You are on page 1of 37

3

F AFSFPFòK @BIRI>O
?>@QBOF>K> .23
3+. @na_eieajpk_ahqh]nubeoeÅj^ej]ne] .22
3+/ Mnkpa~j]oCpou`ereoeÅj_ahqh]n .23
3+0 Jna?uhko`apaniej]jpao`ah]
iknbkhkc~]_ahqh]n .24
3+1 P~jpaoeo`alalpe`kche_]jku`ereoeÅj
_ahqh]n .26

@OB@FJFBKQL

?m`^dhd`ioj AB ML?I>@FLKBP


?>@QBOF>K>P
)2 Qaniejkhkc~]u_kj_alpk

hd^mj]d\ij
`a_na_eieajpkatlkjaj_e]h .3.
)3 Ckniqh]_eÅj`ah_na_eieajpk
atlkjaj_e]h .3/
)4 @e_hk`ah_na_eieajpkie_nk^e]jk
+5 @qhperk_kjpejqk7ahmqeiekoR

JBAFA>ABI@OB@FJFBKQL
J F@OL?F>KL
Aapanien
_}hqh]o7n

Ja`e`]`ah]i]o]ie_nk^e]j]
i}pk`kopqn^e`ei}pne_ko .4-

QBJMBO>QRO>
V  @OB@FJFBKQL
J F@OL?F>KL
Bba_pk`ah]pailan]pqn
ah_na_eieajpkie_nk^e]
@na_eieajpkie_nk^e]i
pailan]pqn]o .42
@na_eieajpkie_nk^e]i
pailan]pqn]o .45

LQOLP C>@QLOBP
>J?FBKQ>IBP
NRB>CB@Q>K
> I @OB@FJFBKQL
@na_eieajpkie_nk^e]jk
Bba_pkokoiÅpe_kook^na
ah_na_eieajpkie_nk^e]j

Feic _Yhe eh]W d_ic eiYh[Y[d[dje Z e i bei^ s X _jW ji Z [ bWN_[hhWgk[


f [ hc _j[ d bWl_ZW'_dYbkie[dbei^_[ beiZ [ b] t b_Z e c Wh; d js hj_Y e )

.21
? \ k ~op gj Å  E  ? m` ^ dh d` i oj h d^mj ] d\ i j  .22

E @ ER EO Eô J  ? A H Q H = N 
> = ? P A N E= J =

B jhkoÇhpeikopnao_]l~pqhkodaiko_kiajp]`kh]ao*
pnq_pqn]`ah]oi]_nkikh}_qh]o_ahqh]nao%@]l~pqhk
0&)h]nah]_eÅjajpnaaopnq_pqn]ubqj_eÅj%@]l~pqhk1&u
hkolnej_elekocajan]hao`ah]jqpne_eÅjie_nk^e]j]u `ah
iap]^kheoik%@]l~pqhk2&+>jpao`a_kiajv]nahaopq`ek
`ah]^eko~jpaoeo`ai]_nkikh}_qh]oajhkoie_nkknc]*
jeoiko%@]l~pqhko4u Ŕ &)r]iko]_kjoe`an]nah_na_e*
ieajpk ie_nk^e]jk+ Bh _na_eieajpk ao h] bej]he`]`
Çhpei]`ah]_}hqh])ao`a_en)mqaqj]_}hqh]oa_kjreanp]
aj`ko+

3+.xZ& ? m` ^ dh d` i oj  ^ ` gp g\ mt adn dÅ i 


] di \ md\
Bj i e_nk^ekhkc~]) h] l]h]^n] N]PNTXTPY_Z oa `abeja B db p m\ 3+. BdndÅi]di\md\`ipikmj^\mdjo\]\^dg\m+AgiÇh`mj
_kikmfaf[j]e]flg]f]df{e]jg\][wdmdYk*I]_}hqh] _`^}gpg\nn`_pkgd^\`i^\_\b`i`m\^dÅi+
ie_nk^e]j]peajaqjlan~k`k`are`]bejepku h]aola_ea
oÅhkoai]jpeaja_kiknaoqhp]`k`ah_na_eieajpk_kj* Bopap]^emqaoa_kjk_a_kikk]hlguaoahnaoqhp]`k`ah
pejqk `ah]lk^h]_eÅj+ >`ai|o `ah]_kilnajoeÅj`a _na_eieajpkd]_e]`ajpnk`ah]iai^n]j]_epklh|oie_]u
]ola_pko^|oe_ko`ah_na_eieajpkie_nk^e]jk)iq_d]o `ah]l]na`_ahqh]n`ao`a`ena__ekjaoklqaop]od]op]mqa
oepq]_ekjao ln|_pe_]o d]_aj ja_ao]nek ah _kjpnkh `ah h]o`ko_}hqh]odef]ooaoal]n]j+ Mkn`abeje_eÅj)_q]j`k
_na_eieajpkie_nk^e]jk+Bh_kjk_eieajpk`a_Åikh]o qj]_}hqh])oa`ere`al]n]bkni]n`ko)ahpeailkpn]jo_q*
lk^h]_ekjao ^]_pane]j]o _na_ajn|le`]iajpa ao iqu nne`kajahlnk_aokoahh]i]_TPX[ZOPRPYP]LNTmY%Ce*
Çpeh l]n] ah `eoaÄk `a i}pk`ko `a _kjpnkh `ah _na_e* cqn]Ǿ + Ö &+
ieajpkie_nk^e]jk8aopq`e]naikoaopkoi}pk`koajah Aqn]jpaahpeailk`acajan]_eÅj)pk`kohko_kjopepq*
@]l~pqhk/4+ uajpao_ahqh]nao]qiajp]jlnklkn_ekj]hiajpa)u oa`e_a
Bh _na_eieajpk _ahqh]n ^]_pane]jk `alaj`a `a qj mqaaop|jaj[j][aea]flg]imadaZjY\g*@]`]_}hqh]def]na*
cn]jjÇiank`ana]__ekjaomq~ie_]o`aqj]]ilhe]r]* _e^aqj_nkikoki]_kilhapkuoqbe_eajpao_kle]o`apk*
nea`]``apelko+>hcqj]o`aaop]ona]__ekjaookjpn]jo* `]o h]o kpn]o i]_nkikh}_qh]o) ikjÅianko a ekjao
bkni]_ekjaoajanc}pe_]o+ Lpn]oeilhe_]j^eko~jpaoeo`a ejknc|je_ko)l]n]ateopen_kik_}hqh]ej`alaj`eajpa+Bh
lamqaÄ]oikh}_qh]o)h]oqje`]`ao^|oe_]o`ah]oi]_nk* nal]npk`ahAK>`qlhe_]`kajpnah]o`ko_}hqh]odef]o`a*
ikh}_qh]o)]o~_kikhko`eranoko_kb]_pknaou_kajvei]o laj`a`ah]qjeÅj`ahAK>]h]iai^n]j]`qn]jpah]`e*
ja_ao]neko l]n] h]o na]__ekjao ajvei|pe_]o+ Pej ai* reoeÅj)uh]oacnac]_eÅjna]h`ah]o`ko_kle]oaob]_ehep]`]
^]nck)h]olnej_el]haona]__ekjao`ao~jpaoeo_ahqh]nokj lknh]bkni]_eÅj`ahoalpk%ranCecqn]3+0&+
na]__ekjao`alkheianev]_eÅj)lknh]omqaoabkni]jhko Bhpeailkja_ao]nekl]n]_kilhap]nqj]cajan]_eÅj
lkh~ianko%i]_nkikh}_qh]o&]l]npen`ahkoikjÅianko+ ajh]o^]_pane]o ao iqur]ne]^hau`alaj`a`ar]neko
Rj]ravmqaoa]_qiqh]jajah_epklh]oi]`ah]_}hqh]) b]_pknao)p]jpkjqpne_ekj]hao_kikcaj}pe_ko+ ?]fkh]o
oaajo]i^h]jajjqar]oaopnq_pqn]o_ahqh]nao_kikh] iafknao_kj`e_ekjaojqpneper]oh]^]_pane]@k[`]ja[`aY
l]na`_ahqh]n)h]iai^n]j]_epklh|oie_])hkobh]cahko) [g dalqa`a_kilhap]nah_e_hkajqjko/-iejqpko+Rj]o
hkone^koki]o)hko_qanlko`aej_hqoeÅj)hko_kilhafko _q]jp]o^]_pane]o lqa`aj_na_anej_hqok i|o n|le`]*
ajvei|pe_ko)ap_+)hk_q]h_kj`q_abej]hiajpa]h]`ere* iajpa)lankh]i]ukn~]hkd]_aji|ohajp]iajpa+Bjh]
oeÅj+ j]pqn]hav] ao lnk^]^ha mqa h]o _}hqh]o ie_nk^e]j]o
_nav_]jiq_dki|o `aol]_ekmqa]oqrahk_e`]`i|*
@aka{f ZafYjaY tei])lknmqan]n]iajpaoalnaoajp]j]h]ravh]o_kj*
Bj qj ^]_ehk aj _na_eieajpk) h] ahkjc]_eÅj _kjpejÇ] `e_ekjao u hko na_qnoko mqalaniepaj qj_na_eieajpk
d]op]mqah]_}hqh]oa`ere`aaj`ko_}hqh]odef]o+Bopalnk* Ålpeik+
_aokoa`ajkiej]QT^TmYMTYL]TL%ç^ej]ne]éatlnao]ahda*
_dk`amqaoabkni]j`ko_}hqh]o]l]npen`aqj]&+Bjqj 1 ),  G a f aj j ] n ak a{ f
_qhperk`aqj]^]_pane]^]_eh]n_kik@k[`]ja[`aY[gda(h]o
_}hqh]ooa]h]nc]jd]op]]h_]jv]n]lnktei]`]iajpa`ko Ag^m`^dh d`iojh d^mj]d\ijnpkji`oj _ \ pi\n`md`_`
ra_aooqhkjcepq`knecej]hu hqackoabkni]qjp]^emqa m`\^^dji`ni`^`n\md\nk\m\_ j ]g\ mg\^\iod_\__` oj _j n
mqaoal]n]]h]_}hqh]aj`ko_}hqh]odef]o % B db p m\  3 +. &+ gjn^ jh kji`io`n^`gpg\m`nt o\h ]d}ig\_ dqdndÅi^`gpg\m
. 2 3 Q J E@ = @  . E  L mdi^dk dj n_ `  h d^mj ] dj gj b ~\

k\m\aj mh \m_jn^}gpg\ncde\n+ H\h\tjm~\_ ` gjn


h d^mjjmb\idnh jn^m`^`k j madndÅi]di\md\+

E  @ `adi\`go} mh dijb`i`m\^dÅi+çMp}`n`god` h k j _`


b`i`m\^dÅi<

3+/  L mj o` ~i \ n  Bont _ dq dn dÅ i  ^ ` gp g\ m

M]n]h]`ereoeÅj_ahqh]njkni]hokjaoaj_e]haor]ne]olnk*
pa~j]olnaoajpaoajpk`kohkolnk_]nekp]o8h]ohh]i]`]o
hjgl]xfYkAlk*Bopajki^na`aner]`ahejch}oçCeh]iajpkqo
~ailan]pqnaoajoeperaé)mqa`ao_ne^ah]olnklea`]`ao`a
h]o_}hqh]o_kjiqp]_ekjaoajhkocajaomqah]o_k`ebe_]j+
Q]hao_}hqh]ojkoa`ere`ajjkni]hiajpau bkni]jh]ncko
beh]iajpkoej_]l]_ao`a`ere`enoa+Bj@k[`]ja[`aY[gdau
kpn]o^]_pane]ooad]aopq`e]`k_kj`ap]hhaqj]lnkpa~j]
_h]ra`ahcnqlk)h]lnkpa~j]CpoW+
I]olnkpa~j]oCpoaop|j`eopne^qe`]oqjerano]hiajpa
ajpnahkolnk_]nekp]o)ej_hquaj`k<j[`Y]Y(uoad]jaj*
_kjpn]`kp]i^e}jlnkpa~j]o`aaopapelkajh]oiepk_kj*
`ne]ou_hknklh]opko)hkmqa]lku]h]ateopaj_e]`ah]vko
arkhqperko _kj =Y[l]jaY* Oaoqhp] ejpanao]jpa mqa CpoW
iqaopn]oeiehepq`aoaopnq_pqn]hao _kjh]pq^qhej]) qj]
lnkpa~j]eilknp]jpaajh]`ereoeÅj_ahqh]n`ahkoaq_]nek*
p]o%nwYk]Pa__eÅj.5+2&+

J jg l]yf Yk @lkq \anaka{f []dmdYj


Bjh]_}hqh])h]olnkpa~j]oCpobkni]jqj]l]n]pk`a`ere*
$Z%
oeÅjmqaoahh]i]ah`ereoki]+ Bj_}hqh]o^]_eh]nao) oq
bkni]_eÅj_kieajv]_kjh]qjeÅj`aikh}_qh]o`aCpoW B db p m\ 3 +/  Ag\idggjBonVt g\_dqdndÅi^`gpg\m) #W$?jmo`_`pi\
bkni]j`kqj]jehhk]hna`a`kn`ah_ehej`nk_ahqh]nmqaoa ^}gpg\]\^dg\mlp`hp`nom\`g\idggj_`hjg}^pg\n_`BonV
oepÇ]d]_e]ah_ajpnk`ah]_}hqh]%Cecqn]3+/&+Bopa|na] \gm`_`_jm_`gkg\ij_`_dqdndÅi+H\uji\\ph`io\_\hp`nom\g\
`abejaahlh]jk`ah]bqpqn]`ereoeÅj_ahqh]n+Bjqj]_}hqh] _dnkjnd^dÅi_`g\nkmjo`~i\ndi_dqd_p\g`n_`g_dqdnjh\+Vdk=`n
`a@* [gdaoalkheianev]jqj]o.-+---ikh}_qh]o`aCpoW pi\kmjo`~i\_`ade\^dÅi_`BonV)Bong`npi\kmjo`~i\_`
]djn~io`ndn_`k`kod_jbgd^\ij) BonG\tp_\`ig\n`k\m\^dÅi_`gjn
d]op]bkni]nqj]jehhk _kjpejqkmqahqack ]pn]akpn]o
^mjhjnjh\n)tBon=`npi\=PL\n\+ $Z%=k\md^dÅit_`bm\_\^dÅi
lnkpa~j]o`ah`ereoki]_kikAlk<uUah< %Cecqn] 3+/&+
_`g\idggjBonV_pm\io``g^d^gj^`gpg\m_`?iY^[h_Y^_WYeb_)
Wel>oenra`a]j_h]fal]n]_kja_p]nah]jehhk`aCpoW_kj Id^mjn^jk~\7adg\npk`mdjm)^jiom\no`_`a\n`n8n`bpi_\adg\)odi^dÅi
h]iai^n]j]_epklh]oi|pe_]u hkcn]noqaop]^ehev]_eÅj _`ip^g`jd_`8o`m^`m\adg\)^}gpg\no`Äd_\n^ji pim`\^odqj
%Cecqn]3+/&+Cpo>)mqaaoqj]lnkpa~j]nah]_ekj]`]_kjh] `nk`^~ad^jk\m\BonV+Lmj^`njn_`_dqdndÅi^`gpg\m7kmdh`m\
]_pej]) p]i^e}j]uq`]]_kja_p]nah]jehhkCpoW_kjh] ^jgphi\)\idggjBonV\Çindiajmh\m8n`bpi_\^jgphi\)\k\md^dÅi
iai^n]j]_epklh]oi|pe_]upeajaahl]lah]`e_ekj]h`ana* _`g\idggjBonV^p\i_j`g ip^g`jd_`^jhd`iu\ g\n`bm`b\^dÅi8
_hqp]nkpn]olnkpa~j]o`ah`ereoki]+Bh`ereoki]oabkni] o`m^`m\^jgphi\)\idggjBonV^jhkg`oj_pm\io`g\`gjib\^dÅi8
^]op]jpa`aolq}o`amqad]u]_kiajv]`kh]ahkjc]_eÅj ^p\mo\^jgphi\)_`bm\_\^dÅi_`g\idggjBtnVt_dqdndÅi^`gpg\m+H\
`ah]_}hqh]+Mknafailhk)aj_}hqh]o`a@*[gdaoabkni]d]* ]\mm\di_d^\_jm\`i g\aj ojnpk`mdjmdulpd`m_\)Ö epi+
_e]h]Çhpei]_q]np]l]npa`ahlnk_aok`a`ereoeÅj+>jpao
`amqaah `ereoki]oabknia)h]_}hqh]u]oaaop| ahkj* hqh]n)ahhh]i]`kk]hlg\]\anakazf(d]op]mqah]_}hqh]]h*
c]j`kuahAK>oaaop|`qlhe_]j`k$nwYk]Cecqn]3+0&+ _]jv]]lnktei]`]iajpaah`k^ha`aoqhkjcepq`knecej]h+
Bh`ereoki]p]i^e}j_kjpeajalnkpa~j]oCpoja_ao]* > _kjpejq]_eÅj)k_qnnaqj]_kjopne__eÅjl]n]bkni]nh]o
ne]ol]n]h]o~jpaoeo`alalpe`kche_]jk)_kikh]Cpoh%Ce* `ko_}hqh]odef]o%Cecqn]3+.&+
cqn] Ǿ +Ō &) mqa ao qj] `a h]ohjgl]xfYk \] mfazf Y dY
h]fa[adafYmqaaop|jlnaoajpaoajh]_}hqh]+Bop]olnkpa~*
> mhda[Y[a{f \ ]d > H ; ' h jg l]yf Yk G af  q\anaka{f
j]ooa`ajkiej]j]o~lknmqaoq]_pere`]`naoqhp]^hk*
mqa]`] lkn ah ]jpe^eÅpe_k laje_ehej] %Pa__eÅj 3+1&+ Bh []dmdYj
`ereoki]l]na_a`enecenajah_ajpnk`ah]_}hqh]^]_eh]nh] @kikoad]ej`e_]`k)h]nalhe_]_eÅj`ahAK>k_qnnalna*
o~jpaoeo`ahjqarki]pane]h`aiai^n]j]u`al]na`_a* re]iajpa]h]bkni]_eÅj`ah]jehhk`aCpoW % B db p m\  3 +0 &+
? \ k ~op gj Å  E  ? m` ^ dh d` i oj h d^mj ] d\ i j  .24

hhk`aCpoW_kieajv]]`aolkheianev]noaud]_e]ahejpa*
nekn`aao]vkj]oaeje_e]h]o~jpaoeo`ahkoi]pane]hao`a
h]l]na`_ahqh]nmqabkni]jahoalpkumqabej]hiajpahha*
c]j]oahh]nh]naceÅj`aqjeÅj`aqj]_}hqh]_kjkpn]+I]
lnkpa~j]CpoWpeaja]_pere`]`ajvei|pe_]uao_]l]v`ade*
`nkhev]ncq]jkoej]pnebkob]pk%DQM&)he^an]j`kh]ajanc~]
ja_ao]ne]l]n]h]lkheianev]_eÅju`aolkheianev]_eÅj`ah
]jehhkCpoW%Cecqn]o3+/u 3+0&+
I]bqj_ekj]he`]``ah]olnkpa~j]oCpo_kjopepquajqj
ajcn]j]fa_h]raajahlnk_aok`a`ereoeÅj_ahqh]n+Bjhko
Çhpeiko ]Äko) oa d] ]_qiqh]`k iq_d] ejbkni]_eÅj
jqar]ok^nah]`ereoeÅj_ahqh]naj^]_pane]ou]nmqa]o)u
hkoaopq`ekocajÅie_kod]j_kjbeni]`kmqah]olnkpa~j]o
Cpo aop|j iqu _kjoanr]`]o arkhqper]iajpa+ Bteopa qj
cn]jejpan}oaj_kilnaj`anh]`ereoeÅj_ahqh]n^]_pane]j]
]jerahikha_qh]n) jkoÅhklknikperko`aejraopec]_eÅj
^|oe_]oejkp]i^e}jlknmqap]h_kjk_eieajpklqa`a_kj*
`q_en ]h `ao]nnkhhk `a jqarko _kilqaopko `enece`ko ]
lqjpkoaola_~be_ko`ahlnk_aok`qn]jpaah_na_eieajpk`a
^]_pane]ol]pÅcaj]o+@kikajah_]ok`ah]laje_ehej]%qj
]jpe^eÅpe_kmqaejpanbeanah]o~jpaoeo`ah]l]na`_ahqh]n
^]_pane]j]+Pa__eÅj3+1&)_eanpko_kilqaopko_]l]_ao`a
ejpanbanen_kjh]bqj_eÅj`ah]olnkpa~j]oCpou `akpn]o
lnkpa~j]o^]_pane]j]o nah]_ekj]`]o_kjh] `ereoeÅjlk*
`n~]jpajan]lhe_]_ekjao_h~je_]o+
B db p m\ 3 +0  @pkgd^\^dÅi_`g @ J =t a\n`n_`g\_dqdndÅi
^`gpg\m+H\kmjo`~i\IdiA_dmdb`g\ajmh\^dÅi_`g\idggjBonVt`g j  1 ) -  G af aj j ] n ak a{ f
^jhkg`ej_`g_dqdnjh\`i`gkg\ij_`_dqdndÅi^`gpg\m+ Ai`g
`nlp`h\n`hp`nom\i^}gpg\n_`?iY^[h_Y^_WYeb_^m`^d`i_j^ji H\_dqdndÅi^`gpg\mt g\m`kgd^\^dÅi_` g^mjhjnjh\ `no|i
piod`h kj_`b`i`m\^dÅi_`5-hdipojn+Idi?tIdi@%ij j]_mdY\Yk\]e g \g[gg j\af Y\g'qdYkhjgl]xfYk@lkkgf
hjnom\_\n&njih|n\]pi_\io`n`igjnkjgjn_`g\^}gpg\+ ]k]f[aYd]k]f]klgkhjg[]kgk)= g f dYYqm\Y\ ] G af?'
@ lkT\]^af ]]dhdYf g\]\anakazf]fdgkhjg[YjaglYkq
Bh]jehhkoabkni]ajahaol]_ekajpnahkojq_hake`ao`q* \ aja_]dY^gje Y[azf\ ]d\anakgeY)
lhe_]`kolknmqa)]jpao`amqahkojq_hake`aooaoal]naj)
}opko^hkmqa]jh]bkni]_eÅj`ah]jehhkCpoW+I]hk_]hev]* C  Ö= m v f\gk]\mhda[Y]d[jge gkge YZY[l]jaYfg]f]d
_eÅj`ahlqjpkia`ekna]hl]na_a`a^e`]]qj]oanea`a hjg[] kg\ ] \anakazfZafYjaY:
lnkpa~j]o hh]i]`]o Jej) aola_e]hiajpa Jej@) JejA u C  Ö= z e g \]l]je afY@lkT]dhmflge ]\ ag\]dY[wdm dY:
JejB+JejAbkni]qj]aopnq_pqn]ajaolen]hajh]oqlan*
be_ea`ah]iai^n]j]_epklh]oi|pe_]u ko_eh]ikre}j`koa
`aqjlkhk]kpnk8JejAp]i^e}jaoja_ao]ne]l]n]mqa
Jej@oahk_]he_aajh]iai^n]j]+Jej@uJejAejde^aj 3+0  I m` >  t  gj n _ ` o` mh di \ i o` n 
_kjfqjp]iajpah]bkni]_eÅj`ah]jehhkCpoW+ JejBp]i*
_ `  g\ h j maj gj b ~\  ^ ` gp g\ m
^e}joaiqara`alkhk]lkhk^]nneaj`kajoqikreieajpk
]Jej@u A+@kikJej@uJejAlani]ja_aji|opeailk
>o~_kikateopajlnkpa~j]omqa`enecajh]`ereoeÅj_ahqh]n)
ajhkolkhkomqaajkpn]ol]npao`ah]_}hqh]`qn]jpaoq
ateopaj kpn]o lnkpa~j]o aola_~be_]o mqa `apaniej]j h]
ko_eh]_eÅj)ah_ajpnk`ah]_}hqh]aoh]vkj]mqapeajaaj
bkni]_ahqh]n+Q]haolnkpa~j]oiqaopn]jqj]dkikhkc~]
lnkia`ekh]_kj_ajpn]_eÅji|o^]f]`aaop]olnkpa~j]o+
iqujkp]^ha_kjlnkpa~j]o`ah_epkaomqahapk`a_}hqh]oaq*
Mknp]jpk)ah_ajpnk`ah]_}hqh]aoahhqc]ni|olanieoerk
_]neÅpe_]o+> ia`e`]mqaoad]e`k_kjk_eaj`koqj]pqn]*
l]n]ahajo]i^h]fa`ah]jehhkCpoW)uaopa]jehhk`abejaah
hav] oa d] are`aj_e]`k mqa) _kik hko aq_]nekp]o) hko
lh]jk`a`ereoeÅj+Aaaopaik`k)h]olnkpa~j]oJej]oa*
lnk_]nekp]op]i^e}j_kjpeajajqj_epkaomqahapk_ahqh]n
cqn]jmqah]bkni]_eÅj`ah`ereoki]pajc]hqc]noÅhkaj
iqu`ej|ie_ku mqalnaoajp]iq_d]ob]_ap]obqj_ekj]hao+
ah_ajpnk`ah]_}hqh]u jkajhkolkhko%Cecqn]3+0&+
>  ia`e`] mqa lnkcnao] h] ahkjc]_eÅj _ahqh]nu _k*
@ gje Y []dm dYjq h jg l]yf Yk k]e ]bYf l]k  Y dY Y[lafY
ieajv]h]bkni]_eÅj`ahoalpk)h]o`ko_kle]o`ah_nkik*
oki]oaoal]n]ju _]`]qj]paniej]ajqj]_}hqh]def] ]f hjg [Yjag lYk
%Cecqn]3+0&+I]lnkpa~j]AlkFu kpn]olnkpa~j]ol]npe_e* I]lnej_el]hlnkpa~j]mqa`apaniej]h]bkni]ajlnk_]*
l]jajahlnk_aok+@q]j`kk_qnnah]_kjopne__eÅj)ah]je* nekp]ooa`ajkiej]Hj]=*Bop]lnkpa~j]bkni]aj^]_pa*
. 2 5 Q J E@ = @  . E  L mdi^dk dj n_ `  h d^mj ] dj gj b ~\

n~]o)up]i^e}jlnk^]^haiajpaaj]nmqa]o)qj]aola_ea iej]h]bkni]_ahqh]nna_hqp]j`kkpn]olnkpa~j]omqa`e*
`a_epkaomqahapkoeieh]n]h`ah]]_pej]+I]lnkpa~j]Jna? necajah_na_eieajpk`ah]l]na`_ahqh]najik`ahkoao*
oa`eolkjaaj^]j`]obeh]iajpko]oajaolen]hlknahejpa* la_~be_ko+
nekn`ah]_}hqh])fqopk^]fkh]iai^n]j]_epklh|oie_] I]ej]_per]_eÅj`ahcajmqa_k`ebe_]Jna?aj^]_ehko)
%B db p m\  3 +1 &+ M]na_amqaah_epkaomqahapk`aJna?`apan* _kjreanpa]h]o_}hqh]oaj_k_ko+I]o^]_pane]o_kjbkni]
`a_k_k_]na_aj`alnkpa~j]oJna?u`ahkocajaomqah]o
_k`ebe_]j+Bopkoqceanamqah]bkni]`aqj]^]_pane]çlkn
`aba_pkéaoh]aob}ne_]u mqah]or]ne]_ekjaoajh]`eolkoe*
_eÅj`ahkobeh]iajpkoJna?ajh]o_}hqh]ojk_k_ke`ao`a*
paniej]jh]bkni]^]_eh]nu kpn]oiknbkhkc~]o_ahqh]nao
p~le_]o`ar]nekolnk_]nekp]o%nwYk]Cecqn]1+.&+

G ][Yf ake g  \ ]  Y[[a{f \ ]  G j]<


ã@Åik`apaniej]Jna?h]bkni]_ahqh]n<I]naolqaop]
jkaop|]_h]n]`]lkn_kilhapk)lank hkoatlaneiajpko
na]hev]`kook^nah]`ereoeÅj_ahqh]nuoqnah]_eÅj_kjh]
o~jpaoeo`ah]l]na`_ahqh]nd]j]lknp]`k`ko`]pkoei*
lknp]jpao+Mneiank)h]aopnq_pqn]dahe_ke`]hbkni]`]lkn
Jna?%Cecqn]3+1&jkaoaop|pe_]oejkmqankp]`ajpnk`a
qj]_}hqh]aj_na_eieajpk+ Pacqj`k)ahlalpe`kche_]jk
na_e}joejpapev]`k%Pa__eÅj3+1&oa]ok_e]_kjh]od}he_ao
`aJna?ajlqjpko`kj`ah]od}he_ao_kjp]_p]j_kjh]
iai^n]j] _epklh]oi|pe_]+ >o~) l]na_a mqa Jna? bqj*
_ekj]hk_]hev]j`kh]o~jpaoeo`ajqarklalpe`kche_]jku
`akpnko_kilkjajpao`ah]l]na`ajhqc]naoaola_~be_ko
]hkh]nck`ah_ehej`nk`aqj]_}hqh]^]_eh]n`qn]jpaah
_na_eieajpk+Bopklk`n~]atlhe_]nahda_dk`amqa)ajh]
ahkjc]_eÅj`aqj]_}hqh]^]_eh]n)ahi]pane]h`ah]l]na`
_ahqh]noa`alkoep]ajr]nekolqjpko]hkh]nck`aoqafa
i]uknajrav`aajqj]okh]hk_]hev]_eÅj`abeje`]lkn
bqan]`ahoepekCpoW)_kikk_qnnaajqj]_}hqh]aob}ne_]
%Cecqn]3+2&+Ja`e]jpankp]_eÅj`ajpnk`ah_ehej`nk_ahq*
h]n)aeje_e]j`kh]o~jpaoeo`ah]l]na`_ahqh]najhkolqj*
pko`a_kjp]_pk_kjh]iai^n]j]_epklh]oi|pe_])Jna?
lk`n~]`enecenh]o~jpaoeo`ajqar]l]na``aik`kmqah]
ahkjc]_eÅj`aqj]_}hqh]^]_eh]nk_qnnen~]oÅhk]hkh]nck
`aoqafai]ukn+

= j]k[]flafY
>YmdgZY[l]j [j]k[]flmk( qj] aola_ea `a ^]_pane] _kj
bkni]`are^nek$nwYk]Pa__eÅj .2+.3&)lnk`q_a]`ai|o
`aJna?qj]lnkpa~j]`apaniej]jpa`ah]bkni]_ahqh]n
hh]i]`][j]k[]flafY*I]lnkpa~j]_nao_ajpej]oaknc]jev]
B db p m\ 3 +1  Im`>t ^m`n^`iodi\^jh j_`o`mh di\io`n_`g\
ajbeh]iajpko`aqjkoÖ Õ ji`a]j_dqn]mqaoahk_]hev]j
h jmajgjb~\^`gpg\m)#W$H\kmjo`~i\Im`>_`g ^doj`nlp`g`oj`n
\i|gjb\\g\\^odi\tn`_dnkji`^jhjpihp`gg`\gjg\mbj_`g`e` ajh]_]n]_Åj_]r]`ah]_}hqh]_qnr]`]+Paleajo]mqah]
h\tjm_`g\^}gpg\]\^dg\m)^jio\^o\i_j^jig\h`h]m\i\ `eolkoe_eÅju hk_]hev]_eÅj`aaopkobeh]iajpko`apanie*
^dojkg\nh|od^\`iq\mdjnkpiojn%^~m^pgjnh\m^\_jn`imjej&+ j]jh]iknbkhkc~]_]n]_pan~ope_]iajpa_qnr]`]`ah]o_}*
Ai`nojnndodjnj^pmm`n~io`ndn_`ip`qjk`kod_jbgd^\ij+ hqh]o `a>YmdgZY[l]j%Cecqn] 3+1_&+ >YmdgZY[l]jao qj]
#X$Id^mjbm\a~\n_`g\nhdnh\n^}gpg\n_`<WY_bbkiikXj_b_i) ^]_pane]]_q|pe_]_kjqj_e_hk`are`]ajahmqad]u[wdm)
Eulpd`m_\)^jiom\no`_`a\n`n8_`m`^c\)agpjm`n^`i^d\+H\n^}gpg\n dYkfY\Y\gjYkmqahhac]j]bkni]nqjla`Çj_qhk`abef]*
n`om\o\mji^jipi\npno\i^d\lp`kmjkjm^dji\agpjm`n^`i^d\\g\ _eÅj ] oqlanbe_eao+ I]o _}hqh]o bef]`]o oa `ere`aj l]n]
kmjo`~i\Im`>)lp`\k\m`^`\lp~m`n\go\_\`i]g\i^j)#Y$?}gpg\n
bkni]njqar]o_}hqh]oj]`]`kn]omqa_khkjev]jjqarko
_`=WkbeXWYj[hYh[iY[djki'pi\^}gpg\^pmq\_\^jiajmh\_`
qd]mdj+H\n^}gpg\nn`odÄ`mjik\m\hjnom\mg\^m`n^`iodi\%`imjej&)
d|^ep]po+I]ob]oao`aaopa_e_hkrep]haop|j_kjpnkh]`]o]
g\kmjo`~i\_`o`mhdi\io`_`g\ajmh\lp`n`_`kjndo\`i g\ jerahcaj}pe_ku>YmdgZY[l]joad]ailha]`k_kikik*
npk`mad^d`^Åi^\q\_`g\^}gpg\)to\h]d}i^ji@=LE)lp`odÄ``g `ahkl]n]ahaopq`ek`aatlnaoeÅj`acajao`a`ebanaj_e]*
@J=tkjmo\iojoj _\g\^}gpg\%`i\upg&+ _eÅj $nwYk] Pa__eÅj 6+.0&+ >qjmqa d]op] ]dkn] h]
? \ k ~op gj Å  E  ? m` ^ dh d` i oj h d^mj ] d\ i j  .26

