Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Available online at
ScienceDirect
www.sciencedirect.com
GENERAL REVIEW
a
Service de chirurgie plastique et reconstructrice, centre des brûlés, CHRU Lapeyronie, 325, avenue du
doyen-Gaston-Giraud, 34295 Montpellier cedex 5, France
b
Service de chirurgie plastique et craniofaciale pédiatrique, CHRU Lapeyronie, 34295 Montpellier, France
c
Unité de plaies et cicatrisation, CHRU Lapeyronie, 34295 Montpellier, France
d
Service de chirurgie plastique, reconstructrice et esthétique, CHRU de Rennes, 35000 Rennes, France
e
Service de chirurgie plastique, reconstructrice et esthétique, CHRU de Picardie, 80080 Amiens, France
f
Service de chirurgie plastique, reconstructrice et esthétique, CHRU de Rangueil, 31400 Toulouse, France
KEYWORDS Summary
Leeches; Introduction. — Medicinal leeches have been part of the therapeutic armamenterium of plastic
Flaps; surgeons for more than 50 years. While their use in hand surgery is a matter of course, their use in
Biotherapy; salvage of flaps with venous congestion remains facultative depending on teams.
Review Materials and methods. — We conducted a systematic review of leech therapy for flap salvage
between 1960 and 2015, analyzing 121 articles and subsequently taking into consideration 41
studies. In parallel, we collected data from 43 patients for whom leach therapy had recently
been applied in treatment of venous insufficiency in pedicled or free flaps after revision surgery
had failed to improve flap vascularization, or in cases where flap revision was not appropriate.
The data collected pertained to relevant indications, treatment procedure, efficacy, adjuvant
therapies, side effects and complications.
Results. — For this indication, the success rate of leech therapy ranged from 65 to 85% (83.7% in
our series) according to the situations encountered. Optimal frequency of application ranged
from 2 to 8 hours, while average overall duration ranged from 4 to 10 days. The number of
* Corresponding author at: Service de chirurgie plastique et reconstructrice, centre des brûlés, CHRU Lapeyronie, 325, avenue du doyen-
Gaston-Giraud, 34295 Montpellier cedex 5, France.
E-mail address: drchristianherlin@gmail.com (C. Herlin).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.anplas.2016.06.004
0294-1260/# 2016 Elsevier Masson SAS. All rights reserved.
Please cite this article in press as: Herlin C, et al. Leech therapy in flap salvage: Systematic review and practical recommendations. Ann Chir
Plast Esthet (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.anplas.2016.06.004
+ Models
ANNPLA-1232; No. of Pages 13
2 C. Herlin et al.
leeches to be applied can be determined depending on volume of the flap. In 50% of the cases
reported in the literature, the patients required transfusion. Antibiotic prophylaxis against
Aeromonas is highly advisable. A ciprofloxacin and trimethoprim-sulfametoxazole combination
currently appears as the most relevant prophylactic antibiotherapy.
Conclusion. — Hirudotherapy is a reliable treatment in cases of patent venous insufficiency of
pedicled or free flaps (or when revision surgery is not recommended). Even though the relevant
literature is highly heterogeneous, we have attempted to put forward a specific protocol bringing
together dosage, delivery route, frequency of administration and appropriate prophylactic
antibiotherapy. An algorithm for treatment and management of venous congestion and a
practical information sheet have been placed at the disposal of plastic surgery teams.
# 2016 Elsevier Masson SAS. All rights reserved.
Résumé
MOTS CLÉS Introduction. — Les sangsues font partie de l’arsenal thérapeutique des chirurgiens-plasticiens
Sangsues ; depuis plus de 50 ans. Si leur utilisation est largement protocolisée en chirurgie de la main, leur
Lambeaux ; utilisation pour le sauvetage des lambeaux en congestion veineuse reste une affaire d’école.
Biothérapie ; Matériels et méthodes. — Nous avons analysé 121 articles entre 1960 et 2015 puis retenu 41
Revue études. Parallèlement, nous avons colligé les données de 43 patients récemment traités. Les
données colligées portaient sur les indications, le mode d’administration, l’efficacité du
traitement, les traitements adjuvants, les effets indésirables et enfin, les complications.
Résultats. — Le taux d’efficacité des sangsues dans cette indication était de 65 à 85 % en
fonction des situations (83,7 % dans notre série). La fréquence d’application idéale, adaptée
individuellement, se situait entre 2 et 8 heures et la durée totale moyenne entre 4 et 10 jours. Le
nombre de sangsues à appliquer peut être défini en fonction de la taille et du volume du lambeau.
Les patients ont nécessité une transfusion dans 50 % des cas de la littérature analysée. Une
antibioprophylaxie dirigée contre Aeromonas est fortement conseillée. L’association trimétho-
prime—sulfamétoxazole et ciprofloxacine nous paraît la plus pertinente à l’heure actuelle.
Conclusion. — L’hirudothérapie est un traitement fiable en cas d’insuffisance veineuse patente
des lambeaux pédiculés ou libres lorsqu’une reprise chirurgicale n’est pas opportune. Malgré une
littérature hétérogène, nous nous sommes efforcés de proposer un protocole précis englobant la
posologie, le mode d’administration, le rythme et l’antibioprophylaxie adaptée. Un algorithme
de prise en charge des congestions veineuses et une fiche d’utilisation sont également mis à
disposition pour les équipes de chirurgie plastique.
