Semoogle - An Ontology Based Search

Engine

Nooshin Aghajani

Master in Information Systems

Submission date: June 2012
Supervisor: Torbjørn Skramstad, IDI
Co-supervisor: Jingyue Li, Det Norske Veritas (DNV)

Norwegian University of Science and Technology

Department of Computer and Information Science
   
     

 


 

  


   
   
  !" # $%

$&! '" 


  
()!"
*
)"   
()!" (
  +)

) +!!
    



 
(    , (      

-.
*
)"   
()!" (
  +)

) +!!  ( $
&! '" 

  
()!"-$$'./
( ( 
 ( 
)0 
   -*)) .   
  
(
 " ( $% - $ %.  !!  )!"
 
( !  (   "  
"/ 
 & )
  )
     ( / ( ( ( ( ( "
&))   !(  
( !  
1
))" 

( !/
 
 &) )  1 ( "  2    ( 
 !
 (!( ( & &( ( (/ 
)"  &) )  
&)!
/!" #  $% 3
(    ( ()  !
  
! 
/
" )  $$' (
  ( &   / ! 4) (
( ()  &( ( )  !  ( 
( 
  ( ! ))

 
/ " 
) ( !    "  5" ( 
 &( ()  ! !!   ( 
  (   ))
  / 5)  &) )  
&)! )) " (  
))! &(
   " & " ! ( & (   !/
 ) 6 " !  " )" 
)   ))" ! 

(!  /
# 7  )! 7  &) )  ( " ) ( 8  ( ) 
!   ))   ( (   (&!    
 &( "
"/ (   
  "/

$( 5!(
(  


  
  


( () (  9   )  )

! 
(
!/  ( &" )! )"   )  1 ( 
 ( )
&  9/
( " ! ! )!"      9  ( )
 
  "  
"  & )  &( ! & 
   ! (  / ( (  ) 
!0 
 
!/   &(   ( (    )!"  :6)
  1  ( ( 
1
  ( 1)  "/
(  
  ( "    ( )"  ;

"  


( !  )!"    
( (  9  !  
 
) 
(/ *
! 
) 8" 
( 2   "/
( )! 
( )
  )  ) 
( !  (
    ( ;

"  & )
 - !)./
 </  
 2    $$'
  / !" # $%





( =    )  
( ! (  =
  ;
 
(

) &(   (!( 9)"
))
  
/ )
 
(
))
  6! (   
(! &)) 9  )    =/
5( )    (  ! & )/ >" ! 


(  )!" 
(9 (   ( 
  
()   
/ 

(     
( &(
( 
  ! ( ! 
 9  )

! 
(!/ ( 9  1 ( ! 
 9   !   ( !  ( 9"  )
& ( 9/ >" 
(! ( 
 ( 9 ( 
  ( ?
&))  !) (  (   
( )
/
 

( )! )"   )  1 (

 ( 
  ( ) ! / 
 (  

  

1
 )!    ( 
1
/ 5

!  ( !
( !  ", 9  )  ! 
  =  ( 

(  
)/ ?( ( 
  ( 
( "  
"   )

 (   "  9  
1  ( /
 ( ( &   "  
( !  (& (& 
(  


( )
   )!" 
(9
      
 ( 9)"  ) 
( )
   ) 
( !/
( "  )   9"  ) &(
(  )!"   (
) 
(    1
!/ ( 1     (
)  
( ! "   )" )!"  1 ( ! 
( ) & ( 9  )   ( "/ $6
!0 
( ) 
      ( 9)"  ) 
(  

!0 )/ ( )!"   ( 
( ! " 
) )
   "  
"  &(
( 
)   1  ( 

   " ( )!"  ( ( 1)  "/ ( 
 

 " 

(! ( 
( 9" (!( ( ? ! @!) 
 )

 
( !/ ( )
  ! )!( 
!0  !0
( )  @!) 
(  
! // 8" 
( 2 
 "/ ( 1
!
    ( (
! 
  
  (  ! =
!0/

( )  ( ) " ) ( ( 
( ! &  
(  6
/ 8&   ( 
 ( (   ! "
))"
&( ( 
(     ;
)    1 

( !
(

 )) , /



  
  
  
  
  
/ >
! / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 
/ 2
 @) / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 
/A 5
( / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / A
/B +6
 3) / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / A
/C 4)  ( 
 / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / C
    !
/ 
? / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / <
/  3) / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / D
/A 4)!" / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / D
/B ? 4)!" #!!74?# / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / D
/C 

( / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / E
/F )  4)!" / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / E
/< 3) ? / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 
/</ 4)!"  ) ( 
 / / / / / / / / / / / / 
/</ $ 23+ )!" 
( 

) 
 
 / 
" #  $ % &
A/ 
( +! / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / C
A/ 

( +! / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / D
A/A @!) 
( +! / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / E
A/A/ *
) 2
  @!) 
( +! / / / / / / / / / / / / / E
A/B 3
"  " / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 
A/C 
? 5
(
  
( +! / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 
A/F 
(!  >&! #  &( ? + 5
(
 / / / / / / / A
6
 
A/< 
(9G5)!(  
( +! / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / B
A/</ !  )! 5)!( / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / C
A/D   ( 5 / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / <
A/D/ 4)!"  
( +! / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / <
A/D/ 
 

( +! / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / D
A/D// 
()!  
 / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / A
'      # "&
B/ ()!" / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / AC
B// !  ?!( >   *9
" -*. / / / / / / A<
B/// 80) ?!(-#. / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / AD
B/// %
) ?!(-8
. / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / AE
B/ 5)!(  *
  !) / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / B
B/A !! 4)!" / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / B
B/B )  ! / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / BC
B/B/ *& / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / BC
B/B/ )  ! !" / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / BF
& $   &
C/ +)   / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / C
(  &!
F/ 5!  !) / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / C<
F/ #  !) / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / CD
F/A * ? / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / CE
! ) (
* + ("
 , - ,+  ./- (!
* + ) - 0

6
    
/ ( "
) 
( +! 2
 HI / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 
/ +6
 2
  ( " / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / B
/A 4&  ( !! 5
( / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / B
/ (  )) &  (  )!" HI/ / / / / / / / / / / / / 
/ ( 
"  (  )!" HI/ / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 
/A 4)!" ) 8
(" @) %&  $ 23+ 4)!" HAI/ / / / / A
A/ 8!( #) @!) 5
(
 HBI / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 
A/ 
( 2
  3 HCI / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / A
A/A " 5
(
  ? + HFI / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / B
A/B *)&
(  5)!( H<I / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / F
A/C    HCI/ / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / D
A/F J" 
  +6
 J+K " HDI / / / / / / / / / / / / A
A/< 
3 5)!(  
 HDI/ / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / A
B/ !! &  ( " / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / AF
B/ !) 
(  
 / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / AF
B/A !) ) 
( / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / A<
B/B !! 5)!(    !" 3! / / / / / / / / / / / / / AD
B/C )
  !" 3! 5)!(780) ?!( / / / / / / AE
B/F )
  !" 3! 5)!(7%
) ?!( / / / / / / / B
B/< 
)  $ 23+  4 4)!" HAI / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / B
B/D 
)  
"  &( 
  5
  ) / / / / / B
B/E 
)  
"  &( 5  ) / / / / / / / / / / / BA
B/ 
)  
"  &( (  ) / / / / / / / / / / BA
B/ 
)  
"  &( %))"  ) / / / / / / / BB
B/ 
)  "  &( 2("
)   ) / / / / / / / BB
B/A 
)  
"  &( !  ) / / / / / / / / / BB
B/B 
     9"  !) 
 / / / / / / / / / / / / / / B<
B/C 
   
(!  9" &( 6!   ( )!" ) / / BD
B/F 
   
(! 6 9" ! @!) 
( ! / / / / / BD
B/< 
  
!0! ( @!) 
( )   
!" / BE
B/D 
   1) )   / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / BE
6
#  *!
B/E 2
  ( &() 
  ) !" / / / / / / / C
C/  ( )
"   '3#  L%M 9"  !)
 @!)  (   " / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / CA
C/  ( )
"   '3#  L? %M 9"  
!)  @!)  (   " / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / CB
C/A  ( )
"   '3#  L 55M 9"  !)
 @!)  (   " / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / CC
C/B  ( )
"   '3#  L 6 %M 9" 
!)  @!)  (   " / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / CC

6
  
5
52 5)
 2!! 

5# 5"(
#)
)
4 
) 4)!"
@+3 @(!) :6 
@' @(
) ' 

8 # 8" 6  #!!
    
 
()!"
3  3)
N> N&)! >
@+ 
" @ +6 
$#2 $) #!! 2
!
4?# ? 4)!" #!!
J+K J" 
  +6

3* 3
 
 *&
3* 3
 
 *& O
(
55 " ) 5  5
9
452 ) 4
 5

 2
)
? + 
? 
( +!
!) 
@!)
 ) ( 

*  *9
"
' # '1 
) #!! "
'$ 2 ' $  2
  
 
'3 ' 3
 1
'3# ' 3
 #

% %
 
 )
?A ?) ? ? 
K # K)  #!!

6
#  *!

6
 
 
 

>" 
! (   ? !  
  ( ? &( ! (

( !  &))  ) )   )  9 
 ( ?/ ( (!   
  ( ? (

())! 

(! (!( ( ?   )/ 5  &  ( ) (

 ! ( ) L

( !M/ 5 
( !   )
 

(! (!( 
  ( ? &( ( "&  ! " ( / 5)
( ! )  

)) &  
( (!( ( 
 "

( !/ '))" (  &)) 1 (  " !  "& 
&  ( 
( ! &))  
(  ( "&   ( )
" ( )
/   
( ) ( (!( 9)" 
  )

   ( 
( !/ ( "
) 
   
( !  (&  *! /
  ;
)  (    ( &() 
 ( ( 
( !/
'! 6! )( !    
1
    
)   (
 (!  ) 
( 

)/ ( (  "
!  ) &(  
(!  ( 9  1 ) )/ 4)!"
  3) -3. (   ) &(
( ) (   
(


 ( ( "&/ ( (
  
( ( 
( ! "
! ( )!"   ) /

    
(  !)  ( 
   )    
( ! "/ (
&    L$ 23+ )!"M  )0 ( 

( "   

1
/ ( $ 23+ )!" 
 )"  )

 !" 
 
 HAI/ ( 
)   )!"   

!  (
!) $ 23+ )!"/ (    )!"  1  " 
 ( / 


Search Engine Page

Filter Through Results

Yes
Exhausted
Results

No

Select Result

Assess Page Quality

No Good
Match

Yes

*! / ( "

) 
( +! 2
 HI


 /A/ 5
(

"  
)  ! 1   " (   "/ (
  ( 
   ! (   ! ( )!"  


(  
( !/
( 
 ( ()  
( & ! ( 
(  ) 
( ))&! 
• !! ( ) &  
( !  ) "/
• >)!  )!"   "  
"     1 (
) & ( /
• ! @(
) ' 
 -@'. )  
 ( , 9" 
)( ( ) 
(/
• 
(! @!) ! ( @!) 52 
( )
/
• !0! ( )  1
!/
• +)! ( )  )
  ) @!) 
( )/
• 
)! (    

 )  )/

( 
" ! 
  1! / (& ( 6
 
   


 (  /

  
( 
  & )!  

( "    
))"

( )!"/ ( 
&)! 9  ( 
(  

(
   ( &  " ( (  ( 
 ) M5 "
#
3&  & 
"  55 
" 6"  4)!"M   

)0 
  ))  HEI/
(    ( 
 
  6)! &"   ( 

(
)!"  )" ! )!
/ (  &  &  
(

) =
  (   &( ( 1)  "/ *! /A
))  &  ( !! 
(/
  

( 
  ( (   

( ! " &(
(   )!" 

