LIP Digest Compiled PDF

c

Page 1
Ê
Ê
Ê

1. G.R. No. L-36402. March 16, 1987.]
FILIPINO SOCIETY OF COMPOSERS, AUTHORS AND PUBLISHERS, INC., plaintiff-
appellant, vs. BENJAMIN TAN, defendant-appellee.

!
" "# #" !
"$ # %c
%&'()

*

)

!
)+

, !

-

- .
c)

/0

- ,

-
c 1# ..23 ,
,

c 4

, !, ,)

5&') ,%
,
, , "

c) %! , 6 ,
, "
! ,

, 7,
")% , ! , 4
)

&-! , -

c) #*

-
-

, ,
, ,

)

%
.. ' # - ' &).
1 ! , 8! 92:3 *;
'
;

*
;, #
<=!-

,
1.3
, ! > ! 1<3 !
, ) !
,
,?
,
1.3

,?-,,
,

)/ ! @

,, !,
c)

c

Page 2
Ê
# );
7A A
B

2. G.R. No. 115758. March 19, 2002.]
ELIDAD C. KHO, doing business under the name and style of KEC COSMETICS
LABORATORY, petitioner, vs. HON. COURT OF APPEALS, SUMMERVILLE GENERAL
MERCHANDISING and COMPANY, and ANG TIAM CRAY, respondents.

!
, $0 c, !

'- C D!
,
;
&).=8&).<:84

E -

F
!

;
' C, :!98;

&)2= 94
- - A,
! ! ,
, !

A , 4 !
,?

)

;

- 6 - 7 ! " ,
, ( C % 4
%
7 -

> '
-
4 $0 c, ,

4! F
!

! ,"
, , % >
)

/0+'&$5' )

5&')%"!

,
)#" - ,
,

1"3 - 1- "3
"
) !

) > !

"

), - !!
, - ! --
- - ,)

6 -,?
) % , ,?
" @ ) ,
6 - , !
-
, , ) % A

6 -
,?
c

Page 3
Ê

) @ ! ? ,
-
-
6 !-
-
"
, )
3. [G.R. No. 76193. November 9, 1989.]

UNITED FEATURE SYNDICATE, INC., petitioner, vs. MUNSINGWEAR CREATION
MANUFACTURING COMPANY, respondent.

Ê Ê
"

" 5#;c 0 G;'+&
1;
&);)2 23 >/& &H+0#;!

,
"5#;c 0G;'+&% =
;
&) ;2 2 , ! 9:9 >

>
)! )!

13

" 5#;c 0 G;'+&! E 0I 0

4 1 3 5#;c 0 G;'+& !

6 - , 41.3
5#;c 0 G;'+&! 9=
! 6 4 123

, "

)
{
Ê Ê
! " 5#;c 0 G;'+& E 0I 0 * % !
!!, ! =45#;c 0G;'+&
, !

7 ) "

*5#;c 0G;'+&E0I 0 *
5#;c 0G;'+&
;
', ! 982 '

"
" 5#;c 0 G;'+& -
"
)

+50%50; %50 ;0'&0&% '/;%'C #0#c '>> %%0 H;#I0 #G/0
'C ;0% '& #>'/&% &H %' 0J0 'C K/; % '& +50& G( > &H
%50 #0#c %' % C;'> %50 0 '& 'C %50 ;0%'; 'C #%0&%! %
$&'+ &Hc( ;0H#;0 % '+& 0 '& & #H;)) &').2 !+5 5+#
#CC ;>0 G( %5 5'&';#Gc0 /;0>0 '/;% %' %50 0CC0% %5#% #
'(; H5%0 5#;#%0; >#( &'% G0 #;'; #%0 # # %;#0>#;$ G(
#&'%50;/&0;;0 0&% #c0;00&')29)

Ê{ Ê
% )
5#;c 0G;'+& -,

," 9= &)29!
" )
c

Page 4
Ê
#

! -"

"5#;c 0G;'+&

"
/ C ) 9=:
%I0 #c
0#&/%5#;c 0
G;'+&L)
, "

*' )

4. G.R. Nos. L-76649-51. August 19, 1988.]
20TH CENTURY FOX FILM CORPORATION, petitioner, vs. COURT OF APPEALS,
EDUARDO M. BARRETO, RAUL SAGULLO and FORTUNE LEDESMA, respondents.

Ê Ê
% @

6 ,,?
)#
!
- , &G *
"

@ , )
{
Ê Ê
% @

-
,

&G

-, )
%

! -

- ) % *

,
, - -
,,6 ? )
Ê{ ÊÊ
%

! -
-
)% *

, ,
- -,,6 ?
)%
)
%

-

7

,

)) 29) %

c

Page 5
Ê
, "
") 5!

- -
7
) % "

,
, @ ,,)>

5. G.R. No. 131522. July 19, 1999.]

PACITA I. HABANA, ALICIA L. CINCO and JOVITA N. FERNANDO, petitioners, vs.
FELICIDAD C. ROBLES and GOODWILL TRADING CO., INC., respondents.
A !

98=!C
) ;, ,
, * "!

! ! !
7D
," 0%) % 6 0% ,"
0) %
! ," 0%
," 0! !
;,
" -
, *,"
,
7 )
;A ' &-, 8! 988! ;, Ê !

);
13,"0 ! 6 !
6
-
,"4 1 3 0
@ , 0

,
#
# 1##3! ,
," ,
" ,41.3 ,*6

!
)
;

,

!, 5, ?
,"00% 6,"

C0/ - )ÊÊ

13! 6! @ ,
00%!

41 3
Y Y 0%
" 4 1.3 ;,
, *
! - &)29
;/c &H
+, -;,*

," ,
6! "
,"

*
)
+ , ,"B @

"! -
! , ) "
c

Page 6
Ê
-
" , !

? 6!" )

@
!

" )%
!
-
"-, ) "-

, !,
,
? 6 , ! )
% ,

- ,
)

- ,
!!!
, !

! ! !

, !
!

,
)
,! @ -
,"
0%0) ,,",
,"

,"!
, # ) 5-!

,"
6 ,
)
% , ,,
6 ## , - 6 !

, ,"
)
5-! , - - ;,
,"

6 ! 6,
- 6 ,") % 6
,- ) 5 D 6 ,
"
B
+ Y

;,

H ," ," 0
*

*) ,"0
- - !
, ,"
0

% )

!
, )%

? )5! ? ;, *,"
*"
) ," 0 "

)
5!

",
;, ) * "

?
)

,"

- )%
c

Page 7
Ê

! 82)1,3) F , "
, 6? , !
@
-
!
"! )

6. G.R. No. 148222. August 15, 2003.]
PEARL & DEAN (PHIL.), INCORPORATED, petitioner, vs. SHOEMART, INCORPORATED,
and NORTH EDSA MARKETING, INCORPORATED, respondents.

1 )3! )

-

,6)% 7
, ,"
)
,
;
- )
%-

,6""M#L)C98
,988! - > -
-
)
% !> - ! ,
, !
,6A
)> -13
,6,@ ,
, > > )#!! -6

,6 >)

- !,> &0> ?

,?
,6-> A
, ) "M#!L

)
/ !>

,6&0> "
- M#L
> A)

,> &0> !

"
!
)
/0+

-
1

,63

1

3!
,6

,
B
50c&') EA >

-

,6> , >0(; ,#-

)',- ! A ,
-

6
Y
,6

C ! A

M'L" 1'3291% 3
-
) 6 ",?

0) )%

, ! !
,
"
666666 666
1'3 ! !-
!,!
!,64
c

Page 8
Ê
666666 666
#
A
M#-
/ L1
,6 - 3!

,
)

! !
)G

!
) ,, ?
,?, !
) Y Y Y Y

E
Y % ,
!
A
6

,6
,
M ! !-

! ,!
,6 )L ! - E
-
!-

M )L - ,

,6)% N9OA -

-
- ! ! -

M#-
/ )L + ! 6!

,6 ,

)# ! " "

,6
,, ,

,
& c , M#-
/ )L
! > &0> EA
,
E!, -,

)G
)> A&0> A , E-

,6
, >0(
; ,#-
!
- )+

A
-
B+ ")

7. [G.R. No. 110318. August 28, 1996.]
COLUMBIA PICTURES, INC., ORION PICTURES CORPORATION, PARAMOUNT
PICTURES CORPORATION, TWENTIETH CENTURY FOX FILM CORPORATION, UNITED
ARTISTS CORPORATION, UNIVERSAL CITY STUDIOS, INC., THE WALT DISNEY
COMPANY, and WARNER BROTHERS, INC., petitioners, vs. COURT OF APPEALS,
SUNSHINE HOME VIDEO, INC. and DANILO A. PELINDARIO, respondents.

Ê ÊÊ
Ê
!
& G -

- &) 29! !
-)
#
@!&G #
c);
Y
"
7!
! -

4 !
- !- D
@
ÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊ ÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊ
Ê
c

Page 9
Ê
, 6 , !
! !
! -
)
#
!
@ !
,, )

,
@
- ! , - , 6 ! ,

,,

--
-
! 6
)

{
Ê Ê
- ,

#

@,
÷

! !
- ,, ) #
--!
÷
, ! ! # .! ; < 98=
; , -

-
) %

÷ ,,)5!
- ! ,

)%
÷
! -

- *
"
@ @
! -
-
, )

Ê{ Ê
% *
) !

Y

- ,
-

6 ,,

Y YY

Y
Y
)#,? -

- ,

6 ,@

)K
, 6 !
- -

7 )
-
!
÷ !

!

@ ,, ! , !
,
,, )
Ê

8. G.R. No. 108946. January 28, 1999.]
FRANCISCO G. JOAQUIN, JR., and BJ PRODUCTIONS, INC., petitioners, vs.
HONORABLE FRANKLIN DRILON, GABRIEL ZOSA, WILLIAM ESPOSO, FELIPE MEDINA,
JR., and CASEY FRANCISCO, respondents.

c

Page 10
Ê

Ê Ê
GK ! )1GK 3 D

&)>9 !
K 8!9:!{YY !

9:9::

;5'##& >0 ,
6 - , , * %* #
#%0 6 *;5'##&>0,,
) # N,O
- ! , -
* ;5'# #& >0 P* %* # #%0
,!,
!

D
6)%?,
)# - )
{
Ê Ê
G, - , 6
,,
- {YY
)% GK *
- {YY

- ,

))&)29)
Ê+ %I ,,?

)
Ê{ Ê
% ,

,) )) &) 29!
" 0;00 '& &%0cc0%/#c ;'0;%(! "

! - )
C ! , , 6 - ) %

6 ! ! ! ! !
! ! - !
,! 6 !
!, ")
9. [G.R. No. L-75697. June 18, 1987.]

VALENTIN TIO doing business under the name and style of OMI ENTERPRISES,
petitioner, vs. VIDEOGRAM REGULATORY BOARD, MINISTER OF FINANCE, METRO
MANILA COMMISSION, CITY MAYOR and CITY TREASURER OF MANILA, respondents.

C#% % , ! 98< , ,
, -
- )
&) 98: # #
I

;
G ,
- -

1 , G'#;3) %
', =!
98="# !98<! 1=3 ,
' H7)
'&-,=!98=!
,- !
&) 992 & ;- -
!

c

Page 11
Ê
0) .2) I %) Q % , - !
,"!

! 6 - 4 - ! %
,"- ,,?6)

' ', .! 98<! H > % # !
>-
! , # ! >
# ! - -!
, - !- * !

-
- -
- 6 ,
)% -
- )
% !

