Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SYLLABUS
ACADEMIC SESSION FALL 2019
3
Operation Management Syllabus & Class schedule
• Decision process in OM
• What is decision-making?
• Decision-making under uncertainty
13 Decision Making Analysis
• EMV analysis
• EVPI analysis
• Strategy and decision-making 4
Setting up business performance measurement
system (BPMS)
5
BPMS
Business Process Management System (BPMS)- a nine step model enables companies to model, deploy
and manage mission-critical business processes, that span multiple enterprise applications, corporate
departments. BPMS is usually used for lesser mature processes to make them Repeatable & Reliable.
https://youtu.be/_YXqnEXnnBk
6
SIPOC
SIPOC:
• A tool to identify all relevant elements of a process
• Helps to understand a complex process better
• Graphic display of steps, events and operations that constitute a
process
S - Suppliers
I - Inputs
P - Process
O - Outputs
C - Customers
7
SIPOC
Suppliers
– People who provide input to the process
Inputs
– Information, material etc., goes into the process from some other group of
people (supplier)
Process
– Process is a series of activities that takes an input, adds value to it and
produces an output for a customer
Outputs
– Output of a process creating a product or service that meets a customer need
Customers
8
– Users of the output
Information Flow & Measures
Thinking
Flow
Requirements Requirements
S I P O C
7.Publish Contract
Contract
Number.xls,
Contract
Information Sheet 8.Update Contract Tracking Sheet
10
Contract Management : Contract Review
SIPOC LEVEL I Contract Management : Contract Review
P2P Contract
3. Validate Contract Data
Management
Onshore Team Emptoris P2P Arthur
Contract
Number.xls
11
SIPOC: Example 2:
Call Handling
S I P O C
Agents Team Incoming Call Opening Completed Caller
Call Call
Y
Spanish? Interpreter
Managers Client
ACD
Performance
Confirmation
Reports
Auditors IVR Internal
Verification Customers
16
Operational Definition
Example :
the total number of defective invoices (any invoice with any defect)
or
Each of these cases may require a very different approach for gathering
the data.
17
Example of Operational Definition.
18
Exercise: Operational Definition
19
Basic Statistics
20
Data Types - Overview
§ Not all data is the same, the mathematical attributes for different types of
measurements/data are different
§ A Survey score on a scale of 1-10 has different attributes when compared to room
temperature measured in degrees Celsius
§ Few data types provide more information about the attributes of the unit being
measured when compared to other data types
Discrete Continuous
§ Cant be measured to any desired level of § Can be measured to the desired level of
precision precision
§ Measures of central tendency & variation § Measures of central tendency & variation
cant be applied all times can be applied at all times
§ Easier and less expensive to collect § Requires a gauge and is more expensive to
discrete data collect continuous data
§ Larger samples are required for analysis § Smaller samples can be used for analysis
Identify Data Types
§ The statistical tools and analysis is different for different types of data
distributions
Types of data distributions
There is almost an infinite variety of data frequency distributions, but we
shall consider only three in our efforts to understand how frequency
distributions affect the interpretation of data
Normal Distribution
§ Normal Distribution: Sometimes called the "bell curve“, is perhaps Examples:
the best-known data distribution. Data are symmetrically distributed to 1. Repair Times
2. Any process with specification
either side of a central value, so the entire population can be limits & target
represented equally well by the mean, median, or the mode. 3. Weight/height of people
§ Skewed Distribution: Skewed distributions are similar to the normal Skewed Distribution
Examples:
distribution, but the data are not distributed symmetrically. In these 1. Distribution of wealth
cases, the entire population is better represented by either the median 2. Time between arrivals
Examples:
§ Uniform Distribution: A uniform distribution means that there is no Uniform Distribution 1. High precision processes
2. Mainframe server response
central value but that every value has the same likelihood of occurring. times
In such cases, the mean, median, and mode are meaningless. 3. Intervals between atomic
processes
4. Samples from perfect mixtures
Normal distribution
§ Bell Shaped: A normal distribution is bell shaped with a concentration of data points around the mean of the
distribution and reducing number of data points moving away from the mean
§ Continuous & Symmetrical: A normal distribution spreads till infinity on both sides of the mean and hence is
continuous. The number of data points on either side of the mean will be similar making the curve symmetrical
§ Measures: Mean can be safely used as the measure of central tendency of a normal distribution and a for
perfect normal distribution the mean, median & mode will be equal
§ The idea of comparing an individual data point to the collective performance of the sample is
fundamental to statistics
§ Measures for central tendency are also critical in comparing two groups of data together, these
groups could be teams, organizations, etc
§ Variation is the acid test beyond any central tendency measure in comparing
two or more groups of data
§ Customers to any process feel the variation in the process and not the average
Basic Statistics Primer – Variance Based Thinking >>>
Average = 4 feet
B
Average = 4 feet
Measures of Central tendency
Central tendency can be simply defined as the mid point of a given data
set or a point in the data set where the entire set can be balanced
equally on both sides
§ Mean: The average value, calculated by adding all the observations and
dividing by the number of observations.
