You are on page 1of 6

THE AMERICAN JOURNAL OF GASTROENTEROLOGY Vol. 95, No.

1, 2000
© 2000 by Am. Coll. of Gastroenterology ISSN 0002-9270/00/$20.00
Published by Elsevier Science Inc. PII S0002-9270(99)00730-3

Ampullary Obstruction
Monitoring in Acute Gallstone
Pancreatitis: A Safe, Accurate, and Reliable
Method to Detect Pancreatic Ductal Obstruction
Juan M. Acosta, M.D., Gustavo D. Ronzano, M.D., and Carlos A. Pellegrini, M.D.
Departamento de Cirugı́a, Facultad de Ciencias Médicas, Universidad Nacional de Rosario, Rosario,
Argentina; and Department of Surgery, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to determine the value INTRODUCTION
of ordinary clinical and laboratory data, including the mon-
itoring of ampullary gallstone obstruction in the early There is substantial experimental (1, 2) and clinical (3– 6)
evidence that ampullary gallstone obstruction not only ini-
phases of the disease, in the diagnosis of acute gallstone
tiates but also maintains and aggravates biliary pancreatitis.
pancreatitis (AGP).
A previous study from our institution comprising 97 patients
METHODS: One hundred and thirty-two patients were with acute gallstone pancreatitis (AGP) secondary to gall-
studied. The inclusion criteria were admission within 48 h stone impaction at the ampulla showed that the duration of
from the onset of symptoms, clinical presentation com- ampullary obstruction is a major factor determining the
patible with AGP, bile-free gastric aspirate, elevation of severity of pancreatic injury. The incidence of severe pan-
serum amylase and bilirubin, and ultrasonographic dem- creatic injury was 10.6% in patients when obstruction lasted
onstration of cholelithiasis. Monitoring of ampullary ⬍48 h, and 84.6% in those whose obstruction persisted ⬎48
obstruction included severity of pain, presence of bile in h (7).
the gastric aspirate, and serial serum bilirubin determi- During the last decade a number of authors have advo-
nations. The clinical diagnosis of AGP was confirmed or cated the diagnostic and therapeutic value of endoscopic
excluded by surgical exploration, and that of ampullary retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP) in patients
obstruction by intraoperative cholangiography (IOC) with AGP (8 –12). At present, there is no doubt that patients
or endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography with severe or worsening pancreatitis associated with biliary
(ERCP). obstruction will benefit from this procedure. However, such
patients are a minority, as in most patients gallstones mi-
RESULTS: The overall accuracy of the diagnostic tests for grate spontaneously within 48 h and the process resolves
AGP was high: sensitivity, 0.94; specificity, 0.99; positive rapidly and completely by itself.
predictive value, 0.95; and negative predictive value, 0.99. A confounding factor is the impossibility of predicting
Detection of spontaneous ampullary decompression was which patients will pass their stones spontaneously (and
correct in 100% of the patients, and that of ampullary promptly) and which will not. Performing emergency ERCP
obstruction, in 61%. The accuracy of this test was sensitiv- (i.e., ⬍48 h) routinely subjects all patients to the morbidity
ity, 1.0; specificity, 0.92; positive predictive value, 0.61; and and mortality of this procedure (13, 14), although the ma-
negative predictive value, 1.0. jority would not be expected to benefit from it.
Several methods to detect gallstone impaction at the am-
CONCLUSIONS: Clinical criteria and ordinary laboratory de- pulla have been advocated. In 1981 Coppa et al. (15) re-
terminations are sufficiently accurate to discriminate be- ported the results of percutaneous transhepatic cholangiog-
tween patients with AGP and those with other acute raphy (PTC). In 1983 Neoptolemos et al. (16) and in 1996
abdominal pathologies. Careful monitoring of patients’ Bolognese et al. (17) studied radioisotopic imaging of the
pain, quality of nasogastric aspirate, and serum bilirubin biliary tree in patients with pancreatitis and suspected com-
level can accurately identify the few cases with persistent mon bile duct stones. These methods are either cumbersome
ampullary obstruction. Those patients can then be se- or involve risk, the number of patients studied was small,
lected for intervention to restore the ampullary patency and the results were equivocal.
