Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ASSESSMENT 2:
PROJECT BASED
LEANRING
Rabia Deeb
17464491
PBL Unit Plan
Unit Title: ‘The Universe’ Total Duration of
the Unit (in hours):
5 Weeks
Subject: Earth and Space (ES) Teacher(s): 1 teacher Grade Level:
9
Other subject areas to be included, if any:
(For cross-curricular PBL)
Outcomes
Outcome Type Outcome Code and Descriptor
SC5-1VAappreciates the importance of science in their lives and the role of scientific inquiry in
increasing understanding of the world around them
SC5-2VAshows a willingness to engage in finding solutions to science-related personal, social and
Values and attitudes global issues, including shaping sustainable futures
SC5-3VAdemonstrates confidence in making reasoned, evidence-based decisions about the current
and future use and influence of science and technology, including ethical considerations
SC5-4WS Develops questions or hypotheses to be investigated scientifically
SC5-6WSundertakes first-hand investigations to collect valid and reliable data and information,
individually and collaboratively
SC5-7WSprocesses, analyses and evaluates data from first-hand investigations and secondary
sources to develop evidence-based arguments and conclusions
SC5-8WSapplies scientific understanding and critical thinking skills to suggest possible solutions to
identified problems
SC5-9WSpresents science ideas and evidence for a particular purpose and to a specific audience,
using appropriate scientific language, conventions and representations
SC5-12ESdescribes changing ideas about the structure of the Earth and the universe to illustrate
Knowledge and how models, theories and laws are refined over time by the scientific community
understanding
ES1 Scientific understanding, including models and theories, are contestable and are refined over
time through a process of review by the scientific community.
a. outline some of the major features contained in the universe, including galaxies, stars, solar
systems and nebulae
b. describes, using examples, some technological developments that have advanced scientific
understanding about the universe
d. identify that all objects exert a force of gravity on all other objects in the universe
Sustainability
Cross curriculum Sustainability is concerned with the ongoing capacity of the Earth to maintain all life. It provides
priorities authentic contexts for exploring, investigating and understanding systems in the natural and made
environments.
Assessment
What am I looking for? How will I know the students have achieved these goals? How will we use formative assessment to give students feedback during the unit?
Include project rubric(s) and an assessment plan so that students know how they will be assessed.
Rubric(s)/Assessment Activity Outcome Code Formative or Individual or Group?
Summative?
KWL Chart SC5-12ES Formative Individual
This activity is designed to assess the students’ SC5-8WS
knowledge and understanding of the project. It allows
the teacher to have a rough idea of their students’
knowledge and where they need improvement and help.
Scenario Challenge
Real or imaginary scenario within which the project will take place A description of task as it is presented to the students
The existence of Earth is coming to an end, and oxygen levels Your role is to work alongside scientists and astronauts to
are decreasing. People are urged to have to leave their homes in present prototypes for an invention that will help humans to
order to survive. In the media there has been talk about moving safely explore Mars, in order to determine if people can survive
to the Red Planet. living on the Red planet.
Driving Question
For the teacher: A question that helps initiate and focus the inquiry
For the student: A question that creates interest and a feeling of challenge and guides the project work
How can humans safely explore Mars in order to determine if it is possible to survive living on the planet?
What measures will have to be taken into consideration?
What tools and resources will help you in constructing your idea/model on how to explore Mars?
Entry Event Incursion: Students will be granted the opportunity to speak to an expert from NASA through
skype. Through this experience, students will be able to ask their desired questions to the expert,
and can use this knowledge to help guide their existing ideas on the project.
Excursion: Students will be provided with the opportunity to attend an excursion to the Gravity
discovery center and Observatory. This experience will help consolidate the students understanding
of gravity. Throughout this excursion, students will be able to participate in a range of activities on
the universe and its gravitational forces.
Part 1: Students will be required to construct a 3D model of their inventions on how to safely
Products explore Mars. Students must ensure that they meet the assessments criteria when constructing
their models and presenting them.
Part 2: Students will have to provide their teachers with a hard copy of a 1000-word group
reflection at the end of their presentation of their models. The objectives of the reflection is to allow
students to describe the process on the creation of their models and the ideas associated with it. As
well as their experience.
