Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pune Metro PPP
Pune Metro PPP
:3 Dated 28-05-2018: COMMON SET OF DEVIATIONS TO THE MANUAL OF STANDARDS AND SPECIFICATIONS
Website: www.mahatenders.gov.in
e-Tender Notice Inviting Request for Proposal No. 53, dated 13.03.2018
Chapter
1:General
Technical
Requirements
5 New Clause The term Track Circuit (TC) or Audio Frequency
1.1.8 Track Circuit (AFTC) has been used in a generic
sense in this document and may include Axle
Counter for Train detection.
6 Clause 1.1.3 The codes, standards and specifications applicable for design of The codes, standards and specifications
the components of the Rail System and for its operation and applicable for design of the components of the Rail
maintenance are: System and for its operation and maintenance are:
(i) NFPA–130 – ‘Standard for Fixed Guideway – Transit and (i) NFPANBC–130 – ‘Standard for Fixed
Passenger Rail System’; Guideway – Transit and Passenger Rail System’;
(ii) European Norm (EN); (ii) European Norm (EN);
(iii) International Electro Technical Commission Standards (a) EN 50126: Railway applications- The
(IEC); specification and demonstration of
(iv) International Standards Organization (ISO); Reliability, Availability, Maintainability and
(i) The initial engineering submission shall include the (i) The initial engineering submission shall
outline design and equipment specifications for each system. include the outline design and equipment
The submission shall also include standards, interface specifications for each system. The submission
management plan, quality assurance plans, systems assurance shall also include standards, interface
plans, EMC management plan, RAMs management plan, management plan, quality assurance plans,
calculations and assumptions, software programmes and third systems assurance plans, EMC management
party co-ordination arrangements, to enable the IE to have a plan, RAMs management plan, calculations and
complete understanding of the equipment and system
assumptions, software programmes
RFP Corrigendum No.3 Page 4 of 34
Addendum / Corrigendum No.:3 Dated 28-05-2018: COMMON SET OF DEVIATIONS TO THE MANUAL OF STANDARDS AND SPECIFICATIONS
10 clause 2.1.4 The Rolling Stock shall be fitted with ATC, and traction current The Rolling Stock shall be fitted with ATC, and
collection equipment so that all Trains will be capable of being traction current collection equipment so that all
driven manually under ATP supervision. The Rolling Stock shall Trains will be capable of being driven manually
be designed in a manner such that the ATO can be introduced under ATP supervision. The Rolling Stock shall
within a year of starting operations. be designed in a manner such that the ATO can
be introduced within a year of starting
operations.
12 Clause 2.2.3 (b) The train shall be capable of sustaining a maximum service (i) The train shall be capable of sustaining a
maximum service speed of 80 kmph with ATP
speed of 80 kmph with ATP on track with curve of radius 300 m
on track with curve of radius 300 m and flatter
and flatter for the designed Train formations. 90 kmph designed speed for the designed Train
formations.
RFP Corrigendum No.3 Page 7 of 34
Addendum / Corrigendum No.:3 Dated 28-05-2018: COMMON SET OF DEVIATIONS TO THE MANUAL OF STANDARDS AND SPECIFICATIONS
13 Clause 2.3.1.3 The outer most ends of the end Coaches shall be provided with The outer most ends of the end coaches shall
automatic couplers with simultaneous automatic connection of be provided with automatic couplers with
pneumatic pipes and electrical connection and the Inter-coach simultaneous automatic connection of
coupler shall be semi-automatic type. All couplers shall have pneumatic pipes and electrical connection and
crash worthiness features. the Inter-coach coupler shall be semi-automatic
type. All couplers shall have crash worthiness
features. mechanical and pneumatic coupling
and with crash worthiness feature. Provision
shall be made for electrical connection if there is
operational requirement. The inter-coach
coupler shall be semi-permanent type with crash
worthiness features.
14 Buffers provided between vehicles should resist buffer locking. Buffers provided between vehicles should resist
Clause 2.3.1.4 Buffers and draw gear systems should resist over riding and buffer locking. Buffers and draw gear systems
relative rotation to keep vehicles upright. should resist over riding and relative rotation to
keep vehicles upright.
