Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2 (2014) 64-78
Abstract: The aim of this research was to develop the first basic wind speed map for Oman. Hourly
mean wind speed records from 40 metrological stations were used in the calculation. The period of
continuous records ranged from 4–37 years. The maximum monthly hourly mean and the maxima
annual hourly mean wind speed data were analysed using the Gumbel and Gringorten methods. Both
methods gave close results in determining basic wind speeds, with the Gumbel method giving slightly
higher values. Due to a lack of long-term records in some regions of Oman, basic wind speeds were
extrapolated for some stations with only short-term records, which were defined as those with only 4–
8 years of continuous records; in these cases, monthly maxima were used to predict the long-term
basic wind speeds. Accordingly, a basic wind speed map was developed for a 50-year return period.
This map was based on basic wind speeds calculated from actual annual maxima records of 29
stations with at least 9 continuous years of records as well as predicted annual maxima wind speeds
for 11 short-term record stations. The basic wind speed values ranged from 16 meters/second (m/s) to
31 m/s. The basic wind speed map developed in this research is recommended for use as a guide for
structural design in Oman.
Keywords: Oman, Basic wind speed, Basic wind speed map, Weather stations.
אא
אKKאKאK
אאאKא אא Wא
K 37 4 א א Kא א 40 א
אאאאאאאאאא
Gumbelאא אKGringorten Gumbel
א א א א א א K
Eא א א 8 4 Fאא א אא א א
א 50אKא א אא
אאאאאאEאא9אF29א
KL 31L 16אאאK 11א אא
Kאאאאאאא
.א،אא،אא،Wא
65
A Basic Wind Speed for Oman
66
A.S. Alnuaimi, M.A. Mohsin and K.H. Al-Riyami
more stable trend with limited threshold during the last two decades. Wind load must be
sensitivity, which is in contrast with the rapidly taken into consideration during the structural
fluctuating estimates obtained from the peaks design of high-rise buildings, chimneys,
over threshold methods. transmission towers, and so on, requiring basic
Abohemda and Alshebani (2010) used wind speed values. The basic wind speed is
Gumble’s method to predict basic wind speed determined according to the climatic condition
values for Libya for a 50-year return period from of each region. Before this research, the hourly
the data of 22 stations. Lakshmana et al. (2009) mean wind speed data collected from 55
studied the wind speed data from 70 metrological stations had not been utilized in
metrological centres in India and calculated the development of a basic wind speed map for
basic wind speeds using Gumbel’s approach. Al Oman and, as of this article’s publication, no
Maawali et al. (2008) studied wind data from 10 local unified code or written regulations are
weather stations in Oman. They calculated the available for the design of high-rise buildings.
basic wind speed using the three-second gust at The need for a basic wind speed map that covers
the locations of 10 stations using the Gumbel different regions of the country has become
and Gringorten methods. They found that both evident. The aim of this research was to develop
methods yielded similar results. Dorvlo (2002) a basic wind speed map which can be used as a
used the Weibull distribution to model wind code guideline or regulation for structural
speeds at four locations in Oman. The scale and design in Oman.
shape parameters were estimated using
Pearson’s chi-squared test, the method of 1.3 Gumbel Verus Gringorten Method
moments, and the regression method. It was Gumbel (1958) developed an easily usable
observed that the estimates using the chi- methodology for fitting recorded monthly or
squared test gave the best overall fit to the annual wind speeds. The ASCE (1991) stated
distribution of the wind data. Choi and that the Gumbel extreme-value procedure is
Tanurdjaja (2002) studied extreme wind well accepted by other investigators, including
estimates in Singapore using Gumbel’s method (Simiu et al. 1998). The Gringorten (1963)
and Cook’s method of independent storms. method is considered a simple modification of
They concluded that the independent storm Gumbel’s extreme-value procedure. The only
method and Gumbel’s method both gave quite difference between Gumbel and Gringorten’s
similar results. Kasperski (2002) developed a methods is in the calculation of the probability
wind speed map for Germany based on a of non-exceedance (p). The procedure of
refined extreme value analysis using high gust calculating the basic wind speed is as follows:
wind speeds. He divided the country into four
basic wind speed zones ranging from 22.5 Step 1: Data are ranked in ascending order (1, 2,
meters/second (m/s) to 32.5 m/s. Akosy et al. 3,.., m,) where m is the largest value. The total
(2004) used the wavelet approach to generate number of readings is called N (ie. number of
hourly mean wind speed data using normal and years).
