͸B
ͼͻFͯͼͽͬB
ͲB
ͻBͲͶͳ͵;
Pͯ
ͭͻBͿͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͼͻFͯͼͽBͬB
͸ͳͼ;

ͼBͷPͼͽBͶ͸B
KFͻ
ͽͻBͱF
ͷFͯͳK
ͲB
ͺͻF͸Pͼ
ͺPͻ;͵F
0ͬB
ͼͻFͯͼͽͬB
ͼF
΂FͼͽP

PͲ͸B΂BͬBK;
ͳ
͵BP
ͼͻFͯͼͽͬB
ͷFͯͳKͼ͵F
ͺͻPͺBͭB͸ͯF
͆BK΂F΃ΕF
ͼF
ͷͳͼͶͳ
͸B

;ͺPͽͻFͫ;
ͽFͶFͬͳͲͳKF
ͻBͯͳKB
ͳ
΃ͽBͷͺF
͵BP
ͳ
͸B
ͺͻͳͷF͸;
ͼBͬͻFͷF͸F

ͳ͸ͿPͻͷB΁ͳP͸F
ͽF΀͸PͶPͭͳKF
ͺPͼFͫ͸P
ͳ
ͷͻFͱB
ͲB
ͺͻF͸Pͼ
ͺPͯBͽB͵B

ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳKͼ͵ͳ΀
ͫBͲͪ
ͺPͯBͽB͵B
ͳ
ͼͬB͵B͵P
ͳ͸ͽFͻ͸FͽB
͋ͻP΃͵Pͬͳ

PͭͶB΃BͬBΔB
͵ͻPͲ
ͷFͯͳKF
ͼ;
͵BP
΃ͽP
KF
ͺPͲ͸BͽP
ͬFPͷB
ͬͳͼP͵ͳ
BͶͳ

ͼ;
ͳ
FͿF͵ͽͳ
Pͯ
ͺͻBͬͳͶ͸F
;ͺPͽͻFͫF
ͷFͯͳKͼ͵Pͭ
ͺͻPͺBͭͳͻBΔB
ͽB͵PΌF

ͬͳͼP͵ͳ
0ͬB
ͼͻFͯͼͽͬB
͸BͻP΂ͳͽP
ͼ;
ͬBͱ͸B
;
ͼͳͽ;B΁ͳKBͷB
ͳ͸ͳ΁ͳKBͶ͸Pͭ

PͭͶB΃BͬBΔB
ͽK
;ͺPͲ͸BͬBΔB
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽB
ͼB
͸Pͬͳͷ
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯPͷ

͈ͻPKF͵΁ͳP͸B
ͼͻFͯͼͽͬB
ͷPͭ;
ͳͷBͽͳ
ͻBͲͶͳ΂ͳͽ;
ͿPͻͷ;
B

͸BK΂F΃ΕF
ͼF
;
PͬPͷ
͵P͸ͽF͵ͼͽ;
ͺPͯͻBͲ;ͷFͬBK;
ͺͻPͺBͭB͸ͯ͸ͳ
ͿͳͶ
ͷPͬͳ
ͯͳKBͿͳͶͷPͬͳ
ͳ
ͯͳKBͺPͲͳͽͳͬͳ
B
ͯB͸Bͼ
ͳ
͵BP
ͿͳͶͷPͬͳ
͸B
$%;

ͳ
%7%;

͈ͻPͼͽPͻ͸PͺͶBͼͽͳ΂͸B
ͼͻFͯͼͽͬB
͸BK΂F΃ΕF
ͳͷBK;
ͿPͻͷ;
͸B
ͼͽ;ͺB
͸B
ͺPKFͯͳ͸ͳͷ
ͳͲͶPͱͫF͸ͳͷ
ͳ
ͺͻPͯBK͸ͳͷ
ͼBͶP͸ͳͷB
͸B
͵PKͳͷB

ͼF
ͼ;ͼͻFΕ;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵B
ͽͻBͱΔB
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵B
ͺP͸;ͯB
͋P
ͼ;
;
ͼ;
΃ͽͳ͸ͳ
ͺPͲ͸BͽF
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F
ͫFͻͲF
͸B
͵PKͳͷB
ͼF
ͬͻ΃ͳ
;ͭPͬBͻBΔF

ͽ;ͻPͺFͻBͽPͻͼ͵Pͭ
ͺPͼͶB
BͶͳ
ͳ
ͻFͲFͻͬB΁ͳKB
ͳ
ͺͻPͯBKB
͵B͵P
ͺB;΃BͶ͸ͳ΀

ͺ;ͽPͬBΔB
ͽB͵P
ͳ
ͯͳͻF͵ͽ͸B
ͺͻPͯBKB
ͻBͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀

ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯB
͍PͻͷF
ͷPͭ;
ͫͳͽͳ
ͳ
;
ͬͳͯ;
ͽͲͬ
8PSL
4IPQB
͵BͯB
ͼF

ͺPͼFͫ͸P
BͭͻFͼͳͬ͸P
;ͺPͽͻFͫΓBͬBK;
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳP͸B
ͼͻFͯͼͽͬB
͵BP
΃ͽP

ͼ;
;͸BͺͻFΌFΔF
ͺͻPͯBKF
Pͯ͸Pͼͳ
ͼB
KBͬ͸P΃Ε;
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
PͫͶͳ΁ͳ

̹FͲ
ͳ͵B͵ͬF
ͼ;ͷΔF
KF
ͯB
ͫFͯF͵Fͻͳ
ͳͶͳ
ͬPͯͳ΂ͳ
ͲB
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵F


ͺͻFͯͼͽBͬΓBK;
ͳͲ;ͲFͽ͸P
Ͳ͸B΂BK͸P
ͼͻFͯͼͽͬP
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳP͸F
B͵ͽͳͬ͸Pͼͽͳ

ͲB
ͼͬB͵;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵;
ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳK;
0͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͯ;ͭP
ͬͻFͷF͸B
ͷPͭͶͳ
ͯB
ͼF

ͼͬͻͼͽBͬBK;
ͼBͷP
;
ͭͻBͿͳ΂͵B
ͼͻFͯͼͽͬB
ͺͻPͷPͽͳͬ͸F
B͵ͽͳͬ͸Pͼͽͳ
ͷBͯB

ͼF
;
ͼBͬͻFͷF͸ͳͷ
;ͼͶPͬͳͷB
ͽͻͱͳ΃͸Pͭ
ͺPͼͶPͬBΔB
͵PKF
͵BͻB͵ͽFͻͳ΃F



0HJMWZ
ͳͼͽP
 ͇ͭΔͰ͸
̹ͪ͵ͳΕ

ͳ
ͼ͸Bͱ͸B
;ͺPͽͻFͫB
ͳ͸ͽFͻ͸FͽB
ͳ
ͽͲͬ
XFC
ͺͻFͲF͸ͽB΁ͳKB
P͸ͳ
ͷPͭ;

ͺͶBͼͳͻBͽͳ
ͳ
͵ͻPͲ
PͬBK
ͬͳͻͽ;FͶ͸ͳ
ͬͳͯ
͵Pͷ;͸ͳ΁ͳͻBΔB
ͳ
ͺPͯͬFͼͽͳ

ͺPͯ
ͷFͯͳKͼ͵B
ͼͻFͯͼͽͬB
ͺͻPͺBͭB͸ͯF
̺Fͻ;KFͷP
ͯB
͸FΕFͷP
ͺPͭͻF΃ͳͽͳ

B͵P
ͳͲͻBͲͳͷP
ͼͽBͬ
ͯB
ͫFͯF͵Fͻ
ͯB͸Bͼ
ͺͻFͯͼͽBͬΓB
ͭF͸Fͻͳ΂͵P
ͳͷF

ͲB
΃ͳͻ;
ͶFͺFͲ;
ͽͲͬ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F
ͶͳͽFͻBͽ;ͻF
͵PKB
ͼͽPKͳ
͸B
ͻBͼ
ͺPͶBͭBΔ;
ͺPͽF͸΁ͳKBͶ͸PK
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵PK
ͽͻBͱΔͳ
ͯB
ͼF
ͳ͸ͿPͻͷͳ΃F

P
ͻBͲ͸Pͬͻͼ͸ͳͷ
FͶFͷF͸ͽͳͷB
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F
ͺP͸;ͯF
ͯBͽF
ͭFPͭͻBͿͼ͵P
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F
΁FͶͳ͸F
ͽK
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F
ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳKF
͈PͶBͲFΕͳ
Pͯ
ͭF
͸FͻBͶ͸F
BͺͻP͵ͼͳͷB΁ͳKF
͵PKB
;͵;ͺB͸
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͻBͲͬPK
ͺPͼͷBͽͻB

͵ͻPͲ
ͯͬF
FͺP΀F
ͳ
ͽP
FͺP΀;
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷB
ͺͻͳͬͳͶFͭPͬB͸ͳ΀
͵ͶBͼB
ͳ
ͼBͬͻF
ͷF͸;
FͺP΀;
ͻBͲͬPKB
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷB
ͭͯF
ͼF
ͬͻFͷF͸ͼ͵B
ͻBͲͯFPͫB
ͳͲͷFΌ;

FͺP΀B
ͷPͱF
ͼͷFͼͽͳͽͳ
;
ͺFͻͳPͯ
ͳͲͷFΌ;
ͯͬB
ͼͬFͽͼ͵B
ͻBͽB
B
ͺPͼFͫ͸P

ͺPͼͶF
̽ͻ;ͭPͭ
ͼͬFͽͼ͵Pͭ
ͻBͽB
ͷPͱF
ͼF
ͼͶPͫPͯ͸P
͵P͸ͼͽBͽPͬBͽͳ
ͯB
ͼ;

ͫFͯF͵Fͻͳ
PͯͳͭͻBͶͳ
ͬBͱ͸;
;ͶPͭ;
;
PͽͬBͻBΔ;
͸Pͬͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀

ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳKB
ͼ
KFͯ͸F
ͼͽͻB͸F
͵BP
ͳ
ͺPͺ;ͶBͻͳͲB΁ͳKͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷB
͵BP

ͷBͼPͬ͸Pͭ
ͿF͸PͷF͸B
ͺPͼFͫ͸P
;

ͬF͵;
ͼ
ͯͻ;ͭF
ͼͽͻB͸F

̺Fͻ;KFͷP
ͯB
KF
̓BͻͶ
̹FͯF͵Fͻ
ͿPͻͷͳͻBK;Εͳ
ͼͬPK;
ͳͲͯBͬB΂͵;

͵;Ε;
ͺͻF

ͭPͯͳ͸B
ͼBͷP
ͳ͸ͽ;ͳͽͳͬ͸P
ͫͳP
ͼͬFͼͽB͸
ͬBͱ͸Pͼͽͳ

ͽ;ͻͳͲͷB
͵BP
ͿF͸PͷF͸B
͵PKͳ
ΕF
;ͫͻͲP
ͺPͼͽBͽͳ
ͯFͶBͽ͸Pͼͽ
͵PKB
ͺP

ͼͬPKͳͷ
F͵P͸Pͷͼ͵ͳͷ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬF͸ͳͷ
ͺͼͳ΀PͶP΃͵ͳͷ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
͵P͸P
ͽB΁ͳKBͷB
͵BͻB͵ͽFͻͳ΃F
΁FP

ͬF͵
͢FͭPͬF
t͵ΔͳͭFi
ͫ;ͯ;Εͳ
ͯB
KF

ͱͳͬFP
;
FͺP΀ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷB
ͺͻͳͬͳͶFͭPͬB͸ͳ΀
͵ͶBͼB
ͫͳͶF
ͼ;
ͯPͷͳ͸B͸ͽ͸P

͸BͷFΔF͸F
P͸ͳͷB
͵PKͳ
ͼ;
ͳͷBͶͳ
͸Ͱ͹ͺ΀͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͺͻFͽͺPͼͽBͬ͵F
ͲB
;͵Γ;
΂ͳͬBΔF
;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵B
͵ͻFͽBΔB
ͼͶPͫPͯ͸P
ͬͻFͷF
ͳ
ͼͶPͫPͯ͸B
͸Pͬ΂B͸B

ͼͻFͯͼͽͬB

ͽK
BͻͳͼͽP͵ͻBͽͳKͳ
ͳ
͸BͯPͶBͲFΕPK
ͫ;ͻͱPBͲͳKͳ
͸ͳͼ;
ͫͳͶF

ͬFͶͳ͵ͳ΀
ͽͳͻBͱB
BͶͳ
ͼ;
ͺͻFͯͼͽBͬΓBͶF
ͬFPͷB
;ͫFͯΓͳͬB
ͳ
΃ͳͻP͵P

ͳ͸ͿPͻͷBͽͳͬ͸B
ͼͻFͯͼͽͬB
ͲB
ͽBͯB΃ΔF
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵F
P
ͺͻͳͻPͯ͸ͳͷ
ͶFͺP
ͽBͷB
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸PͳͼͽPͻͳKͼ͵Pͷ
͸BͼͶFΌ;
B͸ͽͻPͺPͭF͸ͳͷ
ͿB͵ͽPͻͳͷB

ͺͻFͬPͲ͸ͳͷ
ͼͷF΃ͽBK͸ͳͷ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
͵BͺB΁ͳͽFͽͳͷB
ͽBͯB΃ΔF
;
ͼͬFͷ;

͸B
ͻBͲ͸ͳͷ
ͼͽͻB͸BͷB
ͼͬFͽB
ͼ͵ͻPͷ͸F
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F
ͺP͸;ͯF

͋BͯB
ͳ

͸ͳKF
ͺPͼͽPKBͶP
ͷBͼPͬ͸P
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵P
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽF
;
ͯB͸B΃ΔFͷ
ͼͷͳͼͶ;

ͻF΂ͳ

ͽF
͸ͳKF
ͺPͼͽPKBͶB
͸ͳ
ͺPͽͻFͫB
ͲB
ͼFͭͷF͸ͽͪ΁ͳKPͷ
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽB

ͳ
ͯͳͿFͻF͸΁ͳͻBΔFͷ
ͺͻPͳͲͬPͯB
͉BͯͳͶP
ͼF
P
ͯPͫͻP
ͼͳͽ;ͳͻB͸PK
ͳ

ͻFͶBͽͳͬ͸P
ͯPͫͻP
PͫͻBͲPͬB͸PK
ͳ
ͺͻͳͬͳͶFͭPͬB͸PK
͵ͶBͼͳ
ͱFΓ͸PK
ͯB

;ͺPͲ͸B
t͸PͬF
͵ͻBKFͬF
ͳ
Γ;ͯF
͵BP
ͳ
Δͳ΀PͬF
Pͫͳ΂BKFi
͢FͭPͬ
ͻBͯ
ͳͷBP

KF
FͿF͵ͽF
t͵BͷF͸΂ͳΕB
ͫB΂F͸Pͭ
;
ͷͳͻ͸;
ͬPͯ;i
KFͻ
ͼ;
ͼF
ͺPKBͬͳͶͳ

ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
ͳͲͯBͬB΂ͳ
ͳ
ͻBͲͶͳ΂ͳͽF
ͳ
ͳͲͯͳͿFͻF͸΁ͳͻB͸F
ͳ͸ͿPͻͷB΁ͳKF
P

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ;ͽPͬBΔͳͷB
͈PͼͽFͺF͸P
KF
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲBͷ
ͺͻFͶBͲͳP

;
ͼͬPK;
ͼͶFͯFΕ;
ͿBͲ;
ͷBͼPͬ͸Pͼͽ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵B
ͽͻBͱΔB
ͼF
;ͷ͸P
 ̺͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
;
ͷͰ͸ͪΘͷͰ͸ͽ;
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹΁ͳ͹͸͹ͭ
ͷͳ͵ͼͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ 

ͱBͬBͶB
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵B
ͺP͸;ͯB
ͺPͬFΕBͬBͶB
B
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵P
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽF

ͺPͶB͵P
ͺͻFͶBͲͳͶP
Pͯ
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽB
ͺͻPͯBͬB΁B
;
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽF
͵;ͺB΁B

"͵P
ͼ;
ͺͻͬͳ
ͫFͯF͵Fͻͳ
ͳͷBͶͳ
ͳͲͻBͲͳͽ;
ͯPͲ;
F͵ͼ͵Ͷ;Ͳͳͬ͸Pͼͽͳ
P͸ͳ

ͽP
ͯB͸Bͼ
ͼͬB͵B͵P
͸FͷBK;
ͳ
ͽP
;ͺͻBͬP
;
ͷFͻͳ
;
͵PKPK
KF
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲBͷ

ͯFͷP͵ͻBͽͳͲPͬB͸
͵BP
ͿF͸PͷF͸
̽B͵ͶF
P͸ͳ
ͼF
ͯB͸Bͼ
͸BͷFΔ;K;
ͳ
΃ͳͻPK

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵PK
͵ͶͳKF͸ͽFͶͳ
ͲBͳ͸ͽFͻFͼPͬB͸PK
ͯB
ͳ͸ͿPͻͷB΁ͳKF
;
ͬFͲͳ
ͼB

ͼͬPKͳͷ
ͺ;ͽPͬBΔͳͷB
ͯPͫͳKF
ͳ
͵ͻPͲ
ͼͬFͼͽͻB͸ͳKF
ͳ
ͯ;ͫΓF
;ͺPͲ͸BͬBΔF

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F
ͶͳͽFͻBͽ;ͻF
͈B
ͳͺB͵
ͼͬPKFͬͻͼ͸;
F͵ͼ͵Ͷ;Ͳͳͬ͸Pͼͽ
ͫFͯF
͵Fͻͳ
ͳͷBK;
ͳ
ͯB͸Bͼ
ͺPͼFͫ͸P
;
ͬFͲͳ
ͼB
΂ͳΔF͸ͳ΁Pͷ
ͯB
KF
PͬBK
ͬͳͯ
ͽ;
ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F
ͶͳͽFͻBͽ;ͻF
ͬFPͷB
ͻBͯP
ͺͻͳ΀ͬBΕF͸
ͬͳͯ
ͳ͸ͿPͻͷͳͼBΔB

P͸ͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺPͽͻP΃B΂B
͵PKͳ
ͼ;
ͳͲ
ͻFͶBͽͳͬ͸P
ͬͳ΃F
ͺͻͳ΀Pͯ͸F

ͭͻ;ͺF
͵PKͳ
ͼ;
ͻFͶBͽͳͬ͸P
PͫͻBͲPͬB͸ͳKͳ
ͼͶFͯͼͽͬF͸P
ͳ
Ͳ͸BͽͳͱFΓ͸ͳKͳ

ͳ
;
ͼͬB͵Pͷ
ͼͶ;΂BK;
ͺͻFͯͼͽBͬΓBK;
ͻFͿFͻF͸ͽ͸;
ͭͻ;ͺ;
͵PK;
;
PͯͶ;͵BͷB

ͭͯF
͵BͯB
ͳ
͵B͵P
ͺ;ͽPͬBͽͳ
ͭͯF
PͯͼFͯBͽͳ
ͳ
΃ͽB
ͻBͯͳͽͳ
;
ͼͶPͫPͯ͸P

ͬͻFͷF
ͼͶFͯͳ
ͷBͼB
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
ͺPͽͻP΃B΂B
tͲͶBͽ͸F
΀PͻͯFi

͆ͳKF
ͯB͸Bͼ

ͻFͽ͵P
͸BΕͳ
͸B
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Pͷ
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽ;
P͸F
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F
ͽK
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵F

BͭF͸΁ͳKF
͵PKF
͵BͺͳͽBͶͳͲ;K;
ͳ͸ͽFͶF͵ͽ;BͶ͸;
ͻBͯPͲ͸BͶPͼͽ
ͳ
ͬͳͼP͵P

PͫͻBͲPͬBΔF
ͺPͽF͸΁ͳKBͶ͸F
ͽͻBͱΔF
ͳ
͸B
ͽPK
Pͼ͸Pͬͳ
͵ͻFͳͻBK;
ͻBͲͶͳ΂ͳͽB

ͺB;΃BͶ͸B
ͺ;ͽPͬBΔB
͵PKB
ͳͯ;
ͽͻBͭPͷ
ͺPͲ͸Bͽͳ΀
͵ΔͳͱFͬ͸ͳ΀
ͯFͶB

͸ͺͻ
;ͺPͲ͸BͬBΔF
ͱͳͬPͽB
ͻBͯB
ͳ
ͷFͼͽB
;
͵PKͳͷB
KF
ͫPͻBͬͳP
&ͻ͸Fͼͽ

͎Ͱͷͳ͸ͭͬͰΒ
ͺͳͼB΁
ͺPͻFͯ
PͼͽBͶPͭ
ͳ
ͻPͷB͸B
t͊ͽBͻB΁
ͳ
ͷPͻFi

͈P
ͳͼͽPͷ

ͺͻͳ͸΁ͳͺ;
͵BͺͳͽBͶͳͲ;K;
ͼF
tͺͻͳ΂Fi
ͳ
ͻBͲͶͳ΂ͳͽF
tͽFͷFi
ͲB
΂ͳͽBͬF

ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳKF
͸ͺͻ
P
ͼBͶFͷͼ͵ͳͷ
ͬF΃ͽͳ΁BͷB
͐ͳ΂B
͋Pͷͳ͸PK
͵PͶͳͫͳ

ͭͻPͿ;
̽ͻB͵;Ͷͳ
ͼͬFͽ͹Β
͈Fͽ͵ͳ
ͳ
ͼͶ

̹ͳͶP
͵B͵P
ͫͳͶP
ͫFͯF͵Fͻͳ
͵BP

ͳ͸ͽFͶF͵ͽ;BͶ͸P
ͼPͿͳͼͽͳ΁ͳͻB͸ͳ
ͳͲͬPͻͳ
ͳ͸ͿPͻͷB΁ͳKB
;ͬF͵
ͺPͻFͯ

ͳ͸ͿPͻͷBͽͳͬ͸F
ͳ
ͺͻPͺBͭB͸ͯ͸F
ͳͷBK;
ͳ
PͫͻBͲPͬ͸;
Ϳ;͸͵΁ͳK;
̹ͳͽͳ

͸B
ͺͻBͬͳ
͸B΂ͳ͸
ͺͻFͲF͸ͽPͬB͸
;
ͫFͯF͵FͻͳͷB
ͺͻFͯͼͽBͬΓB
KP΃
KFͯB͸

Pͯ
ͫͳͽ͸ͳ΀
ͿB͵ͽPͻB
;
ͺͻBͬͳͶ͸PK
ͺͻͳͷF͸ͳ
ͼͽͻBͽFͭͳKF
ͺͻPͷP΁ͳP͸Pͭ

ͷͳ͵ͼB
ͼͬB͵F
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵F
ͯFͼͽͳ͸B΁ͳKF
ͺB
ͽB͵P
ͳ
̹BͶ͵B͸B
͈PͯͶPͭB

ͷPͻB
ͫͳͽͳ
;
ͯPͷF͸;
ͳͼͽͳ΁BΔB
͵PͷͺBͻBͽͳͬ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻFͯ͸Pͼͽͳ
ͽΒ
ͼͬͳ΀

ͻBͲͶͳ΂ͳͽPͼͽͳ
ͼͺF΁ͳͿͳ΂͸Pͼͽͳ
ͳ
;͸ͳ͵Bͽ͸Pͼͽͳ
PͬPͭ
KFͯͳ͸ͼͽͬF͸Pͭ

ͺPͯͻ;΂KB
&ͬͻPͺF

 ͇ͭΔͰ͸
̹ͪ͵ͳΕ

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

0HOKFO
#BLJǀ
3FJTFGÛISFS
JN
.BOBHFNFOU
FJOFS
1SPNPUJPOTNJTDIVOH
EFT
#BMLBO

BMT
FJOFT
FJOIFJUMJDIFO
3FJTF[JFMT
GÛS
5PVSJTUFO

%FS
WPSMJFHFOEF
"SUJLFM
CFTDIÅGUJHU
TJDI
NJU
EFN
#BMLBO
BMT
FJOFN

3FJTF[JFM
JN
XFJUFSFO
4JOOF
JN
7FSTVDI
EJFTFT
(FCJFU
BMT
FJOF
JOUFHSJFSUF

UPVSJTUJTDIF
&JOIFJU
EBS[VTUFMMFO

JOEFN
FJO
LPO[FQUVFMMFT
.PEFMM

[VS
'ÕSEFSVOH

VOUFSTDIJFEMJDIFS
.BSLFUJOH"LUJWJUÅUFO
BVG
EFS
&CFOF
EFS
5PVSJTNVTQPMJUJL

BOHFHFCFO
XJSE
*O
EJFTFN
3BINFO
XFSEFO
WB
1SPNPUJPOTTUSBUFHJFO

GPLVTTJFSU
XJF
BVDI
1SP[FEVSFO
EJF
EBCFJ
BOHFXBOEU
XFSEFO
TPMMUFO
&T

XJSE
BVDI
BVG
3FJTFGÛISFS
BMT
FJO
XJDIUJHFT
.JUUFM
EFS
1SPNPUJPOTTUSBUFHJFO

IJOHFXJFTFO
VOE
[XBS
BVG
VOUFSTDIJFEMJDIFO
&OUXJDLMVOHTTUVGFO
JO
EFS

(FTDIJDIUF
EFT
5PVSJTNVT

"V“FSEFN
HMBVCFO
XJS
EBTT
,BSM
#BFEFLFS
EFS
WPS
NFIS
BMT


+BISFO
TFJOFO
OBNIBGUFO
7FSMBH
HSÛOEFUF
TJDI
OVS
JOUVJUJW
EFS
#FEFVUVOH
EFT

5PVSJTNVT
BMT
FJOFT
1IÅOPNFOT
CFXVTTU
XBS
EBT
JO
LÛS[FTUFS
;FJU
[V
FJOFS

OBDI
XJSUTDIBGUMJDIFO
HFTFMMTDIBGUMJDIFO
QTZDIPMPHJTDIFO
VOE
WJFMFO
BOEFSFO

,POOPUBUJPOFO
GÛS
EBT
HFTBNUF

+BISIVOEFSU
LFOO[FJDIOFOEF
5ÅUJHLFJU

XVSEF
4FJO
8FSL
WFSVSTBDIUF
FJOFO
%PNJOP&GGFLU
EFOO
JIN
GPMHUFO

WJFMF
BOEFSF
7FSMFHFS
NJU
OFVFO
NBOOJHGBMUJHFO
VOE
BVTEJGGFSFO[JFSUFO

*OGPSNBUJPOFO
GÛS
5PVSJTUFO
4P
OÅIFSUF
TJDI
MBOHTBN
BVDI
EFS
5PVSJTNVT

TFJOFS
[XFJUFO
&OUXJDLMVOHTQIBTF
EFS
EFT
.BTTTFOUPVSJTNV
%JF
/BDIGSBHF

XVSEF
JNNFS
HSՓFS
EBT
"OHFCPU
JNNFS
VNGBOHSFJDIFS
XBT
BVDI
FJOF

7FSXBOEMVOH
EFT
5PVSJTNVTNBSLUFT
WFSVSTBDIUF
VOE
[XBS
WPO
FJOFN
.BSLU

GÛS
1SPEVLUBOCJFUFS
JO
FJOFO
.BSLU
GÛS
1SPEVLULPOTVNFOUFO


0CXPIM
EJF
FSTUFO
3FJTFGÛISFS
[XFJGFMMPT
FJOFO
)BVDI
WPO
&YLMVTJWJUÅU

BVGXJFTFO
TJOE
EJFTF
IFVU[VUBHF
EBOL
EFS
%FNPLSBUJTBUJPO
EFT
1IÅOPNFOT

5PVSJTNVT
LFJOFTGBMMT
BMT
FYLMVTJW
[V
CF[FJDIOFO
%JF
3FJTFGÛISFS
TJOE

EFNFOUTQSFDIFOE
GÛS
FJOFO
WJFM
CSFJUFSFO
,POTVNFOUFOLSFJT
CFTUJNNU
EFS

TJDI
BVDI
GÛS
FJOF
EFUBJMMJFSUFSF
VOE
VNGBOHSFJDIFSF
3FJTFMFLUÛSF
JOUFSFTTJFSU

"MT
FJOF
JOUFMMFLUVFMM
TPQIJTUJ[JFSUF
*OGPSNBUJPOTRVFMMF
IBCFO
EJF

3FJTFGÛISFS
OFCFO
FJOFS
SFJOFO
8FSCF
BVDI
FJOF
CFTUJNNUF
#JMEVOHTGVOLUJPO

*O
3FJTFGÛISFSO
BVG
FJOF
SJDIUJHF
"SU
VOE
8FJTF
QSÅTFOUJFSU
[V
XFSEFO
TUFMMU

FJOFO
XFJUFSFO
XJDIUJHFO
'BLUPS
JN
1SPNPUJPOTNJY
FJOFT
UPVSJTUJTDIFO

#FTUJNNVOHTPSU
EBS
%BT
HJMU
BVDI
GÛS
EFO
#BMLBO
%JF
(SVOEMBHF
EBGÛS
NÛTTUFO

7PSUFJMF
C[X
&JONBMJHLFJUFO
EJFTFS
3FHJPO
CJMEFO
EJF
BMMF
&JHFOUÛNMJDILFJUFO

VOE
#FTPOEFSIFJUFO
EJFTFT
CVOUFO
'MFDLT
BVG
EFS
-BOELBSUF
&VSPQBT

IFSWPSIFCFO

ͪͅ΃ͪ
̸̺͇̺͌̓͆́ͣ
̀ͪͬ͹ͯ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻ͹;΂ͪͬͪΔͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͻͪͲͬͳͽ͵ͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

̸̺͉͊̾̾͆́ͅ

͉͋͌́͊͋́͐̓́
̺͇̽́͐́

̸͆
͉́͆͋̾͆̾͋͌

͆ͪͶͪͲͰΕͳ
;ͺ͹ͻͳ΃ͽͰ
;
ͽͰ͵͹ͬͳ͸ͪͷͪ
ͻ͹ͷͪ͸ͽͳͲͷͪ
ͯ͹
ͼͻͰͯͳ͸Ͱ


ͬͰ͵ͪ
͸ͪͼͽͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͪͭͰ͸΁ͳΒͰ
͵ΔͳͭͰͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ

ͪͻͪ͸ͱͷͪ͸ͳ
́ͪ͵͹
ͪͭͰ͸΁ͳΒͼ͵ͳ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͳ

ͯͪΓͰ
ͯͻͱͰ
ͺͻͳͷͪͽ
ͺ͹ͺͪͻͽ
ͼͪ
ͼͬ͹Β͹ͷ
tEPJUZPVSTFMG i
ͿͳͶ͹Ͳ͹ͿͳΒ͹ͷ

͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͽͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͪ
;͹ͺ΃ͽͰ
ͯ͹ͬͰͶͳ
ͼ;
ͯ͹
ͺ͹ͬͰΕͪ͸͹ͭ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ

Ͳͪ
ͽͲͬ
tPGG
UIF
USBDLTi
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͼͪͷ͹ͼͽͪͶ͸͹
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ

̹ͰͲ
͹ͫͲͳͻͪ
͸ͪ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͺ;Ͷͪͻ͸͹ͼͽ
̹ͰͯͰ͵ͰͻͰͬͳ΀
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
ͺͻͰͼ;ͯͪ͸

Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ
Ͳͪ
Ͱ͵ͼͺͪ͸ͲͳΒ;
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͳͷͪ
;ͺͻͪ
ͬ͹
΀ͳͺͳ
ͺ͹͵ͻͰͽ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ
ͯͳͻͰ͵ͽͪ͸
;ͽͳ΁ͪΒ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͻͪͼͽ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͪ

Ͳͪ
tPGG
UIF
USBDLTi
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͸ͪ
΂Ͱͷ;
ͺ͹΂ͳͬͪ
΁ͰͶ͹͵;ͺ͸ͪ
CBDLQBDLFS

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
͆ͪͳͷͰ
ͼͬͪ͵Ͱ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
΀ͳΓͪͯͰ
ͷͶͪͯͳ΀
Γ;ͯͳ
ͽͲͬ
tCBDLQBD
LFSTiB
͵ͻͼͽͪͻͳ
ͼͬͰͽ͹ͷ
ͼ
ͻͪ͸΂Ͱͬͳͷͪ
͸ͪ
ͶͰΌͳͷͪ
͊ͽͳ΁ͪΔͰ
ͳͼ͵;ͼͽͪͬͪ

ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
ͳ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺ΁ͳΒͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
CBDLQBDLFS

ͼ΀ͬͪͽͪΔͳͷͪ
ͼ;΃ͽͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͯͰ͹
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼͪ
;΂ͰΔͪ
;
͵͹ͷͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ



t̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬͪ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼ;
ͺ͹͵ͻͳͬͪͶͪ
ͼ͵ͻ͹ͻ͹
΁ͰͶ;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺ;
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͶͪ
ͼ;

ͽͪ͵͹
ͺ͹ͺ;Ͷͪͻ͸ͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
΁ͳͽͳͻͪ͸ͪ
ͳͲΒͪͬͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͭ
΁ͪͻͪ
̺ͳͶ΀Ͱͷͪ
ͯͪ
͹͸
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͭͪ

ͯͪ͸ͪ
;
ͺ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͼͽ͹Βͳ
͸ͪ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹Ͳ͹ͻ;
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͺͪͶͪͽͰ
Ͳͪͽ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
;
̹ͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ;

͸ͪͺͳͼͪ͸͹
ͯͪ
Βͪ
ͭͶͰͯͪͷ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸;
ͼͽͻͪͱͰ
ͼͪ
ͽ͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹Ͳ͹ͻͪ
ͳ
Γ;ͯͳ
ͼ;
ͺ͹΂ͰͶͳ
ͽ͹
͹ͯ
ͷͰ͸Ͱ

ͯͪ
͹΂Ͱ͵;Β;i
͉
ͪͅͶͳ͸
͈ͳ͹͸ͳͻͳ
͇͌͆̾͊̓
̻Ͷͪͼ͸ͳ͵
m
̀ͪͬ͹ͯ
Ͳͪ
ͷͰΌ;͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸;

͸ͪ;΂͸;
ͺͻ͹ͼͬͰͽ͸;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸;
ͳ
ͽͰ΀͸ͳ΂͵;
ͼͪͻͪͯΔ;
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ



 ͪͅ΃ͪ
̺;͵ͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ

ͳͷͪ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒ;
;Ͷ͹ͭ;
͋ͻͪͱͰΕͳ
ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯ;
ͻͰͬ͸͹ͼ͸͹
t;ͺͳΒͪΒ;Εͳi

tͯ͹ͷ͹ͻ͹ͯͪ΂͵Ͱi
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
CBDLQBDLFSͳ
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ;
ͺͻ͹ͬͰͯ;
ͳ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͷͰ
ͼͰ΁ͳ
͋ͪ͵͹
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪͻͪͬ͸͹
͹ͯͻͪͱͪͬͪ
͸ͪ
t͵͹͸Ͳ;ͷͪ΁ͳΒ;i
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ

ͭͯͰ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽ
ͯͪΒͰ
͹͸ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͺͻ;ͱͪΒ;
͸ͪΒͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂
͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͈͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͼ;
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ͸ͪ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ

ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
͸Ͱͼͬͻͼͽͪ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
͋ͻͰΕͰͭ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
;͹ͺ΃ͽͰ
͋͹͵͹ͷ
ͳ΀
ͳ
ͳ΀

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
Ͱ͵ͼͺͪ͸ͲͳΒ;
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪͬͪΒ;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͸ͪͷͰ
ΔͰ͸ͳ
͹ͬ͹Β
ͼͺͰ΁ͳͿͳ΂͸͹Β
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹Β
ͭͻ;ͺͪ΁ͳΒͳ
;
Ͱ͵ͼͺͪ͸ͲͳΒͳ

͌
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͽͻͰ͸;ͽ͵;
ͬ͹ͯͰΕͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͼ;
-POFMZ
1MB
OFU
3PVHI
(VJEF
̾ZͰXJUOFTT
ͳ
(VJEF
EV
3PVUBSE
͈ͻͪͽͰΕͳ
ͽͰ΀͸͹Ͷ͹
΃͵ͳ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
͹ͬͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͳͷͪΒ;
ͼͬ͹Βͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͽͰͷͪ

͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͻͪͯͪ

͈ͻͰͷͪ
4MBWJD
BOE
&BTU
&VSPQFBO
-BOHVBHF
3FTPVSDF
$FOUFS

΃ͽ͹
ͺ͹ͽͬͻΌ;Β;
ͳ
Ͷͳ΂͸ͪ
ͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬͪ
ͺͻͰͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ

̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
;
΁ͰͶͳ͸ͳ
ͻͪ΂;͸ͪΒ;Εͳ
ͳ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒ;

ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
ͼͪͷ͹

͸ͪ
-POFMZ
1MBOFU
ͳ
:ͪIPP
5SBWFM
(VJEF
͈ͻͰ͹ͼͽͪͶͳ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
΃ͽͪͷ
ͺͪ͸ͳ

ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͸ͪ
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
XͰC
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
͸ͰͷͪΒ;
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ

͹
ͼͬͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
΂ͳͷͰ
ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸Ͱ

͵͹ͷͺͪͻͪͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͰ
ͪ͸;Ͷͳͻͪ͸ͪ
:BIPP
5SBWFM
(VJEF
ͼͰ
͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͪ΃ͪ͹

;
͹ͬ͹Β
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͳ
ͺͻͰͬͪͼ΀͹ͯ͸͹
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͽ͹ͭͪ
΃ͽ͹
:BIPP
ΒͰͼͽͰ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͺͻͰ
ͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂
ͽͰ
ͼͪͷͳͷ
ͽͳͷ
;
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͳͷ
͵ͻͰͽΔͪͷͪ
;͵Γ;΂;Β;Εͳ

ͳ
͹͸ͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͳͷͪ
ͼͽͪͽ;ͼ
ͯ͹ͺ;͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͪ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ

&ZFXJUOFTT

%,
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂͵ͪ
͵;Εͪ
΂ͳΒͳ
ΒͰ
͸ͪΒͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳΒͳ
tͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯi

&ZFXJUOFTT
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂

XͰͫ
TJUF
ΒͰ
͵͹͸΁ͳͺͳͻͪ͸
͵ͪ͹
BNB[PODPN
΃ͽ͹
ΕͰ

ͻͰΕͳ
͸ͪ
ΔͰͷ;
ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;ΕͰ
ͯ͹ͫͳͽͳ
͸ͪͻ;ΘͫͰ͸ͳ΁;
;Ͳ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ

͹
͵ΔͳͲͳ
;͵Γ;΂;Β;Εͳ
͵͹ͷͰ͸ͽͪͻͰ
΀ͬͪͶ͹ͼͺͰͬͰ

͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͻͰ΁Ͱ͸



t#BDLQBDLJOH
JT
UIF
CFTU
XBZ
UP
NFFU
MPDBM
QFPQMF
BOE
GFFM
GSFF
UIBUT
UIF

NBJO
UIJOH
:PV
SFBMMZ
GFFM
GSFF
*
EPOU
MJLF
UP
QMBO
XIBU
UP
EPi
$IBOUBMMF


'SFODI

$
"OEFSTLPW
#BDLQBDLFS
DVMUVSF
.FBOJOH
BOE
*EFOUJUZ
.BLJOH
1SPDFTTFT
JO

UIF
#BDLQBDLFS
$VMUVSF
BNPOH
#BDLQBDLFST
JO
$FOUSBM
"NFSJDB

XXXBOUISPCBTF
DPN



IUUQTFFMSDPSHXFCMJPHSBQIZ


t0O
JUT
PXO
UIJT
HVJEF
QSPWJEFT
BO
JOGPSNBUJWF
HFOFSBM
SFGFSFODF
UP
&VSPQF

5IF
DPODJTF
XFMM
QSFTFOUFE
UFYU
JT
TVQQPSUFE
CZ
JOOPWBUJWF
%
ESBXJOHT
BOE
TUVOOJOH

QIPUPHSBQIZ
XIJDI
QSPWJEFT
BO
JOUFSFTUJOH
BOE
SFGSFTIJOH
SFBE
*U
JT
BMTP
UIF
JEFBM

DPNQBOJPO
BOE
BO
PVUTUBOEJOH
JOUSPEVDUJPO
UP
UIF
OVNFSPVT
EFUBJMFE
HVJEFT
XIJDI

%PSMJOH
,JOEFSTMFZ
QSPEVDF
GPS
FBDI
PG
UIF
JOEJWJEVBM
SFHJPOTi
IUUQVLELDPN
USBWFM
ͻͰ΁Ͱ͸ͲͳΒͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺ;
 ͊ͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͸ͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ; 

