Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Individualizing Fluid
Replacement Guidelines
Rebecca M. Lopez, PhD, ATC, CSCS
Department of Orthopaedics and Sports Medicine, University of South Florida, Tampa, Florida
Downloaded from https://journals.lww.com/nsca-scj by BhDMf5ePHKav1zEoum1tQfN4a+kJLhEZgbsIHo4XMi0hCywCX1AWnYQp/IlQrHD3IOi9dz/r5OE/KArBV6vCohzPAHYhnT1U1JYsrxHCW4annpYMBkQViA== on 04/18/2019
SUMMARY conditions, intensity level, duration, studies have demonstrated that exercis-
rest periods, the amount of clothing ing in a hypohydrated state can result
WHEN DEVELOPING FLUID
worn, and the goal of the session, prac- in increases in heart rate and core body
REPLACEMENT GUIDELINES FOR
tice, or competitive event. Similarly, temperature (10,13,21,30,39,41). On the
EXERCISING INDIVIDUALS, A
individuals may also vary substantially other hand, others (14,32,33) have dem-
VARIETY OF FACTORS SHOULD BE with regard to sweat rate, hydration onstrated that fluid deficits during
TAKEN INTO CONSIDERATION. THE status, physical fitness, level of heat in vivo situations (where intensity was
ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS, acclimatization, and their overall not controlled) may not be as detrimen-
INTENSITY LEVEL, DURATION OF physiological response to exercise. As tal as that seen in controlled laboratory
EXERCISE, VARIABILITY IN SWEAT a result of these variations, it is difficult studies. More recently, several con-
RATE, AND LEVEL OF HEAT ACCLI- to either recommend general fluid trolled field studies (8,22) found that
MATIZATION ARE AMONG THOSE requirements or recommend that all when intensity was controlled in a field
FACTORS. DETERMINING INDIVID- exercising individuals simply drink setting and fluid deficits were present
UAL SWEAT RATES AND ASSESS- according to their thirst. In the past, during exercise, core body temperature
ING HYDRATION STATUS SHOULD various organizations have produced and heart rate were significantly ele-
HELP GUIDE SPECIFIC RECOM- general guidelines for fluid replace- vated in a similar fashion as has been
MENDATIONS. THE TYPE OF ment; however, research and clinical seen in the laboratory setting. Interest-
EXERCISE TOGETHER WITH THE experiences have demonstrated that ingly, in cases where individuals were
SPECIFIC NEEDS OF THE INDIVID- hydration should be individualized. hypohydrated and heart rate during ex-
UAL WILL HELP DETERMINE THE Variability between individuals and ercise was controlled, heart rate was
FLUID REPLACEMENT BEVERAGE even among the same person in differ- significantly elevated after exercise com-
THAT WOULD BE MOST BENEFI- ent situations demonstrates the need pared with a hydrated control, resulting
CIAL. EDUCATING INDIVIDUALS for individualization of fluid replace- in a slower recovery rate (8). Similarly,
ment guidelines (25,40). It is imperative a study examining the effects of dehy-
ABOUT THEIR OWN FLUID NEEDS
that clinicians use the latest research dration on resistance exercise found that
WILL ENSURE THAT THEY
together with the knowledge of their 3% body mass losses resulted in higher
EXERCISE SAFELY AND
athletes to ensure the best, evidence- preset heart rates and also hindered
PERFORM WELL.
based clinical practice when it comes heart rate recovery (20).