15 Clause 2.3.1.9 The door mechanism shall have safety provision whereby the The door mechanism shall have safety provision
Train cannot start unless all doors have been closed and whereby the Train cannot start unless all doors
electrically locked. have been closed and electrically locked.
The door pitch shall be approximately equally spaced over the
The door pitch shall be approximately equally
length of the Train, with the maximum pitch being about 6.0 m.
spaced over the length of the Train, with the
RFP Corrigendum No.3 Page 8 of 34
Addendum / Corrigendum No.:3 Dated 28-05-2018: COMMON SET OF DEVIATIONS TO THE MANUAL OF STANDARDS AND SPECIFICATIONS
16 Clause 2.3.1.12 The doors shall have following additional safety features: The doors shall have following additional safety
features:
(i) Obstacle detection and preventing the Train from starting
in case of obstruction; (i) Obstacle detection and preventing the
Train from starting in case of obstruction;
17 Clause 2.3.1.12 (ii) Internal and External release. (ii) Internal and external release
Provision shall be made for users to open Train doors to permit Provision shall be made for users to open Train
doors to permit evacuation from a stopped Train
evacuation from a stopped Train in an Emergency.
in an Emergency.
All doors shall have internal release. One door
per side per car should be equipped for external
release apart from internal release.
Provision shall be made to open Train
doors/front door to permit evacuation from a
stopped Train in an Emergency.
18 Clause Each Coach shall have emergency ventilation windows, two on
2.3.1.13(c) Each Coach shall have emergency ventilation
each side. These should be opened only by TO or trained staff.
windows, two on each side. These should be
opened only by TO or trained staff.
19 Clause The floor of the Coach shall be at level with the platform (-0 / + The floor of the Coach shall be at level with the
30 mm). platform with a tolerance of (-0 / + 30 mm) -0 /+
2.3.1.15
50 mm
( under normal working conditions which shall
cover AW-4 conditions)
20 New clause The train shall have end opening emergency exit
doors along with safe alighting arrangements.
2.3.1.18
21 2.3.2.1 Nominal clear height inside the Coach shall be 2100 mm Nominal clear height inside the Coach shall be
24 clause 2.3.2.14 The Train/Coach shall have provision of pre-recorded or The Train/Coach shall have provision of pre-
synthesized voice recorded system to announce the name of the recorded or synthesized voice recorded system to
next arriving station or any other general announcement. These announce the name of the next arriving station or
announcements shall be in two languages, viz., Telugu and any other general announcement. These
English. announcements shall be in two languages, viz.,
Telugu Marathi and English.
25 Clause 2.3.2.15 The Coach interior shall have resistance to fire and conform to The Coach interior shall have resistance to fire
NFPA-130,2003 edition – ‘Standard for Fixed Guide way – and conform to NFPANBC-130, 20032016
Transit and Passenger Rail Systems’. User and Train crew edition – ‘Standard for Fixed Guide way –
compartments shall be provided with two dry powder type or Transit and Passenger Rail Systems’ or EN
other appropriate fire extinguishers located near the gangways. 45545 User and Train crew compartments shall
26 Clause 2.3.2.16 The total fire load, above and below the floor, shall be The total fire load separately, for above and
minimized to 28000 Million Joules. below the floor, shall be minimized to not exceed
28000 Million Joules per car.
27 Clause 2.3.4.2 The TO cab shall have full front view. The TO cab shall have full clear front view.
28 New clause TO’s Cab
2.3.4.10 TO’s cab shall be designed in accordance with
BS EN 16186-1-‘Railway applications - Driver's
cab: Visibility, layout, access’, UIC 651/BS EN
16186-2-‘Railway applications - Driver's cab:
Integration of screens, controls and indicators’
and BS EN 16186-3- ‘Railway applications -
Driver's cab Design of displays’.
