Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Objectives and instructions for completing the evaluation and statements of disclosure can be found on page 235.
Demystifying Pediculosis:
School Nurses Taking the Lead
Deborah J. Pontius
C
onsider this scenario com-
mon five years ago: Nathan, a The treatment of Pediculosis capitis, or head lice, is fraught with misinformation,
second grade student, was myths, and mismanagement. Common myths include the need to exclude children
sent to the school nurse’s from school, the need to remove all visible nits (“no-nit” policies), the need for mas-
office for a “head check” after his sive environmental cleaning, that head lice live for long periods of time, and that
teacher noticed him frequently scrat- schools are a common location for lice transmission. Head lice are a common
ching his head. The nurse finds sever- childhood nuisance, causing embarrassment and emotional trauma in both chil-
al tiny white objects on Nathan’s hair, dren and families. This article explores and challenges the commonly held beliefs
about an inch from the scalp. The about the identification, management, and treatment of Pediculosis by presenting
nurse does not see any evidence of current recommended evidence-based practice. It also challenges pediatric nurs-
nits closer to the head, nor does she es, and school nurses in particular, in alignment with the National Association of
find any live lice. Per school policy, School Nurses (NASN) Position Statement on Pediculosis Management in the
the nurse immediately calls his par- School Setting, to act as change agents for reasonable and effective school poli-
ents and requests they come to pick cies and practices.
him up. His belongings are brought to
the nurse’s office. When his parents
arrive, the nurse explains there is evi- teacher asks the nurse to check her Myth #1. Lice Are Easy
head and to sanitize headphones in
dence that Nathan might have lice,
her classroom.
To Get; They Are Easily
and that he needs to be treated. She Passed via Hats, Helmets,
also explains the “no-nit” policy, The problem with the scenario
meaning all nits must be removed described above is that not one of the Or Hair Care Items;
from his hair before he returns to health care provider interventions is And Can Jump or Fly
school. The nurse describes a treat- evidence-based best practice. Many From One Person to
ment program that includes washing school nurses across the county have
successfully advocated their school Another
all the linen in the house, washing all
of Nathan’s clothing, putting all items boards to update their treatment of A head louse is a wingless insect
that cannot be washed, such as Pediculosis to reflect the current state with six legs; therefore, it cannot
stuffed animals, in a plastic bag for 10 of knowledge. Unfortunately, the sce- jump, fly, or even crawl long distances
days, and spraying an aerosol pedi- nario above is still all too common. (Centers for Disease Control and
culicide or vacuuming all hard and This article will evaluate common Preventions [CDC], 2013a). Lice pos-
soft household surfaces. The nurse head lice myths or traditional prac- sess pincher-like grasping structures
also recommends the student and all tices and present current evidence- that allow them to hold on to the hair
members of the family be treated with based Pediculosis practice. shaft quite tenaciously. Bathing,
a pediculicide. As an alternative, the For the school community, Pedi- shampooing, or simple daily hair
nurse suggests a regime that includes culosis capitis, or head lice, is a time brushing cannot easily dislodge them
either a mayonnaise treatment or a consuming, seemingly never-ending (see Figure 1). The pincher actually
commercial lice removal service. The problem. School children (presumed adapts to hair shafts. In the U.S., the
nurse proceeds to check the heads of to be) with lice have been estimated to most common form of head lice
all the students in Nathan’s classroom lose an average of four days of school species has adapted to the round
and sends a letter home to notify the per year in schools where “no-nit” Caucasian hair shaft (Frankowski &
parents of Nathan’s classmates of a policies are enforced (Gordon, 2009). Bocchini, 2010). Lice are much less
case of lice in the classroom. Nathan’s This represents not only a loss of the common among the oval-shaped hair
opportunity for learning, but a loss of shaft of the African-American child. A
funding for schools and loss of parent louse is mostly readily transmitted via
work days as well. Nationwide, it has head-to-head contact.
Deborah J. Pontius, MSN, RN, NCSN, is been estimated that schools lose
Health Services Coordinator, Pershing
There is a very small theoretical
between $280 to $325 million in possibility that hair care items may
County School District, Lovelock, NV, and
Past Board Member and Executive Com- annual funding, and families lose up assist in the transmission of lice,
mittee Member, National Association of to of $2,720 in wages per active infes- although these insects are likely to be
School Nurses, Silver Spring, MD. tation (Gordon, 2009). dead or injured. Therefore, it is pru-
Figure 3. Figure 4.
