Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Yuan2014 PDF
Yuan2014 PDF
BACKGROUND Ablative 10,600-nm carbon dioxide (CO2) fractional laser treatments have shown favorable
outcomes for atrophic acne scars.
OBJECTIVE To compare the efficacy and complications of fractional CO2 laser treatments with different
fluences and densities for acne scars.
METHODS Twenty patients were treated using a single session of fractional CO2 laser in Deep FX mode. In
Group A (n = 10), half of the face was treated with 20 mJ, density 10% and the other half with 20 mJ,
density 20%. In Group B (n = 10), half of the face was treated with 10 mJ, density 10% and the other half
with 20 mJ, density 10%. Patients were evaluated at baseline and 3 days, 1 week, 1 month, and 3 months
after the procedure.
RESULTS There was no significant difference in efficacy between different laser settings within the groups,
although adverse effects were more evident in patients treated with higher densities or fluences.
CONCLUSION Factional CO2 laser treatment using the Deep FX mode may provide a significant efficacy with
lower fluence and density with fewer complications than with higher energies for acne scars.
The authors have indicated no significant interest with commercial supporters.
*Department of Dermatology and Venereology, First Hospital of Jilin University, Changchun, China; †Department of
Dermatology and Venereology, Yanbian University Hospital, Yanji, China
© 2014 by the American Society for Dermatologic Surgery, Inc. Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
ISSN: 1076-0512 Dermatol Surg 2014;40:545–552 DOI: 10.1111/dsu.12467
545
COMPARISON STUDY OF CO2 AFR
4 mm into the reticular dermis, but data on the with 20 mJ, density 20%. In Group B (n = 10), half
efficacy and adverse effects of this novel resurfacing of the face was treated with 10 mJ, density 10% and
technique in dark-skinned patients are limited. the other half with 20 mJ, density 10%. Facial
treatment halves were also randomized. A single
In this study, we compared the efficacy and com- operator then administered a full-face, single-pass
plications of fractional CO2 laser treatment with the treatment without overlapping pulse.
Deep FX mode using different fluences and densities
for acne scars in Asian patients in a randomized, Immediately after each procedure, a thin layer of
split-face, evaluator-blinded study. fluticasone propionate cream (Ketinv; Glaxo Oper-
ations UK Limited, Durham, UK) and a recombinant
Methods human epidermal growth factor hydrogel (Yifu;
Huanuowei, Guilin, China) was applied to prevent
Patients an inflammatory reaction and reduce facial dryness.
This study followed the principles of the 1975 Ice packing (4°C) was applied to the treated surface
Declaration of Helsinki. Twenty Chinese subjects, for 30 minutes or more until the pain or burning
10 female and 10 male, aged 22–31, with Fitzpatrick sensation decreased. Subjects were instructed to
skin types III–IV and moderate to severe atrophic clean the treated sites gently with a mild cleanser
acne scars were enrolled. Informed consent was 24 hours after the treatment. The fluticasone pro-
obtained from each patient. Patients with a history pionate cream was applied twice daily for the first
of keloid scarring, isotretinoin use, pregnancy, 3 days and the recombinant human epidermal
lactation, immunosuppression, history of filler growth factor hydrogel 4 times daily for 1 week.
injection within the past year, or ablative or After complete decrustation, all patients
nonablative laser resurfacing within 1 year of study were instructed to wear a broad-spectrum sunscreen
initiation were excluded from the study. with a sun protection factor of 30 and to avoid
sun exposure.
