You are on page 1of 10

Ecological Sound Art: Steps towards a new field

JONATHAN GILMURRAY
CRiSAP, London College of Communication, University of the Arts London, Elephant and Castle, London SE1 6SB
Email: jonathangilmurray@yahoo.co.uk

The years since the turn of the millennium have seen an reflected that at the time he wrote his article, ‘[c]learly
increasing number of sound artists engaging with there were lots and lots of people already thinking the
contemporary environmental issues such as biodiversity loss, same way, because ever since it’s seemed to me as if
sustainability and climate change through their work, forming deep and moving images and sounds and words have
a growing movement of environmentally concerned sound art;
been flooding out into the world’ (McKibben 2009).
however, their work has yet to achieve the recognition enjoyed
This surge in ecological engagement has been evi-
by comparable environmentalist practices in almost every
other art form. This article argues that this increasingly dent in every area of the arts; and sound art is no
significant area of sound arts practice should be recognised as exception, with an increasing number of artists such as
a distinct field in its own right, and proposes that it be termed Leah Barclay, David Monacchi, Matthew Burtner,
‘ecological sound art’, reflecting its equivalent in the visual Andrea Polli, David Dunn and Jana Winderen using
arts. After establishing its current absence from both sound as a medium to creatively address a wide variety
ecocritical and sound arts scholarship, it proceeds to outline of contemporary environmental issues. In October
some of the core approaches which characterise works of 2006, Joel Chadabe and the Electronic Music Foun-
ecological sound art, as the first step towards its establishment dation evidenced this trend with the staging of Ear to
as a coherent field of practice. The final section draws from key the Earth, a five-day festival of environmentally con-
works of contemporary ecological theory, examining the
cerned sound art in New York – an event which would
fundamental accord that exists between the new modes of
continue to be held annually for the next seven years,
thought they propose and the ways in which we experience and
relate to sound art, demonstrating that ecological sound art and which today operates as ‘a global community of
represents not only a significant new field of sound arts environmental sound artists responding to climate
practice, but also a powerful ecological art form. change’ (Ear to the Earth 2011); while in 2008,
Matthew Burtner established EcoSono, described as
‘an activism network advocating environmental pre-
servation through experimental sound art’ (Burtner
1. INTRODUCTION
2011: 234), through which he has staged an annual
In recent years, environmental issues such as bio- educational ‘EcoSono Institute’ for the creation of new
diversity loss, pollution, sustainability, global environ- environmentalist sound works.
mental justice and, particularly, climate change have
grown to become some of the most significant socio
political – and, many would argue, moral – issues of our
2. ECOLOGICAL SOUND ART: A NEW TERM
time; however, it is generally acknowledged that
FOR A GROWING MOVEMENT
humankind is still failing to respond to them with
the necessary degree of urgency. In a 2005 article on The exponential increase in environmentally concerned
climate change, leading US environmentalist Bill sound arts activity over the past decade clearly
McKibben argued that this problem of inaction was demonstrates the existence of a significant con-
fundamentally a cultural one, and that the arts could temporary movement; however, this movement has yet
play a crucial role in facilitating our ability to tackle to achieve the recognition enjoyed by environmentalist
contemporary environmental challenges, noting that works in almost every other art form. Perhaps most
‘[a]rt, like religion, is one of the ways we digest what is fundamentally, there currently exists no generic termi-
happening to us, make the sense out of it that proceeds nology with which to identify, define or describe
to action’, and asking ‘[w]here are the books? The it – something which is a prerequisite for any field if it is
poems? The plays? The goddamn operas?’ (McKibben to gain a coherent identity, and become part of a
2005). Far from being a lone ecological voice crying in a meaningful discourse. The term ‘environmental sound
cultural wilderness, however, McKibben’s call-to-arms art’ is already in limited use (Bakht 2009; Otsuka and
coincided with the beginning of a huge surge of interest Sandberg 2009; Cummings 2010; Koutsomichalis 2013;
around arts and ecology – a fact which he acknowl- Wright 2015; Bianchi and Manzo 2016; Blackburn
edged in a follow-up piece four years later, in which he 2016) as an umbrella term for sound works in which the
Organised Sound 22(1): 32–41 © Cambridge University Press, 2017. doi:10.1017/S1355771816000315

Downloaded from https:/www.cambridge.org/core. Columbia University Libraries, on 31 May 2017 at 01:11:30, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
https:/www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1355771816000315
Ecological Sound Art 33