Viable Nit Comparison of Egg, Nymph,
and Adult
Source: CDC Public Health Image Library, 2014. Source: CDC Public Health Image
Library, 2014.
through, further follow up, which head lice (Frankowski & Bocchini, HIV or other communicable condi-
may include financial assistance with 2010). A close contact includes all tion in school. However, they do not
pediculicides, additional education members of the household; those who have a legal right to such informa-
and how to check and comb out lice have recently spent the night; family tion. Although no school would send
and viable eggs, referral for prescrip- members who travel between house- home a letter with a specific child’s
tion treatment, or as a rare, very last holds in blended families; children name in it, families can easily deter-
resort, exclusion for non-compliance, who spend large amounts of time out- mine which child is suspected to have
may be appropriate (Frankowski & side of school with each other, such as lice. This right to confidentiality in
Bocchini, 2010; Pontius, 2011). A day care, camp, or at babysitters; and schools is protected by the Family
child should never lose a day at preschool and kindergarten children Educational Rights and Privacy Act
school because of lice. who both sit near each other and play (FERPA), and by state and national
often together. ethical health care and education
standards.
Myth #8. Classroom
Checks Can Limit Spread Myth #9. Letters to Parents The Family Educational
Of Head Lice in Schools Or Guardians When a Case Rights and Privacy Act
Is Identified at School Are FERPA requires that medical and
It is the position of NASN, the
CDC, and AAP that school screenings,
A Good Way to Control educational records cannot, without
The Spread of Head Lice parental/guardian consent, be released
either routine or after an identified to others without a legitimate educa-
classroom case, are not productive, There is no evidence to support tional interest. This is regardless of
cost-effective, or merited, and are the claim that letters sent home pre- whether the information is written,
wasteful of education time (CDC, vent head lice transmission, and they oral, or electronic (ASHA, 2000; Bergren,
2013a, Frankowski & Bocchini, 2010; may, in fact, be a violation of privacy 2001). Even without disclosing the
NASN, 2011). School screenings are and confidentiality (American School actual name, if another person can eas-
not an accurate way of assessing or pre- Health Association [ASHA], 2000; ily determine the identity of a child,
dicting which children are or will Frankowski & Bocchini, 2010). There then student privacy and confidential-
become infested, and such screenings is no known method to prevent lice ly has been violated. For example, if
have not been proven to have a signif- (other than by shaving the scalp hair). the nurse were discussing an issue at
icant effect on the incidence of head Sending home a letter may, as it school about a child in a wheelchair
lice in a school (Frankowski & should, cause parents to check their and only one child is in a wheelchair
Bocchini, 2010; Meinking & Taplin, students to see if they are currently at school, enough information has
2011). One study found that misdiag- infested. However, this may also cre- been provided to identify that child
nosis is so common that non-infested ate a false sense of security because and breech his or her privacy, without
children were excluded from school parents may believe their child is lice- ever mentioning a name. In a pedicu-
more often than actually infested chil- free. There may be undetected, un- losis situation, if after parents receive a
dren (Pollack et al., 2000). Anecdotally, hatched viable nits or one pregnant lice alert letter they ask their own child
prior to the elimination of “no-nit” louse in the hair, or the child may who went home from school today
policies and classroom screening in her spend the next night with friend who and their child knows the answer, a
district, the author had conducted unknowingly has an infestation. similar breech has occurred.
classroom screens whenever one stu- Some parents/guardians will treat pro-
dent was found to have head lice. phylactically, causing unnecessary use National Ethical Standards
During eight years of such screenings, of pediculicides or time-consuming And State Laws
no further cases of lice were ever found combing and environmental clean- Both the professions of education
that could not be attributed to close ing. Sending letters home often and nursing have developed codes of
contact outside of school. results in panic and emotional dis- ethics that stipulate not disclosing
Screenings also have significant tress among caregivers. Letters home information about students obtained
potential to violate the children’s pri- not only provoke a crisis situation within the course of professional serv-
vacy. In schools, parents or guardians and unjustified panic, but they per- ice. For example, provision #3 in the
have a right to control access to their petuate the myth that lice are trans- American Nurses Association (ANA)
child’s body. This could be violated by mitted in schools (Mumcuoglu et.al, Code of Ethics states “the nurse pro-
routinely screening students without 2007). However, some schools contin- motes, advocates for and strives to
parent/guardian permission. The ue to send alert letters because while protect the health, safety and rights of
National Pediculosis Association, a lay they may understand head lice are a patient, which includes both priva-
pediculosis interest group, continues not a public health risk, they are cy and confidentiality” (ANA, 2001,
to recommend the strict adherence to concerned about a public relations p. 6). Failure to uphold national pro-
“no-nit” policies via nit combing and dilemma and community backlash fessional standards can leave the
routine screenings as a way to elimi- (Frankowski & Bocchini, 2010). nurse open to charges of malpractice.
nate the need any pediculicides.
There is no published, reviewed evi- Confidentiality Violations Harm vs. Duty to Warn
dence to support these claims (R. Parents or guardians often insist According to ASHA (2000), when
Pollack, personal communication, they have a right to know when a case contemplating a disclosure of confi-
May 21, 2014). of head lice is discovered in a class- dential health information even if by
It is prudent, however, to check room. Parents have also insisted they default, two ethical criteria must be
close contacts of a child found to have have a right to know when a child has met. The criteria and related consider-
Figure 5.