_nao_ajpej]oÅhkoad]aj_kjpn]`kajaopac}jank)oad]j
`apa_p]`klnkpa~j]ooeieh]naoajkpn]o_}hqh]o_kjikn* 3 +1  O ~io`ndn _ `  k ` k od_ j b gd^ \ i j 
bkhkc~]dahe_ke`]h)_kikC]da[gZY[l]j(hkmqaoqceanamqa t _ dq dn dÅ i  ^ ` gp g\ m
aop]olnkpa~j]olqa`ajoanja_ao]ne]ol]n]h]bkni]_eÅj
`a_}hqh]o_qnr]`]o+ Bjh]oa__eÅj]jpaneknnaoqieikohkolnej_el]haooq_aoko
mqak_qnnajajh]`ereoeÅj^ej]ne]aej`e_]ikomqaqj]
_]n]_pan~ope_]eilknp]jpa`ah]`ereoeÅj_ahqh]naoh]lnk*
G g j^g dg _ yY  []dm dYj]f Yjim]Yk q ]ngdm[a{f
`q__eÅj`ajqarki]pane]h`al]na`_ahqh]n+Bjhko_k_ko)
\ ]  dY \anaka{f q  dY ^g je Y  []dmdYj
h]ol]na`ao_ahqh]nao_na_ajaj`ena__ekjaoklqaop]o]je*
>qjmqaoa_kjk_aiajko`ah_kjpnkh`ah]iknbkhkc~]_a* rah`ah]jehhkCpoW % B db p m\  3+2&ieajpn]omqah]ol]na`ao
hqh]naj]nmqa]omqaaj^]_pane]o)hkocajki]o`ah]i]* `a_}hqh]o^]_eh]nao_na_ajajr]nekolqjpko]hkh]nck`ah
ukn~]`a]nmqa]o_kjpeajajcajaomqa_k`ebe_]jlnkpa~j]o afai]ukn%Cecqn]3+1&+Pejai^]nck)aj]i^ko_]okoah
oeieh]nao]Jna?u aolnk^]^hamqabqj_ekjajajaopa`k* lalpe`kche_]jklnaateopajpa`a^aoan_knp]`kl]n]lan*
iejek_kikhkd]_ajaj^]_pane]o+>`ai|o`ah]ateopaj* iepenh]ejoan_eÅj`ahlalpe`kche_]jkna_e}joejpapev]`k+
_e] `a CpoW aj ]nmqa]o) l]na_a mqa ateopaj bqanpao Sa]iko_Åikk_qnnaaopk+
l]n]haheoikoajhkolnk_aoko`a`ereoeÅj_ahqh]nuajhko Bjh]vkj]`ah]jehhkCpoW%Cecqn]o3+/u 3+0&oa]^naj
`apaniej]jpaoiknbkhÅce_ko`apk`kohkolnk_]nekp]o+ ajh]l]na`lamqaÄkodqa_komqaokj_na]`kolknajve*
Palqa`ad]_anqj]_kil]n]_eÅjajpnahko`apanie* i]ohh]i]`]oYmlgdakafYk(h]o_q]haookjbqj_ekj]hiajpa
j]jpao`ah]bkni]uh]`ereoeÅj_ahqh]najpnalnk_]nek* oeieh]nao]h]heokvei]%nwYk]Pa__eÅj1+3&lknmqade`nk*
p]o u  aq_]nekp]o+ Oaoqhp] ejpanao]jpa ]`ranpen mqa h] hev]jhkoajh]_aoche_ko~`e_kol*.)1mqaqjajh]K*]_apeh
lnkpa~j]Jna?aop|aopnq_pqn]hiajpanah]_ekj]`]_kjh] chq_ko]iej]u ah|_e`kK*]_apehiqn|ie_kajh]aopnq_*
lnkpa~j]]_pej] `ahko aq_]nekp]ou mqaCpoW aop| ]oe* pqn]`ahlalpe`kche_]jk+Bhjqarki]pane]hoa]Ä]`a]pn]*
ieoiknah]_ekj]`]_kjh]lnkpa~j]pq^qhej]`ahkoaq* r}o `aaop]o]^anpqn]o%Cecqn]3+2Y%* I]qjeÅjajpnaah
_]nekp]o+ Bj h]o _}hqh]o aq_]neÅpe_]o h] ]_pej] oa lalpe`kche_]jkjqarkuah]jpecqkbkni]qjna^kn`aajh]
ajo]i^h]ajaopnq_pqn]ohh]i]`]oea[jg^adYe]flgkmqa oqlanbe_ea`ah]o^]_pane]ocn]ilkoeper]ohh]i]`kZYf\Y
bqj_ekj]j_kik]j`]ie]faejpanjk`ah_epkaomqahapk_a* \]hYj]\%Cecqn]3+2Z%(mqaao]j|hkck]qj]_e_]pnev+Bj
hqh]n u  aj h] _epkmqejaoeo) ieajpn]o mqa h] pq^qhej] h]o~jpaoeo`ahjqarklalpe`kche_]jk)naoqhp]aoaj_e]hmqa
bkni]hkoea[jgl{Zmdgkmqaokjeilknp]jpaoajh]ie*
pkoeouajkpnkolnk_aokoaq_]neÅpe_ko%nwYfk]Pa__ekjao
Ŕ +Ǿ ) .5+. u  .5+2&+ >`ai|o) h] lnkpa~j] iknbkcaj}pe_]
_nao_ajpej]`a>Y|dgZY[l]jaop|nah]_ekj]`]_kjh]olnk*
pa~j]o`ah]mqan]pej]mqabkni]jhko^adYe]flgkafl]j)
e]\agkajh]o_}hqh]oaq_]neÅpe_]oumqap]i^e}jbkni]j
l]npa `ah _epkaomqahapk `a hko aq_]nekp]o+ M]na_a lkn
p]jpkmqah]olnkpa~j]omqa_kjpnkh]jh]`ereoeÅj_ahqh]n
u h]bkni]ajh]o_}hqh]oaq_]neÅpe_]opeajajoqon]~_ao
arkhqper]oajh]o_}hqh]olnk_]neÅpe_]o)mqalna_a`eankj
oqateopaj_e]ajh]Qeann]iehao`aiehhkjao`a]Äko]j*
pao%nwYk]Cecqn].+Ǿ &+

FYhjgl]xfYG j] < hYjla[ahY]f dY\]^afa[azf\ ] dY^g je Y


[]dmdYj)?f[wdmdYkZY[adYj]k' G j]<^g je YmfY`wda[]im]
\aja_]dYkxfl]kak\]dYhYj]\[]dmdYjYdgdYj_g\]d]b]
eYqgj\ ] dY[wdm dY) FYhjgl]xfY[j]k[]flafY
hjgZ YZd]e ] fl]j]YdarYmfhYh] dk]e ]bYfl]]f
=WybeXWYj[h'^Yng j][a]f \gdY^gje Y[azf\ ] mfY[wdmdY
[mjnY\Y) FYkhjgl]xfYk\]l]je afYfl]k\]dY^gje YqdY
\anakazf[]dmdYj]fdg k]m[YjaglYkla]f]fYfYdg_xYk[gf dYk
B db p m\ 3 +2  O~io`ndn_`g\k\m`_^`gpg\m`i ]\^o`md\n
hj]k]fl]k]fhjg[YjaglYk) bm\hkjndodq\n+#W$Hj^\gdu\^dÅi_`g\n~io`ndn_`ip`q\k\m`_
C Ö K m w hjgl]xfY]m[Yjazla[Y]klvj]dY[agfY\Y[gfG j]<: ^`gpg\m_pm\io`g\_dqdndÅi^`gpg\m+Aigjn^j^jn)g\n~io`ndn_`
Ö K m w ^mf[azf[m e hd]]klY hjgl]xfY]f dYk[wdm dYk ip`q\k\m`_%hjnom\_\`iq`m_`&n`gj^\gdu\`ipinjgjkpioj
%^jhk\m\m^jig\Bdbpm\3+1&+#X$Id^mjbm\a~\`g`^omÅid^\_`
]m[Yjazla[Yk:
]\mmd_j_`^}gpg\n_`Mjh[fjeYeYYki^[ceboj_Ykilp`hp`nom\i
C Ö K m w ]kdY[j]k[]flafYq[mvd]kkm^mf[azf: g\n]\i_\n_`g\k\m`_%ag`^c\n&+?\_\^}gpg\od`i`
\kmjsdh\_\h`io`Ö Z+h_`_d|h`omj+
. 3 - Q J E@ = @  . E  L mdi^dk dj n_ `  h d^mj ] dj gj b ~\

hkojqarkolna_qnoknao%chq_ko]iej],|_e`kiqn|ie_k,pa*
pn]l}lpe`k&oaej_knlknaj`ajpnk`ahlnaateopajpa`aqj]
i]jan]_kkn`ej]`]l]n]arep]nqj]`eo_kjpejqe`]`ajh]
ejpacne`]``ahlalpe`kche_]jk+ Rj]nqlpqn]lk`n~]k_]*
oekj]nh]]qpÅheoeo%heoeo_ahqh]naolkjp|ja]&+

<agkyfl]kak \ ]  h ] h la\ g _ da[ Y f g


I]aopnq_pqn]cajan]h`ahlalpe`kche_]jkoalnaoajpÅaj
ah@]l~pqhk1$nwYk]Pa__eÅj1+5&+I]_]l]`alalpe`kche*
_]jk]_pÇ]_kikqj]i]hh]]jpe*aopn}o)]ik`k`a_q*
^eanp]`aqjjaqi|pe_k+Aqn]jpaah_na_eieajpk_ahqh]n)
h]o~jpaoeo`ajqarklalpe`kche_]jkoqlkjaah_knpa_kj*
pnkh]`k`ahlalpe`kche_]jklnaateopajpalknh]o]qpkheoe*
j]ou h]ejoan_eÅj oeiqhp|ja] `a lna_qnoknao+ Bj aopa
lnk_aokejpanreaja)_kikpn]jolknp]`kn)qj]ikh}_qh]he*
l~`e_]hh]i]`]^]_pklnajkh%Cecqn] Ǿ +Ǿ &+
Bh^]_pklnajkhaoqj]h_kdkhiqude`nkbÅ^e_k`a@ØØ
mqaoaqja]h]qje`]`lna_qnoko]`ahlalpe`kche_]jkK*
]_apehchq_ko]iej],K*]_apehiqn|ie_k,lajp]l}lpe`k %Ce*
cqn] 3+4]&+ Bh ^]_pklnajkh pn]jolknp] aop]o qje`]`ao
aopnq_pqn]hao]pn]r}o`ah]iai^n]j]_kjrenpeaj`k]hko
lna_qnoknaoajikh}_qh]ohkoqbe_eajpaiajpade`nkbÅ^e*
_]o_kikl]n]]pn]rao]nh]+Rj]ravajahlanelh]oi])ah
^]_pklnajkh_kja_p]_kjajvei]ohh]i]`]o_da[gdYkYkmqa
ejoanp]jhkolna_qnoknaoajahlejepk`a_na_eieajpk`ah]
l]na`_ahqh]nu_]p]hev]jh]bkni]_eÅj`ahkoajh]_aoche*
_ko~`e_ko%Cecqn]3+4Z%*

N jYf kh ]h la\ Y[a{ f


Bhl]okbej]h`ah]o~jpaoeo`alalpe`kche_]jk)_kjk_e`k
_kikpn]jolalpe`]_eÅj)aoh]bkni]_eÅj`ahkolqajpao
ejpanlalp~`e_koajpnaqje`]`ao`a|_e`kiqn|ie_k`a_]* B db p m\  3+4 O~io`ndn_`k`kod_jbgd^\ij+ $Y%Pm\inkjmo`_`gjn
`aj]o]`u]_ajpao`ache_]jk$nwYfk]Pa__eÅj1+3uCecq* km`^pmnjm`n_`gk`kod_jbgd^\ij\om\q}n_`g\h`h]m\i\
n]o 1+.5 u 1+.6&+ Bj ^]_pane]o cn]ijac]per]o _kik ^dojkg|nhd^\c\no\`gkpioj_`^m`^dhd`ioj_`g\k\m`_^`gpg\m+H\
@k[`]ja[`aY[gda(hkoajh]_aooaaop]^ha_ajajpnaah|_e`k \pojgdndi\mjhk`gjn`ig\^`nbgd^jn~_d^jn_`g k`kod_jbgd^\ij
`e]iejklei}he_k`aqjl}lpe`kuh]A*]h]jej]`akpnk]`* km``sdno`io`tg\bgd^jg\n\gjnndio`odu\)pid`i_j`gk`kod_jbgd^\ij
km``sdno`io`^ji`gip`qj) $Z%H\m`\^^dÅi_`om\ink`kod_\^dÅi
u]_ajpa%Cecqn]2*3Z%*Fje_e]hiajpa)d]u`konaoe`qko`a
lp`^ji_p^`\g`iom`^mpu\hd`iojadi\g_`_jn^\_`i\n_`
A*]h]jej] ]hbej]h`ahlna_qnokn`alalpe`kche_]jk)lank
k`kod_jbgd^\ij+H\k`id^dgdi\dicd]``no\m`\^^dÅi+
qj]ikh}_qh]`a A*]h]jej] oalean`aajh]na]__eÅj`a
pn]jolalpe`]_eÅj %Cecqn] 3+4Z%* Bop] na]__eÅj) mqa ao
atancÅje_])lnklkn_ekj]h]ajanc~]ja_ao]ne]l]n]hhar]n iai^n]j]_epklh]oi|pe_]`kj`ajkd]u>QM&+Bj@*[gda
]_]^kh]na]__eÅj%h]pn]jolalpe`]_eÅjk_qnnabqan]`ah] oa_naamqah]lnkpa~j]Cpoh%Cecqn]3+/]&aoqj]lnkpa~j]
aoaj_e]hajh]pn]jolalpe`]_eÅj+ Bjh]o^]_pane]ocn]i*
lkoeper]o)`kj`aaobna_qajpaqjlqajpa`ache_ej])hkoaj*
XÂ 0 XÂ0 XÂ0
h]_ao]pn]r}o`ahlqajpaoaoqahajaop]^ha_anajpnaqj]
F0AĴA Ş AFAGĦÈAFÁAĦ AFAF/Ľ6AF/A Ş X Â X Â / I*heoej]`aqjl}lpe`kuqj]A*]h]jej]`ahkpnk$nwYk]Pa_*
- _eÅj1+3u Cecqn]o1+.6u1+/-&+
.
- : M *- ê
F N jYfkh]hla\Y[a{f  q  h]fa[adafY
k
k : l *_n Aao`aahlqjpk`areop]i}`e_kh]pn]jolalpe`]_eÅjao
iqueilknp]jpalknmqaaoh]na]__eÅjmqanaoqhp]ejde*
- è{;*k
^e`]lknah]jpe^eÅpe_klaje_ehej]+Pad]je`ajpebe_]`kaj
B db p m\ 3 +3  >\^ojkm`ijg%pi_`^\km`ijg_dajna\oj&+Ano\ h]o^]_pane]or]ne]olnkpa~j]o`aqjeÅj]h]laje_ehej])ej*
hjg}^pg\hptcd_mjaÅ]d^\`ng\lp`om\inkjmo\gjnkm`^pmnjm`n_`g _hquaj`kh]lnare]iajpaiaj_ekj]`]Cpoh%Cecqn]3+/Y%*
k`kod_jbgd^\ij_`g\k\m`_^`gpg\m\om\q}n_`g\h`h]m\i\ @q]j`kh]laje_ehej]oaqja]ahh]o`af]j`aoan_]p]h~pe*
^dojkg\nh|od^\+ _]iajpa]_per]o+Bj]qoaj_e]`ajqar]o~jpaoeo`al]na`
? \ k ~op gj Å  E  ? m` ^ dh d` i oj h d^mj ] d\ i j  .3.

_ahqh]n)oalnk`q_ah]heoeo_ahqh]n`a^e`k]h]]__eÅj_kj* ie_nkknc]jeoikoaq_]nekp]o+M]n]qjknc]jeoik`apan*
pejq]`]`ah]o]qpkheoej]o %Cecqn]3+4&mqa`a^ehep]jh] iej]`k)ahpeailk`acajan]_eÅjaj_qhperk`alaj`a`ah
l]na`+ ia`ek `a_na_eieajpku `ah]o_kj`e_ekjao `a_qhperk+
I]laje_ehej]d]paje`k}tepkajia`e_ej]_h~je_]lkn Jq_d]o ^]_pane]o peajaj peailko `a cajan]_eÅj _ki*
]h iajko `ko ikperko+ Bjlnei anhqc]n)hko dqi]jko lnaj`e`koajpna-+2*3dkn]o)lankqj]o_q]jp]o_na_ajn|*
lanpaja_aj]h`kiejek@mcYjqYu lkn_kjoecqeajpa_]na* le`]iajpauoa`ere`ajajiajko`aŌ Õ iejqpkoieajpn]o
_aj`alalpe`kche_]jk8ah]cajpalqa`a]o~oqiejeopn]noa mqakpn]op]n`]jr]neko`~]okej_hqokoai]j]o+
]]hp]o`koeooejnaoqhp]npÅte_k+Mknkpn]l]npa)ln|_pe_]*
iajpapk`]oh]o^]_pane]ol]pÅcaj]o_kjpeajajlalpe`k* = j] [ ae a] f lg ] ph g f ]f [aYd
che_]jk u  okj lkn p]jpk `e]j]o lkpaj_e]hao `a aopa
Bjh] B db p m\  3 +5  oanalnaoajp]qjatlaneiajpk`a_na_e*
_kilqaopk+ Pejai^]nck)ahqok_kjpejq]`k`ah]laje*
ieajpkeje_e]`k_kjqj]okh]_}hqh]mqapeajaqjpeailk
_ehej]`ao`ahko]Äko .61-)lnk^]^haiajpaat_aoerk)d]
`a cajan]_eÅj `a 0- iejqpko+ Bopa ik`ahk `a _na_e*
oaha__ekj]`kiqp]jpaonaoeopajpao`aiq_dkol]pÅcajko
ieajpklk^h]_ekj]h) ajah mqaaj_]`]lan~k`k befk`a
bna_qajpaomqaaop|j]dkn]atpaj`e`koajpnaahdki^na
peailkoa`k^h]ahjÇiank`a_}hqh]o)oa`ajkiej]_na*
uhko]jei]hao+Bjah@]l~pqhk/4_kjoe`an]naikoaopaoa*
_ei eajpk atlkjaj_e]h+ @q]j`kajqjoeopai]`a_kkn*
neklnk^hai]`ah]naoeopaj_e]]hko]jpe^eÅpe_koukpnko
`aj]`]o oa nalnaoajp] ]nepi}pe_]iajpa ah jÇiank `a
ia`e_]iajpko+
_}hqh]o`aqjatlaneiajpkajbqj_eÅj`ahpeailkpn]jo*
_qnne`k)oak^peajaqj]_qnr]_qu]laj`eajpa]qiajp]
1 ) /  G a f aj j ] n ak a{ f _kjop]jpaiajpa%Cecqn]Ǿ +Ŕ Z%*
Pejai^]nck)oenalnaoajp]ikoahjÇiank`a_}hqh]o
@pm\io``g ^m`^dh d`ioj^`gpg\m) g\ip`q\k\m`_n`
ajqj]ao_]h]hkc]n~pie_]%hkcZ-&u ahpeailkajqj]ao*
ndio`odu\din`mo\i_jip`q\n pid_\_`n_ ` b gd^\ijt
_]h]]nepi}pe_]%naoqhp]j`kqj]cn|be_]k]eadg_Yjxlea[Y%
o` om\ k } k od_ j `i`g h \o`md\g km``sdno`io`+Qi\g^jcjg
k^pajaikoqj]h~ja]na_p])_kikoaiqaopn]ajh]Cecqn]
cd_ mj aÅ ]d^jgg\h \_j]\^ojkm`ijga\^dgdo\`gom\i nkj mo`_`
Ǿ +Ŕ Z* Bop]bqj_eÅjheja]haoqjej`e_]`knejia`e]pk`a
g\nip`q\npid_\_`n\om\q}n_ ` g\h `h ]m\i\k\m\
mqah]o_}hqh]oaop|j_na_eaj`katlkjaj_e]hiajpa7h]lk*
di^jmkjm\mn`\g\k\m`_^`gpg\m`i^m`^dh d`ioj+H\
^h]_eÅj_ahqh]noa`qlhe_]ajqjejpanr]hkmqaao_kjo*
om\ink`kod_\^dÅiade\\gjnkm`^pmnjm`n`ig\h \gg\
ajmh \_\k j mg\n^\_`i\n_ ` k`kod_jbgd^\ij+
Pd`hkj JÇh`mjojo\g Pd`hkj JÇh`mjojo\g
E  çMp}njig\n\pojgdndi\nt k j ml p}njii`^`n\md\n< %c& _`^}gpg\n %c& _`^}gpg\n
- . 1 /23%/5&
E  ç?p|g `n g\api^dÅi_`g ]\^ojkm`ijg<
-)2 / 1)2 2./%/6&
. 1 2 .+-/1%/.-&
E  çMp}`ng\om\ink`kod_\^dÅit k j mlp}`n dh kjmo\io`<
.)2 2)2 /+-15%/..&
/ .3 3 1+-63%/./&
/)2 0/
0 31
0)2 ./5 .- .+-15+243%/.6&
EE ? N A ? EI EA J P K 
@ A  L K > H = ? EK J A O  pa&
> = ? P A N E= J = O

@kikdaiko`e_dk)ah_na_eieajpkoa`abeja_kikqj]q*
iajpkajahf{e]jg`a_}hqh]oie_nk^e]j]o`aqj]lk*
^h]_eÅj+>dkn]l]o]iko)`a_kjoe`an]nah_na_eieajpkuh]
`ereoeÅj`aqj]_}hqh]ej`ere`q]h) ]_kjoe`an]nh]`ej|*
ie_]`ah_na_eieajpklk^h]_ekj]h+

3 +2  P ` mh di j gj b ~\  t  ^ j i ^ ` k oj 
_ `  ^ m` ^ dh d` i oj  ` s k j i ` i ^ d\ g
Ja`e]jpah]`ereoeÅj_ahqh]nqj]_}hqh]oa_kjreanpaaj
`ko+Aqn]jpaahpeailkpn]jo_qnne`kl]n]mqaaopkk_qnn]
%ah peailk `a cajan]_eÅj& p]jpk ah f{e]jg `a _}hqh]o
_kikh]eYkY_ahqh]noa`qlhe_]+Ikopeailko`acajan]* B db p m\ 3 +5  H\q`gj^d_\__`^m`^dh d`ioj_`pi^pgodqj
_eÅjr]n~]j]ilhe]iajpaajpnahko`eopejpkoie_nkknc]* hd^mj]d\ij) $Y%@\ojn_`pi\kj]g\^dÅilp`n`_pkgd^\^\_\0-
jeoiko+ Bjcajan]h)h]i]ukn~]`ah]o^]_pane]opeajaj hdipojn) $Z%@\ojnm`km`n`io\_jn`i`n^\g\\mdoh }od^\%jm_`i\_\
peailko`acajan]_eÅji|o_knpkomqah]i]ukn~]`ahko dulpd`m_\&j`i`n^\g\gjb\m~ohd^\%jm_`i\_\_`m`^c\&+
. 3 / Q J E@ = @  . E  L mdi^dk dj n_ `  h d^mj ] dj gj b ~\

p]jpa+I]ocn|be_]ooaiehkc]n~pie_]ookj]`ai|o]`a_q]* u1)2dkn]o`a_na_eieajpk)h]p]o]`alnk`q__eÅj`a_}*
`]ouoeilhao`aqo]nl]n]`apaniej]npeailko`acaja* hqh]oao_kjoe`an]^haiajpai]ukn)/23_}hqh]olkn_]`]
n]_eÅj]l]npen`aqj]oanea`anaoqhp]`ko+Bhpeailk`a 0-iejqpko)uajpna2)2uǾ dkn]o`a_na_eieajpkoalnk*
cajan]_eÅjlqa`a`a`q_enoa`ena_p]iajpa`aaopapelk`a `q_aj/-15_}hqh]oaj0-iejqpko%Cecqn]Ǿ +Ŕ &+Mknp]jpk)
nalnaoajp]_ekjao)_kikej`e_]h]B db p m\  3 +6 + ajqj_qhperk^]_pane]jkaj_na_eieajpk]_perkahjÇiank
`a_}hqh]olqa`a]h_]jv]nn|le`]iajpa_ebn]oiqu]hp]o+
=gfk][m]f[aYk\ ]d [ j][ae a]f lg  ]phgf]f[aYd @kjoe`anaikoqj]_kjoa_qaj_e]ln|_pe_]`ah_na_e*
Rj]_]n]_pan~ope_]`ah_na_eieajpkatlkjaj_e]haomqaah ieajpkatlkjaj_e]h+@q]j`kqjlnk`q_pkjkaop}nehune_k
]qiajpk `ah jÇiank `a _}hqh]o ao eje_e]hiajpa hajpk ajjqpneajpao)_kikh]ha_da)oa`af]qj]o_q]jp]odkn]o
lankoaej_naiajp]_]`]ravi|o_kjahpeailk+Bopk`a* aj_kj`e_ekjaomqalaniepajah_na_eieajpkie_nk^e]jk
paniej]mqaajh]oÇhpei]oap]l]oah]qiajpk`ahjÇiank `qn]jpah]olneian]ob]oao`ah_na_eieajpkatlkjaj_e]h)
`a_}hqh]ooa]na]hiajpaatlhkoerk+Mknafailhk)ajahat* ahaba_pkjkaoiqunahar]jpa+Pejai^]nck)oeoa`af]`q*
laneiajpk`ah]Cecqn]Ǿ +Ŕ )`qn]jpahkolneianko0-ie* n]jpaahieoikpeailkajb]oaatlkjaj_e]hp]n`~]ahna*
jqpko`a_na_eieajpkh]p]o]`alnk`q__eÅj`a_}hqh]oao oqhp]`kao`ao]opnkokl]n]ahlnk`q_pk+I]o^]_pane]o`ah
`aqj]_}hqh]_]`]0-iejqpko+Pejai^]nck)ajpnah]o1 |_e`kh|_pe_kmqaaopnkla]jh]ha_da_kjp]iej]jahlnk*
`q_pk`qn]jpaoqna_kha__eÅj+Bopkoknc]jeoikoejk_qko
oai]jpeajaj_kjpnkh]`ko]pailan]pqn]onabnecan]`]o
%qjko1k@&)u oÅhkpn]or]neko`~]o`a_na_eieajpkhajpku
`alnk`q__eÅj`a|_e`kh|_pe_koai]jebeaop]jhkoaba_pko
`ah`apaneknk+Mank]qj]pailan]pqn]]i^eajpakoqla*
nekn)ah_na_eieajpkn|le`k`ahieoikknc]jeoik]_ahan]
ahlnk_aok`a`apaneknkuh]ha_daoalqa`aaopnkla]naj
_qaopeÅj`adkn]o+

1 ) 0  G a f aj j ] n ak a{ f

H\nkj]g\^dji`nh d^mj]d\i\nh p`nom\i pi h j_ `gjo~k d^j


_`^m`^dh d`iojgg\h \_j`skji`i^d\glp`n`\i\gdu\
h `ejmm`km`n`io\i_j`g iÇh `mj_`^}gpg\n`iapi^dÅi
_`god` h k j `ipi\bm|ad^\n`h dgjb\m~oh d^\+

E  çLjmlp}`g ^m`^dh d`ioj`skji`i^d\gj mdbdi\bm\i_`n


kj]g\^dji`n^`gpg\m`n`i^jmojnk`m~j_jn_`od`h kj<

E  çMp}`npi\m`km`n`io\^dÅin`h dgjb\m~oh d^\<

3 +3  & B j mh p g\ ^ dÅ i  _ ` g ^ m` ^ dh d` i oj 
` s k j i ` i ^ d\ g
Bh]qiajpkajjÇiank`a_}hqh]omqaoalnk`q_aajqj
_qhperk^]_pane]jk_na_eaj`k atlkjaj_e]hiajpaaoqj]
lnkcnaoeÅjcaki}pne_]`a^]oa/%Cecqn]Ǿ +Ŕ ]&+ @q]j`k
qj]_}hqh]oa`ere`aoa_kjreanpaaj`kouaopkoalqa`a
atlnao]n_kik/Ñèé/ $+@q]j`k`ko_}hqh]ol]o]j]_q]*
pnk)hkatlnao]iko_kik/Öè;//)u ]o~oq_aoer]iajpa%Ce*
cqn]Ǿ +Ŕ]&+Bteopaqj]nah]_eÅj`ena_p]ajpnaahjÇiank`a
#X$ _}hqh]olnaoajpaeje_e]hiajpaajqj_qhperku ahjÇiank
lnaoajpapn]oqjlan~k`k`a_na_eieajpkatlkjaj_e]hmqa
B db p m\ 3 +6  ?|g^pgj_`k\m|h `omjn_`g^m`^dh d`ioj
lqa`aatlnao]noai]pai|pe_]iajpa7
h d^mj]d\ij+I }oj_j_`_`o`mhdi\^dÅi_`gjnod`h kjn_`
b`i`m\^dÅi%b&_`kj]g\^dji`n^m`^d`i_j`skji`i^d\gh`io`^ji I :Iã.f
od`hkjn_`b`i`m\^dÅi_`$Y%Ǿt$Z%Ōcjm\n\k\modm_`gjn_\ojn
m`km`n`io\_jn`ibm|ad^\nn`hdgjb\m~ohd^\n+H\k`i_d`io`_` `kj`aI aoahjÇiankbej]h`a_}hqh]o)ãSïaoahjÇiank
^\_\g~i`\`ndbp\g\-)0-.,btf`ndbp\g\giÇh`mj_` eje_e]h`a_}hqh]oufaoahjÇiank`acajan]_ekjaomqad]
b`i`m\^dji`nlp`c\ij^pmmd_j`i`god`h kjo+Pj_jngjniÇh`mjn k_qnne`k`qn]jpaahlan~k`k`a_na_eieajpkatlkjaj_e]h+
`no|i`skm`n\_jn`iijo\^dÅi^d`io~ad^\8`n_`^dm)ÖÕ +ÕÕÕĤÕÕÕ Bhpeailk`acajan]_eÅj%c&`ah]lk^h]_eÅj_ahqh]natlk*
^jhjÖ s .-4) 3-+---+---^jhjǾsÖÕ 4)`o^+ jaj_e]haol+f(`kj`alej`e_]hko`~]o)dkn]okiejqpko`a
? \ k ~op gj Å  E  ? m` ^ dh d` i oj h d^mj ] d\ i j  .30

_na_eieajpkatlkjaj_e]h+Mknp]jpk)o]^eaj`kahjÇiank aba_pklkoeperkkjac]perk`a]hcÇjpn]p]ieajpkok^naah
eje_e]hu bej]h`a_}hqh]oajqj]lk^h]_eÅjmqaaop|_na* _qhperk^]_pane]jk+Mknafailhk)_kjqj_kjpnkh`a_ki*
_eaj`katlkjaj_e]hiajpa)aolkoe^ha_]h_qh]nf(u_kjk* l]n]_eÅj)hkob]_pknaomqaaopeiqh]jkejde^ajah_na_e*
_eaj`kfu l(_]h_qh]nahpeailk`acajan]_eÅj)c+ ieajpkoalqa`aje`ajpebe_]nie`eaj`koqaba_pkok^nahko
l]n|iapnko`ah_na_eieajpkmqadaiko_kjoe`an]`k+
L]dY[a{f \ ] = q  = )[gf f
M]n]atlnao]nf]l]npen`ah]a_q]_eÅjI 9I,. )oalqa* 1 ) 1  G a f aj j ] n ak a{ f
`ajd]_anh]ooecqeajpaopn]jobkni]_ekjao7
= gf g [a]f \ g]df{e ]jgafa[aYdq ^afYd\][wdm dYkq]d
I 9IY.f la]e h g\ ] [j][ae a]flg]phgf]f[aYdk]hm ]\ ][Yd[mdYj
\ aj][lYe ]fl]]dla] e h g \ ] _]f]jY[azfqdYn]dg[a\Y\
hkcI :hkcIã'fhkc/
]kh][x^a[Y\][j][ae a]flg\ ] dYh g ZdY [az f []dmdYj) Fgk
hkcI ) hkcIY9fhkc/ h Yjve ]ljgk]k]f[aYd]kkgf d']'l'a q l)
hkcI ) hkcIY hkcI ) hkcIã C  >a^]j]f[a]]flj]dg klwje afgkn]dg [a\Y \]kh][x^a[Y\]
C 9 hkc/ : -)0-. [j][ae a]flgq la]e h g\]_]f]jY[az f)

:0+0DkcI ) hkcI,& C  MamfYhg ZdY[az f []dmdYj]f[j][ae a]flgYme ]flY\]


0t,+1[wdm dYk*e dY0t,+3[wdm dYk*e d]f3`gjYk'
@kjaop]bÅniqh]oalqa`aj_]h_qh]nhkopeailko`a
[Yd[md]] 'd' lq a)
cajan]_eÅjajbqj_eÅj`ap}niejkob|_ehiajpaia`e^hao
_kikI uIã*@kikafailhkl]n]na]hev]naopko_|h_qhko
lk`aikoqo]nhko`]pkona]hao`ah]cn|be_]`ah]Cecqn]
3+6Z(pajeaj`kaj_qajp]mqaI :.-á)I ã 9 1 p .-Œu l:/+ 3 + 4 Z  ? d^gj _ ` g ^ m` ^ dh d` i oj  h d^ mj ] d\ i j
Mknp]jpk)
Iko`]pkolnaoajp]`koajh]oCecqn]o ǾĤŔ u3+6nabhaf]j
f:0)0Xhkc.-5* hkc%2t.-4& Z :0)0ĹŔ * 4)36&:
oÅhkl]npa`ah_e_hk`a_na_eieajpk`aqj]lk^h]_eÅj_a*
:0)0%-)0.&: .
hqh]n)h]b]oahh]i]`]`a[j][aea]flg]phgf]f[aYd*Bjqj
>o~)ajaopaafailhk)ahpeailk`acajan]_eÅjc)mqa`abe* oeopai]_ann]`kk _kjia`ekjknajkr]`k)p]i^e}jhh]*
jeiko_kikl+f(oan|c:l+f 9/,. :/dkn]o+ Peah_na_e* i]`k_qhperki kjkb|oe_kkajZYl[`( ah_na_eieajpkat*
ieajpkatlkjaj_e]h_kjpejq]n]`qn]jpakpn]oŌ dkn]o)ah lkjaj_e]h `a qj] lk^h]_eÅj jk lqa`a _kjpejq]n
jÇiank`a_}hqh]ooan~]/t.-5+Akodkn]oi|op]n`aah ej`abeje`]iajpauoak^peajaqj]p~le_][mjnY\][j][a)
jÇiank`a_}hqh]ooan~]1t.-5)u ]o~oq_aoer]iajpa ea]flg_kikh]mqaoaej`e_]ajh]Cecqn]3+.-+Bop]_qnr]
`a_na_eieajpk`ao_ne^aqj_e_hk_kilhapk`a_na_eieajpk
I ljY k  ] p h j]kag f ]k \ ]d [j][ae a]flg ulqa`a`ere`enoaaj`eopejp]ob]oaohh]i]`]ob]oadY_(b]oa
Bhpeailk`acajan]_eÅjp]i^e}joalqa`a_]h_qh]n`ah] atlkjaj_e]h)b]oaaop]_ekj]ne]u b]oa`aiqanpa+
laj`eajpa`ah]na_p]k^paje`]ajh]nalnaoajp]_eÅjoa*
iehkc]n~pie_]`ah_na_eieajpkatlkjaj_e]h)lqaoh]laj* @Yk] SHN  g \ ]  dYl]f[aY
`eajpapeajaqjr]hkn`a-)0-.,c+Bjahafailhk]jpanekn)h] @q]j`koaejk_qh]qj]lk^h]_eÅjie_nk^e]j]ajqjia*
laj`eajpaoan~]-)0-.,/)ao`a_en)-).2+@kikcaoecq]h] `ekbnao_k)lknhkcajan]hah_na_eieajpkjk_kieajv]ej*
-)0-.,laj`eajpa)hhac]iko]hieoikr]hkn`a/l]n]c+Bh ia`e]p]iajpaoejkoÅhkpn]oqjlan~k`k`apeailkmqa
p}niejk -)0-.,c oahh]i] n]dg[a\Y\]kh][x^a[Y \] [j][a) _kjopepquah]^Yk]dY_k^Yk]\]dYl]f[aY(h]_q]hlqa`aoan
ea]flg(k]^nare]`]iajpac* ^naraklnkhkjc]`]`alaj`eaj`k`ah]deopkne]`ah_qhperk
Lpn]atlnaoeÅjÇpeh`ah_na_eieajpkaoahejranok`ah u `ah]o_kj`e_ekjao`a_na_eieajpk+Peqj_qhperkatlk*
peailk `a cajan]_eÅj) hh]i]`k n]dg[a\Y\ \] \anakazf( jaj_e]hoaejk_qh]ajahieoikia`eku ^]fkh]oieoi]o
]^nare]`]iajpar+ I]rahk_e`]``a`ereoeÅjoaatlnao] _kj`e_ekjao `a_na_eieajpk)jk oak^oanr]napn]oku ah
_kik .,cupeajaqje`]`ao`adkn]*$+ Jeajpn]omqac ao _na_eieajpkatlkjaj_e]hoaeje_e]ejia`e]p]iajpa+ Pej
qj]ia`e`]`ahla]ehgmqap]n`]qj]lk^h]_eÅjaj`q* ai^]nck)oeahejÅ_qhkoapki]`aqj_qhperkreafk%b]oa
lhe_]noqjÇiank`a_}hqh]o)r aoqj]ia`e`]`ahjÇiank aop]_ekj]ne]&u oaejk_qh]ajahieoikia`ek)oak^oanr]
`acajan]_ekjaomqak_qnnajlknqje`]``apeailkajqj jkni]hiajpaqjnapn]okej_hqok]qjmqapk`]oh]o_}hqh]o
_qhperkatlkjaj_e]h+ I]laj`eajpa`ah]h~ja]mqanah]* `ahejÅ_qhkoa]jre]^hao)ao`a_en)oa]j_]l]_ao`analnk*
_ekj]ahhkc]nepik`ahjÇiank`a_}hqh]o_kjahpeailk `q_enoa+Bopkoa`a^a_kjbna_qaj_e]]mqah]o_}hqh]o_]*
%Cecqn]3+6&aoecq]h]r,0+0+ na_aj`ar]neko_kilkjajpaoaoaj_e]haol]n]`ere`enoau
Pe`eolkjaiko`ahkor]hknao`aju `al(oalqa`a_]h* oanamqeanapeailkl]n]oqnao~jpaoeo+Q]i^e}joa]lna_e]
_qh]nc )cur l]n]`ebanajpaoie_nkknc]jeoiko_na_eaj`k napn]ok_q]j`kh]o_}hqh]o`ahejÅ_qhkd]joe`k`]Ä]`]o
^]fk`ebanajpao_kj`e_ekjao`a_qhperk+Bopknaoqhp]]ra* l]n_e]hiajpa_kj_]hkn)n]`e]_ekjaok_kilqaopkopÅte*
_aoÇpehl]n]klpeiev]nh]o_kj`e_ekjao`a_qhperk`aqj _ko)`a^e`k]hpeailknamqane`kl]n]na_qlan]noau nal]*
ie_nkknc]jeoik l]npe_qh]n u p]i^e}j l]n] lnk^]n ah n]nhko`]Äko+
. 3 1 Q J E@ = @  . E  L mdi^dk dj n_ `  h d^mj ] dj gj b ~\

