You are on page 1of 22

CLINICAL RESEARCH STUDY

Serum Albumin and Prealbumin in Calorically


Restricted, Nondiseased Individuals:
A Systematic Review
Jessica L. Lee, MD, MS, Esther S. Oh, MD, Rebecca W. Lee, MD, Thomas E. Finucane, MD
Division of Geriatric Medicine and Gerontology, The Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, Md.

ABSTRACT

PURPOSE: Undernutrition is often suspected in patients when serum albumin or prealbumin levels are low.
We asked whether these measures are indeed low in undernourished people if no inflammatory illness is
present.
METHODS: We did a systematic review to identify otherwise healthy subjects who were severely nutrient-
deprived due to poor access to food or unwillingness to eat. We excluded children and pregnant women.
We tabulated available measures of nutrient intake, anthropometry, serum albumin and prealbumin, and,
when available, changes in these measures during nutritional intervention.
RESULTS: In otherwise healthy subjects, serum albumin and prealbumin levels remained normal despite
marked nutrient deprivation until the extremes of starvation, that is, body mass index <12 or more than 6
weeks of starvation.
CONCLUSIONS: In these otherwise healthy subjects, serum albumin and prealbumin levels are not “markers
of nutritional status.” The “markers” failed to identify subjects with severe protein-calorie malnutrition until
extreme starvation. That is, they failed to identify healthy individuals who would benefit from nutrition
support, becoming abnormal only when starvation was already obvious. In contrast, serum albumin and
prealbumin levels are known to fall promptly with injury or illness regardless of nutrient intake. They are
negative acute-phase reactants. When these measures are low in sick patients, this cannot be assumed to
reflect nutritional deprivation. Decisions about nutrition support should be based on evidence of meaningful
benefit from this treatment rather than on assessment of “nutritional markers.”
Ó 2015 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.  The American Journal of Medicine (2015) 128, 1023.e1-1023.e22

KEYWORDS: Albumin; Malnutrition; Nutrition; Nutrition screening; Prealbumin

Malnutrition is considered a common, serious problem must ensure that a resident: 1) maintains acceptable pa-
among ill patients. Serum albumin and prealbumin often rameters of nutritional status, such as body weight and
are used to identify malnutrition and evaluate the success protein levels, unless the resident’s clinical condition
of nutrition support. For example, federal regulations for demonstrates that this is not possible; and 2) receives a
care in nursing homes explicitly require that “The facility therapeutic diet when there is a nutritional problem.”1 The
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services also put forth
a guide for long-term care surveyors evaluating nutrition
Funding: JLL received funding support from a T32AG000120-25 and sanitary conditions, which states that “albumin and
fellowship training grant (National Institutes of Health/National Institute
on Aging).
pre-albumin may help in some cases in deciding to initiate
Conflict of Interest: None. nutritional interventions .”2 These regulations and this
Authorship: All authors had access to the data and a role in writing this guide are very influential during nursing home surveys,
manuscript. and as a result they are influential in the nutritional
Requests for reprints should be addressed to Thomas E. Finucane, MD, treatments provided by nursing homes. A 2014 article
Department of Medicine, Division of Geriatric Medicine and Gerontology,
Mason F. Lord Building, Center Tower, 5200 Eastern Avenue, Suite 2200,
recommends use of albumin and prealbumin levels to
Baltimore, MD 21224. identify malnutrition before orthopedic surgery and to
E-mail address: tfinucan@jhmi.edu guide preoperative nutritional management, noting that

0002-9343/$ -see front matter Ó 2015 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.amjmed.2015.03.032
1023.e2 The American Journal of Medicine, Vol 128, No 9, September 2015

normalization of levels should reduce perioperative com- complete list of the search strategy for each database can
plications.3 Another finds serum albumin level to be the be found in Appendix 1, available online. The results of
optimal guide for predicting malnutrition in heart trans- the searches were then transferred into the RefWorks
plant patients.4 A third notes that “Amongst the nutritional (2013; ProQuest LLC, Ann Arbor, MI) online database.
biomarkers used, serum albumin has been, by far, the most Duplicates were removed using the RefWorks exact du-
extensively studied serum protein in patients on mainte- plicates and close duplicates function. Two authors (JLL
nance dialysis.”5 and RWL) then independently
Serum albumin and pre- reviewed the remaining studies
albumin also are affected by in- CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE for exclusion/inclusion criteria.
flammatory illness, however, and  Serum levels of albumin and prealbumin
their value in diagnosing malnu- continue to be used as “markers of
trition in sick patients has long
Study Selection
nutritional status.” Studies were considered, regard-
been questioned; “When there is
evidence of an acute-phase  They remain normal during starvation, less of study design, if they
response (eg, increased CRP [C- however, and are low in inflammatory included human subjects aged 13
years and older. We tabulated and
reactive protein]), decreased illness.
concentrations of plasma proteins graphed the results of studies of
 Initiating nutrition support because participants who had both 1) evi-
such as albumin, transferrin,
retinol-binding protein and pre- these measures are low has no evidence dence of undernutrition, based on
albumin cannot be assumed to base and leads to significant waste. anthropometric measures, history
6
reflect malnutrition.” Low albu- of marked caloric restriction, or
min and prealbumin levels are both; and 2) measurements of
recognized particularly as “reverse acute phase reactants,” serum albumin, prealbumin, or both. We excluded studies
lowered during many inflammatory illnesses regardless of that involved children, pregnant women, hospitalized pa-
nutrient intake. 6-8 tients, or patients with known injury or acute or chronic
We asked whether starvation affects albumin and pre- inflammatory disease, such as malignancy, acute infection,
albumin levels in the absence of inflammatory illness. We specific organ failure, and surgery.
reviewed studies of healthy subjects with markedly
restricted caloric intake, usually due to poor access to food Data Abstraction
or because of unwillingness to eat for psychiatric, political, Detailed reasons for exclusion are documented in the flow
research, or other reasons. diagram (Figure 1). Articles that were categorized
We use “malnourished” to mean “undernourished” as is discordantly between the 2 reviewers or designated
common. We do not discuss albumin or prealbumin ki- “uncertain” had their full text reviewed and discussed. If
netics, acknowledging that serum levels are affected by disagreement remained, then a third reviewer (TEF) cast
synthesis, degradation, loss, and volume of distribution; the tie-breaking vote.
we simply present the measures used in clinical practice. All articles included in the final analysis underwent a
Children, pregnant women, and patients with known in- double data extraction process by the reviewers. We
flammatory illness are not considered here. extracted demographic information, anthropometric mea-
surements, information about caloric intake, and measures
of serum albumin/prealbumin. If multiple albumin mea-
METHODS surements were reported, we used the mean values
measured during caloric restriction. We also recorded the
Search Strategy change in albumin and prealbumin levels after any
We developed a written protocol before our review nutritional interventions. As is common in clinical prac-
following the standards listed in the Preferred Reporting tice, we used serum albumin levels <3.5 g/dL and pre-
Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses albumin levels <20 mg/dL as the lower limits of
(PRISMA).9 normal.2,10-12
We searched PubMed, Embase, CINAHL, and Cochrane
Library databases for published studies from inception up to
the last search date of August 28, 2013. We did not use any RESULTS
restrictions on language, study type, or publication year. We A total of 63 articles were included in the final data
hand-searched the reference lists of included studies for extraction process, with the complete details listed in
other articles possibly relevant to our topic. We did not Appendix 2, available online.13-75 The studies were a mix
incorporate data from unpublished studies, conferences, of case reports, case control, cross-sectional, observational,
dissertations, or other grey literature. and cohort studies, and clinical trials, with dates ranging
We used a combination of keywords and headings from 1944 to 2012. A total of 2125 mostly female patients
related to albumin, prealbumin, and caloric restriction. A between the ages of 13 and 50 years were studied. Most of
Lee et al Serum Albumin and Prealbumin During Starvation 1023.e3