Public Audience Science Fair: In Week five students will be expected to present their models (E.g. verbally, video,
written forms) to an audience at a Science Fair. The audience will include their peers, teachers and
(Experts, audiences, or product users
students will engage with during/at end a panel of expert Science Pioneers. At the end of their presentations students will be peer
of project) assessed on their models/ideas presented.
Resources and Resources: Throughout the course of this project students will be provided week by week, with
content on ‘The Universe’ that will increase their understanding and approach to the project. These
Materials Needed resources may include:
- Timeline- to help students with time management and help them meet their goals on time
- ICT components- Padlet, Kahoot and Nearpod to examine students understanding and help
guide any confusion, misconceptions/understanding
Materials: Basic materials will be provided to students; these may include:
- Elastic bands, tape, glue and popsicle sticks.
Teaching/Learning Strategies and Tools
Outline the strategies and resources that will support students’ completion of the unit
Essential knowledge
and skills Week 1: Introduce topic of focus- ‘The Project’
What knowledge and/or
skills are going to be used to KWL Chart with explicit teaching where required
enable the student to
respond to the driving
question? Students will be required to write down the scenario, challenge and driving questions of the project. They
How will these be taught will then be required to highlight key words and complete a KWL chart in regards to the project.
and/or scaffolded?
KWL Chart: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1IQheDEwWow2QPXGEDDA68vRxonTGBX-E
Teacher will then discuss the project and the expectations required of the students. As a class a discussion
will take place to address what students already know and what they would like to know.
Teacher will allocate students into their project groups with their roles. Students will be divided into groups of
four and the roles will include:
- Recorder
- Observer and reporter
- Time manager
- Researcher
In order to maintain group dynamic students will be expected to create a ‘Team Charter’, comprising of their
expectations of one another and standards. Each student will be expected to sign upon agreement of the
Charter. In this Chater students must include:
- How they will tackle challenges within the group?
- How they will monitor that roles and responsibilities are adhered to?
Students will be expected at the end of each week to submit a reflective statement about the group
dynamic, upon the completion students must provide this to the teacher. Teachers can use this in order to
determine the relationship of the group and their progress in the project.
Project timeline
Each project group will be provided with a project timeline. Students will be expected to refer back to this
timeline throughout the project in order to ensure that they are meeting goals and targets within the
recommended times stated. This will also provide teachers with an insight into the group dynamic and
allows them to also assess students’ progress thus enabling them to provide feedback and advice when
required.
Timeline: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1R-SYZFwtBpvid5ThtAnSB_VBSXA05rUq
As a formative assessment student’s previous knowledge will be tested through a Kahoot quiz, comprising
of stage four outcomes.
Upon the completion of the Quiz a class discussion will take place. Students will be required to discuss their
answers and the questions covered in the quiz.
Students will be provided with individual topics for their expert group (expert groups are the
students project groups), groups will be required to research their topics and will have to generate a
summary and present it to the class. Students will be peer assessing their peer’s expert groups
summaries when presented.
Topics that will be divided among the expert groups will include:
- Some nebulae are objects within our galaxy and some are objects outside it
- A Concept map
Students will have to upload their summaries in a document on a Google slides, these slides will be
presented to the class by the expert groups and peers will assess the structure of the summaries
presented. Teacher will provide constructive feedback and explicitly teach any misconceptions that
may arise.
To further increase students’ knowledge on major features of the universe students will observe a series of
simulations. Following this as a class students will discuss how this can help improve their project ideas or
generate new ones.
In their allocated groups students will collaborate their ideas and proposal plans for their 3D models.
Students will be required to draw their plans (2D Form) and ideas and submit this copy to the teacher in
order to receive feedback as part of formative assessment.
Teacher will construct a visual PowerPoint presentation on Space technology used by NASA to explore
space. Students will be required to note take in order to broaden their understanding of the Project and
develop new ideas.
As a class a discussion will take place and the teacher will ask students a series of questions about the
PowerPoint presentation, these may include:
- Have these developments aided your understanding? If yes, why and how?
- Have these technologies helped you understand how you’d want to construct your model/invention?
Nearpod link: https://share.nearpod.com/KEIMbwaAkW
(NOTE* Weblink might take a little while to open, but eventually will. Thank you )
Student centered activity to help enhance project ideas and proposal plans
Teacher will provide students with a YouTube video on ‘NASA Technology’ this video will be used to help
improve and enhance student’s proposal ideas for their models. In the student’s project groups, they will be
required to extract key ideas from the video and if need be use it to modify their plans and as part of
formative assessment present their new plans and ideas to the teacher in written or drawn form.