( (  9/ (  ) 
( 
!0  
!0
)/ (!( ( )  ( ) " ( 9"  !"
A
 ( / 


Investigating related works in literature

Building ontology to define the relationship between the terms

Creating Graphical User Interface (GUI)

Searching Google using the Google API search

Categorizing the results at predefined categories

Evaluating the results of application vs. traditional Google search results

Discussion and Conclusions

*! / +6

 2
  ( "
Ontology
User query Query expansion
Google search engine

Google search results

Final result Categorize results Categorize Interpretation of

the Search results

*! /A 4&  ( !! 5

(
B
 /C/ 4)  ( 


 &(  "& 
( (! )!(  ( ) 
 
(  "  
( &( 
  "& 
(/
 
  ! 
"
(   ( (  !0  ))&
)   !  &  ( ) & &(
(  9  
( 
/  1 )) ( "

 ) &(  (   ( (/
)  " 
) ( ) " &(
( ) (    9
1  /
)  '  ( !  )   
( !  &))
)) " !  ( !
"
)/
)  & ) ( )   
( ! &(
(   )
   

( ! 
 ( )"  ;

" 
!) 
( ) &( ( )  @!) 
( !/
   (  1! !  ( )  ( !) 
( !
 
/     ( 
(  ( 
/
*))"   ! 

)  ( )   ( (/

C
 ( / 


F
 
  
(
(   &  ( ) ) & &(
(  9
 

   ( (/  1 )) ( "

 ) &( 
(   ( (/

 #" $%

  
 
   
     




 
 
  
   
      

 


    ! "  # 

  
  
 
 $
  %& '(() HI
 ( 
  ( & ! 

 " 
?/ ( 

?   )"     ( ?  )    6  (

 /   ( 

  ( 
? ( 
   

)  
(/ ( 
( () ( 

  (    &(

(
 
   
! ) HI/

?  ( 6 !  ( ?) ? ? &(
( 
) (

( 
)   
! ( !  ( ? 
/  )
& 
? ) ( 
( !  & !   &

  (  &"   ( ! &()     

 HI/ ( 


?   )"  ?  
  )  ?  ) & 

! ) &) 
 // 
 
(  ) )
  /
( )! (   )  ( 
? / (  !)  
)!   ! (

) 
     ) (  &(
(

 )  / 1! (
)6 ! &))  )
<
 ( / 3) ?
" ( )!"

/

 & "  '

(  3) ( " 

/ 8&   

1)  "
 3) !(  1 
 3) -3. 1  ) -))" 
.   

 -))" 6. ( 1   9 &( )!
))
 -
))"  
./  1 )
 (  3)

 ! &(

1
)
  )" 
   "   ( (  

 
))" ( )    
(  ) )&"
 
    )1)) ( ,   HI/
   (
4)!"   


  " = 1)  ( = ! 
 
  /!/ )" 

 ()("  &)! /8&
 !) 
  (  

 ! 
 ( ! & )

 HAI/
( ()(  ( ! 
   
  ( )!"/ 
",   )!"  ( & (  = )  (  ()(
)
/ 
 

  )!"   
  &)!   
  (
  &(
(   
( 
) 
1
 &(  ))" 1
! HBI/
   ) )!  
)) ( 
)" 
(  
(
! (   !G!  !0  !
 &!  
(   " ( )
 ( )! 
=

 HCI/
 $%   ( )
*$)
>( 4?#  3*  ?A 
   ( )!  )!/
4?#   (   3*  &(
(  ) 6     
!   (
)6 &)!/ (    ! 4?# & 
)"  1  ) )
 & 6"  ( )!!   ) ;

! // 
))"/    ! (  
(
 & = ! 
6" (  )!!  4?# 
  4?# (  ! 6
D
 /C/ 

(
 4?# *))4?# #  4?# # HBI/ 4?# *))
 4?# #  4?# #/
4?# #
 4?# #/ 4?# #  ) 6 ( 4?# *))  4?# #
 4?# *))  " 6/
 #" #
 !) 

(   6   ) 
( )/
     3) -3. 
()!" " !   ( 

? / 


(
 
   )
  ( 

?  
(/ ( 
(

 ( 
& &(
(  =  (
!  ( ?) ? ?  
(! (

  ( !) 
/ ( ) 3  )   ( 


  &  
/
' (
6 ( 
( ! /!/ @!) 
( &(   (
(" ) 
  ( ?/ (" ( 
  
( )
   & !  
  ( 
? " = )
 ! ) 
( HFI/

+ !' "   (
 
 " )  )!" ( 
 "
  ?) ? ?
 =  
(  
 )

) )  ! 
/   ( ! 
( )!  "  
!0  !0 ( 
   "  /
 
 ( ! 
  ) )!  )  ))&! H<I
•  (
 !  ( 
   ! ) 
& !
•  ) (   (  &)!

•     6)

)"

•   (  &)!  ( ) &)!

•  )"0 (  &)!

4)!"  9  )  


( !/ (  !  (

) )!"   
 (  &)!  6) ( ) 
&
!  = &
  1/ 5) )!
   


  

     (  &)!/ >" )!

(  &))  )  6 ( 9  
)"  !)" &(
(
)   
  
)) / *))" (!( )!
)
) 1
 
 
( 
(  " (
 
 )) 
 
E
 ( / 3) ?

( 
))" HDI/
( 
 !)  )! )!  (!
 ! 
( 
   ! )G& ! H<I/
  
)" ( 
 &  & )  )! ! )
  &  6 
/

,  $ 
 ( 
 &   )) &  ( ) 
(  )
&  (   
)!"/


      
4  ( =
 

) 
(  )!"  1  ( 1)  
)
)!"/ ) ( 
 (
)
) =
 
(

 
 !   ( 
) )  ! (/ ( !)
 ( )!"   ) !  )"   !0!  " )!

) /    
  &)!   )  &)) !
)!" &))  9/ ( )!" &(
(    L) ( 

4)!"M  
  " 
)  ( / 
  ( 

)   D 

/
) ( 
 - . (  ) ("  
)6 
) 

/
>  ( !  )! (" )" 

) )   " 
()!" 
)! 
 &)! 
!    (  ! &)!


) "/  HI (   &   / (" ! ( (
 )!"   !  ( ) &    
&)! !  &)!   
(   / *! / (&
( &/ (   )) )!  ( 1) &(
(
  ) 
    ( ( 1)/ * 6) ' # -'1 
) #!! ".
   ( )  ) )! 
) )!  )!"  
 &(
(  
 !! 
) )!"/ 5) @+ )!"  
" 6
 @ )!"    ! 
/

(  ( ( )!   )!" (  &   1 (


 (
("    1 ( ) & (

  )! (
)!"/ * ( 

   & (  

  &

      

  &(
(  (&  *! // L(


 )


) (  (

  &)! 
(  
)/ ( 
)

 ( 

"  


 /</ 3) ?

*! / (  )) &  (  )!" HI/

)( 

) &(
(  )!"
) ()/M - 1! /./

*! / ( 

"  (  )!" HI/

*( ) 
( 

 
  (
!  ( )!"
 
  HI/

 ( / 3) ?
  !   ""    #$$ "

$ 23+   & " 3+2 +' 2
 &( (  )) *2<   + < 
- 
) 
 2
./ ( 
   $ D   
4
 / $ 23+ 
(
())! &  ))& HAI
• 5)"  )!  
 &

) 
  
)"!

 &
• !!  )! ;
!! )!(   55 ;

&( 9 !

• +6)!    )" ! 
(  ! ( )
 
55 "
• 1!  ) 
1!) 
(
  55 "

• )  !  
" 
(9  55 "

* ( )

   & ( $ 23+ 
 
 )"  )


 !"   
/ $ 23+ 
   )! 
  
1! 
(9 
(  22 -2  2.  ) !

1!/  
) $ 23+ 
   !! (
(


 22  (   !( 55 " ! 
" 
/ $ 23+
  ! ( 1    !  
1! 
&/ 5 !
"
  )   (    

! 
( " ! &((  &(  
  
"  1))" !! (

"G
1!G 
(   ( 9
))! 
/
 $ 23+ )!" )) 
   "   & 
"
"  55 
 
 ( &    ))
/ ( ))
  6) " ( )!  
/ ( 
"
" &( ( )!"
 
    
)1
 &( 
 )( ! 
" / ( 
)  $ 23+ )!"

 ( ))&!

 HAI
• 5-"(! ( ( )  ( !0.
• %)) -
) &     !   &(
(
 
6) " (.
• ( -)
   & 
 &(
( " )  (  
"  !0.
• 
  


• ! -

 
  
( ( 
 )).


 /</ 3) ?
+
(
) (  & / 2 
 ) 
  

)  ( 
   / ( 

 & 

) %))  & %))  5  )   
/ ( ) & %))  !  ) " ( !,
 HAI/ (  (
("  ( )!"
)    *! /A

*! /A 4)!" ) 8

(" @) %&  $ 23+ 4)!" HAI/
$6
( 
  
( ! 
(  @!)  ( ) 
(9
 
()!   (
 
( !/

A
 ( / 3) ?

B

! "  #  
(
(   &  ( ) )  
( ! 
()! 
 9 1   ( "//

 # 
4  (  )  (!( 1) 
  (   
( !/ 

" 
 &   (    & ;
)  (   1 (
)  ( 
( ! (   ()   1 ( 
 ( ("    (   ( ?/ 5

!  ( " 


( ! 0  ( 
( !   
? )"  
 )  ) ( 

( !/ >" 0  ( 
( !

( )
     ) 

   ( (
) ) 
(/ ( 0
     

(  
   ( ) 
(   , /
( ) =
 & )  

( !  

  )& HEI/
%     1
• N"&-.    ( ! /
• (   " )( & ( "& - )""   "
""./
• (  , ( !  ( "/
• (  & 
(  LM LM LM LM LM///     

 
&))    ( 
( 
/
• ')  () ( )! ) 9/

C
 ( A/ 
( +! 
()!
#    1
• P  ))&   9/

• (  )( & & -""  )""  !)./

• ( "& ( !  ( "/

• (  &    

/

• 5)  () ( )! ) 9/

5   (   ( ) 
( ! 
  "&
&( (   )( & ( "&  / 
( 
  )
  ) 
( !/ ?(  

( ! (  )
! "& !  
1
!  ( "&  ( "/
 &( (  
(  )! ) 9 

( !

)"   
  (  1 ) & 9  )!"/ 
) 
( ! (&  
) 
! ( =
   )
 
) & "&/
 ( ) 
( ! (    
  1! ( 

&(
(  
( " , 9"/ 
( ! 
( 9 !  6 (
("
/ ( 6
  ( &  
( 
  (  
  ( )
 &( ( 
/ ( 
))  L 1)M/ 5 
(
!  3 "
  ) ) HI
•  1 ( )  
   ( 

!    &(
(  
(/ ( 
 
   
))  (  $)0 ( 
     1 Q >
( 
    ) Q )   ! 

 
Q 1 ) 6) )  
Q ) 
&Q  Q +6
 6 Q  &!(Q   
(   1) ! &(
( ( 
( ! 
(    
(
9  
/
• 2+ 1 ( ) (  ) / (   9"

!   ))& -&( (    
!   
(! 

  L 
(M. 0 9" Q )  &Q  &Q 
9" Q +6 9" Q  &!(/ (!(  "


 (  (  
  
( ( 9"  (  1)  " 
   )
 ! ( 
!/ 
 
! ( " 
&( 9" 
!/     
  ( 
 
6  
!   
) 
  /
8& ( )! ( &  ) ( (!( ( 9)"  )/ (
F
 A// 
( +!

