You are on page 1of 7

Knowledge sharing in small

and medium enterprises


a case study of creative clothing industry in Bandung,
West Java, Indonesia
Jann H. Tjakraatmadja, Lenny Martini and
Abstract Yudo Anggoro
When knowledge becomes the School of Business and Management, Institute Technology of Bandung (ITB),
substantial capital of organisation, Ganesha 10th Street, Bandung, 40132, West Java, Indonesia
the process of sharing knowledge
within and outside the organisa- Tel: +62-22-2531923; Fax: +62-22-2504249; E-mails: jannhidajat@sbm-itb.ac.id,
tion becomes an important point to lenny.martini@sbm-itb.ac.id, yudo.anggoro@sbm-itb.ac.id
develop the organisation. Related
with knowledge-based economy,
Introduction becomes very important to contribute
the concept of knowledge hub
as the meeting point to generate, it competitive advantage. On the other
Researchers worldwide are increasingly
transfer and share knowledge is hand, in Triple Helix model, Leydesdorff
proven by several cases in the
showing evidence of the importance of
and Etzkowitz (1995) explained about
world (Silicon Valley, Aston Science knowledge as a substantial capital of
three actors (academician, business
Park, Bangalore, ABC Cluster an organisation (Drucker, 1994; Evers,
and government) as the main institu-
Germany, Munich-high tech zone, 2003; Tjakraatmadja, 2006). In country
etc.). In the case of small and me- tion in knowledge-based economy. The
level, knowledge is also recognised by
dium enterprises (SMEs), it had research proposed that to establish a
not been researched yet about
economists as the most important fac-
small or medium industry as a knowl-
how the knowledge hub should tor of production in a ‘new economy’
edge hub it will need the contribution
support the process of knowledge (Menkhoff et al., 2011). In the knowl-
from the other two actors (academi-
sharing, and also how is the exist- edge-based economy, the competitive
ing process knowledge sharing in cian and government). It explained the
advantage of a country which explained
the SMEs. This research aims to role of each actor in the development
explore the pattern of knowledge
by Porter (1990) consist of four elements
of knowledge hub. The research also
sharing in SMEs, especially the (factor conditions; demand conditions;
explored the knowledge sharing proc-
one that incorporated in a knowl- related and supporting industries; firm
ess which is an important process within
edge hub, using the Triple Helix strategy, structure and rivalry) related to
model. The research provided the a knowledge hub, using case study from
the access and utilisation of knowledge
empirical findings from the case creative clothing industry in Bandung,
of creative clothing industry in
by each actor of country development.
West Java, Indonesia. It revealed the
Bandung, West Java, Indonesia. Several examples had shown the impor-
existing condition of the knowledge
The research clarified the norma- tance of knowledge clusters, knowledge
sharing process in the industry, define
tive aspect of knowledge sharing hub and knowledge architecture in the
process in the industry and also the normative way and propose some
knowledge-based economy era (Silicon
discovered the existing condition suggestion to develop the process.
so that the researcher can suggest
Valley, Aston Science Park, Bangalore,
some prescriptive points to develop ABC Cluster Germany, Munich-high
knowledge sharing process in the tech zone, etc.). Researchers refer it to Knowledge-based economy
creative clothing industry. The re- geographical groupings of firms, both An economy becomes a ‘knowledge
sult will became a useful foundation large and small but often small and economy’ when the sustained use and
for the future research of knowledge
medium industries (Henry and Pinch, creation of knowledge are at the centre
sharing process in other type of
SMEs. The research also provided 2006). In the case of SMEs, they are of its economic development process
empirical result from creative cloth- assumed to play a key role in social and (Chen, 2011). Knowledge-based econ-
ing industry in Bandung, West Java, economic development, expressed in omy uses knowledge as the key engine
Indonesia, that can be used to im- terms of job creation, income generation of economic growth. It is an economy in
prove the knowledge sharing proc-
and imposed balance of trade (Zonooz which knowledge is acquired, created,
ess in the industry thus to increase
the level of competitiveness among et al., 2011). The function of SMEs in disseminated, and used effectively to
business entities in Indonesia. a country as a knowledge hub thus enhance economic development. The