Weibull probability distribution functions. They
concluded that the wavelet approach can be Step 2: The probability of non-exceedance (p) is
used as an alternate to existing generation determined according to
methods. Sahin (2003) developed an hourly
mean wind speed exceedance map for Turkey Gumbel: = (1)
using the Gumbel-Lieblein BLUE method. In
this research, the Gumbel and Gringorten .
Gringorten: = (2)
methods were used for the analysis of hourly .
mean wind speed records.
Step 3: Reduced variant, y is calculated as
1.2 Problem Statement and Motivation
Due to the recent extensive development of = −ln (− ) (3)
major cities in Oman, the trend toward building
higher and lighter structures has emerged only i = record identification number.
67
A Basic Wind Speed for Oman
Step 4: The data are plotted against the reduced Type I (FT1) extreme value distribution,
variant, y, and a line of best fit is drawn, usually respectively.
by means of linear regression. Therefore, if the A comparison between the results given by
best fitting line y = ax + u, then u = the mode of both methods was made. A relationship
distribution = the intercept of the line and a = between the monthly maximum and the annual
the slope of the line (scale factor for x). maxima records was developed and used for
predictions of the annual maxima basic wind
Step 5: For different values of the return period,
speeds from the monthly maximum hourly
Eqn. 4 can be used to calculate the basic wind
mean wind speed of the 11 short-term stations.
speed,
Finally, a basic wind speed map for Oman was
developed based on actual records of annual
= + ln (4) maxima and predicted annual maxima stations
where R = return periods in years (eg. 50, 100, records.
etc.) and Vb = basic wind speed in m/s.
3. Data Analysis and Results
2. Methodology
Table 2 shows that the data used from the
short- and long-term stations (40 stations with
The basic information about Oman’s 55
6,736 records) are consistent, with very few
weather stations is given in Table 1. More than
records considered as outliers or extreme
8,200 records of monthly maximum hourly
outliers based on box plot analysis. The extreme
mean wind speed were obtained from the
outliers have been excluded from the analysis of
Directorate General of Civil Aviation and
basic wind speed calculations. The two worst
Meteorology in Oman.
cases were 1.8% and 1.3% at Muscat
Descriptive statistics along with box plot
International Airport and the town of Saiq,
graphs were developed for each station to
respectively. Figure 2 shows typical monthly
ensure the homogeneity and independence of
maximum hourly mean wind speed data for
raw data, and to exclude extreme outliers. The
Saiq from 1988–2013 based on a box plot
records were divided into three types: long
analysis. The monthly records ranged from
term, short term and not considered. Long term
5.564–21.896 m/s. This range is distributed into
means stations that have continuous records for
three areas to the left and right of the median,
at least nine years (29 stations); short term
with each area representing 1.5 of interquartile
means stations that have continuous records of
ranges (IQR). Four records were excluded
at least four years and less than nine years (11
because they were considered extreme outliers.
stations), and not considered (15 stations) means
The equations for line of best fit and basic wind
records are not included in the analysis due to
speed for the 40 stations are given in Table 3 and
discontinuity of the records (less than four
were calculated using the Gumbel and
continuous years of records are required to be
Gringorten methods for a 50-year return period
classified as not considered).
based on the monthly maximum hourly mean
The monthly maximum and the annual
wind speed. It is clear that in all cases, Gumbel’s
maxima of the hourly mean wind speed records
method is conservative in predicting slightly
of the 29 long term stations as well as the
larger values of basic wind speeds. The
monthly maximum hourly mean wind speed
maximum and minimum differences between
records of the 11 short term stations were used
the two method values were 2.97% and 0.31%,
in the analysis using Gumbel’s and Gringorten’s
respectively.
methods. The wind speed for each station was
Table 4 shows the equations for line of best fit
plotted against a reduced variate by the method
and basic wind speed values for the 29 long-
of order statistics (ascending order), and a
term stations using the Gumbel and Gringorten
straight line of best fit was drawn. The intercept
methods for a 50-year return period based on
and slope of these lines give the mode, u, and
the annual maxima of the monthly maximum
slope, a, of the fitted curve to the Fisher-Tippet
68
A.S. Alnuaimi, M.A. Mohsin and K.H. Al-Riyami
Table 1. Stations’ years of records and elevations (names of stations are as provided by Directorate
General of Civil Aviation and Meteorology).
