Ateneo de Zamboanga University

La Purisima Street, Zamboanga City

School of Management and Accountancy

Defective Contracts

Submitted by:
Jade Dondoyano
Aiza Eroy
Ayannah Laja
Thonie Magsino
Evander Punzalan
Katrine Sabellano
Stacee Salcedo
ACCLAW – C

Submitted to:
Atty. Krystel Natividad

March 21, 2019

Rescissible Contract

LAND SALE AGREEMENT

This LAND SALE AGREEMENT is made this ____21st____ day of _____March_____ between
1.MARIE THONIE MAGSINO – a Guardian of KATRINE A. SABELLANO a minor
(hereinafter called the SELLER) sells the property worth P100, 000 for only P50,000 to
ARCHITECT ADEBOWALE KIZITO BALOGUN OF DON TORIBIO DRIVE, DON TORIBIO
STREET, TETUAN, ZAMBOANGA CITY (hereinafter called the PURCHASER, which expression
shall where the context so admits include his heirs, executors, administrators, assigns, personal
representatives and such other person or persons claiming through or under him)of the other
part;

WHEREAS:

1. The SELLER herein became seized of a piece or parcel of land lying, situate and being at
Dalute Village, Ajobo via Ijaye,Ibadan by inheritance under the Yoruba native law and
customs.

2. The PURCHASER has approached the SELLER for the sale of 2 Acres out of the land.

3. The SELLER have agreed to sell 2(two) acres of land to the PURCHASER for a
consideration hereinafter mentioned and all parties have agreed to evidence the sale by
this present agreement.

NOW THIS AGREEMENT WITNESSES AS FOLLOWS:

a. In consideration of the payment of the sum of PHP 50,000 (FIFTY THOUSAND PESOS
ONLY) paid by the PURCHASER unto the SELLER (the receipt of which the SELLER
hereby acknowledge), the SELLER as the GURADIAN OF THE BENEFICIAL OWNER
hereby, sell to the PURCHASER 2 Acres OF LAND, LYING AND BEING at
FILINVEST, LUNZURAN, ZAMBOANGA CITY the extent of which shall be more
particularly delineated and described in a survey plan to be drawn by the PURCHASER’S
Surveyor; MEANWHILE the PURCHASER is put into immediate possession of the land in
the presence of witnesses;

b. The SELLER hereby covenant to indemnify the PURCHASER against any loss which the
PURCHASER may sustain by virtue of ANY DEFECT in their title to the land herein sold;
c. The SELLER have agreed to sign or execute any further or other documents which may
CONFIRM or further CONFIRM the vesting of ownership in the PURCHASER whenever
such documents shall be presented to the SELLER by the PURCHASER.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF the parties hereto have hereunto set their hands and seal the day and year first
above written.

THE FORGOING HAVING BEEN FIRST READ

OVER AND INTERPRETED TO THE PARTIES

BY ME MARIE THONIE MAGSINO AND ARCHITECT

ADEBOWALE KIZITO BALOGUN

WHEN THEY SEEMED PERFECTLY TO HAVE

UNDERSTOOD SAME BEFORE AFFIXING THEIR

THUMBPRINT IMPRESSIONS THERETO

SIGNED, SEALED and DELIVERED

By the within named SELLER:

______________________________

MARIE THONIE MAGSINO

In the presence of:

(1) Name: Aiza Therese Y. Eroy

Address: Barangay Tumaga, Zamboanga City

Occupation: Certified Public Accountant (CPA)

Signature: __________________________________

(2) Name: Sean Stacee S. Salcedo

Address: Barangay San Jose, Zamboanga City

Occupation: Civil Engineer

Signature: __________________________________

SIGNED, SEALED AND DELIVERED

By the within named PURCHASER

_________________________________

ARCHITECT ADEBOWALE KIZITO BALOGUN

In the presence of:

(1) Name: Evander Punzalan

Address: Barangay Pasonanca, Zamboanga City

Occupation: CPA Lawyer

Signature: __________________________________

(2) Name: Ayannah Laja

Address: Barangay Tugbungan, Zamboanga City

Occupation: CPA Lawyer

Signature: __________________________________

Prepared By:

ADEWUMI STELLA OYENIRAN

6, Aurora Street, Agbowo,

Zamboanga City
Voidable Contract
Agreement for Contract of Sale

THE AGREEMENT MADE THE 24 DAY OF JULY 2018.