# 2016 Elsevier Masson SAS. Tous droits réservés.
Introduction History
Notwithstanding substantial progress in reconstructive sur- While the first written evidence of hirudotherapy, in Egypt, is
gery, particularly microsurgery, venous congestion in trans- more than 3500 years old, actual proof of its therapeutic, by
planted or reimplanted tissues has remained a frequent and the Greek, Roman and Indian civilizations, dates back to
challenging complication [1,2]. While partial venous obstruc- approximately 2000 years ago [7]. Leeches were used mainly
tion can be physiologically offset by neovascularization over a for treatment of phlebitis and hemorrhoids, and only spor-
period of 3 to 10 days [3,4], total obstruction by lumen collapse adically for bloodletting. In France, François-Joseph-Victor
or venous thrombosis leads in 3 hours to severe microcircula- Broussais, an early 19th-century ‘‘Napoleonic’’ physician
tory lesions and in 8 to 12 hours to irreversible microcircula- practicing at the military hospital of Val-de-Grâce, who
tory lesions culminating first in the ‘‘no reflow phenomenon’’ was considered as one of the most sanguinary physician in
inside the flap, and subsequently in tissulary necrosis [5]. history, intensively developed the use of leeches in treat-
While early revision surgery is most often of use, it does not ment of inflammatory diseases and as a method of ‘‘hyper-
always suffice to reestablish physiological circulation in the stimulation’’ of the digestive organs. As a result of his
distressed tissue. In such cases, the use of leeches, otherwise efforts, by 1830, France had become the world leader in
known as hirudotherapy, is a practical technique with which all the field, with a hundred million leeches being put to work
plastic surgeons are acquainted. Along with larvotherapy, it is year in and year out [7]. Over the following decades, how-
one of the rare biotherapies currently employing complex ever, a prolonged cholera epidemic and application of the
living organisms. The most commonly used species in today’s asepsis techniques advocated by Louis Pasteur prevailed over
medicine is Hirudo medicinalis, which has been privileged due the once-fashionable application of leeches.
to its efficacy. Currently, only the company called Ricarim- The 20th century was marked by a crisscrossing of contra-
pex1, located in the Arcachon basin, breeds leeches on an dictory tendencies. On the one hand, in 1974, reimburse-
industrial scale for medicinal purposes [6]. ment of leech treatment by French social security was
Please cite this article in press as: Herlin C, et al. Leech therapy in flap salvage: Systematic review and practical recommendations. Ann Chir
Plast Esthet (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.anplas.2016.06.004
+ Models
ANNPLA-1232; No. of Pages 13
Please cite this article in press as: Herlin C, et al. Leech therapy in flap salvage: Systematic review and practical recommendations. Ann Chir
Plast Esthet (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.anplas.2016.06.004
+ Models
ANNPLA-1232; No. of Pages 13
4 C. Herlin et al.
analyzed in view of drawing up and defending proposed these ‘‘mixed’’ cases, leech use is presumed deleterious
guidelines on good practice. [31]. It should be noted that these cases most often occur
during the late stages of venous insufficiency, when capillary
Indications for hirudotherapy in flap surgery: venous pressure impedes arterial blood influx and thereby
venous insufficiency leads to arterial thrombosis just prior to circulatory arrest
(no reflow phenomenon).
Venous insufficiency often appears during first postoperative Finally, it is more difficult and of major importance to
hours as gradually aggravated congestion. Flaps with cuta- clearly distinguish the pathological congestive venous
neous skin island present accelerated capillary refill insufficiency from the rheological physiological adaptation
(< 2 seconds), and in a few hours, dark pink coloration phenomena undergone by some free or pedicled perforator
becomes purpuric purple (Fig. 2). Quite frequently, dressings flaps, of which the specificity consists in its exhibiting rapid
are stained and the edges of the flap bleed spontaneously of a pinkish coloration during the first 6 to 12 hours following flap
dark red blood. harvesting (Fig. 3). In this particular case, the phenomenon is
It is important to clearly identify early complete venous rapidly reversible and is not associated with other signs
insufficiencies, which affect a major proportion of free flaps (congestion, bleeding of the edges). In the absence of quan-
or propeller perforator flaps with skeletonized pedicle; in tifiable monitoring (doppler, laser doppler, oxymetry, micro-
these cases, hirudotherapy is not considered as first-line dialysis. . .), the needlestick may occasionally be useful to see
treatment. Early venous insufficiencies should be painstak- the blood color to which it leads.
ingly distinguished from late venous insufficiencies, which
are often distally located, and preferentially affect local Local ‘‘random’’ flaps
‘‘random’’ flaps or local-regional pedicled flaps; in these With random flaps, distal venous insufficiency is a frequent
cases, the flap is initially pale and the congestion occurs occurrence; it is often ‘‘mixed’’ and difficult to improve by
somewhat belatedly (often at H + 12). surgical revision. However, prior to the introduction of
While mixed (arterial and venous) circulatory insufficien- leeches, release of some points of tension on the edges or
cies present similar colorations, no congestion ensues, and at the bottom of the flap should be considered as an option,
the needlestick causes an effusion of blood that is less as should be the return of the flap to its initial position
profuse and blackish than in venous insufficiency alone. In through a two-step procedure.
