Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Post-Module Assignment
Section A: Analysis
Complete a SPECCTRE analysis and 5-forces analysis of the international airline business. Evaluate
the attractiveness of the segments of the business in which British Always operates
What are the main factors affecting the profit potential for British Airways? How and why do these
factors affect competitors in ways that are different (Positive or negative) from British Airways?
Using the SWOT analysis, summarise the current competitive position and potential of British
Airways.
State (a) What you believe ought to be the key objectives and performance measures for British
Airways for this period and (b) the reasons why you have selected these objectives and measures.
List the programme headings that make a cohesive strategy for achieving these objectives, explain
how you have derived these from preceding analyses.
2
Introduction
The airline industry was deeply affected by the recent global economic crisis which spurred many
customers to seek for better value for money, and continuous growing of internet online shopping
experience presented opportunistic choices than ever before. The war or insurgencies in oil
producing countries accelerated the oil prices, coupled with government tax increment as caused
much consolidation in airline industry.
These variables have caused collapse of many companies, some airline companies form merger
while some are completely absorbed by another airline. Companies are forced to revisit their
strategy, as customers are more discerning, can shop around for better prices, look for good quality
services at low price, surf online relentless for superb bargains and offers. The company that have
unique value innovation that could perform activities in a different way to competitors, that render
premium service at low price will survive the game.
This reading are in threefold, Firstly, I intend to analyse the internal and external environmental
forces affecting airline industry, how these factors affecting profit potential of British airways and
competitors in a way different from British airways. Secondly, to analysis strategy options available
for British airways for the period 2010 to 2013, the four set of strategy I considered most appropriate
and reasons for selecting these strategies. To list the main objectives and performance measures for
British airways and the reasons for selecting these, and to list programme headings that make
cohesive strategy for achieving these objective and explain how I have derived these from the
preceding analysis. Thirdly, to explain how to communicate these selected strategy to British airways
employees all over the world.
3
tax was £531 million, and group operating loss was £231 million. Passenger traffic accounted for 86
per cent of this revenue, while 7 per cent came from cargo and 7 per cent from other activities.
Ch ono tes,
io b fe
ci
om obal st
in pu , li
ec ra
an mi ta
n lic
So
op and phy
ic
le gra
gl ere
sty mo
e
D
x
Environmental
Competitors
la in
te m in
ns
gu ge
ca sto es
tio
re han
rie s
go er
cu ang
s
C
Ch
Re
s
er
gu
m
sto
la
to
Cu
r
y
Source: Adapted DIT MSC in supply chain management, course manual (2010/11)
4
SPECCTRE Analysis of airline industry
The following are the comprehensive lists of external environmental forces of SPECCTRE analysis
influencing airline industry:-
Perception of certain ethnicity Certain ethnicities are considered high travel risk due
due to Terrorism to 9/11, this impact on travelling.
Social Security issues due to High security measure have to be in-place to ensure
terrorism consumer confidence on travelling
There are high increases in family travel during student
Student holyday period holiday period, putting attractive holiday package to
boost revenue.
Price sensitivity among wider The unemployed adults are more price sensitive due
demography low disposable income.
Any change in government policy might have positive
Change of government policies or negative impact.
5
The global recession intensify the market as price
Continuous grow of no frill become order quantifier, increase number of no frill
operators operators in respond to economic situation, threat
market share of existing operators in this segment
Source: Adapted from (2010/2011) DIT MSC Supply Chain management, Strategy module manual.
6
Source: Adapted from (2010/2011) DIT MSC Supply Chain management, Strategy module manual.
If there is no law or regulation to prevent acquisition or merger of Boeing and Airbus, combined
synergy from such acquisition or merger might impact profit margin in the industry. Any increase in
7
flight maintenance parts supplied by Rolls-Royce etc, the extra cost will be past to airline carriers
which in essence will threat profit margin.
