Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Earthing Report PDF
Earthing Report PDF
A. Purpose/Scope ...................................................................................................................................... 3
B. Earth electrode rods: ............................................................................................................................ 4
C. Earth round conductor electrode: ...................................................................................................... 10
D. Earth rod with round conductor electrodes combination earthing network: .................................... 11
E. Interconnection of MV and LV Earths ................................................................................................. 12
F. Calculation of Touch and Step Potentials ........................................................................................... 14
G. Allowable touch and step potentials .................................................................................................. 15
H. Current Density at Surface of Earth Electrode .................................................................................... 16
I. Appendices : ........................................................................................................................................ 19
Page 2 of 19
A. Purpose/Scope
The purpose of this report to obtain the MV&LV earthing calculation study
for load centre A of KAIA project according to BS Code books
All the formulas and tables are copied from BS 7430:1998 and
BS 7354:1990
Page 3 of 19
B. Earth electrode rods:
Load Centre A - Structural floor level is 7m above MSL with the design
water table level at 4m above MSL, this level is based on recommendations
of HUTA and is subject to final confirmation by them.
So the effective length of the electrode rod through the wet soil (10 ohm.m
resistivity) will be [(3*2.4)-(7-4)] =4.2 m, where the total length of electrode
rod 3*2.4 = 7.2 m.
Page 4 of 19
ρ = wet Soil resistivity (according to the design report) = 10 ohm.m
Page 5 of 19
Page 6 of 19
Page 7 of 19
Page 8 of 19
The total number of electrodes around the rectangle = 24 rods each of the
length of 9.6 m.
So, n = 7 and s = 41 m
Page 9 of 19
C. Earth round conductor electrode:
For the round conductor electrode the resistance R, in ohms is given by the
following equation:
Then, the resistance R for the round conductor electrode = 0.206 ohm.
Page 10 of 19
D. Earth rod with round conductor electrodes
combination earthing network:
RLV = 0.1353ohm
According to the design report to ensure the ground potential rise meets
the requirement the resistance of the earth at the load center must be: -
This condition will be achieved as R = 0.1353 ohm less than 0.143 ohm
Page 11 of 19
E. Interconnection of MV and LV Earths
The MV and LV earth electrodes shall be interconnected within the ground
via a disconnectable test link.
Then,
RT = 0.067 ohm
Page 12 of 19
Page 13 of 19
F. Calculation of Touch and Step Potentials
R = 0.4255 ohm
Then,
Page 14 of 19
G. Allowable touch and step potentials
BS7354 defines the following equations for calculating the allowable touch
and step potentials: -
Where:
Contact resistance = 3𝜌 Ω
Page 15 of 19
H. Current Density at Surface of Earth Electrode
Then,
J= 537 A/m2
Tabulating the above equation against the soil resistivity data from 3.6 to
12m within Table 1 gives the following:
Page 16 of 19
Considering a 16mm diameter earth electrode, its surface area is given
by:
𝑆𝐴=𝑙.𝜋 𝑑
Where:
and the earth fault current is 3000A, the minimum electrode length can
be calculated using the following formula:
𝑙≥ 3000/ .𝜋 𝑑
Where:
Page 17 of 19
Page 18 of 19
I. Appendices :
1- ATK005-422-C100-FD-X-RPT-0000: Design Report Load Centres
A, B, C and AC.
2- Appendix G. Earthing Calculations.
3- 422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010-B: MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING
GENERAL REQUIREMENTS.
Page 19 of 19
100% Design Report Load Centres A, B, C and AC
14. Earthing
The earthing design for each Load Centre will generally follow the guiding principles as defined in
Atkins Report 422-C240-FD-E-RPT-0004 which sets out the design basis for the Medium Voltage
and Low Voltage earthing systems. The earthing system is being designed in accordance with the
British Standard Code of Practice for Earthing BS 7430:1998 and also Section 7 Earthing of BS
7354:1990 and in particular the guidance given in this document regarding the management of
Step and Touch Potentials.