Please cite this article in press as: Herlin C, et al. Leech therapy in flap salvage: Systematic review and practical recommendations. Ann Chir
Plast Esthet (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.anplas.2016.06.004
+ Models
ANNPLA-1232; No. of Pages 13
treatment of choice, and it is aimed at decompressing or where thrombolysis usually failed, monitoring of reperfusion
‘‘untwisting’’ the pedicle by returning the flap to its initial through the bite orifices. . .
position. And then, within 48 hours, the decongested flap is
returned to an appropriate position. This delayed procedure Contraindications
should always be considered as a possible option for large and/
or voluminous flaps, that is to say indications for which the Generally recognized contraindications include immunosup-
efficacy of leeches is limited. In our experience, hirudother- pression, advanced arterial insufficiency, hemophilia or any
apy has been used in 86% of the relevant cases (37/43) for other severe pathology affecting coagulation, hemopathies,
pedicled flaps. sepsis, hepatobiliary insufficiency, cachexis, refusal of trans-
fusion due to religious beliefs or psychological instability
Free flaps [38,39].
Aside from replantation of fingers or small organs such as
auricle parts of the ear [33], leeches are not meant to Introduction of the leeches
supplant a venous micro-anastomosis [34]. Leeches rather
tend to be used in flap microsurgery if surgical revision has Once the patient has been informed of the utilization of
failed to improve local condition or is medically or techni- leeches, of the concomitant treatments and of the hemor-
cally impossible. With regard to free cutaneous flaps, parti- rhagic and infectious risks incurred, he should ideally be
cularly perforator flaps, leeches can be used in the event of placed in a position allowing the leeches to be kept on a
distal insufficiency, when the venous perforasome does not horizontal plane during the period of ingestion (Fig. 4). The
coincide with the arterial perforasome. Distal insufficiency leeches are ordered from a pharmacy, where they are made
often appears belatedly, and on voluminous flaps. Leeches to fast for a hundred days prior to use, thereby rendering
should then be applied rapidly at the affected area, and the them as hungry as possible. They are transported and con-
required number is greater than is the case for pedicled flaps. served until time of use in a plastic pot filled with pH neutral
In our experience, hirudotherapy has been used in 14% (6/43) mineral water at a temperature of 4 to 18 8C (Fig. 5). Placed
of our patients for free flaps. on the surface, the most mobile leeches are often the most
We also perform hirudotherapy during the period between effective, and should be selected. Before introduction of the
the decision to undertake revision surgery and the onset of leeches, it is necessary to eliminate all traces of antiseptics
the actual operation. Indeed, in the event of insufficiency on the flap by cleansing it with lukewarm serum. In our
necessitating revision of anastomosis, the time elapsed experience, the leeches are manipulated with a gloved hand;
between decision and act is often greater than the time that said, some authors have proposed use of a 5 mL syringe
between two monitoring sessions. In such cases hirudother- designed to force the leech to bite at a precise place [38];
apy may be considered as a logical option, especially inas- this is of special interest for intraoral flaps. Faeces collectors
much as it helps, when the operating theater is inaccessible, can also be used in large flaps. As a general rule, we build a
to limit the formation of distal thromboses and to avoid ‘‘cage’’ around the insufficient flap; it consists in com-
highly pejoratively termed circulatory collapse. The leeches presses rolled around the edges of the monitoring window
are removed in the operating theater just before surgery. (Fig. 4). A compress, a hydrocolloid or a punctured trans-
This technique may be associated with the protocols for in parent adherent film can enhance precision of application.
situ thrombolysis applied by a number of teams [35—37], More specifically, the compress-containing cage facilitates
which in our opinion present multiple advantages: no vessel blood harvest and helps to avoid soiling the dressing in its
trauma caused by manipulation, no catheterization, disse- entirety. The compresses are regularly changed. At times,
mination of the anticoagulants on the thrombotic areas
Please cite this article in press as: Herlin C, et al. Leech therapy in flap salvage: Systematic review and practical recommendations. Ann Chir
Plast Esthet (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.anplas.2016.06.004
+ Models
ANNPLA-1232; No. of Pages 13
6 C. Herlin et al.
needle puncture can attract recalcitrant leeches by eliciting gases on the flap may be helpful, in our experience blood
a drop of blood. On the other hand, a leech may refuse color and congestion should suffice. Moreover, once conges-
attachment if it is not hungry or in the event of advanced tion has occurred, skin color only gradually lightens, which
arterial insufficiency [40]. Some authors have described the means that it is not a good criterion during the first hours.
deleterious effects of benzodiazepines and certain systemi-
cally given analgesics on the vitality and effectiveness of the How can the number of leeches to be introduced
leeches [38]. In any case, following a suction period that can during each cycle be estimated?
last from 15 minutes to 2 hours, the leech will detach itself
spontaneously. It must then be sacrificed in acetone or in 70% While we know that leeches are able to anticoagulate 100 mL
alcohol and incinerated; any reuse is strictly forbidden. of blood in vitro [29], there exists no consensus on the
number of leeches to be introduced in cases of pedicled
At what pace should leeches be introduced? flap or free flap insufficiency, whatever may be the composi-
tion and volume of the latter, the characteristics of the
As leeches help to improve blood flow 6 to 8 hours after their receiving site, the degree of congestion, the time elapsed
introduction, one may consider an equivalent time interval prior to therapy, or the overall background. Indeed, our
to be optimally logical. However, some trams have proposed review of the literature highlights the considerable hetero-
pronouncedly shorter time intervals (2 h) [28]. In our opi- geneity of protocols from one team to the other; in equiva-
nion, standardization of these intervals is to be avoided, the lent situations, therapy may involve less than 10 or more than
reason being that the degree of venous overload is not 350 leeches per flap [19,28,34]. In their study, Nguyen et al.
