Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cavity Configurations
Cavity Configurations
net/publication/256589637
CITATION READS
1 1,608
3 authors, including:
Dino Re
University of Milan
121 PUBLICATIONS 395 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Dino Re on 08 July 2014.
QDT 2006 55
FICHERA ET AL
ic
ic
mr
ic ic
D mr M
D id
mr M
mr
id
ic pcr
ic
Fig 1 Occlusal view of structural model of the Fig 2 Buccolingual view of the structural model
tooth. id = interaxial dentin, ic = intact cusp, of the tooth. id = interaxial dentin, ic = intact
mr = marginal ridge. cusp, mr = marginal ridge, pcr = pulp chamber
roof.
56 QDT 2006
Cavity Configurations for Indirect Partial-Coverage Restorations
marginal ridge is affected by any compromise of terms of the presence or absence of the pulp
the interaxial dentin.16,17 chamber roof and the thickness of the enamel-
The pulp chamber roof, contrary to common dentin complex at the adjacent intact cusp (it
belief, is less important than the marginal ridge. must be greater than1.5 to 2 mm in a vital
Reeh et al4 demonstrated that loss of the pulp tooth 18 and 2.5 to 3 mm in an endodontically
chamber roof when both marginal ridges are treated tooth13) and depth at the base.19 The na-
kept intact (ie, endodontic treatment requiring ture of the structural interdependence deter-
removal of some of the interaxial dentin and the mines whether or not it is necessary to cover the
pulp chamber roof) produces a less significant adjacent cusps. Articles by Linn et al20 and Pan-
structural weakening than maintenance of the itvisai et al 21 on the relationship between the
pulp chamber roof when one or two marginal marginal ridge and intact cusps in an endodonti-
ridges are missing (ie, vital tooth with Class 2 cally treated tooth demonstrate a structural and
cavity, occlusomesial, occlusodistal, and mesial- functional dependence of the intact cusp on the
occlusodistal). adjacent marginal ridge. Likewise, the articles
These considerations are important in making confirm the independent biomechanical be-
clinical choices based on the evaluation of healthy haviour among cusps as suggested by Sakaguchi
intact tooth structures and on scientific evidence, et al,22 and which has been clinically confirmed
and not simply on empirical or preconceived no- by numerous studies.5–12 The loss of one marginal
tions. The hierarchy of tooth structures is thus: (1) ridge in an endodontically treated molar, where
the interaxial dentin, (2) the marginal ridge, (3) the the other marginal ridge is intact and adjacent
roof of pulp chamber, and (4) the enamel-dentin cusps are well-supported, should be planned as
complex of the intact cusp. a restoration with partial cusp coverage; the
cusps adjacent to the lost marginal ridge are
covered, while the cusps adjacent to the intact
Peripheral structures marginal ridge are maintained.
The enamel-dentin complex of the intact cusp
The peripheral structures are the marginal ridge represents the most significant clinical factor in
and the enamel-dentin complex of each intact deciding whether to maintain or cover the cusp.
cusp. The marginal ridge is the peripheral struc- Hood6 demonstrated that from the mechanical
ture of the proximal wall, whereas the enamel- standpoint the enamel-dentin complex of the in-
dentin complex of the cusp is the peripheral struc- tact cusp adjacent to a proximal box behaves
ture of the axial-buccal or palatolingual wall. The like a cantilever; the thickness and depth at the
marginal ridge, its underlying enamel-dentin com- base of the intact cusp are the most important
plex, and the interaxial dentin meet at the junc- parameters since they vary with the cube of the
tion of the buccal wall with the palatolingual wall. deformation and, in the final analysis, are re-
The thickness of enamel-dentin complex at the sponsible for the strength of the cusp. This is
base of each cusp does not participate in this why, with equal thickness and in the absence of a
structural junction but is rather the last support of marginal ridge, intact cusps of endodontically
the cusp itself. treated teeth flex more than those of vital teeth.