Figure 1 Albumin and prealbumin flow diagram.9

the reasons for nutrition restriction involved anorexia 3.4 g/dL in a group of prisoners on hunger strike for an
nervosa, bulimia nervosa, or both. Other reasons for nutri- average 43 days with a mean BMI of 21.5 kg/m2.39 All other
tion restriction included dieting, lack of access to food, mean albumin values were above 3.5 g/dL, in groups with
prisoners, hunger strikers, and involvement in research mean BMI as low as 11.3 kg/m2.
studies. The average duration of nutrition restriction ranged Table 2 and Figure 3 show the relationship between
from 4 days to 20 years. BMI and mean serum prealbumin values in 20 studies with
The relationship between body mass index (BMI) and a total of 1052 patients.13,14,17,21,23,25-29,33,35,38,39,42,43,46-49
mean serum albumin values is shown in Table 1 and Two mean prealbumin values were below 20 mg/dL
Figure 2. Of 33 studies with a total of 1695 patients,13-46 (13, 14.4 mg/dL), both among groups of patients with
4 mean albumin values below 3.5 g/dL were recorded. anorexia nervosa and corresponding mean BMI of 9.8 and
Three (3.35, 3.24, 2.95 g/dL) were recorded in groups of 11.1 kg/m2, respectively.14,35 All other mean prealbumin
patients with anorexia nervosa and average BMI values of values were above 20 mg/dL in groups with mean BMI
9.8, 11.1, and 10.5 kg/m2 respectively.14,24,35 The fourth was as low as 12.9 kg/m2.
1023.e4
Table 1 Albumin and Body Mass Index (BMI)
# of Reason for Nutrition Duration of Nutrition
Study (First Author) Year Subjects Age (years) Sex Restriction Restriction BMI (kg/m2)  SD Albumin (g/dL)  SD
Nishida 13
2010 210 29.9  5.31 F BMI <18.5 but no 17.5  0.78 4.49  0.2
anorexia nervosa
118 32.9  4.29 F Self-reported wt loss >1 kg 20.7  3.33 4.45  0.21
Rigaud14 2000 5 29.8  9.3 F Near-death anorexia nervosa 9.77  0.1 3.35  0.28
16 25.2  3.9 Anorexia nervosa 13.6  1.1 4.05  0.58
Chui15 2008 63 21.3  2.3 F Anorexia nervosa 6.5  1.7 years 21.8  3.4 4.13  0.28
Dostalova16 2010 16 24.9  1.34 F Anorexia nervosa 15.7  0.3 4.38  0.112
Gendall17 1999 152 25.9  6.0 F Bulimia nervosa 71.1  65.6 months 23  2.7 4.87  0.34
Gentile18 2011 298 19.8  6.1 278 F, 20 M Anorexia nervosa, eating 14.6  2.1 4.8  0.5
disorder not otherwise
specified
Hildebrandt19 2001 28 Anorexia nervosa 5.0  4.2 years 13.7  2.3 4.86  0.73
24 bulimia nervosa 6.7  5.5 years 19.1  3.7 4.75  0.62
Mukamel20 2001 1 13.5 F Anorexia nervosa 10 months 11.25 4.7
Murciano21 1994 15 24.9  8.7 F Anorexia nervosa 12 months 13.5  1.1 3.99  0.21
Rodrigues Pereira22 2010 11 15.0  0.5 F Anorexia nervosa 15.1  0.6 4.7  0.1
Varela23 1991 17 15.68  0.95 F Anorexia nervosa 1.54  0.21 years 14.67  0.27 4.41  0.06

The American Journal of Medicine, Vol 128, No 9, September 2015


19 18.47  0.75 F Anorexia nervosa 3.80  0.54 years 17.93  0.25 4.2  0.08
Zastrow24 2011 1 26 F Anorexia nervosa 14 years 10.5 2.95
Agnello25 2012 39 26  9 F Anorexia nervosa 60 months 13.9  2 4.6  0.6
Caregaro26 2001 59 22.6  7.1 F Anorexia nervosa 14.87  1.89 4.582  0.578
23 27  7.2 F Bulimia nervosa 20.02  1.64 4.433  0.511
Chu27 2012 62 27 56 F, 6 M Anorexia nervosa 12.9  2 3.7  0.7
Haluzik28 1999 17 24.1  3.82 F Anorexia nervosa 15.22  3.06 4.903  0.602
Haluzik29 1999 11 23.7  3.1 F Anorexia nervosa 15.4  3.2 4.93  0.28
Herzog30 1997 66 20.8 F Anorexia nervosa 13.7 4.171  0.552
Krantz31 2005 1 52 F Anorexia nervosa 20 years 17 4
Lawson32 2009 10 27.5  2.4 F Anorexia nervosa 18.3  0.3 4.7  0.1
10 25.8  1.1 F Anorexia nervosa 18  0.4 4.4  0.1
Nova33 2004 14 15.1  2.56 F Anorexia nervosa 9.4  6.3 months 15.24  1.71 4.51  0.69
Olubodun34 1996 81 27.7  5.9 M Prisoners 229.1  210.1 days 20  2.7 3.66  0.63
Rigaud35 2009 16 26  9 (all) 115 F, 5 M (all) Anorexia nervosa 11.1  0.65 3.24  0.51
35 Anorexia nervosa 13.1  0.5 4.02  0.69
35 Anorexia nervosa 15  0.49 4.18  0.63
21 Anorexia nervosa 16.8  0.51 4.34  0.64
13 Anorexia nervosa 19.5  2.4 4.11  0.72
Rock36 1995 13 26  8 12 F, 1 M Anorexia nervosa, 6.4  3.3 years 17.4  2.9 4.1  0.5
Bulimia nervosa
Smith37 1996 6 27.2  2.36 F Anorexia nervosa 15.35  0.694 3.7  0.193
Van Binsbergen38 1988 20 24.7 F Anorexia nervosa 4.9 years 14.4 4.07
Lee et al Serum Albumin and Prealbumin During Starvation 1023.e5

0.000000402 g/dL)
Four studies of changes in mean serum albumin and
Albumin (g/dL)  SD

0.67  0.06 nmol/L


BMI before and after nutritional supplementation are re-

(0.00000489 
ported in Appendices 3 and 4, available online.16,29,33,39
4.863  0.264
3.4  0.3
In each, the BMI increased by about 2 kg/m2 during the

4.24
4.6

3.9
4.6
4.58079 nutritional supplementation. In 2, the mean albumin values
increased,16,33 while in the other 2 studies they
decreased.29,39 One mean albumin value began below
3.5 g/dL (3.4 g/dL) and decreased to 3.2 g/dL after sup-
BMI (kg/m2)  SD

plementation.39 Four studies measured the changes in


prealbumin and BMI before and after nutritional supple-
21.5  2.6
15.5  2.9

mentation and are reported in Appendices 5 and 6,


14.6  2
14.7
16.5
24.5

14.2

available online.29,33,46,48 All 4 showed an increase in


21

BMI after supplementation. Three studies showed an in-


crease29,46,48 and one study showed a decrease in mean
prealbumin values.33 There were no mean prealbumin
values <20 mg/dL, before or after nutritional
Duration of Nutrition

supplementation.
43 days

57 days

Four studies reported changes in mean albumin values


Restriction

and weight in 9 groups before and after nutrition restric-


tion (Appendices 7 and 8, available online).50-54 All
studies demonstrated weight loss. Six groups50,51
comprising 2 long-term (24 weeks and 46 days, respec-
tively) studies50 showed a decrease in mean albumin
values, while 3 short-term (less than a week) studies52-54
showed an increase. None of the mean albumin values
Reason for Nutrition

fell below 3.5 g/dL.


Anorexia nervosa
Anorexia nervosa
Anorexia nervosa

Anorexia nervosa
Anorexia nervosa
Bulimia nervosa
Hunger strikers

Hunger strikers

DISCUSSION
Restriction

In otherwise healthy patients who are chronically or acutely


undernourished, serum albumin and prealbumin levels have
no value as “markers of nutritional status” that can identify
undernutrition and the need for feeding. These serum mea-
sures remain normal until starvation is obvious by history
17 F, 3 M
1 F, 7 M

1 F, 7 M

(eg, prolonged fasting), physical examination (eg, BMI


Sex

F
F

F
F

below 12), or both.


The study has limitations. First, we have no data on
micronutrient deficiencies, a clear risk during long starva-
tion. These were rarely reported, and many of the included
subjects received vitamin supplementation. Second, in the
43.3  6.2

15.6  2.3
Age (years)

study by Keys et al,50 prolonged undernutrition led to falls


13.3

32.6
20
26

15

in albumin of up to 0.6 g/dL in a group of patients who lost


*Conversion to g/dL gave a nonphysiologic number.

an average of 18 kg (25% of initial body weight). Average


serum albumin levels remained above 3.5 g/dL. Changes
like this may be important but they do not now add to the
Subjects

clinician’s ability to identify patients in need of nutrition


# of

8
14
20
33
18
8
23
25

support.
In 1979, Seltzer et al76 declared that 2 readily available
“parameters, albumin (a measure of visceral protein) and
2001
1998
1991
2005
2004
2011
1993
2002
Year

total lymphocyte count (a poor man’s assessment of


Continued

immunocompetency) will form the basis of instant nutri-


Study (First Author)

tional assessment.” Low values were strongly associated


with mortality among hospitalized patients, and the au-
thors recommended that their assessment “be performed
39

*Pascal46
Haluzik40
Table 1

Dubois44
Faintuch

on all hospitalized patients with appropriate alterations


Roijen41
Cortes42

Okabe45
Orgaz43

and therapy being made to allow for nutritional repletion.”