quantifiable without implementing sophisticated methods [34] reported greater consumption of leeches in partial than
such as oxymetry or microdialysis of which the effectiveness in full-scale flap salvage operations; this disparity is likely to
in our context has yet to be demonstrated. The clinician and be explained by the variable degree of venous insufficiency
the nurse must adapt to each situation by proposing first a severity at the outset. As for salvage failures, they entail less
‘‘trial’’ interval of 2 to 6 hours according to congestion consumption; that is because therapy is often discontinued
severity during the first 12 hours, and then a ‘‘maintenance’’ at an early stage and also because the circulatory collapse
interval of 4 to 8 hours according to congestion reduction and phenomenon reduces venous pressure and the quantity of
blood color during bleeding. While measurement of the blood blood evacuated. In cases of flap insufficiency in the distal
Figure 6 Venous overloading by venous thrombosis of a DIEP flap (a). As revision surgery was not effective, hirudotherapy was
undertaken (b). It permitted effective decongestion (c), but after treatment was discontinued on D5, the flap was completely
necrotized in 48 hours.
Please cite this article in press as: Herlin C, et al. Leech therapy in flap salvage: Systematic review and practical recommendations. Ann Chir
Plast Esthet (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.anplas.2016.06.004
+ Models
ANNPLA-1232; No. of Pages 13
region, one or two leeches are generally used during each the flap and the receiving site, which takes place, on the
cycle according to the size of the flap. As regards salvage in average, between the 3rd and the 8th day [3,4]. For Nguyen
cases of total congestion, it is estimated that a leech can be et al., in their series of 39 flaps, 7 days was the maximum
put effectively to work on 10 cm2 of congested flap. How- [34]. As is the case with regard to optimal time lapse
ever, the sizeable volume of reconstructions such as the DIEP between two cycles, and keeping in mind the risk of blood
flap often renders them difficult to improve by hirudotherapy depletion, we are convinced that duration of treatment
(Fig. 6). It nonetheless seems logical to increase the number should not be standardized. Daily photographic assessment,
of leeches according to flap thickness. More precisely, dou- always at the same time, of the ‘‘grey’’ or shadowed area, of
bling the number of leeches for every 2 additional centi- the cutaneous recoloration time lapse, of congestion and,
meters of flap thickness is from our standpoint both finally, of the color of the blood flowing from the bites should
reasonable and representative of the different studies help to determine the timing of treatment discontinuation
described in the literature [34,41,42]. We have personally [19], which we carry out gradually over one day, dividing by
experienced the advanced deterioration of cutaneous flap two the number of leeches present prior to cessation. In our
due to leech misuse, as advanced ischemia was conjoined experience, average length of medicinal leech treatment is
with action of the proteases delivered by leech saliva. 6.3 days (4 to 10), and only exceptionally exceeds 7 days.
As concerns duration of leech treatment, the data in the Numerous animal studies have facilitated identification of
literature are once again highly variable, with length of time the physiological role of leeches in flaps with venous over-
from one to 22 days [28]. Theoretically, average duration of load. Through their actions, leech bites increase oxygen
treatment should correspond to neovascularization between concentration in the blood by reducing capillary venous
Figure 7 Overall postoperative congestion of a peroneal artery perforator propeller flap (c) in spite of a reassuring early
postoperative aspect (b). Introduction of leeches over 5 days yielded complete flap salvage (d).
Please cite this article in press as: Herlin C, et al. Leech therapy in flap salvage: Systematic review and practical recommendations. Ann Chir
Plast Esthet (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.anplas.2016.06.004
+ Models
ANNPLA-1232; No. of Pages 13
8 C. Herlin et al.
Adverse effects
Blood loss
Blood loss during leech use is constant. In their meta-ana-
lysis, Whitaker et al. [28] reported a transfusion rate of 50%.
The more voluminous the flap and the more pronounced its
insufficiency, the more it becomes necessary to endeavor to
avoid rapid deglobulizing, which would render the insuffi-
ciency of the flap more acute [34]. If possible, the blood
count should be monitored prior to therapy, and once ther-
apy starts, it should be monitored either every day or every
two days according to the number of leeches introduced by
day. Transfusion is indicated when the hemoglobin level is
lower than 8 gdl 1 and/or in the event of poor clinical
tolerance. In the event of non-desired and prolonged bleed-
ing emanating from the bites, hemostatic dressings [45] or
suture [46] may be needed. In clinical practice, with use of
one leech every 2 hours, average blood loss will approximate
1 gdl 1/24 h, necessitating blood transfusion when therapy
duration exceeds 5 days, and/or when the patient presents
with an initial hemoglobin level lower than 12 gdl 1. Blood
transfusion is not a routine procedure, which is why leech use
and bleeding management must be considered taking into
account the effect on risk-benefit balance is comparison to
possible partial or total flap necrosis.
Please cite this article in press as: Herlin C, et al. Leech therapy in flap salvage: Systematic review and practical recommendations. Ann Chir
Plast Esthet (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.anplas.2016.06.004
+ Models
ANNPLA-1232; No. of Pages 13
Complications
Infection
Infection is frequently due to symbiotic bacteria residing in
the digestive tract of the leech; Aeromonas hydrophila is the
species most commonly responsible for localized or general-
ized infections. The other bacteria belong to the Aeromonas,
Serratia, Vibrio, Pseudomonas genus. . . In their meta-ana-
lysis, Whitaker et al. reported an infection rate following
hirudotherapy of 14%, whatever the mode of utilization [28].
