Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Received: 4 May 2013 Revised: 28 October 2013 Accepted article published: 17 December 2013 Published online in Wiley Online Library:
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Polyethylene terephthalate (PET) containers for food oil packaging were evaluated with a newly established
determination method for terephthalic acid (TPA) and isophthalic acid (IPA). The analysis of monomers, TPA and IPA that
migrate from PET bottles into oils was performed using high-pressure liquid chromatography with a diode array detector. Three
types of commercial oils (sunflower oil, canola oil and blended oil which included sunflower oil, soy bean oil and cottonseed oil)
were bottled in PET containers. These samples were incubated for 10 days at 49 ◦ C as accelerated test condition.
RESULTS: The means of recovery for this method varied from 70% to 72% and from 101% to 111% for TPA and IPA, respectively.
The results showed that the amounts of specific migration of TPA and IPA into the samples conform to European Union
legislation that identifies specific migration limits. More important, the results highlighted a different behavior of migration as
a function of the fatty acid profile.
CONCLUSION: Previous investigations have been performed with food simulants such as HB307 or 20% ethanol but our study
used real food samples and determined trace amounts of the migrated compounds. Further investigation will be needed to
better explain the influence of fatty acid conformation on migration of PET monomers.
c 2013 Society of Chemical Industry
Keywords: HPLC; isophthalic acid; oils; polyethylene terephthalate; specific migration; terephthalic acid
the process of mass transfer from a packaging material to its packaged in 1 L PET bottles were purchased from Varamin Corp.,
contents, in particular when these are liquid or semi-liquid.9 Tehran, Iran.
Migration from packaging materials into products generally is The PET polymers used had been made by Varamin Corp.,
concerned with minor constituents that influence the quality of Tehran, Iran, and consisted of Bottle Grade- PARS PET-BG805
the contained product by sensory or toxicological hazards.1,10,11 with DEG max content of 2.0%, by wt. Standards of TPA and IPA
The toxicity of migrated monomers from PET packaging into were purchased from Fluka Chemical, trademarked Sigma-Aldrich
foods has been demonstrated by many investigations: isophthalic Corp., Switzerland. HPLC gradient-grade water, acetonitrile, and
acid (IPA) and terephthalic acid (TPA) are examples of migrant methanol (HPLC grade) solvents were purchased from Merck
compounds, and their harmful effects on laboratory animals have (Darmstadt, Germany).
been demonstrated. For this reason, the EFSA fixed levels of
IPA and TPA migration into foods from plastics of 5 and 7.5 Standards and calibration curves
mg kg−1 of food, respectively12 – 14 (Regulation 2011/10/EU). A mixed stock standard solution of 240 ng mL−1 was prepared
PET is made by polymerizing ethylene glycol with TPA or by from TPA and IPA that were dissolved in methanol and was stored
transesterification with dimethyl terephthalate (DMT), commonly in the dark at refrigerator temperature (4 ◦ C). Calibration standard
using antimony trioxide as catalyst.1 A more recent development solutions were prepared on the day of use at concentrations of
in PET manufacturing is the modification of polymers by the 120, 60, 24, 12 and 6 ng mL−1 and calibration graphs were plotted
incorporation of IPA to generate a polymer. The presence of an using these concentrations of standard solutions.
appropriate comonomer such as IPA or DMT slows down the rate The detection limit was defined as the concentration
of crystallization, which allows the manufacture of thicker bottle corresponding to a peak height three times the baseline noise
walls, sheets and films.4 There is also a requirement to extend the level.
rate of crystallization to restrict movement and deformation at Recovery studies were carried out by spiking selected samples of
elevated temperatures, such as for oven-compatible food trays.15 oils with the blended standard solution (mix of TPA and IPA) at three
In this case, a nucleating agent or promoter is employed to increase concentrations (240, 750 and 1000 µg kg−1 ). The spiked samples,
the polymer’s molecular weight. On the other hand, TPA reacts as well as the controls, were analyzed in triplicate experiments.
with ethylene glycol (EG) at a temperature between 240 and Recovery rates (percent) were calculated by comparing peak area
260 ◦ C and a pressure between 300 and 500 kPa with the use of a in the chromatogram with the peak area calculated from the
comonomer such as IPA to slow down the rate of crystallization, standard calibration curves.