Laser Treatment
Objective and Subjective Evaluations
Patients were treated with a single session of the
Deep FX microscanner handpiece of the fractional Photographs were taken using identical camera
ultrapulse CO2 laser (Ultrapulse Encore; Lumenis settings, lighting, and patient positioning at baseline
Inc., Santa Clara, CA). The treatment areas were and 3 days, 1 week, 1 month, and 3 months after
cleansed with a mild cleanser and 70% alcohol. treatment. Two blinded dermatologists compared
Local anesthesia, comprising a topical eutectic before and after photographs in nonchronological
mixture of 2.5% lidocaine hydrochloric acid and order and provided objective clinical assessments of
2.5% prilocaine cream (Compound Lidocaine the acne scars. Acne scars were graded using the
Cream; Ziguang, Beijing, China), was applied to the echelle d’evaluation clinique des cicatrices d’acne
entire face under occlusion before laser therapy. grading scale at baseline and 1 and 3 months after
After an hour of application, the anesthetic cream the treatment.9 The degree of improvement was
was gently removed, and then, to obtain a com- further assessed on a 4-point scale (0, no improve-
pletely dry skin surface, alcohol was used to ment; 1, 0–25% [minimal improvement]; 2,
degrease the skin. 26–50% [moderate] improvement; 3, 51–75%
[marked] improvement; 4, >75% [near total]
Twenty patients were randomly divided into two improvement). Subjects also performed a
groups. In Group A (n = 10), half of the face was self-assessment of their results (range 0–10) 1 and
treated with 20 mJ, density 10% and the other half 3 months after the treatment.
(A) (B)
(C) (D)
Figure 1. Twenty-seven-year-old male patient before (A) and 3 months after (B) treatment with 10 mJ, density 10% and
before (C) and 3 months after (D) treatment with 20 mJ, density 10%.
izing cream (Lauzome; Canada Highview & Ever- and infection were not observed in any of the 20
bright Medical Technology Co., Ltd., Changchun, subjects.
China) three times daily. Acneiform eruptions in one
subject were successfully treated within 2 weeks using
Discussion
clindamycin phosphate gel and adapalene gel applied
day and night, respectively. Some subjects also expe- Ablative fractional resurfacing (AFR) with 10,600-
rienced cutaneous pruritus in irradiation areas 2–5 days nm CO2 lasers uses fractionated laser beams to
after treatment. The sensation was sustainable produce an array of microscopic columns of con-
and automatically resolved within 1 week. Severe trolled deep dermal tissue volumetric ablation and
complications such as hypopigmentation, scarring, vaporization surrounded by thermally induced
annular coagulation zones of denatured collagen evaluation. Chapas and colleagues6 treated 13
with interspersed regions of untreated tissue.7,10 An patients with moderate to severe acne scars using the
ex vivo histologic study demonstrated that the depth novel ablative 30W CO2 Fraxel re:pair device at
of ablation in AFR depends on the pulse energy pulse energies of 20–100 mJ for two to three
used, with higher energies resulting in greater full-face treatments. Patients treated with higher
penetration depth.10 In turn, the depth of ablation energy levels (70–100 mJ) on deeper scars on the
and coagulation correlated directly with treatment cheeks for the second and third treatments received
efficacy in laser resurfacing.10–12 Various types of the highest improvement scores, with average over-
fractional ablative CO2 lasers have been used for all improvement of 51–75% 3 months after the final
acne scar treatments with different penetration treatment. A previous study with this device showed
depths at variable energy levels. Manuskiatti and tissue ablation and thermal effects as deep as 1–
colleagues12 treated 13 patients using a fractional 1.6 mm into the skin at the higher energies of 70–
CO2 laser for three sessions. Patients with mild to 100 mJ.14 Thus, based on previous studies, it was
moderate scars were irradiated with lower energy estimated that higher energy producing deeper tissue
levels (75–90 mJ/MTZ), whereas deeper scars were injury into the dermis correlated with more-pro-
treated using a high-pulse energy level (105 mJ/ nounced clinical efficacy in laser resurfacing,15,16
MTZ). A fractionated CO2 laser system used in their although it is unknown how deep the tissue injury
study creates 150- to 200-lm-deep MTZs. At the depth would tend to balance the biologic effects of
3-month follow-up, 69% of subjects had at least 25– modulating and suppressing in wound healing
50% improvement. Likewise, in a controlled split-- responses, which presents in similar clinical efficacy
face trial, Jung and colleagues13 treated mild to with different energies. In our comparison study, we
severe acne scars with a fractional CO2 laser. treated patients with moderate to severe acne scars
Lower-fluence, higher-density settings (30 mJ/pulse, using the Deep FX mode at energy levels of 10 and
250 MTZs/cm2) were compared with higher-fluence, 20 mJ (Group B). Farkas and colleagues17 reported
lower-density settings (70 mJ/pulse, 150 MTZs/ that, with a single pulse, the Deep FX mode
