AN OVEREXCITATION RELAY
WITH INVERSE TIME CHARACTERBTICS
ay
Vike Melsinger Jotn hinders Gunnar Steenne
ASEA Inc. Consultant ASEA Ine.
Yonkers, NY Sarasota, FL “Yerieeray NY
Presented To The
Protective Relaying Committee
Electric Councif of New England
Hyannis, Mascachusetts
‘April 28-25, 1983Abstract - The desirebillty for overexeitation protection
of transformers which more nearly matches, te capability of
these compenents Is discussed. A new relay is described which
provides this improved protection. The relay incorporates an
fnverse-time operating characteristic, adjustable over a range
adequate Zor protection ef all size ‘ransiormers, Coordination
fof everexcitation protection on a tystem wide basis appears
feasible.
INTRODUCTION
Overvoltage operation of wansformersy genctators_ and
rotors can result in overheating, end in extreme cases theit
destruction fn a Felstively stort time. Someticnes these condix
tions arize as @ recul: of operating procedures which do net
recognize the hazard. In such cases the solution is obvicus,
although not necessarily easy to implement. In other cases the
‘Svervoltage condition is the result of a syatern upset following
fa disturbance. In these cases operator intervention canrot be
Telied dpen because: a) there may be ne operator, ard) those
‘operatora wno aro available ore busy with "mere important®
tasks. As systems become more fully autorcated a. thire
passible cause of overvottage Is a malfunction of the aurama-
fle regulating, equipment, or the regulating equlproent may
respond to sysvem parameters which Can result in overvoltage
(or specific components.
‘rervottage 4s a mesningtul term only at cated frequency.
A low frequency has the seme effect on reagnetic circuits as
high voltage. Thus the preferred expression Is overexcitation,
and the unit of measurement which incorporates both peta-
eters is voliefierts (Wz). The end use of much of the
power generated and distributed by utility systems is for
{llaningtion which is not frequency sensitive, As a consequen-
‘op. rmost voltage regulating ‘santrol eculpmant responds to
voltage and net to axcitetion. Historically this has nat caused
fserlous system operating problems, because the magnetic
components, trarsfermers and machines, ware not overly sen-
Sitive to overexcitation, Modem designed transformers and
machines ate_more sonsitve 10 oveeschation than earlier
equiprrents. This i the result of more efficient designs, and
designs which rely on the improvement in the uniforrlty of
the excitation level of modern systems. Thus, when a systero
upset that includes overexcitation dons oceur, transformers
and machines thay be damaged unless corrective action is
prompity taken.
QVEREXCITATION LOSSES
‘The equivalent citcuit of a power transformer, Fig. 1, ge
netally shows shunt branches containing, Il. the inagnetizing
ince represented SY 2 pure inductance, 2), the core
losses represented by 2 pure resistance. This equlvalent shunt
circuit is an accurate representation only at rased frequency
and at flav levels up 70 Sut not significantly above the design
Ievels. This equivalent circuit cannot be used to calculate
overexcitation losses because OF the nofolinear relations which
gece in this region. “The present transformer standard,
ANSI/EEE.097-12.00-1940 C1} specifies petmiseble exctation
levels as follows
"%.L6 Operation Above Rated Voltage or Below Rated
Frequency:
41.6.1 Transfortners shall be capable of
(1) Operating continuously above rated voltage
‘oF below tated {requency, at reaxitnum rated
VA for any tap, withaut exceeding limits of
observable temperature rise in accordance
whn SLkd when all of the. following
conditions prevails
(a) Secandary voltage and velts per Herts do
pot exceed [05 6 of rated values
(0) Dead power factor lt 80 % oF higher
{@) Frequency teat lene 956 of rated wake
Fig l. Transtormes equivalent cizeuity useful only in Haear
region below saturation,
‘Transformer conditions at 105% voltage and full load,
0.8 PF,
Hote: Minor saturation existe and exciting current and
Insses ean not be accurately calculated from constants
af fig le
Fig.
(2) Operating continuously above rated voltage
or below rated frequency on any tap at no
load, withour exceeding Writs of observable
‘temperature tise Jn aeccedance with 5.11.1
‘when neither the voltage nor volis per Hertz
exceed 110% of rated values
6.1.6.2 The maximum contimous transformer operating
voltage should net exceed the levels opacified in
ANSIC84.1-1977
S.ll1 Limite of Observable Temperature Rise
All Winding Rise, The average winding temperature
cig showe amMient tenperature shall not excecd
65°C. vhen measured hy resistance, and the
‘wigding hottest spot temperature shall not excess
20°C.
SMe? Other Windlrg Rises Other winding rises may be
resognized for unusual ambiert. conditions, or for
special applications. These are specified In app-
ropriate epplieations, ot in certain product stan
dards.
S.ll.L3 Riso of Metallic Parts, Other than Windings. Me~
tallic parts in contact’ with current-carrying con
‘ductor Insulation shall not attain a tempersture
las in encore of the winding hottest epot eemp-
erature rise. Netallic partsotner than those de-
Sctibed in the preceding paragraph shall not actamm
quemitive temperature rises at maximsm rated
load. The temperature rise of che insulating, liquid
shall not exezed 62°C when measured near the $op
of the main tan."