ͲͳΒͰ
̓ͪ͵͹
;
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͳͷ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͳ
;
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸ͪ

̾ͬͻ͹ͺͪ
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺ;
;͵Γ;΂;ΒͰ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒ;
ͳ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵;
ͯ͹͵

ΒͰ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
ͲͰͷΓͪ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͪ
ͳ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸͹
ͳ
͸ͪ

͸Ͱͽ;

͆ͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
ͼͬͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
ͼ;
ͺͰͻͶͪͽͳͬͳͷͪ
tCFBVUJGVM
TFBTJEF
BNB[JOH
BSDIFPMPHJDBM
TJUF
UISJMMJOH

DBTUMFi
ͳͽͯ
͋ͻͰͫͪ
ͳͷͪͽͳ
;
ͬͳͯ;
ͯͪ
ͼ;
̾ZͰXJUOFTT
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
ͳ
͸ͪΒͶ;͵ͼ;
Ͳ͸ͳΒͰ
;ͻͪΌͰ͸ͳ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
̺Ͱ͹ͷͪ
͵ͬͪͶͳͽͰͽͪ͸
ͺͪͺͳͻ
͹ͫͳΓͰ

͵͹Ͷ͹ͻ
Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ
ͷͪͺͰ
;
͵͹Ͷ͹ͻ;
ͳͽͯ
͸Ͱ
ͯ͹ͺ;΃ͽͪΒ;
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
ͯ͹
ͫͳΒͪΔͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͫͰͼͺͶͪͽ͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ

3PVHI
(VJEFT

̀ͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;
͹ͯ
ͅ͹ͻͳ͸
ͳ
͋͹͸ͳ
̺ͪΒͶͰͻͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͹ͫͶͳ͵;Β;Εͳ
ͼͬ͹Βͪ

ͪͲͳΒͼ͵ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͪ
ͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬͪ
ͼͽͬ͹ͻͳͶͳ
-POFMZ
1MBOFU
͹ͼ͸ͳͬͪ΂
3PVHI

(VJEFT
ͪͅͻ͵
̾Ͷͳ͸ͭͪͷ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ
ͳ΀
͸ͳΒͰ
ͷ͹ͭͪ͹
ͯͪ
ͺͻ͹͸ͪΌͰ
ͪͯͰ
͵ͬͪͽͪ͸
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
Ͳͪ
̻ͻ΂͵;
͇ͬͪΒ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͼͰ
ͽͰ͵
͸Ͱͯͪͬ͸͹
ͺ͹Ͳͳ΁ͳ͹͸ͳͻͪ͹

͵ͪ͹
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͬ͹ͯͰΕͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͳ
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͽͻͰ͸;ͽ͵;
tͺ͹
͵ͻͳͬͪi
͹͵͹

ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
΃ͳͻ͹ͷ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
͆ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ

̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
3PVHI
(VJEFT
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒ;
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵;
͉;ͷ;͸ͳΒ;

ͳ
̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵;

1IPUP
HBMMFSZ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
͸ͪ
XXXSPVHIHVJEFTDPN
 ͪͅ΃ͪ
̺;͵ͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ

͌
ͺ͹ͻͰΌͰΔ;
ͼͪ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͳͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
3PVHI
(VJEFT
͸ͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ

͸Ͱͽ;
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͼ;ͱͪͬͪ
͸ͪ
;ͬ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
͹ͺͪͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͺͳͼ
͸ͪΒͪͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳΒͳ΀

ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͼ͹΁ͳ͹Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵Ͱ
ͯͰͷ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ

ͳ
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂͸Ͱ
Ͳͪ
tͺͻͰͯ
ͺ;ͽi
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ

ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͽͲͬ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳ
ͬͪ΂͵Ͱ
ͼͰ͵΁ͳΒͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͶͳ͸͵͹ͬͰ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽ͹ͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͪͽͻͪ͵΁ͳΒͰ

ͺͻͰͽͰͱ͸͹
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸Ͱ
ͬͪͱͰΕ͹ͷ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪͶͳͲͪ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͯͪͽͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ

(VJEF
EV
3PVUBSE

(VJEF
EV
3PVUBSE
ΒͰ
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵ͳ
t͹ͯͭ͹ͬ͹ͻi
͸ͪ
-POFMZ
1MBOFU

͐ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
(VJEF
EV
3PVUBSE
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͰΕͳ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳ
ͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹
Ϳͻͪ͸͵͹Ϳͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͯ͹ͼͽ;ͺͪ͸

ͼͪͷ͹
͸ͪ
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
ͳ
ͼ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͳͷͪ
;
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ΃Δͳͷ

Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵ͳͷ
͵͹Ͷ͹͸ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͯ͹ͬͰͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͯ͹
ͽ͹ͭͪ
ͯͪ
͹ͬͪΒ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
;ͺͻ͵͹ͼ
͵͹
ͻͳͼ͸ͳͷ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͳͷͪ
Ͷͳͷͳͽͳͻͪ͸;
ͺ;ͫͶͳ͵;
͌
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
͵ͪ͹

ͳ
;
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸͹ͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
(VJEF
EV
3PVUBSE
ͯͪΒͰ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
ͽ͹
ͷͰ
΃ͽͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
΂Ͱ͵ͪ
͵ͪͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͪ
ͳ
ͰͬͰ͸ͽ;ͪͶ͸͹
ͼͽͳͭ͸Ͱ
;
͸Ͱ͵;

͹ͯ
ͺ͹͸;ΌͰ͸ͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
BDDVFJM

͵ͪ͵ͬͪ
ΒͰ
tͶͳ΂͸ͪ

͵ͪͻͽͪ
ͲͰͷΓͰi
ͼ͹΁ͳ͹ͯͰͷ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ

ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂
͸Ͱ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
͸͹ͬ΁;
ͳͼ΀ͻͪ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͺͳΕ;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͳ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹͵Ͷͳ

͊ͽͻͪ͸ͪ
ͼͪ
Ͷͳ͸͵͹ͬͳͷͪ
;
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͳ
XXXSPVUBSEDPN
 ͊ͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͸ͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ; 

ͷͪͽͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͪΒ͸ͳͷ
͵ͪͺͪ΁ͳͽͰͽͰͽͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͼͶ
͇ͼͳͷ
ͽ͹ͭͪ

(VJEF
EV
3PVUBSE
͸ͪ
XͰC;
ͯͪΒͰ
΂ͳͽͪͬ
͸ͳͲ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ΀
Ͷͳ͸͵͹ͬͪ
ͺ͹ͷ͹
Ε;
͵͹Βͳ΀
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͶͪ΁
XͰC
TJUFͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͽͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͶ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͶͪ΁
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ
΁ͳΒͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͯ͹ͫͳͽͳ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͭͪΒͰ

Ͳͪ͸ͳͷͪΒ;
̈́ͳ͸͵͹ͬͳ
ͬ͹ͯͰ
ͺͻͬͰ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸͹
͸ͪ
tͯ͹ͷͪΕͰi
ͼͪΒͽ͹ͬͰ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͯͪ

ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳͷͪ
ͺ͹ͽͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͶ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͶͪ΁
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͪ
͹ͯ
ͻͰͶͰ
ͬͪ͸ͽ͸ͳ΀
;ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬͪ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
tͯ͹ͷͪΕͳ͸ͪi
΂ͳͷͰ
ͼͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;ΒͰ
͹ͯ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀

ͼͪΒͽ͹ͬͪ


-POFMZ
1MBOFU
-POFMZ
1MBOFU
ΒͰ
͸ͪͼͽͪ͹
͵ͻͪΒͰͷ
ͼͰͯͪͷͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
͸ͪ͵͹͸
΃ͽ͹

ͼ;
͹ͼ͸ͳͬͪ΂ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪͶͳ
́͸ͯͳΒ;
ͳ
͏Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶ͸;
̸ͲͳΒ;
ͳ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂ͳͶͳ

ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ͸
ͫͻ͹Β
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷͪ
ͭͯͰ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ΒͰͬͽͳ͸͹

ͺͻͰ͸͹Εͳͽͳ
ͳ
ΒͰͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͺͻͳ
ͽ͹ͷ
ͷͪ͵ͼͳͷͪͶ͸͹
tͳͼ͵;ͼͳͽͳi
ͰͭͲ͹ͽͳ͵ͪ
̀ͪ

ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͪ
-POFMZ
1MBOFU
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰ΃ͪ͹
ͺ;ͽ
͹ͯ
ͽͪ͵͹ͻͰ
Εͳ
΀ͳͺͳ
ͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͯ͹
ͬ͹ͯͰΕͰͭ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂ͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͼͪ

΃ͳͻ͹͵ͳͷ
ͼͺͰ͵ͽͻ͹ͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ

ͳ

ͯͳͼͽͻͳͫ;΁ͳ͹͸Ͱ
ͷͻͰͱͰ

-POFMZ
1MBOFU
ΒͰ
͸Ͱ͵ͪ
ͬͻͼͽͪ
CBDLQBDLFS
ͫͳͫͶͳΒͰ
͌ͺͻͪͬ͹
ΒͰ
-P
OFMZ
1MBOFU
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͼͳ͸ͽͰͽͳͲPͬͪ͹
ͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬͪ
CBDLQBDLFSͪ
͈͹

ͼͬ͹Β͹Β
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͳ
͹ͬͪΒ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
;
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸͹ͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
ͺͻ;ͱͪ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ
΁ͳΒͰ
͹
ͲͰͷΓͳ
͹ͯ
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͽͳͺͪ
ͬͳͲͰ
ͽͻͪ͸ͼͺ͹ͻͽͪ

ͷ͹͸ͰͽͰ
ͯ͹
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ

̀ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ΒͰͯͪ͸

͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͳ΀
ͼͰͭͷͰ͸ͪͽͪ
ΒͰͼ;
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂Ͱ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͬͰͻͰ͸ͪ
ͷͰͼͽͪ

Ͳͪ
͹ͯͼͰͯͪΔͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
͹͸ͳ
΀͹ͽͰͶͳ
ͳ
΀͹ͼͽͰͶͳ
͵͹Βͳ
Ͳͪͯ͹ͬ͹ΓͪͬͪΒ;
͵ͻͳ
ͽͰͻͳΒ;ͷͰ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹ͭ
ͲͪͺͪͯΔͪ͵ͪ

ͺͻ͹ͬͰͻͰ͸ͳ
ͻͰͼͽ͹ͻͪ͸ͳ
ͭͯͰ
ΕͰ
͸ͪ

͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͳͼ΀ͻͪ͸Ͱ
͸ͪͬͳ͵͸;ͽ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͪ΁
ͼͽͰΕͳ
ͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬ͹
ͯ͹ͷͪΕͰ

͵;΀ͳΔͰ
ͫͰͲ
ͼͽͻͪ΀ͪ
͹ͯ
ͷ͹ͭ;Εͳ΀
ͷͰͽͪͫ͹Ͷͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͻͰͪ͵΁ͳΒͪ

͎͹ͽͰͶͳ
΀͹
ͼͽͰͶͳ
ͭ͹ͼͽͳ͹͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͳ
ͻͰͼͽ͹ͻͪ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͻͪ͸ͭͳͻͪ͸ͳ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
΁Ͱ͸ͪͷͪ
;
ͽͻͳ

͵ͪͽͰͭ͹ͻͳΒͰ
#VEHFU
͸ͪΒΒͰͬͽͳ͸ͳΒͰ

.JESBOHF
ͼͻͰͯΔͰ
΁Ͱ͸Ͱ

ͳ
5PQ

&OE
ͼ͵;ͺͪ
ͷͰͼͽͪ

΃ͽ͹
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵;
͹ͷ͹ͭ;Εͪͬͪ
ͯͪ
;͸ͪͺͻͰͯ
͹͵ͬͳͻ͸͹

ͺͻͰͯͬͳͯͳ
ͽͻ͹΃͵͹ͬͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͋ͪ͵͹ΌͰ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͷ
ͼͽͳͭ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
ͱͰΓͰ
͸͹
ͷͰͼͽ͹
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
ΕͰ
;
ͼͬ͹ͷ
-POFMZ
1MBOFU;
͹ͼͳͷ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ΀
͵ͻͪΒΔͰ

ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͼͪͲ͸ͪͽͳ
ͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹ͼͽͳ
;
ͫͶͳ
ͱͰͷ
͹͵ͻ;ͱͰΔ;
ͷͰͼͽͪ
ͳ
ͭͯͰ
ͳ
͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;ΕͰ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪͽͳ
ͳͲͶͰͽͰ

͌
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
ͺ͹ͺ;ͽ
́͸ͯͳΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
-POFMZ
1MB
OFU
ΒͰ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͺ͹Ͳͳ΁ͳ͹͸ͳͻͪ͸
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͬ͹ͯͰ
ͺͻͪͬͳ
ͷͪͶͳ
ͻͪͽ͹ͬͳ
;
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶ͸ͳͷ

ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;ΌͰ
;
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͰ
ͳͲͯͪΔͰ
̺ͳͯ͸ͳͷ
ͳ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
͸ͪͺͪͯ͸ͳͷ

 ͪͅ΃ͪ
̺;͵ͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ

ͳͼͽͳ΁ͪΔͰͷ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸ͳ
ͻͰͼͽ͹ͻͪ͸
΀͹ͽͰͶ
ͻͪͯΔͪ
ͳͽͯ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂Ͱ͸

;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
ͬͶͪͼ͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͳͼͽͳ΀
ͱͰͶͰ
ͯͪ
͸ͪͭͶͪͼͰ
Δͳ
΀͹ͬ;
ͺ͹;Ͳͯͪ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
͵ͬͪͶͳͽͰͽ
;ͼͶ;ͭͰ
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͽͪΒ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
͹ͫͰͲͫͰͯͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰΕͰ
͸͹ͼͽ
͵͹Βͪ
ͯ͹͸͹ͼͳ
Ͳͪͻͪͯ;
́ͷͪΒ;Εͳ
͹ͬ͹
;
ͬͳͯ;
-POFMZ
1MBOFU
ͺͻͪͬͳͶ͹

tQPMJDZi

ΒͰ
ͳ͸ͼͳͼͽͳͻͪΔͰ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹;Ͳͯͪ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͬͰͻͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻ
ͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͰ͸ͳ΀
͹ͯ
͸ͰͲͪͬͳͼ͸ͳ΀
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂ͪ
͇ͼͳͷ
ͽ͹ͭͪ
ͪͺͰͶ;ΒͰ

ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹
ͺ͹ͬͻͪͽ͵;
ͼͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͼͬ͹
Βͳͷ
ͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬͳͷͪ
ͺ͹ͷ͹ͭ͸;
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂ͳͷͪ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͫͳ
͸ͪͻͰͯ͸͹
ͳͲͯͪΔͰ
ͫͳͶ͹

Β͹΃
ͺ͹;Ͳͯͪ͸ͳΒͰ

͌ͽͳ΁ͪΒ
-POFMZ
1MBOFUͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
͵ͻͰͽͪΔͪ
ΒͰ

;
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͸ͪͬͻͪͽͪ
ͺͻͰͳͼͺͳͽͪͬͪ͸ͪ
͇ͬͪ
tCBDLQBDLFS
ͫͳͫͶͳΒͪi
ΒͰ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹

͵ͻͳͽͳ͵͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
ΒͰͻ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹ͬ͹ͯͳ
;
ͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ͸;
ͬͰͲ;
ͼ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͫ;ͷ͹ͷ

͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸ͳ΀
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͆Ͱͭͪͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯͳ΁Ͱ
ͽͪ͵ͬͰ
ͺ͹ͺ;ͶͪͻͳͲͪ
΁ͳΒͰ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸ͳ΀
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͹ͭͶͰͯͪΒ;
ͼͰ
;
ͺ͹ͻͰͷͰΕͪΒͳͷͪ
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶ͸ͳ΀

ͼ͹΁ͳ͹Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͱͯͪ
ͳ

ͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͪͻ;΃ͪͬͪΔ;
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ΀
Ͱ͸ͯͰͷͼ͵ͳ΀
Ͱ͵͹ͼͳͼͽͰͷͪ
͇ͼͳͷ
ͽ͹ͭͪ

-POFMZ
1MBOFU
ΒͰ
͵ͻͳͽͳ͵͹ͬͪ͸
ͳ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
;ͽͳ΁ͪΒͪ
͸ͪ
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͻͪΔͰ
ͼͽͰͻͰ͹ͽͳ
ͺͪ
͹
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸ͳͷ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ

̽Ͱͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
XXXMPOFMZQMBOFUDPN
 ͊ͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͸ͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ; 

͈;ͽͰͷ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͺ;ͽ

ͭͰ͹ͯͰͷ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͹
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͰΔͪ
͹
ͺ͹
ͽͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͶ͸ͳͷ
͹ͺͪͼ͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͬͻͰͫͪΒ;
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;͵Ͱ
͹
ͽ͹ͷͰ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͺͰ
ͻͳ͹ͯ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͪΒͳͯͰͪͶ͸ͳΒͳ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽ;
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸͹Β
ͲͰͷΓͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ
͵Ͱ
͹
ͷͪ͸ͳͿͰͼͽͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͪͽͻͪ͵΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
͵ͻͪͽͪ͵
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪͽ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
PGG

UIF
USBDLT
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
ͯ͹ͺ;͸ͼ͵͹Β
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͳ
͆ͪ

͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;
͹ͬͪ͵ͬ͹ͭ
ͳ͸ͳ΁ͳΒͪͶ͸͹ͭ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͪ
ͼ
ͺ͹ͽͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͶ͸ͳͷ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ
΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
ͼͰ
͹ͯͶ;΂;ΒͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
Ͳͪ
ͼͪͷ;
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͽͪ͵͹
ͳ
͸ͪ
͵;ͺ͹
ͬͳ͸;
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸͹ͭ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
͉ͪͽ͹ͬͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͯͰͬͰͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
͹ͯͬͳΒͪͶͳ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͯ
ͻ;΂Β;
ͫͳͬ΃Ͱ
͍͉͊͠
t͹ͯͫͳͶͳi
ͼ;
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵Ͱ
ͯͪ
ͷͪͼ͹ͬ͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͰ
ͺͻ͹
ͼͽ͹ͻ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
͌
-POFMZ
1MBOFU
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹ͷ
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
&VSPQF
PO
B
TIPF

TUSJOH
ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;ΒͰ
ͯͪ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͺͻͰͬͰͶͳ
͵͹ͭ
ͻͳͲͳ͵ͪ
Ͳͪ͹ͫͳΌ;
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͰ
̹͹ͼ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͽͪͯͪ΃ΔͰ

͠;
ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
͇ͼͳͷ
͸ͪ
͹ͬͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
͹ͺͪͼ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͬͻͰͫͪΒ;
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͯͰ

͌
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͰΔͪ
ͬͰͲͪ͸ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒ;
ͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒ;
ͳ

͏ͻ͸;
̻͹ͻ;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͪͽͳ΂͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
̓͹ͼ͹
ͬ͹
Β;ͭ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͼͰͬͰͻ͹Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸ͪ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͪ
͌
̹͹ͼ͸ͳ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ
͸ͳ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͪͬͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸Ͱ
Ͱ͵ͼͺͶ͹Ͳͳͬ͸Ͱ

ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͼ;͵͹ͫͰ
ͪ
;

͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹Β
͸ͪ
ͷͳ͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͺ͹Γͪ
͑ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͽͳ΂Ͱ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͰ
t͹ͺͪͼ͸ͳi
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳ

ͼ;
͹͸ͳ
ͫͶͳͲ;
ͪͯͷͳ͸ͳͼͽͻͪͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͼͪ
̓͹ͼ͹ͬ͹ͷ
̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͪ
ͳͪ͵͹

͸ͪ
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Β;
ͳͷͪ
Ͷ͹΃;
ͻͰͺ;ͽͪ΁ͳΒ;
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͼͽ͹ͺͰ
͵ͻͳͷͳ͸ͪͶͪ
;
-P
OFMZ
1MBOFU;
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͼͳͭ;ͻ͸ͪ
ͲͰͷΓͪ

̓Ͷͳͷͪͽͼ͵ͳ
ΒͰ
΁ͰͶ͹͵;ͺͪ͸
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
ͭͰ͸ͰͻͪͶ͸͹
ͺͻͰͺ͹
ͻ;΂Γͳͬ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
΁ͰͶͰ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͊ͰͺͽͰͷͫͪͻ
ΒͰ
ͺͪ͵
͹ͺͽͳͷͪͶͪ͸
ͷͰͼͰ΁

͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵;
΂ͳΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͷ͹ͻΒͰ
ͳ
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
͹Ͳ͸ͪ΂Ͱ͸͹
͵ͪ͹
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͪ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ
΁ͳΒͪ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
͸ͪΒͫ͹ΓͰ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͽͳ
;
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
͹ͯ
ͷͪΒͪ
ͯ͹
ͼͰͺ
ͽͰͷͫͻͪ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒ;
ΒͰ
ͫ͹ΓͰ
Ͳͪ͹ͫͳΕͳ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
Β;Ͷͪ
ͳ
ͪͬͭ;ͼͽͪ
ΒͰͻ
ͼͰ
΁Ͱ͸Ͱ

ͯͻͪͼͽͳ΂͸͹
ͺ͹ͬͰΕͪͬͪΒ;
ͪͶͳ
ͼ͵ͳΒͪΔͰ
ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;ΕͰ
;
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
͹ͯ
ͯͰ΁Ͱͷͫͻͪ

ͯ͹
ͷͪͻͽͪ
̿ͰΓͪ
Ͳͪ
ͼ͵ͳΒͪΔͰͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ
;
̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵;
͹ͯ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͿͰ
ͫͻ;ͪͻͪ
ͯ͹
ͺͻͬͰ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͷͪͻͽͪ
͈͹ͼͰͽ;
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͳ
͸ͪΒͫ͹ΓͰ
ΒͰ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ
ͻͪͽͳ
ͳͼ͵Γ;΂ͳͬ͹
Ͳͪ
ͼͰͺͽͰͷͫͪͻ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
ͳ
͏ͻ͸ͪ
̻͹ͻͪ
ΒͰ
;ͭ͹ͯ͸ͪ
ͲͰͷΓͪ

ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
΁ͰͶͰ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͷͪͯͪ
ͼͰ
Ͳͳͷ͹ͭͻ͹ͱΓͳͬͳͷͪ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;ΒͰ
ͯͪ

ΒͰ
Ͳͪ͹ͫͳΌ;
Ͳͳͷͳ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͪ
ͳ
̹͹ͼ͸ͪ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͪ
Ͳͪ΀ͬͪΓ;Β;Εͳ

͵Ͷͳͷͳ
ͺ͹ͭ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽ;
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
΁ͰͶͰ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
͹ͬͪ͵ͬͪ
ͺͻͰ
ͺ͹ͻ;͵ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͪͽͳ΂͸ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
̹͹ͼ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͭͯͰ
ͲͳͷͰ

ͷ͹ͭ;
ͫͳͽͳ
ͺͻͳͶͳ΂͸͹
ͼ;ͻ͹ͬͰ

͌
͵͹ΒͰ
ͭ͹ͯ
ͯ͹ͫͪ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
ͳͷͪ
ͳ
΃ͽͪ
ͯͪ

ͬͳͯͳ
ͳ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
Ͳͪͫͪͬͳ
́ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
;
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;

 ͪͅ΃ͪ
̺;͵ͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ

͸ͺͻ
̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͪ
ͳ
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͪ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͼͺͳͼͪ͵
ͺͻͪͲ͸ͳ͵ͪ
;
͹ͼͽͪͶͳͷ

ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
ͼͰ
ͼ;͹΂ͪͬͪ
ͼͪ
΃ͳͻ͹͵ͳͷ
ͳͲͫ͹ͻ͹ͷ
ͺͻͪͲ͸ͳ΂͸ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹
ͼͶͪͬͪ
ͳ
ͷͪ͸ͳͿͰͼͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
ͳ
͏ͻ͸ͪ
̻͹ͻͪ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͪ
ͳ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͪ

ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
΁ͰͶͰ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳͷͪΒ;
ͫ͹ͭͪͽ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͺͻͪͲ͸ͳ΂͸ͳ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ
ͦͰͲ

ΒͰ
;
̀ͪͭͻͰͫ;
ͯ͹ͫͪͻ
͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͶͰΕͰ
ͪ
ͶͰͽͳ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
̓Ͷͪͼͳ΂͸;
ͷ;Ͳͳ͵;

ͼͶ;΃ͪΒͽͰ
͸ͪ
̹̾͌͊ͅ;
͆ͪΒͫ͹Γͳ
ͶͰͽΔͳ
ͿͰͼͽͳͬͪͶͳ
ͼͰ
͹ͯͻͱͪͬͪΒ;
;

͡;ͫΓͪ͸ͳ
͸ͪ
̹ͶͰͯ;
̀ͪͭͻͰͫ;
͊ͺͶͳͽ;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
ͳ
̹;ͯͬͳ
͋ͪ͵͹Ͳͬͪ͸ͳ

Ϳ͹Ͷ͵
ͿͰͼͽͳͬͪͶͳ
͸ͪ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
;ͱͳͬͪͽͳ
;
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͷ

ͺͻͰͽͰͱ͸͹
ͷ;Ͳͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͼͽͬͪͻͪͶͪ΃ͽͬ;
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͶͰͽͪ
ͼ;
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͿͰͼͽͳ
ͬͪͶ
Ϳ͹Ͷ͵Ͷ͹ͻ͸Ͱ
ͷ;Ͳͳ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͳͭͻͰ
;
͇΀ͻͳͯ;
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
͊ͪͫ͹ͻ
ͽͻ;ͫͪ΂ͪ
;
̻;
΂ͳ
͍ͰͼͽͳͬͪͶ
;
͇ͷͳ΃;
͍ͰͼͽͳͬͪͶ
΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͭͶͪͲͫͰ
;
̽;ͫͻ͹ͬ͸ͳ͵;

͏Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶ͸ͳ
ͷ;Ͳͳ΂͵ͳ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒ
͸ͪ
͹ͬͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
̾ͭͲͳͽ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ

͹ͯͳͭͻͪͬͪ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ
Β;Ͷͪ
;
͆͹ͬ͹ͷ
͊ͪͯ;
ͅͰΌ;
ͬͰΕͳͷ
ͫͻ͹ΒͰͷ
ͿͳͶͷ
ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͿͰͼͽͳͬͪͶͪ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂Ͱ͸ͳ
ͼ;
͊ͪͻͪΒͰͬͼ͵ͳ
ͿͰͼͽͳͬͪͶ
ͳ
͍̾͊͋
͌͵͹
Ͷͳ͵͹
͸Ͱ͵͹
ͱͰͶͳ
ͯͪ
͹ͫͻͪͯ;ΒͰ
ͼͬ͹Β;
ͯͰ΁;
͸ͪ
͹ͬͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
ͺͻͰͺ͹
ͻ;΂;Β;
ͼͰ
ͅͰΌ;͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ
ͯͰ΂Βͳ
ͿͰͼͽͳͬͪͶ
;
͑ͳͫͰ͸ͳ͵;
̀ͷͪΒͰͬͰ
ͯͰ΂ΒͰ

ͳͭͻͰ
;
͆͹ͬ͹ͷ
͊ͪͯ;
ͳ
͉ͪͯ͹ͼͽ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
̸͸ͪͶͳͲͪ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͹͸ͳ΀
͹
ͰͶͳͽͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ

ͼ΀ͬͪΕͰ͸͹Β

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͳ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͳͪ͵͹
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ

͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽͳ΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
͹΂ͳͭͶͰͯ͸͹
΂ͳ͸Ͱ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ
͸ͳ
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͪͷͫͳΒͰ͸ͽ
̓;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ
ͯͳͬͰͻͲͳͽͰͽ
͸ͰͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸Ͱ
ͼͶͳ΂
͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
͸ͰͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸Ͱ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͰ
ͷͰΌ;
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ͹ͷ

͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͼͽͬ͹
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳ΀
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
͵;Ͷ
ͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
ͻͰͼ;ͻͼͪ
ͯͪΒ;
͸ͪͭ͹ͬͰ΃ͽͪΒ
ͺ͹ͽͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
tͅͰ͵Ͱi

̀ͪ
͹΂Ͱ͵ͳͬͪͽͳ
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
͸ͪͻͰͯ͸ͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͪͽͻͪ͵΁ͳΒͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ

̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
;͸ͪͺͻͰͯͰ
͌
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͽͻͰ͸;ͽ͵;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͰ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͳ
ͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
͹ͼͶͳ͵ͪͬͪ
΀ͪ͹ͽͳ΂͸͹ͼͽ
͵͹Βͪ
ͳ
ΒͰͼͽͰ
ͯͰ͹
ͼͬͪ
͵͹ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸͹ͭ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
ΔͰ͸͹ͭ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
͌
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ
ͼͰ

ͺͪ͵
ͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͺ͹ͬͻ΃ͪ͸
;ͬͳͯ
͈͹ͻͰΌͰΔͰͷ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
Βͪͼ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ

ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
;ͺ;ͽͳ͹
;
͹ͬͰ
͸ͪ΃Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͽͰ΃͵͹
ͯͪ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͯͪ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰ

͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
ͼ͹΁ͳ͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹
m
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͪͼͺͰ͵ͽͰ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͫΓ;
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͺ͹ͯ΁ͻͽͪͬͪ
ͼͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͼͽ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
;
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸;
΃ͽ͹
ͳͷ
ͺͶͳ΁ͳͻͪ
͸Ͱ͹ͺ΀͹ͯ͸͹ͼͽ
ͯ͹ͫͻͰ
ͼͪͻͪͯΔͰ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
;
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸;
ͺ͹
ͺͳͽͪΔ;

Ͱ͵͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;Ͱ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳͼͽͳ΀
;
ͻͰͶͰͬͪ͸ͽ
͸ͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ

t́ͼͽ͹͵
ͼͻͰΕͰ
Ͳͪͺͪͯi
ΒͰ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
;͸ͳͬͰͻͲͪͶͪ͸
͹ͺͳͼ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ

ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
͸ͪ΃Ͱͭ
ͺ͹ͯ͸ͰͫΓͪ
ͪͅͶ͹
΁ͻ͵ͪͬͪ
ͳ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͪ
ͷͪͶ͹
΂ͪͻ΃ͳΒͪ

͸ͪͶͳ͵
͹͸ͳͷͪ
;
͋;ͻͼ͵͹Β
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ΀
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶͳͽͰͽͪ
;
ͳͲ͹ͫͳΓ;
ͷͪͶ͹

ͫ;ͻͰ͵ͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͷͰͼͪ
͈ͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͰ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
;
-POFMZ
1MBOFU

 ͊ͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͸ͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ; 

ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
ΒͰ
ͽͪ͵ͬ͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵;
͹ͯ
ͺͻͬ͹ͭ
͵͹͸ͽͪ͵ͽͪ
ͺ;ͽͰͷ
ͳ͸
ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽͪ
Βͪͼ͸͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͻͰ΂
͹
ͺ͹ͯ͸ͰͫΓ;
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
ͼ͵͹ͻ͹
ͺͻͰͱͳͬͰͶ͹ͺͻ͹ͱͳͬͰ
Ͷ͹
ͻͪͽ͹ͬͰ
ͭͯͰ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͪ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͯͪΓͰ
ͫͳΒͰ
ͫͳͽ͵;
ͼ
ͳͼͽ͹΂Δͪ΂͵͹ͷ

͹ͼͽͪͬ΃ͽͳ͸͹ͷ
͏Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶ͸͹
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͺͻ;ͱͪ
͹ͼͰΕͪΒ
ͼͳͭ;ͻ͸͹
ͼͽͳ
t͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹i

ͯ͹͵
ͼ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
͹ͬͪΒ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ

ͻͰͶͪͽͳͬ͸͹
΁ͳͬͳͶͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸;
ͳ
ͭͰ͸ͰͻͪͶ͸͹
ͼͳͭ;ͻ͸;
;Ͳ
͸ͰͺͻͳΒͪͽ͸Ͱ
ͳͼͺͪ
ͯͰ
͸ͪ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͰ͸ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͳͷͪ

;ͬͰͻͽͳͻ;
Ͳͪ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰ
͋;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
͵͹Βͪ

ΒͰ
͹ͺͰͽ
;ͬͰͻͽͳͻͪ
Ͳͪ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰ
̸ͲͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͯͪͶͰ͵͹ͭ
́ͼͽ͹͵ͪ

͋ͻͰͫͪ
ͳͷͪͽͳ
͸ͪ
;ͷ;
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͍͉͊͠
ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͯ;ͭ͹
ͽͻͪΒͪͶͪ


ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͼͬͰ

ΔͰ͸Ͱ
͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ΃ΔͰ
΂Ͷͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͳ
ͯͪΓͰ
ͺͻͬͰ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸͹
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
͸ͪ
͸ͪ
΂ͳ͸
͵͹Βͳ
͹ͯͭ͹ͬͪͻͪ
ͽͪ͵͹ͻͰΕͳ
͵Ͷͪͼͳ΂͸ͳͷ
Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͷͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
΃ͽ͹
ΕͰ

ͻͰΕͳ
ͼ;͸΁Ͱ
ͺͶͪͱͪ
ͼ͸Ͱͭ
ͫͪΔͪ
͠Ͱͯͳ͸͹
;
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ;
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͰ
ΒͰͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͰY

͍͉͊͠
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰͼͽͰ
΂Ͷͪ͸
̾͌
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͳΒͳ
ͺͻ͹ͭͻͪͷ
ͺͻͰ
ͬͪͼ΀͹ͯ͸͹
ͺ͹ͼͽͳͭ͸;ͽ
ͺͻͳͷͰ͸͹ͷ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺͽͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
ͻ;ͽͪ

t͈͹͸;ͯͪi
ͬͰΕͳ͸Ͱ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͬͰͯͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͼͺ͹ͻͽͪ

ͳ
ͻͰ͵ͻͰͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͽͰͱ͸͹
ͳͲ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;Εͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
͹ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹
͸;ͯͰ
͇ͼͳͷ
;
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ;
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͰ
ͻ;ͻͪͶ͸͹Β
ͳ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹Β
͵;Ͷͽ;
ͻͳ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕ;ΒͰ
ͷͪͶ͹
ͺͪͱΔͰ
͌
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͳ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;ΒͰ

ͼͰ
͹ͫͳͶͪͲͪ͵
ͬͳ͸͹ͭͻͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͪͽ
͸ͪͺ͹ͻͪ
͵͹
ΒͰ
ΒͰ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͪ
;Ͷ͹ͱͳͶͪ
;
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
ͺͻͬͰ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸͹

;͵Γ;΂ͳͬͪΔͪ
;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͻ;ͽͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͼͬͰ͹ͫ;΀ͬͪͽ͸͹ͭ
͹ͫͶͳ͵ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹΁ͳΒͰ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͰ
̓;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
ͼͰ
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
ͯͰ
Ϳͳ͸ͳ΃Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
͹͸ͪΒ
͹ͫͶͳ͵
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
͵͹ͯ
͵͹ͭͪ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ

ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͺͻͳͷͪͻ͸ͳ
ͷ͹ͽͳͬ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͌
͸ͪ΃Ͱͷ
ͯͰͶ;
ͼͬͰͽͪ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
͵ͪ͹
͹ͫͶͳ͵
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
;
;ͼͺ͹͸;
ͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ͸
ΒͰ
ͯͪ͵ͶͰ

ΒͰͯͳ͸͹
;
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͳ
ͷͪͯͪ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͳͷͪͽͳ
;
ͬͳͯ;
ͯͪ
ͳ
;
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹Β
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹
Βͳ
ͼͽͻͪͽͰͭͳΒͪ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Βͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
ͯ͹͸Ͱͽͪ
͸ͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸͹ͷ
͸ͳ
ͬ͹;
̓;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
ΒͰ
ͫ;ͯ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
;
͹ͼͽͪͶͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪ

̀ͪͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸͹ͼͽ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
;
-POFMZ
1MBOFU
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ

ͳͲͯͪΔ;
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͰ
ͽ;ͷͪ΂ͳͽͳ
͵ͪ͹
͸Ͱͯ͹ͼͽͪͽͪ͵
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͷ͹
ͱͰ
ͯ͹ͬͰͼͽͳ
;
ͬͰͲ;
ͼ
ͺͻͳͶͳ΂͸͹
͸ͰͻͪͲͻͪΌͰ͸ͳͷ
ͼͽͻͪͽͰͭͳΒͪͷͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ
͸͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
;
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸;
͈;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͼ;
ͬͻͼͽͪ
΃͵͹ͶͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
Ϳ͹ͻͷ;Ͷͳͼͪ͹
ͺͻ͹ͿͰͼ͹ͻ

ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ
ͭͳͷ͸ͪͲͳΒͪ
;
ͽ;ͻͼ͵͹ͷ
ͭͻͪͯ;
̹;ͻͼͳ
͌
΃͵͹Ͷͳ
Ͳͬͪ͸͹Β
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪ
ΔͰ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͫͳ
ͫͳͶͳ
ͺͻͳͻ;΂͸ͳ΁ͳ
́ͪ͵͹
ͫͻ͹Β
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ͵ͪ

ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽͪ
͵͹͸ͽͳ͸;ͳͻͪ͸͹
ͻͪͼͽͰ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂ͳ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀

ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͻͰͯ;͵;Β;
͵͹Ͷͳ΂ͳ͸;
ͯ͹ͼͽ;ͺ͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳͳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͸ͪ
́͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱ
ͽ;
ΒͰͻ
ΒͰ
͹ͬͪΒ
͹ͫͶͳ͵
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
ͼͶͪͫ͹
ͳͼͺͶͪͽͳͬͪ
͵ͪͽͰ
ͭ͹ͻͳΒͪ
͌
͹ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂ͪͬͪΔ;
ͫͰͼͺͶͪͽ͸͹
ͺ;ͽͰͷ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽͪ
ͯ͹ͼͽ;ͺ͸ͳ΀

 ͪͅ΃ͪ
̺;͵ͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ

ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͺͻͰͯΔͪ΂ͳ
%,
&ZFXJUOFTT
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ

΂ͳΒͪ
ͼ;
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ
͸ͪ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͬͰΕ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽ͹
͸ͪΒͶ;͵ͼ;Ͳ͸ͳΒͰ
;ͻͪΌͰ͸ͪ
͆ͪ

-POFMZ
1MBOFU
ͼͪΒͽ;
ͼ;
ͯͪͽͰ
ͼ͵ͻͪΕͰ͸Ͱ
ͬͰͻͲͳΒͰ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͳ΀
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
ͼͪ

ͼ;ͷͳͻͪ͸ͳͷ
ͻͪͼͺ͹͸͹ͷ
΁Ͱ͸ͪ
ͽͻͪ͸ͼͺ͹ͻͽͪ
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͪΒͪ
ͳ
΀ͻͪ͸Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
;͹ͺ
΃ͽͰ͸ͳͷ
ͳͲͬͰ΃ͽͪͬͪΔͰͷ
͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͳ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
(VJEF
EV
3PV
UBSE
;
ͼͬ͹ͷ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͳͲͯͪΔ;
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͼͬͪ
tͺ͹ͭͶͪͬΓͪi
ͳͲ

΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͳ΀
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͼ;
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͽ͸͹
͹ͼ͵;ͯ͸ͳΒͰ
͊
ͯͻ;ͭͰ

ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ
Ͷͳ͸͵͹ͬͳ
ͼ;
ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳΒͳ
͸Ͱͭ͹
͸ͪ
-POFMZ
1MBOFU
XͰC
TJUF

(VJEF
EV
3PVUBSE
ͳ
-POFMZ
1MBOFU
ͼ;
;ΒͰͯ͸͹
ͳ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͵͹Βͳ

t͹ͫͻͪΌ;Β;i
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
͹ͼͳͷ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
͊Ͷ͹
ͬͰ͸ͳΒͰ
͈ͻͳͽ͹ͷ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͳͷͪͽͳ
;
ͬͳͯ;
ͯͪ
Ͳͪ
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂Ͱ
ͬͰΕͳ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ
͹ͬͳ΀

ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͳͲ;ͲͷͰ
-POFMZ
1MBOFU
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂ΒͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ

ͳ
ͯͪΓͰ
͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͪͻ͹΂ͳͽ͹
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ͸͹
ͽͰ
ͼͰ
͹ͼͳͷ
;
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ;
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͰ

ͳ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͬͻ΃ͳͽͳ
ͻͰͶͰͬͪ͸ͽ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͻͰΌͰΔͪ
̀ͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ
ͺ͹ͯͪ
ͽͪ͵
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
&ZFXJUOFTT
ͳͷͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͳͲͯͪΔͰ
͹
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹Β
ͪͶͳ
͸Ͱͷͪ
͹

͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͳ

́Ͳ
ͺͰͻͼͺͰ͵ͽͳͬͰ
tͯ͹ͷ͹ͻ͹΁ͪ i
ͺ͹͸;ΌͰ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͸ͪ
͸Ͱ͵ͳ

͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͻͰͪͶ͸͹
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ;Β;
͹ͬͰ
͸ͪ΃Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͰ
͹ͼͶͳ͵ͪͬͪΒ;Εͳ
t΃ͷͰ͵i

͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;Εͳ
t͹ͽͬ͹ͻͰ͸ͪ
ͬͻͪͽͪi
Ͳͪ
͸ͰͺͻͰͯͬͳΌͰ͸Ͱ
͹͵͹Ͷ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͊ͪͷͪ
ͺ͹
͸;ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͻͪͲ;ͷ͸͹
ͼͽͰͻͰ͹ͽͳͺ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͯ͹ͼͪͯ͸ͪ
΃ͽ͹
͹ͺͰͽ
ͭ͹ͬ͹
ͻͳ
;
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͭ
ͽͰͲͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ
͹ͬͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͼͪ
ͼͬͳͷ
͸ͰͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ͸ͪ
͌
ͼͬͳͷ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
͸ͪͭͶͪͼͪ͵
ΒͰ
ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸

ͺͻͰͽͰͱ͸͹
͸ͪ
ͽͲͬ
tͰͶͳͽ͸;i
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ;
͵͹Βͪ
ͳͪ͵͹
͸ͪΒͺͻͳ΀ͬͪͽΓͳͬͳΒͪ
ͺͻ͹
ͼͰ΂͸͹ͷ
ͲͪͺͪͯΔͪ͵;
͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ
ͼͰͭͷͰ͸ͽ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ

ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
͹ͬͳ΀
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͪ
͆ͪͻͪͬ͸͹
ͳͷͪΒ;Εͳ
;
ͬͳͯ;
ͼͪͷ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼ
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͪΔͪ

ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳ
͹ͬͯͪ΃Δ;
ͽͰ͸ͯͰ͸΁ͳΒ;
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
ͺ͹ͳͼͽ͹ͬͰΕ;ΒͰ
ͼͪ

͹͸͹ͷ
tͰͶͳͽ͸͹ͷi
ͫͳͶ͹
͵͹Βͳ
͹ͫͶͳ͵
tͪͶͽͰͻ͸ͪͽͳͬ͸Ͱi
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵

͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
;
ͼͿͰͻͳ
ͷͳͼͽͰͻͳΒͰ
ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
͹ͺͳͼͳ
ͷ;ͲͰΒͪ
;
-P
OFMZ
1MBOFU
Ͳͬ;΂Ͱ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷ
͹΀ͻͪͫͻ;Β;ΕͰ
͇΂ͳͭͶͰͯ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
͹ͬͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͳ

ͺͻ;ͱͪΒ;
΃ͳͻ͹͵
ͼͺͰ͵ͽͪͻ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹ͼͽͳ
ͪͶͳ
͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
;ͽͳͼͪ͵
ͯͪ
΃ͽ͹

ͼͰ
ͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͽͪ͵ͬͰ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹ͼͽͳ
Β͹΃

;ͬͰ͵
͸ͳͼ;
͸ͪ
ͪͯͰ͵ͬͪͽͪ͸
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
͸ͳͽͳ
ͺ͹͸;ΌͰ͸Ͱ
ͪ
͸ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸Ͱ

΃ͽ͹
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
;
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͭ
ͽ͹ͷͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫ͸͹
;͵Γ;΂ͳͽͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͪ͵ͽͰͻͰ

ͼ͹΁ͳ͹Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵͹ͭ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
;
͹ͬͪ͵ͬ;
ͬͻͼͽ;

ͷͪͻ͵Ͱͽͳ͸ͭͪ

́Ͳ
Ͱͽ͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵Ͱ
ͺͰͻͼͺͰ͵ͽͳͬͰ
͹ͬͪ͵ͬͪ
ͬͻͼͽͪ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͰͫΓͪ
ΒͰͼͽͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲͪͽͰΓ
͵ͪ͵͹
͸ͪͼ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
ͬͳͯͰ
͊ͬͳΌͪͶ͹
͸ͪͷ
ͼͰ
ͳͶͳ

͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͳͶͳͽͳ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹ͭ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
ͼ;
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͪ
ͳ
Ͱͽ͸ͳ΂͵ͪ
ͼͬͪ΃ͽͪͻͪ
΂ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΂͵ͪ
΁ͻͽͪ
ͻͪͲ;ͷ͸ͪ
͸Ͱ
 ͊ͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͸ͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ; 

ͺ͹;Ͳͯͪ͸͹ͼͽ
ͼ
͹ͫͲͳͻ͹ͷ
͸ͪ
ͽ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
͸ͪ
͹ͬͳͷ
ͺͻ͹

ͼͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
;ͭͶͪͬ͸͹ͷ
ͼͰ
͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͺͻͪͬͳͽͳ
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸ͪ
tͼͪͽ͸ͳ΁ͪi
ͪ
͸ͳ

ͫ;ΘͰͽ

́ͷͪΒ;Εͳ
;
ͬͳͯ;
ͯͪ
ͼ;
͹ͬͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͺͻͬͰ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸͹
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸ͳ

tͲͪͺͪͯΔͪ΁ͳͷͪi
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
͸ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸
ͽ͹ͬͪ͸Ͱ
;
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
͸Ͱ
ͺͻ;ͱͪ
͸ͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͼͳ
ͭ;ͻ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͸ͳͽͳ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹ͼͽͳ
́͸ͯͳ͵ͪͽͳͬ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
͵͹͸ͽͻͪͯͳ͵ͽ͹ͻ͸͹ͼͽ

ͼͰͭͷͰ͸ͪͽͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸ͳ΀
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳͷ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͯͰͶ;Β;
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ͸͹
ͳ
;Ͳͫ;Ό;Β;ΕͰ
ͳ
ͼͰͭͷͰ͸ͽͪ
ͺ͹͸;ΌͰ͸ͳ΀

ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
͊͵ͳΒͪΔͰ
ͺͶͪͱͰ
ͺ͹
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰͲͰͻ͹
ͳͶͳ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻ
ͳͶͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
ͳ

ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳ
;
͹͵ͬͳͻͳͷͪ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͳ΀
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
΂ͳ͸Ͱ
ͼ;ͷ;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ

ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
̽ͪ͵ͶͰ
;ͺͻ͵͹ͼ
ͬͳ΃Ͱͫ͹Β͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ

ͱͳͬ͹ͺͳͼ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͯͰ΃ͪͬͪΔͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͬͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
ͺͻͰ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͯͰ΁Ͱ
͸ͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͬͰ͵͹ͬͪ
͹ͺͳͼͪ͸ͳ΀
;
ͼͰ͵΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
tIJTUPSZi
ͳ
tDVMUVSFi
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰͼ;

ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͻͰͼ;ͻͼͳ
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͽͻͰ͸;ͽ͵;
ͯ͹ͷͳ͸ͳͻͪΒ;
ͼͰͭͷͰ͸ͽͳ
ͬͰΕ


ͲͪͼͽͪͻͰͶ͹͵Ͷͪͼͳ΂ͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
ͼ;͸΁Ͱ
ͺͶͪͱͪ
ͼ͵ͳΒͪΔͰ


͋͹
͸ͪͷ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͸Ͱ͹ͺ΀͹ͯ͸͹
ͺͻͬͰ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸͹
͹ͼͷͳͼͶͳͽͳ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͫ͹Γ΃ͪ
ͽͳ
͵ͬͪͶͳͽͰͽ
ͽͲͬ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
ΒͰͻ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͽͪ͵ͪͬ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
͹ͼͷͳ΃Γͪ
ͬͪΒ;
ͳ
͸;ͯͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
͵ͬͪͶͳͽͰͽ͸ͳΒͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͫ͹ͻͪͬ͵ͪ
ͽͪ͵͹

ͳ
Ͱͯ;͵ͪͽͳͬ͸ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͬ͹ͯͳ
Ͳͪ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͽͻͪͭͪΒ;
CBDLQBDLFSͳ

͋;ͻͳͲͪͷ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯ͸ͪ
ͭͻͪ͸ͪ
͵͹Βͪ
͸ͪ
͸ͪΒͯͳͻͰ͵ͽ͸ͳΒͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
;ͽͳ
΂Ͱ
͸ͪ
͵ͻͰͳͻͪΔͰ
ͳͷͳΘͪ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͳͳͶͳ
΁ͰͶ͹ͭ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͻͪͼ;ͯͪ
͆ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ;
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͽͻͰ͸;ͽ͸͹
ͬ͹ͯͰΕͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳ
ͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͺͻͰͼ;ͯ͸ͳ
;ͽͳͼͪ͵
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͳ
͹͸ͪ͵͹
ͷͪͶ͹

Ͳͪͼͽ;ͺΓͰ͸ͳ
͹ͬͳ
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͳ
ͳͷͪΒ;
ͳ
ͼ͵ͻ͹ͷ͸;
ͺ͹͸;ͯ;
́ͺͪ͵
͹ͯͲͬͪΔͪ

ͺ͹ͻ;͵ͪ
t͇̓
͹ͬͳ
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͳ
ͳͷͪΒ;
΃ͽͪ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
ͪͶͳ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͷͳ
ͽ͹
ͯͪ

ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳͷ͹
ͪ͵͹
͸ͳͼͷ͹
ͼͳͭ;ͻ͸ͳ
;
ͺ͹;Ͳͯͪ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪi
͊ͽ͹
ͭͪ
ͼͰ
΂ͳ͸ͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸Ͱͯ͹ͼͽͪͽͪ͵
ͳ͸ͳ΁ͳΒͪͽͳͬͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͻ΃͵Ͱ
;
͹ͬͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪ
ͷͪ
͸ͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳͷ
͸ͳͬ͹ͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͽͰ
͵ͪ͵͹
͹ͯͻͪͱͪͬͪ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
;

ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
ͺ͹
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹
ͺͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͫͳͶ͹
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͳͷ

͌͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͺͻͪͬͳͶͪ
ͺ͹ͯͰͶͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
͸ͪ
CBDLQBDLFST
ͳ

tͪͭͰ͸΁ͳΒͪ΃Ͱi
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
͵͹Βͳ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
;
ͺ͹ͽ
ͺ;͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺͻͰͺ;΃ͽͪΒ;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͪͭͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͷͪ

Ͷ͹ͭͳ΂͸͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪͼͶ;ͽͳ
ͽͳ
ͯͪ
ΕͰ
͹ͬͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ
ͻͪͯͳΒͰ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳͽͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂Ͱ
ͺ͹ͺ;ͽ
&ZFXJU
OFTTͪ
;
͵͹ͷͰ
ͺͻͰ͹ͬͶͪΌ;Β;
͹ͺͳͼͳ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͰ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͼ͹΁ͳ͹͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵Ͱ
#BDLQBDLFSTͳ
ͼ;
ͺͪ͵
͵ͪ͹

΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͬͰΕ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽ͹
ͼ͵Ͷ͹͸ͳΒͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͰ
ͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ΂͸Ͱ

ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
-POFMZ
1MBOFU
3PVHI
(VJEFT
(VJEF
EV
3FUBSE


 ͪͅ΃ͪ
̺;͵ͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ

͊;ͷͳͻͪ͸͹
ͭͶͰͯͪ͸͹
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
͸ͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͪ
ͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
͸ͳ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͪ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͸Ͱ

ͺͻ;ͱͪΒ;
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸;
ͼͶͳ͵;
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪ
͌͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͷ
ͼͬͻ΀ͪ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ

ͳ
ΒͰͼͽͰ
͸ͪ
͸Ͱ͵ͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰ
tͯͻ;ͭͳ΀i
ͽͰ
ͼ;
ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͼͪͷ͹

tͺ;ͽ͹͵ͪͲͳi

 ͊ͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
͸ͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ; 

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

.BØB
7VLBOPWJǀ
.PEFSOF
3FJTFGÛISFS
JN
*OUFSOFU

.PEFSOF
3FJTFGÛISFS
VOUFSTDIFJEFO
TJDI
GPSNBM
WPO
KFOFO
WPO

#BFEFLFS
XPCFJ
JIS
4UPGGMJDIFT
NFJTUFOT
HMFJDI
HFCMJFCFO
JTU
7FSÅOEFSVOHFO

TJOE
ÛCFSXJFHFOE
EBOL
GPSUHFTDISJUUFOFS
5FDIOPMPHJFO
VOE
HSՓFSFS

%JGGFSFO[JFSVOH
WPO
5PVSJTUFO
[V
WFS[FJDIOFO
%JF
;JFMHSVQQFO
BO
EJF

TJDI
3FJTFGÛISFS
XFOEFO
XFSEFO
EVSDI
t6OUFSHSVQQFOi
EFS
5PVSJTUFO

GFTUHFMFHU
EVSDI
5PVSJTUFO4VCLVMUVSFO

E
I
EVSDI
EFSFO
NFIS
PEFS

XFOJHFS
BVTHFTQSPDIFOF
/FJHVOH
[V
TFMCTUÅOEJHFS
PEFS
PSHBOJTJFSUFS

3FJTFWFSBOTUBMUVOH
4P
XFOEFU
TJDI
[
#
&ZFXJUOFTT
PGGFOTJDIUMJDI
BO
5PVSJTUFO

EJF
EJF
(FTUBMUVOH
JISFS
3FJTFO
"HFOUVSFO
ÛCFSMBTTFO
&JOF
CFTPOEFSF

4VCLVMUVS
EFS
5PVSJTUFO
TUFMMFO
TH
tCBDLQBDLFSTi
EBS
EJF
JISF
3FJTFO
TFMCFS

QMBOFO
VOE
BVTGÛISFO
JISF
3FJTFO
TJOE
EFNFOUTQSFDIFOE
BVDI
BVTHFEFIOUFS

BMT
KFOF
EJF
WPO
"HFOUVFSFO
BOHFCPUFO
XFSEFO

VOE
FIFS
QSBLUJTDI

BVTHFSJDIUFUF
3FJTFGÛISFS
CFOVU[FO
FUXB
-POFMZ
1MBOFU
(PVHI
(VJEFT

(VJEF
EV
3PVUBSE
&JO
HFNFJOTBNFT
$IBSBLUFSJTULVN
BMMFS
BOHFGÛISFUFO

3FJTFGÛISFS
JTU
JISF
NPEFSOF
(FTUBMUVOH
+FEFS
EFS
3FJTFGÛISFS
IBU
FJOF

FJHFOF
*OUFSOFUQSÅTFOUBUJPO
NJU
VOUFSTDIJFEMJDI
WFS[XFJHUFN
"OHFCPU
EBT

QSPKJ[JFSUFO
#FEÛSGOJTTFO
JISFS
#FOVU[FS
BOHFQBTTU
XJSE
2VBMJUBUJW
CFUSBDIUFU

WBSJJFSFO
EJF
JN
*OUFSOFU
BOHFCPUFOFO
*OGPSNBUJPOFO
WPO
FIFS
LPOWFOUJPOFMMFO

EJF
TJDI
BVG
HFTFMMTDIBGUMJDIEFNPHSBGJTDIF
(FHFCFOIFJUFO
BVG
EJF
,VMUVS
EJF

(FTDIJDIUF
VOE
BVTHFXÅIMUF
4FIFOTXÛSEJHLFJUFO
CF[JFIFO
%JFTF
3FJTFGÛISFS

CFXBISFO
EBT
(FTUBMUVOHTLPO[FQU
EFS
BMUFO
"VTHBCFO
WPO
#BFEFLFS
5SPU[U

NBODIFS
GBLUPHSBGJTDIFO
6OHFOBVJHLFJUFO
TQJFHFMU
EFSFO
*OIBMU
BLUVFMMF

6NTUÅOEF
JO
4ÛEPTUFVSPQB
HFUSFV
XJEFS
.BO
LBOO
GFTUTUFMMFO
EBTT
LFJOFT

EFS
-ÅOEFS
JO
EFS
3FHJPO
CJT
BVG
4MPXFOJFO
UFJMXFJTF
BVDI
,SPBUJFO
ÛCFS

QSPGJMJFSUF
4USBUFHJFO
[VS
&OUXJDLMVOH
EFT
5PVSJTNVT
WFSGÛHU
&JOF
WPMMTUÅOEJHF

WFSHMFJDIFOEF
4UVEJF
EFS
1SÅTFOUBUJPOFO
BMMFS
-ÅOEFS
JO
4ÛEPTUFVSPQB
XJSE

EBEVSDI
VONÕHMJDI
HFNBDIU
EBTT
OVS
[XFJ
WPO
EFOFO
JO
BMMFO
3FJTFGÛISFSO

WPSHFTUFMMU
XFSEFO
m
XJFEFSVN
IBOEFMU
FT
TJDI
VN
4MPXFOJFO
VOE
,SPBUJFO
*N

WPSMJFHFOEFO
"SUJLFM
SJDIUFU
EJF
"VUPSJO
JIS
"VHFONFSL
BVG
EFO
3FJTFGÛISFS

WPO
-POFMZ
1MBOFU
EFO
FJO[JHFO
BVG
EFTTFO
*OUFSOFUTFJUFO
LFJOFT
EFS
-ÅOEFS

EFS
3FHJPO
BVTHFMBTTFO
XJSE
'BTU
ESFJ“H
+BISF
OBDI
EFN
&JOESJOHFO
JOT

HFTFMMTDIBGUMJDILVMUVSFMMF
t&TUBCMJTINFOUi
CFLPNNU
EJF
)JQQZ#FXFHVOH

JISF
HFTDIJDIUMJDIF
#FTUÅUJHVOH
m
FJOF
EFS
NÕHMJDIFO
3FGMFYJPOFO
TUFMMFO

BVDI
3FJTFGÛISFS
GÛS
TH
tPGG
UIF
USBDLT
m
CBDLQBDLFSi5PVSJTUFO
EBS
/BDI

"OOBINFO
EFS
8FMUUPVSJTUFOPSHBOJTBUJPO
JTU
FJOF
XFJUFSF
&OUXJDLMVOH
EFT

 ͪͅ΃ͪ
̺;͵ͪ͸͹ͬͳΕ

,VMUVS
VOE
EFT
TH
4UBEUUPVSJTNVT
[V
FSXBSUFO
%B
4ÛEPTUFVSPQB
FSTU
KFU[U

MBOHTBN
JO
EFO
#SFOOQVOLU
EFT
*OUFSFTTFT
CSFJUFSFS
,SFJTF
EFS
3FJTFOEFO

LPNNU
TDIFJOFO
BVDI
BOEFSF
SFMFWBOUF
BLUVFMMF
3FJTFSGÛISFS
CFBDIUFOTXFSUFS

[V
XFSEFO
%VSDI
HSÛOEMJDIF
"OBMZTFO
EJFTFS
3FJTFGÛISFS
LÕOOUF
EBT
HFTBNUF

UPVSJTUJTDIF
"OHFCPU
EFS
3FHJPO
WPSBOHFCSBDIU
XFSEFO
"VT
EFS
1FSTQFLUJWF

FJOFS
FJOIFJNJTDIFO
&UIOPMPHJO
TJOE
3FJTFGÛISFS
m
TPXPIM
JO
HFESVDLUFS
BMT

BVDI
JO
FMFLUSPOJTDIFS
"VTGÛISVOH
m
FJO
VOCFEJOHU
OPUXFOEJHFT
"SCFJUTNJUUFM


JO
EFN
FJO
7PML
TP
WPSHFTUFMMU
XJSE
XJF
FT
WPO
BOEFSFO
HFTFIFO
XJSE

ͪͅΒͪ
͇͇͉͇̺͋̽́ͣ

̀ͪͬ͹ͯ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻ͹;΂ͪͬͪΔͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ

ͻͪͲͬͳͽ͵ͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

͉́͆͋̾͆̾͋

̸͈͉̾̀̾͆͋͏́̾͠

͉͎͋͌́͊͋́͐̓́

̸͈͇͆͌̽
ћ
͉͇̾̈́̾̓͋͆͊̓́
̹͉̾̽̾̓̾́

͈͹Βͪͬͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͭͶ͹ͫͪͶ͸͹ͭ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͼ͵͹ͭ
ͷͰͯͳΒͪ
;ͽͳ
΁ͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
;
ͷ͸͹ͭͳͷ
ͼͰͭͷͰ͸ͽͳͷͪ
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸͹ͭ
ͳ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵͹ͭ

ͱͳͬ͹ͽͪ
͉ͪͲͬ͹ΒͰͷ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽͪ
ͷ͹ͯͰͶ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ
ͼ;
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸ͳ
ͻͪͯͪ
ͽͻͱͳ΃͸ͪ

Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͳΒͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͺͰͻͼ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͪ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸ͳ
ͲͪͫͪͬͰ
ͳ
͵͹ͻͳ
΃ΕͰΔͪ
ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯ͸͹ͭ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
͈ͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
;Ͳͻ͹͵͹ͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͻͰͬ͹Ͷ;΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
͹ͯͻͪͲͳͶͰ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͳ

͸ͪ
ͿͰ͸͹ͷͰ͸
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
͇ͯ
ͺ͹ΒͪͬͰ
͸͹ͬͳ΀
Ϳ͹ͻͷͳ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;

ͬͳͻͽ;ͰͶ͸ͪ
ͯ͹
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͯͪΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͺͪͭͪ͸ͯͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂
͵ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯͪ
̽͹ͼͽ;ͺ͸͹ͼͽ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͷͰͯͳΒͪ
;
΁ͰͶ͹ͷ
ͼͬͰͽ;
ͯͪΓͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ

ͳ
ͫͻͲͳ
ͺͻ͹ͽ͹͵
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
;
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷ;
ͺ͹
ͯͰͿͳ͸ͳ΁ͳΒͳ
ͳͷͪΒ;

ͬͰͶͳ͵;
tͺ͹ͽͻ͹΃Δ;i
;ͽͳ΁ͪ͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
͸ͪ
ͽ͹
ͯͪ
͵Ͷͪͼͳ΂͸ͪ
ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͪ
ͽ;ͻͳ
ͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͺͪͭͪ͸ͯͰ
͵ͪ͵ͪͬ
ΒͰ
ͳ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͳ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ
ͭ;ͫͰ
͸ͪ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ;
;

͵͹ͻͳͼͽ
͹͸ͳ΀
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͪͼͽͪΒ;
ͻͪͲͬ͹ΒͰͷ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳ͹͸Ͱ
ͽͰ΀͸͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͰ
͋ͪ
͵͹
ͼͰ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ͼͬͰ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͹
ͰͶͰ͵ͽͻ͹͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻͳͷͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹Β
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹΁ͳΒͳ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͺͪͭͪ͸ͯͳ
͸ͪ
XPSME
XJEF
XFC;
̺Ͱͫ
ͳͶͳ
ͭͻͪͿͳ΂͵ͳ
΀ͳͺͰͻͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͪͶ͸ͳ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͰ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ
͸Ͱͽͪ
Ͳͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;
͹ͯ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͼͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͺͪ
ͭͪ͸ͯͰ
͹ͷ͹ͭ;Εͪͬͪ
͵͹ͷͫͳ͸͹ͬͪ͸͹
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͳͬͪΔͰ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ
ͼͶͳ͵F
Ͳͬ;͵ͪ
ͳ

ͬͳͯͰͪ
ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
͹ͷ͹ͭ;Εͪͬͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͭͻͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
͆ͪ



͠
͈͹ͺFͼ͵;
ͪͅͻ͵Ͱͽͳ͸ͭ
;
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷ;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

 ͪͅΒͪ
͋͹ͯ͹ͻ͹ͬͳΕ

ͽͪΒ
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
͹Ͷͪ͵΃ͪͬͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͬͪͲͳͶͪͱͰΔͰ
ͬͪͱ͸͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͪ
ͬͰͲͪ͸͹ͭ
Ͳͪ

ͷͪͻ͵Ͱͽͳ͸ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͪ
͸Ͱ͹ͺͳͺΓͳͬ͹ͼͽ
̽͹ͼͽ;ͺ͸͹ͼͽ
ͬͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
͵͹Ͷͳ΂ͳ͸Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͸ͪ

̺Ͱͫ;
ͺͻͰͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͰ
ͺ͹
ͻͪͲ͸ͳͷ
͵ͻͳͽͰͻͳΒ;ͷͳͷͪ
ͻͰͲͰͻͬͳͼͪΔͰ
ͳ

ͺͶͪΕͪΔͰ
ͪͻͪ͸ͱͷͪ͸ͪ
ͻͪͲͶ͹Ͳͳ
ͼ;
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
͵͹Βͳ΀
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ͼͬͰ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
Γ;ͯͳ

ͺ;ͽ;ΒͰ
ͽͻͪͱͰΕͳ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͺ;ͽͰͷ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸ͰͽB
͊ͽ͹ͭͪ
ͳ
ͼͬͰ
ͬͰΕͳ

ͫͻ͹Β
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͰͯ;ͲͰΕͪ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͷͪͻ͵Ͱͽͳ͸΃͵Ͱ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
;ͼͷͰ
ͻͪͬͪ
͵ͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͷͪͻ͵Ͱͽͳ͸ͭ;
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹΁ͳΒͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
͸ͪ

ͬͰͫ
ͼͪΒͽ;
͆ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
;
ͬͰΕͳ͸ͳ
ͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ
͸ͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
͸͹ͼͳ͹΁Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͷͪͻ͵Ͱͽͳ͸ͭͪ

ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͳͼ͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳͶͰ
ͼ;
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͺͻ;ͱͪ
ͬͰͫ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ΔͰ
ͼͬ͹Βͳ΀
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯͪ
͈ͻͰͲͰ͸ͽ;Β;Εͳ
͵͹ͷ
ͺͶͰͽ͸;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵;
ͺ͹͸;ͯ;
͸ͪ
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
ͬͰͫ
ͼͪΒͽ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͵ͻͰͳͻͪΒ;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͽͰͽ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͲͰ
ͷΓͰ
ͪ
͵ͬͪͶͳͽͰͽ
ͳ
ͪͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͳ΀
ͬͰͫ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͯ͹ͺͻͳ͸͹ͼͳ

ͺ͹Ͳͳͽͳͬ͸͹ͷ
ͳͷͳΘ;
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͷ
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽ;
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͪ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͪ
ͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
΂ͳ͸ͳͶͰ
ͼ;
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸ͳ
ͯͻͱͪͬ
͸ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
B
ͻͪͼͺͪͯ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͰ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸Ͱ

ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
͹ͫͰͶͰͱͰ͸
ͻͪͽ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͳͲ͹Ͷͪ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͳ
ͽͻͪ͸Ͳͳ΁ͳΒ
ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼͳͷͪ
ͯͰͬͰͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺ͹͵Ͷͪͺͪ
ͼͰ
ͼͪ

Ͱ͵ͼͺͪ͸ͲͳΒ͹ͷ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹Β
ͼ΁Ͱ͸ͳ
̽ͪ͸ͪͼ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ
ͯͬͪͯͰͼͰͽ
ͺͻͬ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͹ͬͰ
ͽͻͳ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͼ;
ͼͪͷ͹
ͼͽͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸Ͱ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͳ
ͼͪͷ͹ͼͽͪͶ͸͹
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ΒͪͬΓ;Β;
͸ͪ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͷ

ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽ;
͊ͬͪ͵ͪ
͹ͯ
Δͳ΀
ͳͷͪ
ͼͬ͹Β;
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵;
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳ
Ͳͪ΁ͳΒ;
͵͹Βͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͬ͹ͷ
ͬͰͫ
ͼͪΒͽ;
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
͑ͽͪ
͸ͪͷ
;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹Β
ͺ͹͸;ͯͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͪ
͎ͻ
ͬͪͽͼ͵ͪ
ͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
ͳ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼ;
ͳͼ͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳͶͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽͪ
ͳ

ͬͰͫͪ
;
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹΁ͳΒͳ
ͼͬ͹Βͳ΀
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͬͳ
ͯͰΕͰͷ͹
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͵͹ͷͺͪͻͪͽͳͬ͸;
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲ;
ͼͪΒͽ͹ͬͪ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͳ΀
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪ

͌ͬ͹ͯ
;
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒ;
m
)PNF
1BHF

͌ͬ͹ͯ͸ͪ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͪ
ͳͶͳ
)PNF
1BHF
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸;
ͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͸;

ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΁;
ͬͰͫ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
͸Ͱ͵͹ͭ
ͺͻͰͯ;ͲͰΕͪ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳͶͳ
͹ͼ͹ͫͰ

ͼ
͵͹ΒͰ
΀ͳͺͰͻͶͳ͸͵͹ͬͳͷͪ
͹ͯͶͪͲͳͷ͹
͸ͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͬͰͫ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ

͇͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰͬͻͼͽͪ͸
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
ͬͰͫ
ͼͪΒͽͪ
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
͸ͪͶͳ͵
͸ͪ
ͼͶ͹ͬ͸͹Β
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ;
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
 ́͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ 

͆ͪ
;ͬ͹ͯ͸͹Β
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͳͲͫ͹ͻ
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ
͸ͪ
͵͹ͷͰ
ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;ΕͰ

ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯͪͽͳ
ͬͰͫ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒ;
͈͹͸;ͯͪ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΀
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ
;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
͸ͪͷ
͸ͪ

΁ͳΓ͸;
ͭͻ;ͺ;
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͪ
;
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͼͪΒͽ͹ͬͪ
ͳ
͸ͪ

΁ͳΓ͸ͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽͪ
͊ͬͰ
ͽͻͳ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͳͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͬͰͫ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ

ͲͰͷΓͰ
͸;ͯͰ
ͳ
Ͱ͸ͭͶͰͼ͵;
ͬͰͻͲͳΒ;
ͼͪΒͽͪ
͵ͪ͹
͸ͪΒͻͪͼͺͻ͹ͼͽͻͪΔͰ͸ͳΒͰͭ
ͳ͸
ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ
̀ͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;
͹ͯ
ͼͪΒͽͪ
͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ

͇͋͊

͸ͪ
ͪͯͻͰͼͳ
IUUQXXXTFSCJBUPVSJTNPSH
͸ͪ
͵͹ͷͰ
ΒͰ
Ͱ͸ͭͶͰͼ͵ͪ

ͳ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͪ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͪ
ͬͰͻͲͳΒͪ
ͼͪΒͽ
͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
͎͋̀


͸ͪ
ͪͯͻͰͼͳ
IUUQXXXDSPBUJBIS
͸;ͯͳ
ͳ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵;
ͬͰͻͲͳΒ;
ͯ͹͵
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͲ
Ͱ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒ;
͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵;
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͰ
͇͊͋

΂ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͪͯͻͰͼͪ

IUUQXXXTMPWFOJBUPVSJTNTJ
ͷ͹ͭ;ΕͰ
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯͪͽͳ
ͳ
͸ͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵͹ͷ
ͳ

͸ͪ
ͳͽͪͶͳΒͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
͌ͺ͹ͻͰͯ͸͹ͷ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲ͹ͷ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ͸ͳ΀
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͪ
ͬͰͫ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͸ͪ
΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͰ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
͊ͻ
ͫͳΒͰ
ͳͲͯͬͪΒ;Β;
ͼͰ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΂͵ͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳ
ͼͬͪ
ͽͻͳ
ͼͪΒͽͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;

ͭͻ;ͺͳͼͪͽͳ
;
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
͵ͪͽͰͭ͹ͻͳΒͪ
m
͹ͺ΃ͽͰ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
ͲͰͷΓͳ
ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ

m
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ
ͳ
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͪΒ
m
ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶ͸͹ͼͽͳ
m
͹
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹Β
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͳ
m
ͷ;ͶͽͳͷͰͯͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳ
ͼͰͻͬͳͼͳ
͌
;ͬ͹ͯ͸͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
ͼͬͪ
ͽͻͳ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͳͻͪ͸ͪ
ͼͪΒͽͪ
ͯͪΒ;
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳ
ΒͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
͸ͪ
͹ͺ΃ͽͰ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
͹
ͲͰͷΓͳ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒ

ͺ͹ͬͻ΃ͳ͸;
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͫͻ͹Β
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵Ͷͳͷͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
;ͼͶ͹ͬͰ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ

ͼͶ;ͱͫͰ͸ͳ
ΒͰͲͳ͵
ͻͰͶͳͭͳΒͰ
̽͹͵
ͼͰ
ͼͪΒͽ
͇͋͊ͪ
;
ͼͰ͵΁ͳΒͳ
͹
ͲͰͷΓͳ
Ͳͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
͸ͪ
͹ͬͳͷ
ͼ͹΁ͳ͹ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͪ
ͯͬͪ
ͼͪΒͽͪ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ

͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͺ͹ͯͼͰ͵΁ͳΒͪ
ͯͪΒ;
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
;
;ͬ͹ͯ͸͹Β

ͺͻͳ΂ͳ
͹
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵ͪͷͪ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͌
ͺ͹ͯ͵ͪͽͰͭ͹ͻͳΒͪͷͪ
ͼͰ͵΁ͳΒͰ
͇ͺ΃ͽͰ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
Ͷͳ͸͵͹
ͬͪ
͸ͪ
ͅͳͼͽͰͻͳ͹Ͳ͸ͳ
͵ͪͻͼͽ
͆ͪͼͷͰΒͪ͸͹
͈͹΀͹ͻΒͰ
͊;͸΂ͪ͸ͳ
̸Ͷͺͳ
̽ͻͪ
ͱͰͼ͸ͪ
͡;ͫΓͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
̀ͰͶͰ͸ͳ
ͷͰͯͳͽͰͻͪ͸
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒͰͷ͹
ͼͰ
ͼͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ

ͻͰͭͳΒͪͷͪ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͰ
ͯ͹͵
ͼ;
;
ͺ͹ͯͼͰ͵΁ͳΒͳ
̻ͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
ͳ
ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͳ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸Ͱ
ͪͯͷͳ͸ͳͼͽͻͪͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͻͰͭͳΒͰ
;Ͳ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸Ͱ
ͷͪͺͰ

͆ͪ
ͼͪΒͽ;
͎͋̀Ͱ
͹ͺ΃ͽͰ
ͳͿ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
ͲͰͷΓͳ
;ͺ͹ͽͺ;ΔͰ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
ͼͰ͵΁ͳΒͪ
ͷͪ
ͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸ͼ͵͹
ͷ͹ͻͰ
͆ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͳ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͪ
͵;΀ͳΔͪ
͈;ͽ͸ͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͼͪͯͻͱͰ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳ΂͸;
ͬͻͼͽ;
ͺ͹ͯͪ
ͽͪ͵ͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͬͪ
ͽͻͳ
ͼͪΒͽͪ
ͳ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸Ͱ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
ͽ͹ͷͰ

͵ͪ͵͹
ͯ͹Εͳ
ͯ͹
ͳ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
ͼ͸ͪͶͪͲͳͽͳ
;
ͲͰͷΓͳ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͳ
΁ͪͻͳ͸ͼ͵Ͱ

 ͪͅΒͪ
͋͹ͯ͹ͻ͹ͬͳΕ

͹ͯͻͰͯͫͰ
ͺ;ͽ͸Ͱ
ͳͼͺͻͪͬͰ
͸͹ͬ΂ͪ͸Ͱ
ͽͻͪ͸ͼͪ͵΁ͳΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯ͹ͼ͸ͪͫͯͰͬͪΔͰ
ͽͰ

ͶͰ͵͹ͷ;͸ͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͲͯͻͪͬͼͽͬͰ͸Ͱ
ͼͶ;ͱͫͰ
ͬͪͱ͸ͳ
ͽͰͶͰͿ͹͸ͳ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳ

ͺͻͪͲ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͈͹ͻͰͯ
͹ͬͳ΀
͹ͺ΃ͽͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹
͸;ͯͰ
͵͹Βͪ
Ͳͪͺͻͪͬ͹
΂ͳ͸ͳ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
ͪ͸ͶͳͲͳͻͪ͸ͳ΀
ͼͪΒͽ͹ͬͪ
͸ͪ

;ͬ͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͰ
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶ͸ͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳ
ͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͯͰ΃ͪͬͪΔͳͷͪ
;
ͲͰͷΓͳ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͷͪ͸ͳͿͰͼͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͼͪΒͷ͹ͬͳ

ͼͰͷͳ͸ͪͻͳ
͈͹ͼͰͫ͸;
͵ͪͽͰͭ͹ͻͳΒ;
΂ͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹Β
ͺͻͳͬͻͰ
ͯͳ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁Ͱ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͳͻͪ͸ͳ΀
ͼͪΒͽ͹ͬͪ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒ;
ͼͪ
ͼͽͪͽͳ
ͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
͹
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͺͻ͹ΒͰ͵ͽͳͷͪ

;
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
͸ͪ
ͼͪΒͽ;
͎͋̀Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
ͷ͹ͱͰ

ͯ͹ͫͳͽͳ
ͼͽͪͽͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
͹
ͯ͹ͷͪΕ͹Β
ͳ
ͳ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸͹Β
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹Β

ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳ
;
ͺͻ͹ͽͰ͵Ͷ͹Β
ͼͰͲ͹͸ͳ
͸ͪ
ͼͪΒͽ;
͇͊͋Ͱ
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯͪͽͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸;

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵;
ͼͽͻͪͽͰͭͳΒ;
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͰ
Ͳͪ
͸ͪͻͰͯ͸;
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸;
ͪ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸
ͽͪ΁ͳΒͳ
͇͋͊ͪ
ͼͪͲ͸ͪͽͳ
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͹
ͺ͹ͯͼͽͳ΁ͪΒ͸ͳͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ

ͺͻ͹ΒͰ͵ͽͳͷͪ
;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
͈͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͰ
͹ͬͪ͵ͬͳ΀
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
ͯͪ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳ
ͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹͸;ͯ͹ͷ
ͬͰΕ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
ͷͪ
͹
ͪ͵΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
͸ͪ
ͺ͹Γ;
ͻͪͲͬ͹Βͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͰ
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹ͬͳ΃;

ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͸ͪ
ͼͪΒͽ͹ͬͳͷͪ

͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ
͊ͪͯͻͱͪΒͳ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺͽ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͳ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺͻͰͽͻͪͭͰ

͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͭ
͹ͯ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͳͽͻͪ͸ͳ΀
ͼͪΒͽ͹ͬͪ
͹ͫ;΀ͬͪ
ͽͪ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒ;
͸ͪΒͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳΒͳ΀
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͻͰ͵ͻͰͪ
ͽͳͬ͸ͳ΀
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͪͿͳͻͷͳͼͪ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
͸ͰͪͿͳͻͷͳͼͪ͸ͳ΀