‘environment’, in its most general sense, functions as Hawthorne 2005; Shedroff 2009; Anker 2010;
site, subject or material; however, the fact that there is Bergman 2012), literature (Glotfelty and Fromm 1996;
no separate terminology with which to distinguish the Armbruster and Wallace 2001; Buell 2005; Garrard
growing movement of environmentalist sound works 2012; Westling 2014), film (Ingram 2000; Willoquet-
means that the philosophies, meanings and methodo- Maricondi 2010; Gustafsson and Kääpä 2013; Rust,
logies that lie at its heart are in danger of being lost, Monani and Cubitt 2013; O’Brien 2016), theatre
ignored, diluted or misunderstood through being (Heinlein 2007; Cless 2010; Arons and May 2012;
subsumed within this wide field. Besel and Blau 2014; Lavery and Finburgh 2015), and
In this respect, today’s environmentally concerned music (Mellers 2001; Ingram 2010; Pedelty 2012; Von
sound art is in the same situation that was resolved Glahn 2013; Allen and Dawe 2016). Such scholarship
within the visual arts a quarter of a century ago, when serves an important function in recognising, con-
the 1992 exhibition Fragile Ecologies collected solidating and promoting common bodies of environ-
together environmentalist art from the previous thirty mentalist practice within these art forms, providing
years and recognised it as a distinct movement in its critical analysis, evaluating their significance and
own right. Up until this point, as the exhibition’s enabling their incorporation into the wider critical
curator Barbara C. Matilsky observed, ‘critics and discourse surrounding the cultural response to con-
curators often lumped dissimilar artists together, temporary environmental issues. In surveying this
which resulted in a confusion of different sensibilities extensive canon of ecocritical scholarship, however,
and tendencies that continues to this day’ (Matilsky sound art is notable by its absence.
1992: 38). In particular, environmentalist artworks While we might perhaps expect to find ecological
were commonly conflated with the movement known sound works incorporated into the critical discourse
variously as land art, earth art or earthworks, within surrounding eco-art, all existing texts in this field limit
the more general category of ‘environmental art’; their coverage to the visual arts (Matilsky 1992; Spaid
however, as Matilsky noted, ‘[n]ot all environmental 2002; Natural World Museum 2007; Weintraub 2012;
art is environmentally sound nor does it carry an eco- Kagan 2013; Brown 2014; Miles 2014). Linda
logical message’ (Matilsky 1992: 43). To address this, Weintraub’s extensive review of the field, To Life! Eco
the movement of environmentalist art represented by Art in Pursuit of a Sustainable Planet, provides a stark
Fragile Ecologies was christened ‘ecological art’, example, with a taxonomy which divides the field into
defined as ‘a new approach to art and nature based eleven kinds of art practice including paint/print,
upon environmental ethics’ (Matilsky 1992: 56) – ter- sculpture, performance, photo/video, bio art,
minology which, either in full or in its abbreviated generative art, social practice, digital art, installation,
form of ‘eco-art’, is now in common usage, a fact public art, and design – but with sound art nowhere to
demonstrated by its entry in the Oxford English be found (Weintraub 2012: xviii–xxi).
Dictionary. Another place in which we might expect to find some
Just as the last twenty-five years have seen ‘ecological’ engagement with ecological sound art is the recently
or ‘eco-’ art gain widespread recognition as a specific established field of ecomusicology, defined by Aaron S.
movement of environmentalist works within the wider Allen in the Grove Dictionary of American Music as
field of environmental art, there is now a pressing need ‘the study of music, culture, and nature in all the
for the same to happen for today’s environmentalist complexities of those terms … consider[ing] musical
sound art. Reflecting its equivalent in the visual arts, and sonic issues, both textual and performative, related
therefore, this article proposes the adoption of ‘eco- to ecology and the natural environment’ (Allen 2013).
logical sound art’ as the most suitable terminology for Indeed, some critics have explicitly argued for sound
this important contemporary movement. art’s inclusion within ecomusicology: Jeff Todd Titon
states that ‘the proper frame [for ecomusicology] is
sound and sustainability; music is too narrowing’
(Titon 2013: 8), while Alexander Rehding argues that
3. THE ABSENCE OF ECOLOGICAL SOUND
if ecomusicology is to achieve the same level of impact
ART FROM CURRENT CRITICAL DISCOURSE
as ecological movements in other art forms, it must
In most areas of the creative arts, the explosion in expand its definition of music, noting that ‘[n]on-
engagement with environmental issues has been Western musical traditions and sound art, in a post-
reflected by growing bodies of both academic and Cagean universe, hold considerable potential in this
popular literature, with an abundance of ecocritical regard, as does the pioneering work in sound studies
texts in the fields of art (Matilsky 1992; Weintraub that has exploded traditional notions of music and
2012; Kagan 2013; Brown 2014; Miles 2014), fashion musicological enterprise’ (Rehding 2011: 412). In the
(Hethorn and Ulasewicz 2008; Brown 2010; Minney recent collection Current Directions in Ecomusicology:
2011; Black 2013; Gordon and Hill 2015), design and Music, Culture, Nature, meanwhile, editors Aaron
architecture (Guy and Moore 2005; Stang and S. Allen and Kevin Dawe claim that ‘[w]ork in

Downloaded from https:/www.cambridge.org/core. Columbia University Libraries, on 31 May 2017 at 01:11:30, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
https:/www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1355771816000315
34 Jonathan Gilmurray

ecomusicology is on a music-sound continuum: the 4. COMMON APPROACHES WITHIN


ecomusicological objects and/or subjects of study are ECOLOGICAL SOUND ART
parts of complex systems involving a wide range of
As a first step towards establishing it as a coherent field
sonic phenomena’ (Allen and Dawe 2016: 8). Despite
of practice, this article will now proceed to outline
these encouragingly inclusive statements, however,
some of the core approaches that characterise eco-
sound art is once again notable by its almost complete
logical sound art, through a summary of some of the
absence from current ecomusicological scholarship,
key works in the field. This brief list is offered here as
which remains confined to the more traditional, ‘note-
an initial description of a dynamic and growing field,
based’ musical genres of popular (Ingram 2010;
and should by no means be taken to represent the full
Pedelty 2012) and classical music (Mellers 2001; Von
extent of its possibilities; nor should these approaches
Glahn 2013).
be understood as mutually exclusive categories, since a
In many ways, this situation merely reflects an
number of them may be (and often are) combined
ongoing problem faced by sound art as a whole: while
within a single work.
it has for some years been gaining increasing recogni-
tion in the gallery-based art world, academia has been
slow to follow this trend, with the established dis-
4.1. Enacting metaphors which facilitate a personal
ciplines of both art history and musicology largely
connection with environmental issues
failing to engage with it. This has led to the gradual
emergence of sound arts as an independent field of Perhaps the most common approach within ecological
study, with its own growing body of critical scholar- sound art is the enactment of artistic metaphors which
ship; and within this can be found a number of texts facilitate a heightened awareness, deeper under-
which do engage with the links between the environ- standing and, most importantly, a personal connection
ment, environmental sound and sound art (Truax with contemporary environmental issues. One example
2001; LaBelle 2006; Bandt, Duffy and MacKinnon is Suspended Sounds, a collaborative work created for
2007; Carlyle 2007; Rudi 2011; Bijsterveld 2013; the inaugural Ear to the Earth festival in New York in
Belgiojoso 2014; Gandy and Nilsen 2014). However, in 2006, in which sound artists Joan La Barbara, Joel
these texts such issues are invariably viewed through Chadabe, Alvin Curran, David Monacchi, Aleksei
the lens of acoustic ecology; and while many of its core Stevens and Rama Gottfried composed 8-channel
principles are of undeniable importance to ecological sound works from recordings of the sounds of extinct
sound art, the fundamental fact that acoustic ecology is and endangered species, which were diffused in an
by definition a field concerned with the acoustic immersive sound environment designed by Alban
environment means that it only tends to engage with Bassuet. As Joan La Barbara commented: ‘As
contemporary environmental issues to the extent that I worked with the sounds of these now extinct or
they impact the environmental soundscape. Many of endangered animals and birds, the depth of the
today’s environmentally concerned sound artists are poignancy of the situation was almost overwhelming.
moving beyond these boundaries, however, using I felt as if I were breathing life into beings that no
sound as a medium to creatively address every facet of longer exist’ (La Barbara, in Ear to the Earth 2015).
the growing world environmental crisis in ways which, An even more direct and personal connection was
despite their enormous contemporary relevance, are achieved in Katie Paterson’s Vatnajökull (the sound of)
still being almost completely overlooked by current (2007/8), in which a phone line connected callers to a
sound arts scholarship. microphone buried in an Icelandic glacier, enabling them
Thus seemingly neither ‘visual’ enough for eco-art, to listen to it melting in real-time. For her related
nor ‘musical’ enough for ecomusicology, and with work Langjökull, Snœfellsjökull, Solheimajökull (2007),
acoustic ecology-based sound arts scholarship largely meanwhile, Paterson made recordings of the melting
failing to engage with the wider environmental issues sounds of the three glaciers of the title, pressed them onto
which are its central concern, the growing movement records made from their own refrozen meltwater, and
of ecological sound art is in danger of silently dis- played them on turntables until they completely melted.
appearing through the cracks. Furthermore, addres- As Andrew Brown comments, through these simple
sing this problem is not merely in the interest of the yet powerful sound works, Paterson ‘transform[s] us
artists involved, but also in that of the field of sound art into silent and impotent witnesses as the polar ice cap
as a whole: for an art form still battling to achieve the recedes before our very ears’ (Brown 2014: 78).
widespread public recognition enjoyed by art in almost The transplanting of sound from one location to
every other medium, its active engagement with issues another was also at the heart of Graciela Muñoz’s El
of such huge global importance represents a prime Sonido Recobrado (‘Sound Recovered’) (2014), a work
opportunity for sound art to impact upon public con- which deals with the ongoing issue of water rights in
cerns and agendas outside the academic institutions Chile, whose largest and most powerful river, the
and specialist circles to which it is still largely confined. Baker, is just one of many being illegally dammed and