thus allowing the manufacture of thicker bottle walls.2
The basic principle of the European Union (EU) legislation Fatty acid profiles of the oils
on food contact materials and articles is expounded in the For determination of the fatty acid profile, a transmethylation
framework of Regulation 1935/2004/EC, which states that ‘food technique followed by gas chromatography–flame ionization
contact materials should not transfer to foodstuffs any of their detection (GC-FID) determination (AOAC 969.22) was used as
constituents in quantities that could endanger human health a practical method. The gas chromatograph system (model
or cause deterioration in the organoleptic characteristics of 6890N, Agilent Technologies, Germany) was equipped with flame
the foodstuff’. This regulation defines the requirements for all ionization detector and HP88 column (100 m × 250 mm × 0.2 m.
materials intended for food contact applications, and not just for The temperature of the column was from 170 to 190 ◦ C in 5 min
plastics. Within the framework of this regulation there is a specific by 0.5 ◦ C min−1 , at which temperature it remained for 20 min; the
regulation for plastics (2011/10/EC) in which a list of authorized detector temperature was 250 ◦ C; the speed of helium as carrier
substances is defined. In this list, monomers commonly used in gas was 0.7 mL min−1 ; the pressure was 10 psı and the volume of
making PET and copolyesters for food packaging are established sample injection was 1 µL. Results are expressed as g kg−1 .
with a specific migration limit (SML).4 Monomers which can migrate
from PET bottles into foodstuff are TPA, dimethyl terephthalate Migration testing
(DMT), IPA, dimethyl isophthalate, EG,1,16 diethylene glycol (DEG)
Experiments were performed on PET bottles which contained the
and 1,4-bis(hydroxymethyl) cyclohexane. The principles behind
three oils (as mentioned above). The oils, which had been stored
the regulatory rules followed by other countries are similar to in PET bottles at room temperature for about 3 months in the
those of the EU. Migration tests of TPA, IPA and DMT from factory, were poured into glass containers and they passed the
PET containers, with food safety in view, have been different test condition (49 ± 2 ◦ C for 10 days), so they served as blank
in their basic forms, and analyses based on high-pressure liquid samples for each type of oil.
chromatography (HPLC) have yielded equivocal results.17 – 21 The samples were kept in an incubator at 49 ◦ C for 10 days
The main purpose of this study was to investigate a new HPLC to obtain accelerated migration conditions. The temperature was
diode array detection (DAD) method for determination of specific controlled and the data were recorded by a data logger (LASCAR,
migration of TPA and IPA from PET bottles into three different UK). A mixture of methanol (1 mL), chloroform (3 mL) and NaOH
types of oils (sunflower, canola and blended oil) after storage (1 mL) was used for the extraction of migrated monomers from
under accelerated migration test conditions. 1 g of oil sample. After centrifugation (Heraeus Biofuge Stratos,
Thermo Scientific, USA) at RCF = 4637 × g and at −3 ◦ C for 20
min, the separated samples were analyzed by HPLC with DAD for
MATERIALS AND METHODS determination of migrants.
Reagents and standard solutions
Commercial sunflower, canola and blended oils (containing HPLC analysis
sunflower, soy and cottonseed oils) (with added butylated Standards and the monomers in the samples were separated
hydroxytoluene as antioxidant at 100 mg kg−1 in all of the oils) and quantified using an HPLC system (model 1200, Agilent
wileyonlinelibrary.com/jsfa
c 2013 Society of Chemical Industry J Sci Food Agric (2014)
Food safety (packaging, migration, oil) www.soci.org
Statistical analysis
Experiments on five selected PET bottles containing each type of oil
sample were performed three times. Statistical analysis was done An HPLC chromatogram of blended oil extract for a real sample
with SPSS version 11.5 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA) and Minitab is shown in Fig. 1. The results obtained from the chromatograms
version 11.12 (Minitab Inc., State College, PA, USA). The standard indicate that the retention times of the two compounds were
calibration curves were plotted using Excel 2007 (Microsoft, USA). between 9 and 11 min and peaks of solvents were eluted in
The significance level was P < 0.05. about 2–4 min. Run time for the analysis of TPA and IPA was
35 min, but all peaks appeared before 12 min, which represents
a short operating time. TPA and IPA in each type of oil in the
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION partitioned extract were well separated from each other and from
The two common monomers from PET plastic packaging are TPA the backgrounds in the spiked oils. The HPLC chromatogram of
and IPA Hence simultaneously analysis of these two components the extracted sample in Fig. 1 indicates that the extraction solvent
would be of interest. did not critically interfere with the detection of the monomers.