and prevent progression of acute pancreatitis. (Am J We conducted a prospective study that included 132
Gastroenterol 2000;95:122–127. © 2000 by Am. Coll. of consecutive patients with acute pancreatitis and biliary ob-
Gastroenterology) struction who were seen within 48 h from the onset of
AJG – January, 2000 Ampullary Obstruction Monitoring in AGP 123

symptoms. This study was performed to assess the value of Ranson et al.’s criteria showed that 101 patients did not
ordinary clinical and laboratory data in establishing the have any of the risk factors, 29 patients presented one or two
diagnosis of AGP, and to predict the course of gallstone risk factors, and the remaining two patients presented with
obstruction of the ampulla in the initial phases of the dis- three.
ease. We expected that if these methods established a con-
fident diagnosis of ampullary gallstone obstruction during Study Design
an attack of pancreatitis, they would provide the stimulus for All patients in this series were considered eligible at admis-
early intervention to remove the offending stone. sion for early ampullary stone disimpaction no later than
48 h from the onset of symptoms. That limit was chosen on
MATERIALS AND METHODS the basis that beyond it, the expected incidence of severe
pancreatic lesions increases significantly (7). To measure
Inclusion Criteria duration of ampullary obstruction, the time of its onset
Acute pancreatitis was assumed to have a biliary origin if (assumed as the time of the onset of symptoms) was care-
the patient presented with an appropriate clinical picture, fully and systematically investigated and recorded in every
and cholelithiasis was seen on ultrasound scan at admission, patient.
or there was a history of previous cholecystectomy for Initial therapy consisted of analgesics (hyoscine butil-
cholelithiasis. In addition, patients had to meet the following bromuro, 20 mg i.v.), intravenous fluids, broad-spectrum
inclusion criteria: admission within 48 h after the onset of antibiotics (ampicillin, 1 g i.v. every 6 h, and gentamicin, 80
symptoms, bile-free gastric aspirate, elevation of serum
mg i.v. every 8 h) and nasogastric suction. Monitoring of
amylase level at least two times the upper normal value
ampullary obstruction was done using three parameters:
(120 ⫾ 2.5 U/dl, by the method of Smith and Roe [18]),
severity of the disease, particularly intensity of abdominal
elevation of serum bilirubin level to at least 1.4 mg/dl
pain using a graded scale of 1– 42 checked at intervals of 4
(normal value, 0.98 ⫾ 0.04 mg/dl, by the method of Malloy
to 6 h; presence of bile in the gastric aspirate, checked every
and Evelyn [19]), and no history of alcohol abuse or other
6 h; and serum bilirubin level determined at admission, and
known etiological factor for acute pancreatitis.
every 6 h thereafter.
Clinical Material The management protocol was as follows. The patients
Between January 1986 and December 1996, a total of 259 who showed signs of spontaneous ampullary decompres-
patients with the diagnosis of acute pancreatitis of any origin sion, such as rapid relief of pain, sudden appearance of
were admitted at the Hospital Escuela Eva Perón, Granadero golden bile in the gastric aspirate, and a significant fall of
Baigorria, Santa Fé, Argentina. One hundred and thirty-two serum bilirubin within 48 h from the onset of symptoms,
of these patients were assumed to have AGP, met all the were reconsidered for elective biliary surgery during the
criteria for inclusion, and were enrolled. Patients’ age av- same admission. The remaining patients, who did not show
eraged 41.3 (range, 16 – 85) yr; 103 were women, and 29 signs of decompression, had intervention to remove the
were men. Serum bilirubin level at admission averaged 4.2 offending stone within the previously identified period.
(range, 1.4 –12.7) mg/dl, and serum amylase level was 1,312 However, the exact timing of operation in these patients—
(range, 256 –14,600) U/dl. though within the preestablished 48-h period— depended
Ultrasound scanning within 24 h of admission revealed upon a number of variables besides duration of obstruction.
gallbladder stones (n ⫽ 122) or muddy bile (n ⫽ 4) in 94% Severe unremitting, increasing, or recurrent pain, associated
(126/132) of the patients; no abnormalities were observed in with stable or increasing jaundice and bile-free gastric as-
two patients, and the gallbladder was not visualized in the pirate, as well as the appearance of tenderness, manifest
remaining four patients, who had previously undergone ileus, fever, or other systemic manifestations, was consid-
cholecystectomy. The pancreas showed changes consistent ered an indication for immediate decompression. The pres-
with acute pancreatitis in 47% (62/132) of the cases; in the ence of associated conditions, such as morbid obesity, preg-
remaining 53% (70/132), the pancreas showed either no nancy, recent myocardial infarction or cerebrovascular
alteration or was not visualized.