cm2). More-pronounced effects were demonstrated demonstrated tissue injury up to 1 mm from the
on the sides treated with higher fluence and lower tissue surface at 10 mJ and up to 2 mm at 20 mJ as
density. Energy levels of 30 and 70 mJ corresponded assessed through histopathologic evaluation. At the
to a depth of the necrotic columns approximately up 3-month follow-up, 80% of subjects had at least
to 282 and 486 lm, respectively, with the CO2 FS 25–50% improvement, and 30% had 51–75%
used in their study, as assessed through histologic improvement in their scar conditions. There was no
significant difference in clinical efficacy between 10 pathogenesis of PIH is unknown. Some studies have
and 20 mJ laser irradiation. Tissue injury after found high density to be a causative factor of
treatment with the Deep FX mode was similar to the PIH.6,18 In fractional resurfacing, too high a density
super-short-pulse Fraxel re:pair system, with the can cause overlapping thermal injury zones and, if
ablation microcolumns penetrating from the epi- dense enough, act like traditional ablative laser
dermis into the underlying papillary and reticular resurfacing, which has a high risk of PIH.18 It is
dermis. The penetration depth with the lower-energy estimated that the risk of PIH may be correlated
level of this specific device may be in accordance with the extent of overlapping thermal injury zones.
with the depth using higher energy with other The extent of the overlapping thermal injury zones
fractional ablative CO2 lasers. In this study, with the seems to be related to the density and fluence setting
lower-fluence 10 mJ of the Deep FX mode corre- of a fractional laser. Hantash and colleagues10 found
sponding to a depth of 1 mm, it was possible to that higher fluence achieved greater thermal lesion
achieve significant clinical efficacy, as previously depth and width and resulted in greater lesion
reported. It was hypothesized that penetration as dimensions, which is likely to enhance the degree of
deep as 2 mm into the deep reticular dermis with overlapping thermal injury zones. When we applied
CO2 FS treatment at higher energy may not result in the higher density or fluence, the severity and
greater efficacy for treating acne scars. duration of the PIH was more significant. However,
we could not compare the effect of higher density
We also compared the efficacy of CO2 FS treatment and fluence on the characteristics of PIH. Because in
with different densities and found that there was no our study, there was lack of a same control group.
statistically significant difference between the lower- To avoid PIH, the use of lower densities and fluences
density 10% and higher-density 20%. The results of is of particular importance. Delayed hypopigmen-
our study were compatible with the previous report by tation, which has been reported with traditional
Kono and colleagues18 indicating therapeutic effects ablative CO2 resurfacing, was not observed in our
of 1,550-nm nonablative FP laser treatment in skin patients after CO2 AFR treatments, but an extended
rejuvenation. It was considered from their study that, follow-up period is essential, because the delayed
when the fractional laser beam creates a dense pattern pigment abnormality usually develops as late as
of epidermal and dermal MTZs, the untreated tissues 6 months to 1 year postoperatively.19
that surround the MTZs serve as a reservoir for
thermal healing. Using higher density, the quantity of Improvement in acne scars was significantly greater
the undamaged tissues decreased, which was likely to at the 3-month follow-up than at 1 month, which
result in no greater efficacy in scar improvement. was in accordance with previous reports.6,12 Several
studies have indicated that FP-induced heat shock
Adverse effects such as pain, edema, crusting, and protein (HSP) expression and new formation of
PIH were found to be more evident or persisted for collagen and elastic fibers lasted for 3–6 months or
longer periods in patients treated with higher den- even longer, which was in accordance with clinical
sities or higher fluences, as found in a previous observation of long-term biologic effects.20,21
study.18 PIH is one of the most troubling adverse Expression of HSPs such as HSP70 and HSP47 plays
effects of laser irradiation when treating Asian an important role in wound healing responses, which
patients. We observed that both sides of the faces in lead to collagen remodeling and formation. It was
all 20 subjects had PIH that had almost resolved estimated that 3 months or longer may be an
within 3 months. The majority of patients received appropriate treatment interval. If the interval is
laser irradiation in the summer and early autumn, short, such as 1–2 months, the wound healing
when the sun is most intense, which may be responses of the last treatment session may not
responsible for the high rate of PIH observed. The produce the extreme effect, and several postoperative
safety indexes such as sebum excretion rate, trans- 3. Nanni CA, Alster TS. Complications of carbon dioxide laser
resurfacing. an evaluation of 500 patients. Dermatol Surg
epidermal water loss, and the melanin–erythema 1998;24:315–20.
