Professional Documents
Culture Documents
M.S. Tian, S. Prakash, H.J. Elgar, H. Young, D.M. Burmeister & G.S. Ross
The Horticulture and Food Research Institute of New Zealand Ltd., Mt Albert Research Centre, Private Bag 92169,
Auckland, New Zealand
Key words: ethylene production, Fragaria ananassa, ionic conductivity, 1-MCP, peroxidase, respiration, ripening
index, strawberry
Abstract
1-Methylcyclopropene (1-MCP), a competitive inhibitor of ethylene action, binds to the ethylene receptor to
regulate tissue responses to ethylene. In this work, we investigated the effects of 1-MCP and exogenous ethyl-
ene on ripening, respiration rate, ionic conductivity and peroxidase activity in strawberry fruit. Strawberry fruit
can ripen without exogenous ethylene treatment, but exogenous ethylene induces secondary ripening processes.
Results indicated that stimulation of respiration by ethylene was dose-dependent. Fruit colour development
and softening were slightly accelerated by ethylene, but changes in soluble solid content were not. 1-MCP
may/may not affect the respiratory rise induced by exogenous ethylene dependent on fruit maturity. Cyclo-
heximide (CHI) reduced the ethylene-induced respiratory increase. Combinations of 1-MCP and CHI reduced
respiration more than CHI alone. 1-MCP and CHI did not influence the primary respiratory change in non
ethylene-treated fruit. This indicates that ethylene induced respiratory increase may involve an ethylene receptor
in early harvested fruit, but not in later harvested fruit. Exogenous ethylene stimulated respiration by regulating
new respiratory enzyme(s) synthesis in strawberry fruit. Ethylene induced an ionic leakage increase, and this
was positively correlated to fruit water loss and peroxidase activity. These results suggest that non-climacteric
fruit, such as strawberry, may have different ethylene receptor(s) and/or ethylene receptor(s) may have different
regulatory functions. It may be the secondary effect of ethylene to stimulate respiration in strawberry. Non-
climacteric fruit ripening may be related to the development of active oxygen species (AOS) induced by postharvest
stress.
Abbreviations: ACC – 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid; AOS – active oxygen species; CHI – cyclohexim-
ide; 1-MCP – 1-methylcyclopentene
the respiration rate [6, 24], although the effect is 2. Materials and methods
reversible and is dependent on continuously elevated
levels of endogenous or exogenous ethylene. Little 2.1 Plant material
work has been done to investigate the mechanism of
these different respiratory responses to ethylene in the Strawberry fruit (Fragaria ananassa Duch. cv. Pajaro)
two types of fruit. Although a number of ripening- were harvested at the pink stage during the summer
related genes from strawberry have been reported seasons of 1996 to 1998 from a local grower property
[8, 21], to our knowledge no ethylene receptor has in Auckland, New Zealand. Fruit were harvested only
been isolated from any non-climacteric fruit. An in the late season (November-December) in 1996 and
ethylene signal transduction pathway is in operation 1997, and both early (October) and late during 1998.
however, as evidenced by the effects on respiration Fruit were transported to the Mt. Albert Research
and other work showing ethylene-enhanced straw- Centre. To compare rates of fresh weight loss and
berry fruit softening and reduced storage life [4, 22, relative ionic conductivity for fruit of various harvest
23]. maturities, fruit were harvested at the green, white,
1-Methylcyclopropene (1-MCP) is a competitive pink and red stages.
inhibitor of ethylene action which binds to the ethyl-
ene receptor to regulate tissue responses to ethylene 2.2 1-MCP treatments
[9, 14]. 1-MCP has been used as a tool to investig-
ate ethylene action and tissue responses to ethylene Fruit were placed in 10 L sealed jars, and treated with
during climacteric fruit ripening and flower senes- 1-MCP (2 µl L−1 ) for 18 h before being vented to air.
cence [15]. Application of 1-MCP delays ripening
of banana, apple and tomato, and flower senescence 2.3 Inhibitors of protein synthesis
[10, 11, 15, 16], presumably via its blocking effect After 1-MCP treatment, fruit were dipped in a 0.4 M
on the ethylene signal transduction pathway. A pho- mannitol solution containing cycloheximide (50 µg
tolysed derivative of DACP, an other ethylene action ml−1 ) for 0.5 h, and then dried on paper.
inhibitor used in earlier trials of this nature [18, 19].