( " ! 
( &(     (   
9)"/ 2)
)" )) 
( ! ))"
(   " (!( 9)"
(!  " 
  
( !/
• #     1 
(! (  1)  
 
 ( 9" 9   )"  L
(!M/   "
))"  
 " 
(   &(( ( 
(   ( 1 & 1  ))
   9" 
!/ ?( (
) 
! 9 
) &!(  >) 9" 
(!   ) ( &( ( )
  $) #!! 2
! -$#2.  9" !  &!( >)
)/  ) ))& ( ( ) ( 
  ( 9"
  ( 
(! )!( ( ) ) ( ) 6

 " ) 9 
(   &  ! 9 ! ( 
!))" &  HI/
8!  &(
(   
  ! 
( ( 9" 9
   !  )" 
 
 & ( 9"  
(

G!   ( 
! )!(  " ( "/
! )!
( !    ( 
G
  9" -.  9
"
  - 9
" O  
 9
". >) )!
)1)) 
9"  &!(/  
( !  
! )!( &(
(   
 

  (  ) ! 
   )
("  
G! HI/
•     +1 5
! ( )"  
( 
  ( 
  
 ( "    )  ( / ( (

 ( !  ( 
 !   ( ) ( "  
&))  ( 
(  ( 
  9" &!(! 
(/ * 6
)  
( ! )" 9 ( 
  " )( 
! 
( 9" 

! "&(  "    

/ ( 
( !
&) 
  " = ! ( (  &(
(  )!
))"


 (!  ( 
  9"   ( )0 (
   &!(! 
( HI/ ?( ( 
( !  
(  ) ) !  (  &(
 ( )"
)
  ))& (
", )   ( )
 
G!/  (
 "

 !  (  ( !  ))& (     )


   " ( 9"   ( ) (" ( !/  
(  (  )) ( " &)) (   9"  
:
 ( )  " 
    ( 
( &( (  9"
 
 (  &   
   )  !  
 
( ) 
(/ (   ( ) ()   HI/
(   "   ()!    !   

<
 ( A/ 
( +! 
()!
G!/   ( "  &(
(  (  

  ) 
(  #
  Q # )"Q 2)"Q  
2)
Q #!(Q 26"  9" Q 2 /
?()  
  L
(M ( 
(  
(! 
  )"   
)/ +
(  (  ) "
 ( 6
  6
 ) (

 ! &( ("   

( !/
>  ( ( !
 ( ?
&)!  6 "  
(
!/ ?
&)!  )"  
 
"  )) (  !  ) 

! "  

( ! ( &)) 6 ( &) !    
(/
&)!  9  )"  !(! (   
  ) 
 (    / 5 ( 1 
 !
 ( 


( ! &(
(   "  )    )
 (  
  
( & 6
))"   "& 
(!/ 5&
!  
 @!) &(
(  6
   -. &( (  

! &( (" (    

( ! HBI/   ( )) ?
&)
! @!) ( (  ?
&)! "  / @!)   )! 
) 
(
!  ( !)  ( 
( !  L  "  ( ) ( 
9)"  
))" HBI/M
 !) 
( !
  "
  ( 
(
 &(
(
& !(  ( & 
)"/ ( 6! 
(
    
(

  EED &( !" >  #&
 2!   '" 
( 
(
  ( 
( !  ( 
)/  ( 1 ! 

( ! ( 9"   
( !  6  ))   ( 

/ 5 ) ! &(  )  )) (  
    (
 HCI/

 #" # 

 

( ! 
  ? 
    

?  )  )
)6 9 
! (
6 &( ( ?

  !/ >" !(! ( 
()!  
(9  
? (

( !    ( )  
(!/  !) ( &() 

 

( !    ( ))&!  HEI
/ (  9    ( )

  ( 
 
6
/
/  

    )  9" (  )
( ! ( )!"
A/ ( )    ( /
D
 A/A/ @!) 
( +!
   )" 

( & (   ) &( ( )!" /
(   )!"
  ()(" (  L( 

  &(   ( 
 
  
   
  )  "   
)"M HDI/
(   ?  (  &( 6)  )!" 
(  P(R
!  4S 
" 50/
 

)! ?$ @4 -@ 4
)!". -&&&/!)!"/!. '1 
) #!! " -' # .  '$
2 )!"  
  
/ (  "   )! &(
(

    (  " HDI

• )!
) )! &(

  &   
  &

• 
)! &(

  
  
  


•  ) )! &(


  )      
 
 
 -
(     
(./
( 1  

(     "  )
 )  
( , 
   )   (   )      ) ?
!/ ( ( !  ( 

( !
 () )! ) 9/

 ( 

(   )!"     
 


) ( )  "& 
(/ ( &)) )" () ( 

(
" 

)" " 
 HEI/
   # 
@!)  (    &) 
( !  ( &)  (  /
 & 
  EEF " #" 2!  !" >/ @!)    
(
!   ))  
( ! -  ) &  ? 
". HI/ (

 
  ( 
) 
  ( @!) 
( !/
%% &$     '    
 ( 
 & 
 ( 
)
  @!) 
( !  ! (
  &  (& ( 
( !  @!) &/ 5 1! A/ (& (
&
&)! -&)!  & !.   " ) 
&)/
#  '3#   
( " (
&)   "  '3# / ( 
( ?
!  (   (  &( ( & ! 
  
  "/ (     -
.  " & ! &(
(  !
&(  & '3#      ? !/ ( 6! 
   "
( 6  ( / ( 6  
(!     
 
)!
! ( " 
!  ! ( 
/ +" 
 

     & 



)) (/ ( &    

E
 ( A/ 
( +! 
()!
 6    0 
)0  
 " (/ ( ( 
(      )
!  ))"  & 6/ 5(
 
  ( 6  !  )) ( )  
( & !  !
   (   
( 1)/ >    
( 1)    &( 
( )      ( 6  ( )/
( 
( 1)  &  " ( '3# )/ 5) ) '3# 

 ) '3#     
 " ( '3# )/ (   (!(
! ( 
( 6  ( & 6 
!  &( ( 
 ( (

(  / ( '3# ) !    ) &(
(    
/
( )    
 2!3  )) ( 
/
(   ( ) &(
(   " 
/ (   )1
 
 ( " &  ! (  6/ #!  )) " 

 ( / (  ) 
  )  &  =  ( 
6/ 5 !
)) #6
  ( ) !( &( ( )6
 

" ( 6  !  & )6
    " ( 
(/ ( 
( 
 "  &    ( )6
 ) " #6
 !( &( ( 
6  ( 2!3  & 9 HBI/

 ! ( ) !   )   " 
( ! 
)  (  
  " 
( ! HAI/ 8
 
   
(
! &))  (!()"   ) &(( ( 
( !   ( (
( 
( !  /  HAI 
 
!0  & 

. ' 2
 . 
( ! 
/ (  
 ( , 
 &(( 
( !
 (  6
/ ( )  ( 
( !
 " 
  (  &(
(  (  )  1 ( ) 
, 9"/

  '( & "  #("

( 1 !  
( !
  ( "  "  

"/ ("  
 -6. 
( !   
( !/

 !  
( !   )   ( 1 ! 
 )"
)"/ $&" ! &( )  
)  

(/ 4 6)  @!)
() &(
(  
1

)  ( 
&( 
! (  
(! ( &/
( =
 & ( 1 !  ( 
 !  (!()!(
"  ))&! 6)/  ( 1 !  
(!  ! 1) ( 
(   ( 9 "&  ( &   ( 
 )  

 A/C/ 
? 5
(
  
( +!

*! A/ 8!( #) @!) 5

(
 HBI
? &(
(
 (   ( !/ (  (  ( 
) (!( ( ?  1 ( !/  
 ! ( 
 ( 


( / ( 
 1 ( )  ))
 "  & "&  ("
    )  (   ( ? !/ (   ( ( 
(
! ( 
 &)  " 6) 
  !  ) "

( !/ ( 
( !
 
)" ( 

  (   ( !

 " &   6) 
/

 #" $% 

  # 
5
 !&! (   ( ? 
( ! 
()!" ( )/ @!)

 ( ( 
 " &))/ 8&  )) ) "  !)
 

 ( 
  ( "&
9)" @!)   )   ( 

 ( "&  1!  ) )/ 8&  
 " @!) 
 " ! 
 &   9 
(!

 

 ( A/ 
( +! 
()!
) HFI/ @!)   "&  
( !/     ) 
)6
 !(! / 
 
  (  ! 
  (
  
( ! "/ * 6) 

)
 ( )
( 
( ! " 

()! &(
( ( 
( !  )  
(
( 9" "

) !    "& 
(!/

(   )  @!) 

 &(
(  )  )
  
  8 #

/ 
 
( )" ( )  ! !
 !
)"

 &( 
 !  )! HFI/

$&  " ( 


(
   )   !" >  #&

2!,  (   !! 
  
 "

9" 
(! 
 

(
 HCI/ 

)
 ( 
( ( 
()!
-

(!.  ( 
( !  @!) (  
 


(! 
()!   
( !  / (  ( ( 

( 
  ( 
( ! ))!/ (  &)) () (   1  )
)   ))
/ 

( )
 = 
(  ) &( (

  ( 
 ( ( 
(! "&  "! 
  1
( "&  
  9/ 5     "& "   )


  ( ( ( 

 "    ( !  )  HCI/

*! A/ 

  (!( )) &  (
   

(
! 
(
/ ( 
  ( 
 

!  HCI 
)
6! 9"! 
(!  ! )   ) !/
 ( 1! 
 ( ( & 6 &(
(  ( (" ( 


  9 ( 
  (

  ( )(/ 5) (
 
 ( 


/  !) )
  

)1
  1  ( )/

 ( 
(
 &(
(    HCI (   )"  ( )

( 
  
)"  &))/ 6) 
  6 &(
( 
(" ( 

  ( " 
  ) " (

/  ( 9 &(

(    
(! 
 &))  
)  !) " (
/ 5) ( )( & 


  ( 
/ (

 & " 
  (
)(    )!"  ( 6 &(
(    
) (
)"  ( 
?/


 A/F/ 
(!  >&! #  &( ? + 5
(


Semantic layer

Syntactic layer

Querying
Navigation

Pages indexing Index Search & Rank

Navigation
List of terms

Ontology

Presentation

*! A/ 

( 2
  3 HCI
+ #   - ) ! - #$#


 HFI ( (
) ( ( )0  
? 
( +!- ? +.
) &  
(
())!
/ ( "  
)  )!   
/ ( "     ( 
  (! "  
)"
:
! 
))
   )!   
/
 ( !  )  ? + 
?   (
)!   ))" )
)  
(  / ') 9 



? 
( ! ? +   
   ()  "



  
( &(
(     )  


! 
1 "& ? +   ! ( ) &) /  ? +

 (   ))&  
" "& 9    6  
&(   )  ) / (" )   (    

/ *! A/A (&  (!( )) &  ? + 
(
 " (&! ( 

/ ( 
(
 ))" ))& (  ) 8 # 
( !/
 ) ( 1! (& (   
(
  ? + " (&! (

 )  
(!  )
) 6  3* ?  )  
(/
( 
) 
  ( "   ))& HFI
• (
&) 

     '3 -' 3

 1.  
 )!   3*   ( ?/
A
 ( A/ 
( +! 
()!

*! A/A " 5

(
  ? + HFI
•(
)
   1 "" -// 9). 1
 (  

) (  

!  ( 9)

 /
• ( !
  )  )"  (
&)  
 
 
! ( 
  ) )  (  -(
!
 )
 '3 
 
 " (
&) &(
! ( )  )"./
• ( !
 )0 &  &(
(  ) " ( (

  (   -( !
 ) 9 '3 

  ) ( &(  
  ./
• ( 6!
   6 &(
(  (  )
 9 " (  
/
9)" ( 9" 
!   