Tech Monitor • Jul-Aug 2011  29


Knowledge sharing in small and medium enterprises

World Bank had constituted the four pil- economic production. The result will be or dissemination of knowledge, including
lars of knowledge economy framework: competitively higher value-added goods the transfer of two directions. Through
• An economic incentive and institu- and service, which increase the prob- the process of sharing knowledge, the
tional regime, which provides good ability of economic success in the cur- organisation will realise what knowledge
economic policies and institutions, rent highly competitive and globalised do they have that can be used to create
promote efficient allocation of re- world economy. new knowledge and innovate in order to
sources and stimulate creativity and create a sustainable competitive advan-
incentives for the efficient creation, Knowledge hub and tage (Desouza, 2003; Lin, 2006).
dissemination, and use of existing knowledge sharing
Triple Helix model
knowledge. Knowledge hub as stated by Evers
• An educated and skilled labour force Due to knowledge-based economy com-
(2008) is:
that continuously upgrades and plexity and dynamic, Etzkowitz and Ley-
‘Local innovation systems that are nodes
adapts skills to efficiently create and desdorff (2000) developed Triple Helix
in networks of knowledge production and
use knowledge. knowledge sharing. They are character- model to explain and breakdown the
ised by high connectedness and high intricacy of the system. The Triple Helix
• An effective innovation system con- internal and external networking and model introduced three dimensions of
sisting of firms, research centres, knowledge sharing capabilities. As meet- social system which is geography, econ-
universities, consultants, and other ing points of communities of knowledge
omy and knowledge.The product of inter-
organisations that keeps up with the and interest, knowledge hub fulfills three
major functions: to generate knowledge, action between these dimensions will
knowledge revolution, taps into the
to transfer knowledge to sites of applica- create knowledge infrastructure, political
growing stock of global knowledge
tion; and to transmit knowledge to other economy and innovation (Figure 1).
and assimilates and adapts new people through education and training.’ In the Triple Helix model, the main
knowledge to local needs.
The knowledge sharing process will institution of the knowledge-based
• A modern, adequate and accessible be effective if it is supported by A-B-G economy is defined as academician/
information infrastructure that facili- collaboration which would include pro- university, industry and government
tates the effective communication, viding the domain, policies, rules and (Etzkowitz and Leydesdorff, 2000).
dissemination and processing of regulations for members of the organisa- These institutions are laboratories of
information and knowledge. tion (Tjakraatmadja, et al., 2008). World innovation system which will interact
The framework thus asserts that Bank (2003) defined sharing knowledge with each other by:
investments and interactions among as means to absorb knowledge from • Constraining each other’s behav-
these four pillars are necessary for the research and experience systemati- iours. For example, university based
sustained creation, adoption, adapta- cally, manage and store knowledge and on its competency will aim to accom-
tion and use of knowledge in domestic information for easy access and transfer modate industry particular demand
for skilled and educated manpower
in certain subjects.
Knowledge • Shaping each other’s expectation. For
example, university and industry ex-
pect government to formulate policy
Innovation that can catalyse collaboration and
Knowledge innovation between institutions.
Infrastructure
The interactions between acad-
emicians who develop knowledge, the
industry/business who run the economy
and the government who rule the geo-
Economy graphical area will contribute to the
country’s competitive advantages in
knowledge-based economy.

Creative industry
Geography Political The term creative industry is defined
Economy as industry which focuses on the
­creation and exploitation of intellectual
Fig. 1.  Triple Helix model ­properties such as, art, movies, games,