accident, was considered indication for delaying surgery as
The severity of acute pancreatitis was evaluated at ad-
long as permitted by the 48-h limit. To be able to perform
mission and before treatment according to personal clinical-
the operation within the preestablished time limit, surgical
biochemical criteria,1 and at 48 h from admission by the
ampullary decompression was anticipated by no later than
criteria of Ranson et al. (20). By the first (personal) assess-
36 h from the onset of symptoms.
ment, pancreatitis was classified as mild in 66 patients,
moderate in 65 patients, and severe in one patient. Applying
2. Abdominal Pain Scale of Severity: 1 ⫽ spontaneous pain, requiring analgesics
1. Criteria of severity of acute pancreatitis (7): Mild, mild or moderate symptoms every 6 h; 2 ⫽ spontaneous pain and tenderness, requiring analgesics every 4 h; 3 ⫽
(particularly pain) with minimal local manifestations; moderate, moderate or intense sharp pain, tenderness, and ileus, requiring analgesics every 3 h or more frequently;
symptoms (particularly pain) with obvious local manifestations; severe, intense symp- 4 ⫽ sharp and continuous pain, tenderness, and ileus, frequently accompanied by
toms (particularly pain) with both, local and systemic manifestations. systemic manifestations, requiring analgesics continuously.
124 Acosta et al. AJG – Vol. 95, No. 1, 2000

Statistical Analysis Table 1. Incidence of Common Duct Stones in 121 Patients


To calculate the accuracy of the methods employed to With Acute Gallstone Pancreatitis Receiving Intervention on
Elective (Group A) or Urgent (Group B) Basis
discriminate AGP from other disease processes and to detect
ampullary gallstone obstruction in such patients, the follow- Common Duct Group A Group B Total
ing standards were defined (21). We assumed the presence Stones (n ⫽ 98) (n ⫽ 23) (n ⫽ 121)
of AGP when cholelithiasis coexisted with macroscopic Impacted 0 (0%) 14 (61%) 14 (11.5%)
lesions of acute pancreatitis such as edema, fat necrosis, Not impacted 17 (17%) 3 (13%) 20 (16.5%)
Total 17 (17%) 17 (74%) 34 (28%)
hemorrhage, or parenchymal necrosis, during surgical ex-
ploration; gallstone obstruction of the ampulla was assumed
when contrast failed to reach the duodenum during intraop- Surgical and Endoscopic Findings
erative cholangiography (IOC) or when confirmed at sur- In Group A, gallbladder stones were found in 93 patients,
gery or by direct observation of the papilla (DPO) during and cholesterolosis in two. The remaining three patients had
ERCP. had prior cholecystectomy. A patent ampulla clinically sus-
To evaluate the accuracy of the diagnostic tests for AGP, pected was found in all 98 patients in this group, 95 by IOC,
we had to consider 4,209 patients in whom such diagnosis and three by ERCP. Common duct stones were detected in
had been excluded, but who were operated on during the 17 (17%) patients, but in none of them was a stone found
period of the study (1986 –1996, inclusive) and within a impacted at the ampulla (Table 1). Changes consistent with
comparable interval from the onset of symptoms, x ⫽ 4.6 resolving acute pancreatitis were seen in 92 patients, and no
(1–15) days, as seen in AGP patients. The clinical diagnoses abnormalities were detected in the remaining six (Table 2).