Downloaded from https:/www.cambridge.org/core. Columbia University Libraries, on 31 May 2017 at 01:11:30, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
https:/www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1355771816000315
Ecological Sound Art 35

drained by mining, agriculture and hydroelectric com- based on ecocentric values … It is a music interwoven into
panies, causing ongoing problems for local commu- a network of interdependent relationships with the world
nities. Muñoz recorded the sounds of the Baker at five outside … [in which the listener] is not the center of the
different locations along its length, then brought the happening, but is included; he listens to music, listening to
recordings to her own home town of Petorca, whose the environment. (Branchi 2012: 71)
river was also dammed and has been completely dry The interaction of electronic technology with
since the 1990s, where she played back the sounds of the environmental soundscapes also represents a central
Baker over twenty-eight speakers set in the dry river part of David Dunn’s artistic practice, in which sound
bed. In doing so, Munõz’s work ‘temporarily recovered is used as a medium to explore the ways in which eco-
a lost experience where a sound that does not exist systems function. In works such as Entrainments 1
anymore appears again, superimposing the past over an (1984), Sonic Mirror (1986–7) and Autonomous
uncertain present’ (Velasco, Pohl and Nieto 2015: 1), Systems (2003–5), automated electronic systems are set
creating a powerful statement which connects the up in which the soundscape of a natural ecosystem is
exploitation of the Petorca with the similar fate faced by recorded, processed, played back into the environment
the Baker and the communities which live around it. and then recorded again, creating a feedback loop
shaped by the interaction between the technological
system and the living ecosystem, and in which ‘certain
4.2. Articulating the harmonious coexistence of humans, participants in the environment – the flies, the birds –
technology and the natural world begin to “play” the system, interacting with it’ (Burt
2007). Dunn regards these sonic experiments as a step
Other works use sound as a medium for the investiga-
towards humanity finding a way back into the inter-
tion and articulation of ways in which human beings
connected ecosystem from which we have become
and our technologies can coexist harmoniously with the
estranged:
rest of the natural world. David Monacchi’s Integrated
Ecosystem (2009), one of several artistic outputs from I’m very interested in these archaic systems of under-
his ongoing Greenpeace-sponsored project Fragments standing environmental balance: seeing ourselves as an
of Extinction, is composed from field recordings of intrinsic part of larger systems. I would be happy if my
soundscapes from areas of primary equatorial rain- work serves no other purpose than to suggest ways in
which we might rediscover this sense of fundamental
forest. The work functions as a demonstration of Bernie
connectedness … We need to compose processes of
Krause’s Acoustic Niche Hypothesis, which states that
interaction which will help reestablish a saner balance of
in a healthy ecosystem ‘each creature … [has] its own humanity within the biosphere. The language I’m envi-
sonic niche … [which is] occupied by no other at that sioning is an experiential, dynamic process that explores
particular moment’ (Krause 1987: 3): it is accompanied whatever tools and metaphors are available in that
by projected real-time spectrogram analyses which direction. (Dunn 1988: 15–16)
allow the audience to correlate the sounds they are
hearing with their arrangement in the frequency spec-
trum, while Monacchi’s own improvisations on flute
and live electronics are strictly confined to the available 4.3. Allowing us to experience normally inaccessible
acoustic niches, thus ‘building a powerful metaphor as aspects of the environment
of one species that performs within a composite eco- Ecological sound art can also allow audiences to
system while trying to find a balanced, harmonic rela- experience aspects of the environment they would not
tionship to it … [and thereby] help[ing] to create an normally have access to, facilitating a heightened
ecological awareness for repositioning our species knowledge of, and respect for, the world we live in.
within nature’ (Monacchi 2011: 247–8). Another of Dunn’s works, The Sound of Light in Trees
While Monacchi’s works are generally intended for (2006), features detailed recordings of the pine bark
the concert hall or gallery, the numerous electronic beetle which is responsible for decimating the popula-
compositions which comprise Walter Branchi’s all- tion of piñon pines in New Mexico, raising awareness
encompassing work Intero (‘Whole’) (1979–present) of the problem by allowing us to hear the destruction
are designed to be heard outdoors in specific environ- going on inside the trees, invisible to the naked
mental locations, with the object of facilitating a eye. However, this constitutes only one element of the
heightened appreciation of their natural soundscapes. work: Dunn also discovered that playing the record-
This approach, which Branchi calls ‘integrated’ or ings back to the beetles had a profound effect on their
‘eco-’ music, stems from his strong ecological con- neural system, causing them to cease their tunnelling
victions, representing an attempt to nurture human- and feeding behaviours, and even shutting down their
kind’s relationship with the natural world: reproductive cycle, enabling him to use his work as an
It is a music that goes beyond the concept of the world effective, and eco-friendly, form of pest control to
centred exclusively on anthropocentric values, but is actively combat the problem.