Load Centre A - Structural floor level is 7m above MSL with the design water table level at 4m
above MSL
Load Centre B - Structural floor level is 8.3m above MSL with the design water table level at 4.3m
above MSL
Load Centre C - Structural floor level is 26.5m above MSL with the design water table level at
20.75m above MSL
Load Centre AC - Structural floor level is 25.75m above MSL with the design water table level at
22m above MSL
Note: The design water table level is based on a long-term uncontrolled design of groundwater
level = existing groundwater level plus 2m. These levels are based on recommendations of HUTA
and are subject to final confirmation by them.
In order to take advantage of the ground water requires a relatively deep electrode system to be
installed and would need to be in some form of deep bored or driven electrode such as earth rods.
In such instances advantage can be taken of other deep structures such as re-inforced concrete
foundations or deep bored piles.
In respect of the Load Centres the foundation design of the majority of the buildings are
constructed from raft type foundations the depths of with are such that they will not necessarily sit
below the ground water table. Originally an architectural screen was proposed to be installed
around a number of the Load Centre buildings, the height of which necessitated the need for deep
bored piles to form the support for the foundation beam upon which the screen would sit. The piles
will generally be in accordance with the parameters as given below and depending on the footprint
of the particular Load Centre which would require in excess of 100 piles to be installed per Load
Centre.
The architectural screen is no longer part of the scope for the Load Centres however, it is
proposed to retain a number of the pile foundation in the design to form the primary MV and LV
earth electrodes.
Using an assumed worst case for Load Centre C where the ground water is typically just under 6
metres below the finished ground level would mean that for a 12.5 metre long pile the effective
length of pile within the water table would be 6.5 metres. Using the formulae from BS 7430:1998
and assumed resistivities of wet soil and concrete of 10 ohm metres and 30 ohm metres
respectively would give a typical effective resistance to earth for each pile of approximately 1.8Ω.
In accordance with Atkins report 422-C240-FD-E-RPT-0004 the maximum resistance of the earth
electrode shall be 0.143Ω in order to limit the maximum Ground Potential Rise to 430 volts. Thus
this value of earth electrode resistance could be achieved by connecting a minimum of 14 piles in
parallel to achieve the maximum required earth electrode resistance for both the MV and LV earth
electrodes. It shall be noted that the piles selected to be connected to the earth electrode system
shall be at least 13 metres apart (twice the effective length of the piled foundation) to ensure that
the maximum effectiveness of each pile is achieved and is not diminished by interaction with
adjacent piles.
It is therefore proposed that a minimum number of 16 piles per electrode will be used to form the
earth electrode using piles at each change of direction in the foundation. In other words 16 piles
will be used to form the MV earth electrode and a further 16 shall be used to form the LV electrode.
In addition a horizontal earth electrode will be installed buried typically at a depth of 2 metres below
finished ground level which will be used to interconnect each of the piles forming the earth
electrode and in addition will be laid around the perimeter of each of the primary buildings and
structures within the Load Centre. The horizontal earth electrode will be formed from either copper
strip or bare stranded copper conductor having a minimum cross sectional area of 120mm2. It is
envisaged that a minimum length of 1,500 metres of interconnecting conductor laid directly in the
ground will be required per Load Centre. Since this will typically be laid at a position in the ground
which is above the water table and assuming reasonably dry conditions at this level it is envisaged
the soil resistivity ‘seen’ by the horizontal electrode will be in the order of 200 ohm metres. Based
on the formulae in BS 7430:1998 this length of conductor and assumed soil resistivity would have
a typical effective resistance to earth of 0.8 ohms which can further contribute to an overall
lowering of the earth electrode resistance.
The calculation for Ground Potential Rise is shown in Appendix G. The configuration of earth
electrode as defined above gives a Ground Potential Rise of 215.6V.
Maximum Allowable Touch and Step potentials have been determined from Figure 3 (a) of BS
7354:1990 as set out below:
(V)
The above figures were determined using the most conservative values possible. It is clear that as
the Ground Potential Rise is less than the maximum allowable value for Touch potential – hence it
is unnecessary to calculate the Touch and Step potentials as clearly it is not possible for them to
exceed the limits shown in Table 22.
The alternative approach is to independently earth the fence and in such instances it has to be
ensured that the main earth electrode is a minimum distance from the fence (typically a minimum
of 3.0 metres). Since for the Load Centres the earth electrode will in the majority of the area be
quite significant distances from the fence and the touch and step potentials are well below the
acceptable limits it is proposed that the fence shall be independently earthed. This will be
achieved by employing earth rods of typical depths of 5.66metres (12 feet) driven into the ground
at each change of direction in the fence and also at maximum intervals of 100 metres in straight
sections of fences. Where the fence is not continuous such as at gate positions earth rods shall
also be located at either side of the break in continuity and an interconnecting conductor shall be
installed to connect the two earth rods together and maintain electrical continuity of the fence.