30   Tech Monitor • Jul-Aug 2011


Knowledge sharing in small and medium enterprises

fashion and advertisement (Sima- example, the British government has creative industry has employed 4.48 mil-
tupang, 2007a, 2007b). UNESCO also just been focusing on creative industry lions of workers, and this number related
defines creative industry as production in the late 10 years. Since then, crea- to 4.71% of total workforce in Indonesia.
and service activities which cover artis- tive industry in the UK has become a The productivity of those workers in 2006
tic substantial element, architecture and benchmark for other countries. The reached to IDR 19.38 million per person.
advertising. According to Jones (2006), British government has successfully The Department of Commerce of
creative industry is activity which has mapped potential creative industry Indonesia in 2007 has also conducted
originality and has potential to create job there, and launched creative economy study to map creative industry in Indo-
and welfare through intellectual prop- programme. As a result of this national nesia. It classifies creative industry in
erty exploitation. Department of Culture, programme, several cities in the United Indonesia into 14 sectors: advertising,
Media, and Sport of United Kingdom Kingdom such as Birmingham, Brighton architecture, art market, craft, design
classifies creative industry into 15 sec- and Newcastle have abandoned their (graphic, interior, product, brand, logo,
tors, which are advertising, architecture, dependency on industry-based econ- packing), fashion, film and photography,
art and antiques, handicraft, fashion, omy and moved their economy towards interactive game, music, performance
movie, software for interactive enter- creative economy (Kamil, 2007). show, printing and publishing, computer
tainment, music, performance, printing In another example, Singapore has software, broadcasting, and research and
and publishing, software and computer made plan to create creative cluster to development (R&D). The top four sectors
game, television and radio. support creative economy in the ­country. of creative industry in Indonesia are fash-
There are some basic differences Singapore Prime Minister, Lee Hsien ion, advertising, craft and architecture.
between creative industry and other Loong, has launched three national
economic sectors. Florida (2004) movements to support creative industry Creative industry in
explains those differences as follow: in 2005. Those national movements are ­Bandung
Design Singapore, Media 21 and Ren-
• Creative products have symbolic and The Indonesian government was also
naisance City 2.0 (Kamil, 2007).
cultural values, which differentiate looking for any possibilities to develop
them from other products. creative industry in certain cities which
• Creative industry produces high di-
Creative industry in are considered as creative cities. One
versified products. Indonesia of the leading creative cities in Indo-
In Indonesia, creative industry is relatively nesia is Bandung, in West Java prov-
• Customers have their own standards
a new issue. The President of Indonesia, ince. Bandung is called as the leading
to determine the quality of creative
products. The quality of those prod- Dr. Susilo Bambang ­Yudhoyono, has just creative city in Indonesia because of
ucts depends on the value of the voiced his concern on the importance of its characteristics. Most of the city’s
customers. creative industry in 2009. His concern populations (around 60%) are people
on the rising role of creative industry on below 40 years old, and another rea-
• Most creative products may last long economic growth was based on the fact son is that because Bandung has many
and reusable. universities. Young people and univer-
that creative industry combines idea, art,
According to Jones (2006), creative culture and tourism to generate welfare sities are believed as the generator of
industry has both short-term and long- for people. These facts are similar to the creative industry. Based on its unique
term impacts. The short-term impacts characteristics of Indonesia which have characteristics and potentials, Bandung
of creative industry mostly are related rich culture and tradition. is appointed by British Council as one
to the opportunities to generate new Creative industry has actually started of creative cities in Asia Pacific in 2009.
creative business training and also to give significant contribution to Indone- From 14 sectors of creative industry,
the creation of new technology to sup- sian economy.There are some indicators the leading sector in Bandung is fashion
port creative industry. In a long term, which support this argument. Indonesian industry. Fashion industry is defined as
creative industry is expected to reduce Ministry of Commerce, Dr. Marie Elka creative activities which are related to
unemployment in post-industrial area, Pangestu, stated that the growth of crea- the design of clothes, footwear, acces-
increase economic growth, and increase tive industry in 2006 has reached 7.28% sories, fashion consultation and ­fashion
people’s welfare. Creative industry is (which is higher than overall economic distribution. Fashion industry is the
also aimed to develop creative network growth of 5.14% in that year). In the same ­largest economic contributor among
among people and involve women par- year, creative industry has also contrib- other sectors of creative industry in
ticipation as new entrepreneurs. uted to, on average, 4.71% of Indonesian Indonesia. Department of Commerce
Several countries have put much GDP. This number is higher than the con- said that fashion industry contributes to
effort to put creative industry as a tribution from electricity, gas and water 44.18% or around IDR 46 trillion of total
new potential economic sector. As an sector. In term of work force absorption, creative industry contribution in 2006.