This has been cited as the first description of nutritional
1023.e6 The American Journal of Medicine, Vol 128, No 9, September 2015

Figure 2 Albumin and body mass index.

assessment,77 and some clinicians and researchers creating the appearance that better nutrient intake caused
continue to use serum albumin (and prealbumin) in this the overall clinical improvement.
way. Acknowledging the effects of inflammatory illness As conventionally used, then, the term “malnourished”
on these measures, however, the 2012 “Consensus State- has 2 distinct meanings. First, the term can mean that a
ment from the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics and the patient’s “markers of nutritional status” are abnormal. The
American Society for Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition: term can also mean that there is evidence to suggest the
Characteristics Recommended for the Identification and patient will benefit from nutrition support. The distinction
Documentation of Adult Malnutrition (Undernutrition)” is critical. A patient with advanced cancer, for example,
no longer include these measures or any other biomarkers, will likely have very poor intake, weight loss, low serum
focusing instead on “insufficient energy intake,” and albumin, and moreeand be clearly malnourished in the
anthropometric and functional measures.78 former sense. Yet “[i]n general, the data failed to
Recommended methods of nutritional assessment, such demonstrate the clinical efficacy of providing nutrition
as these, generally share 2 common characteristics. First, the support to most patients with cancer.”80 The patient is not
proposed assessments neither provide nor require any evi- malnourished in the latter sense. We believe the term
dence that nutrition support will benefit patients who are should be used only in the latter sense, because a diag-
identified as malnourished. Second, severe illness and injury nosis of “malnutrition” will generally lead to treatment
can independently affect every element of both proposals with nutrition support.
regardless of nutrient intake (except “insufficient energy Whether nutrition support will benefit patients with in-
intake”). There is no effort to account for the effects of flammatory illness remains a research question. Simply
inflammation, which can closely mimic undernutrition. adding energy, protein, and micronutrients to a patient with
Both serious illness and injury can cause reduced an inflammatory, cachectic illness may not be beneficial.
appetite and nutrient intake (as part of “sickness Several reviews demonstrate little or no benefit in conditions
behavior”79), weight loss, sarcopenia, and weakness, as where malnutrition is classically considered to play a central
well as prompt falls in serum albumin and prealbumin.6 roleefor example, advanced dementia, wasting illness,
Thus, sick or injured patients can be “malnourished,” pressure ulcers, and cancer.80-84 Randomized controlled
both by the Consensus Statement and the Seltzer assess- trials are necessary to define the clinical situations where
ment, regardless of nutrient intake. Worsening the confu- supplements and enteral or parenteral feeding provide net
sion, if illness or injury improves and the inflammatory benefit to sick patients. These trials could generate mean-
state abates, appetite improves, nutrient intake increases, ingful biomarkers that help find patients who will benefit
and weight, strength, and blood biochemistry improve, from nutrition support.
Lee et al
Serum Albumin and Prealbumin During Starvation
Table 2 Prealbumin and Body Mass Index (BMI)
Study Reason for Nutrition Duration of Nutrition
(First Author) Year # of Subjects Age (years) Sex Restriction Restriction BMI (kg/m2)  SD Prealbumin (mg/dL)  SD
Nishida 13
2010 210 29.9  5.31 F Underweight 17.5  0.78 23.3  3.56
118 32.9  4.29 F Self-reported wt loss >1 kg 20.7  3.33 23.1  3.84
Rigaud14 2000 5 29.8  9.3 F Near-death anorexia nervosa 9.77  0.1 13  6
16 25.2  3.9 F Anorexia nervosa 13.6  1.1 31  6
Gendall17 1999 152 25.9  6.0 F Bulimia nervosa 71.1  65.6 months 23  2.7 27  5
Murciano21 1994 15 24.9  8.7 F Anorexia nervosa 12 months 13.5  1.1 24  4
Varela23 1991 17 15.68  0.95 F Anorexia nervosa 1.54  0.21 years 14.67  0.27 40  10
19 18.47  0.75 F Anorexia nervosa 3.80  0.54 years 17.93  0.25 50  10
Vogele47 2009 8 23.2  3.1 F Fasting bulimia nervosa 5.5  4.1 years (all) 22  3.1 24  5.1
9 24.5  8.5 F Nonfasting bulimia nervosa 23.3  3.3 30.1  6.3
Agnello25 2012 39 26  9 F Anorexia nervosa 60 months 13.9  2 26.3  7.4
Barbe48 1993 12 16-31 F Anorexia nervosa 6 months-4 years 13.8  0.5 25  2
Caregaro26 2001 59 22.6  7.1 F Anorexia nervosa 14.87  1.89 27.924  6.718
23 27  7.2 F Bulimia nervosa 20.02  1.64 27.742  7.489
Chu27 2012 62 27 56 F, 6 M Anorexia nervosa 12.9  2 21  7
Haluzik28 1999 17 24.1  3.82 F Anorexia nervosa 15.22  3.06 27  7
Haluzik29 1999 11 23.7  3.1 F Anorexia nervosa 15.4  3.2 28  7
Nova33 2004 14 15.1  2.56 F Anorexia nervosa 9.4  6.3 months 15.24  1.71 26.3  5.6
Pascal46 2002 25 15.6  2.3 F Anorexia nervosa 14.6  2 29.975  5.995
Rigaud35 2009 16 26  9 (all) 115 F, 5 M (all) Anorexia nervosa 11.1  0.65 14  4
35 Anorexia nervosa 13.1  0.5 23  3
35 Anorexia nervosa 15  0.49 27  2
21 Anorexia nervosa 16.8  0.51 31  5
13 Anorexia nervosa 19.5  2.4 28  6
Van Binsbergen38 1988 20 24.7 F Anorexia nervosa 4.9 years 14.4 30.1
Haluzik39 1998 14 F Anorexia nervosa 15.5  2.9 27 7
Cortes42 2005 33 20 F Anorexia nervosa 16.5 20.9
Orgaz43 2004 18 26 F Bulimia nervosa 24.5 22.3
Coles49 2005 8 23 F Fasting bulimia nervosa 22 24
8 23 F Bulimia nervosa 23.3 30

1023.e7
1023.e8 The American Journal of Medicine, Vol 128, No 9, September 2015

Figure 3 Prealbumin and body mass index.

We do not advocate withholding food from people. As in gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/CFR-2011-title42-vol5/pdf/CFR-2011-title42-vol5-


clinical care, comparator patients in clinical trials of sup- sec483-25.pdf. Accessed May 14, 2015.
2. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. Revisions to Appendix PP:
plemental nutrition should receive attentive efforts to pro- “Interpretive guidelines for long-term care facilities”. U.S. Department
vide food by mouth ad lib where possible. We suspect that of Health and Human Services; 2008. Available at: https://www.cms.
the presence of hunger will be a very important indicator of gov/Medicare/Provider-Enrollment-and-Certification/SurveyCertification
a patient’s ability to benefit from food. We hypothesize that GenInfo/downloads/SCLetter08-28.pdf. Accessed May 14, 2015.
low serum albumin and prealbumin levels, in contrast, 3. Cross MB, Yi PH, Thomas CF, Garcia J, Della Valle CJ. Evaluation of
malnutrition in orthopaedic surgery. J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2014;22:
identify a group of patients who will be unable to benefit 193-199.
from nutrition support. 4. Prenner G, Wasler A, Fahrleinter-Pammer A, et al. The role of serum
In summary, in healthy patients, serum albumin and albumin in the prediction of malnutrition in patients at least five yr after
prealbumin levels are useless as markers of nutritional sta- heart transplantation. Clin Transplant. 2014;28(6):737-742.
tus: they fail to identify those who are starving. In patients 5. Ikizler TA. Using and interpreting serum albumin and prealbumin as
nutritional markers in patients on chronic dialysis. Semin Dial.
with significant injury or illness, nutritional assessment is 2014;27:590-592.
complex because of the similarities between inflammatory 6. Fleck A. Clinical and nutritional aspects of changes in acute-phase
illness and undernutrition; there is no reason to believe that proteins during inflammation. Proc Nutr Soc. 1989;48:347-354.
these measures identify patients who could benefit from 7. Kelley KW, Bluthe R, Dantzer R, et al. Cytokine-induced sickness
nutrition support. Meaningful nutrition assessment of pa- behavior. Brain Behav Immun. 2003;17:S112-S118.
8. Delano MJ, Moldawer LL. The origins of cachexia in acute and chronic
tients who are sick can be developed only when clinical inflammatory diseases. Nutr Clin Pract. 2006;21:68-81.
trials of nutrition support show benefit for particular groups 9. Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG, Group P. Preferred
of patients. reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA
statement. Ann Intern Med. 2009;151:264-269.
10. Thomas DR, Ashmen W, Morley JE, Evans WH. Council for Nutritional
ACKNOWLEDGMENT Strategies in Long-Term Care. Nutritional management in long-term care:
The authors thank the Johns Hopkins Bayview medical development of a clinical guideline. J Gerontol. 2000;55A:M725-M734.
librarian, Christine Caulfield-Noll, for her assistance with 11. Azad N, Murphy J, Amos SS, Toppan J. Nutrition survey in an elderly
population following admission to a tertiary care hospital. CMAJ.
conducting the database searches. We also thank the in- 1999;161:511-515.
terpreters who helped us translate several of the foreign 12. Yu P-J, Cassiere HA, Dellis SL, Manetta F, Kohn N, Hartman AR.
language articles. Impact of preoperative prealbumin on outcomes after cardiac surgery.
JPEN J Parenter Enteral Nutr. 2014 June 4. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/
0148607114536735. [Epub ahead of print].
References 13. Nishida T, Sakakibara H. Association between underweight and low
1. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. §483.25. U.S. Depart- lymphocyte count as an indicator of malnutrition in Japanese women.
ment of Health and Human Services; 2012. Available at: http://www. J Womens Health. 2010;19:1377-1383.
Lee et al Serum Albumin and Prealbumin During Starvation 1023.e9

