Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dragoš Kalajić Ispit Katastrofe PDF
Dragoš Kalajić Ispit Katastrofe PDF
Aparoui KajiaJnfi
AnoHannnca Teo/iora JoBaHa m Bejiycna, K/ia nojeAMHMx, hohctm TyrM bhwx eji©MeHa-
H1430M noopeAHHx mjim Henocpefl)HWx H3pa- Ta 0MM60/iM3Ma JarHbera, Aaw/ie npMpoAe
3a, 0 4 praiBajy Ha c/imhh npM30ipa KaiacTpo- MaTepMjaira y n o T p e 6/benor 3a 0 5 p a30BaH>e
cjae 4>nrypy /by/i,c?Hor eJieM©HTa nao 6mtho Te n c eyAo-TpaAM umoh a/ine, cMHHpeTMHHe
OApeAHUJTe o6etiaH>a v\pm saAaTana rfoje 4>virype AnoHa/iMnce, Mome ocBeuiMTM ca-
caApwn niin n3ncKyje npe/ioMHn Aoraljaj mo napaMOTpe OApet>eiwa 0TynH>eBa/ a/iM-
ncTopnje. OcBeTJiMBLun Te t|3fMrype mm trewio jeHau,Mje mjim A 6 rpaAau,wje HOBe TBopeBM-
noKasaTn H>nxo»a ocHO&Ha cBojcTBa, Te ne cnpaM Mc^oAMUJTa, ajiM we M om e o 6ja c -
OMoryhnTM nopetjehbe m car/ieAaBaH>e cy- H’MTM H>eiH CneUMCjjMHHM CIMHCaO M 4jyHKU,M-
ujtmhckhx pas/inna M3Metjy cnenncj3M4HHx jy y KOHTeHCTy HaTacTpo4>MHHe BM3Mje.
M3Hn4>ecTau,nja xpm utiaHOKe m naraHCHo- Hania eiHcere3a w3Jiow©He „eHMrMe"
-e sponC K e fo rm a m e n tis n p e A vi3a3 0 BHwa
c/ieAM ynpaBO WHAM'KaMiwjy K0jy npyma cbo-
mjiih krcnnTMMa KaTacTpocjDe.* jcTBo ci4M&0JiM3au,wje JbyACKor e/ieMeHTa
1/1 603 n o M o tin ynyliiHBia)H>a K o jy M om e nocpeACTBtoiM 4wrype JarH»eTa; y nwTaH>y
n p y w n T H x p n u jtia H C K a A OHTpM Ha, n p e r/ ie A je bma MAea/iM3auMje u c io r eJieMema ho*
BM3M O HapcKe n p 0 M3 B0 AH>e T e o /io ra Jo B a H a jM ce ABOCTpyK0 MaHM4>©CTyje, npeBacxo-
/laKO y o 4 aBa A a c y 6mthm n p o 4 )vi/in n A e a ji- Aho npMMepoM Mcyca XpMCTa m CTaTyooM
HOr <mjim BO/iyHTapMCTMM'H0r Jb yA C- „Bom jer >CTčwa“ . Ha ije^HOj CTpaHM, nojaM
Hor ejt&MeHTa caApmanM y u©HTpa/iHOj 4>m- Jarn>eTa, im3 c 4>epe opAMHap»or MCHycTBa,
r y p n n a c u e n n K a T a c T p o 4 >e, Aan/ie y no/iH- npOH3BeA&H je y eMiMiHeHTHM cmmSoji wpT-
MOp4>HOM H B’MLU03H &M1HOM OMM0O;iM3My Be Mcyca XpMCTa, Te kpotkoctm ,,CTaAa“ ,
JarH>eTa. y K0 HTeKCTy xpmuhaHCKe H yjiTy- «ojy iM3MiCHyje xpnujtiiaiHOHa KOH^enuMja
pe AnoHaJiM nca jeAMHCTBeHo ncno/baBa AyajiM3Ma 6owaiHCKor im JbyAOHOr e/ie,MeH-
ApaM'aTMHHy ko h n e HTpa hm jy p a 3/iMMMTnx Ta. Ha Apyroj CTpaHM to 4>wrypef vrcno/baBa-
3HaMeH.a 4>Mrype Jarh b e ia . y TM o a « ,,Apa- jy oe CBOjCTBa m hmhoibh HOj*M nornyHO npo-
MaTMMtHOCTM CTMH&MO nO Gpe& CTBO M yBM A3 TMBypeHe „npMpoAM" JarH»eTa. Ty ce Mcno-
