Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mcgrath, 2008 PDF
Mcgrath, 2008 PDF
I. INTRODUCTION
Fig. 1. Topology of an N-level phase leg of a flying capacitor converter.
ULTILEVEL converters offer significant advantages
M for high-power applications by using series-connected
semiconductor devices to operate at higher voltages than
the rating of a single device, while also producing switched
waveforms with a lower harmonic content than their two-level
counterparts [1], [2]. Of the various multilevel converter
topologies that have been proposed, the multicell or flying
capacitor topology (Fig. 1) is emerging as a particularly at-
tractive solution [3]–[14] because it is transformerless and has
redundant phase leg states that allow the switching stresses
to be equally distributed between the semiconductor switches
[3]–[5]. However, the switch blocking voltages must still be
kept below the switch ratings, which, for the N-level con-
verter illustrated in Fig. 1, requires a target device blocking
voltage of . This in turn requires that the th
floating capacitor is charged to a voltage of ,
for . It is known that this voltage profile
evolves naturally when the cell switches ( to ) are
controlled with interleaved pulses of (approximately) equal
duty cycle, phase shifted by [5]–[9], as is typically
Fig. 2. Phase-shifted carrier (PSC) PWM for a five-level multicell converter.
achieved using a modulation strategy such as phase-shifted car-
rier pulsewidth modulation (PSCPWM) (Fig. 2). This voltage
balance process is commonly referred to as natural balancing
Manuscript received July 16, 2007; revised September 24, 2007. This work
was supported by the Australian Research Council for funding this research
[5]–[8].
under project DP0666130 and project DP0666176. Recommended for publica- The static characteristics of the capacitor natural voltage bal-
tion by Associate Editor W. Bin. ancing processes are well documented [5]–[8], but their dy-
The authors are with the Department of ECSE, Monash University, namic response to dc bus variations can vary significantly de-
Clayton, Vic., Australia 3800 (e-mail: brendan.mcgrath@eng.monash.edu.au;
brendan_mcgrath@ieee.org; grahame.holmes@eng.monash.edu.au). pending on parameters such as loading state, the modulation
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TPEL.2007.915175 pulse ratio, filter design, etc. For a complete design process, it
0885-8993/$25.00 © 2008 IEEE
544 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER ELECTRONICS, VOL. 23, NO. 2, MARCH 2008
(6)
(2) 1A simple R-L load is used in (2) for ease of development. More general load
forms will be considered later in the paper.
MCGRATH AND HOLMES: ANALYTICAL MODELLING OF VOLTAGE BALANCE DYNAMICS FOR A FLYING CAPACITOR MULTILEVEL CONVERTER 545
(14)
Substituting (12), (13), and (14) into (2) and solving for the
steady-state ac sinusoidal solution at gives
(15)
Next, (12) and (15) are substituted back into (1) to develop a
forcing function at that drives the capacitor voltage deriva-
Fig. 4. Carrier arrangements and resulting cell gate signals for PSCPWM. (a) tives. Since both (12) and (15) are sinusoidal functions with the
Leading carrier arrangement. (b) Lagging carrier arrangement. same frequency, their product in (1) will result in a dc compo-
nent and a double harmonic frequency component. However,
since only the low frequency average response of the capacitor
voltages is of interest, the double frequency term can be ne-
glected. This results in the first-order state-space equation given
(7) by (16) with the capacitor voltages as the system states, which
can be readily rewritten as (17)
where
(8)
(9)
(10) (16)
(11a)
(11b)
with
(18e)
(18f)
.. .. ..
. . . (18g)
(19a)
(19b)
TABLE I load resistance and inductance. Fig. 7 shows that for the con-
FIVE LEVEL CONVERTER—CIRCUIT PARAMETERS verter studied, there is clearly an optimal loading point from a
dynamic capacitor voltage balancing perspective, at a load resis-
tance of approximately 450 . For a smaller load resistance such
as 20 with a correspondingly higher load current, all three
root locus poles are very close to the axis, and this would
be expected to correspond to a slow and oscillatory voltage bal-
ancing response (in fact this is very close to one of the condi-
tions that was experimentally investigated, as shown in Figs. 11
and 12 in Section VI of this paper, and the response is clearly
slow and substantially underdamped). As the load resistance in-
creases and the load current reduces, the system damping in-
creases as the poles move away from the axis. Furthermore,
the real axis pole moves away from the axis more slowly than
the complex poles, so that the system damping rapidly increases
with reducing load current. However, and more importantly, the
recognition that voltage balance damping can decrease substan-
tially with increasing load current could be of great significance
in a real system design.