to hydration for athletes. These same disparities between field
INTRODUCTION studies and laboratory studies have been
luid replacement for exercising seen in regard to the effect of hydration
F
EFFECTS OF HYDRATION STATUS
individuals is a topic of much on exercise performance. The American
ON PHYSIOLOGICAL FUNCTION
debate both in the clinical and AND EXERCISE PERFORMANCE College of Sports Medicine’s position
research arenas. Coaches and health It is not uncommon for exercising indi- stand on exercise and fluid replacement
care professionals who may have the viduals to experience a fluid deficit if (40) recommends preventing body mass
responsibility of determining their sweat losses are not replaced during
athletes’ fluid needs should consider an exercise bout (25). The extent that KEY WORDS:
a variety of factors before developing this fluid deficit can affect physiological euhydration; fluid replacement; hypo-
a hydration plan. Any given exercise function and performance has also been hydration
bout may vary in the environmental a topic of debate. Decades of laboratory
Copyright Ó National Strength and Conditioning Association Strength and Conditioning Journal | www.nsca-scj.com 49
Individualizing Fluid Replacement
losses greater than 2% to prevent decre- affected by dehydration (16,19,20). performance. However, it seems im-
ments in performance, whereas a recent Hayes and Morse (16) found that practical to continue to argue that there
meta-analysis concluded that body mass dehydration had no effect on vertical is one best method of replacing fluids for
losses may have actually improved jumping or isokinetic leg extensions at all exercising individuals. An individual’s
cycling time trials (15). However, it is 120˚ per second; however, dehydration fluid needs are dictated by several factors
important to note that these cycling time impaired isometric and isokinetic leg and may vary accordingly. The same
trials occurred under mild environmen- extensions at 30˚ per second. Jones fluid recommendations would not be
tal conditions (26˚C) (15). The recom- et al. (19) found that approximately given to a runner participating in a mar-
mendation to prevent body mass deficits 3% body mass losses negatively athon in cool weather as to an American
of 2% or more is supported by several affected the ability to generate both football offensive lineman practicing in
researchers (25,43,44), particularly when upper and lower extremity anaerobic full pads, in 2-a-day practices and in
these fluid deficits occur while exercising power, whereas Kraft et al. (20) found a hot, humid environment. Similarly,
in the heat (8,17,22,45). In 2 recent field that the same body mass losses signif- an individual’s fluid needs in the winter
studies, trail runners running at the same icantly impaired resistance exercise, may vary from his/her own fluid needs
exercise intensity ran significantly slower increased heart rate during exercise, in the hot, summer months.
and had higher heart rates compared increased perceived exertion, and
decreased repetitions. Some of these Some fluid replacement guidelines rec-
with hydrated control trials (8,22).
performance deficits may also be attrib- ommend that athletes drink when
In a recent editorial, these inconsisten- thirsty (33). The basis behind this rec-
uted to mood disturbances and/or
cies in the literature were attributed to ommendation is that the thirst response
impaired cognitive abilities. Studies have
differences between controlled exer- mechanism is triggered to ensure plasma
revealed mood disturbances (2,12),
cise bouts to volitional exhaustion in osmolality is maintained between 280
decreased attention (3), and impaired
laboratory studies and real-life com- and 295 mOsm/kg H2O (33). Although
cognitive performance (12) associated
petitive events, where individuals this may be used successfully for some
with various levels of dehydration.
exercise “as fast as possible” rather than experienced runners in cooler environ-
Therefore, perhaps the combined effects
“as long as possible”(31). Furthermore, ments, drinking to thirst has often
of the physiological and psychological
the notion that individuals can self- resulted in significant fluid losses (24)
impairments due to dehydration result
pace in real-life competition compared that may have negative effects physio-
in decreased performance.
with the fixed-intensity exercise often logically or in performance (40), partic-
seen in laboratory studies is important FLUID REPLACEMENT BEFORE, ularly when exercising in hot, humid
to note. Self-paced exercise becomes DURING, AND AFTER EXERCISE environments.
extremely important in hot conditions Recent studies have demonstrated the
where individuals may be experiencing importance of beginning an exercise Drinking to thirst may not always be
considerable heat strain combined with bout in a euhydrated state (8,22). practical in all settings. For instance, in
a fluid deficit; most individuals will Beginning an exercise bout in a hypohy- some situations, exercising individuals
naturally decrease their intensity to drated state has been shown to decrease may have barriers to hydration, such
accommodate to these circumstances, performance and impair physiological as limited access to fluids because of
often resulting in slower run times and function by increasing heart rate and the nature of the sport or the location
decrements in performance. Ask any core body temperature (8,22,38). Unfor- of the exercise bout, and they may not
runner who has run a marathon in tunately, several studies have shown be able to solely rely on thirst (35).
