You are on page 1of 117

Shiv Nadar University

School of Management and Entrepreneurship (SME)

SYLLABUS
ACADEMIC SESSION FALL 2019

ISM 101 – Introduction to Information Systems and Operations


Management (OM)

Visiting Faculty: Ajit Saxena

1 11/14/19 © Nokia 2017


For internal use
Operation Management Syllabus & Class schedule

Class Topic Objective and Learning Outcomes

• What is Operation Management and economic sense behind OM


• Evolution of Operation Management techniques with evolution of
Overview of Operation Industrial Management
1
Management • Define quality and TQM
• What is ISO , Six Sigma and Lean?
• The seven tools of TQM
• Process overview and concept of SIPOC in defining process flow
Setting up business • Capacity planning
2 performance measurement • Concepts of key performance Indicators and its operational
system (BPMS) definition
• Setting up measurement system
• DMAIC overview
• Basic statistics
Quality Management
3 • Types of data – Discrete & continuous
methodologies – Six Sigma
• Data normality, Central Tendency theorem & Variation
• Gauge R&R – repeatability & reproducibility
• Use and purpose of a control chart
4 Statistical Process Control • Types of control charts
• Process Capability and Learn the use of process capability

Quality Management • Fundamentals and Evolution of Lean


5
methodologies – Lean • Lean principles & tools
2
Operation Management Syllabus & Class schedule

Class Topic Objective and Learning Outcomes

• Process flow concepts, Just in Time (JIT) and Toyota way of


Application of Key Lean production system
6
tools • Value Stream Mapping (VSM) and its application in streamlining
in process flow
• Understand time horizons for forecasting
• Quantitative methods: Simple, moving average, exponential
7 Forecasting
smoothing
• Signal tracking

• Define capacity, determine design capacity, effective capacity,


and capacity utilization
• Compute net present value (NPV)
Capacity planning, location
8 • What factors affect location and Methods of evaluating location
and layout strategy
alternatives
• How to achieve a process-oriented layout facility?
• How to achieve a product-oriented layout facility?

• What is project management?


• Application of PM in production as well as in service industry
9 Project Management • Understand relationships between short time scheduling,
concept of critical path and master schedule
• Learn how to develop Gantt Chart

3
Operation Management Syllabus & Class schedule

Class Topic Objective and Learning Outcomes

• Describe labor planning policies


Human Resources (HR) and • Issues in job design
10 Job Design • Learn the tools of methods analysis
• Understand the contribution of the visual workplace
• Explain the strategic importance of the supply chain (SC)
• Identify the SC strategies
Supply chain Management and • Issues and opportunities in SC
11 Outsourcing • Evaluate SC performance
• Compute percent of assets committed to inventory
• Compute inventory turnover

• Conduct an ABC analysis


• Explain cycle counting
• Details of EOQ and POQ models
12 Inventory Management
• Computation of reorder point and safety stock
• Learn the quantity discount model
• Understand the basics of probabilistic inventory models

• Decision process in OM
• What is decision-making?
• Decision-making under uncertainty
13 Decision Making Analysis
• EMV analysis
• EVPI analysis
• Strategy and decision-making 4
Setting up business performance measurement
system (BPMS)

5
BPMS

Business Process Management System (BPMS)- a nine step model enables companies to model, deploy
and manage mission-critical business processes, that span multiple enterprise applications, corporate
departments. BPMS is usually used for lesser mature processes to make them Repeatable & Reliable.

The nine step approach includes:

1. Create Process Mission


2. Document Process
3. Document Customer & Process requirements
4. Identify Output & Process Measures
5. Build process management system
6. Establish data collection plan
7. Process performance monitoring
8. Develop dashboards with spec limits & targets
9. Identify improvement opportunities https://youtu.be/XtvIU0ZCwjE

https://youtu.be/_YXqnEXnnBk
6
SIPOC
SIPOC:
• A tool to identify all relevant elements of a process
• Helps to understand a complex process better
• Graphic display of steps, events and operations that constitute a
process

S - Suppliers
I - Inputs
P - Process
O - Outputs
C - Customers

7
SIPOC
Suppliers
– People who provide input to the process

Inputs
– Information, material etc., goes into the process from some other group of
people (supplier)

Process
– Process is a series of activities that takes an input, adds value to it and
produces an output for a customer

Outputs
– Output of a process creating a product or service that meets a customer need

Customers
8
– Users of the output
Information Flow & Measures
Thinking
Flow
Requirements Requirements

S I P O C

Suppliers Inputs Process Outputs Customers

Input Measures Process Measures Output Measures

Measures That Are


Internal To Your Output Measures
The Key Quality
Process. They Include Are Measures Used
and Delivery
Quality and Delivery To Determine How
Requirements
Measures Important To Well Customer Needs
Placed On Your
Your Internal Customers And Requirements
Suppliers.
As Well as Waste and Are Met.
Cycle Time Measures.
9
SIPOC: Example 1:
Contract Management : Contract Publishing
SIPOC LEVEL I Contract Management : Contract Publishing

Supplier Input Process Output Customer


Electronic 1.Receive scanned images
Scanning Team Documents

Job Aid: Four-Eye 2.Sanity Check


ABC Bank
principle, Contract
Commodity Record
Classification, 3.Assign Contract Number
Global Sourcing- Template from
ABC Retained Emptoris, A-
signatory list 4. Upload Data