! -
-
)
/0+'&))98:-
- )

5 &') % * - ,
-

,
6 ) G
-
!
) +
,? -
0;00 ,- ! @ ,
, !
, 4
,-
, ,
,, - ,
- -

, -
@4
-- !
- - , - 6
> * @

, )

% # !98<,
,
- )' !- , -

.R6 )

! - -

) + - ?

&)98: - )

Ê
Ê
10. G.R. No. L-24919. January 28, 1980.]
JAMES HOWARD BOOTHE and JOHN MORTON, II, petitioners, vs. THE DIRECTOR OF
PATENTS, respondent.
MELENCIO-HERRERA, J.:
K 5 G K > ! ! 7
/ ! , - ,
!
- - 1 " 3
0% % '&0;Ac# >
' C, 9! 9=2! c -

-

c

Page 12
Ê
=c1;#<=3); * "
,
Y !"#$%)
'
"% "#$%!
7
# c / - 1/)) &)
.2 ==<3)
7 /
><!9<.)
, =c! -
=)# - ,)Q#

- , -

-
! ,
! - -
7 !
- -

-
- !%
-

0
S
, ><! 9=.

>=!9=2!
>=!9=2)
;0'&0&%Ac# >
; &) =2Q&-, 9!9=<!

, , 7 )! , -
- ) #!
,
)
; ,@
,

)5-!
@ * , # 2!9=2

, ) @ !
, !

, = c!

;2:28;- ;
>=!9=2)
/0 +50%50; ;0'&0&% ;0%'; 'C #%0&% 0;;0 & 5'c &H %5#%
0% % '&0;*#c #% '&!>#(&'%G0%;0#%0#C c0/&0;0% '&=#
#>0&0!'C;0/Gc #%&')<=$&'+&#%50#%0&%c#+)
50c&') - , ,)

- c , ! !
)Ê% @

, - !
c

Page 13
Ê
! -

6 ,- )
% , > =! 9=2 ) %
, ) +
- ,) * ,
K ! 9<. ,

); !
&
Y
Y Y YY
Y
"%"#$% Y Y

Y
Y '
- , ; 2: 28!
;- ; !@ , &)<!Y
Y YY
Y
Y Y "!"#$(

Y Y
Y C!,

!
- - , ,
, "

@ )

11. G.R. No. L-27361. May 29, 1981.]
PARKE, DAVIS & COMPANY, plaintiff-appellant, vs. DOCTORS' PHARMACEUTICALS,
INC. and V-LAB DRUGHOUSE CORPORATION, defendants-appellees.

C

'> =!9<<!"!- E !

76

>
!/))#)! C ; 7!
G!

! ?
* ! )! Ic,

)

"! - E

4 13

! ,
!
, !

,
I ! 1 3
! ,
! ! , -

, - I
-, )
Ic,

! -

*
I - -
-
)
' > <! 9<<! C !
!

!
!
,

, * * ,
* , !"!- E ! )#

- ! > 2! 9<<!
)
G * !
> ! > =! 9<<!

!
!

&)

! ,
* )
c

Page 14
Ê
' K :! 9<<! ' > -
!

! * )
-, ,?
! ! ! ,-,

! ! ! c ,? !
! c &) :9! c ,?

! !c&)=)
'K :!9<<! ; '

!
!
-

I !-
)
' K =! 9<<! ;? ; '
!

! "
,*I
!
, , , - , c &) :9! !
)
% C ; 7 #
! 9<<!

"

Ê
+

)

Ê
&) 6 -

!

, !
)5

!
- !
!

) C!

!
-
@ )
#,
! @!

1, -, c &)=3
1,-, c&) :93)
%!
*

,!

- )%

@
" ?
,- )%6
-
,

@ - -
, )
5 !
!

,I
"
,!
-

) C ,

,
!
, !

,
! c &)
c

Page 15
Ê
:9! 2
- ,) .: 2 ;)#) &) <=
-
0).:); H5%'C#%0&%00)#-6 -

"! ! !
!

4"
!

, 7 !

)1 )3
0) 2 ) I c #% '& C'; &C; &H0>0&%) # !

! - !

- ,
! ,
- ,
C !-

,

?
)

c " ! ,
,

* ! )A I
!
-, ) 9 ;)#) &) << - !

!
!

,

13# " )
!
!

!

)
+50;0C';0! ,

)Ê

12. G.R. No. L-32160. January 30, 1982.]
DOMICIANO A. AGUAS, petitioner, vs. CONRADO G. DE LEON and COURT OF APPEALS,
respondents.
Ê
Ê
{
Ê Ê
' # 2! 9< ! H) c C ; 7
F7

#) #
C) 5)
#@

- -
"
!Ê
!-

' !&)<=8
)Ê
#) #

c &) <=8 , "
!

,
- Ê
C)5)#@ E

, "

#) #

-
!
-

,
4 - )Ê
{
Ê Ê
c

Page 16
Ê
% @ - - !
H) c!
! ,? !
- - ! - "

)Ê
% c
,"
)Ê
% - , , !
- -)Ê
%

,
-
- - , > % C
% >
-,
-
,
-)Ê
Ê
Ê
+A*"
*
&I#c ,
- -

,, ,, )

Ê
Ê , - , -
- "
)5 - -
) !c&)<=8 , '
-!H)c!
-

- "
) ! :!
;, # &) <=! - # - !
,! ! -

! ,
,)L
Ê % * - - -
, 6
" )5 " )5 -
"
,
, , ,"
!
-
) 5
- ,
-
-
! ,
, ),
! !-
)
% > - ) %

,
- , )% , ,
,
-)G !> -
-)% ,% c* )%
) % -- "

) ! )#

-

! -- "

)

13. G.R. No. L-27004. August 16, 1983.]
PARKE, DAVIS & COMPANY, petitioner, vs. DOCTOR's PHARMACEUTICALS, INC. and
TIBURCIO S. EVALLE, in his capacity as Director of Patents, respondents.
TEEHANKEE, Acting C.J.:
c

Page 17
Ê
ÊÊ
H);)&)c ! -- ! !
#
.! 9<=
&-,=!9<. &)8
"- E)

* ! ) !

* )
/ .< ;, # <= 1 c3! 7!
,

! 6
) %! * H);) &) c , 6 !
,

! !
- *c&)=
! 6

" )
% - !

! "!
- E)! !
,
@ - 0
18R3

@ , =R)
6
, ,
-
-

=R8R
)
"
=R !
-

HG ! K);)H

)#)* ! D R , ) '

, E )
& c6c, ! =R-
:R! ,!
)
+ 6

&')% ,

6
,
-
) % 8R ,
& ) -
" ! ,
, , !

!
,

!

13

)
%
8R ,
*
! )
- "!- E !
) ,
!"!- E >
!/))#)
* "
? !"!- E)!
) !
,"
)
c

Page 18
Ê
#!%
"!- E)! ), ,
8 R
, , @
, ,
8R)
14. G.R. No. 126627. August 14, 2003.]

SMITH KLINE BECKMAN CORPORATION, petitioner, vs. THE HONORABLE COURT OF
APPEALS and TRYCO PHARMA CORPORATION, respondents.

Ê Ê
$ G" 6
- !
/)
- - M>

G # - /
> = G7 7
,)% -)
-,#,7
-

- ,
!

,

7 )
# 89 -

#,7)

{
Ê Ê
c -,#,7)
%- #,7!, ,)
%GC "
#,7
"
)
-

% - )
% - -
, ,

, - -, )

)

+

)

;

&) + #,7 6 ,
- A !

c
&) 2=<

#,7) #
6 - , - #,7
A

, ) + , -
7
!

#,7 , ,
, !-

-)
c

Page 19
Ê
15. [G.R. No. 113407. July 12, 2000.]

LOTHAR SCHUARTZ, FRIEDEL VERDERBERG, UDOLF KUEHNE, DIETER FISCHER,
JOHN BERNARD WATKINS, HARRY GREAVES, CHEN WOO CHIN, YOSHIMI IWASAKI,
FABIO CARLI, MORTIMER THOMPSON, MALCOLM JOHN LAW, MICHIBAZU OCHI, KENJI
SHIGEMATSU, ENI SHINOZAKI, ROBERT CABI-AKMAN, ARTHUR SPRENGER, REMY
SIMOND and HEINRICH EVBERGGER, petitioners, vs. THE HONORABLE COURT OF
APPEALS (SPECIAL FIFTH DIVISION) and THE BUREAU OF PATENTS, TRADEMARKS
AND TECHNOLOGY TRANSFER, respondents.
' ! G!%"

%
%
) %
; !
> '
"-
A " @ G
, !
' # )#
, ! ,
Ñ "#)*)
% !H
G
";;
) ! "

!
!

G)
! + "#)* -
) ,
,)
%! !
! G
- - ) G
- -, )
K .!
99! - - ) % -
C, :!99! -1:3 !
C, 2! 99) #
! ,
, ) )
% # ,
, =

)%#, ,
- - 4 A
, ,? , -
,?,, G - )
Y Y #

- -
)
Ê
B

Ê ,- ,

!
,)5-!

,
, )

- - G!,

) G !
-
- - )
C

,

,, G
c

Page 20
Ê
)% , ,, K98:!,
,:!98:! G
";, !
", )% ,

)
# A @ , -
, , 6 ) #

) ! A "
,! , - -
! - ) %
)
5!
)% #
- ,

- )

16. G.R. No. 134217. May 11, 2000.]
KENNETH ROY SAVAGE/K ANGELIN EXPORT TRADING, owned and managed by
GEMMA DEMORAL-SAVAGE, petitioners, vs. JUDGE APRONIANO B. TAYPIN, Presiding
Judge, RTC-BR. 12, Cebu City, CEBU PROVINCIAL PROSECUTOR'S OFFICE, NATIONAL
BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION, Region VII, Cebu City, JUANITA NG MENDOZA, MENDCO
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION, ALFREDO SABJON and DANTE SOSMENA,
respondents.
#

, - 0 &
>7!

> - 1>0&'3! -
#

> &G ;% , ) %

7 $ #
06
% !,! 7

,? --

! ,#)
89;- )%! 7 -
! ! 7 - &G
)
-@);K

> F)
? -

;
1 ;3!

# -'&).9=

,;

% !> % > %
;)% - ;

#) 89 ;- - ? )
,@ # - ' &) 29< -

? -- ; ;
% )
/0 3 + ?

D?
3+ --

,#)89
;- 6
50c
c

Page 21
Ê
3 (0! ?
1& ! -!
&'% - 3)%

-)G
, 6 ?

? )%
,
? ) ! % !,!
? )

;)
# - ' &) .9=
--
- ;) !!-6 -?

1
? 3
)% - ;,6 - -
# -'&).9=)
3 &') ;"K 998
- 6 , ) %
-
## )
% --

6 --

!
#)89;- !, ,
)
%-, , - ,- ;)%

,

, >0&'!
!
-

>,
, )%
Q
<8) ) #

,
,
! , ! - -
,

! !,

!,,? )
% - --

- / ) 6
!;#8 9. #)89;-
) ,
!

, - ! ,
6 ,
! @ , )
17. G.R. No. 118708. February 2, 1998.]

CRESER PRECISION SYSTEMS, INC., petitioner, vs. COURT OF APPEALS AND FLORO
INTERNATIONAL CORP., respondents.

, - Y.
A ! 2 c1;)#)<=3!

,
!
c

Page 22
Ê
- ) - ,
-

!
, , - -

? -
7
# ) % ! ! , " -

2 c)

{
- Y.
- C , Ê

YY/ - -4 *- ,
, G 4 -
,
-YY
/
6 -
!
,
? ? 6
-
)

0.
+
,

{ .
&') 2 ;)#)<=! "c!6 -
)2 )Y )Q# !