warmer than usual temperatures, and that athletes, including younger adoles- Similarly, when individuals are not
they will be quick to mention, perhaps cent athletes, are often hypohydrated at knowledgeable about appropriate
even before they begin the race, that the start of practice or even competitive hydration strategies or are unaware of
it is not going to be a personal best events (6,26,36,46–50). Therefore, their own fluid needs, this may result in
race time. ensuring that these individuals are edu- dehydration or even hyperhydration or
cated about their fluid needs, particu- overhydration (24), which may lead to
Although research on the impact of
larly at the start of exercise, is essential. hyponatremia and possibly death.
hydration on anaerobic activity is not
Therefore, exercising individuals
as prevalent, some studies have found Recommendations on how much fluid
decrements in anaerobic performance should be made aware of their sweat
individuals need during exercise have
with fluid deficits ranging from 1 to rates so that they are neither in a state
been extensively debated in sports fields,
more than 3% of body mass losses medical tents, conferences, and in the of hyperhydration nor lose so much
(3,4,11,16,19,20,27). In some studies, literature (31). The reasons for the fluid that it begins to impair their per-
fluid deficit resulted in decrements in debate are well warranted and 2-fold: formance or physiological responses
skill performance during basketball and (a) to prevent injury or death from to exercise.
soccer activities (4,27). Strength and drinking inappropriate amounts of fluid, Replacing fluids after exercise can
power have also been negatively and (b) to prevent decrements in athletic be extremely important as well,
Maresh CM. Exertional heat stroke in the 33. Noakes TD. Hydration in the marathon: environments. Scand J Med Sci Sports 20
athletic setting. Athletic Train Sports Using thirst to gauge safe fluid (Suppl 3): 90–94, 2010.
Health Care 3: 189–200, 2011. replacement. Sports Med 37: 463–466,
43. Shirreffs SM and Sawka MN. Fluid and
24. Lott MJ and Galloway SD. Fluid balance 2007.
electrolyte needs for training, competition,
and sodium losses during indoor tennis 34. O’Connor FG, Adams WB, Pyne S, and recovery. J Sports Sci 29(Suppl 1):
match play. Int J Sport Nutr Exerc Metab Brennan FH, Howard T, and Pappas CG. S39–S46, 2011.
21: 492–500, 2011. Managing emergencies in mass
44. Shirreffs SM, Sawka MN, and Stone M.
25. Maughan RJ and Shirreffs SM. Dehydration participation events: Medical triage and
Water and electrolyte needs for football
and rehydration in competitive sport. algorithms. Presented at: AMAA’s 20th
training and match-play. J Sports Sci 24:
Scand J Med Sci Sports20(Suppl 3): Annual Sports Medicine Symposium at the
699–707, 2006.
40–47, 2010. Marine Corps Marathon. Marymount
University Ballston Center, Arlington, VA, 45. Stearns RL, Casa DJ, Lopez RM,
26. McDermott BP, Casa DJ, Yeargin SW, October 28, 2011. McDermott BP, Ganio MS, Decher NR,
Ganio MS, Lopez RM, and Mooradian EA. Scruggs IC, West AE, Armstrong LE, and
Hydration status, sweat rates, and 35. O’Neal EK, Wingo JE, Richardson MT,
Leeper JD, Neggers YH, and Bishop PA. Maresh CM. Influence of hydration status
rehydration education of youth football
Half-marathon and full-marathon runners’ on pacing during trail running in the heat.
campers J Sport Rehab 18: 535–552,
hydration practices and perceptions. J Strength Cond Res 23: 2533–2541,
2009.