BETWEEN: Evander Punzalan an OFW based in Singapore.

AND: Jade Dondoyano Unregistered owner of Motor Vehicle registered in Philippines.

WHEREAS:

A. The Seller is not the registered owner of the vehicle.

B. The Seller desire to sell and the Buyer desire to Buy the motor vehicle on these terms and
agreements.
C. The contract that the Buyer entered with Seller is a voidable contract. Under the Civil
Code, particularly Article 1390 thereof, a contract is considered voidable if the consent is
vitiated.
 Art. 1390. The following contracts are voidable or annullable, even though there
may have been no damage to the contracting parties:
 Those where one of the parties is incapable of giving consent to a contract;
 Those where the consent is vitiated by mistake, violence, intimidation, undue
influence or fraud.

The DEFINITION and INTERPRATATION:

1. The total purchase price is PHP 87000 paid in cash.

2. The vehicle to be sold shall be conveyed by a standard form Bill of Sale, duly executed by
the Seller.
3. The Seller promise and agrees to convey good, clear and marketable title to all the vehicle
to be sold, the same to be free and clear of all liens and encumbrances. Full possession of
said vehicle will be delivered in the good condition that is now, reasonable expected.
4. Consummation of the sale, with payment by the Buyer that is paid in cash.

5. The Seller may use the purchase money, or any portion thereof, to clear any
encumbrances on the vehicle transferred and in the event that documents reflecting
discharge of said encumbrances are not available at the time of sale, the money needed
to effectuate such discharge shall be held by the attorneys of the Buyer and Seller in
escrow pending the discharge.

6. Until the delivery of the Bill of Sale, the Seller shall maintain insurance on said vehicle in
the amount that is presently insured.

7. If the Buyer fails to fulfill his obligations herein, all deposits made hereunder by the Buyer
shall be retained by the Seller as liquidated damages.

8. The Seller agrees that this Agreement is contingent upon the following conditions: (a)
Buyer obtaining a Lease on the said premises or that the existing Lease be assigned in
writing to the Buyer. (b) Buyer obtaining the approval from the proper authorities (Town
and State) of the transfer of all necessary to the Buyer. (c) The premises shall be in the
same condition, reasonable wear and tear expected, on the date of passing as they are
currently in.

9. All of the terms, representations and warranties shall survive the closing. This Agreement
shall bind and inure to the benefit of the Seller and Buyer and their respective heirs,
executors, administrators, successors and assigns.
 10. If this Agreement shall contain any term or provision which shall be invalid or against
public policy or if the application of same is invalid or against public policy, then, the
remainder of this Agreement shall not be affected thereby and shall remain in full force
and effect.

IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this instrument to be executed in
triplicate on the day and year first above written.

SELLER:

__________Jade T. Donoyano______________________________________________

BUYER:

___________Evander L. Punzalan_____________________________________________
Unenforceable Contract

LAND SALE AGREEMENT

This LAND SALE AGREEMENT is made this ____21st____ day of _____March_____ between
1. KATRINE A. SABELLANO a minor (hereinafter called the SELLER) sells the property worth
P100, 000 for only P50,000 to ARCHITECT ADEBOWALE KIZITO BALOGUN OF DON
TORIBIO DRIVE, DON TORIBIO STREET, TETUAN, ZAMBOANGA CITY (hereinafter called
the PURCHASER, which expression shall where the context so admits include his heirs,
executors, administrators, assigns, personal representatives and such other person or persons
claiming through or under him)of the other part;

WHEREAS:

4. The SELLER herein became seized of a piece or parcel of land lying, situate and being at
Dalute Village, Ajobo via Ijaye,Ibadan by inheritance under the Yoruba native law and
customs.