! - !
- ,

! ,
- ,C 1
;
% 3!-

,

?
))))
/ @ !

)%Y
Y Y
Y ! *
!

,
,
!!
!
!6 -

)

- YY/)%!
,
?

, -)
18. G.R. No. 113388. September 5, 1997.]

ANGELITA MANZANO, petitioner, vs. COURT OF APPEALS, and MELECIA MADOLARIA,
as Assignor to NEW UNITED FOUNDRY MANUFACTURING CORPORATION,
respondents.
Ê
, - Y.
#
>7 ' 9C, 98
c&)/>2<9
,

> > ,@
&
c

Page 23
Ê
/ C >
1/& %0 C'/&;(! ,- 3)

13 -, ! !cH
,!
- -!41,3
@ )2!;#&)<=!413> >

! - -

!
- -, 4!13
, )

13 - ,
,", 13 ,
9,9:941,3
-, , ,
13 , )

{
- Y.
- !
! ; > ! !

!H- /& %0C'/&;( !
,
4 !/& %0C'/&;(

"
-,,"
, 4

,,4
9:8> > ,
,

,
4 ,
- - 6 , - "
4 -
- 4!
- - !,
" ! , -

- ) I
- > > ,
) ; > -
,9:9)

0.
+

> > TcHGA

{ .
&')
c&)/>2<9> > McHGL
K 98! ' - - ,) %

-

-)
' : K 98< )
&)8<=<

- ,
, -
- )&
- , -

- , ,
) % -
,
-
, -
- ,
! -
, )% ,
, !! )%
- A c &) />2<9
c

Page 24
Ê
, , D ) & - -
, > >
- ! ! - ,
' c @ )
%
!
, #! - , ,
- )

-

' #)
19. G.R. No. 121867. July 24, 1997.]

SMITH KLINE & FRENCH LABORATORIES, LTD., petitioner, vs. COURT OF APPEALS,
BUREAU OF PATENTS, TRADEMARKS AND TECHNOLOGY TRANSFER and DOCTORS
PHARMACEUTICALS, INC., respondents.

Ê ÊÊÊÊÊ{ Ê {{!Ê c
&) : , G%%%
)

{Ê{ !Ê Ê "
, "4 -
{Ê
{ !Ê ÊÊ -4 {Ê
{ !Ê Ê -,

) ,

" "
-, )
C !
.2.=;)#)&)<=-

@ ) -"# =
- ! - !!
, 9<=)

{
Ê ÊÊ {Ê{ !Ê Ê

,
,
)'.
>98:!
G%%% 7
,
"

)% - .2
;, #&)<=1##
' ,
!
;

!#
C%3! -

6

- ! YY! ,
, )

c&) :
9&-,9:84 , -
- .2;)#)&)<=4 , "
" )Ê
G%%%0 '&I 'c#%0 &%0;&#% '&#cc#+
#0>G' 0 &1#3%50#; '&I0&% '&C';%50;'%0% '&'C
&/%; #c;'0;%(#&1G3%50H#%%%;0#%(!/;/H/#(;'/&!#&>/%
#'; &Hc(G00%# 0#&>' C 0)
5&)ÊÊÊ ÊÊ Ê"#$Ê%Ê Ê&Ê%Ê ÊÊÊ ' Ê
' Ê Ê Ê Ê ÊÊ%Ê ( Ê ÊÊÊ ' Ê
ÊÊ' Ê%Ê Ê Ê%Ê Ê ÊÊ ' Ê( Ê)ÊÊ
Ê%Ê Ê Ê%Ê Ê ' ÊÊ % Ê(Ê Ê #6
- ,, "4-! ,
c

Page 25
Ê
6!

,)
Ê*+Ê%Ê{ÊÊ,-&!Ê ' Ê%Ê ÊÊ)Ê ÊÊÊ Ê Ê Ê
Ê Ê ' !Ê%Ê) Ê) Ê Ê% Ê' Ê%Ê Ê&Ê%Ê ÊÊ
' Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê%Ê ÊÊ,,&-Ê)Ê ' Ê( Ê{ÊÊ
,-&!Ê Ê ' Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê%ÊÊ Ê Ê)Ê Ê ÊÊ%%Ê
Ê Ê ÊÊ' Ê Ê( Ê)Ê Ê Ê%Ê Ê Ê!Ê(Ê
ÊÊ ' Ê Ê)Ê%Ê !

, #!# =- !

" -
;)#)&)<=)
;)#) &) <=! , &) <.!
2 ,
9::!-
)
%, ,
13
.2
- ,
, ! , , )#
,,@- ;)#)&)<=!!

!, !
7

# =!
#1 3 - )
! ,

123 #! # =
-

" "
!

, )
& - -"

H#%% % ! /
;)
% ,"/
C #
=# 992,
% ; 7 &-) C

#
0,
+ % '
7 ! >
! /
C - ) % #

,
+ % '
7 -

) 2,992 ! 6
# I ! ; &) 9:

, #
) %

< , 992)G 4 Ê Ê Ê Ê ' Ê
%% Ê !Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê )Ê Ê Ê ,+Ê (Ê
,..+!Ê Ê Ê' Ê%Ê Ê' Ê%Ê Ê/Ê Ê
20. [G.R. No. 115106. March 15, 1996.]

ROBERTO L. DEL ROSARIO, petitioner, vs. COURT OF APPEALS AND JANITO
CORPORATION, respondents.

Ê Ê
;
@ -
@ "

YYc
, )% - ,c -1=3
6 - 1=3
K 988 2
&-, 99! - ) 5 ,

"!
! 6
c

Page 26
Ê
A- !-, !
,
)

99! - ! K !

,
"YYYYYY,

-, -)%

? ?
-! - ,
,!
!

-
YYYYYY,)

{
Ê Ê
;K - A

! , YY
A
@ )

;

, -YYYY
!"" -!-
"
,
)

{/Ê ,
,
- " ! - !
,?

, - )

! - !
, ,
,, )Ê
, , !
, , !

A/ >&)< .: -
) &
, !
-
, 13,,

- 41,3,
6!
,

4 13
,
6

413,
- 4
13,-

!,!,
41
3,@ " ,

,"!

!,
, "A -
! "

413, ,6 ", 4!1 3,,
)
! ! , A A -- ,
, )

{ ÊÊ
Ê
c

Page 27
Ê
21. G.R. No. 114508. November 19, 1999.] MYRTLE
PRIBHDAS J. MIRPURI, petitioner, vs. COURT OF APPEALS, DIRECTOR OF PATENTS
and the BARBIZON CORPORATION, respondents.
22. G.R. No. 120900. July 20, 2000.]

CANON KABUSHIKI KAISHA, petitioner, vs. COURT OF APPEALS and NSR RUBBER

' K =! 98=! - &; ;,,

" #&'& G ! %"
%
%1G%%%3)#- & ' , !

76
K!

,

,
" #&'& - -

,

1 ! ! 3) , -
%";
&).9.98!
-"#&'&
) ' &-, ! 99 G%%%

-
- A

"#&'&)'C, <!99.!
G%%% , #- G%%%)5!
- )

/0+ "M#&'&L

50c (0) % G%%% # " #&'& ,
! ! , , -
, )
" #&'& , -

" #&'&

) #
!
" -

"

)% ! ,
, ,-

"#&'&! -

"#&'&)C ! "#&'&
, " !

-
G%%%
-
-)%

, )' ! "

,
%"c)5-!" ,
! " A , -
,?)
23. G.R. No. L-28499. September 30, 1977.]

VICTORIA MILLING COMPANY, INC., petitioner, vs. ONG SU AND THE HONORABLE
TIBURCIO S. EVALLE, IN HIS CAPACITY AS DIRECTOR OF PATENTS, respondents.
FERNANDEZ, J.:
% ! I >

! )!

"I %'; #

' &-,9!9<)
c

Page 28
Ê
%'

"

"I#c0&% &0

' K
!9<)
0% % '&0;A'&%0&% '&
I >
! ) '

'
"I )
% "I

-

, "4
I

, "! !

, I "4

, , '
I

I , )

" 6
)
;0'&0&%A'&%0&% '&
;-

, I "

"I

;
&) 889 K ! 9<4 " I

" I
"4
, " ! "

* " I
* "
I

)
%

'
-
"I
,
% @ -

"
)' I#c0&% &0 I %'; #)
% * "

!-!@!
! ! "!
- "!

" ! -
@
) -
, -
! ,
,
,

1 3
@

, )
#
," ! "
? ! ,
!
"! ! !
," , !

, )
c

Page 29
Ê
C !

@

! ! "!

* Q --

- ' ? )
/0+50%50;';&'%%50 ;0%';'C#%0&%0;;0 &';0; &H&'%%'

#&0c%50;0H %;#% '&'C%50;0'&0&%)
50c&')%

" 6

)%
",

7
!
!

)# , !

"
- @
) # -

" @

, )%I

,
) ! -
,

"I -!6
)
)
I I ,

I >
! )'
"
@ ) % , , ,
" @ " *I *
)
% ? -
)
24. G.R. No. L-23954. April 29, 1977.]

AMERICAN CYANAMID COMPANY, petitioner, vs. THE DIRECTOR OF PATENTS and TIU
CHIAN, respondents.

Ê
# .!9=9!

&) =.28 K <! 9=<! - % * "
/c>0% &0 7 -
! ! ! "
, ) "/c>0%
"- !
!,"
7 13 " "4
" 4
,, "!
"! " " ") %

! /c>0% , " ?
,
, , 6 - -
) &

,-!
/c>0% &0
" - , "
*

?)

c

Page 30
Ê
' K 9! 9<2!

*
"/c>0% &0!,

13 *"/c>0%
! !
! !
!/c>0% &0 "
, )
1 3 ' ,! (#&#>
, , ,
#>0; #& (#&#> '>#&(! &0+ (';$ !
&)()
)'!
* ,! 06 , !
50&;(* ,! ,
50&;(*c#G';#%'; 05 c &0

)
1.3 * "

,,!!
, -
,!06 , )

%,- -,
, , "

-

, , )

+ * * " ,
, * /c>0% , &0!
,/c>0%

- ,
! !/c,
-/cC#>0% !
6 -! , &0, !
"
")

Ê
+ *"/c>0% &0
"/c>0%
-

, -
;, #<< "%>"c)

Ê
&)%
" ?
*
" /c>0% &0) # 6
- , ,

"
,,!06 , G!
,
,
) ,
7!,"
!!!
4 )

,,
-"
! ! "
*)

>-!/c>0% -, ,/c
->0% ,
c

Page 31
Ê
,
, &0
* ,
* "
)

%
"

, ! * /c>0% ,! 06 , G!
"
,,)%,
, 6 * ,
!!- " 71"!
3 -
* /c>0% ,) 5-!

,-) %
- )+ ,
, "

-,
, , -

) - /c>0%
/c>0% &0 -
, !
,
)

25. G.R. No. L-23035. July 31, 1975.]
PHILIPPINE NUT INDUSTRY, INC., petitioner, vs. STANDARD BRANDS INCORPORATED
and TIBURCIO S. EVALLE, as Director of Patents, respondents.
Ê
Ê
&! ! , ' #
!
9<! ;
&);2<-
"5 c &0c#&%0;
'; #c0#&/%!, )Ê
Ê
{
Ê Ê
' > 2! 9< ! G
!
"
&*

"

1 G3
" c#&%0; '$%# c 0#&/% - ,
;
&);: ! , ' K 8!9=8)Ê
&*"5 c &0c#&%0;'; #c0#&/%
,
" c#&%0;
'$%# c0#&/%!

" -,
,
)Ê
Ê
{
Ê Ê
c#&%0;, "
@ , -!
+, !