Correct evaluation of the marginal ridge must Keeping an intact cusp in a vital tooth is deter-
follow certain criteria. The loss of a marginal mined by an enamel-dentin thickness greater
ridge signifies the presence of a proximal box. If than 1.5 to 2 mm,20 whereas in an endodontically
the interaxial dentin has been compromised and treated tooth the thickness must exceed 2.5 to 3
the presence of an occlusal isthmus is antici- mm.13
pated, the proximal box must be evaluated in
QDT 2006 57
FICHERA ET AL
ic
ic
D mr M
mr id
TRANSITION AREAS AND POSSIBLE (buccal and lingual) (Fig 4). Configurations 1 to 4
CAVITY CONFIGURATIONS (see Figs 4a to 4d) are characterized by the pres-
ence of the marginal ridge, while configurations 5
After analyzing the peripheral and central struc- to 8 (see Figs 4e to 4h) are characterized by the ab-
tures (ie, the marginal ridge, the intact cusp, and sence of the marginal ridge, and, therefore, by the
the interaxial dentin), it is possible, topographi- presence of a proximal box. These eight configura-
cally, to outline the separation areas between tions cover all clinical possibilities for cavity design
each tooth structure. These areas are valuable in and cusp coverage in relation to the marginal ridge
diagnosing cavity configurations, since they repre- and account for half of the possibilities for a pre-
sent a line of transition between the restoration molar (eight configurations associated with the
and intracoronal and extracoronal cavity to be presence of the opposed marginal ridge and eight
outlined in partial-coverage crown preparation. configurations associated with its absence).
They also act as spatial references and help ac- By considering mirror images of the eight possi-
complish a rapid buildup that is stereoscopically ble configurations for a marginal ridge and adja-
correct. cent cusps, it is possible to obtain every type of
Taking, for example, a maxillary first molar, cavity preparation for a partial-coverage crown—
three areas of transition can be outlined between inlays, onlays, and overlays—in any combination
the marginal ridge and cusp, between cusp and (Figs 5 and 6). A simple calculation of the combi-
cusp, and between the interaxial dentin and the nations shows that 64 types of cavity preparation
peripheral marginal ridge–cusp unit (Fig 3). Given are possible for a partial-coverage crown in a tooth
the anatomy of posterior teeth, two areas of tran- with four cusps. Thanks to the concept of principal
sition are associated with each marginal ridge: a transition areas, it is simple to standardize cavity
buccal transition, at the beginning of the adjacent design. Ascertaining the presence or absence of
buccal cusp; and a lingual transition, at the begin- the marginal ridge is sufficient to determine
ning of the adjacent lingual cusp. whether the adjacent cusp should be maintained
A number of cavity designs are derived from the or covered. Following this decision, the geometry
possible combinations based on the absence or of the cavity configuration can be outlined with
presence of the marginal ridge and on the mainte- certainty.
nance or restoration of the two adjacent cusps
58 QDT 2006
Cavity Configurations for Indirect Partial-Coverage Restorations
Fig 4 Basic cavity configuration depending on presence or absence of marginal ridge and maintenance restoration
of adjacent cusps. bc = buccal cusp, lc = lingual cusp, mr = marginal ridge, pid = prepared interaxial dentin, cc =
cusp cover, pb = proximal box.
lc cc lc cc
bc bc cc cc
4a 4b 4c 4d
lc cc lc cc
pb pb pb pid pb pid
pid pid
bc bc cc cc
4e 4f 4g 4h
Fig 4a Cavity configuration 1: occlusal inlay. Fig 4e Cavity configuration 5: occlusodistal inlay.
Fig 4b Cavity configuration 2: onlay with lingual cusp Fig 4f Cavity configuration 6: occlusodistal onlay with
cover. lingual cusp cover.
Fig 4c Cavity configuration 3: onlay with buccal cusp Fig 4g Cavity configuration 7: occlusodistal onlay with
cover. buccal cusp cover.
Fig 4d Cavity configuration 4: onlay with lingual and Fig 4h Cavity configuration 8: occlusodistal onlay with
buccal cusp cover. lingual and buccal cusp cover.
L L
D M D M
1-4 1-5 2-4 2-5
B B
Fig 5 Mirror-image associations of mesial configuration Fig 6 Mirror-image associations of mesial configuration
1 with the 8 distal configurations. 2 with the 8 distal configurations.