Separate MV and LV equipment earth bars will be installed in all equipment and plant rooms to
which all equipment earths, equipment metal work and all other extraneous and exposed
metalwork will be connected. These connections will be at sufficient intervals to ensure adequate
equipotential bonding of all exposed metalwork is achieved. This will be facilitated by the
installation of earthing distribution networks formed of bare copper strip affixed to walls at a
suitable levels and locations that will afford connections to be made from the various items of
equipment and plant and extraneous metalwork. These networks will be arranged such that the
equipment connections, etc to the earthing distribution system do not form obstructions, trip
hazards or any other impediment to the movement of people and equipment.
It is therefore proposed that connections shall be made to the re-inforcement steel at a number of
locations throughout all the various process plant buildings and facilities. It is proposed these
connections will be made at column positions and will use proprietary system that is exothermically
welded to the re-inforcement steel and is brought out to the face of the concrete as shown in the
detail below:
Connections will then be made from these re-inforcement connection points to the earthing system
distribution network.
Input Data
General
Soil resistivity 200 ohm metres
Concrete resistivity 30 ohm metres
Electrode Arrangement Coefficient
P Q
Horizontal Electrode Strip Round
Length of conductor 250 metres Single 2 -1.0 -1.3
Depth of earth electrode 2 metres Two lengths @ 90° 4 0.5 0.9
Width/diameter of earthing conductor 0.0175 metres Three lengths @ 120° 6 1.8 2.2
Electrode Arrangement Single Four lengths @ 90° 8 3.6 4.1
Electrode Type Round Factor F
Coefficient P 2 No. of lengths F
Coefficient Q - 1.3 2 0.611
No. of lengths in parallel 2 3 0.443
Spacing between electrodes 80 metres 4 0.362
Factor F 0.611
Input Data
General
Soil resistivity 10 ohm metres
Concrete resistivity 30 ohm metres
Output Notes
Structural Steelwork NB; Foundations need to be spaced at least two times the depth of the electrode to
ensure the effectiveness of each electrode is not diminished by interaction between
Resistance of one foundation 1.23 ohms adjacent electrodes
Resistance of multiple foundations 0.08 ohms
Date 15/11/2012
Prepared by C Prentice
Job No. 5101762
Project Title KAIA
Project Ref C100/
Calculation Sheet
Input Data
General Fault Clearance Time (s) 1
Soil resistivity ρ 200 ohm metres
Concrete resistivity ρ 30 ohm metres
Earth fault current I 3000 amps Allowable touch and Step
Resistance of grid to earth R 0.07 ohms Touch Voltage Vt 240 volts
Grid potential rise V 215.6 volts Step Voltage Vs 750 volts
Total length of buried conductor L 1500 metres
Diameter of buried conductor d 0.0175 metres
Depth of burial of grid h 2 metres
Spacing between parallel conductors D 150 metres
Notes
Output Allowable touch/step voltages for soil resistivity of 100Ωm has been conservatively used.
Touch Voltage Vt N/A volts
Step Voltage Vs 32.7 volts
Date 15/11/2012
Prepared by C Prentice
Job No. 5101762
Project Title KAIA
Project Ref C100/
Contact name: Phillip Norman
Address: P O Box 5668, Manama, Kingdom of Bahrain
Email: phillip.norman@atkinsglobal.com
Telephone: +973 1751 0400 / +973 3996 1420
The Atkins logo, ‘Carbon Critical Design’ and the strap line
‘Plan Design Enable’ are trademarks of Atkins Ltd.
Saudi Binladin Group
Final Design Report
MV Electrical
Earthing General Requirements
SBG/DAH Report No
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 1
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
Notice
This document and its contents have been prepared and are intended solely for Saudi Binladin Group’s
information and use in relation to King Abdulaziz International Airport.
[CONSULTANT] assumes no responsibility to any other party in respect of or arising out of or in connection
with this document and/or its contents.
