Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A
cne vulgaris is an extremely common cipitated sulphur cream that contained ben- interleukin-1a (IL-1a) was able to induce
and distressing condition that affects over zoyl peroxide.8 During the 1970s the range of comedonal features such as hyperproliferation
90 per cent of adolescents between the potential uses for benzoyl peroxide increased and abnormal differentiation in isolated pi-
age of 16 and 18 years.1 Of these, approxi- and Kligman et al9 have described the use of losebaceous follicles. In an in vivo study by
mately 15 per cent require medical interven- benzoyl peroxide in the treatment of athlete’s Aldana et al,20 comedones were found to con-
tion.2 Furthermore, research has shown that foot and tinea versicolor. Benzoyl peroxide tain sufficient IL-1a to initiate a non-specific
acne has a negative impact on patients’ qual- has also been used to treat leg ulcers10,11 and inflammatory response if released into the
ity of life that is comparable to that caused by was shown to be of some benefit in patients dermis. However, what remains unclear is the
conditions such as asthma and epilepsy.3 with seborrhoeic dermatitis.12 Today, benzoyl specific trigger for increased production of
Although predominately a teenage problem, peroxide is mainly used in the treatment of 1L-1a. It has been suggested by Jeremy18 that
acne can and does persist into adult life and mild to moderate acne and is often prescribed since follicular keratinocytes in acne are
still affects roughly 1 per cent of women and in conjunction with oral antibiotics in the known to be deficient in the essential fatty
5 per cent of men at the age of 40 years.4 treatment of moderate to severe acne. acid linolenic acid, this could provide the
There is a wide range of over-the-counter In order to understand how benzoyl per- necessary trigger for the increased production
products available to treat acne. In many of oxide works, it is necessary to review the of IL-1a. If these studies are correct, it might
these preparations, benzoyl peroxide is a com- pathophysiology of acne. explain the action of many anti-inflammatory
mon ingredient. Unfortunately, benzoyl per- acne therapies and strengthen the argument
oxide-based products are often rejected by Pathophysiology of acne vulgaris that patients should apply treatment, not just
patients after a few days’ use, once their skin Although the precise cause of acne is unclear to the inflamed lesions but to the whole of
starts to flake or become inflamed.These side it appears to be associated with at least four the acne-prone area.
effects are so common that patients who factors: increased sebum production, follicular Finally, what is the role of the skin bac-
claim not to experience them are likely to be keratinisation, bacterial colonisation and in- terium Propionibacterium acnes in acne? As
non-compliant. Compliance is further re- flammation.13 Of these, sebum excretion is noted by Bojar and Holland21 “there is no for-
duced by the bleaching effects on clothing, under genetic control as shown by the simi- mal proof linking P acnes with acne”. In a
towels and bed-linen. Nevertheless, providing larity of sebum excretion rates in identical study by Graham et al,22 it was shown that vi-
patients with adequate advice and informa- twins, postulating the mechanism of a genet- able P acnes species were able to induce ker-
tion about these side effects and how to min- ically mediated elevation of circulating an- atinocytes to produce IL-1a and other agents
imise them usually results in greater drogens.14 Acne is a disease of the such as tumour necrosis factor in vitro. P acnes
perseverance with treatment and ultimately pilosebaceous follicle and, during adoles- therefore might have a contributory role in
an improvement in their acne. cence, there is an increase in the production comedogenesis through induction of IL-1a
This article reviews the evidence for the of sex hormones (mainly androgens) that within keratinocytes. In addition, there is
benefits of benzoyl peroxide and provides stimulate the sebaceous glands to produce some evidence that the bacterium has T-cell
useful advice and tips for pharmacists to con- more sebum. Indeed, there is a direct rela- mitogenic activity23 and such activity may
vey to patients using such products to ensure tionship between the degree of seborrhoea contribute to inflammation via activation of
that they derive maximum benefit from it. and the severity of the acne15 and sebum itself T cells and the release of immunological cy-
is comedogenic (comedone-forming) and tokines. The mechanism through which P
History of benzoyl peroxide causes inflammation if cutaneously injected.16 acnes is able to stimulate cells to release cy-
Benzoyl peroxide is not a new drug. As early The epithelial cells lining the pilosebaceous tokines appears to be mediated through acti-
as 1905 Loevenhart and Kastle described the follicle are normally desquamated (shed) and vation of toll-like receptor 2 (TLR2) on the
use of benzoyl peroxide in research on pota- carried to the surface of the skin in the surface of cells.24 The TLRs, of which several
toes5 and Loevenhart also noted the benefits sebum. In acne, there is an increase in the types have been identified, are pattern recog-
on burns and chronic varicose leg tumours. production of epithelial cells lining the folli- nition receptors on the surface of cells that
In 1929, the value of benzoyl peroxide in cle, a process termed “ductal hypercornifica- can mediate an immune response to bacterial
treating wounds and burns was reported by tion”, which can lead to the blockage of the ligands. Indeed, activation of the TLR2 sug-
Lyon and Reynolds6 and, in 1934, benzoyl follicle. When the blockage occurs close to gests that this is a primary mechanism re-
peroxide was shown to be effective in a case the surface of the skin, pigment in the sponsible for the inflammatory changes in
of acne vulgaris.7 By 1948 there were many desquamated cells reacts with the atmosphere acne.