29 Two leading Bogies of front Coaches of a Train shall be Two leading Bogies of front Coaches of a Train
Clause 2.3.5.9 provided with wheel flange lubricators. When a leading Bogie shall be provided with wheel flange lubricators.
becomes a trailing Bogie, on change of direction of motion, the When a leading Bogie becomes a trailing Bogie,
flange lubricators on this Bogie shall automatically switch off. on change of direction of motion, the flange
lubricators on this Bogie shall automatically
switch off. Suitable alternative method of flange
lubrication may also be adopted.
30 Clause 2.3.5.11 The Sperling Ride Index (RI) of the Coach under all loading The Sperling Ride Index (RI) of the Coach under
conditions, when travelling throughout the range of all loading conditions, when travelling
operating speeds and cant deficiencies prevailing in normal throughout the range of operating speeds
RFP Corrigendum No.3 Page 12 of 34
Addendum / Corrigendum No.:3 Dated 28-05-2018: COMMON SET OF DEVIATIONS TO THE MANUAL OF STANDARDS AND SPECIFICATIONS
31 Clause 2.3.6.3 If a door opens when a Train is in motion, Emergency Brake If a door opens when a Train is in motion,
(b) shall be applied to bring the Train to a standstill. Emergency Brake shall be applied to bring the
Train to a standstill. the TO in coordination with
Train Controller may work the Train till the next
station at restricted speed if it is safe to do so,
but the train shall not move from that station with
a open door.
RFP Corrigendum No.3 Page 13 of 34
Addendum / Corrigendum No.:3 Dated 28-05-2018: COMMON SET OF DEVIATIONS TO THE MANUAL OF STANDARDS AND SPECIFICATIONS
32 Clause 2.3.6.6 The parking brake shall be automatic and shall be designed to The parking brake shall be automatic and shall
hold a fully loaded Train (10 Users per sq m) on the steepest be designed to hold a fully loaded Train (10
gradient of the Rail System in the worst anticipated wind Users per sq m) on the steepest gradient of the
condition at that location, for an unlimited time. Rail System in the worst anticipated wind
condition at that location, for an unlimited time.
For demonstration purpose the parking brakes
should hold fully loaded Train for at least two
hours and an empty Train for up to 24 hours.
37 Clause 3.1.2(iii) The permanent way shall cover the following sub systems: The permanent way shall cover the following sub
Rail bearers/plinth beams including non ballasted track systems systems:
Rail bearers/plinth beams/slabs including non
ballasted track systems
40 Clause 3.4 Track shall be laid to standard gauge of 1435 mm, the track Track shall be laid to standard gauge of 1435
gauge being the distance between the inner sides of the head mm, the track gauge being the distance
of rails measured 14 mm below top of rails. between the inner sides of the head of rails
measured 14 mm below top of rails.
Gauge widening on curves shall be as per SOD at Appendix I.
Track Alignment shall be such that during Train running, Users Track Alignment shall be such that during Train
on board should have a feeling of smooth running and can running, Users on board should have a feeling
stand in comfort. of smooth running and can stand in comfort.
Track alignment shall generally follow the alignment shown in Track alignment shall generally follow the
the Concession Agreement. alignment shown in the Concession Agreement.
43 Clause 3.6.2.1 The minimum curve length between two transition curves The minimum curve length between two
(d) shall be 25 m. transition curves shall be 2515 m.
44 Clause 3.6.2.3 The length of transition curve shall be worked out from cant The length of transition curve shall be worked
(b) consideration (maximum rate of change of cant limited to 28 out from cant consideration (maximum rate of
mm/sec) and from cant deficiency consideration (maximum rate change of cant limited to 28 35 mm/sec
of change of cant deficiency 25 mm/sec). preferably and 55 mm/sec in exceptional cases)
and from cant deficiency consideration
(maximum rate of change of cant deficiency
shall be 25 35 mm/sec but in exceptional case
the limit shall not exceed 55 mm/sec).