Document History
JOB NUMBER:
TRACKER NUMBER:
Package 422
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 2
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
Table of Contents
Chapter pages
2. Introduction 6
3. Scope of Work 7
3.1. Deliverables 7
5. Earthing Design 10
5.1. Earth Connections from SEC Substations to Load Centres 10
5.2. Facilities with 13.8kV Connections 10
5.3. 13.8kV Cable Connections 11
5.4. Standards 12
5.5. Lightning Protection 12
5.6. Equipotential Bonding 12
5.7. Surge Arrestors 12
7. Summary 19
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 3
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
Tables
Figures
Figure 1 - Simplified Block Diagram for facility earth potential rise ................................................................. 15
Figure 2 - Earth connections to rebar in concrete ........................................................................................... 18
Figure 3 - Electrical Network Diagram for Facility Earth Model ....................................................................... 20
Appendix
D. CRS Responses 39
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 4
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
1.1. Abbreviations
[1] HV High Voltage, above 13.8kV;
[2] KAIA King Abdulaziz International Airport;
[3] LV Low Voltage, 0.4kV and below;
[4] MV Medium Voltage, between 0.4kV and 13.8kV;
[5] NEC National Electrical Code;
[6] NER Neutral Earthing Resistor;
[7] RFI Request for Information;
[8] SEC Saudi Electricity Company;
[9] Zsc Short circuit impedance;
[10] TT Earth is independent of earth from power source
[11] TNS Earth and Neutral conductors are separate from power source
1.2. References
All system design, installation and commissioning works must comply with the manufacturer’s
requirements, the requirements of authorities having jurisdiction and in accordance with the following
reference standards and relevant publications from the following internationally recognised organisations:
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 5
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
2. Introduction
The King Abdulaziz International Airport (KAIA) is expanding its runway and passenger capability. To
facilitate this expansion, a new Air Traffic Control tower, a new Passenger Terminal, Transport Facilities
and supporting buildings and shall be constructed. The new airport shall initially support up to 30 million
passengers per year, growing to 45 million in the first few years to an eventual capacity of 80 million
passengers per year.
This document describes the Generic Earthing for the General MV and LV Systems to be installed in the
King Abdulaziz International Airport to support the distribution of Electrical Power and provide a safe
environment for operators, passengers and equipment. The specific Earthing design will be completed by
the appropriate sections, this document providing an overall co-ordinated design basis. The Generic
Earthing for the General MV and LV System comprises earth busbars, earth rods, cable and terminations
to connect all metallic components of the System to an appropriate earth.
This document does not cover the requirements for earthing of telecommunication systems nor systems
requiring special earthing requirements. This design will be coordinated with the designs for the earthing
requirements for the telecommunications systems to ensure compatibility.
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 6
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
3. Scope of Work
The scope of work shall include, but not be limited to:
1) Provision of all generic earthing design necessary for the General MV and LV Systems. All
necessary components shall meet the requirements of 2008 NFPA-70 Article 250;
2) All design services, drawing and specifications, equipment, materials, labour and services, not
specifically mentioned or shown, which may be necessary to complete the generic design and
installation of the Earthing for General MV and LV Systems;
4) Generally comply with Exhibit “D” Section 260526 - Earthing and Bonding for Electrical Systems
3.1. Deliverables
The following are the deliverables for this package:
3) Earthing calculations.
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 7
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
4.3. MV / LV Transformers
The MV / LV transformers are proposed as: -
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 8
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
• Earthing on LV side: via an NER (Neutral Earthing Resistor) limiting the short circuit current
to 100A
• Delta / Star
The value of the NER can be calculated by considering the phase to neutral voltage, the required earth
current and then applying Ohm’s Law. This gives:
V = I.R
4.5. LV Network
The LV network is specified as 400/230V, 60Hz, 3 phase, 4 wire, solidly earthed.
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 9
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
5. Earthing Design
The Earthing Design shall be compliant with BS7430 - Code of practice for Earthing. The design shall ensure
the safe operation of the electrical network during normal and abnormal conditions and protection personnel
and equipment. The safe operation is demonstrated by calculations.
5.2.1. MV Earth
The MV earth will be achieved by a group of earth rods installed external to the building, the number
of rods depending on the ground conditions but not less than 2. These rods will be interconnected. A
minimum of 4m separation will be maintained between this rod group and any LV earthing.