Figure 10 Major venous congestion of a sural neuro-cutaneous
Infectious manifestations include lymphangitis, dermo-
flap having necessitated intensive therapy (two leeches every
hyperdermitis, abscesses, severe sepsis and gas necrotizing
2 hours for 48 hours, and then two leeches every 4 hours for 5
myositis due to synergistic infections [47]. The infections can
days). In spite of the treatment, flap salvage was incomplete and
appear 24 hours after the leeches are introduced or up until a
necessitated another means of covering (free anterolateral
month later [38]. In the event of infection, the flap salvage
thigh flap).
rate declines drastically (88 to 37% for Whitaker et al. [28],
80 to 30% for De Chalain et al. [48]).
Prophylactic antibiotic treatment is recommended by
most of the authors and should be prolonged up to 24 hours
esthetic cost must be taken into account when the flap after the therapy ends [41,49]. The most widely reported
site is located in a zone of esthetic interest. For improve- molecules in the literature are third-generation cephalos-
ment in severe cases, recommendations include topical porins (3GC) [29,49,50], fluoroquinolones [51] and the tri-
application of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs or methoprim-sulfametoxazole association [38,52]. Some
Figure 11 Algorithm proposed for management of postoperative venous congestion of pedicled flaps leading to hirudotherapy.
Please cite this article in press as: Herlin C, et al. Leech therapy in flap salvage: Systematic review and practical recommendations. Ann Chir
Plast Esthet (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.anplas.2016.06.004
+ Models
ANNPLA-1232; No. of Pages 13
10 C. Herlin et al.
Figure 12 Algorithm proposed for management of postoperative venous congestion of free flaps leading to hirudotherapy.
authors have suggested a ‘‘feeding’’ treatment through the free and pedicled flaps suffering from venous congestion
ingestion of antibiotics directed against bacteria in a com- (Figs. 10—12). That said, while it is possible to apply quanti-
mensal relationship with leeches; this treatment could yield tative protocols for venous congestion in finger [58] or ear
in situ eradication of the potentially pathogenic bacteria [59] replantation, it is appreciably more complex to apply a
species found in the digestive tract of the leeches [53]. Given single protocol to all situations of venous insufficiency in
the elevated risk of inducing resistance in these species, we flaps. We are nonetheless putting forward an algorithm for
consider this proposal to be dangerous. Cases of resistance to treatment of venous congestion in pedicled flaps (Fig. 11)
fluoroquinolones have been repeatedly reported [50,54,55]. and free flaps (Fig. 12) in which leeches take on a clearly
Nor does the use of 3GC appear indicated, given the exis- determined role. Indeed, for cases where the decision to use
tence in Aeromonas of an inducible cephalosporinase. To leeches has just been taken, we are proposing a common
conclude, we are convinced that a ciprofloxacin and tri- protocol (Annexe A) providing guidance for practitioners and
methoprime-sulfametoxazole association (Ciflox1 a poster to be displayed in nursing care rooms (Fig. 13). The
1
500 mg 2/day and Bactrim Forte 1cp 2/day) could be number of leeches can be initially modulated according to
a satisfactory alternative. degree of congestion and time elapsed prior to treatment. As
for frequency of leech introduction, even though it has to be
Less frequently encountered complications modulated, mainly by monitoring treatment effectiveness, it
Cases of cutaneous reactions such as lymphangitis, persis- provides a way of successfully coping in difficult situations.
tent painful adenopathies and even febricula have been Indeed, a strict monitoring protocol not only facilitates rapid
reported [38]. Some patients, 3% according to Whitaker action that limits ischemia, but also allows for optimal
et al. [28], develop an inopportune stress reaction during adaptation of the number of leeches to be employed per
and after treatment. Some cases of pain, vasovagal response cycle.
and protracted hypotension have also been reported. Finally This review of the literature provides corroboration of our
and even more anecdotally, allergic and anaphylactic reac- experience concerning the importance of prophylactic anti-
tions have been noted [38,56,57]. biotic treatment. It seems to us that the ciprofloxacin and
trimethoprim-sulfametoxazole association is currently the
best compromise solution, given the increasing number of
Recommendations for use and therapy reported cases of resistance to fluoroquinolones. Screening
algorithms of resistances by a local pharmaceutical team seems logical,
especially insofar as it should help to avoid the appearance of
Notwithstanding the heterogeneity of the literature, we can multiple drug resistance in the years to come. Means of
confirm the essential role of leeches in the salvage of both packaging and astutely applied methods of introduction
Please cite this article in press as: Herlin C, et al. Leech therapy in flap salvage: Systematic review and practical recommendations. Ann Chir
Plast Esthet (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.anplas.2016.06.004
+ Models
ANNPLA-1232; No. of Pages 13
Figure 13 Leech application protocol proposed in cases of flap salvage printable in the form of a poster that can be used by
paramedical staff.
can increase treatment effectiveness, ensuring enhanced area and/or volume, can likewise benefit from this thera-
comfort for the patient and the health care team. peutic approach when venous supercharging is not feasible.