RFP Corrigendum No.3 Page 17 of 34
Addendum / Corrigendum No.:3 Dated 28-05-2018: COMMON SET OF DEVIATIONS TO THE MANUAL OF STANDARDS AND SPECIFICATIONS
45 Clause The rate of change of lateral acceleration resulting in a lateral The rate of change of lateral acceleration
3.6.2.3 (c) jerk should be preferably limited to 0.2 m/s3 and shall in any resulting in a lateral jerk should be preferably
case exceed 0.3 m/s3. limited to 0.2 m/s3 and shall not in any case
exceed 0.3 0.36 m/s3.
46 Clause 3.6.3.3 The vertical curves shall have a minimum radius given by the The vertical curves shall have a minimum radius
following equation:- given by the following equation:-
Rv= 0.4 V 2 Rv= 0.4 0.16 V2
47 Clause 3.7.3.1 The minimum ballast cushion under the rail seat between the The minimum ballast cushion under the rail seat
upper part of the sub grade and the bottom of the sleeper between the upper part of the sub grade and
should be 300 mm except for track in Depot where the the bottom of the sleeper should be 300 mm
minimum ballast cushion shall be not less than 200 mm. except for track in Depot where the minimum
ballast cushion shall be not less than 200 250
mm.
48 Clause 3.7.3.7 SEJ may be provided at the ends of the corridors where the SEJ may be provided at the ends of the
ballast less track joins the ballasted track. Insulated joints for corridors where the ballast less track joins the
track circuiting may be provided where required ballasted track. as per approved design, where
required. Insulated joints for track circuiting may
be provided where required
(a) UIC flat bottom rails, Grade 900A shall be adopted on (a) UIC flat bottom rails, Grade 900A shall be
main lines and Depot lines except for curves sharper than 500 adopted on main lines and Depot lines except
m, turn outs, and factory insulated glued joints for which Grade for curves sharper than 500 m, turn outs, and
1100(1080 UTS) wear resistant head hardened rails shall be factory insulated glued joints for which Grade
adopted. Grade 1100 rails shall be extended for 18 m on either 1100(1080 UTS) wear resistant head hardened
end of curves sharper than 500 m, turnouts and at glued joints. rails shall be adopted. Grade 1100 rails shall be
Rail shall be in accordance with UIC standard section. Rail shall extended for 18 m on either end of curves
conform to EN-13674-1:1999-Railway Application- Track, Rail sharper than 500 m, turnouts and at glued
Part 1, or UIC 860 O-Technical specification for supply of rails, joints. Rail shall be in accordance with UIC
UIC 861-O standard rail profiles-UIC 54 and 60 kg/m rail standard section. Rail shall conform to EN-
sections and Grade 900A. 13674-1:1999-Railway Application- Track, Rail
Part 1, or UIC 860 O-Technical specification for
supply of rails, UIC 861-O standard rail profiles-
UIC 54 and 60 kg/m rail sections and Grade
900A.
(a) Rails: Rail profile shall conform to UIC 60 or
EN 13674-1:1999 railway application-Track and
Rail material shall conform to IRS-T-12-
2009 class A, including manufacturing and
testing in accordance with IRS-T-12-2009 with
latest amendments.
For depot lines 60E1 880 grade can be used.
Chapter 3,
Appendix I:
Schedule of
RFP Corrigendum No.3 Page 20 of 34
Addendum / Corrigendum No.:3 Dated 28-05-2018: COMMON SET OF DEVIATIONS TO THE MANUAL OF STANDARDS AND SPECIFICATIONS
52 Clause 9(a)
(ii) allowance as per UIC (ii) allowance as per UIC track
due to gauge track gauge due to gauge gauge in curves.
widening on in curves. widening on approved SOD .
curves curves.
53 Clause 12 Maximum horizontal distance from centre of track to face Maximum horizontal distance from centre of
of passenger platform coping. track to face of passenger platform coping.
… …
Taking the above factors into consideration, the distances shall
be as under for a 2900 mm wide Rolling Stock: Taking the above factors into consideration,
the distances shall be as under for a 2900 mm
wide Rolling Stock:
(i) Maximum horizontal distance from centre of track to face of
platform coping: (i) Maximum horizontal distance from centre of
1515 mm track to face of platform coping:
1515 1525 mm
….