At any location where the MV earth does not maintain the 4m separation from the LV earth, the MV
earth will be insulated to maintain the electrical isolation between the two systems.
The MV Main Earth Bar will be connected to MV Main Earth Bars in adjacent substations.
5.2.2. LV Earth
The LV earth will be achieved by a buried copper conductor surrounding the building to achieve a LV
Earth Loop. Duplicate stranded copper conductor cables will connect the LV Earth Loop back to the
LV Main Earth Bar. The LV Earth Loop will be supplemented with earth rods to achieve the required
LV Earth Resistance. The number of earth rods will be dependent on the ground conditions but the
minimum will be two earth rods.
Where practical, the LV Main Earth Bar will be connected to LV Main Earth Bars in adjacent
substations.
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 10
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 11
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
However, as per Section 2.6.3.2 of Specification ‘Aprons, Taxiways, Roads, Tunnels, Bridges, Load
Centres and Infrastructure, Transportation Centre and Supporting Facilities’ Exhibit “D” Part D1
requires a separate earth conductor installed in a separate duct: -
‘Medium Voltage: 13.8 kV and 4.16 kV, 60 Hz 3 phases, 3 wires, and ground (Ground
conductor is to be installed in a separate duct).’
2
Therefore for each 13.8kV cable connection a separate 120mm bare stranded copper conductor will
be installed. Where the cables are ducted, this conductor will be installed in a separate duct. The
function of this conductor is to duplicate the interconnection provided by the MV cable screens and
provide an interconnected MV earth network.
2
The MV Cable screens to the earth bar within the MV switchboards. The 120mm earth conductors
associated with the MV Cables will be connected to the MV Main Earth Bar.
As per Section 5.1, there is no earth connection between the SEC substations and the Load Centres.
Therefore a separate earth conductors shall be installed and the screens of the MV cables earthed
at the SEC substations via this separate conductor. A carefully coordinated design will be required to
ensure the MV cable screens are earthed without interconnection the KAIA and SEC earth systems.
Similarly, the MV cable support structures will require careful design to ensure they do not provide
an earth path between the KAIA and SEC substations.
5.4. Standards
When calculating the earth electrode resistance BS7430 considers the earth rods. It does not
consider the contribution from the buried electrode connecting the earth rods. Also, BS7430 does not
provide a means of calculating the touch and step potentials.
Given the length of conductor required for the load centre BS7430 would under-estimate the overall
electrode resistance.
Section 7 of BS7354 ‘Design of high-voltage open-terminal stations’ provides the equations
necessary to address these aspects. Therefore Section 7 of BS7354 will be used in the following
calculations.
Informative note: BS EN 50522 ‘Earthing of power installations exceeding 1kV AC’ is due for release
soon and will combine the earthing requirements from BS7430 and BS7354 into one document.
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 12
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
Soil
Soil Depth / Probe Maximum
Resistivity
Spacing Resistivity
Model
(m) (Ω.m)
(Ω.m)
5.4 85 34
8.1 25 22
12 6 6
20 4 4
The above table has been determined by considering the maximum measured values and the
second maximum measured value. The second maximum measured value is used for the soil
resistivity model for soil depths between 0.75 and 8.1m as the maximum value is a single value
which is unrepresentative of the bulk of measurements taken. We consider this to be a worst case
model and would expect the actual reading achieved on site to be no worse than the details
identified.
As per Specification 260526 clause 2.2 we seek the Engineer’s agreement to the soil model shown
in Table 1.
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 13
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
The Load Centre earth grid will achieve this value without considering the contribution from the
outgoing circuits and their associated earthing.
Also, in order to meet the requirements of Specification 260526 clause 2.4 (D) 6, the above rating
shall be achieved with the rod group with the lowest calculated resistance disconnected.
Both of the above points will mean the Load Centre earth resistance will, under normal conditions,
be less than 0.143Ω as required by BS7430 and therefore the MV and LV earths can be
interconnected.