The last recommendation pertains to the prevention of
congestion, as it takes into account the evident interest of Disclosure of interest
double venous anastomoses and the supercharging of the
pedicled flaps [1,32,60—64].
The authors declare that they have no competing interest.
Conclusion
Hirudotherapy currently represents the only validated treat- Annexe A. Leech application protocol
ment of patent venous insufficiencies in pedicled or free proposed in cases of flap salvage
flaps when surgical revision is not a suitable option. Its
success rate in salvage attempts is close to that of well- Information & Accord du patient
conducted corrective operations. Even though today’s lit- Antibioprophylaxie
erature is highly heterogeneous, it has enabled us to propose (en accord avec l’écologie locale, du début jusqu’à 24h
a precisely formulated protocol including dosage, means of après la fin du traitement)
administration, frequency and pace of delivery and appro- Sulfamethoxazole 800mg + trimethoprime 160mg (Bac-
priate prophylactic antibiotic treatment. Monitoring and trim Forte): 1cp x 2
dose adjustment are essential to success. While the antic- ou Ciprofloxacine 500mg x 2
oagulant and decongestant effects of hirudotherapy in treat- ou Ceftriaxone 1g x 2 (deuxième ligne)
ment of distal insufficiency in pedicled flaps is well-known, in Positionner le patient, surface du lambeau vers le haut
this paper we have confirmed the hypothesis that free flaps, Confection d’une cage ou mise en place d’une interface
particularly perforator-based cutaneous flaps with a large trouée
Please cite this article in press as: Herlin C, et al. Leech therapy in flap salvage: Systematic review and practical recommendations. Ann Chir
Plast Esthet (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.anplas.2016.06.004
+ Models
ANNPLA-1232; No. of Pages 13
12 C. Herlin et al.
Détersion au sérum physiologique [16] Guneren E, Erolu L, Akba H, Uysal OA, Hokelek M, Erolu C. The
Choix des sangsues mobiles use of Hirudo medicinalis in nipple-areolar congestion. Ann
Manipulation avec des gants/pinces atraumatiques Plast Surg 2000;45:679—81.
Application sur les zones congestives d’une sangsue tous [17] Connor NP, Conforti ML, Heisey DM, Vanderby R, Kunz D, Hartig
GK. Augmented blood removal after medicinal leech feeding in
les 10cm2
congested tissue flaps. J Rehabil Res Dev 2002;39:505—12.
Doubler le nombre de sangsues si lambeau> 2cm [18] Dabb RW, Malone JM, Leverett LC. The use of medicinal leeches
d’épaisseur in the salvage of flaps with venous congestion. Ann Plast Surg
Maximum 4 sangsues en même temps 1992;29:250—6.
Temps d’indigestion entre 25 et 45min (changer au [19] Chepeha DB, Nussenbaum B, Bradford CR, Teknos TN. Leech
besoin) therapy for patients with surgically unsalvageable venous ob-
Renouveler le traitement toutes les 2h si ischémie struction after revascularized free tissue transfer. Arch Otolar-
veineuse ou toutes les 4 heures si congestion simple yngol Head Neck Surg 2002;128:955—60.
Surveillance horaire du lambeau (TRC, congeston, cou- [20] Ribuffo D, Chiummariello S, Cigna E, Scuderi N. Salvage of a
free flap after late total thrombosis of the flap and revascu-
leur du lambeau, couleur du sang)
larisation. Scand J Plast Reconstruct Surg Hand Surg 2004;38:
Bilan clinique à H12 +/- Modification de la posologie ou
50—2.
de la fréquence [21] Brody GA, Maloney WJ, Hentz VR. Digit replantation applying
Numération globulaire tous les jours du traitement the leech Hirudo medicinalis. Clin Orthop Relat Res 1989;245:
Transfusion si Hb<8gdl-1 et/ou si mauvaise tolérance 133—7.
Arret du traitement si amélioration entre J5 et J7 [22] Tuncali D, Terzioglu A, Cigsar B, Aslan G. The value of medical
leeches in the treatment of class IIC ring avulsion injuries:
References report of 2 cases. J Hand Surg 2004;29:943—6.
[23] Cho BH, Ahn HB. Microsurgical replantation of a partial ear,
with leech therapy. Ann Plast Surg 1999;43:427—9.
[1] Riot S, Herlin C, Mojallal A, Garrido I, Bertheuil N, Filleron T, et al. [24] Momeni A, Parrett BM, Kuri M. Using an unconventional perfu-
A systematic review and meta-analysis of double venous anasto- sion pattern in ear replantation-arterialization of the venous
mosis in free flaps. Plast Reconstruct Surg 2015;136:1299—311. system. Microsurgery 2014;34:657—61.
[2] Bui DT, Cordeiro PG, Hu QY, Disa JJ, Pusic A, Mehrara BJ. Free [25] Walton RL, Beahm EK, Brown RE, et al. Microsurgical replanta-
flap reexploration: indications, treatment, and outcomes in tion of the lip: a multi-institutional experience. Plast Recon-
1193 free flaps. Plast Reconstruct Surg 2007;119:2092—100. struct Surg 1998;102:358—68.