y Heyo6wHajeHe yc/ioBe MaHMcJjecTau.Mje JbaBa ,,rHeB S®rH>em, jep Aouiao je Be/iMHM
rTO /lM M O p 4 >HOCTM M B M tU e 3 H 34 HOCTM CM M - Aa« fHeBa hberoBOr! Ko MOwe oncTaTM?l“
6o/iM3Ma cj> M rype JarH*eTa. M3 BecHO je (VI, 16). Jarn>e o TB apa ,,neHarre“ u ocjio-
Aa cy o o h o b h m t p a A m h m o h ajih m o m m 6 o/im Gatia CM/ie yHMuiTeH>a, noiHpefie ,JaxaMe“
0&MHH0 AB03HaHHM MJIM BMUJe3HaHHM, y 3a- KaTacTpo4>e; AaK/ie, Jarn>e noceAyje „Moti
bm choctm o a TaMKe r/ieAMUJTa cno3Haje m Aa y 3Me MMp ca 3eM/be m Aa ^hmhm Aa ce
0 3 HaHaBaiH>a, o a h o c h o cc jje p e v\m psbhm /byAM Metiyco6Ho y S n ja jV ‘ (VI, 4), woti no-
MiaiHMt^ecrauMje CMM6 o#M3 0 B&Hor acne'H Ta M opa „MaMeM, KyroM, cM p fiy m 3BepMMa 3e-
C B e Ta cTBiapM im n o ja a a mjim M A eja. A a n / ie , Ma/bCHMiM" (VI, 8). npeA Jiwi;eM To r ,,rHe-
T y c e BMiue3 HaHHOCT oMMSo/ia OTKpMBa c a - Ba JarH>eTa“ KOjM npM pet}yje nnaH erapnn
MO A^HaMMKIOlM, HpOM eHOM TaHHM T/ieAMUJ- cneKTaKJi yiHMuiTeH»a — 4 M/b n n je to -
Ta c y 6 j© K Ta c n o 3H a je , y 3 O A ro B a p a jyt\ e jim'ko noiMop mviBOTa, sefi M3a3MBan>e c a -
n-poMeHe oSje K Ta n c i e o n o 3 Hiaije. P lpeA M3- AMCTMHHOr yWMTKa yHMUITOH>a ROOpeACTBOM
/lomeHVfM npaBM/iOM CMiMSo/iornje, aiHOMa/i- OMCTeMa MCTpajHMx TO p Typ a m AyrOTpajHMX ✓
Ha cnenM tjiM HHOCT A nO K a /iM nce Mcno/baBa MyneiH>a — /byAC»M poa mojim JeAMHo 3a
c e HMH>6 HM4 0 M A a Ce T y H& CaMO p a 3/lMHM- Tp e H yTH y cm pt: „Kpa/beBM 3©Mjbe m bcjim-
Ta, Beifi im n p o TM B y p e H H a /iMU,a v\ 3HaneH>a KaUJM, XM/lMapC<M M 6oraTaUIM, MOtlHMUM, CBM
4>Mryp© J a r H je ia MaHM4 > e c T y jy « a jeA M H C T- P o 5obm m cjioiSoAHM jbyA'M. caHpMUje ce y
BeHOM m CTaTMH HOM n o r/ ie A y c y 6je K T a b h - nefiMHe m Met)y ropcito CTeH>e m MO/ba-iue
3 Mje, Ha je A M H C TB e H o j paBHM H»eHMx c a A P - rope m CTeH>e: .naAHM Te na Hac n o a H p M j-
w a )a . Te « a c o a JiMi^a oH or rn io coam n a o p e d o -
y nMTan>y je (IeHMrMiai“ n p e A KojOM je Jiy m O A m e B a JarH>e.Ta‘ “ (V I, 15— 16).
H e M O f iH a M 'CTO pM UM CTM H H a M/DM cj>M/lOJl OUJKa C ynpO TH O CT M3Met>y npB or, ,,jarH>efier“ ,
n©pcn©KTMBa e H ce re 3e : yTBptjMBaH>e n o p e - mpTBeHMH'Kor Te KpoTHor im Apyror, „JiaB-
[ 21 ]
* Edward GtBbbon: op. cit. 14 Vaftiirudhnlsmđl, 47; Snonrj: op. clt. 53.
4 Cfr. TepTyflnjaH: A. Scapuia, V 19 Folke Strocn: Nordtsk Hedendom. Tro och Sed 1
fdrkristen fld , reie6opr, 1961.