)
c

Page 32
Ê
; -,
c#&%0;! - -

" )
,"!!
,-c#&%0; ,!! C
F ! ('
G !
F7 ! )! -

! , G
C ! !
>) 7)
-?
c#&%0;
,-
@
)

Ê
+"5 c &0c#&%0;'; #c0#&/%,
& , Y"c#&%0;
'$%# c 0#&/% , G

*"
? )
Ê
Ê #
Ê Ê !
!
"
,
" !
"4
! ", )Ê
+ c#&%0; !- ,
,!,?

)%c#&%0; , ,

" " )
*" G*!
!,? - ,

,
) # c#&%0;
,

)

,

!,! !
, -"
7

G*"!

, ,) # !
* " *" ! ,

)
%

, ,
) % * ,
- c#&%0;
, ,
c#&%0;

)#
>)G*,!
- - , -!

>) -
!
c

Page 33
Ê
-

) +

>) 5 7 "
G! ,
-
- , , -
! "
c#&%0; ,)
+

!

,6 -
"! ,

-!
-
-,
6 - , !
,
, !
)
% ,
,
, -

c#&%0; , , G
9.8 ) & ,
! , , , ,
-
- -
c#&%0; "
) ! - c#&%0;,
-" , !,

," 9.8! G @

"

, )
26. G.R. No. 10738. January 14, 1916.]

RUEDA HERMANOS & CO., plaintiff-appellant, vs. FELIX PAGLINAWAN & CO.,
defendant-appellant.
TRENT, J.:
Ê% -

)G

) ; 5 ,

,

" 9) >! 92! C 6

)G
! !"

- )%"

!
! @
) %
, "
6

7 !

*"
)
K
, - ?

! )G -!
@ , !

)
+ ,
Ê Ê (0) %
- ,
" - 6
!
"
,
- ", 6 "
)
"

!
7"

c

Page 34
Ê
,"
) 6 7!! !
!

"
!
, " - 6

!
) # -

"
, - - "

6 , ,)
Ê %Ê Ê Ê % Ê %Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê %%0Ê Ê Ê !Ê

,, ,

"
) /
-*
")* !

)
,! C 6

! , !

, *! *

6 "
6
)% , " !

! 7! * ! !!
!, , )
H! "

M
L)
"

R

27. G.R. No. 14269. October 16, 1919.]
FORBES, MUNN & CO. (LTD.), plaintiff-appellant, vs. ANG SAN To, defendant-appellee.
GR No. L-14269, October 16, 1919
Malcolm, J:

Ê Ê

7 ,
)
,

6
"" )
"
"" ! " ,

M% $" LM $" L

" , )
6 -

"! "

, !- "

,

{
Ê Ê
;
, > )
c , > """
)
,
)

Ê
+ ,
)
c

Page 35
Ê

{ Ê
()% ,

,

) !- !

") >-! ) % -
,

, -"!

!
)
" - ,
,) # " - ,
? )

28. [G.R. No. 45502. May 2, 1939.]
SAPOLIN CO., INC., cross-plaintiff-appellant, vs. CORNELIO BALMACEDA, as Director of
the Bureau of Commerce and Industry, and GERMANN & CO., LTD., cross-defendants.
GERMANN & CO., LTD., appellee.
#P!Ñ.
Ê
% , ' /
-6 - "
) " !

! !
- , ?

,
"
c )
%@ "! !
! 7
!, c
!" )
% "
" ! !
!
!- ! !6))
% ! ! "
,
" @ )
% C > ?

!-

G
"
-, '
/ !
- 2#&)
<<<!, #&)... )
C ?

- , 13%

"c HE)!c)!

*" 41 3

,
, - -
2 41.3

, !
4123

#&)... 4
1=3 "
?
)

ÊÊ
13
"

- ,
G
B
1 3 -
, B
Ê
c

Page 36
Ê
",$Ê 2#&)<<<!, #&)... !-
,:!9 <!

12 % 3 Y Y YY Y
Y'Y
Y Y

Y Y
YY'
Y Y' Y Y Y Y Y Y
Y Y 4Y Y 0 Y Y

% c
-
- 2 !
, # &) ... ! ! "

- ,
G !
-- ,"

-
"
' / )
, , !
- c
"

! "
)%
, "
@ !
, 6
,)
'
"
,

G !

" "
*
, !, !, !
!

)

"#$Ê % - " , ,

- ,
,,Q,
, , Q ,
"4 , ,
- ! , !
- )
# , c ,

! -, "
" ") *
GG" " - G G" "!
- 4
Y - ")
5-

,
" @ ! !

@ ,
, ! "

) # - " ,,

)% 6 ,
@ ! " ! , ,
)# - "
!,
G @ "
c

Page 37
Ê

4 ! Q
,
" ," - )

# @
@ ?)
! -! ,

! , -
!"

-
)% ,6
)

29. G.R. No. 48226. December 14, 1942.]
ANA L. ANG, petitioner, vs. TORIBIO TEODORO, respondent.
% , % M#

% , L,"!
! ,, 9) 5

" , 9= 9..)

"M#
% , L 9. )
- A")5M#
% , L -
! , ,? ")

"M#
% , L)

/0+"M#
% , L
,

50c(0)M#
% , L -
%"c,
, ")#
, M#
% , L
@
) +

!

,
) ! ,
" -,

@ 6)

30. G.R. No. L-4531. January 10, 1953.]
ANG SI HENG and SALUSTIANA DEE, plaintiffs-appellants, vs. WELLINGTON
DEPARTMENT STORE INC., BENJAMIN CHUA, S. R. MENDINUETO, and FILEMON
COSIO, defendants-appellees.
, 5,Y 'Y
Y - Y.

%
+

, , - ,
,
*
" ,
* - *
! ,

)
% !! ,?
,
+
+
! 4
,
, !
06
,
+
! )

{
5+ Y 'Y
- Y.
c

Page 38
Ê
%+
! )!G?
!,
!

!
!! !! !"

! 1 3

, "+
!
"
! ! !! ,
! !
"! , )

0.
3 + -@
+
L
,3 +! ,
!
! , )

{ .
3 &')%+

)G

!

, ,?6 -"
)1= #)K)!=28)30- +
! -
! , -
) 1 2!

13!;, #)&)<<)3#, "
! - , !
,
) %

?

"
6 -

" ) 1 .! ;, # &) <<)3 - !
! -

? - , +
)
,3 &') % -
- ! 61 ')H7)!&):!<:.367YY3
7 8 4 ) 1H);) &)2<8:!
# 8!92)3
- ,
" ! ,
6 - , ,
!@ !

, , ,

)
G ,! , ,
- , , - ,

,@@
,-!
-@ " ,
, * )
, - , , , *
, ! *,
-
-!, *,
)

31. G.R. No. L-3952. December 29, 1953.]
MASSO HERMANOS, S. A., petitioner, vs. DIRECTOR OF PATENTS, respondent.

, - Y.
c

Page 39
Ê
> 5! )#)!
# &) <<< "
) ' K 2! 928! !
>5!

"- 213;, #&)<<)

{
- Y.
% !" -

!!-,

"
- #&)<<<!@ !
213
;, #&)<<)
%

" # &) <<< - Y ,
-!!
,
)

0.
+ M L - ,

"

{ .
&')%
-!@
) - ,
!
)
% !!
"
#&)<<<- ,
)
-

!

" 6

&)88 K8!928)

32. G.R. No. L-8072. October 31, 1956.]
LIM HOA, petitioner, vs. DIRECTOR OF PATENTS, respondent.

Ê Êc 5! '

"!

,
MGL ,-!
"

# = ) % , '
H7 C, !9=.! # 8! )'
# .! 9=.! #
- )! )! !
-
!
!"
,

"!

M5 GL M> >"L! " ,

!,", )
{
Ê Ê% )K- #- ! 92<!
"
, !
) 92:!,#-
7#

-)! "-
#- !
, ,

M5L) 928! ,
MI% ! 5 GL M> >"!L !

!,! ,,

c

Page 40
Ê
? )
A,!

,! MGL ,-!

" , !
#- )
% K <!9=2!

A " " "
- !
"! ; :8
;- ; %"!9=.)
+c 5,
"

, MGL ,-
5&)% ,,
, ,

",

)@

" , , ) 7!!!
-! -Ê %Ê Ê Ê 1Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê
Ê % Ê %Ê !Ê Ê % Ê Ê Ê Ê 1 Ê Ê !Ê
% Ê 1 Ê 4

,
) Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê %Ê

% Ê%Ê 1ÊÊ) Ê Ê Ê%Ê Ê1Ê ' ' Ê) Ê( Ê 1 ÊÊ
Ê % ÊÊ1 Ê Ê Ê Ê%Ê Ê( ÊÊ ' Ê Ê
%
", ,

-
-!! - !

! !)! -, !

, ! , "
! - ,!
,

, !-"
")5 " , -, ",
"
- ,
- !)
G
! " - !
)
, "
!
,
- )%
"

"
6!,

"! " " !
"- ,

" ,M>"LM>>"L " ,

!
,
) % ! ") % ! -
)
33. G.R. No. L-14761. January 28, 1961.]

ARCE SONS AND COMPANY, petitioner, vs. SELECTA BISCUIT COMPANY, INC, ET AL.,
respondents.

Ê

Ê Ê
c

Page 41
Ê
#;0 '& " , 9..) 5 "
,- *0c0%#C;05> c$*
,)
% , G
)%

13"0c0%#, ,
!
"! ," ! "

7 - ,
!;#4
1 3"0c0%# ,
, 4
1.3 ",
,
, !,

4
123
0c0%# " ,"

4
1=3 " "

,! ,
! * " ,
" , , *
,
*4
1<3 , ,

C > "

?

?

")

Ê
{
Ê Ê
' #
.! 9==! G ! )!
! '

0c0%# " , ,"

,
! ! )))
"
! ,!

, -)
;-Ê
13 , !"!" !
"
! !

! ! "! " ,"
4
1 3 , * , !
> ,,! , 7
#7
!c G-)!> !
, ! 6

, 4
1.3 *
, , *0c0%#*
- "!F # !;!#7
!
G-)!G "%,! *

, G ! )!
- " G ! )! % #-! >,!
; 7!%&) . :4
c

Page 42
Ê
123, ,
4
1=3 - =!)
" .2!)
=!) 7 ! 1<3 *0c0%#* ,
, )Ê
{/Ê%

", !
!
0c0%# -
!," )%

, )
%"**! ,

!
!- !",
,
7

, , )
#*"* -"

,
!

-
)
% *"* ! ! ,! ,!

-
, ,

! , )
I ! *0c0%#* , , , ,
-
,
, , "

, , )% !!

"
)
%*0c0%#*! ! , ,

,
, ! ,
* , ,!
- 7
!,
! @
,6 -
, ) ! ,

, )#
*0c0%#* ") !
-
6 ) #
% ",
7
6!
" !
,
-
6 -"
-

- -
" ,

")

34. MEAD JOHNSON & COMPANY, petitioner, vs. N. V. J. VAN DORP, LTD., ET AL.,
respondents.
c

Page 43
Ê
, -Y.
> K E !
7 ! /))#)! ,

"#c#%#" "!

' K ! 9=!
,

,
"#c#$#
G *5

1#c#$# 3! "! "!
*!
"#c#%#)

{
-Y.