Downloaded from https:/www.cambridge.org/core. Columbia University Libraries, on 31 May 2017 at 01:11:30, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
https:/www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1355771816000315
36 Jonathan Gilmurray

A different kind of hidden world is revealed in employed as a scientific tool in a range of fields, and for
the sound works of former marine biologist Jana a wide variety of purposes (Hermann et al. 2011).
Winderen, which provide a sonic window into the Artist Andrea Polli collaborates with climate scientists
underwater ecosystems which exist largely indepen- and meteorologists to produce sonification-based
dently of human beings, encouraging our awareness sound works which comment upon climate issues,
and respect, and reminding us that we are not the such as her Airlight series (2006–7), in which data from
centre of the universe: air quality monitoring stations in Taipei, Socal and
Boulder are translated into sound to create a real-
[T]his relates back to the importance of the inaudible, to
that which lies outside our senses and our possibility of time aural representation of the levels of various
perception. This is a field which we are not able to atmospheric pollutants; and Sonic Antarctica (2009),
experience and yet other creatures are operating there. the product of an artistic residency with the National
For me, it is important to hear this field since it is Science Foundation, which blends field recordings,
inhabited by beings who have existed for many millions of interviews with scientists, and sonifications of the
years longer than our species. Without wanting to sound climate data they are studying, enabling us to ‘hear’
at all New Age, it is an issue of respect, of sensitivity and our warming world from multiple perspectives. Heat
of developing a questioning approach to the environment. and the Heartbeat of the City (2004), meanwhile, is an
(Winderen, in Lane and Carlyle 2013: 157) interactive work centred on sonifications of projected
One recent project entitled Silencing of the Reefs saw temperature increases in Central Park caused by global
Winderen working in collaboration with Germany’s warming. In an interview regarding this project, Polli
Thyssen-Bornemisza Art Contemporary Foundation commented on what she felt sonification could bring to
to explore the changing soundscapes of the earth’s our understanding of the issue:
remaining coral reefs and promote greater under-
I think that sound is a very visceral thing and I think that
standing of how they are being negatively impacted by if people can really feel the potential difficulties, the
human actions, asking: ‘[w]ill the reefs be silenced potential discomfort, but more than just uncomfortable,
before we even have had the chance to listen to them actual problems that will result from global warming,
and even begin to fully understand these fragile maybe in some way they will be convinced to think more
ecosystems?’ (Winderen 2013). seriously about the issue. (Polli 2005)
In December 2015, two works staged at the COP21
climate summit in Paris used sound to transport Sonification is also at the heart of the compositional
visitors to two very different environments under approach which Matthew Burtner has named
threat from climate change, bringing a vitally tangible ‘ecoacoustic’, describing it as ‘a type of environ-
and experiential dimension to the issues being mentalism in sound … tak[ing] the form of musical
discussed in theoretical terms at the summit. Leah procedures and materials that either directly or
Barclay’s Rainforest Listening (2015) was based at the indirectly draw on environmental systems to structure
Eiffel Tower and accessed via a mobile app which music’ (Burtner 2005: 10). Burtner has composed
immersed visitors in a variety of rainforest sounds- many such ‘ecoacoustic’ sound works, such as Iceprints
capes as they moved around, with each level’s viewing (2009), in which a hydrophone recording made
platform corresponding to a different layer of rain- beneath the Arctic ice is combined with a piano part
forest vegetation. On the streets of Paris, meanwhile, based on a transcription of the recording, with its pitch
Holly Owen and Kristina Pulejkova were dressed as determined by mapping the progressive decline in
polar explorers, wearing ‘backpack cinemas’ equipped Arctic ice over the forty years between 1970 and 2010
with headphones on which audiences could experience onto the first six octaves of the keyboard, and each
their work Switching Heads – Sound Mapping the page of the score covering one year, thus translating
Arctic (2015), in which an ice sculpture of a human the process of ecological change into music. Auksalaq
head with binaural microphones planted in its ears (2012), meanwhile, is a multimedia ‘opera’ composed
explores the Norwegian island of Tromsø, listening to around a narrative which addresses the effects of
its soundscapes and hearing local people’s testimonies climate change upon the Arctic through a combination
of the ways in which climate change is affecting it. of sonification-based compositions, field recordings,
video and interviews with both climate scientists and
the native Alaskan Inupiat people whose way of life is
being threatened by the melting of the Arctic ice.
4.4. Communicating environmental data through sound
Perhaps the most widely known sonification-based
Some ecological sound works utilise sonification as a work of ecological sound art, however, is John Luther
means to achieve an experiential understanding of Adams’s The Place Where You Go To Listen (2004–6),
ecological dynamics and processes. As a technique a permanent sound and light installation at the
which involves mapping data sets onto sonic or Museum of the North in Fairbanks involving the real-
musical parameters, sonification is increasingly being time sonification of geophysical and climatological

Downloaded from https:/www.cambridge.org/core. Columbia University Libraries, on 31 May 2017 at 01:11:30, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
https:/www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1355771816000315
Ecological Sound Art 37

data from the surrounding environment, allowing whether ecological sound art can be regarded as a
visitors to ‘hear’ the dynamics of the Alaskan eco- significant and effective means of approaching today’s
system as a constantly unfolding composition. In the urgent ecological crises. To answer this question, the
accompanying book, Adams reveals that the project final section of this article will draw from three key
stems from his conviction that ‘music can contribute to works of contemporary ecological theory, examining
the awakening of our ecological understanding. By the parallels that exist between the new modes of
deepening our awareness of our connections to the thought they propose and the ways in which we
earth, music can provide a sounding model for the experience sound art, and which reveal it to be an
renewal of human consciousness and culture’ (Adams inherently ecological medium.
2009: 1).