ͪͽͻͪ͵΁ͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͻͪͼͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͳͬͳ΀
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͪΒ͸ͳ΀
͵ͪͺͪ΁ͳͽͰͽͪ
͇͸͹
΃ͽ͹
ͳ΀
΂ͳ
͸ͳ
ͫͳͽ͸͹
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳͷ
ͼ;
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺͽ
ͳ
ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͪ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ

ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺͻͰͽͻͪͭͰ
ͺ͹͸;ΌͰ͸ͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
͆ͪ
ͼͪΒͽ;
͇͋͊ͪ
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
ͯͪͽ
ΒͰ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ

͹ͼͪͷ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
m
̓;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͰ
m
̹ͪΔͰ
ͳ
͵Ͷͳͷͪͽͼ͵ͳ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͳ
m
͋;ͻͳͲͪͷ
͸ͪ
̽;͸ͪͬ;
m
͊ͰͶͪ
m
̈́͹ͬ
ͳ
ͻͳͫ͹Ͷ͹ͬ
m
̻ͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
 ́͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ 

m
͈ͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͪͽͻͪ͵΁ͳΒͰ
m
͈Ͷͪ͸ͳ͸Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
͈ͻͰ͵͹
Ͷͳ͸͵ͪ
ͼ
͸ͪͲͳͬ͹ͷ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
;ͶͪͲͳ
ͼͰ
;
ͺ͹ͼͰͫͪ͸
ͷͰ͸ͳ

͵͹Βͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͳ
͵ͻͪͽͪ͵
͹ͺ΃ͽͳ
͹ͺͳͼ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
ͺͻͰͽͻͪͭͰ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
Ͷ͹͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͊ͬͪ͵ͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
Ͷ͹͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ

ΒͰ
;Ͳ
͵ͻͪͽͪ͵
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͪͶ͸ͳ
͹ͺͳͼ
ͳͶ;ͼͽͻ͹ͬͪ͸
ͼ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ

ͳ
͵͹͸ͽͪ͵ͽ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
Ͳͪ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳͶͳ
Ͷͳ͸͵͹ͬͳͷͪ
͸ͪ

͵͹ͻͳͼ͸Ͱ
ͼͪΒͽ͹ͬͰ
͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽ͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͵ͪͶͰ͸ͯͪͻ
ͷͪ͸ͳ
ͿͰͼͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
;Ͳ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
ͺͻͰͽͻͪͭͰ
ͺ͹
ͷͰͼͰ΁ͳͷͪ
͌Ͳ
͹ͬͰ
ͯͬͰ
ͼͰ͵΁ͳ
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͽͻͪͭ;
͵͹ͻͳ΃ΕͰΔͰͷ
͵Γ;΂͸Ͱ
ͻͰ΂ͳ
ͼͪΒͽ
͇͋͊Ͱ
͸Ͱ
͸;ͯͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ

ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͺͻͰͽͻͪͭͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
ͪͅ͸ͪ

͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͼͪΒͽͪ
ΒͰ
΃ͽ͹
͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ
͸ͳΒͰͯͪ͸
ͭͻͪͿͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ
͵ͪͻͽͰ
΂ͳͷͰ
ΒͰ

͹ͽͰͱͪ͸ͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
Ͷ͹͵ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͺ͹͸;ΌͰ͸ͳ΀
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͪ
ͼͪͷͳͷ
ͽͳͷ

ͳ
ͼ͸ͪͶͪͱͰΔͰ
ͺ͹ͽͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
͊Ͷͳ΂͸͹
͇͋͊Ͱ
͸ͪ
ͼͪΒͽ;
͎͋̀Ͱ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
ͯ͹ͷͳ͸ͳͻͪ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒ
ͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
ͪͶͳ
ͼ
ͬͰΕͳͷ
ͫͻ͹ΒͰͷ
͵ͻͳͽͰͻͳΒ;ͷͪ
Ͳͪ

ͺͻͰͽͻͪͭ;
ͳ
ͷ;ͶͽͳͷͰͯͳΒͪͶ͸ͳͷ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳͷͪ
͈ͻͰͽͻͪͭͪ
ͺ͹
͵ͻͳͽͰͻͳΒ;ͷ;
ͷͰͼͽ͹
ͺͻ;ͱͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ

͹
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͳ
͵ͻͪͽͪ͵
͹ͺͳͼ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͽͳͬ͸ͳ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͳ
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͪΒ

ͪ
Ͳͪ

Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͷͰͼͽͪ
ͯͪͽ
ΒͰ
ͳ
͵ͻͪͽͪ͵
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪͽ
ͳͲͫ͹ͻ
͵;Ͷ
ͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
͌͸Ͱͼ͵͹ͬͳͷ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹
͸ͪͶ͸ͳͷ
ͺͪͻ͵͹ͬͪ
ͳ
ͺͪͻ͵͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͰ
͊Ͱ͵΁ͳΒͪ
͹ͯͻͰͯͳ΃ͽͪ
͸;ͯͳ
ͳͼͽͰ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
ͺͻͰ
ͽͻͪͭͰ
ͺ͹
͵ͻͳͽͰͻͳΒ;ͷͪ
ͻͰͭͳΒͰ
͹ͽ͹΁ͳ
ͭͻͪͯͷͰͼͽ͹
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ
ͺͪͻ͵͹
ͬͳ
ͺͪͻ͵͹ͬͳ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͰ
ͳ
͌͸Ͱͼ͵͹ͬͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͇ͺͳͼ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
;
͹ͫͰ
ͼͰ͵΁ͳΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͺͻͪΕͰ͸
ΒͰ
ͷ;ͶͽͳͷͰͯͳΒͪͶ
͸ͳͷ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳͷͪ
͵ͻͪͽͪ͵
ͿͳͶͷ
͹
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͳ
Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͪͶͰͻͳΒͪ
ͳͲͭ͹
ͬ͹ͻ
ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ
ͬͳͻͽ;ͰͶ͸Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͰ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ

ͺ͹͵ͻͰͽ͹ͷ
ͷͳ΃ͪ
ͷ͹ͱͰͽͰ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͱͽͪͽͳ
ͯ;ͫͻ͹ͬͪ΂͵ͳͷ
͊ͽͻͪͯ;͸͹ͷ
ͳͶͳ

tͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͽͳi
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
͊ͺͶͳͽͪ
͌
ͼͰ͵΁ͳΒͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
ͺͶ;ͼ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽ͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳΒͪͶͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
ͺ͹
͸;ͯͪ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͸ͪͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
Ͷ͹ͬ
ͻͳͫͳͶ͹ͬ
Βͪ΀ͪ
ΔͰ
͸ͪ;ͽͳ͵ͪ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͪͻͰΔͰ
ͻ͹ΔͰΔͰ
ͬͰͻͼ͵ͳ
ͲͯͻͪͬͼͽͬͰ͸ͳ
ͳ
͵͹͸ͭͻͰ
ͼ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
ͪͅ͸ͳͿͰͼͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͼ;
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͸ͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͪΒͽ;
͇͋͊Ͱ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸Ͱ
;

ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹Β
ͼͰ͵΁ͳΒͳ
ͼ
ͽͳͷ
΃ͽ͹
ͺͻͰͽͻͪͭͪ
͸ͪ
΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹ͷ
ͼͪΒͽ;
͸Ͱ
ͯͪΒͰ

ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ
ͼͬͳ΀
ͷͪ͸ͳͿͰͼͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳ
Ͳͪ΀ͽͰͬͪ
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸͹
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰ
͵ͻͳͽͰ
ͻͳΒ;ͷͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻͰͽͻͪͭ;
͸ͪͲͳͬ
ͷͪ͸ͳͿͰͼͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͷͰͼͽ͹
ͯͪͽ;ͷ
 ͪͅΒͪ
͋͹ͯ͹ͻ͹ͬͳΕ

͈ͻͰͭͶͰͯ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͺ;ͽͰͷ
ͷ;ͶͽͳͷͰͯͳΒͪͶ͸Ͱ

͵ͪͻͽͰ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
ͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͪ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͶͪ΁
ͼͪͷ
ͫͳ
ͻͪ
ͺ͹͸;ΌͰ͸Ͱ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͰ
ͳ
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͪ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ
ͭͻͪͿͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ
͸ͪ
ͷͪͺͳ
́ͪ͵͹
͸Ͱ͵ͳ
͹ͯ
ͷ;ͶͽͳͷͰͯͳΒͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͺͻͪͽͰ
ͺ͹͸;ͯ;

͸ͳͼ;
͸ͪ
ͬͳͼ͹͵͹ͷ
ͽͰ΀͸ͳ΂͵͹ͷ
͸ͳͬ͹;
Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹
ͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬ͹
;ͺ͹ͽͺ;Δ;ΒͰ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵;
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͳ
ͯ͹ͺͻͳ͸͹ͼͳ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͶͪ΁
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͪ
Βͪͼ͸ͳΒ;

ͼͶͳ͵;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
͆ͪ
ͼͪΒͽ;
͇͊͋Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ
͸;ͯͳ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
͵ͪ͹

ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪK
̽͹ͱͳͬͳͽͰ
ͳͶͳ
ͳͼ͵;ͼͳͽͰ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒ;
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͪͽͻͪ͵΁ͳΒͰ

ͳͲͬ͹ͻͰ
ͲͯͻͪͬΓͪ
͵ͪͲͳ͸ͪ
ͳ
Ͳͪͫͪͬ;
ͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͰ
ͬͳ͸͹
ͳ
΀ͻͪ͸;
ͽ;
ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͿͪͻͷͰ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬͪ͸
͹ͯͷ͹ͻ
͵͹͸ͭͻͰͼͰ
ͯͰ΃ͪͬͪΔͪ
̈́ͳ͸͵͹ͬͳ
ͼͪ

͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸ͳ΀
͵ͪͽͰͭ͹ͻͳΒͪ
͸;ͯͰ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͽͳͬ͸ͳ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͪͶ͸ͳ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ
ͼ
ͽͰ͵
ͼͽ;ͪͶ͸ͳͷ
Ͷͳ͸͵͹ͬͳͷͪ
Ͷ͹͵ͪ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
͸ͪ
͵ͪͻͽͳ
Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͳͲͫ͹
ͻ͹ͷ
͸ͪΒͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ͸ͳΒͳ΀
Ͷ͹͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
tͼͰͶͰ͵ͽ͹ͬͪ͸͹
Ͳͪ
ͬͪͼi

;
͹͵ͬͳͻ;

ͳͲͪͫͻͪ͸Ͱ
͵ͪͽͰͭ͹ͻͳΒͰ
́Ͳ;ͲͰͽ͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͼͪΒͽͪ
ΒͰ
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͼͬͳ

Ͷͳ͸͵͹ͬͳ
ͷͰΌ;ͼ͹ͫ͸͹
ͺ͹ͬͰͲͪ͸ͳ
ͳ
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͼͪ
ͼͬͪ͵Ͱ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
͹ͽͳΕͳ

͸ͪ
ͫͳͶ͹
͵͹Β;
ͯͻ;ͭ;
͊ͺͰ΁ͳΒͪͶͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸;
ͺ͹͸;ͯ;
Ͳͪ
͹͸Ͱ
͵͹Βͳ
ͱͰͶͰ
ͯͪ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒ;
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ
͸ͳΒ;
ͬͪ͸
j;ͽͪͫͪ͸ͳ΀
ͼͽͪͲͪv
ͼͪΒͽ
͇͊͋Ͱ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͳΒͰ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͻ;
ͽͰ
͉ͪͻͳͽͰͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
;
ͼͰ͵΁ͳΒͳ
ͼ͵ͻͳͬͰ͸ͪ

͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͪ
ͯ͹͵
ͼͰ͵΁ͳΒͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͫͻͲ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
̀ͪ
͹͸Ͱ
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͰͷͪΒ;
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
ͯͪ
ͺͻͰͽͻͪͱ;Β;

ͼͪΒͽ
ͯͪͽ
ΒͰ
ͳͲͫ͹ͻ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
͵ͪͽͰͭ͹ͻͳΒͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͪΒ
ͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵Ͱ

ͽ;ͻͰ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳ
͹ͯͷ͹ͻ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͪͽͻͪ͵΁ͳΒͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ

Ͳ͸ͪͷͰ͸ͳͽ͹ͼͽͳ
ͭͪͼͽͻ͹͸͹ͷͳΒͪ
͈ͻͰͭͶͰͯ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͺͻͰ͵͹
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸Ͱ

͵ͪͻͽͰ
͸ͪ
͵͹Β͹Β
ͼ;
͹Ͳ͸ͪ΂Ͱ͸Ͱ
ͻͰͭͳΒͰ
͌
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ;
͸ͪ
ͭͻͪͿͳ΂͵ͳ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ
͵ͪͻ
ͽͰ
͸ͪ
ͼͪΒͽ;
͎͋̀Ͱ
ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͪ΂͵ͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͪ
ͷͪͺͪ
͸;ͯͳ
ͬͰΕͳ
ͫͻ͹Β

͵ͻͳͽͰͻͳΒ;ͷͪ
Ͳͪ
ͼͰͶͰ͵΁ͳΒ;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
͌
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ;
͸ͪ
ͼͪΒͽ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͇͊͋Ͱ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪΒͫ͹ΓͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻͰͽͻͪͭ;
ͳ
ͼ͹ͻͽͳͻͪΔͰ
ͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͪͽͪ
ͪ
ͳ
ͼͪͷ

͵͹͸΁Ͱͺͽ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
ͳͷͪ
͸ͪΒͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳΒͳ
ͺͻͳ
ͼͽ;ͺ
͋͹
ͯ͹͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺͽ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
͵͹Βͳ
ͺ͹ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
͸ͪΒ͸͹ͬͳ
ΒͰ
ͽͰ͸ͯͰ͸΁ͳΒͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
ͺ͹
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ

ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪΒ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͸ͳͲ
͹ͼͷͳ΃ΓͰ͸ͳ΀
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
ͳ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳΒͪͶͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ΀
ͽ;
ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ
́ͪ͵͹
ͼͪΒͽ
͎͋̀Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
ͼͬ͹Β
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ
͵͹͸΁Ͱͺͽ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ

ͳͷͪ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺ
͵͹Βͳ
ͪͼ͹΁ͳͻͪ
͸ͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͺͻͰͬͪͲͳΌͰ͸͹

 ́͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ 

ͼ΀ͬͪͽͪΔͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵;
ͺ͹͸;ͯ;
;͵Γ;΂;ΒͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͺ͹ͼͷͪͽͻͪΔͰ
ͯͰ
ͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ

ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͻ;ͽͪ
͵ͪ͹
͹ͼͷͳ΃ΓͰ͸ͳ΀
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳ΀

ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
ͳ
ͷ;ͶͽͳͷͰͯͳΒͪͶ͸ͳ
ͰͶͰͷͰ͸ͽͳ
΂ͳ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ

͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͼͪΒͽͪ
ͪͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͷ
ͳ
ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͪͬͪΒ;
ΒͰ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸͹ͷ
ͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺ;
ͺͻͰ
ͲͰ͸ͽ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͈ͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͇͋͊Ͱ
;
͵͹Β͹Β
ͺͻͰ͹ͬͶͪΌ;Β;
͹ͺͳͼ͸ͳ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͳ

ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͼͪ
ͷͪͶ͹
ͺ͹͸;ΌͰ͸ͳ΀
͵͹͸͵ͻͰͽ͸ͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹
ͼͽͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͷͪͶͳ
ͫͻ͹Β
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻͰͽͻͪͭ;
ͳ
͸Ͱͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͰ
ͷ;Ͷͽͳ
ͷͰͯͳΒͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͷͪͶ͹
ͳͼ͵͹ͻͳ΃ΕͰ͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ

ͬͰͫͪ
ͳ
ͯͪ
͹ͬͪ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͬͪͲͳ΃Ͷͪ
͸ͳͬ͹
ͺ;͵͹ͭ
ͺͻͰ͸͹ͼͪ

΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͸ͪ
͸͹ͬͳ
ͷͰͯͳΒ

̾ͶͰͷͰ͸ͽͳ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
͵ͻͰͳͻͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͳͷͳΘ
ͲͰͷΓͰ

͌
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹Β
ͺ͹͸;ͯͳ
͇͋͊Ͱ
ͺͻͰ͹ͬͶͪΌ;Β;
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂
͵Ͱ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽ͹ͬͪ͸Ͱ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͺͪͻ͵͹ͬͰ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳΒͪͶ͸Ͱ

ͻͰͲͰͻͬͪͽͰ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͰ
ͺͰΕͳ͸Ͱ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
͸ͪ
̽;͸ͪͬ;
ͫͪΔͼ͵Ͱ

΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͰ
ͳ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
͸ͪͷ
ͼͰ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ

͵ͪ͹
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸Ͱ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͰ
ͳ
͸Ͱͯͳͻ͸;ͽͰ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͰ
;Ͳ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͰ͸;

ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ΔͰ͸ͳͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
͸ͪͶͪͲͰ
ͫͳΓ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͳΔͼ͵Ͱ
ͬͻͼͽͰ
͵͹ΒͰ

ͼ;
ͬͰΕ
ͳͼͽͻͰͫΓͰ͸Ͱ
;
͹ͼͽͪͶͳͷ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳͷͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
͊ͬ͹ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͪͽͻͪ͵΁ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;ΒͰ
ͳͼͽͳ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͲͪΓ;ͫΓͰ
͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͰ
ͳ
ͼͬͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
΂ͰͲ͸;
Ͳͪ
ͪͬͪ͸ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͯ;΀͹ͷ

t͈ͰΔͪΔͰ
;Ͳ
Ͷͳͽͳ΁Ͱ
ͳ
ͼͽͰ͸Ͱ
΂Ͱ͵ͪΒ;
͹͸Ͱ
͵͹Βͳ
ͳͷͪΒ;
΀ͻͪͫͻ͹ͼͽͳ
ͯͪ
͹͵;
 ͪͅΒͪ
͋͹ͯ͹ͻ͹ͬͳΕ

ͼͰ
ͽͻͰ͸;ͽ͵Ͱ
ͳͼͽͳ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͶ͹ͫ͹ͯͰ
͸ͪ
ͬͳͼͳ͸ͪͷͪ
ͪ
ͪ͵͹
ͼͽͰ
ͻͪͼͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͰ͸ͳ

Ͳͪ
ͺͰ΃ͪ΂ͰΔͰ
;ͱͳͬͪΕͰͽͰ
;
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͼͽͬ;
ͶͰ͵͹ͬͳ
ͽ͹ͭ
ͫͳΓͪ
ͺͰ΂;ͻͪ͵ͪ
ͳ
΃;ͷͼ͵͹ͭ
ͬ͹Εͪi
͌
ͼͬ͹Β͹Β
ͺ͹͸;ͯͳ
͇͋͊Ͱ
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͳ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸Ͱ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂
͵Ͱ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͰ
͵͹Βͳ
͸Ͱ
ͯ͹ͺͻͳ͸͹ͼͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͲͯͻͪͬΓ;
ͬͪ΃Ͱͭ
ͽͰͶͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͳ
ͬͪ΃Ͱͭ

ͯ;΀ͪ
t̾ͿͰ͵ͪͽ
ͺ͹ͯͷͶͪΌͳͬͪΔͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
ΒͪͬΓͪ
͵͹ͯ
΃ͰͽΔͳ
ͺ͹
΂ͳͼͽ͹ͷ

ͬͪͲͯ;΀;
͸ͪ
ͬͳͼͳ͸ͪͷͪ
ͳͲ͸ͪͯ

ͷ
͸ͪͯͷ͹ͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͬͳͼͳ͸Ͱ
ͫ;ͯͳ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽ
͸ͳ
͹ͺͽͳͷͳͲͪͷi
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͲͰͷΓͪ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸ͳ΀
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳ
Ͳͪ

͹ͯͷ͹ͻ
͸ͪ
ͼͰͶ;
t̻͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
ͯͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ
͵ͻͪΒͪ
;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͭͯͰ
ͼͰ
͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͱͰͽͰ
͹ͯ
ͷ͹ͻͳͽͳ
;
ͺͻͰͯͳͬ͸͹ͷ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͪͷͫͳΒͰ͸ͽ;i
͌Ͳ
ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ͹
Ͷͳͻͼ͵ͳ
͹ͺͳͼ

ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
ͼ;
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͫͪΒ͵͹ͬͳͽͰ
͹ͪͲͰ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳΒͼ͵Ͱ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͯͪ
͸Ͱ
ͻͪͯͰ
͸ͳ΃ͽͪ
ͳ
ͯͪ
;ͱͳͬͪΒ;
;
ͷͳ
ͻ;
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͰ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͫ;ͯ;
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳ
΁Ͱ͹
ͯͪ͸
͈͹ͻͰͯ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͪ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳ
͵͹Βͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒ;
΂ͳ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͬͶͪ΂
͸͹ͷ
Ͳͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͼ;
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͌
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹Β

ͺ͹͸;ͯͳ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͪͻ΀Ͱ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ΀
͸ͪͶͪͲͳ΃ͽͪ
ͳͲ
ͻͪͲ͸ͳ΀
Ͱͺ͹΀ͪ
̈́ͰͺͰ͸ͼ͵ͳ

ͬͳͻ
̺ͳ͸΂ͪ
ͅͰͯͳͪ͸ͪ
̻ͪͷͲͳͭͻͪͯ

ͺͻͰ͹ͬͶͪΌ;ΒͰ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸ͳ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͳ

ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͬͰͻͼ͵ͳ΀
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͪͽͪ
΁ͻ͵ͬͪ
ͳ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͪ
ͅͰΌ;
Δͳͷͪ
ͺ͹
ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͼ;
ͳͼͽͪ͵͸;ͽͳ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸ͳ
ͷͪ͸ͪͼͽͳͻͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ

ͯ;΃Ͱ
ͳ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰͬͻͼ͸Ͱ
ͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͭͪͶͰͻͳΒͰ
ͪ
ͿͻͰͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
ͳ͵͹͸Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ
͸͹
ͫͶͪͭ͹
;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͷ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌ;
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
t.FEJUFSBO
LBLBW
KF
OFLBE
CJPi
ͻͰ͵Ͷͪͷ͸ͳ
ΒͰ
ͼͶ͹ͭͪ͸
ͼͪΒͽͪ
͎͋̀Ͱ

͊Ͷͳ΂͸͹
͵ͪ͹
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
ͳ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͪ
ͼͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳͷͪ
͸;ͯͳ
͵ͪ͹
͹ͪͲͪ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹
ͼͽͳ
ͳ
tOFUBLOVUJIi
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͪ
t"VUFOUJǁBO
EPßJWMKBK
NFEJUFSBOB
LPKJ
KF

TWVEB
WFǀ
JØǁF[BP
ǁBL
IJMKBEV
PTUSWB
PE
LPKJI
KF
TWBLJ
TWFU
[B
TFCF
HSBEP
WJ
CPHBUF
LVMUVSOPJTUPSJKTLF
CBØUJOF
ǁJOF
BEVUF
CF[
QSFNDBi
́ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸ͼ͵͹
ͷ͹ͻͰ
͵͹͸͵;ͻͰ͸ͽͼ͵ͪ
ͺͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
͹͸͹

͸ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸͹
ͼͪͷ͹
͵ͪ͹
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͺͶͪͱͪ
ͳ
͵;ͺͪΔͪ
ͬͰΕ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ

͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͬͳͯ͹ͬͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
̀ͫ͹ͭ
͹΂;ͬͪ͸͹ͭ
͵ͬͪͶͳͽͰͽͪ
ͷ͹ͻͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳ΀
Ͱ͸ͯͰͷͼ͵ͳ΀
ͬͻ
ͼͽͪ
ͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸
ͼͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳͷͪ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;ΒͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸ͪ
Ͱ͵͹
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳ
Βͪ
͈ͻͳ
ͽ͹ͷ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͯͪ
Ͳͪͺͻͪͬ͹
ͳ
΂ͳͽͪͬ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͺͪ
ͯͪ
;
Ͱ͵͹Ͷ͹΃͵͹
͸ͰͲͪͭͪΌͰ͸͹
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂ΒͰ
ͫͰͲ
͹ͫͲͳͻͪ
ͻͪͯͳͶ͹
ͼͰ
͹
ͬͪͲͯ;΀;



IUUQXXXTFSCJBUPVSJTNPSH/BUVSB@"UUSBDUJPOT


IUUQXXXTFSCJBUPVSJTNPSHͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸Ͱ


IUUQXXXTFSCJBUPVSJTNPSHͼͰͶͪ


IUUQXXXDSPBUJBISBDUJWJUJFTDPOUFOU
 ́͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ 

ͼͶͪͽ͵ͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͪͷͪ
ͳͶͳ
ͷ͹ͻ;
ͽͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͪ
ͼͳͭ;ͻ͸͹
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂ΒͰ
ͭͯͰ

ΕͰ
ͼͰ
ͭ͹ͼͽ
͹ͼͰΕͪͽͳ
;ͭ͹ͯ͸͹
ͳ
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹ͯ͹΃Ͷ͹
͇͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͳͯͰͪͶ͸ͪ
ͲͰͷΓͪ
Ͳͪ
͸ͪͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
t%VHB
USBEJDJKB
OBUVSJTUJǁ
LPH
UVSJ[NB
TUWPSJMB
KF
)SWBUTLPK
JNJEß
JEFBMOF
OBUVSJTUJǁLF
[FNMKFi

͈͹ͼͰͽͳ͹΁ͳ
ͼͪΒͽͪ
ͼͰ
tQPETFǀBKVi
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͪ
ͺͻͬͪ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵ͪ
ͲͰͷΓͪ

͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͼͽ͹ͽͳ͸ͪ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
͹ͽͬ͹ͻͳͶͪ
ͬͻͪͽͪ
͸ͪͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳͷͪ
̺ͳ΃Ͱ
͹ͯ
΀ͳΓͪͯ;
͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
ͳ
ͻͪͲ;ΌͰ͸ͪ
͹ͫͪͶͪ
ͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸ͪ
΂ͳ͸ͳ
ΒͰ
ͳ

ͳͯͰͪͶ͸͹ͷ
ͲͰͷΓ͹ͷ
Ͳͪ
͸ͪ;ͽͳ΂ͪͻͰ
́ͯͰ͸ͽͳͽͰͽ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
΂ͳ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͹ͯ
΀ͳΓͪͯ;
͹ͼͽͻͬͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰͷ

ͫ͹ͭͪͽͳ΀
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͳ
ͻͳͲ͸ͳ΁;
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳ͹
͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͰ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
ͺͻͰͽ͹΂Ͱ͸ͪ
;
Ϳ͹Ͷ
͵͹ͻ͸Ͱ
ͷͪ͸ͳͿͰͼͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͊ͬͰͽͳ͹͸ͳ΁ͳ
͸ͪ
͹ͼͽͻͬͳͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͯͰ͹
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒ
ͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
ͪͯͪͺͽͳͻͪ͸ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͪΒ
ͭ͹ͼͽͳΒ;
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;Β;
ͼͰ
͵ͪ͹

ͷͰͼͽͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫͪ͸
ͯͻ;ͭͪ΂ͳΒͳ
͹ͯͷ͹ͻ
͠Ͱͯͳ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸͹ͼͽ
΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
΂ͳ͸ͳ
ͳ
΀ͳΓͪ
ͯ;ͭ͹ͯͳ΃ΔͰ
ͼͷͰΔͳͬͪΔͰ
͸ͳͲͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
͸ͪ
ΔͰ͸͹Β
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
̓;Ͷͽ;ͻ
͸͹ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰ
ͼͬͰͭͪ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͺ͹͸;ͯ;

ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
̸͵΁Ͱ͸ͪͽ
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͳ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͳͷ͹ͻͼ͵ͳ΀

ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
ͷͰΌ;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸͹
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽ;Β;
͹͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͯ
Ͳͪ΃ͽͳͽ͹ͷ

͇͌͆̾͊̓ͪ
̽ͳ͹͵ͶͰ΁ͳΒͪ͸͹ͬͪ
ͺͪͶͪͽͪ
;
͊ͺͶͳͽ;
ͼͽͪͻͪ
ΒͰͲͭͻͪ
͋ͻ͹ͭͳͻͪ



IUUQXXXDSPBUJBISBDUJWJUJFTDPOUFOU
 ͪͅΒͪ
͋͹ͯ͹ͻ͹ͬͳΕ

͑ͳͫͰ͸ͳ͵
͈͹ͻͰ΂
ͳ
̽;ͫͻ͹ͬ͸ͳ͵
͇ͬͳ
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͳ
m
ͼͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͹ͺͳͼ;Β;

ͼͰ
͵ͪ͹
͸ͰͲͪͫ͹ͻͪͬ͸ͳ
ͪͶͳ
ͽͪ͵ͪͬ
ͰͺͳͽͰͽ
͸͹ͼͳ
ͳ
΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͪ
ͷͰͽͻ͹ͺ͹Ͷͪ
̀ͪ
ͭͻͰͫ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
͸Ͱ͵ͳ
͹ͯ
͵͹͸ͽͳ͸Ͱ͸ͽͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
̺ͪͻͪͱͯͳ͸
͇ͼͳΒͰ͵
͈͹ͼͰͫ͸;
ͺ͹͸;ͯ;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͬͰͻͼ͵ͳ
ͽ;
ͻͳͲͪͷ
ͼͪ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸ͳͷ
͹ͺͳͼ͹ͷ
ͬͰͻͼ͵ͳ΀
΀ͻͪͷ͹ͬͪ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ͹ͷ

ͽͰͻͷͳ͸ͳͷͪ
ͷͳͼͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͳΔͪΔͰͷ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
͸Ͱ͵ͳ
͹ͯ
Δͳ΀
͸ͪͼͽͻͪͯͪ
Ͷͳ
͹ͯ
ͼͽͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͬ͹Βͼ͵Ͱ
;
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯΔͰͷ
ͻͪͽ͸͹ͷ
ͼ;͵͹ͫ;
ͯͰͬͰͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
̓ͪ͹
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽͪ͸
͵ͬͪͶͳͽͰͽ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͼͰ
ͻͪͲ͸͹ͬͻ
ͼ͸͹ͼͽ
΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
͵;΀ͳΔͰ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͪ
ͳ
͵ͪ͹
͵;΀ͳΔͪ
͸ͳͲͪ
ͻͰͭͳΒͪ
͌

ͭͪͼͽͻ͹͸͹ͷͼ͵͹Β
ͺ͹͸;ͯͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸͹
ͷͰͼͽ͹
Ͳͪ;Ͳͳͷͪ
΃ͳͻ͹͵ͪ
ͺͪͶͰͽͪ
͸ͪ΁ͳ
͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͬͳͼ͹͵͹͵ͬͪͶͳͽͰͽ͸ͳ΀
ͬͳ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͳ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͭ

͵͹Ͷͪ΂ͪ
ͺͪͺͻͰΔͪ͵ͪ
̹͹ͭͪͽͼͽͬ͹
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
ͳ
͹ͼͷͳ΃ΓͰ͸ͳ΀
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
Ͳͪ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪΒ
ͽ;
ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͰ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͼͪΒͽͪ

͇͊͋Ͱ
̓ͪ͹
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
͸ͪ
͵͹ͷͰ
ͼͰ
ͼͺͪΒͪΒ;
ͷͰͯͳͽͰͻͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͳ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ

ͯ;΀
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͪ
ͼͰ
͸;ͯͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳͷͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͲͰͷΓͪ
ͳͲͬ͹ͻͪ
ͲͯͻͪͬΓͪ
ͼ
ͫ͹ͭͪ
ͽ͹ͷ
ͫͪΔͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺ͹͸;ͯ͹ͷ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
Ͳͪ
͸ͪΒͪͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳΒͰ
Ͱ͵ͼͽͻͰͷ
͸Ͱ
ͼͺ͹ͻͽ͹ͬͰ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͲͰͷΓͪ
͵͹͸ͭͻͰͼ͸͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
ͳͯͰͪͶ͸ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹
ͼͶ͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͼ;ͼͻͰͽͰ
ͪͯ͠ͻͪ͸ͼ͵ͪ
͹ͫͪͶͪ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽͰ
ͫ;Β͸Ͱ
ͬͰͭͰͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
΂ͳ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵;

͹ͫͶͪͼͽ
ͲͰͶͰ͸͹ͭ
ͷͰͯͳͽͰͻͪ͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳͷ
ͻͰͲͰͻͬͪͽ͹ͷ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸͹ͭ

ͫͳΓ͸͹ͭ
ͳ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͳΔͼ͵͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
ͷͰΌ;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͳͼͽͳ΂;
ͫͻ͹Β
͸Ͱ
ͬͻͼͽͰ
ͺͽͳ΁ͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
͸ͪ
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
ͳͷͪΒ;
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸͹
ͼͽͪ͸ͳ
΃ͽͰ
͈͹ͻͰͯ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
ͪͽͻͪ͵΁ͳΒͪ
ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ͅͰͯͳͽͰͻͪ͸ͪ

ΒͰ
ͳ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͪ
ͫͪ΃ͽͳ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͼͻͰͯΔ͹ͬͰ͵͹ͬ͸ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ͹
ͬͳ
͈ͳͻͪ͸
́Ͳ͹Ͷͪ
ͳ
̓͹ͺͪͻ
̓ͻ͹Ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵;
ͻͰͭͳΒ;
ͅͳͼͽͰͻͳ͹Ͳ͸ͳ
͵ͪͻͼͽ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ

ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͲͰͷΓͪ
ͼ
͸ͪΒͶͰͺ΃ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯͲͰͷ͸ͳͷ
ͼͬͰͽ͹ͷ
͸ͪ΃Ͱ
ͺͶͪ
͸ͰͽͰ
͈͹ͻͰͯ
ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳ΀
͵ͪͻͼͽ͸ͳ΀
ͺͰΕͳ͸ͪ
͸ͪΒͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
͸ͪΒͺ͹ͼͰΕͰ
͸ͳΒͪ
͈͹ͼͽ͹Β͸ͼ͵ͪ
Βͪͷͪ
͊ͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͹ͯ

ͷͳͶͳ͹͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͽͳͶͪ΁ͪ
͹͸ͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪΒ
ͺ͹ͼͰΕͰ͸ͳΒͪ
ͺͰΕͳ͸ͪ
;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
͠͹΃
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
ͲͰͶͰ͸ͪ
͹ͪͲͪ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͰ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͼͷͰΒͪ͸͹
͈͹΀͹ͻΒͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͺ͹
ͻͰͯ
Ͳͳͷͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼ͵ͳΒͪ΃͵ͳ΀
΁Ͱ͸ͽͪͻͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳͷͪ
͸;ͯͳ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͰ
ͼͺ͹ͻͽ
ͼ͵Ͱ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
΂ͳͽͪͬͰ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͆ͪ΁ͳ͸ͪͶ͸ͳ
ͺͪͻ͵
͋ͻͳͭͶͪͬ
;
ͻͰͭͳΒͳ
͊;͸΂ͪ͸ͳ
̸Ͷͺͳ
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͼͰ

͵ͪ͹
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͬΕͳ΀
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͺͪͻ͵͹ͬͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
͈͹ͻͰͯ
ͫͻ͹Β͸ͳ΀

ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
ͶͰͺ͹ͽͪ
͹ͬͰ
ͻͰͭͳΒͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂;Β;
ΒͰ
ͲͰͻͪ
̹ͶͰͯ
ͳ
̹͹΀ͳΔ
͵ͪ͹
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
΁Ͱ͸ͽͻͳ
ͯ;ͭͰ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳΒͰ
̓ͪ͹
͸ͰͲͪͫ͹ͻͪͬ͸͹
ͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬ͹
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͯͷ͹ͻ
͸ͪ
ΒͰͯ͸͹Β
͹ͯ


ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͪ΂͵ͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
Ϳͪͻͷͳ
t#PSBWBL
OB
UVSJTUJǁLJN
GBSNB
 ́͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ 

NB
KF
PEMJǁOB
QSJMJLB
EB
TB[OBUF
OFØUP
P
CPHBUPN
LVMUVSOPN
OBTMFDžV

PǁVWBOPK
BSIJUFLUVSJ

PCJǁBKJNB
J
USBEJDJPOBMOJN
[BOBUJNB
7BØJ
MKVCB
[OJ
EPNBǀJOJ
QPTMVßJǀF
WBN
EPNBǀV
ISBOV
PSJHJOBMOP
EPNBǀF
WJOP
J

SBLJKVi
͈͹ͻͰͯ
͹ͯͷ͹ͻͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͺͻ;ͱͪ
͸ͳͲ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
;΂Ͱͼͽͬ͹ͬͪΔͰ
;

ͼͰ͹ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͺͻͳͻͰͯͫͪͷͪ
ͼͺ͹ͻͽͼ͵ͳͷ
ͽ;ͻ͸ͳͻͳͷͪ

ͼͰͶͪ
ͼͰ
͸;
ͯͰ
ͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͷͰͼͽͪ
Ͳͪ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ͺ͹ͼͶ͹ͬ͸ͳ΀
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͆ͪ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ
͸;
ͳͲͭͻͪΌͰ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
͹ͼͷͳ΃ΓͰ͸͹ͼͽ
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
ͳ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ

ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵Ͱ
ͿͪͻͷͰ
͵ͪͽͰͭ͹ͻͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳͷͪ

͵͹ΒͰ
͸;ͯͰ
͈ͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͰ
ͬͳ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
;
͹͵ͬͳͻ;
ͼͰ͹ͼ͵Ͱ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
ͪͶͳ

ͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸Ͱ
ͻ;ͽͰ
;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͫ͹ͭͪͽ;
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳΒ;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͬͳ͸ͪ
̺ͳ͸
ͼ͵ͪ
ͻ;ͽͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ͸ͪ΂Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
;
͸ͳͲ;
ͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵ͳ΀
ͻ;ͽͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͪΒͽ;
͇͊͋
͵͹
Βͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
͸;ͯͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͪ΂ͳΒͳ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪΒ
͹ͯ
͵͹͸ͬͰ͸΁ͳ͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
t,SP[

QP[OBUF
J
NBOKF
QP[OBUF
BUSBLDJKF
OB
UFNBUTLJN
SVUBNB
NPßFUF
EPßJWFUJ

4MPWFOJKV
LBP
[FNMKV
LPKB
PLSFQMKVKF
EVI
J
UFMPi
͈͹ͻͰͯ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͳ
Ϳ͹Ͷ͵Ͷ͹ͻ͸͹ͭ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ
͸Ͱ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
ͳ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒ;
͡;ͫΓͪ͸Ͱ
͵͹Βͪ

ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͼͪΒͽ;
ͳ
ͯͰͿͳ͸ͳͼͪ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͭͻͪͯ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
̻Ͷͪͬ͸ͳ
ͭͻͪͯ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͰ

͹ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
ͼͰ
͵ͪ͹
͵;Εͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ΀
ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͳ΃ͽͪ
ͷ;ͲͰΒͪ
ͭͪͶͰͻͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͷͪ͸ͳͿͰ
ͼͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͰ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ
͸ͪΒͼͽͪͻͳΒͳ΀
ͿͳͶ΀ͪͻͷ͹͸ͳΒͪ
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͼͰ



IUUQXXXTMPWFOJBUPVSJTNTJQPEF[FMKF


IUUQXXXTMPWFOJBUPVSJTNTJTUSBOTLF@QPUJ
 ͪͅΒͪ
͋͹ͯ͹ͻ͹ͬͳΕ

͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸ͪ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽ
͈͹ͻͰͯ
ͼͪ΂;ͬͪ͸ͳ΀
͹ͼͽͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͭͻͪͯͪ
̾ͷ͹͸Ͱ
ͳͲ

ͻͳͷͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
ͪͻͽͳͽͰ͵ͽ;ͻͰ
ͼͻͰͯΔͰͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͻͰ͸Ͱͼͪ͸ͼͰ
ͳ
ͫͪͻ͹͵ͪ

ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸ͪ
ͪͻ΀ͳͽͰ͵ͽ;ͻͪ
͡;ͫΓͪ͸Ͱ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͯ͹΂ͪͻͪ
Ͷͪ
ͳͼͺͻͰͺͶͰͽͪ͸͹ͼͽ
ͼͽͪͻ͹ͭ
ͳ
͸͹ͬ͹ͭ
͵͹ΒͰ
;
΀ͪͻͷ͹͸ͳΒͳ
jͱͳͬͳv
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ

ͭͻͪͯ;
͌
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹΁ͳΒͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
ͼͬͰ
ͽͻͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
͹ͻͭͪ
͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
͵ͪ͹
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
ͬͰͶͳ͵͹ͭ
ͯͳͬͰͻͲͳͽͰ
ͽͪ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ΀
ͻͰͼ;ͻͼͪ
ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
;
΁ͳΓ;
ͯͳͿͰͻͰ͸΁ͳͻͪΔͪ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹ͯ
͵͹͸͵;ͻͰ͸ͽ
ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͼͬͰ
ͽͻͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳͼͽͳ΂;
͹͸Ͱ
ͪͽͻͳ
ͫ;ͽͰ
͵͹Βͳ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͳͷͪͽͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͰΔͰ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹ͽͰ͸΁ͳΒͪͶ͸Ͱ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ͵Ͱ

ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
͵͹͸͵;ͻͰ͸ͽͼ͵;
ͺͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽ
͌
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹Β
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
ͳͲ
ͬ͹ͻ͸ͳ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪΒ
ͅͰͯͳͽͰͻͪ͸ͪ
;
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͳ
͵͹͸ͽͻͪͼͽͳ
ͷ͹ͯͰͻ͸͹ͭͼͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹ͭ
ͷͰͯͳͽͰͻͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͳ
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͯ;΀ͪ
ͪ
;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͰͶͰͷͰ͸ͽͳ

͹ͻͳΒͰ͸ͽͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͯ;΀ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͪͼ͹΁ͳͻͪΒ;
͸ͪ
͹ͺ;΃ͽͰ͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
΀Ͱͯ͹͸ͳͲͪͷ
̓ͪ͵͹
ͫͳ
ͯ͹΂ͪͻͪͶͳ
ͪ;ͽͰ͸ͽͳ΂͸͹ͼͽ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸;
ͪͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽ
ͼͬ͹
ΒͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳͼͽͳ΂;
;
ͺ͹͸;ͯͳ

͹͸͹
ͺ͹
΂Ͱͷ;
ͼ;
ͺͻͬͳ
;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
ͳ
ͼͬͰͽ;
ͳͶͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ

tͺͻ͹ͭͶͪ΃ͪͬͪΒ;i
ͳͯͰͪͶ͸ͳͷ
Ͳͪ
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
͹ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
;
͹ͯͻͰ
ΌͰ͸ͳͷ
ͼͰͭͷͰ͸ͽͳͷͪ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͳͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͰ͵ͶͪͺͪΒ;
;
tͳͯͰ
ͪͶ͸͹ͼͽͳi
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
͈ͻͪͽͰΕͳ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͽͻͰ͸ͯ͹ͬͰ
ͼͬͰ
ͽͻͳ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͼͰ
tͺͻͰ
ͺ͹ͻ;΂Β;i
͵ͪ͹
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸Ͱ
Ͱ͵͹Ͷ͹΃͵Ͱ
ͯͰͼͽͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͸ͪ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪͶͪͲͰ

ͻͪͻͳͽͰͽ͸Ͱ
ͫͳΓ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͱͳͬ͹ͽͳΔͼ͵Ͱ
ͬͻͼͽͰ
ͪ
͹΂;ͬͪ͸͹
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯ͸͹
͹͵ͻ;
ͱͰΔͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͳͯͰͪͶ͸͹
Ͳͪ
͹ͯͷ͹ͻ
;
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͳ
ͼͺ͹ͻͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
ͪͬ
͸ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
́ͼͽ͹
ͽͪ͵͹
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸ͳ
ͯ͹ͱͳͬΓͪΒ
́ͼͽ͹͵ͪ

ͳ
̀ͪͺͪͯͪ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ
͹ͯ
ͽͻͳ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͳͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳͼͽͳ΂Ͱ
͵ͪ͹
ͼͬ͹Β;

͵͹ͷͺͪͻͪͽͳͬ͸;
ͺͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽ
͠͹΃
ΒͰͯͪ͸
͹ͯ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͯͷ͹ͻ
͸ͪ
ͼͰͶ;
Ͳͪ

͵͹Βͳ
ͳͯͰͪͶ͸Ͱ
;ͼͶ͹ͬͰ
ͺͻ;ͱͪΒ;
ͳ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͪ
ͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
ͳͪ͵͹
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͪ

ͳͷͪ
ͯͪͶͰ͵͹
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͳΒ;
ͺ͹͸;ͯ;
ͻ;ͻͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
͌
͵ͻͰͳͻͪΔ;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͽͰͽͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͪΒͽ;
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͳ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ

ͯ͹ͷͳ͸ͳͻͪΒ;
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳ
ͽͻͪͯͳ΁ͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͳ
ͬͰͻͼ͵͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
͠Ͱͯͳ
͸͹
͇͊͋ͪ
;
ͼͬ͹Β;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸;
ͺ͹͸;ͯ;
ͺ͹ͯΒͰͯ͸ͪ͵͹
;͵Γ;΂;ΒͰ
ͳ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ
͸;
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ;
ͳ
ΒͰͯͳ͸͹
͹͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽ;ΒͰ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͼͰͭͷͰ͸ͽͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͵ͪ͹

΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͷ;ͲͰΒͼ͵Ͱ
;ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬͰ
ͳ
ͭͪͶͰͻͳΒͰ
́ͪ͵͹
ͼͬͰ
ͽͻͳ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͰ
͹
ͫ;ͻ͸͹Β
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
ͼͬ͹Βͳ΀

ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
ͻͪͽ͸ͳͷ
ͼ;͵͹ͫͳͷͪ
ͯͰͬͰͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͼͰ
ͼ͵͹ͻ͹
ͳ
͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͷͳ
Δ;
ΒͰͻ
ͫͳ
ͽ͹
͸ͪͻ;΃ͳͶ͹
ͺ͹Ͳͳͽͳͬͪ͸
ͳͷͳΘ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͸ͪͼͽ͹ΒͰ
ͯͪ
͵ͻͰͳͻͪΒ;
͸ͪ
ͼͬ͹Βͳͷ
ͼͪΒͽ͹ͬͳͷͪ
 ́͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ 

̓͹ͷͺͪͻͪͽͳͬ͸ͪ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͪ
ͼͪΒͽ͹ͬͪ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
͹ͻ
ͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͰ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ
͸ͳ
ͼͪΒͽ͹ͬͳ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰͬͻͼͽͪ͸
͹ͯͻͪͲ
͸ͳͬ͹ͪ
ͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
;
͹ͬͳͷ

ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
̸͵͹
ͳͷͪͷ͹
;
ͬͳͯ;
ͯͪ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
ͽͰͱͳ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳΒͪͶͳͲ͹ͬͪ
͸͹Β
ͺ͹͸;ͯͳ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸͹Β
ͪ͸ͳͷͪ΁ͳΒͳ
ͳ
ͪͶͽͰͻ͸ͪͽͳͬ͸ͳͷ
͹ͫͶͳ΁ͳͷͪ

ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
͸ͪ
͸ͪΒͬͳ΃Ͱͷ
͸ͳͬ͹;
ͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ΒͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͰ
͋͹

͸ͪΒͫ͹ΓͰ
ͳͶ;ͼͽͻ;ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽ͹ͬͪ͸ͪ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͪΒͽ;
͇͊͋
͵͹Βͪ
Ͳͪ
ͼͬͪ͵;

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵;
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽ
͸;ͯͳ
͹ͼͷͳ΃ΓͰ͸Ͱ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͰ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸Ͱ
ͳ
Ͱ͵͹Ͷ͹
΃͵Ͱ
ͻ;ͽͰ
ͳ
͸ͪΒͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳΒͰ
͹ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
́ͪ͵͹
͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͪ
͸ͳͬ͹;
ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͪ΂͵͹ͭ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͳ

ͼͪΒͽͪ
͎͋̀Ͱ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͰ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂ͳͽͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
͸ͪ
ͯ͹ͫͻ͹ͷ

ͺ;ͽ;
͵ͪ
;ͼ͵ͶͪΌͳͬͪΔ;
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
ͼͪ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͳͷ
ͽͻͰ͸ͯ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͊ͪΒͽ
͇͋͊Ͱ
;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͻͰͶͪͽͳͬ͸͹
Ͷ͹΃;
ͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ͸͹ͼͽ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ

;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ΒͰͻ
ͼͰ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͪ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ
Ͳͪͼ͸ͳͬͪ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͽͰͱ͸͹
ͺͻͰͬͪͲͳΌͰ͸ͳͷ

͵͹͸΁Ͱͺͽͳͷͪ
ͪ
;Ͳ
ͽ͹
͸ͪ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͼͪΒͽͪ
ͬͻͶ͹

΂Ͱͼͽ͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪͳͶͪͲͳ
͸ͪ
ͲͪͼͽͪͻͰͶͰ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
΃ͽ͹
ͳͯͰ
;
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͭ
΂ͳΔͰ
͸ͳ΁ͳ
ͯͪ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
͸Ͱͷͪ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸;
ͼͽͻͪͽͰͭͳΒ;
͈͹ͻͰͯ
͸ͳͬ͹ͪ
ͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͪ
͹ͬͪ
ͽͻͳ
ͼͪΒͽͪ

ͺ͹͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
ͳ
ͼͽͰͺͰ͸
ͳͼ͵͹ͻͳ΃ΕͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͬͰͫͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹ͭ
ͷͰͯͳΒͪ

;
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹Β
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹΁ͳΒͳ
ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͻͰͯ͸͹
ͳ
͸ͳͬ͹
ͻͪͲͬͳΒͰ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ
͸Ͱͽ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
΂ͳΒͪ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽ;ΒͰ
́
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͼͰͭͷͰ͸ͽ;

͇͊͋ͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪΒͫ͹ΓͰ
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͳͶͪ
͹ͬͪΒ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ
ͷͰͯͳΒ
;
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹΁ͳΒͳ
ͳ

ͺͻ͹ͯͪΒͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯͪ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͷͪͯͪ
͸ͳ
ͼͪΒͽ
͎͋̀Ͱ
͸Ͱ

Ͳͪ͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
;
ͺ͹͸;ͯͳ
ͷ;ͶͽͳͷͰͯͳΒͪͶ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳ΀
ͼͪͯͻ
ͱͪΒͪ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
ͯ͹͵
ΒͰ
ͼͪΒͽ
͇͋͊Ͱ
ͳ

;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͪͼͺͰ͵ͽ;
ͬͰͫ
ͺ͹͸;ͯͰ
͸ͪΒͶ͹΃ͳΒͳ
͐ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͯͪ
ͳͷͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
ΒͰͯͪ͸

ͳ͸ͽͰͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳ
ͼͰͻͬͳͼ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͳͷͪͽͳ
ͳ
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹
͹ͫΒͪ΃ΔͰΔͰ
ΒͰͻ
;

͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
͸ͳͼ;
ͻͰ΃Ͱ͸ͳ
ͷͰ΀ͪ͸ͳͲͷͳ
ͺͶͪΕͪΔͪ
ͳ
ͻͰͲͰͻͬͪ΁ͳΒͰ
POMJOF

ͪͶͳ
ͽ͹
ͳͼͽ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹
;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
ͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪ
͹ͬͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
Β͹΃

;ͬͰ͵
͸ͪ
͸ͳͼ͵͹ͷ
͸ͳͬ͹;
ͳ
ͯͪ
Ͳͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;
͹ͯ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
;

͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
Β͹΃
;ͬͰ͵
͸ͳͼ;
;
ͺͻͪͬ͹Β
ͷͰͻͳ
ͼ΀ͬͪΕͰ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ

ͽͻͱͳ΃ͽͪ
̸͵͹
tͻͪ͸ͭͳͻͪΔͰi
͵ͬͪͶͳͽͰͽͪ
ͽͻͳ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͳͻͪ͸ͪ
ͼͪΒͽͪ
ͯ͹ͬͰͯͰͯͰ
ͷ͹
;
ͬͰͲ;
ͼͪ
ͼ͹΁ͳ͹Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵͹ͷ
ͼͳͽ;ͪ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͲͰͷͪΓͪ
΂ͳΒ;
ͺ͹͸;ͯ;

ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽ;Β;
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸Ͱ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͬͳͯͳͷ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͹͸ͪ

ͺ͹͵Ͷͪͺͪ
ͼ
ͻͰͪͶ͸͹ͷ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͼ;͵͹ͫͪ
ͯͰͬͰͯͰͼͰ
ͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
͸ͪΒͯ;ͱͰ
ͺ͹ͯ
ͳͲ͹Ͷͪ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ΒͰ
ͲͰ
ͷΓͪ
͸ͰͼͽͪͫͳͶ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͳͽ;ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͯ͹͵
ΒͰ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͪ

 ͪͅΒͪ
͋͹ͯ͹ͻ͹ͬͳΕ

ͻͪ͸ͳΒͰ
;΃Ͷͪ
;
ͽͻͪ͸Ͳͳ΁ͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻ͹΁ͰͼͰ
ͳ
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
ΒͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͽ͸͹
ͼͽͪͫͳͶ͸ͳΒͳ΀

Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪ
ͪ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͰΕ
΂Ͷͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
̾͌
ͼͪ
͸ͪΒͼͽͪͫͳͶ
͸ͳΒͳͷ
ͼ͹΁ͳ͹Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ

ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͪ͵͹
;ͲͷͰͷ͹
;
͹ͫͲͳͻ
ͽͬͻͯΔͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͷͪͻ͵Ͱ
ͽͳ͸ͭ
͸ͪΒΒͰͿͽͳ͸ͳΒͳ
͹ͫͶͳ͵
ͻͰ͵ͶͪͷͰ
ͯ͹ͼͽ;ͺͪ͸
΂ͳͽͪͬ͹ͷ
ͼͬͰͽ;

ͯͪ͸ͪ

;
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͳ
ͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͳͻͽ;ͰͶ͸ͳ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͪͷ
ͫ;ͯ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
ͽ;ͻͳͲͷͪ
͹͸ͯͪ
ͳ
Ͳͪ

ͲͰͷΓͰ
Ͷ͹΃ͳΒͳ΀
ͯͻ;΃ͽͬͰ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪ
͵ͻͰͳͻͪΔͰ
ͪͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͳ΀
ͰͶͰ͵
ͽͻ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͫͻ͹΃;ͻͪ
ͷ͹ͻͪ
ͫͳͽͳ
ͳͷͺͰͻͪͽͳͬ
;
ͺͻ͹ͷ͹΁ͳΒͳ
ͳ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β;
ͽ;
ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͰ
 ́͸ͽͰͻ͸Ͱͽ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹͸;ͯͪ 

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

.BKB
5PEPSPWJǀ
*OUFSOFUQSÅTFOUBUJPOFO
UPVSJTUJTDIFS
"OHFCPUF

FMFDUSPOJTDIF
3FJTFGÛISFS

&JOF
WFSHMFJDIFOEF
"OBMZTF
EFS
WPO
EFO
OBUJPOBMFO
3FJTFBHFOUVSFO

4MPXFOJFOT
,SPBUJFOT
VOE
4FSCJFOT
FJOHFSJDIUFUFO
8FCTFJUFO
[FJHU
EBTT
EJFTF

UBUTÅDIMJDI
FJOF
8JEFSTQJFHFMVOH
EFT
&OUXJDLMVOHTTUBOEFT
EFT
5PVSJTNVT
JO

EFO
BOHFGÛISUFO
-ÅOEFSO
EBSTUFMMFO

8FOO
JOEJWJEVBMJTJFSUF
"OHFCPUF
PSHBOJTJFSUF
"OJNBUJPOFO
VOE

BMUFSOBUJWF
5PVSJTNVTGPSNFO
BMT
.B“TUÅCF
BOHFMFHU
XFSEFO
SBHU
4MPXFOJFO

EVSDI
FJO
IPIFT
/JWFBV
EFS
5PVSJTNVTFOUXJDLMVOH
IFSWPS
%JFT
XJSE
CFJ
EFS

"OBMZTF
EFS
8FCTFJUF
EFS
TMPXFOJTDIFO
UPVSJTUJTDIFO
0SHBOJTBUJPO
CFTUÅUJHU

XP
[V
VOUFSTDIJFEMJDIFO
;XFDLFO
HVU
VOE
SFJGMJDI
EVSDIEBDIUF
*OIBMUF
JO

LVMUVSFMMFS
)JOTJDIU
CFEFVUVOHTWPMMF
VOE
VNXFMUCFXVTTUF
3FJTFSPVUFO

XJF
BVDI
XFJUFSF
NBOOJHGBMUJHF
'PSNFO
EFT
BLUJWFO
5PVSJTNVT
BOHFCPUFO

XFSEFO

0CXPIM
EJF
1SÅTFOUBUJPO
EFS
LSPBUJTDIFO
UPVSJTUJTDIFO
0SHBOJTBUJPO
JN

7FSIÅMUOJT
[VS
TMPXFOJTDIFO
FJOJHFT
[VN
XÛOTDIFO
ÛCSJH
MÅTTU
MJFHU
FT
EPDI

OBIF
EBTT
TJDI
EFS
5PVSJTNVT
JO
,SPBUJFO
CFIBSSMJDI
FJOFO
8FH
[VS
"OQBTTVOH

EFT
"OHFCPUFT
BO
8FMUUSFOET
CBIOU



%JF
*OUFSOFUTFJUF
EFS
UPVSJTUJTDIFO
0SHBOJTBUJPO
4FSCJFOT
CF[FVHU
EFO

CFLBOOUMJDI
WFSIÅMUOJTNœJH
OJFESJHFO
&UXJDLMVOHTTUBOE
EFT
5PVSJTNVT
%JF

WPSLPNNFOEFO
"OHFCPUF
CFSVIFO
BVG
ÛCFSXJFHFOE
ÛCFSIPMUFO
,PO[FQUFO

FJOJHF
4FJUFO
FOUIBMUFO
WFSBMUFUF
*OGPSNBUJPOFO
XPSBVT
OVS
[V
GPMHFSO
JTU

EBTT
EJF
UPVSJTUJTDIF
0SHBOJTBUJPO
JO
4FSCJFO
JNNFS
OPDI
LFJOF
LMBSFO

&OUXJDLMVOHTTUSBUFHJFO
CFTDIMPTTFO
IBU


%JF
EVSDIHFGÛSIUF
"OBMZTF
WFSNBH
OJDIU
OVS
BVG
EFO
&OUXJDLMVOHTTUBOE

FJOFT
8JSUTDIBGUT[XFJHFT
[V
WFSXFJTFO
TPOEFSO
BVDI
BVG
EJF
"VTOVU[VOH
EFT

*OUFSOFUT
BMT
NPEFSOFO
.FEJVNT
[VN
;XFDL
EFS
5PVSJTNVT'ÕSEFSVOH

NJUUFMCBS
BVDI
BVG
EJF
*OUFSOFULVMUVS
EFT
-ÅOEFS
EFSFO
"OHFCPU
QSÅTFOUJFSU

XJSE
"VDI
JO
EJFTFN
4FHNFOU
XVSEF
WPO
EFS
4MPXFOJTDIFO
5PVSJTUJTDIFO

0SHBOJTBUJPO
450

EJFTFT
NPEFSOF
.FEJVN
BN
CFTUFO
[VS
1SPNPUJPO
VOE

[VN
7FSLBVG
UPVSJTUJTDIFS
1SPEVLUF
CFOVU[U
PCXPIM
BVDI
EFS
*OUFSOFUTFJUF
EFS

,SPBUJTDIFO
5PVSJTUJTDIFO
0SHBOJTBUJPO
,50

IJOTJDIUMJDI
EFSFO
"OHFCPU
BO

NVMJUNFEJBMFO
VOE
JOUFSBLUJWFO
*OIBMUFO
XFOJH
BVT[VTFU[FO
JTU
NJU
EFOFO

EFS
/BUJPOBMUPVSJTNVT
HFGÕSEFSU
XJSE
XÅISFOE
EJF
4FJUF
EFS
5PVSJTUJTDIFO

0SHBOJTBUJPO
4FSCJFOT
BVDI
JO
EJFTFN
)JOCMJDL
BOEFSFO
0SHBOJTBUJPO
BVT
EFS

3FHJPO
IJOUFSIFSIJOLU
%JF
5BUTBDIF
EBTT
FT
JO
4FSCJFO
OVS
FJOFO
FJO[JHFO

 ͪͅΒͪ
͋͹ͯ͹ͻ͹ͬͳΕ

JOUFSBLUJWFO
4FSWJDF
HJCU
TDIFJOU
FJOF
QMBVTJCMF
&SLMÅSVOH
[V
IBCFO
EB

.FDIBOJTNFO
[VS
0OMJOF3FTFSWJFSVOH
VOE
#F[BIMVOH
SFDIUMJDI
JNNFS
OPDI

OJDIU
GFTUHFMFHU
TJOE
"OEFSFSTFJUT
TUFMMU
TJDI
IFSBVT
EBTT
TJDI
EJF
*OUFSOFULVMUVS

JO
VOTFSFN
-BOE
JNNFS
OPDI
BVG
FJOFS
TFIS
OJFESJHFO
&OUXJDLMVOTTUVGF
XFJU

IJOUFS
FJOJHFO
BOEFSFO
"OSBJOFSTUBBUFO
CFGJOEFU
*N
6OUFSTDIJFE
[V
4MPXFOJFO

VOE
,SPBUJFO
XFSEFO
JO
4FSCJFO
7PSUFJMF
EFS
#FOVU[VOH
EFT
*OUFSOFUTBOHFCPUFT

JNNFS
OPDI
OJDIU
JO
WPMMFN
6NGBOH
XBISHFOPNNFO

8FOO
NBO
EBT
3BOLJOH
EFS
ESFJ
BOBMZTJFSUFO
8FCTFJUFO
JN

;VTBNNFOIBOH
NJU
HFTFMMTDIBGUTXJSUTDIBGUMJDIFS
-BHF
EFS
KFXFJMJHFO
-ÅOEFS

WFSHMFJDIU
EFSFO
"OHFCPU
WPO
EFO
OBUJPOBMFO
UPVSJTUJTDIFO
0SHBOJTBUJPOFO

WPSHFTUFMMU
XJSE
MÅTTU
JDI
FJOF
HFXJTTF
1BSBMMFMF
[JFIFO
4FSCJFO
XBS
JOGPMHF
EFS

,SJFHTFSFJHOJTTF
JO
EFO
/FVO[JHFSO
KBISFMBOH
JTPMMJFSU
VOE
JTU
BVDI
IFVU[VUBHF

JN
QPMJUJTDIXJSUTDIBGUMJDIFO
4JOOF
[JFNMJDI
VOTUBCJM
XÅISFOE
,SPBUJFO
EJF

6NHFTUBMUVOH
EFT
4ZTUFNT
FUXBT
GSÛIFS
EVSDIMFCUF
XBT
EFN
-BOE
WJFM
TUBCJMFSF

XJSUTDIBGUMJDIF
6NTUÅOEF
HFXÅISMFJTUFUF
4MPXFOJFO
JTU
TDIPO
.JUHMJFE
EFS

&VSPQÅJTDIFO
6OJPO
NJU
EFS
TUBCJMTUFO
HFTFMMTDIBGUTXJSUTDIBGUMJDIFO
-BHF

8FOO
EJF
#FIBVQUVOH
EBT
*OUFSOFUNBSLFUJOH
TFJ
EJF
CJMMJHTUF
8FSCFGPSN

CFTUÅUJHU
XJSE
EB
XFMUXFJU
VOE
SVOE
VN
EJF
6IS
[VHÅOHMJDI
XFOO
EFS
WJSUVFMMF

5PVSJTNVT
BMT
;VLVOѫ EFT 5PVSJTNVT BOHFTFIFO XJSE NÛTTFO
BVDI
-ÅOEFS
JO

EFOFO
(FTFMMTDIBѫTVNTUÅOEF
OJDIU
CFTPOEFST
HÛOTUJH
TJOE
BO
EFS
(FTUBMUVOH

BUUSBLUJWFS
FMFLUSPOJTDIFS
3FJTFCSPTDIÛSFO
WFSTUÅSLU
BSCFJUFO



͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
͈
͉́͊͋́ͣ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
̸͊͆͌

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

̸͈͇͇͌̀̽͆͊͋
̸̸͈͇̽͋̓
ћ
̺͉͇̺́͋̾̓̾
̸̸̸͎̈́͆ͅ

͇
̸̻͇̺͌͊̈́́́͠͠

͆ͪͼͽ͹ΒͰΕͳ
ͯͪ
͹ͫͰͲͫͰͯͳ
ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͪ
Ͳͪ
ͳͲͯͻͱͪͬͪΔͰ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͫͻ͹Β͸Ͱ


ͺ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΁Ͱ
ͳͲͬͰͼ͸ͳ
̾͸ͭͶͰͲ
ͦ͹ͲͰͿ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ
+PTFQI
8IJUBLFS

ΒͰ
ͼͳ
ͼͽͰͷͪͽͳͲ͹ͬͪ͹
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
ͳͲ
ͼͬ͹Βͳ΀
͸͹ͬͳ͸ͪͻͼ͵ͳ΀
ͫͰͶͰͱ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͳ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ


͹ͫΒͪͬͳ͹
ͺͻͬͳ
ͭ͹ͯͳ΃Δͪ͵
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ͹ͷ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀

͇ͯ
ͽͪͯͪ
ͺͪ
ͯ͹
ͯͪ͸ͪͼ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͳ͸;͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

͹ͬͪΒ
ͭ͹ͯͳ
΃Δͪ͵
ΒͰ
΂ͪ͵
ͳ
;
ͻͪͽ͸ͳͷ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳͷͪ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪ͸
ͫͰͲ
ͺͻͰ͵ͳͯͪ
;
ͳͲͯͪ
Δ;
ͿͳͻͷͰ
+
8IJUBLFS
BOE
4POT
-5%
-POEPO
͈ͻͬͪ
ͭ͹ͯͳ΃ͽͪ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͪ
ͼ͵ͻ͹ͷ͸͹ͭ
͹ͫͳͷͪ
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
;ͫͻͲ͹
ͺ͹ͺͰͶͪ

͸ͪ
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͼͽ͹ͽͳ͸ͪ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͳ
;
ͯͻ;ͭ͹Β
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͯ͹ͼͰ
ͭͶͪ
͹ͫͳͷ
͹ͯ
͹͵͹

ͼͽͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
́͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
͸ͪΕͳ

ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵
;
͵͹ͷ
ͽͳͻͪͱ;
ΒͰ
̸Ͷͷͪ͸ͪ΀
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪ͸
ͪͶͳ
ΒͰ
͸Ͱͼ;ͷΔͳͬ͹
ͯͪ

ͼͰ
ͻͪͯͳ
͹
͹ͭͻ͹ͷ͸͹ͷ
ͫͻ͹Β;
ΒͰͻ
ͼͰ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪΒ;
ͽͻͳ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ
ͳ
ͽ͹
͵͹ͷͺͶͰͽ
͸͹
ͳͲͯͪΔͰ
ͺͶͪͽ͸Ͱ͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͬͰͲͪ
ͫͳͫͶͳ͹ͽͰ΂͵͹
ͳͲͯͪΔͰ
͵͹ͱ͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͬͰͲͪ
ͳ

ͼ͵ͻͪΕͰ͸͹
ͳͲͯͪΔͰ
͈ͻͬͪ
ͯͬͪ
ͳͷͪΒ;
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ͵
ͫͻ͹Β
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͪ
ͪ
ͽͻͰΕͳ
ΒͰ
;ͺ͹
Ͷͪ
ͷͪΔͳ
͇ͬͪΒ
̸Ͷͷͪ͸ͪ΀
͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸
ͼͪͷ͹
ͫͻͳͽͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
΂ͳͽͪͶͪ΂͵͹ͷ

͵ͻ;ͭ;
͸ͳͽͳ
ͼͪͷ͹
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͳͷͪ
Ͱ͸ͭͶͰͼ͵͹ͭ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͯͻ;΂Βͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͼͬͳͷͪ

͵͹Βͳ
ͽͻͪͭͪΒ;
Ͳͪ
͵ͻͪͽ͵͹ͷ
ͳ
ͺ͹;Ͳͯͪ͸͹ͷ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͳͲ
͸ͪΒͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳ
ͽͳΒͳ΀
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͪ
ͼͬͰͽͪ
;
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
͹ͬͳ
ͭ͹ͯͳ΃Δͪ΁ͳ
ͼͽͳͲͪͶͳ
͆ͪ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵;
ͼͬͪ͵Ͱ
͵ΔͳͭͰ
̸Ͷͷͪ͸ͪ΀ͪ
ͼ;

ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
ͽͰ͵;ΕͰͷ
͵ͪ
ͶͰ͸ͯͪͻ;
ͪͼͽͻ͹͸͹ͷͳΒͳ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸;
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͷͰͻͰΔ;
΀ͻ͹͸͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͳ

ͭͰ͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳͷ
Ͱͻͪͷͪ
 ͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
͈
͉ͳͼͽͳΕ

͊͵͹ͻ͹
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸;
̸Ͷͷͪ͸ͪ΀ͪ
Ͳͪ;ͲͳͷͪΒ;
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͳ
͹
̺ͰͶͳ͵͹Β
̹ͻͳ
ͽͪ͸ͳΒͳ
̓͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͼ;
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸Ͱ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹
̹ͻͳͽͪ͸ͳΒͳ
ͺ͹͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ
ͳ

ͶͰͽͳͷͳ΂ͪ͸
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
͋;
ͼ;
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͳ
͹
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͳ
͹
ͼͽͪ
͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ;
͹
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵͹Β
ͺ͹ͻ͹ͯͳ΁ͳ
ͺͰͻ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͫͪͻ͹͸ͳͷͪ
͹
ͬͶͪ
ͯͳ
ͳ
͈ͪͻͶͪͷͰ͸ͽ;
΂Ͷͪ͸͹ͬͳͷͪ
Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹ͭ
͈ͪͻͶͪͷͰ͸ͽͪ
͹
Ͷ͹͵ͪͶ͸͹Β
ͳ

ͻͰͭͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹Β
;ͺͻͪͬͳ
͹
̾͸ͭͶͰͼ͵͹Β
̺ͰͼͶ;
͑͵͹ͽͼ͵͹Β
ͳ
͊ͰͬͰͻ͸͹Β
́ͻ
ͼ͵͹Β
͹
Ͳͪ͵͹͸ͳͷͪ
͹
ͺ͹Ͷͳ΁ͳΒͳ
ͳ
Ͳͪͽͬ͹ͻͼ͵͹Β
ͼͶ;ͱͫͳ
͹
Ͳͯͻͪͬͼͽͬ;
͹

͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬͪΔ;
ͳ
ͻͰͶͳͭͳΒͳ
͹
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ;
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͳΒͳ
͹
͵͹͸ͲͰͻͬͪ΁ͳΒͳ
ͳ

ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͷ
͸ͪͼͶͰΌ;
Ϳͳ͸ͪ͸ͼͳΒͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͳͭͻͪͷͪ
͸ͪ
ͼͻͰΕ;
͹
ͳ͸ͽͰͶͰ͵ͽ;
ͪͶ͸͹ͷ
ͬͶͪͼ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ;
ͳ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͯͪΓͰ
͌
͸ͪ΃ͳͷ
ͫͳͫͶͳ͹ͽͰ͵ͪͷͪ
͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͰ
ͺͻͬͳ
ͫͻ͹ΒͰͬͳ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ͹ͭ

̸Ͷͷͪ͸ͪ΀ͪ
ͺͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
;ͽͬͻΌͰ͸͹
͵ͪͯͪ
;
ΔͰͷ;
ͺ͹΂ͳΔ;
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ΒͪͬΓ;Β;

ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
ͼͪ

ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶͰ
͹ͫ;΀ͬͪΕͰ͸Ͱ
͸ͪͲͳͬ͹ͷ

͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
̻͹ͯͳ΃ͽͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼ;
ͯ͹ͼͽ;ͺ͸ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͻͰͶͪͽͳͬ͸͹
͵͹͸ͽͳ͸;ͳͻͪ͸͹

ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͰ
͹ͫ;΀ͬͪͽͪΒ;
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
̽ͻ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
͋͹
ΒͰ

;
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ;
͸ͪ΃Ͱͭ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ
ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͪ
Βͪ΂ͪΔͪ
ͳ
ͻͪͼͺͪͯͪ

ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
ͲͰͷΓͰ

ͫͳͬ΃Ͱ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͼͬͻͼͽͪ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
;
ͯͰ͹
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
͸ͪΒͺͻͰ
͸ͪͲͳͬͪ͸
'PSFJHO

$PVOUSJFT
ͪ

͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
$PVOUSJFT
PG
UIF
8PSME
"
m
;

͋ͻͳ
ͼ;
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
͸ͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͺ͹ͯͰͶͳͽͳ
ͳͲͬͰ΃ͽͪΒͳ
͹
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪ
ͬͳΒͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
̽ͻ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͺͻͳ
΂Ͱͷ;
ͫͳ
͵ͻͳͽͰͻͳΒ;ͷͳ
ͫͳͶͳ

ͼͪͯͻͱͳ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͬͰͶͳ΂ͳ͸ͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
͵͹Βͳ
Β͹Β
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸
͈ͻͬͳ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ

ΒͰ
͹ͯ

ͯ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͊Ͷ;΂ͪΒ͸͹
ͳͶͳ
͸ͪͷͰͻ͸͹
͹ͯ
͹ͬͰ

ͭ͹
ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͳ
ͺ͹΂ͳΔ;
ͼͪͯͻͱͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;Β;
͹ͯ
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸ͳ΀

̓ͻͪΒ
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪ

ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵;
ͯͰͬͰͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͋ͻͰ
Εͳ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ
͹ͫ;΀ͬͪͽͪ
ͯͰͬͰͯͰͼͰͽͰ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
99
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽͪ͵
͸͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͷͳ
ͶͰ͸ͳΒ;ͷͪ


͈ͻͬͳ
ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͺͰͽ͹ͭ͹ͯͳ΃Δͳ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ
ͳͷͪ
ͽͪ΂ͪ͸
ͻͰͯ͹ͼͶͰͯ
ͳͲ
ͶͪͭͪΔͪ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
͆ͪΒͺͻͰ
ΒͰ
ͯͪͽ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸Ͱ
;ͺͻͪͬͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ͬͶͪ
ͯͰ
͍͉͍͉͆͊͠͠
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
͹ͯ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͪ͹
ͳ
ͼͺͳͼͪ͵
΂Ͷͪ͸͹ͬͪ

͏Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶ͸͹ͭ
͵͹ͷͳͽͰͽͪ
͊̓͠
ͪ
͹ͯ

ͳ
͈ͻͰͯͼͰͯ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
ͳ
́Ͳͬͻ΃͸͹ͭ

ͬͰΕͪ
͍͉͊͠
͊ͶͰͯͳ͹
ΒͰ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸ͳ
͵ͪͯͻ͹ͬͼ͵ͳ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬ
̸ͷͫͪͼͪͯͰ

͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
;
̈́͹͸ͯ͹͸;
͇ͬͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
ͼ;
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ͫͳͶͳ
ͯͻͪͭ͹΁Ͱ͸ͳ
Ͳͪ

ͼͬͰ
͹͸Ͱ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͳͲ
ͫͳͶ͹
͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͲͶ͹ͭͪ
ͳͷͪͶͳ
ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫ;
ͯͪ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳ΁ͳͻͪ
Β;
ͼͪ
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͪͷͫͪͼͪͯ͹ͷ
͊ͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹ͷ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ΂;
ͷ͹ͭ;
ͫͳ
ͽͳ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ͸Ͱ
͵ͪͯͻ͹ͬͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
͹ͯͻͪͱͪͬͪΒ;
ͺ͹΃ͽ͹
ͬͪΔͰ
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͳ
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ΂͵͹ͭ
͵Γ;΂ͪ
;
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
̓ͪͯͻ͹ͬͼ͵ͳ

 ͈͹;Ͳͯͪ͸͹ͼͽ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵ͪ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀
͹
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ 

ͼͪͼͽͪͬ
̸ͷͫͪͼͪͯͰ
̺ͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
̹ͻͳͽͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ

;
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ;
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
;ͬͰ͵
͸ͪ
͵ͻͪΒ;

ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ
͹
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
͈ͻͬͳ
ͷͪΔͳ
ͯͰ͹
͹ͯͬ͹ΒͰ͸
ͺ͹ͯ͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ΒͰ
͇ͫͶͪͼͽ
ͳ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ
΃ͽͬ͹
͌͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͰ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͳ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪͷͪ
;Ͳͪͼͽ͹ͺ͸͹
ͺ͹͸ͪͬΓͪ͸͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͠;
ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
΃Ͱͼͽ
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͯͬͰ
ͺ͹͵ͻͪΒͳ͸Ͱ
̽͹


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
΃Ͱͼͽͪ
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
͹Ͳ͸ͪ΂Ͱ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
tͯͰ͹
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹
͸ͳΒͰi
ͅ͸͹ͭ͹
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͺͪͱΔͰ
ͫͻͳͽͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻͳͻͰΌͳͬͪ΂
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰͽͳ͹
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ

ͬͪͱ͸͹ͷ
ͳ
ΒͰͯͳ͸͹ͷ
ͯ;ͭ͹
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
͵͹͸ͪ΂͸͹
͸ͰͻͰ΃Ͱ͸͹ͷ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͪͶ
͸͹ͷ
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
ͺͳͽͪΔ;
͋ͻͼͽͪ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
;ͺ͹ͻ͸͹
ͺ͹͸ͪͬΓͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹
ͻͳΒͪ
ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹
͹ͯ
ͽͲͬ
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵Ͱ
Ͷͳ͸ͳΒͰ
;
́ͼͽͻͳ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸͹
ͼͪ
͹ͼͽͻͬ͹ͷ

͈ͪͶͪͭͻ;ͱ͹ͷ
ͳ
͹͵͹Ͷ͸ͳͷ
͹ͼͽͻͬͳͷͪ
;ͼͽ;ͺΓͰ͸ͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ

ͯͪ

ΒͰ
Ͳ͹͸ͪ
#
ͽͻ΃Εͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
ͺͻͳͺ͹ΒͰ͸ͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
͸ͪ
ͪͯͷͳ͸ͳ
ͼͽͻͪͽͳͬ͸͹
;ͺͻͪͬΓͪΔͰ

ͽͰ
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͪΒͲͪͯ
ͽͰ͵
͹ͯ

;ͺͳͼͪͶ͹

ͳ
ͽ͹
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͇ͼͳͷͼ͵ͳͷ
ͼͺ͹ͻͪͲ;ͷ͹ͷ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;΂Ͱ͸ͳͷ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
́ͽͪ
ͶͳΒͪ
ͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
ͼͪͭͶͪͼͳͶͰ
͹͵͹
ͼ;ͯͫͳ͸Ͱ
ͽͰ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
͋ͪΒ
ΒͰͯͬͪ

͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
ͷͪͶ͹
ͷͰΔͪ͸
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ
ͺ͹͸ͪͬΓͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵ͪ
ͺͰͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ

ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͌Ͳ
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͹ͯ

ͺͪ
ͯ͹

΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͪ
ͼ͵ͻ͹ͷ͸ͪ

͵ͪͻͽͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͼͶͳ΂͸Ͱ
ͼ;
;͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͷ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸Ͱ
ͳ
Ͳͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͯͻͱͪ
ͬͰ