Pd`hkj

B db p m\ 3 +. -  ?pmq\o~kd^\_`^m`^dh d`ioj_`pi\kj]g\^dÅi]\^o`md\i\+ Agm`^p`ioj_`qd\]g`nhd_`g\n^}gpg\nlp`nji^\k\^`n_`


_dqd_dmn``i`g^pgodqj+H\_`ind_\_Åkod^\%opm]d_`u&`npi\h `_d_\^p\iodo\dq\_`g\_dnk`mndÅi_`g\gpu`ipi^pgodqjg~lpd_jtn`
di^m`h`io\^p\i_j\ph`io\`g iÇh`mj_`^}gpg\n+

I]b]oa`ah]pane_e]p]i^e}jk_qnna_q]j`koapn]jo* h]per]`aejpan_]i^ek`ajqpneajpaou`alnk`q_pko`a`ao*
beanarej]lk^h]_eÅj`aqjia`ekne_k]kpnkia`eki|o a_dkaj_kil]n]_eÅj_kjh]o_}hqh]oi|ocn]j`ao)uaop]
lk^na)lknafailhk`aqjia`ek_kilhafk]qjia`ek`a* rajp]f]iap]^Åhe_]]ba_p]jkp]^haiajpa]oq_na_eieajpk
beje`k$nwYk]Pa__eÅj2+/&+M]n]mqak_qnn]_na_eieajpk u]kpn]olnklea`]`ao$nwYk]Pa__eÅj1+/&+
ajqjia`ek`a_qhperkl]npe_qh]n)h]o_}hqh]o`a^ajpajan
qjamqel]ieajpk ajvei|pe_k _kilhapk mqa laniep]h] @Yk] ]klY[agfYjaY
o~jpaoeo`ahkoiap]^khepkoaoaj_e]haomqajkaop|jlna*
Bjqjoeopai]`a_qhperk_ann]`k)ikjkb|oe_kkajZYl[`(
oajpaoaj ahia`ek+ >hl]o]n]kpnkia`ek) oaja_aoep]
ah _na_eieajpk atlkjaj_e]h jk oa lqa`a lnkhkjc]n `a
peailkl]n]h]o~jpaoeo`ah]ojqar]oajvei]o+
ik`kej`abeje`k+ Palqa`a_]h_qh]nmqaqj]okh]^]_pa*
ne]_kjqjpeailk`acajan]_eÅj`aŌ Õ iejqpkolnk`q_e*
@Yk] ]ph g f ]f [aYd n~] aj p]j okhk 15 dkn]o `a _na_eieajpk atlkjaj_e]h
I]b]oaatlkjaj_e]h`a_na_eieajpk)mqau]d]oe`k_k* _kjpejq]`kqj]lk^h]_eÅjmqalao]n~]qj]o1+---ra_ao
iajp]`]ajh]oa__eÅj]jpanekn)ao_kjoa_qaj_e]`amqa ahlaok`ah]Qeann]+Bopknaoqhp]eilnaoekj]jpalknmqa
_]`]_}hqh]oa`ere`al]n]bkni]n`ko)_]`]qj]`ah]o qj]okh]_}hqh]^]_pane]j]lao]]hna`a`kn`a ÖÕ Ň ÖŌ cn]*
_q]haor]]bkni]nkpn]o `ko)u ]o~oq_aoer]iajpa`q*
n]jpaqjlan~k`k`apeailkmqalqa`aoan^naraklnk* Oaoqhp]k^rekmqa]hck`a^al]o]niq_dk]jpaol]n]
hkjc]`kajbqj_eÅj`ahkona_qnoko`eolkje^haou`akpnko heiep]nah_na_eieajpk`ah]lk^h]_eÅj+ Ikmqacajan]h*
b]_pknao+ Bjcajan]h) h]o _}hqh]o aj _na_eieajpk atlk* iajpaoq_a`aaomqa% Ö &qjjqpneajpaaoaj_e]h`ahia`ek
jaj_e]haop|jajahaop]`kbeoekhÅce_ki|oo]jkulknahhk `a_qhperkoa]ckp]uhhac]]oanqjb]_pknheiep]jpa`ah_na*
h]o_}hqh]o pki]`]o aj_na_eieajpkatlkjaj_e]hokj ] _eieajpkk% Ō &oa]_qiqh]jajahia`ek]hcqjkolnk`q_*
iajq`kh]oi|oej`e_]`]ol]n]aopq`ekoajvei|pe_kou pko`a`aoa_dkd]op]jerahaoejde^epknekomqad]_aj_ao]n
aopnq_pqn]hao+ ah_na_eieajpkatlkjaj_e]h+Cna_qajpaiajpak_qnnaj]i*
I]i]ukn~]`ahkoie_nkknc]jeoikoqje_ahqh]nao_na* ^]o_ko]ou) ]hlnk`q_enoaaopk)h]lk^h]_eÅj]h_]jv]h]
_aj atlkjaj_e]hiajpa lank h]o rahk_e`]`ao `ah _na_e* ^Yk]]klY[agfYjaY*
ieajpkatlkjaj_e]hokjiqur]ne]^hao+I]rahk_e`]``a Bjh]b]oaaop]_ekj]ne]jkd]u]qiajpkje`ao_ajok
_na_eieajpkaop|ejbhqaj_e]`]lknh]o _kj`e_ekjao]i* japkajahjÇiank`a_}hqh]o+>qjmqajkoqahad]^an_na*
^eajp]hao %pailan]pqn])_kilkoe_eÅj`ahia`ek`a_qh* _eieajpkajh]b]oaaop]_ekj]ne])iq_d]obqj_ekjao_ahq*
perk& ]o~ _kik lkn h]o _]n]_pan~ope_]o caj}pe_]o `ah h]nao_kjpejÇ]j)ej_hquaj`kahiap]^kheoikajanc}pe_ku
knc]jeoik+ Mknhkcajan]h)hkoie_nkknc]jeoikolnk_]* ]hcqjkolnk_aoko^ekoejp}pe_ko+Bj]hcqjko_]oko)lqa`a
nekp]o_na_aji|on|le`kmqahkoaq_]nekp]ou hkoaq_]* k_qnnenqjhajpk_na_eieajpk`qn]jpah]b]oaaop]_ekj]ne]8
nekp]olamqaÄkohkd]_aji|o`alneo]mqahkoi]uknao+ ]hcqj]o_}hqh]o`ah]lk^h]_eÅj_na_aj)lankkpn]oiqa*
Bopk`a^an~]na_kn`]ikoah_kj_alpk]jpanekniajpa_k* najuhko`kolnk_aokooaamqehe^n]j`aik`kmqajkd]u
iajp]`k`ah]nah]_eÅjoqlanbe_ea,rkhqiaj+ @q]jpki|o ]qiajpkje`eoiejq_eÅjajahjÇiank`a_}hqh]o+Bopaba*
lamqaÄ]ookjh]o_}hqh]o)lnaoajp]jiafkn_]l]_e`]`na* jÅiajkoahh]i][j][aea]flg[jxhla[g*
? \ k ~op gj Å  E  ? m` ^ dh d` i oj h d^mj ] d\ i j  .32

@Yk] \ ]  e m ] jl] h]nckolan~k`ko+ Mknafailhk) oeoaaop|aopq`e]j`kqj


Pe_kjpejÇ]h]ej_q^]_eÅj`aolq}o`amqah]lk^h]_eÅjd] lnk_aok_kikh]o~jpaoeo`aqj]ajvei]l]npe_qh]n)ah`eo*
]h_]jv]`kh]b]oaaop]_ekj]ne])h]o_}hqh]olqa`aj_kjpe* lkjanb|_ehiajpa`a_}hqh]oaj_na_eieajpkatlkjaj_e]h
jq]nrer]ouiap]^Åhe_]iajpa]_per]o)lankbej]hiajpa lqa`aoan`acn]j]uq`]+BopkoÅhklqa`ahkcn]noaai*
iqanaj+Pek_qnnaaopkÇhpeik)oa`e_amqah]lk^h]_eÅj lha]j`k_qhperko_kjpejqko+> `ebanaj_e]`ahko_qhperko
aop|aj^Yk]\] em]jl]* Bj ]hcqjko _]okoh] iqanpa oa _kjia`ekjknajkr]`k)qj_qhperk_kjpejqkaoqjoeo*
]_kil]Ä]`aqj]heoeo_ahqh]nna]h+I]Cecqn]3+.-ej`e_] pai]YZa]jlg*Bhna_eleajpa`ah_qhperk_kjpejqki]jpeaja
mqah]b]oa`aiqanpa`ah_e_hk`a_na_eieajpkaop]i^e}j qjrkhqiaj_kjop]jpa)]hmqaoa]Ä]`a_kjpejq]iajpa
atlkjaj_e]h8jkk^op]jpa)ajh]i]ukn~]`ahko_]okoh]ra* ia`ekbnao_k]qj]rahk_e`]`_kjop]jpau`ahmqana^ko]
hk_e`]``aiqanpa_ahqh]naoiq_dki|ohajp]mqah]`a _kjpejq]iajpaia`ekqo]`k_kj_}hqh]o]h]ieoi]ra*
_na_eieajpkatlkjaj_e]h+ hk_e`]`+Rj]ravmqaoa]h_]jv]ahamqehe^nek)ahrkhqiaj
E]umqanao]hp]nmqah]ob]oao `ah]_qnr]`a_na_e* `ahmqeiekop]pk)ahjÇiank`a_}hqh]oajahoeopai]u ah
ieajpkikopn]`]oajh]Cecqn]3+.-_knnaolkj`aj]oq* aop]`kiap]^Åhe_klani]ja_aj_kjop]jpaouoa`e_aaj*
_aoko mqa k_qnnaj ] jerah hgZdY[agfYd( jk aj _}hqh]o pkj_aomqaahoeopai]aop|aj]klY\g\]]imadaZjag*
ej`ere`q]hao+Mknp]jpk)hkop}iejkob]oa`ah]paj_e])b]oa
atlkjaj_e]h)b]oaaop]_ekj]ne]ub]oa`aiqanpajkoa]lhe* ?d i m ae ag klYlg
_]j]h]o_}hqh]o]eoh]`]ooejkoÅhk]lk^h]_ekjao_ahqh]* Bhpelki|o_kiÇj`a]l]n]pkqpehev]`kl]n]_qhperk_kj*
nao+Bh_na_eieajpklk^h]_ekj]h aoahi|onahar]jpaaj pejqkaoahmqei ekop]pk% B db p m\  3 +. . & mqalqa`a_kjpnk*
aopq`eko`aa_khkc~]ie_nk^e]j])lknmqah]o]_pere`]`ao h]np]jpkh]rahk_e`]``a_na_eieajpk_kikh]`ajoe`]``a
ie_nk^e]j]omqaokjia`e^haooa`a^aj]lk^h]_ekjao lk^h]_eÅj`aqj_qhperk`aik`kej`alaj`eajpau oeiqh*
ie_nk^e]j]o)jk]_}hqh]oie_nk^e]j]oej`ere`q]hao+ p|jak+M]n]hkcn]naopa_kjpnkhajqjmqeiekop]pkokjei*
lknp]jpao`kob]_pknao% Ö &h]rahk_e`]``a`ehq_eÅj)mqaao
h]rahk_e`]`_kjmqaoa^ki^a]ahia`ekbnao_kuoana*
1 ) 2  G a f aj j ] n ak a{ f
pen]ia`ekc]op]`ku% Ō & h]_kj_ajpn]_eÅj`aqjjqpneajpa
= m Y f\gk]af g[mdYf]f mf e ]\ag\ ] [mdlang^j]k[g' heiep]jpa)p]h_kikh]bqajpa`a_]n^kjkk`ajepnÅcajk)
dg ke a[jggj_Yfake gkem]kljYfmfY[mjnY\ ] [j][ae a]flg mqaaop|lnaoajpaajahia`ekaop}nehmqaajpn]ajahna_e*
[YjY[l]jxkla[Y) Hgje Yde ]fl]`YqmfY^Yk]\ ] dYl]f[aY' leajpa`ahmqeiekop]pk+
q dm ]_gmfY^Yk]]phgf]f[aYd)= m Y f\gk]Y_glYf dgk Bjqj_qhperk_ann]`k)h]_kj_ajpn]_eÅj`ajqpneajpao
fmlja]fl]k]k]f[aYd]kg k]Y[memdYf hjg\ m[lgklzpa[gk' ]ba_p]]h]rahk_e`]``a_na_eieajpku]h]lnk`q__eÅj`a
[]kY]d[j][ae a]flgqdYhg ZdY[az f ]fljY]f^Yk]
]klY[agfYjaY)MadYaf [mZY[azf[gflaf {Y'dYk[wdm dYk
hm]\]f]e h ]rYjYegjaj)

C  Ö?fim w^Y k]\ ] dY[mjnY\][j][ae a]flg\ ] dY@a_mjY


3+.-k]\ana\]fdYk[wdmdYk\ ] mfYeYf]jYj]_mdYjq
gj\]fY\Y:

C Ö= m v f \ g f g k]hj]k]flY dY^Yk]\]dYl]f[aY:

C  Ö J g jim w]fljYfdYk[wdmdYk]fdY^Yk]]klY[agfYjaY:

? p godq j  ^ j i odi p j 7 `g l p dh dj n o\ oj

Kqaopn]atlkoe_eÅj`ah_na_eieajpkie_nk^e]jkoad]na*
bane`kd]op]]dkn]]_qhperko_ann]`kokajZYl[`( ao`a*
_en)_q]j`kah_na_eieajpkk_qnnaajqjrkhqiajbefk`a
ia`ek`a_qhperkmqaaop|oeaj`k_kjpejq]iajpaik`ebe*
_]`klknh]]__eÅj`ahkoie_nkknc]jeoikomqa_na_aj
d]op]mqau]jkao]`a_q]`kl]n]oqopajp]ni|o_na_e*
ieajpk+Bjhko_qhperko_ann]`ko)h]o_kj`e_ekjaolqa`aj
oannah]per]iajpa_kjop]jpao]hlnej_elek`ah]b]oaatlk* B db p m\ 3+.. Anlp`h\ _`pi\k\m\oj_`^ pgodqj^jiodipj
jaj_e]h`a_na_eieajpklank`aolq}o)_q]j`kahjÇiank %lpdh djno\oj&+H\_`ind_\__`kj]g\^dÅin`^jiomjg\kjmg\
`a_}hqh]ohhac]]oaniqucn]j`ak_qnnaj_]i^eko`n|o* ^ji^`iom\^dÅi_`gipomd`io`gdhdo\io`km`n`io``i`gm`n`mqjmdj)t
pe_koajh]_kilkoe_eÅjmq~ie_]`ahia`ek+ g\q`gj^d_\__`^m`^dhd`iojn`^jiomjg\kjmg\q`gj^d_\__`agpej
Bjiq_dkoaopq`eko)oejai^]nck)ao`aoa]^hamqahko jn\gd_\%q}\n`Bdbpm\3+.2&+=h]jnk\m|h`omjnkp`_`iade\mn`
_qhperkooai]jpajc]jajqj]i^eajpa_kjop]jpa`qn]jpa kjm`g`sk`mdh`io\_jm+
.33 Q J E@ = @  . E  L mdi^dk dj n_ `  h d^mj ] dj gj b ~\

?ji^`iom\^dÅi_`ipomd`io`n%hb,hg&

B db p m\ 3 +. /  Aa`^oj_ ` gjnipomd`io`nnj]m`` g^m`^dh d`ioj+


R`gj^d_\__`_dgp^dÅi%c & H\q\_j
N`g\^dÅi`iom`g\^ji^`iom\^dÅi_`ipomd`io`n)q`gj^d_\__`
^m`^dhd`ioj%g~i`\q`m_`&tg\o\n\_`kmj_p^^dÅi_`^}gpg\n%g~i`\ B db p m\ 3 +. 0  N`g\^dji`n`ipilpdh djno\oj`i`no\_j_`
mje\&`ipindno`h\^`mm\_j+= ]\e\^ji^`iom\^dÅi_`ipomd`io`n `l pdgd]mdj+H\q`gj^d_\__`_dgp^dÅiqd`i`_`o`mhdi\_\k jmg\
o\iojg\q`gj^d_\__`^m`^dhd`ioj^jhjg\o\n\_`kmj_p^^dÅin` q`gj^d_\__`agpejj_`n\gd_\tkjm`gqjgph`i_`gm`^dkd`io`_`g
q`i\a`^o\_\n+ ^pgodqj+=n~)^jipi m`^dkd`io`_`.+---hdtpi\q`gj^d_\__`agpej
_`2--hg,cg\q`gj^d_\__`_dgp^dÅin`m|_`-)2c*.+JÅo`n`lp`\
ie_nkknc]jeoik %B db p m\  3 +. / &+ > _kj_ajpn]_ekjaoiqu q`gj^d_\_`n_`_dgp^dÅi\go\n)`g^m`^dhd`iojijkp`_``lpdgd]m\m
^]f]o`aqjjqpneajpa`apaniej]`kh]rahk_e`]``a_na_e* \g\_dgp^dÅitg\kj]g\^dÅim`npgo\èg\q\_\ê_`g ^pgodqj+JÅo`n`
ieajpk`eoiejqua)`a^e`k]mqaahjqpneajpajkoapn]jo* dbp\gh`io`lp`\pilp`g\_`ind_\__`kj]g\^dÅik`mh\i`^`
lknp]]hejpanekn`ah]_}hqh]hkoqbe_eajpaiajpa`alneo] ^jino\io``i`lpdgd]mdj) g\q`gj^d_\__`^m`^dhd`ioj%t`god`h kj
_kikl]n]o]peob]_anh]`ai]j`]iap]^Åhe_]+> _kj_aj* _`b`i`m\^dÅi&kp`_`q\md\m\hkgd\h`io`+
pn]_ekjaoik`an]`]ok]hp]o`aaoaieoikjqpneajpa)h]
rahk_e`]``a_na_eieajpkoaaop]^ehev]]qjmqah]lnk`q_* Bjahmqeiekop]pk)h]`ajoe`]`_ahqh]n%_}hqh]o,ih&oa
_eÅj`a_}hqh]olqa`a_kjpejq]n]qiajp]j`kajbqj_eÅj _kjpnkh]lknahjerah`ahjqpneajpamqa]_pÇ]_kikb]_*
`ah]_kj_ajpn]_eÅj`ajqpneajpaod]op]qjh~iepa%Cecqn] pknheiep]jpa) `aecq]hi]jan]mqaoa_kjpnkh]h]^ek*
3+./&+Bjqjmqeiekop]pk)lknah_kjpn]nek)h]rahk_e`]` i]o]_ahqh]najqj_qhperk_ann]`k%Cecqn]3+./&+Peoa
`a_na_eieajpkuh]lnk`q__eÅj_ahqh]nlqa`aj_kjpnk* ahar]h]_kj_ajpn]_eÅj`aaopajqpneajpaajahia`ekaj*
h]noaej`alaj`eajpaiajpaqj]`akpn]) h]lneian]ia* pn]jpa)i]jpajeaj`k_kjop]jpah]rahk_e`]``a`ehq_eÅj)
`e]jpaah]fqopa`ah]rahk_e`]``a`ehq_eÅjuh]oacqj`] h]`ajoe`]`_ahqh]n]qiajp]n|ieajpn]omqah]rahk_e*
%jÇiank`a_}hqh]o,ih&r]ne]j`kh]_kj_ajpn]_eÅj`aqj `]``a_na_eieajpkoan|h]ieoi]Mknhkp]jpk)i]jelq*
jqpneajpamqa]_pÇa_kikb]_pknheiep]jpa+Bh_kjpnkhej* h]j`kh]rahk_e`]``a`ehq_eÅju ahjerah`ajqpneajpao)ah
`alaj`eajpa`aaopko`kol]n|iapnko`ah_na_eieajpkao atlaneiajp]`knlqa`ak^pajan]rkhqjp]``ajoe`]`ao
eilkoe^haajqjoeopai]_ann]`klknmqah]o_kj`e_ekjao `a lk^h]_eÅj _ahqh]n `ehqe`] %lkn afailhk) Ö Õ Ø _}hq*
r]n~]j_kjpejq]iajpa_kjahpeailk+ h]o,ih&)ik`an]`]%lknafailhk) Ö Õ Œ_}hqh]o,ih&k`ajo]
%lknafailhk) Ö Õ Ř_}hqh]o,ih&_na_eaj`k]^]f]o)ik`a*
PYjaY[a{f \ ]  dgk h Yjw e ] ljg k  \ ]  mf i m ae ag klYlg n]`]ok]hp]orahk_e`]`ao`a_na_eieajpk+
Bjh] B db p m\  3 +. 0  oanalnaoajp]jhkoaba_pkomqaoalnk*
`q_aj]hr]ne]nh]rahk_e`]``a`ehq_eÅjuh]_kj_ajpn]* Okgk ] p h ] jae ] f lY d] k  \ ]d im ae ag klYlg
_eÅj `ah jqpneajpa heiep]jpa+ @kik lqa`a ranoa) hko Rj] rajp]f] ln|_pe_] `ah mqeiekop]pk ao mqa laniepa
h~iepaoajhkomqah]rahk_e`]``a`ehq_eÅj_kjpnkh]h]ra* i]jpajanqj]lk^h]_eÅjajb]oaatlkjaj_e]h `a_na_e*
hk_e`]``a_na_eieajpkokjiqu]ilheko)]qjmqa]r]hk* ieajpk `qn]jpa h]nckpeailk) `~]o a ej_hqok oai]j]o+
nao atpnaiko ah amqehe^nek oa nkila+ > rahk_e`]`ao `a @kikh]o_}hqh]oajb]oaatlkjaj_e]h`a_na_eieajpkoqa*
`ehq_eÅjiqu]hp]o)ahknc]jeoikjklqa`a_na_anhkoqbe* hajoanh]oi|o]`a_q]`]ol]n]atlaneiajpkobeoekhÅce_ko)
_eajpaiajpan|le`k_kikl]n]arep]noq`ehq_eÅj)uah_qh* ia`e]jpaahmqeiekop]pkoalqa`a`eolkjan`ap]hao_}hq*
perk `ao]l]na_a lkn çh]r]`ké `ah mqeiekop]pk+ Mkn ah h]oaj_q]hmqeanikiajpk+>`ai|o)hkoatlaneiajpkooa
_kjpn]nek)]rahk_e`]`ao`a`ehq_eÅjiqu^]f]o)qj]cn]j lqa`ajnalapeno]^eaj`kmqah]lk^h]_eÅj_ahqh]naoln|_*
l]npa`ah]lk^h]_eÅj_ahqh]nlqa`aiknen`a^e`k]mqaah pe_]iajpah]ieoi]_]`]rav+Bj]hcqjko_]oko)_kikah
jqpneajpaheiep]jpajkhhac]]oanoqiejeopn]`k]rahk_e* aopq`ek`aqj]ajvei]l]npe_qh]n)h]o]_pere`]`aoajve*
`]`]`a_q]`]_kikl]n]laniepenahi]jpajeieajpk`ah i|pe_]ooqahaji|o^]f]oaj_}hqh]oajb]oaaop]_ekj]ne]
iap]^kheoik_ahqh]n+Pejai^]nck)ajpnaaopkoh~iepao)oa mqaajb]oaatlkjaj_e]hulknp]jpkhko_qhperkoajmqe*
lqa`ajhkcn]n`eopejp]orahk_e`]`ao`a_na_eieajpkr]* iekop]pkokjiqu]`a_q]`ko+Bjh]ln|_pe_])_q]j`koa
ne]j`koeilhaiajpah]rahk_e`]``a`ehq_eÅj+ napen]qj]iqaopn]`ahmqeiekop]pk)oaja_aoep]qjlan~*
? \ k ~op gj Å  E  ? m` ^ dh d` i oj h d^mj ] d\ i j  .34

k`k`apeailkl]n]mqaahna_eleajparqahr]]oqrkhqiaj E  A skgdlp`gjlp`j^pmm``ipilp dh dj no\ojndg\


knecej]hu oanaaop]^hav_]ahaop]`k`aamqehe^nek+Rj]rav q`gj^d_\__ ` _ dgp ^dÅ inpk`m\g\q`gj^d_\__`
mqaaopkk_qnna)oalqa`ak^pajanqj]jqar]iqaopn]+ ^m`^dh d`ioj_ ` pijmb\idnh j
Bhmqeiekop]pknaoqhp]p]i^e}jiquÇpehajaopq`eko E  çO`od`i `ilp`pn\m^pgodqjnkpmjn`ipilpdh djno\oj<
`aa_khkc~]ie_nk^e]j]+Mknafailhk)_kikahmqeieko*
p]pklqa`aoeiqh]nh]o^]f]o_kj_ajpn]_ekjao`aoqopn]pk
mqak_qnnaj]iajq`kajh]j]pqn]hav])aolkoe^haahao*
E gg I A @ E@ = 
pq`ekajqjmqeiekop]pk`alk^h]_ekjao^]_pane]j]oiet*
p]ol]n]`apaniej]n_qaopekjao`a_kilapepere`]``aqj @ A H  ? N A ? EI EA J P K 
knc]jeoikok^nakpnk]_kj_ajpn]_ekjaol]npe_qh]nao`a I E? N K > E= J K
jqpneajpao+ Rpehev]j`kaopkoi}pk`ko) ]o~_kiklk`ank*
o]op}_je_]o`apej_eÅjbehkcaj}pe_]u `an]opnakc}je_k Bh_na_eieajpk`aqj]lk^h]_eÅjoaie`aaopei]j`khko
$nwYk] @]l~pqhko .1u //&) oalqa`ajenaopq`e]j`khko _]i^ekoajahjÇiank`a_}hqh]o)ajh]_]jpe`]``a]hcÇj
_]i^ekoajh]_kiqje`]`ie_nk^e]j]`ahmqeiekop]pkaj _kilkjajpa`ah]oieoi]o)_kiklnkpa~j]o)|_e`kojq*
bqj_eÅj`ah]o`ebanajpao_kj`e_ekjao`a_na_eieajpk+> _hae_kokahlaokoa_k`ah]o_}hqh]o+>mq~_kjoe`an]naiko
iajq`k)aopkoatlaneiajpkonarah]jejpan]__ekjaoajpna `koi}pk`kobna_qajpao`aia`enah_na_eieajpk7 ahna*
_kilkjajpao`ah]lk^h]_eÅjmqajknaoqhp]jare`ajpao _qajpk`ahjÇiank`a_}hqh]ouh]`apaniej]_eÅj`ah]
ia`e]jpaaopq`eko`a_na_eieajpkaj_qhperko_ann]`ko+ pqn^e`av)}opaÇhpeik_kikia`e`]`ah]^eki]o]+
Ikomqeiekop]pkop]i^e}joaqo]jl]n]ah]eoh]ieajpk
uajnemqa_eieajpk`a^]_pane]o+> l]npen`aqjejÅ_qhk
ietpk`aqj]iqaopn]j]pqn]h)oalqa`aoaha__ekj]nqj] 3 +6  @ ` o` mh di \ ^ dÅ i  _ ` g i Ç h ` mj 
lk^h]_eÅjaop]^ha^]fk`apaniej]`]o_kj`e_ekjao`ajq* o j o\ g _ `  ^}gpg\n7 m` ^ p ` i oj 
pneajpaou `arahk_e`]``a`ehq_eÅjahace`]o)uhqackenaj* h d^ mj n ^ Å k d^ j
_naiajp]j`khajp]iajpah]rahk_e`]``a`ehq_eÅjd]op]
mqa oÅhk mqa`a qj pelk `a ie_nkknc]jeoik+ Aa aopa BhjÇiankpkp]h`a_}hqh]oie_nk^e]j]ooalqa`ak^pajan
ik`k) oad]_kjoacqe`kna_eajpaiajpa]eoh]n`ahoqahk qo]j`kqjie_nko_klekl]n]k^oanr]nu_kjp]nh]o_}hq*
qj]^]_pane]_kjqjpeailk`acajan]_eÅj`aǾ iejqpko) h]olnaoajpaoajqj_qhperkkajqj]iqaopn]j]pqn]h+Bh
mqaaoh]^]_pane]`a_na_eieajpki|on|le`k_kjk_e`]+ i}pk`kaooeilhalankhkonaoqhp]`kolqa`ajoanlk_koa*
cqnko+
1 ) 3  G a f aj j ] n ak a{ f
L ][m ]f lg  \ ]  [xdmdYk lg lY d] k
Hjndinomph `iojn_`^pgodqj^ ji odip j%lpdh djno\ojn& Bhi}pk`ki|obna_qajpal]n]`apaniej]nahjÇiank`a
k`mh do`i h \io`i`mkj]g\^dji`n^`gpg\m`n`i^m`^dh `dioj _}hqh]opkp]haoaoahna_qajpkie_nko_Åle_k`ena_pk+ Bh
`skji`i^d\g k j mg\mbjnk`m~j_jn+ Aipilp dh dj no\oj)g\ _kjp]faie_nko_Åle_k`ena_pkoalqa`ad]_anajiqaopn]o
q`gj^d_\__ ` _ dgp ^dÅ i_ `g^pgodqjb j]d` mi \g\q`gj^d_\_ oa_]ook^nalknp]kajiqaopn]oh~mqe`]o+ I]oiqaopn]o
_`^m`^dh d`ioj)h d`iom\nlp`` go\h \Äj_ ` g\kj]g\^dÅi oa_]ooalqa`ajpaÄenl]n]]qiajp]nah_kjpn]opaajpnah]o
`no|_` o` mh di\ _jk j mg\^ji^`iom\^dÅi_ ` i pomd`io` _}hqh]ouahbkj`k$nwYk]Pa__eÅj/+/&+@kjiqaopn]oh~*
gdh do\ io`lp``iom\`i`g m`^dkd`io`+ mqe`]ooaailha]j_|i]n]o`ana_qajpkaola_e]hao)mqa
E  çAilp}n`_ da`m`i^d\igjnh d^mjjmb\idnh jn_ ` pi aj aoaj_e] okj lknp]o at_]r]`ko u  ik`ebe_]`ko ok^na
gk _c _e ijWje_ ` gjnkmj^`_`io`n_ ` pi^ pgodq j`i _qu]oqlanbe_ea`are`nekaop|i]n_]`]qj]nafehh]_kjla*
i_ij[c WY[hhWZe< mqaÄko_q]`n]`ko`a|na]_kjk_e`]% B db p m\  3 +. 1 &+ @]`]

L\m\^\g^pg\m`giÇh`mjkjmhdgdgdomj
_`hp`nom\7./^}gpg\ns/2^p\_mjn
bm\i_`ns2-s.-Ŏ
a a a

JÇh`mj,hhŌ%0s Ö j/&
H\hp`nom\n`\Ä\_`\lp~^ji^pd_\_j
_`lp`ijm`]jn`8`g`nk\^dj`iom` JÇh`mj,hhŎ%.)2sÖÕ 1&
kjmo\t^p]m``n_`-)-/hh%.,2-hh&+
H\m`edgg\od`i`/2^p\_m\_jnbm\i_`n)
pi|m`\ojo\g_`Ö hhŌtpiqjgph`i JÇh`mj,^hŎ%hd&%.)2s.-4&
ojo\g_`ÕĞÕŌhh0+

B db p m\ 3 +. 1  Lmj^`_dh d`ioj_`^ jio\e`h d^mjn^Åkd^j_dm`^ojpodgdu\i_jpi\ ^|h\m\_ ` odk j L`omjaa*D\pnn`m+Jjmh\gh`io`n`


pn\pih d^mjn^jkdj_`^jiom\no`_`a\n`nk\m\`gm`^p`ioj_`^}gpg\n)`qdo|i_jn`g\i`^`nd_\__`odi^dÅi+
. 3 5 Q J E@ = @  . E  L mdi^dk dj n_ `  h d^mj ] dj gj b ~\