Vendor folder P2P Arthur


in shared drive
5.Create Vendor Folder in the shared drive
Vendor Number
from SAP, Contract
template from
Emptoris 6. Review Contract record

7.Publish Contract
Contract
Number.xls,
Contract
Information Sheet 8.Update Contract Tracking Sheet

10
Contract Management : Contract Review
SIPOC LEVEL I Contract Management : Contract Review

Supplier Input Process Output Customer


Electronic 1. View & analyze electronic document
Documents
Global Sourcing-
ABC Retained Review
ABC Bank
2. Check Contract Compliance Record
Job Aid

P2P Contract
3. Validate Contract Data
Management
Onshore Team Emptoris P2P Arthur

4. Check terms & conditions Vs ABC standard terms & conditions

Contract
Number.xls

5. Create Contract Summary records

11
SIPOC: Example 2:
Call Handling
S I P O C
Agents Team Incoming Call Opening Completed Caller
Call Call
Y
Spanish? Interpreter
Managers Client
ACD
Performance
Confirmation
Reports
Auditors IVR Internal
Verification Customers

Number of App Assistance


agents, Speed of
Managers, answer
Response Satisfaction
Auditors, Number of
Calls score
ACD calls,
Certified /
Pattern, Q
Y abandoned
ASA
On training Escalate? & Time
Experience
Spanish? N Quality
Agent
productivity
/Vintage Nature of Closing Talk Time
Query Talk Time
Process
Wrap Time
Knowledge App Wrap Time
After Call Work Hold time
Listening / Response %
Accent, Resolved ? Abandoned
Uptime of
speaking & No of lines per step, Time per
ACD, Alltel Aband Time
keyboarding step, Time holding for response,
Skills Noise? Call Accuracy, Quality, Cycle Time AHT,ACW
Input Measures Process Measures Output Measures
12
Performance Measurement Indicators
Performance Measurement Indicators
Performance Measurement Indicators
Operational Definition

An operational definition is a precise description of the specific criteria used


for the measures (the what), the methodology to collect the data (the how),
the amount of data to collect (how much) and who has the responsibility to
measure the data

When developing an operational definition, it is important for the team to


fully understand and agree that the DEFINITION reflects exactly what
information the team is attempting to gather on the process.

16
Operational Definition
Example :

Operational definitions may determine whether, a team is required to


count all the defects on an invoice (required to calculate defects per
million opportunities)
or

the total number of defective invoices (any invoice with any defect)
or

the type of defects encountered on an invoice (to eliminate the most


common defects first).

Each of these cases may require a very different approach for gathering
the data.

17
Example of Operational Definition.

Poor Operational Definition:


Cycle time of a transaction

Good Operational Definition:


Collect data for all transactions processed from 1-Aug-05 to 31-Aug-05.
The cycle time of each transition will be determined by the date and
time of transaction download from client server by an agent/CSR to the
date and time of the PROCESSED transaction was submitted in client
server as per the client server system time.

18
Exercise: Operational Definition

Write operational definitions for the following cases

1) Maximization the server availability

2) Reduction of the attrition rate in ABZ

3) Improving the quality percentage a process

4) Reduction of call handling time

5) Minimization of abandoned calls in a call center

19
Basic Statistics

20
Data Types - Overview

§ Not all data is the same, the mathematical attributes for different types of
measurements/data are different
§ A Survey score on a scale of 1-10 has different attributes when compared to room
temperature measured in degrees Celsius

§ Few data types provide more information about the attributes of the unit being
measured when compared to other data types

§ The type/attributes of data determines


§ What are the appropriate measurements of central tendency & variation
§ The amount of data to be collected for sampling
§ What tools should be used for analysis of data for accurate test results
§ The distribution/shape of the data
Types of Data
Data Types

Discrete Continuous

Binary Ordinal Count

Classified into two Measured on a continuous scale.


Rank / Rating / Discrete Count
categories only Can be measured to infinity & to
Definite Scale any decimal precision

Has an employee Number of


Employee
completed 5 years employees who
in the company satisfaction with completed 5 years Tenure of employee measured in
the company on a in the company years of service completed
scale of 1-5
Data Types – Key differences

Discrete Data Continuous Data

§ Can identify if a unit/situation is a problem § Apart from identifying whether there is a


or not with limited/no understanding of the problem or not, captures the extent of the
extent of the problem problem in great detail

§ Cant be measured to infinity § Can be measured to infinity

§ Cant be measured to any desired level of § Can be measured to the desired level of
precision precision

§ Measures of central tendency & variation § Measures of central tendency & variation
cant be applied all times can be applied at all times

§ Easier and less expensive to collect § Requires a gauge and is more expensive to
discrete data collect continuous data

§ Larger samples are required for analysis § Smaller samples can be used for analysis
Identify Data Types

Identify the data types for the examples below


§ Revenue by sales person
§ Employee satisfaction survey score
§ Cycle time for processing an invoice
§ Average speed to answer for a call
§ Function over budget / under budget
§ Meters of cable required for installation
§ Project completion on time
§ Number of calls received by the call center
§ Number of visits to resolve a service request
§ Lead time to fulfill purchase requisition
§ % of parts stocked for service
§ Supplier meets OH&S requirements
Shapes of data - Overview

§ A data distribution is a frequency distribution (Histogram) for the data


values in a given sample

§ The shape/distribution of the data provides more information about the


randomness of the individual data points apart from highlighting some
aspects of the process being studied