Elevation above mean see
Station Years of records Record type
level (m)
69
A Basic Wind Speed for Oman
Table 2. Outliers and extreme outliers of wind speed data for long- and short-term stations.
1 Adam 120 5 1
2 Adam Airport 89 none none
3 Al Amrat 45 1 none
4 Al Mudhaibi 39 none none
5 Bahla 185 none none
6 Bidiyah 44 none 1
7 Buraimi 288 2 1
8 Diba 153 1 none
9 Duqum 115 3 none
10 Duqum new 58 none none
11 Fahud 178 4 none
12 Ibra 182 1 none
13 Ibri 139 none none
14 Jabal Nus 59 1 none
15 Jabal Shams 118 5 none
16 Joba 123 none none
17 Khasab Airport 105 none none
18 Khasab Port 246 2 none
19 Majis 365 5 1
20 Marmul 261 4 none
70
A.S. Alnuaimi, M.A. Mohsin and K.H. Al-Riyami
21 Masirah 335 5 3
22 Mina Salalah 182 6 1
23 Mina Sa bouy 1 124 1 none
24 Muscat Airport 442 15 8
25 Nizwa 174 2 none
26 Qairoon 168 4 none
27 Qalhat 166 1 none
28 Qaranalam 93 1 none
29 Qumaira 37 1 none
30 Ras Al Haad 93 none 2
31 Rustaq 184 7 2
32 Saiq 311 2 4
33 Saiq new 111 3 2
34 Salalah 335 13 1
35 Samail 187 5 1
36 Sunaynah 50 1 none
37 Sur 331 2 none
38 Suwaiq 45 1 none
39 Thumrait 336 none none
40 Yalooni 120 3 none
71
A Basic Wind Speed for Oman
hourly mean wind speed. Again, Gumbel’s 4. Basic Wind Speed Map
method predicted slightly larger values for basic
wind speed. The maximum and minimum The basic wind speed values contained in
differences between the two method values Table 6 were used to develop a basic wind speed
were 7.58% and 1.85%, respectively. Gumbel’s map of Oman using the largest reading in each
method was considered for further assessment nearby groups of values as shown in Fig. 3. As
and a comparison between the annual maxima expected, the coastal regions of Oman recorded
and the monthly maximum basic wind speeds of basic wind speed values higher than the interior
the 29 long-term stations. regions due to the presence of the Al Hajer
Due to a lack of long-term records in some Mountains and the reduction of wind speed
regions of Oman, the monthly maximum basic over the land. This is more pronounced in the
wind speed from the short-term stations was Musandam Region in Oman’s far north where
used to predict the long-term basic wind speed the basic wind speed dropped from 21
in those areas using Eqn. 5. meters/second (m/s) in Diba to 16 m/s in
Khasab. The basic wind speed values ranged
Vb(annual) = 0.76 + 1.21Vb(monthly) (5) from 16 m/s in Khasab, which is surrounded by
tall mountains, to 31 m/s in Masirah, which
R2 = 0.665 borders the Indian Ocean.
It is assumed that the basic wind speed at any
where, location in the country will fall within the range
Vb(monthly) = basic wind speed based on monthly of 16–31 m/s. This implies that for areas in the
maximum hourly-mean (m/s). interior,, basic wind speeds that do not exactly
fit in any given value(Fig. 3) should be assigned
Vb (annual) = predicted annual basic wind speed to the nearest higher level value due to
(m/s). similarity in topography and the absence of
wind barriers such as mountains.
In the coefficient of correlation for Eqn. 5, R2 It is worth mentioning that this research has
(0.665) shows an acceptable degree of developed basic wind speeds based on hourly-
correlation. Furthermore, analysis of variance mean raw data which is in line with the BS6399-
(ANOVA) for Eqn. 5 resulted in a satisfactory 2 procedure, superseding the previous method
hypothesis with P value = 0.000 for the given F- of CP3: Chapter 5-Part 2, which used the three-
value (53.59) as shown in Table 5. Therefore, second gust which as is (Al Maawali et al. 2008).
Equation 5 can be used as a conversion factor in
the 11 short-term stations.