_q]`n]`k`ah]l]nnehh] _kjpejaqjrkhqiaj_kjk_e`k) E  ç?p|g`nnjigjnk mj]g`h \nlp`kp`_`inpmbdm^p\i_j


iqulamqaÄklank`apaniej]`k_kjlna_eoeÅj+?]fkah n`` h kg`\ikm`k\m\^dji`nijo`Äd_\nk\m\`g m`^p`ioj
ie_nko_klekoalqa`a_kjp]nahjÇiank`a_}hqh]olkn _`^}gpg\noj o\g` n`ih p`nom\n_`\h ]d` io`ni\opm\g`n<
_]`]qje`]``a|na]`ah]l]nnehh])hkmqalaniepa_kjk*
_anahjÇiank`a_}hqh]olknahrkhqiajmqa`apaniej]
_]`]|na]+I]_kjranoeÅj`ap]hr]hkn]jÇiank`a_}hqh]o
lkniehehepnk`ah]oqolajoeÅjknecej]hoad]_ab|_ehiajpa 3 +. -  E N ` ^p`ioj _ `  ^}gpg\nq d\ ] g` n
iqhpelhe_]j`klknqjb]_pkn`a_kjranoeÅjmqa`alaj`a
Rj]_}hqh]aTLMWPao]mqahh]mqaao_]l]v`a`ere`enoaukne*
`ahrkhqiaj`ahpelk`a_|i]n]%Cecqn]3+.1&+
cej]n`ao_aj`aj_e])uajh]i]ukn~]`ah]ooepq]_ekjao}opa
Rjoacqj`ki}pk`k`a_kjp]n_}hqh]oajiqaopn]oh~*
aoahpelk`a_}hqh]omqajkoejpanao]+@kjaopabejoad]j`ao*
mqe`]oaoah_epÅiapnk`abhqfk+ Bopa]l]n]pkailha]qj
]nnkhh]`ki}pk`ko`ana_qajpk`are]^hao+Kkni]hiajpaoa
n]ukh|oanuqjoeopai]aha_pnÅje_kl]n]_kjp]n_}hqh]oej*
`apaniej]ahjÇiank`a_}hqh]o`ah]iqaopn]mqaao_]l]v
`ere`q]hao+Bhi}pk`koaqo]lk_kl]n]h]`apaniej]_eÅj
nqpej]ne]`ana_qajpko`a_}hqh]oie_nk^e]j]olankpeaja `abkni]n_khkje]ook^naqjia`ekoÅhe`k]`a_q]`k+Mkn
aop]n]vÅj)h]`apaniej]_eÅj`are]^hao]iajq`koahh]i]
]lhe_]_ekjaoajah_]ilk`ah]ia`e_ej]l]n]`ebanaj_e]n
p]i^e}j]PN`PY_ZPY[WLNLk]PN`PY_ZOPNZWZYTL^$Bj
chÅ^qhkonkfko`akpnkopelko_ahqh]naoajiqaopn]o_h~je*
aopalnk_a`eieajpkoaoqlkjamqa_]`]_}hqh]re]^halqa`a
_]o$nwYk]Cecqn]0/+/.&+Pad]ailha]`kp]i^e}jaja_k*
hkc~] ie_nk^e]j] lknmqa laniepa oal]n]n _}hqh]o `a _na_anu`ere`enoad]op]bkni]nqj]_khkje]+>o~)ahjÇiank
`a_khkje]ouahjÇiank`a_}hqh]ookjlnklkn_ekj]hao+
`ebanajpaopelko]bej`ahkcn]n]eoh]ieajpko+
E]u]hiajko `koi]jan]o `ana]hev]nqjna_qajpk
Bh_kjp]faie_nko_Åle_k`ena_pkaoqji}pk`kn|le`k
ajlh]_]l]n]re]^hao7ahewlg\g\]]pl]fkazf]fhdY[Yuah
`a_kjk_anahjÇiank`a_}hqh]o+Pejai^]nck)lnaoajp]
_eanp]oheiep]_ekjao7% Ö &oejp}_je_]oaola_e]hao`apej_eÅj ewlg\g\]n]jla\g]fhdY[Y%B db p m\ 3 +. 2 &+Bjahi}pk`k`a
atpajoeÅjajlh]_]qjrkhqiaj`a_qhperk`ehqe`k]lnk*
$nwYk]Pa__ekjao/+/u//+0&jklaniepa`eopejcqenajpna_}*
le]`]iajpa) mqajkoqahaoanoqlanekn] Õ Ğ Ö  ie) oaat*
hqh]orer]ou _}hqh]oiqanp]o8%Ō & h]o_}hqh]olamqaÄ]ookj
peaj`aok^nah]oqlanbe_ea`aqj]lh]_]_kjia`ekoÅhe`k
`eb~_ehao`aran^]fkahie_nko_kleku]hcqj]ooalean`ajaj
qpehev]j`kqj]o]aop}neh`aatpajoeÅj+I]lh]_]oaej_q^]
ahna_qajpk8%0&ao`eb~_ehajk_]oekjaoh]lna_eoeÅj8%1&oana*
] _kjpejq]_eÅj d]op] mqa ]l]na_aj h]o _khkje]o u  oa
mqeanaqjie_nko_klek`a_kjpn]opa`ab]oao_q]j`kh]o
_qajp]oqjÇiank+Boeilknp]jpamqah]oqlanbe_ea`ah
iqaopn]ojkoapeÄaj8%2&ahi}pk`kjkoqahaoan]`a_q]`k
l]n]oqolajoekjao`a^]f]`ajoe`]`_ahqh]n%iajko`aÖÕ Ǿ ia`ekaop}oa_]`aik`kmqaahh~mqe`k`ah]iqaopn]oa
]^okn^]u h]o_}hqh]omqa`ajbef]`]o+Kkoaoqahajqo]nrk*
_}hqh]o^]_pane]j]olkniehehepnk&lqaoaolkoe^hamqajkoa
hÇiajaoi]uknao`aÕ Ğ Ö  ielknmqaahat_aok`ah~mqe`k
ra]j^]_pane]oajah_]ilk`ahie_nko_klek]iajkomqa
h]iqaopn]oa_kj_ajpnalneianku oanaoqolaj`]hqackaj jkoa]^okn^auknecej]lnk^hai]oajah_kjp]fa]hb]rk*
na_anh]atpajoeÅju iav_h]`ah]o_khkje]o+
qjlamqaÄkrkhqiaj8% Ǿ &h]o_}hqh]oiÅrehaooa`a^ajej*
Bjahi}pk`k`ahranpe`kajlh]_]%Cecqn]3+.2&oale*
ikrehev]n]jpao`ah_kjp]fa8%4&hkonaopkolnaoajpaoajh]
lapa]qjrkhqiaj_kjk_e`k%jkni]hiajpaÕ ) Ö * Ö Ğ Õ ie&`a
iqaopn]lqa`aj_kjp]noaannÅja]iajpa_kik_}hqh]o+
Bja_khkc~]ie_nk^e]j])h]`apaniej]_eÅj`a_}hqh]o _qhperkajqj]lh]_]Mapneaop}nehok^nah]mqaoa]Ä]`aah
ia`ek_kj]c]nbqj`e`ku oaiav_h]pk`k^eaj_kjoq]rao
pkp]haooana]hev]]iajq`kajiqaopn]oj]pqn]haoailha*
ikreieajpko`ah]lh]_]ok^nah]oqlanbe_ea`ah]iao]
]j`kpej_ekjaol]n]reoq]hev]nh]o_}hqh]o+ Bh_khkn]jpa
]jpao`a`af]nokhe`ebe_]n+@kikh]iqaopn]oaiav_h]_kj
A>MFpeÄapk`]oh]o_}hqh]olknmqana]__ekj]_kjahAK>+
Mknkpn]l]npa)oalqa`ajlnal]n]n_khkn]jpaobhqknao_aj* ahia`ekbqj`e`k)oalqa`ajqo]nrkhÇiao`aejÅ_qhki]*
uknaomqaajahi}pk`k`a_kjp]falknatpajoeÅj8oejai*
paoiquaola_~be_kol]n]i]n_]nknc]jeoikokcnqlko`a*
^]nck)_kjaopai}pk`kahknc]jeoikmqaoa_qajp]`a^a
paniej]`ko qje}j`khko ] okj`]o aola_~be_]o `a |_e`ko
jq_hae_ko $nwYk] Pa__eÅj//+1&+Peh]o_}hqh]oaop|jlna* oan_]l]v`anaoeopenh ]pailan]pqn]`ah]c]nbqj`e`k%12k*
oajpao]^]f]`ajoe`]``alk^h]_eÅj)_kiklknafailhk 2-Ñ@&+>mq~h]o_khkje]ooabkni]jlknpk`]h]lh]_]u jk
okh]iajpalknh]oqlanbe_ea_kikajahi}pk`klknat*
oq_a`aajiqaopn]ok_a|je_]o)lneiankoa_kj_ajpn]jok*
pajoeÅj+Mkn_kjoecqeajpa)h]lh]_]`a^aat]iej]noa_qe*
^naqjbehpnkuhqackoa_qajp]jpn]oh]pej_eÅj+@kikaob|*
_eh`ana]hev]nu lqa`alnklkn_ekj]nqj]ejbkni]_eÅjiqu `]`ko]iajpal]n]pajanh]oacqne`]``a_kjp]npk`]oh]o
_khkje]o+Peaopai}pk`koaqo]l]n]ajqian]n_}hqh]o`a
Çpeh)ahna_qajpk`a_}hqh]opkp]haolknqjkqkpnki}pk`k
qj]iqaopn]j]pqn]h)lqa`aoqncenkpnklnk^hai]8_q]h*
aobna_qajpaajaopq`ekoie_nk^ekhÅce_ko`a]i^eajpaoj]*
pqn]hao+ r r r +h d^ mj ] dj gj b t k g\ ^ ` +^ j h  P p ojmd\ g j i gdi `  3+.7 mqeannaopklnaoajpaajh]iqaopn]`a^a`eopejcqenoa`a
h]o_khkje]o^]_pane]j]ona]haokahna_qajpkoan|annÅjak+
Lmj^` _dh d`i oj_` g m`^p `i ojh d^mjn^Åkd^j_ dm`^ oj+

>adm[a{f \ ] dYkkmkh]fkagf]k []dmdYj]k Yfl]k


1 ) 4  G af aj j ] n ak a{ f
\ ]  dY ka]e ZjY ]f hdY[Y
Ag^jio\e`^`gpg\mh d^mjn^Åkd^jh d_ ``g iÇh `mjoj o\ g_` Bjhko`koi}pk`kooaÄ]h]`ko]jpanekniajpaaoeilkn*
^}gpg\n`ipi^ pgodq j_ ` g\] jm\ojmdjj `ipi\hp`nom\ p]jpamqaahjÇiank`a_khkje]omqa]l]nav_]ajh]olh]*
i\opm\g+ _]ojkoa]`ai]oe]`kcn]j`aje`ai]oe]`klamqaÄk+Bj
? \ k ~op gj Å  E  ? m` ^ dh d` i oj h d^mj ] d\ i j  .36

G x lg \ g \ ] k a]e Z jY hg j] pl]fka{f

H\hp`nom\%-).hdjh`ijn& H\hp`nom\n``sod`i_`
n`kdk`o`\nj]m`g\npk`mad^d` pidajmh`h`io`nj]m`g\npk`mad^d`
_`g\kg\^\^ji\b\m _`g\b\mpn\i_jpi\n\_`qd_mdj
`no}mdg

G x lg \ g \ ] ka]e Z jY hg jn ] jla\ g ]fh dY[Y

B db p m\ 3 +. 2  @jnh }oj_jnk\m\_`o`mh di\^dÅi_`qd\]g`n%m`^p`ioj`ikg\^\&+Ai`gh }oj_j_`q`mod_j`ikg\^\)g\n^jgjid\nn`


ajmh\io\ioj`i g\npk`mad^d`^jhj`i`gdio`mdjm_`g\b\m+Aig\^p\mo\^jgphi\n`hp`nom\pi\ajojbm\a~\_`^jgjid\n_`?iY^[h_Y^_W^`
ajmh\_\nk jm^}gpg\nn`h]m\_\nkjm`so`indÅi%\mmd]\&jk jmq`mod_j`ikg\^\%\]\ej&+

lh]_]oiqu_]nc]`]o]hcqj]o_}hqh]olqa`ajjkbkni]n
_khkje]o u ]hcqj]o _khkje]o oa lqa`aj bqoekj]n knece*
j]j`k aopei]_ekjao annÅja]o+ Q]i^e}j ao eilknp]jpa
mqaahjÇiank`a_khkje]ojkoa]`ai]oe]`k^]fkl]n]
mqaah_|h_qhkoa]aop]`~ope_]iajpaoecjebe_]perk+ Bjh]
ln|_pe_])hkd]^epq]hu aop]`~ope_]iajpar|he`kaomqaah
jÇiank`a_khkje]olknlh]_]ko_ehaajpna0-u 0--+
M]n]k^pajanah jÇiank ]lnkle]`k `a _khkje]o) _]oe
oeailnaoa`ehquah]iqaopn]+@kikn]n]iajpaoa_kjk_a
`a]jpai]jkahjÇiank`a_}hqh]ore]^hao)jkni]hiajpaoa
d]_ai|o`aqj]`ehq_eÅj+Iki|oqoq]haona]hev]n`ehq*
_ekjao`a_ei]hao`ah]iqaopn]%B db p m\  3 +. 3 &+ M]n]d]_an
qj]`ehq_eÅj`a.-ŅÖoaiav_h]j-)2ie`ah]iqaopn]_kj
1)2ie`a`ehquajpak.ie`ah]iqaopn]_kj6ih`ah`ehq*
uajpa+Peoaja_aoep]qj]`ehq_eÅj`a.-x/)oalqa`ajiav* L\n\mhp`nom\n_`. hg\kg\^\
_h]n-)-2ie`ah]iqaopn]_kj1)62ie`a`ehquajpak-).ie
_kj6)6ie+>hpanj]per]iajpa)qj]`ehq_eÅj .-ŇŌoalqa`a b U _
d]_an`aik`koane]`kd]_eaj`koq_aoer]iajpa`ko`ehq*
_ekjao`a_ei]hao`apelk.-\.+Bjh]i]uknl]npa`ahko_]*
okooana]hev]jp]hao`ehq_ekjaooane]`]o_kj_qhperko`ajoko
l]n]]h_]jv]nh]`ehq_eÅjbej]h`aoa]`]+>o~)oeoanamqeana
qj]`ehq_eÅj ÖÕ ÓǾoalqa`ahkcn]nd]_eaj`kpnao`ehq_ekjao
oq_aoer]o`a.-ŇŌkoaeooq_aoer]o`a.-ĦÖ%Cecqn]3+.3&+ .26 s .-Ŏ : .+26 s .-Ø
N`^p`ioj B\^ojm_` ?}gpg\n%pid_\_`n
@m]fl]k \ ] ] jjg j ]f ]d j][m ]f lg  ]f hdY[Y _dgp^dÅi ajmh\_jm\n_`^jgjid\n&
kjmhdgdgdomj_`hp`nom\
BhjÇiank`a_khkje]omqaoak^peajaajqj]`apaniej]* jmdbdi\g
_eÅj`are]^haojkoÅhk`alaj`a`ahp]i]Äk`ahejÅ_qhk
B db p m\ 3 +. 3  Lmj^`_dh d`iojk\m\g\_`o`mh di\^dÅi_`
oejkp]i^e}j`ahk]`a_q]`kmqaoa]ahia`ek`a_qhperk
qd\]g`npn\i_j_dgp^dji`nn`md\_\n_`g\hp`nom\t `g h }oj_j
u`ah]o_kj`e_ekjao`aej_q^]_eÅj)]o~_kikp]i^e}j`a _`gq ` mod_ j `ikg\^\+Agg~lpd_j`no}mdgpn\_jk\m\c\^`mg\n
h]`qn]_eÅj`ah]ej_q^]_eÅj+Mknafailhk) oeoaqo]qj _dgp^dji`nkp`_`n`mndhkg`h`io`\bp\)k`mjpi\njgp^dÅin\gdi\
_qhperkietpk)jkpk`]oh]o_}hqh]o`alkoep]`]oa `lpdgd]m\_\j h `_dj_`^pgodqjnp`g`kmjkjm^dji\mh`ejm
`ao]nnkhh]n|j_khkje]o]h]ieoi]rahk_e`]`)u m`^pk`m\^dÅi+Aga\ ^ojm_`_dgp^dÅi`n`gdiq`mnj_`g\_dgp^dÅi+
. 4 - Q J E@ = @  . E  L mdi^dk dj n_ `  h d^mj ] dj gj b ~\

lha]qj_knpkpeailk`aej_q^]_eÅjoak^paj`n|jiajko aoqj]p}_je_]iquoajoe^ha)ahna_qajpkajlh]_]lqa`a
_khkje]o`ah]olkoe^hao+>`ai|o)ahp]i]Äk`ah]o_khk* oanlk_kbe]^ha_q]j`koa`aoa]r]hkn]nahjÇiank`a_}*
je]or]n~]u oe]l]na_aj_khkje]oiqulamqaÄ]olqa`aj hqh]o aj iqaopn]o j]pqn]hao) _kik ah oqahk k ah ]cq]+
l]o]n`ao]lan_e^e`]oajahna_qajpk+@kj_qhperkolqnko) >hcqjkoie_nk^eÅhkcko_kjoe`an]jaopk_kik çh]cn]j
ah`ao]nnkhhk`ah]o_khkje]oaoi|ooej_nÅje_ku h]jkni] ]jki]h~]`ahna_qajpkajlh]_]é+
aoajpkj_aoqj]iknbkhkc~]qjebknia`ah]o_khkje]o+ ã@q|haoh]n]vÅj`aaop]l]n]`kf]<Rjb]_pknk^rekao
I]`apaniej]_eÅj`a_}hqh]ore]^haolqa`aaop]noqfap] mqahkoi}pk`koie_nko_Åle_ko_qajp]j_}hqh]oiqanp]o
]cn]j`aoannknaolknr]ne]on]vkjao)_kikennacqh]ne`]* ieajpn]o mqah]`apaniej]_eÅj `are]^hao jk+ Pejai*
`ao aj ah lelapak) lk_] dkikcajae`]` `ah] iqaopn]) ^]nck)i|oeilknp]jpaaoahda_dk`amqa`ebanajpaokn*
iav_h]ejoqbe_eajpa)ukpnkoikperko+Mknaok)oeoa`aoa]j c]jeoiko) ej_hqokhkolnaoajpao ajiqaopn]o j]pqn]hao
na_qajpkolna_eokooanamqeanaqjcn]j_qe`]`kajh]lna* iqulamqaÄ]o)lqa`aj`ebaneniq_dkaj_q]jpk]ja_a*
l]n]_eÅj`ah]oiqaopn]ouajahlelapaku p]i^e}jd]_an oe`]`aojqpne_ekj]haou_kj`e_ekjao`a_na_eieajpkajah
lkn`qlhe_]`kh]olh]_]o`ah]o`ehq_ekjaoi|oeilknp]j* _qhperkajahh]^kn]pknek+Mknp]jpk)qjia`ekuqj]o_kj*
pao+E]umqa]`ranpenmqaqj]]cnql]_eÅj`a`koki|o `e_ekjao`a_na_eieajpklqa`ajoqopajp]nah_na_eieajpk
_}hqh]ookhklnk`q_en|qj]_khkje])`aik`kmqaahna* `ap]joÅhkqj]oq^lk^h]_eÅj`ah]_kiqje`]`ie_nk*
_qajpk`are]^haoaoqj]aopei]_eÅji~jei]+M]n]nao]h* ^e]j]pkp]h+Peaop]oq^lk^h]_eÅjnalnaoajp])lknafailhk)
p]ni|o_h]n]iajpaahnaoqhp]`k)ahna_qajpk`are]^haooa ÖÕ Ǿ_}hqh]o,cajqj]_kiqje`]`pkp]h`a Ö Õ Ř_}hqh]ore]*
atlnao]]iajq`k_kikmfa\Y\]k^gjeY\gjYk\][gdgfaYk ^hao,c)ahna_qajpkajlh]_]narah]n|okh]iajpaahÕ ) Ö " `a
k^paje`]o)ajrav`a_kikjÇiankna]h`a_}hqh]ore]^hao) h]lk^h]_eÅjie_nk^e]j]pkp]h)hkmqaoqlkjaqj]aopei]*
u]mqaqj]qje`]`bkni]`kn]`a_khkje]olqa`a_kjpa* _eÅjiqu^]f]`ahjÇiankna]h`a_}hqh]ore]^hao+
janqj]ki]o_}hqh]oeje_e]hao+ Ikonaoqhp]`ko`ahna_qajpkajlh]_]_kjhhar]j)lkn
Maoa]aop]o`ebe_qhp]`ao)ahna_qajpk`are]^haooqie* p]jpk)_eanp]ej_anpe`qi^na+I]`apaniej]_eÅj`acnqlko
jeopn]qj]^qaj]ejbkni]_eÅjok^naahjÇiank`a_}hqh]o aola_~be_ko lkn na_qajpk aj lh]_] ailha]j`k ia`eko
rer]ou ahlnk_a`eieajpkao`aqokiqu]ilhekajiq_d]o iquoaha_perko_kik)lknafailhk)ajah]j|heoeoie_nk*
|na]o`ah]ie_nk^ekhkc~]+Bjh]]heiajp]_eÅj)ej`qopne]o ^e]jk`a]cq]onaoe`q]haok`a]heiajpko)lqa`alnklkn*
h|_pa]o)ia`e_ej]u ie_nk^ekhkc~]]_q|pe_])ahna_qajpk _ekj]n `]pko be]^hao+ Mkn ah _kjpn]nek) ah na_qajpk `a
`are]^haooaailha]`aik`knqpej]nek+Bhi}pk`kpeaja çpk`]oh]o_}hqh]oé `ah]oieoi]oiqaopn]oqo]j`kqj
h]renpq``ah]ahar]`]oajoe^ehe`]`lknmqalqa`a`apa_* Çje_k ia`ekuqj] okh] oanea`a _kj`e_ekjao `a _na_e*
p]noah]lnaoaj_e]`aej_hqokqj]okh]_}hqh]re]^halkn ieajpklqa`anaoqhp]nèujkni]hiajpanaoqhp]è ajqj]
iqaopn]+Bop]_]n]_pan~ope_]laniepaqj]`apa__eÅjoaj* aopei]_eÅj]h]^]f]mqa`ebeanaajr]nekoÅn`ajao`ai]c*
oe^ha `a h] _kjp]iej]_eÅj ie_nk^e]j] `a ]heiajpko u jepq``ahkojÇiankona]hao`a_}hqh]o+
kpnkolnk`q_pko+
Bhailhak`aia`eko`a_qhperku`a_eanp]o_kj`e_ek* 1 ) , +  G af aj j ] n ak a{ f
jao `a _na_eieajpk aj ah na_qajpk `a re]^hao laniepa
`apaniej]noÅhkpelko_ahqh]naol]npe_qh]naoajqj]lk^h]* Ag m`^p`ioj_ ` ^}gpg\nqd\]g`n%m`^p`ioj_ ` ^jgjid\n`i
_eÅjietp]`aie_nkknc]jeoiko)u aj]hcqjko_]okoej* kg\^\&h d_`nÅgjg\kj]g\^dÅiqdq\km`n`io``ipi\
_hqok `a qj] okh] aola_ea ej`ere`q]h lnaoajpa aj h] h p`nom\+
iqaopn]+Mknafailhk)aj]lhe_]_ekjaoln|_pe_]oajh]ej*
E  çLjmlp}pi m`^p`ioj_ ` qd\]g`n`nh|nn`ind]g`lp`
`qopne] `a ]heiajpko) h] `apaniej]_eÅj `a re]^hao _kj
pim`^p`iojh d^mjn^Åkd^j<
ia`eko_kilhafkou oaha_perkob]rkna_ah]r]hkn]_eÅj_q]j*
pep]per]u _q]hep]per]`ahkoie_nkknc]jeoikomqaoaaj* E  çMp}npkjnd^dÅin` c\^`\g m`g\^dji\m`gm`^p`ioj`i
_qajpn]jajhkolnk`q_pko]heiajp]neko+Bo`a_en)_kjqj] kg\^\^ji`g iÇh `mj_ ` ^}gpg\n<
okh]iqaopn])oalqa`aailha]nqjia`ekl]n]ahna_qajpk
E  @`n^md]\^ Åh jj ] o`i_m~\pi\_ dgp^dÅi.-ĦŒ_`pi
pkp]hu qjoacqj`kia`ekl]n]`apa_p]nqjknc]jeoikl]n*
^pgodqj]\^o`md\ij+
pe_qh]n)_kikqjl]pÅcajkaola_~be_k+I]`apaniej]_eÅj
`enece`]aobna_qajpaaj]j|heoeo`a]cq]onaoe`q]haouaj E  çAilp}^jindno`g\èbm\i\ijh\g~\_`g m`^p`ioj`i
kpnko ]j|heoeo`a]cq]o$nwYk]Cecqn]o 03+. u03+/&+Mkn kg\^\ê<
afailhk)_kikh]o^]_pane]oajp}ne_]olnk_a`aj`ai]pa*
ne]ba_]hu okjb|_ehao`a`apa_p]nqo]j`kia`ekooaha_pe*
rko)oeoa`apa_p]j^]_pane]oajp}ne_]oajqj]iqaopn]`a
]cq]`aqjhqc]n`aj]p]_eÅj)oqlnaoaj_e]aooaÄ]h`amqa 3+.. &  I ` _ d_ \  _ `  g\ h\n\ h d^ mj ] d\ i \ 7
ah]cq]jkao]`a_q]`]l]n]ao]]_pere`]`na_na]per]+ h } oj _ j n op m] d_ dh } om d^ j n
FY _ jYf Y f g e YdyY \ ]d j][m ]f lg  ]f hdY[Y Aqn]jpaah_na_eieajpkatlkjaj_e]hpk`kohko_kilkjaj*
Bhna_qajpkie_nko_Åle_k`ena_pk`aiqaopn]oj]pqn]hao pao_ahqh]nao]qiajp]jajlnklkn_eÅj]hjÇiank`a_}hq*
oqahanarah]niq_dkoi|oknc]jeoikomqahkomqaoana* h]o+Mknp]jpk)ajrav`aia`enhko_]i^ekoajahjÇiank
_qlan]jajlh]_]`a_q]hmqeania`ek+Mknp]jpk)]qjmqa `a _}hqh]o aj bqj_eÅj `ah peailk lk`n~]iko ia`enah
? \ k ~op gj Å  E  ? m` ^ dh d` i oj h d^mj ] d\ i j  .4.

]qiajpkajlnkpa~j])ajAK>kajahlaokoa_k`aqj_qh* zhla[Y %L A& ]qj]hkjcepq``a kj`]`apaniej]`]8 lkn


perk_kikqjej`e_]`kn`ah_na_eieajpk+Rji}pk`kiqu afailhkLAØŐÕej`e_]h]ia`e`]`ah]`ajoe`]`Ålpe_]]
n|le`ku Çpeh`ak^pajanaopei]_ekjao`ahjÇiank`a_}* 21-ji%Cecqn]3+.4&+
hqh]ookjh]oe]\a\Yk\]lmjZa\]r)
Rj]oqolajoeÅj_ahqh]n]l]na_apqn^e]]h]reop]lknmqa L]dY[a{f ] f lj]  \]f ka\ Y\  { h la[ Y  q  f |e ]jg 
h]o_}hqh]o`eolano]jh]hqvmqa]pn]reao]h]oqolajoeÅj+ \ ]  [xdmdYk
@q]jp]oi|o_}hqh]oaop}jlnaoajpaoi]uknoan|h]hqv`eo*
lano]`]ulknp]jpki]uknh]pqn^e`av+Ikmqana]hiajpa Bjah_]ok`aknc]jeoikoqje_ahqh]nao)h]`ajoe`]`Ålpe_]
oa`apaniej]lknr]hkn]_ekjaopqn^e`ei}pne_]oaoh]i]o] aolnklkn_ekj]h%`ajpnk`a_eanpkoh~iepao&]hjÇiank`a
_ahqh]npkp]h+Pejai^]nck)_kikh]^eki]o]aolnklkn_ek* _}hqh]o+Mkn_kjoecqeajpa)h]oha_pqn]o`apqn^e`avlqa`aj
j]h]hjÇiank`a_}hqh]o)ajqj_qhperkaj_na_eieajpklk* qo]noa_kikqjoqopepqpk`ahkoi}pk`ko`a_kjp]fa`e*
`aikoqo]nh]pqn^e`avl]n]ia`enahjÇiank`a_}hqh]o+ na_pkl]n]_}hqh]opkp]haokre]^hao+Pejai^]nck)]jpao`a
qpehev]nh]pqn^e`av_kikoeopai]l]n]aopei]nahjÇiank
> ]fka\ Y\  { h la[Y `a_}hqh]o)oa`a^alnal]n]nlneiankqjaop|j`]nmqana*
I]pqn^e`avlqa`aia`enoa_kjqjaola_pnkbkpÅiapnk)qj h]_ekjaahjÇiank`a_}hqh]o%na_qajpkie_nko_Åle_kk`a
ejopnqiajpkmqad]_al]o]nh]hqv]pn]r}o`aoqolajoek* re]^hao&)ahlaokoa_kkah_kjpaje`kajlnkpa~j]_kjh]
jao_ahqh]naou`apa_p]h]_]jpe`]``ahqvaiancajpajk pqn^e`av+@kiklqa`aranoa)p]h_qnr]`a_]he^n]_eÅjoÅhk
`eolano]`] %B db p m\  3 +. 4 &+ Bhaola_pnkbkpÅiapnkailha] aor|he`]`ajpnk`a_eanpkoh~iepao%Cecqn]3+.4_&+> ]hp]o
qjlneoi]kna``a`ebn]__eÅjl]n]cajan]nhqvej_e`ajpa _kj_ajpn]_ekjao_ahqh]nao)h]hqv`eolano]`]lknqj]_}*
`ahkjcepq``akj`]aola_~be_]%Cecqn]3+.4]&+I]ohkjce* hqh])mqajkni]hiajpajk]h_]jv]n~]ah`apa_pkn)lqa`a
pq`ao`akj`]i|o_kiÇjiajpaqo]`]ol]n]ia`enh] oanna`eolano]`]lknkpn]`ap]hik`kmqal]n]h]bkpk_}*
pqn^e`av^]_pane]j]okj15-ji%]vqh&) 21-ji%ran`a&) hqh] ao _kik oe jk dq^eaoa oe`k `eolano]`] jqj_]+
3--ji%j]n]jf]&u 33-ji%nkfk&+I]oajoe^ehe`]`aoi]* @q]j`kaopkk_qnna)h]_knnaolkj`aj_e]ajpnaahjÇiank
ukn]hkjcepq`ao`akj`]_knp]o)lankh]oia`e`]o_kj `a_}hqh]ouh]pqn^e`avlean`aheja]he`]`%Cecqn]3+.4_&u
oqolajoekjao_ahqh]nao`ajo]ookji|oat]_p]o]i]uk* h]oia`e`]ona]hev]`]o`a`ajoe`]`Ålpe_]okjlknp]jpk
naohkjcepq`ao`akj`]+Pejai^]nck)]_q]hmqeanhkjce* iajkoat]_p]o+Pejai^]nck)`ajpnk`aaopah~iepa)mqa
pq` `a kj`] hk mqa oa ie`a ao ah `ao_ajok `a hqv jk r]n~]l]n]_]`]knc]jeoik)h]oia`e`]o`apqn^e`avlqa*
`eolano]`]_]qo]`klknh]pqn^e`av+Bjqjaola_pnkbkpÅ* `aj oanaopei]_ekjaon]vkj]^haiajpalna_eo]o `ah jÇ*
iapnkh]oha_pqn]ooaatlnao]jajqje`]`ao`a\]fka\Y\ iank`a_}hqh]ok`ahlaokoa_k+

#X$ $[%
B db p m\ 3 +. 4  I `_d_\nopm]d_dh }omd^\n_ ` g^m`^dh d`iojh d^mj]d\ij)#W$H\n
h`_d_\n_`opm]d_`un`m`\gdu\i`ipi`nk`^omjajoÅh`omj+ H\ajoj^}gpg\hd_`g\gpu
di^d_`io`ij_dnk`mn\_\kjmg\n^}gpg\n`inpnk`indÅit_\g`^opm\n_`_`ind_\_
Ank`^omjajoÅh`omj Åkod^\j pid_\_`najojh}omd^\n+ $Z%?pmq\_`^m`^dhd`iojo~kd^\k\m\_jnjmb\idnhjn
lp`^m`^`i\q`gj^d_\_`n_da`m`io`n+L\m\km\^od^\m)^\g^pg``god`h kj_`b`i`m\^dÅi
%
@`ind_\_Åkod^\%K@& %b&_`gjn_jn^pgodqjnpn\i_jg\aÅmhpg\d:%gjbJ * gjb,R-&, -)0-.)_ji_`H o H+
nji_jnq\gjm`n_da`m`io`n_`_`ind_\_Åkod^\ojh\_jn`iom`pidio`mq\gj_`od`h kj
o+çMp}jmb\idnhj^m`^`h|nm|kd_j)= j >< $[%N`g\^dÅi`iom``giÇh`mj_`^}gpg\nj
k`njn`^jtnpng`^opm\nopm]d_dh}omd^\n+ JÅo`n`lp`g\`lpdq\g`i^d\n`kd`m_`\
q\gjm`n\gojn_`opm]d_`u+R}\n`g\Bdbpm\ . _`g\n`^^dÅi Eiajmh\^dÅi\_d^dji\g+
. 4 / Q J E@ = @  . E  L mdi^dk dj n_ `  h d^mj ] dj gj b ~\

I]oia`e`]o`apqn^e`avpeajajh]renpq``aoann|le`]o `ko oan|j _kjoe`an]`ko i|o ]`ah]jpa aj aopa he^nk


u b|_ehao`ana]hev]n+>`ai|o)aop]o`apaniej]_ekjaooalqa* _q]j`koa]j]he_ajd|^ep]poie_nk^e]jkoajhkomqapea*
`ajd]_anjkni]hiajpaoej`aopnqenkik`ebe_]njkp]^ha* jajqjl]laheilknp]jpa+
iajpa h] iqaopn]+ Mkn aopko ikperko) h]o ia`e`]o `a
pqn^e`avoaqo]j_kjbna_qaj_e]l]n]oacqenah_na_eieajpk
`a_qhperkoie_nk^e]jko+ I]ieoi]iqaopn]lqa`aia* 3 +. /  A a` ^ oj  _` g\ o` h k ` m\ op m\  n j ] m` 
`enoanalape`]iajpauhkonaoqhp]`kooalqa`ajnalnaoajp]n `g ^ m` ^ dh d` i oj  h d^ mj ] d\ i j
oaiehkc]n~pie_]iajpabnajpa]hpeailk+> l]npen`aaopko
`]pko)naoqhp]b|_eh_]h_qh]nahpeailk`acajan]_eÅjukpnko I] pailan]pqn]aolnk^]^haiajpaahb]_pkni|oei*
l]n|iapnko`aqj_qhperkaj_na_eieajpk%Cecqn]3+.4#&+ lknp]jpaomqa]ba_p]]h_na_eieajpku ]h]oqlanreraj_e]`a
I]o`apaniej]_ekjao`apqn^e`avokj]ra_aolnk^ha* hkoie_nkknc]jeoiko+> pailan]pqn]oiqubn~]okiqu_]*
i|pe_]o+ >qjmqa iq_dko ie_nkknc]jeoiko _na_aj aj heajpaohkoie_nkknc]jeoikojk_na_an|julqa`ajej_hqok
ia`ekh~mqe`kbkni]j`koqolajoekjaoqjebkniao)kpnko iknen+ Mankhkor]hknao]^okhqpko`aaop]opailan]pqn]o
jkhkd]_aj+>hcqj]o_}hqh]obkni]jlamqaÄ]okcn]j`ao i~jei]oki|tei]or]n~]jiq_dkajpnaie_nkknc]jeo*
]cnac]_ekjaou ajp]hao_]okoh]oia`e`]o`aLAlqa`aj iko`ebanajpaou lknhkcajan]hnabhaf]jahn]jck`ah]pai*
oaniqueilna_eo]o_kikej`e_]_eÅj`ah]^eki]o]pkp]h lan]pqn]ia`e]`aoqod|^ep]poj]pqn]hao+
ie_nk^e]j]+>`ai|o)iq_d]o^]_pane]o_na_ajbkni]j`k
^ekbehioajhkoh]`ko`ahkopq^koukpnkona_eleajpao`a N ] e h ]jYlm jYk [Yj\afYd]k
_qhperknabhaf]j`k)aj_kj`e_ekjao`ah]^kn]pknek)_Åik I]pailan]pqn]afan_aaba_pkoklqaopkook^nahkoknc]*
_na_ajna]hiajpaajh]j]pqn]hav]$nwYk]ajFjbkni]_eÅj jeoikorerko+> ia`e`]mqaoaahar]h]pailan]pqn])h]o
]`e_ekj]h7 ç@na_eieajpkie_nk^e]jkajahiqj`kna]h7 na]__ekjaomq~ie_]ouajvei|pe_]o`ah]_}hqh]okji|o
^eklah~_qh]oé&+>o~)l]n]mqah]LA`aqj_qhperkh~mqe`k n|le`]o)uah_na_eieajpkoa]_ahan]8oejai^]nck)lknaj*
nabhafa_kjat]_pepq`h]i]o]_ahqh]n%ulknp]jpkahjÇ* _ei]`aqj]_eanp]pailan]pqn]]hcqj]olnkpa~j]ol]npe*
iank`a_}hqh]o&`a^aarep]noah]]cnac]_eÅju h]bkni]* _qh]nao lqa`aj oqbnen `]Äko `a ik`k ennaranoe^ha+ Bj
_eÅj`a^ekbehio+Bopkoahkcn]bna_qajpaiajpaia`e]jpa _kjoa_qaj_e])`ajpnk`aqj_eanpki]ncaj)qj]qiajpk
]cep]_eÅjklkn_q]hmqeankpnkik`kmqai]jpajc]h]o_}* `apailan]pqn]]_]nna]qj]qiajpkajah_na_eieajpku
hqh]o^eajiav_h]`]o`qn]jpaahlnk_aok`ah_na_eieajpk+ ajahbqj_ekj]ieajpkiap]^Åhe_kd]op]mqah]ona]__ek*
jao`aej]_per]_eÅjoalkjajaji]n_d]+Mknaj_ei]`a
p]hlqjpk)h]ona]__ekjao_ahqh]nao_]aj]_ank+
1 ), ,  G af aj j ] n ak a{ f
M]n] _]`] ie_nkknc]jeoik ateopaqj]pailan]pqn]
H\nh `_d_\n_`op m] d_ ` u njipih }oj _jdi_dm`^ojk`mj i~jei]lkn`a^]fk`ah]_q]hjklnk`q_a_na_eieajpk)
h ptÇ odgt m|k d_ j_` h `_ dm`g ^m`^dh d`ioj]\^o`md\ij+Odi qj] pailan]pqn]Ålpei] ] h] mqa oalnk`q_a ah _na_e*
`h ]\mbj)k\m\ m`g\^dji\mpim`^p`ioj^`gpg\m_ dm`^oj^ji ieajpki|on|le`k)uqj]pailan]pqn]i|tei]lknaj*
piq \gjm_ ` op m] d_` u)n`m`lpd`m`` no\]g` ^`mk mdh `mjpi\ _ei]`ah]_q]hjkaolkoe^haah_na_eieajpk% B db p m\ 3 +. 5 &+
^pmq\`no|i_\m_ ` ^\gd]m\^dÅi+ I]pailan]pqn]Ålpei]aop|oeailnai|o_an_]`ah]i|*
tei]mqa`ah]i~jei]+Bop]opnaopailan]pqn]o)mqaoa
E  ? do`_ jnq`io\e\n_ ` gpnj_ ` g\op m] d_ ` u k\m\h `_ dm`g
^m`^dh d`ioj^`gpg\m+

E  @`n^md]\^ Åh jpn\m~\ piq \gj m_ ` op m] d_` uk\m\


_` _p ^dm^p|io\n^jgjid\nj ] o`i_m~\\gn`h ]m\m`i
kg\^\pi^pgodqj_`pi\K @ _ `o`mh di\_\+