5.1. The ecological thought: sensing the mesh of


4.5. Facilitating community engagement with vibrant matter
ecological issues
One of the fundamental pillars of contemporary eco-
Finally, some works of ecological sound art move logical theory is the principle of interconnectedness
beyond the one-way ‘artist-to-audience’ dynamic to between the different elements within the earth’s eco-
engage communities as active participants and colla- systems, our understanding of which Timothy Morton
borators, facilitating a direct and personal engagement describes as ‘thinking the ecological thought’:
with the environmental issues that most affect them.
Leah Barclay has realised many such projects, under- The ecological crisis we face is so obvious that it becomes
pinned by her ‘Sonic Ecologies Framework’, ‘a multi- easy – for some, strangely or frighteningly easy – to join
the dots and see that everything is interconnected. This is
platform methodology proposed to initiate cultural
the ecological thought. And the more we consider it, the
change through sound … [which] pivots on a site- more our world opens up. (Morton 2010: 1)
specific creative project embedded in a multi-layered
community cultural engagement process developed in Morton coins the term ‘the mesh’ to describe the net-
response to a specific environment’ (Barclay 2012: 17). work of interconnections between everything, noting
Her projects have included Sonic Explorers, which that ‘[t]he mesh of interconnected things is vast, per-
engages young people in ecological sound art; The haps immeasurably so … Nothing exists all by itself,
Dam(n) Project, which has seen Barclay working with and so nothing is fully “itself”’ (Morton 2010: 15). He
communities in India’s Narmada valley, using sound explains that the mesh does not just include living or
art as an activist tool to respond to the destructive organic forms, but all matter – every ‘thing’ on the
damming projects which threaten their water supplies; planet – and that ‘each being in the mesh interacts with
and Biosphere Soundscapes, an ongoing series of net- others. The mesh isn’t static. We can’t rigidly specify
worked projects in which artists and communities are anything as irrelevant’ (Morton 2010: 29–30).
working together to use sound as a means of under- In The Spell of the Sensuous, David Abram states
standing the environmental health of UNESCO bio- that the only way to truly internalise this principle of
sphere reserves. All these projects stem from Barclay’s ecological interconnectedness is through the cultiva-
firm belief in the power of sound art to impact how we tion of our sensorial perception of the world around us,
approach today’s urgent environmental issues: since to do so is to ‘enter into a sympathetic relation
with the perceived … Perception, in this sense, is an
Now, more than ever, there is a critical need to listen to
attunement or synchronisation between my own
our environment and generate a paradigm shift that
engages our auditory perception. Sound, as a creative rhythms and the rhythms of the things themselves,
medium, is undoubtedly one of the most powerful means their own tones and textures’ (Abram 1996: 54).
to stimulate this shift in consciousness. Electro-acoustic Becoming sensorially attuned to the world in this way,
music, with the use of natural sounds exposing the state of argues Abram, will result in an embodied under-
the world, could be an unprecedented tool in artists taking standing of our place within the earth’s biosphere:
action in ecological crisis. (Barclay 2012: 22)
As we return to our senses, we gradually discover our
sensory perceptions to be simply our part of a vast,
interpenetrating webwork of perceptions and sensations
5. THE ECOLOGICAL AGENCY OF borne by countless other bodies … It is, indeed, nothing
SOUND ART other than the biosphere – the matrix of earthly life in
which we ourselves are embedded. Yet this is not the
The five approaches outlined above serve to demon- biosphere as it is conceived by an abstract and objectify-
strate just a few of the ways in which ecological sound ing science … it is, rather, the biosphere as it is experi-
art might help audiences to engage with contemporary enced and lived from within by the intelligent body – by the
environmental issues. However, it still remains to attentive human animal who is entirely a part of the world
address perhaps the most vital question of all: that of that he, or she, experiences. (Abram 1996: 65)

Downloaded from https:/www.cambridge.org/core. Columbia University Libraries, on 31 May 2017 at 01:11:30, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
https:/www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1355771816000315
38 Jonathan Gilmurray

In Vibrant Matter, Jane Bennett argues that it is our (Dyson 2014: 109). Like Abram and Bennett, Dyson
failure to acknowledge the vitality and power of non- argues that only a new sensibility, grounded in the
human matter which ‘feeds human hubris and our direct sensing of the dynamic, vibrant world around us,
earth-destroying fantasies of conquest and consump- can hope to furnish us with the true ‘common sense’
tion … preventing us from detecting (seeing, hearing, which is the necessary foundation for a heightened
smelling, tasting, feeling) a fuller range of the non- ecological consciousness – and ‘this is where sound and
human powers circulating around and within our listening play a pivotal role’ (Dyson 2014: 149):
bodies … [and impeding] the emergence of more
Sound’s ephemeral and atmospheric nature is, like the
ecological and more materially sustainable modes of environment, something that circulates outside of
production and consumption’ (Bennett 2010: vii–ix). exchange, and refocuses attention on the space and the
Like Abram, Bennett advocates ‘a cultivated, patient, environment of the subject rather than the subject per se
sensory attentiveness to nonhuman forces’ (Bennett … [that] offers some entry into the dilemma of how to
2010: xiv) as the key to enhancing our perception of, hear the world and in hearing, also be able to act, with the
and respect for, their agency, arguing that ‘[s]uch a aim and existential condition of the ‘in-common’. (Dyson
newfound attentiveness to matter and its powers … 2014: 149)
can inspire a greater sense of the extent to which all Comparable descriptions of the inherently ecological
bodies are kin in the sense of inextricably enmeshed in nature of sound are also found within ecomusicology:
a dense network of relations’ (Bennett 2010: 13) – in in Music and the Skilful Listener: American Women
other words, facilitating our thinking of Morton’s Compose the Natural World, Denise Von Glahn
‘ecological thought’. observes that the fact that music ‘surrounds us and
enfolds us in space simulates our relationship within
the all-embracing natural world’ (Von Glahn 2013: 6–
5.2. Sensing ecological relationships through sound 7), and argues that the act of listening encourages a
Sound’s unique ability to reveal the system of dynamic particular mode of being in the world based on
relationships that exists between things in the world is, ‘growing into an environment rather than insisting
of course, a fundamental pillar of acoustic ecology: upon reshaping it’ (Von Glahn 2013: 322). In The
in Acoustic Communication, Barry Truax states that Jukebox in the Garden: Ecocriticism and Popular Music
‘[l]istening … is the primary interface between the Since 1960, meanwhile, David Ingram explores the
individual and the environment … Moreover, listening notion of ‘eco-listening’, which argues that ‘the activity
habits create a relationship between the listener and the of listening itself has a special role to play in the for-
environment … the interlocking behavior of sound, the mation of ecological awareness’ (Ingram 2010: 16),
listener, and the environment [are understood as] as a concluding that ‘music is the art form best suited to
system of relationships, not as isolated entities … With fostering the ecological self … [since] the dominance of
sound, everything interacts with everything else’ the visual sense in human beings encourages a sense of
(Truax 2001: xviii–xix). More recently, in Sonic Pos- separation between subject and object, or human
sible Worlds, Salomé Voegelin notes that ‘[s]ound is the perceiver and things in the world, which has had
invisible layer of the world that shows its relationships, disastrous consequences for the health of the environ-
actions, and dynamics … [and] augments, expands and ment … [while] the sense of hearing overcomes the
critically evaluates how we see the world and how we limitations of sight by enacting the fundamental
arrange ourselves to live in it’ (Voegelin 2014: 2). ecological principle of holistic interconnectedness’
Voegelin explains that, since sound is the product of a (Ingram 2010: 59).
dynamic event, it indicates not what is, but what is
happening, in our environment, facilitating our per-
ception of the network of relationships between things: 5.3. Sonic possible worlds
Sound … [indicates] phenomena that function not as To move towards genuine and lasting ecological
objects or subjects, as entities, but sound the temporal change, however, requires not just the attainment of
connections between objects and subjects as things more ecological ways of thinking and being in the
thinging, contingently … We do not hear entities but present, but also that we are able to conceive of alter-
relationships, the commingling of things which generate a
native futures: to re-imagine how things could be. In
sonic world. (Voegelin 2014: 162)
Eco-Aesthetics: Art, Literature and Architecture in a
In The Tone of our Times: Sound, Sense, Economy, and Period of Climate Change, Malcolm Miles considers
Ecology, Frances Dyson similarly notes that ‘[s]ensa- art’s ability to help us to do this, asserting that ‘art
tion is heralded by noise – the noise of movement, inflects life, just as life inflects art. Representations of
not of things. Sensation flickers on the skin and ideas establish them’ (Miles 2014: 11), and going on to
gathers up the body, pulls it out of its tempestuous reflect that ‘[p]erhaps I am lost in a dreamworld if
inner monologue, and presents it with the world’ I imagine a postcapitalist, environmentally just and