14. Rigaud D, Hassid J, Meulemans A, Poupard AT, Boulier A. 35. Rigaud D, Tallonneau I, Verges B. Hypercholesterolaemia in anorexia
A paradoxical increase in resting energy expenditure in malnourished nervosa: frequency and changes during refeeding. Diabetes Metab.
patients near death: the king penguin syndrome. Am J Clin Nutr. 2009;35:57-63.
2000;72:355-360. 36. Rock CL, Vasantharajan S. Vitamin status of eating disorder patients:
15. Chui HT, Christensen BK, Zipursky RB, et al. Cognitive function and relationship to clinical indices and effect of treatment. Int J Eat Disord.
brain structure in females with a history of adolescent-onset anorexia 1995;18:257-262.
nervosa. Pediatrics. 2008;122:e426-e437. 37. Smith G, Robinson PH, Fleck A. Serum albumin distribution in early
16. Dostalova I, Kavalkova P, Papeova H, Domluvilova D, Zikan V, treated anorexia nervosa. Nutrition. 1996;12:677-684.
Haluzik M. Association of macrophage inhibitory cytokine-1 with 38. Van Binsbergen CJ, Odink J, Van den Berg H, Koppeschaar H,
nutritional status, body composition and bone mineral density in pa- Coelingh Bennink HJ. Nutritional status in anorexia nervosa: clinical
tients with anorexia nervosa: the influence of partial realimentation. chemistry, vitamins, iron and zinc. Eur J Clin Nutr. 1988;42:
Nutr Metab. 2010;7:34-42. 929-937.
17. Gendall KA, Bulik CM, Joyce PR. Visceral protein and hematological 39. Faintuch J, Soriano FG, Ladeira JP, Janiszewski M, Velasco IT,
status of women with bulimia nervosa and depressed controls. Physiol Gama-Rodrigues JJ. Refeeding procedures after 43 days of total
Behav. 1999;66:159-163. fasting. Nutrition. 2001;17:100-104.
18. Gentile MG, Manna GM, Pastorelli P, Oltolini A. Laboratory evalua- 40. Haluzik M, Papezova H, Nedvidkova J, Kabrt J. Serum concentrations
tion in patients with anorexia nervosa: usefulness and limits. Clin Ter. of leptin and nutritional parameters in female patients with anorexia
2011;162:401-407. nervosa and bulimia. Ceska Slov Psychiatr. 1998;94:464-469.
19. Hildebrandt M, Rose M, Monnikes H, Reutter W, Keller W, Klapp BF. 41. Roijen SB, Worsaae U, Zlotnik G. Zinc in patients with anorexia
Eating disorders: a role for dipeptidyl peptidase IV in nutritional nervosa. Ugeskr Laeger. 1991;153:721-723.
control. Nutrition. 2001;17:451-454. 42. Cortes J, Escalada J, Alonso JI, et al. Predictive factors for osteopenia
20. Mukamel M. Synovial effusion in a patient with anorexia nervosa. Clin in women with anorexia nervosa: importance of total body fat. Endo-
Pediatr. 2001;40:242. crinol Nutr. 2005;52:344-349.
21. Murciano D, Rigaud D, Pingleton S, Armengaud MH, Melchior JC, 43. Orgaz MT, Rodriguez L, Melero MJ, Caro B, Vaz F, Torres MD.
Aubier M. Diaphragmatic function in severely malnourished patients Nutritional evaluation of a group of patients with diagnosis of bulimia
with anorexia nervosa: effects of renutrition. Am J Respir Crit Care nervosa. Nutr Clin Diet Hosp. 2004;24:28-37.
Med. 1994;150:1569-1574. 44. Dubois F, Sudre E, Porte A, Bedry R, Gromb S. Evolution and follow-
22. Rodrigues Pereira N, Bandeira MM, Assumpcao CR, et al. Oxidative up of hunger strikers: experience from an interregional hospital secured
stress, l-arginine-nitric oxide and arginase pathways in platelets from unit. Rev Med Interne. 2011;32:669-677.
adolescents with anorexia nervosa. Blood Cells Mol Dis. 2010;44: 45. Okabe K. Assessment of emaciation in relation to threat to life in
164-168. anorexia nervosa. Intern Med. 1993;32:837-842.
23. Varela P, Marcos A, Munoz-Velez A, Morande G. Liver changes in the 46. Pascal N, Amouzou EK, Sanni A, et al. Serum concentrations of
evolution of anorexia nervosa. Med Sci Res. 1991;19:471-472. sex hormone binding globulin are elevated in kwashiorkor and
24. Zastrow A, Wolf J, Giannitsis E, et al. Elevated myocardial enzymes anorexia nervosa but not in marasmus. Am J Clin Nutr. 2002;76:
and natriuretic peptides in anorexia nervosa: prototypic condition for 239-244.
the pathophysiology of cachexia? Cardiology. 2011;118:256-259. 47. Vogele C, Hilbert A, Tuschen-Caffier B. Dietary restriction, cardiac
25. Agnello E, Malfi G, Costantino AM, et al. Tumour necrosis factor autonomic regulation and stress reactivity in bulimic women. Physiol
alpha and oxidative stress as maintaining factors in the evolution of Behav. 2009;98:229-234.
anorexia nervosa. Eat Weight Disord. 2012;17:e194-e199. 48. Barbe P, Bennet A, Stebenet M, Perret B, Louvet JP. Sex-hormone-
26. Caregaro L, Favaro A, Santonastaso P, et al. Insulin-like growth factor binding globulin and protein-energy malnutrition indexes as indicators
1 (IGF-1), a nutritional marker in patients with eating disorders. Clin of nutritional status in women with anorexia nervosa. Am J Clin Nutr.
Nutr. 2001;20:251-257. 1993;57:319-322.
27. Chu ES, Gaudiani JL, Mascolo M, et al. ACUTE center for eating 49. Coles J, Vogele C, Hubert A, Tuschen-Caffier B. Fasting and (over)
disorders. J Hosp Med. 2012;7:340-344. eating: effects of yoyo diets on measures of cardiac sympthovagal
28. Haluzik M, Kabrt J, Nedvidkova J, Svobodova J, Kotrlikova E, balance. Z Klin Psychol Psychother. 2005;34:95-103.
Papezova H. Relationship of serum leptin levels and selected nutri- 50. Keys A, Brozek J, Henschel A, Mickelsen O, Taylor HL. The Biology
tional parameters in patients with protein-caloric malnutrition. Nutri- of Human Starvation: Volumes 1 and 2. Minneapolis: University of
tion. 1999;15:829-833. Minnesota Press; 1950.
29. Haluzik M, Papezova M, Nedvidkova J, Kabrt J. Serum leptin levels in 51. Hukshorn CJ, Menheere PPCA, Westerterp-Plantenga MS,
patients with anorexia nervosa before and after partial refeeding, re- Saris WHM. The effect of pegylated human recombinant leptin (PEG-
lationships to serum lipids and biochemical nutritional parameters. OB) on neuroendocrine adaptations to semi-starvation in overweight
Physiol Res. 1999;48:197-202. men. Eur J Endocrinol. 2003;148:649-655.
30. Herzog W, Deter HC, Fiehn W, Petzold E. Medical findings and 52. Goodnight SH, Inkeles SB, Kovach NL, Connor WE. Reduced pros-
predictors of long-term physical outcome in anorexia nervosa: a pro- tacyclin survival after fasting-induced elevation of plasma free fatty
spective, 12-year follow-up study. Psychol Med. 1997;27:269-279. acids. Thromb Haemost. 1985;54:418-421.
31. Krantz MJ, Lee D, Donahoo WT, Mehler PS. The paradox of normal 53. McMurray RG, Ben-Ezra V, Forsythe WA, Smith AT. Responses of
serum albumin in anorexia nervosa: a case report. Int J Eat Disord. endurance-trained subjects to caloric deficits induced by diet or exer-
2005;37:278-280. cise. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1985;17:574-579.
32. Lawson EA, Misra M, Meenaghan E, et al. Adrenal glucocorticoid and 54. Vaisman N, Sklan D, Dayan Y. Effect of moderate semi-starvation on
androgen precursor dissociation in anorexia nervosa. J Clin Endocrinol plasma lipids. Int J Obes. 1990;14:989-996.
Metab. 2009;94:1367-1371. 55. Bentdal OH, Froland SS, Askevold F, Bjoro K, Larsen S. Nutritional
33. Nova E, Lopez-Vidriero I, Varela P, Toro O, Casas JJ, Marcos AA. assessment of anorexia nervosa patientseanalysis of anthropometric
Indicators of nutritional status in restricting-type anorexia nervosa and biochemical variables to evaluate patients at risk. Clin Nutr.
patients: a 1-year follow-up study. Clin Nutr. 2004;23:1353-1359. 1988;7:93-99.
34. Olubodun JO, Akinsola HA, Adeleye OA. Prison deprivation and 56. Dowd PS, Kelleher J, Walker BE, Guillou PJ. Nutritional and immu-
protein nutritional status of inmates of a developing community prison. nological assessment of patients with anorexia nervosa. Clin Nutr.
Eur J Clin Nutr. 1996;50:58-60. 1983;2:79-83.
1023.e10 The American Journal of Medicine, Vol 128, No 9, September 2015