ER  P A I L A N = P Q N =
U  ? N A ? EI EA J P K 
I E? N K > E= J K
I]o]_pere`]`ao`ahkoie_nkknc]jeoikooaraj]ba_p]`]o
`aik`kiqueilknp]jpalknh]o_kj`e_ekjaomq~ie_]ou
b~oe_]o`ahia`ek+> aopanaola_pkoalqa`aj_kjoe`an]n
iq_dkob]_pknao]i^eajp]hao) lankd]u_q]pnkb]_pknao
mqafqac]jqjl]lah`aop]_]`kajah_kjpnkh`ah_na_e*
ieajpkie_nk^e]jk7h]pailan]pqn])ahlE)h]`eolkje^ehe*
`]``a]cq])uahkt~cajk+Lpnkob]_pknaop]i^e}jlqa`aj B db p m\ 3 +. 5  P`hk`m\opm\n^\m_di\g`n7h~idh\)Åkodh \t
]ba_p]nlkpaj_e]hiajpa]h_na_eieajpk)_kikh]lnaoeÅju h|sdh\+ Hjnq\gjm`nm`\g`nq\m~\ik\m\^\_\jmb\idnhj%q}\n`
h]n]`e]_eÅj+Bopkob]_pknao]i^eajp]haoi|oaola_e]hev]* Bdbpm\3+.6&+
Cf ^g j e Y [ a{ f  Y \ a[ ag f Y d

=j][aea]flgea[jgZaYfg]f]d emf\gj]Yd5Zagh]dy[mdYk

#
i`no`^\k~opgjc`hjnkm`n`io\_j kjgdn\^|md_jt%1&_`n\mmjggjkjno`mdjmc\no\ H\n]djk`g~^pg\no\h]d}im`km`n`io\ipi
q\mdjnhj_jn_`h`_dm`g^m`^dhd`ioj ajmh\mg\k`mndno`io`t^\nddhk`i`om\]g` kmj]g`h\k\m\g\di_pnomd\)tgjn_`jmdb`i
hd^mj]d\ij)^jhjgjnh}oj_jn h\gg\_`g\]djk`g~^pg\h\_pm\+Aig\n hd^mj]d\ijkp`_`ikmj_p^dm\o\n^\hd`iojn
hd^mjn^Åkd^jn)gjnm`^p`iojn_`qd\]g`nt kmdh`m\na\n`n_`g\ajmh\^dÅi)g\pidÅi_` _``lpdkjntg\^jio\hdi\^dÅi_`
g\nh`_d_\n_`opm]d_`u_`npnk`indji`n g\n^}gpg\n\pi\npk`mad^d`di_p^`g\ kmj_p^ojn)`nk`^d\gh`io`ndc\tg~lpd_jn
^`gpg\m`n`ih `_djg~lpd_j+H\n `skm`ndÅi_`b`i`nlp`nji`nk`^~ad^jn_` lp`n`\ipi]p`inpnom\oj)^jhjg\g`^c`+
`nodh\^dji`nopm]d_dh}omd^\n_`g ]djk`g~^pg\n+Anojnb`i`n_dmdb`ig\ P\h]d}ikp`_`igg`q\m\^\]jpi_\Äj_`
^m`^dhd`iojhd^mj]d\ijn`]\n\i`ig\ kmj_p^^dÅi_`kjgdn\^|md_jnnpk`mad^d\g`n) g\mbj\g^\i^``ig\ndino\g\^dji`n_`
npkjnd^dÅi_`lp`g\n^}gpg\nod`i`ipi\ ^pt\kmj_p^^dÅia\^dgdo\g\pidÅi_`h|n _dnomd]p^dÅi_`\bp\t`ijom\n
_dnomd]p^dÅipidajmh``ih `_djg~lpd_j+ ^}gpg\n+Bdi\gh`io`)h`_d\io`^m`^dhd`ioj diam\`nomp^opm\nkÇ]gd^\n+H\n]djk`g~^pg\n
>\ejo\g`n^ji_d^dji`n)g\_`ind_\_Åkod^\ tm`^gpo\hd`ioj)n`_`n\mmjgg\pi\ lp`\k\m`^`i`ibm\i_`n_`kÅndojn_`
_`pi^pgodqj`nkmjkjm^dji\g\ggjb\mdohj ^jhpid_\_hd^mj]d\i\^jhkg`o\_`iomj \gh\^`i\hd`ioj)^jhjgjno\ilp`n_`
_`giÇh`mj_`^}gpg\n`inpnk`indÅi _`g\adi\h\omdukjgdn\^\m~_d^\+ ^jh]pnod]g`)kp`_`i^jio\hdi\m\}no`t
%Bdbpm\.&+Ano``nodgj_`qd_\`iagjo\^dÅi) H\n]djk`g~^pg\n]\^o`md\i\nkp`_`i jmdbdi\m\^d_`ukjm^jhkp`nojnlp~hd^jn)
_`ijhdi\_jkg\i^oÅid^j)`n`ghj_jm`\g \a`^o\mijo\]g`h`io`\gcjh]m`+Ljm ^jhj`gnpgapmj_`cd_mÅb`ij%DŌO&)lp`
`i`glp`hp^c\n]\^o`md\nqdq`i`ig\ `e`hkgj)g\ndia`^^dji`n]\^o`md\i\n`no|i n`^m`o\ig\n]\^o`md\n_`g\]djk`g~^pg\+
i\opm\g`u\)^jhjkjm`e`hkgjg\n^}gpg\n \h`ip_jm`g\^dji\_\n^jik\oÅb`ijnlp` H\n]djk`g~^pg\nnjipi\ajmh\_`
lp`c\]do\i`ig\^jgphi\_`\bp\_`pi _`n\mmjgg\i]djk`g~^pg\n_pm\io``gkmj^`nj ^m`^dhd`ioj]\^o`md\ijam`^p`io``ig\
g\bj+J jj]no\io`)hp^cjnjomjn _`g\`ia`mh`_\_+H\ad]mjndnlp~nod^\%B?& i\opm\g`u\+H\]djk`g~^pg\ijnjgjjam`^`
hd^mjjmb\idnhjnnjin}ndg`n)`n_`^dm)qdq`i n`^\m\^o`mdu\kjm`g_`n\mmjggj_`pi\ kmjo`^^dÅiam`io`\^jhkp`nojnk`gdbmjnjn)
pid_jn\pi\npk`mad^d`+Ano\n^}gpg\n ]djk`g~^pg\`igjnkpghji`nlp`^jiod`i` ndijlp`g\bmp`n\h\omdunpkji`pi\
pid_\nkp`_`iajmh\m]djk`g~^pg\n+ \Ji[kZecedWiW[hk]_deiWt\jom\n ]\mm`m\`ad^\uk\m\lp`jomjn
Agcjh]m``i^p`iom\\_d\mdj ]\^o`md\n`igjnk\^d`io`n^ji`no\ hd^mjjmb\idnhjnn`\gdh`io`i)`dhkd_``g
]djk`g~^pg\n]\^o`md\i\n^p\i_jgdhkd\`g `ia`mh`_\_%Bdbpm\/&+H\h\omdu_`g\ _`nkg\u\hd`iojj\mm\nom`_`g\n]\^o`md\n
]`]`_`mj_`pi\idh\gom\nq\mdjn_~\n)j ]djk`g~^pg\)lp`^jiod`i`\gbdi\ojtjomjn ^jinodopt`io`n\jomjc|]do\oh`ijn
^p\i_jnd`io`^jinpg`ibp\g\k`g~^pg\ kjgdn\^|md_jnepioj^ji@J=]\^o`md\ij) a\qjm\]g`+=pilp``i`gg\]jm\ojmdjg\n
lp`n`c\_`n\mmjgg\_jnj]m`gjn_d`io`n m`_p^`hp^cjg\^\k\^d_\__`k`i`om\^dÅi _`ind_\_`nÅkod^\nijn_\ipi\d_`\_`
_`\b`io`n\iodhd^mj]d\ijn^jhjgjn ^pgodqjn]\^o`md\ijn`ik`ma`^o\
Qi\]djk`g~^pg\`npi\h\omdu \iod]dÅod^jn)tkjmo\iojg\n]\^o`md\n_`g\ npnk`indÅi)`i`ghpi_jm`\gg\ijmh\_`g
kjgdn\^\m~_d^\ade\_\lp`^jiod`i`^}gpg\n ]djk`g~^pg\kp`_`iijq`mn`\a`^o\_\nkjm ^m`^dhd`ioj]\^o`md\ijkp`_`n`mg\_`
]\^o`md\i\n+H\ajmh\^dÅi_`g\n gjnh`_d^\h`iojn+H\n]djk`g~^pg\n ajmh\m]djk`g~^pg\n+
]djk`g~^pg\ndi^gpt`q\md\n`o\k\n7%Ö &pidÅi ]\^o`md\i\no\h]d}in`c\im`g\^dji\_j =i\gdu\m`hjng\n]djk`g~^pg\n^jih|n
m`q`mnd]g`_`^}gpg\nkg\i^oÅid^\n%Ō&pidÅi ^jidia`^^dji`n_da~^dg`n_`om\o\mlp`q\i _`o\gg`^p\i_j`i`g?\k~opgj/0ijn
dmm`q`mnd]g`_`_d^c\n^}gpg\n) \nj^d\_\n\dhkg\io`n_`q|gqpg\n^\m_~\^\n ^`iom`hjn`ig\nnpk`mad^d`n^jhjc|]do\on
%0&^m`^dhd`ioj^`gpg\mtkmj_p^^dÅi_`g t\mod^pg\^dji`n\modad^d\g`n+ hd^mj]d\ijn%q}\in`O`^^dji`n/0+0*/0+2&+


MBØŐÕ M ÕĞÖŔ ÕĞŐØ ÕĞǾŔ
B db p m\ / =tbkbWiZ[Ln`p_jhji\n\`mpbdijn\j[v_ZWiYedkd
B db p m\  . =kbj_leibugk_ZeiZ[An^c`md^cd\^jgd+ ?d[ijeiYkbj_lei YebehWdj[\bkeh[iY[dj[[dkdWck[ijhWZ[[ifkjeZ[kdfWY_[dj[
bWiYtbkbWi[ijtd[dkd[ijWZefbWdYjwd_Yeo ikif[dZ_ZWi Yed\_Xhei_igkuij_YW)FWiYtbkbWihe`WiiedZ[L+\`mpbdijn\t [b
kd_\ehc[c[dj[[d[bc[Z_e)FWZ[di_ZWZwfj_YW#I > Z [ YWZW cWj[h_WbXbWdYe[iWb]_dWje'kdc Wj[h_Wbfeb_iWYWhuZ_YefheZkY_Ze
Ykbj_leWkc[djWZ[_pgk_[hZWWZ[h[Y^Wo n`ck[ijhWXW`e[ bjkXe) f e hL+\`mpbdijn\+
. 4 1 Q J E@ = @  . E  L mdi^dk dj n_ `  h d^mj ] dj gj b ~\

hh]i]j_PX[P]L_`]L^NL]OTYLWP^"okjcajan]hiajpa_]* ]hp]opailan]pqn]oÅlpei]o)aST[P]_P]XmQTWZ^"_kjpai*
n]_pan~ope_]o`a_]`]pelk`aknc]jeoik+ lan]pqn]oÅlpei]oiquahar]`]o%B db p m\ 3 +. 6 &+
I]opailan]pqn]o_]n`ej]hao`a`ebanajpaoie_nkknc]* IkoiaoÅb~hkopeajajqj]]ilhe]`eopne^q_eÅjajh]j]*
jeoiko`ebeanajiq_dkajpnao~8]hcqjkoiqaopn]jpai* pqn]hav]+Paaj_qajpn]jaj]jei]hao`ao]jcna_]heajpau
lan]pqn]oÅlpei]op]j^]f]o_kik1Ñ@ukpnkop]j]hp]o ajia`eko]_q|pe_kou pannaopnao`ah]pepq`aopailh]`]o
_kiki|o`a.--Ñ@+Bhn]jck`apailan]pqn]oajahmqa upnkle_]hao+Ikoloe_nÅbehkouhkopaniÅbehkooaaj_qaj*
k_qnna_na_eieajpkaoej_hqoki|o]ilhekmqaaopai]n* pn]jaj]i^eajpaoiqubn~kokiqu_]heajpao)naola_per]*
caj)`ao`apailan]pqn]olkn`a^]fk`ahlqjpk`a_kjca* iajpa+ Iko delanpaniÅbehko okj p~le_ko `a ]i^eajpao
h]_eÅjd]op]pailan]pqn]ooqlaneknao]h]o`aa^qhhe_eÅj+ _kj_napkoatpnai]`]iajpa_]heajpao_kikbqajpaopan*
K kk^op]jpa)jkd]ujejcÇjie_nkknc]jeoikmqak_qla i]hao)c}eoanaouaieoekjaode`nkpani]haooq^i]nej]o+
pk`kaopaejpanr]hk`apailan]pqn]omqa)l]n]ah_]ok`a @k[`]ja[`aY[gdaaoqjp~le_kiaoÅbehk)u oad]j`abe*
qjknc]jeoik`apaniej]`k)oqahaoan`aqjko/2*1-Ñ@+ je`k_kjlna_eoeÅjoqopailan]pqn]o_]n`ej]hao+I]pai*
I]pailan]pqn]i|tei]`a_na_eieajpk`aqjknc]* lan]pqn]Ålpei]l]n]h]i]ukn~]`a_al]o`a@*[gdaao`a
jeoik`apaniej]`knabhaf]lnk^]^haiajpah]ej]_per]_eÅj 06Ñ@)h]i|tei]15Ñ@u h]i~jei] Ŕ Ñ@+Mknp]jpk) ah
`aqj]ki|olnkpa~j]o_ahqh]naomqaokjaoaj_e]hao+Pej jYf_g`apailan]pqn]ol]n]@*[gdaao`a1-Ñ@)lnÅteik
ai^]nck)hkob]_pknaomqa`apaniej]jh]pailan]pqn]i~* ]hh~iepaoqlanekn`ahkolnk_]nekp]o%Cecqn]3+.6&+
jei]`a_na_eieajpk`aqjknc]jeoikjkaop|jp]j_h]nko+ Kko_ajpn]naiko]dkn]ajhkoejpanao]jpao_]okomqa
@kikoaiaj_ekjÅ]jpao$nwYk]Pa__eÅj1+2&h]iai^n]j] nalnaoajp]jhkoie_nkknc]jeoikomqa_na_aj]pailan]*
_epklh]oi|pe_]`a^aaop]najqjaop]`kbhqe`kl]n]oq_k* pej]oiqu^]f]okiqu]hp]o)hkoatpnaiÅbehko+
nna_pkbqj_ekj]ieajpkup]hravh]pailan]pqn]i~jei]`a
_na_eieajpkoa]ahnaoqhp]`k`ah]ç_kjcah]_eÅjé`aao]o
bqj_ekjao`ah]iai^n]j]aj_q]jpk]pn]jolknpa`ajq* 1 ) , -  G a f aj j ] n ak a{ f
pneajpaok]h]bkni]_eÅj`ahcn]`eajpa`alnkpkjao+ I]
H\o` h k `m\opm\`npia\ ^oj m\ h ]d`io\gdh k j mo\ i o` `i`g
pailan]pqn]zhlaeY`a_na_eieajpknabhaf]qjaop]`kaj
^jiomjg_` g^ m`^dh d`iojh d^mj]d\ij+H\no` h k`m\opm\n
mqapk`kokh]i]uknl]npa`ahko_kilkjajpao_ahqh]nao
^\m_di\g`n_ `adi`ig\no`h k`m\opm\nh ~idh \)Å k odh \t 
aop|jbqj_ekj]j`k]oqi|tei]rahk_e`]`+
h|sdh\\ g\nlp`^m`^`^\_\jmb\idnh j+Hjnh d^mjjmb\*
idnhjnk p`_`i\bmpk\mn`n`bÇi gjnh |mb`i`n_`
=dYk]k\ ]  e a[jggj_Yfake gkk]_|f
o` h k `m\opm\l p`m`lpd`m`i+
dY l] e h ] jY lm jY
E  ç?p|g`nnjig\no`h k`m\opm\n^\m_di\g`n\kmjsdh \_\n_`
>qjmqaateopapk`kqjaola_pnk_kjpejqkajpnahkoie_nk*
?iY^[h_Y^_WYeb_<ç=l p `^g\n`k`mo`i`^`k j mnp
knc]jeiko)`ao`ahkomqapeajajoqpailan]pqn]Ålpei]]
o` h k `m\opm\Åkodh \<
pailan]pqn]oiqu^]f]od]op]hkomqah]peajaj]paila*
n]pqn]]hp])oalqa`aj`eopejcqen]hiajko_q]pnkcnqlk`a E  @ da`m`i^d`pic dk `mo` mh Åadgj_ ` pi knd^mÅadgj
ie_nkknc]jeoiko_kjnah]_eÅj]oqpailan]pqn]Ålpei]7 E  ?iY^[h_Y^_WY e b_kp `_ `^m`^`m\o`h k`m\opm\h|n\go\`i
[^TN]mQTWZ^"_kjpailan]pqn]oÅlpei]o^]f]o)XP^mQkWZ^" h `_ dj^ jh k g` ejlp``i h `_dj_ ` adid_ jçLjmlp}<
_kjpailan]pqn]oÅlpei]oik`an]`]o)_P]XmQTWZ^"_kj

- .- /- 0- 1- 2- 3- 4- 5- 6- .-- ..- ./-
P`hk`m\opm\%Ñ?&

B db p m\ 3 +. 6  N`g\^dÅi` iom`g\o`h k`m\opm\t g\nq`gj^d_\_`n_ ` ^m`^dh d`ioj_`knd^mÅadgjn)h`nÅa~gjn) o` mh Åadgj nt _jn


cdk`mo`mh Åadgjn_da`m`io`n+Ai^\_\^\njn`di_d^\ig\no`hk`m\opm\nÅkodh\n_`hd^mjjmb\idnhjnm`km`n`io\odqjn+
? \ k ~op gj Å  E  ? m` ^ dh d` i oj h d^mj ] d\ i j  .42

; e Z a] f l] k ^jyg k
3+. 0  ? m` ^ dh d` i oj  h d^ mj ] d\ i j  \ ]\e\n
Dn]jl]npa`ah]oqlanbe_eapannaopnaatlaneiajp]^]f]o
o` h k ` m\ op m\ n
pailan]pqn]o+Ikok_}]jko)mqanalnaoajp]ji|o`ah]
Ikooanaodqi]jkorereikoupn]^]f]ikoajh]oqlanbe_ea iep]``ah]oqlanbe_eapannaopna)peajajqj]pailan]pqn]
`ajqaopnklh]jap]ajhqc]nao`kj`ah]opailan]pqn]ookj ia`e]`a2Ñ@u h]olnkbqj`e`]`aoi]nej]opeajajpai*
cajan]hiajpaik`an]`]o)u lknahhk_kjoe`an]ikomqa lan]pqn]o_kjop]jpao`a .*0Ñ@+Bjahñnpe_kuajah>j*
hko]i^eajpaoiqu_]heajpaou iqubn~kookjçatpnaikoé+ p|npe_kd]ur]op]o|na]olani]jajpaiajpa_kjcah]`]ok
Pejai^]nck)hkod|^ep]pojkni]hao`aiq_dkoie_nkkn* mqaoa`ao_kjcah]joÅhk`qn]jpa]hcqj]ooai]j]o]h]Äk
c]jeoikolqa`ajoanatpnai]`]iajpa_]heajpaokatpna* ajahran]jk %B db p m\  3 +/ - &+ Bopko]i^eajpaobn~kon]n]*
i]`]iajpa bn~ko+ Q]hao ie_nkknc]jeoiko oa _kjk_aj iajpaokjaop}nehaouajahhkooaaj_qajpn]jie_nkknc]*
_kikatpnaiÅbehko$nwYk]Pa__eÅj/+1u Q]^h]/+.&u d]j jeoikorerkou _na_eaj`k]_q]hmqeanpailan]pqn]^]f]]
arkhq_ekj]`kd]op]_na_an`aik`kÅlpeikajao]o_kj* h]mqa]Çjateop]]cq]h~mqe`]+I]oo]haoukpnkookhqpko)
`e_ekjao+@kjoe`an]naikoh]^ekhkc~]`aaopkob]o_ej]jpao lknafailhk)na^]f]jahlqjpk`a_kjcah]_eÅj`ah]cq]u
knc]jeoiko]mq~uajh]oecqeajpaoa__eÅj+ laniepaj ah _na_eieajpk ie_nk^e]jk lkn `a^]fk `a h]

#X$ #Z$

B db p m\ 3 +/ -  D|]do\onhd^mj]d\ijn_`gh \m= i o| mod^jt h d^mjjmb\idnhjn) #W$Qi\hp`nom\_`\bp\_`h\mk`mh\i`io`h`io`


c`g\_\_`I ^Ipm_jOjpi_)=io|mod_\+ H\hp`nom\od`i`Ŕ^h_`\i^cj+JÅo`n`g\dio`in\^jgjm\^dÅi_`]d_\\hd^mjjmb\idnhjn
kdbh`io\_jn) #X$Id^mjbm\a~\_`^jiom\no`_`a\n`n_`hd^mjjmb\idnhjnajoÅomjajn_`g\hp`nom\\io`mdjm+H\h\tjm~\_`gjn
hd^mjjb\idnhjnnji_d\ojh`\nj\gb\nq`m_`n%oj_jnhd^mjjmb\idnhjnajoÅomjajn`p^\mdjo\n&+#Y$Id^mjbm\a~\`g`^omÅid^\_`om\inhdndÅi
_`JebWhecedWi'pi\]\^o`md\^jiq`n~^pg\n_`b\nlp`qdq``igjncd`gjnh\mdijntod`i`^m`^dhd`iojÅ kodh j\1Ñ?+#Z$Bjojbm\a~\_`g\
npk`mad^d`_`gg\bj>jii`t) I^Ipm_j@mtR\gg`tn)=io|mod_\+?jhjhp^cjnjomjng\bjn\io|mod^jn)`no`g\bj)_`pijn1-h`omjn_`
kmjapi_d_\_)`no|k`mh\i`io`h`io`c`g\_j^jipi\^p]d`mo\_`cd`gj_`pijn2h`omjn+H\^jgphi\_`\bp\`i`gg\bj>jii`t`no|
kmÅsdh\\-jt^jiod`i`o\iojuji\nÅsd^\n^jhj\iÅsd^\n8kjmo\ioj`i `gg\bjc\thd^mjjmb\idnhjn\`mj]djnt\i\`mj]djn+Odi
`h]\mbj)idibÇih d^mjjmb\idnhj`p^\mdÅod^jc\]do\gjng\bjn_`@mtR\gg`tn)gjlp`gjn^jiqd`mo``i pi`^jndno`h\hdj^mj]d\ijÇid^j+
. 4 3 Q J E@ = @  . E  L mdi^dk dj n_ `  h d^mj ] dj gj b ~\

pailan]pqn]`a_kjcah]_eÅj`ah]cq]lqn])-Ñ@+Fj_hqok
ajiq_dkoi]pane]hao_kjcah]`kojkni]hiajpaateopaj
lamqaÄ]ovkj]oie_nko_Åle_]o_kj]cq]h~mqe`]`kj`aoa
_kj_ajpn]jokhqpkomqahkoie_nkknc]jeoikolqa`ajia*
p]^khev]nulknp]jpkqo]nl]n]_na_an+Aajpnk`ahkoch]*
_e]nao)lknafailhk)ateopaqj]i]hh]`a_]j]hao`a]cq]
h~mqe`]aj`kj`ahkolnk_]nekp]ooa`ao]nnkhh]ju oana*
lnk`q_aj+
Boeilknp]jpa`eopejcqenajpnahko]i^eajpaomqaokj
bn~kopk`kah]Äku ]mqahhkomqaokh]iajpaokjbn~koajah
ejreanjk+IkoÇhpeiko)mqaokj_]n]_pan~ope_ko`a_hei]o
pailh]`ko)lqa`ajpajanpailan]pqn]oaoper]hao`ad]op]
1-Ñ@+Rjh]ckpailh]`k)lknafailhk)lqa`apajanqjla*
n~k`k`aoqlanbe_eadah]`]ajahejreanjk)lankahlan~k`k
ajahmqaah]cq]aop|]-Ñ@aonah]per]iajpa_knpk+Q]hao
]i^eajpao]hp]iajpar]ne]^haookjiq_dkoiajkob]rk*
n]^haol]n]hkoknc]jeoiko]`]lp]`ko]hbn~kmqahko]i*
^eajpaomqaaop|j_kjop]jpaiajpabn~ko)_kikhkomqaoa
aj_qajpn]jajh]onacekjaolkh]nao)]]hpqn]oahar]`]o)k
ajh]olnkbqj`e`]`aok_a|je_]o+ Mknafailhk)hkoh]cko
]jp|npe_koajJ_Jqn`kAnuS]hhauo_kjpeajajqj]_]l]
lani]jajpa`adeahk`ar]nekoiapnko`aaolaokn%Cecqn]
2*.,\%* I]_khqij]`a]cq]^]fkahdeahk`aaopkoh]cko
lani]ja_a]-Ñ@klkn`a^]fk`aao]pailan]pqn]pk`k
ah]Äku aolknp]jpkqjd|^ep]pe`a]hl]n]hkoie_nkknc]*
jeoikomqaokj]_perkoajahbn~k+

G a[jg g j_ Yf ake g k hka[j{^adgk


@kikoaej`e_Å)hkoknc]jeoiko_kjpailan]pqn]Ålpei]
^]f]oahh]i]jhka[jz^adgk* Rjloe_nÅbehklqa`a`abejenoa
_kikqjknc]jeoikmqapeajaqj]pailan]pqn]Ålpei]
`a_na_eieajpk`a.2Ñ@kejbanekn)qj]pailan]pqn]i|*
tei]`a_na_eieajpklkn`a^]fk`a/-Ñ@u qj]pailan]*
pej] i~jei] `a _na_eieajpk `a - Ñ@ k i|o ^]f]+ Iko
knc]jeoikomqa_na_aj]-Ñ@lankpeajajpailan]pqn]o
Ålpei]o`a/-*1-Ñ@oahh]i]jloe_nkpkhan]jpao+
Ikoloe_nÅbehko oaaj_qajpn]jaj]i^eajpao lani]*
jajpaiajpabn~kouiqanajn|le`]iajpaoeoaatlkjaj]
p]jokhk/-Ñ@+Mknaop]n]vÅj)oqaopq`ekajahh]^kn]pk*
neknamqeanaqjcn]j_qe`]`kl]n]aop]noacqnko`amqa
jqj_]oa_]heajp]j`qn]jpaahiqaopnak)ahpn]jolknpa]h
h]^kn]pknek)ah]eoh]ieajpku kpn]oi]jelqh]_ekjao+Bj
]cq]ok_a|je_]o]^eanp]o)`kj`ah]pailan]pqn]lani]*
ja_a_kjop]jpa]hna`a`kn`a0Ñ@)aop|jlnaoajpaor]ne]o
=Y[l]jaYq<j[`Y]Y(]qjmqaokh]iajpaoad]jhkcn]`k]eo*
h]nu_qhper]nqj]olk_]oajahh]^kn]pknek+Iko]i^eajpao
pailh]`ko)mqaoa_]heajp]jajahran]jk)jklqa`aji]j*
pajan]hkoloe_nÅbehkooajoe^hao]h_]hkn`a^e`k]mqajk #X$
ok^nareraj]h]opailan]pqn]oaoper]hao+
I]o]hc]oloe_nÅbeh]o_na_ajaji]o]o`ajo]oajpna)k B db p m\ 3+/. =gb\n_`g\nid`q`n)#W$>\i^j_`id`q``iOd`mm\
J`q\_\)?\gdajmid\)^ji^jgjm\^dÅimje\_`]d_\\g\km`n`i^d\_`
^]fkahdeahk`ah]onacekjaolkh]nao%Cecqn]3+/-])ã;&uoa
\gb\n+H\id`q`mjn\_\`n^jhÇi`ioj _ j `g hpi_j_pm\io``g
k^oanr]j]iajq`kok^nah]oqlanbe_ea`avkj]ojar]`]o
q`m\ij`i]\i^jn_`id`q`_``g`q\_\n\godop_`n) $Z%Id^mjbm\a~\
u ch]_e]naoajjÇiankp]jahar]`kmqalnaop]jqj_khkn
_``nkjm\nkdbh`io\_\n_`g\gb\_`g\nid`q`n=^bWcoZecedWi
nkfkkran`a]h]oqlanbe_ea%B db p m\  3 +/ . \ &+ Bh]hc]`ah]o d_lWb_i)H\n`nkjm\nb`mhdi\ijmdbdi\i_j^}gpg\n_`g\gb\q`m_`n
jearaoi|o_kiÇjao>`dYeq\gegfYkfanYdak(_qu]oao* thÅqdg`n+=gbpi\n^`k\n_`\gb\n_`g\id`q`njiq`m_\_`m\n
lkn]o`a_khknnkfk^nehh]jpaokjh]onaolkjo]^hao`ahk_]* knd^mÅadg\n)k`mjhp^c\nnjiknd^mjojg`m\io`nt^m`^`ih`ejm
oekj]h_khknnkfevk`ah]jeara%Cecqn]3+/.X $ ) Bop]]hc] \o`hk`m\opm\nnpk`mdjm`n\/-Ñ?+
? \ k ~op gj Å  E  ? m` ^ dh d` i oj h d^mj ] d\ i j  .44

ran`a_na_a`ajpnk`ah]jeara_kik_}hqh]oracap]per]o Pa__eÅj1+2&bqj_ekj]iafkn]^]f]pailan]pqn])hkmqa
_kjleciajp]_eÅjran`ko]u hqackaolknqh]8_q]j`kh] _kjopepquaqj]ej`e_]_eÅj`amqah]iai^n]j]_epklh|o*
jearaoa`annepa)h]ankoeÅjuh]r]lknev]_eÅjb]_ehep]jmqa ie_]`ahkoloe_nÅbehkoaop|_kjopnqe`]`ap]hik`kmqa
h]oaolkn]ooa_kj_ajpnajajh]oqlanbe_ea+Lpn]oaola_eao h]o^]f]opailan]pqn]ojkejde^ajaopkobajÅiajko+ I]
`a]hc]onah]_ekj]`]o_kjpeajaj`eranoko_]nkpajke`aou _kilkoe_eÅj`ah]oiai^n]j]o_epklh]oi|pe_]oajhko
h]o vkj]o`ajeara_kjaop]o]hc]olqa`ajoanp]i^e}j loe_nÅbehkopeajaqji]ukn_kjpaje`kaj|_e`kocn]okojk
ran`ao)j]n]jf])i]nnÅjkrekh|_a]o+ o]pqn]`ko$nwYk]Pa__eÅj2+.4&)u aopkb]_ehep]ahaop]`koa*
>`ai|o`ah]o]hc]o`ah]ojearao)oad]j]eoh]`k^]_* iebhqe`k`ah]oiai^n]j]o]^]f]pailan]pqn]%h]oiai*
pane]oloe_nÅbeh]o)iq_d]o`ah]o_q]haolnk_a`aj`aoa`e* ^n]j]o_kilqaop]obqj`]iajp]hiajpalkn|_e`kocn]oko
iajpko i]nejko k `ah >jp|npe_k+ >hcqj]o `a }op]o) aj o]pej]`kooarqahraj_}na]ou jkbqj_ekj]hao]ao]opai*
l]npe_qh]n]hcqjko]eoh]ieajpko`ai]naodah]`ko_kik lan]pqn]o&+ Ikoh~le`ko`a]hcqj]o^]_pane]oloe_nÅbeh]o
KgdYjgegfYk%Cecqn]3+/-_&)peajajh]iajknpailan]pqn] p]i^e}j _kjpeajaj|_e`ko cn]okolkheejo]pqn]`koade*
Ålpei]ui|tei]`a_na_eieajpk`apk`kohkoie_nkkn* `nk_]n^qnko`a_]`aj]h]nc]_kjiq_dkoajh]_ao`k^hao+
c]jeoiko_kjk_e`ko%1Ñ@u ./Ñ@)naola_per]iajpa&+ > aopanaola_pk)ajhkoh~le`ko`a]hcqj]o^]_pane]o`ah>j*
p|npe_koad]e`ajpebe_]`kqjde`nk_]n^qnk_kjjqara`k*
G a[jg g j_ Yf ake g k h ka[jg lg d]jYf l]k ^haoajh]_ao %@0.86&) u h]^]_pane]Kkq[jg^d]pmk _kjpeaja
Ikoie_nkknc]jeoikoloe_nkpkhan]jpaopeajajqj]`eopne* |_e`kocn]oko_kj1u 2`k^haoajh]_ao+Bopko|_e`kocn]*
^q_eÅjiq_dki|o]ilhe]mqahkoloe_nÅbehkouoalqa* okolani]ja_aji|obhate^hao]^]f]pailan]pqn]mqahko
`aj ]eoh]n `a oqahko u ]cq]o `a _hei]o pailh]`ko ]o~ |_e`kocn]okoo]pqn]`kokikjkejo]pqn]`ko+
_kik`a_]njao)ha_daulnk`q_pko`aner]`ko) oe`n])ra*
cap]hao u  bnqp] ]hi]_aj]`] ^]fk nabnecan]_eÅj %1 Ñ@&+ =gf_ ]dY[a{ f
@kikoad]oaÄ]h]`k)hkoloe_nkpkhan]jpao_na_ajiafkn] > lao]n`ah]_]l]_e`]``a]hcqjkoknc]jeoikol]n]_na*
pailan]pqn]oajpna/-*1-Ñ@+>`ai|o)]qjmqahkoloe_nk* _an]^]f]opailan]pqn]o)ateopaqjh~iepalkn`a^]fk`ah
pkhan]jpaookj_]l]_ao`a_na_an]-Ñ@)jk_na_ajiqu _q]haoeilkoe^hah]nalnk`q__eÅj+Bh]cq]lqn]oa_kj*
^eaj]ao]pailan]pqn])uoa`a^aaolan]n]ra_aor]ne]o cah]]-Ñ@u ah]cq]`ai]n]*/)2Ñ@)lankh]_kjcah]_eÅj
oai]j]o]jpao`amqaoalqa`]]lna_e]nah_na_eieajpk`a jkaoqjlnk_aokdkikc}jakaej_hqok]h]opailan]pq*
_khkje]oajia`eko`a_qhperkajahh]^kn]pknek+S]nekoc}* n]oi|o^]f]oateopajie_nk^kho]o`a]cq]jk_kjcah]`]+
janko`a^]_pane]ou]nmqa]ouie_nkknc]jeoikoaq_]nek* Jeajpn]oateop]]cq]h~mqe`]`eolkje^ha)aolkoe^haah_na*
p]opeajajnalnaoajp]jpaomqaokjloe_nkpkhan]jpao+ _eieajpkie_nk^e]jklkn`a^]fk`ahlqjpk`a_kjcah]*
_eÅj+ E]uare`aj_e]o_kjrej_ajpaomqa`aiqaopn]jmqa
; \ Y h lY [ ag f ] k  e gd][mdYj]k Y dY hka[jg^adaY ateopa_na_eieajpkie_nk^e]jk]*./Ñ@)lankjklkn`a*
Iko loe_nÅbehko lnk`q_aj ajvei]o mqa bqj_ekj]j `a ^]fk`aaopar]hkn+
ik`kÅlpeikajahbn~kumqa_kjbna_qaj_e]oa`aoj]pq* >qjmqa h] _kjcah]_eÅj arep] ah _na_eieajpk ie_nk*
n]hev]jkej]_per]jej_hqok]pailan]pqn]oiquik`an]* ^e]jkjk_]qo]ja_ao]ne]iajpah]iqanpa_ahqh]n+I]o_}*
`]o+I]o^]oaoikha_qh]nao`aaopada_dkjkoa_kjk_aj hqh]o ie_nk^e]j]o lqa`aj _kjpejq]n iap]^khev]j`k ]
lkn_kilhapklankoad]k^oanr]`kmqa) ajcajan]h)h]o pailan]pqn]oiquejbaneknao]h]omqalaniepajah_na_e*
ajvei]o]_per]oajbn~kpeajajajoqaopnq_pqn]oa_qj`]* ieajpk+ Mknafailhk)oad]`aikopn]`knaolen]_eÅj_kj
ne]i]ukn_]jpe`]``ad}he_ao*]uiajkn_]jpe`]``adk* lnk`q__eÅj`a@LŌajoqahko`apqj`n]]pailan]pqn]o
f]o*l $nwYk] Pa__eÅj 0+4& mqa h]o ajvei]o mqa okj p]j^]f]o_kik*06Ñ@+Mknp]jpk)d]uajvei]omqa_kjpe*
ej]_per]oajbn~k+ I]`eolkoe_eÅjajdkf]*lpeaj`a]oan jÇ]jbqj_ekj]j`k]pailan]pqn]oiquejbaneknao]h]o
qj]aopnq_pqn]i|on~ce`])u h]i]ukn_]jpe`]``ad}he_a* mqaheiep]jah_na_eieajpk+
]ajh]oajvei]o]_per]oajbn~klqa`alaniepen]aop]o >`ai|o)ahia`ek`aoqolajoeÅj`ah]o_}hqh]o]ba_p]
lnkpa~j]oi]uknbhate^ehe`]`ajao]o_kj`e_ekjao+ oqoajoe^ehe`]`]hbn~k+Peajahia`ekaop|jlnaoajpaook*
I]oajvei]o]_per]oajbn~kp]i^e}joqahajpajani|o hqpko_kikahche_ankhkah`eiapehoqhbÅte`k%AJPL&) oa
]iejk|_e`kolkh]naou iajko]iejk|_e`kode`nkbÅ^e_ko na^]f]ahlqjpk`a_kjcah]_eÅj+Bopkookhqpkolajapn]jaj
mqah]oajvei]olnaoajpaoajiaoÅb~hkoupaniÅbehko+>`a* h]o_}hqh]ou h]olnkpacaj`ahkoaba_pko`ah]`aode`n]p]*
i|o)oqahajlnaoajp]niajkoajh]_ao`}^ehao$nwYk]Pa_* _eÅj]h]ravmqaarep]jh]bkni]_eÅj`a_neop]hao`adeahk+
_eÅj 0+.& u qj] iajkn ejpan]__eÅj ajpna `kiejeko Aada_dk)h]]`e_eÅj`ap]hao]cajpao)mqaoa`ajkiej]j
aopnq_pqn]haonaola_pk]h]olnkpa~j]o`aie_nkknc]jeo* [jaghjgl][lgj]k(aoqji}pk`kjkni]h`a_kjoanr]n_qhpe*
ikomqa_na_ajiafkn]i]uknaopailan]pqn]o+>i^]o rkoie_nk^e]jko]pailan]pqn]oiqu^]f]o+M]n]i]jpa*
_]n]_pan~ope_]olqa`ajoanrenecq]hiajpa`a]uq`]l]n] jan_}hqh]o`qn]jpah]nckpeailk) h]o_}hqh]o oaoqahaj
i]jpajanbhate^haouajvei|pe_]iajpa]_per]o]^]f]pai* oqolaj`anajqjia`ek_kj.-"`aAJPLkche_ankhu oa
lan]pqn]]h]olnkpa~j]o`aaop]oajvei]oajah]i^eajpa _kjcah]jn|le`]iajpa`a*4-]*.63Ñ@+I]o_}hqh]o_kj*
]hp]iajpalkh]n`ah_epklh]oi]+ cah]`]o)lnal]n]`]o]`a_q]`]iajpaumqajkd]u]joe`k
Lpn]_]n]_pan~ope_]`ahkoloe_nÅbehkoaomqa)aj_ki* _kjcah]`]ou `ao_kjcah]`]onalape`]iajpa)lqa`ajlan*
l]n]_eÅj_kjhko iaoÅb~hko) ah pn]jolknpa]_perk $nwYk] i]ja_anre]^haolknh]nckpeailk)]hiajkolkn`}_]`]o+
. 4 5 Q J E@ = @  . E  L mdi^dk dj n_ `  h d^mj ] dj gj b ~\