benzoyl peroxide products available for treat- and turns black.This produces an open come-
ing wounds and varicose leg ulcers. However, done or blackhead, which is the primary acne Mode of action of benzoyl peroxide
the use of the drug in acne was not explored lesion.17 The mechanism that initiates hyper- Benzoyl peroxide has both comedolytic and
in any detail until the 1960s when William cornification is now thought to be an inflam- antibacterial effects. Evidence for the
Pace began treating acne patients with a pre- matory process. Research by Jeremy et al18 comedolytic effect comes from several stud-
demonstrated the presence of significant in- ies.Work with experimentally induced come-
Rod Tucker, PhD, MRPharmS, is flammatory factors such as CD3+ and CD4+ dones by Oh and Myung25 and Kaidbey and
a pharmacist at HMP Hull. Shernaz Walton, T cells and large macrophages around clini- Kligman26 both demonstrated that 5 per cent
MD, FRCP, is consultant dermatologist at Hull cally normal follicles before hypercornifica- benzoyl peroxide was an effective
and East Yorkshire Hospitals NHS Trust tion. In addition, Guy and Kealey19 observed comedolytic. Kligman et al27 have also shown
(e-mail rodtucker@rodtucker.karoo.co.uk) that in vitro, the pro-inflammatory cytokine that benzoyl peroxide can reduce the size of
Effectiveness of benzoyl peroxide Swinyer et al51 More than 20 facial BP 5% gel v clindamycin 1%. Greater reduction in total lesions by BP.
One extensive review of the literature on the RDB; n=60 lesions, face only
management of acne in 200137 found that, of 12 weeks
250 comparisons, only 14 had level A evi-
dence (ie, based on at least two trials of ac- Milani et al52 Mild – moderate acne BP 4% gel v hydrogen peroxide 1%. No difference in reduction of lesions
ceptable quality with good statistical and RDB; n=60 (defined), face only however, hydrogen peroxide gel had better tolerability profile.
meaningful clinical outcomes). This review 8 weeks
concluded that benzoyl peroxide is superior
Hughes et al53 Mild – moderate acne BP 5% gel v isotretinoin gel 0.05% v placebo. BP effective earlier than
to vehicle or placebo. A second, more recent RDB; n=77 (defined), face only isotretinoin and had a greater effect on inflamed lesions. Little difference in
systematic review using more rigid inclusion 12 weeks adverse effects.
criteria looked at well designed randomised
controlled trials from 1966 to 200438 and Chalker et al54 Grade III (defined), BP 5%/erythromycin 3% combination v 5% BP gel v 3% erythromycin gel v
identified only one clinical trial involving RBD; n=165 face only vehicle gel. Combination not different to BP for comedone reduction or for
benzoyl peroxide. A search of PubMed using 10 weeks papules and pustules.
the terms “acne vulgaris” and “benzoyl per-
oxide” identified several studies. The refer-