Tech Monitor • Jul-Aug 2011  31


Knowledge sharing in small and medium enterprises

West Java, Indonesia, is chosen as a sharing in their business, and wheth-


KICK is the place for clothing case study. er they already applied it or not.
business owners to gather, The aim of in-depth interview in this • Six government officials: They are
share their idea, knowledge study is to explore and identify ­problems heads of government institutions
and problems with one main which occurred in creative clothing which are related to creative industry
purpose and to develop cloth- industry; to understand current relation sectors. They are asked about their
ing business. and pattern among academicians, busi- role in making policy to develop cloth-
ness owners and government officials ing industry, their ­efforts to share their
and to discuss some possible solu- policy to other actors and their opin-
One important part of fashion industry tions which may be applied to solve the ion on the importance of knowledge
in Bandung is creative clothing industry ­existing problems. sharing in creative ­industry.
(Anggoro, 2009). What makes clothing Literature review is useful to high-
industry becomes special is the quantity All of interviews are recorded and
light particular aspects of the research
of its product. While most fashion indus- the results are transferred into several
problem most in need of further inves-
try focuses to create mass production, interview transcripts. These transcripts
tigation. It is also necessary to define
clothing industry offers limited quantity then are read thoroughly and are coded.
and conceptualise variables and theo-
of products. It offers only 50–100 items The aim of coding is to classify some
ries in this study. In this case, literature
in a single model of product. Its products important words into several categories
review is used to define some concepts
vary from clothes, shorts, sandals, bags, which may answer research questions.
of knowledge sharing, knowledge hub,
shoes, etc. What the clothing industry These classifications are important data
Triple Helix model and creative industry.
offers is exclusiveness. for further analysis.
This study involves 20 people in the
The main advantage of clothing in-depth interview process.They are cho-
industry’s products is the design of the
Research findings and
sen because they are considered as key
products. The design offers originality, analysis
actors in their area. Key actors are those
uniqueness, and has meaning. These who have influence in their community, As stated above, the research resulted
are creative works. Clothing industry they drive their idea to the people, and in gap analysis between the existing
owners have their own original brands get respect from their surroundings. All condition of knowledge sharing in the
and mostly sell their products in their of the interviews use open-ended ques- research object and the normative
own shops, usually called distribution tions to gather all possible information concept of knowledge sharing in small
outlets (distro). There are hundreds of from respondents. Respondents in in- and medium industry. The findings are
distros in Bandung which attract many depth interview are as follows: resumed in Table 1.
young people to be their customers. These are the obstacles that hinder
• Six academicians:They are research- the knowledge sharing process to run
Those distro owners are gathered in an
ers and university lecturers who
association for clothing business own- smoothly between the three actors in
have interests in creative industry
ers, called KICK (Kreative Independ- creative clothing industry:
in Bandung. Questions for academi-
ent Clothing Kommunity). KICK is the • No integrated planning between the
cians are aimed to explore concepts
place for clothing business owners to three actors (A-B-G)
and theories of knowledge sharing,
gather, share their idea, knowledge and
knowledge hub, SMEs and creative • Less motivation
problems with one main purpose and to
industry. Respondents are also asked • Less initiatives
develop clothing business.
about the role of academician, busi-
KICK also serves as the formal rep- • No clear definition of each actors’
ness sector and government to de-
resentation of clothing business own- role and function
velop clothing industry in Bandung.
ers to collaborate with government
• Eight businessmen: They are own- • Budget is not on the target/does not
and other private institutions. One of
ers of well-known clothing industries match the needs
the missions of KICK is to educate its
members by actively holding series of in Bandung. Questions for business On the basis of the findings, the
discussions, trainings and workshops. owners are aimed to explore about researcher then suggests a model to
clothing business and all problems minimise the gap of knowledge shar-
Research design occurred. Business owners are also ing process and achieve the objective to
This study aims to explore the pattern asked about the possible solutions constitute the industry as a knowledge
of knowledge sharing in SMEs, espe- for problems and what is the role of hub. The model consists of three actors
cially the one that incorporated in a each actor to develop clothing in- related to their initiatives to share knowl-
knowledge hub, using the Triple Helix dustry. Business owners are asked edge drive by each actor’s interest. The
model. Clothing industry in Bandung, about the importance of knowledge model is shown in Figure 2.