 
 9 
( 6 )  (  /
( 
(
 (  )" &( ) 
( ! 
( 
&)!
!  6!   (   (
 )  ()! 3*
  
)
  ( !
 HFI/

, ./
0 "  # 
(  &"  )! ( 
( !  ! ( 9)"  
 
( )  ( 
( !/ 
   ( ? ()     

(!  ( " ()   9
)" ;

" 
&)!  6!
 "   
( !/ +
))"  @!) (    

&)! 6!  !/ >" ! 

(9  )!( 
( !

 (  

   ) )    HBI/

B
 A/</ 
(9G5)!(  
( +!
4  ( ) !!  )  
! ( ) 

   ) 
(/ (   
  ))"  " ! )!(/
( ! )!(  (
   ) " HI/
   ( ! )!(  )! ! )!( &(
( 
 ( L9)"M  ( &  (  ( &"  ! -
). 

  (  ( ("
     ( ! !  !
()!"/
5
))"
)! ( )
  " ())   
( ( 
(
) &(
( (" ))" / 3
)" ! 
( 

   
)!
( )  
( !/ ( 
(    (  H<I
34 '! ( !  8  2!3 )!( HBI   

 -A/A/. (" )"0 ( (") ! ( ? ! 
) ( !
&( ( )   (  
(/
#4 ( 
( &(
(   " 8 S! HCI   )"! (
6 )! 
)! 
( ! )/ >" ( ( ( ! &))
 )  
 
( )   
   (  6
)! )!( 

) ( )/

%4 ( 
( &(
(   " 2 8! ?! HFI " ! 
!  ,  !  )!(  0 (  
)! )/
( )!      ( 
1
) ( (!(   (
) &))  )
 /
$& ) )!(    & ) )/ 4
  & )!(
  )  ! ( 
  ( )!( ()  
  HI/

% ( # $  


)! )!(    ( 
 %
 
 ) -% . &(
(
   ! ( ? 
/ ( % )!(
  
  &(
(
( 
  9   " 
/ 5)(!( ( )!( 
"  ) ( !  
(
)  
)  /  ( )" 

( )  )! ( 
 (() (" )" 
0 ( 
( )

) ( 
( )  (  
(/  ( ) &))  

 )
( )!(  ;
/ 9)" ("  ) ) 

) 
(
!/

C
 ( A/ 
( +! 
()!
5(  H<I   
( &(
(  ( &(  )&
)6"
)!( ("
 (  ;

)!/ ?  ( ( 
 

 &))  ( 9
"   ( 
/    ( 9
"
( 

 
)  = ! " = 
/ ( )
! = 
 
   ( 
  (   (

  
 
) ! (
)/ (  (&  1! A/B/
 " 
( ! (    "  " )!   
&(
( "  (     
! ( ))/ * )
  (
 
(!  ))    (  ;
  
 ( ! ))
&))/ * )
 
 (
)
)6"  )!  
!
)!(   (
  !  )
  H<I/

Search results are Set of vectors

encoded as vectors Feature selection

Set of keywords

Feature clustring

..... . .. ... Clustring

.. . .. ... ..
+
search results

Clusters of search results Set of feature clusters

*! A/B *)&

(  5)!( H<I
 1! A/B 
( 
( ) ! " ( 
( !  
 9" 
    
) / 8!( 


 9
"   & 
 ) 
( 
  (!( 
 H<I/ ( (!( 9
" &
 
!  ( "
(

   
  (
 ("
    
( 
/
& 6) 
(

   !)   ( "&, 9
" 
 
( )  &))  ( 9
"  ( 
( ) ( ( "& 

 
( 
( )
))
/  & =  
  
( ( (!(

 )( 

(  (   
( )  ( ) 
(
))

 ( 9
"  ( ) 
(  &(
( (  / * )

F
 A/D/   ( 5

)! &!(
  
( )
)! &))  ) 

!  (
)! )!(  ( )
 
( ) (  

 
 H<I/
5! "   ) =
 (  ) ( ) &"
 ! ( 
   
( ! &(
( 
))   

 / 3

))  L(   ) 

   " ( )   6!
) 
 ( () (  M &() 
  L(   )
 
  
(   " ( )   
 /M
 ( & &( (

   
)) ( 9    L8 )) (
) 
  TM 8& &( (

   
 ( 

 

!  ( 9 L5 )) (  

 )TM (

  
))  
    ) "  3! -E<E. HDI/
+9/ -A/.

recall =
|{relevant documents} {retrieved documents}|
|{relevant documents}|
-A/.

precision =
|{relevant documents} {retrieved documents}|
|{retrieved documents}|
-A/.
 
)  ( +9/ -A/  A/. (  
)) )) ) 
 
6
 &()  
 ))  
 
/
 (   
&  
 )  
( !  (  ( 1
( 
 
 )&"  ( ?  ( /
1 #2 22
(
(  ( 
 
(  (   
( ! 
(9/
%)
    
5 ( 1 ! &(  > #  ( ! 
   ( 

 ( ? ("   (  ( 
?/ (  ( )  (

 
  ( ? ("  ( 
(! (!( ( ?  1!

1

   " ( / 
 ( 
(
  ( 

 ( 
 &(
(  ))  ( ?  > #  ( ! 

 1 ( 
  ( !  ( 
(/ (" (!(  ( 

?   )
  (
 ?/ ( 
 9   
 ))
  ( ?/ >" ( 
   ( ? 
   &)) 


)  

(! 
 HCI/ *! A/C (& (  ! )! 

 
 ))!
/
<
 ( A/ 
( +! 
()!

Increasing
Ontology and
intelligence
automated reasoning

XML taxonomies and

docs with mixed vocabularies

XML documents using

single vocabularies

Text documents and

data base records

*! A/C    HCI/

 1) ! &(
(  (& " & & 
  
  6! 
&( ( )/  ( ! (     ( ( )(
&( (  &(
(   )" ) " 
(  (/  &
)! )"   )  ( 
?/ 4)!" 
 
!    ( ) )!  (   ( )(
& (

/
>" )! )!" 
! ( )!"   
1
 (   
)"      ))" 
  )!  
 6/ (  &  (    6 ! 
)
)!
  6
!   ( 6/ 5 ( ( 
   6
!
( )(   ! 
) ( 
(  
 ) 
!) () 
(/
$() (   )) )! ( 
 "  )
 )! 
 ;
)/ (   !   ) ( 

 
  )
 (  )!"   
1
/

%)        

( 
 
  
? 
( !  ( ?
))   / (


( !  ! "    89  (
$& P  B HDI/ (   ( 
( !   
  ( 9)"  (
)  )) ! 
)! ? $& >)! 
 @)) ) 

%  !/ 5! ( ! $& >)! )  !))  

 " 
 , "
 

()!"
)) J+K!/ ?  
D
 A/D/   ( 5
!  
 " 
 , 
3 
()!" ! ( " 52 /
 (" )
( ( & 
     58 $&2
 35+/
   ( 

( !    HDI/ 5) ( 
  &(
(  ( =
 & 
6!  "& 6
! 
  
 
( ! 
/ (   
  ))&!/
5   6   +       708
/ 9      1 5 

( !  6
 
() )) ()!
)  /!/  )) 
/ 4 
 /
 ( & ( ) () 
(! &(( " " L! 9)"
 )M )) ( 
 )
 ()!
)   ( 9"/
/ 9  ++   1 5 

( !  6

 () "" /!/
 () // 
/  ( !(
6  &(


 & / * 6) ( & LM
  ! 
)  
 
   &(
( &)  

  ( 
) / ( 6)
9" L ( 
  5# M (& ( 
 ! ) &( "" &(
(

 / ( ))   !   

( ! 
 !   !/
A/ 9   : 1 5 

( !  6
  () !
)0 /!/  U @+3 5#  5  
/ ?( ( , 9" 
6  !)0  ( )  6
   
1
/ ( 6)
9" L?(
(  ( ( " 
!(!TM !  )   


( ( @+3  
!0 " ( "  ( 
1
&/
B/ 9    1 2( ( 
())!! 
)" !
))  

( !  6
  
!0

  ! )
)/ '))" ( (  (
)"  
  
)  
  &)  )
 6

!  )) 
  ( / (
6) 9" L&(  (
(M !  )   
 
)!



(! 
( ( ! )!  (

  (
(  ( 
)
/
C/ 9     1 %" )  (    


( !  6
  (  &)!     ! )
)  /!/ & : U 8$ :U:0/ N&)! 
( 

 
(
 )  
) " =  

  ( &" (
)"  
9/
( 6) 9" L& : M !  )   
 &( ( 
 
(  )/
F/ 9        ;  ;1 5 

( !
 6
   )" &( ( 9"    9   /!/ &(
E
 ( A/ 
( +! 
()!
&( (& &(" 
/ $ (  L
( !M  = (  L9
&!M "/ 
( !,      
( )  ( 
)!
)  )  &(  9 &! " " 
 
!) 6
 "/ ( 6) 9" L(&   & : !TM !
 )   
  ( )!(  (
)"/
</ +              4
1 ')
) 
( ! &(  9"   



(  6
   
( / 5 9"    )" 

  )  ) 
  (/ ( )  
( &(
(      ( 
  1 ( ) 
/
D/ +   ; +<       ;<  * 
 1 ?( !  9" 
)  9  
! 
(!  (   &( ",  

( !/ ( 
 ! 6   ! 
(   ! ( )
( )"! &  ( 
( 
()!"/
E/ +     +   <   <  
=   1 5 

( !  6
  ! ) )
" )"0! (
   ! - 
.  
 (  (

)"  ( )     9"/ 3)"!  ) ) 
(G!!!  ( 1
)  " 
 ! ) &( 
(
  ))    ( )  

(/ >"  )"!
 1
)  

( 
()!"   ) )
)  "
 
))"   
  ) 
 &( 
( 
  6/
/ +       1 ?( (   


)"   
( )!( )
" 
   1
)  /!/
(& ) ( ! / 5 

( !  6
  
  )
"

 :
! ( !  ! 
(/ (
)"  :6)" 
( )  )" ! (()/ 5

!)" ( 

( !

   
  
))" :!    ( 
/
">0>> %  
 ( 
  
  ( 
()!"   
 
( !  ( 

)  ( 
( !  6)
• J" 
  +6
-J+K. (   & &"  )"0  
!
    &)!   " 
/    )
  (
 6 ( 
)"  "/ (   
( )

A
 A/D/   ( 5

*! A/F J" 

  +6
 J+K " HDI
! &( 
))" 
(    ()  (!(   ? 
(
   
( HDI/
*! A/F (& ( J+K " )"  ( 
   !/ (
( J+K )!( 6
 )) ) 9 (
    (

  )!(  / ( 9 -9
. 
 !&"  (
!! 
 !(  
 ! ( ) / $
( ( 
  )
 = )  (   " 9"/

!
  ( &"   ! :6)"  )0 
))"

(    )" )) ( 
!  9) 9/ 4(&
 
)"  ))" )     6) /
• 
3 5)!(  
   
   )  (

)  
 *00" #!
 ) #!
  (
/
(   ( )!(    
( )  (  )
"/
*! A/< (&  )  ) !(
!  ( J+K " 
 ! 9" / ( ( 1) )
"   " ( 
3
)!(    
 
 )" 

 
( & (
9"  (  
  
( !(/ 5! ( (! ()!
)
 "

)"  ) /  (  (   "&

(!  >) )! )/
• 
) 4)!" (  L!M )"   
! 

  ( (  &(   
   
))
)" )"0
 1  )!  

!"  ( &) &)!/

A
 ( A/ 
( +! 
()!

*! A/< 

3 5)!(  
 HDI/
0 !  ! )  ) (
)6  )" 
&
! 
 ! )!(/ $ )  () 6
 (

0 !
  "(!
)   )!
)
 
( 6 ( "/
(
0 ! )"    ) 
) 

  ( (    ! (!()" 

1
/ 4(&  & 
 ) (  
  " )" 
  ( " 
/
(  L

) )!"M - 4.    (0 (  
 ( (
)  
 , )!" 
  !!  
 )  (

( 
 ! !)  ) "  ( &) &)!/
 ( )! )   
))" ( !!  