Fig. 8 shows how changes in load inductance can also af-
fect the dynamic voltage balance, with a significant reduction in
damping as the load inductance increases. This result was also
confirmed experimentally, and can be seen by comparing the re-
sponses shown in Figs. 11 and 12 to those in Figs. 15 and 16.
The above discussion is by no means exhaustive in terms of
Fig. 7. Root-locus as a function of load resistance. exploring converter voltage balancing. However, it illustrates
how the analytical model presented here allows powerful linear
control analysis strategies such as root-locus to be used to in-
vestigate flying capacitor voltage balance performance under a
wide variety of load and operating conditions.
Fig. 9. Step response of the five-level converter to a 50-V dc link step: Lagging Fig. 11. Step response of the five-level converter to a 50-V dc link step with the
carrier arrangement, Load inductance = 19 mH. frequency dependence of the load resistance included: lagging carrier arrange-
ment, Load inductance = 19 mH.
Fig. 12. Step response of the five-level converter to a 50-V dc link step with the
frequency dependence of the load resistance included: leading carrier arrange-
ment, Load inductance = 19 mH.
Fig. 10. Measured load resistance versus frequency.
Fig. 15. Step response of the five-level converter to a 50-V dc link step: lagging
carrier arrangement, Load inductance = 4 mH.
Fig. 16. Step response of the five-level converter to a 50-V dc link step: leading
carrier arrangement, Load inductance = 4 mH.
The validity of the linearized model was verified by com- [14] Y. Liang and C. O. Nwankpa, “A power-line conditioner based on
paring it against a five-level experimental converter, and ex- flying capacitor multilevel voltage-source converter with phase-shift
SPWM,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 36, no. 4, pp. 965–971, Jul./Aug.
tremely good correlation was achieved once the frequency de- 2000.
pendence of the load resistance was taken into account in the [15] B. P. McGrath and D. G. Holmes, “An analytical technique for the
analytical model. The model was also used to explore the im- determination of spectral components of multilevel carrier based PWM
pact of the PWM pattern on the converter balancing dynamics, methods,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 49, no. 4, pp. 847–857, Aug.
2002.
and it was found that a leading carrier arrangement between [16] D. G. Holmes and T. A. Lipo, Pulse Width Modulation for Power Con-
the switching cells is preferable, since it mitigates the non-min- verters. New York: IEEE Press, 2003.
imum phase response characteristic of the converter. This re-
sult was predicted theoretically and confirmed experimentally
for both under-damped and over-damped systems. Brendan Peter McGrath (M’99) received the
B.Sc. degree in applied mathematics and physics,
the B.E. degree in electrical and computer systems
REFERENCES engineering, and the Ph.D. degree in pulsewidth
[1] J.-S. Lai and F. Z. Peng, “Multilevel converters—A new breed of power modulation theory for multilevel converters from
converters,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 32, no. 3, pp. 509–517, May/ Monash University, Clayton, Vic., Australia, in 1997
and 2003, respectively.
Jun. 1996.
He spent two years with Creative Power Tech-
[2] J. Rodriguez, J. Lai, and F. Peng, “Multilevel inverters: A survey of
nologies, Melbourne, Australia, where he was part
topologies, controls and applications,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol.
of a development team working on auxiliary traction
49, no. 4, pp. 724–738, Aug. 2002. converter systems and precise utility instrumentation
[3] S. Bernet, D. Krug, S. Fazel, and K. Jalili, “Design and comparison of systems. In 2004, he was a Postdoctoral Researcher with the Laboratoire
4.16 kV neutral point clamped, flying capacitor and series connected d’Electrotechnique et d’Electronique Industrielle (LEEI), Toulouse, France,
H-bridge multi-level converters,” in Proc. IEEE Ind. Appl. Soc. (IAS) where he worked on the modulation of multicell converters. He has just recently
Annu. Meeting, 2005, vol. 1, pp. 121–128. joined the faculty at Monash University, after having spent two years at the Uni-
[4] T. Meynard, H. Foch, P. Thomas, J. Courault, R. Jakob, and M. versity of Newcastle, NSW, Australia. His principle research interests include
Nahrstaedt, “Multicell converters: Basic concepts and industry appli- the modulation and control of multilevel power converters and the application
cations,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 49, no. 5, pp. 955–964, Oct. of signal processing and control theory to power conversion systems.