§ Median: Middle value of a list or smallest number such that at least half the
numbers in the list are no greater than it.
Variation can be defined as the difference in the values of the data points in a given data set or
the deviation of any given data point from the center of the process.
§ Variance: Is computed as the average squared deviation of each number from its mean
§ Inter Quartile Range: Difference between the 75th & the 25th percentile
Variance
§ Not a measurement in itself but used as a method to represent a specific measurement for a
sample.
§ Standard deviation is simply the square root of variation. However it is a more popular measure in
statistics as it is easy to compute percentile rank associated with the source using standard
deviation. In a normal distribution ~68% of data points are within 1, ~95% of data points are within
2 and ~99.99966% of data points are within 6 standard deviation units from the mean of the data
sample
§ The correct measure of variation when the data is Continuous & Normal, a more widely used
replacement to variance as the measure of variation
§ Formula in Excel to calculate Standard Deviation : stdev(Range)
Inter Quartile Range
§ Divides a set of data into two groups (high and low) of equal size at the statistical median if there is
an even number of data points, or two groups consisting of points on either side of the statistical
median itself plus the statistical median if there is an odd number of data points
§ The correct measure of variation when the data is Continuous/Nominal & Non-Normal, best used as
a measure of variation when the measure of central tendency being used is Median
§ percentile(Range,.75)-percentile(Range,.25)
STATISTICAL PROCESS CONTROL
PROCESS STABILITY & CAUSES OF VARIATION
Example:
Generally
Looking at the past values, it is possible to give some range around
9:30 am (e.g.: 9:30 ± 5 Minutes) to reach office
Normally it is possible to reach office within this range
Suppose
A particular day , there is vehicle break down
that day it may not be possible to reach office at 9:30 ± 5 Minutes
Say, you reach office at 9:50 am
In other words
If you reach office too late (beyond normal range of 9:30 ± 5 Minutes),
there will be some special reason for that or
it is easy to find out the reason for such variation
CONTROL CHARTS
• A statistical tool to ensure that process is stable or in control
• A statistical tool to detect the presence of Assignable Causes in the process.
1. Stable Process
Stable Process
Mean = 5.01
SD = 0.351
Mean + 3 x SD = 6.063
Mean – 3 x SD = 3.956
CONTROL CHARTS
UCL =Mean + 3 x SD
CL = Mean
LCL = Mean – 3 x SD
Control Chart
UCL
CL
LCL
Control Charts: Working
Control Chart
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
Types of Control Charts
Continuous Data
• Xbar & R Chart
• Individual X & Moving range Chart
Discrete Data
Control Chart for Defectives
• p chart
• np chart
Control Chart for Defects
• c chart
• u chart
Steps for monitoring Handling Time using this Xbar & R Chart
CL=4.997
LCL=4.98
Steps for monitoring Handling Time using this Xbar & R Chart
Range chart
UCL = 0.053
CL=0.0233
LCL=0.00
Xbar – R Chart: Example
Process: Characteristic: Handling Time
Sample Size N: 9 Sub Group Size n: 4
Frequency of Sampling: Once in a Hour
Step 1: Collect Data
Center Line
CL = Mean = Rbar = Sum of all Range Values / Total Number
of Values
= 0.21 / 9 = 0.0233
R Chart
0.06
0.05
0.04
0.03
0.02
0.01
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Homogenization:
Remove the out of control value
Recalculate the limits
Xbar – R Chart: Example
Step 6: Calculate Control Limits for Xbar Chart
Center Line
CL = Mean = Xdoublebar = Sum of all Means / Total Number
of Values
= 44.975 / 9 = 4.997
xbar Chart
5.02
5.01
5
4.99
4.98
4.97
4.96
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
A BPO company wants to ensure that the transaction processing process is free from
assignable causes. The following data on processing times was collected, How would
you establish a control mechanism so that the process is free from assignable cause?