"#c#$#
* " #c#%#! *
- "! " ! * 2: C

C! * -
<! >
)

0.
+#c#$#
#c#%#

9.
&') + - 6 " ,
, ,
, ,

' !,
? -
* )5!
-
)

Ê Ê Ê Ê*+Ê

{ Ê

"#c#$#
G *5

)

" #c#$# *
" #c#%#! * - "! " !
* 2: C
C!
* -
<! > )

Ê

,
,

"#c#$# G *5

!
"! " ! * !

"#c#%#)
' 13
"
"
, *", "

" -!1 3

"
,
, -, 6 -)
5! - )

Ê2Ê Ê 1ÊÊÊ ( Ê
c

Page 44
Ê
Ê , * " #c#%# *
#c#$#
!, 6
, ,-!,

) %
" -,,

)%
,-
,
, ,

)5-

- ! , - "

"
) %

"
13% 7
)%
7!

2 "42D - "4<
- ")
1,3% )' *
,"
!

,4,"
! " )% *
-,! )

13 * " #c#%# 7 ,")
;*"#c#$# 7 6
" )
#
!

-, " @ !

*
! -
& & <
> !
*

,
, ,, )'!*
- "! "! *

! 2:
C
C!
@ )
+-6 " ,
, ,
, ,

' ! ,
? -
* ) 5!
-
)
35. G.R. No. L-18289. March 31, 1964.]

ANDRES ROMERO, petitioner, vs. MAIDEN FORM BRASSIERE CO., INC. and THE
DIRECTOR OF PATENTS, respondents.

C
' C, ! 9=:! > C G )! )! !

;#&)<<"M#
L, , !
,
) # ;
"

M#
L, -
, !!
,! "
c

Page 45
Ê
, , , 928 ,?
)

+'&"M#
L, -
,
,)

5
&)%"M#
L !
", , )G

! , 1 3 " ,
, ) "
! "!
, )# !M "

, !
, ")L

36. G.R. No. L-18337. January 30, 1965.]
CHUA CHE, petitioner, vs. PHILIPPINE PATENT OFFICE and SY TUO, respondents.
0% % '&0;A'&%0&% '&
'

-J:)

) J: " ! , !
,
)
, , "J: ,

1 3 *!
D

;0'&0&%A'&%0&% '&
;

) %
" J:
5/#50 " , ", -

, )
'*,
K .!9=."J:
! " 4,
,

"
- "
Q

!, , , -
!- - ) -
, !)) % @ ? -,

"J:)
% ! !

-
c

Page 46
Ê
% ?

- %)
/0+50%50;';&'%/;5#0;'CJ:0;C/>0!c % $#&&# c'c 5

+'/c c $0c( /'& 00 &H J: c#/&;( '#! #%%; G/%0 '>>'& '; H & %'
%50 ;'/% '; #/>0 %5#% %50;0 0J %0 '>0 $ & 'C %;#0
'&&0% '&G0%+00&#c #&%#&''0;)
50c(0)% % "J:

! ") %
"
, !

"!!,)%,-
-
" J:
J: ! " " -

! ")
+

,

- !- @ %>"#9=!

" , " ! "!
! -

) 1# -
)! =C) ! :)3% !
) % "

) G
,
, ! ! *
" J:!
,
" -
, )
37. G.R. No. L-20635. March 31, 1966.] YEN

ETEPHA, A.G., petitioner, vs. DIRECTOR OF PATENTS and WESTMONT
PHARMACEUTICALS, INC., respondents.
38. [G.R. No. 112012. April 4, 2001.]

SOCIETE DES PRODUITS NESTLE v. CA and CFC CORP
YNARES-SANTIAGO, J.:
Ê C G%%%
"
Cc#I';>#%0; ) &!

7! '
"

" 6 >#%0; ;'#%
>#%0;Gc0&)
c " ! , & !

) & , C " Cc#I'; >#%0;

" 4 -

, , &! Y
." >#%0;4
C
, "-

)
c

Page 47
Ê
G%%% CA

)#-

)
Ê + " Cc#I'; >#%0; , "
>#%0;;'#%>#%0;Gc0&,
)
Ê(0
)Ê
,

,
-
,)

, 6 !? -"
%5 %)% -

"

)% " @
,

)

" !

"
, !
,)0, )
%#, , !
!
!

,
6 - " !
6
,
)
%
,-
)

,
6 -
! , 6
,
! ,
" CA"Cc#I';>#%0;

&A,)%
,
! !

6 - )
>-!
"
, ,
- !! - -
, "
- ") %
- , "
- , -
- ,")
%
G%%% ) %
>#%0; A")
, , 7 ;'#%)C!
>#%0; ,
- %I
-
) ;, K" # ) ; !

!
- >H
>%"! - ) !,-

,
, >#%0;
A
)
+ " , ,
" Cc#I'; >#%0;! A
>#%0;! 6 )%!
c

Page 48
Ê
,
,
"

)

%>#%0;
-)#! ,

)/ -
,!
!
"
!
- ,
6 -
!
, - -
!
,)# '
- " ! !
- ! !@

- " ! -

!@
!

- - -6

)
% >#%0;
- ,

, , -

&) ' @
!

) ! ,

, !
, ,

) +
- " ,

- ! - --

!
-!
-,-)
% >#%0; @
>#%0;;'#%>#%0;Gc0&, &)#!, C
>#%0; " Cc#I'; >#%0; "
"- - )

39. [G.R. No. 111580. June 21, 2001.]
SHANGRI-LA INTERNATIONAL HOTEL MANAGEMENT LTD., SHANGRI-LA PROPERTIES,
INC., MAKATI SHANGRI-LA HOTEL AND RESORT, INC. and KUOK PHILIPPINE
PROPERTIES, INC., petitioners, vs. THE COURT OF APPEALS, HON. FELIX M. DE
GUZMAN, as Judge, RTC of Quezon City, Branch 99 and DEVELOPERS GROUP OF
COMPANIES, INC., respondents.
YNARES-SANTIAGO, J.:
Ê ' K ! 988!

c 5 >
! c)!
c
! )!>"
c5;! )$" ! )
1 -
c H3! G !
%" %
% 1G%%%3 !

c " - D
- H
! )!

,
* , ) %
c H

, ,?"
4 ,
"

, >9< ,

9:=!

, -H 98 )
c

Page 49
Ê
c " !
cH G%%%

,? "
) % - H ) #
1.3 ! # =! 99! - H

? !

cH)'K
8!99 !
cH-

-
,G%%%)%
!> ; !, )%
cH
Y,#)%#
)
+ "

G%%%1Gc
# ! ' 3, !
- ,@

?

")
(0) =) , - the
earlier filing of petition to cancel the mark with the Bureau of Legal Affairs shall not
constitute a prejudicial question that must be resolved before an action to enforce the
rights to same registered mark may be decided.
5! ,! ,

c H
c " - D

G%%% - , ,@

,

-H)%6 )
% ;

&).92!

,! - ,

,, G,

) # ! - H* ;

- -
!
*
"!
*6 -

!, - )
, ! - H

-

*
)
C! , G%%% @
) % , G%%% "
, -
H ,? !
cH
") ' ! ,
c
H

-H
;, #<<)
C
,? YY
Y 0

Y!

G

? - )
! G%%% 1
G c
# ! ' 3

" , )
5-! ;
% !

- - H!
- *
-

cH)
c

Page 50
Ê
% ,

-

!- < )+
;
%
-
- "

c
-H! G
,)%G
, ;
% ! ,
)
? ) -!#? -
;% )
%- ? !%

, G

! -
,?"

-H)

40. [G.R. No. 114802. June 21, 2001.]
DEVELOPERS GROUP OF COMPANIES, INC., petitioner, vs. THE COURT OF APPEALS,
HON. IGNACIO S. SAPALO, in his capacity as Director, Bureau of Patents, Trademarks
and Technology Transfer, and SHANGRI-LA INTERNATIONAL HOTEL MANAGEMENT,
LTD., respondents.
C
' K ! 988!

c 5 >
! c)! 1
-
c H3! 1G%%%3 !

c " - D

-H ! )!
%

,
*, )
%
c H

, ,?
"
4 ,
"

, >9< ,

9:=!
, -H 98 )
c " !

cH G%%%

,?"
)
% - H ! "
&).= 9)
# 1.3 ! # =! 99! - H
;
% F7 ! G 99!

cH)
'K 8!99 !

cH-

-
,
G%%%)% , ; K <!99 )
c

Page 51
Ê

! "

G%%%1Gc
# ! ' 3, !-
,@

?

")
;

(0) &

- ! -

- ? ?

" " 6 ?

" , #)%

"
6

? - ,@
")On the other hand, the earlier filing of petition to cancel the mark
with the Bureau of Legal Affairs shall not constitute a prejudicial question that
must be resolved before an action to enforce the rights to same registered mark
may be decided.
C! ,G%%% @
) % , G%%% "
,
-H ,? !
cH
") ' ! ,

c H

- H
;, #<<)
41. G.R. No. 139300. March 14, 2001.]

AMIGO MANUFACTURING, Inc., petitioner, vs. CLUETT PEABODY CO., INC., respondent.
PANGANIBAN, J.:

; , )! ) 1 & (" 3

#
>
) 1 3
")
; 6 -
"- !
*"3H'c%'04,30I 0! "

"430I 0!

"
,

?"
43c &0& P0)
'!N *O"- *H'c%'!c 706
+* * * *," ,* ,"

"*
! ,*#
>
)!>
!
>> !> *)
% G -
#
>
! ) %
- 6

,")
"
-
,
! , - ) % G
,"
c

Page 52
Ê

!,@
--

- )
6 - "*H'c
%'**H'c%'0* , *
"!
"
) N O* " ,

", NO)
Issues:
13 + * "
* "B
1 3 *"
*"B
1.3 - ,B

ÊÊ

"0.+Y:6YYY +
",$; "- @
* )

G!
G

"
- 3><!9=2!H%4,3C, !9= !;
" >

H4 3 K .! 9. ! H % ; 4 3
C, 8!9= !c 7)
%
,- " -
- ! - ! *
"! - )
>-!- ;
@ )&
- )@ !
* " - ) !
* H%- 9=8)
C!
"
)
8Y 8Y Y /!

- ")

÷ 0.1Y6YY
"#$Ê
!
" H % H %
" ) -

!

6 -)
%
)%! ,

, *H% *
H%)# ! !, -! )
%G!-! -

)%

[ Y Y Y Y{

Y Y Y YY
YY

,
Y : 1Y

[
Y Y

Y Y
'Y Y
Y

Y &;8+ 6, < +2=02& Y Y &;8+ 62& 6
YY YY
Y YY YY Y
YY &;8+62&Y &;8+6,&

c

Page 53
Ê
Y
Y 4>Y?
Y YY &Y Y
&;8+ 6,& YY
Y
& &803230@2+& Y
Y["(

%G
,!,!

! *
") ',- !
, , *"
)
! %5 %
, 6 , * H % * H %) #
*" " "
, " -
4 !
H%! "

!H%
7)
#6 @

"
,","
"

) !,
)G
*
" 7
,)c !, H%H%)>-!
,

, )
(0.6,Y
"*$ Ê #
- ) #

" !

" ,
@

)
# !
"
!
@ , )% 7!
=# ;, # << @ ,

) "
! 6
!
)
, )
%! , / -
> ! 88.! " - !
/ ,); /

H%")5!
- )#
, "!
-
"!:

- .: ;, # <<!
%"c )

42. G.R. No. 118192. October 23, 1997.]
PRO LINE SPORTS CENTER, INC., and QUESTOR CORPORATION, petitioners, vs.
COURT OF APPEALS, UNIVERSAL ATHLETICS INDUSTRIAL PRODUCTS, INC., and
MONICO SEHWANI, respondents.
C
6 - ,
! F!
/, , " M
L) %

/ -!

c

Page 54
Ê

" M
,L) G - - ! / -A

7 " M
,L
) -
/ -) % -
,F @

-
"M
L)% -

)%# A )/ -!