2002. Dr. McGrath received the Douglas Lampard medal from Monash University
[5] T. Meynard, M. Fadel, and N. Aouda, “Modelling of multilevel con- for his Ph.D. dissertation in 2004. He is a member of the IEEE Power Elec-
verters,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 44, no. 3, pp. 356–364, Jun. tronics, Industrial Electronics, and Industry Applications Societies.
1997.
[6] X. Yuang, H. Stemmler, and I. Barbi, “Self-balancing of the clamping-
capacitor-voltages in the multilevel capacitor-clamping-inverter under
sub-harmonic PWM modulation,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. Donald Grahame Holmes (M’88–SM’03) received
16, no. 2, pp. 256–263, Mar. 2001. the B.S. degree and the M.S. degree in power
[7] R. Wilkinson, H. du Mouton, and T. Meynard, “Natural balance of mul- systems engineering from the University of Mel-
ticell converters: The two-cell case,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. bourne, Melbourne, Australia, in 1974 and 1979,
21, no. 6, pp. 1649–1657, Nov. 2006. respectively, and the Ph.D. degree in pulsewidth
[8] R. Wilkinson, H. du Mouton, and T. Meynard, “Natural balance of mul- modulation (PWM) theory for power electronic
ticell converters: The general case,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. converters from Monash University, Clayton, Vic.,
21, no. 6, pp. 1658–1666, Nov. 2006. Australia, in 1998.
[9] G. Gateau, M. Fadel, P. Maussion, R. Bensaid, and T. Meynard, “Multi- In 1984, he joined Monash University to work in
cell converters: Active control and observation of flying-capacitor volt- the area of power electronics, and he now heads the
ages,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 49, no. 5, pp. 998–1008, Oct. Power Electronics Research Group at this university.
2002. The present interests of this group include fundamental modulation theory and
[10] B. P. McGrath, T. A. Meynard, G. Gateau, and D. G. Holmes, “Optimal its application to the operation of energy conversion systems, current regula-
tors for drive systems and PWM rectifiers, active filter systems for quality of
modulation of flying capacitor and stacked multicell converters using
supply improvement, resonant converters, current-source inverters for drive sys-
a state machine encoder,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 22, no. 2,
tems, and multilevel converters. He has a strong commitment and interest in the
pp. 508–516, Mar. 2007. control and operation of electrical power converters and has made a significant
[11] J. Huang and K. A. Corzine, “Extended operation of flying capacitor contribution to the understanding of PWM theory through his publications and
multilevel inverters,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 21, no. 1, pp. has developed close ties with the international research community in the area.
140–147, Jan. 2006. He has published well over 100 papers at international conferences and in pro-
[12] C. Turpin, L. Deprez, F. Forest, F. Richardeau, and T. A. Meynard, fessional journals, and regularly reviews papers for all major IEEE transactions
“A ZVS imbricated cell multilevel inverter with auxiliary resonant in his area. He has recently co-authored a major reference textbook on PWM
commutated poles,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 17, no. 6, pp. theory (with T. Lipo of the University of Wisconsin-Madison) Pulse Width Mod-
874–882, Nov. 2002. ulation for Power Converters (New York: IEEE Press, 2003).
[13] X. Kou, K. A. Corzine, and Y. Familiant, “Full binary combination Dr. Holmes is an active member of the Industrial Power Converter and Indus-
schema for floating voltage source multilevel inverters,” IEEE Trans. trial Drive Committees of the Industrial Applications Society of the IEEE and
Power Electron., vol. 17, no. 6, pp. 891–897, Nov. 2002. is a member of the Adcom of the IEEE Power Electronics Society.