(    ( " 
 
! ( !) ) " 

)! (  &) &)!/ 8
 ( )
  

) )
=  )
  
/
4
  &   )! &(    :/ ( " 1 :

   
 -. 
)! !) (!  &)) 

) / (
  ( )!"  (   )) (!/ *  ! & ( 

 6 ( 1 )"  4 1 ( )  &( (" )!   (
&) &)!  /
( 
 :
     -  
./ ( (
("

A
 A/D/   ( 5
! ! 
)  6()"

  
( (/ 
=    

  ( 1 :   &( (" )!
  ( &)  / * 6)   (   (  L!M 
L !M &(
( )!  )  ( 1 :/ 
 ( 



  )  ( "  &)) ) 

  ( )   (
1 :/ 8& (   L! &)!M  
() &))   =
  (    ( 1 :/
( ( ) 
 
 
  9
)" )0 ! (
!! L)!M )!"/ 5) : 
)  )
  ( 
)  ( 

  ( : )&/
5)"0!  6 ! 4  
(  )  9 ( ( 9"
 6 (
 )
  ( )!/ ( ) 
(  :6)
 )  "! ! 
( &( (!( 


"/   ) )"

)  9 !  )
  "
  ( 
  : 
/ !  ) ()  4 " )!
( )!" &( 9
   !) & 1/ 5

!)" ( 


  4   
  !) &/
  (
( !( &( ) & 
(    

   

( !  =   / (  (

( " 
 &)) (  !  )  

( ! 

!
  &  )!" &(
( 1 ( ) ! ( " 
1

/ 5  ) )   

( " 
 &)) ( = ! 
( 
/ * 6) 
"  )  ! (  = !  
"
 
) "/ 
(    )  =    ( )

 ( ) 
! = )!/ >  (
6 )
 )!  
( ! ( 
 " /
 ( 
 &   !!  

( ! )   

 
 

( !  &(  =   )!"  =
/ (   )!  "  
"    
1
 &( (
 
!0   =
!/ +)(  " ! 
)  

( ! &))    ( 
/ $6
( &))
6) ( !  
(
  &))  )  (  


( ! &(
(  !)/

AA
 ( A/ 
( +! 
()!

AB
 $
   
 
  
!
 
 
>  )   ) & 
  
( (
    !!  

( !  (   "  
"/ (
1   ! ( 

( !   ) )!"  " 

"/ ( )  ( )!"  1  

! & 
&( ( /  ) & 
(   (  (  
1
!
  " (  = !  (  &(
(   (   (
"/ 

( !   1  (  9 ! )!"
  )  
!  ) 
(    /
>  ( 
( &   ) ) 
(
 ! )
 6
  ! ( "/ (   (
(   
 ( !
 ) )  ( !! )/ ( 1 
 !  & 
( "/ ( 
 
 &))  ( )!"   ( " &(
( 
))& " ) 
  ( 
(/
 3   (
( 
 &))  ( ()!"  ( !) 
( !  &)) ))
" !  ( !
"
)/ ( 1! B/ (& ( &  ( &() "/
( 1   ( 
  &( (   ( 9"  !) 

 ))  1! B// ?  ( (  9"  ))  ( 
)!" )  !)/ ( ( 9" &))  6  ( 6  
 (  )!"/   9"   ))  ( )!" ) ( 
(

 &)) 
 " ! @!) )   ) 
(/ ( )  
 )!"   1 ( )  (  ! (   
AC
 ( B/ !  )  !)

Ontology
User query Query expansion
Google search engine

Google search results

Final result Categorize results Categorize Interpretation of

the Search results

*! B/ !! &  ( "

9"/ ?( (    9" &(
(  ))  ( )!" ( 9" &))
 6 

!  ( )  )

 " ( )!"/ J" 6 
!   (  9"       
( )/  (
& &( ( 9"  6 " ( )   ( )!" ) ( )
 ( 
( &))  (!()" )  (   "/

*! B/ !) 

(  

 ( 6  ( 
))" 
( 9" &))    ( @!)

( !/ @!) &))  " *+ / (  ) 
( &))  
   ( )  &))  ))
   1
!/ ( 
(
&))  ( 
( )   ( / (
!0  ( )
   
!  ( )  ( @!) 
( ()   ( ! 
( 
!     ))
  (


!"/ ( 
!
 L8"M L 
(M L2M L  "M/ (
!0 ) &)) 
)(  ( ! (&  1! B/A/

 ( )

 ( 

(   @!) 
( ! &
(
( L #M    )
/ 5)) ( !!   )
AF
 B// ()!"
 " "( !! )!!  ( @(
) ' 
 -@'.  
 ! ? !! )!! &(
(   )"  "   
/
History

Mechanism

Prevention

Case Study

*! B/A !) ) 

(

* "$  +   &,$  -&.

(   )!  
 ( )  "&  
( (  
&    (   ( 
? 
  !
  ( ) E,/
4 &"  (& ( 

  
( !   
9   9"  
  ( ) )!" 6 ( 9" !  &)! -N>. )!" 
 )  )!" ) ( " ( 9" &(
( (  )  

( ! "/ ( 
 &)) 
   
( " !
( )!" )  ( @!) 
( ! ))& "   ( ) 

 " @!)/    
( (  ) '3#  ( 
!"
  
!-8" 
( 2  ".   !! 
 
  &  
!  &!(  ( 
( 
&(
( 
) ( ))&! &!(! 

/ 80) ?!(-#.

/ %
) ?!(-8
.
*! B/B (& ( &    ( ( &!(! / ( (
  
 ! ))!

 &(
(
   (  
1!   &!(
!   9
"/ ( )G  ( 

  ! 
  ! )/  ( 1 (  ( !
A<
 ( B/ !  )  !)
&   
  (0) &!( &(
(  ))  1! B/C 7" 
 ) &(
(  6  (
!" ) (  ! 6
   9)  7
 (   6
9)"  ( 
) &!( " 
"! 16 &!( 

(
!"  ! 6!   ( ) &(
(  ))  (
!"
)/ (  )  ! )  6) )&/

*! B/B !! 5)!(    !" 3!

'>>> 9:  ?- @

  ( 
 (  
 )  @!) )   9  
" ( )
   ( 6!
!  !)/  (   (  &(
( 

( " 
!"   ( ( (  ( ) &))  
1  (

!" &( (    ( 9 "&/ (  (  ( (
L(0) &!(M  
! (  9 "& &(
(   ( )/
*! B/C (&  )  (0) &!(   6)/  1! B/C ( )
 
( 9"  (& &(
(  L "M L5
M  L !M/ ( 
   ( )  '3#  ) 
(/ (     ! (
   ( )
"  
(
!"/ 
 ( L "M  L5
M 
 )  ( 
(
!" (" &)) ! ( (!( " ( ( 
( ! ) &))    ( 
(
!"/

AD
 B// ()!"
Horizontal Weight

Matched query
Cyber Attack Mitigation Weight
Category
History - 1 - 1
Mechanism 1 1 - 2
Prevention - - 1 1
Case study - 1 - 1

*! B/C )

  !" 3! 5)!(780) ?!(
'>>> A  ?9@
4
 ( '3#     (0) &!( &  '3# 
" 
=
!/     
"  '3#  =
! &

  )" 
) &!(/ (   
  ! !   
( "/ %
) &!( ) )"  (  '3# &( ( 9)   
!/ 5

!  (  
( 6   (
!" ) ! 6
 &!(/ *
6) 
&  ! 6
  / 
  ! 6
  /  
 

1 &( 6
  /   &  ! 6
  /A/ , &
!"
( ( (!( " ( ( (
!  ( )
/ (    (
(!( 
 
    "  
" 1)/ ( 16 
 "    :6) 
(! ( "  (
!0 "
(!! (
6
  &(
(  
1  
(
!"/

 
 
>" 
"! ( 6
 &!(  
(
!" &  '3# 
"/ (
(  
) &!(  ( )/ *! B/F (& ( 16 &!(  
(

!"/
(  
 "&  )) " ( &!( 
/ *! B/F
(&  6)  
) &!( !  )   /
( (    )  ! '3# 
"  ( 
&( (  & ) &( (    9 "&/
(  ()!"  ! & ( ) )  ;
)" :6
)   1   ( 
  "  (
!0/ * 6)
& ! ( 6   ( 1)
!" &(
(  L  "M/ 
 
AE
 ( B/ !  )  !)

Vertical Weight

Default Matched query

Rank for
Scada Attack Cyber Vulnerability Weight
each Category
Category
1 History -
1.1 Mechanism 1.1 1.1 2.2
1.2 Prevention 1.2 1.2
1.3 Case study 1.3 1.3

*! B/F )

  !" 3! 5)!(7%
) ?!(
!  ( (
! 

!  ( 

/
( ( !  ( ()!"  ( 
    (   "
 &)) &(
(  " "! ( )!" )  ( )   ( " (
 )

  )  ( 9"  
(/  ( ( &  !
(   (   "  
" /
  "  4
  #" 
( 

 ( ()!"  )!(  
)! 
)"  (
"/ >  
 
  ( A ! ( &() 
  


( ! ( 
) 
  !) 
( !  
  ( 
/
? )( ( !) 
( !   ( ))&! 
/ (   ( 9"   ( )  !)  & ( 9"
 !) &/
/ ( 6
 !) & 
  ( ) 
! ! 
)!"  )

 -)!" )./
-.  (  9"   6   )!" ) ( 
( 

&)) 
 " ))&!  B   ) @!) 
(/
-.  (  9"  6   )!" ) ( 9"  6
  ( ))   ( )/
A/ ( 6 9" &))  
( ! @!) 
( !/
B/ ( )  ( 
( &))  6
  @!) 
( )    

  ( 6 /
B
 B/A/ !! 4)!"
C/ ( ) &))  
 
 ( @!) ) 
( &( (
!"
) &(
(  !  
(  &" 
) ( 
( )  
!
// L8"M L 
(M L2M  L  "M/
F/ 9)" (
!0 
( ) &))  (&  !)  

 !/
 #
   (
4)!   
 &)!  (   / 5 )!"

 (

  (   ) ( )( ( () & (


/ = )!" )!!  = 
) HEI/ 5 )!" ()
   ) ( 
  ( &)! &(  !
/ 5
)!"  (!   &)! 1! ( )( &
= 
 !  (    

)0
! ) )!! 
(  3* 4?# 
HAI/ (  
 ) 
 )!" )!!  4?#  ( ?) ? ?  -?A . 
&(
( (  
 
( /
(   ( )!" )  ( "    $ 23+
)!" &(
(    
 ( 
"  
 

) 
/
( )!"  ! " 
() ( HAI/
( $ 23+ 2
 
 )"  )

 !"  
 
 HAI/ ( 
)   )!"  

!  ( !) $ 23+

)!"  &  ( 
)    9  " 

"/ ( 
)  ( )!"  L5M L !M L(M L 

 
M  L%))M HAI/ ? )(  )!"   ( 
)
 ( 
)  ( 
) &(
(  

!  , 9 

"  
" / *! B/< (& ( 
)  $ 23+ )!"
&(
(  (   !  )!"  &))/
*! B/<  
   )!" ( ( 
  4?# #
)!! ! ( 2V!V )
/ 5

!  ( 
)  $ 23+

  (  9  "  
"  &  )

)  
( 
)/ *! B/D B/E B/ B/ B/  B/A  

  
)  !! )!"/
 ( 1! ( )   "  
"   / +6

 2("
) 
) &(
(    "  ( ( 
)  
(   
" / 5)) (
)     " ( )! &(

  

B
 ( B/ !  )  !)

*! B/< 
)  $ 23+  4 4)!" HAI

*! B/D 
)  
"  &( 
  5
  )

B
 B/A/ !! 4)!"