Project based Group work: Student led first hand investigation with guided instruction where
required
As part of a means of expression (UDL), in their project groups students will use their prior knowledge, ideas
and proposal plans and design and implement a practical investigation to test and determine whether their
models will be effective when exposed to different environmental factors mimicking the conditions on Mars
(E.g. gravity).
- Stability
- Durability
- Sustainability
Upon the completion of the experiment students will be required to formulate a scientific report on their
experimental procedure and their findings and use the report as a guide to improve parts of their proposed
models. As part of formative assessment students will be required to submit this report as a group to the
teacher and in return will receive constructive feedback on their new proposed ideas and modifications.
Students will be required to participate in a brainstorming activity to help strengthen their knowledge on
Gravity. In this activity students are required to take notes and collaboratively as a class discuss and share
ideas on the term gravity and its influence on exploring Mars.
In their allocated groups students will be required to summarize an article on ‘Gravity’. Students will have to
summarize the article in written form and share their notes with the class. Upon the completion of this
activity students will be required to present their notes to the class, as a class students can discuss what
they took from the article and what benefit it has on their existing model/ideas.
Article: ‘The role of gravity in human walking: pendular energy exchange, external work and optimal speed’
https://physoc.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1111/j.1469-7793.2000.00657.x
Students will be provided with the opportunity to go on an excursion to visit the Gravity discovery center and
Observatory. This will help strengthen the students understanding on Gravity and its components. At the
Centre students will be able to participate in a range of fun and interesting activities such as:
- Explore the Discovery Gallery, students will be able to learn about fundamental forces in regards to
Gravity and the waves present within the Universe.
- Tower Climb and Analysis: In this activity students will be able to climb a tower and conduct an
experiment on Galileo Galilei’s gravity.
Students will be expected to take notes while they explore the center and participate in the activities. After
the excursion students will have to provide their teacher with a short paragraph on their experience at the
Centre and how their new knowledge will help modify, further develop and construct their models.
Week 5: Presentation of Inventions/Models
In their allocated groups students will be expected to present their models, in their desired presentation form
(written, spoken, PowerPoint, audio, video) to their peers and panel of expert NASA pioneers at a Science
Fair. At the end of the presentation students are expected to provide their teachers with a hard copy of their
group reflections on the construction process of their models.
Summative assessment
The student’s models will be assessed by the teacher. Teacher is required to provide students will
constructive feedback on the structure of their model.
At the end of the project each group is to submit one hard copy of a reflection to their teacher. The reflection
must cover the following questions:
- How has this project helped shape your understanding of the universe?
- What was one thing you found most difficult?
- How would you want to improve your model for future reference?
- Did you enjoy this project, what was your favorite aspect and what was your least favorite?
- What strategies did you use to analyze your data, findings and observations?
Time management Timeline
What strategies will you use
to help students complete - Students will be provided with a timeline to help them organize their time in order to ensure that they
the project on time? meet the requirements of the project before the dead line.
- Each week students will have to go over the timeline as a group and discuss whether their on track
and if not must implement strategies to help them achieve their goals.
- The timeline will also provide students with the ability to speak to their teachers on where they feel
stuck in order to receive guidance on how to tackle particular setbacks.
Students will be expected to complete a reflective statement on the group dynamic each week in order to
ensure that responsibilities are being met and goals are being achieved. This will also provide teachers with
an insight into the groups progress and can help the teacher establish methods to encourage the
development of the student’s social skills within the group.
ICT Scaffold
How will you guide students
to use technology effectively
In order to ensure that technology is used effectively for researching and presenting, teacher will scaffold
in researching and presenting
their project? how to effectively use ICT components responsibly and proficiently. Teacher will provide students with a set
of expectations that must be compiled with when using technology to conduct research and presentations.
Excursion: Students are provided with the opportunity to visit the Gravity discovery center and Observatory.
This experience will allow students to gain a deeper understanding of the concept of gravity and how and
where to apply it to their models.
Incursion: Students are able to skype experts from NASA, this provides them with the ability to ask
questions and use the feedback to enhance their undertraining of the project.
