THE IMPACT OF HOT-DRY CLIMATE ON HOUSING:
A comparative Study between Traditional and Contemporary
Houses, with Special Reference to Ghadames City, Libya.
ABUBARKER SHAWESH
ABSTRACT
The arid climate conditions in Libyan Arab Jamahiriya, have been carefully and
‘ffectvly dealt with in the traditional cities where bullaings, streets, and tho
cities themselves have evolved in response to such conditions by utlsing
‘afural materials and traditional techniques. In contrast, contemporaly city
development, and dweling design, has fallen short of a chiaving similar comfort
Conditions, without resorting to mechanical or electrical devices such as alr
Conditioning. This paper describes and investigates the traditional and modem
‘areas of the desert settiement of Ghadames in ordor 10 determine the impact of
the extemal cimate on the performance of the buildings and the comfort ofits
‘occupants. Based on fleldwork carried out in Ghadames city in August, 1991, it
attempts to establish the diferent responses of traditional and modem housing
to the hot-cty climate of Libya.
INTRODUCTION
Climate is an important aspect of lite
periculary in counties with hokdry
climates such as Libya, where people face
a variety of problems related to climate
especialy in modern housing. Ghadames
city provides a good example of the
contrast between tradtional and modem
houses. though Ghadames is one of the
coldest cities in Libya, its buildings remain
wall maintained, and still ved in, This
provides the opportunity to compare and
contrast the performance of the
architecture of the old town with that of
the new town in order to understand the
fradiional techniques for maintaining
thermal comfort in ari climatic condtons
and the weaknesses of contemporary
race,
‘Tho oasis of Ghadames is located in the
Libyan Sahara Desert. It les 630 km.
south-west of Tipo, close tothe junction
with the borders of Algeria and Tunisia
stated at an altiude of 350. motors
above sea level
In the new city areas, modem bulcings
Predominate, and because of the shortage
of housing, most people are compelled to
2
live in whatever modem dwelings are considered appropriate for both the
‘available, whether they are climatcally climate, as well as for the social
salstactory o nt. conditions, The modem architecture of
the international style which has
(ominated the new developments is
generally considered inapproprate,
partcularly because it was introduced
‘without consideration forthe local climate
‘or forthe cultural needs ofthe population
Traditional houses in Ghadames have
evolved in response to alimate, reducing
the effect of the hostile desert climate
conditions. The main concer of the
masons was to modity extremes of air
‘temperature, and 10 protect the
inhabitants fom solar radiation and glare
as well as rom sand and dust.
‘The aim ofthe study isto demonstrate the
differing responses of the modem and
tradional buildings as to the hotdry
climate and to discover the factors which
influence their performance.
In order to cary out the investigation, the
author spent sity days in Ghademes from
July to August curing the summer of 1881
Information was collected about the
macro-cimate of the city, the micro-
climate of selected buildings, and people's
response to climate. The study was
divided into two parts: climatic condtons
in Ghadames, and housing design in
GGhadames. These are summarised In order to assess the climatic comfort, sx
below: houses were chosen for in depth
investigation, The folowing analysis
House Decichs examines the six selected houses in the
did and new town, and demonstrates the
eee factors which have influenced their
The aim of this survey i to identify the climatic perfomance. The case studies
tradtional_ and modem architecture of Were selected on the basis of their
Ghadames cy and to compare ther feptesenttveness for the specif areas.
appropriateness. for the local climatic The thee areas namely the southemn,
condiions and ways of life. While rival and northern parts ofboth the old
tradtional architecture is generally andthe new town, show dierent
FORUH Vol2 1998‘Tho Impact of Hot-Dry Climate on Housing
protect the occupants ftom the direct
sunshine In this house, habitable rooms
are found on the ground floor, as well as
‘on the other levels. However, during the
summer nights people always use the root
as a living area, enjoying the cool night
breeze,
‘Sample two
This house is stuated in the centr ofthe
town, in Tangzin neighdouthood, within a
Figure 1. Zamoet House in the Old Town
conditions, and the case studies are
aimed at illustrating these_ differences,
paricularyin the old town.
THE DESIGN OF
TRADITIONAL HOUSES
In order to evaluate the climatic
performance of traltional dwelings tree
houses were selected for examination, in
hich climatic conditions were measured.
‘These three houses, which are typical of
the tradtional dwelings, are described
below.