Downloaded from https:/www.cambridge.org/core. Columbia University Libraries, on 31 May 2017 at 01:11:30, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
https:/www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1355771816000315
Ecological Sound Art 39

sustainably joyful society, yet unless I can imagine it ecological theory outlined by Morton, Abram and
I have no way to contribute to it … art … is an Bennett: providing a sensuous experience of the inter-
imaginative as well as an interruptive project, requiring connectedness of our own agency with the agency of
a re-visioning of the world’s value structures’ (Miles vibrant matter, as part of the dynamic and shifting
2014: 29–30). mesh of the earth’s ecosystem.
The power of sound art to realise such a re-visioning –
or, perhaps more correctly, a re-listening – of the world
is explored by Salomé Voegelin in Sonic Possible
6. CONCLUSION
Worlds, in which she outlines how listening to sound can
impact our perception not only of what the world is, but As global weather patterns grow increasingly erratic,
also, crucially, of what it could be: the Arctic ice sheets continue to recede and scientists
issue ever-starker warnings concerning our fate, it has
Listening to the landscape’s pluralities and possibilities, become increasingly clear that the numerous environ-
hearing the dense multiplicity of its mobile production, mental crises we face require urgent action on an
allows us to challenge the singularity of actuality and
unprecedented scale; however, as Naomi Klein points
articulate a different sense of place and a different sense of
out, ‘[f]aced with a crisis that threatens our survival as
self that lives in those possibilities and shows us how else
things could be … Sound slices through the visual frame a species, our entire culture is continuing to do the very
and organisation to propose others: temporary, invisible, thing that caused the crisis, only with an extra dose of
and ephemeral re-framings that demand our participation elbow grease behind it’ (Klein 2014: 2). Given this
and re-frame the listener also. (Voegelin 2014: 22) situation, perhaps the most critical question of all is
how we might begin to re-imagine our relationship to
When we listen to a sound work, Voegelin argues, we these environmental crises in order to overcome this
become submerged in a ‘sonic possible world’, which is state of fatal inaction: as Bill McKibben notes, ‘[w]e
created and recreated by our experience of what we can register what is happening with satellites and
hear. Furthermore, when we emerge from the possible scientific instruments, but can we register it in our
world that has been generated through our listening, imaginations, the most sensitive of all our devices?’
we do not do so into the version of the world (McKibben 2005).
we previously inhabited – indeed, we cannot – since the In recent years, an increasing number of artists have
new thoughts, perceptions and sensations that we have begun using sound as a medium to help us to do exactly
experienced will be carried forth into the actual world, that, creating works which take a variety of approaches
creating ‘a different actuality linked to and infected by including (but not necessarily limited to) creating
new possibilities’ (Voegelin 2014: 31). For Voegelin, this metaphors to help us connect with environmental issues
has ‘not only an aesthetic but also a social and political on a deeper and more personal level; articulating the
significance in that it has an impact on ideas about what harmonious coexistence of humankind and our tech-
the world and what the subject is presumed to be and nologies with the earth’s ecosystems; engendering
what else they could be’ (Voegelin 2014: 2–3). Thus the awareness and respect for invisible or inaccessible areas
effect of the sound work is to create not only a new of the environment; expressing environmental data
possible world, but also a new possible listener with a through sound; and actively engaging communities in
renewed relationship with the world that is inherently the environmental issues that most affect them.
ecological; as Voegelin explains, ‘[t]he listening subject This article has argued that this growing area of
inhabiting the sensorial sense of the work is not a sound arts practice must be recognised as a significant
humanist subject but a post-humanist subject who lives contemporary movement in its own right; and that,
in equivalence and reciprocity with her environment following the precedent set within the visual arts, it
and understands her role as one of responsibility instead should be distinguished from the wider field of
of superiority’ (Voegelin 2014: 141). environmental sound art by the terminology ‘ecological
Furthermore, the fact that these new possibilities are sound art’. Such a move is vital if this important
generated neither by the sound nor by the listener movement is to be afforded the same recognition as that
alone, but rather by the interaction of the sound with currently enjoyed by comparable ecological movements
the consciousness of the listener, reveals ‘that the out- in other art forms, and included within the wider critical
side is not overwhelming and infinite, but is the inter- discourse surrounding the cultural response to con-
twining of himself, his agency, with the agency of temporary environmental issues – a discourse from
nature, equivalent, reciprocal, and generative … Such which it is currently notable by its absence.
a worldview is more equal and does not grant the Furthermore, the recognition that the fundamental
power of conquest but the responsibility of together- characteristics of how we experience and relate to
ness’ (Voegelin 2014: 118). Sound art is thus revealed sound art directly embody the new modes of thought
as a medium which inherently embodies and ties proposed by some of today’s leading ecological
together the fundamental principles of contemporary theorists regarding our understanding of today’s