First hand investigation: Students are expected to create a first-hand investigation to test aspects of their
models. The data collected allows students to make modifications to their models where required and also
consolidates their understanding of the project.
Expert groups: Expert groups allows students to experience a role other than their roles of students. It
allows them to take control to an extent and dictate their learning.
These activities/experiences are significant for differentiation because it provides the students with the
ability to contribute and further their understanding of the content through their personal strengths. It also
provides students with the ability to express their understanding of content through a variety of mediums.
Resource checklist:
(Attach all relevant resources to the program)
Project schedule/calendar/timeline
- Week 1 Timeline: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1R-SYZFwtBpvid5ThtAnSB_VBSXA05rUq
Scaffolds (may support development of essential knowledge and skills, self-management, group management, etc)
- Week 1 Timeline: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1R-SYZFwtBpvid5ThtAnSB_VBSXA05rUq
- Week 3 Nearpod : https://share.nearpod.com/KEIMbwaAkW
- Week 2 Peer assessment: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1seSzeUfogGD0YqfneXwIiOPhiSkWU2IJ
Rationale
Project based learning (PBL) is becoming a highly prevalent teaching and learning strategy within the 21st century, it provides students
with the opportunity to deepen their learning and establish a variety of skills that enable them to question and research (Aitken, 2019). In
basic terms PBL can be described as a student-centred strategy that provides students with the opportunity to learn about a particular
focus topic and in groups are expected to use their problem solving skills to unfold open-ended problems (Nilson, 2010). PBL differs from
the traditional strategies of teaching in that the teacher becomes the facilitator and the style of learning becomes more collaborative and hands on
driven by real-world relations (Aitken, 2019). There are a variety of benefits associated with PBL, however the most common ones include, an
increase in both student and teacher motivation, positive student attitudes and an increased connection between concepts and the real world
(Boaler, 1998). A variety of schools throughout NSW are using PBL successfully and are noticing a decrease in negative student behaviour. This
theory can be supported by a study by Creghan & Adair-Creghan (2015), which state that PBL has the ability to positively impact student attendance
and behvaiour due to a students sparked interest and relation of school work to the real world.
This paper will highlight the use of PBL in the unit of work attached above. The chosen focus topic for this project is about ‘The Universe’, with
particular focus to the Red Planet (Mars). This focus topic was mainly chosen due to its ability to be highly relatable to the real world, as students
use their knowledge of Earth and Space to construct their ideas. Through the use of PBL students will be provided with a scenario, challenge and
discovery questions to guide their thoughts and ideas on the project. These can be used as a guides to challenge the student’s way of thinking as it
enables them to think outside the box, and encourages and motivates students to build their own creativity (Creghan & Adair-Creghan (2015). The
approach of inquiry based learning can also be observed within the unit of work, as students are provided with a variety of opportunities to control
and construct their own learning. Guided inquiry, ‘is not simply answering questions and getting the right answers; it engages, interests and
challenges students to connect their world with the curriculum’ (Kuhlthau, Maniotes, & Caspari, 2015). This type of inquiry can be observed in the
unit of work above, for example students in week three are expected to create their own first hand investigation. This task is designed to enable
students to determine the effectiveness of their models by mimicking the environmental conditions of Mars. Throughout this task, limited teacher
involvement is present as the teacher will only guide students when required. Therefore, this enables students to critically think and reflect upon
their problem solving skills in order to approach this task successfully.
An additional example of inquiry based learning can be observed in week two of the unit of work, in a student centered expert group task. This task
enables students to control their way of questioning research resources and allows students to examine and compare their answers collaboratively.
In doing this task, students are able to teach one another, interact collaboratively and share ideas, challenges and strengths (Ann, Doris, Martha,
Kathryn, Ann & Joseph, 1997). A component of this task is also to get students to present their research summaries to the class, and would be peer
assessed at the end. The strategy of peer assessment is used because it, ‘can help learners to understand what their learning goals are, what
approaches are needed to meet the goals, and make their revisions more effective’ (Meusen-Beekman, Joosten-ten & Boshuize, 2015). An
alternative advantaged of peer assessment, is that it promotes student’s self-regulation, as it enables students to create peer-to-peer feedback that
is both easy to understand and access through peer communication. It also enhances a student’s ability to share responsibility, discuss, collaborate
and reflect on ideas (Birenbaum, 1996).