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 14
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
IF
IR
Load Centre Facility VL
RL IL
RR
Key
120mm2 Cu Earth Conductor
47mm2 x 3 Cu MV Cable Screen
IF - Earth fault current
IR - Proportion of IF flowing to remote earth network
IL - Proportion of IF flowing to local earth network
VL - Voltage rise at local earth network
RL - Resistance of local earth network
RR - Resistance of remote earth network
RC - Resistance of earth conductors
RS - Resistance of MV cable screen
The voltage rise at the facility substation is calculated in Appendix A.1. This shows the maximum
acceptable total earth resistance at the facility substation is 0.28Ω.
Referring to Section 5.2 the target resistance for MV and LV earths is 1Ω. These target for MV and
LV earths must be reduced to 0.56Ω, the combination in parallel achieving the required earth
impedance.
The simplified block diagram in Figure 1 only considers 2 MV sets of MV cable screens and 2
associated earth conductors. In most installations the minimum will be 4 of each. Also, the simplified
block diagram does not consider additional substations along the feeder providing additional earthing.
These considerations indicate that the earth resistance stated is conservative.
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 15
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
resistivity values shown in Table 1, showing the minimum summated earth rod length required for
the various resistivities under fault conditions.
3.6 150.3
5.4 61.6
8.1 10.4
12 3.759
20 0.707
25 0.390
Earth rods 9m in length or less are considered shallow and driven. Earth rods greater than 9m in
length are considered deep.
To achieve the resistances required in Sections 6.3 and 6.4 and the surface current densities given
in Section 6.5 and Appendix A.2, it is clear that the lower resistivities provided by longer / deeper
earth rods will be required. As a practical observation, it is recommended that the minimum earth rod
length considered is in excess of 12m.
The earth rod resistances calculated above should be achieved across the whole KAIA site due to
the resistivity data used. The design could be optimised by taking electrical resistivity measurements
at individual facilities. In the majority of locations this will provide lower resistivity values and will
allow the design to be optimised.
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 16
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 17
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
Note: Whilst the calculations in Appendix A.9 consider the MV fault current, the connection to the
rebar is not intended to form part of the earth fault current path. This connection is intended to
ensure equipotential voltages during fault conditions to protect personnel and equipment.
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 18
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
7. Summary
This report shows how the requirements for the earthing as part of the KAIA installation can be met.
The report and calculations are based on the British Standard BS7430 as required by the revision to
Contract Exhibits D1 and D2. British Standard BS7354 has been used for equations to calculate the
touch and step potentials, as these calculations are not included within BS7430.
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 19
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
RC IR IF
RS
Key
RF RC 120mm2 Cu Earth Conductor
VL 47mm2 x 3 Cu MV Cable Screen
RS IF - Earth fault current
IR - Proportion of IF flowing to remote earth network
IL - Proportion of IF flowing to local earth network
VL - Voltage rise at local earth network
RR IR RL IL RL - Resistance of local earth network
RR - Resistance of remote earth network
RC - Resistance of earth conductors
RS - Resistance of MV cable screen
RF - Total feeder resistance
The resistance of the earth conductors and MV cable screens can be calculated by the following equation: -
𝑙
𝑅= 𝜌
𝐴
Where:
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 20
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
The combined resistance of the MV cable screens and the associated earth conductors can be
calculated as:
0.596 0.7
.
𝑅𝐹 = 2 2 = 0.16Ω
0.596 0.7
+
2 2
Using the model in Figure 3, the following equations can be determined using Ohms Law: -
𝑉𝐿 = 𝐼𝐿 . 𝑅𝐿
𝑉𝐿 = (𝐼𝐹 − 𝐼𝐿 ) (𝑅𝐹 + 𝑅𝑅 )
Solving gives:
𝐼𝐹 (𝑅𝐹 + 𝑅𝑅 )
𝐼𝐿 =
𝑅𝐿 + 𝑅𝐹 + 𝑅𝑅
𝑅𝐿 . 𝐼𝐹 (𝑅𝐹 + 𝑅𝑅 )
𝑉𝐿 =
𝑅𝐿 + 𝑅𝐹 + 𝑅𝑅
Where:
Rearranging:
𝑉𝐿 (𝑅𝐹 + 𝑅𝑅 )
𝑅𝐿 =
(𝐼𝐹 (𝑅𝐹 + 𝑅𝑅 ) − 𝑉𝐿 )
VL must be less than 430V to satisfy BS7430, IF is 3000A, RF is 0.16Ω and RR is 0.143Ω as per Section 6.3.