;
͹͵ͬͳͻ;
΂ͳΒͳ΀
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
́ͼͽͻͪ
͋Ͱ͵
͹ͯ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
́ͼͽͻͪ

ΒͰ
ͳ
͸ͪ
͵ͪͻͽͳ
;
ͼͪͼͽͪͬ;
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
 ͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
͈
͉ͳͼͽͳΕ

͆Ͱͷͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹ͭ
Ͷ͹ͭͳ΂͸͹ͭ
͹ͫΒͪ΃ΔͰΔͪ
Ͳͪ΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
͹ͯ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵ͪ

ͺͰ
ͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͺͪ
ͯ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸ͳͷ
ͺͪͼ;ͼ͹ͷ
ͼ͵ͻͰΕͰ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
͸ͪ
ͽ͹

ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͏ͻ͸ͪ
̻͹ͻͪ
;ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳͶͪ
ͼͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
ͼ͵;ͺ΃ͽͳ͸Ͱ
͹ͯͻͱͪ͸Ͱ
;

͈͹ͯͭ͹ͻͳ΁ͳ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͇
ͺͻͳͼͪΒͰͯͳΔͰΔ;
͹ͼͽͪͶͳ΀
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
;

̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸;
͎͊͊
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
ͼͰ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
͆ͪ
͵ͻͪΒ;
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
͹
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
ͳ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ;
;ͺ͹ͻ͸͹
ͼͰ

ͯ͹

ͺ͹͸ͪͬΓͪ
ͳͼͽͪ
ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸ͳ΁ͪ
t̓ͪ͹
ͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͪͽ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͫͻ͹Β
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ
͵ͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ΒͰ
͹ͺͪ͹
Ͳͪ
ͫͶͳͲ;

ͳ
ͽͪΒ
ͭ;ͫͳͽͪ͵
ΒͰ
ͽͰ͵
͸Ͱͯͪͬ͸͹

͸ͪͯ͹͵͸ͪΌͰ͸i
̽͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͻ͹Β
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ

ͺͻͰ΃ͪ͹
 
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
͵͹͸ͼͽͪͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
ͺͻͳͻ͹ͯͪ͸
ͺͻͳ
ͻͪ΃ͽͪΒ
ͯͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
ͻͪͽͪ
;΂ͳ͸ͳ͹
ͯͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
ͫͻ͹Βͳ
ͫͪ΃
ͽ͹Ͷͳ͵͹

ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͪͯͪͅ
͸Ͱͷͪ
͹ͯͬ͹ΒͰ͸͹ͭ
ͯͰͶͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͫͳ
͸͹ͼͳ͹
͸ͪͲͳͬ
́ͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
ͺ͹
ͭͶͪͬΓͰ
͌ͺͻͪͬͪ
ͯ;ͭ͹
ͼͪͯͻͱͳ
͹ͼͬͻͽ
;
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽ
ͯ͹
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽͪ͵ͪ
ͼͽͬͪͻͪ
Δͪ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸Ͱ
͊ͻͫͪ
͎ͻͬͪͽͪ
ͳ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͪ΁ͪ
͇
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
ͺͻͰ
99

ͬͰ͵ͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ
͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
ͪ
΃ͽ;ͻ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽ͹
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͹ͼͽͪͶͰ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹
ͻͳΒͰ
ͫͰͲ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͰ
͏ͻ͸Ͱ
̻͹ͻͰ

;ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳͶͰ
ͼͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒ͹ͷ
͆ͪͬ͹ΌͰ͸Ͱ
ͼ;

ͺͻͰͶ͹ͷ͸Ͱ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;
ͽͻͪΒͪΔ;
ͷͰΌ;ͻͪͽ͸Ͱ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ






ͳ
ͺͪͻ
ͯͪͽ;ͷͪ
ͳͲ
ͻͪͽ͸͹ͭ
ͬͻͽͶ͹ͭͪ
̽ͻ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ
͸ͳ΀
Ͳͪ
ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͰ
͸͹ͬͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒ;
͉ͰͶͪͽͳͬ͸͹
͵͹ͻͰ͵ͽ͸͹
ͳ
ͪͱ;ͻ͸͹

ͺͻͪͽͰ
ͼͰ
;ͼͽͪͬ͸Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ
ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͪ
͸͹ͬͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ

ͺͻͰ͵͹





ͳ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̀ͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
ͯͪ

͹ͯ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ
ͯͰ͹
͵͹Βͳ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͹
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
ͺͻͰ
͸͹
ͬͰͷͫͻͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
̓ͪ͹
ͯͪ
ͽͪΒ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͹ͽͬ͹ͻ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͸ͳΒͰ

ͫͳ͹
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬ
͸ͳ
ͺͻͳͻͰΌͳͬͪ΂;
͸ͳ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁;
͈͹ͻͰΌͰΔͪ
ͻͪͯͳ
ͬͻͰͯͳ

ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
͹
̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵͹Β
Β͹΃
ͯ;ͭ͹
͹ͫΒͪ΃ΔͪͬͪΒ;




̽Ͱ͹
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ͹ͷ
̺Ͱͻͪ
ͳ
͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬͪΔͰ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͺͳͼͳͬͪ͸
ͳͲ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

;
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸;
̀ͪ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹Ͱͬͻ͹ͺͼ͵͹ͭ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ͵ͪ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ͹ͭ
̸Ͷͷͪ͸ͪ΀ͪ

ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬͪ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͯͪ
ͬͰͻ͹͸ͪ;͵ͪ
;
΃͵͹Ͷͪͷͪ

͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͯ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
͹ͫͪͬͰͲͪ͸
ͬͰΕ
ͳͲͫ͹ͻ͸ͳ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͷͰͽ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͯ
Βͪ͸;ͪͻͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͲͪͫͻͪΔͰ͸͹
ͺͻͰͯͪͬͪΔͰ
ͬͰͻ͹͸ͪ;͵Ͱ

;
΃͵͹Ͷͪͷͪ
ͽͰ
ͯ͹Ͳͬ͹ΓͰ͸͹
ͼͪͷ͹
;
΁ͻ͵ͬͪͷͪ
̽ͻͱͪͬͪ
ͺͻͳͲ͸ͪΒͰ
ͯͪΓͰ
ͼͰ

͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬ͸;
͵ͪͽ͹Ͷͳ΂͵;
ͺͻ͹ͽͰͼͽͪ͸ͽͼ͵;
ͳͼͶͪͷͼ͵;
ͳ
ΒͰͬͻͰΒ
ͼ͵;
ͬͰͻ;
͈ͻ͹΁Ͱ͸ͪͽ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳͷ
ͻͰͶͳͭͳΒͪͷͪ
;
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪ
ͬͳΒͳ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͺ͹ͺͳͼ;
ͳͲ

͹ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪ͸
ͼͬͰ
ͯ͹

͵ͪͯͪ
ͼ;
͹ͫΒͪ
ͬΓͰ͸ͳ
ͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͪͽͳ
ͺ͹ͺͳͼͪ
ͳͲ

ͪͶͳ
;
ͪͺͼ͹Ͷ;ͽ͸ͳͷ
ͫͻ͹ΒͰͬͳͷͪ
̀͸ͪ
΂ͪΒ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
͵͹͸ͼͽͪͽͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳ΀
΂ͰͽͻͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͯ;ͭͳ
͸ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͺ͹͸ͪͬΓͪ
t͈ͻ;ͱͪΒ;Εͳ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ
͏Ͱ͸ͽͻͪͶ͸Ͱ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
ͯ͹
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ

 ͈͹;Ͳͯͪ͸͹ͼͽ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵ͪ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀
͹
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ 

ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͰ
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͰ
ͺ͹ͯ
ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽͳͷ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ
ͬͰͻͼ͵ͳͷ

͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸ͳͷ
ͳ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͷ
;ͽͳ΁ͪΒͳͷͪi
͋͹
ΒͰ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͳͶ͹
m
ͯͪΓͰ
ΒͰ
͹ͫΒͪ
΃ΔͰ͸͹
m
ͯͪ
ͼ;
͊ͻͫͳ
ͺͻͳͷͳͶͳ
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬΓͰ
ͺͪ
ͺ͹ͽ͹ͷ
ͺͰͽ
ͼͽ͹ͽͳ͸ͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͫͳͶͳ
ͺ͹ͯ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵͹ͷ
ͬͶͪ΃Ε;
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;
̹͹ͼ͸ͳ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ
ͫͻ͹Β
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ
͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͯ
ͺͻͳͼͳͶ͹ͷ
ͺͻͳͷͳ͹
ͳͼͶͪͷ
ͪ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͪ
ͳ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͪ

ͫͳͶͰ
ͺ͹ͯ
;ͽͳ΁ͪΒͰͷ
͵ͪͽ͹Ͷͳ΂͵Ͱ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ
͋͹
ͼ;
Ϳͪ͵ͽ͹ͻͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
;ͺͻ͵͹ͼ

tͻͪͼ͸͹ͷ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬ;i
͹ͷͰͽͪͶͳ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱͼ
ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͪ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ

͊ͬͰ
ͯ͹
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵ͪ
͹ͼͪͷͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
͹ͫͶͪͼͽ
͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͺ;Δͪͬͪ͸ͪ
ͯͰ
ͽͪΓ͸ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
͹
ͫͻ͹Β;
Όͪ͵ͪ
ͳ
͸ͪͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
ͼͻͰͯΔͳ΀

΃͵͹Ͷͪ
;͸ͳͬͰͻͲͳͽͰͽͪ
ͳ
Ϳͪ͵;ͶͽͰͽͪ
͑ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͽͳ΂Ͱ
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ
͵͹Βͳͷ
ͼͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳͶ͹
;
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱ
ͻ͹ͬ
̸Ͷͷͪ͸ͪ΀
͹ͫͪͬͰ΃ͽͪͬͪ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁Ͱ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
tΒͰͲͳ΁ͳ
;
ͲͰͷΓͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻ
ͬͪͽͼ͵ͳ
ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͪ΂͵ͳ
ͳ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͼͬͪ
ͽͻͳ
Β;ͱ͸͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵ͪi
ͼ
ͽͳͷ

΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͳ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳ
;
ͿͰͯͰͻͪͶ͸͹Β
;ͺͻͪͬͳ
͌
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ

͏ͻ͸͹Β
̻͹ͻͳ
ͳ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳ
ͼͰ
ΕͳͻͳͶͳ΁ͪ
ͪ
;
͹ͼͽͪͽ͵;
ͯͻͱͪ
ͬͰ
m
Ͷͪͽͳ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͅͰΌ;
ΒͰͲͳ΁ͳͷͪ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔ;
ͼͰ
ͷͪΌͪͻͼ͵ͳ

ͻ;ͷ;͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͳ
ͪͶͫͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͳͽͪͶͳΒͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
ͪ
͹ͯ

ͼͶ͹ͬͪ΂͵ͳ
ͳ
ͻ;
ͼͳ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͇ͯ

ͺͻͳͯͻ;ͱͳΕͰ
ͳͷ
ͼͰ
ͳ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵ͳ
̀ͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;
͹ͯ
ͬͰΕͳ͸Ͱ

ͯ͹ͫͻͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͺͪ
ͳ
ͷͪΔͰ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳ΀
ͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͹
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
΁Ͱ
Ͷ͹͵;ͺ͸ͪ
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵ͪ
͵ΔͳͱͰͬ͸͹ͼͽ
ΒͰ
;
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ͹ͷ
̸Ͷͷͪ͸ͪ΀;

͹ͼ;ΌͰ͸ͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
͸ͪ
ΒͰͯ͸;
ͼͽͪͶ͸͹
ͺ͹͸ͪͬΓͪ͸;
ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸ͳ΁;
ͫͰͲ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
ͳ

ͼͷͳͼͶͪ
t̿ͰΓͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬ͹ͷ
͠;ͱ͸ͳ΀
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͬͰ
Ͷͪ
ͯ͹
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬͪ
ͳ
͹ͱͳͬΓͪͬͪΔͪ
ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͰi

͇ͫͶͪͼͽ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
͸Ͱ
͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
ͺ͹ͽͺ;͸͹
ͺͻͪͲ͸ͪ
Ͳͪ΀ͬͪΓ;Β;Εͳ
͸ͪͫͻͪΒͪΔ;

͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͯ͸Ͱͬ͸ͳ΀
Ͷͳͼͽ͹ͬͪ
ͳͲͶͪͲͳ
;
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͳͷ
ͳ
͸Ͱ͵ͳͷ
ͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͳͷ
ͭͻͪ
ͯ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ
͆Ͱ
΂ͳ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸Ͱ
ͽͰ΃͵͹ΕͰ
ͪͶͳ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ
͸Ͱͯ͹
ͼͶͰͯ͸͹ͼͽ
;
ͺͳͼͪΔ;
ͺͻͰͲͳͷͰ͸ͪ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
Ͷͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
Β;ͭ͹
ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͰͼͽͪͫͶͳ΃ͷͰ͸ͽͪ
͈ͻͳͻͰΌͳͬͪ΂
ͼͰ
͹΂ͳͭͶͰͯ͸͹

ͯͬ͹;ͷͳ͹
͵ͪͯͪ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫͳͽͳ
ǁ
ͪ
͵ͪͯͪ
ǀ
ͺ͹͸Ͱ͵ͪͯ
ΒͰ
UDI
ͪͶͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹

΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
ǀ
ͳͶͳ
D

͵ͪͯͪ
[
ͪ
͵ͪͯͪ
ß
΃ͽ͹
ͳͺͪ͵
͸Ͱ
ͼͽͬͪͻͪ
͸ͳ͵ͪ͵ͬͰ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸Ͱ

ͺͻ͹ͫͶͰͷͰ
͊ͪͷ͹
ΒͰ
ͺͪͻ
ͺ͹͵;΃ͪΒͪ
tͺͻͳͶͪͭ͹ΌͪͬͪΔͪi
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹ͷ
͸ͪ΂ͳ
͸;
ͺͳͼͪΔͪ
4
,SBJHIFS
ͳ
͸Ͱ΃ͽ͹
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
3J[B
4BQVOYIJV
ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ

ͭͻͰ΃͵Ͱ
ͭͯͰ
ΒͰ
4MBWPOJB
;ͷͰͼͽ͹
4MPWFOJKB


3JFKLB


ͳͶͳ
3JKB
LB


;ͷͰͼͽ͹
͉ͳΒͰ͵ͪ
ͪ
̓͹ͽ͹ͻ
m
$BSSBSP
;ͷͰͼͽ͹
$BUUBSP
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͰ
͸ͪ

ͺ͹ͷͳͼͪ͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͻͰΌͳͬͪ΂;
ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ
ͼͶͪͫͪ
ͼͽͻͪ͸ͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͽ͹ͺ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ

̓ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
ΕͰ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹Βͪͬͳͽͳ
ͭͻͰ΃͵Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
Ͳͫ;Δ;Β;
͵ͪͯͪ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͳͷͰ

͆Ͱͫ͹Β΃ͪ
ͺͻͰͽͬ͹ͻͰ
;
#FCPKTB
 ͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
͈
͉ͳͼͽͳΕ

͌
ͺ͹ͻͰΌͰΔ;
ͼͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͯͰͶ͹ͬͳͷͪ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ
͹
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
;
̺ͳͽͰ
͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀;
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
ͯ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
͹
ͺͻ͹
ͳͲͬ͹ͯΔͳ
ͳ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͳ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸
ͯ͹ͬ͹Γͪ͸
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
͈ͻͪͽͳ
ͼͰ
ͺͻ
ͬͰ͸ͼͽͬͰ͸͹
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ
ͺ͹Γ͹ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͰ
ͳ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͰ
;
;͵;ͺ͸͹Β
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸͹Β

ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͳ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
ͬͶͪͼ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
̽ͰͽͪΓ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͳ
ͻͰͶͪͽͳͬ͸͹
ͻͰͯ͹ͬ
͸͹
ͪͱ;ͻͳͻͪ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
͵͹Ͷͳ΂ͳ͸ͳ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬͰͯͰ͸Ͱ
ͺ΃Ͱ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͵;͵;ͻ;Ͳͪ

ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
ͱͳͽͪͻͳ΁ͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͰ΂Ͱ͸Ͱ
ͯͻͬͰ͸Ͱ
ͭͻͪΌͰ
͈ͪͱΓͳͬ͹
ΒͰ
ͺͻͪΕͰ͸

ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
;ͲͭͪΒͪΔͪ
͵ͻ;ͺ͸Ͱ
ͼͽ͹͵Ͱ
͹ͬͪ΁ͪ
ͼͬͳΔͪ
ͳ
ͱͳͬͳ͸Ͱ
́
ͻ;ͯͪͻͼͽͬ͹

͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ΒͰ

ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸͹
ͫͻ͹ΒͰͬͳͷͪ
͹
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯΔͳ
;ͭΓͪ
͵͹͵ͼͪ

ͭͬ͹ͱΌͪ
΂ͰͶͳ͵ͪ
ͪͶ;ͷͳ͸ͳΒ;ͷͪ
΁ͳ͸͵ͪ
͸ͪͿͽͰ
͉ͰͺͰͻ
Ͳͪ
ͻͪͼͽ
ͺͻ͹ͳͲ
ͬ͹ͯΔͰ
ͼͽͪͶ͸͹
ΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͺ͹ͬͰΕͪ͸ͪ

ͼͰͯͪͷ
ͺ;ͽͪ



ͪͯͪͅ
ΒͰ
ͷͪͶͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͺ;ͽͰͬͳ
ͺͻ;
ͭͰ
ͺͶ͹ͬ͸ͳ
ͺ;ͽͰͬͳ
ͽͰͶͰͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͽͰͶͰͿ͹͸ͼ͵ͪ
ͷͻͰͱͪ

Βͪͼ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ

ͽ͹
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͪ
͹ͫͶͪͼͽ
;
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔ;
ͳ
ͻͰͯͪ͵΁ͳΒͰ
ͳ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁ͪ
̀ͪ͸Ͱͷͪͻ
Γͳͬͪ
ΒͰ
ͭͻͰ΃͵ͪ
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽͪ͵
ͻͪͽͪ
ͳ
Ͳͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒ;
ͼͷͰ΃ͽͪ
;


ͺͪ
ͼͰ
ͽͬͻͯͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͫͪͻ
ͯͰ͹
ͺ;ͽ͸Ͱ
ͷͻͰͱͰ
;͸ͳ΃ͽͰ͸
;
ͻͪͽ;
͹ͯ

ͯ͹


ͽͰ
ͼͰ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͫͻ͹Β͵Ͱ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͺͻͪͽͳͽͳ
ΔͰ͸͹
͹ͫ͸ͪͬΓͪΔͰ
ͳ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β

͈ͻͳͻͰΌͳͬͪ΂ͳ
͸ͳͼ;
ͺͻ͹ͺ;ͼͽͳͶͳ
ͯͪ
͸ͪͫͻ͹ΒͰ
ͼͬͰ
ͬͰΕͰ
Ͷ;͵Ͱ
͸ͪ
Βͪͯͻͪ͸
ͼ͵͹Β
͹ͫͪͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;
͹͸Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͰ
;
ͳͲͭͻͪͯΔͳ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͯͪ
;͵ͪͱ;

͸ͪ
ͽ͹
ͯͪ
t̽;͸ͪͬ
΂ͳ͸ͳ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ
ͽͻͭ͹ͬͪ΂͵ͳ
ͺ;ͽi
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͷ;
ͺͻͳͽ͹͵Ͱ
͊ͪͬͪ

ͳ
͋ͳͼͪ
ͯ͹͸Ͱ͵ͶͰ
ͺͶ͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͽͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
tͶ;͵ͪ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
͸ͪ
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͷ
ͷͰͼͽ;
ͺ͹

ͺͻ͹ͷͰͽ;
͸ͪ
̽;͸ͪͬ;i
͍ͳ͸ͪ͸ͼͳΒͰ
ͺͻͳͬͶͪ΂Ͱ
ͺͪͱΔ;
;
͹͸͹Β
ͷͰͻͳ
;
͵͹Β͹Β
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͻͰΌͳͬͪ΂

ͳͷͪ͹
͸ͪͷͰͻ;
ͯͪ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͱͰ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳ
ͫ;ΘͰͽ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͽͻͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͼ͵;

ͻͪͲͷͰ͸;
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
̺ͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
̹ͻͳͽͪ͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
́
ͳͲͬ͹Ͳ
ͳ
;ͬ͹Ͳ
ͼ;

͵͹͸ͼͽͪ͸ͽ͸͹
ͻͪͼͶͳ
ͪͶͳ
;ͺͪͯΓͳͬ͹
͸ͪ
΃ͽͰͽ;
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ΒͰͻ
ͼͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ
͵ͪ
;
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳͲͬ͹Ͳͪ
;
̺
̹ͻͳͽͪ͸ͳΒ;
ͳ
;ͬ͹Ͳͪ
ͳͲ
ΔͰ
ͼͽͪͶ͸͹
ͺ͹ͬͰΕͪͬͪ
Ͷͪ
ͯͪ
ͫͳ
ͯ͹ͼͽͳͭͶͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ
͹ͯ
ͼ͵͹ͻ͹


 
;
͵͹ͻͳͼͽ
̺ͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
̹ͻͳͽͪ͸ͳΒͰ
͊͵͹ͻ͹
ͯͪ
͸Ͱͷͪ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
;
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͳͷͪ
͹
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪ
ͬͳΒͳ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ͹ͭ
̸Ͷͷͪ͸ͪ΀ͪ
ͯ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͈͹ͻͰͯ
͵ͻͪΒΔͰ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯ͸͹
ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͰ
͵ͪͻͽͰ
;
͵͹Β͹Β
͸Ͱͷͪ
;͸;ͽͻͪ΃Δͳ΀
ͷͰΌ;ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ΂
͵ͳ΀
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͬͻͰͯͳ
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
ͼͽͪͽͳͼͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
͹
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ;

ͺ͹Γ͹ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͳ
ͳ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͳ
͌
ͼͺͳͼ͵;
ͬͰΕͳ΀
ͭͻͪͯ͹ͬͪ
;Ͳ
΂ͳΒͰ
ͳͷͰ
ΒͰ

͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸
ͳ
ͫͻ͹Β
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͼͪͷ͹
ΒͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
ͲͪͼͶ;ͱͳͬͪ͹
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹

ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͹ͺͳͼͪ
ͳ
ͽ͹
ͼͪͷ͹
ͯ͹
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵ͪ
΃ͰͲͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
͆ͪ
͵ͻͪΒ;
͵ͪ͹
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳ
ͼͳͷͫ͹Ͷͳ
ͺ͹ͷͳΔͪ͸ͳ
ͼ;
Ͳͪͼͽͪͬͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹͸Ͱ
͵ͪͯ
΀ͳͷ͸ͪ
͇ͯ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻͪͲ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͲͪͫͰͶͰͱͰ͸ͳ
ͼ;

͵ͻͪΒͰͷ
΂ͰͽͻͯͰ
ͼͰͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
̺ͳͯ͹ͬͯͪ͸
,PTTPWP
%BZ

ͳ
̽ͪ͸
;ΒͰͯͳΔͰΔͪ

ͯͰ΁Ͱͷ
ͫͪͻ

ͪ
͹ͯ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵ͪ
ͺͰͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
ͼͪͷ͹
̽ͪ͸
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
 ͈͹;Ͳͯͪ͸͹ͼͽ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵ͪ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀
͹
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ 

͊ͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͼͰ
;ͽͳͼͪ͵
ͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͹ͺͪͯͪ
ͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͪ

͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒ;
͋Ͱ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͳ
ͼ;
͵ͻͪΕͳ
;
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ;
͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
ͼͪ

ͷͪΔͰ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
͈͹΂ͳΔ;
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
ͯ͹ͫͳΒͰ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͺͳͼ͹ͷ

ͳͲ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͪ
͹ͯ

ͺͻͬͳ
ͺ;ͽ
ͼͰ
;
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀;

͵ͪͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
͹
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͷ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬ;
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
;ͺ͹ͽͻͰͫΓͪͬͪ

ͻͰ΂
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͳ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯ
Ͳ͸ͪ΁ͳͷͪ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͪ
͊ͬͰ
ͯ͹
͵ͻͪΒͪ
͹ͼͪͷͯͰͼͰ
ͽͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
͸ͪͬ͹ΌͰ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
ͼͪͼͽ͹Βͳ
͹ͯ
΃Ͱͼͽ
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶͳ
ͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ
ͳ
ͯͬͰ
ͺ͹͵ͻͪΒͳ͸Ͱ
ͪͶͳ
͸ͪ
͵ͪͻͽͳ
͸ͳͼ;
;΁ͻͽͪͬͪ͸Ͱ

;͸;ͽͻͪ΃ΔͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ΂͵Ͱ

ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͆ͪ
͵ͪͻͽͪͷͪ
ͼ;
ͳͼͺͳͼͳͬͪ͸ͳ

͸ͪͲͳͬͳ
ͼ;ͼͰͯ͸ͳ΀
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
ͪͶͳ
Δͳ΀͹ͬͪ
ͳͷͰ͸ͪ
͸ͳͼ;
͸ͪͬ͹ΌͰ͸ͪ
;
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;

΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
;
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ;
̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͻͰͯ͹ͬ͸͹
΂ͳΔͰ͸͹
͊ͬͳ
͹͸ͳ
ͺ͹
ͯͪ΁ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
ͻͪ͸ͳΒͰ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͳ
ͪ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͳͶͳ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
͠;
ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰ
̽ͻ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ

ͳͲ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͪ͸ͳ
͋ͪ

ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵ͪ
͵͹ͷͺ͹͸Ͱ͸ͽͪ
;
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵͹Β
ͺͻͳ΂ͳ
ΒͰ
;ͷͪΔͰ͸ͪ
ͳ
ͳͲ͹ͼͽͪ
ͬΓͪΔͰͷ
͹ͼͬͻͽͪ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͳͺͪΒͪΔͰ
Ͳ͹͸Ͱ
̺
́Ͳ
ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽͳ
͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
Β͹΃
ͼͪ
ͷ͹
͸ͪͫͻͪΒͪΔͰ
;ͼͽͪͬͪ
ͳ
;ͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
ͳͲ

͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
ͺͻ͹
ͭͶͪ΃Ͱ͸ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵;


ͺͻ͹ͷͰ͸ͪ
ͼͶ;ͱͫͰ͸͹ͭ
͸ͪͲͳͬͪ
;
͍͉͊͠



;ͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ
ͪͷͪ͸ͯͷͪ͸ͳ
m
;
̸Ͷͷͪ͸ͪ΀;
ͼͰ
ͼͷͪͽͻͪ
͸ͪΒͬͪͱ͸ͳΒͳͷ
͹͸ͪΒ

͵͹Βͳͷ
ΒͰ
;ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬΓͰ͸͹
͈ͻͰͯͼͰͯ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ͹
͍͉͊͠
m
tOFX
SVMJOH
CPEZi

ͳ


ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
t͇ͯͶ;͵Ͱ
͹
ͷ͸͹ͭͳͷ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͳ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺͳͽͪ
Δͳͷͪ
ͼ;
ͼͪ
ͿͰͯͰͻͪͶ͸͹ͭ
ͺͻͰ͸ͰͽͰ
EFWPMWFE

͸ͪ
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ΂͵ͳͺ͹͵ͻͪΒͳ͸
ͼ͵ͳ
͸ͳͬ͹i
͋Ͱ͵
͹ͯ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;
͹ͬ͹ͷ
̸Ͷͷͪ͸ͪ΀;
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͰ
ͼͪͲ͸ͪͽͳ
ͯͪ

ΒͰ
͊̓͠
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͪ
ͺͪͻͽͳΒͪ
;
ͲͰͷΓͳ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳ͹͸͹
ͺ͹ͯͰΓͰ͸ͪ
ͺ͹

ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ
͇ͫͪͬͰ΃ͽͰΔͪ
͹
͹ͯͫͻͪ͸ͳ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͼ;
ͼͬͰͯͰ͸ͪ
͸ͪ
ΒͰͯ͸;
ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸ͳ΁;
͹

ͫͻ͹Β;
͹Ϳͳ΁ͳͻͪ
ͳ
ͬ͹Β͸ͳ͵ͪ
́
ͯͰ͹
͹
ͻͰͶͳͭͳΒͳ
ͳ
͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬͪΔ;
ΒͰ
ͼͬͰͯͰ͸

͸ͪ
͸ͪΒͷͪΔ;
ͷͰͻ;
͋͹
ΒͰ
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͽͳ΂Ͱ
΁ͻ͵ͬͰ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͳͶ͹
ͯͪ
ͼ;
tͽͻͳ
ͭͶͪͬ
͸Ͱ
ͻͰͶͳͭͳΒͰ
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬ͸ͪ
͵ͪͽ͹Ͷͳ΂͵ͪ
ͳ
ͷ;ͼͶͳͷͪ͸ͼ͵ͪi
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
΁ͻ͵ͬͪ

͹ͯͬ͹ΒͰ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
ͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͬͰͻͼ͵ͪ
͸ͪͼͽͪͬͪ
;
΃͵͹Ͷͪͷͪ
ͲͪͫͻͪΔͰ͸ͪ
Β͹΃

Βͪ͸;ͪͻͪ

ͪͶͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͯ͹Ͳͬ͹ΓͰ͸ͪ
;
΁ͻ͵ͬͪͷͪ
͇ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ

͸Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ
ͺͪͱΓͳͬ͹
ͫͰͶͰͱͳͶ͹
͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͳͷͪ
΃͵͹Ͷͪ
Όͪ͵ͪ
ͳ
͸ͪͼͽͪͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ

ͯ͹ͫͳͶ͹
ΒͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
͵͹͸ͼͽͪͽͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸͹
ͫͰͼͺͶͪͽ͸͹
ͳ
ͯͪ
;
ͯͻͱͪͬͳ

ͺ͹ͼͽ͹Βͳ

;͸ͳͬͰͻͲͳͽͰͽͪ
̀ͪ
ͻͰͯͪ͵΁ͳΒ;
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ͹ͭ
̸Ͷͷͪ͸ͪ΀ͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ͫͳͶ͹
ͳ͸ͽͰ
ͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ͸͹
ͯͪ
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͳ
ΒͰͲͳ͵
͹͸ͪΒ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
;ͭͶͪͬ
͸͹ͷ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͳ
;
ͯͻͱͪͬͳ
ͪͶͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͰ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ
ΒͰͲͳ΁ͳ
ͺͻͳ
΂Ͱͷ;

ͼͰ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͰ
ΒͰͲͳ΁ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͪ΂͵ͳ
ͳ
ͷͪ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ

ͳ
ͼͰͯͪͷ

͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
t͆Ͱͷͪ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͼͶ;ͱͫͰ͸͹ͭ
ΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ
ΒͰͻ
ͼ;
ͼͬͳ
ͺ͹
;ͼͽͪ
ͬ;
ͻͪͬ͸͹ͺͻͪͬ͸ͳ
͹ͼͳͷ
;
ͪͻͷͳΒͳ
ͭͯͰ
ΒͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͳ
͹ͫͪͬͰͲͪ͸i

 ͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
͈
͉ͳͼͽͳΕ

̻ͻ;ͫ͹
ΒͰ
͹΁ͰΔͰ͸͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ
ͳ
͏ͻ͸͹Β
̻͹ͻͳ
ͺͳ΃Ͱ

ΕͳͻͳͶͳ΁͹ͷ
ͪ
;
͹ͼͽͪͶ͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
Ͷͪͽͳ͸ͳ΁͹ͷ
͉Ͱ΂Ͱ͸ͳ΁ͪ
t̿ͰΓͪ

Ͳͪ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬ͹ͷ
͠;ͱ͸ͳ΀
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͬͰͶͪ
ͯ͹
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻ͸͹ͭ

ΒͰͯͳ͸ͼͽͬͪ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ͹ͯͪ
ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͰi
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯ
Δͳ
ͺ;ͽ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͌
ͺ͹ͻͰΌͰΔ;
ͼͪ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳͷ
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳͷͪ
ͯͰ͹
͹
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͳ
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͫͳ͹

Ͳͪͯ͹ͬ͹ΓͪͬͪΒ;Εͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
͈ͻͪΕͰ͸
ΒͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ
ͳ͸ͯ;ͼͽͻͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹Γ͹ͺͻͳ
ͬͻͰͯͰ
;
͸ͪ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶ͸͹ͷ
ͯ͹΀͹ͽ͵;
ͻͰͯ͹ͬ͸͹
ͼ;

ͪͱ;ͻͳͻͪ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
ͭ͹
ͯͳ΃Δͳͷ
ͺͻͳ͸͹ͼͳͷͪ
ͱͳͽͪͻͳ΁ͪ
΃ͰΕͰͻ͸Ͱ
ͻͰͺͰ
ͳ
ͼ͹ΒͰ
ͳ
ͫͻ͹Β;
͵ͻ;ͺ͸Ͱ

ͳ
ͼͳͽ͸Ͱ
ͼͽ͹͵Ͱ
͉;ͯͪͻͼͽͬ;
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕͰ͸ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸ͪ
ͺͪͱΔͪ
͹͸͹
ͺͻͳͷͰ
ΕͰ͸͹
ΒͰ
΂ͳ͸ͳ
ͬͰ͹ͷͪ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ͸
ͯͰ͹
ͺͻͳͬͻͰͯͰ
ͽͰ
ͼͰ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͽ͹ͭͪ
ͳ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ΃Δͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
ͺͻ͹ͳͲͬ͹ͯΔͳ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸ͳ΀
ͻ;ͯͪ
ͳ
ͷͰͽͪͶͪ
̓͹ͷͰ͸
ͽͪͻͳ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒͪ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪ

ͼ;
;͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͰ͸ͳ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͰ
ͼͰ
΀ͳΓͪͯͰ

͵ͳͶ͹ͷͰͽͪͻͪ
ͺͻ;ͭͪ
ͳ
ͺ;ͽͰͬͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸Ͱ
ͺͻͳͷ͹ͻͼ͵Ͱ
Ͷ;͵Ͱ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͷͳͶͳ͹͸ͳ

ͽͰͶͰͿ͹͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻͳ͵Γ;΂ͪ͵ͪ
̓͹ͻͳͼ͸ͪ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
Ͳͪ
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͭ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁ͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
͹͸ͪ
͹
͹ͯ
͸͹ͼ;
ͯͳ͸ͪͻͪ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
΂ͬͻͼͽͳͷ
ͬͪͶ;ͽͪͷͪ
̀ͪͽ͹
ΒͰ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
ͺ͹͸ͪͬΓͪ͸͹
ͯͪ

ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
ͯͰͬͪͶͬͪ΁ͳΒͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;ͼͶͰͯͳͶ͹
Β͹΃
͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
́ͺͪ͵

ͻͰͯ͹ͬ͸͹
ͼͰ
͸ͪͬ͹ͯͳ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ
ͯͳ͸ͪͻͪ
ͳ
Ϳ;͸ͽͰ
́͸ͽͰͻͰͼͪ͸ͽ͸͹
ΒͰ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͷͰΌ;
ͯͻ
ͱͪͬ͸ͳͷ
͹ͫͰͶͰͱΒͳͷͪ
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͲͪͼͽͪͬͰ
ͳ
ͺͻͪͲ͸ͳ͵ͪ
̽ͪ͸ͪ
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ

ͺ͹ͷͳΔͰ
ͳ
΀ͳͷ͸ͪ
͎ͰΒ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳ
;Ͳ
΁ͳͽͳͻͪΔͰ
ͺͻͬ͹ͭ
ΔͰ͸͹ͭ
ͼͽͳ΀ͪ
͵͹Βͳ

ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͬͰͯͰ͸
͸ͪ
Ͱ͸ͭͶͰͼ͵ͳ
ΒͰͲͳ͵
΃ͽ͹
ΕͰ
;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽ͹ΒͰΕͳͷ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪͷͪ
ͯͰ
Ͷ͹ͬͪͽͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͼͬ͹ΒͰͬͻͼ͸ͪ
ͳͻ͹͸ͳΒͪ

͈ͻͬͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵ͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
;͹΂ͪͬͪ
;
ͭ͹ͯͳ΃ͽ;
Ͳͪ

ΒͰͼͽͰ
͸ͪͺ͹
ͷͰ͸ͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͪ
ͬͰΕ
͹ͯͫͪ΁ͳͶͪ
ͰͺͳͽͰͽ
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͪ
ͯͪ
ͼ;

;
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͳ
ͳ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹Β
;ͬͰͯͰ͸ͳ
ͬͳ΃ͰͺͪͻͽͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͼͳͼͽͰͷͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;

ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ
͹΂Ͱ͵;Β;
ͬͳ΃ͰͺͪͻͽͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͳͲͫ͹ͻͳ
ͯ͹͵
ͼͰ
ͼͪͷ͹;
ͺͻͪͬΓͪΔͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͰͺͰ͸͹
;͵ͳͯͪ
͇ͼͽͪͶͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
ͼ;
ͷͪΔͰͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͳͼͽͳ
ͼͪ

ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸ͳ΀
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
̻͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ

͸ͪͭͶͪ΃ͪͬͪ
ͼͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ

͋ͳͽ͹ͬͰ
ͼͷͻͽͳ
ͯͬͰ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸Ͱ
͸ͪͺͻͰͯ͸ͳΒͰ
͵ͪͽ͹Ͷͳ΂͵Ͱ
XFTUFSOMPPLJOH

ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
͹ͯͬͪΒͪΒ;
͹ͯ
͹ͼͽͪͶͳ΀
ͺͻͰͽͰͱ͸͹
ͺͻͪͬ͹ͼͶͪͬ͸ͳ΀
ͳ
ͷ;ͼͶͳ
ͷͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ
͈͹ͯͰͶͪ
͸ͪ
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
͸ͳΒͰ
;

͹ͯͰΓ͵;
͇ͫͶͪͼͽ
ͳ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ͹
ͬͰΕ
;
͌ͺͻͪͬͳ
͌ͷͰͼͽ͹
;͹ͫͳ΂ͪΒͰ͸Ͱ

Ϳ͹ͻͷ;Ͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
ͿͰͯͰͻͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
ͼͪͼͽ͹Βͳ
͹ͯ
΃Ͱͼͽ

ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ
ͺͻͰͶͪͲͳ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
͵͹͸ͼͽͪͽͪ΁ͳΒ;
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
ͫͳͶͪ
ͿͰͯͰͻͪ΁ͳΒͪ
;Ͳ

͸ͪͬ͹ΌͰΔͰ
ͫͻ͹Βͪ
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͇ͯ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹ͷ
ͼͺͳͼ͵;
ͯͻ
ͱͪͬͪ
ͺ͹
ͷ͹͸Ͱͽͪͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
;
Δͳͷͪ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͰ
͹ͯͬ͹ΒͰ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸Ͱ

 ͈͹;Ͳͯͪ͸͹ͼͽ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵ͪ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀
͹
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ 

ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
̹͹ͼ͸ͪ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͪ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͪ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͪ

ͪͶͳ
ͽͪ͵͹ΌͰ
͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸Ͱ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
ͳ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
ͳ
͏ͻ͸ͪ
̻͹ͻͪ
̓;ͻͼ
͸ͪͬͰ
ͯͰ͸Ͱ
ͬͪͶ;ͽͰ
m
ͯͳ͸ͪͻͪ
m
ΒͰ
;
ͼͬͳͷ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪͷͪ
ͳͼͽͳ
ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
;
ͺͻͰ
ͭͶͰͯ;
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
͹ͬͰ
͸͹ͬͰ
͸ͳͼ;
͹ͯͬ͹ΒͰ͸Ͱ
ͳͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽ͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͯͬͪΒͪΔͰ

;ͬͰͶͳ͵͹
ͽͻͪΒͪͶ͹
͊ͬͰ
͹ͬͰ
͸͹ͬͰ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
͹͵;ͺΓͰ͸Ͱ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͯ
͹ͯͻͰͯ͸ͳ΁;