in this group were acute appendicitis (1,927 cases), acute In Group B, gallbladder stones were found in 21 patients,
cholecystitis (1,430), bowel obstruction (381), sigmoid di- and cholesterolosis in one. The remaining patient had pre-
verticulitis (177), obstructive jaundice and cholangitis viously undergone cholecystectomy. Common duct studies
(117), acute abdomen of unknown etiology (96), perforated by IOC in 17 patients or by DPO in six patients (ERCP, two
peptic ulcer (69), complicated aorta aneurysm (six), bowel cases, and exploratory duodenotomy, four cases) revealed
infarction (five), and acute nonbiliary pancreatitis (one). common duct stones in 17 (74%) patients, among whom 14
Statistical analyses were performed by means of Student’s t (61%) had a stone impacted at the ampulla (Table 1). The
tests (two-tailed) (22). remaining nine patients showed a patent ampulla at the time
of exploration. However, in six of these nine patients, phys-
ical evidence of recent transpapillary stone migration was
RESULTS observed: one or more gallstones free in the duodenal or
jejunal lumen seen through a transparent bowel wall (three
Clinical Course cases) and acute lesions, such as tears and ecchymosis, at the
After admission, the 132 patients studied demonstrated two papillary meatus (three cases). Typical lesions of acute
distinct patterns of evolution. The great majority, 83% (109/ pancreatitis were observed at surgery in 21 patients (Table
132), showed signs of ampullary decompression such as 2). The remaining two patients were subjected to ERCP plus
rapid relief of pain from grades 2–3 to grades 0 –1, sudden endoscopic sphincterotomy (ES) during the attack and, as
appearance of golden clear bile in the gastric aspirate, and a the pancreas was not adequately visualized at that time, the
significant fall of elevated serum bilirubin level (mean, cases were not considered for evaluation of the diagnosis of
37.5%) from 4.8 to 3 mg/dl (mean values) (p ⬍ 0.001) AGP.
within 48 (x ⫽ 26) h after the onset of symptoms (Group A).
The remaining 17% (23/132) showed typical signs of per- Operative Management
sistent ampullary gallstone obstruction, such as severe un- Free common duct stones were removed by chole-
remitting or increasing pain (grades 2–3) associated with dochotomy in the patients subjected to open surgery in
stable or increasing elevated serum bilirubin, mean peak
value ⫽ 6.8 mg/dl (2.5–11.0), and bile-free gastric aspirate, Table 2. Incidence of Lesions of Acute Pancreatitis in 119
as well as the appearance of epigastric tenderness, manifest Patients With Diagnosis of AGP Subjected to Open Surgery on
ileus, or fever (Group B). Eleven of the 109 patients in Elective (Group A) or Urgent (Group B) Basis
Group A were treated successfully during their attacks of Lesions of Acute Group A Group B Total
AGP by conservative measures only, and received no sub- Pancreatitis (n ⫽ 98) (n ⫽ 21) (n ⫽ 119)
sequent treatment in our service. They were excluded from Present 92 (94%) 21 (100%) 113 (95%)
this study. The remaining 98 patients of Group A received Edema 56 9 65
Fat necrosis 35 8 43
elective intervention for the associated cholelithiasis once Hemorrhage 1 3 4
the attack subsided, between 1 and 17 days (mean, 4.3 days) Necrosis 0 1 1
after the onset of symptoms. The 23 patients in Group B Absent 6 (6%) 0 (0%) 6 (5%)
were operated on urgently, between 18 and 48 h (mean, Total 98 (100%) 21 (100%) 119 (100%)
37 h) from the onset of symptoms. AGP ⫽ acute gallstone pancreatitis.
AJG – January, 2000 Ampullary Obstruction Monitoring in AGP 125

Table 3. Technical Procedures Performed in 121 Patients Table 4. Accuracy of Ordinary Clinical and Laboratory Data in
Divided Into Two Groups, A and B the Diagnosis of Biliary Pancreatitis, and in Monitoring
Ampullary Gallstone Obstruction
Group A Group B Total
Technical Procedures (n ⫽ 98) (n ⫽ 23) (n ⫽ 121) Biliary Ampullary Gallstone
Surgery 98 21 119 Pancreatitis Obstruction
Cholecystectomy 67 4 71 Accuracy Factor (n ⫽ 119)* (n ⫽ 121)†
CDE 31* 17† 48 Sensitivity 0.94 1.0
Choledochotomy ⫹ T-tube 24 10 34 Specificity 0.99 0.92
drain Positive predictive value 0.95 0.61
Choledochoduodenostomy 3 1 4 Negative predictive value 0.99 1.0
Papillotomy 1 6 7 * Total number of patients who were subjected to open surgical exploration to confirm
ERCP ⫹ ES 3 3 or exclude the diagnosis of AGP.
ERCP ⫹ ES 2 2 † Total number of patients who were subjected to IOC and/or to DPO (ERCP or
Total 98 23 121 exploratory duodenotomy) to confirm or exclude the diagnosis of ampullary gallstone
obstruction.