QDT 2006 59
FICHERA ET AL
Fig 7 Horizontal cross section of in- Fig 8 Frontal cross section of intact Fig 9 Diagnostic model for type of
tact tooth structure at a specific oc- tooth structure at a specific mesio- cusp cover facilitates analysis of
clusocervical level to identify distal level to identify enamel-dentin occlusocervical and mesiodistal
enamel-dentin thickness on the thickness on the occlusocervical line. enamel-dentin thickness of the intact
mesiodistal line. cusp. pu = peripheral unit, cu = cen-
tral unit, de = distal extremity, me =
mesial extremity, red grids = transi-
tion area.
60 QDT 2006
Cavity Configurations for Indirect Partial-Coverage Restorations
cusp cusp
marginal ridge
1.5-2 mm
ness of the cusp. A Johannson thickness gauge preparation. To simplify analysis of the model, it is
for metals may be used as a diagnostic aid. appropriate to consider first the structural defi-
The structural units (nine in all) may be subdi- ciency of the enamel-dentin thickness in the 2-mm
vided into central3 and peripheral units (three on occlusal area of the cusp. This deficiency indicates
each side, ie, six per cusp). The peripheral struc- the need for shoeing (Figs 10a and 10b). When the
tural units coincide with the mesial and distal perimeter of the intracoronal cavity is in proximity
halves of the transition area, and, as such, will be to or coincides with the tip of the cusp, shoeing is
the site of maintenance or restoration (ie, the pas- indicated. This is true for all situations in which the
sage of the cavity perimeter) depending on the occlusal isthmus is intact and conventional capping
clinical situation. is not considered a conservative enough ap-
By examining the various parts of this model, it proach. The lateral view shows the cusp cover with
is possible to obtain all the necessary diagnostic its mesiodistal extension, whereas the frontal cross
information related to cuspal coverage. Before an- section shows its conservative quality and the ease
alyzing the model, it is important to observe that of performing this type of cusp cover.
a mesial and a distal extremity can be distin- Depending on the combination of mesial and
guished in the transition areas. For example, dur- distal extremities of the transition area, the shoe-
ing the preparation phase the cutting line may be ing will have four possible configurations; the most
traced through the transition area between cusp conservative approach does not involve the adja-
and marginal ridge, or between cusp and cusp, cent ridge or cusp, and the most extensive ap-
anywhere from the mesial to the distal extremity, proach involves both. There are schematic distinc-
ie, within a range of approximately 1.5 to 2 mm. tions between minimum-extension shoeing
Conceptually, wherever the cutting line runs within (required exclusively for a deficiency of a central
this range of 1.5 to 2 mm, the design of the gen- structure), intermediate-extension shoeing (for a
eral cavity shape (types 1 to 8) does not change deficiency of a central structure plus one periph-
(see Fig 4). If the transition line is located at the eral structure), and maximum-extension shoeing
mesial or distal extremity of the area, it will affect (for a deficiency of a central structure and both pe-
the type of cusp cover that is required. ripheral structures) (Figs 11a to 11f). Should the
Identifying transition areas and their extremities structural deficiency in enamel-dentin thickness in-
limits the preparation line and avoids unnecessary volve the middle third as well as the occlusal band,
QDT 2006 61
FICHERA ET AL
cusp cusp
marginal ridge
11a 11b
cusp cusp
marginal ridge
11c 11d
cusp cusp
marginal ridge
11e 11f
Figs 11a to 11f Models (left) and occlusal views (right) of cusp cover by shoeing
with minimum (a and b), intermediate (c and d), and maximum (e and f) mesiodistal
extension. red grids = transition area.
capping will be required (Figs 12a and 12b). Four those in which an intact cusp is combined with a
combinations of capping are also possible, one structural deficiency involving a missing adjacent
classic total capping and three partial capping of marginal ridge and an adjacent cusp requiring
minimum to intermediate extension (Figs 13a to complete restoration (eg, 2-6,2-8,3-7,3-8 [see Figs
13f). A structural deficiency in the cervical third in- 5 and 6]). Such situations allow full exploitation of
volves the same combinations as outlined above, the operative space, due to the absence of transi-
the only clinical difference being that the cervical tion areas adjacent to the cusp. Despite this, it is
margin will lie closer to the gingival margin, and, possible to resort to maximum-extension cover in
consequently, the axial wall will be longer (Figs 14 the presence of adjacent marginal ridge and cusp.
