How to write a better feasibility study
Strategies to attract more investment with your feasibility study
SByMauo Chess | February 18,2019
the last few years, the notion ofthe “bankable”
feasibility study bas evolved from what anxious
bankers would ask for p
chat shareholders now demand before filly committing to a
jor to granting a loan to something
project. What's more, ie has gone from one study to several,
asthe mining project goes from design through to
construction and commissioning, What factors have led to
mining company shareholders making such demands?
Fist, cher is the mining sector's credibly: After more than
[USS120 billion was written off herween 2010 and 2015, the
capital markets ate cautious, In addition, the mineral
resources sector has been marginalized by the tech sec
making capital harder to find and forcing companies to
conduct ther studies in phases to continvally lure investment
into a project,
Secondly, it has become more difficult to find major
geological deposits, despite record-high mineral exploration
expenditure, Shareholders and the mining companies are
more cautious about assuming 100 percent of the tsk of
investing in exploration given the seacity of new finds,
therefore, many CEOs are now taking consolidation or
simply downsizing, as Capstone, New Gold and Barrick.
Gold have done.
Thirdly, there are huge cost overruns, especially 25 new
mining projects are increasingly in remote locations and
many yield thinner grades. McKinsey noted in a 2017 report
that four out of five mining projects experience a 43 per cent
average cost overran,
“The result ofthis is that today’s phased approach to feasibility
studies have now become a series of hurdles to clear atthe
cequity-entry level, then atthe debt-entry level, and then
possibly atthe project-commissioning level,
A smart mining company, however, can adopt some pre
ive strategies inthe feasibility study process to allow it
ae will
to locate hard-to-find equity and publish a stady th
deliver value for «longer period of time:
Phasing: A phased development may require more capital in
the long run, say $400 million per phase ws. 8700 million for
the whole project. However, $400 million may be easier to
rise, Once operational, the proj
an then start generating
capital for subsequent phases, offering lower risk.
Infill drilling: Using infill drilling while your project is being
b
and Probable Reserves during const
ican offer many advantages, including adding: (a) Proven
ion, (b) a cost
‘cushion in ease cost overruns occa and (€) 4 revenue cushion
{in case metal prices go soft before commissioning, Inf
dailing allows a mining company to also present a “growth™
investment toa capital market looking for growth,
Share: Mining companies can share their infrastructure
more. Whether itis power, roads, water of telephony, often
feasibility studies show infrastructure usage rates of 5-10 per
cent, while the project is situated next door to a town or
‘other mines where all could benef
from sharing these
utilities, Sharing could not only reduce the costs, but it may
also reduce the mine's politcal and permitting risks
RELATED: SX STRATEGIES FOR CUTTING POLITICAL RISKIN
MINING PROJECTS (HTTP: MAGAZINE CM Ss
/BOLIFICAL-RISK-AND-HOW-TO REDUCE EN)
Solar: The cost of setting up a solar power utility has dropped
dramatically. So if your mine is situated between latitudes 35
North and 35 South, and far from a reliable power grid,
definitely look t solar options. Not only can this energy be
cost-competitive, but i reduces involvement with the various
authorities, Setting up solar power can also allow you to sel,
surplus electricity toa neatby town, reducing political risk
‘Once your mine is exhausted, you can transfer the power
asset to the local utility to further reduce restitution costs
Realistic: The world has databases and can pre-screen your
studies. Do nor suggest that certain costs could vary +/- 10 or
20 per e
the
four or more years. The same goes for
hen they in Fact vary 40 or 50 per een, or that
ake si months when in fact it will take
siting wil
of grades and
metal prices. Your feasibility study should reflect realy
LLeast-isk: Feasibility studies focus mostly on reducing costs
to maximize net present value, but say tele about risk. Often
risk can be substantially reduced fora fraction of the
‘operating cost increase, For example, by providing power toa
nearby town, a project may marginally is
ease its operating
costs, but substantially reduce the political risk
Update: Yes, de-risking a project takes time. While an
‘update may be validated by an internal Qualified Person,
ultimately you will need an external author to review your
remaining project from the ground up. So choose your
authors careilly and make sure tha they are subsequer
available to update the report
Finding capital ie getting more and more difficls for mining.
companies, so the required feasibility study has to work alot
harder, These strategies can make the feasibility study a better
and longer-lived investment for mining companies to attract
capital
‘Mauro Chiesa has over 35 years of experience in financing
and advising extra
ive and infrastractare projects, He has
worked with multinational banks in New York City, a the
World Bank Group and EDC.