6 U,MM,epoH: Tusculanarum di&putaftionum, !V, 13.
10 Hiodskvldha, 31
* McTopnja paHor eeponcKor cpeAH.eBeHOBA>a npywa
hbm CTpaBMMa« npn3op npoueca Hacwimr nOHptuTa- 17 Cfr. Thomnas CaHyle: O n Heroes (npesoA B. H«e-
BaH>a. Tbho Je Hapno Bejiuuu no6eljeHWM sajeAttM- w©BMha).
i;aua eBponcKor pagamPtas Ha/iarao cawpeny a/iTep-
HaTMBy: noKipujTaBaH>e mj m c m p t. yocTaflOM, m y ra- 18 Minrtr=MeMopMja. y BeflycnM (28), ripopoMM^a
hbmm npouiecMMa eHcnaH&Mje xpmiihancTBa jeaaH- a/iyfl?fpa na enM3ojny Oamhobot oc&a}aH>a MeMOpw-
1)e/bc«a yMeH>a HMcy MMafla H©Hy 3HaHajHMjy y;iory je, mpTBOM OHa, obmm peHMMa: ,,3aujTo « e MCKy-
HHAOKTpvnHaujMje, Beti npeBacx0AH0 ohm ejieMeHTM ujaBom (OAJwe}7 fto6po 3HaM rAe noHMBa TBoje oho:
AOHTpMHe HOj*i cy nofl ycjioBMMa BeiUTe TpaBecrnje y M wmwpobom M3BOpy“ .
Morm eBOLt^aTn eBponcKHM naraHWMa cbot h>hxo-
BMX OpWMHaJlHMX HBMe/ia H BH3Mje WHBOTa, y 3HSHV 19 ,,M awo 3,npo6/beH nponaAHe c b o t — oh he «eno-
enpM/iHe cro^>MTya/iHOCTM. HOjie6jhH®o crajarM Mefly pyuieBvmaMa“ (Oanrrtlno
(li, 3, 7— 8).
7 Franco Ganđifri: ANe radici della cavalleria medi-
evale, d>npeHua 1982. norjiefl MOBe«a eflcne Hy/i- w Sporr!: op clt., 49.
Type Ha npo6/ieMaTMKy poncne npnpOfle Hajpe/becf)-
HMje M3paw&Ba recT Xom a: npefl npnaopoM HyHa- 21 Snonri: idwn.
BMMHe cm ptm c/iyre XJa/iea, („K^KaaMna"), He mo-
raBiun Aa noAHCoi H>eroBe npwne n 3anoMarahbe, o*h ” C/M^ba HajMeiuhe nonpMMa 4>opMy nom ynor vae-
ce nyflM Aa 3aweHM c/iyry na cTpaTMiUTy (Volsunga peH»a npeA c/ieAehoM, me3A6cer neTOM, CTpocpoM
Saga ok Ragnors Saga Lodbrćkar). Beflycne, r^e ce HajaBJbyje „ae/iMHM cyA“ m AO/ia3aK
,,M3 BMCMHa, cMamnor fonOAapa hoJm cshm M aAs’V
8 TepTyjiMjaH: Đ e spectaculus, XXX.
3aro MHore sep3Mje m npeBOAM Benycne Ty cTpo$y
6 Snonrl: Gylfaginning, 13. MCH/bynyjy Kao nyHH tJjanoMtfmHaT. Htmh, ycsajaH>e
apryM6HaTa T63e o ()>ancH4>MHaTy He peuiaBa npo-
10 Snoml: op. cit., 13 m 51. 6/ieM BepoAocrofHocTM. yKpaTHo, nMTaH>e r/iacM: Aa
/im caApmaj Te crpo<i>e noTnyHo OAyAapa oa mkao-
II TeMe/bHy ttHAMHannjy r©H©pwMHe onpere 6oma*H- -eeponcHe TpaAnnnje? y MHAP-eBponoHoJ TpaAMLyijvi
CHor h /byflCKor e/ieM«HTa npywa Rigsthula; ny- nocTOjM c/TMHaH motmb: cTapo-npaj+cttn mmt o ao-
Tyjyfin CBeTOM hoa mmohom Pnr, Oamhob omh XenM- jiacHy Be/iMHor CnacMO^a (Saožyairrt) m tberoBOM
Aanp („OHaj ko]h CBet/iM h ^a CBeTOM*'} oanotjasa Be/inKOM cyAy, Ha Hpajy MuneHapMCTMHnor UMH/iyca
w&He pa3fljHMMTMx 6M O-Ky/iTypH«x npo<t»MJia, Te no- MCTopnje, npeMAa Je Sao®yarrt, MnaH, osmo „nocna-
cpeACTBOM OMMOBa ycnocTaB/ba 0AT0eapajyhe CTa- hmik Eora“ (Yiasna, 49:8). Ms/imuiho je OBAe mctmh*-
/ie>«e, TpMinapTMTHy cTpyKTypy 3ajeAHMue. HHane, tm a® Je MOAe/i To r CrracMona Msepujno npecyAHM
Befi npBe, xpMUjt\awcHe, MHTopnperau^je npMpo^e yTMuaj Ha pejivtrMje m sepoBaH>a E/iflCHor McTOHa,
eACHor naHTeoHa npeHeCperaBane cy cyiuTMHy nao npa-y30p cbmx o6/iwna ,,MecMjaHM3Ma" m ,,mm-
cnpere /byACKor m SofHaHCHor e/ieMeHTa, Te M3Ban- /ieHapn3Ma", hoJm cy nyHM, h Baa M-ceHy/japM30BaHM,
peAHy c/ioweHOcr h bmllie3hshhoct KpMCTartM3aMwje AepMBaTM wpawc«or yneHia. Ranne, m y nor/ieAy
6omaHCKMX ct>jirypa, npn6 erqeajyhM MaTepnjanucTM- crpod)e 65. Be/iycfie, Mcnpaetfo je npemocTaenTM a&
mkoJ, oahocho eBeMepMCTMMKoj, eHcere3M. Tano Up- je Ha H^enoM Mecry nocrojao caftpmaj hojvi je aHO-
haf allra frasagna (noMeTaK cbmx npnnoBeAaiba), m hmmhot, xpMu/haHCHOr, cnpiiSa „MHontipMcao' fl/a ra
X5V CTonehe npyma iukoachm npnMep eB6MepM3Ma: „nonpaBM11.