and 15). By exploiting the transition areas bordering the in-
Out of the possible 64 cavity designs, configura- tact cusp and using a cavity perimeter that passes
tions with the greatest space for cusp coverage are through the more distant mesial and distal extremi-
62 QDT 2006
Cavity Configurations for Indirect Partial-Coverage Restorations
cusp cusp
marginal ridge
1.5-2 mm
cusp cusp
marginal ridge
13a 13b
cusp cusp
marginal ridge
13c 13d
cusp cusp
marginal ridge
13e 13f
Figs 13a to 13f Models (left) and occlusal views (right) of cusp cover by capping
the middle third with minimum (a and b), intermediate (c and d), and maximum
(e and f) mesiodistal extension. red grids = transition area.
QDT 2006 63
FICHERA ET AL
cusp cusp
marginal ridge
1.5-2 mm
cusp cusp
marginal ridge
15a 15b
cusp cusp
marginal ridge
15c 15d
cusp cusp
marginal ridge
pb
15e 15f
Figs 15a to 15f Models (left) and occlusal views (right) of cusp cover by capping
the cervical third with minimum (a and b), intermediate (c and d), and maximum
(e and f) mesiodistal extension. pb = proximal box, red grids = transition area.
64 QDT 2006
Cavity Configurations for Indirect Partial-Coverage Restorations
cusp cusp
marginal ridge
ties, the minimum operative space needed to ac- simplify explanation of the model and clarify the
complish a maximum-extension cusp cover can be differences between various cusp covers. Clinical
obtained. Furthermore, understanding of the practice produces a wide range of possible com-
mesial and distal extremities of a transition area binations (Figs 16a and 16b), but by following a
makes it possible to consider different designs for number of guidelines it is possible to make the
cusp coverage, provided that one or both transition best compromise between maximum conserva-
areas adjacent to the undermined intact cusp are tion of tooth structure and optimal biomechanics
not involved. Partial capping and minimum- and in- of the tooth restoration (Fig 17).
termediate-extension shoeing, combine the biome- Furthermore, the grid and its central and pe-
chanical benefits of cusp covers with the advan- ripheral subdivisions allow a realistic evaluation of
tages of maximum conservation of tooth structure. buildup possibilities for reinforcing the intact
Various combinations of enamel-dentin thick- enamel-dentin complex (Figs 18 to 33).
ness on the intact cusp have been illustrated to
QDT 2006 65
FICHERA ET AL
Fig 23 Application of primer and Fig 24 Bright white chrome com- Fig 25 Application of fluid com-
bonding agent. posite facilitates potential endo- posite buildup.
dontic re-treatment and enhances
value of buildup.
Fig 26 Application of restoration Fig 27 Preparation of onlay cavity Fig 28 Sectional matrix, wedge, and
composite buildup. with cusp cover by shoeing of retractor ring for Class II occluso-
mesiolingual cusp and by capping mesial cavity at the second premolar.
middle third of mesiobuccal cusp.
Fig 29 Construction of mesial wall Fig 30 Direct resin composite Fig 31 Adhesive cementing of
of the second premolar. restoration of the second premolar. composite onlay to the first molar.
Field for adhesive cementing of
onlay to the first molar is placed
under rubber dam.
66 QDT 2006
Cavity Configurations for Indirect Partial-Coverage Restorations
CONCLUSION 7. Khera SC, Goel VK, Chen RCS, Gurusami SA. Parameters
of MOD cavity preparations: A 3-D FEM Study, Part II.
Oper Dent 1991;16:42–54.