57. Narayanan V, Gaudiani JL, Harris RH, Mehler PS. Liver function test 73. Russell DM, Prendergast PJ, Darby PL, Garfinkel PE, Whitwell J,
abnormalities in anorexia nervosaecause or effect. Int J Eat Disord. Jeejeebhoy KN. A comparison between muscle function and body
2010;43:378-381. composition in anorexia nervosa: the effect of refeeding. Am J Clin
58. Silvetti M, Magnani M, Santilli A, et al. The heart in anorexic teenage Nutr. 1983;38:229-237.
girls. G Ital Cardiol. 1998;28:131-139. 74. Thibault L, Roberge AG. The nutritional status of subjects with
59. Symreng T, Cederblad G, Croner S. Changes in nutritional assessment anorexia nervosa. Int J Vitam Nutr Res. 1987;57:447-452.
variables caused by total parenteral nutrition in anorexia nervosa. Clin 75. Yap SH, Hafkenscheid JC, van Tongeren JH. Important role of
Nutr. 1985;4:81-86. tryptophan on albumin synthesis in patients suffering from
60. Tey HL, Lim SC, Snodgrass AM. Refeeding oedema in anorexia anorexia nervosa and hypoalbuminemia. Am J Clin Nutr. 1975;28:
nervosa. Singapore Med J. 2005;46:308-310. 1356-1363.
61. Jackson JM, Blaine D, Powell-Tuck J, Korbonits M, Carey A, Elia M. 76. Seltzer MH, Bastidas JA, Cooper DM, Engler P, Slocum B,
Macro- and micronutrient losses and nutritional status resulting from Fletcher HS. Instant nutritional assessment. JPEN J Parenter Enteral
44 days of total fasting in a non-obese man. Nutrition. 2006;22: Nutr. 1979;3:157-159.
889-897. 77. Skipper A, Ferguson M, Thompson K, Castellanos V, Porcari J.
62. Bufano G, Bellini C, Cervellin G, Coscelli C. Enteral nutrition in Nutrition screening tools: an analysis of the evidence. JPEN J Parenter
anorexia nervosa. JPEN J Parenter Enteral Nutr. 1990;14:404-407. Enteral Nutr. 2012;36:292-298.
63. Caughey JE. The spectrum of protein calorie malnutrition in adoles- 78. White JV, Guenter P, Jensen G, Malone A, Schofield M. Academy of
cents. Australas Ann Med. 1970;19:341-349. Nutrition and Dietetics Malnutrition Work Group; ASPEN Malnutri-
64. Dekaris D, Sabioncello A, Mazuran R, et al. Multiple changes of tion Task Force; ASPEN Board of Directors. Consensus statement of
immunologic parameters in prisoners of war. Assessments after release the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics/American Society for Paren-
from a camp in Manjaca, Bosnia. JAMA. 1993;270:595-599. teral and Enteral Nutrition: characteristics recommended for the iden-
65. Gorsane I, Zouaghi K, Goucha R, et al. Acute renal failure in a prisoner tification and documentation of adult malnutrition (undernutrition).
after hunger strike. Tunis Med. 2007;85:234-236. J Acad Nutr Diet. 2012;112(5):730-738.
66. Hertlova M, Lata J, Vodicka J, Staudova M. Anorexia nervosa e the 79. Dantzer R, Kelley KW. Twenty years of research on cytokine-induced
views of the internist. Cas Lek Cesk. 1994;133:759-761. sickness behavior. Brain Behav Immun. 2007;21:153-160.
67. Mira M, Stewart PM, Vizzard J, Abraham S. Biochemical abnormal- 80. Klein S, Koretz RL. Nutrition support in patients with cancer: what do
ities in anorexia nervosa and bulimia. Ann Clin Biochem. 1987;24: the data really show? Nutr Clin Pract. 1994;9:91-100.
29-35. 81. Sampson EL, Candy B, Jones L. Enteral tube feeding for older people with
68. Narayanan V, Gaudiani JL, Mehler PS. Serum albumin levels may not advanced dementia. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2009;2:CD007209.
correlate with weight status in severe anorexia nervosa. Eat Disord. 82. Payne C, Wiffen PJ, Martin S. Interventions for fatigue and weight loss
2009;17:322-326. in adults with advanced progressive illness. Cochrane Database Syst
69. Pertschuk MJ, Crosby LO, Barot L, Mullen JL. Immunocompetency in Rev. 2012;1:CD008427.
anorexia nervosa. Am J Clin Nutr. 1982;35:968-972. 83. Langer G, Fink A. Nutritional interventions for preventing and treating
70. Richard JL, Bringer J, Mirouze J, Monnier L, Bellet MH. Effica- pressure ulcers. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2014;6:CD003216.
ciousness of enteral feeding at continuous low flow in the treatment of 84. Koretz R. Death, morbidity, and economics are the only endpoints for
anorexia nervosa. Ann Nutr Metab. 1983;27:19-25. trials. Proc Nutr Soc. 2005;64:277-284.
71. Rigaud D, Sogni P, Hammel P, et al. Anorexia nervosa: absence of
sensitivity to nutritional protein markers. Study of 23 patients and
comparison to a paired group with colonic Crohn’s disease. Ann Med APPENDIX
Interne (Paris). 1989;140:86-90. Supplementary materials accompanying this article can be
72. Rolla M, Cella PL. Findings on protein metabolism in constitutional
thinness. Research with radio-iodinated serum albumin. G Clin Med.
found in the online version at http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.
1967;48:1163-1171. amjmed.2015.03.032
Lee et al Serum Albumin and Prealbumin During Starvation 1023.e11

APPENDIX 1 SEARCH TERMS BY DATABASE transthyretin*:ab,ti OR ‘serum transthyretin’:ab,ti OR