5. Conclusion and Recommendations
Table 6 shows the 50-year return period for
predicted basic wind speed of the 29 long-term
5.1 Conclusion
stations based on actual annual maxima of the
Hourly mean wind speed records were
monthly maximum hourly-mean wind speed as
obtained from 55 metrological stations in Oman,
well as for the 11 short-term stations using Eqn.
and 40 stations with at least four continuous
5.Return periods for 100 years or more
years of records were used in the calculation of
(implying a low-risk level) may have to be
basic wind speeds. The monthly maximum and
extrapolated for exceptionally important
the annual maxima of the hourly mean were
structures, such as nuclear power reactors and
used in the analysis using Gumbel and
satellite communication towers. Extrapolations
Gringorten’s methods. It was found that
of basic wind speed to higher return periods of
Gumbel’s method predicted slightly larger
more than 50 years for ultimate limit state
values of basic wind speed than Gringorten’s.
design have not been carried out in this research
The maximum and minimum differences
due to the limitation of historical records, which
between the two method values were 2.97 and
are generally less than 37 years old.
0.31%, respectively, in the case of monthly
maximum hourly mean and 7.58 and 1.85%,
72
A.S. Alnuaimi, M.A. Mohsin and K.H. Al-Riyami
Table 3. Linear best-fit equations for the 40 stations (monthly maximum hourly-mean).
73
A Basic Wind Speed for Oman
Table 4. Linear best-fit equations for the 29 long-term stations (annual maxima of the monthly
maximum hourly-mean).
Gringorten Gumbel Gringorten %
Station Gumbel Method
Method Method Method difference
Adam y = 1.715x + 11.59 y = 1.595x + 11.63 18.30 17.87 2.40
Bahla y = 0.848x + 9.460 y = 0.748x + 9.483 12.78 12.41 2.97
Buraimi y = 1.201x + 11.38 y = 1.092x + 11.41 16.08 15.68 2.53
Diba y = 1.624x + 12.19 y = 1.421x + 12.24 18.54 17.80 4.18
Duqum y = 3.512x + 13.74 y = 2.981x + 13.88 27.48 25.54 7.58
Fahud y = 1.413x + 15.79 y = 1.289x + 15.82 21.32 20.86 2.18
Ibra y = 1.325x + 10.46 y = 1.180x + 10.49 15.64 15.11 3.56
Ibri y = 1.542x + 12.89 y = 1.331x + 12.94 18.92 18.15 4.27
Jabal Shams y = 2.967x + 18.12 y = 2.513x + 18.24 29.73 28.07 5.90
Joba y = 0.918x + 14.63 y = 0.780x + 14.66 18.22 17.71 2.88
Khasab Airport y = 0.644x + 9.708 y = 0.541x + 9.735 12.23 11.85 3.17
Khasab Port y = 0.904x + 12.29 y = 0.825x + 12.30 15.83 15.53 1.93
Majis y = 2.378x + 11.39 y = 2.190x + 11.43 20.69 20.00 3.48
Marmul y = 2.311x + 15.28 y = 2.124x + 15.32 24.32 23.63 2.93
Masirah y = 4.100x + 15.05 y = 3.789x + 15.11 31.09 29.93 3.86
Mina Salalah y = 2.567x + 12. y = 2.310x + 12.07 22.06 21.11 4.53
Mina Sabouy 1 y = 1.345x + 10.16 y = 1.160x + 10 15.42 14.74 4.64
Muscat Airport y = 4.555x + 12.08 y = 4.268x + 12.13 29.90 28.83 3.72
Nizwa y = 1.091x + 12.17 y = 0.959x + 12.20 16.44 15.95 3.05
Qairoon y = 2.209x + 13.98 y = 1.925x + 14.05 22.62 21.58 4.82
Qalhat y = 1.614x + 15.22 y = 1.420x + 15.27 21.53 20.83 3.40
Ras Al Haad y = 2.898x + 14.62 y = 2.486x + 14.70 25.96 24.43 6.27
Rustaq y = 1.672x + 9.103 y = 1.503x + 9.134 15.64 15.01 4.20
Saiq y = 2.509x + 13.54 y = 2.286x + 13.59 23.36 22.53 3.65
Salalah y = 1.909x + 13.12 y = 1.743x + 13.16 20.59 19.98 3.05
Samail y = 2.083x + 9.659 y = 1.866x + 9.701 17.81 17.00 4.75
Sur y = 1.848x + 17.59 y = 1.685x + 17.63 24.82 24.22 2.47
Thumrait y = 1.741x + 17.17 y = 1.627x + 17.18 23.98 23.54 1.85
Yalooni y = 1x + 12.69 y = 0.867x + 12.72 16.60 16.11 3.04
74
A.S. Alnuaimi, M.A. Mohsin and K.H. Al-Riyami
Table 6. Basic wind speed for 50-year return period based on annual maxima of monthly maximum
hourly-mean.
