Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Themes are the fundamental and often universal ideas explored in a literary work.
The central philosophical conflict of The Brothers Karamazov is the conflict between religious
faith and doubt. The main characters illustrate the different kinds of behavior that these two
positions generate. Faith in the novel refers to the positive, assenting belief in God practiced by
Zosima and Alyosha, which lends itself to an active love of mankind, kindness, forgiveness, and
a devotion to goodness. Doubt refers to the kind of logical skepticism that Ivan Karamazov
practices, which, in pursuing the truth through the logical examination of evidence, lends itself
to the rejection of God, the rejection of conventional notions of morality, a coldness toward
mankind, and a crippling inner despair. Dostoevsky does not present these positions neutrally.
He actively takes the side of faith, and illustrates through innumerable examples how a life of
faith is happier than a life of doubt. Doubt, as we see in Smerdyakov’s murder of Fyodor
Pavlovich and in Ivan’s breakdown, leads only to chaos and unhappiness. But the novel
nevertheless examines the psychology of doubt with great objectivity and rigor. Through the
character of Ivan, in chapters such as “The Grand Inquisitor,” Dostoevsky presents an incisive
case against religion, the Church, and God, suggesting that the choice to embrace religious faith
can only be made at great philosophical risk, and for reasons that defy a fully logical
explanation.
The novel argues forcefully that people have free will, whether they wish to or not. That is,
every individual is free to choose whether to believe or disbelieve in God, whether to accept or
reject morality, and whether to pursue good or evil. The condition of free will may seem to be a
blessing, guaranteeing the spiritual independence of each individual and ensuring that no
outside force can control the individual’s choices with regard to faith. But throughout The
Brothers Karamazov, Dostoevsky portrays free will as a curse, one that particularly plagues
those characters who have chosen to doubt God’s existence. Free will can be seen as a curse
because it places a crippling burden on humanity to voluntarily reject the securities, comforts,
and protections of the world in favor of the uncertainties and hardships of religious belief. Most
people are too weak to make this choice, Ivan argues, and most people are doomed to unhappy
lives that end in eternal damnation. The Grand Inquisitor story in Book V explores Christ’s
biblical rejection of the temptations offered to him by Satan and concludes that Christ was
wrong to have rejected them, since his rejection won free will for humanity, but took away
security. Nevertheless, the condition of free will is finally shown to be a necessary component
of the simple and satisfying faith practiced by Alyosha and Zosima, and the novel’s optimistic
conclusion suggests that perhaps people are not as weak as Ivan believes them to be.