Threat of substitutes
The impact of threat pose by substitute is low in airline industry, the main substitutes to airplane are
high speed trains specially suitable for short-haul within region. The shipping liners will threat
profitability in long-haul transportation of goods. The usage of video conference, and VOIP software
among business executives reduced number of business travellers
Competitive rivalry
The airline industry have low profit margin which further intensify hyper-competition among
carriers, every carrier fight toothlessly to retain their part of the pie. The legacy airliners like BA,
Lufthansa etc find it difficult to compete on price with no-frill airliners like Ryanair etc. The
companies that remain profitable in the airline industry are those carriers that could create value
innovation, render reasonable service at lower price, and play the game slightly different than the
competitors.
8
Fig. 3 BCG Matrix
High
Question ? Stars
Market Growth
Low
Low Market Share High
Source: Adapted from (2010/2011) DIT MSC Supply Chain management, Strategy module manual.
The financial outlook of the airline industry is gradually changing because economy is returning to
normal, but the no-frill segment of the business remain more profitable especially on short-haul. Fig.
4 illustrate British airways premium segment life cycle as it decline as the result of low demand,
although the outlook of global economic is improving. The economic upturn will improve growth,
and a deployment of strategy extension to counter decline will return British airways to profitable
growth.
9
Fig. 4 British airways premium segment life cycle
Time
Source: Adapted from (2010/2011) DIT MSC Supply Chain management, Strategy module manual.
The main factors affecting the profit potential for British Airways
The airline industry is exposed to external environmental factors that inhibit profitable growth, those
forces affecting profit potential of British airways are:-
• Competitors Factors.
• Economic Factors.
• Bargaining power of buyers
• Cabin crew strike
• Regulations
10
Economic Factors
Currency variation significantly affect British airways operation due it global present, but currency
variations have little impact on profitability of budget airlines operating within euro zone. The
British airways saved 2.7 billion between 2004 and 2009 from fuel hedging; some of their
competitors might not benefit such huge money at this period. The economic recession present
significant opportunity for no-frill airlines, while cost decline in numbers of business travel. British
airways carried substantial dept that need refinance, of which their competitor might carry less or
negotiate better interest repayment.
Labour Union
The constant strike action by labour union significantly impact British airways profit due to the legal
cost accrued on court cases filed by cabin crew trade union and dissatisfied customers. This affects
competitors slightly different to British airways.
Regulations
Open-skies agreement between countries present opportunity to expand but competition remain
limited for British airways in certain international routes due to restriction on numbers of flights that
can operate, and regulation countries tend to favour the country flag carrier to other airline. The
ambition to expand routes to such country is limited.
11
The British Airways SWOT analysis
The SWOT analysis enables British airways to make strategic decisions by combined evaluation of
internal factors of strengths and weaknesses with the external factors of threats and opportunity.
Strengths Opportunities
Strong brand name Increase demand for flight within China.
Excellent customer service Expansion of civil aviation in India.
strong global market positioning Airline industry generates USD 408
network and alliances billion in global GDP.
diverse customer base Merger, alliances, and joint venture.
Innovative. Open Skies agreement.
Learning culture. Global economic recovery.
Sufficient liquidity. Acquire no-frill
Well trained and knowledgeable staffs.
Fuel-efficient aircrafts.
Weaknesses Threats
Heathrow has no spare runway. High Regulations.
Disconnected with employees. Cabin crew strikes.
Management team lost focus. Competitors.
Order and obey culture. Terrible weather conditions.
Poor decision making. Oil dependency and fuel price.
Annual loss 2009/10, £231m. Currency fluctuation.
Employees adamant to change. Act of terrorism.
High % of lost baggage. Economic recession.
Flight cancellation to small size. Customers bargaining power.
Interest rates variations.
Source: Adapted from (2010/2011) DIT MSC Supply Chain management, Strategy module manual.
12
British airways-weighted SWOT
Strengths Opportunities
Strong brand name 4 Increase demand for flight within 4
Excellent customer service 3 China.
strong global market positioning 1 Expansion of civil aviation in India. 4
network and alliances 2 Airline industry generates USD 408 3
diverse customer base 3 billion in global GDP.