In our laboratory, we studied the effects of DACP 2.4 Ethylene/propylene treatments
on ethylene-induced respiratory rises in strawberry
[19]. This work indicates that ethylene biosynthesis in In an experiment investigating ethylene dose effect
nonclimacteric strawberry fruit may be regulated by on respiration rate, each replicate of four fruits was
ethylene receptor(s) with inhibition of ethylene pro- placed in a 600 ml jar (n = 4), and flushed with an
duction. DACP may release this inhibitory effect, and air flow of 50 ml min−1 containing various concen-
resulting in increased ethylene production. Respira- trations of exogenous ethylene, at levels of 0 (air),
tion in strawberry fruit may not be regulated by an 0.5, 1, 5, 20, 50 or 100 µl L−1 . In other experi-
ethylene receptor at most stages of maturity. Present ments, fruit were treated with 50 µl L−1 ethylene at
work did not investigate differences of the responses a continuous flow rate of 50 ml min−1 (with air as the
to 1-MCP and ethylene in fruit harvested at early and control).
later seasons. It is possible that they have different
sensitivities and responses to ethylene. 2.5 Colour, firmness and soluble solids content
Here we report further investigations on the role
of ethylene in strawberry ripening and respiration. We Fruit skin colour was measured with a Minolta CR300
used 1-MCP as a tool to investigate whether exogen- reflectance Chroma Meter (Minolta Camera Co. Ltd.,
ous ethylene binds to the receptor to induce the res- Osaka, Japan). The ‘a’ and ‘b’ values on the ‘Lab’
piratory rise and to affect ripening in strawberry fruit. mode were used as indices of colour changes from
We also used cycloheximide to determine whether the pink to red. Colour was measured at two opposite
ethylene effects are the result of new protein syn- points around the equator on each fruit. Fruit firmness
thesis, and measured changes in ionic conductivity (N) was assessed using an Imada penetrometer (PSM-
and peroxidase activity in ethylene-treated strawberry 10, Imada Co. Ltd., Toyohashi, Japan) fitted with a flat
fruit as markers for the progression of ripening and as round 13.16 mm diameter head. The head was pushed
indicators of tissue stress. into the strawberry flesh through the skin to the depth
85
Figure 2. Respiration rate (ml.kg−1 .h−1 ) of (A–D) early- and (E–H) late-harvested pink strawberry fruit in ethylene (100 µl L−1 ) after being
treated with 1-MCP (2 µl L−1 ) and CHI(1 mM). A and E, –MC, –CHI; B and F, –MCP, +CHI; C and G, +MCP, –CHI; D and H, +MCP, +CHI.
The a/b ratio of skin colour and soluble solids content 1 Different letters represented significant differences at the 5%
increased, and firmness decreased significantly after level (n = 16).
harvest in the control fruit (air) at 20 ◦ C (Tables 1 &
2). Exogenous ethylene appeared to accelerate colour
development and softening, without affecting soluble ‘a’ value for these fruit. The decrease in fruit firmness
solids content. The enhancement of colour develop- was greater in fruit treated with ethylene at concen-
ment and softening depended on ethylene concentra- trations over 0.5 µl L−1 . No significant difference in
tion and duration of exposure (Table 1). After treat- soluble solid content was evident in fruit treated with
ment for three days, the a/b ratios were significantly different concentrations of ethylene. Again, ethylene
greater in fruit treated with higher concentrations of at 50 µl L−1 significantly enhanced the a/b ratio and
ethylene (>40 µl L−1 ) than with lower concentrations accelerated softening in the control fruit (Table 2),
(Table 1). This was mainly due to the increase in the but did not change soluble solids content. 1-MCP,
87
Table 2. Colour (a/b ratio), firmness (Kg) and soluble solids content (%) in strawberry
fruit harvested at the pink stage and treated with 1-MCP (2 µl L−1 ), cycloheximide
(CHI, 1 mM) and ethylene (50 µl L−1 )
Figure 4. Changes in ion conductivity (%) in ethylene -treated (100 µl L−1 ) strawberry fruit harvested at the pink stage.