54 Clause 15 Rolling Stock Rolling Stock
(a) Maximum height above rail level for floor of Coaches – 1130 (a) Maximum height above rail level for floor of
mm Coaches – 1130 mm
(b) Minimum height above rail level for floor of Coaches – 1105
mm (b) Minimum height above rail level for floor of
Coaches – 1105 1100 mm
Chapter 4-
Signalling and
Train Control
57 Clause 4.2.4 Audio Frequency Track Circuit (AFTC) for vehicle detection Audio Frequency Track Circuit (AFTC) for
(iv) and for transmission of data from track to Train on revenue vehicle detection and for transmission of data
lines as well as on the transfer track and test track in the Depot; from track to Train on revenue lines as well as
on the transfer track and test track in the Depot
or alternatively the vehicle detection and data
transmission by any suitable technology;
58 Clause 4.2.4 (viii) Help to detect “broken rail.” Help to detect “broken rail.”
59 Clause 4.3.10.1 Wash Mode (WM) driving, a sub-mode of YM, shall be Wash Mode (WM) driving, a sub-mode of
(e) used for controlling the low speed movement of Trains through YM, shall be used for controlling the low
the Depot wash plant. speed movement of Trains through the Depot
wash plant and will be controlled and
supervised by the TO.
60 Clause 4.4.4 All Rolling Stock, passenger Trains and on-line maintenance All Rolling Stock, passenger Trains and other
vehicles required to operate during commercial service shall than on-line maintenance vehicles required to
be fitted with facilities for self verification of correct operation operate during commercial service shall be
of the onboard CATC equipment and Train safety systems. Any fitted with facilities for self verification of
failure of safety critical equipment, as specified in the safety correct operation of the onboard CATC CBTC
case, shall result in the Rolling Stock not being admitted to the equipment and Train safety systems. Any failure
revenue lines, and if a failure occurs in service the affected of safety critical equipment, as specified in the
vehicles shall be taken out of revenue service at once. As soon safety case, shall result in the Rolling Stock not
as possible, the defective Train shall be removed from the being admitted to the revenue lines, and if a
revenue line, with suitable precautions to ensure safety. failure occurs in service the affected vehicles
…. shall be taken out of revenue service at once.
As soon as possible, the defective Train shall
Emergency vehicles capable of working under ATP shall be Emergency vehicles capable of working under
provided in Depots for faster and efficient response in the event ATP shall be provided in Depots for faster and
of breakdown of power supply efficient response in the event of breakdown of
power supply
72 Clause 5.7.1.1 The concessionaire shall provide a 33 KV 3 Phase ring-main The concessionaire shall provide a 33 KV 3
circuit within the Rail system infrastructure, providing redundant Phase ring-main circuit within the Rail system
connections to Auxiliary Sub-Station (ASS) at each station, infrastructure, providing redundant connections
Depot and on-line equipment rooms. Cable route diversification to Auxiliary Sub-Station (ASS) at each station,
RFP Corrigendum No.3 Page 27 of 34
Addendum / Corrigendum No.:3 Dated 28-05-2018: COMMON SET OF DEVIATIONS TO THE MANUAL OF STANDARDS AND SPECIFICATIONS
Chapter 6 -
Communication
Systems
73 clause 6.2.1.2 The DTS shall be STM-16 or other applicable transmission The DTS shall be STM-16 or other applicable
network systems to ITU-T standards and capable of transmission network systems to ITU-T
transporting all of the user communication interfaces and, standards and capable of transporting all of the
therefore, the bandwidth provided by the DTS shall be matched user communication interfaces and, therefore,
to the loading required by the data speed of the subsystem’s the bandwidth provided by the DTS shall be
interfaces. The DTS shall provide sufficient bandwidth to cater matched to the loading required by the data
for the data loading required at the present implementation speed of the subsystem’s interfaces. The DTS
stage and shall provide an additional spare bandwidth of at shall provide sufficient bandwidth to cater for the
least 20% of the useable total bandwidth data loading required at the present
implementation stage and shall provide an
additional spare bandwidth of at least 20% of the
useable total bandwidth
A passage of width not less than 700 mm with safety railing A passage of width not less than 700 mm with
shall be provided on each side of the double track all along the safety railing shall be provided on each side of
elevated corridor the double track all along the elevated corridor
to facilitate evacuation of Users during Emergency. to facilitate evacuation of Users during
Emergency.