5. The PURCHASER has approached the SELLER for the sale of 2 Acres out of the land.

6. The SELLER have agreed to sell 2(two) acres of land to the PURCHASER for a
consideration hereinafter mentioned and all parties have agreed to evidence the sale by
this present agreement.

NOW THIS AGREEMENT WITNESSES AS FOLLOWS:

d. In consideration of the payment of the sum of PHP 50,000 (FIFTY THOUSAND PESOS
ONLY) paid by the PURCHASER unto the SELLER (the receipt of which the SELLER
hereby acknowledge), the SELLER as the THE BENEFICIAL OWNER hereby, sell to
the PURCHASER 2 Acres OF LAND, LYING AND BEING at FILINVEST,
LUNZURAN, ZAMBOANGA CITY the extent of which shall be more particularly
delineated and described in a survey plan to be drawn by the PURCHASER’S Surveyor;
MEANWHILE the PURCHASER is put into immediate possession of the land in the
presence of witnesses;

e. The SELLER hereby covenant to indemnify the PURCHASER against any loss which the
PURCHASER may sustain by virtue of ANY DEFECT in their title to the land herein sold;
f. The SELLER have agreed to sign or execute any further or other documents which may
CONFIRM or further CONFIRM the vesting of ownership in the PURCHASER whenever
such documents shall be presented to the SELLER by the PURCHASER.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF the parties hereto have hereunto set their hands and seal the day and year first
above written.

THE FORGOING HAVING BEEN FIRST READ

OVER AND INTERPRETED TO THE PARTIES

BY ME MARIE THONIE MAGSINO AND ARCHITECT

ADEBOWALE KIZITO BALOGUN

WHEN THEY SEEMED PERFECTLY TO HAVE

UNDERSTOOD SAME BEFORE AFFIXING THEIR

THUMBPRINT IMPRESSIONS THERETO

SIGNED, SEALED and DELIVERED

By the within named SELLER:

______________________________

MARIE THONIE MAGSINO

In the presence of:

(1) Name: Aiza Therese Y. Eroy

Address: Barangay Tumaga, Zamboanga City

Occupation: Certified Public Accountant (CPA)

Signature: __________________________________

(2) Name: Sean Stacee S. Salcedo

Address: Barangay San Jose, Zamboanga City

Occupation: Civil Engineer

Signature: __________________________________

SIGNED, SEALED AND DELIVERED

By the within named PURCHASER

_________________________________

ARCHITECT ADEBOWALE KIZITO BALOGUN

In the presence of:

(1) Name: Evander Punzalan

Address: Barangay Pasonanca, Zamboanga City

Occupation: CPA Lawyer

Signature: __________________________________

(2) Name: Ayannah Laja

Address: Barangay Tugbungan, Zamboanga City

Occupation: CPA Lawyer

Signature: __________________________________

Prepared By:

ADEWUMI STELLA OYENIRAN

6, Aurora Street, Agbowo,

Zamboanga City
Void Contract

Marriage Contract between

Isaac Hempstead Wright and

Ayannah Laja
 In the name of Allah, most Gracious, most Merciful

This is a marriage contract between

Isaac Hempstead Wright and Ayannah Laja

Preamble

“And among His Signs is this that He created for you mates from among
yourselves that you may dwell in tranquillity with them and He has put love and
mercy between your (hearts); verily in that are Signs for those who reflect.”
(Qur’an, Surah Al Rum Verse 21)

We, Isaac and Ayannah, agree to take each other as marriage partners on the
understanding that this contract shall regulate our relationship.

While Islam is quite clear that marriage is a contract or agreement between two
people, it is distinguished in that it is a contract whose necessary component is
love. We pray that our marriage will be blessed by the “love and mercy” of God,
and we commit ourselves to constantly striving to ensure that love and caring
are strong pillars of our relationship.