Suggested Scheme for Head Louse Infestations
“Nits” No Relax! Do
discovered NOT treat
on hair? for lice.
Yes
• Apply an FDA-registered over-
• Inspect hair for live (crawling) lice. the-counter pediculicide
• Compare samples to images on our website according to label directions.
or submit a sample for evaluation. • Change or launder pillowcases,
• Inspect all other people in the home for live pajamas, and towels that were
lice. in direct contact with the
infested person within the past
day.
• If live (crawling) lice persist, a
second application may be
Live Periodically needed about 10 days after the
(crawling) No reinspect hair first treatment.
lice on for live lice. • Consult your physician or
hair? Do NOT treat. pharmacist for advice.
Yes
Yes
Yes
Source: © 2010 IdentifyUS, LLC. Used with permission. Retrieved from https://identify.us.com/idmybug/head-lice/head-lice-
documents/lice-mgmnt-chart-home.pdf
Table 2.
Lice 101: Myths and Realities about Head Lice
Definitions
Lice: More than one louse. Nit: Eggs, dead or alive, of a louse
Louse: Small insect that lives on the scalp. Parasite: Lives off another, in this case the blood of humans.
Pediculosis: Having an infestation of lice. Infestation: Having an insect present, in this case, in your head.
Myths Truths
Head lice are easy to get. Lice are spread only mainly by head-to-head contact. They are much harder
to get than a cold, flu, ear infection, pink eye, strep throat, food poisoning, or
impetigo.
You can get lice from your dog, guinea pig, or Lice are species-specific. You can only get human lice from another human.
other animal. You cannot get another animal’s lice.
You can get head lice from hats and helmets. Rarely, but possible. Hairbrushes, pillows, and sheets are also uncommon
modes of transmission.
School is a common place for lice transmission. School is an unlikely source of transmission. Much more common are family
members, overnight guests, and playmates who spent a large amount of
time together.
Poor hygiene contributes to lice. Hygiene makes absolutely no difference. You get lice by close personal
head-to-head contact with someone else that has lice, not by being dirty.
Lice can jump or fly from one person to another. Lice can only crawl. They can neither fly nor jump. They must crawl from
one person to another.
Any nits left in the hair can cause lice to come Any nits farther away than one quarter to one half on the hair shaft are
back. ALREADY HATCHED and pose no risk to others.
Eggs or nits can fall out of the hair, hatch, and Nits are cemented to the hair and very hard to remove. They cannot fall off.
cause lice in another person. Newly hatched lice must find a head quickly or will die.
Lice can live a long time. Lice live only 1 to 2 days off the head. Each louse only lives about 30 days
on the head.
All members of a family should be treated if one Only the person with lice should be treated. Lice shampoos are
person has lice. INSECTICIDES and can be dangerous if used incorrectly or too frequently.
Household members and close contacts should be checked, but only treat
those who actually have lice. The house should NOT be sprayed with
insecticide, nor used on clothing or other items.
Checking a classroom when one student has lice Classroom transmission is EXCEEDINGLY RARE and checking students is
can prevent lice from spreading. a waste of valuable teaching time. Checking family members and close
playmates is much more appropriate.
Avoiding lice is important as they spread disease. Head lice do not spread any known disease. They are annoying
and irritating, but not dangerous.
Even in light of evidence to the school nurses are the perfect change
contrary, the lay public, including agent to promote policy improvement References
teachers and school administrators, to match what the evidence shows American Nurses Association (ANA). (2001).
Code of ethics for nurse. Retrieved from
often remain unconvinced of the need about the transmission and treatment http://www.nursingworld.org/MainMenu
to remove “no-nit” policies and will be of pediculosis. Not only can nurses Categories/EthicsStandards/Codeof
unmotivated to do so on their own. provide education with every interper- EthicsforNurses/Code-of-Ethics.pdf
Further, some experts believe the only sonal encounter, they can lobby their American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP).
hope for true success is to focus on the school board. Following the examples (2012). Red book: 2012 report of the
children. “Teach them to think, to set by leaders in school districts such as Committee of Infectious Diseases. Elk
Grove Village, IL: Author.
evaluate conflicting bits of informa- Oakland Unified, the author did just American School Health Association
tion and to form logical and rational that (see Figure 6). Because many (ASHA). (2000). National Task Force on
conclusions, and to be compassionate health care professionals are unaware Confidential Student Health Infor-
and caring” (R. Pollack, personal com- of the realities of lice and newer lice mation. Guidelines for protecting confi-
munication, May 21, 2014) to help treatments regimes, school nurses, as dential student health information. Kent,
children develop a new reality about well as pediatric nurses in general, are OH: ASHA.
Bergren, M. (2001). HIPAA hoopla: Privacy
head lice. Armed with the evidence, in the ideal position to lead the charge! and security of identifiable health infro-