You are on page 1of 4

Inspection of

post tensioned
concrete: WHO
and WHY?
BY RAYMOND F. MESSER
VICE PRESIDENT
WALTER P. MOORE AND ASSOCIATES, INC.

O wners and municipalities are becoming more


aware of the need for detailed inspection to insure
safe and economical construction, particularly for de-
sign-build or fast-track construction and for more so-
phisticated structural systems such as post-tensioned
c o n c re t e. For such inspection to be effective, the in-
spection team must understand the basic design
process, structural behavior, and field installation of the
structural system.
The owner can frequently save money when post-ten-
sioning is properly used. Howe ve r, these potential sav-
ings may disappear if the structure is inadequately con- Well painted datum marks and careful measuring give
structed. Completion delays and repair costs associated accurate readings of tendon elongation. This is an important
with improper construction sequence, tendon elonga- part of inspecting tendon stressing operations, as outlined
tion discrepancies, and concrete distress are avoidable in the guidlines given on page 3
with proper quality control and inspection at the site.
While inspection is not a cure-all, it goes a long way in
eliminating jobsite problems and assuring quality con-
struction. To eliminate structural inspection in a move to praises the risks associated with lack of inspection may
cut costs is asking for trouble. want to retain a qualified inspection service. The obvi-
ous question becomes: “Who is qualified to review post-
Inspection team qualifications tensioning installation?”
Inspection and quality control may involve seve ra l To assure quality review, the owner should require the
organizations, depending on the owner’s standards and following of the inspection team:
municipal regulations. The first line of quality control is 1. Understanding of the most common post-tension -
the contractor’s own quality assurance program. Quali- ing systems and components such as types of pre-
ty placing of post-tensioning tendons and mild reinforc- stressing steel, anchorages, sheathing and corrosion
ing steel in proper sequence requires little or no rework protection, stressing equipment, and proper termi-
upon final inspection by the reviewing authority. Many nology.
times, rework of post-tensioning material is the source 2. Knowledge of the post-tensioning design p ro c e s s
of tensioning problems. Installation of post-tensioning and basic principles. While the front-line inspector
material is not necessarily difficult, but repair after a may not need detailed design experience, he should
concrete pour usually is. have a basic knowledge of such concepts as load bal-
In addition to the contractor’s review, the local munic- ancing, initial and stage stressing, anchorage zone
ipality may require a final inspection of the embedded bursting, and hydraulic force/pressure. Without this
steel before any concrete pour. This review is usually knowledge it is virtually impossible to intelligently
p e rf o rmed by the structural engineer of record, local and reasonably inspect post-tensioning placement.
building department, or independent testing lab. If the The importance of tendon profile, bursting or back-
governmental agency, by law, does not require a final re- up steel, stressing sequence, and jacking force/pres-
view prior to each concrete pour, the owner who ap- sure becomes obvious with this knowledge.
Improperly tied tendons can be severely displaced during
concrete pours, resulting in substantial damage when
stressing is applied. Full-time inspection can help to
Properly spaced tendon anchor groups with adequate alleviate such problems.
bursting steel prevent concrete blowouts during tendon
stressing.

field deviations, discrepancies, and conflicts. In fact,


3. Experience in major phases of field installation and some city building codes now require construction in-
plant fabrication. Years of hands-on experience is spection by a structural engineer.
not necessary, but regular plant tour and complete
review of all phases of field installation are a must. An Coordination
understanding of why, when, and where helps the in- Early coordination among the owner, contractor, en-
spector and engineer appreciate the practical limits gineer and testing laboratory is a must to establish mon-
for tendon sweeps, fixed end quality control, and itoring guidelines, areas of responsibility, and re p o rt -
stressing equipment behavior. submittal procedures. Discrepancies of any nature must
4. Experience inspecting conventionally re i n f o rc e d be brought to the attention of the appropriate parties,
concrete structures. Since post-tensioned structures formally and immediately, so corrective action can be
are in part conventionally reinforced, it is appropri- taken. The longer a post-tensioning field problem re-
ate to require related experience. mains unsolved, the more difficult it is to correct. For ex-
If testing laboratories or other inspection agencies do ample, restressing or lift-off operations to verify tendon
not have the recommended experience, the structural force may be relatively easy immediately after stressing,
engineer of record can be retained to review the tendon but impossible 6 weeks later due to freezing of wedges,
and conventional steel placement. A separate contract damage to anchor head threads, removal of tendon
for such detailed inspection service may be negotiated. stressing tail, and other flaws.
While this approach may cost the owner more, it has ad-
vantages. The engineer is most familiar with the struc- Full-time inspection
tural design and the design criteria, and has seen the Is full-time site inspection required, including moni-
project evolve from the owner’s requirements. As a re- toring the in-place stability of mild reinforcing steel and
sult, he can make appropriate judgements re g a rd i n g post-tensioning tendons during concrete pours? Steel
displacement can occur for a variety of reasons after an

A simple engineer’s log for tracking post-tensioning submittals and tendon stressing. A form like this will help the structural
engineer of record in his review of stressing records.
GUIDELINES FOR INSPECTION OF POST-TENSIONING
UNBONDED TENDONS BONDED TENDONS

Are fixed end wedges evenly and adequately seated in Are the anchor heads properly machined, cleaned, and
the anchor? protected from corrosion?
Is excessive sheathing stripped at the fixed end? Are the wedges or threaded nuts free of rust and steel
Is the plastic sheathing of sufficient and uniform thick- shavings, and of consistent quality?
ness? Is the duct manufactured from quality steel strip with
Is the grease evenly applied and of consistent texture? specified thickness and watertight seams?