‘serum transthyretins’:ab,ti
PubMed
“Starvation”[Mesh] OR “Energy Intake”[Mesh] OR “Mal- AND
nutrition”[Mesh] OR “Anorexia”[Mesh] OR “Caloric ‘Eating Disorders’/exp OR ‘Prisoner’/exp OR ‘Low Calory
Restriction”[Mesh] OR “Weight Loss” [Mesh] OR “Protein Diet’/exp OR ‘Survival’/exp OR ‘Accident’/exp OR ‘Bar-
Deficiency” [Mesh] OR “Fasting” [Mesh] OR “Food iatric Surgery’/exp OR ‘Hunger’/exp OR ‘eating dis-
Deprivation” [Mesh] OR starvation[tiab] OR “energy in- order’:ab,ti OR prisoner*:ab,ti OR ‘low calory diet’:ab,ti
take*”[tiab] OR malnutrition[tiab] OR anorexi*[tiab] OR OR ‘low calorie diet’:ab,ti OR ‘hypocaloric diet’:ab,ti OR
“caloric restriction”[tiab] OR “weight loss”[tiab] OR “pro- ‘reducing diet’:ab,ti OR surviv*:ab,ti OR accident*:ab,ti OR
tein deficiency”[tiab] OR “fasting”[tiab] OR “food depri- ‘bariatric surgery’:ab,ti OR ‘bariatric surgeries’:ab,ti OR
vation*”[tiab] OR “low nutrient intake*”[tiab] OR ‘bariatric procedure’:ab,ti OR ‘bariatric procedures’:ab,ti
“nutritional deprivation*”[tiab] OR undernutrition[tiab] OR OR ‘bariatric operation’:ab,ti OR ‘bariatric operations’:ab,ti
malnourish*[tiab] OR “caloric intake*”[tiab] OR “dietary OR hunger:ab,ti OR famine*:ab,ti OR ‘hunger strike’:ab,ti
restriction”[tiab] OR ‘hunger strikes’:ab,ti OR stunts:ab,ti OR ‘self
starvation’:ab,ti
AND
“Albumins”[Mesh] OR “Serum Albumin”[Mesh] OR
CINAHL
“Prealbumin”[Mesh] OR albumin*[tiab] OR “serum albu- (MH “Starvation”) OR (MH “Malnutrition”) OR (MH
min*”[tiab] OR prealbumin*[tiab] OR “serum pre- “Energy Intake”) OR (MH “Nutritional Status: Nutrient
albumin*”[tiab] OR transthyretin*[tiab] OR “serum Intake (Iowa NOC)”) OR (MH “Restricted Diet”) OR (MH
transthyretin*”[tiab] “Weight Loss”) OR (MH “Protein Deficiency”) OR (MH
“Fasting”) OR TI starvation OR AB starvation OR TI
malnutrition OR AB malnutrition OR TI “energy intake*”
AND OR AB “energy intake*” OR TI “restricted diet” OR AB
“Eating Disorders”[Mesh] OR “Prisoners”[Mesh] OR “Diet, “restricted diet” OR TI “weight loss” OR AB “weight loss”
Reducing”[Mesh] OR “Survival”[Mesh] OR “Acci- OR TI “protein deficiency” OR AB “protein deficiency” OR
dents”[Mesh] OR “Bariatric Surgery”[Mesh] OR “eating TI “fasting” OR AB “fasting” OR TI “food deprivation” OR
disorder*”[tiab] OR prisoner*[tiab] OR “reducing di- AB “food deprivation” OR TI “low nutrient intake*” OR
et*”[tiab] OR “weight loss diet*”[tiab] OR “weight AB “low nutrient intake*” OR TI “nutritional deprivation*”
reducing diet*”[tiab] OR “weight reduction diet*”[tiab] OR OR AB “nutritional deprivation*” OR TI undernutrition OR
surviv*[tiab] OR accident*[tiab] OR “bariatric surgery” AB undernutrition OR TI malnourish* OR AB malnourish*
[tiab] OR “bariatric surgeries”[tiab] OR famine*[tiab] OR OR TI “caloric intake*” OR AB “caloric intake*” OR TI
“hunger strike*”[tiab] OR “stunts”[tiab] OR “self anorexi* OR AB anorexi*
starvation”[tiab]
AND
Embase (MH “Albumins”) OR (MH “Serum Albumin”) OR TI al-
‘Starvation’/exp OR ‘Malnutrition’/exp OR ‘Caloric bumin* OR AB albumin* OR TI “serum albumin*” OR AB
Intake’/exp OR ‘Diet Restriction’/exp OR ‘Anorexia’/exp “serum albumin*” OR TI prealbumin* OR AB prealbumin*
OR ‘Weight Reduction’/exp OR ‘Protein Deficiency’/exp OR TI “serum prealbumin*” OR AB “serum prealbumin*”
OR ‘Food Deprivation’/exp OR starvation:ab,ti OR mal- OR TI transthyretin* OR AB transthyretin* OR TI “serum
nutrition:ab,ti OR ‘caloric intake’:ab,ti OR ‘caloric intakes’: transthyretin*” OR AB “serum transthyretin*”
ab,ti OR ‘diet restriction’:ab,ti OR anorexi*:ab,ti OR
‘weight reduction’:ab,ti OR ‘protein deficiency’:ab,ti OR AND
‘food deprivation’:ab,ti OR ‘low nutrient intake’:ab,ti OR (MH “Eating Disorders”) OR (MH “Prisoners”) OR (MH
‘low nutrient intakes’:ab,ti OR ‘nutritional deprivation’:ab,ti “Diet, Reducing”) OR (MH “Diet, Fat-Restricted”) OR (MH
OR ‘nutritional deprivations’:ab,ti OR undernutrition:ab,ti “Diet, Low Carbohydrate”) OR (MH “Restricted Diet”) OR
OR malnourish*:ab,ti OR ‘energy intake’:ab,ti OR ‘energy (MH “Survival”) OR (MH “Accidents”) OR (MH “Bariatric
intakes’:ab,ti Surgery”) OR (MH “Bariatric Patients”) OR TI “eating
disorder*” OR AB “eating disorder*” OR TI prisoner* OR
AND AB prisoner* OR TI “reducing diet*” OR AB “reducing
‘Albumin’/exp OR ‘Serum Albumin’/exp OR ‘Prealbumin’/ diet*” OR TI “fat-restricted diet*” OR AB “fat-restricted
exp OR albumin*:ab,ti OR ‘serum albumin’:ab,ti OR diet*” OR TI “low carbohydrate diet*” OR AB “low car-
‘serum albumins’:ab,ti OR prealbumin*:ab,ti OR ‘serum bohydrate diet*” OR TI “restricted diet*” OR AB “restricted
prealbumin’:ab,ti OR ‘serum prealbumins’:ab,ti OR diet*” OR TI surviv* OR AB surviv* OR TI accident* OR
1023.e12 The American Journal of Medicine, Vol 128, No 9, September 2015

AB accident* OR TI “bariatric surger*” OR AB “bariatric AND


surger*” OR TI “bariatric patient*” OR AB “bariatric pa- albumin* OR “serum albumin*” OR prealbumin* OR
tient*” OR TI famine* OR AB famine* OR TI “hunger “serum prealbumin*” OR transthyretin* OR “serum
strike*” OR AB “hunger strike*” OR TI “stunts” OR AB transthyretin*”
“stunts” OR TI “self starvation” OR AB “self starvation”

Cochrane AND
starvation OR malnutrition OR “energy intake*” OR ano- “eating disorder*” OR prisoner* OR “reducing diet*” OR
rexi* OR “low nutrient intake*” OR “nutritional depriva- survival* OR accident* OR “bariatric surgery*” OR
tion*” OR undernutrition OR malnourish* OR “caloric “weight loss diet*” OR “weight reducing diet*” OR “weight
intake*” OR “dietary restriction” OR “caloric restriction” reduction diet*” OR “low carbohydrate diet” OR “fat
OR “weight loss” OR “protein deficiency” OR “fasting” OR restricted diet” OR “restricted diet” OR famine* OR “hun-
“food deprivation” ger strike*” OR stunts OR “self starvation*”
Lee et al
APPENDIX 2 TABULATED DATA FROM ALL INCLUDED STUDIES

Weight Albumin BMI Weight Albumin Prealbumin


Total Mean Amount/ After After after After After after

Serum Albumin and Prealbumin During Starvation


Study Number Baseline Baseline Baseline Baseline Duration Reason Type Caloric Caloric Nutritional Nutritional Nutritional Nutritional
(First Year of Study of Mean BMI Weight Albumin Prealbumin of Caloric for Caloric of Caloric Restriction Restriction Nutritional Intervention Intervention Intervention Intervention
Author) Study Design Subjects Age (years) Sex (kg/m2) (kg) (g/dL) (mg/dL) Restriction Restriction Restriction (kg) (g/dL) Intervention (kg/m2) (kg) (g/dL) (mg/dL)

Nishida13 2010 Cross- 210 29.9  5.31 F 17.5  4.49  0.2 23.3  3.56 BMI <18.5 but
sectional 0.78 no
anorexia
nervosa
118 32.9  4.29 F 20.7  4.45  0.21 23.1  3.84 Self-reported
3.33 weight loss
>1 kg
Rigaud14 2000 Case 5 29.8  9.3 F 9.77  24.55  3.35  0.28 13  6 Severe 230  57 kcal/ 8 weeks 32.67 
control 0.1 1.64 anorexia day enteral 1.73
nervosa nutrition
16 25.2  3.9 F 13.6  4.05  0.58 31  6 Anorexia 840  8 weeks oral
1.1 nervosa 157 kcal/day intake þ
enteral
nutrition
Bentdal55 1988 Case 33 25 F 39.67 4 31 6 years Anorexia
control nervosa
Chui15 2008 Case 63 21.3  2.3 F 21.8  4.13  0.28 6.5  1.7 Anorexia
control 3.4 years nervosa
49
Coles 2005 Observation 8 23 F 22 24 Fasting
bulimia
nervosa
8 24 F 23.3 30 Bulimia
nervosa
42
Cortes 2005 Observation 33 20 F 16.5 4.6 20.9 Anorexia
nervosa
Dostalova 16
2010 Observation 16 24.9  1.34 F 15.7  4.38  0.112 Anorexia 2 months 17.5  4.76  0.072
0.3 nervosa partial 0.23
refeeding
Dowd56 1983 Cross- 18 24 16 F, 40 3.61  0.5 29.2  8.2 Anorexia
sectional 2M nervosa
Keys50
1950 Randomized 8 25.5  3.47 M (all) 68.32 4.39 24 weeks Conscientious 1543.6 cal/day 51.99 3.925 12 weeks oral 55.42
controlled (all) (all) objectors intake 400
trial (all) cal/day
8 69.41 4.32 1571.0 cal/day 51.74 3.716 12 weeks oral 56.98
intake 800
cal/day
8 72.3 4.219 1619.1 cal/day 54.48 3.888 12 weeks oral 61.72
intake
1200 cal/
day
8 67.51 4.178 1544.3 cal/day 52.09 3.919 12 weeks oral 60.91
intake
1600 cal/
day
Gendall17 1999 Case 152 25.9  6.0 F 23.0  4.87  3.4 27  5 71.1  Bulimia
control 2.7 65.6 nervosa
months
Gentile18 2011 Cross- 298 19.8  6.1 278 F, 14.6  4.8  0.5 Anorexia
section 20 M 2.1 nervosa,

1023.e13
eating
disorder
NOS
1023.e14
Continued

Weight Albumin BMI Weight Albumin Prealbumin


Total Mean Amount/ After After after After After after
Study Number Baseline Baseline Baseline Baseline Duration Reason Type Caloric Caloric Nutritional Nutritional Nutritional Nutritional
(First Year of Study of Mean BMI Weight Albumin Prealbumin of Caloric for Caloric of Caloric Restriction Restriction Nutritional Intervention Intervention Intervention Intervention
Author) Study Design Subjects Age (years) Sex (kg/m2) (kg) (g/dL) (mg/dL) Restriction Restriction Restriction (kg) (g/dL) Intervention (kg/m2) (kg) (g/dL) (mg/dL)