32   Tech Monitor • Jul-Aug 2011


Knowledge sharing in small and medium enterprises

The model indicates that the three Existing condition Subject Normative concept
actors, business, academician and gov-
• Only small aspect of Type of knowledge • Financial and
ernment, each has different interest that
marketing management shared accountancy
drives them to make initiatives to share • Marketing manage-
knowledge. On the basis of the interview ment
result, all parties agree that the existence • Small business man-
of key resource in each parties (creative agement
clothing expert in business, academician • Intellectual property
who has expertise in SME research, cer- right
tain division assigned in government to • Knowledge about
business entity right
regulate SMEs) having no guarantee at
and obligation
all that the knowledge sharing will exist.
The reality on the ground shows that the • KICK only utilised by Media and frequency • KICK (face-to-face
three actors often run their programme business practitioner dialogue or forum)
• Joint forum and creative city (once a month,
separately, thus make it ineffective to the
council only held once or regular)
other parties, and sometimes can cause twice and no future plan to • Joint forum A-B-G
failure in reaching the programme objec- do it again in the future (once a year, irregu-
tive. For example, the business practi- • Regular exhibition only lar, impulsive)
tioner has the event called KICKFEST, utilised by business prac- • Creative city council
which is a festival of all members of the titioner to sell ­product and (no formal forum yet)
association that gathered in a public by government to allocate • Exhibition from
place to exhibit their latest products and budget, but not as the business practitioner
media to share knowledge (once a year, regular)
to sell them to mass customers. This
• Conference held by acad- • Conference held by
event is seen by the government as emician rarely socialised to academician (once a
economic contribution for local trading government and business year, regular)
index, thus being planned in the annual practitioner
budget allocation. The government gives
some amount of money to the organising Table 1.  Knowledge sharing in SME: normative and descriptive
committee, expecting that the fund will
somehow support the event. But actually,
when it came to the need of the busi- Knowledge hub
ness practitioners, they need the money
to fund some other activities, such as
training of skill workers, short courses
Academician
or seminar in management and other
knowledge development agenda. The
government usually does not want to
know about this and insist that the budget
Initiatives
only goes to the festival.
Another example is on the confer-
st

Int
ere

ence of small and medium business that


ere
Int

st

annually held by academician that is not


well socialised to the business practition- Knowledge
ers and also government. Where actu- sharing in
ally this is a good event where business SME
es
Ini

tiv
tia

practice can share the reality in business


tia
tiv

and also share about ideal way to man-


Ini
es

age business. As for government, it can Interest


Government
Business
be the place where fact-finding process
can be done in the process of regula-
tion establishment. To solve the problem,
they cannot rely on each others’ agenda.
They should start with their own initia-
tives to share knowledge and invite the Fig. 2.  Knowledge sharing in a knowledge hub: a model for SMEs