̹ͳͬ΃ͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
͆ͪ
ͬͰΕͰͷ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
͸Ͱͭ͹
ͻͪ͸ͳΒͰ
͹ͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ

ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͪ΂͸͹
;Ͳ
͸ͪͺ͹ͷͰ͸;
ͯͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͷͰΌ;͸ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹

ͺͻͳͲ͸ͪͽͪ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͪͭͻͰͼͳͬ͸ͳ΀
͸ͪͷͰͻͪ
͆ͪ
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵;
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͪ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͰ
;͹΂ͳͽͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ

ͯ͹ͫͳͶͪ
ͼ͵ͻ͹ͷͪ͸
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
;ͬ͹ͯ
͋͹
ΒͰ
ͻͪͲ;ͷΓͳͬ͹
ͼ
͹ͫͲͳͻ͹ͷ
͸ͪ

ͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ͸;
ͬͰΕ;
Ͳͪͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪ͸͹ͼͽ
΂ͳͽͪͶͪ΁ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͯͰ͹
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͰ
;
͵͹ͷͰ

ͫ;͵ͽͰ
ͻͪͽ͹ͬͳ
ͼ͵͹ͻ͹
ͯͰͼͰͽ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
͈ͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͪ
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ͸͹ͬͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
ͯ͹ͫͳ
ΒͪͶͪ
;
̸Ͷͷͪ͸ͪ΀;
ͫͳ͹
ΒͰ
;ͺͻͪͬ͹
ͺͻ͹ͺ͹ͻ΁ͳ͹͸ͪͶͪ͸
ͫͻ͹Β͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͳ
Ͳͪͷͻ
΃Ͱ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͳ
ͻͪͽ͸ͳ΀
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͪ
͸ͪ
ΔͰ͸͹Β
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͳ
̀ͪͽ͹
ΒͰ

 ͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
͈
͉ͳͼͽͳΕ

͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͯͬ͹ΒͳͶͪ
͹ͯ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
͸ͪ
͸ͪΒͫͻͱͳ
ͳ
ͻͰͶͪͽͳͬ͸͹

ͫͰͲͫ͹Ͷͪ͸
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸
ͯ͹ͫͳͶͪ
͸ͪΒͷͪΔͰ

ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
͈͹͸ͪͬΓͪ͸ͪ
ΒͰ
͵͹͸ͼͽͪͽͪ
΁ͳΒͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒ;
;
͹ͯͬͪΒͪΔͰ
͹ͯͬͰ͹
ͼͽͻͪ΀
͹ͯ
ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͯ͹ͷͳ͸ͪ΁ͳΒͰ

ͽͰ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͹͸ͪ
͸ͪΒͫͻͱͰ
ͻͪͲͬͳΒͪ
ΒͰͻ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪ
͸ͪΒͫ͹ͭͪͽͳΒͪ
ͷͰΌ;
ͫͳͬ΃ͳͷ
͵͹
ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͪ
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͫͳͶͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
͹͸ͯͪ

͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
ΔͰ͸͹ͭ
͹ͯͬͪΒͪΔͪ
͹ͯ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
̻ͻ΂͵ͪ
͹ͯͫͳͶͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳ
Ͳ͸ͪ
ͳ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͳͲͫͳ͹
t;ͼͽͪ͸ͪ͵i
ͯ͹ͷͪΕͳ΀
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͪ΁ͪ
͉ͪͲ;ͷΓͳͬ͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ

ͼ;
̹͹ͼ͸ͪ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͪ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͪ
ͳ
t͹ͼͽͪͽͪ͵i
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ

ͳ
͏ͻ͸ͪ
̻͹ͻͪ

ͯ͹ͫͳͶͰ
Ͳ͸ͪͽ͸͹
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
ͳ
ͺͪͱΔͰ
͊ͪ
΀ͻ͹͸ͳ΂ͪͻ
ͼ͵͹ͷ
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸͹΃Ε;
ͼͰ
ͺ͹͸Ͱ͵ͪͯ
ͺͻͪͽͳ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͪ
;
ͲͪͻͪΕͰ͸ͳͷ

͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳͷͪ
ͺͻͳ
΂Ͱͷ;
ͼͰ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͺ͹͸ͰͭͯͰ
;͹΂ͪͬͪ
ͼͰͶͰ͵ͽͳͬ͸ͪ
ͳ
;ͼͷͰͻͰ
͸ͪ
Ͳͪͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪ͸͹ͼͽ

́
;
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳͷͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͻͪͼͺ͹Ͷͪͱ;
ͼͪ
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹
ͻͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͰ
ͭͻͰ΃͵Ͱ
͇͸Ͱ
ͼ;
ͯͬ͹Βͪ͵Ͱ
͹͸Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
͸ͪ

ͺͻ͹΃Ͷ͹ͼͽ
ͳ
͹͸Ͱ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸Ͱ
͹͵͹Ͷ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͪͯͪͅ
ͳ΀

ͳͷͪ
ͼͬ;ͯͪ
Δͳ΀͹ͬ͹
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͰ
͸Ͱ
͹ͺͻͪͬͯͪͬͪ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀
΂ͳ
Βͳ
ͺͻͳͻͰΌͳͬͪ΂ͳ
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽ
ͼͬ͹ͭͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
ͻͰ͵ͶͪͷͳͻͪΒ;
ͳ
ͽͪ΂͸͹΃Ε;
̸͵͹

ͼͰ
ͫͰͲ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸ͳΒͰ
ͳ
ͯ;ͫΓͰ
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͰ
ͺͻͳ΀ͬͪͽͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
΀ͻ͹͸͹Ͷ͹ͭͳΒͪ
ͯ͹ͭͪ
ΌͪΒͪ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͽͪ΂͸ͪ
ͽͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͳ
͹ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂Ͱ͸͹ͼͽ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ͹ͷ
ͼ;
ͲͳͶͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;Ε͸͹ͼͽ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸;
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒ;
͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
ͺͳͽͪΔͰ
͸Ͱ͵ͳ΀
͸Ͱ
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸ͳ΀
Ϳ͹ͻͷ;Ͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͸Ͱͽͪ΂͸ͳ΀
ͯͪͽ;ͷͪ
ͳ
͸Ͱͼͳͭ;ͻ͸ͳ΀
ͫͻ͹ΒͰͬͪ
̺ͰΕ
;
ͭ͹ͯͳ΃ͽ;
Ͳͪ

̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀
ͺ͹ͼͬͰΕ;ΒͰ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ
͸;
ͺͪͱΔ;
ͼͬͪ͵͹Β
͸͹ͬ͹Β
ͯͻͱͪͬͳ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͪ΂͸͹
͸ͪͼͽ͹ΒͰΕͳ
ͺ͹͸͹ͬ͹
ͯͪ

ͼͰ
ͫͪͬͳ
ͳ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ͹ͷ
̹ͪͬͰΕͳ
ͼͰ
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ͹ͷ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
;
͹͵ͬͳͻ;

͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͻͰͯͪ͵΁ͳΒͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͯͶ;΂;ΒͰ
͸ͪ
ͳͲͶͰͽ
ͯ͹
ͼͻͰͯΔͰͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
̀ͪ
͊ͻ
ͫͳΒ;
ΒͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;

ͬͰ͵;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵;
ͳ
͸ͪͺͻͰͯ͸;



͌
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
%F
1BSJT
Æ
$POTUBOUJOPQMF
͈ͪͻͳͲ


΂;ͬͰ͸Ͱ
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵Ͱ
͵͹ͶͰ͵
΁ͳΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
$PMMFDUJPO
EFT
(VJEFT+PBOOF
͹ͼ͸͹ͬͪ͸Ͱ
Β͹΃
ͯͪͶͰ͵Ͱ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͽͪ͵͹
ΌͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͰ
ͭͻͰ΃͵Ͱ
;
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒͼ͵͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
͋ͪ͵͹
ͺͳ΃Ͱ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
ͼͰ
ͪ;ͼͽͻ͹ͽ;ͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͫ͹ͻͫͰ

͹͵͹
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳͶͰ
ͳ

ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
͵͹͸ͪ΂͸͹
΀ͪͽͳ΃ͰͻͳͿ͹ͷ
ͳͲ

ͺͻͳͺͪͶͪ

͊ͻͫͳͷͪ
ͽͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͵ͻͪΓ
͈Ͱͽͪͻ
̓ͪͻͪΌ͹ͻΌͰͬͳΕ
ͯ͹΃ͪ͹
͸ͪ
ͬͶͪͼͽ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
;ͫͳͼͽͬͪ
͵ͻͪΓͪ

̸ͶͰ͵ͼͪ͸ͯͻͪ

ͷͪΒͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
%F
1BSJT
Æ
$POTUBOUJOPQMF

DBSUFT

QMBOT


JMMVTUSBUJPOT
FU

QBOPSBNB
1BSJT





uѮF SFQVUBUJPO PG 8IJUBLFST "MNBODL SFTUT PO JUT BCJMJUZ UP QSPWJEF JOGPSNB
UJPO
UIBU
JT
CPUI
BDDVSBUF
BOE
VQ
UP
EBUF
*U
JT
FYUFOTJWFMZ
SFWJTFE
FBDI
ZFBS
XJUI
UIF

IFMQ
PG
PWFS

TQFDJBMJTU
DPOUSJCVUPST
UP
FOTVSF
UIBU
FWFSZ
TFDUJPO
JT
DPNQSFIFOTJWF

BOE
FYBDU
8IJUBLFST
PXO
FEJUPSJBM
UFBN
XPSLT
BMM
ZFBS
SPVOE
MPDBUJOH
BOE
DIFDLJOH

EBUB
GSPN
UIPVTBOE
TPVSDFTi
w
u"
CFTUTFMMFS
BNPOH
CVTJOFTT
QFPQMF
QPMJUJDJBOT
KP
VSOBMJTUT
MBXZFST
BOE
XSJUFST
8IJUBLFST
"MNBOBDL
JT
UIF
SFGFSFODF
CPPL
GPS
BMM
UIPTF

XIP
JOTJTU
PO
QSFDJTJPO
BOE
UPQJDBMJUZi
8IJUBLFST
"MNBOBDL



m
͸ͪ

͹ͷ͹ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͵ΔͳͭͰ

 ͈͹;Ͳͯͪ͸͹ͼͽ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵ͪ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀
͹
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ 

ͯͻͱͪͬ;
͸ͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒ;
ΒͰ
ͽͰ͵
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͬͳ͸͹ͷ
ͯͰͬͰͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀

;ͺͳͼͪ͸͹
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͼͻͰͯΔͰͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͹ͼͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯ
ͬͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͼ͵͹ͷ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͳ

ͺ͹ͯ
ͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵͹ͷ
ͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͷ
ͬͶͪ΃Ε;
̻ͻͰ΃͵ͪ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳ͸ͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ

ͺͻ͹ͭͶͪ΃Ͱ͸ͪ

͸ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͬͰͶͳ͵ͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͽͬͻͯΔͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
͏ͻ͸ͪ
̻͹ͻͪ
ͺͪͶͪ

ͺ͹ͯ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵;
ͬͶͪͼͽ

ͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͶͪ
͸ͰͲͪͬͳͼ͸ͪ

ͳͷͪΒ;
ͯͻ;ͭͪ΂ͳΒ;

ͽͰͱͳ͸;
̽ͻ;ͭͳ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͳ
ͻͪͽ
ΒͰ
͹ͫΒͪ΃ΔͰ͸
͸Ͱ͹ͫͳ΂͸ͳͷ
ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸ͳ΁ͪͷͪ
̹͹
ͼ͸ͪ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͪ
t͹͵;ͺͳͻͪͶͰ
ͼ;
ΒͰ
͸Ͱͷͪ΂͵Ͱ
ͼ͸ͪͭͰ
ͳ
ͼͳͶͰ
͹ͼ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ

ͳͲͷͰΌ;

ͳ

͵ͪͯͪ
ͼ;
ͺͪͻͽͳͲͪ͸ͳ
;
ͺͶͪ͸ͳ͸ͪͷͪ
ͺͻ;ͱͳͶͳ
ͼ͸ͪ
ͱͪ͸
͹ͽͺ͹ͻi
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͪ
t͊;ͻ͹ͬͪ
ͫ͹ͻͫͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
͸ͪ͹ͻ;ͱͪ͸ͳ΀
Ͱ͵ͼͽͻͰ
ͷͳͼͽͪ
͹ͬͰ
ͼͪͽͰͶͳͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͳ΀
͵ͪ͹
;ͼͽͪ΃Ͱ
ͼͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͻ͹
ΒͪͶͳͼͽͳͷͪ
ͳ
͵͹ͷ;͸ͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺͪͻͽͳͲͪ͸ͳͷͪ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸͹
ͼͪ
ͺͻ͹ͼͪͬͰͲ͸ͳ΂
͵ͳͷ
΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺͪͻͽͳͲͪ͸ͳͷͪ
͹ͼͽͪͬͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͭ͹ͻ΂ͳ͸;
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͺ͹͸͹ͬ͹

ͳͼ͵ͻͼͶͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰi
͊ͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
͸ͳΒͰ
Ͷͪ͵͹
ͬ͹ͯͳͽͳ
ͼͽͪͽͳͼͽͳ͵;
͹
͹ͫͶͪͼͽͳͷͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
Ͳͪ
΀ͬͪΕͰ͸Ͱ
ͻͪͽ͹ͷ
͋ͪͯͪ
ͼͰ
Ͳͪ
͵ͪ͵ͬ;ͽͪ͵ͬ;
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒ;
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͻͪͽ͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
ͳͶͳ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱ͸Ͱ
͌Ͳ
΂ͳΔͰ͸ͳ΁;
ͯͪ
ͻͪͽ͹ͬͳ
ͳͲͪͲͳͬͪΒ;
ͺͻͳ
͸;ͯ͸Ͱ
ͷͳͭͻͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͽͳ
͸Ͱ͵Ͱ
͸ͰͶ͹ͭͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
;
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸ͳͷ

ͼͽͪͽͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
͹
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ;
͋ͪ͵͹
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ΃ͽͬ͹
̹͹
ͼ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸ͪͷͪ
ͺ͹͸ͪͬΓͪ͸ͳͷ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳͷͪ
ͳͲ
ͳͼͽ͹ͭ

ͺ͹ͺͳͼͪ


ͬͪͻͳͻͪ
͹ͯ
 
ͷͳͶͳ͹͸


ͯ͹
 
ͷͳͶͳ͹͸ͪ



ͪ
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ
 
ͷͳͶͳ͹͸ͪ


ͯ͹
 
ͷͳͶͳ͹͸ͪ


́ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ

;͹΂Γͳͬ͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͫͻ͹Β
ͼͽͪ͸͹ͬ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͷͪΔ;ΒͰ
͹ͯ

ͯ͹


ͺͻ͹΁Ͱ͸ͪͽ
͊ͻͫͪ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
΂ͳͽͪͬ͹ͭ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯͪ
͹ͼͽͪΒͰ
ͳͼͽͳ
m

͌
ͪͅ͵Ͱ
ͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ
ͬͪͻͳͻͪΒ;
ͺͻ͹΁Ͱ͸ͽͳ
ͼͬͳ΀
ͺͻͳͺͪͯ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͸ͪͻ͹ͯͪ
;
͏ͻ͸͹Β
̻͹ͻͳ

ΒͰ
ͼͪͷ͹

͊ͻͫͪ


ͳ
ͽ͹
͹ͯ

ͯ͹͵
ͼͰ
;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
͊ͻͫͳ
ͳ
͏ͻ͸͹ͭ͹ͻ΁ͳ

ͲͫͻͪΒͪΒ;
͋Ͱ΃͵͹ΕͰ
ͼͰ
;͹΂ͪͬͪΒ;
ͳ
ͺͻͳ
ͺ͹͵;΃ͪΒͳͷͪ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹;Ͳͯͪ͸ͳΒͰ
;ͽͬͻ
ͯͰ
ͫͻ͹ΒͰͬͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
͸ͪ
ͳͲͫͰͭͶͳ΁Ͱ
͵͹Βͳ΀
͸Ͱͼ;ͷΔͳͬ͹
ͳͷͪ

ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͳ
ͽͰ΃͵͹
ͳ΀
ΒͰ
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸͹
ͰͬͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͻͪͽͳ
͋ͪ͵͹
ͺͻͰͷͪ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱ
ͻ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀;
;
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒ;
ͯ͹ͶͪͲͳ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;

ͳ

ͪ
͹ͼͽͪ
ΒͰ

ͳͲͫͰͭͶͳ΁ͪ
;
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵;
ͼͰ
ͼͶͳͬͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;

ͳ


;
̹͹ͼ͸ͳ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͳ
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
tͼͻͺͼ͵͹ͭ
Ͱͽ͸ͳ΂͵͹ͭ
΂ͳ΃ΕͰΔͪi
;ͷͳͻͰ

΀ͳΓͪͯͰ
ͅ;ͼͶͳͷͪ͸ͪ
ͪ
;
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵;
ͫͰͱͳ
ͼͽ͹ͽͳ͸Ͱ
΀ͳΓͪͯͪ
ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ

ͫ͹ͷͫͪͻͯ͹ͬͪΔͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
tͼͽ͹ͽͳ͸Ͱ
΀ͳΓͪͯͪ
Γ;ͯͳ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͫͰͭͶͰ
ͳͶͳ

ͫͳͶͰ
ͺͻͳͷ͹ͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͯͪ
͸ͪͺ;ͼͽͰ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͷ͹ͬͰ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͽͻͪͱͰ
ͼ͵Ͷ͹͸ͳ΃ͽͰ
;

̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͳΒͳ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͳ
ͳͶͳ
͏ͻ͸͹Β
̻͹ͻͳi
̓͹͸ͪ΂͸͹

΂ͳͽͪ͹΁ͳ
ͼ;

͹ͫͪͬͰ΃ͽͰ͸ͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͸ͪ
̓͹ͼ͹ͬ͹
ͬͻͪͽͳͶ͹



ͳͲͫͰͭͶͳ΀
̸Ͷͫͪ͸ͪ΁ͪ

ͪͶͳ
ΒͰ
͸ͪΒͷͪΔͰ

͵͹ͼ͹ͬͼ͵ͳ΀
͊ͻͫͪ
͹ͽͳ΃Ͷ͹
ͺͶͪ΃ͰΕͳ
ͼͰ
͹ͼͬͰͽͰ
͊ͪͼͬͳͷ
ͽͪ΂͸ͪ
ͼ;
͹ͫͪͬͰ΃ͽͰΔͪ
ͯͪ
ͼ;
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͳΒͰ
͸͹ͬͳ΀
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ

m
͹ͼͳͷ

͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͰ
m
ͫͳͶͰ
ͯͻͪͼͽͳ΂͸͹
ͻ;ͳ͸ͳͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͻͪͽ͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂
 ͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
͈
͉ͳͼͽͳΕ

͸ͳͷ
ͫͶ͹͵ͪͯͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͼͪ͸͵΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
̓ͪ͹
ͳ
;
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ;
ͺͻͰ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͽͰ͵
ͼͽ͹ͬͳ
͹
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
ͫͳͬ΃Ͱ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
;
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ͹ͷ
̸Ͷͷͪ͸ͪ΀;

;ͺͻ͵͹ͼ
ͼͬͳͷ
͹ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΂ͰΔͳͷͪ
ͯ͹͸͹ͼͰ
ͯ͹ͼͽͪ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸͹ͼͽͳ
͹
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳͷ

ͪͺͪͻͪͽͳͷͪ
ͳ
͵ͪͯͻ͹ͬͳͷͪ
;ͺͻͪͬͳ
ͼͪ͹ͫͻͪΕͪΒ;
ͺͪ
ͳ
͹ͫͻͪͲ͹ͬͪΔ;
͊ͪͷ͹
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͪ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͯͰͬͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀

ͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
ͼͪͷ͹

ͳ



ͳͷͪΒ;
͹ͯͰΓͪ͵
͇ͯͫͻͪ͸ͪ
ͼ
ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ͹ͷ
͹ͻ;ͱͪ͸ͳ΀
ͼ͸ͪͭͪ
͌
ͼ͵Ͷ͹ͺ;

͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
͹ͯ

ͯ͹

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
͹ͻ;ͱͪ
͸ͳͷ
ͼ͸ͪͭͪͷͪ
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
̓ͻͪΒͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͌ΒͰͯͳΔͰ͸ͳ΀
͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
́Ͷͳ

ͼͰ
;
ͻͪͽ͸͹ͷ
ͬͳ΀͹ͻ;
͸ͳΒͰ
ͷ͹ͭͶ͹
;ͽͬͻͯͳͽͳ
͹
͵ͪ͵ͬͳͷ
ͼͰ
ͬ͹Β͸ͳͷ
Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ
΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͻͪͯͳ
ͳͶͳ
ͼ;
͹͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ
ͼ;͵͹ͫͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪΒͪͶͰ
ͽͪ͵ͬͰ
ͯͪ
ͳ΀
͸ͳΒͰ
͸ͳ

ͬͻͰͯͰͶ͹
ͰͬͳͯͰ͸ͽͳͻͪͽͳ
͇ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͰ
ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ΀
͵ͪͻͪͽͪ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
͸Ͱ͵ͪ
ͯͪ
ͫͳͶͰ
;
ͼͪͼͽͪͬ;
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ΒͰ
͹΂ͳͭͶͰͯ͸͹
ͲͪͬͳͼͳͶ͹
͹ͯ
ͼͽͪͽ;ͼͪ
ͳ

ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁ͪ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ΀
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪͯͻͱͪͬͪ
ͪͯͪͅ
ͼ;
ͫͳͶͰ
ͼ͵ͻ͹ͷ͸ͳ΀
ͳ͸
Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͽͳͬ͸ͳ΀
ͬͻͰͯ͸͹ͼͽͳ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸ͳͷ
͵ͪͻͽͪͷͪ
;
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹
ͬ͹ͷ
̸Ͷͷͪ͸ͪ΀;
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͰ
;͸Ͱ͵͹Ͷͳ͵͹
ͺͻͪͽͳͽͳ
ͳ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
ͼͳͽ;ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͸ͪ

Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹ͷ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
͌
ͭ͹ͯͳ΃ͽͳͷͪ
Ͳͪ

ͳ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸;
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹

ͭͰ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ΀
͵ͪͻͪͽͪ
͌
ͭ͹ͯͳ΃ͽ;
Ͳͪ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸;
ͷͪͯͪ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͯ
ͲͪΒͰͯ
͸ͳ΂͵ͳͷ
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ͹ͷ
̹ͳͬ΃ͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
̹͹ͼ͸ͪ

ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸ͪ
͎ͻͬͪͽ
ͼ͵ͪ
ͪͅ͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͪ
ͳ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͪ
ͳͷͪΒ;
ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸Ͱ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͰ
ͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪ
ͳ

͏ͻ͸ͪ
̻͹ͻͪ
ͼ;
͹ͫΒͰͯͳΔͰ͸Ͱ
ͲͪΒͰͯ͸ͳ΂͵ͳͷ
;ͬ͹ͯ͹ͷ
͋ͪ͵͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
͸ͪ
͵ͪͻͽͳ

ͭͯͰ
ͼ;
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
͹ͫͰͶͰͱͰ͸Ͱ
ͳͼͺͻͰ͵ͳͯͪ͸͹ͷ
Ͷͳ͸ͳΒ͹ͷ
͵͹Βͪ
ͼͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;
ΒͰ
͹ͯ
ͷͰΌ;ͯͻͱͪͬ͸Ͱ
͊ͶͰͯͰΕͰ

͹ͬͰ
ͭͻͪ͸ͳ΁Ͱ
ͳ
͸ͪ
͵ͪͻͽͳ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪΒ;

ͷͰΌ;ͯͻͱͪͬ͸Ͱ
̓ͪͻͽͪ
̹͹ͼ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͎Ͱͻ΁Ͱͭ͹ͬͳ͸Ͱ
ͼͪ
͎ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹ͷ
͸ͪ
͵͹Β͹Β
ͼ;

ͻͪͲͶͳ΂ͳͽ͹
͹ͫͰͶͰͱͰ͸Ͱ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͯͻͱͪͶͳ
͊ͻͫͳ
ͅ;ͼͶͳͷͪ͸ͳ

ͳ
͎ͻͬͪͽͳ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ

ͳ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͇͸ͪ
ͼͽͬ͹ͻͰ͸ͪ
̽ͰΒͽ͹͸
ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͼͺ͹ͻͪͲ;ͷ͹ͷ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸ͪ
ΒͰ

ͳ
͸ͪ
Δ͹Β
ͼͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;ΒͰ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳ
Βͪ
͵͹Β;
ͼ;
ͯͻͱͪͶͳ
t̹͹ͼͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ
͊ͻͫͳi
͹ͯ
ͽͰͻͳͽ͹ͻͳΒͰ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪͶͪ

tͅ;ͼͶͳͷͪ͸ͼ͵͹΀ͻͬͪͽͼ͵͹Β
ͿͰͯͰͻͪ΁ͳΒͳi
͊Ͷͳ΂͸͹
ΒͰ
ͳ

ͼ
ͽͳͷ
΃ͽ͹

ͼͰ
ͺ͹ΒͪͬΓ;ΒͰ
ͽͰͻͷͳ͸
t͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͪi
͉Ͱͯͪ͵΁ͳΒͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰ


΃ͽͪͷͺͪ
͵ͪͻͽ;
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸Ͱ

͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͼͪ
ͼͬͳͷ
͸͹ͬͳͷ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪͷͪ
Ͳͪ
ΒͰͯ͸͹

͇ͯ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͸ͪ
͵ͪͻͽͳ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͽͪ͸͵͹ͷ
ͳͼͺͻͰ͵ͳͯͪ͸͹ͷ

Ͷͳ͸ͳΒ͹ͷ
͹ͯͬͪΒͪ
ͼͰ
ͳ
̓͹ͼ͹ͬ͹
΃ͽ͹
͸ͳΒͰ
ͼͶ;΂ͪΒ
ͼͪ
̺͹Βͬ͹ͯͳ͸͹ͷ
͌
͹ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰΔͳͬͪΔ;
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀ͪ
͵͹Ͷ͹ͻ
Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳ
Β͹ͷ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰ
ͷͰͼͽ͹
ͼ;
͸ͪ΃Ͷͪ
ͳ
ͲͫͳͬͪΔͪ
;
ͫͳͬ΃͹Β
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
͈͹ͽͻͰͼ͸Ͱ

ͼ;
Ϳ͹ͽ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ
ͼͪ
ͺͳΒͪ΁Ͱ
ͪͅͻ͵ͪͶͰ
;
͊ͪͻͪΒͰͬ;
ͳͲ
ΒͰͯ͸͹ͭ
ͫ͹ͼͪ͸ͼ͵͹ͭ

Ͷ͹ͭ͹ͻͪ
ͳͲͫͰͭͶͳ΁ͪ
ͳͲ
̓ͻͪΒͳ͸Ͱ
ͽͪͶͪ΁ͪ
͌ΒͰͯͳΔͰ͸ͳ΀
͸ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͳ
̸͇͆͋

ͫ͹ͷͫͪͻͯ͹ͬͪΔͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹Ͷ͹ͱͪΒͪ
&WFOUT
JO
&VSPQF
&WFOUT
PG
̾BTUFSO
&VSPQF
&WFOUT
PG
UIF
:FBS

ΒͰ

ͺ͹ͼͰͫ͸͹
͹ͯͬ͹ΒͰ͸ͪ
΀ͻ͹͸ͳ͵ͪ
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸Ͱ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͭͯͰ
ͳ
͸ͪΒͲ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͳͷ
ͯ͹
 ͈͹;Ͳͯͪ͸͹ͼͽ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵ͪ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀
͹
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ 

ͭͪΌͪΒͳͷͪ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪ
͸ͪΒ΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͺ͹
ΒͰͯ͸ͪ
ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸ͳ΁ͪ
͌
ͽ͹Β
΀ͻ͹͸ͳ΁ͳ

ΒͰ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͪ
΂Ͱͼͽ͹
͹ͯ͸͹ͼ͸͹
ΔͰ͸Ͱ
ͫͳͬ΃Ͱ
ͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ

ͳͷͪͶͪ
ͼͬ͹Β;

ͻͰ΂Ͱ͸ͳ΁;
͇ͯ

ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
;ͼͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͯͺ͹ͭͶͪͬΓͰ
ͺ͹ͯ
͸ͪͲͳ
ͬ͹ͷ
ѮF
'PSNFS
:VHPTMBWJB
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͵͹Β;
ͼͰ
΀ͻ͹͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
ͼ͵͹ͻ͹
ͳͲ
ͯͪ͸ͪ
;

ͯͪ͸
ͺͻͪͽͳ
ͻͪͲͬ͹Β
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͪ
͸ͪ
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͻͪͽͳ΃ͽͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂
͵͹Β
ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻ͸ͳ΁ͳ
͊ͷͳͻͳͬͪΔͰͷ
ͼͳͽ;ͪ΁ͳΒͰ
͹͸͹
ΕͰ
ͺͻͰͻͪͼͽͳ
;
#BMLBO

$POëJDU
B
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͳ
͸Ͱͼͽͪͽͳ
̺Ͱͼͽͳ
ͼͪ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹ͭ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͪ
ͺͻͰΕͳ
ΕͰ
;

ͻ;ͫͻͳ͵Ͱ
&VSPQF
ͳͶͳ
*OUFSOBUJPOBM
3FMBUJPOT
͇ͬͪ
΀ͻ͹͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵͹Βͪ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͼͬ͹ΒͰͬͻͼ͸;
΀ͻ͹͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵;
ͽͪͫͶͳ΁;
ΒͰ
͸Ͱͼ;ͷΔͳͬ͹
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͸͹

Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͪ
ͳ
͵ͪ͹
͹ͫͪͬͰ΃ͽͪΒ͸͹
ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬ͹
ͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͺ͹ͯͼͰͽ͸ͳ͵
͹
ͺͻ͹ͽͰ͵Ͷͳͷ

ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͳͷͪ
́ͷͪ
;
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͳͷͪ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼͰ
͹ͯ͸͹ͼͰ
͸ͪ

ͫͳͬ΃;

͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒ;
ͫͰͲͫͻ͹Β
ͯͻͪͭ͹΁Ͱ͸ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
ͽͬͻͯΔͳ
͵͹
ΒͰ
͸ͳͼ;
͸ͪ
͸ͪΒͼͽͪͫͳͶ͸ͳΒͳͷ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬͪͷͪ
͢ͳ΀͹ͬ͹
ͳͼͺͻͪͬΓͪΔͰ
ͳͶͳ
;ͽͬͻ
ΌͳͬͪΔͰ
ͽͪ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶ͹
΁ͳΓ
͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͻͪͯͪ
͢Ͱͭ͹ͬ
΁ͳΓ
͸ͳΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
͸ͳ

ͯͪ
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸͹
ͺͻ͹ͬͰͻͪͬͪ
ͽͪ΂͸͹ͼͽ
͸ͪͬ͹ΌͰ͸ͳ΀
ͼͽͪͽͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ

;
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳͷ
ͭ͹ͯͳ΃ͽͳͷͪ
̸Ͷͷͪ͸ͪ΀ͪ
͈ͻͬ͹
Ͳͪͽ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼ;
ͽͰ
ͽͬͻͯΔͰ
ͳ

ͽͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
ͷͪͯͪ
͸Ͱ
;ͬͰ͵
͹ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳͬ͸͹
ͳ
͵ͻͳͽͳ΂͵ͳ
͹ͫͻͪΌͰ͸ͳ
ͬͰͻ͹ͬͪͽ
͸͹
ͺͻͰ;Ͳͳͷͪ͸ͳ
ͳͲ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸ͳ΀
ͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͪ
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͰ͸ͳ΀
;
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ

ͳͶͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͯͰ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭ͹
Ͳͪͽ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͫͳ
ͽ͹
Ͳͪ΀ͽͰͬͪͶ͹
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹
ͬͳ΃Ͱ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ

ͳ
ͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
͹͸͹ͭͪ
͵͹ΒͰ
͹ͷ͹ͭ;Εͪͬͪ
ΒͰͯͪ͸
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͭ
Ͳͫ͹ͻ͸ͳ͵;
͹
ͬ͹ͯͳ
΂ͳͷͪ
́ͺͪ͵
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͯ͹ͬ͹Γ͸͹
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬͰ
ͯͬͪ
͵Γ;΂͸ͪ
ͺͳͽͪΔͪ

͹ͬ͹ͭͪ
ͺͻͳͶ͹ͭͪ
͈ͻͬ͹
ͯͪ
Ͷͳ
ͼͰ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͬͻͼͽͪͽͳ

ͺ͹ͯ
͹͸͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼͬ͹Β͹ͷ
͹ͺ΃ͽͰͺͻͳ΀ͬͪΕͰ͸͹ͷ
ͼͪͯͻͱͳ͸͹ͷ
ͺ͹ͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪΒ;

ͻͰ΂ͳ
CBFEFLFS
͸Ͱͷ

HVJEF
Ͱ͸ͭͶ

HVJEF
Ϳͻ

ͺ;ͽͰͬ͹ͯͳͽͰͶ·
ͻ;ͼ


ͳͶͳ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͳͶͳ
ͪͻ΀ͪͳ΂͸ͳΒͰ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͬ͹Όͪ
́
ͯͻ;ͭ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
ͺͳ
ͽͪΔͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬΓͰ͸͹
;
͸ͪͼͶ͹ͬ;
ΒͰͼ;
Ͷͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͵͹Βͳ
ͼ;
͸ͪͬͰͯͰ͸ͳ
;
ͺͻͳ
Ͷ͹Ͳͳͷͪ
͹
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
m
ͺͻͰ΁ͳͲ͸ͳΒͰ
Ͳͪ
ͺͰͻͳ͹ͯ
ͯͰͬͰͯͰͼͰͽͳ΀
͹
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹
ͬͰ͸ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
m
ͽͪ΂͸ͳ
ͽͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
Ͷͳ
ͼͰ
Ͳͪͳ͸ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ
΂ͳͽͪͶͪ΁

͹ͼͶ͹͸ͳͽͳ
͸ͪ
Δͳ΀

ͅ͹ͱͯͪ
ͯͰͶ;ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
;
͸Ͱͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;
ͼͪ
ͯͰͿͳ͸ͳ΁ͳΒ͹ͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͪͶͳ

͹ͯͭ͹ͬ͹ͻ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͬ͹
ͺͳͽͪΔͰ
ΒͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ͺ͹Ͳͳͽͳͬͪ͸
͆Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
Ͳͫ͹ͭ
ͽ͹ͭͪ

΃ͽ͹
ͳͲͯͪͬͪ΂
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ͹ͭ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀ͪ
ͽ͹
ͼͷͪͽͻͪ
͵ͪͯͪ
͹ͫΒͪͬͳ
͸ͪ
͵͹ͻͳ



͠Ͱͯ͸ͪ
͹ͯ
ͷ͹ͭ;Εͳ΀
ͳ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ͷͰͻͳͽ͹ͻ͸ͳ΀
ͯͰͿͳ͸ͳ΁ͳΒͪ
ͫͳ
ͷ͹ͭͶͪ
ͫͳͽͳ
u%F
TUJOÊ
BVY
ÊUSBOHFSFT
FU
EFWBOU
ËUSF
BWBOU
UPVU
VO
HJEF
QSBUJRVF
TPO
CVU
FTU
EF
EPOOFS

BV
WPZBHFVS
MFT
SFOTFJHOFNFOUT
OÊDFTTBJSFT
QPVS
CJFO
WPJS
TBOT
QFSUF
EF
UFNQT
FU
TBOT

USPQ
EF
GSBJT
DF
RVJ
ÊSJUF
WSBJNFOU
EËUSF
WV
EBOT
MFT
QBZTi
"VUSJDIF)POHSJF
Z
DPN
QSJT
$FUUJHOÊ
#FMHSBEF
FU
#VDBSFTU
.BOVFM
EV
WPZBHFVS
QBS
,BSM
#ŽEFLFS
-FJQ[JH
m
1B
SJT

1SÊGBDF
7

 ͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
͈
͉ͳͼͽͳΕ

΁ͪͷͪ
͵ΔͳͭͰ

ͭ

ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͽ͹
͸Ͱͺͻ͹΁ͰΔͳͬͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͫͻͳͽͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͳ

ͼͬͰͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͯ͹ͭͪΌͪΒͰ
ͽ͹͵͹ͷ
ͺͻͰͽ΀͹ͯ͸Ͱ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
ͳ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ
ͳ

ͯͪͽ;ͷͰ
͸ͪͻͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͭ͹ͯͳ͸Ͱ
͌
ΔͰͷ;
ͼͰ
Ͳͪͳͼͽͪ
ͷ͹ͭ;
͸ͪΕͳ
͸ͪΒͯͰͽͪΓ͸ͳ
Βͳ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
ͽͪ΂͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
̺ͰͶͳ͵͹Β
̹ͻͳͽͪ͸ͳΒͳ
͆ͪ
Ͳ͸ͪͽ͸͹
ͷͪΔͰͷ

ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻ;
ͪͶͳ
͸Ͱ
ͷͪΔͰ
ͺͪͱΓͳͬ͹
ͻͪͼͺ͹ͻͰΌͰ͸ͳ
ͼ;
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
ͳ
͹
ͯͻ;
ͭͳͷ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͷͰΌ;ͯͻͱͪͬ͸ͳͷ
͹ͻͭͪ͸ͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪͷͪ
͊
͹ͫͲͳͻ͹ͷ
͸ͪ
ͽ͹

΃ͽͪ
ͼͪͯͻͱͳ
ͳ
͵͹ͷͰ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀
ΒͰͼͽͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
́

ͽ͹
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͼͪ
ͬͳ΃Ͱͼͽͻ;͵ͳͷ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͰΔͰͷ

ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ

͵͹Βͳ
͸Ͱ
ͬ͹ͯͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͰ
ͬͰΕ
͵͹Βͳ
͵͹ͻͳͼͽͰΕͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͰ
͹ͼ͸͹ͬ͸Ͱ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵Ͱ

͵ͻ͹ΒͰ
ͯͻͱͪͬ͸;
ͳ
Ͱ͵͹͸͹ͷͼ͵;
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ͵;
Βͪͬ͸͹
ͷΔͰΔͰ
ͺͳ΃;
΂Ͷͪ͸͵Ͱ

ͺͪͷͿͶͰͽͰ
ͻ͹ͷͪ͸Ͱ
ͳͶͳ
ͻͰ΃ͪͬͪΒ;
;͵ͻ΃ͽͰ͸Ͱ
ͻͰ΂ͳ
ͳ
ͽͪ͵͹
͵͹ͯ
ͼͰͫͰ
ͳ

ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
ͼͽͬͪͻͪΒ;
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬ;
͹
͸Ͱ͵ͳͷ
ͯͪͶͰ͵ͳͷ
͵ͻͪΒͰͬͳͷͪ
;

͵͹ΒͰ
ΕͰ
ͷ͹ͱͯͪ
͹ͽͳΕͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͯͳͺͶ͹ͷͪͽͰ
͸͹ͬͳ͸ͪͻͳ
Ϳͳ͸ͪ͸ͼͳΒͰͻͳ
ͳͶͳ

ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ
ͳͶͳ
;͹ͺ΃ͽͰ
͸ͰΕͰ
ͺ͹ͱͰͶͰͽͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
ͽͪͷ͹
ͺ͹ΒͪͬͰ
͠Ͱͻ
ͽ͹
ΒͰ
ͬ͹
ͯͳ΂
͹
ͼ;ͯͫͳ͸ͳ
ΒͰͯ͸Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
͵͹Βͪ
ΒͰ
͹ͯ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͻͪΒͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͶͪ
ͺͪ
͵ͪ͹
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͹
ͽͻͪΒͪΔ;
ͼ͹΁ͳΒͪͶͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͼ͸ͪ
ͳ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹ͷ
ͻͪͼͺͪͯ;
ͬ͹
ͯͳ΂
͵͹Βͳ
ͭ͹ͬ͹ͻͳ
ͳ
͹
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͳͷͪ
Ͳͪ΀ͬͪΕͰ͸ͳͷ
ͻͪͽ͹ͷ
;
͵͹ΒͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹

͸ͳΒͰͯͪ͸
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͪ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷ
ͻͪͲ;ͷΓͳͬ͹
͸Ͱ
ͫͳ
ͯ͹΃ͪ͹
ͪ
͹ͯͶͪͲͰ
͹͸ͳ
͵͹Βͳ

ͽ͹
ͷ͹ͻͪΒ;
͋͹
ΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂
͵͹Βͳ
ͷͪͶͳ
ͯͰ͹
ͼͬ͹ͭ
͹ͭͻ͹ͷ͸͹ͭ
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ
ͺ͹ͼͬͰ
Ε;ΒͰ
͸ͪͼͽͪΒͪΔ;
͸͹ͬͳ΀
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ
;
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ
;
͵͹Β͹Β
ͼͽͪͻͰ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
ͫͻ͹ΒͰ

ͬͰ͵͹ͬͰ
ͼͬ͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͼͽ͹ΒͪΔͪ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͳͼͪΔͪ

;ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͪͬͪ
͌ͺ͹Ͳ͹ͻͰΔͪ
ͷͪ͵ͪͻ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͽͰͻͪ͸ͪ
ΒͰͼ;
͸Ͱ͹ͺ΀͹ͯ͸ͪ
͈ͻͰͶͳ
ͼͽͪͬͪΒ;Εͳ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽͰ
Βͪͬ͸Ͱ
Ͷͳ΂͸͹ͼͽͳ
ΕͰ
ͼͰ
ͺͻͳ
ͯͻ;ͱͳͽͳ
ͫͰͼ͵ͻͪΒ͸͹ͷ
͸ͳͲ;
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͳ΀
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͷͰΌ;
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹

ͳ
̺ͳ͸ͼͽ͹͸
͐Ͱͻ΂ͳͶ
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
Ͳͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰ
̽ͻ;ͭ͹ͭ
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵͹ͭ
ͻͪͽͪ
ͽͻͪͱͳ͹
ͯͪ

ͼͰ
͸Ͱ
͹ͫ;ͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹
͹ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͰ
ͪͶͳ
ͳ
͑ͰͻͶ͹͵;
͎͹Ͷͷͼ;
͵͹Βͳ

ͭͪ
ΒͰ
ͯͻͱͪ͹
;
ͻ;͵ͪͷͪ
ͻͰ΃ͪͬͪΒ;Εͳ
ͷͳͼͽͰͻͳΒ;
;
̽͹Ͷͳ͸ͳ
ͼͽͻͪ΀ͪ
̸
ͯͪ

̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ
ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͪ
ͼͬ͹ͭ
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺ;ͽ
ͺ͹ͽͬͻΌ;ΒͰ
ͳ
ͽ͹
ͯͪ
ͼ;
;
ͼͬͪ
͵͹ͷ
ͭ͹ͯͳ΃ͽ;
ͯͰͽͪΓ͸ͪ
;ͺ;ͽͼͽͬͪ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͼͰ
;
̹ͻͳͽͪ͸ͳΒͳ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͯ͹Εͳ
ͯ͹

ͺͪͼ͹΃ͪ
ͪ
͵ͪ͵͹
ͯ͹
ͬͳͲͪ
͆ͳΒͰ
͹ͯ
ͷͪΔͰͭ
Ͳ͸ͪ΂ͪΒͪ
͸ͳ
ͽ͹
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
;ͬͰ͵
ͯͪΒͰ

ͼͺͳͼͪ͵
͹ͼ͹ͫΓͪ
ͫͻͳͽͪ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͪͷͫͪͼͪͯͰ
;
͹ͯͻͰΌͰ͸͹Β
ͲͰͷΓͳ
ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬ
͸ͳ΃ͽͬͪ
ͯ͹ͽͳ΂͸Ͱ
ͲͰͷΓͰ
;
̺
̹ͻͳͽͪ͸ͳΒͳ
͠͹΃
ͺ͹΂Ͱͽ͵͹ͷ
9*9
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͑ͪͽ͹ͫͻͳΒͪ͸
ΒͰ
;
ͼͬ͹ͷ
ͺ;ͽ͹ͺͳͼ͸͹ͷͰ
ͷ͹ͪͻͼ͵͹ͷ
ͯͰͶ;
%F
1BSJT
Æ
+FSVTBMFN
͵͹ΒͰ
ΒͰ
͸ͪͷͰͻͪͬͪ͹
ͯͪ
͹ͼͽͪͬͳ
͵ͪ͹

ͳͲͬͰͼ͸;
ͬͻͼͽ;
ͳͽͳ͸ͰͻͰͻͪ
ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
͹͸͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹ͭ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͲͪͫͰͶͰͱͳ͹
ͯͪ



uѮF SFGFSFODF CPPL "O BNB[JOH WBSJFUZ PG TVCKFDUT JO POF SFOPXOFE BO
OVBM
WPMVNF
m
BMM
UIF
GBDUT
BU
ZPVS
êOHFST BU IPNF PS BU XPSLu 8IJUBLFST "MNBOBDL


 ͈͹;Ͳͯͪ͸͹ͼͽ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵ͪ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀
͹
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ 

ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹
ͯͰͶ͹
͸ͳ΃ͽͪ
͸ͰΕͰ
ͽͪ͵͹
ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;΂ͳͽͳ
͵ͪ͹
ͽͪ΂͸͹ͼͽ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ

͵͹ΒͰ
ͫ;ͯͰ
ͳͲ͸Ͱ͹
͇͸
ΒͰ
ͽͪͯͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬͳ͹
ͷ͹ͯͰͶ
ͳ
;ͼͶ͹ͬ
;ͼͺͰ΀ͪ
ͫ;ͯ;
Εͳ΀
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͳ
ͼͬͳ΀
ͯͻ;ͭͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͆Ͱ΃ͽ͹
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ


̸ͷͳ

̹;Ͱ
ΒͰ
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
ͳͽͳ͸ͰͻͰͻͪ
ͺ͹ͼͽͪͬͳ͹
ͼͶͳ΂ͪ͸
͹͵ͬͳͻ
t̓͹͸ͪ΂͸͹
΂ͳ
ͽͪͶͪ΁
͸Ͱ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
͸ͳ͵ͪͯͪ
ͯͪ
Ͳͪͫ͹ͻͪͬͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͷ͹
͋;ͻͼ͵;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳͶͳ
͹͸ͪ
͵ͬ;
͵ͪ͵ͬͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪi

tͯͪ͸ͪͼ
͵ͪ͹
͸ͳ

͸ͳͼͷ͹
͸ͳ΃ͽͪ
ͼͪ͵ͻͳͶͳ
͸ͳ

;ͶͰͺ΃ͪͶͳ
ΒͰͻ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͳͼͽͳ͸ͪ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͫͳͽͳ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͪi
͊ͳͭ;ͻ͸͹
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
ͼ;

ͼͪͷ͹
ͽͪ΂͸ͳ
ͺ͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
ͫͳͶͳ
͵͹ͻͳͼ͸ͳ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ΁ͳͷͪ
ͳ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͼͽͰͺͰ͸
ͽͪ΂͸͹
ͼͽͳ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳΒͰ
ͳͲ
ͳͽͳ͸ͰͻͰͻͪ
ͳͶͳ
͵ͪͼ͸ͳΒͰ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͪ

ͺͻͰͺ͹ͻ;͵ͪ
Ͳͪ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬ͹
͵͹ͻͳ΃ΕͰΔͰ
̽ͬͪ
ͼ;
͸ͪ΂ͳ͸ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͺͻ͹ͬͰͻͪͬͪΔͰ

ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͺͻͰͲͰ͸ͽ͹ͬͪ͸ͳ΀
;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
͈ͻͬͳ
Ͷͪ͵΃ͳ
ͳ
ͫͰͲ
ͺ͹ͼͶͰͯͳ΁ͪ
ͺ͹

ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͻ͹ͬͰͻͪͬͪΔͰ
͵ͻ͹Ͳ
ͻͰͶͰͬͪ͸ͽ͸;
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻ;
ͯ͹͵
ΒͰ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ

ͽͰͱͳ
ͻͰΌͰ
͹ͺͪͼ͸ͳΒͳ
΂Ͱ΃ΕͰ
Ͳͪͫͪͬ͸ͳΒͳ
ͺͻ͹ͬͰͻͪ
͸ͪ
ͽͰͻͰ͸;
͑ͽ͹
ͼͰ

ͽͳ΂Ͱ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͰ
΂ͳ͸ͳ
ͼͰ
ͯͪ
;
ͬͰΕͳ͸ͳ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰ͸ͳ΀
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
͸ͳͼ;
͸ͪ
ͬ͹ΌͰ͸ͳ
΃ͳͻͳ
ͼͺͳͼ͵͹ͬͳ
͵͹ͻͳ΃ΕͰ͸ͳ΀
͵Δͳͭͪ
̀͸ͪ΂ͪΒ͸ͳΒͳ
ͽͰͷͰΓ͸ͳΒͰ

ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷΓͰ͸ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ
ͽ͹
ͳͺͪ͵
΂ͳ͸Ͱ
͌
͸ͰͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ͸͹ͷ
͸ͳͲ;
ͽͪ͵ͬͳ΀

ͯͬͪ
ͼ;
ͺͻͳͷͰͻͪ
Ͳͪ͸ͳͷΓͳͬͪ
͌
ͺ͹ͷͰ͸;ͽ͹ͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
%F
1BSJT
Æ
$POTUBO
UJOPQMF
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͳ
ͼͬͰͼ͸ͳ
ͯͪ
͍ͻͪ͸΁;Ͳͳ
͵͹Βͳͷͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͳ͹
͸ͪͷͰΔͰ͸
͹ͬͪΒ
ͬ͹
ͯͳ΂
ͼͶͪͫ͹
ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪΒ;
ͳͼͽ͹ͻͳΒ;
̺ͳͲͪ͸ͽͳΒͰ
ͳ
͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͪ
t͋;ͻͼ͵ͪ
ΒͰ
ͷͪͶ͹

ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͽͪ
;
ͳ͸͹ͼͽͻͪ͸ͼͽͬ;
ͪ
;
͍ͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵͹Β
ͺ͹ͭ͹ͽ͹ͬ;i

;ͺ;Ε;Β;
͸ͪ
͹ͯͻͰ
ΌͰ͸;
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻ;
͇͸ͳ
;ͺ;Ε;Β;
͸ͪ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͪ
ͳͷͰ͸ͪ
͵ͪ͹
΃ͽ͹
ΒͰ
͋ͰͿͳͶ

̻͹ͽΒͰ
ѮFPQIJMF
(BVUJFS

ͳͶͳ
̹ͪͻͽ
#BSUI

͸ͪ
ͻ͹ͷͪ͸Ͱ
͈ΒͰͻͪ
̈́͹ͽͳΒͪ

1JFSSF
-PUV

ͳͶͳ
͈͹Ͷͪ
̸ͯͪͷͪ
1BVM
"EBN

ͪͶͳ
ͳ
͸ͪ
͈ͪͻͪͯ͹͵ͼͰ
͹
͋;ͻ
ͼ͵͹Β
̸ͿͳΒ;͸̾ͿͰ͸ͯͳΒͰ
ͳͶͳ
͸ͪ
ͺͻͰͬ͹ͯ
̓;ͻͪ͸ͪ
ͳ
͸ͪΒͲͪͯ
Ͱͻ;ͯͳͽͪͷͪ

͸;ͯͰ
͵Ͷͪͼͳ΂͸ͪ
ͯͰͶͪ
͑ͶͪͷͫͰͻͭͰͻͪ
4DIMVNCFSHFS

ͳͶͳ
͑ͪͻͶͪ
̽ͳͶͪ

$IBSMFT
%JFIM

̽ͳͻͰ͵ͽ͹ͻ
΂;ͬͰ͸Ͱ
Ϳͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵Ͱ
͵͹ͶͰ͵΁ͳΒͰ
-FT
(VJEFT

#MFVT
'SBODJT
"NCSJÍSF
;
;ͬ͹ͯ;
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͪ
-B
:PVHPTMBWJF
͈ͪͻͳͲ



Ͳͪ΀ͬͪΓ;ΒͰ
͸Ͱ
ͼͪͷ͹
ͯͬ͹Βͳ΁ͳ
ͼͬ͹Βͳ΀
ͼͪͻͪͯ͸ͳ͵ͪ
ͬͰΕ
ͳ
ͪͽͪ΃Ͱ;
Ͳͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;
ͻ;
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵Ͱ
ͪͷͫͪͼͪͯͰ
;
͍ͻͪ͸΁;ͼ͵͹Β
͵͹Βͳ
ΒͰ
ͯͪ͹
tͯ͹͵;ͷͰ͸ͽͪ΁ͳ
Β;
ͺͻͬ͹ͭ
ͻͰͯͪi
ͳ
ͺ͹ΒͰͯͳ͸΁ͳͷͪ
ͳͲ
ͅ;ͲͰΒͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸͹ͭ
ͷ;ͲͰΒͪ

͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵͹ͭ
ͼͪͬͰͲͪ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͽ;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ΀
ͼͪͬͰͲͪ
͊Ͷ͹ͬͰ͸ͳΒͰ
ͪͅ
͵Ͱͯ͹͸ͳΒͰ
ͳͽͯ




$IBUFBVCSJBOE
%F
1BSJT
Æ
+FSVTBMFN
1SÊGBDF
B
MB
QSFNJÍSF
ÊEJUJPO
1BSJT


m


"NJ
#PVÊ
3FDVFJM
EJUJOÊSBJSFT
EBOT
MB
5VSRVJF
E&VSPQF
%ÊUBJMT
HÊPHSBQIJRV
FT
UPQPHSBQIJRVFT
FU
TUBUJTUJRVFT
TVS
DFU
&NQJSF
5PNF
QSFNJFS
7JFOOF

*9


%F
1BSJT
Æ
$POTUBOUJOPQMF

DBSUFT

QMBOT

JMMVTUSBUJPOT
FU

QBOPSBNB

1BSJT

99*9


:PVHPTMBWJF
-FT
HVJEFT
CMFVT
1BSJT


ͼͶͳ΂͸͹
ΒͰ
ͳ
;
:VHPTMBWJB
#BF
EFLFST
5PVSJOH
(VJEFT
'SFJCVSH
m
-POEPO
m
/FX
:PSL

ͳ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳͷ
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
 ͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
͈
͉ͳͼͽͳΕ

ͅͰͻͰ͸
͹͸ͳͷ
͑ͪͽ͹ͫͻͳΒͪ͸͹ͬͳͷ
ͳ
̹;Ͱ͹ͬͳͷ
ͷͰͻͳͶ͹ͷ
ͳͶͳ
ͼͽͻ͹
ͭͳͷ
ͷͰͻͳͶ͹ͷ
ͼͬͪ͵͹ͭ
ͺ;ͽ͸ͳ͵ͪ
͵͹Βͳ
ͽͻͪͱͳ
ͺ͹;Ͳͯͪ͸;
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪ΁ͳͳΒ;

̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
̸Ͷͷͪ͸ͪ΀
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͯͪ
ͳͼͽͻͺͳ
͵ͻͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͺͻͳͷͰͯͫͰ
ͳ
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
;ͬͻ
ͼͽͳ
ͷͰΌ;
ͯ͹ͫͻͪ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻͷͪͽͳͬ͸ͪ
ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͪ
͇͸͹
΃ͽ͹
ͫͳ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͭͶͪͬ͸ͪ

ͺͻͳͷͰͯͫͪ
ͫͪͻ
΃ͽ͹
ͼͰ
ͽͳ΂Ͱ
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ΒͰͼͽͰ
ͼ͵ͻ͹ͷͪ͸
͹ͫͳͷ
ͳ͸Ϳ͹ͻ
ͷͪ΁ͳΒͪ
ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͳͼͽͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͯͫͪ
ͼͰ
ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͼͽͪͬͳͽͳ
ͳ
Ͳͪ
͹ͫͪͬͰ΃ͽͰΔͪ

͹
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪͷͪ
͈ͳͽͪΔͰ
ΒͰ
ͯͪ
Ͷͳ
ͼ;
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
ͺ͹ͬͻͰͷͰ͸͹

ͽͻͺͰͶͰ
͹ͯ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵͹
͸ͪͷͰͻ͸Ͱ
ͼͺ͹ͻ͹ͼͽͳ
;
;ͬ͹ΌͰΔ;
͸͹ͬͳ΀
ͺ͹ͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͳ

ͳͺͪ͵
ͯ͹Ͳͳͻͪ͸Ͱ
ͪͶͳ
ͺͻͳͷͰͽΓͳͬͰ
ͺ͹Ͷͳͽͳ΂͵Ͱ
ͿͳͶͽͻͪ΁ͳΒͰ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱ
ͻ͹ͬ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀
ͪ͸ͪͶͳͲͳͻͪ
ͼͳͽ;ͪ΁ͳΒ;
͸ͪ
Ͳͪͺͪͯ͸͹ͷ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸;
͸Ͱ
ͷ͹ͭ;Εͳ

ͳͺͪ͵
ͯͪ
ͼͰ
͹ͽͻͭ͸Ͱ
͹ͯ
Ͳͬͪ͸ͳ΂͸͹ͭ
ͺ͹ͭͶͰͯͪ
ͳͲ
̈́͹͸ͯ͹͸ͪ
͆Ͱͼ;ͷΔͳͬ͹
ΒͰ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͯͪ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀
ͼͽͳͱͰ
;
͸ͪΒͻͪͲͶͳ
΂ͳͽͳΒͰ
ͻ;͵Ͱ
ͽͰ
ΒͰ
ΔͰͭ͹ͬͪ
;Ͷ͹ͭͪ
m
ͺ͹ͻͰͯ
ͷ͸͹ͭͳ΀
m
ͳ
ͽ͹
ͯͪ
ͼ͵ͻͰ͸Ͱ
ͺͪ
ͱΔ;
΂ͳͽͪ͹΁;
ͯͪ
ͼͬ͹Β;
ͱ;ͯΔ;
Ͳͪ
;ͺ͹Ͳ͸ͪͬͪΔͰͷ
ͫͪͶ͵ͪ͸ͼ͵ͳ΀
ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͪ

ͷ͹ͱͰ
ͺͻ͹΃ͳͻͳͽͳ
ͳͶͳ
;ͭͪͼͳͽͳ
;
͸Ͱ͵͹ͷ
ͯͻ;ͭ͹ͷ
ͼͺͰ΁ͳΒͪͶͳͲ͹ͬͪ͸ͳΒͰͷ

ͳ
ͼͶͳ͵͹ͬͳͽͳΒͰͷ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂;
́
ͪ͵͹
ͼͪͷ͹
ͽ͹
ͺ͹ͼͽͳͭ͸Ͱ
ͪ͵͹
ͺ͹ͯͼͽͪ͵͸Ͱ
ͳ͸
ͽͰͻͰͼ͹ͬͪΔͰ
Ͳͪ
ͼͽͳ΁ͪΔͰ
ͯͪΓͳ΀
ͼͪͲ͸ͪΔͪ
Ͳͪ
Β;ͭ͹ͼͶ͹ͬͰ͸ͼ͵Ͱ

ͺͻ͹ͼͽ͹ͻͰ


̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀
ΒͰ
ͺ͹ͼͽͳͭͪ͹
ͷ͸͹ͭ͹

̸̸̹̹͇̻͉͍́̈́́́͠

"O
"MNBOBDL
'PS
UIF
:FBS
PG
0VS
-PSE
w
&TUBCMJTIFE

CZ
+PTFQI

8IJUBLFS
'
4
"
-POEPO











̸̸͉͉̈́́͋̾͋͌

"VUSJDIF)POHSJF
Z
DPNQSJT
$FUUJHOÊ
#FMHSBEF
FU
#VDBSFTU
.BOVFM
EV

WPZBHFVS
QBS
,BSM
#ŽEFLFS
"WFD

DBSUFT
FU

QMBOT
EF
WJMMFT


QMBOT
EÊEJêDFT FU EF NVTÊFT
FU

QBOPSBNB
-FJQ[JH
m
1BSJT

#PVÊ
"NJ
3FDVFJM
EJUJOÊSBJSFT
EBOT
MB
5VSRVJF
E&VSPQF
%ÊUBJMT

HÊPHSBQIJRVFT
UPQPHSBQIJRVFT
FU
TUBUJTUJRVFT
TVS
DFU
&NQJSF
5PNF

QSFNJFS
7JFOOF

$IBUFBVCSJBOE
'SBOÉPJT
3FOÊ
%F
1BSJT
Æ
+FSVTBMFN
QVCMJÊ
FO



1BSJT

%F
1BSJT
Æ
$POTUBOUJOPQMF
$PMMFDUJPO
EFT
(VJEFT+PBOOF

DBSUFT


QMBOT

JMMVTUSBUJPOT
FU

QBOPSBNB
1BSJT

 ͈͹;Ͳͯͪ͸͹ͼͽ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵ͪ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀
͹
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ 

,POTUBOUJOPQFM
#BMLBOTUBBUFO
,MFJOFBTJFO
"SDIJQFM
$ZQFSO
)BOECVDI

GÛS
3FJTFOEF
WPO
,BSM
#ŽEFLFS
-FJQ[JH

-PVJT
-FHFS
-B
4BWF
MF
%BOVCF
FU
MF
#BMLBO
7PZBHF
DIF[
MFT
4MPWÍOFT
MFT

$SPBUFT
MFT
4FSCFT
FU
MFT
#VMHBSFT
1BSJT

:VHPTMBWJB
#BFEFLFST
5PVSJOH
(VJEFT
8JUI

.BQT
BOE
1MBOT
BOE


4LFUDIFT
'SFJCVSH
m
-POEPO
m
/FX
:PSL

:PVHPTMBWJF
-FT
(VJEFT
#MFVT
TPVT
MB
EJSFDUJPO
EF
'SBODJT
"NCSJÍSF

1BSJT

:PVHPTMBWJF
-FT
HVJEFT
/BHFM
99*7
m

QBHFT
m

QMBOT
FO
OPJS


QBHFT
EF
QMBOT
FO
DPVMFVST
FU
VOF
DBSUF
SPVUJÍSF
EF
MB
:PVHPTMBWJF

(FOÍWF
m
1BSJT
m
/FX
:PSL
m
,BSMTSVIF

:PVHPTMBWJF
-FT
HVJEFT
NPEFSOFT
'PEPS

QBHFT

QIPUPT
FO
OPJS


QIPUPT
FO
DPVMFVS

DBSUFT
FO
DPVMFVS
%FTTJOT
1BSJT
:PVHPTMBWJF
1PDIFWPZBHF
.BSDVT
$PMMFDUJPO
NPEFSOF
EF
HVJEFT
EF

WPZBHF
1BSJT


 ͡;ͫ͹ͯͻͪͭ
͈
͉ͳͼͽͳΕ

;VTBNNFOGBTTVOH

-KVCPESBH
1
3JTUJǀ
;VWFSMÅTTJHLFJU
EFS
%BUFO

8IJUBLFST
"MNBOBDI
ÛCFS
+VHPTMBXJFO

6N
GÛS
EFO
6OUFSIBMU
TFJOFS
WJFMLÕQGJHFO
'BNJMJF
BVGLPNNFO
[V

LÕOOFO
TZTUFNBUJTJFSUF
FJO
HFXJTTFS
CSJUJTDIFS
+PVSOBMJTU
OBNFOT
+PTFQI

8IJUBLFS
*OGPSNBUJPOFO
BVT
TFJOFO
/PUJ[CMÕDLFO
VOE
HBC
JN
+BIS


EFO
FSTUFO
"MNBOBDI
VOUFS
EFN
5JUFM
8IJUBLFST
"MNBOBDI
IFSBVT
0CXPIM

8IJUBLFS
TFMCTU

WFSTUBSC
WFSMPTDI
TFJO
-FCFOTQSPKFLU
OJDIU
EBT
+BISCVDI

XJSE
VOVOUFSCSPDIFO
JN
7FSMBH
+
8IJUBLFS
BOE
4POT
-5%
BVT
-POEPO

WFSÕGGFOUMJDIU
BVDI
JO
EFO
,SJFHTKBISFO

%JF
FSTUFO
+BISHÅOHF
XBSFO
WPO
FJOFN
CFTDIFJEFOFO
6NGBOH
EFS
BCFS

GPSUXÅISFOE
BOTDIXPMM
VN
JO
EFS
[XFJUFO
)ÅMGUF
EFT

+BISIVOEFSUT
CJT
[V

FJOFN
6NGBOH
WPO

4FJUFO
[V
HFMBOHFO
&T
TFJ
IJFS
[V
FSXÅIOFO
EBTT
FT

BO
FJOEFVUJHFO
"OHBCFO
ÛCFS
EJF
"VGMBHF
EFT
"MNBOBDIT
NBOHFMU
m
FT
CMFJCU

KFEPDI
VOCFTUSJUUFO
EBTT
FT
VN
FJOF
HSP“F
;BIM
HFIU
EJF
ESFJ
"VTHBCFO
VNGBTTU

FJOFO
WPMMTUÅOEJHFO
-FJOFOCBOE
FJOFO
-FEFSCBOE
GÛS
#JCMJPUIFLFO
VOE
FJOF

WFSLÛS[UF
"VTHBCF
%JF
CFJEFO
FSTUFO
IBCFO
EJF
HMFJDIF
4FJUFO[BIM
EJF
ESJUUF

JTU
VN
EJF
)ÅMGUF
LMFJOFS
%JFTFS
"MNBOBDI
JTU
OJDIU
OVS
GÛS
EFO
CSJUJTDIFO

-FTFSLSFJT
VOE
EJF
7ÕMLFS
JN
FOHMJTDITQSBDIJHFO
3BVN
HVU
HFFJHOFU
TPOEFSO

BVDI
GÛS
BMM
EJFKFOJHFO
EJF
OBDI
LVS[FO
VOE
[VWFSMÅTTJHFO
*OGPSNBUJPOFO
BVT

VOUFSTDIJFEMJDIFO
3FHJPOFO
EFS
8FMU
TVDIFO
XP
EJFTF
+BISCÛDIFS
TJDIFSMJDI

BVDI
IJOLBNFO

8IJUBLFST
"MNBOBDI
JTU
FJO
+BISCVDI
NJU
FJOFS

+BISF
BMUFO

5SBEJUJPO
VOE
NJU
HSP“FN
"OTFIFO
%JF
"OHBCFO
ÛCFS
+VHPTMBXJFO
VOE
EJF

KVHPTMBXJTDIFO
(FCJFUF
OBDI

EJF
JN
"MNBOBDI
FSNJUUFMU
VOE
BOBMZTJFSU

XFSEFO
LPOOUFO
FSMBVCFO
EJF
"OTJDIU
EJFTF
1VCMJLBUJPO
LÕOOUF
BMT
3FJTFGÛISFS

CFOVU[U
XFSEFO

'ÛS
5PVSJTUFO
TUFMMU
8IJUBLFST
"MNBOBDI
FJO
3FJTFGÛISFS
EBS
[VHMFJDI

BCFS
BVDI
FJO
"OTQPSO
[V
TFMCTUÅOEJHFS
4VDIF
OBDI
*OGPSNBUJPOFO
JO
XFJUFSFO

1VCMJLBUJPOFO
'ÛS
BMMF
BOEFSFO
JOUFSFTTJFSUFO
-FTFS
m
V
B
BVDI
1PMJUJLFS
VOE

4DISJGUTUFMMFS
m
JTU
8IJUBLFST
"MNBOBDI
FJOF
LPO[JTF
*OGPSNBUJPOTRVFMMF
ÛCFS

EJF
&OUXJDLMVOH
EFT
TP[JBMJTUJTDIFO
+VHPTMBXJFOT
TFJU
EFS
#FGSFJVOH


ÛCFS
EFTTFO
KBIS[FIOUFMBOHFT
'PSUCFTUFIFO
VOE
USBHJTDIFT
;FSGBMMFO
JO
GÛOG

4UBBUFO

*OOFSIBMC
WPO
NFIS
BMT
ESFJ“JH
+BISFO
CBU
8IJUBLFST
"MNBOBDI

CFTDIFJEFOF
*OGPSNBUJPOFO
ÛCFS
FJO
-BOE
BO
JO
EFN
NBO
TJDI
HFNÛUMJDI

BVGIBMUFO
LPOOUF
*O
EFO
MFU[UFO
GÛOG[FIO
+BISFO
HJCU
FT
KFEPDI
NFIS

 ͈͹;Ͳͯͪ͸͹ͼͽ
ͺ͹ͯͪͽ͵ͪ
̺ͳͽͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͬ
ͪͶͷͪ͸ͪ΀
͹
͠;ͭ͹ͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ 

*OGPSNBUJPOFO
ÛCFS
,SJFHTFSFJHOJTTF
BMT
ÛCFS
(FPHSBGJF
8JSUTDIBGU

7FSLFIS

5SPU[
EFS
5BUTBDIF
EBTT
FT
JO
5FYUFO
ÛCFS
+VHPTMBXJFO
VOE
EFTTFO

¾CFSSFTUF
FUMJDIF
OJDIU
HFSBEF
VOCFTUSJUUFOF
#FIBVQUVOHFO
VOE
NBODIF

VOHFQSÛGUFO
*OGPSNBUJPOFO
HJCU
EÛSGUF
8IJUBLFST
"MNBOBDI
BMT
FJOF

*OGPSNBUJPOTRVFMMF
GÛS
EFO
8FTUCBMLBO
CFOVU[U
XFSEFO
%BOL
TFJOFN

"OTFIFO
VOE
TFJOFS
BMMHFNFJOFO
XFMUXFJUFO
7FSCSFJUVOH
IBUUF
8IJUBLFST

"MNBOBDI
EFO
7PSSBOH
JN
7FSIÅMUOJT
[V
BOEFSFO
'ÛISFSO
0CXPIM
TJDI
EJF

"O[BIM
EFSFS
EJF
JO
JIN
OBDI
OPUXFOEJHFO
*OGPSNBUJPOFO
TVDIFO
FJHFOUMJDI

OJDIU
FSNJUUFMO
MÅTTU
TDIFJOU
FS
JO
KFEFS
"OBMZTF
EFS
3FJTFGÛISFS
ÛCFS
EFO

8FTUCBMLBO
FSGPSEFSMJDI
[V
TFJO

̸͇͉͌͋́
̸͇̺͋̾̓͊͋
"6503&/
%&3
#&*53¨(&

"OUJǀ
NS
ƀFEPNJS
%VSCBCB
ES
0MJWFSB

#BMLBOPMPØLJ
JOTUJUVU
4"/6 'JMPMPØLJ
GBLVMUFU

#FPHSBE 
#FPHSBE
,OF[
.JIBJMPWB
 4UVEFOUTLJ
USH

FNBJM
BOUJDD!FVOFUZV FNBJM
PMJWFSB@EVSCBCB!IPUNBJMDPN

#BLJǀ
QSPG
ES
0HOKFO
ƄPSDžFWJǀ+PWBOPWJǀ
NS
+PWBOLB

'BLVMUFU
[B
VTMVßOJ
CJ[OJT
/PWJ
4BE #BMLBOPMPØLJ
JOTUJUVU
4"/6

/
#FPHSBE 
#FPHSBE
/FISVPWB

TUBO
 ,OF[.JIBJMPWB

FNBJM
PCBLJD!FVOFUZV FNBJM
+PWBOLB%KPSEKFWJD!TBOVBDZV

#PLBO
5BUKBOB ÂJWLPWJǀ
NS
7BMFOUJOB

;BWPE
[B
QSPVǁBWBOKF
LVMUVSOPH
#BMLBOPMPØLJ
JOTUJUVU
4"/6
SB[WJULB
#FPHSBE 
#FPHSBE

#FPHSBE ,OF[
.JIBJMPWB

3JHF
PE
'FSF
 FNBJM
UJOB[JW!FVOFUZV
FNBJM
UBOKBCPLBO![BQSPLVMPSHZV
;PUPWJǀ
ES
3BENJMB

7VLBOPWJǀ
.BØB "SIFPMPØLJ
JOTUJUVU
;BWPE
[B
QSPVǁBWBOKF
LVMUVSOPH

#FPHSBE
SB[WJULB
#FPHSBE ,OF[.JIBJMPWB


#FPHSBE FNBJM
S[PUPWJD!FVOFUZV
3JHF
PE
'FSF
 +PWBOPWJǀ
QSPG
ES
7FSLB
FNBJM
NBTBWVLBOPWJD![BQSPLVMPSH
ZV (FPFLPOPNTLJ
GBLVMUFU
.FHBUSFOE

%JNJǀ
QSPG
ES
-KVCPESBH VOJWFS[JUFUB
'JMP[PGTLJ
GBLVMUFU 
#FPHSBE

#FPHSBE .BLFEPOTLB

ƀJLB
-KVCJOB
 FNBJM
KPWBOPWJD!NFHBUSFOEFEVZV
FNBJM
MKEJNJD!CJUTZVOFU
,PTUJǀ
QSPG
ES
ƄPSDžF
4
1FUSPWJǀ
NS
5BOKB

#BMLBOPMPØLJ
JOTUJUVU
4"/6 #BMLBOPMPØLJ
JOTUJUVU
4"/6

#FPHSBE 
#FPHSBE
,OF[
.JIBJMPWB
 ,OF[
.JIBJMPWB

FNBJM
KNLPTUJD!FVOFUZV FNBJM
UBYFNB!ZBIPPDPN
,VMFOPWJǀ
3JGBU
1BOPW
QSPG
ES
/JLPMB

.V[FK
OBVLF
J
UFIOJLF 1SJSPEOP
NBUFNBUJǁLJ
GBLVMUFU
*OTUJUVU


#FPHSBE [B
HFPHSBêKV
ƄVSF
+BLØJǀB
 
4LPQKF
.BLFEPOJKB
FNBJM
NOU!CJUTZVOFU 6M
(B[J
#BCB
CC
1
G

FNBJM
OJLPMBQBOPW!IPUNBJMDPN
-VUIBS
QSPG
ES
0UP

;OBOTUWFOPSB[JTLPWBMOJ
DFOUBS
4";6 1PQPWJǀ
ES
%BOJDB


-KVCMKBOB
4MPWFOJKB #BMLBOPMPØLJ
JOTUJUVU
4"/6
/PWJ
USH
 
#FPHSBE
FNBJM
MVUIBS![SDTB[VTJ ,OF[.JIBJMPWB

FNBJM
EBOB!TBOVBDZV
.BLVMKFWJǀ
ES
/FOBE

'JMP[PGTLJ
GBLVMUFU 1PQPWJǀ
ES
.BSLP


#FPHSBE "SIFPMPØLJ
JOTUJUVU
4"/6
ƀJLB
-KVCJOB
 
#FPHSBE
FNBJM
TTNPMDJD!GCHBDZV ,OF[.JIBJMPWB

FNBJM
EBOB!TBOVBDZV
.JMKLPWJǀ,BUJǀ
NS
#PKBOB

*TUPSJKTLJ
JOTUJUVU 3JTUJǀ
NS
-KVCPESBH
1


#FPHSBE #BMLBOPMPØLJ
JOTUJUVU
4"/6
,OF[.JIBJMPWB
 
#FPHSBE
FNBJM
JTUPSJOTU!TBOVBDZV ,OF[
.JIBJMPWB

/PWBLPWJǀ-PQVØJOB
FNBJM
SJTUJDCW!FVOFUZV
QSPG
ES
+FMJDB

'JMPMPØLJ
GBLVMUFU 5PEPSPWJǀ
.BKB


#FPHSBE ;BWPE
[B
QSPVǁBWBOKF
LVMUVSOPH

4UVEFOUTLJ
USH
 SB[WJULB
#FPHSBE
FNBJM
KOPWMPQ!FVOFUZV 
#FPHSBE
3JHF
PE
'FSF

1BKPWJǀ
QSPG
ES
4MPCPEBO
FNBJM
NBKBUPEPSPWJD![BQSPLVMPSHZV
(FPFLPOPNTLJ
GBLVMUFU
.FHBUSFOE

VOJWFS[JUFUB $WKFUJǀBOJO
ES
5BUKBOB


#FPHSBE /BSPEOJ
NV[FK
V
#FPHSBEV
.BLFEPOTLB
 
#FPHSBE
FNBJM
TQBKPWJD!NFHBUSFOEFEVOFU 5SH
3FQVCMJLF

FNBJM
EJS!OBSPEOJNV[FKPSHZV
 ̸͊
̹͉͇̾̽̾̓̾ͅ
͈͇
̻͇͇͇͌́͊͋͐͆͠͠
̺͉͇͈̾́
͌ͻͰͯ͸ͳ͵
͚͹ͻΌͰ
͊
̓͹ͼͽͳΕ

́Ͳͯͪͬͪ΂ͳ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
̸͊͆͌
̓͸ͰͲͅͳ΀ͪͳͶ͹ͬͪ


̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
CBMLJOTU!TBOVBDZV
͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ
ͷ;ͲͰΒ
͋ͻͭ
͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͪ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
XXXOBSPEOJNV[FKPSHZV

$*1
m
̓ͪͽͪͶ͹ͭͳͲͪ΁ͳΒͪ
;
ͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪ΁ͳΒͳ
͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͪ
ͫͳͫͶͳ͹ͽͰ͵ͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

 



͊ͪ
ͫͰͯͰ͵Ͱͻ͹ͷ
ͺ͹
͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸͹Β
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͳ

;ͻͰͯ͸ͳ͵
͚͹ͻΌͰ
͊
̓͹ͼͽͳΕ
<ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͳ

ͽͰ͵ͼͽ͹ͬͪ
̸͸ͽͳΕ
͐Ͱͯ͹ͷͳͻ

<ͳ
ͯͻ>>

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ

̸͊͆͌

͆ͪͻ͹ͯ͸ͳ
ͷ;ͲͰΒ
̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

̹Ͱ͹ͭͻͪͯ

͐ͳͭ͹Βͪ
΃ͽͪͷͺͪ



ͼͽͻ

ͳͶ;ͼͽͻ


΁ͷ

͈͹ͼͰͫ͸ͪ
ͳͲͯͪΔͪ

͊ͻͺͼ͵ͪ
ͪ͵ͪͯͰͷͳΒͪ
͸ͪ;͵ͪ
ͳ
;ͷͰͽ͸͹ͼͽͳ

̹ͪͶ͵ͪ͸͹Ͷ͹΃͵ͳ
ͳ͸ͼͽͳͽ;ͽ




͆ͪ
ͼͺ͹ͻ
͸ͪͼͶ
ͼͽͻ

.JU
3FJTFGÛISFSO
EVSDI
4ÛEPTUFVSPQB
͋Ͱ͵ͼͽ
͸ͪ
ͼͻͺ
ͳ
͸Ͱͷ

ΒͰͲͳ͵;
͈͹ͯͪ΁ͳ
͹
ͪ;ͽ͹ͻͳͷͪ
ͺͻͰ;ͲͰͽͳ
ͳͲ
͵͹Ͷ͹Ϳ͹͸ͪ
͋ͳͻͪͱ

͆ͪͺ͹ͷͰ͸Ͱ
ͳ

ͫͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͼ͵Ͱ
ͻͰͿͰͻͰ͸΁Ͱ
;Ͳ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ

͉ͰͲͳͷͰͳ
͸ͪ
͸Ͱͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;
;Ͳ
ͼͬͰ
ͻͰͿͰͻͪͽͰ


̹ͳͫͶͳ͹ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ
;Ͳ
ͼͬͰ
ͻͪͯ͹ͬͰ


*4#/
9

̸͸ͽͳΕ
͐Ͱͯ͹ͷͳͻ
ͪ

͋;ͻͳͼͽͳ΂͵ͳ
ͬ͹ͯͳ΂ͳ

͠;ͭ͹ͳͼͽ͹΂͸ͪ
̾ͬͻ͹ͺͪ

̀ͫ͹ͻ͸ͳ΁ͳ
$0#*4443*%