Haluzik40 1998 Case 14 F 15.5  42.7  4.863  0.264 27  7 Anorexia


control 2.9 1.83 nervosa
Hildebrandt 19
2001 Case 28 13.7  4.86  0.73 5.0  4.2 Anorexia
control 2.3 years nervosa
24 19.1  4.75  0.62 6.7  5.5 Bulimia
3.7 years nervosa
Hukshorn 51
2003 Randomized 12 34.9  1.3 M 28.6  95.0  4.08  0.06 46 days Semi- 2.1 MJ/days 80.4  2.4 4.03 
controlled 0.5 3.2 (all) starvation (all), 0.09
trial in placebo
overweight
pts (all)
12 34.6  1.2 M 28.9  97.1  4.13  0.05 Leptin 85.3  0.9 4.05 
0.4 1.8 0.07
20
Mukamel 2001 Case report 1 13.5 F 11.25 4.7 10 months Anorexia
nervosa
Murciano 21
1994 Cohort 15 24.9  8.7 F 13.5  37.1  3.99  0.21 24  4 12 months Anorexia 8 weeks oral 42.9 
1.1 4.7 nervosa intake and 4.6
enteral
nutrition
Narayanan57 2010 Case report 1 34 F 10.7 32 4.7 17 years Anorexia Oral intake 36.8 3
nervosa 137 kcal/
days

The American Journal of Medicine, Vol 128, No 9, September 2015


1 26 F 11.2 31.5 5.1 8 years Anorexia <400 kcal/days Oral intake 33.3 2.4
nervosa 400 kcal/
days
Orgaz43 2004 Observation 18 26 F 24.5 4.24 22.3 Bulimia
nervosa
Rodrigues 2010 Case control 11 15.0  0.5 F 15.1  4.7  0.1 Anorexia
Pereira22 0.6 nervosa
Silvetti58 1998 Cross-section 23 15 F 14.2 4.6 (median) Anorexia
nervosa
Symreng59 1985 Cohort 10 14-18, 34 F 36.5  4.3  0.4 25  7 Anorexia Total 46.0  4.5 4.4  0.5 29  6
3.1 nervosa parenteral
nutrition,
oral diet
Tey60 2005 Case report 1 19 F 36.6 4.3 Anorexia
nervosa
Varela23 1991 Case control 17 15.68  F 14.67  38.64  4.41  0.06 40  10 1.54  Anorexia
0.95 0.27 0.94 0.21 nervosa
years
19 18.47  F 17.93  47.34  4.20  0.08 50  10 3.80  Anorexia
0.75 0.25 1.55 0.54 nervosa
years
Vogele47 2009 Case control 8 23.2  3.1 F 22.0  24.0  5.1 5.5  Fasting
3.1 4.1 bulimia
years nervosa
9 24.5  8.5 F 23.3  30.1  6.3 5.5  Nonfasting
3.3 4.1 bulimia
years nervosa
Zastrow24 2011 Case report 1 26 F 10.5 2.95 14 years Anorexia 60 days 13.2
nervosa enteral
nutrition
Agnello25 2012 Case control 39 26  9 F 13.9  37.5  4.6  0.6 26.3  7.4 60 months Anorexia
2 6 (median) nervosa
Lee et al
Continued

Weight Albumin BMI Weight Albumin Prealbumin


Total Mean Amount/ After After after After After after
Study Number Baseline Baseline Baseline Baseline Duration Reason Type Caloric Caloric Nutritional Nutritional Nutritional Nutritional
(First Year of Study of Mean BMI Weight Albumin Prealbumin of Caloric for Caloric of Caloric Restriction Restriction Nutritional Intervention Intervention Intervention Intervention

Serum Albumin and Prealbumin During Starvation


Author) Study Design Subjects Age (years) Sex (kg/m2) (kg) (g/dL) (mg/dL) Restriction Restriction Restriction (kg) (g/dL) Intervention (kg/m2) (kg) (g/dL) (mg/dL)

Barbe48 1993 Case control 12 16-31 F 13.8  25  2 6 months-4 Anorexia Oral intake 17.1  0.2 30  1
0.5 years nervosa
Bufano 62
1990 Cohort 9 F 34.51  4.3  0.6 21.9  6 17  14 Anorexia Oral intake þ 39.8  3.3 4.0  0.4 27.9  4.6
4.48 months nervosa, enteral
reduced nutrition
intake and
weight loss
Caregaro26 2001 Cohort 59 22.6  7.1 F 14.87  4.582  0.578 27.924  Anorexia 1078.58  Oral intake 13.8  2 to
1.89 6.718 nervosa 708.27 þ enteral 14.9  1.7
kcal/days nutrition, (20 pts)
oral
intake þ
oral
nutrition
supplement
23 27  7.2 F 20.02  4.433  0.511 27.742  Bulimia 2393.44 
1.64 7.489 nervosa 3053.33
kcal/days
Caughey63 1970 Case report 1 18 M 35 4.8 Lack of access 9 months high 45
to food protein
diet þ iron
Chu27 2012 Cohort 62 27 56 F, 12.9  76.1  3.7  0.7 21  7 Anorexia Oral intake 13.1  1.9
6M 2.0 14.4 nervosa
Dekaris64 1993 Case control 29 48 (median) M 69.5 4.5 4-7 months Prisoners
(median)
Dubois44 2011 Observation 8 32.6 1 F, 21 3.9 57 days Hunger Total starvation,
7M strikers water only
Goodnight52 1985 Clinical trial 10 30.6 5 F, 76.49 4.4  0.3 4 days Fasting Multivitamin 72.59 4.8  0.3
5M and water or
weak tea
Gorsane65 2007 Observation 1 29 M 69 1 month Hunger striker Total 59 3.5
starvation
Haluzik28 1999 Case control 17 24.1  3.82 F 15.22  4.903  0.602 27  7 Anorexia
3.06 nervosa
Haluzik29 1999 Case control 11 23.7  3.1 F 15.4  43.1  4.93  0.28 28  7 Anorexia Oral intake 17.2  3.0 47.9  8.4 4.04  0.624 33  9
3.2 8.5 nervosa
Hertlova66 1994 Clinical trial 5 23.4 13.1 34.6 3.25 Anorexia 3057-3828 kJ Total 40.2 3.5
nervosa parenteral
nutrition
Herzog30 1997 Cohort 66 20.8 F 13.7 4.171  0.552 Anorexia Enteral 19.3
nervosa nutrition,
total
parenteral
nutrition
Krantz31 2005 Case report 1 52 F 17 49 4 20 years Anorexia
nervosa
Lawson32 2009 Case control 10 27.5  2.4 F 18.3  49  1.2 4.7  0.1 Anorexia
0.3 nervosa
(all)
10 25.8  1.1 F 18.0  48.6  4.4  0.1
0.4 1.5

1023.e15
1023.e16
Continued

Weight Albumin BMI Weight Albumin Prealbumin


Total Mean Amount/ After After after After After after
Study Number Baseline Baseline Baseline Baseline Duration Reason Type Caloric Caloric Nutritional Nutritional Nutritional Nutritional
(First Year of Study of Mean BMI Weight Albumin Prealbumin of Caloric for Caloric of Caloric Restriction Restriction Nutritional Intervention Intervention Intervention Intervention
Author) Study Design Subjects Age (years) Sex (kg/m2) (kg) (g/dL) (mg/dL) Restriction Restriction Restriction (kg) (g/dL) Intervention (kg/m2) (kg) (g/dL) (mg/dL)

McMurray53 1985 Clinical trial 6 20-31 M 70.48  4.4  0.1 1 week Research 1363  68.32  4.6  0.1
3.66 135 kcal/ 3.47
days
Mira67 1987 Case control 61 25  5.5 F 60.4  4.82  0.34 (all) Bulimia
10.7 nervosa
22 27.5  6.9 F 41.4  Anorexia
6.2 nervosa
7 25.1  6.0 F 56.7  Atypical eating
19.6 disorder
Narayanan 68
2009 Case report 1 34 F 11 36 3.5 Several Anorexia <400 kcal/days Total 35.2 3.15
weeks nervosa parenteral
nutrition
1500
kcal/days
Nova33 2004 Cohort 14 15.1  2.56 F 15.24  39.4  4.51  0.69 26.3  5.6 9.4  Anorexia Inpatient 17.34  1.97 45.2  6.7 4.77  0.45 25.8  6.8
1.71 6.1 6.3 nervosa
months
Okabe45 1993 Cohort 12 19.25 11 F, 27.7 4.1 2.28 years Anorexia Inpatient 31.1 3.5
1M nervosa
Olubodun 34
1996 Case control 81 27.7  5.9 M 20  2.7 3.66  0.63 229.1  Prisoners
210.1
days