Does the strand appear to be of new quality, free of cor- Is the bare prestressing steel free of corrosion and
rosion when sheathing and grease are removed? debonding contaminants, and adequately protected dur-
ing storage?
Are the anchors properly cast with smooth wedge
holes?
Are the wedges free of rust and steel shavings, and of
consistent quality?
Are mill reports and certifications available for the pre-
stressing steel and other components, as required by
the specifications?

Are the tendon high and low points at the correct ele- Are high and low points of the center of duct at the cor-
vation? rect elevation?
Are the tendon profiles smooth and correctly shaped Are duct profiles smooth and correctly shaped (parabol-
(parabolic, circular, or straight) between re f e re n c e ic, circular, or straight) between reference points?
points? Are all duct joints properly mated and sealed with duct
Do the tendons have excessive horizontal wobble? tape?
Is the sheathing damaged, and if so, has it been re- Are there any holes in the duct, and if so, have they been
paired? repaired to prevent concrete intrusion?
Are there any kinks in the duct which will prevent pre-
Does the chair or support-bar system conform to con-
stressing steel installation?
tractor documents?
Is the support system adequately tied to prevent dis-
Are the stressing anchors securely fastened to the form placement and floating of the duct during concrete
with appropriate pocket formers? placement?
Is bursting steel installed behind the anchorages as re- Are the bearing plates securely fastened to the form
quired by the contract documents? blockouts?
Has the method of concrete placement been reviewed Is bursting steel installed behind the anchorages as re-
as to its effect on tendon stability during placement? quired by the contract documents?
Has the conventional steel placement been reviewed? Has the method of concrete placement been reviewed as
to its effect on duct stability during placement?
Has the conventional steel placement been reviewed?

Are the stressing anchor wedge holes free of grout, dirt Are the anchor heads, wedges and nuts free of corrosion,
and plastic? dirt and grease?
Is a consistent dimension used for the elongation da- Has the elongation datum mark for the initial and final
tum mark on the strand? reading been logically and clearly located?
Is the stressing equipment well maintained, and are cal- Is the stressing equipment well maintained, and are cali-
ibration charts available? bration charts available?
Is the stressing ram operator careful with the equip- Is the stressing ram operator careful with equipment and
ment and consistent from tendon to tendon? consistent from tendon to tendon?
Are the tendons stressed slowly enough to allow the Are the wedges, shims, or nuts properly seated after
strand to overcome as much friction as possible prior to stressing?
seating?
Are the tendon ends and stressing pockets properly pre-
Are the wedges seated evenly and under pressure? pared for patching?
After elongation approval, are the tendon tails cut off
well inside the pocket to allow proper grout cover?
Are pocket surfaces sufficiently clean to allow good
grout bond during and after patching?
inspection has been completed. To preclude or at least The table (opposite) lists important questions about
minimize this potential problem, full-time inspection each of these phases for both bonded (grouted) systems
may be appropriate. One critically displaced tendon can and unbonded (greased and sheathed) tendons.
cause concrete distress during tendon jacking that will Material manufacturing: Most fabrication plants have
result in added construction costs ranging from a few similar production facilities. Depending upon the mag-
dollars for repair to substantial damages for project de- nitude of the project and the general reputation of the
lays. material supplier, plant inspection may be appropriate.
If not, then jobsite material review is in order.
Monitoring stressing operations Tendon installation: An experienced inspection team
Typically, technicians are familiar with hydraulic jack- will review the process with the placer during installa-
ing operations, and can be trained to properly monitor tion of the first pour, and reach an understanding with
tendon stressing and measure elongations (see photo, the crew regarding critical elements.
page 1). A preliminary briefing by the structural engineer Tendon stressing: Stressing or jacking is probably the
regarding tolerances and stressing sequence is impor- most stra i g h t f o rw a rd operation associated with post-
tant. tensioning. Yet it seems to be the most troublesome and
Normal daily inspection reports may be handwritten controversial. Experience with the various stressing pro-
or typed, but should be issued to all concerned parties cedures is a must for the inspector.
( ow n e r, contractor, engineer, and architect) within 24
hours of the actual inspection. Stressing logs recording Conclusions
jacking pressure and tendon elongations should be If experienced inspection services are employed and
neatly handwritten and formally submitted for engineer quality work is maintained by the contractor, the inspec-
review within 24 hours of stressing. tion can be quick and relatively inexpensive, compared
The structural engineer of record usually reviews shop to costs of repair should improper procedures be al-
drawings and other such construction submittals. Simi- lowed. With the current prevalent atmosphere of litiga-
larly, review of stressing records should be the engineer’s tion, inspection by qualified and experienced persons is
responsibility. He will know best what deviations may be well worth the investment. One only needs to read the
tolerated beyond those specified in the construction newspaper to recognize the costly settlements associat-
documents. A simple form makes tracking of field data ed with construction failures. While inspection is not 100
and submittals easy, and helps assure complete execu- percent effective in eliminating mistakes and failures, it
tion. is the most cost-effective method known for minimiz-
ing risk.
Inspection guidelines Well painted datum marks and careful measuring give
As in any industry, there are tricks of the trade which accurate readings of tendon elongation. This is an im-
should be understood by the inspection team to assure portant part of inspecting tendon stressing operations,
quality. Three phases are involved for all post-tensioning as outlined in the guidelines given on page 3.
systems:
• Material manufacturing
PUBLICATION #C830317
• Tendon installation Copyright © 1983, The Aberdeen Group
• Tendon stressing All rights reserved

You might also like