Solving the equation shows RL is required to be less than 0.28Ω to maintain the VL below the 430V limit.
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 21
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
57.7
J = 103 �
𝜌𝑡
Where:
2
J - [A/m ] The maximum current density of the earth electrode
Tabulating the above equation against the soil resistivity data from 3.6 to 12m within Table 1 gives
the following:
Allowable
Soil Resistivity Time
Current Density
(Ω.m) (sec)
(A/m2)
120 1 693
34 1 1303
22 1 1619
6 1 3101
4 1 3798
Considering a 16mm diameter earth electrode, its surface area is given by:
𝑆𝐴 = 𝑙. 𝜋 𝑑
Where:
and the earth fault current is 3000A, the minimum electrode length can be calculated using the
following formula:
3000
𝑙≥
𝐽 .𝜋 𝑑
Where:
2
J - [A/m ] The maximum current density of the earth electrode
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 22
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
Minimum
Allowable
Soil Resistivity Electrode
Current Density
(Ω.m) 2 Length
(A/m )
(m)
120 693 86
34 1303 46
22 1619 37
6 3101 19
4 3798 16
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 23
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
Based on the resistivity values in Table 1 the resistance of earth rods of various depths can be calculated
using Section 10.2 of BS7430: -
ρ 8L
R= 2πL
�ln � d � − 1� Section 10.2
Where:
ρ - [Ωm] Ground resistivity
L - [m] Length of rod
d - [m] Diameter of rod = 16mm
Given the resistivity model is layered, each section of earth rod is calculated and then the total rod resistance
is calculated by considering the sections in parallel (sections of earth rod with resistance greater than 100Ω
are not included in the total rod resistance):
20 8 0.871 0.707
25 5 0.869 0.390
Earth rods 9m in length or less are considered shallow and driven. Earth rods greater than 9m in length are
considered deep.
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 24
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
Where:
R - [Ω] Resistance of single rod, as Appendix A.3
ρ
α=
2πRs
s - [m] Distance between rods
𝜆 - Is stated in BS7430 in Tables 2 and 3 for the various configurations
n - number of earth rods
Giving: -
12m Rods
Equilateral
Item Hollow square Straight Line Units
Triangle
n 3 2 3 4 5
s 24 24 24 24 24 m
𝜌 22 22 22 22 22 Ωm
Number of
Electrodes 3 4 8 4 5
Total Length of
Electrode* 11.7 15.6 31.2 15.6 19.5 m
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 25
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
20m Electrodes
Equilateral
Item Hollow square Straight Line Units
Triangle
n 3 2 3 3 4
s 40 40 40 40 40 m
𝜌 6 6 6 6 6 Ωm
Number of
Electrodes 3 4 8 3 4
Total Length of
Electrode* 24 32 64 24 32 m
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 26
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
1 𝛿 2𝐿
𝑅= �(𝜌𝑐 − 𝜌) 𝑙𝑜𝑔𝑒 �1 + � + 𝜌 𝑙𝑜𝑔𝑒 � ��
2𝜋𝐿 𝑧 𝑧
Where:
a s
Gives:
8
𝑧 = �52 . 𝑎 . 𝑠 7
Where:
ρc = 30Ωm
δ = 0.15m
a = 0.006m
s = 0.2m
and the values of resistivity given in Table 1, allows the following values to be calculated:
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 27
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
𝜌 22 6 4 Ωm
L 12 8 5 m
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 28
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
𝐼 √𝑡
𝑆= Section 14
𝑘
Where:
2
S - [mm ] Conductor cross sectional area
I - [A] Fault current
t - [sec] Fault current duration
k - Constant from Table 10 of BS7430
The fault current is rated at earth fault current for the MV installation and LV installation. The fault duration is
o
as per 260526 Section 2.5 (G), which also specifies the maximum final temperature of 160 C enabling k to
be looked up in Table 10 of BS7430. These give: -
I 3,000 40,000 A
2
Specification 260526 Section 2.5 (G) states the minimum earth conductor to be 120mm and hence this size
is selected for the MV network.