The American Journal of Medicine, Vol 128, No 9, September 2015


Pascal46 2002 Case control 25 15.6  2.3 F 14.6  2 0.67  0.06 nmol/ 5.45  1.09 Anorexia 30 days oral 17.2  1.4 0.67  0.06 6.36  1.45
L (0.00000489 mmol/L nervosa intake nmol/L mmol/L
 (29.975 (0.00000489  (34.98 
0.000000402  5.995 0.000000402 7.975
g/dL)* g/dL) g/dL)* mg/dL)
Pertschuk69 1982 Cohort 22 23.3  5.5 21 F, 32.9  4.3  0.7 Anorexia
1M 5.3 nervosa
Richard70 1983 Clinical trial 8 23 F 36.3 3.9 27.6 Anorexia Oral intake, 43.2 36.6
nervosa oral
intake þ
enteral
nutrition
Rigaud71 1989 Observation 23 26 24 F, 37.7 4.4 29 Anorexia
2M nervosa
Rigaud35 2009 Case control 16 26  9 (all) 115 F, 11.1  3.24  0.51 14  4 Anorexia
5M 0.65 nervosa
(all) (all)
35 13.1  4.02  0.69 23  3
0.5
35 15  4.18  0.63 27  2
0.49
21 16.8  4.34  0.64 31  5
0.51
13 19.5  4.11  0.72 28  6
2.4
Rock36 1995 Cohort 13 26  8 12 F, 17.4  4.1  0.5 6.4  3.3 Anorexia Oral intake
1M 2.9 years nervosa,
bulimia
nervosa
Roijen41 1991 Cross-section 20 13.3 17 F, 14.7 34.9 4.58079 Anorexia
3M nervosa
Lee et al
Continued

Weight Albumin BMI Weight Albumin Prealbumin


Total Mean Amount/ After After after After After after
Study Number Baseline Baseline Baseline Baseline Duration Reason Type Caloric Caloric Nutritional Nutritional Nutritional Nutritional
(First Year of Study of Mean BMI Weight Albumin Prealbumin of Caloric for Caloric of Caloric Restriction Restriction Nutritional Intervention Intervention Intervention Intervention

Serum Albumin and Prealbumin During Starvation


Author) Study Design Subjects Age (years) Sex (kg/m2) (kg) (g/dL) (mg/dL) Restriction Restriction Restriction (kg) (g/dL) Intervention (kg/m2) (kg) (g/dL) (mg/dL)

Rolla72 1967 Observation 9 (all) F 38.8 3.35 Anorexia


nervosa
F 46.4 3.64 Constitutional
thinness
Russell 73
1983 Cohort 6 23.8  2 5 F, 1 M 38.8  4.3  1 Anorexia 8 weeks oral 46.5  4.4 4.4  0.3
3.3 years nervosa intake
Smith37
1996 Case control 6 27.2  2.36 F 15.35  38.8  3.7  0.193 Anorexia
0.694 2.43 nervosa
Thibault 74
1987 Cohort 25 18  5 24 F, 35.1  5.8  1.2 18 months Anorexia 773  349 kcal/
1M 6.9 nervosa days
Vaisman 54
1990 Clinical trial 4 41.25 3 F, 1 M 24.58 69.5  3.7  0.3 6 days Very low 200 kcal/days 65.4  8.9 3.8  0.2
9.3 calorie diet
Van 1988 Case control 20 24.7 F 14.4 39.6 4.07 30.1 4.9 years Anorexia 1090 kcal/days
Binsbergen38 nervosa
75
Yap 1975 Case control 3 35.67 F 35.3 3.543
Jackson61 2006 Case report 1 30 M 28.36 96 44 days Personal Water only 65.4  8.9 5.29
endurance
Faintuch 39
2001 Observation 8 43.3  6.2 1 F, 7 M 21.5  66.4  3.4  0.3 43 days Hunger Water only, Intravenous 23.0  2.4 71.4  7.5 3.2  0.2
2.6 6.6 strikers occasional fluids þ
multivitamin oral intake
and
electrolytes

APPENDIX 3 ALBUMIN AND BODY MASS INDEX (BMI) BEFORE AND AFTER NUTRITIONAL INTERVENTION

Reason for Duration of BMI (kg/m2)  SD Albumin (g/dL)  SD Type of BMI (kg/m2)  SD Albumin (g/dL)  SD
Study # of Nutrition Nutrition Before Nutritional Before Nutritional Nutritional After Nutritional After Nutritional
(First Author) Year Subjects Age (years) Sex Restriction Restriction Intervention Intervention Intervention Intervention Intervention
Dostalova16 2010 16 24.9  1.34 F
Anorexia 15.7  0.3 4.38  0.112 Partial refeeding 17.5  0.23 4.76  0.072
nervosa (2 months)
Haluzik29 1999 11 23.7  3.1 F Anorexia 15.4  3.2 4.93  0.28 Refeeding (30 days) 17.2  3 4.04  0.624
nervosa
Nova33 2004 14 15.1  2.56 F Anorexia 9.4  15.24  1.71 4.51  0.69 Inpatient rehab 17.34  1.97 4.77  0.45
nervosa 6.3 months
Faintuch39 2001 8 43.3  6.2 1 F, 7 M Hunger 43 days 21.5  2.6 3.4  0.3 Intravenous fluid 23  2.4 3.2  0.2
strikers (2 days), then oral diet

1023.e17
1023.e18 The American Journal of Medicine, Vol 128, No 9, September 2015

APPENDIX 4 ALBUMIN AND BODY MASS INDEX BEFORE AND AFTER NUTRITIONAL INTERVENTION.
DOSTALOVA ET AL,16 HALUZIK ET AL,29 NOVA ET AL,33 FAINTUCH ET AL.39
Lee et al
APPENDIX 5 PREALBUMIN AND BODY MASS INDEX (BMI) BEFORE AND AFTER NUTRITIONAL INTERVENTION

Serum Albumin and Prealbumin During Starvation


Prealbumin Prealbumin
Reason for Duration of BMI (kg/m2)  SD (mg/dL)  SD BMI (kg/m2)  SD (mg/dL)  SD
Study # of Nutrition Nutrition Before Nutritional Before Nutritional Type of Nutritional After Nutritional After Nutritional
(First Author) Year Subjects Age (years) Sex Restriction Restriction Intervention Intervention Intervention Intervention Intervention
Barbe48 1993 12 16-31 F Anorexia nervosa 6 months-4 years 13.8  0.5 25  2 Oral diet (40  5 days) 17.1  0.2 30  1
Haluzik29 1999 11 23.7  3.1 F Anorexia nervosa 15.4  3.2 28  7 Refeeding (30 days) 17.2  3 33  9
Nova33 2004 14 15.1  2.56 F Anorexia nervosa 9.4  6.3 months 15.24  1.71 26.3  5.6 Inpatient rehab 17.34  1.97 25.8  6.8
Pascal46 2002 25 15.6  2.3 F Anorexia nervosa 14.6  2 29.975  5.995 Refeeding (30 days) 17.2  1.4 34.98  7.975

1023.e19
1023.e20 The American Journal of Medicine, Vol 128, No 9, September 2015

APPENDIX 6 PERALBUMIN AND BODY MASS INDEX BEFORE AND AFTER NUTRITIONAL INTERVENTION.
BARBE ET AL,48 HALUZIK ET AL,29 NOVA ET AL,33 PASCAL ET AL.46
APPENDIX 7 ALBUMIN AND WEIGHT BEFORE AND AFTER NUTRITION RESTRICTION

Lee et al
Albumin

Serum Albumin and Prealbumin During Starvation


Weight Before Albumin (g/dL)  SD Duration of Weight after (g/dL)  SD
Study # of Nutrition Before Nutrition Type of Nutrition Nutrition Nutrition After Nutrition
(First Author) Year Subjects Age (years) Sex Restriction (kg) Restriction Restriction Restriction Restriction (kg) Restriction
Keys50 1950 8(1) 25.5  3.47 (all) M 68.32 4.39 1543.6 kcal/day 24 weeks (all) 51.99 3.925
8(2) M 69.41 4.32 1571 kcal/day 51.74 3.716
8(3) M 72.3 4.219 1619.1 kcal/day 54.48 3.888
8(4) M 67.51 4.178 1544.3 kcal/day 52.09 3.919
Hukshorn51 2003 12(1) 34.9  1.3 M 95  3.2 4.08  0.06 2.1 MJ/day 46 days (all) 80.4  2.4 4.03  0.09
12(2) 34.6  1.2 M 97.1  1.8 4.13  0.05 2.1 MJ/day 4 days 85.3  0.9 4.05  0.07
Goodnight52 1985 10 30.6 5 F, 5 M 76.49 4.4  0.3 MVI, water or weak tea 72.59 4.8  0.3
McMurray53 1985 6 20 - 31 M 70.48  3.66 4.4  0.1 1363  135 kcal/day 1 weeks 68.32  3.47 4.6  0.1
Vaisman54 1990 4 41.25 3 F, 1 M 69.5  9.3 3.7  0.3 200 kcal/day 6 days 65.4  8.9 3.8  0.2

1023.e21
1023.e22 The American Journal of Medicine, Vol 128, No 9, September 2015

APPENDIX 8 ALBUMIN AND WEIGHT BEFORE AND AFTER NUTRITIONAL RESTRICTION. KEYS ET AL,50
HUKSHORN ET AL,51 GOODNIGHT ET AL,52 MCMURRAY ET AL.53

You might also like