§ The statistical tools and analysis is different for different types of data
distributions
Types of data distributions
There is almost an infinite variety of data frequency distributions, but we
shall consider only three in our efforts to understand how frequency
distributions affect the interpretation of data
Normal Distribution
§ Normal Distribution: Sometimes called the "bell curve“, is perhaps Examples:
the best-known data distribution. Data are symmetrically distributed to 1. Repair Times
2. Any process with specification
either side of a central value, so the entire population can be limits & target
represented equally well by the mean, median, or the mode. 3. Weight/height of people

§ Skewed Distribution: Skewed distributions are similar to the normal Skewed Distribution
Examples:
distribution, but the data are not distributed symmetrically. In these 1. Distribution of wealth
cases, the entire population is better represented by either the median 2. Time between arrivals

or the mode than by the mean.

Examples:
§ Uniform Distribution: A uniform distribution means that there is no Uniform Distribution 1. High precision processes
2. Mainframe server response
central value but that every value has the same likelihood of occurring. times
In such cases, the mean, median, and mode are meaningless. 3. Intervals between atomic
processes
4. Samples from perfect mixtures
Normal distribution

§ Bell Shaped: A normal distribution is bell shaped with a concentration of data points around the mean of the
distribution and reducing number of data points moving away from the mean

§ Continuous & Symmetrical: A normal distribution spreads till infinity on both sides of the mean and hence is
continuous. The number of data points on either side of the mean will be similar making the curve symmetrical

§ Measures: Mean can be safely used as the measure of central tendency of a normal distribution and a for
perfect normal distribution the mean, median & mode will be equal

§ Area: Total area under the normal curve is always equal to 1


Key Statistical measurements

§ Central Tendency (Mean, Median, Mode, etc)


§ Easiest way to measure performance for more than one transaction/event as a group
§ Typically used to define performance targets & benchmarks
§ Not sufficient by itself to provide a true picture of performance

§ Variation (Standard Deviation, Span, Range, etc)


§ Customers always feel the variation in any process/operation
§ Is inevitable and cannot be eliminated completely
§ Tolerances are an effective way of controlling variation
§ Is caused by a lot of factors, primarily variation in inputs and methods
Why measure central tendency

§ The idea of comparing an individual data point to the collective performance of the sample is
fundamental to statistics

§ Measures for central tendency are also critical in comparing two groups of data together, these
groups could be teams, organizations, etc

§ Majority of measurements we see around us in commercials/reports are measures of central


tendency. Ex: Average mileage, Average survey scores, etc
Why measure variation

§ Variation is an important statistical measure as it measures consistency and


compliments the measures of central tendency to provide a complete picture of
performance

§ Variation is the acid test beyond any central tendency measure in comparing
two or more groups of data

§ Customers to any process feel the variation in the process and not the average
Basic Statistics Primer – Variance Based Thinking >>>

An average without variation is of very little value!

Which river would you walk across?

Average = 4 feet

B
Average = 4 feet
Measures of Central tendency

Central tendency can be simply defined as the mid point of a given data
set or a point in the data set where the entire set can be balanced
equally on both sides

§ Mean: The average value, calculated by adding all the observations and
dividing by the number of observations.

§ Median: Middle value of a list or smallest number such that at least half the
numbers in the list are no greater than it.

§ Mode: The most common (frequent) value


Mean (Average)

§ Mean is popularly known as average and is representative of the center point


of a sample
§ The correct measure of central tendency when the data is Continuous &
Normal
§ Formula in Excel to calculate Mean : average(Range)
Median (Mid Point)

{Date must be sorted ascending before calculating Median}

§ Not a measurement in itself but used as a method to represent a specific


measurement for a sample
§ Median is the 50th percentile of a given data sample
§ The correct measure of central tendency when the data is Continuous &
Normal/Non-Normal
§ Formula in Excel to calculate Median : median(Range)
Mode

Mode is simply the most frequently occurring value in a


sample

§ Not a measurement in itself but used as a method to represent a specific


measurement for a sample.
§ The correct measure of central tendency when the data is Continuous/Nominal
& Normal/Non-Normal
§ Formula in Excel to calculate Mode : mode(Range)
Measures of Variation

Variation can be defined as the difference in the values of the data points in a given data set or
the deviation of any given data point from the center of the process.

§ Variance: Is computed as the average squared deviation of each number from its mean

§ Standard Deviation: Computed as Square root of Variance, standard deviation is also


referred to as the SPREAD of a process.

§ Inter Quartile Range: Difference between the 75th & the 25th percentile
Variance

§ Not a measurement in itself but used as a method to represent a specific


measurement for a sample
§ Variance takes into consideration the difference of each data point from the
central point in the process
§ The correct measure of variation when the data is Continuous & Normal
§ Formula in Excel to calculate Variance : var(Range)
Standard Deviation

§ Not a measurement in itself but used as a method to represent a specific measurement for a
sample.
§ Standard deviation is simply the square root of variation. However it is a more popular measure in
statistics as it is easy to compute percentile rank associated with the source using standard
deviation. In a normal distribution ~68% of data points are within 1, ~95% of data points are within
2 and ~99.99966% of data points are within 6 standard deviation units from the mean of the data
sample
§ The correct measure of variation when the data is Continuous & Normal, a more widely used
replacement to variance as the measure of variation
§ Formula in Excel to calculate Standard Deviation : stdev(Range)
Inter Quartile Range