‘Sample one
This house is stated in the south of the
town in the Auld Bll neighbourhood. I is
located within a plot area of 31. square
meters and has a covered floor area of
about 64 square meters. The house is
three storeys high (Fig. 1)
From the section A-A in figure. we notice:
the main enrance of the house opens on
to the public street which is uncovered,
but the high walls onthe other side of the
narow sitet generally keep it shady, to
FORUM Vol2 1998
Figure 2. Maghora House in the Old
Town
bultwup area and has a plot area of about
26.50 square meters and a total floor atea
of about 80 square meters. It is four
storeys high (Ig. 2).
From section A-Ain figure we notice: the
main entrance of the house, opening off
‘he public testis completely covered, in
‘ardor to maintain the temperature a8 cool
as possible. One of the important aspects
of his house is that he entre area ofthe
round tloor is organised for storage
purposes, Living areas are stuated on
the fist, mezzanine, and second floors.
However, during summer nights, people
sleep on the root, enjoying cool night
breezes,
Sample three
“This house is stuated tothe north ofthe
town in Mazigh neighbourhood within a
Plot area of 25 square meters and with a
‘covered floor area of about 75 square
meters. Its four storeys high and there is
‘a courtyard to one side. Part ofthe house
is also bul over the stret (Fig. 3).
From section A‘Ain gure. we notice that
the main entrance ofthe house opens off
the public street which is also completely
covered to maintain the temperature as
cool as possible. The wiole ofthe ground
floor accommodation is used for storage
purposes. The living area is situated on
the fst floor, mazzanine floor and te top
floor during the summer.
From the observation of the thee
tratitonal houses several pois were
‘noted. Mud is the main material for bah
roofs and walls. All he rooms are it and
ventlated in diferent ways, The windows,
Figure 3. EL Athany House inthe Okt
Town
3‘Abubaker Shawesh
Which are smal, open on to interior light
wells, shady oF covered seats. Their
opening size is not more than 50 by 0
centimetres, located at a high love, near
the celing are colour washed in white to
keep the interior ofthe house as cool as,
possible; the walls ate thick as well
Moreover, it was found that air-
conditioning is hardy used in these
houses,
‘THE DESIGN OF
MODERN HOUSES
The three houses of modem design,
Uihich were selected for investigation, in
which climatic conditions were measured,
are described below:
Sample one
‘This house is situated inthe south ofthe
‘ew tow within a plot area of about 232
square meters. It has about 187 square
meters of floor area. IL is one story high
‘The house cecupies the whole width of
the plot, and is built up tothe boundary of
the plot. Thore is @ small garden at the
‘ear of he house (Fig 4).
From the section AVA, in figure itis
noticed that: the main entrance opens
rectly to outside and has no protection
from the sunshine and wind, which
increases the interior air temperature. It Is
found that inthis house, many diferent
styles and systems of construction do not
sut the way of ife of the residents
Sample two
‘This house is situated in the middle of the
new town within a plot area of about 164
square meters and a floor area of 168
‘square meters tis two storeys high. The
house occupies the whole width of the
Plot, and is built up tothe front boundary
of the plot. There isa small garden atthe
rear of house and a kichen yard (Fig. 8).
Figure 4. EL. Mahal House in the New
Town
44
Figure 5. Abdul Salam House inthe New
Town
From section AA, in figure it can be
noticed that: the main entrance opens
rectly to the outside, facing the wide,
asphalt pubic street. The ground floor is
organised as @ main ling area, and tho
fist floor is used as a sleeping area
However, there is no separate storage
area,
Sample three
‘This house is situated tothe north of the
‘ew town within a plot area of about 102
‘square meters and a floor area of about
170 square meters. It fs of two storeys
Figure 6. Abdul Rahman House inthe
New Town
high The house cccupies the whole
Width of the pot, and is built up to the
front boundary ofthe pot. There i a small
garden, and a small kichen yard (Fig. 6)
From the section A-A, in figure tis
noticeable that: the main entrance opens
on fo the wider uncovered street, which
causes an increase in the interior
temperature. All ving areas are
istrbuted between the ground floor and
the fist flor. There is no separate storage
area. The rooms are it and ventlated
through the windows which open drecty
‘onto the exterior space
From the observation ofthe thee madern
houses we natice that: concrete is used as.
‘the main materi! fr bth rots and walls
All the modem houses are lit and
ventiated through large windows opening