In general, HPLC chromatograms showed good detection sensi- Samples without treatment were stored by maintaining the oil
tivity. The reproducibility of separation was validated by three indi- bottles from production until time of purchase (about 3 month)
vidual injections of each concentration of standard solution. Quan- at room temperature (25 ◦ C with relative humidity about 65%);
titative parameters of the proposed method, such as linearity range probably, a slight migration of monomers occurred which could
of detection within the range of 6–120 ng mL−1 , and limit of detec- not be measured by common methods.
tion (LOD) = 6 ng mL−1 based on a signal-to-noise ratio higher than Amounts of the specific migration from PET bottles into the
3, were evaluated. The liner regression equations had determina- different types of oils are shown in Tables 1 and 2. The highest
tion coefficients (R2 ) equal to 0.9978 for TPA and 0.9998 for IPA. levels of migration were 37.20 ± 0.11 µg kg−1 and 8.26 ± 0.20 µg
TPA recoveries varied in the range of 70–72% for all the tested kg−1 for TPA and IPA, respectively, in canola oil samples. The lowest
oils. Also the mean recoveries for IPA varied in the range of levels of migration were 21.32 ± 0.20 µg kg−1 and 5.31 ± 0.12 µg
101–110%. kg−1 for TPA and IPA, respectively, in sunflower oil samples.
wileyonlinelibrary.com/jsfa
c 2013 Society of Chemical Industry J Sci Food Agric (2014)
Food safety (packaging, migration, oil) www.soci.org
11 Farhodi M, Emam-Djomeh Z, Ehsani MR and Oroumiehie A, 19 Tice PA, PIRA project on migration of monomers and overall migration.
Effect of environmental conditions on the migration of di(2- Food Addit Contam 5:373–80 (1988).
ethylhexyl)phthalate from PET bottles into yogurt drinks: influence 20 Environmental Protection Agency, Phthalate esters by gas
of time, temperature and food stimulant. Arab J Sci Eng 33:279–287 chromatography with electron capture detection (GC/ECD), Method
(2008). 8061A. EPA, Washington, DC (1996).
12 Sheftel VO, Indirect Food Additives and Polymers. Lewis, Boca Raton, FL, 21 Lee KH, Polyethylene terephthalate. Annu Rep KFDA 7:129– 34 (2003).
pp. 147–149, 211 (2000). 22 Haward W, Starkweather JR, Paul Z and Glover A, The heat of fusion
13 SIDS Initial Assessment Report for 14th SIAM, Isophthalic Acid (IPA), CAS poly(ethylene terephthalate). J Polym Sci Pol Phys 21:295–299
No. 121-91-5. UNEP Publications, Nairobi, Kenya (2001). (1983).
14 SIDS Initial Assessment Report for 14th SIAM Terephthalic Acid (TPA), CAS 23 Pawlak A, Pluta M, Morawiec J, Galeski A and Pracella M,
No. 100-21-0. UNEP Publications, Nairobi, Kenya (2001). Characterization of scrap poly(ethylene terephthalate). Eur Polym J
15 Castle L, Mayo A, Crews C and Gilbert J, Migration of PET oligomers 36:1875–1884 (2000).
from PET plastics into foods during microwave and conventional 24 Cornier-Rios H, Effect of recycling on material properties of
cooking and into bottled beverages. J Food Prot 52:337–342 (1989). polyethylene terephthalate at various recycling ratios and recycling
16 Kashtock M and Breder CV, Migration of ethylene glycol from generations. MSc thesis, University of Puerto Rico, pp. 19–22
polyethylene terephthalate bottles into 3% acetic acid. AOAC 63: (2003).
168–172 (1980). 25 European Committee for Standardization (CEN), Materials and articles
17 Begley TH and Hollifield HC, High-performance liquid chromato- in contact with foodstuffs – plastics substances subject to
graphic determination of migrating poly(ethylene terephthalate) limitation – Part 2: Determination of terephthalic acid in food
oligomers in corn oil. J Agric Food Chem 38:145–148 (1990). simulants, ENV 13130-2. CEN, Brussels, pp. 1–7 (1999).
18 Tice PA and McGuinness JD, Migration from food contact plastics. Part
I. Establishment and aims of the PIRA project. Food Addit Contam
4:267–276 (1987).