§ Divides a set of data into two groups (high and low) of equal size at the statistical median if there is
an even number of data points, or two groups consisting of points on either side of the statistical
median itself plus the statistical median if there is an odd number of data points

§ The correct measure of variation when the data is Continuous/Nominal & Non-Normal, best used as
a measure of variation when the measure of central tendency being used is Median

§ Formula in Excel to calculate IQR:

§ percentile(Range,.75)-percentile(Range,.25)
STATISTICAL PROCESS CONTROL
PROCESS STABILITY & CAUSES OF VARIATION

Example:

Time to reach office : 9:30 am


It is not possible to reach office exactly at 9:30 everyday
Normally there will be a small variation around 9:30 as follows:

9:31 9:33 9:28 9:29 9:25

9:34 9:26 9:27 9:34 9.58

This small variation is difficult to explain.


PROCESS STABILITY & CAUSES OF VARIATION

Generally
Looking at the past values, it is possible to give some range around
9:30 am (e.g.: 9:30 ± 5 Minutes) to reach office
Normally it is possible to reach office within this range

Suppose
A particular day , there is vehicle break down
that day it may not be possible to reach office at 9:30 ± 5 Minutes
Say, you reach office at 9:50 am

In other words
If you reach office too late (beyond normal range of 9:30 ± 5 Minutes),
there will be some special reason for that or
it is easy to find out the reason for such variation
CONTROL CHARTS
• A statistical tool to ensure that process is stable or in control
• A statistical tool to detect the presence of Assignable Causes in the process.

PROCESS STABILITY & CAUSES OF VARIATION

1. Stable Process

• No Assignable Causes are present


• Process is operating under chance causes only

If a process is stable & the data follows normal distribution


Then the variation will be Mean ± 3 x Standard deviation
PROCESS STABILITY & CAUSES OF VARIATION

2. Assignable Cause of Variation

• Variations of large magnitude


• Easy to identify the causes of variation
• Easy to eliminate the cause of variation

3. Chance Cause of Variation

• Variations of small magnitude


• Difficult to identify the causes of variation
• Difficult to eliminate the cause of variation
PROCESS STABILITY & CAUSES OF VARIATION

Stable Process

• No Assignable Causes are present


• Process is operating under chance causes only

If a process is stable & the data follows normal distribution


Then the variation will be Mean ± 3 x Standard deviation
PROCESS STABILITY & CAUSES OF VARIATION

Stable Process: Example

The processing times of 10 transactions randomly taken from a transaction processing


process is given below. Based on the data, can we conclude that this process is stable?

5.1 5.5 4.5 4.8 5.0


5.1 5.2 5.5 4.9 4.5

Mean = 5.01
SD = 0.351
Mean + 3 x SD = 6.063
Mean – 3 x SD = 3.956
CONTROL CHARTS

1. For Normally distributed Data

UCL =Mean + 3 x SD
CL = Mean
LCL = Mean – 3 x SD

Control Chart
UCL

CL

LCL
Control Charts: Working

1. Calculate the Control Limits from past data


2. Plot the values in the chart
3. If the values are within the limits, the process is stable. Otherwise not.

Control Chart

6
5
4
3
2
1
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
Types of Control Charts

Continuous Data
• Xbar & R Chart
• Individual X & Moving range Chart

Discrete Data
Control Chart for Defectives
• p chart
• np chart
Control Chart for Defects
• c chart
• u chart
Steps for monitoring Handling Time using this Xbar & R Chart

1. Every hour collect Handling Time of 4 transactions from the process


2. Calculate the average Xbar & range R
3. Plot R value in R chart and Xbar value in Xbar chart
4. If either R chart or Xbar chart is showing out of control, the process is not
stable, search for assignable causes and correct the process. Otherwise
continue
Xbar chart
UCL = 5.014

CL=4.997

LCL=4.98
Steps for monitoring Handling Time using this Xbar & R Chart

Range chart
UCL = 0.053

CL=0.0233

LCL=0.00
Xbar – R Chart: Example
Process: Characteristic: Handling Time
Sample Size N: 9 Sub Group Size n: 4
Frequency of Sampling: Once in a Hour
Step 1: Collect Data

Sample No. Hour x1 x2 x3 x4


1 8:00 5.00 5.01 4.98 5.00
2 9:00 5.01 4.98 5.00 5.00
3 10:00 5.02 5.01 5.00 5.00
4 11:00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00
5 12:00 4.98 4.98 5.01 4.99
6 13:00 5.02 4.99 5.00 4.98
7 14:00 4.99 4.99 4.98 4.98
8 15:00 5.00 5.01 5.02 5.00
9 16:00 4.98 5.00 5.01 4.98
Xbar – R Chart: Example
Step 2: Calculate Sub Group Mean & Range

Sample No. Hour x1 x2 x3 x4 Mean Range


1 8:00 5.00 5.01 4.98 5.00 4.998 0.03
2 9:00 5.01 4.98 5.00 5.00 4.998 0.03
3 10:00 5.02 5.01 5.00 5.00 5.008 0.02
4 11:00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 0.00
5 12:00 4.98 4.98 5.01 4.99 4.990 0.03
6 13:00 5.02 4.99 5.00 4.98 4.998 0.04
7 14:00 4.99 4.99 4.98 4.98 4.985 0.01
8 15:00 5.00 5.01 5.02 5.00 5.008 0.02
9 16:00 4.98 5.00 5.01 4.98 4.993 0.03
Xbar – R Chart: Example
Step 3: Calculate Control Limits for R Chart