Sample x1 x2 x3 Sample x1 x2 x3
Number Number
1 6.0 5.8 6.1 11 6.2 6.9 5.0
2 5.2 6.4 6.9 12 6.7 7.1 6.2
3 5.5 5.8 5.2 13 6.1 6.9 7.4
4 5.0 5.7 6.5 14 6.2 5.2 6.8
5 6.7 6.5 5.5 15 4.9 6.6 6.6
6 5.8 5.2 5.0 16 7.0 6.4 6.1
7 5.6 5.1 5.2 17 5.4 6.5 6.7
8 6.0 5.8 6.0 18 6.6 7.0 6.8
9 5.5 4.9 5.7 19 4.7 6.2 7.1
10 4.3 6.4 6.3 20 6.7 5.4 6.7
Individual X & Moving Range Chart: Example
MR Chart
250000
200000
150000
100000
50000
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Center Line
CL = Mean = Xbar = Sum of all Data / Total Number
of Values
= 1968162 / 16 = 123010.1
Individual X Chart
350000
300000
250000
200000
150000
100000
50000
0
-50000 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
-100000
CL=123010.1
LCL= -55539.9
Steps for monitoring Customer Rating using this Xbar & R Chart
CL=67124.07
LCL=0.00
Individual X & Moving Range Chart: Exercise
The weekly debit outstanding (in K) is given in t he table below. Kindly device a
mechanism to ensure that the assignable causes are not acting on the process
Day Data Day Data
1 8.1 11 8.1
2 9.5 12 8.2
3 7.2 13 8.3
4 6.0 14 9.1
5 9.1 15 8.0
6 5.8 16 7.3
7 8.1 17 8.4
8 7.2 18 4.5
9 5.1 19 7.1
10 8.0 20 5.1
Control Charts for Defectives: np Chart
1 47
2 42
3 48
4 58
5 32
6 38
7 53
8 68
9 45
10 37
np Chart : Calculation of Control Limits
CL = Mean
UCL = Mean + 3 SD
LCL = Mean – 3 SD
pbar = Sum of Defectives / total Number Inspected
= 468 /(1000*10) = 0.0468
np Chart
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
np chart
UCL = 66.84
CL=46.8
LCL=26.76
np Chart: Exercise
The following are the data on defectives in payment of dental insurance claims.
Device a mechanism to ensure the defectives is under control. Sample Size is 300
1 3 11 6
2 6 12 9
3 4 13 5
4 6 14 6
5 20 15 7
6 2 16 4
7 6 17 5
8 7 18 7
9 3 19 5
10 0 20 0
Control Charts for Defectives: p Chart
Example: The daily report on Escalations are given below. Device a control
mechanism to ensure that the Escalations are kept under control
day by day ?