*! B/E 
)  
"  &( 5  )

*! B/ 
)  
"  &( (  )

BA
 ( B/ !  )  !)

*! B/ 
)  
"  &( %))"  )

*! B/ 
)  "  &( 2("
)   )

*! B/A 
)  
"  &( !  )
BB
 B/B/ )  !
 ) &( = 
  
"  "  & ( )  
) 1) // )  !/ ( K # 1) )  ( )!
   
56 5/

 &""   !

( 
 &)) !  
  ( ) "/ * ( 52 
) & ( (    ( )  
/ $6 
6) 
  ( " &))  !/
** &/0
( 
 &))   &  ( 52  ) &   )
!  ( 
( ! "/
+    
 
  6) !! )


!! &(
(   6"
 
)"  )"   
)) 
()" / 2"(   &) "
!! )
!! (     & "  )
 / 2"(  
 

) 2) 3"
(  /    " !(!  
) 


• %"
) ) "6

• ! 

)

•  
 

• $) 6  

)


• *)) )" ! (

(
) 
!

• +6
   ()!

• %" (!( )) "

 "

• +6  )  ( " )  ))" " 

• +6  ) )" &   WW -   "(  /$+
)!!  2"(.
• +) &( )
   
! 

  

  


BC
 ( B/ !  )  !)
2"(  ))  ))  ! " 
(  ?& #6G'6
4 G 
 5! ! (/ ?  2"( /<  ! " '>'$'
/    
  !  )  !) )
/

    
 &   (!( )) 2"( ? & ( 


!  ) 

) !
!/ ! 
  !
 
(  )      )  ?   9
)"  &(
)
/ ?  ! ? !! &    ! (  
? !  ( 
   !( ( )  ( ) !/
B   " &"      52  
" ) 


!/ (   ! ( 52  ( "   ( 

  @!) 

(
!  !( ( '3#  )  ( '3#  @!) 
( !  


))
/ * (  2"@!)  )"/
+B   "   &  @!), ? 52/ ?  ( )


 ( 

  @!), ? 52 (!( 452     

(  
(


@!)  ! ( ) !

))"/
CC      
 ) &(
(     ) 




  )  &)!  )
 &( )!/ 5 

2V!V )  
(   &)! )! 
  
 &(
( 
 (
 )0  )  )!   
/ 
 
0    )"  
! &)!
 )  !  
  6 " &"   )!  
(

    52  )! &)!  )  )
 HEI/ ? 
2V!V )  ! ( )!"   ( "/ ( )  (
)
   !   ))  
 B/A 
   K # 1) 
 ( )( &  " 4?#GK # 3*GK #  ) )!!/
( ))&! 
 
 ( ) !"  ( "/
** "    ( 
( 
 
 ( )  ) " !
  (
6) 
   
/
*  ))  )! ( " & 
   
   (&
  
 
  
   

   
 
  !"#$%
 
&


BF
 B/B/ )  !
 &  ( ) / 
    ) & (&!  
) 
 )) )) 0 )   !      ! )
  ( / ?   ) 
))" 1 )) (  
)  ( ) /  1! B/B ( !   
   ( 
9" 
  !) 
/  ( ! ( !)  &!   9"
 ( 6  (  (  9"  ( )!"  6! ( ,
9"/ *! B/C (& ( 6   ! (  9"  ( )!" 

(! ( , 9" ! ( 6!   ( )!" )/ * 6) 
  )!  L 6M ( )!" ) ()
 L 6M   (
)  )  ( L 6M -
(  &  (" 
)&///.  6 ( 9"/

*! B/B 
     9"  !) 

( ) 
  ( ))& " 
! ( 
  
(!
( 9" ! ( )!" )  6! ( 9"/ ( 6 9"  "
   @!) 
( !  
(   ( ) '3#/ *! B/F
(& (  &(
(   ) 
( ! @!) 
( !/ ( ) 
(
 ( @!) &))  
! 
  *+  
( )/ ( )  '3#
  
!0 ( ) )   
!/ *
!0! (

( ) 
!" ) (   !  
1   
!0 (
)   (
!/ 
!" ) (  )  
(
!"
 / * 6)  ( '3#, )
 (   (
 (
)   

 &(  

   '3# ()  

  (
"
&
!"/ *! B/< (& ( 
  
(! ( ) "& 
( ) &( )
!"/ 5

!  ( 1! )  )  (

B<
 ( B/ !  )  !)

*! B/C 
   
(!  9" &( 6!   ( )!" )
L 6M  "
&
!"
)   
(  (" 
! (" 
)
& & 
/ 5!! (   
(
!"    (   (
)!"/ ?  ! ( "  
"   (   
(
!" 
)  (  

/ *! B/D (& ( 
   1) ) &(
(
    
!0! ( @!) ) 
(     

! -8" 
( 2  "./

*! B/F 
   
(! 6 9" ! @!) 
( !
2
  ( &() !"  !  1! B/E/ ( 
  &(
! ( 9" -
 &(
(  ))  ( )!" ) ./ ( 6 )  
BD
 B/B/ )  !

*! B/< 
  
!0! ( @!) 
( )   
!"

*! B/D 
   1) )  

 (& (  

  )  )  ( 9" -
 )!"
) ./ 5 (  ( 6  ()    ( @!) 
(
!-) A  1! B/E./ >" ! ( 6   ( @!) 
(
! ( ) 
(   &))     ( ) 
(
  ( 6 /  ( !  ( 
 
  (  
)  )  ( 9"  ) )  ( ) &))   (
( 6
 9" 
( ! @!) 
( !/ (   ( !" &)) 
BE
 ( B/ !  )  !)
( 

( " !  )    
(! ( 6
 9"

)"  @!) 
( !/  6 )  ( 
 ( )  ( @!)

( &))     " 
!0    /  ( 6 
 )  ( '3# &(
( ( (    
(   & 

! 
/ ( )  (   &!(!  &(
( 
 ! &!(  ( )
!/ >" ( )
!"  "
& &)) (
( )& " ( (
!"  %
/ 5) (
!"  %
 (
( )& " ( ( / 

!"/ , &
!" &)) ( ( (!(
"  ( 
/ 20!  (
! 
))"   ( 
 &(
(  (   :6)  ! ( " 
!0  
( 9  (   (  !/

For (each qi in Q) {

Retrieve all the existing relevant terms in ontology list related to the qi;

Expand the qi based on the relevant terms related to qi in ontology list;

Transfer the expand qi to Google search engine;

Return the results of Google search based on expand qi;

For (each Title Ti in each Link Li) {

Find the relevant keyword Ki, which is matched to the category Ci;

Assign the Title Ti to category Ci;

Remove the repetitive links;

If Title Ti has equal keywords to be assigned to category Ci and Cj {

Assign the Title Ti to category Cj;

Show the categorized results for user;

*! B/E 2

  ( &() 
  ) !"

C
 %
"  
4
 ( !  )  ( "       ) (
!) )
/ ( ) 
 )" 

) )    !
)!  
( !/ ( " 
  )  
( !  

   0
 &/ ( 
  ( ) 

 &( ( 
 
( ) "/ ( 


  ( 6  )
" &
(  )   9"  ( 
( / ( )  !1
)"
  ( )!" 1! ( )   6! (  9"/ 
( 
 ( 
  ( 

(    (  1 )
!"/
( 
  (
(   ( )   
  !"  )
/ 5) (     
/ >  ( )  (

  ( )
  )/
   ) ( 
  ! )!"  1 ( 

( !
&  (  
  !  )/ ( 

) 

   &       1,2/ * ( 
  )!"  ( 

 &  1   ( 9)"  '3# 

 " (   !)

) 
(/  (  &
 ( '3#  ( @!) &( !) )

(   ( 
  ( '3# ( 
!0 " ( !) 
"  ( '3#
 &( @!)/ ( !)  ( 

(  
 &(( ( '3# 
  !)   ) 
! (
= 
  ( , /

 '
  !
   ) ( ) ( ) 
(   1 9  ( "
 
"  
  ( 
 )/  ( " ( 
C
 ( C/ +)
) " @!) 
( !  )
  ( 

/
  
"  
 ( !) ) 
( ) 
 &(
(     '3#, )  @!)/  !) 
( 9"  6
" ! ( )   
( 
    
(  ) 9" 
  1 )!"/ 4 ( ( (  @!) 
( )"  9"  
(
   (  ( 6
 & (   
( )  @!)  
( !) &() (  '3#  !)  
))"  ) 
(   "/
(   ( )   "  
" / ( )!" &
 !  ( 
( ! " )  ( $ 23+ )!" &(
( 
1   ( 9  (   "/ $&(! " 
(

  $ 23+ )!" )
 ! (

  ( & )!"


!  $ 23+ )!" ( 

)  ( & )!"  (   $
23+ )!"/   ( )
   ( & )!"  )  )"
  )  ! ( !) )
 /
 ) (  ) 9  )
  ( ) 
 &(
@!)/ ( ) 9   ))&!
/ %
/ ? 
A/ 55
B/ 6 
( 1 & ) 9 
)  !)  &(
(
  
)  
) 
1
 
 

  
) 

  !
)/ (
) & )   
1
 ( 
  ( ( (& )) L 55M

 )"  )
) "   
) 

) 

/
 ( ) ( 
( ! =
 
  91/ ( 9
1
 
   
(  &" (  &( 6 ( 
( !  (
) (

 ( 

 )  (  9"  ( /
5)) (   )  
  ( ))&! !(/
 1! C/ ( ) 
(  !) 
 &( @!)  L%M  (
, 9"/ 5 (& @!)   '3#  ( 6
 9" (&  (
( )  !) 6(  

 / *! C/

 (
 )  E '3# (  @!)  !)/

C
 C// +)  
100
90

URLs
80
ReturnedU 70
60
beroftheR

50
40 Semoogle
30 Google
Numb

20
10
0
Virus Stuxnet Duqu Threats Malicious Malware Worm
code
Related Terms
RelatedTerms

*! C/  ( )

"   '3#  L%M 9"  !) 
@!)  (   "
5   L%M   !) 9"  =   
)
" 

  
(/ * 
 
 

  
) )& 

 ( ( ( " 
 " &(  (  
( 

) 

 ( 
))" =

/  (  @!)  
'3# &( 
  ( & 
   &() "  (    (

  "  
"/ ( ( )  !)  ))" )& (
@!)  ( 6
 &  L%M -3 ./ 4 ( ( ( !) 6(
 
  ( ( )   (&  ) / 5)) (  
( 1! ( 


   1 )!"  !) 
( !
)!  !() ) " !)/
 1! C/ (  L? %M  )
   ) 9"  6 
) ( !) 
( !, 

  @!)   B '3#/
5 (&     ( 6
   '3# (   " @!)/ 
  1! ( 6
  L& M  ( )   '3# @!) 
)"   ) ( ( !)/ 8& 
   (

( (
  " @!)  =  ("   
)" )  
  "/ ( 
  
(  !)  & &   

( =
  

(  ( )
 / 8
 @!)   )
 ( 6
  L?M  L%M (&   / 8&  ( ( )
 )  (  9"  "  
"  !)  
) /!/ L 6M L9M L 
"M L(M  L )&M/
( & )  (
  ( " 

  = 
 / ( )  ( ( @!) 
( !   '3#
 ( 6
  9" (& ( !)   ) ) 

 &( ( @!)   ( 6! )( &    9" 
CA
 ( C/ +)
!) 
( !/
URLs 120

100
beroftheRetunedU

80

60
Semoogle
40
Google
Numb

20

0
Worm Worm Virus Stuxnet Duqu Security Threats Malware
Virus
RelatedTerms

*! C/  ( )

"   '3#  L? %M 9"  !)
 @!)  (   "
?
"  ( )  & ( )    
 ( 

  !)  ( 
1
  "  
" 
 
@!) 
( !/  ( 
 L 55M  )
   )  9"/ 
 )  )"  "  
"   )  ( ( 1) /!/ 
)
)   
) 

) 
/ ( 6 9"  L 6
%M &(
(    
)" )  
"  " 1)/ $ ( ))&! 
!( ( )  (

  & !)  @!)  /
*! C/A (& (    )  !)  @!) 
( !
 L 55M / (  
(  L5M L 
"M L(M L3M  L%)
)"M  )
  ( )   L 55M  "  
"  
 (  1 )!"  !)/ (   (& ( ( @!)  
'3# ( !) ) 
(  ( 6
   L 55M/ ( )  ( 
 & 9  / * ( ( )   L 55M  "  
"
    ( @!) 6( !1
)"  
/ ( 
'3#   A  ) 0  @!) 
( )  (  )  
"
 " / ( )  ( @!)   '3#  (
6
   !)   