F
, , #)

# F ,
/ -

B

5
F , ?
,

)
/ -

,
,,) -,-,

)
+ ! ! 7

F!6 ?
"

" @ )

43. G.R. No. 123248. October 16, 1997.]
TWIN ACE HOLDINGS CORPORATION, petitioner, vs. COURT OF APPEALS and
LORENZANA FOOD CORPORATION, respondents.
, -Y.
%+ & #0 - Ê -

1.8!3,.=)!.:=!:=)
, ,
, c';0&P#&# - 6 ! -
;# &) < .)Ê Ê % ,
,

6
)

{
-Y.
c';0&P#&#-
;#&)< .
, -", %+ &#0, ,-

) G!
Y %+ & #0* -!

c';0&P#&# ,
Y -
6 , ) <Ê , YYY =Y
2
!0 ))
Y)

0.
+
? c7
,% #

9.
+ )%@
@
!
! , " , ;# &) < . ,
YYY =Y 2
0 ) )
Y) aÊ ! @

-
@!

!
, , ! ! - ,-

c

Page 55
Ê
, ;# &) < .! ) @ YYY =Y
2
! )?
.=) ,c%U! )!
" c %U! ) H , >
@
)
G

!
- , @
6
)< 6
Y
Y
Y Y [[ [Y [ [

Y[ Y Y Y
)

44. G.R. Nos. L-27425 & L-30505. April 28, 1980.]
CONVERSE RUBBER CORPORATION and EDWARDSON MANUFACTURING
CORPORATION, plaintiffs-appellants, vs. JACINTO RUBBER & PLASTICS CO., INC., and
ACE RUBBER & PLASTICS CORPORATION, defendants-appellants.
A
,
H
" % !
" % ,

, !
,

,

"% )%

,!,
,!
)

;A
13

,
, " % !
, , ,
,
" ! ! )
-
,
K ;,,*
" , ,

-
;,,*""% ! - )
,

9< )

/0
+50%50; 0C0&#% H/ c%( 'C /&C# ; '>0% % '& +50& 0C0&#&%
K# &%';/GG0;Ec#% ')! &)!>#&/C#%/;0#&'c;/GG0;'c0
#&I#5'0/&0; %;0H %0;0%;#0>#;$/%'>G/ c%L

50c
C 6 !+ , !,
! -;,,
!", 0>
!6
- ,! ) +
-

!!"!,!
6 )))13 ! ,

, "% )% -
,
) 0- ?
!
! ! -
- -
, -! !
c

Page 56
Ê
!, ,"% )K
- ! , ,)
45. G.R. No. L-26676. July 30, 1982.]

PHILIPPINE REFINING CO., INC., petitioner, vs. NG SAM and THE DIRECTOR OF
PATENTS, respondents.
Ê
Ê
Ê + ! &
! !

!,!"

"#> #
"
)
Ê

Ê ÊÊ
%"#> # , ;

) 9 ) 929!
"
'
&).= .=.
!, > .!929) ;
&).= --
,
! ! , "
! 2:
1C
C3 ; ' !

&).=. , -
!

" 123)

&
A )
Ê
{
Ê Ê
' &-, =! 9<! &
! 7
!

"
#> # !! " 2:)#

", C, !9=9)
Ê
Ê
{/Ê%"

- " ,
) !, -
" "
- !

)
% #> #,

"
, ,, 1 3)
%"#> # ,

!,!"

! , -
!
" ) ;
!)+
2:1C
C3! - -

)0 ,
-- ,

)
%,- )%

,, "

) 5 -

c

Page 57
Ê
)'
6 ,
)! -!

! 6 ! " "! 6 " , )
G !, " *
, ) % , , !
, #>* 5#> #& G#'& C#%';( ,

,"
!
)
!

, - -
, !

*
)#,
! - , )

46. G.R. No. L-29971. August 31, 1982.]
ESSO STANDARD EASTERN, INC., petitioner, vs. THE HONORABLE COURT OF
APPEALS ** and UNITED CIGARETTE CORPORATION, respondents.
C#%
A
%
,

"0'@ ,

6 ,
, " " 0' @ -

@ ) , -
"0'
,
-

, @
-
)
;A
! "0'

! ,

*");
,"
! ,",,

" *)

/0
+50%50;%50;0+#%;#0>#;$ &C; &H0>0&%

50c

"0'!
! !
!
) G
"
6

, ,! ! -
")
, !
,-
, * ?
) %

" " "
*
) %
"
- ",
" )
c

Page 58
Ê
47. G.R. Nos. 63796-97. May 21, 1984.]

LA CHEMISE LACOSTE, S. A., petitioner, vs. HON. OSCAR C. FERNANDEZ, Presiding
Judge of Branch XLIX, Regional Trial Court, National Capital Judicial Region, Manila and
GOBINDRAM HEMANDAS, respondents.
Ê c c C "
Mc!LM c!LM - L "

McL D
!

," 1, , ;3
9<2) 9:=9::!5F))

" M c F - L,
;
) 98! c c #
M - L
McL)HH1H, 5!
5F))3

Mc)L 98.! c c &G

, 5 @

A ) # , ) I

76 )5 @
!
)%!

,)c c )
Ê+'&"M cF - L
,)

c c
,"-,9<2!5, "McL

;
"
);
;
,
-

;
) , ,
-
"
)c c
"!, - &-,98>> %
-
! -
"!
Mc)L
48. G.R. No. L-32747. November 29, 1984.]

FRUIT OF THE LOOM, INC., petitioner, vs. COURT OF APPEALS and GENERAL
GARMENTS CORPORATION, respondents.

C

!
7 6
;
!/ # !
"!C;/ %'C%50c''>)%
- , ;
A! A A
! A 2
' A
)

-! !
"C;/ %C';0I0
' ;
&)<!K
!9<.-

A "A ?)
' .! 9<=! , !

"
- )

- A " C;/ % C'; 0I0

"C;/ %'C%50c''>A 6
c

Page 59
Ê
)C!

-A

,
,

)
# ! ?
, - ) % #
-?
)

+'&
)

5
"C;/ %'C%50c''>C;/ %C';0I0! C;/ %)
+
,
"! ,
-" ! ")
, !C;/ %
'C%50c''> C;/ %C';0I0)+

, " C;/ % -

" ,

!C;/ % -)
#
!

!

" ,

-

)+ ,

)+"C;/ %'C%50c''>
C;/ %C';0I0, - )
% ,
-
! !

,,,- ," @ )
C!, -, A- "

!
-A

)

49. G.R. No. L-27906. January 8, 1987.]
CONVERSE RUBBER CORPORATION, petitioner, vs. UNIVERSAL RUBBER PRODUCTS,
INC. and TIBURCIO S. EVALLE, DIRECTOR OF PATENTS,
{!Ê3Ê
/ - ;,, ! )

" M/& I0;#c '&I0;0 #& 0I 0L ,,
,, )
0% % '&0;A'&%0&% '&
-;,,

13"
,

M'&I0;0L
A M'&I0;0 ;/GG0; ';';#% '&L
" - ,6
, " , , , , 4 ! 1,3

A "
, ? ,

8!;#<<!)
;0'&0&%A'&%0&% '&
c

Page 60
Ê
O% * '&I0;0;/GG0;';';#% '&,
6 K .!92<4
7>!/#

, .9 )!>! > 6!>4
O ,
,
4!
.O ,,"5/$%#(c';

#cc%#;#&0I 0)
% 0- - ;,,
-
/ -;,,A )>; )
/0 +50%50; '; &'% %50 ;0'&0&%* #;% #c #;'; #% '& 'C
0% % '&0;* ';';#%0 &#>0 'C /5 5#;#%0; %5#% % #c/c#%0
%' 00 I0 '; '&C/0 %50 /Gc %' %50 &K/;( 'C %50 0% % '&0; %'
+5 5%50&#>0G0c'&H)
50c (0) %

, " M/& I0;#c '&I0;0
#& 0I 0L - ;,,A D " M5/$
%#(c';LM#cc%#;0I 0L
, ?
-;,,)%"M/& I0;#c'&I0;00I 0L
,, ) ! "
-;,, M'&I0;05/$%#(c';L ,
,,)
% -

"

M
"
, " " "
,
, ) , ! !
, , , "
, "
, )L 0- ?
!
! !-
-N O -
, -)L
# "

) # ,
)
C M'&I0;0;/GG0;';';#% '&!A
- M'&I0;0L -;,,

, ) / - ;,, -
;,,A 6 92<
7

,, ) % , "

, -,
"
@ ) $
! ! M'&I0;0L ,
,
,
- ;,,! - ;,,A !
/ -;,,

,
, -;,,)
c

Page 61
Ê
50. G.R. No. 75067. February 26, 1988.] YEN

PUMA SPORTSCHUHFABRIKEN RUDOLF DASSLER, K.G., petitioner, vs. THE
INTERMEDIATE APPELLATE COURT and MIL-ORO MANUFACTURING CORPORATION,
respondents.
51. G.R. No. 78298. January 30, 1989.]

WOLVERINE WORLDWIDE, INC., petitioner, vs. HONORABLE COURT OF APPEALS AND
LOLITO P. CRUZ, respondents.
Ê'C, 8!982! !

76

/ ! ,
, '
;
"5/5/ 0'H0I 0
-!C 7)
!
! !

""5/5/ 00I 0

/ , -
!
, - !
!, !!,
-
A " 1 ,
- 3
!
- )
,@ ! --

? !-
9:.! , !
! -- " 5/5
/ 00I 0!, ' )%
- -A )%#
)
@ ! )'!
# A ! -!
- -)

Ê ,, ? B

Ê () % ?
, , ,@
!
@ 13 , ?
41 3
? -,? 41.3 ,?

4123, ,! !,?!
)
A !?
- --
A
"

, 6)%):;, #
<<!"%"c!
"
- A

", , , @ ? )
# ?
!
- ? !
,
,
, )
,! #
!
9:.! - ) @ !
# ! -
,
!

?

-
c

Page 62
Ê
A ,

A !, )
,!
! ?

- ,) + 6
! !
",
)
/, ! ! !
? ! !- ,, #, )

52. G.R. No. 78325. January 25, 1990.]
DEL MONTE CORPORATION and PHILIPPINE PACKING CORPORATION, petitioners, vs.
COURT OF APPEALS and SUNSHINE SAUCE MANUFACTURING INDUSTRIES,
respondents.
CRUZ, J.
Ê Ê "

1 "3

7 ) ' # ! 9<9! >

7/

,
!
"
! ,
-
!
!>"
)
'', :!9<=!> 7 "

'
> ,
!
%"
;
&);9., ' ;
)'
&-, !9: !>,
"0c
>'&%0
)
; >

;

, G % # :!98!

! "
!
, - " ! ,
C )Ê%

;
, ! 98.)%
- " ,!
> ,! -
,
?"
)
5-
- -
6 -
,

>*! "

)%!
,
! ">

-
"
!
? )
!

>,

, >
,
,
)
# ! ;

% >" )
, ,
" 4

*,4 ,
, ?" )C!
, * , !

" )%# )
c

Page 63
Ê
+"

Ê ) +

7 ,
> !