„Oamh h H>eroBH cmhobh 6exy seoMa m^aph m 06-
AapeHH no3HaaaH>eM Manije, nenor HsrneAa h nyHM 28 CnopM aaH/bynyje npMTioBecT mmtb o mpTBM Tm-
HpenocTH. M mhoix Apyrn n>yAH hs H>MX0B0 r n/ie- poBe AecHMue: ,.Bor MMa caMO JeAHy pyKy m M3&ec-
Mena pacnonaraiiH cy pasHHM caBpuieHCTBMMa Te HO HQ MOJHe HOCMTM MMe HOMMpMTe/ba JbyAM“ (op.
cy (ocranM) JbyAM noiaiiM Aa mm npMHOce mpTee, a » cit. 24). HcnpnHy aHanvi3y CMM6o/iM3Ma TnpoBe mp-
Bepyjy y H6He oa h>hx, Ha3MBajynH hx 6oroBHMa“ TB6 npyma HHopm Ammc3m/i y Les dleux des Germa-
(A M 764,4° Kalund Katai. 2,184). HujpnHVtje MHTepe- ins (!lapiM3, 1959), /iyaMAHO yoMMajytln napanenna-
coaaH>e sa MSJromeHM acneHT npBMx MHTepnpeTau,M- M6 eAcne Tp^MUMje m pmmchmx Jierenjvi, Tupoee m
ja ynyhyjewo na cTyAMjy Anne Holtjsmairtk: Snorres MynwycoBe mpTee. O CMM6o/W3anK}M npaBAe no-
cpeA dB O M AecHHu,e CBeAone m mhotm MHflo-eBpon-
ckh nflnoMn rfle ce m a^hsc nojaM .^npaBfla" m no-
jaM „flecHO" 03HanaBaJy wa©htmhhmm mjim TOMOJior-
hmm M3pa3MiMa. M«aHe, ca cTanoBViujTa pa3MaTpahba
nojiapH*ix pa3JinKa M3Met)y xpmutiaHCHor m naraHCHO-
-eBponcHor estbasa 3asHHMJhvtBo je ynope,nwTvi oflro-
Bepajyfte dHHoce cnpaM XpncTOBe n Tnpose mprBe:
oko XpwcTOBe mpTBe, «ao oko ueHTpa, o«ynJb©Hfl
je cBa xpMLufiaHCKa AOKTpnna, Kopncrefin je nao oc-
HOBHO CpeflCTBO MOpajlMCTMHK© yU6He HHTa&Or 40 -
BeHSHCTća, obmx noToitnx BpeMeHa, aok TnpoBa mp-
TBa HMHor ne o6 aBe3yje, Te y H>oj hob©k naraHCHe
Eepone BHfln, cnopo ca CTMfl0M , 3HaHCJia6jbeH»a60-
waHCKMx cHara n moIim. Ajim hh eBeHTyajnHM yonex
TnpOBe mpTBe, Tpajno 3aT0MJbaBflH>e omia CTHXMje
n xaoca, Hoje wHKapHHpa Byn (DeHpHp, ne 6m mo-
rao vt3HCHWBaTM ofl HOBeKa eflOHe KyjiType HmiiTa
Bnuie flo flocTojHOr noLuioBanja ti yrjiefla. 3 a Be-
pOflocTo)Hor HOBeKa MHflO-eBponcHe Bktpnrme cnn-
pMTyanHOCTM nornyHo je HenojMJbMBa n Ma« ancypfl-
Ha xpMwtYaiHCKa wHCTHTyu,nja HOJieKTVt&Hor wcHynjbe-
H>a m HOJieKTMBHOT 3aflymnBan.a nojy « 3tH0 Hyje Xpn-
croBa mpTBa.