 ) )  ( L 55M  

   " -( )   ( 1! C/A./
( )
( )  L 6 %M &(
(  
1
  ( " 

" / (   )   )" 
  ( !)  /!/
L%M  1 ( ) '3)    "  ) 
"  ( 
1

  (  &(

(  )!  (   " /!/ L 6 %M/
( )  L 6 %M  
  1! C/B. &(
(    BD 
CB
 C// +)  
35

NumberroftheReturnedURLs
30

25

20

15 Semoogle
Google
g
10

0
SCADA Asset Security Threat Risk Vulnerability
RelatedTerms

*! C/A  ( )

"   '3#  L 55M 9"  !)
 @!)  (   "
'3#/ ( 1! (& (  ( 6
  L 6 %M @!) 
( !
  !1
 ) ( !)/ # ( (
 ) 
( !)   

 )  (  &(

( (& ( 6
)
" & L 6 %M  (  )  ( L 6 %M 
(
 L 
"M L(M L )

M L )&M  L?M/
80
70
RLs
eturnedUR

60
50
eroftheRe

40
Semoogle
30
Google
Numbe

20
10
0
StuxnetVirus Security Threat Malicious Malware Worm
RelatedTerms

*! C/B  ( )

"   '3#  L 6 %M 9"  
!)  @!)  (   "
( ) ( (& (  ! ( 
( ! " 
 (

  
(
 &( )" "&  
(/ (
 

  ( &( 

  ( !)    
1
  (  
"/ )  

(   ( )
 )!"  
 ( "&  
(/ "  ( ) ) '3#
! ( 
 
( 
( 9"  1)   (   
(    ( )

  "/

CC
 ( C/ +)
 & 
( ( )
"  )   (   " ( 

   )
 9/ ( 
   " !)    
& &   
1
  "  
" / !  !)
  
1
  ( ) 
(   

  ( 6
 
9" &() ( =
  =  !)/ ( ) 
(    
( )  
  
1
9/
( ) (  (  
(  

(  &(
 ( ( ) 
(  @!) 
( ! 
  1 (
 9/ ( "  )
) 
!0 ( ) 

!  (

!" )/    ( !  ( 


( (
!0 
( ) &))  " !  
 ( )   &"  ( /
  ( 
  ) 6!   )!" )  ( 
( ))
(   (  ( )!"   ( )   6 
 ( )(/ (
)6"  ( 
(  
1
  !1
)" 

    
(   1 ( 
))" )   (   "/

CF
 &
  
(
( &)) !  
   1!  )  &)) 
 
( )  ( )    ( "/ (
( &))

 ( 
  (   !  !)  ) 
 &    ) ( )
/
+ ' #" 
 
) 
( " !) 
( ! &(
(   !
  )!"  
( ! (     !  =

/ ? &)) ( 
 ( /
!) 
( !  
)" 
   )!"   
   )!"
/ )"! )!" &(
( 
 &)!  (    


  
) &( (   )( & (/  !)

( ! ( & !  ( )
/ 4  ( !   


(  1 ( )( ! / ( ( !  )
 (  9" &(
( ) (    & 9  
( 
 ( @!)/
( 1    ) 6!  )  ( 9  ( )!"/
( )!" )"  ( )
  "
 )! (  
)!"  "  
" /   )  6 ( )  (
)!"  ( ))  "  
"   
 ( )  
( 1)  "/ )  ( )!" &)) () (   (  

( ) (
 )!"/ 5)   "
    ( )
!"  (   (  
(  )  ! ) )

)   
/

 ( )  !) 
( 
!0  
! ( )

    )"  
 )  ( / >  (
(


( !) ) 
( ( 
 1 ( )  
1
!" )! 
  ( 
(! 
/ ( ( 1  ;
    

)
C<
 ( F/ 

( 

)"  ( 9   (    !/
* 
( &)) & 
( ! !))"   ) )/

 ( !) )
  ! ( @!) 
( !    
(! (
 9   
 &
) !)  )) !  @!) 
(
! &(
(  &)) & 
( ! (!(  ( &)  (  / 4
( ( ( 
 ( !)
  ( )   ) 
 

!0 (  

! &

) ( )"   )  
!) 
( !   ( @!) 
( !/
  ( 
( ! &(
(   ) 

( ! !)

  )   "   

(  )  ! ) )

) &
! &   &&
))
 " !  
!  1
 )&"  "  )) 1)  " " ! (
)!"  ( ) / > (
) ( ( &) )  

 
)  1
)  /

+ )"  #" 

( 
( ! " (  )/  ( 
 & &))
 (
)  !)/ 
 (
( &)) (& (     & 
9
) 
" 
   )    ) ( "/
* )!)" (!( @!) 52 &))  (    ( 
(
   ( 9  "  /   )  (  

  " 
" "!  (/ 5)(!( ! @!) 52 &(  ( 9  " &))
 (  
 ( 
    )!(!  "  &))

( 9" 6
/    ) ( " 
   )  " 
9  @!) 52/ 8& ( )
 &))    ! 
( 9 
( 9  @!) 52 /

 
 (  9"    )!" & (    ( 


( (  ( )   ( 9 &(
(  
 " )!"/
( ( )  
( "  =
  ,
 (  
/

 ( )!"      ) ( )
  ) 
 "   
 )!"/
( (  6! 
( ! ) )    ( )
  
( !  )!! ( ( +!)(/ ( !) )
 

)   )" +!)( ) 

   )!! ( ( +!)(/
 
 
   

CD
 F/A/ * ?
*( (  
)  ( )  ( "   )
   
(
  6 ( )!"  ) )
    (

  
 
  
"  " / 8
  ( )!" )  
 ))
( 
  ( 1)  " ( )  ( 
( 
 )/ ( "
      (
) )    )    

)!"/ (  )"  !1
 )  ( )!"   
( )/ 


"  )( & (   ( )!" &))  ( 

)  ( 
(/  ( )! ) )"   )  ! (
)   1 ( )( & ( /
$ ( " 
       &( ( 
  ( 

 &))   
  )/ +)! ( ) !  

  
))    )  ( 
/ (  )"   ( 

( &   (  &  &(
( 
  ( 

))
 
(
()    )  
(  ( 9/ ( 
(
(  ( )
  ( !  ( (   
" ) 9  ( (  )
(   (  
( 9"  
( !"/ $ ( ( !  
( )
   @!) 
( ! !  "! ( @!) 
(, ! 
" ( 
  ( "/
?   )) !  ( ) ! ( )/ ? 
 ( ( " & 
)  () ( 
" 
   
( 9"  !
))" 
/ ?    (  " 1!
 9/ 5) &(    ! ( "& &(
(   6 
( )!" ( )
 &  )  ()   ( 9"  ( @!)

( !/ >"   ( )
 
) &  ()  
( "& &(
(   6!  ( )!"  @!) 
( !  
) )/

+ 4

 $ 

 ( !) 
( !  "     " 

( !!   & &)) () ( )  ( 1
  
)  ( !) 
( !  ( /  ( 
 & &))

( )   (  &/
( 
(  ( 
   !  "   

( ! 
(  
   
( !    ( 
/  (  ( !
)!"      )  (  &/ 5   (

6  (  ( )!"  )"  )) 

 &(
(  (  
)!  ( 1)    )  
/ 5) (  )!"

    =  

(  )

)
(
) & ) 
CE
 ( F/ 

 
/ ( 
)" &)) () ( )  ( ( )"  ) ( 
(
!  "   ( /
!) )
  (!( &!(  L  "M
!"   ! )!
(  (
 

0  !(! ( (
!/ ?() (
&!(! )!(  0  L  "M ))" (  )" 
   (
! &(
(      /
?()  
( ! )
 ))&   )
  
   )
( )
 )
    (   ! ( 
( ) 

!
 (   /!/ )
 / 9)" ( 1 
( )
 (
(!( )
" ( ( ( 
( )/

F
 '
  

 !) 
( ! 
(  @!)  
))" 6  // 
( )" (
"&  " (    ( )  ) ( 
( ! "

  ( " ! ( )  (  @!) 
 (   )" 
( "&  " (   ) 
( ( (
"& (! )( &( ( ! "&   )!/
5

!  (   ( "   "   


(
!   !)/     )!"   0 ( 
( 
 
   ( 9)"  ( ) 
(/ (  )!" )" ( 
)  ( 

( !/ 5   ) 

))
 ( 
  ( 
 

! ( 

( ! &(
(  )  (
  "  
"/ ( )!"      ! )!" 

)"    ( (   "    " (  9
 ( 1)  "/
( "
!0 ( ) 
(   !
!  
 9/ (
!  ))" !(    &(
(  
  ( " 
    ( ( !  ( ( 
/ ( !) 
( !  @!) 52  
(    (
)  @!) 
( !/
( (
(   (   ( !  ) 
( 
1  &      )
  (  )  =

!/ ( &     (0) &!(  
) &!(/ (  
  ! ( ) 
(  ( )
!"  ( )  
 0 (
!/
 )
( &  
(     ( )
/ ( 1
  )   !) 9"/ ( )  !) 
( ! 

&( @!)/ ( 
     " (  
1
  " 
F
 ( </ 
)

"   ( !)  @!) 
( !/
! ( )  !) &( @!)  0  ( ))&!


)! 
( !) 
( !   ) ) 

!  ( 

•
9"/
• (  )!" )"  )  0 (  ) 
!) 
( !/
• (  )  !) 
( !     )  (
1)  " ( @!)/
• !  !)   
1
  ( ) 
(   


  ( 6
 9"  @!) 
( &(  !)  
  ) ) 
(  (   "/
• 

" & (   ( )!" &))   )
)  ( 
  !) 
( !/
(
!0  ( ) 
( &)) () (   1 (  
 9
)"   ( @!) ) 
(/

F
(  )
HI L( 
( ! 
(
 

 C<  )  
( 
!  M * 3 3

   4 

 *

&  
,

 /

HI P/   5/ P L4)!" )!  )  )

(

M  

 4 

   5 
 '((67 %45 8(67 '  5 

  ,     
/ E /  7C/

HAI / ( 5/ *)0& 3/ N0  ?/ 8)&

0 L
  ) 
)!"  ! 

) 
 ))  ( )
"M / ED7 /
HBI / >  #/ 2! L( "   )! 
) ("6) & 
( !M
,7 97 5 :9 &7 )/ A / <7< 5/ EED/

HCI %/ !  / @)) $

  
   
/ ")  *

/
HFI 5/ 8! 5/ 8( / '
( / N)) 5/ 2))  / 
 L 
(! 
&! )  &( & ( 
& 
( !M   
;

  
   $     
  )/ E / B / H4)I/
5)) (GG&&&/&
)/!G6/(GG
)G&GB
H<I 8/ S(! >/ 2! N/ K  8/ ? L ) ))!
  