) - ,
- )
%@

,, , ,
,
,

! "

)#,- ",

! " ) , -!
,," ! )%?
,

,"
,
)
#!- , 7

,
, > ") %
> ,

! ) % ,
, D ) #

!
-6 )
#- !

" ,
" ,
!

,

)+ ,
"
!, , !
! ,
)+
! ! ,6 !
, >
,! - ,
, -)
# ! - ! - ,

> ! & , ;
, ,! * , "
")% -*,
7 *

>)
# *,

>*"!@
- *
,

@ , ")+
>* ,!
4!, ? ÊÊ
Ê/Ê&#4 )Ê Ê Ê"$Ê
, -Y.
5-
- -
6 -

,

>*! "

) %!
,
!
" >
-

c

Page 64
Ê
" !

? )

{
-Y.

>,

, >
,
,
)

0.
+
" 6

9.
A21#!- , 7

, , > ") %
> ,

! ) %
,, D )#

!
-6 )
# *,
>*"!@
- *

,
@ ,")+
>*,!
4 ! , ?
,)

53. G.R. No. 75420. November 15, 1991.]
KABUSHI KAISHA ISETAN, also known and trading as ISETAN CO., LTD., petitioner, vs.
THE INTERMEDIATE APPELLATE COURT, THE DIRECTOR OF PATENTS, and ISETANN
DEPARTMENT STORE, INC. respondents.
0Ê Ê
$, $ " (
c-

)
%
" &-,=!9.<)
" , "
$! %" , % "
%? $
C )
%" (
c-

K-

.2
)'',.!98.!

(
c-
'
&)= 2 = 2 . - !

*
V -! !
K
K 9:9)
V% 6%!

7
, 7

G
, ,
)
V
! ) C

' ;);
)&)2:2:2! - !
G % ;
&). )

c

Page 65
Ê
V'&-, 8!98! )' 1 3
K-
%" =!;
&);
2::
;2:) % 06
103

" 0%#&

! ) - , 0

, # "

+,
"M L

;

V# %"c
@ @ - "
)
V# "
-6 -
)

)# )' "- ! !
-

4,
-6 -
)C"
)
V% - , )
- " )
, ,
)/!

")
V#
! !"

"
-)
V ! ) -
)
V% 7 ,
)
V%
C ! ,
")
V %

"
- 6 -
V !

% ! ! ,

""")
5-! % - 6 ,
" ,
"

W", ""4,?
,
"!

4W",
"
!W
,")

54. G.R. No. 71189. November 4, 1992.]
FABERGE, INCORPORATED, petitioner, vs. THE INTERMEDIATE APPELLATE COURT
and CO BENG KAY, respondents.
MELO, J.:
c

Page 66
Ê
"
*G;/%

" G;/% .. 0I 0 !
! -! -D ! ! !
G
$ +,
H>

,G;/%0, )' ,
, , ? , - )
+
- ! K H
"
""G;/%!G;/%..G;/%0"
, - 4
,, - - "
,
,

,
")
c! * > ; -
,
, , - *

211 1Y Y 2Y 0 ))
Y!

",,

)

"G;/%..
0I 0 , 6 6 " G;/%

! - ,? *

, " ")
' ! -

*
,
,-
-- " Y
Y
YY - ,

G;/%0, G;/%- ! ")
>-! - , ,

- - "
*
- " ,
)

- " G;/%0
, , , -

,G;/%G;/%..
Ê
() Y

' - -
1#)= != != 3'Y';, #&)<<1) ! #!2!213! 3!
! / %"#92<)
5-
- , ! - ,

" G;/%0 , ,

*-
"

- !-
!! )
- , !

! ,

- - * 6 - ) % , !

6 G @
6 "G;/%
)0-! ,
-6 -
- ,
, %"c)
!
%"c
- , !
,
6 -
,

c

Page 67
Ê
!,? )'
"
-
", )
K KGc; 213;, #&)<<!!
@ - "
-
,

"
) (! @
! -%"c6
,

- ,
)
5+ , 213
, K KGc ; 1Y) Y B
213@
, ,

, 6 -

)G,
,
-
- -
6 )) ,

! ! - ,
, )
%

,,
6 ! " ,

* G;/%0 , , " ,
G;/%
-

- )

+ Y 1BY
Y Y9C

@ !

77
!
-
- , !"
, 6
, ,
) '
,6-

%"c
-
,

)
G

,
!
+
! '

- , 213 @ , ,?

-
,)
55. G.R. No. 103543. July 5, 1993.]

ASIA BREWERY, INC. petitioner, vs. THE HON. COURT OF APPEALS and SAN MIGUEL

' , =! 988! >
13
1#G 3

" A G00; &# G00;
,
>A #& > H/0c #c0 c0&A ,
") > M L G00; c0& ! M
#& > H/0c
#c0 c0& , , , . ) ! , ,

,)
c

Page 68
Ê
'#
:!99!;% )>#
A ) / , #G !
!#G , ;2=;)
#G A G00; #c0 c0& , M
L
#& > H/0c
#c0 c0&B
;

&)
'
"!- "

7 , ) , @

" , , ) 7!
! -! -)
"
! " !
"
) 4

,

)
% #G A "

>A " #& > H/0c #c0 c0&! M L

- 1ML3! , 1M L3!
, ,

-
7-" ,
>
)M L M

-L)

# , - !
! !@ !, "
6 , -@

- ! -
,

!
6 - 6 ! - ! @ !

!

!

,
)
% 6
-, )#
, !
6 - -
! , -
,
! , -
-
) -!, ! ,

,6 - )N= #K)=2
=2.O)
% G00; #c0 c0&! # G !
-, ,,!,",!
, ! - >A
#G
G00;#c0 c0&>A) - - ,
, ! , - A @ " -

",G00;#c0 c0&#&> H/0c#c0 c0&)

56. G.R. No. 91332. July 16, 1993.]
PHILIP MORRIS, INC., BENSON & HEDGES (CANADA), INC., AND FABRIQUES OF
TABAC REUNIES, S.A., petitioners, vs. THE COURT OF APPEALS AND FORTUNE
TOBACCO CORPORATION, respondents.
, -Y.
> ! )! G 5
13! )! C, @
%,; !)#)! ,
6

c

Page 69
Ê
, <!;=8;- ;#
?
C %, !
- !

>#;$

")
G"
* - , >#;$ I ! >#;$ %0&!
c#;$!
! ,
7 !

,

)

{
-Y.
C %, *

' ,? - ?
) -
, 7 , G
;-
,
" >#;$!
>#;$ ,6 - )

0.
+
> @

? , #

9.
&') ? -!
,

,

) - ,-

, - K C * ,-
- - ,

"
- ! !
, , "

>"
)
! ,
-

" , ,? , ? !

) )
57. G.R. No. 91385. January 4, 1994.]

HEIRS OF CRISANTA Y. GABRIEL-ALMORADIE, herein represented by the special
administrator LORENZO B. ALMORADIE of the Intestate Estate of the Late Crisanta Y.
Gabriel-Almoradie and LORENZO B. ALMORADIE, petitioners, vs. COURT OF APPEALS
and EMILIA M. SUMERA, herein sued in her capacity as special administratrix of the
Testate Estate of the late DR. JOSE R. PEREZ, respondents.
C#%
A
7 / ?
! #
8!
9<!" - &) 2 !
H, ) !7

H, ! ? - ,
!

,
+'&0;! ',.!9<H,

"+'&0; )
;A
'',9!9< !H, ! &) 8!
;
&);.89-
"+'&0;,
)7)H, 6 - "+'&0; -
, -
7)
c

Page 70
Ê

H, -)7!!
,
"+'&0;, H
5 ,@
*4 &)
2.! &-, <! 982 --
- * " -
&)82: )
/0
+ H, -)7!!,
50c
, 6 ?

,-,

)
- -

-
, ,
) &
,-
-
#
)+
- -
,, ?
, ,- , ) >-!
- ! -

-
?
58. G.R. No. 115115. July 18, 1995.]

CONRAD AND COMPANY, INC., petitioner, vs. HON. COURT OF APPEALS, FITRITE INC.,
and VICTORIA BISCUITS CO., INC., respondents.
A {ÊÊ !Ê !Ê -"!

!
Y! ? )

"? )
{ÊÊ !Ê -
,
, , G /#
-

1 4 Y
Y & Y D
4,666% , * "
/&5 &0G / %
,
/ ,

! )! ,
, D
D

G ! )
! -"
+
;

Y )
Y1 9
;#:=3! C * ;

&);< :&)2:=9 ;
;
!
- ! G ! )!/ # 989
991" &)..9:.:.93 G%%%,
-* 6 -
"
)
;A C %; %0! &)I %'; #G / %')! &)N -
O!, !

,
!

,
, " ,
"/&5 &0 )
c

Page 71
Ê
'&;##&'>#&(N O

,

!
,
, " )
# 98 !C %; %0 G!%"%

%1G%%%3
"/&5 &0!
, ;
!,, " )C %; %0*
" 1
Y{-, G%%%)!

C %; %0
"/&5 &0#&0I 0c#G0c!

,
I %'; #G / %)% K99!

- 6> .!99, '&;#* >
06 -#
, ;' !
-'&;#
,
!
,
, " ! ,

" )#
'&;#-,,

! , !# 8!988
'&;#
6 -
G ! ) "4
# - , 13

?
, -

- *
" , * G ! %"
%
%1G%%%34
5&)+ - Y Y

"

:Ê;, #&)<<!!
"%>"c!6 -
7G%%%1)9!%
>"c3! !-!
!
?
! 6 @ ,
? )
- ;

&)2:=91 ;
3
@ ") 8 /Y Y) Y YY=2;#: .! -
+
Y )
Y8;#2!-

;

- -

*
6 - ")

-,
)Ê # -

) ! G%%%
-
"
-

-
6 ? )%
! - ! "

!! !

,G%%%)
59. G.R. No. 100098. December 29, 1995.]

EMERALD GARMENT MANUFACTURING CORPORATION, petitioner, vs. HON. COURT
OF APPEALS, BUREAU OF PATENTS, TRADEMARKS AND TECHNOLOGY TRANSFER
and H.D. LEE COMPANY, INC., respondents.
Ê
Ê
Ê
c

Page 72
Ê
%%
Ê Ê
5))c)! )!

7!/))#)!
G!%"E%
%1G%%%3
;
&);==21;
3"
%(c % >;) c00 " ! ?! ,! "! , ! ?"! ?

!!!
=! :',98
0 H >
!

76
)
% -").:;)#)&)<<1%"c3#)I
- ! - *
" , "!*c00*-

!,!, " !
*
! ! "

,

)Ê
Ê
Ê
%
Ê )Ê
0H " ",
-

-
)Ê
0H
,
"%(c % >;)
c00 > 9:=! ! 8,985))c)
0A
")Ê
Ê
Ê
{/Ê %
, ) % ,

, -
!,

"
-

-

-!

,)Ê,
)& @ , ),
! ! ! !
!
!

" "
- ! , - - "

)Ê

, 6 ! ? - "
Q % 5 %)
# ! -

"

)
"
! " !
")
4

,

)
' ! "
@ ,

)

"
! )
%" -,

c

Page 73
Ê
,
) %

,- ,

, ,

)Ê
Ê Ê % Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê ' Ê Ê 1 Ê Ê Ê Ê

% Ê Ê %Ê Ê !Ê ) Ê Ê Ê 1Ê ' ' Ê Ê Ê ) Ê
Ê Ê Ê 0Ê 5 Ê {Ê 5Ê Ê Ê % Ê Ê Ê ' Ê
0Ê55Ê 1Ê
*" %(c % >;)c00)#

,c00
! " , ) %
,", ! ,,

- ,, )
! -- ,! !- " ?)%
" ! )
>
? 6 -)#
!, ,

- )
!! " )
! " ,! -

C
, ? , ,) 5
""
?,! !c- !H!+
-
# )5 !!"
,
, )
!

