362 JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH POLICY - VOL. 20, NO. 3
retary of the Committee for the Improvement of Medical Care, pres-
ident of the Physicians Forum, and a founder and head of the Boston
Committee for the Sane Nuclear Policy (publicizing the hazards of
radiation exposure and opposing nuclear testing and the nuclear
arms race), he was elected president of the American Pediatric Soci-
ety and the New England Pediatric Society. Butler won the Ernst P.
Boas Memorial Award for the Advancement of Social Medicine in
1963 and, in 1969, the Howland Award of the American Pediatric
Society.
In his last decades, Butler fiercely opposed the war in Vietnam,
counseling young men who sought conscientious objector status. In
an address entitled “On Vietnam and the Younger Generation’s
Opportunity for Social Responsibility,” Butler, a septuagenarian,
defended the “loyalty of civil disobedience.” He testified for Ben-
jamin Spock, his friend of thirty years, charged with conspiracy to
assist draft resistance. Governments can make mistakes, and unjust
laws must be resisted, Butler declared: “The shibboleth of ‘our coun-
try right or wrong’ was declared at Nuremberg to be no excuse for
wrong” (Butler Papers). Butler died at home on Martha’s Vineyard in
1986 at age ninety-two, never wavering from his beliefs.
Acknowledgment: This article is reprinted from Lois N. Magner, editor,
Doctors, Nurses, and Medical Practitioners: A Bio-bibliographical Source
Book, an imprint of Greenwood Publishing Group, Inc., Westport, CT, with
the publisher’s per
BIBLIOGRAPHY
The Francis A. Countway Library of Medicine, Boston, holds the Allan
Macy Butler Papers. They contain several boxes pertaining to his career in
medicine and medical politics. The Ernst P. Boas Papers at the American
Philosophical Society Library in Philadelphia contain materials relating to
Butler's hearings before loyalty boards during the 1950s. There is no biog-
raphy of Butler; biographical sketches appeared in various newspapers and
obituaries. The Countway Library maintains a list of his publications, with
144 entries. Some of the articles that Butler believed were among his most
significant are listed below.