Table 3. Peroxidase activity (1A485 .g−1 FW.min−1 ) in and ethylene production were not recovered by applic-
propylene–treated (0.5%) pink strawberry fruit (n = 4)
ation of exogenous ethylene [16]. It was hypothesised
Days at 20 ◦ C Air Ethylene that ethylene may bind to metal in the reactive or
catalytic centers of enzymes to stimulate their activ-
1 1.66 1.66 ities [15]. Ethylene binds to the receptor, then diffuses
2 1.47 1.59 rapidly from the receptor, whereas 1-MCP and other
3 0.47 1.47
inhibitors remain bound for a long period. While
inhibitors are bound, ethylene cannot bind [15]. There-
fore, responses to ethylene in climacteric fruit are
delayed.
different sensitivity thresholds to exogenous ethyl- 1-MCP stimulated ethylene production, but did not
ene. Also, different ripening processes such as colour, induce a respiratory rise, in late-harvested strawberry
softening and soluble solids may all be regulated by fruit [19]. The ethylene-induced respiratory rise was
ethylene, but may have different threshold levels. dose-dependent. Thus, this result can be explained
In late-harvested fruit, 1-MCP did not affect the that the respiratory rise in strawberry fruit required a
ethylene-induced respiration increase. This result can greater concentration of ethylene than that induced by
be explained by the fact that ethylene may not neces- 1-MCP.
sarily bind to the receptor to enhance respiration of Cycloheximide (CHI), a protein synthesis inhib-
strawberry fruit. Similar results were observed with itor, depressed ethylene-induced respiration in straw-
another ethylene action inhibitor, DACP, which stim- berry. This indicated that de novo synthesis of respirat-
ulated ethylene biosynthesis without changing res- ory enzymes may be required for the ethylene-induced
piration rate in late-harvested strawberry fruit [19]. respiratory rise. Combination of 1-MCP and CHI
Different results were detected for DACP-inhibited reduced the ethylene-induced respiratory rise more
ethylene biosynthesis and respiration in climacteric than CHI alone. Thus, there is an interaction between
fruit, such as apple and tomato [16, 18]. A pos- 1-MCP and ethylene in the regulation of synthesis
sible explanation is that there may either be different of respiratory enzymes, but the mechanism of this
ethylene receptor(s), or the same receptor has differ- interaction still remains unclear.
ent functions, in climacteric and non-climacteric fruits It has been reported that 1-MCP inhibits ethylene-
[24]. induced cellular senescence symptoms in ethylene-
1-MCP can depress respiration and delay ripening sensitive flowers such as petunia [12]. Ionic con-
of climacteric fruit [10]. The decreases in respiration ductivity of strawberry fruit increased with stages of
89
maturity and ripening. This increase was correlated 4. El-Kazzaz MK, Sommer NF and Fortlage RJ (1983) Effect
with loss of fresh weight, and was also stimulated by of different atmospheres on postharvest decay and quality of
fresh strawberries. Phytopathology 73: 282–285
exogenous ethylene. 5. Foyer CH, Descourvieres P and Kunert KJ (1994) Protec-
Free radicals and other active derivatives of oxy- tion against oxygen radicals: an important defence mechanism
gen inactivate enzymes and damage important cellular studied in transgenic plants. Plant, Cell and Environment 17:
components [5]. To counteract the toxicity of act- 507–523
6. Janes HW, Chin CK and Frankle C (1978) Respiratory upsurge
ive oxygen species, a highly efficient anti-oxidative in blueberries and strawberries as influenced by ethylene and
defence system, composed of non-enzymatic and acetaldehyde. Bot Gaz 139: 50–52
enzymatic constituents, is present in all plant cells. 7. Kumi Sato-Nara, Ken-Ichi Yuhashi, Katsumi Higashi,
The enzymatic antioxidative components include Kazushige Hosoya, Mitsuru Kubota and Hiroshi Ezura (1999)
Stage- and tissue-specific expression of ethylene receptor
superoxide dismutase and peroxidase. Two peroxidase homolog genes during development in mushmelon. Plant
isoenzymes (58.1 and 65.5 kD) have been detected Physiol 119: 321–329
in strawberry fruit [3]. Peroxidase activity, found 8. Nam Y-W, Line T, Monique L, Blondine C, Isabelle M and
primarily in a membrane-bound form, decreased dur- Jean-Marc L (1999) Isoltion and characterization of mRNAs
differentially expressed during ripening of wild strawberry
ing strawberry ripening. Present results have demon- (Fragaria vesca L.) fruits. Plant Mol Bil 39: 629–636
strated that peroxidase activity in pink strawberry fruit 9. Serek M, Sisler EC and Reid M (1994) Novel gaseous ethylene
was low at harvest and decreased during fruit ripening. inhibitor prevents ethylene effects in potted flowering plants. J
Amer Soc Hort Sci 119: 1230–1233
However, treatment with exogenous ethylene main-
10. Serek M, Sisler EC and Reid MS (1995a) 1-
tained peroxidase activity. It is possible that active Methylcyclopropene, a novel gaseous inhibitor of ethylene
oxygen species, induced by postharvest stress such as action, improves the life of fruits, cut flowers and potted
water loss, may be involved in non-climacteric fruit plants. Acta Hort 394: 337–345
11. Serek M, Sisler EC and Reid MS (1995b) Effects of 1-MCP
ripening. on the vase life and ethylene response of cut flowers. Plant
In this work, results suggest that non-climacteric Growth Regulation 16: 93–97
fruit such as strawberry may have different ethylene 12. Serek M, Tamari G, Sisler EC and Borochov A (1995c) Inhib-
receptor(s), and/or ethylene receptor(s) may have dif- ition of ethylene-induced cellular senescence symptoms by
1-methylcyclopropene, a new inhibitor of ethylene action.
