Marx on India: A Clarification ‘Thee isa laege and by now ol dono des the ous of empice a wall the sof Kerra be lowland he pert perils sites, schol and schol clipe. to other word, the body of ‘na au he mid 1970, i by people who wer the ‘Manas emacs ar were ke pepe to ace det ae With Mari poionon tof clay and epic: mach el werk it ind cote robe doe ven cy, Wich intra hla, he ‘8 ech smpleminds! snd propagandic. Dizi by the pre rite isasale cullen, ho he oabalay ao ‘ois, ane aw dace tht wo of at hind ws oo psi, oo eet Tete of ing word ke spl ‘ply conaiated with rpc, hiram, the poblenatic of tem nd repmsentlty, the metic el rin, a0, Telus bean Er Sit'sachicwmen ore rough chi gion of ‘altar prism othe very ene ofthe ongoing trary dees in ‘he mrp university by pig it in enn tha wre epee) 4d, eee Metal pte had co cncae bth et he knew itSpec ed is Avshc wel hey di a hare crsay was ot ‘popaganditic inthe way he 19608 radical usull wer. Ono Said’ orale conto co the Armaan Tf, ct, eat he, orp the ie sea avatar ey. Te age of eu Tena coeienle net, ugh beeeryone who wrote fm be Macs rion war ely edit. And ee ceri is gues, ‘Muon sd the eostacton o 4 whole ea pp fr deng ontenoler inl of ancl, I ei Seid can among the Ee, pte of ted The Marae avon hd een notably a ‘cuore tae tat is pecs what Ii Been wn — ot with he Nicesceeo ileus ut with antnperis ise. Ke abd ve bean Niche and gow nes do sme doi growin w ‘masa pdton mera wi tht option co colonia submerge i es pean yeh of pope’ i leas ery cote Juco fei thes and he hi which Mex wn fo he New Yer Tene 835 and wei are he est antidote he Bis Rein tit ond “The Face Reuitfehe Bish ale in ‘th uncosiosfon!pdiae,rbd thee 0 eideninOia Tm eat he hs come egal ha w= npr psig fe so consider ogaganen: wth Mar’ anya high complex writings tn cloilism attach andon she enebuner between nomexpial a ‘pile sili. This i cen in Keeping with Sid's carci ‘lly ear wy with author and ett, bat Ne ain we Sheri Gam the es tha by now ay faa pred in Sling wich ar'swiing on aoa," arsine ants then Combine in ey cou wap mith nde 0 ~ pos igcence ot ow te comple ie to by Mane’ epee wings on Inia ave eval toon eo inthe seach of key Taig historians thesis tafe th ante yy of Ranjit Guha, Wh tis trae suet tin ner Maras tg Ini oe wha nda eelankip asd sy oat hat wring i ely wrth knowing ay deal the ise f Indian clan is nf er Soagetion Ti, et i uit, One woud fave dough ta soe csi of ta “Oral” igh wel be oe tring cindy hme ancien Inn iris who have ben onus with Eampe asin ege asprin, Ligh by rekooing schs the lee of Mars ring lino evi the Trang on the he scope of he preset snpurent, Rater, [aul ket cine S's uray wa of dealing, pet har would be ‘ola tgp nda, eared caros et ths rca Sts oncom on hi meri ohaharative and inde ste he pce in hi rte of Naya uma ar een ik the ceo Ascy sed De othe pees chapter he dc ieee, eve contedity, dictions, The gr sion othe ok a which Ss cron oa Mar te cecld culy dese with Engh an Bench icy cls inthe Near fur ~ Edvard Yane, Neva, Fabs, Lana, Baro, ad sv wins rough back the form oferetogue, ton, pi, linguiscc Knowledge, so my Twa thes, thefre Tow’ Mare ayeee etna rem seca a, epving a ow, it iobviosy re th aii did nang ws evn Whar bough wwe, ped,» aon-revouiony and reonnde ‘ecient cea, ina el stagnation etna ic wel ren) ao dye mare 0 costa an os (0 tne fmpasibe viable coin pun the ncaching cli ome Tike, ules tut th heap of Ain a onchanig, ‘eg’ place was pat ofthe Inbred world-view i sorte orope nl bo lowed by auch gre of the alge “nesses an Monnet rae ~Agh ad des te eu theme fe ead elcid vilage comms hace oda Mars valid, ali verb, ov oF Hegel Al his ad Ico ete rhe Tale, yee pi by Petry Adenia as Lie of te Abin St (973) whe hcl wisely wile Oia fv being ate, Sas conebusion Was one ha he poised coals Thre beh esi! ised, Literal sion Got sa ‘he Rowan) bere sine a hrc of sal as we sale pct Ta tt hexorc, mse, th lly was o or ee coe vcs of Me's though or sequal re tht Mae's densi of reclonial sxesyin ada m ove ident than is ents of pe’ own feu pat or of the Abolcic monarchies, oof ch ‘Ger barges hissy Geran re cresy itesnay. His dies comment bout the power ofthe cate rptem in te Indien village — ‘eamitig) tie hut mind within the salle pole compas, raking i the uarsising tol of pension, enlving fe both the ‘nao us, depsving ic ofall grander and bis eeie ae essary os rng mireinthe nyo rl end ec oc, the ‘the nd of he wl age refried wigs Indi ‘anning grimy ceca a nel he ape the weet ina oe «dnote conesivance sop and eee henity 6 Amber pci the pice Te tcl ht dear a Sips he ners af the nda pear, att yea fe sean mankind fl Genny without vlucion {nec exe of Amy bce o he ponte ind enue of epic eli from the ‘human ibrtinn, bu is surely na genertd by the kind fact Said series eo Mor, weal oa se ee lo wath ealing hatte As Win trfomacen wil veo tke plein Asan cee In oder co mk ta ibetion ple — have ben po pan aa ‘gain in carom cenrary: doggedly Chi, Kee, the dah ounei, bur sain hone evalua cei whch wae deed Indonesia, che Philippines, India, ° ” Tatler th ot acy, ack, in Mae’sudgnene cerey. Ne eG epron othe aye Bina ct trode codon wu scan a eo) oc tor ngin te Pon tens it Orly che rmetbabloial ene wat mde af sheghr wit cane pase nny view, the atngemte silos of toe denen Belo 30 alogeter dent hen poblemace or dcoure, mS che term: The en «ein progressive reo ol