By looking to biomechanical studies and a struc- 8. Goel VK, Khera SC, Gurusami SA, Chen RC. Effect of cav-
tural model of the tooth, it is possible to standard- ity depth on stresses in a restored tooth. J Prostht Dent
1992;2:174–183.
ize the diagnosis of cavity configuration and the
9. Rees JS: The role of cuspal flexure in the development of
application of clinical and operative guidelines. abfraction lesions: A finite element study. Eur J Oral Sci
Determining the strength of the intact healthy 1998;6:1028–1032.
tooth structures represents the starting point for 10. Lin CL, Chang CH, Wang CH, Ko CC, Lee HE. Numerical
investigation of the factors affecting interfacial stresses in
all analysis. In examining the adequacy and defi- an MOD restored tooth by auto-meshed finite element
ciency of intact tooth structures, a clinician can de- method. J Oral Rehabil 2001;6:517–525.
termine all biomechanically valid cavity configura- 11. Takahashi A, Inoue S, Kawamoto C, et al. In vivo long-
term durability of the bond to dentin using two adhesive
tions. Using a model of the enamel-dentin complex systems. J Adhes Dent 2002;2:151–159.
of the intact cusp, an analysis can provide indica- 12. Hashimoto M, Ohno H, Kaga M, Endo K, Sano H, Oguchi
tions for restoring any intact cusp, as well as the H. In vivo degradation of resin-dentin bonds in humans
over 1 to 3 years. J Dent Res 2000;6:1385–1391.
choice of type of cusp cover. This approach en-
13. Becciani R, Castellucci A. La biomeccanica del dente trat-
courages cavity configurations and types of cusp tato endodonticamente. Implicazioni cliniche. Dent Cad-
cover that offer structural strength and maximum mos 2002;1:15–32.
14. Mondelli J, Steagall L, Ishikiriama A, de Lima Navarro MF,
conservation of the natural tooth.
Soares FB. Fracture strength of human teeth with cavity
preparations. J Prosthet Dent 1980;43:419–422.
15. Larson TD, Douglas WH, Geistfeld RE. Effect of prepared
cavities on the strength of teeth. Oper Dent 1981;6:2–5.
REFERENCES
16. el-Mowafy OM. Fracture strength and fracture patterns of
maxillary premolars with approximal slot cavities. Oper
1. Carossa S, Pera P. Corone Parziali in Oro e in Ceramica. Dent 1993;18:160–166.
Milan: Masson, 1997:3–8.
17. Caron GA, Murchison DF, Cohen RB, Broome JC. Resis-
2. Manhart J, Hickel R. Longevity of Restorations. In: Roulet tance to fracture of teeth with various preparations for
JF, Wilson N, Fuzzi M (eds). Advances in Operative Den- amalgam. J Dent 1996;6:407–410.
tistry, Vol 2: Challenges of the future. Quintessence 2001:
18. Touati B, Miara P, Nathanson D. Estetica Dentale e
237–304.
Restauri in Ceramica. Milan: Masson, 2000:259–291.
3. Fichera G. Restauri indiretti in composito nei settori pos-
19. Anderlini G. Moderni Orientamenti per la Restaurazione
teriori. Principi di preparazione cavitaria. Il Dentista Mod-
Dentale, Vol II. Edizioni Bologna: Martina, 1995:594–604.
erno, 2002;5:73–93.
20. Linn J, Messer HH. Effect of restorative procedures on the
4. Reeh ES, Messer HH, Douglas WH: Reduction in tooth
strength of endodontically treated molars. J Endod
stiffness as a result of endodontic and restorative proce-
1994;20:479–485.
dures. J Endod 1989;15:512–516.
21. Panitvisai P, Messer HH. Cuspal deflection in molars in re-
5. Blaser PK, Lund MR, Cochran MA, Potter RH. Effects of
lation to endodontic and restorative procedures. J Endod
designs of Class 2 preparations on resistance of teeth to
1995;21:57–61.
fracture. Oper Dent 1983;8:6–10.
22. Sakaguchi RL, Brust EW, Cross M, DeLong R, Douglas
6. Hood JAA. Methods to improve fracture resistance of
WH. Independent movement of cusps during occlusal
teeth. In: Vanherle G, Smith DC (eds). International Sym-
loading. Dent Mater 1991;7:186–190.
posium on Posterior Composite Resin Dental Restorative
Materials. Amsterdam: Szulc, 1985:443–450.
QDT 2006 67