Center Line
CL = Mean = Rbar = Sum of all Range Values / Total Number
of Values
= 0.21 / 9 = 0.0233

Upper Control Limit


UCL = Mean + 3 SD = D4 Rbar, For n = 4, D4 = 2.282
= 2.282 x 0.0233 = 0.053

Lower Control Limit


LCL = Mean - 3 SD = D3 Rbar, For n = 4, D3 = 0
= 0 x 0.0233 = 0.0
Xbar – R Chart: Example
Step 4: Plot R values in R chart as shown below:

R Chart

0.06
0.05
0.04
0.03
0.02
0.01
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

Step 5: If any value is beyond Control Limits, Do Homogenization

Homogenization:
Remove the out of control value
Recalculate the limits
Xbar – R Chart: Example
Step 6: Calculate Control Limits for Xbar Chart

Center Line
CL = Mean = Xdoublebar = Sum of all Means / Total Number
of Values
= 44.975 / 9 = 4.997

Upper Control Limit


UCL = Mean + 3 SD = xdoublebar + A2Rbar, For n = 4, A2 = 0.729
= 4.997 + 0.729 x 0.0233 = 5.014

Lower Control Limit


LCL = Mean - 3 SD = xdoublebar - A2Rbar, For n = 4, A2 = 0.729
= 4.997 - 0.729 x 0.0233 = 4.98
Xbar – R Chart: Example
Step 7: Plot mean values in xbar chart as shown below:

xbar Chart

5.02
5.01
5
4.99
4.98
4.97
4.96
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

Step 8: If any value is beyond Control Limits, Do Homogenization


Xbar – R Chart: Exercise

A BPO company wants to ensure that the transaction processing process is free from
assignable causes. The following data on processing times was collected, How would
you establish a control mechanism so that the process is free from assignable cause?

Sample x1 x2 x3 Sample x1 x2 x3
Number Number
1 6.0 5.8 6.1 11 6.2 6.9 5.0
2 5.2 6.4 6.9 12 6.7 7.1 6.2
3 5.5 5.8 5.2 13 6.1 6.9 7.4
4 5.0 5.7 6.5 14 6.2 5.2 6.8
5 6.7 6.5 5.5 15 4.9 6.6 6.6
6 5.8 5.2 5.0 16 7.0 6.4 6.1
7 5.6 5.1 5.2 17 5.4 6.5 6.7
8 6.0 5.8 6.0 18 6.6 7.0 6.8
9 5.5 4.9 5.7 19 4.7 6.2 7.1
10 4.3 6.4 6.3 20 6.7 5.4 6.7
Individual X & Moving Range Chart: Example

• For Short Run Process


• Not possible to collect data in Sub Groups

Characteristic: Vendor Debit Balance at the end of day

Day Vendor Debit Balance Day Vendor Debit Balance


1 83670 9 233506
2 130682 10 72886
3 96428 11 59160
4 80396 12 141705
5 179682 13 92573
6 62505 14 223495
7 99748 15 144321
8 129064 16 138341
Individual X & Moving Range Chart: Example

Step 2: Calculate Moving Range

Vendor Debit Moving Vendor Debit Moving


Day Balance Range Day Balance Range
1 83670 9 233506 104442
2 130682 47012 10 72886 160620
3 96428 34254 11 59160 13726
4 80396 16032 12 141705 82545
5 179682 99286 13 92573 49132
6 62505 117177 14 223495 130922
7 99748 37243 15 144321 79174
8 129064 29316 16 138341 5980
Individual X & Moving Range Chart: Example

Step 3: Calculate Control Limits for M R Chart


Center Line
CL = Mean = MRbar = Sum of all MR Values / Total Number
of Values
= 1006861 / 15 = 67124.07

Upper Control Limit


UCL = Mean + 3 SD = D4 MRbar, For n = 2, D4 = 3.276
= 3.276 x 67124.07 = 219898.4

Lower Control Limit


LCL = Mean - 3 SD = D3 MRbar, For n = 2, D3 = 0
= 0 x 67124.07 = 0.0
Individual X & Moving Range Chart: Example

Step 4: Plot MR values in MR chart as shown below:

MR Chart

250000

200000
150000
100000
50000

0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Step 5: If any value is beyond Control Limits, Do Homogenization


Individual X & Moving Range Chart: Example

Step 6: Calculate Control Limits for Individual X Chart

Center Line
CL = Mean = Xbar = Sum of all Data / Total Number
of Values
= 1968162 / 16 = 123010.1

Upper Control Limit


UCL = Mean + 3 SD = xbar + A2MRbar, For n = 1, A2 = 2.66
= 123010.1 + 2.66 x 67124.07 = 301560.1

Lower Control Limit


LCL = Mean - 3 SD = xbar - A2MRbar, For n = 1, A2 = 2.66
= = 123010.1 - 2.66 x 67124.07 = -55539.9
Individual X & Moving Range Chart: Example

Step 7: Plot individual values in Individual X chart as shown below:

Individual X Chart

350000
300000
250000
200000
150000
100000
50000
0
-50000 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
-100000