Having both descended from the first single human created by Allah, we
acknowledge the basic equality of all people, and especially of each other
insofar as our respective rights and responsibilities in our marriage are
concerned.
Marriage involves the joining of two individuals with the purpose of forming a
partnership that will combine our individual strengths, abilities, talents and
skills. It will be a partnership based on interdependence, a mutually beneficial
relationship where we each retain our individuality and personality but where
the relationship is also accorded its significant place.

Together with love and caring, we commit ourselves to striving for a marriage
characterised by mutual respect, appreciation, support, co-operation and
loyalty between the spouses. These, we believe, will be essential for the success
of our marriage and we commit ourselves to upholding these values as
determining factors in our dealings with each other, as advised by the Qur’ān
and the example of the Prophet Muhammad (s).

Furthermore, we commit ourselves to a spirit of openness, trust, strong

communication and mutual consultation in our relationship. We will discuss
key decisions fully, taking into consideration, among others, the personal, social
and economic consequences thereof.

We commit ourselves to marriage and to relationship-building and

strengthening, with the assistance of an outside party, if necessary.

Marriage needs to be a relationship free from abuse: physical, emotional or

verbal. And we commit ourselves to building a relationship free of such abuse
and one that allows us both to feel safe.

We agree to identify mutually agreed-upon spiritual, career and psychological

goals and priorities and strive towards achieving these.

Our daily interactions with each other will be guided by the spirit of fairness,
dignity and justice promoted by the Qur’ān and shown to us by the example of
the Messenger of Allah, Muhammad (on whom be peace).
We will strive to ensure that our interactions with each other are in a spirit of
 Love, compassion and generosity
 Mutual respect and courtesy
 Openness and honesty
 Communicating freely and fully at all times
 With a willingness to learn from each other and from others
 Generously acknowledging each other’s love, support and
achievements
 Having the humility and the courage to admit our mistakes and
learn from them.

We understand marriage as being a relationship that should be free from abuse,

of an emotional, physical, or verbal nature. We therefore undertake to refrain
totally from abusive behaviour and speech toward each other, and to create an
environment within which all members of our family will feel safe.

We agree that decisions will be made following a process of mutual

consultation (shura) and agreement by both of us. All key decisions will be
discussed fully, taking into consideration, amongst others, the social, economic,
and professional consequences thereof.

We agree to identify and strive proactively and fully towards achieving

mutually-agreed-upon spiritual, financial, career, and psychological goals and
priorities, both in our individual and our joint capacities.

We commit ourselves to relationship building and developing a strong and

faithful marriage.

We commit ourselves to healthy lifestyles regarding diet, exercise, and stress

reduction, and are willing to obtain medical advice and feedback from time to
time as a means of ensuring and sustaining our health.
Mahr
Isaac gives and Ayannah accepts a mahr of **** (or amounting to R***** (*****
rands).

Religious foundation of marriage

We commit ourselves to a life of ongoing learning and growing in

understanding – of ourselves, each other, all those we interact with, all of
creation, our Creator, and our religion, Islam.

We commit ourselves to creating a home environment which respects and

fosters the spirit and message of Islam as upheld in the Qur’an and as
demonstrated by Prophet Muhammad (on whom be peace) in his living.

Education

We will both endeavour to educate ourselves as much as is possible – both in

terms of education related to our careers and in terms of Islamic education.
Neither spouse will have the right to prevent the other from furthering her /
his education; nor will either spouse place impediments in the path of the other
if the latter seeks to further her / his education.

Marriage rights and responsibilities

Matrimonial property regime
We have chosen to marry by adopting the out of community system
(encapsulated in an ante-nuptial contract), in terms of the Matrimonial
Property Act of 1984, and will register the marriage as such with the relevant
authorities.

In so far as it deals with any proprietary consequences of the marriage, this

contract, governing our overall relationship, is subject to the ante-nuptial
contract referred to in the above paragraph.