* In 28 cases, in association with cholecystectomy, and in three previously cholecys- AGP ⫽ acute gallstone pancreatitis; IOC ⫽ intraoperative cholangiography; DPO
tectomized patients, as a unique procedure. ⫽ direct papilla observation; ERCP ⫽ endoscopic retrograde pancreatography.
† In 16 cases, in association with cholecystectomy, and in the remaining previ-
ously cholecystectomized patients, as a unique procedure. laboratory diagnosis of AGP had been made. It revealed that
CDE ⫽ common duct exploration; ES ⫽ endoscopic sphincterotomy; ERCP ⫽
endoscopic retrograde pancreatography. 113 had cholelithiasis associated with lesions typical of
acute pancreatitis (true-positive cases). The remaining six
patients showed cholelithiasis but no lesions suggestive of
either group, and by ES in three patients of Group A sub- pancreatitis (false-positive cases). On the other hand, surgi-
jected to ERCP as the initial procedure. In the 14 patients of cal exploration carried out in the 4209 control patients in
Group B in whom a stone was found impacted at the whom the diagnosis of AGP had been excluded showed that
ampulla, the stone was removed by papillotomy in eight the exclusion diagnosis was correct in 4202 patients (true-
patients (transduodenal, six cases, and endoscopic, two cas- negative cases) and incorrect in the remaining seven. The
es), and by maneuvers that avoided papillotomy (removal of lesions of acute pancreatitis found in this latter group were
the stone through choledochotomy, three cases, and by edema (two cases), fat necrosis (two), and hemorrhage
pushing the stone with a probe toward the duodenum, three (three). All these latter patients showed cholelithiasis also
cases) in the remaining six patients, all of whom were (false-negative cases).
subjected to open surgery. The operative procedures per- Exploration of common bile duct by IOC or DPO in 121
formed in both groups are listed in Table 3. In the five patients (Group A, 98; Group B, 23) revealed that monitor-
patients primarily subjected to ERCP plus ES (Group A, ing of ampullary obstruction was a highly efficient way to
three cases, and Group B, two cases) standard or laparo- recognize ampullary decompression; this diagnosis was cor-
scopic cholecystectomy was carried out electively within 17 rect in all the 98 patients (100%) in whom it was made
days after the onset of symptoms. (true-negative cases). On the contrary, the diagnosis of
Postoperative Course ampullary obstruction was wrong in 39% (9/23) of cases
All the patients in Group B showed signs of ampullary (false-positive cases).
decompression such as rapid relief of pain (grades 2–3 to The accuracy of the methods used to discriminate the
0 –1), sudden appearance of bile in the gastric aspirate, and patients with AGP from those with other acute abdominal
a significant fall (averaging 45%) in serum bilirubin level, conditions, and to detect ampullary gallstone obstruction in
from 6.2 to 3.4 mg/dl within 6 h after endoscopic or surgical such patients in terms of sensitivity, specificity, and positive
decompression. Eleven (9%) of the 121 patients operated on and negative predictive values, is represented in Table 4.
in this series had immediate postoperative complications.
None of them required reoperation, and all recovered un- DISCUSSION
eventfully. There were no deaths. Eighty-six (71%) patients
were monitored during a follow-up period of between 2 and The results of this study strongly suggest that our method—
12 yr (mean, 6.5 yr). Only one patient in Group A developed based on simple, safe, and easily available tests—accurately
an episode of AGP with cholangitis, 8 yr after hospital diagnoses AGP. Indeed, its accuracy was high; the sensi-
discharge. The attack subsided 30 h after the onset of tivity was 94%, with a specificity of 99.8%. When the test
symptoms, and on the 12th day of admission ERCP plus was positive for AGP and the patients were explored oper-
ES was performed. Muddy bile and small calculi were atively, 95% of them showed clear signs of the suspected
removed from the common duct. The patient’s recovery condition. Delay in surgery may explain the six false-posi-
was uneventful. tive cases, as the mean time to exploration was 6.4 days,
compared with 4.3 days for the true-positive cases. When
Accuracy of the Diagnostic Methods AGP was excluded by the method described, surgical ex-
Open surgical exploration was carried out in 119 patients ploration demonstrated that ⬍1% of such patients actually
(Group A, 98 and Group B, 21) in whom a clinical and had AGP.