Step 8: If any value is beyond Control Limits, Do Homogenization


Steps for monitoring Customer Rating using this Individual X & MR Chart
1. Collect the vendor debit balance every day
2. Calculate the Moving Range (MR) using current and previous day value
3. Plot MR value in MR chart and current vendor debit balance in Individual X
chart
4. If either MR chart or Individual X chart is showing out of control, the process
is not stable, search for assignable causes and correct the process.
Otherwise continue
Individual chart
UCL = 301560.1

CL=123010.1

LCL= -55539.9
Steps for monitoring Customer Rating using this Xbar & R Chart

Moving Range chart


UCL = 219898.4

CL=67124.07

LCL=0.00
Individual X & Moving Range Chart: Exercise
The weekly debit outstanding (in K) is given in t he table below. Kindly device a
mechanism to ensure that the assignable causes are not acting on the process
Day Data Day Data
1 8.1 11 8.1
2 9.5 12 8.2
3 7.2 13 8.3
4 6.0 14 9.1
5 9.1 15 8.0
6 5.8 16 7.3
7 8.1 17 8.4
8 7.2 18 4.5
9 5.1 19 7.1
10 8.0 20 5.1
Control Charts for Defectives: np Chart

Used when sample size is constant

Example: The number of transactions audited each day is constant and is


equal to 1000. Construct control chart to ensure that the quality of
the process remain stable?
Day Number of Defectives

1 47
2 42
3 48
4 58
5 32
6 38
7 53
8 68
9 45
10 37
np Chart : Calculation of Control Limits

CL = Mean
UCL = Mean + 3 SD
LCL = Mean – 3 SD
pbar = Sum of Defectives / total Number Inspected
= 468 /(1000*10) = 0.0468

Mean = npbar = 1000 x 0.0468 = 46.8


SD = Önpbar(1-pbar) = Ö(1000 x (0.0468 x (1-0.0468))) = 6.67

CL = npbar = 1000 x 0.0468 = 46.8


UCL = Mean + 3 SD = 46.8 + 3 x 6.68 = 66.84
LCL = Mean - 3 SD = 46.8 - 3 x 6.68 = 26.76
np chart: Example

Plot the number of defectives in np chart as shown below:

np Chart

80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

If any value is beyond Control Limits, Do Homogenization


Steps for monitoring Defectives using np Chart

1. Audit 1000 transactions every day


2. Count the number of defectives in 1000 transactions audited
3. Plot the number of defectives in the np chart given below
4. If the plotted value is beyond the limits, the process is not stable, take
actions to eliminate assignable causes. Otherwise continue

np chart
UCL = 66.84

CL=46.8

LCL=26.76
np Chart: Exercise

The following are the data on defectives in payment of dental insurance claims.
Device a mechanism to ensure the defectives is under control. Sample Size is 300

Sample Number of Sample Number of


Number Defectives Number Defectives

1 3 11 6
2 6 12 9
3 4 13 5
4 6 14 6
5 20 15 7
6 2 16 4
7 6 17 5
8 7 18 7
9 3 19 5
10 0 20 0
Control Charts for Defectives: p Chart

Used when sample size is not constant

Example: The daily report on Escalations are given below. Device a control
mechanism to ensure that the Escalations are kept under control
day by day ?
Day Number of Calls Number of Calls
Attended Escalated
1 500 5
2 550 6
3 700 8
4 625 9
5 700 7
6 550 8
7 450 10
8 600 6
9 475 9
10 650 6
p Chart : Calculation of Control Limits

CL = Mean
UCL = Mean + 3 SD
LCL = Mean – 3 SD
pbar = Sum of Defectives / Total Number Inspected
= 74 / 5800 = 0.0128

Mean = pbar = 0.0128


SD = Öpbar(1-pbar) / ni
p Chart : Calculation of Control Limits

Day Number Number of p LCL UCL


Inspected Defectives
1 500 5 0.010 0 0.028
2 550 6 0.011 0 0.027
3 700 8 0.011 0 0.026
4 625 9 0.014 0 0.026
5 700 7 0.010 0 0.026
6 550 8 0.015 0 0.027
7 450 10 0.022 0 0.029
8 600 6 0.010 0 0.027
9 475 9 0.019 0 0.028
10 650 6 0.009 0 0.026
p chart: Example

Plot the proportion of defectives in p chart as shown below:

p Chart

0.035
0.03
0.025
0.02
0.015
0.01
0.005
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

If any value is beyond Control Limits, Do Homogenization


Steps for monitoring Escalations using this p Chart

1. Collect the data on number of calls attended and number of calls escalated
everyday
2. Calculate the proportion p of escalated calls
3. Plot this p value in the p chart constructed using the pbar =0.0128
4. If p chart is showing out of control, the process is not stable, search for
assignable causes and correct the process. Otherwise continue

p Chart

0.035
0.03
0.025
0.02
0.015
0.01
0.005
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
p Chart: Exercise

Daily inspection results for the purchase order processing are given in the table.
Construct a control chart to ensure that the defectives are kept under control day
by day?