Where:
k - [A/mm2] Current density
o
𝑇1 - [ C] Initial temperature
o
𝑇2 - [ C] Final temperature
K and 𝛽 are material specific constants (for copper 226 and 254 respectively)
2
Using the above equations it is possible to calculated the final temperature of a 120mm conductor with a
o o
3000A fault for 1 second and an initial temperature of 40 C. This gives a final temperature of 43.6 C .
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 29
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
𝜌𝑉 1 1 1− 0.5𝑛−2
𝑉𝑇 =
𝜋𝑅𝐿
�ln ��ℎ⁄𝑑 � + �2ℎ + 𝐷+ℎ
+
𝐷
�� 𝑘𝑖 - Equation [17]
𝜌𝑉 1 1 1− 0.5𝑛−2
𝑉𝑠 = � + + � 𝑘𝑖 - Equation [20]
𝜋𝑅𝐿 2ℎ 𝐷+ℎ 𝐷
Where:
k i = (0.15n + 0.7)
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 30
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
Where:
Contact resistance = 3𝜌 Ω
It is taken from curve c2, Figure 5 of PD 6519-1:1988. At 1 second this can be taken as
50mA.
50 154 465
Alternatively, Figure 3(a) in BS7354 graphs allowable touch and step potentials as a function of the duration
of the fault. Taking the maximum time of 1 second and the minimum resistivity value gives VT < 240V and VS
< 720V.
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 31
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
If
Amm² = [Equ 10-13]
TCAP x 10−4 K +T
�� � .ln� o m �
tc .αr .ρr K o + Ta
Where:
Ta = 40 ºC
αr = 0.0016
ρr = 15.9 µΩ.cm
t c = 1 sec.
TCAP = 3.28
K o = 605
o
This calculation shows that to limit the temperature rise of the rebar to 55 C will require a cross sectional
area of 174mm² or greater. 16mm diameter rebar has a cross sectional area of approximately 200mm² and
therefore will meet this requirement.
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 32
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
1
𝑥 = 𝑟 �� � − 1�
𝜋𝑉𝑥
𝑎𝑟𝑐 sin
2𝑉
Where
x - [m] is the distance from the edge of the grid to the extent of the hot zone
Within the UK the value of Vx it usually taken as either 430V or 690V. As both the load centres and the
package substations are designed to maintain the ground potential rise below 430V the hot zone is
maintained within the earth electrode and the calculation of the zone is unnecessary.
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 33
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 34
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 35
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
The apparent resistivity column is left blank where the resistance reading is 0.
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 36
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 37
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 38
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
D. CRS Responses
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 39
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
9. Clause A8:
a. Provide the criteria on which the MV screen C.S.A is considered to be 285 mm2.
b. Indicate the reference standard where the ground potential rise formula is derived.
Contractors Response:
a. The screen of the MV cable has been changed based on a previous DAH comment.
The screen size is 47mm2 per core or 141mm2 per trefoil. The report will be
updated.
b. The ground potential rise is calculated by applying Ohm's Law to Figure 3.
10. Clause A10: Soil resistivity is 140 Ω -m while it has never been measured nor in
accordance with the values used throughout the report, Contractor is to clarify.
Contractors Response: The resistivity will be updated based on the response to item
6 inspect of this report.
Also the calculations will be expanded to include alternative values of z (this defines the
quantity and arrangement of rebars within the concrete) which will align with the
structural design for the piles which will be installed on site.
11. Indicate the ratings / sizes or dimensions of the equipotential copper busbars within MV
and LV rooms as per the related short circuit calculations.
Contractors Response: This will be included in the updated report.
12. Indicate the surge arrestors earthing.
Contractors Response: This will be included in the updated report.
13. Using 21 meter deep driven earth electrodes for load center peripheral earthing system
needs to be revisited considering the existing soil conditions.
Contractors Response: Noted. The load centre earthing design will change based on
the measured earth resistivity and the availability of earth connections to the piles for
the visual screening.
14. 45kA ground-fault level shown on page 28 must be substantiated by explicit calculation.
Contractors Response: The LV fault level will be changed to 40kA to align with the
maximum switchgear ratings. Calculations are provided in Report ref. no. 422-C240-DF-
E-RPT-00001 demonstrating the fault level to be lower than 40kA.
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 40
MV ELECTRICAL EARTHING GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
Contact name
Address
Email:
Telephone:
Direct telephone:
Fax:
ATK002-422-C240-FD-E-RPT-00010 41