! ,
-
) - !
,
,

--)
Ê) Ê' Ê ' Ê Ê Ê Ê%Ê % Ê Ê( ) Ê 1ÊÊ
' Ê (Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê %Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê
' !Ê1 Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê%!Ê) Ê ÊÊ Ê Ê
Ê Ê 1Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê %% Ê Ê Ê 1 Ê Ê Ê Ê
% Ê ÊÊ % Ê
# -

" -- -
"
,)c00 ) -!!
@ 6 - -
) ,
, 7"

)C ,!!!

)%! +
!

? +
,6 -
)Ê

!
* -
- c00"
,

G%%% ! @
- ")
c

Page 74
Ê
# @ @
-" %"c1;)#)&)<<3)
C " @ " 0
HA " ,
,
"!5))c*
)
60. [G.R. No. L-24075. January 31, 1974.]

CRISANTA Y. GABRIEL, petitioner, vs. DR. JOSE R. PEREZ and HONORABLE TIBURCIO
EVALLE as Director of Patents, respondents.
{
Ê ÊÊ
# ;
&);.89 ) "+'&0;
, - ,
, 1> 3
=) -)7!
! >
!9=. "#
!9=.
" ,

Ê Ê
%

"

4", ,

4

,
4 ,

" >!9=9!

7

)
%
6 - , 6 , ,
- 6 - "+'&0;)
;

Ê2ÊÊ ÊÊ Ê% Ê) Ê%Ê Ê 1Ê62{ Ê
Ê Ê % ;
) 7
G ! , ! ! ;) #
!

)K;)7)%
-
! , - ,

-

- !
! ,)/ #%"c!;, #&)
<<!!

" , ,
,
"!- "!

")
%
6 - ,"

! ,

"
' ) !

-

")
,
61. G.R. No. L-14377. December 29, 1960.]

THE EAST PACIFIC MERCHANDISING CORPORATION, petitioner, vs. THE DIRECTOR OF
PATENTS and LUIS P. PELLICER, respondents.

c

Page 75
Ê
C'K2!92:!>%) '

#<<<"MI,L
)%
"
, , #
=! 92: !
! !, ! ")c!

" ! "
' &-,8!9=:)% - A
, H7)c )
,

,
" )
! ,,
"McI,L!
"! -!
- ;

&)=8=)
M-,L
,"
5 &! @ "
-
- ! c
- -
1
- ,

3! , " ) % 6
MI,L ,
-

1I,3! !
,
!-" 6-,!
4!
!
,
6 )
%
-

!
- ,! "
,")%
! ,
!, -4

, @ MI,L
! ,
" , @

, )
,

! " M-,L!
, , ) %

A )

62. G.R. No. L-19297. December 22, 1966.]
MARVEX COMMERCIAL CO. INC., petitioner, vs. PETRA HAWPIA & CO., and THE
DIRECTOR OF PATENTS, respondents.
{!ÊJ.:
5 E)!

7

, =2. >) 1G - 3! > 1
3!',2!9=8
"c '&#
! ' !

K9!9=8)
0% % '&0;A'&%0&% '&
'
!

"-

"#c'&# !

;
=28<! ,
c

Page 76
Ê
, 9! 9=<! , "
,
)
;0'&0&%A'&%0&% '&
%

- !

! "!
" ,
," )
>; )% )
/0 %50 %;#0>#;$ c '&# '&C/ &Hc( > c#; %' %50 %;#0>#;$
#c'&#B
50c (0) - " #c'&# c '&#

)
G- 6!#!

, - ) ! ,
-!

, 10 -)
! c <.=! > .! 9<<3 , ,? " ,
, )
%#c'&#
c '&#4 )G
!!
)#

- - !
1
%
-) ! 9= )
& ! % c /
%"! 2 )! -) ! ) <:8<:93) % 7 ,
-
-
1'! )-) !
Y3)
,! #c'&# c '&#! "! - ")

"

- 1
# -)0) )!=2C) )2<!283
%
c '&#,
-)
&G & ,
" c '&# , ,
D
, -!

1'! )-) !
Y3
63. G.R. No. L-23023. August 31, 1968.] YEN

JOSE P. STA. ANA, petitioner, vs. FLORENTINO MALIWAT and TIBURCIO S. EVALLE, in
his capacity as Director of Patents, respondents.
64. G.R. No. L-26557. February 18, 1970.]

c

Page 77
Ê
AMERICAN WIRE & CABLE COMPANY, petitioner, vs. DIRECTOR OF PATENTS and
CENTRAL BANAHAW INDUSTRIES, respondents.
'K9< !G ! )

" (&#Cc0J - ,
! ! "
,
> 9! 9< ) %
# + , )! )! 7
# ! 9=8
" /;#Cc0J H, !
!! ! !

A"(&#Cc0J )
#
!
A"
(&#Cc0J , -
" /;#Cc;0J)
@ ! G
(&#Cc0J
- , # + E , )
% )

Ê+"(&#Cc0J-
,,
)

() % ,
"!
/;#Cc0J(&#Cc0J! )&
!, 6

) , " - 6 ,
4, ,6 !! 74

7
7

" 4 ," , ,6
,"
!
M';
L
C L! 6

- )
65. G.R. No. L-29155. May 13, 1970.]

UNIVERSAL FOOD CORPORATION, petitioners, vs. THE COURT OF APPEALS,
MAGDALO V. FRANCISCO, SR., and VICTORIANO V. FRANCISCO, respondents.
CASTRO, J.
à Ê / !Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê 7Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê

ÊÊ
Ê # ," 9.8! >

I) C ! ) - -

13 -,
">#C;#&4
92 !
"
- G4" 6
, ! 9<! % %); !

! / - C
-
6 > !9<5 Ê%Ê 5
, ! >

I) C ! )
.) ! I I) C
=))
c

Page 78
Ê
! >
I) C ! )!

, ! - ! - !
H>
% %); !!,
" )
5-! 6

- -
, " ,
!,-@
)'K <!9<! H>
% %);
@
, ,-
*>*!, @ , ) !% %);
@)
! , - G #

! >
I) C
, ,

>)
/02 Ê(Ê' Ê%Ê Ê Ê%Ê Ê Ê%Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê

8Ê !Ê Ê Ê Ê % Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê % Ê %Ê
% Ê )
50c&') - G #

*
!>
I)C !)
>)%!

[Y Y Y Y

Y
Y YY YY Y Y { 3 1 :2 ,Y
1 ,Y[Y Y
YYY
YY [Y Y Y Y
YY YBY C YY, {6A692,YYY
Y Y { 3 YY Y YY
Y[
5-! -

Ê*Ê Y Y
>)% !Ê+Ê
)
! G #

Y
%+'1 R30;0&%/> 7
, D >!)% !
!
- )
1 ! - >- 7
! -
=13G ,
))) !
, !
- @ ,
) -
=13
-6 ,- -,
- "

6 )
c

Page 79
Ê
6 ! >
! , ! - - ,
-
- )Ê
6!

G !
- "!
- "
-)
!

. *
, - G #
1
3) % - , @ -
.
*)5! @ , )Ê
!

>
, )
Y! , - -
,
!Ê ,6

! !
>)
%

#Ê
, >
I) C ! ) -
) "
!G #

- ) + , ! !
,- ,
,
>)
66. G.R. No. L-28744. April 29, 1971.]

ACOJE MINING CO., INC., petitioner-applicant, vs. THE DlRECTOR OF PATENTS,
respondent.
C
#?>

-
! !
" c'%/! ,
6
-
;
! , ! ,
"
! !,"

) % ? ,

" c'%/
'
;
&) 2:< - ;
')! )!
)
, * , "
",
, B
;
&) ,
7
,
)% @ , , )
"! " ?,"
c

Page 80
Ê
c'%/) 0- " ! , )
>-!
,

!
! *",

;
,

! 7
* ") +
"
-,,

- ,
, ! ,

- )

)Ê

LIP Digest Compiled PDF

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

LIP Digest Compiled PDF

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

c 

3. [G.R. No. 76193. November 9, 1989.]

%     )

  5#;c 0G;'+&      -, 

 ,         "  

%        @     

%       @     

%       

%            

5. G.R. No. 131522. July 19, 1999.]

 A      ! 

;        

+, -   ;,*   

+   Y

5!     

 GK ! )1GK 3  D

  Ê+    %I ,,?  

9. [G.R. No. L-75697. June 18, 1987.]

0% % '&0;Ac# >

' C, 9! 9=2!  c    - 

   ,  =   c! -   

 =)#  -   ,)Q#    

      ,       ><! 9=.   

;       &) =2Q&-, 9!9=<! 

50c&')   -    ,     , )

 Y       Y "!"#$( 

 Y C! ,     

%   - ! 

+         6 

&')%  ,         

14. G.R. No. 126627. August 14, 2003.]

15. [G.R. No. 113407. July 12, 2000.]

  '   !    G  !%"

 - @  ); K

       ?   -   

/0 3 +    ?

           

%  -- 

17. G.R. No. 118708. February 2, 1998.]

)2 )Y     )Q#   !  

 ! 6 -

18. G.R. No. 113388. September 5, 1997.]

19. G.R. No. 121867. July 24, 1997.]

   !  ,    

     

&     -  -"  

20. [G.R. No. 115106. March 15, 1996.]

22. G.R. No. 120900. July 20, 2000.]

23. G.R. No. L-28499. September 30, 1977.]

%  ! I    >  

0% % '&0;A'&%0&% '&

%     "I    

     

; -    

% @       - 

%       * " 

/0+50%50;';&'%%50 ;0%';'C#%0&%0;;0 &';0; &H&'%%'

50c&')%      

  I I    , 

24. G.R. No. L-23954. April 29, 1977.]

26. G.R. No. 10738. January 14, 1916.]

 Ê%   -  

+    ,  

c

% )

5#;c 0G;'+& -,

, "

% @

% @

%

%

A !

;

+, -;,*

+ Y

5!

GK ! )1GK 3 D

Ê+ %I ,,?

0% % '&0;Ac# >

' C, 9! 9=2! c -

, =c! -

=)# - ,)Q#

, ><! 9=.

; &) =2Q&-, 9!9=<!

50c&') - , ,)

Y Y "!"#$(

Y C!,

% - !

+ 6

&')% ,

' ! G!%"

-@);K

? -

/0 3 + ?

% --

)2 )Y )Q# !

!6 -

! ,

& - -"

% ! I >

0% % '&0;A'&%0&% '&

% "I

;-

% @ -

% * "

/0+50%50;';&'%%50 ;0%';'C#%0&%0;;0 &';0; &H&'%%'

50c&')%

I I ,

Ê% -

+ ,

"

Ê %Ê Ê Ê % Ê %Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê %%0Ê Ê Ê !Ê

,! C 6

H! "

) " !

% , % M#

Y - Y.

3 &')%+

) Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê Ê %Ê

%"! ,

#*"* -"

% *"* ! ! ,! ,!

%0c0%#! ! , ,

7!

-,! )

0% % '&0;A'&%0&% '&

'

, , "J: ,

;

% ! !

% ?

/0+50%50;';&'%/;5#0;'CJ:0;C/>0!c % $#&&# c'c 5

50c(0)% % "J:

+

c " ! , & !

,

- ,

- " ,

Ê ' K ! 988!

+ "

% ;

Y!

' K ! 988!