126 Acosta et al. AJG – Vol. 95, No. 1, 2000

The results obtained from the method used to monitor In conclusion, we suggest that this study has two impor-
ampullary obstruction indicate that this may be a very useful tant findings. An accurate diagnosis of AGP can be made
way to manage biliary pancreatitis. It is important to con- using basic clinical and easily obtained laboratory data.
sider that in 88% (107/121) of our patients the gallstone Further, using our method it is possible to identify patients
initiating the episode of pancreatitis migrated spontaneously with persisting obstruction of the ampulla requiring urgent
through the ampulla within 48 h from the onset of symp- decompression, and to spare those who have already passed
toms. Thus, neither emergency surgery nor ERCP with their stones unnecessary procedures, such as ERCP and
papillotomy would have been beneficial or necessary in exploratory surgery.
these patients. To treat these patients correctly one needs to
know whether the causative stone remains blocking the
ampulla. Our study showed that when signs of ampullary
ACKNOWLEDMENTS
decompression were present, 100% of such patients had a We are indebted to Dr. Frida Bergmann, and to Dr. Mónica
patent ampulla at the time of surgery because of migration Liborio for their expert assistance in the statistical analyses,
of the impacted stone. On the other hand, when signs of and to Dr. Jean Mc Allister for her invaluable editorial
ampullary obstruction persisted and the patients were oper- assistance.
ated on within 48 h of evolution, only 61% (14/23) of them
had an impacted stone at the ampulla, which was removed.
Reprint requests and correspondence: Juan M. Acosta, M.D.,
It is important to emphasize that six of the nine patients with Profesor Titular, Universidad Nacional de Rosario, Facultad de
diagnosis of ampullary obstruction had a patent ampulla Ciencias Médicas, Pte. Roca 786 Piso 1, 2000-Rosario, Argentina.
with signs of recent stone migration at the time of surgical Received Sep. 10, 1998; accepted Sep. 24, 1999.
exploration. Nevertheless, it remains uncertain whether or
not it would be beneficial for these patients to delay the
intervention for a few more hours in the expectation of REFERENCES
impending gallstone migration. If that did not occur within 1. Senninger N, Moody FG, Coelho JCV, et al. The role of biliary
the first 48 h, the risk of severe pancreatitis might be obstruction in the pathogenesis of the acute pancreatitis in the
significantly increased (7). In addition, such risk is more opossum. Surgery 1986;99:688 –93.
than hypothetical as, according to our experience, ⬍l5% of 2. Rünzi M, Saluja S, Lerch MM, et al. Early ductal decompres-
stone migrations occurred after 36 h of obstruction. sion prevents the progression of biliary pancreatitis: An ex-
perimental study in the opposum. Gastroenterology 1993;105:
Using ultrasonography, we were able to detect gallblad- 157– 64.
der stones in 94% of patients. This observation differs from 3. Acosta JM, Rossi R, Rubio Galli OM, et al. Early surgery for
other studies in which the procedure was hampered by acute gallstone pancreatitis: Evaluation of a systematic ap-
excessive gas in the bowel associated with the ileus of proach. Surgery 1978;83:367–70.
severe acute pancreatitis (23–25). This finding is highly 4. Acosta JM, Pellegrini CA, Skinner DB. Etiology and patho-
genesis of acute biliary pancreatitis. Surgery 1980;88:118 –25.
consistent with the low incidence of severe pancreatitis in 5. Stone JP, Fabian TC, Dunlop WE. Gallstone pancreatitis:
our series (⬍1%) assessed by two different criteria. The fact Biliary tract pathology in relation to time of operation. Ann
that 95% (113/119) of the patients explored at surgery Surg 1981;194:305–12.
proved to have cholelithiasis and obvious lesions of acute 6. Mercer LC, Salzstein EC, Peacock JB, et al. Early surgery for
pancreatitis is a solid argument against the term “pseudo- biliary pancreatitis. Am J Surg 1984;148:749 –53.