Kkoikraiko]dkn]]hkpnkatpnaik`ahpaniÅiapnk
l]n]_kjoe`an]nhkoie_nkknc]jeoikomqareraj]paila* P\]g\3+. H~h do`n_ ` o` h k ` m\ op m\ ^jij^d_jn
`ig\\ ^ op\ gd_ \_ k\m\`g^m`^dh d` ioj
n]pqn]oahar]`]o+
_ ` n`m`nq dqjn

1 ) , .  G af aj j ] n ak a{ f Ahkfe Fuc_j[ijthc_Yei
ikf[h_eh[i#z=$
W  W
Hjnjmb\idnh jn^jio`h k`m\opm\nÅkodh \n]\e\nn` I\^mjjmb\idnhjn
gg\h\iknd^mÅadgjntgjnm`km`n`io\io`nh|n`som`hjn =idh\g`n
c\]do\i\h ]d`io`nk`mh \i`io`h `io`am~jn+Hjn L`^`ntjomjnq`mo`]m\_jn\^p|od^jn 05
knd^mÅadgjnkm`n`io\i]djh jg}^pg\nlp`api^dji\i h `ejm Ein`^ojn 12*2-
Knom|^j_jn%^mpno|^`jn& 16*2-
\]\e\o` h k `m\opm\k` mjl p ` nji\ijmh \gh `io`
n`ind]g`n\o`h k`m\opm\no` hkg\_\n+ Lg\io\n
Lg\io\nq\n^pg\m`n 12
E  çAilp}n`_da`m`i^d\pijmb\idnh jknd^mÅadgj_ ` pi Ipnbjn 2-
knd^mjojg`m\io`<
Id^mjjmb\idnhjn
E  çMp}\ _\ko\^dji`nkm`n`io\ g\h`h]m\i\ Id^mjjmb\idnhjn`p^\mdjo\n
^dojkg|nh d^\_` gjnknd^mÅadgjntk j mlp }nji Lmjojujjn 23
=gb\n 22*3-
i`^`n\md\n<
Djibjn 3-*3/
Lmj^\mdjo\n
<WYj[h_W
3 +. 1  ? m` ^ dh d` i oj  h d^ mj ] d\ i j  \ \go\n ?d\ij]\^o`md\n 40
ë o` h k ` m\ op m\ n BjoÅomjajn\ijsdb}id^jn 4-*40
>\^o`md\nlpdhdjmb\iÅomja\n,
I]re`]ie_nk^e]j]bhkna_aaj]i^eajpao`aahar]`]pai* lpdhdjgdoÅomja\n 62
lan]pqn]) ej_hqokaj ah]cq]denreaj`k+ Mknaj_ei]`a ;hY^W[W
32Ñ@okhkrerajbkni]olnk_]nekp]o)lankajao]o_kj`e* ;hY^W[Wlpdhdjmb\iÅomja\n,
lpdhdjgdoÅomja\n ÖŌ Ö\
_ekjaoateopaqj]ajknia`eranoe`]``aie_nkknc]jeoiko
lanpaja_eajpao]=Y[l]jaYu <j[`Y]Y* î H\o`hk`m\opm\g~hdo`npk`mdjm\g\lp`kp`_`^m+^`m`gjmb\idnhjJohebeXki
\kcWh__`n_`..0Ñ?H\`nk`^d`JoheZ_Yj_kckp`_`^m`^`mdi^gpnj\./.z=)
; e Z a] f l] k [gf l] e h ] jY lm jY k YdlYk
>mqahhkoie_nkknc]jeoiko_qu]pailan]pqn]Ålpei]aop|
r]ne]_ekjaoiajknao`a .*/Ñ@]hkh]nck`ah]Äk+Bop]o
lknaj_ei]`a12Ñ@oahh]i]jl]jez^adgku]mqahhko_qu]
bqajpaopeajaj`erano]o_kilkoe_ekjaomq~ie_]our]hknao
pailan]pqn]Ålpei]aop|lknaj_ei]`a5-Ñ@okjhko`a)
`alE+Mknaj_ei]`a32Ñ@)oÅhkoalnaoajp]jlnk_]nek*
h]jl]jez^adgk%Cecqn]3+.6&+Bjh]j]pqn]hav]oaaj_qaj*
p]o %P \]g\ 3 +. &) lankh]`eranoe`]``a=Y[l]jaYu <j[`Y]Y
pn]jpailan]pqn]op]j]hp]ooÅhkaj]hcqj]o|na]oiqu
lqa`aoaniqu]ilhe]+
naopnejce`]o+ Mknafailhk)ajoqahkoiquatlqaopko]h]
hqvokh]noa]h_]jv]j]ia`ek`~]pailan]pqn]ooqlanek*
nao]2-Ñ@)aej_hqokoalqa`ahhac]n]hko4-Ñ@+Ikoi]* B ah ] jl] je { ^adg k  ]f ^m ] f l] k l] je Y d] k
pane]haoajbaniajp]_eÅj)_kikhko]_Çiqhko`a_kilkop Bjiq_d]obqajpaopani]hao%B db p m\ 3 +/ / &oalnaoajp]qj]
u hkoajoeh]`ko)lqa`aj]h_]jv]np]i^e}jpailan]pqn]o cn]jr]nea`]``adelanpaniÅbehkop~le_ko)p]jpkaola_eao
`a4-Ñ@+Mankh]opailan]pqn]oi|o]hp]oajh]j]pqn]* mqeiekknc]jÅpnkb]o _kik mqeiekhepÅpnkb]o+ Bh _na_e*
hav]aop|j]ok_e]`]o_kjbajÅiajkorkh_|je_ko)ajl]npe* ieajpk`aaopkoknc]jeoikolqa`aaopq`e]noaia`e]jpah]
_qh]n_kjh]obqajpaopani]hao+ ejianoeÅj`alknp]oajah]cq]uoqatpn]__eÅj]h_]^k`a
Jq_dkoao_]lao`a]cq]_]heajpapeajajpailan]pqn]o qjko`~]o8ahat]iajie_nko_Åle_k`ahkolknp]onarah]_k*
lnÅtei]o]h]`aa^qhhe_eÅju h]o bqi]nkh]olqa`aj]h* hkje]o`alnk_]nekp]omqaoa`ao]nnkhh]j]l]npen`a^]_pa*
_]jv]nhko.2-*2--Ñ@+I]oaieoekjaode`nkpani]hao`ahko ne]o]eoh]`]omqaoa]`deanaju_na_ajok^nah]oqlanbe_ea
bkj`koi]nejkopeajajpailan]pqn]o`a02-Ñ@koqla* `ahre`nek%Cecqn]3+/-#&+Ikoaopq`ekoa_khÅce_kook^naao*
neknao$nwYk]Pa__eÅj/1+..&+I]obqajpaopani]haooaaj* pkoknc]jeoikomqarerajaj]cq]denreaj`k`aiqaopn]j
_qajpn]j `eopne^qe`]o lkn pk`k ah iqj`k) lank oa mqah]orahk_e`]`ao`a_na_eieajpkokjjkp]^haiajpan|*
_kj_ajpn]jl]npe_qh]niajpaajahkaopa`ahko Bop]`ko le`]oumqaoalnaoajp]jpeailko`acajan]_eÅjp]j_kn*
Rje`ko`a>i}ne_])Kqar]Wah]j`])Foh]j`e])G]lÅj)Fp]* pko_kikÖ dkn]+
he])Fj`kjaoe])>i}ne_]@ajpn]huñbne_]@ajpn]h+I]vkj] Pad]jk^paje`k_qhperko`aiq_dko`aaopkolnk_]*
`ai]ukn_kj_ajpn]_eÅj`aaopapelk`aaieoekjaoaoah nekp]odelanpaniÅbehko)mqa_knnaolkj`aj]pelkoiknbkhÅ*
M]nmqaK]_ekj]h`aVahhksopkja)Tukiejc%RP>&+ ce_ko u beoekhÅce_ko r]ne]`ko `a ^]_pane]o u ]nmqa]o+
>qjmqaaj]hcqjko_]okoh]pailan]pqn]`ah]obqaj* Bopq`eko behkcaj}pe_ko^]o]`ko ajh] oa_qaj_e]_eÅj `ah
paopani]haoaor]ne]^ha)ajkpnkoaoiqu_kjop]jpa)_kj OK>ne^koki]hp]i^e}jd]jnarah]`kqj]cn]j`eranoe*
? \ k ~op gj Å  E  ? m` ^ dh d` i oj h d^mj ] d\ i j  .46

hhac]`k]h]_kj_hqoeÅj`amqa% Ö &hkoknc]jeoikolnk_]*
nekp]ookj_]l]_ao`a_na_an]pailan]pqn]oi|o]hp]omqa
hkoaq_]nekp]o8% Ō &`ajpnk`ahkolnk_]nekp]o)hkoi|opan*
ikb~he_kookjaola_eao`a]nmqa]ou %0&hkoknc]jeoikojk
bkpÅpnkbkookj_]l]_ao`a_na_an]pailan]pqn]i|oaha*
r]`]mqahkobkpÅpnkbko+
Ikolnk_]nekp]opaniÅbehkooaaj_qajpn]jp]i^e}j_kj
bna_qaj_e]aj]i^eajpao]npebe_e]hao+Iko_]hajp]`knao`a
]cq]`ki}ope_kokej`qopne]haolnaoajp]jpailan]pqn]o`a
3-*5-Ñ@u_kjopepquajlknp]jpkqjd|^ep]pb]rkn]^hal]n]
ah_na_eieajpk`aaopkolnk_]nekp]opanikb~he_ko+Pad]j
]eoh]`k`a_]hajp]`knao`a]cq]knc]jeoikooaiaf]jpao]
O`]jemkYimYla[mk(mqaaoqjpaniÅbehk_kiÇjaj]nnkuko
`a]cq]_]heajpa$nwYk]Pa__eÅj.3+.4&+I]o_ajpn]haoah}_*
pne_]o)h]oej`qopne]omqaqo]j]cq]_]heajpaukpn]obqaj*
pao ]npebe_e]hao `a j]pqn]hav] p}nie_] okj oepeko `kj`a
lqa`aj_na_anhkopaniÅbehko+Jq_dko`aahhkooalqa`aj
]eoh]nb|_ehiajpaqpehev]j`kia`eko_kilhafkoej_q^]`ko
]h]pailan]pqn]`ahd|^ep]p`ah]iqaopn]knecej]h+

? klYZ ada\ Y\ \ ]  dYk h jg l]yf YkY ]d]nY\ Yk


l] e h ] jY lm jY k
ã@Åiklqa`ajhkopaniÅbehkou hkodelanpaniÅbehkolnko*
lan]n]p]j]hp]opailan]pqn]o<Bjlneianhqc]n)oqoaj*

 

B db p m\  3 +/ /  ?m`^dhd`ioj_`cdk`mo`mh Åadgjn`i\bp\
cdmqd`i_j) $Y%>jpg_`mOkmdib)pik`lp`Äj\mmjtj_`\bp\
cdmqd`i_j`i`gk\mlp`i\^dji\g_`U`ggjrnoji`+Ano`\mmjtj
^\gd`io`km`n`io\pi\o`hk`m\opm\_`.*/Ñ?k jm`i^dh\_`g
kpioj_``]pggd^dÅi+Hjn_`kÅndojnhdi`m\g`n^`m^\_`g^\p^`nji
_`n~gd^`t\upam`) $Z%Id^mjbm\a~\_`pi\hd^mj^jgjid\_`
kmj^\mdjo\n_`n\mmjgg\_\nj]m`pikjmo\dih`mnj`i`g\bp\_`g
^\p^`_`pi\ap`io`o`mh\gn`h`e\io`\g\hjnom\_\`i$Y%*

`]`ajpnahkodelanpaniÅbehko+>hcqj]o]nmqa]odelanpan*
iÅbeh]olnaoajp]jpailan]pqn]oÅlpei]olknaj_ei]`a
hko .--Ñ@ulknp]jpkoÅhk_na_ajaj_|i]n]olnaoqnev]*
`]omqalaniepaj]h_]jv]najahh]^kn]pknekpailan]pqn]o
oqlaneknao]hlqjpk`aa^qhhe_eÅj+Kejcqj]aola_ea_kjk*
_e`]`a^]_pane]oao_]l]v`a_na_anlknaj_ei]`a62Ñ@+

N]je { ^adg k
Jq_dko paniÅbehko %_kj pailan]pqn]o Ålpei]o `a 12* B db p m\ 3 +/ 0  ?m`^dhd`ioj_`pi\^d\ij]\^o`md\o` mh Åadg\`i
5-Ñ@& oa lnaoajp]j p]i^e}j aj bqajpao pani]hao u  aj pi\ mmjtj_`\bp\^\gd`io`_ ` gL\mlp`J\^dji\g _`
kpnko]i^eajpao`a]cq]o_]heajpao+ Bjh]obqajpaopan* U`ggjrnoji`+ L\omÅi_`_`n\mmjggj^\m\^o`m~nod^j`iajmh\_`R
i]hao)]ia`e`]mqaah]cq]denreaj`kbhquau _knnalkn %h\m^\_jk jmg~i`\nmje\n_dn^jiodip\n&`i`gbm\_d`io`o}mhd^j)
ajmh \_jkjm^d\ij]\^o`md\n`i`gg~hdo`npk`mdjm_`o`hk`m\opm\
hko^kn`ao)oaajbn~]cn]`q]hiajpauknecej]qjcn]`eajpa
k\m\g\qd_\ajoÅomja\)4-*41Ñ?+Agk\omÅi^\h]d\kjmlp``g\bp\
`apailan]pqn]+> hkh]nck`aaopacn]`eajpa)_na_ajr]*
n``iam~\h|nm|kd_\h`io``igjn]jm_`nlp``i`g^`iomj_`g
nekoie_nkknc]jeoikou _]`]aola_ea`ebanajpa_na_aaj
^\p^`+Ag\bp\agpt`_`n_`_`om|n_`g\ajojbm\a~\c\^d\`gam`io`
qji]ncaj`eopejpk`apailan]pqn]o% B db p m\ 3 +/ 0 &+ Bopq* _`g\hdnh\+Ag^jgjmq`m_jnjn`_`]`\pi\^`k\_`g\
`e]j`kh]`eopne^q_eÅj`ah]oaola_eaoajahcn]`eajpauaj ^d\ij]\^o`md\Mod[Y^eYeYYknlp``nm`ndno`io`\g\o`hk`m\opm\+
`eopejp]ol]npao`ahiqj`kaolkoe^ha`apaniej]nhkoh~* =h`_d_\lp`agpt``g\bp\`i`gbm\_d`io`) g\_`ind_\_^`gpg\m
iepao`apailan]pqn]oqlaneknl]n]_]`]_h]oa`aknc]* \ph`io\kjmlp`n`_`n\mmjgg\i^`k\nh`ijno`mhja~gd^\n)t`g
jeoik %Q]^h] 3+.&+ > l]npen `a aop] ejbkni]_eÅj oa d] ^jgjmq`m_`n`dio`indad^\+
. 5 - Q J E@ = @  . E  L mdi^dk dj n_ `  h d^mj ] dj gj b ~\

vei]ou kpn]olnkpa~j]ookjiq_dki]oaop]^haobnajpa] ]]hp]opailan]pqn]o+I]oajvei]o`ahkopaniÅbehkou `a


h]pailan]pqn]mqah]o`ahkoiaoÅb~hkou oqoi]_nkik* hkodelanpaniÅbehkooaqo]j]ilhe]iajpaajie_nk^ekhkc~]
h}_qh]obqj_ekj]j`aik`kzhlae g]]hp]opailan]pqn]o+ ej`qopne]hlknmqaokj_]l]_ao`a_]p]hev]nna]__ekjao^ek*
ã@Åikhkcn]jaop]aop]^ehe`]`bnajpa]h_]hkn<Ikoaopq* mq~ie_]o]pailan]pqn]oahar]`]ou okji|oaop]^haomqa
`eko`ahkoajvei]opanikaop]^haoej`e_]jmqa]iajq`k h]o`ahkoiaoÅb~hko)`aik`kmqah]re`]ia`e]`aaop]o
oqoa_qaj_e]`ebeanaajiqulk_ko]iejk|_e`ko`ah]`a lnal]n]_ekjaoajvei|pe_]oaoi|olnkhkjc]`]+
hkoajvei]omqahhar]j]_]^kna]__ekjao]j|hkc]oajhko Rjafailhk_h|oe_k`aajvei]naoeopajpa]h_]hknu`a
iaoÅb~hko+ M]na_amqaqjko_q]jpko_]i^ekoajlqjpko cn]jeilknp]j_e]^ekhÅce_]aoh]AK>lkheian]o]]eoh]`]
_h]ralaniepajqjlhac]ieajpk`ebanajpa`ah]_]`aj]lk* `ahpaniÅbehkD`]jemkYimYla[mk*Bop]ajvei])_kjk_e`]
helalp~`e_])mqaaonaolkjo]^ha`ah]panikaop]^ehe`]`+ _kikOYihgdae]jYkY(oaqo]l]n]h]nalape_eÅj]qpki|pe_]
I]aop]^ehe`]`ajhkodelanpaniÅbehkooa`a^ap]i^e}j] `ahkol]okomqapeajajhqc]najh]na]__eÅjaj_]`aj]`a
qj]qiajpkajahaop]^ha_eieajpk`aajh]_aoeÅje_koajpna h]lkheian]o]%M@O)`ahejch}ohgdqe]jYk][`Yafj]Y[lagf%(
h]o_]nc]olkoeper]oujac]per]o`a`eranoko]iejk|_e`ko qj]p}_je_]iqueilknp]jpaaj^ekhkc~]%nwYk]Pa__eÅj
lnaoajpaou]hail]mqap]ieajpk]hp]iajpade`nkbÅ^e_k`ah ./+5&+Pa_kjk_ajkpnkoqoko`aajvei]opaniknaoeopajpao
ejpanekn`ah]olnkpa~j]omqab]rkna_ah]naoeopaj_e]j]pqn]h u`akpnkolnk`q_pko_ahqh]naoaop]^hao]h_]hknmqaaop|j
] h] `aoj]pqn]hev]_eÅj aj ah ]i^eajpa ]_qkok `ah _epk* oeaj`k`ao]nnkhh]`kol]n]]lhe_]_ekjaoej`qopne]hao+
lh]oi]+>`ai|o)hkodelanpaniÅbehko_kjpeajaj_]jpe`]`ao
oecjebe_]per]o`aokhqpko)_kik`e*ejkoepkhbkob]pk)`e*che_a* 1 ) , /  G a f aj j ] n ak a{ f
nkhbkob]pku i]jkoehche_an]pk)mqa]uq`]j]aop]^ehev]nh]o
lnkpa~j]oarep]j`koq`acn]`]_eÅjp}nie_]+ Fgkgj_Yfake gk[mqYkl]e h]jYlmjYkzh lae Yk\]
[j][ae a]flgk]kal{Yf]flj]/0q3+}=k]ddYeYf
?klYZ ada\ Y\ \ ] dYk e ]e Z jYf YkY ]d]nY\Yk l]je z^adgk'qYim]ddgk[mqYkl]e h]jYlmjYkzhlae Ykkgf
kmh]jagj]kY3+}=k]ddYeYf `ah]jl]je z^adgk)?klgk
l] e h ] jY lm jY k
gj_Yfake gk`YZalYfYe Za]fl]k[Yda]fl]kim ]hm]\]f
Gqjpk]hkoajvei]ou]kpnko_kilkjajpao_ahqh]nao)h]o Yd[YfrYjl]e h]jYlmjYkkmh]jagj]kYdg k,++}=) Fgk
iai^n]j]o_epklh|oie_]o`ahkopaniÅbehkou`ahkode* l]je z^adgkqdg k`ah]jl]je z^adgkhjg\m[]f
lanpaniÅbehkoja_aoep]joanpanikaop]^hao+>jpanekniajpa e Y[jge gdw[mdYkl]je g]klYZd]k)
iaj_ekj]ikomqahkoloe_nÅbehkopeajajiai^n]j]o_kj
h~le`kone_koaj|_e`kocn]okolkheejo]pqn]`komqai]jpea* C Ö= m v d]k]d\g e af ag\]gj_Yfake gkim ]af[dmq]
jajh]oiai^n]j]obqj_ekj]haouajaop]`koaiebhqe`k] ]kh][a]kim ]hm]\]f[j][]jhg j]f[ae Y\ ] ,++}=:
^]f]opailan]pqn]o+> h]ejrano])hkopaniÅbehkolnaoajp]j C Ö=mvd]kdY]kljm[lmjY\ ] dYe ]e ZjYfY\ ] mfYYjim]Y
p~le_]iajpah~le`koiqune_koaj|_e`kocn]okoo]pqn]`ko) `ah]jl]je z^adYqhg ji mw]klY]kljm[lmjY]k^m f[agfYdY
laniepeaj`k ] h]o iai^n]j]o lani]ja_an bqj_ekj]h* ]d] nY\Yl]e h]jYlmjY:
iajpaaop]^hao]ahar]`]opailan]pqn]o+Iko|_e`kocn]oko
o]pqn]`kobkni]jqjie_nk]i^eajpai|ode`nkbÅ^e_kmqa C ÖK m w]kdYNYihgdae ]jYkYqh g jim w]kae hgjlYfl]:
hkojko]pqn]`ko)b]rkna_eaj`kh]aop]^ehe`]``ah]iai*
^n]j]+
IkodelanpaniÅbehko)ajoqi]ukn~]]nmqa]o)jklna*
oajp]j|_e`kocn]okoajoqoiai^n]j]ooejkde`nk_]n* R K PNK O B=?PKNAO
^qnko `a pelk @ŐÕ mqa aop|j _kilqaopko `a qje`]`ao = I > EA J P = H A O 
eoklnajke`aonalapeper]o`a_ej_k|pkiko`a_]n^kjkmqa MQA= BA ? P= J 
oaqjajlknajh]_a}pan]hche_ankhbkob]pk%nwYk]Cecqn]o
= H  ? N A ? EI EA J P K
1+4_u 1+5#&+>`ai|oh]aopnq_pqn]chk^]h`aaop]oiai*
^n]j]oaoh]`aqj]egfg[YhYhel~`e_]ajrav`aZa[YhYhe* I]pailan]pqn]peajaqjaba_pkeilknp]jpaok^naah_na*
l~`e_]%Cecqn]1+59ã&+Bop]aopnq_pqn]iafkn]h]_]l]_e`]` _eieajpkie_nk^e]jk+Mankiq_dkokpnkob]_pknaop]i*
`ah]oiai^n]j]ol]n]naoeopenh]`eocnac]_eÅj]h]opai* ^e}j)ajpnaahhkoahlE)h]koikikh]ne`]`u ahkt~cajk+
lan]pqn]orep]haop]j]hp]o`ahkodelanpaniÅbehko+@kjoe*
`an]naikokpnko]ola_pkook^nah]aop]^ehe`]`]h_]hkn`a
hkodelanpaniÅbehko)ej_hquaj`kh]`ahAK>) ajh]oPa_* 3 +. 2  ? m` ^ dh d` i oj  h d^ mj ] d\ i j t  kD
_ekjao .4+.0*.4+.2+
I]]_e`avk]h_]heje`]``aqj]okhq_eÅjoaatlnao]lknoq
lEajqj]ao_]h]ajh]mqah]jaqpn]he`]`aolE4%Cecqn]
N ]je g ^adaY q  Z ag l][f g dg _ yY 3+/1&+Ikor]hknao`alElkn`a^]fk`a4okjv[a\gkuhko
Ikoie_nkknc]jeoikopaniÅbehkoadelanpaniÅbehkonaoqh* i]uknao`a4okjYd[Ydafgkg Zvka[gk*Boeilknp]jpapa*
p]jejpanao]jpaolkn]hcki|omqalknn]vkjao`a^ekhkc~] janaj_qajp]mqaahlEaoqj]bqj_eÅjhkc]n~pie_]8lkn
bqj`]iajp]h+Bopkoie_nkknc]jeoikokbna_ajeilknp]jpao ahhk)qj_]i^ekajqj]qje`]``alEnalnaoajp]qj_]i*
rajp]f]ol]n]lnk_aokoej`qopne]haou^ekpa_jkhÅce_ko)iq* ^ek `a Ö Õ ra_ao ajh]_kj_ajpn]_eÅj`ade`nkcajekjao+
_dko`ahko_q]haobqj_ekj]j`aik`ki|on|le`kuabe_]v >o~)ahrej]cna%_kjlE_an_]jk]/&u ah]ikj~]_k`k*
? \ k ~op gj Å  E  ? m` ^ dh d` i oj h d^mj ] d\ i j  .5.

I j g` n k j mgdomj _` 7 @q]j`kahlEoaahar]lknaj_ei]`a1)h]o_}hqh]o`aK*


gk`aeY] oa heo]j+ Bopa ie_nkknc]jeoikrera aj oqahko
iqu_]heajpaouatpnai]`]iajpa|_e`ko]ok_e]`ko_kj
Op`gjnt\bp\nqjg^|id^\n ]_pere`]`aorkh_|je_]o+
Bgpd_jnb|nomd^jn
Vphj_`gdhÅi
@m`i\e`_`hdi\n|^d_\n ; d[Yd{^adgk
Rdi\bm`
Npd]\m]j Rjko_q]jpkoatpnaiÅbehkolnaoajp]jqjlEÅlpeikl]n]
I`gj^joji`n
Pjh\o`n _na_eieajpkiquahar]`k)]ra_aop]j]hpk_kiklE .-+
Mp`nj\h`md^\ij Ikoie_nkknc]jeoikomqa_na_aj]lE Ålpeiko `a6 k
i|o)oa`aoecj]j_kik]h_]hÅbehkok^]oÅbehko+Iko]h_]*
I\~u)n\ghÅi)b\h]\n hÅbehkooaaj_qajpn]jlknhkcajan]hajd|^ep]poiqu^|oe*
=bp\kpm\ _ko)_kikh]ckooÅ`e_kokoqahkone_koaj_]n^kj]pao+Iko
lnk_]nekp]o]h_]hÅbehkoiafknaopq`e]`kod]joe`kaola_eao
\]=Y[addmk(_kik=*^ajemk*Bopaknc]jeoikoao]h_]hÅbehk
Op`gji\opm\g\g^\gdij
H\bjn\g^\gdijn lankpeajaqj]ilheklk_kqoq]hn]jck`a_na_eieajpk)]
Ojgp^dji`ne\]jijn\n lE`a4+2] h h + >hcqjkoie_nkknc]jeoiko]h_]hÅbehkoat*
=hji~\^j_jh}nod^j
H\bjnnÅ_d^jn pnaikookjp]i^e}jd]hÅbehko%]i]jpao`ao]h&)u h]i]ukn
`som`h\_\h`io` l]npa`a}opkolanpaja_aj]<j[`Y]Y*Jq_d]o^]_pane]obk*
\g^\gdijn
?\g%njgp^ pÅpnkb]o nkf]o $nwYk] Pa__eÅj .2+/&okjp]i^e}jbqanpa*
iajpa]h_]hÅbeh]o+ >hcqjko]h_]hÅbehkopeajaj]lhe_]_eÅj
ej`qopne]hlknmqalnk`q_ajajvei]ode`nkh~pe_]o)_kik
lnkpa]o]ouhel]o]o)mqabqj_ekj]j^eaj]lE]h_]hejku oa
B db p m\ 3 +/ 1  H\`n^\g\_`kD+=pilp`\gbpijn qo]j_kik]`eperko`ahko`apancajpao`ki}ope_ko+
hd^mjjmb\idnhjnkp`_`iqdqdm\kDh pt\gojj hpt]\ej)`gkD Iko]h_]hÅbehkopeajajejpan}o^|oe_klknr]ne]on]vk*
diom\^`gpg\mk`mh\i`^`kmÅsdh j\g\i`pom\gd_\_+ jaounaoqhp]jp]i^e}jiquejpanao]jpaolknhkolnk^ha*
i]o^ekajanc}pe_komqalh]jpa]j]hreren]lEp]j]hpk+
i}ope_k%_kjlElnÅteik] h h & `ebeanajiehiehhkjao`a Mknafailhk)jknaoqhp]k^rekn]_ekj]hev]n_Åiklqa`aj
ra_aoajh]_kj_ajpn]_eÅj`ade`nkcajekjao+ aop]^ha_anqj]bqanv]ikpnev`alnkpkjao_q]j`kh]oq*
@]`]ie_nkknc]jeoikpeajaqjn]jck`alE`ajpnk lanbe_eaatpanj]`ah]iai^n]j]aop]j]h_]hej]$nwYk]
`ah_q]haolkoe^haah_na_eieajpkujkni]hiajpalkoaa Pa__eÅj2+./&+Bjaopq`ekona]hev]`ko_kj=*^ajemkoad]
qjlEÅlpeik^eaj`abeje`k+I]i]ukn~]oa`aoajrqahra are`aj_e]`kmqa) ajhqc]n`ah]qoq]hbqanv]ikpnev`a
aqji]ncaj`alE`a/*0qje`]`ao+Jq_dko]i^eajpao lnkpkjao)aoqj]bqanv]ikpnev`aK](h]mqaoqiejeopn]
j]pqn]haopeajajqjr]hkn`alEajpna1u6)uhkoknc]* h]ajanc~]l]n]ahpn]jolknpau h]ikrehe`]`+Pknlnaj`aj*
jeoiko_kjlEÅlpeiko`aaopakn`ajokjhkoi|o_kiq* paiajpa)oejai^]nck)p]i^e}joacajan]qj]bqanv]ik*
jao+PÅhkqj]o_q]jp]oaola_eaolqa`aj_na_anlkn`a^]fk pnev`alnkpkjaoaj_}hqh]o`a=*^ajemk(ej_hqok]qjmqa
`a0klknaj_ei]`a6+ h]_]n]atpanj]`ah]iai^n]j]aop|nalhap]`aekjaode*
`nktehk+Bj=*^ajemk(h]bqanv]ikpnev`alnkpkjaoaoh]
; [a\ { ^adg k naolkjo]^ha`ah]o~jpaoeonaolen]pkne]`a>QM+
Ikoknc]jeoikomqa_na_ajiafkn]lE^]fk_kjopepquajqj
pelk`aatpnaiÅbehkohh]i]`ko]_e`Åbehko+Bhcnqlk`ahko h B  af ljY[]dm dYj
dkjckooqahaoani|o]_e`Åbehkmqah]o^]_pane]o+Jq_dko BhlEÅlpeikl]n]ah_na_eieajpk`aqjknc]jeoikna*
dkjcko_na_aj`aik`kÅlpeik]lE2kejbaneknu qjko lnaoajp]okhkahlE`ahia`ek]pljY[]dmdYj*BhlEafljY[])
_q]jpko_na_aj^eajej_hqok]lE/+>hcqj]o^]_pane]ookj dmdYj`a^a lani]ja_an lnÅteik ] h] jaqpn]he`]` l]n]
p]i^e}j]_e`Åbeh]o+Aada_dk)d]u^]_pane]omqaokj]_e`Å* arep]nh]`aopnq__eÅj`ai]_nkikh}_qh]o_ahqh]nao+Bjh]
beh]ogZda_Y\Yk(ej_]l]_ao`a_na_an]lEjaqpnk+Bjpna}op]o i]uknl]npa`ahkoie_nkknc]jeoiko _quklE Ålpeik
oaaj_qajpn]jr]ne]oaola_eao`a<[a\al`agZY[addmkur]ne]o l]n]ah_na_eieajpkaop|ajpnaǾ uŔ )hkohh]i]`kof]mljz)
<j[`Y]Y_kikNmd^gdgZmk(O`]jeghdYkeYu A]jjghdYkeY* ^ldgk(ah_epklh]oi]lani]ja_ajaqpnkkiqulnÅteik]
Bhb]_pkn_n~pe_ki|oeilknp]jpal]n]ah_]n|_pan]_e* h]jaqpn]he`]`%Cecqn]3+/1&+Pejai^]nck)ajhko]_e`Åbe*
`Åbehkk^hec]`k aoh] aop]^ehe`]``ah]iai^n]j]_epk* hkou ]h_]hÅbehkoahlEejpanjklqa`ar]ne]n+Mknafailhk)
lh]oi|pe_]+ @q]j`k ah lE ao jaqpnk) h] iai^n]j] ajah]_e`Åbehk]jpaoiaj_ekj]`k)K* gk`aeY]( ahlEej*
_epklh]oi|pe_]`ah]o^]_pane]o]_e`Åbeh]ooa`aopnquauh]o pn]_ahqh]nao1)3uaj]h_]hÅbehkoatpnaikooad]jhkcn]`k
_}hqh]ooaheo]j+Bopkej`e_]mqaaopkoknc]jeoikojkokj ia`enr]hknao`alEejpn]_ahqh]n`ad]op]6)2+K koao]^a
ian]iajpalgd]jYfl]k ]h |_e`koejk mqaj]ima]j]f ]hp]o _kj_anpav]oeaopkor]hknaonalnaoajp]jnaola_per]iajpa
_kj_ajpn]_ekjao`aekjaode`nÅcajkl]n]oqaop]^ehe`]`+ hkor]hknaoi|o^]fkoui|o]hpko`alEejpn]_ahqh]n)lank
Mknafailhk)ahlnk_]nekp]i|o]_e`Åbehk_kjk_e`k)Ka[jg) p]haoh~iepao`a^aj`aoaniqulnÅteiko]}opko)lqaoah
h`admkgk`aeY]%]nmqa]&) _na_a]qjlEÅlpeik`a-)4+ AK>aoh|^eh]h|_e`kuahOK>aoh|^eh]h|h_]he8oeqj]_}*
. 5 / Q J E@ = @  . E  L mdi^dk dj n_ `  h d^mj ] dj gj b ~\