Financial rights and obligations

Both of us have the right to seek and secure employment, to derive income from
business or other investments, to save and invest our savings, and to develop
our respective careers.

We commit ourselves to discussing from time to time, as required by our

circumstances, a joint budget and financial plan that will be beneficial to our
marriage, in the short and long terms.

We may retain individual bank accounts and have the right to manage and
dispose of our individual finances and assets as we deem fit. Nevertheless, we
agree that we will consult with each other before incurring any personal
expenses that do not benefit the marriage.

Financial responsibilities will be determined and shared in a way that is

mutually agreeable and equitable depending on our respective circumstances.

Domestic Responsibilities
We agree to share domestic responsibilities. It will not be the sole duty of either
spouse to maintain an attractive domestic environment or to provide meals
and, in general, to maintain the household.

Social relations
We shall strive to the best of our ability, at all times, to lead a full life – one that
takes cognisance of the rights of others – interacting with and contributing to
the well-being of the various communities we are part of and to society at large.

Respect
Respect is an essential ingredient of any marriage. We will, at all times,
endeavour to respect each other’s humanity, intelligence and our family. We
will thus give due and serious consideration to the words and actions of each
other and other members of our family. Neither of us will have any right – nor
will resort – to physically, mentally or psychologically abuse the other, no
matter what justification or rationalisation could be given for such action.

We both commit ourselves to providing a home environment where each of us

is able to maintain her / his privacy.

We commit ourselves to building a respectful family environment where no

disrespect is shown by any family member to another.

Sexual relations
Sexual relations will be consensual at all times and will, like all other relations
in the marriage, be based on mutual trust and respect. Isaac and Ayannah agree
that we will both be tested for HIV before our wedding.

Polygyny
We both agree to have a monogamous marriage. Isaac agrees that he will not
enter into additional polygamous marriages during the validity of this
marriage. If he, however, decides to marry another woman, which decision will
serve as grounds for Isaac to immediately divorce Ayannah.

Family obligations
We understand that, as a result of our marriage, we will both have new family
structures to relate to. We commit ourselves to interacting with our respective
spouse’s family with respect and kindness at all times.

Any decision regarding our living with any member or members of either family
or their living with us will require the explicit consent of both of us. In making
such decisions, due regard shall be given to the joint and separate
responsibilities that we have, and the financial implications of such decisions.

Children
Ayannah accepts the responsibility for child-bearing and breastfeeding of our
children. And, during this period, Isaac will solely be responsible for the
material maintenance of the family and household.

We acknowledge that one spouse may take primary responsibility for acting as
a child caregiver during the marriage, while the other spouse may assume the
burden of support. Any such division of roles will be mutually-agreed to and
neither partner will be treated as contributing any less to the family because of
that spouse’s particular role. Both parents will play an active role in our
children’s upbringing. We undertake to raise our children in an Islamic family
environment, with Islam being the family religion and education of the children
in Islam being a joint responsibility of both of us.
At the same time, we commit ourselves to the principle of religious
understanding and undertake personally that we will respect, and teach our
children to respect, other religious views and philosophies, both within Islam
and without.

Divorce and related matters

Dispute resolution procedures and the initiation of divorce proceedings

A dispute will be deemed to have resulted during the marriage if either of us
declares it to be so. In the event of such a dispute arising we will first use our
ability to listen, communicate and learn to find an internal solution.

Both of us agree to allow the other to express any criticism or concern freely
(provided it is done respectfully). We undertake not to be dismissive of the
other’s concerns without first being self-critical and assessing the criticism or
concern from the other’s point of view.

If we realize we are at fault in any way (and we may both be partially at fault),
we undertake to acknowledge our faults honestly and fully and if either of us
has learnt something beneficial from the other’s concerns we undertake to
express our gratitude to the other for helping us see something about ourselves
we might not otherwise have done.

