Chapter 08 - Intercompany Indebiedness
CHAPTER 8
INTERCOMPANY INDEBTEDNESS
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS
Q8-1 A gain or loss on bond retirement is reported by the consolidated entity whenever (a)
‘one of the companies purchases its own bonds from a nonaffiiate at an amount other than
book value, or (b) a company within the consolidated entity purchases the bonds of an
affiliate from a nonaffiiate at an amount other than book value.
Q8-2 A constructive retirement occurs when the bonds of a company included in the
consolidated entity are purchased by another company included within the consolidated
entity. Although the debtor still considers the bonds as outstanding, and the investor views
the bonds as an investment, they are constructively retired for consolidation purposes. If
bonds are actually retired, the debtor purchases its own bonds from a nonaffiliate and they
are no longer outstanding.
Q8-3 When bonds sold to an affiliate at par value are not eliminated, bonds payable and
bond investment are misstated in the balance sheet accounts and interest income and
interest expense are misstated in the income statement accounts. There is also a premium
‘or discount account to be eliminated when the bonds are not issued at par value. Unless
interest is paid at year-end, there is likely to be some amount of interest receivable and
interest payable to be eliminated as well.
Q8-4 Both the bond investment and interest income reported by the purchaser will be
improperly included. Interest expense, bonds payable, and any premium or discount
recorded on the books of the debtor also will be improperly included. In addition, the
constructive gain or loss on bond retirement will be omitted if no eliminating entries are
recorded in connection with the purchase.
Q8-5 If the focus is placed on the legal entity, only bonds actually reacquired by the debtor
will be treated as retired. This treatment can lead to incorrect reports for the consolidated
entity in two dimensions. If a company were to repurchase bonds from an affiliate, any
retirement gain or loss reported by the debtor is not a gain or loss to the economic entity and
must be eliminated in preparing consolidated statements. Moreover, although a purchase of
debt of any of the other companies in the consolidated entity will not be recognized as a
retirement by the debtor, when emphasis is placed on the economic entity the purchase must
serve as a basis for recognition of a bond retirement for the consolidated entity.
Q8-6 The difference in treatment is due to the effect of the transactions on the consolidated
entity. In the case of land sold to another affiliate, a gain has been recorded that is not a gain
from the viewpoint of the consolidated entity. Thus, it must be eliminated in the consolidation
process. On the other hand, in a bond repurchase the buyer simply records an investment in
bonds and the debtor makes no special entries because of the purchase by an affiliate.
Neither company records the effect of the transaction on the economic entity. Thus, in the
consolidation process an entry must be made to show the gain on bond retirement that has
‘occurred from the viewpoint of the economic entity.
84Chapter 08 - Intercompany Indebiedness
Q8-7 When there has been a direct sale to an affiliate, the interest income recorded by the
purchaser should equal the interest expense recorded by the seller and the two items should
have no net effect on reported income. The eliminating entries do not change consolidated
net income in this case, but they will result in a more appropriate statement of the relevant
income and expense categories in the consolidated income statement.
Q8-8 Whenever a loss on bond retirement has been reported in a prior period, the affiliate
that purchased the bonds paid more than the book value of the debt shown by the debtor. As
a result, each period the interest income recorded by the buyer will be less than the interest
expense reported by the debtor. When the two income statement accounts are eliminated in
the consolidation process, the effect will be to increase consolidated net income. Because
the full amount of the loss was recognized for consolidated purposes in the year in which the
bonds were purchased by the affliate, the effect of the elimination process in each of the
periods that follow should be to increase consolidated income.
Q8-9 The difference between the carrying value of the debt on the debtor's books and the
carrying value of the investment on the purchaser's books indicates the amount of
lunrecognized gain or loss at the end of the period. To determine the amount of the gain or
loss on retirement at the start of the period, the difference between interest income recorded
by the purchaser on the bond that has been purchased and interest expense recorded by the
‘debtor during the period is added to the difference between carrying values at the end of the
period.
Q8-10 Interest income and interest expense must be eliminated and a loss on bond
retirement established in the elimination process. Consolidated net income will decrease by
the amount of the loss. Because the loss is attributed to the subsidiary, income assigned to
the controlling and noncontrolling interests will decrease in proportion to their share of
common stock held
Q8-11 A constructive gain will be included in the consolidated income statement in this case
and both consolidated net income and income to the controlling interest will increase by the
full amount of the gain.
Q8-12 A direct placement of subsidiary bonds with the parent should have no effect on
consolidated income or on income assigned to the noncontrolling shareholders,
Q8-13 When subsidiary bonds are purchased from a nonaffiiate by the parent and there is a
constructive gain or loss for consolidated purposes, the gain or loss is assigned to the
subsidiary and included in computing income to the noncontrolling shareholders.
Q8-14 Interest income recorded by the subsidiary and interest expense recorded by the
parent should be equal in the direct placement case. When the subsidiary purchases parent
company bonds from a nonaffiiate, interest income and interest expense will not be the
same unless the bonds are purchased from the nonaffliate at an amount equal to the liability
reported by the parent.Chapter 08 - Intercompany Indebiedness
Q8-15 A gain on constructive bond retirement recorded in a prior period means the bonds
were purchased for less than book value and the interest income recorded by the subsidiary
each period will be greater than the interest expense recorded by the parent. Consolidated
net income for the current period will decrease by the difference between interest income
and interest expense as these amounts are eliminated in preparing the consolidated
statements. Income to the noncontroliing interest will be unaffected since the constructive
gain is assigned to parent company
Q8-16 A constructive loss recorded on the subsidiary's bonds in a prior period means the
interest income recorded by the parent is less than the interest expense recorded by the
subsidiary in each of the following periods. Consolidated net income will increase when
interest income and expense are eliminated. Income assigned to the noncontrolling interest
will be based on the reported net income of the subsidiary plus the difference between
interest income and interest expense each period following the retirement. As a result, the
amount assigned will be greater than if the bond had not been constructively retired.
Q8-17 On the date the parent sells the bonds to a nonaffiliate they are issued for the first
time from a consolidated perspective. While the parent will record a gain or loss on sale of
the bonds on its books, none is recognized from a consolidated viewpoint. The difference
between the sale price received by the parent and par value is a premium or discount. Each
period there will be a need to establish the correct amount for the premium or discount
account and to adjust interest expense recorded by the subsidiary to bring the reported
amounts into conformity with the sale price to the nonaffliate.
Q8-18 The retirement gain or loss reported by the subsidiary when it repurchases the bonds
held by the parent must be eliminated in the consolidation process. From the viewpoint of the
consolidated entity the bonds were retired at the point they were purchased by the parent
and a gain or loss should have been recognized at that point.
83