75
A Basic Wind Speed for Oman
76
A.S. Alnuaimi, M.A. Mohsin and K.H. Al-Riyami
respectively, in the case of annual maxima. Due Determination of basic wind speed for building
to the lack of long-term records in some regions structures in Oman. Proceedings of
of Oman, the monthly maximum basic wind International Conference on Construction and
speed from the short-term stations was used to Building Technology, ICCBT’08, F(22):235-244.
predict long-term basic wind speed. American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE)
Accordingly, a basic wind speed map was (1991), Guidelines for electrical transmission
developed for the 50-year return period using line structural loadings, 1801 Alexander Bell
the basic wind speed from 29 stations with at Drive, Reston, Virginia 20191, USA.
least nine continuous years of records based on An Y, Pandy M (2005), A comparison of
actual annual maxima as well as predicted methods of extreme wind speed estimation.
annual maxima basic wind speed for 11 stations Journal Wind Engineering and Industrial
with 4–8 continuous years of records. The basic Aerodynamics, Elsevier 93:535–545.
wind speed values ranged from 16 m/s to BS 6399-2: (1997), Loading for buildings part 2.
31m/s. Code of Practice for wind loads. British
Standard Institution, London.
5.2 Recommendations
Choi E, Tanurdjaja A (2002), Extreme wind
• The basic wind speed map developed in this
studies in Singapore, an area with mixed
research is recommended for use as a guide
weather system. Journal Wind Engineering
for structural design in Oman.
and Industrial Aerodynamics, Elsevier
• For future research, results from different 90:1611–1630.
Gulf Cooperative Council (GCC) countries Dorvlo ASS (2002), Estimating wind speed
and Yemen are compiled and a regional distribution. Energy Conversion and
basic wind speed map is developed. Management. Pergamon 43:311–2318.
• Further analysis of future wind speed data Dyrbye, C, Hansen SO (1999), Wind loads on
need to be carried out every five years. structures. John Wiley & Sons.
• Special analysis of recent odd readings, such Gibbs T, Browne H, Rocheford B (1981), Code
as those that resulted from Cyclones Gonu of practice for wind loads for Structural
and Phet, should be made if such events Design. BNS-CP28, sponsored by the
recur frequently enough to establish Organization of American States, the National
records. Council for Science and Technology and the
Barbados Association of Professional
Acknowledgment Engineers.
Grigoriu M (1984), Estimation of extreme winds
The authors are indebted to the Directorate from short records. Journal of Structural
General of Civil Aviation and Meteorology Engineering ASCE 110(7):1467-1484.
under the Ministry of Transportation and Gringorten I (1963), A plotting rule for extreme
Telecommunication for the provision of the data probability paper. Journal of Geophysical
used in this research. The data included station Research 68(3):813-814.
names, locations and hourly mean wind speeds. Gumbel EJ (1958), Statistics of extreme,
The concerned staff’s cooperation is gratefully Colombia University press. New York, NYC,
acknowledged and appreciated. USA.
Harris RI (1996), Gumbel re-visited – a new
References look at extreme value statistics applied to
wind speeds. Journal Wind Engineering and
Abohemda MB, Al Shebani MM (2010), Wind load Industrial Aerodynamics 59: 1-22.
characteristics in Libya, World Academy of Holmes J (2001), Wind loading of structures,
Science, Engineering and Technology 63:240-243. SPON press.
Akosy H, Toprak ZF, Aytek A, Unal NE (2004), Kasperski M (2002), A new wind zone map of
Stochastic generation of hourly mean wind Germany.Journal Wind Engineering and
speed data. Renewable Energy, Elsevier Industrial Aerodynamics 90:1271–1287.
29:2111-2131. Kishor CM, Delahay J (2004), Guide to the use of
Al Maawli SS, Majid TA, Yahya AS (2008), the wind load provisions of ASCE 7-02, 140,
77
A Basic Wind Speed for Oman
78