Day Number of Calls Number of Calls
Attended Escalated
1 500 5
2 550 6
3 700 8
4 625 9
5 700 7
6 550 8
7 450 10
8 600 6
9 475 9
10 650 6
p Chart : Calculation of Control Limits
CL = Mean
UCL = Mean + 3 SD
LCL = Mean – 3 SD
pbar = Sum of Defectives / Total Number Inspected
= 74 / 5800 = 0.0128
p Chart
0.035
0.03
0.025
0.02
0.015
0.01
0.005
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1. Collect the data on number of calls attended and number of calls escalated
everyday
2. Calculate the proportion p of escalated calls
3. Plot this p value in the p chart constructed using the pbar =0.0128
4. If p chart is showing out of control, the process is not stable, search for
assignable causes and correct the process. Otherwise continue
p Chart
0.035
0.03
0.025
0.02
0.015
0.01
0.005
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
p Chart: Exercise
Daily inspection results for the purchase order processing are given in the table.
Construct a control chart to ensure that the defectives are kept under control day
by day?
1 171 31 11 181 38
2 167 6 12 115 33
3 170 8 13 165 26
4 135 13 14 189 15
5 137 26 15 165 16
6 170 30 16 170 35
7 45 3 17 175 12
8 155 11 18 167 6
9 195 30 19 141 50
10 180 36 20 159 26
Control Charts for Defects: c Chart
1 8
2 19
3 14
4 18
5 11
6 16
7 8
8 15
9 21
10 8
c Chart : Calculation of Control Limits
CL = Mean
UCL = Mean + 3 SD
LCL = Mean – 3 SD
cbar = Average number of defects per 1000 transactions
= 13.8
CL = cbar = 13.8
UCL = Mean + 3 SD = 13.8 + 3 x 3.71 = 24.93
LCL = Mean - 3 SD = 13.8 - 3 x 3.71 = 2.67
c chart: Example
c Chart
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
c chart
UCL = 24.93
CL=13.8
LCL=2.67
c Chart: Exercise
100 transactions are inspected every day for fatal errors. The data for the past 20
days is given below. Construct a suitable control chart to ensure that the fatal errors
are under control?
Day Number of Fatal Day Number of Fatal
Errors Errors
1 22 11 15
2 29 12 10
3 25 13 33
4 17 14 23
5 20 15 27
6 16 16 15
7 34 17 17
8 11 18 17
9 31 19 19
10 29 20 22
Control Charts for Defects: u Chart
1 10 45
2 10 51
3 10 36
4 9 48
5 10 42
6 10 5
7 10 33
8 8 27
9 8 31
10 8 22
u Chart : Calculation of Control Limits
CL = Mean
UCL = Mean + 3 SD
LCL = Mean – 3 SD
ubar = Sum of Defects / Total Number Inspected
= 340 / 93 = 3.66
u Chart
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
u Chart
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
u Chart: Exercise
Construct a suitable control mechanism to ensure that the errors in payoff process
is under control?
1 40 45 11 52 55
2 40 40 12 52 74
3 40 33 13 52 43
4 40 43 14 52 61
5 40 62 15 40 43
6 52 79 16 40 32
7 52 60 17 40 45
8 52 50 18 40 33
9 52 73 19 40 50
10 52 54 20 52 28
Failure Mode & Effect Analysis
(FMEA)
What is FMEA ?
• Analytical technique and systemised group of activities.
• Used to identify the potential failure modes, the effect of failures and their
associated cause and mechanism,
• A tool for design and process engineers / managers.
• An interactive and never ending process.
• Technique of reducing risk or of avoiding risk.
• A living document.
• “Before-the-event” action; and NOT an “After-the-fact”
exercise.
Cases
Case 1 : To design or setting up of new process. This will make the
process from beginning itself defect free (Design FMEA)
Case 2 : To modify existing processes to make it defect free (Process
FMEA)
Benefits
- Engagement level
- Process level
- Sub Process level
Application
• Increasing creativity.
• Increasing acceptance.
• An analytical technique.
• Identifies potential process failure modes.
• Customer normally is end user but can be next process too.
• Assesses the potential effects of the failures on the
customer.
• Identifies the causes and process variables
to focus on.
• Prioritize corrective actions
Potential Failure Mode & Effects Analysis (Process FMEA)
Examples: Penalty, Client loss, Monitory loss, problems with next operation
etc.
Severity
• Probability that the proposed process control will detect the presence
of potential cause / mechanism
None No effect 1
Process FMEA
Guideline for estimating detection (D)