76 Clause 9.3.2 A passage of adequate width (not less than 700 mm) on both A passage of adequate width (not less than 700
(i) sides of the guide way all along the corridor shall be provided mm) on both sides of the guide way all along the
for Emergency evacuation. corridor shall be provided for Emergency
evacuation.
77 Clause 9.3.7 Parapets Parapets
Parapets shall be provided on both sides of all viaducts for the Parapets shall be provided on both sides of all
full length of the structure. They shall be designed to act as the viaducts for the full length of the structure. They
support structure to the railway cabling and junction boxes as shall be designed to act as the support structure
appropriate. Parapets shall be designed to resist a horizontal and to the railway cabling and junction boxes as
RFP Corrigendum No.3 Page 29 of 34
Addendum / Corrigendum No.:3 Dated 28-05-2018: COMMON SET OF DEVIATIONS TO THE MANUAL OF STANDARDS AND SPECIFICATIONS
Bearings for the viaducts shall be designed for the span for the Bearings for the viaducts shall be designed for the
different loading combinations. Span shall be defined as c/c of span for the different loading combinations. Span
bearings. shall be defined as c/c of bearings.
(c) Where clearances are available and a suitably designed (c) Where clearances are available and a
safety crash barrier can be provided, the piers need not be suitably designed safety crash barrier can be
RFP Corrigendum No.3 Page 31 of 34
Addendum / Corrigendum No.:3 Dated 28-05-2018: COMMON SET OF DEVIATIONS TO THE MANUAL OF STANDARDS AND SPECIFICATIONS
Chapter 10:
Station
Planning and
Design
81 Clause 10.9.5.3 Platform minimum width shall be 4 meter . Platform minimum width shall be 4 meter 3 meter.
82 Clause 10.9.6.2 For egress/fire evacuation measures, the Station design shall 10.9.6.2 For egress/fire evacuation
meet the requirements for Stations as provided in NFPA 130- measures, the Station design shall meet the
latest Edition, Section-5, Item 5.5 - Means of Egress. Fire requirements for Stations as provided in NFPA
detection and suppression shall be generally as per latest edition NBC 130- latest Edition, Section-5, Item 5.5 -
of NBC – 2005. Means of Egress. Fire detection and suppression
shall be generally as per latest edition of NBC 130
– 2005 latest edition.
84 Clause 10.5 (a) All public spaces including stairs and ramps shall generally All public spaces including stairs and ramps shall
Chapter 13 -
Commissioning
of the Rail
System
86 Clause no. Commissioning of Rail Systems In accordance with the Andhra Pradesh
13.1.1.8 In accordance with the Andhra Pradesh Municipal Tramways Municipal Tramways (Construction, Operation,
(Construction, Operation, and Maintenance) Ordinance 2008, or and Maintenance) Ordinance 2008, METRO
any substitute thereof, rules made thereunder and the provision RAILWAYS (OPERATION AND
of the Concession Agreement, the Safety Commissioner shall MAINTENANCE) ACT 2002 as per METRO
inspect and conduct necessary Tests or cause such tests to be RAILWAYS ( AMENDMENT) BILL, 2009
conducted, and after satisfying that the Rail System is a safe for or any substitute thereof, rules made thereunder
carriage of Users, issue to the Concessionaire a certificated of and the provision of the Concession Agreement,
RFP Corrigendum No.3 Page 33 of 34
Addendum / Corrigendum No.:3 Dated 28-05-2018: COMMON SET OF DEVIATIONS TO THE MANUAL OF STANDARDS AND SPECIFICATIONS
The Corrigendum No. 3 shall form part of the RFP. All other terms and conditions of the Concession Agreement shall remain unchanged.