7. Acosta JM, Rubio Galli OM, Rossi R, et al. Effect of the
pancreatitis,” coined to describe the condition of patients duration of ampullary gallstone obstruction on severity of
with hyperamylasemia and minimal clinical manifestations lesions of acute pancreatitis. J Am Coll Surg 1997;184:499 –
(26). Such a term leads to confusion, because such patients 505.
may indeed have genuine acute pancreatitis, albeit mild. 8. Rosseland AR, Solhang JH. Early or delayed endoscopic pap-
The overall percentage of successful diagnosis of the illotomy (EPT) in gallstone pancreatitis. Ann Surg 1984;199:
165–7.
presence and absence of ampullary obstruction in this series 9. Neoptolemos JP, London NJ, James D, et al. Controlled trial
was 93% (123/132). The high success rate observed in our of urgent endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography
study might be due to the high accuracy of our method of and endoscopic sphyncterotomy versus conservative treatment
diagnosing ampullary decompression, which, in fact, is the for acute pancreatitis due to gallstones. Lancet 1988;2:979 –
most important issue that needs to be determined for appro- 83.
10. Neoptolemos JP, Carr-Locke DL, London N, et al. ERCP
priate management. Indeed, correct and timely diagnosis of findings, and the role of endoscopic sphincterotomy in acute
a patent ampulla by this method prevented unnecessary gallstone pancreatitis. Br J Surg 1988;75:954 – 60.
urgent intervention in 83% (109/132) of our patients, all of 11. Schölmerich J, Gross V, Johanesson T, et al. Detection of
whom recovered uneventfully from their attack. Thus, using biliary origin of acute pancreatitis; comparison of laboratory
this method, only nine patients (7%) underwent urgent ex- tests, ultrasound, computed tomography, and ERCP. Dig Dis
Sci 1989;34:830 –3.
ploration of their ampulla (by ERCP or operation), which, 12. Fan ST, Lai ECS, Mok FPT, et al. Early treatment of acute
although unnecessary, did not seem to impact negatively on biliary pancreatitis by endoscopic papillotomy. N Engl J Med
their outcome. 1993;328:228 –32.
AJG – January, 2000 Ampullary Obstruction Monitoring in AGP 127

13. Liu CL, Lo CM, Fan ST. Acute biliary pancreatitis: Diagnosis 20. Ranson JHC, Rifkind KM, Roses DF, et al. Prognostic signs
and management. World J Surg 1997;21:149 –59. and the role of operative management in acute pancreatitis.
14. Freeman ML, Nelson DB, Sherman S, et al. Complications of Surg Gynecol Obstet 1974;139:69 – 81.
endoscopic biliary sphincterotomy. N Eng J Med 1996;335: 21. Dawson-Saunders EK, Trapp RG. Bioestadı́stica Médica. Ed.
909 –18. El Manual Moderno, S.A. de C.V. México, D.F., 1995:267.
15. Coppa GF, Le Fleur R, Ranson JHC. The role of Chiba-needle 22. Snedecor GW, Cochran WG. Statistical methods, 6th ed.
cholangiography in the diagnosis of possible acute pancreatitis Ames, Iowa: State University Press, 1967:104,114.
with cholelithiasis. Ann Surg 1981;193:393– 8. 23. Fölsch UR, Nitsche R, Hilgers RA, et al. Early ERCP, and
16. Neoptolemos JP, Fossard DP, Berry JM. A prospective study papillotomy compared with conservative treatment for acute
of radionuclide biliary scanning in acute pancreatitis. Ann Roy biliary pancreatitis. N Engl J Med 1997;336:237– 42.
Coll Surgeons Eng 1983;65:180 –2. 24. Schölmerich J, Volk BA, Grünholz J, et al. Die Bedeutung
17. Bolognese A, Muttillo IA, Scopinaro F, et al. Biliscintigraphie sonographischer Verlaufskontrollen bei der akuten Pankreati-
contre échographie dans le diagnostique étiologique de la tis. Ultraschall 1983;4:31– 6.
pancréatite aiguë. J Chir (Paris) 1996;133:78 – 81. 25. Neoptolemos JP, Hall AW, Finlay DF, et al. The urgent
18. Smith BW, Roe JH. A photometric method for the determi- diagnosis of gallstone in acute pancreatitis. A prospective
nation of ␣-amylase in blood and urine, with use of the study of three methods. Br J Surg 1984;71:230 –3.
storch-iodine color. J Biol Chem 1949;179:53–9. 26. Warshaw AL. Invited commentary in cholecholithiasis in
19. Malloy HT, Evelyn KA. The determination of bilirubin with acute gallstone pancreatitis. Incidence and clinical signifi-
photoelectric colorimeter. J Biol Chem 1937;119:481–90. cance. Arch Surg 1991;126:566 – 8.

You might also like