If we are unable to resolve a dispute after reflecting, deeply engaging with each
other, praying and asking our Creator for assistance, we will appoint a mutually
acceptable facilitator or facilitators to mediate and possibly arbitrate (if
mediation fails) in the dispute. Relationship-building and counselling may form
part of this process.
If the dispute is of a nature that could lead to the termination of the marriage
and counselling has not helped to resolve the dispute, before either of us
decides to initiate divorce proceedings, we will make a final effort to save our
marriage by undergoing a trial separation for a period of three months.

We will follow this procedure in respect of each such dispute. If, however, after
this time (in respect of any such dispute) the marriage relationship still cannot
be healed, then either of us may initiate divorce proceedings through a legal
forum – which is the only forum that may validly terminate the marriage.

We pray that our marriage will not reach a stage where either of us will
consider divorce as an option. Notwithstanding any contrary understanding of
any law, we agree that both of us will have an equal right to initiate divorce
proceedings and that these will be governed in accordance with the terms
stipulated in this contract.

Isaac agrees to use the Islamic jurisprudential mechanism of talaq al-tafwid to

delegate the right of talaq to Ayannah so that both of us will possess that right.
Whichever of us initiates such proceedings, a procedure of three repudiations
will require to be followed as described in the Qur’an in Surah Baqarah verses
228-232.

In addition, Ayannah will be able to exercise her right to khula’ by which she
will be able to initiate a divorce subject to and by the return of the mahr to Bilal.

Ayannah will also be able to exercise her right to apply for a faskh to a judicial
authority. Among other circumstances, a faskh could be used in cases which
involve:
 any physical (threatened or actual) abuse,
 any infidelity, or
 severe or ongoing verbal or emotional abuse.
Such a divorce could be granted unopposed and no trial separation will be
necessary.

In all of the three processes above (talaq, khula’ and faskh), a divorce will only
be deemed to have been effected once presided over and allowed by a judicial
authority that is agreed upon by us both.

Isaac’s desertion of family life inexcusably or his absence without contact with
the family for six continuous months would be grounds for Ayannah seeking a
divorce. In such a case the judicial authority will be bound to effect a divorce.

Maintenance

Spousal maintenance and the maintenance of children will be determined in a

fair and equitable manner at the time of divorce. If necessary, an arbitrator may
be used to determine what a ‘fair and equitable’ resolution would be. The
agreement will be in writing and binding.

Custody of minor children

The custody of minor children that might result from this marriage shall be
determined according to the children’s best interests. Should the custody of
children be contested, the matter shall be referred for dispute resolution as set
out in this contract. If agreement is reached, this will be incorporated into an
agreement which will be attached to the application for divorce.
Irrespective of who gets custody, there shall be no denial of reasonable
visitation rights to the parent that is not granted custody.

If the marriage ends in divorce and a child or children have resulted from the
marriage, both parents will be responsible for the financial maintenance of the
child or children in proportion to their respective incomes at the time, taking
into account the effect of the dissolution of marriage on the working lives of
both parents.
No variation

We understand that this agreement does not detract from our Islamic rights
and obligations but elucidates and complements these.

No changes or variations made to this contract shall be valid unless reduced to

writing, signed by both parties and appended to this agreement.

Conclusion

We undertake to inspire each other to achieve the best that we are capable of.

May Allah grant us the wisdom, honesty, commitment and strength to make this
marriage a successful one. And May He bless us with His Love and Mercy.

Signed on this, the 14 day of November 2009 in Makati, Republic of the

Philippines.
___ISAAC HEMPSTEAD WRIGHT____ __AYANNAH LAJA___
Isaac Hempstead Wright Ayannah Laja

Witnesses:

Katrine Joy Sabellano __KATRINE JOY SABELLANO___

Aiza Therese Eroy _AIZA THERESE EROY___

This marriage was solemnised on the 14 day of November 2019 at Makati City,
Republic of the Philippines, by Ms. Sam Pinto:

______________________________