Downloaded from https:/www.cambridge.org/core. Columbia University Libraries, on 31 May 2017 at 01:11:30, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
https:/www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1355771816000315
40 Jonathan Gilmurray

urgent and complex environmental issues reveals Bianchi, F. and Manzo, V. J. (eds.) 2016. Environmental
sound art to be an inherently ecological medium – one Sound Artists: In Their Own Words. New York: Oxford
which enables a direct, sensorial engagement with the University Press.
agency of vibrant matter, facilitating an embodied Bijsterveld, K. (ed.) 2013. Soundscapes of the Urban Past:
understanding of our embeddedness within an inter- Staged Sound as Mediated Cultural Heritage. Bielefeld:
Transcript Verlag.
connected ecosystem, and creating sonic possible
Black, S. 2013. The Sustainable Fashion Handbook. London:
worlds which allow us to re-imagine how things could Thames and Hudson.
be. Taken together, all of these factors make plain the Blackburn, P. 2016. Bio. http://philipblackburn.com/bio/
importance of establishing ecological sound art as a (accessed 3 February 2016).
distinct and significant new field of practice within Branchi, W. 2012. Canto Infinito: Thinking Music
contemporary sound arts: one which, in the words of Environmentally. New York: Open Space.
David Dunn, might perhaps serve as ‘a conservation Brown, A. 2014. Art and Ecology Now. London: Thames and
strategy for keeping something alive that we now need Hudson.
to make more conscious, a way of making sense of the Brown, S. 2010. Eco Fashion. London: Laurence King.
world from which we might refashion our relationship Buell, L. 2005. The Future of Environmental Criticism:
to nonhuman living systems … [and which might] Environmental Crisis and Literary Imagination. Malden,
MA: Blackwell.
provide us with clues to our future survival – and that is
Burt, W. 2007. Liner notes. In David Dunn. Autonomous and
a responsibility worth pursuing’ (Dunn 2009: 97).
Dynamical Systems. New York: New World Records.
Burtner, M. 2005. Ecoacoustic and Shamanic Technologies
for Multimedia Composition and Performance.
Organised Sound 10(1): 3–19.
REFERENCES
Burtner, M. 2011. EcoSono: Adventures in Interactive
Abram, D. 1996. The Spell of the Sensuous. New York: Ecoacoustics in the World. Organised Sound 16(3): 234–44.
Vintage Books. Carlyle, A. (ed.) 2007. Autumn Leaves: Sound and the
Adams, J. L. 2009. The Place Where You Go to Listen: In Environment in Artistic Practice. Paris: Double Entendre.
Search of an Ecology of Music. Middletown, CT: Cless, D. 2010. Ecology and Environment in European
Wesleyan University Press. Drama. Abingdon: Routledge.
Allen, A. S. 2013. Ecomusicology. In C. H. Garrett (ed.) The Cummings, J. 2010. About Environmental Soundscape Art.
Grove Dictionary of American Music, 2nd edn. New York: http://earthear.com/aboutesa.html (accessed 3 February
Oxford University Press. 2016).
Allen, A. S. and Dawe, K. (eds.) 2016. Current Directions in Dunn, D. 1988. Environment, Consciousness, and
Ecomusicology: Music, Culture, Nature. Abingdon: Magic. http://davidddunn.com/~david/writings/interv1.
Routledge. pdf (accessed 6 June 2015).
Anker, P. 2010. From Bauhaus to Eco-Haus: A History of Dunn, D. 2009. Nature, Sound Art, and the Sacred. In D.
Ecological Design. Baton Rouge, LA: Louisiana State Rothenberg and M. Ulvaeus (eds.) The Book of Music and
University Press. Nature, 2nd edn. Middletown, CT: Wesleyan University Press.
Armbruster, K. M. and Wallace, K. R. (eds.) 2001. Beyond Dyson, F. 2014. The Tone of Our Times: Sound, Sense,
Nature Writing: Expanding the Boundaries of Ecocriticism. Economy, and Ecology. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Charlottesville, VA: University Press of Virginia. Ear to the Earth. 2011. Ear to the Earth is a global com-
Arons, W. and May, T. J. (eds.) 2012. Readings in Perfor- munity of environmental sound artists responding to
mance and Ecology. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. climate change. http://twitter.com/ear2earth (accessed 14
Bakht, S. 2009. Noise, Nonsense, and the New Media December 2015).
Soundscape. eContact! 11(4). http://econtact.ca/11_4/ Ear to the Earth. 2015. Suspended Sounds. http://
bakht_newmedia.html (accessed 3 February 2016). eartotheearth.org/2015/01/suspended-sounds/ (accessed
Bandt, R., Duffy, M. and MacKinnon, D. (eds.) 2007. 21 February 2016).
Hearing Places: Sound, Place, Time and Culture. New- Gandy, M. and Nilsen, B. (eds.) 2014. The Acoustic City.
castle upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars. Berlin: JOVIS Verlag.
Barclay, L. 2012. Shifting Paradigms: Towards an Auditory Garrard, G. 2012. Ecocriticism, 2nd edn. Abingdon:
Culture. Proceedings of ISEA 2012 Albuquerque: Machine Routledge.
Wilderness. Albuquerque, NM: ISEA. http://socialmedia. Glotfelty, C. and Fromm, H. (eds.) 1996. The Ecocriticism
hpc.unm.edu/isea2012/sites/default/files/ISEA2012_ Reader: Landmarks in Literary Ecology. Athens, GA:
confproceedings_WEB.pdf (accessed 3 October 2014). University of Georgia Press.
Belgiojoso, R. 2014. Constructing Urban Space with Sounds Gordon, J. F. and Hill, C. 2015. Sustainable Fashion: Past,
and Music. Farnham: Ashgate. Present and Future. London: Bloomsbury Academic.
Bennett, J. 2010. Vibrant Matter: A Political Ecology of Gustafsson, T. and Kääpä, P. (eds.) 2013. Transnational
Things. Durham, NC: Duke University Press. Ecocinema: Film Culture in an Era of Ecological
Bergman, D. 2012. Sustainable Design: A Critical Guide. Transformation. Bristol: Intellect.
New York: Princeton Architectural Press. Guy, S. and Moore, S. A. (eds.) 2005. Sustainable
Besel, R. D. and Blau, J. A. (eds.) 2014. Performance on Architectures: Cultures and Natures in Europe and North
Behalf of the Environment. Plymouth: Lexington Books. America. New York: Spon Press.