‘The temperature profite within the transformer due to
overyoltage will be different from that due to overlcad. While
the Standard recognizes this in general terms, it dees not
quantify the sigiificence of this different profile, rer of the
extremely son-linear effects of serious overescitation.
‘The fult load kVA, 0.8PE, 105% voltage requirement
results in an actual flue level in the transformer cove, not
Signidicanty different from That at the 110% voltage, 29 lead
foquleament, For a transformer with (5% impedance, equally
divided between primary and secondary windings, and a load of
0.8 + U6 pu the Lux level wity 103% ourpit voltage wil
nearly esreespord t6 1.10 pet unit.‘The applied primary voltage would be correspordtingly
Digner at LI per unit as shown in Fig. 2, With the flux fevel
atan acceptable value, his higher primary voltage i not
dewinental 1 2 transtormar fully Toades at D.APR. The
operation of Tully Yoaded transformers up to 105% ourput
voltage weuld thus appear to be a conservative practice at
fated frequency, especially with wansformers having less
leakage reactance assoclated with the ousput whiding,
At these limiting values, ene can estimate the losses as
follows, Assume 9 transformer sith maximam efficiency of
99% at 75% load. Assure the core losses are equal to the
copper losses and are thas 1/256 cach. At full load, the losses
srould bes
2
os ESP y 0.5 = 39%
73
Ad og losd and Lil pu voleageythe lecaes would be also ab=
out 1.39% based on the Standard which calls for no, graater
femperature rise than under cated load conditions. Ts, in
ralting the fut level from 100% 9 LIOX the no lead leeeus
have increased from 0.5% to 1.39%, vey, a 10% increase in
voltage increased 90 load losses 20M. “Above LLO0% excita
ton, losses will increase etl more rapidly. At shorg higher
Jevals the core saturates and some of the fh will enter ton
Jarninated structural componenss smich have large hysteresis
ang eddy current losses. The excitation current will inereass,
approaching full load current value at 150% excltation. The
semperature rise fron all of these losses can damage Ini
tion, weaken mechanical structures and lead to actoal trant=
former failure in @ short period of time,
OVEREXCITATION CAPABILITIES
Bh 1926 McNutt, ct af [4] presented a comprehensive
analysis of the saveral components of trapstormet over~
excitation losses. They showed that a rather lorg period of
overezctation is required ‘or the cors laminations to overhost
and cause canage. However, unlamirated structural parts cen
experience runaway heating in a very short time. For example
thay show that these losste Incraasé 25 fold in going. from
110% to 120% excitation, Similarly, conductor loss due to
seeay flux eddy currents can Incresse’ to necrly 200% of Tull
load conductor Joss at 1308 excitation, They (3! proposed a
Buide for permissiste short time wansformer ovetexcitation
capabillty ‘as shovn in Tig, 2 Sevecal ower irenslormer
overexcitation capability curves, Including the German Stané-
ard are shown in Fig, $ The curves in Figs 3 and & are
preserted with vespect to the rated voltege af each tearoferr=
et. It the case of a generatar ~ stepup transformer urit, the
‘ranstoriner rating is frequently 5% lower voltage than the
gonerater-
LTT” cena ou FoR esse —
ent. uronic
i
Lt
wh ; Io
|
Tine net *
Fig 3 Standare overexcitation capabilities.
T
2 oie concent |
‘WRI FAC TERS
Fae ¢
;* mea [ore mata
re |__. Saas
5
2m =
a
ea
Pig 4 Various overexdttation capabilities.
This mist be properly considered! when rationalizing the comb
ed overexcitation capability of the unit. And of course the
‘eansformer. capability is bared oa is auiput voltage wtiereas
the rit generator is. based on the generator-autput)
transformer Input vortage.
CAUSES OF OVEREXCITATION
‘The most licely location for an everexcltation condBtion 1s
at a genarating plant, but most ary poitt on a system could be
so affected for one reason or another. Some of the causes of
During generator start-up and shut-down overexci~
‘tation will cour at any machine apecd if the rated
Vjsiz ratio is exceeded.
2 Less of Ina or long sheng with fate to reduce
generator Held corent scordinghy._ Mainaiing field
Shrrent in such circumstances has eoviows eliecss
Howeves, generator voltage maintatsed atthe foreat
valve cx also raul in overexciattn of the tarpon
There ils is avident trom fig. here the teansbort=
rpeimiry voltage of 13 pu ls also the sezondary
Woltage under ane load condition, Tals can be further
ggrovened It tre charging crvent of high vonage
Cit alo posers
3+ Lees af toad or load shedding a¢ 2 tranformer subsiax
tlen. Norinally L-T-C cqntrat action or voltage cf
trol capacitor. switching will restore voltage to an
scuepteble lavel,, But if the loss ef load is wide
spresd, the primary supply system voltage may be toe
high for toca) corrective action to be fully effective.
8, landing
a). Lass of Joad of load shedding as noted in items 2
land 3 above may de compounded by low frequer=
‘ey when Islanding occurs.
b) Malntaining voltage, as many regulating systems
ddo during low Jrequency can also result in over—
excitation
J. Malfunctigning of regulating equipment. Historically
operator interveniion has provided suitable "baclup®
42 L-TCh an€ other automatic regulating devices.
Pewor eperaiors, more automatic sequences and more
sensitivity of transformers and machines to overexc
tation increases the prababllity of overascitation