Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Glucksberg: Is this something that is deeply rooted in our nation’s history? Description of
the liberty asserted
Connect to the 4 established rights (Don’t need all)
o Use cases to back up
Determine if Fundamental Right and Analyze SS
o State Interest?
o Necessary/ Narrowly Tailored to achieve this compelling interest
State’s response to Arguments
o Has the Supreme Court ever come close to saying this is a fundamental right?
o Deeply rooted in nation’s history? Would argue not
o Argue that there are alternatives
o SS should not apply, use RB
Conclude
o Say whether FR or not? SS? Will it fail?
Equal Protection Analysis:
Facial Classification or Facial Neutral?
o Facial Class: Disadvantages group on its face
o Facial Neutral: Intent and Impact
Level of Scrutiny?
o SS – Race/ Nat’l Origin
o IS – Gender
o RB – Everything Else
Does the law meet the scrutiny?
Religion Analysis
Free Exercise Clause
o Define religion under Seeger
o If the law is generally applicable and validly enacted, use the Smith Test
Rational Basis
o Argue both sides of whether is facially neutral
Establishment Clause
o Lemon Test
Secular Purpose
Primary effect neither inhibits/advances a religion
No excessive entanglement
o Endorsement
Would a reasonable observe see a message of government approval or
disapproval of religion
o Coercion
Whether the government is coercing people to take part in religion