[3] Capla JM, Ceradini DJ, Tepper OM, et al. Skin graft vasculari- [26] Frodel Jr JL, Barth P, Wagner J. Salvage of partial facial soft
zation involves precisely regulated regression and replacement tissue avulsions with medicinal leeches. Otolaryngol Head Neck
of endothelial cells through both angiogenesis and vasculogen- Surg 2004;131:934—9.
esis. Plast Reconstruct Surg 2006;117:836—44. [27] Pantuck AJ, Lobis MR, Ciocca R, Weiss RE. Penile replantation
[4] Lindenblatt N, Calcagni M, Contaldo C, Menger MD, Giovanoli P, using the leech Hirudo medicinalis. Urology 1996;48:953—6.
Vollmar B. A new model for studying the revascularization of [28] Whitaker IS, Oboumarzouk O, Rozen WM, et al. The efficacy of
skin grafts in vivo: the role of angiogenesis. Plast Reconstruct medicinal leeches in plastic and reconstructive surgery: a
Surg 2008;122:1669—80. systematic review of 277 reported clinical cases. Microsurgery
[5] May Jr JW, Chait LA, O’Brien BM, Hurley JV. The no-reflow 2012;32:240—50.
phenomenon in experimental free flaps. Plast Reconstruct Surg [29] Houschyar KS, Momeni A, Maan ZN, et al. Medical leech therapy
1978;61:256—67. in plastic reconstructive surgery. Wien Med Wochenschr
[6] cf page email: Ricarimplex; 2016, http://sangsue-medicinale. 2015;165:419—25.
com. [30] Haycraft JB. On the action of secretion obtained from the
[7] Rolleston JD. François-Joseph-Victor Broussais 1772 to 1832: his medicinal leech on coagulation of the blood. Proc R Soc Lond
life and doctrines. Proc R Soc Med 1959;22:405. 1884;36:478.
[8] Derganc M, Zdravic F. Venous congestion of flaps treated by [31] Schlaudraff KU, Bezzola T, Montandon D, Pepper MS, Pittet B.
application of leeches. Br J Plast Surg 1960;13:187—92. Mixed arterio-venous insufficiency in random skin flaps in the
[9] Baudet J, LeMaire JM, Guimberteau JC. Ten free groin flaps. rat: is the application of medicinal leeches beneficial? J Surg
Plast Reconstruct Surg 1976;57:577—95. Res 2008;150:85—91.
[10] Foucher G, Norris RW. Distal and very distal digital replanta- [32] Herlin C, Sinna R, Hamoui M, Canovas F, Captier G, Chaput B.
tions. Br J Plast Surg 1992;45:199—203. Distal lower extremity coverage by distally based sural flaps:
[11] Rados C. Beyond bloodletting: FDA gives leeches a medical Methods to increase their vascular reliability. Ann Chir Plast
makeover. FDA consumer 2004;38:9. Esthet 2015.
[12] Azzopardi EA, Whitaker IS, Rozen WM, Naderi N, Kon M. Chemical [33] Broussais FJV. Francois Joseph Victor Broussais(1772— 1838).
and mechanical alternatives to leech therapy: a systematic review System of physiological medicine. JAMA 1969;209:1523.
and critical appraisal. J Reconstruct Microsurg 2011;27:481—6. [34] Nguyen MQ, Crosby MA, Skoracki RJ, Hanasono MM. Outcomes
[13] Gideroglu K, Yildirim S, Akan M, Akoz T. Immediate use of of flap salvage with medicinal leech therapy. Microsurgery
medicinal leeches to salvage venous congested reverse pedi- 2012;32:351—7.
cled neurocutaneous flaps. Scand J Plast Reconstruct Surg Hand [35] Anavekar NS, Lim E, Johnston A, Findlay M, Hunter-Smith DJ.
Surg 2003;37:277—82. Minimally invasive late free flap salvage: indications, efficacy
[14] Utley DS, Koch RJ, Goode RL. The failing flap in facial plastic and implications for reconstructive microsurgeons. J Plast
and reconstructive surgery: role of the medicinal leech. Laryn- Reconstr Aesthet Surg 2011;64:1517—20.
goscope 1998;108:1129—235. [36] Tamplen M, Blackwell K, Jahan R, Nabili V. Salvage of free-flaps
[15] Gross MP, Apesos J. The use of leeches for treatment of venous in vessel-depleted mandibular osteoradionecrosis cases using
congestion of the nipple following breast surgery. Aesthet Plast catheter-directed thrombolysis and angioplasty. J Reconstr
Surg 1992;16:343—8. Microsurg 2013;29:347—52.
Please cite this article in press as: Herlin C, et al. Leech therapy in flap salvage: Systematic review and practical recommendations. Ann Chir
Plast Esthet (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.anplas.2016.06.004
+ Models
ANNPLA-1232; No. of Pages 13
[37] Kirschner RE, Xu J, Fyfe B, Chang B, Bucky LP. Salvage of free leech therapy: is practice keeping pace with current research?
flaps after secondary venous ischemia by local delivery of Microsurgery 2009;29:619—25.
heparin. Ann Plast Surg 1999;42:521—7. [53] Litwinowicz A, Blaszkowska J. Preventing infective complica-
[38] Mumcuoglu KY. Recommendations for the use of leeches in tions following leech therapy: elimination of symbiotic Aero-
reconstructive plastic surgery. Evid Based Complement Alter- monas spp. from the intestine of Hirudo verbana using
nat Med 2014;205929. antibiotic feeding. Surg Infect 2014;15:757—62.