hqh]jklq`ean]i]jpajanh]aop]^ehe`]``aaop]oi]_nk* _k_eajpaajpnah]lnaoeÅj`ar]lkn`ah]enaajamqehe^nek
ikh}_qh]oaoaj_e]haojklk`n~]ok^nareren+ _kjqj]oqop]j_e]kokhq_eÅju h]lnaoeÅj`ar]lkn`ah
]cq]lqn]]h]ieoi]pailan]pqn]+Ikor]hknao`a]sr]*
NYe hgf]k n~]j`aÕ ]Ö )u]hcqjkor]hknaonalnaoajp]perkooaej`e_]j
Bj_qhperko_ann]`koahlE_]i^e]`qn]jpaah_na_eieajpk ajh]Q]^h] 3+/+I]]_pere`]`d~`ne_]`aoqahko]cn~_kh]o
]_kjoa_qaj_e]`ah]ona]__ekjaoiap]^Åhe_]omqa_kjoq* ko_eh]cajan]hiajpaajpna-)6-u.+
iajklnk`q_ajoqop]j_e]o|_e`]ok^|oe_]o+Mknaok)] Bh]cq]`ebqj`a`ao`anacekjao`a]hp]_kj_ajpn]_eÅj`a
hko ia`eko `a _qhperkie_nk^e]jko oa]Ä]`aj _kjbna* ]cq]%^]f]_kj_ajpn]_eÅj`aokhqpko&]nacekjao`aiajkn
_qaj_e] oqop]j_e]o ]iknpecq]`kn]o k p]ilkjao l]n] _kj_ajpn]_eÅj`a]cq]%i]ukn_kj_ajpn]_eÅj`aokhqpko&aj
i]jpajanahlEnah]per]iajpa_kjop]jpa+Q]haop]ilkjao qjlnk_aok`ajkiej]`kgkegkak$nwYk]Pa__eÅj1+3uCecqn]
`alEbqj_ekj]jajqjn]jckaopna_dk`ar]hknaou)lkn 1+/.&+Bh_epklh]oi]`aqj]_}hqh]peajaqj]_kj_ajpn]_eÅj
p]hikperk)oaqo]j`ebanajpaop]ilkjaol]n]i]jpajan `aokhqpkoi]uknmqaahia`ek)lknhkmqaah]cq]peaj`a]
`ebanajpaor]hknao`alE+ ajpn]n`ajpnk`ah]_}hqh]+Bjao]o_kj`e_ekjaooa`e_amqa
M]n]r]hknaolnÅteiko]h]jaqpn]he`]`ahbkob]pklkp|* ateopaqjZYdYf[]\]Y_mYhgkalang*Pejai^]nck)_q]j`kqj]
oe_k%H E ŌM- 1& uah_]n^kj]pk_|h_e_k%@]@-0&oqahajoan _}hqh]aop|ajqjia`ek`a^]f]]_pere`]`d~`ne_])ateopaqj]
p]ilkjao]`a_q]`ko+Bteopajiq_dkokpnkop]ilkjaomqa paj`aj_e]`ah]cq]]o]hen`aahh]+Bopklqa`analnaoajp]nqj
oaailha]jajhkoia`eko`a_na_eieajpkkajahajo]uk`a cn]ralnk^hai]oeh]_}hqh]jkpeajaia`ekol]n]arep]nhk)
ajvei]oatpn]~`ko`aie_nkknc]jeoiko)u ahiafknoeopai] lqaoqj]_}hqh]`aode`n]p]`]jklqa`a_na_an+
l]n]qjknc]jeoiklqa`aoan_kjoe`an]^haiajpa`ebanajpa
B Yd{ ^adg kq  g j_Yfake gk j]dY[agfY\gk
`ah]lnkle]`kl]n]kpnk_]ok+Mknp]jpk)ahi|o]`a_q]`k
l]n]_]`]_]ok`a^a`apaniej]noa`aik`kail~ne_k)]qj* Bjh]j]pqn]hav]hkoaba_pkokoiÅpe_kookjjkp]^hao)lnej*
mqaajajo]ukoajvei|pe_koafnaljg(qj`apaniej]`kp]i* _el]hiajpaaj]i^eajpao_kj]hp]o_kj_ajpn]_ekjao`a
lÅjmqabqj_ekja^eaj_kjahajvei]`aqjknc]jeoik o]h+Bh]cq]`ai]n_kjpeaja]lnktei]`]iajpaqj0"`a
oqahabqj_ekj]n^eajajahajo]uk`ahieoikajvei]`a K]@h]`ai|o`alamqaÄ]o_]jpe`]`ao`akpnkoiejan]hao
kpnkoie_nkknc]jeoiko+ uahaiajpko+Ikoie_nkknc]jeoikoi]nejkopeajajcaja*
n]hiajpaqj]`alaj`aj_e]aola_~be_]`aK]@hu _na_aj`a
ik`k Ålpei k ]h r]hkn `a ]_pere`]` d~`ne_] lnklek `ah
1 ) , 0  G af aj j ] n ak a{ f
]cq]`ai]n%Cecqn]3+/2&+Q]haoie_nkknc]jeoikooahh]*
H\\^d_`uj\g^\gdid_\__`pih `_ djdiagp`i^d\ i]jd]hÅbehko+Bh_na_eieajpk`ahkod]hÅbehkonamqeana]h
ij o\ ]g`h ` io``g^m`^dh d`iojh d^mj]d\ij+= gbpijn iajko]hck`aK]@h)lankh]_kj_ajpn]_eÅjÅlpei]r]n~]
h d^mjjmb\idnh jn^m`^`ih `ejm\kD \ goj j ]\ej)\pilp` _kjahknc]jeoik_kj_napk+>o~)oaqo]jhkop}niejko`Y)
g\h\tjm~\gjc\^`i\kD`iom`Ǿ t Ŕ + AgkD  diom\^`gpg\m dz^adgk\ak[j]lgku `Ydz^adgkeg\]jY\gkl]n]`ao_ne^enaj
_`]``no\mk mÅ sdh j\g\i`pom\gd_\_+ _]`]_]oknamqaneieajpko^]fko% Ö *Ǿ " &uik`an]`ko% Ǿ *
.2"&`aK]@h)naola_per]iajpa%Cecqn]3+/2&+
E  ç?p|g `n` gdi^m`h `ioj`ikmjoji`n_ ` pi\njgp^dÅi
lp`k\n\_ ` kD4\kD0<

E  çMp}nji gjno\h kji`ntk\m\lp}n`pn\i< P\]g\ 3 +/  = ^ odq d_ \ _ _ ` g\bp\ `iq\md\nnpno\i^d\n

;Yj_l_ZWZ
Z[bW]kW
%\ñF GWj[h_Wb ?`[cfbeZ[eh]Wd_ice.
3 +. 3  A a` ^oj n j n h Å od^ j n  n j ] m` 
ÖĞÕÕÕ =bp\kpm\ =WkbeXWYj[h'Mf_h_bbkc
`g ^ m` ^ dh d` i oj  h d^ mj ] d\ i j
-)662 O\ibm`cph\i\ Mjh[fjeYeYkn)?iY^[h_Y^_W
Bh]cq]aoah`eokhrajpa`ah]re`]uh]`eolkje^ehe`]``a]cq]
-)65- =bp\h\mdi\ Ji[kZecedWi'P_Xh_e
aoqjb]_pkneilknp]jpamqa`apaniej]ah_na_eieajpk`ahko
-)62- L\i Ip^cjn]\^dgjnbm\hkjndodqjn
ie_nkknc]jeoiko+I]`eolkje^ehe`]``a]cq]jkokhkaobqj*
_eÅj`ah_kjpaje`kaj]cq]mqaaop|lnaoajpaajqjia`ek) -)6-- F\m\]`_`\m^`) ?j^jnbm\hkjndodqjn^jhj
ao`a_en)`ah]dqia`]`koamqa`]``aqj`apaniej]`kd|* e\hÅi MjWf^obeYeYYki
^ep]p)oejkmqap]i^e}j`alaj`a`ah]_kj_ajpn]_eÅj`aok* -)52- O\g\hd MWYY^WhecoY[i%g`q\_pm\&
hqpko)_kiko]hao)]vÇ_]naoukpn]ooqop]j_e]omqalqa`]j -)5-- L\no`g_`ampo\n) MWYY^WhecoY[ihekn__%cjibj&
aop]nlnaoajpaoajah]cq]+I]ooqop]j_e]o`eoqahp]opeajaj h`mh`g\_\
qj]_eanp]]beje`]`lknah]cq]mqad]_amqaah]cq]]ok* -)42- H\bjnn\gdijn) BWbeXWYj[hukc'BWbeYeYYki
_e]`]]hkookhqpkojkaop}`eolkje^hal]n]hkoknc]jeoiko+ k`n^\_jn\g\_j
-)4-- ?`m`\g`n)^\m\h`gjn) R[hecoY[iX_ifehkitjomjn
; [ lan a\ Y \  `y\ja[Y q gkegkak ampojnn`^jn cjibjns`mÅadgjn
Bjp}niejkob~oe_ko)h]`eolkje^ehe`]``ah]cq]oaatlnao]
Ae`hkgjn
_kikh]]_pere`]``a]cq])]^nare]`]iajpa]s)mqaaoah
? \ k ~op gj Å  E  ? m` ^ dh d` i oj h d^mj ] d\ i j  .50

p]i^e}j`ao`aahlqjpk`areop]]lhe_]`kajh]ej`qopne]
]heiajp]ne])`kj`aokhqpko_kikh]o]huh]o]_]nko]oa
ailha]jbna_qajpaiajpa_kik_kjoanr]jpaol]n]ejde^en
ah_na_eieajpkie_nk^e]jk+
Ikoknc]jeoiko_]l]_ao`a_na_anaj]i^eajpaoiqu
o]hejkooahh]i]jd]hÅbehkoatpnaiko%Cecqn]3+/2&+Bo*
pkoie_nkknc]jeoikonamqeanaj.2*0-"`aK]@hl]n]oq
_na_eieajpkÅlpeik)oacÇjh]oaola_eao+Ikoknc]jeoiko
_]l]_ao`a_na_anaj]i^eajpao_kj]hp]_kj_ajpn]_eÅj`a
]vÇ_]naooa`ajkiej]jkoiÅbehko)u ]mqahhko_]l]_ao`a
_na_anaj]i^eajpaoiquoa_ko%lknh]b]hp]`a]cq]i|o
^eajmqalknlnaoaj_e]`aokhqpko&oahh]i]jtanÅbehko+
I]Q]^h]3+/na_kcaafailhko`aaopkoknc]jeoiko+

M gdmlgk[g e h YlaZ d]k


@q]j`kqjknc]jeoik_na_aajqjia`ek_kj^]f]]_pere*
`]`d~`ne_]oÅhklqa`ak^pajan]cq]`ah]i^eajpaej_na*
iajp]j`k oq _kj_ajpn]_eÅj ejpanj] `a okhqpko+ Q]h
B db p m\ 3 +/ 2  Aa`^oj_ ` g\^ji^`iom\^dÅi_`^gjmpmjnÅ_d^j ej_naiajpklqa`ahhar]noa]_]^k]l]npen`ahia`ek]i*
nj]m``g ^m`^dh d`ioj_`h d^mjjmb\idnhjn^ji_da`m`io`n ^eajpa]qiajp]j`kah^ki^ak`aekjaoejknc|je_kod]_e]
ojg`m\i^d\njm`lp`mdh d`iojnn\gdijn+H\^ji^`iom\^dÅiÅkodh\ `ajpnk`ah]_}hqh])k^eajoejpapev]j`kk_kj_ajpn]j`k
_`J\?gk\m\hd^mjjmb\idnhjnh\mdijn^jhjP)\_iY^[h_`n_`g qjokhqpkknc|je_k+Pa_kjk_ajknc]jeoikomqaailha]j
0"8k\m\gjnc\gÅadgjn`som`hjn`no|`iom`.2*0-"_`k`i_d`i_j qjkqkpnk`aaopkoia_]jeoikou h]P\]g\ 3 +0  lnaoajp]
_`gjmb\idnhj+ ]hcqjkoafailhko+
Bhokhqpkqpehev]`kajahejpanekn_ahqh]nl]n]]fqop]nh]
I]i]ukn~]`ahkoie_nkknc]jeoikookjej_]l]_ao`a ]_pere`]`d~`ne_]`ah_epklh]oi]jk`a^aejde^enhkolnk*
lnkolan]naj]i^eajpao_kjiqu^]f]]_pere`]`d~`ne_]u _aoko^ekmq~ie_ko_ahqh]nao+Q]hao_kilqaopkooahh]i]j
iqanaj)koa`aode`n]p]jul]o]j]qjaop]`k`ah]paj_e]) okhqpko _kil]pe^hao+ Bjhkoie_nkknc]jeoikoateopaj
ajp]hao_en_qjop]j_e]o+Ikoknc]jeoikod]hkpkhan]jpao `ebanajpao okhqpko _kil]pe^hao+ Qk`]o aop]o oqop]j_e]o
lqa`ajoklknp]n]hcqj]na`q__eÅjajahr]hkn]s`ahia* okjiquokhq^haoaj]cq]u oapn]p]`a]vÇ_]naok`a]h*
`ek)lankcajan]hiajpa_na_ajiafknaj]qoaj_e]`aok* _kdkhao`aner]`ko`a]vÇ_]nao)`akpnkpelk`a]h_kdkhao)
hqpko]Ä]`e`ko%Cecqn] 3 +/ 2 &+ Mknah_kjpn]nek) ]hcqjko `a]iejk|_e`kok`aoqo`aner]`ko%Q]^h]3+0u  B db p m\ 
knc]jeoikooa`ao]nnkhh]j]iqu^]f]]_pere`]`d~`ne_]) 3+/3&+Bjah_]ok\]<j[`Y]Yd]hÅbeh]oatpnai]o)_kikCY)
u }opkookj`acn]jejpan}ojkokhk`ao`aahlqjpk`areop] dgZY[l]jameuqj]o_q]jp]o=Y[l]jaY`ahieoikpelk)ahok*
`aoq]`]lp]_eÅj]h]re`] aj`e_d]o _kj`e_ekjaooejk hqpk_kil]pe^haaoH ($nwYk]Pa__eÅj.4+0&+

P\]g\ 3 +0  O j gpoj n^ j h k \ od] g` n _ ` h d^mjjmb\idnh jn

Ih]Wd_ice Jh_dY_fWb[iiebkjeiWYkckbWZei \rcud_cWfWhWYh[Y_c_[dje


<WYj[h_W'ijajoÅomja\n Cgd^di\]`o\~i\)kmjgdi\%kmdi^dk\gh`io` -)64*-)6-
bm\hkjndodq\n&)bgpo\h\oj%kmdi^dk\gh`io`
bm\hi`b\odq\n&
?d\ij]\^o`md\n_`\bp\_pg^` O\^\mjn\)om`c\gjn\ -)65
?d\ij]\^o`md\nh\mdi\n \*bgp^jndgbgd^`mjg -)6/
I\idojg)q\mdjnbgd^Ånd_jn)kmjgdi\)kmjkdji\oj -)6/
= $0ì â â _`_dh`odgnpgajidj
?d\ij]\^o`md\n_`g\bjnn\gdijn Cgd^di\]`o\~i\ -)6-*-)42
>\^o`md\nc\gÅadg\najoÅomja\n\ijsdb}id^\n%`nk`^d`n_` Cgd^di\]`o\~i\)`^oj~i\)om`c\gjn\ -)6-*-)42
?Yjej^_eh^eZeif_hW*BWbeh^eZeif_hWtL^eZel_Xh_eif[Y_[i$
;hY^W[Wc\gÅadg\n`som`h\n%kjm`e`hkgj)BWbeXWYj[h_kc$ G?E -)42
t\gbpi\n<WYj[h_W%kjm`e`hkgj)D\gj\i\`mj]dph&
>kdWb_[bbW%\gb\q`m_`c\gÅadg\& Cgd^`mjg -)42
H`q\_pm\ns`mÅadg\n Cgd^`mjg -)50*-)3/
Djibjnadg\h`iojnjns`mÅadgjn Cgd^`mjg -)4/*-3.
. 5 1 Q J E@ = @  . E  L mdi^dk dj n_ `  h d^mj ] dj gj b ~\

?D) ?D) aoqj`aner]`k`ah]iejk|_e`kche_ej]ajahmqahko|pkiko


dXm ís c ) `ade`nÅcajk`ahcnqlk]iejkoad]joqopepqe`klknpnao
B.= ( J(*? D )*? K K *
) D<L cnqlkoiapehk+Bopk`af]qj]_]nc]lkoeper]lani]jajpaaj
^ c Ŏ c0^  Z J Z  ?KK*
Cgd^di\]`o\~i\ A^oj~i\
ah|pkik`ajepnÅcajk)mqa]qiajp]h]okhq^ehe`]``ah]
oqop]j_e]%Cecqn]3+/3&+ I]che_ej]^ap]~j]aop|]ilhe]*
?DŎ K iajpa`eopne^qe`]_kikokhqpk_kil]pe^ha)aola_e]hiajpa
cŎ^ * n * ^ c Ō^ c Ō^ * j * ajpna^]_pane]od]hÅbeh]ou _e]jk^]_pane]o%Q]^h]3+0&+
Lmjkdji\oj_`_dh`odgnpgajid^j >hcqj]o^]_pane]od]hÅbeh]oatpnai]olnk`q_ajkpnk
MgdmlgklahgYe afgw[a\gq j]dY[agfY\gk okhqpk_kil]pe^hahh]i]`ka_pk~j]%Cecqn]3+/3&mqaao
qj`aner]`k_~_he_k`ah]ol]np]pk+I]o]hc]oi]nej]olnk*
`q_aj_kikokhqpko_kil]pe^haoqj]cn]jr]nea`]``a
che_Åoe`ko u `eiapehoqhbkjeklnklekj]pk %Cecqn] 3+/1&)

=
fV)}B *  +
DK
R ,X lank_kjn]n]o at_al_ekjao oÅhkhko ]_qiqh]j aj^]f]
_]jpe`]`lknmqajkoqahajoaniqud]hÅbeh]o+I]ohar]`q*
n]otanÅbeh]ouh]o]hc]oran`aod]hÅbeh]olnk`q_ajlnej_e*
l]hiajpache_ankh_kikokhqpk_kil]pe^ha+
KD KD
O\^\mjn\
1 ) , 1  G a f aj j ] n ak a{ f
?D/KD

,RgbE FYY [lana\Y\\ ] Y_mY\ ] mf` vZalYlea[jgZaYfg]klv


[gfljgdY\Yh g jdY[gf[]fljY[azf\ ] kgdm lg\akm]dlg]f]d
I e ]\ag)JYjYkgZj]nanaj]fe ]\ agk[gfYdlY[gf[]fljY[azf
\]kgdmlgk'dg kgj_Yfake gkhjg\m[]fg Y[memdYfkgdmlgk
Pm`c\gjn\ [ g e hY laZd]kim ]eYfla]f]fYdY[wdm dY]fmfZYdYf[]\]
Mgdmlgklahg[YjZg`a\jYlg Y_mYhgkalang); d_ m f g ke a[jggj_Yfake gkkgf[YhY[]k\]
[j][]je ]bgj[gfY [lana\Y\\]Y_mYj]\m[a\Y']af[dmkg
Yd_mfgkj]ima]j]f]d]nY\ gkfan]d]kkYdafgkhYjY[j][]j)
?D/KD
C Ö= m v d]k]dnYdgjYo\ ]dY_mYhmjY:
D K *?*D
C ÖK m w]kmfkgdm lg[g e hY laZd]q hYjYim wk]f][]kalY:
D K *?*D
?D/KD D *? *K D C Ö=mvd]k]dkgdm lg[g e hY laZd]]f]kh][a]k\]
BWbeXWYj[h_kc <
?DKgg D *? *K D
?DŌ-D ?D/KD
Cgd^`mjg I\idojg
MgdmlgklahgYd[g`gd K s ~b ` i j t ^ m` ^ dh d` i oj 
h d^ mj ] d\ i j
B db p m\ 3 +/ 3  Anomp^opm\_`\gbpijnnjgpojn^jh k\od]g`n
njgp]g`nlp`njiam`^p`io`n`ihd^mjjmb\idnhjn+H\n @kikhko]jei]haopeajajja_aoe`]`]^okhqp]`akt~cajk
`nomp^opm\n_`g bgpo\h\ojt kmjgdi\)lp`njio\h]d}iam`^p`io`n) ikha_qh]n% Õ /&)naoqhp]b|_ehoqlkjanmqapk`]oh]obkni]o
n`hjnom\mji`ig\Bdbpm\0+./+Agijh]m`ajmh\g_`g\`^oj~i\`n `are`]p]i^e}jnamqeanaj- /+ Pejai^]nck)aopkjkao
.)1)2)3*o`om\cd_mj*/*h`odg*1*kdméhd_di\^\m]jsdg\oj+ _eanpk8iq_dkoie_nkknc]jeoikolqa`aj%u]hcqjko`a*
^aj&rerenaj]qoaj_e]pkp]h`aÕ /+
I]_kj_ajpn]_eÅjejpn]_ahqh]n`ahkookhqpko_kil]pe* Bhkt~cajkao`}^ehiajpaokhq^haaj]cq]ulqa`a`ao*
^hao`alaj`a`ahjerah`ahkookhqpkoatpanjko)u l]n]_]`] ]l]na_ann|le`]iajpa`a^e`k]h]o]_pere`]`aonaolen]pk*
knc]jeoikh]_]jpe`]`i|tei] mqalqa`aoejpapev]nk ne]o`ahkoie_nkknc]jeoikoajhkod|^ep]po]_q|pe_kou
]_qiqh]naoqj]_]n]_pan~ope_]caj}pe_]+Bopkknecej]mqa dÇia`ko+Mknaok)ateopajajjqaopnklh]jap]]^qj`]jpao
`ebanajpaoknc]jeoikolqa`]jpkhan]n`ebanajpaon]jcko d|^ep]poie_nk^e]jko]jÅte_ko)_kikb]jckoukpnkooa*
`a]_pere`]``a]cq]%Q]^h]o3+/u3+0&+Bj_kjoa_qaj_e]) `eiajpko)l]jp]jkou_e}j]c]o)oqahkobknaop]haoejqj`]*
hkoie_nkknc]jeoikojkd]hkpkhan]jpao)hkod]hkpkhan]j* `ko)pn]_pkejpaopej]h`ahko]jei]hao)ranpe`ko`a]cq]o
pao)hkod]hÅbehkou hkod]hÅbehkoatpnaikooa`abejajaj jacn]o)vkj]olnkbqj`]o`ah]oq^_knpav]pannaopnaukpnko
cn]jia`e`]lknoq`eopejp]_]l]_e`]`caj}pe_]l]n]oej* iq_dko]i^eajpao+Bjaopkod|^ep]po]jÅte_kolnkheban]j
papev]nk]_qiqh]nokhqpko_kil]pe^hao+ ie_nkknc]jeoiko)l]npe_qh]niajpalnk_]nekp]o+
Iko_k_kocn]ilkoeperko`ahc}jankNlYh`qdg[g[[mkokj
jkp]^haiajpad]hkpkhan]jpao%`ada_dk)qjlnk_a`eieajpk Nah g k \ ]  e a[jg g j_ Yf ake g k [gf j]dY[a{f
jkni]hl]n]]eoh]nhkooa^]o]ajqo]nia`ekomqa_kjpea* Yd g py_ ]f g
jaj4)2*.-"`aK]@F&)uaopkoknc]jeoikoqo]jah]iejk* Ikoie_nkknc]jeoikookjiqur]ne]`koaj_q]jpk]h]
|_e`klnkhej]_kikokhqpk_kil]pe^ha+I]che_ej]^ap]~j] ja_aoe`]`kpkhan]j_e]`ahkt~cajk+@kikoaoaÄ]h]ajh]
? \ k ~op gj Å  E  ? m` ^ dh d` i oj h d^mj ] d\ i j  .52

Q]^h] 3+1) oa lqa`aj `ere`en aj r]neko cnqlko `alaj* pkc}je_]o)]o~_kikiq_d]o`ah]o^]_pane]oejpaopej]hao
`eaj`k`ahaba_pk`ahkt~cajk+Iko]ank^ekookjaola_eao u`ah]_]re`]`kn]h+ K kk^op]jpa)ajpnahko]j]ank^eko
_]l]_ao `a_na_an]pajoekjaojkni]hao `akt~cajk %ah k^hec]`koh]oajoe^ehe`]`]hkt~cajkr]n~]]ilhe]iajpa)
Ō Ö "`ah]enaaoÕ /& u naolen]jkt~cajkajoqiap]^kheoik+ lqao]hcqjkoknc]jeoikookj_]l]_ao`apkhan]npn]v]o`a
Jq_dko]ank^ekolqa`ajej_hqokpkhan]n_kj_ajpn]_ekjao kt~cajkieajpn]omqakpnkojkhkd]_aj+
i|oahar]`]o`akt~cajk%kt~cajkdelan^|ne_k&+Ikoie*
_nk]anÅbehko)lknah_kjpn]nek)okj]ank^ekomqalqa`aj Nx[fa[Yk\ ]  [m dlang  h YjY  Y]jg Z ag kq YfY]jgZagk
qo]nahÕ ŌoÅhk_q]j`kaop|lnaoajpa]jerahaoi]o^]fko M]n]ah_na_eieajpk`aiq_dkoie_nkknc]jeoiko]ank*
mqaajah]ena%_kj`e_ekjaoie_nkÅte_]o&)jkni]hiajpa] ^ekoaoja_ao]nekoqiejeopn]nqj]ejpajo]]ena]_eÅj+Bopk
_]qo]`aoqheiep]`]_]l]_e`]`l]n]naolen]nklknmqa oa`a^a]mqaahÕ Ōaolk_kokhq^haaj]cq]u ahÕ Ōqo]`k
_kjpeajaj]hcqj]ikh}_qh]oajoe^ha]hkt~cajk_kikaj* lknhkoknc]jeoiko`qn]jpaah_na_eieajpkjkoanaai*
vei]omqaokjh|^ehaoajoqlnaoaj_e]+Jq_dko]ank^eko lh]v]hkoqbe_eajpaiajpan|le`klkn`ebqoeÅj]l]npen`ah
okjb]_qhp]perko)hkmqaoecjebe_]mqa^]fkh]o]lnkle]`]o ]ena+Bo`aoa]^halknp]jpkh]]ena]_eÅjbknv]`]`ahko_qh*
_kj`e_ekjaojqpneper]ou `a_qhperklqa`aj_na_anp]jpkaj perko)^eajoa]lkn]cep]_eÅj`ahkoi]pn]_aokpq^koaj
_kj`e_ekjaoÅte_]o_kik]jÅte_]o+ qj]^]j`af]`a]cep]_eÅjk^eajia`e]jpa^qn^qfak`a
>hcqjkoie_nkknc]jeoikojklqa`ajnaolen]n- Ō8p]* ]enaaopanehev]`k]pn]r}o`ahia`ekia`e]jpaqjpq^kbejk
haoknc]jeoikooahh]i]j]j]ank^eko+Bteopaj`ko_h]oao `are`nekkqj`eo_klknkok+Kkni]hiajpahko]ank^eko
`a]j]ank^eko7hko]j]ank^eko]ankpkhan]jpao)mqalqa* _na_ajiafkn_kj]ena]_eÅjbknv]`]mqa_q]j`koaoqie*
`ajpkhan]nahkt~cajku _na_anajoqlnaoaj_e]]qjmqajk jeopn]ahÕ Ōlknoeilha`ebqoeÅj+
lqa`ajqo]nhk)uhko]j]ank^eko k^hec]`kokaopne_pko Bjah_]ok`ahko_qhperko`a]j]ank^ekoahlnk^hai]
mqaokjejde^e`kokej_hqokiqanajajlnaoaj_e]`akt~* aoat_hqenahkt~cajk)jkoqiejeopn]nhk+Iko]j]ank^eko
cajk%Q]^h]3+1&+I]n]vÅjlknh]mqahko]j]ank^ekok^he* k^hec]`kor]n~]jaj_q]jpk]oqoajoe^ehe`]`]hkt~cajk)
c]`koiqanajajlnaoaj_e]`akt~cajkao`ao_kjk_e`]) u ateopaj`eranokolnk_a`eieajpkol]n]na`q_enah_kjpa*
lanklqa`a`a^anoa]mqaokjej_]l]_ao`aaheiej]n]h* je`k aj- Ō`ahko_qhperko+ >hcqj]o p}_je_]ookjiqu
cqjkolnk`q_pkopÅte_komqaoaknecej]jajahiap]^k* oeilhaou]`a_q]`]ol]n]hkoknc]jeoikoiajkooajoe*
heoik`ahkt~cajk%Pa__eÅj3+.5&+ ^hao)lankkpn]ookji|o_kilhaf]ou ja_ao]ne]ol]n]ah
Mknhkmqaoao]^a)h]]j]ank^ekoeok^hec]`]k_qnnaok* _na_eieajpk`ahko]j]ank^ekoaopne_pko+M]n]hkoknc]*
h]iajpaajpnao_h]oao`aie_nkknc]jeoiko7qj]]ilhe] jeoikomqajkokj`ai]oe]`koajoe^hao]lamqaÄ]o_]j*
r]nea`]` `a lnk_]nekp]o) qjko _q]jpko dkjcko u qjko pe`]`ao `a kt~cajk) oa k^peajaj _kj`e_ekjao]jÅte_]o
_q]jpkolnkpkvkko+Aajpnk`a=Y[l]jaY(qjk`ahkocnqlko ]`a_q]`]ohhaj]j`kh]o^kpahh]okpq^ko_kjia`ek`a
iafkn_kjk_e`ko`a]j]ank^eko k^hec]`koaoahc}jank _qhperk_kilhap]iajpad]op]]nne^]u _ann]j`k_kjp]*
>dgklja\ame(bkni]`klkn^]_ehkocn]ilkoeperkomqabkn* lkjaodani}pe_ko)+Q]i^e}jaolkoe^ha]Ä]`enqj_ki*
i]jaj`kolkn]o+Iko_hkopne`ekookjiqubna_qajpaoajah lqaopk mq~ie_k mqa oa] qj Y_]fl] j]\m[lgj _]l]v `a
oqahk)ajoa`eiajpkoh]_qopnaou ajahpn]_pkejpaopej]h)u na]__ekj]n_kjahkt~cajku na`q_enhk]E Ō -+ Rj^qaj
]iajq`kokjhkonaolkjo]^hao`ah`apaneknk`a]heiaj* afailhkaoahpekche_kh]pk)mqaoa]Ä]`a]qjia`ek`a*
pkoajh]p]`ko+Lpnko]j]ank^ekok^hec]`kookjhkoie_nk* jkiej]`k _]h`k `apekche_kh]pk) mqa ao jkni]hiajpa
knc]jeoikoiap]jkc}je_koukpn]oiq_d]oaola_eao`a qo]`kl]n]ajo]u]nhkonamqaneieajpko`aÕ Ō`aqjkn*
<j[`Y]Y(h]o^]_pane]ooqhb]pkna`q_pkn]ouh]odkik]_a* c]jeoik#@a_mjY1)-2$)

P\]g\ 3 +1  N`g\^dji`nh d^mj ]d\i \n^ji`gj s~b` ij

Ahkfe L[bWY_wdYed[ b+ Ç N_feZ[c[jWXeb_ice ?`[cfbe% BsX_jWjX


=`mj]djn
K]gdb\_jn J`^`n\mdj N`nkdm\^dÅi\`mj]d\ G_YheYeYYkibkj[ki%>& Ld`g)kjgqj
B\^pgo\odqjn Jji`^`n\mdj)k`mj^m`^`i N`nkdm\^dÅi\`mj]d\) ?iY^[h_Y^_WYeb_%>& Eio`nodijbmp`nj
h`ejm^jiKŌ \i\`mj]d\)a`mh`io\^dÅi _`h\h~a`mjn
Id^mj\`mÅadgjn J`^`n\mdjk`mj\]\e\no`indji`n N`nkdm\^dÅi\`mj]d\ Mf_h_bbkclebkjWdi%>& H\bjn
=i\`mj]djn
=`mjojg`m\io`n Jji`^`n\mdj)ij^m`^`ih`ejm^jiKŌ B`mh`io\^dÅi Mjh[fjeYeYYki Pm\^ojm`nkdm\ojmdj
foe][d[i%>& npk`mdjm
K]gdb\_jn @\ÄdijÕg`o\g B`mh`io\^dÅiÕ G[j^WdeXWYj[h_kc%=& @db`nojm`n_`\bp\n
m`nkdm\^dÅi\i\`mj]d\ \ehc_Y_Ykc i`bm\n)n`_dh`iojn
g\^pnom`n\iÅsd^jn
. 5 3 Q J E@ = @  . E  L mdi^dk dj n_ `  h d^mj ] dj gj b ~\

M]n]aheiej]n_kilhap]iajpa`ah_qhperk`a]j]ank^eko
pk`]pn]v]`aÕ Ōlqa`a_khk_]noaqjc]omqana]__ekja_kj
ahÕ Ōajqj]f]nn]mqa]oqrav_kjpajc]hkopq^koklh]_]o+
Bh`eolkoeperki|ooaj_ehhkaoh]f]nn]]jÅte_]`a]j]ank*
^eko)qj_kjpaja`kn_kjqj]p]l]`an]mqalqa`aoahh]noa
u`ajpnk`ah_q]hoa_khk_]jhkopq^koklh]_]omqaoar]j
]ej_q^]n%B db p m\  3+/5]&+Bh]ena`ahna_eleajpaoanaai*
lh]v]hqacklknqj]iav_h]`aE Ōu@- Ōu)ajlnaoaj_e]`a
l]h]`ek_kik_]p]hev]`kn)h]opn]v]o`aÕ Ōmqalq`ean]j
mqa`]n aj ah _kjpaja`kn oa _kjoqiaj bkni]j`k ]cq]
%E Ō(- Ōè;E Ō- &uoaaop]^ha_aj]o~_kj`e_ekjao]jÅte_]o+
M]n]ah_qhperk`a]j]ank^ekoaopne_pkojkoÅhkaoja_a*
o]nekaheiej]npk`]oh]opn]v]o`aÕ Ōoejk]`ai|ona]hev]n
pk`]oh]oi]jelqh]_ekjao`ah _qhperkajqj]]piÅoban]
]jÅte_])u]mqaaopkoie_nkknc]jeoikolqa`ajiknenlkn
qj]^naraatlkoe_eÅj]h- /+ Bjaopko_]oko)ahia`ek`a
_qhperkoadeanralneiankl]n]he^an]nahkt~cajku hqack
oa]Ä]`aqj]cajpana`q_pkn_kikE/Pu oaoahh]h]iqao*
pn]ajqj]]piÅoban]`ac]ohe^na`akt~cajk+Qk`]oh]o
#W$ #X$ #Y$ #Z$ #[$
i]jelqh]_ekjaod]umqana]hev]nh]o^]fkqj]_knneajpac]*
B db p m\ 3 +/ 4  ?m`^dhd`iojt ^ji^`iom\^dÅi_ ` js~b`ij+ oako]`ade`nÅcajkkjepnÅcajk)he^nao`aÕ /)mqaoa`eneca
$Y)]%=j][ae a]flg\]Y]jgZagk'YfY]jgZagk'^Y[mdlYlangk' ]hna_eleajpa`a_qhperk_]`]ravmqaoa]^na)arep]j`k]o~
ea[jgY]jz^adgkqYfY]jgZagkY]jglgd]jYfl]k'j]n]dY\ghgjdY mqaah- Ōlqa`]ajpn]n+M]n]hhar]n]_]^kejraopec]_ekjao
hgka[azf\]ea[jg[gdgfaYk#j]hj]k]flY\Yk[geghmflgkf]_jgk$ _kj]j]ank^ekoaopne_pkoaoja_ao]nek`eolkjan`a[veYjYk
]flmZgk[gf[Yd\g\]lag_da[gdYlg)M]YyY\]Ydgk[mdlangkmfY
Yfzpa[Ykmqaokj`eolkoeperkoaola_e]hao`eoaÄ]`ko_kj
h]im]yY[Yfla\Y\\]Y_YjhYjY]nalYjh]jlmjZY[agf]k]f]d
cq]jpaoej_knlkn]`komqalaniepajpn]^]f]n`ao`abqan]
e]\agdxima\gqmf[gdgjYfl]j]\gp[ge gaf\a[Y\gj'j]kYrmjafY'
_kj_qhperko]^eanpkoaj]piÅoban]opkp]hiajpa]jÅte_]o
im]gpa\Y\g]kjgkYqj]\m[a\gfgem]kljY[gdgj' $Y%?dgpx_]fg
h]f]ljYkgdgmfY[gjlY\aklYf[aY]f]dlmZg'\]eg\gim]dgk %Cecqn]1)-3Z %*
Y]jgZagkgZda_Y\gk[j][]fkzdg]fdYkmh]j^a[a]' $Z%Fgk
YfY]jgZagk'[ge gkgfk]fkaZd]kYdgpx_]fg'[j][]fkzdgd]bgk\] 1 ) , 2  G af aj j ] n ak a{ f
dYkmh]j^a[a]'^]$FgkY]jgZagk^Y[mdlYlangkkgf[YhY[]k\][j][]j
lYflg]fhj]k]f[aY[geg]fYmk]f[aY\]gpx_ ]fgq[j][]fhgj FgkY]jgZ agkf][]kalYfg px_ ]fghYjYnanaj'e a]fljYkim]
lg\g]dlmZg)Maf]eZYj_g']d[j][aea]flg]ke]bgj[]j[Y\]dY dgkYfY]jgZagkfg'] af [dmkghm]\]fe gjaj]fkm
kmh]j^a[a]hgjim]]klgkgj_Yfakegkhm]\]fj]khajYj'$\%Fgk hj]k]f[aY) Fgkgj_Yfake gk^Y[mdlYlangkhm ]\]f nanaj[gf
ea[jgY]jz^adgk[j][]fYhYjlvf\gk]\]dYrgfYevkzpa[Y) $]%Fgk
+ kafgpx_ ]fg)M]j]ima]j]flw[fa[Yk]kh][aYd]khYjYim]
YfY]jgZagkY]jglgd]jYfl]k[j][]fhgjlg\g]dlmZg)?d
[j]r[YfYdg ke a[jggj_Yfake gkY]jgZ agkqYfY]jgZag k)
[j][aea]flgfg]ke]bgj[]j[Y\]dYkmh]j^a[a]hgjim]]klgk
gj_YfakegkkgdYe]fl]hm]\]f^]je]flYj) , Ö K m w ]kmfY]jgZ ag^Y[mdlYlang:

