11/4/2019 Crossing A Red Line - The Times Of India - Chandigarh, 11/1/2019

Crossing A Red Line

Chinese transgressions in South China Sea need strong pushback
Baladas Ghoshal

Haiyang Dizhi 8, a Chinese survey vessel that encroached deep into Vietnam’s exclusive economic zone
(EEZ) before withdrawing has clearly impinged on the country’s territorial integrity and economic
security. Asean, whose one member has been subjected to aggression, must tell China to refrain from such
activities. The Haiyang Dizhi 8 vessel first entered Vietnam’s EEZ early July where it began a weekslong
seismic survey, triggering a tense standoff between military and coast guard vessels from Vietnam and
China. Typically extending up to 200 nautical miles from the coastline, the EEZ allows a country
sovereign rights to exploit any natural resources within that area.

Last month, a Chinese giant crane vessel had been tracked to 90 km from the Vietnamese coastline fuelling
the risk of further maritime confrontation between the two countries. The Lan Jing, believed to be one of
the largest crane ships in the world, left the coastal city of Zhanjiang in southern China’s Guangdong
province earlier last month. It arrived offshore of Quang Ngai, a province in Vietnam’s south central coast,
according to Marine Traffic, a website which tracks vessel movements.

The presence of the ship so close to the Vietnamese coastline is an indication of Beijing upping the ante to
stretch Hanoi’s maritime capacity to its limit, by hampering Vietnam’s oil and gas exploration which is
being carried out in partnership with Russian petroleum company Rosneft. The arrival of the Lan Jing not
only had a “political signalling utility” – according to an observer on the issue but also an “operational
one” – forcing Vietnam to stretch its limited maritime forces capacity not only in Vanguard Bank but also
over Lan Jing. This complicates the situation for Hanoi which already faces a yawning asymmetry with
China in terms of maritime forces capacity.

Even though Vietnam and China have for years been embroiled in a dispute over the potentially energy-
rich stretch of waters and a busy shipping lane in the South China Sea, the latter’s encroachments into
Vietnam’s EEZ has intensified in recent years and particularly in the last few months, perhaps to fulfil
Emperor Xi Jinping’s dream of Chinese hegemony of the region and to coincide with the celebration of 70
years of the founding of the Communist Republic. China’s unilaterally declared “nine-dash line” marks a
vast, U-shaped, expanse of the South China Sea that it claims, including large swathes of Vietnam’s
continental shelf where it has awarded oil concessions to Russia and India.

The Permanent Court of Arbitration Tribunal in 2016 had nullified Chinese claims on practically the whole
of South China Sea and its so-called historical rights and nine-dash line, pointing out that Beijing had no
entitlement to an exclusive zone within 200 nautical miles of the Spratly Islands. The judgment also
indicted Beijing for destroying marine ecology and environment by establishing artificial islands and
militarising them for bolstering its claims. The PCA ruling is undoubtedly a victory of a 21st century rules-
based order over China’s 19th-century plans for its own sphere of influence. China’s expansive claim on
the South China Sea comes at the expense of the legitimate claim of some other countries like the
Philippines, Vietnam and Malaysia to name a few. Its land-grabbing techniques by stealth, artificial island-
building and subsequent militarisation to scare others away have reached a dangerous proportion turning
South China Sea into a flashpoint that can go out of control any moment.

https://epaper.timesgroup.com/Olive/ODN/TimesOfIndia/PrintArticle.aspx?doc=TOICG%2F2019%2F11%2F01&entity=ar01500&ts=20191101021542&… 1/3
11/4/2019 Crossing A Red Line - The Times Of India - Chandigarh, 11/1/2019

The burden of restraining China and evolving a mechanism to manage conflict in South China Sea falls on
Asean. In June, when the Asean foreign ministers met, the chairman’s statement noted concern and
weariness about Beijing’s activities in the South China Sea, took note of the land reclamations and
activities in the area, which have eroded trust and confidence, increased tensions and may undermine
peace, security and stability in the region. In the ongoing Asean Summit in Bangkok, it is imperative that
the organisation shows greater unity and insists on Chinese restraint.

While India takes a cautious approach on the South China Sea issue, we cannot be indifferent to the
increasing tension in the region caused by China’s bellicosity. India must accord South China Sea a higher
priority and greater seriousness in foreign policy taking into account geo-economic realities. The South
China Sea is a vital waterway through which $5 trillion of trade passes every year. The Straits of Malacca
– the choke point which connects the Indian Ocean with the South China Sea – handles five times the
volume of oil than the Suez Canal. India’s strategic ties with countries in the region, especially with
Malaysia, Indonesia, Singapore, Vietnam and the Philippines have become stronger under Prime Minister
Narendra Modi’s Act East Policy.

More importantly, the Indo-Pacific is virtually India’s new neighbour. India has as much stake in peace and
tranquillity in the South China Sea, as any other regional power – Asean, China, Japan or the US. Asean
also likes India to take a more active role in the emerging political, economic and security architecture of
Indo-Pacific and it fits in with New Delhi’s own image as an emerging global power. It is therefore
expected that PM Modi will touch on the South China Sea in his speeches at the summit and will reiterate
India’s position on the freedom of navigation, a rule-based maritime order and settlement of disputes
through peaceful means.

The writer is a former Professor and Chair in Southeast Asian Studies, JNU

https://epaper.timesgroup.com/Olive/ODN/TimesOfIndia/PrintArticle.aspx?doc=TOICG%2F2019%2F11%2F01&entity=ar01500&ts=20191101021542&… 2/3
11/4/2019 Crossing A Red Line - The Times Of India - Chandigarh, 11/1/2019

More importantly, the Indo-Pacific is virtually India’s new neighbour. India has as much stake in peace
and tranquillity in the South China Sea, as any other regional power

https://epaper.timesgroup.com/Olive/ODN/TimesOfIndia/PrintArticle.aspx?doc=TOICG%2F2019%2F11%2F01&entity=ar01500&ts=20191101021542&… 3/3