LECTURE 5: OP AMPS -VOLTAGE COMPARATOR & SCHMITT TRIGGER
Voltage Comparator
Thus far, our circuits have been useful only if the output
remained unsaturated. The voltage comparator is a device which uses no
feedback; saturation is the desired result. In this circuit we want a
simple yes-no answer to be signified by either positive saturation or
negative saturation of the output.
Suppose we have some sensing device. We want to be warned
whenever the voltage of the sensor, Vs, rises above some level Vj,
called the turn-on voltage. (The sensor could be, for example, @
voltage divider with a temperature-dependent resistor whose resistance
rises with temperature. We are to be warned when a chemical bath gete
near the flash point.) Consider the circuit shown below.
v
R
Mi
Ry
Vs
The output will saturate positively when Vg>V, +8 and will saturate
negatively when VsVe, the output is saturated
negatively instead of positively as in the voltage comparator circuit
figure. If one wants a positive output for Vs>Ve, the output can be
inverted with another op amp, or another version of the Schmitt
trigger can be used.
+Voe
RyThe use of Ry connected from Vo to Ve (positive feedback) changes
the voltage level to which we are comparing Vg. If Vs is low, then Vo
is high and Ve is equal to Vy. If Vs rises and reaches Vy, the output
drops, lowering Ve. Since now Vs > Ve, the output will saturate
negatively, lowering V_ to V,. The output will not go positive again
until Vg drops below V,.
The next figure gives an example of the response of our Schmitt
trigger.
The example demonstrates a particular usefulness of the Schmitt
trigger. If we have a Vg which rises (or falls) through the switch
region in a “noisy" or fluctuating manner there will only be one
switching unless the fluctuations are of amplitude greater than Vy-V;
We get a "clean" transition from a noisy signal.
The values chosen for Rj,Rg and Ry depend on the desired values
for Vp,V; and the saturation voltage of the output. If you will look at
the data sheet for the F351, you will find that the maximum
peak-to-peak output voltage swing is typically 30 volts for a load
resistance of 10 kQ and supply voltages of +18 V to -18 V. That is,
the device saturates at 15 volts positive or 15 volts negative. Thus
we expect the output to saturate about three volts shy of the supply
voltage. We usually operate with supply voltages of +12 v. For a quick
calculation we ignore the three volt difference and assume the output
saturates at the supply voltage.“Vee
In general we can write the following equations on the basis of the
previous figure:
Ve-Vo = URE
Veo-Ve = (ly +1)R,
Vo Veo) = Ve* Veo = 122
Exercise 2
Eliminate [| and Ij from the above equation and show that:
Veo Ve = (Ve-VoIRWRE + (Vo+ Vee)Ri/Ra
Using F and D as abbreviations for RyRp and Ry/Rp respectively, we
have:
Veo-Ve = (Ve- Vo)F + (Vet Vee)D
Now when Vo is saturated at Voc Ve becomes Vp, and when Vo is saturated
at -Vec,Ve becomes V,. So we have two equations.
Vee-Vh = (Vh- Veo)F + (Vit Veo)D
Veo- Vr = (Vet VeolF + (Vet Veg)D
Exercise 3
Solve these equations for F and D and show that:
FeBi a Mov og pa i _ VerM } apeneato
Rp Ve+Y Ry VetV, | otheropamp
Ry,Rz and Rr can be chosen to avoid loading the output excessively and
to have Rp<V. the device output
is an open circuit so the Vo terminal is simply connected to V through
R. When V+