BISHOP'S SIMPLIFIED METHOD

SOIL 1 SOIL 2
Su = 25 Su = 70
Ɣsat = 18 Ɣsat = 18.5
ɸ'cs = 28 ° ɸ'cs = 22 ° Ɣw 10

Find the depth of the crack

Zcr = 2.778

h b Area W Wtotal Wcosα Wsinα hw u

Slice (m) α
(m) (m2) (Ɣ * b* h) (soil 1+soil2) (Ɣw * hw)
1 1.4 4 5.6 100.8 100.8 32 85.483248 53.41586 1 10
2 3.6 4 14.4 259.2 259.2 18 246.51385 80.0972 3.2 32
3 6.4 4 25.6 460.8 460.8 7 457.36527 56.15739 5.4 54
4 8.6 4 34.4 619.2 619.2 8 613.17399 86.17598 6.8 68
5 9.8 4 39.2 705.6 705.6 18 671.06548 218.0424 7.2 72
6 8.2 4 32.8 590.4 590.4 32 500.6876 312.8643 6.2 62
7 3.6 3.8 13.68 246.24 246.24 48 164.76672 182.992 4 40

2739.0561 989.7452

BISHOP'S SIMPLIFIED METHOD

SOIL 1 SOIL 2
Su = 25 Su = 70 Zs 7
Ɣsat = 18 KN/m3 Ɣsat = 18.5 KN/m3
ɸ'cs = 28 ° ɸ'cs = 22 ° Ɣw 9.8

Find the depth of the crack tan(ɸ' 28°) 0.531709

 Zcr = 2.778

Without Tension Crack FS 0.97 Asumsi

z b W Zw ru
Slice (m) α cos α sin α mj Wsinα
(m) (Ɣ*b*z) (m) (Ɣw*zw)/(Ɣ*z)
1 1.4 4 100.8 1 0.3889 -31 0.857 -0.515 1.740 -51.916
2 3.6 4 259.2 3.2 0.4840 -18 0.951 -0.309 1.279 -80.097
3 6.4 4 460.8 5.4 0.4594 -4 0.998 -0.070 1.042 -32.144
4 8.6 4 619.2 6.8 0.4305 6 0.995 0.105 0.951 64.724
5 9.8 4 705.6 7.2 0.4000 18 0.951 0.309 0.893 218.042
6 8.2 4 590.4 6.2 0.4117 30 0.866 0.500 0.877 295.200
7 3.6 3.8 246.24 4 0.6049 48 0.669 0.743 0.929 182.992

SUM 596.80157
FS

Tension Crack FS 0.95 Asumsi

z b W Zw ru
Slice (m) α cos α sin α mj Wsinα
(m) (Ɣ*b*z) (m) (Ɣw*zw)/(Ɣ*z)
1 1.4 4 100.8 1 0.3889 -31 0.857 -0.515 1.758 -51.916
2 3.6 4 259.2 3.2 0.4840 -18 0.951 -0.309 1.285 -80.097
3 6.4 4 460.8 5.4 0.4594 -4 0.998 -0.070 1.043 -32.144
4 8.6 4 619.2 6.8 0.4305 6 0.995 0.105 0.950 64.724
5 9.8 4 705.6 7.2 0.4000 18 0.951 0.309 0.890 218.042
6 8.2 4 590.4 6.2 0.4117 30 0.866 0.500 0.873 295.200
7 3.6 3.8 246.24 4 0.6049 48 0.669 0.743 0.922 182.992

SUM 596.80157
FS
R = 13 m
TCM /R = 102.9774

Tension Crack filled with water FS 0.9 Asumsi

z b W Zw ru
Slice (m) α cos α sin α mj Wsinα
(m) (Ɣ*b*z) (m) (Ɣw*zw)/(Ɣ*z)
1 1.4 4 100.8 1 0.3889 -31 0.857 -0.515 1.809 -51.916
2 3.6 4 259.2 3.2 0.4840 -18 0.951 -0.309 1.301 -80.097
3 6.4 4 460.8 5.4 0.4594 -4 0.998 -0.070 1.046 -32.144
4 8.6 4 619.2 6.8 0.4305 6 0.995 0.105 0.947 64.724
5 9.8 4 705.6 7.2 0.4000 18 0.951 0.309 0.882 218.042
6 8.2 4 590.4 6.2 0.4117 30 0.866 0.500 0.861 295.200
7 3.6 3.8 246.24 4 0.6049 48 0.669 0.743 0.902 182.992

SUM 596.80157
FS

TCM = 1338.7059899
COMPARE
FS
CONDITION
ESA TSA
Without Tension Crack 1.467 1.316
Tension Crack 1.465 1.316
Tension Crack filled with water 1.461 1.316
 l u*l
(b/cosα)
4.716714 2.73
4.205849 2.73
4.030039 2.73
4.03931 274.6731
4.205849 302.82112
4.716714 292.43624
5.679011 227.16044

1105.2809

KN/m3
 TSA
ESA
Su b/cosα
56.97741 116.663
90.98683 105.146
138.0754 100.244
178.2644 100.551
200.9063 105.146
161.9982 115.470
48.04946 141.975

875.2581 785.196
1.467 1.316

TSA
ESA
Su b/cosα
57.57268 116.663
91.40382 105.146
138.1914 100.244
178.0602 100.551
200.2689 105.146
161.1825 115.470
47.6697 141.975

874.3492 785.196
1.465 1.316

TSA
ESA
Su b/cosα
59.2403 116.663
92.54666 105.146
138.5048 100.244
177.5123 100.551
198.5714 105.146
159.0249 115.470
46.6757 141.975

872.076 785.196
1.461 1.316
7.11477401 trase 3
7.20127993 trase 4