"M
P/ ?! P/ / (!  8/ # +/ >) 8)! ! %)!
<
(/ 5 +;
 5)!(  )! 
( +! 3) / FF7F</
H4)I/ 5)) (GG6//!G/<GE<D A CB <BA<< BXFE
HDI 8/ H4)I/ 5)) (GG&&&/(/
-5

E*"E.
HEI $/ 5!( L5 "
) &  & 
"  
 
"
6"  )!"M /
HI / > # / 8)  4/ #) L( 
? -> # / )
.M 
 
 $
  " /
FA
>)!("
HI @/  #/ N!) / *  / 2)

 L 
"  ) & 

5  
(!M  5 /
   '  5  
   

 ,   
 5 / ! A / AAC7AC/
HI / / ! 2/ 3!(  8/
(0 5 
  5 
 +
/
$& P $P ' 5 ! '" 2 D/
HAI N/ $/ 5 +/ *

 Y/ @Z)  / /  +! +/ 4

<      5 
 & /
    5  
  , 
  4<#35 '())  =  $ '6   ' '())7 /

/ #
 $  

 )/ FDFF/ ! /
HBI 2/ 80) / NZ0
(  / 3)( = 
    
   
/
( [ 8))G 3  E/
HCI / #/
@ L4)!
  !M  95  5 

&  / 
'" A/
HFI 3/ %/ @( 3/
)  +/ )) L 

(M    5  

   
  ,   A / <7<E/
H<I $/ */ $"  / #/ 
! L4)!" )  5 @ 
! P * 4)!"M / H4)I/ 5)) (GG&&&/)//
G)G)GG)!"G)!" " 
!/()
HDI >/ (  / ?)" L* 
 4)!"\&  &
"(M  =#5 8(); /
  
 
      =
# &
5 
 &/ 5 2 / H4)I/ 5))
(GG6//!G/BCGCCFD/CC
HEI / N  / 3(" L
  

( !M  4

4 

   5 
 '((67 5,445 8(67 5  
  ,     )/ 
!/ E / AD 7ADF/
HI +)0( #"2
()   / "
 '"  L8&
 
( ! &M ;  %>
  : /
  )/ E
/ AD7BC " /
HI 3/ 5/ >0 P  >/ 3 $ % 5 
 +
/ >
5 ' 5 5 ?)" #! 2)(! / 
/ EEE/
HI L4 ("  (/M H4)I/ 5)) (GG&&&/!!)/
GG

"G("G
HAI / ) / ]0 / !  / 2 "   +  
5 
 & .
& D/

FB
 >)!("
HBI P/ ?!  / N!& L' ) 
)!   & 
(
)M   5 
 & 4 

 '(()7 /
    
5  
  ,     )/  
/  / C7B )//
HCI 8/ / S! J/ / 8 S/ ( ?/ P/   / / @3 B B
(/
#!  ) ? 
( 3) / 7</
HFI 2/ 8/ ?! / P/ ?!  8/ / # LJ" 1 
( !   ,

  6, !M 5444 )/ B / BD7CB $& P B/
H<I 5/ $ #/ (!) $/ ("  +/ % LL !(  
)
  !   )
  ) 
"/MM  $ 
9
5 
 /
 & )?/  2 C / 77/
HDI ?/ >/ *  3/ 5/ >0 P +/ 5 
 +
; : 
@ $
/ 2
 8)) EE/
HEI / 8! 8/ N)
( 5/ 3
 3/   / ? L5 

) !
 )! &) )! ! ( ! &) )! 
  )M )/ <
/ 7< B/
HAI / 0)0 L  )!!  )0  ! M C/ H4)I/
5)) (GG&&&/
))!/!GG)!"/()

FC
>)!("

FF
 * 
+ + )  ,-

F<
56 5/ 4?# 4)!"  K #
<?xml version="1.0"?>

<!DOCTYPE rdf:RDF [
<!ENTITY owl "http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#" >
<!ENTITY xsd "http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#" >
<!ENTITY rdfs "http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#" >
<!ENTITY rdf "http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#" >
<!ENTITY Ontology1335173950609 "
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#" >
]>

<rdf:RDF xmlns="http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#"
xml:base="http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl"
xmlns:xsd="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#"
xmlns:rdfs="http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#"
xmlns:rdf="http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#"
xmlns:owl="http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#"
xmlns:Ontology1335173950609=
"http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#">
<owl:Ontology rdf:about=
"http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl">
<rdfs:comment>A security ontology that discribe the various terms based on
relationship between the terms.</rdfs:comment>
</owl:Ontology>

<!--
///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
//
// Annotation properties
//
///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
-->

<!--
///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
//
// Object Properties
//
///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
-->

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#AffectedBy -->

<owl:ObjectProperty rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;AffectedBy">
<rdfs:range>
<owl:Restriction>
<owl:onProperty rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;AffectedBy"/>

FD
 <owl:someValuesFrom rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Threats"/>
</owl:Restriction>
</rdfs:range>
</owl:ObjectProperty>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#isRelateing
-->

<owl:ObjectProperty rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;isRelateing"/>

<!--
///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
//
// Classes
//
///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
-->

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Application
-->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Application">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Logical_Assets"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Application_Vulnera
bility -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Application_Vulnerability">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Vulnerability"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Assets -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Assets">
<owl:disjointWith rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Safeguards"/>
<owl:disjointWith rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Source_of_Attack"/>
<owl:disjointWith rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Threats"/>
<owl:disjointWith rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Vulnerability"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Audit_And_Monitorin

FE
56 5/ 4?# 4)!"  K #
g-Logs -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Audit_And_Monitoring-Logs">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Safeguards"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Avoidance -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Avoidance">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Fault"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Common_cause
-->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Common_cause">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;physical_assets"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Components -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Components">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Physical_Assets"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Components_Fails
-->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Components_Fails">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Equipment_Failure"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#DDoS -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;DDoS">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;DoS"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Dangerous -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Dangerous">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;physical_assets"/>
</owl:Class>

<
<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Dependent -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Dependent">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;physical_assets"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#DoS -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;DoS">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Threats"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#DuQu -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;DuQu">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Worm"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Equipment_Failure
-->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Equipment_Failure">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Source_of_Attack"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Error -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Error">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Operating_System_Vulnerability"
/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Failure -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Failure">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Operating_System_Vulnerability"
/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Fault -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Fault">

<
56 5/ 4?# 4)!"  K #
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Operating_System_Vulnerability"
/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Fingerprinting -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Fingerprinting">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Threats"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Firewalls -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Firewalls">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Safeguards"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Flood -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Flood">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Threats"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Hacker_Attack -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Hacker_Attack">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Human_Origin"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Hardware -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Hardware">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Physical_Assets"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Hardware_Vulnerabil
ity -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Hardware_Vulnerability">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Vulnerability"/>
</owl:Class>

<
<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Human_Origin
-->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Human_Origin">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Source_of_Attack"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Human_error
-->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Human_error">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Error"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#ICT -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;ICT">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Physical_Assets"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Information
-->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Information">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Logical_Assets"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Insider_Attack -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Insider_Attack">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Human_Origin"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Intrusin_Detection_
System -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Intrusin_Detection_System">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Safeguards"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Logical_Assets -->

<A
56 5/ 4?# 4)!"  K #

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Logical_Assets">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Assets"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Malicious_Code -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Malicious_Code">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Threats"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Malicious_Code_Dete
ction_And_Elimination -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Malicious_Code_Detection_And_Elimination">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Safeguards"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Malware -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Malware">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Malicious_Code"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Mistake -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Mistake">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Error"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Module -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Module">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Application"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Network -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Network">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Physical_Assets"/>
</owl:Class>

<B
<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Network_Snooping
-->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Network_Snooping">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Threats"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Network_Vulnerabili
ty -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Network_Vulnerability">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Vulnerability"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Operating_System_Vu
lnerability -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Operating_System_Vulnerability">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Vulnerability"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Operator_Error -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Operator_Error">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Human_Origin"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Password_Attack -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Password_Attack">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Threats"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Passwords -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Passwords">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Safeguards"/>
</owl:Class>

<C
56 5/ 4?# 4)!"  K #
<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Physical_Assets -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Physical_Assets">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Assets"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Physical_Fails -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Physical_Fails">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Equipment_Failure"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Power_Fails
-->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Power_Fails">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Equipment_Failure"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Protocols -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Protocols">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Logical_Assets"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Role_Based_Access_C
ontrol -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Role_Based_Access_Control">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Safeguards"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#SCADA -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;SCADA">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Physical_Assets"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Safe -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Safe">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;physical_assets"/>

<F
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Safeguards -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Safeguards">
<owl:disjointWith rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Source_of_Attack"/>
<owl:disjointWith rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Threats"/>
<owl:disjointWith rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Vulnerability"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Safety_Instruments
-->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Safety_Instruments">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Physical_Assets"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Scanning -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Scanning">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Threats"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Security_Adminstrat
ion_Vulnerability -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Security_Adminstration_Vulnerability">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Vulnerability"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Sniffing -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Sniffing">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Threats"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Social_Engineering
-->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Social_Engineering">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Threats"/>
</owl:Class>

<<
56 5/ 4?# 4)!"  K #

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Software_Flaws -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Software_Flaws">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Equipment_Failure"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Source_of_Attack
-->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Source_of_Attack">
<owl:disjointWith rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Threats"/>
<owl:disjointWith rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Vulnerability"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Spoofing -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Spoofing">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Threats"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Stuxnet -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Stuxnet">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Worm"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Symetric_Key_Crypto
graphy -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Symetric_Key_Cryptography">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Safeguards"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Threats -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Threats">
<owl:disjointWith rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Vulnerability"/>
</owl:Class>

<D
<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Tolerance -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Tolerance">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Fault"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Trojan_Horse
-->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Trojan_Horse">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Malware"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#User_Error -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;User_Error">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Human_Origin"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Virus -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Virus">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Malware"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Vulnerability -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Vulnerability">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&owl;Thing"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#Worm -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Worm">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Virus"/>
</owl:Class>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#hardware -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;hardware">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;Failure"/>
</owl:Class>

<E
56 5/ 4?# 4)!"  K #

<!--
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#physical_assets -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;physical_assets"/>

<!-- http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2012/3/Ontology1335173950609.owl#systematic -->

<owl:Class rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;systematic">
<rdfs:subClassOf rdf:resource="&Ontology1335173950609;physical_assets"/>
</owl:Class>

<!--
///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
//
// General axioms
//
///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
-->

<rdf:Description>
<rdf:type rdf:resource="&owl;AllDisjointClasses"/>
<owl:members rdf:parseType="Collection">
<rdf:Description rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Audit_And_Monitoring-Logs"/>
<rdf:Description rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Firewalls"/>
<rdf:Description rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Intrusin_Detection_System"/>
<rdf:Description rdf:about=
"&Ontology1335173950609;Malicious_Code_Detection_And_Elimination"/>
<rdf:Description rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Passwords"/>
<rdf:Description rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Role_Based_Access_Control"/>
<rdf:Description rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Symetric_Key_Cryptography"/>
</owl:members>
</rdf:Description>
<rdf:Description>
<rdf:type rdf:resource="&owl;AllDisjointClasses"/>
<owl:members rdf:parseType="Collection">
<rdf:Description rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Hacker_Attack"/>
<rdf:Description rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Insider_Attack"/>
<rdf:Description rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Operator_Error"/>
<rdf:Description rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;User_Error"/>
</owl:members>
</rdf:Description>
<rdf:Description>
<rdf:type rdf:resource="&owl;AllDisjointClasses"/>
<owl:members rdf:parseType="Collection">
<rdf:Description rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Components_Fails"/>
<rdf:Description rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Physical_Fails"/>
<rdf:Description rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Power_Fails"/>
<rdf:Description rdf:about="&Ontology1335173950609;Software_Flaws"/>
</owl:members>
</rdf:Description>
</rdf:RDF>

D
D
56 >/ 2"(  #!

 * (
)    

D
DA
56 >/ 2"(  #!

DB