Reading Putnam Edited by Peter Clark and Bob Haleei Ba Bac 19515 eptines 94 ead 95 opal ppc 15 a ian 2 {tena Selo Asie re sg re gn ppt he papein ‘atc eer ptember ein or ‘nd nny fre agen eee ne pore ‘ws nr eer aie inte dS esi ite lene a ‘ripretoncr rie adhd ect $5ltetnd ia ning oat Shepocpcne “pn tion Fae PnclestmSGermacny, “Tintatiepend nae ie Je ppl Pay Tey Bars Contents [Noes on Contributors Tnwolucsion Peer lark a Bob Hale 1 Enchanting Views Sion Blue 2 1819 Gone Bole 13 Wingentcia on Necessity Some Reflections ‘Miche! Demet “4 Punam and the Sklem Paradox Micha! Hallet 5 Realy, Realm and Reatvom Kern Kal, (Gey Ja and Cart Chrsar 6 Logi, Qua, and the Two-tc Experiment ‘Mutha Redhead 7 Carna's Principle of Telenace, Empire, snd Convendoralin Thomas Ricks 1 Pauan’s Docrine of Natural Kind Word and Frog’ Dans of Sense, Reference, and Extension: Gan They Care?” Dev Wiggins 9 On Petman's Proof that We Are Not Brsins in # Vat Chip Wks 10 Comments nd Reps Filer Paton Sekt Bibliography ofthe Publican of Hilary Pot Index of Names 2 216 S58Contributors suo Lacan i Edn J. Koury Distinguished Profesor of Philosophy 1 the University of North Carling, Cape Hil and Adjunct Profesor a {he Aumann Naina Univers Hes the autor of Sprang he Word (xtra Univensty Pres, 1964) and dhe ellen Ess in aa Reais. (Oxted University Pres, 199) ‘eoncr socks is Profenr of Phisphy a the Masachust Inte {CTectneoy He isc View Pres of the Asati fr Sb Logic an tn ctr ofthe Jounal of Symbac Logic is tous incade ‘The Unpochiny of Caen (Cartridge University Pen, 1979), The Lagi of Prec (Crige University Pre, 199), a Compuhity sand Lop, with Wiha Jey (Cai Unie Prom 1974, ion, Ti). He ett Meaning and Meshal: Ess iv Hw of ary Pasar (Cambridge University Pre, 192) scius: ouxoer is Wykeham Profence of Logic Emeritus inthe Univer- ‘iy of Oxford. His major pcan incde Pree Phlsphy of Langue {Duckworth 197, 1H, 198 199, Tach and Ore Eviar (Duckworth, 199, The Interpretations of Prge’ Philly (Duckworth, 1981), The Lop! Bas of Metphys (Duckwith, 19M), The Princ of Inttin- fam (Oxford Univeraty Pre, 197), Frege and Other Phlphers (Orford University Pres 1991) and Frge Phlaoply of Mathematics (Duckworth, 19. ccuank ciywoun is Alsi Prfeir of Philosphy at Carnegie Mallon University and Adjunct Prfasor of Hinory and Phos of Scene fa the Univerity of Paburgh. Hei the author of They and Bide ‘Nate on Cotton vs (Princeton University Pres, 1980), Diovering Canal Sire, with R. ‘Scbsnes . Spire, and K Kel (Academic ren, 1987), Thnbing Things Thragh MIT Pr, 192), Causation Prediction and Search with P Spee and R Schines (Springer Lecture Noes in Stasis, 199), and ste ‘reir f volumes on foundations af phys, hls medicine, and with Ilya options rey Cami Ue Po, sacs, HALLETT is Asocite Profenar of Philesophy a McGill Univer- Sig, Montel He isthe author of Canin Set Theory and Liman of Size (Carendon Press 1988, sod i crenly writing a bok on the ‘und work of Davi Hiller, camry Asian Profesor of Piso athe University of Tes, ‘atin, save ary ie Associate Profesor of Philosphy st Carnegie Mellon Universy. Hes the ater, with C. Glo, Scheie and P. Spies, ‘Dacre Casal Sire (Ace ress, 1987), ado urbe of apes on earning theory and philwphy of scence. His forthcoming book, The Lop of Rekabe Ing, presets «syste investigation a ipl ‘ats of xning theoreti frameworks He the eta, with C. moun, ‘of Lap, Computation, and Dievery (Cambridge Univesity Pres rth ‘ming. aay FTAA is Walter Beverly Pearson Profesor of Mathematical Logie tnd Profesor in Philosphy in Harvard Univesity. Among his major ‘ublicatins in pilsophy are Php of Lg: (Harper and Row, 197), Phloophy of Mathomtc,eied wih Pal Benacera (Cambridge Unt ‘vers Pres 198), Mathematics, Mater and Method (Cambie Univer ‘sy Pres, 1573), Mind, Language and Realty (Cambridge University Pros, 1975), Reto and Reason (Cambridge University Pres, 1989) Meaning ond ‘he Moral Scenes (Route snd Kegan Pal, 178), Reson, Tah and Hlsry (Cambridge University Press, 191), The Many Feces of Realm (Open Gout, 1987), Rerscmation and Realty (MIT Pres, 1969, Rea ‘nh « Haman Pace (Harvard Univesity Pree, 199, and Rening Pi apy (Harvard Univers Pres, 1992) sacs is Profesor of History and Piosphy of Sac inthe Univesity of Cambridge: Hi book ‘Nonbealy, and Rak (Osdord Universit Pres, 1967) wa the wine ofthe 1988 Lastoe Award for an oustanding contnbuton to the phil of science.