Components of Information and Communication Technology (ICT) are used throughout the unit of work/project to enhance the students
understanding of the content and project objectives. For example, in week three, a digital artifact, ‘Nearpod’ was used as an interactive tool to not
only present a PowerPoint presentation to students but to also increase their participation through answering questions and collaboratively
contributing their ideas. This type of teaching strategy is also incorporated in order to correlate with the principals of Universal design for learning
(UDL). UDL can be understood as a teaching approach that constructs specific pedagogies and curricular activities that are compatible with the
learning needs of a diverse range of students (Loreman, Deppeler and Harvey, 2011). It entails three significant principals these include, providing
students with multiple means of representations, expressions and engagement (CAST, 2014). A means of representation can be observed in the
incorporation of the ICT component, as students are provided with the opportunity to view information not only through a PowerPoint format but also
through an interact technological format. The principal of means of engagement can be observed as the ICT activity can increase the student’s
motivation and spark their interest as they are able to interact and share their ideas and not just examine a ordinary PowerPoint presentation.
In conclusion, it is evident that PBL and its effectiveness has a significant impact on a student’s learning environment. It enhances the student’s
confidence in their learning and provides students with the ability to gain essential life skills such as, problem solving skills, critical thinking skills and
creative skills. In the creation of this unit of work and project, the main goal was to ensure that students are able to engage in challenges that allow
students to think outside the box. This goal was reinforced through the use of pedagogical and learning framework approaches such as, inquiry
based learning and ICT components. Thus, PBL is the future of greater teaching and learning environments, not only at a school level but at a
community level.
References
Ann, L. B., Doris, A., Martha, R, Kathryn, N., Ann, G. & Joseph, C. C. (1997). (pp. 188-193). The Pitt Building, UK: Cambridge
University Press. Retrieved from, https://books.google.com.au/books?
hl=en&lr=&id=m8Yna0cjxAgC&oi=fnd&pg=PA188&dq=expert+groups+in+classrroms&ots=-
uCx4UvQKp&sig=xMxcX7DCFNiWbvDNLPrEZbGn9wM#v=onepage&q=expert%20groups%20in%20classrroms&f=false
Aitken, L. (2019). Teacher perspectives on using project-based learning. Teacher magazine. Retrieved from
https://www.teachermagazine.com.au/articles/teacher-perspectives-on-using-project-based-learning
Birenbaum, M. (1996). Assessment 2000: Towards a pluralistic approach to assessment. Alternatives in assessment of achievements,
learning processes and prior knowledge (pp. 3-29). Boston, MA: Kluwer Academic. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.stueduc.2007.01.004
Boaler, J. (1998). Open and Closed Mathematics: Student Experiences and Understandings. Journal for Research in Mathematics
Education, 29(1), 41-62. DOI: 10.2307/749717
CAST. (2014). The Three Principles. National Center On Universal Design for Learning. Udlcenter.org. Retrieved from
http://www.udlcenter.org/aboutudl/whatisudl/3principles
Creghan, C., & Adair-Creghan, K. (2015). The Positive Impact of Project-Based Learning on Attendance of an Economically
Disadvantaged Student Population: A Multiyear Study. Interdisciplinary Journal of Problem-Based Learning, 9(2), 1-9. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.7771/1541-5015.1496
Kuhlthau, C. C., Maniotes, L. K. & Caspari, A. K. (2015). Guided inquiry: What is it? Why now? What’s new? (pp. 50-76). Santa
Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO, LLC. Retrieved from, https://books.google.com.au/books?
hl=en&lr=&id=LxCFCgAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PP1&dq=define+guided+inquiry&ots=-
9EVuqQ0Mp&sig=sozdwItOwy18aJiv6o0PFKjRBPk#v=onepage&q=define%20guided%20inquiry&f=false
Loreman, T., Deppeler, J., and Harvey, D. (2nd ed.). (2011). Inclusive education: Supporting diversity in the classroom. Crows Nest,
Australia: Allen & Unwin.
Meusen-Beekman, K. D., Joosten-ten Brinke, D., & Boshuizen, H. P. A. (2015). Developing young adolescents’ self-regulation by means
of formative assessment: A theoretical perspective. Cogent Education, 2(1), 1071233.
https://doi.org/10.1080/2331186X.2015.1071233
Nilson, L. B. (2010). Teaching at its best: A research-based resource for college instructors. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.