index may not completely recover.22 4. Manstein D, Herron GS, Sink RK, Tanner H, et al. Fractional
photothermolysis: a new concept for cutaneous remodelling using
microscopic patterns of thermal injury. Lasers Surg Med
Acne scars were graded using the ECCA grading scale
2004;34:426–38.
at baseline and at follow-up visits.9 The ECCA
5. Laubach HJ, Tannous Z, Anderson RR, Manstein D. Skin
grading scale is a tool designed to help dermatologists responses to fractional photothermolysis. Lasers Surg Med
assess the severity of acne scars and in standardizing 2006;38:142–9.
discussions about the treatment of scars.9 The 6. Chapas AM, Brightman L, Sukal S, Hale E, et al. Successful
treatment of acneiform scarring with CO2 ablative fractional
advantage of the ECCA grading system is that it could resurfacing. Lasers Surg Med 2008;40:381–6.
reflect the overall facial atrophic acne scar conditions
7. Walgrave SE, Ortiz AE, MacFalls HT, Elkeeb L, et al. Evaluation
with both qualitative and quantitative grading scale, of a novel fractional resurfacing device for treatment of acne
but it cannot reflect the efficacy of each independent scarring. Lasers Surg Med 2009;41:122–7.
scar improvement without the true pre-/post-scar 8. Cho SB, Lee SJ, Kang JM, Kim YK, et al. The efficacy and safety
of 10,600-nm carbon dioxide fractional laser for acne scars in
depth measured, which is a limitation of our study. Asian patients. Dermatol Surg 2009;35:1955–61.
pigmentary changes. 16. Alster TS, Tanzi EL, Lazarus M. The use of fractional
photothermolysis in the treatment of atrophic acne scars.
Dermatol Surg 2007;33:295–9.
References 17. Farkas JP, Richardson JA, Brown SA, Ticker B, et al. TUNEL
assay to characterize acute histopathological injury following
1. Alster TS, West TB. Resurfacing of atrophic facial acne scars with treatment with the active and deep FX fractional short-pulse CO2
a high-energy, pulsed carbon dioxide laser. Dermatol Surg devices. Aesthet Surg J 2010;30:603–13.
1996;22:151–5.
18. Kono T, Chan HH, Groff WF, Sakurai H, et al. Prospective direct
2. Tay YK, Kwok C. Minimally ablative erbium: YAG laser comparison study of fractional resurfacing using different fluences
resurfacing of facial atrophic acne scars in Asian skin: a pilot and densities for skin rejuvenation in Asians. Lasers Surg Med
study. Dermatol Surg 2008;34:681–5. 2007;39:311–14.
19. Metelitsa AI, Alster TS. Fractionated laser skin resurfacing 22. Oh BH, Hwang YJ, Lee YW, Choe YB, et al. Skin characteristics
treatment complications: a review. Dermatol Surg 2010;36:299– after fractional photothermolysis. Ann Dermatol 2011;23:448–
306. 54.
20. Walia S, Alster TS. Prolonged clinical and histologic effects from
CO2 laser resurfacing of atrophic acne scars. Dermatol Surg
1999;25:926–30.
Address correspondence and reprint requests to: Shan-
21. Xu XG, Luo YJ, Wu Y, Chen JZ, et al. Immunohistological Shan Li, MD, PhD, Department of Dermatology and
evaluation of skin responses after treatment using a fractional
Venereology, First Hospital of Jilin University, 130000
ultrapulse carbon dioxide laser on back skin. Dermatol Surg
2011;37:1141–9.
Changchun, Jilin, China, or e-mail: shansalee@gmail.com