Tech Monitor • Jul-Aug 2011  33


Knowledge sharing in small and medium enterprises

Triple Helix Knowledge sharing in knowledge hub


models
Initiatives Interest/motivation
Academician • Design entrepreneurship-based curriculum • Science development
• Research about SME • Character building in education
• Transfer knowledge through education and training process to produce graduates with
• Being mediator for business and government through ­entrepreneurship skills and ­knowledge
academic forum and conference about SME
• Invite business practitioners and government as guest
lecture in entrepreneurship course, or as resource
­person in entrepreneurship conference
Business • Find out the necessary knowledge for business • Apply knowledge to increase ­business
application through discussion or sharing session in competitiveness
association • Refinement of management practice in
• Actively requesting training or knowledge transfer to business to develop the business
academician • Gathering information about market
• Actively meeting with government to discuss about opportunities from government channel
budget allocation for knowledge sharing session • Develop new product or design resulted
­(training, forum or other knowledge sharing methods) from academician’s research
Government • Develop blueprint of small and medium industries • Success of development programme
development (including creative industry) • Absorption of the budget
• Define target for small and medium industries • Contribution to local and national
­development and allocate the budget development
• Establish development programmes for small and
medium industries, including making forum and
­creative council as knowledge sharing media
Table 2.  Initiatives and interest of A-B-G in knowledge sharing process in knowledge hub

other parties. For example, the busi- and fund provider, the government sides Back to the main objective of the
ness practitioners should have courage are sometimes seen as the arrogant par- research to constitute the small and
to come to universities, seek for experts ties by the other two. But actually the gov- medium industry as knowledge hub,
in small and medium business man- ernment can provide legal support and the research defines clear role of
agement and ask them to transfer the also open strategic channel to commu- each of the parties in the three main
knowledge to the business communities. nicate with other business sectors, other functions of knowledge hub: to gener-
The academician should have enough areas and even connected globally. The ate knowledge, to transfer knowledge
willingness to conduct joint research initiatives and interest of academician, to sites of application and to transmit
with business practitioners. Both parties business and government in knowledge knowledge to other people through
should actively ask the government part sharing process in knowledge hub can education and training. The result can
to fund on these agendas. As regulator be seen in Table 2. be seen in Table 3.

Functions of knowledge Hub

Triple Helix To generate knowledge To transfer knowledge to sites To transmit knowledge


models of application to other people through
education and training
Role of Knowledge generation through Being source of knowledge Being source of knowledge,
academician research. To define body of knowl- trainer
edge about SMEs/industries
Role of Knowledge generation through Receiver of knowledge, implement Training participant, giving
business business ­experience knowledge in business area, giving feedback of training, can be
feedback to generate new knowledge provider of funds in term of
being the training host
Role of Knowledge generation through the Making regulation about knowledge Facilitator and provider of
government process of ­regulation establishment transfer, facilitator and provider of funds funds
Table 3.  Role of A-B-G in knowledge hub

