Niquisha Keys
Professor Suwak
English 1020
10/30/17
A Social/ Historical Analysis of The Birthmark By: Nathaniel Hawthorne
One of the greatest influences on Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “The Birthmark” is
found in his hometown of Salem, Massachusetts. During the 17 century Puritans
colonized New England, which included Massachusetts. Nathaniel Hawthorne’s
great-great grandfather was John Hathome, a Massachusetts Bay Colony judge
(Hawthorne Life). John Hathorne was a Puritan whose goal was to purify the
Catholic church; he strictly followed the bible and ruthlessly punished those who
did not (Hawthorne Life). John Hathome was notoriously remembered by
Nathaniel Hawthorne for his role in the Salem Witch Trials.
The Salem Witch Trials was a Series of Trials held by Puritans in Salem,
Massachusetts to prosecute suspected witches that bewitched the Puritan
community with their supernatural powers (Crocker). Puritans such as John
Hathorne believed that prosecuting suspected witches proved that they were loyal
servants of God. Beliefs of Puritans included the need to purify the people who do
not literally follow the Bible and the idea that Puritans “glorify and do the will of
God” (Crier). Through the Salem Witch Trials, Puritans believed that they were
doing the work of god by ridding New England of the supernatural. The bibleitaly preaches against the supernatural such as in Leviticus 19:31 and
Deuteronomy 18:9-13; these Bible verses tell Christians not to seek out the
supernatural and that supernatural creatures are abominations (“35 Bible Verses
about Supernatural”). However, the Puritans soon began to overstep their
boundaries by playing God. Puritans used witches to explain and to control their
“visible world”; if'a suspected witch was imprisoned, Puritans believed that Indian
attacks would stop, and the winter would not be as cold (Crocker). Nathaniel
Hawthomne felt guilty about the unethical actions of John Hathome, and about the
lack of consequences John Hathorne faced for his role as a Salem Judge during the
time (Hawthome Life). In “The Birthmark”, Nathaniel Hawthome examines the
negative consequences of attempting to exert control over nature through his
criticism of Puritanism and alchemy.
Nathaniel Hawthome did not agree with Puritan views on Nature
(“Hawthorne life”). Due to the many hardships aboard the Mayflower and their
first year in Massachusetts, Puritans believed that “Nature was against humans”
(Crocker). Through their faith, Puritans believed they could overcome hardships by
controlling the force of nature through their creation of witches. Nathaniel
Hawthome’s “The Birthmark” illustrates how Aylmer attempted to control nature
in a way similar to the Puritans in Salem, Massachusetts, Aylmer believed that
nature created Georgiana perfect accept for her birthmark; he thought thebirthmark was “the fatal flaw of humanity which Nature... stamps ineffaceably on
all her creations” (Hawthorne, 213). Aylmer believed that the birthmark
symbolizes Georgiana’s “liability to sin, sorrow, decay, and death” (Hawthome,
213), Aylmer attempted to purify Georgina of her humanity by removing the mark
from her face to correct “what Nature left imperfect in her fairest work”
(Hawthome,215). Aylmer wanted a physically perfect wife that was not
constrained by her human nature, so he wanted to go against nature and remove the
birthmark to remove her mortality and ability to sin (Hawthome 214). However, by
attempting to remove Georgiana’s symbolized humanity, Aylmer takes her life as
well. He fails to realize that Georgiana cannot live without her Nature given
humanity, for that is what makes her human.
Aylmer wanted ultimate control over Nature, so he attempted to change and
perfect the work of Nature using Alchemy. Alchemy is a sub category of
Chemistry that focuses on the sublime and almost magical reactions of Chemistry.
‘The nfairy goals of alchemists were to purify and perfect elements to make them
more valuable and to create the elixir of life (Cite). In The Birthmark” Hawthorne
mentions famous medieval natural philosophers such as Albertus Magnus,
Agrippa, and Paracelsus; Aylmer thought it was dangerous for Georgiana to read
the works of these philosophers due to the power he believed they had. Aylmer
thought the works of these philosophers were dangerous due to the “power above