ferent regulatory functions. Exogenous ethylene stim- Physiol Plant 94: 229–232
ulated respiration by regulating de novo respiratory 13. Schaller GE, Ladd AN, Lanahan MB, Spanbauer JM and
enzyme synthesis in strawberry fruit. However, it may Bleeker AB (1995) The ethylene response mediator ETR1
not be necessary for ethylene to bind to the receptor from Arabidopsis forms a disulfide-linked dimer. J Biol Chem
270: 12526–12530
to stimulate respiration in strawberry. Non-climacteric 14. Sisler EC (1991) Ethylene-binding components in plants. In:
fruit ripening may be related to the development of Mattoo AK and Suttle JC (eds) The Plant Hormone Ethylene.
active oxygen species induced by postharvest stress. CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida, USA. ISBN 0-8493-4566-9,
pp 81–99
15. Sisler EC and Serek M (1997) Inhibitors of ethylene responses
in plants at the receptor level: recent developments. Physiol
Acknowledgements Plant 100: 577–582
16. Song J, Tian MS, Dilley DR and Beaudry RM (1997) Effects
of 1-MCP on apple fruit ripening and volatile production.
The authors wish to thank Drs. IB Ferguson and
ASHS Ann Meeting 23–28 July, 1997, University of Califor-
N Lallu from the Horticulture and Food Research nia, USA.
Institute of New Zealand for helpful discussions. 17. Lee Soon A, Ross GS and Gardner RC (1998) An apple
(Malus domestica L. Borkh cv Granny smith) homologue of
the ethylene receptor gene ETR1 (Accession No. AF032448).
(PGR98-125) Plant Physiol 117: 1125
References 18. Tian MS, Bowen JH, Bauchot AD, Gong YP and Lallu N
(1997a) Recovery of ethylene biosynthesis in diazocyclo-
1. Abeles FB (1973) Ethylene in plant biology. New York: pentadiene (DACP)-treated tomato fruit. Plant Growth Reg-
Academic Press ulation 22: 73–78
2. Chang, C, Kwok, SF, Bleeker, AB, Meyerowiltz EM (1993) 19. Tian MS, Gong YP and Bauchot AD (1997b) Ethylene bio-
Arobidopsis ethylene-response gene ETR1: similarity of synthesis and respiration in strawberry fruit treated with
product to two-component regulators. Science 262: 539–544 diazocyclopentadiene and IAA. Plant Growth Regulation 23:
3. Civello PM, Martinez GA and Chaves AR and Anon MC 195–200
(1995) Peroxidase from strawberry fruit (Fragaria ananassa 20. Tieman DM and Klee HJ (1999) Differential expression of two
Duch.) partial purification and determination of some prop- novel mambers of the tomato ethylene-receptor family. Plant
erties. J Agri Food Chem 43: 2596–2601 Physio 120: 165–172
90
21. Wilkinson JQ, Lanahan MB, Conner TW and Klee HJ (1995) 23. Wills RBH and Kim GH (1995b) Effect of ethylene syn-
Identification of mRNAs with enhanced expression in ripening thesis in fruit ripening. In: Thomson WW, Nothnagel EA
strawberry fruit using polymerase chain reaction differential and Huffaker RC (eds) Plant Senescence: Its Biochemistry
display. Plant Mol Biol 27: 1097–1108 and Physiology. The American Society of Plant Physiologists,
22. Wills RBH and Kim GH (1995a) Effect of ethylene on pp 156–166
postharvest life of strawberries. Postharvest Biol Technol 6: 24. Yang SF (1987) The role of ethylene and ethylene synthesis in
249–255 fruit ripening. In: Thomson WW, Nothnagel EA and Huffaker
RC (eds) Plant Senescence: Its Biochemistry and Physiology.
The American Society of Plant Physiologists, pp 156–166