Downloaded from https:/www.cambridge.org/core. Columbia University Libraries, on 31 May 2017 at 01:11:30, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
https:/www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1355771816000315
Ecological Sound Art 41

Heinlein, K. G. 2007. Green Theatre: Promoting Ecological O’Brien, A. 2016. Transactions with the World: Ecocriticism
Preservation and Advancing the Sustainability of Humanity and the Environmental Sensibility of New Hollywood. New
and Nature. Saarbrucken: VDM Verlag Dr. Mueller e.K. York: Berghahn Books.
Hermann, T., Hunt, A. and Neuhoff, J. G. (eds.) 2011. The Otsuka, T. and Sandberg, U. 2009. Environmental Sound
Sonification Handbook. Berlin: Logos Verlag. Art Technology. Proceedings of the 38th International
Hethorn, J. and Ulasewicz, C. (eds.) 2008. Sustainable Congress and Exposition on Noise Control Engineering:
Fashion: Why Now?. London: Fairchild Books. INTER-NOISE 2009. Ashland, OH: Noise Control
Ingram, D. 2000. Green Screen: Environmentalism and Foundation.
Hollywood Cinema. Exeter: University of Exeter Press. Pedelty, M. 2012. Ecomusicology: Rock, Folk, and the
Ingram, D. 2010. The Jukebox in the Garden: Ecocriticism Environment. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
and Popular Music Since 1960. Amsterdam: Rodopi. Polli, A. 2005. Heat and the Heartbeat of the City: Central
Kagan, S. 2013. Art and Sustainability: Connecting Patterns Park Climate Change in Sound. http://landviews.org/
for a Culture of Complexity, 2nd edn. Bielefeld: Transcript articles/heat-ap.html (accessed 28 January 2016).
Verlag. Rehding, A. 2011. Ecomusicology between Apocalypse and
Klein, N. 2014. This Changes Everything: Capitalism vs. The Nostalgia. Journal of the American Musicological Society
Climate. New York: Simon and Schuster. 64(2): 409–14.
Koutsomichalis, M. 2013. On Soundscapes, Phonography Rudi, J. (ed.) 2011. Soundscape in the Arts. Oslo: NOTAM.
and Environmental Sound Art. Journal of Sonic Rust, S., Monani, S. and Cubitt, S. (eds.) 2013. Ecocinema
Studies 4(1). http://journal.sonicstudies.org/vol04/nr01/ Theory and Practice. Abingdon: Routledge.
a05 (accessed 3 February 2016). Shedroff, N. 2009. Design is the Problem: The Future of Design
Krause, B. L. 1987. The Niche Hypothesis: How Animals Must Be Sustainable. Brooklyn, NY: Rosenfeld Media.
Taught Us to Dance and Sing. http://appohigh.org/ Spaid, S. 2002. Ecovention: Current Art to Transform
ourpages/auto/2010/12/21/52074732/niche.pdf (accessed Ecologies. Cincinatti, OH: Contemporary Arts Center.
28 January 2016). Stang, A. and Hawthorne, C. 2005. The Green House: New
LaBelle, B. 2006. Background Noise: Perspectives on Sound Directions in Sustainable Architecture. New York:
Art. London: Continuum. Princeton Architectural Press.
Lane, C. and Carlyle, A. 2013. In the Field: The Art of Field Titon, J. T. 2013. The Nature of Ecomusicology. Música e
Recording. Axminster: Uniformbooks. Cultura 8(1): 8–18.
Lavery, C. and Finburgh, C. (eds.) 2015. Rethinking the Truax, B. 2001. Acoustic Communication. New York: Ablex.
Theatre of the Absurd: Ecology, the Environment and the Velasco, M., Pohl, N. and Nieto, I. 2005. Water Issues in
Greening of the Modern Stage. London: Bloomsbury Chile: How Does a Dry River Sound? http://academia.
Methuen Drama. edu/11685879/Water_issues_in_Chile_how_does_a_dry_
Matilsky, B. C. 1992. Fragile Ecologies: Contemporary river_sound_Submission_Accepted._Network_Ecologies
Artists’ Interpretations and Solutions. New York: Rizzoli. (accessed 12 February 2016).
McKibben, B. 2005. What the Warming World Needs Now Voegelin, S. 2014. Sonic Possible Worlds: Hearing the
is Art, Sweet Art. http://grist.org/article/mckibben- Continuum of Sound. London: Bloomsbury.
imagine/ (accessed 14 March 2015). Von Glahn, D. 2013. Music and the Skillful Listener:
McKibben, B. 2009. Four Years After My Pleading Essay, American Women Compose the Natural World.
Climate Art Is Hot. http://grist.org/article/2009–08–05- Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.
essay-climate-art-update-bill-mckibben/ (accessed 14 Weintraub, L. 2012. To Life! Eco Art in Pursuit of a
March 2015). Sustainable Planet. Berkeley, CA: University of
Mellers, W. 2001. Singing in the Wilderness: Music and California Press.
Ecology in the Twentieth Century. Champaign, IL: Westling, L. (ed.) 2014. The Cambridge Companion to Lit-
University of Illinois Press. erature and the Environment. Cambridge: Cambridge
Miles, M. 2014. Eco-Aesthetics: Art, Literature and University Press.
Architecture in a Period of Climate Change. London: Willoquet-Maricondi, P. (ed.) 2010. Framing the World:
Bloomsbury Academic. Explorations in Ecocriticism and Film. Charlottesville,
Minney, S. 2011. Naked Fashion: The New Sustainable VA: University of Virginia Press.
Fashion Revolution. Oxford: New Internationalist. Winderen, J. 2013. Silencing of the Reefs, Dardanella, Belize
Monacchi, D. 2011. Recording and Representation in 3–14 December 2012. http://janawinderen.com/fieldtrips/
Eco-Acoustic Composition. In J. Rudi (ed.) Soundscape sielncing_of_the_reefs_dardane.html#.V6Sq1FfgVbw
in the Arts. Oslo: NOTAM. (accessed 16 January 2016).
Morton, T. 2010. The Ecological Thought. Cambridge, MA: Wright, M. 2015. Contact Zones and Elsewhere Fields: The
Harvard University Press. Poetics and Politics of Environmental Sound Arts. PhD
Natural World Museum 2007. Art in Action: Nature, thesis, University of the Arts, London. http://ualre
Creativity and our Collective Future. San Rafael, CA: searchonline.arts.ac.uk/8662/1/Wright-PhD-thesis-2015.
Earth Aware Editions. pdf (accessed 3 February 2016).

Downloaded from https:/www.cambridge.org/core. Columbia University Libraries, on 31 May 2017 at 01:11:30, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
https:/www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1355771816000315

You might also like