Day Number Number of Day Number Number of


Inspected Defectives Inspected Defectives

1 171 31 11 181 38
2 167 6 12 115 33
3 170 8 13 165 26
4 135 13 14 189 15
5 137 26 15 165 16
6 170 30 16 170 35
7 45 3 17 175 12
8 155 11 18 167 6
9 195 30 19 141 50
10 180 36 20 159 26
Control Charts for Defects: c Chart

Used when sample size is constant


Example: A financial transaction process has compiled the data in the table
showing the count of nonconformities for 1000 accounting
transactions per day. Device a mechanism to ensure that the non
conformities are under control?
Day Number of nonconformities

1 8
2 19
3 14
4 18
5 11
6 16
7 8
8 15
9 21
10 8
c Chart : Calculation of Control Limits

CL = Mean
UCL = Mean + 3 SD
LCL = Mean – 3 SD
cbar = Average number of defects per 1000 transactions
= 13.8

Mean = cbar = 13.8


SD = Öcbar = Ö13.8 = 3.71

CL = cbar = 13.8
UCL = Mean + 3 SD = 13.8 + 3 x 3.71 = 24.93
LCL = Mean - 3 SD = 13.8 - 3 x 3.71 = 2.67
c chart: Example

Plot the number of nonconformities in c chart as shown below:

c Chart

30
25
20
15
10
5
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

If any value is beyond Control Limits, Do Homogenization


Steps for monitoring Defects using c Chart

1. Audit 1000 Accounting transactions every day


2. Count the number of Errors in 1000 transactions audited
3. Plot the number of Errors in the c chart given below
4. If the plotted value is beyond the limits, the process is not stable, take
actions to eliminate assignable causes. Otherwise continue

c chart
UCL = 24.93

CL=13.8

LCL=2.67
c Chart: Exercise

100 transactions are inspected every day for fatal errors. The data for the past 20
days is given below. Construct a suitable control chart to ensure that the fatal errors
are under control?
Day Number of Fatal Day Number of Fatal
Errors Errors

1 22 11 15
2 29 12 10
3 25 13 33
4 17 14 23
5 20 15 27
6 16 16 15
7 34 17 17
8 11 18 17
9 31 19 19
10 29 20 22
Control Charts for Defects: u Chart

Used when sample size is not constant

Example: The inspection results of transaction monitoring is given below.


Construct a control chart to monitor the process and ensure that
errors are under control ?
Lot Number Number Inspected Number of Errors

1 10 45
2 10 51
3 10 36
4 9 48
5 10 42
6 10 5
7 10 33
8 8 27
9 8 31
10 8 22
u Chart : Calculation of Control Limits

CL = Mean
UCL = Mean + 3 SD
LCL = Mean – 3 SD
ubar = Sum of Defects / Total Number Inspected
= 340 / 93 = 3.66

Mean =ubar = 3.66


SD = Ö(ubar / ni)
U Chart : Calculation of Control Limits

Lot Number Number of u LCL UCL


Number Inspected Defects
1 10 45 4.5 2.80 5.47
2 10 51 5.1 2.86 5.47
3 10 36 3.6 2.70 5.47
4 9 48 5.3 2.83 5.57
5 10 42 4.2 2.77 5.47
6 10 5 0.5 1.09 5.47
7 10 33 3.3 2.66 5.47
8 8 27 3.4 2.56 5.69
9 8 31 3.9 2.63 5.69
10 8 22 2.8 2.44 5.69
u chart: Example

Plot the defects / unit (u) of in u chart as shown below:

u Chart

6
5
4
3
2
1
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

If any value is beyond Control Limits, Do Homogenization


Steps for monitoring Errors using this u Chart

1. Collect the data on number of transactions audited and number of errors


detected everyday
2. Calculate the number of errors per transaction u
3. Plot this u value in the u chart constructed using the ubar =3.66
4. If p chart is showing out of control, the process is not stable, search for
assignable causes and correct the process. Otherwise continue

u Chart

6
5
4
3
2
1
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
u Chart: Exercise

Construct a suitable control mechanism to ensure that the errors in payoff process
is under control?

Sample Number of Number of Sample Number of Number of


Number Payoffs Defects Number Payoffs Defects
inspected inspected

1 40 45 11 52 55
2 40 40 12 52 74
3 40 33 13 52 43
4 40 43 14 52 61
5 40 62 15 40 43
6 52 79 16 40 32
7 52 60 17 40 45
8 52 50 18 40 33
9 52 73 19 40 50
10 52 54 20 52 28
Failure Mode & Effect Analysis
(FMEA)
What is FMEA ?
• Analytical technique and systemised group of activities.
• Used to identify the potential failure modes, the effect of failures and their
associated cause and mechanism,
• A tool for design and process engineers / managers.
• An interactive and never ending process.
• Technique of reducing risk or of avoiding risk.
• A living document.
• “Before-the-event” action; and NOT an “After-the-fact”
exercise.
Cases
Case 1 : To design or setting up of new process. This will make the
process from beginning itself defect free (Design FMEA)
Case 2 : To modify existing processes to make it defect free (Process
FMEA)
Benefits

• Identifies potential problems with customer point of


view.

• Predictive & Preventive. (A Pro-active Approach).

• Prioritizes the variables to be focused.


When ?
• FMEA can be done at

- Engagement level
- Process level
- Sub Process level
Application

Design FMEA Process FMEA

Purpose Design / set up processes To ensure processes meet


to meet client SLAs
requirements
Responsibility Design & Operations Operations

Objective Avoiding design failures Avoiding failures during


processing
Advantage of Cross functional team

• Benefit of more extensive knowledge and experience.

• Increasing creativity.

• Increasing acceptance.

• Simultaneous & not successive decision process.