C  Ö = z e g ^mf[agfYmfY_]f l]j]\m[lgj:Jgf_Ymf
Bh_]h`k`apekche_kh]pkaoqjia`ek_kilhafkmqa_kj* ] b]e hdg\ ] Y_]f l]j]\m[lgj)
peajalamqaÄ]o_]jpe`]`ao`a]c]n)hkmqad]_amqaahia*
`ekoa]reo_kok)]qjmqapk`]r~]bhqe`k+Aaolq}o`amqaah
pekche_kh]pkna]__ekj]_kjahkt~cajk]hkh]nck`ahpq^k)ah
kt~cajk]pikob}ne_koÅhklqa`alajapn]nlknh]l]npaoq* 3 +. 5  B jmh \noÅ s d^ \ n  _ ` g j s ~b ` i j
lanekn`kj`aahia`ek_kjp]_p]_kjah]ena+Iko]ank^eko
k^hec]`ko_na_an|joÅhkajh]l]npaoqlanekn`ahpq^k+Iko Bhkt~cajkaoqjlk`ankokkte`]jpau ahiafkn]_alpkn`a
knc]jeoikob]_qhp]perko_na_an|jlknpk`kahpq^k)lank aha_pnkjaoajh]naolen]_eÅj+Mankp]i^e}jlqa`aoanqj
_kjlnabanaj_e]ajh]l]npaoqlanekn+Ikoie_nkanÅbehkohk rajajkl]n]hko]j]ank^ekok^hec]`ko+Bhkt~cajklkno~
d]n|j_an_]`ahatpnaikoqlanekn)lankjkfqopkajh]lnk* ieoikjkaohap]h)lankbkni]`aner]`kopÅte_komqalqa*
teie`]` `ah] ejpanb]oaajpna ah ia`ekuah ]ena+ Cej]h* `aj`]Ä]n]h]o_}hqh]o+
iajpa)hko]j]ank^eko_na_an|joÅhk_an_]`ahbkj`k`ah
pq^k)`kj`aahkt~cajkjklqa`alajapn]n+ Bobna_qajpa K m ye a[Y \ ]d g py_ ]f g
]Ä]`en]hia`ekqj_khkn]jpana`ktej`e_]`kn_kikh]j]) Bhkt~cajkaooqaop]`k^]o]hjkni]hoahh]i]pnelhapa`a
kYrmjafYmqa`ebanaj_e]h]onacekjaoÅte_]o`ah]o]jÅte_]o8 kt~cajk% Ŏ - /&+Pejai^]nck)okjlkoe^haokpn]o_kjbencq*
ah_khkn]jpaaonko]`k_q]j`kaop|kte`]`ku oej_khknaj n]_ekjaoaha_pnÅje_]o)u h]i]ukn~]okjpÅte_]ol]n]h]o
aop]`kna`q_e`k)`aik`kmqaoaÄ]h]reoq]hiajpaahcn]`k _}hqh]o+Rj]bkni]pÅte_]eilknp]jpa`ahkt~cajkaoah`a*
`alajapn]_eÅj`ahkt~cajkajahia`ek%Cecqn]1)-2$) jkiej]`koejchapa`akt~cajk% Ö Õ /&)mqanalnaoajp]qj]
? \ k ~op gj Å  E  ? m` ^ dh d` i oj h d^mj ] d\ i j  .54

#Y$ #Z$

B db p m\ 3 +/ 5  Ei^p]\^dÅi`i^ji_d^dji`n\iÅsd^\n+#W$F\mm\\iÅsd^\+Qi\m`\^^dÅilp~hd^\kmj_p^d_\kjm`gnj]m`di^gpd_j`i`g
dio`mdjm_`g\e\mm\b`i`m\DŌ(? -/+AgDŌm`\^^dji\^ji`g- Ōk\m\ajmh\mDŌ- Ōnj]m`g\npk`mad^d`_`pi^\o\gdu\_jm_`k\g\_dj
km`n`io``ig\e\mm\+H\\ohÅna`m\adi\g^jiod`i`J/)DŌt? - /*
#X$?|h\m\\iÅsd^\^jibp\io`nk\m\h \idkpg\m`di^p]\m^pgodqjn]\ej^ji_d^dji`n\i\`mj]d\n+H\^jhkp`mo\_`g\_`m`^c\)lp`kp`_`
q\^d\mn`tgg`i\mn`^jib\ngd]m`_`Õ /)k`mhdo`diomj_p^dmj`som\`mh\o`md\g`n_`g\^|h\m\^jibp\io`n+

bkni]iq_dki|oajanc}pe_])ajh]mqah]_]l]aha_pnÅ* i]opn]joepkne]omqaoaaheiej]jn|le`]iajpaajkpn]ona*
je_]atpanj]mqank`a]]hjÇ_hakaoiquna]_per]u ao_]* ]__ekjao+J|o]`ah]jparanaikomqah]o_}hqh]o`ahoeo*
l]v`ahhar]n]_]^kaolkjp|ja]iajpaqj]cn]jr]nea`]` pai]ejiqjalqa`ajlnk`q_enr]ne]oaola_eaopÅte_]o`a
`akte`]_ekjaoej`aoa]^haol]n]h]_}hqh]+Bhoejchapa`a kt~cajkuqpehev]nh]ol]n]i]p]n]hkoejr]oknaoie_nk*
kt~cajkoalnk`q_ap]jpkbkpkmq~ie_]iajpa_kik^ek* ^e]jko#ltWi[ Pa__eÅj/6+4&+
mq~ie_]iajpa)ajaopaÇhpeik_]ok]pn]r}o`ah]]__eÅj
`ar]nekoajvei]ohh]i]`kolankte`]o]o+Ikoknc]jeoiko M m h ]j{ p a\ g  \ake mlYkY q  g ljYk  ]frae Yk
mqabna_qajpaiajpaoaaj_qajpn]j_kjoejchapao`akt~* i m ] \ ]kljm q]f ^g je Yk l{ pa[Yk \ ]  g py_ ]f g
cajk)_kikh]o^]_pane]o`ah]enauhkoie_nkknc]jeoiko @kjp]jp]obkni]opÅte_]o`aner]`]o`ahkt~cajk)jkna*
bkpÅpnkbko)]iajq`k_kjpeajajleciajpkohh]i]`koYW( oqhp]oknlnaj`ajpamqahkoknc]jeoikod]u]j`ao]nnkhh]`k
hej[ de _Z[ i _qu]bqj_eÅjao_kjranpenhkooejchapao`akt~* ajvei]ol]n]`aopnqenaopko_kilqaopko% B db p m\ 3 +0 - &+ Bh
cajkajbkni]ojkpÅte_]o+ oqlanÅte`kuahlanÅte`k`ade`nÅcajkokjh]obkni]opÅ*
te_]oi|obna_qajpao)`aik`kmqah]oajvei]omqa`ao*
M m h ]j{ p a\ g q g ljYk^g je Yk  l{ pa[Yk \ ]d g py_ ]f g pnquajaopko_kilqaopkopeajajqj]]ilhe]`eopne^q_eÅj+
>`ai|o`ahoejchapa)ateopajkpn]obkni]o]hp]iajpapÅte* I]ajvei]Y W jW bW i W  ]p]_]]hlanÅte`k`ade`nÅcajkbkn*
_]o`ahkt~cajk)_kikokjahW d _w d i kf [hw n _Z e % Õ /í&)ahf[( i]j`kkt~cajku]cq]8oq]_pere`]`oaaomqai]pev]ajh]
hw n _Z e  Z[^ _Z hw ] [ d e  %E Ō- /& uah hW Z _Y W b^ _Z he n _be  %LE'&) Cecqn]3+0-]uajh]B db p m\ 3 +0 . +Lpn]ajvei]mqa`aopnqua
_]`]qjk`ahko_q]haooalnk`q_a_kikqjlnk`q_pkh]pa* ahlanÅte`k`ade`nÅcajkaoh]f [ hen_ZW iW %Cecqn]3+0-ã;&)
n]h`qn]jpah]na`q__eÅj`a- Ō]E Ō- Ōajh]naolen]_eÅj%B d* mqa`ebeana`ah]_]p]h]o]ajmqanamqeanaqjna`q_pkn)jkn*
b p m\ 3 +/ 6 &+ >`ai|o)h]obh]rklnkpa~j]o)mqejkj]o)pekhao)u i]hiajpaK>AE)l]n]knecej]noÅhkE /- _kiklnk`q_pk+
lnkpa~j]o_kjdeannku ]vqbna%ltWi[Pa__eÅj2+..&)mqaoa BhoqlanÅte`kao`aopnqe`klknh]ajvei]ik f [ hw n_Z e Z_i(
aj_qajpn]jln|_pe_]iajpaajpk`]oh]o_}hqh]o)p]i^e}j
lqa`ajhhar]n]_]^kh]na`q__eÅj`a- Ō]- /YMknp]jpk)oa N`\^odqjn Lmj_p^ojn
naolenakjk_kjkt~cajk%Q]^h]3+0&)qj]_}hqh]lqa`aao*
- Ō (`xë'* - /*  Opk`mÅsd_j
p]natlqaop]k_]oekj]hiajpa]aola_eaopÅte_]o`akt~cajk+
- /[(`[ ( / D (ëü DŌ- Ō L`mÅsd_j_`cd_mÅb`ij
BhoqlanÅte`ku ahn]`e_]hde`nktehkokj]cajpaoiqu DŌ- Ō(`*  ( D( ëü D/-  ( KD' N\_d^\gcd_mjsdgj
kte`]jpaoulqa`ajkte`]nln|_pe_]iajpa_q]hmqean_ki*
KDê (`[ ( D(ëü D/-  =bp\
lqaopkknc|je_k`ah]_}hqh])ej_hquaj`kh]oi]_nkikh}*
_qh]o+IkolanÅte`ko_kikahEŌ - Ōp]i^e}jlqa`aj`]Ä]n Oph\7
- Ō ( 1 `í  ( 1 D(*ü  /D/-
hko_kilkjajpao_ahqh]nao)lankcajan]hiajpajkokjp]j
pÅte_kol]n]h]_}hqh]_kikah]jeÅjoqlanÅte`kkhkon]* B db p m\ 3 +/ 6  N`_p^^dÅi_` g- /c\no\\bp\k j mg\\_d^dÅi
`e_]haode`nktehk+yopkoÇhpeikookjhkoi|ona]_perko`a n`^p`i^d\g _`^ p\omj`g`^omji`n+Hjndio`mh`_d\mdjnlp`n`
pk`]oh]oaola_eaopÅte_]o`ahkt~cajklankokjokhkbkn* ajmh\injim`\^odqjntoÅsd^jnk\m\g\^}gpg\)`s^`koj`g\bp\+
. 5 5 Q J E@ = @  . E  L mdi^dk dj n_ `  h d^mj ] dj gj b ~\

emlYkY%Cecqn]3+0-^& mqa_ki^ej]`koikh}_qh]o`aoq* Ae_dkoeopai]jkaop]jabe_]v_kikh]oqlanÅte`k`eo*


lanÅte`kl]n]bkni]nqj]ikh}_qh]`alanÅte`k`ade`nÅ* iqp]o]lankp]hna]__eÅjlqa`ad]^anbqj_ekj]`k_kik
cajkuqj]ikh}_qh]`akt~cajk+I]]__eÅj_kjfqjp]`ah] qj]bkni]lneieper]`aoqlanÅte`k`eoiqp]o]ajhkokn*
oqlanÅte`k `eoiqp]o]u`ah]_]p]h]o]lqa`alknp]jpk c]jeoiko]j]ank^ekolneiecajekomqaoaajbnajp]nkjlkn
_kjranpenahoqlanÅte`kajkt~cajku]cq]%Cecqn]3+0M_&+ lneian]rav]hkt~cajk_q]j`k]l]na_eankjh]o_e]jk^]_*
Iko]ank^ekouhkob]_qhp]perko_kjpeajajlknhkcaja* pane]ook^nah]Qeann]+
n]hp]jpkoqlanÅte`k`eoiqp]o]_kik_]p]h]o]+I]oqla*
nÅte`k `eoiqp]o] ao eilnao_ej`e^ha aj h]o _}hqh]o M m h ] j{ p a\ g  j]\m[lYkY
]ank^e]ouoq]qoaj_e] ajhko]j]ank^eko k^hec]`ko oa >hcqj]o<j[`Y]Y ]j]ank^e]o k^hec]`]o lnaoajp]j kpnk
lajoÅmqaan]h]_]qo]lknh]mqaahkt~cajknaoqhp]pÅte_k i}pk`k`aaheiej]nahoqlanÅte`k+Mknafailhk)ajahde*
l]n]aop]o_}hqh]o%lanknwYk]p]i^e}j]aopanaola_pkah lanpaniÅbehkKqjg[g[[mk^mjagkmk jkateopaoqlanÅte`k
l|nn]bk oecqeajpa&+ >hcqjko ]j]ank^eko ]ankpkhan]jpao) `eoiqp]o]lankaop|lnaoajpaqjajvei]l]npe_qh]n)h]km)
_kikh]o^]_pane]o`ah|_e`kh|_pe_k)_]na_aj`ah]oqla* h]jzpa\gj]\m[lYkY(mqaoaaj_]nc]`ah]aheiej]_eÅj`ah
nÅte`k`eoiqp]o]lankqo]j_kilhafkojklnkpae_ko`a oqlanÅte`k+>`ebanaj_e]`ah]oqlanÅte`k`eoiqp]o])h]
Jj/(he^nal]n]hkcn]nh]`eoiqp]_eÅj`a- /í]E Ō - Ōu - /+ oqlanÅte`kna`q_p]o]na`q_aah]jeÅjoqlanÅte`k]E Ō- Ō
oejh]lnk`q__eÅj `a - Ō %Cecqn] 3+0-_&)_kjhkmqa oa
B-+ - & B-+ -(W-B-+  & + - arep]h]atlkoe_eÅj`ahknc]jeoik]h- /+K ^mjagkmkp]i*
^e}j_]na_a`a_]p]h]o])qj]ajvei])mqa_kikh]oqla*
#W$=YlYdYkY
nÅte`k`eoiqp]o])p]i^e}jcajan]- Ō%Cecqn]3+0-]&+Bj
B-+ - & H;>B & B& (  -B-+  & H;>% aopaie_nkknc]jeoikahE Ō - Ōlnk`q_e`klknh]oqlanÅ*
#X$J]jgpa\YkY te`kna`q_p]o]oaaheiej]lknh]]_pere`]``aajvei]ooa*
+ -"  & , .t & -B&(W B-+ - & + - iaf]jpao ] h]o lankte`]o]o mqa lnk`q_aj E/-  _kik
lnk`q_pkbej]h%Cecqn]3+0-Z%*I]oqlanÅte`kna`q_p]o]
#Y$Mmh]jzpa\g\akemlYkY
peajaecq]hiajpaqj]]ilhe]`eopne^q_eÅjajpnahko]j]a*
/+ -(  & / B &(W -B-+  & .+ -
nk^ekok^hec]`ko) _kikh]o^]_pane]ooqhb]pkna`q_pkn]o
#lx$Mmh]jzpa\g\akemlYkY*[YlYdYkY]f[geZafY[azf $=Y[l]jaY%(hkoiap]jkc}je_ko$<j[`Y]Y%(]o~_kikajao*
+ -X &-B%&  jmZj]\gpafYWm[a\_(à( B-+ - & jmZj]\gpafY+7a\Y\. la_eaoie_nk]anÅbeh]o`a=Y[l]jaY(`ahpelk`aOj]hgf]eY*
#[$Mmh]jzpa\gj]\m[lYkY Mknp]jpk) aopkoie_nkknc]jeoiko)mqaoalajo]^]mqa
an]j]j]ank^ekoaopne_pkolkn_]na_an`aoqlanÅte`k`eo*
B db p m\ 3 +0 -  Aiudh\nlp`_`nompt`i`nk`^d`noÅsd^\n iqp]o])peajajjkk^op]jpaqjia_]jeoikl]n]aheiej]n
_`mdq\_\n_`gjs~b`ij)#W$H\n^\o\g\n\nt#X$g\nk`mjsd_\n\nnji ah]jeÅjoqlanÅte`k+I]oajoe^ehe`]``aaopkoie_nkknc]*
kmjo`~i\nlp`^jiod`i`ikjmadmdi\n)\pilp`o\h]d}i\gbpi\n jeoiko]hkt~cajklqa`a`a^anoalkn_kilhapk]kpn]on]*
ag\qjkmjo`~i\nkp`_`i^jinphdm`nk`^d`noÅsd^\n_`js~b`ij+
vkjao]Çj`ao_kjk_e`]o+
$[%H\nnpk`mÅsd_j_dnhpo\n\nnjikmjo`~i\nlp`^jiod`i`i
Jq_dko]j]ank^ekoadelanpaniÅbehkok^hec]`ko)_kik
h`o\g`n)api_\h`io\gh`io`^j]m`tudi^)h\ib\i`njj cd`mmj+
Kqjg[g[[mk(rerajaj_deiaja]ode`nkpani]haok_a|je_]o
$\%N`\^^dÅi^jh]di\_\_`g\npk`mÅsd_j_dnhpo\n\tg\^\o\g\n\+
%`&H\npk`mÅsd_jm`_p^o\n\^\o\gdu\g\m`_p^^dÅik jmpi`g`^omÅi $nwYk]Pa__eÅj/1+..&lankokjiqupkhan]jpao]_kj`e*
_ ` - /* \ D /- /+ _ekjaoÅte_]o+>qjmqajk_na_ajajp]hao_kj`e_ekjao)oa
oqlkja mqa h] oqlanÅte`k na`q_p]o] arep] oq iqanpa
_q]j`koaatlkjaj]h- /+I]pkhan]j_e]]hkt~cajklqa`a
oanqj b]_pkneilknp]jpamqalaniepaahpn]jolknpa `a
aopkoknc]jeoikoaj]cq]oi]nej]oÅte_]o`ao`aqjao*
_]lacakp}nie_k]kpnk+

1 ) , 3  G a f aj j ] n ak a{ f

/ ?f dY[wdmdYk]hm]\]fg ja_af YjnYjaYk^gje Yklzpa[Yk\]d


gpx_ ]fg'h]jg]pakl]f]fraeYkim ] hm ]\]f f]mljYdarYjdY
@ a_ m j Y 1 )., G w lg \ g \]]fkYqg\]dYhj]k]f[aY\ ] [YlYdYkY e YqgjhYjl]\ ] ]ddYk) ?fhYjla[mdYj']dk mh ]jz p a\ghYj][]
]fmf[mdlangea[jgZaYfg)OfYkY\][mdlang[Yj_Y\Y[gf[wdmdYk k]jmfY^g je Ylzpa[Y e mq^j][m]fl])
j][g_a\Yk\]dYkmh]j^a[a]\]mf[mdlangkzda\gk]e]r[dY
C  Ö = z e g hjgl]_ ]YdY[wdm dYdYk mh ]jz p a\g\akemlYkY:
[gfmfY_glY\]Y_mYgpa_]fY\YYd.+!kgZj]mfhgjlY
#\]j][`Y$)FYafe]\aYlYYhYja[azf\]ZmjZmbYkaf\a[YdYhj]k]f[aY C Ö?fim wk]\a^]j]f[aYdYY[lana\Y\\ ] dYkmh ]jz pa\g
\][YlYdYkY)FYkZmjZmbYkhjg[]\]f\]d+ /_]f]jY\g]fdY \akemlYkY\ ] dYk mh ]jz p a\gj]\m[lYkY:
j]Y[[azfB/K /&B/+ /(à -B-+ &+ -)
? \ k ~op gj Å  E  ? m` ^ dh d` i oj h d^mj ] d\ i j  .56

` i
>_e`Åbehk7qjknc]jeoikmqa_na_aiafkn] BtpnaiÅbehk7qjknc]jeoikmqa_na_a`a Moe_nÅbehk7knc]jeoik_kjqj]
lE^]fk8jkni]hiajpa]lEejbanekn]3+ ik`kÅlpeikajqj]ki|o_kj`e_ekjao pailan]pqn]Ålpei]`a_na_eieajpk`a
>_pere`]``ah]cq]7_k_eajpaajpnah] b~oe_]okmq~ie_]oatpnai]o)_kiklkn .2Ñ@kiajknuqj]pailan]pqn]
lnaoeÅj`ar]lknajamqehe^nek_kjah]ena afailhk]]hp]k^]f]pailan]pqn]klE+ i|tei]`a_na_eieajpkejbanekn]/-Ñ@+
u h]lnaoeÅj`aqj]okhq_eÅj`a]cq] C]_qhp]perk7_kjnaola_pk]h- /)qj Moe_nkpkhan]jpa7knc]jeoik_]l]v`a
knc]jeoikmqalqa`a_na_anajoq _na_an]^]f]opailan]pqn]olank_qu]
>ank^ek7qjknc]jeoikmqalqa`aqo]nah ]qoaj_e]uajoqlnaoaj_e]+ pailan]pqn]Ålpei]`a_na_eieajpkaop|
- /ajh]naolen]_eÅj8]hcqjkonamqeanaj CeoeÅj^ej]ne]7`ereoeÅj_ahqh]nmqaoecqa lknaj_ei]`a/-ê@+
L/l]n]ah_na_eieajpk+ ]h]qiajp]nqj]_}hqh]`kora_aooq Nqeiekop]pk7]l]n]pkmqalaniepaah
>h_]hÅbehk7qjknc]jeoikmqapeajaqj p]i]Äki~jeik+ _qhperk_kjpejqk`aie_nkknc]jeoikoaj
_na_eieajpkÅlpeik]lE6koqlanekn+ CpoW7qj]lnkpa~j]_h]raajh]`ereoeÅj ahmqaoalqa`aj_kjpnkh]n
_ahqh]nmqabkni]qj]jehhk]hkh]nck`ah ej`alaj`eajpaiajpah]rahk_e`]``a
>j]ank^ek7qjknc]jeoikmqajk
lh]jk`a`ereoeÅjl]n]eje_e]nh]`ereoeÅj _na_eieajpkuahjÇiank`a_}hqh]o+
lqa`aqo]nah-/ajh]naolen]_eÅj
u_quk_na_eieajpkoqahaoanejde^e`k _ahqh]n+ Oa_qajpkajlh]_]7i}pk`k`ana_qajpk
lknah- /+ E]hÅbehk7qjie_nkknc]jeoikmqaja_aoep] `are]^hao`kj`aoaqo]ahjÇiank`a
>j]ank^ek]ankpkhan]jpa7qj K]@hl]n]_na_an+ _khkje]oajqj]lh]_]_kikia`e`]`ah
ie_nkknc]jeoikej_]l]v`anaolen]n_kj jÇiank`a_}hqh]o+
E]hÅbehkatpnaik7qjie_nkknc]jeoikmqa
kt~cajkikha_qh]n%L/& lank_quk namqeanal]n]_na_ancn]j`ao_]jpe`]`ao Pkhqpk_kil]pe^ha7qj]ikh}_qh]mqaoa
_na_eieajpkjkao]ba_p]`klknh] `ao]h%K]@h&)lknhkcajan]hoqlaneknao ]_qiqh]ajah_epklh]oi]l]n]]fqop]nh]
lnaoaj_e]`a- /+ ]h.-"u ]ra_aolnÅtei]o]h] ]_pere`]``a]cq]u mqajkejde^ahko
>j]ank^ekk^hec]`k7knc]jeoikmqajk o]pqn]_eÅj+ lnk_aoko^ekmq~ie_ko+
lqa`a_na_anajlnaoaj_e]`a- /* E]hkpkhan]jpa7qjknc]jeoikmqajk Qailan]pqn]o_]n`ej]hao7h]o
>qpÅheoeo7heoeo_ahqh]naolkjp|ja]) namqeanaK]@hl]n]_na_anlankmqa pailan]pqn]oi~jei])Ålpei]ui|tei]
jkni]hiajpa`a^e`]]h]]_pere`]``a lqa`a_na_anajoqlnaoaj_e])aj]hcqjko mqalaniepajah_na_eieajpk`aqj
lnkpa~j]oh~pe_]ohh]i]`]o]qpkheoej]o+ _]oko)]jerahaoo]hejkoahar]`ko+ knc]jeoik`apaniej]`k+

?ekbehi7i]pnevlkheo]_]n~`k_]bef]`]mqa EelanpaniÅbehk7lnk_]nekp]mqapeajaqj] QaniÅbehk7knc]jeoik_qu]pailan]pqn]


_kjpeaja_}hqh]o^]_pane]j]o+ pailan]pqn]Ålpei]`a5-ê@koqlanekn+ Ålpei]`a_na_eieajpkaop|ajpna
12u 5-Ñ@+
@na_eieajpk7ej_naiajpkajahjÇiank`a JaoÅbehk7qjknc]jeoikmqa_na_aiafkn]
_}hqh]o+ pailan]pqn]oajpna/-u 12ê@+ Qeailk`acajan]_eÅj7ahpeailk
ja_ao]nekl]n]mqaqj]lk^h]_eÅj`a
@na_eieajpkatlkjaj_e]h7_na_eieajpk`a Je_nk]anÅbehk7knc]jeoik]ank^ekmqa
_}hqh]oie_nk^e]j]o`qlhemqaoqjÇiank+
qjie_nkknc]jeoik_qukjÇiank`a lqa`a_na_anoÅhk_q]j`kh]lnaoeÅj
_}hqh]ooa`qlhe_]ajqjlan~k`k l]n_e]h`ahkt~cajkaoiajknmqah]`ah Qn]olalpe`]_eÅj7bkni]_eÅj`alqajpao
_kjop]jpa`apeailk+ lalp~`e_koajpnah]oqje`]`ao`a|_e`k
@qhperkikjkb|oe_kk ajZYl[`6_qhperk K*]_apehiqn|ie_k`qn]jpah]o~jpaoeo
LoiÅbehk7knc]jeoikmqa_na_aiafknaj
ie_nk^e]jkajqjoeopai]_ann]`k`a `alalpe`kche_]jk+
lnaoaj_e]`aahar]`kojerahao`aokhqpk)
rkhqiaj_kjop]jpa+ bna_qajpaiajpaqj]vÇ_]n+ Se]^ha7_]l]v`analnk`q_enoa+
Aereoki]7_kilhafklnkpae_kmqa`enecahko lE7r]hknjac]perk`ahhkc]nepik`ah] UanÅbehk7knc]jeoikmqaao_]l]v`areren)
lnk_aoko`a`ereoeÅj_ahqh]naj _kj_ajpn]_eÅj`aekjaode`nÅcajk%E'& kmqareraiafkn)aj]i^eajpaoiqu
lnk_]nekp]o+ ajqj]okhq_eÅj+ `aoa_]`ko+

J j] _ m f lY k  \ ]  j] h Y k g

.+ Aao_ne^]hkolnej_el]haolnk_aokoikha_qh]naomqa lnkpa~j]Jna?`ah]o_}hqh]o_kjpnkhjkiqp]`]o<ã@q|hao


k_qnnaj_q]j`kqj]_}hqh]_na_auoa`ere`a+ãNq} ahikperk%Pa__eÅj3+0&<
lnkpa~j]oaop|jeilhe_]`]oajaopalnk_aok`a`ereoeÅj 1+ ã@Åiki]p]h]laje_ehej]]h]o_}hqh]o^]_pane]j]o
%Pa__eÅj3+.&< u lknmq}oÅhkaheiej]]h]o_}hqh]oaj_na_eieajpk
/+ Aao_ne^]ahl]lah`ah]olnkpa~j]oCpoajahlnk_aok`ah] %Pa__eÅj3+1&<
`ereoeÅj_ahqh]n%Pa__eÅj3+/&+ 2+ ã@q|haoh]`ebanaj_e]ajpnah]_kjop]jpa`ah]rahk_e`]``a
0+ ãBjmq}oa`ebanaj_e]jie_nk_Åle_]iajpahkoeiep]jpao _na_eieajpk$c%`aqjknc]jeoikuoqpeailk`a
`ah^]_ehk@k[`]ja[`aY[gdamqapeajajej]_per]`]h] cajan]_eÅj$_%%Pa__ekjao3+2u 3+3&<
. 6 - Q J E@ = @  . E  L mdi^dk dj n_ `  h d^mj ] dj gj b ~\

3+ Aao_ne^]ah_e_hk`a_na_eieajpk`aqj] ..+ Aao_ne^]qjd|^ep]p`kj`aoa]lkoe^haaj_kjpn]nqj


lk^h]_eÅj`a_}hqh]o^]_pane]j]o`ao`aahpeailk loe_nÅbehk8uqjdelanpaniÅbehk%Pa__ekjao3+.0u3+.1&+
ajmqaoaeje_e]oqejÅ_qhkajia`ekbnao_k ./+ @kjnaola_pk]hlE`ahia`ekuah`ah]_}hqh]ãajmqaokj
%Pa__eÅj3+4&+ `ebanajpaohko]_e`Åbehko`ahko]h_]hÅbehko<ãBjmq}okj
4+ ã@Åiklqa`anacqh]nqjmqeiekop]pk`aik`k ecq]hao%Pa__eÅj3+.2&<
ej`alaj`eajpah]rahk_e`]``a_na_eieajpkuahjÇiank`a .0+ Btlhemqaajp}niejkoikha_qh]nao_Åikqj]_}hqh]`aqj
_}hqh]o%Pa__eÅj3+5&< d]hÅbehkao_]l]v`ad]_anmqah]oikh}_qh]o`a]cq]
5+ ã@q|haoh]`ebanaj_e]ajpnaqjna_qajpk`a_}hqh]opkp]hao ajpnajajoqejpanekn%Pa__eÅj3+.3&+
u qjna_qajpk`are]^hao%Pa__ekjao3+6u3+.-&< .1+ @kil]naqj]ankpkhan]jpau ie]j]ank^ekk^hec]`kajhk
6+ ã@Åikoalqa`aailha]nh]pqn^e`avl]n]`apaniej]nah mqanaola_p]]oajoe^ehe`]`u_na_eieajpkajlnaoaj_e]`a
jÇiank`a_}hqh]o%Pa__eÅj3+..&< kt~cajk%L/&+ãBjmq}`ebeanaqj]j]ank^ek]ankpkhan]jpa
.-+ Bt]iejah]cn|be_]`ah]Cecqn]3+.5mqanah]_ekj] `aqjie_nk]anÅbehk%Pa__eÅj3+.4&<
h]rahk_e`]``a_na_eieajpku h]pailan]pqn]+Bj .2+ @kil]nah]oajvei]o_]p]h]o])oqlanÅte`k`eoiqp]o])u
p}niejko^ekmq~ie_ko)atlhemqalknmq}h]pailan]pqn] oqlanÅte`kna`q_p]o]`ao`ahkooecqeajpaolqjpko`areop]7
Ålpei]l]n]qjknc]jeoikaop|jkni]hiajpai|o oqopn]pko)lnk`q_pko`akt~cajk)knc]jeoikomqahko
_an_]j]]oqpailan]pqn]i|tei]mqa]oqi~jei] lnaoajp]j)l]lahajh]pkhan]j_e]_ahqh]n]hkt~cajk
%Pa__eÅj3+./&+ %Pa__eÅj3+.5&+

? b] j [ a[ ag k  h j w [ l a[ g k

.+ Rj_qhperkajia`ekjqpneperkne_koaeje_e]_kj_q]pnk @]l~pqhk3h]mqaiafkn`ao_ne^]hkmq}k_qnnen~]oeqj]


_}hqh]o^]_pane]j]olkniehehepnk)ulnaoajp]qjlan~k`k`a _}hqh]`aKqjgdgZmk^meYjaaoa_khk_]n]]h]oieoi]o
h]paj_e]`a.dkn]uqjpeailk`acajan]_eÅj`a/- _kj`e_ekjao+Aao_ne^]lknmq}jejcqjk`ahko`ko
iejqpko)ã_q|jp]o_}hqh]od]^n|aj.hepnk`aaoa_qhperk knc]jeoiko_na_an~]+
pn]o .dkn]`aej_q^]_eÅj<ãVpn]o/dkn]o<ãVpn]o/dkn]o 1+ ãBolnk^]^haaj_kjpn]nrerk]qjie_nkknc]jeoik
oeqj]`ah]o_}hqh]o`ahejÅ_qhkeje_e]haopqrean]iqanp]< loe_nÅbehkajqj]cq]pani]h<ãMknmq}<@kjbna_qaj_e]
/+ @]h_qhaahr]hkn`ac u`acajqjatlaneiajpk`a naoqhp]lkoe^ha]eoh]nie_nkknc]jeoikopaniÅbehkoaj
_na_eieajpkajahmqaoaejk_qhÅqjia`ek_kj2t.-3 ]i^eajpao`a]cq]bn~]+O]vkjaqj]atlhe_]_eÅj`aaopko
_}hqh]o,ih`a@k[`]ja[`aY[gdau mqa)`aolq}o`aqjlan~k`k da_dko+
`ah]paj_e]`a.dkn])_na_eÅatlkjaj_e]hiajpa`qn]jpa2 2+ ãBjmq}`ena__eÅj%bqan]k`ajpnk`ah]_}hqh]&oaikran|
dkn]o]h_]jv]j`kqj]lk^h]_eÅj`a2)1t.-6_}hqh]o,ih+ ah]cq]`ah]o_}hqh]o`a@k[`]ja[`aY[gda%mqad]^ep]ajah
0+ @kjoqhpaah@]l~pqhk0u hk_]he_aqj]becqn]mqa`ao_ne^] ejpaopejk&oeoaoqlaj`ean]j`alnkjpkajqj]okhq_eÅj_kj
hkmqaoq_a`a]hkoajvei]o`aqjiaoÅbehk_kik /-"`aK]@F<ãVoeoaoqolaj`ean]jaj]cq]`aopeh]`]<Pe
@k[`]ja[`aY[g da_q]j`koa_khk_]ajqjia`ek`a oa]Ä]`ean]jjqpneajpao]_]`]qj]`ah]ooqolajoekjao
_qhperk]5-Ñ@+@kil]naaopk_kjqj]becqn]`ah ã_q|hoan~]p]hrav_]l]v`a_na_an)ulknmq}<

You might also like