J Athletic Train 46: 581–591, 2011. 2009.
27. McGregor SJ, Nicholas CW, Lakomy HK,
36. Osterberg KL, Horswill CA, and Baker LB. 46. Stover EA, Petrie HJ, Passe D, Horswill CA,
and Williams C. The influence of
Pregame urine specific gravity and fluid Murray B, and Wildman R. Urine specific
intermittent high-intensity shuttle running
intake by National Basketball Association gravity in exercisers prior to physical
and fluid ingestion on the performance of
players during competition. J Athletic Train training. Appl Physiol Nutr Metab 31: 320–
a soccer skill. J Sports Sci 17: 895–903,
44: 53–57, 2009. 327, 2006.
1999.
37. Pfeiffer B, Stellingwerff T, Zaltas E, 47. Stover EA, Zachwieja J, Stofan J, Murray R,
28. Miller KC, Mack G, and Knight KL.
Electrolyte and plasma changes after Hodgson AB, and Jeukendrup AE. and Horswill CA. Consistently high urine
ingestion of pickle juice, water, and Carbohydrate oxidation from a drink during specific gravity in adolescent American
a common carbohydrate-electrolyte running compared with cycling exercise. football players and the impact of an acute
solution. J Athletic Train 44: 454–461, Med Sci Sports Exerc 43: 327–334, 2011. drinking strategy. Int J Sports Med 27:
2009. 38. Rowland T. Fluid replacement 330–335, 2006.
29. Miller KC, Mack GW, and Knight KL. requirements for child athletes. Sports Med 48. Volpe SL, Poule KA, and Bland EG.
Gastric emptying after pickle-juice 41: 279–288, 2011. Estimation of prepractice hydration status
ingestion in rested, euhydrated humans. 39. Sawka MN, A.J. Y, Francesconi P, of National Collegiate Athletic Association
J Athletic Train 45: 601–608, 2010. Muza SR, and Pandolf KB. Division I athletes. J Athletic Train 44:
Thermoregulatory and blood responses 624–629, 2009.
30. Montain SJ and Coyle EF. Influence of
graded dehydration on hyperthermia and during exercsie at graded hypohydration 49. Yeargin SW, Casa DJ, Armstrong LE,
cardiovascular drift during exercise. J Appl levels. J Appl Physiol 59: 1394–1401, Watson G, Judelson DA, Psathas E, and
Physiol 73: 1340–1350, 1992. 1985. Sparrow SL. Heat acclimatization and
31. Mündel T. To drink or not to drink? 40. Sawka MN, Burke LM, Eichner ER, hydration status of American football
Explaining "contradictory findings" in fluid Maughan RJ, Montain SJ, and players during initial summer workouts.
replacement and exercise performance: Stachenfeld NS. American College of J Strength Cond Res 20: 463–470, 2006.
Evidence from a more valid model for real- Sports Medicine position stand. Exercise
50. Yeargin SW, Casa DJ, Judelson DA,
life competition. Br J Sports Med 45: 1, and fluid replacement. Med Sci Sports
McDermott BP, Ganio MS, Lee EC,
2012. Exerc 39: 377–390, 2007.
Lopez RM, Stearns RL, Anderson JM,
32. Noakes TD. Drinking guidelines for 41. Sawka MN, Francesconi RP, Young AJ, Armstrong LE, Kraemer WJ, and
exercise: What evidence is there that and Pandolf KB. Influence of hydration level Maresh CM. Thermoregulatory responses
athletes should drink "as much as and body fluids on exercise performance in and hydration practices in heat-
tolerable", "to replace the weight lost the heat. JAMA 252: 1165–1169, 1984. acclimatized adolescents during
during exercise" or "ad libitum"? J Sports 42. Shirreffs SM. Hydration: Special issues for preseason high school football. J Athletic
Sci 25: 781–796, 2007. playing football in warm and hot Train 45: 136–146, 2010.