Process FMEA

• An analytical technique.
• Identifies potential process failure modes.
• Customer normally is end user but can be next process too.
• Assesses the potential effects of the failures on the
customer.
• Identifies the causes and process variables
to focus on.
• Prioritize corrective actions
Potential Failure Mode & Effects Analysis (Process FMEA)

Title : _________________ FMEA Number _________________


Process Responsibility : _______________ Page__________of ________
Prepared by ______________
Core Team : __________________ FMEA Date (Orig)__________ (Rev.)_____________
Process Potential Potential S Potential O Current D R Recomme Responsibility Action Results
Function/ failure effect(s) E causes / C proces E P nded & target
mode of failure mechanism s action(s) completion Actions S O D
Requirements V C T N date
s of failure control RPN
U E
s Taken
R C
T
Process function / requirements

• Description of process / operation being analyzed


Potential Failure Mode

• Manner in which process could potentially fail to meet the process


requirements and / or design intent.

• Description of nonconformance at that specific operation.


Potential Effect(s) of Failure

• Effect of failure mode on the customer (s)

• Describe effects of failure in terms of what customer(s) might notice or


experience

Examples: Penalty, Client loss, Monitory loss, problems with next operation
etc.
Severity

• Assessment of the seriousness of the effect of potential failure mode to


the customer.
Potential Cause(s) of Failure
• Every conceivable cause assignable to each potential failure mode.
• Specific causes where remedial efforts can be aimed.
Occurrence

• How frequently the specific failure cause /


mechanism is projected to occur ?

• Only occurrence resulting in failure mode to be considered.

• If available, use statistical data to determine occurrence ranking.


Current Process Controls

Description of the controls that either prevent to the extent possible


the cause from occurring
or
Detect the cause when it occur
Types of Process Controls Effected Ranking

Prevent the cause / mechanism from occurring or Occurrence


reduce their rate of occurrence. Ranking

Detect the cause / mechanism & lead to corrective Detection Ranking


actions.
Detection

• Probability that the proposed process control will detect the presence
of potential cause / mechanism

• Use of statistical sampling is better to detect as compared to random


sampling.
Risk Priority Number (RPN)

• RPN = (S) x (O) x (D)

• RPN used for prioritizing the area of concern

• Regardless of RPN, special attention required when 'SEVERITY' is


high.
Recommended Action

• Intent is to reduce severity, occurrence and / or detection rankings.


• Design and / or process revisions are required to reduce severity
rankings.
• Improving detection control is costly & ineffective in general.
• Focus on permanent corrective action.
Action Taken

• Enter a brief description of the action


• Estimate and record the resulting O,S,D and RPN rankings.
• Repeat Columns 19 through 22 if further action is considered
necessary.
• This ensures FMEA is a living document.
• FMEA can also be updated as and when new failure modes are
discovered.
Process FMEA
Guideline for estimating severity (s)

Effect Criteria : Severity of Effect Ranking


Hazardous Loss of Client, Huge Penalty, loss of job etc 10
without
warning

Hazardous Penalty, Huge client dissatisfaction, Affects 9


with performance appraisal
warning
Very High Affects performance appraisal, entire transaction need 8
to be reworked
Process FMEA
Guideline for estimating severity (s)

Effect Criteria : Severity of Effect Ranking

High Client dissatisfaction, transactions need to be reworked 7


partially

Moderate Client experiences discomfort, partial rework or 6


changes to processed transactions
Process FMEA (Contd.)
Guideline for estimating severity (s)

Effect Criteria : Severity of Effect Ranking


Low Partial rework. 5

Very Minor rework 4


Low
Process FMEA (Contd.)
Guideline for estimating severity (s)

Effect Criteria : Severity of Effect Ranking


Minor Minor rework 3

Very Minor rework 2


minor

None No effect 1
Process FMEA
Guideline for estimating detection (D)

Detection Criteria : Likelihood the existence of a defect will be detected by Ranking


Process Controls before next or subsequent process, or before
transaction leaves the operations.
Almost No known control(s) available to detect failure mode. 10
impossible
Very Very remote likelihood; current control(s) will detect failure mode. 9
Remote
Remote Remote likelihood; current control(s) will detect failure mode. 8
Very low Very low likelihood; current control(s) will defect failure mode. 7
Low Low likelihood; current control(s) will detect failure mode. 6
Moderate Moderate likelihood, current control(s) will detect failure mode. 5
Moderately Moderately high likelihood; current control (s) will detect failure 4
high mode.
Process FMEA (Contd.)
Guideline for estimating detection (D)

Detection Criteria : Likelihood the existence of a defect will be Ranking


detected by Process Controls before next or
subsequent process, or before transaction leaves the
operations
High High likelihood; current control(s) will detect failure 3
mode.
Very High Very high likelihood; current control(s) will detect failure 2
mode.
Almost Current control(s) almost certain to detect the failure 1
certain mode. Reliable detection controls are known with
similar processes.
Potential Failure Mode & Effects Analysis (Process FMEA)
Exercise 1 : Carry out PFMA for one process
Title : _________________ FMEA Number _________________
Process Responsibility : _______________ Page__________of ________
Core Team : __________________ FMEA Date (Orig)__________ (Rev.)_____________

Process Potentia Potenti S Potential O Curren D R Recomme Responsibil Action Results


Function/ l failure al E causes / C t E P nded ity & target Actions S O D
Requireme mode effect(s V mechanis C proces T N action(s) completion RPN
nts ) of ms of s date Taken
U E
failure failure control
R s C
T

You might also like