Innovative. 4 Merger, alliances, and joint venture. 5
Learning culture. 4 Open Skies agreement. 4
Sufficient liquidity. 5 Global economic recovery. 3
Well trained and knowledgeable 3 Acquisition of no-frill carriers 3
staffs.
Fuel-efficient aircrafts. 4
Weaknesses Threats
Heathrow has no spare runway. 2 High Regulations. 3
Disconnected with employees. 3 Cabin crew strikes. 4
Management team lost focus. 3 Competitors. 4
Order and obey culture. 2 Terrible weather conditions. 2
Poor decision making. 4 Oil dependency and fuel price. 4
Annual loss 2009/10, £231m. 4 Currency fluctuation. 4
Employees adamant to change. 3 Act of terrorism. 1
High % of lost baggage. 2 Economic recession. 4
Flight cancellation to small size. 1 Customers bargaining power. 3
Interest rates variations. 2
Source: Adapted from (2010/2011) DIT MSC Supply Chain management, Strategy module manual.
The British airways is a strong brand, although the company report annual loss of £231m in 2009/10,
but enter the recession financially strong. To maintain British airways strong market position which
was under threat due to economic downturn, low demand in premium flight, and customer
bargaining power, strengths in fuel-efficient aircraft and superior customer services will improve
competitive position.
The company liquidity strengths could exploit possible opportunity in acquire low cost no-frill
airline to counter competitors route by route in the European market. Although the company high oil
dependency and variation in oil price create major threat but the continuous oil and currency hedging
minimise exposure to these risks. British airways potential strong financially, if the cabin crew union
constant threat resolved, and the management team refocus on key objectives and reinforce those
objectives, the company will return to profitable growth.
13
The British airways TOWS matrix framework
The TOWS matrix systematically matches the external environmental forces of threats and
opportunities impacting British airways profitability with the internal factors of strengths and
weaknesses, and base strategic options for 2010/13 on the relationships identified. The following
table summarised conversion of SWOT analysis to TOWS matrix.
14
Strategic Options
It is essential to evaluate the varieties of alternative strategic choices available taken external
environmental implications and internal capabilities to considerations. The business environment is
uncertainty and astatic, it constantly changes. The environmental dynamism means we have to
constantly revisit our strategy to stay ahead of the game.
EU-US Open Skies agreement presents opportunity to operate in US airline market. It allows
any EU carriers to fly from any point to any destination of their choice in USA without any
restrictions on pricing or capacity, it allow US carriers to enjoy the same. The agreement
altered competitive landscape on transatlantic routes. It is an opportunity for British airways
15
to make transatlantic investment in the USA airline industry and could use the opportunity to
operate transatlantic flights from outside London base.
Investment in no-frill airline will improve market share and profit margin in the long run. Evidence
in investment in BA CityFlyer a new entrant to no-frill carriers and acquisition of OpenSkies a low
cost long haul carrier operating from Paris to America. The merger with Iberia airline and joint
venture with American Airlines benefit British airline through economic of scale, cost reduction,
capacity and load factor enhancement, and improve service offering.
16
To continue meeting customer’s needs.
British airways have to create customers value innovation to please the targeted customers, in the
market segment it operates. There is need to improve internal customer relationship between workers
union and management. The focus should be to continually provide outstanding customer service
because there are few customers globally willing to pay extra money for superior services, even
among those passengers travel on economy. The excellent services culture associated with the
British airways is a difficult to copy competitive advantage, should exploit this competitive edge.
Liquidity Ratio
Before embark on implementation of strategic options suggested, the financial health of British
airways needs to be considered. The current ratio evaluates financial performance of British airways,
how the company convert current assets to cash in order to fulfil financial obligations. The quick
ratio, evaluate how British airways are meeting short-term obligation with the company most liquid
asset. The inventory to net working capital, the amount of British airways cash tied on inventory.