34   Tech Monitor • Jul-Aug 2011


Knowledge sharing in small and medium enterprises

The research found that in the three References tion studies”. Science and Public Policy,
main functions of knowledge hub, each Vol. 25(3), pp. 195–203.
Anggoro, Y. (2009). “Social collaboration
three actors has the same common role. Lin, C.P. (2006). “To share or not to
to develop clothing creative industry”.
The academician mainly performs as share: modeling tacit knowledge shar-
Master Thesis, School of Business and
the source of knowledge. The business ing, its mediators and antecedents”.
Management, Institute Technology of
practitioners function as the implement- Journal of Business Ethics, Vol. 70,
Bandung.
ers of knowledge, the party who ‘test’ pp. 411–428.
the knowledge in the business practice. Chen, Derek H.C. (2011). “Using knowl-
edge as an engine of growth”. Beyond Menkhoff, T., Evers, H.D., Wah, C.Y. and
While the government being regulator,
the Knowledge Trap. World Scientific, Fong, P.E. (2011). Beyond the Knowl-
facilitator and provider of funds, every
Singapore. edge Trap. World Scientific, Singapore.
party can be a moderator of the other.
This supports the suggested model that Desouza, K. (2003) “Facilitating Tacit Porter, M. (1990). The Competitive
every actor has the same position and Knowledge Exchange”, Communica- Advantage of Nations. The Free Press,
force in the knowledge hub. tions of the ACM 46, 85–88, in Lin, New York.
Chieh-Peng (2006) “To share or not to Simatupang, T.M. (2007a). “Gelom-
Conclusion
share: Modelling tacit knowledge shar- bang ekonomi kreatif”. Pikiran Rakyat,
The existing condition of knowledge ing, Its mediators and antecidents”, Wednesday, August 1, p. 20.
sharing in the research object had not Journal of Business Ethic, Springer. Simatupang, T.M. (2007b). “Peluang
proven to be significantly useful for all
Drucker, P.F. (1994). “The theory of ITB dalam Era Kreatif”. Pikiran Rakyat,
three actors, mostly because it is usu-
business”. Harvard Business Review, Monday, March 2, p. 20.
ally done impulsively and unplanned,
­September–October, pp. 95–104. Tjakraatmadja, J.H. (2006). “Hakekat
thus did not give the business practition-
ers with type of knowledge they need Etzkowitz, H. and Leydesdorff, L. Manusia dalam Kerangka Manajemen
to improve their business. Although (2000). “The dynamics of innovation: Pengetahuan dan Organisasi Belajar”.
several type of media had been used from National Systems and ‘Mode 2’ Jurnal Manajemen Teknologi MBA – ITB.
and developed to share knowledge, but to a Triple Helix of university-industry- Tjakraatmadja, J.H., Martini, L. and
many obstacles hinder the knowledge government relations”. Research Policy, Wicaksono, A. (2008). “Knowledge
sharing process to occur intensively. In Vol. 29, pp. 109–123. Sharing in Indonesian Context: Institut
SMEs, the existence of all three entities Evers, H.D. (2003). “Transition towards Teknologi Bandung (ITB) as Poten-
in Triple Helix model, which are acad- a knowledge society: Indonesia and tial Knowledge Hub To Create Value
emician, business and government, Malaysia in comparative perspective”. from Academia, usiness and Govern-
does not guarantee that the region or Comparative Sociology, Vol. 2(2), ment Linkages”. Fourth International
hub will be automatically transformed as pp. 335–373. Research Conference on Asian Busi-
a knowledge hub. In order to be consid- ness: Knowledge Architecture for Devel-
Evers, H.D. (2008). “Knowledge hubs and
ered as a knowledge hub, within which opment: Challenges Ahead for Asian
knowledge clusters: designing a knowl-
knowledge production and knowledge Business and Governance, Singapore
edge architecture for development”. ZEF
sharing happens intensively, each of the Management University (SMU), 24–25
Working Paper Series, Vol. 27, pp. 1–21.
three entities should have its own initia- March 2008.
tives to share knowledge that are trig- Florida, R. (2004). The Rise of the Crea-
tive Class. Basic Books, New York. World Bank (2003). “Sharing Knowl-
gered by certain interest or motivation.
edge to Achieve Development Goals”.
All interests actually contribute to local/ Henry, N. and Pinch, S. (2006). “Knowl- World Bank Operation Evaluation
national competitive advantage, thus edge and clusters”. In C. Pitelis, Department.
making the knowledge sharing process R. Sugden and J.R. Wilson (eds), Cluster
an important agenda for the country. All World Bank Institute-OECD report
and Globalisation. Edgar Elgar, Cheltenham.
the three actors need to communicate (2000). “Korea and the Knowledge-
Jones, A., Williams, L., Coats, D., Lee, Based Economy: Making the Transition”.
their interest clearly to the others, so
N. and O’Keeffe, A. (2006). Enabling Cit-
they all together could develop an inte- Zonooz, B.H., Farzam, V., Satarifar, M.
ies in the Knowledge Economy. DCLG,
grated plan of knowledge sharing in the and Bakhshi, L. (2011). “The relation-
London.
area in order to constitute a knowledge ship between knowledge transfer and
hub and gain benefit from the process. Kamil, R. (2007), “Kota Kreatif, Bukan competitiveness in “SMES” with empha-
For further research, it is suggested Jargon”, Pikiran Rakyat, Monday, sis on absorptive capacity and combina-
to expand the research object to other ­September 17. tive capabilities”. International Journal
sectors of SME, whether it is creative Leydesdorff, L. and Etzkowitz, H. (1998). of Business and Management, Vol. 2
industry or others. “The Triple Helix as a model for innova- No. 1, pp. 59–85. 

Tech Monitor • Jul-Aug 2011  35

You might also like