[39] Whitaker IS, Josty IC, Hawkins S, et al. Medicinal leeches and [54] Wilmer A, Slater K, Yip J, Carr N, Grant J. The role of leech
the microsurgeon: a four-year study, clinical series and risk water sampling in choice of prophylactic antibiotics in medical
benefit review. Microsurgery 2011;31:281—7. leech therapy. Microsurgery 2013;33:301—4.
[40] Irish JC, Gullane PJ, Mulholland S, Neligan PC. Medicinal [55] Patel KM, Svestka M, Sinkin J, Ruff PT. Ciprofloxacin-resistant
leech in head and neck reconstruction. J Otolaryngol 2000;29: Aeromonas hydrophila infection following leech therapy: a
232—327. case report and review of the literature. J Plast Reconstruct
[41] Elyassi AR, Terres J, Rowshan HH. Medicinal leech therapy on head Aesthet Surg 2013;66:e20—2.
and neck patients: a review of literature and proposed protocol. [56] Heldt TJ. Allergy to leeches. Henry Ford Hospital medical
Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol 2013;116:e167—72. bulletin 1961;9:498—519.
[42] Kashiwagi K, Hashimoto I, Abe Y, Kotsu K, Yamano M, Nakanishi [57] Telo W, Panciroli E. Clinical observations on two rare cases of
H. Quantitative analysis of hemodynamics of congested island local hypersensitivity to application of leeches. Policlinico
flaps under leech therapy. J Med Invest 2013;60:213—20. [Prat] 1954;61:1674—9.
[43] Grobe A, Michalsen A, Hanken H, Schmelzle R, Heiland M, [58] Buntic RF, Brooks D. Standardized protocol for artery-only
Blessmann M. Leech therapy in reconstructive maxillofacial fingertip replantation. J Hand Surg 2010;35:1491—6.
surgery. J Oral Maxillofacial Surgery 2012;70:221—7. [59] Momeni A, Liu X, Januszyk M, et al. Microsurgical ear replanta-
[44] Soucacos PN, Beris AE, Malizos KN, Xenakis TA, Georgoulis A. tion-is venous repair necessary? A systematic review. Micro-
Successful treatment of venous congestion in free skin flaps surgery 2015.
using medical leeches. Microsurgery 1994;15:496—501. [60] Enajat M, Rozen WM, Whitaker IS, Smit JM, Acosta R. A single
[45] Fedor PJ. Novel use of a hemostatic dressing in the manage- center comparison of one versus two venous anastomoses in 564
ment of a bleeding leech bite: a case report and review of the consecutive DIEP flaps: investigating the effect on venous
literature. Wilderness Environ Med 2012;23:44—8. congestion and flap survival. Microsurgery 2010;30:185—91.
[46] Zengin S, Yarbil P, Kilic H, Al B. Prolonged bleeding due to a [61] Deleyiannis FW, Badeau AM, Leem TH, Song JI. Supercharging
medicinal leech bite: another treatment method, primary and augmenting venous drainage of an anterolateral thigh free
suture. BMJ Case Rep 2012;2. flap: options and indications. Plast Reconstruct Surg Glob Open
[47] Mackay DR, Manders EK, Saggers GC, Banducci DR, Prinsloo J, 2014;2(4):e135.
Klugman K. Aeromonas species isolated from medicinal leeches. [62] Bekara F, Herlin C, Somda S, de Runz A, Grolleau JL, Chaput B.
Ann Plast Surg 1999;42(3):275—9 [PubMed PMID: 10096618]. Free versus perforator-pedicled propeller flaps in lower ex-
[48] de Chalain TM. Exploring the use of the medicinal leech: a tremity reconstruction: What is the safest coverage? A meta-
clinical risk-benefit analysis. J Reconstr Microsurg 1996;12(3): analysis. Microsurgery 2016. http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/
165—72 [PubMed PMID: 8726336]. micr.30047 [Epub ahead of print] Review [PubMed PMID:
[49] Bourdais L, Heusse JL, Aillet S, Schoentgen C, Watier E. Leech- 27018650].
borne infection on a TRAM flap: a case report. Ann Chir Plast [63] Bekara F, Herlin C, Mojallal A, et al. A systematic review and
Esthet 2010;55:71—3. meta-analysis of perforator-pedicled propeller flaps in lower
[50] van Alphen NA, Gonzalez A, McKenna MC, McKenna TK, Carlsen extremity defects: identification of risk factors for complica-
BT, Moran SL. Ciprofloxacin-resistant Aeromonas infection fol- tions. Plast Reconstr Surg 2016;137(1):314—31. http://
lowing leech therapy for digit replantation: report of 2 cases. J dx.doi.org/10.1097/PRS. 0000000000001891 [PubMed PMID:
Hand Surg 2014;39:499—502. 26371391].
[51] Whitaker IS, Izadi D, Oliver DW, Monteath G, Butler PE. Hirudo [64] Chaput B, Vergez S, Somda S, et al. Comparison of single and
Medicinalis and the plastic surgeon. Br J Plastic Surg double venous anastomoses in head and neck oncologic recon-
2004;57:348—53. struction using free flaps: a meta-analysis. Plast Reconstr Surg
[52] Whitaker IS, Kamya C, Azzopardi EA, Graf J, Kon M, Line- 2016. http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/PRS. 0000000000002087 [In
aweaver WC. Preventing infective complications following Press].
Please cite this article in press as: Herlin C, et al. Leech therapy in flap salvage: Systematic review and practical recommendations. Ann Chir
Plast Esthet (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.anplas.2016.06.004