These ratios are interested for the investors, shareholders, potential lenders because these ratios have
impact on amount of working capital and ability of British airways to meet current dept payment.
17
Return on total asset
The return on capital employed will measure the earning power of various investment made. The
investment in new fuel-efficient aircrafts returns over the course of years, and investment in other
elements such as, gate and ticket counter at the new airport destinations as a result of expansion.
Customer satisfaction
The customer satisfaction performance measures will highlight area to improve in the company
service quality, such as response time for queries, onboard catering, low flights cancellations,
baggage rates, and missed connection.
18
Continuous providing quality customer service
Remain market leader and invest in fuel-efficient aircrafts.
Operation efficiency
Less noise and reduction on CO2 emissions
First to market in innovation
Experience curve acceleration
Strategy communication
The company like British airways that spread in nook and corner of the world are presented with
mammoth logistic challenge when it comes to communicating organisation strategic intents, deciding
strategic decisions is one thing, communicating it is another thing. The advent of information and
communication technology make communication easy for most organisation’s CEO, the like of
video conference, VOIP, etc served the purpose of communication and visual mechanism instead of
travelling long distance.
The first step in communicating the British airways strategy is to consider which stakeholders to
inform and how the messages should be composed, different message goes to British airways
shareholders, key customers, suppliers, and employees. The employee communication is vital and
most challenging since the employees are the one to carry out the strategy, they need to embrace the
strategy as the bases for new growth initiative for the future of British airways. To Cascade the new
strategy top down need superb strategic communication mechanism.
The strategy team need to invite the regional representatives to British airways headquarter, they are
to be briefed of the new direction British airways intent to pursuit, and participate in new strategy
workshop to gain valuable insight and clarification of objectives. Upon completion of the workshop,
the company have to unveil the new British airways strategy in a worldwide conference to be visited
by many British airways most senior personals. The regional representatives have to report directly
to British Airways CEO as the leader of the strategic team for progression of the strategy within their
various regions.
The next step is for the regional representatives to cascade the strategy down the organisation
regional structure. Each regional representative has to organise conference to introduce the new
organisation strategy to various country managers, in the conference, the video of the British airways
19
CEO with the member of the strategy team have to be showed talking to the conference participants
in detail of the new strategy and reiterate the important of the strategy to the organisation profitable
growth.
The last step is for the country managers to inform their workers of the new direction the British
airways will be taken, they need to engage the employees directly for them to know what the new
strategy mean to them and to know possible operational change it will bring. The country manager
has to invite all staffs to meeting. In the meeting, the video of the CEO played asking the entire staffs
to promise their support for the new strategy. In essence, strategy communication is not the end-point
of strategy making process, it needs constant feedback to stakeholders.
Conclusions
The global economic meltdown significantly affected many businesses, weakening the financial
sectors in facilitate loan. The airline industry was significantly hit by loss of passengers which
spurred many airlines to consolidate, divest, or be acquired.
Reference
DIT MSC supply chain management course manual, 2010/11
British Airways (LON:BAY), viewed 10 Feb, 2011,
<http://www.wikinvest.com/stock/British_Airways_(LON:BAY)>
Airline Leader, ISSUE 3 | DEC ‘10 – JAN ’11 Viewed 5th Feb,
2010<http://www.airlineleader.com/pdfs/Airline%20Leader%20-%20Issue%2003.pdf> by
Brancatelli, J 2010, ‘Willie Walsh and the Airline Factory’ viewed 12 Feb, 2011
<http://www.portfolio.com/business-travel/2010/03/24/willie-walsh-wages-war-on-british-
airways-flight-attendants/#ixzz1Cu35UM5M>
Michael, M 2010 ’Global Economic Prospects for 2010 and 2011’ viewed 13th Feb, 2011
<http://www.iie.com/publications/papers/mussa0410.pdf>
20
British Airways, viewed 14th Feb, 2011
<http://www.trueknowledge.com/q/facts_about_british_airways>
21